Finance Bill, 1956—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 154–317 of 317. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1956 ›
I am quoting from column 176 of the Official Report, dated 13th June, 1956. The receipts from motor vehicle duties increased from £2,838,380 to £5,097,068 in the same period. That was a further increase of roughly £3,000,000 from motor users from 1950 to 1956. The motor user, who is also a ratepayer, had all that money taken from him. He gets back a portion of it in the Road Fund. The balance, some £5,000,000, is thrown in here to swell the coffers of the Exchequer and to be put to other uses.
There has not been a roads meeting in Cork County for the past number of years when we have not had, meeting after meeting, deputations complaining about the condition of the ordinary county roads. Every branch of Muintir na Tíre and of every organisation in the country is, meeting after meeting, complaining about the condition of the roads.
Then we are met by another breakout on the part of these people this year by a further raid on the Road Fund to the extent of £500,000. I cannot see any justification for it, to be quite honest about it. I cannot see any justification for a Government, whose revenue has been increased by taxation on petrol, and by the extra petrol used, by over £4,000,000 a year in five years, to come back now to raid the Road Fund again. Every penny in the Road Fund could usefully be spent in endeavouring to repair the damage done to the roads by the use of the extra amount of petrol reflected in that extra revenue got through petrol taxation, and more with it. A few years ago we were advocating that part of that petrol taxation should go into the Road Fund each year to help to make up for the additional expenditure which would be necessary on the roads as a result of the extra traffic on them as reflected by the increased sales of petrol as well as by the increased revenue from petrol taxation. Undoubtedly, the roads are being starved.
The ordinary farmer who has to take his crops to market finds that, in a large number of instances, the lorry which he hires to take his beet will not go off the main road because of the condition of the county road into his farm. Then he has to get his tractor, trailer, horse and butt to cart his beet to the main road before the C.I.E. lorries will come to take it. That is the condition of affairs that is at present prevailing with about 80 per cent. of the farmers growing beet in this country. Even the lorries drawing the milk will not go into those roads for the same reason. Then we have what to my mind is a disgraceful manoeuvre by a Government who are at their wits' end to-day to find the wherewithal to hold them there in office over the holidays. That is all that is bothering them—to know if they can last from now until Christmas.
The Parliamentary Secretary stood up and told us there is no financial crisis. I was at a meeting last Monday at which we discussed the reply which I got here to a question in regard to housing grants.
Comment on this
I am replying to the Parliamentary Secretary's statement that there is no financial crisis.
Comment on this
I suggest that if the Minister for Finance went to an insurance company and borrowed from them instead of coming along here——
Comment on this
I told the Deputy that he cannot proceed on that line. The section has nothing to do with insurance companies or housing grants.
Comment on this
I am suggesting other means by which the Government could get the £500,000 of which they are depriving the roads.
Comment on this
The transfer of £500,000 from the Road Fund to capital funds is the question before the House.
Comment on this
The absence of our share of that £500,000 in Cork County this year will mean a large amount of unemployment on our roads. It will mean that the men, about whom the Labour Deputies were complaining last Monday as being out of employment, will have to continue to be out of employment. That is hitting at the poorest section of our community, at the ordinary road worker on our roads. They are the people who will suffer in the first instance. People in the engineering and other grades are safe enough: they will have their salaries even if no men are employed. The ordinary road worker, however, has no guarantee of continuous employment and he is the man who will suffer. He will be hit by this.
Instead of coming at this stage and cutting in on the Road Fund, I think the Government would have been well advised to take some of these extra millions which I was informed here a fortnight ago had been collected from the motorists and hand that money out to the local authorities for spending on the roads. You cannot have four or five times the traffic over a road that was there four or five years ago and expect to maintain that road with the same amount of money. The road will be in such a condition that no motorist will travel over it and the ordinary farmer and ratepayer will be unable to take out his produce. I admit freely that he has no bother once his produce is out on the main road because he can get it the rest of the way all right. However, a considerable number of farmers are three, four and five miles from the nearest main road and they are the men who will suffer and are suffering at the moment by reason of this action by the Government.
We can all see the attitude which is adopted here, even by the Minister for Lands last week, towards the agricultural community who are endeavouring to have the roads repaired for them and put in some kind of order—roads for which the Land Commission were responsible. All of us can see what is happening all round us in that regard. I remember when Deputy Smith made that statement in this House. Every Deputy who was here at the time, and who now sits over there, stood up and cheered it. One would expect that ordinary Deputies would have a right to expect some continuity of policy in regard to roads. It is impossible to prepare any roads programme, unless there is some continuity of policy. Instead of that, we have this shabby method of endeavouring to stave off the evil day by watching and saying: "There is money—grab it." I do not know what Deputies over there think of it. I am sure they are as much ashamed of it as are the Deputies of the Labour Party who have cleared out and left the benches there idle again, while the question of whether the road workers in their respective constituencies will be employed for the next 12 months, is before this House.
Comment on this
I am here oftener than the Deputy. He only came up on the late train this evening. I am here a longer time——
Comment on this
I guarantee that in any 12 months I am inside this House at least ten times oftener than the Deputy.
Comment on this
I am calling attention to the fact that there is not one Labour Deputy present here while the question they themselves are so concerned about—they are in Cork, anyway, and I presume in other counties too—the employment of the men they are supposed to represent in the local authorities, is being examined as to whether or not money is to be provided for them.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry is entitled to speak without interruptions but he should not invite them.
Comment on this
I cannot help the interruptions. Deputies over there are supposed to represent the road workers. My complaint is that we have each year extra millions of pounds pouring into the revenue of whatever Government is in office at the expense of the roads of the country, and every bit of this money diverted from roads compels the ratepayers to find more money for roads. On the other hand, we have this—to my mind, disgraceful—move by the Minister for Finance who comes in and breaks the guarantee given by his predecessor. That is what I feel most strongly about in this matter——
Comment on this
I do not wish to delay matters further. I have made the case as I see it; I have given the figures as they have been given in this House, but I hope that, during the next nine or ten months, I shall not hear those absent Deputies, when they are attending local authority meetings, complaining about unemployment on the roads.
Comment on this
Now that we have had this bit of play-acting from Deputy Corry who has been making statements which he knows are not true——
Comment on this
The Deputy drew attention to the absence of certain members from this House. Apparently, there is more than one plan of campaign on the way on behalf of Fianna Fáil. For the past month or two, over 60 members of Fianna Fáil have been absent from this House. This afternoon the same thing happened; last week the same thing happened, and the week before. Deputy Corry is sent in—I dare say because no other member of the Party would do it—at a particular time every afternoon to call for a House.
