We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–145 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958
Defeated

No. 25 of 1958 ›

As I was saying when the House adjourned last night, no Deputy has so far in this debate made any serious effort to refute the well-established fact that stable government is essential to progress in any country and no Deputy has attempted to refute the fact that stable government is invariably the outcome of an election under the straight vote system. It is in an attempt to obscure these facts that the Opposition have dragged all sorts of red herrings into the debate. A case had to be made by the Opposition that Fianna Fáil were proposing this change for a mere Party manoeuvre. That could not be properly contested unless they could malign the commission which will be responsible for the setting up of the constituencies.

In order to do that, it meant that they even had to impeach the members of the bench also, in an attempt to prove in the most abstract manner that Fianna Fáil were activated merely by Party motives in bringing in this measure. None of them believed that. Each Deputy is looking at it from his personal point of view or the view of his Party. It is a well-known fact on the other side of the House that the vast majority of the people want stable government and if the people in the last election voted for one thing more than another, it was for stable government after their experience of the previous few years. The Opposition know that the people are already well aware that by voting in favour of the referendum, they are voting for the elimination of frequently recurring elections.

Deputy Blowick referred to the cost of the referendum but he did not mention the number of elections that were necessarily held in the past 30 years.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

He refused to refer to the number of times the people have had to bear a cost of £80,000 in their quest for stability. Deputy Norton tried to prove that we had stability under P.R. and he referred to the few changes we had in government, but he was careful not to mention the number of elections we had to secure that stability. If we had few changes, it was because of special circumstances, in the absence of which the position could have been very different. The special circumstances were that we had the Fianna Fáil Party with a strong programme, determined not to "truck" with any other Party but determined to secure stability, even though it meant referring to the country fairly frequently.

The people do not want frequent elections and no doubt they will seize this opportunity to ensure, as they can do now, that elections will not take place except when normally due. Nobody, even among those who have tried to make the case, believes that anybody will be disfranchised. The people will decide what Government they want. They will exercise their vote to the best of their ability and to say that various minorities will be deprived of representation is absolute nonsense. As is well known, the P.R. system creates minorities unnecessarily and it is not a question of minorities seeking representation. I come from a constituency where the Protestant minority cannot secure representation directly here as such. It is a three-seat constituency and under P.R. about 3,000 people who come out and vote for whatever member on the panel they think suitable are not directly represented; but they do not abstain and I have great pleasure in saying that I have the confidence of the greater part of the majority. I am not ashamed to say I have always been prepared to do what I could for them in the little matters that affect their everyday lives. They are good citizens and make a full contribution to the economy of the State. They will not be affected by the single-seat constituency.

The people do not expect every little pocket representing every "sorehead" section of the community to send somebody here and the people who would suggest that this House should be representative of every little section or pressure group would turn this House into a mere talking shop, with no possibility of making any progress, no possibility of enacting any defined programme put before the electorate at election time. That is what the Deputies opposite advocate.

If there is one thing more than another that the straight voting system provides, it is that any Party coming before the people at election time must have a programme and a policy in which the people will have confidence. If a Party fulfils that requirement it is very likely to obtain the necessary support, but if it does not live up to its promises and to the programme offered to the people before getting their support, it will not be returned on the next occasion. That is amply demonstrated in any country where direct voting operates. Therefore, people who say that by this enactment Fianna Fáil will continue the life of the Party as a Government Party in perpetuity are paying Fianna Fáil a definite tribute in that they assert that Fianna Fáil is the only Party likely to retain the confidence of the electorate.

One cannot continue discussing points that have been made repeatedly in the past few weeks. Everything that could possibly be said by the Opposition, using the Dáil as a platform from which to try to drag the minds of the people away from the actual purpose of the referendum, has been said. No Opposition can convince the people that you will not have stability under the direct system, and unless they can convince the people that stability is unnecessary for progress, their entire case falls to the ground.

They fall back on the old argument that Fianna Fáil are trying to gerrymander the constituencies. That is impossible. Take any constituency, in the Twenty-Six Counties and consider how many times it has changed. I know constituencies which at one time sent three or four Fine Gael or Cumann na nGaedheal representatives to this House, but that position is reversed to-day. They may have changed several times in the past few years. How can anybody select a pocket or area and say: "I know the people in that area will remain loyal to such-and-such a Party for all time"? I do not think anybody or any commission, even if they wished to do it, would be capable of doing it. I am prepared to let a commission appointed entirely by the Opposition go into West Donegal to-morrow and carve it up to suit any particular Party. The position can change in 12 months' time.

I believe there is more rightcousness on the side of the Government in respect of this measure than any other measure that has come before the House. It is a simple matter for the Opposition members to get up and make threats about people being deprived of representation, but they are losing sight of the fact that it is the people who will decide, as decide they will. When they go before the people and tell them this is tantamount to setting up a dictatorship simply because a Government will be sufficiently strong to remain in office for five years it will be a very poor argument to the people as a whole who are disgusted with elections taking place before the lapse of the normal period.

I do not see what case can be made by those people who make taunts about the loyalty of Fianna Fáil to the leadership of the Party. I do not think the members of a Party in this House have any other ambition than to see that their Party is well disciplined, well organised and can act as a body. They have their Party meetings and discuss their proposed legislation. They can discuss their future plans and come to the Dáil with one voice. It is certainly new tactics on the part of the Opposition when that is held up as an example of dictatorship.

At one time, it was the practice to sneer at this side of the House and say there was a split in the Party. Now the great crime is that there is too much loyalty. Members are all voting the same way. We are not the only members showing loyalty. I remember on one occasion when we were discussing, I think, the City and County Management (Amendment) Bill the Labour Party put down an amendment which Fianna Fáil saw fit to support, and they withdrew the amendment rather than support Fianna Fáil and defeat the Coalition Government at the time. These things are not unusual in the House. A Party is not worth its salt if it cannot have loyalty and discipline. It will never be successful as a Party, unless it can act in accordance with proper leadership. If you think you can get the country to believe that is dictatorship, you are reckoning on very low intelligence on the part of the electorate.

I do not propose to hold the House repeating things that have been said so often in the past few weeks. However, I want to say something I will not be ashamed to read if I live for generations to come. I believe we are doing right by posterity. I never supported anything in this House in which I believed more sincerely. I do not think the Deputies who have opposed it, just as they have opposed the various reforms which Fianna Fáil have brought about in their time, will be prepared in years to come to have their names associated with the opposition they are now putting up to this measure which will do something which I believe is necessary, that is, ensure stability of government in the generations to come.

We talk about bringing in the unfree portion of the country. The unfree portion of the country does not want to come into a Parliament where elections and instability are the order of the day, where economic progress is inhibited by the fact that a strong stable Government is seldom elected under the system the Opposition are upholding. For that reason, I merely intervene in the debate to say what I think is honest and sincere, that generations to come will vindicate the action we have taken in giving the people the opportunity to vote in this referendum to give to themselves a system that will stand the test of time and ensure a Government by majority, not by pressure groups or minorities.

Comment on this

We may accept that the views Deputy Brennan has expressed are sincerely held, and that prompts one to consider what has been happening to people like Deputy Brennan who now in the month of December, 1958, find themselves making a speech in this House which this night 12 months ago they never thought they would be making. Is it not extraordinary that a decent man like Deputy Brennan can express here with obvious feeling opposition to a system which sent him into Dáil Eireann?

Comment on this

No system could keep me out.

Comment on this

Is it not extraordinary that this is the first time Deputy Brennan ever criticised P.R.? In the last election I have no doubt Deputy Brennan when seeking his seat in Dáil Éireann had due regard to the fact that there were 3,000 Protestants in his constituency and he did not say to them, nor did any other Deputy in that Party over there say: "Vote for us; elect us as a Government and we will introduce a Bill designed to end P.R." I am prepared to accept that Deputy Brennan holds sincerely the views he has expressed here. I am impressed by the iron discipline that kept him quiet until now and prevented his speaking in the last election campaign for fear the cat might get out of the bag and there would be no support from religious and other minorities for the Fianna Fáil Party who were seeking their votes just 18 months ago.

Deputy Brennan has now the opportunity to speak, secure in his position in this House, with full knowledge of the fact that if this "gimmick" succeeds, he can click his fingers at the 3,000 Protestants in West Donegal because no matter when an election is held back into Dáil Éireann will come the bold Deputy Brennan.

Comment on this

That is what they want and that is what they will have.

Comment on this

He is now expressing views which obviously he so sincerely holds. He said—and I was a little surprised by his audacity—it was rather a pity that the Opposition, we in the Fine Gael Party and the other Parties in opposition, had in this debate sought to mislead the people and held up the House on a discussion of the merits or demerits of the Government's proposal. What does Deputy Brennan think we should do— sit silent and mute while the Government proceeds to tear down the Constitution as we know it?

Comment on this

We are building it up.

Comment on this

Does he think, and if he does whence does he get his view, that we on this side of the House do not conceive it our duty to do now what we did at much cost 36 years ago—preserve the rights of the people against assaults? If we are having a full discussion on the merits or demerits of P.R. in this autumn session of the Dáil, let the people outside realise who has initiated this discussion. There are burning problems facing our people, unemployment and other economic problems of various kinds, and we would be serving the people better by discussing those problems, but we are not allowed to do it because the Government, bereft of ideas, have no legislative proposals to put down for the autumn session of this Dáil. Accordingly, instead of discussing the economic situation and its implications, matters of burning concern to the people, here we are discussing the merits and demerits of P.R.

