Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 10—General (Resumed).
Contributions 306–481 of 481. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I was assured that he promised that prices would be brought back to the 1951 level immediately the Coalition would be returned.
Comment on this
I am accepting the Minister's denial and I am glad now that it is on the official records for I shall have the official record to take down to the people in the area and to the church gate and they will be the best judges. If they accept the Minister's denial, I shall be quite satisfied.
Comment on this
I have met a number of people recently in the wage-earning groups and they have told me they would be delighted with a standstill wages Order, provided it was accompanied by a standstill prices Order and a standstill profits Order similar to the Orders we had in operation in the years in which they were in force. It was asked here to-day as to why the trade unions are meeting the Federation of Employers. Is it not for a standstill Order on wages and prices and profits? If they are wrong in that, then I suppose we were wrong. Nevertheless, they are apparently looking for that and that is what they want.
Comment on this
I hope this Budget will do what it is designed to do, but I doubt it very much. Mark you, there are a number of us on this side of the House anxious for financial stability. We are anxious to see the country progressing.
Comment on this
We will vote against it at the right time. We were never afraid to follow the dictates of our conscience. We are not voting against it because of the increase in taxation but for the purpose of showing up the hypocrisy, the dishonesty and the deception practised on the people, even by the Minister for Finance himself, and by his colleagues from 1952 to 1954.
Comment on this
I have listened now to the former Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. I listened earlier to-day to the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party. I listened last week to the Front Benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party. Never have I heard such a poor contribution to any debate and particularly to a debate on a Budget.
Comment on this
It is something. I listened to Deputy Corry and to many more speakers on the Opposition Benches. Their principal form of amusement here seems to be that of baiting a Parliamentary Secretary on the Government Front Bench because he happens to be a distinguished professor.
Comment on this
Swift wrote about those who bait educated people. I now realise what a great genius Swift was in being able to create the characters he did without ever having been in this House. I listened to the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party this afternoon and his contribution to the debate was a series of recriminations and harking back. He said Fine Gael was the great Party for reducing taxation—I wrote it down. His Party was in power for 20 years. In each of those 20 years they brought in a Budget and in not one of those Budgets was there ever a reduction. Each year taxation increased, increased and increased. There was never a decrease.
Comment on this
It is like all the figures they produce on that side of the House. They cannot count up to 20 and they come in here and talk in millions. We were always taught to believe that when we would go to the hereafter, if we had suffered any penances in this life, we would be rewarded. Much reward is awaiting the members of my Party who had to listen to Deputy Corry here this afternoon.
Comment on this
Deputy Moher is the danger to Deputy Corry, a great danger. Deputy Corry is a good man for asking questions. I have his answers. I have Volume 146, column 1174, 6th July, 1954. Deputy Corry did not produce these. He produced a figure for 1952. Then he asked a question to-day, and it was answered, and he did not give these figures either, because they would not suit. I heard the Leader of the Opposition pontificating around the country, warning everybody that the country was in pawn. Let us see about the pawning, according to the figures returned here in this House, in reply to Deputy Corry's question. In 1950-51 the inter-Party Government put the country in pawn to the tune of £21,000,000 according to these figures, and according to the Leader of the Opposition, in 1951-52, when the Fianna Fáil Government came back, it went up to £38,900,000—I will say £39,000,000. In 1952-53 it was £31,000,000. Fianna Fáil were in power in those years. In 1953-54 it was £32,000,000, 1954-55, £29,000,000, 1955-56, £23,000,000. There is consistency in reducing the figure.
Deputy Corry, of course, was ranting and raving about the Civil Service and the enormous waste of money that seemed to be poured out on the Civil Service. I met the civil servants first when I came up two years ago, and I must say they are a most efficient and competent body of men. We have always had an idea that is common down the country, that we get from our comic papers——
Comment on this
There was a good deal said to their detriment, and I thought I would right it, but if you say it I will not continue about them.
Comment on this
The only thing I would say about the increase in the Civil Service is that the Civil Service increased during the term of office of Fianna Fáil. It was they who created this enormous machine. Deputy Corry and some other Deputies mentioned the rates and local officials down the country, and the cost. I am right on the the button now, because it is in the Budget, I might as well say. I pointed out when I interrupted that we had no power or authority to rectify these costs down the country, as all our powers had been taken away by the Managerial Act brought in by Fianna Fáil.
