We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956—Committee Stage (Resumed) and Final Stages.

Contributions 141–282 of 282. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956
Enacted

No. 16 of 1956 ›

Of course.

Comment on this

I do not want to hold up the Minister. This man was vested. The county council proceeded to carry out repairs, but they were not properly carried out due to bad weather and other factors and it is now admitted by everybody that the repairs were not carried out satisfactorily. The engineer reports that an extra £20 would make a good job of it.

Comment on this

Nothing can be done about it.

Comment on this

We have about a dozen cases of that kind in the county. Would the Minister's Department at least arrange that those cases would be met?

Comment on this

If he applies for an improvement grant, each application will be considered on its merits.

Comment on this

That is the only thing that can be done, as far as I can see.

Comment on this

The Minister has the happy knack of bringing trouble upon himself and prolonging the debate. He went to quite a bit of trouble to misconstrue some statements I made. I was not trying to save money on house repairs. I agree that people should have their houses put into a proper state of repair before becoming owners, after having paid rent for so long. That can be done without all the expense that the bringing of an engineer from Dublin would involve.

Comment on this

Why is it not done?

Comment on this

Because the suggestion I made earlier has not been adopted.

Comment on this

That should be made to the local authority and not here. You have that power at the moment.

Comment on this

Even existing regulations are not clear. They should be clarified. I am trying to save waste — not the expenditure of money on house repairs.

Comment on this

Advocate that at county council level, not here.

Comment on this

This is where housing legislation is being enacted——

Comment on this

But not administered.

Comment on this

I can see waste of engineers' car expenses, and so on. I agree wholeheartedly with Deputy Smith who says it may be necessary to bring a squad of workmen back from one area to re-cover an area which was done before. If the method I suggested were adopted, everyone would be clear on what repairs were to be carried out. The Minister's loophole in that regard was to the effect that the contractor did not do his job properly. As the Minister says, there are ways and means of dealing with that situation. If a contractor goes into a housing scheme or into a rural area where there are a number of cottages and carries out repairs, our quarrel is not with the repairs but with the manner and method of carrying them out. Why should the Minister bring in all this cumbersome machinery to deal with a contractor who did not do the work properly? Is there not machinery there already?

Comment on this

Of course there is. I am only changing the dates in relation to which the appeal may be brought.

Comment on this

I suggest that all the money that will be wasted under the provisions of this section should be spent on house repairs.

Comment on this

I think this is a very good section. One of the reasons I welcome it is because I think the Minister has agreed that there are people who deserve houses but cannot get them because they did not qualify as agricultural labourers. There are various classes that found it very difficult to qualify. I should like to take the largest section first of all, that is, the women. Suppose a woman is a widow. Her ordinary work is to look after her family and her house by cooking, washing, and so on. Because she was engaged in those occupations, she was not qualified as an agricultural labourer. However, a bus conductor — who, to my mind, has very little connection with agriculture — could qualify although the job of a woman who was cooking the produce of agriculture was not regarded either as a trade or a handicraft for the purposes of being qualified as an agricultural labourer.

Old age pensioners could not be qualified because, I understand, they were no longer working or, if they worked, they could not be insured and, therefore, they would not qualify but they also might need houses.

Another very deserving class of people are the blind pensioners. A man might become blind when young. In fact, by the time he reached 30 years of age he might be getting the blind pension. He might be married with a family. Because he could not work, he could not qualify as an agricultural labourer and could not get a house. His wife could not qualify and his daughters could not qualify either because if they went and helped a neighbour to wash and clean the house that is counted as domestic service and is ruled out specifically under the definition. These people quite often need houses and it is found very difficult to qualify them for houses.

I think this section recognises that there are these people and, though I had an amendment down which I am not allowed to move, I hope the Minister will read it and——

Comment on this

I have.

Comment on this

——take note of it because, though it comes in under this section, it is dealing with another class of person. I welcome this section. I hope it will mean that the Minister will consider the whole question of applicants for cottages.

Comment on this

I certainly will.

