We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Adjournment Debate: Government Policy (Resumed).

Contributions 172–325 of 484. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I am pleased and satisfied that the fishing industry in this country has embarked on a new era. Foresight and impetus have been put into it now which were never before devoted to it by any previous Government. I believe that in this respect a great deal of hope for the future of the western seaboard is based. We can look forward now to continuous expansion in that industry, but we have still much ground to make up. After all, the aim and outlook of every Deputy, particularly of every member of the Government, must be to give a better standard of living to an increasing population. If I were Taoiseach in the morning I could concentrate on agriculture alone and solve all our difficulties by giving a lovely standard of living to a very small population. However, we must not only try to cater for our present declining population but we must also endeavour to arrest this decline so that future Governments will be catering for an increasing population.

We must concentrate on the other branches of industry besides agriculture—afforestation, bog development, fisheries and the manufacturing industries. Deputy Everett spoke about industry in Wicklow. Wicklow is not so much the concern of Donegal, but I would advise Deputy Everett to read the statement of the Chairman of the Arklow Potteries Board of Directors a few days ago. I should think the chairman of that board would know more about industry in the town than the Deputy. I feel equally sure that he was not trying to give any uplift to Fianna Fáil.

We must try to encourage our subsidiary industries, particularly those allied to agriculture, so as to take care of any surplus population on the land. As I said earlier, employment on the land over a number of years shows a continuous decline. In 1944, there were 526,147 people, male employees, on the land, all over 14 years of age. In 1955 that figure had dropped to 418,000 showing a continuous downward trend each year except for the year 1953-54 which showed a slight increase, according to the Abstract of Statistics.

What was the position in industry in those years? An extra 98,000 people found employment in industry since 1932. Is it not worth concentrating on? Yet, I remember Deputy Dillon accusing Fianna Fáil of concentrating too much on the manufacturing arm in this country——

Comment on this

How many extra since 1948?

Comment on this

—when he pointed out, trying to be as cynical as possible, that Fianna Fáil would create a factory for putting Aspros on a string. I do not care what the factory is doing so long as it gives employment to some people who would otherwise have to go abroad.

I believe the outlook for the establishment of industries here is good. We might be unduly optimistic if we were to consider the possible outcome of the European Free Trade Movement. Our position could be very good. I believe it will help us, and I think the manufacturers who are already in production are now sufficiently efficient to withstand any test. I believe we can have various other commodities produced here in addition to those at present manufactured with the possible expansion of our export market.

I do not believe Deputy Dillon's speech should really worry anyone on this side of the House. He did not really point out that the trends for the future were not good. Most of his speech was in castigation of the Minister for Lands because of something he is supposed to have said about capital development. I think that was a pretence, and the Deputy then proceeded to take credit for all the capital development that has taken place in the country since 1932 when, in my opinion, progress really began. Those are very recent events and nobody will be deceived about them. If any Government did any useful work let us say here: "Good luck to them; more power to them". Let us continue in that direction and let us not give the people the impression that we are here for the express purpose of contradicting each other, depending on which side of the House we sit.

I think anyone who succeeds in getting into this House has something to recommend him because it is not too easy and we should use that "something" to best advantage. I do not believe anybody here, can with reason represent to the public now that in the eight months during which we have been in power we should have completely transformed the situation which we found in existence. I do not think the members on the other side of the House can be serious when they take up that line.

I heard Deputy Dillon trying to trip the Minister for Health on the figures for unemployment. When he gave the figures for last week, which showed a reduction for some 4,000 or 5,000 on the corresponding figures for the previous year, Deputy Dillon said: "Tell us the figure for the week before that." That figure was lower, but it also went up last year during this period, and what is the good of taking up little points like that, trying to hoodwink the people by pretending something has happened which has not happened.

Unemployment figures always go up at this time of the year because the employment period has ceased and new claimants come on the register. Every smallholder in Donegal registers as unemployed and qualifies for the dole, which he draws weekly. He has a few cows or sheep, and a bit of land, as a supplement to his income. He is available for employment, if it is there, and is prepared to take it. The trend in the past few weeks is for unemployment figures to increase, and it was the same in previous years, but what the Minister for Health effectively pointed out is that the trend is not quite so great this year. Let us take some encouragement from that even though we are not happy about the position. We would like to see it 20 times better. Nevertheless, I believe the outlook is good.

Speaking in previous years on this debate I said I was not prepared to judge the Government on what was actually the position at the time, but that I was prepared to judge them on what the political, or rather the economic, barometer indicated for the future. I believe, in every aspect of our economy, consequent on the immense improvements in our financial position, confidence has been restored and we are moving forward towards greatly increased activity in every sphere of our economy. What is more important is that we have completely dispelled the idea that the Government can do everything for everybody. I think we have succeeded in getting the people to see that they must make an effort to put things right themselves.

I feel elections took place too frequently in which we had one Party going out to outbid another as to what they expected to do in regard to social welfare benefits and other things. This created the idea that the Government was prepared to do everything for everybody. I think that has been changed and that many people realise the time has come when the Government can only point the way, leaving the people to do the rest themselves.

I remember a few lines of a poem in the old school books which said:—

"Land of our birth! We pledge to thee

Our love and toil in the years to be;

That we may bring from age to age An undivided heritage."

That is the spirit we want to foster.

Comment on this

The previous speaker said that the future of the country is in safe hands. Now, I shall have to repeat what I said earlier to-day in another discussion. When I left Leinster House last July for the Recess I came to the conclusion that, when I returned here in the autumn, this place would be a hive of industry and there would be schemes and proposals by Ministers, mainly by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I thought we would be very busy and I thought we would have something to be very busy about. I am referring to the Minister for Industry and Commerce's £100,000,000—mark all the noughts; I am afraid they are nothing but noughts — and the 100,000 jobs.

Deputies have said here that one could not expect the Government just to blot out unemployment overnight, and the last speaker said that they would not hoodwink the people. I know he is a fair man and I suppose he believes what he says. What about this: "All energies devoted to one aim, full employment. Unemployment can be cured." This is the famous opus published by Fianna Fáil. What have they been doing? We hear nothing now about the £100,000,000 and, of course, if the 100,000 jobs could be provided there would be no unemployment problem and I would not be standing here now speaking in this debate.

On 23rd October Deputy Desmond asked a question about the unemployment position, and I made a comment at the time, a comment which was not published. Deputy Desmond asked the Taoiseach if he would "indicate what immediate steps the Government had decided upon to meet the serious unemployment position." The Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Donnchadh Ó Briain, replying for the Taoiseach, said:—

"...These incentives are:

(1) the raising from 50 per cent. to 100 per cent. of the relief for profits derived from increases in exports;

(2) an alternative concession in the form of a relief of 25 per cent. of tax on profits attributable to total exports of manufactured goods;

(3) a 25 per cent. increase in the wear and tear allowance on plant and machinery (other than vehicles);

(4) the extension to all securities issued to the public by Irish manufacturing concerns since 1932 of the income-tax remission granted under Section 7 of the Finance Act of that year;."

I interjected there: "And Uncle Tom Cobley and all", because this was just words, words, words. The question was: What steps had the Government taken to meet the immediate serious unemployment position?

When the Minister for Health was speaking to-day he told us that we should take our medicine. Whoever first coined that phrase was inspired, because it was a medicine man's job that was being enacted over there— cheap mumbo-jumbo. The Minister for Health came in here and had a "go" at Deputy McGilligan, former Minister for Finance; he said he was put into cold storage. Where was Deputy MacEntee put when he was taken out of the Department of Finance? Where was this wonderful financial expert who tells us about the finances of the country? Why did the Taoiseach not make him Minister for Finance?

Let us take now what happened since this Government came into office. In my opinion since the Government came into office, and particularly since the recess last July, they have gone into coma. Occasionally some members wake out of the coma to attend some dinners and say, each of them in turn: "What a good boy am I." The main actor in this "What-a-good-boy-am-I" rôle is the present Minister for Finance. He is reported as having attended some dinner given by some bankers in some hostelry, where he told these nice gentlemen that things are good, a good deal of money is coming in now with the Prize Bonds, and ends with his little Jack Horner: "What a good boy am I."

The next item was the balance of payments—"What a good boy am I." What, in the name of Heaven, has the Minister for Finance done about any of these things since he took over office? The latest brag by the Minister for health is the success of the last loan—£10,000,000.

Comment on this

Hear, hear—£11,000,000 odd.

Comment on this

I was in the House when that loan was introduced. The Minister spoke about the good value of the loan and the good offer he was making. When he sat down the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, got up and advised the people to put their money into the loan. The Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Norton, rose and advised the people to support the loan with everything they had. That was a great change from what happened when Deputy Costello's Government was in office and a loan was floated. We had Deputy MacEntee's famous "Kiss of Death to the Irish Parliament" speech. We had the then Deputy Aiken saying that nobody would put a "bob" into it. I could see him putting the emphasis on the "bob". That was the loyal way these gentlemen helped us along when they were in opposition.

Another question was asked about unemployment and we were told, again by the Parliamentary Secretary, that there were long-term proposals for unemployment. There were no long-term proposals when Fianna Fáil were telling the housewives to put their husbands to work—"Vote Fianna Fáil!" The husbands were all going to work the following Monday.

The Minister for Health said that he was speaking to-day as a responsible Minister and for a responsible Party. Deputy J. Brennan referred to a debate which took place here when Fianna Fáil were on this side of the House and we were over there. But Deputy Brennan subsequently ducked away from that and jumped to last March, and I would like now to remind the House of what happened. The entire Opposition was lined up behind Fianna Fáil. It was the most scandalous performance I have ever experienced. It is reported in the Official Report. The Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, would utter a few words and he would be interrupted immediately by three or four Opposition Deputies. That is the atmosphere that existed in this House this time last year. I came into the House this evening and even though the Minister for Health is usually on the bone he was let go. They were drawing us and trying to trick us into doing what they were doing last year.

