Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–143 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When progress was reported last Thursday I think we had reached a fair measure of agreement on all sides of the House that it was necessary to provide from taxation sufficient moneys to meet our current expenditure.
Comment on this
On a point of order —I thought perhaps Deputy Allen would refer to the matters he raised at the end of last Thursday's session. I do not want to take the Deputy short, but now that he is resuming the debate where he left off and has had time to consider the matter, does he still hold that what he said was true?
Comment on this
I am merely giving the Deputy an opportunity, if he wishes to take it, to correct himself gracefully as his colleague did just now.
Comment on this
Is that so? Of course the former Minister denies the fact that managers and members of local authorities from June of last year onwards, were at their wits' end to know where they would get the moneys to finance their ordinary current expenditure because of the fact that Departments of State failed to advance either loans or grants to them——
Comment on this
I deny categorically what the Deputy said—that any county council had cheques dishonoured.
Comment on this
——and that they were told—there were circulars go leor on this point—to apply to their treasurers for overdrafts. I said that, and I said——
Comment on this
I deny that I spoke any untruths in this House. In the course of my remarks I said also that in areas in this country paying orders of local authorities were refused by their treasurers and I was questioned very severely on that. Possibly Deputy Sweetman may enlighten us when he gets up to speak about incidents that took place in that connection. I shall say no more than that, but if he wants further details I shall give them to him.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants further details, he was very emphatic in denying that in the last year——
Comment on this
The Deputy was very concerned with one particular incident and he got things put right——
Comment on this
When I was so rudely interrupted a few moments ago by the Deputy I was remarking that we had a substantial measure of agreement that it was through taxation we had to raise sufficient money to pay for ordinary current expenditure. I do not think that is denied by anyone. We had also reached agreement that last year Deputy Sweetman's Budget did not balance to a very considerable extent and that he was forced— I suppose reluctantly—to pay for current expenditure out of borrowed moneys. That brought about the chaos that existed in local authorities throughout the country when they had to reduce building activities and restrict other activities—the giving of loans and grants and everything else. Such action caused considerable unemployment.
He spent capital moneys which should have been spent in making advances to local authorities to build houses and do other works. That is what brought about the serious situation and entailed a lot of unemployment last year and in the early months of this year. It was due to Deputy Sweetman's current Budget—it did not balance and he had to borrow money to pay the salaries of the Guards and the Army and so on. That is admitted on all sides of the House. It is not denied.
Comment on this
The Deputy told me a minute ago that I was interrupting him. Now he wants to know why I am not interrupting him. He wants it both ways.
Comment on this
No one will mind Deputy McGilligan, or what he will deny. One day he will come to the radio on the eve of a general election and tell the State employees he is going to give them £2,000,000 if he gets in.
Comment on this
He will tell them also that there is £20,000,000 in the Exchequer and that if there was a good man in his job he could save it.
Comment on this
I want that quotation badly. Would the Deputy be asked to produce the quotation? I deny using that phrase. Surely the rule is that when a matter is denied the Deputy who asserts it must produce the quotation? Is that not the rule?
Comment on this
I am not bound to give quotations at all, good, bad or indifferent. I will not be tied down to making any quotation. The Deputy's Government——
Comment on this
If a Deputy makes a statement respecting another Deputy and that other Deputy denies the statement, the Deputy must either withdraw it or prove it by producing the document.
Comment on this
I suggest, a Cheann Comhairle, that we send for a record of Deputy McGilligan's broadcast which he made on the eve of the general election in 1954.
Comment on this
I am referring to that broadcast, but for the purpose of order in the House we will let it pass.
Comment on this
When the 1952 Budget was brought in here, there was a Fianna Fáil Government in office at that time and Deputy McGilligan had a lot to say about there being £10,000,000 too much raised in that Budget. There was one thing about which we had agreement in this House last week, as a result of the debate, that there is no £10,000,000 in this Budget being raised by these moneys this year. There is no £10,000,000 too much.
Comment on this
We will be delighted to hear the Deputy, because there is some financial wizard wanted at present.
Comment on this
We were looking for a wizard all last year and would have been delighted to meet him. The local authorities throughout the country were at their wits' end to pay the salaries and wages for many months in the last financial year and they would have liked to meet this financial wizard, Deputy McGilligan or anyone else available to them, who would provide them with funds. There is no doubt about that.
We fully realised that the Government which was in office here 12 months ago left the Government meetings with bleary eyes, after considering for hours and hours how finance could be made available to meet all their problems and all their commitments. They failed to do so; they turned in the end to the easy way and used up the capital moneys which had been raised for the purpose of giving employment in house building and various other interests in which local authorities were engaged, in paying grants and things like that.
We remember the nightmare there was here in this House and every member of a local authority listening to me knows the nightmares there were in all local authorities down the country last year, because of the Budget failing to balance and because of the scarcity of money. That was due to the fact that the Government were not prepared to come in here like men, in October or September or July of last year, with another supplementary budget and raise money by taxation when they knew hey had not sufficient to meet their commitments. These are all well-known facts. People have not such short memories as the Deputy may think in regard to the situation.
We agreed also here last week, a Cheann Comhairle, that the last Government left office because they could not carry on any longer. That was a well-known fact.
Comment on this
We will get whatever it is they call it that the children learn their numbers on, for Deputy Rooney, and let him count them up. We will get that. We got agreement on that.
Comment on this
The financial state of the nation was low under the direction of that Government because they failed to meet their liabilities and therefore they had to levy taxes because they could not get any agreement in what way they would raise the necessary money. It was well known for 12 months before they left office, that things were going bad and seriously bad.
We have a lot of talk about the bread and butter subsidies and their removal and the serious burden about to be put on the community at large. I will admit straight away there are sections, poorer sections of our people, in the low income sections, who will be affected. But it must be remembered—according to returns of the consumption of beer and spirits tobacco, betting, cinemas and dances and everything else—we are by no means a poor country and we are not poverty stricken, anyway. In some recent year, on what would be considered to a certain extent luxuries— desirable, if you like—we spent a total in taxes, without considering the value of the commodity itself, of £40,250,000 on beer, wine, spirits and tobacco. That was over £40,000,000 and I suppose there was another £20,000,000 in the value and the selling of those commodities. Therefore, it could be considered to be £60,000,000 which our community spent in any one financial year in recent years—on beer, wine, spirits and tobacco. They paid that for them. They paid a lot more. Some of our people, a very small section of them, I do not know what the numbers may be, are entitled to have a "flutter" an odd time if they like, laying a few bob on their fancy, whether on the racecourse or down the town, and they actually laid £17,000,000. This country which cannot afford, according to some of the Deputies over there, to pay the cost of production for butter or flour, were able to pay up to £60,000,000 for beer, wine, spirits and tobacco and they laid £17,000,000 with the "books". That is a considerable sum of money for a small country of 3,000,000 people or fewer.
They paid in cinemas and dances in 1955, according to the last available figures in the Statistical Abstract, £1,341,000 and I suppose that was about 5 per cent. of the charges, so I suppose it would amount up to £6,000,000 or £7,000,000 altogether for cinemas and dances. Therefore, the total amounts to over £80,000,000 in one normal year, which we spent on entertaining ourselves in one form or another—all legitimate and all desirable, if we can aflord it.
We turn to the other side of the picture for a moment. On a rough estimate, in a normal year, we pay about £15,000,000 for creamery butter, consumed in this country, and about £15,000,000 to £20,000,000—I cannot get the exact figure—for bread and flour. It is said that it is £20,000,000. I doubt that. Taking those figures, we pay £35,000,000 for the two staple articles of food and we spend about £80,000,000 on the other luxury or semi-luxury commodities. Is it seriously suggested, taking the country as a whole, without reference to the poor, that, when we are able to spend over £80,000,000 on these luxury commodities, we cannot spend less than half that on bread and butter? The poor are always with us. There will always be those on a low income as there always have been. We hope that will not apply always.
Comment on this
I want to go a little further and suggest that what the people will be asked to pay for bread and butter this year is the actual cost of production in our own country. If anyone on the far side of the House can suggest that there should be economies affecting those growing the wheat and producing the bread or producing the milk and manufacturing it into butter so that these commodities will cost less, it is up to him to say so. Will anybody suggest that the people, taken as a whole, are entitled to eat the bread and butter that is produced by Irish labour at less than the cost of production, while, at the same time, we are paying over £80,000,000 for luxuries? That is not the total.
There was a lot of play here by Deputy Norton and some of the Deputies on the front Opposition bench, Fine Gael Deputies, with the £250,000 the Minister proposes to give to the bakers. Over the week-end, somebody down the country suggested to me that it was far more decent to give that, when the commission, appointed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, presided over by a most eminent Supreme Court judge, had recommended it, than to do what the former Government did. The former Government advised the master bakers to pay increases to their operatives and when the master bakers asked how they could reimburse themselves, the suggestion was that they should take a slice off the end of the loaf, make the loaf a bit smaller, that people would never feel it and would know nothing about it. That was the suggestion. It was the meanest type of suggestion that ever came from a Government Department. They dare not increase the price of the loaf by one halfpenny, but they suggested taking a slice off the end of it, that it would not matter a button, that the people could eat a bit less.
Comment on this
A meaner suggestion never came from a Government Department. Last year, some things happened that never happened before in this country. Children's oranges and lemonade were taxed to try to balance the Budget.
Comment on this
Such a tax never existed before. Oranges and lemonade were taxed in order to balance the Budget.
Comment on this
Even with the tax on mineral waters, the Budget was not balanced. Oranges, I grant, came within the luxury category and they were taxed later on in the year in order, moryah, to get the capital moneys to build houses and to do other public works. That is what the tax on oranges was for. That did not succeed either. Not a single penny of the moneys that were got out of the special levies was to be used for any purpose except capital purposes. Considerably more than the amount the special levies produced was used for current revenue purposes last year. There is no doubt about that.
An effort was made in the last fortnight in this House to renew the campaign that was started after the 1952 Budget. Nobody knows better than the Government that left office a few months ago the damage that campaign did to this country. They led the campaign and the country reaped the whirlwind. They can start the campaign now, in the same way, if they like, start telling the people they are unable to buy the bread and butter produced in this country by the farmers and farm workers. They may get votes by that method, but I do not know. If the people are fools, they will vote for them.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to speak a bit louder; I cannot hear him. As I have said, we have reached a certain measure of agreement, with the exception of Deputy McGilligan. I am sure that in a few moments he will set out to prove that there was £8,000,000 too much in this Budget. I think he said that the Minister could do with £8,000,000 less. I hope the Deputy will be able to prove to the Minister's satisfaction that he can do with £8,000,000 less. I am sure the Minister would be very glad to have £8,000,000 to pay for some of the services that are called capital services, many of which, to my mind, should be financed out of ordinary revenue.
