We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956—Committee Stage.

Contributions 452–682 of 682. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956
Enacted

No. 16 of 1956 ›

Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of roads does not arise.

Comment on this

It was not I who brought in the roads.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It was the Deputy who mentioned the Road Fund.

Comment on this

To conclude, I ask Deputies opposite to keep the straight road. I will bet that Deputy Coogan has not even looked at the Bill.

Comment on this

Maybe I could tell you a few things yet.

Comment on this

Please God, he will enlighten us for once, and not sit there for his nuisance value. I seriously ask each Deputy to examine carefully the implications of this section. I ask the Minister to withdraw it in its entirety. I cannot envisage the Labour Party going into the lobby to vote for this provision.

Comment on this

We do not want to continue this discussion unduly. We do not want any more long speeches on this section. We want, as I tried to convey to the Minister on another section, and as we are entitled to get, a free explanation of what the Minister has in his mind, and what the Department has in mind regarding this section. We have the assurance from the Minister that all local authorities will be able to borrow freely from the Local Loans Fund for the purposes of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. Later we have this assurance from the Minister: "I will make sure that the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts are not available to rich people." That is No. 2. No. 3 is that I know a local body that, when they made an application for £20,000 under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, were told that they had been granted £10,000. No. 4 is that I have heard it reported that a conference has taken place with the managers where they were told that the amount of money under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts would be limited this year.

We have the Minister's assurance that the local authorities can borrow freely; we have his assurance that he will not allow the rich to avail of the Acts; we have the proof that a local body applies for £20,000 and gets £10,000, and we have the report that representatives of local bodies would not get money as freely as before. The Minister did not make a clear statement on the section during the Second Stage. I invite him to make a clear statement on it now. Remember, I am not making this in any way as a threat, but I would be encouraged to keep this House going for a long time unless the Minister faces up to his responsibilities. I suggest that the Minister really did not know what he was talking about on the Second Stage and that is why I am asking him for an explanation now. If it is the position that the Minister cannot get the money we shall discuss Section 9 on a different basis but, for goodness' sake, do not try to treat us as children.

Comment on this

I have given an undertaking to this House, and I now repeat it, that any applicant of modest means who requires a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts will get it from the Local Loans Fund.

Comment on this

What does the Minister mean by modest means?

Comment on this

Builders like Deputy O'Malley, builders such as he, have defeated the Act and have succeeded in having local authorities depart from the intention of the original Act. We all know that people who could have, and who should have, procured the money elsewhere were throwing an unnecessary burden on the local authorities by procuring loans from local authorities that should never have been given to them.

Comment on this

Then why give them a State grant?

Comment on this

They why get a State grant provided they build a house of less than 1,400 square feet. That is to encourage them to build their own homes.

Comment on this

A rich man.

Comment on this

A rich man if you wish. It is not I who introduced that legislation. I am trying to ensure that the rich man does not build his house on State funds. I am trying to do that but the opposition to that effort is coming from over there. This, I hope, is the thin edge of the wedge.

Comment on this

Who are the people of modest means?

Comment on this

The people who should have access to it, the people of modest means.

Comment on this

Who are they?

Comment on this

That is a matter for the local authorities.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will tell us what he means by the expression "modest means"?

Comment on this

I am telling the House in the phrase which was used when the Act was originally introduced. There are people of modest means and people who may have access to the funds which the building societies have. In my own county 95 per cent. of the applicants for loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts are school teachers. I do not think that the school teacher is a man of modest means.

Comment on this

I hope they do not hear you saying that.

Comment on this

I do not think they are men of modest means.

Comment on this

I think they are.

Comment on this

A school teacher is a man with between £700 and £800 a year and I am telling the House that in my county 95 per cent. of the applicants are school teachers.

Comment on this

You gave them 10 per cent. extra three months ago.

Comment on this

I do not grudge them that. I am referring to the men of modest means within the terms of the Act. I do not say he is a rich man.

Comment on this

He is very rich, according to the Minister.

Comment on this

I do not think he is a rich man but at the same time he is not a man of modest means. It is quite possible that he could not put up the 25 per cent. of the capital necessary to build his house. He may not have that readily available capital and as a result of this section such a man will be able to go to a building society and merely put down 5 per cent. and borrow the remaining 95 per cent. from the building society.

Comment on this

That wealthy man can do that.

Comment on this

He is not a wealthy man but he is not a man of modest means. He is in between. I think we are doing a good turn by making available now for the building of houses a fund that has never been tapped before. We are now giving such a man a way out. He can now put up his house by putting down a deposit of 5 per cent. of the price. Deputy O'Malley is talking about paying 7 per cent. I do not know what the rate will be but, whatever it is, he would also have to pay it on the 75 per cent. if he borrowed that amount. Deputy O'Malley is the builders' man. Deputy O'Malley knows that I do not mean this for him personally, but these are the gentlemen who have ruined the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. I am referring to builders generally.

Comment on this

Here in Dublin.

Comment on this

All over the country. They succeeded in getting local authorities to grant loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts to people who should never have qualified for them. This section is for the "in-betweens", the men of modest means, the white-collar worker, such as the school teacher. I think they should not be expected to put up 25 per cent. of the capital cost of their houses. I do not think they have got the money to put up but under Section 9 I think we are doing something to meet the needs of this particular class. I do not know what the percentage will be but I will take Deputy O'Malley's word for it, that it is 7 per cent. Suppose that we did not have this section, they would still have to pay the 7 per cent. but they would get only 75 per cent. of their capital outlay. I think this section confers considerable benefits on that particular class of people.

In regard to the question of interest, Deputy O'Malley wanted to know why it was that the Government could not get money for 98½ per cent. stock at 5 per cent. and building societies could. The difference is that a depositor to a building society is guaranteed interest at the rate of 3¾ per cent. tax free.

Comment on this

I said that.

Comment on this

That is equal to 6 per cent. The building societies are holding out a greater inducement.

Comment on this

Why does the Government not offer 6 per cent. and cut out the building societies?

Comment on this

You object to giving 5 per cent.?

Comment on this

We are not objecting at all.

Comment on this

We have heard sufficient talk about that.

Comment on this

We heard it from the Minister himself.

Comment on this

The Deputy heard it in 1952. I agreed that in 1952 5 per cent. was too high because it was much higher than the percentage in every other country in Europe. To-day compare our 5 per cent. and it is much less than any other country in Europe.

Comment on this

And you did not get the money.

Comment on this

Of course we could not get the money simply because other countries were offering higher rates. Is that not so?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot act the ostrich and stick his head in the sand. He knows exactly what occurred. May I quote what I said in my introductory remarks on the Second Reading of this Bill? I am quoting from column 500, Volume 4, of the Official Debates of the 10th July, 1956:—

"It is intended that local authorities should continue to operate the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts for persons willing to provide their own houses and who are unable to provide the necessary finances otherwise but many persons have been availing of the facilities provided under the Acts who either did not need to do so or who would not have needed to do so if commercial agencies would advance a higher percentage of the purchase price and would allow a longer repayment period."

