Finance Bill, 1956—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–153 of 317. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1956 ›
When I was speaking on this section last night, I referred to the taking of £500,000 from the Road Fund. I also spoke of the effect that would have on employment in this country and also of its reaction on emigration. I pointed out that 2,000 wage earners at £5 a week were being deprived of employment. That money was generally spent locally; every penny of it went into the pockets, in the first instance, of local traders and circulated within the country.
Consequently, I think it is a very grave mistake on the part of the Minister, at this or any other time, to do this, because, when the fund was created and increased for a particular purpose, it was made clear that no succeeding Minister should raid that fund and take away from it for quite a different purpose. There is another thing about which we hear a lot at the present time and over a number of years—the flight from the land. I should like to point out to the Minister that the taking away of this £500,000 is no incentive to the people in the remote areas of this country to remain on the land, because it is denying them, to a very great extent, the amenities which they might otherwise enjoy and which are enjoyed in the cities in this country and outside this country.
Pleas are being made to the people to remain on the land; the flight from it seems to be a matter of grave concern, and expressions deploring the tragedy have been voiced not merely by politicians but by members of the various churches. At the same time, we all know that the country has got very much smaller in the past 50 years and smaller still within the past 15 years. There was a time when people were content to remain on their small holdings in the West and in the other remote areas of rural Ireland. At that time, many of them never had the opportunity of visiting even the capital of their own county, never mind to come to Dublin. During the years since, things have changed. Thousands and thousands of our young people, because of the attractions here in the city and because of the functions that take place in it, come here, and when they see the vastly different state of affairs and the greater amenities and facilities the people have in the cities, they will not be kept at home in the country.
For those reasons, I think it is a very retrograde step to take away this money which, in the first instance, was giving so much employment to people who were badly in need of it. We have heard appeals made by the Minister for Finance, and by anybody else who speaks with authority, for greater agricultural production. This is no incentive to greater agricultural production. I need not go to the Gaeltacht areas at all to point out isolated districts throughout the country in which we have very good farmers; but the roads leading to their homes are in such a very bad state of repair that it is almost impossible to get any modern machinery into their places. I feel sure these people are prepared to respond to the pleas for increased agricultural production, but they are not in a position to buy the types of modern machinery that would give them some comfort and help them towards greater production. On the other hand, the owners of such machines, whom they would be inclined to employ, will not bring their machines over bad roads since they can stay on the good roads. These farmers also have difficulty in getting lorry owners to come to their places.
It is likely that the Minister will say I am talking about cul-de-sac or village roads. In my opinion, every road in this country at the present time should be regarded as a main road, if it serves at least three families. There should be no distinction at all, because all the roads are important now, since the mode of transporting fertilisers, lime and other commodities is by lorry. If agriculture is as essential as we are led to believe—and we really do believe it is—I think this reduction in the revenue of the Road Fund is very inconsistent with the pleas that have been made for greater agricultural production.
Many sections of the Finance Bill impose burdens on the people and on particular sections of the people, but, in my opinion, this is the most injurious section because it hits the wage earners and it also hits the agricultural producers. I cannot understand why the Minister ever thought of inserting this section in the Bill, or of going to the Road Fund as a means of balancing the Budget and for getting out of the financial difficulties which he says are there at the moment and have been coming on for some time. It is all right for his advisers in the Department of Finance to advise him: "Here is a pool of money that it is easy to raid".
Comment on this
I feel sure that when going through the different items of expenditure and the different sources of income, he discusses with his Department——
Comment on this
It has always been pointed out that this was a ready source from which to swipe £500,000 or £1,000,000. That seems to be the procedure being followed now. It was different in 1952, I think, when the Minister for Local Government, with the sanction of the Minister for Finance, introduced a Bill that was a very unpopular one indeed as far as many sections of the community were concerned. Great play was made with it in the House at the time. The present Minister for Finance and his colleagues put all the obstacles they could in the way of its passage into law. They pointed out the injustice that it was and insisted on an assurance from the Minister that it would be used for no purpose other than the improvement of our roads. The Minister at that time gave the only assurance that he could give, that so long as he was Minister for Local Government, it would be used for no other purpose. It was a real blessing to the people because it held out hope to them that had been delayed so long, that all the roads in time would be brought up to a proper state of repair, thus giving the people the amenities to which, both as ratepayers and taxpayers, they were entitled.
That progress will now be very considerably hampered and obstructed. Half a million pounds is a considerable sum of money and, as I said, it would provide 50 weeks' work for 2,000 wage earners at the modest rate of £5 per week. I have had experience over in the Office of Public Works of having hundreds and thousands of applications for minor relief schemes all over the country and the minor relief schemes, in the main, would give at most 12 weeks' employment. But here you have a fund which was giving at least 50 weeks' employment and that was a very welcome change from having only 12 weeks' employment in the winter period in different parts of the country.
The Minister is taking away from the people that 50 weeks' employment and there is no promise of any alternative employment. If there is to be alternative employment to absorb them, it should be stated. No reasons have been given to justify the injustice that is being perpetrated on what I could term the wages section of our people. There is no excuse given, other than the financial difficulty. We hear every Minister saying that this financial difficulty is of no concern to the ordinary people, that it is only a matter of copybook accountancy. Apparently it is copybook accountancy as far as the Minister for Finance is concerned now in respect of this section. If he is taking £500,000 away in order next year to show a reduction in expenditure and to be in a position to balance the Budget, that is a very poor form of economy, and this copybook accountancy is of more importance to the ordinary people than was indicated by a Minister, according to the Press quite recently.
I take it this is part of a well thought out plan, that this is the forerunner of a direction which, it is rumoured and generally believed all over the country, has been given by the Minister for Finance to every Department of State, that there should be a 33? per cent. cut in all Estimates and in the expenditure on all capital investment schemes and projects. If that is the position, then as regards all the slogans we heard: "Vote for the Coalition,""Vote for Fine Gael,""Vote for full employment, less emigration and better times," we may say that the people who have responded to those appeals have been fairly disappointed during the period in which the Coalition Government have been in office since 1954, but that they will be fully disillusioned very soon. If that is true, then the present Book of Estimates which has been submitted to the Deputies of this House is a faked Book of Estimates.
Comment on this
I hold that this step is a very bad form of economy, if it brings in its train unemployment and emigration, as it is bound to do and that it is far from being consistent with all the appeals that are being made from time to time by members on the Government Benches. I should like to know what is the more useful type of employment which was hinted at by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach yesterday evening. If there is a more useful type of employment, we should all be very glad indeed to hear of it. However, there was not much sign of alternative employment in the reply given to a question put down last week by Deputy Kieran Egan and myself regarding the development of the bogs around Banagher. We were told that Bord na Móna was quite free to change its plans.
Comment on this
The Deputy is travelling very far from the question of the transfer of £500,000 from the Road Fund.
Comment on this
I am merely pointing out that there does not seem to be any hope of alternative employment of a suitable type for the people who are being deprived of employment as a result of this swiping of £500,000 from the Road Fund. Evidently the Government do not intend to carry out all the work which the people in that area were led to believe would be in full swing this summer. I did not have very high expectations of the Coalition promises as regards full employment, the stemming of emigration and the provision of better times; even so, I never believed they would, in such a short time, succeed as well as they have in bringing the country to the verge of misery and bankruptcy, if we are not actually in it at the moment.
It appears now that the only plans the Government have to increase employment and to give us better times is to take advantage of every fund of this kind and collar every penny in order to have this copybook accountancy to present to this House at some future date, even if it means depriving thousands of people of employment and aggravating the emigration evil. The reason the Minister for Finance is doing this—otherwise, I cannot understand his motives—is so that he will be in a position to point out next year the great feat he has accomplished, how he has brought down national expenditure and how, as a result of what he has done in the previous year, he is able to balance the Budget.
If that is the only plan and the only policy, if the Government have any respect at all for the promises made during the 1954 election campaign and the allurements that were held out to the people, they should take cognisance of the direction they were given in the recent by-election in Laois-Offaly and clear out and make room for another Party to take over and stem the decay that is fast setting in.
Comment on this
It might be no harm if I intervened for a few minutes at this stage of the debate on Section 32. Deputy Childers, I must confess, made it very easy for me to intervene by his remarks yesterday. At least, he showed some appreciation of the reason, even though he disagreed with it, that was behind my action, unlike the last speaker. The position is perfectly clear, beyond question, that at the present moment there is not adequate capital available to do all the things that we might wish to do, without risk of further inflation. In those circumstances, it is obviously correct for the Government to adopt certain priorities. We, as a Government, differ from the Fianna Fáil Party in that we think that, to the extent of this £500,000, there are other matters that require greater priority than the main and trunk road works on which this money would otherwise have been spent.
The issue that is before the House in this section is a simple issue. It is this: whether the House would prefer this money to be spent on what I would term polishing trunk roads or on productive schemes that will bring far more value to the national economy as a whole. This is not a question as between other productive schemes and the county roads to which references were made in the debate last night. In last year, 1955-56, we changed the trend and ensured that the trend for grants from the Road Fund would be away from main roads to county roads and, instead of a sum of £1.7 million that was given from the Road Fund in 1954-55, announced by our predecessors before they came into power, last year, for county roads, we gave a sum of £2,200,000 and this year for county roads, or by-roads, as they are called, in our part of the country, a sum of £2,400,000, that is to say, £700,000 more than our predecessors.
