Adjournment Debate: Government Policy (Resumed).
Contributions 326–484 of 484. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I am not ashamed to mention it anyway. I think there is no doubt whatever that at the rate cattle exports are going at the moment we cannot hope to maintain exports at that level. We have a bigger export figure this year because it was low last year. The position has arisen now where we have depleted our stocks and we will also have to replace the cattle slaughtered under the T.B. scheme. For all these reasons it would be too much to hope that our cattle exports in the next couple of years will be so good. It must be recognised that some of the increase in this year's exports has been at the expense of stocks—the June, 1957, cattle census revealed a fall of 106,800 in cattle stocks, mainly two-year-old and upwards. This encroachment on stocks, together with the need, which will be a growing one, to replace T.B. cattle, must in time adversely affect export potentialities. These increases, at any rate as regards wheat and milk, are not without their drawbacks from the narrow Exchequer point of view inasmuch as present arrangements provide for the payment of prices to farmers for any surplus to home-grown consumption which are now far in excess of the prices realisable on the export market.
The situation with regard to the mounting requirements of subsidies on these commodities would give any Minister for Finance food for thought. The very uninformed economic suggestion made by Deputy Crotty has often been made by other speakers, that is, that we are exporting butter and maintaining our high export level while, at the same time, denying our own people cheaper butter for consumption at home. Everybody knows that this is due entirely to budgetary considerations. We could give our people much cheaper butter out of State finances but we cannot afford it. There has, of course, been a balance of payments gain from the increasing production of wheat and barley in particular. As compared with 1956 there was a reduction of £2,135,000 in imports of maize in the first nine months of this year. That, of course, is a very welcome development.
We have succeeded in building up our wheat and barley production and I am glad to say we no longer suffer from the difficulty of which Fine Gael have until recently been afraid — that we cannot grow our wheat and barley at home. Fine Gael now realise that we can, so we have no further dispute in regard to that matter. We can not only supply ourselves with our wheat requirements, with the exception of the small quantity of hard wheat which the bakers think is necessary, but we can supply ourselves with animal feeding stuffs.
As regards industrial output, the position is that it has not yet recovered to the 1955 level. Output in the first threequarters of 1957 was lower than in the first threequarters of 1956, but the rate of decline was checked and the September quarter index for 1957 is almost the same as the corresponding index for the year previously.
I spent some time studying the position of our exports and I was rather pleased to see that in the industrial side we have, in the group including yarn, thread, textiles, boots and shoes, paper and cardboard, reached a stage when the export value of these items is £10,000,000 a year. That is certainly a tribute to the long term policy of Fianna Fáil because when Fianna Fáil came into office in 1932 we were importing our textiles, all our thread, most of our shoes and boots and whatever paper and cardboard we were using. We have now reached the stage where we are largely self-sufficient and have a surplus of £10,000,000 for export.
We can now take the sugar group — sweets, sugar preparations, chocolate and cakes. Our exports in that regard amount to about £1,000,000 a year. Again, in 1932, in this country we were producing only about 25 per cent of our requirements in sugar. Now we are practically self-sufficient in sugar. In 1932 we imported a great deal of confectionery from Britain and from Belfast. We are now producing our own and exporting it as well. These items are a tribute to the long term policy of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton this evening gave the impression that we were now prepared to scrap the Control of Manufactures Act. I believed it was necessary at the time it was introduced and it has served a very useful purpose. I believe indeed that the Act is still necessary under certain circumstances but it is possible it can be relaxed now much more than it was some years ago. It was foreseen at the time that relaxation would be necessary and in the Act itself provision was made for that relaxation. Accordingly, there was nothing very strange as far as our attitude to the Control of Manufactures Act was concerned.
The Fianna Fáil Government did, in their time, invite foreign capital in here and in fact when people came in to start factories they were referred to by the Labour Party as spivs, fly-by-nights and other such names. One would imagine from Deputy Norton now that he was the first to advocate that foreign capital should be brought in. I remember very distinctly in an election held perhaps in 1948 — I am not sure that was the one — when the Labour Party in criticising our attempts at tourism appealed to the people of this country to withhold their votes from Fianna Fáil because Fianna Fáil were trying to bring in millionaires to take the food off the poor man's table. These were the sentiments we had from the people who are now trying to give the impression that they were the first to speak about bringing in foreign capital.
The trade figures for the ten months, January to October, showed the following results: Our imports are down £1.7 million and our exports are up £21.8 million so that we have a more favourable balance as compared with the ten months of last year to the extent of £23.5 million. This great improvement, as I mentioned earlier, is due for the most part, to increased exports of cattle and meat. The change for the better has been so good, in fact, that there is no doubt now that there will be a balance of payments surplus for the calendar year 1957 of the order of £5,000,000. I should say that covers both visible and invisible imports and exports. That surplus is against a deficit in 1956 of £14.4 million and in 1955 of £35.5 million. In fact, if this surplus works out as we anticipate, it will be the first surplus since 1946.
Comment on this
The trade gap widened somewhat in October as compared with October, 1956, and this I mention as a reminder that there is a danger of complacency. Indeed, in each of the three months, August, September and October, imports were actually higher than they were for the same three months last year and, for the first time, in the month of October there was a decline in exports. These are indications that we must not be complacent about our position. We must be watchful, and it is necessary to keep a close watch on the trade balance so as to ensure we can continue to pay our way in our external transactions.
I should not like it to be taken that a decrease in imports would always be the sign of a good economy. An increase in imports is not to be deprecated provided we are earning, through increased exports, the means of paying for them. I would say the economic ideal would be to balance imports and exports on the highest possible level.
Comment on this
It should be said again and again. Fianna Fáil used to say the reverse when they wanted to put all the ships to the bottom.
Comment on this
Generally speaking the savings position is not unsatisfactory but the savings made available to the Government by the public are not yet adequate to support State capital expenditure on its present scale. Two new methods of collecting and stimulating the savings of the public have met with gratifying success, the first being Prize Bonds, for which on more than one occasion I have given credit to Deputy Sweetman. On the one occasion when I did not I was pulled up about it. On many occasions I have done it——
Comment on this
And on other occasions, too. No less than £8,000,000 was raised by the two issues of Prize Bonds in March and September. A particularly satisfactory feature was that the money subscribed consisted for the most part of new current savings and was not just a transfer of past savings. The £2,000,000 issue of Exchequer Bills in July and the £3,000,000 issue in September were both over-subscribed. The difference in the receipts from the two issues of the Prize Bonds suggests a strong element of once-for-all success in the venture. It would seem as if the aggregate of subscriptions will inevitably reach a ceiling in the course of a year or two.
Bank deposits increased by £17,000,000 between October, 1956, and October, 1957. The banks' external assets have gone up by £11,000,000 and their bills, loans and advances within the State by £6,000,000. Small savings in the form of Saving Certificates and Savings Bank deposits are not doing as well as last year but this is only to be expected in view of the competition from Prize Bonds.
All told, taking small savings, Prize Bonds and National Loan subscriptions, I am afraid we may still be short of meeting the requirements of the public capital programme and a further increase in indebtedness on Exchequer Bills may be necessary. I need hardly remind Deputies that borrowing by Exchequer Bills is not the most desirable way of getting money for State capital purposes. It is short-term borrowing.
No effort can be spared to stimulate savings if we are to continue the work of national development. I should like to refer to the Savings Gift Tokens now on sale as a result of a recommendation of the Savings Committee. I hope this scheme will be availed of extensively by parents and others who wish to make Christmas gifts to children.
The Trustee (Authorised Investments) Bill just introduced in the Dáil and the Trustee Savings Banks legislation which is about to be introduced, should help to channel more savings into Irish securities.
