Dairy Produce Marketing Bill, 1960—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–232 of 696. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 45 of 1960 ›
I move amendment No. 1:
In pages 6 and 7, to delete paragraphs (c), (d) and (e) of subsection (2) and insert the following paragraphs:
"(c) one person being—
(i) a person who is nominated to be a member of the Board by the licensed manufacturers of cheese and as respects whose nomination notification in writing is delivered to the Minister (together with a statement in writing signed by the person signifying his consent to the nomination) before the nomination day in the nomination is year in which the nomination is made, or
(ii) if in any nomination year the licensed manufacturers of cheese do not, before the nomination day in that year, nominate a person and deliver to the Minister the notification and statement in relation to the person referred to in subparagraph (i) of this paragraph, a person nominated by the Minister whom the Minister considers to be representative of those manufacturers,
(d) one person being—
(i) a person who is nominated to be a member of the Board by the licensed manufacturers of milk powder and as respects whose nomination notification in writing is delivered to the Minister (together with a statement in writing signed by the person signifying his consent to the nomination) before the nomination day in the nomination year in which the nomination is made, or
(ii) if in any nomination year the licensed manufacturers of milk powder do not, before the nomination day in that year, nominate a person and deliver to the Minister the notification and statement in relation to the person referred to in sub paragraph (i) of this paragraph, a person nominated by the Minister whom the Minister considers to be representative of those manufacturers,
(e) one person being—
(i) a person who is nominated to be a member of the Board by the licensed manufacturers of chocolated crumb and as respects whose nomination notification in writing is delivered to the Minister (together with a statement in writing signed by the person signifying his consent to the nomination) before the nomination day in the nomination year in which the nomination is made, or
(ii) if in any nomination year the licensed manufacturers of chocolate crumb do not, before the nomination day in that year, nominate a person and deliver to the Minister the notification and statement in relation to the person referred to in sub-paragraph (i) of this paragraph, a person nominated by the Minister whom the Minister considers to be representative of those manufacturers,”.
Comment on this
That the nomination shall be by all licensed manufacturers, not by one or two of them. I understand that was omitted from the original.
Comment on this
The explanation tendered by the Minister does not seem to me to be adequate. He is eliminating (c), (d) and (e) and substituting another system of choosing?
Comment on this
If it is the same system, does the Minister now say if all the licensed persons engaged in the manufacture of cheese do not nominate somebody, that he then has the right to nominate a person on their behalf?
Comment on this
Suppose six licensed cheese manufacturers put up nominations and a seventh licensed manufacturer does not put up a nomination, does that mean the Minister says: "Well, you have not all duly nominated somebody; therefore, I shall make the nomination myself"? Or is the position that if any licensed cheese manufacturer makes a nomination, and there is no other nomination, that person will be the representative of the cheese manufacturers?
Comment on this
Does the Minister realise what that means? Let us say there are ten licensed cheese manufacturers. The tenth manufacturer himself wishes to be nominated. He seeks the consent of the other nine. He cannot get it because they want somebody else. He goes to the Minister and says: "The other nine fellows will not nominate me. Will you nominate me if I succeed in frustrating the other nine by refusing to join in nominating their candidate?" The Minister says "Yes, I will." All that tenth manufacturer has to do is to say to the other line: "Whoever you nominate, I shall not agree to him." Therefore, when the due date passes, the right to nominate falls to the Minister and the Minister himself can nominate No. 10 although the other nine manufacturers want to nominate someone else.
Comment on this
While there is something in the argument the Deputy has advanced, it is desirable to bring home to the organisations concerned that they must have some kind of arrangement between themselves for exchanging representation. If there were three or four interests involved and they were obliged to nominate one person, they could say: "We have agreed among ourselves that one concern will represent the various manufacturers on the Board." The next time a vacancy occurred, another concern would have the representation. I think it is better to force them into doing that than to have all the trouble and strife that would result from any other plan.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 7, to add to the section the following subsection:
"( ) In this section ‘the licensed manufacturers' means, when used in relation to cheese, milk powder or chocolate crumb, all persons carrying on the manufacture of cheese, milk powder or chocolate crumb, as the case may be, in premises acquired, established or maintained under and in accordance with licences granted under the Creamery Act, 1928, to those persons or their predecessors in title."
Comment on this
The whole point of election now seems to go by the board. I understood that you were going to group all the cheese manufacturers and that they could nominate one man. It now appears that unless they all agree on one man the Minister will make the appointment. If any group fails to agree unanimously on one man the Minister steps in and appoints.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister sees the abuses that could arise from that. If the Minister wants one particular man he can say to him not to agree to anyone and the Minister could then appoint that man himself.
Comment on this
It is better to make them aware that they must have an organised, disciplined approach to the matter.
Comment on this
Suppose the Minister says to a man: "I want you on this Board and I am not sure that we are going to appoint you. The best thing to do is to refuse to agree to anyone else and I will appoint you."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 8, line 26, before "the Company" to insert "University College Cork,".
This is an amendment to bring in the creamery attached to University College, Cork. It was accidentally left out. It could not be regarded as a cooperative creamery or under the Dairy Disposals Board.
Comment on this
You have a group consisting of the Condensed Milk Company and the Newmarket Dairy Company. Are these both branches of the Dairy Disposals Company?
Comment on this
University College, Cork, would then have to give its vote and as it is a University, it would not be fair to ask them to do that.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain under this section how the producers would be represented?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
Before Section 11 to insert the following section:
(1) A person who, in any nomination year, has signed a statement in writing signifying his consent to nomination as a member of the Board by any one of the groups of manufacturers specified in Section 8 of this Act shall not, in that nomination year, sign a statement in writing—
(a) signifying his consent to nomination as a member of the Board by any other of the groups of manufacturers specified in the said Section 8, or
(b) signifying his consent to proposal for nomination as a member of the Board under Section 9 or 10 of this Act.
