We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 10—General (Resumed).

Contributions 135–266 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Speaking in the Dáil on 23rd June, 1954, at column 403, Deputy Dr. Ryan said:—

"I only want to ask the Minister whether, in his reply, if he will give an indication when this matter of increased benefits under social welfare will be considered. I do not want to embarrass him by saying that if I were there I would do it. I think it could not be done. I think we were spending as much as we could out of the national income on sickness and other benefits."

Comment on this

What could not be done?

Comment on this

Increased social welfare benefits.

Comment on this

Increased taxation.

Comment on this

We were talking about unemployment assistance, but now the Minister switches over to a general statement on social welfare benefits made by Dr. Ryan.

Comment on this

The whole lot.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

There is a big difference.

Comment on this

What did the Leader of the Opposition say about the whole lot?

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary put that on a blackboard, so that we will be able to read it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy McGrath should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

I think the Parliamentary Secretary is only making things worse for his side of the House by these interruptions. If he had any sense, he would keep his mouth shut.

Comment on this

That would apply to the Lord Mayor who interrupted the Taoiseach when he was speaking.

Comment on this

I only interrupted once when he was telling the people to save more. I said there is nothing left for them to save. I do not think anybody can deny that. There is a lot of play about the numbers of the unemployed. I should like to point out to the Minister for Social Welfare that there are a number of factories working on four days a week now in Cork and Cork district.

Comment on this

And everywhere else.

Comment on this

That is not registered in the local employment exchange. Dunlops and Carrigaline Potteries are working on four days a week, as are furniture factories and a lot more. I can assure the Minister that, if the number of unemployed included those working four days a week, the figures would be more serious than they are at present. Even apart altogether from those figures, there are numbers of people flying out of the country every week as fast as they can go.

I should like to know if there is anything in this Budget that is going to help the Cork Corporation to build their houses. Are we to have our contracts held up for the best months of the year? We have one contract in respect of which a tender has been sanctioned by the Minister for Local Government, but we cannot build our houses because we cannot get money and that notwithstanding the fact that sanction was given for us to borrow money from the bank by the Minister for Local Government.

When we went to get the money, we could not get it, as I think everybody knows by now. We have not yet been told when we will get the money. The contractor is waiting to start the work on 100 or 98 houses. Men come to me and ask me when this job is going to be started and it is not started. The previous Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government, the late Deputy Davin whose passing we all regret, because he was sincere in his efforts to build houses, came down and told us we need not bother about money. He told the City Manager to go to sleep——

Comment on this

He never suggested that you spend a couple of hundred too much on a house.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Parliamentary Secretary is talking about.

Comment on this

The Lord Mayor would not understand that. Should £200 too much be paid per house?

Comment on this

I do not know what this stupid man is talking about.

Comment on this

Too well the Lord Mayor knows what I am talking about.

Comment on this

If he is talking about those houses, the Minister for Local Government delayed them a couple of months. He brought the architects up from Cork Corporation and the architects from the Department of Local Government and there was agreement in regard to a reduction of £20 per house. The Parliamentary Secretary multiplied that by ten.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be a matter for the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this

Would it be fair to expect that I should allow an untrue remark like that to pass—a remark which was put in a sneering way by a person who does not know what he is talking about?

Comment on this

There was some reduction.

Comment on this

That is a long way from £200.

Comment on this

I am going to say very definitely that the £20 per house was agreed on by the architects of Cork Corporation, the architects in the Department of Local Government, the Minister for Local Government and the five Cork City Deputies. The Deputies who sit behind the Parliamentary Secretary were present when we came to that agreement. That is multiplied now by ten.

Comment on this

The Deputy should bring the Parliamentary Secretary the next time.

Comment on this

I think I should, but most people now are beginning to understand that this Parliamentary Secretary is more stupid than they thought.

Comment on this

That is direct from a Grey Eminence, anyway.

Comment on this

I am glad that Deputy Barry has come in.

Comment on this

He is going out again.

Comment on this

He could confirm my statement.

Comment on this

I could confirm a lot of things about the Deputy.

Comment on this

You can, but you do not want to. You can go out now and ask the Minister for Finance for that few thousand pounds.

Comment on this

He will not face it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy McGrath, on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I want to know from the Minister for Finance how long more we will be kept waiting for this money, or are we going to get it at all?