The unexpectedly heavy subsidies required for C.I.E. and also for some items of agricultural exports threaten to throw the current Budget out of balance. There appears to be little prospect of revenue rising above the budgetary estimate. On present indications, I believe further that the prospect for the coming year is not encouraging——
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot say it anyway. In other words, while the country as a whole is in surplus in its accounts with the rest of the world, the Exchequer is not yet sharing in this turn of fortune. Indeed it would seem that while certain increases in expenditure are impossible to avoid, tax revenue has lost its buoyancy under many important heads. One might say that the limit of taxable capacity has been reached in some directions and it is difficult to see any method by which additional revenue on a substantial scale can be raised without very injurious effects on employment and on economic activity in general.
Everyone would agree that we must strive to reach a position in which we can reduce the heavy burden of taxation. This is the greatest fillip that could be given to economic development and progress. The difficulty is to get agreement on any substantial item of retrenchment.
The greatest contributory cause of increased taxation, because of its effect in increasing expenditure year by year, is the growing cost of the service of debt. This is rising at present by about £2,000,000 a year. Obviously there can be no relaxation of the policy announced in the Budget speech of switching the public capital programme progressively from non-productive to productive works. It will be understood that the longer a public capital programme of a predominantly non-productive character is persisted in, the more dependent employment will become on this artificial support and the less resources will remain for the productive investment which alone can yield lasting and self-sustaining employment and give higher real incomes. What we want is that workers should enjoy as high an income as possible based on the sale of the products of their work at economic prices, either at home or abroad — not that workers' income should depend on the proceeds of State taxation or borrowing.
When imports and exports, both visible and invisible, are balanced we know for certain that, as a community, we are not living beyond our means. Internally, however, the current Budget should be balanced and savings must balance capital requirements because otherwise the balance of payments would again go out of gear. As I have said already, the Government is not getting enough practical support from the public for their capital programme. A good lot of the money has to come from the banks and it is lent eventually to the Government in the form of short-term loans, which is unsatisfactory.
Deputies have quoted figures in relation to unemployment, and quoted them correctly. They have pointed out that we are about 3,764 down as compared with this time last year; but last year was 16,394 higher than in the same period in the previous year. While this improvement is nothing to boast of and not a figure on which the Government would like to congratulate itself, it does represent a reduction and it gives some promise for the future. That is the most we can say about it.
Employment in agriculture — that is, the number of males engaged in farm work on 1st June — declined by 6,700 in 1957 compared with 9,000 in 1956 and 3,000 in 1955, representing an average annual decrease of over 11,000 between 1941 and 1953; 1954 was the only year which showed stability in agricultural employment.
Employment in transportable goods industries in the September quarter of 1957 averaged 149,100 as compared with 151,100 in the same quarter in 1956. All that we can say is that the downward trend which appeared in 1956 has been checked, but has not yet been completely wiped out.
Consumer prices have, of course, increased. The Index for August, 1957 (to base 1947-100) was 143 as compared with 135 in August, 1956. This increase up to August, 1957, has been mainly due to the provisions in the Budget. Of the eight points by which the cost of living went up in the last 12 months, five points were caused by the Budget and the other three points are attributable to other causes. As compared with pre-war, consumer prices have gone up by 163 per cent, weekly industrial wage earnings have gone up by 190 per cent, and the minimum agricultural wage has gone up by 255 per cent.
Neither private individuals nor the Government can afford to neglect the lessons of the past two years in deciding future action in the economic or financial spheres. It is too easy to generate a situation in which at the cost of a heavy deficit in our balance of payments we may enjoy a temporary semblance of prosperity. We know now that prosperity depending on realisation of external assets can only be of very short duration. Indeed, we cannot afford any more of the short-lived boosts because our external reserves could not bear a further impact of the 1955 magnitude. With great difficulty, and at great cost in terms of reduced industrial output and employment, the ruinous drain on our external reserves which set in in 1955 has been stopped. It is much too early to assert that the leak has been permanently plugged. As was mentioned earlier, the October trade figures carried a warning of the danger of rising imports and of flattening out of exports.
A breathing space has been gained and our external position made right for the first time since 1946. It is particularly important that, as we can no longer afford heavy deficits, we should take care not to add to unproductive spending or do anything else which may generate increased imports for which we cannot pay or hamper production and exports. It is essential that our spending should satisfy the test of productivity, so that we may strengthen still further our ability to pay for the raw materials and basic commodities needed to support an expansion in home production.
There is a real danger to our economy from increases in expenditure not offset by economies or increased production. For that reason further increases in costs and prices must be avoided to the utmost extent. It is better to avoid such increases now than to accentuate the difficulties of the immediate balance of payments situation and the problems of adjustment to the freer trading conditions which seem to face us in the near future in Britain and on the European Continent.
The Government is very much concerned with the problem of future economic development of the country. It is receiving advice in this matter from the Capital Investment Advisory Committee and, of course, the various Departments concerned are giving special thought to it and examining the possibilities of development both general and specific. So as to have the best advice, not merely from home but also from external sources as to future lines of productive development, the World Bank, which Ireland recently joined, has been asked to study our investment needs at first hand by sending a mission here. The bank has unrivalled experience of the problems of the less developed countries and we hope to benefit from its expert advice and assistance.
It is clear that only a combination of capital enterprise and technical competence, backed by advice from the most reliable sources available to us, will achieve what I stated to be the Government aim when I stood up to speak, namely, an expanding economy paying its way in its transactions with other countries and providing higher living standards for a growing population.
Comment on this
I take pride in having the honour of speaking here. I have been 20 years trying to get here. That will give the House some idea of how hard it is for young people or new people to get into politics. One hears a great deal about it. But it is like a lot of other things—people do not mean what they say. Join a political Party and, if you have any independent view at all, out you go. Even if you try to form a Party there are many obstacles put in your way because people control the Press, or something else, and give you no publicity. However I did not come hear to elaborate on that. It took me 20 years to get here and now I want to protest in the name of the plain people, of whom I am one.
I won the recent by-election and I believe I could have won a by-election in at least six areas of this city had there been a by-election in those areas. The people have made their attitude very clear. They condemn all Parties. Up to recently, they had no choice but to vote for one Party or the other. People like to have confidence in somebody but they have been tricked so often that they now find it difficult to have confidence in anybody. If they have any confidence in me, it is because of very hard work.
I understand that on this debate on the Adjournment one can express opinions on Government policy. Naturally, I have something to say on the policy of the present Government. Before the recent general election we had grandiose statements in the Press, particularly in the Irish Press, of the plan the Government had in mind and how they could get £100,000,000 to put everybody to work. I know that most political Parties make promises in order to get into power. It is inherent in every political Party that they want to get into office and the aim of every one of them seems to be to get a majority and get it whatever way they can, particularly through the making of promises. In saying that, I am not trying to say that the Party system is knavish or venal but to some extent it is. There are honourable men in all Parties. Every Party in turn does a certain amount of good but the trouble seems to be that no Party will give credit to the other for the good it has done. There is a good deal of knavery in politics and it was knavery to say that you could put everybody to work and that you could get £100,000,000 to do so.
The public are largely agitated at present owing to the decision to withdraw the subsidies on foodstuffs. The Government Party never mentioned, before the election, that they might do that but then, Parties never tell the truth at election times. While there might have been some grounds for withdrawing the food subsidies there was no possible justification for withdrawing them in the case of people who are already in need, people in receipt of social benefits. In getting back £5,000,000 or £7,000,000 the Government could have given back a small percentage of that to these poor people. But what did they do? They gave them a miserable 1/- a week.