Deputy Brennan blames us, but if ever a Government have proceeded in the teeth of public opinion this Government have done so. They have ensured that this entire session of Dáil Éireann will be consumed in dealing with this matter, which, no matter how long it is discussed here, will not put a single man who is out of work back into work. It will not cause the draining of a single acre of land and it will not put a house or a roof over those without a home. It is being discussed at a time when people are streaming from our shores daily, when the queues of the unemployed are becoming longer and longer. We are here, in the second year of this Government, which got into office to get cracking, doing nothing but talking about the merits and the demerits of P.R.

It is a shame on the Taoiseach, on every member of his Government and on the Deputies sitting behind him that this situation should be permitted to develop. This Government got into office to get cracking. It appealed to the women of this city to "Vote Fianna Fáil and get your men back to work". It used such slogans as "Vote Fianna Fáil and we will beat the crisis". Now, 18 months later, that Government spend the entire autumn session of Dáil Éireann in an academic discussion of the best method of ensuring its continuance in office. We cannot help that. As a vigilant and determined Opposition, it is our duty to resist this effort by the Government, to ensure that, here in the only place where we can do it, it will be fully discussed, that every angle of it will be explored, and even though Deputy Brennan and his colleagues do not like it, we intend to continue to do it.

Let us throw our minds back and see how this extraordinary proposal saw the light of day. I am willing to wager that if Deputy Brennan, Deputy Booth and the other Fianna Fáil Deputies were put into a room at the end of last August and asked to define the 12 or 24 most urgent and most important political problems, and if they were left there for three days, they would emerge without a single one of them having mentioned the abolition of P.R. It was never present in the minds of the people. It was never mentioned except by the Taoiseach occasionally when Fianna Fáil was beaten and then, every time he was challenged about it, the Taoiseach was careful to say: "I did not quite mean that."

Towards the end of August, an inspired report crept into the newspapers that the Government were considering proposals to end the system of P.R. Shortly afterwards, one of the most extraordinary developments took place. The Taoiseach, or Prime Minister, held a Press interview. He called the reporters in and disclosed to them his own personal views with regard to P.R., but he was careful to say that he had not yet put it to the Government. Was there ever such a bit of balloon-flying and play-acting as that —a Press interview by the Taoiseach giving his own views on P.R. and saying that he did not know whether the Government would agree with him or not? He need not have had any doubt because, a few days later in the Council Chamber in Merrion Street, the Government met and entirely agreed with the Taoiseach. I am sure that any doubts he had about his proposals were quickly put at rest. The Government endorsed the Taoiseach's proposals and so this Bill saw the light of day.

I believe there is not a member of the Government who examined for himself what is involved in the Taoiseach's proposals. There was no critical examination. Apparently, once the Taoiseach said that this was his view, the boys said: "Yes." As long as the Taoiseach said that it was a good thing, it was accepted. I wonder are they now beginning to realise that Homer nodded, that there was a mistake and that they have started something they cannot control? Are they beginning to realise that in a matter of this kind they are playing with fire and that not only will other people be burned but that their own hands may be singed also?

I am quite certain that, even if the members of the Government and their colleagues in this House have convinced themselves that everything is all right, their own supporters throughout the country by no means agree with them. The more this matter is discussed and examined, the more the people are worried as to what the outcome may be. I believe that fair-minded Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party realise that this proposal just goes too far. It may be all very well to delete from the Constitution the reference to P.R. and to allow this House to endeavour to devise the best method of election, whether or not it be the single member, non-transferable vote, but it is quite another thing to remove P.R. from the Constitution and to put in its place a system which is completely untried, so far as this House is aware. Is that not going too far?

Comment on this

So far as this House is aware?

Comment on this

So far as this House is aware. I am talking about Ireland and an Irish problem and I would advise the Deputy to contain himself.

Comment on this

I will try to but you are leading us up the garden path.

Comment on this

I am saying that under this proposal the Government want to insert in the Constitution a system of election of which we, in this House, have no experience.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

We had not experience of P.R. when it started here.

Comment on this

I do not know about the Deputy, but all of us have grown up under it, and this House has stood the test of time under it and withstood assaults of a variety of kinds. Those who at one time opposed this very House are now in the House, and the House has been able to open its arms and has now even been able to place its arms around Deputy Booth.

Comment on this

That is a shame. I think that is the most insulting remark ever made in this House.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke has grown far in this House as a result of P.R., and he should hold his tongue.

Comment on this

I will speak after you.

Comment on this

And no disorderly interruptions by Deputy Burke will prevent me saying what I have to say.

Comment on this

I intend to reply.

Comment on this

I do not believe that this proposal has received the kind of critical examination that it should have from the Government. I do not mind the boys behind them. Deputies Booth and Burke will obviously just dance whatever steps the tune dictates. Deputy Booth some time ago was violently in favour of P.R., but now that the Government have decided otherwise, Deputy Booth will follow their line.

Comment on this

The boot is on the other foot now.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy O'Higgins will develop that.

Comment on this

Give the quotation.

Comment on this

As I say, the proposals have not been examined in a critical manner by the Government. Certain arguments have been used here in its favour and other arguments have been used against the system we all know. One argument has been that it was imposed by the British. I would have thought that, by 1958, Deputies in Fianna Fáil would have grown up— but no. The same sort of silly cant we used to bear in this country, 20 or 30 years ago, is solemnly trotted out again. "P.R. was imposed by the British"— that kind of argument is used by Deputies who are expected to be reasonably intelligent people. For what purpose do they use that argument? They use it to try to work up outside an unthinking antipathy to P.R. It is the same sort of slogan as: "Burn everything British except their coal"—"oppose P.R. because it was imposed by the British." Imposed how are you!

Was P.R. imposed when this House sat as a constituent assembly in 1922 and freely resolved, in the first Constitution, to elect its members by P.R.? Is it suggested that the British were trying to impose their will upon us at that time?

Comment on this

It was the same British who attempted to do it before that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Loughman should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

He is going away.

Comment on this

In 1922, this House, "sitting as a constituent assembly in provisional Parliament, acknowledging that all lawful authority comes from God to the people and in the confidence that the National life and unity of Ireland shall thus be restored," proclaimed the establishment of the Irish Free State, and in the exercise of undoubted right, declared and enacted the Constitution of 1922. Article 26 of that Constitution provided that "Dáil Éireann shall be composed of members elected to represent constituencies determined by law," and the Article went on to provide that the system of election would be in accordance with the principles of P.R. There was one of the first acts this House did—the very first act—in proclaiming its existence, and in declaring the manner in which it would control its own affairs.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say Article 26?

Comment on this

Article 26 of the 1922 Constitution. I want to know, when this argument is used that this system was imposed by the British, if it is being suggested that our leaders at that time, who had succeeded in seeing the last British Tommy march down to Dún Laoghaire and sail away, our leaders, like the great Michael Collins and the rest of them in this House, accepted dictation from the British as to the manner in which this House would elect itself? Every Deputy who uses that kind of argument shames himself, if not this House, and certainly shames those who gave much to establish this State 36 years ago. When the Constitution Deputy N. Lemass is looking at was enacted by the people in 1937, when in that Constitution Article 16, sub-Article 5, provided that the system of election to the Dáil should be in accordance with the declared system of P.R., is it suggested that the British were imposing that upon us?

The argument is absurd and whoever uses it, and it is being used by members of Fianna Fáil, is puring scorn on his own leader in 1937. They are pouring scorn on the man who now leads their Government because it was the present Taoiseach who, in this House, in 1936, declared his belief in P.R., declared that it had worked well in the country, declared that it had given stability to the country, stability which had been denied to other countries that did not use it. It was their own leader who, in 1936, asked the Irish people in a referendum to support the system of P.R. Nevertheless, here we are told in this debate, by Fianna Fáil Deputies, that this system was imposed on us by the British. If it was, if that is so, then, in 1936, the present Taoiseach was doing what the British told him to do, and I do not believe that.

What are the facts? They have been stated here already by the leader of the Opposition in the magnificent speech which he made. He has reminded Deputies that anyone who says the system of P.R. was imposed by the British, in effect, is insulting the memory of the founder of Sinn Féin and the first President of the State, the late Arthur Griffith. It was Arthur Griffith who campaigned tirelessly through the years for the adoption in this country of the system of P.R. Right from the early years of this century, the achievement of P.R. was one of Griffith's aims.

When a measure of Home Rule or independence became possible in the early teens of this century and when the British used the argument that Home Rule would mean Rome rule, Griffith was more insistent than ever that that argument must be resisted in order to ensure there would not be Rome rule, as had been urged at that time, but that the new Irish State would pledge itself to give under P.R. due and proper representation to minorities. Deputy Booth must remember that well. It was because of the sincerity of Griffith and those associated with him, including the present Taoiseach, that pledges were given in 1919, that if we established here by the success of our arms a new Irish State, that State would ensure that its minorities would be accorded fair representation under the system of P.R.

That is how P.R. became part and parcel of our history. It is because of that that P.R., as we know it, means something in comparative Irish history. It is because of that historical background and the pledges given by Griffith and repeated by Collins, pledges which they were prepared to honour even unto their deaths, that we in this Party, as the main Opposition Party, are determined to play fair by those who founded this State. We are determined to ensure that no improvisation urged now will tear a page or write a line across the pledges given on the foundation of this State. The system has nothing to do with the issue of any British Government. It was part and parcel of our national heritage.

Having achieved our independence, we freely and gladly put it into our Constitution in 1922 and the Irish people freely and gladly approved of it in the present Constitution. I hope that that kind of argument will not further be heard because it is not an argument on the merits. It is designed merely to cloud the issue. It is hoped that by using it a blind prejudice may be worked up amongst the people and that many people may vote against the system because of some anti-British feeling they still retain.

