We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Referendum (Amendment) Bill, 1958—Second Stage.

Contributions 140–273 of 273. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Referendum (Amendment) Bill, 1958
Enacted

No. 31 of 1958 ›

Because it will be 16 with this ballot paper.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

If the whole Bill goes on. There are 14 pages in it.

Comment on this

No. Look at the last sentence of your speech in column 1102.

Comment on this

Wait now. I am coming to it.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I point out in relation to Deputy O'Higgins's interruption and reference to Professor O'Sullivan's cross-examination, that what the Minister at that time referred to in columns 1101 and 1102 was an entirely different matter? Professor O'Sullivan was dealing with a petition.

Comment on this

We can read it. The Minister will read it for us. Why not let him do it?

Comment on this

I read it.

Comment on this

He did not read it very carefully. Column 1103: "I cited a Bill...." The only point in that interruption was to give the Minister a chance of reading it. He has had it now. It was a nice helpful method of giving the Minister a chance to read it.

Comment on this

Has the Minister read it?

Comment on this

If I may resume— first of all, let me say, with all due deference to Deputy O'Malley, it was not a case of cross-examination; it was a case of joint discussion in council as to how to deal with this particular problem and all that emerges is that we frankly were not able at that time, sitting in committee, to find a satisfactory solution. That is the only thing that comes out of that discussion. Deputy O'Malley has pointed out, however, that we are now dealing, not with the subject-matter of sub-sections (2), (3) and (4) of Section 15, but with the subject-matter of sub-section (5) of Section 15, which is quite a different thing. But if Deputy Sweetman is anxious for me to recall to the House what I did say on 3rd December 17 years ago, I am quite prepared to do it. I do not think there is anything which would in any way substantiate the sort of speeches which have been made, particularly by Deputy O'Sullivan, here to-day. I said:—

"I do not think the public will be in any ignorance as to what they are voting on, but in any event they will have to guide them an authoritative statement of the nature of the proposal, the statement which is contained, first in the petition which the President in accepting and acting upon has approved of as being a fair and equitable representation of it...."

There is no question of a petition here in the case of a Bill to amend the Constitution. There cannot be any question of a petition here. Do we agree on that?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Therefore, that statement of mine had not particular reference to the problem which we are now discussing. Is that not admitted?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

It had not—not in that context.

Comment on this

The Minister is taking part of it out of its context.

Comment on this

I am not. I am keeping it in its context. What the Deputy has been trying to do is to take it out of its context and utilise it in relation to quite another problem. However, we go on:—

"...and, secondly, in the President's message to the Taoiseach. It will perhaps be mainly upon that representation and that view of it that the people will determine their votes...."

In relation to a matter of ordinary legislation which has been the subject of a petition. That is clear.

Comment on this

It is not a bit clear.

Comment on this

It is clear. I quote:—

"...contained, first, in the petition which the President in accepting and acting upon has approved of as being a fair and equitable representation of it."

Comment on this

Does it not go on the ballot paper according to the Minister's assurance at the time?

Comment on this

I am sure we are-all very anxious, if we are to amend the provisions of the Referendum Act, which deal particularly with a constitutional amendment, not merely this one but any change which may arise in the future, to find a way out of this dilemma. You cannot deny it is a dilemma. There will be 16 pages of this Bill on the ballot paper. It would be quite impossible for the people to handle it. If the position is that members would be satisfied with having something like the Long Title expanded so as to cover the main provisions of the Bill, we could consider that. If the Deputies from the opposite side who are concerned to ensure that the matter will be put fairly to the people will put down an amendment, we are open to consider that.

This does not necessitate, as Deputy O'Higgins suggested, the withdrawal of the Bill. It is quite clear that the Title of the Bill is so drawn that any reasonable amendment could be considered, so that on the Committee Stage, if the Deputies had anything to suggest which would help us to solve the problem in that way, I am perfectly certain that the Minister for Local Government will be prepared to consider it. We want the ballot paper to be as compact as we properly can.

Comment on this

As what?

Comment on this

As compact. I think that, as a matter of ordinary common sense, that should be agreed upon. We want the proposal to be put fairly within this limitation. If the members of the Opposition have any proposal to suggest, I am sure the Minister for Local Government will consider it with an open mind.

Comment on this

I admired the Minister for having said that they wanted to put it fairly to the people. The Minister asked if the Opposition had any suggestion to make. I suggest it should be made as plain as possible to the people what they are voting for or against. In one part of the ballot paper, it asks: "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution in the undermentioned Bill?" Why put it in that form? Why not put it in this form: "Do you disapprove of it?" We are as much entitled to put it that way as the other.

Therefore, that is very unfair. It is not being put fairly to the people. It says: "Do you approve of it?" I think that is very unfair. I have a suggestion to put forward. Why not have it the same as in a general election? Under this proposal, if a blind person, for example, goes to the returning officer and asks for an explanation, the only explanation he gets is that it is the third amendment of the Constitution.

Of course, the Minister for Health is only playing politics when he talks about having 16 pages. Why not tell the people that this is a Bill to abolish or not to abolish P.R.? That would make it very plain to them. It would not require 16 pages to tell them that. Why not put it that way? It is just the same as a general election. There is a list of voters. A person who is blind and not capable of reading the names hands his ballot paper to the returning officer. Will the returning officer say to him: "I will not read it for you"? This is a general election. How many people could vote at all then?

I do not think that this is a mistake on the part of the Civil Service. I say it is a deliberate attempt to mislead the people. If the Minister wants a way out of it, there is a way out of it. Let it not be to refer the voter to the amendment of the Constitution. Tell him straight that it is a vote for or against the abolition of P.R. That will not take 16 pages.

This is not a Bill upon which a speech can be made. Any Deputy who endeavoured to speak for a long time on this would be like operating a hula hoop—going round in circles. I ask the Minister to accept my suggestion and put the matter straight to the people. They should be told that they are voting for or against the abolition of P.R. That would make it very simple.

Comment on this

The Minister for Health can be the most naive person under the sun, when he wants to be. He excelled himself to-day in his naive approach to this problem. First of all, before I discuss this Bill, may I correct his memory in relation to what took place on 3rd December, 1941? The debate to which he referred and which had some reference to legislation on a referendum was preceded and followed by most specific references, by the late Professor O'Sullivan, and by the Minister for Local Government as he then was, the present Minister for Health, to the fact that they were considering the question of what was to go on the ballot paper for a Bill dealing with the Constitution and not merely a Bill dealing with ordinary legislation.

Column 1100 is full of such references. At column 1103, Professor O'Sullivan summed it up when he said:—

"I cited a Bill which, in the normal way, would have to go before the people—a Constitution Amendment Bill."

It was in relation to that, that the proposals in the 1942 Act were introduced by the then Government and piloted through the House by Deputy MacEntee, then Minister for Local Government.

I did not understand the Minister for Health to-day when he said he made it clear that in 1942, it was then an experimental measure, and that it was being amended now as a result of consideration of that experiment. The only interpretation I can give to the word "experiment" is something that has been tried, and the fact is that since that measure was passed, there has been no referendum to the people, on foot of that Bill. It is quite nonsensical to suggest that this amendment is being brought in purely as a result of what has transpired, and been seen by experience, since that Referendum Bill, as there has been no referendum.

The Minister for Health also tried deliberately to mislead the House into believing that this Bill is a Bill having sole reference to the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill which is going through. Of course it has not. It is a general Bill.

Comment on this

No; I did not say so.

Comment on this

While it may be that the Short Title of every Bill, of every Constitution Amendment Bill, is to be the matter which is to go on ballot papers in the future and it is not only in relation to specific problems that may be posed in the Bill in question that we are asked to put this——

Comment on this

I do not like to interrupt the Deputy——

Comment on this

I willingly give way to the Minister.

Comment on this

There are two points to which I should like to draw the Deputy's attention.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

The first is the form of the ballot paper. We had been dealing with the Trade Union Act in 1941. I said at column 1103:—

"I do not know what it means, but I do not propose to prognosticate as to what it will eventually involve in the form of a ballot paper."

It is quite clear that I had a very open mind as to what the shape of ballot papers, in future, might be on a referendum.

The next point I want to make is that I suggested we could deal with this proposition by expanding the Long Title and providing that the Long Title would appear on the ballot paper, not the Short Title.

Comment on this

What is the Minister quoting from?

Comment on this

Column 1103. Of course, the Minister contradicted in column 1103 what he had said in column 1100.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Oh, yes; most certainly.

Comment on this

What I said 17 years ago is not very germane really.

Comment on this

Not terribly, except from the point of view that it is nonsense to say that the reason this Bill is brought in now is that the other Bill was an experimental Bill.

Comment on this

It was.

Comment on this

There has been no experiment on it. So far as the Long Title of the Bill is concerned, the Minister would be better advised, as a member of the Government, to read the Bills that he has brought to the House. The Long Title of the Bill, the Committee Stage of which we shall discuss following this, gives perhaps even less information than the Short Title.

This Bill is a deliberate attempt to do two things, one of which has not yet been mentioned: first, to get the people to vote as blindly as the Government can get them to vote, to hide from the people what the issue is on which they are being asked to express an opinion; and secondly to prevent separate issues being put to the people. In the 1942 Act, which the Minister for Health sponsored in this House as Minister for Local Government, separate issues had to be put separately. We have, in this Bill, for example, two very different issues which, as the law stands at present, would have to be put to the people separately: first, whether there should be single seat constituencies or multi-seat constituencies, and secondly, whether there should be the transferable or non-transferable vote.

As the law now stands, each of these two propositions would have to be put separately on the ballot papers to the people. The purpose of this Bill is to prevent that happening and to parcel them up into a global parcel in which the people will be asked to deal with them merely under a general phrase, such as the Thrid Amendment of the Constitution Bill.

