Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–151 of 302. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When I moved to report progress here on Thursday evening, I was endeavouring to make the case that a withdrawal of subsidies should be through a series of gradual minor reductions over as long a period as possible, to avoid too serious an impact on the incomes of the people and further to avoid endangering our stability in this country.
It would look clear that the Minister availed himself of the opportunity to get most of the revenue from one source. I am doubtful if he could justify his case on that, when he has not looked further afield and sought avenues or sources of revenue in these difficult times. He could have sought other avenues—such as cosmetics, pictures and amusements of all kinds. Everyone realises that we are spending far too much on all sorts of pleasure and amusement. In the national interest and in the interest of those people who so spend, I think it would be wise to put some check on that trend.
Very derisive comments were made here about Prize Bonds and I should like the Minister, in his reply to this debate, to say whether he intends to continue the Prize Bonds Scheme. Considering that it has been such a relief to the Exchequer, it would be disastrous if the statements such as we heard here last Wednesday evening were to jeopardise the prospects of the new Prize Bonds Scheme. The Minister for Education, when speaking here, said that the Prize Bonds Scheme had shown a distinct improvement since there was a change of Government. Personally, I do not believe the change of Government had anything whatever to do with the added interest in the Prize Bonds. I believe that the attraction was that the money invested in the bonds could be redeemed at par at any time, that it was a novel venture in this country and that it had the element of gambling about it. These were the factors which contributed to its success. At all events, the former Minister must be complimented on his initiative in putting the Prize Bonds Scheme into operation, considering the advantage it will be to the present Minister for Finance and to future Ministers.
The £250,000 made available to provide further markets for our increased exports is a thing we all welcome. It is not easy to find such markets and it would be well if the Minister would, in his reply, give us some idea of the efforts which will be made to secure those markets abroad. It is vital that we go after them at once. I was speaking recently to a gentleman who spent a month in England last year— an Irishman, of course—and to my surprise he told me he was not able to get Irish beef in several towns he had visited in Great Britain. It would look as if we have failed in our distribution methods. We should go after those markets and push our wares into every conceivable part of Great Britain. That is a major problem requiring the best expert advice and the most vigorous efforts.
The same thing applies to eggs in Great Britain. I was talking recently to a lady doctor who spent four years in practice in Great Britain and never used an Irish egg, simply because those she had seen cooked were unusable because of their staleness. I do not know what the remedy is, but I believe our co-operative societies should arrange a weekly collection of eggs so that they would be dispatched at the point of export in the freshest possible form.
I welcome the assurance from the Minister about the economies he intends to effect. He has mentioned the Irish News Agency. I am at one with him in that. I believe it is too costly for us to maintain it at its present standard. I believe we can get all the publicity we need through An Bord Fáilte and, now that we have been admitted as a member to the United Nations, that gives us a forum for explaining the position of our country here and for advocating the integration of our territory.
I should like to go further afield and see whether the School for Advanced Studies would afford us any great scope for economy. Its existence is almost paradoxical, when we have our own National University, which should be in charge of all forms of higher education. The School for Advanced Studies should be incorporated in the National University, where there is greater scope for research and for advanced studies of all kinds.
The Army is another Department of State which calls for a drastic reduction. Armies as at present constituted are about to become obsolete and eventually they will be replaced by armies of technicians. Here we have to maintain the Army at its present strength, or at least at its present cost, and I do not see how our circumstances can afford that.
This House itself calls for greater economy. It is an extraordinary thing that here in this little island, with 2,750,000 people in this part of the country, we have 207 people legislating for us. It seems to be out of relation to our economic standards here to maintain an institution up to that number. We have a Seanad of 60 members which has very little function, if any at all. Because of its restricted function, I hope this Minister will think it wise not to maintain that Second House in its present form, without giving it some more useful functions, at all events.
We have almost 30 Deputies representing Dublin City. In this impoverished island, is there any realism in that state of affairs? Any Dublin Deputy, if he lives in his constituency can go to any part of his constituency by a fourpenny bus trip at any time and it looks altogether unrealistic to try to maintain that set-up at the present time.
The Minister has mentioned the Civil Service, to which he is going to apply the axe and stop recruitment right away. Ironically enough, I saw in one of the daily papers last week that the Civil Service Commissioners were seeking extra staff. I want to be clear in my references to the Civil Service and say at once that it is a magnificent service, 100 per cent. dependable and 100 per cent. incorruptible. It is the greatest buffer we have here in protecting and guaranteeing the security of the State. However, it is costly in its administration—there is no question about that. When a Civil Service costs £17,000,000 in this small island, there must be room somewhere for reduction. Personally, if I may venture an opinion, I think the service is over-sectionalised, each section dealing with a particular phase of its respective Department. These sections should be co-ordinated, thereby cutting out the possibilities for redundancies in promotions and in staff. That can only be done effectively through the goodwill of the service itself and by beginning at the bottom, that is, at the recruitment stage.
It is a rather staggering fact that we have to face a bill of £160,000,000 this year in making provision for this State.
In the past, volumes were written about the iniquity of Great Britain in imposing £2,000,000 a year taxation on this country through the Act of Union, but when we compare that £2,000,000 with the £160,000,000 we are now asked to provide for the various services and the maintenance of public works, it gives food for reflection.
I remember speaking recently to a gentleman in Cork who was a great friend of the late General Michael Collins. Michael Collins said to him away back in 1922 that in getting control of our affairs we would be very lucky to have fiscal control here, that as far as he could see the Irish people would not have to be asked for a shilling towards the maintenance of the State. If Michael Collins were alive to-day, or if some of our other dead patriots were alive, how disillusioned they would be at the existing situation. There must be many in this House who are disillusioned at the trend of events with this seemingly uncontrollable expenditure mounting up year after year.
It would be interesting if we had a graph representation of our expenditure and revenue side by side. There we would see that, year after year, revenue is chasing after expenditure. When will there be an effective check on that trend? We are exhorted here from time to time to have faith. The Irish people are told they should have confidence in public administration. It is a credit to the Irish people that they have had confidence over the past 35 years, but that confidence has come to breaking point when efforts to bring the administration of this State more into relation with our expenditure have been unsuccessful. High taxation to-day seems to me to be the cumulative result of misspending over the years. We follow slavishly the patterns in other countries, and Irish genius and initiative, which have been asserted many times in the history of this country, have never asserted themselves to the maximum in the Parliament of the nation.
A good deal of talk has been made about the great gap this year between revenue and expenditure, but that gap is not so formidable when we realise that almost every local authority depends for a great part of the year on borrowing from the banks. I do not say it is a wise thing; in fact it is a tendency that should be checked. Whether they take their pattern from this House, I do not know, but this over-spending has left us without the capital for productive works.
Deputy Murphy mentioned a very important matter last week. He said that for men in rural areas the average rate of unemployment assistance would be about £3 a week. He advocated—I think a very wise and constructive point on his part—that instead of giving these men £3 a week for being idle, work should be provided for them and that, as well as receiving their unemployment money, they should get an additional payment out of some local fund to bring their standard wage up to £5 a week. In that way we would be making some progress and creating activity in certain parts of the country. There are local men prepared to come together and put up a sum, provided the State does its part in putting up at least a similar sum in order to carry out some utility works. Take, for instance, all the derelict sites we see, and very objectionable they are. We are anxious to invite tourists here and, travelling up and down the country, they must be horrified at what they see. These derelict sites could be cleared and some sort of attractive wall built around them, if there were more elasticity between the Department providing this unemployment money and some of the local people with initiative.
The Taoiseach last week spoke about unity in the House. I believe there is a unity of purpose here, that purpose being the full development of our resources, the provision of full employment for our people and the checking of emigration. These are the problems about which we are worried at the moment. We could have greater unity if we had less of a political slant in our debates and if we were more objective in our contributions. This House should be a source of inspiration to our people and it would be disastrous for this country in the House were to fall into disrepute outside. We should all be zealous about maintaining the dignity of the House and more appreciative of our responsibilities.
Above all we should make every effort to produce greater results in the Assembly of the nation. This Assembly should give the greatest inspiration to our people. They are at the point of losing confidence after 35 years of exploitation. They cannot endure such hardship for ever, and we must make some drastic changes in our public administration.
Comment on this
The country knows now to a fair extent what the effect of this Budget is on the domestic user. It is beginning to have an appreciation of the disturbing effect it may have at the employer and employee level. However, it is on production and marketing, which is concerned more with the future, that the greatest stress has been laid in this discussion by those who want to pass over the immediate shock of the Budget. The country is left in a very great state of obscurity as to the effect of the Budget on employment in the future. There is complete darkness on the horizon of the future.
A number of speakers here, including the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Lands, have painted in a rather broad way the future which we are facing. The practical people who are concerned with the interests and the well-being of the people, who know that the blow has fallen on them in the form of additional taxation and the removal of food subsidies through this Budget, would all like to concentrate on those aspects of the situation. For that reason we ought, in as detached a way as possible, to look at the circumstances in which we are told from the Government Benches that a new national era has begun.
The Minister for Lands tells us that we are in a new national era now; the Minister for Industry and Commerce has indicated to us the position which the manufacturing industries are going to occupy in that situation. The Minister for Finance tells us they mean to increase our general economic level through agriculture and the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us the main hope of employment is in increased manufacturing industry and organisation. The Minister for Lands tells us of the increased and elaborate improvements and developments that have to take place in our manufacturing industries, if we are to have any hope of maintaining the present standard of employment and the present living standards of our people, or to make any attempt to increase production in the country generally.
The circumstances in which we are approaching the future have had a certain light thrown upon them by some of the reports that have been made recently. These reports have thrown a certain amount of critical light on the economic facts of the situation. The Capital Investment Committee has reported, having been set up to go into the position with regard to capital investment, the capital which might be expected to be available and the volume and nature of the investments that could be undertaken, or that must be undertaken, if we are to improve our production and increase our employment.
In that report dealing with the capital Budget for the current year, they have pointed to certain moneys that are being spent, and that have been spent for some years past, subsidies, on the one hand, and assistance to agricultural development, on the other, and they have indicated that a better use could be made of these moneys. They indicated that these moneys should not be used for current revenue. Among the recommendations they have made for consideration is a recommendation that, if a change is to be made in their use, that change should be made for capital purposes.
It is reasonable that the Minister for Finance and the Government should say that they have not had time to examine the recommendations with regard to action at the present time, but the recommendations with regard to the use of moneys here, and the use of capital here, and the purposes for which these moneys are put, are fairly clear—that, as they are used at the present moment, the committee did not consider they were effectively applied towards securing an increase in production and, at the same time, an increase in employment in the country.
However, in relation to any recommendations for the alternative use of these moneys for capital purposes, without any examination, the Government, as I say, have put their foot down on the full scheme of proposals in that report by applying the subsidies on butter and on bread to current revenue. The facts of the situation have shown that capital is enough to keep going the necessary amount of capital development that ought to be carried out by the Government on one hand, and yet leave enough on the private side to secure increased development and production there. That is one of the facts in the present situation that we have to take cognisance of.
At the same time, there has recently been published a report on the transport situation in the country. In 1944, the present C.I.E. company was set up in circumstances in which this House defeated the proposal to set it up. We had a general election and a Fianna Fáil Government was returned and it established C.I.E. After 12 or 13 years of operation, we are told by this report that not only has a sum of £11,000,000 of its capital investment to be written off, but that the services provided to the country by the railway line, a system of 1,918 miles, has to be reduced by more than half, that the services provided by 194 stations have to be reduced to the extent of five-sixths and that there are a substantial number of workers on the rail system who have to be made redundant, together with reorganisation that must necessarily take place, either under public organisation or by private organisation, of the road transport services in the country. That is another important aspect of the present situation in which we are supposed and expected to carry on.
