We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Adjournment Debate: Government Policy (Resumed).

Contributions 1–171 of 484. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I shall not deal further with the specific matters in relation to the pig industry to which I was referring save to say that the Minister would be well advised to review this matter at an early stage. We want to help in the eradication of the present outbreak of swine fever but it is our duty to say that the burden is becoming extremely heavy on small farmers with large numbers of young pigs who are unable to move them. It should be legitimate now to consider whether limited movement in respect of certain categories of pigs might not be allowed in restricted areas. The Minister is bound to bear in mind the value of the pig industry as a whole and the danger there is of driving people out of that industry if they find that the burden is becoming unbearable.

I am in the difficulty that I cannot praise or indict the Fianna Fáil policy for increased production because I do not know what it is. Anything that I have read so far in publications of consequence I have been constrained to comment upon adversely to-day with special reference to the observations of the Minister for Lands. I do observe that, despite the Taoiseach's reply to-day to questions put to him, unemployment has jumped in the last three or four weeks. It is common knowledge amongst us that emigration is proceeding at a rampant rate. I am entitled to ask Fianna Fáil what has become of their general election poster campaign, what are they doing about it or was it all fraud?

The only categorical statement of policy put out by Fianna Fáil was that of the Tánaiste when he spoke of the £100,000,000 Fianna Fáil plan. It was published in the Fianna Fáil Party Pravda. Do you remember that?

Comment on this

Deputy Haughey remembers the supplement. He probably has a copy of it so that he can keep himself in step. Could he tell us what has become of the plan?

Comment on this

The financial situation has deteriorated since then.

Comment on this

Has the plan been abandoned? Is it to be revised? For the first time since 1946 we have a credit balance of payment to-day.

Comment on this

Where are the external assets we had?

Comment on this

I think we have rather more to-day than we had then.

Comment on this

They are gone with the wind.

Comment on this

Not at all. Deputy Haughey had better cast up his figures again and refer back to the plan. The plan is in cold storage. Perhaps Deputy Haughey could tell us if it is coming out again.

Comment on this

This is not Question Time.

Comment on this

No, and the Deputy is not a Minister yet. I am only trying to penetrate the ivory tower into which the plan disappeared two years ago. The Deputy is the only member of his Party who remembers that the £100,000,000 appeared in the Fianna Fáil Pravda.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not think that the Deputy should be allowed to refer——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This conversation is not at all relevant to the debate.

Comment on this

I wonder if it is in order for Deputy Dillon, when referring to the property of a number of people in this State, to refer to it as the Fianna Fáil Pravda. I think that, in common decency, he might refer to it as The Irish Press. I am a shareholder in that property and I object.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The use of the phrase is undesirable and should not be continued.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Pravda is the instrument of Fianna Fáil falsehood in this country. I understand that Pravda is the Russian word for truth. In our judgment the Fianna Fáil Pravda is an instrument of the Taoiseach, who is the controlling director, and who uses it for the propagation of Fianna Fáil propaganda. I return now to the fact that the £100,000,000 proposal was published as a supplement in the Fianna Fáil Pravda. I am entitled to ask, two years after, for the delectation of the Irish people, what has become of it. I am told by Deputy Haughey that it has been put in cold storage not because there is an adverse balance of payments but because the external assets are less now than then. I think Deputy Haughey ought to go and have another look at the figures. That is the trouble of reading nothing but the Fianna Fáil Pravda. Your propaganda begins to deceive yourself.

Comment on this

What about the Deputy's propaganda? He was going to drown them in eggs.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should keep silent until he addresses the House himself.

Comment on this

Those who read nothing but Fianna Fáil propaganda will end up by believing in it themselves.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, if the Deputy has nothing to say, would you ask him to sit down? He is wasting the time of the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

When the Deputies read nothing but the Fianna Fáil Pravda they cannot blame me if they are deceived by it. Here is the place where the innocent can be brought in and made to listen, made to engage in debate and discussion——

Comment on this

The Deputy is not a good teacher.

Comment on this

If we have brought three of them to their feet in indignation at what I am saying, they should search their consciences if they are not prepared to prove me wrong——

Comment on this

In due course.

Comment on this

I invite them to undertake the assignment in the course of this debate to disprove one single proposition which I have advanced and I am prepared to stand on this: if one single proposition be successfully controverted, all the rest may fall. But will the Deputies give a corresponding undertaking that if they discover that that which they believe to be true is now demonstrated to be false, they will retract in the presence of their constituents the falsehoods which they presented to them when they sought their suffrage? I do not think they will and I am asking a member of the Front Bench, is Deputy Haughey's description of the present state of Deputy Lemass's £100,000,000 plan for the rehabilitation of Ireland authorised? Is that the truth? Is it in cold storage?

Comment on this

You are over there because of all the plans you had in cold storage.

Comment on this

I do not think that is true. I think the Minister for Justice must search his conscience because, you know, he put up that poster in Ballybough "Wives, vote for Traynor so that your husbands may get jobs".

Comment on this

That is a pure invention of the Deputy.

Comment on this

Gracious me! Oh, no, it is not, I assure the Minister. I solemnly declare that poster was erected in this city and, I believe, in the Minister's constituency——

Comment on this

It would not be the first thing the Deputy solemnly declared.