(2) A person who, in any nomination year, has signed a statement in writing signifying his consent to proposal under any provision of Section 9 of this Act by any of the societies specified in that provision for nomination as a member of the Board shall not, in that nomination year, sign a statement in writing—
(a) signifying his consent to proposal under any other provision of, or by any other of the societies specified in, the said Section 9 for nomination as a member of the Board.
(b) signifying his consent to nomination as a member of the Board by any of the groups of manufacturers specified in Section 8 of this Act, or
(c) signifying his consent to proposal for nomination as a member of the Board under Section 10 of this Act.
(3) A person who, in any nomination year, has signed a statement in writing signifying his consent to proposal by any of the persons specified in Section 10 of this Act for nomination as a member of the Board shall not, in that nomination year, sign a statement in writing—
(a) signifying his consent to proposal by any other of the persons specified in the said Section 10 for nomination as a member of the Board.
(b) signifying his consent to nomination as a member of the Board by any of the groups of manufacturers specified in Section 8 of this Act, or
(c) signifying his consent to proposal for nomination as a member of the Board under Section 9 of this Act.
(4) Where a person signs a statement in contravention of any of the foregoing provisions of this section, the nomination or proposal to which it relates shall be null and void.
This is a drafting amendment to ensure that no person shall consent to nomination as a member of the board by more than one of the groups who comprise the electors or by persons entitled to nominate or propose persons under Sections 8, 9 and 10.
Comment on this
This seems to me to be an entirely new section and it can hardly be called a drafting amendment. It comprises a full page on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
It is largely covered by nothing. It is a new section and a new amendment to the Bill. It is not good enough for the Minister to come in and say that it is a drafting amendment when it is not. It is a new provision entirely and the House is entitled to know what it is about. Is it designed to prevent a person getting himself nominated by two different bodies?
Comment on this
I had to say it for you and I should not have to say it. This is not provided for anywhere else in the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 10, line 2, to delete "the Dairy Disposal Company, Limited," and to insert "University College, Cork, the Company, the Condensed Milk Company of Ireland (1928), Limited, the Newmarket Dairy Company (1932), Limited,".
This follows upon the bringing in of University College, Cork.
Comment on this
Does it do more than that? Does the Newmarket and the Condensed Milk Company cover all the creameries operated by the Dairy Disposal Company?
Comment on this
You are moving to delete the Dairy Disposals Company and to insert University College, Cork, the Condensed Milk Company and the Newmarket Dairy Company.
Comment on this
This does not seem clear to me. The Dairy Disposals Company controls the majority of the other companies over the south and west of Ireland and their suppliers were all brought in by "the cost of, and the expenses in relation to, a ballot."
Comment on this
I asked the same question as the Deputy and I was told that "the Company" covers the Dairy Disposal Company. The Newmarket Dairy Company and the Condensed Milk Company are owned by the Dairy Disposal Company.
Comment on this
The three companies, the Dairy Disposal Company, the Newmarket Dairy Company and the Condensed Milk Company—all three of them have creameries registered in their names.
Comment on this
On this amendment you are deleting from sub-section (4) of Section 11 the "Dairy Disposal Company" and you are substituting for it "University College Cork".
Comment on this
Ah, now you are explanning it and really this subsection is for the purpose of adding to the Dairy Disposal Company, University College, Cork, the Condensed Milk Company and the Newmarket Dairy Company?
Comment on this
Can the Minister indicate, is it intended that the members of the board are to be remunerated?
Comment on this
It seems to me that the Minister has brought in this measure to the House and has nominated a board without any idea as to what the remuneration of the members of the board will be. This vague way of putting it in the Bill does not give sufficient information. There is a definite obligation on the Minister to tell us in £.s.d. what will be the remuneration of the members. I cannot see what new information the Minister is likely to get that would vary any decision he would make now.
Comment on this
The section deals with the term of office of the members of the board and remuneration does not arise.
Comment on this
We want to let this Bill through but really I do suggest that no Minister ought to come before the Dáil with a Bill of this kind and brush aside reasonable enquiries for information. When you have considered legislation of this kind and determined the constitution of a board and the number of members it is to have and the conditions under which the chairman is appointed, somebody, sometime, must have said; "What is the basis of remuneration to be for these people?"
Comment on this
That would arise on Section 18—the remuneration and expenses of members of the board. We are now on Section 14.
Comment on this
The Minister is reserving the function of filling casual vacancies that may arise on the board. Those casual vacancies will be filled in the very same way as the original position was filled and the probability is that these casual vacancies may be filled by henchmen, if I may use that term, of the Government Party. Whilst I agree that a Minister is a very responsible person and is entitled to have rather elaborate functions, our experience has been that, in the filling of vacancies by Ministers of State, the political qualifications of the applicants are the main ones concerned, and while I agree that the political qualifications of a person should not preclude him from the right to become a member of the board, at the same time, other qualifications should be taken into account as well.
I do not like the idea of the Minister holding this particular function of filling casual vacancies on his own with-our reference to any method of selection or recommendation from any group of bodies.
Comment on this
The question of remuneration arises now and we should like a statement from the Minister as to why he is unable to give us any idea as to the proposed rate of remuneration of the personnel of the board. I think the House should be so informed at this time, on Committee Stage.
Comment on this
In my time in this place, when a measure of this nature was being discussed for the purpose of setting up a board, I do not believe the question has even been asked and I would regard it as entirely unreasonable to start off by announcing the remuneration before even the matter has been considered, before the Bill was drafted, or before it passes through this House. The only thing I can say in this regard is that the Minister for Agriculture, in consultation with the Minister for Finance, will have regard to the recommendations of the advisory body.
