We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1959—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–135 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1959
Enacted

No. 41 of 1959 ›

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 43.

Comment on this

That is my amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The debate has concluded on amendment No. 42 and the other amendments discussed with it.

Comment on this

I did not find anything in Standing Orders making provision for that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is, without doubt, a provision for that in Standing Orders. These amendments were all of the same nature.

Comment on this

Agreed, but my amendment was not moved and what I was questioning was the right of the House to debate an amendment which was not moved.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Two motions may not be before the House at the same time.

Comment on this

But apparently that is what the Chair holds.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

No, the Chair does not hold any such view. The Chair allowed a discussion on the two motions, which is a different thing altogether. Is the Deputy pressing the amendment?

Comment on this

I am.

NEW SECTION.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:

Before Section 12, to insert a new section as follows—

"(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this or any other enactment, any person who, on the date of the passing of this Act, is the holder of a six-day licence shall be deemed to be the holder of a seven-day licence.

(2) Any person who is deemed by virtue of subsection (1) of this section to be the holder of a seven-day licence may opt to remain the holder of a six-day licence only by notifying such option to the Minister for Justice not later than one month after the date of the passing of this Act."

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 31
·
Níl 61
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 44:—

In subsection (1), to delete paragraphs (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e) and insert the following paragraph before paragraph (f):

"(a) that, if the acquisition, construction or alteration, as the case may be, of the premises were then completed and the application for the grant of the certificate aforesaid were then made and no objection on the ground of the character, misconduct or unfitness of the applicant were made on the hearing of the application, it would be proper, having regard to the provisions of the Licensing Acts, 1833 to 1960, to grant the application, and".

This is a drafting amendment which shortens and simplifies the wording of subsection (1). Perhaps I should at this stage also draw attention to the wording of the following subsection, subsection (2), line 47. That line should begin with the word "and". The intention is that the club may appeal to the court "and the court, if it is so satisfied, may grant the application..." I understand arrangements will be made to have the correction made when the Bill is being reprinted.

Comment on this

Does this mean that the Minister wants now to insert a word which is not in the amendment?

Comment on this

Yes. The word "and" was omitted. I do not want to blame the compositor, but it was omitted and we want to make certain now that it is put in

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 45 and 46 might be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 45:—

To add to the section a new subsection as follows:—

"(9) On the hearing of any application for a new licence brought by virtue of the provisions of this Act or any other Act, the Court may, at the request of the applicant, treat the application as an application for a declaration under this section and on making such a declaration the Court may include therein, if such be the case, a declaration that the Court is satisfied as to the character and fitness of the applicant and that the application for a licence is refused solely on the grounds of the unsuitability of the premises at the time of hearing the application."

This amendment is designed to enable an applicant for a licence to ask, on the hearing of the application, that the application be deemed to be an application for a certificate, as envisaged by the Bill. The reasons for the amendment are quite simple. Frequently one comes across cases where the applicant applying for a licence either has not got the work entirely finished at the time of the application or a position arises in which the judge, hearing the application, indicates that he is not satisfied with the premises as they then stand, but that he would be disposed to grant the application if certain alterations were made.

The suggestion in my amendment is that in such circumstances the applicant, rather than be put to the trouble and expense of starting entirely new application proceedings, should be entitled to ask the court to deem his application at that stage to be an application for a certificate. The certificate would be the type of certificate envisaged in the Bill. That would enable the applicant, if granted such certificate by the court, to finish the work, on the one hand, or to carry out the alterations indicated by the court, on the other, and then come back to the court and get his licence, rather than that he should have to start all over again because of some possible minor lack of finish at the time he went in to make his application or because of some trivial minor alterations indicated by the Court as necessary. That is as far as amendment No. 45 is concerned.

Amendment No. 46 is consequential and deals with Section 13 of the Bill. Section 13 refers to the licensing of premises which are the subject of a declaration under the Act. If my amendment No. 45 is accepted it would be necessary to provide for that in Section 13. I think the Minister for Lands in any event will have a knowledge of the type of situation to which I am referring and which does require simplification. In any event, I think there are definite merits in favour of this amendment. I do not proposes to press the Minister to accept the amendments precisely in the form in which they are moved. If the Minister would indicate that he agrees in principle to an amendment to cover this situation, I would be quite satisfied.

Comment on this

I am advised that these amendments are defective in form. Section 12 provides for the granting of what is, in effect, a declaration of approval in principle for the granting of a licence for a particular premises that the applicant proposes to build, to reconstruct or to buy. The declaration will, as a rule, be given on the basis of plans of the construction work proposed, and the declaration is, above all, a declaration of the suitability and convenience of the premises. Deputy O'Higgins's amendment envisages that this declaration could be granted, even if the premises are unsuitable. He goes on, in amendment No. 46, to provide that a licence must in due course be granted if the premises are completed or altered in substantial accordance with the terms of the declaration. But there could be no question of premises being completed in accordance with a declaration given under Deputy O'Higgins's amendment, for the simple reason that that amendment deals with the case where an application is being made for a new licence and where, therefore, the court is dealing with premises as they are and not with plans of new premises or of proposed reconstruction.

One cannot speak of premises being completed in accordance with a declaration unless the declaration is linked with plans. It would not be so linked under the Deputy's amendment. If the applicant has plans, and they are approved, then, of course, he can get his declaration under Section 12 as it stands.

Quite apart from the fact that the two amendments, Nos. 45 and 46, are defective for the reasons I have explained, I am afraid that I cannot agree with what the Deputy is trying to achieve. The Deputy is concerning himself with a person who has neither a suitable premises nor plans for a suitable premises. If he has one or the other, he will be catered for in full without any amendment by the Deputy. What the Deputy wants amounts to this. He wants to create a situation in which a person with an unsuitable premises or inadequate plans can go into Court and get from the Court a declaration saying, in effect: "You are a suitable person to have a licence and the site or location of your premises is also suitable and objection by other publicans in the neighbourhood will not be sustained. If you produce suitable premises, you will get a licence."

The first question to be asked about this is what is the necessity for it. We are providing in the Bill that a person may go into court and seek a declaration without committing himself to the expense of buying or building the premises that he has in mind. We are providing that the court may give an approval in principle to the granting of a licence for the premises, irrespective of who the licensee may be in due course, as long as he is a suitable applicant; he does not have to be the person who applies for the declaration. The Deputy apparently wants to cater for a person who will not even go to the trouble of producing adequate or acceptable plans. Why should we cater for such a person?

But it is not merely a question of why should we cater for him. We cannot do so. Opposition to the grant of a licence, and the court's decision as to whether a licence ought to be granted, would often be greatly influenced by the type of premises to be licensed. A court might very well be disposed to grant a licence for premises planned to provide amenities other than drink where it might otherwise refuse. The opposition of other publicans and of residents in an area might well be influenced by the size of the premises proposed. It is, surely, quite obvious that before a court could give approval in principle to the granting of licensing facilities, it would have to see at least a plan of what sort of premises is proposed.

The Deputy also wants the applicant to be able, at the preliminary stage, to get a declaration of his own personal suitability. There are several reasons why we ought not do so. First of all, such a declaration would be unnecessary and pointless except in borderline cases, where there is a doubt about personal suitability. I see no reason why we should go out of our way to cater for such cases. As far as 99 applicants out of 100 are concerned, no question of unsuitability would ever arise.

If, however, we do look at the exceptional type of case, we must recognise that a person might appear suitable today but might be shown to be unsuitable long before the final application would come to be made perhaps two years hence—he might well be convicted of offences of a kind which would make him quite unsuitable. This alone puts out of question the idea of giving a certificate of personal suitability perhaps two years before this could possibly become an issue. But apart from that, the declaration that is provided for is a declaration attaching to premises, actual or planned, and has nothing to do with any individual. The declaration will be valid for any particular applicant who may, before the premises are licensed, acquire the necessary interest in them, provided of course he is not unsuitable. For these reasons, neither in form nor in substance, could I accept the amendments.

