Committee on Finance. - Vote 47—Lands.
Contributions 1–144 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That a sum not exceeding £1,173,950 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1957, for the salaries and expenses of the Offices of the Minister for Lands and of the Irish Land Commission (44 & 45 Vict., c. 49, sec. 46, and c. 71, sec. 4; 48 & 49 Vict., c. 73; secs. 17, 18 and 20; 54 & 55 Vict., c. 48; 3 Edw. 7, c. 37, 7 Edw. 7 c. 38 and c. 56; 9 Edw. 7, c. 42; Nos. 27 and 42 of 1923; No. 25 of 1925; No. 11 of 1926; No. 19 of 1927; No. 31 of 1929; No. 11 of 1931; Nos. 33 and 38 of 1933; No. 11 of 1934; No. 41 of 1936; No. 26 of 1939; No. 12 of 1946; No. 25 of 1949; No. 16 of 1950; No. 18 of 1953; and No. 21 of 1954).
The gross Estimate of £2,211,381 for Lands for the current year shows an increase of £74,006 over the gross total for last year—including the sum transferred to the Lands Vote from the Vote for Increases in Remuneration.
For sub-head A, salaries, wages and allowances, an increase of £29,808 is shown. Of this amount, over £29,000 represents the pay increase awarded last year to the Civil Service generally. The balance is accounted for by normal incremental increases. Since last Estimate the indoor staff has been reduced by 18.
The increase of £2,000 in sub-head B arises largely from a change in procedure before the Appeal Tribunal. As a result of court decisions it is now necessary for the Land Commission inspectors to give evidence before the Appeal Tribunal on questions of value and to undergo cross-examination by owner's counsel. This, of course, involves increased travelling for the inspectorate.
Over 37 per cent. of the entire Estimate is allocated to sub-heads H (1), H (2) and H (3) for making good deficiencies in the Land Bond Fund arising from the statutory halving of annuities—which alone accounts for £695,000—and other aids to land purchase. As the land settlement programme proceeds, new annuities are set up which call for additional provision under sub-head H (1), for costs fund, and H (3), for halving of annuities. This year it is expected that the halving of annuities will result in an increase of £13,000 under sub-head H (3) which, together with an estimated increase of £500 under sub-head H (1), gives a total increase of £13,500 under this group of sub-heads.
Almost 30 per cent. of the entire Estimate is allocated to the improvement of estates, including the erection and repair of buildings, the construction of roads, fences, drains and other works. This sub-head, more than any other, reflects the extent of the land settlement activities, as concentration on the relief of congestion involves heavy expenditure on improvement works, particularly buildings. This sub-head provides a substantial amount of employment particularly in the congested districts. Expenditure under sub-head I last year was £625,424, the highest for many years. For this year, additional provision has to be made for recent wage increases and the upward trend in cost of materials. The likelihood of some increase in expenditure through improved design for Land Commission houses also arises. In the course of last year's debate on this Estimate. I said that improved plans for dwelling-houses would be introduced. As an experiment, some houses have already been constructed to new plans near Trim, Navan and Oldcastle, County Meath, and others will be erected soon in Westmeath and elsewhere. Expert architectural advice has been sought and I have every confidence that the housing designs which will ultimately be adopted will be a distinct improvement on the past.
Certain deficiencies in funds such as the Local Loans Fund and Land Bond Fund are made good out of sub-head Q. These deficiencies arise when the Land Commission, having taken over land which is subject to a statutory payment, direct that the payment shall cease. The payments thus terminated are subsequently replaced by new annuities on the lands. The charge to sub-head Q is recurring and cumulative and an increased provision of £1,100 is required for this year.
As regards sub-head R, which deals with the purchase of land in the open market, I am this year proposing an increase of 50 per cent. in the amount of this sub-head. When I introduced the principle of open-market purchases into the Land Act, 1950, I envisaged the section as a means of augmenting the Land Commission's main programme for the laying-out of holdings by making available in significant numbers, holdings complete with all essential buildings and ready for occupation. It is, of course, a matter of importance that the Land Commission's use of this power should not monopolise this market to the exclusion of suitable private purchasers of land, or tend to inflate prices. A certain amount of caution is therefore essential.
It may also be mentioned that the number of holdings coming on the market, which would be suitable for the Land Commission's purpose, is limited. Generally speaking, the holding must be the right size, suitably located, comprise fair to good land, and be equipped with dwelling-house and outoffices in good repair; title must be reasonably clear and the price not prohibitive. Altogether 43 holdings containing 1,700 acres have been purchased under the section. With the knowledge and experience being gained in its operation, better results may be expected in the future. No effort will be spared this year to secure the maximum results and, accordingly, provision is made for an increase of £10,000 in this sub-head.
The amounts being provided under the other sub-heads of the Vote vary, if at all, to a small extent from last year's figures and do not call for any special comment.
As regards the general work of the Land Commission, it is gratifying to note that the drive for the completion of tenanted land purchase continues to show good results even though the rate of progress is inevitably slowing down as the residue of extremely difficult cases has been reached. Of 110,000 tenanted holdings, which vested in the Land Commission since 1923, there are now only 14,000 holdings left for vesting in the tenants. Vesting of all the tenanted holdings has been completed in County Carlow. In each of the ten counties of Cavan, Kildare, Kilkenny, Laois, Limerick, Longford, Louth, Meath, Monaghan and Wexford, the number of tenanted holdings still awaiting attention is less than 50. The total number of outstanding cases for these 11 counties is 168. For all practical purposes, therefore, the revesting of tenanted land has been virtually completed in the 11 counties I have named.
Some 12,800 of the 14,000 unvested tenanted holdings, to which I have referred, are situated in the western counties and, together with about 6,000 unvested holdings on the estates of the former Congested Districts Board, constitute the really hard core of congestion which still remains to be dealt with. About 9,000 of these holdings are in rundale or intermixed plots and require extensive rearrangement as well as enlargement and other improvements before vesting may take place. Scattered plots—sometimes upwards of 40 in a single holding— require to be consolidated into workable units; new dwelling-houses and outoffices have, in most cases, to be built and means of access and drainage are invariably unsatisfactory.
It is essential that additional land be obtained before a satisfactory and acceptable scheme of rearrangement for any group of intermixed holdings can be formulated. Scarcely any land is now left for acquisition or resumption in the immediate neighbourhood of the remaining acutely congested estates, however, and the migration of families from these districts is the only way in which land can be made available there to facilitate the rearrangement of the intermixed holdings, the abolition of rundale, and the improvement of conditions generally. Last year, it was found possible to migrate 102 families from congested areas to new holdings elsewhere.
Largely as a result of these migrations, the rearrangement, enlargement and improvement of close on 700 holdings in the congested areas was effected last year. This compares with a total of 607 holdings rearranged during 1954-55 and the increased output is most welcome and is the result of unremitting effort throughout the entire year on the part of the officials engaged on this highly skilled branch of the work. In the past few years over 2,500 families living on such intermixed holdings and comprising altogether up to 20,000 human beings have benefited greatly by these rearrangement schemes. For the information of those Deputies who are unfamiliar with the type of holding about which I speak, perhaps I may point out that in this branch of Land Commission work there arises a variety of problems, which at times appear almost insurmountable and, under the most favourable circumstances, occasion delays. Migration is inseparable from rearrangement but the natural reluctance of a family to leave the homestead, where they were born and bred, frequently constitutes a major problem in the initial stages of preparing a rearrangement scheme. Sometimes when everything is settled a prospective key-migrant will change his mind at the last moment and everything is back in the melting pot once more, after all the trouble and arrangements. Very often acquisition proceedings for the lands, which are to provide the new holdings for the migrants, are vigorously contested and as a result the proceedings are long drawn out. In contrast, the successful rearrangement schemes must be based on the consent and co-operation of the participating tenants. Prolonged negotiations by the inspectorate are essential to secure the necessary goodwill of the landholders. Very often, the more acute the congestion, and the intermixed condition of the old holdings, the more difficult it is to secure general agreement for a satisfactory scheme.
Resourcefulness of a high order, patience and tact are thus necessary to resolve the issues which come to the forefront once a rearrangement scheme is attempted. The delays which occur are attributable mainly to the difficulty of securing consent and co-operation when many landholders are involved. In the general exchange and reshuffle of disconnected plots to form composite holdings, there is rarely sufficient land available to satisfy the aspirations of all.
Having regard, therefore, to all the factors connected with this difficult work, I am most gratified with the results which have been obtained in the past year, which are the best yet achieved, and I will endeavour in the future to intensify to the utmost the sustained drive which is in progress and which has for its objective the eradication of all these remaining rural slums wherever they exist.
There is another feature of this work which I think is worth mentioning. Some Deputies, no doubt, are aware that the problem of fragmented holdings is not peculiar to this country but is also engaging attention in many countries of Europe. It has been a source of satisfaction to learn that in this particular business we are as efficient as any other country and better than many. To illustrate the general excellence of these rearrangement schemes which the Land Commission are operating and in order to demonstrate that our schemes can stand comparison with the best of rearrangement schemes completed abroad, I have placed in the main hall of the House two maps showing sections of rearrangement schemes—one carried out in this country and one abroad. The maps, in each case, show three badly intermixed holdings before and after they were rearranged. Before rearrangement, the three Irish holdings contained 93 intermixed plots which in the final result were plotted into as few as four compact divisions. Furthermore, the provision of new dwelling-houses and outoffices was necessary in the case of all the Irish holdings in this scheme but did not arise in the foreign scheme.
Whilst migration and rearrangement may—by reason of the publicity given to these activities—appear to the House to be the predominant feature of the land settlement programme, I would point out that such operations carried out last year absorbed less than half of the total area allotted, so that a fair balance is being maintained in this contentious work. In all, about 35,000 acres were allotted to some 1,900 allottees. Over 30,000 acres were acquired, resumed or taken over in exchange and over 7,700 holdings, parcels and rights of turbary were vested in tenants or allottees.
Before passing from this brief review of the Land Commission activities for last year I should like to pay a tribute to the staff—both outdoor and indoor. I can assure the House that they apply themselves wholeheartedly and efficiently to their work which for contention and difficulty is well above average. The acquisition and allotment of land are by no means the only functions of the Land Commission; each year, the collection of £2,500,000 from 500,000 payers is effected; upwards of 7,700 separate properties are vested, some 2,000 applications for consent to sub-divide holdings are examined and decided, almost £650,000 is spent on improvement works and, on top of all this, hundreds of letters have to be dealt with each day on a wide and most varied range of land business throughout the State. In the complexity and variety of its functions I think that the Land Commission is unique among State Departments.
In conclusion, I am pleased to be able to report that the collection of annuities is proceeding most satisfactorily. The amount outstanding at the 31st March, 1956, was £139,493 which is over £3,000 less than at the same time last year and represents only 0.26 per cent. of the total amount collectable since 1953.
Comment on this
To put the Vote which the Dáil is now discussing in its proper perspective, it is necessary, I think, for Deputies to have some familiarity with the work of the Land Commission, and it would be very helpful to them if they were familiar with the facts set out in the report of the Irish Land Commission—the last one available, dealing with the year ended 31st March, 1954. On that date, according to a table on page 18, the total acreage of land acquired, resumed or taken over by the Land Commission for allotments up to 31st March, 1954, or which was the subject of proceedings for acquisition on that date under the Land Acts, 1923 to 1953, was 1,218,368. With regard to expenditure on estate improvements, a similar table on page 23 shows that the total expenditure for the period 1923 to 1954 came to £10,608,686.
As Deputies are aware, the Land Commission is primarily taken up with the problems of the congested areas, or, if we wish to describe them so, the Gaeltacht counties. In this report, there is a section dealing with the Gaeltacht which, for the purposes of the Land Commission, is taken as comprising the five counties, Galway, Mayo, Donegal, Clare and Kerry. Since 1923, the Land Commission state that they have divided 553,875 acres of untenanted land in these Gaeltacht counties and have expended £4,039,284 on estate improvement works, apart from employment schemes. It gives particulars of the numbers of tenants who have been migrated and the number of families under the colony and group migration schemes which have been in operation for a good many years. The total number of families migrated to date seems to be 619.
With regard to the details of the Vote, there is not much to be said about the sub-heads. The Minister has pointed out that the increase of approximately £30,000 under sub-head A is due to pay increases awarded last year to the Civil Service generally or is accounted for by the normal incremental increases. He mentions that the indoor staff has been reduced by 18; however, there are still 1,073 on the establishment.
As regards the halving of the annuities, since 1948-49 the amount provided by the State for the statutory halving of the annuities under the 1933 Act has risen from £639,000 to £695,000—an increase of £56,000. This year, the Minister expects that the halving of the annuities will result in an increase of £13,000. Naturally, one wonders whether the halving of the annuities in the case of new allottees, or allottees who are receiving land under present proceedings, is justified, and whether, strictly speaking, they are entitled to this subsidy, in addition to whatever else they may be getting in the way of concession or advantage. However, I understand the position is that the Land Commissioners assert that, under the law as it stands, the concession of halving the annuities has to be given to the allottee who is receiving land under the Land Commission schemes at the present time. It raises the question, of course, as to the total liability which may be placed upon the State in respect of this work and whether there is any way in which it can be reduced.
The total price paid for land under all proceedings of the Land Purchase Acts up to 31st March, 1954, came to £130,000,000. I am trying to get the figure from 1923, but I do not seem to be able to lay my hands upon it. However, in connection with the liability of the State, the question of the loss on resale, which occurs for example in the case of a migrant, has to be taken into consideration; and, with the improvement in economic conditions and agricultural prospects and the advantages that migrants have and the assistance that has been given to them, it is easy to see that a case could be made to urge that the losses on the resale of holdings to migrants or others should be reduced to the minimum possible.
