Committee on Finance. - Health and Mental Treatment Bill, 1957—Committee Stage.
Contributions 146–290 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1957 ›
May I say just one thing before the Minister concludes? I know we are all free to think, but I do not know whether any of those in the House who are free to act could have been in any sense convinced by the arguments advanced here by the Minister. Deputy Major de Valera said—I do not know whether he had studied this matter before he spoke—that the Minister's proposal was a simple and easy way of making the better-off sections pay for benefits under the Health Act. He seemed to suggest this was merely a matter of mechanism. I wonder was he serious in saying that? Of course the Minister's proposal is simpler and easier to administer because it hits all sections under Section 15. I am certain it might commend itself on the ground of its simplicity.
My proposal, I know, errs on the side of being more cumbersome, perhaps, more difficult to administer— although I do not believe that—but its object is to prevent an imposition falling uniformly on all sections under the Act irrespective of whether they are able to meet it or not. It is an effort to do a bit of sifting to ensure that under Section 15 only those better able to afford it will have to meet the increased charge which the Minister thinks is necessary.
Had I my way, were it open to me, in proposing the amendment to this Bill I would oppose the charge imposed by the Minister in its entirety. That course was not open because the principle of the Bill was accepted by the Dáil on the Second Reading and therefore we must start from the fact that it is the view of the Dáil that increased charges for these services must be provided. Starting from that, I have endeavoured in this amendment to ensure that these charges will be as limited in their application as possible having due regard to the view of the Dáil that some increases are necessary.
I think it was Deputy McQuillan who said that this amendment would result in further investigations as to means and so on. I do not think he could have been serious in that. At the moment, in order to qualify under the Health Act farmers must demonstrate that their valuation does not exceed £50. If they have to produce their poor law valuation certificates that in itself demonstrates whether or not their valuation is above or below £25. There is no added difficulty in regard to that. If they are farmers in the sense contemplated under the Health Act, if they depend on farming, the production of their poor law valuation certificate entitles them, if it is less than £25, not to be charged the increase proposed by the Minister.
Again in relation to insured persons, no investigation as to means is involved. Once a person is insured even for a day under the provisions of the Social Welfare Act, under this amendment he is entitled to be shielded from the increase proposed by the Minister and no investigation as to means is involved. So far as administration is concerned it is simple. A farmer whose valuation does not exceed £25 or any insured person is entitled under this amendment to get the same treatment under the Health Act of 1953 as he was entitled to get before the Minister introduced this Bill. Therefore, I would suggest that the amendment—it may not be perfect —should be accepted. I think the principle of imposing this taxation in present circumstances for budgetary purposes is wrong but as we have to accept that principle, at least it should be our concern here to seek to ensure that a bit of legislation, conceived, I believe, impetuously, should not be allowed to have a very harmful effect on many sections that should not have an increased burden imposed on them.
May I add that it has been suggested here, and the point has been made by the Minister, that these are discretionary charges? Of course they are, but Deputies will realise that under Section 15 there are certain categories of persons who are given a statutory right or entitlement to services. There is also a general category of people who are entitled to services if they demonstrate that they are in hardship. I must say, again from my experience, I find that since these services came into operation scarcely 12 months ago, generally speaking, in the first instance an effort is made to get from those who may be charged, the full hospital charge of 6/-.
I fear that now the effect will be the same, that the full charge of 10/- per day will be sought in every case. I do not say it will always be paid because I know well, since I believe in this amendment, that in a great many cases it cannot be paid because the money is not there and, in fact, if the section remains unamended in the Bill, the health authorities throughout the country will be involved in more administrative trouble because they will be inundated with representations through public representatives asking that bills of, say, £3 10s. or so be reduced because, for example, the worker involved by reason of his illness lost his wages and is unable to pay.
I am certain that when reasonable cases of that kind are made to health authorities deductions will in fact be given and that the bill will be written down. I am certain that in many cases it will be written down to nothing, but it seems to me quite wrong that we should, by our legislation here, impose a burden which may not be charged merely for the sake of uniformity. In my opinion it would be far wiser for the Minister to recognise the facts now and realise that when a worker becomes ill his source of income ceases; he is unable to pay a hospital bill and he should not be asked to do it.
Again, it is only reasonable the Minister should realise that farmers with a valuation of less than £25, whatever case may be made for their being asked to pay something, are not in a position to pay 10/- per day for themselves or for their dependents.
Comment on this
I do not want to delay the House very long, but I think that in the interest of the discussion which has been taking place as to whether or not the Minister's proposals in this Bill, which the amendment is designed to ameliorate, will affect many or few people, it is worth while placing on record the reply which the Minister gave to a question on this subject last month. On 14th May last, Deputy Declan Costello asked the Minister if he would state the number of persons who, it is estimated, will be affected each year by the proposed increases in charges and the imposition of new charges in the health services outlined in the Budget speech.
The Minister replied that an estimated 17,000 persons would be affected in a single year by the proposed increase in charges for institutional services. The remainder of the Minister's reply dealt with the new charges for specialist services. I merely want to point out that, in my view, 17,000 persons cannot be dismissed as just a few people. According to the Minister's estimate, 17,000 people will be affected by the increased charges imposed by this Bill. On that occasion, Deputy Dr. Browne asked, by way of supplementary question, if the Minister could give any indication of the total amount involved. The Minister's reply was: "At a rough guess, between £70,000 and £90,000."
I assume that the Minister, in giving that reply, was thinking in terms of the saving to the Exchequer only and not of the saving to local authorities. The figure mentioned here earlier this evening was that the total, as between the ratepayers, on the one hand, and the taxpayers, on the other, would be about £180,000. I should like to continue with what the Minister had to say on that occasion—May 14th last— because it is interesting to know that a Deputy from the Minister's Party thought fit to ask a supplementary question. Deputy J. Brennan asked: "Is the Minister aware that there is a tendency on the part of the county managers to charge the maximum fee in each case, irrespective of means, in the middle income groups?" I have no doubt Deputy Dr. Browne would be interested in the Minister's reply to that. The Minister said: "I regret to say that my information is to the contrary—that in many instances county managers are reluctant to demand all they might legitimately require."
It seems to me to be quite clear from the Minister's reply to Deputy Brennan's supplementary question that as far as the Minister's attitude on this question of charges is concerned, he has left his views on record. His views are that he regrets that the information he has is that county managers are reluctant to demand all they might legitimately require. As far as the Minister is concerned, I take that to mean that, if he has any say in it, he will see that county managers will demand everything to which they are legitimately entitled under the provisions of the Health Act and of this Bill, which will go through when the Minister mobilises his forces behind him.
Comment on this
Because of the continuous obstruction of certain people, I cannot reply to Deputy Corry. I can only say I will have the matter he raised investigated.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:—
In sub-section (1) (b), line 24, to delete "shall" and substitute "may".
The purpose of this amendment, which deals with the charge sought to be imposed for specialist services under Section 1 of the Bill, is in some way to prevent this charge falling where perhaps the person seeking the service is unable to pay for it.
I draw the attention of Deputies to the wording of the proposed new sub-section (5) in the Bill. It provides as follows:—
"Where specialist services are made available under sub-section (1) of this section for a person who is not a person specified in sub-section (2) of Section 14 of this Act and who is not an in-patient in an institution, there shall be charged, on each occasion on which the services are provided, such charge as may be specified by Order made from time to time by the Minister...."
In other words, the effect of the Minister's proposal is to remove any discretion from health authorities and to provide that each health authority must impose a charge in respect of specialist services for each eligible person who is not an in-patient in a hospital and who is not a holder of a medical card.
I would remind Deputies that this proposed amendment is quite contrary to the principle of the Health Act, 1953. Whatever different arguments may have been put forward on behalf of the Health Act, 1953, or against it, the one thing that was clear and recognised was that specialist services were being provided free for all eligible persons, whether or not they held medical cards or whether or not they were entitled to free general practitioner medical services. They were all, under the Health Act, entitled to free specialist services.
The Minister's proposal now is aimed against that principle. It is aimed at imposing a charge and I would remind Deputies that this charge is not a discretionary charge. It is not a charge that may be imposed. It is a charge that shall be imposed on every person who seeks henceforth to avail of the specialist services as an out-patient in any of the local authority or other hospitals with whom health authorities have arrangements. I want Deputies to have regard to this. I understand it to have been accepted policy that no person should be denied needed medical care and attention because of lack of means. At least to that extent, we were all taken to have agreed and at least in that regard I would have found myself in agreement with Deputy Dr. Browne and others.
Here now is a proposal, however. The charges may not appear to be significant, but it, nevertheless, is a proposal which says that the health authority shall not henceforth be under any obligation—in fact, may not—to provide specialist services for eligible persons, unless the sum designated by the Minister is paid. That appears to me to be a most remarkable departure from what we were told represented the policy and the aims of the Health Act, 1953.