The average man will eat five or six loaves of bread every week. He will eat a lb. of butter and use a half lb. of tea. I do not use statistics. I have heard them used here to-night and, while it is said that statistics do not lie, they are used in order to confuse. These people each eat five or six loaves of bread; they eat a lb. of butter and use a half lb. of tea in the week. The withdrawal of the subsidies has cost them 2/8 or 3/- each per week and all you gave them back was a miserable shilling.
The class of people to whom I refer could not afford to pay the increased cost of food due to the withdrawal of the subsidies. Owing to that withdrawal, you have had a demand for a 10/- a week increase by employed persons. An employed person may have £7 or £8 a week coming into him and he says that is not enough and that he wants an additional 10/- to offset the increase in the cost of living but the person who is in receipt of social benefit gets only 1/- a week. What does the Minister for Social Welfare propose to give those people now assuming that the employed person gets an extra 10/-? Is he going to give them another shilling?
Compare social benefits here with the social benefits in England and in Northern Ireland. I wonder if it was put to the people of Northern Ireland that they could come in here if they wished, if England said to them that she would withdraw her forces and that they could have a free vote about coming in here, would they really vote to come in? I do not believe that they would unless they were fools. While I do not expect that social benefits here can be on the level that they are on in England, I do expect that the people who are in receipt of them here should get at least three-fourths of what they get in England.
I am in touch with the people. I do not come along and get on any platform but I know the people. I mix with them and I know what they feel. I meet them in the corporation and I meet them in the streets. Compare the benefits here with the benefits in England. The single man there gets 30/- a week and old age pensioners there get anything from £2 to £2 10s. 0d. a week. In addition, they can travel free on local bus services where the buses are owned by the municipality. They get into cinemas at half price. What do they get here? Nothing.
I know this is not a rich country but I am pretty sure that we are living a little bit too high and mighty for a poor country. I am not sure that we need so many Embassies and Consular Offices abroad and that we are getting value for the money we spend on U.N.O. I say, in the name of the people who sent me here, that I protest against the miserable 1/- a week that they got as a result of the withdrawal of the subsidies. I am asking what the Government proposes to give them in view of the general increase in wages and in view of the fact that the price of commodities will rise again as a result of that increase, as they must.
I am not tagged to my Party here. As a member of the corporation I am not tagged to any Party and I put down motions at that body without consulting my colleagues. I do not consult anybody here. I recognise that there are honourable men in all Parties. I recognise that the Taoiseach is an honourable man, I do not care what anybody else says. I know politics from the bottom up. That is one advantage I have over quite a number of Deputies here. They came in at the top while I came in at the bottom. I know we are not a rich country. I know our difficulties.
I know our difficulties about partition, and I want to protest that the Government seems to have no idea of a plan in that connection. If there are people in the Curragh to-day the Government must take some responsibility for it. It may be that the men who lead the Parties here have got too old. I know that there are back benchers who have got old sitting back in their seats, but the youth of to-day expects some encouragement and hope. There is a patriotic outlook in this generation as there was in the past. Patriotism did not cease to exist in 1921 and 1922. Unless these young people get some hope and some lead they are going to go on an independent course. I considered that John Redmond was an honourable man and that he was doing his best for the country but, nevertheless, we ignored him and went out ourselves.
It is time that the Government gave some lead. It is all right saying that it is tough. We know it is tough, but the present Government would have thought differently 20 or 30 years ago and they can now blame themselves that the young men of to-day are acting as they are. We are up against it. If they were honest with those young men, maybe they would see there is some sense in what they are saying. We are giving no lead or no example. The result is that we will have this state of affairs now, in the next generation and in every generation. If you are not able for it you should back out and let the young people in. I know the difficulty. I have learned my history.
I did not come here to say much more except to make a protest on behalf of the people who sent me here. I will say nothing further beyond this. Do not ask the youth to come into politics if you are just going to keep them running around with a bucket and a pail of water. Do not ask the people to live on a few pence, such as the miserable shilling you offered them recently when you took approximately 3/- each from their pockets. Do not ask the people in the North to come in when that is what they would get. Try and bring up the people who are down. Do that and the people will not be so suspicious. In conclusion, I would appeal to the Minister for Social Welfare to keep in mind the people on social benefits and give them a rise.
Comment on this
Certain things were particularly noticeable about the speech made this evening by the Minister for Finance. It was perhaps the most complete vindication, not merely that has been given but that could have been given, of the economic policy put into force a year ago by the inter-Party Government and for which that Government, and I particularly, were assailed by Fianna Fáil. They have now heard the Minister for Finance express here to-day the results of that policy in certain of the aspects to which he adverted.
If it was a vindication, as it was, of our policy, it was also the most damning exposure of the hypocrisy of Fianna Fáil during the general election campaign of last year and previously. It was particularly noticeable that the Minister when speaking never once made any reference whatsoever to any plan, to any project, to any promise or to any speech made by him or any of his colleagues prior to the election that took place on the 5th March last. It was particularly noticeable that he ran away from any attempt to justify, as Deputy Childers, the Minister for Lands, did earlier, the hypocritical promises, pledges and carrots that were dangled before the electorate last February and March.
Deputy Dr. Ryan is now the Minister for Finance. It is he who now controls the purse strings. It was he who made a broadcast on behalf of Fianna Fáil during the General Election campaign and it was he who in that broadcast, in the implications of the words he used, deliberately got not merely hundreds, but many thousands, of farmers to vote for Fianna Fáil. They did so in the belief that he was sincere, honest and honourable when he criticised the then existing price for wheat and impliedly made it clear, and was accepted as doing so by everyone listening to that broadcast, that if only Fianna Fáil were returned to power on the 5th March, there would be an increased price given for wheat for the 1957 season.
What did he say? He criticised the previous cut in the price. He said it was "cruel and unjust to cut the price down to a level which farmers believed to be uneconomic." He went on from that to say that a remunerative price would be fixed by Fianna Fáil for crops such as wheat. What would anybody around the country think that was meant to be? Was it not as clear an indication of a promise of an increased price for wheat by Fianna Fáil in 1957 as was ever made by any public man?
In that broadcast he passed on to the Milk Costings Tribunal. He accused the previous Government of vacillation and evasion by their spokesmen in relation to that tribunal. Admitting the fatality in relation to the Department of Agriculture which we all sincerely regret, what has this Government done in relation to milk costings during its nine months of office? Nothing.
They would be better respected by the people if they were men enough to get up and say that the criticisms they were hurling against us, and against Deputy Dillon in particular, last year were unjustifiable and had no reality or honesty.
The plain fact of the matter is that when in Government we did the hard, unpalatable things—the things that were bound to be unpopular—and that the present Government and the present Minister for Finance in particular are now reaping the benefit of the things we did. That is undeniable in any analysis of our present economic trends.
We had the twofold policy at that time of ensuring by a positive policy of production that we would be enabled to expand our exports to a level at which we would be able to afford a greater proportion of imports. I was glad to hear the Minister for Finance saying that he had now been converted to the view we have held in this Party for a long time that the desirable thing from the economic point of view was to balance imports and exports at the highest possible level. It is a long advance from the day Deputy Aiken said down in Athlone that it would be better for this country if all the ships were down at the bottom of the sea.
Comment on this
It is a welcome conversion that they have now come along that road with us.
During the course of the General Election campaign the present Taoiseach—Deputy de Valera as he then was—said in some speech that they would have to take care in relation to the balance of payments. I remember prophesying, long before any person in Fianna Fáil ever took that line, that he need not bother. I remember saying in February that he need not bother, that we had laid the basis and that, by virtue of the change in the balance of payments situation in 1957, we would be on a reasonably easy keel.