Comment on this

The Minister seems to miss the point of the amendments. I think the reason is that he is reading out a prepared brief in reply to a case which has in fact not been made and which it was not intended by me should be made in these amendments. The Minister appreciates when he talks about an applicant having suitable or unsuitable premises that that is a question which is decided by the Court. As far as the applicant is concerned, he is going into Court and presenting his premises to the Court. He does not know at that stage whether or not those premises will be dubbed as suitable or not by the Court. The simple point I am trying to cover is this. You do not infrequently come across cases where the Court says to an applicant: "Your premises are not entirely suitable, but with a slight alteration here or extension there your premises would be suitable." At present the Court carries out its functions through the existing legislation. Under this Bill, as drafted, the court must refuse that application on the grounds that the premises are unsuitable.

Comment on this

What is to stop them adjourning it?

Comment on this

That possibly could be done but if the law, as the Minister informs us, is hereafter to be fully enforced, the court should refuse the application and I am simply trying to cover that case by enabling the court—remember it rests with the court, not the applicant, under my amendment—if requested by an applicant to say it is prepared to deal with this matter on the basis of considering it as an application for a certificate. The court could then give a certificate to the effect that if the applicant carried out certain alterations on the premises, the premises would be suitable premises in the view of the court. That is all that is involved in these two amendments.

There is no need to set up bogies which do not exist, as the Minister did in his prepared reply. I am not urging the matter on the case which the Minister tried to knock down. I am not interested in the particular form of the amendment and, if the Minister thought there were more suitable ways of framing the amendment, I should be quite happy about it.

Comment on this

I think this matter is fully covered by Section 12. At all events, I am sure the Deputy is well aware that, even under existing law, in dealing with new hotel licences, it is a regular practice of the courts, where a door is discovered that must be closed, to adjourn the matter for a period to give the applicant an opportunity to do so.

Comment on this

But there is no obligation on the court to adjourn.

Comment on this

I agree there is no obligation on the court in strict law but the judges invariably are not unreasonable men in matters of this kind. Certainly if the application is any way reasonable, is just something small, I have no doubt that any court would give the applicant, on grounds of expense and convenience, the opportunity of putting it right. What could be done under the type of amendment which the Deputy suggests is an entirely different matter and I think, as far as Section 12 of the Bill is concerned, it gives a new power, a very useful power, and I cannot see the necessity for the amendment suggested by the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am in agreement this time with the Minister for Justice and the Minister for Lands. This amendment is not really one which simplifies an application for a new licence. It relieves the applicant for a new licence of responsibility of providing money for the erection of his proposed licensed premises so as to enable him to proceed. At least that is what I gather the amendment visualises and I think that this matter, as explained by the Minister for Lands, is adequately dealt with in the Bill. I do not really see any necessity for the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46a:

To add to the section the following subsection:

"( ) A declaration under Section 41 of the Tourist Traffic Act, 1952, which is in force at the commencement of this Act, shall, notwithstanding the repeal of that section, remain in force for the period provided for in subsection (5) thereof and shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (7) of Section 12 of this Act and subsection (1) of this section to be a declaration under subsection (1) of Section 12 of this Act."

This is little more than a drafting amendment to repair an omission from the section as it stands.

The Tourist Traffic Act, 1952, made provision whereby a person who intended to build or acquire premises for an hotel could apply to the court on the basis of the plans of the premises and, if the court was satisfied in the matter, it could grant to the applicant a declaration that a licence would in due course be granted for the premises, if constructed in substantial accordance with the plans. As the House is aware, this Bill, in Section 12, proposes to apply that principle to all licensed premises, and the relevant provisions of the 1952 Act are being repealed because they become superfluous.

It is possible, however, that at the time the Bill becomes law there may be in existence some declaration granted under the 1952 Act, the holder of which will not have completed the construction of the premises to which the declaration relates, with the result that the relevant licence will not have been granted under the terms of the declaration. The purpose of the amendment is to ensure that if any such cases exist, licences will be given in accordance with the declarations, notwithstanding the repeal in this Bill of the provisions under which they are granted.

Perhaps I may at this point mention briefly that it has been suggested to me that I should extend the principle of the section a little further by allowing applications to be made to the court on the basis of plans, by persons who wish to obtain a restaurant certificate, that is, a certificate that the premises are structurally adapted for and mainly used as a restaurant. I should like to consider this and perhaps bring in an amendment on Report Stage in this regard.

Comment on this

I think this is a peculiarly obnoxious amendment on account of its form. It reads:

A declaration under section 41 of the Tourist Traffic Act, 1952, which is in force at the commencement of this Act, shall, notwithstanding the repeal of that section, remain in force for the period provided for in subsection (5) thereof and shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (7) of Section 12 of this Act and subsection (1) of this section to be a declaration under subsection (1) of section 12 of this Act.

There is no juggler or prestidigitator in the known world who could understand the meaning of that, and I merely wish to record a legislative protest against legislation in that form. Some effort should be made by the draftsmen to make the law reasonably comprehensible, not only to those who are required to enact it but to those who are afterwards required to advise their clients in regard to its provisions.

Comment on this

This will have a legal life only in respect of pending applications under the former Act and it will have no application when such applications are finished with.

Comment on this

The most powerful argument the Minister could make for it is that it is fated for an early death.

Comment on this

I do not see why an hotel, when looking for a new licence, should not be obliged to extinguish an existing licence, as a new public house will have to do. The position at the moment is that every hotel that has been granted a new licence is carrying on a trade similar to a public house trade and in a great number of cases these small hotels who have gained licences are doing a trade far in excess of that carried on by the public houses and are paying a far smaller licence fee.

Comment on this

At all events, I suggest, Sir, that it is not open to us to discuss the matter on this amendment.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy McGilligan, I move amendment No. 47:

In page 13, line 16, before "registered" to insert "entitled to be".

The purpose of the amendment is to provide that if premises are entitled to be registered, even though they have not yet actually been registered, they should be eligible for renewal in the terms of Section 16 of the Bill. I am urging it on the Minister. Does he accept it?

Comment on this

We are not accepting that amendment. Does the Deputy want some information on it?

Comment on this

I am depending on the Minister's customary courtesy. I expect him to tell me, if he is not accepting it, why he is not accepting it.

Comment on this

Section 16 provides that hotels which get new licences in future must, as a condition of the renewal of those licences, be registered with An Bord Fáilte. It does not apply to hotels now licensed other than hotels which are subject to the requirement already, that is to say, hotels licensed by virtue of the Tourist Traffic Act, 1952, and there are very few of these hotels, if there is any at all. Practically speaking, therefore, the section is confined to hotels which get licences for the first time after the Bill becomes law. Deputy McGilligan's amendment proposes, in effect, that it should suffice if the hotel is entitled to be registered with Bord Fáilte, even if it is not registered in actual fact.

When the section was being drafted, we deliberately decided to require registration only for renewals and not for the first granting of the licence, because we felt that it might happen for one reason or another that the original application to the court might have to be made before registration with the board had been completed. The section as drafted takes care of the time factor in this respect—as long as the registration is completed before the first renewal becomes due, that is sufficient.

Once we get beyond this initial stage, however, I think that it would be wrong to accept anything less than actual registration with Bord Fáilte. If premises are entitled to be registered with the board, I do not see why the proprietor should not register them as soon as possible. I do not think that it would be in accordance with public policy, as enshrined in the various Tourist Traffic Acts, to allow concessions to be given for premises on the grounds that they are an hotel, if the premises are not registered.

Comment on this

I take it that, in the first instance, if a person applies for registration, he has substantially a year's grace and that it is only if he comes back for renewal and has not by then registered, he will be caught by the section. Is that substantially correct?

Comment on this

That is so, yes.

