An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Cúigiú Céim. Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Fifth Stage.
Contributions 1–117 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
Dáil Éireann is a very great institution. It is also a very queer one. I do not know how to describe the Government's attitude but the manner in which this Bill has been put before us and moved marks this as a unique moment in the history of this House. The Bill which comes before us for the last time, when it leaves this House with the majority the Government have been able to command for it will have proposed that the foundation upon which this Parliament rests will be radically changed and substantially weakened.
The measure is of such a kind that I want to suggest to the members of the Government, to the Government Party and every Deputy in this House, that the proposals contained in the Bill are quite unconstitutional, that they are contrary to the letter and the spirit of the Constitution itself, and that they are an outrage on the Preamble.
The Government and Government Deputies have committed themselves to pushing through this House a proposal that in future Deputies can come into this House only by election in single member constituencies and by means of a vote that, in our state of society here, means that the people elected under that system will not represent the majority of the people, either in their own constituencies or in the country, and they can get out of that only by outraging another provision in the Constitution which provides the right of free association. These are such radical changes in the Constitution that I submit they are unconstitutional in reference to the letter of the Constitution, its spirit and, as I say, all that is in the Preamble.
The senior people associated with the work of this House came into Irish political life in reaction, by the people as a whole, to a substantial threat to Irish liberty, Irish freedom, and the life of the Irish nation, and the proposal that is made here to-day, coming from inside, is a threat and an attack as insidious as the attack that brought every Party, creed and class together in the 1912, 1913, 1914 and 1919 eras. Part of the greatness of this House and part of the result of its tradition, and of the solid roots from which it comes, is that it is possible to discuss such a measure in the manner in which it has been discussed here. There have been clashes and there have been expressions of passion and all that, but that a proposal of such a kind could be discussed here in so unexplosive a manner is a tribute to this House.
We are discussing the very foundations of our liberties when we discuss a law intended to deprive a substantial number of people of the power of their votes, which in fact is intended to deprive the majority of the electorate of the power of their vote, and is intended to deprive the citizens of this country who desire to go forward as candidates and become members of the Dáil, of the open door that the Constitution, which has been described as a Christian and democratic Constitution, offers. I do not see how a Constitution establishing a Dáil on these principles, denying minorities of any particular class in the country of their rights—rights which in the modern world are so important to the individual and to society, rights of representation in an orderly and effective way in the Parliament that controls so much of the social, economic and other destinies of the people—can be called a Christian Constitution. The manner in which the proposal has been presented here, as well as its matter, is a reflection on that situation, too. I say that it is contrary to the whole spirit of the written Constitution itself, and to its Preamble.
Forty-five years ago or so when we came, from various callings and various interests unassociated in any way with political intent, into political life we did so because the whole life of this nation was threatened. It was threatened by a movement in Britain intent on destroying Irish liberty and nipping in the bud the growth of the strength of our Irish people at that time when they had a possibility of getting their hands, to some extent, on their own affairs. That movement resulted in a rebellion against their own Constitution, and it is a fact that the attack which called men of every Party, creed and class, in 1913, into the political situation to defend Irish liberty, brought a reaction against the movement of the Conservative Party in Britain, which movement has been described by British historians as a rebellion against the British Constitution in order to prevent Ireland having its freedom.
British historians have written that the guns of Sarajevo only broke out in time to save British parliamentary institutions. Such was the intention against the ordinary liberties of this country, based on the rank and file of its people, that we had to withstand an attack that was so great that it could be described by English historians as an attack which would have destroyed English parliamentary institutions.
To-day we are concerned with an attack upon the fundamentals of our representation here that is possibly destructive of our Constitution, but, at that time, we were called into political life to take the torch of Irish tradition out of the hands of those who had carried that torch through difficult days. Through difficulties we held that torch. We got the tradition generally accepted in the Dáil that was set up in 1919 and we hoped here, under this roof, to give it asylum. The fact that these liberties have passed successfully through difficult and dangerous days shows of itself that this House was firmly established in its foundations, and to-day we are able to discuss, without the kind of explosions that would be warranted if this threat came from outside, the pros and cons of this proposal, but what it means to express in terms is very difficult to arrive at.
We have had the case for this proposal put to us smothered under the political literature of Europe and some of the literature of the United States. Can we face the consideration of this case from the point of view of our experience of our lives, our faith, beliefs and experience, or are we to look into the literature of other countries for that? The Taoiseach says, or at least his Party imply, that this measure is his will and testament to their Party. Now that he is, as it were, departing from active public life, or feels he is prepared to do that, he wants to leave this as his will and testament to his Party.
I stood before another leader face to face as, in critical times, I have stood face to face with the present Taoiseach. I stood with Pearse in his cell in Arbour Hill. He was departing from active political public life. Had he a will and testament to give those who had an opportunity of having a last word with him? He had issued an order to surrender which had fallen into our hands and, in the presence of British army representatives there, I had to ask him was that his order. He said it was. When asked did it refer to the whole of Ireland or only to Dublin, he said it referred to the whole of Ireland. When asked if there was any good in the County Dublin people, who had given a good account of themselves during the week, continuing to hold out, he said "no." We could get a "yes" and a "no"; but there was no advice as to how a Parliament should be established. There certainly was no advice from the man who came from the side of Connolly in the G.P.O., that minorities were to be kept in their place in this country. There certainly was no feeling in his mind, I am sure, that the Irish people were to be one massed Party. He had plenty of experience to show that it would not be just. His will and his testament showed his faith in the people and he asked no guarantee there. That was the example that he gave. From that example and that spirit, men of every Party, creed and class, having confidence in one another, sharing one another's burdens and helping those on the right and the left, have built up this State here and kept this Parliament going.
There have been moments of tragedy and moments of glory in this House. If there was any moment of glory or of triumph here, for those of us who mixed with the rank and file, who shared their troubles and tried to guide them and keep our own faith and keep up their spirits, it was in 1948 when the National Labour Party, the Labour Party, Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta and Fine Gael came in and sat on the Government Benches to form a Government of all Parties apart from the Party that would never touch anybody or co-operate with anybody. That was a moment of great triumph in this House, because it was a moment that restored to the work of this House the spirit that emerged when a reaction was called for against an attack on this country that would have burst the British Constitution and British parliamentary institutions.
We have had the sorrow of hearing a Leader of a Party, who call themselves a national Party, with a national record of a particular kind, a man who is held up as the Leader of all the Irish nation at home and abroad, saying that he hated that Government, that he hated the grouping of men in an Irish Parliament which brought every aspect of Irish life and every experience of Irish life together to do, at Government level, what every Party, creed and class worked and slaved and sacrificed to get done, so that the rank and file of the people, having their own burdens and their own work to do throughout the country, could do their work satisfied that they had put representatives into an Irish Parliament who could represent them in their varied outlooks and in their mutual generosity and confidence.
In the freedom that we have had and in the experience that we have, with various groups coming together in the natural order of things, in the economic, in the social and in the cultural, as well as in the political spheres, we have seen what a great richness and differentiation there is in Irish life and how, under the inspiration of their Christian faith and their belief and their personal responsibility, they feel that as they are doing their national work in the fields and factories they want to do it here in Parliament.
In this House, which knows so much of that history, through the actions and the experience of its individual people and through the work of the House here as a whole, we are being told that that must stop. We are told there is to be an end to the great and rich differentiation on the part of the rest of the people, who agreed to co-operate and mingle with one another, who have so much confidence in one another that they can concentrate on their own job for 24 hours of the day and, when it comes to communal and co-operative action, can co-operate. As citizens of a State and as members of a nation, with a tradition, holding together, even in the rough and tragic days of the world, in a free Irish State, we should be able to discuss these matters, even in the comparatively calm way in which we discuss them.
I have to bring my imagination back almost to a pre-1798 point to be able to put into a phrase what is happening to-day. What is happening to-day is that something like this is being said by the Government Party: "Without the ruin of the Fianna Fáil Party, other Parties in this country must not be allowed the smallest influence on the State; Fianna Fáil will not be compelled by any authority whatever to abandon that political situation, which their forefathers won with the sword and which is therefore their birthright; sinne Fianna Fáil."
We have to go back to an ascendancy of more than 150 years ago to catch the mentality. Thanks be to God, that ascendancy has gone, but now we have here this as an amendment to a Constitution which invokes the Holy Trinity, which refers all its actions and our actions to the Holy Trinity, which invokes our fathers and their struggle throughout the centuries, which invokes the national independence of our nation, which invokes the common good and the dignity and freedom of the individual and true social order. I believe in the unity and Trinity of God, by faith. I do not know what the Most Holy Trinity has to do to-day with a proposal of this particular kind. We know from our faith what man is and what his destiny is and what his duty is, when we dare to pray and breathe every day that we in our individual selves may be made partakers of the Divinity of Him who partook of our humanity and when we realise what Irish democracy has meant and where it has come from and where we want to go in the days that are there to-day.
