Committee on Finance. - Vote 47—Lands.
Contributions 145–309 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
It is undoubtedly, and 15 or 20 years ago I would not have made that statement, because I believe that we had a Meath situation to settle first. I do say that at the present moment, although the Minister is doing good work, he should give more attention to seeing that the uneconomic holders of those counties into which migrants are brought should get first consideration. There are many uneconomic holders passed over, and I do not know why. There are good and useful men with seven, eight or ten acres of land and there is no reason why they should not have got 25 or 30 acres and the same chance as the people coming in.
Taking it all in all, the Land Commission is doing good and useful work. It makes no difference whether Governments come in or go out. It is my belief that the same policy operates right through. There is no use in lambasting this or any other Minister. I lambasted the Fianna Fáil Minister when he was in power, and the present Minister, but at the same time I find that they are working within the Acts we have given them from this House, and as long as they work within them there is little we can do or say.
Only a few days ago, we read on the papers of the census taken, and were alarmed at the emigration of our people from all areas. That is an alarming situation which this or any other Government must face. Something that I would call big and gigantic must be done. I believe that one of the things that can be done is speedier work in land resettlement. It may be that we have not the money from term to term to carry out a bigger programme of resettlement, but the Land Commission, from the time they take over an estate, hold it too long. I know estates in my county which the Land Commission took over, four, five or six years ago, and I count that criminal, because it is criminal to see them setting them in some cases in conacre for wheat. Perhaps a great conacre rancher comes in and takes that land, works the very heart out of it for three or four years, and leaves it like a dust bowl. Those people who get it afterwards are expected to bring it back to full fertility, sometimes with very little in their pocket by way of capital. It is criminal when that happens. I ask the Land Commission when they take over a holding to divide it and have proper resettlement in the speediest possible way.
I and other Deputies from my own county have year after year been drawing attention to the many men who come into this country and buy, perhaps by telephone, large tracts of land—estates of anything from 500 up to 1,000 acres. The Land Commission should be more alive to that situation. In County Meath, there are many men who came in here—speculators, if you like, some of whom came from Pakistan and some from England—and bought large tracts of land. We were told, when they came, that they were in the bloodstock industry and would be an asset to the country. They certainly brought a few old nags with them, but we find that they stocked the land with whitehead bullocks. I do not believe in that sort of thing.
Beside where I live, 200 to 400 acres are being worked by about two men. It is criminal. There is the Drumlargan estate at my own door. Four years ago, that estate gave employment to two men and a boy. There are about 250 Irish acres of perhaps the best land in Europe in that estate. It changed hands a few years ago, notwithstanding the fact that the Land Commission inspectors walked it and re-walked it. The people were happy that it was to be taken over and that resettlement would take place. That was not the case. A bigger man from some other part of the country came in and offered almost twice what the Land Commission were offering and got that large estate. I would not worry about that, if employment were given. The position is that there is one herd employed. The people who bought the land never come to see it from one end of the year to the other. I regard it as criminal on the part of the Land Commission that they allowed that to happen. That estate could have provided holdings for 12 farmers. It would make all the difference in this denuded, unpopulated area if that estate were taken over and divided amongst people, irrespective of where they came from. I would ask the Minister to take a special note of that estate.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not mention individuals by name or in such a way that they might be recognised.
Comment on this
Right beside that estate there is another estate of 300 acres where there are about three people employed. There is not the slightest hope of a man working a plough on these estates. Green grass is growing there and the whiteheads are grazing on them. At the same time, our young people are emigrating to England.
There is no reason why that should be allowed to happen. It is no wonder that the census showed what it did. Big speculators are being allowed to come in here and take over these vast tracts while there are boats going in the other direction taking scores of farmers' sons who are emigrating to earn a living in another land. These people are entitled to a living in their own land, and they can get that living in their own land if we do the right thing, that is, divide the land amongst the Irish people and let the people settle down and marry and be of some use to their own country.
The same thing happened in Dunshaughlin. A body calling itself a limited company bought 300 or 400 acres of land. They were not satisfied with that. Every holding for miles around that was put up for auction or in respect of which the owner was glad to get a good price was bought up by this limited company. They bought up practically the whole area of land half way from Dunshaughlin to Navan. That is a crying shame. We will be told that it is good for the cattle trade, that these people are exporting a vast amount of cattle. They are, but I would like to know what they are doing with the money they are getting in return. Is it being invested in this country? Is it being ploughed back into the land or into the area from which a large number of young men have to fly? It is not. It is invested in every part of the world, except Ireland.
I ask the Minister to concentrate on seeing that those large estates are immediately taken over and divided. I do not want any of those estates wiped out. When I see a man with 500, 600 or 800 acres which is not half worked, I realise that there is work there for the Land Commission to do.
I raised the question of another estate here last year by question in the Dáil. I also interviewed the Minister. It is the Dunsany estate.
Comment on this
It is not the practice in this House to mention individuals. Individuals have no way of replying.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied that this estate has been walked by an inspector of the Land Commission. That inspector went back and made a report to the Land Commission that it was worked with good husbandry and that there was no waste land on it. I am quite satisfied, and so are the public, that there are at least 300 acres of this estate that can be immediately taken over in the interest of this country, because it is almost derelict. Since I raised that question in the Dáil, a vast amount of that estate was set in conacre, and about 300 acres of wheat are being planted on it by a man who owns almost as much land as is comprised in that estate.
I regard that as a crying shame, when at the same time in County Meath the Land Commission are prying into other people's affairs. Where a man has 50 or 60 acres of an outlying small farm, they are doing everything they can to acquire it. Why do they not pare down the large estates? They must realise that the owners of these estates were put there by Cromwell. You can trace their ancestors right back. In every ditch along the estates, there are the bones of our ancestors who had to fly or suffer the holocaust. It is only right and fair, now that we have our national freedom, that we should undo that conquest.
It seems to be the position that any decent Irishman who has an outlying holding must surrender it. Why are we afraid to face these things? These people cannot squirm at what happens to them. They will get the full market value. I will not be satisfied until I see these large estates, which were Cromwellian settlements, pared down to reasonable dimensions. I say: Leave them 300 acres, but, after that, take all the outlying land they have and divide it amongst the people. There should be no quibbling about it. Are we afraid to do those things? If we are, we are not worthy of being Irish freemen. It is a problem that has remained unsolved for scores of years and, as far as I see, the Land Commission will skirt miles away from these large estates before they will do anything.
I ask the Minister, who has his heart in the resettlement of our people, to get after the job immediately and not to take any answers when his inspector comes along with a report which I would say was a false report. I do not mean that the inspector made a false report, but I know he was led up the garden path in many cases. It was very unfair that he had to make that report.
Comment on this
I said that I did not. It was not he who made the false report, but he was led up the garden path when he went in to inspect these estates.
Comment on this
No, not the Minister. The inspector who was sent down to get the report was led up the garden path. Perhaps he was led into the lounge and got a good glass of wine. I expect these things do happen.
Comment on this
In connection with North Meath, Deputy Tully raised the matter of the Beltrasna estate and he almost said here—he had to withdraw it—that Deputy Hilliard and I were quite satisfied with the division of that estate. We are not by any means satisfied with it. The Oldcastle area is a very congested area and the Beltrasna estate should have gone to the relief of congestion in North Meath. What was the position? The position was that a fair number of men got allotments of land, but migrants got a vast slice of that land—I think about 150 acres.
I know the man who got the last settlement. I do not blame him for getting it. I think he came from Kerry. I am satisfied he is a splendid type of man and that he will make good, but surely the Minister could have placed him in South Meath, where there are tens of thousands of acres of land. It is criminal that that fine young man was brought to the Beltrasna area and given a holding there. The local people have nothing against the man personally, but four or five people already in the area wanted land and were not given it. That Beltrasna estate could be eaten up by congests.
The Minister should proceed cautiously in this matter. North Meath is almost as congested as many parts of Mayo, where he lives. That should not have happened, and it happened only a few short months ago. The young man in question is a fine type, but you know what the position is like when he is not wanted. There is bitterness there, not alone against the man, but against the Minister and the Deputies. If the Minister had placed that young man in South Meath, where there are thousands of acres and where there is room for him, he would be well received and he could live in happiness amongst his neighbours. The area in which the young man was placed is congested. In future, the Minister should bear in mind that the North Meath area stretching roughly from Athboy to Drumconrath or Meath Hill is a congested area. The Minister could carry out much resettlement there. There are men in that area holding three or four small fields scattered here and there and surely there could be a resettlement there, so as to make the people happy and comfortable.
Fifteen or 20 years ago, I think the Land Commission used to give 22 statute acres of land. That was a shortsighted policy. I saw that happen all around me. I saw people getting land, and from 19 to 22 statute acres were the limit. It is criminal to expect a man to live on that. The result is that such men are neither farmers nor workers. I know thousands of them. They are not able to make a decent living out of such a small acreage and all they can do is watch for the first work they can get. They are working for the Forestry Department and the county council practically the whole year round, and not working on their holdings.