Comment on this

I really think the Minister for Health is being extremely circumspect. His head is sunk in his hands. I do not think he will deny it. Now, you see, the Minister for Justice is beginning to discover that something he thought was wrong is right. Come, this debate is having a most useful purpose. One, two, three, four —all having a chink opened in the impenetrable cuirass of illusion in which the Fianna Fáil Pravda has hitherto wrapped them round. The more you proclaim that the Fianna Fáil Pravda——

Comment on this

The Irish Press.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Irish Press does not fall for discussion on this.

Comment on this

It is their primary channel of falsehood.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not fall for discussion here. It is Government policy that falls for discussion here.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is the governing director of The Irish Press. I am indicting him for his responsibility.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy can indict him for his policy, not for The Irish Press.

Comment on this

Surely I can indict him for his agents?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy can indict the Government for its policy, not for The Irish Press.

Comment on this

Surely I am entitled to warn Deputies against the danger of reading it too much?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not entitled to make his entire speech on The Irish Press.

Comment on this

No. I have already converted four members of the Opposition to a realisation of the fact that what they read in the Pravda——

Comment on this

The Irish Press.

Comment on this

——is not true. Even the Minister for Justice has discovered that the posters did not say all he thought they said.

Comment on this

This is pure invention of the Deputy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dillon should come to the policy of the Government.

Comment on this

The policy of the Government is to deceive the electorate. I would ask them to give an account of their stewardship and I propose to demonstrate the deception they practise on the electorate and on themselves. I am able to illuminate them here but I would exhort them to go out and do as much for the electorate they mislead.

I am in the difficulty that the Ceann Comhairle obdures me to deal with the policy of the Government. I do not know what the policy of the Government is and they cannot tell me. I venture to prophesy that they will get up here to-day. They sent for the Minister for Health, and his assignment will be to shovel mud all over this debating chamber, but we will hear nothing about what he proposes to do. The only man who helps us is Deputy Haughey, who said the programme is in cold storage. What is the Government doing now until they take that plan out of cold storage?

Comment on this

Those are your words, not mine.

Comment on this

What were your words?

Comment on this

You will hear them in due course.

Comment on this

I am in that difficulty. I cannot deal with their policy. I do not know what it is. I want to direct their attention to this: we are all agreed that the cost of living is rising in this country. Is that not so? Fianna Fáil have put 7d. on the lb. of butter and approximately 3d. or 4d. on the loaf——

Comment on this

Fine Gael put it on.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Loughman ought to restrain himself.

Comment on this

The Deputy is asking questions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

These are rhetorical questions.

Comment on this

We are all agreed that the cost of living is going up. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has agreed to a formula whereunder industrial workers are to get increased wages to compensate, within a limit of 10/- per week. What proposals does this House make to assist the 500,000 farmers of this country, the great majority of whom are living on holdings of 20 acres or below 30 acres of land and whose average weekly income is substantially less than that of any industrial worker? What proposal is there to help him to meet that cost of living increase? Or are we drifting back into the happy state— and I speak ironically—that this country was in prior to 1948, when the small farmers were cast for the role of hewers of wood and drawers of water, when they were the despised element in our community and when they were the element to whom the Minister for Agriculture could say in Dáil Éireann, as reported in Volume 106, column 2239:

"I would have had inspectors tucked after them, and I would have tucked them out into fresh land, and I would compel them to break fresh land, and if they did not do it, I would tuck in the tractors through the ditches and through the gates and tuck out the land for them——"

Comment on this

And quite right at the time.

Comment on this

"If the Lord Almighty provides us with good weather that will enable us to make a start, and if there should be a necessity next season to be as rigid as heretofore—and there may be—I am going to tell them here and now that I will recruit the full of ten fields of inspectors and I will spend plenty of money in paying them travelling expenses and everything else, and I will hire all the tractors and machinery I can get and I will go down and pick every one of the ‘cods' out and I will say: ‘Take down that piece of wire and put it around the other corner...' When I do that you can call me a thug or a clod or a driver, whatever you like, I do not care——"

I do not blame Deputy Moher for leaving the House particularly when he hears Deputy Loughman beside him interpose "and quite right too". Are we on the road back to that? Deputy Loughman like myself is primarily a business man. He is not a farmer. I see that the Deputy has now left. That is another one gone. The truth is hard to bear. Could there be any more eloquent peroration than the two vacant seats and the two receding backs that we have just seen? If their colleagues can contradict a word I have said they can disregard it all. There were two of them there who sought to challenge it and now as I sit down their seats are empty but let them read it in the report. If as Deputy Loughman thinks, they can revive in this country the dispensations we broke down in 1947 they have another think coming.

Comment on this

The Deputy having said nothing repetitiously for a considerable period of time——

Comment on this

I said enough to drive two of your colleagues out.

Comment on this

Of course a good orator holds his audience; he does not drive them out. It is only a bore that succeeds in doing that.

Comment on this

Better send for Major Vivion.

Comment on this

I heard a portion of the Deputy's opening remarks with great interest. He claimed he had been responsible for the building of the tuberculosis sanatoria. I have here the Statutes of the Oireachtas. It contains the 1945 Act, initiated and introduced into this House under my auspices as Minister for Local Government and Public Health, steered through the Oireachtas by my then Parliamentary Secretary. Under this Act every one of the sanatoria, which the Deputy has boasted about was built——

Comment on this

Would the Minister like to name the Parliamentary Secretary?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon now boasts that the sanatoria will soon be empty. Millions of pounds were spent on building marble halls for Deputy Dillon to bellow in.

