An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—Tairiscint (atogáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Motion (resumed).
Contributions 190–356 of 356. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
There was no promise of that before the election. If, as Deputy Kitt says, the people gave their answer in no uncertain manner in the 1957 election, I do not know why there is all the horror of putting this matter to the people in a general election. The Taoiseach expressed himself more clearly than any of his Deputies when he said in Monaghan that there was no hope under the present system of Fianna Fáil ever getting an overall majority again.
Comment on this
I hope that on any other occasion on which I am speaking here, the Deputy to whom I shall refer as the cuckoo will come in here to his nest. I find that he is very helpful to me. If the Taoiseach could count on it, we would still have the same system. Is that not right?
Comment on this
Of course, he cannot count on it. He knows he would never again get it in his lifetime or in that of his Party. The pattern of politics in this country changed just after the war. The Government were lucky to be in office during the time the war was on because then there was a feeling that it would be wrong to change the Government during a time of crisis. The first time the people got a chance to speak their mind after the war was in 1948 and Fianna Fáil were beaten. In those days, the people had not got acquainted with the form of coalition governments, but whether they knew about them or not, they were certain of one thing, that is, that they did not want Fianna Fáil—and they were quite decisive about that.
Comment on this
After the 1948 election, a coalition Government was formed, something that nobody expected.
Comment on this
It was formed to the frightful disturbance of the Party which Deputy Booth was later to join. It was a strange thing for the Taoiseach to find that this could happen. Before that Government was formed and before the election, there was no coherence between the Parties who formed it. Thy had different policies but they met together and decided it was better to give the people a chance to enjoy a different form of government from that provided by Fianna Fáil.
That Government went out in 1951. It was actually returned in 1951 also, but six people who were told by the electors to join a coalition Government went over to Fianna Fáil. Those six people were wiped out ruthlessly by the voters at the next election because of their traitorous behaviour at that time. In 1954, the people most deliberately voted for a coalition Government. It was promised to them from the platforms. We said that we would go into coalition if the people gave sufficient votes to enable us to do so and they gave us the votes.
There is no doubt that the whole fabric of government in this country has changed since 1948. The Taoiseach, who knows politics, if he knows nothing else, can see that. He knows that the victory of 1957 was a very hollow thing. It is because the truth is known that there is never again a possibility of his getting an over-all majority for whatever Party he leads that he has brought in this proposal for the abolition of proportional representation.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy does not want that, but perhaps the people do. Are they not entitled to have it if they want it?
Comment on this
There is no alternative then. There would be no alternative if no Party could get an over-all majority.
Comment on this
Then if there is no alternative, I welcome that position. Is it not the right of the people to say that that is what they want?
Comment on this
Were the Fianna Fáil Party not put out of office by proportional representation? Was that not the system which gave the people the greatest freedom of choice?
Comment on this
The Deputy is so genteel it is hard to understand what he says. In any event it is seen here now after the two statements made, one of which was an aggressive statement against an Opposition; that was by the Minister for Local Government: "If this thing goes through Fine Gael have had it." That was the attack on his part and the other is the nicer phrase of the Taoiseach that unless this goes through—at least he wants it to go through—there is no hope of Fianna Fáil ever having an overall majority in this House again.
The Taoiseach apparently equates the national interests with the fortunes of the Fianna Fáil Party, and, therefore, feels he is entitled to throw everything into the arena. It is now being made a completely Party question. There is no longer any pretence that it is being put in an ordinary way for the people to express their views on it after deliberation. The main thing emerging from the debate is that what Fianna Fáil detests most is the effort to educate the people as to what this thing means. All the efforts that have been made in the Seanad during the various Stages, and here again now, are not so much devoted to the question as to whether a vote should be taken on a certain date or not, but that when the matter comes before the people the people will know to some degree what they are voting for, and will not be swayed by Party emotion and a one-Party machine.
Comment on this
As a Deputy from the same constituency as the Taoiseach I feel it incumbent on me to stand up at the close of this debate and say a few words.
Comment on this
The Chair is not aware that Deputy Booth is reading any newspaper. The reading of newspapers is not allowed in the House except for the purpose of reference.
Comment on this
The question before the House has been debated since last November, and there is not a whole lot left for me to say this evening but, anyway, I shall try to be honest with the House and with the people who sent me here. While saying that, I must add that I honestly believe what has been happening here since last November is nothing more or less than the result of a civil war. Mind you, a civil war in other countries, as well as here, is not easily forgotten. I personally believe it is the spirit of that civil war which permeates this House through the years, unfortunately to the detriment of the country and of the people of the country.
One thing which strikes me very forcibly is that every native Parliament since 1922 has been elected under the P.R. system. As far back as 1927 even the leader of the Government, then Leader of Sinn Féin, speaking at Cavan said that he would be completely out against anybody who would oppose the P.R. system. Again, in 1937, not being satisfied with the then Constitution he drafted his own which, of course, as leader of the Government he was perfectly entitled to do, but he took very good care to insert and endorse the system of P.R. in that Constitution, simply and solely because he said we were a lucky people to have it—it was the system we knew and the system we understood.
Having made those statements I feel it is rather peculiar, now that he is about to retire from the political arena, that he should ask to have the system of election which placed him in power done away with, the system which gave him the strong majority which his Government has at present. Despite that, he gives as one of his reasons for the abolition of proportional representation that we could never get a strong and stable Government until it was abolished. It is an extraordinary thing that the man who got what he says could not be got under P.R.—a strong Government —should now use his power to do away with the system which gave him the power to do away with it.
I honestly believe there must be something very sinister behind the proposal. What it is I do not know, but time will tell. Personally, for the sake of our people and for the sake of generations yet to come, I certainly would not like that that system would be done away with inasmuch as it is quite possible—and I think Deputies and the Minister on the opposite side will agree with me—that Fianna Fáil can get into office with a very big majority, and it is possible, having got that majority under the straight vote, there is nothing to prevent them from prolonging the life of the Dáil. After five years they could easily say—we should all rejoice in it if we were inside here at the time—that the life of the Dáil should be ten years, and that once in ten years would be enough to have an election. I definitely would agree with them on that, if I were here myself, but it would be giving them a power which I would not like them to get, and it might be as well for themselves that they should not get that power.
Those are my views. I believe that when the Taoiseach is resigning from the public and political life of the country he should leave to the people the system of election which he has said they should be proud to have, the system of election they knew and the system of election they understood.
Comment on this
I should like to join my voice with that of every member of the House outside the Fianna Fáil Party in appealing to the Taoiseach to accept the amendment tabled by Deputy Costello and Deputy Mulcahy. This is a very reasonable amendment, that a committee of both Houses of the Oireachtas study the whole system of election in this country and ascertain whether there is any better system, or any improvement on the present system, which could be suggested. The Taoiseach has done that already in relation to the Seanad. He has already set up a committee to go into the form of election for the Seanad. If that is necessary for the Seanad, how much more necessary is it for the Dáil, the real power in government? We have seen the power of the Seanad during the past few months when they turned down this Bill. We saw where the Government, by a mere motion and with a majority in this Dáil, could override the Seanad's decision on this matter.
We have had a debate here for quite a long time on the referendum and only one or two Independent Deputies spoke in favour of the change. Every other Independent spoke against it. We saw an even more united front in the Seanad and not one Independent member there spoke in favour of the change from proportional representation to the straight vote. When it came to the question of voting, the result was 29 against the proposed change and 28 for a change. The result looked very close, but I wonder do many people realise that 11 of the people who voted in favour of changing the present system were nominated to the Seanad by the Taoiseach? They had not even to go to the trouble of being elected as the other Senators had, so that really of the elected members in the Seanad, there were 29 in favour of no change and 17 for a change.
Immediately after, we had a proposal made by six University professors, six independent men, not depending on Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour or any other Party for their votes. They got their votes, you might say, in their own right as representative men. The graduates of the Universities felt that these candidates were best fitted to represent them.
Comment on this
The Chair has ruled that the individual views of Senators are not relevant to the motion.
Comment on this
The Deputy is entitled to refer to the action of the Seanad but not to the individual actions of Senators.
Comment on this
I take it that the Deputy is entitled to refer to a published statement by six University Senators?
Comment on this
That is what I am referring to. These Senators do not belong to any political Party. They are six independent people and they just asked for the same thing as this amendment asks for—that a committee be set up by both Houses of the Oireachtas to go into the matter of a change in the system of election.
As the Minister for Lands stated definitely here this evening, if this goes through, it is a leap in the dark. Do the present Government want the country to take a leap in the dark? After all, we in this House will not be here in 25, or 30 or 40 years' time. We do not know what could happen here. We have had practically 40 years' experience of the present system and we know what can happen. We know that the people at any general election, if they so desire, can change from a Fianna Fáil Government to an inter-Party Government or any other Government. In fact we have had various changes since 1948 and there was no trouble about the people changing from one Government to another. The system in operation gave them that opportunity and under that system we have had the strongest Government since the State was established.
The Government have not been two years in office and they have three years more to complete their term. If in two years' time the Government said: "The plans which we had in 1957 have not yet matured. We firmly believe that we have got so far in the field and that if a change were made in the Government next year, all these plans would be dashed to the ground. We want a change in the system so that we may be able to carry on for another five years" there might be some grounds for this. Instead, having been in office for two years—during which time we saw no fruits of good Government, although we have seen the fruits of strong Government—they seek this change. We have seen the various Budgets brought in by the Minister for Finance and we saw that the Minister for Agriculture, during the year, was lost and could not be found. That can be strong Government. It can be strong Government when you can have the position that the Ministers are in such a position that they do not care about the Dáil and give irrelevant answers when they are challenged. But can you have good Government in that way?
It is most essential for Parliament, in any country outside the Iron Curtain, to have a responsible Opposition and to have a reasonably-sized Opposition. When you have Bills passing through this House, as you have nearly every month or so, you must have some Opposition to examine these Bills, someone who is qualified, possibly by reason of previous Ministerial experience. If we have not got representative Opposition, there is no hope of helping the Government. The Government produce Bills and the people expect the Opposition to perform the duty of an efficient Opposition, and examine the Bills and suggest amendments. If the Government are not prepared to carry out those amendments, the Opposition cannot help it, but they are supposed to do their duty, and often when a non-contentious Bill is passing through the House, the Government see their way to accept the Opposition's amendments, or see the good points put up by the Opposition. If you gave a Bill direct from the draftsman to an ordinary man, he would hardly understand it and it is only a man qualified through years of Parliamentary experience who can go through it.
