We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 1–145 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

As far as the agricultural side of our economy goes, the Fianna Fáil Government has given the farmers maximum protection. When Fianna Fáil came into office in 1932 there was practically free trade as far as agricultural produce was concerned. Fianna Fáil gave the farmers maximum protection on the home market. As a result of that protection we have now reached the stage when we are faced with over-production in agriculture. Various people criticise the Government and the Minister and, in so criticising, demonstrate their negative approach. We had the experience in County Dublin of the County Committee of Agriculture passing the usual vote of censure on the Minister. So much political eyewash! These people cannot themselves make any constructive suggestions. All they want to do is to criticise the Minister.

The Minister has proved a good friend to the farmers, to the market gardeners and all the others concerned. He has helped them by giving them all the protection necessary. We are now able to fulfil our own requirements on the home market. I ask these people who criticise, what would they do? We have kept our bargain with the farmers, with the people generally and with the workers. We have given protection in the industrial field as well as in agriculture. Nobody can say that we have failed in that respect. No one can say that we have failed in our promise. We have honourably fulfilled that obligation to the workers, the farm workers, the farmers and the industrialists. Any promises that were made by us in 1932 were honourably carried out by us. We honoured them as far as was humanly possible. Deputies at the other side of the House may smile—they find it easy to do so—but we went through a severe time, and we were up against many problems during that period. However, Fianna Fáil did a good job with those problems.

There are parties outside this House who speak on behalf of various organisations and they can do nothing more than cast a negative vote of censure on the Minister for Agriculture. These people are making a poor contribution to the welfare of this country. If that is all the contribution they can make, it is a very poor reflection on their intelligence, when they know that we are doing our best to honour our promises.

These people must realise now that we have to go into the export market and compete in that market. We are now subsidising certain agricultural commodities, such as butter. We have to try to export our butter in order to help the farmers to produce more milk and butter. We have protected our farmers in regard to all the commodities which they could produce for the sheltered market at home. The country to-day wants the enterprising farmer or industrialist to go into the export market, so that we can make a profit from the produce which cannot be consumed at home. If we do not succeed in getting export markets and if we cannot encourage our people to do the best for themselves, we are not going to have a prosperous country.

The great countries of the world which have achieved great things did so by the enterprise of the individual and by the enterprise of groups of industrialists and agriculturists. These people succeeded in getting into the export market and now they are clamouring more than ever for an export market. We have reached saturation point in the home market in regard to certain commodities and now we must put these commodities on the foreign market, if we are to progress.

Comment on this

They are eating too much butter in your constituency.

Comment on this

I am well able to look after County Dublin, and, if the Deputy looks after his own constituency as well, he will not be doing too badly.

Comment on this

You are saying that we have reached saturation point in the consumption of butter.

Comment on this

I am talking about the export market. Surely, when there is a national problem to be faced up to, we should not have these nonsensical interruptions from the other side of the House. We are facing up to these problems and we will win our battle with them, as we won in the past.

The Minister for Finance holds a very responsible position and has a very responsible task in trying to guide the ship of State through troubled waters. However, I want to make this suggestion to him: any factories or industries which have received protection over a long number of years from this and previous Governments, and which are confining themselves solely to the home market, should now be told to make an honest effort to get into the export market. We have given them protection over a long period of years and now, if they have any products to sell in a foreign market, they should try to sell them there and do so to as great an extent as possible.

The condition in which we find our country at the moment is one that should be far outside the range of Party politics. If we are to bring our country back to prosperity, give employment to our people and keep them from emigrating, it can be done only with the wholehearted co-operation of the people who are in a position to help the country. The only way they can do that is to get into the export market and sell our surplus products there, whether they be industrial or agricultural. I should like to see cooperative societies developed in every parish in Ireland, so that the people would be able to help themselves and not be blaming the Government for everything that happens.

I believe that if that spirit of co-operation and goodwill was developed, and if the people were anxious to help one another in the solving of their own difficulties, they would help the country to get out of its difficulties. There is no use in people who have control over certain organisations condemning the Government, while failing themselves to make any constructive contribution to the solution of our problems. If that is what we are to be up against, we will not get any place.

Another point I should like to make, which must have been considered by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and his predecessors, is the question of friendly nations who purchase our goods. When friendly nations purchase our goods, we should not purchase goods from any other country, if it can be avoided. I do not think that we should deal with any country except those countries that are prepared to buy from us. Certain pressure groups have from time to time tried to secure the import of certain products from countries with which we have no trade. That should not be tolerated at all.

Any money available to the Government should be devoted towards the development of our export markets. Last night, I mentioned one industry at random, the whiskey industry. It is one of the many products for which we have an export market. If lack of money is responsible for our failure to put this product on foreign markets, then it is a matter to which serious attention should be given. However, exporting companies should endeavour to help each other to sell their products abroad, as well as getting assistance from the Government.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce has given industrialists all the encouragement possible and has set up a special body to deal with their problems. If this country is to survive, these people will have to be helped; but they will have to give up blaming the Government for everything and will have to do something for themselves.

Everyone here deplores unemployment. I have my own difficulties in County Dublin in regard to employment and emigration. Every other Deputy here has the same. Under Fianna Fáil, we have carried on housing schemes, made roads and built schools and hospitals. We have reached the point where we will have to change there any more. We have reached the point now where we will have to change our economy, if we are to survive, and we will have to do something that will give continual employment. I have not much regard for these small factories that will keep people on for a week or two and then let them go when the home market is satisfied. It is the same with relief schemes. They are a stopgap to help us for a little while, but to the ordinary family, they mean only a little money for a month or two, and then back on the dole again.

We all deplore the idea of a father leaving the country, having to leave his wife and family behind him and having to keep two houses. We are anxious to see that as far as possible we should develop an economy here which will alleviate the distress existing among certain sections of our people. Some people here have cures for all our ills. that they have cures for all our ills. They write to the papers and they speak outside. There are certain people who are trying to say politically that they have a cure for the partition of our country. The best way to get our country united is to build up our economy here. If we can succeed in achieving a stable economic unit, it will be the best possible contribution towards ending Partition, and perhaps we will be able to influence the people in the North who are trying to keep away from us.

The people outside, and especially those in the universities, who have an opportunity of studying our problems should concentrate their studies on ways to help the country's economy. More than any time in its past, the country needs to-day intelligent people who will give a lead, soldiers of goodwill who will secure goodwill for us in friendly nations. The greatest ammunition any country has is a spirit of goodwill, harmony and common understanding. We should do anything we can to build up our goodwill with other countries, always bearing in mind that we will act honourably towards our own country. We should endeavour to get the wholehearted co-operation of the people, get them to give up these votes of censure on the Government and give a lead themselves. The Government cannot work miracles.

Last year in County Dublin we had a surplus of vegetables. Some of them were ploughed into the ground by the market gardeners. We found a few intelligent people——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It is a long time since I saw any of them in County Dublin.

Comment on this

——among the market gardeners, and with the assistance of the Minister for Agriculture, they succeeded in getting a market for their surplus vegetables. That shows what can be done. Down through the ages, the great individuals responsible for improving their own countries economically and politically have left something for posterity to study. We in Fianna Fáil are doing our best and I am confident that we will succeed in bringing the country back to where it was when we were defeated by misrepresentation in 1948.

Comment on this
John Murphy Mr. J. Murphy Independent

This Supplementary Estimate is the tail-end of what will go down in history in this country as the infamous famine Budget of 1957. We now see the full extent of the insane financial policy embarked on by the Minister for Finance last year. This last year has been one of the blackest in our history. The same Budget of last year gave the working people of Ireland no hope and was directly responsible for almost 60,000 of our people emigrating. An economic policy, if it is to be sane, must be reckoned in terms of human beings. The overall loss to our nation has been irreparable. The Government is supposed to be representative of the people and if that is so, its policy will be reflected in the economic conditions in which we live and will also work in the interests of the people. If, on the other hand, a Government, though supposed to be representative of the people, has a policy reacting to the detriment of the people, it is natural to assume that such a Government is not in fact representative of the people but of the vested interest group.

Look at the structure of our society to-day. Need we ask of whom is the Government representative, of the people of Ireland or of the vested interest group, when we have 90,000 unemployed every year and almost 40,000 or 50,000 people emigrating? That answers the question. Away back in 1940, the Minister for Supplies said the existence of large numbers of unemployed for long periods, through no fault of their own, was the acid test of any system of Government, commerce or finance. If within the present system we cannot cope with unemployment, he said, the system must go. How does that sound to members of the Fianna Fáil Party after almost 20 years? How can they account for the brutal system which gives us 90,000 idle every year and 40,000 or 50,000 forced to emigrate through sheer economic necessity?

I have repeatedly asked the Taoiseach in this House what he intends to do to bring about an end to mass unemployment and up to date I have got no satisfaction, nor has the Taoiseach given any indication that he intends to bring about an end of mass unemployment. I now ask the Taoiseach again, or the Minister, if he will tell us and tell the people what he intends to do to bring about an end to mass unemployment, and more important, when he intends to do it? Let him say if he has a plan for full employment and when he intends to put the plan into operation, or does the Taoiseach still prefer to remain silent on the question of unemployment?

If the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party is to be a continuation of the disastrous policies which have been pursued for the past 30 years, will the Taoiseach not now agree that the Party system and Party jobbery have been the main factors in bringing about the damaging situation whereby economic policies, instead of being far-reaching and intelligent, have been merely tools of vote-catching politicians?

I feel that the working people of Ireland are now ready and more than willing to play their part sincerely, if given an example by those in high places. The time has come when we of this generation must rid ourselves once and for all of the seeds of dissension sown by the civil war and nourished by the bickerings of the politicians ever since. We of this generation have grown tired of living in the past: we want the future for ourselves and for our children. It is time the Taoiseach, if he has a spark of honour left in him, resigned. He should get out of this House; he is "washed-up". He should give us in this generation a chance to provide for the future of ourselves, our wives and our children.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It is customary for the debate on the Vote on Account to bring from the Government an outline of future policy and customary for the Minister for Finance who introduces the Vote, to give the Dáil and the country an idea of what Government policy will be; but, judging from the Minister's speech and from the speeches of those who have spoken from Government Benches, it is now clearer than ever that the Government are completely bankrupt of any policy whatever. There was no statement of policy on agriculture, on the language, on emigration or on unemployment. There was nothing but the hoisting of the white flag, evidence of despair and complete evidence of surrender in any attempt to formulate, or consider formulating, future policy.

When we hear the member for County Dublin, Deputy Burke, saying that his Party always honoured their promises, it is time to examine briefly their record. Deputy Burke singled out the year 1932 and said that from that year they had honoured the promises they made. I should like to remind Deputy Burke and every other Deputy who feels the Fianna Fáil Party has honoured its promises since then, of three promises clearly and distinctly made by the present Taoiseach at that time. I fail to see where there is any stim of honour left, in so far as the fulfilment of these promises is concerned. One of these was that they would bring back the emigrants from the United States, that there would be so much work here that they were sending out invitations to every Irish emigrant who ever went to the United States or Canada to come home.

He went on to say—and I am sure it was in Athlone he made the statement—that traffic in the provincial towns would come to a standstill between 12 and 1 p.m. every day because there would be so many people working in the factories. That promise was not fulfilled. Another statement was that no man was worth more than £1,000 a year and no man would get more. Long forgotten are the days of 1932 when those baits were successfully thrown out to catch votes. Again, we had the 1932 promise that the Seanad would be abolished, because it was too great a burden on the taxpayers. The Taoiseach abolished it right enough, but he brought it back three months later. These were some of the promises made, some of the baits held out, in 1932, to which Deputy Burke has made no reference.