I listened with amazement to Deputy Dillon claiming credit for the rural electrification scheme. The rural electrification scheme was——

Comment on this

A white elephant.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

It was not a white elephant. If the Opposition have come in here to interrupt and make a jeer of the plight of the people, because that is what they are doing, let me remind them that the rural electrification scheme was initiated by a Fianna Fáil Government. It was started by a Fianna Fáil Government which had decided that the benefits of electricity should be brought, so far as possible, down to every farm house in the country. It found the money to do that, it found half the cost to do that out of the public Exchequer. It was necessary that the scheme should be subsidised in order that electricity might be made available to the farmers of Ireland at rates which they could pay.

We took upon ourselves the responsibility of raising the money and of course imposing the necessary taxation to defray the charges which would undoubtedly arise in consequence. This scheme went ahead on that basis until the second Coalition Government came in and what did Deputy Dillon and his colleagues do then? Not merely did they discontinue the subsidy, and thereby increased the direct cost of electricity to every user in the country. They also by their action tended to slow down the rate at which the rural inhabitants would have the benefits of electricity. Not merely did they do all this. They dishonoured the bond which the Fianna Fáil Government had entered into with the E.S.B., an obligation which had been accepted by the first Coalition and which had not been disturbed by the Fianna Fáil Government from 1951 to 1954.

As I say they were guilty of a breach of public faith with this statutory body because not only did they discontinue the subsidy, but they imposed retrospectively on the E.S.B. the obligation of repaying so much of the subsidy as had already been paid out to it. Yet Deputy Dillon has the hardihood now to come in here and say it was the Coalition Government which was responsible not merely for initiating the hospitalisation programme, not merely for erecting the sanatoria, but also for initiating and carrying through the rural electrification scheme.

Yesterday I was looking at a cartoon in a newspaper. It showed a rather brusque gentleman in the act of blowing something out of his mouth and over it was the caption, "Mr. Khrushchev launches the latest satellite out of his own big mouth." I think that after Deputy Dillon's speech Mr. Khrushchev had better look to his laurels for Deputy Dillon apparently is out to beat that gentleman.

Comment on this

He is not a senile delinquent as Deputy Coogan called the Minister.

Comment on this

But this speech of Deputy Dillon had a purpose. I understood that this debate was to concern itself with the present problems of the people, the economic conditions prevailing in the country. The speech which Deputy Dillon made did not relate to those conditions at all, not from beginning to end. They were not aimless remarks. I am sure they were well directed to their purpose and the purpose of them was to divert the minds of the people from the seriousness of the situation—the seriousness of the situation which the second Coalition Government left behind it.

The problems with which the country is confronted to-day are not of recent creation. They are the product of the policy initiated by the Coalition Government in 1949; the policy which, as Deputy Dillon has told us, made the millions fly; the policy under which they borrowed £40,000,000 from the American Government and could find no better way of spending than by flinging out $6,000,000 in one afternoon to buy cereals which we could have produced in this country; the policy which has left every successive Government from now until 35 years have elapsed with the burden of extracting out of industry in this country, of taking out of the pockets of the citizens, an increasing amount of money every year until that American debt is repaid. The £40,000,000 which Deputy Dillon borrowed has been spent as he boasted they would spend them and the burden is now falling on the people of repaying that money. It will be repaid out of the toil and sweat of the Irish people and for that Deputy Dillon and his colleagues are responsible. It was not necessary to borrow that money. It was borrowed with the deliberate purpose of creating an inflationary situation here.

Comment on this

Blatherskite!

Comment on this

It was borrowed in order to create an inflationary situation here and the records of the internal disputes in the first Coalition Government prove that.

Comment on this

Inflated pounds repayable in dollars.

Comment on this

Signed for by the present Taoiseach.

Comment on this

It was not signed for by the present Taoiseach. The Taoiseach did not put his name to a single American note. Peculiarly enough, the man who did sign for it was not the Minister for Finance, but the then Minister for External Affairs, Mr. Seán MacBride. He threatened that he would break up the Government if he did not get his way, and by his threat imposed his inflationary policy upon the more conservative elements of Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Bunkum!

Comment on this

It was not necessary to borrow one penny of that American money. The manner in which it was spent shows it was not. Out of the £40,000,000 I do not think that £6,000,000 was spent on what might be described as capital goods, as productive equipment. The rest if it was spent, as Deputy Dillon boasted it was spent, on importing materials into this country which we could have produced at home.

Comment on this

Dishonest blatherskite!

Comment on this

All this was done so that, by creating an inflationary situation here, by pumping unnecessary money into circulation a fictitious appearance of prosperity might be produced. We are paying and the country is paying now for those fevered years of 1949 and 1950 when prices were mounting and money was being spent lavishly to produce an artificial appearance of prosperity. The fever is over and we are now suffering from the depression.

There was a purpose in Deputy Dillon's apparently nonsensical speech. He wanted to get away from the fact that the present position is the culmination of the policies that were initiated in 1949 and 1950 by the first Coalition and were reverted to when the second Coalition came in in June, 1951.

Comment on this

And which produced a favourable balance of payments for the first time in over five years.

Comment on this

We will deal with that in a moment.

Comment on this

And which gave us dollars to finance Briscoe's trip.