I do not know what we mean by our professions of man and his destiny and his divine conception and his divine and natural attributes, I do not know what they can be, that we cannot hear, as it should be heard, the case that is being made here. We have seen this House thrown into difficulty and turmoil in this discussion, even as between the House and the Chair. I ask the Deputies of all parts of the House to think what they are doing and what the results of these actions may be. I ask them to think in terms of life rather than literature, and if I do refer to one book, I refer to a book that is the compilation of minds of many Irish people sitting on a commission, set up by the Fianna Fáil Government, under the chairmanship of Most Reverend Dr. Browne, Bishop of Galway. I refer to just two pages, with a glance in between to see the multiplicity of callings and of organisations we have in this country dealing with Irish life and to realise what it means to them to have a Parliament which is a reflection of them and in which they can have confidence and over which they can have control.
In one phrase in his foreword, Dr. Browne says that the report is a serious effort to show how abstract principles can be applied to the concrete realities of our complex social and economic life and he goes into what may be regarded, perhaps, as a principle: "It has in more than one place made it clear that vocational organisations should develop from existing institutions and follow the laws of organic, vital growth, without violent breach of continuity."
The Government in dealing with their proposal have used the word "integration". They want integration in Irish political life. They stand as the people whose forefathers won by the sword what they believe is their birthright, and they are "the national Party". All the rest of the nonde-scripts, they say, can come together and integrate. How? By going into the back rooms in the various constituencies and seeing which of them will let the other go up, and while that process of integration, which I suppose they might like to think was something of an organic movement, was going on, while, through the long age that that process would take, every bit of differentiation making a differentiated contribution to the political life of the country is going to be a strength to the people who want to get into the Dáil on the basis of "first past the post".
The type of integration the Dáil has carried out ought to have some kind of meaning and some kind of message for our people as it has had. Individuals have been merged into Parties; Parties have been merged together to meet difficulties such as the economic war when Fine Gael was formed. Integration will go on, but we hope it will do so, not because of dangers arising for the people, forcing them to depart from their ordinary work and thoughts and come together as if to defend themselves from a military danger. We hope it will be the integration that comes when men sit down at one table with their various experiences and different interests and bring their minds to bear on things. It is in relation to that that Deputies have thrown their eyes over what Irish life is, as shown in the Vocational Organisation Commission Report and that they could come to the No. 1 reservation. The No. 1 reservation coming from Miss Bennett and Senator Campbell reveals what I accept as a typical comment on things that have to be minded. It says in the beginning of the reservation:—
"We agree with the principle of vocational organisation, because the general trend of economic and social development impels us inevitably towards a system based upon it."
Later on, they say:—
"Organisation is limited to the sphere of occupation—that is, vocational organisation—and final control of national welfare remains in the hands of a democratically elected Parliament."
Again, they say:—
"...we feel it necessary to emphasise our conviction that the one reliable safeguard will be the conservation of freely elected parliamentary institutions and of the subordination of the Executive Government to Parliament."
Finally, they say:—
"But we cannot subscribe to any proposals which would infringe upon the right of the workers to choose their own forms of organisation."
We cannot subscribe to anything that would deprive the ordinary citizens who are guaranteed a right to vote and that one vote should be as good as another, of the right of entry to the Dáil and the right of association. We cannot accept any denial of that and we repudiate this Bill because it attempts to deny that.
In the light of what we know of our life, our experience and our known capacity, we are asked—facing people who have very definitely declared before that they knew they were wrong when they took certain actions in the past under their present leadership; that they would not follow him to-morrow if they knew where to go —to turn our backs on our own experience and turn to Britain for its experience. Quotations from all kinds of people and all kinds of documents are given to us.
I do not want to refer again to the challenge I issued to the Minister for Health and the Minister for External Affairs as to why they quoted the literature of Europe and shut their eyes to what was printed with Irish money in a national publication dealing with the condition of things in Northern Ireland and the effect the wiping out of P.R. had there. I do not refer to that again, but I do refer to the fact that they have told us that the British system is the thing for security.
Belloc and Chesterton have commented on that in fairly recent years. The presentation of the British system given by the Ministers in this debate has been a deception of the most astonishing kind. They have been offering to the people something great, freedom and liberty. They are making sacrifices in offering the people a great machinery for their betterment. They are really misrepresenting what they are doing. That is why the picture of Ananias comes before my mind.
Hilaire Belloc describes the British Government as the only aristocratic State in white civilisation. There is ample evidence in the writings of Belloc to show there is not a representative Government in Britain in terms of democracy. At a time when Belloc was writing before the war, I have reminded the House that Winston Churchill, as a rather monumental figure in British action and British politics, was complaining that they, by their type of representatives, destroyed the personalities of the great cities and that they were in the position that they were unable to resist what he called the danger of dictatorship. In 1934 he complained of:—
"These enormous political landslides which occur now one way and now the other after some stunt election campaign are harmful both to our trade and livelihood and to the House of Commons."
He complained that in many ways at that time the House of Commons was most unhealthy and that all types of views should be represented there and that if they went on lurching about every few years from one side of the road to the other they would soon find themselves in the ditch.
He was writing that at a time when Belloc and Chesterton were describing the British system of government as the only aristocratic Government in white civilisation. Afterwards, when they had gone through the disaster of the war he was saying, in 1950:—
"We have certainly reached a parliamentary deadlock or stalemate differing in its character from any in living experience."
We are asked to trample on our tradition and our experience and in one blind move to jump into a situation in which, with eyes on the future, Ireland is going to have its parliamentary affairs in the hands of two massed Parties in opposition to each other. Never was such a trick played on any people and, as I say, it is partly to the credit of this House that the people have been awakened a little to what is happening.
I want to make it clear that this is contrary to everything that we know of the roots of Ireland's strength, that it is contrary to everything we know of the classes, Parties and groups that have made sacrifices to give us an Irish Parliament, to help and be a guiding and subsidiary body to our people in carrying on their own work.
The Taoiseach must know that this is building up a situation that can lead to nothing but dictatorship and autocracy. This move is being made in this House, and in this way, at a time when we are celebrating what is called the 21st anniversary of the Constitution. In 1925 I stood in the House of Congress with the Leader of the Labour Party, Mr. Tom Johnson, and Senator Michael Hayes, who was then Chairman of this House. I remember well that in front of every nation in the world Tom Johnson, the Leader of the Labour Party, got up and commenting on a speech made by Churchill, that when the King was at war all the Dominions were at war, made Sir Robert Horne come back into the House and in front of every nation made him declare that he was right. Sir Robert Horne said:—
"It is all very well, however, to twirl your fingers and say I am not playing in a game of tig, but if war is being made by a powerful enemy of Great Britain, Ireland cannot hope to escape."
But in 1925—34 years ago—the Leader of the Labour Party, with the Chairman of Dáil Éireann and myself—then just a Deputy of the House—were able to wring from the representative of the British group of the Inter-Parliamentary Union that what we said about Irish sovereignty and what we said about command over our own affairs was true then. There is not a man or woman in this House but must admit that all that has gone in between was a contribution made from the very soil of Ireland by men, women and children and by every Party, creed and class.
We tell those responsible for the present trick that their position is to-day what the position of the Conservative Government was in 1912, 1913 and 1914 and in all that led to the disastrous trampling on this country in the years following by Lloyd George's and other British Governments continued denial of the full integrity of our country and the full rights of our people. They have learned enough since to know that their country's strength is as much dependent on the strength and neighbourliness of the countries alongside, as it is on their own strength and the internal neighbourly spirit, that will avoid frustration and enable the qualities, the energies and the capacities of the people to be exercised to the full.
To-day countries of the world are exercising to the full their power to take from the ordinary material elements from which the Creator made the earth. The minds and character of the people are more constructive and more powerful in achieving even material happiness than all the Creator put into the material earth. This Bill leads people along pure materialism and pure dictatorship and I resist—and I can speak for every man in the Fine Gael Party—the invitation to sit down in a back room with members of the Labour Party, Clann na Poblachta, Fine Gael and Sinn Féin, and decide who shall represent the Irish people, for any spot of Ireland, in this Parliament. We do that openly by the display of our personalities and political and social characters and the organisations that we put together, and we shall continue to do that.
The Taoiseach will find—haloed and all as he may be by the past—that he is welcome to all the haloes and all the glory he can get from the past. We do not put our haloes and our glory into the scales against him; but we will put our work and the generosity of our minds towards him and towards his colleagues. We realise the difficulty that leadership on his side has brought to so many of the people and so many of his declared supporters, just as we sympathise with the people of Britain and with the traditional element even of the Conservative Party in Great Britain, whose actions in 1913 and all along against this country have played a substantial part in ripping Europe to pieces and bringing down around their own heads the problems that exist, not only at their doors, but at nearly every end of the world to-day.
