Referendum (Amendment) Bill, 1958—Second Stage.
Contributions 1–139 of 273. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 31 of 1958 ›
I move that the Bill be now read a Second Time. The purpose of this Bill is twofold: first, to prescribe a new form of ballot paper for use at a constitutional referendum; and, secondly, to grant to persons employed by the local returning officers in connection with the poll at a referendum the same facilities in regard to voting as are granted to persons employed by returning officers at Dáil and local government elections.
Comment on this
On a point of order, we need amplification here for a long time.
Comment on this
I shall commence again.
The purpose of this Bill is twofold —first, to prescribe a new form of ballot paper for use at a constitutional referendum and, secondly, to grant to persons employed by the local returning officers in connection with the poll at a referendum the same facilities in regard to voting as are granted to persons employed by returning officers at Dáil and local government elections.
Under the Referendum Act, 1942, the form of ballot paper to be used at a referendum contains a space in which the proposal which is the subject of the referendum is to be set out. The voter is asked to state whether he approves or disapproves of the proposal becoming law. The Act provides that in the case of a constitutional referendum the proposal must "be stated on the ballot paper in the same terms as nearly as may be as such proposal is stated in the Bill containing such proposal passed or deemed to have been passed by both Houses of the Oireachtas". I am advised that in order to comply with this provision it would be necessary to set out in the appropriate space in the ballot paper virtually the whole text of the Bill to amend the Constitution, in both official languages.
This would be quite impracticable in the case of a Constitutional Amendment Bill running to several pages, such as the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958. It would, obviously, be unreasonable to expect a voter to read a long document of that kind in the polling booth. Copies of the Bill to amend the Constitution will be provided for inspection and purchase in post offices in accordance with the provisions of the Referendum Act, 1942, so that voters can study the terms of the proposed constitutional amendment before polling day.
The First Schedule to the Bill sets out the new form of ballot paper at a constitutional referendum. The proposal which is the subject of the referendum will be stated by citing by its Short Title the Bill to amend the Constitution and the voter will be asked to vote "Yes" or "No" to the question, "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution contained in the undermentioned Bill?" The opportunity is being availed of to have a bilingual form of ballot paper. The ballot paper at the plebiscite held under the Plebiscite (Draft Constitution) Act, 1937, was bilingual.
The Second Schedule contains minor consequential amendments to the rules governing the form of notice of poll and the procedure for voting by physically incapacitated or illiterate voters.
There is provision in the law relating to Dáil and local government elections to enable persons employed by a returning officer to be authorised to vote at a polling station in their constituency other than the one assigned to them in the polling scheme if the circumstances of their employment are such as to prevent them from voting at that station. This means, in practice, that presiding officers and poll clerks can vote at the polling station at which they are employed. This facility was afforded on the occasion of the plebiscite on the Constitution in 1937. It is considered desirable that it should likewise be afforded in the case of a referendum, and Section 3 of this Bill provides accordingly.
Comment on this
I move the following amendment:—
To delete all words after the word "That" and substitute therefor the words:
Dáil Éireann declines to give a Second Reading to the Bill as it proposes to deprive the voter of that knowledge of the issue on which he is asked to express an opinion, as would otherwise be set out on the ballot paper as required by Section 15 (4) of the Referendum Act, 1942.
Having regard to the manner in which the proposals for the amendment of the Constitution were brought before the House and are being hurried to the country, this amending Bill, which appears, according to the Minister's statement, to be very simple—perhaps in his view, it is entirely unobjectionable—is regarded by us with extreme suspicion.
The Act of 1942 was passed at a time when calm and objective consideration could be given, and doubtless was given, to the necessary details in connection with the holding of a referendum, be it constitutional or otherwise. We want to know why it is that this Bill now is so framed as to deprive the electorate going in to vote on the referendum and reading the ballot paper of at least a certain amount of information as to what they are voting on and to give them no information.
We must approach the consideration of this Bill on the basis that, under the existing law as contained in the Referendum Act of 1942, a considerable amount of information was set forth on the ballot paper. Under the proposal put forward by the Minister in this Bill, the electorate is to get no information—good, bad or indifferent. The proposal is to change the form of the ballot paper from what is required under the Referendum Act of 1942 to merely putting in the Short Title of the Bill. If Deputies will look at the Short Title of the Constitution Amendment Bill, the first thing that will strike them is that the Short Title is very much longer than the Long Title of the Bill, which is a rather absurd situation. All that the elector will be told on the ballot paper is that the proposal is "The Third Amendment of the Constitution Act, 1959".
There was an opportunity in 1946 to make this particular amendment, or some analogous one, had that been thought necessary. Presumably consideration had been given to it at the time when changes in the electoral law effected by the Electoral Act of 1946 were being considered to deal with difficulties that may have been apparent in the Referendum Act, 1942. No such change as is proposed in this Bill was thought desirable or necessary. Again, we were in a time of calm consideration when the passions and controversies that have arisen as a result of the Government's proposals for the proposed amendment of the Constitution did not exist.
Presumably the same calm consideration was given at that time as was given in 1942; but now, as a first act in the new year, this Bill is hurried into the Dáil and will be hurriedly pushed through on the lines characteristic of the entire of the proposals connected with the amendment of the Constitution, namely, hurry, withholding of information from the country, hypocritical suggestions that the people's will must be secured before they can get full information adequate to understand not merely what is contained in the Bill but the implications of its passing into law in the near future, not so much as in the near present.
As I say, the proposal was not thought necessary in 1946, but, of course, after the Referendum Amendment Act of 1946, there emerged the two reasons why this proposed Constitution Amendment Bill became operative in the Taoiseach's mind: he had been beaten twice, beaten in 1947 and again in 1954.
In the 1942 Act, there is a reasonable provision that the voter, when voting, should be told what he is voting on. Section 15, sub-section (4) of that Act provided that every ballot paper in a constitutional referendum should contain a statement of the subject of the referendum. Sub-section (5) proposed that that statement should consist in stating on the ballot paper the proposal in the same terms, as nearly as may be, as those in which such proposal is stated in the Bill containing such proposal passed by the Oireachtas. That Act required that the ballot paper on which the voter was casting his vote should contain a statement of the proposals of the Bill. I see no reason why there should not be an obligation on the Government to state on the ballot paper, as nearly as may be possible, a statement of the proposals contained in this Bill. It could be reduced to a pretty simple form that could be understood by the voters being asked to vote on this proposal, radical as indeed it is.
Instead of having this statement, apparently in the interests of simplicity, the voter is to be told nothing. Under the existing law, the voter had in front of him a statement giving him some information—in fact, considerable information—as to what he was voting on. Here he is to be told nothing. Deputies voting on this Bill must realise and understand the significance of that. Voters are to be told what is the Short Title of the Bill, and the Short Title of the Bill gives no information, good, bad or indifferent, except that it is the Third Amendment of the Constitution Act, 1959.
When Deputies turn to consider other proposals in this Bill, they will see the absurdity of this and perhaps they will realise the sinister motives behind these proposals. Under the Act of 1942, where what are called incapacitated voters found themselves in a difficulty in their understanding of what they were asked to do, they were entitled to seek the assistance of the presiding officer. He had to give them certain information. He was bound to tell them what was on the ballot paper. In other words, he gave them the information which would enable them to understand what they were being asked to do and he then asked them did they approve or disapprove.
Under the present proposal, the procedure will be different. An incapacitated voter who does not understand what he is doing, asks the presiding officer to explain the matter to him. The presiding officer takes up the ballot paper and says nothing but: "This is the Third Amendment of the Constitution Act, 1958. Do you approve of that?" That, briefly, is what is proposed in this Bill. An intelligent, even though illiterate voter, a blind or incapacitated voter is asked to do something he does not understand; he wants to understand it, and goes to the returning officer. That is what he is told.
Let me read the section as amended in order to bring out the absurdity and sinister nature of these proposals. Paragraph 2 of the Second Schedule of the Bill proposes that in the case of a constitutional referendum "in applying paragraph 3 of Rule 18 of those rules, the following sub-paragraph shall be substituted for subparagraph (c) of that paragraph." Let me read the existing law and compare it with what is proposed to be done.
Rule 18 deals with what are called in the marginal note "incapacitated voters," that is to say, blind persons, persons otherwise physically incapacitated or so illiterate as to be unable to vote without assistance. Such a person seeks guidance from the presiding officer, and the presiding officer is given directions in accordance with which he is to give such guidance. Under the 1942 Act, he is told to ask the voter: "Which do you wish to do —to vote in favour of the proposal or to vote against the proposal?" Then the presiding officer is to mark the ballot paper in accordance with the answer the voter gives to that question. Where the voter fails to understand the import of the question, the presiding officer shall read out to the voter the proposal as stated on the ballot paper and then ask the voter: "Do you approve or do you object to that proposal becoming law?", and in accordance with the answer, he is to mark the ballot paper.