We had done that because we had laid down a twofold policy—a positive policy of production which would ensure more exports. Pending the time that that positive policy would take effect, the negative side of our policy, the policy of restricting imports on non-essential goods, had to operate. As I said, it is inevitable that that would not be too popular. But there is no doubt whatever that the course we adopted at that time has shown dividends now.
The present Government took office in March at a time when the trends in our external trade were already beginning to show and when it was already clear that we had turned the corner and surmounted the hump. It is equally clear, and I think every economist and every administrator will admit that in relation to imports a Government can influence the flow of imports restrictively or in an expansionist way almost immediately but that in relation to exports it takes a very long time for a policy, comparatively speaking, to have effect in relation to those exports. I think it would be fair, therefore, to say that in considering the position in the nine months that Fianna Fáil have been in office it is undeniable that in relation to exports during that period, and particularly bearing in mind the type of exports, that they had no hand, act or part, to a material extent, in the £22,000,000 by which exports have increased in that period. Those exports are solely the result of the policy of the Government of which I had the honour to be a member.
I heard the Minister for Finance a few minutes ago suggest that the financial position with which he is faced at the present time is not satisfactory. No Minister for Finance ever likes to admit, particularly at this time of the year, that the Exchequer position is satisfactory. What are the facts? We find that there has been a revenue of £70,120,000 compared with £67,710,000 last year. Deduct the special import levy in each case as going to capital and deduct motor vehicle tax as going to the Road Fund and the revenue alone is up by some £3,000,000, current revenue, that is to say, up to 23rd November last. I would suggest that the Minister for Finance should take a little heart from that or perhaps he was, early or in advance, only trying to create propaganda for another tough Budget.
The most damning thing in relation to the present Government, however, has been the manner in which they have failed completely to redeem any of their promises in relation to unemployment which they made during the last general election. I listened to-day to the Minister for Lands, Deputy Childers, and he spoke about certain things—that they may have to be done, that they might be considered, that they require long thought and that the long term implications should be studied. Everything that he put forward was put forward as a question mark, a policy which might be considered but he added they had not yet decided on what they ought to do. The only thing I could find they had decided upon definitely was that Deputy Childers had concluded that the Minister for Industry and Commerce's plan for £100,000,000 had definitely been thrown overboard.
During the general election campaign when Deputies over there were seeking votes from the people, they were not saying that things had to be considered or that a policy had to be thought out; they were saying that they had a positive and complete plan, one that was ready to go into operation at once. We have in this House members, who are not at present in the Chamber, from County Cork—Deputies Galvin and Healy and the Minister for Education. I have here in my hand the leaflet that they issued in the last general election. They did not say that Fianna Fáil were going to consider how to deal with unemployment. They came down flat-footed and said Fianna Fáil had a plan for full employment. I should like to see the Minister for Education and Deputies Galvin and Healy coming into this House and going to the people of Cork, apologising for having misled them and for saying that Fianna Fáil had a plan whereas from what we have heard to-day it is quite clear they have no plan, whatsoever, different from that which we had initiated some 12 months ago.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, for example went down to Waterford and when speaking there he made it clear that the plans they had were not long term plans but plans that were going into complete and immediate operation. He went to Wexford and there made it clear again that their plans were ones for immediate employment. Even the Taoiseach said that Fianna Fáil's first objective as a Government would be to deal with the present serious unemployment position. That was at Ennis on 24th February. We remember the advertisement that was published in every newspaper "This is the only issue—how to put our men and machines to work." That was the advertisement that followed the initial speech of Deputy Lemass at Dundalk when he said these things would be done at once in relation to unemployment.
What are the facts? I should like the Taoiseach, if he speaks in this debate, to give some explanation so far as his stewardship is concerned. No Government ever got such an opportunity or such a chance as this Government. They came into power at a time when we had done the unpalatable things and they were able to reap the reward of those things. In the first eight months they were in office they were given more co-operation than was ever given to any Government by any Opposition since the State was founded. They were given the Estimates speedily and without great discussion because they made the plea that they wanted the time and the opportunity to settle down. They were given even the Budget without an unduly protected debate and they were given the Finance Bill as well.
They had a very different time, a very different task than, for example, the task given to me when, 14 days after I became Minister for Finance, they launched into an all-out assault to try to ensure that I would not be able to get down to doing the nation's work. We gave them every chance, every opportunity. During this period they have shown they had no plans or, that if they had, they were keeping them a secret to themselves. The results are tragic to behold.
Louth, Meath, Kildare, Dublin, Wicklow and Monaghan represent a very cohesive chunk of our territory. In every one of those counties, according to the unemployment figures for October-November, there were more people unemployed, more people registering at the exchanges, than 12 months ago. In the three Ulster counties that we have under our jurisdiction, if you want to take that territory for the purposes of a comparison instead, again there were more people registered as unemployed than in the equivalent period of last year. That was after eight months of Fianna Fáil administration. In three out of four of the employment exchanges in Kildare, there were substantially greater numbers registered than in the previous year.
We have that at a time when anybody who moves throughout the country knows that, during the past summer, there has been wholesale emigration on a scale and of a type never before known in this country. We never before had the experience of entire families packing up and going away. We had seen, unfortunately, people going as individuals, sometimes perhaps followed by their families, but during last summer for the first time we have seen widespread emigration of entire families because they found out that there was nothing but hypocrisy in the promises that had been made. Disillusionment came upon them when they realised what the Government were doing compared with the rosy promises made at election time.
One cannot compare the figures of unemployment for one year with those for another without at the same time considering the position in relation to emigration. I ask every Deputy on the other side if it is not true that there has been worse emigration from the parishes they know during the past six to eight months than there was, not merely in the equivalent period last year but in any similar period they can remember. I would ask them if it is not true that there is scarcely a parish in Ireland from which whole families have not pulled themselves up by the roots and gone away because they have lacked any confidence or any hope in the future of our country, largely because of the type of propaganda the Fianna Fáil Party were prepared to use for the purpose of getting over to that side of the House.
The September quarter of 1957 would be a suitable quarter to mention in relation to industrial employment. If the present Government had a plan readymade as they told the electorate, surely that plan or policy should have been put into operation by them. Yet in relation to that period there were some 2,000 fewer people employed in manufacturing industries than in the equivalent period last year—140,000 as against 142,000. I know a number of other people wish to speak and I do not propose therefore to delay the House unduly to-night. I want the Government to tell us, even at this late stage, what is their policy in clear and unmistakable terms.
I believe there is a future for this country if only we can get a Government in office to ensure that they carry on with the economic policy we framed some thirteen months ago and that we then announced. I want the Government to tell us, for example, what is their policy in relation to whether we are to have a high or low cost economy. We must have exports other than agricultural exports if we are to succeed. How can we get those exports if, by deliberate action of the Government, we have got into a situation, as we said we would last May, where we are going to have a high cost economy which will put our manufacturers in a comparatively worse state than before the Government took that action?
I do not think the present Government know where they are going in this respect. We warned them then that the result of the action they were taking was likely to lead to the situation in which we have started another spiral of prices chasing prices and wages chasing prices and the inflation which was bound to mean that we would be in a far more difficult position to compete with other countries for the exports which we so badly need for our own salvation.
I commend for the study of Deputies the economic data issued by the Central Statistics Office on the 2nd of this month so that they can see what our actions were designed to do, unpopular and unpalatable though our task was, attacked and impugned as we were by Fianna Fáil. Our work was designed to remedy the situation, to ensure that we would have sufficient reserves to avoid the mass unemployment that would have arisen if those reserves had been encroached upon unduly. All the analyses of our economic statistics at the present time make it certain that we can claim the present Government got the opportunity presented to them but that they did absolutely nothing about it. Their inaction has been noticeable even during this session of the Dáil.