In this matter we offer the Fianna Fáil Party our fiercest antagonism and our most energetic fight against what they are proposing to blind the people. We do so as honestly, as faithfully and as dedicated to God's glory and the honour of Ireland, as we did in the struggle we put up against the British invasion of our country at that time. We do it in the fullest spirit of people who think that our Constitution should be worthily dedicated to the Most Holy Trinity and that we should be able worthily to say that it follows in the traditional history of our fathers and is dedicated to a true social order here. We guarantee them all that—no malice, no bitterness and no aggression; but we do ask them to consider whether, in regard to their proposals here, they cannot find examples in the Old Testament and in the New Testament and in the modern history even of England and of Europe, on which they might very well meditate.
This, I say, is a great institution. It has gone through great days. It has been great in its small moments and in its big moments. It is being demeaned to-day by the fact that a Government and a Government Party, who have had an opportunity of seeing so much in the country, who have been treated with so much tolerance and generosity, should come in here and make, under a deceitful guise, a proposition to this country that is as big and as fierce a bit of aggression on the liberties of our people and of Parliament as was the case when the Conservative Party, even at the risk of bursting parliamentary institutions in Great Britain, began the attack on this country that developed in 1913 and that, in so many queer ways and in spite of much that they might have learned or had an opportunity of learning, has continued even in some parts of Ireland to-day. We oppose this measure.
Comment on this
Many hours and weeks of parliamentary time have been given to the debate on this Bill. That should suggest to the public the great importance that Deputies on all sides attach to this measure. In my ten years' experience as a Deputy I do not believe I have ever seen a Bill get such detailed examination and exhaustive discussion. Section by section, sub-section by sub-section, in fact, paragraph by paragraph, this Bill has been examined and discussed. Nevertheless, it is the only major Bill I have seen during my ten years here that did not require a reprint from the first to the final issue. Not one single paragraph or single comma was altered by all the discussion, all the advice and all the various amendments. One is inclined to ask oneself: why was there no change in this Bill in particular? Was there any reason for it? I suggest there was this reason. This Bill was deliberately drafted with one set purpose in view, and to change it in any way would defeat what the measure set out to do. All the paragraphs, sections and sub-sections were so interdependent that to carry out the slightest alteration or to yield to the desires of the Opposition, even on a minor point, would nullify the full effect of the Bill.
The Government's case in support of the Bill was based on a number of points. One was that it was essential for stable Government that minority Parties should be deprived of their right of representation in Dáil Eireann. They suggested that that had been achieved under the direct voting system. Instances were given of the weakness of the inter-Party Governments in 1948 and 1954. Instances were also given of the weakness of coalition Governments in various parts of the world, even of some Governments not elected by P.R. at all. It was made a point of supreme importance by many of the Government's speakers that the people of this country were entitled to decide by their votes what system of election to Dáil Eireann they required.
The Opposition countered the points raised by the Government on the basis that the present system of P.R. gave stable Government, comparable with any country in Europe. They pointed out that Governments elected under this system here within the past 40 years had a longer life than the Governments elected in Great Britain under the direct voting system. In fact, it was pointed out, as well it might be, that the present Government, elected under P.R., is numerically—whatever may be said of it in other ways—a strong Government.
The Opposition pointed to the dangers that might arise from this attempt to deprive small groups and Parties of their right to constitutional representation in the Dáil. They pointed out the dangers that might arise by forcing them into unconstitutional methods to achieve their objects. They pointed out that the decision to refer this matter to the people was being taken at a time when the economic distress throughout the country was so acute and had such an effect on the people that the issue involved might not receive the consideration to which it was entitled and there was no demand by the public that the Government should put the question to the people at this particular stage. It was pointed out that there was no need for this rush to change a Constitution which had operated satisfactorily for upwards of 21 years.
Fianna Fáil made a virtue of necessity in this matter, insisting that the issue would be put before the people and it would be the people who would decide. It is a basic principle of the Constitution, and fundamental to it, that no alteration in the system of voting can take place without the people being consulted. Were it not for that, we might not have such enthusiasm on the part of Fianna Fáil for the people to decide in this matter. In opposing this Bill we know, just as Fianna Fáil know, that it is the people who will have the final say. The case we made was not that we wished to deprive the people of their right to decide what system of election we should have, if a change were needed, but that this was not the opportune time or the appropriate moment at which to put the issue to the people. There were much more serious issues to be tackled first, such as unemployment and emigration; it was our contention that the problems in which the country finds itself should first be solved and then, and only then, should this issue be brought before the people so that they might consider it in the bright sunshine of prosperity and the calm atmosphere of economic wellbeing.
I should like to point out some of the dangers that may follow the abolition of P.R., should the proposed referendum go the way the Government hope it will go. It has been pointed out by experts, experts who have no particular axe to grind and can examine the matter quite objectively, that on the figures of the last election, and the elections prior to it, it is more than likely that more than 90 per cent. of the Fianna Fáil Party will be returned to power if the system of election is changed to the single non-transferable vote. Should that happen, to all intents and purposes, for the next ten years, the country will be faced with Government by one major Party and an Opposition so small as to be almost negligible. That Government, sure of its numerical strength here, will then be in a position to pass legislation, with practically no opposition, altering the system of local government elections so as to ensure the same advantage to their Party in local government as they will have secured here. It will also mean—to my mind, this is the most important point—that, with fewer than 20 Deputies in opposition and with control of the various county councils throughout the country, secured by manipulation and regulation, the right of nomination for the Presidency will be taken from the people and handed over to one Party. There is a grave likelihood that that will happen.
If we leave aside all the questions raised by the Opposition and simply confine ourselves to saying that there is no public demand for an alteration in the system of election, if we confine ourselves to the argument—and it is true—that the majority anti-Fianna Fáil vote will be so divided by this ruse that the various sections will not be able to combine to defeat Fianna Fáil and the Government Party will directly gain thereby, if we confine ourselves to the fact that for the next ten years the Government are likely to be faced with an Opposition of ten or 12 Deputies of the various combined Parties, if we are satisfied that one can have dictatorship by Party as well as by the individual, as we know can happen from our experience of Governments in other countries where Party or sectarian rule is supreme, and if we give Fianna Fáil credit for all they say and accept that they believe it is worth paying a price so that the people may have stable Government and it is worth taking all these risks to secure stable Government, then why this rush at this particular time to change the system? Where is the need to do it? Why must it be done now?
The argument has been advanced that the constituencies revision due some time this year necessitates the change. That, of course, is not true. There is machinery in the Constitution for revising constituencies. That machinery must operate at least once in every 12 years. It is not laid down anywhere that constituencies cannot be revised more than once in any 12 years. There is nothing to prevent the Government continuing its normal life span until 1962. There is nothing to prevent Fianna Fáil deferring this issue for a reasonable length of time. But Fianna Fáil, at the start of this debate, were determined to have this Bill passed through this House at any cost and we were told that this decision should take place by March of this year.
By the exercise of their rights in this Dáil, the Opposition groups delayed that up to the present day, so much so that we forced Fianna Fáil to depart from the cry that they wished this to be taken as a separate issue, that they wished that the referendum should not clash with the Presidential election. We forced Fianna Fáil to declare that, because of our action in exercising our rights as Deputies in fully discussing a measure of fundamental importance to the country, they now have decided that it is essential that the two elections should be held on the same day.
I wonder does that decision give us a clue to what was behind this Bill from the first? Would it not suggest to the public that the intention was that the Referendum Bill would be over and done with and that the Fianna Fáil Party could rest secure in the knowledge that at the next election, by virtue of the fact that, the Opposition being divided into various groups, their numerical strength could not be passed on from Party to Party by means of the system of P.R., Fianna Fáil had a safe term in office for the next ten years and that then, with that done, the present Leader of the Government could divest himself of office and go forward to Presidency of the country?
We were told by the Taoiseach at some stage of the debate on this Bill that the main reason for having this referendum was to find out the will of the people on this matter, that it was not desirable that anything else should over-cloud that issue or clash with it. Since then, the Taoiseach has repeated that, apart from the question of putting the country to double expense, it was not desirable that the referendum and the Presidential election should be held on the same day, but that the Opposition, by their deliberate policy, had rendered that inevitable.
Certainly, there is the question of expense, but, on a fundamental issue of such importance as to necessitate an alteration in the Constitution, the question of the expenditure of £100,000 or £150,000 should not be made the excuse for obscuring the issue and for holding the Presidential election and the referendum on the same day.
The two nominees for the Presidency are of national repute, men who in their own way have given long and distinguished service to the country, but they are, unfortunately, men who have taken opposite sides in that most regrettable period of civil war. These two men will be contenders for the Presidency. On the same occasion as the Presidential election is held, amidst the strife and political bitterness that is bound to arise, the question of the manner of electing representatives, in the national interest, will also have to be decided.
