We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 144–277 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

"The boy stood on the burning deck."

Comment on this

Get a new record.

Comment on this

If the Fianna Fáil Party had a new record they would have played it before now. Apparently they have not and, therefore, they have been silent. There are some features of this Budget which I should like explained in more detail. A sum of £250,000 will be spent on the development of markets. In what sphere will that money be spent? The removal of the butter subsidy and the consequent increase of 7d. per lb. in the price will naturally mean that we shall have a greater surplus of butter than was originally anticipated. It must be admitted that, in order to enable us to compete with other countries, it will be necessary to subsidise our butter exports at the rate of 1/8 per lb. Is the £250,000 to be spent in that direction?

The Minister has also suggested that he intends to curtail the Civil Service which is costing us about £17,000,000. I have always found civil servants very competent, as is the case, I am sure, with every other Deputy, and I have no reflection to cast on them. Nevertheless, we feel the Civil Service is costing the nation too much, and, for that reason, I welcome the Minister's statement.

A sum of £160,000,000 is being spent on the services of 2,750,000 people. It is a ridiculous sum of money for such a small community. Surely it is about time some reductions were effected in that direction? The Minister and the Government should do something to ease the unemployment situation. A recipient of unemployment benefit is entitled to £3 1s. per week. I suggest that, by the expenditure of an additional £2 or £2 5s. per person, we could put such persons into productive work. It seems ridiculous that so many people are in receipt of £3 1s. per week while they are idle when so many of them would prefer to earn that money. The Minister should make some suggestion or recommendation in the very near future as to putting those people in employment.

Mention has been made of the Health Act and the Minister has recommended economies. The present Minister is the man who introduced that Health Act, in the first instance. I should love to hear him say he is considering scrapping that Health Act altogether because it is a dreadful burden on every county council in the country and the people whom it was intended to help find it more of a hindrance and a worry to them than anything else. The Minister should suggest to his colleague, the Minister for Health, the abolition of the present Health Act and the introduction of a new one.

In the course of the past week I met some people who were discussing the Budget. They pointed out to me that one effect of it is to increase the cost of living by £1 per week for a family of six. Surely that is a very heavy imposition? I wonder whether the Minister and the Government realised that such unpleasant consequences would follow from the disastrous increases? We know what happened in 1953 as a result of the 1952 Budget. I recommend the Government to go back to the country and receive from the people the same fate they received in 1953.

Comment on this

I shall try to be as realistic as possible and to dwell solely on what I believe the repercussions of this Budget will be on our community. In his introductory speech, the Minister paved the way in regard to the contemplated impositions. While drastic measures may require drastic remedies, I cannot for one moment believe that our country is in a worse position now than it was 12 months ago when the then Minister for Finance, without removing the subsidies or imposing extra burdens, brought about undoubted improvements whose benefits could be seen and felt in the course of the past financial year.

I know very well that the framing of a Budget is not the sole responsibility of a Minister for Finance. That responsibility rests on the Cabinet. They consider the problems which confront them and, by pooling their information, ideas and conclusions, finally arrive at a certain decision. The solution of these problems should, above all, be brought about with the least possible imposition on the people.

I hope the Minister will not take it ill of me when I say I honestly believe that neither much time nor much thought was given to the framing of this Budget and that the attitude was: "We have £8,000,000 odd here by way of subsidies. We will remove those subsidies—and to hell with the consequences." I will not refer to the statements made from public platforms by the now Ministers and the Deputies sitting behind them. If the people were gullible enough to be taken in by those statements and if they were lured to vote for Fianna Fáil by those statements——

Comment on this

What statements?

Comment on this

I can tell you this, my friend——

Comment on this

They are all falsehoods.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should address his remarks to the Chair.

Comment on this

——I do not know your name. The Dáil will be dissolved before I know half of you over there. If the people were gullible enough to be led astray by statements made from Fianna Fáil platforms, they now have plenty of time to ponder the error of their ways. Every time they sit down at their kitchen tables and see the loaf of bread in front of them, they must realise the extra amount placed on the loaf by their vote. While the price of bread might fall lightly on a certain very small section of our people every member of the House must admit it will fall heavily, and very heavily, on the middle and lower income groups, who form the great majority of our people.

Think of the man on a small salary, of the working man earning his weekly wage, of the old age pensioner, of the unfortunate drawing £1 disability benefit, of those who do not yet qualify for an old age pension and are solely dependent on the good graces of the home assistance officer who can give them, at most, only 10/– a week. Think of the unemployed we have, of those who walked up to this gate only last week. If this Budget was meant to restore stability to the country and if stability can be brought back only by the privations which the Budget has inflicted on these people, then all I can say is God help Ireland.

Comment on this

Amen.

Comment on this

Let us come to the question of butter. Bread and butter go hand in hand. While we cannot do without bread, there are substitutes, or supposed substitutes, for butter. They have been and are being availed of. They have to be. To-day, with huge stocks of butter in cold storage, we are facing the greatest butter production year we ever had. We cannot sell what we have in cold storage. If we could, it would not be there. Then we have the new crop coming in on top of it. When it could not be sold at the old price, how will it be sold at the increased price? What will be the result? Is it not plain that, if the butter is to be sold, it must be sold at a reduced price? A reduced price for butter means a reduced price for milk. It is well known that the dairy farmers have increased their herds over the years. With a reduced price for milk, those herds will be reduced again. That means a reduced population of young cattle, and if our young cattle population is reduced, it means a reduction in the revenue of our number one industry in this country—the export of our cattle.

I am merely giving my views honestly to the House. I can see the writing on the wall, so far as the dairying industry is concerned. In spite of that, this House has been asking the farmers to work harder and produce more. Surely we do not believe for one moment that the farmers should turn themselves into the nation's philanthropists? Surely we do not expect that, at our bidding, they will plough and sow and dig and mow, for no purpose other than to feed the people of this country? If we want them to do that, surely we should give them some encouragement by way of decent prices for the goods they produce? If we give them that, it will encourage them to produce more and still more. Not alone that, but it will be an encouragement to their families to stay on the land with them. In that way, we will be helping to stem the flight from the land.

I am not taking up a political attitude. For the sake of the country, I hope that the predictions I have made here will never come to pass. We have the increased tax on petrol. There are very many who would not mind if petrol were 20/– a gallon. Those people are forgetful of the fact that petrol plays a big part in the life of the country. I cannot understand how this extra price could be put on petrol at a time of year when we are paying thousands of pounds to foster the tourist industry. It is supposed to be our second best industry. Surely there is no member of the House listening to me but must admit that 6d. a gallon extra on petrol, more than in England or Northern Ireland, must affect the tourist industry for the coming season? At the same time, we are throwing away thousands to develop that industry.

That poor man's pint! I remember sitting over there this time last year listening to abuse hurled across the floor at us because of the poor man's pint, not because we had put any increase on it but because we had not taken off the increase put on by a former Minister for Finance in 1952. Now we come to 1957 and it has taken a Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance once again to add still another 1d. to the pint. The rich man may have his champagne, his whiskey and so on, but we must always bear in mind that the pint is the poor man's beverage and, so long as he earns the price of it, he is as much entitled to that pint as the rich man is entitled to his champagne and his whiskey. That imposition was cruel. It was harsh. It was bad enough to increase the price of bread and butter but increasing the price of the pint is altogether outrageous. I hope the predictions I have made here will not come to pass, for the sake of the country, but I warn the House that there is a possibility of their coming to pass. We can only wait and see.

Comment on this

This Budget has been debated fully here for some eight or nine days and it is somewhat difficult to speak at this stage without the risk of repetition. However, I would be accused of a grievous sin of omission by my constituents in East Cork, by those who supported what is now the Opposition and by many also who supported what is now the Government, if I did not express their abhorrence at the action perpetrated by the Minister for Finance in the Budget he introduced some three weeks ago.

While there is some element of disadvantage in speaking three weeks after the introduction of the Budget when so many have said practically all that has to be said, there is too an element of advantage in intervening at this late hour. In the period that has elapsed since we have had an opportunity of seeing the effects of the budgetary impositions and hearing the people's views thereon. I want to put briefly before the House some of the criticisms I have heard.

I own a grocery, provision and bar in a provincial town. It is not a very big business and it is not a very small business either. I have had an opportunity in that business of observing what is happening and listening to the people's comments. To say they were shocked is to put it mildly. It is my belief that the housewives now have become indifferent in the matter of balancing their own budget and, if the present trend continues, I am afraid their morale will break. I have also noticed that the sale of butter has decreased over the past three weeks by anything from 35 per cent. to 50 per cent. and the sale of margarine has increased correspondingly. Is all the money that we have invested in the improvement of health and the improvement of our institutions here now to be negatived because of our putting that important essential, butter, out of the reach of so many of our people? That is an aspect that the Minister for Finance and his Government should seriously consider.

People are asking if the Minister for Finance had anything at all to say in the framing of this Budget. I believe that this Budget could truly be described as a Civil Service special. I am sure what really happened was that the Minister's financial advisers kept dangling this £9,000,000 deficit before his nose until he finally took the plunge and abolished the food subsidies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I would remind the Deputy that the Minister is responsible for the Budget and not any civil servants, or combination of civil servants, or any Department of State.

Comment on this

It would appear then that the Minister wielded his 78-member Party and his big majority like a shillelagh, struck out at every source of income within his reach and left us with the terrible impositions that we now have to bear. Consider the position of the unemployed man, the unemployed man who was holding on for the next spectacular recovery plan promised by Fianna Fáil. He thought he would get a new start in life and he finds instead that he has to pay an extra 7d. on the pound of butter and an extra 4d. on the loaf of bread. Apparently the Minister and his Government think that an unemployed man and his family can exist, or subsist, on one loaf of bread and one lb. of butter in the week because the compensatory allowance was an extra 1/– per week for that unemployed man.

Those who are successful enough to own a motor car are under orders as a result of this Budget to leave the car rust in the garage because of the extra 6d. per gallon on the price of petrol. National policy seems to be: take the bus, scrap the car, denude the Road Fund and create still further unemployment.

There was one statement in the Budget that might be interpreted in its favour. That was the Minister's reference to the radical changes he intends to make in the Civil Service. He said we had 32,000 civil servants costing us £17,000,000. That statement was received generally as something that might be regarded as an earnest. How inconsistent it appears when twice since that statement was made in this House advertisements have appeared in the daily papers for the recruitment of still more civil servants. It is no wonder the people are growing a little uneasy about the burden of government.

I notice Deputy Corry is not here to-day. I had the doubtful pleasure of listening to him here about three weeks ago. He was one of the Fianna Fáil Deputies who had sufficient neck to come in here and try to defend this Budget. But he accused his own Minister in relation to the Civil Service. He told the House there were worse things in store and that next year's Budget would be worse still. I wonder has Deputy Corry forgotten the promises he made to the people of East Cork when he told them on different occasions during the election campaign that there was a brighter future in store, that the price of wheat would go up, the price of milk would go up and the price of beet would go up. I have a copy of an advertisement here which appeared in last Saturday's Cork Examiner: “Fianna Fáil Victory Dance at Dungourney Hall on Sunday, June 2nd, Chris Moloney and his Band, Dancing 9.30-2.30, Celebrate the victory with Senator Liam Ahern and Mr. M. J. Corry, T.D., who will definitely attend. We are going ahead—Will you come with us?”

I wish to make reference to that advertisement, first of all, in connection with the statement: "Celebrate the Victory with Senator Liam Ahern and Mr. M. J. Corry, T.D., who will definitely attend.""Definitely" is not a word that is very often used in that context I presume it is put in there for one or other of two reasons. It may be that the people of East Cork thought or knew that Deputy Corry was not used to doing the things he told the people he would do, and it may be put in to encourage them to come, that he was definitely coming. It may be used for another purpose, that, because the people, ever since the election, have got such a feeding up of the Fianna Fáil Party and this Government, the Fianna Fáil hierarchy running this dance thought that the crowd would be small and they had to use the word "definitely".

In any case, it concludes by saying: "We are going ahead—will you come with us?" We are going ahead and the people of the country know we are going ahead. I suggest that the Minister for Finance and the Government have put us ahead not only on the rugged path but on the rocky road. They have brought us to the verge of the cliff, the decline of which is so precipitous that if the Minister and the Government do not take stock, it may soon be too late to cry halt, much less turn around and climb back again.

I have already said it appears to me that this Budget was conceived without any serious thought. The Fianna Fáil Party, as Deputy Murphy pointed out, seem to be annoyed because we on this side of the House give views which the people expect us to give. I remember over the past two years that certain Deputies now on the Government side, never lost an opportunity of bringing in quotations, speaking here on all debates and even asking questions in an antagonistic and provoking way of the then Government. I refer to Deputy Neal Blaney, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, and Deputy Michael Davern who talked so much about the poor man's pint.

Fianna Fáil think we should now give them this Budget, that we should recommend it to the people. I say that any Party which takes credit for the rain must not be at all surprised if their opponents blame them for the drought. In regard to the overall position, I have been searching my mind over the past two years as to what has brought this country to such a state that the people are so over-burdened and discontented, and I have sincerely come to this conclusion, that there has been an infinity of political errors, which, being once adopted, become principles and unfortunately in many cases become law.