The Minister told us in his Second Reading speech that the charges he proposes to make will be 7/6d. in respect of an X-ray and 3/6d., I think he said, in respect of the first visit to a specialist and 2/- in respect of each repeat visit. Those charges, depending on the way one looks at it, may not appear dramatic or significant, but they will appear quite a heavy burden to a worker who becomes ill. He may not have to go to hospital, but he is unable to work. He sees his doctor and his doctor tells him that he had better go to hospital to have an X-ray. He then cannot get his X-ray, unless he provides a sum of 7/6d., and if it is in Dublin or elsewhere, neither can the health authority, under the administrative proposal, provide him with the facilities because it is obligatory, under the Minister's proposal, to impose this fee or payment.
Again, the amendment I have suggested is not designed to attack the principle of this Bill since that was accepted on the Second Reading. It is designed to prevent a hardship being imposed, perhaps not intended, but a hardship on persons who are sick and are poor and who require specialist services. The amendment is a simple one. It is designed to give to health authorities a discretion to enable them to impose a charge, if they so wish, since that is the principle of the Bill and also enable them to refrain from imposing a charge, if they so wish. I think it is reasonable and proper and in accordance with the view we all have of the need in the case of the individual of specialist services. No one should be deprived of those services merely because he has not got in his pocket a few coins to jingle.
Under the Minister's proposal, if a person requires an X-ray and has not got three half-crowns in his pocket, that is the end of it. He cannot get it and the health authority cannot give it because there stand between him and the X-ray three half-crowns. I am certain that, upon reflection, the Minister will agree that that is not a desirable state of affairs and that he will agree with me that in relation to these ser vices a discretion should be given the same as is elsewhere provided under the Health Act.
Comment on this
The Labour Party will have to continue to adopt on this the attitude they took on the previous amendment of not agreeing to vote for it. Our attitude is that no charge should be made. It is true that this amendment seeks to give a discretionary power, but our attitude and belief is that where you give a discretionary power, the maximum has always become the minimum and "may" becomes "shall". There is no difference whether the word is "may" or "shall" inasmuch as, in the administration of the Act, the 7/6 will be charged. We do not want to be misunderstood and we do not want it implied that because we did not vote for an amendment which said "may" or "shall", we admitted there was some case for increasing the charges.
Our attitude is that the Health Act should be left as it was. We feel that an alteration that will worsen the position of the middle income group— which, in general, is made up of the ordinary working people of this country—is a deliberate attempt to save the Government, and possibly taxpayers, money. It will be done at the expense of the working people—those who can least afford it. Consequently, while not voting for the amendment, we shall oppose the section as a whole.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins has put the case very fairly and forcibly. The Minister for Health must be well aware that in recent years, particularly in very recent years, we have had the pleasing state of affairs whereby T.B. is completely and entirely on the way out. I feel that that is due to the fact that people have had recourse to the X-ray so freely. Appeals were made by the Minister for Health and his predecessors to people to avail of the X-ray. Practically every doctor throughout the country will very freely advise a patient, after a severe chill or a heavy cold, to have an X-ray. It is the surest and safest manner of discovering any ill-effects after a severe chill or cold.
Can any person say it is reasonable to expect an old age pensioner or a recipient of home assistance to pay 7/6 for an X-ray? Consider the case of a person in receipt of unemployment benefit who requires an X-ray but who must pay 7/6 for it. Such a person will give first consideration to the household requirements even though the natural reaction would be to look after one's health. Therefore, I feel the collection of 7/6 for an X-ray should be left to the discretion of the local authority.
It may be argued that there is great danger in leaving such a decision in the hands of the health authority who, naturally, is the county manager. All county managers are not hard-hearted. I know of no case in which the county manager, as the health authority, deliberately turned down an application that had merit. Again, the chairman of the local authority always has recourse to the county manager, as have the members of the local authority, to put forward the merits of any case. If Deputy O'Higgins's amendment is not accepted, the local authority or even the county manager, no matter how willing he may be to give special consideration to the needs of the poorer sections of the community, will be placed in a very difficult position.
It has been pointed out that there are many people who will not have 7/6 at their disposal for an X-ray. It is unnatural and inhuman that we should embody a clause in our legislation whereby no person may have an X-ray except by paying 7/6. What will happen to the unfortunate person who has not 7/6 and who is in need of an X-ray? Perhaps the Minister for Health will answer that question.
There was a time when the present Minister for Health and the members of his Party loudly said that no citizen would be refused proper medical attention, specialist treatment or X-ray, for want of money. They have changed entirely from that viewpoint.
Comment on this
Surely Deputies know that not every old age pensioner has a medical card. I could supply a long list of old age pensioners in my constituency who have not medical cards. I am sorry that Deputy Loughman is not the county manager in my constituency because then perhaps quite a number of difficulties might be solved in so far as that matter is concerned. If an old age pensioner has a son or two sons who are road workers or agricultural workers in full employment he will not get a medical card. Now, even though he has no medical card, if he has not the 7/6 to pay for an X-ray he will have to do without it.
Comment on this
The old age pensioner who has not a medical card is a fairly good example to cite. Is he now expected to pay 7/6 for an X-ray out of his old age pension, not to talk of a second or a third X-ray? The relevant section of this Bill provides that he must pay. If the Minister for Health and his Party are as sympathetic as they pretend to be at election times towards the poorer sections I feel that, in fairness, this matter should be reconsidered.
The substitution of the word "may" for "shall" gives the local authority an option. When a strong case is put forward I find that most county managers, having investigated the financial circumstances of the aggrieved party and found that there is merit in their case, are reasonable. However, if the county manager, as the health authority, has not the law on his side to enable him to decide in favour of the aggrieved person I believe that the brunt of the difficulties will now fall on the person seeking the X-ray.
Apart entirely from old age pensioners, there are the people on home assistance. Then again, you also have people who receive home assistance to supplement very small incomes. When this Bill becomes law, such persons will be obliged to pay for an X-ray. I do not consider that that is right. I appeal to the Minister to accept this amendment which is reasonable. If there is merit in any particular case, the county manager may then make the decision about the payment.
If this section is enacted, many people will not avail of the X-ray service. The Minister for Health should be deeply concerned, as I have no doubt he is, with the health of the community. He should not, however, place obstacles in the way of citizens seeking to comply with the advice given them by their doctors in regard to X-rays. I can see a good deal of difficulty. If this becomes law, I can see that a section of the community, and no small section, will be denied the right of an X-ray. Most of us here can remember a time when all working class people could have free X-rays. It is not very many years ago at all.
If the amendment is not accepted, it can lead to a severe hardship on a section of the community. Are deserving people, who feel they are entitled to an X-ray, to be refused it because they have not 7/6 to place before the radiographer, the almoner or the matron of the hospital? Will the Minister explain what is the position of a person who has not got 7/6 for an X-ray? Is he to have a collection? Is he to ask his friends to contribute the three half-crowns? Does he expect such a person to go without an X-ray? Not everybody has 7/6 to spend freely, particularly in these times. I would like to know where the Minister expects such a person to get 7/6. Will the Minister give it to him? It is all very well to say that the poorer sections of the community, who have not got medical cards, are obliged to pay 7/6. If they have not got the 7/6, who is to give it to them? An X-ray may be prescribed, and their health may break down completely because they do not have an X-ray. I think there is at least a responsibility on the Minister to leave this matter to the discretion of the health authority. I hope he will.
Comment on this
I should like to support this amendment for two reasons. First of all, I am very largely in agreement with what Deputy Flanagan said. It is a question of collecting the sum. I am very dubious as to whether a sum that will accrue to the State for the purpose of balancing off the Health Act, which is already imposing a burden on the people without sufficient return for it, will be fully recouped. If it is not, and if the larger portion of the money is to be expended on administrative expenses, this does not seem to me to be a practical section.
As I said on the Second Reading, if anyone is sent to a hospital for the purpose of an examination, he goes in and maybe is examined by a consulting physician, if you like, or a consulting surgeon. He is sent by the local district officer, as he is now known— the district medical officer. There may be no thought in the mind of the patient, in the mind of the doctor who sent him or even in the mind of the surgeon who examines him that he has to have an X-ray. Deputy Flanagan has raised the point of who will pay the 7/6. Where will the 7/6 come from? Obviously, you cannot go out in the street and have a collection of 7/6 for Mr. X to have an X-ray. If not, is it then to be booked? If it is to be booked, it will mean further administrative expenses.
My objection to the 1952 Act and any subsequent legislation that may flow from that, is the fact that it was impracticable from beginning to end. It is a snowball in the collection of administrative expenses. I think this section in itself, and in fact every section in this Bill, proves that. I further object to it on the grounds that it further violates the relations that exist between doctor and patient. I know, of course, that some Deputies will object to that, but there has always been a relationship between doctor and patient, a confidential relationship, that seems to be entirely abolished in this case. An X-ray may not lead to very intimate details, but it ploughs through the whole function of a State Health Act in any shape or form that every import you have to put on, every charge you have to make, will lead subsequently to an investigation.