Comment on this
I think nothing of the kind. It is set up as an advisory body representative of the interests vitally concerned, but everything they advise need not be accepted. However, in a matter of this kind, when they say the members of the Board should be remunerated on a basis which will enable them to give sufficient time to their work, that is a consideration which is capable of a fair interpretation and there is no reason why it has to be interpreted before the Bill is passed.
Comment on this
Section 27 provides:
The Board may perform any functions imposed on the Board by this Act through or by any member of the Board or any officer or servant of the Board authorised by the Board in that behalf.
I should like the Minister to explain that very wide section.
Comment on this
These people must be given liberty to carry out a wide range of functions. There is no danger in it anyhow.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 16, line 20, to substitute "section" for "Act".
This is a drafting amendment. The provision refers to moneys advanced under Section 30.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 16, lines 47 and 50, to substitute "subsection (2)" for "subsection (1)" in both places where at occurs.
This is a minor drafting amendment. Subsection (2) and not subsection (1) provides for the specification by the Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, of purposes and conditions in relation to a grant.
Comment on this
Subsection (4) of this section provides:
A grant under this section shall not be used to defray more than two-thirds of—
(a) any loss incurred by the Board in relation to the export of milk products by the Board, or
(b) any subsidy, grant, or other like payment made by the Board in relation to the export of milk products,
and a purpose or condition which is inconsistent with the provisions of this subsection shall not be specified under subsection (2) or (3) of this section.
This is the section which declares that the maximum contribution the Exchequer could make to the export subsidy is two-thirds of its cost and this is the section which provides that as our exports of dairy produce expand—I am glad to see that Deputy Clohessy is listening closely—the levy on creamery milk will grow. Deputy Donegan says he thinks that is a most equitable arrangement and that no reasonable dairy farmer will object to it. They will all cheerfully pay up and like it.
I do not think it is an equitable arrangement. I do not think it is reasonable to say that the dairy farmers should carry the whole burden of the cost of expanding the exports which the country urgently requires to balance its external trade. It is notorious to anybody who knows his business that the international market in dairy produce is honeycombed with subsidies and State assistance of every sort and kind. I admit that in respect of the subsidies provided by Denmark and Holland it is extremely difficult to detect the method by which they are supplied but it is well known to anyone who is dealing with international markets in dairy produce that extensive subsidies are provided and their dimensions are virtually unascertainable except by experts of the Government administration in those countries. It is true that they present an exterior of being without subsidy of any kind and I am sorry to say that it has become the practice frequently to uphold these pretensions to our people as a justification for suggesting that the farmers are a kind of burden on the community here.
This section now adopts the principle that in the future the more dairy produce the dairy farmers produce the more they will have to pay by way of levy in order to meet the cost of getting into the extra markets which they are now being urged to cater for. Deputy Donegan says he thinks that is fair and just and right. I do not think it is. Deputy Clohessy sits in silence. Deputy Moher has entered the symposium and Deputy Ó Briain is smiling benevolently on this trinity of wisdom.
Comment on this
It will not be a shilling a gallon anyway.
Comment on this
Nor would anybody else make any such proposal. That is now a venerable Fianna Fáil falsehood which has long green whiskers on it. Nobody believes it but the poor dupes in the Fianna Fáil Party but it is a good defence for Fianna Fáil to use when they are ashamed of what they themselves are doing in 1960 and 1961. Whenever I hear the Minister for Agriculture becoming sufficiently coherent as to mention this venerable Fianna Fáil falsehood, I always know he is in a pretty tight corner. And when it spreads back to Deputy Ó Briain I know the panic is beginning to spread in the ranks.
Comment on this
Carefully preserved and every one of which I was careful to take a copy out of, for I would not trust the Minister for Agriculture as far as I would throw him. This is the section designed to increase the levy on creamery milk. And that is what we are told about it now and I can sympathise with the Minister and his colleagues who want to talk about anything else on earth but Section 31. I was delighted when the Deputy from Cork got up this morning to make his valiant intervention but I could not help feeling he had all the exterior appearance of a Christian martyr marching out and submitting to be tied to the stake. As he braced his shoulders he looked down upon Deputy Moher and said to himself: "I spoke and you did not."
It struck me very forcibly that Deputy Donegan was raising the cry of martyrdom and saying to himself: "How can man die better than facing fearful odds?" I praise him for his values. I am hoping to hear Deputy Clohessy get to his feet and brace his shoulders. We do not often hear from him, more is the pity. I should like him to get up and say he was marching, with head erect, towards a 2d., a 3d., or even a 4d., a gallon levy on milk.
Comment on this
I hope it will not. I guaranteed that it would never come lower. Mind you, then the bob was worth more than 1/6d. Now. We were casually asked from these benches what 1/- was worth before Fianna Fáil got cracking. A shilling in 1949 money is worth about 1/6d. today. That was guaranteed as a minimum with freedom to get the best price the dairy farmers could. They were the days when butter was selling on the British market for 470 shillings a cwt.
The Fianna Fáil innocents will believe anything they swallow. I believe Deputies Donegan and Clohessy believe all those stories. I do not believe Deputy Moher believes them; he is far too shrewd a practitioner. But it was he who told Deputies Donegan and Clohessy that story. It was like the 84/- a barrel for wheat. Deputy Moher told them that too. That was what got him elected in East Cork. Then he wept on Deputy Corry's shoulders saying he was completely misled. He is now misleading Deputies Donegan and Clohessy. But bear in mind we are arguing about the events in 1949. Some other time we can continue that argument. I am talking about 1960 and 1961 now. If this Bill provided a maximum levy there would be something to be said for it. But obviously it does not do that. Section 31 provides a maximum for the contributions which the Minister may make but it puts no ceiling whatever on the levy.
