We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Dairy Produce Marketing Bill, 1960—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 462–696 of 696. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Dairy Produce Marketing Bill, 1960
Enacted

No. 45 of 1960 ›

There is nothing irrevocable about it. I can see the purpose behind the plan envisaged in this section. If we did not have in the past some means by which we could store our summer surplus of butter I cannot see very well how we could have maintained an even price, and given an assurance to the producers that we would try to maintain that even price throughout the year. I do not know what the merits are of Deputy Dillon's proposal but this levy is included in the price of butter to the consumer. I do not think there is anything wrong in that. What is proposed in this section and the sections that follow is really the continuation, under new auspices, of a scheme or practice that has been going on for years. I do not think there is anything wrong with it. I do not know what the board may have to say in regard to such matters when they come to examine the whole field for which they will be responsible.

As I have said, there is nothing irrevocable in this in the sense that if we saw more advantageous means of handling our milk production we would be inclined to accept them. This scheme seems to be admirable designed to see to it that the creameries would not be all rushing out to the market to sell at a time when butter was in flush supply. We are aiming at having butter all the year round at a uniform price. That is all that is proposed here in the way of financing a scheme through levies which are there at present and have been in the past.

Comment on this

The more I think of it the more daft it seems to me. We can leave Denmark out because of the quality of the butter which is somewhat peculiar. New Zealand is located in the antipodes. Their season of maximum production is our season of minimum production, so we do not compete directly with them. It does not seem to be in order that simply because the practice grew up—I believe it originated during the economic war—that we should simply jog along. It must be clear to us that it is costing us £500,000 a year.

Comment on this

What about the flush period in Britain?

Comment on this

Do not mind about the flush period in Britain.

Comment on this

It is the Danes flush period.

Comment on this

We do not compete with the Danes at all. Deputy Moher knows more about this than he appears to. The vast bulk of our exports are to Northern Ireland where the people have the same prejudices against Danish butter as we have. At present 80 per cent. of our butter exports abroad go to Northern Ireland and the remaining 20 per cent. to Great Britain and that only for a very short period of the year. Our period of scarcity is New Zealand's flush period. It seems to me that we have a system operating like a pendulum and that if there is an attempt to stop the pendulum, even though stopping it may save £500,000, we exclaim: "For God's sake leave it alone; it has been working that way for years." Is there any sane man whose own personal income is involved, and who saw a prospect of saving £ 500,000 a year, who would say: "Leave well enough alone. I am able to stagger along"?

It seems to me to be quite irrational. There is a certain risk involved but I suggest to the Minister that this is the kind of buck we should not pass to the board. I think this is the type of responsibility that the Dáil must shoulder itself. We started this business; we inaugurated it. There is no doubt that it is very hard to jog people's minds out of fixed habits. But £50,000 a year is a lot of money.

I have not yet heard anyone try to demonstrate that there is a flaw in my reasoning. If that is so, surely the prospect should provoke more interest in the Minister for Agriculture than he appears to show. I do not think it is enough for him to say that he is passing this over to the board to let them do what they please. It is very hard to ask the board to make a radical change of this kind the moment they take over. They are a new body. They will naturally go to lengths to try and avoid colliding with any vested interests in the country. Accordingly, if this is a thing we ought to do, I suggest the Minister should seriously consider doing it before transferring that responsibility to An Bórd Bainne.

I should dearly like to hear what some of the experienced Deputies who constitute the trinity behind the Minister are thinking on this matter. They are probably saying: "I suppose he is right as he usually is." I am encouraged by the affirmative nods of some of them. Unfortunately the Minister cannot see the nods or perhaps he would not feel very pleased if he did. I heard him make some observations to some of his older colleagues this evening that made me suffer vicariously on their behalf. Is there no Deputy interested in half a million pounds?

Comment on this

Except the Deputy himself.

Comment on this

A man who spent £4 or £5 million in a few minutes should not be so concerned about a half-million.

Comment on this

It is because I knew how to spend the £4 or £5 million that I am so concerned about the half-million. We were never afraid to spend money when we got value for it.

