We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1959—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 136–275 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1959
Enacted

No. 41 of 1959 ›

When the Commission strongly urged that Gardaí and sergeants should be in a position to raid clubs we felt that Section 29 met the wishes of the Commission, but Section 29 was completely misleading because it substituted "member" for "officer", but the rank is that of inspector and not lower. If the word "member" meant an ordinary member of the Garda Síochána there would be no need for me to put down this amendment, and it was just by luck that I hit upon it at the last moment before matters had gone too far.

In the section dealing with powers to raid public-houses, Section 22, subsection (2) of the 1927 Act, states:

Any member of the Garda Síochána may arrest without warrant any person who, on his name and address or such corroborative evidence as aforesaid being lawfully demanded of him under this section, fails or refuses to give such name and address or either of them or such evidence.

A Garda is entitled to arrest a man in a public-house for failing to give his name and address but no such power exists with regard to clubs. In the section in the 1924 Act which deals with clubs it merely states that if there is failure to give names and addresses the persons concerned can be liable to a fine not exceeding £10, but the officer making the raid has no power to make an arrest of any individual who fails to obey the law whereas, in the ordinary public house, Joe Soap can be taken out by the ear by a Garda and arrested for failing to disclose his name and address. If that is not showing a differentiation between the various citizens of this State I do not know what is.

I would suggest to the Minister that one way of dealing with this is by accepting the new section which I propose here, which merely brings into operation in respect of clubs the same provision as applies to licensed premises.

Comment on this

I cannot understand how Deputy McQuillan cannot see a very basic difference between a club and an ordinary licensed premises. The licensed premises is a business established for the sale of drink for the purpose of making a profit. A club, on the other hand, is not solely for wealthy people. I cannot recall the word Deputy McQuillan used.

Comment on this

Snobocracy.

Comment on this

There are several working men's clubs, soccer clubs, football clubs and other clubs all over the city. The most usual feature about them is that most of them are up to their ears in debt to their banks. In fact, even the Catholic Commercial Club this year—which I do not think is full of snobs—was forced to increase its members' fees considerably. A club is the next nearest thing to the home. People subscribe a fee to the club and support its activities. There are several fund-raising activities in order to run a soccer team, promote some other form of sport or just for the sake of having a social amenity and meeting place. The members, in fact, own any drink that is on the property. They are shareholders in that intoxicating liquor. As such, they should be given more consideration than the ordinary licensed publican who is in business for profit. There is adequate protection against abuse. They can be raided. It is most desirable that there should be recognition of their special position.

For that reason, I certainly cannot support the views of Deputy McQuillan and I am more prepared to go along with Deputy Ryan, to leave the position as it was heretofore. I think the Minister should consider the very special position of the club. However, since Deputy McQuillan has spoken, I am quite satisfied with the section as it stands if "member" means inspector. I take it the Minister will deal with that point and if this word "member" does mean the rank of inspector, then, of course, the section is perfectly satisfactory to my mind.

Comment on this

Are not all the names on the register?

Comment on this

I think Deputy McQuillan has missed the point. A guard, as he says, may arrest Joe Soap for refusing to give his name in a seven-day licensed premises but in a club every person knows who the person on the premises is because, first of all, he must be a member and if he is a member he is known by everybody and, secondly, if he is not a member, he must be introduced by a member and must sign the visitors' book.

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this

All the inspector need do is to check the book and he finds out who the person is. I am in full agreement with Deputy Lemass and with Deputy Dillon who has said that the club should not be subject to a raid by every Guard on patrol simply because his curiosity may get the better of him. He has a method of checking any hour of the day by looking up the register and seeing who is there, if they are members and, if not members, by whom they were introduced. Deputy Lemass is quite right. A club is somewhat similar to the home and one would not like to have a Guard dropping into the house at every moment of the night and asking one to account for all the visitors to one's house, particularly when they are usually partaking of hospitality, and they would be in a case such as this partaking of the hospitality of the members of the club because no profit, as Deputy Lemass has pointed out, or very little profit other than a marginal one, is made.

I think the Legislature, in its wisdom, was very correct in confining the right of entry to a club to an officer of a certain rank but I should like to hear the Minister confirm that "member" means no person of a rank less than inspector.

Comment on this

You will find it does.

Comment on this

I should like to have confirmation.

Comment on this

I completely disagree with the opinions expressed by Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Lemass and Deputy McGilligan who has put down this amendment. First of all, Deputy Lemass suggests that in a club the drink belongs to the club member and he is in his home. Why is he subject to licensing laws at all if it is his own drink and if he is in his own home? It must be considered that if the person to raid a club must be a person with at least the rank of inspector, the number of clubs in certain police districts is so great that there would not be sufficient inspectors to go round.

I do not see why the member of a club who is a member of the drinking fraternity should not be subject to the same police supervision as the customer in an ordinary public house. The purpose of this Bill was to create uniformity in the licensed trade. Three things govern uniformity—trading hours, supervision and licence fee. The clubs get away with a very nominal licence fee whereas the public house which is competing against it, down the road, is paying top wages, which the clubs are not, and paying top licence fee. Therefore, to my mind, Deputy McQuillan's amendment is a very, very good amendment. In my view, all the people who want to partake of intoxicating liquor should be subject to the same police supervision.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

I must say at the outset that I have misled Deputy Lemass just as the particular drafting of the Bill itself has misled me. This section as it is worded is a classic example of the drafting to which Deputy Dillon, the Leader of the Opposition, has already taken exception to-day. At the time I was considering this Bill I had not before me the precise terms of the Act of 1924 but I was speaking from recollection, from my experience as a lawyer, in relation to the Intoxicating Liquor Act. I was not in the fortunate position of having before me an opinion of the Attorney General as to the meaning of the Act, which is not on record, and the section as it goes down on paper is full of so many brackets and substitutions in relation to subsections which are again in brackets, inverted commas and otherwise, that one would need the time that only civil servants can afford for consideration of a Bill of this kind in order clearly to understand the section. Despite all that has been said, written and recorded, Deputy O'Donnell is apparently still in some doubt as to the precise effect of the section as drafted.

The precise effect of the section as drafted is to permit any member of the Garda Síochána not below the rank of inspector to issue a warrant for the search and inspection of clubs but I am of the same opinion as Deputy McQuillan and Deputy Belton that there should be no distinction between the searching and inspection of clubs and the searching and inspection of other premises which have liquor licences. I take my stand from experience. I very frequently pass two clubs in the City of Dublin at a late hour of the night on my way home, outside of which there may be anything from 12 to 20 cars, some of which are there long after even the bona fide houses close.

Under Section 25 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1924, any officer of the Dublin Metropolitan Police or of the Garda Síochána who is of the opinion that there is reasonable ground for supposing that a club is committing an offence may issue a warrant. If the presence of 12 or 20 cars at 1 a.m. or 2 a.m. is not reasonable ground for supposing there is a commission of an offence, I cannot imagine what the judges would consider a reasonable ground.