I have allowed myself to be carried away in replying to Fianna Fáil, and I have not contributed much, but I want to compliment the Minister on this Budget. The Minister protected the people of this country. He disappointed Fianna Fáil, and the reason for the venom, the vilification and all the twisting and misrepresentation over there is that their prophets were proven to be false. I am reading now from the Irish Press, tied to Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
The Sunday Press, February 19th, 1956: “Norton will have to tell the nation bread is going up.—Mr. Lemass.” That was a frightful disappointment to him, that we did not follow the line of Fianna Fáil in our Budget, and remove all food subsidies and let crushing imposts fall on our people as Fianna Fáil intended in the 1952 Budget. I had to take notice of this.
The Leader of the Opposition said to-day that democracy was on trial, as the Parliamentary Secretary said. It is threatened by those who will promise most, says the Leader of the Opposition—the greatest promiser of all time. "I will bring back the emigrants, do away with emigration, reduce all salaries." Salaries in this country were to be brought down to a minimum; no Cabinet Minister would have more than £1,000 a year. Not only were taxes going to be brought down but we were nearly all going to be paid to live in the country. Bills were put up with all the salaries of district justices and God knows what on them. Not one of these promises was carried out.
It has been said here in the House that this enormous burden was put upon the country by the inter-Party Government. The misrepresentation by Fianna Fáil, again, was that £13,000,000 must be found, that huge sums were going to be thrown cheerfully down the shore and let run off into the bogs. We should see what we have on the credit side since they came into office. Forty-two thousand houses have been built in this country since 1948. That was mentioned by my colleague this evening. One person in ten is in a new house. That was worth laying out money for. Where ships could not be tied up and discharged there are magnificent docks and magnificent port installations in the various ports down the country, that were neglected by Fianna Fáil.
It used to be said, and it was said about six or seven years ago, that T.B. would always be with us and that the sanatoria would be empty. The millions spent on those sanatoria were well spent. I always remember the frontispiece of Knocknagow when I look at a sanatorium, and I remember how Kickham wrote there how his little nieces begged of him not to let poor Nora Leahy die. The Nora Leahys of Ireland were dying in their thousands, but, thank God, they are not now, because there are sanatoria there for them that they can go into. It is nothing to laugh at, but a triumph for the people over here.
Comment on this
When Deputy Ward was there there was not a vestige of a sanatorium in the city I come from, Waterford. The foundation stone was not laid until 1949, and Dr. Ward was far away from this House then.
Comment on this
I had no intention of coming in here. I was in politics then and I was not being paid for it. Deputy Corry spoke for nearly three-quarters of an hour on agriculture this evening.
Comment on this
He spoke about the poor farmers and he constantly referred to the 12/6 and the tax. I must refute this. Deputy Corry is a member of the Beet Growers' Association. That association was the negotiating body in the fixing of the price of barley for the years 1941, 1942, 1943, 1944, 1945, 1946 and 1947. They negotiated a price of 35/- a barrel. That was all we could get for our barley and we had to take it. Messrs. Guinness were paying 72/- for the English barley.
Comment on this
He was, but I think it is only fair that I should get an opportunity of answering what he said. There seems to be great grief on the Fianna Fáil benches that the poor people have to pay a penny a gallon on paraffin oil. I remember a right candle racket in this country that was run by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
It has, because candles cost money. These were the friends of the Minister of the day. They got the concession and the monopoly of candles. A good fat penny candle—
Comment on this
If the Deputy refuses to obey the Chair, I shall have to ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
With all due respect, I consider that, having been so lenient with other people, you might be lenient with me. I have been only two years in the House.
Comment on this
I have grown up all right. I have been about. The former Parliamentary Secretary, in his silver-tongued manner, said we were accusing Fianna Fáil of being conservative. Just look at the fine old bunch of conservatives over there. We have heard talk about the poor man, the small man, the small farmer and the unemployed man. They seem to be a sort of monopoly with the Opposition. According to Fianna Fáil, these people have been squeezed by us in the few years during which we have been in office. In my view, these people took a lot more punishment from Fianna Fáil than they ever took from us. Another thing we have to our credit is the land reclamation scheme. I am continually coming across fine fields now laid out in crops which were fox coverts before.
