An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 146–275 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
I had hoped, optimistically maybe, that this important measure would have been debated in a somewhat different manner from that in which it has been debated in the past few weeks. I had hoped it would be debated in a non-Party and constructive fashion, as I have pleasure in saying Deputy Coburn has debated it. Unfortunately many things have been said here in the course of the debate which, to my mind, only tend to cloud the issue before us.
We have heard allegations of presumption, arrogance and dictatorship levelled against the Fianna Fáil Party, because they have brought this measure before the House. It is hard to understand on what grounds these allegations are made. Presumption and arrogance are alleged because the people are asked to give a decision on a matter of national importance or on something which the Government consider is of national importance. It is not as if this House were trying to bring in and pass a law which would deprive the people of rights or privileges.
Deputy Coburn said that Fianna Fáil did not go before the electorate in 1957 and tell them they intended to abolish P.R. Fianna Fáil did not have the power to abolish P.R. It is the people who make the decision and Fianna Fáil are going to the people and asking them for their decision on the matter, at a time when they think it is opportune to do so. It is the duty of the Government to take such a course, in a matter of such importance, a matter that will influence the future of this country. It has been inferred that we should not mould the future of the country, but surely any reasonable person will not suggest that we must not take precautions to see that whatever pitfalls are before us are removed, in our time, from the future, if at all possible.
Then, of course, we have the allegation that Fianna Fáil are trying to set up a dictatorship. I believe any intelligent man who makes a remark like that is talking with his tongue in his cheek. Our Constitution lays down, that after a certain number of years, the Government must go before the people for a decision as to whether they have done their job well or have carried out the tasks entrusted to them as they should.
In this case Fianna Fáil are asking the people for a decision and an honest decision. It has not been a characteristic of dictatorships, to my mind, to consult the people at all. I cannot for the life of me understand how a charge like that could be made by people who have a responsibility, at least to those who elected them.
I much prefer to deal with the future than the past but it seems to me, if I have to refer to the past, that if we go back to 1948 we find that Fianna Fáil had been about 16 years in office and the people were seemingly willing and may be anxious for a change. But where had they to turn?
I submit if they had confidence in the Fine Gael Party, which I take it was the principal Opposition Party, they would have given a mandate to Fine Gael to form a Government. It has been said, and maybe with some truth, that they did not give a mandate to Fianna Fáil, but surely they did not give a mandate to any other Party at that time.
I feel that if the abolition of P.R. were carried out, it would mean the growth of a strong Opposition Party who could put their policy before the people and the people would have an alternative at election time. It is in the nature of democracies that they do not leave any one Party in office all the time; if they can find a better Party, they are willing to change after a number of years.
I feel also that if P.R. is retained, it will lead to a multiplicity of Parties. That is my view, and I think a multiplicity of Parties leads very often at least to a dangerous situation. We all realise, or should realise, the frailty of human nature and if small Parties can form a Government, there is bound to be jockeying for position and bargaining for power. I suggest that without charging anybody with any ulterior motive. That position does not lead to stability. A senior member of the Opposition Party spoke here about their own experience when they were an inter-Party Government and said they had twice to go before the people because of circumstances outside their control, because a small section deserted them or betrayed them, or changed their allegiance, and for no other reason whatever. At any rate, whatever emerged, the inter-Party Government vanished and they had to go before the people again. I suggest that does not give stability. I realise, of course, that no system is perfect. There are two sides to every story and a case may be made in theory at least for the P.R. system.
It seems to me that however desirable it may be to have all shades of opinion represented in Parliament, it is far less important than having a Party in power that can govern. It may be necessary or desirable to have several interests represented, but it is more desirable still, and essential for the country, to have a Government which can govern and which can put an employment policy before the people.
As I say, the question the people are to be asked to decide is a simple one: are they in favour of single-Party Government or inter-Party Government? Recently, within the past 20 years, they have had experience of both and they should be able to make a wise decision. I have more confidence in them than a great many Deputies. I believe they will make a wise decision and I shall be content to abide by any decision they make. It should not be in any way denied that it is the people who will make the decision.
I have been listening here, I am sorry to say, since I came into the House, to speeches by various members on the other side about Fianna Fáil having earned the wrath of the electorate for all the sins of omission and commission they have committed during, and since, the last election— they deceived the people about the food subsidies, broken promises, emigration, unemployment and all the rest. We have heard all that time out of number. To my mind, our time has been wasted in this House. Why should there be any anxiety now to keep this from the people? You cannot have it both ways. If we are in so much disgrace and if there is so much resentment against us, then the obvious thing is to let the people decide now and they will take a decision in favour of those who spoke so honestly and so vehemently of their own opinions.
Somebody has mentioned the cost of the referendum. The cost, and I do not mind what it is, is small compared with the cost to future generations of being unable to elect a Government that can give them stable government. Nobody can count or estimate the cost of instability of government in a country or what it will lead to eventually.
I admit and state that I got my seat in this House through the system of P.R. I would not have got in otherwise. Nevertheless, I am sincerely and honestly convinced that it is a bad system. I have been convinced of that for many years. I have been convinced that it is not as good a system as the direct method of election. I also feel that it is the most important question to be put to the people since the Constitution was put before them in 1937. Certainly, I am not in the slightest bit worried as to whether or not my face appears here in the future. If it does not, I have no doubt but that there will be a better representative. I am sure that the last thought of any honest representative would be the safety of his seat as against the common good. I hope that the last thought of any Deputy will be his own interests at the expense of the people being deprived of the opportunity of adopting a system of election that will give them an honest Government. Bear in mind that that Government would put their policy before the people and would come back again in five years' time to accept the verdict of the people. Then, if they had not done well, they would have to make way for another Government.
Comment on this
My opposition to the Government's proposals is based on a belief that they are likely to lead to conditions in this country comparable with conditions in countries which have a one-Party Fascist State. They are likely to lead to a decline in parliamentary government in this country and to dictatorial and unrestrained government.
The risks involved in the proposals which the Government are sponsoring are great. The reasons these risks are being run are inadequate. Over the past few weeks, various reasons have been put forward by Government spokesmen as to the desirability of introducing a change in our electoral system. Any analysis of what has occurred in this House clearly demonstates that the one reason the Government have brought forward these proposals is because, on two occasions within recent years, the present system of election caused them to suffer electoral defeats.
It is to my mind manifest that the dislike of the inter-Party Governments has so warped and clouded the mind of the Taoiseach that he is incapable of forming a rational judgment on the system of election which made possible the formation of the inter-Party Governments. I have said advisedly "the mind of the Taoiseach" because it is of some consequence in discussing this matter to recall that not one of the people who have spoken in this debate, with the exception of the Taoiseach, has ever spoken before in public condemning the system of P.R.
At not one Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis, except this year, have resolutions been passed against the system of P.R. At no general election was it made an issue. In the 1954 General Election the Irish Times, by a questionnaire, asked the present Taoiseach, the then Leader of the Opposition, whether, if returned to power, he would abolish P.R. His answer was: “P.R. is not an issue in this election” and he added that his views on the subjects were well known.
P.R. was not an issue in the 1954 election. It was not an issue in the 1957 election. Not one of the Deputies who have come into the House and spoken against P.R. ever, to my knowledge—and I challenge them to prove it—made a speech against the system of P.R. That is why I said that this proposal emanates from a decision arrived at personally by the Taoiseach.
Within the past two months, for the first time since the Government was formed last year, the Taoiseach said that P.R. should be abolished and that he would discuss the matter with his colleagues. Other reasons have been put forward in the course of this debate against the present system of P.R.—reasons which, to my mind, are fatuous, irresponsible and fundamentally dishonest. The Minister for External Affairs, like a backward schoolboy who has learned the wrong lesson, keeps repeating that P.R. was imposed upon us by the British. P.R. was accepted by the Irish people in the Constitution of 1922. It was inserted in the draft Constitution by the present Government in 1937 and accepted by the people when they passed the Contitution of 1937.
Equally fatuous, to my mind, is the argument, again propounded by the Minister for External Affairs and taken up by some of the back benchers of his Party, that P.R. is likely to lead to dictatorship in this country. He points to this danger by reference to conditions in Italy in 1922 and conditions in Germany when the Nazis came into power. The answer to that argument is twofold. In the first place, the Fascists got into power in 1922 in Italy and in 1931 in Germany. Notwithstanding this, the present Government inserted and copper-fastened P.R. into our Constitution in 1937. In the second place, I think the Italian and German people are the best judges themselves of what occurred in their own country. I think the German people would be wise enough to know it P.R. made possible the emergence of Nazism in Germany and would not have written it into the Constitution adopted in that country after the war. I think the Italian people, with their violent anti-Fascist feelings after the war, would not have written P.R. into their Constitution if P.R. were responsible for bringing Fascism into Italy.
There are theoretical arguments for and against every electoral system. One of the theoretical arguments that can be put forward against P.R. is that it leads to instability in government. The Taoiseach never mentioned that argument when moving the Second Reading of this Bill. It has been an argument very little used here for very good reason. We have had no more general elections in this country since 1922 than were held in Great Britain under the single member constituency system. Under P.R. our Governments have been just as stable over the period of the last 36 years as Governments in Great Britain were under the single member constituency system. The real reason— indeed the reason which is not hidden by the members of the Government and their supporters, the reason paraded here by them—is their dislike of Coalition Governments.
Some of the spokesmen here on behalf of Fianna Fáil asked us to believe that they are sincere in their opposition to the P.R. system of election to the Dáil. I am perfectly prepared to accept there are some members of the Fianna Fáil Party and of the Government who have now been persuaded by the Taoiseach that the P.R. system is not a good one. But if they are sincere, I want them to examine one aspect by which they have arrived at their judgment. The opinion of the Government and its supporters on the system of P.R. is based on their political judgments of the work of the two inter-Party Governments. Because they believe those Governments were failures, they believe that the system of government which elected them is a bad one. Let me repeat: these are political judgments, forged in the heat of Party battle, and if that is the basis on which a judgment is based, I submit it is very difficult to see how that judgment is an unbiased and unprejudiced one.
Sincerity is not enough. I am sure the Pharisees were sincere men; you must also be right. On a subject of such vital importance as this, on proposals which are likely to have very serious consequences, it is not sufficient to say you are sincere in believing that the present system is wrong. It is necessary to examine the basis on which you have arrived at a decision. Because the Government has specifically stated they oppose the P.R. system because it creates Coalitions, it is manifest that this judgment on this issue is biased and prejudiced and that it is impossible for them to arrive at a final decision on a subject that has such considerable political content.
In discussing the merits and demerits of the P.R. system of election, it is relevant to point out that there is only one democratic country in Europe that has the single member constituency system. That is the United Kingdom. Of all the democratic countries in the world, only a small minority have the single member constituency system, such as the Government is now proposing. The other countries of Western Europe—small countries such as Denmark, Luxembourg, Belgium, Holland, Norway and Sweden and larger and more powerful countries like Western Germany and Italy—all have systems of P.R. Even Australia, whose Parliament is part of the heritage of British rule, is not based on the same system of government as pertains in Great Britain. The Government is trying to suggest that this country should adopt a system of government which only a minority of democratic countries has adopted.
The reasons why, in the last 30 years or so, P.R. has come to be accepted as a fair system of election are very obvious. The system under which the British Parliament is elected is a system which is likely to lead to, and has in fact led to, dictatorial forms of government. It is a system which is likely to result in, and has in fact resulted in, Governments with a minority vote in the country obtaining a large majority of votes in Parliament. In other words, it is a system which gives unrepresentative Parliament. Earlier to-day, Deputy O'Higgins quoted figures for the South African elections in 1948 and 1953. I do not intend to repeat those figures. But experience in South Africa has demonstrated that it is possible and likely for a Government to be elected with a minority vote in the country.
It is perfectly true that in recent years, in England at any rate, there has been a fair balance in the two-Party system, that Governments have come and gone, that Parliament has remained stable and that democratic institutions have not been endangered. I do not think there is much use in our looking abroad to try to find how different forms of government are elected and how electoral systems work in other countries. Like other speakers, I believe we should examine our own affairs here and draw from our own experience.