I believe that if there is that reasonable ground for supposing that there is a commission of an offence such as the presence of a large number of cars in the concourse outside a golf club or out on the public street or if there are sounds of hilarity, laughter and jollification coming across the night air, it is desirable that an ordinary Guard on the beat might make his presence felt, come in and inspect the club and prosecute those found committing breaches of the law, irrespective of whether or not the club is solvent or not solvent, irrespective of whether the main objects of the club are sporting, religious or commercial.

The whole purpose of this Bill is to impose uniformity. Against the very clearly stated wishes of Deputies in different parts of the country, the Minister and the Government have ploughed on indiscriminately insisting on this principle of uniformity but here, for some strange reason in relation to this item, we are conferring privileges on that relatively small section of the people who may belong to clubs which hold liquor licences. I believe that is very bad. I might say that at one time I was of opinion that it was not desirable that noncommissioned officers of the Garda Siochana should be raiding clubs because so many clubs were in off the public highway there was a possibility that a Guard, as soon as he went into a clubhouse would be persuaded by the members to overlook the fact that a breach of the licensing laws was taking place, that he would be given a few "jorums", and there would be no more about it. However, I think that fear of mine was imaginary and not within reason, as with the men we have in the force at the present time there is not that likelihood.

I would not agree completely with the wording of Deputy McQuillan's amendment because I believe it would allow Guards to inspect clubs without having a reasonable suspicion that the law was being broken. I do not think that desirable because they could easily pester a club. I appreciate the point that Deputy Lemass and Deputy O'Donnell were making that a club is a private institution and should not be raided without a reason. However, if it is known to the Guards that people leave club premises at a late hour of the night long after public houses are supposed to be closed and if the Guards can see with their own eyes a large number of cars outside a licensed premises, they should be able to inspect that building without having to return to the station to get a warrant from an inspector or a superintendent.

Comment on this

I am in agreement with the views expressed by Deputy Lemass and Deputy O'Donnell but I am in disagreement with the views expressed by Deputy Ryan and Deputy Belton. There has been a bit of mixed thinking involved in this amendment proposed by Deputy McQuillan. Reference has been made to the section as it stands conferring privileges on clubs. I do not think that is so. I think the section as it stands and the earlier provisions in the licensing code merely recognise a difference which is there already. There is a vast difference between a public house, that is, a business in which the owner engages in the sale of drink to the public, and a club. A club is an institution in which a number of people band themselves together jointly to own and run a building and own and dispose of whatever stock of drink may be in it. It is a private concern of the members and it is not in any sense an enterprise in which drink is sold to the public.

The licensing provision have always recognised the distinction between a public house and a private club and there is no question of "snobocracy." It would be quite intolerable if any Guard on the beat, for whatever idea might come into his head, had the right and authority to go into a club and raid it. When the term "club" is used I suppose one is inclined to think of golf clubs, tennis clubs and clubs in which persons who enjoy a large income spend their leisure hours. As Deputy Lemass very correctly pointed out, the vast majority of clubs in the city are clubs in which ordinary working people have banded together. I have been for many years a member of a club not very far from this building which would, under no circumstances, qualify for the definition used by Deputy McQuillan.

Comment on this

That is not the Kildare Street club?

Comment on this

Indeed it is not, but I know well the members of that club would very much recent the fact that a Guard on the beat outside could raid their premises, invade their privacy and treat them as if they were persons in a public house. They are not in a public house. They are in premises which they own jointly and they are exercising their ordinary rights of property.

The provisions as they stand are proper provisions and recognise the essential difference between the law applicable to public houses and the law applicable to clubs, and I see no reason why they should be changed. The fact that in order to inspect or raid a club a member of the Garda Síochána must seek the authority of, and act through, a senior officers is a very desirable provision. I have little doubt that it has not been abused. It has worked well in the past and I see no reason why it should be changed.

Comment on this

This is a case of much ado about nothing. This is the existing law. Deputy McQuillan has created the impression in the minds of members of the House that the Government were endeavouring to deceive them in some manner or other by the use of the words which are contained in the section. In the explanatory memorandum issued with the Bill it is stated in the clearest possible language that the reason we had to put in a Government amendment was that in the 1924 Act the word "Officer" is used and this is probably news to members of the House; I myself was, until I went into the Department of Justice of the firm belief that an inspector was an officer—an inspector is not an officer of the Garda Síochána. Therefore, we have to use the word "member" in order to exclude an inspector so that a warrant can be secured from an inspector.

If any person thinks that something untoward is happening in a club, all he has to do is to inform an officer, who will be a member of the Garda Síochána, that something undesirable is happening in that club, and the officer of the Garda Síochána, or an inspector, who is now included, can issue a warrant and a Garda can go in and search the premises. I think it would be highly undesirable for a Garda to go indiscriminately into what is purely a private concern. He is allowed to go into a public house because a public house is a place where the public can congregate and it is run purely for profit. A club is run to provide amenities for the members and it is, I think, as private as a home. Members meet there to converse, to talk about the affairs of the day, to play games or something of that kind.

It would be highly undesirable that every Garda patrolling the street could, at will, walk in and search the premises. He can do that if Deputy McQuillan or Deputy Ryan or any other individual thinks something is going on there that should not be going on and he can have the place searched but only in the circumstances in which it should be done. There is something wrong about that. I think it is desirable that a power should be there, if it is necessary to use it, but what I want to impress on Deputy McQuillan and Deputy Ryan is that that has been in existence and has been operating since 1924 and we have not had anything in the nature of what might be described as bad reports about what has been going on.

Comment on this

The Commission made recommendations on it.

Comment on this

The Commission made many recommendations which the Government did not accept, in their wisdom or otherwise. In this case, we thought it undesirable that the same freedom should be granted to an ordinary Garda in respect of clubs as in respect of public houses.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

On Second Stage, the Minister said that when the Bill became law, it would be strictly enforced. I believe if the power of inspection of clubs were properly used, even the present limited powers, many of the objections would be removed. If we had an assertion from the Minister that those powers will be exercised as often as necessary, the strong objections of some members to this section would be removed.

Comment on this

It comes as a complete surprise to me to hear the views expressed by Deputies who favour this proposition. I am completely bewildered by the suggestion that there should be any difference between a Garda and an inspector. I simply do not understand it. If a person has broken the law—and that is what we are dealing with: we are dealing with laws which have been made by this House to control the operation of publichouses and clubs or whatever you like to call them; they are the licensing laws which are made here, and they must be implemented by the members of the Garda Síochána —I cannot see, for the life of me, why a Garda should not have the same right as an inspector to go in, to inspect the club and see whether or not the laws are being broken.