The £8,000,000 Deputy McGilligan has in mind is the £8,000,000 deficit in the Budget last year, which had to be met by borrowing and had to be taken out of the capital moneys that should have been available in order to create employment. There was an unemployment situation last winter and spring, a considerable amount of which is still continuing, as compared with 12 months ago, two years ago or any number of years ago, arising out of the mismanagement of the financial affairs of the country.
I think there was a substantial measure of agreement also on the fact that during their three years of office the previous Government were 95 per cent. responsible for the inflation which was created. An inflationary situation was created by putting into circulation nearly £30,000,000 more than there was in circulation when they took up office. Goods were not produced in this country to meet that figure and consequently goods had to be imported. It is on record that some £24,000,000 to £25,000,000 was spent on foreign goods. Let Deputy McGilligan deny that.
Comment on this
Any way the Deputy likes—the subsidy on butter, the subsidy on tea, the rounds of wages or other factors the Government were responsible for. After each round of wage increases that the workers got, and their directors know it quite well, people were put out of employment. It is unfortunate but it is true.
Comment on this
That has happened down the years and the only people whose numbers were increased were those in sheltered employment and who could not be got rid of. The numbers of people engaged in industries outside the control of this House and outside the control of local authorities were reduced every time there were increases. The cost of Government services has become so high now that it is agreed on all sides of the House that, unless they can be cut seriously in the very near future, we will be unable to maintain our present standard of living—those who have a standard at all, and their numbers are getting smaller each year.
Everybody wants to see the standard of living maintained, but let everyone remember that those who are maintaining their standard of living at the present time are maintaining it at the expense of further people becoming unemployed and of further emigration. That, I think, will not be denied and the sooner we give serious thought to it, the better. The members on all sides of the House have a very serious responsibility in this matter. There is no trouble in the world in starting a campaign to tell the people that the cost of their food is too high and that the Government are responsible. That does not get the country anywhere. It drags the country down further and prevents it from making the progress that everybody wants to see it making.
The suggestions of Deputy Costello and Deputy Dillon in regard to taxation alternatives were childish in the extreme.
Comment on this
Has the price of oranges gone down? Why not take down the price consequent on removing the levy?
Comment on this
The tax on radiograms or on motor cars and some other things should not have been removed. The total bagatelle would not pay the wage of a corporal's guard.
Comment on this
It is no wonder that this country got into the mess it is in because of the childish minds of the Deputies opposite. It was an unfortunate thing for the country that, even by a combination of groups, they got a majority and were able to do such an injury to the nation. I will take only the two periods of the two Coalitions, without reference to other periods in the last 30 years. They did injuries to the country in every possible way and because of their policy they put a burden on people such as will remain for the next 40 to 50 years on the backs of posterity.
They thought that they would never see the end of all the capital moneys and the external assets that were accumulated—and we were giving money to wage a war in some part of the world at 1 or a 1/2 per cent. At the same time, we were charging our own people 5 per cent, or 6 per cent. if they wanted to build houses. Was that campaign not carried out by the Fine Gael Party? On the last occasion when Fianna Fáil were in Government and had to seek a loan at 5½ per cent., we were told that our credit was so low that it was only a banana Republic that would have to pay such a rate of interest. The last Government, no matter what rate of interest they offered, got very little money and all the loans they floated were failures.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, it is true. It is no satisfaction to anyone on this side to have to say it. The higher the credit of a nation the better it is for everyone in the nation. The election of Parties to form a Government that mismanages the affairs of the nation and brings down its credit is unfortunate. That is bad for everybody in the country and it is the people who are depending on employment which is created out of public moneys who are hit first. There are many thousands of such people in this country. That has always been the position and they were hit severely in the past 12 months.
The Government who have left office were responsible for pushing up the ordinary current expenditure by £20,000,000 in three years. This Government has taken over that baby and they must find the money to meet that expenditure as best they can. Nobody on the opposite side will suggest that £8,000,000, £10,000,000 or £11,000,000 could have been raised by any alternative taxation which would not create further unemployment and prevent developments and improvements in industry and agriculture. Can any of the Deputies opposite show how those millions could have been raised this year without injuring the State or its people in a more serious way? By the removal of the subsidies on bread and butter, the people are being asked, not for patriotic reasons, to pay the price for those two staple commodities which they cost to produce from the land of this country.
That is all they are being asked to do; they are being asked to pay the full cost of commodities produced within the State. They are not imported commodities; they are not commodities on which taxes are being paid. The people are being asked to pay the full cost of production of commodities which Irish men and women are engaged in producing—bread and butter. That is all that is being asked of the people in this Budget, in connection with the food subsidies. Perhaps the Opposition Parties would prefer to continue their campaign of dragging the country into the mire as they nearly succeeded in doing in the three years just past.
Comment on this
The speech of Deputy Allen must be a record low even from the point of view of the man who has just delivered it. I do not know if he himself realised the theme of his speech. It appeared to me to lead to two different conclusions. The first of these was the suggestion that it was reasonable this year to take off the food subsidies and to make, as he says, the people of the country pay the full cost of production of the affected commodities, even if his argument led to the putting on of a couple of pence on the loaf of bread and a couple of pence on the pound of butter.
He had an argument about the amount being spent by certain people on amusements, on drink, on tobacco, on dancing and gambling and says: "Is it not ludicrous to say that people who pay money for those things cannot pay the full cost of production of butter, flour and bread?" He also gives the usual Fianna Fail viewpoint with regard to wages—that any favouring of increased wages to the wage earning community is a campaign that is meant to bring this country into the mire and will result, according to the Deputy, in the country being brought into the mire.
Deputy G. Boland, when Minister for Justice, said there were certain things which Fianna Fail wanted to prevent, among them increases in wages. They would have prevented such increases had they got a majority in 1948. They are now heading towards the development of the same policy and Deputy Allen, I think, represents better than any other Deputy in the House, the mind of Fianna Fail in regard to these two things.
He has an amazing knack of calling things that have been hotly disputed "agreements". He says there is agreement about the fact that there is a serious situation. I disagree entirely. He says we have reached agreement that this £9,000,000 must be raised by the methods employed by Fianna Fail. I disagree entirely. He says there is agreement that it was the fifth round of wage increases and other moneys put into circulation that led to the imbalance of payments. I disagree completely. That is demonstrably false. He says there was no other way out of the difficulties confronting the country than by saving this money by the withdrawal of the food subsidies. I suggest that as far as the present Minister is concerned, on the financial side nobody had an easier time in the presentation of the Budget.
The year 1955 was a troubled year and the measures taken in 1956, which were then described as totally inadequate to meet the critical situation that existed, have fully proved their worth. The situation in which the Minister finds himself, starting from the first day of the present year, is that the balance of payments difficulties had been completely solved and that the deficit of £14.4 million equated itself in the first three months of the year. That had the effect that on the 1st of April this year the imbalance of payments had been rectified.
The Minister also finds himself in this advantageous position. The terms of trade as between imports and exports against this country last year represented something over £7,000,000. Accordingly, if the terms of trade could be got back again to the 1955 basis-and for a time that was likely—the Minister would not only have the balance of payments corrected but would have a balance of £7,000,000 in his favour in the international account. In those circumstances it is ludicrous for a Minister to speak first of all of the amazing difficulties in which he found himself; it is worse for him to say that there is no other way, and that no other way has been pointed out to him, for getting the £9,000,000 except by the taxes on beer, tobacco, petrol and diesel oil and by the hacking of the subsidies.
First of all, the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, and at least four other Deputies who spoke from this side of the House, did suggest that if the Minister wanted to get his Budget balanced this year without touching the subsidies, all he had to do was to divert the revenue derived from the special import levies over to the revenue side. A great part of his £9,000,000 would have been got in that way. Let us assume he wants £9,000,000. He himself suggested it was only £8,000,000, but £9,000,000 was the figure he mentioned in his Budget statement.
If the Minister can add £5,000,000, £3,000,000 and £1,000,000, arithmetically he surely has £9,000,000. The special import levies, at the increased rates of July, 1956, would certainly have produced £5,000,000. I suggest that these levies represented good revenue taxes. It is quite true that when Deputy Sweetman, as Minister, put on these levies he did put the revenue coming from them into a special fund which he said would be devoted to capital purposes. But, in the meantime, another of Deputy Sweetman's devices had proved a success—the matter which had been characterised as putting the State up for a great raffle by trying to get money from Prize Bonds. The Prize Bonds have brought in a significant amount of money and have provided a method of saving. In the circumstances, there is not the same necessity as existed in 1956 to hand over the revenue from the special import levies to a special fund for capital purposes.
As far as this side of the House is concerned there was definite agreement that £5,000,000 could be had by these methods without touching the food subsidies. As I have said, there is no reason why these moneys should not be devoted towards meeting the ordinary expenditure of the State. They are revenue taxes as proper as any put on in any country ever. There is nothing in their character or style to take away from their being good revenue taxes.
Last year, it is true, Deputy Sweetman, as Minister, put away these moneys into a special capital fund. As I have pointed out, there are other means of getting those moneys now and, if there are not, surely the great financial wizard in the Fianna Fail Party has his efforts decried. An amount of £100,000,000 has been given by Deputy Lemass as the amount that could be produced out of current savings and taxation to be applied by the Government in power for capital development purposes. If the Minister sticks to the £5,000,000 for the import levies, as I suggested was the proper thing, he has still to get £4,000,000. He himself said he would take £3,000,000 for general over-estimation, but he gives back nearly £1.95 million as a general allowance for Supplementary Estimates.
I suggest that he should take £3,000,000 net as the amount he would get from general over-estimation after allowing for Supplementary Estimates. I say that for this reason—the phrase has often been misquoted—that the economy has ready money to hand for any Minister for Finance, if he looks to get it. It has been the record over the years that, when Government Departments are asked to put up the Estimates for a particular year, they put them up to the highest point they can think of. These Estimates are generally screened and subjected to a definite examination in the Department of Finance after that. During the time I was associated with the Government, they were screened by a committee and that committee was able to take many millions off the Estimates which came in. The Estimates this year were not screened by anybody. They were the raw material put up by the Departments in the first instance and were not subjected to any investigation because the impending general election did not permit it.
These Estimates are more definitely inflated than any Estimates have been since this State was established. They are open to more cuts. The general over-estimation has been assumed to be £3,000,000 for years. If it was £3,000,000 in regard to Estimates subjected to considerable scrutiny, there is clearly much more money to be secured in regard to this matter of over-estimation than ever before. The Minister, accepting the £3,000,000 as the usual figure for many years in respect of general over-estimation, then says that £3,750,000 has been allowed for Supplementary Estimates so that this year in which the Estimates are more inflated than ever before and subjected to less scrutiny, he allows an extra £200,000 for Supplementary Estimates.
