We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956—Committee Stage (Resumed) and Final Stages.

Contributions 1–140 of 282. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956
Enacted

No. 16 of 1956 ›

This section deals with the provision of grants for private water supplies and sewerage and there is just one matter which I want to raise. In sub-section (3) of Section 10, this question of valuation crops up. The Minister guarantees that there will be no increase in the valuation of the property for seven years after the completion of the work. That is a usual stipulation where a premises is reconstructed or repaired, a new roof put on, an extra room or bathroom added, but surely the Minister will agree with me that it is paradoxical to contemplate that the Valuation Commissioners will increase the valuation of any holding where a private water supply is installed, for which the Minister is giving a grant of £40, or where a private sewerage system or septic tank is installed, for which the grant will be £20. Surely the Minister will drop this section entirely or rather change it in such a way that there will be no increase in the valuation, if he has such power. I do not know whether he is empowered to do that or not, but my point is that it is entirely fallacious and actually paradoxical to say that, on the one hand, the Minister is giving these grants and, on the other hand, that a small farmer will be faced, after seven years, with a heavy increase in valuation.

The Minister may say that the increase in valuation as a result of installing a private water supply or a septic tank will be infinitesimal, but we must remember that the Valuation Commissioners will come along to a property which may not have been valued for a considerable number of years. They may then avail of that occasion to revalue the property in toto. That is what happens. I think the Minister will agree with that view. This is one of the main complaints of people who, down through the years, write in to the newspapers from rural areas.

It was said by certain Deputies last night that it was unfortunate that these services and grants were not being availed of to the full extent. I think members on the Minister's side of the House will agree that it is this fear of an increase in valuation after seven years which is responsible for a lot of people not availing of the grant. It would be all right if a small farmer had only 5/- or 10/- put on his valuation— and even that I would be against—but we have had cases, and the Minister should know of them more than anyone else, in which a person with a £10 valuation does a small job meriting a grant. That person often finds afterwards that he has property valued at £25 or £30.

Would the Minister consider putting in a section here, or changing the existing section, to ensure that if a person does avail of a water supply or a sewerage grant, he will not be liable for an increase in valuation?

Comment on this

I think the Deputy misconstrues the meaning of the section. His speech was entirely related to the Valuation Acts and I have absolutely nothing to do with them.

Comment on this

I was asking if the Minister could do anything.

Comment on this

No. I have absolutely nothing to do with the Valuation Acts or the Commissioners of Valuation, but I am ensuring that if a small farmer wants to take advantage of this measure, they will not increase his valuation for a period of seven years. It is but fair to my predecessor, Deputy Smith, to say that he had a similar section and a similar provision in the 1952 Act. We have, however, no control over the Valuation Commissioners. It is entirely a matter for another Department, and all I am doing is ensuring that if any farmer takes advantage of the grants provided for in this measure, the Commissioners of Valuation will not penalise him for a period of seven years.

Comment on this

I want to deal with the division of the £60 grant, that is, the proportion of £40—£20. Under this section as amended, a person who installs a water supply will get £40, whereas the person who installs a sewerage system gets only £20. I think there is a maladjustment there. If the grant were to be kept at £60, I think it would be better to have it on a £30-£30 basis rather than a £40-£20 basis, because I think the major part of the cost goes into the installation of sewerage.

Seeing that both are separate—I agree that it is a good thing to have them separate—there might be a danger, on account of the maladjustment of the amounts, that a person might be enticed or compelled to put in water and neglect sewerage. This would be a grave danger in the case of new houses. Up to now, if a person wanted to get a grant at all, he had to do both, but this allows him to do one or the other and the one that will most commonly be done will be the installation of water, and water only. That is something new and the Minister is committing himself to that. I think some steps should be taken to see that, where water is installed, there will be sewerage also. Alterations could be made in this legislation to ensure that both will go hand-in-hand as heretofore. I entirely agree with Deputy O'Malley who says that revaluation of premises should not take place——

Comment on this

That does not arise on the section.