Comment on this

I should like to be clear on this, because, if I understood the Minister aright, possibly the need which I was trying to meet in the next amendment does not arise. As I read Section 16, it refers to the certificate for the renewal of a licence in respect of the Tourist Traffic Act but it seemed to me, carrying on from that, to refer to the granting of a certificate after this Act by virtue of Section 2, subsection (2), of the 1902 Act. I took that to mean, not simply the first renewal of a certificate granted under Section 2, subsection (2), of the 1902 Act but the actual granting of a certificate. Am I mistaken in that?

Comment on this

It is the renewal of the licence.

Comment on this

Even the licence granted under the 1902 Act?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If the Minister looks at the White Paper, that does not seem to be clear. It seems to relate entirely to the portion of this section dealing with the Tourist Traffic Act, 1952.

Comment on this

I do not know to what portion of the White Paper the Deputy refers.

Comment on this

The explanatory memorandum.

Comment on this

According to the section and the explanation given by the Minister for Justice, this applies to renewals and it is provided in this Section 16 that registration must now be effected under this section.

Comment on this

Generally on the section, I should like to say that I do not regard it as being entirely satisfactory. I am relating this to Deputy McGilligan's amendment. It seems to me that the Government, by virtue of this provision, are now setting up the Tourist Board as the arbiters as to whether or not a hotel should continue to hold a licence.

I suggest that this is a very great departure from the law. It seems to me that whether or not a hotel or any other licensed premises should continue to hold a licence is a matter which should be dealt with by the court and not by the Tourist Board. Under Section 16 of this Bill, the say is being given to the Tourist Board as to whether these hotels will get a renewal of their licence or not, because, if the Tourist Board decide that whatever requirements are imposed by them for registration as a hotel are not being complied with, the board will not continue to register that hotel in their register. If it is not registered, the licence cannot be renewed. I think that is the position.

Deputy McGilligan's amendment might afford some protection against a capricious use by the Tourist Board of their powers because the amendment at least would put the hotelier in a position, if he thought he was entitled to be registered, of claiming then that he was entitled to a renewal of his licence and having the matter tested out in the court, whereas if the section remains as at present, unamended, the hotelier who is not registered or whose registration is not continued by the Tourist Board, has no business going into court looking for his renewal because the first question that must be asked is: "Are you registered with the Tourist Board and, if you are not, you cannot get a renewal." It seems to me that that is taking the power away from the court and vesting it in the Tourist Board.

Comment on this

Actually, the principle to which the Deputy has referred has been accepted largely already by the House in the 1952 Act. In actual fact, without this at all, under the form of procedure, the courts these times in practically all cases of hotel licence applications insist on the Tourist Board's recognition being proved.

Comment on this

They may not always be satisfied. The best check and safeguard a court can have that the premises for which the licence is sought will not be used as a glorified "pub", that the application is not being made solely for the purpose of getting a licence to sell liquor, is to ensure that Bord Fáilte have passed it as a hotel suitable to be licensed. That is the best safeguard for all concerned, including those in the licensed trade. Under the 1952 Act, the House did accept the principle, which is, I agree, extended very slightly by this provision.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that under the 1952 Act Board Fáilte approval applied only in respect of new licences? Under this section, it will be obligatory on applicants to satisfy Bord Fáilte in respect of a renewal of a licence. Under the 1952 Act, existing licenses had not to get a certificate from Bord Fáilte but under this change, it is proposed that all licensees, whether applicants for renewals or new applicants, must have a certificate from Bord Fáilte.

Comment on this

It applies only to new licences.

Comment on this

Does it not apply now to renewals as well as new ones?

Comment on this

The renewal of new licences.

Comment on this

The renewal of a licence granted after the passing of this Act?

Comment on this

It strikes me there is something contradictory about this matter. To procure a licence for a hotel you would apply under the 1902 Act?

Comment on this

Not necessarily now.

Comment on this

You can do it under the 1952 Act.

Comment on this

But it has the same conditions—ten bedrooms set aside for hotel guests.

Comment on this

That is in the country.

Comment on this

Yes. It has been known that Bord Fáilte has registered premises and give a certificate for only six or seven bedrooms; in other words, only six or seven bedrooms come up to the standard required. There might be a few boxrooms left over which the board would not register but it would be sufficient to qualify for a licence under the 1952 Act or the 1902 Act.

Comment on this

I do not agree with the Deputy. I say this subject to correction, but my recollection is that you must have ten bedrooms set aside specifically for guests; in other words, you must have ten bedrooms. In addition, you must have the usual accommodation for staff, and so on. Therefore, I do not quite understand the Deputy's point when he says the board might recognise six bedrooms and that you could throw in a few boxrooms in order to come within the hotel law. As a matter of experience, I know that you must show that you have these ten bedrooms fully furnished and set aside specifically for guests, irrespective of the staff.

Comment on this

That is the point. You must satisfy the courts that you have ten rooms but you need not satisfy the Tourist Board that you have ten rooms. The Tourist Board are prepared to register six or seven rooms. When you go into court for a hotel licence, these questions are asked: (1) are you registered with the Tourist Board and (2) have you ten bedrooms set aside?

Comment on this

It becomes 20 under this Bill.

Comment on this

Only in certain cases; in Dublin, not in rural Ireland. The licensing authority does not inquire into the number of rooms registered by the Tourist Board.

Comment on this

No matter what the Tourist Board may say, the court will grant the licence only on being satisfied that there are ten legitimate bedrooms.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Minister's point of view and I agree with him. My point is that in order to register with the Tourist Board, if you can set up a minimum of five rooms up to the standard which the board requires, you are entitled to be registered with the board.

Comment on this

There may be a differentiation by the board as between guest houses and hotels.

Comment on this

I shall come to the guest house afterwards; I am referring now to the hotel. The board do not require a minimum of ten rooms in order to register with them. Take the case of guest houses. There are certain parts of the country which cater for a class of tourist who cannot afford the hotel standard and for whom the guest house is sufficient. I take it that once you are registered as a guest house with the Tourist Board, you automatically qualify for a licence, if you have ten bedrooms.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the question of guest houses arise?

Comment on this

Very much so.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The amendment deals with certain licensed hotels.

Comment on this

When is a hotel a guest house and when is a guest house a hotel?

Comment on this

Yes. Would the Minister agree that registration as a guest house is sufficient to qualify for a hotel licence?

Comment on this

provided it has the statutory requirements.

Comment on this

Of ten rooms.

Comment on this

Is that definite?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Yes. We want to protect ourselves from this contradiction. The Tourist Board may refuse to register you as an hotel but they will register you as a guest house. The licensing court does not recognise a guest house and they will register you as an hotel. We are up against this contradiction in terms and I can envisage it arising in small towns in my own country and other rural parts where that class who want guest house accommodation are catered for. I should like to have that point clarified.

Comment on this

Am I right in thinking that under Section 2 of the 1920 Act, there is an artificial definition of a hotel. Under that section, the expression "hotel" refers to a house which has at least ten bedrooms set aside exclusively for the use of travellers. The register of hotels kept by the Tourist Board is a different thing entirely. My objection to the section is not because of any possible conflict between the register of the Tourist Board, on the one hand, and the definition in the 1902 Act, on the other hand. It is because it seems to give the Tourist Board the last say as to whether or not a genuine hotel is to continue to hold its licence or not.

The Tourist Board, in respect of registration of premises in its register of hotels, has a whole set of requirements which, within the past 12 months, have been stiffened up. They intend to look into such matters as the provision of a proper reception desk and reception facilities, hot and cold water, and so on, in bedrooms and certain minimum standards which will have to be observed in the case of premises which want to get on the register of hotels.

Some of these requirements which are minimum requirements by the Tourist Board may have nothing at all to do with whether or not the premises are suitable to hold a licence for serving drink. It seems to me that it is not right that the Tourist Board requirements, which may be in no way related to the drinking facilities of the hotel, should be allowed to override the decision of the court that a premises should be licensed.