The Ministers have the assistance of experts in their Departments. They are there, whatever Minister or whatever Party is in power. They, or their successors, are there to assist the Ministers, but the Opposition have no facility whatever for obtaining assistance from any expert and it is most essential that there should be a responsible and representative Opposition in the House. If this Bill goes through, it could happen that Fianna Fáil or any other Party, would come back in another election, with 100 seats. Where would we be then? There might be only 30 or 40 people in opposition. Those people would not be whole-time politicians. They would have only a Deputy's allowance and could devote only part of their time to the business of this House. How could the people expect those Deputies to sit down week after week and do the work which should be done by 60 or 70 Deputies? When there are 60 or 70 Deputies, the job is quite easy, although they still have not got the expert assistance the Government have. That is natural enough. A Minister must have expert assistance to carry a Bill through the House.
The one great fault in this proposal is that it represents a leap in the dark and I say that we would have much the same result as they have had in Northern Ireland. The Unionist Government in Northern Ireland abolished P.R. from the same point of view as Fianna Fáil are trying to abolish it. First there was the cry: "We do not want small Parties. Small Parties can put up an election programme to the people which they will not have to carry out because they can never be called upon to form a Government." However, since last November or December the people have seen through that attitude and now the Taoiseach bluntly says it was because Fianna Fáil could not count on obtaining an over-all majority in any future elections under the present electoral system that they wished to allow the people to decide in what way Deputies should be elected in future.
It was not a member of the Opposition who said that. We have been saying it all the time but the Taoiseach is saying it now, that it is because Fianna Fáil could not obtain a majority that they are going to the country in this manner. Surely it is unfair for them to change the rules of the game when it suits them. The advantage of setting up this committee is that the people would see that here was a committee representing all Parties in the Dáil and Seanad, which would remove the impression that this Bill is being promoted to perpetuate a Party. The Taoiseach is advancing in years and many people expected he would not be here this week but if he cares to be present another week that is his business. However, it is very bad policy to try to perpetuate a Party in office. Who can be sure of anything in this world? If this change comes about it could act as a boomerang on the Fianna Fáil Party.
When Deputy Carew was speaking about the abolition of P.R. in the North, Deputy Cunningham, I think, said it would make no difference whatever here. Does he forget the gerrymandering that was done in Derry under this new system? The same thing could happen in Kilkenny and in Dublin. If there was a surplus in one constituency they could remove that surplus to another constituency and create another surplus there. Deputy Cunningham could not see that there would be exactly the same results here as in the North. In Derry City where there is a large majority of Nationalists, a majority of Unionists are sitting on the council due to the gerrymandering of that area.
I have already mentioned the difference between strong Government and good Government. We have the fruits of strong Government. I was speaking in Callan on an occasion when Fianna Fáil supporters were distributing handbills printed by the Irish Press saying: “Let us go ahead again.” It gave me an idea: to where are we going ahead? Are we to go ahead as we did in 1952 when under the Budget of that year Fianna Fáil took away half of the subsidies? We were wondering would we take away the other half and they were hardly back in Government when they removed it and put up the price of essential foods.
It is very hard for a man, employed or unemployed, nowadays to live in reasonable conditions. There is a great deal of unemployment, leading to emigration. Last Saturday week in Kilkenny a woman told me that the seventh of her eight sons had gone to England. I knew that woman and her family well and they had come to me to help them obtain jobs on the corporation building scheme. They were anxious to work and were physically able to do good work as I found out from the engineer. Every building scheme closed down and when I went to the Minister for Local Government about building in Kilkenny he said: "Do not mention unemployment. That has no bearing on it." I tried to put a hardship case. The former Minister had sanctioned a full scheme and the present Minister had cut it down to half. He said unemployment had nothing to do with it. I went to him on behalf of the people I represent——
Comment on this
I am pointing out what strong Government means. If he was not a member of a strong Government he would not have said that. He would have said: "We have three Deputies in Kilkenny. If I do not at least investigate the unemployment situation in Kilkenny I shall not be carrying out my duty." However, words of his have become famous in this country: "If this Bill goes through Fine Gael will have had it." He is only a few hours away from the Bill going through and he will have his heart's desire. I am sure the Minister for Local Government will be delighted to think that Fine Gael will have had it. However, if this change is made it is not Fine Gael or any other Party who will have had it but the people for generations to come.
No matter what propaganda goes out from the Government and the Party opposite, no matter how much money they collect, in whatever way they collect it and whatever machine they use, the people can be trusted to take the right decision. If the Bill had been rushed through last December the people would have been at a disadvantage, but now they have seen the difference between P.R. and the single member dictatorship. The people will not stand for dictatorship. The Minister for Local Government will be proved wrong, and the people will not have had it. They will say, "no" when they are called on to vote and I have no doubt that they will also say "MacEoin" in the Presidential Election.
Comment on this
Most of us are inclined to forget a very important thing, that the electorate of this country who are under 59 years of age know only one system of election, that is, P.R. All under 59 years of age are ignorant of the method of election known as the straight vote. It is essential to point out to them the difference between election by P.R. and election by what Fianna Fáil like to call the straight vote.
A Bill was introduced here last October or November. The Opposition were upbraided because they dared oppose it. The Seanad was upbraided because they dared oppose and defeat it. Today we are being told by Fianna Fáil: "You are trying to waste the time of the House by talking this matter out." I think the nation owes a vote of thanks to the Opposition for the manner in which they have talked this matter out, because all the electorate under 59 years of age would not know what this Bill was about or why a referendum is being held were it not for the manner in which the facts have been presented to them by the Opposition speakers. For that reason they have done a service to the nation.
Every speaker on this side and in the Labour, the Clann na Talmhan and Independent benches has done a very good service to the nation by explaining to them from this forum what is meant by this Bill. I wonder what would have happened if no opposition had been offered here and the Bill became an Act, came before the country and the people were asked to mark a cross before "Yes" or "No". What percentage of the electorate at that stage would know what it was all about? I am afraid very few indeed of those under the age of 59.
Having justified our action in talking it out, we now come to the question as to why we should have this Bill before us at all. The people had a Constitution in 1922. That Constitution was accepted, and it worked perfectly for 15 years. The present Taoiseach and his Party decided to amend the Constitution in 1937. In my opinion the big thing in the Constitution of 1922 and in the Constitution of 1937 is proportional representation. If the Taoiseach had any doubts as to the virtue of that particular Article in the Constitution of 1937 he should have brought it to the notice of the Irish people, but he now tells us that even in 1937 he had his doubts.
He says the Irish people had a Magna Charta in 1937 in Bunreacht na hÉireann, the Irish Constitution. But the Taoiseach says he doubted very much if the Irish people would have accepted it if the electoral system was amended by the abolition of proportional representation. Surely that is a fraud? I think that is a downright fraud. It is pulling the wool across the eyes of the Irish people, by saying: "Look, accept this Constitution. There is one of the good Articles in it —an electoral system by which minorities will be represented in Parliament and will have the forum of the Parliament to voice their opinions. I am putting that in but immediately I get the chance I shall take it out. There are doubts at the back of my mind today in 1937, but unfortunately I cannot afford to express my doubts because, if I do, you will not accept this Magna Charta we are offering." The Taoiseach decided to let sleeping dogs lie and did not bother any more about it. It never worried him until 1948. Something happened in 1948 which created grave doubts in his mind as to the advantages of proportional representation.
What caused those grave doubts? Those doubts were caused by a number of Parties representing different political opinions coming together and deciding to work for the benefit of the nation as a whole. Remember the time that that occurred in 1948. It occurred in the month of February. Up in my own constituency, two months before, the present Tánaiste appeared; and what was the picture he painted for the Irish people? He said to them: "You are facing the three blackest years in the history of this country economically and financially." He said that, to try and pull us out of the mire, he would impose certain taxes. The Irish people believed the Tánaiste and said: "This is serious. He evidently meant what he said because he has imposed these penal taxes."
The Irish people hastened to listen to the voices of Fine Gael, Labour, Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta and the Independents who said: "We do not believe that this nation is facing this critical time which the Tánaiste says it is." Each of those Parties asked the electorate to elect them to office. The electorate did not elect them to office but gave them a majority over Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that the Coalition Parties had not got a majority over Fianna Fáil in 1948.
Comment on this
Does the Minister agree with me that those gentlemen there, representing independent interests here, were right in voting for any Government they wished?
Comment on this
My argument is that the people did not believe the then Tánaiste that this country was in the dire economic and financial state in which the Tánaiste said it was. Sinking their differences, all those Parties decided to come together and work on a common platform to prove that by co-operation between them they could pull the State out of this mire into which the Tánaiste said it was sinking.
I put it to the Minister that they did pull it out of the mire. What was the first thing they did? The only visible evidence of mire was the imposition of penal taxes. Is that not so? They abolished them right on the spot. Not only did they do that but they saw that this country at that time was reeking with tuberculosis and no effort was being made by the then Government to house those unfortunate patients. Not only did they take away those penal taxes but they found money for the erection of sanatoria all over the country. When did they do that? In the days when Fianna Fáil told us we were facing the greatest financial and economic crisis this State had ever known. How did they do it? By coming together, pooling their plans, getting the best out of the policy of each Party and cooperating. That is what they did in the years when Fianna Fáil were prophesying disaster for the future. But they did it so well that they created a doubt in the mind of the Taoiseach.
Then the Taoiseach said: "We are up against a problem. This thing is going so well that the first chance we get we shall nip it in the bud. We shall leave this State with two Parties, and two Parties only." Now let there be no doubt whatever about this. Fine Gael is based on the acceptance of the Treaty; they are Treatyites. That was the foundation of the Fine Gael Party. I am not saying what Fianna Fáil are now but they were anti-Treatyites. That was the difference between the two big Parties in this State. But there were a number of Parties, such as Clann na Poblachta, Clann na Talmhan and Labour, who said: "To hell with the Treaty, the Treatyites and the anti-Treatyites, let us try and get together." What does the Taoiseach say? "No, we still have two Parties, Treatyites and anti-Treatyites. That is what I want. Let history decide which was right."
I shall not debate the merits of the Treaty. Like the Minister, I was probably going around in skirts at the time. The less I know about what occurred at the time the better. But it is a pity that we should perpetuate that difference. It is a pity we should try to wipe out Labour, Farmers, Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta and Independents. My good friend over there, Deputy Davern, on one occasion when I was saying it was a pity that Labour and Farmers should go, said: "We have all those in the Fianna Fáil Party." Is that not the clue to the whole thing? In other words: "We represent all interests in this State; therefore, there should be only one Party, namely, Fianna Fáil." Another Deputy said the same thing. It was said by way of interjection, but I think it was letting the cat out of the bag. Does the Minister agree with one Party being elected to a democratic Parliament such as this?