Comment on this

——especially in view of the fact that a person under Section 10 is now allowed to install water only. I can imagine a farmhouse, or a house in a small town or village, where water is found piped into the house in one spot only and the only alteration done to the premises——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is the Deputy dealing with the Valuation Acts?

Comment on this

The Minister has made valuation provisions here.

Comment on this

No, I have exempted valuation for a period of seven years.

Comment on this

Yes. The Minister can go further by way of improvements——

Comment on this

I can make it 21 years.

Comment on this

Before I finish I may advocate that. That is what I am dealing with and before I advocate anything I must make a case for it. That is what I am trying to do. The only alteration, whether it is a farmhouse or a house in a village that is involved, might be the boring of a two-inch hole through the wall to allow a pipe in. A sink may already be in that kitchen and the only work done might be the boring of the hole. Yet, after seven years that house will be revalued and the full blast of the revaluation will come into operation.

Comment on this

The Deputy forgets that a grant will not be given for boring a hole; a lot more must be done than that.

Comment on this

An applicant under this section will get a grant where the only operation is——

Comment on this

Complete nonsense.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister that if a farmer goes up the field behind the house——

Comment on this

And water flows down and he just bores a hole in the wall for it.

Comment on this

If the farmer finds a well and has a pipe laid into the house, and if there is already a sink in the kitchen, that is all that is required to get the grant.

Comment on this

That is more than boring a hole in the wall.

Comment on this

I know, but there was no alteration except boring the hole. In the similar section in the old Act the applicant had to install flush lavatories and he had to have a sink in the kitchen but now that is not necessary to get the £40 grant. All that he has to do is to take water through a one-inch or two-inch pipe into the sink in the kitchen and for doing that he will get the £40 grant. As I say, that entails no alteration to the house except boring a hole through the wall. Yet a person who has a two-inch hole bored in the wall to allow in a pipe will have to suffer revaluation, and its full effect, after seven years.

Comment on this

We do not say any such thing. We say if it is revalued, it will be exempt for seven years.

Comment on this

The valuation officers usually go there to see what has happened and may be something else has occured and the place is revalued in its entirety.

Comment on this

That one small operation, resulting from the installation of water, will be made an excuse, if the house has not been valued for the last 50 years, to go back and bring the valuation of that premises up to date. That is what is going to happen.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not agree the premises should be revalued? I am exempting it for seven years.

Comment on this

I would suggest that in the case——

Comment on this

That a man boring a hole through his wall should be exempt for 21 years.

Comment on this

That he should have some safeguard that the operation of this Act will not come against him.

Comment on this

When a grant is paid, whether it is for water or sewerage, or the reconstruction of a house — and surely a new house — even if we provide for a seven years' remission, the Valuation Department will not care about the seven years. That is nothing to them, with their outlook. They will come to the premises at any time that is convenient for them and they will revalue not only the house, but the entire premises, if it is an agricultural holding, and if there were any buildings erected since it was valued before, they will be taken into account. You can ask what is wrong with that, but it is something that does not appeal to the people concerned.

Comment on this

I quite agree with you there.

Comment on this

Unless there was some general approach to revaluation it is hardly fair that the fact of getting, say £20, for the installation of sewerage should result in having this revaluation, which might not take effect in relation to the improvements carried out to one particular building. Suppose the valuation officer found that a number of alterations had taken place since the previous valuation, to premises not attached to the dwelling-house, how would that go? I do not know how you can get over this difficulty. It is there and it will have a frightening effect.

Comment on this

Deputy Smith says that if somebody bores a hole to bring water into the house he will get a grant merely for that and that the valuation officer will come along and, finding other buildings, he will increase the valuation. The valuation officer has access to such information in several other ways. One of the ways lies in the fact that anywhere to-day you have to ask your county council for permission to build and following that, when you do build, it is the duty of every county council ganger in the area to report a new building to the county council.

Comment on this

It is the duty of every citizen.

Comment on this

There will be disciplinary action taken if such a report is not made.

Comment on this

The Deputy is an innocent young man if he believes that.

Comment on this

It is quite easy to make a remark like that but it has no bearing on the discussion.