There has been no argument given as to why that figure was adopted. There is no reason why this year the £750,000, which ordinarily stands as the amount of money that might be expected, should be increased by £200,000. I seriously suggest that the figure which should be taken for general over-estimation, after allowing for Supplementary Estimates of the £750,000 type, should be £3,000,000, plus the fruits of the special import levies which give the Minister £8,000,000. There is a sum of £1,000,000 still to be got.
The Minister has given his calculations about economies. Leaving out the food subsidies he is to get £250,000 by stopping recruitment to the Civil Service; he is to get £.08 million by stopping expansion in the Land Commission; he is to get £.07 million by putting extra charges on people who avail themselves of some matters in regard to the health services; and he is to get the magnificent sum of £100,000, by careful scrutiny of the Estimates of the Department of Defence.
According to calculations that I have made for many years, the annual wastage in the Civil Service runs about 1,200 per annum, and it has been as high as 1,500. That embraces the people who go out on pension, people who die, the womenfolk who get married and the people who resign for various reasons. By merely stopping recruitment and allowing the wastage to cause a reduction in the Civil Service, the figure that could be taken is a minimum of 1,200 and it could be as high as 1,500.
The average wage in the Civil Service is about £550 per annum and if one multiplies that £550 by the 1,200 people who might be expected to retire from the Civil Service in a year, one gets savings in remuneration alone of £636,000. If one takes 1,500 people at the £550 per annum level, there is a saving to be made of about £800,000. I am speaking, as the Minister spoke, of remuneration only. There are a variety of other things in regard to the administration of the Civil Service which cost money. I have no doubt, even if the lower figure or an intermediate figure of 1,300 is taken, that there is easily £1,000,000 to be got. I am not promoting the idea that any single civil servant should be removed from his office; I am taking a position in which the annual wastage would be availed of and that there would be either no recruiting or very little recruiting to fill the posts of those who leave.
If the Minister were to accept £5,000,000 from the special import levies, £3,000,000 as being the amount of money he could easily expect as the fruits of general over-estimation, even allowing for Supplementary Estimates in the ordinary way, he could look for the £1,000,000 as between the wastage in the Civil Service and two other items. The Department of Defence should yield more economies than the miserable £100,000. It seems to me that if the developments that were in course of operation in the Guards were allowed speedy procedure, they would easily bring in between them another £250,000. I am taking the Army and the Guards together, so that even with considerable recruitment in the Civil Service, there is bound to be savings, if wastage is availed of and economies are made in the Army and the Garda. There is an extra £1,000,000 to be had. That would give the Minister his £9,000,000 which he says he requires, without touching the food subsidies or having to put any taxes on tobacco, beer, petrol or diesel oil.
I have yet to hear any argument from any person backing the Minister as to why those plans should not be availed of, instead of disturbing the whole stability of the country by attacking the food subsidies. If one accepts the meanness of spirit of Deputy Allen, who thinks that people are too well off—that was the argument to-day—in that people could afford to spend £80,000,000 on drink, tobacco and entertainment and gambling, the food subsidies should not merely be hacked, as the Deputy's colleague is doing, but we should be able to put an extra few pence on the lb. of butter and the loaf of bread.
I want to suggest to the Minister that he will not get, as a result of withdrawing the food subsidies, the figure he puts down in his table explanatory of the Budget. He takes the gross savings on the food subsidies to be £7.1 million. Then he hands back £1.95 million by way of social assistance payments. These have been criticised as not being sufficient to make up for the hardship that will be inflicted upon people in the lower income groups by the increased prices for bread, butter and flour.
In 1952, when the Minister's colleague, the Minister for Health, decided to make certain savings in food subsidies, the gross savings he put in his table explanatory of the 1952 Budget amounted to £6,600,000. He had to give back £2,750,000 for compensatory social welfare benefits. This year, he is taking £9,000,000 in a full year; but in this part of the year, he is taking £7.1 million and giving back only £1.95 million and we may measure the hardships put on the lower income group by that as being lower—only £6? million savings and a giving back of £2,750,000. This time, he is either definitely robbing the people for whom he is pretending to provide by these payments or his figures are incorrect and are put forward here in the pretence that they have been carefully considered and that this is the exact sum.
The other matter that has to be considered is this. In 1952, when only £6? million was the gross savings on the food subsidies, State personnel went to their arbitration tribunals. The Civil Service invoked the aid of the arbitration tribunal which dealt with themselves and those whose salaries were assimilated with the Civil Service got their increases in good time. These were civil servants, Garda, the Army and the teachers. As far as my memory goes, the amount which the State had to show them per annum as a result of the cut in the food subsidies was £2,500,000. In 1955, does anybody believe that all that State personnel will remain quiet, now that the food subsidies have been removed? I hope I will not be told I am attempting to foment another campaign for the civil servants to seek a rise. Supposing they do, has any calculation been made of the amount the State will have to bear annually?
Comment on this
On a point of order, might I ask if the Minister and Deputy Allen will adjourn to the Party Room for their conference? They have been at it now for the past 20 minutes.
Comment on this
The Minister says that savings are £7.1 million and he gives back £1.95 million and his net savings will be £5.15 million. Supposing the State personnel have to get their remuneration and allowances raised and that it costs no less than it did in 1952, when the cost of living by the reduction in the food subsidies rose by less than what it will rise now, the price of that will be, as I have said here to-day, definite instability in the country.
All these wage tribunals will be meeting again. The Labour Court will be resorted to. People may say to us that we on this side of the House are fomenting a campaign. That campaign is already on. It is not human to expect that one group in the community should agree to bear the whole burden of this year's fantastic Budget. I want to know what the Minister and his colleagues will say when they meet the trade union people and when it is pointed out to the Minister that it was he handed away the £5,000,000 that he could have had from the special import levies and that there was £3,000,000 which it is reasonable for him to take as general over-estimation. They will point out, as I have done, that there are other economies which would bring in an extra £1,000,000 by allowing certain economies to develop in the Army and in the Garda. How can the Minister, in view of the arguments placed before him in this House, ask one group of the community to bear the impact of the abolition of these food subsidies when these statements are paraded to the Minister by these people when he meets them?
I certainly would not like to be the person to sit down and argue with that element of the people who are going to be hardest hit by the savings in the food subsidies when they see that the bakers are going to be compensated by nearly £250,000. How, if they are anxious to see that employment is taken up again in the country, is it that the amount of money in the Budget for special employment schemes is increased by little more than £20,000 over the sum handed over to the bakers as compensation to them for moneys they have lost through increased wages? One would like to listen to the Minister and his colleagues in their deliberations with these people and in asking them to bear these imposts, while, as I say, bakers are given compensation of £230,000 and employment schemes are being increased by only £250,000.
In connection with the bakers, we were told that public faith was pledged. That was one of the chief falsehoods uttered in the course of the debate. There was no public credit pledged. The real situation was described by Deputy Norton. It was pointed out that the advisory committee's recommendation that payment should be made was carried merely by the casting vote of the chairman. The chairman used two votes and the Government of the time were made fully aware of that. In other words, it was not put forward as a really important proposal and there was certainly nothing in it to indicate that public credit had been pledged. It took the casting vote of the chairman to carry the proposal that the money should be paid in this way and that the payment should be made retrospective.
Deputy Allen made a great deal of pother about the reduction in the size of the loaf. Deputy Rooney asked would Deputy Allen and his colleagues put the slice back on the loaf, would they restore the loaf to the ordinary size, in addition to these compensations that are being paid to the bakers? They would have a better fund out of which to raise the loaf to its old status, if Deputy Allen likes to put that proposal forward.
I read in the papers that the Minister for Lands said the only argument he used against transferring the revenue from the special import duties to meeting the ordinary expenses of the State—he made the statement outside this House—was that they needed these moneys for capital development. How did they need these moneys for capital development? There has been a good deal of sneering talk about financial wizards. I have here a supplement to the Irish Press of October 15th, 1955. It has a big heading, “Full Employment—Lemass's Outline of Proposals.” Half way through this supplement, the Tánaiste says:—
"There is no doubt that there is available to finance the proposed capital investment programme resources which are well in excess of the £100,000,000 which may be needed and which are at present being employed in a way which yields the minimum of national advantage."
He goes on to say:—
"There is no need to entertain the idea of negotiating foreign loans to finance it or to anticipate difficulty in completing arrangements for the transfer of these resources as required."
He emphasises:—
"that it is an essential feature of these proposals that the whole of the additional investment expenditure to be undertaken by the Government must be financed without drawing upon current savings."
He said earlier in this supplement that this £100,000,000 is not to be derived from taxation. There is the financial wizard. In 1955, he had a plan to have a vast programme of new investment. In it there is a tabular statement in which he outlines in precise detail the investment of that extra £100,000,000 over seven years and this £100,000,000 was not to be derived from current savings or by way of taxation. There is money well in excess of the £100,000,000 which will be needed and which is at present being employed to the minimum of national advantage.
In October, 1955, this financial wizard decided there was no necessity to entertain the idea of foreign loans. The Minister for Finance now comes here with a programme to get £5,000,000 by taking away the subsidies on bread, flour and butter. Furthermore, he includes in his Budget statement the information that we are going to join the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank for the purpose, in the first instance, of getting technical assistance and eventually of negotiating loans with that international organisation. The Minister for Finance has made that statement in his Budget speech of this year although the financial wizard of October, 1955, decided there was no such necessity as he said there were capital resources available well in excess of the £100,000,000 which his tabular statement showed to be required over six years.
If a sum of £100,000,000 is there and if it can be diverted from purposes which are not yielding anything but the minimum national advantage and if that money can be taken rather than from current savings or as the product of taxes, why does the Minister for Finance not do something about it when all that is required in respect of his capital fund is £2.8 million? He says somewhere in his statement—Table 4—that the money will have to be got by loans, if the people will give the money, or, if not, by going to the banks, that is, the ordinary banks here. All that was required to obviate the necessity of their taking any money from the poor people by the removal of the subsidies was to find a sum of £2.8 million. Is that such an enormous sum of money to ask the financial wizard of the 1955 plan for full employment to get this year out of the £100,000,000 which he says is available for investment and is at present employed to the minimum national advantage?
