We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 152–302 of 302. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I am glad I was reminded of this. We were in office from 1932 to 1948.

Comment on this

From 1932.

Comment on this

The Coalition were in power from 1948 to 1951. During that period, we did not see any of the unemployed throwing themselves on O'Connell Bridge, although unemployment and emigration had reached near record figures. When we came back to power in 1951, we had organised marches of the unemployed; we had them throwing themselves on O'Connell Bridge; and we had the irresponsible leaders, some of whom were members of this House but have happily left, in the background.

Comment on this

Name them.

Comment on this

I do not have to name them. The House knows very well who they were.

Comment on this

Indeed we do not.

Comment on this

If I name them, the Ceann Comhairle would say that I should not refer to people who are outside the House.

Comment on this

That is as good an excuse as any.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Malley, on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I suppose the Deputy will now be throwing out Communist slogans.

Comment on this

It is about the 100,000 new jobs I want to hear.

Comment on this

One of the members of Deputy Corish's Party stood on the Communist ticket ten years ago.

Comment on this

Which one was that?

Comment on this

The Deputy will find him in the records.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Malley, continuing his statement, please.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Malley made no reference to Communism. He did not open his mouth about it. The first mention was by the former Minister for Social Welfare. I do not take any great pleasure in referring to these things. The former Minister for Justice, Deputy Everett, having caused a number of interruptions, to-day said he would leave a number of things for Deputy Norton to speak about. However, Deputy Everett had this to say. I am quoting from the Wicklow People of ten years ago.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

How does that affect the Budget introduced a few weeks ago?

Comment on this

Perhaps if I read it——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy reads it, he will have achieved his objective.

Comment on this

He said there was no man in Ireland more anxious than he was to see a strong and united labour movement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We will not have that dispute dragged into this controversy. It has nothing whatsoever to do with it and the Deputy will desist.

Comment on this

I was not dragging in that dispute. The former Minister for Social Welfare interrupted and asked me if I was referring to Communists.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not follow that line.

Comment on this

What about the 100,000 new jobs? That is what I want to hear about.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must be allowed to make his statement in his own way.

Comment on this

I pointed out that during the first Coalition we had no marches of the unemployed; we had no workers throwing themselves on O'Connell Bridge, organised by certain people now in the House and others who have departed. Now what happens? On March 20th, the new Government was formed. A few weeks later, the gates of this Parliament have to be closed because there is a mass march of the unemployed. As a matter of fact, it was much harder to get out of here that night than it is for some people to get in here. Is it not quite obvious that there is a sinister background to all this?

Comment on this

That is always a good line in this country.

Comment on this

I have no criticism to offer of an Independent member of this House who is entitled, if he wishes, to go on hunger strike, or thirst strike, or any other kind of strike. That is no concern of mine. But the people of this country are well aware of what is behind this. When those people arrived at the gates of this Parliament, they did not ask if they might see a member of the Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not discussing the activities of whatever body marched towards the gates. I suggest the Deputy should deal with the matter before the House — the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

And I respectfully submit that, in dealing with the very grave problem we have inherited, I am entitled to say that the problem will not be solved by the irresponsible actions of certain parties and by the marchings which took place the week before last. As I have said, it is notable that these people did not seek an interview with the Taoiseach. They sought an interview with Deputy Denis Larkin.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must proceed along the normal lines of dealing with the Budget, or he must desist.

Comment on this

He prefers to make a dirty speech.

Comment on this

I want to point out that members of the Labour Party, when they were appointed Ministers of the previous Government, did not——

Comment on this

Refuse to see anybody.

Comment on this

——see any of these representatives of the unemployed. If they did, they were not very successful.

Comment on this

They did not hide on them.

Comment on this

No one in our Party ever hid.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance did that night.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The matter of interviewing the deputation from the unemployed is purely one of administration for the Government in power at the moment and has nothing whatsoever to do with a debate on the Budget.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling, but I respectfully submit that the conduct which took place——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have told the Deputy that is a matter of administration.

Comment on this

As I was saying ten minutes ago when Deputy Corish interrupted me, we have inherited this problem. Agricultural output is substantially lower than in 1954. Industrial output is much lower. The balance of payments position is much more critical than in 1954, when the deficit was £5.5 million.

Comment on this

The estimated deficit when I came into office was a great deal more than £5,000,000.

Comment on this

When Deputy Sweetman went into office, there was a deficit of, I think, £5.5 million in the balance of payments——

Comment on this

That was after I had been there for six months. When I came in it was £15,500,000.

Comment on this

£15,500,000. As usual, Deputy Sweetman is totally incorrect in his statements. I have shown, from agriculture and industry, from the employment point of view, from the emigration and the balance of payments, that we have inherited a position of a crisis status. I have no hesitation in saying that one of the main reasons why we have 78 seats in this House to-day is—I can be quoted at future elections if Deputies so wish—that the people look to a Fianna Fáil Government to solve this unemployment problem.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy said that on several occasions. I suggest he should not repeat himself.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He should try to travel new ground in dealing with this Budget.

Comment on this

I may also mention, Sir, to Deputy Sweetman, and he might also mark that in his coming reply——

Comment on this

I am not the person replying. The person in the dock is the Minister over there.

Comment on this

The person in the dock will be acquitted.

Comment on this

A suspensory sentence.

Comment on this

The savings in 1954 were £38.4 million and the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, had to admit that those had dropped 50 per cent. to £17,000,000 in 1955. The capital expenditure went down considerably. The main cause of that was the inaction of Deputy Sweetman in failing to bring in remedies, which he called the special import levies, in time. Too little, to late. We in Fianna Fáil maintained that there was never any necessity for the levies. If the former Minister had acted in a proper manner immediately he assumed office in 1954, we would not have been faced with the indirect taxation which those levies imposed and the resultant unemployment in many industries to-day.

Since we have assumed office, at least we have removed some of those levies in order to alleviate unemployment; and possibly in the future more of those taxes will go. If the Minister of the time had moved in a proper manner, we would not have found ourselves in our present position.

I asked Deputy Sweetman, when he was Minister, dealing with the question of tourism, if he would ensure that tourists who purchased goods in Dublin could have them forwarded direct, as they do in every other country in the world.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is getting into administration.

Comment on this

I hold the former Minister for Finance responsible for what I have now said.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will get an opportunity of making whatever suggestions he thinks desirable on an Estimate. This is not the proper place to make suggestions on administration.

Comment on this

It is not a question of administration.

Comment on this

It is terribly interesting.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It may be interesting, but these observations should be made on some other occasion.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, if Deputy Sweetman were here he would see that from my Budget speech in 1955 the Minister for Finance, Deputy Dr. Ryan, has adopted two of my suggestions which Deputy Sweetman laughed to scorn.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy can give himself that testimonial on an Estimate.

Comment on this

I want to point out that, in my respectful opinion, the Minister for Finance is the responsible person to deal with the matter to which I am now referring.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not deal with matters of administation in this debate.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He should proceed on that instruction.

Comment on this

With respect, Sir, I am not dealing with administration now. However, I shall leave that point alone, Sir. I want to bring the Minister to task for not adopting another suggestion of mine. Perhaps in the next Budget he will do so. We are told that this is only a stop-gap.

Comment on this

The next one will be the real thing.

Comment on this

No; we are on the way back now.

Comment on this

This is only an instalment.

Comment on this

We are in a period of recovery. There is one thing, the Deputy will never be on the way back again. He had better make himself very comfortable over there in the seat he has now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

These asides must stop. The Deputy must deal with the Budget.

Comment on this

I came in, Sir, to make my speech and since then, since about six o'clock, I have been bombarded with interruptions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Not very much.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell us about the 100,000 new jobs?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Flanagan will please allow Deputy O'Malley to make his statement.

Comment on this

I was reminding him; I thought he might have forgotten.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy need not worry.

Comment on this

Will I tell Deputy Flanagan about the 100,000 new jobs?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will make his statement on the Budget.

Comment on this

The point on which I want to bring the Minister for Finance to task, in the first place, is this. I agree that capital as such cannot be directed and it is a fallacy in this country—when we have Irish people investing in outside securities, outside loans, making investments outside this State—for certain people, responsible people, to get up on public platforms and write letters to the Press—and, indeed, some leading articles by our leading writers have been published—stating that income-tax in some form or other should be placed on the income from such investments. It is obvious that that line of argument is fallacious. It is easy to get over that problem by such things as nominees or by a hundred and one other ways. I think the only way this so dearly sought capital is to be obtained is by offering sufficient inducement to the people.

Those who are conversant with markets in the United States and in Europe know perfectly well—and this has been hammered home by the directors of Córas Tráchtála—that if this country relies purely on sentiment it will not get very far. Therefore, the Minister should give serious consideration to the question of inducing the large shipping companies and ship owners—the Greek ship owners, particularly—to register their vessels in certain ports in this country. The financial benefit deriving from such a decision would be very far-reaching.

Then, again, the concessions given in such places as Bermuda in death duties and the concessions given in respect of the investment of outside capital all show that Ireland must seriously consider offering something along these lines. I do not see it in this Budget and I am disappointed. We all agree that the Minister for Finance and the Government found themselves inheriting this appalling burden and that they have gone very far towards getting back on the straight road. However, I hope that at the earliest opportunity the Minister for Finance will see fit to offer these revolutionary concessions which would mean so much to us here.

The attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party towards the investment of outside capital has been grossly misrepresented from time to time. I, and I think most of my colleagues, have not the slightest objection to foreign capital as such, but we do believe that that should be resorted to only after all the available savings in the country for such purposes have been utilised, and apparently we have reached that day. A clear-cut statement is needed both from the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce about foreign investments. Let us have it. I know I can be referred to previous speeches by both Ministers, particularly the Minister for Industry and Commerce, but I am not too clear on the exact situation, and I think there are quite a few people in the same position in the country.

The position for the future of capital investment by the State should surely receive earlier attention than it has received in the past by the previous Minister for Finance. I am glad to say that, at least, we have some indication from the present Minister for Finance as to how we stand in the coming 12 months. We have a typical example of the businesslike methods of the present Government in the manner in which Deputy Smith, the Minister for Local Government, within six days of assuming office informed every local authority throughout the State that commitments which had been entered into under housing and some future commitments would be met in full, and that represented a sum of nearly £2,000,000.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should be able to distinguish between administration and the Budget statement.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no use saying "Yes, Sir" without paying some attention to what I say.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy could explain where that sum is in the capital Budget?

Comment on this

What sum?

Comment on this

The sum to which he referred a minute ago. That would be in order, Sir.

Comment on this

I cannot follow Deputy Sweetman.

Comment on this

All Deputy Smith did was to pay out in accordance with the provision I made.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Malley must be permitted to make his statement in his own way.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman has challenged me on the figure I have used here. I stated that Deputy Smith, within six or ten days of getting back to power as Minister for Local Government, issued an instruction to every local authority throughout the State that the obligations to which they had been committed would be met in full, and, in certain cases, intimated that some future schemes contemplated by the local authorities——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely the Deputy sees that is all administration?

Comment on this

Yes, I am departing from that. I referred to this sum of nearly £2,000,000, and Deputy Sweetman suggested that it was his £2,000,000.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy O'Malley did not err, Deputy Sweetman could not err.

Comment on this

With respect, I do not follow that logic. I trust I have given a brief summary of the appalling plight with which we have been faced. I am glad to say that in my travels throughout the country I have seen a new air of expectancy and hope, particularly among the business community. There seems to be a feeling of confidence and a realisation that we have a Government in power who will make their primary object the cure of the unemployment problem, and quickly. Remember Deputy Lemass's words and remember our posters: "Wives, get your husbands back to work."

Comment on this

When is the work going to start? When will there be work?

Comment on this

Deputy Flanagan is the very Deputy who, on the last occasion when he was a Parliamentary Secretary, pleaded, after seven weeks: "Give us time. We are in office only seven weeks and we have done tremendous things already."