Comment on this

Get the price right and you will get the money.

Comment on this

Do not talk nonsense.

Comment on this

This price has been agreed on and if this stupid man on the other side is going to continue, I cannot help stupidity even in a Parliamentary Secretary. The price is settled. It has nothing to do with the price.

Comment on this

I am sorry; I have to go out.

Comment on this

It is about time. Wisdom departs.

Comment on this

We hear all this talk about this Budget which is described as a housewife's Budget, but I am sure there are many Deputies who remember the 1947 Supplementary Budget, when the Fianna Fáil Government increased the price of the pint, the price of cigarettes and cinema tickets and reduced the price of bread, tea, sugar and butter for the housewife, as an emergency measure. What happened? Fianna Fáil lost office by reducing the price of those very essential goods, the things that hit the poor more than anybody else. Now we have the Cork Workers' Council welcoming this Budget. They did not welcome the 1947 Supplementary Budget which helped the housewife more than anybody. I will always stand over, and never regret——

Comment on this

The wages standstill Order.

Comment on this

Do not mind that. There is a very good standstill at the moment, as regards building, at any rate. I will never regret that Fianna Fáil brought in a Budget to reduce the price of bread, tea, sugar and butter for the poor man and his wife and family.

Comment on this

When Labour opposed subsidies.

Comment on this

I have been listening in Cork and elsewhere to statements that the cost of living must be reduced, even if it is necessary to restore subsidies. We got 5d. off the butter and the poor fellow who smokes will have to pay that 5d. on every packet of cigarettes. Is that not the position?

Comment on this

That is the position——

Comment on this

Is the Minister for Social Welfare not ashamed that he has done nothing now for the people who are drawing the dole and of being a member of a Government that has done nothing to increase the allowance to disabled Old I.R.A. men, who are put in the position that they must be incapable of self-support before they can draw the special allowance?

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was looking for a reply.

Comment on this

Is the Minister for Social Welfare not ashamed that they would not give some increase in the T.B. allowance? Do they think that the cost of living has gone down for T.B. patients and has gone up for everybody else?

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy did not listen to the speech of his leader yesterday.

Comment on this

I am speaking for myself and the Minister ought to speak for himself. Is he ashamed or not that he is not dealing more fairly with the Old I.R.A., with the people drawing T.B. allowances, with those who are forced, through slackness in the building trade and everything else, to draw the dole? He forgets them now, but they will not forget him.

Comment on this

We are doing more for them than you would.

Comment on this

What about the '40s?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. O'Sullivan) Fine Gael

At this stage of the discussion on the Financial Resolutions Deputies are in a better position to assess public reaction to the Budget. The Minister in his introduction was quite frank in describing the Budget as a realistic rather than a popular Budget. He is to be congratulated on his presentation of it, on its content and on its reception in the country.

I represent an area which is predominantly agricultural and what I was most impressed with was the Minister's watchfulness to ensure that production costs in the agricultural industry would be protected from the impact of any new taxes. This attitude contrasts with that of a previous Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, who enshrined a precept in an earlier Budget that taxation rests lightly on the land. That was supported at that time by a Deputy who has now departed from this House, but who has been honoured by acceptance into the National Executive of the Fianna Fáil Party. He was quoted here earlier by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. It is a good thing that we have got away from that mentality, from anything like an indication from the Minister charged with the finances of the country that he would incorporate in a Budget statement an opinion that taxation rests lightly on the land.

There were many impacts in earlier Budgets on the agricultural community which could have been avoided if the same consideration had been given as is afforded by the Minister for Finance in his Budget statement of this year. That is appreciated by the agricultural community.

Deputy Lemass intervened in the debate to-day, the selected speaker on behalf of the Opposition. I confess that, as a Deputy who came into this House at a time when Deputy Lemass was in these benches and was acting as Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce, I had considerable regard for him in his capacity as a Minister and in the way that he received representations in the course of debates, and so on, but, since his translation to the other side of the House, he has fallen very quickly and very far from the pedestal on which many people had placed him.

