Committee on Finance. - Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956—Committee Stage.
Contributions 232–451 of 682. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 16 of 1956 ›
I am dealing with a matter which the amendment does not do. The Minister should not assume the role of Ceann Comhairle as well as that of Minister. I am quite entitled to raise this matter. I am dealing with the case where a man and his wife have a joint income over the statutory amount which would entitle them to a supplementary grant and they have no dependents. Now it is not fair in the case of a man and his wife and six, or five, dependents to assess their income at the same figure as those who have no dependents. That has been the position in the past. Irrespective of the number of dependents, there was no amelioration of the means test.
Comment on this
In other words, some local authorities are basing their means test on gross income instead of net. Dependents are not taken into consideration. I would like the Minister, apart from trying to assure me that the matter is not relevant, to clarify the position.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom a rá go gcuidighim leis an méid a dubhairt an Teachta MacGabhann. In the last six months, anyone living in the country knows that the income of the farming community has fallen and that they have been hit very hard. Whether it be the small beast or the big beast, there has been a drop in what the beast was bought at——
Comment on this
What the butchers did does not arise on the amendment. The Deputy should deal with the amendment.
Comment on this
Trick questions are coming across the floor of the House. I was dealing with the point that the farming community have lost very considerably in their income, no matter what their valuation may be, so much so that, when my county council met recently to consider a circular from the Minister as to whom we would give loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, we departed from the accepted interpretation of "farming income" from £12 per £1 valuation and reduced it to £10. That was done unanimously by the Westmeath County Council. The Party which the Minister represents are in the majority in that county council. They pulled down their assessment of the valuation of income from £12 per £1 valuation to £10.
In his amendment to Section 10, the Minister has approached this matter in relation to earned income, to cash income. If that is true about cash income, it is more than true about the farming community because the cost of living has gone up to the same extent and by the same percentage for them as for the wage earner. Their earnings have been hit very hard. They have had to fall back on reserves in the past six months. They did not get what they paid for live stock at the sale of these live stock after fattening them for six or eight months. That drop has continued up to to-day. If ever a section of the community wanted help it is the farming community at the present time. To skip by Section 9 and give relief under Section 10 is a city man's approach to the question of housing.
The Minister should, on Report Stage, do the same for the small farmer as he is doing for the wage earner. He should now give an undertaking to bring in a section that will bring up the valuation of the small farmer in relation to new housing grants and reconstruction grants in the same ratio as he has dealt with Section 10. Otherwise, there will be this continued flight from the land. The man on the uneconomic farm, the man on the small farm, unless he is helped out and well helped out, will just sell out the farm and go to England or somewhere else. Every time you raise wages in the cities and towns, and those of rural workers employed by local authorities, you establish a standard of living which, in contrast with the standard of living of the smallholder, is miles ahead. He naturally seeks the same standard of living as the wage earner. Here, you are weighing down the scales in favour of the wage earner and ignoring the smallholder.
I spoke of a figure of £12 income as interpreted on a well-run farm for £1 valuation. If Deputy Larkin and those city Deputies who so glibly interrupt, and who know a standard of living that many of our people will never know in the country, were put on those small farms to live, the whole lot of them would die in 12 months and, after a very short while on the farms, they would be looking for social welfare benefits of one kind or another. They are living in luxury compared with the people whom I have in mind. That is the pattern of life not only in Donegal, Galway or Kerry, but it is the pattern of life of the majority of farmers in County Westmeath. The majority of our people, first of all, live on the land and 63 per cent. in that comparatively rich county live on a valuation of £20 and under. I should like to see some of the city Deputies placed on these farms to see what kind of a living they would get out of them.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry says you never till an acre in Westmeath and that all you do is look at the cattle.
Comment on this
Naturally, it does not arise. I am very glad somebody is in the Chair because it is a very difficult position when one is up against a lawyer. When a simple person from Westmeath is up against a keen northern intellect, he is in a very difficult position in debate.
Comment on this
I should like to reply to Deputy J. Brennan. He raised the question of family income. In case he does not understand the position, I would explain that, under the 1952 Act, every applicant for a grant had taken into account not only his own income but the income of his wife and of all the children who were over in Scotland or England, even at the potato gathering for a few months of the year. Their income was taken into account and the applicant had to swear an affidavit as to the amount of income received—not the amount they contributed but the amount of income. I tried to eliminate the earnings of the family and to confine it to the income of the applicant and his spouse. I was personally aware of the amount of trouble and hardship imposed upon these applicants, particularly in West Donegal.
I was pressed by Deputy Smith as to the source from which I received representations to amend the Act. He criticised me and said no representations were made here on the Second Reading by fellow Deputies from Donegal or the West or anywhere else. He said I should not have introduced this amendment because I had received no representations. I pointed out I had personally received the representations and that, as a result, I was introducing the amendment. It should not be necessary, if the Minister is aware of the sufferings and harships which people endure, to wait until some Deputy——
Comment on this
I am well aware of what the amendment of this section proposes to do with regard to family income. I should like the Minister to clarify the position with regard to gross and net income. As it stands now, the income of the man and his wife jointly arises. In cases where there are one, two, three, or more dependents, will any relief be given in respect of the same income as against cases where there are no dependents?
Comment on this
The Minister is still leaving it to the local authority to place whatever interpretation on the means test——
Comment on this
The Minister should give a directive to those people by means of a further expansion of the amendment which he has already introduced. In many cases, it might be more beneficial than what he proposes doing here. I am sure he is aware that the income referred to in Section 10 of the 1952 Act relates to the income of the applicant during the 12 months immediately preceding the date of his application. Therefore, those members of the family who are abroad are not taken into consideration.
Comment on this
Only if the applicant's income for the 12 months immediately preceding the date of application——
Comment on this
I am more familiar with the administration of that section than possibly anybody in the House. That is exactly the position. I have never been able to elicit a suitable reply from anybody in relation to the question of net income as against gross income.
Comment on this
I did not hear the Minister justifying the position that ratepayers, who pay well over three-fourths of all the grants, are being penalised as against another section of the community. I do not understand why they should be penalised as against another section, while, at the same time, they do not get the same benefit.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
I was inquiring from the Minister as to why he is proposing an injustice in this section. He is well aware that at least three-fourths of all the grants made by a local authority outside the urban area are raised from the land. Landowners who apply for a grant, although compelled to pay for another section of the community, are not entitled to any increased grants. I am sure the Minister fully realises that fact. He is proposing to increase the grants to those who apply on the basis of income, but those who apply on the basis of valuation are not entitled to any increased grant, although they will be forced to pay towards the grants given to the income earning class. That is what this section means.
Has it been shown up to the present time that there was unfair discrimination towards the income earning class in any rural area as compared with the ratepaying class? The person with a valuation up to £37 can apply for a supplementary grant from the local authority for the building or reconstruction of a house. A scale was laid down in the 1952 Act, and a scale was also laid down in respect of the income earning class. Now it is proposed to increase the scale in respect of the income earning class and to force the ratepaying applicant to pay more in rates in order to supplement the other man's grant. There is a grave injustice in all this.
I am very surprised that the Minister can give no justification for this. None of this money will come out of the Exchequer. We can be very generous when we are legislating to make the ratepayers pay more, but if the ratepayers are forced by this legislation to pay more, at least they should be entitled to a fair share of the extra rates that this House proposes to put on them. That is the argument of Deputy Smith. It is one that should be considered by Deputies sitting behind the Minister before they walk into the division lobby to vote for increased rates, when those who pay the greater part of the rates will get no benefit whereas those who are income earners and pay no rates will benefit.
A Minister who would make such proposals and ask the House to accept them does not realise the problem in rural Ireland to-day. I am sure the Government are aware that the income of those who live on the land has fallen by a good 30 per cent. recently and, unfortunately for everyone in the country, when the count is taken this year, it will be shown that the income of those who live by the land will have fallen by a minimum of 30 per cent., and, in many instances, by a much higher percentage. The Government are proposing to give local authorities power to give higher supplementary housing grants to people who own no land. It is a grave injustice and I suggest that the Minister should withdraw the amendment. If there is justification for giving increased grants to one section, he should at least give the option to local authorities to give it to the other section who will pay the money.
Comment on this
We have been discussing this section for nearly two and a half hours and, in order that progress can be made, I ask the Minister to undertake to re-examine the matter on Report Stage in order to meet Deputy Smith's very reasonable suggestions and his requests for clarification. The kernel of the matter is that the onus is being thrown on the local authorities to interpret this section. The Limerick County Council could give one interpretation and the Westmeath County Council another. The Minister has power on the Report Stage to add a clause to this so that the position will be clear beyond yea or nay or else he could use the powers vested in him under the Act whereby he can make regulations so that we could make some progress. I would ask the Minister to meet Deputy Smith's request and clarify the amendment on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
The Minister said he received representations on behalf of the wage-earners whose incomes govern the amount of the supplementary grant to which they are entitled from the local authority. He also said he received no such representations from people whose incomes are measured by rateable valuation but then he added later on, quite properly, that he himself would be perfectly entitled, and, in fact, would feel it a duty upon him, to bring in whatever amendments he thought justice demanded.