Comment on this

When you had it.

Comment on this

When we had it, we were never afraid to spend money when we could benefit the farmers of the country by doing so. I remember spending in one morning £1 million on the purchase of superphosphate of lime for the farmers at 9/- a cwt. and within eighteen months they were paying 28/- for it because my successor paid 24/- a cwt.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

All this is hardly relevant.

Comment on this

I think I am entitled to make a rejoinder when the Minister intervenes. We were never afraid to spend money when the spending of it helped the agricultural community.

Comment on this

When you could get it.

Comment on this

I am proud of every shilling we spent and the records will be there for all the world to see long after Fianna Fáil are forgotten. That is what makes Deputies opposite as mad as wet hens.

Comment on this

But you left when you had spent it all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us keep to the butter.

Comment on this

We shall try to. Is there no Deputy interested in £500,000? I think there is.

Comment on this

I do not think they are worrying any more than I am.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not worried in any case.

Comment on this

In the case of Deputy Booth, so familiar with the economics of butter production, I should expect some throb but I shall not pursue that. I feel that in his heart he does sympathise.

Comment on this

The Deputy will sing a Christmas carol before he has finished.

Comment on this

I shall not, but surely I am entitled to express surprise that no member of the Fianna Fáil Party is prepared to get up and express in audible accents the agreement that they are whispering to and fro along the second bench of their Party.

Comment on this

There is a problem here. Has the Minister adverted to it? This is the section under which the Minister is taking a power that the Milk Marketing Board had in the past to make levies on butter stocks in retailers' hands. Is it not?

Comment on this

Yes, on a change of price—wholesalers and retailers.

Comment on this

The Minister is taking power here to envisage the making of a levy on stocks in retailers' or wholesalers' hands. Does he mean to use that power or is it put in here in terrorem?

Comment on this

That was always done.

Comment on this

No, it was not. I remember that I did it one year and it cost me substantially more to collect the levy than I got out of it. A ridiculous situation developed in which I had to go around to every grocery shop in the country and count the rolls of butter on the shelves. Then we found the rolls disappearing under the shelves and we had inspectors who wanted to see what was under the shelves. We found it was not worth while.

Comment on this

I am told it does not apply to amounts under three cwt.

Comment on this

Well, that is some relief in the situation but even there you are faced with the position——

Comment on this

Is it not better, seeing there is a reasonable prospect of collecting the difference—a difference that is effective overnight—to make the effort to collect it?

Comment on this

I doubt it. My real belief is that if you could confine your activity to wholesale premises it is probably worth doing. There are probably quantities of butter there which are significant and, if a levy were made on butter, it is fairly reasonable to collect it; to go to retailers' premises rarely paid and set a premium on fraud. On balance, I doubt if it is worth doing at all but I should be prepared to agree with the Minister if he said that there is too much malaise created if you do not levy a substantial wholesaler and the public think he is getting away with murder. Of course, the public never think that if the price of butter comes down the wholesaler who is carrying stocks is very rarely required for the loss he has to carry on his stocks if there is a reduction in the levy that has been imposed.

I do not know if the Minister has power in this long section—which it is not easy to follow in detail—to discriminate, or is he required to levy on every butter trader. Subsection (5) says:

In this section and in section 39 of this Act "butter trader" means a person (other than a registered proprietor of premises), who carries on for trade or gain, whether alone or in conjunction with any other business, the business of selling, by wholesale or retail, butter.

Suppose you place upon yourself the obligation of checking the butter stocks of every retail butter shop in Ireland, does that not oblige you to make a visitation to every butter shop in Ireland? You may not collect a levy except on three cwt. or more but would you not be obliged to inspect every premises to know if they had three cwt. or more?

Comment on this

I hardly think so.

Comment on this

I think so. How would you find out otherwise?

Comment on this

Those who carry out this investigation will be guided by a list of fairly large retailers which they have prepared and it is on these people they will make the check—the people who would be expected to have at least three cwt. of butter. That would reduce the amount of investigation required very, very substantially.

Comment on this

I should like to ask if the provisions in this section are similar to the provisions of kindred sections in other Acts of this kind?