Another factor in the situation is the proposed setting up of a European Free Trade Area and the resultant impact upon the economy of this country, whether we join that area or not. It has been particularly stressed, in the future being painted in relation to this Budget, that we have to have a substantial development in agriculture and a substantial increase in agricultural exports; that we have to have a substantial development on our industrial side and a substantial increase in our industrial exports. So important is that considered by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that, when he spoke on the matter, while saying he had not thought of applying sanctions to industrialists in this country in relation to increasing their capacity for export, he nevertheless implied, in view of the fact that he mentioned sanctions, and then put them aside, that he had certain types of sanctions in mind. He said that if there was not a development of industrial activity on the scale he wanted and in the manner in which he wanted it applied, he was going to apply very effective and very serious sanctions on industries. The circumstances in which people produce in this country are circumstances that are surrounded by all the factors which that implies.
When the inter-Party Government first came into power, one of the first things we did was to establish the Central Statistics Office and to detach it from any other Department of State, so that every aspect and every detail of our economic life would be available in terms of statistics and information, so that any policy pursued here would be based on well-known facts and every section of our people, and every section considering the matter at Parliamentary level, fully informed of every aspect of our economic life and that policies would be policies openly adopted in the light of these facts. Here we have a picture painted in regard to increased agricultural development and increased industrial development, but the position is that unless there is that increased development, the present unemployment must not only continue but must increase and that emigration which is so much talked about must continue.
While, therefore, appreciating the circumstances and appreciating the implications of not dealing in a satisfactory way with financial and economic matters, we assert that the action of the Government has been to take a blind swipe at a rather fundamental point in our financial stability; in other words, they have abolished food subsidies which were originally introduced for the purpose of assisting and stabilising wages, but were, at the same time, of vital importance in our production policy. Food subsidies have been wiped out now and everybody knows what the increase in butter, bread and flour will be; but those who are vitally concerned here, the producers on the agricultural side, have no idea in the world as to how the withdrawal of the subsidy on butter, for instance, will affect milk production and the creamery industry generally.
On the flour and bread side of things, many people do not yet know what the result will be. When flour was protected in such a way as to make it a national monopoly, though not in Government hands, one of the things the Government of the day insisted upon was that the small millers should be protected. The protection that was given them, in order to assist the industry in general and the small millers in particular, was such as to put exorbitant profits into the hands of flour millers of whatever kind, so much so that about 1935 the Government of the day caused an inquiry to be made into flour prices.
To the best of my recollection, that inquiry reported that over and above a normal profit—that is, a profit to the millers that the Government would consider reasonable—there was a profit of about £34,000 taken exclusively by the millers in the course of their business. A recommendation was made that, as the small mills at that time were suffering losses or were receiving less than would be considered a normal profit, the larger mills would surrender, by way of levy of one kind or another, part of the profits they were making and that money would be used for the purpose of assisting the smaller mills.
The Government, I think, threw up its hands in horror at the idea of making any kind of rectification of the situation along those lines and, what ever scheme was subsequently adopted by the Government, the fact remains that on the flour milling side a situation has developed in which the larger mills have aggrandised themselves into very big concerns indeed. That has had a certain effect upon the bakeries and complaint is made from time to time that the smaller bakeries are being absorbed by the larger bakeries, or by the larger miller-cum-bakery, and even such smaller bakeries as are left are being gradually wiped out by the larger concerns.
I do not know to what extent the smaller mills have been injured. I do not know how employment stands at the small mill end of the flour milling industry. I do not know whether all the small mills have been absorbed, but I submit that the process that is taking place is an injurious one from the point of view of the smaller bakeries and it may have been injurious, too, to the smaller mills which have been absorbed in a painless kind of fashion. I submit that, in the withdrawal of the flour subsidy, the Government has struck a blow at the production and industrial side in so far as there is there an element of competition to keep down prices, on the one hand, and employment scattered in a reasonable way throughout the country, on the other hand.
It is in these circumstances that the people are asked to make sacrifices for a policy that is guaranteed, in so far as declarations by the Government or its supporters can ensure, to bring about increased agricultural development, increased industrial development, greater production all round and increased exports. The people are asked to make sacrifices, on the one hand, for that; on the other hand, they are asked to cut losses just as the country is asked to cut the £11,000,000 losses incurred in the rail transport system as a result of a scheme introduced against the protests of the majority in this House in 1944.
The creameries do not yet know what losses they will be asked to cut. The point that I make is that this blow has been struck in such a way that nobody can understand the effect on our production. Remembering the general difficulties of the situation, those who have their capital invested in productive concerns here are being asked to do, in an urgent way, something which may very well prove impossible. In other words, they are being asked to reorganise industry in such a way as will meet the increasing pressures brought about by, let us say, economic circumstances alone; they are being asked to increase exports, both agricultural and industrial, so that the country will not find itself faced by serious unemployment problems; and, above all, they are being asked to prepare for what is likely to arise from the situation in Europe. Remember, a free market is likely to be set up there and it is more than likely that we shall find ourselves involved in it.
The Minister for Lands shuts his mind to anything beyond the last ten years. I do not query the reasonableness of that for the purpose of setting our compass for the future. However, he asks us to consider what a magnificent thing it would be if the Dáil would interest itself in time and motion factors. If there is any place in which a sense of time and motion factors was wanted, it was in the Cabinet Chamber when the Cabinet were discussing what they would do with regard to food subsidies. We all appreciate what time and motion factors can do. They are vital in dealing with the general economic situation. They are vital in the ordinary lives of our people, trying to organise their domestic lives and their daily working lives.
The Government has sinned in a critical way in dealing with these food subsidies. It has sinned in abolishing them, all in one slap, on the one hand, and, again, by abolishing them in current circumstances in the face of the implications of the Report of the Capital Investment Committee. The Minister for Lands asks us to look back over those years. If we are to set our compass straight for the future we have to glance a little further back, not for the purpose of saying who did this, that or the other thing, but for the purpose of discovering what is militating against our people doing their job in an efficient and fully organised way.
Those of us who can look back over developments in this country before the first war realise that this country had to suffer trampling on both its economy and liberty. We had the political struggle after that with Britain. We had our own internal troubles and we were still left with internal and external political difficulties by reason of the division of the country. That affects us economically as well as politically and we have to eliminate in so far as we can dissension, irritation and the blame in relation to any of our present circumstances if we are to give our people a chance of dealing with our present problems.
The Government in presenting this Budget asked the people for sacrifices. They have to cut their losses. They have done more than that. They have washed their hands in regard to certain aspects of our past economy which they led the people to believe was part of Government responsibility. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, when speaking here on the 14th May last in relation to food subsidies, at column 1158 of the Official Debates, said they were put on to meet a very temporary situation:—
"...a temporary upsurge in prices which would be reversed very quickly. We were guided by the world experience after the first Great War. We thought that it would have been repeated and it might have been, were it not that the Korean war intervened to alter the process."
We were given to understand and the people generally were given to understand that the difficulties with regard to prices at the time of the Korean war arose out of the mismanagement of affairs by the inter-Party Government. It was by beating that particular type of war drum that the Fianna Fáil Government was returned in 1951 in the same way as on a similar occasion before during the depression of 1930 and 1931. Again, it was alleged, it was a non-Fianna Fáil Government which was responsible for that particular situation. However, prices did not fall and it is accepted by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and no doubt by his colleagues that it was the Korean war which intervened with the process and prevented the recession in prices arising after the last war in the same way as they receded after the first.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce goes on to say:—
"I think it will be a good thing for the country if it becomes more generally realised that alterations in regard to wheat or milk prices will have consequences and they have to be kept in mind when decisions are being made. It was a completely false atmosphere in which these matters were discussed while these subsidies were in existence."
The wheat farmers and the dairy farmers are apparently to be left to their own resources now and beyond whatever the Minister for Industry and Commerce does to mark prices here and there, the farmer is being thrown his own job to do. To some extent the industrialist is being thrown his own job to do also with a slight kind of threat that is reminiscent of the threats made by the present Minister for Local Government when he was Minister for Agriculture.
The Minister says:—
"The time has come when we must think in terms of a new approach to the whole question of industrial expansion...the expansion of employment depends mainly upon the increase in industrial activity."
It was in those circumstances he said: "We have not thought of and I hope there will be no need to think of sanctions in that regard." But they may think of sanctions. The Government have asked the people to make sacrifices. The taxpayers generally who provide capital have to cut their losses in respect of C.I.E. The industrialists, those who are producers, are now being told that they must stand more on their own feet. Happily, during the past ten years, in respect of which the Minister for Lands thinks there has been so much neglect, there has arisen in this country a greater sense of responsibility to accept representatives from among various people in agriculture and in industry.
The setting up of the Agricultural Advisory Committee by the Minister for Agriculture and the various representative bodies which deal with different aspects of industry shows that there has been a growth of representative organisations among those who are functionally representatives of the productive life of the country. It is in these particular circumstances that we look to hope in the country. It has been indicated by the Ministers that the reason this Budget is accepted by some at least of their followers—I am sure it is representative of a number of them—is that they accept these recommendations for the withdrawal of the food subsidies because they believe they represent a move towards full employment.
If we could get all Parties to fix their mind on what they mean by full employment and to watch carefully the things proposed, the things that are possible for strengthening our agriculture and our industries and make it possible for greater production to take place without a former Minister for Agriculture wanting to say in the House that another Minister for Agriculture, now on the opposite side, was no good and avoid the exchange of pure personalities, of a non-constructive and frictional kind, we might be able to use our thought and resources to stimulate the people who labour under difficulties in the country, particularly those who labour under difficulty in agriculture and industry from the point of view of further development and employment.
We can make no excuse for the Government for sweeping aside the subsidies in such a rough and ready way. They say it is the best way they know of. We say we are sorry they do not know a better way. They insisted that the country would never have a chance of bettering itself in any way until the last Government was got out of office. They got the last Government out of office on the representations they made to the people. They say now that they have taken the best action they can take. Let them not stop, in facing up to their responsibilities to ask: "What would the last Government have done?" They have been told in a certain amount of detail what the last Government would have done—but that is only touching their responsibility and the work they see and that they say is in front of them. They have taken this step. They have the record of the votes on the various Financial Resolutions which shows that the Finance Bill will go through and that the proposed increased prices on butter, flour and bread will become a reality to the consuming public. That being so, let them go and take the next step. But, facing people who have to co-operate with the Government in taking the next step, at every step is the gambler's thimble over the vital spots—the vital spot of the creamery industry, the vital spot of the bakery industry, the vital spot of the milling industry, particularly the small mills. It is over the question of wheat production and the wheat subsidy.
We were told here the other night that not only too much milk but also too much wheat is being produced. We have even been told that some of the wheat which Deputy Dillon, with his experience and his knowledge, insists is quite fit for use in flour for bread making is "bad" wheat. We were told that some of the wheat saved last year which is available for flour making is "bad" and that we shall have to throw £150,000 after that so-called "bad" wheat, according to the Government. Therefore, even in respect of wheat-growing, the thimble rigger's thimble is over the situation as well as being over many other things. In the interim period, we do not know how much has to be paid at, I suppose, a rate of about £10 a cwt. in that particular way for the export of butter.