Then it is said that the single-member constituency, with no transferable vote, is something better. Did you ever hear anything like it? The same Deputies who are saying: "Do not vote for P.R. because it was imposed by the British" are seeking to put into operation in this country the system which the British have made peculiarly their own. There is not a person who has made any study, theoretical or practical, of political matters who must not be aware that in Britain for many years there has been a growing concern about their present system of election. In Britain itself, many people realise that the system is faulty; that it is undemocratic; that it brings minority government and that from time to time it has produced considerable injustices; but it is the system, we are told, which will be better than P.R. We are to do here what they found it necessary to do in the North to maintain in office the Unionist Party. That is what we are to have here.

The Deputies who ask the people to vote against P.R. because it was imposed by the British say the suggested system will give stability. I wonder do the Deputies who use that argument ever pause to think what is meant by "stability". What does "stability" mean to them? I know of no word more abused than "stability". Surely "stability" means the continuance of law and order and the institutions of our State? Surely "stability" means that the Constitution itself and the organs of society shall continue to operate properly and smoothly?

Stability does not mean—the Lord forbid that it should—that there should not be a change of government. If stability meant that after every election the same Deputies occupied the same old seats in this House that would not be stability. That would be atrophy. Really, those who talk about stability misuse the term and what they say is that this will mean that there will not be a change of government and, of course, that is what they really intend and desire.

We had true stability in this State over the past 36 years. We had the stability that enabled this Dáil to withstand assaults from without. We had the stability that enabled our courts, our Garda force, our Army and our laws to be respected up and down the State. We had the kind of stability that enabled a Government which never had a majority in this House to govern effectively and wisely for ten years. We had the kind of stability which enabled this State to grow up to full manhood. We had it under P.R.

We had at the same time our due and proper change of government without the Constitution or the organs of the State being endangered. In 1932, when a Fianna Fáil Government came into office, they took over a machine running well. They did not try to abuse it. They did not try to misuse it. They respected this House because they learned where they had gone wrong in the past. They upheld the organs of the State because they knew they were sent into this House to take over the Government by a majority of the people. That was given to them by P.R.

Throughout the past 36 years in dangerous and difficult times in this State, when a Government had to stand up to make a difficult decision and when individual Ministers had to take their own lives in their hands, they were enabled to do that because they knew that under P.R. they had the backing and support of the majority of the people. P.R. gave us stability in the past 36 years. If Deputies do not realise that inside this House, there are people outside who will.

As I say, those who use this argument misuse it. Saying one thing, they intend another. What they really hope to achieve is a situation in which it will not be possible easily to change the Government itself. Suppose we had a situation south of the Border such as obtains in the Six Counties in the North. If, after every single general election, as certain as the clock moves on, or as day follows night, the same old Government was bound to be reelected, if the same old team went back to the same old jobs, it might be called stability but I would hazard a guess that it would lead to the break-down of the organs of society.

I believe that here, south of the Border, there are classes and sections of people who would not easily abide a situation in which they could never change the Government, in which they could never get a new policy in operation. I believe they would resent the kind of system that gave them back, from a farcical election, and same Government, unvarnished and unchanged each time.

I want to warn Fianna Fáil Deputies and people outside who may be misled that as sure as the system of P.R. is changed—if that ever happens—we shall have instability, the like of which has never been seen anywhere else throughout the globe.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Because the people will not stand for the kind of system in which there is no change of policy in accordance with their wishes. Our people are the most democratic people under the sun and if there is an effort made here to put our people in straitjackets they will throw off those straitjackets. The kind of change proposed here is a change which in time, probably sooner than many people realise, will lead to fearful chaos, anarchy and instability.

Comment on this

Inciting to violence; is that right.

Comment on this

No man of my name ever did that.

Comment on this

Not until to-day.

Comment on this

I would remind Deputy Booth—he is a young Deputy in this House and a stranger— not to follow the line of the Minister for Health because it only leads to absurdities.

Comment on this

No, but do not incite to violence either.

Comment on this

I am not inciting to violence. I am warning Deputy Booth and his colleagues that they are likely to bring about that situation in the country——

Comment on this

Only if the people want it.

Comment on this

May I have the protection of the Chair, Sir?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins.

Comment on this

I want to warn the people and Deputies here whose minds are not blinded with prejudice about the system of election which is proposed. I just want to give a few examples of what I mean and I hope I shall be permitted to refer to minorities without its being assumed immediately that I am referring to religious minorities. I want to remind Deputies that there are definite views of a minority kind held by different section of our people. There are political movements and organisations in this country designed to represent a section of the people. There are various farming organisations and their purpose and concern is to represent the interests of farming. There are different organisations dealing with different forms of activity by different people which represent various sections.

The big movement, however, in this country is the trade union movement. The trade union movement is part and parcel of Irish life. It owes its existence to the efforts made by great Irishmen in the past, men like James Connolly and such people. They were men who played their part in establishing this House and in building up the freedom that this part of the country enjoys to-day. James Connolly was succeeded later by Big Jim Larkin who fought on the side of the workers and who came into this House to do it—to ask, to demand and to appeal from whoever was on the Government Benches for the implementation of a policy designed to create more employment and to better the living standards of the Irish workers.

I want to remind Fianna Fáil Deputies that men like Connolly and Larkin just cannot be forgotten. They are not just names that can be scored out of a page of Irish history. They are part of Irish history. Were it not for the fact that men such as Larkin could come into this House, to fight inside this House for the things they believed in; were it not for the fact that the gates of Leinster House were opened to them—provided they were able to get a sufficient number of people to give them a quota—we would still have minority demands but they would be made down on the Custom House Quay and elsewhere by persons fighting for the people they were pledged to serve. Were it not for that fact we would have in this country the kind of situation in which the gates of Leinster House would be shut in the face of a new Connolly, or a new Larkin, or people legitimately representing 800,000 Irish workers. If that day ever comes, this House itself will be in jeopardy and those who think that they are fashioning comfortable seats for themselves in this House will find that they have been playing with fire and that more than those they set out to burn have felt the flames.

There are other minorities here apart from the trade union movement. We always have the lunatic fringe amongst our people, those who still think of the things which others have learned to forget: those who still think that an Irish State can be ignored and that Irish law can be shrugged aside; those who still think they are entitled to hold the view that the gun in an individual's hand is the best setter of an argument. That lunatic fringe has always been——

Comment on this

They are not entitled to hold that opinion.

Comment on this

They are entitled to make that opinion the law of the land, provided they get sufficient people to send them in here with a majority, just as others learned that lesson in time. We have always had that view amongst our people. Possibly it is part of our temperament. There are those amongst us who still think that 1922 never dawned. There are those amongst our people who apparently never realised that the last British soldier left this land of ours 36 years ago. There are people amongst us who are still fighting fights that are now forgotten and believing views now discarded.

There is that lunatic fringe that did not learn the better way, as Fianna Fáil did 30 years ago. There are those who never learned to respect this House as Fianna Fáil did in 1927. There are those who never realised that the democratic way and the right way of getting their policy accepted is by securing a majority of votes, as Fianna Fáil did, and getting elected by Deputies as a Government, as Fianna Fáil did. There are those who have not learned the lesson which the Taoiseach learned in 1927. They have a definite point of view. Deputy Booth may say that they are not entitled to be there. They are there. There is no good in going around in blinkers, in believing that by closing our eyes, what is in front of our noses will disappear. They are there at the moment, so much so that a couple of hundred Irishmen have now to be kept in durance, interned in the Curragh. What is the use of saying whether they are right or wrong? Right or wrong, those are their views.

I want to say to Deputy Booth that that problem did not arise in the past 18 months or the past three years. It has been there all along. It has been eased to some extent because we have always been entitled to say to these people—no matter what Government has been elected to this House in the past—"You are wrong. You know how you can make yourselves right, by going to the people and getting the people to accept your policy. You can then come into the House, as others did before you, and try to make the changes which, in your salad days, you believed in." The very moment we appear to adopt a system of election which they can assert closes the doors of Leinster House upon them then we lose the authority and the right to enforce our admonitions against them.

Comment on this

P.R. has not brought them in.

Comment on this

P.R. has brought them in. Deputy Booth is a young man in the service of this House, but does he not know that the four Sinn Féin Deputies who should be sitting here are not the first who arrived in this House believing in the use of force?

Comment on this

They are not sitting here.

Comment on this

This particular Dáil to which Deputy Booth was elected is not the first Dáil. There have been 14 Dála before this. In practically every single Dáil, Deputies have been elected because they were supposed to represent an extreme point of view of one kind or another. I do not care if they call themselves Sinn Féil nowadays. That is a proud old name given to this country by Arthur Griffith. No matter what they call themselves, their point of view, up to this, has consistently been represented in this House and it is a point of view, whether Deputy Booth likes it or not, that is held by Irishmen.

Comment on this

They will not sit in the House.

Comment on this

These four Deputies who were elected in the last election were not the first to hold this point of view. They are entitled to sit in this House; they were elected to it.

Comment on this

Quite a number.

Comment on this

Quite a lot. The Party Deputy Booth belongs to, at one time shared these views, and would not take their seats, but the House survived, and in due course opened its arms to them. They did come in. They had learned the folly of their ways and determined to come into this noble House of ours.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Higgins has said that at least four times.

Comment on this

Deputy Booth invited me to say it again.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not allow himself to be drawn.

Comment on this

If Deputy Booth wants more of it and if you permit him to invite me to do it, I will continue to do it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot prevent Deputies from interrupting but interruptions are not orderly.