Deputy Lemass suggested that clubs are like private houses, that it would be wrong to have an individual Garda going in to inspect them, and that an inspector should be sent in. That does not seem to follow at all. In the case of the burglary of a private house, there is no objection to a Garda going in to see if the law is being broken, and if a burglary has, in fact, been committed. An inspector is not sent to a private house if a burglary has taken place. When a crime is suspected between two people living in a private house and it is necessary to see whether the law is being broken, we do not have to get an inspector to investgate, because it is a private house.

Obviously, that is completely absurd. It is an evasion, and an attempt to retain a privilege which was begun, the Minister said, in 1920 something or other, and Deputy McQuillan said in 1870 something or other. As the Minister said, that is the law as it stands. That is why we object to it. We object to it because it is a law which was introduced at a time when these privileges were very marked between ourselves and the aristocracy of the time. For the reasons stated by Deputy McQuillan, they felt they should not be soiled by an ordinary member of the Garda putting his hands on their shoulders and saying: "I arrest you." We are now to have the same differences in our own society in that a club member would be contaminated by being dealt with by an ordinary plain member of the public Garda. The only person who can arrest him or charge him with a breach of the law in an inspector. That is obviously and demonstrably absurd.

This suggestion that because one is a commercial undertaking and the other is run for the benefit of the members of the club can be pursued. Let us have legislation organised in this way. A taxi man runs his taxi to make money and a private motorist runs his car for pleasure. Very good. The taxi man has an accident and is arrested by a member of the Garda but the private motorist cannot be arrested by a Garda and must be arrested by an inspector. In that way, we cannot have a Garda dealing with anybody who is not engaged in a commercial undertaking, and an inspector can only touch somebody who is in a private business and does not contaminate himself by being involved in this invidious practice of making a living.

The suggestion that a Garda may pester a club is quite clearly absurd. If we have a man who is so irresponsible, why are we not worried by the fact that he might pester a pub too? Suppose he does pester a pub, let us insist in order to get a responsible type of officer, a man who will not pester a pub that only an inspector can raid a pub as well as a club.

It is obviously quite absurd that a Garda might see, as Deputy Ryan suggested, 12 or 13 cars outside a club and have to go back to the Garda station and say: "I suspect a breach of the licensing laws; I want a warrant." Why all this unnecessary fuss? Why cannot he do what he would do if he were passing a pub and saw the lights on and cars outside and say: "I believe there is a breach of the law; I will inspect in the ordinary way." I do not think this whole idea of a differential between the pub and the club is right. The pub is the poor man's club, the working man's club. He cannot afford to band together with his friends in this way and have the amenities which Deputy Lemass points out are to be found in clubs.

Deputy Lemass made another bizarre suggestion that these people should not be pestered or worried in this way because they may be up to their ears in debt and, by inference, he seemed to suggest they should be allowed to break the law to get out of debt. What about the unfortunate publican who is making a loss? Are we to give him special privileges so that he will not be worried by the Garda, and say he will be raided only by an inspector? There are so few inspectors——

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is under a misapprehension there. The inspector is the person who can issue a warrant but a Garda can go into the premises and carry out a raid or make an arrest, if he so desires.

Comment on this

I am grateful for the Minister's interruption and clarification. If that is so, all right. Let us have that for the pubs as well—let us have uniformity.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of public houses does not arise on this amendment which deals specifically with clubs.

Comment on this

The point was made by some Deputies that the law should not be the same for clubs as for pubs. The Minister introduced this legislation to establish unity in our licensing laws. Various anomalies have been discussed during the past few days— the differentiation between the country and the city, the bona fide, Sunday trading, and so on. This is another anomaly which the Minister would be well advised to remove so that pubs would be raided by inspectors as well as clubs.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not continue to discuss public houses now. The amendment relates to the searching of clubs by the Garda Síochána.

Comment on this

The suggestion that these clubs only should be raided or inspected is an attempted to retain what is manifestly class legislation. It is about time we got rid of it.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Dr. Browne is endavouring to misrepresent a situation when he talks about class distinction. He said that if a burglary is committed, an ordinary Guard can go into a house. That is not so; he must be invited. The ordinary Garda may not go into a Corporation park unless invited to do so by the Corporation. If an offence is committed in a public park, he may not go in unless he is invited.

Comment on this

By an inspector?

Comment on this

I am not sure of the rank—by an officer of the Corporation. I am delighted to have heard the Minister. The amendment is now very clear and satisfactory to the majority view. I can understand some publicans taking the line: "Maybe we have a slight disadvantage here but these clubs providing football pitches, handball alleys, billiard tables, card rooms, and so on, must submit to rules. They must cease the sale of intoxicating liquor at the prescribed hour. They may play billiards or a game of cards in the club until a late hour but they may not sell intoxicating liquor." I think the National Progressive Democrats are trying to work up a lot of wind about nothing. The Minister is quite right in what he said.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass has suggested, with regard to parks and other such places, that an invitation would have to be issued by the responsible authority, in this case, the Dublin Corporation——

Comment on this

Park rangers, for instance.

Comment on this

——before a Garda is entitled to make an inspection where a crime is committed. It would appear that what he is aiming at is that clubs in the city and throughout the country now and again invite a member of the Garda Síochána and perhaps an inspector who wish to have a raid carried out——

Comment on this

Nonsense. I am simply pointing out that it is a private concern.

Comment on this

There is every reason to ensure that far more vigorous inspection will take place after the argument by Deputy N. Lemass that poor football clubs, working-men's clubs, and a variety of clubs made up of the poorer sections of the community need money and that the only way they can make it is through the sale of drink. Under the law, there are certain house for the sale of drink. Is it now suggested that the only way they can make money is by selling drink illegally and that they should not be allowed——

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that.

Comment on this

Ha, ha!

Comment on this

I can think of no other interpretation. I am afraid Deputy Lemass has not helped to shorten this debate. The Minister for Justice is a very innocent man, as far as clubs are concerned. I doubt very much if he has ever seen the inside of a club, judging by his remarks. I thought for a moment his description of a club sounded much more like a place where a branch of the Legion of Mary hold their meetings.

From my limited experience of clubs, I have found that from the official closing time onwards, until all hours they are without supervision. There would seem to be no question about that. Deputy Ryan pointed out that, on his way home, he passes one or two clubs at a late hour——

Comment on this

Does he always pass them?

Comment on this

I do not know if Deputy Haughey passes them.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass is not allowed to say anything more. Deputy Haughey has told him so. Deputy Haughey was told to tell him so by Deputy Geoghegan and Deputy Geoghegan was told by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach to tell Deputy Haughey.