It is just on that issue that we want the Minister to say quite definitely, seeing that he has provided no improvement for the rateable valuation class, why it is that he has made an exception of them. What is the meaning of the statement he made earlier on, that their valuations are static? The implication I gathered from it was that the Minister wanted the House to deduce that their incomes had not been affected by the change in the value of money. Of course, I do not believe that he could be so naïve as to suggest that we might swallow any such implication.
After all, valuations with a changeable rate do not produce the effect of a static income. If a man has a static poor law valuation of £20 that does not mean he is paying just the same amount of rates that he paid three or four years ago. The Minister knows he is paying a far higher rate than he was three or four years ago. If the changing value of money is the case which he now offers to the House for the amendment he has brought in, can he give us a reason as to why he is not providing an equivalent improvement for the ratepaying class?
Comment on this
I will answer both Deputy Allen and Deputy Smith on that point. I am not changing the class. Any person with a poor law valuation of £12 10s. is still entitled to a 100 per cent. grant irrespective of the value of money. Let us take the class which had a family income up to £208 per annum. That class is not being changed. In my opinion, we have no person now with an income of £208 per annum. In other words, the rise in wages has moved those individuals out of that class and they do not now qualify for the 100 per cent. grant, but the valuation of the farmer, irrespective of the rise in the value of money, is static. His class, with a valuation of £12 10s., is still the same and is still entitled to a 100 per cent. grant if they wish to apply for one.
We will have no person in the class of wage earners with £208 who would be entitled to a 100 per cent. grant, so that to try to keep that section of the community within the 100 per cent. grant range, we have to step up the figure of family income to £312, but in respect of the farmer who is entitled to a 100 per cent. grant his valuation has not changed and he is still entitled to it. He is still entitled to apply and he still exists.
Comment on this
The valuation limits of £12 10s., £20, £25 and £37 were decided upon having regard to the earning capacity of those in occupation of holdings in regard to these categories.
Comment on this
We decided upon the income limit of the wage earners in relation to the earning capacity of a man with a valuation of £12 10s. and so on. The Minister is perfectly logical when he says that because of the increase in the earning capacity we are driving a number of people outside the limit in all catagories. But if you are doing that in relation to one class covered by Section 10, you are also doing an injustice to the other class. It is on the basis of earning capacity that they too had their standard set. The Minister is preventing those from enjoying the benefits of grants at a higher maximum level than £12 10s. Their income limit has decreased. In one case the Minister is conferring a benefit on those whose earning capacity has increased and he is depressing those whose earning capacity has decreased.
That is the point we are making. That is the injustice we have exposed here and that is the injustice we are asking the Minister to agree to remedy. As I say, I would not ask the Minister to do that if he himself had not proposed to amend Section 10. There would have been no protest from this side of the House because of the reasons I gave but once the Minister set out to amend Section 10 he is bound in justice—if the Minister is anxious to do justice to the sections of the community covered in these cases —to alter the valuation limits. I am pressing the Minister for an assurance and if he gives us that assurance the discussion will come to an end now.
We have discussed the matter of the spouse and all the rest of it and we have at least reached some little agreement, although I am still satisfied that confusion will prevail there as it existed before. However, it may be better than what was there. We are not anxious to discuss the matter any further and we would like to bring it to finality. I should like to ask the Minister to give us some assurance that he will do justice to the classes of people who are covered in Section 9.
After all, the Minister confessed to the House that a number of applicants approached him who were affected by Section 10. The Minister did not hear any case for it in the House. The Minister agreed to amend Section 10 by the introduction of this amendment. I think we are fairly responsible people and we are urging that no injustice be done to these other people. If the Minister is going to amend Section 10, he should also agree to amend Section 9. If he does that, we will have no further discussion on the matter.
Comment on this
What I am asked to do is to step up the poor law valuation of the people who may come within the scope of the supplementary grant class. Deputies Allen and Smith are asking me to bring in more farmers into the supplementary grant class. Is that not so?
Comment on this
What would happen if I stepped up the poor law valuation of a farmer? At the moment the maximum amount is £35. The Deputies are asking me, say, to double that. What limit would the Deputies put on it, £50?
Comment on this
All we ask is that the Minister relate the £104 increase to the valuation and give a similar increase to the other class.
Comment on this
If we put up the poor law valuation by £5 that would bring the maximum up to £40 per annum and that would bring in more farmers. It would add to the burden on the taxpayers. By increasing the money, I am certainly bringing no more of the working class into this. Although wages have gone up, the same number of applicants will be affected.
Comment on this
No, I am not adding one additional person to the class who will benefit but you ask me to put a severe burden on the ratepayers by bringing in more farmers. There is the difference. There would be no additional applicant by my amendment but there would be additional farmers were I to accept an amendment to Section 9. I think that is quite clear. Deputy Smith rightly pointed out that by my amendment alone, there would be an addition on the ratepayers. There may be a slight extra charge but I am adding no person—not one single individual—to the class or to the numerical strength of the class that is going to benefit. But were I to increase the poor law valuation of farmers I would bring further applicants within the ambit of the Bill.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is not seriously asking us to accept that reasoning. The contention now is that in his amendment to Section 10 he is not bringing in any greater number of people.
Comment on this
But, surely if you prevent people from going out of a category, is not that in effect increasing the number?
Comment on this
Never mind about the mathematics, it is good, solid argument. Suppose that the income limit for the maximum grant—
Comment on this
The income limit for a maximum grant under Section 10 was £208 and in the case of a farmer it was £12 10s. valuation. These two figures were related. It was felt that the occupant of a holding of £12 10s. valuation would have an income of around that figure. I admit that. The £208 is now being increased by £104 and it becomes £312. If the amendment were not inserted, those people over £208 would not secure a maximum grant from the local body as a supplementary grant—is not that right?
Comment on this
Therefore, when this amendment is inserted here, it will mean that those people who would formerly have been excluded from the maximum grant will now secure the maximum grant and in that way you would be increasing the number of people.
Comment on this
You are increasing the number of people under Section 10 who will obtain the maximum grant by inserting this amendment. I am not saying that we are opposed to that, but our contention in regard to the man whose valuation was £12 10s. or over £12 10s. in 1952 is that his earning capacity, related to that figure, has gone down.
Comment on this
We want to ensure that, if you keep in people who would not otherwise be kept in under Section 10, you will bring in a similar number under Section 9, that is under valuations. That is a perfectly genuine, logical and just case and there is no use in the Minister now attempting to pretend that he is not discriminating between two sections of the community. He is doing it, as I say, without any apparent justification and without any urge from those who will have to pay. I want to ensure that the council of the county I happen to represent, if confronted with the task of deciding whether or not they should adopt this scheme, will not have a discussion between two councillors, one of whom will say: "Here is the Act we now have, setting out the scale of grants for different classes of people. The Minister, the Government, and the Dáil have discriminated in favour of one section and we will not vote for the adoption of this scheme as a result of that." I want this House, if we are to send down a scheme to county councils, to send a scheme that can be adopted by them if they like, and if they do not like it, it can be rejected; but I want to make sure that it will be a just scheme.
The Minister knows that there are councils that have not so far adopted this scheme. He knows there are councils who feel that the scheme, even though limited as it was, has imposed——
Comment on this
Well, it must have been in recent times, because in the early stages they did not adopt it. That goes to show there was hesitancy on the part of county councils as to the wisdom of taking that course. I am pressing the Minister now since he is proposing an amendment with which we are not disagreeing, to amend the section in order that those councils that have adopted the scheme will not be using such arguments as those I have mentioned in order not to adopt it in future. I want to ensure that the ratepayers of the county that has been paying the grants that have been made since 1952 will not be in the position that they will get no benefit themselves although they may contribute.
I put it to the Minister that it is a serious matter for the ratepayers because these grants are paid entirely from rates even though the money is borrowed. The annuity has to be met until the borrowed money is repaid. I hope the Minister will appreciate the justice of what I am pleading—that it is unfair to come along and say to these ratepayers: "You must pay for the increased grants to those who are getting increased income in order to keep them in a certain class but you yourselves are to be kept in the same class even though your income has gone down." There is no justice in that.
Comment on this
There is a danger that we will depart from the kernel of the whole thing which, as I see it, is to encourage people to reconstruct their own houses——
Comment on this
——rather than having to provide subsidies for new houses of a rather substantial nature.