Comment on this

You have done tremendous things. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

There is one matter I forgot to mention. I have not the Budget speech with me but I think the Minister for Finance mentioned that we were becoming members of the International Monetary Fund, not the monetary reform crowd with which Deputy Flanagan is connected. I am not conversant with the facilities or loans which this body might offer. Personally, I am against this country obtaining foreign loans as such. There is a big difference between foreign investment and foreign loans, but I understand that the facilities which this membership now qualifies us for are invaluable in so far as we can get information on agriculture, industry and 101 other things. That has been glossed over by many of the speakers here and they do not appreciate what exactly it means to the country. I think it will have very far-reaching effects.

In conclusion, the position is that we will have to put these people back to work as quickly as possible and it is with that aim—I repeat it over and over again—that this Government is working. When Deputy O. Flanagan and his cohorts choose to criticise us after six weeks in office, I would remind him of the inactivity and appalling plight which we have inherited after the past two and a half years of the Coalition Government. The day of the marches of the unemployed on the Houses of Parliament will be stopped, once and for all.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

My criticism of this Budget is based on two propositions. Firstly, I think it imposes grave hardship on the weaker sections of the community and, secondly, it is a Budget which will retard economic progress. I say that the hardships imposed are unnecessary because I believe the arguments which the Minister for Finance and his colleagues have put forward are based on false reasoning. He justifies the abolition of the food subsidies on two propositions, first, that the Government had to balance the Budget, and second, that to balance the Budget, it was necessary to abolish the food subsidies.

I accept the first statement, but I vehemently deny the second. The savings to the Exchequer through the abolition of the food subsidies this year amount to £7.1 million. The Budget proposes to give compensatory relief in social assistance to the amount of £2.5 million and the net gain to the Exchequer is £5.15 million. The Government holds that there is no other way of getting that £5.15 million and that the only way to balance the Budget is to cut the subsidies.

I want to suggest four ways in which this Budget could be balanced without cutting the food subsidies. I suggest that there are at least four alternative methods open to the Minister, if he saw fit to use them, and if he wished to avoid the step of cutting the subsidies. I am not advocating these methods. All I am saying is that there are other methods and that it is nonsense to suggest that this was the only method by which the Government could balance the Budget this year.

The returns for last year show that taxes from import levies came to £4.25 million. It must be remembered that the levies last year were put into force in March and were increased in July, and that the increased levies were not in operation for the whole of the year. It must also be remembered that it is very likely that imports this year will increase over last year. Imports last year were down very considerably and in the last quarter were down 20 per cent. as compared with the previous quarter. It is a fair estimate that over a full year the levies would have brought in over £5,000,000, but they are not going to do it this year. The Government, instead, have cut the import levies this year, some of them, so that on the figures they are going to bring in only £2.5 million.

Had the Government decided to restore the levies, to bring back the levies they had taken off, and to save the £5,000,000, they could have got it from that, by transferring it from the capital account to the current account in the Budget and it would have been unnecessary to cut the food subsidies. The saving of £5.1 million which the Minister had to get, and which he got in the manner we all know, was there to be got by the import levies.

I know that transferring the import levies from capital account to current account would raise difficulties. I know there were grave economic difficulties facing this State and no matter what the Government were going to do, it was going to create difficulty, but I suggest that the Government should have taken the remedy which would cause least social and economic upset to the State. I know there would be difficulties on the capital account as a result of removing the revenue which the levies brought in from it. I only suggest it would have been better economically, and better socially, for the Minister to have balanced the Budget this year by that means rather than by the means he did adopt.

At the week-end the Minister and his colleagues and various Government spokesmen said that there were no concrete suggestions put up by the Opposition in the debate on the Budget. This suggestion was put forward by the Opposition very early on in the debate and it has not so far been answered.

There is another means I would suggest to the Minister of getting a saving of £5.1 million. The grants to the local authorities in relief of agricultural rates amount to £5.6 million. The Minister could have got the money there. He could, if he wanted to, have cut the grants to local authorities. It would have an effect on the ratepayers and on the local authorities and the farmers would have to pay more rates. It would have an economic effect, but the Capital Investment Committee did not think the economic effect would have been so severe. I am not suggesting that it would be the proper method of balancing the Budget; all I am saying is that there was another way of doing it. The Government took a bad political decision, an economic decision that they would not put the hardship on the rural community that they have put on the urban community.

There is another way in which the Budget could have been balanced. Do Deputies realise that there is £5.2 million coming into the Exchequer from taxation of motor vehicles? Do they realise that the proceeds of motor taxation, which is indirect taxation, go to building roads and repairing roads, which is merely a capital item? I suggest it is open to the Government to treat motor taxation as any other form of taxation, and bring it into the current account, and so balance the Budget. I am not suggesting again that this would not cause difficulties. It would mean that there would have to be £5,000,000 found on the capital Budget in order to pay for the roads, but what I would suggest is that it is possible to get that £5,000,000, or what-ever sum it is decided to shift to the current account, from the proceeds of motor taxation and that it would have caused much less social and economic difficulty in this State.

The fourth method I suggest is to combine the three methods I have mentioned. I suggest that there is not a Deputy in this House who is not conversant with conditions in our towns and cities and who does not know that in our towns and cities there are people living on the borderline of destitution. To my own knowledge, there are people going hungry. To my own knowledge, and I suggest to the knowledge of many Deputies here, there are people going cold because they cannot purchase adequate fuel. These are the people whom this Budget will hit.

I should like to ask the Minister a question: what could the Minister do with £2,500,000? Could he, for example, increase unemployment insurance, which he is not increasing under this Budget? Could he increase widows' contributory pensions, which he is not increasing under this Budget? Could he increase the T.B. allowance to those suffering from T.B., to those who will have to pay more for their bread and their butter but who, under this Budget, will not get any compensation? Could he increase pensions to retired local government officials or civil servants who are living on pittances at the moment? The Minister has this £2,500,000 in taxation. He has it in the Capital Account and I suggest that it should be pushed from the Capital Account into the current account and used to assist these people. He has it from the levies; he has £2,500,000 coming in from the levies, being used in the Capital Account.

The Government in 1952—the last period during which Fianna Fáil were in office—cut food subsidies. They agreed then that it was necessary to give compensation. They agreed it was necessary to compensate all recipients of social welfare benefits and not just the social assistance class. They agreed it was necessary to compensate those who were on unemployment insurance and widows in receipt of contributory pensions. They were given compensatory benefits to offset the cut in subsidies in 1952. No compensation has been given in this Budget. In this Budget only that class known as the social assistance group is getting any benefit, and the members of that group are getting 1/– per week. This figure of 1/– per week is based on what I might call a cynical miscalculation; it is based on the average increase in cost throughout the State of the increased price of certain commodities as a result of the abolition of the subsidies. Everybody knows that the poor eat more bread and butter —bread certainly, and butter when they can get it at a reasonable price— than the wealthier classes do. I am of the firm conviction that what the Government has done to the blind, the old, the infirm, the widow and the unemployed by their actions in this Budget is morally unjustifiable.

I want now to refer briefly to a certain aspect of the economic situation which has not been sufficiently stressed. The balance of payments deficit in 1956 was £14.4 million. In 1955 it was £35.5 million. Last year's reduction in the balance of payments amounted to some £21.1 million. But for an adverse movement in the terms of trade, this deficit would have been reduced by a further £7.2 million. Let me remind Deputies now that exports have increased in volume; that in the last three-quarters of last year they increased by 8 per cent., 10 per cent. and 9 per cent. respectively over the similar quarters in the previous year. Let me remind Deputies also of the fact that, for the first four months of this year, there has been an increase in exports by as much as £12,000,000. Whatever economic troubles this Government have to face, they do not have to face a balance of payments problem. The effect of movements last year and the results of actions taken by the last Government are to be seen in the banking statistics, statistics which, I think, are of great relevancy when dealing with the capital sides of this Budget.

It is recognised, in view of the fact that there has not been an inflow of foreign capital, to which we were accustomed, and as a result of the fact that we have not got the American loan to fall back on, that deficits in the balance of payments now reduce the sterling assets of the banks. This, of course, affects their ability to lend at home, as increased banking credit means more cash requirements, which, in turn, involves the transfer of sterling to the Central Bank. But the banks have not that worry this year. The deficit in the balance of payments was dramatically reduced last year and, in relation to their lending policy both to the Government and on private account, they need not fear the effects of that policy on the balance of payments position. Last year, in fact, the net external assets of the commercial banks increased by £2.674 million but that net figure does not give, to my mind, a true account of what happened last year because the banks' gross external assets increased last year by £11,000,000 and the rapid improvement in their position is to be seen when the figure for the June quarter of the last year is compared with the March quarter of this year. In that comparison it will be seen that their gross external assets increased during that period by £17,000,000.

I have always held the view—I do not say this because I am in opposition; I said it also in the last two and a half years when I supported the Government—that the Capital Budget of this State should not be limited by the amount of the annual subscriptions which can be obtained from the public. I welcome the decision of the Government to have recourse to the banks this year to finance the capital investment programme inasmuch as there is a shortfall from direct subscriptions to it from the public.

There are a couple of questions about the Capital Budget that I should like the Minister to answer. First, is the rate of interest that it is proposed the banks should get for lending direct to the Government decided? Is it proposed to pay the banks 5 per cent. or whatever rate of interest is paid to ordinary savers who forgo their income to lend to the Government? Or is it proposed that the rate of interest shall be lower?

I should also like the Government to consider the possibility and, indeed, to my mind, the desirability, of investing some of the assets of the Central Bank in Irish Government funds. I do not think it is justifiable for the Central Bank to have 100 per cent. backing of its note issue in foreign securities. I can see no economic reason, and no financial or social reason, why the Central Bank should not have a proportion, at any rate, of its assets held in Irish Government securities. This is an operation which cannot be done overnight, neither can it be done in one year. But it can be done gradually and a start could be made this year. In that way the capital side of the Budget problem would be eased by the assistance of the Central Bank.

The Government, of course, play a large part nowadays in investment here. It would be desirable if private enterprise were sufficient to do all this, but clearly it is not. Clearly, the Government have to play their part in increasing demand and in bringing about conditions of employment by investing in large-scale capital projects. I think every Government should try to see as much capital on private account invested in this country as possible. The Government should seriously consider the introduction of a discriminatory tax against Irish citizens who invest abroad and not at home. I do not think there would be any administrative difficulties in putting a discriminatory tax on incomes payable to Irish citizens at home from British securities. Of course, I would suggest it be limited to Irish citizens since we must try to get as much foreign capital as possible invested here.

I welcomed the remarks of the Minister for Industry and Commerce concerning the Control of Manufactures Act, because he appeared to indicate that at long last the Control of Manufactures Act will be got rid of. Any step in the direction of bringing foreign capital into the country should be welcomed as a means of giving the necessary employment we all desire. I agree with the Ministers who said that this Capital Budget should be as large as possible. I am not one of those who think that expenditure on so called social capital should be cut down. For instance, I think that expenditure on housing, which is the big item in social capital outlay, must be maintained because of the very serious housing conditions which exist, particularly in the City of Dublin.

However, my criticism of this Capital Budget is that too small a part of it has been devoted to capital works of a productive nature. It is an extra-ordinary fact that out of the £40.99 million which is the amount of expenditure on capital services this year, only a little over £3,000,000 is being spent on agriculture. I have gone through the figures in the Capital Budget—the moneys devoted to the E.S.B., Bord na Móna, the Industrial Credit Corporation, An Bord Iascaigh Mhara and so on.

All these total only £13.69 million so that of the total Capital Budget only a very small proportion indeed is being devoted to matters of a productive nature.