Comment on this
It is only the mind of the Minister for Agriculture that could think of a ceiling under the floor. That is the kind of mentality we are dealing with here. When I speak of a ceiling I am talking about something on top. The Minister thinks the farmers of this country are like files that can walk on the ceiling. There is a floor and the floor is that there should be no levy if there are no exports. There is no ceiling on the fact that if exports of butter expand the levy on milk will go up.
Comment on this
If you are getting your full market price in Britain you will not have a levy. I would suggest to Deputy Moher and to Deputy Clohessy and the Deputy from Cork that they think of that closely and get all the consolation they can from it.
Comment on this
So we have got to that stage now. All I am concerned with is what the dairy farmers will be called upon to pay and Section 31 is the instrument designed to extract from them a steadily growing levy on the price of milk. I would remind the Minister that An Bord Gráin was established by legislation of this House for the economic marketing of the grain crops in this country. The immediate consequence of that legislation was as levy of 4/6d. a barrel on the price of wheat which I had fixed and which the Fianna Fáil Party described as the cruellest imposition which was ever placed down on the suffering heads of the tillage farmers of Ireland.
Fianna Fáil hearts bled all over Ireland about the cruelly inadequate price I fixed for millable wheat. The setting up of An Bord Gráin meant that there was an immediate price reduction on wheat of 4/6d. per barrel. Now the Minister is about to establish An Bord Bainne and Section 31 of the Bill, designed to do that, is also the section designed to do for milk what An Bord Gráil did for wheat last year and the year before.
I am delighted that the valiant soul of Deputy Donegan rises to meet the challenge of these events. I admire his spirit of self sacrifice but I would remind him that his function here is not to play the role of Joan of Are going to the stake for the cause; his role here is to defend equity and justice for the agricultural community and I say it is not fair or just to require the agricultural community to carry all the increased costs and then to say they, alone in their circumstances, will be required to accept less and less for the labour that they do. Warm as is my personal regard for Deputy Donegan, I think he does himself less than justice in appearing to proclaim that he thinks that the farmers are the only section, of the community for whom that kind of treatment is good enough.
Comment on this
I should like to know, under this section, if there is no export of anything from the country in the line of milk or milk products, would there be any levy then collected to maintain this Board? This Board is going to cost a lot of money and is the money to provide for the running expenses of the Board to be met by the two-thirds which is being put up by the Minister or by the one-third which is being put up by the suppliers? There is bound to be a considerable amount of expense before any exports take place. The nine members of the Board will cost £9,000 and their buildings and equipment will cost more and I should not like to have the producers asked to meet the first burden in that respect by putting a levy on them to pay the overhead expenses of the Board.
I want to know from the Minister will this two-thirds balance that expenditure in the first instance? I join with Deputy Dillon in saying that it is not fair to impose the complete one-third levy. If the Minister could alter subsection 4 of Section 31, which reads "a grant under this section shall not be used to defray more than two-thirds ...", to read "a grant under this section shall not be used to defray less than two-thirds...", there might be some benefit in it. The Minister might then see his way to increase the contribution from the State. Under the subsection he cannot increase it. If the Minister could alter that subsection by substituting the word "less" instead of "more" it would be a safeguard for the farmers to ensure that they would not be maintain, perhaps too heavily, to maintain their exports.
I should like to see exports growing but we must try to instil that confidence lacking so much in dairy farmers so that they will increase production. When we get a market, there will be continuity of supplies to enable us to hold our grip on that market. I think the time has come when the Government should do a little more for the dairy farmer. When we send out our agents to look for markets abroad for industry we do not ask the industrialists to pay a levy. Industry is always highly protected. Only last week we sent out agents to foreign countries to seek export markets and our industrialists did not have to pay a levy. If the Minister provided that the Exchequer would not pay less than two-thirds I think the House would then accept.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
This section provides:
The Board shall provide itself with such offices, stores, warehouses, shops and other premises in and outside the State as it considers necessary.
Is it seriously suggested that this board should go into the retail trade in Ireland?
Comment on this
Display centres may be required. They may decide to have such centres, but it is not the intention that they should go into business in any sense at all.
Comment on this
I seriously question the prudence of including the word "shop". I can see the necessity for leasing offices, stores, warehouses, but certainly not shops. I should have been much easier in my mind if the list had been confined to offices, stores, warehouses and other premises other than shops.
Comment on this
I take it our purpose is to authorise the Board to acquire premises of the kind mentioned in this section outside the State? I do not exclude the possibility of engaging in the retail trade in export markets, but surely nobody wants them to engage in the retail trade in the home market?
Comment on this
These levies will enable the Board to meet its expenses, including the dairy industry's proportion of the deficit arising out of the export of milk products. There are also provisions in Sections 36 and 37 for levies on butter sales and stocks.
Comment on this
I can very easily understand the consequential provisos mentioned in Sections 36 and 37 if the principle contained in Section 35 is accepted. I want to draw the attention of the House to this important fact. We have been keeping continually under our control in Parliament the whole question of levying farmers' milk, and any Minister for Agriculture who proposed such a levy had put upon him the obligation of coming before Dáil Éireann and justifying it to the Dáil.
Earlier to-day, on the question of the status of the Milk Board after the passage of this Bill, the Minister for Agriculture, I understood facetiously, interjected that after the passage of this Bill he would answer the Parliament for none of the things done in pursuit of the powers conferred on the Milk Board by this Bill. I do not know whether the Minister meant that seriously or not. Perhaps he would say now did he mean that seriously?
