Committee on Finance. - Health and Mental Treatment Bill, 1957—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–145 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1957 ›
I move amendment No. 1 standing in the name of Deputy T.F. O'Higgins:—
1. In sub-section (1) to delete paragraph (a) and substitute the following:—
(a) by the deletion in sub-section (4) of the words "not exceeding six" in the third and fourth lines thereof, and the substitution therefor of "not exceeding, in the case of the dependents of persons specified in sub-section (2) (a) of this section and in the case of such of the persons specified in sub-section (2) (c) of this section and their dependents, whose farm or farms exceed £25 in valuation, the sum of ten shillings, and in all other cases the sum of six".
This matter was discussed already. It was pointed out that this is a rather serious departure in principle from the provisions of the original Act and from the general type of intention, as expressed by the Minister already, enshrined in the general principles of the Health Act.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment is to try to segregate in some way the charges imposed under the Bill on those entitled to services under Section 15 of the Act. As Deputies will appreciate, under Section 15 of the Health Act, 1953, there are certain categories of eligible persons, first of all, those entitled to free medical services whose right is evidenced by their being on the general medical service register; secondly, insured persons, which, of course, means all persons insured under the Social Welfare Act; thirdly, all persons whose yearly means do not exceed £600 and fourthly, farmers whose valuation does not exceed £50. There are other people also entitled to services under the Health Act but the Minister's proposal in this Bill is to impose on all those categories, except those entitled to free medical services, a charge of 10/- per day in respect of their treatment in hospital.
I said on Second Reading, and I felt very strongly, that this is going too far, too quickly. I could always understand that a case might be made in respect of some of these classes that a charge greater than 6/- a day might be imposed, but I feel that the Minister's proposal may inflict a very serious hardship on these categories of entitled people mentioned in the Health Act.
I shall just take the two classes mentioned in the amendment as an example. In the first place, let us take insured persons, and in this connection may I say that on Second Reading when I was speaking I inadvertently mentioned that roughly 800,000 insured persons were entitled to services prior to the Health Act? The Minister corrected me; I think from the record, I appear to dispute the Minister's correction but I would like to say that in that respect he was perfectly correct. Whatever the exact figure may be, my recollection is that prior to the Health Act, approximately 400,000 insured persons were entitled to specialist and hospital services without any charge.
These people had that right. Under the Health Act a change was provided. Under the Health Act an insured person whether in benefit or not—in other words, whether he had three years' stamps or not—was entitled to services, to specialist and in-treatment service in hospitals only at a charge of 6/- per day. Ostensibly, the specialist services were provided free but he was charged 6/- per day as an in-patient in hospital. There was considerable opposition to that charge and it became my responsibility, although I was not party to the legislation, to defend throughout the country the charge that was imposed. I defended it in precisely the same way as the Minister referred to it on the Second Reading of this Bill, to the effect that while the insured person under the Health Act was being charged 6/- per day for his hospital treatment he now had the advantage of having his wife and children also provided with in-patient treatment in hospital at a charge of 6/- a day——
Comment on this
I think the Deputy should emphasise that the 6/- to which he is referring is a maximum charge.
Comment on this
I can assure the Minister, as I think the Minister will find very quickly, that the maximum charge of 6/- per day is the usual charge. I have not come across any case—there may be cases; I do not dispute it—in which anything less than the maximum was charged by any health authority. In any event, the defence which I made to every health authority in the country was that for the charge of 6/- now being imposed under the Health Act the insured persons received similar rights for their dependents.
I do not think that defence satisfied insured persons and those who spoke on their behalf throughout the country that this charge of 6/- per day was a reasonable one, but I would like to remind Deputies that this 6/- charge under the Health Act came into operation only in April of last year and accordingly it is a charge that is little more than 12 months in operation. If there are any Deputies here who are aware of the criticism that has arisen in the last 12 months about this 6/- per day charge, they can certainly recognise the justice of the suggestion I made on Second Reading that the 6/- per day charge was so recently in operation that it seems unjust now to increase it by more than 50 per cent.
If I still had the responsibility in the matter, I might have introduced legislation, once health insurance was available to our people, to increase some of these charges under the Health Act. I think I would have excluded from the effect of such increases all insured persons themselves and certainly the small farmer. I would have excluded insured persons for this reason. As Deputies will realise, when an insured person falls ill and has to go into hospital, his wage ceases in many cases and generally he is then drawing not a wage but a benefit under the Social Welfare Act. That benefit is then the only source from which his hospital maintenance has to be provided and his family have to be kept in food, the rent paid and so on. The purpose of this amendment, or one of its objects, is to ask the Dáil to say that an insured person, when he becomes ill and has to go to hospital, should not be charged any more than it was proposed to charge him in 1953 when the Health Act was passed.
That proposal is based on experience; it is based on a knowledge of the fact that when an insured person becomes ill in many cases he is not earning the fixed, or any, wage. He is depending on a social welfare benefit and, accordingly, my submission to the Dáil is that he should not be charged anything approaching the proposed charge of 10/- per day. I concede in the amendment, since apparently it is part of the principle of the Bill, that a charge of 10/- per day may be imposed on the dependents of insured persons if they get sick. Though generally I would be against it, I can see some case for it because if a child gets ill, presumably the father is still earning wages and possibly from those wages a sum of 10/- per day might be forthcoming. But I can see no case to be made for imposing this charge on a sick worker whose sickness may entail loss of income—a person who may become completely dependent on whatever social welfare payments he is entitled to.
The first object of this amendment, therefore, is to ensure that, under the Minister's proposals, the charge of 10/- per day will not fall upon insured workers in this State who themselves have to go to hospital, who themselves have to get hospital treatment and who, because of their illness or injury, lose their source of income. The second purpose of the amendment is to try to separate in some way that category of entitled persons who may be classed as farmers.
I propose in this amendment to ask the Dáil to say that in respect of each farmer and his dependents, whose valuation does not exceed £25, the old charge of 6/- per day should remain and that the new charge of 10/- per day should apply only where the valuation exceeds £25. Again, if there is to be an increase in the charge some effort should be made, even though it may be difficult, even though it may involve the Minister and his Department in some research, to ensure that the charge does not press unduly on different sections throughout the country.
All of us know that in so far as valuation of land is a yardstick of wealth and living standards it is a very faulty one indeed. There are landholders in different parts of the country who, holding land with a valuation of £50, may be regarded as being in a very good way of living while only 70 or 80 miles from him land of the same valuation may not be regarded as anything very extravagant.
I have endeavoured in this amendment to take a valuation of £25. I feel from my experience—and I have discussed this matter with, I think, every health authority in the country—that, taking a valuation of £25, it is safe to say that below that figure it would be a hardship to impose a charge of £3 10s. per week in respect of hospital treatment for the farmer, his wife or other dependents. Above that valuation figure a case might be made for the increased charge in respect of certain individuals. I bear in mind in the amendment that under the section proposed to be amended there is a general hardship clause under which the health authorities are entitled to remit charges if they feel a case of personal hardship has been established.
I seriously recommend this amendment to the Dáil. It is aimed at ensuring that a charge which may be unjust should not fall on all insured persons. The Minister has pointed out this is a maximum charge. I wonder will Deputies agreed with me when I say that while it may be a maximum charge, in relation to the 6/- per day charge it has worked out as the charge that will be imposed. Dublin Deputies know that under the Health Act in respect of a person who in any way exercised any sort of choice of Dublin hospitals the Dublin Corporation paid in respect of their treatment only a sum of £4 4s. per week which is, in fact, imposing on an insured person the 6/- per day charge.
Generally speaking, throughout the country all persons who may be charged in fact are charged the full rate under the Health Act. I do not think it would be quite fair of the Minister to ask those who genuinely have doubts about the wisdom of this charge to reject this amendment on the basis that the 10/- per day charge will not be imposed. Of course it will; it is intended that it will be imposed because the expectation is that £90,000 will be saved to the Exchequer. That sum cannot be saved unless health authorities throughout the country impose this 10/- per day. Certainly, that has been their practice up to this.
If it is done it means that certain workers in this city and elsewhere, who are troubled enough because of their illness, who worry enough because their wages have suddenly ceased, will have to face this charge of £3 10s. per week for their hospital treatment. Workers will find themselves with their wives and families having to exist on their social welfare benefit payment. I think that is wrong. I think that if the Minister is free to review his opinion he will agree that it is unjust. He will agree in respect of such persons that the other provisions of Section 15 are going to be invoked to suggest that no charge at all will be imposed. The purpose of this amendment is to suggest that no charge may be imposed in respect of such cases.
In relation to farmers, if the Minister proposes to charge all farmers in this country with a valuation of £50, 10/- per day, the purpose of my amendment is to suggest some half-way house, to suggest that the charge be imposed only on those with a valuation of over £25.