Comment on this
Very good. Therefore the Minister agrees there should be at least two Parties? More than one? Why should not new Parties, if they wish to creep up, have an opportunity——
Comment on this
The Minister for Defence will remember when the Labour Party first came into being in England. It came into being or rather gained momentum and strength during the first World War.
Comment on this
Exactly, how long would it have remained in petticoats were it not for that uplifting of what I might call the lower middle classes during the first World War? Suppose for a second that Gael Linn want to voice their policy and views by electing members to this House. Political Parties do not spring up as mushrooms in this State of ours. They proceed as Clann na Poblachta did, that is, by getting a candidate in now and another in again and by using this forum for putting their policy before the people. Eventually, they are able, possibly, to elect a Party which will have some weight either in Government or in Opposition. But, under the straight vote, they have not a hope in hell of electing a Deputy to this House.
Suppose for a second the people of rural Ireland decided they wanted to elect a farmer candidate. Must he join one of the two Parties in order to get representation here? The Minister says he must join either Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael. However, the policy of the farmer might clash with the policy of either of the two big Parties in the House. If it does, he has to swallow the policy he is advocating and accept the policy of one or other of the two Parties. He will be left in the wilderness if he does not do that. That is one of the Taoiseach's arguments.
The Minister for Health went down the country and said, in effect: "I think, under the straight vote, that what will happen is that the best candidate, the most popular candidate, the most influential candidate in each constituency, will be elected irrespective of the Party to which he belongs." Supposing that happens and supposing we have 146 Independent Deputies coming in here. Surely the first thing we would have to do would be to form an inter-Party Government. They would have to form themselves into groups—rural groups, urban groups, Gaeltacht groups and probably Masonic groups. Then they would have to coalesce amongst themselves and come to produce some agreed policy. Would that be a proper system?
I think the electoral system we have is an ideal one. Let me take as an example the constituency which I have the honour to represent with Deputies Breslin and J. Brennan. Suppose for a second that in my constituency a supporter of Deputy Breslin is dissatisfied with the manner in which he is looking after a particular matter. He has the right to turn to me, as the opposite number.
Comment on this
Sure—because he knows he has us on our toes. We have to be on our toes because if I do not work for my constituent and my supporter he will very soon go to Deputy Breslin or to Deputy J. Brennan. I shall take care that I shall work for him and he will not go to them—and Deputy Breslin and Deputy J. Brennan will do the same thing for their supporters. They know well that if a constituent is dissatisfied with them he will switch over to me very quickly. We can hold up West Donegal as an example to most constituencies. All the Deputies there are on their toes, which is a very good thing.
Suppose one Deputy only represents my constituency. Suppose he happens to be Deputy Breslin or myself. I know who is voting for me just as Deputy Breslin knows who is voting for him. We know our supporters. What chance has the opposite number, the person who supported the defeated candidate, of getting cothrom na féinne from the elected Deputy? None whatever. What is worse, if that Deputy is a Party hack—I am not saying he is one side or the other—what say exactly has the local convention in his election? We have had examples of it. I shall quote only Fianna Fáil. You remember the by-election in Wicklow. The local convention selected a candidate but the Party bosses said, in effect: "No, we do not want him. You will take our man. If you do not take our man, out you get."
What would it be like, I wonder, if there were only one Deputy for a constituency? That Deputy would be selected by the Party bosses in Dublin and that Deputy would eventually reap the fruits of office in the profession of which he happened to be a member, be he a farmer, lawyer, doctor or anything else. He will move on and his successor, again, would be nominated by the Party bosses in Dublin, and so on down through the years with the result that, after a few generations, the elected Deputies would probably live in Dublin City and have no contact whatsoever with their constituents, as happens in England to-day. They would live in the City of Dublin.
Comment on this
Remember that, if some of my own do that, the people, under P.R., have an opportunity of throwing them out. Under the direct vote, they will not have a hope of throwing out a man of that type because he will be the nominee of the Party boss and he is the big chief and what he says goes.
I am referring to what Fianna Fáil hope there will be, namely, two Parties and two Parties only. While a Deputy was speaking the other day and referring to the two-Party system in the North he was interrupted by Deputy Booth who said that the Government is elected by the will of the people. Do Deputies here subscribe to the view that Stormont is elected by the will of the people in the Six Counties? Will any person here stand over that statement by Deputy Booth? We who live on the Border have some experience of gerrymandering. Derry, Fermanagh, Tyrone, South Armagh are left without representation despite the fact that the Nationalists there have a majority of the votes. However, by the manipulation of gerrymandering, they are left without representation. Suppose we had a strong Government and a weak Opposition here and suppose we came to revise the constituencies, as we would have to do every ten years. Suppose that strong Government had the say in the revision of the constituencies, I wonder if we would have gerrymandering here? Does anybody doubt that we have had gerrymandering here? I think that is one of the strongest reasons why we should oppose this Bill.
There is another matter to which Deputy McGilligan referred. On the occasion of the last referendum, there were local elections. One of the reasons advanced at that time for having the local elections and the referendum on the same day was that there were no politics in local authorities, that the members were not elected on Party lines, that, in the main, they were independent and that their supporters would be coming out to vote and that it would be an opportunity to bring them out to vote. Despite that, as Deputy McGilligan has pointed out, 100,000 electors who came out to vote in the local elections refused or failed to cast their votes in the referendum. If an elector wishes to vote for one of the two candidates for the Presidency, or one of the three, if there are three, and goes to the polling booth and demands a ballot paper, will the referendum ballot paper be pushed into his hand or, if he wants to vote in the referendum and demands a referendum ballot paper, will the ballot paper for the Presidential election be pushed into his hand? If it is, surely that is intimidation, because he has to return the paper and there is a duty and an onus on the returning officer to see that every ballot paper handed out by him goes into the box.
When this matter was first mooted, the Taoiseach assured us that there would be no other election on the same day as the referendum, that the people would have an opportunity there and then of expressing their views for or against proportional representation. He then changed his mind, without expressing a view, and hinted that it might be possible that we would have the two elections on the same day.
Immediately Fine Gael announced their intention of putting Deputy MacEoin forward as a candidate for the Presidency, the Taoiseach, as a political stroke, had to counteract that and threw himself into the fray, not, in my opinion, in the hope that he would go to the Park—I do not believe that the man ever wanted to go to the Park. I think it is breaking his heart to leave that front seat—but because he is being pushed. The reason he is being pushed is, not to make him President, but to carry the referendum, in the hope that the name of the Taoiseach will encourage all Fianna Fáil supporters to come out and vote, not only for him, but for his policy, as they did in the past, without even knowing what it is.
As I said the other day, Fianna Fáil played their cards and, in the end—I do not say it in any way disrespectfully— they produce the joker and they hope the joker will win the trick. I do not say that in any disrespectful manner to the Taoiseach.
He will have the right to nominate his successor as Taoiseach. The ambition of his Party is that he will go to the Park, that he will nominate his successor as Taoiseach, that the referendum will be carried and that his Party will remain in office for at least another generation. Not only does he write his last will and testament, but wants to see it probated as well. That, in my opinion, is exactly what they are endeavouring to do by holding these two most important elections on the same day.
As I said at the outset, we have performed our duty in the proper manner to the nation by endeavouring to enlighten the electorate, particularly all those under 59 years of age who knew only the proportional representation system of election. We have done a great day's work for the nation by educating the electorate into the disadvantages of doing away with a system which has worked so satisfactorily since the foundation of this State.
Comment on this
This is the final stage of this debate and, as Deputy O'Donnell has said, it gives every Deputy a further chance of putting his views before the House. The charge that we on this side of the House have held up the debate unnecessarily is unwarranted, especially when one reflects on the seriousness of the subject. It is a very important matter and it is only right that it should get the fullest possible discussion, preparatory to its being put to the people.
The Taoiseach has a motion before the House in which he asks this House to deem a certain Bill to have been passed by the Seanad. That is a very unsatisfactory way of dealing with a Bill that has been fully discussed in the Seanad and defeated there. We are asked to assume that it has been passed by another part of the Oireachtas. A Bill comes before the House and is passed or defeated. This Bill, as we know, has been defeated in the Seanad after very frank and full discussion. Now, under the Constitution, it must come back to the Dáil and the Taoiseach asks that we should deem it to have been passed by the Seanad.
It is very interesting to contrast the methods of discussing this subject in the Dáil and in the Seanad. When the Bill was discussed in the Dáil some months ago, on the various Stages, it was passed by a Party vote. It then went to the Seanad and was defeated on a non-Party vote. That is very significant. In the Seanad, there are men of all shades of political opinion, men experienced in economic and political affairs, who are unbiased. They gave their decision and defeated the Bill. That is in sharp contrast with the result in this House. As Deputy O'Donnell has said, if the discussion on the Bill does nothing but draw people's attenton to the seriousness of the matter, it will have done a great deal.
In opposition to the Taoiseach's motion, there is a Fine Gael amendment which asks that the matter be referred to a commission composed of members of both Houses of the Oireachtas. To my mind, that might be rather dangerous because, human nature being what it is, vested interests might creep in, unavoidably. My personal opinion is that, if a commission were set up, it should be composed of impartial men of good standing, having no immediate connection with any part of the Oireachtas. However, I agree with the principle of setting up—shall we call it a court of inquiry? At least, it would mean that the issue could be put to the people with a certain degree of unanimity, that Party bitterness would be avoided and the people would be able, calmly and dispassionately, to assess the implications of the two systems. It is obvious that the amendment will not be accepted. This issue will be decided now on a Party basis. Deputies will be addressing the electorate throughout the country at weekends and they will appeal to the Party loyalties of the people; they will ask the people to vote in a certain way on this issue.
I do not think that is the proper way to tackle this matter because people will be blinded by their Party loyalties and they will not be able, objectively and dispassionately, to give a decision for or against, in the absence of a careful examination of all the implications inherent in the issue. It is more than significant that the two elections will be held in the same day. The Taoiseach is entering the Presidential contest. I think, in company with many others, that the Taoiseach is holding the referendum on the same day as the Presidential election for the express purpose of attracting out to vote the lukewarm Fianna Fáil supporter. If the two issues were decided separately on different days, it could easily happen that many Fianna Fáil supporters would not bother to come out to vote either for or against the abolition of P.R. I am convinced that many Fianna Fáil supporters throughout the country are quite satisfied to leave things as they are. They do not want this change. But when they see the name of Eamon de Valera on the Presidential ballot paper, they will feel impelled to vote for him out of a sense of loyalty and, having voted for him, they will go on and vote in the referendum.