There cannot, therefore, be any question that the choice here is between the type of productive work to which we will put this fund or county roads. It is the choice between main arterial trunk roads and the type of work that we regard as having infinitely greater priority for our capital programme. Let me stress that again —for our capital programme.
This money is not being transferred for the purpose to which Deputy Beegan referred, for the purpose of balancing the Budget. It is being transferred, not to any fund that has anything to do with the current Budget at all. It is being transferred for capital purposes and the issue that the House has to decide is a simple one: if the amount of capital that we could so spend is limited because of the inflationary forces that are around us, is it better for the national economy that it should be spent on main trunk roads or on other productive purposes?
I gather from Deputy Childers—he is entitled to his view—that he felt that roads were the most productive form of expenditure. I do not agree with him.
Comment on this
I did not say the most. I asked the Minister whether he had made any calculation. He heard my speech. It was a speech of a technical character. It did not raise a particular issue. I did not say they were the most productive.
Comment on this
I do not want to misinterpret the Deputy. Quite frankly, the implication I got from the Deputy's speech was that he regarded roads as being one of the most productive forms of capital expenditure, or one of the most productive forms of expenditure on which capital was at present being spent in the national economy.
Comment on this
I put it the other way round. I said that increased expenditure on maintenance might succeed in doing what the Minister wanted to do in another direction. It is quite a different way of doing it.
Comment on this
I differ from the Deputy categorically on that. I think that if, because of the inflationary forces that are around us and because of other circumstances, it is necessary to limit capital expenditure to a particular sum, it is far better, for example, that we should take this £500,000 from main trunk roads and utilise it for ensuring that we can carry on the arterial drainage programme on the standard to which it was set rather than that it should be utilised for main roads, that it is better that the land project, the work of getting the land itself back into full heart and full fertility should be done rather than it should be deprived of the £500,000 that is going to the capital fund in this fashion.
Similarly, if there had to be the limitation of capital expenditure, it was better that it should be taken from the Road Fund in this fashion than that housing grants should be cut by £500,000; it is better that it should be utilised out of the capital fund to ensure that there would be some drainage work done under the Local Authorities (Works) Act rather than that it should be spent on main trunk roads. I think the capital fund expenditure would be better utilised on forestry than on main trunk roads to the extent that is included in this section.
Those are the choices. I was told by members of the House last night that I would find it difficult to defend this section. I have no difficulty whatever in defending the section on that basis in any part of the country at any time. Let me be quite clear in relation to what Deputy Beegan said. The decision is mine, my recommendation to the Government, not that of any official or adviser. The decision which I recommended to the Government and which the Government accepted shows that we as a Government have a proper conception of the proper priorities in regard to productive work that will inure to the benefit of the national economy.
We have had too often too little consideration given to the end and the aim of our capital programmes. Spending money on capital projects gives employment at the time at which such expenditure is carried out, but unless it creates permanent assets that will inure to the benefit of the national economy in the future, it will not build up our country and prevent emigration and ensure that we will have a better standard of living. On the contrary, it will mean a dissipation of our resources and it will mean that in the long run we will be worse off rather than better off. It is for that reason I have been harping continuously, inside the House and outside it, that the real test in relation to our capital expenditure must be the productive value which will inure to the economy as a whole when such capital expenditure has been completed and not merely the passing benefit that will arise during the spending of the capital sum in question. That is the basis upon which we test our priorities. On that test, I have no doubt whatever that the country will feel, as I feel, that it is better that this money should be utilised for some of the purposes I have mentioned rather than the purposes for which it would otherwise be used on the main trunk roads.
Comment on this
I submit to the Minister that the transfer of this £500,000 from the Road Fund is a matter of grave local and national concern. These moneys are, after all, the fruits of a tax imposed on users of the public thoroughfares in order to put those thoroughfares into such condition that they will serve the transport system of the country and provide against wear or damage to vehicles.
Local authorities and the community generally are concerned at the ever-increasing tendency to put on local charges and local rates burdens which should be carried by the Exchequer. This is an example of that ever-increasing tendency. This money is collected for a specific purpose. That money will now be diverted and local authorities, in order to provide against the unemployment that may occur as a result of increasing wages, increased costs of transport and increased expenses in the provision of machinery for the improvement of roads, will have to put these charges on to the local rates in their respective counties and districts.
First of all, they have to meet this road tax. Then they must make provision for the roads and they must provide against unemployment. On top of all that, they will have to meet an increased petrol tax. They are paying in three different directions for a particular service. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Government last night compared figures. The results of his comparisons are contrary to the personal knowledge that every member of a local authority has as to the trend. Everybody knows that the funds available to local authorities run out by Christmas. A problem arises in relation to unemployment then on the roads from that until the new rate is struck. Comparing figures now with what the position was a few months ago serves no useful purpose because the results are contrary to the weight of evidence of members of local authorities who deal with these problems.
At the moment, there is considerable unemployment because sufficient money is not available to meet the charges on the roads and to relieve the unemployment that will occur because of increased wages, and so forth. Now people must receive a decent wage if they are to meet present-day costs. Last year we had to provide from local rates something in the region of £33,000 to meet increased wages. If that £500,000 were available, we would not have had to put on the local rates an extra £33,000 to meet increased wages.
Unfortunately the Exchequer is not satisfied even with that. Petrol has increased in price as well. Anyone using a motor vehicle has now to pay an increased road tax, an increased rate and an increased charge for petrol. The increased petrol tax ought to be sufficient for the capital purposes the Minister has in mind. One pound spent inside a fence may be worth £4 spent outside the fence but, at the same time, we must put the roads into proper condition. When there is a special fund for that purpose, the proceeds of that fund should be devoted to that purpose. If the money is not used in that way, an additional charge is thrown back on the local rates. We are up against that, year after year, in our local authorities. That seems to be conveniently forgotten. No account is taken of it. I would emphasise that point to the Minister. The Road Fund should be used for the purpose for which it was established.
The labourer is worthy of his hire. We must meet the increased cost in wages. We must meet the increased costs of providing up-to-date machinery. It is our aim, by the use of suitable machinery, to get more work done for the same amount of money, employing the same number of workers. That is the only advantage that machinery can have for us. We all know that our roads are not up to standard. The people are calling on the local authorities day after day to improve the roads. We must use modern machinery to do that work and we must try to get more work done for the same amount of money, with the same labour content. Local authorities are alarmed at the rising rates, and rightly so. Counties that face their responsibilities and ask their ratepayers to take on additional responsibilities and see that at least the same amount of work is done and that their labourers are paid a decent wage are the counties for which that increase has to be provided. If it is not provided by the Exchequer from the Road Fund, then the local authority rates have to provide it, or they have to put the men on the dole, and the Exchequer will have to pay the dole.
What kind of a system is that? Is it not upsetting the whole economy of the country and discouraging the local people who prefer to work rather than have to draw the dole and so on? Is the main aim not to keep the people employed on useful work? This policy is operating against what is best for the community. If you are putting an additional 1/- or 2/- on the rates to meet these charges when you already have funds collected from taxes to meet the same charges, then you are doing an injustice to the ratepayers and the community generally. If that money is not provided by the ratepayers, then you are doing an injustice to the workers because you are depriving them of the employment they should have.
The position of the road workers now and for the past three months is extremely hazardous and their chances of employment are very low. The result is that they are thrown back on the dole and such things. A man coming home after earning his week's wages is a better man in every way, and his family have pride in the fact they are contributing something to the national welfare and to the upliftment of the State. That is a better policy than to fall back on a continuance of this policy of robbing Peter to pay Paul.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any cogency whatever in the Minister's statement. His memory cannot be so short that he forgets the case which he and his colleagues made when the road tax was increased a few years ago for the purpose of servicing the roads. There were so many pleas made, both on behalf of the motorist and also for the benefit of county councils and road authorities, that they elevated the payment of road tax on a motor car into a contract between the central authority and the owner of the motor car—a contract of such a kind that it would be almost a criminal offence for any authority, central or local, to apply this money to any purpose other than roads. So far did they go with the argument and so many guarantees did they ask from the Minister for Local Government at the time, that the members of the Fianna Fáil Party who listened to these arguments taking place across the floor of the House were convinced that, when this Road Fund had done the greater part of its job and when a lesser amount of money would be required to keep the roads in their newly improved state, from that point on, it would be immoral to collect this high rate of motor taxation and that the motorists would receive a reduction in their motor tax.
I do not think the Minister forgets that that is the case they made: that the only justification for motor taxation at all was the fact that every penny received in respect of it would go into the roads. They did not even classify the public roads for this expenditure. One felt that, if the main roads had been serviced, they would be in favour of applying the produce of this taxation to all the other roads used by the owners of motor vehicles.