Comment on this
If it is practicable to reconstruct a house, we should encourage people in that way. Sometimes we hear people say that the middle-income group is hard hit by the circumstances of life as they are at the moment. To my mind the middle valuation people are equally hard hit in many ways and any help that can be given to them in regard to the construction or reconstruction of houses should be given to them. In doing that, we are providing a health safeguard by having better housing and, as well as that, we are building up a national asset because no sooner is a house reconstructed or a new house built than the valuation officer goes around to know what additional charges he is to put on the person who does it. To my mind, if you are to help out to the extent that is intended here, and in equity, I think——
Comment on this
Is the Deputy speaking in favour of the amendment to Section 9? He thinks the municipal authorities will be called upon to house farmers of £10 valuation?
Comment on this
If a person with a valuation, say, of £12 10s. wants to reconstruct his house, he will be entitled to certain supplementaries and at the moment would benefit. My view is that income and valuation have been related under certain Acts, say, £1 to £12.
Comment on this
I think many of them in our towns and villages require this encouragement to-day to reconstruct their houses. We are talking about valuations other than those of farmers.
Comment on this
I know, but what I am trying to argue on equity is that we have related, under certain Acts, £1 valuation to—in some cases—£10, £11, or £12.
Comment on this
We can keep the same relationship and try to have an equitable result from what we are now attempting to do. If one class of people get this advantage it should apply generally, because you are only giving local authorities the power to put more taxes on the people they represent. A person who builds a new house will have increased charges placed on him after a certain number of years.
Comment on this
In sub-section (4) of Section 10 of the 1952 Act, where there was a one-third grant for a new house, the maximum income was £416. If this Act becomes law, the maximum income will be raised to £520 and it is completely wrong for the Minister to state that there will be no addition to the number of people who will be serviced by the passing of this Act. Of course there will be. It seems that the £10 a week man who did not qualify heretofore for grants, or supplementary grants, will now come in.
Comment on this
There is many a £10 a week man in the country who does not qualify now, but if this Bill becomes an Act he will qualify and he will apply. We are not objecting to him; we are contending that the small farmer should equally qualify. If there is an increase in the number of beneficiaries of the wage-earning class as a result of the passing of this Bill, it should not be lopsided and weighted on the side of the wage earner in contrast to the small farmer and the middle-sized farmer. The Minister should make an addition to bring them to the same level as the wage-earners. The burden, I contend, would be less on the ratepayers and on the State.
As the Minister knows, and as we all know, the farmer is a conservative man. He weighs everything up before coming to a decision. He is very slow to come to a decision to build a new house. The pros and cons are weighed up and down before the decision is made, whereas the wage earner will take a chance. He is living in a town or village and, seeing the benefit, he rushes in and builds a house. Therefore, the beneficiaries will be more on the wage-earning side than on the farming side. All we are asking is for a reasonable approach and that the Minister will promise to examine the farmers' position and bring them the same benefits as are proposed in this amendment.
Comment on this
We are getting a fair amount of instruction as to the incidence of hardship caused by the depreciation of money. It is true that if you raise the valuation limits to qualify applicants for supplementary grants, you do bring in more farmers, but the Minister seems—although he has not said so in so many words—to suggest that a man who has, say, £20 valuation has the same earning power to-day as he had when money was at a higher value, say four or five years ago. That argument, as far as I can see, only holds water in the case of a farmer who can be made out to be 100 per cent. self-sufficing. How many farmers have we who provide all their needs from their own agricultural resources? Do we not know that this earning capacity has been affected by the increase in wages where he employs labour? Is it not affected by the amount of rates he pays, and above all, is he not affected by the price of the articles he buys in the shops, just as the wage earner is affected? Surely it cannot be contended that the man with a valuation of £20 has the same earning capacity as he had formerly? That seems to be the fundamental line upon which the Minister is going.
In my opinion, it is certainly necessary to increase the total number of farmers who should now, in justice and equity, be made potential applicants. Can the Minister give us any clear explanation of the effect of the depreciated money on the earning capacity of a farmer, of any given valuation, now, as compared with five or six years ago? We do not accept at all the statement that the earning capacity is the same. This measuring of income by a figure of rateable valuation is not at all a guarantee that the person who has property that is rateable in that way is immune from the consequences of devalued money, such as happens to a wage earner.
Comment on this
He has increased rates and wages to pay. He has increases to pay for his fertilisers, and in the case of one very important section of producers, the producers of wheat, he has had the price of his product reduced by 12/6 per barrel. We cannot see where the equity is. We should like the Minister to apply himself a little more diligently—even if his equity is sound enough—to see that he is not doing an injustice in this matter.
Comment on this
I was surprised to note that the Minister was somewhat alarmed when the question of the farmer was mentioned. To-day, compared with the period when money was more valuable and its purchasing power was greater, it makes a very great difference to farmers, particularly small farmers of £20, £30 or £35 valuation, if some relief is given. Recently, in regard to one local authority, we had a case where farmers were informed they could receive a certain grant from the State. They applied for a grant from the local authority, but the little extra made all the difference to them, and they could not proceed. I know the Minister is a reasonable man and he appreciates what it is to live in a rural district. Kerry and Donegal are comparable——
Comment on this
It makes all the difference to the small or medium sized farmer of £30 or £35 valuation——
Comment on this
—— and it makes a very great difference to the man with £10 or £12 valuation. That is why I join with my colleagues in making this plea to the Minister. Seeing that he is catering for the wage earners, he should also include the farmers and amend Section 9.
Comment on this
I wanted some information about Section 9, but the Minister has not been too anxious to give it. First of all, I should like to know is Section 9 designed only for two local bodies—Dublin and Cork?
Comment on this
If that is the case, I should like to know if the Local Loans Fund will be available to all local bodies for the purposes of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts?
Comment on this
This is what produces the confusion. If local bodies are to get advances from the Local Loans Fund to finance house purchase and the erection of houses under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, there will be nobody to apply to a building society or insurance company.
Comment on this
Those people, who I expect should have applied, namely, people of modest means, will always have access to the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts.
Comment on this
It is a matter of either giving us information or not. We have been on Section 8 since 3.30 simply because the Minister did not even attempt to give us information and we had to drag it out of him. Section 9 is either an important section or it is not an important section. If it is not an important section, it does not serve any purpose and there does not appear to be any reason why it should be here. In the course of the debate on the Second Reading, the Minister gave us to understand that local bodies will be as free as before to borrow from the Local Loans Fund to finance transactions under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. I began to wonder did that statement mean that all local authorities, with the exception of Dublin and Cork—Dublin and Cork never had access to the Local Loans Fund up to recently and have not had such access even yet—would be entitled to go to the Local Loans Fund to get the necessary finance to operate under these Acts. Now the Minister tells me that that is not the case. He assures me that all local bodies will be free to go to the Local Loans Fund to enable them to continue their activities under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, but the Minister interjected a remark which seemed to suggest that there will be some question of the type of people to whom these moneys, when borrowed by local bodies, will be allocated.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting anything. I am suggesting the Minister is in this House in charge of a Bill. That is what I am suggesting.
Comment on this
It would serve the passage of this Bill if the Minister would take some interest in this and tell us what Section 9 means.
Comment on this
It is usual in this House, when a Housing (Amendment) Bill is introduced, that some forward move or some little progress is made beyond what had been accomplished in the previous Acts. For the first time in the history of the State we are now confronted with a measure which, instead of making some advance, is actually a retrograde measure.
We have now reached the most controversial section of the whole Bill. Everything else fades into oblivion compared with this section. This is the famous, or, should I say, the infamous section whereby local authorities are entitled to come to an arrangement with the building societies. What the man in the street wants to know is exactly what this means. What exactly does the Bill which hinges around this section mean? It is very simple. The Minister could have stated the facts and given the full truth in his introductory remarks. The position, for the benefit of the man in the street, in simple language is that the Government cannot get the money from the public and as a result there is a recession in house building.
Comment on this
There will be no recession in house building, absolutely none. I am making available for house building a source of funds never before available.
Comment on this
I shall prove, before I sit down, how there will be a recession in house building. Not alone will there be such a recession but it is there at the present time, not only in Dublin and Cork but in Limerick and all over the country.
Comment on this
I read that the Deputy tried to make that case in Limerick last night but that it was denied by the city manager.
Comment on this
The Minister has only to look at the statistics and he will see the tremendous reduction in employment.
Comment on this
We are talking about two different things. We are now discussing Section 9, the section making provision for the building of houses by people for their own use. In the other sections, we have scope for dealing with the erection of county council cottages and so forth. The 7 per cent. people are being brought in now. Is it any pleasure for the Minister to have to make arrangements with the societies on behalf of the local authorities? I am convinced it does not give him any pleasure in the world.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Deputy a question? Would he suggest that every person in this country should have access to the funds of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts?
Comment on this
The Deputy would suggest that the system whereby the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts have been administered up to now should be continued.