Deputy Lemass, of those days, noticed other things. He noticed, in particular, that, with this vast injection of capital into the country, there might be a possible inflationary effect coming from the programme but that that would be met by the Government by modifying import restrictions or price control measures that would impose checks. At any rate, the inflationary matter was not a danger. He had that under control, too. He was a bit worried about wages. At the end of the third page of this statement, he said:—
"The problem of determining wage rates in full employment is likely to be one of considerable difficulty, as British experience indicates."
Then here he parted a little bit from his colleague, the present Minister for Health, who, many years ago in University College, Dublin, decided that full employment could never be brought about in this country because of the tendency there would be to look for increased wages.
The Tánaiste-Deputy Lemass of October, 1955-says:—
"In a private enterprise economy, with free wage bargaining, unemployment or the fear of it is a very considerable check on the upward pressure of money wage rates."
Therefore, he said, the one difficulty in this £100,000,000 plan was that when there was not the check of unemployment about, those who were in employment might look for increased wages and that, if wages were increased as high as a particular point, it might destroy the good effects of the £100,000,000 investment plan. However, there would be no great fear of that happening when only £2.8 million is required to meet the Minister's Table 4 if he were to divert the import levies and the fruits of those import levies over to his ordinary Budget and use these to meet the expenses of the State for the year.
I suppose that, before this debate is over, the Minister will ask us: "Has the £100,000,000 plan been accepted? Will it be put into operation? Why is it being delayed?" If this is such a critical year as the Fianna Fail spokes-man says it is and if one of the great difficulties, in particular, is to find capital moneys, is this not the year to make the first fumbling step for the £100,000,000 to be put into operation to provide something less than £3,000,000 out of the resources which the Tánaiste said are there at present and are being employed to the minimum national advantage?
As well as the falsehood of which I have spoken already, the Tánaiste, speaking in this debate, found it necessary to introduce some very courageous and bold falsehoods with regard to the levies. One understands the difficult and delicate situation in which he finds himself. He knows he has been criticised outside and inside this House, together with a colleague of his in that Party. That is an amazing thing. The benefits that should have been given to people by some modification in import levies accrue mainly for the benefit of people in motor car production.
I do not believe the Tánaiste's mind was swayed by that matter at all nor even swayed by the fact that he had a colleague also in the motor car assembly business. However, the Tánaiste is very well aware that he has been subject to criticism about that. He probably felt it was necessary for him to get some protection for himself in respect of that matter. Therefore, on the 14th May, 1957, as reported in the Official Report, Volume 161, No. 9, columns 1162 onwards, he told the Dáil that the difficulties that arose in connection with motor car importation came from the fact that, when the levies were put on, the Government of the time had made a mistake. He said they put the levy on motor cars and that the levy was in breach of the agreement made in 1948. That was a complete falsehood. The Tánaiste said that the representative of the British Minister for Trade very quickly knocked on their doors and talked about the provisions of the trade agreement. All he could assume was that the levy was put on by mistake.
When he was asked if he was aware that there was a notice in his office indicating that agreement, in association with the British Government through our ambassador in London, to these particular proposals had been secured, he said he did not know if it was true that that prior discussion took place or that there was any such notice. Then, at column 1164, the Tánaiste said: "In fact, it was not done".
Deputy Norton as Minister for Industry and Commerce was in charge of this matter at the time. He interrupted the Tánaiste and, in a counter interruption, the Tánaiste asked: "Is Deputy Norton trying to assert that he had prior consultation with the British Government before putting on this levy?" and Deputy Norton replied: "Our ambassador in London had". At that point, the Tánaiste said: "As the dignity of the Irish Parliament and the Irish Government in relation to England is involved in this, I will say no more about it for the present". There have been many days since in which he could have said something more about it. He could have found out if what Deputy Norton said was correct. He could have found out if there had been discussions in London, through our ambassador, with the British Government and whether or not there had been any agreement in regard to this country.
Is it again to be asserted that any objection was taken by the British Government to the continuance of these import levies? I am not talking about the mistake the Tánaiste may have made in changing the expression from "import levies" to "customs duties" and possibly putting himself into the hands of the British in connection with the breach of agreement. I cannot understand how the Tánaiste could have forgotten the improvement we made in 1948 on the arrangement he was responsible for making ten years earlier. His arrangement of 1938 was at least bettered to meet the circumstances that occurred in 1955.
The second Article of the Agreement of July 31st, 1948, is:—
"For the purpose of safeguarding Ireland's external financial position and of achieving and maintaining stable equilibrium in its balance of payments, the Government of Ireland, as and when they may deem it expedient, will prepare lists of those goods imported from the United Kingdom to which Article 5 of the Trade Agreement signed between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom on the 25th April, 1938, applies and the importation of which they may desire to restrict. The Government of the United Kingdom will forthwith consider such lists and agree with the Government of Ireland as to the contents thereof. The Government of Ireland shall thereupon, notwithstanding the provisions of the aforesaid Article, be entitled to impose on the import of the goods in question such quantitative restrictions or import duties as they think fit and as may be agreed between the two Governments."
That was not in the 1938 Agreement. It was brought in in 1948. It was brought in because—let us be frank about it—in those days the British were rather particular with regard to imports of our goods. They thought they might have to preclude on the balance of payments argument. The counterbalance was put in Article 2 which was brought in as a safeguard.
It gave the right and, in full accordance with Article 2, the Government to which Deputy Sweetman belonged asked the Irish Ambassador in London to see the representatives of the British Government and get that matter agreed. That matter was agreed. Notwithstanding that, Deputy Lemass, not knowing whether what Deputy Norton said was true or not, came here with this amazing falsehood to say it was a mistake to put that levy on motor cars and to say the British representatives had made their objections to it. The only excuse he could think of for the then Government was that they did it by mistake. That was a brazen effort to mislead the Dáil. On Thursday last, Deputy Norton gave him chapter and verse for his association with that matter. Deputy Sweetman can also add to that. The ball is now with the Tánaiste and the Minister for Finance to see to it that the false statement made on the 14th May is repudiated.
Notice the delicacy of the Tánaiste. Having started, or tried to start, trouble between the two parties, he then pulls out of the argument because he says the dignity of the Irish Parliament and the Irish Government in relation to England is involved. The dignity of the present Government is involved in so far as they tried to mislead the Irish Parliament by a concoction which the Tánaiste, if he had read it through, would have known to be untrue. If he did not read it, then it is gross negligence on his part.
We have at the moment a recurrence of the campaign which led up to the Budget of 1952, stressing that the country is in a desperate position. One Minister says it is a question of national survival; a second says the national coffers are empty; while yet another Minister tells us that one does not know where money is to be had. Do not forget that this is merely repetition. In 1947, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, also the then Tánaiste, made a speech at Letter-kenny which was a preliminary to the autumn Budget of that year. He spoke in these terms:—
"If there is an idea we are facing an easy time with more pay and less work, it is very desirable to kill that idea. We are entering on four years of most acute difficulty in which economic disaster will threaten on every side. Our only weapon of defence is our capability to work hard."
That was in September, 1947. A few by-elections took place and some time after that the change of Government occurred. In the spring of next year, instead of economic disaster threatening on all sides, it was found possible to reduce a lot of the taxes imposed by the autumn Budget of 1947. No economic disaster was either present or threatening us. The country was never as happy as in the years 1948 to 1951. There was not the remotest sign of acute difficulty.
The food subsidies were not being mentioned in 1947. At that time, the food subsidies were being granted in order to keep down the cost of living. Very heavy taxes were imposed on beer, spirits, tobacco, entertainments and anything the Government could think of. We were told that, unless these taxes were kept on, the subsidies could not be paid. We were told they were in equal balance. They required the subsidies-they were all out for subsidies in those years. It was unfortunate, but they had to put taxes on beer, spirits, tobacco and everything else to get the money for the subsidies. Several years later Deputy Lemass could say-we did not know what was in their minds in 1947-that they were budgeting for a surplus, that they were doing what Deputy Allen was aiming at in his speech to-day. They wanted to take purchasing power out of the people's control because they were afraid there would be a terrific inflationary effect if wages were increased and the people were allowed to spend more.
We know about the proposals there were for a wages standstill Order-proposals we found after the people rejected Deputy Lemass and his colleagues and allowed us to get in to ransack the files in Government Buildings. We found the proposals for the standstill Order in 1947. We know that was in the minds of Fianna Fail in 1952 and we know they would like to have it in their minds and to operate it in the present year. The food subsidies were talked of during the course of the election. The first sign that came from Fianna Fáil was from their headquarters. A notice was published from the Fianna Fáil headquarters that there was a rumour being spread by canvassers that Fianna Fáil, if elected, would cut the salaries of civil servants by 10 per cent. The announcement said there was no truth in this allegation. It was very precise. It is still open to the Fianna Fail evaders to say: "That is all right. We are not going to cut them by 10 per cent. That was all we promised not to do."
The Minister for Justice, as Deputy Traynor, spoke in his own constituency during the last election. He told us that, if there had been standstill Orders on the previous occasions, such Orders were designed to protect the workers' wages at the lower level. They were actually a protection for the worker. They kept their wages from going higher, but stopped them from going any lower. That excuse was never promulgated about the cuts in the previous year, but it was given out prior to this election.
The House has heard several times— and I do not intend to worry it again —about the Taoiseach's remarks down in Belmullet. He said there had been an attempt to frighten civil servants and secondary teachers by telling them that their salaries would be reduced if Fianna Fail got back. He said they had also been told they would have to pay more for their bread. He went on to weep about bread. What had been done in 1952 was done because nothing else could be done; but it was not done completely. The reason the subsidies were not taken off completely he said was that he was so conscious of how necessary such foodstuffs as bread and butter were to the poor people and they could take it from him that these subsidies would not be removed.
Of course, the Tánaiste was more open in his condemnation of people spreading rumours. He said that all sorts of unpleasant things were being threatened if Fianna Fail became the Government—cuts in the Civil Service, unemployment, higher food prices, lower wages and more besides. He said: "A Fianna Fail Government does not intend to do any of these things" and that phrase is fastened on by the new Minister for Defence, who said that neither did they do them. It was not their intention, the Tánaiste said, to cut food subsidies. It was not their intention but, of course, new intentions had to be formed in the face of new circumstances, and that is how the decision was taken to do what they had denied they would do.
The Tánaiste said:—
"A Fianna Fail Government does not intend to do any of these things, because we do not believe in them. How definite can we make our denial of these stupid allegations? They are all falsehoods."
Even after the election, when the Taoiseach saluted the people for giving him his victory, he said that now that Fianna Fáil were in power again the new march was on, they were "getting cracking" once more, and he asked for the support of everybody. He asked for the combined effort of every section:—
"Everyone who produces more—every farmer who gets more from the soil, every manufacturer who extends his business, every worker who does better and finer work, everyone who saves and invests his savings in private enterprise, or in community projects sponsored by the State—each will contribute his share to the winning of the final victory. One great combined and sustained national effort and the task will be done."