That is a most unfortunate state of affairs. A man who gets a farm of land should get enough to enable him and his family to live there and, if possible, to give employment to a neighbour. In some areas where there are large colonies of migrants—there are about 12 beside myself—trying to eke out on 19 statute acres, it is obvious that they are finding it impossible to make a living on their holdings. Up to now, they were able to avail of the 11 months system and take perhaps 15 or 20 acres that might have been going in the area. However, as land division is closing in on them, and no 11 months system, they have to go to England or try to get work on the roads, or at forestry, and so on. A farmer should work his own holding and it should be big enough to keep him there.
In the past five or six years, the size of holdings has increased to, I think, 35 statute acres. In my view, they are not big enough yet and it is unwise to adopt as a pattern a unit of 35 statute acres. There should be a new and original idea in land resettlement. There should be large holdings, middle-size holdings and small holdings and the small holdings should surround a large holding. I understand that in Italy they had a scheme some years ago whereby large estates were divided up and there was a 300-acre holding in the centre, with smaller holdings surrounding it. The larger holding was able to buy the produce of the smaller holdings and there was a satisfactory economy there. With a pattern of 35 statute acres, or thereabouts, you will have a slum or congestion in the area in a few short years. It is a bad system.
I hope that in the future the Minister will tend to increase the size of the holdings. I believe such a step would be in the interest of the country as a whole. It is shocking to think of a man whose holding is such that he is neither a farmer nor a labourer. We have enough unemployment in the country without letting those people get into the pool of work. They should have enough work to do on their own holdings, but they will not do that with 22 statute acres.
In Meath, you must live by the land and the land alone. There is nothing else there for you. Something should be done about landless men and farmers' sons. Some of these men are fine types, but, under the Land Acts, there is no hope for them. Nowadays, many farmers send their sons to agricultural colleges. They give them a fair amount of education on the technique of agriculture. It is unfortunate to see these young men leaving the college after they have been trained and having to go across the water to earn a livelihood as there is nothing here for them. The Land Commission should keep some of these students— not all of them—in mind and should give some of them a holding on the large estates. These students could apply their knowledge of modern agricultural methods there and set an example to the people on the remaining holdings. They could settle down in the area as agricultural instructors. They would be an incentive and an example to those living around them and much good work could be done by having the right men in the right place.
In County Meath, we Deputies have a hard time. Scores and scores of the finest young farmers' sons living on 30 to 40 acres of land must get out. There is not the slightest hope that either they or their parents will be able to purchase a farm of land there to-day, because the highest they would be able to go would be £1,000 or £1,500, and they would have to raise the most of that. In County Meath, the first bid now for a farm is about £3,000 and these people have not a hope from the very start. They are leaving the country by the score. Twenty or 30 years ago, it was almost unknown that a man would migrate from County Meath. An old person might go to America, and that was all. At present, however, the emigration from my county is just as large as it is from Connemara, Mayo or Kerry. That is a very serious state of affairs. These men in my county are completely excluded from anything that is going. I am not against bringing in migrants, because I realise that that is national policy, but I feel that something should be done to cater for the people who are already there and who need help.
Land division is national policy; we must accept that fact and we do accept it. I would, however, ask the Minister to bring a little vision into this whole matter and see that something new is done. After 30 years of native Government, what is the position? Changes of Government do not seem to make any difference to the vast number of the best types of our people who must leave our country to seek a living elsewhere. Bear in mind that frequently it is the manliest type who seeks his living abroad. He says: "If I cannot make a living at home, I will make a living abroad" and, rather than remain idle at home, he emigrates. There is a living for thousands of such people in County Meath, if we would spend the money there and tear down the large estates and give them full market value. Then no one would whimper. Think of an estate of 1,500 acres. At least 500 acres of that are waste, growing nothing but furze bushes, blackthorn and sedge grasses of all kinds that not even an ass would eat. Why should the men who own these estates worry? Most of them are what we call the "gentry". Some of them have British Army pensions and some of them are getting their shares from gold mines and every other kind of mine abroad. They live on that. They are lords of their big estates, 500 or 600 acres of which have gone wild. I say it is criminal to leave these lands untouched. This is a small country in which we cannot afford to waste a single acre, even the land on the roadsides.
What do the Land Commission think they are doing, flying around the country looking for small bits of land here and there while there are these big tracts going wild? It is hard on the small farmers who have spent their lives working hard for their country to see this kind of thing happen. We cannot go inside the gates of these big fellows, but I hope to see their gates open before long and the large acres done away with. It is my belief there is a Masonic influence at work somewhere and that it is at work in high circles and low circles, making these "gents" immune. These lads live in their mansions while their estates are immune from confiscation. I should not use the word "confiscation". We do not believe in confiscation; we pay for the land we take to the last penny.
My advice to the Minister is that he should take this land and have a proper resettlement. There is too much hugger-mugger going on. It went on during the reign of the first, the second, the third and the fourth Governments we have had. It is nothing but cowardice. As I said, there is a Masonic influence at work which must be smashed. These people came in here and, by telephone, were able to buy their 1,500 acres. You will see them coming on horseback or in their big high-powered cars once a year. The decent, hard-working farmers have to raise their hats to them. The day is gone for that kind of thing. It is in the province of the Land Commission to change that position, but they are not doing it. They are cowardly about it. I ask them to do it in future and give our farmers a chance to enjoy the freedom that was achieved by such great sacrifice.
There is one matter which I have been raising for the past three or four years. It concerns the exchange of an old I.R.A. man named Patrick Mulvaney who lives in my constituency. He was listed for exchange and was allotted a farm in the Ashbourne area. He was told to be ready to go there, but, when he eventually went, he found another migrant in possession of the farm allotted to him. I ask the Minister to go fully into that question and to give justice to this man. He is fully entitled to the exchange which he was promised. His exchange would do a lot of good in the area in which he lives, because there is considerable congestion in the vicinity. He is a man who gave splendid service to his country, a man of fine physique, a good farmer and an excellent worker. Three or four other farmers in the locality were fortunate enough to get exchanges. They were Fianna Fáil supporters and I suppose they had more influence than this man, because Fianna Fáil were in power. This man belongs to our side and I want the Minister to see that justice is done for him. The other three got good holdings.
Comment on this
There is no copying about it. It is only justice. This man has all the credentials. His land is needed in the congested area in which he lives. He is a good man. He lost about £400 waiting for the exchange. He was told he would be given the exchange in April or May. He did not plough his land that year and when he went to the other holding he found it was already allotted. Consequently, he lost all his crops for that year because it was too late to plough.
In connection with vested cottages, the Minister told us he would reconsider the whole position. There are many very good men living in vested cottages who are entitled to a full holding or to accommodation plots. Many of them have cows which they keep either on the sides of the road or with neighbours. When they live on the boundary of a divided estate, they are surely entitled to a piece of land. If they got seven or eight acres each, it would make all the difference in the world to their comfort, to the happiness of their homes and to the economy of the country. I do not expect the Land Commission to give land to every cottier because there are many of them who would not work it. I suggest, however, that when the commission comes across good, thrifty, honest men, who will be in a position to stock and work seven or eight acres, they should not be passed over. There are three or four of them living beside me and I ask the Minister to pay particular attention to them. They live beside an estate to be divided. It will be unfair and criminal if they are passed over. They are rooted there for generations.
In conclusion, I say to the Land Commission, though I have struck hard at them, that the problems facing us are big ones. They must be faced up to and the Land Commission should not be afraid of attacking the estates bought by telephone by Indian princes and maharajahs of all types. I would like a good man with 300 acres to be allowed to keep that land. Such a man must work in order to keep that land. He is not a man who will be skedaddling around the country to every race-and dog-track. But the people who own the large estates never see their land at all, even though they may live in a mansion within the estate. They have stewards and assistant stewards. The man living on 300 acres will need no steward. He will not be a man who can afford to take time off. I tell the Land Commission not to delay about this matter any further. If the Minister has not the money, let him come to the House and we will give it to him in order that proper land resettlement may be carried out and that our country may be stocked by people living in happiness and working in the interests of Ireland.
Comment on this
The burden of the debate on this Estimate has veered very strongly towards the question of the division and the sub-division of land. Much emphasis has been placed on the apparent neglect of the congested areas in the West. It is a difficult problem to find land to meet the reasonable requirements of all the people in Ireland who are applicants and who can show good and justifiable reasons why they should be considered. All applications for land cannot be met since the acreage available is limited. I suggest the position could be alleviated somewhat by an alteration of the present policy in relation to the acquisition of land for forestry purposes. A good deal of the land taken over for forestry could be rendered suitable for agricultural production, if well prepared, drained and manured. Many such areas have in the past maintained quite a dense population at a time when the cultivation of land was nothing like as scientific as it is to-day. If that land could be put into proper condition, surface drained and fenced, many people would be prepared to work it rather than migrate or emigrate.
I think the Minister realises that the anxiety to procure land for afforestation is in excess of reason. Down in my own county, the Forestry Branch took over a large tract of land. Representations were made to the Minister and, so impressed was he by the case made in support of utilising that land for agricultural purposes, that he insisted upon the Land Commission resuming the land for the enlargement of uneconomic holdings in the area. Seeing that the Minister himself has had experience of that inordinate desire on the part of the Forestry Branch to acquire land, thereby taking it out of agricultural production, I suggest that he should go further and insist on the exercise of greater caution in the taking over of land for afforestation, land which can be used for agricultural production.
