Dairy Produce Marketing Bill, 1960—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 233–461 of 696. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 45 of 1960 ›
These sections include a section in which the board is obliged to buy butter at certain prices and the butter will then be disposed of by the board. In regard to the domestic market the Minister will fix the prices at which the butter is to be disposed of in the domestic market but in respect of any butter over and above that the board must sell it wherever and however it can but it must raise sufficient to liquidate the losses after two-thirds of the losses have been made good. I do not think Deputy Donegan understands the Bill. What we are claiming now is, that in that section, where events which the board itself cannot foresee, can bring in a statutory obligation upon the board to impose a levy on milk, we in this House should be entitled to raise the query: "Why, or how, does the new board claim the right to levy 2d. or 3d. a gallon on creamery milk?"
We in this House should be entitled to raise the query why, and how it is, the Milk Board claim the right to levy 2d. or 3d. a gallon on creamery milk? The Minister says "No. Once you have passed this Bill no one in Dáil Éireann will have the right to ask that question. It will be a matter within the discretion of the board." I want to point out to Deputy Donegan it is not within the discretion of the board because the Minister takes power, by order addressed to the board, to fix the price at which it will but butter, and to fix the price at which it will sell butter on the home market and he leaves with the board the obligation of selling the rest of the butter, and all the other dairy produce which it may have had to purchase, for whatever price it can get, plus the residual obligation of making good any loss sustained by it in that operation after it has received from the Treasury two-thirds of whatever the total loss may be.
Now, that simply means that we are creating a board and we are telling the farmers that it is absolutely essential from the point of view of the national economy, and this is something with which I entirely agree, to expand production. I make the case that, if it is in the national interest to expand production and that creates a marketing problem, it is contrary to sanity to say to the people whom you are asking to expand production: "The more you expand the less you will get." I want to compare the procedure here envisaged vis-á-vis the creamery milk suppliers with the procedure we adopted in the 1956 Finance Act when we were dealing with industrial exporters, and I want to defend what we did.
I am always being challenged—even by my own supporters—with having no interest in anybody but the farmers. I should like to compare now what we did for the industrialists in exactly this situation. The industrialists said: "We have been exhorted to establish industries to furnish the home market, and we undertook to do that under high protection; but we admit that, paying the wages we do and with the equipment we have, with the limited market which the Irish home market represents, we have no competitors if you compare us with Northampton or New England and, therefore, it is impossible even to go out and secure permanent foreign markets; one of the heaviest charges we have to carry is corporation profits' tax and income tax."
Having heard all that, we made them this proposition: "We will take your industrial output as of a certain date and we are prepared to say to you, in respect of your entire export after that day, you will be free of all corporation profits' tax and you will be free of all income tax." When that scheme came to be administered it was manifest that one could not examine every pair of boots that was manufactured and apportion to one pair of boots the costs of the factory production. As I understand it, the rough and ready device was employed that the Revenue Commissioners said that, if, at the end of a year, a factory had made £10,000 profit and one-fifth of the output had gone abroad in exports and four-fifths had been sold at home, the industrialists would pay income tax on £8,000 of profits and, in respect of £2,000, they were tax free. What the result of that stimulus has been we have seen in the very steep increase in industrial exports. I know of one boot factory that was working one shift——
Comment on this
No. The trouble is that the boot manufacturers will have plenty of milk to drink but, if we are going the way we are going, the milk producers will have no boots to wear. I do not want to give the Deputy a sharp answer.
Comment on this
Is the Opposition right in saying that Sections 42, 43 and 44 affect the milk output?
Comment on this
Ah! I think the Minister is fervently hoping that the Deputies behind him will not be able to see it. He creates the whole price structure. Please do not distract me for a moment from my theme.
Comment on this
The Deputy should remember that I was doing this before he was born and I do not fall for these tricks. Since he is a neighbour, I do not want to smack Smart answers across the floor to the Deputy, but I appeal to the Deputy not to try me too far. All I am saying is that I do not deny that the concessions we made in the Finance Act of 1956 were of a generous scale. But they had this result: a boot factory which, to my knowledge, was working one eight-hour shift three years ago is now working three shifts and exporting nearly half of its entire output. It is doing that because its release from tax on all these exports has made it economic to break into foreign markets. What astonishes me is that, when we are dealing with the manufacture of boots, or textiles, or tin cans, or any industrial product, we all approve of the 1956 Finance Act approach. When this Government came into office they not alone adopted the scheme we had introduced but they even extended it.
What has gone wrong with the minds of our people that when we approach farmers we do not say to them: "If you double, or treble, your output substantial benefits will be conferred upon you as a result of your contribution to the balance of our international trade." Not at all. We say we want higher production in order to expand our exports but, remember, with regard to every increase you make there is automatic machinery here to ensure you will get less for your output. What is more, you will get less, and there will be silence; no voice must be raised about it in Dáil Éireann, ever, any more. I often wonder am I standing in an Irish Parliament at all. Or are we all going daft?
Comment on this
——nor persuaded to depart from the topic of the levy which we are now in process of imposing on the milk production of the dairy farmers of this country.
Comment on this
That is the purpose of this Bill, according to the Minister. From the moment this Bill passes through Dáil Éireann we are all to be stopped. That is the purpose. We are to talk no more about it. He said today that, once we have legislated for this levy, it will be nonsense to allow any Deputy further to discuss it in Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
The records will show. I could not say such a thing. I did say that if we legislate to give certain functions to a board it should not be the business of a Minister, or anybody else, to poke into the way in which that board transacts its business unless and until there is a discussion here, for instance, on the presentation of the financial accounts, or something like that. That is what I said.
Comment on this
This is like telling us that we can discuss C.I.E. after they have torn up the rails and shipped them to Czechoslovakia. There is no use discussing the West Cork Railway if the rails are in Czechoslovakia. There is no use my discussing in Dáil Éireann the levy imposed on milk in the months of March, April, May, June, July, August and September in November when the levy has been collected and spent. I want the right, when the levy is put on, to come into the House the following sitting day and ask the Minister for Agriculture why he has allowed a levy of 2d. or 3d. on creamery milk.