Under the existing law, the presiding officer reads out what is on the ballot paper. In other words, he reads out a summary of what is the subject matter of the referendum and asks: "Do you want that put into law or not in the proposed amendment here?" The presiding officer asks the question: "Which do you wish to do—vote in favour of the proposal or against the proposal?" If the voter fails to understand the import of that, this is what it is proposed the presiding officer should do, in accordance with the amendment set out in the Second Schedule to the Bill, paragraph 2, subparagraph (2):—
"(c) where the voter fails to understand the import of the said question, the presiding officer shall read out to the voter the Short Title of the Bill to amend the Constitution as stated on the ballot paper and then ask the voter, ‘Do you approve of or do you object to that Bill becoming law?' and then mark the ballot paper in accordance with the answer of the voter;".
Assume—and it is a fair assumption— that the incapacitated or illiterate voter does not understand the question put. The incapacitated or illiterate voter will come up to the presiding officer and say that he or she does not understand. What happens? The presiding officer does nothing more than read to the voter the Short Title of the Bill to amend the Constitution and then asks the voter: "Do you approve of, or do you object to, that Bill becoming law?" Could any more absurd and more ridiculous proposal be put for consideration to an intelligent assembly, such as this Dáil is supposed to be?
Consider the two proposals. The form of the ballot paper is to be changed. Nothing will appear on the ballot paper except the Short Title of the Bill. Even there, there is the absurdity that the Short Title of the Bill is actually longer than the Long Title of the Bill. No information of any kind will be given. The incapacitated or illiterate voter who does not understand what he is to do will have solemnly read out to him by the presiding officer the Short Title of the Bill and he will then be asked, having heard that Short Title, does he approve of, or does he object to, that Bill becoming law?
There is another proposed amendment in the Bill now before the House in relation to the form of the ballot paper. In the Referendum Act of 1942, the form of the ballot paper is set out in the Second Schedule. I have dealt with the vital change proposed, in which no information will be given to the incapacitated or illiterate voter, instead of adequate information as was the practice hitherto. The Short Title of the Bill will be given instead of the substance of the Bill as was required by the Act of 1942. But there is another change in the form of the ballot paper. On the ballot paper under the 1942 Act, the following question appears at the top: "Do you approve or do you disapprove of the proposal in the first column becoming law?" There is an alternative set out there: "Do you approve or do you disapprove?" In the proposed new form, the words "Do you disapprove?" are left out.
Are we to be blamed if, because of these tendentious arrangements, we see something sinister in these proposals? On the proposed new form of ballot paper, the question is: "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution contained in the undermentioned Bill?" Could anything be more tendentious than that method of putting the question? Why are the words "or do you disapprove" left out in the proposed new form of the ballot paper? The House is entitled to be told by the Minister why that change has been made.
Is it not obvious that it is all akin to leading the voter to say: "Tá— Yes.""Do you approve of the proposal?""Tá—Yes." If the voter does not understand the import of the question, he or she gets no information from the returning officer, other than the Short Title of the Bill. Under the existing law, that information had to be given. Under the existing law, one was asked if one disapproved of the Bill. Here, all one is asked to do is to approve of the Bill. Why is it proposed to make these changes? We cannot come to any conclusion except that all this is in strict line with the policy pursued throughout by the Government in this matter.
The Government do not want the electors to form an intelligent view of the proposals put before them. In the Referendum Act of 1942, there is a provision whereby a copy of the Act must be hung in the post office and in certain other places. How on earth could even an ordinarily intelligent voter form the remotest opinion of what this Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill means by looking at it in a post office? Even those of us who are expert and experienced in reading Bills found it extremely difficult to follow this Bill when it first came before us, or to understand what its effect and purport were.
On the first page, at the left hand side, one finds that the Irish text is to he changed by the insertion of a number of matters set out in a Schedule and by the alteration of certain numbers. Then one finds that the English text is to be altered in somewhat similar fashion. The citation of the Act is provided for and the Title is given. Astonishingly enough, one then finds a Schedule in Irish at the end of the English version. On the second page, there is a whole heap of Irish. Likewise, on the third, fourth, fifth and sixth pages, there is nothing but Irish. Then one comes to a whole heap of English headed "Part II." It was difficult for us to find out the reason for all that.
Consider the position in which the ordinary, even the intelligent, voter will find himself. He will not have the remotest possibility of finding out what it is all about by looking at it in the post office. Is it not the duty of the Government to provide all of us with ample opportunity for understanding this? Is it not the duty of the Government to provide ample opportunity for informing the electorate and educating the electorate in what it is proposed to do in abolishing P.R. and substituting therefor the single member constituency? It looks very simple on the face of it. It is not so simple when it comes to the point of bringing the electorate to a full realisation of what the effect of all this might be in the future, when many of us will have passed from the scene. In the course of the Second Reading, the very serious effects which may ensue were pointed out.
All this is in accord with the line taken by the Government to rush this matter through. We have been brought back to deal with this Bill in the first week of the new year. The Dáil has been summoned at an unprecedentedly early date in the new year, not to deal with vital economic matters, but with the Referendum (Amendment) Bill, 1958, and the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958. Does that not show all the rush, the hurry and the effort to get this through before the people realise what the effect will be?
Added to that, there is the proposal in this Referendum Bill to deprive the electorate of the knowledge and the information to which they were entitled under the existing law, together with the entirely novel proposal whereby the presiding officer will inform the incapacitated or illiterate voter, who does not understand what is required, of the Short Title of the Bill. We are, I think, justified in assuming that all this is not really necessary, but is merely in accord with the Government's desire to rush this Bill through, thereby preventing the electorate from fully appreciating what they are being asked to do.
Comment on this
We are to-day discussing this very important measure. The Leader of the Opposition has advanced reasons as to why we on this side of the House feel that it should not be passed. There are eight Deputies on the Government Benches. seven of whom appear to be awake. Not one of them is prepared to get up and say whether he approves or disapproves, agrees or disagrees with what the Leader of the Opposition has said. What has happened over the Christmas to the thundering forces who were behind the Taoiseach on the Second Reading of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill? Why are they not here to-day to defend this Bill? When Deputy Costello sat down, why was there not somebody on the other side of the House to get up and say what Deputy Costello said was right or wrong?
Comment on this
The Deputy and his Party will have a lot to answer for, when they meet the people. They will have lost their opportunity of answering. The opportunity is here, in this House. This is where they should answer. We say that the manner in which the Minister has framed this machinery to implement what the Government propose to do in seeking the people's authority to amend the Constitution is quite in line with their approach to the question of the purpose of the amendment of the Constitution.
We were presented with a Constitution—this year, we celebrate its coming of age—which we were told was perfect, which catered for every possible contingency. Later, as Deputy Costello has pointed out, in the calm deliberation of this House, the Government Party now in office set out the machinery under which a referendum was to be carried out if ever the occasion should arise. This is the first occasion on which that 1942 Act is being invoked. Without having the experience of a single referendum to show up any defects in their 1942 Act, they themselves strike their breasts and say: "Mea culpa.” Here is the Act that we put through the Dáil. Here is where we copperfastened every aspect of the conduct of a referendum. We now eat humble pie.” Before that Act functions, they ask the House to delete the very provisions they wrote into the 1942 Act. Could anything be more ridiculous?
If the people allow this Government to proceed with the third amendment of the Constitution, if they allow them to copperfasten for posterity provisions in relation to constituencies and so on, how can they have faith in the intention of the Government to stand over what they present to them, when the Government are not prepared to stand over what they wrote into a simple administrative Act in 1942? Is it not all one pattern of a Government that at one time felt we should have bicameral government and proceeded to wipe out the Seanad and then said: "We made a mistake. We would now prefer to have the Seanad back"?
Comment on this
They change their minds and they say they are at liberty to change their minds. Then we have had the circumstances in which the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and so many others represented P.R. as being an ideal system of election for the Irish people—no better on the face of the globe.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not seem to be confining himself to the terms of the Bill before the House.
Comment on this
With respect, Sir, I am showing this vacillation to be part and parcel of the general vacillation of the Government in administration. They have chopped and changed with the Oireachtas down through the years. Now they are chopping and changing with the system of election. We are discussing to-day, Sir, with respect, another effort to chop and to change the very machinery under which a referendum is to be carried out. We ask: What has happened that they should now introduce in this measure proposals intended to prevent the people from understanding fully what they are doing when they go into the polling booth?
