We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—An Cúigiú Céim. Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Fifth Stage.

Contributions 118–247 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958
Defeated

No. 25 of 1958 ›

The British system is the system we have now. It is the system the British wanted for us.

Comment on this

Is the Minister for Defence asserting again——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Lindsay must be allowed to make his statement without interruption. If other Deputies have anything constructive to add, it can be raised at a later stage.

Comment on this

Is the Minister for Defence suggesting again, as he did earlier, that the system of P.R. as we know it in the present Constitution, was imposed upon us by the British?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

In 1937?

Comment on this

Get your heads examined.

Comment on this

Who imposed it in 1937?

Comment on this

It was not done away with. It had been imposed earlier.

Comment on this

We will come to that later.

Comment on this

The currency was imposed then, too.

Comment on this

As a result of the efforts of the Sligo people and by mutual agreement, the election to the corporation that year was carried out on the principles of P.R., and the results were remarkable in many ways. In relation to the number of votes cast for each Party, it gave almost the identical number of seats they would have got if one had taken the total number of votes cast and worked the matter out mathematically.

I do not wish to weary the House by again going into the figures of that time, but I must say, in answer to the people who tell us, in 1959, that the people of this country do not understand P.R., that in Sligo, in 1918, when it was tried for the first time, with an almost 11 per cent. illiterate vote, only a little over 1 per cent. of the votes were spoiled. That is a considerably smaller percentage than the percentage spoiled, for instance, in the Constitution voting of 1937.

Let us see what was said about it at that time and about the result. The Sligo Independent said:

"Sligo has the honour of being the first municipality in Ireland to adopt the principle..."

—to adopt the principle—

"...and everyone agrees that it was a great success."

That was the Sligo Independent. At that time, the Sligo Champion said:

"The system has justified its adoption. We saw it work; we saw its simplicity; we saw its unerring honesty to the voters all through. We also saw the result of the final count and we join in the general expression of those who followed it with an intelligent interest that it is as easy as the old way. It is a big improvement and it is absolutely fair."

In the Freeman's Journal——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy, but surely we are not discussing the system of election to local authorities or local councils, and the system of P.R. which was introduced in Sligo appertained purely to the local councils.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I should not care to venture to say how much of the argument advanced in this debate was relevant.

Comment on this

I venture to say, with respect, Sir, that when I attempted to quote one article from the Limerick Leader, you ruled me out of order very vehemently.

Comment on this

It was not on the Fifth Stage.

Comment on this

"If winter comes——"

Comment on this

"Can spring be far behind?"

Comment on this

Can Deputy Lindsay be far behind.

Comment on this

I will keep the Deputy well behind me, anyway. I take it, Sir, in spite of that unruly interruption, I can go on?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest the Deputy should confine his readings to something more immediately relevant.

Comment on this

Than P.R.?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes, but the Deputy is going back too far.

Comment on this

The merits——

Comment on this

I am talking about the merits and the foundation of P.R.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have allowed the Deputy a good deal of latitude. Surely reading from the Sligo Champion, or whatever paper it is——

Comment on this

I will not for one minute agree that I have been allowed any latitude. I suggest——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not concerned with whether or not the Deputy accepts that he has been allowed latitude. What I am saying is that he is exceeding the limit in reading comments by papers in connection with the Sligo Corporation election.

Comment on this

I do not have to read it but surely I will not be stopped from talking about it.

Comment on this

Another Deputy went back to St. Thomas Aquinas.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy talked about 1798.

Comment on this

You went back to Cuchullain.

Comment on this

I shall come back to Sligo. It was so successful at that time, and the result was recognised as being so fair and so just, that many local authorities passed resolutions asking that it be adopted all over the country, and it came in in 1919 as a result—asked for by Irishmen for Irishmen.

In 1922, it was brought into the Constitution and I do not think it will be suggested that the people responsible for the drafting of the Constitution in 1922 were actuated by any other motive than the welfare of the country for which they had worked so hard. It continued to be our system of election from that time in 1922 up to 1937, when we got another Constitution. In 1922 when P.R. was recognised here for its fairness to minorities, recognised as a charter of liberal thought, it was abolished by the Stormont authorities as a system of election for local elections.

In the year 1929, while it still remained operative here, it was abolished by the Stormont authorities as the system of election for parliamentary elections. It is now proposed, by the Fianna Fáil Party supporting the Government, to ignore the protection to which minorities are entitled and to discard all care for the rights which are theirs, by adopting the system which was taken up in Northern Ireland in 1922 and 1929—manifestly as a move to destroy minority rights and discard all care for the protection to which they were entitled.

P.R. has been recognised as the charter of freedom for minorities. It has been described by eminent church authorities as a unifying and healing force. Why, in the face of its fair working and the stability which it has given, do the Fianna Fáil Party seek to remove it? The true reason, of course, was given by the Taoiseach himself, the Minister for External Affairs, and by practically all their colleagues in the Government, and to-night by Deputy Vivion de Valera. Mainly it is that, as a system, it failed to continue Fianna Fáil in power from 1948 to 1951 and from 1954 to 1957.

Have we reached the stage in this country where we are to identify stability in government with a particular Government in perpetuity? That would appear to me to be the result which Fianna Fáil seeks to get from this Bill and subsequently from the referendum. Is stability to be equated with Fianna Fáil in perpetuity? Are our minorities, big or small, to be described as they were described to-night by the Minister for Health as cranks elected here by crackpots?

Everybody has a right to seek entry into this Parliament. This measure is designed to prevent people coming into this Parliament. This measure is designed as a sort of ex cathedra performance to give the Fianna Fáil Party the right to judge who are the people to come in and what is the policy that should be allowed to come in with those people. Surely in a democratic State such as we hope this is—and we hope it will continue to be—it is the right of anybody or any group to be able, without fear or favour and without resort to corruption, to take their places in this House.

We in the Fine Gael Party are loyal to the principles of P.R. because they protect minorities and give fair representation. It cannot be denied that if the principles of P.R. had not been incorporated in the Constitution of 1922, the Fianna Fáil Party would have found it extremely difficult then, when they were a minority, or even now, to come into this House. It is true that by P.R. they came in here and now they propose to abolish it in order that they may stay here, because, if justice or equity is to prevail and if the people are to exercise the franchise in relation to the policies which they can trust and which have been put into operation, they know that at the next general election, under the system of P.R., they would not be the Government of this country.