I do not know whether one is permitted to speak about comparative sources of employment, because the money is being transferred to a capital fund. But let me say this about employment: I think, even viewing this matter on that narrow issue, I would say in reply to what the Minister has just said that, in view of present circumstances and in view of the information revealed by the recent partial census, the best expenditure at the moment for the purpose of influencing the trend of emigration would be this widespread expenditure on roads all over the Twenty-Six Counties.
I had a question down some time ago to the Minister for Local Government asking that he would specially arrange that county councils would be permitted to resurface their county roads at their existing widths. He pointed out that his predecessor had provided that these roads should be widened where necessary to 18 feet before any such dressing or resurfacing took place. I put this request to him in the nature of a question because of the very many representations that were made to me in my constituency by motor owners who have to use these roads. Very many of these roads are in a very bad condition, and what has been happening in recent years is that the increase in the number of vehicles using these roads has aggravated that bad pot-holed condition. The result is that the eventual job will be more costly when the county councils come to tackle it.
If the Minister—he referred to the Local Authorities (Works) Act and I take it he views it as capital expenditure—had transferred this £500,000 for that purpose, possibly he might be able to make a plausible case that the money was to be expended for a purpose for which, in the main, road taxation is imposed; but I do not think he can make that case in respect of arterial drainage or of any of the other desirable projects which are progressing around the country. Quite apart from the question of employment there is a pressing need in this regard, and I am speaking particularly for the areas which do not benefit so much from the industries set up by private enterprises through the creation of this capital fund or other methods, areas which do not gain so much by the expenditure on arterial drainage and which have not benefited so much even from rural electrification as have other areas. These certainly could have benefited very much by a continuance of expenditure at recent levels and, in fact, by an increase in it.
The previous Government were very much alive to this necessity when they established the fund known as the Tourist Road Development Fund. I was very much surprised and, I must say, disappointed when I heard the Minister for Local Government speak about autobahns for plutocrats.
If there has been a sort of objection created to expenditure on that type of road, it can only arise from the fact that the job undertaken by Deputy Smith, as Minister for Local Government, has in fact, been very largely achieved, but I do not think even the Minister for Finance will agree that it has been completed. In any event, even if it has been completed, for the reasons that I have stated, the checking of emigration in the remote areas, the improvement of the county roads and generally in those western areas the aiding of the tourist industry by the improvement of the roads leading to resorts, then all these arguments would still be sufficient to make a good case for the retention of the Road Fund at its income level.
Deputy MacCarthy has referred to the difficulties of local authorities in providing all the moneys necessary for the public services which they administer. These difficulties are greater to-day than they have been at any time since the end of the war. In reducing this fund by a sum of £500,000 the Minister is still further accentuating these difficulties.
Personally, I think that the Minister will have to give some reasons other than those which he has stated to induce the public generally to accept that the conditions which induced him and his colleagues a few years ago to make this fund almost a sacred contract between those who pay motor taxes and the Minister for Finance no longer exist. He will have to adduce some better arguments to satisfy the public that those arguments no longer hold. It is a complete volte-face on his part to adduce now that the requirements of capital for industry generally are a sufficient justification for raiding a fund that had so very special and inviolable a character as was represented a few years ago.
I cannot quote exactly the words used by the Minister and his colleagues but I have a very vivid and distinct recollection of the enthusiasm, the vigour and the punch which they put into the case at the time against increasing the taxation in the first instance, and if in fact there was any case for increasing it that its purpose should be the one and only purpose of improving the main roads. We now on this side of the House are availing of this the first opportunity since that increase in taxation to hold the Minister and his colleagues to the case which they then made. We are making it our case for the purpose of deciding this issue.
Comment on this
I must say I was glad to hear the Minister try to throw a faint murky light on the problem of raising capital for various State construction schemes this year. It is good to know from him that at least we face not merely a copybook problem, as suggested by the Minister for Defence, but a real problem. It makes it very difficult for members of the Opposition, such as myself, to hear the Minister for Finance say he has regretfully had to take £500,000 from the Road Fund for other more urgent capital purposes and when I go down to my constituency at the week-end and have to deal with the Minister for Defence, to be told that it is a copybook problem, that it can be easily managed and that it is not really the concern of the ordinary man. So we find it rather hard on this side of the House. We would have to recognise whether or not the cause has been the general treatment of financial problems by the Coalition Parties since the war.
If we have a shortage of capital at least we can consider what the priorities are but it is very hard for us to consider what they are when we have the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government waving £500,000 of external assets before the people week after week without mentioning the liabilities we have incurred to other countries and the Minister for Defence saying it is merely a copybook problem. Now we have the Minister for Finance saying that he prefers to carry out arterial drainage schemes to polishing the main roads. I agree with him. We would all prefer to do that. That is what he meant by the grant of £500,000 from the Road Fund to the local authorities. I think myself it is a gross exaggeration. Furthermore we find it still more difficult to discuss this question of the £500,000 from the Road Fund when the Minister for Finance said in his Budget speech that the people of this country will have to save at least twice as much as last year in one form or another if he was going to get through any important or notable part of the construction programme. At the same time, we have the copybook theory from the Minister for Defence down in County Longford. We understand from the Minister that capital is short. He has a list of priorities in his mind which he really has not given to the House. We have to consider the whole question in that light. I understand that the contribution from the National Development Fund is also being cut. So we are really dealing with £1,000,000 cut on the Road Fund. In relation to this £500,000, the amount contributed from the National Development Fund which was wholly towards county roads, other roads and some special employment schemes, has to be considered. This has all to be considered in the light of the amount spent by the State in one form or another.
Comment on this
I could not find the reference as to how exactly it was spent. I only found the total expenditure from all sources last year. I could not get the figures at short notice for these purposes. I am arguing from the particular standpoint of whether it is a good form of economy, even in relation to any priorities in the use of capital. There is absolutely no evidence that the Minister for Local Government, of any Government for that matter, ever indulged in some really keen thinking on the cost of poor communications to retail prices, export prices and the cost of exporting our produce. As far as I know, no one has ever done it. We regarded road expenditure far too much on a county to county basis, on a sentimental basis, on a basis involving immediate employment. I think, now that capital is scarce, it is about time the Minister for Local Government started inquiring. That has been carried out in other countries. The results have been published. The effect of poor communications on roads causing damage to vehicles is well known and accepted.
I do not mean merely roads in a shocking condition, but roads that create vibration of a continuous pattern. It is about time we started some investigation of that kind. I am not arguing that we should stop arterial drainage in order to carry on the work of the roads. I am arguing that we ought to have more information from the Minister for Finance as to why he places the expenditure of £500,000 in a low capital priority. He has not given me convincing technological arguments. I do not think he has given any members of the House proper arguments or even an idea of priorities to enable us to debate this question properly.
There is a very good labour content in road work, whether it is roads repaired by machinery or otherwise. It gives employment to people who in many cases are not skilled in any other form of work. For that reason, we are concerned with this matter. There is also the human approach to this problem. It is perfectly ridiculous for a Minister of the present Government to quote figures in respect of unemployment. In connection with that matter, we had some member of the Opposition yesterday—I forget who— citing unemployment figures that no longer have any meaning whatever, and this in spite of the fact that we know there is a smaller number of people to be employed on the roads this year on account of the reduction in the grant.
People are emigrating so rapidly that they leave practically within 48 hours of losing their jobs. There are many cases known to us personally where people do not wait even 24 hours to get on the boat to take up a job that is waiting for them. In Great Britain, there has been a continuous scarcity of unskilled and semi-skilled labour for construction work, and skilled labour for housing and construction work of all kinds. For heaven's sake, let us be realistic in this House. With the recent census before us, it is ridiculous to start citing unemployment figures. There is a rapid shift to Great Britain, if anybody loses his job. There are exceptions, of course. For instance, people are prevented, through family circumstances, from leaving the country and they have to stay with their parents.
Let us be frank about the matter. Any reduction of expenditure involving the use of semi-skilled labour on the roads is bound to give rise to some unemployment and will result in emigration. That is part of our problem. The Minister has told the people to save as much as they did in 1955. It is impossible for them to do that without affecting the content of employment in this country, and, whether it is necessary or not, it is impossible to do it.
We are living in a world of half-truths at the moment because the Government is composed of Ministers who disagree with one another in regard to their approach to this problem. As a result of that atmosphere, we are not given a proper category of priorities in connection with the capital scheme and we are not given a full appreciation of the facts in regard to the necessity for savings in order to continue any of our construction work. We are debating in vacuo. Whether or not communication expenditure comes within a high, middle or low priority, the Minister for Finance has not made it much clearer to us to-day.
Comment on this
Arising out of what Deputy Childers and some of the other Opposition speakers said about this section, it seems to me that their attitude is similar to that expressed by an English politician over the past fortnight about people in general. They are in favour of general economy and in favour of particular expenditure. That is precisely the problem that is before the House with regard to this sum from the Road Fund.
Deputy Childers spoke with much truth about the question of unemployment and the drop in employment which any reduction in road works will create. If we are to tell the whole truth about this matter, we must consider whether there would not be a similar reduction in employment if we cut off some other capital project financed by the State at present. It seems to me that if you cut out one capital project, there will be an abatement in employment in that case.