Comment on this
That is so. When Deputy Costello sat down, neither Deputy Loughman nor any Deputy sitting with him got up to say that he was wrong. No doubt, when they are whipped into the Lobby, they will exercise a certain opinion, but let them get up and support what their Minister is doing. Let them defend the Minister against the allegations we are making that the Minister in this Bill is deliberately concealing from the electorate the information which it is their right to have before they will be in a position to decide which is right and which is wrong.
Comment on this
We met plenty during the holidays. Apparently, the Government were desirous of preventing members of this House from meeting too many people during the holidays. That is one of the reasons we were brought back here. The Deputy and his colleagues would be far better employed to take the month of January and meet more people. They might learn what the people really think of their antics in this matter.
We feel that the people can have no faith in the Government which implements, in the cool atmosphere of this House, in non-election years, proposals to deal with a situation that may arise in the years to come and, on the very first occasion on which the people are asked to vote in a referendum, the people find the very machinery that was presented to them as the perfect machinery is being changed, whole sections of it being taken out and the Minister failing to implement what his Party, when previously in office, had written into the Statute Book. We have every reason, therefore, to be suspicious of the omissions from this Bill and the provisions contained in it.
Who, on the opposite side of the House, can say that it is right that the prosecuting counsel against P.R. should fail to make a case and should ask the electorate, who are the jury in this case, to decide, while keeping from them the case that the Government claim they have and failing to provide the elector in the polling booth with that clear exposition of what they are doing? There are very few measures of such radical importance that could come before this House or the electorate. The decision which will be taken relates to changing the system of election. In this important issue, the electorate are being denied the information that would help them to make up their minds one way or another. It is part and parcel of the whole drive to try to steamroll this measure through at all costs, before the truth is brought home to the electorate.
These are the reasons why we vigorously oppose the way in which the Minister is presenting this Bill, the way in which he is denying the electorate the full information they require. It is indicative of the Government's approach to the whole matter, the contempt with which they are treating a question which is so vitally important to the future of the country. The Minister will have a lot of explaining to do before he can satisfy the people that this is not part of a jigsaw—in which the Government are seeking to put something over on the electorate which they hope to get away with. We say that they will have a lot to do before they will succeed in perpetrating what they propose to do.
Comment on this
My contribution to this debate will be very brief because I think it is a waste of time for the House to be discussing this Bill, in particular, or this Bill as a facet of the fraudulent masquerade which it is sought to put over on the people in this combination of Bills, which have one purpose and one purpose only, that is, the sordid purpose of abolishing P.R. in the hope that Fianna Fáil as a minority Government can cling on to office after they have forfeited the confidence of the people at a general election.
The ballot paper which is to be used in the referendum is set out in this Bill and the Referendum Act, 1942 provides that, in the case of a referendum, the subject matter on which the referendum is held should be set out in detail as nearly as possible as the Bill to make the change contemplated in the reference to the referendum. The purpose of the referendum on this occasion is to abolish P.R. That is its primary purpose and that purpose is clearly imprinted on the Bill. Would one not imagine, therefore, that some inkling of the fact that the referendum was being held to abolish or retain P.R. would appear on the ballot paper? But there will not be the slightest reference to P.R. on the ballot paper. There will be no reference whatever to P.R. on the ballot paper, although the purpose of the referendum is to decide whether we are to abolish P.R. or retain P.R. Instead, the voter, not very familiar with the preparation and the procedural arrangements governing ballot papers, will be brought into the polling booth and if he has not bought a copy of the Constitution Amendment Act or gone to the post office to look up the well-thumbed copy to familiarise himself with what is taking place, will be asked by the presiding officer: Do you approve of the Third Amendment of the Constitution?
Would it not be easier to ask him: Do you approve of the abolition of P.R.? But he will not be asked anything about P.R. So far as the presiding officer is concerned he can put one question only: Do you approve of the Third Amendment of the Constitution? Why is the voter not being asked: Do you approve or not approve of the abolition of P.R.? There seems to be some occult purpose in not putting that question to the voter. Yet that is what this Bill provides for. The voter will not be told on polling day that all this masquerade called the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is for one purpose only, that is, to abolish P.R. in the interest of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Perhaps some people on the Government Front Bench might tell us by what process of mental research they arrived at the conclusion that it would make for greater clarification, if the voter were told nothing about the abolition of P.R. P.R. is not mentioned once in the ballot paper. No effort whatever is made to simplify the issue for the voter by saying: Look, when all the talk is over, what you are doing to-day is you are voting either to abolish P.R. or retain it. The voter is not given one clue that his vote that day has any relation to P.R.
I suggest that all this is part and parcel of the dishonesty which surrounds this Bill and the Constitution Amendment Bill. I do not suppose it is any use pointing out to the Government and the silent and mute battalions behind them that what they are doing is dishonest and that it has all the hall-marks of political manipulation in the interests of the Party upon it because I think this Government want to steamroll it through the House. So far as the Opposition Parties in this House are concerned and so far as those who believe in democratic government are concerned, our only hope now is to appeal to the people throughout the country to hang on to their rights to retain the system of P.R. which they used for the benefit of the nation over the past 40 years.
For the past 40 years, people have voted on the single transferable vote. Every person, not over 60 years of age, has voted on no other system of election in this country but the single transferable vote. The only hope now is not to make futile appeals to this Government to see reason or recognise the basic principles of political Parties but, instead, to appeal to the people of the country to vote "No" at the next election, knowing that by voting "No," at the next election, they will retain the system of P.R.
This Government do not want the people to see the issues clearly. This Government are doing their best by the legislation and by the dishonest speeches made in support of it to confuse and befuddle the minds of the people. I still believe that the people who have experience of the system of voting for the past 40 years, who know and who can clearly see the results, will not be willing to part with the system of government which has been a check on the dominant one Party Government, but will retain instead not government by a minority, but good government by a broadly based Government, responsible to checks by the people and responsible in proportion to their voting strength in this House to the other Parties which constitute the Opposition here.
Comment on this
I cannot quite follow the reasoning of the Opposition in this matter. Unfortunately, I was not present to hear what Deputy Costello said but I did hear Deputy O'Sullivan and now Deputy Norton. It appears to me that we should try to confine ourselves a little more rigidly to the terms of the Bill.
Comment on this
It was not intended to be criticism of the Chair. The Chair has always been very considerate, not only to other Deputies, but to myself. The point at issue basically is whether the electorate will know what they are doing when they enter the polling booth. This whole campaign has been going on already for a period of months. I do not think that there can be any single voter in the country who does not know that there is a proposal on foot to amend the Constitution and to substitute a new electoral system.
Now, once that is known already, I think it can be clearly assumed that after further months of debate in this House and discussions outside this House, every person will know before the referendum is held, that he is being asked to vote on a referendum whether the Constitution is to be amended or not. Surely that is a very straight question?
Deputy Norton stated that the real point at issue was whether P.R. was to be abolished or not. I can agree with him to a certain extent, but at the same time he admits or ignores that there are a very large number of consequential provisions in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958. Let it be granted that all these additional provisions result from the alteration of the Constitution which brings in one member only for each constituency and the single non-transferable vote. After those two provisions are made in Part 2 of the Schedule to the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, I think it could be just as easily contended that to say that this constitutional amendment was purely the abolition or retention of P.R. is quite wrong.
There is the whole question of the constituency commission and the provision for the deemed election of the Ceann Comhairle and so on. It would, to my mind, be quite wrong to say to a person who intends to vote: "This is purely a question of the single transferable vote or the single non-transferable vote." That ignores a number of other provisions.
Consequently, I feel that the alternative which was faced by the Government, was not that which Deputy Norton and other speakers have suggested, namely, whether to put the matter clearly or to cloud the issue. The problem surely, once you start trying to explain this Bill is: can you do anything less than put the Bill in the hands of every elector? The proposal is reasonable that you cannot really put the whole Bill in the hands of every elector in his own house, but you can readily make the Bill available in a public place, such as the post office, and he can buy one, if he wants one. Everyone will surely know the question at issue on the referendum is: "Do you want a change or do you want to maintain the present system?" Consequently, the form of the question on the ballot paper is: "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution?" Surely every voter is immediately put on his guard: "Will I vote ‘yes' for an amendment to the Constitution or will I vote ‘no' for an amendment of the Constitution?" That, to my mind, could not be clearer and any further explanation might only serve to increase the confusion.
