We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance.

Contributions 170–328 of 328. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I suggest that is a disservice to the country and, in the few words I propose to contribute to the debate, I shall not in any way attempt to follow that line, but I shall try to express either approval or disapproval of what, in fact, is proposed in this Vote on Account, and leave the past where I believe it should be left. Let us all look forward in the future to try to improve this country as we all want it to be improved. I listened to the Minister's opening speech very carefully. It struck me as cold, calculated and devoid of any promise or hopes. By means of the manipulation of figures, he sought to prove that £5,500,000 increased expenditure on the Estimates was, in fact, not an increase at all, but a decrease on the figure needed for 1958-1959.

Perhaps it is my inability to follow his reasoning, or the fact that when figures are read out, it is not so easy to follow them, but it has struck me that it must be pretty clear to everybody that, whether or not there is an increase or a decrease as compared with 1958-59, certainly had the food subsidies not been withdrawn, and had they to be included in the Estimate to allow for the subsidisation of the necessary foods of the people, the sum we are now being asked to vote would be considerably higher. In 1957, when the food subsidies were withdrawn those of us on the Labour Benches pointed out that it was likely the organised workers, the trade unions, would demand and would secure compensation from the various industries with which they were connected. As the members of the Dáil are aware, that has taken place, and practically 500,000 workers have secured, at the expense of private industry, the compensation necessary to make up for the withdrawal of the subsidies.

What did this mean in actual fact? It meant that private industry was being called upon to pay part of the money that had heretofore been provided out of Government funds, and I suggest that the consequent increase in the cost of exported articles is reflected in the fact that in the year just passed, notwithstanding the exhortations and pressure for an export drive, our exports are actually lower than in the previous year. The Minister, in announcing the various headings of the Vote, in pointing out the various increases, has made it clear that many of the increases are simply a reluctant repayment by the Government of the amount of money necessary to offset the increase in the cost of living, a repayment that was wrung from them by the various organisations representing Government employees. Nowhere could I find any hope, or any promise of dealing with what we must all admit is a serious economic position for the country, beyond the Minister's statement that the White Paper on economic policy was to be implemented.

While it is agreed that the White Paper is sound and could be made to bear fruit—something we would all like—the immediate indications, and the outlook for the year, seem to hinge upon the promise that a shipyard will be established at Haulbowline to provide for the building of ships in three or four years' time, and that an alteration in policy is taking place at Shannon Airport. The policy of catering for passenger traffic is now being altered to deal with freight, and to encourage that, provision is to be made so that a continuance of the employment given there will be assured. These two things seem to be complete and separate issues, but I suggest that there is a connection. If it is true that increased freight by airlift from the United States and other places is to be the order of the day, then it would indicate that a policy of improving our shipping to the extent of an expenditure of £5,000,000 on a shipyard is a shortsighted one.

The expenditure of a vast sum like £5,000,000 on shipbuilding can only be contemplated on a long-term policy that ships and shipbuilding will be in urgent demand for a long time to come. If that is so, then it is ridiculous to believe that we are justified in our increased expenditure at Shannon, in seeking to provide for increased freight by airlift. I believe that the improvements at Shannon are good and are essential, but I have grave doubts, though I wish it well, as to the wiseness of the course of devoting money to the development of shipbuilding in this country, at this late period in that traffic.

In the Estimates for 1959-60, no provision is being made for subvention to C.I.E. This follows upon the Transport Bill passed here some months ago. Under that Bill, the Government shed the responsibility of finding the money to keep that industry in being. They gave the green light to the manager of C.I.E. to discard the nonprofit making portions of the company's activities, irrespective of the effects on the workers employed in that industry. I suggest that if C.I.E. are deprived of what money is necessary to keep that industry on its feet, we can have no other result than a repetition of what has happened in the Dundalk Engineering Works, and that vast unemployment will follow in the years to come. That seems a poor outlook for the 70,000 unemployed people who have been awaiting the fulfilment of the promise of the Government that they would be put back to work.

If the Transport Act had not been passed some months ago, we would to-day have to find some figure of approximately £2,000,000 in the present Estimates and consequently we would have been asked to-day to pass an increased Vote on Account. Taking the abolition of the food subsidies and the withdrawal of the subsidies to C.I.E. into account and putting these at a figure of some £6,000,000, together with the £5,500,000 increase we have here, we find almost £12,000,000 more is being spent on government now compared with 1956. At the same time, emigration continues and an admitted 70,000 are unemployed.

It is amusing, were it not such a tragedy, to hear the Minister for Social Welfare passing over emigration with the simple statement that it has stopped because the people now have confidence in the Government. Replying to Deputy Lindsay, I think, he said: "I have dealt with emigration long ago. Everybody knows that emigration is now practically solved." I wonder did the Minister read the Cork Evening Echo of November 14th, 1958? The heading said “40,497 Irish Emigrants in Britain This Year.” Underneath it read:—

"Mr. Ernest Davies (Labour) asked the Minister for Pensions and National Insurance in the House of Commons what was the number of people arriving from the Irish Republic who applied for National Insurance cards for the first time during 1958 to the latest date available.

Miss Edith Pitt, Parliamentary Secretary, in a written reply said: In the period January 1st to October 31st, 1958, the number of people arriving from the Irish Republic who applied for National Insurance cards for the first time was 40,497."

In a period of ten months, 40,497 people who had never previously held an English insurance card left this country seeking employment and the Minister says: "The people have confidence in us: the people are not emigrating".

It is quite true that the Taoiseach announced that half of those who go come back. While admitting there was no reliable means of knowing the number who went, he was able to announce calmly that half of them returned. He must be living in a dream world; if he went anywhere through the country he would hear of emigration. His Ministers who do go through the country surely hear the people talking about the emigration that is taking place. In the little town in which I live, with a population of a little more than 5,000 people, in the past 12 months, some 400 workers left to seek employment in Britain, according to the figures kept by the trade union office there. In my own immediate neighbourhood, in the past four months, four families comprising over 23 people, man, wife and child, left that village.

Unemployment in country areas is worse now than it ever has been during my lifetime, even during the war years. Whatever juggling is done with figures and whatever way the Live Register compares with 1957, the answer is not more employment. If that were the answer, would we not be told that the records of the Social Welfare Department proved, by the issue of insurance cards, that there were now more people employed than in the previous year? When these figures were sought and obtained some six months ago, they showed that, instead of an improvement there was, as we knew, a steady decline in the number of people in insurable employment in the past year. If there is a reduction in the register of unemployed, it is only because the English people can say that never before were there so many seeking employment in Britain.

While the trade unionists and Civil Service associations and various organisations representing workers or employees in private enterprise industry, in the Government or in local government are able to fight their battles, we must not forget that there is a large group of people known as the social welfare class, the old, the widowed, the sick and the unemployed, who must depend on the bounty of the Government and on the provision made by the Government for their future welfare. In his speech to-day, the Minister did not mention that group. There is no indication of any improvement in the compensation of 1/- which they were offered in 1957 to meet the increased cost of living caused by the withdrawal of the food subsidies. Even if at the time the food subsidies were withdrawn that compensation was adequate —which it was not—the mere fact that organised workers throughout the State had to secure, and did secure, increased remuneration—which was also passed on in increased cost of living which this social welfare class had to meet again—proves that it is not adequate now.

It was amusing to hear the Minister for Health set out the advantages given by his Government to the workers of this country and talk of the love borne by his Party for those who are employed here. He spoke of the Conditions of Employment Act, the Wet Time Act, widows' and orphans' pensions and children's allowances. He did not remember that many of these concessions were given because at the time they were given there was a Labour group in this House being courted by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Never.

Comment on this

He did not mention that there was another Act in 1942, an Act known by the workers as the Standstill Wages Act. When that Act was passed, it became unlawful for a worker——

Comment on this

You did not criticise it at the time it was going through.

Comment on this

Every trade unionist in this country criticised the Standstill Wages Act when the Government made it illegal for an employer to give an increase to his workers, while, at the same time, they permitted share-holders——

Comment on this

We did not permit it.

Comment on this

Yes, you did. You permitted shareholders to get increased dividends by shutting your eyes to the dummy companies formed throughout the country. You were well aware of it.

Comment on this

We were not aware of it. Make your speech without falsification.

Comment on this

You criticised the Minister for Health for going back on past history.

Comment on this

I am going back to the Act which he forgot to tell us about. I am not going to allow the Minister for Health to tell me, or to tell the people of this country, that a Fianna Fáil Government have more thought for the workers than the Labour Party or anybody else in this House.

Comment on this

He is entitled to say it.

Comment on this

He is entitled to say it, but it is my duty to contradict it. The only thing the workers have been offered this year, outside of the two instances I have given, is a proposal by the Government to give the people of this country the right to abolish P.R.; in other words, to take part in an election by which they may be induced to deprive themselves of the facility of sending representatives to this Dáil. It is a useful smokescreen.

Comment on this

It is not in the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

No, but the cost of it is, unless you intend not to have it.

Comment on this

We cannot put it in yet.

Comment on this

I am worse to be replying back. I am suggesting that the proposition to abolish P.R. may be looked upon in two ways, first, as a smokescreen to divert the people's attention from the failure of the Government to keep their election promises, and, secondly, as an effort by the Government to put themselves in a position in which they will be secure in government for the next five years. Through this House, I appeal to the workers of this country, when they get the opportunity, be it in May or June——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely that has been discussed in extenso.

Comment on this

I am appealing to the workers, when that day comes, not to forget the Minister's speech to-day in which he put forward no solution for the problems of emigration, unemployment or the cost of living.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present.

Comment on this

The Book of Estimates which has just been published shows an increase of £4,482,000 in the Estimates for the coming year, as compared with 1958-59. I should like to draw attention to the fact that, of this increase, no less than £2,687,000 is applicable to capital services. If we examine the heads of the capital services responsible for the increase, we find that they are almost exclusively devoted to productive investment. The principal items involved are: £150,000 for resort development and grants towards the provision of additional bedrooms in hotels; £545,000 for the development of Shannon and Dublin Airports; £50,000 to assist the development of industries in the West of Ireland; over £2,000,000 for agriculture; £150,000 for fisheries and £62,000 for forestry.

These figures which I have been giving are the amounts by which the various productive capital outlays will be increased during the coming year. We find therefore that the amount of the increase in the Estimates which is attributable to current expenditure, as distinct from productive capital investment, is less than £2,000,000. Indeed, if the Supplementary Estimates which went through during the year 1958-59 were added to the original 1958-59 Estimates, there would in fact be no increase at all foreshadowed for the coming year. The increases on the current side are in the main attributable to unavoidable—indeed, justifiable—increases in the remuneration of State servants. I think the Minister and his entire Civil Service is to be congratulated on the efforts they have made in these Estimates. In the preparation of the Book of Estimates, they have been careful, obviously, to prune all uneconomic and wasteful expenditure to the bone. They have seen to it that the Estimates are as economical as they can be, consistent with keeping up the policy of the Government in relation to productive investment.

Comment on this

What about the Local Authorities (Works) Act? The Deputy does not mean that that is productive investment?

Comment on this

No, I do not.

Comment on this

That is interesting to hear.

Comment on this

My straight answer is—I do not. I believe it was wasteful expenditure in the main.

Comment on this

I do not withdraw anything. I mean that. The Deputy is not trapping me into saying anything.

Comment on this

And the Government backs the Deputy, I presume.

Comment on this

I believe that the Minister and the Civil Service are to be congratulated on the relentless manner in which they have pursued efficiency and modernisation in the entire administration during the past year. I have no doubt that the Estimates as put before us would have been much more inflated, if it were not for their successful efforts in that direction.

I said here last week that, in my opinion, the situation in this country had improved—I think the phrase I used was "things in general are 50 times better than they were in the winter of 1956". What I said, of course, was twisted by the Opposition into meaning something different. I was referring to the change which has come about in the country generally since the Fianna Fáil Government assumed office. There is no doubt whatever about it. Anyone examining the situation must honestly admit that there is a complete change of mind and heart. The despair and the despondency which were so rife in the winter of 1956 have gone and a new mood of optimism has taken their place. One does not hear any more of a lack of belief in the future of the country.

Comment on this

I wonder if that is because Fianna Fáil are not in Opposition to say it?

Comment on this

Factories are being opened and projects are been started now, whereas in 1956 they were closing down. When I was referring to the state of things being so much better, I was referring mainly to that change of mind, to that change of mentality, the replacing of despair by optimism. However, there are also some facts and figures which I can quote to show that that new feeling is based on a foundation of reality.

