Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance.
Contributions 1–169 of 328. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That a sum not exceeding £38,000,000 be granted on account for or towards defraying the Charges that will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1960, for certain public services namely:—
£
1 President's Establishment | 2,900
2 Houses of the Oireachtas | 80,300
3 Department of the Taoiseach | 9,400
4 Central Statistics Office | 43,000
5 Comptroller and Auditor General | 12,150
6 Office of the Minister for Finance | 58,000
7 Office of the Revenue Commissioners | 707,000
8 Office of Public Works | 200,000
9 Public Works and Buildings | 1,350,000
10 Employment and Emergency Schemes | 273,800
11 Management of Government Stocks | 66,250
12 State Laboratory | 9,200
13 Civil Service Commission | 20,000
14 An Chomhairle Ealaíon | 6,500
15 Commissions and Special Inquiries | 3,000
16 Superannuation and Retired Allowances | 362,000
17 Secret Service | 2,000
18 Expenses under the Electoral Act and the Juries Act | —
19 Supplementary Agricultural Grants | 1,200,000
20 Law Charges | 41,700
21 Miscellaneous Expenses | 11,500
22 Stationery Office | 191,000
23 Valuation and Boundary Survey | 28,340
24 Ordnance Survey | 33,430
25 Rates on Government Property | 20,000
26 Office of the Minister for Justice | 33,900
27 Garda Síochána | 1,706,620
28 Prisons | 61,420
29 District Court | 33,400
30 Circuit Court | 44,330
31 Supreme Court and High Court of Justice | 35,760
32 Land Registry and Registry of Deeds | 38,600
33 Public Record Office | 3,250
34 Charitable Donations and Bequests | 2,120
35 Local Government | 1,705,000
36 Office of the Minister for Education | 125,000
37 Primary Education | 3,320,000
38 Secondary Education | 480,000
39 Technical Instruction | 630,000
40 Science and Art | 50,000
41 Reformatory and Industrial Schools | 136,000
42 Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies | 40,000
43 Universities and Colleges | 460,000
44 National Gallery | 4,130
45 Lands | 888,000
46 Forestry | 611,000
47 Fisheries | 117,100
48 Roinn na Gaeltachta | 190,000
49 Agriculture | 3,692,000
50 Industry and Commerce | 580,000
51 Transport and Marine Services | 588,000
52 Aviation and Meteorological Services | 330,000
53 Industrial and Commercial Property Registration Office | 9,500
54 Tourism | 200,000
55 Posts and Telegraphs | 3,495,000
56 Wireless Broadcasting | 145,500
57 Defence | 2,241,300
58 Army Pensions | 559,000
59 External Affairs | 142,400
60 International Co-operation | 31,800
61 Office of the Minister for Social Welfare | 160,000
62 Social Insurance | 1,455,000
63 Social Assistance | 6,827,000
64 Health | 2,080,000
65 Dundrum Asylum | 16,500
66 Repayment of Trade Loans Advances | —
TOTAL | £38,000,000
The Vote on Account is the forerunner of the financial year 1959-60. It is the sum required for expenditure on the Supply Services for roughly the first four months of the new year. By the end of four months the Dáil has normally considered the Estimates individually and passed the Appropriation Act, thus giving full authority for the proposed expenditure on Supply Services. Without a Vote on Account, however, the Government would be without finance after the 31st instant.
Comment on this
I suggest we should have an amplification system here. We have to complain repeatedly that we cannot hear what is being said.
Comment on this
The total expenditure proposed for the new year, as shown by the Estimates Volume, is £115,547,070. The Vote on Account is for £38,000,000, roughly one-third of the total. The items covered by the Vote are set out on the Order Paper.
Before looking at the details, I think it would be well, for a few moments, to take a broader view. The total of £115.55 million compares with £110,000,000 on the face of the Volume last year and with actual audited expenditure of £111.4 million in 1957-58. The Estimates for 1959-60, therefore, show an increase of £5.55 million over the original Estimates for the present year. Taking account, however, of the Supplementary Estimates already passed or introduced, we find that this year's requirements will amount to £113.69 million. Compared with this more up-to-date figure for the present year the 1959-60 total shows an increase of £1.86 million. Dividing the totals into capital and non-capital services, the comparisons are:—
1959-60 | Capital | £14.42
1958-59 | ,, | £12.31
(original plus supplementaries)
Increase | ,, | £2.11 | million
1959-60 | non-capital | £101.13
1958-59 | ,, | £101.38
(original plus supplementaries)
Decrease | ,, | £0.25 | million
Comment on this
Might I interrupt the Minister to inquire if he proposes to circulate copies of this speech?
Comment on this
No; I have not copies. Let us examine first this net decrease of £250,000 in the provision for non-capital services as compared with this year's total provision for such services.
The change is the net outcome of a number of "ups" and "downs" of which the most important are as follows:—
DECREASES (NON-CAPITAL).
As most of the loss on the disposal of the 1958 wheat crop, as well as the balance of loss on disposal of the 1957 crop, is being met out of this year's total provision, the provision carried over into 1959-60 shows a reduction of £1,490,000. The provision for butter subsidy is down by £1,025,000 as it is expected that the quantity available for export will be substantially lower, owing to the fall in production throughout the late autumn and winter months, and that a better price will be realised on the export market than in 1958.
Another major decrease arises on the Vote for Transport and Marine Services. The decrease in this Estimate is almost entirely accounted for by the reduced provision being made for C.I.E., as capital expenditure is no longer being provided for by way of voted moneys and as there is a transfer to the Central Fund of interest payments on transport stock which were formerly a charge on this Vote. The effect is to reduce the non-capital element by £963,000.
Other decreases are shown on the Estimates for Supplementary Agricultural Grants and for Social Assistance. In the case of the former, actual experience in the current year, on which the Estimate for 1959-60 is based, enables a reduction of £100,000 to be made. In the case of social assistance the decrease arises mainly on widows' and orphans' non-contributory pensions but is offset by an increase in children's allowances.
It will be seen that the Vote for Roinn na Gaeltachta also shows a decrease of £60,800, the item mainly responsible being the drop of £110,000 in the Grant-in-Aid of An Bord Gaeltarra Éireann. The sum provided in the current year has proved too large and the figure provided for 1959-60 is regarded as a more realistic appraisal of the board's requirements.
INCREASES (NON-CAPITAL).
Under the heading of increases, I shall take first the three main Votes in the Education group, viz., Primary Education, Secondary Education and Technical Instruction which show an aggregate increase of £723,750. It is necessary also, in the context of general education, to take into account the additional provision being made in the Vote for Public Works and Buildings for the expanded national school building programme and the additional £260,430 which is provided in the Universities and Colleges Vote for increased grants to the universities. In the case of primary, secondary and technical education, the major part of the extra provision is attributable to higher pay for teachers but a part is due also to the continued growth in the number of pupils and teachers in secondary schools and to the continuing expansion of the technical education system. Further increases arise from the abolition of the 10 per cent. cut in secondary school capitation grants and from an increase in the provision for grants towards the cost of heating, etc., of national schools.
The total increase in the Universities and Colleges Vote amounts to £260,430 attributable mainly to increased grants for University College, Dublin, University College, Galway, University College, Cork, and Trinity College.
Comment on this
Has the Minister included some capital moneys in the last figures he gave, in the general figures for education?
Comment on this
I am just mentioning these now.
A substantial portion of the increase in the grants for University College, Cork, University College, Galway, and Trinity College is in respect of the provision of additional permanent accommodation and, accordingly, this amount (total £55,000) has, for 1959-60, been treated as a capital service.
There will, I am sure, be no questioning of the desirability of the increased provision—amounting in all to some £1.3 million—which is being made in 1959-60 for education and research.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt the Minister, but did he include in respect of primary and secondary education some capital sums?
Comment on this
No, not in that context, only in the ones I mentioned, the universities. A new provision in the Vote for Local Government is the £200,000 grant to the Road Fund to help pay for improvements to roads required to carry heavier traffic because of railway closings in the North-West and industrial developments. There will also be an advance of £200,000 from the Central Fund for this purpose. Another item of increase in this Vote is the additional £140,000 provided for contributions to loan charges of housing authorities.
The increase of £476,740 in the Estimate for Posts and Telegraphs arises mainly in respect of the provision of equipment for the Civil Aviation and Meteorological Wireless Services, for engineering materials and telephone capital repayments.
In the Defence Vote the items mainly constituting the increase are:— (1) pay, (2) civil defence, (3) clothing and equipment and (4) provisions. Part of the overall increase arises out of provision for an increase in the strength of the Permanent Defence Force.
In the Estimate for Garda Síochána the increase is almost entirely attributable to additional provision for pensions, gratuities, etc.
The increase in the Vote for Repayment of Trade Loans Advances results from provision being made for repayment to the Central Fund of amounts outstanding in the case of four companies that defaulted in the repayment of guaranteed loans.
In other words, most of what we are saving on the non-capital services mentioned earlier, we shall be spending on education generally, including increased aid to the universities and the first year's provision for An Foras Talúntais, on a contribution to the Road Fund, on the provision of equipment for the Civil Aviation and Meteorological Wireless Services, engineering materials for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, and on Defence, as well as meeting the full cost of the pay increases granted last year to those remunerated out of public funds. So much for the non-capital side of the Estimates.
On the capital side the net increase as compared with this year's total provision is £2.11 million. This arises out of the declared policy of the Government with regard to the development of our capital resources as outlined in the Programme for Economic Expansion published last November. I would, therefore, like to take this opportunity of making a brief progress report on that programme since its initiation last November.
As Deputies are aware, the Programme for Economic Expansion referred to contained an outline of the Government's projected contribution to economic development in the crucial years immediately ahead. The objective of the programme is to double the present rate of increase in real national income. It is hoped to achieve this by encouraging private enterprise, by giving productive expenditure a higher priority than before in the public capital programme, and by additional productive State investment amounting to £53.4 million in the five-year period from 1959-60 to 1963-64. The figure of £53.4 million is additional to the amount required to finance the public capital programme on the basis of existing policies. As the maximum possible productive development will not be achieved unless the people are willing to co-operate in fulfilling the objectives of the programme, it is heartening to record that the public response has been encouraging. A broad measure of support for the programme has been forthcoming from organisations representative of agriculture, industry, finance and commerce.