That is what I am trying to provide for now.

Comment on this

Does it lie now with the local authorities to find what is meant by the man of modest means?

Comment on this

Yes, absolutely.

Comment on this

In other words, if the local authority says a man of modest means is a man with a large family with an income of from £200 a year, that man in the opinion of the corporation or the county council, as a man of modest means, will be entitled to get a loan under the ordinary Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts?

Comment on this

It is absolutely at the discretion of the local authority to decide who will have access to this fund or otherwise.

Comment on this

If they decide that those who availed of it heretofore will be free to avail of it in future, the Local Loans Fund will be available to them?

Comment on this

Deputy Smith did not hear what I said to Deputy O'Malley. I said that builders procured admission to these particular loans for people for whom they were never intended and I am now suggesting to the local authority a method of weeding those out, so that people who would not have access to these loans and who would not be in a position to put down 25 per cent. deposit would have this opportunity to provide a house for themselves. I am not trying to ram this section down anybody's throat. I merely want to explain what this section means. Supposing the section were not included in the Bill and a local authority decided that John Brown or John Smith, or whoever he might be, is not a person who should have access to a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, what would happen? This man may have a fairly decent certified or guaranteed income but unfortunately he cannot put down 25 per cent. of the purchase price of a new house. Therefore, he must do without a house. I intend to encourage him to build his own house despite the fact that the local authority may not give him access to a loan. If I take this section out, as Deputies on the other side of the House are requesting, we are depriving that unfortunate individual of the chance of building or procuring his own home. I think the section confers a considerable benefit on a number of people, the class in between those of modest means and the rich.

Comment on this

The Minister has endeavoured to give a definition of people with modest means and apparently he is leaving matters to the discretion of the local authorities in this respect. Does the Minister think that that is fair in view of what has happened in Dublin? The Minister stated here on the Second Reading of this Bill that small dwellings loans were available. Is he aware that the Dublin Corporation have refused to accept applications for small dwellings loans no later than a few days ago?

Comment on this

Did I not answer that by way of parliamentary question?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not discuss the administration of the Dublin Corporation.

Comment on this

Furthermore, the Minister stated that money is available for small dwellings loans just the same as it was heretofore.

Comment on this

I said no such thing.

Comment on this

The Minister said the same amount of money would be available——

Comment on this

Next year as this year.

Comment on this

The Minister said, at column 584 of the same Volume:—

"Again some Deputies referred to the fact that the 1954 Act had ceased to exist on 31st March last. That is not so. One small section, Section 6 of the 1954 Act, is the only section that expired on 31st March and I made it very clear many months ago in this House that, if there was to be any reduction in the grants for the building of new houses or the reconstruction of houses, due notice would be given to the House. No such notice was given; therefore I took it for granted that every person was well aware of the fact that there would be no reduction."

Comment on this

In housing grants.

Comment on this

He stated also that housing loans would be available and surely the Minister——

Comment on this

The Deputy purported to quote me and he is not able to do it now.

Comment on this

Let me quote from column 589 of the same Volume where the Minister said:

"These Acts and the various amending Acts will continue. It is a matter for the local authority to decide who shall be the successful applicant."

The Minister stated that he would definitely make small dwelling loans available as heretofore. Notwithstanding the Minister's instructions to the local authority, will he ensure that those instructions will be carried out?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy read the instructions?

Comment on this

The Minister's instructions are very clearly defined. He has stipulated a particular class of people. He has referred to very wealthy people and I put it to the Minister that if any man is able to purchase his own house, he will not look for a loan for it. I do not know of any wealthy man in County Dublin who got a Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts loan to purchase his house. The only people who look for loans, to my knowledge, are those who are unable to purchase their own houses without some assistance. It would be a rather strange thing to have anyone applying for a loan, if he were already blessed with sufficient wherewith to purchase a house. Surely, such a man would not be so foolish as to pay the high interest rates involved in the repayment of loans for house purchase.

The Minister states he will look after the poor people. As far as the Dublin County Council and the Dublin Corporation are concerned, the poor are those with £9 10s. per week, or under. If a man has £10 per week he will not get a loan. I live in County Dublin and I know of a number of applicants who were told they would not get a loan because they are in receipt of £560 per annum. They are occupying their houses under caretaker agreements. They have been misled by statements made by the Minister and other people here. Now, they will be left in the lurch. I am sorry I have to speak in this way, but I feel that neither this House nor the Minister has been honest with the people whom I represent. I regard Section 9 as fraudulent in conception because it does not meet the position good, bad or indifferent of those people whom we wish to protect. If the Minister told us quite honestly that the money was not available, we, as responsible Deputies, would say: "Then we shall have to meet the position in some other way." But the Minister is trying to shove it down our throats that money is available for these people. I know that money is not available for them.

Speaking here, for over an hour last week, on the Second Stage of this measure, I read out particulars of cases wherein people had contracted to purchase houses in good faith and the contractors had built the houses in good faith. Those people are occupying those houses now under caretaker agreements. They are nobody's children. Nevertheless, we are asked to swallow this section; we are told that everything in the garden will be lovely. But we are leaving thousands of people outside. The contractors who purchased land and built the houses are on the verge of bankruptcy. We are told this section will cure all ills. I have a certain responsibility to the people who sent me here and those people are not being properly treated under this Bill. This section will not meet their position or help them in any way. There is no use codding ourselves.

The Minister told us about the poor people and the "rich poor", shall we call them; he referred to school teachers. I certainly do not know any wealthy teachers. Some of them may be in receipt of possibly £700 per year, but I think very few of them would have that. Even with £700 per year, their commitments are heavy. Here we have a means test and all the rest of it. Will the Minister come clean and tell us exactly what the position is? If he does that he will receive loyal co-operation. It is not our purpose to disrupt. The Minister has told us that everything in the garden is lovely and that Section 9 will cure all ills. I say that it will not.

I am opposed to this section. Furthermore, there is provision in this section whereby the local authority will give a guarantee in relation to loans. I want the Minister to define the type of person who will get that loan. The Minister has told us that it is the man who is above the section. What type of man will get it? Will the decision on that be left to the local authority in the same way as it was in the case of the supplementary grants in the City and County of Dublin? I hold that we should be very definite about this and not leave it to be interpreted by local authorities at will. The section as it stands is a deception on the people whom we are trying to protect. I do not say that as a personal reflection on the Minister; nevertheless the section is a deception on the people. It will not cure any ills. It is one of the most ambiguous pieces of legislation with which we have ever found ourselves confronted.

Will the Minister amend this section to ensure that those people in my constituency who have entered into commitments in good faith and who are now occupying their houses under caretaker agreements, together with the contractors who built the houses in good faith, will be in a position to honour their commitments, commitments entered into on or before 10th March last?

Comment on this

That does not arise on this section.

Comment on this

The Minister may say it does not arise, but I hold it is inherent in the section. Deputy Larkin knows that what I am saying is true. Constituents have approached me and every other Deputy in both the City and the County of Dublin. We are sent in here to do our job to the best of our ability on behalf of our constituents. If it is a case of not being able to "get blood out of a turnip", then I suppose we shall have to accept the position.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is repeating himself.