Comment on this

I know the facts of the case the Deputy is talking about and he is talking in the clouds.

Comment on this

I am not. The Deputy says that it is possible that the valuation officer may appear and even value piggeries. That has no relation whatever to the work which was done under the grant. The valuation officers have access to that information in several other ways and it is no excuse——

Comment on this

I do not wish to interrupt, but surely the discussion has developed into one on revaluation?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The discussion is in order.

Comment on this

The point I wish to make is that this section is going to have an adverse effect on people who want to take in water. If a farmer is anxious to take in the water, the fact that a valuation officer may revalue his premises within seven years will frighten off the farmer from taking in the water. We are all very anxious to see water in everybody's home, but this is a very frightening section.

Comment on this

It is the same section as in the 1952 Act.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The very same section.

Comment on this

Deputy Smith and Deputy Cunningham made the point very clearly. As a result of this section, any farmer or anybody else in rural Ireland anxious to get in water will say: "It is very nice to get £40 for putting in the water; we will accept that and we will put in the water." But what will the result be? The valuation officer will be put on to them.

Comment on this

The same thing was done in the 1952 Act.

Comment on this

Water is essential for the people and it is also essential for the animals.

Comment on this

You would not get it under the 1952 Act, unless you had sewerage as well. I am giving you water here.

Comment on this

The Department of Agriculture were giving it before either the Minister or myself.

Comment on this

I am not saying they were not.

Comment on this

Now that the Minister is giving it, would he not go a step further and protect them from the valuation officer?

Comment on this

I have no control over valuations.

Comment on this

The Minister could extend the period.

Comment on this

I am doing that over seven years.

Comment on this

Seven years is no use there. If a man is lucky enough to get a well outside his house and if the well is only about——

Comment on this

That well has been there from time immemorial and he has not deepened it. I am giving him the money to deepen the well.

Comment on this

That is the point. He closes in that well, deepens it possibly and puts down a pump. Then he puts a sink into the kitchenette, kitchen or scullery. But because he does all that, he is subject to revaluation immediately. That will have a frightening effect on the man who wants to get water into his house. Surely a man should not be subject to revaluation because he does all that?

Comment on this

The section does not make him subject to revaluation; it exempts him from valuation for seven years.

Comment on this

Nevertheless, the implication is there.

Comment on this

I did not put the bad thoughts into their heads; it was the 1952 Act.

Comment on this

I wanted to make this point clear.

Comment on this

The Deputy made it as clear as mud.

Comment on this

We all admit that the installation of water is one of the most desirable amenities for rural dwellings. If we are serious in our purpose of encouraging people to avail of the grants now available, we ought also to be ready to reduce or do away with the impediments which are preventing these installations. This is a very serious matter. Even when an additional yard of space is taken in in the reconstruction of a room and an improvement carried out, the valuation officer comes along and revalues the whole premises. That is one of the most serious impediments to reconstructions of dwellings all over the country.

We ought to tackle that problem. I would say the Minister is not responsible; but instead of making the exemption period seven years, he ought to make it ten years, or at any rate increase the period. He should try to reduce the impact of this provision on people who want to bring their dwellings up to date and in order to encourage the women folk to have these amenities in their homes. He should encourage people to continue to improve their dwellings and to continue to live in rural Ireland rather than to go away from it. At present they cannot have these amenities without having an intolerable burden placed upon them, and it should not be the case.

Comment on this

I want to draw the Minister's attention to a matter to which I referred on the Second Stage. I indicated to him that it had come to my notice that the local authority had refused a grant for the installation of water, in a case where the public supply was deemed to be too far distant from the house to be connected. The distance was about 200 yards or thereabouts. I do not know exactly how the provisions under what is known as Section 12 apply. I think we all know these Section 12 cases. All the applications go, in the first instance, to the local authority and are dealt with there. If, in fact, the application for the water is from an applicant who would come under Section 12, I want to find out, in the first place, if the local authority refuses the application for a grant for the installation of water, does that automatically disqualify the applicant for the Government grant also?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The section deals with the installation of a private water supply and not a water supply by a local authority.