Comment on this
I have not called for a House this afternoon, but since Deputy Morrissey did not do so, I call for a count of the House now.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
Not one of the Fianna Fáil Deputies has answered the bell. Deputy Corry told us he was perfectly satisfied with the state of the trunk roads; they were all right as far as he is concerned. He did not care a hang about them, but he wanted to protest against the state of the county roads and the minor roads. The Deputy knows quite well—nobody in this House knows better—that more and better provision has been made for county roads by the present Government than by the previous Government. I have too much respect for Deputy Corry's intelligence and his knowledge of the work of local authorities not to be quite satisfied that he knows that.
The Deputy said that there was nothing more contemptible than the Minister for Finance raiding the Road Fund. What contempt he must have had over the years for some of his own colleagues who had held the position of Minister for Finance! One would imagine that this was the first time that the Road Fund had ever been raided. Perhaps the Deputy, if he were on this side, would prefer a raid on the food subsidies. The Deputy sheds crocodile tears about how employment on the roads is to be affected. There are far more people in employment in this country to-day than there were when Fianna Fáil went out of office in 1954.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that quite well. Let us, for goodness sake, stop running down the condition of our own country. I travel probably as much in this country as the average person does, over a considerable number of counties, and I want to say— and I think I can say it without fear of contradiction—that our roads will, as regards condition, compare favourably with the roads of most other countries in Europe. There is no question about it. Let us remember that there has been a revolutionary change for the better in the condition of all roads in this country. That is a fact, and Deputies know it. We have spent over the last 25 years, relatively speaking, enormous sums of money on the roads of this country, and while it is very important that the roads should be maintained in as good a condition as we can afford, there are other services that have a higher priority. There is no question about that.
I know that some of the county roads, minor roads and link roads are in need of improvement, but let us not say here, or try to create the impression outside, because it would not be true, that even our county roads and main roads are all pot-holes and hump backs. They are not. There are some roads in certain counties that are not up to the general standard, and there is no representative of a county council, I do not care to which Party he belongs—and I served for many years on a county council—but knows that there are certain counties where roads are, comparatively speaking, in a poor condition, mainly because, when roads could have been made and maintained at a comparatively low figure, certain county councillors, no matter what was the estimate submitted by the roads engineer, insisted on cutting it. Those are facts and that is the reason; let us be quite honest and fair about it.
I am not claiming credit for any Government, but I am saying that, over the last quarter of a century or 30 years, excellent work has been done and enormous sums of money have been spent. Do not let us forget either that—Deputy Corry made a passing reference to it—some people down the country and even some county councillors, apparently, yet do not understand, when they talk about roads being made for motorists, that motorists are paying for roads on the double and on the treble. They are paying both as taxpayers, as ratepayers, and through a special levy in the form of motor taxation levied on them as a contribution to the roads over which the cars run.
Let us get these things clear. I want to ask Deputy Corry if that £500,000 has been taken away from the trunk roads and main roads this year to be put to an urgent and more necessary purpose, does he object to that? If the £500,000 has to be found, if it is not to be taken from the Road Fund, where in my opinion it will cause less hardship, will he suggest from where it is to be taken? What additional taxation is to be put on to find it? What other commodities will he suggest?
I must say that I get pretty fed up listening to people in this country trying to decry the country. I want to say that in respect of our public services, having regard to the leeway we had to make up, whether it was roads, bridges, houses or anything else, we have made progress. We have in respect of these matters made as much progress, having regard to the point at which we had to start, as probably any other country, and we are as near to providing our people with first class services in relation to any of these as they are in most countries. Deputies talk as if this were the only country in which there were poor roads. I have not been very often abroad, but I have been abroad a couple of times, and I have seen roads in some of the great continental countries that could not compare at all with some of our roads here. I am talking now about their main trunk roads, but their by-roads, what would correspond to our county roads here, are infinitely inferior to our roads. Let us get that clear.
I said at the beginning that there were apparently two plans of campaign. Deputy Corry and some of his colleagues will not help either roads or anything else in this country, and certainly will not improve the employment situation, by using this section and any other section and every other debate to try to suggest that the credit of this country has gone. We had the Deputy saying what he said in so many words here to-day, that the credit of this State is so bad that this Government would not be able to carry on to the end of the holidays. That is terribly devilish, and a malicious thing to say. I do not mind what the Deputy says against a Party, or what he says about me or any other member of this Party, but Deputy Corry or any other Deputy, particularly a seasoned warrior like Deputy Corry, ought not to be guilty of saying things that are only injuring the State and the credit of the State.
There is no point whatever in talking about continuity of policy. There is continuity, so far as the fundamentals are concerned. There is no question, however, about that. But either in this or in any other country, where there are changes of Government, the changes are brought about because the people want a change of policy in whole or in part. That is the main reason for changes, because the people are dissatisfied either in whole or in part with the policy that has been pursued by the Government of the day. Certainly, as far as I am concerned, there are quite a number of parts of the Fianna Fáil policy that I should like to depart from as far and as quickly as possible. There are other parts of their policy that I might not find myself a thousand miles away from, but I might differ very strongly from them on how effect should be given even to those parts of their policy.
It does not do any good for the Deputy, for his Party or for his country, to get up here and talk as he has just talked, repeating himself six times, notwithstanding the efforts of the Ceann Comhairle to keep him somewhere within reach of the section under discussion. There was nothing real about the Deputy's simulated indignation; it was nothing but play-acting. He can do that pretty well, but, of course, he has had quite a lot of practice. The Deputy is not codding anybody in this House. Apparently he is satisfied that he can still put it over. He has been doing it successfully in Cork for quite a while; otherwise he would not be trying to continue it.
The Deputy should be fair to this House, to the county councils, to their officials and to the workmen, and not pretend that the roads are worse than they are. I think the roads are quite good. I think we have spent perhaps more than a fair proportion of our earnings and our income on the roads of this country. I believe they are in a condition of which we need not be ashamed. I believe we will not do any irreparable damage to them by taking this £500,000 out of the Road Fund. I am satisfied that the £500,000 being taken from that fund—to which it will do little damage—is to be used where it will be most beneficial.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey has had the hardihood that even many of the Deputies on his side have not had. He has given a reason why the Road Fund has been raided. His reason, in so far as I can gather, is that the roads are quite good enough.
Comment on this
I do not think they are half good enough. I think they are in such a condition that we could not afford to take a single pound out of that fund. Deputy Morrissey suggested that the roads were not bad and at the same time tried to say that the people in some areas would be affected by bad roads. Those of us who have been members of local authorities during the past ten years know that, if we were to get three times the amount of money available for roads, we still would not meet the needs of the people.
