Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 146–305 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
There was taxation at that time and the argument was that the amount left over was only 3/10.
Comment on this
It is extraordinary how those subsidies have jumped on the Fine Gael and Labour stock market since that time. I believe that had there not been a change in Government and no election this time last year, those subsidies would have disappeared by now. It was the intention of the Opposition to abolish those subsidies. We have Deputy Mulcahy's own words for it when he said: "A good deal of the money is being given out to those who could well afford to do without it. There must definitely be a reduction of the burden of the subsidies on our people".
Comment on this
It is not a matter of the Deputies waiting for it. It is usual to give the reference when giving quotations.
Comment on this
It was Deputy Mulcahy speaking at the Fine Gael Ard Fheis held on February 16th and reported in the Irish Independent, the Fine Gael Pravda, if you like, of February 17th, 1950.
Comment on this
We have heard a good deal here about unemployment. We have been hearing about unemployment since the establishment of the State, but the figures show that there are about 8,000 fewer unemployed now than there were this time last year. I should like to say that I feel, for one, that agriculture will not support a large population. I feel that it will not give sufficient employment to support a large population, especially since the advent of machinery into Irish agriculture. Let it not be taken for one moment that I am opposed to the introduction of machinery into Irish agriculture, but I believe it is a bad thing to subsidise surplus wheat and to allow the wheat rancher to import costly machinery with a short term of life into this country. However, if we are to keep our place in the markets of the world, we must have machinery.
Deputy Corish, in his very able statement last night, referred to the fact that there is now less demand for, and less work in, housing and hospitals. That is true. We are now reaching the stage where the demand for housing and hospitalisation has almost been met. When Fianna Fáil took over in 1932, after ten years of Cumann na nGaedheal Government, they were working on virgin soil as far as industry, housing, agriculture and everything else in this country was concerned. We have heard a great deal about free trade. I can remember plenty of free trade in this country when we were importing everything that the Irish people needed, when our Irish mills were closing down——
Comment on this
Is it in order for the Deputy in this debate to go back to the days of the first Government of this country? If so, it will be in order for other Deputies to go back to those days.
Comment on this
Deputy Browne just mentioned the question of free trade and he is entitled to do so, in so far as Government policy is concerned. In referring to a period with which he is acquainted, he is entitled to do so. The Chair will not allow Deputy Browne to expand on that subject.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, I have referred you to the fact that Deputy Browne, in his contribution to this debate, spent some time referring to the first Government of this country, the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. He referred to the first ten years in office of that Government. I want a ruling from you as to whether that is a relevant matter for discussion in this debate.
Comment on this
If the Chair has allowed Deputy Browne to mention these matters, they must be relevant.
Comment on this
I will resume my seat when I finish. I take it that other Deputies can follow the same line?
Comment on this
This is the first time I have spoken at any length here. I certainly did not come in to annoy Deputy O'Higgins or anybody else, but if he is annoyed, I cannot help it. If the truth annoys Deputy O'Higgins, well and good.
I am not so old but I remember plenty of free trade in this country. I remember the time when everything we ate, everything we wore and everything we used came from abroad. We had bacon from America, bread and flour from Liverpool and machinery from England, Germany, Japan and every other place. That was the position when we first took over. By establishing our industries and affording them the necessary protection, by growing wheat here to supply our own mills to make our own flour and produce our own bread, Fianna Fáil rectified that position.
Deputy Dillon and Deputy Flanagan mentioned something about the Irish millers. I am not getting up to defend the millers, but I want to say this. We have in Enniscorthy town a very important milling industry. It would be a tragedy for that town and the County of Wexford if that milling industry closed down. I will say for that milling firm——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, a few minutes ago Deputy Cunningham was very careful to preserve the privileges of the House. For the past five or ten minutes, he has been reading a newspaper. It is not very complimentary to his colleague who is speaking, nor is it respectful to the House.
Comment on this
There was more to read about finance when the previous Government left office last year. There was very little in the banks at that time.
I was dealing with the milling industry in Enniscorthy town. That firm has spent something like £500,000 on improvements——
Comment on this
The Deputy is now going into detail. He should reserve these details for the Estimate.
Comment on this
I was just pointing out the difficulties that milling industry has to meet and the grave loss it would be to a town like Enniscorthy. We nearly lost it away back in 1930 or 1931 before those people left office.
There has been much discussion about emigration. Deputy Dillon claimed many records for the years 1946 to 1956, but there was one record established during that period which he did not mention. That was the record for emigration. The average net emigration was at a higher figure during that ten-year period than at any other period in the lifetime of the present State. From 1936 to 1946, the average net annual emigration from the Twenty-Six Counties was 18,711. From 1946 to 1951, which included three years of Coalition Government, that figure rose to 24,384 annually. From 1951 to 1956, which included three further years of Coalition Government, the figure rose to 40,079.
Comment on this
That is your record as far as emigration is concerned—the highest figure on record since the establishment of this State and long before it.
I agree there is nothing to boast about with regard to emigration and unemployment figures. Nobody wishes to boast about them. It is about time we stopped trying to make political points in this House about emigration and unemployment. They are very serious problems. It will take the best efforts of every Party and every Deputy to solve those problems. I am sure every Deputy would prefer the situation to be otherwise. Every Deputy would prefer to see employment for every able-bodied man and woman in this country, willing and anxious to work. Every effort will have to be made to try to solve these serious problems.
It is a question of promoting new jobs. As Deputy Corish said last night, the many jobs available from the time Fianna Fáil took over from 1932 on, building houses, hospitals and roads, were of a temporary nature and are now rapidly drying up. It has been stated that there is something like £700,000 less in the coming Estimates for housing. In introducing this Vote on Account, the Minister said that the demand for housing was not the same as it was in the past. That is admitted, but I would say there is a demand in urban areas and provincial towns for a certain amount of housing. Under the existing financial conditions, however, I am afraid we are not able to meet that demand.
It is agreed that the ratepayers and the central authority provide very generous financial assistance for house-building, but that assistance is not sufficient to provide under present conditions houses that can be let sufficiently cheaply for some applicants in our towns. I am sure it would be more appropriate to say this on the Estimate for the Department of Local Government, but I think the time has come for a new approach to that problem. All down the years we have been dealing with houses on old, well-established lines and I think it is time to establish a commission of all Parties interested in housing—trade unions, builders, architects and so on—to see if they can provide a house that can be built for, say, £1,000. I believe it can be done. England has tried it and has, I believe, succeeded in doing it.
During this debate we have been accused of being a "towny" Government. That expression was used already in the past few weeks by a Fine Gael Deputy who I am sure got a considerable number of votes from the towns in his constituency. It is deplorable that any attempt should be made to create a cleavage between the towns and the rural areas. One depends to a very great extent on the prosperity of the other; they are really inter-dependent. Last evening Deputy Corish referred to the small traders in the towns and said their difficulties began just one year ago. As far as the Opposition is concerned, all our difficulties began on the 20th March of last year. It is not a very pleasant thing to face, but we know that the small traders in our towns during the past three or four years have probably been the hardest hit section of the community and are just now beginning to pick up a bit.
The outlook of the Opposition has changed over the past 12 months. Now they tell us everything was rosy when they left office; there were no difficulties and everything was grand. That is their approach to the position to-day. During the debate over the past two days that was their approach, but on this night 12 months ago when Deputy Costello spoke on the formation of the new Government there was a different approach. In a very brief speech then, I think he made seven references to the tremendous difficulties that faced the new Government. It must be admitted that it was those difficulties, and nothing else, that made the previous Government make up their minds to get out. It was those difficulties, many of them of the Government's own creation, that made the people ensure the Coalition Government would not be returned.