Comment on this

Deputy Ryan pointed out that where 15 or 20 motor cars are parked outside a club at midnight, it is fair to assume that 50 per cent. of the people who own the cars are having a "jorum" on the premises after hours. The only way in which that can be established by law is through some individual inviting the inspector to come in, the inspector thinking it over very carefully and then deciding to issue a search order to a sergeant or a Garda, possibly two hours afterwards, when the birds have flown. Unquestionably you cannot——

Comment on this

They are not allowed in after 10 p.m.

Comment on this

——have proper supervision of clubs under the existing arrangement. Evidence given before the Commission was to the effect that more illegal drinking goes on in clubs than in publichouses. As a result, a number of us on the Commission felt so strongly about it that we persuaded all but two members of the Commission to agree that there was only one way to sort this out—apart from the inequality of having one law for people in a club and another law for people outside—and that was that, in order to have proper supervision, it was necessary to bring the clubs more under the control of the Garda Síochána.

I feel a slur has been cast by a number of Deputies on the ordinary member of the Garda Síochána. It was suggested it would be wrong for an ordinary member of the Garda Síochána to poke his nose, out of curiosity, into the inner sanctum of some club—that it would annoy the members of the club. They only question that arises is an offence under the licensing laws. The inspection would not be for any other purpose. It would not be for the purpose of seeing if they were playing pitch-and-toss or anything like that in one of these exclusive clubs. Some Deputies seem to have an idea that an ordinary member of the Garda Síochána is slightly——

Comment on this

Déclassé.

Comment on this

——and that he should not be allowed to move in among the gentry. The argument that there are workingmen's clubs, and so on, does not carry any weight at all. It is suggested in this House now that if a group of people band together for the purpose of having social events organised and so forth and register themselves as a club—sporting or otherwise—they are immediately outside the normal scope of the law as far as the sale of drink is concerned. That is what you are establishing. I believe that where you have drink on sale, it is not a question of the property of the members of the club. The members of the club purchase their drink. They can invite visitors in who likewise purchase.

Comment on this

Again, not officially, as the Leader of the Opposition should well know.

Comment on this

Surely, a visitor to a club cannot purchase drink?

Comment on this

He cannot, and neither can the club sell drink after hours—officially. I doubt whether Deputy Dillon is as familiar with the working of many of the clubs in Dublin as he appears to suggest he is when he maintains that a visitor does not pay for the privilege of being allowed as a visitor. He would not pay many visits if he were to go in on such terms.

Comment on this

That is a very revolutionary doctrine, I must say.

Comment on this

I do not want to delay the House on this matter. I can assure the House that Deputy Lemass was responsible for the greatest part of the delay so far. I would ask the Minister to have another look at this. It is a recommendation that goes back even to 1925. There is no use in the Minister telling us that that is there since 1924 and that, because it has been there since then, it should remain now. There is no argument on that basis. The licensing laws have been there for many years. We have been changing them and the purpose of this measure is to change the existing regulations and improve them. We want to get rid of anomalies and introduce uniformity all round.

Comment on this

In the course of my remarks a few minutes ago, I omitted to mention that the Garda Síochána were consulted on this matter. They were satisfied with the power which they have. Perhaps, my omission was the cause of the debate continuing. I also mentioned the fact that this is the existing law.

Comment on this

Since they are not content to be tried in the District Court, would they not like to go to the Supreme Court?

Comment on this

If the police are satisfied, I am satisfied.

Comment on this

I am sure that the "Tubs of Blood" would love to go to the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:—

Before section 30 to insert the following new section:

"(1) Section 25 (which relates to the recording of convictions on licences) of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by—

(a) the deletion in subsection (1) of ‘if the Court in its discretion so thinks proper' (inserted by the Act of 1943) and the substitution therefore of ‘subject to subsection (4) of this section',

(b) the substitution of ‘two years' for ‘five years', ‘four years' for ‘seven years' and ‘six years' for ‘ten years' in subsection (2), and

(c) the addition to the section of the following subsection:

‘(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (1) of this section, where a person is convicted in relation to any premises in respect of which he holds a licence for the sale of intoxicating liquor by retail of an offence to which this Part of this Act applies and the conviction is the first conviction of that person in relation to those premises of an offence to which this Part of this Act applies, the conviction shall not be recorded on the licence.'

(2) Every conviction which, immediately before the passing of this Act, stood recorded under section 25 of the Act of 1927 on a licence then in force, shall, upon the passing of this Act, cease for all purposes to be so recorded and where, before the passing of this Act, the holder of a licence then on force had been convicted of an offence to which Part III of the Act of 1927 applies, such holder shall, for the purposes of subsection (2) and subsection (4) (inserted by this section) of the said section 25, be deemed never to have been so convicted."

This amendment makes provision in relation to the compulsory endorsement of a licence for each offence after the first. We have already discussed it with Amendment 31 and I need not say anything more.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.56:—

Before section 30 to insert the following new section:

"(1) Where an order under section 9 of the Intoxicating Liquor (General) Act, 1924, prescribing the sizes of bottles in which an intoxicating liquor specified in the order may be sold is in force, neither section 28 nor section 29 of the Act of 1878 shall apply in relation to a bottle to which this section applies.

(2) The denomination of a bottle to which this section applies and a line defining its capacity shall be indicated on the bottle by indelible marks.

(3) The Minister for Industry and Commerce may make regulations in relation to bottles to which this section applies—

(a) prescribing the size and position of the line defining the capacity of the bottles,

(b) prescribing the denomination marks for the bottles, their sizes and their positions on the bottles,

(c) prescribing the limits of error to be allowed in relation to the capacity of the bottles as defined by the line aforesaid,

(d) prohibiting any feature in the design of the bottles which appears likely to facilitate the perpetration of fraud.

(4) Where in relation to a bottle to which this section applies there is a contravention of subsection (2) of this section or of regulations made under subsection (3) of this section, the bottle shall be deemed to be an unjust measure for the purposes of section 25 of the Act of 1878.

(5) Every regulation made under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, and if a resolution annulling the regulation is passed by either such House within the next twenty-one days on which that House has sat after the regulation is laid before it, the regulation shall be annulled accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done thereunder.

(6) In this section—

‘the Act of 1878' means the Weights and Measures Act, 1878;

‘bottle to which this section applies' means a bottle which is required by an order referred to in subsection (1) of this section to be of a size prescribed thereby."

This is an amendment to replace Section 30 of the Bill by a revised section. May I say, right at the outset, that the new section as now proposed will achieve in full the object of the original section while at the same time allaying the fears of certain trade interests who expressed their satisfaction with the amendment.

As the House is aware, the object of Section 30 was to put an end to the present elaborate system of verification of the sizes of beer bottles by inspectors of weights and measures. As I explained in my reply to the Second Reading debate, the system was imposed, not as a result of a considered decision, but by what I might term a legal accident. An Order was made which required beer bottles to be one of three standard sizes. After that was done it was found that this simple provision made each bottle into a legal measure and attracted all the provisions of the Weights and Measures Acts.