Comment on this

Perhaps discretion is the better part of valour.

Comment on this

Has the Davern family recovered its breath?

Comment on this

The Minister for Health treated us to a treatise on agriculture. One would imagine that the Fianna Fáil Party and the Government were all wearing Texas hats, that they were all cowboys, and that they were all mad about cows.

Comment on this

There is a touch of Oklahoma about that.

Comment on this

We had a touch of that too when there was a draught and when they were all killing the calves.

Comment on this

It is a good thing for the Deputy that they were not killing asses.

Comment on this

If Deputy Davern likes I will have a "go" at him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps Deputy Lynch would be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

The bullock that nobody wanted saved this country. They go around now to dinners and make speeches about increased production. They say that all we want is increased production but I asked the Minister for Agriculture to-day if he wanted increased production in butter and I got one of those Fianna Fáil crosswords of replies when I was told that his Department would be in favour of an economic production of butter. Deputy Dillon was being taunted by the Minister for Health who says that everything Deputy Dillon did was wrong and that Deputy Dillon was not responsible for the production of anything. The one thing about it is that the farmers did put in their crops last year and that they did have a good harvest and that there was a good cattle trade. If we were able to avail ourselves of the good price for cattle it was because we had the cattle.

A great many people are going about the country telling us about the Free Trade Area. We are a very innocent people down in Waterford and we would like to be told what it is all about. It is a very nice thing for a Minister to go to Paris, come back and say that agriculture is going into the Free Trade Area but how would we find ourselves in the British market without the present of £20 per head which we get for store cattle? How would we find ourselves with butter, even if we have to subsidise it, if Denmark, Holland and these other countries got in on the same terms as we have? I think that people in this country forget that we have a substantial preference in the British market in return for preferences which they have here. What this House should discuss and weigh up is the fact that if we allow other industrialists in we will not be able to give the British the preferences we have been giving them up to the present. We should ask ourselves if this will interfere with us on the British market. I put that question fairly to thinking Government Deputies.

We have seen what happened recently with regard to ministerial changes. We must ask ourselves, and we must answer the questions of our constituents who want to know, what is actually happening and why it is that, from the 78 members of Fianna Fáil, it was not possible to bring in a new Minister for Agriculture. That question is being asked and the Taoiseach is the only person who can answer it. Perhaps he is a better judge of his men than I am. It is as well to let Fianna Fáil know that people are asking that question. Their own supporters are asking it.

On the question of fisheries, Deputy Brennan got up and extolled the Minister as if he had directed the shoals to our nets and all the rest of it. I think that kind of thing is wrong. I know that the present Minister is very keen on his job and that he has gone out of his way to investigate the working of his Department and to do a good job to the best of his ability. However, I would suggest to him that the policy of his Department as carried out for many years in concentrating all their handouts and all their boats on the western seaboard is not a good policy.

The Government has put up £5,000 for an ice plant at Dunmore East. It was first announced to be £50,000 but that was said to be a misprint. We do not consider that £50,000 would be an excessive amount for Dunmore East. Any Deputy who reads the newspapers will see that Dunmore East is in the headlines notwithstanding the fact that it has got less money and fewer boats than any other fishing port in Ireland. They are catching the fish there and catching plenty of it. There is a good market for it. That is what I want to point out to the Minister. There is an excellent market for fish in Dunmore East with English and foreign buyers. That is what made Dublin cattle market a good market, having all the different classes of buyers competing there.

In the matter of ships and trade, there has been a policy of Fianna Fáil to build 10,000 tonners. In answer to a question here, the Minister for Industry and Commerce told me that only the port of Dublin can take a 10,000-tonner fully loaded. I respectfully submit that it is not to our economic interest to build these monsters. In the first place, what they call a 10,000 ton parcel is too big for the average Irish merchant. Even if these ships could be got into the small ports and to the small piers, on which so much money has been spent, there is nobody in these areas who could afford or would need so much cargo.

My suggestion to the Government is that they build ships of smaller draught, and that they build them from 5,000 tons back. They should also consider going into the coasting business. We discussed this here when discussing cross-Channel shipping rates. I want to repeat this because it is very important. We sent 697,000 cattle in nine months, and we should have ships of our own to take some of them. If the Minister is given the opportunity of meeting British Railways and the people who control shipping in and out of our ports, what he says will have no weight unless he is in a position to say that a company he is sponsoring or that ships he has available are ready to go into the market and carry these cattle. But the answer to that is that you can only bring the cattle over and land them at the ports. British Railways have you there. They can tell you they will not have waggons until next Tuesday, and leave you at the port.

There is no restriction on these matadors. Perhaps it would be as well if we could get the lot of them out of the country. If we had our ships plying between the Irish and English ports and 40 to 50 matadors, we could handle those cargoes of cattle. Forty matadors at 12 a piece—that is 480 cattle, and that is a handy load.

Successive Ministers for Industry and Commerce have been asked in the House to try to direct factories down the country, and successive Ministers for Industry and Commerce have answered that they have no function in the matter. I do not think that is right. The majority of the people promoting industries go to the Government for concessions in the way of tariff protection and for money.

I admit Dublin is a great city and a great capital and that there is a demand for industry in it. But when you see 20 industries proposed for Dublin and one down the country, it is something to which attention should be paid. I shall not be parochial about my constituency, but I am sure nearly everybody down the country can look around his constituency and see fine towns dying. It is terrible to consider that if ten or 15 industries are being promoted over a certain period, nearly all of them will open in Dublin. At least one third should be promoted down the country. The Government have got themselves in with a great majority and by saying "Let Us Get Cracking"——

Comment on this

A good slogan.

Comment on this

It did not work in North Dublin. They were finished with it.

Comment on this

We are cracking in Dublin.

Comment on this

"A Vote for Cregan is a Vote for Dev." It is "bust" for the first time.

Comment on this

Fine Gael did not do so well.

Comment on this

You put us out and now you are over there. Commencing my speech I said that when this Government took office, they came in here, got their Budget through and then the Cabinet went into a coma—

Comment on this

Got your Budget through. There is a difference.

Comment on this

Come over and make his speech for him.

Comment on this

Nobody need ever say my words for me. I was able to say them when you had the follows trying to break my poll with an ash plant and you had the gunners in the Broy Harriers after me——

Comment on this

And you had the Blueshirts.

Comment on this

Aye, the Blueshirts and the Brownshirts. You are over there now, a strong Government. It was a pity to see what happened when we came back here. Nobody came in from the Government Benches to discuss the Bills. Nobody cared. The Bills just ran through here. The most important Bill to come before the House was hardly debated by any Fianna Fáil back bencher—the Agricultural Institute Bill. No legislation was brought before the House, except the carry-over from the last Government. That proves that during the recess the Ministers did nothing despite all the "cracking" they were supposed to do.

This morning we had a debate on money for C.I.E., and again I noticed the absence of the backbenchers. Who cares about that? I want to repeat that this matter about C.I.E. is very serious. It is a very serious matter for the economy of this country that people should lightly come along and say they can chop off branch lines here and there, close workshops and tempt men out to take buttons for a pension. I know you can lightly do it over there and do it ruthlessly. You would take the people's livelihood out of their hands. I have seen it done in the city I come from, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the man who was to get "cracking", came in to-day and asked us for £1,800,000 to keep the railways going. He should have had his permanent proposals here ready before the Dáil to-day.

He had the report of the Traffic Commission on his desk since May 27th last and what has he been doing ever since? That is the thing on which you build your Party—claptrap. Read your kept-paper and if there is any constructive proposition put up to a Minister it is not printed in it. That is not government. I do not know whether I am in order in talking about this matter, but the Chair can direct me if I am out of order. I remember a time when matters like this would be discussed in the country and we would be told that statements would be made by leading members of the Government. We discovered, if we went to the meeting to hear this magnificent opus, that it was "Ireland free from the sod to the sky", the resurgence of the Gael and the resurrection of the Irish language. That was the sort of thing that was handed out. I was half expecting that would be dished out here to-day.

In the matter of industry Deputy Brennan said that 98,000 people went into industry since 1932. How many people went into it since 1947? The greater portion. How many people left the land since 1932? This is something worth talking about, something that is far removed from the pavements and asphalt in Dublin. Deputy Haughey can go down and look at parts of the country for himself. If Kickham were to come back he could write Knocknagow again and truly say that Knocknagow is gone, for all the people have gone out of it. I have been speaking here for some time and all I have heard are innuendoes, mumbles and mumbo-jumbo from the trained men at the back who come in here and who have not spoken since the Dáil met or even put down a question.

Comment on this

It shows that they have confidence in their Ministers.

Comment on this

I do not think the Ministers know that they are there or that they know that the Ministers are there either. As for their confidence in the Minister we have not got much to show for it. We were under very heavy fire and under hot fire, from where I am standing, last year about the building of houses. I do not hear any of these people who were then firing off shots about the building of houses, firing them now.

Comment on this

We have all the money we want now.

Comment on this

Yes, but you are not building houses with it.

Comment on this

We are.

Comment on this

How is it then there are so many people out of employment in the building trade?

Comment on this

Because of the repercussions of your Government. You are on a bad wicket there.

Comment on this

Leave that subject and get on to safer ground.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Ignore him.

Comment on this

I do not like ignoring him at all because I always like to let them have it back. The Government got in on false pretences. They went around the country like cheap medicine men with their promises. The Taoiseach went to Belmullet and said "Do not believe them, we will not take away the subsidies". He said that and I quoted it here in this House. I have the Irish Press in which it is reported and I will treasure it all my life.

Comment on this

Produce it.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, then Deputy Lemass, could not wait for a cup of tea in Waterford but dashed back to Dublin to make sure it appeared the next day.