For instance, the statistics show clearly that, on the last Saturday of December, 1956, the figure for persons unemployed on the Live Register was 84,093. On the same date, the last Saturday of December, 1958, that figure was down to 70,302. Admittedly, I must be the first to confess that 70,000 people is still a very high number of unemployed persons, but the point I want to make is that the trend is downwards from 84,000 down to 70,000.

The national income, for the first time in the history of this country, dropped in 1956. It was £461,000,000 in 1955, and in 1956 it dropped to £457,000,000. It rose again in 1957 up to £477,000,000 and this year it will be substantially in excess of that figure. Again, the figure go to show that out of the bottom of the trough into which we had descended in 1956 the trend is continually upwards.

Revenue figures are also a good guide to the prosperity or otherwise of an economy. In the period from the 1st April, 1957, to the 22nd February, 1958, the revenue into the Exchequer was £109.7 million. In the same period in the current financial year, that is, from last April, 1958, to the 21st February, 1959, at the same rate of taxes, the revenue into the Exchequer was £113,000,000. There we have one of the best indicators of the prosperity of the economy, namely, a buoyancy in revenue.

Generally speaking, over the whole financial scene the picture is the same. Take deposits in the Post Office Savings Bank. At the 31st December, 1956, they were £84.9 million. At the corresponding date in 1958, they were £91.2 million. The figures for savings certificates also show an increase. At the 31st March, 1956, they were £23.8 million and at the same date in 1958 they were £27.1 million.

Probably the most important statistics in the national life to-day are the figures which show the trend of foreign trade and our balance of payments position. Here again, there has been a consistent improvement since Fianna Fáil assumed office. In 1957, for the first time for a long period, the balance of payments showed a surplus; and in 1958, the year just passed, the reliable estimates are that, while there may not be a surplus, the balance of payments will almost certainly be in a state of equilibrium. When one thinks of the dreadful prospects facing us in 1955 and 1956, the recovery in that very short time in this particular direction is little short of miraculous.

Exports for the period January to November, 1956, were £94.9 million. For the same 11 months in 1958, they were £116.2 million—again a heartening and cheering indication of the manner in which the economy has recovered and improved since that time. As a result of the favourable development in our exports and in our balance of payments position, the external assets of the banking system over the last three years have gone as follows: 31st December, 1956, £180,000,000; 31st December, 1957, increased to £189,000,000; 31st December, 1958, a further increase to £192,000,000. There is no one on this side of the House who would set the target of an increase in the external assets of the banking system alone as one of the overall objectives of economic policy and the real significance of these figures is that the downward trend in our external resources to a dangerous level has been arrested and they have, in fact, now been built up again to a reasonably safe one.

Bank deposits between January, 1957, and December, 1958, increased by 10 per cent. Between the same dates bank advances increased by 22½ per cent. In the last two years the banks lending rates have been reduced on five different occasions. The significance of these factors is that they have brought about a radically different approach in banking policy; and Irish banks, with their faith now restored, as everybody else's faith has been restored, in the future of the country have adopted a new approach to financing farming and agricultural activities and, as we have seen in the newspaper announcements, very definite and very specific credit schemes are now being organised by the banks to aid agricultural production.

During 1958 also we had the experience, the absence of which was such a disquieting feature in 1956, of successful public flotations. The E.S.B. floated a loan for £5,000,000 and the Minister for Finance floated a loan for £15,000,000. Both of these were over-subscribed. That is an excellent indication of the stability and prosperity of the economy.

There is, as I said, a completely new feeling abroad, a feeling of optimism, and a belief that things are once again moving towards progress and towards prosperity. It is not very useful for Deputy Kyne to begin his speech by stating he will be constructive and blaming the Minister for Health because he was not constructive and then going on to make a speech in which not one constructive suggestion was put forward. I listened carefully to the Deputy. The only thing he did, in fact, was to throw some doubt on the desirability of some of the progressive expansionist schemes which Fianna Fáil have embarked upon.

Among the things that have gone to contribute towards this new feeling of hope, enthusiasm and optimism throughout the country are the imaginative proposals for the expansion of the Haulbowline Steel Mills, the Cork shipyards and the proposed nitrogenous fertiliser factory in the Midlands. During 1958, 38 new major enterprises were started. There are 12 more new enterprises scheduled to start within the next few weeks involving a capital expenditure of approximately £2,000,000. That is a picture of an economy successfully restored to prosperity. On all sides, new ventures are being started, new activities being commenced and new projects being embarked upon.

Deputy T. Lynch, for some extraordinary reason that I could not understand, said that since Fianna Fáil assumed office there has not been one single piece of legislation which would help us to overcome our problems of unemployment and emigration. That statement is so utterly farcical and so utterly nonsensical that it is to me quite extraordinary that even he would make it. In the short lifetime of the present Government to date there has been a whole host of measures expressly designed to promote the conditions necessary for the expansion of production and the provision of employment. The Government have, at the same time, positively assisted in the setting up of many new ventures and projects.

The capital of the Industrial Credit Company has been substantially increased by legislation and funds have been placed at the disposal of that company to the extent that the Minister for Finance is able to say here, for the first time in the history of the House, that no worthwhile industrial project need now be held up because of lack of capital. Surely, that is an important and significant development and sufficient in itself to rebut what Deputy Lynch said, if anybody were foolish enough to take him seriously.

The Minister for Finance has, since coming into office, been concerned to do all that he can to achieve an overall condition in which an expansion of production and employment can take place. He has put through this House imaginative and original proposals giving tax incentives to industry to expand and develop. The Industrial Development (Encouragement of External Investment) Act was passed with the specific object of facilitating the importation of foreign capital, foreign skills and foreign know-how. We have joined the World Bank and the International Finance Corporation. With the issue of Exchequer Bills for the first time and by adding to the functions of the Central Bank we have laid the foundations of an Irish money market. In the last few weeks Bills have been introduced here to increase the capital and resources of Irish Shipping and Bord na Móna. Legislation has been passed to bring about a completely new pattern of industrial development in Shannon Airport. The air companies—Aerlínte and Aer Lingus—have been encouraged to expand their activities across the Atlantic and into the Continent of Europe. With all that activity, how can Deputy Lynch say that nothing is being done to tackle the fundamental problems of unemployment and emigration?

With regard to my proposition that the atmosphere generally is so much healthier to-day as compared with 1956, I am sure nobody will accuse the Central Bank of being in any degree partial to Fianna Fáil. Neither, I am sure, could anybody say that the Central Bank would be guilty of wilfully giving Fianna Fáil any ammunition to use in these debates. I shall quote therefore from this unbiassed source, from the Quarterly Statistical Bulletin in which, having discussed the position generally, the Central Bank says:—

"The economy is, however, more soundly based and less vulnerable so that better progress is likely in the near future if continued restraint is shown both in the private sector and in the sphere of current Government outlays. The present situation should encourage greater optimism on the part of private enterprise in general, especially as regards carrying out schemes for the extension of production or the reduction of costs."

That type of statement issued by a completely impartial institution can be multiplied from the many other journals and the many writers who have discussed this situation recently.

I maintain that the Minister for Finance has directed all his efforts and has been at great pains to introduce the necessary legislation to create favourable financial and economic conditions for the development of our economy and these measures have achieved very considerable success. They have culminated in the publication of the White Paper on economic expansion. That to my mind is certainly the most significant and important document that has been published in this country, for the past 20 years.

In this connection I had hoped that in this debate the discussion would be kept away from the rather pathetic note on which Deputy McGilligan started and that we could get down to constructive discussion of the White Paper and all that is outlined in it and in the Estimates and that possibly helpful suggestions would be made to the Government in relation to them. In so far as the Book of Estimates which we have before us is carefully prepared and clearly indicates the determination of the Government to pursue vigorously a programme for economic expansion as outlined in the White Paper, we should have no hesitation whatever in approving of this Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I do not think that Deputy Haughey has been entirely just and fair to Deputy Kyne. I must compliment Deputy Kyne on his opening remarks. He said we should get away from the desire of one side to find fault with the other for whatever was done in the past. I admire his approach to the debate. His contribution was reasonable and not emotional in any way and he should get credit for that. I hope his words will have some effect on the proceedings of the House.

I cannot share the optimism of the last speaker. The greatest criterion for judging the social conditions of this country is to be found in the views of those who are members of sick poor societies such as the St. Vincent de Paul Society. I am near enough to Cork City to know many members of these societies who work so gratuitously and unselfishly. Recently one of them, a man of great standing— I do not know what his political views are—told me that never before were they faced with such difficulties and such frustration in their efforts to get money for the needs they are called upon to supply. Is that a good sign that all is well with the country? Personally, I do not think it is.

I was pained to hear the remark of the Minister for Health when he was winding up, when he said it was a good thing for the country that Deputy Costello had fled. That is a very unworthy remark and I am sorry the Minister finished on that note. I hold no brief for Deputy Costello, any more than I do for anybody else, but I have admiration for him in that he demonstrated to the Irish people and to the world at large that Irishmen in Irish Parties could agree to differ. When he came here to lead the Irish people, he undertook a major task and no one in this House made such a monetary sacrifice as he made in taking the office of Taoiseach which he had never ambitioned. As Head of the Government from 1948 to 1951, he did a good job. I believe he would have achieved the same success in 1956, were it not for the unfortunate position that arose then.

Deputy Haughey talked about our balance of payments being righted. It was well on the road to being righted when Deputy Costello left office and it was righted at the cost of a great sacrifice to the Irish people. It is very unfair to castigate the ex-Taoiseach for his efforts to save the trading position, the balance of payment position. I should be very slow to castigate the Taoiseach for anything he did and we should all, as Deputy Kyne said, leave the past behind us and face the issues now confronting the nation.

We all realise the position is anything but good. We all realise that our national concept of territorial freedom has changed considerably in recent years. We now know, saddened by experiences, that there is no such thing as economic independence. That is why we see the great nations of the world coming together in order to establish for themselves some form of economic security and independence. We in this little island have very little hope of competing with the world at large to-day, except on the basis of a united effort of all our people. There would be some hope if we could get rid of Partition in the morning and work as a united nation for the development and advancement of our people.

I come now to the Book of Estimates. The Irish people are very disturbed since they read in Saturday's daily papers what the Government contemplate spending in the coming 12 months. I have no doubt that a great part of the expenditure is inevitable and quite justifiable, but there is quite a percentage of it that one finds very hard to explain or give excuses for. One thing that strikes anybody, from a casual perusal of the Book of Estimates, is the extraordinarily high percentage of the Estimates that go towards public administration. I am sure that is why the Estimates appear so large at the moment.

There is not very much comfort to be gained by the Irish people in perusing this Book of Estimates. We had thought that the experience gained during 1956 would have given future Governments to understand that they should be very prudent about public expenditure and that they should be very careful so that, in case the same difficulties arose, they would be in a position to meet those difficulties by the imposition of certain tariffs on imports here as was done in 1956. That is not so obviously possible now, should a situation similar to that of 1956 arise again.

The Book of Estimates is not complete in so far as there is nothing in it to show that we must also provide £20,000,000 for the Central Fund services for the coming 12 months and nothing to show that we must also provide approximately £21,000,000 in rates for the coming 12 months. Combining all these, a simple calculation will bring the conclusion that this country contemplates spending a total of approximately £157,000,000—an overall £54 expenditure per head of the population.

I think we should not be very happy about that position, no matter on which side of the House we sit. At the moment, local authorities are feverishly working on their estimates, trying to bring in estimates that will be generally accepted and, as Deputy McGilligan pointed out this afternoon, in the case of most of those authorities that have already made decisions and have already completed their estimates, there is a general increase, a sharp increase, in very many instances.

Who would have thought, 37 years ago, that we here, with our own native Government and our own native Parliament, would have to face a bill of such major proportions as £157,000,000? The extraordinary thing that strikes me is how patiently people have endured this down through the years, but will their patience last? Will there come a day of reckoning when they will assert themselves and say that this cannot go on, that there must be an end to all unproductive investment in this country? The position is all the more staggering when we find we have such a number of unemployed here at the moment and, talking about the unemployed, it is no harm to say that there is never any record of all those who come out of our universities, our secondary schools and our vocational schools, fit and ready and equipped to take up jobs. There is no record of those, and they never come into the unemployment figures, until they have already worked in some form of insurable employment.