I challenge the Government to proceed with the election of the President in June and, when the turmoil and strife of Party politics have died down, following the result, at a later date, when the people will be able to come to a fair decision in the calm and quiet atmosphere that will then prevail, to hold the referendum. I challenge the Government that, if they refuse that request, they will be found guilty of putting Party above the people.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy in the course of his speech in which he dealt with many things, including a meeting of the Inter-Parliamentary Union in Washington a long time ago, had one main theme at the heart of his discourse and that was that we were reverting to what he described as the British system of election. That system of election is not of British origin but the system of election which is embodied in Article 16 of our Constitution is. This system of election by transferable vote in constituencies returning more than one member was invented in Great Britain over 100 years ago. It has been the subject of a great deal of controversy and examination in Great Britain. Many eminent men have urged that it should be adopted there, but the common sense of the British people was against the theorists and when, in 1910, the system was made the subject of an examination by a British Royal Commission, which had been set up by a Liberal Government, it was roundly condemned. The British attitude towards the particular system which is in operation here has not changed since.
The position, therefore, is that Deputy Mulcahy has a greater regard for this child of a Briton's brains than the British people themselves have, such a regard and affection for it that he is not even prepared to look at its faults nor at the manner in which the Irish people were led to adopt it.
In the face of the record, no one can urge that this system was of our devising. We know how it came to be adopted here. It crept in under the guise of a Local Government (Ireland) Bill which had its Second Reading in the House of Commons in the year 1919. The person in charge of that Bill was the then, I think, Attorney General for Ireland, Mr. Samuels, K.C,. and, on the Committee Stage of the Bill, this exchange took place between him and an Ulster Tory: Mr. Samuels advocating the Bill and sponsoring and piloting it through committee said:—
"At the general election, on the parliamentary franchise, 75 per cent. of the representation has gone over to the Sinn Féin Party. What is the declared object of that Party? It is to make local government in Ireland absolutely impossible and to break down British reign and rule in Ireland by capturing local bodies...
Major O'Neill: Is it not the fact that the right hon. gentleman never mentioned this question of the Sinn Féiners in his speech moving the Second Reading of this Bill? May we take it that that was the real reason why this Bill has been introduced?"
That is a very significant passage. First of all, it proclaims in undeniable terms what is the provenance of the system which we adopted, and secondly, it proclaims undisguisably what it was hoped that system would accomplish. It was hoped that that system would accentuate every point of division among the Irish people, that it would make it more difficult to secure that union of opinion and action in Parliament which the British regard as being one of the great factors in their history, the factor that the British people in Parliament have had a reasonable alternative to the Government in power and that that alternative has been secured while being compatible with the greatest degree of unity that permits such an alternative to exist.
This amendment to the Constitution is now being proposed to the people. We are not doing any more than submitting our proposal to the people for their judgment; we are not, as Deputy Mulcahy suggested, trying to force it down the throats of the people or to force them to adopt it against their better judgment. We will have an ample opportunity, I hope, to present our case to the people and the Opposition will have an equal opportunity of doing so. What we are doing—we are not appealing to the prejudices of the people as the Opposition are—is putting this matter to their own sober judgment and asking them, with the knowledge of the history not merely of this country but of other countries to teach them and to guide them, if they are prepared to continue to live under the danger of anarchy and coalition and corruption which is inherent, as the Leader of the Opposition himself admitted, in this system of election by the transferable vote——
Comment on this
That is the issue that is being put to the people, and I say we can point not merely to what has happened abroad but to what has happened here. We have seen in the course of every Parliament that new Parties have sprung up here. We have seen the main Opposition Party change its personnel and composition in order to absorb some of these splinter Parties which grew up.
Comment on this
We have seen that even the assimilative quality of the Fine Gael Party, which seems to be able to take everything into its maw, the right as well as the left, has not been able to prevent the growth of small, splinter, nuisance Parties in this country——
Comment on this
Not even Fine Gael were able to absorb them. Not even when Fine Gael had entered into bargains with them, when they were subservient to these minor Parties, when Clann na Poblachta was wagging, so to speak, the dog of Fine Gael, could Fine Gael maintain a united Party with a consistent coherent policy for more than two or three years. Twice the Coalitions have broken up in this country—the only two Coalitions which existed here since 1922. Twice Fine Gael Coalitions have broken up, sometimes on the question of mere imcompatibility of personality, sometimes on the question of policy and sometimes because the minority in the Government was asking too high a price for the appearance of unanimity which was manifested. In the course of the first Coalition, we saw a fundamental principle of our Constitution violated. Deputy Mulcahy has been talking about the Preamble to the Constitution and everything that is in it and told us, merely because we are asking the people, in the light of experience, to decide whether or not they want an Article of the Constitution changed, that we are acting unconstitutionally.
The Leader of the Opposition who was Taoiseach in the first Coalition, threw overboard in this House the Article in the Constitution which provides that the Government shall act with collective responsibility and he disclaimed collective responsibility for certain statements that had been made down the country by a member of his Government—statements which, of course, were quite contrary to the avowed policy of the major Party in the Coalition, the Fine Gael Party.
What does this Bill do? It asks the people to abolish the present method of election. I have said elsewhere, and I will repeat it, that the very name of the method of election we have here is a misnomer. We have never had true P.R. in this country, representation which gives to every Party—and it can give it only to Parties, not to people—a place in the Legislature proportionate to the votes which they were given. We have not got here, as I said, P.R. We have a different system altogether. It may give the appearance, and is giving the appearance, of conceding proportionality to some extent; but it is not P.R. What we have here is election by the transferable vote. With the degree of individuality which exists among our people, it would be very difficult not only for us to apply the principle of P.R. but to get them to accept the list system as it exists elsewhere. It is only under the list system that the theory of P.R. can be applied and it can be applied only where tightly organised Parties dominate political life.
On the Continent, an attempt has been made to give effect to the theory of P.R. and it is significant that the system which is in force throughout all the Continent, except, I think, to-day in France, is this list system. But under that system every elector has an equal right. Every elector has only one vote and can vote only once. He votes for the Party list. There may be certain refinements with certain variations in use in various countries, but his vote counts only once and he can cast it only once. It is not possible to have any second, third, fourth or fifth preference because you have the non-transferable vote.
Under the list system—it has many disadvantages—there is this virtue, that every elector is the equal of every other and a premium is not put, as it is under our system, upon dissent. That system of P.R. requires large constituencies returning numerous members. Arising out of this, it has many defects. There is, first of all, no place in it for the Independent. There is no place whatever in it for the Independent. There is a place in the system of transferable vote for the Independent and under the system which we are proposing of single member constituencies with representatives elected by the non-transferable vote, there will be a place for the Independent who can command the suffrages of the majority of his neighbours.
The second defect about the list system is this. It produces a divorcement of representatives from their electors. The personal relationship which ought to exist as between the representative and the electorate, and his people, is completely broken under this list system of P.R.
The third defect is that the representatives who are elected under the list system are more responsible—in fact, in some cases, solely responsible —to their Party executives rather than to the people who vote to elect them. Therefore, if a representative is not in good standing with the Party boss, his name will not appear at election time upon the Party list. He will have no chance whatever of being elected or even of standing as an Independent, as I have already mentioned. The list system, therefore, tends to give control of Parliament to Party bosses, Party executives and because the Party executives are all-powerful in regard to their representatives in Parliament, it leads ultimately to the control of public life by Party bosses and, therefore, to widespread corruption.
There is a fourth demerit in this system. It lends every inducement to the ambitious politician to try to gain control of the Party organisation. If he cannot do this, then it induces him to try to form his own Party. Thus, once again, you have this influence of an attempt to construct Parliament upon a mathematical basis manifesting its disadvantageous side in the fact that it again tends to create division where it is desirable that union should exist.
I have said that the list system tends to make the ambitious politician endeavour to gain control of the Party organisation and that where he is not able to secure control of it, it tends to make him look for an organisation of his own or, if you like, split the Party and form another organisation to further his own particular ends or ideas. We have an example of that occurring just within the past four days. When this Bill was having its Second Reading before December, I referred to the parliamentary situation which existed then in Italy. I pointed out that with the system of P.R. which they had, the number of Parties which it had bred and the general tendency to disruptive action which is inherent in these systems, it was not likely that the then existing coalition of Christian Democrats with Social Democrats would be able to continue and that before very long the Italian Government would be out of office.
That has happened within the past few days and it has happened for one reason only—that, first of all, an ambitious politician tried to secure control of the Christian Democrat machine and, secondly, other members of the Christian Democrat Party, formerly Prime Ministers, resolved to contest it and succeeded in breaking up the coalition.
That is a temptation which exists in every coalition. It is a temptation which has been shown to exist here beyond denial in the Coalition from 1948 to 1951, when, because of a rift inside the Clann na Poblachta Party, the Fine Gael Coalition was broken up. We have not yet been able to discover what led to the very significant General Election of 1957 when the Leader of a Coalition which then had a strong majority in this House asked the President to grant him a dissolution before the Book of Estimates for the year 1957-58 appeared and before the financial provisions for that year were put before the people. We do not know what internal stress led the Taoiseach to ask the President for that dissolution but it is quite clear from things said in the course of that election, not by Deputy Norton, the Leader of the Labour Party, but by supporters of the Labour Party, that we had not that happy, united family which Deputy J. A. Costello, the Leader of the Opposition, likes to talk about now.