Comment on this
The Deputy can discuss it when the Order imposing the levy is made. That Order will be placed on the Table of the House and the Deputy, as he would say himself, can talk about it until the cows come home.
Comment on this
That is what the Minister tells us now. Earlier in the evening he told us that once we had conferred this power on the board, it would be absurd for us to claim the right of discussion here in Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
In so far as we have clarified that position and retained the power to control that matter, I think a useful purpose has been served. Perhaps the Minister would point out to us the provisions of the Bill which require the Order to be tabled?
Comment on this
Section 62 says:—
Every order and regulation made under this Act shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made and if a resolution annulling the order or regulation is passed by either such House within the next subsequent twenty-one days on which that House has sat after the order or regulation is laid before it, the order or regulation shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under the order or regulation.
Does that cover Orders made by the board?
Comment on this
It may. If the board makes a levy on milk, is it requisite for it to make an Order or a regulation?
Comment on this
I accept unhesitatingly the Minister's word that that relates to every Order made by the board. But remember, our experience has been in regard to the other statutory boards that the Orders and regulations made by them have not been susceptible to discussion in the House.
Comment on this
I am informed that where a provision like this is included in the Bill for the presentation of Orders made and where there is a time limit fixed, such Order can be annulled by Parliament. I do not see what more freedom of discussion you want than that.
Comment on this
If the Minister assures me that any instrument fixing a levy on milk is required to be laid on the Table of the House and is subject to annulment by resolution of this House within a given period——
Comment on this
Then the procedure here will not be analogous to that enjoyed by the other statutory boards?
Comment on this
Then the Minister will agree that he was mistaken when he said it would be absurd for us to discuss it?
Comment on this
I did not say that. I said that there would be no point in setting up a board if Ministers and others had the right to poke into anything defined by law as the business of the board from day to day. That is the statement I made.
Comment on this
On another occasion a Minister included a similar provision and assured the Dáil there would be prior consultation and that if an Order were made there would be a period of two months within which interested parties could make their observations. However, the board involved has refused to meet anybody.
Comment on this
I have heard that charge made here a few times. I would not be immediately concerned with undertakings given on these matters by other Ministers. However, having heard these charges flung across the floor of the House, I endeavoured in my intervention to make it clear that when you set up a board of this nature, set out clearly the powers and functions of that board, it is absurd for any of us to think we can be acquainted with all the day to day details and decisions made by them and based upon their judgment and responsibility.
Comment on this
In this matter we are not dealing with something like nuclear energy or something divorced from our ordinary pursuits. After having transferred certain powers to this board, the Minister has also retained certain powers. He has the authority to fix the prices in relation to the home market. Surely, what the Minister does in relation to the home market could have a very strong effect on the operations of the board relating to the market of the surplus?
Comment on this
Surely those are matters in regard to which I shall be answerable to Parliament at all times?
Comment on this
The effect of what the Minister does in that case should have consequential effects in the levy imposed on the producers.
Comment on this
Very well. If it is a consequential effect of a Ministerial action, then why cannot we discuss the levy on the floor of the House?
Comment on this
I am not discussing the making of an Order. I am discussing the powers still retained by the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture, with the concurrence of the Government, fixes from time to time the prices at which butter will be purchased by the Butter Marketing Committee and by this board. Having fixed that price, he determines generally the price at which milk will be purchased by creameries. The board has nothing to do with those functions. They are Ministerial functions. The board's task is to endeavour to market as profitably as possible any surplus of milk products that may exist.
Now the Government say to this Board that if its export losses this year amount to £900, £9,000 or £1,000,000 that we will give them two-thirds of any sum that may be necessary to dispose of these surplus milk products. As Deputy Donegan has said, the Board is composed of people who have a deep interest in the industry and I am, in this measure, giving effect to the report of the advisory committee which was composed of people who were interested in the industry and who knew that, if we are going to go out and encourage the production of milk and then dispose of our milk products, it would not be reasonable to think that the industry would not make some contribution towards the effort to improve its productivity and its profits.
What Committee would recommend that a board should be set up to improve an industry and that the State should bear all the cost of that improvement? Do you think we would be taken seriously in that or that it would be taken seriously by the consumers of milk products who are, in the main, the people who are supporting the milk producers.
I could talk about all the matters mentioned here, about the utility of boards and about the injustice of handing over of delegating functions to these boards. The only thing I said in this House, and I would say it to myself, is that I would regard myself as being very foolish if I took part in a deliberative assembly as to whether a board should or should not be set up and then, immediately that proposal had passed into law, that I should start to trick with them, interfere with them and ask for information which I should know in advance would not be available to me once I had taken the original course.
I do not like people who try to have it both ways. There are a lot of people in this country who want to have the hide and the price of it. What I do say to-day and what I have said outside is that any man is entitled to his view as to whether it is a good thing to delegate these responsibilities and to hand them over to a board. Any Deputy can have his own view as to the wisdom of such a course but I also say that when Parliament makes a decision by a majority vote of this House we cannot expect to have it the other way the following day. If Parliament, having given powers of this nature to a particular board, think that they are too extensive, Parliament can easily rectify that. That is the reasonable way to approach this matter.
It is childish to come in here and ask a Minister for Agriculture when he is going to give effect to the report of such an advisory committee and then, when he is giving effect to it, to say that we do not want the board to have that much power. If any member of this House, no matter who he is or how experienced he is, thinks he is going to put that sort of stuff over on the public or that he is going to affect the public mind in a political sense by saying these things he is making the mistake of his life.
I do not mind if we talk over the Bill for the next seven days but there is no justification for all the repetition that we have had here to-night. I have made my point on this matter. It was recommended to me by the advisory committee but if it was never recommended it would still be in this Bill because I think if is fair. I shall go out to the country as a politician and, with my colleagues, meet the people who are affected by these provisions. When my point of view and the other point of view have been stated we should not have this futile and endless repetition which gets us nowhere.