We have this high emigration running at a rate of 50,000 a year, accepting the figures generally given by economists and statisticians. These people have left the country in despair. They see very little hope for employment here, and in the past few months, it has been my sad experience to find that I never before was approached by so many, asking me to try to help them to get some job here. I am sure that has been the experience of many other Deputies also. As long as that position lasts, we cannot sit back and say all is well in this State.

If we could have cut the rate of emigration by one-half during the past three years, we would have no butter surplus, and no butter problem. Our trade and business would be from 5 per cent. to 10 per cent. better than it is to-day, and no one can estimate what value the labour and talents of these people would be to this country, if their services had been retained here. Unfortunately for us all, it is impossble for us to retain them in our present condition.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated here after the last general election, in March, 1957—I read it in the public papers—that the coming five years would be the test as to whether we would survive as an economic entity. Two of those five years have already passed, and I think the challenge is as formidable to-day as it was five years ago. In the competitive world around us, we will find it all the more difficult to face up to realities, or to realise a nationally secure position and, unless we get to grips with realities, have an eye to fundamentals, cut out all waste and try to put our savings into development that will revive employment in this country, I think our chances of survival are very small.

These Estimates are singular in the fact that in the 66 items listed in the tabular form included in the Book of Estimates, only ten decreases are shown. All the rest are increases.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Manley will appreciate that the Estimates are not before the House. What is before the House is the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir.

Comment on this

But surely, Sir, some of the Estimates are before the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

None of the Estimates is before the House.

Comment on this

But the whole Bill and the background to the Bill are before the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Vote on Account before the House is a grant of supply to the Government until such time as the Estimates are passed by the House. Detailed discussion on the Estimates would not be relevant.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy Manley was pointing out that the overall picture presented by the Minister for Finance showed a decrease in about ten items, and an increase in the remaining items. I submit that any Deputy is entitled to make the point that the Minister is presenting a bigger bill to the House than last year, and to give his reasons as to why he thinks that is the position.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to point out how the bill is greater this year than last year, but to refer to the Estimates is not in order. There is nothing before the House but a token Vote, a Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I do not understand the ruling.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has always been the ruling.

Comment on this

I do not understand it in the terms in which the Chair is now putting it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I put it several times to the Deputy and I thought I made it very clear. The fact is there are no Estimates before the House and the Estimates cannot be discussed.

Comment on this

I am not claiming that an attempt is being made to discuss the Estimates.

Comment on this

We were presented with a document by the Government which states "Estimates 1959-60—Vote on Account—an Estimate showing the several services for which a Vote on Account is required for the year ending 31st March, 1960, totalling £38,000,000", and it lists 66 items under which the Government are seeking funds by means of the Vote on Account. I suggest to the Chair that any Deputy who desires to discuss this matter may discuss what is before the House, that is the 66 items.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would point out to the Deputy that it has never been the practice to discuss items on the Vote on Account. They cannot be gone down, one by one.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting detailed discussion.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may refer to them in toto but he cannot discuss any Estimate singly. That would not be in order.

Comment on this

Surely it is in order for a Deputy to point out where the Government are reducing and where they are increasing Estimates, under the different headings?

Comment on this

The Minister himself demonstrated that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have not objected to Deputy Manley pointing that out to the House. My fear is that the Deputy may go on to discuss various Estimates in detail.

Comment on this

Surely the Chair cannot rule in anticipation.

Comment on this

I have no intention of ignoring the ruling of the Chair, and I had no intention of going into the Estimates in detail. I wanted to point out that the decreases were really negligible, with the exception of the withdrawal of the grant to C.I.E., because, by legislation, C.I.E. is now compelled to stand on its own feet. I have mentioned that and I suppose I may leave it there. That is the material side of the picture as I see it, but what do we find around us throughout the country to-day? Our whole social system is changing rapidly and I think that all the disappointments, frustrations and disillusionment of former years, with the loss of faith in Government and in parliamentary institutions, has brought about a spirit of recklessness.

We find to-day a complete disregard for private property, a complete disregards for owners' rights with regard to their property, and damage to property is becoming an everyday occurrence in many parts of the country. We find that those principles we all cherished, the high principles of integrity and honesty, are all going by the board, and that is due to the political confusion, political despair and political disappointment that has arisen over the years. I do not know what will happen in the future. I cannot share the optimism either of the Minister or of Deputy Haughey. I feel that this nation is living, to use the common jargon, from hand to mouth.

It is a good thing to see that foreign capital is coming in here and that men of enterprise are coming here to start industries, but let us be careful that we have not a national sell-out of our people. Deputy Haughey has spoken about our banking deposits. They have increased, but how is it when our own people with capital and means have not confidence enough to invest their capital in this country, we have to go abroad to secure that capital? We assert, on the one hand, that we have the capital at home in our banks and yet we go abroad seeking capital. That is a question I cannot answer. It is a question I pose for people more familiar with economic development than I. I had more hope some years ago than I have now. I sympathise with the public who have to face this bill, because, in the last analysis, it is the people who foot this bill, and it is no consolation or encouragement to them to find themselves faced at this stage with such a formidable bill.

Comment on this

I was rather shocked, listening to Deputy Manley, whom I look up to as a very decent, honourable man. I have been very shocked by the speech he has made. If he spent a week trying to write out a defeatist speech and misrepresent the situation, he could not have done better. I do not believe there is any disregard for law or order. The same petty crimes have happened before from time to time. The police force are doing their job and the citizens respect the law. I live in an area, two-thirds of which is within the city boundary, and I find the people are law-abiding and there is no evidence of lawlessness.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This would be a matter for another Vote.

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

This Vote on Account gives great encouragement to the people and to public representatives. Fianna Fáil has again established confidence in the country and I would remind Deputy Manley that whatever loss of confidence there may be in public representatives is due to the actions of the Deputy's Party and the inter-Party group as a whole.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has nothing to do with the Vote on Account.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this
Mr. Burke

I was just replying to statements made by Deputy Manley and if the Chair rules me out of order, I shall have to make a new approach. If Deputy Manley or any other Deputy were making a constructive contribution to this debate, I would be a most attentive listener, but while I admire him as an honourable man, I must say that he made no constructive proposal or suggestion. He criticised everything in a general way—"Everybody was out of step only our Johnny". That was his attitude.

The people will now listen only to honest statements. They have been hoodwinked too often by false promises of certain politicians who said there was a short cut to prosperity, if Fianna Fáil were put out. We went through that phase and we now find the only way to prosperity is the hard way that other nations have tried and found successful through the centuries. We must produce for our own needs and get an export market for the surplus. We had no suggestions from the Opposition on these lines. The great countries of the world who have become prosperous succeeded in doing so because they produced first for their own needs, cut down imports of goods they could make themselves and then developed an export market. Fianna Fáil are gradually following that plan by every means in their power. We have established confidence and credit in contrast to the situation in 1957 when people were told that there would be money for everything but found it was not there when they wanted it for certain projects.

To-day anybody who is creditworthy and wishes to start an industry which is a bona fide proposition has credit available through the Agricultural Credit Corporation and the Industrial Credit Company. People wanting to get into the export market are helped in every possible way. I want to appeal to industrialists who have enjoyed protection from native Governments and who had an opportunity of going into the export market and have failed to take it, to do their duty, so far as the State is concerned.

We cannot get full employment merely by talking about it. We hope that the industrialists who have been protected here over the years will respond to the advice and the encouragement given to them. We are helping the industrialists to get into the export market and we hope they will appreciate that. It is disappointing that some of our industrialists are not as good in that regard as they ought to be. It is a disgrace to the people of this country that the people of the neighbouring island should be ahead of us in the export of a commodity in which we should lead, that is, the export of whiskey.

We will have to get down to these problems. If there is an article coming in here that could be produced at home, we should produce it here. Fianna Fáil have always realised that, but now we have reached the time when we must compete with other nations in the export market in order to provide employment for our people. There is no other way to do it.

A number of the people at present in our schools and colleges will have to go abroad until such time as our economy is improved. It should be part of their education that when they go abroad, they will be good ambassadors of this country and buy Irish products abroad. By educating the people in our colleges and universities in that way, we would help the various export organisations which are trying to sell our goods in foreign markets. I know our people are going. We have no cure for that state of affairs except to get into the export market, or else find gold or minerals in this country. We have to accept the situation as it is and to educate our people going abroad so that they will be good ambassadors against the time when they or their children will be able to come back.

I am confident that our country is going well; I am confident that we have established economic and political stability. I hope that when the Minister for Finance comes in here next year, he will be able to report still further improvement in our economic position. We are going ahead slowly but surely. We in Fianna Fáil have nothing to fear from the people of Ireland because we are doing our job.

Comment on this

We all know that every year around this time there is considerable speculation as to the outcome of the Minister's work in compiling the Estimates. There is that speculation year after year and it usually results in disappointment. We have the optimists who expect that the Government will be able to reduce expenditure and the pessimists who shake their heads and say that the Estimates will inevitably increase. We have a third category of people who hope that things will at least remain as they have been.

This year, we have again an increase in the estimated expenditure which this House must provide for the various services. We have only to recall the widespread protests which have appeared in the daily papers and which have been heard amongst the people to realise that there is a grave spirit of discontent throughout the country at the ever-increasing cost of the public services. That does not apply only to Government expenditure; it applies also to the finances of local authorities.

The lot of the Minister for Finance and of the local councillors is not a happy one, because, on the one hand, you have people clamouring for increased services and on the other hand, they expect and demand a reduction in expenditure. The trouble is that it is very difficult to reconcile these two expressions on the part of the people. It is because I acknowledge the difficulty for any Government in meeting the demands of the people for increased services and, at the same time, for reduced expenditure that I approach this Vote with a sympathetic attitude.

We find, in the Book of Estimates, 66 items to be disposed of, and we see that the overall expenditure is increased by approximately £5,000,000 as compared with the current year. Included in the total estimate of £115,000,000 is £14,500,000 to be met by borrowing for capital works. It would not be too bad if we could say to ourselves that that £115,000,000 is the maximum which this Government will spend in 1959-60. However, we must remember that there is an additional estimate to be made of the amount required for the larger capital projects undertaken from year to year to the value of between £20,000,000 and £30,000,000.

The Book of Estimates now before us shows the result of the Government's efforts to fulfil the promises which they made during the election campaign. I do not think the Government can pride itself on the results as we see them to-day.

I should like to make a very brief analysis of some of the Estimates in general. I find that, of the 66 various Votes, there are ten which show a reduction. That is to be commended, that is very good. There are three which are maintained at the present level. Again, that is good. Unfortunately, the picture is discoloured very much by the fact that the remaining Estimates, 53 in number, have increased, some of them very considerably, but, I agree, some of them unavoidably. In the case of those Estimates which have been reduced, the reduction amounted to £2,288,100. The increased value of those which were increased amounts to over £6,000,000, practically £7,000,000. That leaves a net increase of almost £5,000,000 on the current year's Estimates.

Those figures show that the Government were very foolish, to say the least of it, when they made promises to the people at the last election that they would do this and that to reduce expenditure, reduce taxation and generally make this country into a Utopia. It shows that a Government is foolish to promise people, to dangle the carrot of prosperity before the people, in an endeavour to persuade them to cast their votes in favour of a particular Government.

In common with many other Deputies, I would urge the Minister that when he is providing capital moneys he should provide these moneys only for productive purposes. We have reached the position now, in this year 1959, when we cannot afford to do otherwise. We cannot afford to indulge in philanthropic enterprises for the benefit of the people, even though they may be worth-while, looking at them from the broad point of view, though in reality they are purely luxuries. Under Capital Services, we find a number of hospitals and sanatoria now becoming not obsolete but superfluous. We must admit that the cost of providing them was worth-while when we consider the great reduction in the incidence of T.B. I would urge the Minister to investigate every channel whereby these sanatoria and other superfluous public buildings might be utilised for productive purposes and not allowed to deteriorate through want of attention.

I have very little to say on this particular Vote, for the simple reason that each individual Estimate will be before us and I presume that it will be more relevant to go into detail on the individual Estimates. However, I must comment on the alarm and general disappointment at the present time amongst our people, at the annually recurring increased expenditure which must be provided. It is a mistake for any Government to take on themselves the credit primarily for the prosperity of a country. If they take on themselves credit for prosperity, they must likewise, in justice, accept the blame for any lack of prosperity. One cannot have it both ways. The various members of the present Government and their colleagues went about the country during the last election campaign, dangling the carrot before the people. I doubt very much if the carrot was accepted; it certainly was not eaten. The people realised and have come to appreciate that the promises made by succeeding Governments down the years are not to be taken seriously.