Accordingly, what is the best thing to do? Get rid of it; try to abolish it and form single member constituencies with the non-transferable vote, so that on the figures which I have no doubt all the experts have gone into with great care, they will be able in the first event, at any rate, to get a majority of seats. What will happen then? On Second Reading, I mentioned The Last Hurrah in which Edwin O'Connor said: “The Ninth Ward Democratic Club—such was the homogeneous structure of this ward that there was no Ninth Ward Republican Club.”

The wonderful effects of having a one member constituency have been portrayed for us time and time again. We were told how close the Deputy would be to his people; how, with a small constituency, he would recognise their needs in a much more intimate manner and how he can be a better Deputy and give better results to his people. I would accept that view if I were dealing with any other Party but the Fianna Fáil Party, because I know what will happen. Whatever slender majority they might have, every effort will be made to strengthen and increase it by the use of State patronage and State moneys. What hope is there in circumstances such as those, in an atmosphere almost of political tyranny, of getting a constitutional Opposition to reach a stage where it would be able to oust the tyrant—not constitutionally, but probably by other means?

Do the people of this country want an ultimate atmosphere of discontent and unrest that will most likely emanate from this dastardly system as it would be operated if, by any unfortunate chance, this referendum should be successful? What are the divisions, vocational, professional, industrial, agricultural or any other, that will divide our people on matters of policy in a small single member constituency? Ours is not the kind of country which can be compared, as Deputy Moloney invites me, with the United States of America, where you have heavily concentrated industrial areas, rural areas and a great cleavage between wealth and all the other elements that make up the different grades of society. The same situation obtains in Great Britain. Even in Great Britain there is considerable volume of support for the view that their system as operated now is not fair because it deprives so many million people of representation in Parliament. How can anybody assert that the same conditions applicable in the United States or Great Britain are applicable here in a country where we are all more or less the same with no great division between us either in money, land or anything else?

What makes the smallholder in the West of Ireland a Conservative while a similar smallholder beside him is either a Radical or a Socialist? What economic circumstances or what kind of thought do the Government think would operate to make those people different? The answer is nothing but the bitterness that has divided neighbours of that kind down the years. That was the tone of speeches by Ministers of this Government when they tried to tell us that P.R. was imposed on us by the British, when they talked about the Lloyd George Treaty and when the Minister for Health, this afternoon, for well over an hour, with the most vituperative bitterness, attacked the Fine Gael Party. Then, in the end, he wanted to leave the House appearing to be the grand benign fellow hoping for peace, hoping for a forgetfulness of the times that were—after spending a whole hour in trying to revive bitterness.

In addition to the single-member constituency and the single non-transferable vote, this Bill enshrines another principle, that is, that a commission be set up to revise the constituencies and to carve out the country into little boroughs. Who will compose the commission? The President, first of all, at the request of the Government, will appoint a High Court judge or a Supreme Court judge who will be the chairman of the commission. Three members will be chosen by the Taoiseach from the Government side of the House and three members will be chosen by the Ceann Comhairle of the day from what he judges to be the Opposition.

With, say, the referendum a success, the single-member constituency and non-transferable vote in operation and the hoped-for result for Fianna Fáil of probably 100 seats in this House on a minority vote, who would the Ceann Comhairle be? Fianna Fáil smashed to smithereens the principle of continuity in the Chair of this House which was established by the first Government. With a Ceann Comhairle of their own choice, judging absolutely who was Opposition, and judging absolutely the members he would choose from that Opposition, in spite of the best efforts of the most pure-souled judge of the Supreme Court or of the High Court, you would get a result that would put gerrymandering in Northern Ireland to shame. That is the purpose—nothing else. We have seen it before.

We have been tinkering with P.R. before here in what might be described as a mild way. We saw the majority of the larger-seat constituencies reduced to three seats. That was tinkering in the hope and knowledge that, with 51 per cent. of the votes cast, Fianna Fáil would get two seats. That was gerrymandering. What was it but gerrymandering to take the Gort area of Galway and put it into the Taoiseach's constituency in Clare? What was it but gerrymandering to reduce the number of seats in Mayo from four to three and to take away the area of East Mayo and put in the Newport-Mulranny-Achill area instead? The voting strength there was known, as was the voting strength in the other area. By taking away one it weakened the Opposition and by putting in the other it strengthened the Fianna Fáil Party. That action was not guided by any kind of directives of social justice, equality or anything else. It was political expediency of the worst kind.

What exactly, then, do we hope for from this proposed change? Nothing, in my view, save further despair, nothing save a further loss of hope by our people. If they are to expect from a Fianna Fáil Government, 100 strong, what they have been getting deliberately from a Government of the present majority, which is very big, how can the people have any hope in the future?

Deputy Major de Valera, commending the new system to us this afternoon, talked first of the logic of it. He said that what he meant by the logic of it was that the new system would give us a workable Government, that is, a Government democratically able to perform its task. What is wrong with the present Government? It has been democratically elected. It is a workable Government, if a majority is an indication. Why can it not perform its task? It knows it cannot perform the task it expressly, and in some cases impliedly, promised it would. It knows that defeat from a disappointed, deceived and disillusioned people is the inevitable result of such failure. It looks around to find out what is the next method whereby jokers can be pulled out of political sleeves: "Ah! We will abolish P.R. We will confuse the people. We will draw a smoke-screen over our incompetence and our inability to do what we promised to do and we will divert the people's minds from the issues before them."

Deputy Vivion de Valera said the proposed system is more sensitive to public opinion. How could a system which makes the voter no longer a voter, in the derivative sense of being able to choose, be more sensitive to public opinion than P.R. which gives him so many choices, so many preferences and enables him to assess the merits of the different people and vote in that order for the different people for whom he is called upon to vote?

Deputy Vivion de Valera complained that P.R. brings about a system whereby you could play political musical chairs, and that there might be bargaining. It may be that one can steel oneself to close the mind to facts or that it is the political philosophy of the Fianna Fáil Party and Deputy Vivion de Valera to choose a memory so short that they cannot remember the bargaining of 1951, the musical chairs of 1951, that extended from city constituencies to the furthermost constituency in this country in order to get the necessary support to have themselves elected as a Government.

Do they forget that bargaining? Do they forget that wonderful round of musical chairs when people sped through the night on long journeys to near country districts and far country districts trying to effect a bargain which they did in fact effect? Coalition is to be regarded, according to Deputy Vivion de Valera, as a disaster. What is disastrous about men of different groups putting aside their detailed differences and adopting a common plan designed to achieve the betterment of this country as they see it? Remember this, that the average life of the two Coalition Governments here is longer than the average life of any Fianna Fáil Government.