Those are my objections to this. They are a few of many. In every section of the Act, in every part of health legislation you deal with, you come up against the same thing. If Deputies go to a doctor they do not want everybody to know what is wrong with them. They do not want their private affairs made public. That is what happens with State legislation and for that reason I am opposed to it. Therefore, I will have the pleasure of voting for this amendment.
Comment on this
This amendment is designed to alter the definite character of the section proposed by the Minister. A certain amount of play was made, in arguing in favour of this Bill previously, on the grounds that it was permissive legislation, that it simply permitted the local authority to charge up to a maximum of 10/- and so on. With regard to the matter we are dealing with now, there is no question of permissive legislation. By the Bill which the Minister is proposing the imposition of these new charges is being made mandatory. The amendment is designed to alter the mandatory character of the Minister's proposal, or at least mitigate it to the extent of making it permissive.
I think, in ordinary courtesy to Deputies, the Minister should give us an explanation if he will not accept the amendment, particularly having regard to the arguments which have been advanced from his own side of the House that one of the merits of this Bill is that it is simply permissive legislation. There is nothing permissive about this. If the Minister feels, in regard to the increase in the charge from 6/- to 10/-, that there was some merit in leaving it permissive, as something that the health authority might or might not do, surely the same argument can be made in favour of the amendment which has been proposed to make the imposition of these new charges permissive also?
I did not hear the proposer of the amendment, but certainly the arguments which have been advanced by Deputy Flanagan are arguments which the Minister should, in my view, endeavour to answer, if he can. Quite apart from anything else, as a matter of courtesy to the House we should hear from the Minister, if he will not accept this amendment, why he will not accept it.
Comment on this
The arguments put forward by both Deputy Flanagan and Deputy O'Higgins would lead any neutral observer to think that it is wrong and inadvisable to have any charge whatever in connection with X-ray services. It would be simpler, from the point of view of administration and easier and less costly, if such a suggestion as that indicated by Deputy Flanagan were adopted. He mentioned the case of an old age pensioner who did not happen to have a medical card and pointed out that quite possibly under this measure the old age pensioner would be required now to pay for an X-ray if an X-ray is recommended for him. That is correct. What has rather surprised me, and what is disturbing to the public, is that there are so many Deputies who are not aware that under the provisions of the Health Act such is the case and that Deputies in the Fianna Fáil benches who interrupted Deputy Flanagan have shown a complete lack of knowledge of the administration of the Health Act.
Comment on this
I am referring specifically to the old age pensioner who does not happen to have a medical card and who must be charged 7/6 under this measure. For the information of the Deputies on my right, there is a large number of old age pensioners in this country who do not hold medical cards.
Comment on this
Deputy Galvin and Deputy Loughman from Tipperary were very vocal in their interruptions on this matter. They should be aware that income has a bearing on the issue of medical cards. It is clear that those who have interrupted have no knowledge whatever of how the decision is arrived at when a medical card is being issued. That is a very serious situation, because it shows that a Minister can, with sufficient backing of Deputies like those, bring any type of legislation through the House successfully, with that sufficiency of members who do not make themselves familiar with the proposed legislation. If the Minister is logical in his approach, he should accept this amendment by Deputy O'Higgins.
In case any one misunderstands my position, I want to make it quite clear that I am against any charge whatever, having taken that line all through the health discussions here for many years. My action in connection with this is to say: "A plague on both your Houses." I do not intend to support this amendment myself personally. I intend to vote against the actual section when the section comes before us for adoption or otherwise.
I want to show the fallacy of the arguments which are being put here at the moment. On the previous amendment the Minister argued that county managers or local authorities were not unreasonable and he felt the managers would be reasonable in the interpretation of legislation passed here. In taking up that line, he said that it was "permissive"—I think that is the word he used—and that there was enough scope in the legislation to allow discretion to the managers where hardship might be involved. Why did he find it necessary to leave discretionary power to the manager in certain aspects and why now in this particular portion make it mandatory? It is no longer permissive and the permission is not allowed there to managers to vary it. "You must", and that is all there is to it.
The charge is to be 7/6 for an X-ray and at this stage it is ridiculous for the Minister to bring in legislation to try to enforce that. The man who has not the 7/6 must get the X-ray. I agree with Deputy Esmonde that you cannot go outside and have a collection for an individual.
I would prefer to see agreement here on health services, on the basis that the best possible services be made available for all our people, rather than take the line of thought of some Deputies, that nobody should be deprived of treatment because of lack of means to pay for it. That may sound a plausible approach, but one interpretation of it could be that we can degrade certain sections or lower them to such an extent that they will be getting certain services only at the whim of others. Such legislation is undesirable. It has been in effect for many years and we do not see the end of it in the present measure.
I am perturbed about the case of an individual who has not a medical card and is not entitled to it and who may need an X-ray. In the words of Deputy Flanagan, he may have had a heavy cold and then be advised to have an X-ray. Is it suggested that that individual or a member of his family will have to pay for it? If so, the position is even more serious than people outside would believe it to be. One of the greatest advances made here in recent years was the triumph over tuberculosis. That was achieved by cutting all the red tape; whether you were the richest or the poorest in the State did not matter. The poorest person got exactly the same service as the rich and there was no question of means test or degrading inquiry as to how many eggs the hens laid in the year.
If we are to revert to the old system in operation prior to the 1947 Act, the position is more serious than even the most reactionary Deputies believe. I should like to have that position cleared up. If we are to interpret from what we read, the implication is that the result will be an increase in those likely to suffer from tubercuculosis. If a man is told to get an X-ray within a certain period and fails to get it, the result may be tragic for him and his family. In three or six months he may have to undergo prolonged treatment at heavy cost to the State and the community. If the necessary X-ray was taken in time the cost of treatment might be negligible. Very often any tendency such as this may mean that the individual may postpone taking the X-ray and the result will be serious for himself and the community as a whole. I should like to have that position clarified to make sure that that cannot happen if, and when, this measure becomes law.
Comment on this
May I put this aspect of the case to the Minister? Apart entirely from the old age pensioner who has not received his medical card, there are school medical examinations which take place frequently. If there are four or five children attending school, and their father is unemployed, and if they are supposed to have X-ray as a result of the examination, does the Minister not consider it too much to expect the unemployed father to be obliged to pay 7/6 in respect of each of those four or five X-rays? I feel that this is too important a point for the Minister to remain silent. The old age pensioner without his medical card is a case which is one of many throughout the country and, as has been asked earlier to-night, is a person who has not got 7/6 to do without the X-ray?
I think the Minister is treating the House with a considerable amount of contempt on a very important issue because as Deputy McQuillan has said, the X-ray may be the means of saving the life of the person concerned. Again an X-ray in time may be the means of saving a whole family from an infectious disease. I think the Minister, in accordance with the reasonable manner in which Deputy O'Higgins has put forward his amendment, supported by Deputy Dr. Esmonde who speaks from his own knowledge as a doctor, cannot get away with remaining silent when a case of so great importance and calling for the most sympathetic consideration is put before him. I should be glad if he would make a statement on the matter to clear it up.
Comment on this
I am accused of treating the House with contempt. I do not treat the House with contempt but I do treat with contempt the arguments I have just heard from Deputy Flanagan and the proposer of this amendment. I do not know whether Deputy Flanagan is aware of what is contained in the Health Act, or in this Bill, but I can assure him that there will not be any interference with the present position for those who are covered by sub-section (7) or Section 15 of the principal Act. Nobody is going to interfere with the present system whereby any person who wants to avail of tuberculosis services can get an X-ray free of charge, nor will the Bill change the position in respect of any child who is receiving treatment arising out of a medical national school inspection. Those matters are not affected by this Bill but they are being trotted out by the Opposition in order to becloud the issue.
Another person referred to was the old age pensioner who had not got a medical card. Let us see what sort of old age pensioner has not got a medical card. It is quite true that there are some old age pensioners who have not got medical cards but they are old age pensioners who are in rather peculiar circumstances. If the Deputy had looked it up he would have seen who they are. They are persons who are not entitled to a medical card because of the provisions of sub-section (6) of Section 15 of the 1953 Act which says that when the yearly means are being calculated they must include the yearly means of any unmarried son or daughter of such person concerned, where the son or daughter is normally resident with such person.
Deputy Flanagan knows the type of old age pensioner excluded by that. He knows that it is an old age pensioner who has assigned a farm and made a covenant whereby he would be entitled to accommodation, maintenance and upkeep. The valuation of the farm may be £100, £120 or £150. That is the type of person that Deputy Flanagan wants this House to believe could not raise 7/6 for an X-ray.
Comment on this
He can come, as is often the case, driving in his motor car to draw his old age allowance. He can pay 5/- a gallon for petrol but not 7/6 for an X-ray, according to Deputy Flanagan. Is there any use using schoolboy, debating society arguments in a serious issue of this sort? Deputy Dr. Esmonde referred to the person who goes to see a doctor and the doctor says that he requires an X-ray. Then this poor patient trots down to the out-patients' clinic and presents himself there. He has to trot down to it because, according to Deputy Dr. Esmonde, he has not got the wherewithal to pay his bus fare.