Comment on this

You have not produced it.

Comment on this

It was useful to trick the people. That is what is said by a prominent Fianna Fáil man, to trick the people.

Comment on this

I did not say anything of the kind. Whatever misstatements the Deputy may make about Deputies who are not here to answer them, he cannot misquote me. I said produce it. It is your imagination that I said it was useful.

Comment on this

What did you say?

Comment on this

I distinctly heard Deputy Briscoe say it was useful anyway.

Comment on this

I cannot be responsible for the person who presumes to say he heard something that was not said.

Comment on this

I did hear it.

Comment on this

You did not hear it.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir. Deputy Briscoe says that I made a false statement in the House. I would request you to ask him to withdraw it. I distinctly heard the word used.

Comment on this

I am sitting beside Deputy Briscoe and I did not hear him make that remark.

Comment on this

I emphatically say I heard the word used.

Comment on this

Now I know the position the reporters were in at the Ard-Fheis when Deputy Blaney delivered his opus about Radio Eireann.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Somebody said it because I heard it.

Comment on this
Liam Cunningham Acting-Chairman (Mr. Cunningham) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy concerned said he did not use the word.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It was said anyway.

Comment on this

Would it not be better if the Deputies allowed Deputy Lynch to continue with his statement?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It would be better for Deputies on both sides of the House, and for Deputy Lynch also, if they allowed the Deputy to continue with his speech.

Comment on this

They always fly at me when I interrupt them.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy is now straying from the trend of the debate.

Comment on this

They cheated the people with the opus in Belmullet and with the opus in my constituency in Waterford. They cheated the people through the Waterford statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that there would be no unemployment on the railways if Fianna Fáil were returned to power. In this document I have with me they said they were out for action. Look at the action we have got for the past three or four weeks. We came here two days one week one day another week and we had no meeting at all another week because there was no business. There were no proposals, no 100,000 jobs. That is the way they have cheated the people. They are the people who now have the brass to say that they have a long term policy. They have the largest majority ever held by a Government in this House. Anything they want to do they can do it. Let them do it. Let them get cracking.

Comment on this

I think the House should have on an occasion like this a statement of Government policy. One Minister has already given his contribution. I sat here during his speech hoping I would hear some indication of what Government policy for the coming year was to be like, but so far no such indication has been given. The House has been treated with contempt and the people of the country with disrespect by the Government in this matter. I think it is not good enough, in view of the fact that we have three kindred major problems at the present time—emigration, unemployment and the high cost of living.

The high cost of living has been brought about largely by the removal of the food subsidies. Deputy Brennan attempted to excuse the Government for removing the food subsidies on butter and bread by giving the stock argument that it became necessary to do this because of some action of the inter-Party Government. I suppose other speakers from the Government side will maintain the same thing. I want to ask those who think in that way what Government produced that situation in 1947 when, out of the blue, it was decided to increase the taxes on drink and tobacco. Was there an inter-Party Government or Coalition Government prior to that time to produce such a background?

Again, when the inter-Party Government went out of office in 1951 we left the Minister for Finance with £24,500,000 of Marshall Aid money unspent. Despite that, they came along and cut the food subsidies in 1952 when they produced their disastrous Budget of that year. We left the country in first-class shape again this time and again the subsidies on bread and butter were completely removed despite the fact that we left them £5,000,000 in the Prize Bond Fund which was not available to us. Despite this they raised a further blister on the backs of the poor people. They captured £8,500,000 from these poor people by the withdrawal of the food subsidies.

Deputy Briscoe interrupted a few moments ago to say there is plenty of money now. Of course they have plenty of money now. We left them the Prize Bond Fund and the removal of the subsidies plus the £10,000,000 Loan brought the kitty up to £25,000,000. Despite that it is impossible for a person anxious to build his own house to get a grant either from the Government or from a county council. Housing is completely finished. Perhaps Deputy Briscoe could tell us why housing has been knocked on the head by the people who in all probability have fairly good houses themselves and who do not know what it is to live under the roof of an old shack, 150 years old. These people say to the poor occupants of such shacks: "Continue on living in that shack because you will not get your grant to build a new one."

The same is true of the land project which Deputy Dillon initiated when he was Minister for Agriculture. Every possible obstacle has been put in the way of those who want their land reclaimed. The land reclamation scheme was considered by every sensible person in this country to be the best scheme of its kind ever introduced. It was a tremendous boon to many farmers who are paying rent and rates for useless portions of their holdings. Through this scheme it was possible for them to bring some extra acres into production. Now the reply most applicants get is that their land is too shallow, too wet, too deep or too rocky.

Would somebody on the Government side tell me why that scheme has been deliberately sabotaged? It has been sabotaged in Mayo. If the same does not apply elsewhere I shall be very glad to hear it. If the Minister for Agriculture were here I should like to ask him what it is proposed to do in regard to the report of the Milk Costings Commission. We heard a great deal of talk about it during the past three years when we were in office. There is not a word about it now. Have Deputies on the other side ceased to be so vociferous because there is some truth in the rumour that they intend to reduce the price of milk? It is high time something was done about this report. It is high time something was done about it.

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, Deputy Ó Briain, was wailing and shedding tears at least twice a week in this House during the period of the last inter-Party Government because the Milk Costings Report was not finished, as though the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, could walk up to the chairman of the commission, put a gun to his head and demand the report whether finished or not.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy advocate a reduction in the price of milk?

Comment on this

No such thing.

Comment on this

I understood that was what the Deputy wanted.

Comment on this

That is not the first wrong thing the Deputy understood. I would be only too glad if it was. I have a sneaking regard for the Deputy but at the same time I am afraid he has been guilty of the most atrocious statements in this House. I heard many of them which I let go unchallenged. He is accustomed to making such statements.

Comment on this

I suppose the former Minister for Lands is still thinking about the "babes in the wood."

Comment on this

Perhaps I am a bit dull or stupid but I cannot follow the Deputy's reference.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not remember when I brought in the little trees to show them to him?

Comment on this

I remember now. The Deputy went into a nursery down the country, pulled a year-old seedling, brought it up and exposed it in the House as something the Forestry Department had done.

Comment on this

They were brought in from all over the country.

Comment on this

Brought in from a nursery. No trees were planted under three years old during my period of office and I would say that no other Minister was so foolish as to plant anything like that either.

Comment on this

The trouble is that Deputy Davern went back to the nursery.

Comment on this

I think he is still in it. Let me tell Deputy Davern that it was the inter-Party Government that put forestry on its feet in this country as well as many other useful projects. I am glad that it is one activity, at least, that has escaped the axe since Fianna Fáil came back because I do not know of any other branch of Government activity that has not suffered despite the fact that Fianna Fáil lured the people into supporting them through the Tánaiste's £100,000,000 plan, and the promises from the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste that the food subsidies would not be removed.

Comment on this

Had you not decided to remove them on 26th November, 1956?

Comment on this

That is not true. It is not even good politics. If Deputy Davern wants to tell a lie like that he should at least try to tell a lie that will stick——

Comment on this

It is not a lie it is the truth.

Comment on this

It is futile to say that we were planning to remove the subsidies.

Comment on this

No, you decided to do it.

Comment on this

I can go further and admit a bit of innocence on my own part—I did not believe that Fianna Fáil would remove them.

Comment on this

You are an innocent man.

Comment on this

I admit that, and that is why I do not blame the people so much for believing what they were told by the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste. I did not think they would have the colossal "neck" to do it particularly after the promises made by the Leader and Deputy-Leader of the Party that they would not remove the food subsidies.

I want to ask the Government why the import levies which we imposed on certain luxury goods were removed. We imposed such levies in order to bring the balance of payments into some kind of equilibrium. We succeeded in that and I remember the Tánaiste speaking on this side of the House when these levies were imposed and saying that the only fault he had to find with them was that they were not severe enough. I want to know why these levies were removed because it hits the people down the country though that might not appear to be so.

The motor car manufacturers certainly seem to have a deadly grasp on the present Government and it would take a great deal of talk from the other side of the House to convince me of the contrary. It appears that any string they pull, the Government, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce particularly, must dance to their music. That is a serious matter.

We had a Minister boasting to-day that the last loan was over-subscribed, but if we had floated a loan at an exorbitant rate of interest we would have had the same result. We did not believe in asking the ordinary working man to pay 6 per cent. interest on a loan, because it is the small man in Deputy Davern's constituency and mine who must pay that interest. The wonder is that the Government did not make it 10 per cent. I should like to know who fixed or dictated the interest rate on this loan?

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman, and all to his credit.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman is not Minister for Finance. It was Deputy MacEntee, now Minister for Health, the man who slashed the subsidies before, and he must have a clique of very powerful supporters in the wealthy classes who are able to make him dance to every tune they play.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy Blowick is alleging that Deputy MacEntee is Minister for Finance——

Comment on this

He is in cold storage now.

Comment on this

In case Deputy Corry would have any doubts about what I said, that is the way it appears to me, and if the Deputy does not like it he can lump it. I want to tell Deputy Corry that I have a little experience of pressure being put on Ministers, and perhaps we were not politically wise in not playing ball with certain people, but we believe in holding ourselves free.

Comment on this

You did not wake up until you were thrown out.

Comment on this

No doubt Deputy Corry can go down and fool the people in the country, as he admitted——

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy Corry has just said that he is going to see a Deputy "run" out of the House.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I did not hear the Deputy say that.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry could not run himself down to the Front Bench in his own Party, never mind run anyone out of the House. I want to ask whatever member of the Government will be speaking during the remainder of this debate something that the House and the country ought to know. What does the Government intend to do about the three major problems facing the country to-day, emigration, the high cost of living, and unemployment? These are three burning questions, especially the denuding of the country of its boys and girls that never occurred here since the famine.

