We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 10—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–134 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I was dealing with the Taoiseach's speeches both during and since the Budget of 1952. The Taoiseach told us about the unjust and unnecessary toll of taxation. He told us about the comparatively trivial reliefs. We heard, of course, about our austerity proposals. But, as I have already said, we have heard nothing from him since he resumed office to show that these things were wrong. If they were wrong then, the Taoiseach has since had the remedy in his own hands. The Taoiseach could have got his Government to rescind those taxes and do all the things he said should be done in order to right the position. The Taoiseach is, of course, prepared to make speeches; he is also prepared to sit about and take no action.

We have listened time and again to all the Ministers on our present financial position. We have heard a good deal of talk about the balance of payments. Deputy MacBride has been very vocal and some little bit of heed seems to have been given to his utterances in relation to the collecting and spending of our external assets. I remember when the Government floated their second last loan. We were told here and down the country that that loan was an indication of the confidence the people placed in this Government. The Minister had quite a different story to tell the other day when he said: "In December, however, the Dublin Corporation issue of £6,000,000 attracted little public support." Do the Government realise now that if the previous loan, which proved a success, was a vote of confidence in the Government, the failure of subsequent loans is a vote of no confidence in the Government? We were told that the last Government loan was not fully subscribed. We know that only 40 per cent, was subscribed and that the banks had to be called upon to put up the remainder—the banks that Deputy MacBride wants to wipe out of existence, the banks that have been abused by every member of the present Government, when it suited them to do so.

I do not know very much about this banking business, except in so far as I have to try to meet my bank manager the best way I can; but I would say that if one approaches a bank manager, it is not wise to go in with a hammer in one's hand and threaten to hit him on the head. The way to approach a bank manager, or banks, is not the way of wild attack. The way to create confidence in the people is not by way of attacking the banks.

When we in Fianna Fáil set out, shortly after coming into office, to build up industries here, it was not by attacking those who had money to invest that we hoped to achieve success in that direction. The task was a pretty big one. We had, first of all, to encourage those who had money to invest their savings in these industries. At the same time, we had to ensure that the workers employed in those industries would receive a wage which would encourage or induce them to remain at home, rather than go abroad. It was not by wild attacks on those who had the money to lend that we achieved the success we did. If this Government had to face that task, I do not think they would do so by attacking the people they wished to come to their rescue, should they fail to find the money elsewhere. They would not succeed by attacking the people prepared to advance the money. I want to move away from that now.

Comment on this

Should we not discuss it at all?

Comment on this

I am speaking for myself now and I want to come to something that is of considerable importance in my constituency. I have heard a good deal of talk from Deputies here about the prosperity of the country at the present time, about the employment position—more employment, and all the rest of it. I wonder if there is any Deputy from my constituency who could sincerely subscribe to that view? I wonder if there is any Deputy from my constituency who can get up here and say that from the town of Tuam, since the end of January last, when the work that Fianna Fáil had put under way in relation to the building of schools and houses and so forth came to an end, hundreds and hundreds of unemployed workers have not emigrated. Deputies from my constituency know that they have emigrated and they know that there are others walking around, looking for even an hour's work, if they can get it. The position, therefore, is that unemployment is worse to-day than it ever was.

Comment on this

What? Say that again.

Comment on this

It is worse to-day than ever it was.

Comment on this

Six thousand less.

Comment on this

Short hours.

Comment on this

The vast majority have gone away. They are not here. Unfortunately, we cannot get from anybody the exact numbers who have emigrated to find employment because the figures are not segregated. We have no true record which would give us an exact picture of the numbers who have gone to seek employment. But each of us knows in his own heart the number who have gone and that number must be added to the unemployed register.

Comment on this

That never happened until this year?

Comment on this

Is the beet factory there still?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows the beet factory gives employment, and good employment, for a couple of months in the year. That is all.

Comment on this

It is there, anyway. It has not been done away with. We grow beet in Wexford for it.

Comment on this

Then the Deputy should know something about it.

Comment on this

It is still there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Killilea. Deputy O'Leary has already made a statement. He should be satisfied with that.