Comment on this

Does this apply to a letting originally made by the manager and subsequently referred to the council for a decision as to the eligibility of the tenant? It says here that the council of a county by whom a cottage is let under this section may declare that the person to whom the cottage is let is a qualified person. How did the person become a tenant originally if, in fact, he was not a qualified person? I have not before me the relevant sections of the 1950 Act.

Comment on this

He had to be a tenant of the cottage before the local authority could vest it.

Comment on this

It is just a case of deciding definitely that he is a fully qualified tenant before the vesting operation can take place?

Comment on this

For vesting. He could have been a tenant but he would not be qualified for vesting under the old Act.

Comment on this

But he is under this?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

He is not a person who is qualified to be a tenant of a county council house——

Comment on this

Take a soldier, for example. He could have been a tenant of a local authority house but was not qualified for vesting.

Comment on this

——on paragraph (b) which says:—

"the making of a declaration under this sub-section shall be a reserved function,"

while I welcome such fresh devolution of authority on the elected representatives, it seems strange to me that a completely minor matter of this sort should be made a matter for the councils, when so many matters of greater importance are taken out of their hands. Would it not be better not to bother the elected authority with minor declarations of this sort and leave it to the managers to do it?

Comment on this

I should say that they would know the facts much better than the county managers. They can act on the suggestion of the county manager, if they wish.

Comment on this

That would be a more desirable way of dealing with it. It would make for a more efficient and expeditious working of the local authority. If the manager made a decision in the matter which was followed by the local authority, it would obviate the necessity of bringing a large number of these applications for discussion by the elected authority. Such a procedure might introduce lack of uniformity into their decisions. That is the only danger I would see of having a full-dress discussion on all these applications. The county manager, if he drew up a rule about them, would have brought about some sort of uniformity.

Comment on this

It should be possible for the elected members to decide on a certain class and then leave it to the manager to deal with the individual applications.

Comment on this

On the point about the classes of people who would qualify for a cottage, I should mention to the Minister that in County Kerry we seem to have a different interpretation in regard to applicants. One instance I will mention is that in which a widow applies for the tenancy of a cottage of which her deceased husband was the tenant. She will qualify for the tenancy, but a widow who applies for a new cottage is not regarded as qualifying. I understand that in most other counties widows are regarded as being eligible for the tenancy of cottages. This question of uniformity which has been referred to by Deputy Bartley should be considered by the Department and by the county managers. It seems very peculiar that each county manager can put a different interpretation on this matter.

Comment on this

The matter will be in the hands of the members of the councils now.

Comment on this

It is about time that something was done about it. There is another point I should like to bring to the notice of the Minister. In Section 35 of the 1948 Act, the question of priorities is referred to. At one time, applicants afflicted with T.B. received a preference, but now I understand they are being graded down.

Comment on this

This section does not deal with lettings; it deals only with vestings.

Comment on this

I am talking of the types of people concerned. Irrespective of this section, I should like the Minister to take a note of what I have said with regard to T.B. patients.

Comment on this

I will see that a note is taken of it.

Comment on this

The local authority in Kerry at present has a list of people recommended by the doctor for houses. We had two from the one household and the county manager told us that there was no preferential treatment for T.B. persons. I understand that there was a preference at one time and why that preference should not be renewed is a matter I cannot understand.

Comment on this

This section raises a number of points on which I am not quite clear. I was surprised to hear the Minister say that this section widens the scope for vesting and not for letting.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

That does seem peculiar to the ordinary person — that persons must be of a certain type to qualify for a cottage, in the first instance, and then widening the scope for vesting so that any person who becomes a vested owner of a cottage must be a tenant of that cottage or already is a tenant of it.

Comment on this

It has to be that way. That is essential. I am sure that no one will come in and buy a cottage over the head of the tenant.

Comment on this

This section is probably brought in to clear up the legal difficulty which arises when the vested owner of a cottage was a qualified person, but where, after his death, the person resident in the cottage is not a qualified person. There is a major difficulty there. I understand that a case has been decided in the courts where the local authority found it difficult to eject a person who occupied a cottage after the death of the previous owner. The decision went against the local authority. I think this section is possibly brought in to cover up that——

Comment on this

The Deputy should read the section.