We do not have to dwell to any great extent on years long past: we can come closer, to the past 12 months. Everybody knows that it is a waste of time for the Minister for Finance, for the Taoiseach or for any Minister to say that the people gave them a blank cheque at the last general election. The people did no such thing. Certain promises were made at the last general election. Not only were promises made, but pledges of honour to carry them out were given from every platform in every constituency. Promises were made in every constituency to suit the best-thinking and most attractive elements of the electorate. For example, in the large provincial towns and cities, the Fianna Fáil Party devoted all their promises to the provision of full-time employment for every person who was able and willing to work. They guaranteed the provision of full-time employment. They condemned bitterly any policy whereby there would be any unemployment. There is no use in saying that there were no promises. There was a promise made that, when a change of Government took place, there would be 100,000 new jobs available and that every unemployed person would be put into productive full-time employment, with good wages and a good standard of living.

The chief worry of the present Tánaiste at the time was the fact that there were not sufficient wages going into the pockets of the working-class people. In Castlecomer, County Kilkenny, when he was endeavouring to secure victory in the by-election for Deputy Medlar, he said that the new Government must at once stimulate employment by the institution of a capital investment programme designed to put men to work, to put wages in their pockets, so that those wages would be spent in the shops and so that the whole national economy would get a boost.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Deputy say what the quotation is from?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The statement made by the Tánaiste at Castlecomer, County Kilkenny, on 24th February, 1957, and published in detail in the Irish Press and the Irish Independent of 25th February. That speech certainly impressed the low wage earner and the large number of unemployed miners in, that area. His speech was given such publicity in the papers the following day that it must have impressed every unemployed person in the country. It was a promise given to put wages into the pockets of the workers, which would, in turn, benefit the shopkeeper. The shopkeeper thought that, if there was a change of Government, his shop doors would not be wide enough, that he would have to take on extra hands and erect new shelves to hold the additional goods that he would require, following that statement in Castlecomer, that there would be such a boost, following a change of Government, that it would provide full-time employment and put big money in the pockets of the wage-earners which would benefit every shop in the country.

I sympathise with the shopkeepers; I sympathise with the workers; I sympathise with the unemployed; I sympathise with those who have fallen for that false promise; but while all sides of the House appear to sympathise with sincere efforts to provide work for those who cannot get it, it must be borne in mind that the people had had previous lessons of Fianna Fáil's promises, prior to the last general election, and that Fianna Fáil deceived the people previously because of their lack of policy and lack of initiative and drive to formulate a policy and, while we sympathise with those who are now disappointed, it is extremely difficult to be sorry for people who have deliberately voted themselves into the position in which they now find themselves.

We enjoy great freedom in this country. We enjoy the freedom to elect a Parliament through the secrecy of the ballot box and if we want to elect a Government of responsible, intelligent people, we can do so. If we want to elect a Government of duds, we are free people and we can do so. If we want to elect a Government that we know can make false promises and that deliberately deceive the people and make hard beds for them, we are a free people and there is nothing to stop us from voting for such a Government. If we want a Government that will provide full-time employment, that will improve agriculture and the living standards of all our people, as free people, at the elections, we can do so. The people get the Government they deserve. In the long run, that is the summing up of the position. I have said in this House on many occasions that if the people sow nettles, they cannot expect roses to grow. That is the position. The electorate deliberately sowed nettles at the general election.

In relation to the provision of full-time employment, as outlined by the Tánaiste at Castlecomer, I ask the House to consider the present position. There is a cut of £174,000 in the provision for the building of schools and a cut of £700,000 in the provision for housing grants. How do the Government reconcile the speeches made prior to the election with the cutting down of funds for school building and housing? We have heard a great deal of sympathy expressed for the Gaeltacht and the people there. There is a reduction of £27,000 in the provision for Gaeltacht housing. The reduction in these grants means that there will be fewer people employed in the building trade and less money in circulation.

That does not worry the Tánaiste. What he said in Castlecomer is of no concern to him now. He is gratified and overjoyed at the success of his speech there, which he knew at the time was a means of tricking the people into voting for his candidate. The speech has served its purpose. It was a good speech, from that point of view. It was a clever speech, cutely designed and deliberately uttered, with the full design and intention of hoodwinking the electorate and it must be given first prize as an outstanding success. Unfortunately, the ribbon of success must go to the Tánaiste, but failure, despair and want are the results for those who were listening to him.

I can remember distinctly that, on the border of my own constituency at Graiguecullen, quite convenient to Carlow, Deputy Lemass, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, made a further speech. On that occasion when he spoke at Graiguecullen on the 11th November, 1956, he referred to the fact that he had published on behalf of Fianna Fáil proposals for a full employment policy designed to secure that in five years capital investment would be extended until jobs were available for every boy and girl leaving school as well as for those who were unemployed. Therefore, he went a little further with the joke at Graiguecullen than he did at Castlecomer. At Castlecomer he dealt with the unemployed and wages but in Graiguecullen he appealed to the boys and girls, to the younger element, saying that in five years there would not be a single one of them that would not be in full productive employment and that there would be jobs available for all. Then he tells us there were no promises made. The Government tells us there were no promises made and the Minister for Agriculture says they had a blank cheque from the electorate.

One of those five years expired last Tuesday. There are four remaining and the steps that were taken to provide employment in the first of the five years must certainly be looked upon as a step backwards, not forward. Forestry work is at a standstill, which means additional unemployment. Bord na Móna works in the Midlands in the immediate vicinity of Deputy Egan's home are closed down and hundreds have been paid off. Bog development works have been completed and Local Authorities (Works) Act schemes abolished. County councils are taking on fewer road works. There are fewer people employed all round and a record number of unemployed registered in every town and village in Ireland. In addition to that, the greatest number of emigrants that ever left Rosslare, Dún Laoghaire or the North Wall have left within the past 12 months.

I fail to understand why the present Government, after 12 months of failure in dealing with the problem of unemployment, having obtained office by this mean low trick, of promise and deceit, will not now admit that they cannot provide work, that they will not provide work and that unemployment must grow and grow.

I do not know if many Deputies have had the experience in recent months of standing on Dún Laoghaire Pier and seeing the large queues particularly from the West of Ireland, from West Cork, parts of Kerry, Roscommon, Sligo and Donegal. Many of these people leave, never to return. There is little use in speaking of emigration from the Midlands. Not alone have workers emigrated from the Midlands in the last 12 months but we have experienced what we never experienced before in relation to emigration. It was always the head of the family who went and sent home the weekly earnings in the form of a money order. Now not only the head of the family emigrates but entire families, mothers with babes in arms, little children clinging to their playthings and fathers of families steering them before him down the corridor into the mail boat.

County councils, particularly the council in Offaly, have experience of more houses becoming vacant in the past 12 months than ever before because of entire families emigrating. I very frequently go out to Dún Laoghaire around 8.30 p.m.—I suppose people have their own strange fads— because I like looking at the mail boat. However, I do not like the heartrending scenes that take place there very frequently. Recently when I was seeing a friend off on the mail boat who came home on a holiday, he told me of four emigrants who were on the boat home with him and who were from some place near Rosaviel in County Galway. They were going home for a fortnight's holidays and they said it was pitiful that so many had to leave Ireland because work was so hard to find. Nevertheless, he said they were still glad they were home last year to have the honour of putting "Good old Dev" back. However, they were not too long in Rosaviel after the elections because to-day the same four men are employed in a big industrial concern on the outskirts of Leeds.

Is that not an extraordinary mentality for people to have, that they will look upon the conditions in this country with despair, surrender, and depart, but still are glad to have the honour of putting "Good old Dev" back into office? I suppose the Irish people have many peculiarities but the most expensive love—and I suppose all of us in this House have some experience of the use of that phrase from time to time—that has ever been experienced or ever will be experienced is the love the Irish people have for the present Taoiseach, because it has certainly cost them a lot. It costs everyone who buys a pound of sugar a halfpenny more because they love him. It costs every person much more to eat a loaf, because, in February, 1957, an ordinary two lb. loaf cost 9¼d. To-day the same loaf costs 1/1½d. The price of the stone of flour in February, 1957, was 4/10. That has been increased to 7/- per stone by the people who were supposed to bring down the cost of living and who still say that the cost of living is not rising. When they say these things publicly in this House, what do they say behind closed doors where nobody but their local cumann members can hear them?

During the régime of the inter-Party Government, the price of the lb. of butter was 3/9. That has been increased to 4/4 to-day because of the love of the Irish people for Éamon de Valera. A packet of cigarettes cost 2/10 during the time of the inter-Party Government. To-day it costs 3/-.

Comment on this

It costs more—3/1.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It has gone up again. I am not a very heavy smoker. I do not think it would worry me if they were 5/- a packet.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not buy them. He smokes other people's.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I never got any of the Deputy's anyhow, I can assure him. I did not reach the cigar stage yet. I was not admitted to the cigar company yet and it is doubtful if I will enter it at this hour of my life, either. The price of the pint in February, 1957, was 1/4; it is now 1/5, despite the fact that in Dublin and elsewhere we had the Fianna Fáil people speaking very loudly about the poor man's pint. During the last election, the impression was created that if Fianna Fáil got back into office, the brewing and distilling industries would get a fillip and the price of the pint, in addition to that of beer and spirits, would be reduced. Petrol cost 4/7½d. per gallon during the time of the inter-Party Government; it is now 5/- per gallon. We have all those charges piled on the burden of the housewife. It is the housewife who has to bear the brunt of increases in the cost of living.

Bearing all that in mind, you had the meanest possible type of theft performed during the past 12 months when a Bill was passed in this House, whereby hospital charges on the poorest of the poor were increased to 10/- per day by the deliberate action of the present Government.

Comment on this

There is no hospital charge on the poorest of the poor.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If they have not got a medical card, they are supposed to pay 10/- per day, whereas they paid only 6/- per day during the term of office of the inter-Party Government. To raid the pockets of the sick, the semi-invalid and those in ill-health was the lowest form of theft. I think it was wrong, uncalled for and unnecessary. It certainly was not in accordance with any of the many promises made.

The cost of living was the main topic of debate from every Fianna Fáil platform at the last election. You cannot divorce the cost of living from both unemployment and emigration. It would be worth while in relation to the cost of living, unemployment and emigration to compare the pre-election speeches with the performance of the Government during the past 12 months. Deputies who made promises at the last general election are very silent upon them to-day.

Instead of Opposition Deputies making speeches in this House, I have a feeling that it would be much better if we invited the Fianna Fáil Deputies to speak at every chapel gate in the country from now on. I think that if we are sincere on this side of the House, all of us, the Labour Party, the farming representatives and the Fine Gael Party——

Comment on this

And Sinn Féin.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——anybody you like—should invite the Fianna Fáil speakers to come now and give an account of their stewardship. I should like to start in Banagher. I think I will, as I have not been there for a long time. I am prepared to bet 2/6— I am not a heavy gambler—that if I turn up in Banagher on Sunday week, Deputy Egan will be 50 miles away.

Comment on this

I will be there.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I take the Deputy up on that. We will have a meeting in Banagher next Sunday week.

Comment on this

If I thought the two of you would be there, I would go myself.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am sure that, however Deputy Egan and I may differ politically, our hearts are still overflowing with hospitality and welcome. We would both be delighted to see everyone who can come, but I should like to assure Deputy Egan that I would be delighted to make the trip by the banks of the Shannon. I want to speak on unemployment, emigration and the cost of living. I want to go further than that and speak on unemployment in that area, where the local tile factory is on the verge of closing. Other drawbacks have been experienced in that part of the constituency during the past 12 months.