Comment on this

95,000 went out in your time.

Comment on this

Very well, let us say there was a huge exedus but the Deputy's Party has a working majority such as no Party ever had before. Suppose that we left a mess behind. The Deputy's Party is there now, put there by the people to clear up the situation. They were not put there to spend their time crying about what happened in the past. Let them take off their coats and to use the words of their own expression in the last election, "Get cracking". It is about time they did so.

Comment on this
Erskine Hamilton Childers Minister for Lands (Mr. Childers) Fianna Fáil

My first reaction on hearing the last speaker is to say that anything which we could do quickly in this country to increase employment would largely be fugitive in character because the big problem is a long term problem requiring organisation, thought, study and careful action. It would be easy enough to spend a few million pounds on giving employment temporarily to people, but that would be a useless expenditure if the net result was that we were unable to find further moneys to go on keeping those people employed. That is the truth. We will not solve the problems of the country by quick, rapid fire legislation. The problems are deeper than that. The problems may require legislation and organisation in many forms, Government action, Government assistance and Government capital guarantees. But, whatever else they may require, they are not the kind of problems which can be solved simply by shoving into the Dáil a mass of legislation within five months of our coming into office. I think everybody appreciates that.

The second matter I should like to deal with before coming to the major comments I have to make is that, regardless of how Deputies in opposition may interpret individual statements made by members of this Party during the general election, that election was fought on the whole in a spirit of grim realism. All we said was that we were going to do our best to get some of the wheels moving as quickly as possible.

Comment on this

Relentlessly, to end unemployment.

Comment on this

I and all my colleagues said over and over again that the road would be tough and hard and long, and the job would not be done easily.

Comment on this

Women were asked to vote Fianna Fáil to get their husbands back to work.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps Deputy O'Higgins would allow me to say something. Every Deputy is allowed to speak and, when a Deputy rises to speak, he should be allowed to speak without interruption. The Chair will have to ensure that that happens.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! Unfortunately that was not the case when Deputy Blowick was speaking. Deputy Davern kept interrupting.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! The Minister for Lands.

Comment on this

A good deal has been said of what is now described as the £100,000,000 plan of Fianna Fáil. It is as well to give the facts about the £100,000,000 plan. We decided we would publish an elaborate statement dealing with all the financial and economic problems as we found them. We made it absolutely clear in the preface to the first statement we published that these were ideas for consideration and did not constitute an official political policy. We encouraged everybody to comment on them. We made it perfectly clear in the substance of the plan, as published, that it simply gave a blue print to the sort of things that might be done in order to achieve full employment.

Comment on this

Let's get cracking!

Comment on this

That plan was reprinted and in the second version we said we had to take account of the fact that there had been a serious disimprovement in the financial state of the country. We made it absolutely clear that the raising of capital depended on capital being available and savings being available and we again repeated, beyond all doubt, that these were plans for study and consideration. Many of them could be quickly accepted as good ideas. Others would require study in the light of conditions as we found them if we should be asked to form a Government. That was a very definite statement made in the publication of that plan and it is useless for Deputies on the other side to wave it around and call it the official programme of political action at the time of the election, because it was not.

Comment on this

It was merely a dodge to get votes.

Comment on this

I would like to state again that in our official policy we said we would do as much as possible to get going; we said we had faith we could do the job in the end; that we could expand production and could find capital provided there was a stable Government and a stable financial policy, and provided everyone understood where we were going and how we were going. I do not think anybody could deny that the general election was fought in that atmosphere. We realised, and we made it clear, that our difficulties would be great. We made it clear that our problems would be many. Nobody yet on the opposite side has repeated the statement made by the former Minister for Finance that the savings of two world wars, totalling nearly £200,000,000, had largely been spent; therein lay the problem facing the Government in 1956 and in 1957. That is the key to our present difficulty.

Comment on this

I notice the Minister on this occasion is nearer to what I said than he has been on any former occasion. He has always used the word "wasted" before. I am glad he has changed now. I never used the word "wasted" although the Minister has alleged up and down the country that I did.

Comment on this

He has a slush mentality.

Comment on this

As I have said, that changed the situation. All these savings were accumulated. They were spent, and the adjustment has been painful. On an average, over a period of ten years there was £20,000,000 extra circulating every year—a form of purchasing power that came from savings and not from current production. This was equivalent to an expenditure of about £37 per year in every household for a period of ten years. Naturally this expenditure made a great difference to our economy, made a great difference to the appearance of things, gave people the idea that there was a kind of artificial prosperity and standards could be very quickly earned of an artificial character; that money was flowing freely in a permanent way and that money was available for this kind of scheme and that kind of scheme and for this kind of public service and that kind of public service; that the flow of money would continue and that nothing, apparently, was going to end it.

The position is that we have now exhausted these reserves and they have to be built up again. I might add that during that period everything possible was done by many members of the two Coalition Governments to confuse the mind of the public over these savings. The people went through periods of several years listening to Ministers of the Coalition Government criticising the Fianna Fáil Administration for checking the spending of savings. But, if we had not checked the spending of these savings in 1952, the result would have been more serious than it was, in fact, in 1955. We had no reserves to deal with a temporary trade recession. We were one of the very few countries with savings when the war ended. Most countries lost their savings during the war.

There were very few in our lucky position and we should have dealt with our savings more carefully and used them for productive purposes and not for the purpose of giving the people the impression that they could enjoy a standard of living based on a rise in agricultural prices which simply could not continue indefinitely. Everybody was given the impression that the Government somehow could induce employment on a permanent scale, using savings. A false impression was given to the people as to what the capacities of the nation were in regard to maintaining the standard of living. A great deal of that was the result of the influence of the Coalition Government.

I remember lectures and lectures and lectures for months and months and months on the price of cigarettes and on the cost of living. I remember discussions on the value of spending our savings as quickly as possible. It did not matter how they were spent or on what they were spent. I remember hearing people accusing the Fianna Fáil Government of being a hair-shirt Government, not wanting the people to enjoy themselves and, at the end, there came the real and genuine hair-shirt Government in 1956 when there were insufficient savings to enable us to get through what was not a major trade depression but simply a situation in which our exports temporarily decreased in relation to our imports. We should, as a creditor nation, have had a full volume of savings available at that time to cushion us over that difficult period. All that we can say in Fianna Fáil is that the facts are clearly there and that we were not responsible for the disruption of those activities.

Comment on this

Would the Minister mind answering one question? The major part of those savings was spent on housing. Does the Minister think that is a good or bad thing?

Comment on this

I would not agree with the Deputy that they were spent on housing. I think a great deal of that money was spent on importing consumer goods instead of capital goods. I understand that Deputy Dillon, in the course of his speech, referred to my deprecation of the spending of capital. Deputy Dillon always likes to twist and turn statements made by other people. I said that we had spent £228,000,000 of State capital from 1947 to 1956 and of that some £2,000,000 was spent on promoting industry and £26,000,000 on promoting agriculture, and that the remainder had not been spent directly for the promotion of useful production. I said that it would be better if we had spent more of our savings in developing production, in solving unemployment; in preparing to face foreign competition; in preparing markets for our produce; in preparing new types of agricultural exports and in preparing to export more. If we had spent money on those projects in the earlier years we would now be able to spend all the money we need on housing.

It is the question of the direction of capital spending that is important. I never advocated that we should not spend State capital for useful projects. All the useful projects that we have in this country at the moment were initiated by the present Government. In those years we should have been arguing about how we were going to develop our exports and instead of arguing here and listening to lectures from 1947 to 1951 on the cost of living we should have been arguing about the work of establishing the export economy of this country on a firm and expanding basis.

We are now living in a different world. We require to build up our savings sufficiently so that if there should be another trade recession, when our imports and our exports show adverse trends, we will have enough to get us over the crisis without having to impose levies or without involving ourselves in measures which would lead to unemployment. At the moment capital is difficult to get because the savings of our people have been depleted and the money has to be saved over again. That has been said as much by the former Minister for Finance as by the present Minister for Finance.

We find it impossible to end emigration or to bring about an increase in employment when the finances available to the Government are not of the magnitude that they require. One of the most important problems facing us in the future is to establish the right atmosphere in which money will be available for economic productivity. We have got to rely on private enterprise to improve our trade. The Government cannot export goods or agricultural produce. It is essential that the people recognise that we have a stable Government and a stable policy that is likely to last.

The people in this country who are ambitious and who are going to help to develop our economy must be persuaded that we do accept certain vital facts in regard to our economic position and one of these is that our costs must be kept down. If people are going to invest money, they have got to be convinced that they are investing in a stable economy and that their investments will be given a chance to earn profits.

We must cheerfully face certain disadvantages. There is the disadvantage of the small home market; the disadvantage of being more remote from the main stream of European commerce, and there are also certain disadvantages with regard to freight rates. We must overcome disadvantages and still go ahead and increase our exports. We may be able to do it by producing goods of a better quality; perhaps by selling at lower prices. This may mean changes in our marketing methods, Government help in stabilising exports and other changes, largely of a technical or marketing character, to bring about a stability in our economy which will encourage people to spend money here in producing more goods.

People have got to become accustomed to the idea that there must be a certain definite fund of savings available to help in productive schemes. One of our difficulties is the maintenance of capital saving, and there still is a deficiency of capital for productive purposes. For prosperity it is essential that the ambitious people in this country who are willing to help us to increase productivity get accustomed to the idea that capital will be available if they want it for productive purposes.