I want to make quite sure that when people are asked to vote on these issues, they will know clearly and succinctly what they are voting on. The proposal the Government have brought before us to-day does not help that in any way at all. On the contrary, it is designed to put into effect something which means that there will be nothing official initially, giving any indication of what the issue is.

After all, if the Minister was serious when he said he would like to hear some proposition as to the way in which the proposals could be put succinctly, is it not perfectly obvious that there are two questions in relation to each of these principles which could be asked on the ballot paper compactly, to use the Minister's own words: "Do you wish to change from multi-seat constituencies to single seat constituencies?" and as Deputy Donnellan said: "Do you wish to abolish P.R. in favour of the non-transferable vote?" There is nothing very long about either of those questions and they are the two principles which the Ceann Comhairle has ruled are the principles underlying the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill.

There is no difficulty whatever in putting either of these questions, if what is required is a specific ad hoc Bill to deal with the problem of the 14 or 16 page Bill at present before the House. They are two perfectly simple questions upon which there would not be the slightest difficulty in getting the assent of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges of this House, as being unanimously prepared to express the question which should be put. There would be no difficulty at all about the interpretation of the question if an approach were made by the Minister in that way.

The Minister for Local Government, the Minister for Health and every member of the Government must accept that what the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill attempts to do is to abolish multi-seat constituencies, to substitute single seat constituencies, to abolish P.R. and to substitute the non-transferable vote. It goes on to make a constitutional change in relation to the commission which, again, could be covered easily enough in a single question.

The other two matters are the prime principles upon which the Bill is framed. If this Bill were to be, as the Minister for Health tried a few minutes ago to pretend, an ad hoc Bill to deal solely with the question of a long Amendment of the Constitution Bill then there was a very simple way of doing it. It could have been done, if the Government were really genuinely anxious to ensure that the matter would be understood. The discussion here to-day has made it clear beyond question that there is that absence of genuineness on the other side of the House.

This Bill was introduced by the Minister for Local Government in a terse speech in which he hardly bothered at all, if at all, to give any explanation as to why the proposals that had been enacted by the House in 1942 are now being repealed. He confined his introduction purely to an explanation, the briefest possible explanation, of what the Bill purports to do. The House and the country are entitled to assume that when a Minister is bringing into this House a Bill repealing an existing Act of the Oireachtas and, particularly, repealing an Act of the Oireachtas enacted at a time when his own Party was in Government before, he would deign to give the House some explanation of the reasons that prompted the Government to introduce it into the House to-day.

The reason the Minister did not do that is that the purpose of the Bill is to prevent the people having an opportunity to express their view on more than one issue. The purpose of the Bill is to prevent the people having an opportunity of understanding clearly and authoritatively the issue under discussion. Of course, the purpose of all that is—just as in relation to the other Bill—that the more vague you make it, the more wrapped up you make it, the more it is likely to be a smokescreen to get the Government out of their difficulties as a result of being completely and absolutely unable to redeem their election promises. Nothing else can explain away the fact that the Minister for Local Government just pitched the Bill in without any adequate explanation to-day.

If the Government, as a whole, are as sincere as the Minister for Health tried to make us believe a few minutes ago, if the Minister was not speaking with his tongue in his cheek as only he can do in this House, with the most bland simulation even of rage, sometimes, with his tongue in his cheek the whole time, if they were in any way genuine, they would go about this Referendum Bill in a manner that would ensure that the people would know upon what they were to be asked to cast their vote. The questions that should be put on the ballot paper, if we are to make this an ad hoc Bill, should be simple, compact, short, easily understandable, such as: “Do you wish to abolish P.R.? Do you wish to abolish multi-seat constituencies and have single seat constituencies?” If those were in the Bill, nobody could object.

Comment on this

Surely it would be absurd to have an ad hoc Bill for every constitutional amendment?

Comment on this

I think Deputies, reflecting on this Bill, will appreciate one significant fact. This Bill is introduced in order to amend the Referendum Act of 1942. In the past 16 or 17 years, no member of any Government felt impelled to propose in this House the amendment of the 1942 Referendum Act. Since 1942, as Deputy O'Sullivan pointed out, no referendum in fact has been held. Accordingly, the Referendum Act, 1942, remained on our Statute Books unopened and unused.

It was only when the Government decided to seek the abolition of P.R. and were faced with the necessity of holding a referendum that they opened the Referendum Act, 1942. As a result of a study of that Act, they propose this amendment to the House. The first question I think any Deputy must ask himself is this: Is the amendment proposed in this Bill designed to facilitate or to make more difficult the abolition of P.R.? That is the question which must be asked, if not in this House, then by the people outside.

Is it not clear that the Government who seek to hold a referendum aimed at the abolition of P.R. are introducing this machinery to make the solution of that question more easy? Quite obviously, they will not propose an amendment to an Act passed 16 years ago at a time like this, if the result would be in any way to jeopardise their proposal in relation to the abolition of P.R. Accordingly, if not in this House, then certainly outside, the majority of opinion must be that this simple bit of machinery, "this simple Bill" as it has been described by the Minister for Health, is designed to make more easy the proposed abolition of P.R. Therefore, we on this side of the House must view this measure with the gravest suspicion.

When we examine the Bill and when we see that the amendments proposed to the Act of 1942 consist of a proposal which denies the voter the information accorded to him by the 1942 Act on what he is asked to vote upon, well, then, we feel our suspicions somewhat more confirmed. It surely is reasonable for any Deputy to suggest that an amendment of our fundamental law, of our Constitution, should be a matter of the gravest import to the people. This year, at the instance of the Government, everybody who buys a threepenny stamp is reminded that, 21 years ago, the Constitution of this country, enshrining P.R., was adopted by the people. An amendment of that Constitution in any way should be a step not lightly taken by anybody and not lightly decided by the people. It surely is strange that if this Bill becomes law, the one type of referendum in respect of which the voter will be given no information is a referendum dealing with a constitutional amendment.

As the law stands at the moment, whenever a proposal has to be referred to the people, be it a proposal in respect of which the view of the people is sought other than an amendment of the Constitution or a constitutional amendment—whatever the proposal may be—the ballot paper must contain an indication to the voter as to what he is asked to vote upon. This Bill, if it becomes law, will apply only to a constitutional referendum and provides that the voter in every referendum, except a constitutional referendum, shall be told on the ballot paper what he is voting upon, but in relation to a constitutional referendum, he will be told nothing except the Short Title of the Constitution Amendment Bill.

Is it not strange that, if this Bill becomes law, if the President, in the exercise of his powers, doubts the constitutionality of a Bill passed by this House and directs its submission to the people in a referendum, the ballot paper should contain a statement of the question the people are asked to vote upon and when they vote in such a referendum, they will know what they are voting upon, but if it is an amendment changing the fundamental law of this State, the people are to be given no information!

That is a matter which must cause disquiet among the people who follow the moves in this game of chess initiated by the Taoiseach last August. What case can be made for providing one set of law for a referendum dealing with matters other than amendments of the Constitution and another set of law dealing with constitutional amendments? I should have thought the Government and the House would lean backwards to ensure that where any proposal was made which would effect an amendment of the Constitution, the greatest possible care would be taken to ensure that every voter who cast his vote cast it with a full, knowledge of what was involved, fully understanding the question he was asked to decide. Here we find that in relation to that type of amendment information which at present must be given to the voter will no longer be given.

The Minister for Health said that to give proper information to the voter under the 1942 Act would involve printing 16 pages of this Bill. I do not know whether that is so or not. I do not intend to try to interpret the wording of the 1942 Act, but as I recollect sub-section (5) of Section 15 it provides that the proposal shall be stated on the ballot paper as nearly as possible in the same terms as it is stated in the Bill passed by the Oireachtas. I do not think it would defeat the ingenuity of the Government and its advisers to devise a formula whereby on the ballot paper a short statement would appear containing the heads of the proposal being submitted to the people. I received to-day from your office, a Cheann Comhairle, a letter which admirably summarises the effect of this Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, namely, that the system of the single member constituency with the single non-transferable vote should replace the present system of P.R. There is a simple, succinct, accurate statement of the effect of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. Why could not a statement of that kind, short and simple, in easily understood words, appear on the ballot paper so that every voter, when he goes in to vote, will know what he is asked to vote upon?

Deputy O'Malley suggested here— he did not in fact say it but he might very well have said it—we are not living in a balloon. When a voter goes in to vote, he goes in to vote. He does not, I think the Deputy said, go in to do a football pool. Of course he does not, but I wonder is there not something still more sinister in this proposal. When the Taoiseach gave his Press interview in relation to the proposal which eventually was enshrined in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill last September, he gave an assurance that when the people voted on this proposal to abolish P.R. they would not be troubled by any other question and he said quite positively: "We will not hold the Presidential election on the same day." He gave an assurance, which he subsequently repeated, that this issue would be submitted to the people as a separate issue, not confused or complicated by anything else.

I wonder is that assurance still to be relied upon or have Fianna Fáil since decided that perhaps they will hold the referendum and the Presidential election on the same day, with the present Taoiseach as a candidate, in the hope that, having so decided, they will get their voters to go to the booths not to fill up their football pools, but to vote for the Taoiseach and, when they are there, present them with a ballot paper relating to the referendum which merely contains the question: Do you approve or disapprove of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill?

It is significant that this amending Bill was late in making its appearance in this political game of chess. It is significant that only in recent weeks have the Government decided to change the machinery under which this referendum is to be held. I believe the reason is that they have decided to run the Taoiseach as their Party's nominee for the Presidency and they hope, by doing so, to get people out to vote for him and, when they get them there, by this sleight of hand, they will secure extra support for the referendum. In any event, we feel that this Bill is part of the plot that has been hatched by the Government to maintain their position in this Parliament.