As previous Deputies have said, we are very used to economic platitudes in this House. I suggest there is not a Deputy who is not in favour of full employment, who does not think agricultural production should be increased. Will anybody deny it would be a wonderful advantage to have industrial production increased? Nobody will suggest we should not have as much capital investment in the State as possible. All these matters are of common agreement. I see no point in making elaborate speeches or of occupying the time of the House in saying this is what this Government is aiming to do. We are all agreed on these things and my criticism of this Budget is that these aims, on which we are all in agreement, will not be achieved by it because the financial measures are such as to do the very opposite.

The economic effects of cutting the food subsidies will be very grave. May I refer the Minister to an article written by a very distinguished Cambridge Professor of Economics, Professor Pigou, in the Economic Journal for June, 1948? This was written on food subsidies. It concerned the particular English conditions of that time which were very similar to the conditions with which we are familiar—balance of payments problems and inflationary tendencies in the State. I should like to refer to some of the conclusions which he arrived at in a very balanced type of article on the economic effects of cutting food subsidies.

On page 205 of this volume, he says:—

"In normal conditions, with all essential foods reasonably abundant, and no rationing, subsidies on these foods would inevitably push productive power towards them in a greater degree than people, given their individual post-transfer purchasing powers, would have chosen to push it, had the State remained neutral as between different kinds of expenditure."

It is a fact which we cannot deny that subsidies do have the effect of increasing production on items on which they are placed. Can it be denied that the effect of withdrawing the subsidy will reduce the production of butter? That, in fact, was the effect of cutting the subsidies from 1952 to 1954. The Government preaches about the desirability of higher agricultural production and then takes a step which will inevitably reduce one aspect of it.

May I refer the Minister also to a very important statement in this article at page 206? This is one of the matters on which this side of the House has criticised the Government most strongly. Professor Pigou says:—

"It is common ground, too, that subsidies could not properly be abolished at a single blow, but only by a gradual process. So much being understood and allowed for, how does the case for and against abolition stand?"

Professor Pigou is arguing on purely economic grounds. He says that it is common ground that subsidies could not properly be abolished by a single blow. That is exactly what the Government have done. If the effect of the abolition of food subsidies is that wage earners demand and get increased wages, that, in turn, is bound to have a serious effect on our general economy.

At page 208 of the same journal, the article states:—

"Every rise in money wage rates (without an associated rise in productivity) would push up the prices of goods produced in this country and, even though further secondary wage increases consequent upon that are somehow prevented, the price is bound, provided that the dollar sterling exchange rate remains fixed, to hamper our exports, thus making harder the urgent and overriding task of closing the adverse gap in our foreign balance."

Later on the same page, Professor Pigou states:—

"On the hypothesis that money wage rates do not rise to offset the cut in subsidies this policy, while it would do nothing to modify the disincentive effect of the tax system, would obviously exercise a considerable disinflationary effect."

I believe that, whether wittingly or unwittingly, that is what the Government is doing by cutting the food subsidies. It is creating a disinflationary movement in this State just when we need the very opposite type of policy to bring about more production and more employment. The conclusion he arrived at in this article, page 209, is:—

"Unless the trade unions enter into an arrangement with the Government under which cuts in the food subsidies can be made without consequential increases in money wage-rates being called for, it is almost certain that they will be called for and will, moreover, in large part be conceded. Under the stress of our balance of payment difficulties an arrangement of this kind may perhaps be made. But there are as yet few signs of it. It is a thing to be aimed at. If we can get it, let us begin cutting the subsidies forthwith; if we cannot, for the present leave them alone."

I want to examine the effects of cutting the food subsidies on our economy —firstly, on the very rebuttable assumption that wages do not go up. What will be the effect? People will have to pay more for bread and butter. Certainly, it will have a deflationary effect—a fall in real wages and in incomes, less purchasing power, less demand for the products of producers.

A secondary effect of the cut in the subsidies will be a fall in savings. Of course, the Minister is increasing forced savings by this method, but I think that that will show itself in a drop in voluntary savings. Supposing there is a rise in wages; supposing that, in fact, the exhortations of the Minister are not listened to and that wages do go up to compensate for the rise of 4½ points in the cost of living. Will that not mean another twist in the cost-of-living spiral? Will it not affect our capacity to export? It may also mean that a number of businesses and firms will go out of production because they cannot afford to pay the increases.

I do not know whether or not the Government has examined the economic effects of cutting the subsidies. If they have, I should be glad to know the answer to my suggestions. If I am correct in what I suggest, I think the Government should have done anything rather than take the steps they did, in fact, take.

May I refer, too, to the effect on the future budgetary position of the cut in the food subsidies? Supposing there is no increase in wages: the cut in the price of necessary foods is bound to have a deflationary effect. There will be less money to spend on dutiable goods and there is bound to be a fall in Exchequer returns on dutiable goods. Will this also not affect Government expenditure in future years? There is the first obvious fact that public servants may require and may rightly get an increase in their salaries to compensate them for the rise in the cost of living. It is a first increased charge on the Exchequer as a result of the abolition of the food subsidies. Supposing they do not get an increase in their salaries: still, even if all the matters that are in this Budget are kept next year and the year after, there is bound to be an increase in the cost of Government.

As a result of cutting the food subsidies, the cost of living will go up by at least 4.5 points. The total cost of Government this year, capital and current, is £160,000,000. A 2 per cent. increase in the cost of living means that Government expenditure next year will go up by £3,000,000. If the cost of living goes up, as suggested, all the savings that are being made this year will be eaten up as a result of the increased cost of Government next year and the year after.

I have suggested that there is little use in the members of the Government Party and their supporters talking about the desirability of increasing production and of increasing employment. We want actions, not words. I should like to see them, in their own words, getting cracking. I should like to see them do something that will increase employment and production. I refuse to accept the view that this country is doomed to suffer a haemorrhage of 40,000 people a year leaving its shores and a cancer of unemployment at a rate of 60,000 or 70,000 a year. I refuse to submit to the view that this country is doomed to stagnate in an economic backwater. I believe the conditions we are living in are remediable. I think the years and the passage of time have sapped the vitality of the Fianna Fáil Party and that power over a number of years has in a curious and subtle way corrupted it.

If this Budget is an indication of how this country is to be governed for the next few years, I see little hope of an immediate amelioration of our present difficult circumstances.

Comment on this

I should like to comment briefly on the Budget which has been the subject of debate in this House for the past fortnight. It might be considered very strange if I opened on the note that I welcome the Budget. It might draw a gaze of amazement or wonder from my colleagues, but the truth is that I have very little sympathy—and I deliberately utter these words for the purpose of having them on the record— with the people who voted for Fianna Fáil and who are now suffering from the effects of this Budget. If you sow nettles, you cannot expect roses to grow.

When the people were casting their votes for the return of a Fianna Fáil Government, they understood and believed that Fianna Fáil had been taught a lesson by their defeat, arising out of the 1952 Budget, in the 1954 General Election. The people believed Fianna Fáil had been taught a very dear lesson, that they had mended their ways and changed their political conduct and that their outlook on the poorer sections of the community was a little more sympathetic. That again was reinforced by the solemn under-taking of the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party. The people believed him when he gave his word of honour and his pledge that there was no truth what-ever in the falsehoods, as he described them at that time, uttered in the speeches of the then Government Ministers, the candidates and their supporters who warned the electorate that the return of a Fianna Fáil Government would mean dearer bread and butter and a considerable increase in the cost of living and a considerable lowering of the standard of living.

It cannot be said that the people were not warned of the danger of a Fianna Fáil Government, or that they were not told in advance before voting. They did not purchase a pig in a poke. They were warned by the Fine Gael Party, by the Labour Party and by every other Party opposed to Fianna Fáil. They were told that the return to power of a Fianna Fáil Government would merely prove that a leopard does not change his spots, that an old dog never forgets to wag his tail, and that an old dog cannot be beaten off his track, that if Fianna Fáil came back, their first raid would be on the pockets of the people with the object of leaving the people less money to spend. The object of Fianna Fáil in diving its hand down deep into the trousers pocket of every taxpayer in the country is to make his loaf dearer, his tea and sugar dearer and his tobacco and beer dearer —if he drinks—and leave less money in his pocket to spend; in other words, to make life more difficult for him.

We had Deputy O'Malley quoting speeches made by the present Taoiseach and I asked him to quote—I am sure he had it—the undertaking given by the Taoiseach during the election campaign in connection with the food subsidies. Mr. de Valera, as he then was, addressed the public and his observations and remarks appeared in every newspaper. He said: "You know the record of Fianna Fáil in the past." What he meant by that, I do not know, but that is exactly what he said. He went on:—

"You know we have never done the things they said we would do. We do not want the price of bread, so important an article of diet for the poor, to be increased. We left on several million pounds as subsidy for bread."

Why was he not honest during the election campaign? Why was he not straight and sincere and frank with the electorate? Why did he not say: "All we want is to get into office and we do not give two thraneens after that, and when we do get in, we will give you dearer bread and dearer butter"?

When one compares the record of prices as a result of the Budget with the prices prevailing before it, we see that a few weeks ago a 10-stone bag of flour cost 40/–. It has now been increased to 72/– per sack. Why were the people not told that before the election? We see that the price of the loaf—and I agree with the Taoiseach's statement that the main item in the diet of the poor is bread—has gone up. That is his consideration, and that of his Party, for those who are bread eaters — deliberately without any reason or justification to increase the price of the loaf from 9d. to 1/1½, despite the fact—and this makes it more difficult for us to understand—that one can recall the headlines of the papers on the morning prior to the taking of office in 1954 of the inter-Party Government: "Price of Butter to be Reduced." I cannot understand the mentality of people who put out a Government that takes 5d. a lb. off butter and put in a Government that puts 7d. a lb. on butter. However, if that is the mentality of the electorate, as I said before, they do not deserve very much sympathy. They have asked for it and they have got it, and it is exactly as we told them it would be. The only thing we say is that if we were in office to-day the prices of bread, flour and butter would not be increased.

It is of importance to note that when the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, spoke here recently, as reported in last Wednesday's newspapers, he made it clear that the Budget was not concerned in any way with one penny piece of debt left behind by the inter-Party Government. They left a clean sheet after a very difficult year. Is there a Deputy who can deny that?

Comment on this

There certainly is.

Comment on this

There is not a Deputy who could deny that——

Comment on this

We certainly shall deny it.

Comment on this

——because after a difficult year not a penny piece of debt was left behind by the inter-Party Government. The Fianna Fáil Party have an old way of putting off their dirty work by throwing it on to somebody else, and the first speech delivered—and every other speech that will be delivered by every Fianna Fáil Deputy will be to the same effect —was to this effect: "We have to increase the prices of the bread and butter because the other Government left debts behind." That is an old story. That cock will not crow any more; he has crowed himself out now.

Every Fianna Fáil speaker in the general election campaign in the Mid-lands, particularly in Carlow and Kilkenny, said that the inter-Party Government was wrong in reducing the price of wheat and that when Fianna Fáil got back in office, they would see that nothing like that would ever happen again and that the farmers would get a proper price for their wheat. The Fianna Fáil Government was in office before the seeds of the wheat were put in the ground for this year's crop and yet the reply that came from the Minister for Agriculture was that it was too late to do anything about this year's crop. There was no question of increasing the price of wheat. If the Fianna Fáil Party is so sympathetic to the farming community, the growers of wheat, why do they not, now that they are in office with a bigger majority than any other Government ever had in this country before, show their sympathy for the farmers by increasing the price of wheat and not try to "wangle out of it" as they have done?

It is noteworthy that while the prices of bread and butter have increased, the levies have been removed from gramophones. You can have cheaper gramophones but you must pay more for bread and butter. In addition to that, they have removed the levies from umbrellas. Anyone who wants to purchase an umbrella may have an umbrella cheaper, at the expense of somebody who is paying more for butter and for bread and tobacco. No matter what part of the country one goes to, the indication of a rich and prosperous man's house is the television aerial.