The experts of the Department of Agriculture are available to advise in that respect. They are also available to advise the farmers in the different areas as to the best method of utilising second class and third class land for agricultural production. That would be a much cheaper policy to implement than the present policy of wholesale migration from one area to another. Since there is not enough land available to meet the requirements of all the people, the present unsatisfactory position can, I suggest, be alleviated to a great extent by putting this poorer land into good heart and making it fit for agricultural production. I speak with personal knowledge and practical experience of the lands in question.
There is another matter which I should mention at this juncture. Many smallholders are living in very poor circumstances — families where the fathers are dead, where there are only a few girls or perhaps aged people unable to use the land to its best advantage. They have not the necessary funds with which to provide themselves with proper living accommodation. They are not numerous, but there are a few in practically every district. The Land Commission should step in and provide these people with suitable houses, making the houses a charge upon the lands. I see no reason why that scheme should not be put into operation. The labourer is entitled to a cottage at the expense of the ratepayers; the farmer, who is in reasonable circumstances, can get substantial grants; and even the business man and the professional man are catered for. These people to whom I refer, living in the most pitiable conditions, have no one to come to their rescue. I think the Land Commission should step in. They control the lands and they are the best people to handle the situation. It is in that spirit I make the recommendation.
Listening to the points of view expressed in relation to migration, one realises that the Minister is faced with a very difficult task, because every speaker speaks with his own interest in view. The views expressed are, indeed, very contradictory. We had Deputy James Tully here this evening talking about the congestion in his area and saying that it was not right to bring in outsiders. Who are outsiders? I suggest to Deputy Tully that, if he studies the record and the heritage of the people he has in mind in County Meath, he will find that their title is very, very short indeed as compared with the title of those who come from the West of Ireland.
Nobody has a claim to the land of this country. The fact that one lives on a farm does not mean that one is the owner of that land. No man has an absolute ownership to land. It belongs to the State.
Comment on this
The Deputy is looking for my concurrence in something he has said, and I am not giving it.
Comment on this
The Minister is not very generous in many respects. As a Christian Minister for Lands, he should know that it is the law of the Church as defined by the bishops that no person has absolute ownership in land. It is given by God to the State to be used for the needs of the people and no man has an absolute right to it in the same way as he has to the suit of clothes he wears or the pair of boots on his feet. It is to be maintained from generation to generation and used for the benefit of the nation only. Therefore, no man living in a particular county has any greater claim to the land in that county than the man living in some other part of the country. It belongs to the nation. No individual claim exists, and the fact that a man lives in closer proximity to land than others living some miles away does not give him a greater claim to that land. The Minister should know these elementary things, seeing that he is in charge of such a responsible office. He should know and there should be some test applied to men in your position——
Comment on this
——to you, anyway, to see that you have some qualification for filling the job you have, as otherwise you will not shoulder your responsibilities in a proper way and in a Christian manner. Again and again, I had cause to complain about these things. I asked the Minister some time ago to give me the figures as to the number of migrants taken from each county over the period during which he was in office, and he refused to give me this information. He said I was trying to create bad feeling and unpleasantness between the different counties.
I would draw the Minister's attention to a diagram that he has on the wall of this building—a map showing the conditions in parts of Mayo two or three years ago and the conditions today, since his new scheme of readjustment of farms has taken place. Undoubtedly, there is a great improvement there and the Minister must be complimented on it; but, by way of contrast with the improved conditions in Mayo, he shows us another country, Switzerland, where similar sized farms still remain the same.
Comment on this
I showed a rearrangement scheme in Ireland and a rearrangement scheme in Switzerland.
Comment on this
A rearrangement scheme in Mayo—that was the only county I saw. I would ask the Minister to learn that the whole of Ireland is one unit and that Mayo does not constitute the whole of the country.
Comment on this
Why not show, side by side with Mayo, what is being done in every other county, instead of giving us a contrast with Switzerland and leaving out neighbouring counties for which the Minister has done nothing? That is the most vexatious, nonsensical and idiotic thing that could be done by any man with any sense of responsibility in any country.
The Minister has refused to give the information which it is his duty to give. He has no right to withhold information about the spending of public money. The Minister is not the owner of the money, no more than he is the owner of any farm of land, although he thought he was. The Minister now thinks he can use public money for the individual interests of Mayo and to his advantage, as far as he may seek to get advantage from the work done. I give the Minister credit for effecting a big improvement in Mayo. Occasionally when I take up a paper, I am met with a photograph showing a number of migrants being taken at the expense of the Land Commission to some place in the Midlands. Nearly always they are Mayo men. There is not a man from the West of Ireland who has spoken here this evening who has not condemned the Minister and the Minister's system because it is an outrageous reflection that the Minister should concentrate public money to the benefit of the people of Mayo and to the disadvantage of other counties.
Comment on this
Did the Minister not refuse to answer the question I submitted to him to give me figures in regard to migration and the amount of public money spent in other counties besides Mayo? Why did the Minister not give me the figures I asked for? Is he not the Minister in charge of lands? I am entitled to know what he intends to do with public money in respect of his Department. The fact is that we have reached a position where something must be done to stop this abuse and squandering—I will go as far as saying misappropriation—of public moneys in so far as the Minister has refused to give a public account of this expenditure in this House to which he is responsible. There must be some reason why the Minister is withholding these figures.
Deputies from the congested areas know that nothing has been done by the Minister to improve their lot. I have no desire to be unpleasant to the Minister. He is a nice, cheerful man, with good intentions, but his attitude in his capacity as Minister for Lands is something that is intolerable. Again, I ask him could he tell me what are his plans for migration, if any, for people from the West of Ireland, county by county? There is no use telling me that it will create disturbed minds and bitter feelings if he gives me figures for any county in the West of Ireland.
Comment on this
The reason I cannot give the Deputy figures out of my head is that I am not a prophet. I am just an ordinary individual like anybody else and I have no powers of prophecy.
Comment on this
The Minister is two years in office now and surely he must know what he has done in the last two years?
Comment on this
The Minister must surely have some indication of what he is going to do in the future? One does not commence work without a plan.
Comment on this
Our plan is to relieve congestion; but how many tenants will accept what we will offer them next year is something I cannot tell the Deputy.
Comment on this
There should be a degree of broad-mindedness and frankness, but I am afraid the Minister has not measured up to that. There is no use in answering me with a short, quick, witty answer——
Comment on this
My question was a clear and direct question and it should receive a similar answer. There are hundreds, maybe thousands, of applications coming in to the Land Commission year after year for exchange of holdings, migration or otherwise. These people have their plans to make for their future and the Land Commission should be able to say to these people when they make application: "Our commitments at present will not allow of your being dealt with in the next 12 months or two years." Let them make their own provision if they wish to remain on; but to refuse to say in advance that there is no prospect of dealing with them is not the proper way of dealing with people planning for their future.
The Minister's method is not conducive to any hope and I do not see there is much we can do about it. It has reached an intolerable position. We in the West will have our duty to do and I, for one, will take the opportunity of telling the people in my constituency that I can see no prespect for an improvement in, or an amelioration of, their condition. If they tell me that they see other people being migrated, I will say that I have done my best, that I have spoken to the Minister about it and all I can say is: "Get busy and see that that Department is properly managed and is run in the future on a more just and equitable basis than it has been in the past." I will tell them the circumstances and let them judge.
From a selfish point of view, this may react very favourably on the Minister in regard to his own constituency; but in a general way there will be a reflection on the Government because the Government are ultimately responsible for the Minister's action. That being so, there is a responsibility on the Minister to let the people in the congested areas know what their prospects of migration are. I definitely assert that the bulk of migration in the past two years has been from Mayo. I would say that there were not five migrants from County Leitrim in those two years, and the need for migration there is just as great as it is in Mayo.
From what I hear stated here by the Meath Deputies, migration is still alive and going strong. I thought it had ceased; but it is going on steadily in a big way. I would ask the Minister to be more careful and more tolerant in his manner of dealing with these affairs, and not to consider that Mayo is the one and only county that has to be dealt with. Deputy Giles stated that the migrants who came from the West of Ireland were a credit to the part of the country they came from, that they were doing great work and showed an example to the people in the area to which they were migrated. He mentioned other estates there of sizes ranging from 300 to 3,000 acres that had been bought by foreigners and used by them for the purpose of ranching, and said that side by side with those were a number of congested farmers who badly needed land. That is an extraordinary statement and one to which I am sure the Minister will reply when he is concluding the debate. If that statement is correct, it will have a very disturbing effect on many farmers who are content to carry on as best they can if they feel that no land is available but who, if they hear that land to which they have a claim is being bought up by foreigners and used by them for the purpose of making money, while they themselves are in an extreme state of need, will demand that strong measures be taken to combat that and bring it to a close.
Quite a number of farms of moderate size and otherwise have been offered to the Land Commission by farmers in Leitrim, who are becoming tired of the constant struggle, who despair of the future and are emigrating. They have offered their land to the Land Commission and while there are many small-holders in the area who would gladly avail of portion of this land the Land Commission have made no attempt to acquire it. Consequently the land is left vacant because the farmer leaves it and the adjoining holders are deprived of its use. Where land is offered for sale to the Land Commission and where there are suitable holdings around it, or, if not immediately around it, not far distant, it should be availed of, and all the land in the country, first, second, third and fourth quality land, should, as far as possible, be put into production. It can be kept in production if there is somebody in charge of it and responsible for it. It will not be in production if it is left derelict, and that is what has been happening in recent years in respect of a great many farms in Leitrim of which I am aware. The Land Commission have failed to acquire these lands and utilise them for the natural purpose for which they should be used.