As the British system has been held up to us as an example, we have to bear in mind how and why the British system, which has not worked well in other countries, has worked in England. It is for the simple reason that, for hundreds of years now, the system has developed in Great Britain. You now have there, which you would not have here, the tradition of single-member constituencies, some of which return Conservative members to Parliament and some of which return Labour members to Parliament, no matter what Government is in office or what candidate the Party concerned puts forward. These traditional Labour and Conservative seats have so enabled the Government and Opposition to be maintained that the number of seats that can be regarded as marginal is quite small. No matter what shifts there are in public opinion, there is still a large and effective Opposition Party in the country. We have not got those balancing forces in this country. We have not got the traditions Great Britain has for working this most difficult and dangerous system of government.
There are other disadvantages flowing from the British system which it is desired our people should now accept here. Anybody who has any knowledge of the manner in which English politics work knows the great power of the local political organisation in choosing candidates for election. The real power in the choice of a member of Parliament very frequently vests in the local political machine and not in the people. There are constituencies in Great Britain in which, it is admitted by many writers on political affairs, the people will vote for the Conservative candidate no matter what his status is; and there are constituencies in which the people will vote for the Labour candidate, no matter what his status is. The real tussle at election time is not at the polls. It is not in the election campaign. The real tussle rests in trying to get nomination from the Party machine before the election.
Under our system the local constituency executives select the candidates to go forward, subject to control from the centre in some instances. But, at any rate, the people in the constituencies have an opportunity of choice as between the various individuals put forward by the different Parties. One of the grave disadvantages, if these proposals now put forward are accepted by the people, will be the growth of the power and influence of the Party machine in this country. I have said that the danger I see in these proposals is a breakdown in our normal system of parliamentary government. Our system of parliamentary government will break down if there is no effective opposition. Government spokesmen have stated that they wish to see an Opposition Party formed and an alternative Government available to the people so that the people could choose for one Party as against another at election time.
It is important to remember that we are not discussing this matter in a debating society. We are not discussing it in a vacuum. We are dealing with the flesh and blood realities of Irish politics in 1958, with the Fianna Fáil Party in power and the opposition to it coming from the Fine Gael Party, the Labour Party, Clann na Poblachta, Clann na Talmhan, Sinn Féin and a number of Independents. If the Opposition Party, to which reference has been made, is not formed and if this Government goes forward at the next general election, having passed successfully these proposals, there can be only one result. These proposals, if put into operation, will mean that the people who get a minority vote in a constituency can be elected. These proposals will mean that the Party which gets a minority vote will be able to get a majority of the seats in Parliament and I foresee as a very real danger the emergence of a very strong single Party and a very small Opposition.
Power corrupts the best Party, and election defeat disheartens the most valiant souls in opposition. Power takes power to itself and, in this country, with the traditions which we have, I see it very difficult to carry on effective opposition if, in fact, there is only a handful of Deputies in opposition here. I see it very difficult to have an alternative Party available at all if one Party, with all the power and the influence that people think a Party in power has, will be in office for five years. I fail to see how an Opposition Party of small numbers in the Dáil will get the support from people to offer themselves as candidates. I fail to see how an Opposition of small numbers in the Dáil will get the subscriptions from the public necessary to carry on a political organisation. I fail to see how such a Party will be able to maintain itself adequately in the Dáil and carry on parliamentary government for five years in face of a Party, with not just an overall majority but an overwhelming majority. These are possibilities in the near future.
They are also possibilities in the more distant future because, as has been pointed out here by several spokesmen, one of the disadvantages of the British system is that where you have not got the built-in balancing forces, which the British have built up over the years, this single-member constituency system, by which members can be elected on a simple majority, leads to violent swings. It is perfectly legitimate for us, debating this subject now, to look into the future to see what possibility there is of a violent swing in favour of some unconstitutional group which, for one reason or another, may have made itself popular with the electorate. Such things have happened in other countries. They could happen here.
Some Deputies have stated that there is only one issue before the Dáil at the present time and that the Opposition are, in fact, hindering a democratic process in debating this subject at all. It is suggested that we are standing in the way of the people in debating here the merits and demerits of this measure, and that this is a matter for the people to decide. Such a view demonstrates a very poor and low opinion—a low opinion—which I believe some members of the Government have—of the functions of Parliament. It is our duty to see that this Dáil is the national forum for public discussion, and that matters decided at Party meetings are not just steamrolled through Parliament. It is our duty as an Opposition to inform the people through the medium of the public Press of the dangers we see inherent in these proposals.
If there is even a modicum of truth in the fears we have of what may happen in this country as a result of the change in the electoral system, then these proposals should be dropped. The very fact that these dangers, to which I and other spokesmen have referred, exist and have, in fact, been experienced in other countries is reason enough for dropping these proposals, even though circumstances in the future may not produce conditions so disastrous as we now think are possible.
The danger that we see is a real one and the justification for bringing in these proposals is inadequate. I am satisfied that if we can explain to the people effectively, by means of the public Press, the very real dangers which the abolition of P.R. may, in the peculiar circumstances here in Ireland, bring to us in future, these proposals will be rejected. We have, I think, been fulfilling a task of national importance in debating here for the last three weeks the measures, proposed by the Government for inadequate reasons, which are likely to produce conditions in this country comparable to those existing in Fascist States and conditions in which the very existence of parliamentary government will be threatened.
Comment on this
My main objection to this Bill is the time chosen for the introduction of a measure of such importance to the future of this country. This measure has not been properly thought out by the Fianna Fáil Party or else they are not in sufficiently close touch with the people. If they were in close touch with the people, they would not introduce this Bill at this particular time when we have passed through one of the worst years, as far as the farming community and the agricultural industry are concerned, almost in living memory. My main objection to the Bill, therefore, is based entirely on the timing. I have other various objections, and I support the many Deputies on this side of the House who spoke against the Bill.
I can see that, if this Bill is presented to the people in its present form, it will give rise to a certain amount of irritation and to unnecessary expense. I issue a timely warning that it will, in the long run, cause friction and unhappiness in the years to come and in, perhaps, the not too far distant future. I have heard no solid reasons from the other side of the House for the abolition of P.R. One need not go outside this country to express an opinion on the utility or serviceability of the P.R. system. I shall not make comparisons with other countries. I have been in this House since 1943 and, in my opinion, P.R. has served its purpose very well.
The only reason I have heard adduced from the other side of the House for the abolition of P.R. is that the system is cumbersome and gives rise to multiplicity of Parties. I do not at all agree that it is a cumbersome system. I think it is a very fair and democratic system and the people of the country have been sufficiently educated in the system to carry on under it for the next number of years. The people understand P.R. thoroughly.
As far as the production of multiplicity of Parties is concerned, I do not see much harm in that. As a matter of fact, I entirely agree with it. Deputies on the other side of the House think the Labour Party serves no useful purpose in this House, that the Clann na Talmhan Party serves no useful purpose here and that the members of these Parties must be liquidated or put out of the House. If that is the intention of the Government, the more courageous way to tackle the problem would be to bring in an emergency Order and to say: "These are illegal and unnecessary organisations." That would be a more courageous way of eliminating these Parties from public life. In my opinion, the numerous Parties we have had in inter-Party Governments served a useful purpose and represented a big section of the community. They should hold their place and be allowed to hold their place in our national Assembly.
I can see the growing danger of dictatorship. If this measure becomes law and by referendum receives the assent of the people, I can see we are heading straight for dictatorship. God forbid that we should be heading in that direction because it would be a bad day for the country when we would have a dictatorship. As I have said, I have heard no sound or solid reason adduced by the members on the other side of the House for this measure and I am still waiting patiently. I have heard many speeches from the other side of the House but have yet to hear one concrete argument in favour of the abolition of P.R.
The leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party, particularly the members of the Government, must be completely out of touch with the people in rural Ireland. This Bill is highly unnecessary. In the early stages of the debate, three weeks ago, people down the country were taking it in a calm and cool way, not looking at the serious side of it, but, as time went on and as the Opposition Parties began to expound their opinions as to what the abolition of P.R. meant, the people began to wake up and I find in the country at the present time—and I am speaking very sincerely now—not alone among the opponents of the Fianna Fáil Party throughout the length and breadth of the country but among Fianna Fáil supporters, a spirit of resentment and irritation aroused by the introduction of this measure.
Had this measure been introduced at any other time, say, after a good and prosperous year, there might be some justification for it. Have the Government considered the plight of the country at the present time? Have they looked at the unemployment figures? Have they considered the disastrous results of a bad year for wheat production and for the production of other crops? Have they studied the emigration figures?
This measures has been rushed unnecessarily. I give sound advice to the Taoiseach, who is wholly responsible for the introduction of this measure. I would censure him. If in future years the consequences of amending the Constitution and abolishing P.R. militate against the welfare of this country, I shall certainly lay the blame on the shoulders of the Taoiseach for having introduced this measure.
This is a dangerous measure and I think quite a number of people will agree that the abolition or elimination of small Parties from the House is not good. What will happen to these Parties and the people they represent here? Do the Fianna Fáil Party not know that they will create a spirit of uneasiness, that there will be an uprising against such treatment of minorities? Do they not know that—I hope it does not happen—those Parties who have been deprieved of representation here may join some underground movement, and, in their irritation, resort to hostile measures to enforce their right to representation? I can see that happening; I know it is coming, but God forbid that it should come. Perhaps in their saner moments and after this week particularly, when the views of the Opposition have been put clearly and lucidly across this House to the members of the Government, there is still hope—perhaps I am over-optimistic—that the Taoiseach in his wisdom will withdraw this Bill from the House forthwith.
I am issuing a solemn warning and I am basing my views on the opinions I have come across in the past week or ten days. I know the people of the country are resentful and irritated by the introduction of this Bill and at some not far distant time—it may be very soon—that resentment may grow to immense proportions and give the Government a very unpleasant time. The Taoiseach on occasions is quite a moderate man. I must give credit where credit is due. For many years, he has been a great figure in this country and his time is passing. At this stage of his career, is he going to throw a blight on everything that he has done for the past 30 years? Is he to retire—we must all retire some time through death or otherwise— and perhaps see everything good he has done being undone by some revolutionary movement that may arise here? I say that in his saner moments he should consider this.
Some people say that the straight vote in a single seat constituency is most suitable for this country. I entirely disagree because I cannot see how minorities will get any representation. I can prophesy now that should this Bill go through, some day or other there will be no Opposition in this House. That can easily be managed and I shall tell you how. Where you have a Party, any Party, with plenty of money and newspapers behind them which can provide plenty of propaganda, I say that they can carry an election and secure a majority, not a substantial majority, but a sufficient majority in this House, to enable them to eliminate anything in the line of opposition. This may lead to corruption in elections. I have no hesitation in saying that, because a strong Party, in the case of a single-member constituency, may get certain people to stand for them, knowing quite well that these people will not be elected. But they can split the vote of the Opposition Party, with the result that the strong Party will benefit. That could happen—I am not accusing any Party of being so corrupt as to employ such tactics but we must remember we are not all saints in this country.
I am totally against this measure and everything I can possibly do up and down the country, in my own constituency and outside it, as far as I can travel, to induce the people to vote against the abolition of P.R., I shall do. I advise the Taoiseach in his own interest and the interest of his Party, and particularly in the interests of this country, not to hesitate to withdraw this measure from the House at once.
Comment on this
I have listened carefully to the debate and read the contributions from both sides of the House, and I have studied the different reasons advanced pro and con. In many instances, Deputies stated they were not satisfied with the present system. They know it has been a freakish system, giving freakish results, and one of the main things they have learned from their experience of Coalition Governments is that they might get a "lucky-dip" Government. They do not know what kind of Government they will get, as a result of a combination of different political Parties or groups getting together after, but not before, an election. Practically every speaker I have heard to-night referred in one way or another to the weaknesses of this system as we know it. There was the extraordinary case mentioned by one Deputy of the fate of the former Deputy Mannion from Connemara who, although he headed the pole, was not elected. That is one of the results one can get from this freakish system when one compares it with the straight vote.
When we talk about minorities, it is clear that under this system there is a tendency to give minorities the power out of proportion to their numbers and what they represent. We have had some extraordinary examples of that under coalition government here and if Deputy D. Costello wants to suggest that I, or the Party, should not use our experience with coalition government here as a reason for abolishing this system, he completely misunderstands this Party's whole attitude to the system of P.R. One of our reasons, and in fact that reason that is freshest in our minds, is the disastrous effect brought about by this system in providing this country with coalition government and the results of coalition government.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present.