Is it not more important to look after the needs of the poorer sections of the community than to provide the well-to-do people with cheap television? The same applies to private motor cars, radios and fur coats. Last but not least, we can have cheaper toilet paper because the levy was also removed from toilet paper. Our people do not live on gramophones, umbrellas, television sets, private cars, fur coats and toilet paper. Our people live on bread, butter and other foodstuffs.

I am sorry for the large section of the community living on home assistance, blind pensions, widows' pensions, teachers' pensions, Civil Service pensions, local government pensions and T.B. allowances. They will all pay more for food and the necessaries of life in order that the rich may enjoy cheaper radios, television sets and motor cars. But, again, if the Irish people want to see the well-off and the privileged classes with cheaper motor cars and television sets while they are prepared to sacrifice themselves to pay more for bread and butter, that is their business. Apparently, that is the position. Again may I say that if they sowed nettles for themselves they cannot expect roses to grow?

It was all very well throughout the election campaign to hear the speeches dealing with unemployment but we do not hear speeches dealing with unemployment from Fianna Fáil since they got into office. To-day I glanced through the Fianna Fáil supplement supplied with the Irish Press of Wednesday, October 15th, which bore the heading “Full Employment.” The Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce announced another of his plans, not in Leinster House but in Clery's Restauarant. All the promises seem to be made in Clery's Restaurant, if not in Jury's Hotel just as, when Fianna Fáil were last in office, all the plans for the farmers were announced in the Gresham Hotel.

In Clery's Restaurant there was a plan let loose, a few weeks before the elections, to provide 100,000 new jobs after five years, at the rate of 20,000 new jobs a year. I wonder when will that start because I am interested in this. The unemployed are also interested in it. In the course of the Budget statement we did not hear one word of the Clery's Restaurant plan for full employment. I am sure we will not be regarded as inquisitive when we ask about it. May I suggest that the Tánaiste should go to Clery's Restaurant again any night next week and let us know when he is putting his plan into operation, when we may expect the 20,000 jobs per year, where he will get the money for that and the nature of the work? Remember, it is 100,000 new jobs, not merely the filling of existing jobs. That is the plan he announced before the elections.

I am sure that when Deputy Lemass outlined the full employment programme there were many thousands of voters in the city who were gulled, who had the wool completely pulled over their eyes and sincerely believed that Deputy Lemass, as he then was, would provide 100,000 new jobs the moment there would be a change of Government and they said: "Maybe there is something in this. They fooled us before but they will not be so brazen as to try to do it again. We will renew our confidence in them and vote them back and perhaps they will be able to provide the 100,000 and 500,000 new jobs in the five-year term." I trust that when the Minister for Finance is replying he will refer to the Clery's Restaurant plan for full employment and will let us know when this plan will be put into operation.

From our experience of the Fianna Fáil Party, they were never short of plans. They always had plans and plenty of plans. After the change of Government in 1948 and again in 1954, the inter-Party Government pulled some of those plans from the shelves of various offices, such as the Office of Public Works and elsewhere, shook the dust from them and scraped off the cobwebs that had accumulated in the years they had been lying there. Fianna Fáil were always a great Party for having plans but never seemed to put any of the plans into operation.

The Clery's Restaurant full employment plan is to-night as dead as mutton. It has served its purpose, helped to gull the voters and helped to sway the floating vote in the City of Dublin which would contribute a good deal to a change of Government. Again we see that through deceit, through false statements, through false propaganda, the change of Government has come about. No effort is being made to provide work but greater hardships and greater suffering are being inflicted on the people. When the Taoiseach was speaking at Booterstown, as reported in the Sunday Independent of the 12th May, 1957, there was not a word spoken about unemployment or the food subsidies. The only advice he could give the people was not to eat seed potatoes, having a day or two before that announced that if an Irishman wanted to play a good game, it should be Rugby football.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has no relevance to the Resolution before the House.

Comment on this

I respectfully suggest that the head of this Government should interest himself in the food subsidies, in the cost of living and in the provision of work rather than to offer advice on any particular form of foreign sport.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of sport does not arise on the Budget.

Comment on this

The only consolation that could come from his lips after such a severe imposition on the people was to tell them not to eat seed potatoes; seed potatoes were not good for them; they should not eat them and there was no headline in the Sunday Press of 12th May other than one advising the people not to eat seed potatoes. The people cannot now buy flour, butter or bread. Every family in the State will have to cut down on their eating. Then we are expected to put up a fight against T.B. and our younger people are advised by the medical profession and others that they should be better fed, reared in a healthier atmosphere, well nourished, well cared for.

I feel that the home assistance recipients—and every local authority in the country has quite a large number of home assistance recipients on its books—will get no increase what-ever from the local authority. That is despite the fact that the local authorities will be obliged to increase rates because the various hospitals, the mental hospitals, the fever hospitals and the county hospitals, will be obliged to present bigger bills for their foodstuffs. I feel that it was a wrong move in this Budget to increase hospital charges, because again this is an attempt to join in the war waged against the poor. There are working class people, agricultural labourers, forestry workers, road workers and mill workers who enjoyed free hospital treatment before the present Health Act became law. The majority of them no longer enjoy free hospital treatment. A charge was imposed on them by the Health Acts and here again we see in this Budget that hospital charges per day are to be vastly increased. The rates will now be vastly increased on working class people who had free treatment some time ago.

It has been suggested, and I want this again on the records, that, as an alternative to balancing this Budget, the Minister for Finance might consider abolishing the agricultural grants. I want to make it clear that any attempt by the present Government to abolish that grant will increase the hardships on every rate-payer in the country and will be vigorously and bitterly opposed by those of us on this side of the House. I understand it is at present under consideration by the Government. If that serious step were taken, the rates on every holding in the country, from the smallest and poorest waterlogged holding to the mightiest and most prosperous holding in the rich lands of Meath, will be vastly increased.

I advise the Government, for what the advice is worth, not to interfere with that grant, but to let the agricultural community and the ratepaying community enjoy the privileges they are enjoying—and it is little enough they do enjoy. I advise the Minister for Finance and every other member of the Government to keep their hands off the agricultural grant. Any attempt to have it removed will meet with the bitterest and sternest opposition that the farmers and ratepayers can put up against the Government. I trust that the necessary steps will be taken to see that this course of action, in regard to the abolition of this grant, is not proceeded with.

I should like the Minister for Finance to make reference to the question of the wages of workers when he is replying, because, if my information is correct, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, has, within the past ten days, given instructions to a senior officer of his Department to make inquiries with regard to the drafting of legislation for a permanent wages standstill. If that is so, the people should be told now. Can there be anything more severe on working-class people than deliberately to increase the price of foodstuffs and make no effort to provide work for them, and, in order to muzzle trade unions and render powerless their strength and membership, to endeavour to bring in a Bill, as the present Government tried before, to peg down the wages of workers and not allow them to seek to right the position in order to meet the rise in the cost of living? I hope either the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Finance will make reference to that. I feel that the workers will not stand for a Wages Standstill Order. No matter how strenuously the Government may try to bulldoze such an Order into existence and compel the workers to obey it I feel that every single worker will resist it, as every worker should resist the attempt of any Government to peg down wages and keep them down, while that reckless and careless Government allows the cost of living to be vastly increased.

I was interested in the interruptions which came from the Fianna Fáil Party. One interruption which always seems to come is: "We have to try to solve the financial difficulties the inter-Party Government left us in. It is extremely difficult but it has been left to us to do it." If there are any financial difficulties, they were made by Fianna Fáil themselves. When the Marshall Aid money was being spent, the inter-Party Government was in office and in three years they spent £3,000,000 of that money, whilst in six months Fianna Fáil spent £24,000,000.

Comment on this

That is very good.

Comment on this

That cannot be denied.

Comment on this

It can be denied absolutely.

Comment on this

You did spend that money.

Comment on this

Reverse the figures, and it would be nearer to it.

Comment on this

If there is any question of the origin of financial difficulty, I feel it is of Fianna Fáil's own making and it is only right that they should realise their responsibilities in that regard. We read recently in the papers that the secondary schools grant has been drastically cut. I feel that the Government by cutting that grant has betrayed its election promises. It is an important educational grant which should not be interfered with.

If we are to consider the proposals of the Budget, let us reflect for a moment on the increased rate for children's allowances. How was it that out of all social service benefits we have it was children's allowances which were selected? Every person who qualifies whether he is rich or poor— there being no means test—enjoys the benefit of the allowances. Therefore, the rich and the well-to-do benefit as a result in the increase in the allowance.

Why should the Government have increased children's allowances in preference to a substantial increase in old age pensions? A shilling to an old-age pensioner is far from sufficient to purchase his regular necessaries, particularly if he wants to purchase them at the same rate as he did at the old prices. If any increase was to be given to the old age pensioner, it should have been from 5/– to 7/6 per week. No human being can suffer from any greater disability than loss of sight; yet even the blind pensioner himself is given the blind eye by the Government. While he pays more for his foodstuffs and essentials of life, there is to be no increase in his blind pension.

Comment on this

There is an increase.

Comment on this

The same applies to recipients of T.B. allowances and the many other pensioners in the State who are receiving no benefits whatever to compensate for these increased charges.

I feel that the Government is making a serious mistake in winding up the Irish News Agency. I believe it is a wrong step. It should be examined more closely rather than have the country at the mercy of the foreign Press. It is rather late to ask the Government to reconsider the matter now. I believe it was a mistake and one which the Government will realise in the years ahead.

This Budget may be looked upon as a Budget which blisters every section of the community. It is an unpopular Budget, an unwelcome Budget and, as has been pointed out, an unnecessary Budget. I hope it will be a lesson— although a very expensive lesson—to the voters of this country. I hope the people now realise the very great mistake they made. I am sure the majority of them do. I notice that, since the Budget and its new taxes were announced, the speeches from Fianna Fáil Deputies have become fewer and fewer.

There will be far reaching and disastrous effects from this Budget. I can see the small country bakeries closing down; I can see the bakers added to the list of unemployed; I can see business slowing up; I can see the brewing industry affected; I can see less business in licensed premises. This is because there will be a lesser amount of money to spend in people's pockets. One of the most disastrous blows struck in this country for a long time has been struck by the present Minister for Finance in this unpopular and disastrous Budget. It has been put to this House without one iota apology.

Remember the election posters: "Only a Team can do it." They leave the question mark there. If the imposition of such hardships on the people is the work of a team, I can only say that the people at this late stage can compare the record of the inter-Party Government. The inter-Party Government kept down prices. They did not allow prices to be increased one iota, without first having a full inquiry by the Prices Advisory Body, who had to submit a full report to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The principal concern of the inter-Party Government was to keep down prices, particularly of essential foodstuffs. It is our principal concern to-day.

There is the difference between ourselves and Fianna Fáil. They believe in vastly and recklessly increasing the prices of essential foodstuffs, while reducing considerably the cost of luxury goods for the wealthy. I trust that, in the short space of a few months, the people, particularly the working class people, now see the mistake that was made. If this is the first instalment of Fianna Fáil policy for the next five years, I feel it is a policy that will undo considerably the work done by the inter-Party Government. They need never be ashamed of that work; they can be proud of it. As far as our record in relation to foodstuffs is concerned, despite the international situation, no Government in Europe controlled the price of essential foodstuffs with better result than the inter-Party Government.

It is well known that the changes now taking place are not changes for the better. I have considerable feeling for the members of Fianna Fáil behind the Minister for Finance who must defend this Budget. I sympathise with them. It will be a difficult job to do at the church gates; it will be a difficult job to do in the parish halls; it will be a difficult job to do with the unemployed, who were expecting a full employment programme and who are still expecting it.

I do not propose to comment further on this Budget beyond saying it is a black Budget, a disastrous one and a bad one, one as a result of which grave hardships and unnecessary distress will be inflicted upon the poorer sections of our people, a Budget which would not have left its mark on this country if the inter-Party Government had been returned at the last general election, because our concern has always been for the poorer sections, particularly in regard to keeping down prices of essential foodstuffs. I oppose these increases and say again that the Budget is a severe blow to every section of our people but, to those who were tearing up the pavement stones to get votes for Fianna Fáil, all I will say is it is too good for them. They asked for it and they are getting it.