Comment on this

I think there is some confusion as between my understanding and the Deputy's understanding of the situation. We are dealing here in Section 16 with new hotel licences. The Deputy will understand the reasons, without my elaborating on them, why a court must be very careful about the granting of a new hotel licence, and particularly a hotel licence in a country area. The tendency has been to try, since 1952, in many instances to get a hotel licence, shall I say, for the purpose of getting a liquor licence. This principle, as I have said, has been accepted in the 1952 Act. Under this section, it is proposed that a hotel to get a new licence, in future, must be on the register of the Tourist Board.

Comment on this

With regard to the 1952 Act, they are the ones who get their certificates on the plans, are they not?

Comment on this

On the plans, yes. In my recollection, at that time, you could go to the court with the plans——

Comment on this

I have no objection to the plans.

Comment on this

——before building the premises.

Comment on this

That is in relation to the 1952 Act. I am talking about the 1902 Act.

Comment on this

In respect of the 1902 Act, the position, in fact, is that the applicant did have a choice. I have seen that choice exercised for different purposes. By proceeding under the 1902 Act, without going near the court a chance is taken to complete the premises and then go to the court, all in one go, if I may put it like that. By going on the other procedure under the 1952 Act, they were expending no money except the architect's fees. They applied to the court to have the plans approved and then they were all right, if the building subsequently complied with the plans. Under the 1902 Acts, even since the passing of the 1952 Tourist Act, in actual practice, before granting a hotel licence, the courts had, of necessity, some evidence from the Tourist Board.

Comment on this

They had.

Comment on this

There is another way. The applicant who takes the risk of going into court and looking for a hotel licence under the 1902 Act without availing of the most simple proof of the suitability of the premises for a hotel, has no chance, in my view, of getting a licence from any court now. I think the Deputy will agree now on the desirability of that assurance where a new hotel licence is granted. Remember, under this section, we are granting a hotel licence possibly in areas where the hotel bar will be in competition with the local licensed premises and these facilities should not, on that ground, be granted, except in the case of a genuine hotel. They will be new premises and, therefore, there is no reason, in my view, why they should not comply with the requirements laid down for hotels by the Tourist Board.

That would be in the national interest, in the interests of the tourist business, and in the interests of the Tourist Board. With all due respect to the courts, they are in a far better position to assess, or to judge, the suitability of hotel accommodation than a learned judge might be. At all events, it will save the courts a lot of trouble if the Tourist Board witness is prepared to say: "We have already passed the premises as being suitable in accordance with our standards". The court need then concern itself only with the character of the applicant.

I suggest the section is a good section and, if I may say so, it is very necessary in order to prevent people from trying to get any kind of gazebo licensed for the purpose of selling drink, and not a genuine hotel.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:—

To add to the section a new subsection as follows:—

"(2) This section shall not apply to an application for a certificate for the renewal of a licence which was granted after the passing of this Act by virtue of paragraph (2) of section (2) of the Act of 1902 if the notice of application in respect of which the licence was granted was pending for hearing in the Circuit Court prior to the passing of this Act."

I am not quite clear, now that that discussion has taken place, whether or not this amendment is necessary. I am rather inclined to think it is, for the purpose of seeing that by this legislation we do not prejudice the position of any applicant who may have his application before the court at the moment. It seems to me that under the provisions of the Bill at present, if the Bill were to go through to-day, and if there were an application at hearing in court to-day, if that application were to be continued to-morrow, there might be an alteration of the law. That might lead to the rediculous position that where to-day an applicant is entitled to a hotel licence under the 1902 Act, to-morrow he is not.

The type of case I have in mind is: under the 1902 Act, Section 2, a hotel with ten bedrooms is entitled to get a licence from the court, whether in the city of Dublin or outside it. This Bill will provide that hereafter, so far as the city of Dublin is concerned, an applicant must have 20 bedrooms before he can get a licence. It seems to me that we must safeguard the position in all fairness and in all justice for the applicant who at present has an application before the court. I do not know how many cases are involved.

In relation to Section 16, the necessity for Tourist Board registration for renewal of licences will apply only to new licences, as I understand from the discussions which have taken place. If the existing licences are not to be prejudiced, I think the applicant who, before this Bill goes through, has his application before the court and is, on foot of that application, granted a licence, should be in the same position as an existing hotel licensee.

Comment on this

I do not think there is any necessity for the amendment, but I shall have the point raised by the Deputy looked into.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied with that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:

To add to subsection (2) the following paragraphs:—

"or

(c) that notice of application for a licence under paragraph 2 of section 2 of the Act of 1902 was duly served and advertised in a newspaper in accordance with the appropriate Rules of the Circuit Court prior to the passing of this Act, or

(d) that an application for a licence under paragraph 2 of section 2 of the Act of 1902 which was pending for hearing in the Circuit Court prior to the passing of this Act was refused solely on the grounds of the unsuitability of the premises in respect of which the application was made and that a further notice of application in respect of the same premises was duly served and advertised in a newspaper in accordance with the appropriate Rules of the Circuit Court within one year after the passing of this Act, if on the hearing of such further application the Court should decide that the premises had been rendered suitable for the granting of a licence since the hearing of the first application."

The same point is involved as was involved in the previous amendment. I shall be satisfied if the Minister will look into the matter to protect applicants who have applications pending.

Comment on this

I shall have the matter looked into.

Comment on this

This refers to the licensing of premises adjoining premises already licensed. I am afraid I do not quite get the effect of this section. I do not know the effect of the 1902 Act in this connection. At present, one can extinguish a licence in a premises which is already licenced and then, if the place next door has a licence, one can apply to the Court to break into the adjoining premises and to have the adjoining premises, in respect of which you sold the licence licensed by extension. Is it the intention of Section 20 to put an end to that practice?

Comment on this

The Explanatory Memorandum has the explanation of Section 20. The explanation reads as follows:

Section 6 of the 1902 Act made provision for the granting of a new licence to cover an extension of a licensed premises where the extension made the premises more suitable for the business. Its scope is limited, however, to premises licensed at the date of the passing of the Act and there is no provision to enable a new licence to be granted in the event of substantial extensions to public houses which were licensed for the first time since 1902 under one or other of the provisions of the law which allow new licences to be granted in particular circumstances.

Section 20 is designed to make such provision. It is designed to make the same provision for extensions of a suitable kind to these premises as was available under the 1902 Act.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:

50. Before section 21 to insert the following new section:

"(1) Section 19 of the Act of 1943 is hereby amended by the deletion of the definitions of ‘licence', ‘publican's licence' and ‘beerhouse licence' and the insertion of the following definition:

"‘licence' means a licence for the sale of intoxicating liquor for the grant of which the production of a certificate of the Circuit Court or of the District Court is required."

(2) Reference to the Circuit Court in sections 21 and 22 (which relate to the grant of new licences in respect of more convenient premises or premises substituted for destroyed premises) of the Act of 1943 shall in relation to applications made thereunder by virtue of the amendment effected by subsection (1) of this section for certificates entitling the applicants to the grant of off-licences, be construed as references to the District Court and the reference in the said section 22 to the County Registrar shall, in relation to such applications, be construed as a reference to the District Court Clerk and the sections shall have effect accordingly."

This is one of a couple of amendments designed to remove some anomalies and to simplify procedure in relation to the granting of new licences in certain cases. The purpose of the amendment is, first of all, to extend to off-licences certain facilities which holders of on-licences have at the moment. Under Section 21 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1943, the holder of an on-licence in a rural area may, in effect, transfer that licence to new premises in the immediate vicinity, provided, of course, the Court allows him. Section 21 does not apply except in rural areas, no doubt because the likelihood of interference with existing equities would be very high if it were extended to urban areas, where even a small change in location could make a great deal of difference. Section 22 of the 1943 Act allows a new on-licence to be granted for premises in the immediate vicinity of premises that have been burned down or otherwise destroyed.