Comment on this
There is one good answer to that and that is that it took a lot of repetition to get the Minister to his feet—not that we are any wiser than we were before he got up. The Minister defends the principle he has introduced and, in addition, introduces a third point, that of the impact on the public mind. Let me ask the Minister in what other Department of State in connection with the marketing of goods outside this country are the producers required to pay anything by way of a levy?
There is in existence in relation to industrial exports a body known as Coras Tráchtála. Is there any industrialist in this country who has objected to the fact that Coras Tráchtála operates under State funds and that industrialists do not contribute directly to the expenses of Coras Tráchtála? How could anybody in the agricultural community feel that this board would have less authority if the State carried the entire cost as it carries it for Coras Tráchtála?
I would ask the Minister to tell me if there is in existence in the State a single example of such a contribution, being exacted from other producers in the case of such a board. If there is, the Minister will have succeeded in the arguments he has advanced. He appears to be the solitary member of the Government who is prepared to put a levy on the people for whose welfare he is responsible, to put on them the burden of bearing a substantial contribution of the expenses of the board.
As Deputy Dillon pointed out we have very effectively given financial assistance to industrial exporters. They are secured, no matter what they-produce, against any reduction in their profits. Here, we find the same thing happening as happened in the case of An Bord Gráin; the producer has been told that the matter will not arise unless he works harder and produces more goods. You are removing the guarantee to the people that they have had up to the present and the result of the appeal made to them to produce more will be that they will receive a reduction on their investment. That is a serious things to revive in the minds of these people. After the assistance they have been given, after the markets that have developed for them and having got production up to this point, if we remove any of the guarantees that were responsible for bringing about increased production we may be inviting more trouble.
It is for these reasons that we object. If the Minister stands on the principle of a contribution being fair, on the principle that he attempted to explain to us a few moments ago that the producers would appreciate being given this responsibility, why is it that industrialists who are being assisted so well and who are availing of the facilities provided for them in marketing their surplus, do not resent the fact that they are not called upon to pay any direct levy?
Comment on this
Does not an expanding industry carry the expense of its own expanding selling organisation?
Comment on this
No. We provide, and have provided down through the years, through the Department of External Affairs, facilities abroad for the securing of markets——
Comment on this
To sell more Guinness, yes. Why not? To sell also more boots or anything that we can produce and sell profitably abroad. That was part of the function of our diplomatic service.
Comment on this
Now we are relieving the Department of expense and responsibility that it had in the past and we will ask Deputy Moher's constituents, Deputy Donegan's constituents and my constituents to pay one shilling out of three towards the cost of marketing whatever dairy produce our constituents produce.
Comment on this
There is a very big volume of public opinion both inside and outside the House at the present time that this Parliament has made a blunder in giving too much power to boards. The action of one board recently is responsible for a good deal of discussion.
Comment on this
I appreciate what Deputy Seán Flanagan said tonight and I am sure there are many men on his side of the House who would express the same views. He was able to express them in a much nicer way than I, as a farmer, can do. Nevertheless, he had the courage of his convictions and disagreed with giving power to boards.
The Minister gave me the impression early today that Deputies could not ask a question with regard to this board once it is set up. I am glad that he has clarified that position now and that we will at least be in a position to question the expenditure of the money which we are providing.
Comment on this
As long as the board is functioning properly, I do not think anybody would be looking for publicity. Deputy Donegan seemed to think that the board as set up was weighted in favour of the producer. There are only four producers out of nine members, three from the cooperative societies and one from the Dairy Disposal Company. The remaining five are representative of manufacturing concerns many of whom would like to buy the farmer's produce as cheaply as they possibly could—the chocolate crumb manufacturers, the cheese manufacturers, the dried milk powder manufacturers and I will not say anything about the Minister's nominee.
Comment on this
The constitution of the board arose on a previous section. It does not arise on this section, which deals specifically with the milk levy.
Comment on this
On a point of order, surely this section deals fully with the board? The board is mentioned in every single part of Section 35.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Deputy Donegan in defending the powers in respect of the levy pointed out that this board was heavily weighted in its membership to producers and that that reassured him that the board would do nothing untoward in reference to the levy. I take it that that is the matter to which Deputy Wycherley is applying himself to.
Comment on this
The Deputy may hold those views but I cannot accept that the composition of the board can be discussed on this section.
Comment on this
On a point of order, on the fixing of the levy, as it is the board who do it, surely Deputy Wycherley is in order in saying that the board would be unsympathetic to the interests of the producers?
Comment on this
Under subsection (3) (a) the board may, whenever it thinks fit, make an order fixing the rate of the milk levy and specifying the date on which the rate so fixed is to come into operation. In fixing the milk levy I do not think the board would in any way favour the producers because the majority of the board are not representative of the producers.
Comment on this
This Section relates to the imposition of a levy. The composition of the board is irrelevant on this section.
Comment on this
On a point of order, if the board has power to make a levy and we are discussing the probability of that levy being unduly burdensome, surely we are entitled to argue that the board as constituted is not likely to be leaning towards the producer?
Comment on this
The time to argue that point, with all respect to the Deputy, was on the section dealing with the composition of the board, not this section.
Comment on this
Surely we can argue that the power to make a levy on producers of milk is a power which we have good reason for viewing with alarm? The Minister was not present but very wide ground has been covered. His colleague seemed to say at one time that these decisions were not reviewable by the House; then he tried to reassure us that they were reviewable by the House. I am going to make a further submission that they are not reviewable by the House after Deputy Wycherley is finished.
Comment on this
The function of the board as set out here is, amongst other things, to make an order fixing the rate of milk levy. I do not see how it is open to the House, having already discussed the composition of the board, to suggest that the board would be weighted one way or the other on this section.
Comment on this
Could not you argue that they should not have power to make a levy at all on account of the way they are constituted?
Comment on this
The Chair is concerned with the fact that the section before the House deals with the milk levy and the composition of the board does not arise.
Comment on this
It is a consolation to me to know that, the board having fixed a levy, we are entitled to question their activity.