Comment on this

It is rather strange how people can change in a few months.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I refer to the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, and his colleagues. I suppose they are still trying to gull the people of Ireland by platitudes. But the people of Ireland will not forget that when we took office we were facing economic collapse due to mismanagement by the inter-Party Government during the past three years. In 1951 we faced a similarly hard task. It is no pleasure for any of us to increase the cost of living. It was no pleasure for the Minister for Finance to introduce proposals that would mean an increase in prices. We were faced with the position that there was no money left, loans had failed and there was mass unemployment and emigration.

What was the Minister for Finance to do? He could not start out immediately to relieve unemployment. He had to balance his Budget. We found nothing but economic decay around us. The principal industry in the country as well as the building industry had gone. Supplementary grants could not be paid. Hundreds of people in my constituency had to emigrate and try to keep two houses. We are told we imposed these burdens because we wanted to do something against the people. I am sorry we had to do it but there was no other way. We put the interests of Ireland before our own interests. We were big enough to do it. If, as a result of the policy adopted by the Minister for Finance in trying to rectify the mistakes of the last three years, we imposed some passing hardships it will be realised that we did so to stop economic decay. We see what is happening. The marches have started already. Do they think we have a magic wand, that we can bring gold out of the sky?

Comment on this

You said you could.

Comment on this

We were left with a bankrupt State when the inter-Party Government went out. People supporting the inter-Party Government are anxious now to get the unemployed marching again. They want to force the Government into something they cannot do. We cannot make money within two months. The Minister for Finance is doing his best to promote employment. Nobody can ever accuse us of doing other than our best for all sections of our people. We shall do the same now as we did before; we shall try to ease the economic decay which we inherited from the outgoing Government.

It is very hard sometimes to listen to would-be patriots speaking on unemployment and other such problems. We cannot work miracles within two months. In two months we cannot undo the mismanagement of three years. In 1954 we gave over this country in excellent order. The economic trend was upwards. Inside three years you have this decay of which I have already spoken. If we went back to the people of Ireland in the morning they would give us the same vote.

Comment on this

Try it on.

Comment on this

The people would prefer to see us in office. They know that we shall try to solve the problem with which we are faced. The people know that the first thing we must do is to clean up the mess that was left to us. Numerous people had to leave this country in 1954, people who up to then had been engaged in gainful employment. Those people were glad to see the return of this Government because they knew we would endeavour to stop the economic rot. Political freedom is very little use if a high standard of living does not accompany it. There must be economic freedom. That is what we are attempting to achieve. The road may be hard for a little while but by the time the next general election comes around mass unemployment, mass emigration, will not be there.

Any intelligent voter knew well enough where the country was going and that it could not carry on as it had been during the past three or four years. We were told they kept down the cost of living. They did; but they sent many thousands of boys and girls to the emigrant ship and anyone who had not the passage money was left on the dole. In any place where money could be found to subsidise and bolster up that inter-Party Government during those years, they found it. The National Loans had failed; everything had failed and we were the laughing stock of other countries, as we could not manage our own affairs and keep going.

Then the present Minister for Finance came in here with this Budget. He introduced an honest-to-God one. He is faced with a shocking problem and, in face of that problem, he is asking the people of Ireland to accept the Budget in good faith from the national and economic point of view, to give this country a chance of coming back to prosperity again, to lift up the country from where it had fallen, to try to improve the economic life of the nation, to bring back production and prosperity in every phase of our national economic life. That is what we are trying to do. I can assure you we cannot do it in two, three or four months.

There is nothing which would give us greater pleasure than to hear the Minister for Finance, in the course of the next few months, say: "We have succeeded in relieving unemployment to a considerable degree." The only way it can be done is by managing affairs rightly, not by going on hunger strike or playing to the gallery outside this House. The people must realise that we must help one another, that we must help every section, from the agricultural community to the industrial arm.

All we were faced with during the inter-Party Government's term of office was their talk of unemployment, while they were cutting down the road grants, the housing grants and the industrial grants. Anything that was giving any employment worth while was chopped off and certain reasons were given for doing so. From the economic point of view, even if a man has to pay a little more for his goods, I would sooner see him with a week's wages than on the dole.

The first job I would like the Minister to tackle, if he can raise the money to do it, is in connection with the builders and the applicants for houses who have been caught and left in the lurch by the inter-Party Government. They are facing a position here to-day and I will only refer to it in a general way. We have a position in County Dublin where a number of builders have been broken and a number of applicants for small dwellings have made commitments. They find themselves in the houses now——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow the Deputy to proceed along those lines.

Comment on this

I am referring only to a general problem.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a purely local matter, and if I allowed the Deputy to raise it, I would have to allow every Deputy to do so in respect of his own constituency.

Comment on this

I am only citing it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Citing it or referring to it is not in order. The Deputy will find an opportunity on an Estimate to raise the matter with some Minister.

Comment on this

I am citing it only to show another section of our people who were badly let down by the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will not get past the Chair in that fashion. The Budget is a means by which money is collected to meet expenses. On Estimates, one may discuss the distribution or the spending of that money.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling, Sir. I am grateful to you for allowing me to cite it. I have some other points I wish to cite also, but I suppose I had better defer them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have no doubt the Deputy will find an opportunity.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance is doing a good job. I hope he will continue trying to put the ship of State back in proper order and that when he puts to sea the crew will not mutiny, as the inter-Party people did. There is no fear of our doing that, anyway. We will keep together, sink or swim, and we will bring the old ship of State into harbour. The Minister has succeeded in facing up to his responsibility, doing the things the people expect he should do, bringing back our country to a sound economy; and I offer him the heartiest congratulations.

Comment on this

I have a great deal of sympathy for the last speaker, for he is not the only misguided Deputy on the other side of the House who has accepted the arguments of his Minister that this Budget is the first step in a long term programme for the expansion of our economy. We must increase production; we must balance the Budget; we must balance our international payments; we have to coax the farmers and stimulate industries— these are all common ground which we all accept.

The programme which the Minister has put before us to achieve those goals has, to my mind, one very striking characteristic—it sets a completely false scale of priorities. It has a completely unbalanced sense of proportion. The first step which is being taken to achieve these desirable economic objectives is to strike a body blow at the weakest section of the community, the old age pensioners, the unemployed. I wonder if the Minister has any conception as to how an old age pensioner is to survive this Budget on the miserable insult of the increase which has been given—a shilling a week, less than a penny three farthings per day.

We were told that, according to the nutritional survey, it has been estimated that a shilling is enough to recompense those unfortunate people for this increase. That is said, despite the fact that everyone knows that bread and butter—sometimes butter, but more usually "bread and scrape"—is the staple diet of those unfortunate people. Has the Minister any conception of how they live? If he has not, will he invite some of his Dublin colleagues to bring him down to Summer-hill, Gardiner Street or some of our Dublin tenements, where we have 16,000 old age pensioners trying to eke out a miserable existence on a pension of 24/– a week, now increased to 25/–. How are they to do it?

This Budget shows callous indifference to the fate of those people. However little the Minister knows about the unemployed and the pensioners in the City of Dublin, certainly he has plenty of colleagues who, I am sorry to say, I think are guilty of the grossest dereliction of their duty to their constituents in permitting him to introduce these proposals.

This Budget has a far graver impact on the people of Dublin, on urban dwellers generally, than it has on the people, say, in the Minister's own constituency of Wexford. However badly off they are, a great many country people always have a few drills of potatoes or a few heads of cabbage in their back gardens. They are not dependent, as our people in the cities are, on the loaf of bread from the shop at the corner and the half pound of margarine.

In that connection, it may be of interest to point out that the Capital Investment Committee, of which we have heard so much, made three recommendations to the last Government. I think it was the Minister for Defence who said here as a justification for this Budget: "We have been told to abolish these subsidies We have been told to do this and we have been told to do that by the Capital Investment Committee." Whatever else has been done, certainly the recommendations of the Capital Investment Committee have not been implemented in these proposals.

I do not know whether the Capital Investment Committee set any priorities in their recommendations but it is significant that the first of their recommendations was the abolition of the agricultural grant. That has not been implemented. I am not saying it should be implemented. I am inviting the Minister to tell us in replying to this debate what his intentions are in regard to that matter. The recommendations were joint and several ones, as Deputy Costello pointed out here last week. The agricultural grant was to be abolished and the moneys formerly applied to it were to be diverted to a scheme for the subsidisation of fertilisers so as to relate the grant more directly to increased agricultural production. That has not been done.

As regards the food subsidies, the money formerly used for that purpose was to be diverted to the capital programme. I do not think that has been done either. Therefore, it is rather futile for Deputies from the other side to wash their hands of responsibility for these proposals by saying: "That is what the Capital Investment Committee told us to do. It is not our fault; blame them."

The organised workers, trade unionists, will, no doubt, in the course of a few months, cushion themselves from the impact of this Budget. We will have a further round of wage increases, perhaps 7/6 to 10/–, which will have the effect of destroying whatever stability there has been in our price structure heretofore. However, there is one class of persons who will not be able to cushion themselves from this increase, that is the unorganised worker, the middle class worker or white collar worker a section of the community who have to strive more than any other to make ends meet, for whom there are few social services, an independent group of people for whom it is desirable, for social and economic reasons, to provide every encouragement.

This section of the community, wage and salary earners, in particular those who pay income-tax under Schedule E, are contributing a completely disproportionate share of the national revenue. This is the section whose employers return their wages to the Revenue Commissioners, who are taxed in full for every 20/– of their £. They are contributing, it is well for Deputies to know, 27 per cent. of the total income-tax revenue, which is far more than their just share, which is far more than is being contributed by Schedule E taxpayers in other countries in Europe.

The Minister has been enabled to provide certain concessions in this Budget. That is why I say he has shown a completely distorted scale of priorities, an extraordinary sense of proportion. I am well aware it is desirable to rehabilitate industry, to provide tax concessions for increased production. We have increased the wear and tear allowance, which will cost £400,000 in the next tax year. Grave and all as the position of industry is—I am well aware of the tax disabilities under which industrialists labour—I suggest that it shows a completely false sense of values to provide that concession, and to provide £250,000 for agricultural marketing, and £250,000 for an alleged commitment to the master bakers which the last Minister for Industry and Commerce has shown did not exist, while at the same time delivering such a body blow to the old age pensioners, the unfortunates trying to eke out a miserable existence on 25/– a week.

In regard to the increased wear and tear allowance, which is for the purpose of assisting industrialists to finance the purchase of capital equipment, I suggest to the Minister that that purpose would be better served by introducing an investment allowance, an initial allowance on the lines of that made available in last year's Finance Bill for industrial buildings. This wear and tear allowance is granted to far more than industrialists. This increase will not be directly related to the provision of new capital equipment in industry. It is available to people engaging in the retail trade. It is available to the shopkeeper on his cash register and on his refrigerator. There is no particular purpose served by encouraging increased expenditure on such items.

On the problem of tax reform and, in particular, tax concessions for industry, I have no doubt whatever that the Minister, during his term of office, will be subjected to considerable pressure from vested interests of all sorts clamouring for concessions. His colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, will probably press him very hard to make further concessions to industry next year and the following year.

The Minister, in his Budget statement, stated that he was prepared to consider tax reform, notwithstanding the fact that there is a commission considering taxation at the moment. I think that is desirable, that the Minister should express such a willingness not to have himself tied down by reason of the fact that this commission is sitting. At the same time, I would urge that he must not set about tax reform on a patchwork and piecemeal basis; that he must set for himself some scale of priority as to what sections of the taxpayers are most deserving of concessions.