Some remarks were made by Deputy Tully about the unsuitability of people brought in to farms and he wondered why they were brought in at all. They are brought in, I suppose, because they are entitled to be brought in. But if the farmers of Meath were the energetic and capable people they should be, there would be no need for anybody to come in. As a matter of fact, down through the years and long before the Land Commission started the division of land at all, these farmers were unable to carry on their business and run their farms, without the assistance of the migratory labour from the West of Ireland. Even without the division of land at all, these people were unable to do their work and had to take advantage of migratory labour at harvest time and during other periods, and these people from the West of Ireland did that work. It is only natural that, when land is available on these farms on which they worked, it should be offered to them. If Deputy Tully thinks that he and his people in Meath require the land, I would remind him they showed bad example down through the years in not cultivating it as they should have, and whatever cultivation was done was achieved by the labour and the energy and knowledge of the western holders.
Let me say, in a general way, that Mayo and the Land Commission now seem to be synonymous. Indeed, the Mayo people and the land of the Republic are synonymous. As far as we can see, over the past few years, land is taken to be synonymous with Mayo. That state of affairs is morally wrong and cannot be tolerated. It is the duty of the Government to see that whoever is responsible for this misappropriation of public funds is brought to book and that ordinary decent administration is put into operation. In spite of the individual interests that I may have in my constituency of Sligo-Leitrim, or that any other Deputies may have in their constituencies, let us have justice and honesty, so that whatever decisions are arrived at will be in the interests of the community as a whole.
Comment on this
Some time ago, when speaking on this Estimate, I said publicly that I thought the Land Commission had failed hopelessly in the performance of their task and that they should hand in their gun. I suppose that I said that at the time out of interest in the solution of the problem that was given to the Land Commission in 1923, in succession to the Congested Districts Board, and because of our failure as a Legislature to bring this problem sufficiently near a solution as to see the time coming when the Land Commission would no longer be necessary. However, I feel now that, the problems being still there, the necessity for having some body to solve them being still there, the Land Commission should be given another chance.
I feel that in some respects the fault lay with the Legislature in not giving the Land Commission in 1923 sufficiently clear directions as to the scope and nature of the problems which they had to solve, and that, at the time when the Land Commission was reconstituted, the Land Commissioners should have been obliged to undertake a proper survey of all the requirements; that they should have been obliged to obtain the number of congested holdings that needed enlarging, the area and valuations of the holdings that would have to be acquired by them for such a purpose; the area and valuations of untenanted land and the area and valuation of land retained under the 1923 Act or other land available for the relief of congestion or other purposes. It is an extraordinary thing that even now there appear to be no data in the hands of the commission relating to these basic questions and problems which we are here to solve.
As a result of the many opportunities for acquiring untenanted lands which were missed up to the time after the last war when outsiders with big money, and people in this country with big money, rushed into the market for untenanted land and took away the Land Commission's monopoly, there was a system of fixing prices which was said during the Minister's first period in office to be no longer applicable. It was in the light of circumstances that arose with regard to the rush for untenanted land after the last war that the Minister found it necessary to introduce the 1950 Land Act. One of the results of that Act was that the Land Commission was given power to bid for land up to a certain value. It is most disappointing to the people in the West of Ireland and elsewhere that the Land Commission had been so very sparing in the use of the powers that were conferred on them by that 1950 Act. Indeed, so far as this aspect of the matter is concerned, Deputy Maguire was certainly completely wrong in saying that the Land Commission was run for the benefit of the people of Mayo. As regards land acquired by the Land Commission by public auction, nothing has been done for the benefit of Mayo or anywhere else. No effort is made to use the powers conferred in the 1950 Act.
I should like to know from the Minister whether it is proposed to extend those powers or whether he proposes to try to get the Land Commission to use those powers more frequently in future, particularly at a time when there are hundreds of holdings throughout the country which have become vacant and which are lying idle and unproductive, remembering it is a basic principle of the policy of the Clann na Talmhan Party to which the Minister belongs that the land should be put into maximum production. In his own constituency the Minister should know that there are areas——
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary is going to continue like that, a Cheann Comhairle, I must ask for your protection. I am trying to make a speech——
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan will get the protection of Standing Orders just as every other Deputy will.
Comment on this
I want to get through to the Minister the fact that, in his constituency and in mine, there are large areas where lands are completely untenanted and where the people have locked up their houses and gone away to England or America. It is bad enough that the lands themselves are unused, but it is even worse that taxpayers' and ratepayers' money which has gone into the erection of new houses and the reconstruction of houses and farm buildings, and so forth, should be completely wasted when these houses and out-buildings are allowed to deteriorate, as they do very rapidly when left untenanted, and when this land and these buildings which have cost the people so much are allowed to go into a state of disrepair and ruin while the Land Commission sits idly by. I do not have to tell the Minister the areas concerned in his own county, but, being a man of the people and a sensible person——
Comment on this
——he will realise the amount that we are losing through the fact that these lands are being left there idle at a time when the need for increased agricultural production is greater than it ever was in the history of the State.
The present Minister for Lands is not to be blamed in any way for the fact that the standard economic holding, in the opinion of the Land Commission, is placed at a valuation of approximately £10. It is possible that in 1923, or even in 1933, that was a good-enough target, and, in any event, the Land Commission had to have some target. It was felt at the time—reasonably, I think—that a valuation of £10 would represent a proper basis to go on for the purpose of deciding what was an economic holding. I submit that time has passed and that we should concentrate in future on a standard holding of £20 valuation. Judging by the way in which the people are leaving the land of this country at present, I believe it would be possible to concentrate on this without very great effort by the Land Commission because the holdings will be there, and certainly, in many areas in the West of Ireland, they are already there. It is a sad thing, as I say, that these should be left vacant and that, when many of them, as they do from time to time, go up for sale, the Land Commission either do not have the power, or do not use the power they have, to purchase the lands in what is certainly the quickest way they will get land—that is in the open market by public auction.
I have several grievances with regard to my own county. I should like to refer the Minister back to a time in 1953 when questions were raised here about the division of the Nally Estate in Mayo. There was an interesting adjournment debate at the time during which the Minister, then Deputy Blowick, made various interesting statements about Deputy Michael Moran and myself. In the course of his statement at that time —I am quoting from Volume 141, column 1458—the then Deputy said:—
"The Land Commission have statutory powers to acquire and resume land for the relief of congestion. Under the 1950 Act, they have power to buy land for the relief of congestion. These Acts, and particularly the 1923 Act, oblige the Land Commission to dispose of any lands on their hands with the minimum of delay. In other words, they are not allowed to purchase land and hold it in their hands for the purpose of taking in grazing rents and of making money for the Department of Finance at the public expense. I know, of course, that the Minister cannot interfere statutorily with the Land Commission in certain matters which are clearly set out, but he should keep an eye on the Land Commission, as a whole, to see that the law is not violated, either by omission or commission. I say that it is entirely wrong for the Land Commission to take land and hold it indefinitely, thereby securing such huge amounts in grazing rents —almost £3,000 in approximately two and a half years.
"The Land Commission took possession of that farm about mid-March, 1951, shortly before the change of Government ..."
As I said, that was in July, 1953, and very nearly three years have since elapsed, for two of which Deputy Blowick has been Minister for Lands. He has therefore been in charge of the Department while extra grazing rents were being taken in. Deputy Derrig, who was Minister at the time, pointed out that, in fact, the Land Commission had not made any such profit out of the Nally Estate and that they had a relatively small profit on their outgoings on the rents and other things they got in. The fact is that three years have since elapsed, during which no further progress has been made towards the division of these lands.
If the Minister was sincere about what he was saying as a Deputy in 1953, he had his opportunity during the past two years to push his Department to see that this estate was divided. He is perfectly well aware that the local people are dissatisfied that the Land Commission should let out these lands in conacre and grazing for the past three years, in addition to the two and a half years during which Deputy Blowick was complaining about the situation in 1953. One is bound to have some misgivings as to what is going on in the background when one gets nothing by way of concrete information, either from the Land Commission or the Minister, with regard to the proposals of the Department in respect of the division of this estate. We on this side of the House will certainly watch the development of the situation with regard to the Nally estate very carefully and will oppose any attempt on the part of the Minister to interfere with the Land Commission in the way we have very good reason to believe he did before.
Comment on this
In regard to the Tooronin estate, that was another estate about which the Minister himself raised a question when he was a Deputy some three years ago and which has been divided since he came into office. He is perfectly well aware of the case of a man with a very large family who was living adjacent to some of the lands which were left vacant after the four tenants were migrated.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister is responsible for the selection of allottees. That is purely a matter for the Land Commission. Neither is he responsible in the matter of the particular lands to be acquired.
Comment on this
He is not supposed to be, I agree, but there are grave doubts in the minds of many whether the Minister has not succeeded in interfering with the Land Commission in connection with some of these estates.