It is true that the question of communications does have an effect and probably a more subtle effect than is generally realised, on costings, not only for internal distribution, but for export as well. As a person who travels around the country, it does seem to me that whatever the effect is it must be at its minimum at the moment in regard to the main roads. If the purpose of this reduction was to reduce the amount of work done on the secondary or smaller roads, then one might be gravely concerned with the question of distribution costs, particularly distribution costs in regard to the export of agricultural products.
Again, as one who does a lot of travelling on main roads throughout the country, I can say they are at the stage for this year, in most parts of the country, where a reduction of work on them is not going to have any appreciable effect in hindering, obstructing, making more costly or slowing up the distribution of goods of any description. If that is so, the Minister has made out clearly the case for this reduction.
There is no use in the Fianna Fáil Party coming into this House, as they did on the Budget debate, howling to high heaven about expenditure and creating as much panic as they could about where money was to be got for capital as well as for ordinary supply services and then coming in here on a specific section of the Finance Act and saying: "Here is a case in which the difficulties of obtaining capital have been recognised. Here is a case in which in one sense an economy has been effected and the whole question of priorities clearly recognised, but we do not like it because it affects employment and because we have a general vague notion about the desirability of keeping the main roads in good order." If they are going to face up to this in a general way and if their attitude with regard to the provision of capital, and particularly with regard to the priority of capital, is right, then if they believe that this is one of the Government expenditures which should come before some other capital projects which are maintained or which have been increased, let us hear about it. These capital projects are for everyone to see. They are in the Estimates, as well as the amount of them, and the comparison is there between this year and last year. If any Deputy believes this is a particular capital project which comes in priority to some of the others which are being maintained or which have been increased this year, that is a matter for serious consideration by the House.
It does not seem to me to assist the debate, and certainly it does not seem to assist the consideration of this section, for Deputies opposite to say: "We do not like the reduction because, as a solitary instance, it causes some reduction in employment, and, looking at it as a solitary instance, there are advantages to be got from expenditure on main roads." Of course, one of its by-products and advantages is a certain amount of employment. If somebody points a finger at some other capital project which is being undertaken this year on the same scale or on a larger scale than last year and says: "I believe the last"—and it is the last —"£500,000 to the Road Fund for main roads ranks in priority to that scheme in the national interest", that argument is worthy of consideration, but that argument has not been put forward.
The Minister has made a case for this section and for the realisation that the question of capital priorities must be kept in front bearing in mind the fact that he has not touched the amount of money that will be spent on county or secondary roads. In point of fact, the policy of this Government has been to increase that work and particularly in proportion to the main roads. The state of the main roads at present seems to justify the view that some reduction in expenditure on them this year would be the least harmful way of reducing the capital expenditure of the State.
Comment on this
Like my colleagues, I wish to protest against the Minister's decision to take £500,000 out of the Road Fund. When he was speaking about the £500,000 an hour ago, the Minister tried to point out that it was not national progress to improve our roads. I hold it is. I hold that it is very important to have good roads. We have too many prairie tracks in this country yet. We need to go ahead with spending more and more money on our main and trunk roads before we shall get our roads into any kind of condition at all. They are talking about the main roads here. We have over 10,000 miles of main roads and the main roads that have been referred to and that have been put into a reasonable state of repair would be only about 680 miles out of the 10,000. That is a very small mileage, out of the 10,000 miles of main roads, to be repaired.
Down the country you see crosses and statues and various other monuments at dangerous corners where men and women have been killed. Surely, if this House does anything about removing dangerous corners, thus saving life, we shall at least contribute something worth while to the nation. There have been misrepresentations about the position. The Minister said he does not want to polish the main roads. If you go off the main road at all, you will find yourself in a prairie track, in a lot of the counties. As recently as last Sunday, I was down the country and I went off one of the main roads. I was afraid I would break a spring in the old car while I was off the main road, and that is the position with everybody else.
We were up against this question before. The Coalition Government cut the Road Fund on another occasion by £2,000,000. When we resumed office, we found that the roads had deteriorated considerably. It is important to national progress that we should have good roads. Furthermore, the Minister could easily allocate some money towards the minor roads, the very minor roads and the cul-de-sac roads which we still have. A very strong case can be made for their improvement. Surely any intelligent person can appreciate the difficulty which farmers experience in having to bring machinery and farm produce along these roads. The state of some of them is shocking. I spoke on this matter on the Vote for the Department of Local Government and I asked the Minister if it was possible to allocate some money for the improvement of these cul-de-sac roads and very minor roads because their present condition is placing the farmers concerned at a great disadvantage.
We have heard the foolish remark about polishing a certain section of our roads. Only 680 miles out of 10,000 miles of main roads have been touched. The remainder are in a shocking condition. I do not want to mention any particular roads just now. My principal reason for intervening in the debate is to protest against the decision of the Government on this matter. It is a completely retrograde step to interfere with the Road Fund.
Not alone did the previous Minister for Local Government try to improve the roads, but we had a special development fund from which he gave liberally for road improvement. We shall have to continue that for a considerable number of years before our roads are in any proper condition at all. We are anxious to encourage our tourist industry, to improve it and to bring people to our country. I do not know of any better way of encouraging people to visit us than by saying that our country has the name, at least, of having good roads. We want tourists. They will help to solve our adverse trade balance problem. They have helped us since the tourist industry first started here and we want them to continue to visit us.
Considerable work was done on tourist roads as a result of the Act which was passed by the Oireachtas. Until the passing of that Act, we had a number of tourist roads which were prairie tracks. It was wise to give an allocation towards the improvement of roads in those parts of the country where the scenic beauty is such as to attract visitors. Now, the Minister for Finance comes along and says we do not want to polish main roads. We have only about 680 miles of main roads which are in any moderate repair out of a total of 10,000 miles of main roads.
Comment on this
I do not want the Parliamentary Secretary to misunderstand me. I am trying to point out that there are thousands of miles of main roads that have not been touched at all.
Comment on this
Some day, when the Parliamentary Secretary has time, or if he is able to take a few days off, I will bring him along some of them.
Comment on this
I will bring the Parliamentary Secretary along a number of roads in my constituency, not far from Dublin City, where you would want a pilot to walk in front of you to guide you along them.
Comment on this
On some of the roads in Deputy Burke's constituency, you would require a compass, they are so wide and big.
Comment on this
I think it must be to O'Connell Street the Deputy is referring because I do not know any road in my constituency as wide as that which the Deputy seems to have in mind.
Comment on this
I deplore the step that has been taken by the Government in robbing the Road Fund of the money that should go into the roads. As other speakers have said, motorists or owners of motor vehicles are faced with higher taxation, insurance and wear and tear costs and I feel that they should at least get reasonably good roads on which to travel. I can point out a number of reasons why the Road Fund should not be interfered with. I can mention that we still have a number of dangerous bends on roads throughout the country and even in my constituency. People have been killed as a result of these bad bends. I am not going to say to this House that people have not been killed on the straight roads but more accidents happen on dangerous bends. I am sure the House will agree that a number of people, both men and women, are still being killed as a result of dangerous bends. I feel the House has a responsibility to try to eliminate the cause of these accidents and that can only be done by removing those bends.
From time to time we were told what Fianna Fáil was to spend, including so much money on roads. We looked upon that as national advancement and felt it was our duty to see that we should have good roads in the country. As regards our ordinary county roads, the cul-de-sac roads, and other roads, we have yet a long way to go before they are improved even to the satisfaction of those who live beside them. It is easy to stand up in this House and say that Fianna Fáil wanted the roads for the special touring cars but that is a misrepresentation of the facts as they were put before the House. This misrepresentation is going on all the time. We had to listen to that when we were trying to encourage tourism and when we were told that the hotels we were fostering were white elephants. We have to cope with the same criticism here to-day but so long as I am here, I feel bound to voice my opinion as to what is right for the country. I do not want to play any political game. I could go a long way if I began to remind the Minister and his Party and the people who make up the inter-Party Government about their promises, but I will refrain from that on this occasion. I am dealing with this problem simply and solely from the national point of view, and it is in the national interest that we should carry on with the improvement of roads and eliminate loss of life. We should try to ensure as far as possible in the future that people are not killed because of dangerous roads.
From the point of view of employment, road work is also of great national importance. I understand that the spending of £500,000 in a year would give employment to approximately 1,600 workers. That, in a situation where we have heavy emigration, would be of considerable help. We have heard the Minister and those who support him, speak about arterial drainage and about the Local Authorities (Works) Act. What about productive schemes, they ask? We are all anxious to have productive schemes but we are also anxious that other schemes should go on. I was very sorry when the Minister made this decision because I had seen the effect of the decision of the previous inter-Party Government when they cut down the road grant by over £2,000,000. As a matter of fact there were so many springs broken on roads down the country during the last period of the inter-Party Government that it would take at least three years of Fianna Fáil Government to restore the roads, even partially, to their previous condition.
Are we now to revert to that policy? We are told this money is wanted for other essential purposes. I think the best thing the inter-Party Government could do would be to open up canals and get the people to travel by them because, apparently, the Government does not like to improve the roads at all.