Comment on this
I am making certain that rich people will not have access to these funds, that the money will be reserved for the smaller people, the poorer people, the people of modest means.
Comment on this
That sounds terrific. It will make great reading in tomorrow's newspapers, that the money available for people who want to build houses for themselves will not be available for millionaires. Where are the millionaires? I have not seen excessively wealthy people availing of the provisions of the Acts. If the Minister says that during the years wealthy people availed of the provisions of these Acts, why does he not cut out the housing grant of £275 which is available to these people? If you build a house of 1,400 square feet, be your income £10 or £10,000, you will still get a grant of £275 under this section.
Comment on this
Under this Bill, you need not build the house for yourself. You can get a grant for the house and then let it; or I could get a grant for a house and sell it to you.
Comment on this
I do not want to get away from the point I was trying to make. The Minister now finds himself in the position that the last public loan was a failure and that in order to provide moneys from the Local Loans Fund and keep things going as best he can, he has had to seek outside sources. Is it not fantastic to say that the Government cannot get money at, say, 5 per cent. or 5? per cent. but that the building societies, some of the 2½d. societies can, at much lower interest rates, attract capital? Is there not something seriously wrong? A Government loan, with an interest rate of 5 per cent. at 98, fails. The building societies offer lower rates of interest than the Government offered on a public loan.
The position now is that the Government, through the Minister, have said: "We will have to call a halt to private building under certain categories." The Minister suggests that people have been raiding the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts funds throughout the country, people who could well afford to build their own houses. Of course there is not the slightest truth in such a statement. Every Deputy knows that the ordinary man in the street is put to the pin of his collar to find the 5 per cent. statutory deposit, not to talk about finding sufficient money to put up his own house. We have the admission for the first time that the Government cannot get money to keep private house building going on in this country. Local authorities are asked to enter into an agreement with building societies under which certain terms will be agreed on between the two parties. The Minister, when speaking on the Second Stage of the Bill, said:—
"The same amount of money under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts will be made available this year under these Acts as was made available last year."
Is the Minister serious in stating that?
Comment on this
The Minister has given an undertaking, mark you, that the same amount of money will be made available this year to such bodies as the Limerick Corporation and Cork County Council as was made available last year. Right. We are satisfied in Limerick; the demand for houses is on the decrease. That being so, possibly we will need next year only as much as we asked for this year. Therefore, what is the need for a deal with the building societies? Could the Minister answer that? If he intends to make as much money available next year as this year, why bring the building societies into the scheme at all?
Comment on this
If people want to go to the building societies, that is their own business, but if the facilities are there under the Small Dwellings Acts, why not let him continue?
Comment on this
Is there not a growing trend to get money other than through the Small Dwellings Acts?
Comment on this
At the outset, when introducing this Bill, the Minister said that to meet the need for 40,000 houses, as estimated in the White Paper of 1947, approximately 35,000 had been built under the Housing Acts administered by his Department. Would not that suggest that the demand is falling?
Comment on this
We do not deny the fact that everyone who wants a loan will get it. Why we are going to vote against Section 9 is purely and simply that we want to show up what can only be described as the treachery and deceit to which the Government has descended in introducing this ignominious section, whereby people in this country will have to pay 7 per cent. for their money. We have in the past heard criticism from the Tánaiste when we paid, in 1952, according to him, 5 per cent. for money we borrowed.
Comment on this
The Minister interrupted with that same remark on the last occasion here and I will deal with it later. We had the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, with his usual cant, saying that such rates of interest would not be paid by a banana republic. I do not want to indulge in anything of that kind. I want to bring home to the House the serious plight that people are going to find themselves in. This is permissive legislation which any local authority, if they so wish, can adopt. In this section we are holding out a bait to the local authorities and saying: "If you do not adopt Section 9, you will not get sufficient funds from the Local Loans Fund to pay for private housing."
Comment on this
If the Minister gives Limerick Corporation the same amount this year as last year, there is no need for this section. If we get £100,000, that will do us.
What is the reason for Section 9? I have already pointed out the necessity for it. The reason is that the Government, for the first occasion, confesses to the public of this country that the Government has broken down, although the Taoiseach and Tánaiste have said that nothing will stand in the way of speeding the housing drive. The Minister has my sympathy. He is the Minister for Local Government. He can only do his best with the funds at his disposal and in the circumstances in which he finds himself. However, the Minister is a member of the Government and therefore he has to be responsible, along with that Government, to the people of this country for having the audacity to bring Section 9 into this House and to suggest that local authorities should enter into deals with the building societies, on behalf of the citizens, at 7 per cent. We had a meeting of Limerick Corporation last night at which Senator Reidy, a supporter of the Government, said——
Comment on this
It was said that the rent of an ordinary £1,200 or £1,300 house, if increased by 7/- or 8/- per week, would mean nothing. Does the Minister realise that an increase of even one shilling per week is a very substantial amount? To people who embark on building their own houses, every shilling counts. The day will come when the two-thirds remission of rates will end and they will have to make some form of saving to provide for the serious impact of that additional two-thirds on them. The ordinary individual comes along and makes arrangements to build his own house. He has x shillings a week for his repayments, and he calculates what it will cost him for his ground rent, for one-third of his rates, for insurance, for wear and tear and so on. I defy the representatives of local authorities on any side of this House to say that they will be able to do it. What a millstone to put around any unfortunate individual's neck!
We can imagine a young, timid man coming along, just after getting married, to look for a Small Dwellings Acts loan. A "buff" comes out and tells him to take himself away and that all he can get, under Section 9, introduced by the Minister for Local Government, is a loan on which he pays 7 per cent. in interest alone. How is he going to pay 50/- or 70/-, or whatever it may be? The whole thing is fantastic.
We have limits of £1,800 for houses in Cork and Dublin under the Small Dwellings Acts. We hear the Minister saying that the purpose of the section is to ensure that rich people who are getting money under the Small Dwellings Acts will now be debarred and that the poor, who are in need of houses, will, instead, be encouraged. That is all very well if those were the facts, but they are not. The position is entirely ludicrous. I defy anyone to-day to make out what is at the back of the Minister's mind in this section. It means one thing, and one thing only, and that is that the Government are "broke" and that they have no idea of where they are to get the money to keep the Local Loans Fund going.
The Minister's main reason for bringing in this section is to soften the blow next year if he should happen to occupy the same seat as he now occupies, which I doubt. The reason is that the Government would not have to announce next year that they cannot give money for private housing development.
The third matter I wish to deal with has to do with Dublin and Cork Corporations, which up to last year had floated their own loans and were allowed into the Local Loans Fund for the first time. Why had they to come in? Because like the Government they could not get the money from the public of this country. The Government could not get the money but building societies can get money from the same public who refused the Government.
Comment on this
Because the building societies pay a higher rate of interest. Is that not the answer?
Comment on this
We will come to that point. Building societies can get money from the same public who refused the Government and then the Government who is refused has the audacity to say to the building societies: "We will guarantee you with the local authority." They could not raise the money themselves and another party comes along and the Government says: "In case you lose we will see you will be all right."
The Minister suggests that the reason the building societies get the money from the public, and that the Government does not, is that the building societies offer a higher rate of interest.
I have not seen the newspapers to-day but if the Minister looks at the back page of any of the newspapers he will see an advertisement from the Irish Permanent Building Society, the Educational Building Society and those other societies to this effect: "3¾ per cent. free of tax". Would the Minister go to the trouble of calculating what that is equivalent to and then compare it to the last National Loan issued by the Government? The last National Loan was at 5 per cent. for stock issued at 98½, equivalent to approximately £5 2s. 3d. per cent. per annum. The building societies, the Minister suggests, are offering such attractive rates that they can get the money, but the Minister had better re-examine those figures. It is an extraordinary thing, to which I draw the attention of the House, that in this so-called deal which the Minister has negotiated with the building societies the insurance companies opted out, not that they ever opted in, but they would have no dealings whatever with this set-up for, as the Minister said in his speech, certain reasons about which we did not hear.
We have heard from the Minister to-day the most extraordinary statement, that what a local authority got this year under the Small Dwellings Acts loans they will get next year. In Limerick we got £100,000. I do not know what Deputy McQuillan got in Roscommon or what was obtained elsewhere throughout the country, but we are quite satisfied. Our housing position is very satisfactory from the point of view of private building being solved. If we get the £100,000 next year, as the Minister says, there is no reason at all why Section 9 should appear on the agenda of the Limerick Corporation. The Minister says in good faith that to the best of his belief the local authorities will get next year what they got this year.