With regard to business, is it not well known that every shopkeeper, whether he is a grocer, a draper or a hardware merchant, and particularly if he is a publican—somebody told us that, in Bray, the public houses have to close down at 6 o'clock in the evenings——

Comment on this

In Wexford. I said some —I did not say the majority.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

So long as one has to close down at 6 o'clock——

Comment on this

It is enough for me to exaggerate about Wexford, without the Deputy starting.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I will not exaggerate about Wexford. A statement has been made by a Deputy, representing Wexford, to the effect that a shop connected with the licensed trade has to close down before closing time. The owner of a licensed premises was always glad to evade the law to keep open as late as he could, while he had a customer, and no blame to him. I am not asking that the law should be broken in that respect. Here we see that those interested in conducting licensed premises have customers on Friday and Saturday, but they must close down for the rest of the week. There is no business in the licensed trade. The very same applies to shopkeepers. The volume of business transacted in the drapery or hardware or provision line is not what it was 12 months ago. In so far as the provision of capital is concerned, everybody knows there is not the same stir of money as even 12 months ago. Therefore, the owners of business premises who were expecting the boost to which Deputy Lemass referred in Castlecomer are sadly disappointed.

Let us hear from the Government what they intend to do about these matters. They are a very important aspect of policy. What will be done to stimulates more business in business houses for the circulation of more money? What will be done about the promises made to wage-earners before the election so far as a decent wage and a proper standard of living are concerned? Having regard to the fact that business is at a standstill, surely it must be within the full knowledge of the Government that at the present time the banks will not allow business people to carry overdrafts?

I am sure I am voicing the opinion of most Deputies who have experience of activities in rural Ireland when I say that if a small farmer or even a small business man asks to-day for money in a bank the position is that a thief with a "six-shooter" in his hand would be more welcome. Due to Government policy, there is less money in circulation and certainly there is less money in the pockets of the people.

The old Fianna Fáil policy has come out in its true colours in the past 12 months. They have always been singing the tune that the people were living too well and looking too well, that they were eating too much, living beyond their means and spending too much. I have here a newspaper report of a recent speech by the Minister for Lands, who makes a very busy man of himself. He speaks more than all the Ministers put together. However, he could not speak loud enough to have his own Estimate for the coming financial year increased because it is down considerably. It would seem that the Minister for Lands does not speak where he should speak—at the Government and Cabinet meetings. He had this to say at the Dublin University Commerce and Economics Society meeting, as reported in the daily Press of the 1st March, 1958, under the heading: "Had Been Living In Make-Believe World—Mr. Childers":—

"For the past 11 years they had been living to a considerable extent in a convenient, make-believe world. They had got happiness in motor cars, wireless sets and other amenities."

Comment on this

What about television?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That was the line taken by the Minister for Lands recently in Dublin. He seemed to think that those who are fortunate enough to have a wireless set, those who have a motor car and those who, through their own hard work, skill and industry, have any comfort should not enjoy these amenities. He was very much disturbed and annoyed about the matter. It was against the grain of the wishes of the present Government that anyone should have anything but rags, sackcloth, hard times, tough times, dry bread, crusts, unemployment and long queues outside labour exchanges and the farmers beggared, paupered and driven into the workhouses.

I was told in the county registrar's office in Portlaoise this morning that, since the appointment of the present county registrar, there were never so many sheriff's decrees down. Shopkeepers cannot wait for money. Business people cannot wait for money. Process servers, sheriffs and bailiffs are the only people in full-time employment to-day. They are concentrating all their energies on the people on the land in order to drive them off it and make things harder and tougher.

On top of all this, there is a reduction in the price of wheat which may be a reduction of 6/- a barrel but it may go to 12/- a barrel when the harvest comes. During the last election, Fianna Fáil promised the barley-growers in my constituency—Deputy N. Egan will be glad to hear of this as there is a good malthouse in Banagher: I love to refresh his memory—not the 40/- a barrel which Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture gave them—that would not be sufficient in the eyes of Fianna Fáil, they said—but 45/- a barrel, if they were elected to office. The change of government came and the barley-growers are still waiting for the promised 45/- a barrel for barley. The sad position is that they have not now even the 40/- a barrel which Deputy Dillon gave them when he was Minister for Agriculture. The price per barrel for barley has now been reduced to 37/-.

I shall be interested to hear the explanation which Deputy N. Egan will give the barley-growers next Sunday week at Banagher. I shall be interested to hear an explanation as to why the barley-growers were promised 45/- a barrel for barley at a time when they were receiving 40/- a barrel for it under the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, and why now there has been a reduction of 3/- in that price of 40/- a barrel so that, under the present Government, the barley-growers are receiving not the 45/- a barrel which they were promised but 37/- a barrel.

Not alone have the prices of barley and wheat been drastically reduced but the price of grade "A" pigs is down by 5/- a cwt. Where you have good barley ground in barley production, and usually where you have maltings, you have industries in which barley producers are always interested such as pig feeding. I am sure the pig feeders of Banagher, Shannonbridge, Shannon Harbour, Ferbane, Clonbullogue and Belmont, particularly, will be interested to hear from Deputy N. Egan why the Government has not seen to it that the price of grade "A" pigs which was guaranteed by Deputy Dillon when he was Minister for Agriculture should not drop by 5/- per cwt.

A cut in barley and wheat prices, the price for pigs down by 5/- a cwt. and the fact that bailiffs, sheriffs and process-servers are working overtime will soon drive the farmers back to where they were when Deputy Smith was Minister for Agriculture some years ago and to where they were when Fianna Fáil's Minister for Agriculture conducted the economic war that beggared the majority of our farmers, that put them into debt, want and hardship to such an extent that many of their families have not since recovered from the severe damage done to them by that war. I heard Fianna Fáil condemn the old Cumann na nGaedheal policy. I was not so active in the public life of this country at the time to recollect fully all the old Cumann na nGaedheal policy. However, I recollect that its policy was that our greatest export was cattle and every encouragement was given to our people to sponsor and foster our cattle trade. It was completely cried down by Fianna Fáil.

Is it not quite evident that the difficulties brought about as a result of the balance of payments problem—to which no Government can close its eyes but must take efficient steps to rectify —can best be overcome, in our case, by the export of cattle? Fianna Fáil can claim no credit whatever for any achievements as a result of cattle exports, because it was their policy all down through the years to discredit and discourage the raising of cattle for export. They always looked upon the man who raised cattle for export as unwanted in farming society. He was looked upon with a certain amount of suspicion and disgust. Where were we but for the exports of cattle?

The Minister for Education, who is in the House now, can convey this to the Minister for Finance. I say that the greatest achievement of any Government since this State was founded was in the 1948 Trade Agreement, brought about by Deputy Dillon and the inter-Party Government. Where would this country be to-day but for the millions and millions put into the pockets of the Irish farmer through the 1948 Trade Agreement? The country was sunk long ago but for that agreement. I want to warn the present Government that, in whatever negotiations are going on with regard to agriculture and free trade, there is a bounden duty on Ireland's representatives at any free trade conferences to see that whatever happens the terms of the 1948 Trade Agreement will be held steadily and firmly.

That agreement was an outstanding achievement. I feel that the majority of our farmers do not realise the tremendous benefits which flowed from it. Not alone did it put millions into the Irish farmers' pockets but the Irish farmer passed it on to his farm worker and it went into the shops, to the business people and on into business circulation. I hope and trust that the terms of the 1948 Trade Agreement will be always protected and cherished, because the Irish farmer could not have better security or firmer security than to be linked up with the prices of live stock in Great Britain—that is to say, if the price of cattle is raised in the British market and if the English farmer is to benefit, it follows that the Irish farmer will benefit also.

Whilst the Fianna Fáil policy and programme are to condemn and criticise all actions and works of Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture, I say here and now—and I challenge contradiction from any member of the House—that the greatest achievement since this State was founded was the 1948 Trade Agreement. Not a single member of Fianna Fáil has given credit to Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture for that proud and pleasant state of affairs, which has brought tens of thousands of pounds into the pockets of the Irish farmers.

When we speak of the price of barley and the price of wheat, I do not want to let the opportunity pass without reminding Deputy Kieran Egan—who owes his seat in this House to wheat, as one of the five wheat Deputies—that on Sunday week he will have a contribution to make on wheat.

Comment on this

It will be all chaff.

Comment on this

He will be out of town.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

He will turn up; he would not do that. Let me quote Deputy Dr. Ryan on wheat. Speaking on December 2nd, 1954, on wheat prices, as reported at column 1565, he said:—

"Three hundred thousand tons of dried wheat are, I think, as near as can be to two-thirds of our requirements."

Comment on this

Now, that is interesting.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I hope Deputy Haughey heard that.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy read it very haltingly. Read it again.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Deputy Dr. Ryan on wheat, on the 2nd December, 1954, at column 1565, of Volume 147:—

"Three hundred thousand tons of dried wheat are, I think, as near as can be to two-thirds of our requirements."

That is what Deputy Dr. Ryan said. I presume this is an accurate and true account of every syllable uttered by Deputy Dr. Ryan on that occasion. We do not have to quote Deputy Dr. Ryan on wheat, because there are many other celebrities in Fianna Fáil who can be quoted. Attention has been directed already here to the fact that the same Deputy Dr. Ryan was speaking over Radio Éireann on February 25th, 1957, in his election broadcast and he described the 1954 cut in wheat as "cruel and unjust". That is what he said about it, that it was "cruel and unjust". The farmers were listening. Whether the present Minister for Lands likes it or not, the farmers have wireless sets, although it annoys him and worries him that they are sufficiently well off to have them. They were listening to Deputy Dr. Ryan on the 25th February crying bitterly and sadly. Afterwards, he was laughing at how he had pulled it off, how they fell for it and how it sounded coming over the air. They were lovely words to hear over the air—"cruel and unjust"—particularly when referring to wheat.

He said there would be a remunerative price fixed for crops such as wheat, giving the farmer to understand that when he, Deputy Dr. Ryan, said it was "cruel and unjust" that was a safeguard against a further cut in wheat. The farmers said: "We can put two and two together; he did not actually tell us he was going to give back 82/6 a barrel for wheat, but it is as good as that; he said the cut was cruel and unjust and when he gets back this is, at any rate, a guarantee over the radio, in his own voice; we will take the chance and put him back into office, in the hope of getting 82/6 a barrel" I sympathise with them. They fell for it. They asked for it, but they did not get it this time.

I want to get back now to the present Minister for Lands. When Fianna Fáil were in office he was on most of the Fianna Fáil committees. In other words, he was the Party coroner who held inquests into every item submitted for examination to see whether there was a failure when the inter-Party Government was in office. This political coroner spoke as a member of the Fianna Fáil agricultural committee and addressed the Ard Fheis of Fianna Fáil in 1956. He said:—

"The biggest problem of all was to convince farmers that if they produced more prices would not go down drastically."

That is what he said when he was a political coroner for Fianna Fáil and an active member of the Fianna Fáil Agricultural Committee. That is what he said at the Ard Fheis—that the biggest problem of all was to convince farmers, mind you, that if they produce more prices will not go down. What happened?

Comment on this

There is another word.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

"Drastically". It is a very important word because that is what did happen. Prices did go down drastically. Whether they went down drastically or modestly they went down; they did not go up. I want to place on record that while farmers are asked to work harder and produce more, there is clear evidence that it is the present Government's policy that the harder they work and the more they produce the less they will get for this produce. That refers not alone to wheat; it refers also to barley, pigs and to practically everything that comes off the land.

I ask what encouragement has the farmer to work hard to-day? What encouragement has the staunchest, most patriotic Fianna Fáil farmer, who loves to grow wheat because he feels, if he is Fianna Fáil, he is pleasing the Taoiseach and the Government to do so, or what encouragement is there to work harder in any capacity to-day? We are told to work hard and produce more and get less for it. That is clearly the position, particularly as far as wheat, pigs and barley are concerned. The present Government have come a long way in 12 months in beggaring and making paupers of the farmers. I venture to say that if there was a general election in a month's time the present Government would be swept, bag and baggage, out of office forever.