In the short period since the publication of the programme a satisfactory amount of progress has been accomplished. In some cases amending legislation is necessary, and the work of preparing the amending legislation is well advanced. Bills have been introduced to enable the fleet of Irish Shipping, Ltd., to be increased and to provide for additional expenditure by Bord na Móna and further Bills will be introduced to provide for additional expenditure by the E.S.B., to make available additional resources to the Industrial Credit Company Ltd. and to Bord Fáilte and to provide for the financing of the Shannon Free Airport Development Company. Other legislation which is in preparation will extend the functions of An Foras Tionscal, establish Córas Tráchtála as a permanent State agency, and give effect to the agreement providing for oil and natural gas exploration.
Consultations with agricultural, industrial, financial and other organisations are an essential preliminary to action in the case of such proposals as the improvement of agricultural credit facilities, the establishment of a meat research unit, the modernisation of bacon factories, etc. These consultations are proceeding.
The superphosphate subsidy was introduced with effect from the 1st September, 1958; the net cost this year is estimated at £500,000, and the Supplementary Estimate for Agriculture agreed to last week includes provision for this sum. Revised grants, approximately double those previously in force, have been made available for the construction of silos. Research into cattle breeding problems has been intensified and steps have been taken to expand the broiler industry. A Farm Management Survey will be started this year to improve the technical and economic efficiency of the farmer.
More attractive facilities for the purchase of fishing boats have been announced. The first part of the survey of fishery harbours has been completed. It is hoped that the construction of the first of two exploratory fishing vessels will commence shortly and £45,000 has been provided for this purpose in the 1959-60 Fisheries Estimate. Grants towards the cost of fish ponds have been announced.
The Industrial Credit Company has introduced and extended hire-purchase facilities and is prepared, in appropriate cases, to make available loans on terms which provide for deferred repayment of capital and for reduced interest rates. The organisation of the Institute for Industrial Research and Standards is being reviewed and the productivity committee foreshadowed in the White Paper has been established. A scheme is being prepared to assist private firms in the exploration and development of mineral deposits. It is hoped to announce shortly the details of the grants which will be made available for the development of major tourist resorts.
This brief survey, which does not, of course, cover all projects, gives some indication of the progress which has been made in implementing the Programme for Economic Expansion. I do not propose, on this occasion, to attempt any analysis of our general economic position and prospects. This, I think, is more appropriate to Budget time.
I shall confine myself to mentioning the provisions in the 1959-60 Estimates which relate to the Programme for Economic Expansion.
The first and largest is the provision in the Vote for Agriculture of £1,750,000 for subsidy on phosphatic fertilisers, following upon the initial provision of £500,000 included in the Supplementary Estimate for Agriculture which was agreed last week.
The other major increase in the Estimate for Agriculture relates to the bovine T.B. eradication scheme for which an additional gross sum of £1,680,000 is being provided. This represents a net additional provision of £936,000 when account is taken of receipts from the sale of cattle slaughtered under the scheme. It is vital that this scheme be pressed ahead with maximum speed in order to protect our productive capacity and external earning power. I have no doubt that Deputies will use every endeavour to impress on those concerned in the scheme and with whom they may be in contact the urgent need to bring the campaign to a successful and speedy conclusion.
There is a further increase in 1959-60 in the provision for the farm buildings scheme even as compared with the recently increased provision for the current year.
A total amount of £150,000 has been provided in the Vote for Tourism in respect of projects arising under the White Paper Programme. The principal item is £100,000 for resort development. The purpose of this provision is to defray the cost of schemes for the improvement of major tourist resorts. As already indicated, it is hoped to announce shortly details of the grants which will be made available. The other item is £50,000 for grants to encourage the provision of additional bedroom accommodation at tourist resorts.
The Vote for Fisheries contains various provisions in respect of projects arising out of the programme. On the sea fisheries side, £30,000 is included in the Grant-in-Aid of An Bord Iascaigh Mhara for grants for the additional boats mentioned in the White Paper. £100,000 is the total allocated for this purpose in the White Paper but £70,000 is provided for in the repayable advances from the Central Fund to the board and the balance is included here as grants. A provision of £34,000 is also included in this Grant-in-Aid for normal grants as distinct from grants for additional boats—these are grants of 15 per cent. of the cost, which the fishermen formerly had to borrow in full. In addition, this Grant-in-Aid includes a total sum of £37,800 in respect of grants for plant and premises. A further sea fisheries item is the amount of £45,000 being made available for the provision of an exploratory fishing vessel.
On the inland fisheries side a provision of £4,000 has been made for pond fish culture and the scheme of grants has already been announced. A sum of £4,000 is included for improvement of salmon fisheries in the subhead for contributions to the Salmon Conservancy Fund.
In the Vote for Public Works and Buildings the increase of £532,870 is attributable mainly to expanded programmes of arterial drainage and national schools building.
In the Aviation and Meteorological Services Vote the greater part of the increase is attributable to constructional works at Shannon and Cork Airports.
In the Estimate for Local Government an increased provision of £400,000 has been made for housing grants arising out of increases in these grants and extensions in their scope under the 1958 Housing Act. As Deputies are aware, grants for repairs and improvements are now available on a more generous scale.
I have already mentioned that part of the total increase in the Universities and Colleges Vote is to cover increased grants to University College, Cork, University College, Galway, and Trinity College, towards the provision of additional accommodation.
I have now given a general explanation of the non-capital and capital provisions contained in the Estimates for supply services for the coming year. The services for which provision is made in the volume represent expenditure undertaken on behalf of the citizens for the common good. I am satisfied that the changes as compared with the current year are changes which, on balance, are to the national interest, in the economic and social fields. I refer in particular to the increased provisions made for education in all its branches and for the improvement of agriculture, fisheries, industry and tourism. I ask the Dáil with confidence to agree to the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
The only thing I have been able to collect in the way of information from the speech the Minister has read is that he hopes that in the coming year, there will be a lot of people who will refuse to go into butter production to the same extent as they did last year. He asks us to accept the madness which, of course, affects this House round about this time of year in respect of C.I.E., and his hopes are based, as far as reductions are concerned, on the belief that C.I.E. will not require—or, at least, will not be given—the same amount of subvention as they had in earlier years for what are called capital schemes.
There is also a reference to this Programme for Economic Expansion and the Minister is right in saying that the programme has been very well received. It has been well received by the public: I wish it were better received by the Government and that they were in a position, even at this early stage, to give at least some idea of the results that may accrue to the benefit of the community from the expenditure of the money set out in the last few pages of the programme.
Finally, we have what is called "Aids to Education." The aids to education, in the main, are the provision of such sums as will enable the teachers and their various allied groups to buy more or less the same amount of food at something more than the old price, before the food subsidies were reduced. Those are the salient items as they appear to me in what I understood from the Minister's rather hurried reading of the matter he had before him.
It is just two years—all but a couple of days—since the Taoiseach, exulting in his victory at the polls, announced what he thought would be the openings for the future of those who corresponded with him. It is reported in the papers of the 8th of March, two years ago:—
"Commenting on the elections ...Mr. de Valera expressed his thanks to all who organised and worked for the success of Fianna Fáil."
Then he said:—
"The battle of the polls is over. I am glad the result has been decisive. We can, again, look forward to a stable Government. The battle with unemployment and the other economic ills from which the country is suffering has now to begin. We must as a people see to it that the result of this battle will be no less decisive. For that we shall need the combined effort of every section."
"Economic ills" were summed up in two newspaper accounts written, one about a year and the other about 18 months after that. One of those accounts set out the picture this way:—
"The shadow of unemployment grows darker every day; the population is steadily dwindling; emigration is threatening the existence of the race; people are eating into their savings and their capital. The external trade has been somewhat redressed, but this is largely due, on the one hand, to the cattle exports which are enjoying a prosperity that nobody can say will endure, and, on the other hand, to illusory benefits from other agricultural exports which are artificially maintained by costly subsidies."
Comment on this
It is from the Independent of March 8th, 1958, a year after the Taoiseach set out to conquer the economic ills of the country.
Comment on this
The Minister can go and look it up. The Minister might read something the Cork Examiner says from time to time.
Comment on this
In the Sunday Independent of December 7th, 1958, the editorial writer said:—
"The man who is trying to make a living, the man who is bringing up a family, the housewife who is daily faced with the problem of making ends meet, are all much more concerned, and very properly and urgently concerned, with bread and butter. They look around them and they see the young men and women fleeing the land. The farmers are desperately and courageously endeavouring to put their industry on a sound basis. The businessman is watching the wolf approaching his door because of the oppressive demands of the national tax-gatherers and the local rate-collectors. The cost of living remains an economic nightmare. The building trade is depressed, and unemployment is driving whole families out of the country."
Those were the ills which the Taoiseach set out to cure. In the time of his glory and exultation, he had addressed a meeting at Limerick and he asked the people to:—
"make up their minds when it comes to pass judgment on politicians who come before them at election times, that they will be ruthless with those who lied to them and who tried to degrade the political life of this country to be a dirty political game."
Comment on this
He asked the people to be "ruthless with those who lied to them and who tried to degrade the political life of this country to be a dirty political game."
I have a memory, though it is not my memory alone that I rely on, of the statements made with regard to subsidies—the statements made by the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and by the Minister for Justice. There is no necessity to quote the words, as they are so well known. The Taoiseach referred to the fact that there were stories going around that the Government intended to cut the subsidies. The Tánaiste referred to the same thing and wanted to know "how strong must be our contradictions of these falsehoods." The Minister for Justice described those rumours as "blood-curdling". All three agreed that Fianna Fáil had no intention of cutting the subsidies—not only that, but they did not believe in that sort of thing. We said it would happen; and it did not take very long to show how right we were in what we had prophesied. Unemployment and emigration are, I take it, two of the main things.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it correct that the quotations or the references which Deputy McGilligan gives are not correct, in so far as the three speakers he purports to quote from qualified their statements by saying that it appeared to them there was no necessity for the removal of the subsidies, but that they did not yet know how bad exactly the national finances were?