Comment on this
The Minister would be quite capable of so attempting to interfere and cut out people who, to ordinary lay people, appear to have much more valid claims than some of those whose claims have been recognised. If the Minister wants to get examples of the type of behaviour I am speaking about, he will get plenty.
Comment on this
I have already ruled that the selection of allottees is not a matter for the Minister, nor is the Minister responsible in the matter of the particular lands to be acquired.
Comment on this
I am perfectly well aware of what the position is and I am warning the Minister that, when this estate in particular is divided, we will watch very carefully for any signs of his attempting to interfere in the way he has done before and which I can prove he has done before.
Comment on this
Another matter to which I wanted to refer was the question of people being put to cost as a result of minor mistakes made by the Land Commission—mistakes which are quite understandable in regard to very complicated matters such as the rearrangement of estates. It has happened in my experience in a few cases that, as a result of mistakes made in the identification of parcels of land which people were given on the rearrangement of estates, some tenants found years afterwards they were not recorded officially as being in occupation of the holdings which in fact had been allotted to them. It has happened in my experience in a few cases that they have had to make representations to the Land Commission with a view to having the mistakes rectified and the holdings which in fact belong to them duly and properly recorded in the Land Commission as being theirs.
In my experience, the Land Commission have refused to pay the costs involved by these people in having these mistakes rectified. There is no fault to be found with anybody in regard to these mistakes, but I feel that the individual tenant should not be responsible for any cost or expenses he incurs in having himself duly noted as the owner of the lands which in fact he was allotted. It is unfair to him that the Land Commission should not bear the cost of rectifying the mistakes which were theirs originally.
Another matter referred to before was the scandal about the present price of land bonds and the fact that people whose lands have been sold to the Land Commission are forced to accept four-fifths of the value which the State agreed to give them for their lands. As somebody pointed out, this can amount to £1,000 or £2,000, depending upon the value of the lands acquired. I believe that is shameful behaviour which would not be tolerated, unless it had the backing of a Government Department behind it.
Another matter is one which is more a matter of evidence than anything else, but it shows the power given under this system to the Land Commission and courts, whereby, when an appeal is heard as to the value of land, the evidence given consists of the evidence of an auctioneer on behalf of the appellant, the person whose land is being taken, but no evidence is offered by the Land Commission. The only way in which the auctioneer's evidence on behalf of the appellant is questioned is by cross-examination by counsel in the court. I claim, and I have always thought, that, when the Land Commission do not bring in evidence on their own account and submit it to the court, the court should be bound to accept only the evidence before it.
Comment on this
I am not canvassing them, a Cheann Comhairle. I am merely pointing out that peculiar situation which arises—and perhaps other barristers here in the Dáil may support me in this—whereby the only evidence given in that court about value of land is evidence given by the auctióneer on behalf of the appellant.
Comment on this
For a legal man, the Deputy is showing a deplorable lack of appreciation of what is happening in the Land Court.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with that. What I am concerned with is decisions of a court being discussed here, which is never right.
Comment on this
No. It very often is true that the only evidence is by the auctioneer on behalf of the appellant. I am aware personally of cases in which it happened.
Comment on this
I am aware personally of cases where the only evidence was by an auctioneer on behalf of the appellant. However, I am only speaking of cases of which I have personal knowledge, and it may not be standard procedure, but it is a matter I would ask the Minister to look into.
Another matter which I should like to ask the Minister is if it is still the policy of the Land Commission not to give land to a person living with his family on a holding where he does not have a separate dwelling-house of his own. I am speaking of a case where a father, a householder, secures a small holding of land, maybe ten acres, and puts down his son's name, but the son remains in residence with his father. I understand that the policy of the Land Commission always has been that the son or any other person is not recognised as being qualified to get an addition or an exchange of holdings unless he has his own separate dwelling-house on the land, in which event he will be recognised. I should like to know if that is still the policy of the Land Commission, because I consider it should be, and I have some reasonable belief that there may be some cases where it has been departed from. God knows, the problems of the Land Commission are difficult enough without allowing this chicanery, which is all it would be, to enable people to get away with dividing land like this and creating more problems.
There are a lot of other matters of one kind or another which arise in this debate, but many of them have already been touched on, and I do not wish to go over the ground again, but I do want to say to Deputy Maguire and other people who say that County Mayo is getting too large a share that at all times the problems there were more acute and complex than in any other county, and at all times, whether Fianna Fáil or the present Government were in power, the number of holdings rearranged in County Mayo would have exceeded the number in any other county, for the simple reason that the problems there were more complex and greater in number than anywhere else. I am not afraid to support the present Minister in saying that I do not think for a moment that he is administering his Department solely for the benefit of the people down in County Mayo. I wish there were a Department that would administer it solely for our county, but my grievance against the Minister and against successive Ministers for Lands and the Land Commission is that the problems we had when the Land Commission was reconstituted in 1923 in Mayo very largely subsist to the present day, and that our attitude at the present time to those problems is that the Land Commission will last for ever and, just like the poor, will always remain with us.
The conception originally was that the Land Commission was a temporary organisation set up to relieve certain problems, to deal with and finish with congestion, and that, when that part of their work had been completed, they would be disbanded. I do not think we can say, without blaming the Land Commission or otherwise, that we are in any way nearer to the solution of the problem of congestion in the West of Ireland than we were 20 or 30 years ago. Fine strides have been made in the matter of rearrangement on some estates like Kilvine, and the Land Commission local officials are to be congratulated on the work they have done. If they speed up the division of the Nally holding, perhaps another milestone will be passed in the progress of the Land Commission in the area.
All this time land has been left vacant and untenanted, unproductive, and it is vital for the economy of the country that we should acquire these lands with the minimum of delay and divide them up into, if possible, economic holdings of £20 rather than £10 valuation, and in that way give an incentive to the young people to remain at home and to put the land of the country into production for the benefit of the country, as well, of course, as of themselves. In that respect, it is hard to ask for greater powers, but it seems a pity that some of the best land in the country is being absolutely wasted, while small tenants in my county, and particularly in certain parts of it, who are crying out for land and still being asked to live on nine or ten acres of rock and scrub, are denied the opportunity of having even a £5 valuation holding, never mind a £10 or £20 valuation, while other people are making no reasonable attempt to produce a livelihood for themselves or a future for the country from some of the best land we have, not too far away from the unfortuate people I am talking about.
I am hoping that, in the near future, we will tackle the solution of these problems with greater vigour than we have ever shown before, because, if we do not do it, still more of these people will be lost to us, and our County Mayo in particular, which has already lost so much in emigration, will lose even more heavily in the future.
Comment on this
I suppose that the Department of Lands is the one Department in this country where Deputies of all shades of opinion seem to find an outlet for grievances that seem to irritate them annually. Before going into the main portion of the speech I intend to make on this Estimate, I want to refer to the last Deputy's references to the Appeal Tribunal and its procedure. Up to little less than a year ago, what Deputy Flanagan has just described in relation to the procedure on evidence was in fact the practice. Last year, speaking on this same Estimate, I made the point which Deputy Flanagan has made to-day, that the court should act on evidence before it, and, that being so, of course, should act on the evidence of the valuer for the appellant against the price offered by the Land Commission.
Since then—I can never make up my mind whether it was due to any point made during the debate on the Estimate last year or to a particular case in which the point was made by myself actually in the Appeal Tribunal that the tribunal would have to act on the evidence before it and nothing else— the Land Commission, I am glad to say, have altered the practice. Now the position is that the Land Commission put up evidence of value on their side after the valuers for the appellant against price have given their evidence. It is true, of course, that the evidence that is put up by the Land Commission's is the evidence of the Land Commission's inspectors and it is arguable whether they can give evidence as valuers or not.
Comment on this
I am coming to that. As I say, it is arguable as to whether the evidence of a Land Commission inspector would be regarded as evidence on valuation by somebody competent to judge. On the one hand, of course, the Land Commission inspector has certain fixed duties and included in those duties is the picking up of the ordinary knowledge that one picks up in the course of one's business and profession and that would include, in their case, attendance at auctions and the study of prices at auctions. The Land Commission inspectors are very closely in touch with the sale of lands and, if they know their business at all, and I am quite certain that they do, they must have some knowledge as to the correct valuation of lands. Until somebody successfully challenges the valuation qualifications of Land Commission inspectors, I am quite satisfied that the procedure now is certainly much better than it was hitherto and, I think, much more satisfactory.
Comment on this
I am prepared, as a practitioner in the Appeal Tribunal, to give the present practice a fair chance, having regard to the fact that for so many years there was no evidence at all and now, for less than a year, we have been having that evidence. I think it should get a fair trial. That trial will best be judged on the prices obtaining as a result and it gives the tribunal a better chance of being able to decide between two figures.
So much for the Appeal Tribunal. As I am on that point, I think that possibly, from the point of view of policy, the Land Commission could do a little speeding-up between the first visit of the inspector to the lands, the notices to acquire, the actual hearing of the acquisition proceedings, the ultimate appeal against price and the decision of the Land Commission to take the lands at the price fixed, or otherwise. The time spent in that process is somewhat too long. There are isolated cases, of course, and there will be cases of that kind, where delay is unavoidable but there are other cases, I am sure, where the matter could be speeded up somewhat because upon that speed depends to a very great extent how the local Land Commission inspectors can pursue their work, particularly if they are waiting for, say, two or three holdings, one after another, in order to have an effective resettlement scheme. The delay impedes their work considerably and subjects the local inspector to a considerable amount of trouble from people who hope to get land on the ultimate resettlement and, I am sure, to a considerable amount of trouble from public representatives who keep harassing them.