Comment on this

I am sorry for being so vehement this evening. I have spoken on this matter before and I have spoken then with all the coolness at my command. I would be long sorry to introduce any element of discord into the debate but, when I am told repeatedly that this section will cure all ills, I am not going to swallow that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not repeat himself. He has said that several times.

Comment on this

Will the Minister take the people who committed themselves out of the lurch now? Will he tell the House in all seriousness that small dwellings loans will be available as heretofore? Will he tell the House what section will get these loans? Will he tell the House what section——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We are dealing specifically with Section 9 and these general questions are not relevant.

Comment on this

It is here under Section 9.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is asking general questions as to what section will give power to a local authority in respect of certain matters. That surely cannot arise under Section 9. The Deputy should confine himself to Section 9 and he should deal with it.

Comment on this

I have confined myself to Section 9.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not my opinion.

Comment on this

I shall read the section:—

"(1) A housing authority may, in accordance with a scheme approved of by the Minister, guarantee part of an advance ... by a building society or an assurance company for the purchase or erection of a house together with interest thereon.

(2) For the purpose of a scheme under this section, a housing authority shall have the like powers of borrowing as are conferred on them for the purposes of the Housing of the Working Classes Acts or the Labourers Acts."

I do not see why the Minister wants to introduce this ambiguous section. I want to refer again to the reason for his wanting to introduce it—trying to tell the people that things in the garden are lovely when, in fact, they are not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy does not deal more specifically and more succinctly with the section, I shall have to ask him to resume his seat.

Comment on this

I want to protest in the strongest possible way against the introduction of this section, because I feel it is dishonest and ambiguous and does not meet the position which exists to-day.

Comment on this

The Minister said that this section does not in any way put a brake on private building. I have yet to hear any arguments adduced to show that that is true. In my view, it is the first attempt to put a real brake on private building. It is an attempt to pass on a section of the community who desire and require loans to build their houses to building societies who may or may not give them the necessary loans.

The Minister said it was not fair that everybody should be able to secure a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and that, therefore, a scheme was being drafted whereby some persons would procure loans through the building societies. If that is so, as Deputy O'Malley pointed out, why give these people grants from Government funds? Secondly, why go to their further assistance by having the housing authority guarantee that portion of the loan which they may require over and above the normal amount which would be paid by the building society? That is further testimony, if such be necessary, that this scheme was not designed to compel the better-off classes to confine themselves to procuring loans from the building societies. The Minister also said it had not retarded private building in any way. I do not know what effect it may have had generally, but I think it is true that it has created a serious recession in private building in cities, particularly Dublin City.

This section is of little or no use, so far as rural Ireland is concerned. In rural areas, those who qualify for a supplementary grant from local authorities have to show that their income is under a certain figure. They must, in order to qualify for a loan, show that their income is above a certain figure. Therefore it is impossible to qualify for the supplementary grant from the housing authority and, at the same time, to qualify for a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. The type of people in rural Ireland who were accustomed to benefit by Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts loans were white-collar workers who would not, under the means test, qualify for a supplementary grant from the housing authority. By virtue of the present imposition on them, as well as the ambiguities surrounding this proposed scheme, they will be put in a position in which they will not apply for loans from a building society.

I was late for the Minister's opening statement and I do not know whether or not he explained the principles of the scheme in any broad terms. Usually, a building society requires a first mortgage on the property. In the past, when local authorities granted a loan, not merely did they require a first mortgage on the property, but they also required two personal solvent securities. If the building society advances portion of a loan and the housing authority comes in to guarantee the portion over and above what would be the normal amount paid by the building society, will they also seek a charge on the property on which the building society will already have obtained a first charge? Will they look for a second mortgage or will they be content with two solvent securities only? Since the amount to be repaid, in the event of default by the housing authority, can only be two-thirds of the amount in excess of the normal loan which would be paid by the building society, will the building society be prepared to give loans under these conditions at all? The whole thing is in the melting-pot.

I have a copy of a letter which was written to the Minister by the standing sub-committee of the Dublin House Builders' Association. I do not know whether or not anything has resulted from this correspondence. That body wrote to the Minister on 12th instant as follows:—

"We wish to refer to a letter dated 22nd June, 1956, to which no reply has been received. The conditions existing at the date of our letter still persist and our members are extremely concerned and feel there is not likely to be a change in the situation for some time."

It is a sensible letter written by a responsible association which, naturally, is perturbed at the present situation. The letter continues:—

"It is understood you have recently made available to the Dublin Corporation and Dublin County Council the suggested terms of agreement with the building societies under the guarantee scheme. From our information, it would appear that these matters have yet to be dealt with by the committee of Dublin County Council in the next few weeks and by the Dublin Corporation Housing Committee in August and, providing these local authorities are satisfied, the terms will have to be accepted by the building societies. We are again informed it will not be possible for the building societies to approve of any application under the scheme, let alone advance moneys thereon, until this stage has been reached."

That would seem to indicate a complete deadlock.

Comment on this

The Deputy is lengthening the deadlock the longer he speaks here.

Comment on this

The extra time we will spend here in exposing the shortcomings of Section 9 will not be time wasted. The building trade in Dublin has had to wait for the past three or four months——

Comment on this

Since last November.

Comment on this

——in a period of complete indecision. They will welcome any complete exposure of the shortcomings, which are many, of Section 9 of this Bill.

I want particularly to refer to the last paragraph of that letter which really sets out the situation which exists:—

"As you are no doubt aware, it is the custom for the building industry to pay off the entire labour force at the end of July, the time of the annual holidays. Unless our members are certain that purchasers will be able to take up loans, it is a fact that very few of these employees will be re-engaged after the holidays. In view of this, it is sincerely hoped you will be able to give us as soon as possible the information that sufficient funds have been made available to the local authorities to enable them to continue the operation of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts.

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with the section.

Comment on this

It has this much to do with it: the building trade in Dublin are not in a position to-day to know what is likely to happen to-morrow with regard to the building trade. The Minister has already given us an assurance that Section 9 will in no way interfere with private building as such. That copy of that communication is in itself sufficient proof that, not merely is Section 9 likely to interfere with the building trade, but has already created chaos in that industry. Therefore, there is no question of doubt about the implications of this section. It has already put the brake on private building.

Borrowing from the Small Dwellings Acts Fund has been of little assistance to a particular section of private builders in rural Ireland, because, as I have already explained, they cannot qualify for a supplementary grant and at the same time obtain a loan since the income that is sufficiently low in one case will not be accepted if it is too low in the other case and the people concerned were not likely to turn to the building societies for a loan. Building societies are very wary about touching property in rural Ireland. As a matter of fact, I do not think they do give loans in many instances to rural communities.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

They may in the provincial towns in respect of business properties.

Comment on this

That is not true. All over rural Ireland they give advances for dwelling-houses.

Comment on this

I should like to know the number of farmers who within the last ten years have obtained grants from any of the building societies in Dublin.