Comment on this
These are fanciful objections. The cost of an X-ray to the health authority is very much more than 7/6 and the cost of specialist's advice is very much more than 3/- or 2/-. They are not recurring charges; they are not going to recur in the sense that they will be daily charges in the same way as the charges made for institutional charges. They are exceptional charges which will arise in exceptional and rare instances, in the great majority of cases. I do not think it a great hardship to ask those who want to see what they look like inside, or who want to avail of the best advice available, to pay this moderate fee. After all, so far as specialist advice is concerned, they would pay more for a packet of cigarettes.
Comment on this
What kind of a packet of cigarettes would cost more than 7/6? Talk sense. They may be 7/6 before the Minister leaves office. That is not a dirty gibe; that is a statement of fact.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan should simmer down. He should relapse into the silence which he used to maintain on these benches.
Comment on this
I can assure the Minister I am very comfortable here. I am more comfortable here than the Minister is where he is.
Comment on this
Let the Deputy become the sort of dumb quadruped to which Deputy Dillon once likened certain people in this House: just be silent and listen. I do not say the cost of the X-ray would be little more than the price of a packet of cigarettes. I said that taking the specialist's advice would be less than the cost of a packet of cigarettes. Perhaps the X-ray might cost as much as two packets of cigarettes; but, damn it all, if the X-ray is going to help him to preserve his life, surely the community is entitled to say: "Well, give up a couple of packets of cigarettes for one week at least." All this talk about a man not having three half-crowns to jingle in his pocket is so much claptrap. Seven and sixpence is 7/6. Of course it is; it always was. The fact of the matter is it is equivalent now, as I have said, to about 50 cigarettes. I do not smoke, but I think that is about the price.
Comment on this
All a man has to do, if he wants to have an X-ray and if he does not come under Section 14, is to deprive himself for a short period of 50 cigarettes.
Comment on this
That puts all the pathetic case made on the other side for this amendment in its right perspective and that is what has to be done, if we are to get this country out of the mess in which the Coalition has landed us.
Comment on this
I am not surprised the Minister took so long to get on his feet if that represents the manner in which he refutes the arguments advanced on behalf of this amendment. The amendment is a simple one. It should certainly call for a simple reply, if there is a reply at all.
I do not suggest that a charge of 7/6, or any other charge, may always be impossible to bear. I can assure the Minister that there have been, there are and there may be in the future some people so reckless as to spend their three half-crowns on 50 cigarettes —if 50 cigarettes cost that much. There are some people so unfortunate as to have no means of income. There are some people who may have to spend the three half-crowns on buying 2 lbs. of butter—less than 2 lbs. of butter under the Minister's Government's proposals in the Budget. Whatever the reason may be, all I have asked the Minister to do is to bear in mind that there may be people who have not got the necessary money. To such people, the Minister says: "Because you have not, you will not get any of these specialist services."
That is unreasonable; that is contrary to the policy of the Health Act. It is contrary to the underlying principle of the health services we have developed here. It is contrary to the slogan of the Minister's Party, the Party which asked the people to accept that health should not depend on wealth. It is contrary to common sense that we should, by legislation, say to certain people: "Because you have not got this money and cannot pay, you will not get any specialist services. You cannot be X-rayed."
All I have asked the Minister and the House to do is to say that the charge may be discretionary. These cases may not be many in number. The Minister may be right in saying that such cases may arise only rarely. All I have asked the House to do is to make this charge a discretionary charge and not a mandatory charge in all cases. Why should the Minister come in here blowing hot and cold? Why should he defend the increase proposed in the previous sub-section and say that there it is discretionary; it may be imposed or it may not be imposed? Why should he, then, in relation to this charge insist that in all respects it must be mandatory and no exception may be made?
I think that is an unreasonable attitude and I am astonished at the Minister. He should at least have undertaken to consider this amendment further. He must recognise that quite a number of people do not qualify for free medical treatment, who are not nevertheless in a position to pay even a charge as small as this. The administration of Section 14, as the Minister is aware, differs in different counties. Reference was made to persons in receipt of the full old age pension. When I had the responsibility that the Minister has now, I was informed that there were persons in receipt of the full old age pension who were refused medical registration. I thought that was wrong. I thought it was quite wrong that this State, under part of its social legislation, should regard persons as entitled to a full old age pension but not entitled to free medical services.
As the Minister is aware, I issued a circular to all health authorities advising them to register automatically persons in receipt of the full old age pension and certain other categories. The fact is that circular was not implemented by all county managers and there are counties in which persons in receipt of old age pensions, and not necessarily the kind of case the Minister has mentioned, have been refused medical registration. There are cases in which persons, who never owned a rood of land in their lives and who are in receipt of old age pensions, have been refused medical registration by certain county managers.
It all comes down to this: under the Minister's proposal, no matter what the means may or may not be, no matter what hard luck or ill-fortune may befall, a person who requires an X-ray, for example, cannot have it unless he pays 7/6. Neither can the health authority make it available to him, even though that authority may be convinced that he lacks the three half-crowns, through no fault of his own, because the Minister's proposal says that this charge shall be imposed. All my amendment suggests is that instead of the word "shall" we should insert the word "may", and it will then be a matter within the administration and policy of health authorities to impose a charge where they think it should be imposed, but they will have the discretion not to impose a charge where they are satisfied that such a charge would deprive a person of a service he requires.
Comment on this
I am surprised that the Minister has treated this very important matter with so much comedy. One would expect the Minister to treat this urgent problem with some seriousness. The Minister has pointed out that there is no person in need of an X-ray who would not be only too pleased to sacrifice two packets of cigarettes to see his inside. Those are the Minister's own words. There is no person who ever wanted an X-ray who wanted to see his inside, because if he did itself he would not understand it. It is the doctor who sends the patient for the X-ray who wants to study the X-ray. I feel that for a responsible Minister to have such a statement on record in the House shows complete disregard for the merits of this urgent and sympathetic case. He goes on to say that he will have no trouble finding the 7/6 if he stops smoking two packets of cigarettes. Assuming the person is like the Minister and myself and does not smoke——
Comment on this
If the person is like the Minister and myself, a nonsmoker, he then has to find 7/6, which means that he must do without a pound and a half of butter. Who has the easier task, the man who has to do without two packets of cigarettes in order to find the 7/6 or the unfortunate man who must do without the pound and a half of butter, or perhaps sacrifice a loaf of bread a day?
Comment on this
The Minister gave an example of how the person who required an X-ray could secure the 7/6 for it.
Comment on this
Yes. The Minister is very shrewd. It must be admitted that no man can paint a case to suit his own ends better than the Minister for Health. He gave an example of an old age pensioner who had not his medical card but who signed his place over to his married son or daughter with the reservation that he was to be given free keep, free lodging, and all the rest. Surely the Minister deliberately picked out this type of old age pensioner to suit himself? There may not be so many of those old age pensioners in the State. There is quite a number of old age pensioners who have no medical cards and who never owned a perch of land in their lives, who never had any assignments to make or anything to leave in a will.
As Deputy O'Higgins has pointed out, it is of the greatest importance that the House should now give special consideration to the fact that a person will be refused an X-ray unless he can place three half-crowns on the counter of the clinic. I asked earlier in the night where the person is to get this 7/6. The county council or the county health authority cannot give him the X-ray free. The local authority is prevented from so doing. Assuming the local home assistance officer, the local dispensary doctor, the local county councillor or the local warden, as the case may be, can certify that this is a person who has not got 7/6 for an X-ray, I submit that when this section is passed even though these various people, who are equipped with a first-class knowledge as to the applicant's circumstances, certify that this is a person who has not got 7/6 to spend on an X-ray and who needs the 7/6 to purchase the necessaries of life, not cigarettes or petrol as described by the Minister a few moments ago, that citizen is to be denied the X-ray which, as Deputy McQuillan earlier in the night pointed out, might be the means of saving his life.
One would have expected the Minister for Health to put up serious objections in this matter. Deputy O'Higgins's arguments are not unreasonable. All he is arguing is that it be left to the decision of the local health authority as to whether the X-ray is to be given or not. I believe that the Minister should accept the amendment because he knows from his own experience that the local authorities are extremely strict as to who receives home assistance or who is given any type of public assistance. He can trust the local authority. He can particularly trust the county manager and those given that responsibility to see that no person will be given an X-ray who is not entitled to it.
We are putting up the case of the unfortunate person who is prescribed an X-ray by his doctor and cannot pay for it. That is the type of people in whom we on this side of the House are interested. Will the Minister tell us, without bringing in any red herrings, if the person has not got 7/6 who will give it to him? He cannot have the X-ray unless he has the 7/6. Is that person to carry on without the X-ray and is that person to ignore the advice of his doctor? Surely the Minister will see that the section of the community that is best entitled to obtain an X-ray free will get those facilities.
If a patient who is sent to the clinic for an X-ray and is refused the X-ray, returns to the doctor, naturally enough, there is nothing further the doctor can do for the patient. The doctor has pointed out the importance of the X-ray and the patient not having had the X-ray there is no point in his reporting back to his doctor when his complaint cannot be diagnosed properly.