Comment on this
Of course, if we enact legislation here giving powers to such a body, it will remain their responsibility to operate within the limits of the laws laid down by this House.
Comment on this
Now, observe what we are being asked to do. We are being asked now to confer on this body the power to levy anything they like on creamery milk, and nobody can raise the question in Dáil Éireann ever again. Does any Deputy in this House want to do that? Do we want to confer on a statutory body a power to levy any sum it likes on all the creamery milk delivered to any creamery in Ireland? If any Deputy raises it here, he can be told it is none of his business and, if he has any inquiries to make, to address them to the Milk Board, that the Minister is not responsible and will not answer him.
I think that is a crazy provision. Does Deputy Batt Donegan think it is proper for any Minister for Agricultural to say that he disowns hereafter all responsibility for the net price payable to farmers for milk delivered to creameries throughout the country?
Comment on this
He is. The Board is charged with the responsibility of selling the output. There are strict statutory provisions requiring the Board to meet its losses in a particular way and to meet its expenses in a particular way.
Comment on this
Yes. When the Board meets losses, for certain of those losses the Minister said that, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, he can contribute up to two-thirds of the amount, but that any other losses, over and above two-thirds of the export subsidy, must be met by the board and that the board is to recover those losses by means of a levy on creamery milk.
Comment on this
That is a different matter altogether. We could talk about this for months but I do not think it would do very much good. The basis upon which this Board will operate is clearly defined here. Any losses sustained by the Board will be met on the basis of not more than two to one. I shall have to come to the House to seek its approval for my share, which is not more than two-thirds of whatever is necessary. In view of the picture that would unfold of the activities of the Board and the amount of its surplus, surely there is no question of Deputies being unable to discuss these matters? We may talk about the West Cork Railway or whatever we like, but when we discuss here and pass legislation empowering a Board to do certain things, if Ministers and others in this House want to have their fingers in the pie, that board could not function profitable.
Comment on this
I am talking about the proposal to authorise this board to make a levy on creamery milk.
Comment on this
I am pointing out to the House that if the Minister's interjection was to be literally interpreted, the passage of this section would mean that hereafter no question could be asked in this House as to the propriety of the levy which the board propose to make on creamery milk. I want to remind the House of the fact that it is only 12 months ago since An Bord Gráin levied 4/6d. a barrel on wheat. The ground on which that levy was made was that there was an exportable surplus of millable wheat which the Board had to deal with. It transpired there was no exportable surplus. The matter was raised in this House and, after a good deal of wriggling and twisting, the Minister for Agriculture finally announced he was going to refund 4/6d. If nobody had raised it in this House it would never have been refunded. It was refunded and it was a very substantial sum of money.
Comment on this
If my memory serves me correctly that refund would not have been made only that the matter was raised in the House.
Comment on this
The case was made here that the levy should not be retained because there was no exportable surplus. It was resisted for a fortnight and then the Minister gave way. This year the levy was retained and is being used to help in the sale of unmillable wheat. Last year the 4/6d. was refunded because the matter was raised in this House.
Comment on this
Because at the time of fixing the levy, nobody knew whether or not we would have a surplus. Why bring up this matter now instead of on the many occasions when it could be discussed? Why not discuss what we are here to discuss at the moment, not that I have any objection?
Comment on this
It will be a far distant day when the Minister for Agriculture can tell me what I can discuss in this House and what I cannot discuss. The Minister, if he is to be believed, claims that if we pass this section we shall never have to discuss a levy in this House again. One could feel the rustles among the trinity behind him when he made that statement. I do not include Deputy Seán Flanagan as being one of the trinity. He is a Roscommon man like myself and we have not much to do with creameries, although we have one in Ballaghaderreen.
The Minister then went on to say that although he had already said that the levy could not be discussed he thought that when he came into the House with a Supplementary Estimate to pay his two-thirds these matters could be raised. I want to say that we should not, by passing Section 35, accept for one moment the proposal that the action of the Board in making a levy is not subject to review by this House. We should assert most emphatically that if a Deputy representative of the farmers of this country believes that this levy has been made ultra vires the Bill that he should have the right to raise the matter here and query the Minister for Agriculture on what has been done.
I think it would be most deplorable that we should accept the principle that Ministers should have the right, by setting up boards, to exonerate themselves from their liability to answer Parliamentary questions. That is a tendency that is growing. One of the greatest bulwarks of liberty is the institution of the Parliamentary Question. We have all seen the ludicrous spectacle of a Minister for Transport and Power who is responsible for C.I.E. and the E.S.B. coming into this House day after day——
Comment on this
That is the way that the simple man is led agley although I would not describe Deputy Moher as a simple man. The Minister for Transport and Power, when he is questioned with regard to the activities of the E.S.B. or C.I.E., makes the answer that he has no function in the matter. The Minister for Agriculture now seeks to set up an Board Bainne to exonerate himself from answering for the things for which he has traditionally answered down through the years. I think the House ought to carefully watch Section 35 in order that we may retain our right to keep these matters under review and to require the Minister for Agriculture to answer for them to Dáil Éireann. We ought to assert that Dáil Éireann does not delegate that right to any Board or anybody else but insists on its right to have the Minister for Agriculture of the day answer to Dáil Éireann for any tax or levy that may be put on the creameries of this country.
Comment on this
This section confers too much power on the Board, It states that the Board may, whenever it thinks fit, make an order fixing a rate of milk levy. That indicates clearly that that Board will have the sole responsibility for determining the amount of the levy and if any member of this House is dissatisfied with the matter there will be no use raising it here because the Minister will say that he had no hand in determining the levy which was put on by the Board to which this House gave the power.