Comment on this
Let me first of all reciprocate the service which the Deputy has rendered to the accuracy of the knowledge which every Deputy should have of the conditions under which medical hospital treatment was given prior to the enactment of the 1953 Act. When we were debating that Bill on its Second Reading the Deputy made certain statements in relation to the position of insured persons. He omitted, as he has acknowledged to-day, to point out that treatment was given under very severe restrictions. First of all a worker had to have 156 stamps on his card. Secondly, it was given only for six weeks and thirdly, of course, it was not given to his dependents at all.
I should like to apologise to the Deputy because I said in the course of my reply to him on Second Reading that I had not heard him mention the term for which treatment is given. I now wish to say that the Deputy did point out that hospital treatment was for a limited term.
Comment on this
And others will qualify also. Is it not rather extraordinary at the same time that the Deputy who was so conscious of the disability under which insured persons laboured in respect of hospital treatment prior to the enactment of the 1953 Act, should have been one of the foremost opponents of the Act? I know it did fall to his lot, under pressure from some of his colleagues and allies in the Coalition, to bring into operation certain provisions of the Act. In the course of the speech to which we have just listened he has been at pains to misrepresent the provisions of Section 15 of the Act. If you read his speech——
Comment on this
If you read his speech it contains the statement that the maximum charge of 10/- per day would be the universal and general charge. Every second sentence contained that statement. It was an act of deliberate propaganda to misrepresent even yet the provisions of the 1953 Act and of Section 15 which conferred such great benefits not only on insured persons and their dependents but on other sections of the public as well. The Deputy learned this propaganda technique in a school where it has been brought to perfection; in a school which inspired the old Blueshirt movement.
Comment on this
The Deputy learned under the able guidance of a person who said that if a he is repeated often enough people will begin to believe it.
Comment on this
The Minister realises this is the Committee Stage. I can speak as many times as I like.
Comment on this
I heard the Deputy with patience, with a degree of patience that I found it hard to exercise. Let any Deputy get the report of Deputy O'Higgins's speech and he will see, as I have said, that Deputy O'Higgins repeated and reiterated time and time again——
Comment on this
——that the maximum charge would be the usual and the universal charge and then he went on to give his authority for that statement. He went on to say: "As far as I know that will be the situation." What inquiries did Deputy O'Higgins make in relation to the matter even when he was Minister for Health? I cannot find any record that this question was examined in my Department before I set certain inquiries on foot. I do know this. I have received deputations from health authorities in the course of which they said that the charge of 6/- per day was not the general and universal charge. I have made other inquiries since; more definite inquiries, and I find that, according to the estimates which are made and the information supplied to me, the maximum charge is not general and universal, that it is in fact an exceptional charge.
I have had a test check made in certain institutions here in Dublin and I find, first of all, that only one person out of four who comes under the provisions of Section 15 is charged at all. Does Deputy O'Higgins know that?
Comment on this
The Deputy says it is nonsense. I want to know what investigations did the Deputy make?
Comment on this
I have said now that a test check has indicated that only one person out of four was charged at all.
Comment on this
And of those fewer than 55 per cent. were paying the maximum charge. That is the position.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins had the audacity to get up here and, as I have said, in every second sentence of his speech he tried to mislead the Dáil and the country by suggesting that this maximum charge, the maximum charge permitted, was the general, universal, and inevitable charge. That is not discussing the problem in a responsible way.
The Deputy also said that there had been considerable criticism of the provisions of Section 15 which permits the health authority to ask for a contribution from certain classes of patients towards the cost of their treatment in hospital. The Deputy said there was considerable opposition to the 6/-. No doubt, there was some opposition, but it was opposition which was fostered and inspired by the Fine Gael spokesmen at every crossroads in the country.
Comment on this
Oh, no. That was the Deputy's get-out. It was not against Deputy O'Higgins. Not at all!
Comment on this
——and the Deputy was held out as the poor innocent victim of the Labour element in the Coalition.
Comment on this
The Deputy was being held out as the poor young man who had to do what his Labour colleagues told him and operate the provisions of the iniquitous Health Act of 1953. Now his performance here to-day was not at all consistent with the attitude he and his colleagues—certainly his colleagues at any rate—took outside this House.
Following upon this misstatement that every insured person in hospital will be compelled to pay £3 10s. per week, the Deputy referred to a hypothetical case of an insured person who, by reason of the fact that he becomes ill, loses his job and he then went on to say that that poor man would be compelled to pay £3 10s. per week. I think the Deputy ought to take another look at the Health Act. If a person is out of employment, he has no income and one cannot take breaks off a Highlander—not even the Fine Gael Party could do that—and, therefore, if he has no income I do not think any health authority would have the audacity to try to collect from him £3 10s. a week, as Deputy O'Higgins has suggested they would.
Comment on this
Let me try to make it quite clear now so that we shall not have any further misrepresentation in relation to this matter. These charges will not be imposed and will not apply to the institutional services provided for maternity cases, nor to patients receiving institutional treatment for infectious diseases, nor to pupils of national schools receiving institutional treatment in respect of defects discovered at school health examinations. I hope we are quite clear about that for we do not want to hear Deputy O'Higgins when he goes outside this House again making the same sort of misstatement as he made on Second Reading, when he implied that maternity cases would be affected by this.
Comment on this
If the Minister quotes me as having said that, then he is misquoting me. I never said that. I brought the maternity services into operation, and I know all about them.
Comment on this
The misstatements which the Deputy will not believe now were made by himself—by him and his colleagues. I am quoting from Volume 162, column 38 of the Official Report. The Deputy was referring to the maternity service:—
"I am glad that service is now in operation and working successfully, but it is a general practitioner service, service based on the family doctor. If specialist assistance is needed, then, under this Act, a charge must be imposed, and I want to remind Deputies that whatever discretion is given to health authorities in respect of a charge for persons going into hospital, under this Bill, if it is not amended, it is mandatory on them to charge for specialist services."
That is what the Deputy said.
Comment on this
"I am glad that service is now in operation", and then he went on to say:—
"If specialist assistance is needed, then, under this Act, a charge must be imposed..."
Comment on this
I only want to say that that is the Deputy as reported in the Official Report. I do not know whether or not the Deputy revised the typescript of the report—perhaps he did not. It is very difficult sometimes for Deputies or Ministers, speaking here, to be reported correctly, particularly when there is a crossfire of interruption coming from the Opposition Benches and, as I say, it may be an error in paragraphing; it may be that the whole of what the Deputy said was not caught by the reporter.
Comment on this
But I am not pinning him down to that statement because, to me, it is inconceivable that any person who had been a Minister for Health could possibly have made it. I mention it now so that we will be quite clear that the Deputy did not intend to say what he is reported to have said, and I am quite prepared to accept that position. But I want to make it quite clear now that the charges for specialist services which are being provided for by the Bill are charges for specialist services under Section 15 only and these services, whether general practitioner, specialist or hospital maternity services will continue to be provided free of charge to the recipient. I hope we are all satisfied about that now and that we shall not hear this suggestion repeated.
Comment on this
No, the suggestion the Deputy made. I have to take, subject to corrections which may be made in it later, the Official Report as being a correct report of what the Deputy said and I just want to nail that statement now and say that it is not true and I am glad to know, from the attempts which the Deputy has made to interrupt me, that he does not believe he made that statement.
Comment on this
The Official Report does not show that I made it either. I went out of my way to say "the general practitioner service".
Comment on this
On a point of order. I wonder could this crossfire cease so that the official reporter will at least have a chance of getting the Minister's speech?
Comment on this
I shall read what I have in front of me:—
"The Minister goes on to say that also excluded from these increases is the maternity service, that is, the general practitioner service. That is a service in respect of which I had considerable difficulty in providing something that would work——"
Comment on this
I am quoting what is reported here. I am quoting the full text. Deputy O'Higgins is reported to have said:—
"That is a service in respect of which I had considerable difficulty in providing something that would work and be accepted by all. I am glad that service is now in operation and working successfully, but it is a general practitioner service, service based on the family doctor."
What does that really imply? When he said it was a general practitioner service based on the family doctor, he excluded by implication any specialist services that might be needed apart from those which the family doctor could provide. That is the implication. It may be the Deputy was speaking impromptu and I do not want to hold him to this, but I want to clear myself of the charge which the Deputy has made that I quoted something which he did not say. Then he went on to say this:—
"If specialist assistance is needed, then, under this Act"—
and here he draws a clear distinction between the family doctor service and the specialist service:—
"a charge must be imposed and I want to remind Deputies that whatever discretion is given to health authorities in respect of a charge for persons going into hospital, under this Bill, if it is not amended, it is mandatory on them to charge for specialist services."
That is what the Deputy is reported to have said.
Comment on this
I think I can take it that the Deputy did not mean it to be construed as I have construed it.
Comment on this
The Minister, in opening, said that he was excluding the charges for specialist services in this Bill, under the maternity service, and I was pointing out this was a general practitioner service which could not be charged any way.
Comment on this
I was pointing that out already. I did point it out and I emphasised it. The reason I am dealing with this point now is that the Deputy stood up and referred to my statement in such a way as would lead people to believe that even in respect of the maternity service we were making it mandatory on the health authority to charge for specialist services. That was the implication of that statement. However, the Deputy says he did not mean that, that he does not intend it to be read in that way, so that matter has been cleared up. I am satisfied. I hope that we shall not hear that statement repeated outside this House——
Comment on this
I will repeat it because it is not capable of the meaning the Minister has given it.