The reason and the evidence as to why that should happen is only too clear. I was present in a place called Mountcollins in West Limerick and while there I distinctly heard the present Minister for Agriculture speaking from the steps of the graveyard——

Comment on this

A suitable place.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——after Mass in Mountcollins. He said it was the duty of any Government who had the interests of the dairy farmer at heart to see that they were given a substantial increase in the price per gallon for milk. However, the script which he gave to the Press reporter was a little different. He did not put it as bluntly in the script as he actually said it but he gave every farmer in Mountcollins to understand that if Fianna Fáil were once back in office, so far as milk prices were concerned, they were sure—as sure as they saw him in Mountcollins—to get a substantial increase in the price per gallon.

What did they get? One penny per gallon less. Therefore we see that as well as milk producers, wheat growers, and barley growers every section of the agricultural community has been attacked and brutally assaulted. Every effort is being made to deprive them of a decent standard of living. The grants made available for cow-byres is being halved. I want to add my voice to the protests that have been made. I have noted, as other Deputies have, that a number of farmers have signified their intention, as a protest against the decrease in the price of milk, not to participate in the scheme for the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. I deplore that attitude. I hope that no sensible farmer will follow that course. I hope that no sensible association no matter how genuine or sincere they may be in their protest, will resort to such action. I hope that, in their own interests, owners of herds will resort to some other means of making their protests felt and heard.

Comment on this

They can march again as they did when we were in office.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

They can march but I think their protest is ill-advised if they are to be asked not to participate in the scheme for the eradication of bovine tuberculosis because the day is coming very speedily when no beast will be allowed into Britain unless it carries a tuberculosis free certificate. Nobody can say that that is not right and proper. I hope that in the interests of this country, in the interests of the high standard of all our live stock and in the interests of the farmers themselves they will give every support and co-operation even though they have got no lead from the Government. The Minister for Agriculture himself stated recently in public that even though this scheme for the eradication of bovine tuberculosis was commenced some years ago by the inter-Party Government he himself had not got his own cattle attested under that scheme. I think that is a bad headline for any Minister for Agriculture to set because any Deputy who wants to set a headline to his constituents will be the first to avail of any scheme for the benefit of the community in general.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This would be a matter for the Estimate on the Department of Agriculture. The Chair has allowed the Deputy to mention the matter, but to go into the question in detail is not permissible at this stage.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Very well, Sir. I presume that many weeks will not pass until the Agriculture Estimate will be before us and we will have an opportunity of hearing more on this subject from the Minister for Agriculture, particularly with regard to his own dairy herd. In my opinion, the farming community are facing hard, tough, bad times. It is commonly known that when the farmer is well off, and when agriculture is thriving, everybody is well off and everybody seems to have a stir of money. That has been my experience and the experience of every Deputy. There is no better spender than the farmer and no more decent man than the farmer. Because of the Government's agricultural policy, the farmer is not in that happy position to-day.

We hear speeches from members of the Fianna Fáil Party with regard to wheat, but some facts must be borne in mind by Deputies of that Party, particularly by Deputy Kieran Egan, one of the five wheat Deputies. Fianna Fáil brag and boast about being the Party that encouraged wheat and started wheat growing. Let us examine the position closely. Let us give Fianna Fáil all the credit they like to have for encouraging wheat growing, but, under Fianna Fáil, the wheat growers secured six, seven or eight barrels to the acre. Who changed the position for the betterment of wheat growers in this country? Deputy Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture, saw to it that ground limestone was made available. I did not hear him, but I presume he pointed out to this House yesterday evening that when he took office, there was not a thimbleful of ground limestone in the country.

Comment on this

He did not say that.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am probably exaggerating, but there was no ground limestone, and, as a result of the setting up of ground limestone plants and of the encouragement that was given to our farmers to use ground limestone, instead of six, seven or eight barrels of wheat being grown per acre, there were 18, 20 and 22 barrels of wheat grown per acre.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will agree that this again is a matter for the Estimate.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I agree with the Chair.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be interested to hear that the average intake per barrel per acre in 1956-57 was 8.19?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am sure the Minister for Education will agree that, if the ruling of the Chair is for me, it is also for him. We will obey the Chair. I want to draw the attention of the House to this aspect of agricultural policy. Did any member of the Fianna Fáil Party during the course of this debate say that the inter-Party Government, when they were in office, did any one thing that was of benefit to the agricultural community? In addition to the 1948 Trade Agreement being one of our greatest achievements, there was another great achievement of ours in the fact that, due to the land rehabilitation scheme, sponsored and begun by the inter-Party Government, we have 1,000,000 acres of arable land now that we had not got before that scheme was started.

If we read in the papers that a Government in Holland, or any other country abroad, had initiated a scheme making 1,000,000 acres of additional land available to produce food for man and beast, and to yield bountiful return, would we not say that it was a marvellous Government and that they were great people. When that has happened at home, when we can see that our national wealth has been substantially increased by the addition of 1,000,000 acres of land, it is a wonderful achievement about which we should never stop congratulating ourselves. Because of the envy and disgust of the Fianna Fáil Party, they are prevented from paying a tribute to the scheme which brought that great addition to our national wealth, a scheme that was launched by the inter-Party Government.

Among our other great achievements was the parish plan which provided advisory services for the farmers on their own farms. That is an achievement for which the inter-Party Government can claim credit and which has brought untold benefits in its own way to the farming community.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is going into agriculture in detail.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I was about to refer to the fact that if our farmers and people in general are asked to produce more, we must ask ourselves one question: what means of credit will be placed at the disposal of these producers in order to assist them to produce more? We have only two means by which credit can be made available to increase production. One is by loan from the banks on security, and the other is to have recourse to the loan machinery available through the medium of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. It is not common sense to ask our people, particularly our farmers, to produce more, unless there is some means by which we can give them capital to produce more.

Comment on this

What about monetary reform?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

In order to produce more from the land, in order that the farmer will carry more stock, in order that additional land will be broken up and put under the plough, additional capital should be made available. It is the duty of the Government to tell us what is their policy on the provision of capital for farmers and others to increase production. Over a 30 year period, the Agricultural Credit Corporation issued a total of 47,000 loans, of which less than 45,000 were for £500 or under. For sums between £500 and £1,000, they issued 1,766 loans while loans bigger than £1,000 totalled 555. These figures are for the 28 years between 1928 and 1956. This means that, of a total of around 200,000 farmers who are deriving most of their livelihood from the land, only one-fifth have ever applied or received a loan from any Government or semi-Government concern.

I know quite well that merchants find farmers honest to a very high degree. Bad debts between them are few and far between. On this Vote on Account we should hear from the Government what steps they propose to take in the critical period that lies ahead for the farming community to help them to increase production and what steps they propose to take to make money available to them at a low rate of interest for investment in their land. The farming community in general is looking to the Government to give a lead. This year, I venture to say, we shall have as much land under tillage as we have ever had. In many areas, additional land is being put under the plough because of the inability of farmers to buy stock and to keep stock on the land.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is discussing agriculture in detail. He should reserve his remarks for the Estimate for that Department.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I agree, but I was merely endeavouring to obtain from the Minister what Government policy is in relation to credit facilities for farmers to enable them to increase production. If we are to have more cattle for export, the farmers must be provided with the wherewithal to buy stock. That is a major point of policy. It is one of the utmost importance and there should be a statement of Government policy on that matter.

I bow to your ruling in that regard, but I must refer to the fact that the Minister for Finance saw fit in Wexford recently to offer belittling and insulting criticism of the National Farmers' Association. A word of encouragement and a pat on the back would have been better, coming from a Minister for Finance, and would have been more welcome than belittling criticism. I do not always agree 100 per cent. with the National Farmers' Association, but they are a very important representative body. They are a negotiating body. They are the link between the farmers and the Department of Agriculture. I think that the Minister's statement was made deliberately in an effort to divide and break up the National Farmers' Association.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has no relevance to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister is responsible for making that speech and it was a speech that would have been better left unmade. I should like from the Government a statement on rural electrification. We were led to believe at the general election that rural electrification was to go full steam ahead. We were told from public platforms by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and his henchmen that not alone would rural electrification go full steam ahead, but it would progress more rapidly, more efficiently and give more employment than under the inter-Party Government. I distinctly heard that statement being made. I hope Deputy Egan, who is easing his tie, is not choking when he listens to me because he is one of those who were very vocal on rural electrification. I expected the Minister for Finance to make some statement in that regard, because here on 21st May the Minister for Industry and Commerce stated that the estimated 60 new areas would be completed in the year 1957-58. He has given no explanation to the House for the slowing down of rural electrification.

Comment on this

The target was 100.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is so. May I place this on record now and may I ask the Minister for Education to remind the Minister for Finance, when he is replying, to make some reference to the deliberate slowing down of rural electrification? Is it Government policy to stop rural electrification? Is it Government policy to slow it down? Or is it Government policy to reach the target of 100 areas a year? That is a simple question to address to the Minister for Finance with special reference to Government policy.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is again a matter for the Estimate. The Deputy will understand that the Estimates are not before us. We are dealing with the Vote on Account and the policy of the Government generally, not in detail.

Comment on this

He is only throwing a bit of light on it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I cannot claim to be as familiar with procedure as you, Sir. I am asking for a statement of Government policy on rural electrification. So far, we have not had any statement of policy. I trust it will be forthcoming.

A debate such as this should not be allowed to pass without comment on the statement made by the Minister for Lands with regard to the erection of houses and hospitals and their part in providing employment for our people and keeping our people at home. The Minister for Lands spoke in Kilbeggan. He said that millions had been wasted in the vain hope that building houses and hospitals would keep our people at home. Does the Minister for Lands or the Minister for Finance hold that the millions spent by the inter-Party Government on hospitals and houses were millions spent in vain? I should be glad to be associated at any time with the spending of money on hospitals and houses for our people.

There has been no repudiation or contradiction by any member of the Government of the statement made by the Minister for Lands. He did not finish his speech at Kilbeggan in that tone. He went on to say that far too much money was being spent on nonproductive services which provided little employment. The Minister for Lands seems to look upon the building of houses and the provision of houses —in other words, the provision of work for our people—as a waste of public money and a waste of time on the part of the Government. We shall be very glad to hear from him what contribution he has to make in so far as the putting into operation of the plans and promises he made before the general election is concerned.

May I say that there is a growing tendency on the part of the Government and, indeed, on the part of all Governments, to hand over a great deal of responsibility to different boards and committees? We are asked on this Vote on Account to vote a substantial sum of money and I feel that there are many times when members of this Dáil are not given the opportunity of inquiring into every detail of public expenditure which we feel, as members of this House, we are entitled to get. There have been many occasions in the past when Deputies have addressed questions to various Ministers asking how certain public moneys voted by the House were spent and they have been given the reply that this was a matter for the everyday administration of the body given charge of the matter.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Since the Estimates are not before us at the moment, the Deputy may not raise that matter now.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It is bad Government policy to hand over the spending of large sums of money to different bodies, without some provision whereby bodies will be answerable to the House. I shall give an example.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have a further and more relevant opportunity to raise that point.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Very well, Sir. There has been a good deal of talk in this debate, particularly by Deputy Burke, who asked what machinery the Government had for furthering the sale of our exports abroad. He made particular reference to the export of whiskey. It is only right that the Government should have an efficient and up to date organisation for the handling of our exports and for the finding of suitable markets for them, particularly in the United States.

I am told by one very extensive merchant, who lives in Jackson Heights, New York, and who visits this country frequently in an effort to obtain supplies of frozen meat and fish and various other Irish goods which he is anxious to have displayed in his stores in New York, that the limited supplies available are no sooner displayed in his store windows in New York than they are immediately bought up. I feel that contact with such business men in the United States is highly important because of their practical experience and their efficiency in selling products in the United States, and their advice and assistance should be more appreciated by Córas Tráchtála, or whatever other body is pushing the sale of Irish manufactured goods in the United States.