The Minister has not made any reference to this, but I think it is only right and proper to do so, when we are dealing with a Vote in respect of which there are so many sub-heads about which we can do very little. We simply must accept them so long as we accept the position that the Land Commission must continue, that such functions as it performs in connection with the collection of annuities, for example, must be carried out together with the halving of the annuities and the work it carries out in the congested or Gaeltacht districts which might be regarded as social to the extent that it is carrying on the work of the old Congested Districts Board and is endeavouring to improve the circumstances of the congests in the western counties, to give them better housing accommodation, to give them as far as possible some extra land or to rearrange, improve and make more economic the patches they have, and also to give them roads and to provide them with a certain amount of employment while these improvements are going on in their areas. This is all very advantageous, but, as the total amount of money in question is large, it is only right and proper that attention should be directed to a particular item where one feels that perhaps losses are greater than might reasonably be considered necessary or where one feels that perhaps the best service or the best return is not being given for the money expended.
I take it to be the function of the Opposition in a parliamentary democracy to suggest economies and to press upon the Government the need for economy in public expenditure at every turn. It is really begging the question and it is a very old story to ask: what items or what services do you suggest should be discontinued or abolished? The real aim should be, if we are agreed that certain services must be provided, to see that these services are operated in the most economical and efficient way possible, to take precisely the same trouble and interest in the expenditure of public moneys as we would if it were our own personal expenditure and try to see that the utmost value and the greatest possible return is got for it.
The expenditure last year in respect of improvements came to £625,000. For this year, the Minister says additional provision has to be made for recent wage increases and the upward trend in the cost of material. When Ministers are making references of this kind to additional provision that has to be made for either wage increases or cost of material, they might tell us specifically whether the whole of the increase is due to these reasons or what proportion may be due to wage increases. If the whole or even the greater part of the increase is due to wage increases, I presume it means that not even the same amount of work, but perhaps a lesser amount, in the way of completed buildings or improvements in other directions, is likely to be carried out in the congested areas.
The item under sub-head Q seems to be an accounting item and there is nothing we can do about that. As regards the purchase of land in the open market, the Minister has not told us the number of holdings which have been purchased during the past year. He has given the total number of 43 holdings containing 1,700 acres. I have not the figures—I do not know whether they are available—as to what the 43 holdings of 1,700 acres cost, what their valuation may have been, but, in any case, I do not think there need be any fear that the Minister's determination to do somewhat more under this sub-head will create any great excitement in the market for land sale and purchase. The Minister tells us that he is anxious that the Land Commission should not monopolise the market. I do not think there is very much fear of that. It may be that, in a particular instance, there might be fault found with the Land Commission for bidding for a holding which a local man wanted and felt he could make good use of, but I take it the Land Commission are interested only in land which is definitely needed for their purposes and which they must have, if they are to improve the conditions of the congests in the area.
The Minister has stated that there are now 11 counties—last year there were ten—in which the vesting of the tenanted holdings has practically been completed, the number of tenanted holdings still awaiting attention being fewer than 50. In fact, he says that the total number of outstanding cases for the 11 counties is 168, so that for all practical purposes revesting work is finished in these 11 counties. It might seem, therefore, as if even a larger reduction in staff than the 18 to which the Minister has referred might be made, and perhaps the saving in respect of the 18 is not altogether attributable to the work of revesting.
The real question is whether, with the expenditure and the work that is being done by the outdoor staff, of whose interest, industry and competence I have no doubt, we are really ameliorating the conditions in the West of Ireland to any great extent. Unfortunately, one has to weary the House with figures in this regard, but I think it is inevitable. According to the figures given here under the heading "Western Congestion", there are 19,800 holdings which the Minister describes as the "really hard core of congestion" which still remain to be dealt with. About 9,000 of these holdings are in rundale or intermixed plots and require extensive rearrangement, as well as enlargement and other improvements, before vesting may take place.
This year, the Minister is able to report that 700 holdings were rearranged. Last year, 607 were rearranged, so that we have 1,300 holdings rearranged in the past two years. I do not know whether it will be possible to maintain the present rate of progress, but it would seem that, even at that, it will take another six years to deal with holdings that are in a very bad way from the point of view of rearrangement, not to speak of the holdings that are left. If you take away the 9,000 holdings where rearrangement is necessary, you have still 10,000 or 11,000 holdings left over. The Minister says it is essential that additional land be obtained before a satisfactory or acceptable scheme of rearrangement for any group of intermixed holdings can be formulated, but, in the very next sentence, he tells us that scarcely any land is now left for acquisition or resumption in the immediate neighbourhood of the remaining acutely congested areas.
He states, however, that the migration of families from these districts is the only way in which land can be made available to them. That means leaving on one side the question of the 9,000 holdings which may require rearrangement and in respect of which rearrangement can be carried out during the next six or seven years. The migration of 102 families is a very good result and must not be belittled in any way, because it shows a tremendous amount of work has been done. Nevertheless, it is rather disappointing, if one looks at the figures for the many thousands of congested district holdings that still remain to be dealt with.
As I said last year, one might ask oneself the question whether even after another period of years it will be possible to do more than attend to a fraction of these holdings? I remember the Minister claimed last year that the effect of the work of the Land Commission, when the holdings were rearranged, was to make them reasonably economic, but I think, having regard to the changes that have taken place in agriculture and the general changes in the scheme of things in this country, that the congests will scarcely feel that these holdings, whatever the Minister may think and no matter what industry they may display there, are scarcely likely to provide them with a reasonable livelihood for themselves and their families.
The Minister tells us also that there is difficulty in getting migrants, sometimes, to accept the recommendations of the commission and fall in with the rearrangement plans. He has not told us definitely whether this is changing and whether it is a problem we are likely to see the end of, or whether it is a continuing one and whether these key migrants or key-men in the rearrangement schemes have the feeling that, through going to this political person or that, changing their allegiance, perhaps, as the circumstances may demand, they will get something it was not intended they should get. As a Land Commission inspector said to me on one occasion: "Time was when tenants did what the Land Commission inspectors advised, almost universally and invariably. Then we got an Irish Government and they felt they could do better by going to the T.D.s. Now," he said—and he retired from the service a good many years ago—"they have come back again to the inspectors." I hope the position now is not that they have again reversed their engines and are going back to the T.D.s in an effort to get the Land Commission to do something which is impossible as there is not, as has been explained by the Minister, a pool of land available.
The Minister goes on to tell us in the very next paragraph that "there is rarely sufficient land available to satisfy the aspirations of all". With regard to the figures that have been given on the last page of the Minister's statement, in which he says that 35,000 acres were allotted to some 1,900 allottees and that over 30,000 acres were acquired, resumed or taken over in exchange and over 7,700 holdings vested, it would be useful I think, in connection with the figures for acquisition and allotment, if Deputies in future could be told what the value of the lands was, that is, the valuation and, if possible, the price.
I asked the Minister last year to let us know what is the amount of land in the machine at the present time. He has not attempted to give any estimate of the pool of land which he thinks may be available for acquisition and all we can do is to ask him to be good enough to give us the figures for land which is, as the saying goes, "in the machine", and also, perhaps, if he would be kind enough to give us some information as to the acreage of land at present under consideration, that is, the total acreage of the different schemes which either have been lodged by the inspectors or are expected to be lodged.
The Minister told us last year, or the year before, that he expected that the intake of land would be maintained fairly steadily. I do not know whether he still adheres to that view, but I think that conditions generally are making the operations of the Land Commission more difficult and, were it not for the fact that it is of the greatest importance that the work in the congested areas should be continued and everything possible done to improve the situation of the people there, one might wonder whether the Land Commission could possibly continue its work satisfactorily.
I stated on the Vote for the Minister for Agriculture that, in my opinion, the trend of events, in spite of the boom that we have had in agriculture for some years past and which is now, perhaps, giving rise to another situation, has not benefited the small farmer to the same extent as the larger man. He has not the resources and he has not the means to take advantage of the opportunities as regards the provision of credit and the utilisation of machinery and so on. He is obviously in a very weak position. That is why I believe that, in addition to the work of the Land Commission, more should be done to create industries. I urge that if possible, while paying due regard to the social importance of the commission's work in the West of Ireland, more regard ought to be paid to the necessity for improving productive resources, or, as the economists put it, "productivity", either by reducing costs or increasing the output from the land which the Land Commission is dealing with or by getting both of these results together, if possible.
I suggest to the Minister that, perhaps, after getting a certain amount of experience in the Land Commission, the younger inspectors could be called together and asked for their opinions, asked to say frankly what they thought might be done to improve matters in the work that they have to perform, and invited to give whatever suggestions they may have to offer as to how better results could be obtained.
It would be a confession of failure to regard the money that the Land Commission is spending in the congested areas simply as being in the nature of a dole or in order to provide relief work or as something that simply has gone on and we do not quite know why it is being continued. The rearrangements and the housing schemes which the Land Commission have been carrying out, which in many cases show such excellent results, should be followed up.
In the Report for 1954, there is an appendix dealing with the question of migration and with the rearrangement of a townland in County Mayo. It reveals the great amount of work that is being done about which we hear very little. One might legitimately inquire under this heading, as under other headings in connection with the improvement of rural areas, whether or not more could be done to follow up the expenditure involved, in association with the Department of Agriculture, which, it might be claimed, has the primary responsibility, in order to help out the smallholders and to encourage them, by advice and propaganda. If the State can do more by the provision of credit and by getting the people to take advantage of the other available schemes, once the Land Commission has started them on the road, we will feel that we have provided our people in the West of Ireland not only with a place in which to reside but with a place in which they can attempt to make a livelihood with more success than has been possible in the past.
In that connection I should like to ask what is the position generally as regards turbary. Are there many schemes in operation of the type that we had during the war where the Land Commission gave the use of bogs to persons in need of fuel? Are there any of these still in operation or have they all been terminated? What is the position as regards turbary in the western areas? Is the Minister satisfied that everything possible is being done to provide turbary where bogs are available for Land Commission tenants?
The provision of turbary is one of the great works that the Land Commission has been able to achieve. It has been of inestimable benefit to the people. If their turf supply is not as near to them as one might wish, nevertheless, the fact that they have turbary is a tremendous security to them. When other people have to face increased coal prices and the difficulty of getting coal, they can feel safe and secure as far as turbary is concerned. They may thank the Land Commission in a very great degree for that happy occasion.
Last year the Minister told us, in reply to a Deputy who was rather doubtful about the work of the Land Commission, that good Deputies have lost their seats by endeavouring to speed up the Land Commission machine. I do not think I have heard of any but I need not prolong my speech by going into that matter. There are many Deputies from western constituencies who, no doubt, will again voice their opinions but it would be well if we had a general examination and review of the work of the Land Commission.
While due note must be taken of complaints and grievances in constituencies, we ought to try to see the work of the Land Commission as a whole and ask ourselves whether or not it could be improved, whether or not better results could be secured, and whether or not there is any more that it could do to encourage people to stay at home in their own country. The emigration figures are very alarming and they are only a continuation, an accentuation, of previous figures and in some degree the figures have become even worse.
I remember that before the war about one-third of the 15 to 19 age group emigrated within a decade. I am sure that that fraction has increased very greatly. I am sure that about one-half, if not more than one-half of the young people must be leaving many of these congested areas, particularly counties like Mayo. We are in duty bound to do everything we possibly can to make conditions more suitable for them and to enable them to get a living in their own country. Therefore, as far as possible, Deputies should offer constructive suggestions. If they display impatience with the speed of the Land Commission or dissatisfaction with its work, I do not think the Minister should just say that they want to "crab" the work or that they are not as interested in it as he or anybody else may be.
I feel that there is not proper integration of the work of the Land Commission and that of the Department of Agriculture at the present time. I have no desire to travel further afield in that connection now. I simply want to impress upon the Minister that I realise the social benefits which flow from the work of the Land Commission in improving in some degree the position of the congests. It would be of the greatest advantage and would make that improvement very fruitful if it were followed systematically by agricultural schemes, in which the inspectors of the Land Commission would help the tenants to take advantage of the present favourable situation. We do not know how long the promising situation may last; I hope it will continue indefinitely, but we ought to do more, if possible, and not confine ourselves strictly to the technical work of rearrangement and migration. We ought to try to do more through the outdoor staff to help the people in other ways and particularly to get the largest return they can from their holdings.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that in the past year 102 migrants were brought from the West to places in the Midlands. He did not state exactly from what counties these migrants were brought and, according to the information at my disposal, I do not think any one of them came from the congested areas of South Kerry. In fact, none of those people in my constitutency who applied for an exchange of holding was transferred during the past three years, so far as I am aware. We have continually been receiving representations from such people to try to expedite the transfers.
Where transfers or exchanges were made, the lands thus vacated have been let for a number of years to local farmers. It may be all right to do that for a year or so, but when they have been let for quite a long time, not only the land itself but also the houses, and very good houses in many cases, are bound to deteriorate. Therefore I ask the Minister to examine such cases in the congested areas of South Kerry and to expedite the subdivision of the holdings which have been vacated.
I think that sometimes the subdivisions, in the case of holdings of that kind, are too small. I can quite understand that the inspectors try to satisfy the local people who have applied for a portion of the lands, but it is really bringing about a situation such as that which the Land Commission have been trying to improve for many years, namely, rundale or intermixed holdings. In my view, when such lands are being subdivided, it would be much better if some two or three of the local smallholders got a sufficient acreage to make their holdings economic.
I ask the Minister to look into the matter of supplying turbary to holders of land in the different areas. For instance, we have extensive areas of bog in South Kerry. The Land Commission have repeatedly been requested to take over some of those acres of bog for the purpose of giving a plot to each landholder, but they have been very slow in doing so. I must say that, on the whole, the Land Commission officials, both at the head office here in Dublin and the outdoor staff with whom we have to deal, have always been courteous, efficient and helpful and, so far as I know, they have tried to be perfectly fair in subdivision recommendations, and so forth.