It is admitted on this side of the House that there are defects in the present system. As I pointed out on an earlier occasion, a man can head the poll on the first count and yet be defeated. That happened at the last election in Galway. The man who headed the poll on the first count was eventually eliminated. Under the present system, too, we have the situation where a man who heads the poll with a large surplus draws in with him his colleague who may lie at the bottom of the poll. These are two glaring defects in the present system. That is one reason why I suggest this inquiry should be held in an effort to eradicate and eliminate such defects. There may be others.
When, however, we come to consider the proposed new system, we find that a man can easily be returned as the elected representative of the people in a constituency and yet not command the majority support of the people in that constituency. If for no other reason, an inquiry should be held for the purpose of examining into such a situation as that. It would redound to the credit of Fianna Fáil and to the credit of the Taoiseach if they would now accept this amendment. If this inquiry were set up, there would then be no further bitterness and there would be no regrets. The issue could be put to the people on a unanimous recommendation from this House.
It has been stated on many occasions by Fianna Fáil speakers in answer to criticisms which have come from this side of the House that it is the people who will decide. Of course, it is the people who will decide. It is only right and proper that they should decide. But the people should only be asked to decide an issue calling for a change for which they themselves have clamoured. They have not demanded this change. The Taoiseach has stated, here and elsewhere, that going around the country since 1948, he was asked on various occasions to abolish P.R. and bring in the straight vote. I am not aware of anyone in my constituency clamouring for that change. It is very significant that the Taoiseach made that statement only after he was defeated in 1948 and again after he was defeated in 1954. It appears now that the people were not clamouring for such a change prior to 1948. They were not demanding a change between 1932 and 1948. It was only after the accession to power of the two coalition Governments that the supposed clamour was noticed.
The charge is being made against us that we are preventing the issue from going to the people. That is a nonsensical charge to make, especially when one remembers that Fianna Fáil have a majority of 17 or 18 in this House, for all practical purposes. The combined Opposition know that Fianna Fáil can carry this issue, and will carry it. It is our duty, however, to insist on a discussion of this matter, a matter of grave import for the future of the country. The straight vote, if carried, will govern all future elections. For that reason, it is only right and proper that the matter should be fully discussed here.
There is one particular danger I can see resulting from this change. It might easily mean that we will have a preponderance of urban representation. There will be only one seat in each constituency. The bulk of the population reside in the towns. In each constituency, there will probably be one or two towns. The man who can attract the majority of the votes in the urban areas will most probably be an urban representative. His election will be detrimental to the rural population in that constituency, unless specifically rural constituencies are established. We shall have to await the outcome of the proposed commission before we shall know what the position will be.
In recent weeks, since this Bill came back from the Seanad, there is apparent in the country, reflected in the national Press, a growing realisation of the serious implications inherent in the Bill. When the suggestion was first mooted by the Taoiseach and when the Bill was introduced here, comparatively little notice was taken of it. The discussion which took place here and in the Seanad has brought to the people generally a realisation of the importance of this issue. I feel confident that they will vote wholeheartedly against the proposed change. We must remember, however, that many people who walk into the polling booth to vote on this issue will become somewhat confused when they read the official jargon on the ballot paper. They will not know whether to put "yes" or "no", respectively, in the squares.
Before they go in, they may have their minds fully made up to vote in a certain way, but when they get inside, they may get mixed up and put down "no" when they mean "yes" and vice versa. It is only right, therefore, that we should fully inform the people as to the implications of this, and as to the meaning of the question on the ballot paper, what it means actually. As a result of that difficult question on the ballot paper, this issue can be won and lost by default, by many people not realising they are making a mistake in putting “yes” where they meant to put “no”. Whatever the result of this issue, but especially if it is passed, it will not be a true reflection of the wish of the people because that wish will hinge on their Party loyalties.
I believe the two elections, the referendum election and the Presidential election, should be separated. I held the opposite view about that on the Second Stage, and I expressed the hope then that the elections would be held on the same day, if only for the reason of saving a certain amount of expense. Since then, I have been converted to the view that the two issues should be separated, not only to try to get a definite reflection of the opinions of the people, but also so that they will not be distracted by the attraction of the magnetic name of Eamon de Valera. The fact that the Presidential election and the referendum are being held on the same day will damage the ability of the people to give a proper and fair indication of their desire in this matter.
As I said before, there are other far more pressing problems to be tackled throughout the country at the present time. We have the high rate of emigration, and the high rate of unemployment, and it would suit the Government and the whole House better, if they tackled or tried, in a genuine way, to tackle the more pressing problems. I doubt that this change, if it is brought about, will solve or will help to make it easy to sole, the pressing problems which beset us.
I am convinced that there is an ulterior motive in the mind of the Taoiseach and in the mind of Fianna Fáil, in general, in bringing this motion to the House. I am convinced that this is a move to try to perpetuate their continuance in office, especially when they will no longer have the binding influence of the Taoiseach when he retires from politics—and it appears that that day is not far distant. It may be difficult for Fianna Fáil in those circumstances to remain a cohesive and united Party and I believe that in future, when the Taoiseach retires, they will find it rather difficult to command the support of the people which they command at the present time.
Therefore, I think there is really an ulterior motive in trying to change to the straight vote system. The reason put forward by the Taoiseach for the introduction of this measure is that P.R. leads to instability of government and irresponsibility in government. As I said before, if Fianna Fáil press this reason, they must admit that it is a reflection on themselves, and on their past periods of office since 1932, because they were elected under the P.R. system. If, therefore, the P.R. system results in instability and irresponsibility Fianna Fáil have been irresponsible and unstable for the past number of years. We must remember that under the P.R. system they have a majority to-day of 17 and that majority, in this comparatively small Parliament, is sufficient for them to implement their various plans and economic proposals, without seeking to consolidate themselves completely.
As the leader of the Opposition said, we are coming to the end of an era in this country and no one knows what is in front of us. An attempt, such as the attempt now being made, to change the system of election is, to my mind, fraught with great danger. Hints have been thrown out that a spirit of unrest and, possibly worse, might result under the straight vote system. I would hesitate to contribute to that view, because I should not like to hold the opinion that this spirit of unrest should be encouraged by any kind of inflammatory speech.
Deputy Dillon appealed to the Taoiseach even at this eleventh hour to accept the amendment. I should like to endorse that appeal even at this eleventh hour and a half. I am convinced it will not be accepted, but we would be failing in our duty if we did not press the amendment, and the importance and the efficacy of the amendment, on the Taoiseach in so far as possible.
I have not very much more to say except to comment briefly on the setup envisaged in the proposed commission which may revise the constituencies if the Bill goes through. There are to be seven men on the commission: three from the Fianna Fáil benches, three from the Opposition benches, with a neutral chairman to be appointed by the President. If the three Fianna Fáil members and the three Opposition members of the commission do not agree on any plan for the revision of the constituencies, the Chairman, the seventh man on the commission, may present his plan for the proposed revision, and that plan will be accepted, even thought it is the work of only one individual. The job of recarving and reshaping the constituencies, if it ever happens, is too big for one man, and he should not be given that terrible power, as I would put it, the power to decide on the new constituencies. His suggestions will be accepted in their entirety by the President. That is a very wrong and very unsuitable arrangement.
Mention has been made of the fact that under the straight vote system the people will have no choice of candidate. That is quite true because no Party will put forward more than one candidate for one seat in a constituency. If the people in a constituency do not like the candidate of a particular Party, it could easily result in their abstaining from voting and you would have a reduced vote. That would be bad because it would mean we would not have a reflection of the majority opinion of the people.
They may be in favour of voting for the particular Party but they may not be in favour of voting for the particular candidate and therfore they would abstain from voting. Under the present system, the people have at least two candidates from whom to choose their favourite; sometimes they have three and sometimes they have four. They will pick the man they think best to represent them. When they are confined to voting blindly for one person, it is bad.
I express the hope that this Bill, whenever it does go to the people, will be overwhelmingly defeated, as I think it will be defeated. I think the people are satisfied with the present system of election. It is the system they know. The Taoiseach himself said that in 1937 when he said it is the system we know and that it has worked well. I forget the other utterances of the Taoiseach in defence of proportional representation but I do know that he was a champion of it in 1937. It is significant that since 1948, after two defeats, he has thought the time opportune to make the change he wants made.
Comment on this
We have before us an amendment and I do not think it is too much to ask the Government Party to accept it. It merely asks that an independent body not tinged with any political bias should report on the system of election. The Taoiseach is not prepared to accept that. Instead he proposes to bulldoze this proposal through the House just as he tried to bulldoze it through in the middle of winter for the purpose of preventing the people from knowing all the facts.
There is no support outside this House for this proposal. Not one of the Fianna Fáil cumainn throughout the country asked for it. Only the Taoiseach asked for it and of course "yes" men have to say "yes" but I know that a lot of them throughout the country are saying "no." Not even the local Fianna Fáil cumainn have asked for it.
Different arguments have been put forward in support of the change. One Minister says one thing and another says something else. It has been said that it was imposed on us by the British and for that reason it must go. It was imposed on the North of Ireland by the British and the Taoiseach used to say that it would have to go there. He is not saying that to-night but he is saying that proportional representation must go here. He also says that we must have stability in government. That is a vote of no confidence in his own Party because Fianna Fáil now have the largest majority ever given to a Party in this House and still the Taoiseach says that there is no stability.
We have had a quarter of a century of Fianna Fáil rule and what have we after it? We have unemployment, emigration, pessimism, railways closing down all over the country and, worse still, no faith in democracy. That is the most dangerous point we have ever reached in our history. The Taoiseach has spoken about everything but the thing he was elected to do—to deal with the problems of unemployment and emigration. That is what he and his Party were sent into this House to do and yet we have such unemployment and emigration as were never known before. They have pulled this political red herring across the path to take the people's attention from the problems facing the country.
At the recent Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis, the Taoiseach said they would all have to take off their coats but now he himself has thrown in the towel. He has lost faith in us and in the country. He is not going on any platform throughout the country. I know the amount of hard work that has been done by the Party. The Taoiseach says that we must abolish P.R. in order to get stable Government, but if the Taoiseach would abolish what he was sent here to abolish, unemployment and emigration, the people would have more faith in democracy.