Comment on this
It is precisely because of our experience of Coalition Governments produced by the system that we know exactly what we are talking about. We have seen extraordinary political somersaults brought about by small minority groups in Coalition Governments. We have the extraordinary position of the traditional Commonwealth Party completely reversing their oars as a result of the action of a few people who were in a Coalition Government. We had the then Taoiseach announcing in Canada the repeal of the External Relations Act and reversing not only his own policy but the policy of his Party over many years. I can well remember Deputy Mulcahy in the years before the war freely advocating an offensive and defensive alliance with Britain.
Comment on this
I remember Deputy Mulcahy, before the war, advocating, in this House as part of our external policy that it would be wise to have an offensive and a defensive alliance with Britain.
Comment on this
It does not seem to be relevant but it is the stock-in-trade of the Government Front Bench.
Comment on this
We have these people who called themselves the Commonwealth Party reversing their policy at the behest of two or three people who had come into the Coalition Government. Whatever other effect it may have had, one thing it proved to all and sundry—what the present Taoiseach maintained, of course—was that this country, since the passing of the Constitution in 1937, was a Republic. However, this operation went on over in Canada at the behest of a very minor minority group in that set-up, which is an indication of how minorities brought into a Coalition Government can reverse engines and make major national decisions although the number of people they represent throughout the State is negligible.
Comment on this
We stated at all times that in a two-line Bill we could repeal the External Relations Act. Fine Gael were saying we were living a lie, that we were still in the Commonwealth and were not a Republic, but it remained for their period of office to prove that what we said was correct because in a two-line Bill in this House we did repeal the External Relations Act. At all events in dealing with this constitutional change, we shall not go out to make any announcements in Canada. We are making them in this House and the Irish people will be able to judge one way or the other whether the system we have, which has now been in operation since 1922, is to be accepted or rejected.
I should like to quote from the speech on this measure of the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello. At column 1024, Volume 171, of the Official Debates of the 26th November, 1958, he made this assertion:—
"I object most strongly to having any hand, act or part in trying to mould the future of this country. I object strenuously to the horrid phrase ‘the foreseeable future'. There is no such thing. But we are reaching out our hands under this proposition into the future and trying to impose our will upon the people of the future. We are doing that in circumstances in which we have not the remotest idea of what conditions will be when this proposed system comes into operation a few years hence."
The former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, strongly objects to our trying to mould the future of our nation in this Parliament. I should have thought one of the primary duties of Parliament in a democracy would be to mould the future of our nation, to lay down a solid foundation for that future. One of the primary tasks of Parliament should be to ensure a bright future for the nation. In any case, it appears that Deputy Costello will not have any hand, act or part in moulding the future of this nation.
In organising our society we must think very carefully of the foundation on which it should be laid. One of the most important things, as far as our future and our parliamentary institution is concerned, is to have a proper basis for it, a stable and reliable basis. I think it is clear to practically all thinking people in Ireland that P.R. never worked satisfactorily here, that it always led to crises. Even as far back as 1927, when it was possibly first tested here in Parliament, a Government had to hang on by the casting vote of a chairman. It was not until this very last election, when the people were driven to desperation, that they came out and gave a solid mandate to us to get rid of Coalition Governments. The people having given that mandate, it is obvious that the system that leads to Coalition Governments must go.
Deputy McGilligan wished to prove last night that this Party never got a majority of the votes cast by the electorate. If Deputy McGilligan is right in that argument, that we have never got a majority of the votes cast although we have been the largest Party in the House, surely that is a very strong argument in favour of the abolition of P.R.? It must be a cracked system if, right down through the years with the exception of two periods, the Fianna Fáil Party got control of the Government on a minority of the people's votes. If Deputy McGilligan's argument on that score is correct, it is obviously an argument which proves that there is something fundamentally wrong with the P.R. system as it has been practised here. There have been different P.R. systems in different countries to which I shall refer briefly in a moment, but in so far as it has worked here up to the present time, it has worked for certain reasons which will not be recurring reasons as far as one can judge.
There were very special reasons why the system worked here at all. The system worked here because, going back to the pro-Treaty and anti-Treaty days, the country was mainly divided into two large groups. These political associations tended to bring into this House two large Parties and were it not for that, P.R. would probably have founded here much earlier than it did. You had the pro-Treaty and anti-Treaty groups which gave us the two-Party system with some very small splinter groups in the early days of the history of this State.
There were certain other major issues which tended to get the people to give a strong majority to one particular side. You had the fighting of an economic war here, when we were engaged in an economic struggle with an outside people. That is something that will not occur again.
Comment on this
The Deputy and his successors are quite free now. They will never have to pay those annuities again as a result of the fight we fought. That struggle tended to show the people the direct road and for that reason the people, in that major national issue, rallied behind the leadership given to them from this Party. You also had the return of the ports, the passing of the Constitution and our neutrality, which was promulgated before the war, and which was agreed to by practically everybody in this House. You had all these issues which tended to make the people make the best of the P.R. system as they knew it. All those issues are now past. In addition, this Party and this nation had the outstanding qualities of leadership of the present Taoiseach down through these years. If it had not been for that it might well be that this system of P.R. would have foundered long ago.
Does anybody in this House who was present at the counting of votes understand the P.R. voting system? Does 90 per cent. of the electorate understand this system? Somebody on the opposite benches said that the people come out of the polling booths and ask for directions as to Party affiliations. How many people who watched the counting of votes will deny that many voters stopped having marked their first or second preferences?
Comment on this
It is because I think the people are intelligent that I am prepared to leave the decision to the people. Because they are intelligent, I know that they will do away with this system which could become a millstone around the neck of our democracy. It is because I know that the people are satisfied that this has not been a good system that I am satisfied that they will get rid of it. I know that this is possibly not a very fair jury before which to put these arguments because in this forum there are many Deputies who have vested interests. There are very many Deputies who feel that, if we had a straight vote, they would disappear from this House and it is very hard to expect a completely impartial view from many Deputies when they feel that their own future is in danger.
However, surely the people opposite who have been so vehement in their opposition to this measure, if they are so confident in their arguments and their appeal to the intelligence of the people, should have no fears as to what will happen the referendum when it goes to the people. All these speeches that I have listened to remind me of the wailing wall of Jerusalem. All that and all the crying we have heard is a confession of the failure of the people opposite to get the people of this country to support their viewpoint. I should think, if Deputies opposite are so confident of the validity of their arguments, that there should be no need for all this obstruction. If they are so confident, they should take the view that the people will have a chance to decide the issue and say to themselves: "The people will throw out the proposals by an overwhelming majority."
This much is true. The direct vote has worked in the two great democracies of the present day, in Britain and the United States of America. It has worked, and worked successfully, in these two countries. It is true that Deputy Dillon stated here that the Americans are only a polyglot people and that what might suit there might not suit here. That is an argument that will not cut any ice with anybody. Where you have democracy working and working successfully it is doing so under the straight vote.
Let us see what happened to a number of countries which, before the war, had one form or other of P.R. and where democracy failed from within as a result of that system. There were Italy, Germany, Austria, Bulgaria, Greece and Yugoslavia and to a certain extent Latvia, Czechoslovakia and Roumania. Note what happened in all these countries. Under the systems of P.R. which they had, there grew up a multiplicity of groups which gave disruptive elements a foothold to work from the inside and thus destroy their institutions. That is what happened in these countries and what led to dictatorships in these countries. The mess in which these countries found themselves in those days, and in which some of them even still find themselves, was due to the system of P.R. which they adopted.
We see what happened in France in recent times. The situation was quite clear and is still fresh in our minds when, only a couple of months ago, nobody reading the papers could gamble overnight as to whether there would be a civil war in France or not. There was a situation in France which made a visit to that country like a visit to London and walking down Whitehall to see the Changing of the Guard, except that one went to Paris to see the changing of the Government every second night.
Comment on this
It was as a result of the P.R. which they had there that they got into the mess that they were in.
Comment on this
And as a result of that, their nation was virtually on the brink of civil war when they resurrected General de Gaulle to get them out of the trouble, and he is making no mistake about what he is doing under his new Constitution and his new system of election. In view of these experiences, and taking the States where this system in one form or another worked, it has not worked successfully in any country. It has brought disaster in its wake in many countries, and it is because we want to be sure that disaster will not come in its wake in this country that we decided to let the people make up their minds, and give them the opportunity, having heard both sides of the case, of deciding whether they should retain the system or reject it.
Some Deputy said he thought it was an inopportune time to introduce this measure. I think it was Deputy Beirne, of the Clann na Talmhan Party, who said that after a bad year it was inopportune to talk about things like this. I gathered from the Deputy by implication that possibly if there were a good year, he might consider this. At all events, it would appear from the Clann na Talmhan amendment which is tabled that they want to get rid of the system as at present. That amendment reads:—
"Dáil Éireann declines to give a Second Reading to the Bill as it does not make provision in the proposed single member constituencies for voting on the system of P.R. by means of the single transferable vote."
Comment on this
I gathered from that that Clann na Talmhan want to scrap the system as we know it. They want single seat constituencies. That is the effect of their amendment. That is what Clann na Talmhan are suggesting the House should do, so at least we have one minority group in the House who are also sick and tired of the P.R. system as it works and who, I assume, see the dangers of it. At all events, they want to bring about some kind of change in that system.
We had an Independent Deputy speaking here who also wants the straight vote system. I think it was an Independent Deputy from Limerick, and he has made up his own mind and has given his own reasons as to why he wants it to go. Therefore, it would appear to me there is at least one minority group and one of the Independent members who want to change the system we have, no matter what we should get in place of it, some of them going further than others.
Under the new system that we visualise, we will have single seat constituencies, and some of the criticism that has been voiced here with reference to the present system has been that in some cases constituencies are very unwieldy and stretch over long distances. I happen to come from one such constituency and, on occasion, it is necessary to travel a distance of 90 miles from one meeting to another in the same constituency. From that point of view, the system is bad and unworkable. If there were a single seat constituency, a compact group and compact area, I believe the people would be better served and, under such a system, Deputies would be much more in touch with their constituents and with their businesses than is possible under the multi-seat constituency system we have under the existing law.
As to the opportuneness or otherwise of the time, we all know that, under the law as it stands, next year there must be a revision of constituencies, even under the old P.R. system and, therefore, I think this is a most opportune time to examine the whole system and see whether the people should change it, amend it or retain it. I can visualise no more suitable time than the present. It is not necessary for me to stress the fact that, but for the result under the existing system at the last election, it would not be possible for an enabling measure of this kind to be given to the people so that they might have an opportunity to express their views. I have no doubt that if we had no Party in control and if we had a number of individual groups, for the reasons I have mentioned before, legislation like this could never pass through this House and, therefore, the people could never have an opportunity of stating whether they wanted to get rid of the system or whether they wanted the straight vote. At all events, they will get that opportunity now and we will see what the people who have had long experience of the operation of P.R., as we know it in this country, will do about it.
Of course, it is not true to state, as has been suggested by Deputy J.A. Costello, that this would be binding the country for all time. If at some future time the people want to change back, or change to some other system, the people will have the right to do so.
Comment on this
I thought it was quite clear to the Deputy, but it would appear it is not clear to his colleague, Deputy J.A. Costello, and I think it is no harm to repeat and emphasise such a very simple statement, that if the people want a change now and, if at any future time they want to change back, they are free to do so. He holds up his hands in horror at the idea of planning the future. If the people want a change in the future, they are entitled to make such a change.
Comment on this
So many smokescreens have been raised about this issue by some of the Deputies opposite——
Comment on this
——mainly I am sure with the idea of confusing the electorate who will have to deal with this issue, trying to terrorise them as to what will happen, that I want to let in a little light.
Comment on this
Irrespective of the source, I shall still insist on giving my views to the House and to the people I represent on what I think of P.R. as it exists in this country.
Comment on this
And the people, no doubt, will give their views when they get the opportunity which they will get under this Government.
Deputy McGilligan attacked the procedure laid down to deal with constituencies, or the creation of new constituencies, under this measure. In fact, Deputy McGilligan set out to talk about everything and anything which was not before the House or which was not in this Bill. I am quite sure he did that with a purpose. He proceeded to talk about everything from the White Paper on economics to the policy of Fianna Fáil Governments back over a long number of years. That, again, I take it, was for the purpose of trying to throw dust in the eyes of the people and divert their minds from the real simple issues involved, upon which the people will get an opportunity of voting.