Comment on this
I am afraid it does not arise on the Financial Resolution. That would be a matter for the Estimate.
Comment on this
The last speaker mentioned electricity on the farms. He spoke at length about it, and about television sets and wireless sets. Why should people on the land not have television and wireless sets? They have a greater right to them than anybody else in the country.
I thought, when I was coming into Dáil Eireann that, whenever there would be a Budget debate, I should hear constructive criticism from the Opposition, or at least from the leaders of the Opposition, and that I should also hear constructive suggestions. I have not heard one constructive suggestion. Fianna Fáil taunted us again this evening about the old age pensioners. They said the old age pensioners are now being ground under foot, and so on. Before the inter-Party Government came into office, the leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party said that nothing could be done and nothing would be done for the old age pensioners: they said that at a time when the old age pensioner was receiving 12/6 a week. When the inter-Party Government came into office, they were able to raise that amount to 17/6 and, what was more important, they were able to raise the means test from £39 to £104, thus bringing in a lot of people who were not able to come in before that. That is not a bad record for a Government.
According to the Opposition, the tax on petrol will stop production. The usual venom was poured out on the Minister and on the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government. We had jeers, and all that sort of thing. I went to the trouble to find out something in this connection. I discovered that 75 per cent. of the petrol sold in this country is premium petrol. Therefore, only 25 per cent. of the petrol sold in this country is for commercial purposes.
I want to make a plea on behalf of one class of petrol users who are being squeezed a bit, so far as this petrol tax is concerned. It might be said that if the Minister gave them a concession or a rebate, there might be abuses. However, I put it to the Minister that some rebate should be given to hackney-drivers and taxi-men, as they are working people. I shall be interested to hear what the Minister has to say in regard to that suggestion.
At this late hour of the evening, may I express the hope that, in the remainder of the Opposition speeches on this Budget debate, we shall hear some constructive suggestions, as well, maybe, as some constructive criticism. Everybody over there on the Opposition Benches just shouts and says: "The Minister should not have taxed this, that and the other." Maybe they want to follow Deputy Lemass—possibly the wish was father to the thought—and to put a tax on bread. "Bread is going up," said Deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
They talk about increased production. It was said by the Opposition that there is no increased production in this country and that overall figures and so forth are down. Deputy Corry admitted this evening that there was a production of a ton of wheat to the acre. There were not 8 cwt. or 9 cwt. to the acre in 1947. Is that not an increase? Is that not an improvement?
Deputy Derrig who sat on the Government Benches for 20 years wanted to know when the Government would make a statement about reduction in expenditure. There is one matter about which I asked a question this evening. I do not know whether I will be allowed to discuss it or not, but it is a matter arising out of the Budget, as it involves expenditure. It is a question of ships. A lot of money will be required again this year and I am very glad to compliment the Minister and the Government on the news I got this evening in regard to the magnificent shipping programme Irish Shipping are carrying on at the present time. They have dropped their policy of building 10,000 ton ships and are building 9,000 and 2,000 ton ships deadweight.
Comment on this
I feel that would be a matter for discussion in connection with the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
It is a source of great consolation to me to know that these ships will be able to enter ports down the country, as well as being able to enter the Port of Dublin. I hope to speak on that. If I have gone off the line and if I have not kept to the Budget, I will do what none of my colleagues in the Dáil did, apologise, having tried the Chair so often.
Comment on this
The most disappointed people in the country to-day are the members of the Opposition, because, during the election and especially during the by-election, they said everything was going up in the Budget. That was their cry. They are very much disappointed because flour, butter and the other necessaries of life remain as they are. I have been here for the introduction of 14 Budgets—one of which was the Supplementary Budget that put Fianna Fáil out of office in 1947. Deputy Aiken was Minister for Finance in that year and he introduced a Supplementary Budget imposing £6,000,000 on the people in the way of taxes on tea, sugar, butter, cigarettes, tobacco and drink. In 1948, when the people got the chance at the ballot boxes, they put that Government out of power.