Comment on this
How do we know that when the Minister goes to look for that money from the Local Loans Fund the well will not have run dry? Where will the Minister for Finance get the money to give to the Minister? I am sure before the Minister made that statement he consulted the Minister for Finance. When the individual gets his loan from the local authority through the building society, he will be paying for it at the rate of 7 per cent. I am not saying whether he is paying £2, £2 10s., £3 or £4 a week nor can the Minister say. All we know is that the rate is 7 per cent. The next thing that happens is that the individual must employ a local solicitor to act on behalf of the building society's solicitor in Dublin. The local solicitor will send up the title and all the usual documents, and by the time the unfortunate individual concludes his business with the solicitor he will find that it would have been far better for him to seek a higher percentage deposit and look elsewhere for the money. That might be an exaggeration but the legal costs in building societies are very heavy indeed.
Comment on this
They are in certain counties where the county councillors are lax but every local authority throughout this State has the power of appointing a solicitor on a full-time basis at a salary, and he can only charge the amount of his out-of-pocket expenses. If I get a loan in Limerick to-morrow my expenses to the law agent will not be 45/- but if I cross the border into Clare they will be around the £60 mark, not that I am criticising the gentleman in Clare, who is within his rights with the powerful trade union known as the Incorporated Law Society——
Comment on this
I am coming back from Clare to the intervention of the Minister on this point. The legal costs will be one of the greatest burdens in this connection. In his Second Reading speech the Minister, in his introductory remarks, made no reference whatever to the terms he came to with the building societies. He made no reference as to the fixed charge, if any. How can the local authority be expected to underwrite the legal charges of a building society? I do not think there is a local authority in the State who would bother their heads about adopting this, and I do not think it will concern very many local authorities in view of the assurance given by the Minister.
We were at the stage where the person has got the loan, the papers have gone to Dublin and he has to bear the legal costs. He has paid the society's fees to become a member. There is nothing now but to execute the mortgage and start the house. Where does he find himself? He finds himself in the position that he has to pay 7 per cent. for his money. Mark you, here is the bogey. I cannot say it will cost him only £2 per week and the Minister cannot say it will cost him £4 per week, because neither the Minister nor anybody else knows whether the period will be 35 years, 30 years, 15 years or 20 years. The Minister admits that. The Small Dwellings Act is spread over 35 years. The period is a statutory one. No local authority can say: "These are our rates. This is what you will get and this is what it will cost you." The building society may make a loan over 35 years in certain circumstances.
What are the circumstances? Surely before the Minister introduced such a measure he should have ascertained what the circumstances are. At column 586 of Volume 159 of the Official Report the Minister said:—
"A lot of talk has been made about the percentage which the building society can charge. I have no control over that, other than that I have received a guarantee that they will charge the same rate of interest as they charge a private individual who procures 75 per cent. and in certain cases the term for repayment will be 35 years. I think that is very fair indeed."
Does the Minister now think it is very fair indeed? In certain circumstances, the building societies will grant a repayment period of 35 years. In possibly 10 per cent. of the cases, a period of 35 years will operate.
If this is adopted, the position will be fantastic. People will hang millstones around their necks, paying 60/-, 70/- and 80/- per week for houses. This is putting temptation in their way, and the Minister knows that quite well. If the building societies charge 7 per cent. to-day and find they have not sufficient funds at their disposal this time next year—mark my words—the first thing they will do will be to increase their rates on borrowed moneys in order to get in more money and then the Government will find itself in the position of underwriting the local authority, which, in turn, will be underwriting the difference between what the society would normally give and what they will then give to the unfortunate applicant. There will be a vicious circle through the next few years if this Government—of course, I am only wasting the time of the House; this Government will not be here, so what am I worrying about?
I am, however, worrying about this Bill and the time local authorities will spend in discussing it. Here and now, will the Minister withdraw this section altogether? I have not heard any Deputy say he wants it. Even those newspapers which are not in love with Fianna Fáil have criticised this measure very strongly in their leading articles—a most foolhardy piece of legislation. If the Minister gives to every local authority, as he says he will, the same amount of money next years as this year from the Local Loans Fund for private building, then I do not know why we should spend our time on Section 9.
Comment on this
I am trying to get the Minister to answer my question. The Minister himself has said that the demand for housing is on the decline. This year in Limerick we got £100,000.
Comment on this
Would the Minister state what the purpose of Section 9 is? Why should Limerick Corporation adopt Section 9 if we are to have adequate funds at our disposal under the Small Dwellings Acts?
Comment on this
There are men down there who would like to apply to private building societies for a loan, but they could not put up the 25 per cent. deposit. They could put up 5 per cent. but not 25 per cent.
Comment on this
There are men down there and the last people they would have dealings with would be a building society.
Comment on this
There are many places in which circumstances are similar to those in Limerick. The majority of the applicants in Limerick could not make any headway out of their own resources towards building a house. However, I had better get away from that. The Minister gave no information on the very relevant points raised by Deputy Smith. With respect, I have never seen anyone with such a capacity for saying so much while, in fact, saying so little, as the Minister for Local Government. He is certainly full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.
The Minister issued a circular letter to local authorities. To what type of person will building societies give loans? Where is the line of demarcation as between the person who can avail of the Small Dwellings Acts loan and the person compelled to leave the Small Dwellings Acts classification at 5¾ per cent. and take on the burden of a building society loan at 7 per cent. with, perhaps, 15 years less repayment period; instead of having 35 years in which to repay he will find himself saddled with 20 years? Would the Minister tell us, as he was requested to do by Deputy Smith, is there to be a means test? Is there to be a scale? Will we get the usual answer that it is a matter for the local authority? As far as my local authority is concerned, I hope we will pitch it out, lock, stock and barrel.
Look at the Labour Benches. There is not a member in them while we are discussing this important measure. They are the people who are crying out for housing. They are the people crying out for houses for the white-collar workers and not one of them has seen fit to listen to this debate on this important section, even when the Minister was speaking. It is a scandal.
On the last occasion on which we discussed this measure, Deputy D. Larkin stated at column 157 of Volume 159 of the Official Report:—
"...if somebody has £10 5s. per week, or for that matter £11 per week, under modern conditions, he has too much money to justify getting a loan under the various Acts and that he should be deprived of assistance from the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts is, I think, a hardship."
Deputy Larkin is, of course, right. There will be grave hardship. Will this be like the Health Act? Will the lower income, the middle income and the higher income groups have to have a white ticket in order to get a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts? Will they have to have a particular kind of card? Will there be a kind of slur on those who have to avail of a Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts loan? Will it be the snobs who will avail of the building societies, the 7 per cent. people?
We will be voting on this to-night and we will see what the Labour Party will do on Section 9. They will answer to the public in the election in November, or whenever it is, if this piece of legislation goes through this House. Of course, they will not turn in; the usual stunt—we will not see them here.
At column 518 of the Official Report of the 10th instant, Deputy D. Larkin, speaking for the Labour Party, is reported as saying:—
"...I would impress on the Minister the importance of a definite statement from him as to the future of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and whether the passing of this Bill will not lead to the actual disappearance of these Acts as we have known them."
Unfortunately, if this matter goes through, his fears will be realised.
I was at a meeting of a certain local authority and building societies were mentioned. The city or the county manager, as the case may be, said: "I am satisfied with our present financial position but, to play ball with the Department of Local Government and the Minister, we had better adopt it or they might cut us down on the amount of money from the Local Loans Fund." That is the mentality. Are local authorities to be coerced into saddling this thing on the backs of the citizens? The ordinary man in the street knows very little about the finances of building. He depends for a lot of advice on Deputies, members of county councils, and so on, to tell him the exact implications. It will be like other things It will be like the raiding of the Road Fund. It will be like the Racing Board's having to pay a tax of £140,000. The Minister for Finance will say: "These building societies are financing private building; we will cut this provision by a couple of million pounds for private building." Is that not what will happen?
I was on the point of the type of person who will get this loan. Every local authority is evidently being allowed, to use the Minister's own words, to decide what category will continue to get loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and what categories will be thrown over to the building societies. Here is what the Minister said when replying to the debate on the 10th instant, as reported at column 589 of the Official Report:—
"These Acts and the various amending Acts will continue. It is a matter for the local authority to decide who shall be the successful applicant. It is a matter for the local authority to impose any screenings they may wish to impose. I do not wish to intervene. The same amount of money will be made available this year under these Acts as was made available last year. I have gone further. I have told the Dublin Corporation that they will receive the same amount of money next year as this year, and in the succeeding year, in order to enable them to plan for the future so that there will be continuity of acceptance of tenders for building in the City of Dublin."
It was very decent of the Minister to tell that to Dublin Corporation—a body which raided the Local Loans Fund, along with Cork Corporation, and you and I and the rest of us are paying for it now down the country. The Local Loans Fund has been steadily depleted as a result of the failure of the last loan the Government tried to raise. If they could not raise it, Dublin Corporation and Cork Corporation could not be expected to float public loans successfully either and, as a result, they were allowed into the Local Loans Fund.