Comment on this

The beet factory works only for a couple of months in the winter, and the Deputy must know that. It does not give employment during the rest of the year. It gives a certain amount, but nothing like it gives during the campaign. The numbers have increased. We may not have them actually parading at the labour exchanges, but we must take the number that have emigrated and add it to the number of unemployed here to see what is the true picture. If all the people leave this country and seek employment in another country, we cannot say that we are making progress or that we are better off. We were promised an industry there and, I think, if it came like a streak of lightning, the Parliamentary Secretary would admit that it would not be too soon now.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy try and sabotage it now if he can.

Comment on this

It would be far from me to sabotage it. The Parliamentary Secretary need not be looking for a way out. I am not going to sabotage anything. I do say that anything that can be done by this Government to give a bit of employment in my constituency at this moment would be welcomed by the workers as a whole. Whoever brings that along will be hail-fellow-well-met with the whole lot of them.

I have nothing more to say except to remark that the speeches we have listened to here are not a reflection of the opinions expressed by the people in the country. There is no cheering or clapping for this Budget at all. Of course, Fianna Fáil supporters did not expect anything from this Government, but there were other sections who were led to believe that they would have concessions. Now it has been brought home to them quite clearly that this Government have just been bluffing them all along the line and are continuing to do so. To try to tell them that the taxes imposed in this Budget are not going to hit our people hard is only fooling them further and it cannot be done. They have to part with their cash to buy their cigarettes, to meet the increase on fuel oil and whatever charges the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs decides to put on, as well as the increase on matches and the other commodities. They may be termed as luxuries to-day, but we all know they were not termed luxuries by members of that Government some years ago.

Comment on this
Michael Donnellan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Donnellan) Clann na Talmhan

I often heard of people having faces of brass, but if ever such a thing happened, it occurred in the Fianna Fáil Party, especially in the case of Deputy Killilea who has just spoken. They talk about the cost of living. As far as I know, the cost of living is made up of the price of the bag of flour, the couple of pound of tea, the pound of sugar, the pound of butter and the loaf of bread. If our people have plenty of those, they will not die. Yet we hear Deputy Killilea and the Fianna Fáil Party talking about how this Budget has increased the cost of living. Because the Minister for Finance had to put a certain increase on the price of petrol, tobacco and cigarettes, the inter-Party Government have put the cost of living sky-high! They have not interfered with the price of bread; they have not interfered with the price of flour; they have not increased, but since they came in here have reduced, the price of butter; they have not interfered with, regardless of what Deputy Corry may say, the price of sugar——

Comment on this

And the child's bottle of lemonade.

Comment on this

There has been a little increase in the commodities I have mentioned, such as petrol, cigarettes, tobacco, matches, and the penny on the paraffin oil that Deputy Killilea spoke about. I go down to Galway too. He said he met a lot of people there last week and that they must be gone mad in North Galway. Certainly I met ten to every one Deputy Killilea met. I met taxi drivers. According to Deputy Killilea they should get special concessions— when Fianna Fáil is out of office. When they are out of office, Deputies opposite look for special concessions for everybody, but when they are in office, they have a face as hard as a blacksmith's anvil.

From 1943 to 1948, I looked across at them on this side of the House for two or two and a half years, with the "busted flush" that has now "busted" to all ends of the world. What was the view on farming of some of the "busted flush" that supported Fianna Fáil at that time? What was the view of the then Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, when bringing in his Budget here? Poor Deputy Killilea was worried about cattle at the fair of Tuam. I sold a few cattle there, my father before me sold cattle and, please goodness, my son will sell cattle, too. Ninety per cent. of the people who sold and bought their cattle there, long before Deputy Killilea knew where the town of Tuam was, were satisfied if they got £50 or £52 for their cattle. They are the class of people to whom the Minister for Agriculture referred here—the people who reared their own. It is not the fellow who does the jobbing or the "tangling" that matters; it is the man who rears his own, and he is the man, as was pointed out by the Minister for Agriculture, who will always get on in this country, and not the "tangler." If the 5/- "tangler" is disappointed in the fair of Tuam and if Deputy Killilea is worried about him, I am not one bit.

Comment on this

On a point of order. What have "tanglers" at the fair of Tuam to do with the Budget? I was kept very strictly to order when speaking last night.

Comment on this

We do not want Cromwell over here at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Standing Orders are applied equally to everybody and, so far, the Parliamentary Secretary has not travelled outside Standing Orders or been irrelevant.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has not moved outside of Tuam, as far as I can see.