I do not wish to delay the House any further, but with your permission, Sir, before I sit down, I would make a reference to something I said when I came into this House two and a half years ago. I make it under the heading of economy. In this case, it would be an economy of words and money. I sat here three days last week and for a good part of to-day. I have listened to Deputies speaking at length, and it is no wonder that the Press and the public comment sometimes on the few Deputies who take an interest in the debates. When a person speaks for three hours it is not easy to sit and listen. I would suggest that it would be a good thing if we could make up our minds at the start of this session of the new Dáil to limit our speeches to a length that would keep us all interested. Then there would be more constructive ideas, and government would be better conducted and better carried out. What some Deputies lacked in depth, they gave us in length, and I make a special appeal that for this session we would all make a promise to say what we have to say as clearly and as concisely as possible, and thus give the country an indication that we are in earnest.

Comment on this

I would like to make some comments on the Budget, principally from a business point of view. When one comes to consider this Budget, one sees that it is produced in a framework of very difficult circumstances which this country is facing. It is, therefore, the duty of every Deputy to be as constructive as he can in this matter because we are in a time of great difficulty in Ireland and what we do now will vitally affect our whole economy, perhaps our very existence, and I feel we must do what we can to help in those circumstances.

I would have hoped that the Government, in its efforts to improve the national economy, would have done something towards alleviating the very heavy strain of income-tax at the present moment. Certain people are apt to think of income-tax as being a tax paid only by wealthy people. They forget that nowadays what are very often described as working people are paying income-tax. Industry pays income-tax and it is with that aspect of it I would like to deal principally this evening.

I mentioned the framework surrounding the Budget, and that framework is the one of the credit squeezes, shortage of money, decreased business, agriculture not increased, and high figures of unemployment. The Budget is usually used as a means not only of accounting for the nation's expenses, but of helping to improve the national economy and the health, happiness and livelihood of the citizens. We all know, and I need not labour the point, that we have tens of thousands of young people leaving the country every year. We all deplore it, and I am sure everybody, not only in this Chamber but outside, is anxious to see that flow of young people—and older people, too— arrested. One of the ways that can be done is by helping industry; the other is by helping and encouraging agriculture in every way.

In his Budget speech the Minister mentioned the concessions that had been given to firms engaged in export. Actually those conditions are very slight but I would like to have seen him give those concessions to industries which are not engaged in the export business. I do not want to be taken as decrying, even by inference, the necessity for exports. Of course the more exports we can get the better it is for the country generally, but there are also people engaged in various types of trade and commerce and industry and who are not engaged in any form of exporting and who are very unlikely to be engaged in exporting in the foreseeable future. We do not have minerals or metals—to take one group of articles—in this country, so that to build up an export business in that type of goods can only be done by exceptionally skilled firms. I wish them the best of luck.

As I say, it is a valuable contribution to our economy but there are many people—and this is the point I want to make—engaged in industry of a type which does not readily lend itself to exporting and yet those industries are of enormous importance in the total employment here. If they are not flourishing we shall have high unemployment figures and that is what is happening now. The whole building industry is in a very bad state at present. That is having its effect on other industries and trades and we have the sad fact that skilled men are obliged, through unemployment, to emigrate.

We have firms in difficulties and firms who find that they have to dispense with men in order to keep down rising overheads. I would have expected the Government to have made concessions to industry in that respect in this Budget. One way in which this could be done is in the tax allowance for capital expenditure. Under certain circumstances businesses are obliged to make capital expenditure but they have to do that out of money on which tax has already been paid. That, coupled with the fall in the value of the £, has placed a very serious burden on industry and production in this country.

We are not finding the necessary capital to improve our trade and manufactures or even to put industry into the position in which it could, perhaps, in certain circumstances, build up an export trade. That is something I would have expected the Government to remedy. Furthermore, as is well known, we have a tax system in this country which is designed for one of the greatest manufacturing countries in the world. We are very largely agricultural and we now find ourselves in the position that industry is being very severely handicapped on that account.

Many Deputies here represent rural constituencies and, naturally, the problems they deal with from day to day are those arising from agricultural matters; nevertheless, I think most of these Deputies will appreciate that what I am saying is not just talk of business people trying to rid themselves of burdens which they do not like. I refer to the desire of business people to be rid of burdens which should not be put upon them because, as a result of that, the industries here are not in a position to give the employment which they could, and would, give, if they were not faced with these appalling tax burdens.

I do not want to make a long speech, as Deputies have already heard a number of speeches; but I would stress again that it is only by encouraging agriculture and industry that we can get ourselves out of this position in which we have high unemployment figures and the export of young people. One of the ways to do that is to take the shackles off industry and encourage agriculture by every means in our power.

Comment on this

There are no shackles on agriculture.

Comment on this

I said we should take the shackles off industry and encourage agriculture by every means in our power. The shackles referred to industry. I shall close on that note. I do not think the Government showed any imagination or made any real concessions to industry in this Budget. They have not faced the real problems which lie in front of this country. The Budget should be used as an instrument for furthering social policy. At the present moment we as a Government certainly are living too extrava-gantly. There were many promises made during the elections and people faithfully believed, apparently, judging by the way they voted, that those promises about lavish expenditure would be honoured. They have not been honoured in this Budget. There-fore, regretfully I say that this Budget has made very little contribution towards alleviating the very real difficulties under which we are suffering at the moment. I believe we shall pull out of it, but we shall need all the help from the Government we can get and I am afraid we have not got it in this Budget.

Comment on this

The few remarks I shall make are quite impromptu. They are born of the fact that there was another demonstration outside Leinster House to-day. I am beginning to wonder what all these demonstrations are about. I am beginning to think that what has happened here over the last five or six weeks has not helped us as a Legislature to get down to the problems and tackle the root causes of demonstrations of this kind.

I do not have to defend this Budget. I am not going to do so. People more competent than I have made the case already. There is no point in reiterating what has been said several times already. What I want to say is that this Budget has been the most disappointing political experience I have had since I came into the House. The day the Government was formed, I left the House with a very happy feeling that a new age was dawning in Irish politics.

I admired the speech made by Deputy Costello when he became Leader of the Opposition. He said it was now agreed on both sides of the House that we had very serious problems to tackle. If that is so, I must ask him why it is that Fine Gael have come again with the same claptrap and nonsense of 1952, which was rejected by the Irish people. We cannot afford this nonsense, this talking in a vacuum about the problems of the Irish people, this blathering here at great length, trying to make a nation of whingers out of the people. That policy has failed. It is a policy which, as far as Fine Gael is concerned, only for Deputy Sweetman would have gone much too far.

I always admire the way Deputy Sweetman tried to face up to the very serious problem we as a country had to face. He had behind him a solid phalanx of people who kept on saying from day to day: "There is no need of this, it is all unnecessary and undesirable and we do not have to face up to it." We have Deputies now saying that we still have the liquid assets we had ten years ago and all this nonsense, as if this were not the only country in Europe which has a declining population, a declining population of working age, a declining labour force over the last five years, as if we had not all the problems which Deputy Dockrell, for one in Fine Gael, was brave enough to stand up and admit we have to face and try to solve.

As well as that, and over and above all, we must try to get over to the Irish people that the day has gone when the State, or any policy on the part of any Government in the State, can decide what way the country is going to travel. It is the people who will decide in the long run whether we are to solve these problems or not. It is these young men who, I believe, laid themselves on the road and on the footpaths outside Leinster House to-day, who will have the solving of those problems every bit as much as the Government which happens to be here in charge of the affairs of the State. We can only point the way; it is up to the people to decide whether they will travel that way or not.

All the plans, big and small, produced by our side, by Fine Gael, Labour and everyone else are based on the assumption and statement that the Irish people have the initiative, the energy and the goodwill to solve these problems. I am beginning to doubt it. I am beginning to doubt if these people who come along talking about unemployment and about not being satisfied with paper proposals any more, who want practical proposals based on something concrete, really know what they are talking about or want to provide a solution for the problems that we are facing. There are methods by which we can solve the unemployment problem, but they are methods used in Russia and not in Ireland. There are methods by which we can solve unemployment, which have been used in Germany and Italy. Do these people want those methods to be used and if so will they get up and say so?

In the meantime, why are Fine Gael sending up a solid phalanx of speakers, one after another, coming out with that claptrap again in 1957, that there is no need for "this unnecessary, this undesirable, this hairshirt Fianna Fáil Budget." We have been through all that before. When Deputy Costello rose after the election of Taoiseach, I thought we had finished with all that. Occasionally, someone like Deputy Declan Costello deals with the Budget in a sensible way by making constructive proposals. I suppose he will find himself on the mat at the next Fine Gael Party meeting along with Deputy Sweetman. Of course, I do not agree with what Deputy Declan Costello said about the Budget, because it is fundamentally based on the statement that we should retain the levies and treat them purely as taxation. When the levies were introduced by Deputy Sweetman, it was not intended that they should be used as a form of taxation: they were intended to be used for the purpose of reducing the adverse balance of trade, reducing imports and thereby reducing the gap between exports and imports.

The Taoiseach at the time, in December, 1956, was very proud when he was able to announce here in the Dáil that the levies had had the desired effect and had bridged a large portion of the gap which everyone admitted was too large. We now find Deputy Declan Costello saying he wants those levies retained for taxation purposes. I do not agree with him —but at least it is a constructive suggestion from the Fine Gael side of the House.

I heard nothing from the Labour side which would even suggest that anyone in the Labour Party realises that such problems exist in Ireland to-day. Do we have to go over them again? I do not think it is necessary. Anyone who has read, as I did, the report of O.E.E.C.—which of all things is a dispassionate report by impartial people who are looking at this country from outside—anyone who had bothered to read it, and in particular the chapter on the problems of this country, could not rise here, or certainly should not, to pretend that in 1957 we can tell the Irish people: "Everything in the garden is rosy; all we need do is put out those people; their hairshirts are unnecessary hardships; and we will look after you." We have had too much of that.

We must say to the Irish people— and I want to say to those young people who are lying outside on the road to-day—"what do you want us to do? Just come along and tell us." They ask that the Deputies talk to them. We will talk to them from here. We will talk to them anywhere. We will be glad to meet them any time. They are people who are supposed to have ideas. Let them tell us in what way we should solve these problems. We are not afraid to face them at any time, but, at least, let us tell ourselves, to begin with, that unless we do what Deputy Costello said we would do, that is, from both sides of the House, tackle these problems and admit that they are there, we will continue to be talking in a vacuum in this House and we will be going backwards instead of forwards over the next five years.

I know that the Budget was harsh, but it was less harsh than the sad experience of the debate on it in the Dáil. I know it was harsh, but these organised demonstrations were no help —organised, I should like to know, by whom, for what purpose, to what end and founded on what belief? It has been very disappointing and I hope that when Deputy Sweetman gets up to speak this evening as I am sure he will, he will bring some light into this debate from the Fine Gael point of view. Let him tell us what he would have done as Minister for Finance to balance the Budget. Let him tell us whether he thinks we should have tried to balance it at all or not. Let him tell us whether or not these serious problems exist, if Fine Gael want them to be solved and, if so, how.

Finally, will he agree with me when I say that, no matter what Government is in this House, the day of paternalism is over and should be declared to be over? We have gone, if anything, too far on social welfare and we must now tell the Irish people that the future of this country does not depend on the efforts of any political Party, Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour or anybody else, but on whether they have what we politicians presuppose they have, energy, vigour, initiative and goodwill. I do not know whether they have or not. If they have not, they have no future as a people.

Comment on this

I would be failing in my duty if I did not protest against this Budget. I came into this House on the votes of workers and unemployed in my town. This Budget is about the twentieth Fianna Fáil Budget presented here. On each occasion that we had a Fianna Fáil Budget we were told there was a crisis hanging around. That was a smokescreen so that Fianna Fáil could put the screw on to the last twist. This time we have been told that there is a gap to be bridged. We have been given figures by various Deputies. I think some of them mixed up the prize bonds with their figures.

This Budget is to be balanced on the stomachs of the poor and the unemployed, the unemployed about whom we hear so much from the opposite side of the House.

Comment on this

See what I was talking about.

Comment on this

I am not talking about some of the gentlemen who may have lain down outside this House to-day. Some of them never stood up in their lives, if it went to that.

Comment on this

There could not be many of them from the Labour Party, anyhow.

Comment on this

Not at all. I know these gentlemen, and the type they are, and I do not have to tell Deputies here. This Budget is the product of people used to six-course dinners, but the people of whom I am speaking are used only to one course of bread and butter. That butter is now being replaced by margarine and the people are lucky if they have that at all. Fianna Fáil told us in the past that the people were eating too much.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

We were told by Fianna Fáil that the people were eating too much. A Deputy from the opposite benches was in the States recently and he told the people there that we were drinking too much whiskey and he asked would they buy the whiskey and make the Irish people sober. That is the mentality we have to deal with. At the same time, Fianna Fáil were putting a penny on what they were shouting about, the poor man's pint. Deputy Corry, who is conspicuous to-night by his absence, was one who shouted about the poor man's pint to such an extent that I almost felt thirsty, even though I am a pioneer.

Comment on this

Would you like to have him in? We will send for him.

Comment on this

We heard the outcry in this House in the past when a penny went on to a packet of biscuits. We were told the people would starve, that the ladies could not have their 11 o'clock coffee in the restaurants and gossip over everything except politics and the way they affected them. Now we hear a lot of talk about the mandate that Fianna Fáil sought and got. They had a slogan—"Bread and work for all." We were told that the first thing the Government were concerned with was unemployment. I should like to know what proposals are before this House to settle the question of unemployment. We heard talk about the Lemass £100,000,000, but we have heard no talk about it since the election. That was before the election. I have it in black and white, if Deputies want it. We hear talk about democracy. The people are losing faith in democracy because of the cheap slogans that people have fallen for. That is why we have such a poor poll at every election. The people are sick and tired of this sort of stuff. That £100,000,000——

Comment on this

What is the quotation?