He attacked by innuendo, if not by direct implication, the Supreme Court and High Court judges and the way they were appointed. He also "had a go" at the President, Seán T. Ó Ceallaigh, as to how he would operate under this Bill.
Comment on this
Did it occur to Deputy McGilligan that his colleague, Deputy MacEoin, might be very annoyed with his attack last night? It appears to me that it will be the new President of Ireland who will exercise the functions under this Bill. It would appear extraordinary to me that Deputy McGilligan should think so little of Deputy MacEoin's chances of the Presidency that he still talks about what originally appointed Fianna Fáil Presidents might do with the powers conferred on them under this measure.
The whole suggestion was that in an issue of this kind the judges would be venal. Indeed, he followed the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, who said at column 1030, Volume 171 of the Official Report:—
"...That is all I have to do. I will appoint CD, who is a tool of the Government in power, who is what the late Kevin O'Higgins would have called a legal careerist, who got his job on the bench because he was the lickspittle of a political Party. That is the system supposed to give us impartiality and supposed to create public confidence in this whited sepulchre, the commission set up under this Bill."
So we are informed by Deputy Costello apparently that the judges of the High Court or the Supreme Court would become lickspittles in operating the measure set up here. That is followed by Deputy McGilligan who said the same words in a different way in his speech last night.
I do not know what is the reason for that. The way the proposed commission will deal with these constituencies is set out very clearly. The judge, whoever he may be, will be appointed by the President, whoever he may be, after consultation with the Council of State. The Opposition will be represented on this commission by three people picked by the Ceann Comhairle, whoever he is at the time. The Taoiseach will nominate his own three to that commission. If there is any better way of getting an impartial tribunal in this country to deal with the division of constituencies, I should like to hear it from somebody, but I deplore the suggestion that any of the judges who have been elevated to either the High Court or the Supreme Court, no matter what their political colour or connections were prior to their elevation, should be abused in this way in this House and that it should be suggested they would not do their duty under the law when called upon by the President of Ireland to do so.
Of course, there could be another reason for this particular form of attack. I have always noticed that when the Fine Gael Party were in the political doldrums, some type of smear campaign started against some institution of State. They are now in the political doldrums and I assume this is the highlight and the starting point of the new smear campaign when they started to attack the people sitting in the High Court and the Supreme Court, and suggested they would be the creatures of the political Parties who were in power when they were appointed.
Comment on this
I do not think that the people who are now supposed to be so concerned with democracy and our institutions of State should have taken that line. Perhaps, on wiser consideration, even at a later stage, they might withdraw these innuendoes, if, as they profess, they have such respect for the institutions of State which have been built up here. Thinking about the institutions of State, I listened to Deputy D. Costello talking to-night about Fascism in different countries and my mind ran back to the time when the democratic institutions of this State were threatened by the Blueshirts.
Comment on this
The former Taoiseach proclaimed that the Blackshirts were victorious in Italy; the Brownshirts were victorious in Germany and the Blueshirts would be victorious here.
Comment on this
These are the people who now profess to have such respect for parliamentary democracy.
Comment on this
Speaking from these benches, I do not deny that part of the reason for our knowing that the P.R. system is a bad system is our experience of Coalition Governments in this country. The question was put by Deputy D. Costello, as to why P.R. was put in the Constitution in 1937. The answer is very simple. In the evolution of a nation, you can take only one major constitutional step at a time. When we were endeavouring to get that Constitution through it was bitterly opposed by all those Deputies sitting opposite and was misrepresented up and down the country. In every possible way they could, they tried to confuse the people. It was a sufficient burden on our hands to get the people to adopt that Constitution and shake off the shackles imposed on the nation. One great national goal was in sight. If at that time the issue of P.R. was also thrown in, it would still further confuse the issue before the people.
I remember during that campaign it was suggested to the women of Ireland that the new Constitution would mean a change in their kitchens and that they would never be let out. It is amazing that when responsible men come out with statements of that kind they will get a number of people to believe them. The fundamental aim, from the national point of view, was to get the Constitution through. If the Taoiseach at that time tried to change the system at the same time as he brought in the new Constitution, there would be the danger that the people would be so confused by the misrepresentation that the majority of them would not vote for it.
Let me say that as far as the P.R. system of voting is concerned it has proved itself after trial in this country to be a freak system. It has proved itself on trial to give the people, not what they voted for, but a lucky-dip Government with, perhaps, the tail wagging the dog instead of the dog wagging the tail. It has given this country instability and, in so far as it is our duty to provide a solid foundation for the future of this nation, I say to the people: "Let us adopt the straight vote which has been successful in the United States of America, where democracy has been working for a long time, as it has also been successful in England."
Comment on this
On a personal matter introduced into the debate by the Minister, I have never quibbled as to the importance to the economy and security of this country of British military strength but the Minister for some obscure purpose has stated—he put words into my mouth—that I proposed an offensive and defensive alliance for this country and Britain. I deny that I ever made such a proposal. The Minister has indicated that on some suitable occasion he will produce the reference and I wish to ask him when he will do so.
Comment on this
I propose to produce what the Deputy said. If the House is sitting to-morrow I shall secure it.
Comment on this
The Deputy has already made it and the Minister has stated that he will produce it to-morrow in the House.
Comment on this
I am very glad to have an opportunity of expressing my opinion on the measure before the House and I have no hesitation in declaring my opposition to it. If I were looking for a reason to convince me of its merit, I would fail to get one from the Deputies who have spoken on the opposite side. It is a strange thing to hear a Minister of the Fianna Fáil Government stating, as the Minister for the Gaeltacht has just stated, that P.R. is a freak system of election. It is very strange that after all those years have passed and after all the experience gained, both in Government and out of Government, it took Fianna Fáil until 1958 to decide that this system was unsuitable for the Irish people.
If I were looking for guidance in this matter I would prefer to go to the founders of this State. I shall quote from Arthur Griffith, the founder of Sinn Féin, speaking as far back as 1911. Nobody in this House, I am sure, will doubt the honesty, sincerity and national outlook of Arthur Griffith. In the Sinn Féin movement Arthur Griffith had with him many of the people associated with 1916 and 1921. We were engaged in a struggle for freedom for many years after many centuries of occupation and it fell to Griffith to devise some means, other than the British system, to elect people to represent this country.
In 1911 Arthur Griffith spoke as a member of the Proportional Representation Society of this country. He said:—
"P.R. secures that the majority of the elected shall rule, and that minorities shall be represented in proposition to their strength. It is the one just system of election under democratic government."
When Griffith got the opportunity of drafting the Constitution in 1922, he provided for P.R. Griffith, a founder of this State, and an associate of all those whom we honour and shall honour, no matter how time goes on, was clearly convinced when drafting the Constitution that care should be taken that minority groups should get just representation. He was mindful of the fact that in the northern part of this country there was the Unionist element who, for reasons of their own, were divided amongst themselves in many cases but, on the question of the independence of this country, preferred to remain attached to the British Government. Arthur Griffith naturally thought that people such as those should get due representation and he made provision for such representation in 1922. I think the ex-Unionist element agreed that they were not overlooked and provision was made for them in that Constitution, and rightly so.
That system obtained from 1922 to 1932 when there was a change of government and it still obtained after the change of government. When the Taoiseach came to change the Constitution in 1937 this was what he said about the P.R. system:—
"The system we have, we know; the people know it. On the whole it has worked out pretty well. I think that we have a good deal to be thankful for in this country; we have to be very grateful that we have had the system of P.R. here. It gives a certain amount of stability, and on the system of the single transferable vote you have fair representation of Parties."
What could be clearer than that? He approved of the P.R. system. Those are his words, not mine. These are also the views of men who have been closely associated with the national movement. Nothing could be clearer, to my mind, than the fact that this issue was considered, and considered very carefully, from time to time and under different circumstances. Then we had a change of government in 1948. That system obtained until the next election in 1951, when we changed again to a Fianna Fáil Government. Nobody said anything about it; nobody suggested any unfairness in it. I have been associated with elections all the time from 1937 and I have always found that all Parties had nothing but praise for that system. They considered it to be fair. It gave every fellow a chance and nobody need be afraid to go forward for election because he knew his friends and knew what transferable votes he would get from other Parties. In all sincerity, I think that is a very democratic way of giving people an opportunity to go forward for parliamentary election.
In 1954, Deputy Costello came into power again. At that time, the same system of P.R. obtained in both local and Dáil elections. In 1957, the present Government came back to power again, and now after one and a half years or nearly two years of Fianna Fáil government, suddenly, overnight, it has been decided that this is a freak system, a bad system of election. Every member of the Fianna Fáil Party who has spoken here to-night has re-echoed that it is a bad system. It is very strange that it took them all these years, from 1922 to 1958, to decide that it is a bad system.
People ask me what is all this about, what is the necessity for having this referendum? I will quote, for the benefit of the Dáil, the opinions of a number of people trained and versed in economics, who held a meeting in Dublin on, I understand, last Friday night. The meeting was reported in the Irish Independent of Saturday, December 6th. At the Economic Congress in Dublin of the Irish Universities' Societies' Association, Mr. D. Hamilton made this statement:—
"At a time when our efforts should be directed towards preparing the economy in the light of markets emerging in Europe and when a spirit of co-operation is essential to the achieving of this, the Irish people are again dividing over matters of nationalism and over the method by which our Government representatives are elected.
The emphasis here should be on developing our economy so as to alleviate unemployment and emigration.
He told the meeting that Irish people were noted for their lack of co-operative spirit and their distrust of their neighbours, which was evidenced by the poor response to the efforts of Sir Horace Plunkett, Father Finlay and others to develop the co-operative movement and also by the apparent lack of co-operation between the political Parties.
Mr. Hamilton said that the work of O.E.E.C. should serve as an example of what co-operation could do to increase economic welfare. Ireland, although a member of O.E.E.C., had progressed economically at a slower rate than most of the other member countries."
Comment on this
I gave that, because I want to say that in my opinion—and that is what attracted my attention— instead of discussing a Bill of this kind, we should be discussing unemployment and emigration. These are the matters that should be engaging our wholehearted attention, and there should be no question of the House being divided now, after an election held exactly one year and nine months ago, in which the people gave their decision and decided that Fianna Fáil were entitled to be the Government of this country for the next five years.
I should much prefer to be discussing these problems I have mentioned than discussing P.R. It is unfortunate that a matter like this is engaging our attention instead of unemployment and emigration. As Deputy McGilligan stated, the population of my city—I represent Limerick—is 52,000. When one realises that that figure corresponds exactly to the number of unemployed people and that the city of Cork has a population of 60,000——
Comment on this
The Deputy is well aware that the question of unemployment does not arise on this Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that a Labour amendment dealing with these matters was ruled out of order, and I cannot see how the Deputy is relevant in referring to them.
Comment on this
I merely want to say that the population of Cork City, which is 60,000, is equivalent to the number of people leaving this country every year, and I shall not continue on that line any further. I am glad to have had an opportunity of saying that the problem we should be considering is not the abolition of the system of election which was given to us here by the founder of this State, who said it was a fair system. In the words of the Taoiseach, it has been a fair system since 1937.
Why the decision to abolish P.R.? We all know that for some months past the Fianna Fáil Party have been holding meetings, and at those meetings the decision to abolish P.R. was discussed. I assume—I have no reason to know what goes on at these meetings—that they discussed the proposed boundaries. Maps may have been produced—I do not say they were because that has been denied—but P.R. was discussed, and it was decided at that Party meeting, and brought forward to the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis to be endorsed, that the Party would agree unanimously to the abolition of P.R.
Why that decision was arrived at I do not know, but it does strike me, and I was asked by several people, why is it being pushed on the country at the moment? People asked me is it not a fact that Fianna Fáil have an overall majority and practically three years of government to run. They are a strong Government; they claim to be a stable Government, and they can make that claim. In these circumstances, why annoy the people at the present time with these matters when other problems are more pressing?
That is a matter for which my constituents have asked for an explanation. I have no explanation to give because none of the Fianna Fáil speakers has given me any clear indication that the intention of the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party is other than to hand down as a legacy to his Party the government of this country. We naturally ask has the Taoiseach lost faith in P.R.? If he has, he must swallow his words of 1937. It is quite evident that the Taoiseach is more concerned with Fianna Fáil ruling in this country than he is with the Constitution.