As a public representative, I find that my greatest problem is to try to explain to people why, year after year, they must continue to travel over bad roads, while other people, fortunate enough to live elsewhere, have had the benefit of good main roads. It will not give those people any satisfaction to tell them that the £500,000 taken out of the Road Fund this year was not needed there, because the roads are not so bad at all. I repudiate that statement in so far as it may be offered to this House for acceptance. We have had the taxpayers, the ratepayers and the workers all contributing in their own way to the reconstruction and maintenance of our roads. It was found necessary recently to increase the amount which the motorist should pay. Many motorists were prepared to accept that extra imposition at the time, on the assurance of the then Minister for Local Government, Deputy Smith, that the money so collected would be made available for the improvement of roads which the motorists had to use.
At the moment, when you talk about the roads the motorists use, you are not talking about the main roads alone, because there are mechanically propelled vehicles of every kind in every district in the country. It is only the people who do inter-county travel, so to speak, who are chiefly concerned with the main roads. The farmer's son, the local shopkeeper the bread agent, the tractor owner, the lorry owner and a thousand and one others, as well as the man with the autocycle and the motor cycle, have to use the backward roads, the link and connecting roads on which we in Donegal could spend £1,000,000 and still not have solved our problem.
I think it is rather serious that a former Minister of the Coalition Government should get up here and try to justify the raid on the Road Fund by saying that the roads were not so bad at all, that the money could be used in a much more useful way. What more useful way is there in which this money could be spent? No one in this House will deny that money spent on roads—let it be county roads, second class or third class accommodation roads, not to speak of main roads at all—could be spent in any other way. In trying to make his case, Deputy Morrissey pointed out that this year more money than ever before was available for county road improvement and maintenance, that we have got, at the expense of main road grants, an increase in county road grants.
I do not know what people in other counties think, but I know that in my own area increased wages will account for practically every penny of the extra money which we will receive in that way. Surely we must be concerned about the all-important question of employment. When Deputy Morrissey referred to employment figures, in which, he said, we had an improved position as compared with some years ago, one would have thought we were living in a paradise. One certainly would not think that he was living at a time when the census figures have exposed the most serious and critical situation the country has ever passed through. There is one way of giving employment to people who most need it and at the same time doing useful work with the money so spent, that is making roads in rural areas. If all the so-called economic experts were to discuss ways and means of providing immediate employment and, at the same time, doing useful work, they could arrive at no better solution than the giving of extra money for the making of better roads.
If there were better roads built into the areas from which our people are fleeing, it might be an incentive to them to work the holdings which become derelict; it might be an incentive to them to remain at home. By building better roads, we would be encouraging our tourist traffic. We should improve the link roads leading from main roads which bring them to the scenic parts of the country and to the places of historic interest. By giving better roads to the farmer for his tractor, his cart, his bicycle or motor car, we are making him feel that, for the high rate he is paying— and he is paying over 40/- in the £ in many counties—we are giving him something out of the fund to which he is contributing so largely.
We must remember that county councils are the biggest employers of labour in each county. No concern in any county employs so many people as do the local authorities. Anybody who gets up in this House to make a case for the action of the Minister for Finance on this occasion is fighting a losing battle, as he will learn if he tests his case before the electorate in a general election. I challenge any Deputy to get up at the next general election and justify his action in defending in this House the taking of £500,000 from the Road Fund.
I should like to know what is the more urgent work to which Deputy Morrissey has just referred and to which he suggests this money will be diverted. Will it have anything to do with the creation of more employment on the western seaboard? Will it have anything to do with the serious situation revealed by the census report just published? Will it be used as the nucleus of a fund to set going a scheme of employment that will employ even a fraction of the people which it would employ if it were to be used for the purpose for which it was subscribed? If we could be told that it would be used in a specific manner, we would have some idea in regard to challenging the Minister as to the usefulness or otherwise of the purpose to which it will be devoted; but nobody has at any stage in the debate attempted to pinpoint the purpose for which these moneys will be used, other than the vague suggestion that it is to be devoted to capital development and to more urgent needs.
While the Road Fund is being deprived of this £500,000, let us ask ourselves who is likely to suffer as a result of that depletion of the fund. Is it the staff, all the high grade administrative officers who are employed in the Custom House or in the engineering, or administrative section in any of the counties? Will their staff be depleted by one person or expenditure in that direction be reduced by 1/-? Not one single penny will be saved in that direction, but the unfortunate people who are working for a wage of from £4 15s. to £5 7s. 6d. per week on roads throughout the country will lose the £500,000 which is being robbed on this occasion.
It is the last straw for any Deputy to try to justify that action in this House. We could easily understand the Minister making an apology to the House and saying: "I had to find the money somewhere and it was the only place I could get it," which is the real answer. However, Deputy Morrissey has endeavoured to explain that the money is to be used for much better purposes, that the roads were all right and good enough in this country; in fact, he went so far as to say that they were up to the standard of those on the Continent and elsewhere. I do not approve of that statement. He also castigated the members of the Fianna Fáil Party for what he referred to as the small attendance on this side of the House out of 62 members. That is not consistent with the attitude of the people who are sitting behind the Government. He neglected to remind the House that the Labour Benches, but for the attendance of the old warrior, Deputy O'Leary, were completely vacant.
Comment on this
I thoroughly agree, but a previous speaker saw fit, by referring to the sparse attendance on this side of the House, to castigate this Party as not being genuinely interested in the motion under discussion. Most Deputies over here have already contributed to this debate and I am sure many more of them will; it behoves every Deputy to give his or her views on this important question. Those of us who are members of local authorities know well what we have to put up with in the council chamber from the beginning of the year to the end because of this eternal question of road repairs. After persistently pointing out to the people over the years that if we had the money we could do a lot with it, but that with the meagre resources at our disposal we were compelled to carry on with a curtailed and restricted roads programme, we are now to tell them from this House to-day that the roads are quite all right and that this is the one fund which could afford to be raided for the purpose of balancing the Budget.
It is the duty of every Deputy to give his views and I personally should like to put on record my complete refutation of that statement. We had a county engineer some years ago make an assessment of what we would require, if we were to put the roads of the county in a reasonable state of repair. He told us that the staggering figure of £1,000,000 would put in a reasonable state of repair only the more important county roads and the second-class roads in the county, in addition to carrying on the main roads programme—
Comment on this
I cannot follow altogether the Galway Deputy's reference. Does he insinuate that, instead of getting the money from the Road Fund, we should raise it from the rates? I think that is the meaning of the interjection; it has no other bearing on the discussion. If we thought the ratepayers could stand it, we could provide £1,000,000 for our roads through the rates.