Its effect will be to ask the people to vote in blinkers on this important question. Its effect will be that a percentage of people, as a certainty, those who are incapacitated or illiterate, will in going to the booths, cast votes in this referendum without having any idea of what they are voting on. There is a percentage of our people who have never learned to read or write, who will not read such report as will appear in to-morrow morning's newspapers of our deliberations here to-day. There is a section of our people who have not been able to follow the discussion in this House on the Second Reading of the Amendment of the Constitution Bill because they are illiterate. There is also another section of our people who, by reason of blindness, have been unable to follow the proceedings in Parliament on this important question, and those incapacitated people have always been recognised under our electoral laws.

They are always zealous about exercising the franchise, as every Deputy here knows and, under the existing Electoral Act, when they get their ballot paper, the presiding officer must acquaint them with the names of the candidates on that paper, and must mark the ballot paper in accordance with their directions. Can the Minister tell the House how such an elector, or blind person, going out to vote as a citizen of this country on this referendum, not having read or being able to read, not knowing of the discussions that have gone on here over the past two months or so, is to be acquainted with the facts necessary to make his choice when he is told the question is: "Do you approve of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill?"

If he were told that the question he had to decide as a legislator—mind you, as a legislator—was whether he approved or disapproved of a proposal that the system of a single-member constituency and the single non-transferable vote should replace the present system of P.R., then, at least, the issue would be brought fairly and squarely before him. As the Leader of the Opposition has pointed out, this Bill contains other proposals and perhaps proposals of a more detailed nature which are also objectionable. It is significant that, in the proposal for the change in the ballot paper, the question and the form of the ballot paper seem to be weighted into suggesting that a voter should vote "Yes".

The question is: "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution?" The present law says the question shall be: "Do you approve or disapprove of the proposal?" In other words, "or disapprove" has been taken out. Again, one can think of the illiterate voter who is asked the question: "Do you approve of the proposal entitled the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill?" The next thing read out to him is "Answer ‘Yes' or Answer ‘No'." That form of ballot paper, in my view, is shaped and designed to encourage an affirmative answer from the voter, and I believe it was designed to do so. Would anyone explain to me, when all other things are equal here and we should all endeavour to maintain the existing law, the status quo, why should the first answer appearing on the ballot paper be “Yes” and the last “No”?

It was always understood that on our ballot papers the names of candidates appeared in alphabetical order, but, in this ballot paper, the alphabetical sequence is disregarded. "Yes" appears before "No" and the Minister cannot say that perhaps in Irish it might be different because "Tá" comes after "Níl" in the Irish language. We have this very interesting coincidence that the question is: "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution—answer ‘Yes'." I believe that this type of proposed ballot paper is not put in this Bill just by chance. I believe it is put there by design and that it is intended to facilitate the passage, by the people, of the proposal being submitted by the Government.

The Minister for Health referred to difficulties in printing a large ballot paper. I think I have dealt with that by reminding him that it would be possible to ask this House, if it were necessary—I do not think it is necessary, but even if it were—to approve of a system whereby a short, understandable statement of the effect of the proposal could be put in the ballot paper.

I wonder do Deputies realise that under the Constitution, which is being celebrated now by a stamp, this issue is decided by the people as legislators. It is they who effect the change or decide against it and they do it as legislators. We are their representatives here and we merely propose this measure to them and it is they who decide it, not we.

What right have we in this House to say we will just dole out a certain amount of information to the people; that we will not give them the Bill as they would not, understand it? What arrogance is that? What right has any Minister to suggest that an Irish voter should not have, as the member of every legislative assembly is entitled to have, the exact proposal upon which he is asked to vote? What is wrong in demanding that the voters in this referendum be given precisely a copy of this Bill? Are they not entitled to have it? It is going to affect their votes. They are the people by whose votes this issue will be decided and nobody else's.

Under what circumstances are we entitled to say we will just give them a little bit of information, because if we give them the Bill, they would not understand it? I regard that as the greatest piece of arrogance that could be uttered by any Minister in a democratic assembly. I should have thought, from the Press interview given by the Taoiseach and his references to the importance of this proposal in relation to the electoral system, that he would instruct his Ministers to ensure that no stone was left unturned, that no effort was spared to see that every voter from Cork to Donegal, and from Dublin to Galway, was given all the necessary information to enable a proper decision to be arrived at.

Those were his sentiments when, with a fanfare of trumpets, he told the Fianna Fáil Party they were really concerned about P.R. for many years back. Those were his sentiments last September when he told the people that they were seriously worried about the electoral system. Those were his sentiments last September, that this issue should not be clouded by any other issue, that he wanted a calm and objective discussion so that the people could follow exactly what is involved, that the issue could be fully realised by the people.

Why this change now? Why the sudden change to furtiveness and secrecy and diffidence that we are now presented with in this Bill? I think there is something very sinister in this proposal. The rules are being changed to suit certain players; the machinery for a referendum is now being altered in a particular way on the eve of a referendum which may shape the future of this country. The change sought, in my view, is sought to facilitate the passage of the Government's proposal by the people. It certainly is not designed to hinder it in any way.

The effect of the change is to deny the people the right which they now have to get information on the question on which they are asked to vote. I believe it is done, not because of any difficulties such as have been mentioned by the Minister for Health—difficulties of that kind can be overcome—but is designed to ensure that things will be made easier for the passage of the Government's proposal. It is for these reasons that we oppose the Second Reading of this Bill and we have tabled an amendment in the names of the Leader of the Opposition and Deputy Mulcahy so that the people may appreciate that this Bill is not merely a machinery Bill. It is a Bill designed to deprive them of the right they now have and a Bill which is part of a plot concoted last August.

Comment on this

It became very plain as soon as this Bill was introduced and commented on that there were a number of very obvious difficulties and weaknesses involved. The Bill, of course, has been described by the Minister, and some of the Fianna Fáil spokesmen, as a Bill to make it possible for the citizens to vote on a proposal to amend the Constitution in a more simple manner, and that the Bill before the House would provide machinery which should commend itself to everyone because of its simplicity. Listening to the debate, it struck me that it was a wonder that some Fianna Fáil Deputies did not suggest that to have on the ballot paper a "yes" or "no" form of answer was a simple system that sometimes applied in cases where workers were being asked to take a decision on whether or not they would accept a wage increase. They did not do that because they were quite well aware that the circumstances in such a case would be entirely different from the circumstances of the citizens going to ballot in the expected referendum.

In those cases, workers know quite clearly what the issue is and there is no possible doubt about it, but in this case we have proposed the terms of a ballot paper with which the voter going to a local polling station will be issued which asks, according to the terms of this Bill: "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution contained in the undermentioned Bill?" and it refers them then to the Short Title of the Bill. Take an average elector. Suppose that question is put to him. The normal reaction is: "What are we asked to do?" It is very easy for the Minister or members of the Government. As one Fianna Fáil Deputy said, it is very simple: all you are asked to do is just to agree to the amendment of the Constitution. But even Fianna Fáil Deputies who appear to be able to speak on this matter with only one voice must at some time or other ask themselves what does "the proposal to amend the Constitution contained in the undermentioned Bill" mean. Will the voter, even the one who makes a habit of reading the daily newspapers be quite clear as to what the issue is? Surely it is not suggested here or elsewhere that every citizen has been able to follow the complete discussion on the proposed amendment of the Constitution through the newspapers? Even the people who followed the discussions in Dáil Éireann as closely as possible up to the adjournment of the House will most likely be considerably confused as to the issues.

I think it is fair to say that no one has spoken here on the proposal to amend the Constitution from a purely objective point of view; certainly no Minister and no Fianna Fáil Deputy could do so because they were pledged to support a measure for a particular purpose which it is not necessary to go into now. Even if electors read the newspapers very carefully and if they read the many speeches of Fianna Fáil Ministers and Deputies on that matter, they certainly would not have had the issues put before them objectively. Consequently, it appears that it is the responsibility of the House to ensure that if a referendum takes place, the people who vote on it shall at least be quite clear as to what they are voting on.

When a Bill of particular importance is introduced, it is customary for the Minister responsible not only to circulate the Bill to the members but also to issue a memorandum, in most cases, setting out the main purposes of the measure. Surely this House in submitting a proposal that the Constitution be amended to the citizens at large is in exactly the same position as a Minister bringing a Bill to the House? Whether supporters of the Government or members of the Opposition Party or Independents, no matter how they are concerned in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, once the Bill is passed by this House and the Seanad, it becomes an Act and the proposal goes to the electors as legislators. The body putting that Act to the electorate is the Oireachtas. It is clear to me, therefore, that we have a responsibility to see that the proposals going before those entitled to vote shall be clear and definite and that there shall be no misunderstanding. There are many opportunities for misunderstandings in the present Bill.

The electorate will be asked:

"Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution contained in the undermentioned Bill?"

That question will be addressed to thousands of electors throughout the country. It will be contained in a ballot paper which in normal circumstances may be issued to housewives taking a little time off from the day's work to go to the polling station in the morning, to people going home or returning from lunch during the day and taking a short time to vote, or to people coming to the polling booths in the evening between 6 and 9 p.m. when normally every polling station has very severe congestion.

The Bill provides that in the case of a person who cannot read or write, and perhaps in the case of those afflicted with blindness, those who cannot themselves take this "ever so simple ballot paper" and read it and make a decision, the presiding officer will be entitled to proceed in accordance with regulations set out on the last page:—

"Where the voter fails to understand the import of the said question, the presiding officer shall read out to the voter the Short Title of the Bill to amend the Constitution as stated on the ballot paper and then ask the voter, ‘Do you approve of or do you object to that Bill becoming law?' and then mark the ballot paper in accordance with the answer of the voter;".

In any case where the presiding officer is satisfied the prospective voter for any reason does not understand the import of the question, he is not entitled to give that voter information. He is entitled under this Bill only to put the question: "Do you or do you not approve of the proposal?"

For instance, if I want to cast my vote in a referendum and I say to the presiding officer: "I am not clear as to what this ballot paper means," he can only direct that question to me, asking me do I approve or do I object to the Bill becoming law; do I object to something I do not understand, that I do not know anything about and on which nobody has given me any official information.