To my mind, it is the fluctuating fortunes of industry—and by industry I mean private industry—which determine whether a country is going to progress economically or not. It is not so much what a Government will do or can do—except I suppose in totalitarian States or States where dictatorships are the rule.

I am firmly convinced that there are three or four remedies for the present plight of the country. When I speak of the present plight of the country, I do not suggest for a moment that things are as bad as people sometimes suggest. They have been bad before and better before, and please God they will improve, but they will not improve unless there is greater co-operation, in the first instance, between people in authority and those under them. I would especially pinpoint the domain in which you find the employer on one hand and the worker on the other. Some of the difficulties are due to lack of co-operation between them. Another remedy would be increased production—that is an axiom, but I say it because increased production in recent years has been hampered and handicapped by a lack of trust amongst employers and workers.

What I want to refer to now may be a delicate matter, but I feel obliged to refer to it. It is the spate of strikes which we have experienced, particularly in the past year or two. I have not the figures for the number of industrial disputes for this year compared with previous years, but one knows that in recent weeks one cannot take up a newspaper without finding that some group or other has walked out and that there are strikes here and there, sometimes unofficial strikes. I feel that these unofficial strikes are not condemned strongly enough by those who should condemn them.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I feel that would be a matter for one of the Estimates.

Comment on this

Very well. I thought I would get it off my chest. Another remedy which might merit consideration is that we should cease trying to ape other countries, especially in regard to luxurious amenities and services. If there is a particular service which can be done without and which cannot be supplied by private enterprise, I do not think it is the duty of any Government to step in and supply the finance requisite to provide that amenity. As the Chair correctly observed, it would not be relevant to go into details of the various Estimates on this Vote on Account. As I said, it is unwise for any Party to promise the people that success will automatically follow, if they are elected as the Government of the country. No Government can make a country prosperous unless there is the will to prosper in the various sections of the community and unless the people are prepared to work harder, mentally and physically. It is only when the people generally accept that ideal that this country will prosper to its fullest degree.

Comment on this

The last speaker was the fourth speaker from the Opposition Benches. He was the first honest speaker on those benches to whom we have listened to-day. We have heard a good deal of criticism from most of the speakers without a single constructive suggestion. Certainly Deputy McGilligan made no constructive suggestion. He even produced the old cuttings from his pocket, cuttings that he has been using for years. Some of them are brown with age. He made the same speech as he has made on every occasion here, with the exception of the one he makes when the Coalition are in office.

Deputy Manley talked about frustration and the disillusionment from which the people are suffering because of the political acrobatics. If there is disillusionment and frustration, it is caused solely by those people who get up and condemn in toto any efforts made to improve things, without, at the same time, offering a single constructive alternative. The last speaker was an honest speaker. He said no Government can make a country prosperous without the co-operation and goodwill of the people. That is perfectly true.

The Vote on Account before the House contains certain important and significant proposals. It is possibly the most significant Vote on Account we have had in this House so far. It is criticised because it shows an increase. In the past, whenever the Vote on Account showed a decrease, there was criticism because of the reduction. That kind of approach creates more frustration and disillusionment than anything else.

The Estimates show an increase of £5,500,000. That increase is due mainly to the effort being made to implement the proposals contained in the White Paper, proposals which meet with the approval of every organised section of our community. What is the use of panic measures? We have had panic measures in the past, too many of them. We have had too many temporary measures to cure unemployment, measures dictated by nothing more than political expediency. We will never strengthen our economy or expand production, unless we have some sound plan to guide us, such as that adumbrated in the White Paper, towards which the increase in the Estimates is now mainly directed. We have had a good many years' experience of Government now and those on the other side of the House ought to be mature politicians by this time. They should have some mature experience in relation to economic development generally. Surely they are capable of making a better contribution to an important debate of this kind than using a string of superlatives to condemn and criticise, without making a single constructive suggestion.

I am quite pleased with the increase shown in the Estimates for the coming year. Anyone interested in the economy of the country could not be other than pleased. We either believe there is a remedy, or we do not. The proposals laid down in the White Paper outline the proper road to travel in the future. I do not claim to be an expert economist, but we have all of us had a certain amount of experience. We know what the facts are. We know what has succeeded in the past. We know what mistakes were made. We know that certain efforts failed. With all that to guide us, we should now be able to signpost the road to the future. It is only elementary economics that an expanding production, increased activity in industry and agriculture, increased exports generally, will strengthen our economy. Such expansion is absolutely essential if we are further to enhance the standard of living we now enjoy.

We have gone a long way in our programme of social development. Deputy Manley criticised the burden of rates in the different counties. Every Party, and every member of every Party, in this House has contributed towards that burden. No one can put the blame for it on someone else. The burden is largely due to the acceleration of our social development programme. I have heard Deputies here take credit for housing, hospitals, water supply schemes, and other amenities, all involving heavy borrowing by local authorities. It is in respect of that borrowing that we are now repaying both capital and interest charges. There is a huge indebtedness which has to be met out of local rates. On occasions, we try to reap political capital from the efforts which created that burden. We boast about the houses we have built, the vocational schools, the hospitals, and the public services generally which we have made available for our people. Now that we have to pay for them in the form of accumulated loan charges, we talk about the heavy burden the local rates have to meet—a burden weighing down the unfortunate people who pay rates.

The burden of local rates and taxation generally is a serious matter, but it is a question largely of an optimum, it is a question of striking a proper balance between two things. We are told that increased taxes and extra charges are pressing our people out of the country at the rate of 50,000 per year. If we had not these amenities, if we did not pursue the programme of social capital development which we have pursued in the past, it would be pointed out that people did not think it worth while living in a country which did not provide the fundamental social amenities and services. We have got to have them. We have got to keep reasonably well in line with many other countries and we are far behind them in our social amenities and services.

Something has got to be done now that we have reached a stage where we want to strengthen our national economy and increase our national income. We have shown a slight upward trend. We want that upward trend to continue, we want to strengthen our national economy and income to the extent that we can start a sound programme of social capital development—and that is really what we are doing in the Estimates this year. There are certain things which we know are productive of wealth that will also tend to increase employment activity in the country and these are the only things that create national prosperity. It is towards the expansion of those things that money is directed in the Estimates for this year.

Nobody in the House will deny that a good deal of useful and essential money is being canalised into agriculture in the Book of Estimates. Not merely are we retaining our position on the foreign market by an increase in our output from the land, both in live-stock and agricultural products generally, but also we have the bovine eradication scheme which everybody in the House appreciates is a "must" so far as the country is concerned. It accounts for £3,500,000. I shall not go into the Estimates in full, but it is no harm to pin point some of the matters that have caused the increase in the Estimates before us.

Tourism is productive of real wealth. Every possible effort to expand in that direction is being made. There are also forestry and fisheries and industry generally. I heard some Deputies making vague references about hunting abroad for foreign capital. We are not the only Government to do that. When the Coalition Government were in power, they excelled in their efforts to bring foreign capital in here.

Comment on this

This is not the first time it was done.

Comment on this

We are being criticised now for going out to invite foreign capital here.

Comment on this

No, for the advantages you are giving them over native capital. That is the criticism.

Comment on this

Nobody is given an advantage over anybody else. All the advantages are available for any concern going into the export business. Any industry which can improve its exports has the same facilities available to it. It ill becomes any Deputy opposite to talk about favouritism or disadvantages to home industrialists. We were a long time listening to the taunts of the Opposition that native industries were being spoon-fed and sheltered behind tariff walls, and we were told that they were incapable of competing with anything made on the foreign markets. That is one point on which we are all agreed and on which opposition has been dispelled. We are now being told that we are not giving them a fair advantage with outside investment from industrialists who manufacture in this country. That is quite untrue and we are all glad of any outside capital, for which every inducement will be given.

Comment on this

Do you remember when you said we were putting the country in pawn by doing that?

Comment on this

The country was put in pawn in a few different ways, but in relation to foreign capital here, nobody can quote a statement in which it was said that was putting the country in pawn. The use of money for these productive purposes is undoubtedly beneficial and that cannot be denied by anybody, and it is a step in the proper direction towards the ultimate development of our resources in the proper way. If anybody has a better plan, we have yet to hear it.

Deputy McGilligan deplored the rate of emigration as if it started only when this Government came into power two years ago. Towards the end of his speech, he made a reference to the open market for employment which is on our doorstep and the difficulty of keeping our people from seeking employment on that market. That was the difficulty really. In our economic development, we cannot at any stage hope, no matter how well we develop our economy, to compete with Britain in the matter of wages and living standards. We all know perfectly well that many people who had remunerative employment left the country and went to similar work abroad for almost twice the wages paid here. I should like to hear if the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party have any proposal for the solution of that problem. I do not say that everyone who goes away leaves a remunerative post behind, but I know, and each Deputy can point to many occasions, where there was decent employment available and people saw fit to leave it and go abroad. Who can blame them if they improve their position financially?

In addition to providing extra money for productive employment and for an expansion of production in the various fields of agriculture, tourism, fisheries and forestry, we have also in the Estimates this year a considerable increase in the amount of money available for education. That is completely in accord with the provisions enshrined in the White Paper proposals. It is definitely pointed out that increased production by improved methods and lower costs of production is more important in so far as they enable us to get into the export market on a competitive basis than is increased production as a result of incentives, subsidies or otherwise, and in that respect any extra money expended on improved agricultural education is of the greatest importance.

I did not hear anybody criticising these different items which have been increased and in fact if some of these items which account for an increase on the non-capital side of the Book of Estimates had not been granted, we would have had criticism from the other side of the House. That is the type of thing—criticism for the sake of criticism—that has led to the disillusionment and frustration in the country which members opposite have talked about. There has been no unity, no agreement or purpose, obvious in an important debate of this kind. There has been no Deputy on the opposite side getting up and saying: "I agree, in so far as those Estimates are implementing the sound proposals laid down in the White Paper on economic expansion, they are good." That is not being said by anybody but every Deputy on the other side of the House may agree with that and know it to be true, but he sets about explaining the "crippling burden" which Deputy Manley has said the people will shortly revolt against.

The last speaker said the Government cannot do everything to create prosperity, particularly in a country where private enterprise is the paramount factor in our industrial expansion and economy, but they can point the way to certain essential and desirable factors towards real economic expansion and, after that, they can only depend on the co-operation, as the last speaker said, the goodwill of the people, and their determination to make themselves prosperous, using the implements of prosperity placed at their disposal by the Government. That is a perfectly sound statement by the last speaker, and these Estimates now before the House cannot be denied by any speaker as other than a serious attempt—the first serious step forward —towards implementing the sound principles of that programme of economic expansion and, for that reason, I welcome them.

Comment on this

It is usual to regard the Vote on Account as an opportunity of discussing the Government's policy and its effect in general terms, rather than to deal with the Vote on Account as a kind of statistical exercise or analysis. It seems to me that the Deputies opposite are all travelling very much along the same lines. They are getting up, one after the other, to boast about the restoration of confidence in the country, to deplore the fact that they do not hear any constructive suggestions from the Opposition and to talk about the White Paper. As far as this question of confidence in the future of the country is concerned, I think that anyone in these benches can claim, with every justification, that if there is one man more than another in this country who has, day to day, preached both in Government and in Opposition, the necessity for people to have confidence in the country, in the financial structure of the country, and in the future, that man is Deputy J.A. Costello.

Deputy J.A. Costello did not merely talk about and appeal for confidence in this country and in its future when he was speaking from those benches as Taoiseach. He made the same speeches and the same appeals as an Opposition Deputy, both in the House and outside the House, and I certainly think that anyone speaking from the Fine Gael Benches behind him can be proud of the fact that, in Government and out of Government, he recognised the necessity for the people to have confidence in the future of the country, and he did that whether it suited him politically or not. The lead Deputy Costello has given to the people, the lead he has given in his appeals for confidence in the country, the lead he has given to the youth of the country in appealing to them to take an active interest in political affairs, in economic affairs, and in asking them to lend their support to building up the welfare of the country and the confidence of the people in the welfare of the country, is something on which we should compliment him, and something for which the members of the Fianna Fáil Party should be grateful.