Comment on this

I went on my own.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy Briscoe should not be interrupting his colleague, the Minister for Health.

Comment on this

Nobody paid for my trip. I imported no carpets.

Comment on this

The Deputy must not be reading Time magazine.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputies Briscoe and Lynch will permit me I should like to say that the Minister for Health is entitled to speak without interruption and should be allowed to do so.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon has referred to the balance of payments both in the course of his speech and by way of interruption. Apparently he attaches a great deal of importance to it. So do we all. For any year it might be described as the final accounting. It gives us the figures which indicate the final out-turn of our operations as a trading community from year to year.

Let us see what the position was in the past in regard to it. In 1947, which was the year before the Coalition Government came in for the first time, there was a deficit of £29.8 million. It was large by comparison with anything we had hitherto experienced. In fact we had not experienced any substantial deficit in any previous year, even in 1939 and even during the economic war about which Deputy Dillon so frequently twits us so often.

In 1947 there arose the first deficit of any substantial amount. It was a relatively small deficit having regard to our resources at the time and to the conditions from which we were emerging. Over the period from 1940 to 1946 it was impossible to import many things which were necessary for the expansion of our industries and for the maintenance of our economic activities.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

It is a pity the Deputy did not say "hear, hear," in 1945 and 1946 when he was going out bellowing to the people about the hardships they were undergoing then. He knows as well as I do that those hardships were not of our making, but that they were imposed by world circumstances at the time. However, conditions began to improve when materials became available, when it was possible for us to resume the industrial development interrupted by the war in 1939. It was, of course, imperative for us to import new plant and to build up our stocks of raw materials and in many ways to make good the deficiencies which were a consequence of the war. Therefore, in 1947, we had a deficit of £29.8 million in our balance of payments. It was a relatively small deficit in relation to the resources which were at our disposal. But it was sufficiently large to compel the then Taoiseach, now Deputy Costello, to speak in August of 1948—I think—and refer in rather startling terms to this deficit which had emerged as a result of our external transactions during the year 1947. In consequence of that, there was imposed by the then Government a certain slackening in activity: things were slowed down and the old hidebound, conservative Fine Gael mentality was beginning to prevail.

I am not one of those who think we can cure all the nation's ills by spending money we do not have, or are not prepared to save, or which we must borrow and ultimately repay, but there is, I believe, a happy mean between extravagance and demoralising lack of enterprise. However, it was the un-enterprising element that shaped the policy of the Government in 1948 and continued to shape it during 1949, because the deficit in the balance of payments fell from £29.8 million to £19.7 in 1948 and to £9.7 million pounds in 1949. And then there came the change to which I have referred. Then Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, was—as Deputy Dillon said in reference to another matter—put into cold storage at the behest of the then Minister for External Affairs.

Comment on this

Blather.

Comment on this

And the financial policy of the Coalition Government began thereafter to be shaped by Mr. Seán MacBride. With what consequences?

Comment on this

Blather.

Comment on this

Consequences which were reflected in the serious balance of payments deficit which began to emerge in 1950, when it jumped from £9.7 million to £30.2 million in that year, to be succeeded in the year 1951 by a deficit amounting to no less than £61.6 million.

It has been said that history does not repeat itself. Perhaps it does not repeat itself in detail but it may often do so in a general way and indeed in relation to our economic situation it has repeated itself in a general way. It did so from 1954 over the period of the second Coalition Government, because what I am about to establish is the striking similarity between the conditions which obtained when we took office in June, 1951, and the conditions as they existed when we took office in March of this year.

Let us deal with the balance of payments to which I have referred. In 1950 it was £30.2 million; in 1951 it was £61.6 million; in 1955 it was £35.5 million, and in 1956 it was £14.4 million. What was the interim trend of the balance of payments over the period from 1951 until we were leaving office and the Coalition Government took office in 1954?

Comment on this

And the trend of the unemployment figures?

Comment on this

The Deputy should be silent for a little while. In 1951 we had a balance of payments deficit of £61.6 million and in 1952 that had been reduced to £8.9 million. It fell to £7.0 million in 1953.

Comment on this

And unemployment had reached record level.

Comment on this

In 1954, because the impetus of the Fianna Fáil policy had not been spent, it fell still further to £5,500,000.

Comment on this

More employment and more emigration than ever before.

Comment on this

Then the Coalition came in and reverted to the old MacBride policy and again we had unjustifiable expenditure in order to reap political kudos, expenditure which could not be maintained——

Comment on this

Such as?

Comment on this

Such as subsidisation of tea out of borrowed money. However, I am not being diverted. I want to get back. The old MacBride policy was restored and the balance of payments deficit jumped to £35,500,000. That was in the year 1955. In that year, a motion was brought into Dáil Éireann, a motion of no confidence in the Government, and in the course of that debate Fianna Fáil Deputies warned the Government as to what the consequences of their policy would be. They were jeered at, and sneered at, and told that everything was for the best in the best of all possible worlds here in Ireland, because we had a Coalition Government in office. Within less than six months the Minister for Finance in the second Coalition Government came in here on the Vote on Account and described the economic peril which the country was facing. He begged and implored us to allow him to take measures to deal with it. That was in March, 1956. I have referred to the position which existed in 1951 when we took over——

Comment on this

I thought the Minister was coming to 1957?

Comment on this

I shall come to 1957 in a little while.