The country is bewildered by the action of the Government in removing the subsidies despite all they themselves said in regard to that matter and in the light of existing facts. Those who are most important in the country from the point of view of doing what the Government considers necessary to increase production, the farmers and the industrialists, are bewildered about what is in front of them arising out of the action taken by the Government in this Budget and arising out of implications of the speeches from the Government Benches on this General Resolution. These, together with facts that are more and more disclosing themselves in the various authoritative experts' reports in regard to aspects of our economy, are the things that require our attention, very clear delineation and careful thought.
I plead with every person concerned with any aspect of affairs in the country to realise that it is not sufficient for the Taoiseach to say that this is a very critical situation. It is not sufficient for the Minister for Lands to say that we are approaching a new era. It is not sufficient for either the Minister for Lands or for the Minister for Industry and Commerce to say that we have to deal with industry in the light of facts that were unpredictable or unforeseeable when we began to protect our industries. It is not sufficient to say these things and not to show urgently what the Government think the people can do and what it can do to help the people to meet the position. To do otherwise will only prolong the people's uncertainty and throw those who could help as organisers of or investors in new development into a spirit of despondency or inertia. Before doing anything radical about increasing industry here they will wait until they are sure of what the Government is going to do besides telling them that the ball is back to them now, that the Government cannot do as much for them and should never have done as much for them as was done in the past and that it is their job to seek out how best to organise themselves and their production and to export.
The Government will have to wake up and show at the earliest possible moment the lines upon which they are thinking. They will have to give a clear indication of their intended line of action in relation to which the people can go ahead with their own work.
Comment on this
A noticeable feature about the debate this week is that there are no interventions from the Government side of the House. By "no interventions" I mean that there are no speeches from that side of the House. Government Deputies have probably had very much the same experience as Deputies on this side of the House, namely, that on the introduction of the Budget the people generally were not aware of the implications. It is now dawning on the people of Ireland that they had inflicted on them one of the cruellest and hardest Budgets in our history. I am not a doctrinaire believer in subsidies as a sound economy. However, the subsidies in question were introduced by a Fianna Fáil Government at a certain period for the purpose of sheltering people against the hardships of a rising cost of living and the difficulties the world as a whole was facing after the last world war.
There does not appear to be any indication that the present moment is the time, at one fell swoop, to remove all those subsidies and totally upset and disorganise our economy. In effect, that is what the present administration has done. No doubt they have been advised by economic experts and their financial advisers that that was the correct thing to do. I accept that financial advisers are there for the purpose of giving what they consider to be sound advice. That has been so in the economic history of different countries down through the ages. However, it is not incumbent on a democratic Government to accept that advice in toto. I submit to the House that, in accepting that advice and removing in toto the subsidies, it was not good policy and it was not motivated really by any collective school of thought that could hope to produce a good effect on our economy as a whole. Our stability is destroyed overnight.
This debate has gone on for a fairly long time now and I do not want to cover any ground that has already been covered. I just want to deal with one or two facts. We are told that this extraordinary Fianna Fáil Budget was introduced for the purpose of getting greater production. I should like to say something about the butter subsidy. We introduced the butter subsidy, and the fact that we introduced it means, of course, that the Fianna Fáil Party would like to take it away. They did not hesitate to take it away. I believe, if the truth had been known, that Fianna Fáil back benchers thought, when the Minister stood up to make his Budget statement, that the butter subsidy was the only subsidy that would go. It was doomed from the word "go" because we had introduced it.
I shall endeavour to show the House why I believe that subsidy served many purposes, and why I believe its removal will greatly disorganise our agricultural production. In the first instance, it is crystal clear that a subsidy such as that made it possible for old people such as old age pensioners to buy butter. It made it possible for the mothers of bigger families to give their offspring nutritious butter to eat, and in that way it was helpful to the health of the nation as a whole.
I came into this House in 1951, and from 1951 to 1954, I was conscious in a constituency such as mine—Wexford— of the marketing difficulties which farmers encountered in trying to dispose of their surplus butter. I had nothing but complaints from 1951 to 1954 about the inability of farmers to sell their butter, but I had not one complaint from 1954 to 1957 because of our increased consumer potential for butter, and as a result, the price was also considerably increased and we had no surplus on hand. Apart from the fact that our people were eating butter, the butter subsidy obviated the necessity for the importation of margarine and it also acted as an agricultural stimulant in that it represented an inducement to increased production. It encouraged farmers to breed more live-stock because they realised that, if they had more cows in calf, they could dispose of the milk to advantage by having it converted into butter, with no risk of being thrown back, as they were before, on to chocolate crumb, dried milk or cheese when markets were becoming more difficult.
That is one indication of the instability that may be caused by the removal of the butter subsidy, caused not alone in the agricultural industry. Deputy M. P. Murphy, a Labour Deputy from Cork, very ably detailed, the other evening, the position with regard to the financial aspects of the removal of the butter subsidy. The Government will gain £2,000,000 by it, but he proved here— and I think his arguments were very sound—that it will cost £1,000,000 to subsidise the sales of butter abroad, allowing that 12,000,000 lb. would have to be sold outside the country, and this will probably be necessary.
One of the greatest difficulties encountered by the last Government was to sustain and equate the price of milk. Have we any guarantee that the Fianna Fáil Government, by removing the butter subsidy and thus creating the situation that I have outlined, can maintain that price? If they do maintain it, they may have to do it by subsidy and what will that subsidy come to, once they have to get down to giving a subsidy for the price of milk at all? We listened to criticism from the other side of the House when the Fianna Fáil Party was in Opposition about the price of milk; they can now face the situation which they themselves, by their own stupidity, have created.
That is only one subsidy. Everyone in the lower income group, everyone on a salary—and that is the major portion of the people of this country— is dependent on bread and butter for existence. The Fianna Fáil Party know that now; they did not know it the first week of the Budget, but they know it now, because when they went back to their constituencies last week they heard of the sufferings they were imposing on the people. They also began to hear from the people what the people think of them, and that is the reason for the silence on the Fianna Fáil side to-day. Last week they were prepared to get up and make speeches to the effect that they were more or less conferring a benefit on the people of the country by stabilising their economy.
They took over this country in balance except for a small sum that was out of balance due to the unnatural situation which arose last year on account of the Suez Canal crux. That involved a certain loss of revenue, and there was also the untoward drop in agricultural prices. However, Fianna Fáil took over the country with every possibility of buoyancy and could have taken a risk to that effect but they did not do that. A leopard does not change his spots and what they did in 1952 they have done again now. Whenever they get a chance they will do it again, because their idea of economy is to get all they can out of the Irish people and make the money available to increase agricultural and industrial production.
What schemes have they got for increasing production? I read the Budget speech, and—I may be very stupid—the only thing I could see in it is that they are to spend £250,000 for marketing. I approve of that, and I am sure every Deputy in the House approves of it, but no matter how they spend that money for the purpose of marketing, the only Minister who has spoken so far on the matter was the Tánaiste, who says that they are to go into consultation with the agricultural associations to consider how to spend that money. I wonder if it will cost £250,000 to have a consultation with the agricultural associations? If so, it will be a very expensive consultation.
I should like to make some suggestions with regard to marketing. We went through a very difficult time last year because cattle prices were falling all through the winter and it was a very severe shock to our economy. That was largely due to the fact that we have nearly all our eggs in one basket. Britain, one of the greatest food importing countries in Europe, decided for some reason or other—perhaps to bring down her own cost of living—to import a great deal of beef from South America. That, in itself, was understandable but I think we buy more per capita, perhaps, from Britain than any other country, and they might have given us more consideration. Not only were they buying beef abroad but they were exporting into the very markets we ourselves had secured. That was the situation we had to face last year. I think it is a situation which should not be allowed to arise again.
We did not sit back and do nothing about it. Members of our Government went out and negotiated and found a market for our agricultural produce for a certain limited period. The French Government was persuaded to take off the 25 per cent. tariff on the import of live-stock and when the French people got a taste of the Irish beef—and it was the first time that Irish beef found its way into the continental market— they liked it so much that they took the tariff off a second time and we were still able to export it to France. Then the British Government, seeing the opportunity, bought cattle from us in limited quantities and exported them wholesale to France. They then bought more beef from South America and we were unable to balance this off because we were unable to send direct there ourselves—we had no ships to do so.
We have at the present moment under examination a treaty which will be made effective in a very short time between certain European countries including Luxembourg, Holland, Belgium, France and Italy, and the Federal Republic of Germany, representing 160,000,000 people, who propose to constitute a common market. The purchasing power of that group is enormous. The potentials there are enormous. Although they have agreed to a free trade among themselves, there is no reason why they cannot make separate and collateral agreements with other countries. That seems to me to be our opportunity.
I observe from to-day's paper that we are negotiating with regard to the common market. The paper does not say who is negotiating for us. It is very probable that some civil servant is doing so. I do not want to say anything derogatory of civil servants, but I know enough about Europe to know that you can negotiate through civil servants in the United States of America and in Britain, but, if you want to get proper and fruitful negotiations on the Continent of Europe, it is advisable to negotiate at political level.
I should like to offer this advice to the Government, that they should go in at political level as early as possible to try to get a market which is so fruitful, in which there are such potentialities at the moment. If they can get in there, all our troubles in regard to exports for the future should be solved. I do not mean to suggest that we should abandon the British market or that we should turn our back on the British market. We should in every way utilise the benefits of that market. We must realise that we are facing a changing situation and that our potential to sell in Britain in future may be largely confined to a store market and, if we wish to sell our finished products, Europe is the place to look for a market. In any case, it would be a good auxiliary to what we already have.
With regard to employment, the only provision I can see in the Budget for employment schemes, relief employment, out of the large sums which are being gathered under the new methods of taxation, is another £250,000, and the members of the Government have been very coy or uninformative as to how they will spend it. An inkling has been given that this money is to be spent in Dublin. Of course, as a countryman, I cannot approve of that, but I suppose there is at the moment considerable hardship in the City of Dublin.
In this debate, the question was discussed as to how that money should be spent and it was suggested that it would be a good thing if it were put into a productive scheme. I suggest to the Government that there is a crying need in the City of Dublin for parking accommodation for motor cars. If the Government propose to spend £250,000 or less in Dublin, let them provide proper parking facilities, be they overhead, over the Liffey, underground or wherever else they may be. If they charge a small sum for parking, that parking place will be full from morning to night. Every countryman knows that if he takes his car to Dublin, there is nowhere to park it. Such a parking place would pay for itself and the Government would get their money back. It would be a productive scheme and it is productive schemes that we want, not only in the City of Dublin but in rural Ireland.
According to the latest statistics compiled by the Secretariat of the Council of Europe relating to all countries, the population of Dublin is 522,000. The total population of the part of Ireland over which we have jurisdiction at the moment is under 3,000,000. Deputies will realise that Dublin has got to the stage where it is no longer economic to expand. I would suggest to the Government that any schemes they may have for industrial expansion should be concentrated in rural Ireland. There are many opportunities, many facilities, in many parts of the country, buildings available for factories, and so forth. It is time that some Government tackled that problem seriously in the interest of the community as a whole.