Comment on this

Perhaps the next time Deputy Booth interrupts, you might frown upon him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Chair.

Comment on this

Considering this argument about stability, one would imagine that we were going to have a change of government every few months. Of course, that is absurd. Over the past 36 years, we have had only three Prime Minister or Taoisigh —only three. In Britain in that period, they had seven different Prime Ministers. Does that mean anything to Fianna Fáil Deputies? Are they so blinded by prejudice that they cannot realise what is meant by that? Three Prime Ministers in 36 years—emphasising that under the system of election here, our people are slow to change but when they change they change.

Edmund Burke was a great Irishman who was sent from Trinity College across to Westminster in the 18th century. He defined stability as being change in continuity and continuity in change. Have we not had that in the past 36 years? We have not, merely for some quite odd or fanciful reason, put in a Government and taken it out again. It was ten years before there was a first change of government. It was 16 years before there was a second change, and in that period, as I say, we had only three leaders of Government in this country. Where is the instability?

Comment on this

The number of elections.

Comment on this

The number of elections represents the folly of one man. It is perfectly true that the present Taoiseach has always been concerned to have an election. He has had them in doubles, in pairs and in braces of elections. He had an election in 1932 and 1933; 1937 and 1938; 1943 and 1944; 1947 and 1948.

Mind you, I suppose there was method in his folly because each time he decided to have an election, he said to the people: "The reason I want an election is that I want an overall majority." He got it each time —under P.R. Are the people to be blamed for that? Each time they were told that a Government whose policy they were supporting needed an overall majority in this House, the people gave it to the Taoiseach and his Party. Who is trying now to bite the hand that fed him? Who is now being ungrateful to our people?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

I suggest if Deputy Booth and his colleagues had regard to the extraordinary manner in which an indulgent Irish people have dealt with their Leader and their Party over the past 20 years, they would realise that to speak of the system of P.R. leading to instability is to insult the people themselves. We all know our people are fundamentally honest. Our people have always done the thing they believed to be right, If they wanted to give any Party standing before them a complete majority in this House they gave it to them every time; if they felt it was a wrong thing to do, that it might be better not to put one Party in a position of pre-eminence in this House, they did not do it. Why are Deputies so audacious in this House? Why are we so preened with our own importance that we can look back over the past 36 years and say the Irish people were mistaken? That is a bit of audacity in which I do not think any Deputy in this House is entitled to take part.

It is also said that the present system of P.R. does not lead to strong government. Again, we should have agreement on terms. I do not know what "strong government" means. I thought it should be the concern of this House to get and retain good government. You have strong government in many cases throughout the world. It is not necessarily beneficial and power, we know, corrupts. Surely the concern should be, in examining the record, to see whether we have had good Governments in this country?

We are all entitled to our points of view. People are entitled to criticise the things in which my Party believes, the things they have done, the mistakes they have made. Of course they are entitled to it. But those who say that P.R. does not lead to strong government should remember that, for ten years from the foundation of this State, there was in charge of this country a band of young men, the first Government of this country, who never had a majority in this House. I believe they were a good Government. I believe they were a strong Government also. I believe they had to take decisions that cannot be compared with what had to be done since. They were strong because they were good, because they were doing the right thing, following the right policy.

Strong government; you have strong government now—and what are we doing? Instead of trying to solve the problems of the country, we are discussing P.R. here. A strong Government; mind you, it is not a good Government because it is not putting first things first. When eventually we all, as we must, stand on this issue before the bar of public opinion, before the people who will decide it, I trust that from this debate at least may come a discarding of some arguments and that the issue will be put properly before the people by those who believe in the merits of the change by doing it honestly and genuinely.

Other arguments are used. It is said that the change proposed will lead to a better type of Deputy in this House. That argument is used by Fianna Fáil. Since there are 77 Fianna Fáil Deputies in this House, presumably it is used about themselves. Though each Deputy in Fianna Fáil uses that argument, yet when he looks in the looking-glass when he is shaving himself in the morning, he says: "I am not talking about myself." I am sure that Deputy Burke will say that the change will bring a better type of Deputy to this House. He has not in mind that Deputy Burke should cease to sit here. It is more Deputy Burkes that Deputy Burke wants.

We know well that the kind of change proposed here is unlikely to lead to a better type of representation. I have read what Deputy Booth had to say. I hope I am not having the somniferous effect on the rest of the House that I am having on Deputy Booth. Although he has limited experience in this House, Deputy Booth will remember, I am sure, the feeling of dismay which must arise with any Government when, apart from the loss involved, suddenly a by-election has to take place. The hearts jump to the mouths. A cold shiver runs to the spine. If it is a country constituency, they will look around for the best hurler or the best footballer and try to nab him first. Fianna Fáil Deputies know this very well. Is that the kind of representation that is good for this House? Under a by-election, you have a single member being sent here—I agree with the transferable vote but a single member is sent here.

I believe that if the proposed change takes place, the level of representation in this House will suffer very much. We have a good House. I believe, largely speaking, that Deputies in the different Parties—and I include Deputies not in Parties—are a good cross-section of our people. We have a decent good House and a good personnel inside this House.

Comment on this

We shall have fewer lawyers.

Comment on this

That is part of your difficulty.

Comment on this

Pádraig Pearse was a lawyer.

Comment on this

There are a few over there with nothing else.

Comment on this

The kind of representation now held up to our people to have in this House is that of the so-called Mother of Parliaments, Westminster. I would say, in regard to some 80 per cent. of the members in that Assembly, that it would take three of them to make one Deputy in an Irish House. They are elected because they are the local bigwigs or the local something else. They are sent into Westminster representing a Labour constituency, a Tory constituency, not because of any peculiar ability they have but merely because they are the particular persons the boys in the Party machine have selected.

Here in this House, under P.R., no Deputy can afford to become complacent. If he desires to continue to be a member of this House, he has got to be up and about. Deputy O'Malley and other Deputies know that well. You cannot just take your post from the pigeon-hole outside, stuff it in your pocket and say: "Maybe, in Tibb's Eve, I shall get around to answering that." When your constituents come to you, you have to do as Deputy Burke does—to make sure that their problem is raised in this House. Deputy Burke is a past master at that—and more power to him. He is representing the people of his constituency. He is not sitting indolently on a safe seat because the Party boss has put him there. It might be that the Party bosses might have tried to get rid of Deputy Burke in the past but back in Deputy Burke came because the people Deputy Burke represented had the opportunity, under P.R., to vote for Paddy Burke.

Comment on this

I hope we shall see him again.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be discussing Deputy Burke.

Comment on this

I am discussing the system. I want to remind Deputies that, under P.R., each Deputy representing a constituency, particularly if he has colleagues, has to play the part of a proper representative in this House, to speak intelligently, to contribute by discussion to the solution of the people's problems, to look after the particular affairs of his constituency. He knows well that, if he does not, then, when the next election comes, his Party supporters will prefer another candidate in the Party. That is important.

Comment on this

You could do that under the straight vote

Comment on this

I do not think they can because, in a single member constituency, under the straight vote, Fianna Fáil supporters who, I am sure, will continue to be Fianna Fáil, must vote for the candidate. If they do not vote for him, the other side will take the seat. Whether or not they like his bright blue eyes, whether he is a lazy or an active man, whether or not he can read, whether or not he answers letters, they must vote for him because if they do not the other side get the seat.

Comment on this

It is the same under P.R.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke stands in County Dublin with two other good colleagues, the Minister for Defence and somebody else. If the Fianna Fáil supporters in County Dublin turn against Deputy Burke, they will vote for the Minister for Defence or the other candidate. If the Party has sufficient support, they will still have two seats, but out will go poor Deputy Burke. That has meant that we are not morons in this House. Each one of us has a part to play in pursuance of our ideals and of the policies in respect of which we were elected.

Those are a few considerations in favour of the system we now have. There is an old saying that the devil you know is better than the devil you do not know. We do not know the British system. We had it here in the British days. Deputies will remember that in the 1919 election the people turned against the Irish Parliamentary Party—a Party which, in its own way and in its own time, had rendered tremendous service to the country. But the people turned against it in 1919 and that Party was wiped out, although in that election it polled more votes than Fine Gael polled in the last election.

The Fine Gael Party still has 40 seats in the House. We are enabled to live to fight another day. "Béidh lá eile ag an bPáirteach seo" was a phrase used by a certain individual one time. Under the system of single member constituencies the Irish Parliamentary Party did not live to fight another day. It disappeared in 1919 but, thank God, its history, traditions and principles survived. There is something Deputies should remember.

Under this dangerous change the Government are asking the people to accept, very serious things can happen. Those in this House at one time may all be wiped out in due course. This House may be undermined and the Government of this country may be entrusted to those who never had experience of the House before. A change of government can mean such a revolution that catastrophe may result. We get away from the change in continuity and continuity in change, which represents the stability that Edmund Burke talked about some hundreds of years ago. P.R. has given us stability. In the words of the Taoiseach himself: "It has served the country well."

We in this country are fortunate to have had P.R. We are fortunate to have inherited this system as part of the wisdom which Arthur Griffith brought to Irish political life. It has served this country well. It has meant that we have been saved from some of the violent changes that took place in other countries. Of course, we have changed. Deputies who at one time were on this side of the House walked across and took up government over there. They did so under the system of P.R. And when the time came for a change, it came. But there have not been the dramatic changes in thought associated with the kind of system now urged upon us.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy give us any instances of that?