I am sure the Minister for Health can read an X-ray. Most of us with average intelligence, particularly if we ever had any dealings with or recourse to X-rays, can read one, but for the Minister to tell this House that a citizen is anxious to run off with 7/6 in his hand to get an X-ray for the purpose of seeing his inside is an unworthy statement to come from the lips of any responsible person charged with the administration of the Department of Health.
I would ask the Minister to reconsider this matter because there are many hard-working, honest citizens who will now be denied the right of an X-ray because of the provisions he is introducing and which he is asking this House to pass. While the Fianna Fáil Deputies may say what little inconvenience this will cause to the poorer section of the community, they do not tell us where the unfortunate person is to get the 7/6.
Comment on this
That is the question I have been asking the Minister since 7 o'clock and it is now 9 o'clock. Where is the 7/6 to come from? That is the kernel of the whole situation. If that question could be answered I am sure it would satisfy Deputy O'Higgins and other Deputies in the House and give a great deal of satisfaction throughout the country as well.
Comment on this
I think we have established that a person who has a medical card is entitled to a free X-ray.
Comment on this
I think that is established. The person around whom Deputy Flanagan built his case is an old age pensioner who, the home assistance officer, the dispensary doctor, the warden and the county council are satisfied has no money. Surely a person of that description is entitled to a medical card under any circumstances.
Comment on this
I am satisfied that such a person is entitled to a medical card and to argue that he is not is simply arguing for the sake of talk. All the reasoning that we have had this evening against this charge of 7/6 is based on very foolish grounds. There is no person who is as poor as Deputy Flanagan suggested who is not entitled to a medical card. I believe that, having a medical card, he is entitled to the X-ray.
Comment on this
I am very reluctant to intervene because I am not a member of a local authority. I welcome the intervention of Deputy Loughman. I do not know whether or not he is a member of a local authority.
Comment on this
At least he has experience of the administration of the health services in his own county. He has given a certain example which he says shows that there is no hardship. May I give another example?
Comment on this
This whole Bill is quite a serious matter for the people who are supposed to benefit under it. Let me give the example of the road worker who, say, gets £5 a week. He becomes ill and is ordered to have an X-ray. He is expected to pay 7/6. That may be all right for the first week, but, by reason of the fact that he has £5 a week—at least in my county—he is not entitled to a medical service card.
Comment on this
It may happen in Cork. That is my complaint about the Health Act, that the administration of it all over the country varies. This road worker with £5 per week becomes ill and, after perhaps two weeks of waiting, he gets his disability benefit, which amounts to 30/- per week. After he has attended a doctor two or three times, perhaps over a period of three or four weeks, the doctor decides that he should have an X-ray. The doctor does not decide that on the first visit. The man has lived on 30/- a week and if then he is ordered to have an X-ray, he is expected to pay 7/6 for it.
Comment on this
That is an argument that we put up when the then Minister, Dr. Ryan, was putting the Bill through the House. We were not listened to. He is expected to pay 7/6 for the X-ray.
Comment on this
Deputy Galvin will have an opportunity of making his case, if he wants to. Deputy Corish is entitled to speak.
Comment on this
I have given the experience in County Wexford and I can speak only for my own constituency. He is expected to pay 7/6, and, under this Bill, if he is ordered into hospital, he will be expected to pay 10/- per day.
I made certain inquiries about this and discovered that in my constituency the maximum charge is the usual charge. I asked a member of Wexford County Council staff, who assured me that the 6/- a day was the ordinary charge. The manager, or whoever administers the Health Act, never once used the discretion which the 1953 Act was supposed to have given to the manager. Members of local authorities are not absolutely blameless in that respect, in not insisting that he should use his discretion. Such a person is not deemed to be in the lower income group until he has been ill for six weeks or two months. That is my experience and I do not pretend to know either Cork City or County. I can speak about the County of Wexford and I know I speak for constituencies represented by some of my colleagues in the Labour Party.
The objectionable thing about this is not the 7/6 or the 3/- for the specialist service; it is the mean way in which the Government tax people who will be ill in order to get £90,000, the same Government as gave a total of £370,000 to the Racing Board and to the master bakers.
Comment on this
I should like to put another point of view altogether to the Minister, in the hope that he might reconsider the decision to alter the permissive to the compulsory charge and would consider Deputy O'Higgins's amendment. It strikes me that this proposition by the Minister is on a par with the mediaeval obscurantist window tax under which the more windows, the more ventilation and airiness you tried to get into your house, the more it cost you.
The very serious consequences of this proposition will be felt in the first instance by the doctor, the conscientious practitioner. I do not know if the Minister fully appreciates the position of radiology generally in health services. In making it difficult for a doctor to prescribe an X-ray picture for the patient, he will make a very big contribution towards restricting the use of the advances in radiological technique which can be of great help to the doctor and, of course, in that way, a great help to a patient. It occurs in other branches of medicine where a general practitioner is treating a poor person and he has a choice of two drugs, a very expensive drug which the patient cannot afford and a cheaper drug which he gives the patient. The cheaper drug takes longer, is not so certain, but, at least, it is in most cases effective. The patient is denied the advantage of the speedier and easier drug because of his poverty, but the patient survives in the majority of cases. These are things told to me by general practitioners. I have little or no experience of general practice myself. There are conscientious general practitioners who find that they cannot give a patient a particular medicine because of the cost, and so they give a substitute. In that way, they discharge their responsibility to their patient to the best of their ability in the circumstances.
The trouble about an X-ray picture is that there is no substitute for it at all and the doctor is in the position of either ordering an X-ray picture or not ordering an X-ray picture. I believe that one of the consequences of this provision here is that doctors will tend to become more chary, more nervous of ordering an X-ray picture for patients, the reason being that the vast majority of X-ray pictures are normal and it is only a minority which are abnormal. The general practitioner's trouble is that, if he orders a series of X-rays which he thinks are necessary and which are unnecessary, he has to tell the patient that the series of pictures, costing 7/6 each, are all quite normal and the time will come when the patient will begin to wonder whether the doctor is a fool in putting him to this unnecessary expense. Eventually, the doctor will have to be a very strong-minded man to resist the temptation to say: "Unless there is absolute certainty, I will not prescribe an X-ray picture."
I remember, in the days before chest radiology was free, that many times a general practitioner was very loath to put a patient to the expense of an X-ray picture for fear the general idea would get around that he lost his head immediately a person got a cough and sent the person for X-ray and the person had to pay. The result was that the doctor was eventually in that way—it was a subtle enough influence —frightened into waiting until the symptoms were so clearly defined that he hardly needed an X-ray at all in order to decide whether the condition was active or not.
I think there will be a tendency on the part of the doctor who does not want to cause his patients unnecessary expense to wait, but the trouble about it is that, as I say, it is an impossible situation. If you can tell that there is nothing wrong with the patient, there is no need for an X-ray; it is in the uncertain case that it is required. As I say, the majority of X-ray pictures are normal. Then the doctor will be faced with the prospect of ordering a lot of normal and costly X-ray pictures, or of withholding X-ray until it is probably too late to do any good. I think that is a probable serious consequence of this proposition.
There are other considerations. There are the cases of difficult diagnosis, the difficult early disease type of case, and medical-legal questions may be involved in cases where a person has been subjected to some sort of accident and will not be able to recover damages from an insurance company, a person who falls, for instance, in the ordinary way and probably hurts himself. If the doctor is in doubt as to whether there is a fracture or something like that which can be diagnosed by an X-ray picture, if he hesitates and does not get an X-ray in such a case—he may be concerned about the cost to the patient and he may hesitate to have the X-ray picture taken—then he is faced with the possibility of some medical or legal action for malpractice or something of that nature, because he has not taken the precautions the average medical practitioner would consider to be the normal precautions in such a case.
I think that from the point of view of the patient and the doctor, this is a very considerable deterioration in the existing situation. I think it must inevitably cause a deterioration in the standard of medicine, creating a situation where a doctor, with the best will in the world, may not be able to give his patient the best available treatment. It must also bring about the position in which the wonderful advances made in recent years in the medical field, particularly in radiology, will be denied to people merely because of the fear which the general practitioner will have in his mind on the subject of committing the patient to a whole lot of X-rays in the hope that out of the many X-rays which are normal, he may find one which is abnormal.
I do not think that is a dilemma which should be created. I think no regulation should be passed in this House which will restrict the right of the medical practitioner to use all the modern means at his disposal, including the many new therapeutic substances, in dealing with his patients. I think this proposition of the Minister does that, and I think the amendment mitigates it to some extent. As for myself, I believe there should be no charge at all for these things and for that reason I propose to abstain on this amendment and vote against the section.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister very honestly if he would answer a question when he is replying, if he replies at all. I shall read the particular section on which I am not quite clear. It says:—
"Where specialist services are made available ... there shall be charged, on each occasion on which the services are provided ..."