They have brought to the Dáil during this session practically no business of their own. Bill after Bill discussed here have been Bills not merely prepared by us when in Government but even published by us before we left Government. This Dáil has sat less in this autumn session than it has ever sat before in the same period and I venture to say, although I have not checked on the matter, that during the period of this session we have not had more than three working days in the Dáil in which business prepared by the present Government was fruitfully discussed. Everything that was discussed, with the exception of two items, was business which we had prepared and publicised before leaving office. So the Government are prepared to ride along on the work we have done. That will not do the country any good. That is not the way in which we should go into Christmas Recess. If that is the position no wonder the Minister for Finance worries about future problems. If that is the position we are going down the hill from the happy position in which we left the country last March.
Comment on this
The happy position in which we were left last March was that we had unemployment figures at about 86,000, that we had a deficit in our current Budget, that we had had a violent attempt to try to deal with a situation which should have been foreseen. It was clear to everybody paying attention to the country's affairs that two or three years ago an economic blizzard was threatening us, but we had in office a Coalition Government, the members of which, when we tried to rectify the errors of their previous term of office, went round the country and pretended that every step taken by us to make the economic position right was something that was completely unnecessary. When we warned about the position regarding our external reserves, the cry from every one of them was that we had huge foreign investments and that these should be repatriated. It was an echo of what Deputy McGilligan said during the previous period when we were building up some of these assets—not that we wanted to do it at the time, but we were unable to get in products from outside—that we were only piling up a quantity of waste paper——
Comment on this
If the Deputy did not say that, he gave that general impression, because I was here.
Comment on this
There is a rule that when a Deputy challenges a quotation ascribed to him, the quotation should be given or the misquotation withdrawn. I am challenging that quotation.
Comment on this
My impression was that the Deputy believed that the policy of sending goods out at that time meant that we were only getting paper in exchange.
Comment on this
During that whole period of the first Coalition the people were told "We have given you good times". The period ended in our having a deficit in the external balance of payments of some £61,000,000 and also an unbalanced current account. We came in at that time to try to remedy the situation. Large sums were being used in subsidies and we had a deficit of £14,000,000 or £15,000,000—I forget the exact figures now. We could not get that by extra taxation, and we had to cut down on subsidies. Because we did that we were told it was quite unnecessary, that it was cruel and unjust. Every epithet that could be coined was used in trying to misrepresent the situation and in trying to get the people to think that burdens were being put on their shoulders that they should not have to bear.
That was how we were met after the first Coalition Government when we tried to set the finances of the country right. It was a difficult task. But that was not the spirit in which we, when we were in the opposite benches, met the proposals of the former Minister for Finance. We told him at that time that we understood the difficulties of the situation and, so far as we could, we tried to get the people to understand also. But we pointed out that they were measures that should have been foreseen, that they were hasty and panicky and were causing an amount of unemployment which was not absolutely necessary. We said that if the situation had been handled with prevision some of the difficulties need not have been imposed. We did not go round the country telling people these steps were unnecessary or cruel or unjust or that the restrictions need not have been imposed or that the situation could be rectified without them.
Comment on this
The Deputy could not have known then the way agricultural prices would go. They pretend now after the event that they could foresee all the things that have happened since. They could not.
We believed at that time that some of the measures would not be effective. They very well might not have been. I said previously, when we first succeeded the Coalition Government, that we were favoured not merely by the steps which we took and by the things which were done but also by good fortune.
At that time, however, we had to face the position of an unbalanced Budget and we had to try to set the finances of the country right because unless that is done and unless external trade is set right there is no hope for the country. That was only realised by the second Coalition Government when they had done everything they could to mislead the people about the unimportance of our external investments. It was better, however, to have a conversion at the end than not at all. We came into office in a situation where there was a very great unemployment problem and a great emigration problem. We have been talking about emigration here over a long period and it always happens that when we are in office emigration is the highest ever.
Comment on this
But it is not true. It has been proved untrue time after time, when the statistics have come to hand. In the period of the Coalition Government it was said that Fianna Fáil had the greatest emigration figures ever but when the statistics became available, when the census had been taken it was proved that the years in which it was claimed that emigration was highest were the very years in which the improvement was taking place and that the time when the Coalition was in office was the time in which the position worsened. So far as any estimates I have been able to get show, the figures for emigration were rising during the whole time of the last Coalition Government. What they are now I do not know, but I am very much perturbed about them—
Comment on this
I know it is a serious position both in regard to unemployment and emigration and so far as I am concerned these would be the matters to which I would direct, as far as possible, all the attention of the Government. We have been doing something in that respect: the figures show it. We are told that the unemployment figures are not as good as in 1955, but we did not start from 1955 because one starts from where one finds oneself, and we found ourselves starting from where the Coalition put us. There has been an improvement—
Comment on this
The improvement has been this, that in March when we came in the figure was 86,000, 16,000 more than in the same period of the previous year. Now, it is some 4,000 less than it was at the same period last year. I am told it is not the same as compared with the year before that, but we have to compare these figures with those for the year immediately preceding the point of time at which we came into office.
We tried to remedy the situation as we found it. We believed that the restrictions which had been imposed could be relaxed and that increased employment would result from that relaxation, without endangering the prime purpose of the steps taken by the previous Government to remedy the balance of payments deficit. That relaxation did help. The relaxation in the motor car industry and so on did help. We tried to help in the case of the building industry. In the nature of things, building is something which will diminish in the country as a whole. Housing needs have been substantially met throughout the country, but not so in Dublin. There is still a problem here.
Let me repeat now my conviction. I have expressed it time after time. I have always believed it was wise to embark on the policy upon which we embarked in 1932, a policy upon which the Government in office prior to that time did not embark. It was wise to lay the foundations of good living here by providing decent houses. I admit that perhaps, we may have gone a bit too fast. Deputy Dillon spoke about the slums around George's Street and Hardwicke Street with which he was familiar as a boy. All these slum dwellings have been replaced by decent houses for our people. I am glad of that. These slums had to be removed at all costs. They were a disgrace and they would continue to be a disgrace to any people who, by joint effort, could get rid of them and failed to do so. There were, however, cases where building took place where others might hold the view that it would have been better economy not to have made these improvements but to have established, rather, the foundations of expanding and thriving economy.
Comment on this
I am giving my own view. It would be quite possible for an economist, divorced from politics or irrespective of political affiliation, to look over the expenditure of external reserves in the last ten years and say that a good deal of the money was not spent as wisely as it would have been had it been invested in productive enterprise. That is a statement which any person can quite reasonably make.
Comment on this
Everything that was done was done towards achieving an excellent objective, and I stand by that objective. I am quite willing to admit there may possibly have been, in the general effort, a too rapid expansion of the building industry, so rapid an expansion that when a sudden decline comes we are faced with the problem of diverting those hitherto engaged in building into alternative productive employment. The fact is it was we who pursued that policy of house building and it is we who will have to bear the brunt of any adverse criticism of that policy. In our time we built more houses than did any other Government. We built and reconstructed more houses than any other Government. It is true that, in our effort to provide good houses, we may have overstrained ourselves. I can see economists coming along and stating that is so. It is open to any economist to come along and say that we might have done better and established a sounder foundation had we diverted more of the money spent on housing into building up productive industry.
It is all very well to talk about building up industry. When we came into office originally there were very few industries here and, when we started out to develop industry, we were attacked by the Opposition and we were told that the development of industry was not in the farmers' interests. We believed it was then and is to-day in the farmers' interests to have manufacturing industries built up here. They provide the farmers with a market for their produce and they provide occupation for those members of the family who cannot hope to remain on the land. The two are interdependent. The development of our agriculture and the development of our manufacturing industries ought to go hand in hand.