In order not to get away from the main theme, in order to come back again, may I say that, with the list system of P.R., you have again the fissiparous tendency manifested. It makes for coalitions; so that the great disadvantage of every variation of the list system, as well as of the system of voting by transferable vote, is that it tends to breed coalitions.
The system of election by transferable vote has most of the defects which I have mentioned in a greater or lesser degree. It calls for large constituencies in most districts. We have avowedly tried in the Electoral Bill of 1947 to get away from that defect and to reduce even the rural constituencies to manageable proportions. It has given us, I suppose, some degree of stability, but not enough.
Comment on this
It boomeranged, if you like—and we were succeeded by the first Coalition, about whose unhappy ending I have been talking for quite a while. It boomeranged, but, in the end, while it may have boomeranged on us, it succeeded in guillotining you. You, in the end, were hoist with it.
Comment on this
The Chair was not. Perhaps, Sir, if the Minister used the third person, it might help him.
Comment on this
I was saying that this system calls in general for large and unwieldy constituencies. I was pointing out that we endeavoured to counteract that so that we might have the right sort of relationship between the representative and his people which can be found only in the system of election by non-transferable vote and single member constituencies. In addition to that, in addition to this weakening of the relationship between the people and the representatives, it makes elections very expensive. We all know that. Even in an urban constituency, the cost of conducting an election campaign is becoming oppressive. It must be much more oppressive in large rural constituencies covering perhaps, as some do, not merely part of a county but even two counties.
Then, as we all know, it leads to the multiplication of Parties and the accentuation of differences—differences even in Coalitions. In fact, a Party is driven, when it is within a Coalition, to try to maintain its separate identity to the point of acerbity with every one of its associates. In order that the Labour Party, say, for instance, might not come to stand in the public mind for everything Fine Gael stands for, the Labour Party, if it happens to be in a Coalition, has to try to set its face against the things the Fine Gael members of the Government would like to do and has to pretend, even when it has yielded to the pressure of the major Party, that in some way it is not responsible for them. It has to adopt the rôle of a political Herod and wash its hands of the things which its own associates are doing within the Government.
In addition to all these defects, the system of election which we have here, by transferable vote, has an additional defect. It gives undue weight to the wishes or the whims even of the cranky voter, of the fellow whose very nature it is to be at variance with everyone else. There is one great fallacy underlying the whole system. It assumes that it is of no great moment whether the people are represented in Parliament by those men or women whom they think most closely represent their point of view, that is, by their first choice, or by men or women, by Deputies whose title to sit in Parliament is based on an amalgam of inferior choices.
If one applied this system of election to a football team, its absurdity would be manifest. Nobody would have much regard for a team that was selected on the basis that a player whom the majority of the selectors thought was a fifth or sixth rater was regarded as being just as good as one whom the largest body among the selectors would place first. People would not have any regard for such a team; because every man knows that only the player who is best fitted for his place is worthy to be chosen for an important occasion.
No task is more important than the choice of a representative of the people in an area in the national assembly. No assembly can have a more critical function than that of selecting a Government. Yet, under the system of election by transferable vote, the personnel of a Government and the public policies of a State are determined by, among others, some who were not the first or even fifth, but who may have been the 15th or the 16th choice of the electors who were ultimately responsible for sending them to Parliament. It is contrary to the very nature of things that a system which gives the lower choice of the electors equal validity with their first choice can work satisfactorily.
The very nature of the transferable vote changes with every transfer and, with every transfer, changes in an increasing degree. It starts off in most cases with being a vote for something, with being, that is, positive in its character. In its ultimate stages, it becomes a vote against something. It changes its character and, instead of being positive, becomes negative in its direction.
Comment on this
I have said that the single transferable vote gives undue weight to the crank who loves to be at variance with his fellows, that it puts a premium on dissent, that it encourages disunion. Let us see how that arises. We must take the peculiar people first in the consideration of this matter; because the transferable vote is intended to cater for the peculiar people.
Comment on this
Do not delude yourself. They were not such a minority. The people who will go out in face of desperate odds in any community are bound to be in a minority, but do not pervert history. They were not in a minority in their sense of nationality. They were not in a minority in their view of what the Irish people wanted.
Comment on this
We are not talking now about desperate struggles or armed combat. We are talking now about the peaceful process of election.
Comment on this
——I was saying that because his vote may determine the result of an election, we are going to deal with a peculiar person first. Let us see what happens to his vote. When he goes to the polling booth there may be, probably will be, a candidate rather closely resembling his own point of view and he will vote for him. His vote will be to that extent positive for that candidate or the Party for which he stands. Then he votes for the second best man on the list. The second best man may have very little in common with his first choice but at any rate he marks him down. The first choice is all positive but in his second choice he is voting for a person whom he would not put first, and to that extent the positive decision is blended with the negative.
The first candidate goes out, the second candidate goes out, and the crank still remains at the firing line. He has a third choice, but this time the degree of positivity in the vote has become less and he is voting more for the third person because he is against all the rest rather than because he is for the same policy as the No. 1 choice. So it goes right down until, as I have said, at the end we get this extraordinary situation that the voter is voting not for something but against something. While his first vote may have been intended to advance a policy, his last votes, his final preferences, are designed to prevent other policies from being put into operation.
This elector's first vote may have had a constructive element in it from his point of view; but certainly his last preferences are destructive in their very nature and that is why, among other things, it is very difficult with this system of transferable vote to get anything constructive done in any Parliament, to get a Party returned with the unmistakable support of the largest section in the community, with the effective driving force in the community behind it, so that with such a force behind it it may be able to carry through a coherent, consistent policy.
What are we asking the people to accept in exchange for this system which makes it so difficult to get a Government which will have sufficient momentum to carry through any constructive policy? What are we asking them to accept for this system which tends by its very nature to divide the people, to give an undue place in determining the affairs of the State to the person who likes to be at odds with his neighbour, to the quarrelsome, self-assertive, bumptious elements in the community, rather than to those who are prepared to work with their neighbours in harmony for the common good. We are giving them this system which has tended, where-ever it has been in operation, to unite within two Parties all the elements in the community.
Comment on this
Northern Ireland is a special situation. The great thing about the two-Party system is that on both sides of every Parliament which is elected upon that basis there are men of very similar points of view. You have in the Conservative Party men who would regard themselves as very advanced in their social outlook. In the Labour Party you have men who certainly could not be regarded, even taking the most liberal view of their principles, as radicals. The merit of the system lies to some extent in that, because it means that those two Parties tend to converge towards a common centre, tend to have a great deal in common with each other, tend to make the parliamentary system work, because there can be and there is where this system works a great deal of agreement among members of the Front Benches as to what is best in the national interest, a great deal of agreement within the Parties as to what is best in the national interest.
Moreover it has this merit from the people's point of view, that no Party can have a monopoly of the Government, that whatever the Party in power may be, the people have in front of that Party sitting on the other side of the House a reasonable alternative—an alternative which will not make for revolution if it should come in, if it should be a Party which is left of centre; nor make for reaction if the Party coming in should be right of centre; but will keep the Government policies towards the centre of the road where the mass of the people in every community want them to be. It will mean that the affairs of the nation will be shaped and moulded not by the fringes, not by the extremities, but by the good solid middle that exists in every community, the good solid mean that embraces every creed, and every class, and every economic interest within the community. That is the system which we are offering as an alternative to the system which has been so disastrous wherever it has had an opportunity to work itself out elsewhere.
We have been saved the consequences of having that dangerous system here by reason of the fact, as is quite properly admitted, that we had one division between us that is now passing, and thank God it is passing. We were radically divided on a matter of supreme principle, but we have now come to common acceptance of the fact that Ireland must be an independent nation outside the Commonwealth. Again, we have had the advantage of having an outstanding personality as Leader of our Party and a great spirit of unity, stemming back to the division upon the Treaty, if you like, which has held that Party together. I do not want to decry anything done by any member of any Party that was in favour of the Treaty but we were fortunate in some ways that, at a critical period, we had Mr. W. T. Cosgrave and that he was succeeded at an equally critical stage as head of the Government by Deputy de Valera. The mere fact that we had these factors in the public life of our country has prevented the system under which we live here from showing all its defects and all its disadvantages.
When the scene changes, as it is likely to change in a short time, and other men and other Parties and other policies emerge, then the evils of the system may become manifest and, if we are wise in our generation, we will change the system of election. We will try and get that system which, while providing the people with, let me emphasise, a reasonable alternative to the Government of the day, whatever that Government may be, will tend also to mould the people into the greatest possible degree of union within their respective Parties.
Comment on this
The very arrogance of the Minister for Health is amusing, and certainly the finish of his speech reminds me of something I read in Dickens. I forget in which of his novels it was, but it was a description of a death-bed repentance on the part of one of the characters in the book. The Minister's speech reminds me very much of that, and I am just beginning to ask myself very peculiar questions in view of some of the Minister's utterances to which he has just treated us.
Comment on this
The Deputy should congratulate him on that. Was he being sarcastic or is the Deputy being sarcastic?