Comment on this

I could quote for a week and the Deputy might not like to hear it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is referring to something that is supposed to have been said. We should like to know what it is.

Comment on this

Here it is, by the big chief himself—"By their fruits you shall know them." This is not fruit.

Comment on this

There is not a levy on it now. That has been taken off.

Comment on this

It has been taken off rock 'n' roll records.

We have handed back £1,750,000 to the Jews in the city and to the hire purchase boys for television which the Minister said, if I may quote him from the newspaper of Monday, 27th May, "is a must." We must have television, and, at the same time, we must take bread off the tables of the poor people. We must have radios and, as I said before, "rock 'n' roll" records. Some of the gentlemen on the opposite side said that the levies were too little and too late. Still, it was not too late to take £1,750,000 out of the pockets of the taxpayers. What a false sense of values we have. In reply to a question I asked here in regard to what subsidy the Minister for Agriculture is paying on Irish butter in the British market, I was told that it was 1/3½ a lb., that is, 1/3½ a lb. for John Bull to eat our butter. I further asked him would he estimate our exports of butter in the coming year and he replied 6,500 tons. We have increased the price of butter in this country by a little less than half that 1/3½ so that John Bull can have enough. We are going to pay John Bull £1,000,000 to eat our butter, but of course we will have plenty of butter to export before the year is out.

Comment on this

But John does not want it.

Comment on this

No, but he is being paid to eat it. I do not want to get into the Bog of Allen any more. In regard to the increase in the price of bread, we had a threat in 1956 by the then Deputy Lemass. I quote him from "Truth in the News" and some of the Deputies might be able to read it from where they are. Deputy Lemass said: "Bread is going up". He said: "Norton will have to tell the nation that". That was on February 19th, 1956, and Deputy Norton did not tell the nation that. That was running through the mind of Deputy Lemass then and we know the mentality on that side of the House.

Comment on this

What about cutting the slice off the loaf of bread?

Comment on this

If the Deputy went outside the House to-day, some of the Teddy Boys, for whom I hold no brief, might have cut a slice off him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Coogan, on the Budget.

Comment on this

Getting back to the Budget, I represent an area——

Comment on this

Not Teddy Boys, I hope.

Comment on this

No, we would not tolerate them.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Coogan is entitled to make his speech without interruptions. If Deputies do not wish to listen to him, they have the remedy in their own hands.

Comment on this

If they go out, I will ask for a House again. In my area, which is a tourist area, we have very many hotels which have accepted bookings over the past few months. This Budget is going to cause them a grave hardship and some steps should be taken to give them relief. Some steps should be taken to bring things to a pre-Budget level because these hotels accepted those bookings on that basis. I know they have been very badly hit. It is a matter for the Minister and I am just putting it to him to consider. There is not much more for me to say, because, no matter what I do say, the blister is on the backs of the people. Fianna Fáil have "got cracking" and the results will be shown only in an increase in T.B. That is how this Budget will be measured in the coming few years.

Comment on this

This Budget is a bad one not alone for the consumers and the farmers, but also for the wheat growers and the milk producers who were led by Fianna Fáil to believe that their conditions would be improved, if they were elected as a Government. It is clear that Fianna Fáil got no mandate for this Budget. They got their answer from the people when they introduced a Budget of this type in 1952. They were defeated in every by-election that took place after that time, until eventually they were forced to throw in the towel and have a general election in 1954 which gave the inter-Party Government a bigger majority than the present Government have at the moment. This Budget is the kind of Budget one would expect from the tired and lazy old Fianna Fáil Front Bench which has now introduced 19 or 20 Budgets.

It is strange that, on the average, the Budgets brought in by Fianna Fáil always created hardship and rarely created any kind of prosperity or improvement in the conditions of the people. It is strange that since we became responsible for our own affairs the Fianna Fáil Party have always been associated with hardships which were imposed upon the people by reason of their activities. The Minister in his speech put the cost of living up more in ten minutes than the inter-Party Government did in three years, since 1954. Fianna Fáil were put out of office in 1954 because they had put up the cost of living by over 20 points during the previous two years.

It is obvious that this Budget is going to cause a measure of destitution particularly amongst those classes in receipt of assistance. It is going to cause a measure of hunger among the poorer sections. It is obvious, if we are to be guided by the 1952 Budget, that unemployment will increase rapidly. In 1952, when the Budget was introduced, approximately 20,000 people lost employment in the succeeding few months. It is probable that this Budget will cause unemployment to the extent of 10,000 people, if we are to measure it by the hardships imposed in the 1952 Budget.

There is nothing in this Budget which shows that there is any attempt being made to improve the position in relation to either unemployment or emigration. The Fianna Fáil Party appealed to the unemployed people to give them support and have them returned in the recent election. The result of the general election shows that, in the whole country of 40 constituencies, the Fianna Fáil Party succeeded in getting only an extra 12,000 votes. It took me 10,000 votes to get in myself, and in the whole country Fianna Fáil got only an extra 12,000 votes. Now we have them with a large majority believing that they have a mandate to implement a Budget of this nature.

This is a tax on the appetites of the people instead of a tax on their pockets. It is obvious that the wage earners with the large families, the old age pensioners and the classes in receipt of assistance are going to find the difficulties imposed on them a very great strain. Fianna Fáil have always been two-faced with the people.

They have got away with it on every occasion. In 1951 they came in on a policy of which point 17 was the maintenance of the food subsidies and the control of prices. In 1952 a great part of the subsidies was removed and prices rose so steeply that by 1954 the cost of living had risen by 20 points. The price of the loaf of bread was increased by 3d. in 1952. Now there is another 4d. added, a total increase of 7d. on the loaf through the deliberate action of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

And a big bite taken off it by the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

The Deputy complains that the loaf shrank in size under the inter-Party Government. The Deputy's Party have now compensated the master bakers. I wonder will they put back the slice the Deputy talks about or will they just inflate the loaf? Anyway, it will cost 7d. extra, an increase put on by Fianna Fáil in the five years since 1952. Does anybody remember the harassed housewife the Fianna Fáil Party paraded up and down the country in 1952—the buxom lady with the furrowed brow and the silver hair? She complained that because the inter-Party Government gave an increase in the price of milk to the producers she found herself paying 2d. extra for her lb. of butter.

Of course the soft soap had gone up by ½d. in the £. She got a queer shock in 1952 when the Budget put up the cost of living by 11 points. Nowadays the lb. of butter and loaf of bread will cost approximately 5/5, and as compensation the recipients of social assistance are to receive 1/– a week. The greatest blow will be felt by the people in the rural areas who are now obliged to pay 1/– a stone extra for baking flour. Many of those families live on a diet of bread and tea, and the extra 1/– per stone will be a very severe imposition on them.

There we have the attitude of Fianna Fáil all the time. We remember that in 1951 the present Minister for Finance, then Minister for Social Welfare, told the old age pensioners that the country could not afford an increase of 2/6 a week on their allowances—that it would cost the nation £500,000. Now he gives nearly £250,000 to the master bakers while at the same time imposing higher prices on the consumers. Let us see what the results of the withdrawal of the subsidies in respect of bread will mean. It will have the effect of placing the wheat growers of this country in a position where they cannot expect an increased price for their home-grown wheat, although much of the preelection campaign was devoted to condemning the inter-Party Government because they refused to give to the wheat growers the price promised them by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

You said the farmers were getting far too much for it. We never said that.

Comment on this

We will see what the Deputy's Party will give the farmers.

Comment on this

We will not reduce it by 12/6 a barrel.

Comment on this

The Minister is now so opulent that he can give £150,000 worth of home-grown wheat towards the manufacture of animal feeding stuff. He says he can do that because there is the promise of a good crop this year. No thanks to him for that. The small bakers and millers of this country will also find themselves in difficulty this year. Already the big combines are buying up the small bakeries in order to get consumers into the heels of their fists.

Another effect of the increased price of flour is that small cakes which could be bought for 3d. each are now costing approximately 4½d. each. The people who bought these small cakes will now buy fewer or none at all because of the new prices. Notwithstanding all that, the master bakers were given £230,000 on a casting vote. This sum is to be paid retrospectively. In the meantime, the big bakeries were able to pay substantial dividends to their shareholders and to give increased wages to their staffs. That is the extra slice I heard Deputy Killilea talking about.

Then we turn to butter, the price of which has been increased to 4/4 per lb. It is reasonable to expect that milk producers will be the next to suffer as a result of these subsidy withdrawals. The subsidy of 5d. a lb. on butter made available by the inter-Party Government in 1954 was, in fact, a subsidy to the dairying industry to the approximate value of £2,000,000 a year. That has been withdrawn by a stroke of the pen in this Budget.

It is obvious that the creamery milk suppliers now will find themselves in economic difficulties in relation to the price that they may expect to get for their milk due to the cost of making creamery butter. As Deputy Coogan mentioned, we have a situation where we are subsidising butter for export to England at 2/10 a lb., while our unemployed people at home must pay 4/4 a lb. for it. It is obvious that this is the best stroke of business the margarine manufacturers have ever been handed. The withdrawal of the subsidy on butter will now encourage the widespread consumption of margarine because Irish people cannot afford to eat Irish butter. It is doubtful whether the taxpayers can continue to subscribe approximately 1/4 a lb. for butter exported to Great Britain.

The Milk Costings Commission set up by Fianna Fáil in order to confuse the farmers at a cost of £40,000 is now worthless. No matter what the Milk Costings Commission has decided, this Budget has ensured that milk producers will not get an increase in the milk they deliver to creameries. That, in turn, will affect the production of beef although in his Budget statement the Minister for Finance showed a strange conversion in favour of beef production. If the creamery milk suppliers are forced out of business—I believe this Budget will have that effect —we can expect a drop in our cattle population. In 1951 and again in 1957 when inter-Party Governments handed over office to Fianna Fáil, the cattle population had reached the highest levels in recorded history. I wonder what did the Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association think of the Government's action in withdrawing that valuable subsidy of £2,000,000 to the dairying industry?

I should like now to quote from page 18 of the Minister's Budget statement. He said:—

"The future of our cattle trade is so important that I am including provision for increased expenditure on the elimination of tuberculin cattle under the Bovine Tuberculosis Order, 1926, in those parts of the country to which a new intensive scheme does not yet apply."

That is a change of heart as far as the cattle trade is concerned when we remember the ravages of the economic war in this country which the Minister for Lands said was started by Fianna Fáil for the purpose of achieving a certain objective. We know the cost of that economic war to the country. Its loss to the country must have been something in the region of £400,000,000. We could do with that money to-day. Then we had the calf slaughter policy where the taxpayers' money was being used to reward farmers who brought the skin of a calf to the Garda station to prove that they had followed Fianna Fáil's teaching.

Comment on this

How did the Deputy escape at all at that time?

Comment on this

There is an answer to that one, too, but the question is not worth the reply. Due to all that nonsense in the 1930's, the people are now obliged to pay very dearly. When the slaughter of our cattle population was in full swing, we had the free beef scheme. People were given free beef because they could not dispose of it on the British market. Fianna Fáil were saying then: "Thanks be to God the British market has gone for ever." Now the Minister says that our cattle trade is most important.

In relation to the levies, I want to quote from page 4 of the Minister's Budget statement:—

"There has been a striking, and very welcome, improvement in the trade position in recent months but some further time must elapse before the continuance of that improvement can be regarded as assured."

That is a funny statement in the gloomy Budget the Minister presented to the House; it is a statement which gives promise of prosperity for the country. It is an admission by the Minister that things were in good hands under the inter-Party Government.

He continued:—

"Even with the levies in full operation our external payments have been barely in balance for the financial years 1956-57. Our capital shortage is still acute and the levies are a reliable and necessary supplement to capital resources."

Still, the Minister took away £1,750,000 in levies. In fact, these levies would approximately counterbalance the amount of the butter subsidy. However, in one stroke of the pen the Minister threw away that large sum and made the people pay more for their butter.

I heard some Fianna Fáil Deputies say across the floor of the House to-day that the levies had been removed from oranges. I wonder will the people who buy oranges be any happier. They are still paying the same price for oranges and what is the Government doing about it? They were very worried about the price of oranges. The price of sugar has also gone up by Fianna Fáil Order. In addition to that, the charges under the Health Act of 1953 have been increased. Hospital charges which up to the present had been 6/– per day have now gone up to 10/– per day. Before the introduction of the Health Act of 1953 people got absolutely free treatment. This extra burden is being imposed on poor people who must go into hospitals for treatment.

It will also mean that local rates will be affected. Corporations and county councils will now be obliged to make heavier contributions towards the health services under the 1953 Health Act brought in by a Fianna Fáil Government. In his Budget statement, the Minister gave a warning, apparently noted by Deputy Corry among others. He warned of the possibility of the withdrawal of the agricultural grant next year. This grant amounts to approximately £5,500,000 a year. Its withdrawal will be a heavy blow to the agricultural community.

It was indicated in the Budget statement that reductions were to be effected in our Army. In 1952, when Fianna Fáil were trying to hide the growing number of unemployed persons from the notice of the public, they put up large posters inviting all young men to join the Army. They got an extra 5,000 young men in who would be otherwise unemployed. It was a move to help the growing number of unemployed which resulted from the 1952 Budget. We have a statement now from the Minister in his Budget speech that he intends to reduce Army personnel and there was a question in the House last week about the dismissal of some 30 men at the Curragh.