Another explanation many people give is that at election times when Fianna Fáil go around canvassing, they never mention the names of the candidates. They just announce themselves: "We are de Valera's Party." I think there is something in that. If he retires and goes out of office, Fianna Fáil candidates can no longer say they are de Valera's men. They will have to say "Johnny Murphy or "Johnny Ryan", or whoever they are.
Comment on this
These are the reasons why I assume this P.R. Bill has come before us. That is why we are asked to make a decision. That is why the Irish people are being divided now in an election; it is called a referendum but it is really an election. For these and for many other reasons, I do not think it is fair to the people that a Government who have been elected for five years, and who have an overall majority, should come along and disturb them at this time. Another matter has been mentioned and made little of. We think very little now of £1,000,000. It will cost £80,000 at least—perhaps much more—because the Party machines will have to pour out money and the Party with the most money will get the most support in relation to this referendum.
The question has been asked: "Why be afraid of small Parties?" Is it not a fact that we have had all down the years in this House Parties representing various interests? We have a Farmers' Party, even though they may number only three or four here. There are Independent members, some of whom do not wish to be associated with any Party. They are entitled to be in this House and they hold independent views. I know that this House has had sad experience of some Independents because one never knew what they would do. They proved themselves political weather-cocks, more concerned with stunting, when it came to having influence on any particular Party.
We have a Labour Party here who represent a very large section of our community. The Labour Party represents all the organised workers in this country and they are entitled to be in this House. I definitely say that they are so entitled. I have been associated with Labour in Limerick and I have always found myself in happy company. I found that the Labour Party had the proper approach. I found that the men in it had a deep interest in our civic life.
I fail to see why this Bill is being brought before this House to liquidate the Farmers, the Independents and Labour. You might say to me: "There might be some very popular man who will be elected." It is evident that the system of election now proposed—and I believe it is the opinion of Fianna Fáil—will increase the number of Fianna Fáil representatives in this House. I think the intention behind this Bill is to get that increase.
Here is another fact which concerns me. About 20 years ago, Fianna Fáil, in reorganising the constituencies in this country, brought in 22 three-seat constituencies. As we all know, if Fianna Fáil could get about 51 per cent. of the votes in those constituencies, they would get two seats. They have succeeded fairly well in doing that, but they have not succeeded as well as they might have liked because, in getting a majority in some of those constituencies, the Labour Party, Sinn Féin and Fine Gael have got seats as well. They now fear that those Parties may turn the tables on them. They now feel that the position in the 22 three-seat constituencies may react against them and so they have brought in this system under which every county will be divided into single-seat constituencies.
Let us examine the position in Limerick. At present we have seven seats—four in East Limerick and three in West Limerick. I understand that under the Bill we may have a constituency of 20,000 people or we may have a constituency of 30,000 people— 20,000 minimum, 30,000 maximum. If that be so, it is possible that Limerick may be divided into six single-seat constituencies. Then a situation will arise when the four or five Parties who contested these elections on previous occasions may find themselves with a majority of votes but still beaten by a minority vote.
Suppose four representatives in Limerick go for any constituency in the city or county and that one of them gets 28 per cent. of the votes and the three others 24 per cent. each. Then, without any other count, the man with 28 per cent. is declared elected and the three Parties who each got 24 per cent. of the votes or, in all, 72 per cent. of the votes, are not represented. I ask anybody if that is a fair system.
Are the Farmers, the Independents, the Labour Party and Sinn Féin not entitled to try at the election? Are they not equally entitled, with all other sections, to have a candidate or must we now go back to the old days when it was the man with the money who was elected in this country? It may be that some system of that nature is being brought our now. It may be that small Parties are not even to get a chance to know how they would do in any election. Surely that is unfair.
On the other hand, if Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour contest a seat, and the Farmers and Sinn Féin are cut out, a man with 28 per cent. of the poll is still elected. Suppose that a man gets 36 per cent. of the votes and that the others get 32 per cent. each. Then the man with 36 per cent. of the votes is elected and the two candidates who, between them, got 64 per cent. of the votes are eliminated. That is an unfair system. That is why I read the quotation from Arthur Griffith who, in serious times in the history of this country, gave it as his opinion that P.R. was a just system. That was endorsed by the Taoiseach in 1937 but it is rejected by him in 1958.
Is it not clear that there is a motive behind this proposed referendum? Is it not also clear that at every election you will get constituents who will vote only for their own Party? They are "plumpers" for the Farmers, Indepents, Labour or Sinn Féin. That happened in Limerick. In all the elections I have been in, I have seen all these Parties represented and I feel that to deprive these people of the opportunity of going out and voting in and election is not a fair system of election. It is much better to let these people come out and to let them find out their own strength. If they find their strength is not what they thought it was, then they have no grievance. It is a very unfair system to deprive anybody of the opportunity of going out and exercising the franchise. I am sure some of those people will not vote at all in an election if the straight vote system is brought in.
I cannot understand why the Fianna Fáil Party and the Taoiseach are now so wedded to the single-member constituency. Is it not a fact that they have been telling us all these years about the gerrymandering in the North? Is it not a fact that we were told, in respect of two or three counties there, that, if they had a proper system of election, they would vote themselves out of Northern Ireland?
It is very unfair for the Taoiseach to come along now and swallow all the things he has been saying over the years. This country should aim at the unity of all sections and creeds. Amongst our countrymen in Northern Ireland we can find many good Irishmen to give valuable service to this country. But if we are to adopt this system, I believe many of our countrymen in this part of the country, not of our Faith or political way of life, will resent not being given an opportunity of partaking in either local or parliamentary elections. It is true that the remedy has been suggested: "Join one of the Parties." Many of them have told me they would not like to join any Party. But they have come into our local councils and have given valuable advice and help. We are always very glad to have them represented on our councils.
Why is this change being brought about? It is quite clear that the 1948 election proved that an alternative to Fianna Fáil could be found. Is it because of 1948 and 1954 that the Taoiseach has now decided he will make it impossible for the people to come together in the national interest to form a Government? Many people have talked about France, Belgium, Germany and other continental countries. As the Taoiseach once said here: "It would make a cat laugh." The comparisons I have heard here would make a cat laugh. Here is a country of 3,000,000 people being compared with countries of 30,000,000 or 40,000,000 people who have a different way of life. We all know this is a thinly populated country, and each section has to be small because of the character of our everyday life. The farmers, for example, are entitled to come in here as an organised group and it would be a tragedy if Labour were not represented also. Labour are entitled to be here; they should be here and they are making a contribution to the national economy.
In regard to the commission to fix boundaries, we have been told there will be three Fianna Fáil members, three members of the Opposition selected by the Ceann Comhairle and a chairman. That may appear to be all right, but you can take it that the three Fianna Fáil members will have their cards marked for them. The chairman will be appointed by the President. We all have respect for the President, but we know he was a member of the Fianna Fáil Party. We feel he will probably select as chairman somebody who, like himself, has given service to that Party. We cannot help feeling that that chairman will be disposed to the point of view of the three Fianna Fáil members.
Comment on this
Could I point out to the Deputy that the President's appointment will be on the recommendation of the Council of State?
Comment on this
I am quite well aware of the Council of State, but the President may or may not accept their advice. I do not want to pass any reflection on the President, but that position is quite clear. My own City of Limerick will probably be divided into two. If it suits the three Fianna Fáil members to have two seats in Limerick City, they will do so. On the other hand, they might take 10,000 people and put them in with the rural area.
Comment on this
I never interrupted Deputy Booth and I do not want any advice or interruption from him. If I am to give an alternative I want to give it here. I stayed in the House yesterday and to-day to get time and I am not delaying the House. Anything I have to say, I will say it straightforwardly. I object to cross-examination by Deputy Booth. Not alone is he cross-examining me but he is cross-examining other members of my Party. It seems to me he is playing somebody's game here and I object to it.
As a member of a local authority, I am entitled to ask is P.R. to be abolished in local elections? This matter is not in the present Bill, but it is logical to assume that if P.R. is a freak system in parliamentary elections, it is equally so in local elections. I should be very disturbed if the Government proceeded to abolish it for local elections. If this Bill is passed, I do not believe that Government can have two systems of elections. That would be illogical. If we are to abolish the P.R. system in local elections and go back to the wards and single members, we are going back to something we got rid of—the ward system which brought about the ward heeler and all associated with him. As a member of the Limerick Ratepayers' Association——
Comment on this
If this referendum is passed and the Government are empowered to pass legislation for elections on the basis of single seat constituencies——
Comment on this
I have allowed the Deputy to say that, but to discuss what may happen through mere hypothesis is certainly not relevant.
Comment on this
I bow to your ruling. Sir, but this matter is a fear in the minds of the people in Limerick City. We have been hearing from various people that strength and stability are very necessary for the country. We all agree, but we know that the consequences of strong government can be disastrous for the country. The dairying farmers and the wheat farmers have good reason this year to know the effects of strong government. The people who have to make the most of their weekly wages know the effect of strong government; it is reflected in the price they have to pay for bread, butter and flour as a result of the last Budget. These are the matters that concern the people. These are the matters we will have to put before the people when we come to advise them as to how they should vote on this referendum.
There are at the moment four elected representatives to this House who do not sit in the House. It would be a tragedy if this Bill were to exclude them from any opportunity of being elected to the Dáil in the future. Rather than condemn them too much, we should devote our best efforts to trying to induce them to come in here and serve the country in a constitutional way. None of us has any regard for violence. It does nobody any good. I would prefer to wait 50 or 100 years for a united Ireland rather than achieve it through bloodshed. Many of us fear that, if those young men are denied the opportunity of seeking election to this House, they will resort to other methods to further their aims. They are, I suppose, enthusiasts and, if they feel that things have been so arranged as to prevent their election, they may adopt other measures to further their aims.
I have always advised Sinn Féin supporters in my constituency—good friends and good neighbours that they are—that their methods are the wrong ones: "You are going the wrong way. You are damaging the national interest. This is not the way you would like your children to follow." From any point of view, it would be much better to have some system of election, such as P.R., to give them their chance of eventually coming in here. They will soon learn from experience. They will find out that the people are not with them and, when they do, they will be satisfied. If they are deprived of their opportunity they will feel that the big Parties have denied them something. I know this Bill will go through because the Government have a majority, but, when it goes before the people, I sincerely hope the people will give their answer in a decisive way.
Comment on this
I was down in my constituency over the weekend and the first question my constituents asked me was: "What is the motive behind this Bill or what is the necessity for a change from P.R. to the single member constituency and the straight vote?" I have been here for the past fortnight listening to the debate and I am still not clear as to what is the actual motive behind this. If the argument for it was that it would change the country and improve conditions for everybody, or something like that, that would be something. The Taoiseach in his statement said:—
"It has been suggested there has been no public opinion, no voice asking for this. All I can say to the Leader of the Opposition is that, if he thinks that, he must have had cottonwool in his ears from 1948 to 1951 and from 1954 to 1957, because everywhere I went through the country, everyone I met wanted to know when were we going to get rid of that system which was going to ruin the country."
I am sure the Taoiseach did go down on odd occasions through the country. I wonder what people did he meet? Did he meet the ordinary man in the street? I am sure he did not. He met those who have vested interests in Fianna Fáil and who expect patronage from Fianna Fáil. I wonder did he meet down the country any of the 12 big business men, any of the industrialists, who sent out the appeal for funds for Fianna Fáil in 1948 to help them fight the election then. These people knew what they wanted. They knew that, by returning Fianna Fáil to Government, they would get certain facilities; permits were necessary then for the importation of certain commodities because many of the emergency regulations were still in operation. For every £10 they subscribed to the Party funds then, they expected a tenfold return subsequently. I am sure it was these people the Taoiseach met because these people would, if they could, have no other Government but Fianna Fáil.
The Tánaiste asked: "If the people want the change, why should they be denied the chance?" Do the people want the change? That is the question. From whom did the demand for a change emanate? Was there any discussion in any public body in which it was stated the Government were not performing their duties properly and a change in the system of Government would lead to better government? Did even the most insignificant organisation or association pass any resolution asking for a change in the system of election? Many resolutions are sent up from various bodies throughout the country asking to have the roads made safer, asking to have people's lives preserved on the roads, but, as far as I know, there was never any demand from anybody for a change in our system of election.