All these matters require very careful study. In regard to agriculture, we will have to examine the markets available; we will have to investigate the expansion of existing and new markets. We will need to study the whole problem of our export trade and to examine the export of agricultural products which have not yet been developed here. All of that is of supreme importance. We have also to face the coming into being of the Free Trade Area and its impact on this country. None of that can be done overnight. It cannot be done by introducing Bill after Bill into this House. It is ludicrous to think that we can bring prosperity by sitting in the Dáil and examining Bills. Prosperity will not come that way. Prosperity will come by the greatest possible personal leadership of Ministers and everybody in the House in persuading people to invest their money and making sure of providing more channels for exports if they are required.

There are many problems such as, for example, the fact that many of our industrial units are small. It may be necessary to have some sort of cooperative marketing scheme for certain industries, for any of them which will be able to afford to export, to provide new designs and to provide the commercial salesmen, to enable them to get over the difficulties of freight costs and the other difficulties of trading abroad. That problem has to be examined. As I have said, it takes time and it will need four or five years of hard and consistent work before we can solve these problems and help to develop the economy of the country.

I heard references by some Deputies that we made some promises we would never reduce the subsidies. We made no such promises. We would be crazy if we had made a promise that we would never reduce the subsidies in the light of our experience in discovering a Budget deficit in 1951 and that on resuming office we would find ourselves with a second Budget deficit. It was largely because of the Budget deficit which we faced that we found it necessary to abandon the subsidies.

No one in this election voted against the members of the Opposition because of any statement made about subsidies. They voted against the Opposition because they wanted a resolute Government. We are here now and we have a very tough task before us which we will discharge to the best of our ability.

Comment on this

This Government has been in office for nearly nine months now and if it has succeeded in one way more than another, it has been in the direction of maintaining a complete wall of secrecy as to the policy it intends to pursue. During the past nine months we have had speeches from Ministers, we have had debates here on the Budget and on important Estimates, but never once during the last nine months have we got from the Taoiseach or any of his Ministers a glimmer of policy as far as Fianna Fáil is concerned.

It is true that the Minister for Lands travelled the country like a kind of human ready-reckoner, quoting figures in abundance and almost mathematising the country into prosperity by quoting these figures. I commend the Minister's research proclivities, but when all has been said and done about these figures, we still cannot discover any indications as to the direction of Government policy. The House will now adjourn for approximately two months. Between now and 10.30 the Taoiseach might disclose the secret of the Government's policy which so far has been more closely guarded than any Budget secret of many years.

I thought that this would be the occasion on which we would have an indication from the Tánaiste as to when the £100,000,000 plan would be put into operation. When Fianna Fáil was in opposition they produced this famous plan. The £100,000,000 was not to be got by taxation or borrowing. Some kind of political wizardy would find the £100,000,000 and it would be used for the purpose of financing a kind of economic resurgence in the country. When that resurgence took place, 20,000 new jobs were to be found each year to take up the number of people offering themselves directly from the primary and secondary schools.

Instead of telling us when they proposed to implement the plan, the Minister for Lands apparently has been sent in to lay the £100,000,000 plan to rest, because to-day he said: "Do not take any notice of the £100,000,000 plan. It was never a plan. It was a collection of ideas strung together while we were at leisure in opposition. Some day we might come back to this £100,000,000 plan and see what we could do with this collection of thoughts——

Comment on this

Some of it is in operation already. The Deputy had better be careful.

Comment on this

I would be willing to give time, either to the Minister now or to any other Minister intervening later, to explain where the £100,000,000 plan is in operation and let us view it through the unemployment figures. The plain fact of the matter is that the plan was a bogus sham by which the Fianna Fáil Party sought to mesmerise the people into giving them a new mandate in the belief that their political wizardy was such that, through the £100,000,000 plan, there would be 20,000 new jobs for people each year. In any case, the Minister for Lands has now laid the £100,000,000 plan to rest. Apparently we are to hear no more about that. It has gone into the Fianna Fáil cemetery of unfulfilled and dishonoured promises and apparently it is to remain there.

The question of prices has been raised in this debate and I notice that there have been interruptions from the Government Benches that Fianna Fáil never made any promises on prices. The Minister for Lands, in the course of his speech, said that Fianna Fáil did not promise to retain the food subsidies. Everybody can remember the constant drumming of the Fianna Fáil Party, when they were in opposition from 1954 to 1957, about what they called the cost of living.

From 1954 to 1957, the Government then in power held steady the price of bread, sugar and flour and reduced the price of butter by 5d. per lb. That happened in no other country in Europe. But notwithstanding the fact that we were able to hold steady the prices of these essential articles we were still subjected to criticism from the Fianna Fáil Party on the grounds that that was not sufficient. In the recent elections Fianna Fáil clearly made it plain to the people that, if they were in office, the people would be presented with a better and much more attractive picture and a better and more attractive life as far as prices were concerned.

It is quite clear that Fianna Fáil fooled the people on prices in the last election and that they told the people they would retain the food subsidies. During the last election I said I backed my political reputation on the fact that I believed, if Fianna Fáil got back to office, they would abolish the remainder of the food subsidies. I was convinced they would do so. There were many people who would not believe that Fianna Fáil would go to that extreme, but they did go to that extreme and the remainder of the food subsidies were abolished in the last Budget.

But what did Fianna Fáil tell the people during the last election? Did the Fianna Fáil Party not promise to retain the food subsidies in the last election? That statement of mine has been challenged by interruption and by direct statement during the course of this debate. Let us get the facts and let us get them from the Irish Press, the political bible of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Speaking at a meeting at Doyle's Corner in Phibsboro as reported in the Irish Press for the 1st March, the then Deputy Traynor, now Minister for Justice, said:—

"A blood-curdling story, a warning by Mr. Norton that Fianna Fáil would withdraw the food subsidies."

and the paper goes on to say that Deputy Traynor said:—

"The Coalition groups having no further promises to make for themselves have switched to making sinister promises on behalf of Fianna Fáil."

Deputy Traynor was not on his own in that. The Taoiseach speaking at Belmullet said:—

"The Coalition Party were changing their tactics in this election. The opponents of Fianna Fáil were wondering what new dodge they could try to prevent the people from seeing the real issue in this election."

He went on to say:—

"You know the record of Fianna Fáil in the past. You know we have never done the things they said we would do. They have also told you that you will be paying more for your bread."

How right we were to tell the people that they would be paying more for their bread! They are paying more to-day for their bread than they have paid during the past 35 years and all this notwithstanding the present Taoiseach's denial at Belmullet that there would be no withdrawal of the subsidies.

Comment on this

He was misreported.

Comment on this

Quote what I did say.

Comment on this

I am quoting this.

Comment on this

I shall deal with it later.

Comment on this

Now we turn to the then Deputy Lemass, now Minister for Industry and Commerce. There was nothing indefinite about his remarks. He said on that occasion that some Coalition leaders were threatening the country with all sorts of sinister things if Fianna Fáil became the Government — compulsory tillage, wage controls, cuts in civil servants' salaries, and higher food prices — and he went on to say that the Fianna Fáil Government did not intend to do any of these things because they did not believe in them. He added, by way of clinching his argument: "How definite can we make our denial of these stupid allegations? They are all falsehoods?" That was Deputy Lemass. There was no doubt about the positiveness of that statement.

Earlier, speaking at Mallow, he said that the food subsidies must be accepted as being likely to be a permanent feature in the Estimates, unless a very steep fall in the cost of living should take place and that was not very likely. He added that he would like to express a personal point of view, which he held strongly, that the maximum advantage could be obtained by concentrating all the money which could be afforded on food subsidies, on flour and bread alone. Three months after that statement was made the food subsidies were abolished. The concentration of all the money we could afford on the subsidisation of flour is now just a fragrant memory and instead of maintaining the food subsidies on flour and bread, the Government have abolished both and in the same Budget have given a free gift of £250,000 to the master bakers of this country. That is the Government's record on prices.

Comment on this

The Deputy's own actions were responsible for that.

Comment on this

I repudiate that and the Taoiseach will find nothing in any file in the Department of Industry and Commerce which even remotely suggests that.

Comment on this

It was on that basis.

Comment on this

It was not and I challenge the Taoiseach to set up a committee of inquiry into the matter.

Comment on this

Before you reduced the loaf.

Comment on this

I can tell the Minister for Finance that the people would welcome our loaf to-day. They could pay for it but they cannot pay for their bread to-day. Ask any baker around the country how much bread he is selling to-day compared with 12 months ago. That is the sordid history of the Government, of promises which have been repudiated, which have been ignominously torn up, promises made to deceive the people in the last election. These promises succeeded in doing that and the Government is in office now with one of the largest majorities in this House for the last 35 years. It is a majority which should give them the power to do things in the fulfilment of their promises but the majority is being used to enable them to repudiate the promises on which they rode into office, by deluding the people.

Look at the way the cost of living has moved since this Government came into office. According to the Irish Trade Journal the consumer price index in mid-February was 135. It had moved up to 138 by mid-May and by mid-August it had jumped to 143 so that between mid-February and mid-August the figure had jumped from 135 to 143. I think international statistics will show that that is a higher increase than has taken place in any other country in Western Europe. You can imagine the howls that would have gone up from the Fianna Fáil Benches if that striking and savage increase had taken place in a period of six months when the last Government was in office. Yet this official index shows that Fianna Fáil, not being merely content to repudiate their election promises, now have to their discredit a price increase greater than, I believe, anything that has taken place in the last six months in Western Europe.

I remember during the last election, in the course of my travels, seeing Fianna Fáil posters which urged women to vote for Fianna Fáil and put their husbands back in employment. That was another snare set to trap the credulous people and it worked in the last election. A lot of people believed that the mesmerism of the Fianna Fáil Party was such that all they had to do was vote Fianna Fáil to ensure that all difficulties would be settled and would vanish overnight.