We have been treated in the course of this whole debate to various examples of P.R., the merits and demerits of different systems of it almost from China to Peru. China was not mentioned, of course. Nobody on the Government side of the House, in pointing out the evils that befell European countries as a result of P.R. explained what kind of P.R. was in operation there at the time. Anyhow, nobody proved that any calamity that befell a country in Europe was due in any way to the electoral system they had. All the other factors were ignored but this whole barrage of geographical evidence is being brought in to frighten the more timid of our people into believing that mountains will fall down on top of them if they do not accept this last piece of trusteeship on the part of the Taoiseach; they are to be the beneficiaries of a testator who will be their moral trustee.

Nobody on the Government side of the House has told us, apart from the fact that it failed to elect Fianna Fáil twice, how P.R. does not operate in this country as well as the non-transferable single-member constituency vote. We have been treated to examples from all over the world but nobody has dealt with Ireland. I want some speaker from the Fianna Fáil side of the House, particularly a Minister of State, to deal with Ireland and to say here categorically why the present system has not been successful in giving the people the kind of Government they should have, apart of course from the spurious argument that coalitions were bad, coalitions that built more houses, more roads, more hospitals, and improved social welfare conditions to a greater extent in their short period of time than the present Government in its whole period of 20 years or more.

Apart from that spurious reason, give us some reason electorally, if you like to describe it that way, that might commend itself to us or to the people. I venture to say that this Government and their spokesmen are not doing well with the people on this issue. The people suspect them and rightly suspect them.

Comment on this

Try them out.

Comment on this

We will try them out. We had all this ballyhoo about our opposing the First Reading of this Bill, all this ballyhoo that it was unfair to prevent the people coming to a decision on it. Again I might refer to Deputy Gilbride and his efforts in the Press. He writes one letter to the Sunday Press and a different one to the Sligo Champion, because at the end of the letter in the Sligo Champion of the 24th January, he says——

Comment on this

The Deputy may not quote all those provincial papers.

Comment on this

Who is in the Chair?

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy sit down?

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for Deputy Lindsay to quote ad nauseam the number of provincial papers he has been quoting and continues to quote?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I would not say he is quoting ad nauseam.

Comment on this

I would remind you that I attempted to give one quotation from a provincial paper and you very quickly ruled me out of order.

Comment on this

I do not think the Chair requires any support from me but I would say quoting ad nauseam in this House is the prerogative of Deputy O'Malley. This is a letter to the Sligo Champion of the 24th January. It is a foolish letter. It sets out certain provisions of the Sligo Bill, but nowhere is he able to say that P.R. was in it as a condition precedent to their having the Bill, which he has asserted during the course of this debate——

Comment on this

And will again.

Comment on this

With evidence?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

With the Deputy's own evidence, with his own words.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

The Mount Street Club for the Deputy.

Comment on this

What the Deputy put into the Sunday Press must differ from what he put into the local Press where he is trying to injure somebody.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister was dealing with the application of P.R. Will the Deputy relate his remarks to this stage of the Bill?

Comment on this

He went on then talking about loyalty.

Comment on this

The Deputy is ignoring the Chair.

Comment on this

He was writing on the subject of my last speech which was paraphrased, and Deputy Gilbride was giving his idea of loyalty, loyalty to ourselves and loyalty to those who elect us——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy relate that to the Fifth Stage. of the Bill before the House?

Comment on this

In his letter to the Sligo Champion he says——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Before the Deputy proceeds, will the Deputy relate what he is reading to the Fifth Stage of the Bill?

Comment on this

This is a letter written to the Sligo Champion by Deputy Gilbride, which appeared in the Sligo Champion of the 24th January, and in which he purports to take me to task for in turn taking him to task as a result of something he said in this House on Second Reading.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see how we can discuss all the problems of Sligo on the Fifth Stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not propose to discuss all the problems of Sligo. I propose to discuss the problem of Deputy Gilbride and his interpretation of loyalty in relation to me.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That would not be relevant to the Bill. Loyalty is an abstract subject.

Comment on this

Loyalty, I would contend, is such an abstract thing that it would find no place in this country if this Bill were to go through.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What the Chair is endeavouring to say to the Deputy is——

Comment on this

What I want to say is that loyalty, political loyalty, as far as I am concerned first of all has a supreme meaning——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that the Deputy leave these abstract philosophies.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring, Sir, to educate Deputy Gilbride.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not the time nor the place.

Comment on this

He thinks he will get votes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must speak to the Bill.

Comment on this

That being so, I shall have to postpone his education until I go to Sligo on the 15th of next month, and I hope Deputy Gilbride will be there.

Comment on this

I am always there, and always will be. Can the Deputy say the same for Mayo?

Comment on this

That is very interesting.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Now, can we forget Sligo and deal with the Fifth Stage of the Bill?

Comment on this

Deputy Gilbride wants this.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am afraid Deputy Lindsay is helping him.

Comment on this

I do not want to help him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Then, perhaps, the Deputy will return to the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister for Health told us this evening that there was room for Independents under the proposed system, and he talked about widespread corruption. Under the new system, if it begins to operate under Fianna Fáil, the corruption will be so widespread that a member of a political Party, not to mind an Independent, would not have a chance of beating them down. If the people are foolish enough to give a majority to this referendum and to accept this proposal of the Government, the only way in which it can be changed afterwards will be through unrest, and through methods of which we have had sufficient already.

It is proposed in this Bill, or Government spokesmen say its purpose is, to wipe out not one small Party in this House, not two, but every Party other than Fianna Fáil. It might be gathered from some of their speeches —though certainly not from that of the Tánaiste who regarded Fine Gael as a surplus Party—that all they wanted was Fianna Fáil on the one hand and Fine Gael on the other, and to wipe out the Labour Party. It might be thought that what was wanted was to wipe out Labour, Clann na Poblachta, Clann na Talmhan, the National Democrats and the Independents, and keep Fine Gael.

That is not the view that I have, and that is not the view I am allowed to have by reason of the statement of the Minister for Local Government who said in this House: "If this referendum goes through Fine Gael ‘will have had it.'" What can we expect of the standard of public morality that dictates a denial of that in the face of its true reporting by men of honour in the Press of this country who subsequently stood over it? What can we expect from a Government that might be returned in such strength under the system which they propose? The Minister for Local Government made that statement and he used the radio of this country four times to deny it. He used the services of his Department, through his private secretary, to deny in the Press that he made that statement when, in fact, he made it as just an ordinary Deputy in this House speaking to a Bill. He has never apologised to the people whose competence he so questioned.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not seem to be relevant to the Bill.

Comment on this

It is relevant in this way. If we are to have, as a result of this referendum, a Government composed of Ministers so lacking in all respect for veracity and truth, what is going to happen?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The alleged lack of veracity of the Minister surely does not arise on this.