The Minister, the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste, and the Minister for Finance were setting themselves up as big fellows. They sent the emigration expert, Deputy O'Donovan. Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, with his safety value around the country to say what they had done for Dublin Corporation. We all know what they did for Dublin Corporation —nothing at all. They simply allowed them to obtain moneys from the Local Loans Fund which otherwise would have been made available to local authorities to bring their own housing drives to a conclusion. We shall pay for that now. As a result of the Government's incompetence and their failure to get money, we are faced with this farce, Section 9. I do not think that in any Legislature in the world would such a section or a deal—an undertaking by a Government Department to underwrite an outside body— take place in circumstances such as prevail in this country at the moment.
Never in the history of the Housing Acts was a measure brought into this House of which the Minister introducing it knew so little. This Minister knows absolutely nothing, good, bad or indifferent and he cares less about Section 9. We are witnessing the usual attitude: "Throw it all on to the local authorities; do the best you can; I will underwrite you." Just fancy that a Government that could not raise money themselves will underwrite the local authority. They certainly have some cheek. It is as if I went into a bank for a loan and was refused and then you went in for a loan and got it and I put my name down to guarantee you although, in the first instance, I was refused. God bless us and save us.
Every local authority will be faced with questions like this at the next meeting of the county councils or the corporations. Who is the person to get the loan? Is it the man with £9 a week? Is it the man with up to £12 a week? If he has £12 1s. per week, what will his position be? Will it be his family income? Will his salary be the total family income? Will it, as we had on the amendment to Section 8, be the income of himself and his spouse, if married, whatever that means? Where are we to draw the line? Suppose there is a limit of £520 a year which the Dublin County Council evidently, with the Minister's assistance, got it into their head to suggest they might adopt in giving Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts loan. What happens the man with £521? What happens the man who has two or three children, bringing up his wages, say, from £400 to £600 a year? In what way is the income to be worked? In what way are the supplementary grants to be worked? No one knows.
The Minister talked about his love for the poor; I forget the name of the Saint who was very fond of the poor. However, on Section 8, the Minister spoke of his love for the poor and now, on Section 9, he says his reason for bringing in this measure is to keep the rich from raiding the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts Fund and putting up houses because they can well afford to go to the building societies. He was worried about the poor but yet, to the very people who, he says, can well afford to build their own houses, he gives £275 of your money and of my money. If they are so well off, if abuses have taken place in the past and if people with plenty of money obtained loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, why is the Minister not consistent? I am not advocating it, but let him be consistent and operate a means test also in respect of the Government grant, or let him scrap the Government grant and throw the £275, plus the £137 10s., on to the local authority to be administered by them. But no; he will continue and the man with £10,000 a year can get the full £275 grant as long as the floor area of his house is under 1,400 square feet.
Comment on this
Another question is: is this whole building society arrangement to be worked by the building societies themselves or to be worked by the officials in the local authorities' offices who are at present administering the Small Dwellings Acts? Is it to be done from Dublin? Where does the county council or corporation come in? What work have they to do, apart from guaranteeing the difference between their normal advance and the advance which they give under Section 9? The position is obscure.
The phrase "the normal advance" is used by the Minister. Who is to say that the building societies will not club together or, without clubbing together, who is to say that the building societies will not call on a local authority to give an increased amount under the guarantee by saying "£1,200 is our normal advance," whereas their normal advance might be £1,500, and the local authority might be called on to guarantee the difference between, say, £1,000 and £1,600 and the State underwrites 50 per cent. of that. What is the normal advance? The building societies have no information.
The Minister speaks of an agreement he has entered into with them. He has entered into no agreement. He had a chat with them, a talk, an exchange of views, but he did not enter into an agreement because he had not the authority to enter into an agreement. He had discussions with representatives of the building societies, from which discussions the insurance companies withdrew and said that they would not have any dealings with the scheme, good, bad or indifferent. The Minister thanks the building societies. What is he thanking them for? What great benefits have they bestowed on the community? They have agreed to lend money and there is a guarantee from the Government and the local authority to make up any loss sustained by them over a certain amount.
Of course, the building societies will be anxious to work it and, of course, the building societies will have to lend money next year, not at 7 per cent. but at 8 per cent. and the next year they will be lending money at 9 per cent. because they have not sufficient funds at their disposal at the present time to cater for houses, apart from houses which come under the Housing Acts, that is, houses with a floor area over 1,400 square feet and old houses. Most of the houses dealt with by building societies are not grant-type houses. Grant-type houses represent a very small percentage of their transactions. People go to building societies because they cannot buy an old house under the Small Dwellings Acts. Supposing a house comes on the market in Dublin to-morrow, if it is not a new house, the only source of credit for the purchase of that house is the bank or a building society. It is in respect of such houses that most of the building societies' business up to now has been done.
The position is that the building societies have not sufficient funds to cater for applicants for old houses on sale in Dublin, Cork and Limerick, not to talk of finding funds for this great scheme under Section 9. I have discussed the matter with a member of a building society and he told me to have sense, that that was only talk and that no one in his right mind would take it seriously.
That is all very well in the light of existing circumstances, but, next year, if we are cut down in the payments from the Local Loans Fund for private building under the Small Dwellings Acts, what will we do? We will be forced into this provision, if we adopt it, or we will have to stop building altogether. Is that not the position? We in this House to-night, acting on behalf of the people who sent us here, are being asked to put through a measure which might force them to pay, not 7 per cent. or 7½ per cent., but 8 or 9 per cent. on their money.
Comment on this
The rate of interest does not arise under this section. There is a special section dealing with the rate of interest.
Comment on this
I am speaking now of the building societies and the deal the local authority enters into.
Comment on this
The rate of interest in Sections 18 and 19 relates purely to interest rates under the Small Dwellings Acts.
Comment on this
Which I am not discussing, with respect, Sir. I am discussing building societies' interest rates which arise, not on Section 19, but on Section 9. The local authority has to guarantee the building society the difference between their normal advance and what they do advance and I am discussing the hardship involved for an individual who has to enter into such an arrangement.
The points on which we want clarification from the Minister when he is replying are: who will be allowed to get Small Dwellings Acts loans; what is the limit; what is the tie-up between Small Dwellings Acts loans and the supplementary grant? That is most important. Does it mean that a person who has to borrow from a building society will not qualify for a supplementary grant? That is important. In the case of Limerick Corporation, a person can have £14 per week or approximately £700 per annum in relation to family income. He then gets the £137 10s. In any event, he gets the Government grant of £275 and he gets a supplementary grant, if his income is under £700 a year or £14 a week. He also gets his small dwellings loan.
In Dublin, the matter is much more stringent. For instance, you cannot get a supplementary grant if you have an income of over £500. Is all this to go by the board in Limerick and other places? Are we to say to a man with £14 a week getting a supplementary grant: "You have too much. You should not avail of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. You should avail of the building society plan, under Section 9, introduced by the Minister for Local Government. It will confer great benefits on you"?
The individual concerned may ask what are the benefits and he can be told that he may switch from a lower percentage to the percentage of 7 per cent. When he asks whether he will get the loan for the 35-year period, of course he will not, and he will be very lucky, indeed, to get it at 20 years. There are newly-married couples in this country facing the appalling prospect of paying 60/- or 70/- a week for their houses. I do not exaggerate. The figures are there. Any Deputy who cares to write to a building society and ask for their repayment figures, principal and interest, in respect of the following sums: £1,800, £1,600, £1,400 over 20, 25 and 30 years will discover that my statement is more or less correct. It is very hard to understand the reasons why this section is being brought in.
If people are getting money under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts who have plenty of money themselves, cannot the Minister bring in legislation—not permissive legislation—and compel a local authority to put a limit on the total family income a person may have in order to avail of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and who can get a supplementary grant? If the Minister wants to be consistent, let him do away with the giving of the Government grant to people who could well afford to do without it.
Let him face the facts and say: "From 1st October next, no local authority will be empowered to make a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts to any person having an income in excess of £850 a year." Let us put any figure we like on it, let it be £1,000 or £700, but let a figure be stated. The idea of asking the local authority to do this deal with a building society will not materialise.
The Minister in his introductory remarks stated at column 500, Volume 159 of the Official Debates:
"It is intended that local authorities should continue to operate the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts for persons willing to provide their own houses and who are unable to provide the necessary finances otherwise but many persons have been availing of the facilities provided under the Acts who either did not need to do so or who would not have needed to do so if commercial agencies would advance a higher percentage of the purchase price and would allow a longer repayment period."
The Minister goes on to say:—
"I have investigated this matter in recent months and, as already announced, discussions have been held with the principal commercial agencies engaged in house financing. I am pleased to say that the representatives of these agencies gave ready and generous co-operation in those discussions."
The Minister is the only person who is pleased about this measure. The Minister further said:—
"The principal building societies were willing to widen the scope of their loan activities by making higher proportionate advances than hitherto, and by extending the period of repayment as far as practicable, on the understanding that they would not be required to bear the full risk of the higher loans and longer repayment periods and they have now agreed to the terms of guarantee schemes which will enable them to extend their loan facilities in these respects."