It is difficult to see why these sections of the 1943 Act were confined to on-licences, since there is just as much reason for applying them to off-licences as to on-licences. In fact, under an Act of 1825, if premises are burned down, an off-licence may be transferred to other premises in the immediate vicinity, but the transfer must be made during the same licensing year, and that is a serious weakness in the provision, as it does not allow sufficient time. Section 22 allows a full 12 months, which is more reasonable.

As well as removing the anomalies to which I have referred, the amendment prepares the way for the adoption, in respect of all licensing applications, both in respect of on-licences and off-licences, of a simplified procedure which is proposed in the next amendment, that is, amendment No. 51. I shall deal with that when we come to the next amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:

Before section 21 to insert the following new section:

"(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in sections 21 or 31 of the Act of 1943 (which sections relate to the grant of licences in respect of more convenient premises and the transfer of beer-house licences), where the person making an application under either of those sections is not the holder of the licence to be extinguished or transferred under the section but shows to the satisfaction of the Court hearing the application that he has procured the consent of the holder thereof to the extinguishing or transfer thereof, as the case may be, the application shall not be refused on the ground that the person making it was not the holder of the licence to be extinguished or transferred and the said sections shall be construed and have effect accordingly.

(2) Section 22 (which relates to the grant of new licences in respect of premises substituted for destroyed premises) of the Act of 1943 is hereby amended by the insertion in paragraph (c) of subsection (1) after ‘remains thereof' of ‘or that he has procured the consent of the lawful occupier of such premises or of the site and remains thereof to the making of the application, and if the licence referred to in paragraph (b) of this subsection is then subsisting, to the extinguishing thereof if and when a licence is granted pursuant to this section'.

(3) (a) A conviction recorded on a licence transferred under the said section 31 shall, upon such transfer, case for all purposes to be so recorded and shall be deemed never to have been so recorded.

(b) Where a new licence is granted to any person pursuant to an application under the said section 21 or the said section 22, a conviction recorded on the licence extinguished pursuant to the application (not being a conviction which became so recorded at a time, if any, when that person was the holder thereof) shall, notwithstanding anything contained in the said sections, not be deemed to be recorded on the new licence and the said sections shall be construed and have effect accordingly.

As I have already mentioned, this is an amendment to simplify procedure and incidentally to reduce costs in applications for new licences in certain cases. While the amendment is not dependent on acceptance by the House of my amendment relating to six-day licences—that is, amendment No. 52— I would mention that the simplified procedure proposed in the present amendment is also incorporated in amendment No. 52, and to that extent the two form part of a pattern.

As Deputies know the law does not normally allow new intoxicating liquor licences to be granted, that is to say, licences for premises that have not been licensed previously. There is, of course, a well-known exception for hotels but, apart from that, new licences may be given only in exceptional circumstances and then only in substitution for existing licences. In these latter cases, where the granting of new licences is permitted in substitution for existing licences, the law has generally provided that the new licence may be granted only to the holder of the existing licence. In practice, however, this requirement did not prevent what amounted to the sale of licences by persons going out of business to other people who wished to obtain licences for their own premises, but the procedure was cumbersome and costly.

A licence attaches to a premises and cannot exists apart from a premises. Consequently, the procedure which solicitors had to adopt usually involved the sale, not of the licence but of the premises, to the person who wanted the licence, then an application to the Court by the new licensee to have the licence extinguished and a new one granted to him for the other premises, and finally the re-sale of the first premises, now unlicensed, to the former owner. The sale and re-sale were of course no more than a legal fiction, but I understand that stamp duty had to be paid on the transaction as if they were bona fide sales. And, of course, the legal fees for such a complicated transaction must have been fairly substantial too.

What I am now proposing is that, in all cases where the grant of a new licence is conditional on the extinguishing of an existing licence, the complex procedure that I have outlined will no longer be necessary and that where the applicant for the new licence does not already hold the existing licence it will be sufficient for him to procure the consent of the holders of the existing licence to the extinguishing of the licence. The court will, of course, satisfy itself that a valid consent has been obtained. It will be for the parties concerned, as at present, to fix the price to be paid for the consent to the extinguishing of the existing licence. This will, in effect, be the price of the licence.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 52, relating to six-day licences, has been discussed with amendment No. 42.

NEW SECTION.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:

Before Section 21 to insert the following new section:—

"(1) In this section—

‘full licence' means a publican's licence within the meaning of Part II of the Act of 1910 which is neither a six-day licence nor an early-closing licence;

‘restricted licence' means—

(a) a publican's licence which is not a full licence, or

(b) a beerhouses licence within the meaning of Part II of the Act of 1910.

(2) Where a person who holds a restricted licence in respect of any premises (in this section referred to as the relevant premises) shows to the satisfaction of the District Court on application thereto at any sitting thereof for the Court area in which the relevant premises are situate that, in relation to—

(a) another restricted licence in respect of premises situate in that Court area, or

(b) each of two other restricted licences in respect of premises both of which are situate elsewhere than in that Court area, or

(c) a full licence,

either—

(i) he is the holder thereof, or

(ii) he has procured the consent of the holder thereof to the extinguishing thereof if and when a full licence in respect of the relevant premises is granted pursuant to this section,

the Court shall cause a certificate to be given to that person entitling him to receive a full licence in respect of the relevant premises.

(3) Upon the grant pursuant to an application under this section of the full licence in respect of the relevant premises—

(a) the restricted licence in respect of the relevant premises shall be extinguished, and

(b) the other licence or licences, as the case may be, to which the application related shall be extinguished and the other premises or each of the other premises, as the case may be, to which the application related shall, for the purposes of the Act of 1902, be deemed never to have been licensed."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

Before section 23 to insert a new section as follows:

"The Court may at any time within one year from the passing of this Act grant an application by the holder of an off licence to transfer such licence from the premises to which it is now attached to other premises in the immediate vicinity which also are in the ownership of such holder and which in the opinion of the Court are more suitable for such licence."

The effect of this amendment is to give all areas the facility the Minister mentioned is already available to rural areas only. I can see the Minister's point of view in regard to where a vested interest had been built up in relation to an on-licence.

I should not have thought that the same case was to be made in respect of an off-licence where the off-licence is to be moved to another premises in the immediate vicinity. If it is not to be in the immediate vicinity, there will be a considerable difference. It seems to me that what we want to do as far as we can is to get premises which will be the most suitable premises in that vicinity licensed. I should like to hear the Minister's observations.

Comment on this

I should say right at the outset that I cannot accept the amendment. Many Deputies, and perhaps all Deputies, will have received representations from a particular firm in Dublin in support of this amendment. They may, indeed, have received representations twice, once before the amendment was tabled by Deputy Sweetman when the firm concerned asked for an amendment of this kind and again since the amendment was tabled.

When an amendment like this is put down and expressed to be limited to one year, it would be unreal for me to speak to it without at least some reference to the circumstances in which the firm for whose benefit it is put down have sought the amendment. They wish, as they say, to transfer an off-licence from a branch in one street to a branch in another street. On the face of it, that may not be an unreasonable request and I hope that it is unnecessary for me to emphasise that nothing I have to say in connection with the amendment is in the slightest degree directed against the firm concerned.

I do not, however, propose to argue the matter on the basis of whether or not it is reasonable that a particular firm should be allowed to transfer a licence from one street to another. I would mention, in passing, that the case made for that firm is by no means unusual or even exceptional. There must be dozens of licensees in Dublin alone who would like to move to what they regard as more suitable premises and letters received in my Department during the years show that there are many others outside Dublin.

The difficulty is that the amendment cuts right across the principles that have been followed in the Licensing Acts for nearly 60 years—since 1902, to be precise. The Licensing (Ireland) Act, 1902, prohibits the grant of a new licence—either on-licence or off-licence—in an urban area, even in substitution for an existing licence attached to another premises, except where there has been a 25 per cent. increase in population in the parish concerned. There is an exception for hotels and one or two other special cases that do not affect the general picture.