Another suggestion that I would venture to offer to the Land Commission is that, when they are refencing or restriping or striping for the first time any village or place, or building roads, they should make these roads wide enough, at least wider than they have been made in the past, and take steps to improve roads which have been made on the narrow side in villages where their work has not been completed.
I am extremely interested in a scheme in my constituency that was started by the Land Commission as far back as 1931, in Ballygarwan in Ballycroy, where a completely new village was created in valleys between the mountains on the North of Mulranny, on the Ballycroy side of Blacksod Bay. The people there seem to have benefited considerably, both from the capacity to till what was made tillable for them and the fine outlet that there is from these holdings.
The Land Commission have in hands in my constituency, as I am sure they have in other constituencies, vast areas of such land, of the character of mountain slopes, semi-arable, that could be made fertile and productive. I said last year in the debate on the corresponding Estimate, that the people before us did a considerable amount of reclamation with the ordinary three-rivet spade and I see no reason why heather-land and moorland adjacent to that reclaimed land could not now be done much faster with all the modern amenities that people have at their disposal.
In that way, in my view, particularly in the congested areas, there could be new villages created where people would have ample opportunity to work, to care and bring up live stock and to have that degree of independence that is so necessary to the ultimate wellbeing of a family.
I am inclined to think, from personal experience, in isolated cases only, I must say, that, when the Land Commission acquire lands, large tracts of land are kept too long in hands, particularly when there is no other land in the locality the acquisition of which the Land Commission have in view. There is an estate near Ballina, the Belleek estate, which has been acquired almost seven or eight years. I do not know the reason for the delay but there are in the area around Ballina many people who would work these lands to much better advantage for the district particularly, and for the country generally, than having them let from year to year to dairy people and graziers from Ballina town.
Of course, every year in this debate, some references are made to the migration of people from my county of Mayo to the lands of Meath and Kildare and such like richer counties. References are made to their unsuitability for such holdings. I have taken the trouble—and, indeed, "taken the trouble" is only a phrase, because it has been a pleasure — to visit these holdings and these people and to see how well they have done. However, it seems to be a feature on this Vote for Deputies, from the County of Meath in particular, to deem it a solemn obligation on them to the people of Meath to rail against the migrants who come in, so as to keep the "have-nots" on their side when they are doubtful about the "haves."
I deprecate very strongly the references by Deputy S. Flanagan to interference by the Minister with the Land Commission. As a lawyer, he should know that the Land Commission is a statutory body, and, as such, certainly ought not be interfered with and ought not allow any interference. From my short experience as a Deputy, and from previous experience of dealing with the Land Commission in another capacity, I am quite certain that interference in the allocation and the division of land must be a very rare occurrence. I should like to see approaches to Land Commission inspectors becoming more rare as time goes on. There can be nothing more degrading than to have a Deputy, a county councillor or some other public man visiting an area prior to the division of an estate or prior to the allocation of land, thereby giving the impression that whatever happens when the Land Commission inspector ultimately comes to divide the land it is as a result of that visit. There are many ways of doing it, but that is one way in which the faith of our people in our public service can be damaged, and damaged to a degree that some people do not seem to realise.
Comment on this
I think the remarks I have just made can well apply to Deputies on all sides of the House. I am not applying them to the Opposition Deputies alone. I am stating it as a matter of principle and I think it is extremely important in the administration of the public service.
I have a proposition to make to Land Commission inspectors. I think it is reasonable and I hope they will accept it, so far as they can. If it is unreasonable, or if it will not fit into their scheme of things, I will certainly accept their rejection of my proposal, because I believe they know their business best, and particularly when it is fully explained to them. Reference has been made to derelict houses and lands. There are not very many of them, but there are some. It might not be a bad thing if the Land Commission directed their local men to pay some regard to derelict houses and lands— to take the necessary steps to have them acquired, or to find out if the owner is living somewhere else in the locality. It very often happens that old people, living without younger help, are brought to a neighbour's house, either in the same district or in the next village, and their land does not appear to be worked and very often ceases to be worked at all after a time.
The suggestion was made that a £10 valuation holding, which was regarded as an economic standard of holding, should be increased to a £20 valuation holding now. I do not know how people can make statements of that kind and not steel themselves to face the facts. This country is not as big as France or Germany, and, accordingly, it has not got the same amount of arable land to give holdings of £20 valuation to everyone who wants one. That type of statement will, however, go down well with unthinking people. They will say: "That is the man who would do the job properly if he were in control." The fact of the matter is that he is not in control and that it is very easy to make certain statements when you are not in control.
In my view, the legislation dealing with the Land Commission and land generally from 1923 to date is adequate and gives adequate powers. Some Deputies have asked that the Land Commission be given more power and direction and that their scope be defined. The ownership of land in this country has been closely identified with our national struggle and the proprietorship of land is a sacred thing. The Land Commission have very wisely, in a great many cases, not used the power they have and in other cases I have often been irritated because they have not used their powers. For instance, in the resettlement of a village, one man can hold up the whole show until some petty irritation has been removed either from his mind or from the resettlement scheme.
In my view, the administration is adequate. The Land Commission is doing its work. If there is any degree of slowness about the manner in which that work is being done, it is due to the fact that the Land Commission have not got enough men in the field. I have first-hand experience of the work being done by Land Commission inspectors. When we relate that work and the area in which they work to one man's capacity to survey, to visit villages, to travel, to come back and do the equivalent of office work, to make submissions to his next superior or to his headquarters, we should be very slow to criticise.
To sum up, I should like a direction, as a matter of policy, that roads will be of adequate width. I hope there will be more fencing, so that a village will not be left without fencing. Trouble can be caused later because of that. It can cause rows and spite and trespass actions. That type of trouble should not arise in a village and adequate fencing would lessen the occurrence of such trouble. I feel that the Land Commission should not keep lands too long and I respectfully ask that attention be paid to my suggestion for the reclamation of moorland adjacent to holdings already showing good productivity in the West of Ireland. The same would apply to other mountainous areas. In order that proper results may be obtained, the Land Commission and the Minister must be given the best of co-operation and every constructive suggestion that can be given from all sides of the House.
It was contemplated at the beginning that the Land Commission work would not go much beyond ten to 15 years. In the course of any business where planning problems arise, exceptions occur to delay the best-laid schemes. For that reason, we all make our suggestions in a constructive manner and play our full part to help the people who handle the legislative and administrative side of this Department. Above all, public men should avoid giving the impression to our people that men who deal conscientiously with our work can be brow-beaten, bribed or threatened. Let us try to put an end to all that practice throughout the country. Then we will probably be at the beginning, at any rate, of the journey towards the real Ireland, the Ireland the people envisaged long ago—the Ireland where men and women would play their full part as wage-earners and as workers, where merit would have its just reward and where political prejudices would not be allowed to retard progress.
Comment on this
I want, in the first place, to compliment the Land Commission on the manner in which they are doing their work. We were always led to believe that it took two generations to get anything done by the Land Commission. If you go to any member of the legal profession down the country you are immediately told: "Oh, that is above with the Land Commission. Sure, you know what they are." That was the first reply you got. I had occasion during the past few months to take up at least five or six different cases in regard to subdivision where the unfortunate men had been with solicitors who were pretending to do the work and not doing it and who blamed the Land Commission for the delays. I want to say that I found the officials courteous. They were able to get those cases fixed up in record time. I should like it to go out to the public generally that subdivision work in the ordinary way, going through the Land Commission at the present time, is done in three weeks. If it is not done in three weeks, it is because the lawyers whom the unfortunate client is paying are not doing their jobs.
It is just as well to make these things clear and let the public know them, because up to now the legal profession have turned the tables on the unfortunate officials and blamed them for their own negligence. Up to recently I was of that opinion. I am glad to say that most of the work in the subdivision department of the Land Commission has been done expeditiously and well. When it comes to the land registry afterwards, I find that the same speed and attention is present. I like to praise each bridge as I pass it.
In regard to the division of land, I should like to say that there are definite rules laid down for the guidance of the Land Commission in the division of holdings. I would suggest to the Minister that he would be doing a very good day's work if he put a copy of those rules in the hands of every Deputy. Who has first claim on a holding to be divided? Who comes second, who comes third and who comes in at the tail end? If Deputies were given that information, I think it would relieve a lot of misapprehension.
The first claim on any holding to be divided is held by the uneconomic holders in the vicinity of that farm or estate. The Minister's duty is to see that the claims of these uneconomic holders are satisfied before any outside people are brought into that land. I do not care where the land is, in what constituency it is. You will find surrounding those holdings to be divided a very large number of uneconomic holdings. I do not know where Deputy Flanagan here or the other legal gentleman, Deputy Lindsay, got their idea of the £10 valuation holding.