What are the facts? I have here before me the last returns issued by the Central Statistics Office as to the number of people unemployed. The number unemployed this year on the 23rd November was 67,392. Last year there were on the same date, 71,157. But in November, 1955, there were only 54,424. In other words the position is that the number of unemployed to-day is 3,764 fewer than this time last year but the number of unemployed to-day is over 13,000 above the number unemployed in November, 1955.

The striking thing is that if you look at the figures for the week-ends of the 16th and 23rd November you find that the number of unemployed this year is now increasing over these weekly periods at a faster rate than the number increased during the same weeks of last year. After nine months in office the Government has succeeded in bringing the figure of unemployed down by 3,700 as compared with November of last year. But, as I said, it is still 13,000 up on the figure for November, 1955, when the inter-Party Government was in office. Of course, this figure of 3,700 is easily explained. During the past nine months there has been unparalleled emigration from this country.

Comment on this

None at all from 1955 to 1956.

Comment on this

Sure you were to get cracking.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is living in a fool's paradise if he thinks there has not been this mass emigration during the past nine months. It is increasing at an alarming rate. I invite the Taoiseach to inquire from a number of building trade unions what has been their experience in the past nine months. Some of these unions have now more members in England than in Ireland. Building trade workers have packed their bags at an alarming rate during the past nine months and notwithstanding that, the present trade unions have still such a number of unemployed on their books that they have reached a period of employment stagnation greater than they have ever before experienced.

These figures can be checked without difficulty. Is it any wonder, therefore, that we have reached this situation? Look at the replies to questions in this House. They have disclosed that there are fewer people employed in afforestation work this year than last year, that there are fewer people employed in rural electrification this year than last year, that there are fewer people employed on the roads this year than last year, that there are fewer employed in housing this year than last year, that there are substantially fewer people employed on drainage work for the simple reason that the Fianna Fáil Government, unlike the inter-Party Government, has stopped all grants which were payable under the Local Authorities (Works) Act.

How could unemployment figures be reduced by 3,700 were it not for the fact that there is unprecedented large-scale emigration, when these potent sources of employment — afforestation, road work, rural electrification, housing and drainage — are this year providing less employment than was provided last year in these various activities? The Government must know that. Anybody interested in ascertaining the facts can get the replies to parliamentary questions given in this House. To-day, in reply to a parliamentary question, a statement was given on behalf of the Taoiseach that the Government had indicated recently what its proposals were when dealing with the problem of unemployment.

Is the Taoiseach satisfied with these proposals? Has he still not got even a lingering suspicion that the proposals will make no substantial contribution to the relief of unemployment, that, while he is talking about proposals for the relief of unemployment the figures of unemployment of men and women keep on rising and rising at a greater rate than this time last year? What is the use of leading people into the belief that the Government has a policy for unemployment when the people cannot see evidence of the Government's policy on it and when the people know it is harder to get jobs this year than it was last year? That fact has been responsible for filling every boat that is leaving for England with people who have been frustrated from efforts to get jobs here, especially when they were told in the last General Election that if women voted for Fianna Fáil their husbands would get back to work.

Somebody should keep faith with these people or apologise to these people because they were ensnared into voting for a Party which said it had an economic policy. That policy has not helped these people find employment; it has put them into the boats to find employment in another country. Even now I want to ask the Taoiseach what policy the Government has which is likely to bring down the number of unemployed. I am certain it is going to rise rapidly after Christmas. I am certain it will rise going into the spring and that then we will have a vast army of unemployed people here.

What is the Government going to do to relieve that problem? The Minister for Lands says he believes this country needs resolute Government. Eighteen months ago he said in Rathkeale that this country needs 20 years of resolute Government. I think Balfour was the last person who gave utterance to these views. The Minister for Lands takes pleasure in saying that we have now a resolute Government. Resolute in what? Is it resolute in doing nothing while the employment figures rise rapidly, resolute in keeping social welfare benefits at a scale utterly inadequate having regard to the recent and rapid rise in the cost of living, resolute in not disclosing its policy, by sitting tight now that they have got into office and that they have got such a large majority that they are sure of staying there for the next four years? Would anybody believe a resolute Government of that character is any use to the people or capable of relieving the nation from the many difficulties which beset it to-day, or that it is calculated to bring a brighter ray into the lives of the people whose lives have been so long darkened by the consistent spectre of unemployment?

This Government got from its predecessors a very substantial gift in the form of the steps which the last Government took to control the balance of payments. We imposed levies.

Comment on this

And unemployment.

Comment on this

To check the import of luxury and non-essential goods we imposed levies, and when we saw that the first levies were not sufficient to do that we increased the levies, and by doing so——

Comment on this

Increased unemployment.

Comment on this

——were responsible for the stopping of the importation of large quantities of luxury and non-essential goods. That was a most unpopular action to take, but we believed the necessities of the situation demanded it. I have no hesitation in saying that when the figures of the imports and exports are checked, and when allowance is made for our invisible exports in the form of tourism earnings, emigrants' remittances and dividends on foreign investments, it will be shown that in the 10 months from June, 1956, to July, 1957, we did, in fact, effect balance in our trade relations. That balance was effected three or four months after we left office, and this Government knows that in July last the balance had been struck and equilibrium had been reached in our balance of payments. Were it not for the fact that we took these measures the Government now would be wrestling with the problem of restoring equilibrium to our balance of payments.

Now Ministers can chirp round the country and say, "Not only have we secured equilibrium in our balance of payments but we are building up sterling assets again." One has only to look at bank figures to see that the banks are again building up sterling assets, adding more and more to these assets. I do not complain about that; I think it is a good development. That is the development we sought to achieve but it was very fortunate for this Government that within three or four months of taking office they were able to say that, in fact, a balance had been effected so far as our trading relations were concerned.

I have no doubt we incurred considerable odium by imposing these levies at that time but it was the right thing to do then, and it would be cowardice to shrink from doing it. As a result of doing it, the present Government was able to inherit a balanced situation so far as our payments were concerned much earlier than they would have been able to achieve that balance if we had not taken these steps as early and as drastically as we did.

I should like to find out what Government policy now is in respect of foreign investment. Before and while I was Minister for Industry and Commerce I urged people outside this country to bring their money here to a country which had a stable Government which was not likely to be in the cockpit of war, which had no Communist movement. I urged them to invest that money in setting up industries here to make goods which were not already produced here. Barely had I said that when a howl of criticism was released from all the shallow minds of the Fianna Fáil Party saying this was absolutely anti-national, calculated to do irreparable damage to Irish industry.

It was intended to do no such thing because Irish industrialists cannot live in a country from which the population is fleeing by every boat and plane leaving the country. The Irish industrialist can only survive in a country where people have jobs. He cannot make profits out of a situation in which 70,000 or 100,000 people are unemployed. People cannot be consumers of goods if they have no money to purchase them. I wanted to invite these foreign industrialists to come here and invest their money in manufacturing goods not already produced here. That point of view and that advocacy of mine was subjected to the criticism of shallow minds. I defended my action then and I defend it now, first, on the ground that every intelligent country in Europe has done, and is trying to do, the same thing.

In my view, it is much better to get a foreign industrialists to invest money and start industries in Ireland rather than stand idly by refusing to think, while seeing tens of thousands of our young boys and girls going to work in foreign countries, in factories financed by foreign capital, and living according to a foreign concept of life when, in fact, by inviting foreign industrialists to invest here in establishing Irish industries we could adopt the far preferable course of finding employment for these people in their own land.

I notice there has been a rapid conversion in the Fianna Fáil party.

Comment on this

I wonder who was converted? Does the Deputy want to suggest that he began that policy?

Comment on this

I know the Fianna Fáil Party began the opposite policy with the Control of Manufactures Act which, it is now realised, is in everybody's way and which the Government has now promised to repeal.

Comment on this

What about the pawnbrokers' three balls?

Comment on this

It had nothing to do with that.

Comment on this

Indeed it had.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party is now whispering its tune to foreign investment. I think that is right. It is a sane and sound policy and I hope it will remain their policy because it is the only intelligent policy for a country of this kind which is not rich in natural resources, which is an outpost of Western Europe and out of the main commercial stream and which is suffering from endemic unemployment and from an emigration problem the like of which is not confronting any other similar country in the world to-day.

I avail, therefore, of this opportunity to welcome this conversion in the Fianna Fáil Party. I hope the Control of Manufactures Act will be interred with appropriate honours side by side with the £100,000,000 plan which was laid to rest by the Minister for Justice this afternoon.

I want to refer also to the Government's attitude towards what is now colloquially known as the Free Trade Area. The Minister for Health was let loose recently to make a speech for the Minister for Industry and Commerce and in describing what the effects of the Free Trade Area were likely to be on this country he said: "If we do not export we shall rapidly approach the time when the mainland of this country will be as depopulated as the Blaskets." There was cheerful advice to give the industrialists as to what the Free Trade Area may mean to us unless, apparently, we go into it and can export goods to it.

I have no doubt the Government will try to do its best to get from the architects of the Free Trade Area the best kind of settlement that can be got to suit our interests, but I am bound to say that I do not see anywhere in speeches by Ministers any recognition of how serious is the question of our entry to or our standing aloof from the Free Trade Area, so far as our industrialists and agricultural possibilities are concerned. Whatever we do in this respect will be very largely dictated by the economic compulsion which will follow whatever Britain decides to do, so far as the Free Trade Area is concerned. If we do not go into the Free Trade Area we have the pleasure of standing aloof as an outpost of Western Europe; if we go in, all the tariff barriers will go down, maybe not immediately but progressively, and one day they will go entirely and then our infant industries will have to meet wintry competition from countries which are highly mechanised, which have a long industrial tradition and which have know-how vastly superior to what we possess in many of our industrial fields.

My complaint is that I do not think the Government is adequately warning industrialists who will be affected by the coming into operation of the Free Trade Area. I hear words used by the Minister for Industry and Commerce which seem to me to be a misrepresentation of the position. He talks about the Free Trade Area being a great challenge to us, a Free Trade Area being something from which we will not run away. That is too lurid language to use for the situation which presents itself to us to-day.