Comment on this
Is that the Deputy's point? We have a Road Fund for the purpose of making roads which is subscribed by the motorists and they want it spent on the roads. We are not going to take it out of the pockets of the ratepayers who are already paying 42/- in the £ for the making of roads. We do not intend to put any further burden on them for the making of roads in Donegal, or in any other county. If the Deputy wants to adopt that attitude, he is quite welcome to it, but my attitude is that we should get the money that rightly belongs to the roads from the Road Fund, and spare the ratepayers who are paying much more than they are able to bear. My purpose in speaking here was to protest against that action. If the Deputy from Galway, or any other Deputy, wishes to pursue the other line, he is welcome to do it, but it is not mine.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey said that our roads compare favourably with the roads in any country in the world. That is an attempt to justify this action. Whatever the views of other Deputies may be on that, my opinion is totally opposite to that. To try to point out that money has been diverted from main roads to county roads this year, that we have got more money for county roads than we have got before, is no answer to the present problem of taking £500,000 out of the Road Fund. We need extra money spent on the county roads. We want to have extra employment created in the counties. As I said at the outset, the county council is the biggest employer of labour in any county and every penny taken from the roads programme from the Roads Fund, is a penny less for the workers employed on the roads. Not a single member of the executive or the administrative staffs in the Custom House or in the county councils will suffer one minute's unemployment. The money will come out of the pockets of the road workers who are the people who would benefit by any additional money expended on the roads.
The question of main roads versus county roads is a totally different question. I may have views on that; other Deputies may have theirs. The members of the Government, even, are not agreed. The Minister for Agriculture thinks that if the bends were left on the roads, motorists would not drive so fast, and there would be fewer accidents. Some other member of the Government thinks that if the roads were opened up so that we could see around the corners, there would be fewer accidents. The engineering staff in the Custom House say that these bends must be removed so that the roads will be accident free. That is a separate question. What we should be concerned with is getting from the Road Fund every possible penny available to it. If Deputy Coogan suggests that it is our duty to go to the ratepayers' pockets for any money we want, I say it is not, that we should ease off there as much as possible and go to the Road Fund for the extra money which has been subscribed by the motorists, and use every penny, every year, even in an increasing amount. I hope it will be an ever-increasing amount because it is increasing only correspondingly with the increase in wages and the requirements of roads generally.
I hope the Minister, even at this stage, will express his regret to the House for having to do what he has done and will give us an assurance that it will never be done again.
Comment on this
As a rural Deputy and a member of a local authority, I should be failing in my duty if I did not speak on this section with regard to the cutting of the road grant. My opposite number from North Tipperary mentioned the very good roads we have in North Tipperary. That shows that he does not travel through North Tipperary. I invite him to some of our county council meetings. Day after day, there are deputations demanding this, that and the other in regard to roads. Our by-roads are in a shocking condition. It is surprising to me to hear a Deputy from that area, where there is a farming community and where the roads are in a deplorable state, saying that they are very good.
I remember, during the last election campaign, when Deputy Morrissey was down in my constituency, the question of a road not far from where I live, a by-road leading to a main road, arose. Deputy Morrissey almost suggested that I was responsible for getting money spent on the main road, while the by-road has been done since. At a meeting yesterday, £11,000 was transferred to the widening of the main road. I objected, but it was put to me that, if that was not done, there would be people unemployed and the workers would say: "You are the fellow who voted against this."
If Deputy Morrissey was sincere in his statements then let him be sincere now. Why is he not stopping the transfer of that £11,000?
If this £500,000 is to be put into capital development, have we any guarantee that it will be spent in the way in which we would wish? There are farmers living on very bad by-roads. In some cases, there are nine or ten families living on such a road. They were to have been improved under the rural improvements scheme, but in that case the persons concerned must contribute £10 to £20 and pay their rates, in addition. That is asking the people to pay a second rate. If there is money available now, why not do these roads at the expense of the main roads and relieve these farmers of this second rate? If there is to be any improvement in county roads, I hope the system of putting a shovel of stones on the road and going to the ditch for a shovel of clay to put over them will be abolished.
Comment on this
It would be capital development to improve the by-roads. There are large numbers of tillage farmers in our constituency who cannot get their machinery into the farmyard for threshing purposes. In certain areas, they have to carry the corn on to the roadside to be threshed.
As regards employment, road work gives employment. In North Tipperary last year, some permanent workers were off the roads a fortnight before Christmas. What will happen to them now? Will they be idle half the year? I am surprised that Deputy Morrissey would not take his stand for these workers. Deputy Morrissey was sent here at one time by the votes of these workers, being a worker himself in the very same position about which he is talking now. I guarantee that he will not go to North Tipperary, to Nenagh, his own town, and tell the workers that there is plenty of money for the roads and ask them what harm it is to take this sum of £500,000. They are coming to us day after day to get them a job on the roads. Deputy Morrissey carried out so much bluff during the election campaign that it is very difficult for him to go down there. It is all very well to speak with one voice here and with another voice down the country.
It is suggested that this money will be used for arterial drainage, a capital development. I should be glad if it were, because in my constituency they are crying out for the drainage of the river Suir, which would help the people generally. Is some of this money going to that area for arterial drainage? It is not.
Comment on this
The drainage of the Nenagh River was started before the present Government was ever thought of. It was launched by Fianna Fáil. You will not deny that.
Comment on this
If there was too much money in the fund, why not remove the large increase in taxation on motorists, lorries and everything else which was imposed during 1952 and which the members of the present Government deplored at that time, but which they continued and increased still further by the increase in petrol two months ago? Why not give this sum of £500,000 in relief of the taxpayer who has contributed to that fund?
A lot of play has been made about the county roads. I have never agreed with all the work that has been done on our main roads. As a member of a local authority I often opposed such work, even when Fianna Fáil were in Government. As I stated here, some of the roads are far too wide. They are a danger to motorists at night-time because light does not reflect so well from them as it would on a narrower road. Certain bends and dangerous turns have been removed in my area, and I was glad that they were removed. It is hard, nevertheless, to understand the mentality of a Deputy who can get up here and say we have very good roads in North Tipperary, a Deputy who does not travel those roads. Some of the roads in that area are in a shocking condition. They will be in a worse condition henceforward.
Who will suffer as a result of this? It will not be the officials in the county council or the civil servants in the Custom House. It is the ordinary worker who will suffer. Labour Deputies are silent on this because they know that it reflects on them. There is no getting away from that. If the roads are too good, as it is claimed they are, and if there is too much money in the Road Fund, why not use that money to give some relief in taxation, relief to the tune of £500,000?
Comment on this
It is a strange experience to listen to some of the people who say they represent different local authorities. I am a member of the Wexford County Council. The Fianna Fáil members on that council will never vote for the county engineer's estimate. They have never voted for it. Over the past 20 years the policy was main roads for C.I.E. It is about time there was a change made and something done for the county roads. We have spent enough money for C.I.E. on the main roads from Dublin to Cork, Waterford, Wexford and elsewhere. The roads leading to our churches and our schools are in a deplorable state.