When representations are made by Deputies or even by other people who may go into the Land Commission, a formal type of reply is sent out. Its terms are neither suitable nor very explanatory. If the Minister examines that little document that is sent out, I think he will agree that it certainly requires some improvement, so that it will indicate to Deputies and others who communicate with the Land Commission the object in relation to which they contacted that Department.
Comment on this
I notice that, so far, in the Estimates which have been discussed in this House, where the Estimate was considered to be of importance some leading Deputy on the Opposition Benches thought fit to move that it be referred back for the purpose of discussion. It is rather significant that the Estimate for the Department of Lands has received no such treatment. In my opinion, that would give the impression that there is as little real interest on the Opposition side of the House as there is on the Government side with regard to the major problem, namely, the solving of congestion. I think a neutral person would be entitled to suggest that the Opposition were more or less satisfied with the progress made by a Minister who was elected by his constituents from a congested area solely to solve the problem of congestion. I feel that, above all Estimates, there should have been moved a motion by the Opposition to refer back this Estimate.
Deputy Derrig pleaded with the Minister and said he should not be hard on those who criticised the Minister and his Department for, perhaps, slowness and lack of effort in solving major problems in connection with congestion, and so forth. He pleaded also that Deputies should offer constructive criticism and suggestions. That is a very reasonable approach, but we must take one factor into consideration: If you have an old ruin and you want to build a new structure, you must destroy the old ruin first. You must have destruction before you have constructive efforts afterwards.
If we are to have any real solution in our lifetime of the land problem, we must destroy this edifice that was built up over the years, this monument to inefficiency and sloth that can be described as the Department of Lands.
On a number of occasions here, I extracted information from this Minister and other Ministers with regard to the alleged work done by the Department of Lands in relation to the acquisition and distribution of lands throughout the country. I find one significant fact emerging from a welter of figures. If we take the period from 1930 to 1950, of the new holdings created by the Land Commission—holdings, mark you, that are supposed to be and that are described by the Land Commission as economic and on which a man can live and rear a family in reasonable economic circumstances—the average size is 21 statute acres.
It is significant that, in spite of repeated attempts, I could not extract from the Minister, or from his Department, what the average valuation of these holdings was. It is an admitted fact that to talk in terms of acres alone is not sufficient. You must have the valuation in order to have a true picture of what a particular holding means economically to a particular owner. I think it was Deputy Derrig who, in the course of his remarks, pleaded with the Minister that he should make available figures with regard to the valuation of land that has been distributed, but the most I could extract was that the average holding of land divided over the years was 21 statute acres. I do not know what the average valuation for such a holding is, but I do suggest that, taking it on an allocated basis, 21 statute acres are not a sufficient holding for a man to live on, unless it is situated in close proximity to a town where the holder is in a position to engage in market gardening and so forth.
I think it is not unreasonable to suggest that, while this State body has been charged with the solution of congestion, they have helped, in no small way, to recreate congestion themselves by the system they have adopted and the size of the holdings they have issued to congests and to uneconomic holders. I do not hold myself out as an expert on what the size of a holding should be in any land redistribution scheme. That is a matter that can be thrashed out and a decision arrived at according to the locality, the circumstances and the type of land involved.
I am going to speak a short time on this Estimate, because I find it is a waste of time repeating what I have had to say here year after year. I am convinced that if anything is to be done in connection with this major problem, it is not inside this House it will be done. We find that the main charge on the Department of Lands is the setting up of as many economic holdings as possible, thereby solving congestion. I should imagine that any State body charged with the solution of congestion would, first of all, try to establish how much land should be taken into a pool for that purpose over a number of years. We must take into consideration that the problem of solving congestion was not meant to be a permanent job for the Land Commission. It was intended, I hope, that a plan would be prepared and that a solution, if such was to be found, would be found in a period of five, ten or 15 years.
In the planning of that solution, the Land Commission would be charged with ensuring that sufficient land came into the pool to enable the commission to create, each year, a specific number of new holdings. Now we find that the cry, each year, is that the pool of land is drying up and that land for the relief of congestion is no longer available. That shows the red light to thousands of uneconomic holders up and down the State and it amounts to saying to them: "There is little hope for you; only one out of 100 of you can hope to be fixed up". If that picture were true, I am sure that these people living in uneconomic holdings in the congested areas would appreciate the fact. However, they know perfectly well that sufficient land is available, and they are not prepared to accept the statement issued by this Minister, or by his predecessor, that the pool of land is drying up.
People in rural areas have only to look around in their own parishes and they can make up their minds as to the circumstances that exist in their own localities. If they find that land is available for the solving of congestion within five or seven miles of the congested districts and if, at the same time, they hear a Minister saying that the pool is drying up, they will lose faith in such a Minister.
I want to give a specific instance to the Minister. In the last week, I drew his attention to a situation in my own constituency. A holding of land was bought on the public market. That holding of land was purchased by a farmer who has 300 acres of land within four miles of this holding. I have nothing to say against the man. He is a decent, respectable man and a good farmer, but apparently he has been seized with the land hunger. Although he has 300 acres of his own, he feels that he is entitled to expand more and more. He has purchased this holding within four miles of his home and I know perfectly well that, within the next 12 months, he is going to purchase another holding alongside that.
Have we any idea of what ceiling must be imposed on the amount of land to be held by any individual while congestion exists in the State? If we allow a man with 300 acres, no matter who he is, to purchase land ad lib. are we not taking away land from the pool that should be available for the relief of congestion? This Minister for Lands will come back and tell me that he stands four-square behind Michael Davitt, that he believes in fair rent, fixity of tenure and free sale. I do not know what Michael Davitt would say were he alive to see the way things are being misrepresented here in the House. I do not think Davitt ever envisaged the day when his aims would be twisted and his ideals turned and shaped to suit the political views, the political expediency, shown by men in responsible positions at the moment.
I do not think Michael Davitt's idea was that small farmers in congested areas in Mayo, Roscommon, Galway and elsewhere should have their holdings purchased by Irish landlords, replacing the landlords driven out through the activities of Michael Davitt. If we are to allow a man to purchase land ad lib. we might as well forget all about solving congestion. This will become a very serious problem in the next few years; it will be a very thorny problem for some Government. If a man can have 300 acres in one parish, if he is allowed to buy 50 acres in the parish beside it and then to buy 50 acres in the next townland and so forth, is it not as simple a proposition to let him buy the whole county and have the rest of the people as tenants?
Comment on this
I do not know what he is doing here, then. I see that happening at the moment and the Minister knows very well it is happening. If he takes up the Mayo papers or any of the western papers such as the Connacht Tribune, he will see reported there the decisions of the land courts. They hear appeals against the Land Commission's acquisition activities. In nine out of ten cases, the people who appeal win their cases; the Land Commission are beaten. Very often, the case is made to the land courts that there is no congestion in the immediate locality. In other words, a man who is not working a farm of 80 or 90 acres and who puts up a plea that he will work it next year or the following year will be successful if he also pleads that there are no congests around the place.
There may not be congestion in the immediate vicinity of the farm, but there may be congestion within ten miles of it. We have lost the real outlook regarding the relief of congestion if we pass over cases on the principle that the congestion to be solved must be in the immediate vicinity of the farms available for acquisition. The question of congestion is one that exists all over the West and, just because regulations are made by the Department of Lands that, where a farm becomes available, priority must be given to people living within one mile of the farm, the excuse is given to the land courts that there is no congestion in the locality. I think the land courts are not doing their duty, apart altogether from what the Land Commission are doing.
We hear a lot of talk about the congested areas and of pleas made to the Minister to keep on with the good work. The Minister need not bother keeping on with the good work, because, if things are left as they are, the problem will solve itself through the trainloads of people leaving Claremorris, Ballyhaunis, Castlerea, Galway and elsewhere. It will probably end up with one T.D. west of the River Shannon in charge of a prairie.
We have seen very efficient Land Commission inspectors functioning in the congested areas in all western counties. These inspectors have to go around and they find, let us say, Michael Murphy in the townland of Cloonkea with a farm, the valuation of which is £4. He finds he cannot make ends meet and he gets on the train for Manchester. He is no sooner there than his neighbours start up a howl to have his land divided. I do not blame them. That is human nature. They say: "This fellow has gone to England; why not divide his land?" The inspectors spend months buzzing round the area. Maybe after two or three years, if Michael Murphy stays away that length of time, they decide they will take over the little holding. They will then hold on to it and set it for the next five years, their excuse being they are waiting for another farm to become available in the area, so that, in the next few years, they may have nine or ten to divide.
While all that is going on, and while the inspectors' time is taken up, across the Shannon in Westmeath, Kildare and Tipperary, there are vast tracts of land that could be acquired. How many miles can one travel in Westmeath or Meath without finding the tracks of an inspector's feet on any farm? If we are serious about the problem of getting land to relieve congestion, the area in which to look for it is not among the small congests but outside in the vast tracts of land to which our surplus population could be transferred. I do not know how many inspectors there are in County Mayo.
Comment on this
I know there are a good many in Galway and Roscommon. I wonder how did they propose to get land over there. When a sincere inspector recommends the acquisition of land in these congested areas, the acquisition order is appealed against and, when they go to the Land Courts, the appeals are upheld and the people in the localities are left in despair for another four or five years. While all this is going on, the Minister tells us about the number of holdings he is vesting each year, as if the major work of the Land Commission were the vesting of holdings.
The vesting of holdings is not half as important as the redistribution of land. As far as I am concerned, there has been no land distribution policy under the present Government. Neither did the last Government have one. The nearest approach to a land distribution policy was between 1935 and 1938. Perhaps, through overenthusiasm in those years, mistakes were made. I do not think that should be taken into consideration now, because the fact that mistakes were made shows there was sincerity. I do not think the fact that mistakes were made should now be an excuse for a halt.
It is undeniable that people got land at that time, people who should never have got land. But that is no reason now for slowing up the process of redistribution. I criticised the former Fianna Fáil Government, perhaps at a time when I was relatively inexperienced, because the general impression given to me, as a young lad, was that if one wanted land one would have to apply to the local political club. As far as the Land Commission officials are concerned, they are far more interested in leaving no openings for rows in an area and in getting the most suitable people to whom to give the land rather than allowing themselves to be subjected to political pressure. I have met these officials and I speak from personal experience of them since I came into public life.
I am not ashamed or afraid to admit that I did say a lot of harsh things at times about land distribution. I do not think now that the people at the top were concerned. I believe it was the local clubs, the small-time politician, the club secretary and so forth who were primarily concerned—the people who, through human weakness, tried to make a certain amount of capital out of the fact that people got land. The club secretary gained political credit for his Party by getting a letter from the T.D. for the county in which the particular Minister stated: "Your representations on behalf of this man will be sympathetically considered." That is the way it was done.
Comment on this
As Deputy Moylan says, cynicism. The individuals concerned were very innocent and they believed that these representations were the be-all and the end-all, so far as the obtaining of land was concerned. But I do not believe these representations were the be-all and the end-all. I believe that in most cases the inspectors went very thoroughly into all the circumstances and into the question as to whether or not the particular individual involved would be a good farmer and took into consideration, too, the size of his holding, and so forth.
Now, the Leas-Cheaan Comhairle pulled me up a few moments ago and more or less suggested that the matters I was raising were not the responsibility of the Minister and the Minister, therefore, had no responsibility in relation to them. That may be, but the extraordinary situation exists that people believe, when a man is Minister for Lands, that he is responsible for the acquisition of land and for the solving of congestion. I do not for a moment suggest that such a Minister should be in a position in which he could turn around and say: "This land should be acquired" or "That man's holding should be acquired". But the Minister for Lands, on the advice of the Cabinet, should be in a position to say to the commissioners: "Gentlemen, I want 10,000 acres of land in the pool in the next six months. Get it". That would only be Government policy and, so far as Government policy is concerned, the Minister for Lands should have responsibility.
But there is no Government policy and I do not believe that such an issue ever came before a Cabinet or that the question ever arose as to whether the Land Commission should be told: "Get rid of congestion within the next ten years". Indeed, I do not believe that was ever even discussed. I do not believe that the majority of the members of the Cabinet know the first thing about congestion. There is no blame to them for that but it does reflect gravely on the man who is charged with responsibility for relieving congestion, namely, Deputy Blowick, the present Minister for Lands, who comes from a congested area and the members of whose Party came in here because the people in the West were dissatisfied with the progress made by Fianna Fáil towards relieving congestion. Whatever we can say about what Fianna Fáil did, we can say that the Clann na Talmhan Party, with their own Minister, have done far less.
I said, earlier on, that the solution to this problem will not be found inside this House. It will come from outside. When it comes I hope it will be the right solution and I hope there will not be an even bigger mess made than in the past. That is always the danger where there is no proper co-ordination, no proper leadership and no proper planning. I think Deputy Derring put his finger on the solution so far as future planning is concerned: there must in future be a very close dovetailing of the work of the Department of Lands and the work of the Department of Agriculture.
Let us send people to Sweden and Italy, and other countries, to see how the people there have dealt with land distribution. In these countries land and agriculture go hand in hand. It is not a question of a State Department handing over a holding at the end of a bad road, with a shaky house built on it, a churn and a plough, and the occupant told: "You fare for yourself from now on." That is not the solution to congestion and that is not the way in which to put this country on the high road to prosperity so far as agriculture is concerned. The men to whom these holdings are given must be catered for all along the line until they have gained confidence in their new surroundings and until they are in a position to utilise and exploit the land to the full. They must be given every possible help with regard to machinery and fertilisers to help them over the first five years at least. It is in that direction we lack co-ordination at the moment between the Department of Lands and the Department of Agriculture. Once the allottee signs on the dotted line, the Land Commission get out like scalded cats and leave it to some other Department to take responsibility from there on. We have had experience of that everywhere the Land Commission works. It is, of course, at times very hard to get proof.