One thing that is notably absent from all this is an appeal to the lower-paid elements of the community to eat dearer bread and dearer butter and lend their effort by accepting dearer bread and dearer butter and not look for increased wages to meet the depression in their standard of living as a result of what was proposed and brought about in the Budget.
"We ask God to give us the strength and we will have the victory."
And the victory was to be achieved by the sustained effort of everybody. The bakers got a gift of £250,000. There was a further £250,000 for extra employment emergency schemes, but £5.1 willion was to be taken from the people who could least afford it because of dearer bread, dearer flour and dearer butter.
The Taoiseach did say at an earlier stage, years before, that one of the things our people would have to do, if they wanted democracy to survive and serve the national purpose, was to make up their minds that when it came to passing judgment on politicians, they would have to be ruthless with those who lied to them and who tried to degrade the political life of this country into a Party political game. In November, 1951, at a Fianna Fail Silver Jubilee Celebration at the Imperial Hotel in Cork the people were asked to pass judgment on politicians and to be ruthless with those who lied to them and tried to degrade the political life of this country into a Party political game. And that is the man who could say afterwards:—
"Oh well, we did not do much about food subsidies in 1952 and the reason why we did not do so much was because we knew how much poor people depended on bread and butter and we tried to make the blow as light as possible."
But this year food subsidies, such of them as are left, go and that after the Taoiseach saying at Belmullet that bread was not going to be made dearer while the Tánaiste told us that these suggestions were falsehoods and these things were not intended.
Deputy Allen was reminiscing to-day about the Minister for Finance in 1952. In 1952, when some millions were taken off the food subsidies because of the level of the finances, the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, said that salaries and wages had increased more than the increase in the cost of living and there was no social or economic justification for subsidising food. Deputy Allen had a few other comments to make. He said there was no justification for subsidising food for everybody; food was something which everyone who can should be expected to work and pay for; he wanted to see an adjustment to real costs. Deputy Allen asked:—
"What have you been asked to pay, those of you who have been asked to pay, after the food subsidy has gone? Merely the price of production in this country—the price of production to our farmers and farm workers of bread, flour and butter."
Deputy Allen adds: "Why should not we ask the people to pay for their flour and their bread?" The people are spending nearly £80,000,000 according to Deputy Allen's calculations, on betting, entertainment, drink and tobacco and so it is no harm at all to ask the people to pay these costs of production for these few items. Is that not reminiscent of the 1952 argument? People were too well off, Deputy MacEntee said in so many words, in 1952; salaries and wages had increased more than the increase in the cost of living. This year Deputy Allen thinks that some part of them can spend nearly £80,000,000 on these luxuries; why, then, cannot they be asked to pay the cost of production of bread and butter?
Of course, as I said to him, the argument goes too far. If this £500,000 is not there next year for the promise, which may or may not be carried out, to the industrialists—that £500,000 could be got by putting an extra penny on the loaf and an extra penny on the lb. of butter—Deputy Allen would have the same argument next year: "People are not reducing the amount of money spent on gambling, tobacco and drink".
Deputy Allen, in another phase of his argument, is of the opinion that it was the increased wages, the fifth round increase, and other things —subventions that were given and subsidies—that caused inflation and, in particular, caused the imbalance in our international payments. The Minister for Defence is on that line too. He took the same line as Deputy Allen did to-day about the conspiracy and the campaign to get wages increased. Speaking here on 15th May at column 1291 of Volume 161 of the Official Report the Minister for Defence said:—
"Because we succeeded in lessening the effect on the people who were less well able to bear it, particularly people with large families, there should not now be any necessity for increased wage demands by workers, arising directly from the Budget at any rate. It is very regrettable that the Opposition should attempt to negative the good effect which this Budget will have by making inflammatory speeches such as they have made here attempting to incite people to take action which they know would be to the detriment of the country."
Speaking at a Fianna Fáil cumann on 20th May, the Minister for Defence said:—
"The incentives provided for industry and agriculture will also have the effect of increasing investment in both these spheres. If demands for wage increases are pressed, however, they will obviously raise costs, reduce export possibilities and also the chance of full or increased employment which would otherwise be obtainable."
It is a pity the Minister for Finance did not think of that before he brought in his Budget proposals.
There is going to be another round of wage increases. It is impossible for this country to maintain standards, low as they are, unless there are increases in wages to meet the increased cost the Budget has put upon the people. That will happen and, in the end, the Minister will be left in the position that he will have shifted from public account the £9,000,000 devoted to food subsidies, so he hopes to gain a gross £7,000,000, giving back nearly £2,000,000 to those in receipt of social welfare benefits.
In my calculation he will give back nothing less than £2,500,000 to State personnel, to the civil servants, the Gardaí, the teachers and the Defence Forces and he will be left with a miserable gain of £2,500,000, which he could easily have got through the special import levies. He will put upon those who control agriculture and industry burdens of new costs by way of increased wages and he will, too, in the end, price us out of more markets in relation to commodities produced at home and in connection with which we are able to fill the market at the moment with the price structure we have.
In the end, then, he will have dissatisfied both the people who are getting these increased social welfare payments, because they could not meet the impositions put upon them, and the State personnel, since, no matter what arbitration he gives, any award made will not meet the charges the recipients of that award will have to meet because of the increases in the price of bread, flour and butter. This will be done without taking any account of savings or of the other way of getting money that has been pointed out, using the fruits of these import levies to meet ordinary current expenses.
I find in Deputy Allen, as he spoke to-day, the mind of his Party. Deputy Allen did say here quite frankly and openly that he was against wage increases. He said the fifth round of wage increases was wrong, that that increase in 1955 had caused inflation, had caused the imbalance in our international payments. The programme operated by Fianna Fáil is an old one. It has been in their minds since 1947. It was their philosophy in 1947. It was the background of thought behind their Budget of 1952 and it is recurring here. I do not know who inspired it or where this mood came from, but it grew in 1947, grew further by 1952 and shows no signs of weakening this year. It is a dangerous and unrepentant type of fanaticism which that Party has adopted from the conservative bankers in this country. They operated the banking report in a way which they are now apparently regretting, and are promising changes in that situation in the autumn. They did what the bankers told them in 1947, in 1952 and again this year.
Last year when there was no election and when they were speaking their minds freely we got exposed to us what their view was in regard to the country's situation, and remember that this comes from people after 15 years in office. Life was standardised in such a way that in 1947 when the health legislation came to be spoken of in this House it was promulgated that there were certain people in the country who could not be expected by their own industry or by any means under their control to provide one penny piece for the medical requirements of themselves or their families. The number of people included in that category was one third of our population. After 15 years under Fianna Fáil rule the standard of life had been reduced to the point where 1,000,000 of our less than 3,000,000 population were at the stage where they could not be expected to pay one penny piece for the medical or surgical needs of themselves or their families. Now in 1957 the standard of living, low as it is, must be reduced by the impositions in relation to bread, flour and butter.
Deputy G. Boland when speaking as Minister for Justice—I have often quoted this in the House—wailed that Fianna Fáil would have prevented certain things from happening if they had only won six seats in Dublin in 1948. He said in a speech printed in the Irish Press that the Guards, the Army, Civil Servants and teachers had all secured salary increases, that no doubt local authority employees would get similar ones and that eventually all the workers in the State would get similar increases in wages to meet the increased cost of various commodities. His statement was that that was what Fianna Fáil was determined to prevent and would have prevented if they had only won six seats in Dublin in 1948. That is the line that Deputy Allen has taken to-day.
In 1945 the Minister for Health, Deputy MacEntee, went to discuss at University College, Dublin, a paper upon full employment. I have his comments made there, as reported in the Irish Times of 9th May, 1945, and I need not quote them at length. His view was that full employment was something to which he could not agree. He would be very hesitant to give an affirmative answer to what the auditor asked as to whether full employment was desirable. The reason for it was, he said, that when there is full employment there are more jobs than there are workers. Workers will look for increases in their wages. The costs of production will go up. The worker will find he is paying a bit more and he will look for a bit more in the way of increased wages and in that way the whole structure of full employment will crash to the ground.
Deputy MacEntee was against full employment. If anybody might think that was an old view, let me point out that he carried that forward to 1952, this attitude of mind that people were too well off, and that, therefore, they could stand the hacking of the subsidies in that year. The Minister for External Affairs, speaking as Deputy Aiken in the summer period last year, disapproved of the increases that were given by the Arbitration Board to the Guards, the Army, civil servants and teachers, and the fifth round of wage increases that was awarded through the Labour Court. He objected to these salary and wage increases and blamed them for the balance of payments position. He said it was because we gave the £1,000,000, which he said was not legally owing, to the civil servants in back pay that touched off the fifth round of wage increases. He wanted to stop that increase, as Deputy Allen to-day would want to stop any further wage increases and bemoaned the one that took place in 1955.
The Minister for External Affairs was joined by the Minister for Health, speaking as Deputy MacEntee last year, in a statement on certain provisions of the Budget when extra payments were given to certain people who because of the depreciation in the value of money were not getting the same amount as they were previously in receipt of. When these increases were given and the increase to the State personnel, Deputy MacEntee then said these were, to use his own phrase, "chunks of inflationary expenditure". They were moneys that had been scattered through the country to people who could not give, and were not expected to give, any better contribution to the community. Therefore, he said they should not have been given.
The Tánaiste was against these increases also. When the Tánaiste produced his plan for £100,000,000 he tried to make up for his deficiency when he forgot agriculture by coming along with a new plan. The new plan had two things in it. The first was that he intended to have a compulsory levy on people's earnings, 5 per cent. to be levied on the earnings of everybody other than people who were unemployed in order to get the savings which he had despaired of getting by way of public loans.
The second was that he wanted to get some less cumbersome machinery for the dismissal of civil servants who were unsatisfactory. I never knew there was any very cumbersome machinery for getting rid of civil servants who were unsatisfactory. The situation has been for years that civil servants hold positions at the will and pleasure of the Government. The Tánaiste wanted to create the impression that he knew there were many of these unsatisfactory civil servants and that he could reduce the cost of administration by dismissing them only for the fact that there was this cumbersome machinery in the way of such a course.
The present Minister for Lands, Fisheries, and something else, had quite a number of plans. He wanted to end food subsidies by stages; he wanted to keep salaries and wages under strict control. He talked about our foolish plan of sending out as exports only what we had over after the people had satisfied themselves by consumption of what they produced. He thought we should make certain commodities so dear that the people at home would not be able to buy them and we would then sell them on foreign markets at subsidised prices.