We have had many quotations from various newspapers and other documents. There has been a good deal of talk about "promises"; many of these I am sure have been invented during the past 12 months, but I am rather surprised that no member of the Opposition—and they are well served by their information section under the charge of Deputy O'Sullivan —at any stage produced an election address issued to the electorate in Wexford even though we are accused of getting in here on false promises.
Deputy Dillon yesterday challenged Deputy Allen and myself in this House and, honestly enough, I told him that we addressed only three or four meetings during the whole election campaign; it was not necessary to do it in Wexford. I addressed four meetings myself, two in the towns. We put before the people of Wexford the seriousness of the position as it then was, the irresponsibility of the Government at the time and how they had failed the community, and, as a result of telling the people of the difficulties and of what had been done by the previous Government, we got a majority of the seats in Wexford.
Nobody produced the election document issued by the present Minister for Finance, Deputy Dr. Ryan, to the electorate of Wexford during the election campaign, even though the Minister has been attacked here. We were told of his "promises" given on the wireless but Fine Gael speakers made sure they did not mention the promises made by the Leader of the Opposition, in 1954 I think, when he promised guaranteed prices for corn crops for a period of five years. Yet, within one year of that promise, the Party that he led, and still leads, reduced the price of wheat by 12/6 a barrel.
Although the Minister has been attacked because of his "promises" and his failing the farmers, I can say that for the past 40 years the Minister has been elected to Dáil Éireann by the finest group of farmers in Ireland or anywhere on the face of the earth. In his election document there is one paragraph which is typical of the whole document and in conclusion I shall quote it. It says:—
"You have the opportunity on March 5th to end the period of drift and depression, the bungling and confusion which the country has had to endure since June, 1954, and to return a Government that will command confidence, that will set the nation on the road to recovery, to overcome the difficulties besetting the country, a task of great magnitude, but with the support of all sections of our people Fianna Fáil will face the crisis with confidence and determination."
There was no rosy promise there.
Comment on this
I have just one comment to make on the statement of Deputy Browne about the great body of farmers in Wexford. Not so long ago the Minister was down there and what did he say about them? He said their spiritual home was in Fine Gael.
Listening to this debate over last week, yesterday and to-day I am sure one fact struck every Deputy in the House, that as far as Fianna Fáil are concerned, it is new Deputies such as the Minister for Defence, sitting in at the moment, Deputy Browne, who has just sat down, and Deputy Carty of Galway who have been speaking—all the young fellows, while the old, hairy warriors remain silent. We should ask ourselves the reason why.
For many years I have listened to the hairy old warriors on the other side of the House referring to the price of milk, the price of wheat and so on, but they cannot do so to-day; it is the youth that they have sent in here to talk this evening, people who, like the last speaker, will talk about what happened in 1932 and so on. I shall not go back that far. I am not entitled to do so. I shall go back to this day 12 months, when a change of Government took place. When I was crossing the floor of the House on that occasion I felt that, if Fianna Fáil were able to live up to the things that they said they would do, it was no harm to have a change of Government. For the past 12 months I have been watching their progress without any criticism. I would ask the Minister not to shake his head. I give credit where it is due. Without the slightest criticism, I have been watching for the past 12 months from day to day, week to week and month to month to discover what advance would be made in fulfilling the promises made so sincerely to the people and that I expected would operate as from this day 12 months ago. For the few weeks prior to this night 12 months ago, outside every church gate, on every platform, on every poster one read: "Give us an all-over majority; give us a strong Government and let us get cracking. Put your trust in Dev."
It took a strong Government, and a very strong Government, a Government that cared very little about the people who gave them that majority, to do what the present Government have done in the past 12 months. Their first act here was to abolish the food subsidies. The first people that they hit were the poorer sections of the community, the widows and orphans, the old age pensioners, the blind pensioners and people who could not earn their own living. With one wave of their hand, the Government took away £9,000,000. The Minister in reply to a question here indicated that that was the saving effected by the abolition of the subsidies. It saved, he said, £9,000,000 to the taxpayer. It is a nice thing to talk about the taxpayer but the person who is in need deserves consideration before the taxpayer. One of the first acts of the strong Government that took office this day 12 months ago was to deprive the needy, the old age pensioner, the widow and orphan and the poorer sections of the community.
Of course, they would tell you that they gave 1/- to the old age pensioner, that they gave this and that they gave that. The Minister admits that in a full year that will amount to only £2,500,000 but they took away £9,000,000 and therefore gained £6,500,000 at the expense of the poorer sections of the community. The Minister, Dr. Ryan, is laughing but he will not laugh when I am finished.
Comment on this
During the election Fianna Fáil reminded me of the time when I was a young lad, some 45 years ago.
Comment on this
Indeed it is and a good bit more, but I am not as ancient as the Minister. Going around to the fairs in the country there was a fellow selling patent medicines—the "black doctor" they used to call him. He had a pill which would cure anything. For three or four weeks before the last general election Fianna Fáil reminded me of that black doctor. They had a pill that would cure anything. The best pill of all was the pill that the present Minister had. We see the result of that pill—the taking away of £9,000,000 from the poorer sections of the community through the abolition of the food subsidies. The price of bread, the price of flour, the price of every commodity that the poorer sections use, were affected.
Of course, that is the reason that the younger elements appeared in this debate. The old, hairy element that I have referred to did not appear at all. I was amused at Deputy Browne of Wexford speaking while Deputy Allen sat as mute as a mouse beside him. Do you know why? Wheat, wheat, wheat! I am glad that my old friend, Deputy Killilea, is in the House because during the last election in North Galway everywhere he went Deputy Killilea referred to wheat and to "what Jim Dillon did". I tried then to point out to the people, and successfully pointed it out, that the reason the inter-Party Government made that change was that certain individuals were turning out acres of wheat, people who probably would not grow an acre of wheat when the country needed it. It was in order to prevent them from doing so, in order to prevent the taxpayer from subsidising such wheat ranchers, that the inter-Party Government made that change. Would Deputy Killilea listen to that? Not at all. It is the same policy, word for word, that has been advanced by Deputy Browne of Wexford on the other side of the House to-night. How can Fianna Fáil blow hot and cold?
As a representative of the farmers, I believe that the price of wheat should not be depressed. It is all right to ask, "Why should we subsidise it?" but why are we subsidising everything else? Why should we not subsidise wheat when we subsidise other sections of industry? None of the hairy warriors appeared to say a word about it. The young Minister for Defence opened the debate. Young Deputy Browne intervened in the debate. I think he was making his maiden speech. It sounded like it.
Deputy Carty also contributed to the debate. He said he was glad to see in the Book of Estimates an increase for forestry. He is a national teacher and surely he can read. There is a reduction in forestry of £135,000. It is in Vote No. 7, sub-head C (2). Another reason why the old hairy warriors did not speak was the reduction in the price of milk. I am glad to see my friend, Deputy Moloney, in the House and I will tell you why. I happened to be campaigning successfully in a by-election in North Kerry and "successfully" is the word.
Comment on this
The by-election where the former Deputy, Miss O'Connor, was elected for the inter-Party Government—you might remember it—and Fianna Fáil were beaten. I would not say anything hard to Deputy Moloney. We will be good friends, but down in that part of the country, within a week, it was decided there should be an increase in the price of milk. I was going down to Dingle to a meeting and I met this fellow in a car. The front of the car was filled with a set of posters beside him and in the back of the car was another set of posters. I said I would see what this fellow was at. He took one poster from the front of the car and posted it up. It said there would be a mass demonstration and a march to Dublin, a demand for an increase in the price of milk. On the other side of the road he posted up a notice: "Vote Moloney No. 1".
Comment on this
On a point of order, I do not believe any such thing could have happened and as to the march to Dublin, we know who marched to Dublin, Deputy Donnellan's colleagues.
Comment on this
I did not say they did not and they will soon march again. As regards the price of milk, the Minister said it was a cruel thing.