Comment on this

I do not want to be led away. I believe with Deputy Dillon that this is an Irish question to be decided in an Irish way by Irish people and that you do not learn much by looking over the garden wall and seeing what John Bull and other people may be doing. But there are examples. Deputy Booth is probably aware that in South Africa there is a tremendous sentimental factor involved in the policy of racial segregation. Those who believe in racial segregation are operating a system whereby the coloured people are treated openly as under-privileged, herded into particular sections and kept underground. That is opposed to Christian ideals. Deputy Booth may be aware that that policy became the policy in South Africa through a minority Government elected on single member seats.

In the general election of 1953 the South African Nationalist Party—the Government Party—polled 598,685 votes, a shade more than 500,000, and the Opposition—the Smuts Party —which opposed their policy, polled 608,000 votes. They polled more votes than the Nationalist Party, but under the system urged upon us here the Nationalists got 92 seats and the Smuts Party 43 seats. Thus the Prime Minister was able to say that the policy of racial segregation had been supported by the South African people whereas, in fact, a majority had voted against it. That is a policy in respect of which there are high feelings on both sides. Is it to be suggested that that is the kind of system we should have here?

The Tánaiste was prophetic away back on the 10th November, 1933. He saw away into the future and the danger that might occur, such as occurred in South Africa. Deputies will remember that in 1933 it was proposed at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis that the system of P.R. should be changed and this British system introduced. The Tánaiste said:—

"P.R. was certainly a better system than that which prevailed heretofore and which was now in operation in Great Britain. The system which operated in that country might well give a minority a very substantial majority in Parliament. It had done so in Britain and could do so here by the system of single member constituencies and the non-transferable vote."

Those are the very words the present Tánaiste used about the proposal he now asks the people to support, a proposal which would lead to minority government, a proposal which would be undemocratic and which might result in a policy being put into operation which had not the support of a majority of the people.

Comment on this

What decision did the Fine Gael Árd-Fheis take that year?

Comment on this

It never came before a Fine Gael Árd-Fheis and it was not even considered by them.

Comment on this

It was.

Comment on this

The writer of that letter very kindly withdrew the letter and apologised. That was the position. In 1933 the Tánaiste condemned the system now proposed, and he was quite right. As he said then, it could lead to minority government and he asked the Fianna Fáil Party at the Árd-Fheis and the people generally to retain P.R.

In conclusion, if we are supposed to be unrepresentative, everyone in this House knows quite well that we have our title deeds from the people who sent us here; and the Government over there could be a good Government, as well as a strong Government, if they acted properly in the knowledge that they were sent here by a majority of the people. Our system is a good system. It is a democratic system and it is an Irish system. It has worked in this country over the last 36 years. The change now proposed is, as has been described, an invitation to the people to take a leap in the dark. We do not believe the future of this country can be decided by any one individual. We do not think it is right that, merely because the present Taoiseach had a bright idea in bed in the early hours of August last, this country's future should be jeopardised. We have no doubt that in due course when, after proper examination here, this matter goes for decision to the people, the people will say, as they said in the past: "No dictatorship in Ireland."

Comment on this

I had no intention of intervening in this debate but I happen to represent the area in which P.R. was first tried out and, reading some of the things which have been said, I felt compelled to put the facts on record. Speaking here on 26th November as reported at column 1009 of Volume 171 Deputy J.A. Costello, the Leader of the Opposition, said:—

"...for the first time in this country and the adjoining country of Great Britain elections were held in Sligo under the principles of P.R. That was not done at the dictate of the British Parliament. It was done at the request of the people of County Sligo because they found that the other system, the system that the Taoiseach wants to impose upon this country for parliamentary elections and to impose for all time, caused complete chaos in their local affairs."

That statement is without foundation and, therefore, completely wrong.

Up to 1919 Sligo Corporation under an old Charter dating back over 300 years could levy a rate only of 5/- or 6/- in the £. They could do nothing to relieve local conditions. I remember Sligo town at the time. I canvassed the town in 1918. The conditions under which the people lived were appalling. The houses were infested with vermin. Very often they had neither chimneys nor windows. The streets were unsurfaced. There was no proper sanitary accommodation. There was no water. The people began to agitate for better amenities. This agitation started around 1916 and 1917. The only way in which the condition could be relieved was to enable the corporation to strike a higher rate. The corporation asked for leave to strike a higher rate and, following on further agitation by the people and the corporation, a Bill was passed in the British Parliament giving the corporation the necessary power. A condition of the passing of that Bill was that P.R. would be accepted. The corporation had to pay the costs of having that Bill passed and they amounted to the tidy sum of £986 17s. 7d. That bill was paid by the Sligo Corporation. That is the history of the introduction of P.R. in Sligo.

Lloyd George thought Sligo an ideal spot for P.R. As everybody knows, the population of Sligo holds a big percentage of Protestants. They control practically all the business, the shipping, the milling and the hardware. Lloyd George believed that by getting P.R. accepted he would create a Protestant Party in Sligo town but, thanks be to God, he failed—and I am supported in that by Deputy Booth— and the Protestants in Sligo have to-day taken their place in the other Parties and they are honoured representatives in both the corporation and the county council.

The Bill was agreed by a meeting of Sligo Council on 13th February, 1918. It was agreed to accept P.R. It was agreed that a charge would be levied on the local rates. The Sligo Corporation Act, 1918, received the royal assent on 30th July, 1918, with the relevant provisions incorporated in it. The first election of the borough council by P.R. was held on 15th January, 1919, and the first meeting of the new council, comprised of 24 members, was held on 23rd January, 1919. Sligo town was the unit.

I am not in a position to say how many went forward for election on the first occasion, but on the second or third occasion 80 candidates went forward for 24 seats. Most Deputies in this House have had experience of Seanad elections. In the second last election they were confronted with a panel of something in the region of 100. It is assumed that Deputies are competent to mark ballot papers. We had those papers in our homes where we could study them. In the case of the election in Sligo old people and people with bad sight were asked to take this paper with 80 names on it and to select from it the people they wished to represent them. Not even the most educated could do justice to a ballot paper such as that.

Comment on this

May not any citizen desire to serve his local community in a local body?

Comment on this

I am not questioning that at all.

Comment on this

Who is going to decide that they will not be allowed to do it?

Comment on this

I am not questioning that at all.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy is. He is questioning the right of 80 people in Sligo to offer to serve their local authority.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Gilbride is entitled to make his own speech.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt the Deputy. I am entitled to make my point. I have experience, and I know what I am talking about. I went through this whole matter of P.R.

Comment on this

Who is going to tell No. 79 that he or she should not offer to serve the people?

Comment on this

I am pointing out that the system is impossible. I heard Deputy Carty saying the other night that with ten candidates, there could be 10,000,000 ways of voting. He is not here. If he has not too much to do, I will ask him to find out in how many ways the ballot paper could be marked when there would be 80 candidates and when he has made that calculation, I will ask him to give Deputy Mulcahy a copy.

Comment on this

Who is to stop a man or woman from offering to serve on the local authority and holding himself or herself out to the electorate?

Comment on this

No one in the world. Under the straight vote system, where there will be one area, the chances are that there will not be 80 candidates. The point I want to make is that, under the P.R. system, with 80 candidates, or any such number, it is impossible to mark a ballot paper. We will get away from that point, as Deputy Mulcahy does not like it.

We remember when experts were sent across from a P.R. society that was formed in England. We had lectures and classes to instruct us as to how to vote and as to how P.R. should be worked. As a Deputy pointed out, the cranks became so enamoured of it that they could talk about nothing else and became so obsessed with it that they went around the country pointing out the benefits of P.R. This system has continued from that day to this.

Comment on this

And the Deputy got elected by it.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Deputy Lindsay took part in that or not. I know that any man who spoke in opposition to those cranks was told that he was a fool, that he did not know what he was talking about. That is the system that obtains.

I will give a few examples of what did happen under P.R. in Sligo. In one area in Sligo, at county council elections, on three different occasions, a certain man headed the poll and on each of those occasions he did not get the seat. The quota was between 700 and 800. He got close on 700 first preference votes. A man who got 200 first preference votes was elected. If that is majority rule, I do not know what to say.

Comment on this

We will still have it for local elections.

Comment on this

Wait and see. Not like that. We know quite well what little care is given to what happens to third, fourth and fifth preference votes. When a man who secures a number of first preference votes so near the quota is thrown out three times and a man who secured 200 first preference votes is elected on the tenth and eleventh count, it cannot be said that that is a good system.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy give us the figures he is talking about?

Comment on this

I gave the figures. I am not able to give the exact figures. As I have said, the quota was between 700 and 800. This man on three occasions got close on 700 and a man who got 200, in another end of the area, got the seat.

Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Lindsay will probably remember that in the general election before the last general election an Independent beat a Fine Gael candidate for the last seat, although the Fine Gael candidate had 2,000 more first preference votes. It goes on the pure chance of the count. I know that because I have watched the working of P.R.

Comment on this

It is not pure chance. It is deliberate.

Comment on this

It is pure chance where the returning officer takes the lower preference votes from. I have watched this. It is pure chance.

Comment on this

He is quite right.

Comment on this

Even yet, it is not laid down how the lower preferences should be taken.

Comment on this

If the Minister for Education knows as much about the home P.R. system as he does about the French system, we need not consider it too seriously.

Comment on this

Have a look at the Third Schedule to the Electoral Act, 1923, and you will see.

Comment on this

It is pure chance as to which candidate's votes the lower preference come from. They might as well be drawn out of a hat.

Comment on this

They do that at one stage.

Comment on this

On the occasion that I am referring to, the Independent beat the other man by five votes. At the last general election, the very same thing happened. There were two Fine Gael men running for the last seat and the man who was beaten had almost 1,000 first preference votes. The man with the smaller number won because, on the chances of the play, he got more transferred votes. That is P.R. No man need tell me that it is not pure chance. You could put the names into a hat and you would get as much fair play.