It was relatively easy at the beginning to establish industries. We had the cream to skim off. Now we have reached the situation in which the cream has been removed and so the situation is somewhat more difficult. But, as a result of our industrial development, we have doubled the numbers employed in industry during our period of office. That is a good thing for the country. It has been said that the people are leaving the land. I do not think that we could have prevented that by any process. Every person employed in industry to-day means one less forced to emigrate.
We have to buy from outside those things which are needed for our development here and we have to produce here the things that will buy the imports we need—the capital plant and the raw material. We have two ways in which to do that. We can do it through the medium of our agricultural exports, which offer the biggest and the best hope, and we can supplement those by our manufacturing industries capable of producing goods for export. We need both. It is no use maintaining we can have one without the other. I believe, as I have always believed, that our agricultural industry is a fundamental one in conjunction with those manufacturing industries which can be based upon agriculture. These are the most valuable in our particular economy. They are the most economic forms of production and provide the best security in time of danger because there will be no necessity to import raw materials from outside. But we cannot depend upon these alone. We want the others as well.
We came into office with the hope that we would be able to develop production in the agricultural industry to start with. I have no doubt about it that we can do that. With a little bit of co-operation and effort and understanding on the part of our farming community we can increase by 50 per cent. the agricultural output from our farms. If we treat our grass lands properly we shall be able to increase our cattle and sheep population up to 50 per cent. I have no doubt about that.
We are continually being asked, as the former Minister for Agriculture asked, what is the use of increasing production unless you can get a remunerative market for your products. It is necessary to secure these remunerative markets, and a study of the possibilities of expanding our markets is as important as an all-out effort to try to increase production from the land. In saying that I am not saying that we should wait for that alone. I am not one of those who says that increased production must necessarily lead to lower returns but even if there was a reduction of prices it would have to be very big indeed to offset what could be gained by an increased volume of production.
What we are aiming at this year is to see that our finances are all right. This year the balance of our external payments is right. We do not know if it will continue to be so. We had it almost right in 1954 but in a year or two the situation very quickly changed. We had an adverse movement in the terms of trade and other things which brought about a deficit, and the same thing could happen again. The Minister for Finance was not manoeuvring about his Budget position for next year but he was pointing out to the members of the House and to the country the fact that, because we have obtained a balance this year, it is not to be taken that we will be able to do so next year.
My opinion is that we are not out of the economic danger in which we found ourselves. We have to proceed with the greatest caution. There are no sums available for the Minister for Finance to give for relief works as he has been asked to do. We simply have not got the money. It is not available.
When people talk about the subsidies they forget that money for subsidies has to be got in increased taxation, and increased taxation is detrimental to the probability of increased activity in industry.
There has been a reference to the withdrawal of the subsidies this year and it was said that I had promised that there would be no change in the subsidy position. What I said was that Deputy Norton, and others like him who were attempting to arouse certain fears, were not right. I had no intention of removing the subsidies; neither had I the intention in 1952 of changing the subsidies. We were up against the grim necessity of having to do it—the same type of necessity which Deputy Sweetman uses now to justify his action in putting into operation measures which reduced our imports.
We had to abolish the subsidies, otherwise we would have had to get the money by increased taxation. One Deputy spoke about the shilling by which social assistance payments were increased. The fact is that £9,000,000 would have to be provided if the subsidies remained. That meant £7,000,000 from the point at which withdrawal of the subsidies became effective. There was a reduction of £7,000,000 in the subsidies this year but we tried to make matters easier for the poorer sections of the community. We did try to help them and we were sorry that we could not do more. We gave back £2,000,000 out of that £7,000,000 which reduced the saving to £5,000,000. If we had given more, that saving would have been still less.
We did that to a very substantial extent when the same issue arose in 1952. In 1952 the position was that the people in whose interest these things were done saw what was taken off but they did not see what was given. When we assumed office this year we were faced with a position in which the Budget for the year which has just closed, was unbalanced to the extent of about £5,000,000. A deficit in one year can be got over but the position is different if there is a series of deficits, year after year. We tried to get a balance but could not do it because the current was running against us. That current had been running against successive Governments every year on account of the increases in the public debt service and increasing costs, not due to any expansion in the services but due, for example, to increases in superannuation and increases of salaries, all of which go to add to our burden. They add to our burden to such an extent that every year the increase in debt charges alone amounts to £2,000,000, which has to be met from taxation.
Can anybody say where we could have got that £9,000,000, if subsidies had been retained? What taxation would be put on in order to get it? What would be the effect of that taxation on the people? We took the subsidies off bread and butter simply because we could not get the money to keep them on. I am willing to admit that Deputy Norton, who was a member of the Government at that time, had better opportunities of being able to foretell the financial difficulties and what financial necessity would compel us to do. It is quite possible that it was on that basis that he was making his prediction during the last general election. I do not think it was on that basis but rather on the basis of saying to the people that if his opponents were elected they would "skin" them.
I had no intention of removing the subsidies and neither had I any intention of removing them in 1952. Neither had we, as a Party, any policy or intention to do that. We did these things because they were necessary. I might as well say to Deputy Sweetman that when he came into office he did so because of promises that he could not put into operation. I shall not say that Deputy Sweetman and his Party assumed office with the intention that they would restrict imports.
Our policy, all the time, has been this—to try and get our people to build up our agricultural and industrial production. That is where the prosperity of our country is to come from. There is no other way. If you try to go in a contrary direction, if you tell the people: "Have a good time; do not worry; we have any amount of money; we can spend freely", then you are telling the people to do something which they will rue sooner or later.
The people on the opposite side who spoke so much about sacrificing enterprises to the sacred cow of sterling, or whatever it was, have been brought down to earth. They have now to go to the people and say there are no such things as these immense reserves. A large portion of them has been used— whether on every occasion wisely or not is another matter—and to that extent are no longer available. We have got to maintain reserves if we are not to get ourselves into a position in which we will have even greater unemployment and greater emigration than before.
We are trying to get the finances and economy of this nation on a sound basis. We will not do so by talk. If eloquence and so on were to solve our country's ills, there is no doubt that the eloquence of certain members on the opposite side would have done it long ago. It is not by those means we will succeed in our national task. It is by acting on the simple but very important principle that we must earn enough to meet, on the one hand, our current expenses and, on the other hand, to make provision for such capital expansion as we need. Savings, no waste, trying as far as possible to get expansion in production—these are the only ways in which we can hope to bring this country out of its present position.
I have never had any doubt about our ability here to get for our people a reasonable standard of living. We are told we are not as good as Britain. We used to hear a long time ago that we were not as good as the United States of America. At other times, it was New Zealand that was held up to us as a model. Before that it was Denmark or Holland. We have a certain area. We have a certain amount of productive land. We have a certain number of people who are producing there and it is on these that the future of the country will depend and from these that the prosperity of the country will come. I believe our resources are sufficient to give, at least to a population such as we have, a reasonable standard of living. I do not say we can have a standard as high as the highest. That depends on a number of circumstances, but I do believe that we can get the material resources for a decent living here in this country, if we set out to look for it and if we remember it cannot be all play and no work.
We must all realise—those who are engaged in production, whether they be employer or employed—that it requires a big and intelligent effort to make a country of our size and resources a country where the material resources for a happy existence can be found. I think it can. We are working towards that in a steady way. We have been told we have been doing nothing because we have not brought in here a plethora of Bills. The activities of a Government are not confined to bringing in legislation. I remember—I was not a member of the House at the time —reading of a Parliamentarian here who said that the best thing that could happen the country would be if the Dáil adjourned for six months, allowed the Executive to get after its immediate tasks and tried to see that the various services were carried out efficiently and that the programme was effectively carried out. We are trying to work in that particular way at the moment.