The fact that it was proposed to change the system came as a bombshell when the news appeared in the Sunday Independent. Evidently the news leaked out and the political correspondent was quick enough to get on to it. That was the source from which the people learned that there was to be a change. If there was any sense of responsibility in the Government, they would have made a definite statement in the first instance and not have permitted the news to leak out from a Cabinet meeting or through the Party organisation. I do not think the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, any more than anybody else, knew of the proposed change until it appeared in the Sunday Independent.
Another question the people are asking is: "What is the point of putting the country to the expense of a referendum? In reply to a question here, it was stated that the cost to the Central Fund would be at least £80,000. I have no doubt that the total cost will exceed £250,000. Why should the country be put to that expense merely because one individual thinks it would be good for the country or good for his own Party?
At the present time the country requires stability and confidence, not turmoil and uncertainty. There is unemployment. Things have reached a very low ebb. Once there is even talk of an election, all discussion revolves around that and people will not settle down to work.
The case has been made by some Deputies that the straight vote would reduce the number of Parties. The Minister for the Gaeltacht said this evening that minorities get representation in the House at the present time out of all proportion to the numbers they represent in the country. I wonder is that a fact? Is he talking off the cuff or has he any proof that that is the fact?
In the 25 years from 1932 to 1957 there were ten general elections. The distribution of seats between the Parties was a very close reflection of the distribution of votes actually cast. Over the ten elections the average percentage of first preference votes gained by the various Parties was: Fianna Fáil, 45 per cent. of the votes and 48 per cent. of the seats; Fine Gael, 30 per cent. of the votes and 33 per cent. of the seats; Labour, 16 per cent. of the votes and 14 per cent. of the seats. "Others" got 9 per cent. of the votes and 5 per cent. of the seats. Could anything be fairer than that? The electors got representation within 2 or 3 per cent. of the votes cast for each Party. Is that not very fair representation?
Is it a fact that Fianna Fáil hope that by this change, in getting 45 per cent. of the votes they will get 100 per cent. of the seats? Is that the idea?
Comment on this
Apparently it is. They hope to be able to secure government by a minority vote. As I have demonstrated, the present system gives a very fair and true reflection of what the people want. It could not be any fairer under any other system. Every Party got representation within 2 or 3 per cent. of the number of votes they obtained. I do not think the Minister for the Gaeltacht was very sure of himself when he said that minorities get representation out of all proportion to the numbers they represent. According to the figures I have given, "Others" got 9 per cent. of the votes and gained 5 per cent. of the seats—less representation, proportionately, than either Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil or Labour. That completely answers the statement of the Minister for the Gaeltacht this evening.
Another case put up is that under P.R. people do not know how to vote and many papers are spoiled. Over the same period, the number of spoiled papers in the constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny in any election was about 1.1 per cent. That is a very small number allowing for the fact that some people designedly destroy the papers and others, possibly through being illiterate or excited, do not mark the papers properly. It is a very small percentage. It shows that the people have a very good grip of P.R. and know how to cast their votes.
The case has been made here by the Taoiseach that small Parties can put up an attractive programme. I wonder he did not blush when he made that case. Could any small Party put up a programme one-half as attractive as the programme Fianna Fáil put up before the last election? In Kilkenny I saw posters which said: "Wives, get your husbands out to work. Let us go ahead again. Just change the Government and the country will move along straightaway." The Tánaiste, when he was in opposition, stated that he was prepared to put up £100,000,000, a blue print for prosperity, and provide 100,000 jobs. How many jobs have they provided? They have a strong Government. One gets tired when there is a division in the House and the Government have a majority of 16 or 17 every time. What have they done? What results have we got from it?
The Government have now been in office for two years. We find that the number of emigrants is 60,000 and the number of unemployed 60,000. Apparently, the same thing will happen next year. There is this difference. Before the present Government came into office, men who were out of work went to England and sent home the wherewithal to maintain the family at home whereas now they bring their wives and families with them. They have lost confidence in the Government and in the country. That is the result of two years of strong Government. It is not two years of good Government. If we had good Government, that would be changed.
I attended a meeting of the corporation of Kilkenny last week. We were discussing special relief grants for Christmas. A prominent member of the Fianna Fáil Party said:—
"We must remember that we never had more unemployment than we have to-day and surely we would not miss the few coppers we would put on the rates to help towards relieving these poor, destitute, unemployed."
That is not a member of the Fine Gael Party speaking. That is a quotation from the Kilkenny People. That was said by a Fianna Fáil member of that corporation, a responsible member, who has been elected for over 30 years. I have no doubt that, if he thought things had improved under the Fianna Fáil Government, he would be the first to say it. He says: “Unemployment was never as high.” That is after two years of strong Government.
Comment on this
It is quite relevant because the Taoiseach stated that small Parties can put up an attractive programme as they will not have the responsibility of forming a Government. No small Party could put up as attractive a programme as Fianna Fáil put up before the last election although they knew that they might be elected and have the responsibility of forming a Government. These are the results.
I should like if the Ministers who have been talking here would tell us, if the straight vote system was adopted and if by obtaining 45 per cent. of the votes cast they obtained 100 per cent. representation in the Dáil, would they be able to give us some promise that we would come to prosperity? As far as I can see, the Government have just sat down since they came into office.
Comment on this
I cannot allow discussion of the economic position in the country on this measure. That has been made evident to every speaker who transgressed. I cannot allow a discussion in detail. I have allowed the Deputy to say a good deal on the economic situation.
Comment on this
I shall not proceed on that line. When this Bill goes through the House—and there is no doubt that it will go through this House, at least, because the Government have a majority to steamroll it through—the President will appoint the chairman of the commission that will be set up. As Deputy Carew said, we all have respect for the President and regard him as the President but we cannot overlook the fact that he was a prominent member, an ex-Minister, of the Fianna Fáil Party and that if he is appointing a judge to preside over the commission——
Comment on this
That depends on how long this Bill will take to go through. We do not know how soon the referendum will be taken.
Comment on this
We do not know. He is a former Minister of the Fianna Fáil Party and a very trenchant speaker on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party and I have no doubt that he would be bound to be influenced. He could not help it, to give him his due. Human nature being human nature, he could not help that.
Comment on this
Well, I think he will be there especially when the Taoiseach said that if we did not get through this Bill straightway we shall be called back on the 6th or 7th of January. It appears that you are trying to work it——
Comment on this
This is not an interruption. It does not matter if he is or even if somebody from this Party would be there.
Comment on this
Three members will be recommended by the Taoiseach. We know the type he will put on. Three members will be recommended by the Ceann Comhairle. But the point about this is that their decision, no matter what it is, cannot be challenged in the courts. They are above the courts. We know what can be and has been done about gerrymandering in Northern Ireland. We have the case of Derry City where there is a very large Nationalist majority and on the corporation there is a Unionist majority. The minority in the city has the majority in the council, and I have no doubt the same thing will happen here and that you will have gerrymandering. Whatever protestations may be made you are bound to have it here and the result will be what we might call dictatorship.
We have had experience before of Fianna Fáil in office for 16 years continuously, being re-elected Government after Government, and when they did not get a clear majority they went back to the country to get a majority because the people said: "We must have some Government." But we know the corruption that went on at that time. We know that if somebody got a permit or anything like that, the local secretary of the Fianna Fáil Cumann demanded £10 or £20 from him.
Comment on this
That is a fact and we know it. We know that if we had dictatorship here again, we would have a repetition of that because the people would say: "There is no hope of changing this Government." They would have to "cough up." My reading of the matter is that the Government feel they have lost the confidence of the country. They are afraid of any other Party coming in and they are even afraid of by-elections——
Comment on this
Why does the Deputy not allow his colleague to speak? Deputy Rooney has only come in and he is interrupting.
Comment on this
My suggestion is: why have a referendum? Why not go right away to the country? If the Government loses on the referendum question they must have an election; they cannot go on without the confidence of the people. If they win on the referendum they will also go to the country so that we are bound to have a general election in a very short time, although that has been denied by some Fianna Fáil speakers.
I would ask the Taoiseach and the Government to reconsider their decision and not put the country through this upset and turmoil in the next few months. If they want a vote of confidence or any reassurance let them have a straightforward general election and let the people show how they feel. But I know that the Government want to stay in power no matter what the feelings of the people are. We know by gerrymandering the votes what it is possible to secure under the straight voting system and the single member constituency.
Comment on this
Listening to, and reading the contributions from the Government side in support of this Bill one must conclude that the Opposition are opposing the Bill solely because we fear to face the people. That has prompted me to stand up here and say to the House that it is not fear on my part of the consequences of the referendum for me personally that moves me. I stand up to speak against the Bill because I honestly believe it will have serious effects on the social and economic life of our people. Why bring in this Bill at this time? The Taoiseach has said it is an appropriate time. Would the reason be that he is afraid he will not again get the chance from the people he got at the last election? After all, under P.R. at the last election a strong Government was elected which placed him in the position of leader and personally I can never understand why the Taoiseach, as Leader of that Government, should take advantage of the opportunities he got through P.R. to do away with P.R.
Before P.R. is abolished and before the referendum question is decided, undoubtedly the Government must put more concrete facts and reasons to the people prior to the people acting on what they have been told. We must remember that we are speaking to an intelligent people, people made intelligent by the things that have happened in this House and through their experience of what has been said in different constituencies, of promises made and never fulfilled.
In the past it was the general opinion —and rightly so—that the country needed strong Government, a Government which could at least put in their term of office and in that way have a good chance of putting into operation at least some part of the policy which they put before the electorate. We have a strong Government now and undoubtedly if the Taoiseach so desires they will complete their full term of office. It is for that reason that, I think, rightly or wrongly, at this time in the history of the country the Taoiseach should leave the question of P.R. alone. With the Government he has behind him he should take up the immediate problems confronting the nation.
Those are not problems which have arisen overnight. Unfortunately for the country they are problems which have been allowed to develop over the years until now they are endangering the very life-blood of the nation. As a humble back-bencher here I think it is time to stop this dilly-dallying about a referendum, or as to what way this Government or that Government should be formed. When the members of a Government are elected, they must do their duty by the people. They must forget about Party interests and work for the people who put them on the Government side of the House and for no other body.
In the Irish Independent of Monday last I read about the Minister for External Affairs going down to Wexford to commemorate, and I dare say celebrate, the 21st anniversary of the Constitution, to celebrate the 21st anniversary of a Constitution that this House has been rattling upside down for the past three weeks and which had solidly embeded in one of its Articles the provision that elections should be fought on the P.R. system, the system the people knew and understood. The very Minister who has been a Minister in that Government for 16 years of those 21, has told us here that it was the system of P.R. that has handicapped the progress and the onward march of this country and that if the system were not abolished it would do more harm in the future. I do not want to be too hard or critical but even a Minister of State can at times make a foolish statement. Undoubtedly that was as foolish a statement as I ever heard and, in fishing parlance, it is a bait to which the fish will not rise.
The manner in which Governments are formed in other countries has been argued. What does that matter to us? We have here a population of less than 3,000,000 people and it is dwindling day by day. Do you think they are worried whether it is P.R. or the straight vote we adopt? It means absolutely nothing to them because the time has arrived when the people do not care what Government are elected or whether they are elected on the P.R. system or the straight vote.
In conclusion, may I say to the Taoiseach, representing the same county as I do, he being the senior member for that county, that he should forget P.R. for the moment and tackle the immediate problems that confront us. He has a strong Government behind him, a Government put there by P.R., a system which he now wants to abolish. I should like him with the help of a constructive Opposition, an Opposition who are disposed to help in every way they can, to seek ways and means by which this country could be run at a lesser sum than it is costing the taxpayers and the ratepayers to-day.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I want to pass judgment on this Bill and on the circumstances in which it was put before the House. I sincerely regret it has been thought wise to introduce this Bill in the present condition of things throughout the country. It is obvious to everyone that this country is in the worst economic position it has been in over the last 60 years. I have been actively concerned in this country's affairs over that period and never have I known the country to be so badly off, economically and socially.
Never during that period, when this country was struggling for its very existence, was it in the depressed and the disillusioned state in which it is now. There was always hope and fight in the people. Now there is none, none whatever. My great regret about this House all over the years is that we made no effort to build up a tradition behind the House. The members of the House itself did not try to build up respect or tradition for the things done in the House. There has been no effort to make sacrosanct the traditions of the House so that the people in it and the people in the country will look up to it.