I observe from the Minister's Budget statement that the question of abolishing the Irish News Agency is being considered. Some Deputies have spoken in favour of that course and some have spoken against it. As a Deputy who has had the privilege of being abroad a good deal in the last few years, I am conscious of the terrific propaganda that exists against this country. We have no means of counteracting that propaganda, unless we utilise other agencies for doing so. The Irish News Agency operated under a difficulty in that it was not in a position to compete for what is known in journalistic circles as "hot" news. It was difficult for them, therefore, to balance their budget and to make the agency a solvent concern, but I can assure the House that that agency is fulfilling a useful function in that it is counteracting subversive propaganda against Ireland and the Irish people.
The tourist potential of a country depends upon its having a pleasing record for all other countries. People are not inclined to visit a country about which they have heard derogatory remarks. There is a lot of that going on against Ireland. I have been personally conscious of that in my contacts abroad in the Council of Europe. Members of Parliament and Deputies of other countries have asked me if such and such a thing is true about Ireland—things that are totally untrue and unfounded. There is a ceaseless flow of propaganda. There will be always propaganda against a small country like Ireland. There will be always propaganda against us from the Communists and anti-Christian outlook which is prevalent in other countries. We can only counteract that by having an agency of our own.
According to the Book of Estimates, the Irish News Agency costs £45,000 a year. That may seem a big sum, but, having regard to the enormous sums the present Administration are collecting by cutting out the subsidies, by imposing extra taxation and so forth, it is a small sum to pay in order that the truth in regard to this country may be maintained and upheld abroad. Why should we lie down under this subversive propaganda? I would ask the Government to reconsider the question of the abolition of the Irish News Agency.
The troubles and difficulties the last Government had to contend with are now evident to the people of Ireland. I sat on the benches behind that Government and I supported them. I did not always agree with everything they did, but what the Fianna Fáil Government have done to the Irish people in the short time they have been in office shows how good a Government the last Government was, in face of all the difficulties and trials that faced them. They created stability. They equalised the cost of living. They increased agricultural production. They got nothing but vilification and abuse from every-where. The people of Ireland believed that abuse. They returned the Fianna Fáil Government to power, probably for four or five years. My guess is as good as anybody's. They will live to rue it.
Comment on this
We have heard appeals from Ministers to trade unions and others to make sacrifices and to tighten their belts. The Minister, introducing his Budget, pointed out that, if certain sections of the community through their organisations were able to secure compensation to meet the increased costs the withdrawal of the subsidies had placed upon the workers, the Budget would be a failure from his point of view. The Minister for Defence suggested that certain people were trying to create a disturbance in the country in criticising this Budget because it was introduced by Fianna Fáil. Every Irishman, whether he agreed with him or not, was to make a sacrifice because Fianna Fáil cannot be wrong.
The Taoiseach stated that it was necessary to have an army and he asked those who were criticising the Budget what was their alternative. I am privileged to be a member of a trade union for the past 35 years, and I am still a paid-up member, and I can assure the Government that no leader of any trade union encourages the members to make demands for increases in wages. The duty of the leaders of the trade unions to the rank and file of the members, notwithstanding what any politician may say, is to protect the interests of the workers and to see that their standard of living is not reduced—as it is being reduced by this Budget. No appeal will prevent the rank and file from demanding that which they are entitled to get.
The workers are asked to make a sacrifice, but for whom are they to make that sacrifice? It is the workers all the time, and especially the lowest paid workers, who are asked to make sacrifices. The unfortunate docker who has worked for eight hours in the hold of a ship does not get home to dinner. He takes a few drinks and some bread and butter, but he can see that the taxes and duties have been removed for the people who drive motor cars worth £1,600. It is for such people that he is asked to tighten his belt. The farm labourer is being asked to continue working for £4 10s. a week. In return, he is asked to pay 4/7 a lb. for butter and 1/1½d. for a loaf of bread. The extra 1/– he is to get through children's allowances will go on Monday morning when he buys his bread and butter. Builders' labourers and all organised workers see a certain influential body of business people who are given a concession so that they can buy mink coats and other furcoats.
They are asked to make a sacrifice so that these business people will be enabled to pay for these coats. They are asked to pay more for their sugar and butter and pint of beer.
If I had a choice in relation to the food subsidies I would vote, as I have always voted, to retain them. I would vote against maintaining some of our embassies abroad at the cost of millions of pounds and especially maintaining an embassy in the United States of America where the newly appointed representative to Ireland said that it was in the interests of America to keep Partition in Ireland.
Comment on this
I am discussing the Budget. Deputy Briscoe, to give him credit, has given more publicity to this country in America in a short time than have our representatives there who have been silent on the question of Partition. If they have been vocal, they have failed to convince the representative of America in Ireland that it is in the interests of America and Europe to have Partition removed. I would save £1,000,000 there.
I remember when the Civil Service was established in this country and an Irishman was brought over here with experience in England. He was a credit to this country. I have had a long experience of the Civil Service since then and I can say that, with the exception of one or two, the civil servants are a credit to our country. The Minister has tried to tell the people that the Civil Service is too large. We admit it, but who is responsible? It was not the inter-Party Government. I, in my own way, tried to refuse to fill major posts while I was in office. It may be possible to reduce here and there, but there will still be high expenditure or, if there is not, there will be further emigrants going to look for work abroad instead of remaining idle at home.
Why do we need to retain—I am expressing my own views now—at a huge cost, the position of President?
I am not saying anything against the present gentleman who holds the office and who fills the position with honour and credit. Why do we not economise in that direction and save another £1,000,000? Another £2,000,000 is practically given away by removing taxes on motor cars and luxury goods. Another £1,000,000 could be saved on the Army, the mechanisation of which at the present time is out of date. It has been said that we require an Army at the present moment because of the dangers of a private army. Is it not known that the alleged private armies in the country do not exceed four figures in numbers? They have no ammunition worth talking about. We are to maintain a huge Army with more officers than men at a huge expenditure when we do not require it because it will be of no use other than that to which it might be put, if somebody were to come across the Border. In that event, not alone would an Army be available but there would be sufficient volunteers as well.
If these savings were effected, the goodwill of the trade unions would be obtained and if the Government were really in earnest the trade unions would be prepared to make the necessary sacrifices. When they know that the sacrifices are to be borne only by one side of the community, the less wealthy people, then their co-operation will not be forthcoming. The trade unions warned that the food subsidies should not be interfered with. In my own constituency, I made a speech warning the people that, if Fianna Fáil were returned, the first thing they would do would be to abolish the food subsidies. I stated that the housewives would have to pay 4/4 or ? per lb. for butter. I pointed out that bread might cost them 1/1. When we were in office, butter cost 3/9 per lb. I told them that Fianna Fáil would take their revenge, remove the food subsidies and put up butter to 4/4.
The Tánaiste contradicted that statement and said that the food subsidies would not be interfered with. I know he is a good Irishman and a good politician, and I would say nothing to him. However, I can imagine how vocal the Tánaiste would be if he were on this side of the House. I can visualise the headlines in the Irish Press: “Labour and the Coalition Betray the Electorate of this Country.” Protest resolutions would be organised by Fianna Fáil members of trade unions demanding wholesale resignations because of the hardship to be inflicted on the people. Now we are asking the people to make sacrifices in the interests of a small section. I proved that the two wealthy sections are getting all the facilities and privileges, while the other section are being asked to make the sacrifices.
I am one of those who intend to secure for the workers the continuance of their present standard of living. I can guarantee that the trade unions will be loyal to their members. That is their duty. They have made too many sacrifices not to endeavour to maintain for workers the standard of living they have succeeded in securing up to now. They will not foolishly accept some of the statments by Ministers. They do not believe in having one small section make all the sacrifices, while the remainder get the concessions. If I had my choice, I would vote to keep on the taxes on the items I have mentioned; I would vote to reduce the Army by £1,000,000 and I would vote to reduce the Department of External Affairs. We are spending money on representatives abroad who have failed to secure anything for us. If we want to have industry here, we must send out men who will endeavour to show to the people in other countries the facilities there are in this country.
I am glad to see the Lord Mayor of Dublin here. For the period he was abroad, I believe he did more than all our ambassadors have done for the past 35 years. Why spend money on having these people there merely for the sake of our name? We are told by various Ministers that the cost of government is falling heavily upon the people. Why not make a reduction at that end before increasing the burdens on the poorer section of the community?
There has been talk about stability. We are not living in a fool's paradise.
We know we will have a sixth-round wage increase demand. The organised workers will be able to secure an increase. What will become of the middle classes and the groups with no organisation? When the docker gets his increase, that will be passed on again to the general community. The employer will not suffer any loss; the community will have to pay. Apart from the increases on butter, sugar and bread, there will be further increases because of the increased cost of petrol. It will mean increased distribution costs in the rural areas far from the principal ports. When goods have to be transported 50 or 60 miles, the businessman cannot be expected to pay the increased costs resulting from increases in insurance and in the price of petrol. He cannot sell his goods to the rural shopkeeper at the same price.
We will not have the stability we all hope for. The middle class section and the weaker section of the community will suffer as a result of this Budget. I believe you could have got the co-operation of all Parties, if you had allowed the food subsidies to remain for the time being and had removed instead the cost of administration in the various matters I mentioned. The Tánaiste pointed out recently that crises had taken place in the country year after year for the past 15 or 16 years. That was not the story during the elections. "Wives, put your husbands out to work.""We have plenty of work for you." We had all hoped there would be plenty of work; but you will not get work for the unemployed by taking off the food subsidies and so creating a demand for higher wages and forcing the unions to take the action they are bound to take to protect the standard of living of their members.
I can picture what is happening in agriculture. Take the case of the farm labourer, upon whom we are so much dependent for the necessaries of life and upon whom we are so much dependent for increased agricultural production. He is living in the rural area where he has to bear extra costs. Deputies from the rural areas know that things will be dearer for him. In one part of Wexford I believe flour is 2d. per stone dearer than places nearer to the cities. Fianna Fáil Deputies from Wicklow said: "Give the Chief his majority." He has got it now and what have we got in return? They were able to secure the people's votes and they came in here and voted for the Budget. They were entitled to do so and I am not quarrelling with it. However, they should have told the people of the country first that they would not inflict these hardships upon the rank and file.
As the people accepted the statements that were made we now have no alternative but to criticise the Government's policy, to try to convert the people, to assure them, if they do not already know, the serious mistake they made when they gave Fianna Fáil such a majority. Maybe it will be said that the inter-Party Government might have been forced to put up taxes. Perhaps they would, but the Labour Party would not support any Government that would inflict further burdens on the masses.
Comment on this
There would and it would probably be more united than the Government at the present time.
Comment on this
The Deputy is entitled to his banter. If the Deputy were amongst the Opposition to-day, he would not be so silent if such a wrong were perpetrated on the workers.
Comment on this
I will not be silent at 6 o'clock when Deputy Noel Lemass finishes. I have a few quotations from the Deputy's speeches. The Deputy, in his speech in Cork——
Comment on this
Deputy Everett must address the Chair.
Comment on this
I am sorry. Deputy O'Malley and myself are very good friends and I will not keep him until 6 o'clock. I can assure the Deputy that an inter-Party Government would never have attempted to withdraw all these subsidies. I shall not refer to the other taxes. I shall leave it to Deputy Norton to criticise the Government's proposal to give compensation to the bakers for increases in wages they gave to their workers. I would agree to give some compensation to the smaller bakeries who are unable to pay their way.