The result of this is that for nearly 60 years now existing licensed premises in urban areas have had what amounts to a statutory protection against any new competition in the vicinity. In the central Dublin area, that protection has been absolute, as it is only in certain suburban areas that the necessary increase in population has taken place. Inevitably, of course, all licensed premises thus acquired a certain monopoly value and premises have changed hands during the years at prices that reflected that position. Furthermore, the various Licensing Acts passed since 1902 have recognised and taken account of this fact and of the equities thus created. In these circumstances, to alter the law now, except for some serious reason connected with the public interest, would be a breach of faith with existing licensees.

What we have to ask ourselves is this: Does the public interest require that this amendment be made? I think it is evident that it does not and that if it did, the amendment would not be expressed to be limited in operation to a period of one year. If the amendment were justified for a year, it would be justified as a permanent amendment. I know, of course, that a precedent for an amendment limited to a year has been mentioned in some of the representations made to Deputies.

That was in the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1927, when holders of on-licences were given the option of converting them to off-licences within 12 months. At this stage, over 30 years afterwards, it is very hard to see why that amendment was limited to a year, since it could not adversely affect anybody's interests, except, perhaps, the Exchequer which would collect less duty from the off-licence, and, as one might have expected, the amendment was re-enacted in permanent form in 1943. That provision, therefore, is in no way comparable with what is now proposed.

This amendment could involve a very serious interference with existing equities and there is no case whatsoever for it, other than the convenience of a particular firm. As I said earlier, there are several other firms that could make much the same case. It really comes down to the fact that we are here to legislate in the general interest and we cannot, or at any rate, we ought not, to depart from general principles merely to benefit individual persons or firms.

Comment on this

Of course, we should not legislate for individual persons or firms. The circumstances in which one firm, as the Minister told us, found itself are also the circumstances in which other firms find themselves. It just happens that if one person draws the circumstances to the attention of a Deputy, the circumstances that apply to one person also apply to many other people.

So far as the form of the amendment is concerned, it is specifically designed to cover everybody who would be so concerned and not the one firm alone. The Minister, if he looks at the amendment, must realise that it is an amendment general in type and not for any specific person. Frankly, the reasons I put in the year was the provision in the 1927 Act and also that I think there is a certain desirability in having an off-licence—I would not make the same case for an on-licence —fixed geographically for periods at a time. I do not think it desirable to have it changed from year to year. There does come a time now and again when premises become unsuitable and having regard to the provisions of the Acts introduced to bring shops up to standard, quite apart from the particular firm, I can see an very definite case for changing an off-licence.

Let me make one case to the Minister which is entirely unconnected with this. Let us assume you have an off-licence in a corner shop and it is desired to widen that corner. It would be desirable in those circumstances, not for the licensee to have power, but for the court to have the power—and it should be the court alone—to transfer an off-licence to the adjoining premises which were being taken away for street-widening purposes.

Comment on this

Although I cannot altogether agree with the amendment, it has been but down. I think it is definitely accepted that off-licences are required mainly in central shopping areas. Unfortunately, these central shopping areas are most unlikely to show an increase in population since the basic date of 1902. In fact, in view of Corporation planning and house planning programmes, it is more than likely that they will all share a decrease of population. There are also, as a result of this and as a result of the changes in the various bus routes and bus stops, shifts in the shopping habits of the people. Some streets which were very prosperous business streets have now become very poor business streets and properties have deteriorated in value, even premises other than off-licence premises.

I have one street in mind in which there are two off-licence premises. They are competing with each other to see which can sell the cheapest and spirits are being sold there practically at wholesale price. That is simply because the Corporation has moved a great many of the population away from that shopping area to outlying areas. Now the tendency is starting to reverse and the central city area is being rebuilt. Even still, the new families who are brought into the Corporation schemes are fewer than the families taken out. Each time the Corporation takes over a street and erects new flats, fewer people go into the flats than were in the street originally.

This is a very desirable thing and we approve of it but it means that equities established in 1902 cannot reasonably be said to apply to-day. I believe some opening should be left, to the High Court rather than the Circuit Court, whereby people seriously affected as a result of Government policy of shifting populations, can apply to have the court consider the merits of their case. I consider the value of off-licensed premises in Grafton Street went up considerably when the buses started to travel down that street, whereas in Camden Street and Capel Street, they have deteriorated according as people were rehoused out of these areas. I think the Minister should look at the equities from this point of view, to see if there should not be some opening and not say, once and for all, that we shall not allow any off-licence premises to be transferred unless there has been the necessary increase in population since 1902. On that basis, we are not ensuring equity at all.

Comment on this

In reply to Deputy Lemass as well as to Deputy Sweetman, we cannot act merely in an individual case.

Comment on this

Nobody is asking the Minister to do that.

Comment on this

I am referring only to general equities.

Comment on this

There might be a good deal more in this than meets the eye. On Second Reading, I pointed out that there should be a very definite minimum standard of sanitation and other points in regard to public houses and I am not in any way withdrawing that view. The object of this section is to enable the local health authority, in whose area the public house is situated, to object to the renewal of the licence in respect of any premises which they consider do not meet the requirements of the Act. A problem might possibly arise here in regard to the acquisition by, for instance, six-day licence holders of seven-day licences.

There are quite a number of premises now in a rather dilapidated condition scattered throughout the country. The licence duty continues to be paid and no objection is made, although in some instances premises have ceased to carry on the business of a public house and carry on a different one; in others, they are not carrying on any business at all. Now, in regard to those in which some type of business is being carried on, they do not enter into this section but the others do, and if somebody vacates his premises and it becomes slightly dilapidated, he might still like to retain the licence as a saleable asset. If the health authorities come along in 12 months' time, when the premises have become dilapidated, and go into court, I do not see how the court could reasonably reject their objection to the renewal. It would be quite clear at that stage that the premises would not be suitable. In other words, this section could be used drastically to reduce the number of licences available.

While I said at the beginning I am most anxious that public houses should be obliged to reach certain minimum standards from the health point of view, I hope this section will not be used in the manner in which I suggest it could be used, and in that way to achieve a reduction in the premises and, in effect, a reduction of the market open to potential purchasers who are desirous of converting their premises from six-day to seven-day licensed premises.

Comment on this

The position is that an objection could already be taken by certain people under the law as it stood. The particular provision contained in Section 24 was recommended by the Commission and is to be read in conjunction with another recommendation by the Commission in regard to unfitness of premises which is being given effect to in Section 25. Under the law, the local health authority was not entitled to object and Section 24 now allows them to object. Under the existing law, the people at present entitled to object to the granting of the new licence are a district justice, a superintendent of the Garda or any inhabitant of the parish in which the premises are situated.

This recommendation of the Commission is just bringing us up to what is necessary in modern practice and I think it is reasonable that the health authority should have these powers. After all, the health authority are now provided with power to object to the granting of dance hall licences on the grounds of unsuitability of sanitary facilities and so on. I think the possible answer to Deputy S. Flanagan's fears is the fact that if this section were operated in any unreasonable way by the health authority, I could immediately visualise the county councillors having something to say on the matter.

Comment on this

I should like to say that when this matter was discussed by the Commission, I felt I could not support the recommendation of the Commission. It was among the points I disagreed with because I feel the health authorities already have sufficient power to take action against licensees in regard to hygiene on the premises. There are sufficient people supervising the publican now without adding the local authority in another capacity. There is nothing to prevent the local authority through its health inspectors ensuring that a proper standard of hygiene is maintained or brought into operation on the premises and the power exists in the Health Acts to do this at present. This new section will add to the existing power in the hands of the local authority and allow them to go into court and actually object to the public-can obtaining a licence.