Before I conclude, though I did not intend to dwell at any length on matters affecting my own constituency, I wish to raise one matter of some importance. I am sorry—I do not say this in any spirit of criticism—that the Minister is not present to hear me on this. The Ceann Comhairle pointed out, and rightly so, that the Minister has no function in relation to what land will be acquired. It is very nice for the Minister to be able to shelter under the wing of the commissioners and to point out that he has no responsibility in these matters. But, if he has no responsibility in these matters, it is extraordinary how much responsibility he can take upon himself when it comes to the making of appointments. I want to make it quite clear here that I do not want to see any Minister appointing pets of his own, or any other political Party, to responsible positions.
I hope that the Minister when he is replying will take time off to clarify for me a particular incident which has occurred in Roscommon. Quite recently a man who was a stock master, or stock manager, in County Roscommon fell ill. He is a very decent man. I do not know whether or not some people were hoping he would die, but he recovered. Prior to his full recovery the good news went the rounds that the Minister for Lands had appointed a successor. Now if anything was calculated to finish that man's improvement and to hand him over to Davy Jones it was the fact that he was replaced before he was fully recovered. I understand that the Minister decided he would replace this stock manager by a gentleman who was recommended to him by a political supporter of his own. That was the greatest recommendation he could have—that he was recommended by a political friend of the Minister's.
I know that a number of people became interested in this appointment, and I believe that a certain amount of pressure was exercised on the Minister not to confirm this new appointment. I want to make it quite clear to him that, before he makes any appointment of this nature, he should have the decency to set up an interview board, advertise the job and let the best man get it. The particular appointment in question was, I believe, worth over the years approximately £700 to £800 in commission. If we find that the people in rural Ireland have the impression that ability does not count and that all that counts for a job like this is how well in you are with the Minister for Lands, I think that is a very bad day's work for all those unfortunate enough to be associated with political life.
Perhaps some Deputies may have the outlook that whatever Party is in power is entitled to all the plums. If that is the mentality, why does it not apply to the Civil Service? Let it apply all round; let it be one or the other. We have an established Civil Service— at times we might suggest it is overcrowded and that a lot of pruning could be done with it—but it can be said that that body is non-political. But if we find that, in an important matter like the division of land, appointments are to be made purely on the basis of Party politics, I think it is a most dangerous precedent. Whenever a man has anything to do with land he must be completely over and above Party politics and must not be tinged with them one way or the other. I want the Minister to inform us that as far as this appointment in Roscommon is concerned——
Comment on this
The Minister is a very innocent man. The Minister is quite well acquainted with the facts that I have outlined. I want to make it quite clear to the Minister that it will not be worth his seat in the Cabinet if he insists on appointing a successor to the present holder of the office of stock manager and if he makes that appointment on political grounds. If the Minister wants to make an appointment, let him make it the decent way, set up a board, have all the applications examined by responsible officers and let the best man be appointed.
Comment on this
Might the Deputy not have the decency to let the present holder of the office run his natural course?
Comment on this
It might surprise both Deputies to know that I have given the man two exensions. I gave him one last August and another early this year.
Comment on this
What I want to get here from the Minister is this. While this man was ill, a number of "carrion crows" were hanging around the vicinity waiting for his removal. Some of them said that this man would not be fit to come back. The Minister cannot deny that within the last two months he made a specific promise to appoint another gentleman instead of the present holder but that, as a result of pressure brought to bear on the Minister, he gave a further extension to the present holder. Will the Minister deny that? That is what I want to get clear?
I do not care who gets the appointment ultimately as long as he gets it on merit and it is not a question of some Deputy, county councillor or Senator walking into the Minister and saying: "I want you to appoint this pal of mine as stock manager." I want to see that cut out. That is no way to make an appointment in respect of a man who will have to deal with the county at large and be responsible for the administration of land and the utilisation of land on behalf of the Land Commission. When the Minister is replying, I want him to assure the House that, as far as the present holder of the office is concerned, there will be no suggestion of his removal and there will be no suggestion of a man replacing him.
Comment on this
The Deputy is the first person I have heard to suggest his removal. If the Deputy is not satisfied with the man, I am.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not use that expression in reference to the Minister. The word "bluffer" should be withdrawn.
Comment on this
If I were dissatisfied with the man, I had plenty of opportunity to let him retire instead of giving him extensions.
Comment on this
I will replace him with whom I like when I like. I will keep him as long as he is useful to the Land Commission. If the Deputy wants trouble on that score, he will get plenty of it.
Comment on this
Not in the least bit. I am perfectly satisfied with the man. If I were not satisfied with him, he could have gone last August or he could have gone last January. I extended his term and I will extend it again when the time comes if it suits me—just if it suits me and no more.
Comment on this
The Minister has stated, and I am glad he has put it on the record of the House, that he will replace this man with whom he thinks he should. In other words, that he will take any decision he likes and that he will put whom he likes into the job. Is that what the Minister means to convey by that?
Comment on this
"I will appoint whom I like." Is not that what the Minister has said? Does the Minister stand over that—that he will appoint whom he likes? Is that the way appointments are made now in the State —that the Minister will appoint whom he likes because he likes the colour of his hair or because he likes the particular individual who recommends this fellow to him?
Comment on this
I will try and help the Minister in every way I can to ensure he solves congestion, but I am afraid he is suffering from another kind of congestion.
Comment on this
I will not solve it in the way the Deputy would like but which he is afraid to say here in the House.
Comment on this
The Minister has suggested I want this man removed. That is what he sought to convey.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that the Minister had a man appointed within the last six weeks but that pressure was brought to bear on the Minister and he went back on it? I want to make sure that there will be no need for more pressure to be brought on the Minister to make appointments and promises and then decide, because pressure was brought to bear on him, that he would extend the period of the present holder for a further period. As far as I am personally concerned, the present holder is quite suitable. He is a man with vast experience of the work.
Comment on this
And I have no doubt that the Minister's own Department and his own officials have so informed him. I hope the information he has received from his own Department will carry weight with the Minister and that he will not be misled or persuaded by political supporters to supplant this man and appoint someone else who is a political pet. I want to make it quite clear to the Minister that, when the time comes for the present holder to retire, the appointment should be made, not on a political basis but on the basis that the most deserving and the most suitable man gets the job, and certainly not on the basis on which the Minister has put it to me five minutes ago: "I will appoint whom I like to the job." I want the Minister to get away from that approach.
Comment on this
Perhaps I will say: "I will appoint nobody. I will allow the position to lapse, if I like."
Comment on this
That may happen. It is quite possible that as time goes on there may not be a great deal of work in this constituency for such an officer to do; but where the Minister does decide to make the appointment, let him make it on merit and not on political recommendations alone. I suppose I can be described and will be described by the Minister as being destructive in my criticism of the activities of himself and his Department.
I should now like to suggest to the Minister that he should read very carefully the report of the Commission on Emigration, that he should read the findings of the majority group and one or two of the minority reports in connection with the utilisation of land. It is high time the Minister and the Government blew some of the dust off this report, took it out of the pigeonholes and studied it carefully, because it has quite an amount of useful material and suggestions that may be put into operation, if the Government and the Minister are serious about facing the major problems that arise from that.
The Minister here not alone to-day but on other occasions has more or less taken the line that I have some sinister views with regard to how the land should be used in this country. The Minister is a great man at the half truth; he is a great man, when he leaves this House, for describing Deputies as being extremists or being dangerous or completely irresponsible characters. I want the Minister to be quite clear on my views in regard to land. I put them on the records of the House, and when he goes down to Knock—I believe he is a great frequenter of Knock—and elsewhere, he can make what he likes out of them.
Number one, there must be a maximum put on the amount of land held by any individual in this country. If I am asked for my personal opinion I will say that no man at the present time should be allowed to hold land of a greater valuation than £120 or of a greater amount than 300 acres. On that basis, it will not be long until you have a pool of land that will enable the Land Commission to create at least 25,000 new holdings of a minimum extent of 35 acres, with a valuation of over £20. It will be suggested that that viewpoint is too extreme. Perhaps it is for many Deputies here, but I think that 300 acres of land or the valuation I have suggested represent a reasonable amount of land for any man to hold, especially while you have 19,000 to 20,000 congested holders in the State. We must always bear in mind that the primary function of the Land Commission is the removal of congestion.
Comment on this
I said that I want to give the Minister something to talk about when he leaves here.
Comment on this
I take it the Deputy is advocating that the Land Commission should not take up any farm under 300 acres or under £120 valuation? If I have taken the Deputy up wrongly, I will apologise to him, but I think that is what he is suggesting.
Comment on this
I think I will have to take the Minister down to the Party Room, get a cane and give him a whack each time I mention a figure.
Comment on this
I do not think so. Let me put it this way to the Minister. The Land Commission is charged with the solution of the problem of congestion. If that problem is to be solved, there must be a pool of land made available. I am trying to help the Minister by putting my viewpoint forward as to how that pool of land should be created. Apart altogether from the holdings which are under £120 valuation and which are not being worked, I maintain that no man should be allowed to hold land over £120 valuation or more than 300 acres, that all land surplus to these figures in the possession of a man should be acquired, either compulsorily or through a system of taxation; in other words by doubling the valuation of land over those figures. You could then bring that land into a pool that could be utilised for the relief of congestion.
I cannot think how the Minister can be so dense as to say that I have suggested that a man with £120 valuation or less, or 300 acres or less, should not be touched. I have made no such suggestion whatever. But if we are to solve the problem, we must put a limit on the amount of land a man may hold. I gave an example—I do not know whether the Minister was in the House or not—of one farmer in my constituency with 300 acres who, if he is allowed to keep on purchasing, is taking land that should be coming into the pool for the relief of congestion, and the Land Commission, with the machinery at their disposal, find he is a good farmer and there is nothing to prevent him purchasing more land. He can keep on purchasing; he can go down to Kildare and purchase another farm. We have a case in Westmeath of one man with seven chain farms. Why should we allow one man to have seven chain farms while, down in the West of Ireland, we have perhaps 50 people living in rural slums on holdings with an average poor law valuation of £4?
Is it not the duty of the Land Commission to say: "We will leave this man one good farm and take the other six and utilise those farms by bringing up congests from the West of Ireland"? What is wrong with that? That gentleman may be hurt. He may squeal to some political Party. I do not know what Party it is. The trouble is that these types of individuals who own the good land seem to have the greatest political power. They are better organised, and have the ear of the powers that be.
This country is described as a nation of smallholders. Just let us see how the land itself works out amongst the smallholders. You have 11,600 holdings in Ireland with a poor law valuation of over £2,000,000. You have 280,000 holdings in Ireland with a total poor law valuation of less than £2,000,000. Bring that down further. These 11,600 holdings represent 3 per cent. of the holdings of Ireland. Three per cent. of the landholders of Ireland have a land valuation of over £2,000,000, while 280,000 landholders, or 70 per cent., have a poor law valuation of less than £2,000,000.
The finest of land is concentrated in the hands of a limited few; the majority of the holdings are small and are on the poorest type of land. Is the land fairly distributed in these circumstances? I have not gone, deliberately, to mix up the situation by going into the figures with regard to acreage. I have adhered as much as possible to valuation, because it is valuation that counts. We know perfectly well that a farm of then acres in Westmeath is a far better proposition than ten acres stuck down in Connemara; yet we will find that for every one who has good land in Westmeath there are 20 trying to make a living west of the Shannon on the poor land.
The argument all through is that there is no return from agriculture. We are told by Deputy Derrig and others here that the small men are not in a position to utilise the machinery available now. There is more machinery utilised by the small farmers than by the big farmers. There are more tractors purchased by the small men than by the big to-day. That cannot be denied. The bigger they are, the less they are inclined to do, the less need there is for them to do, while the small man is put to the pin of his collar to keep his family and himself in some reasonable comfort.
We are not looking to see re-established here another nation of landlords with a group of tenants paid a weekly wage. We want to see as many economic holders as possible set up where they can make a reasonable living. It is a far better and more Christian proposition to have the broad acres of the Midlands divided up into 40- and 50-acre holdings that will give a living to a man, his wife and his family, who in turn will produce the utmost out of that farm, than to have 300 or 500 acres of that land in the hands of one individual, who will wear jodhpurs and be seen entertaining guests in Mullingar or some leading hotel here in Dublin. That is the position that exists at the present moment. If you go down to some hotels in the Midlands it is hard to know what nationality some of these gentlemen are. They own the finest land around the Midlands, and all they are concerned with is getting enough to keep themselves and their doubtful type of friends in luxury either in Dublin or in London, while the people from the localities have to stream to London and elsewhere, and people like myself and Deputies in this House will be pestered by protection associations in Manchester and Liverpool and London to send subscriptions to keep those people together, herd them together in their jobs and in their pastimes beyond in England.
This is the very tragic situation that we have allowed to go on so long. On a number of occasions here before I raised the question of the purchase of lands in Tipperary and Limerick and parts of the Midlands by aliens. I am not going to elaborate on it, because I found that the majority of the men in this House were unsympathetic to the views I expressed, although the views I expressed are the views of the majority of the people, the smallholders, outside this House. If many Deputies had their ear a lot closer to the ground as to the real ideals and feelings of the people they would force changes in the Department of Lands, no matter what Government was in power.
I and the congests in Mayo, Roscommon and Galway would have more confidence in this Minister if he would put a team of inspectors into the Midlands and in portions of Tipperary to examine particularly the way in which large farms are being run, or neglected, and issue acquisition notices by the score to these gentlemen that he was going to resume the lands. If I saw that happening I would believe that the Minister was sincere, but, instead of that, the Minister comes into this House and shelters these people, these brigadiers, retired colonels of the Indian Army, and war profiteers who came back from London to escape just taxation by the British Government. He stands here as the man who protects their interests. He stands condemned in the eyes of the congests in the West of Ireland as the man who is acting as protector of the racketeer, the British colonel, the retired Indian Army major and all the other riff-raff that have come over to this country in the last 15 years and purchased the finest land in the country.
