We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—Tairiscint (atogáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Motion (resumed).

Contributions 1–189 of 356. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958
Defeated

No. 25 of 1958 ›

Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

If the two-Party system does not develop within a very short time, if this proposal is adopted by the people, I think the likely consequences for this country are very grave indeed. I think the likely consequences are also appreciated by the Government Party because, if, in fact, the new system is in operation at the next general election, or the one after, and there are not just two candidates but three or four candidates contesting a one-seat constituency, who is likely to gain by such a situation but the Fianna Fáil Party? It seems to me that unless there are formed either electoral pacts of one sort or another, or a new Opposition Party of some sort or another, the Government are likely to be the gainers. Looking into the future with regard to these matters, it seems to me that one of the distinct possibilities in this proposed change— if it is accepted—is that we shall have a number of Parliaments in this House with a very strong Government Party in office and with a very small Party or Parties in opposition.

These things have developed in other countries, and we have seen what happens in other countries when parliaments are not representative of the people. We have seen what happens when parliaments are dominated by one Party, where the Opposition is a truncated one and enfeebled by electoral defects. I do not think I exaggerate when I say one of the possibilities of this change, if it is adopted by the people, will be a grave weakening of our whole system of parliamentary democracy. One further likely danger is that there may be violent swings if such a system is operated here, swings which will give representation to people unsuited to government, unqualified to govern, with ideas that are ill-thought out, swings which will result in a very dangerous situation developing here.

I think that the dangers which we anticipate are real. It is possible that they may not be realised; it is possible our apprehensions may prove false, but I do not think it is worth while taking the chance that that may be so. I do not think it is worth while taking the chance that what has happened in other countries may not happen here and, in consequence, I do not think this decision, brought about from a political judgment on the part of the Government, is justified.

As I have said, the Government have made this proposal for the abolition of proportional representation because of their dislike of the coalition Governments which have been formed in this country. They are taking what has been described as a leap in the dark, which is fraught with danger for the country and for our whole system of parliamentary democracy. I believe they are taking this leap in the dark for unjustifiable and unjustified reasons and I feel, as I said at the outset, that we are justified in saying that this was not a decision taken by the Fianna Fáil Party.

This was not a decision which was imposed on the Taoiseach by the back-benchers of his Party. It was a decision taken by the leader of the Government in the knowledge that he would shortly be leaving active Irish politics. I am satisfied that the Taoiseach, in that regard, thinks he is actting correctly, but I believe he is wrong. No man should take upon himself the responsibility of doing what the Taoiseach is proposing to do, and I think he is wrong in getting his own Party to agree to amend the Constitution in this manner, in view of the very grave difficulties which are to be anticipated.

Government spokesmen have chided us about being afraid of the people. We are afraid of the people if they are not told exactly what is involved. Unfortunately, we on this side of the House have not got the weapons which are available to the Government Party in their daily newspapers, and in their Sunday paper. It is our task, as parliamentarians working an Irish democracy through this Parliament, to inform the people of what is involved in these proposals, and that is what we have been endeavouring to do. If, in fact, the people decide against this proposal, as I am hopeful they will on June 17th, it will not be because the Parties on this side of the House have been trying to do something undemocratic in keeping this legislation from the people, but, on the contrary, because they have fulfilled their democratic duty of educating the people, through Parliament, in what is involved, and seeing that something which may involve very great danger for this State is not accepted by them through their lack of knowledge of the real issues at stake.

Comment on this

I should like at the outset to refer to some of the allegations made by Government Deputies that because we are opposing the abolition of P.R. we are denying the rights of the people. The Fianna Fáil Government are in the position that they are the only Party in the Twenty-Six Counties in favour of abolishing P.R. The Opposition and other people outside this House, including the United Trade Union Congress, are opposed to it. The United Trade Union Congress has passed a resolution protesting against the proposed abolition of P.R. Now we have the Government speakers repeating their master's voice throughout the country. They do not mention the Belfast Government; they merely say: "We want a straight vote; we want stability."

During the last election I heard a Deputy make a similar statement in my constituency: "We want a strong Government; give Dev a majority so that he will be able to put his plans into operation." I say that the whole scheme of the Taoiseach is a red herring to take the people's minds from the problems which face the country at present. It is brought forward to distract the minds of housewives from the nightmare of trying to make ends meet because of the high cost of living and to take people's minds away from the huge wave of unemployment and emigration.

Not one word has been mentioned about any of these three important matters in the speeches of the Fianna Fáil Deputies but, as I say, they are only repeating their master's voice—"a strong Government and a straight vote." What does a straight vote mean? We do not need to study France to know, although there have been some people making speeches around the country about what is happening there. I am concerned only with what is going to happen in my own country and I suggest that the straight vote means a vote similar to the vote which they have for the Belfast Government at present. The Taoiseach was quite right when he stated on many occasions, along with other Fianna Fáil members, that the reaction to the straight vote in the north would be that minorities would have no representation. How right he has been in that prophecy. Only within the last fortnight a Church dignitary there pointed out that a number of the Catholic minority were unable to get either jobs or houses.

Is that the system that we want to see adopted here, that if one Party gets a majority you must be a member of that Party in order to get a job? I do not believe that would happen but I do not want to be in the position of depriving minorities of their rights. I have been criticised in my constituency for saying that this action would mean that a large section in my constituency would be deprived of representation. The answer given to me was: "Let them join one or other of the large Parties." Why should any minority or any individual be asked to join any Party?