Comment on this

What the Minister said was: "If this referendum goes through Fine Gael ‘will have had it.'"

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I allowed the Deputy to proceed a certain length, but surely he may not attack a Minister for an alleged lack of veracity on this measure?

Comment on this

Surely, Sir, but——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not discussing anything with Deputy Rooney on this matter.

Comment on this

The silence of the Fianna Fáil Party in the face of that charge, against their young and hopeful, undisputed as it is, leads me with confidence to conclude.

Comment on this

Any more mud?

Comment on this

I am not accustomed to wading in the muddy waters of Deputy Calleary.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! I am calling on Deputy O'Malley.

Comment on this

I just want to deal with one aspect of this Bill. Several speakers here have suggested, from time to time, that no ordinary Deputy of Fianna Fáil, at any time down through the years, has criticised the system of P.R. Even one of the leading national newspapers saw fit, during the past few days, to comment on the same lines.

As far as I am concerned, I should like to say that in my short time in political life—since 1954—I was always against this system and notwithstanding the fact that certain members of the Coalition would suggest that I was in favour, at our Party meeting, of retaining it and that I tore up some mythical maps and such things, I am on record on the 14th April, 1954, as speaking at a public dinner at which the Taoiseach, Deputy de Valera, was guest of honour. I then expressed the hope that very shortly P.R. would be abolished. Again, speaking on the 9th March, 1957, speaking in public after the count for the general election, I said the following, which I quote from the Limerick Leader:—

"I hope, too, that this will be the last election held under the P.R. system, a system which was introduced into this country by an alien Government for the purpose of splitting the old Sinn Féil Party. The system can be changed by means of a referendum under the Constitution."

Of course, the Sunday Independent and the Irish Independent did not take much notice of what I had to say. At least it shows that there were people in my Party—and there are far more than have spoken here—who have been against this system down the years. I cannot say the same for the Fine Gael Party. Their followers all over the country know how evenly they were divided when that matter came up for discussion.

Comment on this

That is wrong.

Comment on this

Very well, if Deputy Lindsay so insists. It is a well-known fact that Fine Gael were divided on this issue.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

We have the same diatribe and expressions of consternation about the proposal to go to the people that we had when the Constitution—now quoted so glibly—went to a referendum in 1937. It ill becomes Deputy Lindsay, or any member of Fine Gael, to criticise Fianna Fáil for bargaining. They have a sorry history in that respect. I do not want to go over the ground again but what happened in 1948 when the first Coalition was being formed and again at the start of the second Coalition is well known. People all over the country, of all shapes of political opinion, are asking what is the purpose of Fine Gael in dragging this matter out. They say: "Have we not sufficient intelligence to understand what the issue is?" I do not think any credit is reflected on the Fine Gael Party by their tactics in this House.

Comment on this

What about the Greyhound Bill?

Comment on this

Let the Bill go to the people and let the people decide. Is it not extraordinarily illogical for any speaker on that side of the House to criticise the Irish people for what they might do in the future, in supporting a measure of their own free will? Is it not extraordinary, too, that Fine Gael particularly should criticise us for going to the people under Article 16 of the Constitution, when they themselves, on two occasions, denied an opportunity to the Irish people to decide very major issues which were at stake, but decided them here in this House?

We have heard the old argument from almost every speaker on that side of the House. It is that if a Fianna Fáil candidate gets 2,000 votes, a Fine Gael candidate gets 1,500 and a Labour candidate gets 1,000, the combined Fine Gael vote plus Labour is more than the Fianna Fáil vote and that therefore the vote is against Fianna Fáil. Would you not add the Labour vote to the Fianna Fáil vote and say that the combined Fianna Fáil and Labour vote is more than the Fine Gael vote? Would you not add the Fine Gael vote to the Fianna Fáil vote and argue likewise, or is it a fact that the Fine Gael Party does not want ever to aim at being the sole Government in this country? Must they always have some "suckers" tagging along behind them, until they can get rid of what, in their eyes, are leeches?

I do not consider the Labour Party to be "suckers". From time to time some of their speakers have made major contributions on various problems in this House, particularly on matters of social welfare and health. I think very sound principles have been enunciated by them.

However, there is another aspect of this matter which has not been sufficiently commented on. It is the fact that under the present system minorities are created. They have been created in the past. We have a Party in this House at present which calls itself the Farmers' Party, Clann na Talmhan. They represent an outpost of civilisation over on the west coast but surely they do not suggest to the people that they are the Farmers' Party? The Farmers' Party are represented here in our own Party alone. We represent large farmers and small farmers and certainly Clann na Talmhan do not. It is just an example of the system that creates such a Party. I do not suggest that those in Clann na Talmhan are head cases, but there is a possibility, and it has happened in the past, that peculiar people have been elected to this House. I suppose we have a share of them on this side, too, but what I mean to convey— I am leaving myself very open—is that the day will end with the abolition of P.R., when every single crank and "nut" can jump before what might be termed a dissatisfied electorate and put his case before them.

As the Taoiseach has pointed out, on the Second Reading, these people in small groups and small Parties who can never hope, and know that they can never hope, to form a Government, can promise so much to the electorate that very often there is a certain section of the community, a very small percentage, who are gullible enough to believe them. Under the P.R. system that gullible voter, uninitiated, possibly uneducated, is catered for by these head cases. The new system will definitely give stability. Some Deputy, I am not sure who, said we will have 14 Deputies on the Opposition Benches. If that is so, it is a marvellous tribute to Fianna Fáil, to think the Irish people are going to give us over 100 seats.

Comment on this

Through gerrymandering.

Comment on this

If Deputy Lindsay attended debates here he would not refer to gerrymandering. The commission on the whole got quite unanimous support here last night. If the Deputy heard his own speakers he would not be so anxious to throw in that reference to gerrymandering. When the Irish people decide this issue in June there will not be, I think, an election until 1961, and then we will be under the new system. By-elections, in the meantime, I think, will be fought under the old system.

There is another matter which I wish to mention and I am not afraid of getting my knuckles rapped by what has been called the Party top brass. You can say anything you like at our meetings and you will not be thrown out on your ear.

Comment on this

That is only since he became a Presidential candidate.

Comment on this

Some of the speakers are asking why is the Presidential election under the system of P.R., and why are local elections fought under the system of P.R. I will give my personal opinion on this matter. I admit we are not discussing the system of elections to the local authorities but I wish to refer to what almost all the speakers over there said. They tried to show that Fianna Fáil is completely illogical by bringing in this system, and no mention has been made of changing the system of elections in local authorities. I personally see no reason why it should be changed. Let the Deputy listen to that and write it down in his little book and let him get Colonel Dineen to print it and take it out of its context. But if he gets Colonel Dineen to do that, I will get Tommy Mullins to print what I said in full.