The ratepayers in my area are anxious that the moneys in the Road Fund should be put into the back roads and the by-roads. They think money has been spent on the main roads that should never have been spent on them. What does one see as one travels through the country? Huge machines, some of which cost 35/- per hour, removing corners.
Comment on this
And three times that in other areas. Where is the employment content there? I would like to see more than 400 permanent employees in Wexford but we have never been able to get Fianna Fáil representatives there to provide money for 500 workers when the estimate comes up. Deputy Allen spoke here last night. A few days ago in the Wexford County Council we wanted to do something for the working-class people in tht line of cottage repairs.
Comment on this
It does not arise admittedly but the ten members of the Fianna Fáil Party on the Wexford County Council voted against that proposition; and that would have provided employment.
Comment on this
People speak with one mind here and they go back to the county councils and they speak with another mind. Everyone to-day is looking to the Government. When a man is elected to a local authority he is elected to work for the county and for the ratepayers.
With reference to all the machinery that has been bought all over the country, take a look at the road outside Bray and see what happened there. Was that justifiable? Was it right to spend all that money to make a straight road? Very few men were employed. There were huge excavators, bulldozers and all the rest. I cannot understand why members of local authorities come in here advocating machinery, on the one hand, and talking about unemployment on the other. It is the duty of a local authority to provide employment though we have been told by members of the Fianna Fáil Party that the county council is not a labour bureau.
Someone said last night that everybody is now going to church in motor cars. I do not agree with that. I do not believe our people are as well off as all that. I do not believe that everybody is going to church, chapel and meetinghouse in motor cars. Going through the country on Sunday, one will see poor old people trudging along the roads. The same applies to children going to school. One sees the bicycle.
Comment on this
Very few pot-holes are filled up for those people. We know why the main roads are catered for; my memory is not so short that I do not know why, when the Transport Bill was going through here, the roads had to be improved for C.I.E. to suit a certain person in C.I.E.
Comment on this
The Deputy is getting away from the section. The Deputy must get back to the section now.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy ought either substantiate the statement he has just made or withdraw it. He has made a reference to a certain person in C.I.E.
Comment on this
We know what the Deputy means. He ought not to take advantage of the privileges of this House to make these insinuations.
Comment on this
I have never made an attack on any person under the privileges of this House and I hope I never shall. I suppose that is too much to expect from a Deputy——
Comment on this
Speak about the ass and cart going to the church instead of the motor car and we will be more at home, anyway.
Comment on this
It was said here. There is no doubt about that. I believe there is too much capital made out of this talk.
Comment on this
Members of local authorities have a duty to perform and the most important duty of all is striking the rate. I have always understood that the more money put up by the local authority the more money will the local authority get from the Central Fund.
Comment on this
I am asking you is that right. The more money you give, the more money you get. They are talking about raiding funds. Fianna Fáil raided every fund, food subsidies and everything else. With the 1952 Budget, they raided everything they could get at.
Too much propaganda is being made here. I agree with the speech made by the Minister for Defence, which was referred to here to-day by Deputy Blaney. I have that speech before me. I thought his remarks were very true— that a propaganda campaign is being carried out by Fianna Fáil on the Dublin and Cork Corporations.
Comment on this
Deputy Blaney was let away with it. He accused the Minister in connection with this statement he made and which I am trying to read here. I believe Fianna Fáil are trying to make propaganda. The more they say the fund is being raided, the more unfortunate people in the country will be expecting to get something out of it. We do not stand for anything like that.
Reference was made to the Labour Party Deputies to-day. If any Fianna Fáil Deputy wants to know where they are, they are at the Transport Union Conference in Galway.
Comment on this
It was very unfair of the people on that side of the House to talk about the Labour Party being absent from the House. That is why they are absent to-day. I think it is unfair to use those tactics and try to blackguard members who are engaged to-day on other business. That is what the people over there have been doing from the time they started—black-guarding the Minister, blackguarding the Government and blackguarding the Labour Party. Every one of us is a sinner, and they are all saints.
If the people in the country want something done with the by-roads I do not think it is any sin at all, if we take money from the main roads and put it on to the by-roads. That is what is required.
Comment on this
The people on that side of the House say one thing and try to make big headlines in the Irish Press, that the Labour Party is doing this and doing that——
Comment on this
Order! If Deputy Collins does not desist from interrupting, I will have to ask him to leave the House.
Comment on this
I went down to Limerick a week ago and the by-roads are not so good there, either. I hope Deputy Collins will do better when he goes back there. It is in the local councils that the work is to be done, not in Leinster House. All this talk to-day is simply delaying tactics and will little help the progress of the people we are all supposed to be so worried about—the unemployed. All the talk here is not helping the country at all. We have members saying that the country is bankrupt. I am surprised at the people who call themselves "Fianna Fáil—the Republican Party" getting up in this House and saying such things, so that they will be published in the British papers or the Six County papers to-morrow or the next day. That is not national. These things should not be let go.
I want to see an improvement in every county council, as far as that is possible. If we could get the cooperation they are talking about here in the county councils, then there could be a further improvement in regard to roads. The Minister is living in a constituency over the roads of which more traffic passes than anywhere else—County Kildare. He does not want to see money taken away from the roads, and I do not think it is right to give the country that impression.
I want to see employment given as far as possible. If I thought there was likely to be any unemployment as a result of any action of the Minister, he and I would not agree for very long. I believe that the people who are trying to put that across here are just trying to score points. That is a bad policy. We are sent in here to do good for the nation and not for ourselves or anybody else, and to see that, wherever money is spent, it is spent in the proper manner. That is the duty of any person in a local authority. He has to try to do good for the people he represents. Everybody looks to a council or to a Government to solve problems, but at times we might be inclined to look too much to the Government to do things we could do ourselves. If we could do these things at home in the local council, there would be no need for all the balderdash we hear here to-day.
Comment on this
I think that Section 32 of the Finance Bill has aroused more attention here than any other section of the Finance Bill. It has been castigated and criticised from the overall angle and from the overall aspect of its damaging effects all over the Twenty-Six Counties. However, I intend to summarise those effects in regard to my own county, where I have had the honour of being chairman of the county council for the past six years.
I am glad the Minister for Finance is here, because I wish to put before him the damaging effects of this reduction in the Road Fund, as far as Limerick County Council is concerned. For the present financial year, we based our schedule of road works on the amount of grants we got last year. We got from the National Development Fund £20,000 and, under the headings of main road grant, county road grant and the main road upkeep grant, we got certain amounts which I have here before me and which show exactly the position we had in 1952-53, and 1953-54, 1954-55 and 1955-56. On a general analysis of the headings, we find that, as a result of the reduction, due to this raid on the Road Fund, we are faced with the serious position in County Limerick that we are down by £36,000. That is being snatched by the Government which Deputy O'Leary supports from the workers of County Limerick; and next Saturday, I expect we will have to review the whole position of our schedule of road works.