I suppose I am the only person in this House who has had the experience of seeing three changes in the proportional representation system since 1923. The first time we had five members for Wicklow and Kildare; we came along some years afterwards and we transferred portion of County Wicklow to County Carlow and reduced the membership. In 1937 Fianna Fáil got a large majority and decided that we would not have so many nine member and five member constituencies but that we would have two and three member constituencies. I was put back into my own county which became a three member constituency.

Deputy Loughman gave us a lecture on how easy it would be for all the Party to be elected. I do not believe that the proportion he mentioned would work out as the Deputy believes it would. A commission is to be set up and nobody knows what area that commission will select, whether it will be my constituency——

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, I did not refer at all to the possible division of the constituencies.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I misinterpreted the Deputy's speech when I read it. I took it that he mentioned Tipperary——

Comment on this

I mentioned three member, four member, and five member constituencies as such.

Comment on this

The Deputy pointed out that two big Parties will share the majority of the seats. I do not agree. However, I accept the Deputy's statement. I am opposing this motion as a trade unionist and in doing so am carrying out an agreement with the Trade Union Congress who have passed a unanimous resolution appealing to their members to do everything in their power to try to bring home to the people the seriousness of voting for any system other than proportional representation, as being the fairest manner of voting. We all know that this is not a question of a straight vote or of stability but, and it has been repeated many times here, a question purely of political tactics. Fianna Fáil recognise that with the unsettled state of the country, its economic position and the failure of the Government to fulfil even one of their last general election promises, and the failure of the Tánaiste to provide the 100,000 jobs he promised, their position would be serious if there was a general election at present.

The people were delighted with the promise of the Tánaiste. I remember a bureau being set up in my constituency to which the people were to go with their complaints. It did not remain open for very long; they were too busy and the result was that the bureau was closed. We never had so much unemployment in my constituency as we have at the present time. This is a political tactic because the Taoiseach has stated, in another part of the country, that he recognises that in the next election, under proportional representation, Fianna Fáil would not get a majority. It is recognised that any Government in power for a certain time may have to do something unpopular and lose certain of its members. Here the Government has failed completely to implement even one of the promises they made during the last election. They cannot get on a platform now and talk about the inter-Party Government and the cost of living. We know what the price of food is at present; we also know about the large numbers of unemployed who meet Fianna Fáil Deputies in their various constituencies. In the rural areas there are vacant cottages with a charge of 2/6d. or 3/- a week for half an acre of land, but there are no applicants because they have gone to look for work in another country.

These are the matters the Government should have been considering instead of indulging in political tactics and bringing in red herrings like the abolition of P.R. and the introduction of the straight vote. They are merely following the example of the Belfast Government in their endeavour to deprive minorities of representation. Every member of the Fianna Fáil Party has denounced the electoral practices of the Belfast Government. I am using the word "Belfast" instead of "Stormont" because a large number of people, especially in my constituency, may not know where Stormont is but they know where Belfast is.

I do not intend to deal with the points which have been raised about France or other countries. I shall deal with our country. If Labour were to be defeated in an election it could create a serious situation. I have weathered the storm since 1923 and, please God, if I have the strength I shall weather it again no matter what way my constituency is manipulated. I am not speaking about myself but about the whole trade union movement which is now united. If they have no representation in Parliament there may be certain disgruntled individuals who might use the situation to achieve ends against the policy of the majority of the people.

Do not give that excuse to them. Let us preserve the right of every citizen, whoever he may be, to seek the votes of the people and elect a Government without forcing Labour to join Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil. There are labouring men in both of those organisations just as there are farmers. When it comes to a question of Government versus Labour, naturally as loyal members of the respective Parties they must vote with the Party. I have seen teachers voting with their Party against their own feelings. We should not give to a certain element the excuse that we are not representing the people because this element has no representatives to put forward their views in Parliament. I have been here since 1923 and I remember the time when we were not supposed to represent anybody here. These boys may try to repeat the excuse that we represent only certain elements in the community.

Fianna Fáil have not, over the last two years, fulfilled the promises they made. The Fianna Fáil Party, having been elected, as the Taoiseach said, as a strong Government with a large majority, should have as their first concern the solution of the economic difficulties which we face. I have experienced strikes and various other happenings since 1923 and I can only hope that what has happened in other countries will not happen here. Men of goodwill are doing their best to cooperate but that cannot continue. The leaders of the trade union movement cannot continue from month to month asking the members not to take action.

We in the Labour Party welcome the opportunity of going before the people and I know what the result will be when the question is put in my constituency. However, we are prepared to accept the decision of the people and let us hear no more of this talk of denying rights to the people. We intend to give the people the opportunity of coming to a decision and to explain to them how serious a decision it is.

I am against dictatorship whether it is on county boards, public boards or in the Government. If P.R. is abolished we shall have as firm a dictatorship as we have under the county councils. Members will be powerless because there will be such a large majority on either one side or the other that the minority will have very little say and their representations will not be considered by the Government.

There is only one Party in Ireland asking for this change; there is no other Party to support it. Apart from the other political Parties who are opposed to the change there is the United Trade Union Congress. The Government should consider the fact that an organisation representing all the trade unions, irrespective of what their political opinions may be—and there are various political opinions among the members of those unions—have passed a unanimous resolution appealing to their branches and to their members to do everything in their power to defeat the Government's intentions to abolish P.R. We want P.R. retained so that no excuse will be given either to trade unionists, or any other elements under a different name, to take up a position outside the Constitution.