The Minister at the end of column 501, even though some of the assurance companies had withdrawn, stated:—
"I may mention that some assurance companies, as well as continuing to make advances to individuals for house-purchase, are making or have offered to make direct loans to local authorities."
The point I want to make is—I trust it is constructive—that if the assurance companies and the building societies give these loans to individuals with the guarantees, why cannot the local authority consider the building society as its local loans fund and say: "Right; we will borrow from you?" Could the Minister not cut out this farce of underwriting, guarantee, and so on? Could he not say: "Right; you can borrow from the building society and with that money you can administer, as you have administered so competently, the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. There is no change. Possibly, the interest rates will be higher"? Would the Minister consider that point?
The Minister states that assurance companies have made loans to local authorities. That is true. Some time ago in this House, I said an assurance company made a loan of £49,000 to the Limerick Corporation. Deputy Carew will bear me out in that matter. We accepted the assurance company's rate, even though it was higher than that offered by the bank which was 4¾ per cent. We accepted their rate of 5¼ per cent. to pay the £49,000 when we were extending the borough in Limerick. We accepted the assurance company's offer at 5¼ per cent. because they offered us a 25-year period, whereas the bank offered us only 15 years.
The deed of mortgage came up for signature on Monday night and there was a letter from the Minister for Local Government who now lauds the deal that local authorities can make with assurance companies stating that the period of 25 years for the loan was too long. He would not sanction affixing the seal to the agreement between the Irish Assurance Company and the Limerick Corporation, unless the period was reduced to ten years. Where is the consistency in that? As reported at the end of column 501, the Minister made a very interesting statement:—
"The minimum deposit required from the borrower will be 5 per cent. Some of the societies are prepared to make advances repayable over 35 years."
My information is that none of the building societies will lend money for more than 25 years. They do not want this type of business, because they lose, of course. The terms offered by the Minister appear to be "a good thing", but as I say the position from their point of view is that 95 per cent. of the business of the building societies at the present time is devoted to lending money to those who purchase second-hand or old houses, not grant type houses. Not even .5 of 1 per cent. who buy grant houses to-day avail of building society rates—they all purchase under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. The position is fantastic. The Minister now asks us as members of local authorities—in fact before we go to the local authorities, as members of this House—to bring in a section here empowering local authorities to enter into negotiations with the building societies at 7 per cent. for a start, not knowing what the interest will ultimately be.
The building societies are at present undertaking a continuous campaign for more funds. They have not sufficient funds at the present time to deal with applicants for old houses and they are seeking funds now to deal with the building contemplated under the arrangement now suggested. As one member of a building society said to me: "We will not get sufficient money. We have not sufficient money for the needs of one county, not to talk of the whole Twenty-Six Counties." I asked him what would happen, and he said: "It is quite obvious what will happen. We will have to offer increased interest rates next year, and the result of that will be that instead of lending money at 7 per cent. it will probably be 8 per cent. this time next year."
All this goes back to the point that this measure was brought in because the Government failed to get the money from the loan. Dublin and Cork Corporations failed and yet we have the extraordinary position now that, where the Government failed, a small body corporate or a company such as a building society can get the money at the same rate of interest. After all, looking at the advertisement in today's papers of the building societies' offer of 3¾ per cent. free of income-tax, we can recall that the Government went to the country with a 5 per cent. loan issued at 98½, I think, equivalent to £5 3s. 2d. per cent., approximately, per annum. Yet they could not get the money. But the building societies are getting the savings of the people in this country, the reason being that the people have no confidence in the Government. They have lost confidence in the Government and would not trust the Government to put the money to the best possible use. Therefore, they have said to a lesser body about which they might not know a great deal: "This is a building society; they offer such and such rates; we will invest with them."
The Minister was not truthful with the House. I suppose the shrewdest voter in the world is the Irishman who, when he reads something in the papers, can sum it up, and he knows in his heart and soul that there will be a further recession in house building —not a recession, a further recession. Any Deputy may go to the Library and see the figures there. He can see the number of carpenters, masons and plasterers and the number of labourers employed in work associated with the building industry. He can appreciate that those numbers have fallen in latter months and see how great is the fall since this time last year, due to Government policy.
The Minister, in his introductory remarks, lauded himself and the Minister for Finance for the help they were giving towards getting Deputy Briscoe and Deputy Larkin out of their troubles in Dublin Corporation. They have got no one out of their troubles. They allowed Dublin Corporation into the Local Loans Fund and they got members of local authorities down the country into trouble.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would read Section 9, he would appreciate that what I am saying at the present time can be related to the deal which the local authorities are contemplating with the building societies. On the agenda of Dublin Corporation for the next meeting, I understand, is the circular letter from the Minister for Local Government recommending to Dublin Corporation—and, indeed, to us and to Cork Corporation and to the county councils—that we should consider the possibility which he strongly recommends, of entering into negotiations with the building societies in order that we may come to terms with the societies.
I think that of all the measures that have been introduced, or the introduction of which has been attempted, by this Government since 1954, since they came into power, this is the most evil, ludicrous and farcical. I can think of a lot of other stronger adjectives which, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, you would not allow me to use. I say that I was never more interested in an amendment than in this Section 9, because if the Labour Party have the audacity to go into the Division Lobby —and we will be voting on it very shortly—in the light of what Deputy Larkin has said on this Bill and vote against it, it will be very interesting to the people. These are the people for whom the Labour Party have recently been crying out, the white-collar workers and the newly-weds. I wonder how the white-collar workers will feel to-morrow morning if they find members of the Labour Party have voted for a measure which enables local authorities to tie the millstone round their necks of having to pay interest at 7 per cent.? Does Deputy Denis Larkin know that, not alone must the local authorities give the building societies 7 per cent. but that there is no guarantee that the period will be over 35 years, and that, as one member of a building society said to me, it will probably be 25 years? Does the unfortunate man who is to get a loan know that he will also get a bill for £60 or £84 for costs from the building societies for legal fees——
Comment on this
I was trying to impress on, or remind, the Labour Party of their attitude towards the Minister on the Second Reading of this Bill. I have often said in this House that any fool can get up and talk and criticise but that there should be a certain amount of constructive criticism. I always say to myself: "What would you do if you were there?" The position, as I have tried to point out to the Minister on previous occasions, is that there is absolutely no necessity for Section 9 if he will do one or other of two things. First of all, he should tell the truth. He would then get the sympathy of this House if he came along and said: "The Government cannot get one shilling; we are faced with the position that in order to keep private housing going we must get money; it may be a temporary difficulty, or it may not." But no, the Minister for Local Government could not do that. He has to come along and bluff. He would like to make me feel a fool and all the rest of you feel fools and let the people think that he was omnipotent and the only person who knew anything about housing.
The attitude is: "Never mind O'Malley and the others who interrupt; what do they know about it? These people are only up from the bogs. We will get the section through; ring the division bell quickly." That is the attitude to one of the most important Bills ever to come before this House. To-morrow morning the public will read the names of those who voted on Section 9. We will take down their names and we will publish them in November, or whenever the general election will be, if the Labour Party does what I expect them to do, and they have done peculiar things in the past, and we will also take down——
Comment on this
I was on the question of what the Minister would do, or could do, in the circumstances in which he finds himself, that he possibly has not sufficient moneys at his disposal to continue private building. He could, once and for all, bring in a measure, the Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956, to amalgamate all the Housing Acts.
Comment on this
Unless the Deputy can relate his remarks to the section I must ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I must admit that I was going a bit away from the section. Under Section 9, relating to building societies, I would point out to the Minister that there is nothing in the world—and I am sure he would get co-operation from all sides of the House —to prevent his setting up an investment board to deal solely with the administration of housing, on the same lines as the building societies obtain their money, and divorce that body entirely from the House. The Post Office can get the public to invest their money, and make good use of that money. The Irish people are investing in building societies and the building societies are getting a high rate of interest for the pleasure of lending money to the people. Is there anything wrong with suggesting that we should have, as in America, Denmark and Sweden, a house investment board which could deal solely—whether it was Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael or a Coalition that was in power—with the finances of something that should be far above Party politics, namely, the re-housing of our people? I cannot see anything against such a board and if we had people investing in it, say on the lines of saving certificates, we could revolutionise the building position in regard to interest rates. If we had such a board it is not a section like Section 9 that would be coming before us to-day. I would ask the Minister to look into that matter.