Comment on this
That has reference to what was said in the quotation: we only want to indicate where the matter appeared.
Comment on this
The statements have been made—they have been quoted often in this House and we can get the exact words if they would be any more pleasing to Deputy O'Malley. "We do not believe in these things, we have no intention of cutting the subsidies"—and yet they were cut. One has to inquire whether that benefited those who were looking for employment or those who wanted to get employment in our country.
Deputy Haughey committed himself last week to the statement that the people were better off. He said things were 50 times better off than last year.
Comment on this
Things were 50 times better off. I have a few clippings here from people who apparently do not know how well off Deputy Haughey thinks they are. There is a cutting here saying:—
"Dundalk Urban Council... deplored the dismissal of 300 men from the engineering works earlier in the day."
and a priest appealed to the people of Dundalk to rally around and help what he called "this stricken town."
Comment on this
I shall talk about Dublin in my own good time. I have here a statement issued by the Waterford St. Vincent de Paul Society round about Christmas, stating there were about 300 families hungry in the City of Waterford, and stating also that that factual reference was not intended to be either offensive or critical of any Party or any Government. In September of last year, there was a hope expressed at a meeting in Limerick that public policy would do something for Limerick—"this Cinderella of Cities."
Comment on this
The Deputy repudiates that, but Monsignor Moloney was not repudiated in any paper I read afterwards. I heard many people commend him for what he said to bring the City of Limerick to the notice of people, including the notice of the Deputy. The parish priest of Ballyfermot, which is fairly near the area Deputy Haughey knows is 50 times improved, said around Christmas that there were 700 families destitute in Ballyfermot. If Deputy Haughey does not believe what the P.P. of that area said, would he address himself to some of the members of the St. Vincent de Paul who do their merciful errands around that area and listen to what they tell him with relation to the situation which is developing in one part of the city, the city which Deputy Haughey thinks is so much better off than before?
I asked for a count to be made of the people who were unemployed during the Fianna Fáil period from 1934 to 1947. I asked for it in different ways. The question was replied to on 29th October, 1958. I asked, in particular, for a record of the unemployed as ordinarily calculated without any reference to Employment Period Orders. I got a list giving the figures year by year from 1934 to 1947; and the situation there revealed is that from 1934 to 1942 unemployment ran at the steady level of 100,000 people. Although it dropped a little in the years after that, the tot from 1934 to 1947 shows 94,000 people regularly unemployed, and that at a time when, of course, emigration was proceeding fast.
This is the twentieth year in which the Taoiseach has headed the political Party having control of this country. Emigrants have been running at the steady rate of 50,000 per year all that time. Somewhere this year, we shall reach the millionth count of the citizens who have been deported from the country because of lack of provision for them by the Government who controlled this country from 1932 to 1947 and, with two intermittent periods, up to 1958.
We know what the situation was with regard to capital development all during the years from 1932 to 1947. Public moneys sought by way of loan amounted to about £1,500,000 per year over the 20-year period. Yet this country was in a state of stagnation illustrated by the fact that, as I say, an average of 100,000 people per year remained unemployed right through the whole period and there was a vast outpouring of people by way of emigration right through the whole period.
The Minister for Lands is not satisfied with the efforts that were made from 1948 to 1951. He thinks that people will now have to put up with 20 years of living at a lower standard —20 years at a definitely much lower standard of living. His only hope for this country is that he can persuade people to pay more for whatever goods are produced here, when they are sold at home for domestic consumption, so that manufacturers will be able to export cheaply and feed the foreigner at lower prices than we ourselves pay for what we ourselves produce.
In 1948 to 1951, for the first time since 1932, the curve of earnings and of wages rose above the cost-of-living curve. The workers paid for that in 1952 when they were subjected to all the penalties of the savage Budget introduced in that year. The people, according to the Minister for Finance of the day, Deputy MacEntee, were too well off. The increase in wages had outstepped the increase in the cost of living and there was no social or economic reason for continuing the subsidies. The first cut was made on them.
During our term in office, we inaugurated the capital development schemes. We have left that mark on the finances of the country. Notwithstanding the fact that those schemes were not liked and notwithstanding the fact that they were criticised, and criticised in a most defamatory way, they are being maintained or, rather, there is hope they will be maintained, if there is any sincerity behind the declared programme for development. We reduced emigration and we brought unemployment to the lowest point it ever reached since the State was founded.
Comment on this
What about the £10,000,000 the Deputy was to save in ten months, or was it ten minutes?
Comment on this
At the moment, the situation with regard to unemployment is serious. Deputy Briscoe, touring America on his own, told an American audience when he landed at an airport there that there was about 12 per cent. of our people unemployed; he said that, were it not for emigration, there would be 50 per cent. unemployed. Now, 12 per cent. is bad enough. I take that 12 per cent. to mean those who are potentially industrial workers, not counting as a labour force the farmers and their relatives who help them in the farming business. In that context, 12 per cent. is a staggering figure. In England recently, there was consternation and a Gallup poll indicated that what was revealed is likely to have a serious effect on the Government there.
Unemployment has risen to 630,000 odd; that is about 2.8 per cent. of the labour force. In America, unemployment has risen by 600,000 odd, which represents a total of 2 per cent. of their labour force. The Six Counties are regarded as a deeply depressed area. The unemployment there is about 7 per cent. Our unemployment figure runs at over 80,000 people and those 80,000 come from a labour force which has been desperately weakened and depleted by emigration over the last two years. In each of the past two years, there have emigrated from this country what would represent the normal tot for three years. One can easily understand how there could be a slight lessening in unemployment if one remembers that there have emigrated in two years what, at the ordinary level, would represent the figure for three years.
We had a policy with regard to wages. We did not think it was necessary to bring about national stagnation or national recession of production simply to keep wages low. Over the same two matters, people have been fighting a controversy in England. Some people believe that it is right to bring about a lack of expansion and even stagnation in the industrial development of England in order to trim the ambitions of the labour people. We never gave in to that idea. We introduced arbitration. We opened the arbitration tribunals to all State personnel. We favoured and fostered the idea of approach to the Labour Court, in order that, from 1948 to 1951, wages might be brought up with some approach to the increase in the cost of living. We were so successful that the curve of the increased wages crossed the curve of the cost of living in 1949.
We know that this policy was not approved of. When I was in the Ministry of Finance, not merely weekly but daily I got correspondence addressed to me from various people, bankers, finance houses, chambers of commerce and other bodies of that type, asking—the demands all ran on the same lines—that wages increases should be stopped, that the Labour Court should be closed down, the policy of arbitration abolished and that neither the State nor the local authorities should be allowed to engage any further in capital expenditure. I used to meet some of these people and I asked them if they realised the consequences of what they were asking because one cannot forget the free opening there was in the better conditions in England. I asked whether they desired a still greater diversion of our population to England than there was at that time. The answer I got was that it was my job as a politician to see to that, that they spoke purely from the angle of the economist. That was the cry, a cry that has been repeated in all the reports coming from capital advisory committees and all organisations of that sort. The line is an echoing of the 1952 Budget period, that people are too well off here and if they have money, they will spend it and if they spend it, there is difficulty with regard to imports drawn in from across the water and there may be some difficulty with regard to our balance of payments.
This which we face is the third effort Fianna Fáil has made since the standstill Order days to cut the standard of living of the people, to depress their standard of living by cutting wages because its effect in the end is a cutting of wages in that people must pay more for the things they must buy if they are to live. If we raise the cost of food, butter, flour, bread and the people get the same old wage which they used to get when these commodities were subsidised, they have less to spend on other things, and they will spend less on clothes and all the things that go to the adornment of a house and so the precious balance of trade will be kept right at the cost of an enormous amount of suffering to human beings in this country through the operation of such a policy.
I still cannot understand what happened to the money that was saved by the removal of the subsidies. I have two sheets here indicative of the Budget proposals of 1952 and 1957. The saving on food subsidies in 1952 was £6,668,000. There was a payment of compensatory benefit of £2,750,000, so that the net saving was over £4,000,000. In 1957, the saving on the food subsidies is down as £7.10 millions and there was a compensatory benefit at the rate of 1/- per seven days and the amount was calculated at almost £2,000,000. Taking this calculation, £4,000,000 was hacked out of the people's pockets by making them pay more for their food in 1952 and in 1957 we extorted from them another £5,000,000. But that is not the true picture.
I have the cover of the Book of Estimates for 1957-58, 1958-59 and the present volume. On the cover of the present volume, "Other Services" are down as costing £101,000,000 and in the Estimates for 1957-58—which we left to the present Government—"Other Services" were £102,000,000, a drop apparently so far as the Government are concerned, of £1,000,000, but do not forget that in the booklet for 1957-58 the subsidies were there. The subsidies were under two different heads, the heading for dairy products subsidies and the heading for food subsidies and the figure was £9,500,000. We were expending £9,500,000 on food and that swelled this total of the volume for 1957-58 to £102,000,000.
The figure now stands at £101,000,000 and not one penny piece has been paid of the £9,500,000 which we provided in the Book of Estimates for 1957-58. Where has the money gone? That saving is a saving to the State and not a saving to the people who still have to buy their foodstuffs, if they desire to live in this country.
The matter of rates is one of the matters referred to in one of the two editorials I have mentioned. The various local authorities are making up their accounts in order to strike their rate for the year. I have a list of a certain number that appeared in the last couple of days. Donegal has struck a rate of 48/3 in the £. It is up by 2/9 on last year and the county manager wanted an extra 2/4. He wanted the rate to be struck at 5/1 higher than the previous year.
In Louth, the actual rate struck is up by 1/5 and again the county manager wanted an extra 1/6, making a total of 3/1. In Mayo, the rate is at 45/-, up by 1/9, after the council had refused to grant the additional 2/- which the county manager required. Waterford is running at 40/9 which is an addition of 11½d. on last year, and the county manager wanted an extra 1/1½d. Limerick is being considered at 35/3, showing an increase of 4/3 on the previous year. Carlow farmers are, I see, staging a protest meeting against an increase of 4/9 in the rates which are now running at 35/3. This morning's paper has an announcement that Cork City is likely to see an increase of 4/8 and there will probably be an increase of 3/-. Wicklow stands out as good amongst all these. There is only an increase of 1/5 in the rate they are charging.