Deputy Lemass, in his contribution to the debate, was petulant and angry. His speech followed a statement which was factual and logical, and yet Deputy Lemass, when he jumped to his feet, charged the members of the Government with being almost criminal in their negligence of duty, with having permitted expenditure to get out of hand, with not having done this and not having done that. He charged the Taoiseach with not dominating his Ministers, not riding over them, not directing them as they should be ordered around and he tried to infer that there were men in the Government who are incapable of administering the Departments over which this Dáil and the people of this country have placed them. That was unworthy of Deputy Lemass. He went so far as to say that a requisite for capable administration of a Department was that the Minister in charge should have business experience. I do not know if he ever directed that stricture to his own Party Leader who was Taoiseach and who would not conform to regulations set down by Deputy Lemass, or did he think that his, Deputy Lemass's, experience in that field was sufficient to balance the lack of it in other members of his Cabinet? I think many of his colleagues must have felt rather ashamed of that statement. It was unworthy of him.

He referred also to the fact that Ministers of this Government were paying visits abroad in their capacity as Ministers. One may understand criticism of that nature coming from people far removed from this House, one may understand such criticism from people who would never know the advantages of journeying abroad and the good than can be brought to the country on occasions such as that. Even in Opposition, Deputy Lemass is not averse to travelling abroad and doing much good in the course of his visits in the expression of views which are to the advantage of this country. Realising that, he must have been criticising with his tongue in his cheek when he tried to play to that gallery in relation to visits abroad by Ministers.

The Deputy also, both on that occasion and again to-day when he had an opportunity of making a more complete statement, said there had been an increase in the number of civil servants over the last 12 months amounting to 300. I wonder where he got his figures? That has been said but it has not been supported.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary would tell us what the figures are?

Comment on this

I think I will leave it to somebody who is better fitted to give the figures before this debate concludes.

Comment on this

Surely, if the Parliamentary Secretary is going to contradict Deputy Lemass——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary, without interruption.

Comment on this

Deputy Derrig, Deputy Lemass, and everybody else will then be in a position to know how much they were wrong in their estimate. That is not the only estimate in which mistakes have been made.

Comment on this

And not all confined to one side of the House.

Comment on this

It was asserted that there has been a fall in agricultural production. Last evening, the Minister for Agriculture challenged Deputies on the other side, who said there was an overall reduction of 2 per cent. in agricultural production last year, to support that and to indicate where they got their figures. This morning Deputy Lemass said that those figures were to be found in the Budget statement. He said that the Minister for Finance, in introducing the statement, said there was a fall of 2 per cent. in agricultural production. Again, I think it is unworthy of Deputy Lemass or anybody to take something out of its context and stand on it. I will draw the attention of the House to the Budget statement. Deputy Lemass charged the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance with being at variance with each other on this point. Actually, the Budget statement confirms, though not in as detailed a form, the statement given here in greater detail last evening by the Minister for Agriculture.

Deputy Lemass stated the Minister for Finance said that agricultural production had fallen by an estimated 2 per cent., then he stopped. I shall quote from the Budget statement as it appears in the Official Report of the 8th May, 1956, column 24. The Minister for Finance said:—

"There was a fall last year in the volume of agricultural output, particularly in that part of output which is represented by exports of meat. The extent of the fall in agricultural output as a whole is estimated provisionally at 2 per cent."

Then Deputy Lemass stopped—but I will continue. Here is what the Minister for Finance said:—

"The increase in cattle stocks holds out hope that the ground lost will be recovered this year. Looking to the future, output and exports of cattle are likely to rise with the improvement in veterinary services and the reduction in the mortality of young cattle."

Deputy Lemass would not include the remainder of that paragraph for the reason that the Minister for Finance said exactly what the Minister for Agriculture said here last evening, except that the Minister for Agriculture was more detailed in pointing out the increased value of the stocks in this country at the moment and went into more detail in relation to the greatly increased value of land in consequence of our capital investment over the past seven or eight years.

Comment on this

That does not alter the fall in agricultural production last year.

Comment on this

It certainly does.

Comment on this

There was no fall.

Comment on this

It is very easy to understand the position. The country carries the greatest known stocks in our history, the capital value of which is very much enhanced. Over the past seven or eight years people have invested £8,000,000 in the erection of farm buildings and that has been supplemented by investment by the agricultural community in preparations to house more stocks. One million acres of land have been reclaimed. We must not forget all that has been done by the farmers and that is being done at this moment in the improvement of grassland, the efforts they are making in the clearance of fences and every improvement they are making which will be followed up by greater stocks on the land, more for sale, and consequently more profit to the country as a whole.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is telling us that the market prospects, then, are going to be satisfactory?