Comment on this

The public supply is 200 yards away from the individual applicant. He wants to tap it, but, because the supply is 200 yards away, the local authority says: "We will not give you any grant." Will the Minister say in circumstances of that sort that he will give a grant?

Comment on this

The Deputy is referring to a marginal case, as to whether there should be a public or private supply. All I can promise is that, if he brings the case to my notice, I will personally look into it. It is a question of fact. It is not a question of laying down any hard or fast rule. It is purely a question of fact, and the Deputy knows that as well as I do.

Comment on this

It looks to be a case of hardship.

Comment on this

It does, and possibly it may be, but it is one of those marginal cases. Evidently the local authority knows the facts much better than I do, and possibly better than the Deputy. If the Deputy wants to let me have the facts of this case, I personally will look into it.

Comment on this

It is not a public supply. It is the connection of one individual——

Comment on this

With the public supply.

Comment on this

——with the public supply that happens to be 200 yards away. Obviously, it is a private case; it is the supplying of an individual applicant. The query I am putting to the Minister is: as regards the question of distance, does the Department automatically object because the local authority is objecting? Is the grant available if the person is prepared to put up the difference between the amount of the grant and the cost of the job? Will the Department give the grant in spite of what the local authority does?

Comment on this

It would cost £350 at the very least.

Comment on this

When speaking on the Second Reading of the Bill, I referred to the question of the vesting of cottages. The Minister has made provision in this section in regard to notice to tenants and so on. I should like if he would clarify the position further in regard to the question of tenants who claim that due notice was not served on them when cottages were being vested and when repairs were being carried out prior to vesting. I understand the system that was adopted, and which was given as being in order at the time, was that the engineer concerned made out a list of repairs to cottages due to be vested and that, without giving the names of the tenants, the list was submitted to the Department for approval, that the Minister's sanction was obtained in that way and that subsequently, when the lists were submitted, these people were informed they were vested without having signed anything.

I submit that was entirely irregular and unfair to the tenants concerned. Would it be possible that the Minister would consider making some provision in the Bill to cover such tenants? I know certain provision has been made because the section mentions a period of time, but in Kerry we have an outstanding grievance in this respect. The number of tenants who claim they did not get fair treatment is limited, but I would appreciate it if the Minister would do something for them.

Comment on this

I think the Minister is letting himself in for a great deal of trouble under this section. I also think he will put extra trouble in the way of county councils. I am not clear on what the position was heretofore, but I have an idea it was something as follows: the county engineer decided what repairs were to be carried out and the applicants for vesting were then notified that vesting was about to take place.

Comment on this

That was roughly the procedure.

Comment on this

Now what happens under this section? I can visualise that even where the procedure in operation heretofore has been carried out a tenant can come along and say he is not satisfied. He can appeal to the Minister and, after having inspections by the housing engineer and the county engineer, and after the repairs have been carried out, we still will have a further inspection, possibly by an engineer of the Minister's Department and possibly a further inspection later by the county engineer, with the result that more money will be spent on inspections than on the actual repairs. I know many local authorities are very anxious to have the large number of houses which they own transferred to the tenants and vested in them. That is specially desirable in the case of old cottages where the rents are small and where repairs may cost a good deal. Under statute, the local authority must carry out the repairs where necessary.

In some cases, a good deal of expenditure is incurred, yet the tenant can come along and appeal to the Minister and sometimes, perhaps mischievously or for some flimsy reason, say he is not satisfied and involve both the Department and the local authority in considerable expenditure. In some counties vesting has been very slow up to now. In my county there is a big drive afoot to have most of the old cottages vested. That would relieve the county council and the ratepayers of a great deal of expenditure in regard to the upkeep of these cottages. I also know that tenants are willing and anxious to take over these cottages without any repairs because families have grown up and are anxious to avail of the Department's grants for reconstruction and for the installation of water and sewerage. It is only when they are the owners of the cottages that they can avail of these grants.

Comment on this

What has that got to do with the section?

Comment on this

Indeed it has. I am pointing out that this provision may retard the drive for vesting.