I do not want to be accused outside in the trade unions of failing to do something to alleviate the distress of the workers. Every effort I can make here to redress the grievances of the workers will be made. The trade union leaders do not mind a bit the sugar coated threats made by some Ministers against potential demands from the workers. We will meet such threats. I am speaking now as a member of a trade union. How are we going to have stability unless we restore the taxes on the £1,600 motor car and on the mink coat? When we do these things we can talk about fairness to the workers and the workers will accept the statements made. Trade unions will never allow the standard of living of their members to be reduced. In a short time there will be a further round of applications for increases in wages and the people will then see the hardships inflicted by this Budget. It will be seen then that the Government have blundered.
Comment on this
I have not been in the House very long but I realise that the Government have to deal with vast sums of money. I never realised, though, that £4,000,000 here and £1,000,000 there could be found as easily as has been suggested by Deputy Everett. He said he could save £4,000,000 on the Army, cutting present expenditure by two-thirds. He suggested that an army of volunteers is all that is needed to do the job. According to him those men need not be trained. What he wants is an army of unpaid privates. The system of maintaining officers and N.C.O.s to train recruits at present and to train volunteers in an emergency is the only sensible approach.
I noticed that when Deputy Everett referred to the subsidies he was very careful to say they should be left in operation for the time being. When would Deputy Everett remove the subsidies—next year, in ten years' time, in 20 years' time when a Coalition might again be inflicted on this country?
Comment on this
Some speakers have made references to the 1952 Budget. When Fianna Fáil came back again after this election they found a situation almost exactly the same as that obtaining in 1951. As a result of coalition government in 1951 we found our external assets had been reduced by half, by £106,000,000. In 1951 Deputy MacEntee as Minister for Finance found that the provisions made by his predecessor for public services were inadequate. When he introduced his Budget on March 12th, 1952, the problems were the same as they are now—problems of decreasing employment, of unbalanced external payments, of business recession and so on. These were tackled honestly by Deputy MacEntee then as they have been tackled by Deputy Dr. Ryan on this occasion. Deputies Norton and Everett, who pretend to represent Labour interests in this country, know that in one year after Deputy MacEntee's Budget there were 14,000 more in insurable employment.
Comment on this
The Deputy can check the records. For example during the first coalition period 2,802 dwellings were built or reconditioned by the Dublin Corporation. During the next three years, under Fianna Fáil Government, 6,779 houses were built. Again, during the past three years, there has been a drop to nearly 4,000 houses. Similar figures which could be quoted prove that Fianna Fáil's approach is the right one. Our record shows that our approach has always been the right one. Our policy has always been the provision of more employment. "Get your husbands off to work," has been our slogan.
Comment on this
On the last occasion Fianna Fáil resumed office, 1,000 more people went back to work in the building industry. In the two years following the 1952 Budget, 1,500 more men were put to work by Bord na Móna. In 1954 there were twice as many employed on rural electrification as there were in 1950, employment on forestry had increased by 1,000, on drainage by 500, on emergency schemes by 400 and there were 3,000 more road workers employed. Accordingly, it can be said that the problem now facing us is one which has developed since 1954. During 1953-54 production was increasing. It was not increasing as quickly as might be hoped, but employment was going up and unemployment going down. Although the rate of progress was not as rapid as we would have wished, we were going in the right direction. When we took office this year things were going in the wrong direction.
In 1954, things were going in the right direction. Exports were increasing. In that period there were no serious problems relating to international payments. What is more, Fianna Fáil were able to maintain the capital investment programme, which was as extensive as it was capable of organising. That capital investment programme provided this country with the amenities which any modern State would expect to have. Of course, the main thing was the giving of employment to many tens of thousands of Irish workers—employment which has contracted in the last 12 months. They can refer to the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation. Towards the end of last year the O.E.E.C. were reporting on the conditions in the Republic of Ireland.
Comment on this
They were reporting on the conditions in the Republic of Ireland. I quote that report:—
"Ireland's capital economic situation began to deteriorate in 1955 after seven years of internal financial stability and lower external deficits."
I think nothing could be more damning to the last Government than a comment like that, coming from a body which is not prejudiced by Irish politics in any way, an outside body looking at this country with ordinary interest and not caring about internal political problems here. Nevertheless, they made that statement, so it is not just the Fianna Fáil Deputies who maintain that the problems which are facing us, the problems which led to this Budget and to the severity of it, if you wish, are strictly a result of the mismanagement of our affairs since 1954.
Some people may ask why the O.E.E.C. report referred to mid-1955, why it did not start the minute the Coalition Government came in. The obvious reason for that is that when they took office the last time they were working the Fianna Fáil programme and it was not until they got properly into their stride in the Blueshirt way that the country started to go down.
Comment on this
It was my grandfather. No, white collars were the things in his day.
The Minister for Finance, in making his Budget statement in 1955, referred to the satisfactory trading position—a position, of course, which they had inherited from Fianna Fáil. He assured the House that he had every hope that the improvement in the country's position would be maintained. The Taoiseach, much later in the year, introducing his Estimate, dismissed as completely unimportant the worsening of the import and export trading position.
At that time he gave a very optimistic forecast as to what would happen in the future. All those assurances were proved by events to be completely worthless. The position became much worse, until the Government panicked and introduced its famous policy of restriction. We hope this policy of restriction has been abandoned now, once and for all, and that business firms will be able to expand without any obstacle being put in their way by the Oireachtas.
I believe it will not be long before this expansion gets into full stride and we can see people being put back to work—for that is what we did before and that is what we shall do again.
Comment on this
If the Labour Party had supported Fianna Fáil in doing these things, it would have a bigger group here, I believe, than it has to-day.
Comment on this
Deputy Everett should know. Deputy Norton, speaking on the introduction of the subsidies in 1947, said, as reported at column 435, Volume 108:—
"The highlight of the documents put before us is, I take it, the subsidies to reduce the prices of tea, bread and sugar. I think these are sham reductions."
Further on, at column 437, Deputy Norton said:—
"One would think from these proposals that our people live on bread, tea and sugar and it would seem that this represents the Government's ambition from the point of view of the average person's diet."
From his speech in this House after the removal of the subsidies, it would seem to me, by the same argument, that that is the Labour Party's ambition as far as the average working man's diet is concerned.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello, in his address here, complained very bitterly that we in Fianna Fáil did not state, before this election, that we intended to remove the subsidies. We had the same attitude from Deputy Norton and Deputy Everett and consistently from the opposite benches: "Why did Fianna Fáil not say they were going to do this, before the election?" Deputy Costello might have known—and so might have the Deputies opposite in the Coalition Benches—but Fianna Fáil certainly did not know, that Deputy Sweetman's last Budget was unbalanced to the extent of £6,000,000——
Comment on this
——or that the cost of Government services would be up by £5,000,000. Why were not those facts made clear before the election? Then Fianna Fáil might have been able to answer those questions.
I should like to make a short reference to one of the divisions we had here on the Budget. I noticed a number of Deputies particularly concerned with the unemployment situation, going in to vote against the increased tax of 6d. on the gallon of petrol. These same Deputies come into the House and say it is up to the Government to provide work for the people. Yet even on this taxation on what is generally considered a luxury commodity, they would not support the Government in its efforts to organise funds. Most of these Deputies—I have more than one in mind and they are all in the Independent Benches—had a tremendous showing of high powered cars on polling day and I think the only thing they could have in mind is the expenditure they might be faced with in five years' time.
Comment on this
I suppose it is the usual thing that, when people are faced with a problem and realise they must take some positive action to solve it, some of them try to run away, some try to hide or ask for mercy and help but others take off their coats and get down to do their job. From listening to the Opposition speeches I think they must estimate the Irish people's mentality as that of a crowd of whingers and criers who want to run away and hide instead of facing their responsibilities. We in Fianna Fáil do not believe that. We are a nation of fighting people. It is my belief, and my colleagues share it, that in order to raise this country from the depths of despair into which it fell in the last 12 months, in 1956, the people are prepared now to make the sacrifice which is being asked of them. Before the members of the Labour Party and others start off—we have heard talks of token strikes, demands for increased wages, and hunger strikes—let them go back and see what happened in 1952, 1953 and 1954.
Comment on this
There was a report in a paper last week of a section of one of the Labour Parties in rural Ireland advocating a token strike.
Comment on this
I also take it from Deputy Everett's address here to-day, where he says he will support the trades unions and so forth, that he is making it quite clear that he proposes to take every step in his power to see that there is a general all-round increase in wages.
Comment on this
There is no need for anybody to go on hunger strike. The Budget has looked after that.
Comment on this
If that is what is in Deputy Everett's mind, it is a bad show and I am suggesting that Deputy Everett should look to see what happened in the period 1952-53 and 1953-54, take into account the number of people who found gainful employment during that period and take into account all the work that was done. Deputy Everett should be very slow to advocate either that or even to go into the lobbies against this Budget.
I will conclude by repeating the words of the Minister for Finance in his statement. He said at column 961, Volume 161, of the Official Debates of 8th May, 1957:—
"We cannot hope to solve all our problems at once but, with the co-operation of every section of the community, they can be reduced in scale and urgency and the way prepared for the achievement of what will always be the objective of this Party—permanently higher living standards for all."
Comment on this
It is great to be young and enthusiastic, I thought, when I heard Deputy N. Lemass expressing how appalled he was at the manner in which Deputy Everett had mentioned one or two million pounds. He had not, of course, been in the House when his father was shouting here a year ago about his plan for £100,000,000. That seems to have gone off into Limbo.
Comment on this
Not in this case when he was querying a million pounds and his father could produce a hundred of them out of the hat. Like many other Deputies I went down to my constituency last Sunday and I was told, of course, in every place that there were Fianna Fáil victory celebrations. This poor lone Deputy went off to a Fine Gael dance last Sunday night and he was unable to get into the village. There were 800 people at that dance; they all paid and the place was not plastered with paper tickets.
I have an opus here and I want to talk about it. When Deputy Dillon was addressing this House on the Budget, he mentioned the present Taoiseach and described him as the old practitioner. Some people did not like that. I thought it was a little bit on the bone myself, but afterwards, having read the Taoiseach's speech and some of the other Budget speeches, and having listened to them, I came to the conclusion that there was a lot in it. These old doctors always gave you the mixture as before, and somehow or other in the election campaign the mixture was dished out as before.
Down in my constituency this magnificent document, dated 21st February, 1957, was sent out to the people. It says:—
"...A promise to farmers to maintain the price of wheat has been broken. The drop in wheat prices threatens not only the farmers but the entire community which relies for its food on the farmers. Yes, it is a bread and butter election. The Coalition is taking the bread out of your mouths and is buttering you with the only butter they think you are worthy of—golden promises which are broken."
It was a kind of treason if any of us said on a platform that if the Fianna Fáil Government were returned to office, they would remove the subsidies. This document was being prepared and it was the mixture as before.
"Anything the Coalition promises to do you can do better, with the inspired leadership.... We call back the emigrants who, during the dismal reign of the Coalition, have fled before a 1957 famine...."
This again is the old mixture as before. You must always have the Irish language, Ireland free from the sod to the sky, and resurrect the bones and the record of any worthy patriots that you can think of because they claim them all to have been cumann members, no matter what age they lived in.
Deputy Lindsay spoke about this famous night in Belmullet, and why I can talk about this was that on the same night the Fianna Fáil Party not only had its political atom bomb ready to explode at the far western corner of the country in Belmullet, but they also had galloping down to my constituency of Waterford the then Deputy Seán Lemass, who delivered himself of this opus. This is from his own kept paper the Irish Press, so I cannot be accused of doing anything with it. I am reading it now as quoted by Deputy Dillon at column 1297, Volume 161, of the Official Debates of 15th May, 1957:—
"Some Coalition leaders are threatening the country with all sorts of unpleasant things if Fianna Fáil becomes the Government—compulsory tillage, wage control, cuts in Civil Service salaries, and a lot more besides.