Comment on this

Deputy Derrig is worried about the market prospects. Deputy Derrig belongs to the Party that gloried in the death of the British market.

Comment on this

We never did.

Comment on this

His Party took pride in the fact that it took 100 years to build the British market and that, with the help of God, it would take only 100 days to destroy it. Shame——

Comment on this

Tell us the prospects of the farmers in the coming years.

Comment on this

It is well to see Deputies on the Fianna Fáil benches getting excited over the prospect of anything like a recession in the cattle trade when, as recently as 1947, no fewer than 148,000 calves were slaughtered in this country. Stocks would not have been available as adult cattle for sale at any fair or in any sales ring were it not for the fact that, with the advent of the first inter-Party Government, the slaughter of infant calves was clamped down on and there was an improvement of veterinary services which has succeeded in reducing the mortality in this country from 80,000 to 8,000.

Comment on this

They would be as scarce as the rabbits if Fianna Fáil were there.

Comment on this

There is an achievement. If we to-day have a record number of live stock on the land of this country, notwithstanding the increased exports in recent years, then it is certainly an achievement and it is the greatest asset we have to-day in facing the difficulties ahead of us. Above all, it is wonderful to see the conversion of the Opposition to a realisation of the value of that asset. Indeed, looking back on their criminal neglect of that industry, their deliberate attempts to destroy that industry— which is on record time and time again—surely they must speak with their tongues in their cheeks when they go into a state of alarm because there is a slight temporary recession in the price of cattle.

Comment on this

I hope that is correct

Comment on this

Yes. We all hope it is correct. What a pity we did not do more when the opportunity was there, about the eradication of T.B. and all the things that had to wait for so long to be done. Perhaps we would be in a much stronger position in our foreign markets if we had done all of these things at a much earlier stage. Of course, we were playing with other things during those days.

Deputy Lemass also expressed—I am amazed at this—serious regret that this Government do not attach the same importance to the spending of money on main road improvement as the last Government did. In support of his contention, he provided only one argument. He twitted the Labour Party on the effect that this curtailment would have on employment on the roads. Of course Deputy Lemass ignores the fact that the improvement on main roads was carried out at the expense of the county roads during the years in which the Opposition were last in Government.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a question more appropriate to the Estimate for the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass referred to the fact that he thought there would be considerable unemployment as a result of the reduction in the amount made available for main road grants. I do not intend dealing any further with this matter except to point out, as Deputy MacBride did last night, that the labour content in this work is not very large and that we had imported huge machinery to do this work. That machinery would have been much better employed inside the fences working on the land and helping in our efforts to increase production. When that work had been done, this machinery could perhaps at a later stage have been used to take the bends and corners off our roads and to make fast roads faster. There is unfortunately no indication that the work done on these roads has contributed to greater safety, as we can see from the unfortunate traffic accidents occurring on them so often.

This morning Deputy Lemass in his wailing about the attitude of the Government towards expenditure raised the question of hospitalisation. Everyone is aware of the good work that has been done in the course of the past seven or eight years by the improvement of the hospitals in the country.

Comment on this

Over the past 12 years.

Comment on this

It is not so many years since Dr. Noel Browne expressed strong views on the neglect of the Fianna Fáil Government which, in relation to the hospital programme, allowed a site for a hospital to be used year after year for grazing purposes. Now at last something has been done. That hospital has been erected in Cork and we are proud of it and of the fact that we have no list of T.B. patients waiting for treatment in a hospital or other institution. We are glad to be in a position to say that we have surplus accommodation in relation to the treatment of that disease which had been such a source of trouble to our people for so long.

When people cry about the charges on the investment of that money, they forget the fact that much good work is being done in saving the lives of people and putting them in a position to enable them to go back into employment in a much shorter time than they might otherwise have done if, indeed, they would ever have been able to go back into employment again. We have had great progress in this matter of hospitalisation and in the treatment of T.B.

Comment on this

Does the Parliamentary Secretary say that Fianna Fáil had no hospital programme?

Comment on this

There was no T.B. allowance in 1947.

Comment on this

I am talking about hospitalisation. Will the Parliamentary Secretary stand behind that statement that Fianna Fáil had no hospital programme?

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Flanagan will tell me the amount of the T.B. allowance in 1947.