An issue of such importance as this has been introduced at a most inopportune time when the House is just coming up to the recess. I think that should not be the case. I think that at this stage it would not be any harm at all if the Minister reconsidered the advisability of adjourning this matter until after the Christmas recess. In so far as Section 35 is concerned, I do not agree with giving the Board such wide powers and I must again protest at the bringing in of this measure just prior to the rising of the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon mentioned my name and I find myself in the unlikely position of being a metaphysical improbability—I am in the middle of what Deputy Dillon described as the trinity. May I say that, as a lawyer, I share the misgivings of other members of this House at the continuing process of the past thirty or forty years whereby Parliament divests itself of its functions in various ways. The practical outcome of a practice of this nature is that a member of Parliament is directed to a board rather than to a Minister.
I should like to remind the Minister for Agriculture of an occasion here when I asked the Minister for Transport and Power if he was prepared to stand over the attitude of one of these bodies in refusing to give me and other representatives of my constituency an interview unless and until we withdrew an application for a break down of the figures on which that particular Board had made its decision. The Minister told me that he did stand behind the decision of the board, and that he stood over the attitude of the board. I am afraid we have to face the fact that once we do give these powers to bodies, even if it is right to give them, we then find ourselves in the position that even though we are members of Parliament they can refuse, and do in fact refuse, to give us information which can only be described as reasonably requested.
There are two sides to this question. There is, indeed, the point well taken by the Minister that you either set up a board and give it functions or you do not set up a board and give it functions. But, the trend of legislation in this country over the past few years has in fact progressively denied to members of this House the opportunity, if not the right, of being furnished with information that they are entitled to as such. They are not in theory denied the opportunity because the Minister will say to you that you can write to the secretary of the board and that he is obliged to furnish you with the information. In point of fact they do not furnish you with the information, do not justify their decision if you ask them to justify it and, if you press the issue, they are inclined to tell you, with some show of authority, that the Legislature gave them these powers and that they propose to exercise them.
In Section 34, to which we have already agreed, which concerns the establishment of regional and advisory committees, there is something which very properly was left entirely within the discretion of the board but in the matter of a levy, while in theory the obligations of the board are clearly set forth and while the intentions of the Legislature and of the Minister are clearly set forth in the Bill and in this debate, the fact remains that, so long as this section is allowed to go through, a matter as vital as putting a levy on milk can be done, not merely without consultation with the Minister or this House but, in effect and in practice, without the possibility of reasonable inquiry even by Members of Parliament. Ultimately, if members of this House are not entitled to be furnished with information by this and similar boards one can readily imagine the ordinary member of the public will get very short shrift indeed.
Does the Minister think that if he put in the words "subject to the consent of the Minister" that would set up a sort of class warfare between his Department and the officers and members of the board being created by this Bill? Perhaps he does but even if there would be some unnecessary friction it would be preferable to continuing this process of vesting functions, more and more of them in successive boards, each time removing a little bit of the effectiveness and value of the members of this House. Ultimately, we are watch dogs for the rights of citizens. It is humiliating and infuriating to be told that you cannot get information anywhere because one person has no function and the other will not give it.
Comment on this
Deputy Seán Flanagan has expressed views that are held by a very large number of Deputies. Day after day, week after week we have all come up against the frustration of trying to extract from State bodies information that we are told is obtainable by communicating with them. We could give several examples where such bodies have denied audience to members of this Dáil unless they were prepared to conform to terms set out by the body. It has certainly gone well beyond the stage which could reasonably be regarded as sufficient to excite criticism and create disturbance.
On occasions when the House acceded to requests from Ministers to set up boards such as the one contemplated in this Bill certain verbal assurances were given by the Minister seeking the support of the House but we found in practice that the verbal assurance was very far from observed when it came to the actual effort to meet these bodies. It is because of these very disturbing experiences that we are so concerned by yet another development and the creation of still another board which may remove from this House more and more of the duties, obligations and responsibilities normally attaching to public representatives.
We consider that the imposition of this levy on the milk producer is unjust and unfair and is depriving this section of the community of a facility that is afforded to every other section. The Minister for Agriculture should be the watchdog of agricultural interests in the Government. If this were part and parcel of a general scheme to pass back to various sections of the community charges heretofore borne by the State, whereby, for example, the industrialists would be obliged to pay a levy to assist in the marketing of their products, it might be all very well but we find that industrialists are helped, and rightly so; we do not begrudge them any facilities that the State affords them in the marketing of their surplus goods. It is a good thing for the country that there should be an expansion of industrial and agricultural exports. But, we do not see any evidence of any contribution being levied upon the industrialists in the same way as the agriculturist is now being charged to the extent of one-third of the cost of subsidising exports.
If the Government persist in their action in this regard it will aggravate the fear that exists in too many minds to-day. It is a mistaken fear but, nevertheless, it exists and must be rooted out if we are to make progress. The fear is there to-day that if these people work harder and produce more and answer the call from all sides, in the long run they will suffer a reduction in their incomes. That is the principle on which we opposed the levy in relation to An Bord Gráin and that is why we oppose it in relation to An Bord Bainne. We see in it a removal of the firm guarantee of price which farmers had for some years and which had a dramatic effect in increasing production. As well as that, the Government are absolved from their obligations in this respect, obligations that were borne under most difficult conditions by their predecessors. There was never a question of shedding the responsibility that the Government had to bear in relation to the problem.
We are fearful of the Government's pursuing this policy of taking away responsibility from the members of the Oireachtas, transferring them to outside boards and making these so independent a that they are not answerable to anybody. The effect is to take away from the lawfully elected representatives of the people the forum they have always had here for extracting by Parliamentary Question information in the interest of the public.
Comment on this
Before the Deputy proceeds along that line, I should like to point out that the matter to which he is referring arises relevantly on Section 48.