I am inclined to agree with Deputy Burke that a good deal more can be done in pushing the sale of Irish whiskey in the United States, but whiskey comprises only a small part of our export trade. Our main export is live stock and the Government should concentrate all its efforts on the building up of the cattle trade. That is the one trade which can pay very great and bountiful dividends.

Deputy Burke also asked for cooperation with the Minister for Agriculture and he deplored the fact that various county committees of agriculture had passed resolutions calling on the Minister to resign. I think the county committees of agriculture know their own business best, and, if they find that they have no confidence in the Minister in charge of agriculture, they have a right to express their opinion. There is no better way of expressing an opinion than that which has been adopted by the different county committees of agriculture.

The outlook for the farming community, for the workers, for the manufacturers and for all sections of the Irish people is a bad and gloomy one. I think the only remedy is for those of us on this side of the House to arouse public opinion in the country so that the people will tell the Government to face up to their responsibility, that it is their duty and responsibility now to find a remedy. The Government now have an overall majority. This House does not stand in their way. If the Government have a progressive policy this House must adopt it because of the numerical strength of the Government Party. There is nothing to stop them now. There is no use talking about the past. The future is theirs and the present is theirs.

It is their job and their responsibility to provide a remedy for the decline and distress of the past 12 months. This Government were given a year's trial. They failed miserably in that year. If they cannot do better in the four years ahead, I feel that the outlook for the Irish people is bad, gloomy and disastrous. I am sorry for the people and I am sorry for the Fianna Fáil Deputies who have to defend the actions of the Government. It takes courage and grit and hard neck to do that, but I have no doubt that they have an abundance of the necessary hard neck. For that reason, I feel it is the duty of this Opposition to bring home to the minds of the people their folly of 12 months ago. It is the duty of the Opposition, not alone to be determined and constructive, but to see that a Government fulfils its obligations to the people, and if they do not keep their promises, that their promises will appear before them with frequent reminders. There is a day of reckoning coming for all of us. It may be far away; it may be near. There is a day on which the Government will have to answer for their deeds. It may be far away; it may be near. But there is nothing surer than that it will come, and all the better for the Irish people, the sooner it comes.

Never in the history of this country was there such a game of fraud and trickery as was played in the last election, and the eyes of the Irish people have never been opened wider in horror and amazement than they have been to-day. I hope they will stay open. The people will get only the Government they ask for and they should not be deceived. We on this side were not deceived. We told the people what they would get and they have got it. We are telling them now that blessed are they who expect nothing for they shall not be disappointed. I hope they are not expecting anything in the next four years from the Government because they will not get it.

I want to conclude on the note that it is always best in Irish politics to be honest with the people. I was always a believer in being honest with the people. By being honest with the people, I was always placed at the head of the poll.

Comment on this

Not recently.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

What election is the Deputy referring to?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Placings in an election may not be discussed on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

My reference was to the fact that the Deputy's vote has been going down.

Comment on this

So did that of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I am not discussing the Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I would ask Deputy Haughey not to offer me the insult of being coupled with the Taoiseach. The best policy is to be honest with the people, no matter how Deputy Haughey may laugh at it.

Comment on this

I am not laughing at the statement. I am laughing at the person making it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Honesty always pays big dividends. The present Government were not honest and they cannot expect big dividends. That is why they have failed. They have deceived the people; they have tricked the people, beggared the farming community, pauperised the workers and driven the unemployed outside the four shores of the country. They have brought ruin——

Comment on this

And distress.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——and distress to every home, including those loved most by Deputy Moher, the milk producers and the barley producers. If Midleton is in Deputy Moher's constituency—and I am sure it is—I understand he has a serious unemployment problem that did not exist in that area when the inter-Party Government was in office.

Comment on this

It is only nine miles from Whitegate.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I know every inch of it Did I not walk it?

Comment on this

Did the Deputy not cycle it?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I did.

Comment on this

Deputy Galvin has wakened up.

Comment on this

The Fenians will be after you, the same as your grandfather.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, this is the second occasion on which Deputy Galvin has imputed certain things against my family. On the last occasion, he made the suggestion that I had a picture of King George in my house. The remark the Deputy passed on that occasion was not heard by me, until I read it in the Cork Examiner. I want to state that the picture in my house, to which Deputy Galvin was referring, is that of Brigadier Seán Hales, who was murdered by a person or persons unknown.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

That is the only picture in my house. That statement was published in a daily newspaper and is on the records of this House. I want to deny that and deny again the charge being made now against my forebears by a Deputy who knows nothing about them. I want to say that the people before me were with the Dillons and those who fought the Land War against the bailiffs, some of whose descendants to-day are now Ministers of State. Deputy Galvin can put that in his pipe and smoke it.

Comment on this

My grandfather never had to go from the Fenians.

Comment on this

Let the dead rest.

Comment on this

I want to draw your attention to the fact, Sir, that this Deputy made personal imputations against my forebears which I emphatically refute. I challenge him to provide one scintilla of proof in support of the shocking allegations he has made and has repeated for the third time in the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Galvin should not make charges such as this. The Chair deplores such charges, but there is nothing the Chair can do, as far as political charges are concerned. Deputy O'Sullivan has been afforded an opportunity of denying the charges made by Deputy Galvin.

Comment on this

Thank you, Sir.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Having regard to the entire lack of a constructive policy for employment, for stemming emigration and increasing production, I suggest the Government are entirely bankrupt of policy. Steps should be taken by the Government to come down to earth because the policy on which they have embarked during the past 12 months is one that has been concentrated more in the air than on the ground. The ordinary men and women in the country, who have to work and earn their bread, are not concerned with aircraft, air lines or the extension of air services. While there may be a lot to be said for those, first things should come first.

The Government should concentrate their energies on the ordinary man in the street and see that a decent standard of living is provided for all sections of the community. I want to join with my colleagues in severely censuring the Government. They have failed in their job, failed the Irish people, mismanaged the affairs of the State and have driven the people into distress and poverty such as has never been known in the country's history.

Comment on this
John Lynch Minister for Education (Mr. J. Lynch) Fianna Fáil

It is difficult on a debate like this to avoid making particular references, even though one must, according to the rules of order of the House. It is particularly difficult if one has to sit here for a period to get a chance to speak to avoid following suggestions and arguments made on one side or other of the House. I propose to deal shortly with just a few general remarks and to refer, if I may, to something in particular before I conclude.

Deputy Sweetman, when he opened the debate, made a short review of conditions leading up to the present situation and since he did so briefly, I think he was probably in order and therefore I might similarly be in order in making brief reference to these conditions. It must be admitted, as most Deputies who spoke on the opposite side have admitted, that when the present Government assumed office exactly a year ago to-day, I think, they had a clear mandate from the people. They were given an overall majority and that was because the people realised the situation had been reached when a Government with a sufficient majority should be given control of the country's affairs.

The economic situation was extremely bad then, and in the minds of the people there was a clear realisation of the necessity to set the country back on a steady economic course and to right, as far as possible, the finances of the nation. I think that was what Fianna Fáil promised to do initially. Charges have been made about breaches of election pledges, the breaking of all kinds of promises, but it is only natural that during an election campaign Fianna Fáil Deputies should have shown up as far as they could the deficiencies of the then Government, deficiencies which were apparent to the vast majority of the electorate and which were reflected in the way the people cast their votes.

I should like to support what the Minister for Lands has said, and I have taken particular pains to check the references, that, by and large, the statements made by Fianna Fáil with regard to the task that faced any Government coming into power at that time, were to the effect that it would be a difficult task. I am sure the people realised it would be an uphill fight and for that reason, even though the Government and the people might be disappointed at the progress to date, I believe the people are still patient and still hopeful that the signs of improvement which have been apparent in the past 12 months will continue and fructify in the future.

The Irish people had long been influenced in their approaches to elections by political considerations. Up to the late 1920's, the Civil War was a live issue—probably even later. Subsequent to the accession of Fianna Fáil to power for the first time, much of our progress was of a political nature and that, I would submit, had the support of the majority of the people. There were certain and more significant economic advancements. Then came the war with restrictions and rationing in its wake. Shortly after the end of the war, the first inter-Party Government gained office. I suggest that by that time the progressive policy of Fianna Fáil from their accession to office up to the time they first left office had been generally accepted by all Parties in the State from the economic and social points of view.

Many of the facets of progress in political, economic and social spheres were opposed by the then Opposition, but we are glad to note, and I think the country is pleased also, that the fundamental political aim of the nation is common to all sides of the House, with the result that I think I can rightly suggest that we now have a united country, politically, and if the people differ in supporting different political Parties, it is an economic difference influenced by our study of economic conditions and by the performances of the different Governments we have had. That discriminating public decided, on economic considerations, to remove the former Government from office. They assessed the existing conditions on the merits and they realised that the country 12 months ago was in a bad way. For that reason, they decided to make a change.

Before the previous Government left office, its members knew the country was in a bad way, and they knew that the people fully appreciated the position. They left office, and I use the word advisedly, even though it was suggested that it was because of the withdrawal of support by a small section of Deputies supporting them. I suggest, if they wanted to continue in office, that, even with these defections, they still had a majority in the House; yet they complained they were removed from office before they had an opportunity of putting their programme into effect, before the fruits of their policy began to show the productivity that was bound to come. That situation arose after a period of almost three years; now 12 months after the Fianna Fáil Government acceded to office in a serious situation like that, it is being pilloried and criticised because it has not fully restored the economic situation.

Fianna Fáil faced a similar position in 1951; not so serious perhaps, in some respects, because capital was more readily available in 1951 than it was at the end of 1956 and at the beginning of 1957. Nevertheless, after two years, Fianna Fáil had been able to right the situation and able to mark the end of 1953 as a year of progress and recovery, a year that has been acknowledged as the best year economically the country has enjoyed since the end of the last war——

Comment on this

Of which year is the Minister speaking?

Comment on this

Of 1953.

Comment on this

I see. I would love to know who acknowledged it.

Comment on this

The advantages that were gained in 1953 were gained largely as a result of what has been described as the "harsh, cruel and unnecessary" Budget of 1952, a Budget which, according to the Opposition, involved unnecessary taxation to the extent of £10,000,000, an amount that could have been decreased in ten minutes. Nevertheless, in 1954 to 1957, with the possible exception of the relief in the subsidy on butter, not one penny of that £10,000,000 appeared by way of benefit and not one aspect or item of the cruel hardships imposed by Fianna Fáil was removed by the Coalition Government in any of their Budgets.

The advantages that were gained were quickly lost and in 1956 we had a year in which unemployment had risen alarmingly. By the end of that year the number on the live register had reached something in excess of 95,000. What was more important was that there was almost a complete breakdown in the availability of capital. Two National Loans had failed. I will admit in respect of one of them that outside conditions influenced the success of the loan but the conditions of the previous loan which had not filled were much more favourable. The public did not subscribe to the extent that the then Minister for Finance thought they would or felt was necessary for the advancement of the capital programme of the State. It was apparent, when the Government assumed office, that the people appreciated that they were faced with a difficult task which would not be easy to overcome.

There have been charges made during the course of this debate against the present Government of holding up housing schemes. During the latter part of 1955 and particularly the early part of 1956 we all know the difficulty local authorities had in having provided for them through the Local Loans Fund, through Government agency, the finances necessary for house building. We know also that when the Government had left office many people who had entered into commitments under the Local Loans Fund had not got the necessary money wherewith to complete their houses or to pay their builders. Rather than hold up housing schemes, it must be acknowledged that the present Minister for Agriculture, when he succeeded as Minister for Local Government, provided a substantial amount of money to make up the leeway that existed in the 1955-56 period.