Last week, we had some reference to Fianna Fáil's post-war policy. We remember very well much of the nonsense in which Fianna Fáil were engaged at that time. It was lucky the inter-Party Government came into office in 1948 and put an end to it. We remember their plans for new Houses of Parliament; we remember the imports of Dutch chocolate. There were ten years' supply of wet turf in the Phoenix Park, along with timber and African coal, and we remember the purchase of wheat at £50 a ton, at a time when our farmers were getting 50/– per barrel. We remember also the bus station controversy. That was all Fianna Fáil post-war programme. Those are some of their activities which the inter-Party Government found it necessary to stop. The wet turf and the African coal and timber were not paid for for seven years.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise in the debate on the Budget.

Comment on this

I am just relating it to the post-war policy that was argued between the Minister and a Deputy on this side of the House. We have also the scandal of the Paris Embassy.

Comment on this

What about the London Embassy?

Comment on this

This was the kind of extravagance which the people of this country hope they will forget in future. Let us remember that Fianna Fáil hold the record for registered unemployed. At one stage the number of registered unemployed persons in this country reached 146,000. On the other hand, the inter-Party Government has the record of the lowest number of registered unemployed persons.

Comment on this

If you had been long enough in office, there would have been nobody left in the country to be employed. They would have all emigrated.

Comment on this

That record cannot be denied. If the Deputy goes to the trouble of looking up the statistics, I am sure he will find it.

Under Fianna Fáil policy 500,000 people were obliged to emigrate and yet we had them whining last February about unemployment and emigration and pretending they had a policy to stop emigration and do away with unemployment. We have no evidence that the Fianna Fáil Party has any policy whatsoever, except the policy of hanging on, and they certainly will be able to hang on on this occasion with the majority which they have. I remember when the Taoiseach was challenged about emigration he produced figures for 1946 and 1947. At that time a man engaged in agricultural employment could not get a permit to leave this country. Other people had to get permits, but the agricultural labourer could not get a permit to leave the country for the purpose of going to work in England or elsewhere, so that the figures for emigration in 1946 and 1947 are false.

We remember the large posters of Fianna Fáil before the election: "Get the men to work". We do not see any evidence of it so far. We do not see any policy that will get the men to work, but we do see a Budget that is bound to cause unemployment, if we are to be guided by the results of the 1952 Budget. The people were asked to vote for stability, but it seems that they have voted for stagnation again. The miracle men asked for support to beat the crisis. What have they done since they came into office to beat the crisis? This Budget is obviously going to create conditions of stagnation in this country.

The trading position was improved remarkably under the inter-Party Government and its Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman. It is a pity that Fianna Fáil, just to please a few of these hire purchase people, decided to depart from that policy instead of following it out so that it would bear the fruits that it was expected to bear in this coming autumn.

I propose to conclude by asking the Minister to explain why the Fianna Fáil Party always have one face to show the public when they are in opposition and another to show the public when they are a Government. The leopard does not change his spots and the Fianna Fáil Party should have been sufficiently honest with the people before the general election to tell them they were going to complete their 1952 plan in 1957. In the Budget statement in 1952, the Minister for Finance at the time said he considered it was not advisable to abolish all the food subsidies. He indicated by that statement that it was an instalment of the Fianna Fáil policy. Of course, they found that it did so much damage in 1952 in the matter of unemployment and emigration, and a flop in business, that they did not go ahead with the abolition of the remaining food subsidies in 1953.

During the election campaign, they should have been honest with the people and should have told them they were going to pursue the policy which they embarked on in 1952 by taking away the remaining subsidies. These subsidies were part of the people's wages and it was very aggravating that the Minister, when he was taking away approximately £6,000,000 or £7,000,000 from the people by removing these subsidies, should ask them not to look for compensation; in other words, not to look for an increase in wages. It is obvious that the civil servants who have a cost-of-living bonus, and whose salaries are based on the cost of living, will be entitled to an increase in their salaries. People outside the Civil Service will also be entitled to an adjustment in their earnings as compensation for the increase of approximately five points in the cost of living.

Comment on this

Before entering on the general discussion about the matters that probably will be thrown up by this Budget and the Financial Resolutions, I want to mention one specific matter—a matter in regard to which I think the Minister for Finance will completely agree with me. Whether one may agree or disagree with the Report of the Capital Investment Committee, I think we must all pay tribute to the fact that these gentlemen, who undertook to sit on that committee and investigate the problems concerned, are busy people and that they were giving their time, their energy and a period that they could most usefully devote otherwise in the national interest. I say that and I further say that it should be accepted by every responsible Deputy, whether one agrees or disagrees with their conclusions.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

In these circumstances, it was a disgrace to this House and to the Fianna Fáil Party, in particular, that Deputy Corry should have utilised this debate for the purpose of personally attacking the personnel concerned. If Deputies attack the personnel of committees such as that, attack people who give their time and their energy voluntarily to the consideration of problems of that sort, then we shall come to the day when no one worth while will be prepared to serve on such a committee. I hope the Taoiseach—the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party—who gives us lectures here from time to time about the way in which we should behave in public life will, on this occasion, give one of those lectures to Deputy Corry. However, those of us who know Deputy Corry regard it rather as an honour to be attacked by him than anything else.

This Budget and any Budget must be considered not merely as a mathematical exercise. It is not enough for a Minister for Finance to be good at figures. It is not enough to consider it merely from the point of view of bringing in a Budget in which the figures on one side of the page match the figures on another. If that were the only purpose of a Minister for Finance, it would be simple enough to get an adding machine to do the task. In case anybody may think that, in saying that, I am having any particular dig at the present Minister, I am not. The purpose of a Minister for Finance is much more than that. It is much more than merely calculating the figures on the revenue and on the expenditure side of the national profit and loss account and then producing a balance.

We must ensure that, in the presentation of a Budget, the Minister is shaping and directing the economic policy of the country as a whole at this time of the year. In passing, let me say that I do not at all accept the view expressed by certain Deputies—Deputy Wycherley, for example—that we are paying the higher public servants too much and that we are paying the Ministers too much. If Ministers deal with their tasks properly, then, in my view, they are paid quite the reverse—a great deal too little. If we do not pay the higher public servants an adequate remuneration we shall reach a position in which the best people will not be available for the public service. They will go into business and we shall have a service of mediocrities. That would be a counsel which would result in very grave damage to the national structure as a whole and one which I can only describe as coming from a person ansxious to bring everybody down to a lower level instead of trying to build up all levels to a reasonable basis.

The economic policy that any Minister for Finance must consider when he is framing his Budget must, I suggest, start on one fundamental which, in our circumstances at the present time and which, particularly, has been so for the past 12 months, is that we can have no progress of any kind unless it is in the framework of an external balance on our payments and receipts, visible and invisible. I suggest also to the Minister—I think he will agree with me— that it is absolutely fundamental to any ordered progress in our economic position that we should get that external balance. Indeed, he has given evidence himself of his view in that respect through his Budget speech though some of the actions of his Government are tugging the other way as hard as they can.

I think the Minister would also agree, probably, that it is much more difficult to attain that external balance than it is to alter, to shape or to mould our internal economic policy. Matters of internal economic balance are entirely within our own economic discretion and it is for ourselves to mould and shape them but, in relation to our external position, we cannot hope in any way to affect or influence the affairs of the world outside. No consideration of the position that existed in 1955, 1956 and indeed, in the first quarter of 1957 can be complete or accurate without taking into account the outside influences that were at that time working on our economy. I do not propose to-night to go over them all individually but I want to make it abundantly clear that, so far as I am concerned I put—not merely now but also during the whole of 1956—and the early part of 1957—the question of our external balance as the absolute essential towards which all our economic policy must be framed rather than any question of internal balance.

We are sometimes inclined to forget that, during the past four years or so, we have been suffering pretty severely, as a country, from the events that have been taking place in the world outside. I said on many occasions last year, and I want to repeat it again to-day, that any consideration of our problems at the present time and in the beginning of 1957 is entirely inadequate without taking into account the manner in which the terms of trade have worsened during that period. As a Government last year, having taken that worsening into account and having, in spite of it, surmounted those difficulties, we succeeded in getting the first prerequisite of any economic progress—a balance of our external account.

The Minister must remember and accept that when he came into office on 20th March the work had all been done in that respect to rectify the trend and ensure we were able to surmount the difficulties of the outside factors. Some people are inclined to forget exactly how grateful they were. Let me take, for example, the figures that were available for the last quarter —figures that, of course, are, I am sure, at the fingertips of the Minister. However, in case he might forget for the moment or not have time, shall I say, to remind the House of those figures, I want to quote them.

The other day, the Central Statistics Office published a memorandum showing the results of our trade during the first quarter of 1957. They were able to report that, in each of the 13 months since March, 1956, imports were less than in the corresponding months of the previous year. At the same time, exports were consistently higher than the corresponding months of the previous year and in nine of the ten months since June, 1956. Of course, in that, they are speaking in terms of value, not of volume. I think it was a significant result and a very substantial achievement on the part of the Government of which I had the honour to be a member, that it was able to bring about such a situation; but it is very much more significant and a far greater achievement when one remembers the manner in which international trade had moved against us during that period.

Take, for example, the first quarter of this year. On the figure which the Minister has, for the first three months of 1957, our imports, at £47.4 million, compared with exports at £32.7 million, show that we had a visible trade import excess of £14.7 million. Bear in mind that our imports were some 90 per cent. in volume of what they had been in the same quarter of 1953. We have heard periodically from members on the other side that, while we were acting to restrict our imports excess, we were doing so entirely and exclusively on the basis of restricting imports. If the Minister again turns to the statistical return issued by the Department of the Taoiseach, he will find that in the first quarter of this year, exports had increased in volume by 17 per cent. to 117 per cent. of the figure they were at in 1953.

One can show clearly from those figures that, not merely were we working on the restrictive measures necessary to achieve an external balance, but, in addition, steps had been taken to increase the volume of exports to a very substantial degree. At the same time, one may wonder why it is that, if our imports were restricted in that way and our exports increased in the manner I have mentioned, our import excess was still at the same figure. It is simply for this reason: prices have so moved against us since 1953 that what would have been an import excess of £8,000,000 in the same quarter at 1953 prices had gone up to one of £14,500,000 this year. It is perfectly clear that, if it were not for that adverse international trend, the effect of the increases in production for export and in the volume of exports would have been that we would have been able to support, not a restricted import list but rather an import list somewhat of the volume we had in previous years.

As I say, the previous Government were working on the basis that external balance was the first essential. They took the necessary restrictive measures because they believed that was the immediate necessity and because they believed that was the rock, so to speak, upon which proper economic internal expansion should begin. They also commenced those measures and, as the figures for the first quarter of this year show, were in the process of developing them when the responsibility passed from me to Deputy Dr. Ryan, as Minister for Finance.

I hope that, when he comes to speak in the Budget debate next year, the Minister will be able to show that he has not slipped backwards again into an external imbalance and that he will be able to say he has maintained the progress that I had been able to make along that ground. Unless he is able to say he can maintain that progress, he will not be able to get the confidence without which there cannot be any progress. Unless that confidence is abroad, there cannot be any industrial activity; there cannot be any expansion in our production and output; and indeed there cannot be any prospect whatever of our getting the savings we require to meet the development that must be undertaken if we are ever to move forward.

We had succeeded in obtaining that stability and in persuading the people as a whole that we meant business in relation to our circumstances. It is not necessary for me to remind members of the House of some of the things that were said by Deputies opposite when they were here, or to remind members of the House of the insidious rumours put out this time last year by enemies of this country that there was a danger of devaluation of the Irish £. We met those rumours and succeeded in proving beyond yea or nay, so that it was universally accepted, that so long as we remained in Government, it would be clear and beyond question that we would take every step necessary to preserve, in so far as we could internally, the value of the Irish £. We were able to persuade the people that was so, and, because we were able to do that, we brought about the situation, which the Minister can see from his statistics, that, at the end of 1956, there were increased bank deposits, voluntary savings were coming around and generally there was a feeling of confidence that the difficulties had been surmounted in that respect.

I want to make it perfectly clear that when I speak in that way about the protection of the value of the Irish £, making certain it will retain its value, I am equally sure that the present Government will take adequate steps, and I would be disappointed if they did not do so, should similar insidious rumours be sent abroad in the future. Positive assurances in that respect will, I know, be forthcoming from the Minister.

If we had not succeeded in ensuring that confidence last year, and doing so in spite of the Party political tactics used by certain members of the Fianna Fail Party, there would not have been any prospect of getting the drive for increased voluntary savings under way. That drive was beginning to show results in the first few months of this year.

Again, the Minister will agree with me when I pay tribute to the members of the Savings Committee and also to the film which the Minister and I saw the other day, a film for the purpose of making our people aware of the necessity for saving and aware, too, of the way in which their savings are used. Some money came out of the stocking into prize bonds. The real reason that the prize bonds issue was so successful was because we had engendered once more a spirit of saving amongst our people. The savings were there. I do not think the Minister will find that a national loan or prize bond scheme will be a success in future unless in the intervening period he can see a mood for saving amongst the people and, in fact, saving actually achieved. That evidence will be available in the bank deposits and in the Post Office Savings Bank.

