We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–231 of 682. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956
Enacted

No. 16 of 1956 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

Before Section 8 to insert a new section as follows:—

8. (1) Sub-section (1) of Section 10 of the Act of 1952 shall as respects relevant grants allocated on or after the 17th day of July, 1956, have effect as if each of the amounts specified in paragraphs (i) to (iv) were increased by £104.

(2) Sub-section (2) of Section 10 of the Act of 1952 is hereby amended, as respects relevant grants allocated on or after the 17th day of July, 1956, by the substitution of "the spouse of such person where such person is married" for "every member of such person's family who resided with him during that year and who may reasonably be expected to reside with him in the house."

(3) Sub-section (2) of Section 10 of the Act of 1954 shall, as respects relevant grants allocated on or after the 17th day of July, 1956, have effect as if each of the amounts specified in paragraphs (a) to (d) were increased by £104.

Section 10 of the Act of 1952 enables housing authorities to make grants graduated on the following scale: (a) where the family income is up to £208 per annum, 100 per cent. of a State grant; (b) where the family income is between £208 and £312, 66? of a State grant; (c) where the family income is between £312 and £365, 50 per cent. of a State grant; and (d) where the family income is between £365 and £416, 33? per cent. of a State grant.

The scale of income was amended by Section 10 of the Act of 1954 in relation to houses situate in a county borough, the Borough of Dún Laoghaire, the County of Dublin or the district electoral divisions of St. Mary's Bishopstown, Blackrock and Douglas in the County of Cork, as follows: (a) up to £260; (b) £260 to £377; (c) £377 to £442; and (d) £442 to £520. Having regard to increases in living standards since the foregoing provisions were enacted, many of the persons for whom these provisions were designed would now be ineligible for grant or entitled only to a lower proportionate grant than formerly. It is proposed, accordingly, in this section to raise the scale by £104 a year at each point. The revised limits will apply to applications made to housing authorities in respect of houses for which the State grant is allocated on or after the 17th July, 1956.

The amendment of the definition of family income will make for simplification of administration. The revised definition will be more equitable to the classes of persons to be assisted in providing their own houses. May I say in passing, in relation to assessing family income and to the efforts that were made previously to trace the income of members of the family, some of whom were earning their livelihood out of the country and perhaps were not contributing to the family exchequer, that this definition of family income as being the joint income of the applicant and his wife or the applicant and her husband will simplify matters and clarify the position?

Comment on this

I am somewhat surprised at this amendment inasmuch as the Minister apparently has not seen fit to deal with Section 9 as well as Section 10 of the Act of 1952. In the Act of 1952, Section 10 of which it is proposed to amend here, there are these three sections which are designed for the guidence of local bodies, who may or may not decide to pay supplementary grants. I can quite see that the income limit, as set out in Section 10, entitling the applicant to a maximum supplementary grant, was fairly low. As the Minister has stated wages have increased and a case can be made for the revision which is set out in this amendment. However, when we were originally discussing in this House Section 9, 10 and 11 of the 1952 Act, Section 9 of which refers to farmers with a valuation up to £37 10s. and divides valuations into four classes—under £12 10s., under £20, under £25, and under £37 10s.— it was felt at the time that the rateable valuation as set out in Section 9 was much too low or, as was said then, much too conservative.

In one sense, as I say, it is difficult to be critical of the amendment which is proposed by the Minister but in another sense I can scarcely see the fairness of this amendment in relation to Section 10 when the Minister has not sought to amend Section 9. After all, the difficulties of those who live on small holdings have increased too. The cost of building, the cost of material and all the things they require affect them just as much as these costs affect those who are dependent entirely on their earnings.

There is another aspect of this which we must also consider. These are permissive sections. The supplementary grants provided in these sections need not be adopted at all by local authorities. It is a purely voluntary matter and the Minister knows, or he should know, better than I do that local bodies are experiencing quite a lot of difficulty about rates, the incidence of the rates, the annual increase in rates, and so on. In 1952 when this House was discussing these three sections I argued in favour of a modest approach because of my appreciation then of the difficulties of local bodies in these matters, and because of my anxiety not to make the burden too formidable—not to discourage them by raising the standards too high. I argued for hours in this House along those lines and my main reason was my appreciation of the difficulties of local bodies and of the fact that to be generous with what does not belong to you is not generosity at all, and to be generous to one class without being generous to another class which is similarly situated is not fair play.

It could be said that we as an Opposition Party could have put down amendments here to Sections 9 and 10. The Minister has an amendment to Section 10 and there is no amendment of any kind to Section 9. I would be hesitant to do this because I have the feeling that, much as we talk about the effect of these three sections, the local bodies may be shy about readopting them.

I concede that standards were very low even in 1952; they are, of course, lower now because wage conditions have changed. I admit quite freely that, if we were providing something ourselves from State revenue, something for which we ourselves would have to take responsibility and tax the country in order to meet, I would look upon this proposal in a far more kindly way. But we are not doing that. We are simply widening the scope of Section 10 in order that local bodies may pay these grants to a wider range of people, provided those local bodies decide to adopt these permissive sections.

I do not know what has influenced the Minister to insert this amendment. I do not know whether he has had any representations from local bodies in this matter. I must confess I have not had any. I did not have any such representations when I was Minister responsible for these three sections originally. I have not had any representations since. My hesitancy to put down amendments, although as an Opposition we would be perhaps freer to do so than would any of the Parties comprising the present Government, arises entirely because of my appreciation of the difficulties of local bodies, coupled with the fact that any further amendment following on the lines of that proposed by the Minister now, might have the effect of discouraging local authorities from adopting these sections. Naturally, I shall not say that we are opposed to this. We are not. I would be delighted if we could raise the standard still higher because the standards are still too low.

The points to which I have given expression are points which must be present in the mind of every member of this House who is also a member of a local authority, a member of a body which has to borrow this money and then pay it out in grants to the classes specified in the three sections. I would like the Minister to undertake to amend Section 9 by raising the valuation limits in the same way as he proposes to raise the income limits as set out in this amendment. If he cannot do that now, perhaps he would give us an assurance that it will be done on the Report Stage.

I cannot understand what is meant by sub-section (2) of the amendment where it is proposed to insert "‘the spouse of such person where such person is married' for ‘every member of such person's family who resided with him during that year and who may reasonably be expected to reside with him in the house'". I am afraid the Minister has not given us the complete justification for that amendment. I am not contending that it will not be better than what is there. I may be stupid, but I see no reason why the sub-section as it stood should create any difficulty for any local authority. It merely says: "the income of the applicant and all those members of his family living with him during the 12 months previous and who may be reasonably expected to reside with him in the future". I cannot see why any local body would find it difficult to assess the income of a household along those lines.

What exactly will be the position now when the sub-section is amended by the insertion of the word "spouse"? The Minister should give us more information on that point. I certainly would need more information in order to clear my mind. My main reason for objecting to this amendment inasmuch as it affects the income limits set out in Section 10 is because of the possibility of discouragement of local authorities in times like the present; because I am not convinced that local authorities have been seeking an extension along these lines; and, thirdly, because I feel that, if there is justification for a widening of the provisions of Section 10, there is at least equal justification for a widening of the valuation conditions as set out in Section 9.