Comment on this
The plain truth of it is that the Minister for Agriculture has not the faintest notion of what is in his own brief and is trying to pick it up as he goes along. His hearing is not too good and the width of the passage is more than the advice that frequently flows across. It is quite true that Section 62 provides that every order and regulation made under this Act shall be laid before each House of the Oirechtas but the process of arriving at the levy is a process of determining the price to be paid by the board for butter and then determining the price the board may charge for butter on the domestic market. When you come to the relevant section in which that is done you find this interesting formula employed in Section 42 which provides: "(1) the Minister may from time to time give the Board a direction in writing..." Then you look at Section 62. Is there any provision in Section 62 about a direction in writing being laid on the Table of this House?
Comment on this
No. This is a very astute operation. The Order making the milk levy is relatively irrelevant. It is the situation created by a series of directions given by the Minister which creates the global losses which the Board must meet in making the levy.
Comment on this
The making of the levy is consequential on what the Minister does by way of direction in writing under Sections 42, 43 and 44. In this section, if the Deputy will look at it reference is made to the Minister giving the Board a direction in writing.
Comment on this
That is not covered by Section 62. I do not know what is the exact machinery envisaged in section 43 (2) which provides: "The Government may from time to time fix the price of butter..." They may fix the price of butter but it does not say by Order, and the subsection continues:
for the purposes of subsection (1) of this section or may fix two or more prices varying in accordance with either or both of the following, that is to say, the quantity of butter sold and the method of packing the butter, and may specify a date or dates as on and from which purchases shall be made at the price or prices so fixed and the Minister shall notify the Board in writing of the price or prices so fixed and the date or dates so specified.
Is there any instrument envisaged in that subsection which is caught by Section 62?
Comment on this
We were reassured by the Minister turning up Section 62 and saying every Order made under the Bill, whether by the Board or the Minister, must be laid before the House thus giving any Deputy the right of calling it in question. He sought to demolish Deputy Wycherley's argument, Deputy Murphy's argument and my argument in regard to the levy on milk by saying it has to be laid on the Table of the House. However, when you probe further you find out how the levy is arrived at. You discover it is arrived at as a result of a series of directions to be given by the Minister to the Board under Sections 42, 43 and 44 and that in none of these sections is there any reference made to an Order at all. Then you go to the point of the Government fixing a price but it is not fixed by Order. The way the Government communicates the price is not by including a statutory instrument of which everyone must take notice; it is by the Minister notifying the Board in writing of the price or prices so fixed. That fixation is done, I take it, by Government decision and, as all of us well know—certainly the Minister knows—Government decisions are not placed upon the Table of Oireachtas Éireann.
Comment on this
Whatever relevancy there may be in the Deputy's suggestion, surely it is not relevant to this section.
Comment on this
Yes it is. The whole object of this discussion, into which the Minister has leapt to enable the Minister for Agriculture to have a cup of tea, is to find out whether this House retains effective control over the rate of levy which the board may from time to time make on creamery milk. The case was made at first by Deputy Donegan that we need not worry our heads, that this board was representative of producers and therefore it could be trusted to do whatever was right. That argument having been discussed at length, Deputy Donegan mended his hand and said he was quite mistaken in that belief because his Minister now told him that every Order made would be placed on the Table of the House and would be subject to review by this House. We then reminded him that might be a bit late in the day.
The Minister for Agriculture was trying to reassure us that everything affecting the price of milk or butter would be available to the House under Section 62. He had angrily asserted earlier in the evening that it would be wholly irrational to give a board such powers and then claim the right to review its powers in Dáil Éireann, but he then excepted from that generalisation such matters as were caught under Section 62 and said that that related to all Orders made by the board. However, when I look at Sections 42, 43 and 44 I find that a different procedure is provided for under these sections and that none, of the mandatory directions given by the Minister under these sections are subject to review or, according to the Minister, discussable in Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that everything the Government and the individual Ministers do is discussed in Dáil Éireann?
Comment on this
No. There are heaps of decisions taken by the Government that are never laid on the Table of the House at all. It is perfectly simple to make all these matters subject to review by providing that a Minister should make an Order consequent on a Government decision, but he is not required to do that. All he is required to do is give a direction in writing to the board and on that the board must act. The net result will be of course that the board will have to make an Order in respect of a levy. At that stage it is open to any Deputy to call that Order in question but if the Act provides that the board has a statutory obligation to liquidate its losses through a levy after it has received an Exchequer grant of two-thirds of these losses, there does not seem to be much use in moving a Resolution in this House. Its losses will be created by the directive given in writing to the board by the Minister for Agriculture. Of course when it comes down to tin tacks, this is all an elaborate device to exonerate the Minister for Agriculture from blame in respect of the Fianna Fáil policy which is to levy an increasing sum on the milk producers in order to finance the export of any surplus they produce.
Comment on this
So it is not a matter of transferring it to anybody else. I have actually imposed this levy already.
Comment on this
I have a reason for it. Even if there was never a board I would have done it anyway.
Comment on this
I am putting it to the Minister that in fact this device is that the expanding levy made on creamery milk is now to be the responsibility of the board and that they have got to raise the levy to whatever figure is requisite to meet any losses they incur. I wonder are we wise, are we going to get the increased output we are hoping for, and if we do not where are we going to go?
Comment on this
Is not the levy proposed in this section by the board, under written direction of the Minister, a device to lower the price of milk to the creamery farmers? The board is obliged to engage in the sale of butter abroad and within the State if the Minister so decides. The Government can fix the price of butter under this Bill. It is just a cunning device to lower the price of milk to the producers. In other words, the price being paid for milk is considered uneconomic for the purpose of the export of surplus butter. Now we are going back and imposing a levy which is just another way of reducing the price of milk to the farmers. There is no other way to view it. It may be described as a device to take a load off the shoulders of the Minister for Finance in providing the necessary subsidy for the export of butter. If you give farmers 1/6d. a gallon for milk and take 6d. back in levy you are in fact giving him only a shilling a gallon, no matter how you dress it up. Any Deputy who thinks otherwise is only hoodwinking himself. The Minister has told us, in the light of experience of other boards—C.I.E. being one of them—that the position of this board can be reviewed here and that orders and regulations will be laid on the Table of the House.