Comment on this

We do not move as fast as the Deputy.

Comment on this

So I have observed.

Comment on this

I referred to the position when we took over in June, 1951. I had only been four or five weeks in office as Minister for Finance when I came here and did something quite unusual. As a rule the Vote for the Department for Finance goes through the House without discussion and without any form of statement by the Minister. But the situation which I found confronting me in the Department of Finance when I took over from my predecessor, was so serious that I thought it advisable to let the country know immediately what that situation was. I said that four features of it called for immediate and careful consideration.

The first of these was the character and adequacy of the Budget introduced by my predecessor, Deputy McGilligan. That Budget was never discussed in the House. It was introduced on the 4th May and before the House met again the Dáil was dissolved and we were plunged into a general election. I then referred to the problem of unwieldy capital expenditure. I spoke about our trading situation with the rest of the world as reflected in the balance of payments and I spoke about the rapid dissipation of our external assets. These were all serious matters reflecting the serious position in which the country then was. Instead of being received as my successor— now Deputy Sweetman—was received when he came to the House in March, 1956, this considered statement of mine, which was subsequently substantiated up to the hilt by the actual facts——

Comment on this

Is this the White Paper?

Comment on this

——was sneered at, and jeered at by the then Opposition.

Comment on this

Is this the White Paper?

Comment on this

But the situation was very similar then to what it is to-day. I predicted as early as two months after Deputy McGilligan had introduced his Budget proposals to this House—I informed the Dáil that many important matters had not been covered—that, so far as I could see, the out-turn of the Budget for the year would be a deficit of about £5,000,000. Talking from recollection, it was I think, in fact, an actual deficit of £6.7 million. Again, in October, 1956, the Minister for Finance being still alarmed about the existing situation brought in further proposals to impose special levies. Now, I do not want to be unduly censorious or unfair to the inter-Party Minister for Finance. As I said, when these proposals were before the House, they were the best that he could think of and, as the situation was in our view extremely grave, we did not intend to oppose them though we did think that the effect of some of them would be very grave indeed so far as many industries were concerned. But we received them and we dealt with them rationally. We did not get up and make the sort of speech to which Deputy Dillon treated the House to-day. We dealt with them as responsible men, concerned with the problems of the country and the effect upon the lives of our people of the conditions to which the public economy had been reduced. As I said, we were serious. There was no factious opposition. Indeed, to the extent of possibly imperilling our own reputation with our own people, we supported the measures which Deputy Sweetman proposed.

Let me see what the result of those measures was. We warned Deputy Sweetman that we thought this whole idea of the blanket levy undesirable, but we had in mind also the fact that the balance of payments position was extremely grave.

Comment on this

The Deputy said then it was too late and too little.

Comment on this

Having been £35.5 million in 1955, the balance of payments deficit was in 1956 running at a rate which we thought was exceedingly undesirable and, therefore, we were prepared to concede him the powers which he was asking. What was one of the results of the measures which he adopted? The Deputy has referred to the unemployment position.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It is time the Minister spoke about it.

Comment on this

May I just tell him what the position was? These are the latest figures available. I am talking now about persons having unemployment benefit claims current; these are the persons who would normally be in employment. The unemployment assistance figure is, as everybody knows, distorted by the fact that at this time of the year the Employment Order ceases and a very large number of people come on the register, people who are not in the strict sense of the word "unemployed", many of whom are in general self-employed having small holdings not considered adequate to enable them to sustain themselves and their families in decency during the winter and early spring.

Comment on this

Do I hear Deputy Brennan saying: "Hear, Hear!"?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order! The Minister is in possession.

Comment on this

Not a word from Deputy Brennan. How astonishing!

Comment on this
A Deputy

Bob Hope is not in it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

What was the effect of these Orders and of the manner in which the whole situation was dealt with? I am not going to talk about the general dislocation in industry which ensued upon the wholesale and indiscriminate cutting-down of Government expenditure upon capital works already in course of construction or about some of the other measures that were taken. I do not want to discuss these in detail. I merely want to show the House how all these were reflected in the unemployment figures—that is to say, in the number of persons drawing unemployment benefit.

Comment on this

Nobody registering in Dungloe was included at all.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order! Deputy Dillon should not interrupt.

Comment on this

On the 23rd November, 1955, there were 22,537 persons drawing unemployment benefit. On the corresponding date in 1956 that figure had jumped from 22,000 to 32,000, an increase of 45 per cent. That was the result of the sort of policy that the Coalition Government had been pursuing. This year, while it has not yet reverted to the 1955 level, the figure does show a considerable improvement and a very satisfactory trend in contrast to the figure for the year 1956; on the 23rd November, 1957, the figure was 27,307 as against 32,664.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us the previous two weeks?

Comment on this

We had more than half way recovered.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us the figures for the previous two weeks?

Comment on this

Whole families had gone to England.

Comment on this

We had more than half way retrieved the situation which had been created by the general panic policy of our predecessors when they were faced with a serious situation.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

With reference to the——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It is a point of order, and a very important one. The Minister appears to be giving the House certain information with regard to unemployment figures. Might I enlighten him? In 1940 there were 118,000 unemployed. There was no inter-Party Government in office before that. The Minister is not giving the correct information to the House.

Comment on this

I am quoting from a document circulated by the Central Statistics Office, a document which is available to every Deputy in the House, and I will give my copy to Deputy Flanagan if he wishes to study it.