Deputy Flanagan suggested, since the Minister for Lands has made some statement to this effect, that Fianna Fáil have decided that house building is not good economy. The Minister for Lands mentioned that if we had been in a position to devote the capital moneys necessary for the building of houses, hospitals and roads to projects of a more productive nature, it would have made for more lasting employment in the country and would have been generally conducive to the economic advancement of the country inasmuch as continuous employment would have been made available.

If £10,000,000 is spent on houses or on roads, it would take approximately something short of £1,000,000 to service that debt in one year and that £1,000,000, if devoted to more productive purposes, would probably provide employment for 250 or more people. Nevertheless, our economic difficulties in this respect exist and they are largely influenced—I shall not say entirely influenced—by our political history. Unfortunately there were many decades of neglect in regard to the provision of social amenities of all kinds. Housing, hospitals, schools and roads were neglected and the new Free State Government and the Governments which followed had to pay particular attention to these matters. They had, perhaps, to devote an undue proportion of the available capital to the remedying of the deficiencies in this respect.

The house building programmes embarked upon in the 1930's and ever since, the hospital building programmes, the road making programmes involved the employment of a very big labour force. The houses had to be completed at some stage and in many counties the targets which the local authorities set themselves have already been reached; their programmes have been finished. In the bigger areas, the amount of building has been tapering off.

The problem then arose: what were we to do with the big labour force that was employed on these various projects? Our capital had been sunk, I again say, in a rather disproportionate manner in these very desirable social projects and sufficient capital was not available for the continued employment of that labour force. I think the previous Minister for Finance experienced that difficulty as much as, if not more than, any other Minister for Finance. That is and for some time will continue to be our greatest economic difficulty. It was born out of our political history and I, for one, do not regret the fact that our Governments, when they got the opportunity, did undertake the building of hospitals, houses and roads that were acutely necessary. Anybody who is a member of a local authority and is faced with requests from people living in bad housing conditions for new houses or who was faced up to three or four years ago by people who had relatives suffering from T.B. for the provision of beds in T.B. hospitals, will not regret that such an amount of our capital resources was devoted over the years to these purposes.

I would suggest that the reference to the decreased provision for house building in the current year does not indicate a fair-minded approach to what the facts are. In many areas, particularly in my own constituency, in Dublin and elsewhere, the number of houses to be built is still very large. It has often been suggested that the amount of money available is not sufficient. A peculiar position was reached in my own constituency last year when, of the £750,000 made available to the local authority for capital purposes, £30,000 remained unspent up to about a fortnight ago, with little prospect of that £30,000 being usefully utilised in the balance of the financial year.

Perhaps steps have been taken since then to use up the balance of the £750,000 but the point I am making is that, apart from the few areas where there is still a big backlog in the number of houses to be provided, most of the local authorities either have reached their housing targets or are certainly nearing them. Therefore, it is only reasonable to expect that the overall provision for houses will come down in the coming years.

The main stress in this debate has been placed on the attack, as it has been described, on the farming community. Everybody knows that the taxpayer generally will, in existing circumstances, have to bear a considerable portion of the moneys earned by farmers for their production. Deputy Costello, when he was speaking, mentioned that the levies which were taken off certain commodities in the past 12 months should have been left there in order to subsidise to a greater extent than at present the export of agricultural surpluses. However, he qualified that very particularly. He said they should be left there at least for a very short period.

Comment on this

I think he said "the levies on luxuries".

Comment on this

I want to correct myself. His actual words were "but only as a temporary measure".

Comment on this

But I think he also said "the levies on luxuries".

Comment on this

I would have to check that, but I will accept what the Deputy says.

Comment on this

I have not got the reference, either.

Comment on this

At all events, it is clear that Deputy Costello did not envisage extra taxation to provide the moneys to subsidise these surpluses. Not only did he not envisage extra taxation, but he advocated that if we were to achieve extra production, we would have to decrease taxation. It would be interesting, therefore, to find out from Opposition Deputies how they would propose to make the moneys available to subsidise, without limit, our exportable surpluses of agricultural products.

It is very significant that here in this House, at any rate, the Labour Party have been rather silent on what their remedy would be. Nevertheless, Deputy Norton at a function at Naas, in Deputy Sweetman's constituency, which he was unfortunately unable to attend, said that this policy of exporting surpluses was a suicidal economic policy. I can only conclude from that and the fact that we have not heard any direct contribution to the debate from the members of the Labour Party, that the Labour Party would not support the subsidisation of surplus agricultural products for export purposes. That is borne out by the fact that they failed to support the Fine Gael Party motion some couple of weeks ago. Therefore, it is pretty clear to the farmers that if the Coalition Government were still in power, they would have considerable difficulty in convincing them, as they appear to be trying to do now, that agricultural prices should be maintained, irrespective of surpluses.

The charge has been made that increased production results either in decreased employment or lower prices for agricultural goods, but I should like to draw a distinction between increased production and increased productivity. If increased production will procure only a greater bulk of goods produced at the same unit cost, then increased production will serve very little useful purpose, once the immediate local demand has been satisfied, but increased productivity should— and I think everybody will agree with this—result in reducing the unit cost of all commodities and, therefore, enable the producer, the manufacturer of these goods, to supply them on the market, whether it be the home market or the foreign market, at a lower cost and thus give him an opportunity of competing with more favourable prospects of success in that market.

I do not think there is anything inconsistent with increased productivity and the maintaining of employment at the present level and ultimately increasing employment in certain industries. As I said, if a man produces a manufactured article at a certain cost per unit, at a certain capital outlay, and if, by increased productivity, he can produce, with the same capital outlay, at the same cost, one and a half units of that manufactured commodity, he should be able to market it more cheaply and ultimately expand his production.

Similarly with agricultural goods. I am not setting myself up to be an expert, but I should like to refer to some figures quoted by Deputy Flanagan a few minutes ago when he boasted that as a result of Deputy Dillon's agricultural policy, the barrel production per acre of wheat increased from some six to 20 barrels in a short period. I should like to refer him to the figures with which I have been supplied. They indicate that the mill intake of barrels per acre which was 6.75 barrels in 1954-55 increased to only 8.3 by 1957-58. However, whether it is an increase of six to 8.3 or six to 20, it would appear to me that if the farmer can increase his productivity, get more production out of his acreage, assuming that his capital and his costs remain the same, he should be able to market his produce more cheaply.

I will admit that farming costs have increased over a number of years. Nevertheless, I would suggest that, as in the case of manufacturers who are trying by new methods, by more up-to-date techniques, to reduce their cost of production, similarly the farmers' more modern techniques, the application of fertilisers and the consequent increase in output per acre, should enable them to sell more profitably and more cheaply.

I shall not dwell on the question of wheat, but I should like to remark that, when the price per barrel of wheat was reduced from 82/6 to 70/- in the cereal year 1955-56, there were then 2,604,000 odd barrels produced. The following year there were some 2,781,000 barrels produced but, what is still more significant, is the fact that the number of barrels per acre delivered to the mills increased steadily over the period 1955-56 to 1957-58 from 7.27 to 8.3 barrels per acre, which is a clear indication that the farmers are getting more out of their wheat over that period. As well as that, and despite the large cut made in 1954-55-56, there were more barrels per acre produced, if there was a slightly less acreage grown in the previous year.

If wheat is to be produced beyond our consuming capacity to the extent that the surplus will either have to be exported, sold for animal feed or otherwise utilised profitably, the fact remains that the taxpayer will have to bear the cost of that burden. If a higher grist of native wheat is put into our bread, it will mean an increase in the price of the loaf. The amount of imported wheat now necessary to produce a loaf which appears palatable to the Irish people, is cheaper than the cost of our native wheat and thus contributes to the holding down of the price of bread whereas if we had to put more of our wheat into that bread it would inevitably increase the cost of the loaf.

When we speak about the attack on the farmers' incomes by the decision on wheat made by the Government, one must also take into account that only 60,000 out of 380,000 farm holdings produce wheat apart altogether from the people who do not work in agriculture. All these people have to be taken into account as well. The interest of the community as a whole must be the determining factor in the long run. I have gone into this matter more deeply than I intended. Nevertheless, I think these facts ought to be remembered when people talk loosely about the price of wheat and the attacks made on farmers' incomes.

The point I commenced to make was that if, as appears to be the policy of the Labour Party, agricultural products which we produce to a surplus should not be subsidised by the taxpayer and if, as it appears from the former Taoiseach's statement, these should not, as a permanent measure, be subsidised either out of taxation, what then is the Opposition's objective suggestion as to how a surplus of wheat or a surplus of milk could be carried by the taxpayer in the coming financial year? It would be interesting to know how they propose to finance these exportable surpluses.

I said before—and I shall repeat it —that it is in the national interest to a certain extent that these things should be subsidised, particularly so in the case of exports of butter which is so much an issue now as an international economic matter. Deputy Flanagan a while ago said that Fianna Fáil deplored the person who raised beef for export. He seemed conveniently to forget that unless the dairy farmer was properly looked after, as he was down through the years by Fianna Fáil, we would have no beef for export. Everybody knows that the dairy farmer is the keystone of our agricultural economy. Unless we have calves we shall not have cattle for export. It would certainly be inconsistent for Fianna Fáil to denounce the raising of cattle for export. We all know what we owe to it and all praise to Deputy Dillon and the other Minister for Agriculture for fostering the export of cattle.

I would agree, however, with Deputies who say that we should aim at a higher rate of processing of our agricultural goods. Exporting cattle on the hoof, while it might be profitable to a very large extent, could, I suggest, be still more profitable if we could process more and more of that beef at home. It would provide not only the means of possibly higher prices for carcase meat but it would provide also the possibility of developing an extra industry from by-products which are now lost to us by exporting cattle on the hoof.

Deputy Costello made a suggestion with regard to the possibility of the utilisation of surplus milk. He suggested the manufacturing of cheese and the possibility of extending our exports of cheese. That is a matter in which I was always interested, but, again, I am not sufficiently conversant with the dairying industry and certainly not with the difficulties of processing cheese to suit the taste of our own people and people abroad. Nevertheless, I would suggest to the creameries, particularly those creameries engaged in the making of cheese at the present time, that there must be a method whereby they can increase the utilisation of milk and at the same time benefit the country by providing us with greater markets abroad in milk products. I know there are difficulties involved. If there were not, I am sure the present processes in regard to cheese would have expanded trade in that direction. These are only small instances of how we can expand the export of our agricultural products and relieve the taxpayer of the necessity to pay certain subsidies on such exports.

I mentioned I was going to speak in a general manner and then refer to something in particular. The particular matter to which I want to refer was something mentioned by Deputies Sweetman and Casey, and, perhaps, one or two other Deputies. That was the reference to the apparent reduction in the provision for primary school buildings in the current year. I hope I am in order in making this reference since other Deputies referred to the matter. I shall only deal with it very superficially.

It is true that in the Estimate for primary school building in the current year there is an apparent reduction of £174,000. The fact is, however, that the amount of money provided for last year, £1,589,000, was not entirely spent and will not be entirely spent at the end of the current year. In fact, only £1,200,000 of that provision will be spent by the 31st of the present month. Therefore, the provision of £1,415,000 odd for the coming year is an increase of £200,000 on the amount of money spent in the present financial year on school building. That is a realistic increase and it is the sum which we expect will be spent on the building of national schools in the coming 12 months.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think it is enough?

Comment on this

I do not.

Comment on this

I do not believe the Minister does.

Comment on this

I should like to tell the Deputy not only why I do not think it is enough, but how it is limited to what it is for the current year. At the end of 1956, as the Deputy knows, for the six months June to November, the Office of Public Works was instructed by the Department of Education—possibly as a result of its being, in turn, instructed by the Department of Finance—that no more provision was to be made for school-building in that period. The same applied to vocational school buildings and perhaps other projects of a capital nature as well, but I do not know. Certainly it applied in relation to school buildings. The Office of Public Works then instructed their technicians that no more money would be spent on schools. The Minister for Finance had not the money. We were all aware that a serious capital position obtained in the country at the time.