Comment on this
I have been a member of the House for 17 years. I have seen Orders laid on the Table and I have come to know the futility of questioning any of those Orders because by the time they appear the harm is done and there is no use crying over spilt milk. As far as I can see it, the whole question of dairying and milk production in this country has now become something evil if we are to believe the Government side of the House. We are asked to increase production in many fields, milk being one of them. Now it seems the more we produce, the greater damage we do to the State. In this Bill the Minister calmly divests himself of responsibility and throws it on the board.
Comment on this
One of the things he hands over to the board is the power to impose a levy. That is only a dressing-up of a reduction in the price of milk.
Comment on this
I have been listening to the debate since it began and I have not heard the Minister say that before.
Comment on this
The Minister has spoken about the revenue the board can levy from the creameries. It might run to 4d. or 6d., or as low as a 1d. a gallon, but it is a device to dress up a reduction in the price of milk to the farmers.
Comment on this
The revenue has to come from the producer and that ultimately means the farmer must sell his milk at a lower price.
Comment on this
It is a means of bringing about co-operation between the taxpayer and the producer to do something worthwhile in the national interest.
Comment on this
The board being set up under this Bill will have the responsibility for the export of milk products which will include cheese, powdered milk and cream. Will a levy then be necessary or is it contemplated that it will be necessary to support the export of these commodities and, if so, will a levy for that purpose also be raised from the creameries? At the present time cheese is subsidised in the same way as butter and if the export of cheese is to be expanded—it would be helpful to our economy if it were— will the board have power in regard to the exports of these various products to support them by subsidies and to recoup outlay on these subsidies by increasing the levy?
Comment on this
The levy which I imposed in order to meet the cost of the export of surplus butter in 1958 and 1959 was on butter. At that time we were not supporting chocolate crumb, milk powder or cheese. At present we are, in fact, supporting these products and the board will do likewise. That being so, the levy in future will be on milk and not on butter because milk will be convertible into all these products.
Comment on this
The position is, therefore, that at the present moment the Exchequer supports the export of milk powder, cheese and chocolate crumb and now portion of the responsibility, at least one-third of it, will be transferred from the Exchequer to the milk producer.
Comment on this
No. There is no change. They will have to bear their share whether they are producing milk powder or cheese or chocolate crumb. The milk that is used for conversion into these products will pay any levy necessary in order to provide the one-third share set out here.
Comment on this
We have agreed to contribute on the assumption that a levy would be imposed for that purpose. We have given those who are engaged in the production the option of supporting it.
Comment on this
In respect to exports gone out? So it is true to say the Minister is at the moment supporting exports which hereafter will be borne by the milk levy. That will not be retrospective. Will the milk levy be charged with export burdens that have accumulated prior to the coming into operation of this Bill?
Comment on this
I could at any time myself impose a levy apart altogether from the bringing into existence of this board.
Comment on this
I do not want to press the Minister to go into details on what support has been vouchsafed but we shall assume that a certain dairy product received some measure of support since the 1st June last up to now. That, I take it, has been provided if such has happened by Treasury grant. It is not proposed to carry that charge forward and impose it in a levy when the levy under this Bill comes into operation. That is a finished transaction?
Comment on this
I think that is right. As I explained to the House the levy imposed by me some time ago to meet the marketing problem of the butter surplus was confined to butter. When that problem had been met, and when in the last year the situation developed in which we were not likely to have any large butter surplus, I announced the withdrawal of the levy. In 1960 it became apparent that if we were to continue the policy of a levy on butter only we would not be free, in fairness, to support on a two-to-one basis those industries that were engaged in the conversion of milk into chocolate crumb, milk powder and cheese. I felt that it would be better then to give these concerns an assurance that they too would be supported and I gave them that assurance and indicated the extent to which that support would be given. This assurance that I have given will be fully completed before the board contemplated in this Bill is set up and they will start off, I hope, on a clean sheet.
Comment on this
Then they will not be transferred to the new board from the Butter Marketing Board as existing liabilities?
Comment on this
No, I hope that we shall discharge the responsibilities which we accepted and any assurances that we gave the industries which I have mentioned.
Comment on this
They will be met by 100 per cent. Exchequer grants and after this board comes into existence——
Comment on this
It may be that before the end of the year there will be no milk available for levy—not until April.
Comment on this
The Minister will certainly create a sensation if he starts to impose a levy on milk before the 1st April.
Comment on this
It would not be as attractive as at some other periods from the point of view of getting funds.
Comment on this
It would be very harsh. However, at present a liability in this financial year has been accepted in respect of the export of certain dairy products. I take it from what the Minister has said that liability is to be met by two-thirds as to Treasury grant and by one-third as to retrospective levy which the Minister——
Comment on this
Well, a levy which the Minister may make on milk to realise one-third of the sum to which he is committed in respect of these commodities for any period prior to the establishment of this board?
Comment on this
I do not like the idea— although I do not blame the Deputy for trying—of the Deputy stringing along a chain of words to which I would afterwards be committed. That is not what I mean at all. I do not want to go into any great detail now, as I have already given my reasons for extending Government support to chocolate crumb, cheese and milk powders. That support may not be for this year on the basis of the support that was given to butter for the simple reason that the question that the milk that was used for conversion into these products had not made its contribution in the sense that the milk converted into butter had. These are matters that will be cleared off before the board that is provided for here takes over.
Comment on this
The Minister must bear with his colleagues in the House. I know that very often he thinks that parliamentary discussion is waste of time and my mind goes back to the day when the Parliamentary Secretary behind where he is now sitting said it was high time that we got rid of the Supreme Court because it was "too interfering." He thinks that we are just interfering in these prerogatives but I think we are entitled to ask is it true that dairy products other than butter are at present being supported with 100 per cent. Treasury grants and is it not the truth that after this Bill comes into operation dairy products other than butter will be supported out of the milk levy as to one-third and by Central Fund grant as to two-thirds?
Comment on this
These other products are not being supported to the extent of 100 per cent. State grant but by a State grant which is influenced by the fact that they have not, as the butter has, contributed any part towards a fund for the subsidisation of these exports on a two-to-one basis.