If we are to have it stated here that to improve roads as other advanced nations do, is not national work, I feel it is a deplorable attitude on the part of the Minister for Finance and the members of the Government. It is bad from the country's point of view and also from the employment point of view that this fund should not benefit the people for whom it was created and who apparently need its benefit very badly.
Comment on this
Apparently the moment the Government changes in this country, pot-holes appear in the main roads. I do not agree with Deputy Burke and I think a number of his colleagues on the other side of the House do not agree with him either. I believe we have spent far too much money developing the major road systems of this country, money out of all proportion to the resources of the country in which we live. The main road from here to Cork is a magnificent affair now, and one could really drive eight cars breast for three-quarters of it. I do not think that is necessary. They have cut it straight through from horizon to horizon, taken off enormous corners, removed hills and eaten into very valuable agricultural land, and I am not sure that we want it at all.
I am quite sure that if the ultimate cost of extending that kind of system to all the road lengths about which Deputy Burke speaks became known, the people would turn and rend us if we were to spend that money. Many people for years have been objecting to this enormous and lavish expenditure on the roads. The word was borrowed from another language— autobahn—but it is the word which perfectly describes the kind of thing our engineers are constructing now with the active support of the Custom House. I drove over 2,000 miles in Italy last summer and most of the main roads there would take two buses abreast, one passing the other. They are narrow roads mostly; and when we talk about our tourist industry and compare the Italian returns from tourism, I think the Italians have proved that it does not require enormous road widths or any enormous autobahn to bring tourists along. In fact, if anything, I think that the great wide road is an ugly and horrible-looking thing in our landscape and it certainly is not necessary.
If this decision of the Minister indicates that there is now a trend towards a more modest conception of our road needs in this country, that alone is a very desirable and good thing. I do not care at all about the proposals made by many Deputies that we have many dangerous bends and that they should be removed. I think that we should put bends into some of our roads at least. They were safer when they were narrower, because people drove more carefully.
If you get a man arriving at one of our cities after driving 100 miles from another city on a very fast concrete surface, the moment he enters a place where there should be, and would be in other cities, a speed limit, he is a dangerous driver. Having driven for 100 miles at a great speed, he has not the same concept of safety as would have a driver who had only done a short journey. A lot of accidents take place near the end of long journeys on fast roads. It is a great thing to see that proper priorities are being recognised by this Minister, and that one of the last down on our list is that kind of road that we have had under construction in this country in the past ten years.
Comment on this
This question as to the expenditure of money on roads so as to make them better roads appears to appeal to those who advocate that the roads are necessary merely for the purpose of expanding the interests of tourists and to modernise their convenience. Otherwise, there is not a general demand from the community for big expenditure on the roads, which are at present in very good condition generally. If the problems of this country can be solved by expanding our roads and making what is already good better, then the solution to our whole economic problem is very easy, and the Government should surely have concentrated very much, if that problem can be solved, on more and more expenditure on the roads.
My point of view is that we are just short-circuiting the whole problem and evading the whole issue by discussing here and there the question of how much money should be spent on the roads and how many men can be employed thereon, without regard to the results. If tourism is our problem and our aim, then I suggest that, however desirable it would be, what is of still greater national importance and a much greater step towards solving our economic problem, is to keep the people we have at home at home, and stop this flow of emigration. People at home working, however meagre their lives may be at home, are a national asset, and their families are the same, and the loss of these cannot be replaced by any temporary gain we may secure by the inducement to additional tourists to spend a few months or a few weeks of the year in our country, and thus provide foreign currency for the State, and provide, of course, more employment for the men who are preparing these luxurious roads.
My own impression is that the Government should tackle this problem, not in an isolated way, as a unit and as a matter of expediency, but as part of the whole economic problem of the country, and see how far are our transport needs catered for, and how far that can be done to the best advantage of the whole community and in the most economical way. We have different forms of transport here. We have the canals, to which one Deputy has already referred; we have the railways, which are in a very precarious position. The State is paying for the maintenance of all those. Are all those forms of transport actually needed? How many of them, if any, can we discard, and save expenditure in that way?
Comment on this
The Deputy may not discuss all forms of transport on this section. The section deals solely with the transfer of £500,000 from the Road Fund to another fund. It does not open the way to a general discussion on transport.
Comment on this
Then, am I not entitled to suggest ways and means by which economy on all transport may be secured?
Comment on this
So long as it is relevant to the transfer of £500,000, as provided under the section, from the Road Fund.
Comment on this
Yes, but to what source? It does not state any specific plan to transfer it to any particular Department.
Comment on this
I think the decision could hardly have been made to introduce this section as an item referring to the Road Fund, and try to separate that from all the other forms of transport which we have to take responsibility for.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy would be going very wide if he discussed all forms of transport.
Comment on this
I assure you that I will not transgress very far afield at all. I will keep as near the facts as I see reason to do so. I will not delay you, Sir, or the House, if I refer in a general way at the opening of my speech to what I consider should be the direction in which this proposal to allocate a certain sum of money to one form of transport should be considered. I think I have a right to draw conclusions and parallels as to where it might be saved in another direction, or not spent at all. A general survey of our entire transport would be the first essential to the Government in spending so much money on those roads as has been done, as well as in the new proposals.
Comment on this
I have not the least intention, if you allow me to proceed, of transgressing beyond what is reasonable to a discussion of this section. I think I am entitled to draw a parallel, and if you make the case that, say, £500,000 or £5,000,000 is a sum of money belonging to the State and being spent in a certain direction, I am entitled to suggest that you should reconsider spending it in other directions in which I feel the expenditure would bring better results.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is correct in that, he could also discuss the whole question of agriculture on the section.
Comment on this
I have no intention of doing it, but if I discussed the wellbeing of this State, whether I mentioned it or not, agriculture being the foundation of the State, I must include, by implication anyway.
Comment on this
The Deputy may discuss the transfer of £500,000 from the Road Fund to the Capital Fund. That is all the section deals with.
Comment on this
It is a State fund, and accordingly is subject to criticism by any Deputy in this House. If I am not allowed to proceed further on that, all I can say is that we do not get a chance here of discussing a conception from the broad national point of view when discussion arises.
Comment on this
From the Road Fund, right, which is a State-controlled institution. Reference has been made here by previous speakers to the fact that the removal of bends on the roads would make a great improvement as regards accidents. That has been a disputed point, and evidence has been submitted by experience from statistics to show that, in reality, it is not a safeguard against accidents. If that be the argument on which we base our claim to extend our present system of roads, the removal of all bends, then I think we should have an inquiry to see was it justified, because, in my limited way, I have seen reports where that is no advantage. What is undoubtedly a useful form is to spend more money on the by-roads, which are really a disgrace and a terrible indictment of our system of encouraging the rural population to remain at home.
While it is very desirable to have a good trunk road, it is more desirable to have a good road over which our poorer people must travel from their homes to churches, towns and schools. The majority of those people do not use motor cars. Their feet, their horses and traps and their bicycles are their only mode of conveyance. If that be the general demand—and it is the predominant demand—from that section of the community, then it is our duty to see that we produce for them roads that they can use so that they can enjoy the ordinary amenities of life by securing for them at least a clean foot in travelling over those roads by their simple mode of transport. To that extent, I am opposed to spending so much money on improving what is already a very excellent service. I am talking about the transport vein—the main roads used for the immense heavy traffic of the motor car.
The rural community may not have much money but they are a great national asset. Every penny Governments can spend on them will be of benefit to the country. As I have already stated, by spending more money on the rural community we would be concentrating on keeping our own people at home and, accordingly, on building up our real national asset. In that way we would be doing work of much greater national importance than by advertising the good condition of our roads from town to town and from city to city.
I see a certain advantage in devoting limited expenditure to the improvement of our main roads since it gives a certain amount of employment to workers engaged on improving such roads. However, if the only proposal in that direction we have is the drawing of money from our ratepayers and taxpayers to give work on main roads —an already good service—then we are bankrupt of ideas. The State is bankrupt in planning if it cannot provide ideas which would be more practical and more productive. Roads are not productive. They are an asset in their own way, but they do not produce anything. There are other things which could be improved with greater national benefit. Other things such as land and industry, where workers produce something, should be improved upon in the national interest. When we begin work of that kind we will have reached a stage of practical progress; we will be producing something in the way of national wealth. If we keep on spending money on schemes such as those we indulge in at the moment we are paving our way to a final act of ruin. Having heard so much about the present state of our finances and the necessity for increased production, I thought that the Minister would have indicated in a more general and detailed way such as this section indicates, some means by which money taken from the ratepayers, taxpayers and others for the improvement of undertakings of a practical nature——
Comment on this
Not very much. I am getting to the foundation of things, which is important. If I were to submit matters fundamental to the general economy, it is not £500,000 we would be discussing on this section; I would like to see it £50,000,000. I should like to speak about the system adopted by the Government in the giving of grants to county councils. Grants are made available for the improvement of roads on condition that a local contribution of a specified amount will be made by the county council. When a grant of, say, £5,000, £10,000 or £20,000 is offered to a county council it is conditional on the council raising a certain amount locally. No grant will be given without the undertaking that a local contribution of a specified sum will be made available.