Comment on this

——and to allow the local authority a wider scope so that they can vest a cottage in a person who heretofore was not qualified. I know that local authorities are very hesitant to take proceedings where a cottage has come into the hands of a person who is not qualified under the regulations. It is a pity that the Minister did not go further with regard to the letting of cottages to that class of agricultural worker who earns £5 or £6 a week.

Comment on this

I welcome this section which gives an opportunity in County Dublin to a number of people housed under the Working Classes Act to purchase their cottages. I had a number of such cases in the County Dublin and this section enables soldiers and others to purchase their cottages from the Dublin County Council.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

To add to the section the following new sub-sections:—

(2) In a case in which, by virtue of this section, a confirmation to which Section 17 of the Housing (Financial and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1931 (No. 50 of 1931), relates is effected in two or more stages, that section shall have effect as if—

(a) sub-section (2) required publication and service of notice, in relation to each such stage, stating that the Order has been confirmed in so far as it related to the land to which that stage related,

(b) sub-section (3) applied in relation to each such publication of notice, and

(c) sub-section (4) provided that the Order shall, as respects the land to which any such stage related, become operative at the expiration of six weeks from the date on which notice relating to that stage is published.

(3) In a case in which, by virtue of this section, a first or second confirmation within the meaning of Section 43 of the Act of 1948 is effected in two or more stages, that section shall have effect as if—

(a) sub-section (3) or sub-section (4) (as may be appropriate) required publication of notice, in relation to each such stage, stating that the Order has been conferred in so far as it related to the land to which that stage related,

(b) sub-section (6) provided that the Order shall, as respects the land to which any such stage related, become operative at the expiration of three weeks from the date on which notice relating to that stage is published, and

(c) in the case of a second confirmation, sub-section (5) applied in relation to each such stage as if that stage were the second confirmation.

I indicated on the Second Reading that a further amendment to Section 17 might be found necessary for administrative reasons. In the sub-section it is proposed to deal with administrative procedure and to apply the same administrative procedure to each separate confirmation as if it was a separate confirmation. That has been brought in to meet the wishes on all sides of the House.

Comment on this

I had intended to make reference to Section 16 but I suppose I am too late now.

Comment on this

The Minister was not too lucid in his explanation of the amendment. I think he could have told us a little more about it.

Comment on this

The whole matter was fully discussed on the Second Reading and this is merely bringing in an amendment to apply the same administrative procedure to each separate confirmation. The purpose is to enable confirmation to be given for each section of the acquisition as if it were a separate transaction. The parliamentary draftsmen examined this section and the new sub-section has been drafted to meet the position. It proposes to apply the same administrative procedure to each stage of the acquisition as if that stage was a separate confirmation itself. Deputies will appreciate that in a compulsory purchase prior to this it was necessary to wait for a complete decision before making a comprehensive Order. It was not possible to make a separate Order for each portion of the land being acquired.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister would that enable local authorities to go ahead with small groups without having to wait for a bigger scheme?

Comment on this

That is what it will do.

Comment on this

That is very desirable.

Comment on this

Would the Minister clarify that section in so far as there is a substitution of 95 per cent. for 90 per cent.? Is that the maximum amount that will be available or what exactly does this section mean?

Comment on this

Section 34 of the 1950 Act required a person purchasing or building a house with the aid of finance under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act to contribute from his own resources at least 5 per cent. of the market value of the house exclusive of any grant under any enactment. That is 5 per cent. of the market value. Section 4 of the Act limits the amount to 90 per cent. of the market value. The maximum amount is £1,800 in Dublin City and County and Dún Laoghaire and Cork Boroughs. The section does not involve higher rates of finance and the local authority will have to have regard to the payments of grants and the market value of the house.

Comment on this

What is the purpose of the section?

Comment on this

It is purely administrative.

Comment on this

This is a section which I do not quite understand. Does it mean that in future that without consultation with the Minister any local authority in the State can fix any rate of interest for any period of 35 years or for any period at all?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If they so wish?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That could have very far-reaching results.

Comment on this

This has been inserted at the request of the local authorities.

Comment on this

I would again draw attention to the complete absence of the Labour Party during the debate this morning. We are now at the end of the debate on the Housing Act for 1956 and there has not been one member of the Labour Party in the House.