Comment on this

I take exception to this because nowadays there seems to be a means test in everything. I am not saying that a means test is not sometimes either necessary or justifiable. Here we are dealing with the family. As far as the family is concerned one person, and one person only, is responsible, namely the breadwinner. I object to this kind of means test envisaged here because I do not think it is fair. I have a family and I know that one cannot take the family as a criterion. The earnings of the children should not enter into the picture at all because children to-day have to look after themselves, clothe themselves and perhaps make provision for marriage or taking up some other vocation in life. We are going too far in taking the children into calculation as a method of assessing means. It is for that reason that I object to this provision. The matter should be dealt with on its merits.

Comment on this

I take it the Deputy is supporting me as against Deputy Smith?

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot blow hot and cold. He must have it either one way or the other.

Comment on this

He is against both of us.

Comment on this

That is so. We have gone too far with this chasing up of the family.

Comment on this

But we have cut out the family by the amendment.

Comment on this

He is bubbling with generosity. One cannot stop that.

Comment on this

On the subject of grants, certain local authorities have interpreted the sections to their own advantage. Under the Dublin Corporation one will get a supplementary grant if one is a person whom the corporation would normally house. If the Dublin Corporation cannot normally house a person——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not discuss the administration of the Dublin Corporation on this Bill.

Comment on this

I merely relate it to this. If we had a clear interpretation of this subjection and a clear direction to local authorities, we would not have this ambiguity.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is endeavouring to discuss Dublin Corporation administration. I cannot allow that.

Comment on this

With regard to the point raised by Deputy Smith, I can appreciate his point of view as a representative of the farmers, particularly as a representative of a farming community such as that in Cavan. If, however, the Deputy will read the amendment, he will see that I am providing for applicants who are not farmers and whose wages have increased. With regard to Section 9 of the 1952 Act, provision is made there for applicants whose poor law valuation does not exceed a certain figure; each sub-section sets out the amount. But poor law valuation does not decrease or increase. It is static. That is where the difference lies. The wages of the applicant who is a non-farmer are increased and he is brought out of the class the Deputy provided for him when he introduced this Act. I am trying to bring him back into the class which the Deputy and the House had in mind when the Act was introduced.

The rateable valuation of a farmer remains static. If his rateable valuation in 1952 was £12 10s. he will still get the grant to-day. Consider, however, a man with a salary of £208 in 1952. If he has only that amount to-day he cannot possibly hope to build his own house, not to mind looking for a grant or a supplementary grant. Hence the increase. Again, the farmer has up to three-fifths derating on the first £20 together with an employment allowance. I think the maximum poor law valuation under sub-paragraph (iv) of Section 9 (1) of the 1952 Act—a poor law valuation of £35—covers the vast majority of the farmers of this country, particularly the farming community who cannot build their own houses without State assistance and who would build houses which would bring them within the floorage of a State grant.

I am at a loss to understand Deputy P.J. Burke. He does not want the income of the children taken into account. That is what I am doing by the amendment. As the law stands, the income of every child must be taken into account. I am amending that definition.

Comment on this

Not every child.

Comment on this

Every child residing with the applicant. In my county, we have a considerable amount of emigration. The sons and daughters go across to England and Scotland. Possibly they come home for a month every year. When the parent applies for a supplementary grant he has to procure a sworn affidavit from every employer in England and Scotland as to the family income although possibly those children are not contributing towards the family purse. I think that unfair. I am now defining "family income" as the income of the applicant and his spouse. If I did not include the spouse it is possible that the wife might apply in her own name and have no income despite the fact that the husband may have a substantial income. Therefore, I have included the joint income.

Comment on this

If there were two adult members of the family residing with the parents and if they were engaged income employment outside the place of residence and were paying to the spouse—to the mother—a weekly contribution, would that be taken into account?

Comment on this

No, I hope that this will also encourage the children to save their own money.

Comment on this

What sort of income would the spouse be likely to have?

Comment on this

One can distinguish between "income" and a gift. A gift is not income. Take, for instance, a teacher. Supposing the spouse were a teacher, he or she would have an income. Supposing members of the family wished to give a Christmas present or a weekly present to the spouse, in my opinion, that should not be taken into account.

Comment on this

If it is a weekly payment or a monthly payment, how is the local body to know whether that is income?

Comment on this

There is no difficulty in distinguishing income from gifts. Our income-tax code distinguishes between them and the revenue authorities have no difficulty in proving it. This will simplify the matter and convey a considerable amount of benefit on applicants in areas such as those represented by Deputy Bartley and other Deputies from which there is a considerable amount of emigration. It will also assist local government. They have great difficulty in assessing income. From practical experience as a solicitor——

Comment on this

And they will have it yet, as far as I can see from the Minister's statement.

Comment on this

It is quite possible, but I am simplifying the procedure. I am advocating the very amendment which was proposed on the Bill originally.

Comment on this

I did not trace the Minister in the discussion but I will take his word for it.

Comment on this

The Deputy will see that I was supported by my colleagues who said there would be difficulty in assessing family income and that there should be some definition of "family income". I appreciate Deputy Smith's point that we may frighten local authorities from adopting the scheme. There is always that danger and I know one local authority that did not adopt it. However, in fairness to applicants, where there are increases in living standards we must do this to bring them within the scope of supplementary grants.

Comment on this

We have not very many amendments to discuss on this Bill but I would advise the Minister to be as frank with us in the discussion as he can. It is all very well to reassure us that the amendments are designed for this purpose or that purpose but we shall have to be satisfied that they are in fact what the Minister claims for them. When I mentioned Section 9, and the failure of the Minister to appreciate the need for an alteration in the valuation limit, or limits, as set out in that section, I had given some thought to the very argument the Minister advanced as a reason why Section 9 was not being amended as was Section 10. I asked myself the very same question when I saw this amendment. I said: "Is there any difference between those who have a family income and those who live on holdings of the kind set out in these categories in Section 9? Is there any relation between the incomes they would be likely to derive from these holdings and the incomes set out in Section 10?" I quite realise that the valuation limit, except in exceptional cases where improvements are carried out to farm buildings, and so on, is static but I do not accept the Minister's contention that, because the valuation limit is static, there is not a case to be made just as there is a case to be made in regard to Section 10 where we are dealing with wage earners entirely. Have the costs of a man living on a holding with a valuation of £12 10s. not gone up just the same as those of a man whose earning capacity is under £312? Of course they have.

Comment on this

He is still entitled to 100 per cent. grant, even if his costs have gone up.

Comment on this

Suppose you brought the class up to £20 and said: "We will give £100 under £20"?

Comment on this

The Deputy is afraid we might frighten local authorities off.