Comment on this
Deputy McQuillan is constantly telling us about what is happening to all the fine lands in other constituencies, but no Deputy from those constituencies ever seems to know anything about them. Let him tell us something of what is happening in his own constituency, and give us an instance.
Comment on this
I am going to tell the Minister how he has acted as protector of these gentlemen. The Minister comes in here and tells me and other Deputies that the hard pool of land is drying up, that land for the relief of congestion is not available. The man who makes that statement as Minister for Lands is betraying the congests of Ireland when he knows the position in the Midlands. That is how the Minister acts as protector of these gentlemen who come in. That is how the Minister is betraying——
Comment on this
I think the Deputy when he suggests that the Land Commission should not take up any farm under £100 valuation is the betrayer. In that way, he puts it straight into the mouth of the Land Commission not to take a farm under that size.
Comment on this
I can tell the Deputy I have great sympathy with him in regard to the problems in front of him.
Comment on this
I am beginning to appreciate the problems that the Land Commission must have with this Minister in charge. I wonder does he yet know the difference between the door into the Forestry Department and the door into the Land Commission or does he still have to be led round by the nose to show him the different sections of his Department? I want the Minister not to try to misrepresent me here. I made a case here with regard to the ceiling, or the amount of land which any man should own, and I do not believe that any man should be allowed to own more than 300 acres of land, because it will not——
Comment on this
No, it is the manner in which the Deputy is trying to undermine the work of the Land Commission.
Comment on this
I think perhaps I should wait for the next debate and talk about the amount of forestry that is in the Minister's head.
Comment on this
The upbringing I got places me at a great disadvantage compared with the upbringing the Deputy got.
Comment on this
I do not know exactly what the Minister means. I just do not follow him. All I want the Minister to do is to give congests of Mayo, Roscommon and elsewhere some sign or some hope that in the next 12 months he will make available a pool of land in the Midlands that can be used for redistribution purposes so that he will be able to come to this House in 12 months' time and tell us that it is not 80 new holdings that have been created or 80 new migrants that have gone to the Midlands, but that he will have plans prepared for a minimum of at least 1,000 per year.
We find the daily papers at the present moment publishing photographs and accounts of the send-offs and good-byes of families leaving the West of Ireland and moving off into the wilderness of the Midlands. One would think by the publicity given that the whole West of Ireland was moving in caravans across the Shannon to take over the Midlands, but we find in the whole 12 months that between 80 and 100 is the maximum number of new holdings created in the Midlands for migrants. For how many years does the Minister expect this is going to carry on? Could it be that the reason I gave here last year is the real reason —that this problem is not being solved because finance is the big snag and the money will not be made available to the Minister? Could it be that the Minister, big and all as he may be, is only a small boy when he sits in at the Cabinet meeting and is told to keep his mouth shut and asked how dare he look for money?
I am afraid that is what is happening. I am afraid that, as far as the Minister is concerned, he may bluff the people of Ballyhaunis, Westport and elsewhere, that he has a big "say," and he may bluff his supporters in Roscommon that he has a big "say", because he is able to appoint a stock manager, but, when it comes down to "divvying" out with regard to the amount of money made available for the relief of congestion and for the creation of new holdings in the Midlands, we find that the Minister is not in a position to force his views or even to get a hearing for his views within the Cabinet. By criticism here—not of the Minister personally—by the strongest possible criticism they can level at him, Deputies of all Parties will be helping the Minister because he can then go back to the Cabinet and say: "It will not be possible for me to face Leinster House again after the abuse I got last year. I want more money and I insist on getting it. I am not going to be the small boy in this Cabinet any longer."
If the Minister takes to heart the criticism that is levelled at him here, he will realise that it is levelled for the sole purpose of trying to rid the country of that terrible evil of congestion in our time, that is in the next five or six years. There is no Minister who has a better opportunity of helping to turn the tide with regard to the great drain there is on this country at the moment through emigration; no Minister has it more in his power to redress that than the Minister for Lands. The Minister and his officials are well aware of the fact that there are thousands and thousands of applications—some of them for years— in the office of the Department of Lands from first-class men seeking holdings of land of £5 or £7 or £8 valuation who are being put off year after year because the land is not available and who, in the end, are forced to close their doors, take their families with them, and move out to work in England because they are completely dispirited at the lack of progress towards solving their problems.
Even at this late stage, if the Minister can get a decision from the Cabinet that would allow him to send a field of inspectors—as we will describe them, although that may sound very sinister to the Minister and to the Minister for Agriculture—down to the Midlands, to parts of Tipperary, to examine the lands that he there to hand, to issue acquisition notices, and over the next three or four years have those lands ready for redistribution then he will occupy a place in the history of land division in this country practically as high as Michael Davitt. I know that the minute he attempts to embark on this programme in the Midlands he will be bringing down upon himself the greatest criticism, and the greatest pressure will be brought to bear on him to prevent such a scheme being carried out. When that pressure is brought to bear, it will take a very strong Minister for Lands to stand up to it because I have no doubt that, apart from anything else, the age-old question of morals will be brought into it; the Minister will be described as having the two horns and the cloven hoof and will probably be identified in some close manner with the late Joe Stalin. I have no doubt, however, that he will live longer in history and that there will be a more generous appreciation of his work than of that of the dictator who has recently passed away.
The Minister would really need to be a dictator within his Department; he would need to make it quite clear that the fundamental thing he is after is land, and that he is going to get that land at all costs. There are two things involved: one is the extra number of families that can make a living in Ireland and the second is that, by the fact of establishing these families on the land, output will be increased and agricultural expansion will take place. If that takes place, we shall have solved the greatest problem facing any Government anywhere within the next generation.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it not rather unusual to wait 20 seconds, while one Deputy is standing up, to call another?
Comment on this
It is not unusual for the Chair to go from one side of the House to the other. It has been the established practice here. As no member of this Party was called for some time, I felt one should be called now.
Comment on this
I accept the Chair's ruling, as I must, but nobody offered.
Comment on this
The last speaker mentioned at the outset of his speech that he was surprised the Opposition did not put down a motion on this Estimate to have it referred back. Such a motion was put down from time to time over a number of years, but, as the Land Commission appears to be following such a slow-motion pattern and indulging in goose-stepping, I do not think anybody felt it would serve any very useful purpose at this stage to have the Estimate referred back. The most we can do now is, if possible, to make suggestions and ask for information.
A great deal was said by the previous speaker regarding the amount of congestion and the slowness of the Land Commission in dealing with it. I presume the Land Commission know the number of congests in the country and that the Minister would be able to give a table outlining the number of people having valuations ranging from £1 to £5, £5 to £10, £10 to £15 and from £15 to £20. I expect the Minister has that information at his disposal and it might be well if he had it inserted in the Official Report, if that were possible or permissible.
I should also like to find out whether any survey has been made in recent years of the pool of land actually available for distribution. Some people allege that we have as much land in the country at the moment available for land division as would create 25,000 holdings without much difficulty. I do not know whether that is true or not, but, if a survey were made and a report furnished to the Minister, he would be in a position to come into this House and tell us, county by county in the Twenty-Six Counties, the approximate figure in regard to the land available for acquisition and division among the congests. It was the primary aim of the Congested Districts Board, when the Estates Commissioners were set up, to relieve congestion.
In recent times, and for a good many years, land division has not been carried on with the same speed as it was 18 or 20 years ago and previous to that time. We know that during the emergency period it was difficult, if not impossible, for the Land Commission to take over land and have it divided, but a considerable amount of land was divided in the years before the emergency and all the way back to the passage of the Land Act in 1903.
Many of us would have thought that it would not take over 50 years to take over the land and have it divided. We have come to realise that the people who possess land have their rights and that they, too, can go to a court and put their case as to the amount of land they are entitled to retain and that they have equal rights with the Land Commission in that respect, but, definitely, I find that for the past few years estates are being kept on hands for a very long time and why they are kept on hands for such a long time is very difficult to understand.
I could mention a number of estates in my own constituency of South Galway, some of which were taken over away back in 1947 and which are still held on reserve and let on conacre every year. It is very difficult to understand why it is that the Land Commission have not, after a period of some five to eight years in possession of the land, passed it to the division scheme and allocated it.
There is one thing I think the Land Commission should do when they take over an estate. They should first investigate the problem of local congestion within the mile distance. I do not think it would be a very difficult problem to give extensions of land to the local congests within the mile distance from the estate and hold on reserve whatever amount is not required until there was time enough to prepare a suitable scheme for the migrants it is proposed to take in. That is one of the things the Land Commission could do and I would suggest to the Minister and his Department that the local congests' problem in all cases should be first dealt with, where it is not possible to deal with the whole estate.
This whole question of the acquisition and division of land is a matter for the Land Commission. I think that is right and proper, too. I do not believe that the authority for either the acquisition or division of land should rest in the hands of any Minister for Lands. Indeed, I would not envy the Minister if he were vested with that authority, because I know very well he would not get much time to rest or sleep. It is a difficult problem enough, and the Land Commission have some difficulty, I believe, in coming to a decision as to whether or not they should acquire a particular area of land.
I have great sympathy for congests, but at the same time I have often found that, where people were migrated many years ago to very good holdings of land, they have somehow or other acquired the rancher mentality, just as much as the person from whom the land was taken. In consequence of that, I think the Land Commission in selecting allottees should not all the time adhere to the congests' valuation limit. I would not expect they would go very far outside it or anything of that kind, but they should not be guided by that alone. They should be guided by how the person to whom they are considering allotting the land has worked his own smallholding. If that smallholding has not been worked in the proper manner—I maintain that the proper manner is to have a fairly big percentage of tillage as well as grazing—if the holder is merely a miniature grazier, he should not be considered by the Land Commission. If we are to have a policy that will be useful and that will produce good results, the people who work their holdings on the mixed farming system should be selected as allottees and also as migrants. There is very little use in bringing people from the West of Ireland to the East of Ireland, to Tipperary or elsewhere, if the next thing they want is to earn money working on the roads or somewhere else and utilise the land more as a grazing farm than as a mixed farm.
In that case, I know the Land Commission's inspectors will find some difficulty. They would not succeed in every case. We have had experience of people who did work their small holdings well and had at least 15 per cent. of the land in tillage but who, when they got the 25 acre holding, had not 2 per cent. or even 1 per cent. under tillage; it was all grass. There is a difficulty. We cannot blame the Land Commission for all the failures and all the faults. Certainly there should be a planned policy. I believe that the survey I mentioned at the outset, a survey of the approximate amount of land available for distribution, if it has not been made in recent times, should be made immediately. I am sure there is sufficient staff in the Land Commission to undertake such a survey.
It would be unpopular, I am sure, to suggest that we should not allocate any land for the next five or seven years but I feel that, if we are to have a proper distribution and allocation of land, it would perhaps be just as good a policy as anything else to take over all the land that the Land Commission could possibly take over and, apart from dealing with local congestion immediately around land that is acquired, have that pool of land there and make out a scheme of various sized holdings. If certain of the people whom it was intended to migrate did not agree to take the holding offered to them, it could be offered to somebody else. It should be possible to have a big pool of land available for division at a particular time.
I expect there are snags in that suggestion and perhaps this is rather late in the day to embark on such a scheme. If that had been done 25 years ago we would probably have better distribution of land and there would probably have been fewer failures than there have been because of trying to hasten too much and to carry out too much purchase and too much division within a short period of time, which resulted in some people being allocated land who, on more mature consideration by the officials, would not have been allocated land, and more desirable people would have got it.
While saying all that, I cannot understand the carrying over of large farms for a considerable length of time. People are asking what are the inspectors doing. There seems to be a number of inspectors and one wonders why they are taking such a long time.
Deputy Derrig mentioned the question of turbary allotments. While it is very desirable that turbary should be allotted to people who have land and to people who have no land but who are farmers and who have not turbary, it is essential to carry out the necessary improvements to the bogs. There is a number of cases in County Galway where turbary was allotted many years ago but where no improvements were carried out. The road into the bog was marked out but no road was made. Some drains were opened, but the drainage of a bog is a very difficult matter. A bog cannot be drained in one year. It takes at least six years and even then it would need a very good outfall. The banks were marked out for the tenants but that bog remains virgin bog. It has not been worked and could not be worked because of the fact that improvements were not carried out.
The position now is that the turbary allotment has been consolidated with the parent holding and the Land Commission are no longer responsible. The people concerned are not able of themselves to carry out the improvements. The cost of putting a road through a virgin bog would be very heavy. The carrying out of the work would be a difficult matter. It is something that the Special Employment Schemes Branch of the Board of Works do not want to undertake. The Land Commission are very competent, if they so desire, to carry out the necessary improvements on bog that is allotted. Where they have done so, the bogs can be utilised and the improvement works that have been carried out are a credit to the Land Commission. In many cases it has not been done; it has been passed over.
I know many cases where the turbary allotment was pointed out to people who had got holdings and to migrants but up to the present time nothing has been done in the particular bogs. I have mentioned the matter time and time again to the Land Commission, received the usual acknowledgment and all the rest of it, but nothing has been done. The people concerned have to purchase turf and go into competition for turbary with other people, thus putting up the price of turbary.
There are a few matters which I should like to bring to the Minister's notice. While our sympathy is always with the people who need land, at the same time there are landowners from whom land has been taken who deserve some practical expression of sympathy from the Minister and the Land Commission. Cases have been brought to my notice where the Land Commission acquired land by agreement on price. The price was fixed and the vendor was to be paid in land bonds at 4¾ per cent. I understand that the 4¾ per cent. is of recent origin, that it had been either 4½ per cent. or 4¼ per cent. These people now find that the land bonds are only worth £80 to the £100 on the Stock Exchange. Consequently, a person who sold land at a value of £5,000, agreed between the vendor and the Land Commission, now stands to lose £1,000.