If confidence has been restored, I certainly shall welcome it, but I shall deny that that has come about because of any change of Government, or that it has been achieved because of any worthwhile work that has been done by the Government since they came into office. I think it is fair to remind the Dáil, and the people of the country, that Fianna Fáil have been here in office for two years. A year ago, they were able to make the case that they had been in office only 12 months, and that they had not yet an opportunity of implementing their policy. They cannot make that case now. They have been there for two years and we are entitled to remind them, and the country, of the campaign carried on by the Fianna Fáil propagandists during and leading up to the general election of 1957. We are entitled to ask the people to place the Fianna Fáil propaganda, during and prior to the 1957 general election, side by side with the Fianna Fáil performance since 1957.

I do not think any Fianna Fáil Deputy will disagree with me if I say that the theme of Fianna Fáil propaganda right through the year 1956, and during the year 1957 up to the time of the general election, was that we had too much unemployment, that we had too much emigration, that prices were too high, that taxation was too high. The Fianna Fáil opposition to that state of affairs was all summed up in the notorious poster which they plastered around this country, during the general election campaign: "Beat the Crisis—Let's get Cracking", and the equally infamous poster which placarded every dead wall up and down the country: "Wives, Get Your Husbands Off to Work." Will any Fianna Fáil Deputy sit down now and compare the work of the Government which he is supporting, and set it side by side with all the propaganda we heard in 1956 and 1957?

What are the principal features of Fianna Fáil administration since their return to office in 1957?

Comment on this

We beat the crisis.

Comment on this

You beat the blazes out of the people in the Budget of 1957——

Comment on this

We beat the crisis.

Comment on this

——by removing the food subsidies. Remember, though there is an increase of £5,500,000 in this Book of Estimates, it does not contain a penny piece towards subsidising food for the people, because in the year 1957, at the expense of the breakfast table of every poor person, the Fianna Fáil Government saved £9,000,000 and, were it not for that action, there would be not an increase of £5,500,000 but an additional increase of £9,000,000.

Comment on this

If you were still in power, they would have no breakfast at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy O'Higgins should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

That was the first and principal task of the Fianna Fáil Government in their 1957 Budget. What was the next thing they did? We remember all the criticism about the levies which were imposed by Deputy Sweetman as Minister for Finance. We remember the ill-effects we were told those levies were having. We remember all the difficulties which encountered him as Minister for Finance and made it necessary for him to take those steps. That criticism was made.

The second feature of Fianna Fáil's financial policy since their return to office was to retain the levies and make them part and parcel of the permanent tax framework of the country. Food subsidies were withdrawn and the levies, netting something like £4,500,000 were retained, but instead of being merely a temporary financial device to meet a particular situation, they became part of the permanent tax framework.

The third main feature of the Fianna Fáil Government's actions since their return to office two years ago concerns what we have been doing for the past six months in this House. We have been discussing an electoral system. The final and crowning achievement of Fianna Fáil in their two years is their decision that it is better to do away with P.R. Will any Fianna Fáil Deputy disagree when I say those are the three main features of the Government since they came back to office?

"Wives, get your husbands back to work." What has been the impact of this Government on the unemployment situation? There has been some decrease, but is there a decrease to a degree which the people were entitled to expect, having regard to Fianna Fáil propaganda during the election campaign of 1957 and before it? Twelve months ago, Fianna Fáil might well have been excused, and I am sure did excuse themselves here and behind closed doors in their cumainn throughout the country, by saying they had not yet had a chance to prove themselves; that this poster: "Wives, get your husbands back to work" could not begin to work immediately and that while Fianna Fáil sought an opportunity to get cracking, they had to crank themselves up first. They have been cranking now for two years.

There is a slight decrease in unemployment figures. I have not figures for agricultural and industrial employment, but I clearly remember that as between 1956 and 1957—1956 having been painted as the black year by Fianna Fáil—there was a decrease of 24,000 in the figures, and I think they are estimated figures, for industrial and agricultural employment. I have not the latest figures and I do not know whether that situation has improved or continued to disimprove, but disregarding that entirely and keeping purely to figures for unemployment, is any Fianna Fáil Deputy satisfied he can be complacent about the work the Government have done, this Government with an overall majority in the House in a position to pass any legislation they like, to implement any plan they like to put through the House as legislation? In that situation, are any members of Fianna Fáil satisfied with the slight decrease in unemployment figures? Are they satisfied with it remembering that it is not after 12 months but after two years in which there was no Party or combination of Parties here that could vote down this Government? They had every opportunity of implementing whatever proposals they like and their best effort has been a decrease of some thousands in the unemployment figure.

Are Fianna Fáil satisfied with the emigration position? Figures quoted here indicate a rate of about 50,000 a year. There is some unemployment in Britain at present and there has been for some time past. That is bound to affect emigration because if people cannot go from here and get work easily in England, the odds are they will prefer to be unemployed at home rather than abroad. I believe there is some slight improvement in the emigration figures, but can any Fianna Fáil Deputy be satisfied that after two years, with an overall majority, they have given all the people were entitled to expect from Fianna Fáil propaganda during the last election? Will any Fianna Fáil Deputy now listening deny that the Government were elected to do precisely those things, to end unemployment and emigration, or at least after having spent half their normal span in office, to have made a greater impression than they have made?

If any Deputy doubts that is what they were elected for, I would remind him of what the Minister for Defence said here on 15th May, 1957, speaking. I think, in the Budget debate as reported at columns 1283-1284 of the Dáil Debates of that day:—

"In my opinion, and in the opinion of any fair-minded person who even now goes back and looks over the speeches made in the election campaign, it is beyond all doubt that we were put in here as a Government to take the necessary steps to remedy the situation of mass unemployment and emigration brought about by the previous Government. It is useless for the Opposition now to try to pretend that the action we have taken has come as a shock to the people. The people definitely realised that it was necessary to take decisive and tough action and it was because Fianna Fáil were the only Party who could be trusted to do this that we were put back into office."

The tough action was taken, but what has been the effect, so far as unemployment and emigration goes? Has a decrease of a few thousand in unemployment put an end to what was described as "mass unemployment and emigration"?

What is the Government's record where prices are concerned? We remember the campaign prior to 1957 regarding prices. I shall not bother giving quotations unless Deputies opposite want them. Any of those Deputies who are sufficiently interested and active to follow their own propaganda know precisely the type of campaign that was started when the inter-Party Government were in office. What price decreases have since taken place? The cost of living has gone up; bread has gone up, butter has gone up and the prices of other commodities have increased and not accidentally or by chance, but they have been increased by deliberate positive action by the Government. That is the Government's record on prices.

They are talking about the restoration of confidence. I hope the people have confidence in their country, but how many members of Fianna Fáil had a thought for the necessity of restoring confidence prior to 1957? How many of them, speaking from these benches appealed, when Deputy J.A. Costello appealed, to the people to have confidence in the country? How many of them, in the tough and difficult year of 1956, appealed to the people to support the steps which the Government were taking at the time, steps which a Fianna Fáil Minister has since admitted were reasonable, for the solving of the balance of payments problem?

We hear Deputy Haughey, Deputy Burke and Deputy Brennan talking about the restoration of confidence and we hear Deputy Haughey, in particular, referring to the balance of payments question and describing the recovery in a short time as being miraculous. Surely they know that that was not done by Fianna Fáil. Surely they know that it was due to the steps taken by the inter-Party Government and by Deputy Sweetman, as Minister for Finance, in that Government, with the support of every Deputy sitting behind him. If there has been a miraculous recovery in the balance of payments position, is it not due to the work done by the inter-Party Government? Would it not be just as well for Deputies opposite to concede that? There is no justice in their trying to take credit for it.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce has gone on record in this House as conceding the fact that the steps taken by the inter-Party Government remedied the balance of payments problem. Lest that be questioned, I quote from the Dáil Debates of 14th May, 1957, at column 1151, when he said:—

"I do not intend to criticise the previous Government for the action it took in relation to the balance of payments difficulties that arose last year. We have had our debates upon that in the past and it was the subject of much discussion during the course of the election campaign which brought this Dáil into being. Nobody denies that a problem had arisen there which was critical for the country and one with which the Government in office had to deal. It was dealt with by the Government of the day. I did not think they were dealing with it the right way, but we certainly recognised their obligation to do something about it and as a result of the measures they took that balance of payments problem was solved for the time being."

The balance of payments problem was solved by the steps taken by the Minister's predecessor and his colleagues in the inter-Party Government.

Some of the Deputies opposite seem to be critical of Deputy Manley's reference to the increase in the rates bill which must be added to the amount in these Estimates, if we are to take proper account of the financial position of the country and the extent to which taxation, direct or indirect, has been or is likely to be increased. It is only reasonable that we should remember that very often the legislation passed by this House has an effect, and a very big effect, on the amount of the local rates. Quite apart from some matters of social welfare which are made the direct responsibility of the ratepayers qua ratepayers rather than taxpayers, other types of legislation will have an indirect bearing on the rates and on increases in the rates which must be struck by local authorities.

It is well for us to remember that when the action of a Government results, as did the action of the Government in 1957, in forcing up the cost of living, it will have an effect on the rates throughout the country. When employees of local authorities have to get wage increases to offset the increase in the cost of living, when you have the cost of maintenance in institutions and institutional treatment under the health service being forced up by direct Government action, that will have an effect which will reflect itself in increased rates.

When you have the price of petrol forced up by 6d. a gallon, it is going to have an effect in a number of cases on the rates and on the machinery of local government. It is not at all unreasonable to take into account, in considering a matter of this sort, that the legislation passed here and the budgetary policy of the Government will have its effect on local authorities and on the rates which they must strike. I often feel that members of local authorities are unfairly criticised because of the rates which they have to strike. Very often, large portions of that rate have to be struck by them, whether they like it or not.

I spent ten years as a member of Dublin Corporation and I am fully conscious of the fact that there are many items which go to make up the ratepayers' bill that the corporation can do nothing about. We can do something about it in this House, if we do not pass the type of Budget introduced here in 1957. In addition to increasing the price of essential foodstuffs, it was part of that budgetary policy that the cost of the health services to the people should be increased.

I think it was Deputy Haughey who referred, as one of the marks of increased confidence, to the fact that the bank lending rates were reduced on a number of different occasions in the past two years. I do not mind Deputy Haughey, or any other Deputy, claiming that as a mark of confidence in the Government or in the future of the country, but let us be a little realistic about it. Is it not a fact that the bank rate here has been reduced following on reductions in the bank rate in England? I do not recollect any occasion, except during the inter-Party Government's term of office, when the decision taken by the Irish banks with regard to the bank rate differed from the decision taken by the English banks. I think it was only when the inter-Party Government came into office, pursuing a particular policy for the benefit of the people, that the decisions as between our banks and the British banks in relation to lending rates differed.

Comment on this

It has never been the same thing in both countries since we came in.

Comment on this

I am not saying that the amounts have been the same, but in the case of the increases or decreases, one has followed the other. The Minister can correct me on that, if I am wrong.

Comment on this

The pattern will be the same.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that the actual rate which obtained in the different countries has been the same.

Deputy Burke referred to the necessity to seek increased exports. No one will disagree with that. I do not think there is any fundamental difference in policy on the different sides of the House in that regard. However, what have the Government done in the past two years to find increased export markets or to find new markets? It must be remembered that it was during the period of office of the last inter-Party Government that the difficulties occasioned by the supplying of Argentine meat to England had their effect on the price of cattle and the export of cattle from Ireland. I believe that difficulty does not exist now; but Deputies from rural Ireland will be able to talk with more authority about it.

It was during the period of the inter-Party Government that the Suez crisis arose. That occasioned difficulties and unrest and also a lack of confidence— I am not quite sure that that is the correct description, but there was a general state of unrest which was occasioned by that crisis. That is over and done with; that is finished; there is nothing which need occasion the Government any embarrassment there. In addition, the balance of payments problem has been solved for them by the steps which their predecessors took.

The Government have an opportunity now of getting down to the task of reducing expenditure and reducing taxation. I think I am correct in saying that, while the members of the Government were in opposition, one of them announced proudly from these benches that while in Government he and his colleagues had taken a definite Government decision that expenditure was not to go beyond a particular figure. I have forgotten the figure and the year. They have an opportunity now of looking up their old Government decision on that. They have an opportunity of giving the taxpayer some evidence that it is worth while giving a Government an over-all majority in this House.