Comment on this
——or used for propaganda purposes against this Bill. Having dealt with the arguments which have been used in support of the amendment, let me come to consider the amendment itself. Under Section 15 there are four categories of patients who are entitled to benefit under the section. The Deputy's amendment proposes to subdivide those categories further. He tries to draw a distinction between an insured person, on the one hand, and the dependent of an insured person on the other. He tries to draw a distinction between a farmer who owns land the valuation of which exceeds £25 and does not exceed £50, and the farmer who owns land the valuation of which does not exceed £25. That introduces quite an unnecessary complication and a complication which would make the administration of the Act most difficult and expensive. I think that one of the reasons why this has been done is to increase still further its unpopularity with the health authorities which the Deputy alleges exists.
I do not think the Act is at all as unpopular as Deputy O'Higgins would like it to be, but I know it would certainly be more unpopular with the ratepayers and the local authorities if, instead of having to deal with four categories of patients under Section 15, they had to deal with at least six categories. We would have more red tape, more application forms, more disputes with the manager in relation to each one of these categories. Is that the purpose for which this amendment was put down? I suggest that this was at the back of the Deputy's mind, that by making the position more complicated it would intensify such opposition as there might be among health authorities to the operation of the 1953 Act. As I have said, I do not for a moment believe that the Act is as unpopular as Deputy O'Higgins suggests, but quite obviously the purpose of creating these additional categories is to make administration more difficult, more expensive and more vexatious.
Apart from this aspect of the matter, let us consider what the Deputy proposes to do by his amendment. The Deputy who is so concerned about the position of the insured person comes in here and proposes to put the insured person in a less advantageous position than some of the other categories which he is content to allow to stand as they appear in Section 15. Under the Deputy's amendment there might be an insured person earning, say, £300 a year, £6 a week in round figures. He might—I say "might"— have to pay 10/- a day if he were in hospital but that would be because he would have other resources. Deputy O'Higgins, however, takes the view that he would have to pay 10/- a day. The whole burden of his speech was that this insured person would have to pay 10/- a day so long as he himself or any dependent of his was in hospital. That is the general purport of Deputy O'Higgins's amendment. On the other hand, there might be a small shopkeeper earning, say, £599 a year and a dependent of his, under Deputy O'Higgins's amendment, could not be charged more than 6/- a day. So, here we have a Deputy, those heart is brimming over with consideration and sympathy for the unfortunate insured person, putting him in this situation that he would have to pay 10/- a day —the Deputy said he would have to pay 10/- a day; £3 10s. a week—for a dependent of his so long as that dependent was in hospital, even if the insured person's income did not not exceed £300. On the other hand, a shopkeeper with the resources of property and other things behind him and the certainty of an income derived from trading, if he had an income of £599 and had a dependent in hospital, would have to pay only 6/-. I suggest that all this is contrary to natural justice and that there is no purpose in this amendment.
The real purpose of the amendment was just to muddy the waters and to make propaganda against the Bill because, if there really had been serious consideration given to the effects of the amendment, I doubt if Deputy O'Higgins would put it down. Therefore, on those grounds, I ask the House to reject it.
Comment on this
The Minister has tried to clear a lot of things but in the general confusion that he has introduced here. I should like to get clear on one point. In the early part of the Minister's statement he attempted to rebut the suggestion that this additional 4/- would really be charged. I should like to get clear on that.
The Minister indicated when he was introducing this measure that £90,000 a year would be saved to the State and that £90,000 a year would be saved to the local authorities. That implies to me that somebody will pay the additional 4/- in respect of 900,000 patient days. The implication is that the additional 4/- will be charged for about 2,460 patients spending the whole of the 12 months in hospital. Can we be clear on that, that is, that the extent to which the additional 4/- a day will be charged will be the charging over the full year of 4/- a day for 2,460-odd patients?
Comment on this
There are a few small points arising out of the debate. In regard to the remark of the Minister on the question of the shopkeeper with all the resources of his shop—I know I am not quoting the Minister verbatim—that it would not be right that he should not be charged, that it would be contrary to natural justice if he were not, I wonder would the Minister expand that thesis a little for us and tell us, if that is so, why is it that the magnificent provisions of the 1947 Health Act which the Minister helped to frame, I have no doubt, and which his colleagues helped to introduce, contained a number of clauses, all of which, according to him now, must have contravened the law of natural justice in so far as in relation to the fever hospital treatment regulations, the infectious diseases treatment regulations, the tuberculosis treatment section of that Act and, of course, the famous mother and child provisions, the Act contained a free no means test provision which lays down that a person gets treatment in hospital irrespective of income, family income or personal income? The result is that there are throughout the country at the moment in all our tuberculosis hospitals and sanatoria and fever hospitals and to a certain extent in our maternity hospitals, shopkeepers, wealthy persons, who are being treated under the provisions of the 1947 Health Act of the Fianna Fáil Party, a magnificent Act which, as I have said before, any Government would be proud to have introduced.
Are these people who are in hospital in any way contravening the law of natural justice, whatever that may be? I am very vague about it. The Minister may know about it. He may know more about it now than he did in 1947 when he allowed these things to go through. Does he intend now, in order to remedy the offence to the law of natural justice, to remedy it in respect of these other services and introduce charges of some kind or other in relation to tuberculosis services and fever hospital services generally?
Does the Minister now want to backtrack on the magnificent provisions of the 1947 Act as he is backtracking on the relatively conservative provisions of the 1953 Health Act and does he want now to introduce charges in order to catch the wealthy shopkeeper or other wealthy person who is at present benefiting from the provision of these services?
It would appear to me to be a logical conclusion to the argument he used a moment ago that he should now try to seek out all those people and try to remedy the position in relation to the law of natural justice which he says is offended if a person who can pay does not pay. If a person who falls ill, goes to hospital and gets treated and does not pay if he has money, then this in some way contravenes this curious law of natural justice which applies in health services and which does not seem to me to apply in so many other of our services, whether the service is free fertilisers, lime and so on for farmers or the hundred and one amenities that people get to help them— children's allowances, Small Dwellings Acquisition Act loans and all these other amenities which people get without means test. Are all these people contravening the law of natural justice if they get these amenities from the State without being subjected to a means test and if they have money and, superficially, do not appear to need the grants or concessions from the State?
This, of course, is a very important point because it was one of the main arguments used by the present Opposition against Fianna Fáil when they were trying to introduce the 1953 Act and when at one time I was trying to introduce the mother and child provisions of the Fianna Fáil 1947 Health Act. Has the Minister gone over to the Opposition? Does the Minister now share in this point of view that free health services are contrary to the law of natural justice or that the principle is in any way vitiated or offended by giving a person a health service which he can pay for himself? Does he now in any way wish to repudiate on behalf of Fianna Fáil or do Fianna Fáil wish to repudiate, the free, no means test principle of their 1947 Act? Is that the point he is trying to make now in his suggestion that the wealthy person who can pay for health services should pay for them in order that we may keep intact this curious, amorphous, confused thing, the law of natural justice?
The Minister has made a point in reply to Deputy O'Higgins that there is only a negligible number of people paying the full 6/- at present. I will accept his very small number. A small series of cases were investigated to find out whether they were paying the full 6/- at present and whether the local authorities were using their discretionary powers to reduce that charge in certain cases.
In the first place, I do not know whether this argument merits the vehemence with which the Minister used it to refute Deputy O'Higgins's suggestion that the charges are nearly invariably 6/-. I have no figures at all to go on, but from what one hears, while the 6/- may be a discretionary charge it appears to me to be the standard in use at the moment. The Minister has produced this series of cases to show that only in a negligible number of cases is the full 6/- charged. I am giving only my impression and I do not wish to appear to be in any way dogmatic about it, but I get the general impression that Deputy O'Higgins is nearer the truth when he says that, on the whole, 6/- is the usual charge made by local authorities.
I think that whatever was the case in Deputy O'Higgins's time it is more likely in the present Minister's time that the full charge will be made, particularly when one recalls the answers to questions one hears in the House in which, by implication, the Minister appears to criticise or chide the benevolent-minded managers, the managers who know conditions particularly well and who tend to err on what I call the human justice side that seems to come into these things so very little, through consideration and ordinary human understanding of the personal problems, the financial problems, of the average unfortunate person faced with sickness or ill-health and the insecurity that follows.
I recall one remark of the Minister's in which he appeared to give the general impression that he did not want this soft-heartedness of the managers and it appeared that he wanted them to deal with such cases in a very rigid way so that if a particular charge was recommended, that was the charge he would prefer to have charged. If however, he wishes to undo the impression that I have in my mind, at any rate, through listening to him here, and to undo the impression he made in this House, I hope he will do it, and tell the managers that he would prefer them to err on the side of being thoughtful for the problems of the family in sickness, that he would treat with sympathy and consideration any decision of a county manager which appeared to err on the side of being generous rather than on the side of being stringent and harsh and that he would, as Minister, prefer that all these claims for health services were considered in a generally sympathetic way and that that would be his attitude to it.