A Fianna Fáil Government does not intend to do any of these things, because we do not believe in them. How definite can we make our denial of these stupid allegations? They are all falsehoods."
When he was delivering that, the mixture as before had been prepared over in Mayo. There was an army with banners marching into Belmullet, with the thunder of drums, blazing turf torches, tar barrels and all the usual paraphernalia. The people were prepared for it; the walls were plastered with the famous poster that must have cost thousands of pounds because you could not look anywhere without seeing it. It was even stuck on my own gate:—"You can trust Dev." This caravanserai marched into Belmullet and some Deputy said the whole business was Machiavellian. Poor old Machiavelli! I would say his spirit was there to sit at the feet of his master. The famous speech was delivered there, something on the same lines as that of Deputy Lemass, now Minister for Industry and Commerce —"You know the record of Fianna Fáil in the past. You know that we have never done the things that they said we would do." Now I will have to take you back to Waterford.
Deputy Lemass had to dash down to Waterford, climb on to the platform and, in his most brilliant fashion, say: "Let's get cracking." Having delivered himself of what I have told you here, he got down off the platform, refused all the hospitality they offered him— they had a meal ready for him, but he had to go back—and went back to Burgh Quay into the recesses of the Irish Press to polish up the Taoiseach's speech that had to be got out next day. The whole thing was reminiscent of Lars Porsena and the march on Rome, and of the messengers being sent out to east, west, south and north. The Irish Press vans dashed out to east, west, south and north and the news was read and they said: “You can send out the station wagons, the highpowered cars, and the mugs will come in to vote now. We get the highpowered cars for nothing from the industrialists. They are pouring into us. The dance hall proprietors will pack in the money for us. We have the posters around the walls; we have the prescription; we have the mixture as before.”
Some years ago, somebody asked the Fianna Fáil leader: "What about unemployment?" and he was able to solve that in his usual magnificent way —"I will do away with it" and it was brought out in a beautiful green handbill—as the Deputy said some years ago, a green bill for a green people.
I have discovered that what is worse than the price put on to these various commodities is the feeling of resentment of the people against the deceit that has been practised on them. We have saved a couple of millions, by doing away with the butter subsidy in order to do away with the levies, so that we can have these highpowered motor cars that Deputy N. Lemass talks about and the fur coats, the mink and the chinchilla and the newsprint. Would it not be better to have left the levies on and to have left the butter at the price it was? Do the members of the Government realise the seriousness of this? Do they realise what is happening in relation to butter? Butter is piling up in the cold stores. Nobody can give an estimate of what it is going to cost to subsidise butter for export in order that we can sell it cheap in England next year and leave our people without it. What is going to be the position of these dairy farmers?
There was a very potent sentence from the Tánaiste when he was speaking on the Budget. Because of the uneasiness of dairy farmers at the present time, and the uneasiness that exists in dairy and creamery districts, a statement must be made by the Government. People are going around and saying we want increased production. We might as well ask it here and now: do we want increased production of butter? We are in a very good grass season. Milk is pouring into the creameries. Sales of butter are dropping in the shops. Butter is piling up in the cold stores. It cost £350,000 for storage last year. What will it cost this year and what will it cost when we bring it out?
Comment on this
You subsidise it to sell it abroad. It will have to be brought out of the cold stores to subsidise and sell it.
Comment on this
I am not saying what I would do; that is for you. You had a question about milk costings down almost every day of the last session, but you have had none down yet in this session.
Comment on this
I consider that this was a very bad thing to do. It was bad economically. There is too much lip service paid to agriculture, our main industry, but the agricultural industry gets it first on the nose when the butter subsidies are taken away. I want this marked in this House and I am going to the expense of getting this printed, when it was not printed in the Press or anywhere else. This is what the Tánaiste said when he was speaking on the Budget and I want every Irish farmer to read and digest it. I am quoting from Volume 161, column 1158.
"It brought the question of the price being paid for milk to the farmer and the price being paid for Irish wheat on to a false plane——"
he was talking about the subsidies——
"It created the illusion amongst those who were concerned with these things that increases could be made without consequences. I am not going to argue whether increases are justified. I think it will be a good thing for the country if it becomes more generally realised that alterations in regard to wheat or milk prices will have consequences and they have to be kept in mind when decisions are being made. It was a completely false atmosphere in which these matters were discussed while these subsidies were in existence."
I hope the Irish farmer will read that because I think they are getting the double blister ready for him.
On the question of wheat and its storage, the position is—and it was mentioned to the Minister—that we have an enormous amount of wheat in store. It was even said from the Government Benches that we have too much wheat. I have also said that there should be a statement made from the Government Benches on this question; do we want increased wheat production?
There has been a great deal of talk, too, about the wonderful policies of Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil has gone back on practically every one of its original policies. For years that Party endeavoured to destroy the Irish cattle trade. For years, they were saying: "Thank God, the British market is gone." Now they are here crying out about our financial position and our adverse balance of payments. Where would we be to day in relation to our balance of payments, were it not for the Irish live-stock trade? The Government intends to spend £250,000 on marketing. I hope that, when they come to spend this £250,000, they will not spend it on footling little things which will not bring in £50,000 a year. I hope they will remember the industry which is bringing in £45,000,000.
I should like the Government to note that practically all our live stock is carried in ships owned outside this country. We have built ships for Irish Shipping but we have not built any cattle boats. Last year, when we could have taken better advantage of the French market, we found we had not any ships of our own in which to send the cattle out. Ships had to be chartered elsewhere. They were, at best, makeshift. Many of them had not been constructed for the carriage of live stock and it was only because the officials of the Department of Agriculture strained a point and, in one or two cases, closed their eyes, that these boats were allowed to sail.
This Budget will have an impact on tourists. We like to give people value for their money. When I went in the other day to a small place that I visit on my way to and from my constituency, the first thing I discovered was that the meals had gone up by 3d. The old prescription—up, and up, and up.
I must revert to this £250,000 for marketing. Many industries here are what I describe as feather bed industries. Some clever fellow came along and he saw something being sold in a shop and he said: "I will pack that." He packed it and he employed 25 or 30 girls in the process. He was an industrialist. He was helped by the Government and he stuck the Irish consumer for another 2d. or 3d. on the article he was packing That is one type. Then we have the actual manufacturer. When the manufacturer found himself protected, he did not bother very much about anything any more. The tariff was a good pistol and he was just another Dick Turpin or Jesse James "sticking up" the public. If we intend to get anywhere with our industries, they will have to be based on export. It is a simple policy to base industry on export. I would draw the attention of this group or committee which will be entrusted with the expenditure of this £250,000 to some industries in my own constituency. There we have a paper and wallboard industry based on export. We have A.C.E.C. based on export. We have Clover Meats and Denny's based on export. We have Waterford Glass. Waterford Glass sets a headline to every industrialist in the country as regards initiative, enterprise and promotion in the sale of their product. Nothing leaves the factory except that which is perfect. It is to these things the Government should look when they go to market.
There is one other matter I must raise and that is the all too common use of the words "foreign" and "foreigner". We use the word "foreigner" as if the person about whom we are talking is so much stinking fish. We have Front Benchers here opening exhibitions and advising their audiences about "foreign" and "foreigners". At the same time, we have to sell our exports to the foreigner. The foreigner is our customer. The man who talks about "foreigners" has obviously a chip on his shoulder. Some of this goes back to our boyhood days when we listened to men talking at feiseanna about "foreigners" and "foreign". It is time we left that behind us. We are proposing now to spend £250,000 of the taxpayers' money selling our merchandise to foreigners. I use the word "foreigner" because of unfortunate force of habit. Let us call him "customer" in the future, and let us remember that the customer is always right.
There was one little ray of sunshine to lighten this all too sombre Budget. The Minister mentioned that £45,000 was being allotted by a benevolent State to Dunmore for ice-making and something else. It was a long time coming, but we are grateful for it. My constituency is a most unfortunate constituency. In it, there is a town called Dunmore and the people there buy boats with their own money.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it in order for Deputy Lynch to go into difficulties which obtain in his constituency and the administration of a particular Department of State? These matters are matters for the Department of Lands, in my opinion.
Comment on this
Deputy Lynch was in order in mentioning the matter, but he would not be in order in going into detail. The Deputy will get an opportunity of dealing with the matter on the Estimate.
Comment on this
I am grateful to the Chair, but I deeply resent Deputy O'Malley bringing me to order or talking about order in this House. Above anybody who can talk about order in this House, I certainly do not want it from Deputy O'Malley.
Comment on this
That is all Deputy O'Malley can do—threaten. I will go back now to Dunmore because Dunmore was mentioned in the Budget. That sorry little gibe will not put me off what I want to say. This money will be very welcome in Dunmore. In the years gone by, we got neither boats, nor money, nor repairs nor piers; but we got the fish. We caught so much fish and we sold so much fish during the past eight or ten years that the Government had to give us recognition. A good deal of money has been spent on the ports. The Port of Waterford exports much more in money value than it imports. We have got small grants from the Government for the improvement of that port. The result of these small grants has been to effect a considerable increase in the earning capacity of the ports.
Lastly, I should like to stress a matter in reference to the dairy farmers. This applies to Deputy O'Malley's constituency in particular because there you have the best dairy farmers in the country. I want to know from the Government Benches are they recommending an increase in butter production? If they are and they have a surplus, what will that surplus be or what will it be estimated to be and who will provide £10 per cwt. to help foreigners to eat it?
Comment on this
What I do not like about the Budget is that it brought joy to the moneyed classes. That is something which is very alarming and it is something which I personally do not like. This Budget is a dangerous experiment. It is the experiment of a strong Government chancing its arm. If they can pull it off, it is all right but if they cannot it may be very serious for the country. I agree that many deserve what they got because they saw what happened in 1952 and they knew it would be repeated. It was repeated and I hope that the blister they have got will be a reminder to them for many a long day.
With regard to the food subsidies, I do not believe they should remain there for ever, but when times are more or less normal they could be taken off in easy stages. They should be taken off to the extent of £1,000,000 or £2,000,000 over the years in order to ease the position, but to take them off overnight on a people who are living on a very meagre fare is unjust and unnatural. It is something a Christian Government should not do.
Bread, butter and tea constitute the normal diet of the worker and small farmer. He has very little in the way of meat or savouries. Bread, butter and tea are the commodities which are struck hardest by the present Budget. If you strike you ought to strike at those who are well able to take the blow. The biggest blow has been given to the old age pensioner and the widow. The Budget has taken almost 5/– per week off them. That is the biggest insult which ever took place in this country and it will not go unanswered.
This Budget will start a chain reaction and, if it does, it can have very serious consequences. We will have another round of wage increases. I am certain about that because the people who are fleeced will not take it lying down. We are playing to the Left Wing. The Connolly Clubs are not only very active in Britain but in Dublin and we are playing into their hands. We are playing with fire and we are giving those clubs the opportunity they sought for almost 20 years.
A Budget debate to my mind is always more or less unreal. There are too many pious platitudes from every side of the House. I am a member of the House for very many years and I am sick of this annual rehash. We have Deputy Corry lambasting everybody in a most unreasonable and unnatural way. It is time we adopted a calm and dignified way of discussing the affairs of the nation in this House. It is time that Deputies of that type should be reasonable and sensible. If they cannot be so, their leaders should endeavour to bring them to their senses so that they will debate matters on their merits and nothing more.