I think that is going a little bit too far. Various local authorities will interpret this section to suit themselves and their own localities and what would be reasonable in one local authority might not be held to be reasonable in the next local authority. If a certain local authority had an over-all majority of a political Party they could make it very "hot" for their political opponents who might happen to be publicans. I do not suggest that is going to happen but the position is, as the Minister himself said, that it could happen that a local county council would be in a position to move and object if there is close supervision. The same authority could insist on close supervision. I do not think it is necessary to give this power to the local authorities in addition to that which they have already.

Comment on this

I think it is far more reasonable to provide for this objection than for the objection of a local resident. I believe the Deputy's knowledge of rural Ireland, although I suppose I should not say it, would indicate that conditions in some of the licensed premises leave very much to be desired from this point of view. Personally, I feel that in the interests of all concerned it is desirable that this power should be there. I do not share the fears expressed by Deputy Flanagan that it would be wielded in any unreasonable way. Deputies should realise that we have these powers now as the law of the land in respect of all kinds of business, grocery shops, butchers' shops and all types of mixed businesses, and I see no reason why the same law should not be applied at least in principle to publichouses.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister and I disagree with Deputy McQuillan about the desirability of having this section inserted and this power given to the health authorities. I think it is necessary and desirable but I have the greatest fear about the manner in which the section could be implemented by the health authorities.

I shall give one or two examples to illustrate exactly what I mean. There is hardly a town in Ireland where there is not at least one licensed premises which now is, and which perhaps has been for a year or two, closed up, the owner having gone away. Really, the only asset that person has is possession of a licence which continues in operation. Were the health authority to come along on the application for renewal and object, the court would have no option but to uphold the objection because quite clearly the premises is not fit for use as a public-house. The fact is that it has not been used as a publichouse but that would not be a valid objection, the section being what it is.

Secondly, there are certain people, elderly perhaps, and living alone, who are carrying on a very small business selling an odd bottle of shout here and there, in rather dilapidated premises. If the health authority were to object to some of these I think there is no doubt that the renewal would be refused. I ask the Minister to look into this matter with a view to giving some guarantee or loophole to these people. For instance, if a premises is licensed, vacant and dilapidated, notice could be served on the owner to the effect that in, say, twelve months, an application for renewal would be opposed. In the case of a person in the second class, a notice could be served on him—again not sprung on him in court—giving him twelve months to comply because he would certainly need that period before he would be able to put his premises in any reasonable condition. He simply would not have the money to do it otherwise. Giving the power, having inserted the necessary safeguard against abuse or excessive use of it, is one thing and just giving the power is another. I should like serious consideration to be given to what I have said.

Comment on this

I should like to raise one point in regard to Dublin city. I think either the Health Authority in Dublin or the Minister for Health in consultation with the Health Authority should lay down certain specific requirements so far as the licensing of premises is concerned from this point of view. I see the difficulty of different health inspectors with different interpretations of what they are meant to do. We have seen that happen in other matters in connection with the Health Department. Perhaps the Minister will consider having some sort of basic requirement. In particular, I have this in mind in regard to the bottling departments in publichouses, having stout bins properly cleaned, washing of glasses and care of toilets and so on.

Comment on this

I agree with this section but I have a slight fear as to how it will be implemented. I agree with Deputy S. Flanagan that a certain period should be allowed to a licensee to effect whatever repairs are suggested by the health inspector. I would not be terribly concerned about the city of Dublin, as Deputy Lemass mentioned, as regards bottling stores because the health authorities are on the war-path—and have been for some years—in relation to these. I would be more concerned about toilet accommodation in licensed houses. I suggest to the Minister that the conditions that obtain in rural parts of Ireland are appalling but I should also like the Minister to consider the financial position of the licensee in these cases because the improvements to be carried out would cost a good amount of money.

I know that an ordinary notice would be served on a publican in such a case but as soon as the health inspector discovered that the toilet facilities were not quite adequate, at the next licensing court he would go in and object to the licence. Then, if the health authority in those circumstances objected to the licence, the justice could refuse to renew the licence.

I think a period of one or two years might be allowed in certain exceptional circumstances to give the licensee time to effect whatever improvements might be suggested by the health authority inspector. I would not have quite the same fears that Deputy McQuillan has in this matter. This provision merely gives the health authority the right to object to the renewal of the licence. There is a higher authority who will decide whether or not the licence should be granted, and that will be the justice concerned.

Comment on this

The real answer to the fears expressed by the Deputies is that justices are reasonable men. This is an enabling section to give a statutory right to the health authority to object. It is not conferring power on the authority to be the ne plus ultra authority in the matter. I am sure the court—this has certainly been my experience under another type of legislation—will not alone give the people time, if time is necessary, but will also raise the standards gradually, step by step. All this started with the Dance Halls Act of 1935. From that time local authorities began to come into court and make certain objections, starting with the dry lavatories in rural areas. They progressed from that to Elsans and they have now reached the stage generally throughout the country in which water closets must be provided in these places. All that took many years. It involved considerable expenditure in some instances on the part of the applicant. The courts are not unreasonable and I have no doubt that in endeavouring to get licensees up to the standards expected in this day and age district justices will give reasonable time if anything in the nature of substantial alteration or a new structure is involved.

District justices also invariably take into account the cost to the applicant and the circumstances of the applicant. I think there is full protection. The answer to the fears expressed by Deputies is that we have reasonable men administering the law. They will not make impossible demands. I do not know if Deputies have looked at Section 25 dealing with unfitness of premises. It is stated in that section:

"An objection under this section shall not be entertained by the Court unless notice in writing of the intention to make the objection together with particulars in writing of the unfitness alleged is given not less than 12 months before the hearing of the application to the person who, at the time of the giving of the notice, holds the licence in respect of which the application is brought."

There is provision there for 12 months' notice. It is quite obvious to me that that will be the practice under this Bill when it becomes law. It will be the practice adopted by any reasonable Court.

Comment on this

Would the Minister have Section 24 amended accordingly?

Comment on this

I do not feel that is necessary at the moment. I shall look into the points that have been made between now and the Report Stage, but I do not think any amendment is necessary.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

My opposition to this section arises out of a concern for the consumer. It appears to me that publicans would under this section be allowed to sell whiskey of a lower strength than is now available. I feel it is unlikely there will be any corresponding reduction in the price. Since I recorded my opposition, however, those who know more about whiskey than I do have informed me that we are not the race of men we once were. Apparently, we can no longer take the "hard tack" the hard way as our ancestors did. The modern trend, whether it arises out of fear or physical inability, is to go for a whiskey of a lower strength. As a nation, we are in the undignified position of finding ourselves having to imitate the Scot, and it was our ancestors who taught the Scottish people how to make whiskey.

I have been told that Fíor-Ghaela to-day, particularly those who drive motor cars, are tending to consume whiskey of a lower strength. However, I thought it desirable to record opposition to enable the Minister to make his case for the section. I know the members of the Liquor Commission accepted the arguments put to them that whiskey ought not to be sold at 30º under proof. In view of the wide public interest in the matter I thought it desirable that the full case should be put before the people before the section is passed. If the Minister does that, I shall be prepared to withdraw my opposition.

Comment on this

This section is simply designed to obviate the necessity of a publican hanging up in his bar a notice that the whiskey sold in his premises could be under 24º. Hitherto you could sell Scotch at 30º u.p. If you sold Scotch by the glass and not by the bottle you had to hang up that notice. You also had to hang up a special notice if you sold Irish whiskey 30º u.p. This enables the publican to sell Scotch and Irish on an equal basis. Is that not so?