That is of great importance to managers and health authorities generally. They are bound by the headline set by the Minister to a considerable extent and where they have a generously-minded Minister who is sympathetic to their anxiety to provide good health services it makes a great deal of difference to them. It gives them some support in coming to a decision which might not be in accordance with the absolute letter of the law but which would be in keeping with the spirit of the law as we send it out from here to give as good health services as can be provided under the circumstances.
I wonder when the Minister was thinking about this matter of increasing the charge and looking for a tax— because I insist that it is a tax, or at least one form of it; essentially, it is another form of taxation on the less wealthy and the poor who are already hit by the Budget—when he was thinking of the £90,000 he intended to get, an infinitesimal sum compared with the vast £100,000,000 Budget and because of that it seems all the more inexplicable why he should go for it at the expense of the sick—when he was considering this question, did he have in mind, or was he going on the assumption which he has used here to refute the argument of Deputy O'Higgins, that only a very tiny number of people pay the relatively small amount charged now? I think 25 per cent. was the figure he gave. When he was assessing the amount that would come from the increase from 6/- to 10/-, when he tried to assess the amount available from this increase, did he assess it on the assumption that only about 25 per cent. or so of the people trying to avail of the Health Act would be charged? Or did he assess it on the assumption that a higher number of people would be charged for health services under the present Act?
If he is basing his assumption on a contention that the apparent position is that only 25 per cent. of the persons are charged, then that seems to me to be a very dangerous, or courageous assumption, if you like, to base it on the very small series of cases from which he has derived this information, a relatively small series of cases from which he has derived his information? Is he, in assessing the amount he is getting, deciding that only a relatively small number of people are charged under the Health Act or is he basing it on Deputy O'Higgins's assumption that a very large number are charged the full sum under the Act? Will the figure be in the region of 25 per cent. as suggested by the Minister? Will the number of persons charged 10/- be in the region of 25 per cent. or so, as suggested by him, or will it be in the region of 100 per cent., as suggested by Deputy O'Higgins? To those of us who talk very much to, or have any contact with, the average person it seems the impression we have is that the permitted charge is the standard charge. Is the Minister going on the assumption that the permitted charge will be the standard charge or not?
I wonder did it mean anything to him, did it make any impression on him, the fact that such a tiny percentage of people were charged the full 6/- by health authorities? Did it not enter his mind, and did he not accept, or could he not accept, the reason why there is this small figure, or this apparent small percentage of people who paid the full 6/-? Is it not merely an indication of the fact that only a relatively small number of people can, without great hardship to themselves, pay any charge——
Comment on this
——in relation to health services, any charge of this nature? And because of that, because of the information he has received that a relatively small number of people are chargeable under the Health Act in the opinion of the health authorities, surely that is one very good reason, a most compelling reason and indication against increasing the charge? If anything, it is surely a case for eliminating the charge and not increasing it. How can he justify increasing this charge when he already knows the health authorities find that only very few people can pay even 6/-?
Instead of that, it has been increased by over 50 per cent. That seems to me to be the act of a completely unreasonable person. However, the Minister may have an explanation for doing what he has done here. The main case made by Deputy T.F. O'Higgins was, to my mind, when he talked about the worry of sickness, the uncertainty of employment which sickness brings about, the difficulty of knowing how long a person will be sick, whether his job will be waiting for him when he gets better. These questions seemed to me to constitute a familiar argument, the sort of arguments with which we became familiar from Fianna Fáil in the past. They were the arguments I made when I was pleading for the complete elimination of any charges for good efficient health services for the people. They were arguments which must have been used before my time in the House in order to put through the tuberculosis provisions of the 1947 Act.
They are all compelling arguments; all are arguments that have been borne out by the magnificent results of the 1947 Health Act under which we have a fine, efficient, well-working and just health service. The arguments of Deputy T.F. O'Higgins to-day could well be applied not only to a proposal to reduce the charge from 10/- to 6/- per day but to eliminating the charge altogether. As I have said, these are arguments which anybody who knows very much about health services generally will understand as being most real, telling and compelling.
That the charges should be increased to 10/- per day is indefensible. I maintain there should be no charges at all. I believe that was the system Deputy Dr. Ryan had in mind as Minister for Health when accusations were made against him that the Health Act was not going far enough. Certainly the amendment is an improvement. I believe the arguments made for it by Deputy T.F. O'Higgins are cogent ones. However, I believe this amendment does not go half far enough. The only way that this Act could give us a proper health service would be through the complete elimination of these charges—the extension of Fianna Fáil's plan under the 1947 Health Act in relation to fevers, infectious diseases and, to a limited extent, to child, maternity and infant schemes. I do not think there is any question of such a scheme interfering with what the Minister has called "natural justice".
Comment on this
I think I should follow Deputy Dr. Browne immediately because I think he misunderstood something I said in regard to the statement of Deputy T.F. O'Higgins in relation to this amendment. I did say that the proposals in the amendment were contrary to natural justice and I proceeded to point out why. On the hypothesis put forward by Deputy Dr. Browne's interpretation of the amendment, an insured person whose income was, say, £300 a year, would have to pay 10/- a day for every day that a dependent of his was in hospital and, on the other hand, a shopkeeper with an income of £599 19s. 11d. derived from his business would be called upon to pay at most 6/- a day for a dependent of his.
I said that an amendment which sought to do that was contrary to natural justice. It was only in that context that I used the phrase "natural justice". I do not want to get into a general debate here on the merits or demerits of the means test. That issue was decided by the House when it adopted the 1953 Act. This Bill proposes only to amend the 1953 Act on what is a comparatively minor issue. Therefore, I do not propose to try to refute the arguments which Deputy Dr. Browne used when he touched on that particular aspect.
I think there are a couple of other things I ought to say in order to make my own position clear. I do not regard taxation as an advantage. In general, like most people, I feel it is an evil which we should try to minimise and eliminate as much as possible. And when one asks a person who is in a position to do so to contribute towards the cost of a service which is provided for him, that is not taxation. Its nature is fundamentally different. Taxation is a tribute exacted from the general mass of the people in order to provide general services. This is a charge made for treatment received, for the upkeep and maintenance of persons in institutions.
How can that be called taxation? If a person who could afford to contribute were free to go into any institution— we will not talk about hospitals—and if he were to receive free all the benefits and advantages which that institution could confer upon him and if, at the same time, the general mass of people were to be taxed in order to maintain that institution, that is likely to cause hardship to many of those who are taxed. If a person who can afford to contribute towards his maintenance in such institutions is asked to contribute, I think it is better and more equitable, fairer and more just that he should be asked to make that contribution rather than that the entire cost of the services provided by that institution should be put on the backs of the mass of the people, those who are in the lower income groups.
That is my position anyhow. There is no question of taxing the sick or anything else. It is merely a question of asking a person who can pay for a service, or who can contribute some part of the cost of the service, to make the contribution in fairness to the general community and in fairness, particularly, to those who compose the greater part of the community, those who are in the lower income group.
Deputy Dr. Browne, I think like myself, tends to exaggerate his point of view. I did not suggest that it was only wealthy shopkeepers were concerned when I was discussing the merits of Deputy O'Higgins's amendment. I did not use the term wealthy shopkeepers in the way he has suggested. He has used it on a number of occasions to reinforce his argument. I said they were in the upper limit of the middle income group. I referred to a shopkeeper who had an income of £599 per annum derived from trading in his shop. I do not regard that person as a wealthy person and I am sure Deputy Dr. Browne does not regard him as such either. I do not know, but I suppose he may have in reasonable comfort if he manages his affairs prudently, but I do not regard him as a wealthy person. I do not see any point in obscuring the issue in this debate by using that adjective "wealthy" and by applying it to people in that class.
I did not say that it was a very tiny number of persons who will be affected by this Bill. I was addressing myself solely to the argument used by Deputy T.F. O'Higgins that this maximum charge was the general and universal charge. I did not suggest that there would not be an appreciable number of persons affected by it. I did not say there would be a tiny number of people affected by it, but I did say these would be a very definite minority of Section 15 cases. I said that on the basis of such information as I have been able to procure since I had the matter investigated. I did find that in the City of Dublin the number of Section 15 cases who have to pay is very much fewer than 25 per cent. of the total number covered by the provisions of Section 15.
Let me say this, and it indicates what the general public attitude is towards this issue. Over 40 per cent. of the patients under Section 15 make payment voluntarily, willingly and readily without pressure being brought to bear upon them at all. That is the general attitude of the self-respecting citizen towards this question. I think it is an attitude which is to be commended because it shows that we have still self-reliance in our people and that it is not being sapped by the frequent suggestion that everybody is entitled to get everything for nothing.