These are the economic ills of this country and can anybody say that life has been made easier for those fortunate enough still to remain in this country? We are harassed by the loss of friends, relatives possibly; harassed by emigration, harassed by those who are miserably signing on at the labour exchanges to the number of 83,000 or so, harassed by the increase in the cost of living, harassed still more possibly by increases in taxation arising from the Minister's present proposals, and harassed still more again by heavy increases in the rates. That is what has happened after two years battling against the evils of the Budget in 1957.
The Tánaiste, busying himself travelling around the world, has made many uneasy flights across to London and Paris. He stops at London to call in to see the British Minister of Agriculture in order to get assurances from him that our cattle trade—not always so beloved by the Tánaiste— would still be maintained at its present lucrative point for our farmers. Then he hies off to Paris where he makes the case that this country, with four others, should be given special treatment as being under-developed or undeveloped, amongst those who are clamouring about the Free Trade Area and the Common Market. Then he hies himself back here in order to tell us that we must think about abolishing our protective equipment for industries, but, while he is advising that, he adds on a few duties here and there by Imposition of Duties Orders that are made from time to time.
The one thing he is certain about is that there is to be no free market for agricultural produce, whatever agricultural produce this country may be capable of exporting. He says there will be no free market for agricultural produce, but unless we are deemed to be an under-developed country, we may have to abolish our protective machinery, built up at the cost of very much sweat and blood over so many years, and, of course, there will be a corresponding drop in our cost of living, if that should ever happen. Of course, it is not going to happen, but there will be a woeful increase in unemployment, much worse than in the worst days Fianna Fáil ever gave us.
We have aids to exports and for companies setting up to manufacture goods for export. Sites are to be given free. The rates are to be subsidised on new factories for export; the plant will get certain remissions; and income-tax on the profits that are made will be remitted for a number of years. What must be remembered is that while we are trying to subsidies exports out of this country, we are definitely subsidising the export of human beings, because, by the wage policy the Minister attempted to follow over the past couple of years—which has luckily broken down—there was a definite incentive being given to our people to leave this country and to go to England, where conditions were better, though they were often reported as being much better than they actually were.
One wonders in all this where is the aid to the main producer in this country? It is only to the industrialist who gears himself to export business that these aids are given—remission of rates, help in regard to plant, help in regard to sites, and remission of income-tax for five years on whatever profits he may make in regard to exports. What is the farmer getting? The farmer has kept this country going over all the years, and often in the face of the hostility of previous Fianna Fáil Governments. The former Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, has often said that in ten years the agricultural exports from this country doubled in volume and trebled in value. Yet what aid does the farmer get? He is paying more rates than ever he paid before. The price of his food has been increased by Government action. The price of his clothes has gone up. Of about 200 items that go to make up the cost-of-living index figure over 150 items have been increased in cost since the Government took office, and the farmer buys his share of all these dearer things.
The farmer now claims an increase in the price of milk. He thought he was promised an increase in the price of wheat. He certainly had been promised an increase in the price of barley, and there is a scheme for subsidising grade A pigs. The farmer has been disappointed in all these things, milk, wheat, barley and grade A pigs. These all cost more than they used to, and the farmer has to stand by and see, while industries live on his exportable surpluses, he is not assisted in his economic or domestic life to produce any better or greater exportable surplus than he did before. All this time we are deluding ourselves that there is to be a vast outbreak of industrialisation, particularly in the Shannon area.
Deputy Haughey told a meeting in January of last year that there was a tendency for Americans and Canadians to come into Ireland as a springboard into the Free Trade Area. He said, and it is almost repetitive, that many Americans and Canadians were investigating the possibility of setting up factories here because Ireland would be inside the Free Trade Area. Deputy Briscoe, on landing in America, however, said that the situation at home was not good. He said, to put it mildly, it was bad. We were unable to absorb our unemployed in industries and consequently our emigration figures were at the highest peak. We had about 80,000 unemployed and if the percentage were 50 per cent., that figure would be 350,000, were it not for emigration.
On his way home, the same Deputy told us he had five prospects for industrial development in this country. They included a chewing gum company which was considering establishing a factory at Shannon, a shirt manufacturer and a company thinking of building motels. He boasted that his progress in America had increased exports to America fourfold. He told the people in America that they should never think we would have a depression in this country because we had never been prosperous enough to be faced with a depression.
We have various manufacturing industries being talked of at present. One is a factory to manufacture skittle ball alleys. I see that Dr. Adenaur was operating one of those, sent out, of course, as a sample to a firm. We were told at one time that certain firms were thinking of establishing a juke-box manufacturing industry at Shannon. We know that somebody intends to do big business at Shannon and there is some scheme, I understand, for starting the breeding of chinchillas there. That is the new industrial development, juke boxes, skittle ball alleys and chewing gum factories.
Comment on this
We are exporting the rabbits that Deputy Dillon at one time said would be running wild around Shannon.
Comment on this
There is one person, very like a rabbit, who runs a bit wild around this House. I wish we could export him. What folly is this about these things! Let them be developed—it will be at least something —but I am thinking of the days when the industrial exports of this country covered three big groups of industries, and they were very valuable. Guinness used to do their main brewing here; Jacobs did most of their biscuit production here, even for consumption abroad; and we had a marvellous industrial development in the way of tweeds, the reputation of which was world-wide. The last report I saw of the Guinness firm indicated that half their profits had been made on what they produced here, no matter where it was consumed, and half from what was produced elsewhere.
Fianna Fáil helped to drive that group out. Fianna Fáil were definitely responsible for making Jacobs transfer part of their production to England and the Fianna Fáil policy of tariffs, of course, induced those who used to make tweeds for the foreign market to concentrate on the easier market at home. We have lost three big industrial exports and it will take many years of all these helps and aids before we will—if we ever do—laboriously come near to equating the prosperity that used to be here in these things and the results we got from it.
I noticed in the last debate about remuneration of civil servants that the question of employment as opposed to unemployment was raised here. I have this quarterly industrial inquiry sent round to Deputies from time to time and I see that the number of people engaged in manufacturing industries, the average number for the four quarters of 1956 was 145,000 people. The average for the four quarters of 1957 was 140,000 people and the average number for the four quarters of 1958 was 142,000 people. There are more unemployed; there are more emigrating; and there are fewer in the manufacturing industries. Now we are told everything will be all right if we go according to the White Paper.
The White Paper has two appendices, Appendix I and Appendix II. Appendix I is the full public capital expenditure inclusive of the additional expenditure in Appendix II. Appendix II certainly represents schemes and projects that we had or that we had established in 1948 in the main, so that if there is anything new, it is to be found in Appendix I—"Development Proposals." These new items run to £53,000,000 in five years at £10,000,000 a year. What are they? In agriculture, there is to be credit provided through the Agricultural Credit Company, £7,500,000. There is to be subsidisation of phosphate fertilisers, £6,500,000. I suggest that this £6,500,000 will not add one person to the employed community of the State. It will undoubtedly make for better productivity and we may have a better exportable surplus, but so far as employment is concerned it does not matter.
There is to be an expansion of credit through the Industrial Credit Corporation of £17,500,000, and there is to be the famous nitrogenous fertiliser factory, costing £7,000,000. That is £38,000,000 of the £53,000,000 built up in the provision of credit through the Agricultural Credit Company and the Industrial Credit Corporation, in the hope of course that people will avail themselves of that credit, if it is made available. But can anybody say that is a programme for development? It is certainly not a plan. There is certainly a target in it to the extent that it says: "We will give so much money and we hope people will come along and avail themselves of it."
It represents, of course, a vast increase in the use made up to the present of either the Agricultural Credit Company or the Industrial Credit Corporation. It is a sevenfold increase in one case and a fourfold increase in the other, but who is optimistic enough to believe that will take place? The subsidisation of phosphate fertilisers is a good thing, but looking at it from the employment angle, it does not matter. The nitrogenous fertiliser proposal has come up again and it is amazing to see it recur. I think if a proper tot were made, a proposal for a nitrogenous fertiliser factory came before the Department of Agriculture at five separate times and four Fianna Fáil Ministers for Agriculture, including, I think, the present Minister for Finance, turned down the project. Deputy Dillon, when he was Minister for Agriculture, refused to have it. Is there something new about this project? Has any new development occurred? Is there some way of getting nitrogenous fertilisers produced more cheaply than the scheme originally forecast, because if not, either this £7,000,000 will not be spent or if it is spent, we will find ourselves in respect of nitrogenous fertilisers in the same position as we are in now in regard to butter. We will have to export about half the production annually to make such a factory an economic unit and that after charging the farmers more for fertilisers at higher subvented prices, if we are to try to get into competition with Imperial Chemicals for the sale of this material elsewhere.
That is the additional expenditure that is proposed—£14,000,000 between the two items for agriculture, £17,500,000 in respect of the increase in agricultural credit and credit for industry and £7,000,000 for the fertiliser factory. It does not leave much in the way of new capital expenditure in this famous White Paper. One could, and one must later investigate and analyse what is contained in Appendix II to see how far are these fictitious or real items. But that is the programme for economic expansion. If one thought it was well accepted by the present ministerial group and that it was to be effectively put into practice, there might be a little residuum of hope, but previous performances of Ministers over the years from 1932 to 1947 and their attitude of welcoming stagnation and being afraid of development and afraid of wages that would be spent on development does not give one much hope that the programme will be given effect to.
This is the Presidential year; it is the year in which we must elect a new President and the Taoiseach puts himself forward as a candidate. He leaves all the economic ills that were in his mind when he spoke on 8th March of two years ago by no means remedied. I do not believe that they are to any degree lessened. Somewhere around the middle of this year, somewhere about now, he hits the 20th year of his control of this country, and emigration has been running at about 50,000 a year in all that time. So somewhere this year we shall have reached the point where the one-millionth person will have left the country.