Is there any reason why the taxpayer should believe that, from the record and performance of the Government? One must take into account particularly that the present Book of Estimates no longer carries a penny piece subsidy for essential foodstuffs. One must remember that the Government have saved themselves at the expense of the health services. One must remember that the Government have channelled into the ordinary taxation framework of the country the proceeds of the levies, or of a great number of the levies, which were imposed as temporary measures and temporary expedients by their predecessors. Having regard to those items being no longer reflected in the Book of Estimates, can the Government feel in any way complacent in their work of the past 12 months?

Would it not have been far better for the people, if the Government had spent the past six months planning how to economise, planning how to reduce taxation, planning how to give the people better Government, rather than that they should have spent the past six months planning how to wipe out Opposition Parties in this House and planning how to change the electoral system which has been in operation here for the past 36 or 40 years?

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

Each of us here specialises in particular matters which affect various sections of the community. I do not know too much about agriculture or other aspects of the national life, but I certainly have a good knowledge of the subjects of employment and unemployment. While I do not object to any rise in the amount of the Estimates, if it is for the purpose of industrial expansion or agricultural expansion, I have an idea that we could save as much as we are increasing the Estimate, if we tried to economise from the President down. It seems that the only people at whose expense we are economising are the unemployed—and perhaps the members of the Dáil here. Everyone is getting an increase. Perhaps they are entitled to it, but in very many cases they do not require it. There was a Supplementary Estimate for £1,000,000 here last week and, while I am not disputing their right to it, I would say that a good many of the recipients did not require the increase. I say that, from that class up to the President, we might be able to save £5,000,000 without adding £5,000,000 to the Estimates.

I notice that there is a big jump in the Estimates for the Army. I have a fairly good idea of matters of a military nature and I know what I am talking about, even though I may be learning in other respects. I believe we could save £1,000,000 in the case of the Army. Instead of that, there is an increase. We have no objection to increasing the Estimates and increasing the people's income, but we have no sympathy at all for the fellow on the very floor. We could just as well add another million or two to that five and give him something; or reverse the situation, economise, and give him something. While we are not ashamed to increase the Estimates, we seem to be barefaced in our attitude towards people who are at the very bottom of the ladder. Over a period of years, we granted them 1/-. We come along then and justify giving people who are employed an extra 10/-, as if one ate stones and the other required caviare. I suppose the reason is that those people are not organised. A small number, by organising and ganging-up, can do a lot of damage. That is why any organised body is always considered. With regard to the others, no matter how many there are, one will always be used against the other because they are not organised and they have no real strength. If they were organised, if they had proper leadership, they would be considered very favourably indeed. Unfortunately, one cannot organise those people and that is why advantage is taken of them.

With regard to employment and unemployment, my mind jumps back to a statement made by the Taoiseach —I referred to it some time ago—that this country should be capable of supporting 8,000,000 people. That appeared in the Irish Press in February, 1932. I can understand there were a lot of fancy notions then as to what we could do—fancy notions about bringing all our exiles home when we got our freedom, and all the rest of it. We were very amateur. We talked through our hats. This country is not an industrial country. We have no worth-while raw materials. We have many disadvantages. All that was not appreciated in the beginning. But, remembering that we are up against so many disadvantages, we really ought to model our way of life accordingly and should not live on an elaborate scale at one end of the ladder and give the fellow at the other end 1/- to compensate him for increases in the cost of living. Why not even up and down a bit?

As far as I can see, no matter what the Minister for Industry and Commerce does—I have a tremendous faith in his ability and I agree with everything he is doing—it is quite possible that he may only stave off a worsening condition of affairs, because, even if there is success, there will also be further unemployment because of mechanisation, automation and all that. The whole tendency now is to do everything without labour. The development of science will cause a worsening of the situation here. Why then are we not prepared to admit that we will always have a large number of unemployed here? Why do we not make up our minds that our aim will be to make life tolerable for them? Why do we not make up our minds that we will give them a certain amount on which to live—not too much, but sufficient to make life tolerable? We will have to put up with them. But, no. We want to keep them in a pauper state. Whether that is the decision with a view to forcing them across the water, I do not know. It appears to me it is. If they got another 10/- each, they might stay here; if they get only 10d. they will emigrate. Maybe, that is all part of the plan. It says very little for all our high hopes 25 years ago and the population of 8,000,000 which could stand on its own feet and defend itself. Have we changed now and do we believe in a skimpy little nation which will just get by with a minimum population? We seem to have changed our views a great deal. We seem to have surrendered our future and reached the conclusion that we should allow ourselves now to be wholly dependent on Britain's goodwill. Rather than independence, dependence seems to be our ambition now. I often wonder what would happen if Britain said to us: "Look: You wanted your independence. Now keep your unemployed." What would happen? I am pretty certain we might have a Labour Government, or some extreme Government.

Coming back to the Vote on Account, I notice there is £80,000 less for public assistance. Whether the recipients will get less this year or whether this reduction is due to the cuts made last year, I do not know. Last year, there was wholesale cutting of public assistance. Every applicant was put through the mill. Anyone earning a few "bob" was cut. On social services generally, £20,000 was saved by cuts in public assistance. The other day an old pensioner came to me. His wife was getting 15/- public assistance. She was cut. There were only the two of them in the home. The man was told: "You have two sons working." The sons are married, with families. This is the new approach: married sons and daughters, with families, not living with their parents, are expected to keep the old people. This is the new way of economising at the expense of those at the bottom of the ladder. I kicked up a row with the investigating officer, but I was told——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not go into details on this Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

I suppose I should deal with it in general, but I think most speakers have gone into a lot of detail.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think they have.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

I am not to go into details in dealing with the items?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is right.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

There is £2,000 less for emergency schemes. The whole key to these Estimates is to give less —certainly not more—to those who are in want. I do not see any great hope of any employment on a decent scale. We are told 1,000 or 2,000 more were absorbed into employment last year. At that rate, we will always have 70,000 or 75,000 unemployed.

We are told we should suggest what should be done. Our function is to criticise. It is the function of the fellow with the job, getting the money, to make the suggestions. I might have ideas as to what should be done, but I am not going to say what they are. If I were in power, I might do a lot of things; I might tread on people's toes, but at least I would tread on them. I would not tell them beforehand what I would do because they would never let me in. People in opposition can only criticise; they can never say what they will do until they get in.

Comment on this

I endorse the appeal made to Deputies by two speakers here to-day to refrain from going back over the past 25 years when dealing with this Vote on Account. I shall try in my contribution to be as precise and relevant as possible in my comments. The Book of Estimates shows on its face a sum of £115,547,070. In the course of the speeches made here this evening by members from the opposite benches, and particularly the Fine Gael benches, very strong criticisms were made, in the first place, as to the necessity for the increase in the figures as disclosed by the Book of Estimates. In the second place, quite a few speakers indirectly made the point that certain items of expenditure contained in the Book of Estimates need not be increased and still be efficiently discharged. During the various discussions over the past 12 months, we can all remember that on each and every occasion, in the course of their contributions, Deputies usually made the point that when a particular service was being discussed on certain measures of legislation which came forward for consideration, the Government were not going far enough in their endeavours to meet the requirements of the people.

I find it very difficult, indeed, to understand why speeches of that kind should be made in the House in one breath and then when we come to discuss the Book of Estimates, as we are doing this evening criticism should be offered in the opposite way. I, like every other Deputy of the Government Party who have given views, naturally regret that it should have been necessary for the Minister for Finance, in introducing his Book of Estimates, to show an increase. The total increase, in round figures, is approximately £4½ million of which £2½ million approximately represent capital services.

During the past week, we have dealt with a number of Supplementary Estimates. The discussions which took place arising out of those Supplementary Estimates are still very fresh in our minds. It is quite unnecessary, therefore, to go into all the increases in the Book of Estimates for the purposes of breaking them down. I respectfully suggest, Sir, that the main items have been broken down largely in the speeches that were made a couple of days ago.

I have listened with interest to speeches from the Opposition from time to time, making the case that by the deliberate action—that phrase "deliberate action" seems to be a stock phrase now—the Government removed the subsidies of £9,000,000 in the 1957 Budget and thereby put the cost of living soaring all over the country. The Government did not, I am sure, take that decision lightly. On more than one occasion, the Government have given an adequate explanation of the necessity for that move. I accept that explanation unreservedly. The Opposition would be well advised, if they propose to follow that line of action at least to try to indicate that it could have been avoided.

In the course of his speech here this evening, the Minister for Health told the House that when the Government came into office, they found a deficiency amounting, approximately, to £12,000,000. The Minister gave a complete breakdown of that deficit. It appears to me the fact that that deficiency existed at the time showed very clearly that the Government had no alternative except to close the deficiency by borrowing or economising in some other direction. They took the latter course.

Appeals have been made from responsible quarters—from Government quarters too—that a check should be put on the trend of spending. I accept the wisdom of these appeals and I only hope that sooner or later—the sooner the better—we shall arrive at the stage that a Minister charged with responsibility for the financial structure will have the necessary courage to say: "We have gone thus far and we should go no further." There is some strong feeling in that direction among the ordinary rank and file of the people. It is obvious that we have reached the ceiling in the matter of national expenditure. The day will come and, in my opinion, it will come very shortly, when very stringent measures will have to be taken to arrest any further proposed increase in our national expenditure.

I have before me a table of the details of the Estimates from the financial year 1954-55 to the current Estimates. I find on looking at the totals for the years to which I have referred that the expenditure has been increasing every year. It remained more or less the same for the two years 1957-58 and 1958-59. For the year 1954, I find that the amount was £104,975,706—nearly £105,000,000. I take it that was the Book of Estimates which was introduced by the Fianna Fáil Government before the general election of 1954. In 1957-58, the figure was approximately £111,500,000. That is an increase of £6,000,000 during that period of four years. Perhaps Deputies on the opposite benches could tell us when they are speaking at a later stage why it was necessary for them to bring about this increase when they had such an efficient and successful Government at the time.

In the course of a discussion on the Book of Estimates, I suppose it is to be expected that Deputies will travel rather widely. This is inevitable to some extent because a Deputy naturally picks out a number of subjects which he thinks he is reasonably competent to deal with. If he is not allowed to deal comprehensively, at this stage, with all the items he selects, a Deputy cannot help speaking generally.

There are about 12 headings in the Estimates for the coming financial year which account for the increase I have referred to of approximately £4,500,000. If you go into those items, in detail, you will have no hesitation in agreeing that these headings are of paramount importance to the economic life of the nation, and that it would be exceptionally unwise on the part of the Government, if they were not prepared to provide the necessary, additional money required under those headings.

The promises made by the Fianna Fáil Party prior to the 1957 general election have been referred to at length this evening by speakers from the opposite benches. They have referred to those promises in what I regard as an exaggerated way. It has been suggested by some of those speakers that the Government have now been long enough in power to be in a position to implement the promises made at that time. I was somewhat impressed by the contribution made by Deputy O'Higgins. I think his approach to this matter was a little more reasonable than many of his colleagues. He agreed that there was some appreciable improvement in the matter of unemployment and emigration. I think that is an honest and a more realistic approach to this matter.

I accept that Governments, irrespective of what Party they represent, have down the years made honest attempts to try to cure the twin problems of emigration and unemployment. After all, the people who constitute any Government here are all Irishmen, men of very high civic spirit. If it were not for that fact, they probably would not be representatives of a Party, or representatives of the people in this House. The difference between the methods of one Party and another is what distinguishes the Parties from each other.

I submit that the Fianna Fáil Party over the past 25 years, by and large, have made a very substantial contribution to the solution of the problems of emigration and unemployment. I also think that a great deal of disservice has been done to the nation as a whole by a certain amount of loose talk, particularly from people in responsible positions in connection with these problems. I appreciate that we have certain statistics here which guide us as regards the trend of unemployment, but I have always maintained that those statistics have been for many years outdated, and require to be overhauled.

The first time the real impact of unemployment was discovered was back in 1934. At that time the newly formed Fianna Fáil Government almost created a revolution in social legislation when they stated that, if the Government were unable to find work for those citizens who were unemployed, they should be entitled to some measure of unemployment assistance. That was a very big step to take at that time. Very few countries in Europe at that stage had committed themselves to such a liberal measure of assistance for unemployed. Prior to that the only statistics available were those of persons receiving and claiming unemployment benefit.