Comment on this

Why do it in respect of one class and not in respect of another? The Minister is accusing me of looking at this with a farmer's outlook. I had not the farmer's outlook when these three sections were drafted. I had the outlook of a man who was anxious to provide machinery whereby people, whether landowners or wage earners, would get assistance both from the State and the local body to build their own houses. I tried as best I could at that time to relate the earning capacity to the valuation limits set up for those who were landowners. The limits we set out in Sections 9 and 10—for instance, the earning capacity of £208—were related to what the income of a man whose valuation was £12 10s. was likely to be from a reasonable working of his holding. I say now that, for the reasons given by the Minister, namely, increased costs, and they are good valid reasons, the Minister should give the House an assurance that he will amend Section 9 on Report Stage.

I admit to the Minister and to the House, and I will admit to the country, that I would not seek to impose these amendments in present circumstances. I do not want to have it both ways. If I had the responsibility, I certainly would not, in present circumstances, seek to amend any of these sections, niggardly as they may be, in so far as valuation and income limits are concerned, because of the fact I have mentioned more than once, that it might discourage local bodies from adopting them; but, when you touch one, you are bound to touch the other and I do say that the Minister is not fair in his approach to this matter.

The Minister has not given me the further information. There must be in his Department either a volume of correspondence from local bodies commenting upon these limits, or no correspondence at all. Has there been any resolution passed by county councils asking for an increase in these limits? Has the matter been raised through the General Council of County Councils? Would the Minister say who has asked for a revision of Section 10 without reference to Sections 9 and 11? The House is entitled to be told who urged the Minister to take this course on Committee Stage.

It is all very well for the Minister to fling something at the heads of local bodies that will cost the Exchequer nothing. It is all right to be generous about that which does not belong to you. When discussing proposals of this nature, I like to see the other person's point of view, in this case the local bodies' point of view. If the local bodies have been asking for this, I would give it to them. I certainly would.

Comment on this

The applicants have been asking for it all over the country.

Comment on this

Ah, well; the applicants —when was there an applicant for anything who would not ask for more?

Comment on this

I have respect for them.

Comment on this

We all have respect for applicants. The case of applicants is one thing; the money is another. I am anxious that county councils and local bodies throughout the country should continue to make these supplementary grants and I am naturally concerned that we should do nothing here that might dampen their enthusiasm for these three sections. If one of these three sections is to be amended in favour of one class, I am anxious to see that the sections that deal with the other class, who have an equal right, should be amended also.

The Minister proposes to amend sub-section (2) of Section 10 of the Act of 1952 by the substitution of "the spouse of such person where such person is married" for "every member of such person's family who resided with him during that year and who may reasonable be expected to reside with him in the house". I do not know what benefit that will be to a local body, unless it is covered by some regulation or other.

The Minister is a man—I am afraid to say it, a Cheann Comhairle—who is not in any way hesitant from time to time in giving an assurance on certain points about which I have a kind of suspicion that he is not too clear in his own mind. I have a kind of notion that this is one of the occasions.

If, as the Minister claims for this amendment, we are eliminating all members of the family, except the husband and wife, I repeat my question to the Minister: what will be regarded as income in respect of the spouse? Will it be a matter of some member of the household coming in on Saturday night and, in the case of a weekly payment, paying £2 or £2 10s. or, in the case of a monthly payment, £8 or £10 and, when the housing official from the local body comes to investigate the family income, all they have to say in regard to such payment is that it was a present from the son and there will be no further inquiry about it?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy object to that?

Comment on this

It is not a matter of what I object to. There is no use in this legal quibbling and trying to do the smart Alec here. We want to examine what the amendment will provide for and what the result of it will be. If I were responsible for an amendment such as this, I should like to be clear as to how it would operate. The Minister has said that a payment such as I have described will not be taken into account as income. I do not take that assurance from the Minister. I do not believe that a local body will take that interpretation of the income of the spouse. I am entitled to get from the Minister some clarity on that matter. I say again to the Minister that, for the purpose of getting the business done quickly, he should take this matter seriously and try to give the explanations to which we are legitimately entitled on these points.

Comment on this

My comprehension may be woolly or the Minister's explanation may be complex. He has explained that the income in one case is being increased, apparently in compensation for the change in the value of money. That is understandable. Then he says that, in relation to valuations, no change is necessary because valuations are static. Earned income in one case and rateable valuation in the other case have been taken as yardsticks of income. Will the Minister not admit that a valuation of £20 may represent a greater outgoing now as compared with three or four years ago, owing to the increase in rates? If the Minister can make a case that earned income does not go as far as it did three years ago, surely he must argue, conversely, that a rateable valuation of £20, for example, represents a heavier burden on the man who has to pay rates than it did three years ago. I cannot see the cogency of the reasoning that, because rateable valuation is static, it must be assumed that the income of the rated person has not changed, whereas, owing to the change in the value of money, a man who has an income of £208 is much worse off now than he was three years ago. I think the same reasoning applies in each case.

Comment on this

The only point I should like to reply to is the question raised by Deputy Smith in regard to sub-section (2). He wants to know what the definition of the income of the applicant's spouse is. May I refer him to Section 10 of the old Act which sets out:—

"A housing authority may make, to or in respect of a person (other than a farmer) in respect of a house for which a relevant grant is made, a grant of an amount equal to—

(i) if his family income ...."

It does not say what income is. It merely says family income. I am limiting that to the income of the applicant and his spouse.

Comment on this

What will be treated under the amendment as income?

Comment on this

What was always treated as income? Would the Deputy explain?

Comment on this

Does income mean earnings? Earnings are one thing and income is another.

Comment on this

Income under this amendment means exactly what it meant under Section 10 of the original Act.

Comment on this

What did it mean?

Comment on this

The Deputy introduced that Act and he should know better than I.

Comment on this

That was four years ago and four years is a long time. This is all very fine. The Minister will not get away with it and I again advise him just to cool himself.

Comment on this

If there is any water to be thrown on either of us, I think it should be thrown on the Deputy.

Comment on this

Cold water. If there has been difficulty in the administration of Section 10 of the Act of 1952, the Minister's Department knows about that difficulty. The Minister is in that office now for two years and I have been out of it for two years. I have not the contacts to enable me to understand what these difficulties are or to see them as they arise. The Minister is obliged to tell us in what way the difficulty in determining the income of the family arises as a result of Section 10 of the 1952 Act. He is obliged to tell us in what way the insertion of this amendment will facilitate the determination of the income limit.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister that he is now dealing with a section which has caused considerable difficulty throughout the country in the manner in which it is dealt with by local authorities. There is the question of income or earnings. If it is the earnings of the spouse, that is quite clear, but if it is the income from members of the family that will count as income, on what basis is it to be assessed? Will it be the full earnings of the other members of the family which may be handed up for their upkeep to the heads of the family week by week?

Deputy Bartley referred to the question of the valuation of £20. In this connection, the rate in the £ is not static. It has gone up considerably in recent years in the various counties and, consequently, the charges made are increased in the same way as the responsibility of a person with income is increased. The Minister should consider that whole matter. The officials assess it in one way and then it comes before the members of the council who are dissatisfied, but nobody knows exactly what the basis is on which it is to be assessed.

Comment on this

That is what I am clarifying.

Comment on this

I am sorry I was not in at the start, but from what I have since heard, the amendment is anything but clear.