I have one particular instance of a case where, owing to the fact that one townland in an estate was never valued and that rates were never collected on it, there was a hold-up for months. There was a delay in the payment of the bonds. Of course, the Land Commission required a certificate that all the debts had been discharged and that all the rates had been paid. While a certificate in respect of the various townlands on the estate was submitted to the Land Commission, where they were valued and the rates had been paid, still this other townland appeared on the map of the area comprising the estate and the county council or the county council officials delayed sending on a certificate and, in fact, paid no heed to the Land Commission or to the vendor's solicitor. The person concerned could perhaps have disposed of the land bonds at that time almost at their full value. However, because of a delay of about nine or ten months at least, the land bonds reduced in value and reduced very considerably in value.
I think the Land Commission and the Government have a responsibility in a case like that—and it is not an individual case. It is really not one exceptional case. I believe there are a number of cases all over the country where something similar to that has happened. I do not think it was the intention of the Land Commission, when they were fixing the price, that that person would not get the full value of the land bonds. I should like the Minister to have that matter examined with a view to having something done.
Comment on this
In the future, instead of land bonds, perhaps it might be possible for the Land Commission to pay in cash either a quarter or a half of the purchase price. Maybe there is a big difficulty there. I am only offering that suggestion. I know it could be one that would be found to satisfy a great many of the people who are negotiating with the Land Commission regarding the sale of their land now. The fact that a thing like that happens makes people who would be willing to part with land a bit hard and very difficult. They are not as anxious or as willing as they might be and it puts the Land Commission to a good deal of trouble that otherwise perhaps they would not have to encounter.
There was some crossfire a short while ago between the Minister and Deputy McQuillan regarding some appointment. I know nothing about the case nor do I want to know anything about it.
Comment on this
Allegations may be made against a Minister for appointing somebody whose political views agree with his own and certainly there would be something wrong in that if the qualifications of that person were not as good as the best of the others but, where the qualifications are up to the same standard, it should be no barrier to a person of that kind to be appointed. That should be no barrier. I want to speak on this on general lines. As I say, I know nothing about the individual case, nor am I interested. It has been suggested that an interview board should be set up. Perhaps interview boards are all right. I believe that, in the main, they are honest people; probably 99.9 per cent. of them are. However, what have we heard about interview boards, over the years? From time to time, are the Local Appointments Commission not pin-pointed as not appointing the best people? Local interview boards have been said by other interested people not to have discharged their function impartially, either. Therefore, on this question of appointments, the gift of Ministers or the gift of heads of Departments, or anything like that, I think we could debate the pros and cons for the next three days and after all that I do not think we would be able to formulate a system that would be 100 per cent. perfect or one that would satisfy everybody.
I should like to ask the Minister again to give us, if at all possible, an estimate, county by county, of the approximate amount of land available for acquisition and also to tell us what he thinks would be the period of time it would take to deal with it. We do not want to see the Land Commission, as far as acquisition and resumption and division are concerned, going on like Tennyson's brook—going on forever. I do not think that that was ever intended. When land acquisition and division have been dealt with, I firmly believe the officials of the Land Commission will find plenty of useful work to do, even in that particular Department, in other directions.
With regard to the taking over of land, unless it is an agreed policy to take it over all over the country and keep it for a period of years until you have a pool of several thousand acres in order to have that vast scheme of migration carried out, I think it is very unwise to buy land and hold it over for a period of five, ten, 15 or 20 years, in some cases, while at the same time there are congests not very far away. When they see that land there, they become very dissatisfied with the work of the Land Commission. They say it is just a "mark time" procedure so far as the Land Commission is concerned—that they are just interested in retaining their positions and passing it on to other people rather than doing the work which they have been entrusted to carry out.
Comment on this
Some months ago, a Private Member's motion in my name was discussed very fully in this House. During that discussion, I covered many points affecting the division of land and, therefore, I do not intend to repeat them here this evening. However, there are quite a number of items which I think should be brought to the notice of the Minister and I hope he will give them the necessary attention.
To start off, I noticed recently in the Census of Population Report that there was a very big drop in the population of the congested districts in the West. I noticed that in my constituency there was a slight increase in the population. I am aware that there has been a very big volume of emigration from my constituency and that the loss caused by that emigration was made up by the people who were brought to Meath from the West and South. The result was a net loss to the country. I suggest it is no gain whatever to the country in general if people are brought in from outside—call them migrants, congests, what have you—to places like County Meath and given land for which there is already a demand in Meath. I think that is not the answer to the problem.
It simply means that the natives of the county into which these people are brought emigrate. I feel that something is happening which the Land Commission will have to approach in a different manner. I have the utmost sympathy with the people who have to live on small farms in the congested districts, but people who have to live without any land, people who have been living on small farms in the same district all their lives, people whose grandparents were evicted from their holdings and whose families still live in the district—all these people are entitled to justice. There is no reason why they should get less preferential treatment than the people born in the West of Ireland.
Every day I see the result of the migration of these people into my constituency. I see, not only the young people, but also the older people, having to leave because the portions of land which they should have got were given to somebody else. This situation has been continuing through the reigns of this Government, the previous Government, and the two Governments before them. I feel that something will have to be done to reverse this procedure. While I have great sympathy with the people in the congested areas, and while sympathy is of very little use, I have still greater sympathy for the people who have to emigrate as a result of this policy.
The Minister has said here on several occasions that he is prepared to see that the Land Commission give preference to uneconomic holders who live within a mile of the land that is being divided. I am afraid the big trouble lies in the difference between what the Land Commission consider to be an uneconomic holder and what the people of County Meath consider to be an uneconomic holder. There seems to be some slide rule which the Land Commission use which can be set so that it will rule out some people and rule in some others who are in exactly similar circumstances.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
I was referring to the fact that people, who have lived near estates for years, consider that they are harshly treated when people from outside are brought in to get land from these estates. The result is that there is a continuous loss to the country because the natives emigrate when migrants are brought in from other parts of the country. I suggest that people who live within a mile of an estate and who are uneconomic holders should receive preference when that estate is being divided.
If that were done, it would remove an awful lot of dissatisfaction and there is an awful lot of dissatisfaction because of this matter. We have, in County Meath, quite a large number of very large estates. I do not agree with a lot of what Deputy McQuillan said, but there is something in his suggestion that a farm can be uneconomic just as much because it is too large as because it is too small. If there are large farms in County Meath and other counties which are not being used as they should be used, they should be acquired by the Land Commission to provide economic holdings for local landless people and this would do away with a great deal of the dissatisfaction.
On previous occasions, I paid tribute to the efforts of the Fianna Fáil Government, when, at one time, they did endeavour to do this. They gave farms to the local people. These people did not all turn out to be the best farmers, but 95 per cent. of them did and they are the cosiest farmers in the country at the present time. What is more important is that they were able to rear their families on these farms and the families were able to work the farms. When migrants are brought in, these migrants find that they are not able to make a living, no matter how large the farms they have, and we have recently seen the position where people who are brought into the county find that they cannot live on 30 acres of land and are competing with the local people for employment on the roads and any other type of work that can be got. Not alone do the sons and daughters of these migrants compete for that work, but the migrants themselves compete for it. Something should be done to stop that.
Then there is the question of the person who has been employed on an estate for many years. I find that, when such lands are being divided, there is a growing inclination on the part of the Land Commission to pay these people compensation which generally amounts to less than the price of one acre of the land being divided.
A Deputy referred to the fact that ten acres of land in Counties Meath or Westmeath would be better than 30 or 40 acres of land in County Mayo. That is not quite correct. There is bad land in Meath and Westmeath and the neighbouring counties. Very often, when land is being divided and when some local applicants are being given some of that land, by some strange coincidence, we find that the poorest portions of the land are given to the local applicants. I have mentioned "strange coincidence", but it does just happen that way, and I believe that is something the Land Commission will have to pay attention to. The people of Meath have been very quiet about all this, but it is high time that something were done. Otherwise, they will probably boil over.
Then there is the matter of the landless men. The Minister has stated here that, because there is not enough land to go around, he regrets that there is little he can do for them. I want to say that, despite what has been said by my two colleagues in my own constituency, I am terribly dissatisfied with the way the Land Commission have been carrying on in Meath. I am dissatisfied with this whole system by which landless men are deprived of the opportunity of getting now even what was given to them by Fianna Fáil in the late 1930s—a five-acre holding. It is no consolation to tell these people that those from the West of Ireland who got the land were in a worse state.
We sometimes find that on those old estates, no matter how badly they were run, local people were given at least what we would call the grass of a cow. Is it not ironic to find that, when these estates are divided, the cows must be taken off and put on the road or on the long acre until the Guards get tired summoning the owners? That happens because the Land Commission do not seem to realise that these people are entitled either to portion of the farm acquired or to a cow plot.
I have discussed this matter both publicly and privately with the Minister and I got the impression there would be no difficulty in providing cow plots for people if a case were put up. I find, however, that no new cow plots have been given. What we find instead is a quotation from some letter written 20 or 30 years ago to the effect that cow plots were being handed back to the Land Commission for some reason or another. That is used as an excuse for not giving cow plots now. I think the Minister should carry out what he said in this House to the effect that he would see that the Land Commission provided cow plots where they were needed and where a proper case had been made for them.
Occasionally, when Land Commission inspectors go to check up in an area where land is being divided, they ask questions about whether a person who is looking for a cow plot has a cow or not. Because of the fact that that person had no place in which to keep the cow and he had to sell it, he would get no plot even thought he may have had the money and the intention of purchasing a cow as soon as the cow plot became available. I do not know where the inspectors thought the cow would be kept while its owner was looking for a place in which to put it. People like that should be included in the inspector's lists when a case is being made for a cow plot in an area.
In passing, I should like to refer to the question of correspondence with the Land Commission. Unfortunately, very few of the people in my constituency are native Irish speakers. I do not think it is correct for the Land Commission, when replying to queries about land allocation, to reply in Gaelic. If the Land Commission want to salve their consciences, they could reply in two languages. It is, however, unreasonable and unfair to replay in Gaelic alone. It is bad enough that people have to use the steam of the kettle to open these letters, they are so small and flimsy, without also having the difficulty of interpreting the contents, written in a language they do not understand. I suggest that the Land Commission are not too hard up to reply properly to queries of this sort.
I would also refer to the question of representation. Somebody might send a query to the Land Commission asking whether a person is or is not entitled to a farm. Surely the Land Commission should reply to such a query saying whether a person is or is not so entitled? Why send back a reply which could mean anything and which usually means nothing? Perhaps the Minister has no function in the matter. This system had been carried on for a number of years before the Minister came into office and, if it is something he could discuss with his Department, he should do so. The same thing happens when a question is put down in the House. The answer is sometimes helpful enough, but sometimes it does not mean anything. When it is rumoured that estates are to be considered for acquisition, the Minister will often reply here that officially he knows nothing about it.
I know of cases in my own constituency where the Land Commission have had their eye on a holding for some time and where the local people will tell you all about it. Meanwhile, the people who own the land will either try to sell it or set it to somebody who will use it for growing wheat for possibly three years in succession. Then when anybody wants to go into it, the usefulness has been taken away and a considerable amount of fertiliser must be used on it to put it back into condition. I have the greatest sympathy for the migrants who get this land because, as Deputy Giles said, it is no more than a dust bowl when the people get it.
It seems that a junior official in the Land Commission could know more about the Land Commission than does the Minister or the heads of his Department. Talking about officials, I would make a suggestion to which, perhaps, people might take exception. I think it would not do a bit of harm if the Commission inspectors were changed round a bit. I am very glad that politicians in this House have no say in the division of land. I am not satisfied, however, that people outside have not a say in it. I have been told by people who got farms that they had been recommended by certain people. I have also been told by people that certain people in their area recommended them for farms and that as a result they got them. There is one instance to which I should particularly like to refer and that is the division of an estate in Beltrasna, Oldcastle. I understand my two colleagues are satisfied——
Comment on this
I never said the Deputy did. The Deputy will get an opportunity of refuting what I have just said later.
Comment on this
The Deputy will get an opportunity of refuting my statement later if he so wishes.
Comment on this
The Deputy referred to his two colleagues a few moments ago and said they were satisfied with something else.
Comment on this
Lest there be any doubt, what I said was that my two colleagues said they were satisfied they were doing a good job and that I am not satisfied.
Comment on this
The Deputy is putting words into my mouth which I did not use at all. I think the Deputy should be asked to withdraw that statement.
Comment on this
Deputy Tully has two colleagues in his constituency. When he refers to two of his colleagues saying something which one of them says now he never said, Deputy Tully should accept that refutation and withdraw.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that I had said I was satisfied with the division of this estate in Beltrasna. I never said anything of the kind.
Comment on this
I suggest there is a new procedure here when four Deputies are allowed to speak at the same time.
Comment on this
No. When a Deputy says that a statement made by another Deputy does not represent what was actually said, I think that should be accepted. Deputy Tully should accept the statements of Deputies Giles and Hilliard. Does the Deputy accept their statements?
Comment on this
I did not say what I am supposed to have said, but, if Deputy Hilliard and Deputy Giles are not satisfied, I will withdraw the statement.
Comment on this
That is putting an altogether different complexion on it. The Deputy said his colleagues said they were satisfied with the division of the estate. I said I never said that at any time. I think it would be better now if Deputy Tully told us what the Labour Party's policy is.
Comment on this
Let us not get into policy. It is simply a matter as to what was said by Deputy Tully. Deputy Tully says he accepts that Deputy Giles and Deputy Hilliard did not say they were satisfied with the division of this estate. Is that right?
Comment on this
If he accepts what Deputy Giles and Deputy Hilliard say now, that is an end of the matter. That is as far as I can go. Does Deputy Tully say he accepts the statement of the two Deputies that they did not say they were satisfied with the division of the estate?
Comment on this
Not alone do I accept it, but I am delighted to hear them say it.
Comment on this
Deputy Hilliard has made a statement that I held up the division of land for three months. I ask him to withdraw that statement, because I did not hold up the division of land.
Comment on this
Deputies are very thin-skinned regarding their political actions. If a person says a Deputy held up things, I do not know exactly what he has to withdraw.