I do not want to refer to the condition of affairs in an adjoining country or to say that the method of voting there has brought about such and such a condition. My memory can go back to 1896 and I know what happened in that country. What has the straight vote brought there? Has it not brought the greatest landslides that could come under any system? Again I say that there has been no attempt made towards the building up of a tradition in this House. The whole policy has been that whatever one Party builds up when in office, the next Party will try to pull down. There is no respect for anything in this House. The young people are disillusioned and have no respect for this House or for any other institution in this country. I do not know when we are going to have respect for ourselves, for this House and for the Constitution of this country. We have a Constitution introduced one day by one Party and the next day the other Party sets out to tear it up, just like a lot of children.
We are in this House to-night ignoring certain factors in this country which are really the important things and which, in my opinion, should be a reason for the rejection of this Bill. There is no use comparing this country with other countries. In this country, there has been a hidden background all the time which has been a threat to the stability of the State. That is what annoyed me when I saw this Bill. It is aimed at a certain section and it ignores that condition of things.
There never was an election in this country since the State was founded that was fought on a policy. There have been nothing but slogans in our elections and there has been nothing said about policy. Should the young people who have come into politics since the time of Sinn Féin, who have come into politics since 1914, 1916 and 1920, not respect the memory of the men who brought them here?
They talk about P.R. being imposed on us by Great Britain. Nothing could be more untrue. P.R. was founded in this country by Arthur Griffith. There is an oil painting of him in the main hall. Does that mean anything? Should not this House build around that man, build around the tradition that he left in this country and around the work he did for us? There is no respect for his memory and no attempt to make sacrosanct the system that was part of the work of his lifetime.
Has there not been a continuous attempt since then, sometimes openly and sometimes concealed, to tear down the entire institutions of this State, to tear down the Government, if it could be done? Is that not the whole trouble behind the state of the country at the moment and is that not the real reason why there is no stability in the country itself or in the people in it? Now the young people are so disillusioned that they are shaking the dust of the country from their feet. What is the use of ignoring that?
I have given my whole life to trying to lay the ghost of religious intolerance in this country and here, in 1958, we find it being dragged out in this House. One might as well go back to 30 or 40 years ago in Belfast on 12th July. Can we not concede that here we have a country for all of us, irrespective of the colour of our skins or where we worship on Sundays? I have lived with Protestants, and was reared with them, and spent a long part of my life in Belfast and I have never had any word of one kind or another with my Protestant fellow citizens. Deputies will appreciate how grievously I regret to hear this matter raised in this House in 1958.
P.R. is not the issue in this. The issue in this is that there is now an underground body in this country, and, if you attempt to stultify them by passing this Bill, it will make them all the more energetic. I have heard talk of a strong Government. Is the whole thing not a joke? This Government has the numbers. It should be a strong Government, but is it? Are the events taking place in this country at the moment the fruits of strong Government? Are they not the fruits of the weakest Government we have ever had in this country? A Government with a majority of one would be better. Governments should not be strong; they should be good. Citizens nowadays do not know where they are or what is going to happen to them. No citizen of this country to-day knows what is going to come out of the present condition of affairs and that condition of affairs has been caused by the inactivity of the Government.
That is the reason the young people of this country are deserting it. I am sorry to say it but, speaking from conviction and experience, and knowing what is going on, I must say that there will be huge tracts of country in which there will not be a solitary living being. They will be as deserted as in the days before Cromwell and Queen Elizabeth's troops came here. The tragedy is that they will not be so deserted due to any action of a foreign Government but due to the action of a Government of our own, elected by our own people, a Government returned with a sweeping majority, a Government that was to do this, that and the other thing. They have done so little and the people have become so disillusioned by their conduct and their broken promises that they are flying from the country. I have lived, and worked, and hoped in this House that under a native Government our people would excel those of any other country.
I am sorry, but I cannot avoid thinking that the real purpose of this Bill is to eliminate one Party, not a group of small Parties, and if that be its purpose, there can be nothing more inane. That is the very course that will add impetus to the drive of these men. Have they no support in the country? A band of them have broken loose and none of them has been arrested. What is the implication of that? Is it not that the community is in sympathy with them? Why has none of them been arrested? Do we not remember conditions like that existing in this country before? Did we not see that condition in the Sinn Féin days, through the Land League days, and through the days of the Young Ireland Movement? It is exactly the same picture to-day and we are sitting here as if in a home for imbeciles, talking as if everything in the garden was lovely, as if the roses were in bloom, and as if this situation did not exist at all. We had better sit up and take notice.
The Government swept into office in a land-side victory and it is said that could not have happened under the direct vote. Anybody who is old enough in this House can throw his mind back over the political history of the past 50 or 60 years in Britain, and if some here are not old enough to do that I am sure they have plenty of friends outside who can tell them about it. Do you not remember the Khaki Election of 1903, after the Boer War, when the Liberal Government swept into office? They were in office until 1906 and then they were swept from office again. Even the great Arthur Balfour, that brilliant Englishman, at times friendly to this country, at times unfriendly—he did good things for it but at one time he threatened, when things were not going so well so far as he was concerned as administrator of this country, that the resources of civilisation were not yet exhausted—lost his seat in Manchester under the direct vote system.
There are Deputies sitting here to-day who say that when P.R. is abolished we will get strong Government. They have been saying that for the past fortnight, and they are supposed to be educated men. Did they come in here with blinkers on? Were they born yesterday? Do they think we all came in with the last load of straw? Is it not disgusting that representing decent people, hard-working people, we should have to listen to this sort of thing for a fortnight instead of dealing with the affairs of those people whom we represent?
It is said the direct vote system will give us strong Government but what follows from that? I have been associated with politics for the past 60 years and I have never yet seen a Government that got a sweeping majority that was worth tuppence, and was not swept out of office at the next election. That sort of talk is pulling the wool over people's eyes. Because the people have no experience of that system, they may think they are being told the truth. It is not true. Nothing could be more untrue.
You can pass this Bill; you can get direct voting, but the same things will happen under it as happened under P.R. I have always been an Irish Nationalist, but not in its narrow sense. I am an Irish Nationalist in its broadest sense, and I do not want to say things which might embitter matters with reference to what has been said about bringing Protestants down here. It was said here to-night, by a Deputy from my own constituency, that the reason why the Protestants of Ulster would not come in here was that we have unstable Government, because of P.R. Was there ever such a futile statement made anywhere? I could tell that Deputy a few things, but I will not because I do not want to embitter matters. I believe in living in peace with my people, whether Protestant, Catholic, Sinn Féin, Fianna Fáil or anything else, and I am not going to break that practice. That is a faith with me and I will keep it. The Protestants of Ulster will not come in here because of P.R.—imagine saying that to my fellow Protestant citizens! That is not the reason why this Bill has been introduced—it is not the true reason.
Pass this Bill—go home and you have a victory. The House completely ignores this Bill; it does not know what it is about and it cares less. What does the woman with a family care about this Bill? All she is concerned with is the securing of something that will keep herself and her children until Christmas. She is concerned only with the price of flour being 6/- a stone and butter 4/4 a lb. That is the P.R. about which she is concerned, and what is the House doing about that? It has spent a fortnight or three weeks discussing this Bill and has not concerned itself with the welfare of the people at this period of the year.
The House has brought itself into contempt, and the time spent debating this Bill will bring the House into greater contempt. It will drive the young people of the country into Sinn Féin and let no one make any mistake about that. What hope have the young people when they see the conduct and behaviour of this House? What has this House done since the last election to improve their condition? For what have fathers and mothers sacrificed themselves trying to educate their children? Is there a Deputy who could get six jobs for six young boys who have left school? If there is, let him put up his hand. There is no reply.
It was stated that the direct vote would result in a better type of representative in this House. I consider that an insult to the Irish nation and people. Irish representatives are able to take their place among the politicians and statesmen of the world. This House represents a clear cross-section of the people. How did they get there? They were proposed at conventions and while they may be wrong sometimes, in the main, the results have been quite good. The Deputies elected to this House represents a good cross-section of our people. I say that honestly and if I went out of this House to-morrow, I would say the same thing. I have friends in every Party in this House. To suggest that a better type of representative would result from the adoption of the straight vote is a gross insult to the people in this House and to the people who sent them here—the Irish electorate. I am conceited enough to think that members of this House could take their place among the statesmen of the world.
For the reasons I have indicated, I protest against this Bill. I am convinced that its real purpose is to sidetrack the people to whom I have referred and who are not represented in this House. They are fundamentally wrong. I tell them that they will never conquer Ulster by force. I stated here before, when there was a challenge in this House to use poison gas, I would defy them to do it.
Is it the purpose of the Bill to drive the people out of this House into a body which is illegal, which is unlawful and which has as its purpose the overthrowing of the established order of things in this State? Is that the motive behind this Bill? Does anybody ask himself whether that is so? Is there any other obvious reason for it?
The founders of this State adopted P.R. The Government at the time of the Treaty continued it and the Taoiseach, when producing his testament to the Irish people, embodied it in the Constitution of 1937. Was the Taoiseach of age then? Had he got his milk teeth? Was he hanging on to the apron strings of those who nurtured him? The Constitution was to be the Charter of the Irish people for all time. He solemnly inserted P.R. in it and boasted because he did so. He referred to the blessing it was. What happened since? I suggest that there is something ulterior in it, and I ask this House to reject the measure.
Comment on this
When this Bill first came before the House, it was opposed and I did not vote on the resulting division. The reason for that inaction on my part was that, from the time it was first mentioned that such a proposal was likely to come forward, it was obvious to me that, under the Constitution, the people would have to decide and I could not feel that I could vote against a Bill which would require the consent of the people to become law; nor did I wish to vote in favour of the Bill without first of all having heard the arguments for and against, and having had the opportunity to express my opinions.
I can say that those who opposed the Bill on its introduction probably have a case. For myself, neither then nor since have I heard any argument which would convince me that the people should not have the opportunity to decide such a question. The proposition that the time is not opportune and the much worse proposition that the people would not know what the issues really were did not seem to me to be valid arguments against the people being asked their opinion. As far as referenda are concerned, I think this instrument for finding the people's opinion might have been used on other occasions to great advantage, possibly not always merely to secure what might have been obvious was general opinion but as a means of discovering just how many people did not agree.
Before I come to the Bill itself, there is one point I should like to mention. There has been a fair amount of reference to a particular minority, and, as I intend to refer to the minority which I consider I represent, I feel I should make it clear to the House just what I conceive that minority to be. I admit it is reasonably understandable in this country that there should be some confusion of thought about this point, but I do agree with Deputy Booth in that, first of all, it is most undesirable that it should be in anyone's mind that the religious minority in this country require political representation and, secondly, I agree with him that to consider that the religious minority and the political minority are completely coterminous—it is the only word I can think of—is very wrong.
I should qualify that in some respects. For historical reasons I do not think there is any doubt that, in the three Ulster counties the religious minority, and the political minority to which I want to refer, are almost identical. The political minority to which I referred is one for which, in present circumstances, it is difficult to find a name. It used to be called "Unionist" but that is a term which I think could not now be applied. I doubt if anybody in Ireland, north or south of the Border, would want Unionism in its old sense, say pre-1922, of wanting one Parliament for the British Isles at Westminster. The reasons might not be the same on both sides of the Border but by and large it is probably true. But there is a political minority here which believes that we should not have left the British Commonwealth. That is the political minority which I consider I represent.
As I said, as a hard matter of historical fact, it is probably true that in my constituency the religious minority and this political minority are the same but as you go south that becomes less and less true. There are many people in the South of Ireland of my religious persuasion who are, and have been for generations, convinced Republicans. I think it is also true that there are many people in the South of Ireland who are members of the religious majority and who agree with my minority views.
I mention this because probably I shall have occasion to refer to the minority I represent and I want to make it clear that I am talking about that political minority when talking about my minority. As I said already, I agree with Deputy Booth that it is an understandable point of view, in a general way, that there is an association between this political and religious minority. It is not really so, although I admit that historically it is to some degree understandable but I do think that people would be better to get away from that idea.