If the Government are serious in this matter, surely the first thing they should agree to do is that which has been suggested here, that is, place a copy of whatever Bill goes before the people on the basis of referendum in the hands of every elector, or at least take every reasonable opportunity of doing so. For quite a few years now, it has been the practice in general elections to send a card to electors at their official addresses, showing the polling station, polling number and other details. Now, if it has been considered important by successive Governments to go to the trouble of posting to all electors cards informing them where they are to vote and what their registered number is, as a help to them, surely it is even more important, if the electorate are being asked to consider voting for or against a change in the Constitution, that the details of that change should be sent to them? Indeed, it would not be unreasonable to suggest that not alone should the details of the Bill be so sent, but that there should be included also an agreed statement of this House, on the lines of the usual White Paper or explanatory memorandum, setting out the main purposes of the Bill.

It has been mentioned here in the course of the discussion that there is a certain percentage of illiterate people in the country. I think there is an even larger number of semi-illiterate people in the country. Whether they are illiterate, semi-illiterate or completely literate, or whether they are handicapped in any way, as long as they are registered as electors, they are entitled to be given the full official information on which they, and only they, can make a decision. If the Minister and his colleagues suggest that this Bill is of any help in that regard, I submit that they are not being serious or fair to this House, or fair to the citizens generally.

I said earlier that this ballot paper is in a form sometimes used when workers receive an offer from an employer of an increase in wages and where the offer which is put to them is: "Are you in favour or not of accepting 10/- a week?" They all know it—there is no argument they can use: it is a question of "yes" or "no"; and it is not hedged around with the number of clauses in this Bill. There is nothing in this question as it is put in the form of a proposal, to suggest that the ballot paper itself would give any indication to the voters except: "Do you approve or disapprove of the Short Title of the Act?" Is that fair? Is it reasonable?

Some of us have been in this House for only a few years, but many Deputies have been here for many years; and hardly a session goes by that we do not demonstrate fairly clearly to ourselves and to citizens outside that we do not at all times understand the complete implications of certain Bills brought before the House. On how many occasions does it occur that what appears to be a reasonable Bill requires fairly long and repeated explanations as to its purpose? We are asked to adopt the attitude here that the electors, having either read ex-parte statements and arguments in national and provincial newspapers or other news organs, or having heard secondhand, from a friend or relative, that there is a proposal to change the Constitution, that there is a proposal to abolish P.R., understand clearly what they are doing, if they go to the polls and have the question put to them: “Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution contained in the undermentioned Bill?”, and are given the Short Title of the Bill.

I have said in this House, and I have been sincere in saying it, that the Irish people have shown that they are possessed, on the average, of very high intelligence because of the way they have indicated, down the years, whether a particular political Party liked it or not, their preferences for those who should represent them here. At the same time, I feel sincerely that this amendment to the Referendum Act of 1942 will not realise the aim its proposers suggest they have in mind, the aim of making this simple, clear and understandable. There is no merit in simplifying something, if at the same time that which is simplified does not become more understanable. There is no merit in saying to a person: "Do you or do you not agree with a certain Act?" unless at the same time you make it clear beyond doubt what that Act is. Persons asked whether or not they agree to the passing of an Act are entitled to know the terms of that Act. The electorate are entitled to be given an objective and agreed statement as to what the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill proposes to do.

It appears to me that there is a purpose behind this proposal. That purpose is to make it simple for the people to say "Yes", if that is possible. Of course, this type of simplification is not new from Fianna Fáil, whether as a Government or as a Party. I do not have to remind Fianna Fáil Deputies how simple the Party endeavours to make every general election in practically every constituency. They usually endeavour to make general elections simple by calmly asking the voters, whether they are in Clare, Cork, Wexford, Donegal or Dublin, to "Vote Dev". That is very simple. De Valera may not be the candidate in those areas, but the voters are simply asked "Vote Dev". It is a habit in North-East Dublin, too. To give them credit, it has been successful on a number of occasions.

I am afraid that the people with such a mentality, who have avoided putting any clear economic or political proposal before the country and have covered up their lack in this respect by concentrating on the words "Vote Dev", may be of opinion that a similar approach will be successful in regard to the referendum. It appears to me that they do not want to make it clear to the people in the referendum that if they say "Yes", they are voting to do away with P.R. It seems to me that they do not want to make it clear to the people that if they say "Yes", they are voting for a single nontransferable vote and single member constituencies.

If the assurances of good faith given by the Government, that they desire to leave this matter to the calm and wise judgment of the people, are of any value, the first thing the Minister for Local Government should do is to agree that this Referendum Bill is misconceived, that it will not make any issue clearer to the people but will succeed only in mystifying them much more. If the Government are sincere that whatever is finally decided by the Oireachtas to be the subject-matter of the referendum should be considered calmly and objectively by the electorate and with a reasonable knowledge of what they are doing, then the Minister should assure the House that he is prepared to withdraw this type of ballot paper.

He should indicate that he is prepared to make the necessary administrative arrangements to ensure that a copy of the form of the referendum and a copy of the Constitution Amendment Bill will be in the hands of all those entitled to vote. The printing and distribution of those copies might cost a little more money, but the Government were responsible for introducing this proposal, in the first place, and if there is some little extra cost or worry involved in giving that information to the electorate, surely the Government should not cavil? They have not cavilled at the idea of introducing a proposal to amend the Constitution at the present time and therefore I do not think they should cavil at some extra expenditure.

I put it to the Minister and his colleagues in the Government that the electors are even more entitled than we are to an objective explanatory-memorandum in relation to the proposals upon which they will be asked to make a decision. The Minister has said this is purely a machinery Bill. If there is any real basis for his statement or any sincerity in the statements of his colleagues, he should, before this debate concludes, give the assurances for which we have asked. If the Government want the people to judge, they should at least put them in the position of being able to judge and not play another confidence trick on them, the type of trick they have played so often in the past by asking the people to say "Yes" or "No" to something in relation to which the people have not been properly advised. In equity, the people are entitled to information and it is the duty and obligation of the Government to ensure that every elector is informed clearly upon the matter in which he is called to make a decision. That applies not merely to the technical details of the Bill, but even more so to the effects the Bill may have, if it passes into legislation.

Comment on this

Listening to the various speeches from the Opposition Benches, one would think that Irish voters leave home on the morning of an election with a blank mind and that it is only when they cross the threshold of the polling booth that they unravel for themselves the problems they are asked to deal with there. One would think that it is only there and then that they make up their minds. That, of course, is not the situation that obtains. Take, for instance, a general election. Well in advance of election day, the electors have made up their minds and taken their decision as to the individuals they will support and the policy they wish to see implemented by the in-coming Government. There is no indication on the ballot paper as to the Party to which a candidate belongs; there is no indication as to the policy candidates will support, if elected. There is just the bare list of names. Irish electors down the years have made up their minds long before going to the polling station as to what they will do and as to whom they will support.

Do the Opposition believe that there will be a complete change in the future? Do they believe that the electors will in future leave their homes with their minds not made up? I do not believe they will and I do not believe the Opposition believe they will. Does anyone think it would help electors to present them with a copy of the third amendment of the Constitution on referendum day? In the time available to them, they would not be able to study the contents. If they were presented with an explanatory memorandum, I doubt if they would study such a document in the circumstances. We all know that these electors will be thoroughly familiar with the issue upon which they will be called to vote before they leave their homes and well in advance of the actual referendum. The Opposition suggests that some explanation should be given on the ballot paper for the benefit of the semi-literate, the illiterate and the less educated. They are the very people who would not benefit from an explanation in such circumstances. Such an explanation could help only those who are proficient m reading and capable of assimilating what they read.

I believe the correct procedure is to have a simple ballot paper. I agree that it would be a good thing well in advance to issue some explanation to ensure that all will have a clear picture as to what is intended. It would be a good idea to issue some short explanatory memorandum. If it is beyond the bounds of possibility to do that in the case of individual electors, then I would suggest that some explanation should be issued through the medium of the Press, especially through the medium of the weekly papers in the provincial areas.

There are a few points arising out of the Bill to which I wish to draw the Minister's attention. I do not agree that the Irish translation of the word "referendum" is correct. Secondly, there is a statement on the proposed ballot paper that an "X" should be placed in the square opposite "Yes" or "No". In its present layout, it is not a square and I suggest, therefore, that the word "space" should be used in that context.

Comment on this

This matter has been fairly well discussed this evening. We on this side of the House have been accused of delaying tactics. I want to assure the House that there was no such intention. As an Opposition, it is our duty to give expression to our views on the change in the electoral system which it is proposed to introduce.

The form of the ballot paper is far from clear. No matter how well people may be advised, there will be a certain amount of confusion. The elector is asked: Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution? People who do not take an active part in public life will not realise that in voting for the amendment of the Constitution, they are voting against P.R., that they are denying themselves the right in future elections to vote according to the P.R. system which has been in existence here since the foundation of the State.

I do not know why objection should be raised because doubt has been expressed from this side of the House as to the real intentions behind this Bill. In the City of Limerick, I have been asked what will be the effect of the passing of this Bill. I have been asked will it apply to future local government elections. To my mind, it will. I cannot see the Government having another referendum, if they want this to apply to local government elections. The Government will have the answer: The people have already decided on the abolition of P.R. Many people are disturbed on that point because in the City of Limerick for many years there was an agitation for the managerial system which made Limerick City and other cities one constituency and under P.R. we got representation of all sections and all interests.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid the Deputy is getting away from the Bill before the House.