I have, of course, never sought to make the case that this system was a costly one in terms of so much per bottle, or even so much per gross bottles. What I said was that it began by accident, that it is quite unnecessary and that the cost of it, irrespective of who pays for it, is for the most part wasted money. And the waste is there, however small the cost per unit may be. It is, I hope, a good principle that one should seek to dismantle controls that are unnecessary even though the gain to any one person may be negligible.

I pointed out in my reply to the Second Reading debate that the effect of Section 30 had obviously been completely misunderstood by certain trade interests who appeared to believe that the section would lead to the introduction of new sizes of bottles and would facilitate fraud by publicans. I think I can claim to have shown conclusively that these fears were unfounded.

Meanwhile, however, another aspect of the matter was brought to my notice. Here I should like to express my thanks to Deputy Dillon who wrote to me to draw my attention to it and went to the trouble of sending me some samples of bottles to show what he had in mind.

Comment on this

Were they full or empty?

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon's point which I may say was later endorsed by interested persons outside the House, was that, even though the section as introduced did not leave the way open for fraud or the deliberate introducing of non-standard bottles, there was a distinct possibility that firms handling non-standard bottles for the export trade might get some of them accidentally mixed up with the standard bottles for the home trade if there were not some marks which would readily distinguish the standard bottles from the others.

I accept that as a valid point and the amendment will meet it. The position under the amendment will be that the bottles will, as at present, have to have the size marked clearly on them. The vast majority, of course, are half-pints but pints and thirds of pints are legal as well. The bottles will also be required to have, as at present, a line showing the point to which they should be filled in order to contain the appropriate quantity. All that will be missing from the bottle as at present marketed will be the small official verification mark and the absence of this will make no obvious difference to the appearance of the bottle. The non-standard bottles do not, of course, have the size or a filling line embossed on them. It is this fact which makes them immediately distinguishable from the standard bottle.

The verification mark it at present required and imposed under Sections 28 and 29 of the Weights and Measures Act, 1878. Under subsection (1) of the amendment those sections will no longer apply to beer bottles. All the other provisions of the Weights and Measures Acts will, however, continue to apply to them, including the provisions for enforcement.

Subsection (3) of the amendment gives the Minister for Industry and Commerce power to make certain regulations. Such a power exists already and there are, in fact, regulations in force at present dealing with the various matters set out in the subsection in so far as they affect beer bottles. The authority for the making of these regulations, however, is so worded that it could not readily be adopted to apply to the new situation which the amendment will create and it had, therefore, to be re-enacted in a slightly modified form.

The amendment will, therefore, involve no upset to the bottle trade. Needless to say, all existing standard bottles will continue to be valid and, as I have explained, the markings of the size of the bottle and so on, will continue unchanged, so that there will be no interference with the manufacturing process. As I said at the outset, I understand that all the trade interests that might have an interest in this matter are satisfied with the amendments now proposed. I therefore ask the House to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I understand from what the Minister says that the difficulties which did arise in connection with the original section are now substantially removed. I am glad that my collaboration, expressed in terms of three virgin bottles, has answered the matter.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think that the least he might do by way of expressing his thanks to Deputy Dillon is to send back the bottles full?

Comment on this

I might offend against the licensing laws, if I did that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Am I right in saying that the net effect of the Minister's amendment is to dispense with the weights and measures inspectors who now test and verify the accuracy of bottles at source, that is, as they come off the moulds in the glass factory?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Substantially.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

In that event, I am as much opposed to the Minister's amendment as I was to the original section and I believe the Irish people will also be when they realise what is happening. The Minister said he never made the case that there was a tremendous waste of money by reason of the existing system, but he did say in a comment which he made on Section 30, and which he circulated to the trade, that the community pay for the present system and whether they pay as taxpayers or consumers does not alter the fact that the system is wasteful and unproductive. The truth of the matter is that the present system is an absolute guarantee, an absolute assurance that when you buy a bottle of stout, you are getting half a pint. The present system means that for that guarantee every publican pays only 6/- a year. When you drink that half-pint of stout from a bottle, you are paying, for that privilege, one seven-thousandth part of what you have paid—about as little as the fluorine which is to be put into the water; less than one-tenth of a bubble of the froth of a glass of stout—and it is the intention of the Government to remove that.

The present system operates as a complete guarantee. If we remove the inspectors at the source of manufacture, the result may well be that bottles of less than the stated quantity may get on to the market. The only way of checking it will be for the Guards or the weights and measures inspectors to go into the public-houses and get a bottle and test it. Can you imagine what may happen if there is a run of 10,000 bottles which are under measure? What will happen is that these will be distributed throughout the country long before the mistake is ever discovered.

It is necessary, I think, to understand the system of manufacture of glass bottles. They are manufactured by means of moulds and, as Deputies can well imagine, a considerable amount of heat is used in relation to the manufacture of glass bottles as well as in relation to all glass.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Are you sure?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

As a result of heat applied to the moulds——

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Are you sure?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

—— similar moulds may have a different length of life. One mould might——

Comment on this
Major de Valera

What is the coefficient of expansion of glass?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

——give as many as a quarter of a million accurate bottles and another mould, put on immediately afterwards, might manufacture only 10,000 accurate bottles before becoming inaccurate.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the manufacture of these bottles relevantly arise on this amendment?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

With respect, I think it does, because the necessity to measure bottles is what is being controlled by the section and the amendment.

Comment on this

It is the size of the bottle, not its manufacture.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

The position at present is that there are four weights and measures inspectors permanently in the glass bottle factory checking each and every bottle as it comes off the machine. Only when they are satisfied that it will accurately contain a half-pint, or a third of a pint, or a pint, as the case may be, is it let loose on the consuming public. If we remove that check and simply require the manufacturer to put a half-pint mark on the bottle, the danger may be that hundreds of thousands of bottles may well escape on to the market before a fault is ever discovered. I am not suggesting for one moment that there would be any intention to defraud, either on the part of the manufacturers or on the part of the wholesale distributors of bottles, but the present system guarantees there will be no mistake. Remove that and mistakes may arise.

Regarding the cost, I have already pointed out that the cost of this absolute guarantee and check is less than one seven-thousandth part of the price of a bottle of stout. The case may be made that by bringing in this, you will have four inspectors, four members of the Garda Síochána, returned to other duties and the State saved the expense of paying four inspectors and one part-time inspector. I would direct the attention of the members of this House to a Parliamentary Question which I asked on 25th February. The reply shows that over the past seven years, the total amount paid in fees was £27,000 and that the salary paid to these inspectors came only to £18,900, and that the State had made a profit of £8,162. In other words, there is no question of the existing system being an undue burden on the State's finances. In fact, they are getting a handsome return out of providing what is an absolute guarantee against bottles with a wrong measure getting on to the market.