Another issue raised by Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Dr. Browne was in regard to this question of £90,000. There is more than one section in this Bill. I did not at any time suggest, that by the operation of Section 1 only, I hoped to get something between £70,000 and £90,000, that I hoped to save the community something between £70,000 and £90,000, the community as taxpayers, and a similar sum to the community as ratepayers. I did not say I was going to get that out of Section 1 of the Bill.
Comment on this
For a full year. I mentioned £90,000 but what is involved is £180,000 which will be shared between the ratepayers on the one hand, and the taxpayers on the other. If you can differentiate between them you are welcome to do so. I do not think any great hardship will be imposed on any person. It will depend on whether the persons affected by the Act can afford to pay these sums or not. If it is found, on investigation by the health authorities, that they cannot afford to pay them then we shall not get the £70,000 or £90,000 which we think the provisions will allow. We shall not get it if they cannot afford to pay it and there will be no undue pressure brought to bear on the managers or anybody else.
They will be expected to operate this Act with full consideration of the circumstances as they discover them. I am perfectly certain that no responsible person will act harshly or with undue severity in a matter of this sort. My general experience of all administrative people is that they give the benefit of the doubt wherever they can. They give the advantage, wherever they can, to the citizen. There is no use in anybody getting up here and trying to pretend that county managers, city managers or other officers are out to penalise or grind down in any way those who have to take advantage of Section 15 of the Act.
The figures I have given here after actual inquiry, a limited investigation if you like, indicate that in this large City of Dublin the Act is administered fairly, justly, and equitably, as between the individual who can afford to pay something and the general community that has to meet the deficiency if he is not able to pay the full cost of his treatment.
It is not unusual for us who are in public life to receive many representations about alleged hardship, and alleged influence in the administration of statutory provisions. There may be a genuine hardship case where some aspect has been overlooked when it was being dealt with; but you will always have a very great number of people who believe that members of public authorities, members of the Dáil and Ministers are able to influence decisions in their favour, even when the merits do not warrant any intervention on the part of the public representative or the Minister. That is well known. We shall always get the man who believes that if he can get his case put by a Deputy or a county councillor he will be able to have the balance tilted in his favour.
That does not mean that because people come along and say this is what is being taken as the general universal practice we must not be careful in these matters. We must draw a very clear distinction in our own mind between what is told to us by an interested party and what we can ascertain by actual investigation. Therefore, I am quite satisfied in relation to Dublin, and I am reasonably satisfied in relation to the rest of the country, that the maximum charge is seldom imposed upon any person who has to have institutional treatment.
Comment on this
I want to remind the Minister who has just concluded on a note of sweet reasonableness that he is not the man who spoke a short while ago against the amendment which I put forward. I tabled the amendment in accordance with my rights as a Deputy of this House. It was intended to be helpful to the Minister and the House. It was intended to prevent what I regard as an injustice being imposed upon the workers throughout the country and upon small farmers.
The Minister was pleased in his reply to impugn my motives in putting down that amendment and suggested that my purpose was to make the administration of the health services under the Health Act more unpopular. He was pleased to suggest that I was in some way opposed to the administrational services under the Health Act of 1953. I will not yield to anyone in this House in relation to the actual work I did as Minister to provide that these services would operate.
As Minister, I accepted in full the need for the services under the Health Act and I made it my concern to see that they were not merely promised but were provided. It is because I am firmly convinced that the Minister is acting impetuously and hastily in this Bill that I have endeavoured in some way to prevent some of the injustice that his Bill proposes falling upon sections who are least able to meet it. The Minister in a very airy way talks about different examples. I would not blame Deputy Dr. Browne thinking the Minister meant in his reply that a shopkeeper who earned £599 a year was a person of affluence and standing.
I am quite certain that an insured worker who falls sick cannot afford to pay £3 10s. per week. I do not care what inquiries the Minister may make, or what information the Minister may have at his disposal, the fact is that such a bill cannot be met and the proof comes from the Minister's own mouth. With regard to the 6/- per day charge on workers in this city and throughout the country in the past 12 months under the Health Act of 1953, the Minister says that fewer than 25 per cent. pay. Of course fewer than 25 per cent. pay because fewer than 25 per cent., according to the Minister, are proved to be able to pay. This is 25 per cent. of the eligible persons under Section 15.
In the name of Heavens what is the sense of this Bill? Is it to charge that 25 per cent. more? Surely we should recognise that the 6/- a day has been proved difficult to meet, particularly I suggest where a worker becomes ill. I did not suggest that he would lose his employment but his wages may cease and that worker, on the Minister's figure, is unable to meet the charge of two guineas per week. I think it is asking this House to be more than patient to suggest that when the record of 12 months had shown that only one person out of four is able to pay 6/- that, therefore, the solution is to charge everybody 10/-. That is certainly arguing ad absurdum but those are the Minister's own figures.
Without having the information ready to me that the Minister has, I know from my experience in different parts of the country that, in fact, this discretionary charge of 6/- per day is sought in every case unless the person is a holder of a medical card and, therefore, demonstrably entitled to free medical services or unless the person concerned is otherwise entitled to free medical services under the Health Act. In the first instance, the full hospital charge of 6/- per day is demanded. It then becomes a case of who can convince the strongest in order to see what the bill may be settled for.
Certainly the people who complain to me are not persons interested in it but rather persons who are interested in the general administrational services. They tell me, in fact, that in most cases the money sought is secured. I think it is a pity that we are not enabled to discuss this amendment. I do not say the amendment is perfect but it is an effort genuinely conceived to ensure that a hardship would not be imposed. I think it is a pity it cannot be so received by the Minister.
I think it is absurd that we should have the Minister bringing blue shirts and all the rest into this debate. What are we here for? Are we going to get any sanity in our discussions here? My motives were genuine motives, designed to ensure that the administration of the health services in this country would proceed normally and rationally and that a Minister merely for the sake of some budgetary consideration would not proceed to impose that potential charge or tax which in many cases might mean considerable hardship.
When the Minister proceeds to reply to my proposals and say that what I say is nonsense, because practically no one is paying this charge, anyway, the Minister is answering himself in the most effective way. In fact, it is proposed to raise £180,000 by this Bill. That is not chicken feed—£180,000 as applied to all the eligible classes under Section 15, holders of medical cards who remained and who represent 30 per cent. of the population. It is proposed to raise £180,000 from those people and from the small charges imposed for specialist services. In fact it is expected—I believe the Minister knows it—that the majority of entitled persons under Section 15 will now pay 10/- instead of 6/-.
I have no ready figures available to me but I know that to raise some £180,000, or something less than that, on hospital services alone, will certainly mean that over 2,000 hospital beds in this country will be occupied for the year by patients who will have to pay 4/- extra. I do not believe it is taking this House properly into his confidence for the Minister to advance a whole number of different grounds in defence of this proposal. Either this is a measure designed to save the taxpayer and the ratepayer a total sum of £180,000 or it is not. If it is aimed at saving £180,000 then it is certainly designed to ensure that the majority of persons entitled to hospital services under Section 15 will pay henceforth 10/- per day instead of 6/-. That seems reasonably clear. But the Minister is not prepared to say that. He is quite content to bat on different kinds of wickets. If he is faced with that charge, he says: "Very few people paid this charge up to this. Therefore, there is no injustice." If that is so, this Bill is completely unnecessary.
If so few people up to this are paying 6/- per day, why is it necessary to consume the time of this House with this unnecessary legislation? Why all this trouble and why add further to the difficulties I hoped might be over by bringing in legislation which is going to be effective only for a very small percentage of those against whom it is aimed? I think that would be a reductio ad absurdum. Therefore, I do not believe it and I am quite convinced that this is intended to be a genuine charge.
The Minister knows it is expected that this charge will yield £90,000 to the Exchequer by way of a saving and the same amount to ratepayers. If I am incorrect in that, I shall be interested to see the manner in which the Minister's Estimates are framed for next year. I shall be interested to see whether a saving will be taken to this extent in the administration of health services next year. I am certain such a saving will be taken because the Budget statement of the Minister for Finance takes that saving already. There is no question of any conjecture about it. The framework of the Budget is based on the fact that this money will be saved and, whether the Minister for Health likes it or not, he is told by the Minister for Finance that £90,000 must be provided by way of saving under this heading. Therefore, what is the sense in coming in to meet this amendment and suggesting it is not necessary, that these charges will not be imposed, that they are not imposed and that, in fact, only a small section of the community is affected?
I put down these amendments. I believe in them. I made it clear both in Government and since, in opposition, that I am firmly convinced that some increase in charges might be necessary under the Health Act for those who might be regarded as able to pay. I would only have done so if an alternative means of providing for their own health services were available. The Minister does it now.
The Health Insurance provision may be available in the near future but it is not available at the moment. The Minister does it without attempting to segregate who can and who cannot afford it. This amendment is designed to ensure that the charge will not be a general one and that those whom a Deputy of this House can in the short time available try to distinguish in some way may not have to pay.