Comment on this

I am giving you a guarantee now that they will operate this scheme in any part of rural Ireland.

Comment on this

I should like to know if any guarantee scheme has been arrived at between the Minister and the building societies.

Comment on this

The Deputy saw the circular of the 29th June sent out by my Department to every local authority in the country, including the association whose name he has just quoted.

Comment on this

I have seen a copy of the circular but it does not set out that any specific scheme has been arranged.

Comment on this

Will the Minister make available the replies he received from the local authorities and the number that are in favour of Section 9?

Comment on this

I have a number of local authorities who have approved of the scheme.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Brennan must be allowed to proceed.

Comment on this

While this conversation was going on between the Minister and Deputy McQuillan I unearthed a circular issued by a particular county council in relation to the Minister's circular of the 29th June. It is not Donegal County Council. This is a memorandum issued by way of explanation of the circular dated the 29th June in which they make some references which are striking and which show the indecision which prevails even after the receipt of that circular of the 29th June. The memorandum says:—

"Arising out of the recent circulars from the Department of Local Government in relation to these schemes, there are a number of points to be noted——"

Comment on this

Which scheme?

Comment on this

The scheme under Section 9.

Comment on this

This is in relation to the circular of 29th June.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting?

Comment on this

I am quoting from an explanatory memorandum by a certain county council.

Comment on this

Unless the Deputy gives the name of the county council I do not think he should be permitted to quote it.

Comment on this

Wicklow County Council.

Comment on this

And the date of the memorandum?

Comment on this

The date of the memorandum is 6th July, 1956.

Comment on this

I take it that the Deputy will read the entire memorandum?

Comment on this

I will read the relevant portion.

Comment on this

Ah, now. To whom is this memorandum addressed?

Comment on this

To each member of the Wicklow County Council.

Comment on this

From whom?

Comment on this

The county manager probably.

Comment on this

The county manager, a very wise county manager, who sent out an explanatory memorandum because one would need to break down many of the circulars that we get from the Department of Local Government or any other Department and to issue them in plain, commonsense language. That is what this purports to do. Let us see what it says. The heading is: "Scheme for Guarantees by Housing Authorities of Loans by Building Societies." It says:—

"Arising out of the recent circulars from the Department of Local Government in relation to these schemes, there are a number of points to be noted.

In the circular of 28th June, 1956, it was mentioned by the Department that regard should be had in considering applications for advances to not only the income of the applicants, their capital resources and value of lands occupied, but also the need for new housing accommodation."

If the existing housing accommodation is held to be good enough the applicant may be refused a loan.

Comment on this

Is that not quite natural? If his house is good enough, why should he want a loan to build another one?

Comment on this

One could easily understand a member of a family thinking about branching out on his own.

Comment on this

Let him apply and, if he does, he will get the loan.

Comment on this

If he is a single man and a member of a family and has not already committed the deed, he may be regarded as living in good enough housing accommodation.

Comment on this

Not necessarily. He would be the applicant, not the householder.

Comment on this

The question may arise, is he entitled to a house or does he require a house?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This debate may not develop into a cross-examination between two members from Donegal as to a circular from Wicklow.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

I will give the Wicklow circular to a Wicklow Deputy who will read it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Section 9 is before the House. I hope Deputy Brennan remembers that.

Comment on this

I have rigidly kept to the section. While it does not greatly concern rural Ireland, it is a section that is bound to produce chaos, if it does not already exist, in private building in the cities and larger towns. Under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts we have found difficulty enough in obtaining loans without complicating matters further. As I pointed out when speaking on the Second Reading of the Bill, it was necessary to give a first charge on the property and two solvent securities had to be provided. I should like the Minister when replying to let us know, when the local authority are underwriting a loan or giving a guarantee for portion of a loan given by a building society, will they also seek a charge on the property?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Will they seek personal securities?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The first charge on the property by the building society will be accepted as sufficient?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And no personal securities will be sought?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

That is an important matter because we have been accustomed in the past in the matter of obtaining loans to the procedure that not merely was there a first charge on the property but two solvent securities were also required and the investigation of the guarantors was such that they were very frequently turned down, held not to be suitable, with the result that many people did not go to the trouble of looking for these loans at all. The Minister states that all that will be done away with. I think it introduces a new aspect into Section 9, which may not be as bad as I thought it would be.

Comment on this

It took the Deputy a good while to see that.

Comment on this

If the Minister can give us a guarantee that we can get loans by means of a first charge on the property only, that will be a great improvement——

Comment on this

At 7 per cent.

Comment on this

——on the schemes we had, if the interest is given at the same rate. With all due respect to the Minister's statement, I very much suspect that the regulations in regard to the granting of loans will be waived by some of the county managers whose duty it is to see whether or not they require personal sureties. There is nothing in this Bill to change the situation as it was under the 1952 Act which left it in the hands of the county manager as to whether or not he required personal securities. I take the Minister's word. It is on the record of this House and I will take great pleasure in using it elsewhere, when the necessity arises.

Comment on this

It is not binding.

Comment on this

I, on one occasion, made a very strong effort to get loans.

Comment on this

That does not arise under this guarantee section.

Comment on this

It arises very much under Section 9. What we are really concerned with in the section and in the amendment of Section 10 of the 1952 Act is the availability of and the method by which loans will be procured in the future. That is what I am discussing. I submit it is relevant and absolutely so. I should like to hear the Minister's statement on this when he comes to refer to the section and, as Deputy O'Malley says, I should like to have the views of the Labour people, who are in their hearts opposed to this section. I should like to see if their feet will follow their hearts when it comes to passing this section this evening.

Comment on this

At the risk of protracting this debate, may I point out that every Deputy who spoke so far— they are all on the Fianna Fáil side of the House—represented a rural constituency, with the exception of Deputy O'Malley?

Comment on this

I have not spoken yet.

Comment on this

We have been discussing this section for the past three hours. Again, at the risk of protracting this debate, may I point out that every Deputy who spoke said this section would not affect his constituency?

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

They said they were thinking of Dublin. They were concerned about the City of Dublin.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

I will accept Deputy Smith's word. Every Deputy who spoke represented a rural constituency in spite of the fact that we have three prominent representatives of the City of Dublin here—Deputy MacEntee, an ex-Minister, the Lord Mayor and a third Deputy.

Comment on this

But I was not here.

Comment on this

I am not referring to whether the Deputy was here or not. Not one of the city representatives of Fianna Fáil spoke against this section. Every other Deputy who spoke, with the exception of Deputy Smith, said that it did not affect rural Ireland, but that they were concerned about Dublin, but the Fianna Fáil speakers representing Dublin were not here to say one word against the section.

Comment on this

I speak as a Deputy from a rural area. The Minister assured Deputies from rural areas who spoke that this section would have no adverse effect on housing in rural areas. Personally, I should like to believe that and I think I am entitled to accept the Minister's word as given in this House. I only hope that the Minister's specific statement in this House will have as binding an effect as the legislation that will be enacted.