County councils are in debt because this inducement is held out to them year after year. They are induced to make contributions beyond their capacity to meet in the ordinary way. The employment given is more than offset by the staggering result of having to pay excessive rates. I think these conditions should be withdrawn by the Government. The Government should not seek to tempt the poorer counties by the holding out of this bait and saying: "If you give £1 the Government will give £2." The maintenance of main roads is a matter entirely for the State. Such work is beyond the capacity of county councils.
Comment on this
That is a matter for the Department of Local Government and should have been raised on the Estimate for that Department.
Comment on this
The section is very simple: it deals with the transfer of £500,000 from the Road Fund to the Capital Fund. It does not give the Deputy the liberty he tries to enjoy in this debate.
Comment on this
I am sorry. That is all I wish to say. I hope the Government will learn from the discussion that the demand for the improvement of minor roads is general here in the House and throughout the country. From the distribution of money from the Road Fund, local authorities should get a much bigger proportion for the improvement of these roads which would, in turn, improve the amenities of the people in rural Ireland and help to keep them at home.
Comment on this
I think the members of the House who are also members of local authorities will agree that the greatest problem facing local authorities at the present time, for a number of years past and for a number of years to come, is the question of roads—to try to deal with the problem of the ever-increasing demand for better roads, particularly in respect of county roads. It is only natural that we on this side of the House should protest in the strongest possible terms against the Government's action in extracting from the Road Fund the sum of £500,000 which could be well spent on county roads throughout the country and which could be giving very useful employment.
The Minister entered into the discussion this afternoon to explain the Government's attitude in connection with this matter. He outlined the policy of the present Government in regard to roads generally. He informed us that since the present Government came in, their policy was to give greater grants for county roads, and I think he mentioned an increase of something like £700,000. But the Minister did not tell us that there was a substantial reduction in the grants made available to local authorities for improvements to main roads. The net result of the juggling that went on is that local authorities to-day are receiving less money by way of grants from the Government than they did under the Fianna Fáil Government.
The question of main roads has been dealt with here by a number of Deputies. A substantial amount of work has been done on main roads in my constituency, even since the present Government took office, and I am 100 per cent. behind the Department in their efforts to improve the main roads in County Wicklow and other parts of the country because, by doing so, they are helping to save the lives of many people. A number of corners have been taken off the main Dublin to Wexford road in County Wicklow, but there was one which remained for some time. The result was that some 18 months ago two people lost their lives. I do not think that even the sum of £500,000 would justify the loss of two lives occurring because we did not take off the corner, or because we did not widen a road as it should have been widened.
Modern transport and modern cars are built for speed and they will speed. Therefore, the duty of the local authority and the Government is to try to make the roads a little more safe than they have been. If the manufacturers of cars build them in such a way that they will travel faster than they did heretofore, then the only thing we can do is to meet the situation by improving the standard of our main roads. I am fully behind any improvements that are taking place in my constituency and I think I can say the same for any improvements I see throughout the country. As I said, however, there is an ever-increasing demand by the ratepaying community for better county roals. As far as Wicklow is concerned, we have availed of every opportunity and of every grant possible to improve our county roads and I think we can claim to have done as good a job as any other county in Ireland; but there are many more miles of roads in my county which need to be put in a passable condition, many miles of road which are the responsibility of the local authority and which are classed as public roads, not to mention the number of roads that are not yet classed as public roads, the by-ways and the boreens. There is a difficult problem facing local authorities at the present time and I believe the Government are wrong in transferring this money.
It is very hard to understand the attitude of the Labour Party, in particular, in regard to this matter. When they attend local authority meetings, they are for ever making demands for increases in wages. Quite recently, we had a demand from trade unions for an increase in road workers' wages in my constituency. That is one of the reasons why I stood up here to express my views on this question. It is very hard to fathom the Labour Party. When they go down the country, they expect or demand increases in wages for their union members; notwithstanding that, they come up here and support the Government in reducing the grants that are made available to local authorities.
Comment on this
It is true. As recently as Monday last, we dealt with this question of road workers' wages.
Comment on this
I am saying it is very difficult to understand the attitude of the Labour Party in this regard. When the Wicklow County Council was striking the rate last year, in an effort to keep up the standard of employment and to maintain the same mileage of reconstructed roads, they increased the rates by 10d. in the £. Nevertheless the members of the Labour Party in the Government and supporting the Government are allowing the Department of Local Government to reduce our grants substantially. None of the Deputies from that Party made any attempt here to justify or to give any reason to the House, or the general public, for their attitude in this regard. It is all right for trade unions to make demands for increased wages, but they are in a good position as far as Wicklow is concerned because we have a member of the Cabinet who is a member of the local authority in that county and other members of the Dáil who are members of the trade unions concerned, and these people could have used their influence with the Government to see to it that we would receive increased grants. Even at this stage, if I got any guarantee that we would get an increase in our grants for this year, I would certainly have no objection to giving an increase in wages to road workers——
Comment on this
I have already pointed out that the question of wages to road workers is not relevant.
Comment on this
The question I am dealing with is the robbing of the Road Fund and the Labour Party allowing it to be robbed. They are the Party concerned. As far as the Fine Gael Party is concerned, we would not expect anything from them but the causing of unemployment, if possible. That has always been their policy, but we were expecting something more from the Labour Party and I have yet to hear a member of that Party standing up to justify their action in this regard.
Comment on this
The position before us this evening seems to be that we have been spending too much money on the roads and that that position must stop. Having listened to that argument being used in that way, we can rightly ask the members of the Government whether it is true that our roads are too good or, on the other hand, whether, taking another side of the picture, we have over-employment in rural Ireland at the moment. We can also ask whether or not the people paying taxation on motor vehicles to-day are paying too much or too little.
If the people in Government to-day were to be consistent—of course, it would be too much to expect that they would be at this stage—with the views they expressed when the road taxes were increased to their present level three years ago, when they deplored the increase then levied on the people using the roads, to-day, instead of the Road Fund being raided and the money put to other uses, the Government would be relieving the road users by reductions in motor taxation to the tune of £500,000. Apparently, they do not intend to do that. Rather do they intend to use this money for some other purpose. Despite the platitudes that were uttered here by the Minister for Finance a short while ago about all the various worthy capital uses to which this £500,000 will be put, I am still trying to find out exactly to what capital uses he intends to put this money. To my knowledge, he has not given any concrete plan as to how this money will be spent. He has been beating about the bush in regard to this matter but he has not given any concrete evidence that the money which is now being taken unjustly from a fund which was for the upkeep of the roads will be put to better use.
During the course of his recent contribution to the debate the Minister gave the House to understand that the financial position of the country is such that it is better to use this money for some unspecified capital development than to use it for capital development on roads. Despite the fact that it must be a very grave financial emergency that brings about this pruning of the Road Fund, colleagues of the present Minister for Finance in the Cabinet are stamping around the country telling us that this does not matter, that there is no real crisis before this country at the present moment and that all the talk going on is purely political propaganda emanating from and disseminated by Fianna Fáil in order to bring about the fall of this Government.
In the past week the Minister for Defence made a speech that will live for quite a long time, not for any good sound sense that it contained but for the bunkum that can be read into it. He indicated, as already stated from this side of the House earlier this evening, that this matter of £500,000 taken from the Road Fund is purely a bookkeeping matter and is of no concern to the ordinary people. On the other hand, if we do not like to lay too much weight on the financial pronouncements of the Minister for Defence, we can take the example of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, Deputy O'Donovan, last night in the House. With his educational background, he should say something worth listening to and his opinions should carry some weight in these matters. He also said that we were not really in any great financial crisis.
If we can take the word of the Minister for Defence or of the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy O'Donovan, that there is no financial crisis to bother the ordinary people of this country, why is the Minister for Finance tearing his hair trying to find money and being driven to such straits that he must take it from the Road Fund, a fund that was established in 1953 by the then Minister for Local Government and which was not to be touched for any purpose other than for the upkeep and maintenance of roads? That was an undertaking given in this House by the then Minister for Local Government. It was given inside the House and outside the House. That word was maintained until the present year. To-day that promise has been broken by the present Minister and Government.
We want to know is there a financial crisis? Does the Cabinet agree that there is a financial crisis or can we have one member of the Cabinet saying that there is a crisis and another few members going in the other direction and saying that there is none? Is there any solidity about this Government? Do they ever sit down together and decide once and for all that there is a crisis or that there is not? Can we not expect from them some agreed statement in regard to our financial position? Surely that is the least that we can expect at this stage from a Government.
Comment on this
When the Minister was in the House last week, he took no pains to avoid being personal so far as I was concerned.
Comment on this
Deputy Blaney will allow me. The Minister may not refer to a Deputy as "a dirty and scurrilous speaker".