The criticism which I make and which I made when I came to the Department was why should this six months be lost. I was told that the Office of Public Works, as a result of that six months' lay-off, were not geared to keep up the then existing tempo of school-building. My criticism was that the Department of Education and the Office of Public Works should have insisted on the examination of plans, in so far as they could have gone on. Perhaps they could not be looked after 100 per cent., but certainly there should be no reason for a back log as did appear at the end of the present year.

I pressed as hard as I could but I could get only £1,200,000 out of them. The excuse was that the six months' Standstill Order was the cause of their failure to expend more money on building, that the effects of the Standstill Order still persist, and that they can increase that expenditure by only £200,000 in the coming year. Nevertheless, it is a significant increase, though it is not quite as large as the expenditure in the year prior to last year, and certainly is not nearly as much as I know is necessary and as I hope will be expended in coming years.

I am grateful to the Chair for permitting me to refer in particular to this matter, even though I know that, in so doing, I am possibly straining the rules applicable to a debate such as this. In so far as those specific charges have been made, I hope I have refuted them satisfactorily and allayed any fears Deputies may have had or expressed that there would be a reduction in school building. Rather can I say that there will be a significant increase—an increase of 17 per cent. which, I suggest, is significant.

Comment on this

I listened patiently during the past week, in the hope that we would hear some statement from a representative of the Government in connection with portion of the plan for the relief of unemployment which we were promised. It is no use for Deputies or Ministers to make the excuse that that plan which was announced by the Tánaiste was for discussion only. I am in a position to prove that the plan was announced to counteract the trade union plan for full employment. The Tánaiste made a statement at a public meeting in Wexford, as reported in the newspapers, on 23rd February, 1957, in the course of which he said that they had published their plan, both in the Dáil and elsewhere, and that it had received support from all quarters, amongst the farmers, trade union leaders and businessmen. That plan, as we all know, was promised. Millions of pounds were to be spent and thousands of men were to be put into employment.

This Government have now had 12 months of office. Surely it is time for them to give us an indication of what portion of that plan will be put into operation? As reported in the Irish Press of 9th March, the Taoiseach said:—

"Unemployment is the one thing I am thinking of at the moment. Fianna Fáil's first task would be to secure sufficient employment so that people would not have to emigrate through economic necessity."

On the subject of emigration, the Taoiseach is reported as saying:—

"That is, of course, a longstanding evil. It has become more serious in recent years, partly due to economic factors and partly due to other ones. The proper place to start, I think, as regards the economic side, is to try to secure that there will be sufficient employment available for our people so that they will not, through any economic necessity, have to go abroad."

There was the first task and the Taoiseach stated they were thinking of that plan. He continued:—

"With an overall majority, the Fianna Fáil Government will begin at once to put back into productive employment our 90,000 unemployed."

I believe the Taoiseach, in all sincerity, made that statement, which was reported in the Irish Press of 9th March.

The Minister for Defence made a great case to the effect that unemployment has been relieved. We were inquiring in what areas unemployment has been relieved. Unfortunately, it is not true in my constituency. Let us consider the position in one of the industrial portions of County Wicklow, where at least four factories were giving employment. Three of them have now closed down, and, in one of the principal industries, the employees are on a three-day working week.

In another part of County Wicklow, flour mills which gave employment have been closed down and, since last October, very few men are employed on the roads. Nevertheless, when the Minister for Finance went down to a cumann meeting in that area, he tried to make excuses for the county council being unable to provide the employment which they had provided in previous years. In the course of the whole of this debate, we have not had a statement from any Minister in connection with the serious problems facing the country. I have been associated with this House for over 35 years and I cannot understand the attitude of the Government on this occasion.

We talk about factories closing down. Even in this particular area, 40 families emigrated to England. They were individual farm labourers going up to the county council and paying 2/- a week for a house with a half-acre of land, but they took themselves and their families across where there was more work than in this area. What has become of the plan we were promised to provide employment for our people. There is money in the country. That has been proved by the two successful loans. Ministers and Deputies of Fianna Fáil are responsible for all the prophecies of gloom and despair, but in spite of that a large number of people invested in the E.S.B. and other loans. If they had not painted such a gloomy picture, the position would not be as serious as it is to-day. Even those who are in temporary employment are wondering whether they should remain another week or clear off in the next boat.

The Minister for Lands is taking the long-term view. Notwithstanding that he has reduced the amount provided for forestry, he points out what will happen in 50 years' time. That is a long time to go. He will provide full employment for all men requiring work on forestry then. He is quite safe in talking about 50 years' time. None of us will be here to contradict him or to refer to his speech.

I maintain the Government is responsible for the serious position we are faced with to-day. They deliberately attacked the workers by the removal of the food subsidies. I warn them of the serious ill effects it will have and I am warning the Minister that, notwithstanding his threats, the trade unions will be there to protect their members and get them back some compensation to meet the reduction in the standard of living caused by the removal of the food subsidies. The Minister for Industry and Commerce immediately had to consult with the trade unions to get some agreement between wage earners and employers, to meet partly the deliberate action of the Government in removing the food subsidies.

What do we find to-day? I am sure Fianna Fáil members must feel the same as other members. We find that we are asking the unemployed man, the old age pensioner and poor people in the lower income group to pay a tax in order to give the people in full employment in England butter at 2/6 a lb. I have seen butter brought in by sailors in my own town, Irish creamery butter, three pounds of it, and the sailor told me he paid 7/6 for the three pounds. It was the best Irish creamery butter, bought across in Liverpool. At the same time butter is 4/5 a lb. here.

I could go back to history. I remember one occasion when the then Minister for Finance attacked the social services and a number of Deputies then approached the Minister. We were told by the Finance representative at the time that the Minister thought it was necessary to attack the social services because it was saving £500,000 that year. One man on the deputation had lost his brother in the war and he said: "I am very sorry to-day that my brother gave up his life, if it meant saving Ireland for £500,000 and attacking the social services of the people." The Finance Department were always like that. Naturally, I have nothing to say about the civil servants; I found them nothing but courteous and I am proud of our Irish Civil Service. They have given good service to the State, but they always take the safe course and they will take no risks. Of course, they will advise that the Department cannot do this and cannot do the other. They have advised in connection with the removal of the food subsidies.

What is the position to-day? We remove the subsidy on butter and we have estimated that in this particular year £3,210,000 will have to be found to meet the subsidies on butter. Would it not be better to adopt the Danish plan, announced in the papers yesterday, and give to the Irish people cheap butter, just as the Danes are giving it to their people at 1/9 a lb. instead of sending it to England and depriving their own people of it? Why not right the blunders we made and give our Irish people the butter? Then no one will object and the farmers will get the subsidy at the same time.

I am not alone in this. I will quote the Taoiseach himself. When Deputy Sweetman, as Minister for Finance, was bringing in the resolution to lower the home price of butter by 5d. a lb., Deputy de Valera then said, as reported at column 143 of Volume 146, in relation to the relative values of butter from the point of view of health as against certain health benefits, that he was inclined to agree to a large extent with what Deputy Sweetman had said. He continued:—

"I think that the foundation of health is good food."

That was what Deputy de Valera said in all sincerity in June, 1954.

He continued, referring to the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman:—

"The Minister has indicated that he has put in comparison the health services and butter and I am inclined to agree that if I had to choose in certain circumstances I might choose butter."

Now, however, despite the view which he took then, his Government are penalising the poor people in the lower income group and the unemployed by making them pay 4/4 a lb. for butter, whilst at the same time he is giving butter at a couple of shillings a lb. to people over in England and the North of Ireland. This was made an election issue by a politician in the North of Ireland, who said: "There is the Twenty-Six Counties economy, giving us butter at a couple of shillings a lb. but charging their own people 4/5; they are giving it to England cheaper than they are giving it to their own poor people". He made it an election issue and it appeared in the papers all last week. Here we are asking the poorer section of the community to pay the subsidy and denying them the butter for themselves.

Of course, we shall be told by the Minister about the balance of payments. If the Minister took into consideration the amount of raw materials imported for the manufacture of margarine, because less butter is consumed by the people now on account of the price, one would balance with the other. I am not one to say that the balance of payments is to be held in a state of sanctity while we let our own people become unemployed and disheartened.

During 35 years here I have listened to many debates but it is no pride or honour now to get up and talk about the position of the country. I want to point out that we could take a different course. As I pointed out, it has been proved that the loans were successful. We should not continue talking about "strong Government" but we should get the people who have the money to invest in Irish industry to provide employment for our people at home. Encouragement is being offered by the remission of taxes and by grants for the starting of industries, but if we continue the gloomy speeches made by Fianna Fáil Deputies and Ministers, we are not encouraging people here anxious to invest their money in their own country.

Why not point out the good things that have happened, the great achievements that have been taking place? I could go back over 35 years and talk about many things but I take a great pride in praising this country and boasting about it even when there is a Government in office which I may oppose greatly. I prefer to do that than making statements against the country. I heard a Fianna Fáil Deputy praising some Labour representative in England. He forgot to tell us that the Labour Party, in Government, were the first to attack Ireland by Act of Parliament. He had nothing but praise for them. I have no praise for all of the men who were in the English Labour Government because it was they who made an attack on Ireland by the Government of Ireland Act. Therefore, when he gives a quotation I think he should give it from some Englishman other than some of the Labour men they had there.

I referred to the position that there was unemployment in all parts of the country. While it is wise and proper that we should discuss the distressing position in agriculture and sympathise with the agricultural people, I, representing both an urban and a rural area, regret to say that businessmen, supporters of the Government, have told me that they were never faced with a position such as obtained at the present moment because the Government gave orders to the banks to withdraw credit. They have reduced all the various financial provisions that give employment. They reduced the Board of Works Estimate; they have taken £700,000 out of the Local Government Estimate, although the Minister for Local Government, in a broadcast before the election, said that houses, sanitation and water works were essential and important features of local government administration. Now he is Minister and he has been responsible for reducing the Estimate by £700,000. Where now will we get the money for the erection of houses, with the high rate of interest? Half of the skilled men who were employed in Dublin have had to emigrate and are lost to the country for ever.

I belonged to one public body which initiated direct housing schemes. We had houses erected even during the war, but now, owing to the high rate of interest, an economic rent cannot be obtained. We cannot borrow money because the tenants we have in mind would not be able to pay the rent. Houses will not be erected unless we are able to reduce the rate of interest to encourage public bodies to proceed with their erection. Houses are required and if there is a house available there are ten to 20 applicants for it. I cannot understand why the Government allowed the banks to act in the way they did. I am not divulging any secrets but I know that the banks at one time refused Dublin Corporation £100,000 for the erection of houses. They were given an ultimatum and told that if they did not help the corporation other measures would be taken and then Dublin Corporation got their money. We found out in two days that it was not necessary to withdraw credit on the other side, that it was only a book transaction.

Why are we allowing the banks to take advantage of the present rates when the public require amenities such as water works, sewerage and the erection of houses? You and I must pay extra in our taxes and in our rates, but the banks get away with all the spoils because they lose nothing. Our only hope is to get control of the banking system of this country, through the Central Bank or otherwise. I say so, after my years of experience.

I do not want to detain the House, but I did not wish to allow the opportunity pass without expressing my views in case my constituents might think that we were approving of what has been happening here over the last 12 months. The Fianna Fáil Government have now been 12 months in office and I until recently had some hopes for them, believing that the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste would hardly make statements such as they did unless they really meant to put them into operation. I am disappointed now when I hear a Minister say that the statements were only for public discussion. I appeal to the Government that if a blunder has been made in the removal of food subsidies, to restore them in the coming Budget. If we have to give a subsidy on exports of butter, let charity begin at home and save for our own people first.