To come now to the Bill. First of all there is this vexed question of representation. I think that an undue amount of weight is attached to the necessity for representation of views and the sort of general view that when people come in here they are representatives. For instance, in regard to myself, I am elected by about 6,000 voters. We have some common denominator, some common factor, but among those 6,000 voters there are businessmen, farmers, farm labourers and professional people. Once the subject that happens to be under discussion in this House ceases to be one to which this common factor of a political outlook on a particular point of view would apply, do I cease to be a representative? Of course I do to some degree.
I think undue weight is laid in this House on the subject of the members being representative. I have always held strong views on that. It is so easy to slip from the word "representative" to the word "delegate" and I think that, by and large, in the minds of too many Deputies is the feeling that they are delegates. If that is so then on every question that arises they should go back and ask the people who voted for them whether they think alike on that subject. My own view on Parliament is that that line of approach is disastrous and should not be followed. I do not think it is a logical assumption that when I come in here, representing 6,000 people, I can represent those 6,000 voters equally on every subject which comes up for discussion.
There is another point about this question of P.R. The theory of it sounds very well but in practice so many other factors come in that they seem to me to leave the theory very far behind the practice. For instance, it is not sufficient that a minority should have a certain strength in the country, a geographical angle comes in as well. With the country now more or less divided into three member constituencies that tendency, if this present proposal is not accepted by the people, will increase. The plain fact is it is possible to have a minority of 15 or 20 per cent., evenly distributed throughout the country, who could not get one representative into the House, whereas a two per cent. minority of the entire country, if it happened to be situated inside the bounds of one constituency, can get a representative in.
The theory of P.R., looking at the country as a whole, depends on a good deal of codology. I admit that some nearer approach to direct P.R. of various shades of thought might be obtained within the bounds of the present system by making constituencies larger and allowing more members per constituency. By doing that you will give the possibility of representation to minorities. How big must a minority be to require representation in the national Parliament? Is it to be one to 147, which appears to be the logical thing? If it is, there is only one way and that is to make the country one constituency which I do not think anybody would consider a feasible thing to do, but logically, under P.R. it is the only way to secure in a House of 147, that every 147th of opinion be represented.
Once you move from that, you become more and more illogical and when you come down to the three member constituency I cannot see very much left of P.R., so called, at all. As I say, to get into this House in the three member constituency, supposing your point of view is different from that of the other people in the constituency, you require a 25 per cent. minority in that constituency.
It sounds very well to talk about P.R. but personally I do not think we have it at the moment. Who is to blame for that? I do not propose to discuss it. It does not seem to me to matter. The plain fact is, we pretend we have P.R. when in fact we have not. It is obvious that not only must there be a considerable minority to get a representative into the House at all but that it must be geographically well situated, so that from that point of view alone I am inclined to sheer away from the present system because it appears, on paper, to be doing something which in fact it does not. Apart from that consideration altogether, just what are the advantages of multi-member constituencies?
I was not a member of this House for more than four or five years when I began to realise that there were grave defects, and, I believe, parliamentary defects, which sprang from the system of multi-member constituencies—for one thing, the size of the constituencies. The bigger the constituency, the more difficult it is for an individual Deputy to give real attention to those matters which are of particular interest to his constituents. I admit that problem is more pressing for an Independent Deputy than it is for a Party member, but it is a very real difficulty.
There has been a great deal of discussion here, and even more particularly in the correspondence columns of the Press, on the subject of the closeness of a member to his constituents in single and multi-member constituencies. It would be illogical to talk about the parallels drawn between what would happen here and what does happen in Great Britain, because the proposed constituencies here are very much smaller than the constituencies in Great Britain are. Some members, I am afraid, have been making abstruse calculations as to what might happen under this system, as to the number of voters who would, in fact, turn out in the constituencies. They based their calculations on 20,000 voters. Nobody mentioned it, but on that assumption, I presume that the age at which one can vote is to be reduced from 21 to one, if constituencies are to be limited to 20,000 or 30,000 inhabitants. How, in constituencies of that size, there could be 20,000 voters, I have not yet worked out. The size of the constituencies is a very important matter but constituencies of the size which are suggested in this Bill appear to me to be something which would be of very great benefit to whomever sits to represent them.
It has been suggested, for instance, by Deputy T.F. O'Higgins, who, if I may say so, made one of the few reasoned speeches against the Bill I either heard or read, that the present system gives voters a better choice within the Party they favour. There is, I think, something to be said for that but what interested me was that it seemed to me to be clear from the argument put forward by the Deputy that he was favouring a point of view which I know is common both inside and outside this House, that is, that many people here and outside look upon members of this House as individuals elected to protect the rights of individuals against the State, rather than as members of a legislature.
The only word I can think of for that is one that has a bad flavour attached to it, that is, "carpetbagging". If I use that word, I do not mean it in any insulting way but everyone will know it in relation to this particular point of view that the most essential function of a Deputy is to make sure that Mrs. O'Reilly gets her old age pension when she comes to the right age for it. If I may digress, a great deal of codology goes on so far as that type of representation by members of this House is concerned.
My own experience in the past 15 years has been that, while there are undoubtedly hard cases that turn up in respect of old age pensions, or such matters, the vast majority of the people would get the things to which they are entitled without the intervention of a Deputy. In my view, Deputies themselves have encouraged that opinion among the people, that they are an essential link in the chain. This point of view, that people are elected here primarily to make sure that individuals receive their rights, is one which, I think, is encouraged by the system of multi-member constituencies. Inside all constituencies, there is a fair amount of trying to out-do the other fellow who represents the same constituency. It is a bad thing for a Parliament to be based on that idea.
Deputy O'Higgins also referred to the system in Great Britain by which, under the single member constituency system, there are many—about 80 per cent., I think he said—safe Party men who sit in Parliament but about whom no one in the constituency knows very much. They voted for them because they were good safe Party men. I do not think that is true, to begin with. Deputy O'Higgins is quite wrong in that respect. The British electorate is not nearly as interested in this pure Party outlook as we, unfortunately, are in this country. Members over there have to work very hard and I should have thought it was generally accepted that they are more inclined in the United Kingdom to switch from one Party to another than we are here. We are very much inclined, too much inclined, I think, to stick by the Party and not allow other considerations to come in.
I have been directly involved in a number of elections, and one of the things that is continually cropping up is this business of: "Well, now, we are not going to let the Party down". A general appeal to Party fervour appears to me to be quite common here and I doubt very much if we have really as big a floating vote as they have in the United Kingdom, so I do not think Deputy O'Higgins is quite right in that respect.
There is one point which I feel very strongly about. We have neglected here, or failed to make use of, Parliamentary Committees, to the extent to which I should like to see them used. The business of the State is becoming more and more involved as time goes on, and Parliament has had to give up to Ministers, functions which I am sure Parliament would have preferred to keep to itself. The modern State is such a complex affair that Parliament, unless it sat 24 hours a day seven days a week for 52 weeks a year, would never get through the mass of detail, so that we have had to allow a good deal of legislation by Ministerial Order. A safeguard against that would be strong parliamentary committees.
In my opinion, multi-member constituencies react against good parliamentary committees. I admit it is a matter of opinion, but so far as I can read what happens in the United Kingdom, the great strength of their very excellent parliamentary committees is the good, safe, backbencher who, in a safe constituency, can devote a considerable amount of time and work to the functions of those committees because he is in a safe seat.
The great trouble about committee work, of course, is that there is no publicity attached to it, and I think Deputies here—and very sensibly— are inclined to fight shy of committees, because, while they are engaging themselves in committee work, the other representatives of the same constituency are busy cutting the ground from under their feet at home and in this House, which it is very easy to do. I do not know whether everyone has thought this out consciously, but I myself feel, and have felt for some years, that at the back of their minds when it comes to committee work there is this feeling that it is rather unrewarding from the publicity point of view. I think that is a great pity and there is a great deal that could be done. I am talking not only about speed but about efficiency in the work of parliamentary committees. If there is to be efficiency it means more than just turning up at the meeting and making an odd remark. It means a good deal of spade work behind the scenes which takes up time.
Personally, I am satisfied that the great strength of the system in West-minister is the good, safe backbencher. Speaking of a member of Parliament, whatever my political views may be, I prefer a parliamentarian all the time. Anything we can do to ensure a better parliamentary system is very important.
Other things happen which arise from multi-member constituencies. For instance there is the sort of stooge candidate. The unfortunate fellow is landed in as a second or third or fourth string, as the case may be, because the main candidate comes from one end of the constituency. The Party managers recognise that local interest is a very important thing. Therefore, somebody has to be put up at the other end of the constituency, not that anyone thinks he will be elected but in order to draw out the local votes. He will die in the process but his preferences will go to the No. 1 candidate of the Party—and once one Party does it certainly one other Party is bound to follow one other Party is bound to follow suit. How the Parties continue to find these unfortunate people is something that has never failed to surprise me. It just shows what Party loyalty can mean. There is also this point.
Comment on this
Will you not have to find a hopeless man for the single-member constituency, too—the hopeless seat?
Comment on this
I do not think there is the same danger because the constituency will be smaller. There will be no question of finding somebody 40 miles away. Any Party with any reasonable sort of general appeal can usually, in the middle of a small constituency, find somebody of general appeal. These unfortunate stooges will not have to be found and I think that will be a good job.
There is also the plain fact that people do get in here who may not have a great knowledge of parliamentary affairs and who may not have a great knowledge of national affairs but they get dragged in on the triumphant heels of some popular personality. This is a difficult subject to dwell on because it is almost implied criticism of members of this House. I would be far from wanting to do that. I admit it could work the other way. I can think of one most useful members of this House who gets in, dragged on the heels of somebody who is no use in the House at all. No names, no pack drill. What this has to do with the niceties of P.R., I have not heard anybody explain and I do not think, by and large, it is any great help to the country.
I think, more or less, the Parties think that they find good candidates— and when I say "good candidates" I do not want to suggest that the personnel of the present Dáil are not good representative of the people. They are probably good representatives of the people but, with my view of Parliament, I am not prepared to admit that a good representative of the people is a good Parliamentarian.
I think that a single-member constitunecy would tend to bring into the national Parliament people with a better outlook. It has been argued here that under single-member constituencies by the straight vote a great part of the electorate would be disfranchised. From the point of view of purity of language, I do not quite see it. The people, presumably, would have voted. They would hardly be disfranchised. They may be unrepresented but not disfranchised.
The theory behind this argument appears to be that if a Fianna Fáil Deputy is elected for the constituency, Fine Gael supporters are now left with nobody to whom they can tell their woes about old age pensions, and so on. If that is the experience of Deputies it is very strange to me. I have found it almost invariable that when I go to a Department on behalf of a constituent I find there are letters or representations of some form from the other members of my constituency. Certainly where it is a case of real hardship, nobody I have ever come across has had much hesitation in approaching all the Deputies for the constituency—possibly even assuring each of them that they are life-long supporters. However, whether or not they go to that length I have not found that people are at all shy about approaching Deputies of another Party.
The suggestion that everybody who did not vote for the successful candidate will now be left out in the cold is a very bad impression to give. If there are people with that point of view then the sooner they are disabused of it the better for the country. One of the most disastrous things about the present set-up in this country is that what seemed to me to be dead ashes get warmed into fire and that people can be persuaded that because somebody is in a different Party he is the next thing to the Devil incarnate and is not to be approached. That is a disaster, nationally. If single-member constituencies will help to do away with that outlook then it is only another reason why single-member constituencies should be brought in.
It could be argued that it is all right to say and possibly to prove to my own satisfaction that single member constituencies would give a good Parliament but it is possible, with single member constituencies, to have the election by means of a transferable vote as does happen at present when there is a by-election. It has been argued here that the straight vote in three-or four- or five-corner fights can result in the successful candidate merely representing a minority and that is very true. But there is a good deal of loose thinking about this point. Early in the debate—it seems a long time ago now—Deputy Blowick referred to what could happen in a case where 12,001 people were voting. If one candidate gets 4,001 votes and the other two candidates get 4,000 votes each he said it was a ridiculous situation that the fellow with 4,001 votes gets in and the other 8,000 people are disfranchised. At first glance, this does look a bit odd but it is not necessarily odder than what happens now. Let us take this particular case as it has been given here against the Bill. There are now two candidates with 4,000 votes each. One of them has to be eliminated. The first thing they do is to decided, by drawing out of a hat, which is eliminated. The second preferences of those 4,000 people who voted for the eliminated candidate now assume the same value as the original first preferences of the other 8,001 people. That appears to me neither mathematically nor logically very sensible.