Comment on this

If you say so, I shall not go any further. I am just citing questions that I have been asked. That is one of them. Deputy O'Malley told us that people are quite well aware of how to use the ballot paper. It is a strange thing that in the Limerick Corporation, when we wanted a discussion on P.R., Deputy O'Malley proposed that it should be ruled out of order. Is that fair to the people whom we want to guide as to what to do when they are presented with this ballot paper? I feel it my duty to say that in the House. I regret if I have gone outside the scope of the Bill. I do not feel there is any great harm in going slightly out of bounds when I do so in the interests of the people who are asking these questions. Undoubtedly, the Party to which I belong and other Parties will try as far as possible to make people aware of what they are doing when they are voting.

While we may be in this House for four, five or ten years, we are doing something in this Bill which will affect the lives and interests of the people generally for many years to come. There is some motive behind the Bill. That is the suspicion; that is the doubt. There is no clarity in the ballot paper as to the implications of answering "Yes" or "No" to the question: "Do you approve of the proposal to amend the Constitution?" Many people will not understand what to do. There are many people who vote at election time who do not go to election rooms to know what to do. Illiterate people have been mentioned. There are many intelligent people who like to understand things for themselves and to decide for themselves in the light of their own understanding, without recourse to any Party for guidance.

There is certainly some motive behind the Bill. This is only a beginning and in my opinion the Bill will ultimately be applied to local government elections. We are doing our duty as an Opposition. I do not want to talk at length on this matter because many of the things that I might have said have been said already. I am very happy, as a Deputy representing Limerick City, to oppose this measure.

Comment on this

As I understood the Minister's opening statement, he said that Section 3 was specifically provided to authorise that officers appointed by the returning officer would be entitled to vote. In fact, the wording of the section makes that pretty clear:—

"Where—

(a) a person is entitled to vote at the poll at a referendum,

(b) he is employed, by the local returning officer for the constituency in which he is entitled to vote, for any purpose in connection with the poll in that constituency, and

(c) the circumstances of his employment are, in the opinion of that officer, such as to prevent him from voting at the polling station at which he would otherwise be entitled to vote, that officer may authorise him in writing to vote at a specified other polling station in that constituency, and the polling station so specified shall, for the purpose of rule 8 of the rules contained in the First Schedule of the Referendum Act, 1942, be deemed to be the polling station allotted to him."

A number of other people are engaged at polling stations. Under Section 17 (1) of the Act of 1942, each member of Dáil Éireann and of Seanad Éireann is entitled at such a referendum to nominate personation agents or people whose duty it is to help the presiding officer to prevent illegal voting. Would it not be well that these people, equally, should be entitled to vote because of the fact that duties assigned to them by the State take them from their homes and that they are part of the election machinery in the same way as officers appointed by the returning officer? I would suggest that, if it is intended that these people should be included, provision should be made that such persons—call them personation agents or what you like— whose duties prevent them from voting at the polling station at which they would otherwise be entitled to vote may be authorised to vote at some other polling station.

I intend to support the Fine Gael amendment to this Bill not because of any merits that the latter part of it has, to my mind, but mainly because of the fact that it is a refusal to give a Second Reading to the Bill at all.

I believe that whatever way you arrange this vote, you are simply dealing with an instrument of another Bill which is a complete travesty of justice. The Constitution Amendment Bill itself is, in my opinion, a Bill which is being forced through this House to give a minority group the right to govern here against the will of the majority of the people. Any kind of Bill that will implement that could not be amended in any shape or form because it is so wrong to attempt to amend an evil thing which is evil in itself. I am quite in agreement with the Fine Gael point of view that there are many people who will go to the polling booth unaware of what exactly the third amendment of the Constitution is. I am quite well aware that Fine Gael, perhaps, tabled their amendment from the parliamentary point of view, that it gives them the right to talk and focus attention on the evil of the third amendment itself. I agree with it from that point of view.

I shall support it completely on the grounds that it is a refusal to attempt to implement a previous Bill which has not even yet passed through this House. I feel that any device by which public attention can be focussed upon what is about to happen in this State is good. Anything that gives us an opportunity to discuss the matter in this House and which gives the newspapers an opportunity to publish that discussion is helpful.

It is significant that throughout the length and breadth of this country, in public bodies where Government supporters are chairmen, any attempt to bring this forward at these public bodies has been turned down on the basis that it is a political question. Of course, it is a political question, but would one not think that the more publicity and the more discussion we have about the matter, the better? Is that not all to the good? Is it not suggested that what is needed is the opinion of the whole people on whether or not we should abolish P.R.?

I suggest that Deputy Norton was very correct to-day in his speech when he said that the important thing in connection with the Bill now before the House is whether we are for or against P.R. Is that not really the whole substance of the matter? All the other things are consequential upon the important issue—whether the people want to retain the present system of voting or want to change to the single straight vote. In my opinion. Deputy Norton's solution of the problem was the correct one—that we should say to the people upon every occasion on this Bill and on the Third Amendment Bill, at this stage or on Committee Stage and at all times, to beware of what is about to happen. If they surrender their birthright by voting "Yes" at the time of the referendum, they will live long to regret it.

Comment on this

In my opinion and in the opinion of the Party to which I have the privilege to belong, this is one of the most extraordinary Bills that have been brought before this House under the guise of being necessary for various legal and constitutional reasons. It is, in effect, a Bill which is brought forward for purely political motives. We have not been given an adequate explanation of what will be done, if and when a question is being put before the people in the form of a referendum.

Surely, as previous speakers have stated, there is a clear and simple way of putting that before the electorate. This Bill is complicated and will be quite beyond the ordinary person to understand, not that the ordinary person is incapable of understanding more difficult matters than this, but the whole question will be so confused that the ordinary voter will simply not have the time and the opportunity to understand clearly the issue which is being put before him or her.

That is our objection to this Bill and it cannot be taken without some reference to the Bill which we were discussing last session, namely, the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958. You might almost call this an enabling Bill to permit the results of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill to be put before the Irish people in as confused a way as possible. That is what lies in and behind this Referendum (Amendment) Bill, 1958.

I ask the Government: What is your little game? What on earth are you up to? We have been brought back to the Dáil to-day, 7th January. Certainly, the members of my Party do not object to coming back to do the State's business in January, but why is this suddenly done? What is the rush? Why have we come back almost three weeks earlier? It is because the Government have not made up their minds on whom they are to put forward or what is to be done in connection with the Presidential election and whether they will have the question, if it goes through, of the alteration of the Constitution on the same or a different day.

At any rate, some sort of scheme is being hatched. At the end of it, the Irish people are to be presented with a ballot paper which would really take a constitutional lawyer to understand, instead of their being asked the perfectly simple question: Do you want P.R. or a single-member constituency? It would be quite simple to put the question to the people in a straightforward, easily-understood manner but by the very fact of the Bill's existence, it is perfectly clear that the ballot paper will be presented in a way which will be very difficult to understand. I am very sorry to see an Irish Government not only altering the well-tried method of election in this country but bringing in this Bill so that when the Irish people are asked if they want it or not, that question will be wrapped up in such a way that there will be the maximum confusion about it.

I do not think there is any other matter of great substance in the Bill, and so I wish to record here my very grave distrust of this Bill, and still more of what lies behind it, and my determined opposition to it.

Comment on this

This is a very reasonable amendment, in my opinion. A good many speeches have been made from both sides of the House, but it is a significant fact that most of the speeches have come from the Opposition and in so far as I have been here to listen to any of the speakers from the Government side, they do not seem to have endeavoured to answer the simple question: whether or not the people know what they are voting for.

It is true the Minister for Health spoke at some length and seemed to stress the point that it would be necessary to include the entire Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill— I think he said of 16 pages—to indicate to the people what they were voting for. Supposing we accept the Minister's argument and supposing the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill as it stands at present, was on the ballot paper, I think I can say quite frankly it would not clarify the issue in any way.

I know Deputies who have had considerable experience of reading Bills and they had to take more than one look, and more than half a dozen looks at that Bill, before they understood what it was about. I venture to suggest that there are probably quite a few Deputies who still do not know what it is about or understand its full implications.

I think it was Deputy Booth who said we could not make the ballot paper any simpler for the electorate because it would cost money. One does not wish to be cynical or anything like that, but surely our having to debate this Bill, and the other Bill for which this Bill is the machinery, is due to the fact that the Fianna Fáil Party are foisting on the Irish nation a referendum to change the electoral system without any request to do so.

When Deputy Booth was speaking on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill here, he was very careful to stress the fact that one of the reasons why P.R. should not be permitted to continue in our Constitution was that the people were too stupid to understand it. If the people were too stupid to understand it——

Comment on this

No. I question that altogether.

Comment on this

Perhaps I am wrong and I apologise to the Deputy if I misquoted him. Certainly in my hearing, several Deputies from the other side of the House—the Minister for Industry and Commerce was one—said that the Irish electorate did not understand the P.R. system. I will put it that way if the Deputy prefers it.

Comment on this

Very much so.

Comment on this

Surely if they do not understand P.R., how will anybody understand this ambiguous document? Do Fianna Fáil Deputies not know, unless, to quote the Taoiseach, they have cotton wool in their ears, that there is the most utter confusion throughout the country with regard to this referendum to change the electoral system.

I have spoken to people of all shades of opinion, intelligent and highly educated people, and in spite of what they are reading in the papers, they do not really know what the implications are of this proposed change in our electoral system. If the electorate are to go to the polling booths to vote on this proposal in its present form, if the only information they will have to guide them is that it is a measure relating to an amendment of the Constitution is it seriously suggested by Fianna Fáil Deputies—and I submit that the silence of the Fianna Fáil Deputies is proof that they know that this is the case—that the electorate will know what they are voting for? Of course, it is a good thing to have a referendum because the Fianna Fáil organisation will then come into action, with a whispering campaign by the organisation and so forth, to get the people to vote.