There is a system I know that when a cinema or an airline gets its one-millionth patron, they generally give him some present. Does the Taoiseach think he is deserving of the Presidential office because in his time he has exported 1,000,000 people? Or because in the last two years he has increased the rate of emigration to a higher figure than was ever reached before and when the situation is, and the calculation has been made, that of every three people born in the country now two are destined to die abroad?
Of those who remain, whether in employment or otherwise, the position as revealed by the provisions of the Health Act is this: under the Health Act, people are entitled to free medical services, if they possess this peculiar qualification—that they are unable by their industry or other lawful means to provide any part of the medical requirements of themselves and their families and the calculation has been accepted that that applies to 1,000,000 people out of the less than 3,000,000 we have in the country.
One million of our people are reduced to the position that their industry or other lawful means do not allow them sufficient to have imposed on them the obligation of providing any part of the medical requirements of themselves or their families.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, Deputy McGilligan referred to the quotation of 10th May, 1952. He said in that quotation that if they could get the present Government out before the 1st July, a new Minister for Finance could then save £1,000,000 a minute.
Comment on this
We did not get the Government out at that point. I wanted to bring that quotation out because it depended on a certain condition. However, within four years, we were able to knock off £7,000,000 in less than seven minutes.
Comment on this
This Government have been in office for just two years and we have to consider what was their policy over those two years and try to define what is their policy at the moment. We understood, when we came in here and when Fianna Fáil formed the very strong Government they have at present, that we would be the busiest House of Parliament in the world carrying out the work that Fianna Fáil promised during the election. They said that they could put the people to work, that they would get cracking and that it was only a matter of giving them the opportunity.
Now they have been in office for two years and instead of doing what they promised to do they went into the red-herring business in a big way. We had the Tánaiste saying that he had £100,000,000 up his sleeve, but when he got into office and had eaten a few chambers of commerce dinners, that amount turned into £250,000,000.
Then they brought up the question of the European Free Trade Area. This was to be another of their solutions for our problems. It was to be a wonderful thing, but any ordinary man in the street knew that whatever else we were tied to, we were tied to Great Britain as far as imperial preference, to use the old term, was concerned. We were enjoying imperial preference in the British market and if we allowed certain continental countries to send their manufactured products in here on the same terms as British products, we would lose our imperial preference in their markets.
We were told about all the Canadians and Americans who were to invest in industry here. That was two years ago, and since then they have not come along in any numbers that would make any impact on our unemployment problem. We were told, when the Minister for Finance introduced his first Budget, that he had allocated £250,000 for the expansion of our markets abroad. I should like to know if there is any report about that £250,000. I put down a question here last year when about 15 months had gone by and only a couple of thousand pounds had been spent by that time.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, I should like to point out that there is not one member of the Labour Party present in the House.
Comment on this
There was not a single Minister or member of the Fianna Fáil Party to stand up and utter a word in reply to the indictment Deputy McGilligan made against them.
Comment on this
The Leader of the Opposition is in the House anyway and the Leader of the Government is not.
Comment on this
We are starting out on a very important debate. Can we have an assurance that this debate will be allowed to proceed in a constructive manner, or are we to have the leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party throwing their back benchers into interruptions in order to interfere with the orderly continuance of the debate?
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, is it allowable in the course of this debate, for responsible Ministers to interrupt the debate for the purpose of calling one Party the tail end of another? Is this part of the constructive policy of dealing with the vital, economic and urgent pressing matters that this House is set up to consider and to take the best possible steps to improve?
Comment on this
Who is responsible for keeping a quorum? What is the object of keeping a quorum when it is the Government's policy to interrupt and disconcert Opposition Deputies who are making constructive contributions to the debate? Is it in order for Ministers to interrupt Deputies when speaking?
Comment on this
There is a quorum present. Interruptions, no matter from what side of the House they come, are disorderly and the Chair will endeavour to see that they do not continue.
Comment on this
The interruptions came first from a back bencher of the Government Party and were followed by interruptions from Ministers.
Comment on this
I did not agree with Deputy O'Malley's point of order. He never had a point of order and this is only another red herring. I said that £250,000 had been allocated to expand the markets of this country. What happened to that money? Was it just another red herring to draw the people's attention away from all the fundamental difficulties facing the country? The people on the opposite benches, if they had £250,000,000 to spend, would not know what to do with it. They would not know how to spend it in a proper way or how to set up an organisation to have it invested in a proper way.
They have been two years in office, the two years after which they said that everything would be in hand. They have a majority that no Government in this country ever had before. No matter what Bill is brought in here, they have a majority big enough to pass it. In spite of that, they have not produced any policy, but they did get a member of the Civil Service, a very eminent gentleman, to produce this programme of economic expansion. I should like to say that I suspect that this was produced only to draw people's attention away, to give them something to read. On reading it, I agree with most of it, because most of it is Fine Gael policy.
Comment on this
Oh, oh! I am glad I got that from the Deputy, as that is all they ever say over there. They are able to make only that sound.
Comment on this
There is Demosthenes for you. This White Paper produced by the Government now tells what we could do to improve our grassland. I remember the Minister for Agriculture in the inter-Party Government being hounded to death as the "Minister for Grass" by the Fianna Fáil catch-cry men all over the country.
Comment on this
Now it is part of the Government's policy. The cattle trade is recognised now, even by Deputy Carty down in Galway, as the mainstay of this country. We have it in the Press; we have it from Ministers; and we even had it from Mr. Childers last night in Manchester.
Comment on this
The only thing that is really wrong is that this was written too late, the writer of this was born 30 years too late. If he had been born 30 years earlier and if he had been employed by the Fianna Fáil Government when they went into office and produced this for them and if they had carried it out, how much richer would this country be and how much richer would the farmers of Ireland be?
Comment on this
Probably he would have been deported for it. It would be treason to produce that when Fianna Fáil came into office. I am a little handicapped here to-day because the Minister did not give us a copy of his speech and I think he should have done so. However, I made a note of one of the things he said and I thought it was very important: "Deputies will endeavour to impress on everyone concerned the urgency of this matter". If the Minister looks at his brief, he will see that I am quoting it fairly. He said that in regard to the T.T. cattle scheme. Is the policy the Government are carrying out tending towards the T.T. scheme, or is the Minister for Agriculture competent to bring this scheme to a successful conclusion?
Comment on this
I submit to you that, when the Minister mentioned here that Deputies should "impress on everyone concerned the urgency of the T.T. scheme," you should allow me to say that I think that the man who more than the ordinary Deputy should try to impress everyone is the Minister for Agriculture.
I have some experience in this, Sir. I know the difficulty; I know the expense; I know the risk and I know the hard decision it is to bring a veterinary surgeon in to have one's cattle tested and I know the great experience that it is in getting rid of the reactors.
Comment on this
This would be a matter for the Estimate. A detailed discussion of the Estimates on the Vote on Account is not permissible and has not been the practice.
Comment on this
I just wanted to justify myself, Sir, and to say that I am actually talking about my own experience—only it was an unfortunate one. I was 30 years before my time, just as Mr. Whitaker was 30 years after the time he should be there. I had done this and had an economic war with my T.T. herd.
Comment on this
As I understand Deputy Lynch, he was developing a matter of broad policy in relation to which the Minister is making financial provision here and was impressing on the House that it is a part of the fundamental policy of the Government. Surely, on this Vote on Account, when we are expending money, we may raise the question of experience in dealing with certain matters, the necessity for going ahead with them and of seeing that everybody is so fully informed that they will be induced to go ahead with them? This is not a question of discussing details of Estimates.
Comment on this
Deputy Lynch, so far as I understand, is discussing the question of reactors and that certainly is a matter of detail which would arise relevantly on the Estimate for Agriculture, but not on the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
I submit, Sir, that if we have a policy in relation to the eradication of bovine tuberculosis, one of the fundamental parts of that policy is to get rid of reactors and we are providing money here for the purpose of getting rid of them. The broad policy in respect of which reactors are got rid of and the extent to which the money is to be used, is a matter very vital to any kind of discussion on the Vote which the Minister has put before us. If we cannot see the circumstances in which the money he is asking for now is to be spent, and the time in which it is to be spent, there is no use in discussing the expenditure of public money, either, for the purpose of pursuing a policy that is vital to our economic finances. It is a general matter and not a matter of detail.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that the question of general financial policy is dealt with on the Vote on Account and matters of detail should be reserved for the Estimates. Deputies will get every opportunity of raising them relevantly on the Estimates.
Comment on this
I want to submit that it is not a matter of detail to speak in broad terms of the policy of getting rid of bovine tuberculosis.
Comment on this
Deputy Lynch has been talking of his personal experiences of 30 years ago. What has that to do with this?
Comment on this
These are the kind of experiences which are burnt into you. I had an awful loss at that time and the Minister for Health who has just spoken had something to do with it.
I should like to say now that when I mentioned an official here, Sir, I did not mention that official in any deprecatory way. I have the greatest respect for him as an official; I have the greatest respect for his competence; and I have the greatest respect for him as a man. I just mentioned that he was born 30 years too late. That was not his fault.
The Minister for Finance said to-day that Deputies will endeavour to "impress on everybody concerned the urgency of this matter," that is, the urgency of getting on with the T.T. cattle scheme and bringing it to a successful conclusion. If I were a farmer, I would not have the audacity to go down the country, go into a group of farmers and ask that group of farmers to go ahead with T.T. testing and get it done as quickly as they could, if I had not done it myself. A year ago the Minister for Agriculture stated he had no intention of doing this testing to produce an accredited herd until the scheme became more intensive in his area. If this scheme is to be brought to a successful conclusion, I suggest he should be one of the leaders in it.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have every opportunity of discussing that aspect on the relevant Vote. It does not arise on this.
Comment on this
The fact that the Minister mentioned it in passing does not give Deputies the right to go into details on the T.T. scheme on the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
I respectfully submit that I was not going into detail in the last statement I made. I wanted to ask how the Minister could expect Deputies to go down the country and do what the Minister in charge of the scheme had no intention of doing himself.
Comment on this
There is nothing personal in that. With all due respect, when the day comes that criticising a Minister will be regarded as tantamount to indulging in personalities Parliament will be finished.