I have studied P.R. long enough in Sligo. One thing on which I agree with Deputy Dillon is that it is a complete fraud and a cod. He was the first man who had the guts to stand up to those fellows and tell them the truth.

Comment on this

How did Jinks get on there?

Comment on this

The only argument I heard in this debate that is worth answering is that there was no demand for a change. I have been engaged in every election since 1918. I have been engaged in by-elections all over Ireland. At every election I worked at, either bringing voters to the poll or showing them how to vote, I heard from people: "When will you change this rotten system and let us vote so that we will know how we are voting and whom we are voting for?" We are told here that there is no demand for the proposed change in the system. There is a demand. The people have asked for it time and again since the system was established.

Deputy Corish twitted us on our loyalty and suggested that the Fianna Fáil back benchers are too loyal to take part in this debate, that they did not believe in this change but were too loyal to talk about it. It was the first time that I ever knew loyalty was a crime. A Fianna Fáil back bencher does not want to repeat the same thing, like a parrot, over and over again. The leaders have put the case for them and they are quite satisfied. But we are loyal and we are proud of that loyalty. We are loyal to our leaders, loyal to our comrades and loyal to the people who sent us here. Further, we are loyal to those who will come after us and it is because of that loyalty that we are not afraid to take a chance, knowing that we will leave them something that will give them security.

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this

It is because of that loyalty and because some of us know that under P.R. some of us who are older and longer on the scene than others would have a better chance, that we are prepared to take this chance. It is because we are loyal and because the people know we are loyal that we stand here to-day as the biggest Party that ever came into this House.

Comment on this

Why do you not get cracking, so? Unemployment first and emigration.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order! Deputy Gilbride.

Comment on this

The issue on this Bill is very simple. What all the talk is about, I do not know. The issue before the House is whether the people are entitled to be allowed to decide the question or not.

Comment on this

That is a new philosophy of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

There is nothing new about it. The question is: are the people to get a chance of deciding something that is important for the life of this country? Anyone who votes against the Bill is denying the people that chance and that right, no matter how he may try to disguise it. The people who are opposing this Bill are afraid of the people and have always been afraid of the people. We are not afraid of the people. Therefore, we are voting for this Bill.

Comment on this

In opposing this Bill, I want to refute the statement made from the Government Benches that we are denying the right of the people to decide this issue. What we do suggest is that there are more important issues to be considered at the present time. I have stated outside and will state here that this is a smokescreen to cover up the failure to fulfil all the promises Fianna Fáil made during the last election. They wished to suggest that we are opposing in some way the rights of the people.

In my 36 years here, goodness knows I have always asserted the rights of the people. We have had lectures from Deputy Booth and others on the position in other countries. Deputy Booth emphasised the case of France because of the publicity there is about that country and he compared what happened in France with what could happen here. He omitted to tell the House that France did not have P.R. since 1946 and therefore if French parliamentary institutions have failed —according to Deputy Booth—that failure cannot be attributed to P.R.

The Deputy then supported the Mother of Parliaments and the system associated with it although there are only two other nations that have nontransferable voting. But because it was England it was all right for Deputy Booth. The Government's propaganda efforts on this issue will operate so that some of the Fianna Fáil Party will go down to the West and the Midlands and say: "Ah, this is a British institution. Britain and Lloyd George forced P.R. upon this country." Deputy Booth will go out with his Party and will say that we want to have elections on a system similar to that which exists in the Mother of Parliaments in England.

Deputy Booth had a horror of Coalitions but his own Government, that is the British Government, has such admiration for them that it has congratulated Australia because Australia has got a Coalition Government. Deputy Booth did not mention that. He objects to Coalition Governments because we brought in and passed the External Relations Act and I am very proud and glad to say that Act was passed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not discuss it on this Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Booth and others were allowed in passing to mention it. I am very pleased it was passed because inside and outside this House we removed any excuse that certain people might have to attack Deputy Booth or attack any member of the House. We removed the excuse for them to attack our Army or our Police Force or members of the House for carrying out the work they were sent here to do.

One Fianna Fáil Deputy shakes his head but I suppose I am the one Deputy in the House who remembers, unfortunately, that we received the death sentence for being members——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the Bill. The Deputy should relate his remarks to the question before the House.

Comment on this

I was referring to the remarks of Deputy Booth and others on the passing of the External Relations Act.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise on this Bill.

Comment on this

These people are now allowed to publish articles in the Press and to criticise in public any organisation or political Party and there is no fear that they will be denied their rights because we removed the last vestige of British control. But after stating that he would support this Bill, Deputy Booth went on to speak in a way that indicated, unconsciously, that he was supporting the amendments to this motion. Although he was supporting the Government proposal to abolish P.R. he said he expected he would be one of the first casualties. That is the whole case against P.R. Here is Deputy Booth with a powerful political machine, a wealthy organisation with Party funds, and if he says he has such doubts about his chance of being elected——

Comment on this

Could we have the reference please? Did Deputy Booth say that?

Comment on this

The reference he made was that although he was supporting this proposal he expected to be one of the first casualties.

Comment on this

At what column in the Dáil Debates is this reported?

Comment on this

In Volume 171, No. 8, column 1235. Not alone Deputy Booth but Deputy S. Flanagan also indicated that although he was voting for this Bill, probably many Deputies including himself would not come back again. What chance has an Independent when a member of Fianna Fáil, with its powerful political machine, feels that he may not get back? Does that not show that the whole thing is a smokescreen and that it is not being done at all unanimously by the Party, no matter what they say now? It is introduced to try to cover up the mistakes and the failures of the Party up to the present.

Deputy Loughman implied that we needed no Opposition, no other Parties; that in Fianna Fáil they had the Popular Front including trade unions, farmers and industrialists, even men who had a hatred of the name of trade unions and, that being the case, with a Popular Front there was no need for the Labour Party or any other Party in the House. I am sure the farmers will not agree with the Fianna Fáil members who are farmers and who voted with the Government in refusing to give the wheat levy back to the farmers. I wonder will Fianna Fáil Deputies who are members of trade unions obey the instructions of the congresses not to vote for this Bill? I can remember the time when some people voted against increases for the old age pensioners and voted for the Standstill Order on wages. Even if we have in that Popular Front trade unionists, farmers and industrialists we also have, even in the Government Benches, among the Ministers, anti-trade unionists and anti-Labour men—that is, according to their speeches.

That being so, I am opposing this proposal. I have long service in this House and it is not the first time an attempt was made to change my constituency. The first time I was elected, I think, in 1922, our constituency was Wicklow and Kildare. After some years one portion of that was transferred to Carlow and another portion to Kilkenny. In a further revision we were given back our own constituency but I do not know what portion of the constituency we shall now have. I feel, however, that after 36 years, please God, we shall still be there to make another fight to show up the inconsistency of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Deputy Brennan said we opposed every Bill introduced by the Government that was of great benefit to the people. I do not know of any Bill of that type which we have opposed. We criticised the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he brought in the Transport Bill, when he abolished the Dublin trams and when he was planning to remove all the hire lorries from the country and when he was held up as the rail man, the saviour of the railways——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on this Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan was allowed to refer to it when he said that we opposed every measure brought in by the Government which was to the benefit of the people.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not discuss that at this juncture.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I think the Deputy has misquoted Deputy Booth in his reference to the Dáil Reports. I should like that to go on record.

Comment on this

That is not a point of order, it is just an interruption.

Comment on this

We shall see what is in the report. Deputy Booth stated at column 1235:—

"We know very well that when, as we believe will be the case, this amendment is put before the people and is carried by them and we come to another general election, there will be a number of us who will not be retained."

Comment on this

That is better. Now we have the correct quotation.

Comment on this

He said he would be defeated. When he says: "a number of us", he is speaking of himself and his Party. I am sorry if I misquoted the Deputy. I am not aware of opposing any measures, as Deputy Brennan alleged, except those to which I referred. I referred to the legislation by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. We opposed that and we opposed a Bill he brought in restricting certain rights. We opposed a Standstill Order designed to keep wages down.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy relate his remarks to the Bill before the House?

Comment on this

These are all matters which were referred to by other Deputies. We are justified in opposing this Bill because, no matter what Deputy Booth may say, it will interfere with the rights of a certain minority. I am living in a constituency where there are more than 4,000 people of the Protestant faith. The best and the most important businessman in my town is a man who differs in religion from the majority of the people, the chairman of our council. We work together and co-operate without any difficulty in County Wicklow.

Deputy Booth, I know, will try to get out of some of the statements he made and I am certain he will, on reflection, be sorry that he made some of these statements. We have been here for 35 or 36 years, and, while we may have had differences of opinion on both sides of the House, there was never any contention of a religious nature before, and I regret that it should be brought in now. I do not want this Parliament to be like the Parliament in Northern Ireland. What they argue up there is "a Protestant Parliament for a Protestant people." By abolishing P.R. you will be supporting the Northern Ireland attitude and depriving the Nationalists and Catholics in the North of any representation. I believe the Government in advocating this measure are wrong.

I have no doubt what the decision on the referendum will be, no matter what the Minister for External Affairs may say in the West and South of Ireland, that this is a Lloyd George stunt; no matter what Deputy Booth and others will say in Southern Ireland to the effect that we want to copy the British Parliament. If we deny people the right to be elected to this Parliament, they may adopt other means of having their voice heard and they may get sympathy from unthinking people. The younger men, who have no votes at the present time but who will have in a few years' time, will be brought into the net, perhaps with dire consequences.