Comment on this

I want to know whether the Parliamentary Secretary is saying that Fianna Fáil did not pursue a programme of hospitalisation.

Comment on this

I am and I support that by saying that your old friend Dr. Noel Browne criticised the Fianna Fáil Government for that fact.

Comment on this

You are not.

Comment on this

The Deputy and everybody else, including Deputy McGrath, knows that Sarsfield Court in Cork was allowed to be used year after year for grazing purposes when a hospital was badly needed on that site.

Comment on this

Was there a war on at that time?

Comment on this

The fact is we have invested these millions in hospitals, land reclamation and other capital works which were of great benefit to the country and from which great benefit will continue to flow.

The capital investment programme of this Government has steadily gone ahead. An analogy was sought to be drawn by several Deputies between the rates of interest paid during the period of the first inter-Party Government, the rates when Fianna Fáil was back in office and the rates now with the present Minister for Finance in office. Deputy O'Malley and others have referred to that but I think it right to say that the Parties forming this Government when in opposition were more than active in their criticism of the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, at that time in paying an interest rate which was exorbitant. In these circumstances let us, in retrospect, look at the capital programme. The inter-Party Government went to the country, floated loans and clearly indicated what they required the money for. They conserved the Marshall Aid moneys as a fund from which to siphon off any amount that might be required to fill the amount which they set out to get.

During their first term of office they had the unfavourable propaganda machine of the Fianna Fáil Party put into operation all over the City of Dublin in reference to that capital programme and to everything which had been done by the Government at that time. Unfortunately that propaganda had some little effect. There were again the statements made by responsible members of the then Opposition which also did an amount of damage, with the result that when they found themselves in office again by accident, without a mandate from the people and charged with the Government of the country, they had put themselves in the state that they could not go to the people in that first year to find the money that was required for capital purposes.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

They left office again and passed up a golden opportunity to go to the people for the money that was wanted.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for the Parliamentary Secretary to say that a Party was in Government by accident?

Comment on this

They had a bigger mandate than Fine Gael ever had.

Comment on this

That Government had no mandate as was indicated afterwards in Cork City and in other by-elections, with the result that the Taoiseach of that time, realising the position, submitted himself to the people in a general election before his term of office had expired.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has no connection with the Financial Resolutions.

Comment on this

I was merely dealing with the campaign of criticism and propaganda which was launched against the first inter-Party Government, with the statements made by men who had been Ministers and who were again to become Ministers. The schemes which they criticised at that time were so advantageous to the community that when they came into office they dared not interfere with them. It is those same people who are now attempting to damage the credit of the country by talking of the failure of the national loan.

They found the schemes were so advantageous to the community that they dared not interfere with them. They found they had said so much about the credit of the country that they could not face the people in those circumstances by way of a national loan. They were afraid of the result. Consequently, when they at last plucked up enough courage to face the investing public, they had to do it at an exorbitant rate. That was the first of the dear money for many years. That happened at the time when the money market was completely different from what it is now. It was a time when everybody who went for a loan got it. The circumstances were, indeed, very different from the circumstances obtaining to-day.

Comment on this

In what way were they different?

Comment on this

Inasmuch as money was more cheaply obtained in the money market. There was a distinct gap between the prices paid by Deputy MacEntee at that time and the prices paid by others who were floating loans at that particular period.

Comment on this

How is it that all the British Colonies can float loans?

Comment on this

Have they been successful in recent months?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What was the rate?

Comment on this

The rate does not matter. If you can get the money that is the important thing.

Comment on this

If the rate did not matter why did Deputy MacEntee raise it to 5 per cent?

Comment on this

Because he wanted to get the money.

Comment on this

If the rate did not matter when it had gone to 4¼ per cent., why was its impact felt on the local authorities?

Comment on this

The rate is not the question. To get the money at the lowest price we can get it is the most important thing.

Comment on this

So much had been said about the position of the country and its lack of creditworthiness that you had to entice the investing public with an over-attractive rate in order to secure the money.

Comment on this

What rate were you paying on the Marshall Loan?

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee's was not nearly as attractive as the last one.

Comment on this

2½ per cent. was paid on the Marshall Loan.

Comment on this

We were out on our own in 1952 but how much more difficult is it, the people having tasted the high rate, for them to look at anything less? The biggest loss was when Fianna Fáil failed to go for a loan.