This matter was included in a circular from the Department recently to local authorities. I presume that the members of all local authorities in Ireland had an opportunity of discussing at their meeting the changes proposed to be made by the Minister in new housing legislation. The council to which I belong and in respect of which I have the honour to speak, namely, Roscommon County Council, discussed this proposal in detail and the unanimous opinion of all members of that council on which there is an inter-Party majority, was that this would not be of benefit to the rural areas.

Comment on this

They need not adopt it.

Comment on this

That is what I am coming to. Notification to that effect was sent back to the Department. I feel sure that what suits a local authority like Roscommon suits the majority of rural constituencies. On every rural local authority, there are members of this House: Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour and Clann na Talmhan. That being the case, I presume that the Fine Gael members, the Labour members and the Fianna Fáil members of the local authorities gave attention and thought to the implications of this Bill, with particular reference to this section.

I also presume that when the legislation was introduced into this House, each Party met and discussed the implications of this section. I cannot understand why there is not a unanimous viewpoint expressed from all sides of this House from rural Deputies in regard to the dangerous implications attached to this section. Let me point out what they are.

The Minister stated that so far as the local authorities are concerned, especially in rural areas where the majority of local authorities are, it is optional on them to adopt this. If it is optional, does that mean that, as far as the local authority in Roscommon are concerned, they can ignore completely this section and that we in Roscommon can carry on exactly as we have carried on in the past, that we are entitled to make loans available to any citizen within the local authority area on the same basis as we have given those loans in the past?

Comment on this

Provided the person is a person of modest means.

Comment on this

Now we have got the snag. In other words, the county council in Roscommon need not adopt this scheme, but when they try to carry out the former scheme, they must not put forward to the Minister for sanction a loan on behalf of an individual who, in the opinion of the Minister, does not come within the interpretation of a man of modest means. Is that not what it means? In other words, each case has to be sanctioned by the Minister.

Comment on this

The local authority have the sanctioning of the loan.

Comment on this

Nobody knows what "modest means" is, apparently.

Comment on this

I have nothing whatever to do with it. I allocate a certain sum and it is a matter entirely for the local authority to decide who are to get it. I suggest that they should see that the people who deserve it—the people of modest means— should have first claim to it.

Comment on this

I do not want to criticise the Minister as he is going to get plenty of criticism from other members in this House. I want to satisfy myself in regard to what the Minister said at the beginning, that the local authority in Roscommon can carry on exactly as it did in the past on the same basis. Now the Minister, by means of an interjection, stated they can, provided the loans are given to people with modest means. As far as modest means are concerned, their interpretation of that could be completely different from the Minister's.

Comment on this

They have the last word. I have no say in it.

Comment on this

In the case of a man who has an income of £1,000 per annum —not a school teacher; I do not know of any of them with that income—who is making an attempt to send his children to a secondary school and perhaps a son or daughter to a university—all of which has to be paid for because the fact that the father has £1,000 per year prevents them from getting a scholarship—does it mean that that man, if he wishes to build a new house, will be entitled to obtain from, say, the Roscommon County Council the same facilities as he obtained in the past with regard to a loan? I do not think that there is any answer to that point.

The Minister's way of getting over this problem—in other words, sidetracking the issue, or, to put it bluntly, pulling the wool over the eyes of rural Deputies—is that he says there is no change if the local authority does not wish to adopt this Section 9. Immediately afterwards, he reduces the amount of money made available to that local authority. Mark you, the Minister has stated clearly that only next year will the same amount be made available for these loans for house building to the local authority. That means that the next year—there is no question in the world about it— there will be a complete reduction in the amount of money made available to the local authorities to fulfil their requirements.

I think that this is a backward step, and I regret to have to say it. I think that each Bill that has been brought into this House in recent years by different Governments, whether legislation of a social character or bearing on economics, was a step forward, a progressive step. Some of us may at all times have believed that the steps were painfully slow, but at any rate there were steps forward. This, to my mind, and I regret to have to say it, appears to me to be not even a marking of time—bad as that would be—but a step backwards. I suggest to Deputies on all sides of the House who are acquainted with housing problems in rural areas to be on their guard against this section.

I do not know whether the implications of the section have been brought home to them at Party meetings; I presume if they have been taking an interest in the Bill since it came in they have made themselves familiar with the point at issue now. What does the Minister mean by telling local authorities: "Carry on as you are; do not mind this Section 9 if you do not feel inclined to mind it"? He thereby gives the impression to each of these local authorities that everything in the garden is lovely, and suggests that they can carry on in the future as they did in the past. I think rural Deputies would need to sit down and examine very carefully the Minister's promises in connection with that point. If they do, they will discover for themselves that they may be helping to pass legislation that will not be of benefit to those people who want to build their houses in rural areas.

The Minister took an example, perhaps an unfortunate one in some respects, and said that teachers could not be put in the poorer class. Nobody suggests they can be. He said they should be in the class that can afford to go to insurance companies in order to get the new loans. He also tried to make it appear an attraction that the deposite rate would be reduced when they take advantage of this procedure.

He did not, of course, mention that the interest rate would be, and is now at the moment, 7 per cent. as far as these companies are concerned. That is an important point. Why pick on that section of the community?

Comment on this

I merely quoted them as an example.

Comment on this

The Minister quoted them as an example. If we take the salary scale for married teachers there are very few of them, to my knowledge, earning salaries in excess of £500 or £600.

Comment on this

I think each case would have to be taken separately.

Comment on this

If it is a matter of taking each case separately, how can it arise that the man with £800, £900 or £1,000 could be considered a man of modest means?

Comment on this

It is possible.

Comment on this

If the local authority decides—when I say the local authority, I mean the local authority and not the county manager—does the Minister agree with me on that? When I say local authority I refer to the elected members of the county council. If they decide that a certain ceiling should be placed with regard to the giving of loans will that decision be carried out by the county manager? May I take it that is what the Minister means, or will it be left solely to the county manager to decide what a man of modest means is? We have in the health services a figure of £600. Apparently the Department had no difficulty in clarifying that and in giving the figure of income which they believed would be appropriate in the case, shall we say, of white-collar workers, and under which certain privileges and treatment would be made available.

Is it not possible for the Minister to decide here for the House and for local authorities what in his opinion should be the ceiling or the appropriate figure under which building loans would be made available with the adoption of the new Section 9? If there is no known figure to aim at, the position will be intolerable in regard to defining what a man of modest means is. Perhaps the Minister can satisfy me in this way. If the local authority draw up a scheme which they say they will put into operation they may say: "We will keep the present system in operation for all those whose income is under £800. For those whose income is above £800 each case will be dealt with according to its merits." Can the Minister tell me whether the local authority, as such, will be entitled to formulate a scheme on those lines and put it into operation?

I want to know this because, if I find it will work out satisfactorily in that respect, I am not going to walk into the Division Lobby to oppose this section but if I find the Minister telling me that in this important case it is the county manager who will decide what the man of modest means is, I shall have to go into the Division Lobby to oppose it.