Comment on this

I must say that I feel slightly worried, having listened to Deputy Flanagan speaking for close on two hours this evening. I have come to the conclusion that we must be desperate fellows over here. I am sure I am included in the five "wheat" Deputies who were mentioned. I really feel worried, as I say, rising to speak on this Vote on Account. I find it hard to understand why if the Coalition Government accomplished so much in the space of the last three years they were in office, they left office this time last year. I find it still harder to understand why, when they did get out of office, the electorate of the Twenty-Six Counties made sure that they stayed out.

Over the last four days we have heard many speeches from Fine Gael Deputies in connection with farming. I suppose it is only right that they should deal with farming as the farmers are an important section of the community. Nevertheless, I would say to them that there are a few other people in the country as well. I do not think for one moment that the farmers in the Twenty-Six Counties would thank Deputy Oliver Flanagan for the statements he made this evening when he referred to them as being pauperised and beggared. The farmers are an independent, hardy, hardworking and sturdy people and they, the small farmers in particular, have all down the years supported the national drive and the national efforts of this country.

We have heard no realistic or objective approach whatsoever to this debate by the Opposition. I think the only refreshing contribution I heard was that by Deputy Corish yesterday evening. It was, I believe, the only honest contribution to this debate. It is rare to find a Deputy on this side congratulating a member of the Opposition——

Comment on this

He is a Wexford man.

Comment on this

——and especially an Opposition man in his own county, but I will say this, that Deputy Corish made a constructive and honest speech on this Vote on Account. He made one appeal that I should like to support. It is an appeal which the whole House could back, an appeal to the Irish people to buy Irish goods. It should not really be necessary to do that, but, in view of the possibility that the Free Trade Area will come into being— though I doubt if it ever will—it is only right that our Irish people should be Irish goods conscious. We might extend that appeal to our emigrants overseas. If we could get as many of them as possible to be Irish goods conscious, to buy as many Irish goods as may be available to them, to make the effort to secure as many Irish goods as we can put at their disposal, it would be doing very much to help the home market. If we could get our Irish people in six major cities, London, Liverpool and Birmingham in England, and New York, Boston and Philadelphia in the United States, to support our Irish goods, it would be doing a lot to help the economy of the homeland.

With regard to the Government's policy as a whole, there has been no realistic or objective approach to the situation by the speakers who have spoken for the Opposition. We have gone over the same ground time and time again. I think it has been gone over six times since I came into the House 12 months ago. We have had all this business again about the election promises. We have had the usual papers produced, the Irish Press, or Pravda, as Deputy Dillon would prefer to call it, and the Fianna Fáil publication, An Gléas. We have had a new one produced, the Nenagh Guardian, which has appeared in good company. I would say to my good friends from Tipperary that in future, when they are holding their conventions, they might do like Fine Gael and hold them behind closed doors and, when the conventions are over, issue a statement to the Press saying that everything in the garden was rosy. I think the one reason why we are here after 32 years, stronger than ever, is that we have always held our conventions in the open. They have always been man to man affairs and there has been no hiding and going behind the scenes.

I think the best way to answer a bad argument is to let it go on. We have followed this mysterious £6,500,000 all over the place. I wondered at one stage where it might pop up next. The Opposition speakers seem to forget that when Fianna Fáil took office 12 months ago, there was then a deficit of over £6,000,000 on current account and the Estimates which were prepared by the previous Government sought an increase of over £5,000,000. Were it not for the saving of this £6,500,000, it would still be an additional burden on our people.

The Opposition were critical on the question of agriculture, critical in connection with social welfare and critical in connection with housing and health. If we look at the Estimates, we find, under the heading of agriculture, that something like £25,000,000 will be spent during the coming year. We have a sum of £20,500,000 for social assistance and £4,500,000 for social insurance, a total of almost £25,000,000. It is not a bad figure at all. We have also in the Health Estimates a sum of £8,200,000 to pay the 50 per cent. contribution to the amount of moneys raised by local bodies to meet the health charges and look after the health of the community. That has risen during the past eight years and it is a major contribution to the health of the people of this State.

We have heard a great deal about the cuts in the Estimates, but I have not heard any speaker suggesting that we replace those cuts. The Opposition cannot have it both ways. If they want those cuts replaced, they must be prepared to support increased taxation. I feel that so far as the people in my constituency are concerned, the trend in those Estimates showing a reduction in Government expenditure will be welcomed.

The Government's wheat policy has also been discussed. I am well aware that the Minister for Finance is a man of very great patience. Certainly he required all that patience to sit back during this debate and listen to the Fine Gael Deputies speaking on wheat. If it were necessary or useful to the House, we could rehash all the statements made by Deputy Dillon, and other Fine Gael speakers, down through the years when they were opposed to the growing of wheat. I was only a schoolboy when I heard Dr. Ryan, as Minister for Agriculture, trying to get the people of the Twenty-Six Counties to grow wheat. I remember the task he had in my own county of Wexford to get the farmers of Wexford to grow wheat. Any good supporter then of Fine Gael, or Cumann na nGaedheal, felt it was his duty not to grow wheat, but what has happened to the wheat position now?

Up until two years ago, everything was going fine, but, at that stage, a number of what I would call wheat ranchers entered into this business of growing wheat. We had Deputy Rooney and Deputy Sweetman talking about wheat growing here. It is the wheat ranchers in Deputy Rooney's constituency and Deputy Sweetman's constituency, to a very great extent, and the wheat ranchers in Wexford and other counties, to a lesser extent, who have created the wheat surplus at the present time. It was never intended that we should grow more wheat than was required for home consumption. It was never intended that we should export wheat, even if we could get a market for it. I am quite certain there is no hope of getting a market for our surplus wheat.

Deputy Flanagan, speaking this evening about wheat, referred to a statement made by the Minister for Finance in 1954. He could, of course, have referred to statements made by Deputy Dillon and other members of the Opposition, too. He said that the Minister had stated that 300,000 tons of dried wheat represented two-thirds of our requirements. That statement is perfectly correct. To-day we have 370,000 tons of Irish dried wheat, 70,000 tons more than our requirements.

We have had from Deputy Dillon and Deputy Flanagan the usual boasting about all the increases they have brought about in agricultural production. We had the usual boast about the land reclamation scheme and all the rest of it. We had the boast that there was not an egg-cupful of lime used prior to their coming into office. Deputy Corish, speaking here yesterday evening, referred to the increase in production from seven barrels to 22 barrels per acre of wheat. Deputy Dillon boasted about the greatest quantity of wheat, of barley and of milk being produced in this country, since, as he put it, Adam was a small boy.

I do not think anybody worries about Deputy Dillon's boasting or has any objection to it; it is a rather childish type of occupation. He has taken credit for every good and for every increase in production, but he will not accept responsibility for any of the difficult things or the unpopular things. Deputy Dillon's boasting has done more harm to the interests of the Irish farmer than anything else. It is a fact that Wexford farmers are the soundest and ablest farmers in Ireland, and they will agree with me that at the moment there is less sympathy for the Irish farmer amongst the rest of the community than ever before and that has been brought about by this boasting.

We are told the Irish farmer is now getting 22 barrels of wheat where before he got only seven barrels. It is very hard to follow Deputy Dillon's logic. At one moment he is bewailing any attempt or effort to reduce prices. If the Irish farmer is getting 22 barrels per acre now, whereas he got only seven before, what must the rest of the people think?

Comment on this

Is it a fact that the Irish farmer is getting 22 barrels now as against seven before?

Comment on this

On the statistics, it is not a fact.

Comment on this

If it is a fact, is it any harm to say it?

Comment on this

It has done more harm to the Irish farmer than anything else.

Comment on this

To tell the truth?

Comment on this

The whole thing is codology, because the two years that are taken for comparison purposes are 1947 and 1957. We all know that 1947 was a disastrous year for Irish farming. We had desperate harvest conditions. It was the year the townies went out to try to save the harvest.

Comment on this

They were very welcome.

Comment on this

It was immediately after the war and there were no artificial fertilisers available. It is quite wrong to compare those two years. It is detrimental to the interests of the farmers. It is creating a lack of sympathy and understanding on the part of the rest of the community. Deputy Dillon and Deputy Flanagan must accept a good deal of responsibility for that.

Comment on this

Surely there is nothing wrong in telling the truth. If it is true they are getting a bigger yield now, why not say so?

Comment on this

What about emigration and unemployment? Does the Deputy know anything about those, or does he want to forget them?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

We have heard a good deal about milk and butter in this debate. Deputy Everett told us that we should let the Irish people eat the surplus butter. That might be a good idea, but, if we let them eat the butter, they will have to pay for it. I speak subject to correction now, but I calculate it would cost anything from £10,000,000 to £15,000,000 in extra taxation for the Irish people to eat the butter.

Comment on this

That is a ridiculous figure.

Comment on this

It costs 1/9 per lb. The Deputy can check on that.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. I mentioned the Danes supplying their own people at 1/9 rather than sell the butter in England and I asked why we should not do the same thing here.

Comment on this

Deputy Everett will agree with me that the raw materials to make a lb. of butter cost 3/9: 1/6 a gallon for two and a half gallons of milk. We know quite well what the cost of production of a lb. of butter is. It is produced with the cheapest labour in the country because the agricultural labourer is the cheapest labourer here. Nevertheless, the raw material costs 3/9.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy develop his point about the subsidy? He mentioned a figure of £15,000,000.

Comment on this

We are the second largest butter-eating country in the world.

Comment on this

Thank God.

Comment on this

We are not now.

Comment on this

It is costing £3,000,000 to export the surplus to John Bull and John Bull does not want it. She does not give a damn—he or she, or whatever it is—if we throw it into the Liffey.

Comment on this

There is a trade agreement in existence.

Comment on this

I agree with those who have suggested we should find some alternative method of using our surplus milk. It might be a good idea if we could encourage some of the continental manufacturers to come in here to manufacture cheese. We had hopes recently of having a German firm manufacturing cheese in Wexford, but something has upset their plans unfortunately. If we could encourage some of these continental manufacturers which have an unlimited market in America to come in here and use up this surplus milk, that would, indeed, help to ease the problem considerably.

We had references by Deputy Costello earlier and by Deputy Flanagan to-day to the transatlantic air service. This is still keeping true to the Fine Gael mentality that opposed the setting up of Irish Shipping; that ensured that the short-wave radio station would not go on the air; and that opposed the whole industrial revival in this country.

Comment on this

Did you ever hear of the Shannon scheme?

Comment on this

I was brought up in a very hard school. I succeeded in this House a Deputy who was probably Ireland's leading interrupter and I was brought up in that very same school, so I can proceed on those lines, if Deputies opposite wish it. If there is one thing that an Irishman can be proud of, it is Shannon Airport. This is a small country, but, in having Shannon Airport, it is taking its place amongst the great nations of the world.

Comment on this

What about the Shannon scheme beside it?

Comment on this

We have heard a considerable amount about subsidies. Subsidies were introduced into this country by Fianna Fáil and in the first years of their existence they cost about £15,000,000. They were reduced by Fianna Fáil in 1952 to approximately half of that figure. It is a well-known fact that those subsidies were opposed by many Opposition Deputies in this House, by both Fine Gael and Labour Deputies.

Comment on this

That is not true. On a point of order, Sir, the Deputy has made an allegation which is completely contrary to the facts. I think it should be withdrawn.

Comment on this
Kevin Boland Minister for Defence (Mr. K. Boland) Fianna Fáil

It is a fact.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence was a little boy in short trousers at the time. Now we have this gossoon talking to us.

Comment on this

Subsidies were opposed by Labour and Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Go back to your short trousers.

Comment on this

The Labour Deputies said then that those subsidies were only worth 3/10 weekly to a family of six. They were halved in 1952 and so we can take it that, from 1952 on, they were worth only 1/10.

Comment on this