Comment on this

I could not tell the Deputy what the similar sections in other Acts are. I am told that this is a routine provision. It provides for the recovery as a simple contract debt of levies due under Sections 35, 36 and 37.

Comment on this

There is nothing new in the section.

Comment on this

It is certainly not the ordinary procedure for the recovery of contract debts because it begins by passing the obligation to the debtor of proving he does not own, whereas ordinarily the person goes into court to claim the money and the first obligation on him is to prove that the alleged debtor owes him the money. In this case we reverse the procedure. The board can issue a certificate under its seal against anybody, whereupon he must post off to the court and protest that he does not owe anything to anybody. Mark you, if he fails to turn up, he will have a decree awarded against him because the certificate is prima facie evidence that the debt is due. I never could understand why these statutory bodies should be exempted from the obligation that devolves on ordinary citizens of the State to prove the validity of their debts. This practice is carried in its most extreme form to the claims of the Revenue Commissioners, who can put you in jail for debt. Is there any reason why a board set up by statute should be exempted from the ordinary obligation of demonstrating that someone owes them money before they are entitled to recover judgment against him? Is there any reason why a board should have that power?

Comment on this

There are similar provisions in other enactments, but I think this goes a bit far.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us any reason why this board should have this peculiar power?

Comment on this

I am told that it is the same section as in the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Act except that the board is substituted for the Minister.

Comment on this

Certainly I never heard we had any power to issue a certificate against a retail shopkeeper which was prima facie evidence of his debt due. I was never conscious such a power existed. I can well imagine vis-á-vis creameries it was possible for the Butter Marketing Board to recover levies in this way because the records were there and there was a constant interchange of correspondence with the the Butter Marketing Board. We do these things step by step. This is roughly the same procedure conferred upon the Land Commission by this House at the time of the troubles in connection with the land annuities. This House was prevailed upon then to authorise the Land Commission to short-circuit the courts and to recover by handing to the Sheriff a certificate that the annuities were overdue. I know the number of abuses that arose in that connection were relatively few, but I have known one man to have a decree issued against him for another man's annuity and to have the bailiffs sent out to his house on foot of a document issued by the Land Commission without any reference to the court at all.

I admit this procedure is not so extreme. The board has to go to the court and it behoves the shopkeeper, the wholesaler, or the creamery to prove to the satisfaction of the court that the debt is not due. Mark you, if you go into court and are confronted by what is accepted as prima facie evidence that you had 27 lbs. of butter in the shop and your concern is that you had only 7 lbs., I find it very hard to understand why a board like this should have that preferential position. Is it just to save the board trouble? Can anybody help me?

Comment on this

Would the board not furnish invoices in the same way as an ordinary trader would? An invoice is prima facie evidence that the trader delivered the goods.

Comment on this

The certificate here is more than an invoice. An invoice would be evidence tendered in proof.

Comment on this

I admit this is much better from the point of view of order.

Comment on this

The Minister said there would not be a levy on every bottle of milk. If there were some matters in dispute as between creameries and the board, would a certificate from the board mean that the creamery would owe a certain sum of money as between milk used for manufacture into butter and milk used as liquid milk? Should it not be left so that the creamery would not have to come into court? Should the onus not be on the board to prove the debt?

Comment on this

These are levies on butter stocks.

Comment on this

The section says every sum payable by a person on account of milk levy. It is every sum payable by a person by virtue of this Act relative to milk levy, butter levy or butter stocks levy.

Comment on this

The Deputy is perfectly right.

Comment on this

It is not just butter levy alone. It concerns each sum which may be levied.

Comment on this

The Minister really believes it relates only to butter.

Comment on this

Subsection (2) of Section 21 of the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Act, 1935, reads as follows:

In any legal proceedings by the Minister against any person for any money claimed to be due by such person to the Minister on foot of a levy under this Part of this Act, a certificate under the official seal of the Minister certifying that such person was liable under this Part of this Act to pay a levy of a specified amount on a specified substance in respect of a specified levy month and that a specified sum is due and unpaid by such person on foot of such levy shall be conclusive evidence as to the liability for and amount of such levy and prima facie evidence as to the amount which is due and unpaid by such person in respect of such levy.