Comment on this
The Deputy was but he was travelling along lines which I do not want him to develop until we reach the appropriate section.
Comment on this
Concluding my remarks on this section, I, like Deputy Wycherley, would like to know from the Minister what will be the situation if there is no surplus entailing a levy. If there is an economically marketable surplus the levy will still be exacted to maintain the running costs of the board. If that is so, it is something which has not been levied by any other Minister in relation to his Department.
Comment on this
Quite so, but that staff was performing duties other than the marketing of surpluses abroad.
Comment on this
They would be the very same duties. Supposing there are no surpluses. They then have the home market to cater for and the staff of the Milk Marketing Board will have to do the work that was formerly done by the Butter Marketing Committee.
Comment on this
There are two levies in one: one for cold storage and one for the cost of staff and that has been collected for years.
Comment on this
This is something for the administration of which the Minister was responsible to this House for many years. Now these duties are being transferred to this board plus some additional duties, so that Deputy Flanagan is quite right, that we are continuing this path of ridding the Government of as much responsibility as they can possibly jettison and put on the shoulders of others. It is for that reason we oppose this section which calls for the exaction of this levy on the basis that it was possible to meet the marketing of a surplus which in former years was done without the exaction of a levy on the producer.
Comment on this
Is the Minister seeking to deny that his predecessor subsidised in its entirety surplus butter and that there was no exaction of a levy on the producer?
Comment on this
You had no butter to subsidise. Give me one year in which it was done. We are not going to prove anything by making false or inaccurate Statements.
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, there was no surplus of butter since the war until the year 1956-57.
Comment on this
There may have been just a few cwts. and in the same year as any small amount went out we had to have imports.
Comment on this
Let us be clear on this. After all, the Minister has the assistance of his officers.
Comment on this
Surely if we were to discuss dairy produce marketing, the Minister was briefed before he came into the House in relation to the contents of the Bill and in relation to everything associated with it.
Comment on this
The Minister will have an opportunity of proving me wrong when I say the previous Government met the entire cost of subsidising surplus butter for export. There is no "about" in what I am saying. The Minister will have an opportunity of saying I am wrong, if I am wrong in that respect. It is for that reason I assert it is improper that we should accept a section that makes provision for the exaction of such a levy on the primary producer at this time.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan has put his finger upon the important point, that any levy that this board may make should be subject to the approval of the Minister.
Comment on this
I shall tell you what is subject to the House, the amount of money the Minister looks for.
Comment on this
I want to make this case which I believe to be correct. Hitherto, the Dairy Disposal Board was part of the Department of Agriculture and whatever levy, or failure to make a levy, there was, the Minister was responsible for it to this House and could be cross-examined by Parliamentary Question, by motion, on his Vote or in several other ways. When this board is set up and they strike a levy, even if it is more than they are entitled to do, we cannot take any action on it. It is true that the Minister has to come to get financial sanction and that he can be questioned in that way, but he can say that the amount of any levy struck by the board is not a matter for him.
Comment on this
I cannot say anything of the kind because the Order imposing the levy will be placed on the Table of both Houses of the Oireachtas and time will be given to the House to discuss that Order.
Comment on this
I want to emphasise that up to the present moment the Minister was responsible for the levies on the cold storage of butter. The day this Bill is passed and becomes law, this is the function of the board and it is part of the day-to-day operation of the board. We will be told that that is so and we cannot discuss the matter.
Comment on this
I would like to support the statement of the two previous speakers. In a nutshell, what it boils down to is that this board, as far as the levy on milk goes, has the function and the Minister is completely divesting himself of authority. It is only begging the question to say that they have to come to the House. Under Section 35, the board can, whenever they think fit, make an order fixing the milk levy or revoking the milk levy. The board will have, under this Act— and I have no doubt the Bill will be steamrolled through the House—the power to do what they want.
It is only begging the question to say that Section 62 covers this point. I have had experience of similar provisions to those contained in Section 62 under other legislation and there were many occasions when, in respect of actions taken by other boards, I could not even get a reply to a Parliamentary Question. I was told by the Minister that it was the day-to-day administration of the board and that the Minister had no function at all. what makes it so serious is that the milk industry is fundamental to the whole agricultural industry and the agricultural industry itself is fundamental to our entire economy.
It has been rightly stated here today that the duty of the Minister for Agriculture is to protect the agricultural community. I do not see there is any protection whatever for the agricultural community in introducing a Bill like this and the imposition of a levy as is provided for in this section. Perhaps some of the Government Deputies who may deign to speak on this section will argue that the Minister is conferring some kind of a favour on the agricultural community by imposing this levy.
What the Minister is doing is empowering the board to impose any levy they want on farmers. The Minister's argument is that the farming community have every protection and that he must come back to the House to get the money to finance the operation of this section. I see in it the old story where the levy is imposed first. In this case the money is to be taken off the farmers seven days after the last day of the month. At the same time, the Minister is trying to put across to us that the money must be voted here by the House. He forgets that this board can do what they like.
In other words, it is creating another monopolistic body. I think the Minister should find it easy to accept the view that the board should be under proper Parliamentary control. We spent most of yesterday debating another measure in which we were endeavouring to divest Parliamentary control. What is the point in having an Irish Parliament if it has no say? We are building up a political situation here where we have a series of boards who control everything. That is not the principle of a democratic State. I await with interest the Minister's views on this section. As far as I can read it, it is entirely in the hands of the board to do exactly what it likes about milk subsidies.
Comment on this
Whatever the merits or demerits of the levy that this board may find they will have to impose, I have never known a board more weighted in favour of the actual producers. If Deputies care to study the Bill they will find that the board is practically in the hands of the producers, apart from one representative from the Department of Agriculture, and I cannot see why, if there is difficulty about the price of milk, those people cannot settle it themselves without having it brought in here on a political issue.