One or two other speakers mentioned that the referendum would probably take place at the same time as the Presidential election. It would be easy then with a confused ballot paper like this—and mark you, nobody, even intelligent people, will know what this ballot paper means when they see it—to confuse the two issues: Vote for Dev and vote Yes for the referendum. That is the latest change of tactics and that is why we have this Bill and why the Fianna Fáil Party are trying to amend the Constitution, to get through a referendum because they have been getting their answer in the country. They are afraid now that the referendum will be beaten and if it is beaten and the Taoiseach is successful in winning the Presidential election, they will have to face the next election under the old system, without the Chief at the head, and they know they will get, to put it crudely, the "works." They know that and that is why they brought this Bill in its present form to amend the Constitution. I charge that that is political dishonesty and nothing else. It is political dishonesty, in the first instance, to have a referendum to change the Constitution, when no one wants to do that, and it is political dishonesty to produce a proposal like this which no one will understand.

I know the Minister for Health is an intelligent man and I have the highest respect for his intelligence. Does he seriously suggest that anybody, an ordinary elector in any country in the world, seeing a ballot paper like that with the Short Title of the Constitution Amendment Bill written across the top of it would know what it is about. It is confusion confounded and the only hope I have is that the Irish people will see in it another attempt to put one across them and that the majority will read it and chuck it out.

Comment on this

So far as this debate has gone, and I have spoken before in the House about this, I quite agree with the amendment before the House to-night, but I feel, mind you, that, as the discussion has gone, it is not made clear to me that I can speak as I wish to speak here to-night, inasmuch as it has not been made clear to this House whether this referendum will be put before the electorate as an entity. That has not come as yet. I admit that the Taoiseach, in introducing the Bill, made it perfectly clear on two, three or different occasions that the question of the referendum would have to be voted on by the people as a separate item. Now, as far as I hear—I may be wrong and I may be very wrong but it is no harm to put it before the House—the Taoiseach may possibly be a candidate for the Presidential seat.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no question of the Presidential election——

Comment on this

It comes into it in this way. I want to ask this House, if that is the case, if that election will not be on the P.R. system. Is it not a fact? Will it not be on the P.R. system? It is an extraordinary thing that, if it will, we shall have the electorate putting their papers into one box on the P.R. system and, by the side of that, another box into which they are asked to put their papers saying whether they consider that the P.R. system should be abolished. That is all I want to know. It has not been put here to the House.

I could speak for a longer time if it had been made clear to me and to the House as to whether the question of the P.R. system was being put to the people at the referendum as a separate item. That has not been done. That is why I say that if it is a fact, as we hear—I do not know what truth there is in it and the Taoiseach is perfectly entitled to go for it——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise at this stage.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach must go for it under the P.R. system because it has not yet been decided whether or not P.R. is to be abolished. If they make it the one issue on the one day—I will not say any more until I find out if it is put before this House, as it should be put before this House— does the Taoiseach still stand by his statement that the referendum will be put to the people on its own? If it is the other way about, if the two issues come together and you have one box voting for P.R. and the other one trying to put it out, is it not time that some of the gentlemen on the opposite side of the House were medically examined?

Comment on this

We are concerned in the discussion here this evening with the treatment of the voting in relation to the referendum it is proposed to hold if and when the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958, goes through. It is in the light of the importance of the Constitution to the people and the relationship between the Constitution and the Parliament that has served the people in many ways that we are concerned that this Parliament will do its work properly in regard to an important matter such as the amendment of the Constitution.

I appreciate the approach of Deputy Kyne to our amendment of the Bill, but there is something more in our amendment—at any rate, from my point of view—than Deputy Kyne apparently sees just at the moment. The Constitution is regarded by the Government as a very sacred thing—particularly as they have had a hand in the framing of it as it stands to-day; but, to our people as a whole, the Constitution of this State is a very sacred and a very important thing.

The Preamble to the Constitution firmly states, even from our point of view, the things that ought to be kept in mind when dealing with matters in regard to the Constitution. It accepts that all authority comes from God. It makes reference to the fact that our fathers were sustained by the Almighty in their struggle for the independence of our country and the principles that our people desired to have enshrined actively in the parliamentary and in the general life of this country and for which they sought that independence.

In the type of discussion we are having, leading up to the things proposed to be done, I think it well to read the Preamble to the Constitution of 1937, which is as follows:—

"In the Name of the Most Holy Trinity, from Whom is all authority and to Whom, as our final end, all actions both of men and States must be referred,

We, the people of Éire,

Humbly acknowledging all our obligations to our Divine Lord, Jesus Christ, Who sustained our fathers through centuries of trial,

Gratefully remembering their heroic and unremitting struggle to regain the rightful independence of our Nation,

And seeking to promote the common good, with due observance of Prudence, Justice and Charity, so that the dignity and freedom of the individual may be assured, true social order attained, the unity of our country restored, and concord established with other nations,

Do hereby adopt, enact, and give to ourselves this Constitution."

In that Constitution, it is secured that all persons who have the right to vote in a general election will have the right to vote in a referendum. What I and what we object to in the proposals in this Referendum Bill, related as they are to the proposals in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, is that it carries into the proposition of what will be put on the ballot paper for the voter to decide on everything of the spirit that has dictated the Government's approach to the changes in the Constitution. It brings into the proposal here every desire to deceive and to withhold from the voter any kind of simple, serious, clear, concise statement of what he is asked to give an opinion on. So definite is that intent that the Referendum Act of 1942 is deliberately being changed so as to keep from the voter, by a statute of this House which it is hoped now to pass, a simple statement of what he is asked to say "Yes" or "No" about.

That action is being taken and these plans of deception and withholding of information are being practised in relation to a matter which the Preamble to the Constitution states our fathers made sacrifices for. They struggled for the independence of our nation in order to get principles of justice and charity and prudence established here so that the people of Ireland, individually created to the image and likeness of God, might serve their holy destiny under the light and guidance of the Most Holy Trinity, Whose authority is omnipotent and to Whom in all their actions, both as individuals and representing the State, they are responsible in the light of their final end.

In dealing with a matter like that. we have had many statements of human experience quoted to us. The Minister for Health, who has just left the House, quoted extracts from, I think, a dozen different volumes by a. dozen different persons in relation to human experience on the matters we are discussing here for the purpose of guiding us in every possible way. Every land in Europe was traversed, as well as the United States, in order to show us what is possible when humans take action in relation to their affairs.

When I regard the spirit in which the Constitution Amendment Bill was put before us and when I regard the trickery which was practised in relation to the framing of this Referendum Bill, two events in human experience come very forcibly to my mind, events in which the pride, the arrogance, the stupidity and the lust for power brought about the confusion of Babel, on the one hand and the downfall of Ananias, on the other. What I want to draw particular attention to is that the spirit of Ananias, the deception and the deceit that characterised the Constitutional Amendment Bill discussion is being given a kind of statutory form in Section I of the Amendment Bill here and in the Schedule. When I consider the struggle that was made here to get possession of the resources of the nation for the common good, to develop our character as a Christian people and to do our work for the nation successfully, I can hear the voice of Saint Peter as he cries out to Ananias: "Ananias, why hath Satan tempted thy heart. Why hast thou conceived this thing in thy heart. Thou hast not lied to man but to God."

The electors of this country are being asked, in the name of the Holy Trinity, to amend the Constitution and to say whether they approve of this proposal, without having sufficient knowledge of the nature of the proposal. Many people are being deprived of their rights on the basis that they are irresponsible, have no judgment or intelligence. You are hiding from them vital information. Men and classes concerned with the development of the social and economic life of Ireland are to be deprived of their rightful position in this Parliament. You are setting out by pure trickery to deprive this Parliament of an Opposition that would be worth while talking about. Therefore, I say this Referendum Bill enshrines the spirit of Ananias. I advise those who have been delving into books and quoting authorities on human experience to look back at the deceits and the hypocrisy of Ananias, the rebuke he got and the end to which he came, the young men rising up and carrying him out. Those who are responsible for this deceit and trickery are telling the people this is the last chance they have of wiping out P.R., but they will be carried out by the young men and left where they ought to be left politically.

When we set up this State, we had the tradition of our fathers behind us, their sacrifices and their work. On the very first day Dáil Éireann met, on 21st January, 1919, we declared, as part of our democratic programme, that we desired our country to be ruled in accordance with the principles of liberty, equality, justice for all, which alone can secure permanence of Government and the willing adherence of the people. The institutions that were set up here were challenged by those who are introducing this Bill in other ways than merely by legislation introduced by them in this House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise.

Comment on this

I challenge those who are behind the leaders who are putting this Bill before the House as to how far they are being misled, how far they are being frustrated and how far their sense of loyalty to persons and parties is bringing them along lines that others went along before, only to have to admit: "I would not follow them to-morrow, if I knew where to go." Or: "I know I was wrong when I was brought into so-and-so but I cannot let the leaders down now."

We must consider this whole question not only from the point of view of the economic circumstances of this country but from the point of view of the world outside. All kinds of things are challenging not only the economic well-being of the peoples of the world but the very soul and spirit of man. I must express my detestation of the kind of atmosphere that has crept into this House, of the kind of proposals that are being put before us and the manner in which they are put before us. We are trampling in a careless, thoughtless and brutal way on the spirit of a people, of a people who accept the Christian faith, Christian revelation and Christian ideals. It is because of that that I challenge what is going on here.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy suggest we on this side of the House do not accept those ideals?

Comment on this

This Bill enshrines in statutory form the spirit of Ananias.

Comment on this

Would the Minister clarify the point as to why in relation to the specimen ballot paper he has not kept to the procedure in the past of having the words "yes" and "no" in alphabetical order?

Comment on this
Neil T.C. Blaney Minister for Local Government (Mr. Blaney) Fianna Fáil

It is rather difficult to listen to the sanctimonious whining of the President of the Fine Gael Party, and to contain oneself within the good order of this House——

Comment on this

Those two things are always difficult.