If there is one thing this Budget will do, it is that it is certain to ensure that voluntary savings will decline substantially in the immediate future. It cannot be otherwise. The effect of this Budget will be in that direction. Any decline in savings, no matter who is sitting on the benches over there, will mean a depressing future and a depressing move in relation to that expansion of output on all sides, both from a State point of view and from the point of view of private enterprise, that must be undertaken if we are to get any progress at all.

I should like to hear from the Minister, when he is replying, exactly what proportion of the prize bond issue he thinks came out of what I might describe as the hoarded savings of the past. It seems to me, from the break-down of the amounts, that a great deal of that money must have been money that was kept in the house, money that was not in the bank, in the Post Office Savings Bank or a trustee bank but was held in the stocking, or in the pillow or in the case under the bed. The £2,500,000 approximately that was obtained in applications of up to £50 seems to indicate that that was the likely source of that part of the small savings in any event and, when one couples that with another indicator, the very small amount that was withdrawn from the Post Office Savings Bank, one is forced to the conclusion that a great deal of the money subscribed must have been money put aside and, so to speak, sterilised in the past. If the prize bonds did succeed in getting any substantial sum out of that sterilisation and into a position in which it can be put to work, then it certainly was well worth while.

I was particularly anxious to hear the Budget speech on 8th May in relation to the Capital Budget. I remember the various things that were said by the Fianna Fail Party during the general election, and subsequently. I remember particularly the leaflet: "Let's go ahead again," that they published in every constituency. Deputies will remember whether or not they had it in their constituencies, but, as far as I know, it was published in every single constituency throughout the country. I am pretty sure it was published, gratis, by the Irish Press as their contribution towards the campaign expenses of the individual Fianna Fail candidates in the different constituencies. One of the things stated in that leaflet was: “For this purpose and to provide a stimulus for the recovery and expansion of private business activity, Fianna Fail will increase the amount of capital expenditure by the State and local authorities.” Nice sounding words.

What exactly was the result in the Capital Budget introduced by the Minister? I was wondering whether that leaflet heralded a policy by the Minister for Finance in the implementation of which he would travel on what I describe as the "mad-cap road" of Deputy Lemass when he talked of his £100,000,000 plan. Thanks be to God, the Minister has not been that foolish anyway because that would certainly have brought us to complete ruin. If one takes the capital programme that has been put before the House by the Minister and compares it —and the Minister can compare it because he has in his Department a memorandum dated 4th January last made out by me and amended by me in only one respect thereafter, namely, the E.S.B.—he will see the Capital Budget that I was proposing to introduce and he can relate that to the statements in his election literature.

Unfortunately, I have not been able to ascertain whether the Minister himself in Wexford issued the same election literature. All along the road this Party, which came in with much vaunted ideas that they would increase capital expenditure all over the place, this Party that talked at every church gate about the manner in which I had restricted capital expenditure and how they would expand it beyond question, have come in here now and produced a Capital Budget based exclusively, and I challenge the Minister to deny it, on the memorandum that I submitted to my colleagues on 4th January last.

The differences are trifling. Here and there, there are small differences. There is an increase of £1.2 million in the allocation to the E.S.B. Why? Not for the purpose of doing more normal development. Not for the purpose of extending rural electrification, but solely for the purpose of paying off bank borrowings of the E.S.B., as I elicited in reply to a question addressed to the Minister the other day. In certain respects the Minister, who had promised during the General Election that he would bring in a Capital Budget for increased capital expenditure, has reduced the provision that I had indicated I was prepared to make, the provision that I would have made had the House sat again before the General Election.

One will find that there is about £1,000,000 in his provision for the Local Loans Fund but, as against that, the provision is £1,000,000 down in the voted capital services. One will find there is a decreased provision in respect of C.I.E. and that there is a slight adjustment in some other respects. But, no matter how the Minister may take his figures, the figures in relation to capital expenditure that he is proposing for the current year and about which I have heard some of the back benchers of Fianna Fail talk at great length in relation to a decision of the Minister for Local Government, as if they were making vast new arrangements and announcing vast new schemes, and making it appear that there are vast differences in their approach to this problem, one finds, when all comes to all, vide Table IV of the Financial Tables which sets out the figures of the Capital Budget, the Minister has done very little to alter them, practically nothing. So far as the table is concerned it runs at more or less to the same figure. But when the Minister analyses down the exact allocations in that make-up and compares them with mine he will find that in his allocation there is a smaller proportion for productive expenditure than there was in the proposals that I put to my colleagues when in Government.

I should like to make it clear that I appreciate the additional information that is made available on this occasion for the first time in the printed tables. It is a welcome innovation and one which I hope will be even further extended in the years to come. My programme was based on certain sums that were to be made available from the levies in support of that capital programme. The Minister in his Budget speech, and other Deputies supporting him, have entirely overlooked the fact that the yield brought in by the levies last year was a yield for only part of the year and that the amount that would have been available in support of the capital programme this year would, therefore have been greater.

The Minister is not correct either, I would suggest, when he says in his Budget speech that he has released £1,750,000 of these levies. He has released portion of the levies, yes, but another portion, in relation particularly to motor-cars and newsprint, he has transferred directly to current expenses. On the basis of last year's figures £230,000 would be the amount he has added to permanent taxation in that respect on the first item, and some £43,000 in respect of the second.

I do not understand the purpose of the Minister's action in relation to newsprint. He has made what was and was going to be, as I made clear, a temporary imposition by way of levy for balance of payments purposes on newsprint into a permanent customs duty. I want to know why and I hope the Minister, when he is replying to this debate, will explain clearly and specifically to the House why he has done so. Does he want the national newspapers and the provincial newspapers deliberately to restrict their size for the future? Does he want to ensure that there will be a permanent restriction in volume of that nature, or does he wish that the amount involved, now that it is a permanent charge, will be met by an increase in sale prices?

Did the Minister consider the effect that such a permanent charge is likely to have on the provincial newspapers, on the one hand, and what was his purpose in imposing it, if one considers the national newspapers, on the other hand? It is obvious to anybody that when that is being made a permanent charge now, it will remain as a permanent charge for many years to come, a charge in respect of which much more will be paid by one newspaper than another, that the newspaper that gives better value to its readers in the form of more pages will be paying a higher tax than the newspaper with fewer pages? Did the Minister consider the effect that would have on the daily newspapers, on one newspaper, for example, that has a great number of pages and another newspaper that has not got so many pages and will therefore be paying a lesser tax—and I will give only one guess to the members of the House as to what newspaper will be paying the lesser tax.

The Minister in his Budget speech said that the balance of our external payments is precarious. While believing that, while pulling, so to speak in one direction on the rope to keep that external balance, with the other hand, he is deliberately ensuring that the strands of the rope will be severed. Hire purchase debt contracted during 1956. The Minister has now abolished all the restrictions and we have a position now in which, up and down the streets of Dublin and elsewhere, advertisements are in every shop window of the firms who deal in this business: "No deposit and greatly extended periods." Let me add that that type of business, no deposit and vastly extended hire purchase terms, considered in period of time, means that the foreign firms can squeeze the home firms.

The home firms have not got the resources necessary to indulge in complete no deposit arrangements, or to extend repayments over a long period as can the foreign firms with their resources. The effect of that change by the Minister will undoubtedly be that business will go from some of the home firms dealing in that type of business to foreign firms, and it will mean, as hire purchase does mean inevitably, an anticipation of resources before the production is there to meet those resources, anticipation which, in the circumstances of our economy, can be met only by increased imports.

I do not understand either why the Minister at a time when he was saying that our balance was precarious, was deliberately permitting a situation, if not stimulating a situation, in which there would be greater imports of motor-cars and their assembled parts. Either one course of policy or the other is correct; both cannot be correct. The Minister cannot make the case that our external balance is still doubtful and, at the same time, logically wipe out hire purchase arrangements and stimulate increases in motor-car imports. Let me say, in passing, in that respect that I was the person, unfortunately, if you like, from the political point of view, who imposed the levy and I have no recollection, good, bad or indifferent, of any representation being made to me by the British Government, or anybody on their behalf, in relation to the trade agreement which was mentioned by the Tánaiste, and I would consider it strange that, if such representations were made, they were not made to the person responsible for the imposition of the levies.

I cannot help thinking that the Tánaiste is entirely wrong when he suggests that the imposition of levies on motor-cars in excess of £1,200 was a breach of the trade agreement. It was not, in my view. The balance of payments position was clearly covered there, and I do not recollect, as I say, any suggestion or complaint being made by anybody that it was such a breach; but it would have been a breach, once the Tánaiste wiped out the levy on motor-cars and transferred it to a permanent tax, and the representations to which the Deputy referred were possibly those which were made to him, consequent upon his own deliberate action.

I said when I was speaking immediately after the Budget that it was, not the economics of a madman, as I was quoted as saying—no matter what I thought of the Minister for Finance, I would not be as rude to him as that— but the economics of a madhouse, to be introducing this Budget at the same time as one was permitting free importation of luxury cars of that sort.

So far as the current Budget is concerned, we have heard a great deal about it in the House, and I do not propose to deal in detail now with some of its provisions. The Finance Bill will offer a better opportunity, but again I cannot help thinking and wondering how the welkin would have been made to ring by Deputies now sitting on the opposite side of the House if, for example, I had increased the price of tobacco by 2½d. and had granted only ½d. rebate in respect of the price of hard-pressed plug. I can see every Deputy opposite, no matter what the circumstances were in which that action had been taken, getting up with bitter salt tears running down his face at the thought that I had ventured to give but 1/2d. rebate for the old age pensioners. That is all the Fianna Fail Minister has done and, compared, for example, with the occasion when I found it necessary last year to increase tobacco prices, I made a very much higher percentage of the charge available by way of remission to old age pensioners and those who smoke hard tobacco.

Nor do I think it necessary at this stage to go into some of the tax concessions that the Minister has made, because, again, we shall have an opportunity of dealing with those on the Finance Bill. So far as those concessions are extensions of the principles that I enunciated either in the first Mining Tax Concessions Bill or in the second Miscellaneous Tax Concessions Bill of last November, I welcome them. I am still puzzled to know what is the purpose of the general remission for all securities issued since 1932, and particularly puzzled, when I remember how Deputy Lemass derided the extension that I gave to issues in that respect last year. He told us on many occasions that it was not worth a damn, that it was not of any use whatever, that nobody used these concessions and that nobody made application for them.

Apparently Deputy Lemass has now been converted to the view that my view then was right and that he was wrong. But I still do not understand why the Minister has given uncovenanted benefit in that respect to all securities since 1932 and, if uncovenanted benefit is being given that is not going to mean one penny piece if invested in industry, why that benefit did not go back to securities that were issued since the foundation of the State rather than that the Minister should have selected the first year only in which the Fianna Fail Party came into power.

Comment on this

That is the first year of the world.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Minister proposes to come to the House with a specific resolution to join the International Monetary Fund or whether he deems it necessary to do that. He has announced his intention in that respect. The Minister knows I had started the steps that were necessary for him to announce that decision, that I had inquiries made as to what our quota would be and as to what would be the terms on which we would be permitted to join.

I am not suggesting that he must come to the House from the point of view of being subject to criticism from this Party. On the contrary, as I said, we set out along that line, but I hope that Deputies and people outside the House—and I saw one very stupid comment outside on the Minister's decision—will remember that joining the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank Organisation will enable us to get certain technical advice. It will enable us to get considerable assistance on technicalities and might enable us, in certain circumstances, to get production loans to carry us over on a short-term credit basis for development. But it would be disastrous, I think, if anyone felt that it would provide a panacea for all our ills and that it would provide that panacea to the exclusion of what we should do ourselves. It may assist us in certain respects but what we make of this country will be the result of our own efforts and our own resources and the wise or the unwise actions of any Government that may be in power.

In 1956, as I said some time ago, we were making considerable progress along the road to confidence and stability. I wonder if the Minister is ensuring that in 1957 he will get the same stability? If there is not stability, there cannot be ordered economic progress and the one thing that this Budget might do is jeopardise that stability. General MacEoin stressed a point that was made by the Minister when the Minister made it clear that he and the Fianna Fail Party were calling on the country to make the sacrifices that this Budget involved in a spirit and in a system in which there would not be compensatory increases for the additional sacrifices that the people would have to bear.

The Minister is perhaps better able than I am to judge whether those sacrifices will be accepted at his direction. We must remember that it is a very different proposition from the proposition that was made by the Capital Investments Advisory Committee or even by the trade unions, of having a surplus created on our current account for the purpose of getting an extended capital programme. That is not what the Minister was doing. If the Minister were doing that I think there might be much greater acceptance by the public of the need which he has said exists for these sacrifices, but the way in which the Minister has done it may result in our having the worst of both worlds.

It would be easy for me to say that people must be compensated. I think the Minister has made a mistake in his Budget in jeopardising the stability that the last Government and I established in 1956-57, but it would be a much greater mistake for the country as a whole, and one which would mean greater national difficulty all round, if we were now to fall into the error of other years and allow monetary incomes to exceed current production. On all sides of the House we must realise and accept that in the long run we can only achieve such a standard of living here as our current production will support and that if we try to run ahead of that, then, eventually-and sooner than may be anticipated-we shall run into difficulties on our external payments.