We came into office and we have no apologies to make for setting up the first inter-Party Government in this country, because, at that time, after 16 years under Fianna Fáil, we had the glasshouse at the Curragh Camp——
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
The first inter-Party Government brought relief to the people in the country in connection with prices, but what was more important they brought peace and harmony to the Irish people. That was some achievement and I was glad to be in a Government that did that.
Comment on this
When this Government came back at the last general election, we made it clear to the civil servants that the arbitration award, the machinery for which was set up by Deputy de Valera, then Taoiseach, would be honoured in full. That was no mean achievement. Does Deputy MacEntee think that our Army, our national teachers, our civil servants and everybody down to the postman in the rural areas should not get a higher rate of pay?
We did not hear a single member of the Fianna Fáil Party during to-day's and last week's discussion say anything about the social welfare benefits that are coming. I heard one Deputy say that the Labour Party was getting a few sops from the Government. In 1932, the Labour Party were promised by Deputy de Valera, that, if they put him into office, the down-trodden people would be looked after. After a very short time, when the Labour Party was pressing for certain things from the Government, what happened? He dissolved the Dáil in the middle of the night and told the people that he could not work with the Labour Party. He went to the country and came back with a majority because he deceived the people then.
There are reliefs in the Budget. The people down the country are not what some Fianna Fáil Deputies think they are. They have common sense. They are satisfied that the price of food has not gone up for the family. Any man who does not like to smoke need not do so. It is not compulsory, whether it be a pipe or a cigarette.
Comment on this
Then they cry about the child with the bottle of lemonade. Would it not be a great thing if they could say that the pint has gone up again? That is what is worrying the Opposition.
Comment on this
We hear a lot about the balance of payments. When the inter-Party Government left office, having been tricked out of it in 1951——
Comment on this
——by four Independents, and when a Coalition under Deputy de Valera was set up, what happened when they got in by way of a trick? They got in by a trick, a trick of four men.
Comment on this
These four men have not been seen in Leinster House since. I say that if the Opposition have a case to make, they should make it. Their Leader made no suggestion to-day. He kept far away from making any suggestion. He did not say what the Government should do, but he attacked the Labour Party. Can the Labour Party not use its own common sense? We know that the Party in Opposition at the moment has been dictated to over the years by one man. We are here now in an inter-Party Government. Every Party is represented in the Government and that could not be said for the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
I am glad that the widows and orphans are getting some consideration under this Budget. I am glad that the sick people are getting some relief. God knows it is time that some relief should come to these people, because they have been forgotten all over the years. Do the members of the Opposition say that the sick should not get any relief? They voted here against giving the money that would give them that relief, but will they go down the country, to Galway and elsewhere, and say that they voted against giving that money? No, they will keep away from that and will say that, if they had been in power, the money would have been more.
Let us go back to 1934. At that time, some of the committees of agriculture, including my own in County Wexford, passed resolutions condemning the action of the Fianna Fáil Government in authorising the slaughter of 200,000 calves annually. Was that a good policy?
Comment on this
Whether it was good or bad, the Deputy cannot discuss it on the Financial Resolution.
Comment on this
I want to get it on the records of the House, because on that committee there was a sister of the then Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
I will, Sir. I have got them on the record now. In the daily paper of 22nd January, 1956, it was stated that the current issue of the Irish Trade Journal had stated that, between July and October of the previous year, 176,000 workers had received wage increases totalling £3,250,000. If Fianna Fáil were in power, that would not happen. The present Tánaiste told us that, when he went into the Department of Industry and Commerce, he found there a Bill for the purpose of making a further standstill Order, so that the workers should not get a further increase in wages. These are facts that cannot be denied. I represent a constituency where we have two Labour representatives. We have a Minister for Social Welfare from Wexford, who is looking after the interests of the people whom I represent, the working people, the unemployed, and the widows. Last year, the old age pensioners got an increase twice in the one year. That was no mean achievement. When we left office, Deputy MacEntee spent £24,000,000 of Marshall Aid money. What did he do with it?