The scope of the social legislation that Fianna Fáil passed in 1933 was rather wide, and people all over the country queued up at the local exchanges for the purpose of making initial claims, and registering themselves as unemployed. It was more than a question of the possibility that once their unemployment was accepted, they would be in receipt of some benefit. Wisely, I think, it was indicated at that time that all employment schemes would be considered and, indeed, allocated on the basis of the unemployment content of particular areas.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I feel that a matter of detail of this kind should be reserved for the relevant Estimate, and should not be raised on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir; I accept your ruling. I shall try to speak generally. I was dealing with the question of unemployment because it was referred to in the House. I was trying to make the point that the live register, as we know it, is grossly exaggerated. I am not taking Party advantage when I make that claim because I submit that has been the position for many years. If you say, however, that my remarks tend to be too detailed in this connection, I have to pass on and reserve them for appropriate discussion in the future.

However, it is admitted that since the Government took office two years ago, the number of unemployed has been reduced from the very high figure of 92,000, at which it stood at that time, to approximately 70,000 at present. Opposition speakers, of course, have made the point that there is no real reduction; that in fact, there are more people unemployed to-day than there were when the Government took office. They make the case that, in the interim, we have lost a very substantial part of our population through emigration. Unfortunately, there are no reliable statistics to support or disprove that latter statement. I do wish that we could get down to brass tacks in this matter, and some time or other be able to evolve a system whereby the exact trend of emigration could be registered.

When I was discussing unemployment a few moments ago I went so far as to give credit to all Parties in their good intentions to try to cure that problem. I think it is a very grave problem and it is the duty of the Government of the time being to try to solve it. I suggest that this Government, and indeed the previous Governments, to a very great extent, have endeavoured to create the necessary state of affairs in this country at least to discourage emigration.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I was dealing with emigration and I indicated that it was one of the most difficult problems any Government can face. It will require a tremendous effort to secure an appreciable improvement in the situation in the foreseeable future. I feel this very great problem must eventually be tackled on lines somewhat similar to those used to tackle our defence problem during the emergency. There is not much point in Deputies making speeches about what has been happening as regards emigration in the past. We must accept that the rate of emigration has been far greater than any of us wish and that it is only by co-operative effort that we can cure the position. Among the unemployed is a very large proportion of persons who are unable to find work and who, through no fault of theirs, are unable to contribute the necessary effort to the national labour pool which is so vital for our economic advancement.

I have discussed the matter with various authorities. I feel that if we got down to it in some special way, we might succeed in making the people as a whole more conscious of the problem. I believe the people expect more help than can be forthcoming from any Government, no matter what Government are in power. The responsibility of a Government in this connection, I think, is to provide, so far as possible within their resources, schemes of employment of a productive nature thereby helping to absorb some unemployed. Businesses and similar organisations could help to bring about a gradual improvement. Individual employers, even though they may find it rather difficult to carry on their normal pattern of business, might be approached with some hope of success, with a view to getting them to expand employment in their own organisation. Many small businesses could, with a little extra effort and initiative on the part of the management provide some measure of extra employment. In an existing staff of 10 or 12, if even one other person could be squeezed in it would certainly mean some improvement, not so much in numbers which are important but in the co-operative spirit among the people generally. I make that suggestion for what it is worth. I hope that there is some means of bringing it to the notice of the people concerned and that it will lead to some success.

The unemployed include quite a large proportion of those who would emigrate, even if they got good remunerative employment at home. It is a gross exaggeration for anybody to say that all who emigrate do so of necessity. We know what happens in our own areas regarding emigration and if we trouble to do a little stocktaking, we find a proportion of those who go, particularly to England rather than to the United States or other countries, are not obliged to emigrate for economic reasons. There is some reason which is very difficult to get at. I have met various cases where persons of an age to take up employment here refuse to take up certain types of work, eventually emigrate and are glad to take up employment abroad without the prospects of advancement they could get at home.

A fair proportion—fortunately—of those who emigrate are anxious to return and do return and get work at home, and are all the better for the experience they get abroad. Higher rates of wages seem to attract our people. The amenities associated with employment abroad are in most cases more attractive than we can offer, even though our standard is pretty high and is advancing in recent years. I think it is necessary for public representatives, especially Deputies and members of local authorities to initiate a campaign on a national basis to inspire confidence regarding the prospects for those remaining in this country and instilling that confidence into the young men and women.

Most young people now reaching the employable age are rather cynical. In every clubroom and meeting place where the question of remaining in this country is discussed we find far too many people who should know better adopting the view that there are no prospects here and that they must go abroad. Our people are very impatient in that connection and are inclined to be rather credulous. Very often, they will accept an adverse opinion, while it seems to be very hard to get them to consider an opinion that is more honest and perhaps more realistic.

I rather feel that this House, irrespective of which side of it we may occupy, has a grave responsibility in this matter. I appeal to Deputies to adopt a more realistic approach than has been adopted in the past to the problems of emigration and unemployment. I am quite sure that the Government are fully alive to their responsibility in these matters, but no matter how a Government may handle them, if there is not that required degree of co-operation behind the Government, their efforts are generally nullified.

Comment on this

Deputy Moloney has said a rather significant thing in relation to this question of unemployment and emigration. He said that it was a serious matter and that he thought the only remedy was a getting together of all Parties such as we had on the question of defence during the emergency. He was referring to the setting up of the defence council at that time. That was a council of all Parties, an inter-Party or coalition council.

But what have the Deputy and his colleagues been doing in this House for the past three months? They have been trying to abolish the Parties who could create such a situation. That sort of co-operation is something to be desired by all of us, but for the past three months, Deputy Moloney and his leader have tried to persuade this House that there should be no such thing as co-operation or inter-Party spirit and that we should have merely one Party with a small constructive Opposition. Deputy Brennan, my colleague in this House from West Donegal, held up his hands in horror and said that all the Opposition was good for is destructive criticism. What does he want us to do?

Comment on this

Stop the destructive criticism.

Comment on this

And because we will not do that, you are taking steps to suppress us and to drive us out of this House. Is that not the idea behind the proposal to abolish P.R.?

Comment on this

Why are you afraid of it.

Comment on this

I do not think the people on this side of the House could ever be accused of being afraid of anything. The people were consulted on this matter before. The Taoiseach consulted them on it in 1937 when he explained to them the reason why he was retaining P.R. in the Constitution.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not discuss P.R. on this matter.

Comment on this

I am replying to a Deputy who put a sensible question to me.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not be lead astray.

Comment on this

If ever a Government had an opportunity of doing something for this country, the present Government have. Remember the circumstances in which they came into office. The Suez blitz had hit the country and ended prior to the Government taking up office. The Tánaiste said that while he did not agree with the steps taken by Deputy Sweetman, he admitted that these steps had affected the trend of the adverse balance of trade and had corrected it. He admitted that in this House.

Not only had we done that but we left them approximately £4,000,000 which we had collected on duties which were described as duties on unnecessary luxury goods. We had just initiated the Prize Bond Scheme which is now bringing in about £10,000,000 per annum. They had those moneys for capital development purposes and then, the first thing they did on coming into office was to slash the food subsidies which gave them another £9,000,000, so they had £23,000,000 available for capital development which their predecessors had not. What happened to that money? Where has it gone? We warned them that when they slashed the food subsidies, there would be another round of wage increases and that is what did happen, except that there were no increases for the poorer classes.

Deputy McGilligan to-day read out the rates being struck by local authorities. In my own county, the rate is almost 49/- in the £. What is the cause of that? Is it not the cost of upkeep of patients in mental hospitals, district hospitals and county homes? Where is this sum of £23,000,000 which we left for capital development? Where has it gone? We gave them £14,000,000 and they got another £9,000,000 from the food subsidies.

Deputy Moloney admitted that we still have a serious problem of unemployment. He said it was so serious that the people have grown cynical and that they have lost interest in the country. Can anybody blame them when the Taoiseach told them: "Return us to power with a strong majority and we will end unemployment". The people returned them with a strong majority and have they ended unemployment?

Comment on this

We reduced it substantially.

Comment on this

What do you mean by that? For this £23,000,000 that I have mentioned, you reduced it by approximately 10,000.

Comment on this

You flatter them.

Comment on this

We reduced it by 22,000.

Comment on this

We find that 10,000 migrants are returning here to draw unemployment benefit in this country. That is 10,000 out of the 50,000 who emigrate each year. Does the Deputy remember that as a result of the reciprocal arrangements entered into by Deputy Norton and the inter-Party Government, these 10,000 people are coming back here and drawing the benefit for the unemployment contributions which they paid while in Britain? The Deputies opposite forget that and they forget that it is a result of the agreement entered into by the inter-Party Government and Deputy Norton. They do not want to hear about these things.

Comment on this

Come to the important thing.

Comment on this

I am surprised at Deputy Moloney saying that it is not important that these people should be able to draw their benefits here. I take off my hat to Deputy Norton and the Government which entered into that agreement with Britain.

Comment on this

We are not trying to disparage it.

Comment on this

No, but you do not want to hear about it.

Comment on this

I am quite happy to hear it.

Comment on this

And your constituents are very happy to be able to draw it. It annoys me sometimes to hear Deputies boasting and bragging of our increased exports. What exports have increased? Is it our industrial exports? Unfortunately, I do not think we can claim that. Surely it is our agricultural and our agricultural exports only that have increased. Where have we got markets for these exports, but in Britain, and it is worth while remembering what Fianna Fáil said about those British markets for our agricultural exports.

Do Deputies remember what the Minister for External Affairs, said about the British market? He said he hoped it was gone for ever and that the ships crossing the Irish Sea would all go to the bottom, that one would not want a ship at all for handling our agricultural exports. Does the Deputy remember what he said about our calves, which in a few years' time, would be the products which we would export? He said we could slaughter them, exterminate them. Why? Suppose for a second we had taken the advice of Fianna Fáil in those days and supposing we had not the first inter-Party Government and supposing we had not the agreement entered into by Deputy Dillon with the British Government of that time, where would we be to-day? Where would those exports be of which Fianna Fáil are so proud to-day?

Remember that in 1948, when the first inter-Party Government came into office—I was not a member of that Government—they found fewer sheep, fewer cattle and fewer pigs here since the year of the Famine. Those are statistics supplied by the Department of Agriculture—fewer pigs, cattle and sheep in 1948 than there were from the year 1848. Supposing that trend had continued under the policy of Fianna Fáil, where would the exports of which we are all so proud to-day be? Remember that in 1955, exactly six years after the first inter-Party Government came into power, we had more cattle, sheep and pigs than we had since the time of the Famine— more in six years.

Comment on this

Our people were there for three of them.

Comment on this

We will give you credit for that. Fianna Fáil followed the policy of the inter-Party Government then, but if they had continued their destructive policy, where would we be now?

Comment on this

There was an increase in the price of milk by the Minister for Agriculture. That is what increased the exports.

Comment on this

The increase in the price of milk? The butter which we are selling to Britain? That is how exports have gone up? We are told our exports have been trebled in the past few years. Is it the butter we are selling to Britain?

Comment on this

The Deputy is misconstruing deliberately what I said.

Comment on this

One would not like to misconstrue what Deputy Davern says.

Comment on this

If the farmers had more cows, it would cease to be an uneconomic proposition.

Comment on this

But you cannot keep cows, if you have not calves. Calves come from cows. The Fianna Fáil policy was to destroy the calves. Where on earth would you get the cows?

Comment on this

The Minister increased the price by 1/- per gallon.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps the Deputy would reserve his remarks for the present.

Comment on this

Deputy Davern is interesting to listen to and if he would like to explain this, I would not like to interrupt him. He says: "If only we had the cows", and that the keeping of the cows was the policy of Fianna Fáil. But the slaughter of the calves was also the policy of Fianna Fáil and if we had not the calves, where were we to get the cows? That is something I cannot understand.

Again, we know that in 1955, we had more cattle, sheep and pigs than we had from the year 1848. Then, we could not all get up and boast and crow as we are doing to-day, that we have trebled the exports. Would Deputy Moloney think for a second what the situation would be to-day, if we had permitted the 1947 policy of Fianna Fáil to continue, if we had permitted the continuation of the policy of the Minister for External Affairs, the policy which he enunciated at that time, the slaughter of calves and the abolition of the market with Britain? If we had continued that policy, where would we be to-day? If we had followed the policy of the Tánaiste in the establishment of mushroom industries in the back streets of Dublin in lieu of this wonderful traditional agricultural industry of ours, where would we be to-day?