I think the Minister has produced a Budget that is tough and will undoubtedly bring hardship to many sections of the community, a Budget in respect of which the compensations for the poorer sections of the community are not adequate and a Budget which risks the stability essential to ordered economic progress being thrown aside. I hope it will not be thrown aside because if it is it will not mean that there will be any financial relief to the Exchequer. The sum total at the end of the year will be to worsen the problem with which the Minister stated he was faced. We will get back to the situation that existed in 1952-53, when the then Minister for Finance budgeted for Supplementary Estimates of £4,750,000 and when the Supplementary Estimates were the cause of the spiral in costs and wages he set off in that year, £9,253,000. If that is to be the effect of the Minister's Budget, then it is a sorry, sorry day that the Deputy and his Government walked over to those benches. It will have an effect which will be remembered for many a long year in this country.

The better way to go was along the road on which I had started, the way in which I had made it clear that I was going, to keep and maintain stability at all costs. For example, I met the representatives of the Civil Service and, with Deputy General Mulcahy as Minister for Education, the representatives of the national teachers, the secondary teachers and the vocational teachers. I told them that, in my view, the country could not afford to have any instability on that front. I told them that, in our view, it was absolutely vital, absolutely essential, that they would give, as I knew they would, the lead, a national lead, to the country and make it clear that they were prepared to give their quota to stability.

I gratefully acknowledge that the representatives whom I saw on those occasions did appreciate that, in the event of there being unstable conditions, not merely would we go backwards on our economic front but that the white collar worker particularly would be the class who would feel the pinch and feel the worst effects of any inflationary spiral which might be set off. I made it clear that I was not going to have such a spiral and that I would avoid it with every force at my command. I got co-operation on those lines and I am sure that that co-operation would have been forthcoming as long as that stability was maintained.

I hope the Minister will succeed—not for his own sake, not for the sake of that Party, but for the sake of the country as a whole. So far as the Minister, so far as that Party, is concerned, Fianna Fáil will always go down in this way: "Beware the Ides of March"—remember the 5th March, the day on which they were elected to govern. This is what is really outraging the people now—not the prices they have to pay, but the day on which Fianna Fail were elected, by a series of false promises, deliberately made to trick the people and the people know now that they have been tricked.

Deputy de Valera, as he then was, went down to Belmullet, and made it clear and even positive there that he and his Party stood for the retention of the food subsidies. Deputy Lemass went down to Waterford on the same day, mark you, to repeat the same thing, that the Fianna Fáil Party, beyond all else, stood for the retention in full of the food subsidies. Does anyone suggest it was a coincidence that Deputy de Valera, as Leader of the Fianna Fail Party, went away to the West to Belmullet and Deputy Lemass went to Waterford the same day and spoke more or less the same words; and that Deputy Traynor, as he then was, went to Doyle's Corner and said exactly the same thing?

Was that a coincidence? Was it not perfectly clear that they had met together and had decided that was to be the line to put to the people? We were told during the course of this debate that one of the reasons why they had to change their minds was the financial circumstances they discovered. They are all intelligent people—at least, they boast when they offer themselves as potential Ministers that they are intelligent people; and whatever his enemies may say about Deputy Lemass no one will deny his intelligence.

Week after week in every year for as long as I can remember, and certainly every week during the period that mattered, in Iris Oifigiúil, there is published, every Tuesday, the Exchequer Returns. On 29th January, the last Tuesday in January, there was given the last returns for January. They were there before the election campaign. They were available to Deputy de Valera, to Deputy Lemass, to Deputy Traynor and to the other leaders of the Fianna Fail Party. Anyone looking at these returns knew perfectly well that, quite deliberately, I had for example, in the end of November last, expended a sum of £1,000,000 out of balance for the purpose of alleviating unemployment, for the purpose of ensuring we would not go into a policy of deflation, that I was trying to offset the policy of earlier years by a policy of disinflation.

All the figures were there available to Deputy Lemass. He was able to see that expenditure had risen by £9,000,000. He was able to see that, excluding the special import levies, revenue had only risen by £1,000,000 and that, therefore, there would be a problem which the new Government would have to meet. If that was not enough, when I spoke at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis on 5th February, I made it quite clear, and deliberately made it quite clear, that there would be problems to be faced in this financial year. Notwithstanding the fact that Deputy Lemass knew that—and he did, because he quoted me during the course of the election campaign—Deputy de Valera, Deputy Lemass and Deputy Traynor, as they then were, deliberately went out to the electorate and told them they were not going to take these steps. They had all the information there, if they chose to look for it —and I believe they did, but I believe they deliberately decided to cod the people. It is that, that perfidy by Fianna Fail, which has the people so outraged and insensed by this Budget.

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Finance (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I should like to deal with a few small points raised by Deputy Sweetman, because they may not come into my general reply.

I could not do more than give a guess at the amount which came out of the stocking, as it were, for the prize bonds. The Deputy knows that secrecy is promised in this case and he could make as good a guess as I could, by seeing how much is in small sums, big sums and so on.

Hire purchase was dropped because it had become largely ineffective by the changes made before we came into office. We had to drop it or go back to the original plan of hire purchase, and that is possible any time.

I do not think I can be criticised so much for the higher price of tobacco, because the Deputy last year put 4d. a lb. on the old age pensioners, whereas I only put 2d. Therefore, the Deputy should not try to make out that he has a soft heart for the old age pensioners, if he thinks 4d. of an impost would be taken by them as better than 2d.

Comment on this

Why did you not take off 2d.?

Comment on this

It was a third of the imposition.

Comment on this

The Deputy made a point by the Bretton Woods Agreement. A separate Bill will be issued in connection with our joining the International Monetary Fund. I understand it could not be put into the Finance Bill, so a separate Bill will be introduced.

Comment on this

Is that because 25 per cent. of the quota has to be subscribed in gold?

Comment on this

It is not because of that that there must be a separate Bill. It is because the Bretton Woods Agreement comes into it and it could not be put in a Money Bill.

Comment on this

It would destroy the character of a Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I would say that we have a lot in common in this House. Listening to Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Costello, the Leader of the Opposition, and those whom I might call responsible speakers on the other side, there is no doubt that we have a lot in common, and it is well that we should advert to that fact first. We all agree that our object here is to secure a better standard of living all round. We all agree that that cannot be done, unless we have increased production in both agriculture and industry. It is obvious that if we have increased production in both agriculture and industry, the pool of goods for consumption, and so on, is higher and, there-fore, there is a better standard of living. I need not stress that any further.

That, of course, also will give more permanent employment, which we all desire. For that, we want capital. We all agree on that, too. Capital is necessary to provide the maximum production in both agriculture and industry. It is also necessary for State expenditure in State bodies such as the E.S.B., Bord na Móna, and so on, and, pending full-scale permanent employment, we all realise that we must do something to relieve unemployment, and money is necessary for that purpose.

I agree also with what Deputy Sweetman says, that the balance of trade must be maintained, but—and this is the point that some Deputies ignore—in order to have the maximum capital for capital purposes, we must balance the Budget. In fact, I think every Deputy who spoke from the other side, whether from Labour or from Fine Gael, said that we must balance the Budget, but, having stated that fact, he then proceeded to show how it should not be balanced. That would sum up the speech of practically every Fine Gael and Labour Deputy.

Nobody has disputed the figures I gave in the Budget speech. Nobody has disputed the figure that, having allowed for a certain increase in revenue in the coming year, having allowed for over-estimation, £3,000,000 —Deputy McGilligan in his speech to-day wanted me to put the £3,000,000 in twice—having allowed for that, once in my case, and having allowed for Supplementary Estimates, and so on, we arrived at a figure of £8,000,000 and we had to try to find that amount.

We disagree on a few things. Otherwise, this debate would not have taken up seven days. There was some objection to the 1d. on the pint of stout; there was very little objection to the tax on tobacco; there was a fair amount of objection to the tax on petrol; and I think I am not over-stating the case when I say that there was a fair amount of objection to the withdrawal of the food subsidies. I am not objecting to the Opposition opposing that. It was opposed by Members of my own Government in the beginning until they saw what the position was. The members of the Government to which I belong, at any rate, knew that the Budget should be balanced and when they saw that there was no other way of doing it, they agreed, but Fine Gael and Labour condemn it, although they see no other way in which it can be done and did not even suggest any way.

Comment on this

Oh, yes.

Comment on this

Nobody from Fine Gael or Labour suggested how it could be done from current income—it is current income I am talking about. It is all right to borrow to balance your Budget. I could do that the same as Deputy Sweetman did, but I did not want to. I wanted to balance the Budget properly from current income and, therefore, as current income could not be got, we had to reduce expenditure; in other words, reduce the Estimates.

I say that nobody from Fine Gael or Labour made the slightest suggestion as to how that £5,000,000 could be got if the food subsidies had been left there—nobody. They talked about capital items that could be brought in to do the job. They advised that borrowing should be done—borrowing for the Budget—which would put us back in the bad old days of the Coalition Government. We will not have it. We will not go back to those days. We will not have it. That is all.

I want to go on to another point. Deputy Costello made a reasonable speech. He had a difficult problem. He is an able advocate and he was pleading a bad cause, the cause of the Coalition. He did well as an able advocate and was reasonable and fair in his speech, but there is one thing he said to which I want to refer. He said it was decided at a meeting of the Government, on 2nd November, 1956, that the Estimates should not exceed £94,500,000, afterwards increased by £2,000,000 for C.I.E., that is £96,500,000 now. That was a decision of the Government. It was verified by Deputy Sweetman, former Minister for Finance, that that decision was taken. That means that every Fine Gael Minister and every Labour Minister agrees with that. I do not think an awful lot about the Coalition Government, but I cannot imagine that they would be so bad as to take a decision like that without knowing what they were doing. Surely to goodness, ten or 12 men will not sit down and say: "Reduce the Estimates by £5,000,000", without having some idea of how it will be done, at least a rough idea, and there is no use in any ex-Minister saying to me that they made up their minds to do that, without knowing how it could be done. No ex-Minister speaking in this debate, during the long speeches that were made—I think it probably holds the record for a Budget debate——

Comment on this

Nonsense; a short debate.

Comment on this

——gave us any indication as to what the cut would be on these published Estimates to amount to £5,000,000. None of them even gave us a suggestion of how £1,000,000 could be cut off, nor £500,000 nor £250,000. We had these Ministers in November, 1956, sitting down and solemnly making up their minds that they would take £5,500,000 off the published Estimates. To be exact, £5.66 million would have to be taken off. Will anybody tell me, even a backbencher of Fine Gael, who would nearly tell me anything, that these Ministers made that decision, without knowing how they were going to do it or how it would work out? If he does, remember, he will be telling the country that there was a crowd of incompetents ruling this country—which the people suspected already—who made Government decisions, without knowing where they were going. That is too much to expect. They did it anyway. They were going to reduce these Estimates to £96,500,000. I want to say again that the Labour Ministers agreed to this because I should like to have them included also lest there might be some come-back from them later on.

The non-capital Supply Services, the Estimates, amounted to £102.16 million. They were, as the House knows, prepared and published by the Coalition Government, but they were going to bring them down to £96,500,000, remember, according to a solemn decision of 2nd November, 1956. I learned that in this House. None of us went prying back over Government decisions for the past three or four years. We leave that to other people. We did not do it, but it was told to us in this House by the ex-Taoiseach and the ex-Minister for Finance.

How were they to get that £5,500,000? That is what I want to know. Remember that they had pledged themselves to do it. They pledged themselves to reduce the amount to £96,500,000. It is very strange that the former Taoiseach and Minister for Finance should have referred to this, without giving us some indication of what they had in mind. It is a strange coincidence that we reduced the non-capital Estimates by, first of all, taking out the food subsidies. Any Deputy can subtract the figures. We have £102,166 million and we subtracted £7.1 million for the food subsidies. Add £1.59 million for the social assistance classes and we get £97.02 million. We admit we did not do as well as the Coalition Government decided to do, but it is possible that if they had been doing what we did they might not have been as generous to the old age pensioners and would have arrived at the £96.5 million. By taking off the food subsidies and adding on social assistance increases we effected this economy. The Opposition have not told us how they were going to get that economy even to the extent of £500,000. It is an extraordinary thing that the figures should coincide. I think if I were addressing a jury now I would say that there was enough circumstantial evidence to hang a man.

Comment on this

The Budget has hanged the Minister.

Comment on this

If a man is standing trial for murder, he might have an alibi for the particular time, but the Opposition have no alibi whatever. They never suggested that they would take the money from any other source. They told us they would make this £5,500,000 saving, but they made no suggestions as to how they would do it. If they were to tell us even now how they were going to do it, I would plead with the Irish people to have mercy on them. Will they tell us, for instance, as one Deputy on the opposite side suggested, that they were going to do it by withdrawing the agricultural grant? They were going to do something and my guess is that they were going to do away with the food subsidies.

When Deputy Everett was speaking here on the Budget a few days ago—I think it was on May 21st—and making suggestions as to how we could balance the Budget without resorting to the withdrawal of the food subsidies, he mentioned a figure of £4,000,000 and said that he would save £1,000,000 on the President's establishment and £1,000,000 on the embassies. I am mentioning this merely to give Deputies an idea of Deputy Everett's ability to make up figures because a man who thinks he can take £1,000,000 from £50,000——

Comment on this

Quote Deputy Everett.

Comment on this

He never said £1,000,000.

Comment on this

I will quote it.

Comment on this

I was listening to him and he never said that.

Comment on this

Deputy Everett at column 1565, of the Official Reports said:—

"I would vote against maintaining some of our embassies abroad at the cost of millions of pounds and especially maintaining an embassy in the United States of America where the newly appointed representative to Ireland said it was in the interests of America to keep Partition in Ireland."