Comment on this

——and to hear poured down on our heads here his suggestions of the spirit that animated the men on this side of the House in 1922. When we hear the talk about what their fathers did and the sacrifices they made, and when I sit here and listen to the Deputy opposite talking about the sacrifices made by those fathers, it really makes my blood boil. I hope I shall not hear any more about it from the self-same Deputy.

Comment on this

You will hear a lot more about the traditions of this country from me, while we are fighting for the liberty of the ordinary people.

Comment on this

You are not so good in fighting now as at the time I am referring to.

Comment on this

I do my duty on the public platform and in the proper place.

Comment on this

You do! We have these other Deputies all talking in the same breath without a word of sense in their heads, talking and creating confusion so that the people of the country may not know, even through their own intelligence, what is facing them in this issue. If there is confusion at the taking of this referendum, it will be due to the talk and the red herrings being dragged through this House by Depuites on the Opposition Benches. It will be confusion created by all the various Parties opposite, who have one thing in common, that is, that they do not want to see the referendum carried because they have no faith in themselves and do not believe in their own future. Therefore, they hand it over to Fianna Fáil on a plate and suggest that if we get this system working, Fianna Fáil will be here for all time. From their expressed views, it is clear that they have no faith in themselves nor in their policies, neither do they believe the people have any faith in them and naturally then, Fianna Fáil, who have the confidence of the people, will be here for a long time to come. You in opposition are condemning yourselves, not only by every word you have spoken here to-night, but also by every word you have spoken during the debate on the Amendment of the Constitution Bill.

We have invited helpful suggestions but all I can say is that, with the exception of a very brief moment of sanity on the part of a few of the people on the opposite side, we have got nothing from them to try to make clear that which they say is confused. Far from it. We got from all of them additions to the confusion they have already created. The first point made by the Leader of the Opposition, rather his first plaint, was that we were hurrying this thing through, coming in with it in the first week of the New Year, trying to rush it through without the people or the Deputies of the House knowing what it is about. This Bill was introduced and circulated some weeks before we adjourned at Christmas. It arises out of the introduction of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, which we have discussed for weeks on end and, if anybody feels we have not given to this matter sufficient discussion in this House—and from that discusson sufficient publicity in the newspapers and through the radio—then they should throw their minds back to the time when the draft Constitution was before this House.

What do we find if we do that? We find that the sum total number of hours occupied at that time by 28 speakers was 21½ hours—21½ hours spread over three days on the Second Reading of the entire draft Constitution of which we now, at the moment, are in process of amending but a very small, infinitesimal part. What do we find now? We find 63 speakers on Second Reading of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, having spoken a total of 50 hours, and that with greater methods and means of publicising what is being said from various sides of the House than were then in being, or available to the majority of the people of this country, in 1937. Even those people who cannot read, who through infirmity cannot see have now the general facility of Radio Éireann from which they can get "To-day in the Dáil."

Comment on this

From which you were kicked out.

Comment on this

And which Deputy O'Sullivan, much as he might like it, will never see the inside of.

Comment on this

You never know.

Comment on this

Because, according to himself and his Party, if this goes through they have no future.

Comment on this

The Minister should keep away from Radio Éireann from now on.

Comment on this

This confusion which has been created, and which is continuing to be created, is being created as a smokescreen, as a lot of blatherskite of which we do not lack any amount from the Opposition, both here in this debate and in the other debate which preceded it. As I have said, we find here 50 hours occupied by 63 speakers, spread over nine days of the time of this House, talking on the Second Reading of an amendment of but a small part of the Constitution, while this same draft Constitution went through the House, on Second Reading, with only 28 speakers speaking, I think, a total of 21½ hours, though now there is the added facility of Radio Éireann to give accounts to those who cannot read, through infirmity or illiteracy, of the discussions here. They have the benefit of the radio now to give them reports of the Dáil debates, and yet we are being told that we are rushing this matter through, so that the people will not know what this matter is about, in order that we will be able to have it passed through in spite of the people's wishes.

I want to say one thing to the Leader of the Opposition who has made that kind of nonsensical charge here to-night. If anything stands in relation to this matter at the moment it is this: If we as a Government go to the people and put in a referendum that we want a change, and if we do not give them sufficient knowledge of what that change is going to be, is it not our view that is going to suffer in the ballot paper? Are the people not likely to adopt the old maxim that the devil you know is better than the devil you do not know, and so will not vote for the change? Surely anybody will agree that if we are misleading the people, by blinding them to the issue involved, by not giving them a proper conception of the matter, we, as sponsors of this amendment of the Constitution will jeopardise our chances, and enhance the chances of members of the Opposition who are totally and entirely out against it? That, to my mind, is the most eloquent proof that can be given that what we do and propose here is not done in any spirit of trying to blind anybody. We are doing this because we feel it is proper that it should be done, and because we feel that this is the proper time to do it.

We are not hiding behind any subterfuge, as has been alleged by many speakers, both to-night and on other occasions. We are being asked by the Leader of the Opposition: why hurry this matter? I say we are not hurrying it and have not hurried it. It has been in the hands of the Deputies of this House for weeks. It is a simple, straightforward amendment we are now discussing, and the Leader of the Opposition and the other speakers on that side cannot submit that they have not had time to study and understand this amendment. That is particularly true in regard to the Leader of the Opposition. Of all people he does understand it. He has had time to read it and to appreciate fully what it contains but, nevertheless and despite that, he came along here, as did the other Opposition speakers who followed him, with the story that it is hurried, that it is not understood, that it is a move on Fianna Fáil's part to get this measure through the people while they do not know anything about it.

It is asked why should we do this, why should we introduce the Referendum (Amendment) Bill in 1958, why did we not find it necessary in 1946, and why did we not write it into the Act of 1942. I think a very fair answer to that is that we had not the experience, or had not come up against the practical difficulty that we are now confronted with as a consequence of the introduction of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. It was only when that Bill was introduced that we found ourselves confronted with the difficulty and the absurd condition, under the law, of having a ballot paper of 16 typescript pages, in two languages, in order to conform with something that seemed to be all right in 1942 but, in practice, is not all right.

Comment on this

Change the law.

Comment on this

Furthermore, I should like to say that Deputy O'Sullivan, that brilliant little coming gentleman in the Fine Gael front rank, talked in scathing terms and in a sneering way about Fianna Fáil now having to amend their own Act. I see nothing to sneer at in any Party amending an Act which they themselves were responsible for if they find that it does not suit.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

If they see it is not suitable——

Comment on this

Change the law.

Comment on this

Will the President-elect please allow me to continue? As I said, if they find on any occasion that what they have done was not suitable, and if they find that it was wrong, then surely there is nothing to be sneered at if that Party admits they were wrong in their concept and desire to change it? That is what is being done here and nothing that Deputy O'Sullivan or anybody else can say can take away from the innate honesty displayed in that type of operation.

I might also point out that it is a reflection on the then Opposition, who were composed mainly of the present Opposition, or their successors in those Parties, that they had not operated successfully as an Opposition because they did not find the flaws which we have found ourselves. They have been falling down on their job in this Parliament over the years. Now the Opposition comes along and complains because we have got to operate not only as the Government but also as the Opposition.

Comment on this

That is what you are hoping for.

Comment on this

You seem to be fearing it rather than that we are hoping for it. We had some people saying that we were mutilating the Constitution by this amendment, this boasted Constitution as somebody put it, this Constitution which we are now celebrating by bringing out a stamp to commemorate the anniversary of the introduction and enactment of that Constitution.

Does anyone remember what was thought about that Constitution, which is now being referred to as a boasted Constitution, by the people who are talking as if we were trampling it underfoot? Surely some of the members opposite will recall that at the time of the introduction and the passage of that draft Constitution in this House it was jeered at and sneered at by the present Leader of the Opposition? It was not regarded as a Constitution at all and he so stated that in this House at the time.

Yet we have him and other Opposition speakers weeping and moaning because they say that we in Fianna Fáil are now mutilating the very Constitution which the Leader of the Opposition said was scarcely a Constitution at all back in 1937, when it was before the House. It is obvious that he cannot have it both ways. He cannot condemn the Constitution and at the same time try to uphold it. It is alleged here, of course, that the matter contained in the amendment could be attended to in a very simple manner. The simple manner we find is, apparently, by accepting the amendment tabled by the Fine Gael Party.

I just want to say that if that amendment was accepted it would not mean, as has been said here and as could be implied from what was said, that we could have on the ballot paper a simple statement. That has been suggested by a number of Deputies opposite. By accepting this amendment, as suggested by the Fine Gael Party, all we would do is leave things as they are, which is the situation that confronted my Department and myself when we came to look at this matter. We found that because of the situation as now contained in sub-section (5), Section 15 of the Referendum Act of 1942, we would be compelled to include in any ballot paper we might issue all that is contained, literally word for word and line for line, in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill which is before the House at present. We would have to put it all in and it was because we saw the absolute impossibility and the nonsense of trying to include that, and of expecting the voter to go in and read it all and having read it turn around and make up his mind presuming he could understand its full implications —which many Deputies say the ordinary voter could not be expected to do —that the Referendum Amendment Bill was brought before the House and is being discussed at this moment.

As I said, the amendment proposed by the Fine Gael Party to delete all words and to leave things as they stand, would not get us out of that difficulty. In fact, no real solution has been proposed by the members of the Opposition. Their solution is not a solution at all. It only leaves us in the dilemma in which we found ourselves in my Department when we came to examine the type of ballot paper that would have to carry the entire wording of the Third Amendment Bill now before the House.

I say to the Opposition, if you have a sensible and reasonable proposal would you please put it up because you have not put up one on this amendment, nor has any speaker made any real effort to do so?

Comment on this

The Minister was told to throw it out.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy should go home.