Comment on this
I want to know, and I think I am entitled to know, so is every member of this House and so are the people outside, have we to-day a financial crisis of the magnitude that demands that the Road Fund should be raided to the extent of £500,000 when throughout the country, on the western seaboard in particular, there are roads over which it is impossible to pass at the moment, which are supposed to serve the people in these regions? Is the raiding of the Road Fund justified unless a financial crisis of huge magnitude faces us? Are we not entitled to know the position? Are we not entitled to ask, and to get an answer in a reasonably short space of time, whether this Government is represented by one, two, three, four or five different spokesmen? Will we have a statement denying the suggestions and statements of the Parliamentary Secretary last night and of the Minister for Defence during the last week, that there is no financial crisis?
Comment on this
The Deputy may not discuss in detail the financial position of the country on Section 32.
Comment on this
Very good, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. Getting back to the debate that took place here last night, in which the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government stated that on the average, the cost of reconstructing a mile of county road was £1,500, I contend that as a matter of figures, that statement is inaccurate, but, taking the figure as given and applying it to the position as we now find it, assuming that £1,500 is the average cost per mile of reconstructing county roads, is it not true that, as a result of this cut of £500,000 and the other cuts of £790,000 already made, 850 fewer miles of county roads will be reconstructed in this coming year?
Is it not true that on the average every local authority throughout the Twenty-Six Counties will reconstruct 30 fewer miles of roads in the coming 12 months? Is it not also true that as a result of this cut and the other cuts already applied, 5,000 fewer men will be employed during the coming 12 months in regard to this matter alone? Is it not true, in addition, that as a result of the increase in wages and capital costs during the past year, and particularly during the past few months, that, on top of the 5,000 fewer we will employ because of the financial cut before us now, we will also have a reduction of 10 to 15 per cent. in the employment content on our roadworks during the year?
I come back again to the figures trotted out here last night by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government; he read out statistics giving the number of unemployed in rural Ireland. Surely the number of unemployed in rural Ireland is not the straight answer to the problem? The main feature is the number employed. It is true that thousands of people have become unemployed as a result of the action of this Government and, if those people do not appear on the unemployment register and in the returns of the Central Statistics Office, so much the worse; the reason for their non-appearance is because they are no longer in the country but have been forced to emigrate. Enough of these quick answers to all our problems. Enough of these figures that appear to prove that black is white. That is not sufficient. I come from a county which has been worst hit of all counties.
Comment on this
Whether or not there are more or less unemployed on the unemployment register to-day, there are fewer people employed. That is the real issue in this case.
Comment on this
May I point out to Deputy Blaney that he may discuss the question of unemployment only in relation to the sum of £500,000 mentioned in this section.
Comment on this
The 850 fewer miles of roads that will be reconstructed and the 5,000 fewer men we will employ are represented in the £500,000. In addition to that, the £800,000 National Development Fund which will not come to us this year must also be taken into account.
Comment on this
It is in order that the figures I have given may not be confused that I have not divided one into the other. The figure I am working on is the £1,290,000.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not deal with any other section. This section refers only to a sum of £500,000.
Comment on this
I quite agree that the figure given here is £500,000. Surely, this burden is being placed on the ratepayers and this sacrifice must be made by the workers who will lose their jobs and who will have to emigrate. Surely, that position is being aggravated by the deliberate diversion of this £500,000. Surely, that is a good argument and a cogent reason why this £500,000 should be restored to the Road Fund, even at this late stage, so that the last straw may not be placed on the camel's back in the way of increased costs on the ratepayers and increased unemployment in the country as a whole.
I should also point out that as a result of this £500,000 cut each local authority will lose approximately £46,000. Added to that is this sum of £790,000 which we will not get this year. Now the Minister earlier gave us very good reasons why this £500,000 should be taken from the Road Fund and one of the reasons was that the whole trend of disbursement of the Road Fund to local authorities was changed by the present Government last year. He, and other speakers to whom I listened, maintain that, because more money has been applied to county roads, everybody should be happy. Despite the argument put up by the Minister and his colleagues that we are getting more money now for county roads than we got under Fianna Fáil, the fact remains that the total moneys disbursed during the past year, plus the moneys allocated for the present year, are less now than they were under Fianna Fáil. At the same time the Road Fund, as a result of increased taxation on vehicles, has greatly increased. That is a fact and no amount of quibbling will change that fundamental fact.
Nevertheless our county councils and local authorities are getting less in the aggregate from this Government than they got from Fianna Fáil and Fianna Fáil had much less money at their disposal out of which to give these grants. That is one fact that emerges quite clearly out of all this. There is no point whatever in saying that, because Peter robbed Paul, Paul has got more money this year and all of us should dance in glee around the House.
The finances of this country have gone into a tailspin and that tailspin is causing the Government to do things that should not be done, things which cannot be justified. Reducing the grants from the Road Fund will not get us out of this economic tailspin. The real answer is that some of the crew in this Coalition plane, in the throes of a tailspin at the moment, should——
Comment on this
——whether or not they have their parachutes on, bale out. Those who have parachutes should jump; those who have not should take a chance at crash landing, go to the country and get their answer there.
Comment on this
Politically it would be a bad move to crash land on the hills up there at the moment. Deputy Beegan challenged the Minister here to-day. Whether or not it was a direct challenge, it did bring the Minister to his feet. Deputy Beegan stated that it had come to his knowledge that a directive had gone out from the Department of Finance to other Departments telling them they should cut down their capital programme for the coming year by 33? per cent. Whether or not that is true, Deputy Beegan and I would like to know what the position is. The Minister did not refer to the very serious position when he had an opportunity of doing so.
If that is true, where will we find employment for the people who should be employed on these new capital development works? Where will we find employment for the road workers who are new being disemployed because of the cut in the road grants? Will they have to join the thousands who have already left the country over the past two years? Will they find themselves in the same boat? If that is what the Government have decided is the answer to their present problem, then the best thing they can do is get up here and state that that is their policy. Do they believe that the best way to maintain the people in their present standard of living is by reducing the population and that, with a lower population maintaining the same production, we will be able to maintain that lower population in their present standard? If that is the solution, the sooner it is put into words by the Government the better it will be.
The Minister also mentioned when talking that we on this side of the House did not have a proper conception of the matters governing our financial and economic position to-day, and that it was because of our lack of conception we were making these attacks on his policy from this side of the House. Let the Minister be quite clear on it; we are not under any misconception in regard to the present financial position of the country.
Comment on this
We are under no misconception about that. We know the country is in a difficult position, to say the least of it. We know that unemployment is becoming greater, and it is being added to by the particular item we are dealing with. We want the people on that side of the House to realise that we are not doing as they did when they were here and we were the Government—we are not criticising merely for the sake of criticising and obstructing. That is not our line, and it cannot be taken from anything that has been said that that will be our line.
Comment on this
If the Deputy from Wexford has something useful to say, we shall be delighted to hear it, but it will be the first time I ever heard anything useful from him since I came into this House.
Comment on this
Again during the Minister's contribution, we were given to understand that the main roads are not a very productive part of our economy. That, of course, is a matter that could be debated from now until the cows come home and we would be no wiser. But the view of many of us on this side of the House is that, due to the present mode of transport and the ever-increasing use of it, the roads of our country definitely must be maintained or otherwise we may find ourselves facing very great losses in the near future.
We are not—and I speak now for my own constituency where I have some knowledge of the roads—spending sufficient money on those roads at the present time to maintain in reasonable repair the good work already done and, at the same time, to try and do a little of the work that remains to be done. In other words, the roads we have reconstructed in the recent past will deteriorate unless we spend more in maintaining them than we are at the moment. We will not be able to make any progress on the absolutely huge total of county road mileage, which we must try and bring into passable condition, unless we spend this money and try in some little way to keep our population at home.
This is one of the things that is adding to their quick run out of the country—the lack of proper roads into the more remote parts of our country. I take the Parliamentary Secretary to task for the statement he made in the House last night that the worst county roads were to be generally found in the Midlands——
Comment on this
Then all I can say is that the Parliamentary Secretary cannot have wandered very far from Dublin. If he would, he would find that there are roads along the counties of the western seaboard, and even more inland and nearer to Dublin than that, and, if he or any of his colleagues stumbled into them in the dark at night-time, they would probably be lost in the pot-holes.
Comment on this
The usefulness of the speed tracks in County Kildare will only be fully realised by the Minister when he is getting out after the next election. He will be able to go all the faster, and so much the better.
Comment on this
It may not be very original but it is likely to be very true. The truth of a statement rather than its originality is the important thing. I think the Parliamentary Secretary should try and amend in the near future his statement that the Midland roads are the worst in Ireland. While I agree that there are bad roads around Leix-Offaly, where the Parliamentary Secretary and his colleagues got bogged down not so very long ago, at the same time if they go further West, further North or further South, they will find on the back roads and by-roads there that, not alone will they be bogged down for a little while, but they will be bogged down for good and will never get out of them. And that applies politically and otherwise.
Comment on this
There is another group of people in this House—and I am glad to see one representative of that Party here—the Labour Party.