Comment on this
Whatever subsidy they are getting at present, whether it is 70 per cent., 80 per cent. or 100 per cent. it is coming from the Treasury. Hereafter, one-third will come from the milk levy and two-thirds from the Treasury—is not that right?
Comment on this
We are going to divide on this Section but I do not think that need deter the Minister from trying to give us as much information as we can get.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear that the Minister is so satisfied with his own performance but he must not press us to state frankly what our view is.
Comment on this
——for the nervous system of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle. The milk levy mentioned in Section 35 appears to be payable on all milk purchased by creameries. What will happen in respect of these creameries which distribute a large volume of milk in the form of bottled milk for liquid consumption in the home market? Is the Minister aware that for the past five or six years a great many creameries in different parts of the country have gone into the bottled milk business on a pretty large scale. Will that liquid milk pay the levy the same as milk designed for conversion——
Comment on this
That liquid milk, as I understand it, should only be derived from registered dairy premises, even though it is handled by a creamery. To tell the truth, I have often had the greatest misgivings.
Comment on this
The fact remains that we have allowed the creameries under certain registration conditions to get into the milk distribution business on a pretty large scale. The Minister is as well informed as I am. They take in the milk at a different reception point and keep a register of the suppliers who have registered dairy premises, and so forth; but, as far as I read Section 35, it operates to collect the levy off that milk.
Comment on this
That would be equivalent to collecting a levy off milk intended for liquid consumption.
Comment on this
You must under Section 35. The section says:—
(1) There shall be paid to the Board by every registered proprietor of a creamery or cream-separating station a levy on milk purchased or otherwise acquired by him, other than from another such proprietor, at a time in respect of which a rate for such levy stands fixed by virtue of an order under subsection (3) of this section, and the levy shall be of such amount as may be appropriate having regard to the rate fixed under the order.
(2) The amount of milk levy due by a registered proprietor of a creamery or a cream-separating station in respect of milk purchased or acquired in any month shall be paid to the Board not later than seven days after the last day of the month.
(3) (a) The Board may, whenever it thinks fit, make an order fixing the rate of milk levy and specifying the date on which the rate so fixed is to come into operation.
(b) The Board may, whenever it thinks fit, by order revoke or amend an order under this subsection including an order under this paragraph.
(c) An order under this subsection may fix different rates of milk levy in respect of different periods specified in the order.
(4) In this section "milk" means whole milk.
There is no provision here for refunding the levy to a creamery in respect of milk purchased for liquid distribution. So far as I can see, while there is power to make an Order under the subsection fixing the different rates of milk levy in respect of different periods specified in the Order, there is no power to make different rates of levy, or to exempt from levy, milk purchased or subsequently sold for liquid consumption in the home market. As far as I know, if this levy ran up to something like twopence per gallon, which would produce at present rates approximately £2,000,000, it would have a very grave effect on the creameries which were distributing milk for consumption and I do not think the Minister means to interfere with that trade. I should be glad to know if the implication of levying milk for that purpose has been considered.
Comment on this
I do not think there should be any difficulty about the point the Deputy makes. I know a number of creameries at the moment which purchase milk for conversion into butter and other products and which are also registered for the purpose of selling liquid milk. They have to keep records even now. They are two distinct businesses and the records they keep now should suffice for the purpose of any levy that may be imposed by the board on liquid milk purchased for industrial purposes.
Comment on this
If the Deputy turns to the definition of registered proprietor in Section 2, he will find there what is intended.
Comment on this
He will find it in the Dairy Produce Act. That is not very enlightening without the 1924 Act.
Comment on this
The Section says:
"registered proprietor" means, when used in relation to a creamery, the person carrying on the creamery business in that creamery, and when used in relation to a cream-separating station, means the person carrying an the cream-separating business in that station;
Comment on this
That does not include the liquid milk business. It is under the Milk and Dairies Act that they do it.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) says:
The amount of milk levy due by a registered proprietor of a creamery or cream-separating station in respect of milk purchased or acquired in any month shall be paid to the Board not later than seven days after the last day of the month.
Subsection (1) says: "There shall be paid to the Board by every registered proprietor of a creamery or cream-separating station a levy on milk purchased or otherwise acquired by him ..." The fact that Section 2 says a registered proprietor means, when used in relation to a creamery, the person carrying on the creamery business in that creamery, then that is the person who buys the milk.
Comment on this
He does not have to have another business. The person who buys the milk is the registered proprietor, and that is the creamery committee.
Comment on this
When he comes to sell the milk, he may sell it to a chocolate crumb factory, to a condensed milk factory, a dried milk plant, or he may sell it for liquid consumption. If he is buying milk to convert it into butter, to sell it to a cream factory, a cheese factory, or to another person who will engage in one of the activities entitled to support under the scheme, he must pay a levy on that milk. I understand the Minister does not wish the levy to apply to, say, 250,000 gallons of milk which he buys, pasteurises, bottles and sells for retail distribution in his own area. I know it is done in Monaghan on a pretty large scale. I know it is done in Limerick. I know it is done in Clonmel. In Waterford, I think it is done by a proprietary company. There are several places in which cooperative creameries are doing it.
Comment on this
The manager in one case is purchasing milk as a registered creamery proprietor. In the other case he is purchasing milk as a registered dairy under the Dairy Produce Act. There are two different persons involved here. The milk purchased in one capacity is not leviable—that is the milk purchased in his capacity under the Milk and Dairies Act. No milk purchased under that Act is leviable. It is only on the milk he purchases as a creamery proprietor that the levy will be imposed by the board.
Comment on this
If the Minister gives me his word that that is so, that must influence my mind, but certainly the section does not read that way to me. To me the section reads that if a registered proprietor buys milk the levy must be paid upon it without reference to how he subsequently disposes of it. Now the Minister says if he sends it to a chocolate crumb factory, to a dried milk factory, to a cheese factory or if he processes it himself into butter, the levy must be paid. But if he pasteurises it, bottles it and sells it retail, he does not pay the levy. Surely to goodness, the Minister is opening up the father and mother of a door to grave abuses in that regard?