Comment on this
It was cruel about wheat, but it was not cruel about milk. Both the price of wheat and the price of milk have now gone down. There is another reason why the hairy warriors did not speak. I remember sitting over there and Deputy Dillon, the then Minister for Agriculture, being asked questions about the report of the Milk Costings Commission. It was said from a Fianna Fáil platform in North Kerry at that time that the then Minister for Agriculture had the report, but would not submit it.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not in the House at the time; he was only trying to get in. The hairy warriors did not speak at all. They put up the innocent Minister for Defence, the innocent Deputy Browne of Wexford and the innocent Deputy Carty, but the hairy warrior from Galway, Deputy Killilea, did not speak.
I do not see why we should not subsidise the export of butter. Everything else is subsidised except what the farmer produces. Why should butter and wheat not be exported and subsidised, if it is necessary to do so? Is the farming community not as much entitled to consideration as other sections of the community? They have been asked to increase production and when they have done that, the aim is to depress its price. It is a wonder that after 12 months these marvellous people of the Fianna Fáil Party, who could do anything, have not suggested something else that could be done with this extra agricultural produce. Fianna Fáil will go down as the Government that taxed the pig. The British Government in days gone by taxed the dog in this country. They never thought of taxing the pig but Fianna Fáil taxed them to the extent of 5/-.
The Minister for the Gaeltacht gave out a challenge here last night that it was the inter-Party Government who decided to cut by half the grants for the cow byres. I want to know from the Minister the day and date the inter-Party Government came to that decision.
Comment on this
I want to know the day and date they decided to cut that grant and the conditions under which they decided to cut it. I hope the Minister will give me that information.
Comment on this
It is something that I do not believe happened. I want to appeal to the farmers, whether they are milk producers, wheat growers or any other section of the farming community, who are disgruntled by the acts of the Government, not to cut off their noses to spite their faces. I appeal to them above all to work in every way they can in connection with the tuberculosis eradication scheme. It is important to every section of farmers. I appeal to them to cooperate in that scheme, because, if they do not, it will sound the death knell of the one and only industry of this country.
That is why I ask the Minister to give me the day, the date and the conditions under which the inter-Party Government decided the cow byre grant should be cut by half. It is done now, no matter who did it. Owing to the fact that the West of Ireland and the counties Donegal, Galway, Mayo, Sligo and Leitrim have now been declared clearance areas, I appeal to the Minister to restore the grant in full in the poorer areas of this country in order to help the tuberculosis eradication scheme.
The Minister for the Gaeltacht would love to say the hard thing. Since he became Minister, I do not think we have heard much about what he did for the West of Ireland. He has a sort of scheme called Scéim na Muc. That is the right title for it, because it is the five bob tax on the pig. The Government will be known as the Government which put the five bob tax on the pig.
Comment on this
It is Government policy, Sir. The Minister for the Gaeltacht referred to how well off the farmer was; that he was now getting £25 for calves. I was in Castlebar not so long ago and they were not going for that. They are fetching a good price though, thanks to the inter-Party Government. The inter-Party Government played their part in that. Fianna Fáil Deputies should be ashamed to mention the word "calf", because they were known as calf murderers in their time.
Comment on this
I never will be a Blueshirt, take that from me, but whether your shirt is blue, black, white or green, facts are facts and the truth is the truth. If the people on the Fine Gael side of the House and those on the Fianna Fáil side of the House forgot about shirts and about what happened 20 or 30 years ago and tried to look forward to the future, it would be more in the interests of the community and would probably result in greater prosperity for the people as a whole.
There is another matter which worries me as a farmer representative. At the moment, meetings are taking place of representatives from different countries in connection with the Free Trade Area. As far as the farmers are concerned, the representative of agriculture in this country is the Minister for Agriculture, whether he is a member of the Labour Party, Clann na Poblachta, Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil or any other Party. Might I ask the Minister how it is that at any of these meetings in connection with the Free Trade Area the one man responsible for agriculture has not been sent by the Government? The chief thing to be discussed at these meetings is agriculture. I am glad the Minister is here because I hope that the great position we enjoyed under the 1948 Trade Agreement, so far as agriculture is concerned, will never be lost. Speaking as a farmer and as one who was bred, born and reared on the land, I say that was the greatest agreement ever negotiated. It does not matter whether it was negotiated by Deputy Dillon or by the present Minister for Agriculture, or anybody else.
Comment on this
I will tell the Minister why. As the price went up to the British farmer, it went up to the Irish farmer as well.
Comment on this
Another matter I want to speak of concerns our air services. We had changes of Government and there will be changes of Government when we are all dead and in Heaven.
Comment on this
Deputies will come and go and those who occupy the Government Benches to-day will fill the Opposition Benches to-morrow. That is democracy, but one thing must be realised, that is, that for the benefit of the country, there must be a continuation of the work which one Government starts at the expense of the taxpayer. As regards our air services, I think the proposition is a good thing and I would vote for it to-morrow morning. I think it is good work. The one thing we should do is to keep the name of our country before the eyes of the world in every way we possibly can, but let me sound one note of warning. I am proud of Aer Linte, but might I point out to the Minister that the present seems to be a dangerous time to embark upon that undertaking. I shall give my reasons and the Minister will correct me, if I am wrong.
Many of our Irish people coming to Ireland and many leaving the country will book in on the Irish planes. That is only natural to expect, but is there not then a danger that the other air lines, for the lack of passengers, might not operate through Shannon, but bypass it, with dire results for the airport at Shannon?
Comment on this
It might then be too late, Sir. It is no harm to utter the warning. Another thing which the inter-Party Government did before they went out of office was to put certain taxes on luxury goods. I thought that was a good idea. The money was wanted very badly, as it is to-day. I did not agree when the incoming Government took off those taxes. Had they kept them on, would they not help to-day in giving a better subsidy on our butter? Maybe they would have helped the limestone scheme. Possibly they would have helped to subsidise wheat and thus help the wheat growers or to give the employment to our people which is so very badly needed. I was sorry the present Government did it, but they had their own reasons. I believe it was because it affected the big businessman and, at the moment, to Fianna Fáil, the big businessman is a god. They do not care about any other people in the country. Furthermore, Fianna Fáil took off the subsidies on the food for the poorer people.
Comment on this
The taxes on luxury goods. Surely the Minister has been long enough there now to know them all?
Comment on this
Surely the Minister must realise that the farming section of the community have now lost all faith in the Government?
Comment on this
I do not give a hang, because enough of them will always vote for me. Anything I say here is not said for the purpose of gaining a vote. I do not want it; I can always get enough. I want to advise the Minister. I know he does not like the farmers. I know Fianna Fáil never liked the farmers.
Comment on this
Some people here are trying to put me off my line of argument. I will tell you why I say Fianna Fáil do not like the farmers. It is not so long since the Minister for Health was Minister for Finance of this country. What did he say when making a Budget speech? He said: "Taxation rests lightly on the land." You might remember that your predecessor said that.
Comment on this
"That is right", is it? I suppose you will have a go at it yourself? Surely you will not have another go at them after the pig, milk and butter?
Comment on this
I remember that the Tánaiste also made a statement. He said that the agricultural industry is a feather-bedded industry. You know it. You know what it means? It means a soft sleep. The devil of a soft sleep ever a farmer had in this country. Even yesterday, there was a discussion here about farmers having motor cars.
Who said they should not have motor cars?
Comment on this
I do not know who said it. It was said here yesterday. Deputy Costello did not speak at all yesterday.
Comment on this
He said that at the church which he attends the priest has a job to turn his car on account of all the farmers' cars. Who has given the car to the priest but the farmers? Are they not as much entitled to a car as the priest or the doctor or the politician or those with State cars, either? Are they not as much entitled to have them as any of them?