Comment on this

And the Minister for Local Government will deny you said it.

Comment on this

The issue is as the Taoiseach, the Minister for External Affairs and the Minister for Health have said, that we want to bring in this Bill to give the Irish people stable Government. I see no connection between it and a Presidéntial election, a local election or any other type of election. We are dealing with the system of election to the National Parliament and that is the issue involved. Deputy O'Sullivan is obviously thrilled with what I am saying and evidently he is going to make use of it on some future occasion. He is very welcome.

I shall conclude by saying I hope this measure will be passed speedily. I think everybody is sick and tired of discussing it. Let it go to the people. If Deputies opposite are so worried about the outcome and if they are so convinced that the people of Ireland will reject it, the sooner it goes to the people the better; but I say that the Taoiseach, Eamon de Valera, has never misled the Irish people, and whenever they took his advice and listened to it, it was a good day for the country. It was a very fortunate thing for the people that the Taoiseach was at the head of affairs at the critical period when, if other people were in the Government, there might have been a different story.

Comment on this

"The majority have no right to do wrong."

Comment on this

I do not want to take up much time, but I should like to make a few remarks regarding criticism of the length of time spent on the other four stages and now being spent on the Fifth Stage. It is unfair for Government members or members of the Government Party to make such criticism. It is not our intention on this side of the House to prevent the people from having their say, as far as this referendum is concerned. It is a fact that because the Government have a majority, the Bill will be passed and will be put before the people, but I have spoken on this Bill on different occasions and I am speaking now because we believe this is the national forum. It is the most important place to express our opinions. Surely at this stage in the life of the Dáil nobody would, or should, suggest that speeches on what is described as an important measure should be curtailed.

We are not wasting time that should be devoted to public business. As far as I remember, the month of January has been a period of recess for the Dáil which usually resumes in the second or third week of February. When the Taoiseach announced we would reassemble on 7th January, I understood he intended we should resume early so that we could have a full, frank and lengthy discussion on this Bill. That is merely what we are doing. It may sound as if speeches are being repeated, but if Deputy Mulcahy makes some remark about P.R. and Deputy Casey or another Deputy happens to say the same thing, it may be repetition but not from the same Deputy, and Deputy Casey and Deputy Mulcahy and others are here to express these opinions for the benefit of the people and particularly for the information of the people who sent them here.

On a Bill discussed here yesterday, the Minister for Local Government read out a list of days and weeks and months and hours that had been spent on this Bill, but my opinion—it is not for me to direct them or tell them what to do—is that the 146 Deputies in the Dáil should regard it as their duty to their constituents to express an opinion on the Bill so that the people will be better able to make up their minds. That is the only reason I have spoken and am speaking, and I assume that is why other people also have spoken on this or other stages.

The Minister for Health in a learned speech to-day attempted "to pull the schoolmaster act" and tell us what we should know or should deduce from the methods that have been adopted on the Continent and elsewhere. He suggested that this is the opportune time to change the system of election. I do not pretend to quote him, but my interpretation of part of his speech was that he admitted there was an unnatural division in the country arising from the civil war and because of that, he said, or at least I understood him to say, there was room from 1922 to the present time for different Parties, big and small and middle-sized, to be elected to Dáil Éireann under the system of P.R. I gathered from him that the time was now opportune to do away with that system that gave three, four or five Parties and substitute the system that would give us two Parties.

I spoke on another stage and argued against the abolition of P.R. and the introduction of the straight vote, on the ground that we were not politically mature and that some Parties were based on political thought and philosophy and because of that we should go to a further political stage before the people should be asked to consider adopting the system known as straight voting. Deputy O'Malley described as rather ludicrous the arguments put forward, I think, by Deputy Mulcahy or some other Fine Gael Deputy. He took as an example a constituency where a Fianna Fáil candidate got, say, 2,500 votes, Fine Gael got 2,000 and Labour, 2,000 votes. He said that a Fine Gael Deputy asked was it fair that 4,000 combined votes of Labour and Fine Gael should not prevail over the 2,500 of the Fianna Fáil Party. That is not the argument that was used by Fine Gael Deputies; it is not the argument Deputy Larkin used. He did not suggest a combination of votes should prevail over a majority vote for one individual.

The type of example given by Deputy Larkin and other Deputies was that of a constituency such as Limerick. In any part of Limerick, if straight voting is adopted, there will be a constituency which, in my opinion, and I think it is a fair opinion, will give a candidate from Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour, Clann na Talmhan and Sinn Féin and possibly some Independent. I believe that if there were an election in six months' time, a year's time or two years' time, all those Parties would contest a general election in Limerick City. Then we could have a situation like this—and this is the type of situation we refer to when we try to point out the unfairness of the straight vote in present circumstances in this country. Let us take it that Fianna Fáil get 3,500 votes, Fine Gael get 3,000, Labout get 3,000, Clann na Poblachta get 2,000, Sinn Féin get 2,000, and an Independent gets 2,000. I do not think that is a situation which could not arise in Limerick; I think it is possible that it would arise. There would be a situation where a candidate, let it be Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour, would get 3,500, as against all other candidates getting 12,000. Our contention is that that man does not, under that system, represent the majority of the people in his constituency.

Comment on this

That would not be the proposition.

Comment on this

I do not know Limerick as well as Deputy Russell might.

Comment on this

The Deputy suggested 3,000 to 12,000 against Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

It is possible.

Comment on this

It happened in Dublin, 6,000 to 12,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy would propose anything for the sake of argument.

Comment on this

That could be a realistic example of what would happen. It may be any other city.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

The Independents in Limerick are to the fore.

Comment on this

The Deputy thinks I am critical of Limerick, but I am not. The only reason I take Limerick is that there was a Clann na Poblachta candidate consistently and an Independent and, in the last election, a Sinn Féin candidate also. There always have been Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour candidates there. I might have reduced the figures, to give the other Parties 8,000 as against the first Party getting 3,500.

Deputy O'Malley seems to think what the Opposition want is that there should be a representative from the others as against Fianna Fáil. All we want is that the lowest man be eliminated and that the second preferences be carried on. Let Fianna Fáil get them, or Fine Gael or Labour or any other, but at least eliminate people until there is a result and until there is an overall majority for any one of the candidates.