I warned the Minister when he was embarking on the £15 scheme in respect of T.B. cows in the south that he was going to wind up in trouble. I think he has. Now he has plenty of trouble on hands. Think of what will happen here. The Minister knows as well as I do the almost insoluble difficulties created for the Department in trying to control the intake of this milk and ensuring that no stuff went into bottles that was not produced in registered dairy premises. The Minister and I both know, despite the utmost vigilance of our staff, that neither of us was ever satisfied that we effectively excluded unauthorised milk from being pasteurised and bottled.
How in the name of Providence, if a creamery is taking in 10,000 gallons of milk per day and is bottling 1,000 gallons a day, is the Minister going to satisfy himself that the levy is being paid on all the milk on which it ought to be paid? In the old days we used to have the rough measure of butter output. We multiplied the butter by 2¼ gallons and found out approximately how much milk passed through the creameries. Take the case of a creamery sending part of its milk to a cheese factory, on which levy must be paid, part to a chocolate crumb factory, on which levy must be paid, processing part of it into butter on its own premises, in respect of which levy must be paid, and possibly sending part of it to Dungarvan, Ballyclough or Tipperary for conversion into dried milk, on which levy must be paid, and, at the same time, pasteurising and bottling part of it and selling it in a neighbouring town, and in that case the levy need not be paid. Would it not be reasonable to suggest that sums running into thousands every year could go astray if creameries made returns suggesting that their sales of retailed bottle milk were far in excess of what they actually were? The money involved would run into a substantial sum.
However, I do not think that is the most important aspect of it. I do not think we should willingly legislate in a way well calculated to put temptation under a man's feet. And a penny a gallon when you are handling vast quantities of liquid milk—and this levy might even be 2d. per gallon—can run into a very substantial sum. I do not know what administrative machine the Minister can devise to exempt milk received by a creamery and subsequently sold for liquid consumption from the impact of this levy. I should be glad to know has he considered the machinery that will operate to achieve that. Will he just require the manager to make a daily return of the amount of milk sold? Will there be some system of check or is he simply going to let it rip and make estimates? There must be some machinery in his mind where such large sums of quasi public money are involved.
Comment on this
I cannot say any more than I have said. This business has been carried on for years by some creameries. They are registered under the Milk and Dairies Act for the public sale of milk for liquid consumption after pasteurisation and they are registered under the Dairy Produce Act, 1924, for the purpose of purchasing milk for conversion into industrial milk products. I have, been puzzled for a long time as to how this business was supervised and how they could be assured they were only accepting milk from registered dairies.
However, the question now arises as to the collection of any levy that may be imposed. The people who drafted this Bill were directed to exclude those who handled milk for liquid consumption. I take it the assurance I have given on their advice is correct and accurate. The question the Deputy referred to then arises. Could there be any juggling between the milk in respect of which levy must be paid and that purchased by them for liquid consumption? I do not think that that should present any insuperable problem. There are only a few firms engaged in that business and I have no doubt a means will be found of ensuring that the levy will be paid in respect of the milk on which it is due.
Comment on this
I must say I do not share the Minister's optimism at all. Deputies may say: "If you do not, why were you so calm about the segregation of milk from registered dairy premises? "When it was merely a question of selling bottled milk, the answer was that although we felt all milk for liquid consumption should come from registered dairy premises, the fact was present to our mind that all the milk sold retail from such dairy premises was being pasteurised. Therefore, if it was not entirely of the standard that might be expected from a registered dairy premises, pasteurisation would in large measure correct that.
Comment on this
It was a complete answer, I think, against the danger of the communication of sickness and disease through the medium of the milk.
Comment on this
If you discussed everything with the medical people and the vets—even with the lawyers—you would not sleep at night at all. By and large, I think that was substantially true. The plain truth was that sometimes, if you did not segregate the milk, it was not as clean as you would wish it to be, and was not fit for general retail distribution for consumer consumption. There is no doubt whatever, as the Minister has admitted by implication, that the operation of segregation was a doubtful one. But where you are satisfied there is no danger to public health, that is tolerable. We are all human beings and if you are putting within a man's reach the means of avoiding a statutory levy of 2d. a gallon on milk, and that might amount to 500 gallons a day, you are putting a terrible burden on any man responsible for the administration of such a system in his creamery.
Comment on this
There are several ways by which, if you suspect a man is dishonest, you can check up on him very quickly.
Comment on this
Perhaps you are right. I think the Minister had the same feeling with regard to the scheme of the £15 for the cows. You set up a scheme of this kind with the best intentions of the world and then you find some gigantic scandal building up. The papers in that case are going to the Attorney General and I presume that something is going to happen. If we never put that temptation in the way of people we would not now be facing the situation that some unfortunate men are going to be prosecuted, and, perhaps, convicted of crime. If they are, the fault is largely ours because we put in their way the temptation to which they fell. We are creating here another very great occasion of temptation.
Comment on this
What would you suggest? You cannot divide the creameries who engage in the sale of milk and those who purchase it for conversion into cheese.
Comment on this
I am always willing and anxious to help. I think that the Minister stands greatly in need of that assistance but I must confess that it is becoming rather a burden upon me because he is paid for it and I am not. I imagine that the wiser course would be to have a levy on all milk and then require the manager to furnish satisfactory returns of the milk sold for human consumption in his area and refund the money to him.
Comment on this
It is a better idea than any the Minister has. I do not believe that the Minister adverted to this problem at all until I directed his attention to it. The Minister has a brief a foot thick in front of him and, as I know from experience, it contains every detail that could possibly be raised on this Bill.
Comment on this
If there is it is created by the non-turning of the pages of the Minister's brief. I do suggest that the Minister has not adverted to this problem at all and I think that it is one of the problems that will have to be solved. The net result of it is that the Minister says he will not levy that part of the milk which the creamery manager buys for the retail trade. I think that is a pretty dangerous proceeding and I suggest that every creamery ought to be required to pay the levy and that there would be provision in the Bill, which there is not, to refund the levy to any creamery which sells milk under the appropriate licence for human consumption. Does the Minister realise that there is no provision in the Bill for refunding the levy to any creamery?
Comment on this
We do not want to collect any levy from those who are selling milk for human consumption.