The Minister for Lands was out during the election. According to him, there was no knowing what they would do. Later on, he said it was only the blueprints of the things that would be done, such as the 100,000 extra jobs the Tánaiste would give them and the £100,000,000 for capital investment. However, the Minister for Lands comes on the scene again to defend it. He says that such was not the case.
I have here a copy of an election document. Hundreds of thousands of them were sent all over the country. I will read it to see how far the blueprint goes. The Minister for Lands had this to say:—
"Fianna Fáil Plans the End of Emigration."
Comment on this
It continued:—
"Quick Action Needed to Avert National Disaster."
"Quick action"—that was 12 months ago. The document continues:—
"The full employment proposals recently announced by Fianna Fáil show how the Party intends to deal with the problem of emigration by providing work for all our people at home."
"All our people at home." Note that statement. It continues:—
"The Fianna Fáil plan proposes an increase over five years in the number of new jobs by 100,000. This would result in full employment and the end of abnormal emigration."
"Abnormal emigration." After 12 months, what is the quick action, I should like to know? After 12 months, the position is that over 57,000 of our people have left this country. "Abnormal emigration"—it is at its highest level since the time of the Famine.
Comment on this
As Deputy Kennedy will tell you, in Tuam, whole families have cleared away to England—father, mother, sons and daughters. As Deputy Killilea will tell you, were it not for the textile industry there, for which we have to thank the then Tanaiste, Deputy Norton and his efforts—I am sorry he is not in the House now—only for that little bit of hope, the town of Tuam would be in a very bad way. As Deputy Killilea knows well, Tuam is the capital of North Galway. The town commissioners meet there. The traders meet there. Unfortunately, the people are leaving Tuam by the thousands. Never was unemployment there as bad as it is at the moment.
I see that Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches are laughing. He who laughs last laughs longest. You think you are secure over there now. I would like you to go down before the people and laugh as you are laughing now. You are secure and it is well to be independent. Nevertheless, you must realise that it was on those false promises your Government was formed.
Comment on this
It is not you at all, Sir. Just a few days after that Government was formed over there, under false promises, the Taoiseach called in some master builders, or whatever they were, and work and building were to advance immediately. What is the position now? The Estimate this year is £700,000 less than last year. How will it advance?
We have heard a lot about Fianna Fáil policies for this and that, but I want to ask the Minister what they intend to do to remedy the present position of the country. During the last election we heard a lot of talk about their proposals to "get cracking". Have they stopped "cracking", or when will they start? That is what I want to know.
Last July, from the section of the Department of Finance I was in at one time, the Office of Public Works, there was a statement over the radio that there was to be more money for roads. When I took up the Fianna Fáil Pravda, which I have here with me, I read: “More money for roads”. I read that under the rural improvement schemes grants there was to be a road into everybody's house. But what was it? It was more money for roads, but the men who were to get the roads were to pay the money. Where we, as an inter-Party Government, had a scheme to grant 90 per cent. of the cost of the road to the house, or 95, or even 100 per cent. in some cases, that has been reduced now and the biggest grant they can get is 60 per cent., where we gave 95. More money for roads, but the farmers must pay it. It was not that bunch over there that would pay for it.
Comment on this
I suppose I am. I see that even the limestone grant is cut. Last but not least, I want to say to the Minister that there are farmers who require credit. I know some of the farmers and they are creditworthy people, but if they went to the bank manager the Guards would be sent for or a dog set on them. There will be no progress until something is done, until the stranglehold is taken off and the banks lend money to creditworthy farmers. The rate of interest at the moment makes it out of the question. We generally take a leaf from the English book. Now, in the evening papers—the one I have is the Evening Herald, but I suppose it is in the Evening Press also—I see the bank rate has been reduced by 1 per cent. in England. I hope the Minister to-morrow will have the strength to reduce the rate here by 2 per cent. and go one better than the British.
As we stand at the moment, we have about 90,000 unemployed, and in the past 12 months 57,000 of our people have emigrated; and there is no prospect for them whatsoever. If that is the work of the past 12 months, if that is the work of the "strong" Government, if that is the work of the Government which put the 5/- tax on the pig, if that is the work of the Government that wanted an overall majority and if that is the way they "get cracking", I hope they will soon clear out and let in someone who will do the work.
Comment on this
I should like to approach the problem somewhat differently from Deputy Donnellan. I would just refer to the Vote on Account for a few minutes. In the figures which the Minister for Finance presented to us a few days ago, as I understand them, there is an apparent lower estimate, compared with the figures we got 12 months ago, of £1.7 millions. That is largely accounted for by savings under the head of Industry and Commerce, due to the withdrawal of the food subsidies, £1.9 millions; Transport and Marine, a reduction in the grant to C.I.E. and G.N.R., £1.9 millions; and then a reduction in Local Government amounting to almost £1,000,000.
I take it as a gross saving of £4,500,000, against which we must set off the increase in the Department of Agriculture, £2,500,000, plus some other increases under Aviation, etc., leaving a net difference between this Estimate of the Minister's and the figures presented 12 months ago, of £1.7 millions, as I have just stated. However, that is after the Minister, in introducing his Budget, had raised taxation by an estimated £3,000,000 and had adopted a net saving of £6,000,000 on food subsidies and other savings, which means, in effect, that, 12 months later, we are presented now with almost the same set of Estimates, after the food subsidies have been withdrawn.
I know the Minister's answer will probably be that when he came to examine the Estimates on which he was framing the Budget, he found a deficiency of £6,000,000, and, in order to meet that deficiency and also meet an anticipated increase in expenditure of £3,000,000, he had to find £9,000,000. The fact remains, however, that the only way this Government is able to carry on the services is at the cost of the removal of the food subsidies. That is what it seems to amount to, in a nutshell.
Almost 12 months ago, when introducing his Budget, the Minister—and, I think, quite rightly—attacked the cost of administration. In the four days during which I have been listening to the debate here, that point was not mentioned on one occasion. I listened to discussions on wheat, on milk, on beet and on a lot of matters which had nothing to do with this Vote on Account, but no Deputy, while I was listening, made any reference to what I regard as the key problem, that is, the cost of central and local administration.
Whether we cut the food subsidies or increase the payment to the farmers under the tuberculosis eradication scheme, when the figures are presented to us, we find that the cost of administration remains at the same figure. Twelve months ago, in his introductory speech on the Budget, the Minister said:
"The searching out of wasteful or unnecessary expenditure and its elimination will require keen and continuous attention. But the urgency and difficulty of our budgetary problem this year required that a start should be made at once. I shall mention a number of specific economies which have already been decided upon but which represent merely an instalment of what the Government hope in time to achieve.
It will be no surprise that I should begin with the administrative machine. The present annual cost of the Civil Service, Gardá Síochána and the Defence Forces amounts in round figures to £25,000,000—almost £17,000,000 for the Civil Service, over £3,500,000 for the Garda Síochána and nearly £5,000,000 for the Army."
I have no means at my disposal of knowing what the cost of the Civil Service is, or what the Minister estimates it will be in the coming 12 months. The cost of the Garda Síochána and the Defence Forces combined is now £11,000,000. The Garda Síochána is £4.8 millions, as against the £3,500,000 which, ten months ago, the Minister regarded as too high. The Defence Forces are costing £6.2 millions as against the £5,000,000 which the Minister then regarded as excessive.
It is interesting to refer to the total, compared with the total nine years ago, as represented by the Book of Estimates, to find out some comparative costs of administration nine years ago. It certainly gives very interesting information. The figures show that the cost nine years ago was £73,000,000 for running this unfortunate country and then the combined cost of the Garda Síochána and the Defence Forces amounted to 9.3 per cent. of the total cost. Now, nine years later, it costs 50 per cent. more, at £110,000,000, and the total cost of the Defence Forces and the Garda Síochána amounts to 10 per cent. of the total. The Minister went on to say—and I agree with the Minister in what he was saying:
"There are almost 32,000 civil servants, of whom about half are employed in the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. An annual bill of £17,000,000 for the pay of civil servants is, however, too much for a country of our size and resources."