There is a provision of £25,000 for the sale and expansion of various products. We are told our main market is Britain. Sometimes Ministers say the most uncomplimentary things about Britain, its people and its Government. Two days later, or perhaps a day later, they state publicly they want to improve our market in Great Britain and we should do everything we can to promote a better understanding. That was stated recently by the Minister for Industry and Commerce at a very important chamber of commerce dinner here in Dublin, and on at least two other occasions. Consider his attitude towards Great Britain and its traders. He was not very long in office when he brought in a Bill to prevent anybody here buying tea from an English merchant in Mincing Lane. That was not good policy. How would we like it if a British Minister brought in a Bill in the British House of Commons to prevent Englishmen buying Irish cattle from Irish cattle dealers? Simultaneously with bringing in that Bill to confine the tea trade to five nominees of his own here in Dublin, he was looking for European free trade. Probably the Minister for Finance thinks I am being personal again. I hope he will pardon me; there is nothing personal in this. If we intend to do business with Britain—I hope we do so intend—we ought to stop this anti-British nonsense that goes on, especially on Government platforms.
On the famous day on which the Minister for Finance read his first Budget here, he mentioned that a sum of £55,000 would be allotted for the development of the fisheries at Dunmore East. I was delighted because I have always believed that my constituency has always got the thinnest slice of cake. On that auspicious occasion, we were actually mentioned in the Budget statement. That night, on the radio, I and all those who listened heard the statement repeated. We read it the next day in newspapers. Before the Estimates concluded, however, I got a smell of stinking fish. I asked the Minister for Fisheries, for Lands, for Forests, and so on, what was the position. I was told that Dunmore East was getting £5,000 and that the £55,000 had been a misprint. That was all the satisfaction we got.
Greater care should be taken in the preparation of the Budget statement. No Minister should make a mistake of £50,000. We had copies of the statement over here and the figure was clearly £55,000. A short time afterwards, a fish factory was erected in Galway. It has never functioned. Is that the kind of policy that is being inaugurated now? If enough pressure is brought to bear, installations of various kinds will be erected in constituencies, irrespective of whether or not they are likely to pay? Now, I will stand over the results as far as the returns from Dunmore East for the past four or five years are concerned. The Government's policy in relation to fisheries is plain poppycock—putting fish factories where there is enough political pressure.
Comment on this
It is very important in relation to policy. Apart from that, I have seen hundreds of thousands of pounds spent on various installations throughout the country, in places where the installations were not necessary at all and despite requests for installations of the same kind in areas where the installations were necessary and where they would be a paying proposition. But these areas were ignored.
Very few people ever mention the ordinary small shopkeepers. The impact of Government policy on them has been disastrous. Increased costs and higher rates, coupled with a falling population, have reduced their turnover.
The last thing I wish to say is this. This Government got into office by a trick; they cheated the people. Undertakings were given in Belmullet and in my constituency on the Friday night before the election by the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste. The Taoiseach said they would not remove the subsidies, that "we will never do what they say we will do". Headlines were made the next day in the Irish Press. Fianna Fáil ran out on their undertakings and now, after two years in office, what have they got to show for it?—the Tánaiste's crock of gold, the £225,000,000, the betrayal of the unemployed and the breaking of their word to the housewives that their husbands would be put back to work.
We have had two years here with practically no legislation brought in to help solve the unemployment problem or to reduce emigration, two years in which will-o'-the-wisps like Free Trade were trotted out. Finally, when we came back last October, instead of the House being encouraged to grapple with these problems, we were handed the problem of P.R. That is just carrying on the old Fianna Fáil policy which we have seen down through the years. It started off with the annuities, then the Oath, then neutrality—they always had something—and then when we were not able to go on to the Republic, they proposed the abolition of P.R.
Comment on this
It has a bearing on the policy of the Government and on the wasting of the time of the House. I regret to say that no legislation was brought in which would put one person into employment or stop one young man or woman from emigrating.
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just sat down is as thorny as a porcupine and on occasions he bites somewhat irrationally. He was not in the most amiable mood this evening, but I have sympathy for him, because, after all, it is not an easy thing, or an enviable position for a person to be placed in, to be called on at a moment's notice to become a stand-in for the Leader of the Labour Party, who apparently——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I was not a stand-in for anybody. I had my speech prepared. I prepared it last night and to-day.
Comment on this
What the Minister has to say to the Labour Party should be said without trying to bring me into it.
Comment on this
I am sorry; I gather the Deputy does not deserve my sympathy, so it is being wasted.
Comment on this
I am still full of the milk of human kindness and I am prepared to forgive the Deputy for the sort of speech to which we have just listened from him, because I think he was caught at a disadvantage. On an occasion when the general economic position of the country is under review, I thought we would have heard statements from some responsible member of the right or left wing—I do not know which it was in the last Coalition——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I insist that I am more responsible than the Minister for Health.
Comment on this
I had, perhaps, the rather infelicitous acuteness to refer to the Labour Party as the tail-end of the Coalition. I was rapped on the knuckles by Deputy Mulcahy for so expressing myself. I now take it that, if they were not the tail-end, they must have been the head and intelligence and driving force behind the last Coalition. Yet, in a debate of this sort, one would have expected that the general line of criticism or perhaps of commendation which the Labour Party proposed to pursue in the course of the debate, would have been laid down for us by the Leader of the Party.
Having listened to what Deputy McGilligan had to say on behalf of the Fine Gael Party, and hoping to have heard from Deputy Norton on behalf of the Labour Party, I had intended to follow. It is necessary for me to make that explanation in view of the suggestion made by Deputy Mulcahy that the Government are failing in their duty to the House. After all, surely it is the duty of the Government to listen to the criticisms which can be made against its policy and, if possible, to refute them. We have not heard from Deputy McGilligan any criticism of the Government's policy; we have not heard from Deputy Norton any criticism of the Government's policy, for the simple reason that he was not here to criticise. We have heard some criticism from Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Lynch. I do not want to pursue Deputy Lynch's speech. I shall only say that, having prepared it last night and to-day, he was, so to speak, wide off the beam, in that he addressed himself to controversies which were settled as far back as the years 1932 and 1933.
I listened to part of Deputy McGilligan's speech and I ask any member of the House who heard the speech to tell me what it was about, what relevance, short of the consideration which is extended by the Chair to all members of the House on an occasion such as this, had it to the present situation? We had the old tirade of misrepresentation. We were told what somebody said in 1952 or even earlier. We were told about the emigration which Fianna Fáil had caused. We were told about the stagnation which Fianna Fáil had caused. We had in short—and I think it is a rather charitable description of Deputy McGilligan's effort—a regurgitation of all the red herrings that have characterised the speeches of the Opposition since they were displaced from office in 1932. We had arguments made about the subsidies which, as was pointed out by Deputy O'Malley, were highly selective statements which were fallacious, in so far as they told only half the truth.
We were told that in the past two years, emigration had reached a rate which was the equivalent of what had been regarded by Deputy McGilligan as the rate representing total emigration over three years. That is a very interesting statement coming from Deputy McGilligan. If, in two years, the emigration from this country had equalled what it would have been in three years, one must ask oneself how did that situation come about.
It is not easy to drive people out of any country. It is not easy to coerce people, who are in a settled way of life and who have a substantial business, to the conclusion that there is a better future awaiting them outside this country than they can ever hope to attain here. Yet that is exactly what did happen here in the years 1955 and 1956, and it was mounting to a peak in the beginning of 1957. I, of my own knowledge, know that there were people, men who were in a good way of business in this country, men with families, who said to themselves that under the Coalition there was no future for themselves and their children. They sold their businesses and went elsewhere. I think they are very sorry now that they took that step, but the tide of which they were a part began to rise in the years 1955 and 1956, and possibly may have reached a peak about the middle of 1957.
It has been receding ever since and in the year 1958, in the second year after the Coalition went out of office, the outflow of emigration from this country has come under control and has been vastly diminished. The reason it has been vastly diminished is, first of all, that there have been changes on the other side of the water. We may as well be candid and frank about these things. Conditions in Great Britain do not seem to be as attractive now as they were is 1956 and 1957, as compared with conditions which existed here; but the great reason why people are not emigrating in the volume in which they did, in the numbers in which they did in the year 1956 and in the early part of 1957, is that they have begun again to regain hope in the future of their own country. They have regained that hope because of the policy which has been pursued by the Fianna Fáil Party, and because of the success which has attended the efforts of this Government to undo the evils manifested for the second time in Coalition Government.
Deputy McGilligan said they had a policy in regard to wages and that they did not think it necessary to bring about national recession. If that is the case, why, at the end of 1956—why, as a matter of fact, in the early spring of 1956—did the Minister for Finance in the second Coalition feel called upon to come in here and impose the special levies which marked the first stage in a severe deflationary policy? Why did he follow that in the late autumn of 1956 by a second special levy, again imposing severe deflation upon the economy of this country? Why did he do that if, as Deputy McGilligan says, the Government of the day did not believe that it was necessary for them to create a recession? Was it not to put a curb on the inflation about which they were warned in the middle of 1955 when they reintroduced the subsidisation for tea, and which inevitably followed upon the policies on which they then embarked? I do not say that the Coalition Government willingly created that situation in 1956; I do not say that the Coalition Government desired that the economic dislocation which followed upon their policy would be brought about. I do not say that they wanted to have unemployment in this country. I do not believe that for a moment, but they found themselves in this situation that, unless the State and the whole economy were to go bankrupt, unless we were to have financial chaos and confusion rampant throughout the country, they had to take steps in 1956 to undo the evils which they had initiated with their policy in 1955.
I remember the advent of the first Coalition in 1948. We can all recall the speech of the Tánaiste, on the occasion upon which Deputy Costello became Taoiseach, when he pointed out the sound condition in which this country was being handed over, the enterprises upon which we had embarked, the fact that our credit was standing possibly the highest in Europe, and that our dead weight national debt was modest by any standards then current in the world. He said to the Taoiseach: "We are handing this country over to you in good condition; make certain that you hand it back to us likewise". There was no problem then about balance of payments, at least not any that did not reflect the running down of stocks which was imposed upon us during the war years, and the backlog of technical development which again the war had imposed upon us.