Therefore, I am opposed bitterly to this change and I am saying so as a paid-up member of a trade union. I am confident that my constituency will vote against the abolition of P.R. They will vote for the retention of that system so that the minorities in my constituency will have every opportunity of having their representatives returned in future elections.

Comment on this

Deputy Everett mentioned that Fianna Fáil should be more concerned with the promises they made prior to the last election than with changing the electoral system. If we cast our minds back to the state of this country in January and February of 1957, before that election took place, we can see the advance that has been made in the last two years to carry out the pledges and promises made. Due to the action, or inaction, of the Coalition Government the country was brought to a state of bankruptcy. One of the reasons why we needed a strong Government was to bring it back to the sound economic position to which it has been brought today in the course of two short years. That is one of the reasons why we should have no more to do with coalition Governments here.

Deputy Declan Costello said we were making this proposal because we did not like Coalition Governments. I think the people did not like them either. They gave that answer in no uncertain manner in the last election. We have been told also that there is no demand for this system of voting. Deputy Everett was harping on the trade unions. I am led to believe—at least we were told here anyway—that the system under which they elect their officers is the straight vote and not proportional representation.

Comment on this

Not the union of which I am a member, and it is the largest union in Ireland.

Comment on this

There is only one trade union whose Executive is elected under the P.R. system.

Comment on this

In any event, it has been stated that some of the trade unions use the straight vote system and it has not been contradicted.

Comment on this

It has been contradicted now.

Comment on this

This proposal to change the voting system has been brought before the House. It has been discussed here, in the other House and throughout the country for long enough. Since it was introduced here by the Taoiseach, it has been opposed by the Opposition throughout the country tooth and nail. They do not want to let the people decide the issue for themselves. They tell us that we have an intelligent electorate. If they are intelligent, as we believe they are, why not let the issue go to them? Why has it been held up for so long without letting the people decide for themselves? We have been accused of dictatorship. All we want is to let this proposal go to the people. We have not been told why they have held it up for so long. The only alternative we have got is an amendment by the Fine Gael Party to set up a commission to advise the people what to do——

Comment on this

Not at all. Did the Deputy read it?

Comment on this

——as much as to say the people do not know what to do. It is only another tactic to hold it up.

Comment on this

To hold it up for information.

Comment on this

They have tried every stunt they can to bedevil the position and hold it up instead of letting it go to the people. You do not like it because you know that the Taoiseach has done it in the national interest in order to give us peace, progress and stability in government in this country. Like every other step he took in the national interest, this has been opposed by the same element. When he asked for the removal of the Oath of Allegiance to a foreign King which Deputies had to take here, that was in the national interest and it was opposed tooth and nail by Fine Gael at the time. In spite of that, the attitude of the Taoiseach was endorsed by the Irish people at an election and he removed the Oath of Allegiance.

Later on, when the Taoiseach wanted to prevent the annuities being sent across the Irish Sea by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government —£5,000,000 a year going to John Bull—that also was in the national interest——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not relevant——

Comment on this

I want to show that everything our leader did in the national interest was opposed by the same elements as are opposing this.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

They are not relevant to the motion or amendment.

Comment on this

A reply to this would be proper, Sir?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

As I say, they are not relevant to the motion or the amendment.

Comment on this

I want to show that this is being done in the interests of the nation and that the same tactics are being used by the Opposition to prevent it being put to the people as they used in relation to the other steps taken by the Fianna Fáil Party in the national interest in the past. When the Taoiseach put the new Constitution to the people in a referendum was it not opposed by the same people as are opposing this referendum today?

Comment on this

And you want to change it now.

Comment on this

We want to change it in the light of what has happened in the meantime when we had two Coalition Governments——

Comment on this

That is the reason.

Comment on this

——which brought us to the verge of economic ruin. Deputy Everett mentioned that he had no objection to the people deciding this issue and that he was a democrat. If he has no objection, why has it been held up in this House for so long? What was the need to hold it up since last November or December? Why not let the issue be decided? Why were you afraid to let it go to the people? It could have been decided long ago.

Comment on this

All rubbish.

Comment on this

It is not. You know perfectly well that the whole thing is you are afraid of the people's decision.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Kitt is entitled to make a statement without interruption.

Comment on this

It hurts Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

What did the Minister say? Surely the Minister is literate?

Comment on this

It hurts Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy Kitt.

Comment on this

We have been told here that the straight vote system will ensure that Fianna Fáil will remain in power for ever. How is it then that Deputy McGilligan's own colleague, the former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, favoured the straight vote system?

Comment on this

He never did.

Comment on this

So did Deputy Dillon and Deputy McGilligan himself.

Comment on this

Never. I deny that.

Comment on this

It has been quoted in this House.

Comment on this

I want the quotation, Sir. I deny I ever said anything of the sort.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy did not make a quotation. I am insisting that Deputy Kitt be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Did Deputy McGilligan ever say in the Dáil on the 25th May, 1937, that "It was always held that with regard to proportional representation, which this country adopted, we had adopted the worst possible system?"

Comment on this

That is right—on the system. Has the Deputy the earlier part of that speech?

Comment on this

No. I am quoting the part that applies to Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

I was moving to keep P.R. in the Constitution.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy McGilligan, I take it, will make a contribution to this debate? He can then complement the statements made now.