Comment on this

For the benefit of Deputy MacCarthy and other Deputies, may I refer to Section 10, sub-section (2) of the old Act which states:—

"In calculating the family income of a person applying for a grant under this section in respect of a house, it shall be taken to include the income received during the year ending on the date of such application by such person and by every member of such person's family who resided with him during that year..."

I am merely amending that. I am cutting out "every member of such person's family..." and merely adding the words "the spouse of such person where such person is married".

Comment on this

If both receive the sort of payment I referred to, how will that be regarded?

Comment on this

Suppose you had a grandchild now, how would it be regarded?

Comment on this

I am not talking about what is there now. The section may be wrong.

Comment on this

I appreciate the point.

Comment on this

The section, as it is, may be wrong. I am not objecting to the amendment, but I want to know exactly what the amendment will provide for before we pass it.

Comment on this

At the moment it says that income is the income of the applicant and every member of the family. I am amending that to income of the applicant and his spouse. I am making no change in the definition of the word "income".

Comment on this

If the grandchild was living with these people and made a payment to them, that would be termed income.

Comment on this

The administration of the Act is entirely a matter for the local authorities. I am simplifying the procedure.

Comment on this

It is quite evident from what the Minister said that income means earnings. The income of the spouse will be the earnings of the wife, if she is earning, plus what will be got from other members of the family.

Comment on this

Definitely no.

Comment on this

The Minister is cutting out the members of the family?

Comment on this

Yes. That is what I am doing.

Comment on this

The Minister is doing two things in relation to income. Is he increasing the joint income of the married couple by £104 and is he also eliminating the income of the children residing in the household?

Comment on this

The Deputy has summed it up. That is correct.

Comment on this

That is what I understood it to be. The family living on earned income will enjoy two advantages now. The increase in regard to the limit is raised by £104. You may have a boy working as a carpenter and a daughter working in an office. These two reside at home and their earnings are not now counted.

Comment on this

They are excluded.

Comment on this

That is a very decided improvement in the position of a family living on earned income. I want to compare that very substantial improvement with the static position in regard to the farmer. The Minister said that because land valuation is static, it cannot be altered. Therefore, he does not propose to improve the position of the farmer applicant for a supplementary grant. The point we are making is that land valuation has been used as the yardstick for measuring the income of the farmers, just as the earned income is taken as the measure of the means of the family living in the towns. Is the Minister treating the man whose income is measured by land valuation quite fairly and does this desirable advantage in regard to the question of earned income not reveal a very grievous injustice to the other class?

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to make this sub-section (2) clearer. In this amendment, the Minister is undoubtedly proposing to substitute "spouse" for "every member of such person's family". When an application is received for a supplementary grant by a local body the local authority will then have to proceed to discover the income of the man and his wife. There is nothing in this amendment to say what sort of payment will be treated as means, as income. As far as my reasoning goes, and irrespective of the assurances given us by the Minister, the local authority can send an investigator into a man's house and ask the applicant and his wife who is living with them——

Comment on this

That is just what they do.

Comment on this

Yes, but the amendment——

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not want the amendment?

Comment on this

I want to know what concession it is giving?

Comment on this

I have tried to make it clear.

Comment on this

The Minister did not even give it a thought. I am trying to elicit for the guidance of local bodies what is involved in this amendment. What is in our minds here and the points to which the Minister has referred will not be taken as law when the Bill becomes an Act. Is the Minister giving us an assurance here for the purpose of getting this amendment through that in future only the income of the man and his wife will be taken into account?

Comment on this

Can the Deputy make it any clearer or put it in simpler language?

Comment on this

I am not talking about clearness but about the effectiveness of it. That is what matters. My contention is that the amendment will not be effective. We know that a local body will be entitled to ask a man or his wife what payment or benefit they receive from any members of the family, whether grandchildren or otherwise. They will be entitled to ask about any money or payment received in the course of the year previous to the application.

Comment on this

You cannot get away from that.

Comment on this

There are members on the other side in this House that I believe understand and sympathise with some of the points of view to which I am giving expression. I am not making this a political matter in any shape or form. I want to try to get some clarity on this and I think members of the House, irrespective of their political leanings, should try to induce the Minister to lay down something that will be clear. A number of local bodies will try to take the Minister's interpretation and will say: "We will have regard to nothing but what the man and wife earn". We will have other local bodies who will say that the section does not commit them to that at all and who will take the view that they must have regard to what the applicant and his wife received from every other member resident in the house for the previous 12 months. I do not believe in pretending to confer a benefit as the Minister is doing. I am trying to get a definite answer from the Minister on this point but I suppose I shall not get it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is playing with words in this matter. He comes from a county where these cases must have arisen often and he must have had contact with them. I consider that it was grossly inequitable that a young boy or girl living in a house and earning wages, and who may have been saving for the purpose perhaps of setting up house for themselves—the girl might be getting married and arranging something for her bottom drawer; the boy might be planning to build a house for himself —should have their earnings taken into account. When the local authority came to inquire into the means of that applicant, of the person who was to be the owner of the house and the person who would be entitled to the grant, the income of these young people who perhaps were going out of the house in a short time was calculated and taken into account.

Was it not most unfair that that should happen? Income, of course, is quite a simple thing. The Deputy is pretending he is troubled about it. He is not troubled about it. He knows perfectly well what income is. These young members of a family may get their wages and put the money in the Post Office or in the bank so as to provide for their needs in future life, but when the local authority investigation officer inquires, he asks who is living in the house? How many are there? What are their names? Are they employed? Where are they employed and what are they earning? If the investigation officer is not satisfied about all that, the queries are sent to the employers in order to get the amount that is earned. Surely that is unfair and unjust?

The person who is affected and who should be answerable is the applicant for whom the house is being built, the owner of the house, not people who might be owners of houses of their own in six or seven months' time. Surely it is a wise provision to clarify that? It is not a question of income. If a young man is living with an applicant, whatever that young man earns is his income which he is getting for his own purposes. If he is planning to marry he has to make provision for that. A man has no use in going out empty-handed to get married nowadays. He needs to have a wad and a good stiff one, somewhere between £500 and £1,000 of his own along with the grant. In this case his income is calculated against his father, and is added to his father's income. The whole matter is quite simple and Deputy Smith knows quite well what the meaning of income is.

Comment on this

Deputy McMenamin misunderstands me entirely. I am not arguing the wisdom of the principle of this at all. He is talking about something I am not talking about. I want clarity. My contention is that this amendment will not give us clarity. If the Minister wants to disregard, as Deputy McMenamin is advocating now, the income of the other residents in the house—well and good. Let him set down an amendment which will say that, in determining the income, the local body will disregard any benefits or privileges or payments derived from the children resident in the house or from other residents. That will bring clarity. That is the kind of clarity I want. I am not advocating that principle at all. I do not believe in that principle, but if the Minister is claiming to provide what he says, then let us have it clearly. I know that when the section as amended will go down to the local bodies—I am not a lawyer and I am speaking to the Minister who is—they will proceed to do exactly what they have been doing, that about which Deputy McMenamin has been complaining.