As I said at the start, we based our road works programme for the coming year on the assumption that we would get the same as last year. I think Deputy MacEntee asked the Minister for Finance if it were true that no money would be made available to the National Development Fund for roads. When the Minister answered him in the affirmative, I was free to assume that we would lose £20,000 for County Limerick. Together with that, I would like to tell the Minister for Finance that the amount under the heading of main road grants for 1955-56 is down by £7,700.
Under the heading of county road grants—the grants the Minister for Local Government seemed to be very much against, grants for what he called the autobahn roads; the kind of road that he would like to have dust-free for the autocrats driving their big cars —what do you find in the County Limerick? We find £12,120 under that heading; and the total reduction under all headings, including the loss we have to sustain—I am glad that my colleague, Deputy Carew, who represents East Limerick is present—is £32,800 in the present year.
One penny in the £ brings in £1,800. There was a time, before we gave a certain amount of road territory to the corporation, when one penny in the £ brought in £2,400. We ceded to the corporation land to which they were entitled, with the result that, with the restriction of our area, one penny in the £ now brings in £1,800. Therefore, we are suffering a loss in the coming financial year of £32,800. Now, £32,800 at one penny in the £ means 18 pence in the £ on the ratepayers to give them the kind of roads that they demand. The total vote we struck was 111 pence. Now we find that the reduction caused by the raiding of the Road Fund, plus £20 less in the National Development Fund grant, means, in effect, that the ratepayers of County Limerick will have to contribute 18 pence in the £ to give them the same road service as we gave them last year and to the workers it means ten weeks' less work.
Deputy Morrissey had no hesitation in saying that the roads, both major and minor, in this country were as good as those he saw on the Continent. Deputy O'Leary passed the remark that he was down recently in Limerick and he had no hesitation in saying that some of the roads, especially county roads, were not as good as the county roads in Wexford. I will grant him that and I will give an explanation for it. In the period during the war from 1939 to 1947 when there was an accumulation of funds, very little work was being done on the major roads. Most of the money was devoted to the development of bog roads. In 1947 or 1946, there was an accumulation in the Road Fund of many million pounds. Local authorities at that time were circularised and told if they prepared schemes for the development and maintenance of county roads, they could get a 90 per cent. grant. I regret, as a Limerick man, having to say that only two counties rejected the offer—Limerick and Sligo. Limerick rejected it because they had a Fine Gael majority in the local parliament.
Comment on this
I want to protest to the Minister for Finance that he is doing us an injustice. He is putting handcuffs on us, and retarding and restricting our efforts to bring the county roads in County Limerick to the standard we would like and to the standard which obtains in any other county, whether in Leinster or Munster. We are penalised by this imposition to the tune of £32,800 which will mean a reduction by one-tenth of the work we intended doing in County Limerick for the coming financial year and a reduction of ten weeks' employment for the labourers in County Limerick.
Comment on this
I feel it my duty to bring to the attention of the Minister for Finance the injustice he is causing to the ratepayers and workers of County Limerick by raiding the Road Fund and grabbing £500,000.
Deputy Morrissey said that taking away £500,000 was just a simple movement. For what? We have not been told by the Minister or Deputy Morrissey to what capital productive purposes the money is to be devoted. Is it to be devoted to something that will be productive in the form of the relief of unemployment? We have not been told. Is it being raided solely for the purpose of balancing current revenue?
Comment on this
You were asked here a direct question by Deputy Lemass during the course of your introductory speech on the Bill as to what were the capital purposes to which the money was to be devoted, and you did not give a direct answer.
Comment on this
It was made clear beyond question again and again that this is not going to current revenue.
Comment on this
I do not mind what the Minister may have said to-day. We have the reputation in Limerick that we never haul down the green and white or the green, white and gold, and when we meet you in the final, we will talk to you.
Comment on this
I am addressing the Minister, through the Chair. I can tell Deputy O'Leary that there are workers in Limerick who did not get an hour's work since Christmas last. They are waiting for sanction of the various grants from the different Departments. Deputy Carew, sitting in the Fine Gael Benches, is an honest Deputy and I am sure he will agree with me. What are we going to say when we go back to the local authority meeting in Limerick next Saturday? What will the councillors representing the various Parties—Labour, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil—say to the starved workers outside the barriers who are looking for work? What is the Minister's intention in regard to the £500,000 taken from the Road Fund? Immediate work should be given to the workers of County Limerick who have not got an hour's work since Christmas last.
Comment on this
It is not. We have the best county council in Ireland. I should like the Minister to answer the very pertinent question which is agitating the minds of more Deputies than those from Limerick. What has he in mind in regard to this money he has taken from the Road Fund to the detriment of the workers and the ratepayers of this country?
Comment on this
Bhíos ag éisteacht inniu leis an Rúnaí Parliaminte, an Teachta Ó Donnabháin, agus é ag caint i dtaobh an méid oibre atá le fáil in mo chontae féin. Dúirt sé go rabhamar i gcrua-chás má bhíomar ag brath ar an airgead i gcóir na mbóithre chun an chuid is mó den obair sa chontae do sholáthar. Táim chun freagra a thúirt ar an duine sin anois.
In the course of this debate, the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy O'Donovan, questioned me in a statement in which he said that if we had nothing for the workers in Westmeath except road work, we might throw in the sponge. These were not his exact words, but it is the best interpretation I can put on them. We employ on the average from one end of the year to the other, apart from the engineering staff, a minimum of 700 men on the roads.
I remember being a member of a deputation to the late Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Davin, on a matter pertaining to the roads. He paid a tribute to the amount of work we did in the county all the year round. Therefore, I want to answer the Parliamentary Secretary by stating that providing work for the unemployed and those who offer their labour for hire is a big consideration with us in Westmeath. The curtailment of the grants will seriously affect these men at the end of the financial year.
He also referred to the fact that we should concentrate on agriculture. In the course of the debate to-day, Deputy Morrissey referred to the continental roads. I do not profess to know much about the Continent. I had the honour of being a member of a parliamentary delegation in Austria, with Deputy Morrissey. I covered a good deal of Denmark last year. It is a small country like ours. I state categorically that, having regard to my experience there, in Holland and other places, Deputy Morrissey's statement is a misstatement of fact.
The roads are better than ours. They are better laid out and provision is made for pedestrians and cyclists. The principal reason for the concentration on roads in the lowlands is to ensure that agricultural produce will be brought to the market in the most economic, cheapest and quickest way. That is what we are concerned with, is so far as the rural roads in Ireland are concerned.