Comment on this

I was merely about to reply briefly to Deputy McQuillan who did put a very definite question to me. I think he is entitled, and the House is entitled, to a reply to the question which he put. Let me say at the outset that the granting of loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts does impose a certain burden on local authorities. The local authority must borrow money and I am most anxious to see that everybody who needs a loan will get it. I am also anxious to see that those who can borrow elsewhere than from the local authority should go elsewhere. Further, I am anxious that in the case of those who must go elsewhere, in deciding that question of fact in individual cases, the local authorities should have regard to the following points:—

(1) The circumstances of the applicant including income, capital resources, valuation of lands occupied and the need for new housing accommodation.

(2) The amount of the advance sought and the purchase price or cost of the new house.

(3) Availability of finance from commercial lending agencies including assurance companies and building societies.

Local authorities will, no doubt, have regard to the difference between the annual repayments on advances by building societies and the repayments on advances under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts in considering applications for advances under those Acts. Regard should also be had to the fact that income-tax relief is available in appropriate cases (1) on the interest content of the repayments in respect of house purchase advances and (2) in respect of life assurance premiums.

These are some of the considerations which will govern the decisions of local authorities and I hope that local authorities will take each application on its individual merits. I can imagine a man who is single and advanced in years with an income of £800. He is not a man of modest means. I can also imagine a man with £900 and a large family and, in my opinion, he would be a man of modest income. Each will have to be considered on its own merits.

Comment on this

What would such an old man be doing with a new house?

Comment on this

I had better not say anything.

Comment on this

I should like to ask will the county manager have absolute authority in deciding who is entitled, and who is not, to a loan under the Small Dwellings Acts or from a building society?

Comment on this

In conjunction with the local authorities.

Comment on this

And the Minister?

Comment on this

The Minister does not come into it at that particular time. He does not sanction a loan in an individual case. I see I have provoked the Lord Mayor.

Comment on this

The Minister has not provoked me; it is the section which has provoked me. I will be brief, but I will be very clear.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt, but before the Deputy rises, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, there was agreement last week, and I would like to know if it still stands, that all stages of this Bill would be taken by to-night.

Comment on this

I am very anxious to see them taken. I thought we would be finished with this Bill at six o'clock easily. The Minister has not been as co-operative in this discussion as he should have been.

Comment on this

I do not think that is fair.

Comment on this

There is an obvious desire on the Minister's part to hedge on questions about which there should be no difficulty at all.

Comment on this

Deputy Smith knows that, with the exception of Deputy McQuillan, nobody else spoke from this side of the House. Any question put to me I have tried to answer.

Comment on this

I have asked whether the Minister was going to interpret for us, and for local bodies, what was meant by "modest means". The Minister gave us an example, but later, when shown the effects of the example, he started to hedge and to cite cases of a married man who was old, and so on. I asked the Minister were local authorities to be given a direction by him, or his Department, as to the type of person who would get a loan. I cited a case of a local body which sought £20,000 and who were given £10,000. Does it mean that local bodies will get 50 per cent. of what they obtained last year, or does it mean that they will get 80 per cent. or 100 per cent., and that they can do what they like with that money? We want an answer and it is the Minister's duty to give us the answer. If he gives us the answer, we will not hold up the debate for 20 minutes.

Comment on this

I endeavoured to give an answer as best I could. I cannot say what a man of modest means is; that is a matter entirely for the local authorities. They know the circumstances better than I do. A man in a rural area with £500 or £600 may be a comparatively wealthy man, but a man in a town with the same figure may be a poor man and a man of modest means. It is a matter for the local authorities to investigate each case and say what the position is. I am not going to give them a directive. I am advising them what they should take into consideration in coming to the conclusion as to whether an applicant is a man of modest means. We are in the experimental stage. If we get the opportunity of experimenting, we can see what happens. I take Deputy Smith's word that it was Cavan County Council which applied——

Comment on this

I did not say Cavan County Council. I said a local body.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that the position is that when a local authority applies for a certain amount, it may be that they are offered a lesser figure. It is only by experience that both they and the Department will know what exactly the figure will be. We are anxious that the amount sought should be for the coming 12 months; that it should be confined to 12 months and not spread over two or three years. As Deputy Smith has not given me the name of the local authority, I cannot check for what period the £20,000 was asked for.

Comment on this

The authority in question have already commitments to the extent of £10,000 which means that the £20,000 they applied for was to meet the commitments already entered into. The result of this decision is that the £10,000 will meet the commitments and they do not know if they will have money for anything else.

Comment on this

There are two different things—withdrawals and commitments. While they may have commitments for £20,000, there may not be withdrawals of £20,000. Is that not quite clear? We have asked all local authorities to distinguish between them. You may have commitments for £20,000, but they will not all be paid in the financial year. There may be withdrawals for the following years. That is all we have asked local authorities to do—to confine themselves to what they consider will be the withdrawals for the 12 months.

I should again like to ask if we are to get all stages concluded to-night. The Seanad has been summoned for to-morrow.

Comment on this

When Deputy Briscoe has spoken, I do not propose to prolong the discussion any further. We shall have to put it to a division. We shall do so as quickly as possible. We have no anxiety to break any understanding, I can assure the Minister and the House. This matter should not have lasted as long as it has lasted.

Comment on this

I appreciate what the Deputy says.

Comment on this

In his last attempt to meet the attitude of mind expressed over here the Minister has shown that he does not know how a local authority works or what commitments mean. If a local authority have entered into agreements to advance £10,000, they must know that they are going to be able to get that £10,000, to be given to the building people as and when the houses have reached the stage where the building people can ask for money. Until they know that there will be more money available for them for future transactions, they cannot enter into these contracts.

The Minister is talking nonsense in his arguments. Any member of this House who has had the slightest experience of how a local authority works knows that they are all in the same position. We in the Dublin Corporation have been given for this financial year a sum of £1,000,000 to complete our commitments in regard to Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts loans, but we have no indication whatever that we will be able to get more for future loans. That is the reason we recently applied, having passed a resolution, for another £500,000, in order that we could continue loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts scheme, but we have not yet had a reply, and until we have a reply that that sum will be made available when needed, we cannot commit ourselves to a single transaction.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy seen my reply to Deputy Mrs. Maureen O'Carroll's question on 12th July?

Comment on this

What did the Minister say?

Comment on this

I was asked:—

"Why the Dublin Corporation have not since the 7th June accepted applications for loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts from persons who are qualified for supplementary housing grants."

I replied:—

"The only information I have in this matter is that contained in Press notices published by the corporation to the effect that applications for loans in hands at the 7th June were estimated to require the balance of capital moneys available for the purpose of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, including the £1,000,000 which the Minister for Finance agreed to issue from the Local Loans Fund for that purpose in the current financial year. Since that date, however, the corporation have been informed that the Minister for Finance is prepared to afford them financial backing for capital expenditure to the same extent in 1957-58 as in 1956-57. The application of the funds to be thus made available is a matter for determination by the corporation in the first instance."