Comment on this

I am interested in the tenants, not so much in the county councils.

Comment on this

I am interested in the tenants who are anxious to avail of these facilities when they become vested owners—reconstruction grants and the installation of water and sewerage. I am also interested in the ratepayers and in seeing that their money is not wasted through too many inspections by engineers of all sorts.

Comment on this

I foresaw some of the difficulties that Deputy Cunningham has pointed out. I would suggest to the Minister a method of short circuiting a lot of those difficulties. I do not agree with Deputy Cunningham that heretofore the tenant was made aware of the vesting of his cottage which was about to take place. My experience is that he signified his intention of vesting and one day he was told the cottage was vested.

Comment on this

The Deputy is quite right. That is what occurred.

Comment on this

To obviate the difficulties which Deputy Cunningham has mentioned and which are bound to occur as a result of the provision of this statutory period of 30 days in which to appeal, I suggest that the Minister should send one of his surveyors down from the Department and instruct or advise him to carry out a survey before a cottage is vested and that the tenant be acquainted with all the repairs it is proposed to carry out.

Comment on this

That is the law as it stands.

Comment on this

The tenant should be told, for instance: "It is proposed to plaster that wall, to put a new door on there, and those would be your entire repairs. Will you agree?" If there is mutual consent as between the tenant and the surveyor, the repairs then are likely to go through satisfactorily and there is not likely to be any appeal.

Comment on this

That is what is supposed to be done.

Comment on this

That would short-circuit a lot of the trouble and obviate many of the difficulties to which Deputy Cunningham referred.

Comment on this

The members of local authorities can compel the local authorities to do that.

Comment on this

That has not been done in the past. They did a few jobs and sometimes the tenant was waiting for something else to be done when one day he discovered that his rent and rates were payable in two separate portions as a result of the cottage being vested.

Comment on this

I quite agree with the Deputy.

Comment on this

If this is allowed to go on in the same manner as in the past, you will invariably have an appeal in each case, and you will have weeks of wrangling as to whether or not the house was properly repaired. If you had mutual consent on the proposed repairs before the work was undertaken and if agreement was reached in what was proposed to be done, the vesting of the cottage could be held up.

Comment on this

The members of the local authority may do that themselves.

Comment on this

What engineering machinery does the Minister visualise will be necessary to keep his Department in touch——

Comment on this

The same machinery as the Deputy had when he introduced the section in the 1952 Act. I do not propose increasing the machinery in any way. There was an appeal under the 1952 Act.

Comment on this

If the Minister anticipates that the amendment of this section will increase the tempo of vesting, there could be quite a number of appeals.

Comment on this

I do not believe there will. I think it may increase the tempo of vesting and ensure at the same time that a local authority, knowing that an appeal may be made after vesting, will do the repairs beforehand.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not realise that the impediments we are trying to eliminate, both in the previous Act and in this Bill, are not really the cause of the failure of the tenant to purchase?

Comment on this

I agree there.

Comment on this

We seem to pretend here that we are doing something that will encourage the occupants or the tenants of these old labourers' cottages to become the owners of them. The reason why these people will not purchase these cottages is very simple. The rents are around 1/- to 1/6 a week; these houses are getting old and becoming hard to maintain. If the people purchase the houses, they will get a 50 per cent. reduction on the present rents which would mean in the case of the cottage with the rent of 1/6 that the rent would then be 9d. In turn, they would have 52 ninepences to keep the cottage in repair.

Everybody who is on a local body knows that it takes much more to keep that cottage in repair than the tenant would be saving by having the cottage vested in him, and the tenant realises that he is better off as he is than he would be if he purchased the cottage. Members of local bodies in this House, Ministers and ex-Ministers and everybody else, who pretend that we can induce the wholesale purchase by the tenants of these cottages by sections in Housing Bills, know quite well that we might as well be idle. Except in a few cases in a few counties where people have purchased, the whole campaign has been against purchase for the reasons I have stated. Local bodies know the solution to that problem, if they want to take it.

Comment on this

They have taken it in some cases.