Comment on this
What I want to tell the House is that I am positively stunned, having heard the last few minutes of the Minister's speech. Let the various Deputies take what they like out of that. The Minister has told us that P.R. originated in 1919, in a Local Government (Ireland) Act intended for some specific part of the country. In actual fact it did not; it originated among several of our Nationalist leaders long before 1919, and the records are here to prove that.
I want to ask the Minister one question. The Minister's Party came into power in 1932 and until 1948 they had an unbroken run of Government. They were never out of power once during that time, and they came back to power in 1951 until 1954 for a second period in office. If P.R. was such a very disastrous method of voting for the Irish people I would like to ask the Minister one plain question— what were they doing about it from 1932 to 1948?
Comment on this
Of course they did. The Minister is trying to convey that it was the English imposed P.R. but in his speech later on he tried to convey the impression that it was some men, in this country, who insisted on forcing it upon the country. I shall not go into that. All I am asking is what was he doing for the first 16 years his Party were in office and why did he not remove it? Why did the Leader of his Party insist on putting it into the Constitution and make such a terrific song and dance about it? They did so because they thought that P.R. was a bullet-proof method of election which would allow them to hold office. They thought that it was impossible for Fianna Fáil to be dislodged from office under that system, but they found out the opposite in 1948 and 1954, and now they want to make sure that such a thing will not happen them again. They want to remain in office as long as their cronies are there to support them.
Comment on this
The people did not think that and, if another election came under P.R., Deputy O'Malley can take it from me the people would vote for just such another disaster, as he calls the Coalition.
Comment on this
It would be small loss if every other member of Fianna Fáil went with the Deputy. It is outrageous to think that, having increased the cost of living during the past two years and having such a high unemployment record now, the only money to be spent is on a whim of the Taoiseach to keep Fianna Fáil in power. If Deputy O'Malley wants to go on that basis then the Deputy himself will go and a lot of his colleagues with him.
The second question I want to ask the Minister for Health is, if P.R. is such a bad system of election for the Dáil, why is it retained for the election of the President? I have asked that question here on a couple of occasions and it has not been answered.
Comment on this
I believe it does, Sir. We are abolishing P.R., or rather we are asking the people to abolish P.R.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil are very fond of saying that the two periods of Coalition Government were disastrous for this country and that the Coalition Governments did not last long but during the 16 years' period of Fianna Fáil Government we had seven general elections. We had a general election in 1932, 1933, 1937, 1938, 1943, 1944 and 1948, and the average age of the Fianna Fáil Governments, with their so-called working majorities or overall majorities, was two years and four months.
Comment on this
The Deputy means no stability under Fianna Fáil because in 1937 Fianna Fáil had an overall majority and later they had nine of a majority in this House. Perhaps the Minister for Health would tell us why it was necessary, with nine of a majority, to dissolve the Dáil a full year and a half before its normal span of life expired? I want to say that it is scandalous at this juncture to ask the people to spend £100,000 on this amendment to the Constitution, an amendment which is proposed not for the benefit of the country but for the benefit of one Party. It is regrettable —I do say this sincerely—that the last will and testament which the Taoiseach is leaving is being left to his Party and not to the country as a whole.
It is obviously the Fianna Fáil Party he has in mind when he is trying to secure them in office and not the good of the people. It is a shabby mean testament at the end of a fairly long political career, during which he did a lot of good things, even if he did a lot of bad things also. It would be a pity to spoil the good side of his picture by leaving such a legacy as this to his Party, a legacy which he thinks will be so good for his Party but which will be so damaging to the country.
It is my opinion that this Bill, if passed, will sow the seeds of grievous trouble sooner or later. That is my conviction. The Minister had a lot to say about P.R. leading to a multiplicity of Parties. What is wrong with that? Might I tell him that any new Party, nine times out of ten, is started because of the absolute failure of the Government in power to do something that is badly needed for a particular section of the people? Then these people take the bit in their teeth and say: "All right; we supported such a Party, they gave us promises at election after election, but they have not honoured them. Now we will put our own men in." That is what put the Labour Party into this House, and that is what put the Farmers' Party into this House and that is what will put vocational Parties into the House.
Comment on this
The Labour Party were here before Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Clann na Poblachta or Clann na Talmhan.
Comment on this
It is the contempt of the Government for a section of the people that forces forward a Party. This move will not stop that. I want to assure the Minister for Health that this attempt to bottle the crackpots and the cranks—as he calls those who vote for anybody but Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael—will not stop them. Why should the people, after supporting a Party, as the farmers did, from 1932 to 1943—they gave Fianna Fáil 11 years in which to honour their promises—not form another Party if they are not catered for? During that time Fianna Fáil trampled them into the dust and that gave rise to one of the cases of so-called multiplicity of Parties. The farmers sent in their own representatives and we got what they sent us in to do, and it was no thanks to Fianna Fáil that we did.
Apparently we have a new gospel in Irish politics, that is, that anybody who is not for Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael is either a crackpot or a crank. That will make very interesting reading for many people up and down the country—that if they vote No. 1, 2 or 3, as the case may be, for those who do not belong to either of these two Parties, they are either crackpots or cranks.
Comment on this
The Minister for Health told us here to-night, and on several other occasions, that anybody who does not vote for either of the two big Parties is a crackpot. If Deputy O'Malley had been in the House, he would have heard a very long elaboration of that.
Comment on this
It has been a feature of Fianna Fáil politics for many years always to blame their own misdeeds and their own wrong utterances on their political opponents. I, for one, will not accept that. Any Deputy who wants to accept it may do so, but Deputy O'Malley will not shove that down my throat. It was the Minister for Health who labelled all those who did not vote for Fianna Fáil, or Fine Gael, as crackpots and the people they voted for as cranks. He has told us that within the past ten minutes.
Might I invite the Minister for Health to come to Mayo during the campaign on this referendum and I will get a vast number of crackpots for him? I would nearly advise him to bring a speedy car with him and, like a good general, make sure of his retreat.
Comment on this
I should not like to enter that domestic quarrel down in Mayo. I gather that Clann na Talmhan has a civil war on its hands.
Comment on this
Seeing that the Minister is dodging this issue, will he stand over the utterances he made?
Comment on this
I do not think he will. I should be very glad to see him, whatever about this imaginary domestic quarrel which the Minister talks about. Let us hear him in Mayo—in Castlebar, Claremorris and Belmullet —telling the people that they are crackpots. I can assure the Minister that he will get a good reception and a warm one.
Comment on this
If this Bill becomes law, it will lead to very nasty cases of corruption. Deputy Sherwin, on Committee Stage, gave us a good example of what happened in England—I think, in Southend. There will be many Southends in this country. There are bound to be many such cases because in every constituency you will have a man who can control a certain number of votes. The candidates going forward will be, to a certain extent, at that man's mercy. If he is the kind of man who has a price, a very nasty situation can arise.
Nothing like it could arise under P.R. where, if a man wanted to go forward as a candidate, he was perfectly free to go to the returning officer with his nomination. Under this proposed system, he can play a very nasty game. We can have two candidates going forward with fairly equal chances. If P.R. goes, we can have a third person in a constituency who would jeopardise the person who is almost certain to get the majority. That man, if he is crooked enough, knows his value and can demand his price, and I have not the slightest doubt that instances will arise where an individual will be returned who does not represent the people at all, but who is probably the candidate with the deepest pocket.
That is the situation which the Minister for Health is trying to bring about, trying to recommend to the people, all for one purpose, that is, that Fianna Fáil will not be dislodged from power. The real reason for the Bill is not what is happening in Italy or elsewhere—and all of the Ministers are fond of taking us away from our own country. However, the cat was let out of the bag by the Taoiseach on the very first day this Bill was introduced. He said that when he was put out of office in 1948 and 1951, many of his supporters asked him what was he going to do about it. In other words, what was Deputy de Valera, as he then was, going to do to stop Fianna Fáil from ever being put out of office again? This is his answer. He proposes now to take from the people the power which they have had for 36 years, to vote No. 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5. Now he is going to restrict them to a single "X", to a single vote, and he does that at a time when the unemployment figure was never higher and people are being asked to spend £100,000 of their own money to shackle themselves to the Fianna Fáil Party, whether they like it or not.
The reason is not what happened in Italy or South America—I forget the other countries which the Minister for Health quoted—but the reason is, first, that it worked very well in the North. In the last general election there, the candidates in 27 out of 52 seats, more than 50 per cent., were returned unopposed. That is grand for Fianna Fáil—it will save their election fund a great deal of money. It will save a good deal of trouble. All they will have to do is gerrymander constituencies and admirable machinery for such a purpose is provided in this Bill. After that they will use plenty of money and then they are "home and dried" and the job is done. It is a pretty picture, but I do not believe the people will be deprived of their voting rights by this trick, for trick it is. It is like something tried on the people many years ago by our oppressors.
The Minister has made it quite clear at long last that he wants only two Parties in this House.