Comment on this

Does this section mean that in a case where a person applies for a grant and the grant is forthcoming from, say, a building society, or part of it is forthcoming and only part of it, the local authority may have to guarantee the other part of the loan from the Local Loans Fund? Say there is an interest of 7 per cent. on the first part of the loan by the building society, does this mean that the part of the loan given from the Local Loans Fund will carry the same rate of interest?

Comment on this

The local authority has nothing whatever to do with the rate of interest on the money got from the building society. Under the 1948 Act, the local authority can only lend at a rate not more than ½ per cent. above the current rate. This is to remove that restriction of ½ per cent.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

On account of the overdraft in the bank, and to enable them to discharge the interest on their overdraft.

Comment on this

That seems to give them a great deal of scope.

Comment on this

I do not think they will use it without discretion.

Comment on this

We have not trusted them on other matters and why trust them on this one?

Comment on this

The more we can trust them the better.

Comment on this

I agree with that but it is hard to reconcile the two points of view. We are prepared to trust them in one case but not in the other.

Comment on this

There will be a hell of a row if they abuse this section.

Comment on this

I can see no limit in this matter.

Comment on this

The limit is the members of the local authority themselves.

Comment on this

We have been fortunate in Donegal when turned down by the Local Loans Fund, in getting a loan or the promise of a loan, subject to the Minister's sanction, from a local bank and the rate is 4¾ per cent. We were happy that despite the increases in interest which have taken place that money was being lent to the Donegal County Council by a local bank.

Comment on this

I would like to correct the Deputy. Donegal County Council has not been refused admission to the Local Loans Fund.

Comment on this

They were told to go elsewhere.

Comment on this

They went elsewhere.

Comment on this

We know they have gone elsewhere and they got £55,000 at 4¾ per cent. which is very low in view of present day money prices.

Comment on this

Over what period?

Comment on this

For a period of 20 years.

Comment on this

As against 35?

Comment on this

It suits us well enough, I think, but they have been fortunate and I suppose the good name of Donegal County Council has helped a good deal in that but we were then hoping that borrowers in the case of housing loans would get this money at 5 per cent. or 5¼ per cent.

Comment on this

They can if you wish to give it to them.

Comment on this

Is it left to the members of the council or is it left to the manager?

Comment on this

Borrowing is a reserved function of the members of the council.

Comment on this

Of the members of the council?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

So that we can decide, irrespective of anything contained in the section, to issue the money at 5¼ per cent.?

Comment on this

You can issue it at whatever figure you like. I am removing the restriction of ½ per cent.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister's statement on this matter because it will help people for whom I have been fighting in this House.

Comment on this

Will it?

Comment on this

The Minister is allowing the Dublin County Council, according to his statement here, to give loans to the people at the old rate of interest.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

According to his statement here.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Is that what the Minister meant by that statement?

Comment on this

There is plain English, now.

Comment on this

The Deputy may withdraw his welcome.

Comment on this

In other words——

Comment on this

The sky is the limit.

Comment on this

I thought I might get something done for these people under Section 19.

Comment on this

They will be worse off now.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister might do something for these people—builders and applicants in County Dublin—under Section 19. Will the Minister now say that these people who are caught and who made application in good faith prior to the 10th March, 1956, will be covered? Will he amend the section on Report Stage to give an opportunity of clearing themselves to the people who have already made application for loans and who have been refused loans now owing to the changed conditions and who are in a very bad way? It will not cost the country very much to take them out of the predicament in which they are.

Comment on this

Is there not some substance in the point raised by Deputy Burke? The Minister has not indicated the full implications. Is it not a fact that a local authority may propose to lend money at any interest rate they wish for a certain period but the catch is that if they lend it at a lesser rate of interest than the rate at which they borrow from the Local Loans Fund or some other source the onus is on them to find the difference in some way, which is evidently from the rates.

Comment on this

It is, of course. Would not it be very bad economics to lend at a lesser rate than the rate at which you can borrow?

Comment on this

Not always.

Comment on this

Not when you are maintaining your honour, your contracts and your obligations.