Comment on this

In all cases they know it and, having regard to the housing difficulties of various sections of the community, I often thought they were entitled to take a far more keen interest in this matter than simply to ask would the engineering repairs or the engineering inspection be fair, and so on. I agree that when the cottage is repaired for vesting there is something in giving the tenant the right of appeal in the event of his being dissatisfied with any of the work that is undertaken, but it is a dangerous thing. If the officials of the local body, the county engineer, the assistant engineer, who might be charged with making an inspection, make a report on the condition of a cottage and supervise the carrying out of the work they thought was necessary in order to put it in shape, having regard to the conditions that are laid down in the 1936 Act, I cannot see, since they are officials paid from the rates, that any of them would just set out to do the tenant an injustice in that regard.

Just on the off-chance that an injustice might be done, we are providing for an appeal that can be very cumbersome and very costly from many points of view. There are counties where cottage repairs are carried out by direct labour. Direct labour repairs can be a very cumbersome method of dealing with this problem. Let us suppose that the council decides to have 50 or 60 cottages repaired. I cannot speak of my own county because we have not got that system, but in County Meath they have and the council would propose sending down a direct labour squad to repair, let us say, 60 cottages in a particular area for the purpose of vesting. That squad will go into a house and complete the job there. When they have completed their work, they take away all the materials and go into another district. The Minister's representative gets a letter from the tenant of the cottage and he goes down to inspect it, and who is it who could not find some little flaw even in a new house and say: "There is something that should have been attended to?" Therefore, not only have you the cost of the engineering inspection but the cost of the squad coming back, with all the necessary materials, to deal with the complaint.

Theoretically, I know this amendment seems fair. It appears to provide justice, to provide what is regarded as a court of appeal, but my contention is that while you can justify an expensive court of appeal as between two citizens, or as between two groups of citizens, it is a different thing when you are providing an expensive court of appeal as between a local body and one of those ratepayers. In that case I would not suspect there would be any temptation to steal a march on the tenant by underestimating the amount of work required or scamping the work when it was in progress. The amendment may look all right in theory but I do not think it will help to solve the problem, and while it does appear to give a right to a tenant which he had not previously, it will give it to him at great expense to all concerned.

Comment on this

I welcome this section because it is the only opportunity the individual tenant will have of getting justice. I represent a county in which possibly more money is spent on cottage repairs than in many other counties. We have the position in County Dublin that a good deal of money has been spent on cottage repairs. In fairness to the local authority, to the ratepayers and to the tenants a number of those cottages should have been pulled down altogether instead of being repaired. During the last few months, Dublin County Council has raised the rents of these cottages. The tenants have, of course, been told that, when the cottages are repaired, they can purchase them at 50 per cent. of the old rent. I am in the position that a number of people have been coming to me and saying that the local engineer went out and only half repaired the cottages.

Comment on this

I know that has happened in more places than in County Dublin.

Comment on this

I was in one house recently in Bellview, Tolka Park. If one wanted to ensure that somebody would develop T.B., I would say that would be the house into which to put him. The doors and windows were repaired, but the floor is seeping with water. Yet, it was said the cottage was repaired. Suppose that tenant did not have the right of appeal to the Minister, where would he be?

A number of these cottages were built 50 and 60 years ago, without any supervision, and they are not fit for human habitation to-day. Dublin County Council can spend only a certain amount of money on them. Candidly, it would be a thousand times better if money were made available to pull them down rather than spend money trying to repair them. I welcome this section because it affords some protection to the individual.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider giving the benefits of this section before repairs are carried out rather than after? As Deputy J. Brennan has suggested, the county council decides on the repairs; they list the repairs and notify the tenant.

Comment on this

That is what they are supposed to do.

Comment on this

Allow me to continue. They notify the tenant that this list of repairs will be carried out before a certain date, and, if he is not satisfied with the list, he has the right of appeal to the Minister — a right of appeal which he has not got now.

Comment on this

I would not agree to that at all.

Comment on this

I would suggest that one change in the existing system. When the list of repairs is notified the tenant should have the right of appeal before the repairs are undertaken rather than afterwards. The position would be the same as heretofore except that the tenant would have the benefit of this section. The other situation is not workable and will inevitably, if it is left, involve very heavy expense.