The Minister for Health said that the time was opportune now to change over to the straight vote. I honestly believe the time is not ripe. They may be called cranks and crackpots, but there are fairly big minorities which do not believe in Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour, to take the three largest Parties here. It would be wrong to deprive them of the opportunity of getting into the Dáil. It may be said that they have an opportunity of presenting themselves for election, but in actual fact, the straight vote system, the single member constituency, will deny to all those small Parties actual representation in Dáil Éireann.

The Minister for Health also said that he wanted to see a situation in which there would be two big Parties, Parties which could be described, he said, as being in the middle of the road. He said there would come a day shortly when we would have two Parties and between each there would not be a big difference in policy. I do not believe that such a situation is desirable. I do not believe that, even if we had two big Parties here, such a situation would be desirable at all. If the situation in England is that there is a Conservative Party, regarded as being conservative in policy, as against the Labour or Socialist side, which is regarded as being progressive or more liberal in policy, I would prefer to have heard the Minister say that that is the situation he wanted to arrive at, rather than seek to have two middle of the road Parties in Dáil Éireann.

Deputy O'Malley suggested, as did many of his colleagues, that the straight vote will provide for stability. In spite of that parrot-like cry, I do not think the straight vote will, in its actual effect, give stability. Even if the people were to opt for the straight vote, we still could have a situation such as the Minister for External Affairs has often visualised, where no single Party would have a majority. In a case like that, there must be a combination of Parties or a Coalition. Fianna Fáil will have to make up their mind what they are going to do in such a situation. If Fianna Fáil have one-third of the membership here, Fine Gael have one-third and we have one-third, Fianna Fáil will not be able to sit on the fence, as obviously the Minister for External Affairs wants to sit. They will have to make up their minds what they are going to do, or whether there are to be three or four more elections, until there is an absolute majority for one Party.

Governments having majorities have not necessarily meant that we have had stability; neither has it meant that we have had progress and prosperity. Whilst all of us may pay our tributes to the Taoiseach, and while Deputy O'Malley may have said he never wavered and always made the right decision as far as the country was concerned, all of us must agree that we still have our problems. Fianna Fáil has had a stable Government with a majority of 18, and has not solved those problems. Other Governments have not solved them. Now the people are led to believe that if they do away with P.R. and adopt the straight vote, all our difficulties are solved and all our ills are cured. Such is not the case. It is dishonest for anybody to talk about stability and progress in connection with the change in the system of election, because that change is designed as Fianna Fáil said, to give an absolute majority to a Party which can form a Government. In the past 27 years, only the Fianna Fáil Government have had substantial majorities and we have not had stability in our economy; we have not had progress; and we still have the same difficulties as regards unemployment and emigration. It is dishonest that the Fianna Fáil spokesmen should try to pretend to the people that, as soon as this Bill is put to the people and adopted, all our difficulties will be solved.

It is hard to understand the criticism of many Fianna Fáil speakers who talk about the evils of coalition government. We can appreciate their point of view. It must have been a tremendous shock to them in 1948 when they were beaten. They had been invincible for 16 years. If I had been in government for 16 years and woke up one morning to find that that was all finished and that Deputy de Valera had gone as well, I should feel pretty bad about a Coalition succeeding me.

Apart from what Coalitions did or did not do, the facts are these. In 1948, when no Party had an overall majority, Labour, Fine Gael, Clann na Poblachta, Clann na Talmhan and some Independents decided to come together on a stated policy. To the best of their ability and very successfully, they proceeded to try to work out that policy over a period of three years. They were succeeded by a Coalition of Fianna Fáil and five Independents. After three years, despite what the Taoiseach has said about Coalitions, despite the warnings he gave about them, despite the criticisms of the Minister for External Affairs, the Minister for Health, the Minister for Local Government and every Deputy of the Fianna Fáil Party, in 1954, the people decided they wanted another Coalition. I believe they decided likewise in the general election of 1951, but that is a different story—it was a matter of individual taste on the part of certain Deputies. However, the people are not as spiteful or hateful towards Coalitions as the Taoiseach thinks they are. The evidence of that is in the fact that, despite all the warnings, criticisms and condemnations from 1948 to 1951, they voted in greater measure for a Coalition in 1954.

The Dáil was dissolved in 1957 and Fianna Fáil have come back again. I do not say that under the straight vote, there might not be another Coalition, but Fianna Fáil will not be able to sit on the fence and say: "There you are now. Get together and form a Government." The responsibility of forming a Government is a serious matter. It was a serious decision for the Labour Party to make in 1948 and 1954; but we made the decision and none of us regrets the decision made. The Party, as a Party, does not regret the decisions they made on those two occasions. We make no promise about future Coalitions. We are not prepared to say we will coalesce after the next election with Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil, Clann na Poblachta or anybody else. We will have to decide what we will do in the circumstances in which we find the country in the event of no Party gaining an overall majority.

If we are trying to aspire to unity and stability, it is rather a tragedy that the proposal in this Bill will be put before the people on the same day as that on which they are asked to elect a President. As Deputy Kyne said, for the sake of unity and political stability, the country could afford another £80,000 to have the election on a different day. As Deputy Kyne said also, it was designed by the Government Party some months ago that the election would be on the same day. As far as I can see, in recent weeks, the Government have decided that the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is not such a good horse after all, and now they are trying to swop jockeys. The Minister for External Affairs was the original choice——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of the candidates for the Presidential election does not arise.

Comment on this

I am criticising the fact that these proposals are to be put to the people on the same day as that on which they are to be asked to vote for de Valera. I warned against that in my Second Reading speech. I made a sincere criticism and said the people should not be asked to say whether they are for or against de Valera, for or against MacEoin, or anybody else. In order to try to cloud the issue, the same Government did the same thing in 1937 by muddying the waters of a plebiscite on the Constitution by throwing in a general election, or vice versa. In conclusion, I wish to say that my Party does not apologise for any of the speeches made on its behalf on this Bill.

Comment on this

I think it is a great mistake not to accept the declared intention of the Government at its face value. We have the express authority of Front Bench members of the Government for stating here that their purpose in presenting this constitutional amendment referendum is to wipe out the Labour Party, Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta and the Independents in this House, and, when the Minister for Local Government intervened, he revealed that it was his hope that the principal Opposition Party would be wiped out, too. He was constrained by the intervention of the Taoiseach to publish a denial that he had ever expressed that hope; and he was publicly repudiated by every independent witness of his words. But that is the purpose; that is the hope; that is the aim.