Deputy Dr. Browne supported some of my arguments in proposing this amendment. I was somewhat horrified to find him saying that my arguments were pointing in a direction in which certainly they were not intended to point. I should hate to think that anything I have said in this debate or on the Second Reading, or anything I am likely to say on health services, could ever be regarded as a support for the theory that any person in this country, irrespective of his means and standing, is entitled to free health services. I do not subscribe to that view. It is a degenerate view and one which is contrary to our character and outlook in this country. It has always been part of our tradition here—whatever may be said of other people—that we like to pay our way and stand on our own feet. I have no sympathy whatsoever with those who think that health services in this country and our health problem can be solved by establishing some paternal State that will look after all of us from the cradle to the grave. Once we embark upon that, we shall end in doing nothing.
Free health services are never free. They all have to be paid for eventually. I should far prefer to see encouraged amongst our people a spirit of self-reliance and a belief that each one of us, to the extent we can, would attempt to solve our own problems. It is because I believe that this kind of proposal in this Bill may eventually lead to more supporters for Deputy Dr. Browne's views that I am so concerned about it. The administration of the Health Act has been difficult. It was a new Act and a difficult Act dealing with many complexities. To my bitter cost, I know how easy it has been to magnify difficulties to quite an unwarranted degree.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy would agree that we should not open the question of the administration of the Health Act.
Comment on this
Perhaps, in passing from it, I might be allowed to say it is a pity that, under the Minister's proposal, a great number of people who were entitled to benefit under Section 15 of the Act will now believe they are being unfairly treated —that they have to meet a fresh charge when they have only begun to be accustomed to the idea of a charge at all. That may have the inevitable result of a feeling of irresponsibility and a feeling that the proper solution is no charge for anyone, irrespective of what his standing, position or income may be.
I think that would be a considerable disservice to our people. I would say very sincerely to the Minister that he should reconsider the stand he has taken on this amendment, that he should regard it, if he feels free to do it, as an amendment designed to help him and help the administration of services here and designed to prevent an injustice which I believe is taking place. He should accept the amendment and accept the principle behind it.
Comment on this
Some speakers have given the impression, whether they intended to do so or not, that the Bill proposed by the Minister would extend to other people the charges now being made under the Health Acts. They gave the impression that a bigger number of people will now be subject to these charges. I do not think that is intended in the Bill at all. What is to be considered is that the people who are now deemed to be able to pay up to 6/- a day may be deemed, after the passage of this Bill, to be able to pay up to a maximum of 10/- per day. Deputy O'Higgins said that where before only one in four was considered to be able to pay, now everybody would be made pay 10/-. I do not think that is intended in the Bill at all.
It is a spurious argument to say, as Deputy Dr. Browne said, that because a small group only were liable to pay, therefore, they are not well able to pay. It is no indication at all of the capacity of a person to pay his debts to say he belongs to a small group. It must be clear that if a man heretofore was deemed by his local authority not to be able to pay up to a maximum of 6/-, he will be deemed now not to be able to pay, even though the maximum is 10/-. Therefore, these people will not be asked at all. I do not know whether that argument was put forward on purpose; I hope it was not.
I think it unfair to suggest that, because these charges were accepted in principle in former Health Acts and are now being increased, the time may come when charges in the fever hospitals and tuberculosis hospitals will also be made. It must be clear that there is a public responsibility in relation to infectious diseases. It serves the public well to pay for the individual's care and isolation in the case of infectious diseases. Therefore, it is and must be regarded as a public responsibility. As the present Acts, which are being amended, relate to the individual responsibility, the public responsibility does not enter to the same extent. It is most unfair to suggest that the Minister's action now is paying the way for making charges in relation to infectious diseases and maintenance in hospitals.
Anybody who has argued against the Bill has made sure that he did not refer to the charges which could be made as being maximum charges, and he certainly did not give any credit to the local authorities for their administration of the Acts. The only change is in the maximum amount payable. There is no change in the number of people to be affected. Certainly the poor are not to be affected by this. This House seems always to land on top of the poor when arguing against anything. The people to be affected by this Bill are those who are able to pay. They will not be a further burden on taxation, to which the poor subscribe. Therefore, it is exactly the opposite of attacking the poor.
Comment on this
I want to put myself on record here as being opposed, first of all, to the Bill and also as not supporting this amendment by Deputy O'Higgins. Personally, I am against the idea of these charges. I shall not speak at any length on many of the points raised here by Deputies on both sides. The only important point that emerges is the absolute agreement between the Minister and the ex-Minister on this question of policy. As far as this is concerned, they are absolutely at one. It does not make the slightest difference who sits on the ministerial bench at the present time. I have often used the expression, "Tweedledum and tweedledee" but on this occasion I think I will say that the Irish people are caught between the devil and the deep sea. It makes no difference whether it is Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil, when it comes to health services or any other services.
This amendment is to ensure, according to Deputy Dr. Hillery, that those who can now pay 6/- per day for hospital services will pay instead 10/- a day. Mark the philosophy of people who bring in that type of legislation. Those who are ill are to pay more for their treatment while those who go to the races and gamble will have to pay less in taxation. Is that not an extraordinary outlook in this civilised, Christian community?
The Minister has stated that a sum of £180,000 will be saved, on a 50-50 basis, perhaps, to the ratepayers and to the Exchequer. The purpose of this measure—let us be quite blunt about it—was to save that. It is a form of taxation, if you like. It is saving the Exchequer handing out a further £90,000. We have that type of weak legislation in the same Budget in which the colleague of the Minister for Health, the Minister for Finance, says to the Turf Club and the Racing Board, "Here you are, gentlemen. I will not charge you £140,000 this year for stamp duty. That is the figure I took off you last year. I am handing it back to you this year." When it comes to gambling and driving around the country in big motor cars for the luxury of race meetings, we find that the imposition on those gentlemen last year, in the form of special stamp duty, had to be removed in the Budget. It was removed silently. There was not a "peep" out of any Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches when it came up. While that is being passed, we have at the same time the case put forward that those who are ill must pay more for treatment.
Deputy O'Higgins expressed himself as horrified that some of the arguments put forward by him would add to the case made by Dr. Browne for the complete removal of these charges. If Deputy O'Higgins takes time off next week to read the debate and read his own contribution, he will see quite clearly that, if there is any logic in his approach to it, that is where his argument would lead. There is only one way out of the difficulty these people have been led into over health services and that is to get rid of all these charges. In the long run, it would be a lot less expensive than setting up a horde of officials, inspectors and investigators to examine into the very private concerns of every family in the State. This type of legislation demeans and attempts to demoralise the community.
The amendment put forward here by the former Minister is a further attempt to demean and demoralise the rural community, with a further limit in connection with the 25 valuation. The extraordinary situation was that the Minister himself put forward the best argument against Deputy O'Higgins's case, that if we accept his suggestion about the £25 limit for the farmer, it will mean further investigation, more inspection and possibly an increase in the number employed on these inspections. That is the argument put forward by the Minister.
The fact is that home assistance officers and investigation officers are going full tilt all over the country, examining the credentials and accounts in connection with people under care in hospitals. There is an army of those officials at present and I do not want to see that army added to.
Deputy O'Higgins is very fond of telling the House that the Irish people are self-reliant. The Deputy is able to stand on the backs of the 750,000 who have left the country and who are glad to get the socialised health services available outside this country. I suppose he is critical of the large sections of the Irish population which he and others helped to drive out, owing to his lack of responsibility and that of others, in regard to their duties, whether in office or not.
Comment on this
I do not know, but I will do my best, at any rate, to expose the hypocrisy and sham which goes on here in regard to health services.
Comment on this
A point was raised by the Minister that there is no proof that the local authority will extract the full pound of flesh in connection with these increased charges. The simplest way to deal with this, to assure the House that such will not be the case in future, is for the Minister, if he has not the figures available, to get the figures from all the local authorities and tell us the total percentage in the country who paid this 6/-. Perhaps that is not a fair question to ask and maybe the Minister has not the figures at the moment. They could be made available and he could give an indication as to where county managers said: "I find this applicant not able to pay 6/-; I will charge him 4/-." Has the Minister got evidence that county managers have varied that charge in the country? I should like to know that, as it is very important, since the decision, the implementation of any legislation like this, is to be left to the individual county managers —they are the health authorities.
There is no use in pretending here that it is the members of the local authority who will decide the charges, whether 10/- or 6/-, when this becomes legislation. The final decision in all these matters lies with the county manager. He is the health authority, the sole health authority. A county manager is only a human being and I do not think there are two human beings so alike that the manager in Kerry would adopt exactly the same ideas and methods as the manager in Kildare or Laois, for example. It is quite possible that in certain areas the county managers will administer the health services in a more reasonable fashion than in other areas. I think that is unfair on the community as a whole, as it does not give equal opportunities and fair treatment to all the citizens of the State. The treatment is being meted out on a basis which depends on whether the manager is stupid, generous or a crank. It is left to him to decide. The local authority, in the sense of the members of the county council, have no discretion in the matter.