Further on, he said:—
"I am satisfied that action even on these lines will produce a saving of at least £250,000 in the current year and I am taking that saving into account in framing my Budget.
By the adoption of the most modern methods a reduction in Garda strength has been effected. Every opportunity of further advances in this direction will be availed of consistent with the maintenance of a fully effective force.
The position in regard to the Defence Forces is one which requires special consideration in the light of changing circumstances, but an immediate small economy is possible which, with minor savings elsewhere, should yield £100,000 this year."
Then the Minister goes on to say, quite rightly:—
"It is clear that we have come to a critical stage in our economic affairs. The policies of the past, though successful in some directions, have not so far given us what we want. We are not satisfied with the rate at which living standards are being raised and productive and self-sustaining employment provided."
He went on to say, and this is important:—
"It is to agriculture we must continue to look as the chief source of exports and the mainstay of our economy."
I do not think any Deputy would disagree with that statement. The Minister continued:—
"The raising of agricultural production in volume and in value is, therefore, of vital importance. In broad terms, increased agricultural production depends primarily on the provision on a wider scale of expert technical advice and assistance, on increased use of fertilisers, improved management of grasslands, more intensive production of home-grown feeding stuffs for conversion into export products, the reduction of costs and, not least, better marketing arrangements."
I think every Deputy will agree with the latter part of that sentence. Certainly I was going to welcome the fact that the Minister had made provision almost 12 months ago for £250,000 to improve the marketing of agricultural products, but I do not know what has happened to that money. Possibly some of it has been spent; if it has I do not know anything about it.
With regard to the position of agriculture, again referring to this interesting Book of Estimates, I find that in 1948-49 the Estimate for agriculture —which we all agree is the basis of our economy, on which the future prosperity of the country, and of the people, individually and collectively, and their standard of living depends— including supplementary grants, lands, forestry and fisheries, provided for just over £15,000,000, or 20.5 per cent. of the then Estimates of £75,000,000. In 1958-59 the Estimates provide just over £18,000,000 under the same headings, or a percentage of 16.9 of the total Estimates of £110,000,000. In other words, agriculture, the one fundamental item of our meagre resources, on which we should concentrate as much as possible, has gone down from 20.5 per cent. of the estimated expenditure to 16.9 per cent. in the Estimates for the coming 12 months.
I listened to a number of speakers here and very few of them suggested any constructive method by which the position could be improved. As I said at the outset, I think the Minister must put first things first and the cost of administration must come down. I see no hope of putting our house in order unless the cost of administration can be cut down. I believe the Minister generally started off with that in his mind 12 months ago, but, apart from cutting some of the Estimates, I cannot see where any other apparent saving has been made, or where any effort is made to cut out non-productive expenditure and to channel the money so saved into productive effort.
I understand that the production of wealth means the application of skill, enterprise and capital to material. In our case the material is primarily the land. Unless and until we can save the greater proportion of our national income and devote it to the expansion of agriculture, then our position here will always be as it is at the moment— an under-developed, under-populated country with its people either unemployed or under-employed.
The provision of capital can only come from two sources. One is from our own resources, which means a more stringent standard of living, and the other is to get external capital. The obvious and only way to do that is to induce external capitalists to come into the country. I know that incentives have been given in that regard, and I welcome them, but I do not think that they are enough. I think the Minister will have to give serious consideration to a suggestion already made, both inside this House and outside it, which was to extend the period of the tax-free concession from five years to a longer period. It would be of considerable interest to outside industrialists if that period were at least doubled to ten years.
Some Deputies who have spoken laid the blame on the failure of private enterprise to provide an adequate standard of living, and it has been suggested that the State should take a more active participation in the economy of the country. I think I am correct in stating that this State, which at least gives lip service to private enterprise, takes a greater part in the economy than Socialist or semi-Socialist States, such as Great Britain or Sweden, take.
I do not think you can have it both ways. I know that in the present complex, modern economy, the State has to play a greater part in the economy of the country than it had 25 or more years ago, but I think it is up to the Government, or the people, to decide themselves what sections of the economy should be looked after by the State. The obvious sections are the public utilities, like the railways, Bord na Móna, electricity and so on. But by and large it is, to my mind, to the private side of the economy that we must look to provide the necessary expansion to keep our people employed. While various examples were given, like Bord na Móna, the E.S.B. and the Sugar Beet Company, which are certainly excellent examples, nobody thought of looking to the side of private enterprise industries like Messrs. Guinness, the Sunbeam Wolsey group and other industries which have survived in spite of intense competition both inside and outside the country.
One thing certain is that you cannot have it both ways; you cannot have a sort of semi-Socialist economy. I think you have got to decide which side is going to be Socialist and which you will leave to private enterprise. You have got to leave private enterprise to do its best and, if it fails, then the Government has got the moral duty to step in. To my mind, it is only under private enterprise that the natural gifts of hard work, initiative and enterprise can be encouraged. You must give a man a fair reward especially if he is prepared to risk his capital in a doubtful outcome.
I do not believe there is any ideal system which will ensure prosperity for the country. I know that Deputy Dr. Browne has very fixed ideas on the set-up here, and I agree with a good deal of what he says, but I think that, for quite a few years to come, we must have the political set-up which we have to-day, and it is up to us to make the best we can of it. Deputy Browne referred in rather scathing terms to the whole idea of free trade. It does appear that it is now inevitable and I think our industrialists will have to do a lot of new thinking on the whole question.
A protectionist policy was inaugurated here, especially by the Fianna Fáil Government in 1932. It did give rise to the setting up of a lot of small units spread throughout the country; it did have the advantage of giving local employment in towns and some cities throughout the country. From that point of view, it was a very welcome development, but we are now in the position that, when the European Free Trade Area comes into being, these small units will not be able to compete with the larger and more efficient units in continental countries. If the Free Trade Area comes into operation, there must be some consolidation between these small units, if they are to survive in the concept of free trade.
Many Deputies have blamed one side or the other of the House, according to which side the member speaking happened to represent. I am only a new Deputy, but I cannot help thinking that a lot of the difficulties can be laid at the door of politics. I do not mean the science of government, but I do mean dishonest politics. I have listened to Deputies for two days this week, and two days last week, blaming one side or another. If they just changed sides, I have a feeling those Deputies would make the same speeches. I think it was Deputy Dr. Browne who said we should change these things now and base our politics on economics and social welfare affairs. I hope the day when that will happen is not too far away.
Comment on this
If I can have a minute, I will finish. I should like to say that the root cause of our difficulties is that our national income is too small. We are trying to take too great a slice out of one small cake. That is the difficulty which besets us and which has done so for years. That difficulty will be there until the cake is made bigger, so that every class of the community, particularly the under-privileged, may be given a fairer share.
Comment on this
There is just one point raised by the previous speaker of which I did not previously take note. He spoke of the personnel in mentioning the Civil Service, the Army and the Gardaí. I think the Deputy is making a wrong comparison. He is taking the total Defence Vote as if it were solely for personnel. That comparison is not right. As regards these savings that I promised to make I think I will be able to say in the Budget speech, when it comes along, that I did succeed in keeping the promise I made on that occasion in regard to savings.
The first point I want to refer to is that a number of speakers found it hard to understand how this £6,500,000 had disappeared. We said last year that we were saving between the two years, part of it last year and the remainder of it this year, £9,000,000 on food subsidies. Against that we had to provide £2,500,000 for social welfare for certain classes. That would be £6,500,000 when that sum is deducted from the £9,000,000. The mistake made by Deputies was to compare the Estimates now with the amended Estimates of last year. They should have compared them with the Estimates issued at the beginning of last year before the Budget came along. That first issue contained the food subsidies; the second one did not. On that basis the amount provided for non-capital expenditure in 1957-58 was £102,166,000 and for this year, in the Estimates for the coming year, £98,261,000, which is a difference of £3.9 million. We have then out of the £6,500,000 actually in the Estimates come down by £3.9 million and that means there will be £2.6 million left to be accounted for, if you like, under that particular figure.