I would ask the Government to consider these matters before putting the people to the expense of a referendum. Furthermore, if we are to have a referendum, why not have it on the same day as the Presidential election? This would be better than spending £80,000 or £90,000 for this referendum and then having to spend a further sum of this magnitude for the Presidential election. Alternatively would it not be feasible when holding the referendum on P.R. to find out whether the people want a President or not?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise.

Comment on this

In opposing this Bill I do not wish to deny the people the right to vote on the issue. We know this measure will be passed and then the people will make their decision. I have no doubt what that decision will be, especially when they are being asked to deprive themselves of representation in this House.

Comment on this

There have been so many speakers on this question that it is very difficult to approach it from a fresh or original angle. However, I wish to put forward my reasons for opposing this measure. The first inkling we got of the Taoiseach's decision to remove P.R. was at a Press conference some two or three months ago. A short time after that we had a Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis in the Mansion House. That was a gathering of political supporters of Fianna Fáil and the Taoiseach saw fit to declare there his intention of removing the present system of election and of substituting for it the direct voting system. He has now gone a step further and announced his intentions to this House, which Assembly, in my opinion, should have been the first body to hear of his intention to abolish P.R.

Since that statement was made there has been much speculation throughout the country as to whether P.R. should go; we read in the papers every day where there have been discussions by local authorities. These authorities have gone so far as to pass resolutions condemning the Taoiseach's action. Again, we read letters in the Press every day criticising this measure. All this talk and all these letters about this action on the part of the Taoiseach points to a spirit of unrest in the minds of the people.

We have heard in this House, in support of the Government's contention that P.R. should go, certain reasons given as to way this Bill was introduced. One of the reasons was that the P.R. system of election tended to create a multiplicity of Parties and tended to set up warring groups. It was also suggested that it rendered responsible government impossible. Another reason given was that it was imposed on this country by the British. It was said that direct voting provides government by the majority of the people. I am not impressed by these reasons. I am convinced that there is a feeling in the minds of the vast majority of the people that this Bill is a ruse by the Taoiseach to ensure the return of the Fianna Fáil Party for the future. I may be wrong in that belief but it has been expressed to me on more than one occasion.

Many people think that the Taoiseach has an ulterior motive in introducing this Bill. In support of that it has been stated that no attempt was made to abolish the P.R. system during the 16 years Fianna Fáil were in power, from 1932 to 1948. No expression of opinion was then given that that system of election was unsatisfactory and that it should be replaced by the direct vote.

For those 16 years that Fianna Fáil were in power they suffered no defeat until 1948. During those 16 years we had many general elections and Fianna Fáil were returned every time. I could not say how many general elections there were but there were at least ten, and Fianna Fáil were returned every time under the present system which they now condemn. It is very significant that the Taoiseach thought of bringing in this proposal only after he received two defeats, one in 1948 and the other in 1954.

As I have already said one of the reasons given for the introduction of the present measure was that it was introduced into this country, and more or less imposed on the country, by the British Government in 1919. I am satisfied that previous speakers have conclusively shown that the adoption of the present system of P.R. was an act of the Irish people in 1922. A Constitution was drawn up in that year; it was endorsed by this Parliament and subsequently endorsed again by the people.

In 1937 the present Taoiseach drew up the Constitution and retained the present method of election in that Constitution. I fail to see why a thing should be condemned because it was introduced by the British Government to this country. That may not necessarily mean that such a thing is bad or injurious to this country and I think we could take many a leaf out of the British book without damage to ourselves. I always thought that P.R. was an act of the Irish people and we are told that it was supported and endorsed by no less a person than Arthur Griffith. I cannot reconcile the Taoiseach's statement that P.R. should go because it was imposed on us by the British with his action in retaining it in the Constitution in 1937. That does not make sense to me. I am satisfied, regardless of Government speeches on the matter, that the present method was introduced because it represented the express wish of the Irish people at that time.

It is contended by the Taoiseach and his colleagues that the direct voting system tends to elect a Government which will represent the majority of the people. When one examines the position in Britain in relation to the last ten general elections, one finds that in only two of these general elections did the elected Government represent the majority of the people. In eight out of those ten elections a minority Government was returned in Britain. The same can be said of the operation of the system in Canada.

We in this country have had no experience to go by with regard to Governments elected under the direct voting system and we are stepping into the unknown when we attempt to change the present method. If the single vote system operated in this country at the present time we could have, as a result of a general election, the Fianna Fáil Party receiving 35 per cent. of the total votes, the Fine Gael Party receiving 34 per cent. and the Labour Party 31 per cent. I have left out individuals and others Parties and am just taking the three largest Parties for convenience sake.

If those figures obtain at a general election, under the direct voting system it would mean that Fianna Fáil would be elected though they would not have a majority vote. They could not claim that they represented the vast majority of the people because, in that particular instance, 65 per cent. of the people would have voted against them and only 35 per cent. for them. Therefore, I fail to see how a change to the direct voting system will attain, as the Government contend it will, a Government that will represent the vast majority of the people.

The Taoiseach claims that the present system leads to multiplicity of Parties. My comment on that, as already expressed by other speakers, is that a man should have the right to stand for any Party because, when we consider the matter properly, it is the individual, the individual candidate, who counts and not so much the individual Party. I contend that if good men are nominated to stand on behalf of a small Party, even an insignificant Party, they should at least have a reasonable chance of election. I am afraid, however, that if the present system is abolished such men will not have as good a chance of being elected to Dáil Éireann and, indeed, the Dáil could be the poorer as a result.

Small Parties will be considerably handicapped if we change to a direct system of election, because in single member constituencies you will obviously have the big Parties nominating their respective candidates and, whilst at the present time we have representatives of small Parties in this House, if P.R. goes they will not have a chance of even being nominated. They may have a chance of being nominated but that will not be of any use to them because, obviously, the members of the two large Parties will defeat them overwhelmingly. Further, such men will have no chance of being nominated by either of the two big Parties, should they merge with them, because already the two Parties have their own sitting Deputies, and I am sure these Deputies will be very loath to stand down.

It was also claimed by the Taoiseach that the present system makes for irresponsible government. If we follow that statement to its logical conclusion Fianna Fáil, I think, must admit that is a reflection on their previous terms of office, and also on their present term. They have been in power from 1932 to 1948, for 16 years; they are back in power once more and, in the light of the statement that the present system of election makes for irresponsibility in government, in my opinion they stand self-condemned. We have often heard Fianna Fáil claim that they represented the majority view of the people but it now seems that they are not a responsible Government and that the people have been fooled all down the years because the Taoiseach has said that the present system leads to irresponsibility in government.

The Taoiseach did not say that between 1932 and 1948. He did, however, claim that Fianna Fáil was a responsible Government, but it now appears from his speech, and from the speeches of those who support this measure, that they are condemning themselves. Fianna Fáil are a Government elected under P.R. and thus are an irresponsible Government. In spite of common knowledge to the contrary, a knowledge which I believe is fully shared by the Taoiseach himself, we are asked to believe that countries like Switzerland, Denmark, Belgium, Norway and Western Germany are not progressive because they use the P.R. method of election. That is a rather ridiculous claim on the part of those who support this Bill.

We are also told that the present system of election leads to instability in government but I fail to see how that can be. Again, Fianna Fáil stand condemned because they were elected under P.R. and they have a majority of approximately 17 members at the present time. Surely a Government which has a majority of 17 over all Parties cannot be termed unstable? To say that the present Government is unstable at least appears to be contrary to the facts since they have that majority of 17. When the results of the last general election made it known that Fianna Fáil had been returned to power with a majority of 17, the Government then declared to all and sundry that they were a stable Government, and they were going to do this and that to solve the problems of unemployment and emigration. They said that they represented the vast majority of the people, and that they could go forward in confidence to solve all the problems which they might meet during their tenure of office, but now they say they are unstable because they have been elected under the P.R. system.

It has been said throughout the country, and by many people in my own constituency of Louth, that this measure has been introduced to provide for the rainy day when the Taoiseach retires, a day which probably will not be too long delayed. I am not suggesting that he should retire. I am not suggesting that he has lost any of his efficiency, but I am saying that it has been put forward that this measure has been introduced to provide for the rainy day when he will no longer be present to lead his Party or his Government. He says that P.R. is no good because it leads to instability but, at the same time, he forgets that at present he holds the position of Premier in this country, the position of Taoiseach, as a result of an election held under the P.R. system.

With regard to this point of stability, we have heard many speeches during the past year or so by a number of Ministers, and in particular by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, on the subject of attracting foreign industries and foreign capital in order to solve our unemployment problem. In those speeches the one point most emphasised was, of course, the fact that we had stable government here in the Twenty-Six Counties. It now appears that those speeches were not correct, that we have an unstable Government because it has been elected under the P.R. system, and that system must now go because it leads to instability in government. It is all very confusing. We have only to refer to those other countries which I have enumerated to realise how baseless is the Taoiseach's argument on that point. I do not think Fianna Fáil would admit they are an unstable Government.

It seems to me that the Government imagine that all our economic ills and troubles will be cured, if we revert to a direct method of election in the future. It must be admitted that there is no automatic panacea for our economic problems. There is no system of election which will automatically ensure the proper solution of those problems. It is not so much the system of election which should worry us as the type of Government which is elected. If we change to a direct method of election, I fail to see how the Government will be in a more secure position to implement the £100,000,000 plan which was recently referred to by the Government. Are they not strong enough now to carry out all their promises as they said they would? They have a strong majority and reverting to a different method of election will not improve the position, so far as our economy is concerned.