Comment on this

This could have far-reaching results. The local authority might say: "The administration of the supplementary grant of £137 10s., or whatever it may be, costs us—not a lot—but such and such an amount. Now, instead of giving a supplementary grant to people in our local authority area, we will scrap the supplementary grant in future but we will lend money under the Small Dwellings Acts loans at a lesser rate, in other words, at a corresponding rate, which would save the local authority finding the £137 10s. and that will be made up to the borrower over 35 years by a lesser rate of interest." That is the point I am driving at.

Comment on this

Does it work up and down?

Comment on this

This section means that the Minister no longer wishes to be consulted and it is desperately important, in my opinion. The point raised by Deputy Burke is only one of the items.

Comment on this

He never had to be consulted as long as that maximum of ½ per cent. remained.

Comment on this

The ½ per cent. was purely optional and permissive.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It said that the local authority may charge not more than ½ per cent. over the rate at which they borrowed, for administrative charges. For instance, in the case mentioned by Deputy Burke, the Limerick Corporation decided to lend the money at the rate at which they borrowed from the Local Loans Fund and added nothing for administrative charges. I want to put this point: Under the Housing (Amendment) Bill, 1956, is it not a fact that if Deputy Burke or any other Deputy or any local authority wishes to-morrow morning to cater for those who had entered into commitments before the 10th March, the local authority, whatever it costs them, can lend the money to those people?

Comment on this

That is quite true.

Comment on this

At whatever rate they wish.

Comment on this

That is quite true.

Comment on this

That is the most important point.

Comment on this

That is what I wanted.

Comment on this

That is quite true.

Comment on this

On this question of interest, do I take it that Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act loans will now be available to a very limited class of applicants and that the people referred to by the Minister as the richer classes will now be out? Take the case of those who must go to the building societies. Would the Minister say whether those applicants will be entitled to get portion of their requirements from the local loans and will have to go to the building societies for the balance?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

They will have to go to the building societies for the whole amount?

Comment on this

One or the other.

Comment on this

I do not know what experience the Minister has of the operations of building societies in provincial towns but, so far as I can gather, these building societies are not prepared to give a loan to an applicant outside fairly large towns.

Comment on this

We are now dealing with Section 19. It would not arise on Section 19.

Comment on this

Is it not a question of the rate of interest?

Comment on this

No, no. This is under the Small Dwellings Acts.

Comment on this

Are not we discussing Section 19?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

The rate of interest and advances under Section 1 of the Act of 1899.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

This is a class of people who are being excluded from the benefit of loans from the Local Loans Fund and, therefore, they are compelled to go to building societies. That takes me to the experience that we have of the operations of building societies outside of Dublin. So far as I know, they are not prepared to make loans to people outside the larger towns, the reason, presumably, being that in case of their having to foreclose, the sale-ability of the houses is in question outside the larger towns. It seems to me that the throwing over of the provision of these loans to building societies will greatly restrict the number who now qualify for such loans. The freedom to fix the rate of interest will, because of these special difficulties, mean, possibly, the fixing of what will be tantamount to a penal rate of interest in a good many cases.

Comment on this

I would appeal to the Minister in regard to the point I made on Second Reading about the tenants of cottages in County Kerry who purchased under the previous legislation and whose rents were fixed at 75 per cent. of the original rent. The local authority in Kerry made representations to the Minister and the Department to have uniformity. The Minister might have all of them enjoying, if possible, the reduction of 50 per cent. of the original rent.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That point does not arise on the Schedule. The Schedule is the only matter before the House.

Comment on this

The matter was discussed by me on the Second Reading. Perhaps at a later stage the Minister might reconsider this matter.

Comment on this

There were, as those of us who took part in this discussion know, only two matters which resulted in keeping us here much longer than we thought on these stages of the measure. One of them was the amendment proposed in respect of Section 10 and the other was Section 9 of the measure now about to become law. In spite of our efforts here yesterday, I still do not know why the Minister so abruptly came in to this House with a proposal to amend Section 10 without having some regard to Section 9. The Minister has not given this as a reason but I suspect this is what he had at the back of his mind.