There is another aspect of this section. As I understand the various Acts which relate to this, the manufacturers of bottles which have a wrong measure may not be prosecuted. If there is to be any prosecution, it will be against an innocent publican who buys the bottles in good faith from the wholesaler or the manufacturer. It is extremely difficult to test the difference between 16 bottles to the gallon and 17 bottles to the gallon. It cannot be done with the naked eye and in order to protect himself from prosecution, every publican would want to have a half pint or a pint measure. He would need to have the appropriate measure and to test every bottle coming in. If any duly authorised person should find that he is selling a quantity under the appropriate measure then, that innocent publican could find himself prosecuted. He would not have even the right that a shop-keeper has who sells goods which are found to be defective. If an action is taken against the shop-keeper he has a right of indemnity against the persons who supply him with the goods. That does not apply in regard to the amendment that the Minister is trying to bring in.

I am always reluctant to make comparisons between ourselves and the neighbouring island but, unfortunately, I have not had an opportunity of inquiring elsewhere to see what the state of the law is. It is pertinent to note however, that in Britain and in the northern portion of the country, which is not for the time being under our jurisdiction, they have not got the protection, the guarantee, that we have here but they are crying out for it.

It is being suggested that the amendment gets over the objection which I am voicing and which manufacturers of bottles, wholesale bottlers, and the public have previously voiced. I cannot see that it does. It simply means that the Minister for Industry and Commerce may require a mark to be put on a bottle to indentify the measure it contains but it still allows bottles of short measure to get on the market. It means that instead of the system that is operating of having four inspectors at the point of manufacture checking the bottles, you would have inspectors throughout the length and breadth of the country hounding every other publican to check whether his bottles are of the right measure. Think of the unfortunate publican whose shop is full of people drinking beer and stout when a Guard comes in and asks for a bottle, checks it and finds it is short measure.

We have been asked already this evening to agree to a section of the Bill about under-proof whiskey in order to save the unfortunate publican embarrassment. I think the embarrassment regarding under-proof whiskey would be nothing to that which would be caused in a beer or stout-selling house if the measure were found to be short. We have a system which is cheap: it costs 1/14th part of the pint of stout. I think it is a good and sound guarantee; it is a system that has worked well and a system which we would be very foolish to throw aside.

Comment on this

I do not know if there is any necessity to deal in extenso with this matter. It was obviously very wasteful to spend £27,000 in one case and even more——

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

In seven years.

Comment on this

And it is a waste of time for the Gardaí to sit down looking at bottles for no apparent purpose.

Comment on this

Empty bottles.

Comment on this

There might be some reason for it is the bottles were not empty. The manufacturers are satisfied with this, the public are satisfied and the trade unions are satisfied. If Deputy Ryan is not satisfied that the ordinary drinker of a bottle of stout would not be "codded" for every long by short measure, by some defect in the bottle, he does not, I suggest, know the capacity of the ordinary drinker of a bottle of stout to insist on getting in proper measure what he demands. I do not think there is any substance in Deputy Ryan's argument. The former system was a waste of effort in the first instance and I think that is the reason all the interests concerned are satisfied that it should go.

Comment on this

May I interpose a word? Am I to understand that the effect of the Minister's proposed amendment is substantially to maintain the situation in which the pint, the half-pint and the one-third pint bottle will remain a marked bottle with a line on it indicating the correct measure to be filled and that it will be an offence to sell beer or stout in a bottle not so marked?

Comment on this

It must be filled up to the mark.

Comment on this

And it is an offence to sell beer or stout in a bottle not so marked, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce hereafter will prescribe the capacities of the bottles and that we are simply using different machinery to produce virtually the same results? Deputy Ryan may not agree with me and he may be more discerning than I am but that is the impression I got of what is in the Minister's proposal.

Deputy Ryan does raise an important point. I think it should be made an offence to manufacture or sell bottles that do not conform to the specification of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I do not think it is fair to throw the whole burden on the publican. He takes bottles from the only source from which he can get them in this country, the Irish Glass Bottle Company, and I think the Irish Glass Bottle Company should have a responsibility to see that the bottle itself conforms to the Minister's requirement. Is not that reasonable?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy not agree that it is extremely unlikely that anything would ever arise in this way? In the first place we have many interests coming into this, large firms, large bottlers and large brewers and so on. The Deputy will appreciate that they will be very concerned lest anything should be wrong in their measuring. These marks on the bottles, I assume, will soon become familiar even in the lowly country public house. I cannot visualise any of the fears of the Deputy as being likely to be justified in practical form.

Comment on this

I think if the Irish Glass Bottle Company allowed bottles to leave their premises without being marked they would be committing an offence. A manufacturer of a bottle would commit an offence if he sold a half-pint stout bottle that did not bear the Weights and Measures mark?

Comment on this

I am not quite sure that is so.

Comment on this

I think it is.

Comment on this

I am aware—and the Deputy must also be aware—that it has been the practice for stout to be sold by publicans in different types of bottles such as sherry bottles. It is a regular practice to sell it to people to take off the premises—in a form that is known in the West of Ireland as "a large one". It is generally sold in bottles such as whiskey or sherry bottles.

Comment on this

But that is draught stout.

Comment on this

But it is illegal to sell bottled stout other than in one-pint, half-pint or one-third pint bottles. It must be sold in stamped bottles. I think we all agree on that, but the question that does occur to me is that every stout bottle must be stamped. You cannot sell stout under the existing law except in a stamped bottle. I always thought it would have been illegal under the existing law for a purveyor of bottles such as the Irish Glass Bottle Company to sell stout bottles unless and until those bottles had been stamped.

It is very different if you buy a set of weights or buy a set of pewter measures. You buy them at your own hazard and you must then submit them to the weights and measures officer who will stamp them if correct and, if not, he will destroy them or indicate they are not suitable for use. You have not that option with bottles; you cannot submit a gross of bottles to a weights and measures inspector at the local Garda Station and have him stamp them. They must be stamped at the point of manufacture. I always understood that if a manufacturer issued bottles unstamped he committed an offence.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy not agree that it is easier for a man who is purchasing a bottle of stout to hold it up, look at it and see if the liquid is up to the mark than to have on it a mark which is stamped invariably on the bottom of the bottle?

Comment on this

With great respect, the Minister is obviously no publican. Every stamped bottle has a mark on it at present up to which it has to be filled in order to conform to the existing mark. These are technicalities into which we do not want to draw the Minister in case we seem to seek to trip him. I am certainly agreed with the Minister—I know Deputy Ryan is not—that the provisos he proposes here are adequate to meet the problem that I pressed upon him. But I am uneasy about one feature of the new proposals, which appears to me to release the manufacturer of bottles from an obligation which heretofore bore upon him and to move the responsibility from the shoulders of the manufacturer on to those of the publican. If heretofore, a publican bought a gross of bottles and received them with the mark upon them, that was a good defence for him if he were prosecuted by the Weights and Measures Garda because a bottle of stout sold by him did not contain half a pint. He could produce the bottle and say: "That was filled to the point specified as the correct point to which it should be filled, and it is marked with the mark; therefore, I acted in good faith." If the bottle, in fact, was not of half-pint capacity, although it was so marked, responsibility then fell on the Weights and Measures administration. It was not the fault of the publican and he had no responsibility for it.