Comment on this

Point 7 of the Declaration at the foundation of the Fine Gael Party in 1933 was:

"The abolition of the present P.R. system so as to secure more effective democratic control of national policy and to establish closer personal relationships between Parliamentary representatives and their constituents."

Is that not a statement against P.R. and in favour of the single-member constituency?

Comment on this

Would you read it again?

Comment on this

I read it loud enough. Here it is again:

The abolition of the present P.R. system so as to secure more effective democratic control of national policy and to establish closer personal relationships between Parliamentary representatives and their constituents.

That was point No. 7 of the Fine Gael Party declaration when it was formed in 1933, as published. If that is not a declaration in favour of the abolition of P.R. and bringing in the single-member constituency, I do not know what it means. It is quite clear that Fine Gael, their policy and certain members, have spoken and advocated the abolition of P.R. But now, because our leader has brought in this and has done so in the national interest, they want to oppose it for the sake of opposition—and that is all it appears to me. After today, please God, it will go to the people soon. I know the answer the people of my constituency will give. When that is done, when the P.R. system is abolished and the straight vote is in operation, the people will be following the advice of the Taoiseach as they have followed it in the past on everything that was required to be done in the national interest. I believe they will do this also in the national interest.

Comment on this

I think I should be allowed to talk to Deputy Kitt, through the Chair. He complains about an oath, as he calls it. It was discovered that there was no Oath. Whatever it was, it was swallowed by everybody belonging to Fianna Fáil. Was it not an empty formula?

Comment on this

We made it that but it was an Oath.

Comment on this

You took it also. You took the Oath.

Comment on this

And so did your leaders.

Comment on this

No, they did not.

Comment on this

We were reduced to the position that Deputies said they had seen that the testament was either put out of the room or at least six feet away from the people who took an empty formula. What was the effect of the testment, if it was not an oath? Does it not have the same effect seven feet away as the effect it has six feet away?

Comment on this

On a point of order, you, Sir, prevented me from speaking on the abolition of the Oath. How is it that Deputy McGilligan is now being permitted to dwell on the subject?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy made advertence to what he claimed Fianna Fáil had done in the national interest. He made reference to the Oath and to land agitation. Deputy McGilligan has a certain right to reply to the statements made on that occasion, even though on both occasions they are irrelevant.

Comment on this

The Oath is not there now. It is gone in spite of you.

Comment on this

Is it an Oath or an empty formula?

Comment on this

He just wanted the name in the book.

Comment on this

People came into this House when what they called the Oath was obligatory. Did they take it or not?

Comment on this
Deputies

No.

Comment on this

Because they put the testament five feet away from them? Secondly, there were the annuities. Was it not a great pity that the Seanad were not adverted to in their view with regard to the annuities—that the matter should be held up for a consultation? Instead, we drifted into a war which we started——

Comment on this

In which you helped the British.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

And the Blueshirts——

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence is a bit of a babe in arms. He ought to keep quite while I am speaking of things that occurred while he was not about and which he does not understand.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not keep very quite when Deputy Kitt was speaking.

Comment on this

I was at least interrupting on things I know about.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy McGilligan will be allowed to speak, I take it we can proceed.

Comment on this

Deputy Kitt was not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Kitt unfortunately introduced these elements.

Comment on this

"Unfortunately" in every way—for the debate and for himself.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

——for order in the House and for relevancy.

Comment on this

Let us look back on history. The Economic War was started on the annuities. In 1938, a trade agreement had to be made with England. It was a pretty poor business which we had to try to put shape on ten years later. It was so weak because our farmers were on their knees—because, as the Taoiseach said, he knew the annuities would be paid in a more expensive way than if they were sent across to England. Deputy Kitt will forget that phrase of his great leader.

Comment on this

We won the battle anyhow.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

We won that battle——

Comment on this

In spite of the Blueshirts.

Comment on this

Anybody looking at Ireland in 1938 cannot say we won that struggle with England. We were on our knees.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must come to the motion.

Comment on this

To the Constitution. My phrases with regard to the Constitution of 1937 were relevant to this debate. Deputy Kitt quoted me as saying I was against a certain system of P.R. He will not bring in the full quotation. I was there moving that we would have the principle of P.R. in the Constitution but not the system. Just a little above that quotation which Deputy Kitt read, there is an interruption from the Taoiseach who said: "I know there are many systems of P.R." I added the comment that is there— that it was understood we had adopted the worst system. Immediately after that, the Taoiseach continued and said that that might be my view and I said it was not my view.

Later, in relation to the advertisement that was read out, it was argued that we objected as a Party to the then system of P.R. when we agreed that P.R. as a principle should be observed and we voted for that in the Constitution. The Deputy's followers, of course, voted for it, too, and it was accepted as being the proper way in which the declaration of elections should be done in this country.

Deputy Kitt thinks there was a bad economic position here in 1957. He will remember that one of the tests posed by his leader with regard to a bad economic system and a better one was the question of employment. Since 1956/57, there are 30,000 fewer people in employment than there were in that bad year. Perhaps Deputy Kitt will explain how that happens under the good system his leader has given the country for two years?

Comment on this

Were there not nearly 100,000 people unemployed?

Comment on this

There are 30,000 fewer in employment. There never were 100,000 unemployed in this country——

Comment on this

I said: "practically."