Comment on this

We never failed to float any loan.

Comment on this

In 1951 Fianna Fáil failed to go for a loan and circumstances were more advantageous then than at a later period.

Comment on this

Is this a vote of no confidence in the Minister for Finance, that he did not know his business to look for a loan and not get it?

Comment on this

I am dealing with the points made in the course of the debate in regard to the charges that were given in respect of that loan and the rates in regard to the recent one. Every Deputy who spoke to-day tried to infer that it was lack of confidence in the Government that was responsible for the fact that we were unable to get all we wanted.

Comment on this

Of course it was.

Comment on this

It was quite clear that an extraordinary event coincided with the floating of the loan at that time and this Government, the Minister and the people are still bearing, and will continue to bear, the repercussions of Deputy MacEntee's 1952 Budget. There was such an assault made in that Budget on the incomes of the people by the manner in which the food subsidies were slashed that every employer, State and otherwise, had to make up to their employees to protect them against the full impact of that. The Government then in office had some extraordinary ideas about the impact of that Budget on the incomes of the people.

Deputy McGrath referred to the old age pensioners. It was felt by the Fianna Fáil Government that ? completely compensated the old person in that year for the impact of the increased cost of the loaf, the pound of butter, the pound of tea, the pound of sugar and everything else they had to pay for, ignoring the impact of any taxes levied. It was solely a result of the impact on them of the cut in the food subsidies.

Comment on this

What taxes were the social service recipients paid?

Comment on this

Surely Deputy Derrig does not contend that ? was sufficient compensation in those days for that impact? Surely Deputy Derrig is aware that the Government failed to compensate the people for the impact of that sudden increase in the cost of living? We levelled criticism at them then and we continued to do so ever since. We were quite fair in saying that in regard to any impact on the cost of living in those months, arising out of circumstances outside the control of this State, the Government was not responsible. But we charged them with having wrongly estimated the situation then and taken action which, far from correcting the evils that existed, had a detrimental effect. Ultimately, more money had to be spent to compensate people for the impact on them of the cut in the food subsidies than the actual amount saved to the Exchequer in cutting them.

When this Government returned to office, it still had to provide for State servants in order to bring their incomes into accord with the cost of living and in this Budget we find that this action has had the greatest effect on the balance of the Budget. When the Minister made his Budget statement, he made it quite clear that if those obligations were to be met the money would have to be found to meet them. In placing the burdens on cigarettes, petrol and so forth there will be no impact on the charges the housewife will have to meet.

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance told us of the citizens he met and the satisfaction he found in the country in relation to the action of the Minister and the Government. We all discovered likewise. The Cork Workers Council were not the only independent body who felt that the right course was being adopted. Those in receipt of sickness benefit and insured workers are quite conscious of the increase of 25 per cent. which has become available to them under this Budget. They appreciate that and feel it was something due to them.

Every person who is a beneficiary under it—and the number is quite considerable—appreciates very much what is being done in this Budget. It is well that State pensioned servants would get something in this Budget. It may not be much but, indeed, it is something they know they would not have got from a different Government and a different Minister for Finance. It is something that was due to them.

Comment on this

Would Deputy MacEntee have given them anything?

Comment on this

There is an inordinate number of pensioners in the country. We are going through a period when many of the people who were retired on the formation of the new State are still with us. These people were on pensions that were niggardly in relation to the changes in money values. What is being done is appreciated by them. They are individuals in the community who require to be looked after as well as everybody else.

We have a number of retired Garda, retired teachers and people in the community who are educating families and seeking to maintain a standard of life, a standard to which, indeed, they were accustomed when their incomes were greater. It is agreed that the Minister for Finance found it necessary in the circumstances of the day to do what he is doing for them and they, too, are appreciative of that. The fact that he has had to find £2,000,000 per annum to keep the price of butter 5d. lower than it would be if the Opposition Party were in office is something which is appreciated by every member of the community and, as Deputy Moher will agree, it is a good thing that the reaction has been that more Irish butter is being consumed to-day, in consequence of the fact that the reduction in the price has assisted the industry in withstanding the challenge of a cheap substitute.