The Government ought to make it clear to industrialists what the full effect of our entry into the Free Trade Area is likely to be for our industries if our industrialists are compelled to meet the unrestricted challenge of imports from highly industrialised, highly organised and highly rationalised industries in other countries. I do not believe many of our present industries could survive in an export market. I think a very large number of them will not be able to survive in the home market unless, in the meantime, they can gear their organisation and adapt and reorientate their organisation in such a way as to enable them to meet what, in my view, is not just a great challenge but what looks like being a mortal blow so far as Irish industry is concerned.

I do not want to see a Free Trade Area, after all that has been done to develop Irish industry, operate in such a way that one industry after the other will go down under the blows of European competition; that will have the effect of converting this country again into a vast cattle ranch for the production of cheap beef and cheap foodstuffs for other countries. I think the Government could well spend a good deal of time in analysing the consequences of the coming into operation of the Free Trade Area. They should establish an economic secretariat for the purpose of warning industrialists and explaining to industrialists what it will be necessary for them to do if they are to meet the situation which will arise here so far as the implementation of the Free Trade Area is concerned.

I think the problem and the difficulties have been played down too much — that there has been a certain lightheartedness about it because it appears to be far away. It is already too close to us, too close to burke any further delay in realising what threatens us. While, as I said, I believe and I am satisfied the Government will do everything possible to get the best terms for this country, at the same time I think something more than that is necessary. The whole home industrial machine must have brought home to it the seriousness of the situation confronting it so that our industrialists, by every means available to them and with Government aid, if necessary, may meet this serious danger which, I think, could well undo all that we have tried to do to establish our secondary industries here over the past 35 years.

I do not want to delay the House further except to ask the Taoiseach to avail of this opportunity to tell the House what the Government's economic policy is. What does it hope to do to deal with the serious unemployment problem at the moment and with the still more serious unemployment problem which will supervene when Christmas is over? The Government told the electorate that they had a policy for dealing with all our economic ills. We have never got any details of that policy. It was epitomised under the slogan: "Get cracking!" The Government has adopted a Rip Van Winkle attitude so far as "get cracking" is concerned over the last nine months. It is not too much now to ask them to wake up and, in face of the serious economic difficulties confronting the country, tell the people what they are going to do. The people were promised that they would be led to "Great Expectations". After nine months of Fianna Fáil Government they see themselves being consigned to "Bleak House".

The Minister for Finance and Deputy Crotty rose.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Crotty.

Comment on this

The Government have been in office now for nine months.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Might I point out, at this stage, that the Chair is calling on Deputy Crotty having regard to the motion before the House? Three Fianna Fáil speakers, two Fine Gael speakers, two Labour speakers and one Clan na Talmhan speaker have taken part in the debate.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

Will I be allowed to speak this evening?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair will consider that in due course.

Comment on this

The Government has now been in office for a period of nine months and on no occasion during that time has their general policy been disclosed. The Bills brought before the House were the identical Bills prepared by the inter-Party Government, even to the extent of the Bill setting up the Institute of Agriculture. That was practically the identical Bill prepared by the inter-Party Government. If, however, the Government have shown inactivity in the preparation of Bills they have certainly shown great activity from another point of view, namely, in relation to the resounding blow they have struck the ordinary man in the street and the ordinary householder by the introduction of their Budget earlier this year, in which they increased the price of bread from 9d. to 1/2 per 2-lb. loaf. When they took the subsidy off bread they removed bread from the table of the ordinary household.

The Government did that because they were not in touch with the ordinary people. Had they been in touch, I doubt if they would have removed the subsidy. I have personal contact with people buying bread every day and I know the straits people are in trying to buy this essential commodity. One woman told me that she finds it impossible to keep bread on the table. I can well appreciate that. She has a young family. The situation may be all right for those wealthy people who go out to dine. The situation is intolerable for the ordinary person who has to provide bread for every meal during the day.

After the general election in 1954 the inter-Party Government felt that the ordinary people were being deprived of butter because of the prohibitive price and their first action was to reduce the price of butter from 4/2 to 3/9. When the Fianna Fáil Government returned to office, not alone did they put back the price to 4/2 but they put on another 2d. and made the price 4/4. In other words, they increased the price of butter by 7d. That created a surplus. I do not know if the Government realises that people are no longer able to buy bread and butter. There is a reduction of practically 20 per cent. in the consumption of bread. That is borne out by every bakery in the country. What effect will that have on the wheat produced this year? What surplus will we have at the end of the year because of reduced bread consumption?

The same situation exists in relation to butter. Admittedly, there are substitutes for butter and it is the substitutes the people are buying. We are importing the raw material to manufacture a substitute for butter. There is more butter for export and on every pound of butter exported the Government is prepared to pay a subsidy of one shilling to one and three-pence. I have no great objection to a subsidy being paid on surplus butter. Where I do find fault is that we reduce our home consumption of butter, which we refuse to subsidise at 5d. per lb. for our own people, while we subsidise it to the amount of 1/-, 1/2 and 1/3 a lb. for the people of a foreign country.

In the same Budget the Government removed completely the levy on high-powered motor-cars. The person who wants a £1,500 motor-car no longer has to pay any levy on that car. It is the same with wireless sets and other non-essential goods. We may thank Fianna Fáil if the people of the country cannot have bread but can have oranges instead. However, that is very small consolation to the poor people down the country. If that happened in another country we would have a bloody revolution. I am glad to say that the people of this country are sane and are not likely to go as far as that.

However, during the past month we have had an unbloody revolution in North Central Dublin. Last March every second person who voted in the general election voted for Fianna Fáil but last month only one of every four of the people who voted, voted Fianna Fáil. Is that not a revolution in itself? Does not that show the Government the way things are going? There never was such a fall in the inter-Party vote as there was in the Fianna Fáil vote in Dublin North Central.

Unemployment is now 3,000 less than it was this time 12 months but we must remember that then we had a lot of unemployment in the motor-car industry last year and that helped to enlarge the figure. In the meantime we have had mass emigration from this country. We have all heard of the Lemass plan for the expenditure of £100,000,000. For 12 months before the last general election we had the Tánaiste explaining his plan for full employment at meetings under the auspices of various Fianna Fáil clubs throughout the country. We were tired of hearing of this plan and it is no wonder that the people changed the Government. Could you blame them with all the promises that were held out to them? We had promises from the Tánaiste to put 15,000 people annually into employment but since he has gone into Government he has been too busy with other things to bother about it.

I can speak about my own town. Unemployment in Kilkenny was never greater and the unemployment is not the worst — it is the frustration that is behind the people. If they had a hope that in a month or two there would be a change for the better, things would not be too bad but as it is they have no hope. They are frustrated and you can read frustration in the faces of people in the streets. The county council drivers have been notified this year that they are being let go. That is a thing that never happened before and when I made representations to the county surveyor to keep them on until after Christmas he said he could not do so. Even some of the clerks in the yard are being laid off.

I have heard the Minister for Lands speak twice in the last week, once in Kilkenny and once here. His speech to-night was very mild compared to the one he made in Kilkenny. There he spoke about emigration and said that we should not decry emigration. He said that for the last 300 years Scotland had much more emigration than we had but that, because of the heavy industries on the Clyde, they were able to keep up the general level of the population. He said that on one occasion all the people emigrated from Florida and left the place and that when they had all gone others came in. Is it present Government policy that when all our people have cleared out others will come in? What type of people will come back here? Is it out of the Sputniks they will come?

He said that the boom was over and that we should get down to hard work. He said that £20,000,000 was injected into the economy here every year for the last ten years. He said that that money was money which the people did not earn, and I am glad he called that £20,000,000 slush money. I am glad that I can place it on the records of this House that the Minister for Lands called that £20,000,000 slush money. Does he regard the money spent on the removal of the slums in Kilkenny as slush money? I saw houses last week, two-roomed houses, with high walls behind them lest any light might get to them, in which people reared large families. We removed those through the money spent on housing in the last ten years. Does the Minister for Lands call that slush money? Does he call the money spent on planting 90,000 acres of forestry in the last ten years slush money? Does he regard as slush money the money that was spent on the land reclamation project which brought 1,000,000 acres of land into production? That is what the Minister called slush money.

He mentioned a figure of £37 10s. per household. One would think that that amount was sent down to each household and that they had a spree on it. That money was not sent as a free gift to the people. The people earned that money and with it we have built up domestic assets in the way of housing. People who emigrated from this country 20 and 30 years ago and who come back now could not believe their eyes when they saw the improvements that had been made in our towns and cities with the expenditure of that money.

I cannot understand what the Minister meant when he said: "Wives, get your husbands out to work." I thought at first that it was some bright boy in Kilkenny who thought of that particular one until I discovered that it was posted up in every constituency in the country. Now it is not: "Wives, get your husbands out to work", but "Husbands, bring your wives to England to work."

We can see the mentality of the present Government. They say now that they have a majority and that we cannot put them out. They say that they will not move an inch. A question was asked yesterday about the Grant-in-Aid for the improved marketing of agricultural produce. That was grand window-dressing for the last Budget. Two questions were asked here yesterday about the £250,000 announced by Fianna Fáil for the marketing of agricultural produce. The reply given to those questions was that the committee to deal with that has not yet been set up, even though we are practically at the end of the financial year. Does that show efficiency?

When Deputy Childers was in Kilkenny he spoke about efficiency experts. They were to be the be-all and the end-all of everything in this country. If I got an efficiency expert into my house, everything would be all right. He said they were marvellous in the Post Office. He got efficiency experts into the Engineering Branch and, for an increase of 7½ per cent. in employment, he got an improvement of 150 per cent. in the output of work. I think the Government would be well advised to get in some efficiency experts so that they might set up this committee for the improvement of agricultural produce.