Comment on this
Is there a provision in the Bill to collect the levy for milk that is to be sold for human consumption?
Comment on this
If you read the section you will find that there is an obligation to levy. The real trouble is that the Minister does not know B from a bull's foot about it. He never heard of it until his attention was directed to it here in this House.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
The Minister has explained to us that the system of the levy is being changed under this new device and that the levy is now to be on milk. Section 36 authorises the board to make a levy on butter delivered on sale or manufactured for some other person by the proprietor. Perhaps the Minister will explain to us the purpose of the butter levy envisaged in Section 36? I think I understand the purpose envisaged in Section 37.
Comment on this
The purpose of the legislation in Section 36 is, of course, part of the whole price support scheme for butter. In other words, provision has to be made for the cold storage of butter and at the present time a levy to meet that cost is being collected, to meet not only the cost of cold storage of butter but also administrative expenses that arise. These sections propose to continue these levies and have nothing to do with the supporting of our exports. It means carrying on something that has been the practice here for years. In the fixation of the butter price by the Government regard has to be had to the cost of cold storage and to the administrative expenses of the Butter Marketing Committee. In the fixation of the price at which butter is being sold regard is had to these two factors. This section and the sections that follow are merely a continuation of the practice that is already in existence though, naturally, it has now to be in a different form.
Comment on this
I remember when I was dealing with this matter there used to be an annual fight to persuade the Minister for Finance to make funds available to meet the cost of the storage of butter and, quite apart from the money that used to be provided to pay a subsidy on exports of butter, there was every year a substantial sum in my vote for the Butter Marketing Committee to meet the cost of the storage of butter.
I want to make this case to the Minister: Under this section we are placing an obligation on the Milk Board to collect a levy to pay the cost of storing butter. I would ask the House to consider what this involves. No creamery in Ireland that I know of wants to store butter. It would be much more convenient for creameries to sell their butter as they make it and up to 18 or 20 years ago that was the practice. The creameries sold the butter as they made it and if there was not sufficient butter in the winter, I think New Zealand butter mainly used to come in to fill in the gap of demand which was not met by current manufacture of butter during the months of perhaps January and February.
The community have grown into the habit of requiring that butter of Irish manufacture should be kept in store to suit the popular demand. I think it was the Minister for Finance, Deputy Dr. Ryan, who in his first Budget after the Fianna Fáil Party came back to office this time announced quite casually that in future that charge was going to be taken off the Exchequer and it was transferred to the retail price of butter. Am I to understand now that this butter levy under Section 36 will be included in the retail price of butter by the Minister when he is fixing the domestic price of butter? It will not be levied on the producer?
Comment on this
A penny a 1b. on the total consumption of butter in this country is the equivalent of four-ninths of a penny on the total amount of milk used. Four-ninths of a penny on the total milk used in the production of butter runs into a pretty substantial sum per annum. I often wonder are we following a wise practice in continuing that charge. I know that during the period of scarcity immediately after the World War there existed a difficulty that had never existed before and that was that there was no butter market in Great Britain. That meant if you wanted to get New Zealand butter you had to enter into a contract in New Zealand and if you did enter into a contract as of to-day in New Zealand butter you got no butter delivered here on foot of that contract for about two to three months after the contract was completed, because the butter actually had to come here from New Zealand. With the return to normal in the '50's, stocks of butter are now maintained in Great Britain to supply the British market and any other European market in which New Zealand deals, so that long delay is no longer an obstacle to purchasing supplies of New Zealand butter.
Our people, peculiarly enough, do not like Danish butter because Danish butter is manufactured from ripe milk. Although that butter commands on the London market a premium of anything from 10/- to 20/- a cwt. more than the price paid for New Zealand or Irish butter, our people do not like it; they called it "Dillon's yellow butter". The interesting thing about "Dillon's yellow butter" was that it cost a great deal more than the butter to which they were accustomed and they were getting it at a sacrifice price. However, popular taste is popular taste and we never got into the habit of eating Danish butter. New Zealand butter, as far as I know, is made by the same process as our own butter and is virtually indistinguishable from it, so there is no similar difficulty about filling a gap of supply for consumers with New Zealand butter.
Two matters fall to be considered. We are trying to expand our exports abroad arid for that purpose we ought to try to bring our processing costs as low as we can. We ought to operate the creameries to the maximum capacity and try to keep our costs of production as low as we can, thus reducing so far as we can any losses in which we may be involved in export markets.
Here is an economy we can make and it would run into a very substantial sum. The average consumption of milk for conversion into butter for the domestic market is 240 million gallons per annum, approximately. A halfpenny a gallon on that would yield £500,000 per annum. Is it worth considering the possibility of eliminating that heavy charge of £500,000 a year and bringing in New Zealand butter for two months while domestic production was not equal to domestic demand? I think that is worth considering. It is not that we shall be short of butter; on the contrary we shall be exporting more. Two courses will be open to us: we could either levy the incoming butter to equate the price, because we buy the New Zealand butter at world market prices, and use that money in relief of the levy on milk that will have to be made to pay the charge that falls on the producer when we are exporting our surplus productions. We could use that £500,000 a year to reduce the cost of butter to the consumer in this country.
In addition to that, there is a great deal of storage in the country, most of which could be advantageously used in connection with the dead meat trade because you have got to bear in mind that the storage is there and you must not encourage people to bring in expensive cold storage in one year and embark next year on something else which would result to them in very expensive capital outlay for which there is no profitable return.
If we were to save £500,000 a year by this advice, we could use the cold storage facilities for the storage of turkeys at Christmas or for a variety of other products for which could storage is required. With the growth of deep freeze, which is operating now in every provision shop in the country even in small towns, I think many of these cold stores could be profitably used as depots for frozen vegetables, frozen fowl and frozen fish.
I would be glad to hear from the Minister whether the insertion of this section suggests that he is taking an irrevocable decision about storing our own butter in order to provide a 100 per cent. supply for the domestic market or whether this substantial annual charge could not be avoided to the advantage of either the producer or the consumer, or perhaps to the advantage of both in the years to come.