There must be a continuity in government. Each successive Government when it comes in finds that certain measures have been advanced to a certain point by the previous Government. For instance, it used to amuse us when we saw the Tánaiste of the day, Deputy Norton, going round opening factories and doing things that had just matured at the time but the foundations for which had been laid by the previous Minister. For example, there are schools being opened in our time that were planned during the previous Government, but this happens during every Government's term of office.
There is continuity in government. A new board of directors comes in, so to speak. Fortunately, the concern is a working concern and it continues on, either good or bad, up or down, according to the ability and the operations of the Government in office. Sometimes something happens completely outside of the Government, something they could not have arranged for, claim credit for or bargain for.
Take the example of the Agricultural Institute. I do not know what precisely Deputy Dillon had in mind. The proposal had reached a certain stage when we assumed office in 1951 and I continued it because I believe that if programmes have been planned by a previous Government, it is in the national interest to continue them unless you have definite objection to them and unless you find they are fundamentally unsound or bad. I advanced it to a certain stage. Then the forces were too great for Deputy Dillon apparently, and as a result of discussions with outside bodies and so on, he had to change the whole fundamental plan. We then found a new plan and the first thing we had to do was to make up our mind whether we would revert to the situation when we left office or whether we would take into account the position as it existed in March of this year. I felt that, whatever my own predilections or prejudices might be, it was in the national interest to get the institute going as quickly as possible, although it is not the grandiose institute Deputy Dillon spoke about with his usual eloquence when he mentioned it first several years ago. Then it was going to be the greatest Agricultural Institute in the world. I am afraid that, on the foundation on which we are working now, he would not be able to boast like that.
Comment on this
I hope it will do good for the country. I hope we shall get co-operation because it does depend fundamentally on getting the proper co-operation. If there is an attempt by some of the interests who would be concerned to act selfishly and not for the general good or the good of the institute, then it can be useless. If, on the other hand, there is a desire for co-operation—and I take it that the change was made to try and win that co-operation—if that co-operation is forthcoming, then it can be and may well be even better than the previous plan. But that remains to be seen.
I take that simply as an example to show the way we approached these matters. We did not say what some Deputies said when they came in first, that everything we did was just for demonstration purposes. We have gone over the Bills prepared by our predecessors in every Department. Every Minister has looked at them critically to see whether he was prepared to accept them as policy he would put before the Government for approval. Wherever these Bills have come before the Dáil, they have passed through that process. Each Minister has had to satisfy himself, if he is to bring in a Bill on any particular matter and for which the responsibility naturally rests with him, that the things it provides are in the national interest, and whether it is a sound Bill or not. He has a good deal of work if he does his work, and I expect he does, conscientiously. He has to go over it as a proposal that is new to him, as it is indeed, new to him. He has to go over it to see that he can stand over it as a Bill that would be approved by the Government. We have, therefore, a number of Bills that have reached a certain stage and that have matured and they are there for putting through Parliament.
I want to say again that in my opinion, anyhow, the activities of a Government are not to be judged simply by the number of Bills they bring before Parliament. You must have a Bill of course if there is a new scheme or some new plan. Then you have to bring in a Bill in order to get it into operation But what we need at present is not so much new plans as to make the foundation right, to see that we can, in our present position, make progress. I believe we are doing that. I believe it has been done fairly successfully in the past eight months.
I do not agree with the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, when he says that the Minister for Finance is, at this stage, trying to frighten Departments into making economies or to clear the way for a future Budget. The position is, to my mind, serious because I would regard it as a terrible thing if, after all our efforts, we were to have another deficit in our current account this year. We have had a deficit year after year. We hoped that the measures which we took this year were sufficient to ensure a balance this year. If there is a deficit, it will be a heartbreak for me, at any rate, because I think whilst you can afford to have a deficit one year or two years, you cannot afford to have a continued set of deficits which means that you are borrowing and using up your past savings in order to meet your day-to-day expenses. No individual family could live or no nation could live on that basis. Although we have our external payments in order this year, we dare not face continued deficits in the balance of payments. I think therefore that the Minister for Finance, in mentioning the dangers that are present, is not trying to cry "Wolf, wolf!" or anything of that kind. He is simply trying to face the situation as he sees it.
Listening to Deputy Dillon I only regretted I had not got his artistic oratory, and would be inclined to ask myself "Upon my word, am I dreaming?" He was claiming, on the other side of the House, as his policy, things which in fact had originated with us. He mentioned "we" in regard to housing. If he meant the Dáil as a whole, certainly it was "we" because everything had to be done with the approval of the majority of the Dáil. If you look back on the history of the Fine Gael Party you will find they were not very oncoming when we were on the housing programme.
The Minister for Finance, Dr. Ryan, mentioned a figure of about 380,000 tons of wheat and when I heard Deputy Dillon gloating that we had the greatest wheat production at any time in the history of this State, I said: "It is wonderful. It is delightful to hear Deputy Dillon talking about the great amount of wheat grown in this country when we were told at one time we could not get it grown at the point of a bayonet." When we came into office first, 20,000 acres was all that was grown in this part of the country and we were told by the people on the opposite benches that it was wrong national policy to increase that figure.
When I heard him talking about the limestone project, as one of the fundamental plans in the Fine Gael programme, I was amused because Deputy Dillon had to be driven into that scheme at the point of the bayonet. Then I heard him talking about the land rehabilitation project— he has grand names for these things. We had a farm improvement scheme for which, on average, an annual sum of close on £400,000 had been provided in our time. It was done in a very good way because it was associated with the relief of unemployment. It was for giving employment directly on the land. It was stopped and only when the £40,000,000 of the American Loan was available, did Deputy Dillon embark on what he called the land rehabitation project. Grand fine words! We operated that project but, just as in the house building there may have been money well-spent and money ill-spent, so it was in that project.
I have listened to Deputies talking quietly about that project. They were not out to make political capital but were speaking privately amongst themselves. I heard Deputies talking of land on which large sums of money had been spent and which would not be productive. We had said it was much better to start, if you are to get increased production, with land that will produce quickly. Get quick results to start with and then go on to the marginal land. That was the only difference there ever was between us on the idea of land reclamation. We wanted to have any money that was available for spending spent so that it would produce results quickly and effectively. Just as you might reclaim land, if you are hard up for land, from the sea at prohibitive costs, so also you can pay prohibitive sums for land that will not give returns. That is particularly so if you do not secure that the necessary treatment is continued on that land afterwards. The land rehabilitation project would not have been dreamt of even, were there not the £40,000,000 which was offered through the American Loan.
A certain amount of good work has been done and some very bad work has been done, everybody will admit. One of the things that should be carefully done is to see that any further expenditure in that direction will give good value for the money spent. I do not know whether I should go over the bovine tuberculosis question again——
Comment on this
On a point of order, before the Taoiseach launches into another field, he has been speaking since about twenty minutes to 9. Normally on a motion this debate would end——
Comment on this
On a point of order, is this debate to conclude at 10.30? The Taoiseach has been speaking since twenty to nine. Do I understand that the Taoiseach will speak until 10.30 and accordingly close the debate?
Comment on this
I do not know who is to come after me. As I went along, I felt there was material that I was anxious to give to the House.
Comment on this
It was that side of the House which raised these questions. We were challenged and asked where we stood on the nine points that they called their programme.
Comment on this
My understanding is that this debate concludes at 10.30. Is the Taoiseach to absorb all the time since twenty to nine?