I ask the Taoiseach, at this last minute, to accept the amendment proposed. It would be one of the biggest things he could do, but I suppose he would find it too hard to swallow his words.
Comment on this
Some Deputies who have spoken recently have voiced some hope that the Government would accept the motion in the names of Deputy Costello and myself. I do not speak with any hope of that. The 13th of May, 1959, will be a rather interesting date in Irish history. I do not know much about the history of the Parliament that passed the Act of Union and wiped itself out as a Parliament, but I do know a lot about the history of this House.
I do know that this motion will be passed by the strength of the Fianna Fáil vote in this House and that that vote will be analogous to the vote that passed the Act of Union and wiped itself out as an Irish Parliament. It will be a vote in an Irish Parliament attempting to weaken and destroy the foundations on which this House is based. We all know the need there is, in the light of the work that requires to be done by an Irish Parliament in relation to Irish conditions and the difficulties that confront us, for a secure and stable Parliament, built on the complete support of the people and working with their closest co-operation. If the intention of the vote of the Government Party tonight is carried into actual effect, and the foundations on which this Parliament is based were weakened in the way the Government proposal would weaken them, then the hopes with which this Parliament was set up would be completely dashed.
We are being asked to subscribe to a proposal that would go to the people as the recommendation from the Parliamentary majority that minorities should be allowed no chance of any representation in this House. That is the definite proposal: that the value of the Irish vote, and the restrictive way in which it would be cast, would be such that no minority would be able to appear in this House. We have had an example in the North of Ireland of how that has worked there, the effect it has had on Parliament, which it has nullified, and the effect which it has had on the minority section of the Parliament in the North of Ireland whose political powers it has completely atrophied with all that that implies.
The proposal, therefore, as I say, is so to weaken and destroy the foundations of this Parliament that the action of the Government to-night, in putting their full voting power behind their proposal, as against standing back and allowing it to be examined as the amendment suggests, is analogous to the vote cast when the Act of Union was passed in a previous Irish Parliament. We oppose that. We stand by an Irish Parliament in which the minority sections of the country can be represented with confidence. By permitting them to have their say and influence there, we retain for them a Parliament which they can respect, support and co-operate with.
This House, since its establishment, has had very many tragic moments. It has shown itself, in its ordinary days, to be a place where men of every Party, from every part of the country and every walk of life, can mix in harmony and friendship. Even in the course of the long debate that has taken place here on this issue, that aspect has shown itself. There is, however, one thing in this House which completely nullifies all that. When the drums beat on the 12th July in the North of Ireland the whole atmosphere is changed and people who would ordinarily salute one another and co-operate one with another, change completely. Here the division bells, and the hissing whisper of orders and instructions of one kind and another, have a much more frequent and even much more alarming effect on the Fianna Fáil vote in this House. We have had a situation here in which this House, great and all as has been its strength, and much as it has done for the country, has been hamstrung by reason of the fact that a large Party in this House regard themselves as an Ascendancy.
They are a Party who object to allowing anybody in this House, in Parliament, or in the country, to have any power but themselves. They object to any Party, or anybody in this country, getting any credit for any achievement, for having any brains and intelligence, or for having any national feeling but themselves. That is the blemish which is on this House. Perhaps this is the darkness here before the dawn when the people will have an opportunity of having their say, and the sound of the voices with which they will make their say on the Government's proposal to keep minorities out of this House perhaps will scatter the malignant spirit that holds a great Party in this House. Many people, with fine ideas and all that, will break the malignant spirit that brings so much of malice so much of dissension and so much of the Ascendancy spirit into the ringing of the division bell, and into the Party-whispered instructions.
I say that this House has had many tragic moments. It was founded in January, 1919, and though it was not internationally recognised it had great strength, great force, and great achievements. Where did the strength come from? Did it come from one Party? Did it come from two, or three, or four Parties? It came from the strength of the whole people banded together to stand simply by their own intelligence, by their own devotion to Ireland as a nation, and by their own confidence and comradeship with one another; standing together as a force, as a people, with an institution that they called our Parliament, as the institution to which they looked for guidance and protection and regarded as a symbol of their spirit and industry.
Where did it lead? Some speaker on history recently said history should not be an argument; it should be a conversation. We have not reached a time here in Ireland where history can safely be a conversation. I do not wish to discuss any aspect of history at this particular moment except by way of conversation and merely to put into its perspective the work we are doing here today. I say the Parliament established in January, 1919, representing nothing but a people, a united people in spite of differences of tradition, both politically and otherwise, nevertheless stood for a united people. We can just get one comment, in the conversational way in which people in England can discuss history with one another, on it.
Thornton in The Imperial Idea And Its Enemies, referring to the position in Ireland said:
The case of Ireland made it clear to everyone that the British Empire could no longer be assumed to stand foursquare on a basis of unchallengeable power. For the Sinn Féin movement had challenged that power, and had challenged it successfully. They won Home Rule, denied to generation of Irish Nationalist parliamentarians, in a campaign of terrorism and crime. They won it not because they had superior military force. For England to ‘hold' Ireland in 1922 would have required the tactics of Strongbow, Essex, and Cromwell combined. England had bigger forces at her disposal still Cromwell had possessed: but employment of their tactics was not a practicable imperial policy.
A Parliament was internationally established in 1922 and we must ask ourselves what had the people stood up against? They had stood up against an attack on their liberties that began in 1912 and 1913, when another ascendancy Party, with an ascendancy spirit in Great Britain, thought they could ride roughshod even over a statute of the British House of Commons and, as another English historian, in a conversational way, writing about English history in the way in which they can apparently among themselves write today, described the situation that arose there as a rebellion against Parliament and a rebellious movement which would have destroyed Parliamentary institutions in Great Britain if the world war of 1914 had not broken out.
There was an ascendency spirit at that time in Great Britain. After that, there was the attempt to enforce conscription during the war. After the war for small nations had been won, there was the attempt to destroy the Irish Parliament established in January, 1919. All that came with the Black and Tans and with the arguments, and with the threats of war, and all that kind of thing. The strength of the people here, represented by their Parliament of 1919, was to overcome these forces and to set up this State. The strength of the people, the spirit of the people, and the common sense of the people, and the feeling that they had ideals with regard to life and a tradition with regard to these ideals that would withstand the gun that Pearse withstood, the imprisonment MacSwiney withstood and the torture that Ashe withstood, were all responsible for this Parliament being set up.
This Parliament had its moments of tragedy. The Taoiseach is well aware that I stood in the seat alongside him to answer to this House, and to the people, for an action taken to defend this House from being wiped out of existence by the assassination of the Deputies, one by one. We have come to establish our Parliament through terror and through struggle in arms, but in arms not simply for the sake of arms, but as showing the spirit that lay behind them. If we have had this struggle outside, we are quite aware that the stepping stones to this House are smeared with our own blood. We know how many died unnecessarily, in one way or another. The people, with the political plans they laid for electing this House and holding this House, have maintained this House and the path to this House could not have been maintained in the way it was maintained if it had not been for the spirit of our people, which is in their veins and in their minds and in their traditions and ideals.
If we tamper with the foundations, and tamper with the stream through which there flows into this House the spirit of our people, we are doing something to destroy what is our people's strength.
We are reducing ourselves, temporarily, at any rate, to what Parliament in the North of Ireland has been reduced, where an ascendancy holds itself, through unscrupulous means, in greater strength than it would otherwise have; where Parliamentary life is non-existent and where the political strength of the greater part of the minorities is completely atrophied.
The proposal which it is attempted to put across is in the spirit which I characterise in my own way, as the spirit that wiped out the Act of Union, the spirit that meant the Conservative Party in 1912 and 1913 trampled on British institutions and traditions in order to prevent our people from having a Parliament of its own. That spirit, with all kinds of suggestions, innuendoes and misrepresentations, denies that the electoral system upon which the Parliament is based, was based on Irish ideals and the Irish spirit and that it was intended to give, and did give, a reflection in our Parliament of the spirit that sought for unity and institutions that would represent the people.
In May, 1921, as I have said before, the Taoiseach issued a proclamation affirming the aims of Sinn Féin. He declared and I quote:-
The policy of Sinn Féin remains unchanged. It stands for the right of this nation to determine freely for themselves how they shall be governed and for the right of every citizen to an equal voice in the determination; it stands for civil and religious equality and for the full proportional representation and all possible safeguarding of minorities.
We are told by the same Taoiseach that proportional representation was forced upon the country in order to trick the people who stood for achieving nationalism and in order to divide and split the people. Then, the other day he told us that it was because Fianna Fáil could not count on obtaining an over-all majority in any future election under the present electoral system that they had decided to allow the people to decide by what system Dáil members would be elected in the future. To allow the people to decide——
Comment on this
I am sorry; it was in the Irish Independent for 27th April, 1959. I am sure it was in the Irish Press, too. We are asked that an informed people should be allowed to decide. In the last hours of this debate, we have been left here with no voice speaking from the Government benches, while voice after voice spoke from the opposition benches, and with no attendance except a Parliamentary Secretary for a while and the Minister for Defence.
The Minister for Defence, in helping the people to decide, spoke in Listowel on 24th of January, 1959. I think the extract is from The Kerryman, but if anybody doubts that it is correct, I shall hand it over. The report states:
It is necessary that the Fianna Fáil organisation should be kept at its maximum efficiency in order that the important task of ridding the country of the present dangerous system of election should be successfully accomplished, said Mr. Kevin Boland, Minister for Defence, at a meeting of Listowel Comhairle Ceanntair on Saturday night.
A little over 21 years ago our Party undertook a similar task against the combined opposition of all the elements comprising the coalition of to-day. The object then was to replace the foreign imposed Constitution, which was established on the instructions of Lloyd George and with the aid of British arms by our present opponents, by a Republican Constitution, which will need no alteration when the Six Counties, bartered away by the same people, are regained.
A number of the people here to-day will remember the unscrupulous nature of the campaign that was waged by all the Opposition Parties in their last desperate stand in defence of the British Dominion called the Irish Free State. They will remember the frantic efforts made to mobilise every sectional interest against the enactment of a free Constitution.
Then he referred to—
...those who have stood firm in face of the organised thuggery of the Blueshirts and saved democracy from distinction.
The Minister for Finance, and I quote from The Sunday Press of 26th April, 1959, spoke in Dublin at a 21st Anniversary Dinner of the Irish Constitution. The report says—
Dr. Ryan, who was guest of honour at the function, said this was surprising having regard to the fact that the old Constitution mentioned the King of England 23 times and never mentioned the existence of God.