Comment on this

It is the method of doing the repairs that is often the cause of the appeal. I will give the Deputy an example. Down in Carrick, in Deputy Brennan's constituency, I know an unfortunate tenant there who had repairs carried out to his cottage every few years. On one occasion he notified the county council that he was anxious to have the cottage vested. The repairs were done in the ordinary way and, when they were done, a certain gentleman presented the tenant with a document and asked him to sign it. The tenant signed. Now he was not satisfied with the manner in which the repairs had been carried out. I personally had an opportunity of examining them and I say it was malfeasance on the part of the person who carried them out. Nevertheless, because the cottage had been vested in the meantime, the tenant had absolutely no redress.

I am in agreement with Deputy Brennan and Deputy Smith. I am surprised that Deputy Cunningham should suggest that the county council spend too much money on these repairs. The Deputy thinks the cottage should be repaired and that should end it. That was his original suggestion despite the fact that State grants and supplementary county council grants are being made available to the farmer to have his house repaired. A short time ago Deputy Cunningham advocated that tenants should not pay any rates at all on these repairs. In other words, the tenant who becomes master of his own house will be expected to do all his own repairs, pay his rent and pay his rates. I am surprised at Deputy Cunningham. I am surprised that he does not think more of the people in his constituency who are tenants of labourers' cottages. They are as much entitled to consideration as the big farmers in his constituency. I am astonished that he does not think of them.

Comment on this

Was it necessary for the tenant to sign the vesting order under the 1926 Act?

Comment on this

No. The local authority made a vesting order.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister made a statement that a tenant was presented——

Comment on this

It was an application for vesting which was presented to him, and then the county council made the vesting order.

Comment on this

When a tenant applies for vesting, a scheme is prepared by the county council and the repairs are carried out.

Comment on this

Very often, after they do the annual or biennial repairs, they ask the tenant to sign a vesting application order.

Comment on this

Were they obliged by law to do that?

Comment on this

They were obliged by law to explain to the tenant what the implication of the document was.

Comment on this

Are they obliged by law now? Suppose a tenant applies now to have his cottage vested under this amendment——

Comment on this

They must notify the tenant now when they vest.

Comment on this

That is not exactly what I am coming at. Is it a fact that vesting will now take place on the tenant's application without any further approach to him; they carry out certain repairs, then vest and tell the tenant they have vested the cottage in him?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

That is a change as compared with the previous procedure.

Comment on this

Oh, no. The position was that, once they notified him they had vested the cottage, no further repairs could be carried out. The same procedure will be followed now up to the date on which they notify the tenant of vesting and from the date of notification of vesting——

Comment on this

The Minister is not getting the point. Perhaps if the Minister would allow me to finish we would not waste time. I want to know what the position will be now. Suppose I am the tenant of a labourer's cottage: I write to the county council and say I am anxious to purchase. The procedure is now that they inspect, estimate what work has to be done, carry out the repairs and then ask me to sign. Is that not so? You must sign.

Comment on this

Sometimes they will treat your application——

Comment on this

You must not sign.

Comment on this

Sometimes they treat the original application as an application for vesting.

Comment on this

They are obliged to ask the tenant to sign for vesting before the vesting order is made. Is it the position now that, irrespective of what the practice or the law was hitherto, when the tenant makes an application to the local authority and says he wishes to purchase his cottage, that is the last he will hear of it until he is notified that the cottage is vested in him?

Comment on this

There will be an inspection carried out.

Comment on this

I know, but the tenant will really hear no more until he is told that vesting has taken place and that the right of appeal exists as from a certain date. Is that not so?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

From the Minister's statement, it would appear now that there is no hope for those who are already vested.

Comment on this

In the past?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Oh, no. We cannot make it retrospective.

Comment on this

Even though some clever people——

Comment on this

Of course, they can apply for reconstruction and improvement grants.

Comment on this

That was the point I was about to make. Would the Minister's Department at least consider them?

Comment on this