Comment on this
That is something you should tell the country. That money was squandered by the ex-Minister for Finance and by the present Opposition, the members of which are talking to-day about expenditure and about the Civil Service. Deputy Corry called the civil servants drones. He called professional men who went to college in order to be civil servants drones. That is very unfair because the civil servant is the next man to the Minister in the Department.
We find also that we are up against the fact that poison is being spread throughout the country by the Irish Press. They are poisoning the minds of the people and saying that the country is ruined. That is very bad. This Government is trying to remedy the position the country is in by putting levies on luxury goods. Any man who has a motor car does not mind paying a few extra pence for his petrol, but I would like to remind the Minister of this fact, that the day the Budget was introduced, the extra price was put on to the cigarettes and garages were charging the extra price for petrol that evening. I would like the Minister to keep his eye on that kind of thing and not let the people be fleeced.
We all know that our social benefits are not what they should be. They are not in keeping with those in the country across the water, or with those of our neighbours in the North. There is no use in talking about Partition or about bringing in the North, until we are able to give to the people in the North the conditions they have at present. As far as I am concerned, the Budget is not a bad one and things might be better, if there was more cooperation from the Opposition. There are good men on both sides of the House, but I was disgusted when I heard a statement, made down the country, by the Leader of the Opposition that there is nothing on the Front Bench of the Government but lawyers. That was a bad thing coming from the man who had been head of the State for so many years.
Comment on this
The working-class people are not disappointed with the Budget. They know that taxation must be got from somewhere. They know that the money does not spring up from the floor of Leinster House. Could Deputy MacEntee tell me where he would go for the money, if he had been Minister for Finance? No member of the Opposition has told the House what they would have done if they were in office. They prefer to talk, to jeer and to sneer at what was said during the general elections, but I could remind them of what they said all over the country in those days. I have reason to hope that next year there will be some more concessions and I am sure that as long as my colleague, Deputy Corish, is in charge of Social Welfare, the downtrodden people of this country will not be forgotten.
Comment on this
I do not know what Budget concessions Deputy O'Leary can be referring to unless it is that he takes pleasure at the unfortunate taxpayer having to cough up £5,500,000 in the coming year for housekeeping money for the Government. Of course, if the taxpayer had the knowledge that he was contributing £5,500,000 that would go into capital formation, he might take some comfort from the fact. Deputy O'Leary and his colleagues on the Labour Benches seem to me to have turned into the cheer leaders of the Coalition Government. They come into this House to cheer up the front and the back benches of the Fine Gael Party in order that they may smooth down the national temper, choke unfavourable comment in the country and pave the way for a continuance of this chronic condition in the life of the country. The Government are asking the people of the country to contribute £5,500,000 in extra taxation. For what?
Comment on this
The Deputy came into this House under the smokescreen of lower prices. The Deputy was sent in here by the voters of Dublin to reduce the price of cigarettes, beer, tobacco——
Comment on this
——coal, household goods, wearing apparel, and all the rest. The Deputy is a miserable failure in this House from that point of view and the Deputy should not interrupt when another Deputy tries to make a case——
Comment on this
——for the people of the country and for the people of Dublin. The Minister hopes to fleece the taxpayer this year to the extent of £5,500,000 and he hopes to get that £5,500,000 by an extra tax of 5d. on a packet of 20 cigarettes. I have heard various alibis and excuses to-night from the opposite benches about the price of cigarettes. I am indebted to Deputy Moher for making a small calculation while we were listening to the debate and we find on the basis of that calculation that, contrary to what is thought, the 5d. a lb. subsidy on butter means that the Exchequer contributes 16/8 per year towards that subsidy taking our consumption of butter at 40 lbs. per head of the population. I am not making a case against the subsidy on butter but I merely want to point out that if a man or woman smokes 20 cigarettes a day, he or she will contribute £7 12s. a year to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
Surely that is not an average of the cigarette consumption. You gave us the average of butter consumption.
Comment on this
If he smokes three ounces of tobacco he will contribute £3 18s. Between cigarettes and tobacco they will contribute £11 10s. a year.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture, having failed miserably to produce one more cow, one more sow and one more acre under the plough will sit on the Front Benches and take his medicine.