In these Estimates this year butter subsidy is accounting for £1.1 million, wheat subsidy for £.8 million and bacon subsidy for £.58 million. That means £2.48 million and that accounts for the difference of £2,500,000 I have already referred to, so that the food subsidies that we got rid of last year, less the amount proposed for social welfare, have been divided in this way so that there has been a saving in the Estimates this year of almost £4,000,000 and there is an expenditure of almost £2,500,000 this year on agricultural subsidies.
Some of the Deputies speaking about this—I did not take down names, I just took down the points—talked about the way that money had been frittered away. I do not think any Deputy, if he understands the position, will say that the money we have proposed to spend in addition this year on agricultural food subsidies is money that is frittered away. Another point raised by Deputy Corish, and I think by other Deputies, was that it would appear from the figures published so far that we have a very satisfactory revenue position this year. This sheet, dated the 18th March, does show on the face of it practically £4,500,000 more revenue over last year. I must bring Deputies back to the original figure for the year 1956-57. The actual receipt of revenue in that year was £117.6 million and there was a shortage of practically £5,000,000. That meant in that particular Budget, in the year before we came into office, the revenue failed to reach expenditure by £5,000,000, and we had to make up that £5,000,000 somewhere or other. In these Estimates, published on the 18th March, it does show revenue higher by £4.6 million than last year. That £5,000,000 I already spoke of has to be caught up on.
There is another point which must be kept in mind and that is that the expenditure side for the month of March has not been completed. There was a very big Estimate which came before the Dáil last week of about £3,000,000 for agricultural subsidies and food exports. The greater part of that has not gone into expenditure yet but it has to go in before the 31st March. It will make a tremendous difference. My point is that we will not know until the 31st March what total the expenditure and revenue is as compared to last year and, for fear Deputies might lose any money foolishly, I would say to them do not bet on a surplus.
Deputy Blowick attached us for cutting the expenditure and said it was done at the expense of the rural people. That, of course, is very easy to say and it is an especially convenient sort of point for Deputy Blowick to make if he is appealing to the rural people down in Mayo, because the people down there are evidently not very keen on finding out the truth. The fact is that there was a total decrease shown in the volume here of £5,500,000. But of that total decrease Industry and Commerce and Transport accounted for £3,500,000 and that leaves a decrease, therefore, of £2,000,000. If one analyses that further, one finds that it is not at the expense of the rural population.
Talking about the rural population, one would naturally go to the Vote for the Department of Agriculture, and the Vote for the Department of Agriculture shows an increase of £2,500,000 for this year. Therefore, Deputy Blowick's point is quite wrong, but I suppose Deputy Blowick is quite satisfied that he made a good point and, whether it is right or wrong does not matter to Deputy Blowick.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy listen to me? I shall correct many of the statements made on the Opposition Benches. Deputies on the Opposition Benches should be as interested in the truth as we are; they should listen. Deputy Blowick accused me or the Government—I do not know which— of thinking the farmers were doing a disservice to the country by producing too much wheat, butter and bacon. We never made any such statement. One Deputy on the Opposition Benches asked: Do we want the farmers to produce more butter? Of course we do. Why should we have any hesitation in answering that question. We want them to produce more bacon also. That is an easy question to answer. But the question of dealing with surpluses, when they arise, is not nearly so easy as one would gather from the speeches made by Fine Gael Deputies in this debate.
We have said from the beginning that we want more production. Deputies on the Opposition Benches have tried to make a joke of that. We want more production because, if we have more production, there will be a higher national income. If there is a higher national income somebody, and in all probability everybody, will be better off. There is no doubt about it; a number of people will be better off if there is higher production. If there is higher production there will be a better yield from taxation and more for those classes which are now being taken under the wing of Fine Gael, since they went over there, such as the social welfare classes and all the others. There will be more for health, education and so forth. But that can be achieved only by having a higher national income and a better yield from taxation all round.
We are accused of cutting the farmer in his export subsidies. I suppose we must give Fine Gael credit for wanting to do the best they can and helping us as best they can. But let us look at the matter from a proper point of view. There is no cutting. If you like, we are not following 100 per cent. the increased exports that we think will take place during the coming year. Because of the trend in exports in the last few years, we have made an estimate and we think that exports will be higher still in the coming year. We say to the farmers that we cannot follow 100 per cent. but we will do the best we can to help them out. We are not cutting them. We are giving them more than they got last year and very much more than they got the year before.
If one goes back before 1956-57 one finds they got nothing at all for the export of butter and nothing for the export of bacon. We are comparing our figures with the two preceding years; we are giving a lot more than last year and considerably more than that given in the year before. Creamery butter last realised £2,000,000 more than the year before. In the output of bacon and pigs there was a realisation of £2.2 millions more than the year before. In the case of cattle, —this is only relevant in a certain degree, but I am giving the figure now —the increase was £6.8 millions.
We are told that we are giving subsidies to everybody else and taking something away from the farmers. What are we giving to everybody else? Fine Gael speakers did not tell us what we are giving. They talked in a general way: "You are giving something to everybody and taking something from the farmer." We are not. We are going to give them more in the coming year than they ever got before but, as I say, we came to the conclusion that we would not be able to follow 100 per cent. the subsidies on the exports of milk, bacon, meat, and everything else and we came to the conclusion that we would have to make some cut in the subsidies paid on these particular items.
In relation to the £22,000,000 received by the farmers for butter last year, we tell them that if their output of butter is what we estimate it will be in the coming year, and that is roughly what it was last year, we, on behalf of the taxpayer, will contribute £1.4 millions and ask them to contribute £7 millions themselves. We have divided the £2.2 millions subsidy increase in that way. We are basing that on the assumption that the output of butter will be the same in the coming year as it was last year. If it goes up, we shall pay more. If it goes down, we shall pay less.
We have worked in the same way in relation to pigs. The output of pigs went up by £2.3 millions. We say to the farmers that, if they do the same again in the coming year, we shall give them £2.1 millions and ask them to contribute about £200,000. That is the division there.
I shall deal with wheat separately because there is a different system. Mention was made of the fact that the farmer got a very much better price for his calf this year than he did a few years ago. The increase in the value of cattle last year was £6.8 millions so it cannot be said, as some Deputies on the opposite side contend, that the farmers are being cruelly hit in this and that they cannot afford it.
It has been said that the farmers are impoverished and that we have dealt them this blow when they are not able to take it. It is a question of dividing the burden between the producer, the consumer and the taxpayer. We shall leave the consumer as he is. He will pay the same for his butter and his bacon as he paid last year. He is not concerned in the deal we are trying to make as between the farmer and the taxpayer. We are trying to make the fairest deal we can between the producer of butter and bacon and the taxpayer. The farmers were almost £10,000,000 or £11,000,000 better off last year and the question is whether we should tax the taxpayer this year to the tune of £3.5 millions or £2.5 millions. We have decided the figure will be £2.5 millions. If we decided to pay the full subsidy in the coming year the figure would be £3.5 millions. I appeal to Deputies to look at this matter in a fair way. A Government has to try to live up to its obligations to the taxpayer, as well as to the consumer. We have decided that, in that particular case, where the increase in income was between £10,000,000 and £11,000,000 last year, to say to the farmer: "We ask the taxpayer to give you £2,500,000 this year, instead of £3,500,000." We think that is right and we think that the taxpayer has a right to some consideration in this matter.