—all helping the people to decide whether P.R. should go or not.
This House was in being in September, 1925, although it was not recognised by the leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party at that time. Nevertheless sometime in 1925—Deputies who want to get the exact reference can refer to the records of the Inter-Parliamentary Union Congress in Washington and Ottawa in that year —Deputy Tom Johnston, Senator Michael Hayes who was then the Ceann Comhairle of the Dáil, and myself attended the Inter-Parliamentary Congress as the Irish representatives. In front of the full floor of that congress hall, where men from the very east of the world to the west were represented, Deputy Johnston stood up to challenge a statement made by the British Prime Minister at that time about the King of England. The statement was to the effect that when the King of England was at war all the Dominions were at war and so was the Irish Free State.
The Leader of the Labour Party challenged that and challenged it with such effect that the Leader of the British Party, Sir Robert Horne, who was out of the congress hall at the time, came back and found it necessary to answer what Deputy Johnston put up. He had to admit that what the Deputy had said was right, that there was no body who could commit the Irish Free State to war except Dáil Éireann. He added that it was not much use for the Irish to act like children, playing tig, crossing their fingers and saying: "I am not playing" because if there was a strong enemy at war with Great Britain, he could very easily get an excuse for bringing Ireland into war even without the acquiescence of Dáil Éireann.
However, that is where the King of England won in the Constitution that the electorate are being told about in such an informed way in order to prepare them for knocking down the foundation under our Parliament. As for God in the original Constitution, I wonder are the Government not ashamed of themselves that, incorrectly, wrongly, and in that way, they bring the name of God into the question.
Again I ask the Taoiseach: why do we offer up our prayers at the beginning of our daily work? Why do we as individuals pray daily that we may be made partakers of the Divinity of Him who partook of our humanity? I ask that question because it is a vital one in dealing with the foundations upon which you are to build up Parliament. There can be no question of dealing with our constitutional matters by mere arithmetic, by a mere ascendancy spirit directed to material things. We must realise that the spirit of man is a much bigger thing in which to invest, and requires investment more than the development of the resources of the country, any technique or any scientific approach to things.
This House is here only because it reflects the people's wishes and reflects their strength. It is deplorable that this House should be used contrary to the wishes of the people, so that one Ascendancy Party stands in debate against the rest, determined that nobody can have a voice or a say in Parliament or make any contribution to the work of the Government except themselves. If we cannot exercise that right we shall struggle along in the way in which we have been struggling and with the record that is there, but we shall not be conducting the affairs of Parliament in the way in which our people intended. We shall be carrying on the affairs of our Parliament, dating from its establishment in 1922, in a spirit which never informed our political affairs.
By way of referring to the spirit that moved the people in the difficult days when the Parliament of January, 1919 was set up, I should like to quote, as I have previously quoted, from Col. 1314 Vol. 171 of the Dáil Debates of the 2nd December, 1958, what Arthur Griffith said in June, 1912:
If democracy is to survive as a working principle of government it can only survive on the admission of the minority to a share in representation with its strength in the government of the State
That is good enough for 1912 but I should like to go back to the higher reaches of the stream and to quote from the introduction to the first Irish Year Book that Griffith published in 1908. This was a beginning of an Irish encyclopaedia. In it various aspects of Irish life were dealt with for about four years and then stopped when the political work quickened, when the Home Rule Bill came along for discussion, when the Volunteers had to be organised. He had appealed to men of every Party, class and creed to convey in their own way their own experience and their own recommendations with regard to various aspects of Irish Life. The introduction to the book states:
The object of this book is to render available to the whole people of Ireland that information on the affairs of their country which is necessary for their defence and essential to their progress.
Then it goes on:—
...The National Council is responsible for the publication of the Irish Year Book but not for the opinions expressed by any of its contributors. Each contributor is responsible for what he or she has written, and for nothing else in this Book. Our object is to place before All Ireland a book in which All Ireland expresses itself, and when this book was projected we accordingly communicated with men and women of all parties, classes, and creeds in Ireland, inviting them to deal in the Irish Year Book with those subjects in which they were skilled. The response confirmed our faith that Irish Patriotism is the monopoly of no party, no sect, no class, Unionist and Anti-Unionist, Catholic, Protestant, Presbyterian, Methodist and Quaker, the Northern Manufacturer and the Southern Agriculturist, the man of leisure and the man of toil— all are here offering the results of their study and experience to help their country.
He wanted what he called a concise meeting place in Ireland that would represent the spirit of those who showed, in the manner in which they set out to make a contribution to the Year Book, what contribution they wanted to make to develop Irish resources, to overcome and exorcise the antagonisms that were there for historic and other reasons and to help the various classes of society to come together and exchange their views, experiences and ideas in a developing Ireland on every aspect of Irish life, Irish education, Irish agriculture and Irish industry.
So that the ideal and the principle in the foundation of the system of proportional representation that was introduced in our Constitution, and that was introduced in our Constitution in accordance with the quotation from the Taoiseach's statement in May, 1921, as the tradition of Sinn Féin, sprung from the people of all Parties, creeds and classes and sprang from a recognition that what the country needed was a Parliament with representation for each of these sections of the people, where they would know one another, overcome their differences and bring their power of work and thought and co-operation together to advance the affairs of this country under an Irish Parliament.
If the people are being asked to do such a thing, which even the Government in their statement regard as so fundamental to our people, why have they to be misled and distracted and why have the emotions aroused over the spilling of Irish blood at Irish hands, with memories of our early steps here, to be brought into the situation? Is not the very fact that we have these memories, as well as the achievements in between, a warning to us that we have to look to our true traditions, where our teaching and strength come from?
What on earth are we to think of people's concern for this when we hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce speaking of Griffith, his ideals and his works, as the work of an immature political mind? I think he said "like the back-page expressions of an immature political mind." I heard Deputy Tom Kelly, a member of the Fianna Fáil Party, stand up here and speak very emotionally of the great man Griffith was and how he slaved from one end of the week to the other. He might have had 30/- coming in. Then he found himself in the position in which, when he did go and face the British representatives to have it out in the council chamber and find some kind of a formula for reconciliation and mutual working, he had the faith he had when he came back.
I had a similar experience to that in the corridors of this House when one responsible member of the Fianna Fáil Party, in a discussion with me arising out of what Tom Kelly said and my reaction to it, said, with regard to his own leaders: "I would not follow them to-morrow if I knew where to go." I do not mention that for acrimony. I mention it because I feel that at this hour of the day we ought to be to some extent among ourselves in the position in which we can discuss history conversationally, in the same way as the British can discuss things that were of vital import and that have really brought disaster on themselves. Because what the British attitude towards Ireland, as represented by the Conservative plot or rebellion of 1912 and what ultimately flew from that has brought on Ireland has been less in achievement than what it brought on Britain and British interests throughout the world; and what it has brought on Europe and the United States, goodness only knows.
I mention these things because they are known in the hearts and minds of everybody in this House. The difficulties I speak of are as well known to the people who face us as they are to ourselves. It is because I feel that they are as close to Irish sentiment in the past, and knowledge of where Irish strength lies, that I dare to criticise them and face them in this way. We are asked by an Act of this House to suggest to the people that the Irish Parliament wants them to tamper with their foundations here and to keep minority Parties out of the House.
Deputy O'Donnell spoke to-day of the two big Parties and of the people who wanted to have nothing to do with them because of their origins. He could very well know that there are people who supported one or other of these Parties who want to get away from that and want to find themselves in a position in a Party, or at any rate in a position in Parliament, in which they can discuss Irish matters and cooperate on Irish economic matters without having every expression they make and every discussion they have tangled with thoughts of the past. These people are not allowed to escape from the bird lime the Fianna Fáil Party want to lay around everything that was done here with the pure purpose of assembly.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce has been speaking on economic matters. Let us look at just one item of the economic barometer. The figures published for the Budget discussion show that between 1957 and 1958 there was a fall of 10,000 persons in employment. In the same period there was a natural increase in population of 25,000 or 26,000. Going back to 1951, there was a fall in employment of 88,000 people. In 1958, 88,000 fewer people were in employment in the State than in 1951. In every one of these years, the natural increase in the population was there, an increase of 25,000 to 26,000 persons. Therefore, looking at our Ireland in 1958 and comparing it with 1951 we find that approximately 295,000 people are unaccounted for. I regard that as sufficient fact alone to suggest that there are serious problems with regard to employment and production to be attended to here.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce has indicated that the wiping-out of P.R. is very definitely linked with the economic drive. He is a man with long experience in the Department of Industry and Commerce. I suppose he has been in that Department for about 20 years. A White Paper has been published and a grey book has been distributed to pull together all the possible things that could be done in the Irish economy. I wonder if the Taoiseach would tell us how the wiping-out of P.R. would strengthen the people to do the work required to help our people into employment or even to maintain in employment those in employment.
There is much talk today about adult education and about relations between management and labour. Does the Taoiseach not realise that some analogous principles apply between the people and their Government, between workers and their management? In the development of management-labour relations for better production, certain principles are being arrived at and, from the point of view of man's Divine origin and his Divine destiny, consideration has been given to these things in industry. Will the Taoiseach say that they have no bearing on the relations between man and man and between people and government in politics?
In the March/April, 1959, issue of the Bulletin of the Catholic Societies Vocational Organisation Education Conference, under a note headed “The Key to Management-Labour Relations” I find this quoted from the Bishop of Shrewsbury:
In the construction of good relations between managers, workmen and consumers, the corner-stone is the recognition of the dignity of the human, individual personality.
In another part of the issue, the following sentence appears:
As late as February 5th, 1956, when addressing the International Conference on Human Relations in Industry, Pius XII lamented the fact that while dead matter emerges ennobled by industrial processes, men were there corrupted and degraded.
He then said that a slow improvement was being made from that position.
Later there was a reference to his Christmas message of 1942 in which he laid down five fundamental points for the peaceful order of society, which are as follows:
(i) The dignity and Rights of the Human Person.
(ii) The Protection of Social Unity, and especially of the Family.
(iii) The Dignity and Prerogatives of Labour.
(iv) The Restoration of the Judicial Constitution.
(v) The Christian Conception of the State.
He who would have the star of peace to shine permanently over society must do all in his power to restore to the human person the dignity which God conferred upon him from the beginning ... he must favour, by all legitimate means, and in every sphere of life social forms which render possible and guarantee full personal responsibility in regard to things both temporal and spiritual.