Comment on this

Under Section 6 of the Sale of Food and Drugs Act, 1875, it is an offence to sell to a purchaser any article of food or any drug which is not of the nature, substance and quality of the article demanded. The essence of the offence is that the sale must be made to the purchaser without notice and, if a purchaser is properly put on notice by the seller that the article, as sold, is not precisely as ordered then, of course, there is no offence under the section. Under the provision it would be an offence, therefore, to sell spirits diluted to any extent unless the purchaser was put on notice. By an Act of 1879, however, it was provided that notice need not be given to the purchaser where the dilution consisted of the addition of water only and did not make the spirits weaker than 25º u.p., in the case of whiskey, brandy or rum, or 35º u.p., in the case of gin. In other words, from 1879 onwards, the sale of whiskey, brandy and rum at a strength of 25º u.p., has been legal without special notice to the customers. I do not profess to know at what strength these spirits were normally marketed at that time, 1879, but it is a reasonable inference that many of them were marketed at 25º u.p., that this was commonly known and that there was no reason why a special notice of the strength should have been given once the spirits were at least of a strength of 25º u.p. The purpose of Section 28 is to alter the standards set by the 1879 Act from 25 u.p. to 30 u.p. In other words, to provide that notice need not in future be given to the customers so long as the spirit sold is at least of strength 30 u.p. which, I need hardly say, is weaker than 25 u.p. I have a note here which tells me all about the meaning of proof.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know what he is missing if he is depending on the note to tell him.

Comment on this

I am satisfied that the customer will be protected. It is reducing the strength, so that if the Deputy drinks a little more whiskey, it will not have any more effect on him than what he has been drinking.

Comment on this

The section is a very useful one. Unfortunately, since we took away from the Garda the duties of food and frug inspectors, I am afraid the section is no longer being enforced. Local authorities have not the same interest in it and have not appointed any individuals to take the place of the Gardaí who were food and drug inspectors. The Minister should endeavour to go back to the old system and not only have the section actually written but enforced as well.

Comment on this

It appears to me that they have a republic of their own up in county Donegal. This section will be very much of an ease of the very rigid enforcement of the Food and Drugs Acts under Mayo County Council. This obviously is the nuisance section under which all traders who do not display this notice have to face prosecution in the district court. If that is not the Deputy's experience in Donegal, certainly it is the widespread experience in Mayo. I am quite sure this was the position the Commission had in mind when making their recommendation.

Comment on this

The correct history of this is as follows. Originally, nobody hung up a notice about 30 u.p. but as the consumption of Scotch whisky increased, all of which is bottled at 30 u.p., the production of this notice became an essential. You had to hang it up if you were selling whisky, other than in a sealed bottle, under 25 u.p. But we ought not to pass the section without realising that the universal practice of the trade has been to sell a certain type of Irish whiskey at 24 u.p., a certain type at 25 u.p. and all types of Scotch at 30 u.p. This section now makes it practicable and lawful, without notice, to reduce the proof of all Irish whiskey to 30 u.p. You could not do that heretofore without hanging up your notice.

As a matter of fact, any public house in which Scotch whiskey was sold on draught, so to speak, had to hang up this notice and was free to sell Irish whiskey at the lower proof. It will not now be necessary to hang up the notice any longer. Everyone can sell whiskey at 30 u.p. The truth is, of course, that if you hung up the notice heretofore, you could sell Irish whiskey or Scotch whiskey at 30 u.p., but the practice was to sell Irish at 25 u.p. and Scotch at 30 u.p. Now, without hanging up any notice, it is lawful to sell either at 30 u.p.

Comment on this

The truth is that many innocent publicans who were not well up in the Act had their reputations taken away and were slandered by prosecutions which were understood by the ordinary public to mean——

Comment on this

They were watering their whiskey.

Comment on this

——they were playing puck with their whiskey.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53 (a):

Before section 29 to insert a new section as follows:—

"(1) Section 22 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1927, shall apply in regard to the inspection of clubs by any member of the Garda Síochána.

(2) Section 25 of the Intoxicating Liquor (General) Act, 1924 is hereby repealed."

If this new section were inserted, it would affect Section 29. Consequently, I should prefer that a discussion on amendment 54 would be in order as well.

Comment on this

I think the House could discuss Section 29 and the two amendments all together.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the House is agreeable.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That means that Section 29 and amendment 53 (a) and amendment 54 will be discussed together.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 54 in the name of Deputy McGilligan reads:

In page 17, lines 8 and 9, to delete ‘substitution in subsection (1) of "member" for "officer"' and substitute ‘deletion in subsection (1) of "not being below the rank of Inspector" and the insertion in the said subsection (1) and in subsection (2) of the word "inspectors" before the word "sergeants" and the insertion in subsection (3) of the word "inspector" before the word "sergeant".'

The purpose of this amendment is to restore the minimum rank at which a member of the Garda Síochána can act in pursuance of the searching of a club. Heretofore, the law provided that in fact nobody below the rank of, I think, a superintendent could take responsibility for this action. The proposed wording of this Bill would appear to make it possible for an officer of the rank of inspector to take the initiative in this matter. We think that a commissioned officer of the Garda should be the appropriate rank to discharge the duties envisaged in the section to which this amendment refers and accordingly we thought it right to bring the matter to the attention of the House in the form of this amendment.

Comment on this

I think we are opposing Section 29 on different grounds. My amendment seeks to ensure that the same law will apply to clubs as applies to public houses and that the rank of the officer or member of the Garda Síochána who would be entitled to inspect a public house would be sufficiently high to inspect a club. An ordinary member of the Garda Síochána can raid or investigate an ordinary licensed premises but it takes either an inspector, or a written permit from an inspector, before an investigation or raid can be carried out on a club premises. The Commission, which has been quoted here so often by the Minister in support of a number of sections, were very clear in their minds in connection with this privilege afforded to those people who are wealthy enough to be members of various clubs.

The Commission, with the exception of two individuals, reported that they could see no justification for distinguishing between clubs and public houses. I would refer the Minister to page 13 of the Report of the Commission which states:

Testimony was offered to us that disregard for the hours and conditions of sale of drink was a feature of some clubs and, while there was not sufficient evidence before us to determine whether this abuse was general, we were satisfied that the abuse existed, and we had particular evidence in one case where the huge turnover in bar receipts indicated that the main function of the club would appear to be the supply of intoxicating liquor.

The 1925 Commission recommended that the hours of sale in clubs should be kept the same as in public-houses and we see no reason to depart from that recommendation.

They went on to say:—

"Nor do we see any justification for distinguishing between clubs and public-houses or hotels in the matter of supervision and we recommend that clubs be subject to the same methods of inspection as licensed premises.

I do not see any reason in the world why there should be one law for the wealthy and another for the poor, as far as having a drink is concerned, and the idea of providing something special for the snobocracy is deplorably in disregard of the ordinary amenities which should be available to all sections, irrespective of their standing in the community. I shall not bore the House with the history of how this segregation began, but it should be sufficient to say that this division with regard to the powers to be exercised in relation to the inspection of ordinary licensed premises and clubs stems from the Licensing Acts of 1872 and 1874. At that time a constable, as he was then described, was entitled to raid public-houses but, from then on, clubs could not be raided by the ordinary rank and file of the police force.

The idea was that in the clubs you had the gentry and the gentry could not, under any circumstances, be put on the same basis as ordinary citizens. It would be a shocking state of affairs if policeman McGuire or policeman Murphy were able to walk into a club where Lieut.-Col. So-and-So was having his ball of malt after hours and charge him with a breach of the licensing laws. That is only one aspect of the matter.

One striking thing emerges from the sections which still deal with this in previous Acts. In the 1924 Intoxicating Liquor Act we have the provision in subsection (3) of Section 25 that:

In the event of any person or persons found in such premises refusing to give their respective names and addresses when requested by any such sergeant, constable, or guard or giving false names and addresses, such person or persons so doing shall be liable severally on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding ten pounds.

Comment on this

Does the section not do what the Deputy wants?

Comment on this

No. The word "member" is taken into consideration.

According to the 1927 Act, a member means a member of the Garda Síochána not below the rank of inspector.

Comment on this

Is that the purpose of this section too?

Comment on this