Comment on this
Yes. This is about the best device that could be thought up by Fianna Fáil to make sure the people will have no choice outside two Parties. At the same time, at the back of his mind when he spoke of two Parties, he hoped for only one. That is exactly what he meant. It is a kind of sop to public opinion to say there is to be an Opposition. The Taoiseach, the Minister for Health and the Minister for External Affairs and their colleagues, do not intend to have an Opposition. What they want is a completely autocratic Dáil with all Government on that side and little or no Opposition.
Comment on this
Khrushchev is only trotting after them. There is a certain amount to be said in favour of the ruthless system they have in Russia although I would not like to see it here——
Comment on this
Some of the Deputy's colleagues in the last Opposition were great admirers of the Russian system at one time.
Comment on this
I think the Minister should drop the civil war business. It is not good to be reviving it. None of us wants it. Whatever about his generation none of the young generation wants it and he is very far out if he thinks they do.
Comment on this
I was listening very attentively and I was amazed at the Minister's arrogance and his attempt to trot the House over the whole world without ever mentioning the facts at home. I could not imagine he was so blind to our emigration problem, firstly, and secondly, to our unemployment——
Comment on this
——and thirdly, to the latest thing the Government has brought on the people in asking us now to spend £100,000 on what I would describe as a piece of tomfoolery to benefit the Fianna Fáil Party only.
Comment on this
This is probably the most melancholy and most reprehensible piece of legislation that it was ever attempted to pass through this House. It is the most melancholy and reprehensible performance on the part of the Government Party. We listened to the Minister for Health not so long ago representing to the House and the nation that P.R. crept into this country by means of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1919 and that nobody else is responsible for it. As far as this measure is concerned and as far as the House is concerned we are dealing with a system of P.R. which was deliberately introduced here by the Party opposite who now seek to foul their own nest.
In 1937 the Constitution enacted that election to Dáil Éireann should be by means of the single transferable vote. When I heard the Minister for Health solemnly assure the House that, if there was anything at all to be said for P.R., it could be said only for the list system which is adopted in continental countries, my mind went back to reports of the debate here in 1937 prior to the enactment of the Constitution where on this side of the House Deputy Costello implored the Minister and his colleagues not to tie the Irish people down to the single, transferable voting system of P.R. and suggested that the country might find it necessary at some stage to adopt some other form of P.R. such as the list system.
The Minister and his colleagues at that time turned down that proposal and solemnly enacted that the single transferable vote should be the method adopted for the election of the people's representative.
Notice taken that 20 members were not present, House counted and 20 members being present,
Comment on this
This is the system which the Minister now tells us caters for peculiar people, the system under which undue weight is given to the opinion of the cranky voter, the system under which cranks and crackpots are returned to the House, the system which causes the most expensive form of election, the system which tends by its nature to divide the people. These are some of the litany of faults and failings in the present system that the Minister recited this afternoon.
I can well understand the Minister trying to represent that this system was introduced in 1919 rather than in 1937 by the votes of the Irish people because the Minister has to explain to the people why, if this system has all those faults which he enumerated, he did not advert to them in 1937 when he implored the people solemnly to enact the system as part of the fundamental document of our nation.
This measure, if it passes the Oireachtas, if it passes the people, will give no chance whatsoever of new political growth in this country, at a time when many thinking people are of the opinion there is a need for a new political growth. Each Minister and each member of the Fianna Fáil Party who spoke here made no secret of that. They made it quite plain that this is a measure for the destruction of minorities, a deliberate effort to destroy the voice of the smaller elements in this country and an effort to make sure that into this House there will not percolate the views of minorities. So that, if the measure goes through, there is no doubt whatsoever about it that any effort by a new political growth will be destroyed.
The measure of the belief that the Fianna Fáil Party have in their own Bill is reflected by the nature of the speeches which have emanated from their Front Bench. We have been told by the Minister for External Affairs that the present system was a British system foisted upon us. We have been told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that it was a French system and that it broke down in France. We have been told by the Minister for Defence that it was an obviously ridiculous system although I am quite sure that the Minister for Defence as a youth, with his father, assisted in enshrining it in the Constitution. The same Minister has told us that it was a system without any logical or democratic basis. If all this be true of the Constitution in 1959, surely it was true of the Constitution in 1937.
It was sickening to find the Minister for Health revelling in what he described as the swan song of the Farmers' Party in this country and anticipating with pleasure the destruction of the Farmers' Party in this agricultural country. It typifies the attitude, not of the Fianna Fáil back benchers who, I am quite sure, are as dubious about the value of the measure as we are, but the attitude of the Front Bench of Fianna Fáil who are simply trying to steamroll this measure through the House because, in 1948, P.R. was able to produce an alternative Government to the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
This debate has wandered over the ground in such detail as to be in many respects confusing. The issue, however, is very simple. It is a question of securing an electoral system in this country which will work for the benefit of the country. After a sober appreciation of our own history for well-nigh 40 years, we have come to the conclusion —and this is the only reason this Bill is advanced—that it would be in the interests of the country to change to the direct system.
The reasons for that are, in the first place, on the logic of it, the system of direct voting will give a workable Government and will also reflect by and large the general feeling of the community as well as and probably better than any other fancy academic system. That is human experience where it has been tried. It will give you a Government which can democratically perform its task and lead the country and that is proved, as has been shown, in the debate, not only on the history of the direct system where it has been tried but also on the failures of the alternatives where they have been tried. That is the first point.
The second point is that the system is actually more sensitive to public feeling than the system of P.R., which tends to a certain stagnation. I cannot understand the logic of Opposition speakers who talk about the fixing of any particular group in power for all time under this system. If there is anything that P.R. tends to do, it is to bring about a certain stagnation of pattern, a lot of small groups with certain interests; they tend to stagnate and the country as a whole suffers. That has been the experience. I would go so far as to say, and to point out again, that this country has been saved the evils of Coalition largely because one Party would not play the game of political musical chairs that this system of P.R. almost invariably degenerates into. I would put it in the form of a question: let anyone ask himself what would it have been like if, in 1948, or at any other period, we all got into this bargaining business. Goodness knows, before the last election there was effort enough made to drag us into this bargaining. If every Party in the House had been bargaining and prepared to bargain for office, what would the outcome have been? That is a fair question and I have used the simile, "political musical chairs". I have said that it is the almost inevitable result of P.R. once all the Parties go into the market. That is one reason for our attitude.
We have been taken to task, and the last speaker took us to task to know what is the difference between 1937 and the present day. Very well. It was perfectly fair to give the system a trial. I will answer the question, what is the difference between 1937 and 1959? The difference is this, that in the interim period we had two experiments of Coalitions. Both experiments blew up internally. It was not anything that the one solid opposition to the Coalition did. The first experiment blew up because the Ministers of the Coalition Cabinet could not agree and it blew up in recrimination and all the unfortunate things that attend an internal blow-up.
The second Coalition broke up in precisely the same way. One of their supporters took a different line and stampeded the Coalition into a general election, and that at a time when the country needed a firm Government to see it through its economic difficulties, that at a time when there was very real economic difficulty in the country.
I shall not go over all that political history again but it is true to state that the first Coalition went out leaving the country in a position that demanded drastic action to restore the economic order. The second Coalition went out under such circumstances that the words, "crisis", "disaster", were freely used on all sides and Deputy Costello, when he was Taoiseach, just before he went out was appealing for this, that and the other thing and the Minister for Finance was taking drastic action, and so forth, all because Coalition Governments were too weak to take time by the forelock and to prepare for eventualities that anybody could see were coming.
Comment on this
The economic situation in this country now is much better than it was when you took office and it is getting better still. But we can deal with that on the Vote on Account. The economic situation is better than what it was when your Government blew up and left the country in a bad way.
The contention here is that it is no argument to say you changed your mind since 1937. The fact is we are facing realities. We had two disastrous coalition experiments; and it is in order to try to save the country from similar experiments in the future that many people are supporting this measure. It is best to have a system where you can get a single-minded Government, if you are to operate the two sides of the House system. I will not by-pass into academic arguments about different types of federations and so on. We have a particular political set-up and a particular type of Constitution here, traditionally and actually enacted. With that particular political framework, I believe P.R., in the long run, can result only in disaster. The only method of working it is to have the direct system.
The next point is about stagnation and the sensitivity of the system. The great thing about the direct vote system is that it is more sensitive to public opinion. If you have swings of public opinion, P.R. tends to damp them out. The other system will give due expression to change in public opinion. Not only has it the advantage that it will give us a Government firm enough in office to do its work, but it also gives the people a better method of changing the Government quickly and decisively when they want to change, without having the desperate risk of a stalemate. The only Government that can function for any period is a Government fairly sure of its support for a period. It is a good thing to have a Government in a position where it can appeal to the people and get a direct answer, when it so wishes. I am afraid Fine Gael has made this argument in another way. I should like to suggest to the people who mention that certain political groups are liable to be extinguished by this that I disagree. If a movement is strong enough to command the support of the people, it can more easily secure election under the direct system than under P.R.