Comment on this

There never were 100,000 people unemployed in this country, except when Fianna Fáil were in office. That continued—I asked a Question about it and the statistic is there—for 11 years from 1934 when there was an average of 100,000. At one time, the figure reached 140,000.

Comment on this

Before unemployment assistance was introduced, people did not register at the employment exchanges.

Comment on this

That is a new one. It is well thought out but the figures are there. There was an average of 100,000 unemployed for the period Fianna Fáil reigned. I do not know about the early years such as 1933 because the statistics are not complete, but from 1934 onwards that was the case. Let us face the employment figures. Employment is the thing. You can get rid of the unemployed if they emigrate, as they did in two of your years—in the two years since Fianna Fáil came back to power.

The little pamphlet called Economic Statistics issued before the Budget shows that there were 10,000 fewer people employed in 1958 than in the year before and 20,000 fewer that year than in the year before—30,000 fewer persons. Then we were told by Fianna Fáil propagandists at the time of the 1957 election that it was a question of wives sending their husbands to work and there were 100,000 jobs promised. That is the way in which the present Party got to power. Deputy Kitt can still think of that as the bad economic position of 1957 and then he says people gave their answer to that in no uncertain fashion. The Deputy, I suppose, has not looked at the statistics of voting in the last election. Fianna Fáil did not get a majority of the votes of the country. They got a majority here through the way in which the marginal seats went but they did not get a majority of the votes cast in the election.

Comment on this

Of the No. 1 votes.

Comment on this

Of the No. 1 votes.

Comment on this

I suppose they are all votes.

Comment on this

I am taking how the votes went in the end.

Comment on this

Proportionally, when you take in lower preferences, we got a majority, not of No. 1 votes but of Nos. 2, 3, and 4 votes.

Comment on this

You got a majority under P.R. but, remember, 150,000 people who had previously supported the Party to which I belong, the Labour Party, Clann na Talmhan and Clann na Poblachta, did not vote. They did not vote Fianna Fáil. That is what is called the very emphatic answer in no uncertain fashion given in 1957. It is because Deputy Kitt's leader recognised how bad, in fact, that result was, when analysed, that we are getting this proposal, so that a thinly-spread minority, evenly distributed over a constituency, can achieve a bigger majority in this House than even that which the Party got without getting a majority of the votes in the last election.

I listened to Deputy Kitt as I previously listened to Deputy Seán MacCarthy. It is really dreadful in an area where we are supposed to be ruled by argument to have Deputy Kitt and Deputy MacCarthy at this point asserting that the Party to which I belong, the Labour Party, and all those other than Fianna Fáil are afraid to let this matter go to the people. Is that not the argument that is being used? That is Deputy Kitt's argument. Does Deputy Kitt believe that? It is going to the people. The only difference between us is that we want it to go to an informed people. Deputies opposite would rather have it go to people who would be influenced by emotional sway—vote Fianna Fáil, vote for de Valera, and let us have all the elections on the same day, and then we may scramble through and we can hope to be safe for a good while. It is the difference between having an informed electorate voting on a matter and having an electorate that does not know what it is doing, as would have been the case if this matter had been allowed to be rushed by Fianna Fáil, as they desired when this matter was first introduced.

Deputy MacCarthy was allowed to talk today about the voting in the Seanad, even allowed to speak of certain people who are to be regarded as experts on Constitutional Law. He was then held up. But he did speak of the majority in the Seanad. He said the Second Reading was passed. He did not give the voting—by one or two votes. Then he said it seemed to be ludicrous that a House which had accepted the principle of abolishing P.R. could turn around on Committee or other Stage and vote against it. Of course, Deputy MacCarthy said that that was due to the accident of a couple of people being sick. There were a couple more accidents than that. There were certain people there who would not face up to their responsibilities. There was one lady Senator whose case has been quoted.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There has been a convention here for a long time——

Comment on this

This has been spoken on. I may speak of it in this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy allow me? There has been a convention here for years that members of the Seanad and decisions of the Seanad are not discussed in this House.

Comment on this

It was discussed here today, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy ought to adhere to that convention.

Comment on this

I shall adhere to it but when other people are allowed to make argument, surely I am entitled to at least the same space and to occupy the same time to refute the argument. I do not intend to go into anything with regard to personalities. Deputy MacCarthy spoke of the six university men in the Seanad and asked what do they, while they may be great people academically, know of Constitutional law.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

They were referred to before because they made a statement outside the Seanad and it was not considered as a proceeding of the House.

Comment on this

He was talking about them in respect to their votes in the Seanad. He said that they were six of the people who wanted to have this matter delayed and caused the delay. So they have. I want to put the Opposition point of view. They are six people who stand an election, maybe with a select type of electorate, but they do stand an election. What about the eleven nominees of the Taoiseach? Are they to be counted? If they are not counted, the Seanad vote was not a majority of one; it was very nearly, as somebody said in this House, a two to one majority of the free Seanad against the proposal and, Sir, if Constitutional law is to be regarded as a qualification for a vote in the Seanad, one could think quickly, without mentioning names, of a lot of the personnel in the Seanad in respect of whom one would very easily come to a decisive negative as to their attitude on Constitutional matters and their knowledge of anything in the nature of Constitutional law. The Seanad have acted, as they are entitled to do constitutionally. They have, if the free vote is taken, by an almost two to one majority, voted against the proposal.

Comment on this

How does the Deputy make that out? The most it could be is 30 to 20—10 nominated.

Comment on this

There are 11 nominated.