Some months ago the Minister for Finance, in face of the growing problem which the country had to meet in its balance of payments, came to this House and imposed certain duties. At that time, the Opposition were at sixes-and-sevens in relation to these duties, just as they are at sixes-and-sevens to-day in relation to this Budget. The imposition of the levies was described by some of the Opposition members as being a puny effort, belated, ineffective. The leaders of the Opposition in particular were doubtful of the results which would flow from it, but, despite the prognostications at that time, we have Deputy Carter, of the Fianna Fáil Party, at the other end of the swing of the pendulum stating that much unemployment has arisen as a result of the imposition of these duties. We do not know how Deputy Carter arrived at that conclusion, because the analysis of industrial employment, which is one indication, shows an increase in the number engaged in transportable goods; that would not indicate that Deputy Carter was right in his contention that considerable unemployment has flowed from the impact of these import duties.

Comment on this

What about the distributive trades?

Comment on this

Some provincial papers at the time of the introduction of these duties sent out some of their representatives throughout the country to visit businessmen and consumers—a cross-section of the community—in order to assess the reaction to the imposition of these import duties. We have read, as well as having met these people ourselves and consulted with them, accounts of the results that flowed from these duties. I know that the general impression is that, even though there may be a falling off in the number of new cars purchased, more employment will be available in garages, in the repair of old cars. Consequently, there will be no reduction in employment in that industry.

It is true that the Minister for Finance and the Government did not panic as their predecessors did and did not take any action which would completely disrupt the economy of the country as a whole in this situation; but they took positive action, positive action which they knew would not result in a reduction in the number of employed persons or in a detrimental effect on trade and commerce generally. Even though it is still too early to get a true estimate, we nevertheless see to-day the pleasing result which has ensued. In the recently published figures, there is an indication of an improvement in consequence of their introduction and in relation to the effect they have had on the people as a whole.

Deputy Carter was probably the most emphatic of all the critics of this Budget. He insisted there was extravagance, gross, criminal extravagance, on the part of the Government and the Ministers in the administration of their different Departments. Deputy Carter has been honoured by his own Party to the extent of being appointed Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee and he will there have an excellent forum to pin-point all these items of extravagance.

Comment on this

Do not make it too hard for him.

Comment on this

Deputy Carter's realisation of the incidence of all these extravagances will no doubt, when the Public Accounts Committee reports back to the House, assume quite large proportions and Deputy Carter's observations on the waste and extravagance in every Department of State will, I am sure, reach catalogue size.

Comment on this

No fear of that.

Comment on this

It will all be wrapped up.

Comment on this

It is a strange thing that, in making these blanket charges at Ministries, in the Estimates we have so far discussed there has been no evidence of discovery by any Deputy here of any gross waste or extravagance. It is surprising, considering the time which has been taken up in the discussion of these Estimates, that that has not been brought to light. It is also true, despite the information Deputy Lemass may have as to the inability of some Ministers here, that quite worthy tributes have been paid to them, even by members of the Opposition, when these Estimates were under discussion. In fact, on one occasion, a tribute was paid by a former Minister to his successor, because of the achievements he had found it possible to attain since his accession to the particular Ministry.

We find, therefore, that the criticisms offered of the Budget are completely at variance with the criticisms offered on individual Estimates. In the Estimates still to be discussed, we will look forward to hearing from Deputies who are critical of the Administration at the moment details of this extravagance and waste and the ways in which they would curtail it. It would be helpful if they indicated to the particular Minister or Parliamentary Secretary the schemes which they think should be discontinued. That will help the Government and the Minister considerably in their present aim of reducing the cost of administration.

The Minister has found it necessary to find this additional £1,000,000 to meet the impact of increased payments to State servants. There is, too, the £1,250,000 which must be found for health this year. Surely Deputies on both sides will not contend that that expenditure could be described as extravagant or wasteful. The Minister has reimposed the tax removed by the Fianna Fáil Government on dance halls. That tax was removed at a time when we were told the country was facing very extreme difficulties and it was removed at a time when no other concession was made by way of taxation reliefs. The action of the Minister in reimposing this tax has been acclaimed by the country at large. Even Dr. Browne, who was a member of this House at the time, voiced his disapproval of the removal of the tax and his failure to understand why it should be removed. When the Attorney-General, Deputy McGilligan, was Minister for Finance, he introduced certain changes in the application of this tax on dances and gave a certain relief from it to certain small communities. That was a good thing because it assisted such places in securing patrons, patrons they would not have got had they to bear the same incidence of taxation as the larger centres of population.

Comment on this