On the 6th July, 1956, a letter was sent to the local authority. I do not know if the Deputy wishes me to read it or not?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

It was as follows:—

"I am directed by the Minister for Local Government to refer to your letter of the 29th June and previous correspondence regarding the financing of the corporation's capital programme and to state that the Minister for Finance will be prepared to provide from public funds such a sum as, with any money that may be obtained by the corporation from other sources, will enable them to discharge capital expenditure of £4,000,000 in 1957-58. This intimation is now being conveyed so that the corporation will, having regard to the undertaking contained in the Taoiseach's letter of 16th April to the Lord Mayor and to the undertaking now given, be in a position to plan in advance their capital programme and to regulate the commencement of schemes and the incidence of expenditure thereon as between the current and the next financial year.

Any advance approval of any capital undertakings in this and the ensuing financial year will not imply sanction to capital expenditure in these years, save in accordance with the assurances now given. The Minister would be glad, therefore, if you would be good enough to furnish, in the light of this letter, an estimate of the requirements to be met from public funds (allowing for borrowings from other sources) in each quarter of 1956-57, together with such estimate as can at this stage be furnished for 1957-58. The estimate should be compiled under the headings (i) Housing of the Working Classes Acts; (ii) Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts; (iii) North Dublin Main Drainage; and (4) other capital expenditure."

Comment on this

Of course, these answers read by the Minister and that letter are deliberately misleading. The Minister knows full well that the letter of the Taoiseach, to which he refers, confined the capital expenditure, for which the Government undertakes liability of guarantee and supply, to certain specific types of obligations and excludes Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts loans, except in so far as the special £1,000,000 which was made available is concerned. The Minister is not talking to a lot of schoolboys——

Comment on this

The Deputy's statement is not true at all.

Comment on this

It is true. If the Minister reads the Taoiseach's letter——

Comment on this

The Deputy has got my letter of the 6th July.

Comment on this

What does that mean? It means this: that we have not been given sanction to borrow from the Local Loans Fund a sum of £500,000 to enter into new commitments for building under the Small Dwellings Acts—

Comment on this

That is not true. I asked for an estimate to be compiled under four headings inter alia Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts.

Comment on this

The position has been reached where we get our money through the Department of Local Government from the Minister for Finance as a result of a monthly estimate of our payment demands for the coming month.

Comment on this

Surely that does not arise on this section?

Comment on this

The Minister has thrown that in to try and misrepresent the situation and to create the belief in people that something exists which does not exist. The position is that we have to go every month asking for our payment requirements, which includes Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts payments in respect of the £1,000,000 which we are promised——

Comment on this

We asked you for them every quarter in that letter.

Comment on this

Is it fair that the Minister should take the line of arguing like that? I am saying categorically that the facts are, that whether we ask for the money monthly or quarterly, it is only in respect of that money which has been promised to be made available and does not include any of the commitments by us under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Deputy Larkin, the Chairman of the Housing Committee is here, and I challenge him to say whether the Minister is right or I am right. He is here in the House and he knows more about this subject than any other member of the House. We know what we are talking about. Section 9 is put there again as a smokescreen. We know, we have been informed and we are quite satisfied that the vast bulk of applicants for small dwelling loans hitherto available will not be accepted under any circumstances by the building societies to which the Minister refers in this section. We also know that the building societies have not sufficient capital available to meet the requirements of building loans for small dwellings in the City of Dublin. We know from them that they depend on people depositing money with them as to the extent that they can make it available, and we know that, when the competition for these moneys to be made available to them by way of deposit becomes keener, the deposit rate will increase and will have the consequence of a situation developing where the charge of interest to the borrower will also rise.

I say that Section 9 is purely a "cod" section. It is purely to try and mislead people, and will throw on the local authority, in Dublin, anyway, the responsibility of providing an increased number of houses for letting. We are confined under the present financial situation to a limited maximum sum. The Minister knows that we have reached the stage in Dublin where we are now attempting to build up the centre of the city by the erection of flat-type dwellings. They will cost, per dwelling, far more than the ordinary house, with the net result that the number of dwellings made available for letting purposes will be on the decline and will fall substantially lower as year follows year. We are being denied the means of making money available to the type of person who hitherto qualified. We will not be able to build the same number of houses for letting, and we will be drifting back, slowly but surely, to the slumdom that we wanted to be rid of.

The Minister can use all these tactics he has of trying to confuse the situation, but we in Dublin know that Section 9 will not mean very much. With regard to guarantors and securities, it does not amount to a row of pins. There is no statutory obligation attaching to the operations of these building societies. They are not bound to accept any or all applicants. They are as free as private enterprise can be to choose whom they like, to give their money to whom they like, within what they call good business. They are trustees for their shareholders and depositors in each of their institutions.

I am trying to be brief, brief but truthful, and I think Deputy Denis Larkin feels the same from his own knowledge and experience; I think he feels as I do that we are now reaching the stage where there will be a deliberate policy forced on local authorities like Dublin Corporation to close down on Small Dwellings Acts building, notwithstanding the fact that we have still in Dublin sites on which to build 6,000 more of these houses. This policy will also have the consequence of making available fewer of the letting type houses. I ask for Deputy Larkin's opinion here because this is a matter of great seriousness, not only to the people who require the houses but to the people who make their living in the building of these houses. I ask Deputy Larkin to say whether what I have said is the truth, and whether what the Minister has said is not bluff and smokescreen.

Comment on this

With respect to the Lord Mayor, I think I should say a few words in reply.

Comment on this

I asked Deputy Larkin.

Comment on this

First of all, the number of rural Fianna Fáil Deputies who have spoken here to-day said that Section 9 is a "cod" but that they were worried about Dublin. Now we have had the only Fianna Fáil Deputy who spoke on behalf of Dublin saying that it does not affect it.

Comment on this

I said it does affect Dublin adversely.

Comment on this

The Deputy said it was all a "cod".

Comment on this

It is a "cod" which will destroy building.

Comment on this

I am making available to the City of Dublin this year a sum of £4,000,000. That is the sum spent by them last year. Not only that, but I am making available the same amount for next year and the same for the year after. I am giving them a three years' guarantee, something they have never got before in their history.

Comment on this

I expressed certain views on the Bill, particularly on Section 9, on the Second Reading. I regret that the Minister's contributions here this evening have compelled me to intervene again because, speaking as a Dublin Deputy representing workers in a Dublin constituency, where there are quite a large number of building craftsmen and building labourers, and having some little knowledge of the building operations in Dublin for the past few years, I should like to say it is essential that we should be quite clear what the position is.

I expressed the view in my Second Reading speech that I did not think the section would have any effect in so far as the bulk of applicants dealt with by the corporation in the past few years under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts either fell under or came within the supplementary grant, or were very little above it. Last year there was something like £1,900,000 advanced under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and this year it is true that the corporation received a guarantee that £1,000,000 would be made available.

However, this guarantee carried a direction that only those applicants who qualified for supplementary grants—in other words, either those who came under Section 11 of the 1952 Act and were entitled as persons who would qualify for houses under Housing of the Working Classes Act, or those who came under Section 10 of that Act and whose total income did not exceed £520 a year—could receive the benefit from this £1,000,000 made available from the Local Loans Fund. This has entailed a decision by the corporation that on the lists of applicants in respect of that money being filled—in other words, when that £1,000,000 was fully committed to applicants—the corporation felt compelled to advertise publicly that they could not receive any further applications, unless and until some assurance would be received that further moneys would be made available.