I do not agree that this shows any sign of hurried drafting—quite the reverse. There is every reason to believe this matter has been very carefully considered. The Minister has decided that the only alternative is to refer the public to the Bill as a whole by reference to its title and leave the responsibility on them to inquire into the exact provisions, or else put the entire Bill into the hands of each elector. I do not think it is reasonable to expect the Government to incur the expenditure of public moneys in that way because the issue is a very simple one and the electors will understand it. Can we not just confine ourselves to that question which is the main one giving concern to the Opposition: "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution?"
I submit very definitely that that could not be clearer and I feel that, with the best will in the world, no alternative could be made to the suggestion which would improve it in any way.
Comment on this
Deputy Booth has brought out the real point which his Party is trying to put over on the people when he mentioned that, in his view, the interpretation of the ballot paper would be: do you want a change in the present system? That is quite wrong. What this ballot paper asks the people to do is to abolish the present system, not to change it. They are going around the country saying: "We need a change in the system. Will you vote for this Referendum Bill, which is designed to abolish the system?"
The system is well understood by the voters and has been operated by them in a very satisfactory way for the past 40 years. It is capable of any alteration which the Government wish to make, without abolishing it. The country at all times in the past 40 years has got, under the system, the type of Government for which it voted. That is why there is anxiety in the public mind at present regarding the proposal to abolish this system, regarding the action of the Government in using the majority, which they got to abolish unemployment and emigration——
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot drag unemployment or emigration, or even the merits of the Constitution into this debate.
Comment on this
I am just saying that the Government are using the majority which they have in this House in order to abolish the present system of voting and bring in a system which is foreign to this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy is continuing to argue that the Government are bringing in a measure which is contrary to the wishes of the people. That does not arise.
Comment on this
On a point of order, surely it is relevant to mention the purposes for which this Bill is being introduced.
Comment on this
The merits or demerits of the amendment to the Constitution do not arise on this Bill.
Comment on this
The merits or demerits of the particular measure to which the Deputy is referring will arise on another occasion.
Comment on this
Surely the amendment tabled by the Leader of the Opposition complains against the procedure adopted in this Bill because it does not give the people the information to which they are entitled, if they are to decide on the merits or the demerits.
Comment on this
I am not making that argument. I am trying to keep Deputy Rooney to the terms of the Referendum Bill.
Comment on this
I intend to discuss this Bill and to discuss what I believe will be its consequences. I presume I am entitled to follow that line. The Government are using their majority in this House to put through this Bill, and they are going to present a ballot paper to the general public which will not explain to them what the purpose of the referendum is. Very few people will understand that the Government, for their own purposes, have decided to amend the 1942 Act.
The 1942 Act set out in a very clear manner the way in which a referendum would be conducted, and specified also how the proposals should be explained to the voters going into the polling booths to cast their votes. That legislation was solemnly enacted here in 1942. Now it is thrown overboard as a matter of expediency so that the Government can adopt a more confusing type of ballot paper which will not be understood by the public in general, and is not to be explained to them. That is the main complaint. The people are entitled to be told what they are voting for when they are presented with a ballot paper.
Why all this silence on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party regarding that? Their purpose, of course, is to keep the people in a confused state of mind regarding the proposals to change the system of voting. We have a boasted Constitution which is being commemorated now by a stamp, and is being mutilated to suit the Fianna Fáil Party. It is obviously a slick trick to take from the people the power which they have in their hands at present. They have the power to express freely and clearly their own political opinions and their own wishes in relation to policy. Under the new system, with the aid of this ballot paper, we will have a Constitution under which 25 per cent of the people will have the ruling power over the remaining 75 per cent. It is almost certain to create amongst the people in general a spirit of vengeance and violence. We may be discussing legislation here to-day which will result, in not many years to come, in the arrival of a Castro in this country. The present system of voting has given Governments here——
Comment on this
I have asked the Deputy to confine himself to the terms of the measure before the House. Surely some of the things he said cannot be related in any way to the terms of the measure before the House.
Comment on this
The inclusion of the words "ballot paper" in the sentence will not make the matter relevant.
Comment on this
I am putting the case that it is unfair for the Government to bring any resolution here which will result in having a ballot paper presented to all classes of people. We shall have people arriving at the booth without spectacles; we shall have people arriving at the booth who are illiterate; and we shall have people arriving at the booth who, for one reason or another, will not be in a position to understand the consequences of casting "Yes" or "No" on the ballot paper presented to them because they are not being given information on the ballot paper as to what it means.
Any document that is presented to a person to mark or sign is usually read and understood by the person before he or she does so. Will the proposed document be read and understood by the people who will vote? In the first place, there will be nothing on it for them to read except the question whether they approve of the third amendment of the Constitution. It is most important that the people should know what they are voting for and that no attempt should be made by this Government to hoodwink them, to deceive them or to confuse them. No attempt is being made by the Government to make the position clear to the public as regards what it will mean to them to vote "Yes" or what it will mean to them to vote "No".
The various pieces of legislation relating to this matter—the 1942 and 1946 Acts and now the 1958 Bill—are very difficult to understand even in this House. Now we will present the people with a ballot paper without even giving them an elementary explanation. Surely they are entitled to an elementary explanation of the purpose of asking them to vote "Yes" or "No"?
Deputy Booth quite rightly showed the purpose in the mind of Fianna Fáil, that is, to leave the people in the position of thinking that only a change is taking place, instead of having the present system abolished and a new system adopted. That is what will happen if the referendum is carried. We shall have a new system and not a change in the existing system.
I feel there is a great measure of fair play in the minds of the people in general and that, if a proper effort is not made on this ballot paper to show them what they are voting for, we may find ourselves in a position in which there will be a national revolt and violence amongst the people. If it comes to that, can we expect the people to be held down by the Army, the Guards, the public services, if they realise that an injustice has been done to them? It is obvious that no attempt would be made by those public services to perpetrate an injustice.
It is obvious that the proposed system is designed by the Government to give a complete monopoly of Irish politics to the Fianna Fáil Party and to deprive the majority of people of proportional and adequate representation in the Parliament. We shall have a situation here where a minority of the people, possibly 25 per cent. of the people, will be electing a Government with a very substantial majority. It is obvious that, if that should occur——
Comment on this
I feel, in connection with the form of this ballot paper, that the voters should be asked in a very simple way: "Are you in favour of or against the proposed amendment of the Constitution?", instead of asking twice in a different way if they approve. You have, in respect of the word "Yes": "If you approve of the proposal, place the mark ‘X' in the square opposite the word ‘YES'." Again we see: "If you do not approve of the proposal, place the mark ‘X' opposite the word ‘NO'." There is no sign of a definite negative there which would point out to the people that they are to make a clear decision for or against.
The second suggestion: "If you do not approve of the proposal, place the mark ‘X' in the square opposite the word ‘NO'" is a very mild way of saying: "Well, we could not care less whether you put ‘X' opposite ‘NO' or not." But the first sentence is put very strongly to them: "If you approve of the proposal, place the mark ‘X' in the square opposite the word ‘YES'."
I feel that this Bill is capable of considerable amendment. I would ask the Government at this stage to play fair with the citizens because this Bill is being put before them and, if they should adopt it, the results of the vote that will be taken in this referendum may have their effect for many years to come in many different spheres of our national life. For that reason, the people should be treated fairly.
A ballot paper which would make the position clear to the people in no uncertain manner could be designed and should be designed. The people are being asked by a ballot paper of this type to take a leap into the dark. It could be a smokescreen for dictatorship. However, whatever it is, it is obvious that there are many people of all classes who could be confused by the ballot paper proposed here.
It is well known that electors who are not close to political activity take some time under the existing system to make up their minds before they reach a decision when they are going to the booth, but, at least, they have been doing that and making that decision for the past 40 years. It is unfair to bring in this system now and present them with a ballot paper they cannot properly understand. It is all very well for people who are close to political activity, ballot papers and all the rest, but they cannot expect all the people to understand what they are voting for. It is obvious the vast majority of the people will be kept in the dark.
The last part of this Referendum Bill sets out the words which a presiding officer may use when a person comes into the booth. The only words he is allowed to use are: "Do you approve of or do you object to that Bill becoming law?" It is fair enough for a voter to go to the presiding officer and ask him for an explanation of the questions on the ballot paper. Can you imagine a presiding officer explaining the consequences of "Yes" or "No" in this connection?