A change of Government often brings results but I do not think we will have any results from this change of Government or from this Budget. What the country needs is not so much a change of Government as a change of heart. As one who lives in the country, I can say that apathy exists on all sides no matter what Government is in power. Political insincerity is the cause of most of it. Our people are always told, when there is an election in the offing, to expect big things. When the election is over and the Government returned, the bark is the same again. Very little is done. That is why the people are restive at the present day.
As one of those who speaks his mind, I say that what is wrong with the country is the battle for political supremacy which has been going on for the past 35 years between two gigantic Parties trying to gain control. That has a good deal to do with it. If we could break that up and get a national Parliament of the right type we would forget those old bitternesses, strifes and jealousies and get down to hard work.
Comment on this
This House never got down to work for the past 30 years, and hence we have the flight from the land and emigration to England, America and elsewhere. There is plenty of room in this country for all our people and for more if we had them. This is not a country that is down and out. We have no need to be down and out and there is plenty of money in this country if we try to harness it and employ it properly. Looking back over the years, I would say that this House is the cause of our whole national weakness. We started off 20 or 25 years ago with doles, social security and so on. All these were political palliatives to gain votes.
The dole should have been abolished years ago. The dole is the biggest curse this country has had to endure over a long number of years. I believe that money should be given to a man genuinely unemployed, but in many of our big towns and cities we are giving out doles to men who do not need them —men who could get work if they looked for it but they do not look for it. An honest workingman will seldom be without work. He will go and seek it.
Comment on this
I should like the present Government to investigate the matter of the dole and see whether claims are genuine in all cases. There is an enormous amount of abuse over a long number of years and a vast amount of money is being wasted. Many of the smaller type of grants are a waste of money since they take too many supervisors and officials of all types to work.
Comment on this
The same can be said about social security. I feel we are bringing our people not social security but social insecurity. If we had never heard of the Health Act, I am satisfied this would be a far better country.
Then we have children's allowances. It is criminal to give men money to rear their own children, if they do not need it. I know of people who have never touched the children's allowances which were paid to them. They are banking that money because they do not need it. It would be far better, instead of giving such well-to-do people these allowances, if we doubled the children's allowances payable to the poor.
The trouble with this country is that there is too much wasting of public money and too little sincerity. That is the reason why the nation is going down. At almost every step, there is national demoralisation. We now have a strong Government in office. They should utilise their strength to right the wrongs in our economy.
People are fleeing from the land. These people are not fleeing of their own free will. We are forcing them to go. The moneyed class is as strong and as vigorous as ever. We have the ranchers and other people with money to burn who will not invest one penny in an Irish loan and who invest all their money on the other side of the water.
Comment on this
We should curb that tendency on the part of those people. Is it not time that some of that money was invested here? These are the things that count and, for want of being rectified, are responsible for bringing this country down. This strong Government should get down to bedrock, face realities and get away from political play-acting. If taxes must be increased, they should not fall heaviest on the old, the sick and the infirm but on shoulders best able to bear them.
This Budget is a cruel injustice on the people and it is a cruel injustice on members of the Fianna Fáil Party because I know they did not expect it. It is playing up to the moneyed classes. Read the Irish Times or any of the British newspapers. You will find flattering references in them to the sincerity of the present Taoiseach and his Government. He has played up to the moneyed classes, to the Jews, to the Masonic Order, but not to the old people or to the sick or to the infirm.
Comment on this
They are there all right, and there would be no need for them if the others were not there.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is the Leas-Cheann Comhairle going to permit Deputy O'Malley to make that interruption concerning the Knights of Columbanus? It was an unjust, wrong and ignorant interruption.
Comment on this
The Chair cannot see anything disorderly in the Deputy's remark, but it was a disorderly interruption.
Comment on this
It was made from pure ignorance and I accept it from an ignorant man. When I look through the Budget and find an exemption of duty on high-powered cars, television sets and wireless sets, what must I conclude? Must I not conclude that we are playing into the hands of the big monopolists, Jews and Masons? I am not afraid to say it. Who are the directors of those big monopolies who are able to force a Government to do that? Certainly, it is something worth thinking about. They are playing up to the money changers and the international Jews, and nobody else. It is humiliating that this Parliament must become a tool of those exploiters. One hears a lot of platitudes about "Dear old Ireland" from the Government side of the House but they are a gang of impostors and nothing more.
Comment on this
I have listened to most of the Opposition speeches on this Budget and I am very sorry to say that, up to the present, not one speech has contained anything like a constructive suggestion. All the time the cry has been about "the appalling Fianna Fáil Government" and the "hardships" they have imposed on the poor sections of the community, and so forth —a typical Giles cartoon.
I am sorry the former Minister for Justice, Deputy Everett, is not in the House at the moment. He was a bit of a prophet when he spoke at Bray in February, 1957, according to the report of his speech which appeared in the Press on the 18th of that month. He must have realised, in view of his statement then, how bad, in actual fact, was the condition of the State's finances. We read in the Cork Examiner of 18th February, 1957:—
"Mr. Everett, Minister for Justice, at Bray yesterday said that it was certain that if by some trickery or deceit, Fianna Fáil should win this election and sneak back to power they would abolish all food subsidies and instead of from 3/6 to 3/9 for a lb. of butter we would pay 4/3 or 4/4, and the 2-lb. loaf of bread would be increased from 9d. to 1/1. That was not the only way in which Fianna Fáil would attack the workers and the poor."
We have heard members of the Opposition—Deputy Everett himself and the illustrious Deputy Giles—suggest that these increases work out at 5/– per week, or something like that. I cannot fathom how this figure is arrived at, so far as the removal of the subsidies is concerned. Here is what Deputy Everett had to say last February when he was Minister for Justice in the Coalition Cabinet, after forecasting the exact increases:—
"That meant that old age, widow and blind pensions will be reduced by 1/3...weekly."
We gave one shilling to those people. We do not say it is as much as we should like to give them. Evidently, however, according to Deputy Everett's calculations, they are at a loss per day of three-sevenths of one penny. So much for that.
Deputy Everett was not as successful in all his forecasts as he was on the question of the removal of the subsidies. Furthermore, despite those forecasts from a responsible Minister of State in the Coalition Government, the people of the country must have said to themselves: "The position must indeed be very acute with the National Exchequer," and decided to vote for Fianna Fail.
Deputy Everett, the then Minister for Justice, was not very successful with this prophecy:—
"The Deputy Leader of that Party——"
that is, the Fianna Fáil Party——
"——had also stated that in addition to existing taxes everybody's income should be further taxed at the rate of one shilling in the £1. That meant that old age, widow and blind pensions would be reduced by 1/3 or a worker earning £5 would have to pay a weekly tax of 5/– before he could take home his wages."
So much for Deputy Everett's remarks. I shall quote now some remarks made by the former Tánaiste, Deputy Norton, whose utterances are very well known throughout the State. When subsidies were introduced for the first time by Fianna Fáil in 1947, due to the circumstances which obtained at that time, this is what Deputy Norton had to say:—
"I think these are sham reductions. I do not think they make any perceptible contribution to relieving the plight of the ordinary working people to-day and they make a less perceptible contribution in the circumstances in which they are offered. I took the trouble of trying to calculate hastily what the reductions in the prices of tea, bread and sugar mean to a family of six people."
He then said that a family of six would save 3/10½d. He pooh-poohed the idea. Then he continued:—
"One would think from these proposals that our people live on bread, tea and sugar and it would seem that this represents the Government's ambition from the point of view of the average person's diet."
The members of the Labour Party and their quondam colleagues in the Fine Gael Party have evidently entirely different views to-day.
I trust I shall have some constructive suggestions to offer to the Minister without replying to all the futile arguments and speeches that I have heard from members of the Opposition. The butter subsidy question was mentioned by Deputy T. Lynch of Waterford, who wanted to know what the Government intended to do about the matter. It is quite obvious to anyone that the question of the dairying industry is one which will, of course, require the immediate attention of the Government. It is a very serious problem and one which costs the State a substantial amount because of the necessity to subsidise the export of butter annually. The output of milk at the present time has risen to figures which, it is said, are unsurpassed.
I ask the Minister to bear in mind that the Government might consider subsidising the export of chocolate crumb. I say that because, comparatively speaking, the margin required for chocolate crumb to get into the British market competitively is much less than in the case of butter and as we all know the amount of milk used by the chocolate crumb factories in the past was tremendous, and in my opinion, it is a matter which should get very serious consideration. It would give employment at home; it would help the existing chocolate crumb factories, which to a certain extent have fallen on lean days, particularly those who did not have sufficient foresight to manufacture powdered milk or other products which some of the more adventurous sections of the dairying industry have produced. I would ask the Minister to bring this suggestion to the attention of the Government.
The Minister, during his speech, congratulated the former occupant of that office, Deputy Sweetman, on the success of the prize bonds. Undoubtedly Deputy Sweetman deserved those congratulatory remarks on the success of the Prize Bonds per se, but I should like to ask the Minister and the House whether or not it was a wise thing, in fact, to have introduced this scheme of prize bonds here? To me it appears that henceforward we can never again hope to see, irrespective of what Government is in power, a National Loan having the same success as in the past. The prize bond system is far too attractive to the ordinary man in the street, and even to the big companies—the figures that were given showed the proportions of those who subscribed from all sections of the community. I do not think, in view of the continuation or the expected continuation of the prize bond scheme, that those people will ever again contribute substantially to what we know as National Loans.
Comment on this
I sincerely trust it is tripe, but in the Investors' Chronicle of November 10th, 1956 the opinion of a very eminent economist who wrote an article on premium bonds—or prize bonds; the system differs very little in its operation in Britain——
Comment on this
Possibly, but they are one and the same thing. There might be a difference in the amount of the prize money and the timing of it. This economist suggested in his article:—
"It is clear that these premium bonds are a system of siphoning off funds from bank deposits and, indeed, other investments, but it is too early, perhaps, to judge what effect it is having, or will have, on other forms of old savings or, to what extent, indeed, the campaign is attracting new savings."
My opinion counts for little, but certainly I should not care under any circumstances, and considering the position of this country—what one might describe as the critical condition of this country—to adopt this scheme. I only hope that the fears which I have expressed here are what the Minister says—tripe. I certainly hope I am talking complete and utter tripe.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy directing his mind into the past or the future when he describes me as Minister?
Comment on this
I am not speaking of the present Minister. Deputy O'Sullivan in his contribution here added to the wails of his colleagues about the hardships caused by the Budget to the oppressed sections of the community. He had no constructive suggestion to add but he discovered one gem, and he flattered me as I was the only member of the Fianna Fáil Party that he could quote. The only thing he could quote was a speech by me in which I suggested that if the Government wanted to economise they should amalgamate the Departments of Justice and Defence and have the one Ministry.
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman should agree that the present Government has succeded in reducing the number of Ministers. Deputy O'Sullivan wanted to know, now that we were in power, why we did not amalgamate the Departments of Justice and of Defence but Deputy O'Sullivan forgot to quote me on another occasion. Last year on the Financial Resolutions I said, while dealing with the deficit, in Volume 150, No. 9, of the 11th May, 1955, at column 1263:—
"The deficit, under what you might term a 1954 Fianna Fáil Budget, was brought down to negotiable proportions—£5,500,000. As the Minister said, the receipts from abroad virtually balanced these external payments. He continued by expressing the hope that our exporters, with the assistance of Córas Tráchtála, would increase their business. Yet no concession has been given."