There has been recently in Britain a development which is not without relevance for us here. They had a Royal Commission which produced two reports on taxation. They made dozens of recommendations on taxation which so far have not been implemented. Recently, the British Chancellor invited the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England to submit to him a scale of priority on which those recommendations should be implemented. I think it is very significant that the first reform which that institute recommended, an institute biassed, if anything, very probably on the side of industry, was relief for salary earners taxed with income-tax under Schedule E. As I said, the Minister must be very wary of making further concessions to industry because the effect of those increased concessions is to increase the burden on those taxed under other headings and those taxed by indirect means also.

We have in this Budget an increase in the charges payable under the Health Act, an increase from 6/– a day to 10/– a day. The Minister is saving by this means £90,000 and he has stated that a similar saving will accrue to local authorities. I am very sceptical if any increase will accrue to the health authority in Dublin which is not able to collect the 6/– a day from hospital patients. It would have been far better if the Minister had achieved his economy on the health services by tightening up the administration. Everybody agrees that the Health Act calls for considerable reform and its administration is one aspect which could be tightened up.

In his Budget statement, the Minister drew attention to the fact that diminishing returns have now begun to set in in many of our duties. He commented upon the lack of buoyancy in the revenue. I think it is important to note that in the last financial year the yield of duties from beer fell somewhat short of the Minister's estimate. I think they fell short by something over £100,000. By increasing the beer duty by 1d. per pint, the Minister hopes to get £620,000 in the current financial year. I am tempted to ask whether there is a danger here of killing the goose that lays the golden egg.

It is well to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that in the last year's trading many of the small establishments underwent a period of considerable difficulty. I notice that the increased beer duty allows a small margin for the trade. I do not think anyone will find any complaint with that aspect of the Minister's proposal and certainly the trade is entitled to it. They are allowed a very small margin which has to be apportioned between the brewers and retail supliers of beer. It is desirable to try to restore the buoyancy of the revenue under this head, to stimulate the trade in this respect.

I am tempted to ask, therefore, whether or not the Minister has attempted to consider abolishing the price control on beer in Dublin City and other centres. It was introduced as a wartime measure. This is not a socialist economy and it is hard to see why there should be continuing price control. I believe that the abolition of price control would probably bring about a drop in the retail price of beer in certain types of houses, family-run houses, where the overheads are not as heavy as in other bigger houses. Undoubtedly, we would see, at the same time, an increase in the price in the larger houses.

There is a small point, but, in so far as it indicates an undesirable trend in regard to the beer duty in particular, in regard to the falling rate of return from the duty, I want to point out to the Minister a practice which has developed in the more expensive Dublin hotels where it is very difficult, indeed sometimes impossible, to obtain a bottle of Irish beer or stout. I do not know what form of ignorant imbecility this is on the part of our hotel keepers. I do not know what impression it makes on the foreign tourist. When they visit a country, tourists like to find what they call the wine of the country. The wine of our country is Irish brewed stout. It is impossible to get it in the bars of some better class hotels and it must make a bad impression on our visiting tourists. At the same time, we find Scandinavian and other continental beers, synthetic bilge-water, freely available at fancy prices. I feel that a word from the responsible Minister might bring about a rectification of that undesirable trend.

The Budget proposals have been submitted to us as part of long-term programme. I remarked on the paradox that the first step should be to deliver a body blow to the weakest section of our community. With relation to these long-term plans it is desirable to remind Deputies on the other side of the House of the dictum of a very famous economist: in the long run we are all dead. Certainly the lives of many of our old age pensioners will not be extended by the provisions of this Budget.

It is interesting to note the effect of similar reactionary proposals brought in by the Fianna Fail Government on a previous occasion. Deputy N Lemass, speaking here to-day, produced certain selected figures in an effort to prove to us that, as a result of the infamous and notorious 1952 Budget, employment expanded. That, of course, was not the case for only to-day the Minister for Social Welfare produced certain employment figures in reply to a question tabled by Deputy O'Sullivan. It is desirable that these figures should be put on record again now in refutation of Deputy Noel Lemass's peculiar logic.

In the March quarter of 1952 the number of registered unemployed persons increased on the corresponding period in the previous year by 9,777. In the June quarter the number of persons registered increased by 8,748. In the September quarter the increase on the previous year was 6,700. In the following year, 1953, the increase was even greater. The increase in the March quarter was 25,971. The increase in the June quarter was 26,464. This Budget has been produced in a rush and that, in my opinion, seems to be the only excuse one can make for the Minister, who has, I submit, been guilty of callous indifference in producing these ill-conceived proposals at this particular time.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke was at great pains to condemn the last Government for the alleged financial state of the country. He said that money is scarce for the various services, such as house-building and advances under the Small Dwellings Act. He blamed the last Government for the large number of unemployed. At least one thing has resulted from the previous Government's efforts and that is the fact that no debt was left after its period in office.

In addition, the adverse trade balance has been very considerably reduced as a result of the efforts of the last Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman. One of the measures which he introduced, and which received the commendation of every Party, was the imposition of the special import levies.

They yielded something in the region of £4,500,000 last year.

Deputy Burke also claimed that his Party had the interests of Ireland at heart thereby insinuating that his Party, or he himself at any rate, had a monopoly in having the interests of Ireland at heart. I should like to remind Deputy Burke that we are all Irishmen and we are all doing our best. Indeed, if there was a greater degree of co-operation in the past we might not have so many pressing problems besetting us at the present time.

He criticised the agitation in the ranks of the unemployed. He stated that his Government could not wave a magic wand to provide millions of pounds to give employment. He should ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce where is the £100,000,000 which he was going to provide when he got back to office in order to solve the unemployment problem?

It is true to say that this Budget was received throughout the country, specially by the ordinary working classes, with consternation. It embodies the complete withdrawal of the food subsidies. These food subsidies were introduced in 1947 as a temporary measure and it was not contemplated by anyone on this side of the House that they would continue interminably. But these subsidies had become an integral part of our economy. I consider that it was morally unjustifiable, and other speakers have referred to this matter also, for the Government to abolish these subsidies in one fell swoop.

The subsidies were introduced to keep down the prices of essential foodstuffs. Had their abolition taken a gradual form less harm and less hardship would result. I cannot understand why bread should be hammered. The price of the 2 lb. loaf has been increased by 4d. or, in some cases, by 4½d. That is a very pointed increase in relation to the lower income group where there are very often large families to cater for. The removal of the subsidy on bread will mean an increase for these large families of some 7/– or 8/– per week for bread alone, to say nothing of butter. It is an astonishing fact that the Government did not advert to that before they brought in this proposal. They have given certain compensatory benefits and these benefits will be welcome but they are only a drop in the ocean when one considers the injury done by the total abolition of food subsidies.

Much play has been made with the special import levies. One of the first things the present Government did when they returned to office was to remove certain levies on certain imported goods. These levies, as I said, were imposed by the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, in an effort, and a successful effort at that, to curb the adverse trading balance trend. Now we find the present Government undoing, in part, that good work. They have removed levies amounting to approximately £1,750,000 on certain non-essential imported goods. It would have suited the Government better if they had kept on those levies and applied the £1,750,000 towards the retention of some of these subsidies—at least towards the retention of a subsidy for bread. I think that would have been a good day's work and a step for which the Government would have received credit.

Certain new taxes have been imposed. No Budget is brought in here but there are new taxes imposed. I suppose that is inevitable. Tobacco has come under the hammer again. It is only natural that this commodity should be the butt of every Government. It is an easy way of collecting money. The funny thing about putting a tax on tobacco and cigarettes is that no matter how dear they are the revenue seems to come in from them all the time. That is one of the reasons that Governments turn in that direction. The Government expects to get £1,000,000 in taxes from this source. Cigarettes and tobacco are not essential, I admit, but we must remember that their manufacture has a very high employment content and you may go too far some year and, as Deputy Byrne said, kill the goose that lays the golden eggs. There is a margin for the trade. I suppose that is for the manufacturers and retailers alike as some compensation for increased production costs and also as a compensation for the possible loss of custom in case consumption goes down.

The Minister made reference to agriculture and stressed the importance, and rightly so, of increasing agricultural production. He referred to the amount of money which he allocated for the eradication of bovine T.B. I forget what the actual amount of money was. Everybody in this House and throughout the country, who takes a real interest in this terrible scourge, knows that England and Scotland will very soon be completely free from this disease. Every effort that this country can make to eradicate the disease from this country should be encouraged if we are to preserve the very good market which we have at the present time for our cattle exports, which are our main industry.

I am glad to see that the Minister allocated a sum of money for the improvement of our existing market arrangements. That is very important, especially in the competitive age in which we live. Deputy Byrne referred to the tax rebates granted by the Minister when he referred to the wear and tear allowance on machinery for industrialists. It amounts to 25 per cent. I presume this is the result of a recommendation made by the recently appointed Industrial Taxation Committee set up by the inter-Party Government. It made many good recommendations. We all agree that there is a great fillip and impetus needed for industrial production especially at the present time when we have so many unemployed and when we can envisage the impact of the Free Trade Area on this country.

If our industrial production is not geared to its fullest extent, how can we hope to compete with other countries if we enter this Free Trade Area and it appears that we have no alternative? The Minister gave reliefs with regard to taxes on exports. He gave 100 per cent. relief in that regard. That is a good measure and it should help many industrial firms to step up production because they will be able to plough back into their concerns the money which heretofore they had to pay in taxes. There is one fault that I see in that recommendation. The Minister said that the relief in regard to the wear and tear allowance and the 100 per cent. relief in regard to profits from increased exports would not apply this year. I think that is a pity. I do not know the reason for it. He did not give the reason. It may be an administrative one. I cannot say but in view of the impending setting up of the Free Trade Area, I thought it was a pity that these concessions could not be given this year. This is the year that will count, when industry should be properly prepared if industrialists are to go into the Free Trade Area.

The Minister referred to certain economies he intended to make. That has been the cry up and down the country for a number of years from all quarters, and any Minister who comes in here and states that he intends to make economies in the various Departments deserves the credit of the whole House. With regard to the health services upon which approximately £9,000,000 was spent last year and upon which over £8,000,000 will be spent this year he expects to save £90,000. I might mention in passing that this Health Act since its inauguration has been very unsatisfactory due to the very complex system involved. The trouble seems to be that in each county the various managers have, it appears, different ways of interpreting the Act. I do not suppose I am in order in referring to that but I just wanted to make the point.

The Minister referred to the Civil Service and also to the fact that there are in this small country 32,000 civil servants costing £17,000,000 for salaries alone. He hopes to save £250,000. I hope that his efforts in that respect will meet with success because that is an enormous number to have in the Twenty-Six Counties. I hope that eventually he will succeed and at the same time not interfere, if at all possible, with the existing staffs. I do not suggest that that is his intention. He will probably be able to make some economies by reducing the rate of recruitment and allow an easing off by retirements. In the Defence Department he expects to save £100,000 and in the Land Commission £80,000. They are other good points which are to be recommended.

I notice he made reference to the abolition of the Irish News Agency. Since that concern was set up some years ago, it has gone from bad to worse. It has been criticised from the very start. It loses money hand over fist every year. I do not know a lot about the matter but I remember reading one criticism of it at one stage by a learned man and it struck me very forcibly that the News Agency during its term of office, dealt a very devastating blow to established newspapers, was cutting across their interests and doing them great harm. I do not think the country has lost a terrible lot by the abolition of the News Agency.

As I said earlier, social assistance reliefs have been given amounting to 1/– to old age pensions, widows' pensions and recipients of unemployment assistance. These reliefs, while they are welcome, are but a drop in the ocean compared with the increased money large families will have to spend on paying the increased prices for bread and butter, amounting in some instances to 7/– and 8/–.

I notice the Minister did not make any reference to income-tax in his statement. The recent Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, set up a committee to inquire into the incidence of the tax and asked them to try to devise a method of abolishing this tax, whilst at the same time finding, more or less, the same revenue for the State by other means. The Minister should try to expedite the work of this committee and not put it on the long finger. I also suggest that, when he has time, he should examine the possibility of applying the P.A.Y.E. system in every branch of our manufacturing concerns. The system seems to be working very well elsewhere. It is optional in some cases in this country at present. Some workers, if they so wish, may adopt the system. I believe that if the Minister urged the remainder of the firms to adopt the system benefits would result.