But the deficit on external account was a modest one by comparison with what subsequently followed. It was, I think, of the order of £29,000,000. In the middle of 1948, the then Taoiseach and present Leader of the Opposition, informed the country that, in his opinion, the fact that this deficit had begun to manifest itself was a serious matter and that drastic steps would have to be taken to remedy the situation and put our financial position again in balance.
That, of course, was a preliminary to the policy which was then initiated by the first Coalition, the policy of deliberately creating a recession, because in this case it was deliberately created. The policies of economic development which had been initiated by Fianna Fáil immediately after the war, from 1945 to 1957, were drastically curtailed. Two instances occur to me. We had decided, having regard to the advantages of our geographical situation, that we would get into the air transport industry. We had an excellent opportunity of coming in then on the ground flour. We bought three Constellations which were then, as I think yet, the leading passenger-carrying aircraft in the world. We were ready to initiate one of the first transatlantic passenger services. Everything was set for commencing that service on St. Patrick's Day, 1947. These arrangements, however, were scrapped; the Constellations were sold and sold at a profit showing the potential opportunity which other people saw in the development of air transport across the Atlantic.
With the sale of the Constellations, something else happened. The repair and maintenance depot which was to be established at Shannon by one of these large American aircraft manufacturers and which would have given employment, we were informed, to at least 400 men skilled and semi-skilled, was strangled. That was the first manifestation of the attempt to impose a deliberately restrictive policy on our people.
The next thing that happened was this: in 1940-1941 it had been decided to try to ascertain what was the real value of the mineral deposits in Wicklow. During the war, the exploration work was carried out under circumstances of great difficulty and danger—in fact, I think, men lost their lives in that work—for the Government of the time had no adequate plant and no skilled personnel and were faced with the situation that there was a deposit there honeycombed with old workings of which there was no permanent record. We were setting out to explore these in the same way as a person might set out to cross the Antarctic, but we persevered. From 1941 until 1947, that work was carried out under circumstances often of great difficulty and when other people might have given up and said: "We will abandon the idea; we can find nothing worth while here." But it was carried on until the year 1948 when, for the sake of saving a paltry £50,000 and showing what spendthrifts the Fianna Fáil Governments who preceded it had been, the Coalition shut down that exploration work for many months. They were induced to resume the exploration only under pressure from their own supporters in County Wicklow. They carried it on in a half-hearted manner from 1948 to 1951. Incidentally, when we came in again, we pursued that exploration and we succeeded in proving that there was such a considerable body of ore there that it could be exploited profitably and economically. When the Government changed again in 1954, we had reached the stage at which proposals for the economic opertion and exploitation of the Wicklow deposits could be received and were being sought from competent organisations.
There is the policy of deflation which was being deliberately pursued when Deputy McGilligan was active as Minister for Finance from 1948 until some date in 1950 when he went on a sit-down strike—and this is the Deputy who got up here, and, relying, I suppose, on the ignorance of the people in regard to these matters, relying on the fact that the public have forgotten all about the circumstances —and I suppose he will be reported to-night on the radio—said that he did not think it necessary to bring about national recession.
The fact of the matter is that in the year 1948-1949 the first Coalition can be proven by examination of the records to have embarked on a deliberately restrictive policy. The Sugar Company management was in all sorts of difficulties during that period. Bord na Móna was in exactly the same position. The directors and management of Bord na Móna did not know from day to day what the situation was going to be. They had to fight to save the enterprise from being scrapped; and the reason they had to fight was that it just happened that it was started and had been developed and had been made a success under the Fianna Fáil Governments which existed from 1933 to 1948. It had been made a success in spite of the bitter opposition and misrepresentation of the Fine Gael Party. Our memories are not so short that we cannot recall to mind the old Fine Gael slogan—"Wheat, beet and peat will soon be up the spout."
Comment on this
I am coming to that; we shall deal with the white elephants, too. The prime instrument in trying to send wheat, beet and peat up the spout, and that was Deputy Dillon's elegant phrase, was the Deputy who opened the debate for the Opposition here this evening, Deputy McGilligan, when he was Minister for Finance.
It is amusing for those of us who came into this House in 1927, despite all the attempts to keep us out, who came in when we found that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party was endeavouring to impose a condition which would make it impossible for any Irishman to stand for a seat in the Irish Legislature and who heard Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Industry and Commerce from 1927 to 1932, to hear him now pose as a friend of the working class and to hear him making speeches which are designed to show Deputy Norton what a much more forceful leader of the Labour Party Deputy McGilligan would be than Deputy Norton is.
Of course, Deputy Norton has a come-back to Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan has said that he had a policy in regard to wages. And he did have a policy in regard to wages. It is one which the Irish worker bitterly remembers. Deputy McGilligan was one of those who brought in a German firm to build the Shannon scheme. That scheme, in response to Deputy MacEoin, was so ill-conceived that it has not been possible to develop it even within two-thirds of its estimated capacity in 1924. Money was spent there building works for a scheme which it was assumed would have had a capacity of one-third greater than what exists at the present day.
However, I was referring to the attitude of the friend of labour to whom we listened here this afternoon. What was the attitude of Deputy McGilligan when the Shannon scheme was being built? It was that 15/- a week was good enough for a working man, whether he was married or single, children or no children. That was the attitude set by the Deputy who has just said: "We had a policy in regard to wages." That was the wage policy of Cumann na nGaedheal. That, too, would be their policy and the policy of Deputy McGilligan if they could come out in the open. The wage policy which Fine Gael had was 15/- per week for the labouring man.
Comment on this
He said he had a labour policy. I am recalling to the House what Deputy McGilligan's labour policy was when he was in a position to determine labour policy. He spoke about the Labour Court. Deputy McGilligan did not set up the Labour Court and it was not set up with the approval of Deputy McGilligan. It was established by the Fianna Fáil Government, not by Deputy McGilligan and not by the Coalition.
We had a policy in regard to labour. We wished that labour should get its rights, should get the best that production could afford, that it should get the best that would enable us to maintain our economy and secure a decent standard of living for every Irish producer in this competitive world. Sometimes we had to resist demands made by labour, but we are the Party who made provision for the workers when their unemployment benefit was exhausted. We did not come along and say that people might die of starvation and that it was no part of the Government's duty to provide work for them.
Comment on this
Who is supposed to have said that? That has been nailed in this House time and again. It is a lie.
Comment on this
We are the Party who brought in the Conditions of Employment Act, the Holidays with Pay Act, the Wet Time Act, who tackled the housing problem, who brought in children's allowances, who brought in widows' and orphans' pensions and we brought them in, sometimes against the open opposition of Deputy McGilligan, and always with the covert criticism of Deputy McGilligan and his Party, telling us, as they will tell us to-day, that we were piling burdens on the community which the community could not bear. That was the line they used to take when they did not like to criticise the social objectives which we had in view. They used to come around with their complaints year after year about the cost of our social schemes in the Volume of Estimates.
Deputy McGilligan had the audacity to talk about the legacy which the Coalition Government bequeathed to us in 1957 and he said that he did not understand where £9,000,000 had gone to. Here is the position of the Budget of 1957. According to the Book of Estimates and other things, the expenditure for all services, not capital, amounted to £126.18 millions. That included the debt charges on the Marshall Loan, the £40,000,000 borrowed from America during a time when ex-Deputy MacBride had tacitly superseded Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance. I believe he had the strong support of the then Taoiseach, the present Leader of the Opposition.
Comment on this
There was a meeting between ex-Deputy MacBride and the Taoiseach in regard to what was going to be done with the Marshall Loan Counterpart Fund. That meeting took place in the middle of the life of the first Coalition when Deputy McGilligan had a convenient illness. Deputy McGilligan was not there. He had a diplomatic illness.
Comment on this
Now, Deputy Costello knows pretty well what I am talking about. He remembers the day when he said—not in actual words——
Comment on this
Deputy Costello would not be as precise as I am going to be. He said: "Look boys; we have still £23,000,000 or £26,000,000 in the American Loan Counterpart Fund; what are we doing with it; let us spend it; we will have a jolly good time spending £26,000,000; wages will go up, trade will boom and when we go out, it will be our successors who will have to pay."
Comment on this
The Minister for Health is purporting to give as facts something which I say specifically has no relation whatever to facts. No such thing took place.
Comment on this
One of the items which had to be covered by the Estimates for 1957 was the debt charge, the annuity covering the interest charge and the repayment of the £40,000,000 odd borrowed from the United States under the Marshall Aid plan. £40,000,000 odd against which I challenge anybody from 1951 to 1954 to produce the corresponding asset or assets in this country. They may have bought a few items of plant, but the major part of that £40,000,000 was spent, as I explained to the House, over the years 1951 and 1952.
However, to get back to the general picture of the 1957 Budget, the estimated expenditure on all services, not capital, was taken in at £126.18 millions. We had not any control over that. These were the figures which were handed to us. We had not any opportunity of having a Vote on Account and discussing them. Deputy Costello, the then Taoiseach, made quite certain that we had not. He will recall, no doubt, that he dissolved Dáil Éireann before the Estimates Volume was put before us. He will recall that-apparently without reason— at least, no reason that he dare divulge —he rushed to the Park and had a general election in February or March of 1957. We came in again to office as a result and we were presented then with a Book of Estimates which, with the expenditure upon Central Fund and other services, meant that, some one way or another, the Minister for Finance had to find a sum of £126.18 millions. As against that, the revenue from all sources, tax and non-tax, came to only £117.11 millions, so that there was, on the figures as presented to us at the first glance, a deficit of £9.07 millions. That is not the whole story. Provision had to be made for the secondary teachers' award.