Does it mean that the fee is to be paid before the services are provided or are the services given first and charged for afterwards? If the latter is the case, I am not particularly worried, because if a person has not got the money, so long as the service is carried out, all they can do is try to get the money afterwards. Should it be the case, however, that the people will not get the service at all until they produce the money, that would be a desperate situation. I should like the Minister to give his views on which comes first, the money or the service?
Comment on this
My reading of it is that the money must be produced first before the service is rendered. I feel that Deputy Dr. Browne has made a very strong case and has put the merits of the case from an entirely different angle.
Deputy Corish has spoken of the road worker and has put forward a concrete case. I should like to refer to another section of the community, the forestry workers who are in receipt of £5 a week. When such a worker becomes ill and obliged to have an X-ray in the course of his illness, he will be receiving social welfare benefit. He is expected to pay 7/6 for his X-ray. The forestry worker will not have a medical card as a person in receipt of £5 a week has no medical card and is looked upon as a wage earner, not in the medical card category.
In the constituencies which Deputy O'Higgins and I have the honour to represent, there is a large number of forestry workers. We do not want to be faced with difficulties afterwards; we want to put forward our views to the Minister before the difficulties arise. Take the forestry worker who comes in without a medical card. He will be obliged to deprive his family of 7/6 every time he has an X-ray.
Another point that we want to have cleared up is this: assuming a doctor sends a patient for X-ray and that when the patient arrives to have the X-ray, it is found that the pictures have to be taken at different angles, may I take it that the one 7/6 will cover the visit, or does he have to pay 7/6 for each separate picture taken? I do not claim to be—and I am sure everyone in the House will agree that I am far from being—a doctor, but I can understand that an ankle, for instance, has to be X-rayed from various angles. If a patient is sent along with an ankle injury or with an injury to his knee-cap the ankle or knee-cap has to be X-rayed from various angles. Does this provision mean that 7/6 must be paid for each film used or that the one 7/6 will cover a number of films on the occasion of the patient's visit to the clinic?
I view this with the greatest possible seriousness. There may be people—I am not suggesting for a moment that there are—who would be anxious to help the Government to rake in this £90,000 and the moment a patient would appear for X-ray would say: "You will have to have four pictures or five pictures taken" or, depending on the awkwardness of the injury, a larger number of pictures. I want to know does the one fee of 7/6 cover the visit to the clinic or must the 7/6 be paid for each film taken?
Will the road worker, the forester or the old age pensioner who has not got a health card and who receives an injury have to pay 7/6 for each X-ray film taken? For instance, the collar-bone must be filmed from three different angles. Will the worker have to pay 7/6 for each of these three films? If four different films have to be taken of an injured joint will the worker have to pay 7/6 for each of these? I can see very clearly a difficulty arising in this.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan's speech seems to indicate that there is a peculiar situation in Leix-Offaly where the married forester does not get a health card. I am surprised to hear that a married forestry worker is not in receipt of a health card. There must be some peculiar law operating in Leix-Offaly. In my constituency of West Limerick we have married foresters and road workers all of whom are in receipt of health cards. I do not think Deputy Flanagan should shed too many tears or have any doubt whatsoever as to whether the people mentioned are entitled to free X-ray examinations. The section only asks the people in the middle income group to pay. A large number of people come for X-rays to the county infirmary in Limerick. If they are in the lower income group the X-ray examination is free. It is also free to those with chest complaints.
Comment on this
We know exactly what it costs us. In the Limerick County Infirmary, a voluntary hospital, we know that X-rays are costing an average of 30/- each to the institution. I do not think that we are putting an inordinately high burden on the middle income group by asking them to pay 7/6 for an X-ray examination. Deputy Flanagan talks about paying 7/6 each for films taken from different angles. That is a childish way of approaching this problem. Perhaps Deputy Flanagan wanted to have his banter with the Minister. The sum of 7/6 is not an extraordinary charge.
Comment on this
Take a farmer in the middle income group with a valuation of something like £50. He may be in receipt of a fat creamery cheque every month. Does Deputy Flanagan say that a charge of 7/6 to such a man is an outrage? Deputy Kyne asked a simple question as to whether the charge was made before or after the X-ray examination. It has always been the practice that the charge is made after the examination. In my county if it is found that the person cannot pay, even though he is in the middle income group, it is brought to the notice of the county manager who is the health authority and if there is a case of hardship the manager will remit the charge. Asking members of the middle income group who can afford it to pay 7/6 for an X-ray examination will not do any serious harm.
Comment on this
Is it not desirable that the Minister should say whether payment of the charge will be demanded before or after the examination?
Comment on this
I gather from the Minister's remarks that the purpose behind the introduction of this Bill is to relieve the Exchequer of a certain amount of expenditure. I agree with the sentiment behind his objective when he says the country is going through an exceedingly difficult time and that it will take general sacrifices on the part of the people before we can hope to regard ourselves as being in a strong economic position again. I am wondering if the Minister, in bringing in this Bill, is asking a certain section of the community to pay more than might be regarded as an equitable share of the burden.
This Bill does depart from the 1953 Health Act introduced by the Minister's own Party. The reason for that departure is that the Minister desires to save the Exchequer something like £90,000 a year. I agree with the principle that if a person can afford to pay for a medical or any other service he should pay; principally because by doing so he would give an opportunity to those who cannot pay to enjoy the same service. This country cannot afford to carry generally the standard of living which it has been enjoying in recent years. While some sections have been enjoying that standard of living, quite a substantial number of them have not been doing so because there has been an inequitable sharing of the burden, and I am afraid the recent Budget, to a very large extent, will result in that burden being still more inequitably distributed. I have already made that point in my contribution to the Budget debate and I shall not repeat myself now.
I agree with this amendment and I shall support it. I think this charge should be permissive on the part of the local health authorities. It might be true that a person in the category visualised by the Minister might be able to pay this small charge but what this Bill does say, in effect, is a very different thing. One cannot always say that on all occasions persons in the middle income group can afford to pay 7/6. I think a mistake has been made in arguing too strongly about the widow with one independent son. That family might have a good income. The son might be in a position to pay.
On the other hand, there are a number of people who are not entitled to medical cards, who are members of the middle income group and who are finding things very difficult. I do not think it would require a very active imagination to suggest that there are occasions when, to those people, a charge of 7/6 might be very difficult to meet. A person in the middle income group with four or five children might find it difficult at a certain time to produce 7/6. That person might be a non-smoker, already making heavy sacrifices for his family. I would suggest, therefore, that the amendment, which is a reasonable one, would get over that occasion. My experience is that the local health authority, in my case the city manager, gives a reasonable interpretation of these cases.
I would like to support the amendment proposed by Deputy O'Higgins. I do not think the Deputy has in mind savings to the Exchequer but it does do something towards making the burden a little more equitable and I think it is a reasonable amendment.
Comment on this
It is a great pity that some of the speeches that have recently been delivered here were not delivered at the outset of the debate on this amendment so that a person would have serious arguments to deal with. Let me take the arguments put forward by Deputy Russell. Before I come to deal with that, let me make it quite clear that no person who is in receipt of a medical card, no person who is entitled to the benefit of Section 14, is going to be affected by the proposals in this Bill in any way whatsoever. I want that to go home and to sink into the mind of Deputy O. Flanagan.
Comment on this
Yes, the Deputy has made a confession that he knew it. So did Deputy O'Higgins know it; but that was not the tenor of their speeches. They were talking about the poor man who could not pay 7/6, the poor man who did not smoke or do anything like that, who could not find 7/6; the poor man who is an unemployed person.
Comment on this
They kept on like that and the whole purpose was to mislead the House and mislead the country.
Comment on this
Let us stop talking about the people in the lower income group, though that has been made the basis of the speeches on the amendment. We are not talking about people in the lower income group but, as Deputy Russell has pointed out, we are dealing with those who are in the middle income group.
Comment on this
The Deputy wanted me to talk and I am going to talk now if he will permit me to without interruption. I was coming to the moderate, sensible, reasonable speech made by Deputy Russell. He asks why cannot we accept the amendment and leave this to the discretion of the local authorities. Let us see what is involved. It involves 7/6 for an X-ray examination, plus the first visit to the specialist and if there happens to be a return visit, as probably there would be, another 2/-. That is 12/6. That is the total sum involved and for the sake of determining whether a person can or cannot pay 12/6, we are going to have, as Deputy Dr. Browne called it, an inquisition into a man's family circumstances— what Deputy O'Higgins said was prying into his household affairs—instead of saying plainly and simply it is better to find this 7/6 and any other consequent specialist charges than to have this investigation into family circumstances.
We know that every self-respecting man would prefer to pay the 7/6, and whatever else would be involved, rather than have this examination of his means by a county manager or some person deputed by the county manager to undertake that investigation. Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy Dr. Browne want that sort of means test. I think that if a man is in the broad category of the middle income group and has not got a medical card he can without any undue hardship find 7/6. At least the vast majority of the people in that group can. There is no use in our legislating to meet the hard case. It makes administration impossible. It makes the cost of the service entirely expensive. There is no use in arguing from a case of the old age pensioner to the general case of the middle income group who are going to be affected by the Order when the Order is made. Therefore, I suggest to Deputy Russell that having looked at it in a practical way there is not any merit in this amendment.