More and more, as the days pass, Governments as such are handed more and more responsibility and are finding out more and more vocational services that they can give to the society whom they govern. All the more, therefore, the people who elect the Government have to be sure that they can have confidence that the Government are dealing adequately and fully with those matters in which the people as a whole expect their help and guidance.
With regard to the proposals in this Bill, the Government have set out to bring about a situation in which they will squeeze the independence out of the people. You may have a Fine Gael man, a Farmer, a Fianna Fáil man, a Labour man or an Independent for a particular constituency and, in the game, Fianna Fáil against the rest, with all the astonishing crown of nationalism, achievement, and all that type of thing, around the Fianna Fáil candidate. They hope to be at the head of the list, in any case, and to be a Government supported by, say, about 4,500 people out of 15,000.
Comment on this
——which he claims and prays for and about his function here on earth in being the fingers of God in taking the resources He places here in this earth and moulding them to all the greatness and the beauty and the services for which they were intended. My mind goes back again to the spirit which moved our people towards the years 1912 or 1913.
France has been mentioned here. Before the Volunteers were formed, our thoughts were in touch with Europe and with Christian thought, though we were not University people. There was a Bishop in France at that time who, writing of the magnificent achievements of the 19th century, then drawing to a close, painted a world in 1875—around the time of the Franco-Prussian War—where magnificent advances in science had taken place.
Telegrams were flashing around the world with the speed of light. The Alps were being tunnelled. The Pyrenees were being overcome. Bridges were being built over the seas. Geology was being developed. Unexpected developments in science which astonished the world were taking place at that time. There was never an age, he thought, with bigger disasters surrounding it and bigger abysses under its feet. If we today see how pygmy were the achievements that were referred to there as the achievements of the end of the 19th Century and see the advances of science and the abysses that open under the feet of men, of countries and of Governments today, we ought to realise, just as he was then preaching, that nothing but religion and a return to religion and the religious aspect of man and the strengthening of man's spirit, using the riches of God and dispensing them properly, could save the world from the destruction around it.
What are we to do if we have an Irish Parliament trampling on individual responsibility in relation to Government and telling those who do not belong to the Fianna Fáil Party and who will not join some other Party, to be a massed Opposition here discussing the country's affairs at the Parliamentary level as two groups striving for power? What are we to do if we destroy by Government action and Government policy the sense of responsibility and dignity in the 14,500 people whose mouths will be shut by the man who gets 4,500 votes and enters Parliament as their representative? Where does the Minister for Industry and Commerce think he is leading? Where do we think we are leading Irish society?
I have stigmatised the Taoiseach's approach to political and human matters by ascribing to him advocacy of the Machiavellian approach to policy which is enshrined in The Prince. I should like the Taoiseach to tell me that I misinterpret. I should like him to tell us, if he is instructing the people and wants to instruct the people, what he means or what the Minister for Finance means, by going to some of the hotels of Dublin to meet a Fianna Fáil convention and telling them that the people who developed the Constitution of 1922 had no conception of and no reference to God, because it is untrue. I should like to ask the Taoiseach does he realise where he is and the cauldron of confusion, spite, and mischief he is creating for the people while he gathers himself up and departs, as it is suggested, from active political life?
Unless this Parliament realises that it has no strength except from the people, no intelligence except the intelligence that is the people, you are just building up a kind of ascendancy spirit that certainly, whatever may happen the ascendancy, will ruin the people and destroy their strength at a vital time in the world's history.
This, the 13th May, 1959, will be remarkable in history as a date to be associated with the date that the Union was passed but it will record, I hope, that Irish democracy, that is, the ordinary Irish people of every Party, creed and class, were much more wide-awake in their freedom and well able to take care of their freedom and had less difficulties in doing it than the democracy of Ireland that had to stand helplessly by while the Parliament, such as it was in Ireland at that time, was sold.
I do appeal to those younger speakers from the Fianna Fáil benches who are going around the country to talk some time or another around the fire with their uncles, their fathers or their friends and get the low-down on some of the tribulations that they, as well as other people, and this House, went through from the day it was formed, particularly from the day it was established here in Leinster House internationally recognised. If they do, they will have some chance of disentangling themselves from the web of ascendancy spite that at critical moments here is dragged around every word and every expression of opinion in this House, lest the intelligence of our people would break through.
What the Government are looking forward to is the weakening of the people's grip on Parliament, the establishing of themselves as an ascendancy here. I do not think that it would be good for them because they had every power in the world in the years in which they were in office fully and fruitfully to use Irish resources. There was no assistance from any Party here that could have been denied to them, if it was claimed. They have not shown themselves to have that competency and I do not know how on earth, in their consciences or in their imaginations or in their intellects, they face the problems before this country if they stick their fingers in the people's eyes and if they get massed behind them a strong Government that will just represent a minority of the people. If they do that, then we will have a Government here and a Parliament which has not the people's strength behind it and, caught between a weak and disappointed people and strong world events and internal difficulties, they will just all go, some day or another, into the madhouse.
Comment on this
As I explained at the outset, the purpose of this motion, which is about to be put to the Dáil, is to see that the opportunity is given to the people to decide whether they want an amendment of the Constitution which will provide for the straight vote and single-member constituency, or whether they want to retain the present system. It is necessary that the Bill pass or be deemed to have passed both Houses of the Oireachtas before it can be put before the people for their judgment. It has been passed by the Dáil. It has not been passed— it was rejected by a single vote—by the Seanad. By this resolution we can deem it to have been passed and then it can be referred to the people by way of referendum. An amendment has been proposed, and to me, at any rate, it simply represents a device for the purpose of delay. It is purely a tactical device to prevent this motion from being passed if, by that device, they can prevent it from being passed.
It is suggested that a Joint Committee of the Dáil and Seanad should consider this issue and make a report. The reasons they give for that suggestion are twofold: we would get more information about the possible consequences resulting from the change— more information as to how it has worked out in other countries—and more time would be given to the people to enable them to ponder on this question and make up their minds upon it.
As far as getting more information is concerned, I doubt if any issue before this House has ever shown such research in various directions and over such a wide field. That research proves that nothing more is likely to be got by the setting up of a Joint Committee such as that suggested in the amendment. As for getting decisions which might help us to decide other than what we have already decided, I think everybody knows what would happen; we would get those on one side voting for and those on the other side voting against the change.
As far as giving the people more time is concerned, the people have had close on six months during which this question has been before them on public platforms throughout the country and in the reports in the newspapers of discussions here and in the Seanad. Again, I think I am justified in saying that there is no real basis for this amendment. It is simply a tactical device to gain time and to make it appear, perhaps, that the Opposition are more seriously concerned than, in my opinion, they are in getting time and in getting further consideration of the matter.
I listened to the leader of the Opposition, Deputy Costello, speaking on this amendment some few days ago. It seemed to me he was very hard put to it, indeed, for argument when he had to take a condensed report of a speech of mine—a report which occupied a little over half a column in a newspaper. It was the report of a speech which took, I am sure, well over an hour to deliver and which would require, if it were reported verbatim, the whole side of a newspaper. Yet, the leader of the Opposition took that condensed report. He took from it a single sentence. He took that sentence out of its context in order to suggest that the purpose we had in introducing this amendment to the Constitution was simply to ensure an over-all majority for Fianna Fáil in the future. He suggested that what we had in mind was simply the fact that we could not hope to gain an over-all majority in the future and we were doing this solely for the purpose of ensuring such a majority for Fianna Fáil in the future.
I thought his argument very, very poor indeed. It was an unworthy performance really. He took a sentence, passed away from it, came back to it again with another little twist, like the little twist one gives to advance a screw, turned it about a bit, went on a little further, turned it again until he was satisfied he had it turned sufficiently into the form in which he now wants people to believe it was said. What I said at that point in that particular speech was the culmination of an argument, an argument I thought a sound argument.
The reason we are taking advantage of the fact that we have a majority at the moment is to give the people the opportunity of deciding this question for themselves. I said that an over-all majority for any Party under the present system is extremely difficult to achieve. I said that had been proved in the case of Fianna Fáil. We did not get a majority in 1932. It took two elections to get a majority. We got it in 1933. The same situation was repeated in 1937 and 1938. It took two elections to get an over-all majority. It took two elections again in 1943 and 1944 to get an over-all majority.
We have an over-all majority now. We could not rely—and this is a fact —on over-all majorities for any Party in the future under the present system because of the development of multiplicity of Parties and because of the dispersion into multiplicity of Parties which the present system of proportional representation encourages. One could not rely upon getting a majority, a majority such as we have at the moment. That is a fact. It is because one could not be certain of having a majority in the future under the present system that I felt it was our duty, with the majority we now enjoy, to give the people an opportunity of deciding this issue.
It is a very important matter for them to decide. It lies at the foundations of all our political institutions. It is the basis on which our Parliament rests. If we want to have a good Parliament and a good Government, then it is our duty to make the foundations as secure as we can. We believe they are not secure under present conditions.
The trouble with the Opposition is that they will not face up to the arguments in this particular matter. They are trying to get away from the arguments by alleging that Fianna Fáil is inspired by nothing more than narrow Party interest. I have pointed out already that if we were inspired purely by a narrow Party point of view we would not have touched the present system. There was no reason why we should spark off this controversy and go to all the trouble of bringing this to the people if we were thinking simply in terms of Party. We could continue as we are. We have a majority which would enable us to do our work. What we are doing is using the majority we have to make the foundations of the State as secure as we can make them.
I can understand why Fine Gael in particular are not prepared to face up to the arguments because the arguments are the arguments which they themselves advanced on a former occasion in favour of getting rid of proportional representation and adopting another system. It was they who first advocated a change. They were the first to attack the present system. They were the first to point out its weaknesses and its defects. On a previous occasion here I brought in a photostatic reproduction of an advertisement which they issued in 1927. They pointed out very clearly what the weaknesses of proportional representation were. It is really Fine Gael who are responsible for first stating the arguments for this proposed change. This was the Fine Gael view. They took it that proportional representation leads inevitably to multiplicity of Parties, that multiplicity of Parties leads inevitably to coalition governments, and then they went on to point out what coalition government would mean to the country. They said it would mean bargaining for place and power between irresponsible minority groups. I ask is that a fact or is it not?
Comment on this
It was Fine Gael who said it, or Cumann na nGaedheal, as they were at that time. They said that coalition government meant bargaining for place and power between irresponsible minority groups, and those who lived in this country and saw what happened in 1948 know perfectly well that that was so, that bargaining for place and power——
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy was allowed to speak for an hour without interruption and the Taoiseach should now be permitted to make his statement without interruption.