Comment on this
Deputy Hilliard is telling an untruth.
Comment on this
The Chair cannot investigate every statement made by every Deputy. I suggest that Deputy Tully should now proceed.
Comment on this
I will proceed by saying that what Deputy Hilliard just said is untrue.
Comment on this
There were a number of people living beside this estate in Oldcastle on very small farms, some with two acres, some with five acres and some with six acres. For one reason or another, these people were passed over. Indeed, they were passed over for no apparent reason. Part of the estate was given to a person from outside the county; I would describe him as a migrant. He was given 100 acres of land. The following week—and I have raised this already by way of parliamentary question—that land was advertised for letting on the 11 months system. The Minister assured me then that, if such a thing happened again, the Land Commission would take notice of it. I understand now that there may have been a reason for that letting; the Land Commission did not meet their commitments, or did not make available the money which those people should have got.
I have two objections to make. I object to 100 acres of land being given to people from outside the county, while those living in the county get none at all. I object to the Land Commission allowing those who come into the county to set the land they get on the 11 months system. It is a matter of complete indifference to us who sets the land. We think the principle is wrong. I hope the Minister will take note of that, because there is a very strong feeling about it in the county.
Some time ago, I asked for particulars of the land taken over by the Land Commission in Meath and I was told that there were remnants and odd pieces of land which did not appear on the list I got. I asked what the remnants and odd pieces were. I was told I could not get particulars of them as there were 700 involved. I suggest there should not be any remnants or odd pieces. Surely the Land Commission should be able to divide all the land. It is the Land Commission's job to see that there are no remnants. I asked the Minister to have this matter attended to without delay. Is there any reason why a remnant of three or four acres should be left when there is a man living beside that remnant badly in need of three or four acres? I was surprised to learn there was no real record of these remnants and that I could not be told offhand what the position was or where they were.
Comment on this
I would like to know what the Minister did tell me, when he is replying.
Comment on this
I hope what the Deputy understood was that it would take a lot of time to go through all the files and pinpoint all the remnants. I gave him the bulk of the estates and I pointed out that the amount of official time needed to tabulate all the little remnants, and their value, would not be worth it.
Comment on this
It would be well worth it from the point of view of the people who are looking for land. They would consider it time and money well spent if the Minister could get round to getting the Land Commission to draw up a list of the 700 remnants of estates which are lying about in County Meath.
Comment on this
Deputy Hilliard mentions bog banks. I know there is hardly one bog bank which would not be taken by somebody if the Land Commission would only put pen to paper and give it to an applicant. With the present coal position, people are vainly trying to get firing of some kind every day in the week. It is no answer to tell them that the Land Commission have not tabulated the remnants or the bog banks, and, therefore, cannot give them to anybody. The Land Commission did acquire a considerable amount of turbary. Apparently the people to whom it was allocated were not too anxious to hold on to it and did not pay any rent for it. In some areas, people are very anxious to get this turbary. I have brought that to the notice of the Land Commission in two or three cases. I have no doubt that I am right in saying this time that my colleagues on both sides of the House have done the same with very little result. I was brought to may senses this year when a particular matter came to my notice. I had been asked to look after this matter last year and the year before that, and I was more than surprised to find that the Land Commission are still considering it. That is just not good enough.
There is another matter to which Deputy Beegan has referred already, that is, the setting of land taken over for allocation. I got a reply here some months ago stating that there were very few estates, if any, on hands for more than five or six months in County Meath. I know that there are some estates on hands much longer than that. I suggested then that the Minister's information was not quite correct and I shall be glad if he will refer to this matter when he is replying. If he cannot deal with it now, I will put down a question again in the very near future.
I appeal to him again to give special consideration to smallholders in the areas in which lands are being divided. Consideration should also be given to those to whom consideration was formerly given, namely, the children of evicted tenants. They were given consideration and now apparently they are being completely passed over.
I am sure I will be joined by other Deputies in asking that something should be done about the number of Old I.R.A. men, who are now growing few, left in the country looking for land. I suggest that, since the number is getting smaller and since the necessity for giving land at all will probably disappear inside the next few years, they should get consideration, whether they have got land at present or not. It is the very least they might be offered, and I think this should be done, if it is at all possible.
There is a portion of County Meath on the Cavan-Louth-Monaghan border, where, as I said before and now repeat, there is almost as much congestion as in any place in the West of Ireland. I suggest that those people should be considered, and considered immediately, for transfer holdings when estates are being divided. Many of those people have been promised a transfer holding for years; but promises are no good to them, and many of them have grown old in the promise that some day they will be transferred to better land. The land which they would leave behind would be very useful to the people who live in the area. Might I appeal to the Minister to have this matter looked up and that, before any more migrants from outside counties are brought in, those people will be given the transfer holdings to which they are entitled?
One other thing which Deputy McQuillan referred to here, and which I should like to mention, is the amount of land held by some people. I know of people in the county who have very large tracts of land and I should not be inclined to touch them at all because they give a very high volume of employment there; but I know of other people who have large tracts of land and who give no employment at all. I know of other instances where, when the matter of this land is brought to the notice of the Minister and of the commissioners, those people set the land to outsiders who till it for one year, and what will happen after that goodness only knows. It is quite possible that, if the eye of the Land Commission is taken off those farms, they will be allowed to go back to grass—"the natural way", as one of them described it to me some time ago—and allowed to go fallow. I think that those farms should be looked up by the Land Commission and they should definitely keep their eye on them and not take it off. Even if the land is torn up and tilled for one year by outsiders, that should not leave them free from inspection in years to come. I know of people also who have made promises to the Land Commission that they would do this, that and the other thing, if the land was left with them, and I find that some of them have not kept their promises very long.
With reference to the Land Commission, there was a statement made here that some of the people are dissatisfied with the prices they have got and some of them are dissatisfied with the way the price is given to them. I should like to mention one other point about this question of land which is given back to the owner on appeal, or is left to the owner on appeal. There is one case in South Meath where a man, one of whose farms was being taken from him, apparently proved in the court that he was entitled to hold that farm in order to carry on his business in the first farm. That seemed to be reasonable enough. It was accepted by everybody and the land was left with him. But what nobody mentioned —and this is where I am surprised at the inspectors of the Land Commission —the man had a third farm a few miles away from the second farm, and there was no reference to it, good, bad or indifferent. I think somebody "pulled a fast one" there and I would ask that the inspectors be a little more careful when they are compiling data for their cases to see to it that somebody does not get away with a "quick one" like that.
I should also like to refer to the question of employment by the Land Commission. For many years, the Land Commission built all their houses and outbuildings by direct labour and, by doing that, produced a very good job. Nobody can deny that the houses built by the Land Commission by direct labour were a very good job, and they stand as a monument to the people who built them. Then, for some unknown reason—I am not prepared to accept the excuse, because it is not an excuse, that there was a shortage of these units—a change-over took place. Some of them were employed on a half contract system where somebody was supplied with a certain amount of material and also paid for it on condition that he had a small portion of machinery. These people were given the contract and proceeded to build the houses. I have no hesitation in saying that some of the houses were a disgrace, not only to the man who built them but also to the Land Commission.
The unfortunate people who came to live in those houses will complain as long as the houses will stay up— and that may not be very long—of the condition in which those houses were handed over to them. There is a classic instance of the porch which fell away from the rest of the house as soon as it started to dry. You could go into the house without going through the door at all. I think any Land Commission inspector who allowed that sort of thing to be carried on was doing a very bad day's work, not alone for the Land Commission but for the people who were getting the land. I appeal to the Minister to see to it that the direct labour system of building houses is started again. I know it has been in some places, but I ask him to extend it and have all the houses built by direct labour, as they were heretofore.
I have a motion down here, which apparently will not be reached for some time, asking for a pension scheme for Land Commission gangers. The normal Land Commission worker is somebody who gets employment while an estate is being developed and then goes out of employment; but the Land Commission ganger is usually a man who travels around from estate to estate, particularly in County Meath, where a lot of land division is taking place at present, and for a long number of years he has been more or less a permanent official. I ask that this man should be considered for a superannuation scheme There is the question of some of these people who have had very long service. I have in mind one case of a man with 14½ years' service. Under the type of superannuation or gratuity which the Land Commission gives at present, those men would qualify after 15 years' service——
Comment on this
I ask the Land Commission to look into it. It would not require legislation to look into the case of employees such as the man I have mentioned. The present system could be extended to cover this man I am talking about who had 14½ years' service and who had his services dispensed with and who cannot find further employment with the Land Commission. If he had had a further six months, he would have qualified, and it is hard on him that he should be pushed out. I want to bring the matter to the Minister's notice and I am sure he will look it up for me.
As far as employment generally is concerned, while we are not entirely satisfied with the system adopted by the Land Commission at the same time we think they have improved. I want to pay one tribute to the Minister in respect of the arrangements he made to have Church holidays substituted for bank holidays in this type of work. That was something which most of the men appreciated. There was also the question of the tea break which is allowed to local authority employees and which is now allowed to Land Commission workers also. I wish to thank the Minister for the way in which these matters were attended to, and I trust that further improvement in the conditions of employment will be granted.
There is one other point. It is generally agreed that St. Stephen's Day is granted as a holiday with pay to practically all employees. Under the present system of substituting Church holidays for bank holidays, the men would not be strictly entitled to that day with pay. Since it is a fact that they do not get what we expected they would get, ten Church holidays per year, because on an average one per year falls on Sunday, I would ask the Minister to use his good offices to have the 26th December substituted for the one which is lost.
I would again make an appeal to the Minister in relation to the drawing up of schemes by the Land Commission. Incidentally I would like to know how soon after an estate is acquired a scheme is drawn up, because very often the day before an estate is allocated the Minister will tell me in the House that no scheme has yet been drawn up and the following morning when I wake up I find that someone has come with a lorry or some other vehicle to take over possession of the land. I know the Land Commission can work very quickly but I do not think they can work overnight.
Comment on this
I would ask that, before any further scheme is drawn up, the Minister would give consideration to the people I have mentioned and see that they do not have the grievances which they genuinely have now. In conclusion may I ask would the Minister be able to say when he is replying how much it costs the Land Commission to bring people from various parts to farms in County Meath before they finally select a tenant to take over these farms? My information is that they have brought people to see some of these farms and in one case more than a dozen people were brought before an applicant finally decided to accept the land. It is rather galling to the local people, who would take it under any conditions, to find these people——
Comment on this
That makes the matter a lot worse.
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister to see that such people are excluded and if Deputy Kennedy is able to give any evidence of such people having £4,000 or £5,000 in their pockets—and I believe he would have that evidence—I would ask that the land be taken from those people and given to the local people who need it and who are crying out for it.
Comment on this
What I wish to say on this Estimate is what I have been saying on it for some considerable time, that the purpose for which the Department of Lands is instituted and for which the Land Commission was set up, that of the relief of congestion and the resettlement of the land of this country, is not being served, or, if it is being served, it is not being served quickly enough. We still have throughout the country this question of congestion. That congestion is not being solved, in my opinion, in the way that it should be solved.
Other speakers here before me this evening have spoken of lands that are published for sale especially in districts where congestion exists, and have stated that despite the fact that these lands come up for public sale, very often the Land Commission do not even seem to be interested in the disposal of such lands. At the same time we find money set aside in order that we may keep in being an organisation that is supposed to go round the country and find out where land can be got, land for resettlement and land on which to put new farmers. While they are being paid to do this and while money is being spent on our inspectors going across the country doing this work, at the same time, and in the same districts in which they are operating, we have farms for sale and the Land Commission are not interested in them. There have been cases where, although the attention of the Land Commission has been drawn to such holdings, they took no action.
If the Land Commission are to do anything and if they are to get anywhere in a reasonable time in the future, then I feel that, in addition to going around and making their own investigations and taking over land that they feel should be taken over, they should also keep their eyes open and see that when a farm is put up for sale it will be taken over for the people in that district. In my own county, there is a great deal of congestion and I know that during the past 12 months, as well as during the past couple of years, the Land Commission have allowed farms, which could have been availed of to resettle these congests who were not far from these lands, to go up for public sale and to be purchased, not always by natives or by people of Irish extraction, but in some cases by foreigners who came in and took over these lands which are so badly needed by the local people.
The Minister and the Land Commission, probably through the Minister, will indicate that nothing like that has happened and that they keep their eyes well open, but I know that it has happened and if they want any further information on it I can give it. I have had occasion in the past to give the Minister, and I am sure, through the Minister, the Land Commission, information about lands for sale, lands in the midst of congested areas, and, despite the fact that they were given notice by me and that there was public notice given in the Press and posters displayed throughout the district, the Land Commission allowed that land to be bought up by somebody who came in from outside. That is not the manner in which the land problem can be settled.
Neither can we regard the present situation, where so much rundale is in existence, as satisfactory. There is still quite a number of holdings held under this rundale system and the Land Commission, in my estimation, could do more, and do it more quickly, to rearrange these holdings. They would thereby not only make the bits of land on the small farms of these people worth something, but, by abolishing the rundale system, by rearranging the holdings and making them compact, they would very often prevent a situation of which many of us in rural Ireland are aware, the situation under which people holding land in rundale are not on good terms, for the reason that it is impossible for them, on mixed holdings, with one bit here and another bit there, not to trample on their neighbours' toes. That could be avoided and much harmony could be created where it does not exist to-day if the Land Commission were a little bit more lively and active in regard to this matter.
I want to bring to the Minister's attention, in regard to the division of land and the giving of land to the different people who qualify, the question already mentioned by Deputy Tully. He spoke of landless men not getting consideration. He spoke of the farm labourer who has worked on an estate that is later taken over by the Land Commission; new farmers or migrants are brought in and the farm labourer is left without any means of livelihood. In the east of my county particularly, in the Lagan Valley, we have a rather unique situation. Not only had we got there, over the years, farm labourers working on estates, which have since been acquired by the Land Commission, who later found themselves without employment, but we also have had—and we still have— some conacre farms. That may seem a queer mixture, but it is the truth.