The principle enshrined in Section 10 may be wrong but in how many other cases are local bodies doing the same thing even though it is supposed to be unjust? Do they not do it in regard to differential rents, in regard to scholarships, in fact, in regard to every scheme that operates, in colleges, schools and domestic science institutions? That is something that has been going on for years and these principles have been followed. I am not arguing against them, as Deputy McMenamin has been arguing.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy does not know what he is arguing.

Comment on this

I am arguing on the proposed amendment of the section which, as the Minister said, is designed to limit the income to the income of the applicant and his wife in the case of an application for a supplementary grant. I am asking the Minister to give me an assurance, and the only assurance I want is one that will set out a further amendment to the section and which will say that in determining the income of this pair regard shall not be had to any benefit they derive from any members of the family resident with them or from any other residents in the household. That will give me the principle that the Minister himself is claiming to introduce into this matter. It will also meet the case that has been advocated by Deputy McMenamin. I do not want the Minister to get away with the pretence that he is doing something that he is not, in fact, doing.

Comment on this

In my opinion, what he is doing is quite clear.

Comment on this

Are we to get no assurance, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, on the question of amending the section?

Comment on this

The earnings of the family are not the incomes of the applicant and the spouse and the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

I am asking for some assurance as to what the Minister will do on the Report Stage on Section 9.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say, in regard to the question of income, that if a son is contributing £2 10s. a week towards his maintenance at home, and if a daughter is contributing likewise, and between them the two contribute £5 a week, would this payment for their maintenance at home be regarded as part of the income of the parents?

Comment on this

No. The mere deletion of the words is evidence that it will not be taken into account.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

The words of the section say the earnings of the members of the family are not to be taken into account?

Comment on this

They are to be taken into account in the old section.

Comment on this

The Minister, in reply to me a few moments ago, explained that two items of improvement were taking place in regard to people living on earned income. The limit is to be increased by £104 a year and the earnings of their children are not to be calculated for the purpose of deciding what are the earnings of the applicants. Can I get a categorical "yes" or "no" to what I think is a plain question? If two members of a family are paying £5 a week for their maintenance at home, is that £5 to be reckoned as part of the income of the mother and father, who are applicants for the supplementary grant?

Comment on this

No. The earnings of the family are not to be taken into account.

Comment on this

That is not an answer to the question.

Comment on this

Would payments, as I have outlined, be catalogued as earnings of the family?

Comment on this

That is a matter for the local authority, not for me.

Comment on this

That is going to create confusion because it is already being done in regard to the allocation of cottages. If a man has a certain income and if a son and a daughter have certain earnings and if, when these are totalled up, they come to a certain sum, the man is supposed to be a person who is able to build a house of his own. Unless we clarify the matter, it will end up in a muddle. The local authorities and the various managers are going to have one interpretation and the members of the councils will have another, and nothing can be done because the law is not clear. Deputy Bartley has touched the kernel of the matter. I agree that earnings will not be calculated but if weekly or monthly contributions are made to parents, is that going to be considered?

Comment on this

Definitely, no.

Comment on this

Is there any reason why the Minister himself, from the point of view of clarity and aiding the local authorities to interpret the Act, would not put in the words "the earnings received from other members of the family shall not be taken into consideration"? I believe the Minister himself——

Comment on this

I have deleted that from the original Act and the mere deletion should be evidence of my intentions.

Comment on this

If they are not included they are excluded.

Comment on this

I rather feel that the Minister is trying to do something which is intended to be an improvement on the past, and in order to secure that I am urging him to amend his own proposal to the effect that the earnings received from other members of the family shall not be taken into consideration. That would clarify the whole position and make it certain that, when local bodies were getting down to the interpretation of the section, they might be satisfied as to what they were doing.

Comment on this

The Deputy, as a previous Minister himself, knows that I have no responsibility for the words used by the parliamentary draftsman. I am informed by the draftsman that this wording serves the necessary purpose.

Comment on this

The Minister is very neat in this and again I accuse him of not being frank. We are admitting that this amendment will exclude the other members of the family but it does not define what will be taken into account as income, so far as the husband and wife are concerned.

Comment on this

Their earnings.

Comment on this

What will be regarded as earnings?

Comment on this

I am not teaching a kindergarten.

Comment on this

Suppose we have the case of a man and wife who have two boarders who are each paying the wife £2 10s. a week for staying in the house, and suppose there are two members of the family who are also paying £2 10s. a week each, making a total weekly payment of £10. I want the Minister to tell me what part of that £10 will be taken into account by the local authorities when determining the income of the applicants.

Comment on this

It is a very fair question. If a wife is keeping boarders, she is keeping them for the purpose of earning money. They are being boarded there. You keep boarders for the purpose of earning money. Whatever profit she makes will be part of the income, but at the same time if she is charging two members of the family £2 10s. a week each, that becomes income as well. But if it is a voluntary contribution it does not.

Comment on this

Who is going to determine whether it is voluntary or not?

Comment on this

The local authority.

Comment on this

I knew the Minister had not given any thought to this matter.

Comment on this

I gave it a lot more thought that the Deputy did when drafting the original section.

Comment on this

The Minister is trying to push this through the House. It comes down to this, that if the four persons, two outsiders and two members of the family, each pay 50/- a week——

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like me to withdraw the section?

Comment on this

The Minister is too agreeable.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not very agreeable.

Comment on this

Apparently the Minister is in a shocking hurry to get this through, but the Minister is in the wrong mood to induce me to allow him do that.

Comment on this

I would like to see the Deputy in some other mood some time.

Comment on this

If the Minister were more co-operative he might make more progress. I am asking the Minister again, because the records we are making here now will be interesting to local bodies——

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy said they did not pay any attention to them?

Comment on this

It will be interesting to see what they are thinking of this in six or 12 months's time, if this amendment is put through as it is. I put this to the Minister again. These two outsiders are residing in this house and paying 50/- per week. The Minister says: "That is a payment; that is income, and may be treated as such." There are also two members of the family working out and they are paying 50/- per week. The housing officer, or whatever person is charged by the local authority with the responsibility of making a report on the income of applicants, visits this house. According to the Minister, all the applicant and his wife will have to say, when it comes to the admission that they are getting 50/- a week each from these four people, is: "Our own two children make this to us voluntarily."

Comment on this

That is the correct answer.

Comment on this

Whether it is true or not? Suppose it is not the truth?

Comment on this

There is a very simple method of testing it.

Comment on this

How?

Comment on this

A sworn affidavit. That is the method you have at the moment. Surely the Deputy will not tell me that he has no respect for a sworn affidavit?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

My goodness. I thought an oath was one of the things we respected.

Comment on this

I have never followed the high standards set by the Minister in his time.

Comment on this

I was never on oath in court.

Comment on this

I have doubts about these affidavits.

Comment on this

I think that is a very, very unfair statement to make about the citizens of this country— that the Deputy will not accept the sworn affidavit of an applicant for a supplementary grant because he has doubts about the validity or truthfulness of a sworn affidavit.

Comment on this

I do not think we should be putting temptation in the way of people to tell untruths. My contention and my objection to this amendment all the time is that, without clarification, the Minister is putting temptation in the way of such people.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy state that a person will take a false oath to procure a supplementary grant?