Comment on this

Eleven, I should say.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy do the sum? He will find it is very nearly two to one.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The constitution of the Seanad surely does not arise on this.

Comment on this

The Deputy has gone out to make a calculation.

Comment on this

Looking for a ball-frame.

Comment on this

I made a comment. I do not want to make it again. On the free votes in the Seanad the majority was nearly two to one against. It was not quite. It was, at least, in the bookie's language, seven to four against. It was at least that. Here is Deputy MacCarthy, on this date, a month before the elections take place, still rolling out the old contention that to have a resolution moved and spoken on here indicates fear of the people. There is no fear of the people.

I am quite confident of what is going to happen. I might have been afraid of what the popular result would have been if this matter had been pushed to referendum in the winter of last year but there is no doubt that, as the process of education has gone on, as arguments have been proceeding here and have been reported, there is clarification in people's minds. All over the place, there has been an upsurge of feeling against the proposal. Quite an anger has developed over the arrogance of the people who believe that, just because one man in this country can get a lot of toadies around him in the Cabinet, get them to agree to something and get a wider group of supporters in the Dáil, he is going to get all Fianna Fáil supporters to tread the same way just because, after so many years, he has made up his mind that P.R. is no longer good for the people but something that has to be got rid of.

It is quite clear that this has been run completely and entirely as a matter of Fianna Fáil politics. That seems to be a reflection of the anxiety that Deputies opposite must feel, and express themselves as feeling, with regard to the result. All the Party weight is now to be thrown into these two questions of the President and the abolition of P.R. First of all, we have the fact that the two elections are to be held on the same day. I can understand people objecting to this amendment of ours on the ground that, if it were carried, it would preclude all possibility of the two elections being held on the same day and many people would agree that that would be a proper result and it was what was announced as a principle accepted by the Taoiseach when this debate first started. He said there was no question of having the two matters decided on the same day, that they would be on different dates and different types of electoral machinery would operate in the two elections.

However, we are following now the precedent established at the time of the plebiscite on the Constitution when it was frankly stated here that it was vital to hold the plebiscite for the Constitution and the elections on the same day as, without the incentive given to the voters to come out and vote for an individual, or individuals, there would be no hope of moving them to come out and vote for something abstract like the Constitution. Therefore, to get the Party strength, it was decided to hold both the plebiscite and the elections on the same day thereby ensuring that those who favoured Fianna Fáil would turn into the polling both, decide the ordinary election and carry forward their votes to the Constitution in a sort of Fianna Fáil spirit. It is rather significant that about 100,000 people who voted in the general election did not bother to vote, one way or the other, in the matter of the Constitution.

We are now having the Taoiseach put forward as a Presidential candidate. It makes one think of a previous period, way back many years ago, when defeated in a straight vote with regard to the acceptance of the arrangement with England, the present Taoiseach, then president of an organisation, threw his weight into the scale by resigning from office in the hope that the vote on that issue would strengthen opposition to the Treaty arrangements. That failed as I believe his effort to swing things now by putting his own personal influence into the scale again in connection with the abolition of proportional representation will also fail.

We are also, I understand from a speech made here today—it is a matter that came as a surprise to me—to have not merely the two elections on the same day but it is also contemplated that, while there will be two ballot papers, they will both be handed to the voter as he goes in to the common booth, the one for the referendum on the abolition of proportional representation and the other for the election of a President. If that is true, the thing assumes a most scandalous colouring.

Further, I understand that in the city of Dublin it is now accepted that there are not enough ballot boxes and the position will be that a voter going in to the both and accepting one ballot paper in connection with the Presidential Election and another in connection with P.R. will subsequently have to put both ballot papers into the same ballot box. The first effort made by the scrutineers afterwards will be the segregation of the votes cast in one matter as opposed to the votes cast in the other. If that is the situation likely to develop, it indicates a more confused situation than was ever contemplated and will, of course, take away completely from any security with regard to the vote.

In addition to all this, we have the political attitude stressed by the pressure that is being put and has been put on Deputies that they must all walk the same line, that this is their only safeguard and shield against the terrors of the future and the political wilderness for them unless they conform and do what the Taoiseach asks them to do. Worst of all, we have this matter of the letter issued by the Tánaiste. A letter has been sent by the Tánaiste to business people——

Comment on this

Is it not the same as the one issued by Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Mulcahy?

Comment on this

Would the Minister produce to me anything written by Deputy Sweetman?

Comment on this

And Deputy Mulcahy. I saw it. It is in the same terms.

Comment on this

Would the Minister produce it? I should like to see it.

Comment on this

The Deputy probably has seen it.

Comment on this

I have not seen it.

Comment on this

I have.

Comment on this

I do not regard the Minister as very reliable in his statements and I am entitled to ask for the production of a document when the existence of the document is denied.

By this time one has got used to the Tánaiste writing to people and it is only to be expected that he will write to those who either have received or are likely to receive benefits from the operations of his Department. That is known in America as "lobbying of interested people" to put pressure on members of Congress. We have not, so far, got that system here. We regard it as something near corruption. But we have got used to it in connection with ordinary elections. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, as Tánaiste, addresses letters to people who, as I say, have got benefit or, more particularly, those who may look to have benefit from some of the operations of his Department. With reluctance, one might accept something that has grown up over the years; one might accept that the Minister in charge of the Department of Industry and Commerce is entitled to have some regard of those who supported him politically. It is clear that there is at least a temptation that that may tinge his views when it comes to deciding things which should be decided objectively.