Comment on this

I remember going to the fair of Tuam in the early days when Fianna Fáil was in power. A similar beast to the beast I sold on the 10th March last at £52 10s. I sold at that time for £3 10s.; and I defy Fianna Fáil to deny that. I was a member of Fianna Fáil at one time.

Comment on this

That was most patriotic of the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

I remember not so long ago Deputy MacEntee introducing a Budget here and he said taxation was lying lightly on the land. I was sitting over there where poor Deputy Killilea is now. I began to sweat and worry what was the next thing that would happen the farmers. What was Fianna Fáil going to do? What plan had they up their sleeve now, after having introduced a Budget in which they increased the price of his tea, his sugar, his bread, his flour, his tobacco, his cigarettes, and the famous pint about which Deputy Killilea spoke? They had all gone up—and taxation lay lightly on the land! I thought that that was one of the raving lunacy statements—by that I mean statements made without any consideration—that Deputy MacEntee very often used to make. Later on came a bolt from the blue—the farmers again—and who was involved? One of the "busted flush" who has gone out of existence now.

Comment on this

Deputy Byrne?

Comment on this

No, Deputy Dr. Noel Browne, who joined Fianna Fáil. He made a statement in the House which shows how this was all premeditated. At column 2335, Volume 129 of the Official Debates of the 19th March, 1952, he is reported as having said:—

"...the farmers must be given to understand that unless they are prepared to take on the responsibility of developing their holdings to their maximum the Government will have to take control and reallocate the land to those who are prepared to make the best use of it."

Comment on this

Did he say anything about compensating them?

Comment on this

Not a damn word about it. The land was going to be taken from them. All of this was evolved by Deputy MacEntee but the other boys put in an odd spur as a reminder. There were even worse suggestions than that against the farmers. The same Deputy made another speech in this House and was supported by Deputy Seán Flanagan of the Fianna Fáil Party. He said at column 617, Volume 137, of the Official Debates of the 18th March, 1953:—

"One must do something about agriculture. One must tax the farmers. One must get more of the money that passes between farmers at fairs and that never goes near the banks."

Do you see the point? It never goes near the banks! According to that, Fianna Fáil believe they should raid the homes of the people in rural Ireland and see if there is anything left in the stocking, as we say in Galway. He goes on to say in the same column:—

"Everybody knows that the money is there... Nobody will make any attempt to get it. The larger part of our farming community pays no income-tax."

If Fianna Fáil were in power to-day, if Deputy MacEntee was where I am standing and Deputy Killilea was outside the barrier, there would be a Budget brought in here and it would not be an increase of a few pence in petrol, an extra ½d. on matches, an extra few pence on tobacco or cigarettes. It would be: tax the farmers. Deputy Dr. Noel Browne continued:—

"It is living in the eighteenth century, yet it is the farmers who get free grants and all sorts of other benefits..."

There was the policy of Fianna Fáil as enunciated in this House, and the moment he sat down, Deputy Seán Flanagan, who was not on the sideline at that time, stood up and said that it was a privilege to speak after Deputy Dr. Noel Browne. Deputy Killilea is the last man who should talk about the farmers. Deputy Killilea referred to the best day that ever happened the farmers of this country and said what a rosy picture there was in 1954. The rosiest picture that the farmers of this country ever saw was in June, 1954, when those boys were marched across the floor of the House. That was the rosiest picture that the farmers and the agricultural community could ever see.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Parliamentary Secretary should refer to the members of this House as Deputies.

Comment on this

Some of those to whom I refer are ex-Deputies and there are a few who will be ex-Deputies later on. Deputy Killilea is worried about rural electrification. In his own area in Galway, unfortunately for him, nearly everybody has got electricity. I think 90 per cent. of the people in North Galway have had their houses wired up, thanks to the efforts of Deputy McGilligan back in 1948 and to our efforts at the present time. The Deputy says the people still have to work the stove to boil a kettle of water. Is not the old turf fire that was there in the Deputy's time and in my time still there, so that the people are not depending on the stove to boil a kettle?