Comment on this

Whatever I say will be on the records and the Minister will not put into my mouth something I have not said. I am saying that I would not put temptation in the way of people to the extent that is being done here. The Minister gets up and glibly says that all the applicant has to do is to contend to the housing authority that this payment, made by the children of the house residing there, is made voluntarily. Does everybody not know that there will be abuses in that case? Does everybody not know that it is a source of encouragement to abuse? What I want is clarity. If the Minister wants to amend the section, I want him to say that no benefit or privilege derived by the applicant for a housing supplementary grant from any member of the household will be taken into account when calculating the income. That will make for clarity and will ensure that there will be no question, either here or any place else, of false affidavits being made.

Comment on this

I am very much afraid that the interpretation of "regular payments" will be now what it always was, that if sons and daughters make regular payments, those payments are considered as obligations for services rendered in the way of giving accommodation, food and so forth. If gifts, so to speak, of varying sums are made in the interim periods, they are not interpreted as income.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

But where there is a regular payment, that is considered an obligation and, in consequence, is included in income? What will be the position of the people down the country who will have to interpret this? The Minister referred to the records of the House, but the records of the House will not be presented to the members of local authorities when they are interpreting this, nor will they be presented to the housing officer when he is making his investigations. He will interpret these things in the same way as they have been interpreted under other Acts; he will not give a different interpretation under this Bill.

Comment on this

Perhaps I might explain to Deputy MacCarthy some of the benefits of my amendment? Take the migrant who goes to England and sends home £2 or £4 per week. Under the law as it stands that is regarded as family income——

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

——but under this amendment he can send back £2, £5 or even £10 per week and it is not regarded as family income and is not taken into account. Even though he sends it back regularly every week, he comes back to reside for a few months of the year——

Comment on this

That is not the law.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon. It is the law as interpreted by local authorities all over the country.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The fact is very clear:

"Every member of such person's family who resided with him during that year and who may reasonably be expected to reside with him in the house."

Comment on this

If he is absent he is not residing in the house.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to be dense he has two methods in which to display his ignorance. I think he is doing it of his own volition in this case. If the member of the family is away and returns for six months, the entire income which that member earned is taken into account in assessing the family income. Under the amendment, that applicant will benefit. Take the case of a boarder. A boarder in a house should, in my opinion, have his or her income taken into account whether that boarder be a son, daughter or anything else. If he or she contributes £1 this year and £4 next year he or she is giving a present. We have very good authority for assessing it in that way. We have the income-tax code.

Comment on this

These are not regular payments.

Comment on this

Supposing they are not an obligation. Remember, the investigating officers and the local authorities are very good judges and will be able to say whether or not it is income or a gift. If any Deputy can tell me how I can amend the phraseology of the parliamentary draftsman, I shall be very glad to do it. As I have said, I have a very open mind. The Fianna Fáil Deputies appear to oppose the section. I am prepared to withdraw the amendment if the Opposition do not want it. I do not propose to say another word on the section, which we have discussed now for an hour and ten minutes. If there is opposition to the section I am prepared to withdraw it.

Comment on this

There is no need for the Minister to take that course at all. When I rose first to ask the Minister to explain the amendment now before the House, I merely wanted to have placed on record here what we were doing. I thought it was the duty of the Minister to do that, but I saw from his explanation of the amendment that he apparently was not anxious to do it. I wanted to get from him an assurance, but he has attempted to side-step this question of giving the same facilities under Section 9 as he is proposing to give to wage-earners in Section 10.

I am surprised, I must confess, that the members of the Minister's Party, many of whom are farmers and members of local bodies, when they saw fit to approve of an amendment to Section 10, did not insist on the Minister also amending Section 9 of the 1952 Act and raising the valuation limits from £12 10s. to £37 10s. We discussed what is proposed in sub-section (2) of the amendment and all I wanted was some explanation from the Minister as to why the amendment was necessary. I tried to convey to the Minister that he is now in the Custom House, in contact with local bodies who have had the responsibility of administering Section 10 of the 1952 Act since 1952.

If local authorities, with four years' experience, have had difficulties then let the Minister tell us what these difficulties are. How many local authorities have had these difficulties and how often have they had them? If he is satisfied there are legitimate difficulties, he must try to amend the situation, but I must ask myself will what is proposed here in sub-section (2) of the amendment effect what the Minister professes it will do? He wants to eliminate the incomes of members of families; he wants to have taken into account only the incomes of the man and wife. I then asked him what is to be looked upon as income where they are concerned and he got all hustled and bustled and said he would withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I did not say anything of the sort. I said I was prepared to withdraw the amendment if the Opposition were opposed to it.

Comment on this

I am not opposed to anything. I want clarity. I do not want to have us passing an amendment here that will be supposed to achieve a certain thing and which, in three months, will leave local authorities in the position in which they will not know what we had in mind when we agreed to this amendment. The Minister read out Section 10 of the 1952 Act, which sets out that the income of every member of the family residing with the family would be taken into account in calculating income. Then he cited the case of a man who might be a migratory worker. Surely it is obvious that if a member of a family were a migratory worker he would not have resided with the family during the previous 12 months.

Comment on this

That was the interpretation the local authority in my county gave it.

Comment on this

Here is the point. Are we doing anything in this amendment to give a general direction as to what will be the interpretation when this section, as amended, is passed? My contention is that, when this amendment is passed, there will be more confusion than that which exists at the moment. I may be wrong of course. It is, however, the duty of the Minister when he comes here after four years' experience of the operation of the section, and with the benefit of the experience of the officials of his Department who have been in contact with local authorities, to clarify the position and not just to say that he will withdraw the provision if Fianna Fáil want him to do so. When he was convinced that an amendment was necessary, it is his duty to tell the House the reasons for it.

Comment on this

Deputy MacCarthy told us a few moments ago.

Comment on this

Deputies MacCarthy and Bartley and all the other Deputies who have spoken have been very helpful, but I now ask the Minister to give us a clear line as to what will be regarded as income in the future if this amendment is inserted in the section. I am asking the Minister to say in what way is it provided in this section that if a migratory worker in Donegal sends home a payment over six months the local authority will be prevented from regarding such payments as income. These are the points on which I want the Minister to be clear.

I am not opposing this section and I do not want any withdrawal. I want to make my contribution to ensuring that when this Bill goes through it will improve matters. If there is confusion let us know what it is and whether there is any method by which we can eliminate it.

Comment on this

On the matter of the affidavit to which the Minister referred, he suggested that Deputy Smith was impugning the character of the average citizens who would make such affidavits: I do not think there is any substance in what the Minister says on that matter. I think that, by his very ambiguity, he has left the matter open to a person making an affidavit to say that the payments to the parents are in fact a contribution and are not a fixed figure for maintenance at home. What the Minister seemed to suggest was that if a son or daughter were paying so much per week for maintenance at home and that if an affidavit were made dubbing that payment a contribution, in some way or another they would be guilty of a very shady interpretation and that doing that in the solemn form of an affidavit was a very grave offence indeed. It would be, if such an offence could be substantiated but surely if one in making an affidavit has a choice of calling what he gives to the family budget at home a contribution or a payment in the ordinary sense of the word, he will be entitled to make a genuine legitimate choice as between the two appellations.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows very well that is not true. In an affidavit they will be making statements in solemn form.