Deputies seem to think that the farmers are a lot of fools; they seem to think that the farmers can forget what was done in the past. They think they are going to take the farmers' vote away from us. I told one Deputy here this evening that the farmers always vote for us and that is the truth—the farmers vote for us in any case. Why would they not? Take the case of milk for a start. In the past 12 years, the gallon of milk has gone up from 10½d. to 1/6. That is an increase of 7½d. Fianna Fáil put it up by 6½d. and Fine Gael, or the Coalition, put it up by 1d. Is the farmer going to forget that and listen to the tales of Deputy Blowick and the others who try to persuade them that they, and not Fianna Fáil, are their friends? The farmers know that we are their friends. They are not going to forget that the only increase they got for milk in the past 12 years was given to them by Fianna Fáil and that the Coalition did little or nothing for them.
Take the price of wheat—the price of wheat 12 years ago was 55/- a barrel. It is 72/6 a barrel now.
Comment on this
We will talk about the coming year later. During those 12 years, Fianna Fáil put the price of wheat up by 27/6 a barrel and the Coalition put it down by 10/- a barrel. Do Deputies opposite imagine that the wheat-growing farmers, in those circumstances, think that Fine Gael are their friends? I have been speaking to wheat farmers since this matter was talked of. I did not expect them to like it and they told me they did not like it, but that they would have to put up with it. They said that the worst of the matter was that they had no alternative to us, that they would have to vote for us because they were not going to vote for the Coalition. You might as well be idle as looking for their votes. They will never vote for you again.
Comment on this
You will get the chance all right. Deputy Everett said that we ought to give the cheaper butter to our own people and I heard a Fine Gael Deputy say "Hear, hear!" to that. Suppose we gave the 700,000 cwt. of butter to our own people at the same price as that at which we export it, it would be only fair to assume that the producer would get the same price as he is getting now. That would mean that if we gave the 700,000 cwt. to our own people, as well as the 200,000 cwt. which we export, it would cost us £9,000,000 instead of the £1,500,000 it is costing us this year. Where are we going to get that money? That is foolish talk from people who do not understand these things.
Comment on this
We never contemplated, although Fine Gael did contemplate lately, the growing of wheat for export. It was only Fine Gael thought of that. We started out, when we were in opposition here in 1928 or 1929, to show that wheat could be grown in this country and we were told that it could not be grown. We were told that if we sowed it, it would not come up; if it did come up, it would be choked by thistles and weeds; that if we did reap it, we could not mill it; if we milled it, we could not bake it; and if we baked it, we could not eat it. These are the people who are now talking to us about growing wheat for export in competition with the great wheat-growing nations of the world.
We knew we could never compete against the great wheat-growing nations of the world, but, in 1932, we set the present wheat policy going. Before that, the present Taoiseach, the present Tánaiste and I were on a committee set up by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government to investigate the question of wheat-growing. We signed a minority report, hoping that we would get the others to come over to us, stating that we should aim at growing one-half our own requirements, but they would not have that. When we came into office, we said we would grow as much wheat as we could grow towards our own requirements, and when the war came we were glad to have it. After the war, we again stated our policy that we were aiming at 300,000 tons of wheat per year, but we never at any time said that we ought to export wheat. I think it would be a bad thing to attempt to export wheat from this country, considering the competition we would have to face.
We are in trouble now and we have to do something about it. The Deputies over there have got a hold of the Nenagh Guardian and they are passing it about from one to the other quoting what some farmers said at a Fianna Fáil convention. There are no closed doors in our organisation. We expect to meet criticism when we go to our supporters. When I go down the country, I do not want them to put their hands to their hats and say: “Your are doing a good job.” They may say that we are not doing as good as we might do, but they generally end up by saying that we are doing a better job than anybody else.
Comment on this
They always end up by saying: "You are doing better than the other fellows, anyway." The Minister for Agriculture met various farmers' organisations and they adopted an agreed scheme on which they called the married price. At the same time, he discussed the barley price with them, but he did not take their full advice in regard to barley. They got 1/- less than they asked for. Farmers, in fixing prices for barley, are only fixing what one group of farmers must pay another group, if they want it. When a price is fixed, it means that the Minister must pay that price for the barley, if it is offered to him. A Minister has a perfect right to make up his own mind with regard to price, after hearing the advice given to him by the various organisations. The Minister for Agriculture got agreement on the wheat price and a difference of 1/- on the barley price. It is hardly fair to expect that he should lose the confidence of the farmers' organisations on that account.
Comment on this
I was going there anyway and I am saying it again now, in any case. Listening to Fine Gael speakers here, you would think that an enormous wrong had been done to the wheat growers. You would think that Deputy Dillon did not belong to that Party. When he was speaking here he told the House of the condition of agriculture at present. Every other class was getting something, but the farmers were being cut. When he came along in 1955 and took 12/6 off the barrel of wheat—when there was no problem about export—I said it was a cruel and unjust act, and I still believe it was.
Does the Deputy want to say now that other classes did not benefit? Does he admit that a year before that they were promising better times for everybody? In 1955 they claimed they would give better times to everybody, but they took 12/6 off the barrel of wheat. Deputy Dillon comes along and sheds the proverbial crocodile tears about the farmers at present. It is a good act. The Deputy's action represented a cut of £1,500,000. All the things we are doing at present would not amount to that. With one stroke of the pen, Deputy Dillon took £1,500,000 from the farmers. We had to have all sorts of meetings with farming organisations and amongst ourselves. Yet all the cuts put together would not amount to the £1,500,000 Deputy Dillon took with one blow. Yet he sheds crocodile tears. It is seldom I can pay a compliment to him, but I have often said he is the best actor in the House.
Comment on this
Last year, £670,000 was spent on the ground limestone scheme. A sum of £495,000 was recovered from Marshall Aid Funds, so that the actual amount spent from the Exchequer was £175,000. This year the amount from the Exchequer was £448,000, which means we are providing £273,000 more than last year for ground limestone.
Comment on this
The Minister need not tell us what he is going to do in the Budget about amending the duty on live theatre shows.
Comment on this
During this debate, the Opposition devoted about half their time to an explanation of why they did not win the last election. They quoted from every paper they could lay hands on; they took extracts out of their context, twisted them and used them against us. They did all that to prove they were unfairly beaten. Why are they not sports? When they are beaten why do they not say: "We were beaten by better men"? They would feel much better. They are crying their eyes out now. Give it up—it is very bad.
Comment on this
They even attacked us for things they did themselves. Deputy Costello made a fairly strong attack on us for exporting butter at this low price. He might have said they did the same themselves, but he did not. He put the blame on us for the whole thing. They attacked us in particular for making false promises. That is the funniest of all. When they came into office the last time, their Minister for Finance announced officially over the radio that they would bring down taxation by £10,000,000. We know what happened about that. They were going to bring food prices back to pre-1952 level. They were going to cut out unemployment, stop emigration and speed-up housing. The fellow who wrote this got so tired that he just said at the end, "Better times for everybody." These are the men who talk to us about promises.
Comment on this
Let us take the promised reduction in expenditure. They put it up, instead of bringing it down. We brought it down. They said they would abolish unemployment. Unemployment had reached a phenomenally high figure when they were going out of office. At least, we brought it down by 10,000.
Deputy Dillon always compares 1957 with 1947. It shows the unfairness of his mind when he takes a year like 1947 when half the countries in Europe were rationed. He talks about low production here and winds up with 1957, as much as to say: "I did all that." Why not take 1954 when we went out the last time and compare that? It would be a much fairer comparison.
There was a lot of talk about employment figures. It arose because two sets of figures were quoted. One was in respect of industrial employment in the manufacture of transportable goods and the other in respect of employment in industry generally. Let us take the figure in regard to transportable goods first, because it is more favourable to us.
Comment on this
You were going to tell us why you did not appoint Deputy Smith as Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
He will remain where he is. People like you will not get him out.