He spoke of the fatuousness of keeping the best for ourselves. He thought we should do, as he said Denmark does —send the best away and live on residual matter ourselves. He spoke of the plans that he had; he said he had come back from abroad and that we ourselves would have to accept what all foreign countries had accepted, as well as these plans for eating the worst ourselves and sending the best abroad. He spoke of the European measures that he found in operation on a visit he made abroad in various countries. These were measures, he said, to check inflation and he enumerated them: import restrictions, abolition of food subsidies, compulsory savings, heavily increased taxation, credit restriction, building limitation and wage freezes. He said that these—some, if not all, of them—would have to be among the measures that would have to be taken here and adopted from these foreign countries who had taken such measures —some or all of them—to check inflation in their countries.
Import restrictions, abolition of food subsidies, compulsory savings, heavily increased taxation, credit restriction, building limitation and wage freezes— which of these have Fianna Fáil not intended to put into operation? They are all part of their programme, as far as I can see, listening to Deputy Allen. These were the plans that that group of Ministers I have mentioned had—in order, they say, to get this country out of this dangerous inflationary position and to rectify the unbalance that occurred in our international payments position.
The Minister for Defence echoes phrases of Deputy Gerald Boland. He wants to prevent wage increases. He describes as a conspiracy people agreeing that workers are entitled to look for wage increases. He spoke of inflammatory speeches made with the view of simply saying to the workers that if their cost of living increased in this way they were entitled to get some compensation for it. That, according to the present Minister for Finance, and echoing back to Deputy Gerald Boland, is what Fianna Fáil intended to prevent, and would have prevented, if it had only got those six seats in Dublin in 1948. They have got them now and plans are being prepared. We see some of them in the Budget and no doubt before long we shall hear more of the seven proposals of the Minister for Lands, and other schemes brought home from the Continent as instances of what European countries had found it necessary to do in order to prevent inflation in their cases.
Deputy Allen echoes these words of the people I have quoted, in respect of the troubles of 1955. He stated it quite definitely here to-day. He is a senior politician in that Party and he said it was the fifth round of wages in 1955 that caused the inflation and caused the difficulty in the balance of payments. I have said already in regard to that both of these statements are false, and demonstrably false. If anybody asserts that inflation was caused either by wage increases, subsidies or anything else, I want to know what it is he is speaking of. There may be inflation that is price inflation, but there has been no price inflation caused by anything happening here except by the Fianna Fáil Budget of 1952. That did cause inflation because it caused prices to rise. Other prices have risen but they have risen mainly through importation. We import inflation into the country because many of the goods we have to bring into the country have had their prices increased abroad, but it is quite wrong to say, and anybody who says it is saying it in the face of the most obvious fact, that outside the 1952 Fianna Fáil Budget there has been any price inflation caused here by anything done at home.
There is another type of inflation, an inflation which means that if you have an amount of money seeking for a quantity of goods and if those goods are to be provided from outside you may have more goods of that kind and a much bigger bill for materials that are brought in from abroad. Again, I want to insist that the inflation by way of inflation of imports, cannot be ascribed to the fifth round of wage increases. If anybody denies that statement I would ask him to consider when did import inflation start? Did it start from the fifth round of wages? It did not.
The inflation by way of increased imports was on foot before the fifth round of wages had started and certainly long before it had concluded. Anybody who accepts that must then ask: what was it that caused the greater demand for imports before the fifth round of wages had been started or had concluded? There is an answer for that, but something was occurring in this country prior to that fifth round which called for more imports from abroad and caused inflation of that type. It was not the fifth round, and it could only be said that the fifth round had any effect on the moneys in circulation in the country towards the end of 1955 while inflation of imports was in full swing long before that.
Surely it will be accepted when you are speaking of inflation, that it generally means that because new purchasing power is put into certain people's hands and the quantity of goods remains steady, there will be a bigger demand and prices will rise, but that it is not inflationary, if wages are raised to meet prices that have already risen and risen outside the impact of the new money on the articles that are being sought. That is what happened here. If wages are not raised to meet increased prices that occur mainly through goods imported from abroad then there is in process an operation which is a definite deflation programme in which people are expected to put up with less purchasing power than they had before but it is wrong to describe as inflationary this mere matter of rising wages to meet new costs when new costs are not attributed to new money in circulation.
For that reason, it is completely wrong to say that there was any inflation caused by the fifth round of wages. I also assert it is nearly as wrong to say there was any great trouble caused in the balance of payments because of the fifth round of wage increases. But something caused it. I have always accepted one statement that I got from the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, coming from the records of his Department, that it was in the year 1955 that personal savings had fallen by £30,000,000; in other words people who had saved withdrew their money from savings, or people who were wont to save refused to save in their accustomed way. The result was that there was £30,000,000 more in the people's hands because of their not saving or withdrawing from savings, more than they had in the previous year, and it was that that was responsible for the inflation, such as it was, and for the unbalance in payments. That was rectified by the measures which Deputy Sweetman, as Minister for Finance, took, backed by his own Government. They had the effect, as I said at the beginning of my speech, that the balance of payments difficulties had been completely ended at the end of the financial year we have just gone through. At the start of this financial year, the position was that balance had been achieved and, if the terms of trade ran as much in our favour as they had, not in 1955 but in 1954, there would be not merely a balance but an actual credit, an actual balance to credit, of about £7,000,000.
However, between the mistaken views which operated on the making of this Budget and the failure of the Minister for Finance to recognise the other ways of getting the moneys required, he withdrew the subsidies and we are now faced with these proposals. I accept it that the Minister knew that the £5,000,000 was there in the special import levies and that his Budget could have been balanced, by the acceptance of the fruits of these levies in that way.
I know that the reason why that programme was not accepted was this mood which the Fianna Fáil members had on themselves, that wages were causing all the difficulty, that the increase in wages was causing the increased difficulty and that it was only when the standard of living was brought down by making them bear a greater cost, by letting them make less money according to the Fianna Fáil standard, that that position would be rectified.
There has been some talk in this House with regard to the handing over of money to the bakers. There was also a certain amount of anxiety expressed in the House about a movement that is on foot—and we can see it in the process, as it has become fairly obvious in procedure in recent months—where an attempt has been made by certain large milling units to buy up smaller mills and bakeries throughout the country. We are now apparently starting on that, or at least there is apparently so much anxiety about it, that the Government have been urged to take steps to prevent such amalgamation. One Minister, asked about it, said it was not his business, that it was not in his power to do anything about it.
Deputies who were not here many years ago might be interested to look at a Prices Commission Report published in 1934, Index No. P. 1418. In those days public attention was concentrated on the performance of the great firm of Rank and Company in this country. This commission, which was established by Fianna Fáil on their first entry as a Government, reported in this way. They said:—
"In that connection, the following facts afford an eloquent commentary—"
That is, on certain points which were being urged—
"Twenty-three milling units showed an aggregate net loss on business in 1930 of over £13,000. In 1931 they showed an aggregate net profit of over £379,000 and, in 1932, the aggregate net profits earned by 24 undertakings totalled over £263,000. These results included, of course, profits from maize-milling, etc., but arose chiefly from flour-milling activities. They were, in fact, the results of a costing system based on the least economic unit in the industry."
That was the foundation of the whole milling industry in this country under Fianna Fáil in 1932. They allowed a costing system to be built up based on the least economic unit in the industry. The excuse or argument used in those days was that you had to keep the mills from going out of production and therefore you arranged a price which allowed the least economic mills to remain in production and the rest built up the profits. The report goes on to say:—
"The recent flotation of Messrs. Ranks (Ireland), Limited, is even more eloquent. Concerns previously capitalised at a lower aggregate figure were incorporated in a new company with a nominal capital of £700,000 and it was possible for the promoters to make a successful flotation on the basis of a market value of £1,452,500. Their success in disposing of the shares offered to the Irish public for a sum of, presumably, £533,750, despite the fact that effective control over the company was not transferred with such shares, must have been largely due to the following assurances contained in their prospectus——"
There follows this quotation, then from Messrs. Rank's prospectus of 1932:—
"The amount required annually to pay the dividend on the 350,000 6 per cent. Cumulative Preference Shares is £21,000; on the basis of the average profits for the last three years the dividend on the said 6 per cent. Cumulative Preference Shares is covered more than seven times, and on the same basis the amount available for dividend on the Ordinary Shares, subject to reserves, is over 38 per cent."
That was the system established by Fianna Fáil in 1932. They established a costing system based upon the least economic unit in the whole flour milling industry in this country.
Now there is anxiety expressed by certain Fianna Fáil Deputies because it is thought that Ranks are swallowing up a lot of the smaller milling units in the country. It has been suggested to the Minister that that programme ought to be impeded. It was a programme which was directly led up to by them. Even when the 1934 Commission Report indicated that the flotation of the company, floated with a nominal capital of £700,000, was far higher than the aggregate of the capital involved in the business, and that with a £700,000 nominal capital they had floated their company on a market value of £1,450,000, these people are wondering why Ranks have grown so big that they can proceed now with this new scheme of theirs of buying up a lot of the smaller milling units. It is the fruit of the 1932 programme.
In 1932, there was at least this excuse, that whatever was done was done to prevent the small milling units being bought up, being swallowed up by these giant concerns. Now, when the Minister's attention is drawn to the fact that this programme has produced this result, he says it is not his business and he certainly is not going to interfere with private property, that they can deal with it anyway they like.
I have gathered from the newspapers that Fianna Fáil have said their programme has been completely renovated. Notwithstanding that, we are told it is the same old Party and the same old programme. One of the troubles in recent years is that in the first three years during which the Coalition Government was in office, it tried to do in three years what could easily have been spread over the 15 years during which Fianna Fáil were in office. We did try to do too much in too short a space of time. We found that after 15 years the standard of existence in the country was such that 1,000,000 people could not be asked to pay a penny piece for medical or surgical needs for themselves and their families. Even that, apparently, was too high a standard. That was the standard of 1947.
In 1952, the Minister for Finance of those days thought the people were too well off, that we advanced then to a stage where we needed a good deal of productivity. Productivity was not attended to in the years when money was cheap and was available—not the £100,000,000 the Tánaiste thinks he can get elsewhere. Money was freely available and it could have been used and was not used in those days. Anything which was used was used in respect of industry, to the complete neglect and detriment of agriculture. We are now to have an agricultural programme. We are told that in this Budget there is provision for a very big improvement in agriculture. I want to know where it is. I can see a certain amount for marketing proposals. What proportion of the whole budgetary proposals is the amount newly proposed for expenditure in agriculture?