The only change in this section, as far as I can see, is that the board is substituted for the Minister.

Comment on this

Conclusive, is it not?

Comment on this

It is not. Here we are, labouring away, trying to tread our way through a Bill of 64 sections of a very complicated kind. The Minister is sitting in front of a brief, certainly four inches thick. We direct his attention to the fact that Section 38 concerning the recovery of levies authorises the board to issue a certificate which is prima facie evidence of the existence of the debt and the Minister bluntly replies: “Oh! this only applies to butter.” Nothing could be further from the truth. Now, either the Minister believed that when he brought the Bill into the House or else he did not know what was in the Bill. It certainly makes the labour of discussing this legislation far heavier if the Minister will not read his brief. All I will ask him to do is to read out the page of his brief relative to each section. If he does not understand it, we shall. I do not think it right for him to say quite blandly to Deputy Jones “This refers only to the levy on butter.” It does not.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

It refers to the levy on milk as well.

Comment on this

There is no reason why it should.

Comment on this

Correct me if I am wrong. Maybe there is a misprint in my copy of the Bill. If there is, the fault is not mine but that of the printer. Let us spell it out. "Every sum payable by a person by virtue of this Act to the Board for or on account of milk levy." Are those words in the Bill or are they not? The Minister just told us they are not in the Bill.

Comment on this

What I wanted to say was this. As far as the milk levy is concerned, in this Bill we are making the Exchequer responsible only for up to two-thirds of the export loss. The board will be obliged to find the remaining one-third by way of levy. There is no means by which they can get that one-third except by levy. They are the people who will be responsible for determining the amount of the levy and for collecting it from the creameries. If some creamery were to refuse to pay that levy to the board, I suppose they would have the right to take action in order to recover it. The onus is on the board to provide one-third of their losses and they can only get that by way of levy.

Comment on this

As well as the question of recovery of the levy subsection (2) of Section 38 provides for the issue of certificates by the board. For instance, if a creamery owes a sum of money to the board, is that money held to be legally due immediately such a certificate issues?

Comment on this

No. It is merely prima facie evidence.

Comment on this

Is it to be taken as prima facie evidence in court that such a sum is due at that stage, even though there may be a dispute in the circumstances I outlined? For instance, in the case of a creamery engaged in the manufacture of butter or the sale of liquid milk or milk for processing into milk powder and so on, what is the position?

Comment on this

The board must have power, when it imposes a levy, to recover the amount of the levy in respect of whatever amount of milk is received in that creamery.

Comment on this

I think we are all going daft in this House. The question of the power of the board to recover the levy it is authorised to recover under this Bill is not in question on this discussion. It is the method of recovery. I may get it into my head in the morning that the present Minister for Agriculture owes me 72/6d. for a pair of boots, but no one is going to suggest if I issue a certificate that Patrick Smith of County Cavan owes me 72/6d. for a pair of boots, that that is prima facie evidence he owes me 72/6d. for a pair of boots.

Comment on this

If he produces an invoice, it is prima facie evidence.

Comment on this

I am talking about a certificate. I do not think it is prima facie evidence. I think I would be required to go into court and prove I had delivered to the person in question a pair of boots and that he was the person to whom I delivered the pair of boots. Is it not fantastic to say it is perfectly normal that somebody should have the right of going into court and establishing a prima facie case on the foot of his own certificate? If you confine that strictly to creameries, I could make a case for it. The case I would make is this. If Deputies will understand the relationship that exists between the Department of Agriculture and the creameries, there is no problem here at all, because there is the most intimate contact between them. They know one another so well that it is probably a short circuiting of procedure which the creamery would welcome. In drawing up the certificate there would probably be agreement. They would probably agree on the quantity mentioned in the certificate. It might be on some other issue altogether they would join in the appropriate court, if they went to court at all. But when you go beyond that and give them the right to similar facilities vis-á-vis shopkeepers, wholesalers, and anyone engaged in the trade, why should a statutory board have the right to short-circuit the procedure in court any more than anybody else has? What struck me about the Minister was his reaction. His reaction was “Why should they not?”