Apart from all that, the former Minister was a member of a local authority—I do not know if he is now— and will realise that, as a result both of the Bill and of his amendment, if accepted, more work will be imposed on the ordinary members, that is, the county councillors. They will receive further representations from their constituents requesting that such and such a hospital bill be reduced or cancelled. Many people now have reached the stage where they cannot believe that the local authority will deal fairly with their problems, unless they get representations made on their behalf by members of the local authority itself. This type of legislation will create further havoc in that respect. More and more people will go to their representatives looking for the exercise of "pull" in order to get a bill reduced.
Comment on this
I think the Deputies who talk now have not the foggiest idea at all of what local authorities do. It is beginning to dawn on them now.
Comment on this
I do not accept that, but I would like Deputy O'Sullivan to realise that in his own constituency members of the county council every day get representations from persons who were in hospital to have the bill reduced—whether they are farmers, shopkeepers or anything else.
Comment on this
The amendment says that if the valuation is more than £25, you may be charged 10/- if it is less, you cannot.
Comment on this
The amendment is aimed only at dealing with what may be charged. You cannot be charged if your valuation is under £25.
Comment on this
I am quite aware of what is in the amendment and I know, as far as it is concerned, there is no such statement in the Bill or the amendment, to suggest that "must" is the operative word. That is not suggested. The word "may" can be as emphatic as "must" with many county managers. That is what I want cleared up, in order to get it into the county managers' heads that "may" does not mean "must". Representations have to be made to him very, very strongly at times on that particular line; and I am not anxious that further representations should have to be made to any county manager to have that clarified for him.
I would not like to be taken as pointing a finger at the county manager in my own constituency in this regard. I have discussed this matter with members of the local authority in various parts of the county and I have found a great deal of satisfaction amongst those members with the manner in which the county manager has interpreted various sections of the Health Act. The amendment is certainly not going to make the position any easier. I want to have it on record that, apart from some of the considerations in the Bill itself, I am on principle against the amendment as being impracticable and unworkable.
Comment on this
Deputy McQuillan has tried to put it across that the acceptance of this amendment will mean additional administrative expenses. I think the Minister could inform Deputy McQuillan that a person must provide a certificate as to the extent of his valuation. I support the proposal of Deputy O'Higgins and support it following consultations with some of my constituents over the week-end. They agree that this would be an equitable thing to do. They cannot see, if the Minister must in his budgetary considerations this year save £90,000 on the health services, why any farmer of £5, £6 or £7 valuation should be required to pay the same increase as a farmer of £45, £46 or £47 valuation. Surely that is clear to those who claim——
Comment on this
The Deputy must not have been listening to Deputy O'Higgins, who argued that many of the farmers with a £50 valuation are as badly in need of service as those in the group referred to by the Deputy.
Comment on this
I doubt if Deputy O'Higgins used those words. I am speaking generally; I am not talking about specific instances. Even if one went above that figure, one could find people above that valuation in rather unusual circumstances, but speaking of the class in the £25 to £50 category, if there is to be a saving, would it not be better that it should not extend to those under the £25 valuation? When the Minister is tightening up, it is certainly unfair to require those on the lower valuations to meet the same additional charge as those in the higher valuations. For that reason, many of us support the amendment.
Comment on this
Listening to this discussion, it seemed to me at first as if some of the people who were talking wanted to have it both ways. At the time of the Budget, the criticism was that the Government was not taking action uniformly over the community and the implication was that the better off people should have been made to pay and should not have shared in any advantage. That was the whole case against the Budget. When I came in here, it seemed to me that this case was made in certain quarters where it is now considered that what the Minister is doing is designed to balance in favour of those who cannot pay and to call upon those who can pay. The opposite argument is being invoked; in other words, certain people are trying to have it both ways.
When it comes to general discussions on the Budget they talk about favouring the rich. When a provision is brought in which enables an equitable scale to be provided then, because there is uniformity for everyone, the opposite cry is raised and frankly I came in to deal with that particular problem. But now it seems to me that on this particular amendment the issue appears to be one which is in some respects a matter of mechanics. It is apparently agreed, as between the principal Opposition speakers and this side of the House, that it is equitable to bring about a situation that people who can afford to pay, that is genuinely afford to pay, should contribute in order that the facilities and the funds will be there to provide the necessary contributions and, if necessary, free service for those who cannot afford to pay. That is the simple principle that is involved in this amendment and this discussion, as I see it.
We have a situation where the Minister envisaged, and apparently the movers of the amendment envisaged, contributions by those who can afford to pay and, of course, those who cannot afford to pay, or who are found not to be in a position to pay, will be catered for as heretofore. Therefore, it seems to me that the net issue in this amendment is the one as to how to do it. It seems to me that the proposal of the Minister is the simpler one as the machinery is set up.
I do not wish to weary the House with a re-examination of the mechanism of the health schemes. I think the mechanism is probably open to criticism in many regards but for the moment, in order not to widen the discussion, I accept the mechanism as we have it. Is it not the more direct simpler thing to do what the Minister has done? That is to raise the level to embrace a greater number with a capacity to pay than previously. I could understand many of the arguments that have been put forward on the basis that it was a mandatory question, if it was a question of making everyone pay 10/-, but let us not get away from the Minister's proposal that the charge may go as far as 10/-. It simply means that a person who was well able to pay 10/-, and probably more, has hitherto been only called upon to pay up to 6/-. After that the person who can and could afford to pay more than 6/- can be called upon to pay up to 10/-. That is all that is in issue in this amendment. Anyone who cannot pay 10/- or 6/- will not be in any worse position than he was. I think it is important to grasp that point.
Therefore, the situation is simply this. On the Minister's proposal, anyone who can afford to pay will pay in accordance with his ability to pay, up to the limit the Minister is fixing. The only effect of this legislation is to cover more of the well-off class who were supposed to be getting so many benefits under the Budget, than were covered previously. In other words, the people in the well-off classes, the rich people and the better-off people, about whom we heard so much in the Budget, who were heretofore exempt from paying anything over 6/- per day will now be called upon to contribute according to their means and, logically, if one applies the same arguments as were applied to the Budget in this particular instance, then the case is made.
As against that, Deputy O'Higgins's proposal becomes one of mechanics. I am not very experienced or competent to judge in detail the question of mechanics and I shall not, therefore, go into detail. From experience on this side of the House and some experience on the other side of the House, it is the generally accepted practice here for Oppositions to bring in counter-proposals to those put forward by the Government. These proposals are considered but invariably the Government refuses to amend its proposals because, with the knowledge and advice available to it in the various Departments of State, it has come to the conclusion that a certain process is the most efficient, most economical and just way of operating.
Comment on this
I am putting this as an argument. I do not give it as an overriding reason. Let the Deputy be reasonable. Very often if an impartial observer—and, like the reasonable man, it is impossible to get an impartial observer—were to watch the deliberations here he would probably discover that, when it is a question of mechanism as against a question of principle, the Minister is more likely, because of the advice available to him, to have the more workable solution. In the course of his argument Deputy O'Higgins made constant reference to lack of figures and lack of information and qualified his statements because of the non-availability of figures and information as far as he was concerned. That is understandable. We have all been in that position. In modern times, with complex administration, one has that difficulty. I advance that as one argument in favour of supporting the Minister's view since we are now clear on principle.
I shall hark back now to what was said by Deputy Hillery, who has considerable knowledge of these matters. He said that there is misapprehension. That is quite true. This is not a question of raising the charges. It is simply a matter of raising the ceiling and it will only be the better-off classes that will be affected, thereby enabling us to make more provision for those who cannot afford to pay.
Deputy McQuillan made several points about the mechanics of the health scheme. I do not propose to go into that at the moment. Rather wide issues are involved, though I believe there is a good deal to be examined into so far as the mechanism and so forth of the scheme are concerned. Deputies in Dublin City in recent years have had private representations and complaints about the administration of health services. Questions have been raised which make any thinking Deputy wonder whether all the legislation in relation to health has been as beneficial as it was hoped it would be in certain directions. Undoubtedly in other directions, and here again Deputy Hillery's remarks deserve to be emphasised, there are certain aspects in which there is a real public interest in health.
I do not suggest that in all health matters there is not an interest, but there are certain aspects in which there is a more immediate public interest, such as in infectious diseases and tuberculosis. So far as they are concerned, a considerable amount of good work has been done, particularly in relation to tuberculosis. The scheme has worked satisfactorily.
Comment on this
I am talking now more of what one might describe as ordinary sickness. I am not talking about tuberculosis or fevers. For the moment I prefer to leave it at that. I prefer not to be specific. Where the general hospitals are concerned there is concomitant with their overall problem a financial problem. Generally, the situation is not as happy as one would wish.
Comment on this
Perhaps I am wandering but the point I am trying to make is that, accepting the principle, it is equitable to seek contributions from those who can afford to pay and by raising the level, as the Minister is raising the level here, we are merely bringing in those who at the moment are not paying what they can afford to pay. That is only fair.
Comment on this
I do not like to interrupt but, on the point made in relation to those who, the Deputy says, can afford to pay, why not then be logical and make them pay the full cost of treatment instead of just 10/-? Why stop at 10/-?