He would take £1,000,000 off the embassies. He then goes on to say——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I think the Minister ought to withdraw his allegation that Deputy Everett said he wanted to take £1,000,000 off the President's establishment.

Comment on this

I will quote that. At column 1566 Deputy Everett said:—

"Why do we need to retain—I am expressing my own views now—at a huge cost, the position of President? I am not saying anything against the present gentleman who holds the office and who fills the position with honour and credit. Why do we not economise in that direction and save another £1,00,000?"

I am quoting this only for this purpose. The total cost of the embassies is £320,000 and the cost of the President's establishment is £50,000. In the same speech, Deputy Everett said that he warned his constituents against a Fianna Fáil victory. Bread and butter, he said, would go up if Fianna Fáil should win the election and came back to power. Fianna Fáil would abolish the food subsidies and the people would have to pay 4/3 or 4/4 for butter. Note the figures. He said that the two lb. loaf of bread would be increased from 9d. to 1/1. He said that in Bray on 18th February and the figures are absolutely correct.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

When I was preparing this Budget, I got reports from the Departments of Industry and Commerce and Agriculture on bread and butter. I could not have made these tabulations out myself because they were most intricate and were worked out to such figures as .01674, and there were pages of them. I read the reports and accepted the figures. We know more about figures than Deputy Everett. We did not take £1,000,000 from £50,000.

Comment on this

That is quite unfair.

Comment on this

He could not have made out these figures himself and the only answer is that he must have got these figures from a Government source. Why did he get those figures from a Government source? Why did he get the exact cost of bread and butter, unless the previous Government had issued them for some purpose because, if he did it all himself, he would have said that the loaf was going to cost 4/6 and butter to cost 11/4. He must have got it from some Government source and the previous Government must have been responsible for issuing these figures.

Why did they issue them? Was it because they had something in mind? They were supplying Deputy Everett with figures of what the loaf would cost and what the pound of butter would cost, and they were also going to take £5,500,000 off the Estimates, and they do not say how or why they were going to do it. They will not give in that they were going to remove the food subsidies. If they would only agree now, I would recommend them to the mercy of the Irish people.

We are taken to task because we did not tell the Irish people that, if we came into power, we would abolish the food subsidies. We did not know the position. It is all right for Deputy Sweetman to say the figures were published each week in Iris Oifigiúil. A good student of politics like the Minister for Industry and Commerce probably does read that. However, it only states how much money has come in up to that date and what the expenditure is. There is no use in saying that the Minister for Industry or the Taoiseach had the information at that time. They had not got the information the Government had.

I was asked a question in Cushions-town by an intelligent man. I said that things were in a bad way. At that time I did not think they were in such a bad way. He had asked me what I would do if I were in the Government. I said to him that if I were appointed a receiver to try to bring a firm back on its feet I would first of all have to see the position. That was the answer I gave him.

Comment on this

I will bet the Minister has not gone back there since.

Comment on this

The Government knew in November that they would be obliged to reduce the Estimates by £5,500,000. We did not know that. That was not published in Iris Oifigiúil. That was a Government decision, a solemn decision which was quoted here by the former Taoiseach and the former Minister for Finance. Knowing they had made that decision, Deputy Sweetman said at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis: “We will have to increase taxation.”

Comment on this

I did not. Quote me correctly please.

Comment on this

If I did not quote the Deputy correctly I apologise.

Comment on this

That is the second time the Minister has given an incorrect quotation.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I shall give the Minister the quotation if he wishes.

Comment on this

If I am wrong I apologise. As I have said, we did not know that decision. The committee dealing with capital investment handed a report to the Minister for Finance on the 22nd January last. At that time the Government had decided to cut the Estimates by £5,500,000. They knew what the revenue was like, what the expenditure was likely to be. This report was presented to the Minister, recommending that food subsidies should be withdrawn and that the agricultural grant should be diverted to another purpose. The Minister was busy at that time. It was coming on to the election, but I feel quite sure that he saw the recommendation and that he told some of his colleagues what it was.

Why did he not publish it? Why did he leave that report in his desk and fight the election without telling the people that the report recommended the withdrawal of the food subsidies? We are blamed for not telling the people. Sure we had nothing to tell them. We did not know the Estimates were to be reduced by £5,500,000. We did not know what this committee had recommended. But Deputy Sweetman knew that. The other Ministers knew it. They went to the country, spoke to the people and hid all that information from them. If the Fine Gael Party were as determined then as they seem to be in the past two weeks not to withdraw the food subsidies, why did they not take the opportunity of publishing that report and of saying: "We will not adopt it"? Because, I suppose, they were thinking of the £5,500,000 they had to take off and what a beautiful recommendation they had got to help them in that plot. Off they went to the people and never said a word about the recommendations of this committee.

Comment on this

Because I knew the members of that committee would be blackguarded by everyone as they have been by Deputy Corry in this debate. I take full responsibility for making that decision.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Deputy's delicate feelings for the committee.

Comment on this

After all, he appointed them.

Comment on this

We did not know there would be a deficit of £8,000,000. But Deputy Sweetman was Minister for Finance and has the reputation among his own Party as being a good Minister for Finance. I am not denying that. Deputy Sweetman had a very good idea in February last that there would be a deficit of £8,000,000, yet he did not tell the people the Government would reduce the Estimates by £5,500,000. He kept the report locked away in his drawer. Why did he not tell the people what the report contained—the recommendation that the subsidies be withdrawn?

Comment on this

Why did the Minister tell them he was going to retain the subsidies?

Comment on this

I often admire the effrontery of the Fine Gael Party. My admiration is growing as time goes on.

Comment on this

It was only a recommendation. It need not have been adopted.

Comment on this

You did not reject it.

Comment on this

We want to know why you did not tell the people you would not accept it. Fine Gael, and particularly the former Taoiseach, have always regarded the food subsidies as being purely temporary measures. The Labour Party had the same idea as one will find if one reads what Deputy Norton said when they were first introduced. We are all in the same boat as far as that goes. Not one of us had any belief that food subsidies should remain for all time. We were all agreed they should be withdrawn at an opportune time.

We say this is an opportune time. In fact, we say this is the inescapable time. I suppose it is too much to expect that Fine Gael and Labour, who made such decisions before the elections, would agree with us now. Therefore we must go our own way. This £5,500,000 had to be found by us. The inter-Party Government saw, in November, 1956, that this money would be needed. We did not come to a decision until April but we came to the same decision as the inter-Party Government—that this £5,500,000 would have to be saved.

We could see no other way of saving that amount except on the food subsidies. Deputies opposite might like to tell us some time what they had in mind. It would be interesting to know how they would have saved that £5,500,000. The former Taoiseach and some of his colleagues including Deputy McGilligan say they would have used the special import levies to meet current expenditure. I should like to say that when the Minister for Finance brought in the levies, he put the following clause into the Central Fund Act of 1956:—

"(3) There shall be charged on the Central Fund, and issued in accordance with the directions of the Minister out of the Central Fund to the Fund, such sums as the Minister may from time to time determine as the sums equivalent to the Exchequer receipts in respect of special import levy.

(4) The Minister may apply the Fund for any purposes for or towards the cost of which public moneys are provided and which are conducive to the development or improvement of capital resources, and any such application may be on such terms or conditions as the Minister considers proper."

They were created as capital and if we had done what Deputy Costello and Deputy McGilligan advocated we would have had to change that Act. I am not saying that is impossible but it just gives the House an idea of the Fine Gael Party who this time last year passed an Act of Parliament to make them capital and they now come along and blame us for not turning them over to current expenditure,

I shall now quote Deputy Sweetman when he was Minister for Finance. The quotation will be found at columns 854 and 855 of the Official Report of the 20th March, 1956. He said:—

"I want to state clearly what Section 4 of the Bill means. Section 4 of this Bill provides that the Minister for Finance of the day cannot use the special import levies for the purpose of balancing ordinary current expenditure. He cannot do it under the law when this Bill is passed and enacted. I never intended to do it."

But he would not mind our doing it.

Comment on this

I never said any such thing.

Comment on this

I mean the Deputy's colleagues. Deputies Costello and McGilligan would not mind our doing it if they thought they would put us in a hole. Deputy Sweetman, as Minister for Finance, went on to say: "Luckily I had a fair idea of the depths to which certain Deputies in opposition might go in suggesting that I did intend to use it." Luckily, he had the foresight to see what Deputies in opposition would say about him if he used it for current expenditure. Now his colleagues Deputies Costello and McGilligan want to put us into the depths of using them for current expenditure. That was Deputy Costello's suggestion for balancing the Budget. Deputy McGilligan used that suggestion, plus £3,000,000 a year in respect of over-estimation together with the £3,000,000 already there because otherwise he could not add £3,000,000 to what was there already.

Deputy McGilligan more or less blamed me for raising up the Supplementary Estimates too high. I explained in my Budget speech why I did it, but I will tell the Deputies again. If they have any objection to a Minister for Finance trying to be honest, let them say so. In 1954-55, £750,000 was provided and £2,074,000 was spent. In 1955-56, £750,000 was provided for that purpose and £1,704,000 was spent. In 1956-57, £750,000 was provided and £1,162,000 was spent. This year I put it up to £950,000 to try, if possible, to make it a real figure to meet the Supplementary Estimates that would come along.

Deputy Costello also found fault with the provision of another £250,000 for employment schemes. That sum was provided in addition to what was already in the Estimate. I mention that because there were other Deputies on the Opposition side of the House who blamed me for not providing more. He also found fault with the provision for the bakers. There was a good deal of talk about that. I do not think I am the friend of any baker in the country. I do not think that I owe them anything. The case was put to me that they deserved this money. Deputy Norton says that he gave no undertaking to the master bakers.

The facts are that the bakers went to the Labour Court for an award in respect of wages and the master bakers said they would have to get an increase in the price of flour in order to give that increased wage. Deputy Norton says he gave no undertaking. The bakers gave the increase and it is very hard to understand why the master bakers would give an increase like that claiming they could not afford to give it unless they thought they were going to get an increase in the price of bread. That is all I can say about it at the moment. Is it not obvious that Deputy Norton thought the same, otherwise why would he come along a few months later and reduce the size of the loaf?

That was for the bakers' advantage and for nothing else. It meant that the baker got his 9d. for the loaf but the size of the loaf was cut down by one-eighth. If Fianna Fáil had been in office I am quite sure that, instead of doing that, they would have allowed the bakers to put up the price by a halfpenny or so and do it in an open way and not go behind backs like Deputy Norton did and reduce the size of the loaf. That was one of the trickiest things done in this country.

Comment on this

Is this for a bigger loaf now?

Comment on this

Deputy Norton reduced the size of the loaf by one-eighth. If we had come along now and reduced the size of the loaf by another one-third we could leave it at the same price and we could say like Deputy Norton that we kept the price of bread stable. Deputy Norton also said he had kept the price of sugar stable. He did, of course, but the increase was due on sugar and I suppose if he had remained there he would have gone on refusing to raise the price until he had got himself into the same mess as he got himself into in regard to the tea. You had Labour Deputies going round saying that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would not give an increase in tea. In the end he had to give in and allow the price of tea to go up by 2/– per lb.

Deputies opposite, in excusing their Government for anything that may have happened, always fall back on the defence that it has something to do with matters over which they had no control—in other words, world events. That may be a fair claim enough. Over the past few years there has not been the same economic upheaval in other countries as there has been in Ireland but when those opposite compare figures to show how well they have done they always compare them with the year 1947—a year following a world war when countries generally were recovering from shattered economies. That is a most unfair comparison but they persist in making it all the time but why not take the year 1956 with the year 1954, the last year Fianna Fáil was in office? If there was a good deal of talk about the 1952 Budget, I should like to instruct the Deputies opposite that if they study the figures they will see that the Budget of 1952 did the job. It pulled this country together and if they look at the figures for 1954 they will see that quite plainly.

In 1952 we had to clean up the mess created between 1948 and 1951 just as we are now doing in respect of the mess that occurred in the past three years. We had to bring in the 1952 Budget to do it. In 1951, before we did that our exports were £81.5 million. In 1954, before we left office, they were £115.3 million and in 1956, £107.4 million. We had the highest exports of all times in 1954 and that was as a result of the working of the policy behind, the 1952 Budget. It is time that the back benchers of Fine Gael became a little bit intelligent and found out what was the result of the 1952 Budget before beginning to criticise it. It is all very well to throw remarks around the House that this is the worst Budget since 1952 without knowing the policy behind the 1952 Budget. Deputy Sweetman said here to-night that the most important thing was the adverse trade balance.

Comment on this

Our external balance; that is not the same thing.

Comment on this

Our trade balance.

Comment on this

Our external balance, visible and invisible.

Comment on this

We shall take the whole thing together. In 1951, visible and invisible, it was £61.6 million after three years of Coalition rule—adverse, of course. In 1954, two years after the 1952 Budget, it was £5.5 million. It went down from £61.6 million to £5.5 million. The figures I have already quoted here show that was achieved by exports, not by cutting imports, because cutting imports is a prelude and a sign to cutting the standard of living. The balance in 1955 was £35.5 million and in 1956 it was £14.4 million.