Comment on this

In what other way could they do it?

Comment on this

By going into court and suing me for £73.3s. 9d. levy due under the appropriate section of the Dairy Produce Marketing Act, 1960, in consideration of levy payable.

Comment on this

This is the first step in that procedure. Nothing more.

Comment on this

The board has to go to court.

Comment on this

But it transfers the burden of proof from them to me.

Comment on this

It has to produce its own evidence first.

Comment on this

But that is the only evidence it produces.

Comment on this

It does not transfer the burden of proof in a contest.

Comment on this

The certificate is prima facie evidence of the existence of the debt.

Comment on this

If I went into court to sue them I would have to prove the debt before any obligation devolved on them to refute it.

Comment on this

I thought the section was wider, but in fact it is narrower.

Comment on this

Does anyone think that desirable? I do not think it is. I do not see why the board should be put in any privileged position over and above any individual in proving a debt.

Comment on this

The board is equivalent to the State in this regard. It is a substitution for the Minister.

Comment on this

Go on.

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners have this power in relation to a tax. This is in the nature of a tax.

Comment on this

Now we are travelling. I think Deputy Haughey gave us the Fianna Fáil mind. Why should you object? This is a tax. Pay it and like it. Why should not any Government have the powers of the Revenue Commissioners? Will Deputy Haughey come the whole way with me and go on to say that, if and when a decree is awarded under this, it ought to be open to this board to put the debtor in jail until he pays? That is the power the Revenue Commissioners have. Come now. Deputy Booth and Deputy Haughey are both very logical men. I heard Deputy Booth chortle with affirmative joy at Deputy Haughey's proposition. Will they now have the courage to come this further step?

Comment on this

What is the alternative?

Comment on this

Put him in jail. Make the so-and-so pay. It is just the same alternative as the Deputy or I have, if we claim a debt we have to go into court and prove it.

Comment on this

Unfortunately I permitted myself to be drawn into this to help you in your case. You are just drawing the thing out.

Comment on this

That is the typical reaction of the Fianna Fáil mind, that debate is just drawing things out and is a waste of time. The Minister assured Deputy Jones that this section had no reference to a milk levy. It has transpired in the course of the debate that it does apply to milk sales.

Comment on this

Go on with your filibuster.

Comment on this

Debate, according to Fianna Fáil, is filibuster. The truth is that you are spoilt by having an Opposition that is too responsible. If we were in half the dilemmas in which you found yourself recently over there, I have a good idea of how difficult it would be for us, if you were over here, to defend the Government. I heard some speeches made over there yesterday and I was thinking that if the Minister for Defence were over here, and we were over there, of the attitude he would take. Is there anybody here who is prepared to get up and propose that this board should have the same powers as the Revenue Commissioners, that a board of this kind should be exonerated from the obligations to prove its debt?

Comment on this

It is not exonerated. It has to prove its debt by furnishing a certificate.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not the right to prove his debt by furnishing a certificate.

Comment on this

I furnish an invoice.

Comment on this

You have to furnish a civil bill.

Comment on this

And so has the board.

Comment on this

Under this section the board's certificate is proof of the debt unless it is rebutted.

Comment on this

The board has to produce evidence in the same way as you and I have. We have to produce the invoice delivered to the man against whom the proceedings have been taken and who is present in court.

Comment on this

Would this board be in the same position as the Revenue Commissioners who might issue what is called a protective assessment?

Comment on this

If they issue a certificate saying that so much is due, is the onus put on the individual to come into court and to prove that it is not due? The board is dealing only with figures of returns which they believe they should have received.

Comment on this

A court would take a very serious view of anybody attempting to use a false certificate.

Comment on this

I started this discussion because I recalled seeing a similar section in some other Act and I raised this matter to ask a simple question of the Minister. I find, in point of fact, that the section in this Bill is not as wide as the section quoted by the Minister from the 1935 Act. At some other time I would like to know whether and what other Acts contained clauses of this kind but that is another matter. I do not think the section as it stands is going too far.