I listened to Deputy Killilea when he referred to the terrible position in which the people of Galway and the West of Ireland were placed on account of the reduction in the price of wheat and also the price of barley. I was also listening to Deputy Moran, of South Mayo, just across the river from Deputy Killilea and myself, and he said that the price of barley and of feeding stuffs for feeding pigs had gone too high. What way do they want it? Surely if you want the price of barley, which is the chief item for pig feeding, very high, and if our Minister and our Government must fix a high price to suit Deputy Killilea, how can the manufactured feeding stuffs remain at a cheap price for Deputy Moran? They cannot have it both ways. We heard again from Deputy Killilea about the promises made by the Taoiseach. I was in the Square of Tuam when Deputy Costello, now Taoiseach——

Comment on this

Deputy Hession will never forget it.

Comment on this

Ex-Deputy Kitt will never forget it. What did the Taoiseach say that night? He said, in effect, as he had said all during that general election: "If you give us an over-all majority, we will go back as an inter-Party Government. I will make no promise whatsoever. Anything we can do for the people as a Government we will do." Was there ever a better proof of it than the Budget which has been presented by the Minister for Finance and by this Government? The more a rat is trapped, the more he will squeal, and, if they are squealing over on that side of the House, it is because they know they are in a corner from which they will never escape.

Deputy Killilea referred to unemployment. Is he aware that we have 6,000 less on the register of unemployed to-day than we had six months ago and over 9,000 less than we had two years ago?

Comment on this

They have all gone to England.

Comment on this

There are more in employment. Deputy Killilea asked why there was not more progress in industry in Tuam. He knows very well of another industry right beside Tuam where this Government is spending over £2,200,000 on a drainage scheme. To-day, that scheme is giving employment to more than 400 men, reclaiming 75,000 acres of land, as a free grant to the people of this country.

Comment on this

Do you call that an industry?

Comment on this

The people of this country on the whole, the ordinary decent people of this country, except the odd Fianna Fáil individual who wants to stir up trouble, are satisfied with this Budget. I could go back to my 14,000 or 15,000 constituents in North Galway to-morrow morning and every one of them would say that this is a Budget that is not creating any real hardship. That is the position.

Comment on this

It does not give any relief.

Comment on this

The day of relief for our people will soon be gone. We will have employment for them all. Perhaps we will be doing what Fianna Fáil were talking about doing in 1932; perhaps we will be sending for those who left the country in the Fianna Fáil time, and bringing them back here, and giving them employment.

In talking about the banks and the bank rate, Deputy Killilea said that we thought the only way to deal with the bank manager was to hit him on the head with a mallet. I do not think that is the way to treat any bank manager.

Comment on this

Or anybody else.

Comment on this

The only difference between us and Fianna Fáil, in connection with the bank rate, is that if Fianna Fáil were in office all the time, we would have had two more rounds of it. When our Minister defended his attitude with regard to the bank rate, he was abused from that side of the House. Now, when he has increased the bank rate, why I do not know, but on his own judgment and the judgment of the Government, he is attacked again from that side of the House. That is just like them. When we subsidised tea for 12 or 18 months, or whatever the period was——

Comment on this

He has to look for advice from those beside him.

Comment on this

If ever I have to look for any intelligence, it is not over that side of the House I will look for it. When we subsidised tea, we were abused from that side of the House for doing it. Then when the price of tea found its level and the Government said that they would let the consumer pay the price, we were attacked again for doing that. Fianna Fáil wants to blow hot and cold every time.

As a representative of the farming community in this House, I am proud of this Budget. I was never more proud than when I heard the Minister for Agriculture standing up in this House and pointing out here, as was his job, what the farmers should do and what encouragement they would get in doing it. Anything that can be done for the farmers, no matter what the cost is, will be done for them. A million acres of land that was bog, and brush and scrub has been reclaimed. Even on Deputy Killilea's own land, that was done.

Comment on this

Did he take advantage of it?

Comment on this

Why would he not, as a good farmer?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

These interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

Anything I got, I always paid for it. That is one boast I can make, at least. The speech of the Minister for Agriculture has given our farmers a sense of security. They know where they are now and where they stand. They know they have not got a Government of grabbers under which they did not know where they stood at all. Under that Government, they did not know but that perhaps the land they had to-day would be taken from them to-morrow. Even the machinery that was brought in for doing important work on the farms, was sold away again when we left office. The farmers have security now and they know it. I am proud of this Budget and anything said about it on the Fianna Fáil Benches is only eyewash.