I do not say that the board, as suggested in the Bill, is a really good one, but the issue of whether there will be or will not be a levy is another matter. I cannot see why this board, weighted as it is in favour of the producers, would be guilty of doing anything wrong about the price of milk. There is the provision under which the operations of the board must come before the House in certain circumstances and I do not see how any Deputy can be precluded from making observations in the House on the board.
Comment on this
Deputy Donegan is in a peculiar frame of mind today. How can he, representing a rural community, come in here and say that everything will be all right under this board? Is not that what we were told when previous boards were appointed—that the right personnel would be appointed to them? That is not how these boards have turned out. These boards that we set up here act in the most dictatorial fashion. Here we have a Fianna Fáil farmer from North Cork telling us that he is quite satisfied to hand over the important powers which this Bill confers on the Board without any worry whatever and says that when the nine appointees will be known they are bound to be men who will deal with the matter more effectively than it will be dealt with in this House.
Comment on this
The Minister is safeguarding his own interests because here and there through the Bill in the various sections are subsections which give him the right to ensure that there will be a number of Party nominees on the job. We have too much of that here and it has been stressed again and again by various speakers in discussing the advisability of setting up such boards at all. I think it is completely out of place, judging by our knowledge and experience of the dictatorial boards that have been set up in the past, to say that everything will be all right as Deputy Donegan suggests.
When we set up a board such as the Milk Board, the Grain Board, C.I.E. or the E.S.B. we give them certain functions and a complete monopoly in a certain field. In the case of C.I.E. we removed the competition from them and threw a mantle of protection around them, backed up by State and public funds. We do the same for the E.S.B. and we shall do the same with An Bord Bainne that is now visualised. Whatever activities they are responsible for, whether the members of this House approve or otherwise, they will not be open for discussion here.
I completely disagree with the statements of the previous speaker that the fixing of a levy on milk should be a matter reserved entirely to the board. Section 62 is the usual section embodied in such legislation and, as we know, it means nothing except when the Government of the day is anxious to change legislation. It is quite useless so far as Opposition members are concerned to invoke the aid of Section 62 of this Bill. That is only a cover-up. As Deputy Sir Anthony Esmonde said, that section appears in almost every Act. The whole matter that we are debating here on the eve of Christmas, as so many Deputies have said, is that we are handing over power for the past number of years to this board that board and the other board and I think, that they have been found wanting in their activities. We were told by the Taoiseach the other day that he has no power whatever over the C.I.E. Board at present and that what C.I.E. does, and how they do it, is a matter for themselves and that this Parliament, this House and he himself, as Leader of the Government, have no function whatever. We must be very wary about these boards and I propose to well at some length on the setting up of these boards in tonight's debate if I have an opportunity of contributing to it. This is a big question and I entirely disagree with Section 35 of the Bill.
Comment on this
I want to direct the attention of Deputy Donegan in particular to the complete delusion under which he is labouring. He believes that this board, being largely representative of producers, can confidently be relied upon to protect the interest of producers and to ensure that no unreasonable levy will be made upon the milk delivered by the producer to the creameries. I do not think Deputy Donegan has read the Bill because if he looks at Section 42—he has the Bill before him—he will see that:
(1) The Minister may from time to time give the Board a direction in writing requiring it—
(a) to make and carry out during such period or periods as may be specified in the direction a scheme for the payment to the registered proprietors of creameries of allowances towards the cost of the cold storage, by or on behalf of the proprietors, of butter, or
(b) to suspend, or provide for the cesser of, as from a date specified in the direction, in whole or in part, of a scheme under this subsection and payments thereunder.
Under subsection (2):
The Board shall comply with a direction under subsection (1) of this section.
Section 43 states:
The Board shall purchase at the price which stands fixed for the time being under subsection (2) of this Section and is appropriate in relation to the purchase of all butter which——and the butter is then described.
Subsection (2) of that Section says:
The Government may from time to time fix the price of butter for the purposes of subsection (1) of this section or may fix two or more prices varying in accordance with either or both of the following, that is to say, the quantity of butter sold and the method of packing the butter, and may specify a date or dates as on and from which purchases shall be made at the price or prices so fixed and the Minister shall notify the Board in writing of the price or prices so fixed and the date or dates also specified.
Now we come to Section 44 which reads:
Wherever the Board sells butter which—
(a) is intended for consumption in the State, and
(b) is of a kind which conforms with the provisions in relation to creamery butter of the Dairy Produce Acts, 1924 to 1947, and the regulations made thereunder or is important butter,
the sale shall be made at the price which stands fixed for the time being under subsection (2) of this section in relation to such sale and is appropriate in relation to the sale.
Subsection (2) says:
The Government may from time to time fix the price of butter for the purposes of subsection (1) of this section or may fix two or more prices varying in accordance with either or both of the following, that is to say, the quantity of butter sold and the method of packing the butter, and may specify a date or dates as on and from which the price or prices so fixed shall apply and the Minister shall notify the Board in writing of the price or prices so fixed and the date or dates so specified.
Section 45 transfers the funds of the Dairy Produce Fund to the company but if Deputy Donegan studies these sections he will discover that the board, in fact, has no discretion in regard to the amount of the levy it is required to make. But the Minister is in the glorious position that he claims today the right to say if anybody asks him why did the board levy 2d. or 3d. per gallon on milk his answer will be: "That is none of my business; go and ask the board." But in the section of the Bill he has the right to direct the board to do a series of things which involve them in the obligation to raise from a source other than the treasury the funds necessary to carry out the Minister's direction——