Comment on this

How many emigrants are shown in that?

Comment on this

In the year 1955, for the week ending 16th November, there were 22,000 persons claiming unemployment benefit. In the following year, 1956, that number had jumped to 31,832. This year it is down to 26,001. I am not quoting these figures in any spirit of complacency.

Comment on this

That was the week before the last week the Minister mentioned and it shows an increase of 1,300.

Comment on this

What do you think happened in 1955—the bumper year of Coalition spending?

Comment on this

Why does the Minister not say the trend is satisfactory?

Comment on this

What do you think happened then? On the 9th November, 1955, there were 21,000 claiming unemployment benefit. It had jumped to 22,000 on 16th November, 1955, and it went up further to 22,500 on the 23rd November. Does not everybody know that at this period of the year, due to slackening in building activities and slackening in outdoor work of all sorts and a sort of general malaise which seems to take place just immediately before Christmas, there is more unemployment? This is the slack period in virtually every industry and consequently people who have been employed for the greater part of the preceding 12 months occasionally have to go to the unemployment exchange at this period of the year. Are we to be blamed because in this year, 1957, the general trend of every other year is being followed?

Deputy Dillon has again been talking about the balance of payments, and he has been claiming some credit for the fact that this year it is down to what I think is a very precarious balance. He seems to think that in some way this is due to something which was done last year or the year before by the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

The cows went to the bulls last year or we would not have milk or calves this year.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will look at the figures for the months of January and September in the years 1956 and 1957 he will find that our imports have fallen by £3,011,000 and our exports have increased by £21,820,000. The net result is that the balance of payments is about balanced. What miracle, under Heaven, can the Coalition claim for that.

Comment on this

What are the exports?

Comment on this

Cattle to some extent. Cattle were responsible for the major portion of it but will some person tell me if we could have a livestock industry without a dairying industry? Was it not Deputy Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture, who was trying to get the farmers out of milk production? If the farmers had got out of milk production would someone tell me by what sort of miracle we could hope to increase the livestock population?

Comment on this

What about the advice to keep seven cows instead of five, 14 instead of ten and 20 instead of 17?

Comment on this

There are the cattle to-day. How is it they were not forthcoming in 1956? We were not exporting butter in 1956; it is a substantial item in our exports to-day. People will tell us that we are exporting the butter at a lower price than we are paying the farmers to produce it but where there are cows there is milk and other by-products. We cannot have a healthy livestock industry unless we dispose of its by-products. These by-products are helping to the extent to which we get anything for them.

If Deputy Dillon wants to mime, as he is doing, there is an opening for him in the Olympia Theatre. I think there is a harlequin or a clown there and that he would fill the part.

Comment on this

I am only paying due attention to what the Minister is saying.

Comment on this

However we may have to dispose of these by-products, to the extent that we can sell them abroad for as much as we can get for them, it helps to secure a balance of payments. If Deputy Dillon's policy, when he tried to drive the farmers away from the cows over the period, 1948 to 1951 and again over the period 1954 until he was kicked out this year, had succeeded how could we have a surplus of butter or of anything else to export? Deputy Dillon wanted to drive the farmers out of butter and milk production and into beef. If he had done that he would have been as successful in relation to the dairying industry and the livestock industry as he was in relation to the egg and poultry industry which he encouraged the farmers to get into on the basis that he proposed to drown the British in eggs.

The only thing he succeeded in doing then was in bankrupting many of the unfortunate farmers who took his advice. That slogan of drowning the British in eggs was a political slogan and if Deputy Dillon had had any foresight whatever and knew what was happening in Britain he would have known that the day would come when, not merely would the British be self-sufficient in egg production, but they would be exporting eggs to the continent to the detriment of all who believed there was a secure market for their eggs in Britain.

I got up to show that the speech, the irrational speech, which we listened to from Deputy Dillon had one purpose in mind and that was to divert the attention of the people from the seriousness of the situation and to induce them to forget that it is a situation which is the direct offspring and traceable directly to the policies which were initiated in this country by the first Coalition and reverted to by the second. They succeeded, in their two periods of office, in sinking this country into an economic morass.

It is easy to get the country into a mess but it is very difficult to get it out of it. It is easy to bring the country to the verge of bankruptcy and difficult to restore its economy. It is easy to waste the resources of the country and difficult to build them up again. They can only be built up by a policy of self-denial and a farsighted policy of investment.

We have not been able, in the few months we have been in office, to undo or remedy the ills of the Coalition Government but we are making progress and the figures I have quoted show that we are making progress. The fact that we are now on the knife edge in regard to the balance of payments instead of in deficit, shows that we are making progress. It is indicated by the fact that the people have more faith in this Government than in its predecessors.

Comment on this

What about the Dublin North (Central) by-election?

Comment on this

We have just issued a loan. It is the substantial, thrifty people in a country who sustain a Government. You may have fluctuations in different places for personal reasons, such as were active in a recent by-election, but the indication of the people's support is that they are prepared to invest their savings with us. Contrast the result of the recent loan with that floated by Dr. Ryan's predecessor. The difference in interest was infinitesimal. It worked out at about 2/- per cent. but one loan was oversubscribed and the other one was very definitely under-subscribed because the people had no confidence in the policy of the Coalition.