I heard Deputy Burke say a few moments ago: "Thank God, we have political stability now." Have we political stability now? If we have, why have we been here for the past three months, trying to introduce a new method of election to give us political stability? Why should they continue to say two things which do not agree? We have Deputy Haughey telling Deputy Sherwin that the people of Ballyfermot are 50 times better off to-day than they were in 1956—50 times better off. Perhaps some Deputies would like me to quote what Deputy Haughey said here last week. It is taken from the Dáil Debates of 25th February, Volume 173, column 89. Deputy Haughey was interrupted by Deputy Sherwin and Deputy Haughey said:—

"I can give him the simple straightforward answer that, in my experience, there is not in all these working-class houses on the perimeter of Dublin any suggestion either of destitution or hunger to which there is no solution——

Mr. Sherwin: There is, in Ballyfermot and Finglas. You will see them with their orange-boxes.

An Leas-Cheann Comhairle: Order! Deputy Sherwin should allow Deputy Haughey to speak without interruption.

Mr. Sherwin: He does not represent that side.

Mr. Haughey: I do not agree. To my knowledge, things in those areas now are at least about 50 times better than they were in the dreadful winter of 1956 when the stagnation and despair and unemployment which were rife in Dublin City at that time led practically everybody in the city to the point of almost throwing in the sponge. I can assure Deputy Dillon that, in fact, practically everybody who has considered the situation is agreed that the turning-point after that black winter of 1956 came with the 1957 Budget and that things have definitely and consistently improved since that time."

Comment on this

He told us to-day that the accent was on the "things"—that they were there.

Comment on this

I should like to hear Deputy Haughey speaking up there. He is very closely associated with the Tánaiste and knows what is going on. I should like him to make that speech on a Saturday night in Ballyfermot, or preferably on the night the locals draw the dole. I should like to hear his speech in Ballyfermot, saying that the people are 50 times better off than they were two years ago.

However, he goes further. There is a section about which he is a little worried—one particular section. That section is not the section which includes the person in receipt of unemployment assistance, the person in receipt of unemployment benefit, the poor widow in receipt of a widow's pension, whether contributory or noncontributory. It is not the old age pensioner; it is not the person in receipt of a disability allowance, it is not the person in receipt of outdoor relief. He is worried about one section, a section other than those. For those others, everything is grand; they are 50 times better off than they were two years ago. There is one section he is worried about and this is what he says about them:—

"My main reason for speaking is to appeal on behalf of a particular section of the community: I think this is the appropriate occasion. The Minister has very many claims being made upon him and very many appeals are submitted to him. He would need to have far greater resources at his disposal than he has if he were to meet them all. Nevertheless, it is only right that I should put forward the case of Civil Service pensioners. A considerable number of my constituents are in that category. They have great difficulty in making ends meet on the fixed pension on which they have to subsist."

Why? Because the cost of living has gone up, the food subsidies were slashed. Those poor unfortunate pensioners are entitled to increases, but no more so than the unfortunate recipients of unemployment assistance, outdoor relief, unemployment benefit or allowances in any of the other categories I have mentioned.

Really, I am sorry we have not got a gallery. It just shows the apathy there is in the country. I should like to have a gallery from Ballyfermot listening to Deputy Haughey. I should like to hear him make that speech some night in Ballyfermot, if possible on the night the dole is paid. I should like to hear him telling the people out there that they are doing so well. He might make it, too, out in Finglas and Donnycarney: he could tell the people in those areas that they are 50 times better off to-day. He could tell them that one section of the community is suffering, namely, the poor Civil Service pensioner.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not make any reference to the Public Gallery.

Comment on this

I see in this Vote on Account a sum of money for an exploratory fishing vessel. I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary is here. It is now intended to spend something in the neighbourhood of £25,000 on a fishing vessel.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I should like to point out to the Deputy that details of the Estimates are not for discussion on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I am not going into detail; I am merely mentioning the item.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Merely mentioning it is one thing. The item is not before the House for discussion.

Comment on this

I do not propose to debate the item at all—far from it. I have the greatest respect for you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, but I must point out that the Minister for Finance mentioned various items in his opening statement. In particular, he mentioned fisheries. I should like to tell the Parliamentary Secretary now that at one stage I could have got these vessels, free, gratis and for nothing. There is a type of fish around our coast known as the "winter herring". It is caught generally in the months of February and March and it is followed up again in the month of May.

Comment on this

Do any of them give themselves up?

Comment on this

In some places, they must, judging by the type of fisherman who tries to catch them.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy not agree all this would be more relevant on the Estimate?

Comment on this

I quite agree, but the Minister mentioned it in his introduction. I am merely pointing out that the item is unnecessary. We could have got this vessel, free, gratis and for nothing, were it not for the fact that the Parliamentary Secretary was so ignorant of the advantages to be gained that he refused a licence to the Dutch to come in here.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely, the Deputy will get a more relevant opportunity on which to raise this.

Comment on this

But I will not get a more relevant opportunity on which to tell the Parliamentary Secretary the blunders he made.

Comment on this

Why did the Deputy not get Deputy Dillon to agree to it? I had nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

I am glad Fianna Fáil are beginning to take an interest in fisheries. In the 16 years during which they had charge of fisheries, we could not get rid of any of our surplus fish. We were closing boatyards. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture, as he then was, closed a boatyard in my own county—the boatyard at Meevagh.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I shall have to close this debate on fisheries. All this will arise more relevantly on the Estimate.

Comment on this

It is a pity, but I bow to your ruling.

Comment on this

The Deputy's statement is not true, anyway. I closed no boatyard.

Comment on this

They do not like even the smell of fish.

Comment on this

Several Deputies referred to the famous White Paper. They told us that the increase in the Estimates is brought about because of the desire to implement what is in this famous White Paper. Have they forgotten the "Blueprint of Prosperity" published by the inter-Party Government and published in detail in the Fine Gael digest a few years ago. It would be an interesting exercise for them to read it now and compare it with this White Paper, about which we are hearing so much. Who prepared this White Paper? Is it not public knowledge that it was prepared by the Secretary of the Department of Finance? Is it not public knowledge that it was the inter-Party Government who made him Secretary of the Department of Finance? Is it not public knowledge that he was working on the Blueprint of Prosperity before ever the inter-Party Government went out of office? It is on that blueprint that this famous White Paper is based. There is only one item in the White Paper that did not appear in the blueprint published by the inter-Party Government. That is the £500,000 for Aer línte. Now, we wish Aer línte, and the Irish shamrock painted on it, all the luck in the world and we have no intention of criticising it, particularly at the opening of the tourist season. It would be unfair to say anything that might injure it. But, with that exception, there is nothing in the White Paper that did not appear in the blueprint.

As I said at the outset, this Government had £23,000,000 more than we ever had for capital development. Despite the fact that they have drawn that £23,000,000 for each of the two years in which they have been in office, they now want to increase the Estimates. They tell us the reason for that increase is that they are now, for once, on the right road to prosperity. This is the twentieth year in which the present Taoiseach has held office. It is only now they have found the right road to prosperity. I was very young in 1932, but I can remember the posters. We were supposed to be on the right road then. In every subsequent general election, we were supposed to be on the right road: "Housewives, get your husbands back to work. Vote Fianna Fáil." The husbands are back at work, but they are not back at work in this country. They are back at work in Britain. Contrast that position with the position that obtained when the first inter-Party Government were in office. The Minister went on the air and invited our people to come back from England to take up lucrative employment in the building trade. They came back and we were able to produce booklets showing the good work they were doing. That was all capital employment. Contrast it with the employment being given to-day.

For 16 consecutive years Fianna Fáil were in office. All they asked the country for were loans of £1,000,000 on a few occasions for capital development. What effort did they make to develop the capital resources of the State during all those years? None. Certainly I do not know of any. One has only got to look around one to see that pessimism that exists. Look at the Public Gallery. Is there any interest in what is going on. When the inter-Party Government were in office tickets for admission ran out week after week.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not refer to the Public Gallery.

Comment on this

Is it correct for a Deputy to describe the members of this House as clowns? Deputy Davern has just used that expression.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The expression should not be used by any Deputy in relation to another member, or to members, of this House.

Comment on this

It is an expression Deputy Davern has a habit of using. I think he should be asked to withdraw it.

Comment on this

Did Deputy O'Donnell not use the word "circus"?

Comment on this

That was used by Deputy Kitt.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary were awake, he would know who used it.

Comment on this

I did use the word, and I put the right honourable member for Waterford in the No. 1 category.

Comment on this

Is it a proper parliamentary expression?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have already ruled it is not a parliamentary expression. If it it has been used, it should be withdrawn. I did not hear Deputy Davern.

Comment on this

Deputy Davern used the expression.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has made a statement and the Chair can take no further action.

Comment on this

I have already referred to the fact that my colleague, Deputy Brennan, complained that we were not giving constructive opposition. He said another thing. He said that no Government could make this country prosperous, unless they had the will of the people. This country is not prosperous at the moment and I take it, therefore, that the Government have not the goodwill of the people. That is the logical outcome of my friend's statement. Between Deputy Brennan's complaint that we have not the will of the people, and Deputy Burke who says we have political stability, and Deputy Moloney who says we ought to get together, while the other two are trying to do away with P.R. at the same time, I really do not know what to make of it. They should get together and agree on some policy before coming in here.

I shall not detain the House further, but I sometimes remember a statement made at the general election in 1948. I remember it was made by some disgruntled supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party—they are not so plentiful to-day as they were then—who said of the ship of State: "The skipper is all right, but he has a bad crew." He has not added to the crew since. He has taken on a bit of ballast, a bit of deadweight, but instead of jettisoning the crew, he is now deserting the ship himself. He has an eye on the Park and he will leave the ship with what was described as "a damn bad crew".

Comment on this

If he can.

Comment on this

If he can. I think he is leaving the ship whether he goes to the Park or retires and I often wonder what will happen to the crew. Will there be another "Mutiny on the Bounty?" I hope there will be no grabbing of the loot, if there is a mutiny, but the skipper is leaving and with the crew that will be left, I cannot see much future for the country.

Comment on this

In introducing this Vote on Account, the Minister spoke in somewhat similar terms to those of his contribution this time last year. Deputies who had the patience to listen to the Minister expected that on this occasion he would utilise the opportunity at his disposal to give us an outline of what Government policy is with regard to the country—if there is any Government policy.

On this occasion last year, the criticism was that the Minister came in here and casually gave his statement, sat down and left the matter to the House. A number of Deputies criticised that attitude last year and suggested that it was unfair on the part of the Government and that it was treating the House with contempt. I had hoped that the criticism levelled last year would have impressed itself on the mind of the Minister and that we would, on this occasion, have had a more realistic approach by the Minister.

On these occasions, there is scope each year for Deputies to criticise, constructively or otherwise, Government policy or the policy that is in operation under the particular Government. The trouble at the moment is that so far as this Government are concerned—and they have now been in office for two years—it is impossible for any Deputy to see that their approach to the problems that confront them is different from the approach of the previous Government. So far as I can see, the old saying "The more they seem to change, the more they remain the same" is absolutely true of Government of this country, since a limited amount of freedom was achieved in 1922.

We have had, as Deputy O'Donnell said, 20 years of "de Valera" Government. We also had a Cumann na nGaedheal Government and we had inter-Party Government for six years. From the neutral point of view, from the point of view of persons who were not associated with the tragedy which split the country into the pro-Treaty and the anti-Treaty sides, it is impossible to discern any fundamental differences in the approach of either side of the House to our major problems. When Fianna Fáil are in office, the people in opposition suggest the Government are carrying out a policy which they put into operation, and when the inter-Party Government are in office Fianna Fáil sit back and say, if any good or allegedly good steps are being taken, the inter-Party are only carrying out a policy which they had in mind.

That type of carry-on and criticism has gone on in this House since I came into it in 1948. The speeches made, including my own, are the same speeches we have heard since 1948. It would save a lot of time if the speeches which are to be made for the rest of the debate on this Vote on Account were put on long-playing records and let Deputies go home, because it really amounts to this: what is said in this House does not count for as much as a snap of my fingers. The power and the control in this country now lie outside this House.

Deputies on both sides are beginning to realise that, and if that control is ever to come back to the House, there are a lot of toes to be trodden on, and if those toes are not trodden on, and if these vested interests which have their spear-heads inside the House and their listening posts in both Chambers, are not treated in the manner in which they should be treated, then it is good-bye to the limited freedom which this country has at the moment.

I do not intend to speak at any great length when I resume the debate in the morning because I am feeling very depressed and disillusioned. I do not think that in their position, Deputies should give the impression to the rest of the community by their own speeches that they are beginning to lose hope, because, if we as members of this House lose hope, then so far as the general public are concerned the situation is far more serious.

Comment on this