Comment on this

The Minister said, in reply to Deputy Smith, that if it is a contribution it is not to be reckoned as part of the income of the applicant for a supplementary grant. If, on the other hand, it is payment for maintenance at home, then it must be reckoned as part of the income of the applicant. On that there is no ambiguity in the Minister's words; his words were quite clear. Here is the snag: it does not matter what the Minister says about it, the local authority will say and will do something quite different. Let there be as many affirmations as you like on the part of the Minister that such payments are merely contributions; I have no doubt in my mind that the investigating officer of the local authority will, in the future, dub these payments as income of the applicants for grants and it will be reckoned in making up the limitation of income which decides the amount of supplementary grant which is payable. I think the Minister himself has thrown Deputy Smith off the main point which Deputy Smith seemed to me to be pursuing, that is, why the Minister does not amend Section 9 as well as this section and give a corresponding benefit to those whose incomes are measured by rateable valuation. I think that was the main purpose of Deputy Smith's contention here, but, because of the Minister's ambiguity, he had to contend with the position as stated by the Minister.

I want to support Deputy Smith on this question of Section 9. I do not see why, if there is now going to be an alteration in the limit of earned income, corresponding advantage ought not to be given to people living by agriculture whose means are measured by rateable valuation. The Minister will have to say a good deal more than he has already said about Section 9.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister if he proposes to accept evidence by way of affidavit.

Comment on this

That is what the local authority asked for.

Comment on this

It seems to me that any extension of that would not make for improvement. The Minister, as a lawyer, knows that two people can get up in court and swear exactly opposite things and he is also aware that these two people may not be perjuring themselves at all. It is possible for a person to convince himself that something he would like to be may, in fact, be. It is possible for a person to believe, or lead himself to believe, that what is not, is, in fact, so. I think Deputy Smith was right in asking that we should regulate any extension procedure such as this in a manner in which it would be regulated by any competent draftsman.

Comment on this

I hope you are not going to say anything derogatory about the draftsman.

Comment on this

I am quite sure that the draftsmen are competent enough to draft a section which would meet the requirements of this side of the House and, at the same time, give the reliefs provided in this amendment. Deputy Smith did not say that people do not take an affidavit seriously. What he did say was that we should not put temptation on them in that way. This introduces a type of means test that can be met by a person who knows the conditions. I ask the Minister to redraft the section in such a way as to cut down the margin of error.

Comment on this

I did not intend to intervene in this matter at all. If a son or daughter is earning £10 a week, that is now taken into account in assessing family income. If I accept what the Deputies state, then it means that if a person says he contributes £2 10s. of that £10 to his parents, that £2 10s. will be taken into account. No matter how you look at it, there is a saving of £7 10s.

Comment on this

That is an advantage.

Comment on this

Is that not very fair? To go back to what Deputy S. Flanagan has said about affidavits, I can only speak of the experience I have had in my own county where every applicant must have an affidavit, sworn by himself and by every member of the family earning an income, as to the amount of that income, as to the amount contributed to the family purse. Statements must also be taken from the employers and sometimes there is a multiplicity of employers during the year in the case of a migrant. I cannot for the life of me see how I can clarify the position more than I have already clarified it by the amendment of the sub-section and the elimination of the words "...every member of such person's family".

The elimination of those words is an indication to the local authorities that they should not ask for an affidavit from every member of a family, but, if they think, in a particular case, that this is a hotel or guest house or boarding house, they might ask if this is a gift or if it is, in fact, an actual contribution for board and lodgings. Deputy S. Flanagan knows the difference between a gift and a contribution. There might be some doubt as to what form the payment took, as to whether it was an actual gift to the family purse or as to whether it was a contribution on foot of board and lodgings. There is a big difference between that and what is being earned by the members of the family.

Comment on this

If the Minister is putting it that way, I feel satisfied. That is a concession as against the taking into account of the entire earnings of a family. That would have been a sensible approach to make to this whole question and I have not the slightest doubt in my mind that, in interpreting this section, local authorities will regard such payments as income for the family. I am not giving any direction as to what I think they should do. I do not suppose that they would follow any such direction I might give any more than they will follow any direction which the Minister might give. They will follow the section as laid down, advised, as they will be, by their own lawyers, and will say that they were entitled to regard such payments as income.

Since the Minister has veered round very slowly to that point of view, we can regard the amendment as being some improvement inasmuch as it excludes the earnings of an entire family and enables the local body to treat such payments as income.

There are two points which I thought the Minister should have referred to and which he did not refer to. I asked him two questions. I asked him from what source has the pressure come since the draftsmen prepared this Bill to amend Section 10 and to exclude a similar amendment in the case of Section 9. I am asking the Minister if that is as a result of pressure on the part of any local authority.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

There was no pressure of any kind?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I was just thinking that. There was not pressure even in this House for an amendment on the Committee Stage?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

There was no reference whatever of a critical nature to Sections 9, 10 or 11 and we have the extraordinary position now that nobody seems to have asked for this amendment to Section 10.

Comment on this

I did not say so. I said "no local authority".

Comment on this

It is they that pay and it would be useful to consult them. The Minister at one time was very much concerned about consultations with local bodies.

Comment on this

This is purely optional. They need not operate it if they do not wish.

Comment on this

On coming into office, he was supposed to set a good example for all those who might succeed by keeping intimate contact with local bodies and having the greatest amount of consultation in matters like this. On asking, I have got an admission that no local body has requested an amendment of any of these three sections. No member of this House in the course of the discussion on the Second Reading asked for it. Yet we have Section 10 taken out from the others and there is a proposal here to amend it, one to which I am not objecting but one which, I am complaining, should also be applied in the case of Section 9.

I mentioned before that there are members on the other side of the House who understand this matter as clearly as I do, who know the problem of people with small valuations in the provision of houses for themselves, whose rates, expenses and general costs have gone up and whose income has not increased but has decreased. We are providing here for higher grants for those whose income limit has increased since 1952 and we are failing to provide increased valuations for maximum grants in the case of the large section of our people whose income has decreased. If that is the course of justice that the Minister has decided upon without a request from anybody——

Comment on this

I did not say "without request from anybody".

Comment on this

I am anxious to find out from whom.

Comment on this

A number of applicants and those representing them.

Comment on this

In what way did they make their contacts?

Comment on this

Absolutely verbal contact with me.

Comment on this

The Minister must have been a busy bee, to have met all those applicants.

Comment on this

I usually am. I broke precedent in that, too.

Comment on this

But it is an extraordinary thing the Minister did not meet any of the applicants under Section 9.

Comment on this

I will be honest and say I did not.

Comment on this

The Minister should be in touch with many such applicants in County Donegal because I would say that about 95 per cent. of the holdings there would be under £20.

Comment on this

No, under £12 10s. and they are entitled to full grant.