In our discussion on Section 9 we were not able to get much assistance from the Minister as to the circumstances of an applicant who would be likely to be successful in an application under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. According to the Minister, he could not be a rich person. Then we got to the stage that he had to be a person of modest means. Then we got to the stage that a person of modest means was not a national school-teacher. Then we got to the stage at which we were when we started when nobody knew, nor yet knows, what type of person was involved or in what circumstances an applicant must be in order successfully to make an application for a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts.

I was listening to Deputy Larkin last night and he gave me a clue as to what was in the Minister's mind. The Dublin Corporation were given money to finance activities under these Acts with the stipulation that only those who would qualify for supplementary grants were to secure advances. From the stipulation which was attached to the £1,000,000 advanced from the Local Loans Fund to the Dublin Corporation, that only those who had received supplementary grants from that body could get these loans, I assume that the Minister amended Section 10 so as to keep, in spite of the change of circumstances, the same groups within the different categories so that every local body in the country would ultimately be pinned down to giving small dwelling loans only on the basis of persons who would qualify for these supplementary grants.

If that is what the Minister had at the back of his mind, as I suspect, one would have expected that in the course of all this discussion we would have got from him a clear statement to that effect. Instead of that, we have been moving about and switching from one foot to another. If an assurance given by the Minister, on the advice of his technicians, was found to be a wee bit generous or extravagant, then the Minister proceeded to mend his hand. The result of it all is that we are still in the dark in spite of all the time we spent in discussion here.

If it is the Minister's intention to rule out from participation in the small dwelling loans all those who are outside the valuation limits or wage-earning capacities, as set out in Sections 9 and 10, and if the rest of the people who want to build houses are to be thrown over to the building societies, we know what the Minister's idea of "modest means" is.

Heretofore, local bodies were sceptical about giving these loans except in cases where it was clear that the recipient was in a position to repay. Now apparently the Minister and the Department have at the back of their minds a ceiling which they have not openly revealed and all those who would be outside that would have to approach the building societies and insurance societies.

Deputy Finlay, a young barrister, was, on Second Reading, full of enthusiasm, and so was Deputy Esmonde, for the manner in which all these new moneys were to be released to the private builder. These societies in the past usually made whatever funds they had surplus to their acquirements available to the Minister for Finance in his public issues from time to time. These moneys were always available in one form or another. Yet we listened to efforts being made by some Deputies who had not the faintest idea of what is involved in this housing proposal. They paraded themselves one after another to justify a course of action that could only have a disastrous effect on private building.

What does the guarantee in Section 9 of the Bill mean? It means that the insurance companies or the building societies will have the right to vet the applicants, in the first instance. They will have to approve of the giving of advances to applicants, and if they decide that the applicant is not a person to whom they would give money, this question of the guarantee does not arise at all. Just imagine that we are reduced to the position in which an applicant applies for a loan to a building society or an insurance company and these institutions have a policy under which they give only 80 per cent. of the market value of the house. That fact might prevent certain applicants from taking advantage of these loans because they would not have the other 20 per cent. to put down in order to acquire a house.

We are actually coming forward in that case where the societies must first approve of the individual — and, mark you, he will have to be a very credit-worthy individual before they will approve him — and if they do not approve, this guarantee mentioned in Section 9 is not worth a jot. But when they approve of the applicant, this section provides that the applicant's local authority may give to the insurance company or building society a guarantee — the security of the rates — for the repayment of the additional 15 per cent. the applicant would get if the money had been made available to him under the Small Dwellings Acts, in order that the company concerned will have no doubt that everything is in order.

Then the State says to the local body: "You have underwritten this 15 per cent. for applicant A; we will now underwrite you to the extent of 7½ per cent. of that 15 per cent." Just imagine that the local body has to go to all these rounds to underwrite an applicant who has already been approved by the lending organisation and to whom the company or society would give 80 per cent. of the estimated value of the house. Yet the credit-worthiness of the local authority and the State is at such a high level now that the two of them will have to sign on the dotted line before the society will give the additional 15 per cent.! God knows it is terrible to be here and to have had to listen to and look at the things that have been going on in this place for the past few years!

Comment on this