Comment on this
May I put another point of order? The Standing Orders provide that the mover of a motion has the right to conclude. The Motion for the Adjournment is taken as being moved by the Government. Accordingly, if the Taoiseach wishes to continue until 10.30 he is entitled to do so.
Comment on this
The question must be put at 10.30 or before 10.30 but not after.
Comment on this
The Chair has given the Deputy the information. The Chair is giving its decision on the Standing Orders of this House.
Comment on this
I understand there were certain arrangements between the Whips and that there was an understanding that 12 hours would be allowed for this debate. Since the debate did not start until 1 o'clock to-day——
Comment on this
Very many members at this side of the House are still desirous of contributing to this debate.
Comment on this
The arrangement was that the debate would conclude at 10.30 p.m.
Comment on this
On a point of order, as regards the power of the Chair and the House, I submit that if there was no objection and if there was agreement between both sides of the House, the debate could be allowed to continue.
Comment on this
Would Deputy Kyne kindly allow me to reply to the point raised by Deputy Mulcahy? In reply to that point the debate may not continue, even if the House so desires, beyond 10.30. That is in accordance with the Standing Orders of this House. If the House desired to have the debate last longer to-night, a motion to that effect should have been made before 8.30 p.m.
Comment on this
We had no idea at that time that it was the Taoiseach's intention to absorb all the time of the House.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach started to speak at ten past nine, not at twenty to nine as had been stated.
Comment on this
I want this clear. It has been stated here just now that there was an agreement between the Whips. No such agreement was entered into by the Labour Party Whip. No one communicated with him and no effort was made to ascertain our views. On behalf of the Labour Party I am asking the Government to prolong the debate beyond 10.30 until to-morrow morning if necessary.
Comment on this
The Leader of the Labour Party was told two days ago.
Comment on this
I was told two days ago that the Fine Gael Party had requested 12 hours for the motion. What Deputy Ó Briain told me was that the matter was under consideration. I heard nothing since from the Deputy.
Comment on this
Can I take it that the Taoiseach will, of his graciousness, permit the debate to continue until to-morrow or until all Deputies desirous of speaking have spoken?
Comment on this
I have already pointed out that the question must be put at 10.30, not later than 10.30 p.m.
Comment on this
It was announced in the Order of Business this morning.
Comment on this
Will it not be in order for the speaker, at 10.30, to move the adjournment of the debate.
Comment on this
I understand that an arrangement was made in advance. All I know is that the usual procedure was gone through. This day was to be devoted, with whatever items had not previously been finished, to this motion.
Comment on this
Surely that was announced during the Order of Business this morning—that the Dáil would adjourn at 10.30 to-night.
Comment on this
The other side of the House can help in this matter by withdrawing the motion or helping to defeat it.
Comment on this
According to the Opposition, arrangements can be set aside as lightly as that. When they were in Government they adopted a very different line and we were kept very strictly to what had been decided upon. We have come to a decision in this matter and that remains.
Comment on this
May I put this question: did the House not order this morning that the Dáil would adjourn at 10.30 p.m. until February 12th, 1958?
Comment on this
I am asking a question on a point of order. Was the motion proposed that the House adjourn at 10.30 p.m.?
Comment on this
The Order of Business was settled this morning.
Comment on this
That was not named. The only time February 12th came into discussion was during the introduction of new measures.
Comment on this
This is the normal procedure for a debate of this kind—
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan, on a point of order, specifically put the question, and I think it should be clarified, as to whether or not the Order of Business this morning stated that the Dáil would adjourn at 10.30 to the 12th February.
Comment on this
The terms of the motion under the Order of Business are that the Dáil at its rising this day do adjourn until the 12th February, 1958.
Comment on this
Another point in the Fine Gael programme as put forward by Deputy Dillon was what he called the parish plan. That was the idea of having, for two or three parishes, an advisory service available, an idea with which I had previously agreed. Then there is the question of administration. To whom are these people to report? That is a very different matter from the general idea of having advisers locally who know their business and who would generally be able to give expert advice to the farmers in the locality. With that idea I am completely in agreement; it is a good idea and I think it should be put into operation as soon as we can get the instructors with the requisite qualifications. But I am not satisfied and I never have been satisfied that the method of reporting, or of organisation, provided in the Parish Plan is the best. I think we should not have two groups advising the farmers locally. There should be co-ordination and, so long as we have county committees of agriculture, we should see that these people are provided and available to them and answerable to them. I agree that the headquarters department ought to be there, that the recommendations they make should be made there and that they should be generally in touch with the Committees of Agriculture.
Comment on this
Would it be in order for someone to move the Adjournment at this stage to enable the debate to be continued to-morrow?
Comment on this
I do not see why the rules that have obtained here for so many years should be departed from.
Comment on this
As I have explained to the Deputy it would not be in order. The question must be put at 10.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I wished to run over these points as I was challenged to do so. We claim that most of the schemes had been initiated by us and Deputy Dillon was claiming that they, and any advantages that came out of them, were part of his policy. I am dealing at the moment with the parish plan. I agree that the provision of qualified people to help local farmers is a good idea and I do not care who agrees or disagrees with that. In regard to the method of reporting, however, are they to be answerable to the county committees of agriculture or to whom? That is another matter and I think a great deal can be said for having these people responsible to, and working immediately under, the control and direction of the county committees of agriculture and also helping to direct the activities of these committees.
In regard to soil testing, we also stood for that and the Deputy forgets that back in 1945 or 1946, before the first Coalition Government came into office, the question of Johnstown Castle and its equipment was being considered. We had tried to get equipment from outside. The Deputy spoke about seeing a bicycle wheel and a medicine bottle somewhere, but it must be remembered that the question of soil-testing is not a very old one and it had not been practised extensively in other countries before the war. During the war it was difficult to get equipment. The fact, however, remains and it can be verified, that the importance of soil testing was recognised back in 1945-46 and that provision was being made to get equipment for Johnstown Castle.
In regard to bovine tuberculosis eradication we provided a special £100,000 this year to deal with old reactors that were spreading the disease. That shows we were anxious to deal with that situation. The only difference between us in matters of that sort is regarding the methods by which we shall get results most quickly. It is evident that this matter of the elimination of bovine tuberculosis is one of great urgency because in a few years it will seriously affect the prosperity of our cattle trade in the foreign markets. It is really a question in that case of how we can get going quickly.
As regards lime, Deputy Dillon's position is not nearly as sound as ours I think one of the men who pressed very strongly on that matter was Deputy Aiken whose views in regard to the importance of lime are well known.
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I call attention to the fact that there appears to be a concerted attempt being made to prevent the Taoiseach being heard——
Comment on this
There is a general conversation going on which might take place in a bar or somewhere else but which certainly is not fitting in this Chamber.
Comment on this
In case there should be any misunderstanding about it, I think the Minister should be assured that we are quite willing to sit on to hear the Taoiseach or any other speaker.
Comment on this
Every time there is an adjournment debate this question seems to arise. It is obvious that since the adjournment debate is open to everybody, everybody in the House wishes to speak——
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Dáil will be re-assembling to take an amendment from the Seanad probably next week, perhaps this debate could be adjourned and the debate continued when the Dáil assembles to take that amendment.
Comment on this
The Deputy is incorrect in that. The Bill has not been completed in the Seanad and the Report Stage has been fixed for next week.
Comment on this
The Opposition can carry on its own shoulders the responsibility for removing price control.
Comment on this
I wish to register a protest. Only one Independent Deputy was permitted to speak and I wish to protest against the Government's action.
Comment on this
I have been in this House since early this morning and I have sat through this whole debate and listened to a lot of mud-slinging from one side of the House to the other——
Comment on this
I have been deprived of the right to speak. This is nothing short of Tamanny Hall tactics.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?