Comment on this

The people behind the Parliamentary Secretary must be very proud of his exhibition here this evening.

Comment on this

We will judge you after your speech.

Comment on this

I never heard such blah-blah as we have had from Tuam fair down to the security of the farmers.

Comment on this

Up to the security of the farmers.

Comment on this

I have here a speech made by the Parliamentary Secretary in column 640, Volume 131, in which he said:—

"With the change of Government and with the help of a man like Deputy McGilligan taxation could be reduced to the extent of £10,000,000."

Comment on this

That is the £10,000,000 we would have on now, if you were over in this side of the House.

Comment on this

I heard the Taoiseach saying to-day that this was a sound Budget. Is there any Deputy will tell me what changes there are in this Budget from the 1952 Budget? Is every item of food and drink not dearer to-day than it was then? Is it not the same Budget, plus extra taxation, except for the 5d. off the butter? We were told that that was a hair-shirt Budget. It was a Budget which was condemned by the Minister for Finance, by all the Labour people and by the Minister for Social Welfare, but this is the most depressing Budget ever introduced. Now we have the same Budget introduced by the inter-Party Minister for Finance. We have an extra 5d. on the cigarettes, an extra 6d. on the gallon of petrol, a penny on the pint of lemonade, 4d. on tobacco and the price of snuff gone up. The Parliamentary Secretary said they did not interfere with the price of flour. Of course they interfered with the price of flour. They increased the price of flour for confectionery for the child's cake. Now they have brought the lemonade in with that, so that the children cannot have a cake or a bottle of lemonade, without paying more for them. And this is the Budget that was welcomed by the members of the Cork Workers Council, Deputy Casey said yesterday.

Comment on this

A non-political body.

Comment on this

Mar dheadh! It is only a couple of months since that council protested against the increase in the cost of living.

Comment on this

They were right.

Comment on this

And they are now trying to cod the people by saying they are glad to pay these new taxes.

Comment on this

Have they not got a little more money than they had in 1952?

Comment on this

They have plenty of money now.

Comment on this

A lot more than in 1952.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Parliamentary Secretary was given an opportunity to make his statement and he should now afford the same opportunity to Deputy McGrath.

Comment on this

Deputy Casey says that the Cork Workers Council represents 30 trade unions, some of whom are supporters of Fianna Fáil. I do not know how any body of workers could welcome extra taxation when the cost of living was already so high. This new taxation is on top of the 1952 Budget. It represents, as I have said, extra taxation on cigarettes and tobacco, on petrol, on matches, on the child's lemonade. There was quite recently also the restriction on imports. I know a rowing club in Cork which wanted to import a racing gig which they could get at a cost of £100 extra in order to indulge in the sport of rowing. Now, they will have to pay more because of the import restrictions. Deputy Casey said this was a kill-joy Budget. It certainly will kill the joy of smoking, of dancing, and as far as the Cork Boat Club are concerned it will kill the joy of indulging in the sport of rowing. It has killed the child's joy in the bottle of lemonade and in his cake. All this follows on the promises of the glorious things we were to get when the Coalition were in office. I have various quotations here one of which is from the Minister for Social Welfare who talked about the extra million Fianna Fáil were giving to the manufacturers by their tax on smoking.

Comment on this

I repeated it in my speech last week.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not here then.

Comment on this

They are getting £1,500,000 now from this Government.

Comment on this

How much will they get on cigarettes?

Comment on this

I could not tell the Minister, but I know who will pay the extra tax. It is the workers.

Comment on this

It is the consumers.

Comment on this

It is the smokers.

Comment on this

Nobody denies that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

The Deputy left yesterday and does not know what was said.

Comment on this

What has that got to do with it?

Comment on this

The Deputy would have known what was said.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy McGrath, on the Resolution.

Comment on this

I will say it is a very bad thing to see a body of workers welcoming extra taxation. I think I am entitled to say that here. We heard a lot of talk about the old age pensioners, of their smoke and their pinch of snuff, when the 1952 Budget was introduced. I wonder will the Minister for Social Welfare tell us what he is doing now for the old age pensioners?