My apprehension is that, suppose under the new rule the Irish Glass Bottle Company were to sell bottles which owing to some mistake due to innocence on their part—the mould having shrunk, as Deputy Ryan suggests, or something of that kind— provided to be below the capacity stated, and they inadvertently continued to use the mould to manufacture 20 gross of bottles out of 5,000 gross, and these bottles are sent out, the responsibility does not rest on them in law; but the unfortunate publican, into whose hands the bottles have innocently come, may be prosecuted for selling less than a half pint of stout in the bottle.

I want to make a suggestion now to the Minister. I fully appreciate this is a matter of some little complexity. Deputy Ryan has a different point from mine, and a wider point, but, in respect of my narrow point as to where the liability should rest for selling a bottle which conforms nominally with the provisions of the two new amendments but which is, in fact, deficient, that, I suggest, is a matter into which the Minister might look between now and Report Stage, examine it and see if there is substance in it. I fully appreciate Deputy Ryan's solicitude, but I do not agree with it. I think adequate provision is being made under these proposed amendments by the Minister. However, Deputy Ryan has his own point of view on that.

Comment on this

The Minister will look into the matter.

Comment on this

I am much obliged.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 56a and 56b go together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56a:

Before Section 31 to insert the following new section:

"(1) Intoxicating liquor shall not be sold by retail in a sealed container unless the quantity of the contents of the container is indicated on the container.

(2) A person who contravenes or permits a person under his control or in his employment to contravene subsection (1) of this section shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall on summary conviction thereof be liable, in the case of a first offence, to a fine not exceeding ten pounds and, in the case of a second or any subsequent offence, to a fine not exceeding twenty pounds.

(3) Notwithstanding the provisions of section 8 (which prohibits certain sales of intoxicating liquor otherwise than in marked measures) of the Licensing Act, 1872, a person who sells intoxicating liquor in a sealed container on which the quantity of the contents of the container is indicated shall be deemed not to act in contravention of that section.

(4) In this section ‘container' does not include a bottle."

As has been pointed out, this amendment and amendment No. 56b go together. Section 8 of the Licensing Act, 1872, provided that intoxicating liquor when sold by retail in quantities of half a pint, or more, should be sold either in cask or in bottle, or in legal measures, and therefore makes illegal the sale of canned stout or beer. Deputies will probably have noticed that in recent years cans of stout and beer have come on the market in increasing quantities. In fact, no prosecution for the sale of these cans of beer has been brought under Section 8 of the 1872 Act, which, needless to say, was not intended to apply to canned stout. The introduction of this Bill, however, provided an opportunity to regularise the position.

Section 8 of the 1872 Act is, therefore, scheduled for repeal. Recently, it has been suggested to me that since the customer has no way of knowing how much stout or beer a can contains before he opens it, unless the quantity is stated on the label, a statement of the quantity should, for the protection of the consumer, be made a statutory requirement. That seems to be a reasonable suggestion and one which should be adopted. Hence this amendment which, taken with amendment No. 56b, allows Section 8 to stand and permits the sale of canned beer only where the quantity of the contents is stated on the can.

I understand at present most—possibly all—types of canned stout and beer sold in this country have, in fact, a statement of the contents on the label and the primary purpose of the amendment is, therefore, to guard against future omissions rather than to remove an existing abuse. The amendment does not refer explicitly to cans but to sealed containers of any type. The reason for this is that it may be possible in the future to market beer in plastic containers of some kind. Already I understand certain cordials may be bought in plastic containers. The amendments contain no provision making it an offence to have on the label a false statement of the contents. I am advised that such provision is unnecessary and that any such false representation would be an offence under the Merchandise Marks Act.

Comment on this

What is this section about?

Comment on this

The section is self-explanatory. It explains the position.

A local authority may, if they think fit, and with the consent of the holder, cancel a certificate issued by them under Section 6, the section which provides for the issue by local authorities of certificates approving of the sites for licensed premises in substitution for licensed premises demolished by them under the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1953, and may issue under the section another certificate declaring that a plot acquired by them, other than the site in the cancelled certificate, to be approved by them is approved by them as a licensed premises in substitution for the licensed premises which the cancelled certificate declared had been or were to be demolished.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56b:

To delete:

35 & 36 Vic., c. 94. | Licensing Act, 1872. | Section 8.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 57:

To delete the matter in the third column opposite "Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1927", and to substitute "Sections 11, 15 and 16; in section 27, the words from ‘and on the hearing of such appeal' to the end of the section; sections 36 to 54; subsection (2) of section 55; section 57.".

What the amendment does it is to repeal some provisions of the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1927, over and above those listed for repeal in the Schedule as it stands. These additional repeals are: (a) Section 11 of the 1927 Act, which is the section which allows a six-day licensee to get a seven-day licence, if he extinguishes a seven-day licence in the same or an adjoining District Court district—this section is superseded by the new section inserted by amendment 52—and, (b) part of Section 27 of the 1927 Act, which deals with the removal of endorsements by the Circuit Court on appeal. That power must, of course, go as a consequence of amendment 55 which makes endorsement compulsory. Deputy O'Donnell's amendment was taken with amendments 13 to 15, relating to Sunday evening opening, and the Chair is unlikely to allow any further discussion on that, I understand.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We shall not reopen the discussion.

Comment on this

My amendment to the Minister's amendment reads:

To delete "and 16" in the second line.

The amendment is designed to retain the powers of a district justice to grant an area exemption order on a Sunday. My reason for moving this amendment is that in rural Ireland, there are certain districts——

Comment on this

I do not like to interrupt the Deputy, but surely we discussed this matter already?

Comment on this

With great respect, Sir, what we discussed was the opening of licensed premises on a Sunday. This is exceptional. This is not the opening of licensed premises on every Sunday in the year; this is the opening of licensed premises on certain Sundays.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

But it is a discussion on Sundays.

Comment on this

On certain Sundays. There is a distinction.

Comment on this

With the greatest respect, Sir, we were dealing with the hours of opening on Sunday.

Comment on this

It was specifically taken with these other amendments.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

"Nos. 13, 14 and 15 and amendment to amendment No. 57 are being discussed together."

Comment on this

The Minister has now moved an amendment himself to include in the Schedule the previous section of the 1927 Act which permitted district justices to grant area exemption orders. I am either speaking against it or moving my own amendment.