We are to give attention to agriculture and try to get exports. We will be in the position at the end of the year that the only subsidy which the taxpayer will be asked to provide will be a subsidy to sell our butter, at a loss to ourselves, in England and possibly, if the wheat yield is as good as it is thought to be, we may have wheat to sell, but we will have to subsidise it if we are going to sell it abroad.
Finally, the Tánaiste has announced that the Central Bank has come under criticism and it is thought desirable to make some improvement in the structure of the Central Bank. That is going to come from the Party who set up the structure of the Central Bank. He objected to the aims that we on this side of the House suggested. We aimed at having in this country two things— that the volume of credit in the country and its direction should be under Government or State control. We were derided and we were told that that was gripping the people's savings and they tried to make it clear to the country that, in fact, we were robbing the banks and robbing the owners of these small savings. Now, apparently, we are going to get something of that type introduced.
Meanwhile—Deputy Allen referred to this—the old situation still is allowed to remain as it has been for many, many years, the situation in which there was money, many millions of money, available for investment in this country and not directed here because the banking system was entirely wrongly orientated.
The Minister for Lands talked about the economic illiteracy that prevailed in the Dáil. We thought the majority in this House should say where people's savings were to be invested and all that time the money was being invested abroad, mainly in England, and since 1946, in England, the Bank of England has been under the control of the Government in England. It was referred to in the House of Lords debate on the 7th March of last year. One of the members of that House said:
"...in view of the close association of the whole banking system with the finance of this country, I think that the Chancellor of the Exchequer should make personal contact with the heads of the joint stock banks. I am aware, of course, that under the Bank of England Act, 1946, he has, through the Bank of England, powers of direction to the joint stock banks. The actual words in the Act, which for those noble Lords who have forgotten them I will read, are these:
‘The Bank,'——
that means, the Bank of England—
‘if they think it necessary in the public interest, may request information from and make recommendations to banks, and may, if so authorised by the Treasury, issue directions to any banker for the purpose of securing that effect is given to any such request or recommendation.'"
In this country, where people recoil in horror from the thought that banks ought to be under the control of the State, particularly in respect of the amount of credit that may be allowed in the country or the direction of that credit to worthwhile and socially-good objectives and where people recoil in horror from the thought that in this country the members of this House or the members of the Government should have any such control, we freely send our money across the water to English banks who, under the 1946 Act, are under the control of the Treasury and of the Chancellor of the Exchequer in England. For years we have been in the situation where we would rather trust the Chancellor of the Exchequer in England than trust our own people and we have allowed our funds to go over to irrigate whatever requires any irrigation in England, by way of industrial development, by our moneys, under the direction of the Treasury.
For years we pleaded that, not even so radical a move as that, but some such move should happen here which would control all credit and that the volume of credit and its direction should be under the control of the representatives of the country. That was described as robbing the people of their investments, taking away the people's savings and there was a cartoon in 1952 depicting the then Deputy Sean MacBride, Deputy Norton and myself as the burglars in the bank vaults getting after the people's savings. Now, apparently, the renovation of Fianna Fáil policy will bring something of that nature about after all the years in which these moneys could have been invested here, the 15 years that Fianna Fáil were first in office, when with the aid of a decent banking system, all this money could have been applied to development and could have been done so easily, instead of the attempt having to be made, with the difficulties that have arisen, to try to do in two or three years what was neglected in the doing for all the previous years of Fianna Fáil.
If anybody desires to quote or to listen to any quotation, or misquotation, of a broadcast that I made on the eve of the 1954 election, I shall be happy to read what I actually did say. Deputy Allen made one of the usual misquotations. He is to get the quotation and to quote it here correctly. If he wants it, I shall give it to him. If anyone wants it during the course of the debate on the Finance Bill I shall read it. It is not the folly imputed to me.
What I did say was that there were several millions to the hand of a Minister for Finance who was anxious to get them and was able to look for them and I used that phrase for the reason that over the period when I was in the Department of Finance I knew well that when the Estimates came along from Departments they were exaggerated. When these Estimates were pruned down by some sort of screening process there was still more than what the Departments could spend. I remember saying that and it being put to me as a dangerous thing to say because I was almost challenging the Departments to spend the money they put in the Estimates as being necessary for their provisions during the year. Notwithstanding that challenge, year after year, there were savings that it was easy to make in the volumes that came from the Departments.
I never said £7,000,000; I said several million pounds. I went on further to say that if the saving of £20,000,000 which was so definitely desired by the people of the country were to be made, it could only be made by cutting out some of these gigantic Government Departments which I thought were extravagantly butting into people's lives and doing at great cost what the people could do at cheaper cost for themselves. I made no promise of saving £20,000,000. I said that if the £20,000,000 were to be saved, that was the only way to do it.
I see in these Budget proposals we are getting some economies by minor efforts in regard to civil servants, nothing like what could be got by merely using the ordinary wastage in the Civil Service itself, but, in any event, somebody's mind is turning at last on the Fianna Fáil side to getting the cost of Government taken down. There will be only pettifogging little economies unless the big gigantic Departments of State are overhauled and unless the work they are doing, as I think, extravagantly and needlessly, is left to the people to do themselves, and I think that they will do it at less administrative cost and in the end more cheaply.
In the end, when there comes to be a tussle, as there will be a tussle finally in this House, when things get really bad—and they are not bad now—this country will have to face up to whether all these extravagant proposals by way of Welfare State proposals are within the means of the country and whether, on the whole, it would not be better to have a proper wages policy and to allow wages to rise to meet the cost of living, to go in for a proper wages policy and then, given proper wages, ask the people to meet their own medical necessities, to meet all these other things that we are trying to give to them at very great cost to the State and in an extravagantly administrative way.
I believe that in England the mood is now changed and they are getting away from all these vast accumulations of benefits that they pretend to give free and without charge to the people and they are getting back to the better idea of letting people control their own lives and make their own future, giving them decent wages and letting them operate for themselves. It is a policy that we shall, of course, eventually follow and might have adopted seeing that the new policy is a bit better than the present one.
Comment on this
My remarks will be very brief. I have been listening to this debate for the past few weeks and have been amazed at the absence of speakers on the Fianna Fáil Benches. I admire them because this is a Budget with which the back-benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party are not in full agreement and for which they cannot make any sort of defence down the country. As a county councillor, I know that this Budget will cost every county council a very big increase for hospitals, mental homes, and so on and that councils may have to bring in supplementary estimates in order to meet these charges.
To be quite clear and honest, this Budget appears to me to be a rich man's Budget. It is a Budget which really affects only the poor people. Let us take bread, and only bread. We all know that bread is the main diet of the poor man. He cannot afford to have rashers and eggs in the morning; it is bread and butter that he has for his breakfast. Whether we like the fact or not, 80 per cent. of our agricultural labourers have meat only once or twice a week—bread, potatoes and butter are their staple diet. With the increase on bread and the increase on butter, Fianna Fáil have let down the people who actually support them. The vast majority of these people support Fianna Fáil. I have no hesitation in saying that some of them will support them again because we know that, in 1952, Fianna Fáil did exactly the same as they now have done, but there is an old saying: "Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me." It is possible that in time the working people of this country will realise that any statements made from Fianna Fáil platforms during elections are statements which will not be carried out.
One other point I want to make is that we shall have demands all over the country on behalf of the organised workers to meet the increases in food prices. There is, however, a vast body of people who are not organised. The agricultural labourer and the small farmer have no vast organisation to press for increases for them to meet increased food prices. I do not know whether the Agricultural Wages Board will grant an increase to agricultural labourers, but I hope they do. The small farmer has nobody to fight for increases for him. His ten stone bag of flour has been increased from 40/to 70/–. That is a vast increase for the average small working farmer who has nobody to fight his cause. No great service is given to him by way of pension or anything else. A great number of our small farmers are put in the middle-income group and if a small farmer has occasion to go into hospital to-day, he will have to pay roughly 10/– a day compared with 6/– a day during the past three years. Before we ever had a Health Act, a small farmer or worker could go into hospital and get a bed in a private ward for £3 to £3 10s. To-day, he has to pay £3 10s. for a bed in a public ward, and this under a new Health Act.
When this Government was formed, I was surprised to see that Fianna Fáil's previous Minister for Health was now Minister for Finance. I wondered if he would now put into operation all the recommendations which he made when he brought in the Health Act because I believe we never had to pay as much for hospital services in North Tipperary as we had to pay even before this increase came. It is all right for the Minister to say that he has instructed county managers or local authorities not to press for the increased hospital charges. We all know that once an order comes out, every county manager will press for this increased fee. Even the occupants of labourers' cottages, who now come within the middle-income group classification, will be asked to pay the increase.
Another point is that while there has been an increase in the price of a pint of stout or a bottle of stout, there has been no corresponding increase in the price of spirits. Whether we like it or not, we must admit that the pint of stout and the bottle of stout is the poor man's drink. I am told that often in Dublin it provides a lunch for a docker, along with a sandwich of bread and butter. I think this increase on stout will do a vast amount of damage to our malting barley trade.
Some years ago, when a pint of stout was only 10d., every barrel of barley sold in North Tipperary for 84/–. Some years ago, when the price of a pint of stout was 1/2 and the price of a bottle of stout was 7d. or 8d., the price of barley came down to £3 3s. because of the low consumption. With this extra 1d. and, in some places 2d., barley contracts will be reduced throughout the barley area. In North Tipperary, barley contracts have been reduced by from 18 to 30 per cent. The maltsters maintained that they had not sufficient sale for their malt and that they were not able to give contracts to those who grow barley. This increase is going to reduce the contracts still further.
Some speakers on the opposite side stated that this country was in a very poor financial state. I wonder how it is that it is always when Fianna Fáil come back into office that the country is on the verge of bankruptcy, that there is nothing in the cupboard, that we have pledged our credit abroad and that everything had been done to bring the country down? In their hearts, they know that the country is as sound now as it was for the past 15 years, but we are not honest in our politics. I believe that the day of love of country is gone and in its place we have got love of Party.
We should all throw our weight behind any honest Government which will tell the country where it stands and the best means of getting it out of its difficulties. We have people making promises from platforms about what they will do if they get back into office, about how they will give employment and look after the standard of living and then, within three weeks, the same people actually make a saving of £6,000,000 or £7,000,000 at the expense of the very people least able to afford it.
Various speakers from the Government side have said the money had to be got somehow. My belief is that the deficit could have been made up in some way other than by attacking the poorer sections of the community. We are told there was a sum of £140,000 given back by way of remission of stamp duty and by way of remission of taxation on racing. What about the house in the Phoenix Park and the embassies in Europe? We are to pay £1,000,000 for a new airport runway which the experts say will be a complete loss because jet aircraft will by-pass it. Restrictions on the import of certain types of motor cars, television and radio sets were relaxed. If the Government were sincere in saying this country was in serious difficulties economically, why did they begin by relaxing the import restrictions on these luxury goods? Had they decided to retain these restrictions, they might be able to convince the people of their sincerity. Even if these import restrictions brought in only £1,750,000, does their abolition not mean that the Government are not honest in their statements?