The sum of £4,000,000 has been mentioned here. That sum was one which would be made available to the corporation, providing they were unable to raise that amount from their own resources. The money would be made available for the purpose of providing houses under the Housing of the Working Classes Act. One million pounds would be reserved for the Small Dwellings Acts and for capital works, such as the North Dublin main drainage. I do not think the Minister has been too frank with the House because he has not told the House that the estimate submitted by the corporation in January of this year in respect of their expected requirements under the Housing of the Working Classes Act was not the amount of £2.6 million which he told the House was in reserve for that purpose, but £3.4 million. I am compelled to state that the £4,000,000 the Minister has referred to will not permit housing under the Housing of the Working Classes Act to continue for the remainder of this year and, at the same time, permit advances under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts to continue.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

These are matters I would not normally mention in the House, unless I had already informed the Minister of the position. Up to the end of this year, the Dublin Corporation is committed to the expenditure, under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts, of a sum of £3,000,000. It is correct to state that, in respect of the year 1957-58, the corporation has been informed that £4,000,000 will be made available. The corporation has been asked to prepare and submit firm estimates under a number of headings:—(1) Housing of the Working Classes Acts, (2) Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, and (3) other capital works.

The present estimate of expenditure under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts can only be a rough estimate at the moment, but it has been reckoned that, if conditions as prevailing at present hold, and bearing in mind the fact that the corporation are compelled, due to the lack of available sites in the environs of the city, to build more flats in the centre of the city, our present estimate for 1957-58 would be no less than £3,000,000 and possibly £3,250,000 or £3,500,000.

Comment on this

I asked for quarterly estimates.

Comment on this

What does that matter?

Comment on this

Under ordinary capital works such as the necessary completion of the North Dublin main drainage scheme, there will be an expenditure of something like £600,000. That gives a minimum of £3,600,000, leaving, in respect of that year, under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, a maximum of £400,000, which I do not think we can reach at all. Possibly, if these figures were read in another way, and approached from another angle, it might be possible to provide out of the £4,000,000 mentioned by the Minister in his letter to the corporation, and which he mentioned again here to-night, money for many of those who are desirous of building under the Small Dwellings Acts, but, in my opinion, within those figures mentioned, that would be possible only if there is a substantial reduction of building under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts.

The housing committee has already directed its officials to prepare firm estimates, but it is quite clear that the figures which have been mentioned the present allocation of £4,000,000 in respect of the Housing of the Working Classes Acts and the North Dublin main drainage scheme, and the £1,000,000 which is being made available for Small Dwellings Acts purposes will fall short of what is required.

Comment on this

The city manager and the assistant city manager have assured me that they are quite satisfied with the guarantee of £4,000,000 this year and another £4,000,000 next year.

Comment on this

They have not assured us of that.

Comment on this

It is on the record.

Comment on this

We will check on that.

Comment on this

My information is information which has been prepared for members of the Housing Committee of the Dublin Corporation. It is information which, I believe, is factual information. I asked the Minister on the Second Reading whether he would examine this Section 9 again. I still have very grave doubts on it, and these grave doubts, from my point of view, have not been removed as a result of the debate in this House this evening. The purpose of the section is to enable the corporation and other local authorities to give certain guarantees, but I should like the Minister to give me enlightenment on one or two points.

The first is this: if this Bill is passed as submitted here, and if the Dublin Corporation, as a local authority, decided to give the guarantees mentioned, would that body be entitled to fix the conditions under which they would guarantee loans? Some few years ago, the corporation had a scheme of tenant purchase houses erected. At that time, there were some 1,600 applicants for 204 houses. After considerable heart-searching and considerable discussion, certain regulations were brought in in an endeavour to reduce the number of applicants and to deal with the matter as fairly as possible. One of the regulations brought in was that the maximum income under which an applicant would be entitled to one of these houses was £14 a week. Would the Minister say that, if the corporation, in dealing with this matter, felt, under all circumstances, that this was a reasonable limit, all applicants who otherwise qualified and whose income fell within the figure mentioned would be enabled to get the loans from the corporation through the Local Loans Fund?

It is necessary to mention that there is little hope of the corporation raising any money through its own resources for this purpose. Earlier this year, as I have mentioned, £1,000,000 was made available for the purpose of meeting applications under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and the qualification covered only those who complied with and who would be covered by the supplementary grant. Practically 80 per cent. of the applicants then in hands so qualified and I think it is correct to say that the bulk of those who did not qualify were very slightly outside that regulation. In 1954-55, something like £1,900,000 was also advanced by the Dublin Corporation under the Small Dwellings Acts. Again by far the larger percentage of these applicants would either qualify or be just slightly outside the supplementary grant.

The Minister has mentioned that it lies in the hands of the local authority to fix the regulations and to decide who would get the loan. As far as Dublin is concerned, it is a little more than that because you cannot make regulations in respect to these sections and governing the classes of people who will get the loan unless you have some assurance that the money will be forthcoming. For this year, unless our present application for a further £500,000 receives favourable consideration, the net reduction in respect to the year 1956-57, as against last year, will be an amount of something like £900,000.

I do not think that applications from many of those who would normally obtain loans from Dublin Corporation would be entertained by building societies or insurance companies and, as I put the question before, even if a fairly high percentage of such applicants would receive consideration from the building societies or the insurance companies, have these bodies the money available at the present time in order to deal with applications covering £1,000,000 or £2,000,000 in relation to the City of Dublin alone and possibly as much more in relation to applicants living in the County of Dublin?

I would urge again that the Minister would look at the section. We are told here it does not mean anything to people living in rural Ireland. The Minister himself mentioned that very few Dublin Deputies were speaking on the matter, and that remark, coupled with the other statement, compelled my intervention. I would appeal to the Minister to examine in all seriousness the case that has been made to see whether there is any real purpose served or if anything can be achieved by keeping this section in the Bill.

Comment on this

In relation to Section 9 the Minister definitely stated that it was intended to cater for the lower-paid sections of the community. I have plenty of evidence that the lower-paid sections of the community would require to have £9 10s. a week and they may not have over £10. I wonder if that is the lower-paid section of the community which is to be catered for in this connection? We must remember that only about 5 per cent. of the people who originally got small dwellings loans will get them now.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 53
·
Níl 48
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

The Opposition have met me very fairly indeed on this Bill and I understand the remainder of the Bill may be unopposed. Perhaps it might be possible to sit after half past ten to dispose of it?

Comment on this

Would it do if we gave the Minister the remaining stages fairly quickly to-morrow morning?

Comment on this

It would. I would certainly like to meet the Opposition in that respect but the Deputy will appreciate that the Seanad has been summoned for to-morrow to deal with the Bill.

Comment on this

But not until 3 o'clock.

Comment on this

If it suits the Opposition, I am prepared to leave it over until to-morrow morning.

Comment on this

I think it would be better.

Comment on this