It is easy to get a country into difficulties. It is very hard to extricate it from them. That is proved by what happened over the period 1951 to 1954. We had a tough job then but we were bringing the country back. Then it was plunged back again by the retrograde policies of the second Coalition. We have taken over in exactly the same circumstances as we took over in 1951. Already, within six months, the benefit of the change is being manifested in every sphere of industrial and productive activity and in the new hope which is arising in the breasts of the people.

Comment on this

I have listened with patience for the last half hour to the Minister for Health on this very important question. I was disappointed that we had no statement from the Government regarding their policy to implement some of the things they promised the people. The Minister made the excuse that because some of the farmers over £30 valuation had come on the unemployment register, that accounted for the larger number of unemployed.

I wish to remind the two other Deputies in my constituency of the speeches they made when they were elected, in which they said that one of their first tasks would be to help the Taoiseach to cure the unemployment problem, provide more houses for the people and bring back to live in comfort on their own land some of the men who had been forced to emigrate. What are the facts? In one of the large industrial towns in the county two large factories are being closed up and in one of the principal factories 100 men less are employed to-day. Twenty or 30 families have emigrated. In the rural area a flour-mill, which gave employment to 40 or 50, has closed down. In one area in Bray a factory is on short time.

There is a problem facing the Government in the rural areas which we have never experienced before. Several farmers of 1,200 or 1,300 acres have set their land to large farmers on the 11-months' system and have dismissed their employees, with the exception of one man and a dog to act as caretakers. These farmers received £22 per acre. There should be some arrangement whereby these men who received £2,000 or £3,000 for the setting of their land should have to contribute to the State for dispossessing men of employment. Some of these landowners are not solely dependent on agriculture and have other business sidelines. They are receiving large sums for the setting of their land but they do not pay one penny income-tax on it. If a tradesman gets £400 or £500, he has to pay income-tax.

The industrial worker is protected by the trade unions. He is getting 10/- as compensation for the removal of the food subsidies. But the worker in the rural areas, the forestry worker and the county council worker, has had no increase in his wages and he still has to pay a higher price for food. The men in the rural areas and the old age pensioners have to pay 4/4 per lb. for butter, while we are giving the British and other foreign people £1,250,000 to eat our butter at 3/4 per lb. I am surprised that we have had no statement of policy from the Government. Will we have increased grants to provide work in the rural areas and will the Local Authorities (Works) Act be put into operation to give employment there?

I want to deal now with the question of housing. Dublin Deputies were very vocal last year leading deputations and protesting about tradesmen having to emigrate to England to find work. They are very silent a present——

Comment on this

We have all the money we want now. We had not any last year.

Comment on this

Are you building any houses now?

Comment on this

We have all the money we want now.

Comment on this

Are you building the houses?

Comment on this

We are building flats now. Ask your colleague, Deputy Larkin, to advise you.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Everett.

Comment on this

I am referring to the fact that Deputy Briscoe is very silent—

Comment on this

We are satisfied.

Comment on this

You had your members proposing resolutions of condemnation because you were not getting all the money you wanted for houses you were not in a position to erect. Now you have ceased building in Dublin and building has also ceased in my own area except for a few houses to be erected in Avoca. There is no work there except for a few repairs. Deputy Briscoe's colleagues can verify that. It is not a situation you can take pride or delight from.

The Minister for Health spoke for half an hour about what happened from 1948 onwards but he expressed no hope about our prospects in 1958. As Deputy Briscoe well knows, we will be faced with a problem in January and February. How will we meet that problem? When a public body makes representation to a Department, the Department will not say they have not the money but they will either delay through some excuse or other or they will refuse the grant. If Deputy Briscoe can assure me that he is in a position to provide the tradesmen and building labourers in Dublin with employment in the erection of houses, we will all be delighted.

In my constituency factories have been closed, others are on short time and one principal factory, as I said, has 100 men less—

Comment on this

That happened before we took over.

Comment on this

That happened notwithstanding the promises made that you were going to provide employment for all our people. They were told by Ministers to work harder. In my constituency the men are prepared to work but the trouble is there is no work for them. In certain areas there is wholesale emigration. Sporting organisations find they are losing some of their principal men each week. It is not because they have a wanderlust but simply because there is no work in the constituency.

You may have other positions in the city to meet such a situation but in a rural area where you have land set on an 11 months' system and where the men working machines will not take on a single extra man, it is a problem. It is a problem which, whatever Government is in power will have to face. We do not hear now the speeches or the great statements that were made some months ago during the election. One of my colleagues said then that the immediate problem was unemployment, housing and giving the people a proper place to live in. We warned them about the Budget and that by the removal of the food subsidies that this would take place.

The Minister for Finance argued with me because I warned him that the duty of trade unions would be to protect their own members. I was also worried about the middle-classes who have no organisations to protect them. The men in the rural areas, the forestry workers for example, have not received one penny increase to meet the situation. In the cities and in the industrial areas, workers can meet the situation but in the rural areas they are faced with the problem of having no organisation and these men have not got an increase. I say that the Government has not given any hope to the people and the position, as I pointed out, is that probably by January or February the problem of unemployment will be worse. The Government is not making any provision at this period to meet that situation. The White Paper that the Tánaiste issued was only for discussion, to deceive the people like all the other posters which were put out during the election.