I do not want to be personal, but I believe the brain behind this Budget is that of the Taoiseach. I do not say that by way of a personal attack on a man for whom I have a great regard. However, I do believe that when the Taoiseach makes up his mind to do something, he will stick at it until he carries it out. I say that, having studied his career during the years. The Taoiseach got it into his head in 1952 that the people were spending too much. He then brought in a Budget that the people rejected. Now he has got from the people a stronger majority than he ever before enjoyed on the strength of promises that he would bring prosperity to the people's doors overnight.
Throughout the country, I saw Fianna Fáil slogans which said: "Housewives, get your husbands out to work; get cracking". Mind you, these slogans fooled a lot of people. They were meant to bemuddle and puzzle the poor unintelligent people in some places. In certain places, the people did fall for that propaganda. The Taoiseach, I think, set his mind on this in 1952. When he got his great overall majority in 1957, he said: "Now is my time to carry out the ideas I tried in 1952". If there was another election this year or next year, I do not believe Fianna Fáil would get the majority they now enjoy in the House because they definitely got in on false promises. I think the Taoiseach is honest now, however. Recently in Clare he made the statement that rugby football was the natural game——
Comment on this
No, but I want to finish the argument I set out to make. I do not think it matters which game a man plays, whether it be rugby, soccer, gaelic or any other game. The point is that it is only now the Taoiseach divulges the belief which he must have had since 1913. Was it the safe position brought about by the big majority in the House that prompted the Taoiseach to divulge that secret of his in 1957? Because of his precarious position in the House in recent years, he may have been afraid to divulge this belief earlier.
I invite any Deputy from the opposite side to come down to Thurles, Nenagh, Borrisokane or anywhere else in County Tipperary and publicly defend this Budget. I invite them to get up on platforms in these places and tell the people why bread, butter, flour, tobacco and beer were increased in price. Deputy Fanning interrupted me——
Comment on this
I thought it was the Deputy who interrupted. Perhaps I was expecting an interruption from him.
Comment on this
There is no answer to the contention that this is a dishonest Budget, one which will directly hit the poorer sections of our community. It was well planned. The Government think you can take 15/– a week from the people this year, give them back 4/– of it in a couple of years' time and make them believe they are getting something. They are not far wrong in that because people tend to forget these things, but it will take a long time for some people to forget the effects of this Budget which has come as a shock to the vast majority of the people who know that the wealthier classes have been let off scot-free, while the ordinary worker and small farmer must bear the brunt.
Comment on this
The main argument in this debate has developed around the abolition of the food subsidies. Many Opposition Deputies suggested that the Government had no mandate from the people for their removal. That brings us to the question as to what mandate the Government got from the people. This country has been faced for quite a time, and is still faced, with a very serious crisis, the terrible twin problems of high unemployment and high emigration, the general falling-off in production, the dwindling of our external assets and reserves to a dangerous level and the all-round scarcity of money for any worthwhile new development and, indeed, for existing projects. These all add up to a very serious situation.
Apparently our people have been losing the urge for and the desire to save. They have been suffering from the terrible consequences of the doctrine preached by the Coalition Parties, of better times for all and a lower cost of living, without having to make any sacrifice or any great effort to achieve this very desirable state of affairs. In fact, an atmosphere of despair was settling upon the people. That was the atmosphere in which the general election was held.
Nationally speaking, the people recognised that things were in a very bad way, that the country was heading for disaster, that it would take a good strong Government to pull the country out of the terrible situation in which it was floundering and to start the fortunes of the nation on the upward curve. That explains the result of the election. That is why we are here in such numbers and why we have such a big majority. That is the mandate we got, namely, to take this country out of the danger it was in and to save it from economic chaos and disaster.
Comment on this
The Deputy's argument would be true if his Party had told the people beforehand how it proposed to take the country out of danger.
Comment on this
The abolition of the food subsidies is an essential part of the financial policy enshrined in the Budget, a balanced Budget, and without their abolition it would have been impossible to have the financial foundation to carry out the broad, plain and unmistakable mandate we got from the people.
Comment on this
If, in ten years' time, the people were to exercise, as Deputy Dillon would suggest, their prerogative to go wrong again, and if, as a result, the Coalition Parties were able to form another Government, they would not put back the food subsidies. If any Deputy were so unkind as to remind them of all they said in this debate about their abolition, they would sit tight and leave them off because in the meantime, it would have been proved that the course that has been taken in this Budget of removing the subsidies was the right course to take and proved to have been the right policy. They would adopt the same attitude as they adopted when they came back after the 1952 Budget. They would do nothing about it, but leave the matter as it was. When they brought in their own Budget in 1955, it was almost a repetition of the Fianna Fáil 1952 Budget——
Comment on this
When these subsidies were first introduced, they were brought in as a very temporary measure—an emergency measure, if you like. I doubt that even then it was a wise course to take. There are many Deputies in the Opposition benches now who were very emphatic in their opposition to those subsidies. It is strange that they now appear almost to weep over their abolition. After reading the reports of what some of the Deputies on the Opposition benches at that time said against food subsidies, one must be pardoned for doubting their sincerity when they appear to be broken with grief over their abolition now.
Surely it cannot be held that it is good policy to continue helping the wealthier sections of the community to pay for their bread and butter. Surely it is not good policy to help anyone to pay for his bread and butter who is able himself to buy it. Does that not mean that such a person is getting and accepting a dole from the State? Surely it is more equitable to help the weaker sections of the community to pay for these commodities by sub-venting their incomes as much as possible. Is not that what the Minister has done in this Budget? Surely it was high time to call a halt to the spending of over £9,000,000 indiscriminately in doles on subsidies, particularly when we were so hard put to find between £8,000,000 and £9,000,000 to balance the Budget.
That brings us to the point which the Opposition Deputies have been dodging all along, the issue they have been running away from. Not one of them made a sound, serious suggestion as to how that £8,000,000 or £9,000,000 could be found.
Comment on this
They made tuppence-halfpenny suggestions — suggestions which, if carried out, would mean no material progress towards balancing the Budget but which would create more unemployment, or astronomical unemployment, as Deputy Dr. Browne said.
Deputy Norton assumed the role of a prophet towards the end of the general election campaign. He prophesied that Fianna Fáil would abolish the food subsidies. He omitted to tell the people that he was one of the privileged few who had got and read the report of the Advisory Committee which contained clear, reasonable, and well founded advice to abolish the food subsidies. Having read and studied the report apparently the impact on his mind of that report, and especially its reference to the abolition of food subsidies, was so great that he became prophetic and prophesied that Fianna Fáil would abolish them, if they came into power. He knew in his heart and soul that this was the only course a strong Government could take or would take in the circumstances, but he knew he would not be asked to take it and that he would not have the responsibility for taking it. He knew that someone would have to be hurt, but he came along when the deed was done, taking off his coat and shouting: "Show me the fellow who hit you." He was obsessed with his idea that the food subsidies would be removed and he knew it was certain that Fianna Fáil would be returned to power and that very probably a strong Fianna Fáil Government would be returned to power. He was conversant with the advice given in that report, but he did not say that.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon mourns the fate of the ten-acre farmer who will have to give another 30/– for his sack of flour. Deputy Dillon, with all his knowledge of the farmers and of agriculture, forgot to say, or omitted to say, that the ten-acre farmer could have a half-acre of wheat and if he kept most of that crop—he would not have to keep it all—he would have ample to provide for himself and his family. If he did that, he would have to buy very little flour. Deputy Dillon may rest assured that the ten-acre farmer and the farmers generally, will accept and make whatever sacrifice is demanded of them in this crisis in the nation's interests. He may rest assured that they will show the same spirit now as they did during the economic war when they were called upon to make much greater sacrifices.
Comment on this
They showed that spirit then and they refused to be stampeded into surrendering to the British.
Comment on this
I believe that the people on the Opposition Benches who think that the people will break now, as they expected them to break 22 years ago under pressure from the British, will be surprised. I believe the Irish people will show the same spirit now as they did then and I hope and believe that no section of our people will accept an invitation, from any quarter, to sabotage the great effort that has been so courageously started by the Minister for Finance in this Budget to save the country from economic chaos and disaster.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy a question? Did he at any time during the general election say that he would abolish the food subsidies?
Comment on this
The longer I have listened to the Budget debate, the more I am impressed by the words in Charles Dickens's work, A Tale of Two Cities: “It was the best of times; it was the worst of times. It was the season of darkness; it was the winter of despair.” It was the best of times and it was the winter of despair, so far as I can see, for the people of this country.
Comment on this
Of all the proposals which have come before this Parliament since I became a member of it, there is none that shocked our people more than the recent Budget. We have statements made by Ministers up and down the country that people are living too well and eating too much. We would like to know from the Minister has the time come in this country when some body is to be set up to control our appetites and arrange our standards of living in this welfare State. Let me examine the position as I find it. In order to protect our standards of living and to rectify the balance of payments problem which appeared last year, the inter-Party Government instituted the necessary precautions, but they said that under no circumstances would they impose undue hardship on our people. They considered that the only way to do this was to impose certain levies.
Comment on this
Those levies were imposed on cars, radios, television sets and cosmetics, and they brought in approximately £6,000,000. Those levies were causing no undue hardship on anybody. They were approved by practically every Party in this House and the only thing which Fianna Fáil did not agree with at that time was that the levies did not go far enough. Do they agree to that now, or are they objecting to it?
Comment on this
We may have said at some time that the Minister might not have gone far enough in his measures. We did not say he did not go far enough in his levies.
Comment on this
Butter has been increased to 4/4 a lb.; bread has risen from 9d. to 1/1; the sack of flour has gone up from 40/– to 72/–. The price of cigarettes and tobacco has increased and also the price of the poor man's pint.
Many other increases will follow as a result of this Budget. Just consider what these increases will mean to the people in the country. Take the poor man. Take the small farmer. How will they meet this situation? What will the increases mean in our institutions, in our county hospitals, in our county homes, in our sanatoria? The result will be a further increase in the rates. Did the Minister or the Government foresee this dreadful imposition which has fallen on our people as a result of this Budget?
I welcomed Deputy Egan's courage in getting up here and speaking when so many members of his Party failed to contribute to the debate. He reminded me of a saying which we sometimes hear in this House, that is, of whistling when passing the graveyard.