Now, however, there are new considerations. The Minister for Industry and Commerce as Tánaiste, and possibly as someone elevated to a higher sphere, wants to know not merely how people supported him as head of the Department giving economic benefit but he also wants to know if they subscribed to the Party itself, the Party which wants one vote cast for the Taoiseach as President and another vote cast for the abolition of proportional representation.

These are not commercial matters and while, as I say, it is near corruption to have it done in connection with commercial matters, it approaches much more closely to corruption when it is done in connection with such a matter as the Presidential Election and an issue which should be left to the free vote of an informed democracy, the question of the system of voting under which they will elect their representatives to the Dáil.

Every effort is being made to ensure success. Both elections will be held on the same day. The personality of the Taoiseach is thrown in. The blackmailing letter issues to the industrialists. All that is happening in relation to these two issues, in relation to what is described as a free vote of the people as to the system of voting and their choice in that regard; and it was expected to be their free choice unprejudiced by anything in the way of politics in relation to the person who will hold office as President of the country for the next seven years.

It is not worth while at this stage doing anything more than looking at the arguments used against the system of proportional representation that we have. There was talk about multiplicity of Parties. It is only the dullest of backbenchers in Fianna Fáil who believe in that any longer and who venture to advance it at this hour. There has been no multiplicity of Parties in this country since 1922. There is no likelihood of any great multiplicity of Parties in the future. The number of Parties which has evolved is representative of distinct interests and these interests have a right to claim representation. It is one of the benefits of the system we have that it gives representation where there is sufficient strength, a strength which can be regarded as important and worthy of representation.

We have been told that under proportional representation one might get short Parliaments. In the two periods in which there was coalition Government in this country both Governments had a longer period of parliamentary office than the average Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

On a point of order, my word was doubted here. Would I be in order in producing the document to which I referred, the document issued by Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Sweetman?

Comment on this

Neither of whom is a Minister.

Comment on this

It was denied the document existed. It does exist and it is in practically the same terms.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

The Minister is trying to get in that somebody has done the same thing as the Tánaiste.

Comment on this

They have done it.

Comment on this

They are not Ministers.

Comment on this

I have the letter here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy McGilligan is entitled to speak and, unless he gives way to the Minister, I do not see how the Minister can introduce the matter.

Comment on this

We were told it is impossible to carry through policy under coalitions. The Fianna Fáil Government came into office in 1932. They went out of office in 1948. They had 16 years in Government. Two elections during that period gave them an over-all majority. What did they give in return. Stagnation. There was certainly no break up of Parliament preventing them from carrying through a policy that might be regarded as good for the people. For 16 years they held sway. Yet we get a complaint now that under proportional representation there is not sufficient length of parliamentary life to enable a policy to be put through. The same people have been in control of Government here for 16 years. We can look back now on the record of what they did in those 16 years. Whatever excuse they may make for what they did or did not do, they cannot make the excuse that they were handicapped because proportional representation deprived them of the strength to put their policy through.

As against that, we are told that coalitions are bad. We are told that there was a certain amount of lobbying, a certain amount of bargaining going on. Coalitions are bad, are they? Compare what the two Coalitions did between 1948 and 1951, and between 1954 and 1957 and see is there anything comparable with it since 1932. Taxation was reduced all round. People who had been kept down in their conditions of living by standstill orders, actual and threatened, were not merely allowed but encouraged to have their living standards raised. Those people who had gone out on pension, when their pensions were not equal to the stress of the cost of living, had their pensions improved. The whole personnel of the State service, civil servants, the Garda, the Army and teachers who had the right to arbitration were encouraged to seek it, and those who had not were encouraged to have themselves assimilated in their conditions with those who had these arbitration rights.

The positions of all those people were improved and we started in those years the system of the capital Budget and the capital Budget schemes, which have left their mark on Fianna Fáil and which Fianna Fáil cannot get rid of, much as they would like to, and much as they engaged in a frenzy of vituperation when these things were started. Judging by results, this country should like coalition Governments and abhor at least one type of single Party Government, the single Party Fianna Fáil Government.

I have a liking for coalition Governments, may I say, outside the single Party. I mean a coalition where there is real collaboration, not the type of coalition, as I say, the hysterical mind of Fianna Fáil conjured up where some people try to veto what one of the groups of Parties wants to carry through. I lived for six years under those conditions. There was real collaboration. There was no question of anybody imposing a veto or trying to do so. Matters were resolved by argument, as they are, or at least supposed to be resolved here, and we do not think it any fault that it was done in a council chamber instead of openly in the Dáil, particularly when the fruits of that argument in the council chamber were eventually exposed here in the Dáil and the Dáil was able to do whatever it could to try to drive a wedge between the Parties and Party methods. It was something which might be regarded as a compromise between two extreme points of view and extreme points of view are not always the best. In coalition Government one can get real cooperation and we got it for six years.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

We got such good results that we showed by example and contrast what Fianna Fáil might have done, but failed to do, and in doing so, we aroused the envy and hatred of the Taoiseach and it is that envy and hatred which has led to the present proposals.

There has been a great deal of talk by the Government that coalition programmes should be exposed before an election. Individually, I do not see any great virtue in that, but I should like to look at the application of it. The Minister for Defence is amused but he will not be so amused at what I am about to say. Here is a programme that was not exposed before the last election. At the last election the programme which was exposed was 100,000 new jobs, was it not?