I have been in this House 29 years and I never heard of that line about a £10 valuation holding being regarded as an economic one in the eyes of the Land Commission. In my constituency, away back some 20 or 25 years ago, we maintained that when an estate was being divided any holding with a valuation under £18 was entitled to be included and its owner entitled to portion of the estate. That was the minimum laid down, and I can remember having had serious quarrels with the Land Commission because land in my area is valued at from 25/- to 30/- per statute acre. A very small holding indeed would be one with £18 valuation. I had tremendous sympathy with that last apostle of Fine Gael left in Deputy Giles' area who did not get an exchange holding. Deputy Giles did not make it clear who promised that man land. Was it the Land Commission?
Comment on this
The Deputy is very late in the field. Deputy Giles said the Fianna Fáil fellows were fixed up, but this poor devil, who took his car out and worked for Deputy Giles in the election, and who was told that he was going to get this farm after the election, was left there. I have terrible sympathy with that man.
Comment on this
Before there was ever an election, four men were picked for farms. They were all turned down at that time. Subsequently, three Fianna Fáil men were fixed up. The other man was not fixed up.
Comment on this
I have great sympathy for the poor devil, after the petrol he used in the election and after he worked so hard for Deputy Giles. He has my sympathy and I suggest to the Minister that, since there is only this one poor farmer left in Deputy Giles's area who believes in Fine Gael, the least the Minister can do is give him the land.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy not tell us that he is the only supporter the Deputy had left and, after promising him the farm, that the Deputy could not get him into it? It is very hard. I have a great deal of sympathy for him. I appeal to Deputy Blowick now, the Minister for Lands, to make that a special case and see if something cannot be done, even if the Minister has to take him up to Mayo—he is bringing so many of them down—and give him a bit of land up there, one of these estates about which there are complaints because they are not being divided.
Comment on this
I would even be satisfied to give him a bit of that 500 acre farm belonging to the Smiths at Finure which the Minister allowed an Englishman to buy in my constituency.
Comment on this
Why does the Deputy not give him a bit of his own? I am told Deputy Corry has a very good farm.
Comment on this
The question of conversion does not arise on the Estimate for the Department of Lands.
Comment on this
Down in my constituency a farm of 500 acres was put up for sale. The unfortunate people who had been evicted from that estate were living outside in Guileen in holdings of £5 valuation and £15 valuation, within three miles of this farm. But the Minister very coolly let that farm be sold to an Englishman who came over and bought it.
Comment on this
That farm of 500 acres was put up for sale, unfortunately for the tenants in the area. But, by Jove, I will see that it will be divided, I promise the Minister that.
Comment on this
The Deputy will do everything now when he cannot do anything. The Deputy cannot do anything over there.
Comment on this
——the Minister for Lands was, I take it, specially picked for that office because he comes from a congested area and should appreciate the problem that exists of finding land for migrants and for uneconomic holders.
Comment on this
I went on three occasions to Deputy Blowick, Minister for Lands, and I asked five questions of him in connection with it.
Comment on this
It was Deputy Blowick who was Minister during the three years that this was happening and it was Deputy Blowick, Minister for Lands, who allowed an Englishman in. It was Deputy Blowick who was in charge of the Land Commission when the consent to the sale of that holding to that Englishman was given. Let us be clear on these things.
Comment on this
I do not know whether he was asleep, or lazy, but whatever he was doing, he was not there anyway.
Comment on this
It is no good denying it. The land was put up for public auction and the moment it was put up for public auction the three Deputies in that constituency were called in by the unfortunate people whose families had previously been evicted out of it. Those three Deputies, irrespective of Party affiliations, came up here and called on the Minister and appealed to him. They brought him lists of the people whose ancestors were evicted out of this farm. Then we are told about the migrants. We are told about the people who have to flee the country because there is no land available. I have seen the officials of the Minister's Department down digging around an unfortunate Irishman who had 70 acres of land, trying to get him out in order to divide his land. But an Englishman can come in and get 500 acres with a poor law valuation of 30/- per acre. That will show the kind of land it is—land growing 28 to 30 tons of beet to the acre.(Interruptions.)
Comment on this
The Deputy was 19 years over here and he did not even know he had a Minister for Lands.
Comment on this
I object to the Minister having this conversation. I suggest it is the Minister's job to listen when I am speaking. The Minister will have plenty of time to tell us all about these things when he is concluding. It is my job at the moment to put the case to the Minister. The last reply I got from him in relation to that holding was that, even if it had been sold, the Land Commission could take it over. But it was sold. The Englishman came in and he is still there.
Comment on this
God knows, we had trouble enough getting them out before without the Minister letting them in again.
Comment on this
What the Deputy should do is resign and let somebody in who will manage the affairs of the county. Such a confession of failure.
Comment on this
I have stated what the position is. I should like now to deal with the Rosstellan estate. The Land Commission divided up that estate and built fences, leaving an unfinished road almost the breadth of this House. I have approached both the present Minister and his predecessor in connection with that road. The unfortunate tenants along that road are in the position that no lorry will go in there for milk; no lorry will go in there for beet and no lorry will go in there with artificial manures. But the tenants must pay their annuities to the Minister.
Comment on this
It is a wonder the Deputy did not get the Cork County Council to make an offer to us.
Comment on this
The Minister's head now is as grey as my own. The Minister is no baby. The Minister was a member of a local authority and he knows that a local authority cannot just go in and take over a road.
Comment on this
Of course they can. We would have given £700 if the Cork County Council would put up so much.
Comment on this
There was an offer by the local authority that, if the road were put in a passable condition, they would take it over and maintain it afterwards. That offer was sent to the Minister's Department. The Minister has another Department—the Forestry Department—which is using portion of that road.
Comment on this
Why would the Minister not think that the Department of Lands is under some obligation to the unfortunate people they have put in there? The annuities are high enough and the poor law valuation is pretty high on it. The least they might have is a road.
It was not the Minister who was in office when the land was divided. I pressed his predecessor in connection with this and his predecessor before him again; but I must hold the Minister responsible to the people who are living there, and he must face up to that responsibility. That road is now in such a condition that nobody can travel it; it would even wreck a tractor. Unless the Minister is going to do something in connection with it, I will have to take steps to protect my constituents——
Comment on this
The first step will be to stop the annuities to the Minister. We will repair the roads with 12 months annuities. The Minister can work away then.
Comment on this
The Deputy will do what he considers right at any time; and he never shirked showing the road.
Comment on this
He had not got people out in blue blouses while he was sitting down at his desk telling them what to do. Whenever I told anybody to do something, I showed them the road myself, and I took whatever knocks were coming out of it, either from the Tans or the Green and Tans. I do not want to import any heat into this. I am telling the Minister he has a definite responsibility to those people and I ask the Minister now to see that that road is put in proper condition. If the Minister would even fix up the road now, he would get rid of a very grave difficulty.
We passed special legislation in this House to enable the Minister to take over the Kilworth estate from the Department of Defence; but has our Land Commission gone to sleep on it? I suggest that the Minister, when he is considering the large number of congests alluded to by Deputy Maguire and the large number of congests in his own constituency and in other constituencies, should take a walk around the plains of Kildare and have a look at the Curragh. As I said, legislation has been passed to enable State lands to be taken over by the Land Commission for the purposes of division. I forced it through here as well as I could because I was interested in some 700 or 800 acres in Kilworth, Fermoy. The Minister for Finance assured me that they would be the subject of the first action to be taken under the new legislation.
What is the Land Commission doing since? I suggest that the Land Commission could very well get busy on that and carry out the legislation passed here. The Minister should take steps to take over the thousands of acres lying idle in the Curragh and Kildare and put the migrants from Mayo and Leitrim there. If he does that, he will get the blessing, not alone of the people of Mayo and Leitrim, but of the whole country. I can never pass through the Curragh—and it was particularly so during the emergency period—without a blush of shame at the Departments that were urging on the people the necessity to till their land when we had thousands of acres lying idle there. If the Minister, instead of taking that trip to Scandinavia, took a trip down to the Rosstellan road which I mentioned here, I can guarantee it would do him more good. The shaking up he would get going down there to see his forests would be good for him.
Comment on this
I would be delighted to show him around for the day and to point out to him the number of matters his Department are responsible for and which they have entirely neglected.
Comment on this
It would be worth the Minister's while, if he did it, and it would be worth his while also if he took a few trips down to County Kildare, which is not so far away, and had a look at the land I am talking about. When he goes home, he could have a look around him and see the number of families living there in small uneconomic holdings and just picture how happy those people would be with 40 acres of the Curragh and a lovely house.
Comment on this
When did the Deputy discover the Curragh was there? Was it since the inter-Party came in?
Comment on this
The poor unfortunate Minister, when he was a Deputy, did not come in to us at all. He did not know what was happening then. If he had been interested, he would have seen that I had asked about 35 questions in connection with the Curragh—
Comment on this
——but the Minister never bothered when he was a Deputy. Now he has to come in and sit in the corner. How far his responsibility goes, I do not know. Even yet, I have not heard from him that he is going to do the road. I am putting up a very constructive point to him: that we have legislation passed for the taking over of State lands and that the way is now clear. I am pointing out to him something I would be delighted to have pointed out to me, if I were in his boots.
In regard to the Rosstellan estate and the Finure estate, the Minister has the consent of the Land Commission; he has a good staff—
Comment on this
Two months ago, when I was in the Minister's Department, I asked him to deal with this, and there has been no move since.