The people in these areas are taking to mechanisation rapidly. Deputy Smith, in the course of the debate on the Local Government Estimate, referred to a period 25 years ago when the farmers came to the county councils in deputations and said: "You are making roads that our horses will fall on and you are making no provision for the horse and cart." The very same farmers are at every county council meeting all over the country asking now for good roads—tarmacadam roads and dust-proof roads. That is why we rural Deputies get up here and make the case for good roads.
That is why I yesterday gave facts and figures which I got from the Department about the long period it will take to bring our 39,000 miles of county roads up to the standard of the roads on the Continent. After all our efforts over the years, we have only 8,000 miles of these roads done and we are only doing 800 miles a year. With rising wages and costs that figure is likely to drop.
The people we make the case for are the people who pay into the Road Fund. Whether they have a car, a tractor, an autocycle or whether they walk or have a pedal cycle, they all pay into the Road Fund. Every man who has a cwt. of eggs pays for the conveyance of these eggs and every man who sends a barrel of oats and wheat over the bad roads to the mill is paying taxation in respect of the car, lorry or van used. Everyone who goes on an excursion, let it be anywhere you like, is a contributor to the Road Fund because those making the charges take into account the road tax they have to pay.
I would say to the Minister for Finance, through the Chair, that he has the biggest revenue spinner in transport of all the sources from which he gets revenue. Excise or customs duty or anything else compares in no way to the revenue the Minister gets from transport whether it be the new taxes he put on vehicles or the old taxes which applied to them or the taxes on tyres coming in on new cars or the taxes on petrol and oil or the road tax. The Minister should not kill the goose that lays the golden egg. He should mind this. It is the biggest source of revenue which the State has.
We were all led to believe, and it was the unanimous view here four years ago, that the money coming in through motor taxation would be devoted to the roads. Now it is being taken from them. We, rural Deputies, should fight every inch of the road to prevent this being done because if the Minister gets away with this the danger is that, as it is such an easy source of revenue, the fund may be raided again. There is a grave danger in this whole thing.
Deputy O'Leary was concerned about people going to church. I said that the old people in the country places who were unable to walk to church, Mass or meeting now avail of transport services, and rightly so, and get a cheap seat. That is happening in the Deputy's constituency in Wexford. There is not a chapel or church in County Wexford where old people, like people everywhere else, do not take a seat and pay for it; they may pay two shillings or one shilling. Deputy O'Leary may say they do not do it but they do. They are entitled, and even the individual who has to walk is entitled, to as good roads as the Dubliner or the man in Cork City. They are entitled to as good a footpath as the man in Limerick City. If we are to preserve rural Ireland and arrest the flight from the land we must have the same social services and the same amenities for the rural population that the city people enjoy.
Deputy O'Leary is not as innocent as he pretends to be. He has been boxing shadows all the evening. He spoke as if we were standing for the transference of some of the Road Fund to the main roads. That is not in dispute at all. If the Minister decides at the last minute to give back the £500,000 to the county councils they can devote it all to the county roads and we will say "Hear, hear" to them. The relative merits of main roads versus county roads are not in dispute here this evening. The question in dispute is that as so much has been paid in by the motorists to the Road Fund—£5,500,000 and expected to reach £5,750,000 this year—and as the people were led to believe for the past four years that the whole yield would go towards making good roads, it is unjust that £500,000 is now being taken by the Government.
I challenge Deputy Morrissey on this matter. Yesterday I gave figures about the amount of county roads done in our county; I shall confine myself to my own county. There are approximately 823 miles of county roads in County Westmeath. At present, 92 miles of that number are dust free. Would anyone get any country this side of the Iron Curtain and get the same areas as Westmeath where there is only that amount of county road done or what is comparable to county road? I will not labour the point very much but you have the position there of a Bord na Móna works employing at the peak period 400 to 500 men. Let us leave the motorist out of this consideration altogether now. These men have to cycle a distance of five miles from Multyfarnham to their work through pot holes, and back again, and they have to cycle to and from my little town; similarly with regard to the village of Coole. That would not happen in a coal-mining district in England or anywhere else. Here we have a similar industry and, apart from the inconvenience to the motorist or the lorry man, the ordinary worker has to go through pot-holes on his bicycle all the winter. He is entitled to a better road.
There has been talk about autobahns and autocrats travelling in their high-powered vehicles. I do not see any of these autocrats in their high-powered motors. God knows, the levels in Ireland are fairly even. The rich are very few. There may be a number in Deputy Larkin's constituency in Dublin City but they do not exist in rural Ireland. We do not see these autocrats with their high-powered cars and everything else.
I heard a Deputy from the poorest part of Galway challenge a Deputy from Donegal and ask him if they raised the rates and he was having a race as to who would have the highest rates. I wonder was there anything in Deputy Morrissey's contribution about the sanity of having a national approach to our finances, our credit and everything else? Deputy Morrissey should not throw stones when he is in a glass house. We are all very much concerned with the finances of this country. We do not want to put the last straw on the camel's back. However, whether it be local rates or general taxation, you will find that, if it comes to the last extreme, this Party will not be found wanting in standing behind the nation to see that its finances are sound. It is not a case of sabotage or wrecking; it is a case of sanity and of a right approach to this matter.
If we have taxpayers and ratepayers in Westmeath, Leinster and the rest of the Twenty-Six Counties, then we must make Westmeath, Leinster and the rest of the Twenty-Six Counties a place fit to live in where the amenities will be the same as are obtainable in the more favoured parts of our country. That is why we say that the motorist in the Twenty-Six Counties and every taxpayer whether he be in a labourer's cottage or in a flat in Mullingar should get the same consideration and that this very important thing which is recognised as a necessity in our age, good roads, should be provided and that the progress which has been made should not cease now.
On the subject of the relative merits of the main roads and the county roads, as I calculate it, the Minister for Local Government made a transference of more money for the county roads as against main roads. The sum total, however, on the 31st March, 1955, was that, adding the miles of main and county roads, there were 19.54 less miles done than in the year before.
Comment on this
In the year ending the 31st March, 1955, as compared with the year ending 31st March, 1954.
Comment on this
That is correct, but the year ending 31st March, 1956, was the first year in which the increase of £500,000 for county road improvement was given.
Comment on this
The statement has been made that the same amount in grants as last year is available for roads. Before the beginning of the financial year, county councils are notified about the amount of money that they will get for the coming financial year, and during the year additional grants come from the Road Fund to supplement the sum already given. It is all right to say—and I make this statement subject to correction—that the same amount in grants will be given for 1956-57 as for 1955-56, but we must relate that to the total amount given both in original grants, in supplementary grants and in grants from the National Development Fund for road work. I would like to know will the same amount in each county, and in the country as a whole, be available under these headings in the present financial year as in the past financial year which ended on the 31st March last.