Now, Deputy McGilligan has been talking about the fact that the Coalition Government gave arbitration all round, that is to say, that they placed the public purse under the control of outsiders. That is what they did in relation to arbitration. It would be too uncomfortable a thing for Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance in a Coalition which comprised representatives of, say, the Civil Service—there was one, the Tánaiste in the second Coalition who happened to be general secretary of a large Civil Service organisation—to do his job. Other members of the Coalition Parties had been officers of Civil Service organisations. It would be too embarrassing for a Coalition Minister for Finance to carry his responsibility to the taxpayers and say: "I am sorry; we just cannot tax the people more to find the money." It would be too embarrassing for him to say: "No" to the Tánaiste, too embarrassing for him to say "No" to other members of the Labour Party who represent organisations of civil servants and of public officers. So what did they do? Instead of facing up to their responsibilities, they said: "We will have arbitration" and they handed over the control of the whole Civil Service remuneration to an outsider who was not even responsible to Dáil Éireann. They did that over a very wide field. That is what Deputy McGilligan has been boasting about here this evening—the fact that he could not as Minister for Finance face up to the responsibility which Parliament had imposed upon him.
One of the results of that situation was that when he was preparing his Budget in 1957, in addition to the £126.18 millions, the figure which was printed on paper, he had to find £500,000 for the secondary teachers' pay award. I am not saying that the £500,000 was not justifiable: what I am saying is that it did not appear as an item in the Volume of Estimates and that the Coalition Government had not taken any responsibility for it, that they were calmly passing the buck to their successors. Then there was a sum of £150,000 for wheat losses—losses incurred in disposing of wheat carried over by the Coalition, which otherwise could not be disposed of at a profit or could not be disposed of without loss. Then, of course, there was another £230,000 which was due on foot of a pledge which had been given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to a certain industry; and there was an allowance for Supplementary Estimates of £.951. These items together amounted to £1,830,000. Add that to the £9.07 millions and we get £11,000,000 of a deficit, a deficit which had to be covered by the Minister for Finance in the 1957 Budget. The fact that that deficit of £11,000,000 must have been foreseen in February of 1957 may perhaps be the explanation as to why the then Taoiseach, Deputy J.A. Costello, dissolved the Dáil in that year.
Comment on this
The Minister for Social Welfare made the statement he has just made, more explicitly and in a manner likely to cause greater misrepresentation than he dares to indulge in now, on the debate on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. I answered that misrepresentation at that time. I repeat once more that the Minister's suggestion is entirely without foundation and utterly false.
Comment on this
That is all very well. It is all very well for the Deputy to say that he answered me in the course of the debate on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. Why did he not answer me during the general election in 1957?
Comment on this
No, the Deputy did not, and the proof that the Deputy was not able to answer is the fact that he was subsequently translated to that side of the House.
Comment on this
I shall answer the Minister again and I shall most specifically give him the lie when I intervene in this debate. If the Minister repeats his misrepresentations, I shall repeat my answer to them again and again.
Comment on this
The Deputy may give me the lie. He may do anything he likes, but will he give to the people a rational explanation, one which any person of common sense or intelligence can accept, as to why he dissolved the Dáil in February, 1957. when he had a safe and secure overall majority and had not been up to then even three years in office? I am saying that, prima facie, there is one explanation. It is a likely explanation. It seems justifiable.
Comment on this
Is it? Now, the Leader of the Opposition says it is entirely untrue. What is untrue?
Comment on this
Does the Leader of the Opposition deny that there was a possible deficit of £11,000,000 upon the Budget of 1957?
Comment on this
That is not the charge. The charge the Minister is trying to make against me is that which he stated specifically during the course of the debate on the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. The charge was that I advised the President to dissolve Dáil Éireann because I was afraid to face the implications of the Estimates. That was a lie and it is that lie the Minister is now trying to repeat here.
Comment on this
Wait now! If the Leader of the Opposition is saying that he did not advise the President to dissolve the Dáil because he was afraid, I am not going to start arguing as to what was the psychological——
Comment on this
Will the Minister withdraw the misrepresentation that he has made at least three times?
Comment on this
Oh, no. I am not going to argue as to what was the psychological condition of the then Taoiseach when he asked for the dissolution. If he tells me that, far from being afraid, he was full of courage, I am prepared to accept that. I am quite prepared to accept that, but what I am intrigued about is why, in the ordinary normal way, the Leader of the Opposition, when he was Taoiseach in 1957, did not wait until after the financial business of the year had been put before Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
That was alleged against us, but, at least, in the year 1954, when our position was certainly difficult in Dáil Éireann, we did publish the Book of Estimates and let the people see what State expenditure would be for the year 1954-55. We did have a debate on the Vote on Account, in which the Opposition had a full field of misrepresentation to range over. We did bring in a Budget in June, 1954, and the people had an opportunity of seeing for themselves what their fate was to be. Why did the second Coalition not pursue that course? I do not know what internal difficulties there may have been; I have heard the Coalition was not always a happy family—I have heard that—but, whatever the reason was, there was no justification that would appear to any person of common sense for dissolving the Dáil in February of 1957 and keeping the people in the dark as to what the real financial position of the country was.
Now, we inherited that situation. We inherited a budgetary deficit of almost £11,000,000. We had two successive heavy deficits in our balance of payments—one in 1955 and one in 1956. In addition, unemployment was running at a rate that had not been attained for over 20 years previously. Deputy McGilligan talked here to-day and he mentioned a figure of 100,000 people on the live unemployment register when we were in office. That situation had not developed at any time when we were in office. People did register in substantial numbers for employment in 1933 and 1934 when we made it quite clear that certain useful works would be carried out where the unemployment situation seemed to warrant them. People accordingly registered for employment in the hope that, by doing so, they would get useful works done in their area for their community without cost to themselves.
In January, 1957, the actual number on the unemployment register was 94,600 persons, all but the 100,000 Deputy McGilligan talked about. It fell to 92,600 in February, and to-day the number is far below that. On 20th February, the number on the total live register was 70,806—a reduction of almost 30 per cent. on the figure which Deputy McGilligan left behind him.
Comment on this
I have already dealt with emigration in the absence of the Deputy, and I have been talking for a long time.
Comment on this
It is now admitted, so far as emigration is concerned, that the figure is considerably reduced. I shall not give the proportion, but it is considerably reduced. The figure for emigration during the year 1958 was considerably below the figures for 1957 and 1956 and 1955.
Let us see what has happened since the change of Government. There has been a considerable improvement in the economic position of the country. Productive activity has gone up, no matter what indicator you look at. Electricity sales have mounted very considerably. The average sales per month in 1956 were 137.53 kilowatt hours. They were 142.66 kilowatt hours in 1957 and went up to 154.82 kilowatt hours in 1958. Those are the figures of the monthly output from the generating stations of the E.S.B. That is a very substantial increase, but it is merely an indicator of the increase in productive activity which has taken place in this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy had better have a look at the figures and he will find that rural electrification is a very small part of them. The reason we have to subsidise rural electrification so heavily is the fact that whereas it costs a lot of money to provide a supply in the rural areas the consumption there is relatively very small indeed.
The average daily figures for the bank debits in 1957 was £7.09 million. In 1958, it was £7.63 million. The weekly clearances in Dublin banks were £27.2 million in 1957; in 1958, £30.57 million. In relation to the external trade, in the year 1957, it was 267,000 tons net tonnage of departures with cargoes and in 1958, it was 330,000 tons. No matter what economic indicator you look at, you will find that the economic position has very considerably improved since we took office in 1957.
Comment on this
Yes, the success of the National Loan. Everything has improved. The rates at which our stocks are now being marketed indicate that public confidence has been restored. I have here the Financial Times for 13th February, 1959. No one can say that the Financial Times does not look rather objectively at this country and here is what it has to say. The heading is: “Ireland on the Turn” and the leading article begins:—
"The Irish economic scene looks considerably more promising now than it did a couple of years ago."
A couple of years ago was 1956-57 when the Coalition were last in office. It goes on:—
"The recovery in employment and business activity, therefore, imposed little or no strain on the reserves and appears to be continuing steadily."
It goes on to talk about the White Paper and says that the:—
"rate of national income growth is sufficiently realistic for the widespread optimism it has created to be well founded."
I have kept the House perhaps unduly. I do not wish to weary it. I did not intend to rise so soon. I hoped, as I said at the beginning, we would hear some expression of view from the Leader of the Labour Party or some authoritative speaker on his behalf. We have not heard from them and I have to content myself with dealing with the criticisms of the existing situation made by Deputy McGilligan. I have shown that these criticisms are hollow, unscrupulous and mendacious in the extreme.
Comment on this
On the other hand, I have read to the House the judgment of an impartial observer. I could give quotations from many other sources, but, as I say, I have detained the House too long. I want to say I feel, and most people agree that it was a very good thing for this country that Deputy Costello fled from the responsibilities of his office in February of 1957, when he called for a general election.
Comment on this
When I considered speaking in this debate, I did not think I would be called so early, so the Minister for Health can keep the sympathies he was expressing for Deputy Lynch for me. The Leader of the Labour Party intends to take part in this debate and intends to give the Labour reactions to the speech on this Vote on Account made by the Minister for Finance. Certain circumstances over which he had no control deprived him of the opportunity of giving the Minister for Health the advantage of hearing him. I do not know that that is a crime, but I am just stating that Deputy Norton intends to take part in the debate and to give his views. I am not nor is any other Deputy being put in as a substitute for him. Our views are the views we express as individual Deputies of a Party.
As I was saying, when I decided to speak, I debated with myself as to how I should open and it struck me that in the past ten years during which time I have been a member of Dáil Éireann, on the debates on Votes on Account, we had the experience of Deputies on both sides shifting the blame for all that befell the country in the past from the shoulders of one to the other. We had recriminations as to who started the civil war. We had denouncements of Ministers and ex-Ministers which did nothing but lead to confusion and doubt throughout the country and caused the public to distrust politicians as, undoubtedly, they have come to do at the present day.
The speech which the Minister for Health has just delivered has convinced me that that certainly was not the correct line, because in no way did he attempt to deal with the present economic position, with the future, and with what the year has in store for us. Rather, he went back to the Shannon scheme of 1924 and to the various other half-truths, half-lies, doubtful quotations and suggestions that something underhand was done by people who were previously in charge of the Government of the country. Surely, if he can get the people to believe that, the very same people will believe the same type of suggestion coming from this side of the House at the present day.