Comment on this

God forgive the whole crowd of you.

Comment on this

What is he doing for the non-contributory widows to help them meet the extra taxation?

Comment on this

God forgive you again. God forgive Deputy de Valera and Deputy Dr. Ryan for what they said about them.

Comment on this

What will the Minister for Health have to say for the people drawing T.B. benefits? Will they have to bear all this extra burden themselves? What is the Minister for Defence going to say about the Old I.R.A. men drawing special allowances? They have to bear this extra burden themselves. Nothing is being done for these people. The means test for these Old I.R.A. special allowance recipients is strict enough as it is. Of course their usefulness is gone. Their day is over, and they are not wanted. Why were they not given an increase to meet the increased taxation? It is because their usefulness has ceased.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil did badly by them, too.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil brought in the Act for them and were the only people to do anything for them.

Comment on this

That is what you think.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Leary is continuously interrupting.

Comment on this

The Government gave nothing to the recipients of I.R.A. special allowances, to the people who have to be incapable of self-support.

Comment on this

These people have a very strict means test. There could not be a stricter means test.

Comment on this

What did Deputy Collins say?

Comment on this

I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary knows that that is true.

Comment on this

I know all about Abbeyfeale.

Comment on this

I will tell you more about North Cork than you would ever wish to hear. I know all about it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This conversation across the House must cease. Deputy McGrath is in possession and must be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

Most of the interruptions are coming from the opposite side.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

They are coming from every side. It is most disorderly.

Comment on this

It is very hard for the people on this side of the House to listen to the untruthful interruptions from the other side. These I.R.A. men to whom I have been referring have a most strict means test. If one of their children is working, the whole of his earnings are taken into account in the means test. In the case of old age pensioners, it is only the profit from the earnings that is taken into account. Somebody said there were fewer registered unemployed at the moment. It is no wonder there would be. They were told, when they were walking the streets of Dublin, by the Chairman of the Labour Party, Deputy Kyne, that they would get £3 10s. a week under the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

When did he say that?

Comment on this

Was it not one of the things published in the papers?

Comment on this

Can the Deputy quote it from the papers?

Comment on this

He does not deny saying it. The Labour Party are in control of Social Welfare and there is still no £3 10s. on the dole.

Comment on this

There is something in the Budget to give them.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the Budget to give them anything.

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this

What increase is there?

Comment on this

Twenty-five per cent.

Comment on this

On the dole?

Comment on this

For those unemployed in receipt of unemployment benefit.

Comment on this

I refer to people on the dole. The Minister is not talking to a mug.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should address the Chair and not anyone across the floor of the House.

Comment on this

I am saying, Sir, that the Minister for Social Welfare was trying to mislead the House by saying that the people on the dole were getting a 25 per cent. increase and, when questioned, changed it to people on unemployment benefit. The Minister does not need to be instructed on the difference between people on the dole and people on unemployment benefit.

Comment on this

Neither does the Lord Mayor.

Comment on this

No, but he is not going to let the Minister mislead the House.

Comment on this

I had no intention of doing so.

Comment on this

The Minister said it had been increased. He said there was an increase.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy against it?

Comment on this

Of course, he is.

Comment on this

Do not mind the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

I am against letting them down in the way they have been let down.

Comment on this

Who have been let down?

Comment on this

The men drawing the dole.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. Ryan said he would give them nothing when he was on that side of the House. I will quote him.

Comment on this

The Labour Minister is acting up to what Dr. Ryan told him. Has it come to that?

Comment on this

He told the House that, if he were Minister for Social Welfare, he would not increase the social welfare benefits.

Comment on this

He was Minister for Social Welfare.

Comment on this

What did Deputy de Valera say?

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny it?

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee also said so.

Comment on this

The Minister tried to mislead the House when Deputy O'Leary said there was something in the Budget and said there was about 25 per cent. increase for people drawing the dole. When he was challenged, he changed.

Comment on this

Challenged, my foot! Did I not make the speech last week? Let the Deputy not think the people down the country are as stupid as he is.

Comment on this

I am not trying to hurt the Minister. I am sure the Minister knows that there are more people drawing unemployment benefit than for some few years past.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like me to quote Deputy Dr. Ryan now?

Comment on this

Let us have the full quotation.

Comment on this