Comment on this
Logic is difficult to define and the words "logic" and "logically" are sometimes used to prove something which is not logical. The Deputy's point is another day's argument. I accept the system as it is. Deputy O'Higgins and the Minister accept the system. The Deputy would open a much wider question which it may be no harm to examine at another time and in another place.
For the moment I simply say that it is equitable to make those who can afford to pay, contribute. Since the machinery is already in existence and since that principle is already in operation, the Minister's proposal is a reasonable one. Probably it is the best proposal in the circumstances notwithstanding Deputy O'Higgins's proposition. I think the preference lies with the Minister's proposal because it is more adaptable to the system as it is. It is equitable in principle and it will involve less adjustments in machinery and probably cause less complication in its implementation than the relatively novel suggestion that has come from the other side.
Comment on this
The Labour Party will not support this amendment since we consider that the only way in which we can express our views is by opposing the section as a whole. Notwithstanding what the Minister has indicated as the results of his investigations in Dublin, in the country generally the maximum charge of 6/- per day has been implemented in practically every case where the middle income group is concerned. It may be true that the man or woman earning £599 10s. can pay something more than the person who is just barely over the medical card group or the home assistance group. It is quite possible that certain sections can pay and that the line must be drawn somewhere but this proposal will mean that, no matter how small may be the amount over and above the sum the county manager fixes as entitling one to a medical card, the county manager will in future charge such people this additional 4/- per day.
We believe the 6/- per day has been charged, but the Health Act has not been long enough in force to get a fair trial. We feel this is just an economy measure, a method of balancing the Budget. We have pointed out—I think I actually said it on this section in the original Bill—that the Labour Party recognised the danger of the Health Bill not being a contributory scheme where the member had statutory rights, that it was subject to the whim of any Minister who any time he ran into difficult times, could immediately increase the charges. Our words are coming true. The difficult times are there and the charges are being increased. It is not a question of natural rights or a question of ethics of any sort. It is just a question of economy and needs be.
We feel, as the Labour group, that our section of people, no matter what the Minister says, will have to pay this increase of 4/-. No matter what goodwill the Minister has and no matter what good intentions he has, there is no right of appeal against the county manager's decision. If a county manager decides that a person not holding a medical card must pay that amount irrespective of his means, he will have to pay. Consequently, we cannot support the amendment, but we must oppose the section when it comes up.
Comment on this
I do not think that either the Minister or the Department knows what is happening down the country. If an unfortunate person who had to go into hospital was told he would have to pay 10/- a day, he would be the happiest person in the world. I have before me a certain case which I will instance for the benefit of the House. A widow with 28 acres of land of a poor law valuation of £25, living in a part of the country known as Ballymacoda, went into hospital. This is the bill she received: treatment from 4th April to 16th May, £31 10s., use of operating theatre, £2 2s.; surgical expenses, £33 14s.; X-rays, etc., £7 odd. The total was £77 5s. 8d., less Health Act contribution, £25 4s., leaving a balance of £52 1s. 8d. for 42 days in hospital.
This woman's relatives came to me. I told them to pay 6/- a day and no more. They had great difficulty in getting the woman out of hospital on the payment of £20, that is, £7 8s. more than they should have paid under the Health Act. They were informed that, unless the other £32 1s. 8d. was paid within seven days, the matter would be placed in the hands of the hospital's solicitor. I intend to hand this bill over to the Minister when I have concluded so that he may deal with it.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy say was it a local authority hospital, or what kind of hospital it was?
Comment on this
A Cork hospital. Apparently the local authority and the State had to pay that hospital £25 4s., but the unfortunate woman with the 28 acres had to pay them £52 more. We members of local authorities are well aware that the charges have been trebled since those people found they could knock anything out under the Health Act. Unless patients go into hospital with the toes coming out of their boots, they will have the doctor saying to them: "What about my feel?" and I know of at least nine or ten cases where the doctor was paid fees in addition to having his whack out of the Health Act.
Comment on this
The Deputy should come to the amendment instead of traversing the administration of the Health Act.
Comment on this
I want to know whether under this Bill that woman with the £25 valuation is entitled to free treatment in hospital on payment of 10/- a day. That is a fair question and the unfortunate people down the country want to know the answer. I do not intend to go into the manner in which the Health Act has been administered. I can tell the Minister that there are thousands of people working on medical cards at the present time——
Comment on this
I shall have another opportunity of going into it and I shall present cases such as I have dealt with now. I want the Minister to say whether or not a farmer on a £25 valuation holding is entitled to free medical treatment and hospital treatment at 10/- a day.
Comment on this
The general trend of the speeches on both sides of the House seems to be that people who can afford it should pay and that any other view is a degenerate one and contrary to the character of our people. I do not think any case has been put forward to substantiate that point of view, and it is such a serious thing for a responsible former Minister and an existing Minister to say that I find it difficult to let it pass without some comment. It is such a fallacious point of view that one finds difficulty in believing that anyone could conscientiously or honestly hold it.
However, assuming the view is conscientiously and honestly held on both sides of the House that everybody must pay and that any other view in respect of health services is contrary to the character of our people, then the correct thing for these people to do—Deputy O'Higgins and, I think, Deputy Hillery and the Minister—is to pursue that to its logical conclusion, and alter the existing free services of one kind or another which are made available by the State to the community. Indeed, I would challenge the Party in opposition or the Government to find out whether this attitude to free services is contrary to the character of our people. The fact is that 1,000,000 of our fellow-Irishmen in the Six Counties are at the moment using a completely free health service and, as far as I can see, in no way resent the fact that there are these services there. I do not think that they are acting in any way that could be said to be contrary to the character of our people.
Will the people who hold these views, conscientiously believe them, put forward the idea, in order to find out whether our people are in favour or against free services of one kind or another, that all the existing free services be ended?
Comment on this
Unfortunately, in order to try to deal with the point which has been put forward by both sides of the House.
Comment on this
Neither was I, but, unfortunately, it was put forward. However, I shall not deal with it to any extent except to suggest that the logical conclusion of their argument is to amend the existing free services, tuberculosis services, the various infectious diseases services, primary school free services that people are getting who, presumably, can pay for them, children's allowances, farm allowances of one kind or another. Does the Minister propose to change all these in order to bring them into conformity with the character of the Irish people? I bow to your ruling, a Cheann Comhairle. We shall probably have another opportunity of dealing with it, but it is, quite clearly, an interesting point of view.
Comment on this
The suggestion was made, mostly by Deputy Major de Valera, that this was merely an attempt to do good by stealth, a sort of Robin Hood act, to rob the rich in order to pay for the poor people who could not afford these services. On the contrary, I think the general principle involved is robbing the poor in order to pay for the commitments that the Minister for Finance has made to various other wealthy sections and in that way I do not think that the argument is a valid one at all. It seems to me that, if there is any need to raise charges at all, these charges can be raised, but raised in relation either to rates or taxes. In that way you can get an increase in the money required from the people who are best able to bear that burden.
The suggestion that free health services are never free, of course, is true in so far as the services have to be paid for in taxation of one kind or another but taxation is so designed to bear as equitably as possible on the people who are paying that taxation. I believe that there is the nub of the whole antagonism in this House to the extension of free health services of one kind or another, particularly in this context.
These are all hypocritical arguments about the poor who cannot pay. I think they are concerned about the wealthier sections who do not want to pay more increased taxation. Let them confess to that and admit that. Indeed, I must concede that to the Minister. He did concede that he was worried about the increased taxation but that is a more honest argument than the argument of Deputy Major de Valera that the Minister is trying to take the money from those sick persons who are able to pay in order to pay for the health services of those who could not afford to pay.
Indeed, all Deputy Major de Valera's arguments about the equity of taking from people who can afford to pay, the people paying 6/- now who could afford to pay 10/-, and in that way save the poor person who could not pay, have been put forward before, I think largely by the Opposition, when Fianna Fáil were trying to bring in free health services, as arguments against the extension of free health services. It usually in the past came from the Opposition side of the House. Fianna Fáil, up to very recently, of course, opposed that and brought in the legislation which they did bring in.
For the life of me, I cannot see why any issue should be involved here in relation to whether a person pays for a service directly or in taxation. If the contention is true that no free services are really free, then, of course, if anybody is worried about somebody getting something for nothing, his argument is met because presumably everybody who can pay pays taxation so that everybody who gets these services is paying to the limit of his ability to pay.
I do not think that that is the most important argument. The main argument that I have on this whole question is a medical argument, that these free services are better services; they give better health services. That is the most important argument, not socialism or anything else. They give better health services. These arguments in relation to taxation are old arguments that have been put forward since the beginning of time in relation to the extension of any social service of any kind to the mass of the people, to the underprivileged generally, and up to very recently they have been answered, by the Fianna Fáil Party at any rate, in ignoring them. Consequently, it is all the more regrettable to hear Deputy de Valera putting them forward now.
In the midst of Deputy Dr. Ryan's most vehement fight to put the 1953 Health Act through the Dáil I remember in a moment of great frustration he accused the Opposition of being bloody frauds and bloody hypocrites.