"Vote for Fianna Fáil and provide employment for the people," they were told. They voted for them and we already have more unemployment. We have not had as much unemployment in County Wicklow for a long time. The Deputies are probably doing their best but they are members of the Party who made promises to the people. The promises were like many promises made—never meant to be fulfilled.

Comment on this

I shall not delay the House too long but I think on this annual review of the political events in the country one should avail oneself of the opportunity to say sincerely and candidly what one thinks the position is. In reviewing the past political year, on which the curtain is now descending, we would of necessity cover the activities of two Governments. The present Government is in power only for some eight months and I do not now, nor did I at any time, believe that any Government could work miracles in that short period. I am concerned, and will be concerned, with trends in political events and indications as to how our economy is moving in a particular direction. I am prepared to be satisfied or otherwise by those indications. We spoke on the debate here last year. No member of the House can deny that the outlook then was anything but good. The people never faced a Christmas with such a serious and gloomy outlook as on that occasion——

Comment on this

What about this year?

Comment on this

——and if anybody was prepared to point to any signs on the economic horizon to give them hope it would have been like a shot in the arm to the economy of that time. But such hope was completely lacking. Fianna Fáil took over the reins of Government in March and they faced three immediate problems, in addition to some of the long-standing problems which we are still facing. They faced a budget deficit for which money had to be found and some unpleasant things had to be done in the process of finding it. They faced a serious deficit and in the balance of payments, an adverse balance, and worse than that, and possibly arising from these two problems they faced a pall of gloom which had descended on the entire country and on the outlook of the people.

Those were the three immediate problems which the new Government had to face when they resumed office in March, just about eight months ago. I am prepared to judge their record by how they tackled those problems since. As I said money had to be found to make up the deficit in the Budget. It was found in probably the only reasonable and practical way in which it could be found if we were not to go to people already harassed and who had lost their confidence in giving money to the Government. The balance of payments problem was tackled and brought to the stage where we now can no longer regard it as being a problem. As the Minister for Health pointed out, the position may still be regarded as precarious but certainly as satisfactory. From the manner in which these two problems were dealt with, the third immediate problem, that of the gloom and despair which had descended on our people, was automatically lifted. I would say it was lifted from the day the people first discovered that they had returned to power a strong Government.

The Opposition may talk about promises made, posters displayed and so forth, but if the people had voted for one thing more than another in the last election, they voted for a strong Government with an over-all majority, that would not be trimming its sails every day to meet political expediency and that would not be in a position to put through any stern policy or programme that would ultimately result in the uplifting of the economy of the country. Those people did not expect that they were returning a Government with a Pandora's box or an Aladdin's lamp. They knew they had appointed a Government that had to find money and when you have to find money you do not create it out of nothing. The people are well aware of that.

The fact that the Government has restored confidence in this country augurs well for the future. It was the first essential towards progress in any direction and nobody can gainsay the fact that the people in every walk of life, particularly business people, have come to realise that the future of this country is in capable and better hands. The component parts of the previous Government may have been well intentioned separately and they may have meant well, but when they got working and when each section tried to appease the other it was like the splitting of the atom. The fall-out of radio activity had a serious effect.

Comment on this

You had some radio activity last week.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

And it had a serious effect too.

Comment on this

I am prepared to look at the things which really matter in this country. Agriculture is our No. 1 industry. That is undisputed. We must do everything possible to ensure that those engaged in agriculture get a proper chance to produce more with greater efficiency so that the extra production will be marketed profitably and under the best conditions. We are taking all possible steps to improve the technical knowledge of those engaged in that industry. We are placing at the disposal of our farmers every possible assistance and encouragement to enable them to expand the economy of this country.

But remember those who say we should concentrate on agriculture alone are not conscious of what the position actually is. We must look to other industries as well even though they may take only second, third or fourth place to agriculture. Every Deputy is aware of the figures over the past number of years showing a continuous downward trend in the number of people employed in agriculture. That is due to two things—increased mechanisation on farms and the social problem which is facing the people. In those days people living in congested areas are not satisfied to live in the circumstances in which their forefathers lived and raised families.

This social problem is responsible for a considerable decline in the numbers engaged in agriculture. We must face that fact. We have given rural communities the best possible facilities and amenities such as grants for better houses, more money to lay down and maintain better roads into the townlands in which they live, better water and sewerage facilities, rural electrification schemes and so on. All these have tended towards raising the standard of living of those people. Still many of them are not prepared to remain at home on uneconomic holdings. There are many other things which could be done for those people, such as the provision of specialised branches of agriculture on uneconomic holdings like pig raising.

While agriculture should get the best possible attention, and should get more attention as time goes on, we must not forget our subsidiary industries. After agriculture we have tourism. Tourism is getting every possible encouragement that we can give it. I am satisfied that our future in this matter is very bright indeed. In that respect we have many things for which no Government is responsible. Providence has been good to us in this regard. However, there are many things yet to be done to attract an increasing flow of tourists. I think this Government has proved itself to be wide awake in this matter. After tourism we have afforestation which is being pressed forward with all possible speed. We have bog development in which Fianna Fáil have proved their interest.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is closed down now; that is finished.

Comment on this

We have the development of our fisheries. I do not usually indulge in interrupting speakers, but I was compelled to interrupt Deputy Dillon this evening when he devoted some of his speech to the passing of rather unworthy remarks on our Minister for Lands.

Comment on this

A good judge.

Comment on this