Comment on this

Yes, it was. Let the uneasy cuckoo stay in his nest.

Comment on this

I am not uneasy at all. The Deputy asked a question and the answer is "no".

Comment on this

I should like someone more associated with the Party and someone older than such a newcomer to give me the answer. In any event, the cuckoo always stirs uneasily. Let him keep quite. These 100,000 jobs were promised. Remember the poster: "Wives, get your husbands back to work."

Comment on this

It did not mention 100,000 jobs.

Comment on this

The question of sending them to work in England was not mentioned.

Comment on this

"Let us get cracking."

Comment on this

Which we did.

Comment on this

We will see the result.

Comment on this

We have seen it.

Comment on this

The programme before the election was "Get cracking", "100,000 jobs,""The Lemass scheme"——

Comment on this

In any event, it was planned to give 100,000 jobs and, in addition to that, the food subsidies were to be retained. The Tánaiste was very angry at what he called the stupid comments made as to their intentions and he and the Taoiseach at different places said it was no part of their policy to reduce the food subsidies, that they did not believe in such a thing. May I take it then that before the election the programme was more jobs and cheap food? —and after the election the subsidies disappeared and food became dearer.

It was alleged against us when we asserted that workers and State personnel had a right to have their emoluments raised to meet the increased cost of living, that it was a conspiracy against the State, that we were trying to do away with any good that might have come from the Budget proposals by asking the people to look for increased emoluments. Again, and I have already referred to this, the number of people employed dropped by 30,000. There are 30,000 fewer people in jobs in the country now than there were two years ago. I saw in a journal recently an item on two men meeting in the steerage of the boat at Dún Laoghaire going to Holyhead. One asked the other: "Who are you?" He replied: "I am one of the 100,000 who did not get one of the jobs that were promised. Who are you?""I am worse," he said, "I am one of the 30,000 who had a job and who lost it since Fianna Fáil came in."

Am I right in thinking that the picture is entirely different after an election from what was exposed to the people to get their votes before the election?

Comment on this

The Deputy is not right; he is wrong.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy explain where I am wrong?

Comment on this

No; I am just telling you.

Comment on this

The Deputy is just content to say I am wrong. I thought this House was a place for argument and that we might have the value of the Deputy's argument.

Comment on this

I have already contributed to the argument.

Comment on this

It should not be done in such a namby-pamby way. The Deputy should stand up to it. Will he stand up and say where I am wrong? Was there not a promise of more jobs in the country?

Comment on this

And there have been.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Let us get one thing at a time.

Comment on this

How many more were there?

Comment on this

There was a promise of more jobs, was there not?

Comment on this

There was a promise that we would try to get more.

Comment on this

To do your best.

Comment on this

You promised more jobs. There was no suggestion of "if we can do it". It was: "We will do it.""Wives get your husbands back to work." The Deputy reminds me—what was the number of jobs? Was it 100,000? Am I right?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy deny that there was a figure of 100,000 in what was called "the Lemass scheme"?

Comment on this

Yes, some time before the election.

Comment on this

The promise was made?

Comment on this

Some considerable time.

Comment on this

But not after.

Comment on this

But not after! I am getting the contrast. Was there not a statement that the food subsidies would not be withdrawn?

Comment on this

No. There was a statement that it was not our policy to withdraw the subsidies.

Comment on this

"We have no intention of withdrawing them."

Comment on this

And we had not, but this hardly seems relevant.

Comment on this

Had you taken a decision before you left office?

Comment on this

May I be referred to any record of that decision?

Comment on this

The reference is to be found in the Estimates that were framed. Where was the money to come from?

Comment on this

And the subsidies were still in the Estimates.

Comment on this

Tell us where the money was to come from.

Comment on this

Will you tell us where the money is to come from for the jet planes?

Comment on this

The subsidies were in the Estimates and there was no intention to remove them from the Estimates.

Comment on this

Then tell us where you proposed to get the money to pay the subsidies.

Comment on this

Now let us return to Deputy Booth.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy return to the motion?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy agree that there are 30,000 fewer people in employment now than there were two years ago?

Comment on this

I do not know but I doubt it.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know that the Government have produced a book giving the employment figures at the end of 1958 and they are 30,000 fewer than at the end of 1957?

Comment on this

I do know that unemployment is down and that emigration is down.

Comment on this

I questioned the Minister for Finance on that point during the Budget debate when I asked him how was it possible that unemployment can be lower and that emigration can be lower and at the same time, we have fewer people employed. The answer he gave me was that they must be emigrating.

Comment on this

That was not the answer. The explanation was that the figures referred to dealt with a period in the past and that the figures for last year will be published in a couple of months.

Comment on this

The answer was that they must be emigrating and that is the only answer he gave me. There can be no other answer. Yet it is contended that emigration is down and that unemployment is down.

Comment on this

The figures given were given up to the end of 1958.

Comment on this

They were not.

Comment on this

The figures were published for the year 1958.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This matter is not relevant to the motion before the House. The Deputy is going into great detail on unemployment and emigration.

Comment on this

I am not sure if you were in the Chair when this matter started, Sir. I am answering a question posed by Deputy Kitt that an election programme ought to be made before an election and not afterwards. I contend that in, 1957, the Fianna Fáil Party promised the electorate 100,000 new jobs and after the election, the reality was 30,000 fewer jobs and dearer food.

Comment on this