In the second quarter of 1954, when we went out of office, the number employed in the manufacture of transportable goods was 154,417. When we came in again, in the first quarter of 1957, it was 146,581. It had gone down by 8,000. Why compare 1947 and 1957? Is it to give Deputy Dillon a chance of comparing a war year with a peacetime year? Why not take the year we left office and the year they left office? Since that time, the figure has gone up by 5,000. We were below at the same time last year, until the last quarter when we had 151,000 people employed, which is the best since June, 1956. I am saying that figure is very good; we shall take other figures also.
The year 1954 was the first for many years that agricultural employment remained constant. It was 455,000— the same as in 1953. In 1956, it was 440,000, down by 15,000, and in 1957 it went down to 430,000. There is not very much change in the trend there, I am sorry to say, but I hope it will improve. In industry and in agriculture, bringing in everything, the number employed in 1954 was 296,000; 289,000 in 1956 and 275,000 in 1957. These are much more comparable years—1954 with 1957—than 1947 with 1957.
When Fine Gael are making excuses about what happened they always talk about making the balance of payments right, but why did they make it wrong to start with? In 1951 when we came into office it was £61.6 millions; in 1952 it was £8.9 millions, after a good Budget, but that Budget did not make half the upset that the levies on imports imposed by the Coalition caused. In 1953 it was £7,000,000; in 1954, £5.5 million; in 1955 it went up to £35,000,000 with the Coalition and then to £14.4 millions. Then the import levies came along and now they are blaming the closing of the Suez Canal for all the hardships created.
Why did they do these things? No country had the same troubles so far as we know——
Comment on this
No other country put on all these import levies and put people out of employment as the Coalition did——
Comment on this
The British Government said when the Suez Canal affair was over that it made very little difference to their economy. The Opposition talks about the cost of living. In February, 1954, when we left office, the cost of living was 124; in February, 1957 when they left office it was 135, up 11 points. One would think there was no increase in the cost of living when they were in.
Comment on this
It is 142 now, up 7 points. It was up 11 when you were there. Some Deputy asked me about school buildings. Actually the Estimate provided £1.55 million. We spent £1.2 million principally due to the fact that an order was given to the Board of Works in the last half of 1956 to stop school building. Consequently, preparations were stopped and the money could not be spent. We spent £300,000 less than was provided last year, but the Board of Works now say their plans are going on and that they will be able to spend £1.4 million in the coming year.
Somebody was rather sarcastic because a Minister talked about private enterprise. We believe in private enterprise; we are not tied to it. We believe in it as far as possible and I think the same applies to nearly every Party here. I am not sure if the Labour Party will agree but we may take it that they do to a certain extent. It is not an obsession with us. We have got certain things done by State enterprise but I think we would prefer to get them done by private enterprise if possible, but if it is not possible the State will have to intervene. It is possible that some State companies may come again as time goes on.
The State, however, must help private enterprise in many ways. The first thing the State does is to give protection to our producers, whether agricultural or industrial. I should like Deputies to realise that whether the production is agricultural or industrial, the protection on the home market applies in the same way all round. We try, and I think we succeed, in keeping, let us say, foreign butter, potatoes, eggs, cheese and so on from coming in. The same applies to foreign vegetables and fruits, so far as these are produced here. We do protect the market for the agricultural or industrial producer here if he is producing goods for sale at home.
The State goes further than that. It helps private enterprise by grants in various ways. There are grants provided in the Estimates of £650,000 for industrial enterprises, for new industries starting wherever they may start, whether in the special areas or not.
Comment on this
We provide something like £5,500,000 for the relief of agricultural rates, on the other hand, and we give very large grants—over £2,000,000 worth, I think—for land drainage, fertilisers, lime and farm buildings. The grants are very big so that as far as private enterprise is concerned a fair amount of money is provided in this year's Estimates just as in any other year.
Last year also we introduced encouragements for exports; we gave remission of income-tax on the profits on exports of manufactured goods. That will be provided again this year. Some Deputy asked whether the term would be reviewed, but that is a matter more for Budget time than for the present debate.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been told about that; I do not see why I should repeat it although I saw it myself if the Deputy wants to know.
Comment on this
This policy of grants should lead to increased production on a stable and permanent basis and, as I have mentioned already, if we get increased production — which some Deputies think we are overstressing but which I think is essential—it means we shall have an increased national income on which we can base our taxation and get a better yield in taxation. It will also increase employment and give permanent employment; that is what we should keep in mind. I know no other way in which permanent employment can be provided. As I said on the Budget last year, our aim is to raise the standard of living all round by increased production. We should not look unfavourably, I would say, on a high level of imports and exports so long as the two go up pari passu, because the higher they are the better, as it means a higher standard of living.
Comment on this
It is a pity the Minister did not teach it to the Minister for External Affairs when he was talking about the damned ships.
Comment on this
Give me a chance to finish. As long as the level of imports and exports goes up, it means a better standard of living, but it means that we must have the exports to pay for the imports. That is why it is so necessary to encourage exports of agriculture, as well as exports of industry. Fine Gael may make the other point, and let them make it, if they like, but, in my opinion, there is no reason why producers of butter, for example, could not increase their exports if there is a small reduction in the amount going to them on a large increase of production. In other words, as I said already, their income for butter last year was £22,500,000. All we are asking them to pay is £700,000. Surely, £700,000 on £22,500,000 should not discourage exports of butter. The same applies to the other things that we are dealing with.
As I said in my Budget statement also, we recognise that it is a very slow job to absorb the unemployed by building industries, building up our exports, and so on, and in the meantime something must be done, and we did provide money. We provided a fair amount of money for housing. It was not all taken up. Those who are on public boards know the position better than I do. The money was there and it was not taken up. The Estimate is given for the coming year. It is an Estimate of what may be spent, but I can tell the Dáil now that if more money is needed for housing, it will be made available. That is only the estimate, but more money will be given, if it is needed.
Comment on this
On roads, we did what we could. My predecessor found himself in hard straits. I have sympathy with him in that because I feel like that myself sometimes. He had to take £500,000 out of the Road Fund, but we put £900,000 back into it last year. The result was a good deal more money available for spending. Whether it was all spent or not, I do not know, but I presume it was.
As I have already explained about schools, we have given as much as the technical staff of the Board of Works say they can spend on schools in the coming year and if that amount can be increased, if they can take more, let us say, they will get it.
I am asking the Dáil to vote £36,500,000 on account for the coming year. In nearly every speech here, the criticism was that we were taking something out; in other words, that we were not spending enough. I do not think any Deputy made a point that we should cut something out of the Estimate. It was all "put in more", "Why do you not spend more?" That was the gist of every speech made, that the provision under certain heads was inadequate. I did not take notes, but I am quite sure that, if I had taken notes of all the speeches made by the Opposition, where they found fault with this being too low and that being too low and so on, and added them up, we would have a bill for expenditure of £4,000,000 or £5,000,000, or perhaps £6,000,000 or £7,000,000 more for the coming year.
As far as Fine Gael are concerned, their case is that we should spend £4,000,000 or £6,000,000 more. That was the sum total of the speeches they made. There was no suggestion, as far as I know, of any reduction in expenditure—none at all. It was all "spend more." In spite of this, I hear people down the country and I read the papers, and I know that everybody is saying, that taxes are too high. I am quite sure that the Fine Gael Deputies, when they go down the country and meet people who say that, agree that taxation is too high. How can we keep down taxation if they are pressing for another £5,000,000 or £6,000,000 to be spent in the coming year? That is the pressure from them at the present time.
I do not know whether Fine Gael are going to vote against this or not. Perhaps I have convinced them that they should not. If they are, there is no doubt about it that what they are voting for is the expenditure of more money. That is what they are voting for and I want to make that point. I want that recorded because it may be useful later on.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?