Any of us who have experience of the position in Dublin City and County know that long queues of people are outside all the polling booths, particularly from 7.30 p.m. until 9 o'clock. Would it be fair to expect the presiding officer to hold back that long queue of people in order to explain fairly to any voter the consequences of voting one way or the other and to explain to him also what the meagre wording on the ballot paper meant? There are other obvious defects in this Bill which could be amended at a later stage, but it is unfair for the Government to present us with a Bill of this kind, a Bill which will obviously have to be amended and which is, in its present form, designed to deceive the electorate.
Comment on this
I do not think there is anyone in the Opposition who believes that the amendment put down by Deputy John A. Costello and Deputy Mulcahy is genuine. The speakers on the Opposition side would fail to convince a completely impartial observer of the genuineness of their case.
Comment on this
Is it not quite obvious to anyone listening to the Opposition speakers that they are flogging a dead horse? Let the people know that this amendment to the Referendum Bill is completely frivolous and merely inserted to try to stir up uneasiness and unrest among certain sections of the electorate. The Opposition know in their hearts that this Referendum Bill is quite a sensible measure, and if anyone spoke in its favour, it was Deputy Rooney.
Let us take the case of a person going to the polling booth. If he goes to the polling booth, it follows that he goes for some purpose. He is not a complete idiot or going there to back a horse or fill in a football pool coupon. He knows he is going to the polling booth to vote on a certain matter. We take it that when he arrives at the polling booth, he knows what the issue before him will be, whether it be that P.R. should be abolished or not. In simple language, the Bill is designed to make it far easier for the presiding officer to explain to a voter who might not understand the proposal what it means, and goodness knows, there will be very few of them who by the time they get to the booth will not understand the issue.
As already explained by the Minister in his introductory remarks, if the 1942 Act is allowed to stand without amendment and a voter conveys to the presiding officer that he does not understand the issue, the presiding officer will be forced to read out the whole of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958, be it five or six pages, or whatever number of sections are contained in it. Deputy Rooney has referred to the queues outside the polling booths in Dublin City and County. Down in Kerry and Limerick, too, we have queues of people outside the booths from 7.30 p.m. until 9 p.m. Can you envisage the delay which would take place if the presiding officer had to read out the contents of that Bill to each voter? That is what would happen if the 1942 Act were allowed to stand as it is.
The position in relation to this proposal—and let the Opposition stop their bluffing—is that it should have flown through in 30 seconds because it is merely a measure to put the issue before the people in a very simple manner indeed.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will bear with me for a moment. The Leader of the Opposition, Deputy J. A. Costello, spoke of the time when the Referendum Bill of 1942 was before the House and he spoke of the calm, cool and collected atmosphere—a happy phrase of his—which obtained at that time. Anyone who took the trouble of reading, as I did, the debates which took place when the 1942 Bill was going through the House would have different ideas. Apropos of the calm, cool and collected atmosphere in 1942, Deputy Liam Cosgrave, for instance, made this contribution to that discussion at column 128, Volume 85, of the Official Debates of the 29th October, 1941:—
"We have here 32 pages of a Bill, introduced in a time of emergency and dealing with the procedure to be adopted at a referendum."
That certainly conflicts with the view of the Leader of the Opposition that the time when this Bill went through was a period of calm.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not know what he is talking about. He does not know about any part of it from beginning to end.
Comment on this
It was Deputy Cosgrave, anyway. I quoted the date and the appropriate paragraph. Not one member of the Labour Party, including Deputy Corish, contributed to what they now consider to be a most important issue. They did not bother to intervene in the debate, good, bad or indifferent, and I presume that at that time they agreed with all the provisions of the then Bill.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley is in possession and other Deputies will have opportunities to make their own speeches.
Comment on this
The main point made by Professor O'Sullivan at that time, in 1942, was that simplicity should be the keynote of the Bill.
Comment on this
There are some members of the House who have come into the Chamber since I started to speak and I ask them the question I put previously. Which is simpler for a presiding officer: to read out a small statement to a voter or to read out five or six pages of this Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill of 1958? There is the whole kernel of the business.
Comment on this
How much easier would it be for a presiding officer if P.R. were left as it is, that is, if the position were allowed to remain as it was in 1937?
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy cannot make a statement at this stage. The Deputy must cease interrupting.
Comment on this
Another point made by a speaker for the Opposition was that there would be people taking part in the referendum who would not have a grasp of the issues. The Opposition seem to feel that publishing a copy of the proposals in post offices would not be sufficient in itself, and I should like to point out that the Minister for Finance, in his opening remarks on the Second Reading of this Bill, stated that any reasonable suggestions or amendments by the Opposition would be considered by the Government. In that connection, I have no doubt that the Minister for Local Government would be quite amenable to any reasonable suggestions put forward and, if the Opposition think that publishing the proposals in post offices is not sufficient, I am sure he would be willing to use his good offices with his colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, to get time allotted on Radio Éireann to various speakers.
Comment on this
I will not stop, in the process, to discuss the pros and cons of the matter. Again, I am sure the Minister for Local Government would be prepared to consider taking space in the national Press—if it would satisfy the Opposition—to print advertisements setting out the proposals in toto. Would that satisfy the objection of the Opposition that the post office alone is not sufficient? Here am I, a member of the Government Party, suggesting this to my own Minister.
Comment on this
To listen to the speeches of the Opposition one would think that we were a race of semiilliterates, and that this is the first time the people have voted on such an issue. We had the referendum on the Constitution in 1937, and at that time the people were under no doubt as to what issue they were voting on. A rather extraordinary fact is that at that time, in 1937, there was also a general election.
Comment on this
There was a general election at the same time as the Constitution referendum was held, and an extraordinary thing was that 100,000 more people, approximately, voted for the Constitution than voted for Fianna Fáil the same day. That shows you that the Irish voter is an extraordinarily intelligent voter.
Comment on this
I often wonder if the Fine Gael summer school out at Malahide will ever put on its curriculum a section called logic—simple, pure logic. I bring that point to the notice of the House as a very interesting little aside. I believe I have covered every point except the one raised by Deputy Rooney about voters who fail to understand the import of the question, but again the Opposition, had they listened to the Minister's introductory remarks, would have heard him say:—
"The Second Schedule contains minor consequential amendments to the rules governing the form of notice of poll and the procedure for voting by physically incapacitated or illiterate voters."
That, I think, is another change which aims at simplifying the whole set-up. I do not know why the Minister does not pitch the whole Bill back at the Opposition.
Comment on this
The Government have gone out of their way in this measure to make things easier for the public. They have bent over backwards.
Comment on this
They will listen to constructive suggestions, as the Minister for Finance said, but certainly these frivolous objections of the Opposition should not be allowed to go unchallenged. Deputy O'Sullivan stated that not one member of the Fianna Fáil Party got up to support the Minister, after the Leader of the Opposition had spoken, but I looked upon it as such a simple and sensible measure that, like Saint Paul's Epistle to the Ephesians, there was nothing further to add, but at least the public know now that the conduct of the Opposition is simply designed to stir up unrest and misgivings, and I do not think they will be at all successful in that effort.
Comment on this
When the Fianna Fáil Ministers and Deputies were speaking here on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, their greatest claim, so far as I can recall, was that the issue would be put before the people. If the issue were to be before the people in the form this Bill suggests, I am afraid many of the people will not have an idea of the issue on which they are voting. One of the reasons which the Government have given for the proposal to abolish P.R. is that the people do not understand it. Many members of the Government and their supporters made the point that P.R. was too complicated. I think Deputy O'Malley was one of those who said that P.R. was so complicated that it should be scrapped.
Here now they are being asked to say "yes" or "no" to an amendment of the Constitution which one could not describe as simple. It is true to say that two or three of the proposals are in themselves simple and straightforward, but there are other issues which are not so simple; yet they are expected to vote on this issue, an issue which many of them have not seen in print. The Minister, in his introductory speech, anticipated, I am sure, some of the criticisms which might come from members of the Opposition Parties. He admitted frankly that many people had not seen the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, but said very blandly that if they had not seen it, they could buy it in the post office.
I do not know whether or not the Minister will appreciate this, but I am sure he will, as he is a man who comes from a rural area, or what sometimes is described as a depressed or undeveloped area. Can the Minister tell me how many of the people in Donegal will have the money, the 1/-, 1/6, the 2/- or the 2/6, or whatever the Act might cost, to go into the post office and say: "Please, sir, I want a copy of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill?"
Comment on this
How many will? Deputy O'Malley says that they can read it. Did he ever see a register of electors in the post office?