With regard to employment, in 1951 there were 184,000 employed in manufacturing industry. In 1954 there were 189,000 employed and the figure went back to 187,000 in 1956. Do Fine Gael back benchers believe that? They certainly do not believe that if they listen to their front benchers. The year 1954 was the best year of all and the reason was the 1952 Budget. The number engaged in agriculture was declining all the time but the one year that remained constant was 1954 when the number engaged in agriculture was the same as in 1953. It was the first year for which we have figures to show that the decline in agriculture had stopped. Then the inter-Party Government came in and the numbers employed in agriculture went down again.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Because they came in, of course. Deputy Dillon quoted other figures. I should like to refer to them as figures as amended by Deputy Dillon. He gave us what he said was the highest number of cattle of all time. That may be. I do not know. It may be right but I want to say that while the number was higher over 1954 by 34,000, the number of cows and heifers in calf was lower by 8,000 so that it is questionable if it is going to be a continuous increase.

Comment on this

Certainly, with the elimination of calf mortality.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy is right. Deputy Dillon did not quote pigs. It is a remarkable thing that when Deputy Dillon comes into agriculture, pigs go out. Pigs were down by 216,000 in 1956 compared with 1954 and sows were down by 18,000. If Deputies opposite would like to put all the figures together—exports, adverse balance, employment in both industry and agriculture, cattle, sheep, pigs and everything else—they could then make up their minds whether Deputy Dillon was right or not.

Comment on this

What was the consequent unemployment figure in 1954 following the 1952 Budget?

Comment on this

It was lower than it is now. Deputy Flanagan and others said the Coalition had left us a clean sheet. They left us first of all £6,000,000 of debt on last year's Budget, and moneys owing to every local authority in Ireland and, indeed, to many individuals. I do not know if it is hundreds, thousands, or tens of thousands who were waiting for their grants for farm improvement schemes and so on.

With regard to the Road Fund, Deputy Sweetman as Minister last year took £500,000 out of it. This year, I had to put £1,000,000 back into it. I not only had to put in £500,000, but I also had to put in the £500,000 which he took out as well.

It is suggested that there is inconsistency in some of our speeches or in some of our reasoning because we say it is unfair and wrong to be giving cheap bread and butter to people who are well-off and at the same time giving increases in children's allowances. When children's allowances were first brought in we did deduct the allowance a person got from his income-tax assessment allowance so that he was no better off if he was an income-tax payer. There were changes in the income-tax rate in 1946, 1948 and 1949 and there was no change made so far as children's allowances were concerned but, in 1954, Fianna Fáil brought in a Budget whereby a change was made in the income-tax code. Up to that, a person paying income-tax got exemption on £80 of income for the first child and £63 for other children. In 1954 that was made £85 all round and in 1955, under Deputy Sweetman as Minister for Finance, it was made £100 all round.

I am up against the fact that every Party in this House has agreed to the principle that the income-tax rate should not be interferred with so far as children's allowances are concerned. If we leave the lower and middleincome group aside, and go to the group above that, I think that the amount to be saved would not be very considerable. There is a difference in principle between giving a gift or subsidy, or whatever you like to call it, to the rich and to the poor alike, and giving a benefit to the big family as against the person who has no family at all.

There was a good deal of comment on certain of the import levies that were withdrawn. I am sorry Deputy Sweetman has now gone outside. I was going to quote Deputy Sweetman again. He was first to start this hare on the day the Budget speech was made here. He passed a remark about high-powered cars and Deputy Dillon also commented on that. Again, I do not mind the back-benchers, but Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Dillon I think were very unfair to pass remarks like that when they knew the facts. When these import levies were put on there were negotiations with the British Government and, in a letter from the United Kingdom Trade Commissioner here he said they would agree, provided the levies on those cars costing over £1,300 would be removed at the earliest possible moment, and that as soon as the levy was reduced or abolished for motor cars or motor car parts the levy on that type of car would similarly be reduced or abolished.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said here half an hour ago. I said that, so long as you left my scheme there, it was all right but that as soon as you altered it the British Government had you. You changed it.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy knew, after the Budget speech, that we had not left it there? Still, he started this talk about high-powered cars. Deputy Norton said it was not necessary to do it and that the British had not insisted on doing it. However, they had insisted that that levy should be withdrawn. What object do Deputies expect to achieve by saying that we are in favour of the big cars, and so on? I suppose that, in all, only a few dozen big cars come in here during the course of a year. Remember, too, that they are paying 22 2/9ths per cent., although neither Deputy Sweetman nor Deputy Dillon said so.

Motor bodies are paying 25 per cent. and the chassis are paying 20 per cent. It was explained at the time that there was a good deal of unemployment in the motor industry because of the uncertainty of the future. It was done in order to remove the uncertainty and to let the motor people go on with their business. It is all very well for Deputies to talk here about that sort of thing but I should like to know if they would meet the employees of the motor assembly industry and tell them they are in favour of the old scheme and put them out of their employment again.

The same thing too, to a great extent, applies to wireless sets, television sets, and so on. Deputies on the Opposition benches may laugh: it is easy to amuse them. They are paying 70 per cent., or £7 10s., on a wireless set and 50 per cent., or £5, preference duty if the set comes in from Great Britain. Do Deputies opposite think we should put more on it?

Sometimes we hear Opposition Deputies talk about the protected industries. Sometimes we hear them say that such industries are getting too much protection or are getting away with too much. Then they say, trying to appeal to the mob—the demagogic approach—that this Government is letting wireless sets in——

Comment on this

Television is a must. You ran away from the mob.

Comment on this

There is no "mob" in Ireland. That expression is an insult. The Minister should withdraw it.

Comment on this

Umbrellas—37½ per cent. and 25 per cent. Gramophones—33? per cent.

Comment on this

Rock an' roll records— how much? That shook you.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to answer that sort of silly nonsense. As far as I know, nobody here objected to reliefs given to industry. Deputy Norton, the leader of the Labour Party, said that as far as he was concerned the more done in that direction the better as the objective, naturally, is to get people working.

We are all in favour of permanent employment. This Government is doing something to promote it. Then the Deputies opposite appeal to the mob and say that we are giving something to the big industrialists.

Comment on this

There is no "mob".

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

There is not very much use in subscribing to the principle of balancing the Budget when, at the same time, you object to any plan for balancing it—that is, unless an alternative plan is given. I have been on to that point already. I have not heard anybody give any suggestion of real value. Any suggestions were of two kinds: (1) the silly suggestion Deputy Everett made about saving £1,000,000 out of £50,000 or (2) suggestions by Deputy Costello and Deputy McGilligan which amounted to balancing the Budget by borrowing. We cannot do that. As a matter of fact, I think the spokesmen from the Fine Gael and other benches would say that that would be wrong. The Budget should not be balanced by borrowing but by current income.

I have emphasised before and I will say it again—the other Parties have had seven days to talk on this debate and I want to say my say, too—that the Government have a policy and that the balancing of the Budget is only a part of it. In particular, the policy is to promote more production and to get more permanent employment and, in that way, to get a better standard of living for everybody in the country. I have emphasised also that all our capital resources will be required for success in that object and that capital cannot be spared to pay our current expenditure—to balance the Budget. I agree, therefore, that any suggestions that we should use capital to balance our Budget should be rejected.

We have a desperate situation to deal with. Remember that in the past two years, 1955 and 1956, approximately 98,000 people left this country. It is the highest figure since the famine. In addition, there were almost 100,000 people unemployed at the beginning of this year. It was a terrible situation. Deputies should give more thought to and take this problem more seriously. They should not merely think of the good points they are making which will suit them in the country afterwards, at an election or any place else. They should think of the problem and try to help to solve it as far as they can.

We have heard about the stability of the Coalition Government. We do not want that stability. That stability was coming there all right—stability in emigration, stability in unemployment, stability in doing nothing. We do not want that sort of stability and we are not going to have it. It is all right for Deputies opposite to say that they kept the cost of living, and so on, right. They did not, but they said so. That sort of stability was achieved by the process, all the time, of doing nothing and certainly not doing anything that would try to right the situation that was there—the big problems of emigration and unemployment.

The situation is very serious and courageous Ministers are necessary to deal with it. Of course, capital is one of the essentials to deal with this problem. We want capital for private enterprise. There is a lot of criticism about doing something for the manufacturers but I would point out that we are a private enterprise country. We are not behind the Iron Curtain. We cannot order capital into this or that industry. Private enterprise can get capital only by the profit incentive. People will not put money into a private enterprise unless they think they will make a profit. Therefore, we must make it possible for private enterprise firms to make a profit. The only way we see of doing that is to try to lessen the taxation on them.

We want capital both for private enterprise and for State purposes—the Local Loans Fund, housing, sanitary schemes, the Road Fund, E.S.B., Bord na Móna, telephone services, and so on. To allow the position to drift would be criminal. I am quite convinced—and I am sure the same can be said about many Deputies on the opposite benches, if they could forget the political advantage they could take out of this debate—we should not allow the position to drift but that we should do something to try to right it. We are taking that step. You may say it is wrong but, for goodness' sake, treat it in an honest way and help us or at least do not interfere with us in trying to solve this problem.

We have talked now for seven days. It is extraordinary to hear the members of the Fine Gael Party getting up one after the other and saying the same thing. What do they think they will gain? Will we solve the problem by every man making the same speech as the one before? If they were serious, would they not say "That speech has been made already. Let us sit down and see what we can do to solve the problem"? Is the object not obvious: "I have to make a speech for the local paper the same as the other fellow"? It is far more important for Fine Gael to have speeches in the local papers than to solve the problems of this country.

The Government, which has the responsibility of planning for the future, is in no way indebted to any member of the Opposition for a single worthwhile suggestion. There was not a single one in this whole debate. Could any Deputy opposite get up and contradict that——

Comment on this

Certainly——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Unless the Minister gives way the Deputy may not intervene.

Comment on this

They talked for seven days advocating that we should balance the Budget, stressing the need for more production, the need for capital for that purpose and deploring the high rate of unemployment and emigration but condemning a suggestion that was made by this Government to deal with that problem. They think that by going on talking things will come all right. Seeing that they failed for over three years as a result of their policy of drift, would you not think that they would have contented themselves by saying they did not believe in our plan but were quite satisfied to sit back and let us have a try at it? But no, that would not suit.

Almost every Deputy on the Labour side said we were always talking about production, about people spending too much and about the people being too well off. They also mentioned the appeal I made in my Budget speech for people to take this Budget and try to carry on without compensating themselves for some time. They were appalled at all this. Yet they voted for the Finance Act last year after hearing this speech from Deputy Sweetman——

Comment on this

Quote it accurately now.

Comment on this

It is from the Dáil Debates of the 25th July, 1956, at column 1603. Deputy Sweetman said:—

"Stability of money incomes is essential. The measures which I have announced must reduce the purchasing power of incomes by raising the cost of certain imports. They will be rendered ineffective if there is any effort to compensate for this reduction in purchasing power by pressing for higher monetary incomes."

It was all right for Deputy Sweetman to say it—they went into the Division Lobby and voted afterwards—but when Fianna Fáil says it, there is a cry out to the Labour people all over the country: "Go for your increases of wages and embarrass the Government as far as you can."

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman also said:—

"In the present serious situation we must all accept a temporary lowering of our standards as a condition of building them on a surer foundation."

They were prepared to accept "a temporary lowering" from Deputy Sweetman. If anybody from this side said the workers should lower their standard of living, there would be an outcry from Labour that Fianna Fáil thinks the Labour fellows are too well off. It was all right for Deputy Sweetman to say it. All the Labour men—there were a whole lot more of them there at that time—went into the Division Lobby and voted for them.

Deputy Sweetman went on:—

"Another round of increases in money incomes on top of those gained last year would be certain to price many of our products completely out of foreign markets. It would be certain also to aggravate our balance of payments difficulties and to necessitate a contraction in our plans for national development."

If I had read that quotation to the Deputies opposite, they would say I was reading my Budget speech again. When Deputy Sweetman made it last year they trooped into the Division Lobby afterwards. It shows what genuine Labour men we have in the House. It depends on who makes the speech, not on the speech or on what will be done.

Deputy Norton and other speakers— I shall be able to go on with this homily on much surer ground now seeing that Deputy Sweetman is with me —have forecast and even urged that organised Labour should compensate themselves against the removal of the subsidies by higher wages. The community must pay its way and the community to-day means the workers in the widest sense—those who draw wages, salaries or profits. If we continue to run a Budget deficit, the workers, as I have defined them, will not pay their way. That is exactly what Deputy Sweetman pointed out last year.

This Budget is an attempt to get things right so that we will pay our way. We can all count ourselves workers in the definition I gave—wage earners, salary earners or profit makers, as the case may be. If any section, whether wage earners, salary earners or profit earners, succeeds in getting more money without any increase in production, that extra money will be used to purchase goods. That will have the effect of increasing imports or decreasing exports and will also increase the cost of exports. That, in turn, will eventually lead to a deficit in the balance of trade. I do not think anybody can disagree with me so far. That will be followed by a credit squeeze and then we shall be back again as we were under the Coalition in 1955 and 1956 with more unemployment and more emigration.

If all concerned, instead of urging these measures they have so violently urged here, would turn their attention to reducing the cost of production, it would eventually make more production possible and lead to more employment and a better standard of living all round. Those who urge a general demand for increased wages and salaries must accept responsibility for the consequences. I do not want to exaggerate those consequences but it will be at least more difficult for the Government to solve the twin problems of unemployment and emigration. The Government may be embarrassed in implementing its programme but Deputies should make up their mind as to whether the embarrassment of the Government or the welfare of the unemployed is more important to them. I would ask Deputies to keep these facts in mind in casting their votes in this division.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 75
·
Níl 57
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?