No concession was given in the Budget of that year. I continued, and Deputy O'Sullivan did not think it worth his while to refer to this matter:—
"In my view, that is one of the most unfortunate features of this Budget. I am not dealing now with the increase for... I welcome these increases, such as they are. I am dealing now with a certain matter of Government policy which affects everybody in this House. It is all right for a Minister to speak at a public dinner or to open a factory and to express the sentiment that it is only by increased productivity that we can improve the standard of living in our country. There is no incentive whatsover to industrialists in this Budget such as some tax concession. I am not speaking specifically now about the wear and tear allowance. I have in mind some tax concession for those who might be engaged in industry in the export line. I do not see any concession given—and the facilities of Córas Tráchtála are there and the co-operation of Córas Tráchtála is there.
Where is there any remission in tax by the Government to exporters? I say that such a remission could be given. The Minister may say it would be a complicated issue to differentiate between the proportion manufactured by the concerns for home consumption and the proportion manufactured by the same concerns for export. There is the hope that this body which is examining industrial profits and so forth——"
The former Deputy, Mr. S. Collins, interrupted to say:—
"Is the Deputy looking for an export subsidy?"
I concluded by saying:—
"All Governments are agreed that in this country it is necessary to bring down as much as possible the cost of commodities for export in order that we may become competitive in the export market. I am suggesting that, in order to encourage exports, the Minister should give such a concern a reduction in taxation, or some such thing."
The fact that in this Budget the Minister for Finance, Deputy Ryan, has seen fit to give these concessions shows that, as it has been described by all responsible newspapers and by those who are regarded as holding responsible views, it is indeed a realistic Budget.
Deputy Everett spoke about subsidies. I referred to him previously. He said that neither he nor his colleagues would dream of entering a Government whose policy was to remove the subsidies. I would impress on the House that it appears that Fianna Fáil will be the Government of this country for the next 50 years or at least for a considerable period, because——
Comment on this
It is quite clear that there will not be any country long before that if Fianna Fáil remain in office.
Comment on this
Now where is the sabotage that Deputy Sweetman cried about? Is it not very clear that if Deputy Everett and his colleagues will not agree to join Fine Gael who advocate the removal of the subsidies by degrees, over, evidently, three or four years, there is a deadlock on that side of the House, as there was, of course, long before they left office?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean to tell us that Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Lemass are in agreement on all things?
Comment on this
Who, in the name of goodness, agrees on all things? People have differed from me on occasions.
Comment on this
There is another matter that I should like to bring to the attention of the House. Deputy Everett chose to interrupt with the cliché that is adopted, particularly by the Labour Party when they do grace us with their presence—"what about the Wages Standstill Order?" In May, 1954, Deputy Norton broadcast from Radio Éireann on behalf of the Labour Party and again made reference to the Wages Standstill Order and, by implication, innuendo or otherwise, suggested to his audience that this was an act of Fianna Fáil further to deprive the worker of enjoying a reasonable standard of living. It is about time that the Labour Party shut their mouths once and for all on this issue because the suggestion that the Wages Standstill Order was to hit the workers and to prevent their enjoying a reasonable standard of living is not true.
Comment on this
The Present Taoiseach as quoted, naturally, in the Irish Press of the 15th May, 1954, had this to say:—
"Mr. Norton makes again, in his broadcast, a statement which he made in March, 1950, and which Mr. Costello had at that time to repudiate, namely, that it was the Coalition Government that abolished what Mr. Norton called ‘the Fianna Fáil wage standstill policy'.
The Order restricting wages was abolished by us long before we left office. It had, during a number of war years, helped to keep prices at a stable level, from which the families of the workers benefited most.
But need I deal with Mr. Norton's broadcast further? Not a single practical or constructive hint is given in it as to how the objectives which he says he has in mind, are to be reached."
Comment on this
I shall give the Deputy a quotation showing what the leader of the Fine Gael Party had to say about subsidies.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan was not so very successful in the last three years and everything is coming back to his own door.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy spoke at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis on the 16th February, 1950. That is seven years ago and consider all the time he had to act since. He said:—
"A good deal of money is being given out to those who could well afford to do without. There must definitely be a reduction in the burden of subsidies on our people."
Comment on this
Why does the Deputy put it away so quickly into his pocket? Why does he get his notes printed? I can see from here that it is printed.
Comment on this
These interruptions should cease. I have given the date, the year and the occasion when Deputy Mulcahy made these remarks.
Comment on this
I am quoting from a speech made at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis. It is an extract from one of the daily newspapers.
Comment on this
Which newspaper? Why does the Deputy not tell the truth, that it is from Fine Gael digest?
Comment on this
Bionn an fhírinne searbh, go mór mhór dón Teachta. Deputy Mulcahy was not alone in his views. The former Attorney-General, Deputy McGilligan, waxed eloquent on 3rd February, 1951, and, in case I should be asked the source of this, it is from an article written in the Statist of that date. In the course of that article, Deputy McGilligan wrote:—
"Indeed, many economists hold that taxation cannot, without ill effects, be allowed to exceed 25 per cent of the national income. Fortunately, we are still within that limit, but when the upward trend in prices, in social services and in debt charges is considered, it is difficult to find means of easing the tax burden or even of keeping it within present limits.
In the past two years £3,000,000 has been saved on food subsidies by various means, in particular by marketing quantities in excess of a reasonable ration at economic prices. This year sugar is no longer being subsidised. Given an improvement in production and relative stability of prices, subsidies could be further reduced without hardship to any class and the burden of taxation correspondingly lightened."
That was Deputy McGilligan on subsidies. Does Deputy Sweetman think it fair or in the national interest to have allowed his followers to agitate for and to have encouraged the workers to seek increased wages? I can recall Deputy Sweetman in the first Budget he introduced in this House talking about the necessity for having stability in wages. Surely now he ought to curb the tongues of his followers in the national interest about which he waxed so eloquent in the past. If he thought, before he left office, that the position as such was satisfactory, then I should like him to refer to this matter of grave importance.
I understand that as a result of the removal of the subsidies the index price will be increased by 4½ points. We have had nothing but speeches from the Fine Gael Benches referring to the coming sixth round of wage increases. I do not know whether or not that will materialise. I presume that everybody in this House and every Government wishes to see the workers getting an honest wage for their daily work. I am just bringing it to the Minister's attention that, when in power and acting as Minister for Finance and in a responsible position, he cannot allow his followers to speak in a manner, which, to say the least, lacks responsibility.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance will be very cross with the Deputy when he reads that in the Official Report.
Comment on this
It would be interesting to know if Deputy Corish, who has already spoken in this debate or his colleagues, remember how the smaller loaf came about. Is that forgotten? Is the history of that forgotten? It would be interesting to know if the people who they now suggest are so badly hit by Fianna Fáil, due to the increased cost of bread, have anything to say now about the near £1,000,000 saved on that occasion, by reducing the size of the loaf?
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman knows I am correct, and, because I am correct, he will not please me to say I am. In the Statistical Abstract recently published, we can see that, compared with 1954 when we left office, the financial position and the position of the country from the industrial and agricultural viewpoints are not at all favourable. The slogan of the Minister for Agriculture of the time was: “One more cow, one more sow, one more acre under the plough.” Studying the Statistical Abstract, we can see that, compared with 1954, there were never fewer cows in the country, never fewer sows and never fewer acres under the plough or the tractor.
Comment on this
If Deputy Sweetman would only get correct the quotations of statements he suggests the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce made, he might be better off. Who, might I ask, on this side of the House, said that there was too much wheat? You see, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, when I take up the book to quote, I silence that side of the House.
Comment on this
No. Let us look at the present employment position as compared with that of 1954. This time, when we took over office on March 20th, everyone knew what the position was. The housing position was one of the contributory reasons for people appreciating, for the first time, that something would have to be done and done by a conscientious and united Government. The records of the debates in the House in December, 1956, show that the last Government brought the housing industry almost to a standstill. This industry is the largest after agriculture; it is an industry which gives employment to so many and an industry on which so many other businesses, such as hardware merchants, builders' providers and timber merchants, are dependent. This industry was brought virtually to a standstill by the previous Government. That is another section of private enterprise the position of which to-day compares so badly with that which it occupied at the time we left office in 1954.
This is not the first time we had to clear up such an appalling mess but it will be the last time. We can assure the Opposition of that. For a long time to come this country will have a one-Party Government and, thank God, a Fianna Fáil Government. We recall the Tánaiste's warning in 1948. He told the first Coalition: "You are getting the country in a sound position; make sure you return it in just as sound a condition." We all know that, after the first Coalition were defeated in 1951, they left behind them a deficit in the balance of payments of £62.5 million. We assumed office and continued until May, 1954, when we were again defeated.
At that time the position, comparatively speaking, was sound. The deficit then was £5.5 million. However, due to the inaction of the last Government, we had the finances of the State going completely haywire. It was thrown at us, by broadcasts, by speeches throughout the State from election platforms and articles in newspapers, that Fianna Fáil had supported the Government in introducing the special import levies and it was asked now that the Government had introduced them and that Fianna Fáil was supporting them, what was the Fianna Fáil Party cribbing about? As the Taoiseach pointed out, and indeed as all the present Ministers and other speakers on this side of the House pointed out during the debate when these levies were introduced for the first time in March and again in May, 1956, the action had come far too late; that when the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, and the then Government, saw this downward trend and an indication of adverse trade, these matters should immediately have been halted and not allowed to drift. That was the one political sin which the former Government were most guilty of——
Comment on this
I was attacked for bringing them in too soon by members of your Party. Which criticism is the Party criticism?
Comment on this
I have not seen that criticism. It would not be the first occasion Deputy Sweetman took remarks out of context. I will have to study the speech in question.
As I said earlier, my opinion counts for very little. Last year we had three Budgets. In March, these levies were supposed to yield £3,000,000. In May, the increases on cigarettes, tobacco, petrol, matches, mineral waters, betting and dancing were to yield £6,000,000. In July, just before the recess, we had the third Budget. In fact, it was the fourth; it was the third apart from the ordinary Budget. In July, Posts and Telegraphs came in for £500,000 and E.S.B. for £1,000,000. These measures were supposed to yield £3,000,000. £3,000,000 in March; £6,000,000 in May and £3,000,000 in July. That is £12,000,000 of extra money. I am wrong——
Comment on this
I might be wrong in the figures. According to the then Minister this money was to be disposed of for capital purposes. That is the money accruing from the levies. A comparison of the figure for State capital expenditure for the years 1954 and 1956 shows that the confidence of the people in the last Government had not only been lost but their inaction and inactivity brought about the appalling unemployment crisis we have now inherited.
I almost forgot to deal with this question of unemployment. We inherited this position. I make this statement with a full realisation that it will be trotted up here at a future date: I agree our Party won votes on the undertaking and on the understanding that we would do our utmost to put the people back to work, to put them back as quickly as possible and break the back of the unemployment problem; that we would aim to try and achieve full employment and that we would try to bring emigration to an end as soon as possible——
Comment on this
You were to provide 20,000 new jobs a year. Here it is: "100,000 new jobs in five years."
Comment on this
Is it not a good thing to aim at lofty goals? Possibly one might not reach the summit in such a period but one can achieve a lot. We in Fianna Fáil are aiming at a lofty goal. The primary object of this Party on being returned to power is to break the back of unemployment and to do that as quickly as possible——