Comment on this
It is a very bulky document. There are 7,000 voters in the town of Wexford. I should like to see the mess and the queues there would be in the three post offices in Wexford, with people clamouring to read this Third Amendment of the Constitution Act, as we assume it will be. I think it is fantastic that on such an important issue as this the Minister should say, on behalf of the Government, that if the people want to know what the referendum is about, they can buy a copy of the Act in the post office. Apart from the inconvenience, people are not going to pay l/-, or 1/6, or whatever the price is, merely to see this Act.
Deputy O'Malley says that the Minister could make arrangements to have the Bill—I think he meant the whole Bill—published in the daily newspapers. I do not know whether people realise it or not, but a very big proportion of the population, despite the boasts of the daily papers, do not read the daily papers. Their reading is confined to the weekly papers circulating in their own areas. Therefore it is not feasible—it is impossible—that they should see the Bill in the form in which it is presented to the members of the Dáil and Seanad. It is not possible for a big proportion to afford the money to buy it and not possible for them to see it in the post office; therefore in all fairness there should be a concise statement on the ballot paper as to the main issues involved.
There are three main issues involved. One is the abolition of P.R. and the change to the straight vote; the second is the single member constituency; and the third is a commission to determine the boundaries. I do not think that would take up a lot of paper. It would not be very expensive. As it is, if an illiterate voter does not understand the ballot paper and asks the presiding officer to explain, the presiding officer merely quotes the Long and Short Titles. Deputy O'Malley seems to be more concerned about the inconvenience which might be caused to presiding officers.
Deputies forget that tens of thousands who want to vote will not have the issue put clearly before them. We must, if we are to take the word of the spokesman of the Fianna Fáil Party, consider this a serious issue, this proposed change from P.R. to the straight vote. The Minister for Health spoke at length and cited the cases of half a dozen, or a dozen countries and told us that because they had the straight vote, they were enjoying and had enjoyed prosperity for decades. If we are to believe what the Minister for Health said, he means to suggest that if we change from P.R. to the straight vote, we are going to have an improvement in the general economy of the country.
Comment on this
I am merely trying to stress the importance, as presented to us by the Fianna Fáil speakers, of this proposed change to the straight vote and if we are to have such important and drastic changes consequent on the change in the method of election it is important that the people should have the issue put clearly and concisely to them. Therefore, I suggest that the Minister should send a copy of the proposals contained in this Bill, described as the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, to every voter. I do not think that would be an impossible task.
Comment on this
If the Minister likes, let him send a copy of the Bill to every single voter. In a general election, the candidates are entitled to have sent to every voter in their constituency a copy of their election address. That is sent free, without any charge by the post office. We merely address the election materials, dump them in bundles in the post office, check them in and they are distributed—we hope—to every voter in the constituency. I suggest that is what the Minister should do. So far as we are concerned, we do not oppose this Bill because it comes from the Fianna Fáil Party. We oppose it because it does not allow the issue in the referendum, that we are, we believe, to have this year, being put clearly before the people. It seems to me therefore that the issue will be represented to the country as being for or against "Dev".
It would be wrong if that were to be the issue. It would be wrong if the issue were to be so represented, but if a statement were sent to every single voter, and that could easily be done, the people would have a greater appreciation of the whole matter and would vote not according to Party but according to their beliefs. I suggest that the Minister should do that and not have this referendum develop into a dog-fight, as it undoubtedly will, if one side of the country is to say "Vote ‘no'" and the other to say "Vote ‘yes"'. Let the people know what is the issue and then I believe you will get a clear and honest opinion from the voters.
Comment on this
This Bill which has been introduced by the Minister for Local Government is ill-considered and ill-conceived and that is putting it mildly. I believe this is far more serious than Deputy O'Malley would have us believe. I do not want to attribute motives to the Minister or the Government, but if this Bill were introduced with the deliberate intention of depriving the people of the opportunity of knowing what they are being required to vote for in a constitutional referendum, then I would have no hesitation in condemning the Bill as an outrageous and audacious piece of political thimble-rigging.
Let us see what the Bill proposes to do. I am prepared to give the Minister, Deputy O'Malley and the other Deputies on that side of the House credit for having gone into this business without having considered it, not having gone into it deliberately in order to produce the results this Bill is likely to produce. At the moment we have legislation enacted dealing with the carrying out of referenda in this country. Machinery to operate in the case of any referendum, constitutional or otherwise, is set out in an Act passed through this House under the auspices of Fianna Fáil in 1942 and, as Deputy O'Sullivan has already pointed out, without ever giving that Act an opportunity of working, without ever seeing whether it would be effective or not, we have a Fianna Fáil Government, on what they believe to be the eve of a referendum to amend the Constitution, coming in with a Bill to alter the rules under which that referendum will be held.
As far as I am concerned—and I mean no disrespect whatever to the Chair when I say this—I do not see how any Deputy can give this matter proper consideration or represent, as he ought to represent, the constituents who sent him here, if he stands up and takes part in this discussion blinding himself to the fact that we are discussing the Bill at a time when we also have on the Order Paper a Fianna Fáil Government Bill to abolish P.R., to abolish the single transferable vote and the multi-seat constituencies which have operated here for the past 36 years.
It would be quite unreasonable to expect any Deputy to deal with this Bill seriously and, at the same time, blind himself to the fact that those proposals are before the House. I do not think the Minister or any Deputy behind him will challenge the statement that this Referendum Bill is brought in as part of the Government's proposals to amend the Constitution and the electoral system under which Parliament is elected. We must keep that fact at the back of our minds when discussing this Bill. Even if that were not so, if those two Bills were not being run one alongside the other through the House, the present Bill would be a bad one, but the fact of the matter is that both Bills are there and we cannot consider one without having regard to the other.
The first point of importance in this discussion is to remember that although Fianna Fáil themselves proposed to the House and had passed through the House the Referendum Act of 1942, now, without giving that Act an opportunity of working, they are bringing in a Bill to alter the Act very materially, to alter it in a way which may have very serious consequences for the voters. What are their proposals now? In 1942, Fianna Fáil had an Act passed which made it obligatory on any Government proposing an amendment of the Constitution to ensure that in the ballot paper put before the people when voting on such amendment, there should be an explanation as to what the whole thing was about—there should be something appearing on the ballot paper explaining to the voter the question involved.
If I may give an illustration, if this present referendum were introduced, there would be an obligation on the Fianna Fáil Government in connection with the proposed third amendment of the Constitution to place on the ballot paper an explanation telling voters what was involved in the proposal, telling them that the proposal was designed to do away with P.R., with the single transferable vote, with multi-seat constituencies and that it was also designed to set up a commission, against whose decision there would be no appeal, to this House, to the courts or to the country, dealing with the revision of constituencies.
There would be an obligation on Deputy O'Malley's Government to give that information to the people. Further than that, if anyone went to vote and were not clear as to what the proposal was, if for one reason or another he were unable to understand the proposal, if he were blind or illiterate, he had a right to go to the presiding officer and ask for an explanation under the 1942 Act. Under that Act, the presiding officer had to give that further explanation and had to tell him what it was about. Now the Fianna Fáil Government, on the eve of proposing a vital change in our electoral system, bring in side by side with that, a Bill to relieve them of the responsibility of explaining to the voters, by explanatory note or memorandum on the ballot paper, what the proposed change in the Constitution is.
Does Deputy O'Malley blame us for being suspicious? Deputy O'Malley dismisses the amendment put down by Deputies Costello and Mulcahy as "not genuine" and "frivolous". Has Deputy O'Malley even read the amendment? It reads:—
"To delete all the words after the word ‘That' and substitute therefor the words: ‘Dáil Éireann declines to give a Second Reading to the Bill..."'
Why?
"‘...as it proposes to deprive the voter of that knowledge of the issue on which he is asked to express an opinion, as would otherwise be set out on the ballot paper as required by Section 15 (4) of the Referendum Act, 1942."'
Is there any Fianna Fáil Deputy who will seriously suggest that a voter voting on a vital issue affecting the Constitution under which we live— voting on such a particularly fundamental issue as the electoral system under which our Parliament and Government are to be elected—should be deprived of that knowledge when he goes in to express his views by casting his vote in the referendum?
Deputy O'Malley dismisses that argument by asking if a person goes along to the polling booth at all, is he not going there for some purpose? Does he not know why he is going there? If he does not know why he is going there, he would not be going there at all. That is just cheap verbal fencing. If there were any force or effect in that argument, would Deputy O'Malley say why the Fianna Fáil Government took the trouble to bring the Act of 1942 before the House and get it passed by the House? If there were any force and effect in his argument, would he tell me why the Fianna Fáil Government are taking the trouble now of trying to jettison a vital portion of the Act of 1942, on the eve of the referendum to do away with our present electoral system and to replace it with the English electoral system?