There has been a lot of talk about the origin of P.R. in this country, but the plain fact is that, up to the 1918 general election, you had a system of direct voting. Is it not a remarkable answer to the people who talk about trying to exclude people and drive them to other methods that the fact is this: in 1918, after a succession of by-elections, some of which were won and lost under the system, Sinn Féin could sweep the country under the direct system?
Comment on this
There is an analogy, because there the people were able to put in those whom they wished and they were able to sweep the whole country. Is it a coincidence that, after that experience and after finding that the people could so effectively express their will, the British Government introduced P.R. in order to try to prevent such things occurring and to stabilise and secure the representation of a failing minority?
Comment on this
I am talking about facts, not what anyone said. If I started on what people said, I would need a long time to deal with Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
I shall deal with facts. The fact is I made a certain statement about the 1918 election. I do not think that can be contradicted. I make it merely as a factual statement, that after the 1918 election it was the British Government proposed P.R.
Comment on this
Let anyone interpret those facts, if he likes. I am entitled to draw my own conclusions from them as well as anybody else. The net points I am trying to make are these. The system being proposed has the advantage of giving effective Government and of being sensitive enough to public opinion to enable the public more readily to express their will more decisively than under the existing system. The answer in regard to 1918 was an answer to some of the things said on the other side, as was my answer about Coalition Governments and our experience there. They are two sufficient answers to the arguments that have been made.
I think this Bill should pass. It is a very good thing that every interested person and Party should argue this on its merits as far as possible, but I fail completely to understand a mentality that seeks to prevent and to block the people from giving their decision democratically through a referendum. I completely fail to understand the mentality that seeks to do that in the name of democracy.
Comment on this
After this rather interesting but fatuous treatise on P.R. by Deputy Vivion de Valera, one finds it rather difficult to speak with the expected measure of restraint in a discussion such as this. That is particularly true when we reach the last stages of a discussion on P.R. and the principles incorporated in this Bill, by which it is sought by this Government to change the electoral system.
I had better deal with first things first. Allegations have been made in this House and outside it, principally by the Minister for External Affairs and the Minister for Defence and, just now, by Deputy Vivion de Valera, that the system of P.R. as we have it in this country was imposed on us by the British ab initio and by British initiative. Nothing is further from the truth. A P.R. society existed in England for very many years prior to the Home Rule Bill of 1912 and the subsequent Act of 1914, which is the same, word for word. There was also in this country, from the year 1911, a P.R. society. Some of the original members of that society are still living, and they can and must bear witness to what I now say and will say in relation to the history of the P.R. system of voting as we have known it down the years.
At the time of the Home Rule movement here and in the British Parliament, the Irish P.R. Society of 1911, which included, by the way, the late Arthur Griffith, whose ideals cannot be impugned and in relation to whose work for Ireland I challenge anybody to say anything by way of disparagement, were so captivated with the fundamental principle—they were not alone; there were various other groups and societies throughout the country, which could make their voices felt, equally enamoured of the idea of P.R. —that they reached the stage where, first of all, they consulted with the late Mr. John Redmond, the late Mr. John Dillon and the late Mr. Joe Devlin; and it was as a result of these successful conversations and negotiations that a deputation from this country, composed of Irishmen of the most liberal thought, went to London and there saw Mr. Birrell. It was as a result of their efforts and as a result of the logic displayed in the course of their arguments as to how P.R. would give the best and the fairest results in a country fraught with trouble and constituted of so many varying minorities that it was agreed to adopt the P.R. system.
It is enshrined in Section 9, subsection (2) of the Home Rule Bill of 1914 that in all constituencies, from three member constituencies up, the system of P.R. would operate for election to what was to be known as the Irish House of Commons. Likewise, the 40 Senators who were to constitute the Senate envisaged in that Bill, representing four constituencies based on the four provinces of Ireland, were to be elected on a system of P.R. The fate of the Home Rule Bill is now a matter of history, but the text is there, and the proof is there to show what led the British Government to incorporate in the Bill the principle of P.R. It was incorporated because Irishmen of the most loyal objective and with the purest of motives persuaded Mr. Birrell.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present, House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
So much for the history of P.R. in so far as it is applicable to what is now history, namely, the Home Rule Act of 1914. The shelving of that Act during the First World War did not prevent people from keeping in mind the electoral advantages to be derived from the application of P.R. as an electoral system. I should like Deputy Gilbride to be here to listen to this. He would be very interested in what I am about to say.
The first place where P.R. was tried was in the local election to the Sligo Corporation in 1918. Much of what I am about to say now will be said mainly because Deputy Gilbride, instead of using the privilege and opportunity afforded to him here of coming in here and contradicting statements he considered worthy of refutation or contradiction, saw fit to adopt another course. By himself, or through the medium of some scribe in Fianna Fáil Headquarters, he chose to travel instead into the Sunday Press last Sunday and into the Sligo Champion on the 24th of this month. On the occasion of the Second Reading here Deputy Gilbride crept into the House, stood up subsequently to speak like a man of purpose, with a message — a message of truth, or one purporting to be so—and he proceeded to tell us the details not alone attendant upon the Sligo election but those preceding it also.
At column 1973 of Volume 171 of the Official Report, he stated:—
"I had no intention of intervening in this debate but I happen to represent the area in which P.R. was first tried out and, reading some of the things which have been said, I felt compelled to put the facts on record."
He felt compelled to "put the facts on record". Deputy Gilbride continued:—
"Speaking here on 26th November as reported at column 1009 of Volume 171, Deputy J.A. Costello, the Leader of the Opposition, said:—
‘...for the first time in this country and the adjoining country of Great Britain elections were held in Sligo under the principles of P.R. That was not done at the dictate of the British Parliament. It was done at the request of the people of County Sligo because they found that the other system, the system that the Taoiseach wants to impose upon this country for parliamentary elections and to impose for all time, caused complete chaos in their local affairs.' "
Deputy Gilbride went on:—
"That statement is without foundation and, therefore, completely wrong."
He goes on in the same column, with a sob in his voice, about the conditions that existed in the Sligo of that day, as he purported to know it. He deals with the inability of the then corporation to strike a higher rate than they were allowed to strike. Then he goes on:—
"The corporation asked for leave to strike a higher rate and, following on further agitation by the people and the corporation, a Bill was passed in the British Parliament giving the corporation the necessary power."
One cannot quarrel very much with that thus far, but he made some further comments and this is where Deputy Gilbride purports to contradict Deputy Costello. He says that Deputy Costello's statement was without foundation and therefore completely wrong, namely, that P.R. had been asked for by the people of Sligo themselves and was not imposed on them by anyone else. Deputy Gilbride comes into the House and tries to put it across that it was at the dictates of the British Government that P.R. was incorporated in the Sligo Election Act.
Comment on this
Very good. Deputy Gilbride continues at column 1974:—
"A condition of the passing of that Bill was that P.R. would be accepted. The corporation had to pay the costs of having that Bill passed and they amounted to the tidy sum of £986 17s. 7d."
I have no quarrel with that. What I am quarrelling with, and what I am now labelling a deliberate falsehood, in the absence of evidence to the contrary is——
Comment on this
Then I withdraw the word "deliberate". I assert it is a falsehood, made without any evidence to substantiate it, and, indeed, with no evidence either in Deputy Gilbride's subsequent leap into print last Sunday in the Sunday Press or in the Sligo Champion of the 24th January, 1959, with each of which I shall deal a little later.
Speaking at a later stage in the debate, I challenged the veracity of Deputy Gilbride's statement, that the insertion of P.R. as an electoral system into the provisions of the Sligo Election Act was a condition precedent to their getting permission to have such an Act. I still challenge that assertion and I label it a falsehood, in the absence of evidence to show that it was imposed as a condition precedent to the permission which the Sligo Corporation of that day, and, indeed, the Sligo townspeople, sought.
What was happening at that time in Sligo? Prior to 1898, the Corporation of Sligo was in the hands almost entirely of Unionists. After the extension of the franchise in 1898, the Corporation of Sligo fell into the hands almost exclusively of Nationalists, but due to this low ceiling of rate levying, they could not go beyond a certain figure. Neither Corporation could make any of the headway they would have liked to make in providing amenities for their town. There were considerable local differences of opinion. It was felt locally that if they could get a corporation representative of all sections of the community something could be done. The ratepayers had an association there. The townspeople met in a gathering of their own. The existing corporation, significantly enough, in the beginning opposed the suggestion that the principle of P.R. should be enshrined in the proposed Bill and subsequent Act. However, popular demand carried the day.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cunningham would confine himself to the melancholy of his political disappointment, he would make a better contribution to the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Lindsay is in possession and should be allowed to make his statement without interruption.
Comment on this
Whether they were Nationalists or Unionists who opposed it, it was opposed by a majority which wanted to continue as a majority. That is precisely what Fianna Fáil are doing to-day. The then majority in the Sligo Corporation wanted to hold on to the straight vote system which gave them a majority, just the same as the Fianna Fáil Party are trying to get the straight vote system now, knowing, as a result of their recent efforts, that P.R.—if it remains, as it will remain—will wipe them out of the strong position in which they find themselves to-day.