Comment on this
The Party represented by our friend Deputy O'Leary at the moment has been, and are justified in, looking after the interests of the unions responsible for having them here. But what should be made perfectly clear to the workers and members of those unions—the rural workers of this country and the urban workers as well—is that we have an item here which, taken by and large, represents the biggest source of employment outside of agriculture. The Labour members are quite justified in looking after the interests of the workers engaged in that particular employment; but when we have them to-day going around the country looking for increases for those people and, at the same time, coming into this House and voting less money for the payment of those people, then it is about time that Deputy O'Leary and his friends got red necks and got out of this House altogether.
Comment on this
Not alone would I like it, but it would be a very good job for the country generally at the moment. The Labour Party, if they were consistent—but, of course, like their friends in the Coalition, they cannot be consistent: it would be inconsistent for the Coalition to be consistent—and if they wished to maintain workers' wages on a par with the increasing cost of living to-day, then the last thing they should do in this House is contribute in any way towards the reduction of Road Fund grants to county councils for they must meet the bill and pay those people.
Comment on this
This is worse than a standstill Order because it brings them down below the level they were at. It is a starvation Order. Let us get back to this particular £500,000——
Comment on this
Remember that the reduction in the money being given to our local authorities will have the direct result of putting 5,000 people out of employment for an entire year. Let us also realise that during that same period, basing the cost per mile of reconstructing county roads on the figure given by the Parliamentary Secretary last night, £1,500 per mile, we will do 850 miles less reconstruction on our county roads for the coming year than we would have done if the grants had continued at their existing level.
Those are two factors we must remember. We must also remember that, in addition to the drastic reduction at a time when unemployment is rising—despite the fact that our people are fleeing the country and that one of the reasons they are doing so is the lack of the proper roads into their homes—taking all those things into account, we must also add a reduction of from 10 to 15 per cent. in the labour content and amount of employment that will be given this year on roads as against the figures for last year. These figures discount entirely the figures given here last night—the figures not of how many are employed to-day as against how many were employed this time 12 months ago, but the number of people unemployed to-day and registered as unemployed. I must discount that sort of argument entirely.
That is purely confusing the issue and it was brought in, I take it, for that purpose, because the Deputy who brought that in can handle his figures, I am quite sure, and handle them very well. But he should not be allowed to mishandle them in these circumstances and confuse the issue to the extent that people are given to understand that there are in fact no unemployed resulting from recent increases in the cost of road materials and in wages, brought about by the increased cost of living, or no reduction brought about by reducing the Road Fund grant to the county councils. That is entirely wrong and a complete misconception of the whole situation.
The real picture is that we are getting less money, that materials are costing more and that we are going to do fewer miles of road in the coming year than last year. We are going to employ many thousands fewer and contribute to the flow of emigration. That is the picture; £500,000 plus the £700,000 from the National Development Fund added together, gets that net result.
I want to say that the tailspin in which the Government now find themselves is something which they can quickly remedy. If there are some elements who will not bale out, the other members should fire them. All in all, they will be doing a good national service if they all baled out and went to the country in a general election, when, I have no doubt, they would get their answer to this question of disemployment. In fact, they will be told that the money they have taken from the payers of motor tax in this country has not been used for the purpose to which it was pledged and therefore they have broken their word and taken this money for other purposes, about which we know nothing.
Comment on this
This debate has struck a rather different note from that of yesterday. One would think from the manner in which the speakers on the opposite side have attempted to justify the money which was expended year in, year out, on these main roads and, at the same time, have suggested that they are still in very poor order, that this was a country the size of France. Deputy Burke said that he did not want to make political capital out of the matter. I will have to come into the House some time when Deputy Burke is making a political speech.
I want to refer once again to the key case in the matter of our main roads as against county roads, and that is the stretch of road from Newlands Cross to Naas.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were nót present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
This road was to be completed at a cost of £1,500,000. A considerable part of the work was done and the cost works out at £100,000 a mile. As anybody is entitled to do, I made an estimate of what would make a reasonable road. I made an estimate as to what it would cost to take away a number of corners and widen the road on the left hand side where there was plenty of room to widen it, because of a ditch about eight feet wide which continued for miles. I estimated that the cost would be £250,000, about one quarter of what was actually spent on the part which was completed. The question which arises is whether the road as reconstructed is safer than it was before reconstruction. I think the accidents on it in recent months prove conclusively that it is not safer.
Comment on this
That remark is typical of Deputy MacEntee and of the absurd things he says in the House. If there are "pubs" around Dublin, they are not principally on the main roads, once you leave the city.
Comment on this
I hope he is not going to make any further remarks about public houses on the Naas road.
Deputy Burke referred to the desirability of improving main roads and referred to some of them as prairie tracks. I wonder if he has ever seen a prairie road? It is not a road at all, but merely a dirt road with a track made by the vehicles passing over it. This is the kind of debate we have had on this matter.
Deputy Childers maintains that his original speech was wrongly interpreted by the Minister for Finance, that he made a speech of a technical character. It was the strangest technical speech I have ever heard. If he attempted to make a technical point, it was that, by improving the roads, you would get an increase in agricultural production.
Comment on this
I am glad that Deputy Kennedy said "hear, hear". The only way he could get employment in County Westmeath was on the roads. If he cannot do better than that, then he should go home. If he cannot think up some better suggestion than to give employment on the roads in County Westmeath—one of the finest agricultural counties in Ireland— he should go home.
Comment on this
The Deputy's Government should have attended to the county roads in Westmeath which was one of the counties I referred to in the Midlands as having roads worse than the roads in the West. I was challenged by Deputy Blaney as to why I thought the county roads in the Midlands were worse than those in the West. The stone on the western seaboard is old red sandstone which is far harder than the limestone in the Midlands.
Comment on this
That is the reason why the county roads in the Midlands are not in as good a condition as the roads in the western part of the country.
Comment on this
The only place where I have seen the county roads looked after well was in the far reaches of West Limerick. They were good there. Deputy Blaney asked me a number of questions and that is my real reason for getting up. One question he asked was: Is there a financial crisis, yes or no? The answer to that is no; there is not a financial crisis. Is that definite and specific enough? The Deputy asked another question—a typical question which, I take it, was a creation of the Deputy's own mind. He asked whether the Minister for Finance issued instructions to the Departments that the capital programme this year was to be cut by 33? per cent. The answer to that is no. The amount of money provided for the capital programme this year is the same as last year, as the Minister said. It is something of the order of £44,500,000—a far bigger sum than was ever provided by the Party opposite when they were in office.
There were all kinds of side winds on this section which is purely a transfer. It is a raid on the Road Fund. It is not an air raid, as Deputy Blaney seemed to think it was when he spoke about baling out and going into a tailspin. It is a raid on the Road Fund. As I said last night, that money is but a transfer to the capital fund to finance something in the region of 2 per cent. to 2½ per cent. of the capital expenditure this year. I do not think the money could be put to a better purpose and Deputy Blaney knows that as well as I do.
Comment on this
At a county council meeting in Cork on Monday last, practically every member of the Labour Party—they are not here now—was very loud in complaints about the manner in which labour had been cut down and about unemployment. Quite rightly, these members wanted to know the reason. If there is anything more contemptible than that a Minister for Finance should raid the Road Fund, which is what is now taking place, I am not aware of it.
In previous years, despite protests, the Road Fund was raided. In 1952 we got a guarantee from the Minister that the Road Fund would not be raided again while he was Minister, and it was not. I can understand every manoeuvre that is being made at the present moment to find out where the Government can lay their hands on money. There is no good in the Parliamentary Secretary telling me anything else. Here we have the Party that raided the C.I.E. funds and borrowed from them. Here we have the Party which raided the E.S.B. funds and borrowed from them. Now they have come down to the last tack.
On 13th June last, I asked a few questions in the House. I was endeavouring to get a picture of how matters stood in regard to roads generally and in regard to finance generally. When I sat opposite, I argued that a large proportion of the money got by taxation on petrol should go into the Road Fund, instead of going into general taxation, because every single gallon of petrol used on the roads tends to cause deterioration of those roads. Every extra gallon of petrol used means extra cost to the ratepayer in the upkeep of these roads.
I am not concerned about the main roads. I would not care a hang, if they were never there. They are too darned good, but I am concerned about the roads used by the ordinary farmers and ratepayers and the condition of those roads. Generally speaking, the main roads are lovely, but what do you find the moment you leave them? Pot holes and water tables in some instances two or three feet above the centre of the road, and, in a large number of cases, in the centre of the road.
I asked the Minister if he would state in respect of each of the years 1950-1951 to 1955-1956 the revenue derived from (a) petrol taxation, (b) customs duties on mechanically propelled vehicles. The revenue derived from petrol in 1950-1951 was £3,630,972. In 1952, when we got the guarantee from Deputy Smith, it was £4,483,002. In 1955-1956, that is, last year, it was £7,557,552. That is an increase of over £3,000,000 in petrol taxation. One would think that the Government that got £3,000,000 extra in that manner would be fairly well satisfied with themselves and would say they would at least leave the Road Fund go towards the upkeep of the roads which are being damaged. They did not. The net receipts of customs duties on mechanically propelled vehicles increased from £1,164,915 to £1,825,100. That was an increase of over £600,000.