There is another aspect of Section 9 which is very important and neither the Minister nor any other speaker has made reference to it. If Section 9 is adopted, I see the gravest of difficulties in regard to the ability of speculative builders to carry on. At the present time, a builder may embark on a scheme of 20 or 30 houses. Some local authorities, strange as it may seem, such as Limerick, Kilkenny and Waterford, are empowered to make earlier payments to the builders; they do not have to wait until the roof is on. They can pay them six, seven or eight times. In Waterford, a builder can be paid every month. Deputies can appreciate the saving of, perhaps, £50 or £60 in banking interest alone. A builder can thus build houses more quickly. He can get more staff, get credit with the merchants and he can get on to the job and out of it more quickly. Down the country, builders will have nothing to do with the building societies. There are builders in this House—Deputy Belton will bear me out—who, if they were to have any dealings with the societies, would have been in the bankruptcy courts long ago, because they would be obliged to have the houses completed before they could draw any money.
I would draw the attention of members of local authorities in this House to the fact that the Minister's circular letter is on the agenda for consideration by the local authorities whenever they next meet. The Minister is asking us to adopt this section. I would advise such members to be very careful of the burdens they may impose on the people they represent. The Minister has said earlier that the same amount of money obtainable this year under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts will be available next year. I have said to him, and I got no reply: "All right, drop Section 9; the demand for houses is coming down." In Limerick, we got £100,000 this year from the Local Loans Fund and the Minister says we will get the same amount next year. If we get it next year, what are we worrying about? What is the point in this section? It is like the City and County Management Act, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.
Comment on this
That is what we want to know from the Minister. The Minister makes these momentous statements about housing and the great Section 9 that he has produced, at these meetings in Tallaght, or wherever these mothers' meetings are. Deputy Esmonde congratulates him on its forthrightness, and in Sligo we had the Taoiseach saying that they have young financiers——
Comment on this
There is another small point which I want to draw to the Minister's attention. Let him take this House and the country into his confidence and tell us whether the finances of the country are so bad that this measure is necessary. I, for one, am quite satisfied if we get the same amount of money in my area next year as this year. What will happen is this. The Minister will say this time 12 months—I am always using the phrase "this time 12 months"; I forget they will not be there then. It is inconvenient for us to be coming back here and tabling amendments to Bills which have become law. We could make the one job of it now.
I am asking the Minister, first of all, to give us that information. I am asking him to give that to every member of a local authority. It will save us all a certain amount of trouble if the Minister's statement can be backed up by the Minister for Finance. It is fantastic to think that the Minister for Local Government can make the statement that the same amount of money will be available next year under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts from the Local Loans Fund as is available this year. He cannot say that; the Minister for Finance cannot say it. They can only hope and pray that the same amount of money will be available, but it is completely misleading to say that Limerick Corporation and Cork Corporation will get the same amount next year.
Suppose we do not get the same amount? What will the Minister say then? I suppose he will say that "he thought at the time"—that is a very happy turn of phrase used by the Minister for Local Government—or "he was of the opinion at the time he made his statement that such would be the case, but outside circumstances etc., etc...". We know it off by heart. What will happen if Limerick Corporation and every other local authority in the country lend money to unfortunate individuals next year under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and guarantee the building societies? Where will we find ourselves, with the Local Loans Fund depleted as a result of further raids by Dublin Corporation and Cork Corporation, who could not secure the money themselves and had to be allowed in? Then the Government boasted that they helped the corporations out of their difficulties.
The principal matter on which there is no clarification is the Minister's statement—in my opinion, it is a very unfair statement—that it is purely for the local authority to decide the type of person who will be thrown on to the building societies' books or who will be kept on the small dwellings scheme list. Would the Minister tell us where the line of demarcation is?
Comment on this
The city manager did not tell us last night. This question of Section 9 is on the agenda for the next meeting. The only thing we had last night was a letter from the Minister strongly recommending Section 9. Now that the Minister is giving us the same amount of money next year as we are getting this year, I do not see any reason for discussing Section 9 next Monday night. I do not know the purpose of it. Supposing Section 9 comes up for discussion, where is the line of demarcation between the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and the building societies? If the Minister says that is a reserved function, that it is for the members of Limerick Corporation, Cork Corporation or Donegal County Council to decide it, it may be said that they can also decide to push this section out altogether. This is permissive legislation of the worst possible nature. Does it require the Minister's sanction? Is there a statutory obligation on the Minister to sanction this Section 9 as adopted by a local authority?
Comment on this
Under this section, moneys of this House are being risked, because the State is underwriting the losses to the extent of 50 per cent. of the difference between the normal advances and advances given under this section. The Minister says there is no onus on a local authority to submit a scheme to him, but at the end of a year there might be £x. The Minister might be asked in this House to account for the deficiency, and he might say that that is as a result of the incompetence of the Limerick Corporation in this scheme with the building societies. Somebody might ask if the Minister's Department had not seen that scheme. The position is ludicrous. There is not even a suggested draft scheme.
Comment on this
We have formulated a scheme. We have left it to you to decide to adopt it or otherwise.
Comment on this
Is it not quite obvious that the Minister has not formulated a scheme? If a scheme had been formulated, would an agreement not have been arrived at between the two parties—the Department of Local Government and the representatives of the building societies? Is it not a fact that only discussions have taken place and that there is not one thing in writing as yet?
Comment on this
But under certain sections of the Bill the building society or local authority has power to anticipate legislation?
Comment on this
I am only asking you to adopt the section; the local authority will have to adopt the scheme.
Comment on this
We are going to vote against it. It is in the Minister's hands. Why is this retrospective? It is a bit thick. A building society is an ordinary commercial concern. The Government and local authority are underwriting a risk. Surely they can stand on their own feet and undertake that risk, if any risk there be.
Comment on this
The position is that no local authority has yet adopted this section, even in anticipation. I do not know exactly what the Minister had at the back of his mind. He gives a warning that the days of money for private house building are coming to an end, but, in answer to me earlier, he said there were certain sections of the community who were availing of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts loans who could well afford to build their own houses and who should be thrown on to a building society. He talked about poor people who could not get the means to build their own houses.
Since 1899, right down through the years, the Small Dwellings Acts have been amended for the better, but now we have a retrograde step. The Minister has been asked by Deputy Smith, by Deputies on his own side, including Deputy D. Larkin, if he will state once and for all the type of person who will be allowed to draw the Small Dwellings Acts loan and the type of person who will be thrown on to the building societies. I hope the Minister will not say: "This is a matter for the local authorities." We have a position at the moment, in Limerick, where a supplementary grant will be paid to a person who has £14 a week. In Dublin, the grant will not be paid to anybody who has over £520 a year. Go down to Clare and you will get nothing but abuse. The whole thing is farcical.
I wish the Minister would not have us wasting the time of the House any longer; I wish he would tell us if he contemplates the making of regulations, because he has the power under this Bill, under Section 9, to make regulations as to the type of person who will continue to qualify for loans under the Small Dwellings Acts, who will continue to qualify for loans from the Local Loans Fund. Is a person who is compelled to obtain money from building societies to be debarred from qualifying for a supplementary grant? If there is to be an income limit of £520 a year what happens to the person with £521? The Minister could not care less. I suppose he is as well off not to be worrying here about this measure. There is building going on, as he said——
Comment on this
If this section is adopted, the hardest hit people will be the Dublin people. Deputy D. Larkin gave a very fair criticism of the Minister's Second Reading speech. If the section is adopted, there will undoubtedly be further unemployment. At the present moment, the whole business is a vicious circle. The corporation owes money; the clients owe money; the builders owe money to the builders' providers, and the builders' providers, in turn, owe money to the bank. You have the complete vicious circle, due to Government ineptitude and inactivity. The result will be that everyone with over £10 a week will be at the behest of building societies and will be obliged to pay 7 per cent. interest, if it stops at that. What young married couple can pay 63/- a week in repayments? The onus has been taken off the local authorities.
Since June, 1954, we have done a lot of talking on both sides of the House, but the most evil proposal—I am not casting any aspersions on the Minister in this regard—that has appeared before us is this. It is departing from all the ambitions of Ministers for Local Government in the past. Deputy MacEntee, Deputy Smith, the late Deputy Murphy and Deputy Keyes, in their amendments to the Housing Acts, made some move towards advances on previous legislation. Here we are confronted with the frightening proposition of bringing private building to a halt. People are frightened in this country. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture may laugh.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary should clear out and stay where he has been. What brought him in here, if he is not listening?
Comment on this
People are frightened. I quite agree that Deputy O. Flanagan was not listening to me. He does not care. He is not very interested in the housing of the white collar workers or of the newly-weds. There are no worries like that down in Laois-Offaly— not at the moment at any rate. I hope that Deputies who vote for this section will remember the day they voted for it because they will be committing themselves and those whom they represent to unprecedented interest rates. Next year, the Minister for Finance can come along and say: "This crowd are doing fine with the building societies; we will let them off and utilise the Local Loans Fund moneys for other purposes." It will be like the grabbing of the Racing Board's £140,000; it will be like the grabbing of the Road Fund.