Comment on this

But there are probably others over £12 10s. who are not entitled to a full grant. I am surprised that, as well as meeting those from the wage earning groups, the Minister did not meet some of those who would say: "Why not amend Section 9 and increase valuation limits?". When these sections were being discussed before in 1952, the present Minister for Finance kept me here a whole day with two amendments, one raising the valuation limits from a scale of £25 to £60 and the earning capacity of those affected by Section 10. Although we discussed this matter for a whole day in 1952, the Party of which the Minister is a member has forgotten about this question and now the Minister arrives here with an amendment because he has met somebody.

The local bodies who have to pay are not to be considered at all. The members of the House who are supporting the Government have not even been consulted and I see chairmen and members of county councils who have not expressed one word of support or hostility although I know from their faces they are hostile because they realise the conditions of the ratepayers of the country and they know that when these three sections come before the council a discussion will take place as to whether, having regard to the financial position of the council, they should adopt them at all. Some of them who represent rural people will say the Minister saw fit to amend Section 10 as it affected the wage earner but, of course, did not happen to make contact with any of those who are affected by Section 9, the small farmer.

Comment on this

Nobody made any representations in this House. The Deputy himself did not open his mouth on this question.

Comment on this

Because, as I said, I know the position of local bodies and while I have not the same degree of responsibility to them as the Minister has, I would act in a responsible way. If we wanted to we could have come in with amendments to Sections 9 and 10. We could have proposed raising the valuation limits to £20, £30, £50 and £60 and made great fellows out of ourselves.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows it would have been out of order.

Comment on this

We could have advocated it anyhow on the Second Reading discussion but, of course, the enthusiasts for higher valuation limits in 1952, the enthusiasts for a higher earning capacity in 1952, the enthusiasts for consultation with local bodies in 1952, when they were out of office, the enthusiasts as represented by the Minister for Local Government, now admit that the local bodies, who will be called upon to pay the piper, were not even consulted. He did not even send a solitary line from the Department to any of the county councils in regard to raising income limits. The Minister says he met somebody.

Comment on this

No, a good many.

Comment on this

How am I to know?

Comment on this

The Deputy could accept my word.

Comment on this

I shall not ask the Minister to make an affidavit. I do not wish to put temptation in his way.

Comment on this

The Deputy has more experience of being on oath than I have.

Comment on this

The Minister has greater experience of affidavits than I have.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been on oath several times.

Comment on this

Not too often.

Comment on this

The Deputy would be more particular about what he says if he were.

Comment on this

The Minister proposes to amend Section 10 as it refers to the wage earners in order to keep them in line with present-day circumstances and he ignores the large section of people who are affected by Section 9. He proposes to do this without any consultation although it was always held out by the Minister and others in years gone by as the be-all and end-all. There is nothing wrong with raising the income limits. Certainly they were low. They are still low.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that anyway.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had been in the House during the course of this discussion he would have heard my arguments in this connection, but a Deputy who is interested in housing and in the welfare of the people finds it inconvenient to be here during a discussion, drops in and makes a smart remark in an endeavour to show that I am partial to one section of the people as against another. I am not, because these three sections which we are discussing now were designed by me. They are sections that have stood the test of time. They have stood the test of time because the architect of these three sections was a man who understood what the problems of local authorities were. He was not one of those who would simply come along——

Comment on this

Hear, hear! Give yourself another clap on the back.

Comment on this

Of course I will.

Comment on this

Nobody else will.

Comment on this

I would not, in fact, appreciate a clap from Deputy Rooney and I have tried to convey that to him on more than one occasion. I do not know whether or not it is possible to convey it to him. It is a wonderful thing to hear the present Minister, a man who was loud in his praise of consultation with local bodies, admitting now that he is trying to make himself the big fellow with that section of our people already covered by Section 10 of the 1952 Housing Act. It will not mean any payment——

Comment on this

I apologise to no man for being the friend of the poor.

Comment on this

This will not mean any payment out of the Exchequer because we are taking steps to ensure that, so far as housing is concerned, every payment that can be curtailed will be curtailed. When it is a matter of letting the ratepayers hold the baby we can, of course, be generous. I invite the Minister now to extend his generosity to another section of the community, namely, those who are covered by Section 9 and who are equally entitled to the same generosity.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy want? Does the Deputy want to throw a bigger burden on the ratepayers? Is that what the Deputy wants?

Comment on this

I am anxious about uniformity of interpretation in so far as that is possible. I concede there is an improvement. The position is clearer now than it was when the discussion started. Nevertheless, I am not satisfied that we have got anything nearer to uniformity of interpretation. If there are boarders in a house and they pay £2 10s. per week, the profit on that is regarded as income. If they are a son and daughter, or two sons, or two daughters, and they contribute £2 10s., is it the £2 10s. or the profit on it which will be regarded as income?

Comment on this

The income-tax code defines that.

Comment on this

Now, an inspector goes around to ensure that tenants are qualified for cottages or for village type houses. As the law at present applies, the earnings of the family are taken into account. An inspector goes around under the Health Act and he equates a valuation of £50 to an income of £600. We are altering the income for housing. One inspector comes along and interprets income in one way.

Comment on this

Surely, that is administration?

Comment on this

It is, but I do not want any confusion in this matter. If £50 is equated to £600 income and the income here is being altered, why not make the appropriate equation apply also in valuations? The Minister knows rates are increasing every year. Rates are not static. Valuation may be static but, because rates are increasing, obligations are increasing likewise. Valuations should be increased in proportion in this section. I want two things; I want uniformity of interpretation and the equation of valuation to income or earnings.

Comment on this

The Minister said in reply to Deputy Smith that a proposal to amend Section 9 would be out of order. I do not know why he should say that but I take it that it would not be out of order for the Minister himself to do it. Perhaps he might consider doing it.

I want to add my voice to what Deputy Smith and Deputy MacCarthy have just said. Why, if the Minister has decided to raise the income limits for one section of applicants for these supplementary grants on the basis that the purchasing power of money has gone down, does he make the case that the value of money has not decreased in relation to another section of applicants simply because their land valuations are, as he said himself, static? How can he reason that, because land valuations are static, the income of the farmer has not changed when, on the other hand, he can make the case that the income of the wage earner has changed? Can the Minister give us some explanation of his reasoning in relation to differentiation as between these two categories of applicants?

Comment on this

Deputy MacCarthy was anxious about interpretation. I, too, would like to know whether it is gross or net income which will be taken into consideration in assessing means under Section 10 of the 1952 Act.

Comment on this

We are not discussing Section 10 of the 1952 Act. We are discussing an amendment.

Comment on this

I would like if the Minister would take this opportunity of clarifying the position. I think it is quite in order to give a lead to local authorities in relation to the question as to whether they should base their means test on gross or net income. In the case of a man and his wife, each of whom is in receipt of £10 per week and where there are no dependents——

Comment on this

I cannot give an interpretation.

Comment on this

The section has been interpreted in different ways by local authorities in the past.

Comment on this

That is purely administration. I have nothing to do with administration.

Comment on this

This is an opportunity on which that matter could be cleared up.

Comment on this

That is what I am trying to do.

Comment on this