Comment on this
Deputy Carter is in possession and should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
I wish to contrast the attitude of the present Minister for Finance with that of his colleague, Deputy McGilligan, who has now no responsibility as a member of the Government but who, when the Fine Gael Party were looking for votes in the 1954 election, went down to Radio Éireann and on the 8th of May, 1954, broadcast a statement. Here is a quotation from that statement:—
"There was little doubt, he said, that savings in the cost of Government amounting to several million pounds a year could be secured without much effort. A change of policy was all that was required and a new outlook on the part of Ministers was demanded if the reduction of £20,000,000 and upwards desirable in everybody's interests was to be achieved."
I want to ask the various Parties forming the Government where does public responsibility begin or end, if an experienced ex-Minister, as he was at that time, could go down to Radio Éireann and give the people such an assurance in the name of the Fine Gael Party who set themselves up as the leaders in political thought then; if he could go down to Radio Éireann, beg votes on the strength of that promise and, having got, as they deemed it at the time, a mandate to form a Coalition Government, say afterwards that he would take no responsibility, that he would have no part in that Government and that, therefore, he was not responsible for the promises he made then. In fact he admitted in this House that he had really no authority collectively from the Parties that go to make up the Government to make that promise.
I want to query the methods of catching votes, to condemn it and to say that it is a dreadful thing if political thought has descended to such a low level that any Deputy with the amount of experience which Deputy McGilligan has, or had then, can go down to Radio Éireann and broadcast an announcement such as I have quoted in order to gain the votes of the people and cynically to say afterwards: "I did not make the promise. I have no responsibility. I will take no part in the Government." If we are being subjected to brain-washing tactics of that description, where will we end?
Comment on this
Does the present Government suggest that the Fianna Fáil Party, who are now in opposition, should go out and outbid them in promises to the electorate? Is that the suggestion? Is that, in effect, what they want us to do? It appears to me to be the tone of political expression at the moment that Fine Gael supporters in the country who are disillusioned and who have become cynical say: "Ah well, if we cannot do it, Fianna Fáil could not do it either."
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary, with his half-baked economic theories, is a discredited supporter of the Government at the moment and let him not further discredit himself in this House. Another prominent Minister of the present Government, the Minister for Defence, who represents my own constituency——
Comment on this
——outbid the whole lot put together when he went down to Sligo and said that Fine Gael would see to it that the Central Fund would undertake responsibility for all future expenditure and for some of the existing expenditure which was at present being met by local rates. That is a quotation from the Sligo Champion of the 20th March, 1954. There is another responsible Minister, who has long experience in and out of Government, cynically disregarding promises——
Comment on this
Remember your promises, I must say, which look at this stage as faded and as antiquated——
Comment on this
——as the photographs of their long deceased relatives. There were arguments here to-night on the cost of living and on food subsidies. Members of Parties were arguing from the opposite benches trying to make the case that Fianna Fáil would be glad if the food subsidies were removed and that they would be glad, in fact, if beer and other commodities were taxed. I want to make the point, and I think it is worth recording in the House, that Fianna Fáil were in office from 1951 to 1954 and, despite what the Government or its supporters may say about the cost of living, we realise that the cost-of-living index stood at 100 in 1947 and has shot up to 132; it was 99 when the first Coalition took over in 1948.
Comment on this
It was 99 when the first Coalition took over in 1948. If the Deputy wishes, she can go down to the Library and check up on that.
Comment on this
When Fianna Fáil came in to office in 1951 it was 109 and by June, 1954, when the Coalition came back to power, it was 124. It will be seen, then, that the cost of living went up by ten points during the Coalition's first period of office and by a further eight points to date.
Comment on this
I am taking the full period. It went up a further eight points to date, making a total of 18 points.
Comment on this
A Deputy made a remark about mud and I could give a little quotation on that. It might help the Deputy's outlook: "Two men looked out from bars; one saw mud, the other saw stars." I do not think the Deputy sees many stars. That, I think, deals in a small way with this argument regarding the cost of living.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy give us the increase in incomes in the two periods, to round it off?
Comment on this
Give us the figures for the increase in incomes, to round it off, so that we can make comparisons.