I think that amendment was put down without any great deal of thought. It seems to have been put down on the basis: "Well, you have given the local authorities permission under sub-section (4) of Section 15 of the Act, then why not give them permission under sub-section (5)?" It is one of these things that are done without due thought, without trying to find out what the implications of it are. These are the implications of the amendment. If a man wants to have an X-ray you say: "Let him go and prove to the county manager that his family circumstances are such that they will not permit him to raise 7/6, and that his working sons and working daughters will not give him the 7/6, if he does not have it in his own pocket." Does that dispose of the whole talk about the three half-crowns and where they are to come from?
Comment on this
It is not really of practical importance. There is no use in having a means test after the X-ray.
Comment on this
It is a great pity I cannot get any good manners from there. I had to listen with a great deal of restraint to some of the foolish speeches that were made by Deputy O. Flanagan. Deputy Flanagan did not even read the section in the Bill and, not having read it, he ventured to inform Deputy Kyne what he thought the section meant. I say he did not read the section. If he did read the section, we would not have had the fascinating citations of broken ankles, broken necks, and the rest.
Comment on this
We would not have had that talk because the section says 7/6 in case of an X-ray examination and, when the radiologist is examining the patient, surely he will take as many films as he thinks are necessary. I say there is the answer to all of Deputy Flanagan's futile case which he has spent hours from 7 o'clock building up here to deceive and mislead the people. Have we settled that?
With reference to whether the payment will be made before or after, I have pointed out the futility of having an investigation of means in relation to this matter. Therefore, as far as I am concerned, I think it would be more convenient and, indeed, it would make very little difference to suggest that the fee should be paid in advance. It is not uncommon for many people to consult their own family doctor and pay in advance. Many people do that and a lot of doctors will allow the bills to run, but in any event what will happen is this: a scheme of payment has to be devised and this section permits the Minister to do that. It permits him to make an Order. He is not bound by the Health Act to table the Order, but the Order will be tabled in the House. All the details of that Order can then be subject to an examination, and any Deputy who wishes may put down a question in relation to it or raise the proposals in it on the Adjournment. At the moment, my feeling is it can be done without undue hardship. If we can devise a practical way of doing it, the fees would be paid in advance. There is no use having a charge for an X-ray and then, maybe, have to chase a man all around the country in order to collect the 7/6 from him. It would be much more convenient and much more economic to do it in the way I have suggested.
Let us get back to the other alleged hard case—the hypothetical case of the uninsured person out of work who may not have a medical card. This is one of the examples cited by the mover of the amendment. Of course, a person in the circumstances described could get a medical card immediately ad hoc. He would, of course, then be entitled to all the benefits of the services. The further we go into this matter, the more absurd appears to be the contention that an unemployed, uninsured person can be affected by this proposal. I have disposed of the lower income group. I have disposed of all the women availing of the maternity services and all the persons requiring X-ray examinations under the tuberculosis schemes. Accordingly, we are confined solely to those people who, being in the middle income group, have recourse to the family doctor, in the first instance, and are prepared to pay him his fee, in the first instance, before they are advised to have an X-ray examination.
This brings me to the case made against the section by Deputy Dr. Browne. I think the arguments which he adduced were no stronger than any of the arguments adduced by the other speakers to whom I referred. Deputy Dr. Browne, in my opinion, built up a highly fanciful case on the basis of the supposed reluctance of a general practitioner, himself treating his patient for a fee, to advise him to pay another 7/6 in order to have an X-ray. On what basis?—on the basis that most of the X-ray examinations did not disclose any abnormality or any condition which required treatment. Surely to goodness, most patients whose doctor felt it would be advisable for them to have an X-ray examination would be glad to have the reassurance which he feels when told that his X-rays were entirely normal, even at the cost of 7/6 for the X-ray.
I cannot see that the mere fact that a man will have to pay 7/6 before he has an X-ray examination which will enable his family doctor to diagnose his case more accurately will deter either the patient or the practitioner from advising him to avail of the service. It is just incomprehensible to me that that argument could be seriously put forward in this House. It would indicate that those who use it believe that the members of our medical profession are lacking in moral courage and in rectitude, since because they fear the X-ray will show that the patient was not suffering from any abnormality, they will hesitate to send the patient forward for such examination. I think I have shown there is no merit in this amendment and I hope that we will be able to dispose of it now, having discussed it for four hours.
Comment on this
The more the Minister speaks on this section, the meaner and the lower this Bill becomes. I feel that the payment of the 7/6 in advance is the meanest and the lowest piece of legislation passed in this House for quite a long time. It was even so mean that I am sure it shocked Deputy Collins who thought the 7/6 was to be paid after the X-ray examination. The Minister points out that it is easier to make them pay before than to have to chase people around the country to collect it. That gives one to understand that this will affect the person who has not the 7/6, since the Minister makes provision to have the 7/6 paid before the X-ray is taken. This is the lowest piece of legislation passed through this House, since the Budget, anyway.
Comment on this
When I expressed my surprise at the fact that the Minister answered my question in the way he did, I think Deputy Collins must be equally surprised. I knew, even when I asked the question, that Deputy Flanagan and the Fine Gael Deputies were under a misapprehension. To my amazement, the Minister indicated that so far as he was concerned at present, before a person who is not the holder of a medical card is advised by a doctor to have an X-ray examination, he must pay 7/6. I think the Labour Party took a right line in refusing to vote to amend the Act. We intend to vote against the section as a whole.
Comment on this
Would the person who could only scrape up 7/- and could not find the other 6d. still be refused?
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Minister's outlook in regard to the first amendment was that we should depend upon the attitude of county managers in dealing with the increase from 6/- to 10/- per day for patients. On the second part of Section 1 his attitude was that the county manager should not have the right to decide whether the charge of 7/6 should be put into operation. I suggest that these two conflicting ideas, one in one part and one in another part, indicate that this is merely an attempt to secure more money for the purpose of economising on Government funds.
It would be preferable if the Minister were honest and said: "Look, the county managers will do exactly what I tell them. I am telling them to increase the middle income group charges to 10/- a day in future; charge all X-rays at 7/6; make the charge for specialist visits at 3/- for the first visit and 2/- for every subsequent visit. That is my way of contributing to balance the Budget." If it were said like that, I could understand but it is being cloaked up and make to seem as if something good were being done for the middle income group and the ordinary working people.
We are opposing this section because we believe it is bringing about a worsening of conditions. It is going away from the Health Bill of 1953. Let there be no mistake about it. It is not being done with the intention of helping any section but it is being done with the intention of taking the load off the Government.
Comment on this
Section 1 deals with the parent sections, 14 and 15, in the 1953 Act. As I stated on the Second Reading, I am often asked by people: "Who is eligible for treatment under certain sections?" I want a definite ruling from the Minister whether a person, who has what is known as a health card, is exempt from all health charges whatsoever. I was specifically asked this question the day before yesterday. I was approached by a constituent who has a health card and who had to attend for specialist treatment at two separate hospitals. In both cases he has been sent a bill. For the purpose of getting it on the records of the House, I want to ask whether a health card exonerates a person entirely from all payments?
Comment on this
In matters relating to this code, I am as innocent as a child, but I have a fair experience of life in rural Ireland. My experience in the part of rural Ireland where I live was that, prior to the implementation of this whole Act, any poor neighbours of mine, if they fell ill, if they had defective sight or if there was something seriously wrong—anything that required to be done was done and if they were not able to afford to pay for it, they did not pay for it. Whereas those of my neighbours, whom we all knew were perfectly well able to pay for whatever attention they wanted, got that attention, and they got the bill. There was a fight they could all join in but, finally, they paid the bill. The neighbours knew perfectly well they were well able to pay the bill.
Now a situation has arisen in my part of the country where a person, whom I know perfectly well to have no means whatever, is suffering from rapidly failing sight. She attends at the local dispensary for specialist service, believing that there is now available to her something which she never had before. When she gets there she is informed by the specialist that there is a queue waiting which will occupy the doctor's time for the next four months and that, if she will get into the queue, he may see her some time next November. As a matter of fact, that is quite impossible because it is not impossible that the girl will lose her sight if she waits so long. Of course, some of us get together, take her down to Sligo and pay a specialist in Sligo to see her and will have her sent to hospital in Dublin, if that is necessary.
The impression I get of this section, and of the code, is that those who really want treatment cannot get it and that a great many people who ought to get treatment for nothing are liable, under this new arrangement, to be levied by the local authority in a sum that they will be extremely hard pressed to pay. I wonder would the Minister examine this whole question with a view to determining are the people who are entitled to get benefit getting it. Are the people who can afford to pay for it paying for it and are those who cannot afford to pay for it allowed to get it without being constrained to pay more than they can afford?