The 1942 Act provided that that explanation would be given to the people on the ballot paper and that, if they were in any doubt about it for any reason—because of illiteracy or for some reason of physical disability— they would be entitled to ask the presiding officer and to get an explanation from the presiding officer.
Comment on this
I just want to contradict the statement. He cannot ask for an explanation. The presiding officer has to read out the whole text of the Bill—as things stand now.
Comment on this
I hope I will get Deputy O'Malley the reference before I am through. My understanding of the position, and I have not any serious doubt about it, is that under the 1942 Act there was an obligation to put on the ballot paper an explanation as to what was contained in the Bill. The reference is Section 15 of the Referendum Act, 1942. Sub-section (4) of that section reads:—
"Every ballot paper in respect of one referendum shall contain a statement of the proposal which is the subject of such referendum, and every ballot paper in respect of two or more referenda having the same polling day shall contain, in respect of each such referendum, a statement of the proposal which is the subject of such referendum."
Sub-section (5) of Section 15 reads:—
"At a constitutional referendum, the proposal which is the subject thereof shall be stated on the ballot paper in the same terms as nearly as may be as such proposal is stated in the Bill containing such proposal passed or deemed to have been passed by both Houses of the Oireachtas."
In the First Schedule to the Referendum Act of 1942, the rules of procedure to be adopted by presiding officers are laid down. I shall have these looked up and shall give the Deputy the reference later. One of these rules laid down what the presiding officer was to do in such an event. I think I shall be able to satisfy Deputy O'Malley that the 1942 Act required that the explanation which appeared on the ballot paper be given to the voter and that he would then be asked whether he approved or disapproved of the proposal.
That is the first change being made under this Bill. Instead of having printed on the ballot paper the information concerning the proposal on which the voter is asked to vote, the only thing to appear now will be the Short Title of the particular Bill to amend the Constitution—and, as I say, we are discussing this proposal in the atmosphere of the Fianna Fáil Government's introduction of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill which proposes the abolition of P.R., the abolition of the single transferable vote, the reduction of the constituencies to single-seat constituencies and the introduction of a commission dealing with the revision of constituencies.
Instead of giving that information, the Fianna Fáil Party, for some reason best known to themselves, say: "No, we are going to jettison our own Act of 1942, untried and untested though it may be, and we are going to introduce a Referendum Bill which will preclude by law the giving of any information to the voter, other than the mere fact that he is voting on a Bill to amend the Constitution." That is a drastic change. I hesitate to use strong words, but I can say that, if that proposal has been seriously considered by the Government, it is an outrageous and audacious one.
The particular rule to which I was referring, under the Referendum Act of 1942, is Rule 18 (3) (c), which says:
"where the voter fails to understand the import of the said question, the presiding officer shall read out to the voter the proposal as stated on the ballot paper and then ask the voter, "Do you approve of, or do you object to that proposal becoming law?"
In other words, there is an obligation on the presiding officer to give to the voter the explanation of the proposal which appears on the ballot paper and to ask the voter whether or not he approves of that becoming law.
What happens under the new set up envisaged by the Fianna Fáil Party? No information appears on the ballot paper. All that appears on the ballot paper is the Short Title of the particular Amendment of the Constitution Bill which may be under consideration; and that Short Title contains no information other than the fact that it is a Bill to amend the Constitution. It might be a Bill to abolish the Presidency. There may be people in Deputy O'Malley's constituency who feel that it would be a great idea to abolish the Presidency and save the country some money. That might be the proposal, for all the information given when the Short Title is the only thing given on the ballot paper.
Is there anything to explain to a voter whether the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill relates to abolishing the office of President or relates to abolishing the electoral system which we have been operating in this country for the past 36 years? What information is given? If no information is given, I assert that this is a case where such information should be given. I want to ask Deputies opposite—I want to ask the Minister for Health, who for the moment is in charge of these proceedings—why do Fianna Fáil not want the people to get that information when they go in to vote in the referendum? Why do they not want the people to know what is involved in the third amendment of the Constitution? Why do they object to carrying out their own legislation, passed by them 16 years ago?
Deputy O'Malley said that this Bill should have gone through the House in 30 seconds. It took 16 years for Deputy O'Malley's colleagues to find any fault with the Referendum Act of 1942. Why now, on the eve of their proposal to abolish the electoral system and replace it by the English system, do they feel it is necessary to amend this law?
As I understood the Minister for Local Government, he said something to the effect that as he was advised if he were to adhere to the Fianna Fáil Act of 1942, it would be necessary virtually to print the entire of any Bill to amend the Constitution on the ballot paper. I do not know what advice the Minister was given but I assume that that advice is sound and that the Minister felt that if there were no alteration in the law, he would have to accept that advice and that consequently the ballot paper would become cumbersome. Would it not be very easy to remedy that position without introducing the drastic amendment to clamp down on giving the people any information whatever? Would it not be quite easy to amend sub-section (5) of Section 15 of the Referendum Act, 1942, to provide that the sponsors of the referendum would be entitled to put a precis or summary of the Act and some short explanation of the proposals in the Bill on the ballot paper?
Would there be any objection to that? Would that not save the Minister for Local Government the embarrassment he thinks he would now face in printing the entire Bill on the ballot paper? Why is it necessary to go from one extreme to the other? Why is it necessary to move from the position in which, according to the Minister for Local Government, he is bound to give the people all information and print the entire Bill on the ballot paper, to the opposite extreme, where he gives the people no information other than the mere Title of the Bill?
The Title of the Bill, even for Dáil Deputies, does not give any information whatever. What information is it likely to give the ordinary citizen who has never listened to the proceedings in this Chamber? The Bill is entitled "The Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958." To a person who has not followed the discussions in this House, what information will that convey? To the illiterate person, the person who cannot read, who is not able to follow what is written in the newspapers or to go into a post office and read the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958, what information or knowledge will it convey if the presiding officer says to him: "You are asked to say whether or not you approve of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958."
If that unfortunate man asks the presiding officer: "Well, what is the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958, all about?" the presiding officer will have to say to him: "I am not allowed to tell you that. As far as I am concerned, I am not doing my job here, unless I ensure you vote with blinkers on, without knowing what is in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958."
That is the first and the most grievous objection to the proposals being put before us by the Government in this Bill. As Deputy Costello pointed out, there are other objections which require to be dealt with. One of these is in connection with the form of the question to be put on the ballot paper. If the Government endeavour to amend the Constitution or submit any other question to the people for decision in a referendum, under existing legislation, there is an obligation on them to have the alternative printed clearly on the ballot paper and to see to it that when the voter gets his ballot paper, the question to be put to him is: "Do you approve or do you disapprove of" the particular proposal which is the subject matter of the referendum?
Deputy O'Malley seems to feel that this whole discussion is frivolous. Will he tell me why his Cabinet has decided that on this occasion it is necessary to amend the law so that the question to be put to the people in the referendum the Government propose holding to amend the Constitution, to abolish P.R., to abolish the single transferable vote, to abolish multiple seat constituencies and to set up a commission to revise the constituencies, is merely the question: "Do you approve of the proposal?" and that the question will not be put to the people: "Do you approve or disapprove of the proposal?" Why is it necessary to bring in that alteration? Even if we accept all the arguments made by the Minister for Local Government and his supporters as to why they should be relieved of the bonus of explaining the proposal to the people on the ballot paper, is there any reason why that amendment deleting the words "or do you disapprove" should be incorporated in this Referendum Bill, 1958?
The third major factor I have already dealt with in passing and that is the fact that previously, under existing legislation, the voter who did not understand what was required of him or what he was voting on, when his questions had been answered by the presiding officer, at least got some type of explanation. There was an obligation on the presiding officer to give him the information set out in the ballot paper. Another change is proposed here. Under the Second Schedule of this Bill, the voter in that difficulty will not get the same information from the presiding officer.
It is provided in the Second Schedule that in those circumstances this procedure is to be followed:—
"(c) where the voter fails to understand the import of the said question, the presiding officer shall read out to the voter the Short Title of the Bill to amend the Constitution as stated on the ballot paper and then ask the voter, ‘Do you approve of or do you object to that Bill becoming law?' and then mark the ballot paper in accordance with the answer of the voter;".
We are dealing now with the voter who has not been able to understand the import of the replies he has received from the presiding officer. Possibly we are dealing with an illiterate voter who is unable to read and therefore cannot go into a post office and wade through a Bill to amend the Constitution, but the only information he will be entitled to get from the presiding officer is the Short Title of the Bill, which gives no information at all.