Comment on this
Many times the Parliamentary Secretary used those figures and tried to paint the picture that Fianna Fáil brought the cost of living higher during their period of Government than during the period of any other Government in history. He tried to paint that picture and he sold that dummy to the electorate in 1954.
Comment on this
Yes. They increased prices and unemployment at the same time, a feat that has seldom been performed in history.
Comment on this
The cost of living increased by a total of 18 points during the Parliamentary Secretary's period of office.
Comment on this
There is not even a wisp of evidence that the Government are aware of the crisis that is upon us. It is a crisis. The whole financial statement is in melancholy vein. It sets out our failure in the capital field, our failure as producers and it says, in effect, that we are priced out of every market abroad. It says, in effect, that the full blast is not yet felt. On the strength of that, the Government are asking the taxpayers for a further £5,500,000. All the red lights have been showing against us since the present Minister brought in his first Budget. Like a baby with a toy balloon, he takes great credit for what he has done. The Government, like the drunken driver, have persisted in driving through the red lights.
Comment on this
It may be. It may be even more so before your period of office is over. What is exercising my attention at the moment is where we are to get this £5,500,000. Of course, it will come principally from the younger people. It will come principally from those who go dancing, from those who smoke cigarettes, from those who take pleasure in an odd drive in a motor car.
Comment on this
We all know Fine Gael and Labour are delighted at the opportunity of taxing the people more heavily.
Comment on this
And with no idea of what the money is for. According to them, to travel hopefully is better than to arrive. The Government are living on hopes. Every second sentence in the Budget statement is a hope. The Minister hopes for more production; he hopes for more savings; he hopes for more everything.
Comment on this
Deputies must allow Deputy Carter, who is in possession, to speak. Most of the Deputies who are now interrupting have spoken already.
Comment on this
The Minister said he was fascinated by my book. I must tell him off, since he is so persistent in his interruptions.
Comment on this
What is unmannerly in admiring his book? I never saw the like of it in this House during the past 25 years.
Comment on this
If the Minister likes, I will give him one during the next day or two. It may help him in his Budget speech.
Comment on this
When the Minister for Finance spoke about the monetary situation in presenting the Budget, he was even more dismal. The picture is even blacker than we feared. He stated that, in 1955, for the first time, bank deposits fell by over £13,000,000. He said that bank advances rose by £18,000,000.
Comment on this
Then he goes on to argue in the Budget statement that the figures are closely related to the rise in consumption and in over-spending on luxuries. He states that, of course, in the face of the country's high unemployment rate. I asked a question on the subject in this House last week. We have over 1,000 men unemployed in Longford town and area.
Comment on this
The present Government said we were paupers a couple of years ago. They said the country was pauperised. They tell us now that we are living beyond our means, that we are buying luxuries and that we must stop that. The Minister for Finance catechised the Fianna Fáil Party when he was on this side of the House. He said we were copying Mr. Butler. He himself is now copying Mr. MacMillan. According to Deputy MacBride, we are suffering from anaemia, and he should be an authority.
Comment on this
Deputy MacBride says that the wrong cure has been applied. If so, why does he not get out?
Comment on this
He is up the rigging at the moment. He is up in the crow's nest, shouting. There is no comparison between our position and that in Britain. England has high blood pressure; we have anaemia, according to Deputy MacBride. Yet we have Dr. Sweetman doctoring the patient for blood pressure in the same way as Dr. MacMillan is treating the English patient.
Comment on this
Surely there is no need for Deputy MacBride to associate himself for a moment longer than is necessary with the Minister for Finance, if he thinks the Minister is treating the patient for the wrong disease.
Comment on this
Surely it is common sense to suggest that if you administer the same medicine to a man suffering from anaemia as you do to a man suffering from high blood pressure, you are bound to kill one or the other.
Comment on this
We have a high rate of unemployment. We have a still higher rate of emigration. I would safely say that we had a higher rate of emigration last year than ever before in history. If we are under-capitalised, why the Minister's credit squeeze? Have the Government any idea of orientating their policy? The Taoiseach said at one time that he was going to orientate the whole policy of the Government. There was an accident when he tried the orientation. It did not come off. We are being treated by the present Government blindly with the same medicine as is used by Mr. MacMillan.