Comment on this
It is a twist because Fine Gael and Cumann na nGaedheal are the same. I am told that was not so. Cumann na nGaedheal put an advertisement in, in which the No. 1 point was that coalition government meant bargaining for place and power between irresponsible minority groups, and 1948 proved that that was right.
Comment on this
Next it said that coalition government was weak government, with no stated policy, and that was equally proved by 1948 and even by 1954.
Comment on this
There was bargaining for place and power and then weak government with no stated policy.
Comment on this
Cumann na nGaedheal—they are the same. Cumann na nGaedheal and Fine Gael—I do not distinguish between them. It is simply a change of name. The next thing was that you would have frequent changes of Government. That is what was predicted if you had coalition government. We know that in other countries where there have been coalitions, there have been frequent changes, and we know that here two coalitions were smashed up and burst up from internal friction.
Frequent changes of government— and then the advertisement went on: "a consequent depression in trade and industry". Now I heard the Deputy talking a few moments ago as if he wished to do that. "Trade and industry"—they must have known it very well in 1927. When they wrote that advertisement, they knew perfectly well then how frequent changes of government, weak government, bargaining for place and power and all that sort of thing would influence trade and industry. Depression in trade and industry was to follow. I ask the people of the country to take that and use it as a test of what happened in 1948.
The next point was: no progress, with stability, security and credit in constant danger. Those were the things they said would follow coalition government. The people have had experience of coalition government. We believe in the future things would be even worse than that, and having got the necessary majority and opportunity, we want to see that the people will be given the opportunity, if they take it, to make the change.
Now it may be suggested that it was only in 1927 that Cumann na nGaedheal or Fine Gael, or whatever they called themselves at that time, had those views. I thought I would bring in here another interesting exhibit. On the last occasion, I exhibited here a photostatic reproduction of the advertisement. I have here a photostat of another very interesting document. It is the leader page of the Fine Gael organ at that time, of 10th May, 1930, The Star. In The Star we find an excellent record of the faults of proportional representation.
Comment on this
It was Ernest Blythe and he is still saying the same things. He is as daft now as he was then.
Comment on this
——that they wanted to get rid of proportional representation, and they showed—and I have already said this is the only time they showed any fundamental political sense——
Comment on this
Even Deputy Dillon changed apparently, because he supported this at one time and changed his views afterwards.
Comment on this
It pointed out the faults of the particular system that we were operating. It began, if my recollection is right—would I not love to read it for you? —by finding fault with the system and explaining that political normality had not been arrived at, and that mainly it was the fault of the bad electoral system that we had. It said that the system of proportional representation here, though not quite as bad as that in Germany—but that was the best that could be said of it—had the ineradicable faults which attached to the system and which have exposed themselves wherever this system was in operation. It went on then to say that before the first World War and after it, certain countries had enshrined in their Constitutions this proportional representation system, that certain "theorisers and faddists" had pushed their views, with the result that it had been so enshrined.
Comment on this
Then they went on to say—it is right that Deputy Dillon should interject now; he was their white-haired boy——
Comment on this
He was the white-haired boy. I am taking this from the editorial of The Star, the Cumann na nGaedheal official organ.
Comment on this
Apparently after that he said it was like Prohibition, that it resembled Prohibition in the way that those who had experience of it found, on the whole, it was the cause of various evils, that because certain vested interests have grown up beside it, it will be very difficult to get rid of it. We have vested interests which have grown up beside it, and it will be very difficult to get rid of it because these vested interests will campaign to see that they do not lose it.
It went on to say that the British had thrust it upon us, that it had been thrust upon us by the British. Will Deputy Mulcahy take that to heart?
Comment on this
Here is what this informed article said about it. It said that there had been in Britain for a number of years a certain number of "generously subsidised propagandist societies" which were trying to get the British people to abandon what was their traditional system of election and to adopt proportional representation, that some of the English people were interested but that they were not convinced. It says that the Home Rule Act of 1920, containing the proportional representation system of election, was put on to us, and here I think that Deputy Dillon must have had something to do with the writing of this article, for the words it uses are "on the policy of trying it on the dog." These kind people thought it would be a good thing to try it on the dog. I shall go further. I shall say that they wanted to kill the dog if they could do it.
Comment on this
They were trying it on the dog in order to produce certain results which it had produced elsewhere. That would serve British interests and not our interests. That is why proportional representation was put into the 1920 Act. That is why I say it was thrust upon our people by the British.
Comment on this
I have told the people and told the country why that was done, but many more interesting things have to come out of this article, so I shall not go off on the other trail. That matter can be dealt with again. It was introduced here, and that was the beginning of it in our Parliamentary elections. It was brought in through a British Act of Parliament. They would not have it for themselves but, on the principle of trying it on the dog, they gave it to us.
I should love to be able to read this article because it would be most interesting to do so. The people here, it goes on to say, did not take very much interest in it. There was a certain amount of apathy which was attributed in the article to want of experience, for the reason that the people did not know what exactly would come out of it and also because there were things of greater importance happening at that time. So the Irish people did not kick up a great row about it. I had something to say about it at the time. I said that we knew why they were putting it in here but that we were sufficiently strong to see that it did not produce the effects which they thought it would produce.
This article then goes on to talk about what might have happened after the Treaty if there had not been proportional representation and finally it goes on to talk about the fundamental faults of proportional representation. The first thing it says about it is that it operates to be non-democratic. This is what it says, coming from the other side.
Comment on this
And it goes on to make a good case to prove that. It says that the evils have not disclosed themselves here because of the dominance of the Treaty question. It says that because the Treaty question was such an important matter in the political thought of the people, minor things did not matter.
Comment on this
This is the leading article in this Cumann na nGaedheal organ. I believe that it is the fundamental thought of a large number of Fine Gael people, both here in this House and outside it.
Comment on this
That is just what we are going to do. We shall give the opportunity to the people to see, and I shall be surprised if the arguments behind this leading article do not still persist in the minds of those who subscribed to them at that time.
The article goes on to say that in its operation proportional representation is non-democratic, that it has not shown its evil effects because of the Treaty issue dominating the political field and then it says that perhaps, in four or five years, we would reach political normality and then it would begin to reveal itself.
Then what shall we see, it asks. We shall see a multiplicity of Parties. We shall see five or six of them, not strong enough to form a Government themselves, coming together and by "selfish negotiations and backstairs intrigue"—I am not coining these words—by "selfish negotiations and backstairs intrigue", they will hammer out some sort of programme. That programme will never have been put to the people, and therefore the democratic principles will have been violated by all these Parties who altered democratic methods: democracy itself will be set aside. That is the argument. These are the Cumann na nGaedheal arguments that are put forward against proportional representation. Is it any wonder that we have the speakers on the opposite side running away from the facts? They have not answered these things. If these are wrong, let us hear them, let these things be answered.
Comment on this
I have already given you the same arguments by repeating the Cumann na nGaedheal advertisement. It was only recently I came across this precious document.
Comment on this
I took the decision in the then situation at the time, as I said before. I dealt with it and I knew the people had the power, if they got the opportunity, to make any change they wanted. We have now got the opportunity for them and I hope they will take it, but, in any case, it will be given to them.
Comment on this
We have had this pretence that this system we have operating here is traditionally Irish. My goodness—traditionally Irish! People may talk about the long record, the centuries-old custom of the British system, but to talk of proportional representation as being traditionally Irish when one of the strongest Parties in the State from the very start opposed it, and said it was a system that would lead to multiplication of Parties and, therefore, to instability of government, is nonsense.
It is because we believe these things are fundamentally true that we have introduced this Bill. We believe the system does lead to instability. We do believe that the proposed system is a much better system, that it is nearer to true democracy, nearer to true representation of the people. Deputy Mulcahy is talking about preventing people from being elected, but every citizen who can get votes can go out before a single-member constituency and get them. Every minority that wants to put up a candidate can do so. If they want to join Parties, they can do it. We have no segregation here. We are not trying to segregate our people into groups.
We want a Parliament representative of the nation, representative at least of the people in this State, and we shall get it very much better under the proposed system. It has been proved in practice to be a much better system than the system in which you have little groups that, in any one constituency, represent only a fraction— groups coming along and uniting behind the backs of the people. If there is to be bargaining, let it be done in front of the people. If the various Parties want to get together prior to a general election, they can do so, and that was the difference between 1954 and 1948. At least it could be said in 1954 that you went before the people with a certain amount of unity.
Comment on this
You can combine again under the new system. This is a challenge to you to combine again.
Comment on this
Quite, if the people want it. We are not imposing it upon the people. We are not going behind the people's backs in doing this. We are giving the people the opportunity, in the open, to say whether they want the system that we believe will lead to stable government in this country, that has been proven to lead to stability in countries where it is in operation.
Comment on this
As against a system which has proven its instability in every country in which it has been adopted.
Comment on this
That is the question the people have to decide. If they decide in favour of the amendment, of getting rid of proportional representation, then the bargains can be made before the people's eyes and not behind their backs.
Comment on this
It has been suggested that it would lead to domination by one Party, but surely it is the people who dominate, not an ascendancy of one Party. Our Party is only ascendant in the sense that it gets the votes of our people and as long as it gets the votes of the people. I hope it will have the ascendancy, in a democratic state, for the time being in order to have sufficient power to carry out its programme, to keep the orderly conditions of our State and to make further economic progress.
That is the issue the people have to decide. I do not know what way they will decide it. I know all the Opposition Parties with their vested interests in the existing system will vote against it, and will do their best to get the people to vote against it, but I believe the people will think about the welfare of the country, and about its future, and decide that stability is much more important than having this co-called representation of groups or Parties. The thing that has to be represented is the nation. We want to have a truly representative Parliament and we want to have a stable Government because that is the ultimate centre of power, of energy— the driving centre. We hope the people will have such a Government that will be sanctioned by the people and have their support in carrying out their policy, the policy they have put before the people and to which the people have given their approval.
Comment on this
That is the reason we suggest this system of voting and we hope the people will adopt it.
Comment on this
Swallowed hook, line and sinker.
Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh mar chuid den bhun-cheist na focail a thairgtear a scriosadh."
Comment on this
Rinne an Dáil Vótáil: Tá, 75; Níl, 56.
Do you agree with this result?
Rinne an Dáil Vótáil: Tá, 75; Níl, 56.
Do you agree with this result?