There has been a challenge to the Minister to state into what particular capital development this £500,000 which is being taken from the Road Fund is to be directed, and we await the Minister's answer. May I submit that there is no capital development that gives more general employment than the roads? You may have a turbine scheme or you may have a bog development scheme in a particular county or counties, but in developing the roads —and it is real capital development— you give employment in County Leitrim, in County Westmeath and County Longford; you give employment in areas where as far as we can foresee, there will never be an industry except agriculture.
I hope I know the rules of the House and I know how wrong it is to digress but I should like the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government to go and live on a £10 valuation farm and see how much employment he can give from one end of the year to the other. Then he would know how those people live and he would know the value of roadwork. I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to realise that in addition to the 39,000 miles of county roads in the Twenty-Six Counties there is approximately 50 per cent. of that total mileage in our link roads, accommodation roads and cul-de-sac roads which nobody can see made in our lifetime unless there is a change of policy in relation to these roads. When cul-de-sac roads or when link roads are not made and maintained, when these are left to be done under rural improvements schemes and by getting everyone to contribute, the people will not stay in the small farms down the boreens unless we give them roads as good as the county roads and the main roads.
We are concerned, as I said, with this whole question of the Road Fund. The people were led to believe—and believed up to now—that they would have continued progress, getting better roads at a speed faster than at the present time. The Minister, by his action in this Budget, has shattered that belief and has done an unjust thing to rural Ireland. That is the reason we criticise and oppose this section.
Comment on this
I made my views clear on this section earlier this afternoon and there is nothing that I can add to what I then said. I made it clear that the Government considered that, in our present circumstances, there was a limited amount which could be made available by way of capital development without creating further inflationary difficulties, and that in their selection of the amounts that could be utilised, therefore, within that limit for various services, they considered it was more proper that moneys to the extent of £500,000 should be utilised for productive capital purposes other than what I described earlier as the polishing of main roads. This work has been spoken of to-night as if it were main road maintenance, as if, in fact, the decision was to allow existing roads to go into a state of disrepair.
Deputies who are really seeking to understand the position of local authorities know, of course, that that is not the case; what is in issue is the deferment, in our present capital circumstances, of improvement to the trunk roads which may, perhaps, be desirable, or to arterial roads which may, perhaps, be desirable, but which in our present circumstances we just cannot afford, when there are so many other capital schemes that require to be undertaken which will bring more productive results to the economy as a whole.
I said then, and I repeat now, that if with the inflation that is all around us, I have to choose, and the Government has to choose, as to whether we will do work under the land project, or on forestry, or on various types of capital development of that sort to be carried out from the capital funds; if we are to choose whether it is better to cut back on main roads or cut back on these schemes to the extent of £500,000, we shall make the choice of deferring improvement work on main roads. It is totally dishonest for Deputies on the other side of the House to suggest that this is cutting down on county roads as such, because it is not. We have priorities that are in operation at the moment, and we shall take our capital expenditure into the lines of production where it will bring, not merely employment at the time the capital works are being carried out, but employment in the future also and permanent benefit to the economy. We think that the other devices of productive investment I have mentioned earlier this evening have a greater priority than the straightening of main roads or the work of improving trunk roads which will be to some extent deferred by reason of this section. It is a choice which I think the country will accept. If there has to be that decision, it should be made along the line the Government has made and which I defined earlier.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I want to make it clear that, while we are in complete agreement with the proposal in the section, I think I must bring to your notice, Sir, the question of whether this section should or should not appear in the Finance Bill. You are aware, Sir, that the Constitution requires that a Bill may not be certified to be a Money Bill, unless it deals only with certain matters specified in the Constitution. It appears that this section, however desirable it may be, is not appropriate to the Bill at all, and even though we might wish to see it enacted, we must question whether it would be a desirable precedent to use the Finance Bill as a vehicle for this purpose. You may not feel disposed to give a ruling on the point now, but I should like to ask you to consider it and give the House a ruling on the Report Stage.
The possible effect of giving a certificate to this Bill as a Money Bill, which does not conform fully to the requirements of the Constitution, will be evident from the terms of the Constitution itself. If the Minister for Finance does not want to take the risk of a possible delay in the enactment of the Finance Bill—some question might arise in the Seanad—I can assure him, if he prefers to delete this section and introduce a one-clause Bill to deal with it, we will give him all stages in the one day. We would prefer to do that than to have this slipped in in this manner.
Comment on this
The officers of the House were consulted before the section was included in the Bill.
Comment on this
That may be so. I am asking you, Sir, for a specific ruling
Comment on this
In view of the use by Deputy Lemass of the words "slipped in", I said that. It was not slipped in.
Comment on this
On the section. This is a different point of view on the objection. I should like to speak to the section, not on any question of order so much as on the undesirability, in already confused legislation, of having something that has nothing to do with the Finance Bill, but has to do with the Superannuation Act of 1887, put in here. The Minister, as a lawyer, knows very well how confusing it is to find odd bits of legislation in places where you would least expect to find them. If this is not a precedent, it is a bad way of doing business, to insert in the Finance Bill, where you would least expect to find it, an amendment to Section 8 of the Superannuation Act of 1887.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy will find, if he looks at the superannuation code—I have not got the full details to hand—that it is not by any means unusual for questions relating to civil pay, such as this is, to be included in the Finance Bill through the years. As I say, I have not got the exact references at the moment.
Comment on this
——if the inclusion of this section in the Bill will raise any difficulty for you in certifying this Bill to be a Money Bill.
Comment on this
I should have liked to have the next stage to-morrow, but so long as it is clear that the Report and Final Stages are both completed by Tuesday night next, I am prepared to defer the next stage to Tuesday.
Comment on this
The Minister has a knack of putting things in the wrong way. Under Standing Orders, a certain time must elapse between the Committee Stage and the next stage of the Bill. However, as a concession, we are prepared to grant the Minister the Report and Final Stages on Tuesday next.
Comment on this
The Deputy forces me to remind him of the reason why I did not have the Committee Stage of this Bill ordered for last Thursday afternoon. I did that at the Deputy's specific request, so as not to inconvenience him. When I did agree not to order this Bill, as it should have been ordered, for last Thursday afternoon, I did so on the Deputy's belief, not assurance, that the Committee Stage would finish yesterday.
Comment on this
One concession deserves another concession. We agree to have the Report and Final Stages on Tuesday.
Comment on this
We remember Finance Bills that took months.
Comment on this
The British Finance Bill is proceeding at the rate of one section per day.