Many problems confront this Government, just as many problems confronted the previous Government. One sure way of making money to run the country's services is to attach more importance to one of our greatest money-spinners—tourism. The Minister did not make much reference to it, if any. I believe that money spent on tourism is a good investment. Every year, we take in about £33,000,000 or £34,000,000. That sum of money would go a long way towards helping to balance our external trade. Last year a sum of £400,000 was devoted to the furtherance of tourism and I hope the same amount will be provided for the purpose this year. A question was asked here last week in regard to the 2/– service charge imposed on motorists travelling across the frontier posts after 9 p.m.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be more a matter for the Estimate than for a Budget debate.

Comment on this

With the permission of the Chair, I should like to make just one observation. The Minister gave his reasons for refusing that request. I suggest he might consider relaxing that service charge for the summer months at least, because it would ease the situation greatly as regards the encouragement of tourism.

This Budget, while showing the best efforts of the Government to solve the problem which faces them, will not be received with much warmth throughout the country. I cannot but wonder whether, if those persons now constituting the Government had told the people during the recent general election campaign that they intended to raise the price of bread, butter and flour, they would now be sitting on the Government Benches and we would be sitting over here on the Opposition Benches.

Comment on this

I feel it is my duty to make my little contribution to this very important debate affecting the lives of all the citizens of State. It is important every year when Budget time comes around to examine the effect the Budget has on the everyday life of the people. One must sympathise with any Government bringing in a Budget and particularly with a Government bringing in an unpopular one.

The Government has introduced a severe Budget which will create very great hardship for all sections of the community. By the withdrawal of the subsidies, there has been an increase in the price of the very necessaries of life—bread, butter and flour—not to mention tea, which is imported and over which the Government has no control, and sugar. Anybody who understands the life of the working-class people—and particularly the unemployed people—and we who live in cities are very close to their everyday life—knows that a working-man living on £3 1s. dole, plus children's allowances, cannot afford anything in the luxury line and that it puts him to the pin of his collar to buy the very necessaries of life which, as I have said, are bread, butter, flour, tea, sugar, milk, potatoes, eggs and vegetables. The House will notice that meat is not mentioned. That is the food of the working-class man.

I do not want to be an alarmist of any kind but this is a severe Budget and it will create hardships. I say, not in any hostile manner, that the Government should not have withdrawn the subsidies. No doubt the last Government could have done the same thing. Perhaps they could have had greater ease in government if they had raised their revenue in that way. Anyhow, I feel it is not a question of putting one Government against another and of what they do and what they do not do. Our first duty is to look after the weaker sections of our community. Unfortunately, for various causes, we had a very bad year in 1956. There are factors outside this country over which we have no control but which affect our economy. Last year, the balance of payments simply went haywire, largely due to the fact that the goods we had to import advanced rather steeply in price, while the goods we exported reduced in price.

Cattle prices fell last year—largely due to the fact that the Argentine Government placed large quantities of meat on the British market, thereby depressing our cattle prices on which we were dependent for the revenue to buy the things we needed. That was a very big factor in the Government of last year and any Government facing that situation faced a major issue. Furthermore, war threatened in Egypt. The Suez Canal hold-up severely affected our petrol supplies and the revenue that would have been available had petrol been in full supply, rather than rationed for a period, was lost to the Government of last year. In addition, the price of petrol increased. On top of that, we had the credit squeeze, as it is called, and we know how severe that restriction was in the case of various industries and business people, and even individuals who were, perhaps, half-way through the process of erecting a house. We know how that credit restriction curtailed operations and imposed a very severe hardship on those people. A Government which had to face all that was certainly worthy of consideration from the people. Instead of that—and I regret to say it—certain people came in here agitating, and demanding that more money be given for housing.

In Limerick City, which I have had the honour to represent, we had no money problems because our housing schemes were always financed through the Local Loans Fund. We did not have to go to the public for funds, but evidently Dublin and Cork and other places had to raise money by loan. Briefly, the position was that in Dublin the corporation failed to get the loan from the public, and the Government of the day had to come to the rescue to supply housing needs. Doing that caused a severe strain on the amount of money the Government had for capital investment. As a result, grave unemployment was caused all over the country because there was not sufficient money available and when the Government tried to float loans, they were not able to get the full amount. The corporation in Dublin failed to get a loan from the public and the Government had to take over. That put the Government in a very serious position, and for that reason, I feel they did not get the support they should have got from certain members of this House in such a situation.

I know it is the practice here that the Government has to answer the questions, and when you are out of the Government, you ask the questions. Then you usually ask awkward questions and, perhaps, unfair questions at times. These questions are usually asked to embarrass the Government. I hold that is not as it should be, because we in our local authorities have a duty and a function to look after the needs of our people. That is why they send us up here. If we come here, I think we should at least be fair to whatever Government is in office, and if there are any reasons why money is not available and if there are economic factors such as those which hit the inter-Party Government last year, I do not think political capital should be made out of them. Rather should we be more patriotic and not seek to convey to the people who are looking for money to build houses the impression that it is the fault of the particular Minister or Government in power that they cannot get all the money they need.

I have frequently heard trade balances being discussed here, and while I do not want to go back over these things, it seems to be always a question of whether it is an adverse balance or a credit trade balance. The position is this: if an adverse trade balance is brought about, there is always some reason for it. We know— and I have heard it said here very often—that we had an adverse trade balance of £62,000,000 in 1951. That is true. But we know that prior to 1951, we had the threat of the Korean War and nobody knew at that time what would happen. It was the duty of the Government then—and the Government did live up to its responsibilities—to encourage merchants all over the country, factories, ware-housemen and others, to lay in stocks of goods that would be in short supply if a major war had taken place.

All those people who were so concerned knew well from their experience of the previous war between 1939 and 1946 what the situation would be if war had occurred, and as a result large stocks were brought into the country. The banks, to give them their due, did not restrict credit and allowed the firms to bring in the supplies they wanted. If we had an adverse trade balance in 1951, we had these goods that were needed and the necessary raw materials for our factories. That, to my mind, was a matter of good housekeeping on the part of the Government on behalf of the people, the industrialists and others who were concerned with having those supplies, should a major war occur.

As we all know, when war breaks out, certain goods are not obtainable, and had we been caught in that position, no doubt there would have been large-scale unemployment. One can guard, to some extent, as far as the resources of the country will allow, against adverse effects of war, but we had another type of adverse trade last year which was very different. It was brought about by the fact that goods that could be classed as luxuries were bought by the people. Goods were brought into this country which would not be in the country were it not for hire purchase. We know that the luxury goods brought in here for the past few years were of such a type that many of the homes that enjoyed them would not have had them in normal times, if they had to pay for them.

To my mind, that situation was brought about largely through housing activities throughout the country. Whenever a new house was built in many cases, instead of doing things in the easy way of putting in furniture and other things as time went on and as the people could afford it, a fellow arrived at the new house and said you could have all you wanted, at so much. It was only a shilling for this and two shillings for that and people thought they were going to furnish a house for a matter of shillings; but every week he came, he brought a new gadget, with the result that he was adding to the bill all the time. Many people got in large quantities of goods in that way and, to my mind, their purchases should have been spread over a longer period. That brought about the purchase of goods that, although in some cases they might be necessary, were goods for which people could not afford to pay. It is always said that anything for which you cannot afford to pay is a very dear article.

That situation had developed last year to such an extent that the Government had to take action and I was glad that from all sides of the House it was said that the Government, if anything, did not act in time. That was a reasonable attitude to adopt. It was only correct that the purchase of luxury goods for which we could not afford to pay because of the fact that our trade had been considerably reduced as a result of the factors I have mentioned, should be reduced. There was a loss of at least £12,000,000 to £15,000,000 last year between the cattle and the turkey trade, not to mention many other lines.

The Government acted wisely in imposing the levies. If somebody says that they should have introduced them sooner, I say perhaps they should. The levies caused hardship in some businesses. They dislocated business and caused unemployment but, if they did, it must be remembered that the levies were not imposed on any Irish commodity. We are all very fond of talking about the Irish language and speaking the Irish language. The levies were imposed, not only on English commodities, but on commodities from other countries that never bought twopence worth from us. That factor should be borne in mind.

One matter that should be put before the House annually is our adverse trade balance with countries all over the world. The Government should not encourage trade with a country that is not prepared to trade with us. It is coming to that, or to something like it now, because some countries are beginning to realise that they must trade with their neighbour and that they must have some arrangement whereby they can get the goods they want at reasonable prices and perhaps in the years to come there may be a development in that direction.

In my opinion, the Budget will cause a very severe strain on many sections of the community, particularly on the poorer sections. One can picture in any city, town or village a poor man with a family and what the Budget will mean to him. He will pay more for bread, butter and flour—the three main items. In many homes there is no bread bought; the woman of the house bakes the bread, feeling that she can do better with a four-stone sack of flour and baking the bread herself than by buying bread. It is all the more credit to her that she exercises all the economy she can in her home.

I understand that the four stone sack of flour now costs 28/–. It cost 17/6 prior to the Budget. That woman has to find an extra 10/6 to buy the flour, not to mention all that the butter will cost her or the tea, sugar and other things that she wants. There is no luxury mentioned in this. I would much prefer to see extra taxation imposed on luxury goods and less on the staple food of our people.

It our duty so to arrange matters that the burden of a Budget will fall lightly on the weakest sections. If the Government had to reduce some of the subsidies, one would not grumble so much but it was too severe to abolish the subsidies altogether. The Government acted unwisely in doing so.

People may say to me, as they do, that we are all responsible for it. I know that the Government are responsible for it and that they have to take the responsibility. While we are here as an Opposition it is our duty to point out the effects of the Budget on the people that we represent and people down the country will express their grievances very quickly. It is only right that we should tell the responsible Minister what the effects of his Budget are. In any criticism that I make I am not making political capital out of it. There are five years of office for the present Government and they have acted rather severely in this Budget.

Another matter that concerns my constituency very much is the price of milk. The price of milk has been a thorny problem in Limerick for a number of years.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not argue the price of milk on this Resolution.

Comment on this

I do so because it has a bearing on the price of butter. We all know that, if the price of milk is increased, the price of butter must be increased. The last Government reduced the price of butter, which was 4/2 a lb., to 3/9. It cost £2,000,000 of the taxpayers' money to do so but it had two very important effects on the lives of the people. One was that it gave the people butter at 5d. a lb. less than it was at the time. Secondly, it was an indirect subsidy to the farming community because the higher you put the price of butter the more you increase the price of margarine. We would be all very sorry indeed to see anything happening in this country that would interfere with butter production, which is an important item in our economy.

It is regrettable that at the present time we cannot find a profitable market for the surplus butter we have now for export. The taxpayers are paying something like 1/8 a lb. to export butter to foreign countries. That is regrettable. I do not want to dwell on that. No Government likes that situation. As it is such an important industry, we must try to see what remedies can be found but I do not think that to increase the price of butter helps the situation. It would have been far better, if the Government could have done so, to leave butter prices as they were.

That might mean greater consumption of butter or it might mean, at least, that there would be the same consumption as last year. It will be regrettable if there is less consumption of butter and if the surplus butter has to be exported and sold outside the country at a much cheaper price. I sincerely hope that the Government will take that matter in hand and that the new Minister for Agriculture will give it his early attention.