No system of election can solve our problems; no particular system can ensure the election of a Government that will do so. It is not so much that a different system of election is needed as brains and efficiency. I contend that these attributes can be found equally in small Parties as in large Parties.

It appears, too, that history is about to repeat itself when we consider the 32 Counties as a whole. When the North of Ireland was gerrymandered many years ago to the detriment of the Nationalist minority Fianna Fáil were loud in their condemnation of that action, and rightly so, but how now can we view with patience and indifference a contemplated action of the Taoiseach which may very well result in depriving minorities of the same right of election under a new system as they have under the P.R. system?

I fear we are going to walk hand in hand with the Six Counties in this regard. We recall on an occasion like this the many statements made by the Taoiseach when he reiterated his oft-expressed opinion that Partition was one of our outstanding problems. It appears that he is not so convinced now because if a direct voting system is the future method of electing Governments in this part of the country, there will be little attraction held out to our friends over the Border to unite with us as one nation. In reply to that argument, the Taoiseach contends that minorities could get representation by merging with the majority. We have only to refer to the set-up in the North of Ireland to realise how ineffective that statement is because we know for certain that the minority in the North of Ireland are not satisfied. Is it now contended that the Nationalist minority should merge with the Unionists so as to have proper representation in the Six Counties?

Fine Gael are opposed to this Bill because it represents a threat to small Parties. In the amendment put to the House by the Leader of the Opposition, it is suggested that a commission of experts should be set up to examine the ineffectiveness of the present system. I do not claim that the present system is an infallible one and that it is the absolutely correct one; neither do I agree that the one being put forward as an alternative is the proper one to have. I object especially to this Bill because there has been no real demand for it from the people.

There was a general election last year and on no occasion was this possibility referred to. It was never said by Fianna Fáil that they were seeking support for the next five years and that if they got in, they would promise to do away with the present system of election and revert to the direct method. That was never said and I fail to see how the Taoiseach can justify his contention at column 996, Volume 171, No. 8 of the Official Report of 26th November, 1958, when, referring seemingly to the demand for this measure which was evident to him at least, he said:—

"It has been suggested that there has been no public opinion, no voice asking for this. All I can say to the Leader of the Opposition is that, if he thinks that, he must have had cotton wool in his ears from 1948 to 1951 and 1954 to 1957, because everywhere I went through the country, everyone I met wanted to know when were we going to get rid of that system which was going to ruin the country."

That was stated by the Taoiseach on the Second Stage. Of course, the Taoiseach refers to the period from 1948 to 1951 and the years from 1954 to 1957—very significant years because during those years Fianna Fáil were not in power. I wonder was there any demand between 1932 and 1948, while the Taoiseach was going through the country, for the abolition of this system? It was not ruining the country, it seems, during those years. It was ruining the country only while Fianna Fáil were out of office.

I heard speeches in the Dáil many times since I came into the House in 1954 and on no occasion have I heard it suggested up to the present time that P.R. should go and that it was not a satisfactory method of election. I may be wrong in that, but at least I have not heard those speeches or read about them. I am afraid that the Taoiseach's experience of a demand for the removal of this system is shared by very few.

Reactions have been felt throughout the Twenty-Six Counties as a result of this Bill. In my own constituency, the people believe that there is an ulterior motive lurking somewhere behind the whole set-up. The reasons given so far are not accepted by many people; they are not accepted by me. I am at least a little bit suspicious. Fine Gael and the other small Parties are united in their opposition to the measure and they are confident that the people will reject it as being worthless and unworkable.

In passing, I should like to say that it will not only be the Fine Gael supporters, or the Opposition supporters in general, who will vote against this measure. I am convinced that many Fianna Fáil supporters will say no to the referendum because they realise that it is a bad measure and that it may possibly be the means of removing their favourites from office. It may be, as Deputy Booth said, that many Fianna Fáil faces will not be seen in the House, if this measure goes through.

P.R. has been with us for the past 38 years. That is an important factor when it comes to assessing the merits and demerits of the system. It is the system we know and, as Deputy J.A. Costello said, we are approaching the end of an era in political life and no one knows what undercurrents and repercussions there might be when the Taoiseach retires. I suggest it would be safer and wiser to leave things as they are—at least for the present. I am satisfied that the present system prevents landslides of a reactionary nature. As I say, it is the traditional system of election, and, as the Taoiseach himself said, it is the system we know.

The Minister for Defence referred to the system's complexities and said it was rather cumbersome and that people did not understand it. I agree that people do not understand the theoretical working of it, but they know it gives everybody a proportionately equal chance and they are used to it. They know what the Nos. 1, 2 and 3 mean and they know that "No. 3" may have a voice in electing a candidate and that "Nos. 5 and 6" may equally play their part, even though they may not be too well versed in the theoretical and mathematical aspects of it.

I do not say that there are no defects in the present system because under the P.R. system a candidate could head the poll and yet be defeated eventually. He could fail eventually to be elected and that actually did happen in the last election in the West of Ireland, where a man headed the poll on the first count and subsequently was eliminated. Equally, a candidate right at the bottom of the poll on the first count could be elected, if his colleague in the same Party headed the poll with a very substantial surplus on the first count. There is a seeming paradox there. The person who is first on the first count may be eliminated while the person who is last may be eventually successful and be elected.

There are these seeming paradoxes under the present system and again I refer to the amendment which suggests that a commission of experts should go into the whole matter rationally and objectively, and thrash out the matter in an effort to solve these little idiosyncrasies in the present method. Equally, if we change to the direct method, we have anomalies because a candidate could be elected, even though he represented only a minority of the people. For example, if there were three candidates contesting one seat in a constituency in which the total poll was 20,000, Fianna Fáil could get 8,000, Fine Gael 7,000 and Labour 5,000 votes. That would mean that under the direct vote system the Fianna Fáil candidate would be elected because Fianna Fáil got the greatest number of votes. Yet they have 4,000 votes less than the overall total of 12,000 who voted against them. It is with the object of reconciling these anomalies and defects in both systems that we suggest a commission of experts should be set up to examine the position.

I should like to inquire what would be the position regarding the Presidential election and local authority elections. If we are to have different systems for the various elections—for local authorities, for Dáil Éireann and for the Presidency—it will be very confusing for the people. Again, we must consider the future Seanad elections. No reference, as far as I can recall, has been made to what method will apply in future to the election of Senators.

It is claimed by Fianna Fáil that they represent a cross-section of the people. That may be so. I suppose every Party contend that they represent every section, that they do their best agriculturally, industrially and every other way, for all sections of the people. Fianna Fáil claim that they represent labour, the trade unions, agriculture, industry, commerce and business and every other aspect of the community, but it is very significant that the Seanad, as has always been said, is composed of vocational groups. The statement made by Fianna Fáil that they were the Party representing all sections of the people and, therefore, should be the only Party that should govern the people, is a false claim. When the Taoiseach is replying, I hope he will refer to what system will be used for Seanad elections, for the Presidential election and for the local authority elections.

With regard to the commission for the revision of constituencies, I notice that provision is made for the appointment of seven members to act on this commission. I do not see any provision for the filling of vacancies. If a member of this commission resigns for any reason, or is removed, there is no mention at all in the Bill of that vacancy being filled and no mention of any method for filling a vacancy. That is a very grave omission because if seven members— naturally it must be an odd number for the commission to come to some kind of a decision—are considered to be the proper number, surely the number must always be seven? If there are seven at the start, there should always be seven sitting on the commission in order that the commission may arrive at a proper decision. I presume that that omission will be rectified. I hope it will be rectified because I think it is wrong that these vacancies should not be filled, if they occur.

As regards a decision on the eventual boundary line for the constituencies, I fail to see how there can be a stalemate, if there is an odd number examining the question. How could there be equal numbers voting for and equal numbers voting against, if there are seven? I am mentioning that because it is said that the chairman will submit his report and it will be conclusive and final and will be acceptable to the President. If the other six members of the commission fail to agree amongst themselves as to revision of the constituencies, it will be left to one man to draw up a scheme of new constituencies. That will be a thankless job for one man, no matter who he is. He will be criticised by both Parties. I think the work should develop on the commission as a whole and that it should not be left to one individual, to the chairman of the commission. Of course, it is to be noted that the Government are open to suggestions on this matter, and I hope they will reconsider the position in that respect and amend it accordingly.

Much has been said about the cost of this referendum. A figure has been given of £80,000 and I assume that that is the cost only of the Government expenditure which will be incurred. I wonder is it the total cost? Does it include the cost to the local authorities who obviously will have to go to a lot of expense in arrangements for booths and paying fees to polling clerks, presiding officers and so forth? Again, would it not be better to hold the Presidential election and the referendum on the same day, in order to eliminate expense and duplication, not only of expense but of trouble and inconvenience generally?

In conclusion, I should like to say that it would suit the Government and the Dáil better if more important matters than this issue of the referendum were tackled first. What the people want is not so much a different system of election as more secure employment and an improved standard of living. That is all they want—issues relating to bread and butter. That is what they are most interested in. They are not interested, to my mind, in the method of election, but they are interested in a Government elected democratically by the people which does its best to implement the promises it makes during an election compaign.

We have at present 65,000 unemployed and we were told 60,000 emigrated in the past year. I cannot see how a different method of electing a Government will reduce the number of unemployed or stem the tide of emigration. I am satisfied that the Government have a strong enough majority at present, and are stable enough to attempt to solve these problems. I do not say they can solve them. No Government can solve all the problems with which it is often faced, but the fact that this Government have been elected under the present system of election, the P.R. system, which is now condemned by the Government elected under that system, is the greatest argument against the Bill.

Comment on this