The Taoiseach's severest critic has never charged him with avarice or desire to accumulate money, but for 40 years he has been an ardent disciple of Machiavelli, because ever since he entered the public life of this country, he has been drunk for power, and observe the situation in which we stand to-day. He has now reached the apotheosis of a long struggle for power in this country. He believed he had attained to his aim until his illusion was shattered by the events of 1948 and their repetition in 1954. The fact is that these two successive events shocked him. It shocked him that it had been possible for the Irish people, whose mind he could find by searching his own heart, had suddenly proved his heart a liar, not once but twice.

The thesis is that anyone may disagree with the Taoiseach once by falling into error, but if he should perpetrate that deed a second time, it is no longer error—it is malevolence. For anyone to differ from the Taoiseach twice is self-evident malevolence. He is in the dilemma now that he hesitates to make that indictment of an entire people. Rather than make it, he proposes to provide against the appalling possibility that it should happen a third time. Observe the structure that is now in contemplation. If that is not self-evidence of a power mania, amounting to madness, I do not know what is. This is the programme: he is to be President; he is to be controlling director of three national newspapers, with a succession guaranteed to his own son——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not seem to arise.

Comment on this

——and his Party is to be in a dominant position in Dáil Éireann, from which all Opposition has been effectively eliminated. If that is not the picture of a man gone mad in search of power, I do not know what is.

Comment on this

A clear picture of a man gone mad.

Comment on this

Yes, a man gone mad, intoxicated by an insane desire for power. Mark you, there is the danger of which Deputy Corish spoke. Our people have in their constitution a human strain of sentiment. When there is presented to them a figure for 40 years in the public life of this country, seeking, in the evening of his days, further preferment, who will deny that a great many of our people, whatever their views may be, will be moved to say: "We will either give him that, or something in exchange; if we cannot vote for him as President, sure, we will give him a vote on the referendum?" Certain it is that, with the two on the same day, there cannot be obtained from our people a detached judgment on either issue. There will be those who will say: "We will give him a vote for President and vote against him on the referendum", and others who will say: "If we feel a conscientious duty to preserve the principle of P.R., we will give him a vote for President, lest he feel rebuffed on every front." In fact, what is happening is that he is running true to form, and that constitutes a real danger for this country.

I absolutely refuse to follow the Fianna Fáil Party in their labyrinthine calculations of what may or may not happen at the poll under various electoral systems. Here, in this Chamber is the citadel of the individual liberty of every citizen of this State, from the highest to the lowest, from the richest to the poorest, and the day this Parliament ceases to function, no man's freedom in this society is safe. I ask Deputies, who have some experience of the functioning of this Parliament, what will it look like if there are no Deputies on this side of the House? Remember, that is not my apprehension. That is the hope of the leaders of the Government Party, avowed by some of them, admitted through indiscretion by others; and that is the hope which the Taoiseach, being a skilled and devious politician, is most eager to cloak from the minds of our people. He wants them to trust him and to have faith that, whatever they do, Parliament will still be here.

The vast majority of our people have never been in this House, or seen it function. The vast majority of our people do not understand, as we understand, how Parliament works. But there is no experienced Deputy here who, when he contemplates these benches empty—never mind those where I stand—who will not realise that Parliament will be greatly weakened.

I want to sound this note of warning again. We are dealing with Ireland. We are not dealing with Canada. We are not dealing with New Zealand. We are not dealing with Great Britain. We are not dealing with the United States of America. We are dealing with Ireland, with all her history about us. There is nothing more certain— I speak in this matter with a long personal experience of the public life of this country and a vicarious experience going back over a century in the history of the country—I warn Deputies of this House, that in Ireland minorities cannot be suppressed.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

And, so certainly as we are standing on this floor to-day, if our people are misled by the Fianna Fáil Party into endorsing an electoral system which slams the doors of this Dáil in the face of minorities, we will be, by our act, begetting a development, which whatever Party forms a subsequent Government, may find an almost unbearable handicap.

Let us face this fact. It cannot be too often repeated. The moral position, quite apart from the legal position, of this Government and this Oireachtas in connection with the imprisonment on the Curragh of between 100 and 150 men, without trial, is founded on the proposition that any man, who can get a quota of voters in this country to support him, can come into Parliament and make his voice heard; and, so long as that system exists in this community, no Government will allow any minority, great or small, to arrogate to itself the functions of the Government lawfully elected by the people's Parliament.

Standing on that moral ground, I believe we are unassailable. But I ask Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party how would their consciences sit with them if, at this moment, they felt themselves open to rebuke, as the lawfully constituted Government of the country, for holding 100 to 150 men in prison, without trial, having denied them the opportunity of making their voice heard here? It may be that to a big, powerful, political machine, with vast funds drawn from its protégés, and with a great organisation built up on the resources that it draws from those whom it favours, it is fantastic that it should be a matter of any consequence to a relatively poor, insignificant and weak minority in this country that they should have the right to appear in Dáil Éireann. But it is there, and one of the strongest instruments in the hands of the executive at the present time is that the elected representatives of the Sinn Féin and I.R.A. movement here are afraid to take their place here and make their case; and we are in a vastly different moral position in that knowledge from what we would be in if they were in a position to say to us: "You, by your actions, slammed the doors of Parliament in our faces and we have not got that opportunity."

I do not think it would be expedient at any stage to overstate the issues joined here between us but it is desperately important that the people should know precisely what they are. To get as near to them as I can, and I pledge my word that this is the impression I get from what I have heard from Fianna Fáil speakers from the Front Bench of their Party in the course of this debate, their aim and desire is to slam the doors of Dáil Éireann in the face of all minorities in this country; our aim and desire is to keep them open.

I want to recall again to the minds of the Deputies the events of 30 short years ago when the present Taoiseach was leading a Party solemnly pledged not to enter Dáil Éireann and, seeing the barren futility of the continuance of that policy, he and certain of his colleagues changed their mind and he became himself with his colleagues the splinter of a splinter, a minority in a minority and he said: "If we are not to drift down the road to chaos, the time has come when we must reverse our policy and enter Dáil Éireann."

If this referendum had been decided in favour of the Fianna Fáil case to-day, his own minority would then have been in a position to say to him: "But you cannot go into Dáil Éireann. The Cumann na nGaedheal Government have so fixed the electoral system that you cannot get a man elected and there is nothing for you but to stay with us in the wilderness." But, because there was then a Government that cared more for the country than they did for their own Party, under the leadership of Mr. William T. Cosgrave, he decided that he would not only keep the doors open for them but that he would drag them in through those doors, and he did.

I well remember the flood of vituperation and filth that he cheerfully faced while he taught the present members of the Government how to carry on in Parliament and, mind you, the time is nearly coming, although it is still too early, for the historian to pass his judgment on that period in our history. When the time is ripe for an historian to tell the story of that epoch and the epoch in which we are now playing a part, which will get the verdict of the nation, the Prime Minister who drew a fraction of a fraction, a splinter of a splinter, a minority of a minority into Parliament or——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid the Deputy is getting away from the Fifth Stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

In what respect, Sir?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to refer to what is in the Bill but his remarks just now do not seem to be relevant.