Comment on this

I should.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

If in the minds of the Deputies opposite there are any ideas of how we should get over this matter, and if those are any way reasonable at all, I would be glad to accept them. I can certainly promise one thing, and that is that I will be glad to consider them fully and conclusively. It has been my difficulty, and that of my Department, to get over the situation which arises from sub-section (5), Section 15 of the 1942 Act as it now stands. Anything that has been suggested here does not, in fact, help us. It leaves us back where we were before we brought this Bill before the House. If you have anything worth while do bring it forward and forget this amendment which will not in effect alter anything but leave us in the same dilemma in which we found ourselves before.

There is another matter in this Bill to which exception has been taken. The last query addressed to me by Deputy Coogan was why we did not stick to an alphabetical order. I think I heard the same query from another speaker.

Comment on this

Deputy T.F. O'Higgins.

Comment on this

Very good. The point was made that "yes" should come after "no" and "Tá" should come after "Níl", that therefore this was a trick and therefore this Bill was introduced. Furthermore, it was suggested that we are wrong in putting on the proposed ballot paper, "Do you approve?" rather than, "Do you approve or disapprove?", or some such form. In fact, Article 47 of the Constitution so far as I can see, dictates that the question must be answered in a positive way, when it is a question put to the people in a referendum. They must approve rather than turn down something by disapproving. Article 47 lays that down.

Comment on this

Would the Minister then explain the Schedule to the Referendum Act of 1942?

Comment on this

I am afraid that is not what I am here for at the moment——

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

——but if there is something the Deputy wishes to have clarified or if the Deputy feels we can do something about it——

Comment on this

I was only trying to assist the Minister so that he would not make a blunder here.

Comment on this

Considering what I have heard the Deputy say here to-night, he will pardon me if I doubted that that was his intention, although I accept his word for it now that he was trying to be helpful.

Comment on this

Would the Minister quote Article 47 on which he bases that statement?

Comment on this

Article 47 is headed "The Referendum" and says:—

"Every proposal for an amendment of this Constitution which is submitted by referendum to the decision of the people shall, for the purpose of Article 46 of this Constitution, be held to have been approved by the people, if, upon having been so submitted, a majority of the votes cast at such referendum shall have been cast in favour of its enactment into law."

Comment on this

Is that the "if" upon which the Minister bases his statement?

Comment on this

It is just one of a number of reasons why it should be put in that way.

Comment on this

It would be almost worth while asking the Minister to read it out again.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy please allow me to speak as I allowed him to speak?

Comment on this

Surely the Minister, in what he has said, is talking nonsense——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

Of course there is another reason why the question should be put in that way. I admit it was found difficult to find words in both languages that would give us the answers "Yes" or "No" and to give a true translation in a bilingual ballot paper of what is being presented for the first time. That was one of the reasons why we found we had to put the matter in this way—so that we could get a true or nearly true translation in both languages that could be easily understood, whether "Yes" or "No" or "Tá" or "Níl". That is another explanation I would suggest to some Deputies who may not readily subscribe to my view of Article 47 as to why this has been done in the way it has been done.

I would ask the Opposition: Is there any way we could put it that they would not have disagreed with? Is there any way in which the statement of the subject-matter of the third amendment of the Constitution could be put on the ballot paper, or a synopsis of that enactment? Is there any form of words which could be put on the ballot paper that the members of the Opposition would not take advantage of to show by misrepresentation that we were, in fact, trying to hoodwink somebody or other outside this House?

Comment on this

What about the simple question: Do you approve of P.R.?

Comment on this

They could not translate it into Irish, the Minister said.

Comment on this

No, that is not quite the point. Apparently there were a number of considerations involved. It has been suggested that three questions would need to be answered. It has been said here in all seriousness that it was quite a simple matter to put on the ballot paper three questions requiring an answer of the same type in order that this matter might be solved intelligently——

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not be allowed to make his speech?

Comment on this

Here we find the brains of the Opposition on the Front Benches trying the tricks of the legal trade——

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order !

Comment on this

——by asking flimsy questions, trick questions. I heard it said here to-night that we were asking the question: "Do you approve or disapprove?" and that it was rather like the type of question: "Is it raining or not raining outside?" and the consequences——

Comment on this

Is that another defect in the Referendum Article?

Comment on this

It is a defect in the presentation of the facts by the Opposition, who want to misrepresent the situation so that nobody can understand it. Having failed miserably on the Second Reading on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, this opportunity is being taken to try to add to the confusion that they tried to create in the past.

It has also been suggested that we should run this referendum vote in the same way as a general election and we have been asked why we cannot allow the presiding officer to explain the issue to an illiterate or incapacitated voter who cannot mark his own paper. It has been suggested that we could give the presiding officer the same discretion as he has in regard to general elections. What discretion has a presiding officer in a general election? One finds 17, 16, 14 or ten names on a ballot paper and a voter comes in and does not know which person or what number of persons he is going to vote for. He says he wants his paper marked. That is usually what he says. He does not go up and say: "I do not understand the ballot paper." The only information he is supplied with, by the presiding officer, and the only information that the presiding officer is entitled to supply, is to read the list of names, whether it be five or 25, one after the other, just the names only. He may not tell the voter who, for one reason or another, cannot mark his own paper, what Party a man belongs to, where he comes from, who his father was or his mother, what policy he stands for or what he did during his last term of office or whether it was his first time up or anything else.

Yet, it is suggested here that something is enjoyed by the electorate in a general election that will not be enjoyed in this case. Surely that is rather "daft" thinking and it is rather "daft" to suggest that in a general election illiterate or incapacitated voters are fully conversant with the issues when they have heard from ten to 17 names read out to them, that they are then fully satisfied in their minds as to the people they will vote for. Everybody knows that is not so. Everybody knows such a man may go out as he came in, having forgotten the name of the man he came to vote for and not having had it recalled by the reading of the list of candidates. Very often he may not be able to vote at all. On the other hand, if the reading of the list does recall the name, he indicates that name and has the vote recorded.

Surely in view of all the time that has been spent discussing the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill and the time that has yet to be spent and will be spent on the Committee Stage and later when the Bill goes through the Seanad, does anybody seriously suggest that the people of the country are so dumb that they will not know what is involved and what will be presented to them in this referendum? Are the Opposition taking the line taken on another occasion by the present Leader of the Opposition? When Deputy Costello talked of the electorate, in regard to their intelligence or their lack of intelligence, he said, as reported in the Official Debates on the Draft Constitution, Volume 67, column 295:—

"Ninety-nine per cent. of the people of the country at the moment do not know there is such a thing as a Constitution being enacted in this House, and do not care, and 90 per cent. of them do not know what a Constitution is."

Is that still the mentality of the Leader of the Opposition and those who sit behind him, that the people are so ignorant that they do not know what a Constitution means and that, anyhow, as high a proportion of them as 90 per cent. do not care a thing about it? Are we still being faced with the belief that that is the position in the country? Certainly, listening to the moaning and groaning here to-night by various speakers, it would appear as if the Opposition views have not changed since 1937, that they still believe that the electorate are completely and absolutely ignorant, illiterate and without any knowledge or care as to what is going on. We in this Party and the Government know differently and we believe differently; and possibly that is the reason why we have kept the position on these benches for so many of the years since the State was set up.

Let no one make any mistake about it. The Irish people have very keen sense of what is going on in the political world in their own country. They have a pretty keen sense, indeed, and I think it would be pretty true to say that there are no more ardent politicians in their own way in any country than there are to be found in this country. Our people take a keen interest in all things political and I can assure the House they are taking a very keen interest in this matter.

Comment on this

The unemployed are not.

Comment on this

The throwing of dust in their eyes, as Deputy Coogan has tried to do just now, is not going to blind them to the issue. They will go to the polls to do their duty as they have done on many occasions before and we on this side of the House are quite satisfied to leave it to their good judgment, discretion and intelligence, without trying in any way to confuse them as the Opposition have tried to confuse them; and when the result is known we will abide by it.

Comment on this

You will have to; it is no thanks to you.

Comment on this

It certainly may not be any thanks to the Deputy either— when he is finished.

Comment on this

You will have to abide by the result.

Comment on this

We will be relieved of some of those we have here now amongst us.

Comment on this

The Minister's whispered threats will not avail.

Comment on this

Down on Dún Laoghaire pier we know what the emigrants think.

Comment on this

Was the Deputy down the pier to-night?

Comment on this

I was down many a night, and I would like it if the Minister were there, too.

Comment on this

Which pier? There is not much point in my trying to make things clear to the people who wish to create confusion where none exists. We are abused by the Deputies opposite, we are alleged to be perpetrating tricks of all kinds on the electorate, we are alleged to be trying to confuse the electorate. All sorts of suggestions are being made that our ideas in bringing these matters forward are not on the level.

I do not think that anything I or anybody else could say would really be necessary, because when it comes to the test the people themselves will be the final judges as to who is confusing whom and they will find out that we on this side, as has been our custom down through the years, are not trying to confuse them now.

In so far as the Referendum (Amendment) Bill is concerned, all I can do is repeat now that if any Deputies in the Opposition, despite their efforts to confuse the issue, have any ideas which would be of a helpful nature, to make more clear the situation as we now see it, I shall be glad to consider them in full. I shall consider their suggestions, whether made as amendments on the next stage of the Bill or submitted in any other way between now and the Committee Stage. I shall be glad to look into them and if I find a way out of the difficulties we have encountered no one will be more glad than I that we shall have found something acceptable to all concerned.

I would suggest that the amendment which is tabled here is one which does not remedy the situation, even if it were agreed to—and, of course, I have no intention of intimating that we are in agreement with it. It is of no value whatsoever and, therefore, I suggest that we could not adopt it. It would not give us the benefits which those in opposition seem to think it would give.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister a question?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is very little time.

Comment on this

Since the debate commenced, has the Minister considered the question of sending to each elector a precis of the proposals, as a type of White Paper?

Comment on this

Before the debate commenced, I gave that a great deal of thought and I am still open to consider further that or any other suggestion.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand"—put.

Tá 73
·
Níl 51
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Main motion put.

Tá 73
·
Níl 51
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?