We have farmers working land in the Lagan Valley for generations, land which their fathers, and in some cases their grandfathers, worked, but they never owned that land and had it only on conacre or year by year letting. Some such cases have arisen, and the Land Commission have come in and taken over that estate and divided it, without giving any consideration to the people I have described, the conacre farmers of long standing, who not only have been working that land but have built up farmsteads of their own and have bought machinery to work the land under conacre. They have found themselves without land since the Land Commission came in and they are no longer in a position to get land by ordinary lettings because the Land Commission has taken the only land available in the locality.
I have raised the matter repeatedly and I am raising it again now. I suggest that, where such men exist as do exist in the Lagan Valley, they should be regarded in the same way as small landowners, and the land they had been working in the past should not be taken from them, without recompense being made to them on some part of the estate. It is entirely unfair and it is creating congestion in the Lagan Valley just as bad as the congestion the Land Commission and the Minister have been trying to relieve in other parts of the county. I see no good purpose being served in taking in congests from the western seaboard of the county and placing them in the eastern parts of the county and in so doing creating unemployment among the residents there. That has happened, and some of the former residents have since had to emigrate.
The Minister and his Department, despite the fact that the case has been repeatedly made to them, still seem to ignore the significance of what it may mean to the people in that part of the country. We still maintain that if the Minister were fully informed, or if he fully realised the situation there, he would not allow the present system to continue but would take in as congests in these localities those who have been tilling the land which their fathers before them tilled but never owned. The Minister should go into this matter once and for all and give these conacre farmers of the Lagan Valley some consideration when these estates come to be divided in the future.
The Minister has in the past talked of rural Ireland as he said, "slipping away from us". He has also said that, if the flight from the land continues, the towns of rural Ireland will become as ghost towns. While the Minister was pretty well right in his statement two years ago, before he became Minister, I should like to say that to-day he is doing very little to remedy the situation which he deplored, and this flight is still continuing. It is not being helped in any way by the slow methods being adopted by the Land Commission and his Department in reallocating or resettling lands in the congested districts of the West.
There is another matter which the Minister, when he was a Deputy, spoke of a couple of years ago. He said that when the Land Commission was taking over land it was never intended to be let in order to help the Department of Finance. If that is so, and if he really believed it then, I should like to know why it is that, under his Department and the Land Commission to-day, land which has been acquired by the Land Commission is still being let year by year, until it has reached the stage already described here earlier when it is no use to the migrants who eventually get that land? It has been tilled year after year, the heart taken out of it, nothing put back, and, by the time the new owners or tenants arrive, they would be better off if they had stayed where they were.
That system is still going on despite the fact that the Minister, when he spoke as a Deputy two years ago, criticised it and said it was never intended it should operate. Yet, under his jurisdiction, and under his own Department, it is still going on, and land is being spoiled for those who will come to tenant it later on. It would be far better, in the case where the land cannot be divided the year after it is taken over, that it should lie derelict rather than be misused by those who take it to exploit it for 11 months of the year. The Minister should give heed to his own criticism of two years ago, now that he is in a position where he can stop that letting of land held by the Land Commission. He should put his foot down, if he believes to-day what he then believed —that there should be no more lettings.
Candidly, I do not think that the long term lettings that are evident throughout the country under the Land Commission are necessary. The Land Commission will hold on and will explain to the House that they have got to hold on to one bit of land in order to get several other bits or parcels to try to do a good job. In the meantime, those waiting for that land, the sons of the small farmers nearby, have got tired waiting and have left the country. The only people who will be looking for that land will be the old men who were young men when they started looking for it. That is not a policy that is going to help this country in regard to its land resettlement problem. It will not help a number of people to find a living on the land, and it does not very much improve the system of many years ago, when it was the landlords rather than the Land Commission who held the land.
Candidly, the people I have mentioned earlier, the conacre farmers of Donegal, were much better off before the Land Commission took over. Many of them have now gone away and are not coming back, because there is nothing for them to come back to, as the land has been taken away. They have much to thank the Land Commission for, but they must remember, and I am sure they will remember, that it was the working of the Land Commission that deprived them of the land which their fathers and forefathers had worked.
The Minister should listen to this side of the story and not regard it as just a fairytale. The facts are there and I am sure, if he inquires from his local inspectors in Donegal, he will find out what I have said is true. Unfortunately, I have had occasion to say this to the Minister last year and I said it back in the previous period of Coalition Government, but it had no effect. I am hoping, as this is the last chance I will have with the present Minister as Minister for Lands, or Minister for anything else, that he will make an effort to do something for these people before he leaves office.
The position that is created by bringing migrants from the West of the country into the Midlands has been discussed by the last speaker in a critical manner. While we have land in my county for division, we are also one of the counties from which many of the migrants have gone to the Midlands, and all I can say, having met them and talked to them and to members of their families since they have gone there, is, as has already been said, that they have been well received, generally speaking, in the Midlands.
It is true, as the Deputy said, that there are local men who are deprived of a livelihood as a result of the farms or estates being taken over. Those men in the Midlands, just as the men in the east of my own county, should be given consideration, even though it may be that to some extent I am talking against the number of migrants of my own county in regard to the better lands. I think that, if people are deprived of their livelihood, those are the people who should be given first consideration. There is no point in relieving congestion in Donegal, Mayo, Galway or Kerry, if you are going to create a similar situation in the Midlands. Satisfy the local demand first and, when you have satisfied that demand, you can tackle that other problem.
I should think that the people living along the seaboard, with their tradition of little land down through the years, are in a better position to carry on than will be the new congests created when they move into the Midlands and displace those people who have been working the land. The Minister should deal fairly with all concerned.
I should like to point out to the Minister that at the moment in one district alone, where there is very great congestion, in the west of my county, no fewer than seven people with very small holdings have their applications before the Land Commission for a considerable time for two or three farms that are available in the east of the county. Those half-dozen people are willing to give up the smallholdings they have and take the farms available in the east of the county, but months and, in some cases, two years have passed and those people are still asking whether they are going to get the farms in the estate or not. Should they emigrate, as they are now being forced to do, or wait on for another while?
The situation is really becoming critical so far as those people are concerned. They are waiting for the promised land and the promised land is not being given to them. Their own holdings are there. There are very bad houses which they would be tending to-day if they knew they were not going to get any improvement in their farms. They have not been building all those years because they were waiting for the farms which were promised them in the east of the county. Yet, in spite of all that, we hear of the scarcity of land and here we have this situation in our midst at the moment.
I ask the Minister to take particular note of the applications of several farmers from a district known as Aughterlinn in the north-west of Donegal. I think there are six applicants for a farm in the east of the county, in the Lagan Valley. They have been kept on a string for six months, 12 months and, in some cases, two years. It is about time the Department or the Land Commission made up their minds whether they are going to have these farms or not. If they are not, the people can find their own methods for dealing with the situation; if they are, they should have been put in them long ago.
The Minister, so far as I can gather, goes to greater length to justify everything that is done by the Land Commission than he does in regard to getting something worth while done. Day after day, questions are put down by Deputies from all parts of the country in regard to whether such and such a holding is to be taken over or not. No matter what the question relates to, the one stock answer is that the Minister has no function in the matter.
Apparently the Minister has no function in the matter and yet, when he goes down the country and gets down to his own constituency at the weekend, we read pronouncements made by him about how all-powerful he is as a Minister and the great work that he, as a Minister, has done in this Government and did in the last Government of which he was a member. I suggest that the power he says he has on a Sunday should be taken back by him to Dublin on the Monday and used. If it is his business to decide the policy of the Government in regard to the acquisition and division of land, then he cannot sit back day after day and repeat the same answer that that is a function of the Land Commission and that it is taboo, so far as he is concerned.
That is what the Minister has been doing and nothing he may say on Sundays or at week-ends can relieve him of that blame. He is to blame to a large extent because he allows the Land Commission to do as they like. I am afraid that what they like is not what satisfies very many of us in this House. The Minister's pronouncements are much different from the policy pursued by the Land Commission. The policy pursued by the Land Commission is much slower than the policy the Minister says he stands for. If he is the boss, then he should let the Land Commission know he is the boss and get on with the work.
I can see no future for the speeding-up of land division in this country while we have a Minister sitting across from us on the other side of the House who says one thing on a Sunday and swallows it all for the remainder of the following week. If he is going to dictate his policy to the Land Commission and get them to do the job quickly, expeditiously and economically, then he should lay down the law for the people in the Land Commission. I am sure that the Land Commission would be only too glad if they could get a lead from the Minister.
I am coming to the conclusion that one of the reasons why the Land Commission are not getting on more quickly with the job at the moment is that the Minister blows hot and cold. He says one thing to-day and another thing to-morrow. The Land Commission have not got a direct lead from him. If they had, they might go a little quicker. Maybe it is that their whole outlook is the outlook of the Civil Service generally: make haste slowly, lest you might do any damage. I cannot blame them for that, and I do not blame them, but I blame the Minister.
I suggest to the Minister that the placing of landless men who have been working land on an estate is something he should take full cognisance of. The rundale system which is still being operated is something that must be got rid of, for the various reasons I have already stated. If we are to do anything about the congestion on the western seaboard particularly, it should be done now. The amount of relief that we are giving by migration and the resettling of migrants elsewhere in the country is not sufficient to make itself felt in these badly congested areas. We are not doing enough quickly enough in that respect. If we do not do it, we are going to find, as the Minister, when a Deputy, said a couple of years ago, that the towns of the West will become ghost towns and rural Ireland a depopulated desert, with a return to the ranchers and decay. I think those were his own words a couple of years ago, and they could be well applied to the situation existing to-day.
That situation has not improved. If anything, it has disimproved. There are fewer people on the land to-day than there were two years ago. If the present situation continues, there is no question that, in another two years' time, there will be still fewer and, in a very short time, the Minister's own prediction, made in 1954, will become a fact. The towns in the West will be without population and will become ghost towns, with the grass growing up through the streets. The Minister, as Deputy McQuillan said, is the one man in the Government who can do a good day's work in regard to this matter. We on this side of the House consider that he is not doing it.
Nothing he may say by way of a speech outside this House is going to relieve him of that burden. He is not doing his work as it should be done, he is not fulfilling the function of the Minister for Lands in this Government, he is not giving direction and dictation to those under him who should be the servants of the people. He is not showing the way and, since he is not, it is very difficult to expect those servants to do the job as well as they should if he were directing it. He does not appear as if he wished to do his work.
There was a typical attitude taken up by the Minister here to-day when a Deputy made a suggestion that might be helpful. The suggestion was made by Deputy McQuillan, who said that in future nobody should be allowed to hold more than 300 acres of land or land of a greater valuation than £120. What does the Minister do? He accuses Deputy McQuillan of saying that in future no holding should be taken over of less than 300 acres or of a valuation less than £120. He took that useful suggestion of the Deputy and turned it around; instead of taking heed of what the Deputy had said and what might be helpful to him in future, he tried to score some political point against someone, who appears to be his opponent in the western counties, by reversing the entire idea of the whole suggestion and pointing out that this suggestion, as turned around by the Minister, would in effect retard land acquisition. That, I think, is typical of the Minister's attitude. The sooner he gets away from that idea of trying to twist ideas and never accepting new ideas from anybody except someone from his own Party, the sooner he will learn how to manage his Department and the Land Commission, and get on to do some useful work.
I have nothing further to add except to say that we here, from rural Ireland in particular, are sick and tired of the Department of Lands and the Land Commission and the manner in which they handle this question. We feel that some change for the better is definitely called for. We are asking and even hoping, though it is a rather forlorn hope I know, that even under this Minister we will get some action and get the land divided and resettled in reasonable time. It is the hope of every Deputy who ever came into this House to see this problem solved in his time, but I am afraid that many of us are becoming rather cynical and forced into the view that this problem will never be solved in our time. I, for one, am one of those people who, coming from a congested county, feel that with the present set-up and lack of direction from the present Minister the Land Commission is ineffective for the job it was set up to do. It is swaddling itself around with so much red tape that it is settling down slower and slower, and the Land Commission and the Department of Lands and the Minister for Lands are no use.
The Minister might as well still be examining the growing of trees across in Scandinavia as sitting in this House. He is just as useful there as he is here. No direction comes from him when he is at home, and I am sure we would not say a word to him if he had stayed there still longer if, perhaps, he could learn something from the Scandinavians that might be useful in the future. We would be very satisfied if those people could have got something across to the Minister, because everything we have tried to give him here of a useful nature is always regarded by him with a smile as something to be turned around until it appears to be useless or worthless or ridiculous. This attitude of the Minister is of little use in solving the problem which is becoming desperate throughout the West—the problem of congestion.
Comment on this
This is certainly a most important Department, the most important we have in the country, and I am satisfied that it does valuable work. There is no doubt about it that the Minister has one of the most thankless tasks of any Minister, because no matter what he does he will be criticised. Valuable work has been done under the Land Commission, but much of it could be better done. Undoubtedly, taking a review of the last 25 or 30 years, we must say that the resettlement of the people on the land is advancing stage by stage, but, though a great deal of good has been done for the country, the rate of advancement of the Land Commission is too slow. This resettlement of land should have been completed long ago. It should have been completed in the course of 20 years.
I come from one of the areas in the very centre of the land of the Pale where Cromwell and his followers did their foul deeds. Standing there to-day and looking round on the new holdings springing up there over the years, I feel quite happy that in my part of Leinster we are undoing the conquest. As Deputies know, a vast amount of the migration from the West and the North and the South comes into County Meath. We have our grievances, but we are satisfied, to be honest, seeing these people in our midst settling down and working their new homes. We are quite happy as they are a national asset and working wholeheartedly in co-operation with the Meath people to make the best of their holdings. We are proud of them, and of the Meath men who have settled down also.