Comment on this

What is in this Bill is the Government's plan to wipe out the minorities in this Parliament. I am comparing that with the plan to bring minorities in and I am making the case that, when history comes to be written, it will be the Prime Minister who brought them in, to his own grave political detriment, who will be adjudged the true servant of the Irish nation rather than the Prime Minister who drove them out in the hope of serving his own political advantage, to the grave detriment of the nation.

It is hard to reach all the people. It is hard to make the people understand. It is hard to persuade people how precious certain things are when they have not known the absence of them. There is a whole generation of our people grown up in the last 30 years who never knew what it meant to struggle against the loss of freedom, who have never been without it, and the terrible danger is that an appeal to that generation may be successfully made to the point of misleading them and, as a result, parliamentary democracy, which is the only true citadel of individual liberty, in this country may founder. That would be a disaster in more ways than one because it would be the vindication of everyone who sneered at our people, confidently prophesying that, if given the chance, we would destroy our own freedom, given the time, and that would be detestable to me. What is even worse is that in all my knowledge of the world I have never known parliamentary democracy and individual liberty founded thereon to perish and to be recovered without bloodshed.

If, in a moment of folly, our people consent to what is now proposed, I warn them that they will put these institutions, of which we, the Deputies of Dáil Éireann, constitute a part, in very mortal peril. I believe that will create an atmosphere in the country in which certain elements of our people who are now generally condemned for their refusal to accept lawfully constituted authority in this Republic, may win a growing measure of unthinking sympathy. I believe that we are being asked to walk into all that peril to gratify an insane yearning for power which in the mind of the Taoiseach is to be satisfied by nothing short of his presence in the Park, his son's presence as his deputy in the control of three national newspapers and his nominee and faithful supporters in control of the Executive Government. Is there any reasonable man or woman in this House who considers that such a prospect is consonant with the best interests of the democratic institutions of this country? Is there any man or woman in this House who believes that that is a desirable development in our constitutional evolution?

We are told by certain elements of the Fianna Fáil Party that our desire to debate these things and ventilate them is evidence of reluctance on our part to face a referendum. I want to say quite categorically that I think one of the most unsuitable methods of resolving complex problems in a society such as ours is recourse to referendum. It is about as undemocratic a procedure as is conceivable to the mind of man. How can there be adequate discussion, how can there be adequate investigation, how can there be adequate examination of the complex problems involved in this legislation by referendum?

There have been nine weeks of debate in this House, but that is what we are sent by the people to do, to deliberate, to argue, to match mind against mind, to investigate, to examine, and having taken all that slow precaution, to decide and to legislate. That is democracy. It is not democracy to go out and propagate a piece of legislation and present it to the multitude and say: "Will those in favour shout ‘Aye' and those against ‘No'", particularly if the querist is an aged servant of the State surrounded by an aura of sympathy, and anything else he can call in support, conveying the implication: "Either you vote for me or my long life in the service of the State ends in repudiation and tragedy".

Is that the atmosphere in which to get a deliberate, calm and resolved determination of such problems as are herein involved? It certainly is not. Our Constitution, such as it is, provides that a Government can, in certain circumstances, have recourse to this procedure. Some Deputies may ask why we should express amazement at any question being put to what they call a democratic decision of the people in a referendum? There are hundreds of questions which have been answered in the affirmative in other countries, which I would be appalled to think any Irish Government would desire to put to our people by way of a referendum.

There are hundreds of proposals which are the common coin of States that are unfree in the world in which we live, which I would regard as a public scandal if sponsored by any Government of Ireland as appropriate questions on which to seek the judgment of our people by referendum, on the presumption that they would be entertained for a single moment, whereas they were so outrageous as to be unsuitable for public discussion in our society. I do not accept for a moment that the principle of referendum is the ideal one, but I recognise at once in the minds of those who yearn towards it, the chronic tendency of Fianna Fáil to demand a court of appeal from Parliament.

Fianna Fáil find parliamentary procedure with its examination, its rights, its deliberations, tedious and irksome and hard to bear. They have the feeling that if they have the numbers why should they not prevail? "Why must we submit to this parliamentary interrogation; why must we go through the tedium of persuading Parliament, first the Dáil and then the Seanad, to agree?" If Fianna Fáil feel that way when they have a clear majority, how will they feel if they produce a situation in which they are substantially the only Party in the House, as they hope to be? That is their hope and their aspiration. Will we be told hereafter that if there is any challenge here to their edicts there will be an appeal from Parliament by referendum? Why legislate at all then?

I venture to say that any Fianna Fáil Deputy to whom that question was addressed would say at first glance: "That is the right procedure; that is the most democratic procedure." It is Government by mob law. Mind you, that is the Government and that is the justice that prevails over two-thirds of the human race to-day. Do not forget that within the last fortnight one of the most civilised and modern communities in the world, the Republic of Cuba, a stable State, to all outside appearances, has been turned overnight into a community where trial for life is conducted by public acclaim in a bullfighters' arena. Mind you, in that two-thirds of the world where these practices are coming to be accepted, the Governments in each of the societies would claim as the chief merit of the new dispensation their glorious stability.

I do not believe this Government is a Communist Government. I do not believe this Government is a Nazi Government, though I believe the Minister for External Affairs was a Nazi in his time—I know he was— when he used to canvass the corridors to go up and dine with the Nazi Ambassador to this country during the war years, but that is not relevant to our proceedings at the moment. Let us bear in mind that this perpetual appeal for stability is most frequently heard at the present time on the lips of Mr. Khrushchev and Mr. Khrushchev's explanation is: "We must have stability and in order to have stability anyone who disagrees with me has to be persuaded not to do so again, and if that involves burying him in six feet of good clay the resources of civilisation are not yet exhausted." If his removal demands that he go in the capacity of Ambassador to Mongolia and if that is sufficient to give him second thoughts, then he is very welcome to his oriental sojourn.

I do not think anyone will deny that for the time being at least Mr. Khrushchev has as much stability as any man could hope for. He was actually able to get them to listen to him for seven hours when he addressed the twenty-first meeting of the Cominform.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Dillon move the adjournment of the debate?

Comment on this

With pleasure, Sir, if you ask me to do so, but I cannot imagine why.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for External Affairs wishes to move a motion.

Cuireadh an diospóireacht ar ath-ló.

Comment on this