I take a very serious view of these changes which the Government are now asking the House to adopt. I do not know whether the Government seriously considered the possible effect of the measure they are asking the House to enact, but, now that these misgivings have been pointed out to them, now that the difficulties which this legislation is likely to create for voters have been pointed out, we are, I think, entitled to ask the Government to withdraw this Bill and to reconsider the position. We are entitled to ask them to stand on their own legislation of 1942 and if, having considered the matter, having heard the views of Deputies here regarding the misgivings they have, the Government refuse to do that, then all we can do is to invite the Minister for Local Government, in those circumstances, to take back this dirty little Bill to the Custom House and throw it in the wastepaper basket.
Comment on this
I would not have intervened in this debate were it not for the speech made by Deputy O'Sullivan in which he referred to the 1942 Act as the Fianna Fáil Act and suggested that it had been so carelessly drafted that, on the very first occasion upon which it was necessary to use it, we had to come here to amend it.
The 1942 Act was quite frankly regarded by both sides of the House as an experimental measure. The then Leader of the Opposition, Deputy W. T. Cosgrave, had this to say about it: I am quoting from Volume 85, column 128 of the Official Reports:—
"This is neither the time nor the place to pass judgment upon a referendum, but I might mention that it has not been a success in any country in which it has been employed and most countries have rejected it. It has a disturbing influence—that is nearly all we may say about it."
Of course, we do not agree with that. On the contrary, we think that the importance of the referendum has now transpired, even in the course of this debate when we were told that we must be at special pains to keep the people informed as to the issue which will be put before them.
I do not disagree with that point of view. It is, in fact, my own view. But there is a very practical difficulty which has been adverted to by the Leader of the Opposition, a very practical difficulty in view of the fact that the text of the Bill covers no less than 13 pages. There are probably over 1,000,000 voters and there would have to be something over 1,000,000 ballot papers, each containing 14 pages. From the physical point of view alone, that would constitute a very serious problem indeed. That has been recognised by Deputy Michael O'Higgins in the course of his speech. He realises that it would render the referendum farcical, were we to present each voter with a ballot paper containing anything up to 16 pages, asking the voter to mark that paper in the congested conditions which will certainly prevail in polling booths in our cities and towns. There is, therefore, a very practical difficulty to be dealt with here.
I take it that the Opposition are as anxious as we are, now that the proposal has been put before the Dáil, that the people should have the right to decide. I take it that every member of this House, irrespective of what side he sits, is equally anxious that the people should have an opportunity of deciding this issue, perhaps deciding it once and for all. I certainly do not believe, in the light of some of the speeches made here to-day, that the Opposition are anxious to preclude the people from giving a decision upon this issue and I take it, therefore, that the Opposition will be prepared to co-operate with us in trying to find a practical solution for this very difficult problem.
I referred to what the Leader of the Opposition said on the Second Stage of the Referendum Bill in 1941. I want to contrast that now with the tone in which Deputy O'Sullivan referred to that Bill. At column 128, Deputy Cosgrave said:—
"We have here 32 pages of a Bill, introduced in a time of emergency"—
He differed apparently from the present Leader of the Opposition as to the circumstances in which the Bill was introduced because he said it was introduced in a time of emergency—
"and dealing with the procedure to be adopted at a referendum. Presumably it is not a controversial measure."
I suggest that this ought not to be a controversial measure, either. It is a measure in relation to which, once we accept the principle that something must be done to make it a practical possibility to take the referendum, we should be concerned to see how the machinery will best operate. Deputy W.T. Cosgrave said:—
"...it is not a controversial measure and the steps to be taken to regulate how votes are to be cast, how they are to be counted and the provision for petitions against a measure ought not to be considered in any other manner than as an ordinary act of administration."
I am glad to say that was the spirit in which the then Opposition debated and considered the Referendum Act of 1942. They accepted the position that in relation to a machinery matter of this sort, when the principle had already been determined by the people, it was their duty just as much as it was the duty and obligation of the Government, to devise the best possible machinery that could be provided.
We are up against this difficulty to-day. We have had no experience of the taking of a referendum except for the referendum on the Constitution of 1937, the Constitution we have now all accepted. There the matter was to some extent simplified by reason of the fact that a very large number of copies of the Constitution were distributed privately, as Deputy Michael O'Higgins has said, by the sponsors of the Constitution, which happened to be the Government of the day. It was frankly recognised by speakers on both sides, not merely by myself, who happened to be the Minister in charge of the Bill, but also by the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy W. T. Cosgrave, and by the late Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan, that we had to face up to the fact that we were really making a trial draft of the law which would regulate the taking of a referendum. The extraordinary thing about it is that, though certain amendments had been put down to sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 15, there was no amendment put down to sub-section (5) of Section 15.
Comment on this
It is sub-section (5) which relates to a constitutional referendum. I am not in charge of this Bill and it might be quite possible that I might refer incorrectly by number to the particular provision in the Bill.
Comment on this
The amendments were put down to sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 15 and, after a very brief and reasonable discussion—let me say that I appreciated very greatly at the time the approach which the then Opposition adopted towards this measure—after a very brief and amicable discussion across the House, these amendments were withdrawn. Now, they were not withdrawn because it was held either by the Minister in charge of the Bill or by the Deputies that we had in the Bill a solution to the difficulty, but because it was quite clearly recognised that the approach to the whole problem had to be empirical; that we would pass the Bill in the form in which it then stood because there was not any other Act relating to the taking of a referendum; we would pass the Bill in the form in which it stood and deal with the practical difficulties as they happened to arise.
In fact, referring to one of these amendments, the amendment relating to the printing of two separate proposals in respect to which referenda were being taken upon one ballot paper——
Comment on this
——in relation to that, having discussed the matter across the floor of the House with the late Deputy Professor O'Sullivan, I having rather deprecated the fact that the Minister might determine that particular question by regulation, Professor O'Sullivan said:—
"I do not see why the Minister should bind his hands."
I replied:—
"If it was found that this proposal did not work very satisfactorily it would be easy to bring in a one-clause Bill."
Deputy O'Sullivan deprecated that and said:—
"Is not that a very cumbersome method of dealing with it?"
I said:—
"If the Deputy is suggesting that we should take power by regulation to prescribe the form of the ballot paper subject to certain safe-guards——"
Deputy O'Sullivan said:—
"All right."
I said:—
"Very well. I will consider it and see what we can do about that. I will consider bringing in an amendment on those lines on Report Stage."
I am quoting. Sir, from column 1099, Volume 85 of the Official Report.
In consequence of that, amendments Nos. 2 and 3 were withdrawn, and on the section there was further discussion in which Professor O'Sullivan then raised the very issue that is now being raised, as to what we should do in relation to the manner in which the proposal for the referendum should appear upon the ballot paper and I said:—
"Normally the assumption underlying the section as it stands is that the proposal to amend the Constitution would relate to one specific provision in the Constitution. I do not think that it would be very easy to do anything except to refer the whole of the Bill in itself."
Professor O'Sullivan said:—
"Then it would have to go on the ballot paper?"
I said:—
"I am afraid so."
Professor O'Sullivan said:—
"I think so."
We were all very optimistic and hopeful at the time.
Comment on this
Wait now. Professor O'Sullivan then went on to refer to the Trade Union Bill, where a referendum was demanded upon that. Professor O'Sullivan then said:—
"Suppose I am a person who is in a position to object to, say, the Trade Union Bill and suppose I can get sufficient backing for my objection."
Professor O'Sullivan went on to say:—
"The ballot paper then will be extraordinarily cumbersome."
What was he referring to? He was not referring to the sort of amendment to the Constitution which both sides of the House envisaged, at that time. He was referring to a legislative proposal which I think contained over 100 sections. I am talking from recollection. I have not refreshed myself on the Trade Union Act, but it contains over 100 sections and he put it to me——
Comment on this
Professor O'Sullivan asked in that debate that there should be succinct and accurate expression of the proposal on the paper. The Minister, in response, gave an assurance. Would the Minister like to read his assurance?
Comment on this
Let me see what my assurance was. We had better try to put this somewhat more coherently. Professor O'Sullivan asked me what would be the position of a person who got sufficient backing for a proposal to refer the Trade Union Bill, as it was then, to the people on a referendum and he said:—
"If the President makes up his mind that it is a fair statement of my reasons for objecting to what is in the Bill, he accepts it and sends it to the Taoiseach. That then goes on the ballot paper and it may occupy a couple of pages. It might be the best way, in my opinion, of bringing the matter before the elector. The ballot paper then will be extraordinarily cumbersome."
Even with two pages. What would it be with 16?