I do not claim to know intimately the circumstances in urban areas. Most of my life was lived in rural Ireland and anybody who shares my knowledge of rural Ireland will know that there are a great many people in rural Ireland who try to keep up the best appearances they can, but very often the burden of unexpected illness is wellnigh intolerable when it comes upon them. Their neighbours know it and, under the old dispensation, such cases were provided for by the fact that there was plenty of testimony forthcoming that, whatever the appearances were, these people honestly were not in a position to pay as a result of family responsibilities or something else.
There are also in rural Ireland lots of people eminently skilled in making a poor mouth. These are the people very often who get in at the expense of the person who appears to be well able to pay but who, in fact, cannot. I am not at all sure that the code as at present established, or as proposed to be revised under this, contains the flexibility that it used to have. This much is certain: whatever the reason— and I am not prepared to certify that we know what the reason is—before this health code came into operation none of my neighbours went uncared for.
Since it came into operation, very deserving cases are informed that unless they wait four or five months they will not get what they want. I do not think the proposal contained in this section will put right that wrong. I think what will happen under this new departure is that the present difficulties will be further excerbated—that the person who has to keep up a decent appearance and bear the burdens as far as he can will be soaked still further, while the skilled wangler in rural Ireland will do as well or better than he did before.
It would do this House no harm, if people do not feel free on the far side to testify here to what they themselves know of their own areas in various parts of rural Ireland, if at least at their own Party meeting or in the confidence of the Minister's room they would tell him whether what I say is true or false. I suspect there are many Deputies who know what I am saying is true. It would be a salutary step if someone would set his hand to putting right what is wrong, so as to secure that those who cannot afford the cost of the treatment the maintenance of their health requires, shall get it if needs be for nothing. I do not think that is happening now.
These are the people I worry about; these are the people for whom, in our own unorganised methods of the past, we were able to cater in rural Ireland. I ask Deputies on all sides is it or is it not true that, prior to the enactment of this whole health code, since the hospital accommodation was expanded to the point where we had room for everybody who required hospital treatment, five years ago, any poor labourer in rural Ireland could get treatment, and we would fight out afterwards whether he should pay for it or not? We who knew them were able to ensure in our own areas that those genuinely unable to pay were not made to pay. Is it or is it not true that at present many of those people are not getting the treatment they require and to which they should be entitled?
If that is the fact, is it not time the Minister, instead of authorising others to raise the charges on those who cannot afford even the charges at present levied, should address himself to the general problem of providing for those who want treatment and cannot pay for it—treatment that is at present being postponed in favour of treatment of those who might be able to look after themselves if they were required to do so?
Comment on this
As Deputy Kyne has said, we are opposing this section, and for a clear reason. We recall what was said when the Health Act was originally introduced and we in the Labour Party supported it. We remember the accusations by Fianna Fáil when in Opposition about the slowness of the then Minister for Health in introducing the various benefits set out in the Act. I can recall many prominent members of the Fianna Fáil Front Bench taunting members of the inter-Party Government about slowness in introducing those benefits. They suggested, even asserted, that the inter-Party Government did not intend to put into operation some of those specialist services. Now we are not even at the crossroads; we are back beyond the cross itself. Instead of enjoying the advantages provided in the Act itself when introduced, it is the other way round.
A Deputy from Cork spoke here to-night. I do not want to speak behind his back, but, as I am a colleague of his, he will not mind, as both of us are members of the one Board of Assistance. I give him credit for his activities on that Board of Assistance when he, in company with other members, including myself, had very good reason on many occasions to complain about the unsatisfactory system regarding medical cards and the examination of the means of applicants for cards.
In regard to a charge of 7/6 for an X-ray, I know myself—and perhaps I have reason to know—that sometimes one X-ray will not show a positive or negative result and three or four may be needed. For instance, a very common complaint in modern time is the stomach ulcer or duodenal ulcer, Now, an X-ray will show fractures or broken bones very quickly, but in some other complaints—as I know myself—three or four may be necessary. Take the case of the road worker cited by my colleague to-night. We all know of cases where a man may be at work and hoping for the best, knowing that if he gave up employment, maybe with the county council, he may lose his job—or, what is equally important to him, he may lose holiday pay on a Church holy-day if he gives up work for a period, to go for a medical examination. In his case, because of total family income, he may not be allowed a medical card. He must pay, first of all, for the services and advice of his local doctor, and then for the X-ray; and also lose a day's pay. Because he is not in the labour category under the Act, he may have to pay that 7/6 about which there has been so much said to-night. That is a common case known to members from Cork on opposite sides of this House to-night. We know also of the long delays—sometimes necessitated by circumstances—in the examination of the means of those persons, even when they apply for the card, prior to going for an X-ray, at a time when they must pay the 7/6.
Our views on this are well-known, but I want to put a final point to the Minister. In relation to the increase in hospital charges I have had cases myself. Every member of the House, I am sure, who is a member of a local authority meets cases very much similar in this way, of a man or woman in hospital who has been denied a medical card. In olden times, people in this country were known as saints and scholars. Whatever about there being scholars to-day, I am not sure about the saints. We know that, while the whole family income is checked by the local assistance officer it very often happens that the woman in the home, where she has a grown family, is not in receipt of the amount of money which the members of the family are supposed to be bringing in. We know that that happens.
It happens also that one member of a family wants to stand by a parent and very often has to pay for hospital charges for a parent; yet the other members do not pay their way. The Minister may come along and say that they should but the difficulty is that they do not. Under the present system when a medical card is denied to such people they are placed in the position of having an extra burden placed on them.
Finally, we are told that this in itself will mean a saving to the local authority. That may be but it is poor satisfaction to the person who now, under this measure, will be put in the position of having to pay more. It is poor satisfaction for a person to have to pay more, at the most critical period in his life, when he is ill, whether it is for an X-ray, specialist treatment or for hospitalisation. At the same time the person is quite likely a ratepayer. He must, on the one hand, pay more for his medical treatment and while on the other hand he may be told there will be a reduction in the rates, it is no reduction for him because of the extra charges imposed on him. We in the Labour Party say that the Health Act, with its limitations, was at least a step towards progressive legislation dealing with a very important aspect of national life. We supported it but we refuse to support, at this stage, any measure that will in any way qualify the benefits given then, benefits which apparently are being taken away now.
Comment on this
I just want to say a few words in regard to what Deputy Desmond has said. The Health Act, 1953, cannot have made any great difference to the lower income groups. The wording of Section 14, which lays down the classes entitled to free treatment, is exactly the same as the wording used in the Public Assistance Act, 1939, so there is no difference in the world. Therefore, if there is a belief, and it may be true, that people who were getting free treatment before this Act was passed will not get it now, it is due to administration. It is not due to administration centrally but due to administration locally.
Comment on this
No. I am talking about the enactment and the words are the same. It is also alleged, I think by Deputies Kyne and Desmond, and I think by Deputy Dillon, that people are charged in hospitals now who were not charged before the 1953 Act. That is due to administration and not to the Act. The 1953 Act laid it down that the lower income group is in the same position. Under the 1953 Act the county manager could charge—before this Bill came along—I think 6/- per day but he need not charge that. Before the Act was changed he could charge £1 a day and there was nothing to stop him doing so. The 1953 Act limited him to 6/- a day for the middle income group. It did not give him power to charge more. Again, as far as hospital treatment for the middle income group is concerned, they are better off than they were before.
If Deputy Dillon is right in his observations of what is happening in the rural areas, it is due to a stricter interpretation and treatment on the administrative side locally. The county manager, however, is not compelled to be more strict. In fact, he is in certain cases compelled to be more lenient. We come along now and we propose to make a charge for X-ray and specialist treatment for the middle income groups. Before the 1953 Act was passed, they had to pay the full charge. Now we are going back part of the way and we are saying: "You must pay something." That is due to our straitened circumstances. We must not exaggerate this. The total amount the Minister hopes to save is £90,000. We all know that the total amount spent under the 1953 Act was £1,000,000; in fact, I think it was more but our Estimate was for £1,000,000. So, if we are taking back £90,000 out of the £1,000,000 there should not be such a great furore about it. That is my point. It is only a small amount of the £1,000,000 that is being spent, less than 10 per cent.
I have not been here for the whole debate; I came in here to give my colleague some support, but during the short time I was here one would imagine that we were inflicting an intolerable burden on certain members of the public. We do not think that is correct.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister must realise that never before were people asked to pay for X-ray treatment in advance until now. When this section is passed a person must pay his 7/6 in advance.
Comment on this
The Minister said that in order to save the local authorities the trouble of running around after people who might not be able to pay he would make them pay in advance.
Comment on this
I agree with the point made by the Minister for Finance that the 1953 Act was a step forward. Many of us here were not satisfied that the progress made by the 1953 Act was anything like what it should have been but, at the same time, we accepted that it was a step forward. The step now before the House, however, is going back long before 1953. It is a reactionary step and it is undoing portion of the work, or the progress, that was made by the 1953 Act. On that basis I personally criticise the proposal as strongly as I possibly can.