Comment on this
The Cork County Council will take over the road when the Minister puts it in proper order, and that is the Minister's job. I went down to the Minister's room and asked for even part of the cash and said that we would help him out. He would not agree to that.
The next point I wish to raise is in relation to portion of the Gaskell estate, Garryvoe. For some reason or another that no sane man could ever understand, when this estate was taken over by the Land Commission, there was a strip of land lying by the seashore that was left in the hands of the landlord. The landlord, as soon as he realised that the larger this became the more valuable it was for letting, that the more land that was under water there the more cash he would get every year as rent for it as a duck shoot, let the sluice gates governing the water coming out through that estate get into disrepair.
The complaints made by the tenants in that estate went unheeded. No demand was ever made by the Land Commission on that landlord to keep that sluice in proper repair, or to keep it open to let the water through. The result was that year after year that land deteriorated acre by acre, and went back into bog. It meant that the owner of that duck shoot was able to get an enhanced rent every year, due to the fact that there were more duck coming in and because more of the farmers' land had gone back to marsh and bog.
The poor law valuation per acre of all the land in the Gaskell estate is not less than 32/- a statute acre. On that land, those unfortunate people have to pay rates, which, with the combined assistance of the State and the guardians of the rates, are jumping up tremendously every year. In fact, these people will have to pay this year an increase of 5/2 in the £ or nearly 10/- an acre more for the bog. They have served notice on the county council that the lands are derelict, and that they are unable to till them. We all know how very dry the weather has been, but, when I went down to inspect those lands only last week, I found the potato furrows full of water. I came up here to contact the Minister for Local Government in this regard. He switched me on to the Minister for Lands who switched me on to somebody else. I wonder who is going to carry this baby, who is going to be responsible?
I hold that the Land Commission have a responsibility to the State in regard to the deterioration of land for which public money has been advanced. Public money was advanced for the purchase of those holdings. Surely there should be sufficient Land Acts passed now to enable the Land Commission to take over that strip lying outside those farms in Garryvoe. They ought to have power enough to compel the man who owns that strip to repair his sluice gates and keep them open and in such a condition that the water can leave the holdings. Is it that the Land Commission has got a feeling of laziness in this respect?
I have taken this matter up with the present Minister in the past two years. I took it up with our own Minister when he was in office and I also took it up with Deputy Blowick when he was previously Minister for Lands. We will hear many complaints later on when those tenants, in despair, decide on taking certain action themselves, but I think it is the Department's responsibility. They are not doing their job if they drive those tenants into taking this type of action. The Minister ought not to let to-morrow pass without taking steps to compel that landlord to keep the sluice gates in order and to keep them open. He has derived a fairly substantial income every year out of his duck pond.
Comment on this
Certainly. If not, what the dickens are they doing there and for what are we passing Land Acts here for the past 29 years if they have not got that power to protect the land that has been purchased by the money of the citizens of this country? There is no use in burking a question of that description. Let us get to work on it and see that it is done. I am tired of bringing it up here year after year and month after month, and asking questions here every three months about it and finding that nothing is done. I cannot see any reason why a man should pay an annuity for land which is constantly flooded for many years. That is the position that the farms of those people are getting into through pure, downright, damned neglect.
There are a few other matters with which I would like to deal. There are lying here and there throughout the country what we would call unfortunate holdings, holdings of which the tenants for some reason or other have been evicted. I suggest to the Land Commission that where reasonable offers have been or are made on behalf of the tenants in connection with those holdings, those offers should be accepted. It is always better to see land in production than derelict. I would like to know when was the last annuity received out of Mulcahys' of Gurranes, Carrantwohill. I know that the reverend parish priest of that parish wrote to the Land Commission some two or three years ago making a decent offer for the reinstatement of that tenant. Is it pure downright cussedness that makes the Land Commission say: "We would rather see the damn place there with the roof off the house", or what is wrong?
The same condition of affairs prevails in the Smith Barry estate at Watergrasshill from which a man named Murphy was evicted some years ago. That man's son, to my personal knowledge, is a good young lad who worked hard trying to scrape together a few pounds and he endeavoured to settle up with the Land Commission for that holding. I saw the offer made by the Land Commission to that unfortunate boy and it would not be made by a Jew. That holding is going to be left there a burden on the ratepayers and on the State. Surely there must be some common sense in the Department of Lands that would ensure that those holdings would be kept as short a time as possible in that condition and that some arrangement would be reached whenever a decent offer was made on behalf of the old tenant or the old tenant's family. One would think that an offer would be accepted and the matter straightened out and the land put into condition again.
I know that Mulcahys' farm at Gurranes has been in dispute in that manner for the last 15 or 16 years. I know it is 16 years since there was 5/- of annuity collected out of it despite the fact that the Land Commission put half a dozen grabbers into it from time to time. They came in and they went out, and quick, too. That holding is still there and I know that a meeting of the parish council was called in connection with it in order to stop the outrages that were being committed. I know that a decent offer was made some two or three years ago. Why is that land still there derelict?
Those are questions we would like to have answered. I should like to see a bit of common sense shown by the Land Commission so that these running sores around the country could be healed up as decently and as fairly as possible. I have done my part to heal quite a few of them. With an effort on our part here, let us see if we cannot heal the balance. To endeavour to grind out of existence young fellows who come up and make what I consider to be a very decent offer to the Land Commission will not help the situation. The suggestion made by the Land Commission in one of these cases would not have come from the worst rack-renting landlord in the country. I suggest that those two matters I have mentioned should be taken up, looked into and settled up. We are a peaceful people if we are left alone but God help the fellow that comes in to take anything from us. He will be in a bigger hurry out than he was in.
I dealt at the start of my remarks with the rules of the Land Commission and I pointed out that the first rule was that holders in the vicinity of a holding that was taken over should have first claim. That rule is not always observed by the Land Commission. I would not be the one to say that it was the Fianna Fáil Cumainn, the Fine Gael Cumainn or anybody else who came in and did it. I believe that the Land Commission are a fairly upright body of men who play fair so far as they can but as a matter of interest I mention the Creaghbarry estate at Leamlara where matters could be settled up very easily and decently for, in fact, two uneconomic holders at one stroke, but that was not done and those two uneconomic holders are left there.
We all know that it is only once in a generation that an opportunity arises for the clearing out of uneconomic holders in any district. The chance of purchasing a farm to make other holdings in the district economic occurs only once. If all the uneconomic holders in that area are not looked after then, they will never again get the opportunity of being looked after. Any uneconomic holding left uncared for then will be left for at least another generation, if the commission are ever able to get around to it.
I sincerely suggest that the Minister insist on the ruling of the Land Commission being observed in that respect. I do not think I am asking for too much in that. The rules are there, and, if they are not being observed, it is the Minister's duty to see that they are. A couple of years ago I interested myself in the question of the Flavin estate in Gortroe, near Youghal. We succeeded there, but only because the man who purchased that farm was a decent man. As soon as he found what the circumstances were, he pulled out.
I say it was the duty of the Land Commission, once they had served notice on the auctioneer and on the solicitors when they saw the place publicly advertised for auction, to see it was not sold. Their representative should have been present at the auction. It was unfair of them to allow an unfortunate man to come in and purchase the holding, not knowing the circumstances, and leave him holding the baby afterwards. However, thank God, that farm was eventually taken over by the Land Commission and it has relieved a large amount of congestion in that area. There is still pretty considerable congestion there.
This land lies between three and five miles from the town of Youghal. About 30 per cent. of every holding in that area is intensely cultivated, growing early potatoes, cabbages, beet; 90 per cent. of these holdings are under the plough. It is a pleasure for anybody who loves the land to go down and see the manner in which these holdings are worked. At the moment there is still another holding advertised for auction in that district. Notification has been sent to the Minister's Department in connection with that holding and I would suggest that he purchase it and end congestion in the district. If that farm goes, some 20 smallholders will be compelled to continue living on farms of five, six and seven acres. Now is the time, and I suggest the Minister should make his move.
There should be in every divisional inspector's office a map showing where there is congestion, so that, whenever a farm offers for sale, the commission could step in and purchase it. Difficulty is being met in that regard because of the purchase prices being paid in land bonds. I know because I came up against it in the Flavin estate. If a farm is put up for public auction to-morrow, the commissioners come in and put a valuation on it. That valuation later comes before the judicial commissioner on appeal, and he fixes the amount to be paid. I hold that the owner of the holding is entitled to get land bonds to the cash value put on the farm by the judicial commissioner, not bonds to the nominal value. If that system were adopted, there would be more peaceful taking over of a large number of holdings. If a man is offered £5,000 in land bonds for his place, he knows that these bonds are worth only £4,000. That is very largely the reason why that problem exists. If my system were adopted, legal expenses would be done away with in the purchase of these holdings. Of course, if there are any legal gentlemen in the Land Commission, they will want to look after their brothers outside and keep them working. If I might come back to the position in Kilworth——
Comment on this
I want to deal now with another aspect of it; I want to deal with the aspect of the large number of people who are anxious to till that land. I would like to know why that land is being let on the 11 months' system.
Comment on this
I am not worried. If the Deputy is here to-morrow, he will have two more hours of me. I am only a quarter way through this job yet.
Comment on this
If the Minister kept quiet, we would get along fine. He kept quiet a long time. He should know that interrupting me never paid anybody.