As I have said, the butter and milk problem has been with us for many years. A Milk Costings Commission was set up. To my mind it was used politically. I regret having to say that. It was used when the Fianna Fáil Government were in office as a churn to rattle to please the farmers and used, when we were in office, to embarrass us. I am sorry to have to say that, but that is how I feel about it. Milk and butter production is a very important item in County Limerick. I have the honour to represent East Limerick. Anything that affects that industry adversely is a national loss. Limerick City many years ago was world-famous for condensed milk. Thanks to the efforts of the last Minister for Agriculture and the Dairy Disposal Board, a powder milk plant, one of the most up to date in the world, has been installed in Lansdowne, Limerick, at a cost of something like £50,000. That was badly needed because when there was a surplus of milk, it was necessary to have an outlet for it. While condensed milk has not had the market in Limerick that it had in years gone by, we hope powdered milk will take its place to a certain extent. I think the gratitude of the whole country is due to Deputy Dillon, former Minister for Agriculture, for the encouragement he gave the Board to establish that factory in Limerick. I wish to thank him sincerely as the factory is established in my constituency.

I want to relate the matters I had in mind to a particular item. The farmers in County Limerick, to my mind, are the life-blood of the city and anything affecting their interests is worthy of mention in this House. The dairy farmer, the cattle farmer and farmers generally are entitled to the best price they can get for their produce. That applies particularly to dairy farmers. If many of the people who complain about the price of butter only knew the hardships which these farmers have to endure they would not be so ready to complain. A farmer has to devote a large portion of a seven-day week to milking cows; and that is a condition that does not obtain in any other employment.

There is no use in any political Party saying to farmers: "If you put us in we will give you a bigger price for milk and wheat." You can give a bigger price for milk only by increasing the price of butter, and you can give a bigger price for wheat only by increasing the price of flour. As everybody knows, we have now reached a situation in which both milk and butter have reached practically luxury prices. Milk is one of the essential everyday foods and it is delivered twice daily to the homes of the people. Any increase in the price of milk or butter is really a severe blow to ordinary families. I do not want to make any further comment beyond saying that I feel that the former Government were not treated fairly in the past three years by many sections of the people because there was an agitation, which was not honest, to increase the price of milk and wheat. It was not just or honest to tell those people, as they were told: "If you elect us you will get an increased price for your milk and wheat." I hold that that is playing politics a bit too far.

Another matter to which I wish to refer is to local authority housing. We all feel that local authority housing is a matter of which serious notice has to be taken now. I feel, in view of the present housing costs, that the ordinary person will not be able to pay the higher rates that will be demanded if houses are to be built in the same style as previously because of the increased costs in many directions which he faces. This is a matter in which the Government might take more interest when considering the financial condition of the country. It might be wise to modify our housing schemes. Some local authorities want all semi-detached houses——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This would be a matter for the Estimate on Local Government.

Comment on this

I agree. I do not wish to delay the House any longer. I just want to assure the Minister that I realise the difficulties confronting him in endeavouring to do the best he can for all sections of the community and I hope that my remarks will be helpful. I have made them with that object in mind. I hope that if he can find any way of relieving the heavy strain that this Budget imposes on many sections of the community he will not fail to avail of it so far as finances allow.

Comment on this

I have followed with great interest this debate on this very unpopular Budget. I know that it is very unpopular but it has been brought in as a result of many years of excessive spending on the part of successive Governments. Successive Governments did not regulate their expenses as they should have. Agriculture, which contributes most to this country and which is responsible for 75 per cent. of our exports, received in return only a 10 per cent. allocation. In 1948 we had 500,000 males employed in agriculture and at that time they actually contributed 75 per cent. of our exports. A decline came in and year after year the numbers employed in agriculture dwindled. In 1956 the numbers fell to under 300,000. Notwithstanding that decline, agriculture still maintains its proud position of being responsible for about 73 per cent. of our exports.

I have listened to members from both sides of the House making strong appeals to farmers to work harder and to produce more, pointing out that that provided the only salvation of the country. I doubt if any other industry in the country could boast to-day of the same achievements as those of the Irish farmers, notwithstanding a dwindling population and a shortage of young men to carry out the work. Unfortunately the people who have left rural Ireland are mainly young boys and girls and we are left with too many old men and a lot of young children to maintain.

I understand that £250,000 is to be provided in the Budget for employment. I think it would be very unwise indeed to spend most of that money around Dublin, as was the case in the past. The young men in the area from which I come, and I do not blame them, will again take a single ticket to Dublin, or anywhere they are likely to get remunerative work in preference to remaining idle in West Cork, if employment is created in Dublin or these other areas as it was in the past by building houses, aerodromes and hospitals. There is vast scope for improvement in the area from which I come.

Even with modern mechanisation, there are hundreds of farmers who cannot take a combine into their holdings because the lanes are too narrow.

Thousands of acres of land are flooded because no money is available for cleaning the streams. Hundreds of farmers' houses have been vacated in my area. In some cases, they lock the doors and leave for better employment, either here in Dublin or in some foreign country; in other cases, they do not even lock the doors because they think it better not to do so.

I really appreciate the difficulties which will face the poorer classes as a result of this Budget, but I have no sympathy whatever for the richer people. Looking over statistics I got recently, I made this discovery. Deputy Byrne mentioned to-night the amount of liquor imported into this country and consumed here in the City of Dublin. I can assure you that it is not consumed by the farming community. I discovered that the cost of beer, wine and spirits imported into this country last year was £1,586,184. That is a tremendous amount of drink to be imported and consumed here in Dublin by the people who are clamouring for higher wages and shorter hours, while down the country the farmers' sons are driving the sweat out through their boots in an effort to make ends meet and working 14 hours a day.

That is the position obtaining in this country to-day. Up and down the country, farmers are getting fed up with both political Parties and my presence here is a clear indication of it. They are all very good when in opposition, but, once they become the Government, it is the same story over and over again all down the years. I am here as an Independent. I will not oppose the Government on every occasion; neither will I vote for them on every occasion. I will be as constructive and as helpful as I can in order to try to raise this country from the mire in which it is.

The economic conditions in this country to-day, as a result of unbalanced Budgets and over-expending by successive Governments down the years, are very bad indeed. It is not for me to tell the Government how they should have balanced the Budget, but the feeling of the people in my part of the country is that there are too many highly paid officials and salaried people in this country. A lead should be given in the right direction. I have no doubt that the President, Mr. Seán T. Ó Ceallaigh, would give a lead in that respect by reducing his own salary by 10 per cent. and by a reduction in the running of his own establishment by 10 per cent. If that lead were passed on to every Government office and institution in this country, it would mean a tremendous saving for the Exchequer and create remunerative employment for those very much in need of it.

I was impressed by the speech of the Minister for Lands. He said it was an extraordinary thing that in this country, surrounded by water, there was not even one training school for our fishing boys. Even in my own constituency, there are 100 miles of coast-line to which fishermen from all parts of Europe and further afield, come to reap the rich rewards of the seas. I believe we have the best fishing grounds in the world. At one time in my area, in the village of Baltimore, we had a fishery school established under a foreign Government which occupied this country——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy could argue the question of fisheries more relevantly on the Estimate, which will come up very shortly.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir. I understand it has a bearing on the Budget but I will keep as closely to the point as I can. I have dwelt on the growth of Dublin and on the dwindling population of rural Ireland. Something practical must be done to stop the growth of Dublin and prevent the flight from the land. I feel it is up to this Government, as a strong Government, during its term of office to see to it that what has been happening for the past 35 years will not happen in the coming five years. If the Government succeeds in stopping the tide of emigration, I have no doubt that the young men who are now ready to pack their bags will be quite willing to stay at home and settle down in rural Ireland. One good man between the ages of 18 to 30 is better than three over that age. The wealth of any country depends on its youth. feel that it is because of the flight of our youth from the country we are in the financial difficulties besetting us to-day. There is plenty of work if only finance is directed down the country. I am afraid that was not done in the past. Only 10 per cent. was directed down there in the past.

I realise that the increases brought about by the Budget will mean a rise of four and a half points in the cost of living. However, when the prices of cattle, pigs and various other agricultural commodities dropped last year and brought this country into grave financial straits, when the income of the Irish farmer dropped by 12 points, very little commotion was made about it. Yet, that was actually responsible for the difficulties which have brought about the state of affairs existing to-day. More stability should be brought about in agriculture, in the prices of grain, of milk, of poultry and of eggs. It is the small farmer who produces the wealth of this country, but it is very hard for him to make a good living.

We all realise from figures published last year and again to-day that farmers with over £30 valuations have annual incomes of only £313. How many people employed in industry get as little as £313 a year? They have considerably more. That is why I say that the small incomes which small farmers have at the moment should be protected and improved, if possible, because it is the small farmers, with valuations of between £30 and £50, who are creating most of the wealth of this country. They should be helped and protected as much as possible by any Government having the interests of the community at heart.

From speeches I have heard, I have no doubt that the Government have the interests of the community at heart, but it is my duty to bring home more forcefully to them than has been done in the past that much more money must be channelled into small farms and into the fishing industry because these two industries are of vital importance to the country's economic life. Compare them with some of the industries established during the past few years, many of which are millstones around our necks. I notice that a sum of £250,000 is being allocated this year for exploring markets. I feel that the first market we should look after is our home market. It is an extraordinary thing that we should import over £1,500,000 worth of beer, wine and spirits in a single year. The figure in relation to clothes, boots and shoes and other types of clothing would make startling reading.

If we are to spend £250,000 in developing markets, we should, as I have said, spend the very first £1 in developing the home market, to see that Irish industry will be able to stand on its own feet. I agree that we should give new industries a certain amount of protection in their growing stages, but I cannot see any justification for subsidising and protecting industries established for upwards of 20 years. An industry established for that length of time should be able to fight its own battles and compete not only at home, but on foreign markets as well. When they are subsidised, the same competition does not exist and the same incentives do not operate for increased production generally.

When we have looked after our home market, we can then contemplate what we should do to sell on the export market. Irishmen at home should be as good as Irishmen who have gone abroad. We find that nearly every Irishman who has left our shores, be he from West Cork or from any other part of the country, has done remarkably well abroad. Is it not extraordinary that, while they can do so well abroad, many of them fail miserably at home? It is very hard indeed to get to the root of that problem. I know hundreds of men of my own age who went abroad and each one of them rivalled the other in success. If they had stayed at home, I have no doubt they would not have done so well, perhaps because the same opportunities do not exist here.

I agree with other speakers that there is great scope for the development of our minerals which, if properly developed, could bring great employment and great wealth to many areas, including my own. It is a matter that deserves very close consideration and any help the House can give such explorations should be available.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The development of our mineral resources is a matter which would be more appropriately dealt with on the Estimates.

Comment on this

In my opening remarks, I said I had great sympathy for the poor people who will be hit hardest by this Budget. I include, of course, the old age pensioners. The 1/– increase in their allowances is not sufficient for them. I would be the last to try to impose a halfpenny more on the taxpayer, but I feel that in order to provide additional allowances for old age pensioners there is ample scope for reducing expenditure in other directions. As I have said, I would have started at the top with the President. We must all realise that old age pensioners are unfortunates who had worked hard during their life to keep the country going. They were the people who contributed to obtaining for this country the freedom it now enjoys and they are certainly entitled to more consideration from us than they are now getting.

I think that the means test for these people is much too strict. This is a matter with which I am closely concerned and I am amazed at the number of old age pensioners who have great difficulty in getting any allowances— men who worked hard during their lives being deprived of their just rights at the end of their days. If we could bring about reductions under other headings, we could also give increased children's allowances, particularly to poor parents. Poor people may not always be poor; there are ups and downs in every walk of life, and the poor people of to-day may be the wealthy people of to-morrow. Accordingly, we should be as generous to those people as we can. The social security scheme and the health scheme which were introduced some years ago are now running away with £27,000,000 annually. Notwithstanding that, these schemes are not producing the great social advantages that were promised for them.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is getting away from the Budget.

Comment on this

There is no doubt that this Budget is the most severe Budget ever imposed on the people of this country. However, it is only in keeping with previous Budgets, because as far as my memory goes back, each Budget has rivalled its predecessor in severity.

Comment on this