The Minister for Finance made a statement recently — at a bankers' dinner in Dublin, I think — that, due to the high cost of money, he was only raising a loan of £10,000,000 this year and that he did not want to be putting more charges on the Irish people. Why had he not the courage to say that, due to the £8,000,000 he raised on Deputy Sweetman's Prize Bonds, he did not require any more money to bridge the gap instead of putting on the old soldier and saying he did not require any more?

In this the first year of the present Government they have taken away £8,000,000 in subsidies and have abolished the Local Authorities (Works) Act. I went to the trouble of finding out the details of the number of men employed under that Act in my own county during the last four years. They are as follows:—

In 1954: February, 142; March, 128. In 1955: February, 80; March, 159. In 1956: February, 129; March, 99. In 1957: February, 133; March, 48. That is an average of 110 men employed per week.

The Government have removed the grant enabling those men to be employed. It consisted of about £20,000 to County Kilkenny over the last four years. By their deliberate action the Government have put 110 men out of work. What have they done with them? They have put them on the Employment Exchange. They will draw unemployment benefits to the extent of £12,000. Which is better? To give the men £10,000 to £12,000 through the Labour Exchange for doing nothing or give them £20,000 and have them happy men, rearing families and bringing in money hard earned? They earn only about £5 per week with the county council and they will draw roughly £3 per week in unemployment benefit.

I would make one appeal to the Taoiseach. I would ask him to consider during the recess renewing those grants. They have taken the bread from the people's table by their deliberate action in increasing the price and they have taken the butter from their table by the same method. They have put these 110 men out of employment by their deliberate action in taking the grant from the local authority. I would ask the Taoiseach to give back these grants so that these men at least will have work again, even if they are not buying a lot of bread with it.

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Finance (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

The Government's aim is an expanding economy, paying its way in transactions with other countries and providing higher living standards for a growing population. I am stating that principle and I am sure every Party will accept it. Seeing there can be no dispute on that, I intend to proceed to see whether the Government has been maintaining that principle and whether anything has come from it.

I want to quote again a few words from the Budget speech I made here last May. I said at that time:—

"This Government have full confidence in the inherent soundness of the economy and in its ability to provide higher living standards for an expanding population on the firm basis of an increase in production and exports. The relaxation of restrictions and the assurance of new reliefs, together with the maintenance of the State capital programme at a high level and the prospects of a continuing improvement in exports, should strengthen business confidence and stimulate production. The resultant growth of opportunities for work should effect a marked improvement in the unemployment situation and check the outflow of our people. We cannot hope to solve all our problems at once, but with the co-operation of every section of the community, they can be reduced in scale and urgency."

I just want to emphasise three points in what I have already quoted. In that speech I emphasised that what we wanted was an increase in production and exports. I think we can claim that there has been an increase in production and exports. I am not now dealing with the point whether that was due to the policy of the last Government or to the fact that we came into power. The fact is that over the last six or nine months we have had an increase in production and exports.

Another point I made at that time was that we cannot hope to solve our problems at once. Anybody listening to the speeches made by the Opposition speakers would not give me credit for making that statement in the Budget speech. Far from promising that all our ills would be made to go with the greatest despatch, I said at that time that we could not hope to solve all our problems at once. Everything that has happened since that only confirms me in the view that I expressed at that time.

In reply to various questions about the steps the Government had decided on to relieve unemployment, I want to quote the Taoiseach. He said:—

"The only measures of real advantage from the point of view of reducing unemployment are those which develop the economy, increase the opportunities of lasting employment or create assets of permanent value."

Everybody agrees with that.

"Any attempt now to solve our immediate problems by using up, on unproductive schemes, the limited capital resources so necessary for productive purposes would merely be postponing our difficulties and, ultimately, making them greater."

That is a quotation from Volume 164 of the Dáil Debates, columns 2 and 3 of the 23rd October.

I am merely quoting from my own Budget speech and from the Taoiseach's speech the principles we have laid before ourselves and on which we believe a proper economy can be built up in this country. You may ask what we did to make this policy a reality. Almost immediately after coming into office the Government relaxed the special import levies with a view to reducing their restricting effect on industrial activity. I think there is no doubt that, at least in some cases, the relaxation of the import levies had the effect of increasing employment in certain industries, for instance, the motor industry.

Deputy Crotty, in true Fine Gael style, again brought up this question about the big motor-car coming in free of levy. It has been pointed out to Deputy Crotty and to the Fine Gael Party generally that this was necessary under the 1938 and 1948 Agreements made with the British and it was a thing that could not be avoided under the circumstances. I do not think it is necessary to go into it because I am quite sure that Deputy Crotty will say the same again, despite whatever I may say on this occasion.

In the Budget speech I announced a number of measures due to come into effect for the tax year 1958-59. These were the raising from 50 to 100 per cent. of the relief for profits derived from increases in exports and an alternative concession which gave a 25 per cent. relief for total exports to any exporters who did not wish to have the option of accepting the relief on the increase of exports; a 25 per cent. increase in the wear and tear allowance on plant and machinery; and the extension of the tax remission provided by Section 7 of the Finance Act of 1932 to all securities issued to the public by Irish manufacturing concerns subsequent to 1932. There was also a concession of a 40 per cent. investment allowance on new ships and tax relief on certain subscriptions made for research in universities.

Comment on this

Which I had already announced six months before.

Comment on this

As I said before the Deputy came in, I am not at this stage saying that this is due to one Government or another; I am just saying what has been done. In addition to providing these tax reliefs and incentives £250,000 was provided for agricultural marketing; £50,000 for the benefit of the sea and inland fisheries, and £100,000 for increased expenditure on the elimination of tubercular cattle. It is manifest to all concerned that farmers are prepared to produce more wherever a remunerative price is assured. The guaranteed prices for cattle, milk and sugar-beet and for grade A pigs have evoked a very significant response from agricultural producers. The Government came to the conclusion that if the farmers could be assured of a remunerative market for their products, the response would be very marked in many other lines.

The Government therefore came to the conclusion that, in order to maintain present conditions, and more so if we wanted to encourage increased production, it would be necessary to do something with regard to the marketing of agricultural produce. With that object in view £250,000 was provided for the improvement of marketing. Because of the many changes in the office of Minister for Agriculture which were partly, if you like, fortuitous but partly unfortunate, the machinery necessary for the spending of this money was postponed. Now I think it is fairly certain that in the very near future a committee will be appointed to look after this very important subject.

The £100,000 for increased expenditure on the elimination of tubercular cattle was offered for the old cows which might be the means of spreading tuberculosis, on the basis that these would be paid for at their full value. Rural Deputies know that up to that time a cow with open tuberculosis was paid for only at about one-quarter its value and the farmers therefore were a bit slow offering them under the tuberculosis scheme. I cannot say at the moment what response there has been to this offer but I know that at the beginning it looked promising.

The Government also committed itself to a very large public capital programme amounting to £40,000,000 and expenditure is running very close to this figure. Provision was made for over £1,000,000 to assist new industrial development in the private sector. The provision for housing, sanitary and other works carried on by local authorities is now considerably above the expenditure in 1956-57 and the indications are that in this sector also it will be practically all spent. It will also be recalled that a special grant of £900,000 was put into the Road Fund, partly to discharge liabilities that had accrued and owing to the fact that the last Government had taken £500,000 out of the fund. We had to discharge the debts left to us and give the fund a chance of getting over the difficulties created by the inter-Party Government last year.

Housing finance was put on a more orderly basis and uncertainty on the part of local authorities as regards drawings from the Local Loans Funds was removed. All the sums owing at the time were paid out and certainty with regard to future payments was created. As a step towards relieving the immediate difficulties the Vote for Employment and Emergency Schemes was supplemented to the extent of £250,000. The strain which the financing of all these schemes has put on the Exchequer is not generally appreciated but I can say I am not overstating the case when I put it that it was severe.

While it was eased by the success of the recent National Loan, it is by no means removed. Indeed, as will be mentioned later, the budgetary statement on the outlook for the present year was by no means conservative. No measure that any Government can take will change the whole face of the economy over-night. The Government can only try to stimulate progress and accelerate movements in the right direction. It is the enterprise, energy and general attitude of the private individual, industrialist, farmer and worker which are the most important in the end. Even in the relatively short period since March last, however, some progress has been made in the basic fields of production and exports. There are of course no figures available yet of agricultural output this year but there is little doubt that the indications are it will show a considerable increase.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

One has only to think of the situation in regard to wheat, where we have produced an estimated 370,000 tons for milling, as against a requirement of 300,000 tons; milk where we have an enormous surplus for export in the form of butter, about 14,000 tons, and above all cattle and meat, exports of which have increased in the first nine months by £17,000,000.

Comment on this

And all were born since the 20th March.

Comment on this

No, we do not claim that.

Comment on this

We will have something to say in a few minutes about what the Minister claims.

Comment on this

Indeed as regards cattle exports, live and processed, the total number exported during the first nine months of this year in fact exceeded the number for the whole of 1956. Even allowing for imports of live cattle, the net increase in cattle exports in the first nine months of this year was of the order of 188,000, an increase of 33 per cent. Those are the figures and, whether they suit this Government or that, we can all draw our conclusions from them. A big factor in this increased export of cattle was the low prices in 1956 which compelled farmers or induced them to hold on to their cattle in the hope that prices might improve in 1957.

Comment on this

Of course there were 80 per cent. more calves that did not die.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy still mourning for the calves?

Comment on this

The nation will mourn for them for many years to come.

Comment on this

I was driven to it in my fight against the Blueshirts and the British. The Blueshirts joined the British in their fight against this country.

Comment on this