Comment on this

The Deputy can speak against the Minister's amendment. Of that there can be no doubt.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It was made perfectly clear that all this was being discussed on amendments 13, 14 and 15.

Comment on this

There was no reference to amendment 57 in that agreement. It is quite manifest that Deputy O'Donnell is entitled to speak against the Minister's amendment. For peace sake, let him speak. If we have a procedural wrangle, it will take much longer.

Comment on this

I do not want to have a wrangle about it or prevent the Deputy from speaking, but I want to say it was discussed fully by me and others on the discussion of these other amendments.

Comment on this

That may be, but amendment 57 was not named.

Comment on this

If the Minister is entitled to speak in support of amendment 57, surely Deputy O'Donnell is entitled to speak against it?

Comment on this

Long before we settle that procedural wrangle we will dispose of the matter.

Comment on this

There are certain parts of rural Ireland where there are functions on a Sunday. I am thinking of Deputy Killilea's area and my own area, where you may have a feis, a pattern, an athletic meeting or a football match.

Comment on this

Or a political meeting.

Comment on this

You never require an exemption order for that.

Comment on this

They are quite satisfied with the new extension.

Comment on this

I want to point out to the House that there is a hiatus in the proposed hours. Licensed premises will be closed between 2.30 p.m. and 5 p.m. and again will be closed on Sunday night at 9 o'clock. In certain places—I am thinking particularly of the seaside resorts of Bundoran, Salthill and Enniscrone— where District Justices in their wisdom granted facilities to visitors to have liquid refreshment of intoxicating liquor and otherwise in licensed premises for a certain limited number of hours, sometimes those hours were staggered. I think it was a very good system.

Comment on this

They are always staggered.

Comment on this

I know areas where there is no hotel accommodation whatever and where visitors to such places have to depend entirely on admission to licensed premises to obtain refreshments. It would be a pity if, say, the day turned wet and there was inclement weather—I know Dublin Deputies can laugh at this. It shows how little they know about rural Ireland. It shows how little they know about the pattern of life in the country. It shows how little they know about the hospitality expected from publicans and extended by them to their patrons.

Comment on this

Where does the Deputy think we go for our holidays?

Comment on this

I was going to suggest the Isle of Man. The Deputy is the type who would go there. They have forestalled us. Now you can have a drink there on Sunday up to 10 o'clock. That is what I am asking the House to do, to let us do what they are doing in the Isle of Man which has the most conservative Parliament in Europe. On Saturday, for the first time, they threw open their public houses to visitors during the tourist season until 10 p.m. I make an appeal to the Minister. All I am asking him to do is to leave it to the discretion of the district justices. Remember that unless an individual publican makes the application and pays £5 stamp duty, the application must be made by a superintendent of the Garda. He must satisfy the justice that there will be such an influx of visitors into the locality as to make these facilities necessary.

In my own native county, and I am sure in county Monaghan, county Cavan and other Border counties, we have a big influx of visitors from the Six Counties on a Sunday. I am thinking particularly of the town of Raphoe, which is quite adjacent to the Border. A number of visitors come over there from the Six Counties after lunch on Sunday, have some light refreshments and go back again. Now you are asking them to remain over until the public houses open. They have reasons of their own for coming across that we do not know about down here. They have meetings and functions for which they come over, and they are very welcome at all times.

I should be disappointed if these people could not obtain the refreshments they have been accustomed to for the past five or six years. Remember that we had great difficulty satisfying the superintendents of the Garda Síochána and the district justices that a bona fide catering trade was done in public houses in these border towns and small seaside resorts where there was no hotel accommodation, and we did eventually succeed in establishing to the satisfaction of the courts that exemptions should be given and that area exemption orders should be granted on certain occasions.

In their wisdom, the legislators of the 1927 Act defined the hours. I think three hours was the maximum number which could be granted under that Act, and that would just meet with our present licensing laws, if during the summer months, or on the occasions of football matches in winter time, the district justices were permitted to grant area exemption orders for three hours, between 3 and 5 p.m. and again between 9 and 10 p.m. By doing that, we would be catering for a class of people who would normally expect this and who have enjoyed these amenities in the past. I would oppose the Minister's amendment on that account and, if I am in order, I move my amendment to the Minister's amendment.

Comment on this

Arising out of this discussion, and I pass no judgment on the merits of the case when put by Deputy O'Donnell, does the small voice of conscience not suggest to many Deputies here, in the light of all we have heard, culminating in the representations made by Deputy O'Donnell, that we are talking of establishing new closing hours which are to be rigorously enforced? Does any Deputy believe that the new hours will be one bit more rigorously enforced, 18 months hence, than the hours we used to have?

Comment on this

They will.

Comment on this

I doubt it and I am going to suggest to the Minister that some day, sooner or later, we shall be forced back to the whole question of considering whether we ought to have closing hours at all, or whether we ought to have a period during which we have no closing hours, and let the social practice of our people settle this matter for itself. Then, if regulation should prove to be necessary, and I very much doubt that, public opinion would manifest itself in a very clear and incisive way which would evoke from this legislature legislation of a kind which would really command that quality of assent from the public which would effectively reinforce the arm of law enforcement.

I am sorry to say, though not really sorry, listening to the debate on the various sections of this Bill, that I am being slowly forced to the conclusion that we are not going to get effective enforcement of any closing hours. I am not at all sure that we are doing the right thing in making the attempt because we are all committing ourselves to the proposition that the Minister for Justice for the time being is assured of the unanimous support of Oireachtas Éireann in his attempt to enforce the laws. I have grave misgivings that we are assigning to the Garda Síochána an impossible task. I very much doubt the wisdom of it and, the longer I have listened to the debate proceeding on this legislation, the more the conviction grows in my mind that closing hours, as defined by law, are a mistake and the best service we could do our community would be to suspend them all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is Deputy O'Donnell pressing his amendment?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I notice certain influential Deputies shaking their heads in assent. I admire their discreet silence. I did not hear anybody saying that they agreed with me.

Comment on this

I do not want to leave the Deputy alone with that. Everything I have already expressed to-day stands up to 12 o'clock.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:

In the third column, to delete "Part I." opposite "Weights and Measures Act, 1928" and substitute "Sections 4 to 9.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 59:

After "no. 3 of 1928" to insert:

“No. 7 of 1943. | Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1943. | Subsection (1) of Section 31.”

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Next stage?

Comment on this

April 27th.

Comment on this

May I make a suggestion to the Minister? The White Paper provided with the Bill was clear, lucid and most helpful to Deputies in understanding the Bill. We have had a very long discussion on this and have made a good many amendments to the Bill. When the Minister is circulating the print of the Bill, as amended in Committee, I think he should amend the White Paper and circulate it also. It would be of great assistance when considering the Bill again on Report Stage.

Comment on this

That is an excellent suggestion.

Comment on this