Comment on this

Would the Minister advise us if there are any other obligations involved in this section? Is it to be relative to returns?

Comment on this

What about 39 (e) ? There is no time specified for compliance. You just have to comply. There is a period of three days specified in paragraph (b) but that is the only place there is a question of time being allowed. Three days is a very short time in which to comply and you are liable to a fine of £20 for the first offence.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:

In page 21, line 57, and in page 22, line 1, after "Such", in each case, to insert "documents or".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

Could the Minister explain to us subsection (2) of this section which requires disclosure of information to the Minister or the Comptroller and Auditor General?

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor General is responsible for auditing the accounts and he will have to get the information so as to enable him to do that work.

Comment on this

I never saw that provision before. Does it exist anywhere else?

Comment on this

I could not tell you.

Comment on this

It seems to me to be an odd provision if anyone is in the slightest way interested in the freedom of the individual. Section 39 and Section 40 give the auditor of the board extensive powers to examine records. The implication is that the information absorbed from those records is confidential and is not to be communicated to anybody except the board. It used to be the Minister for Agriculture. Section 41 says that "subject to subsection (2) of the section, information obtained under Section 39 or 40 or in the performance of the functions of the board by the board or a member, officer or servant thereof shall not be disclosed, without the consent of the person to whom or to whose business the information relates, to a person who is not a member of the board or an officer or servant employed by the board." Then it says:

(2) Subsection (1) of this section shall not apply in relation to the disclosure of information to the Minister or the Comptroller and Auditor General or for the purposes of any legal proceedings (whether civil or criminal) taken or proposed to be taken under this Act.

Does the Minister not think that there is something queer about getting access to records on a confidential basis, under Sections 39 and 40, and then claiming that they may be communicated to somebody with a view to instituting civil or criminal proceedings?

Comment on this

They would be released only where there was a matter of the disposal of a serious charge.

Comment on this

How does the Comptroller and Auditor General come into it?

Comment on this

He is responsible for auditing the accounts and if he requires certain information and asks for information you could not simply say: "You will not get it."

Comment on this

Then it is information to enable him to carry out the orders of the board?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Or alternatively for the purpose of legal proceedings, whether civil or criminal. I see the point.

Comment on this

What is contemplated under this? What contribution is contemplated towards the cost of cold storage?

Comment on this

This provision is included to provide for the continuation of the scheme at present operated by the Minister. Already, creameries are paid an allowance during the summer months for cold storing the requirements of butter for the following winter. The cost of such a scheme would be met out of the proceeds of the butter levy provided for in Section 28.

Comment on this

That is specifically the matter we were discussing earlier in the evening as to whether it was desirable to carry it on or not?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Discussing this Bill is like constructing a crossword puzzle because I raised on an earlier section the question as to whether this whole system of storing butter was a wise system and whether we should not review it, to which the Minister replied; "Ah well, we are transferring all responsibility over to the board and we ought to let the board settle it." I made an eloquent argument that this was a matter we ought to determine before we hand it over to the board. If now transpires under section 42 that this is a matter that we are not going to transfer over to the board because the Minister settles the scheme. Section 42 subsection (1) says:

The Minister may from time to time give the Board a direction in writing requiring it——

(a) to make and carry out during such period or periods as may be specified in the direction a scheme for the payments to the registered proprietors of creameries of allowances towards the cost of the cold storage, by or on behalf of the proprietors, of butter, or

(b) to suspend, or provide for the cesser of, as from a date specified in the direction, in whole or in part, of a scheme under this subsection and payments thereunder.

Subsection (6) of the section says:

The terms and provisions of a scheme under sub-section (1) of this section shall, on the direction of the Minister, be amended by the Board in such manner as the Minister specifies in writing to the Board.

Subsection (7) says:

The Minister may give a direction under subsection (6) of this section to the Board from time to time as he thinks fit.

Comment on this

There is nothing at all inconsistent in that with what I have already said here.

Comment on this

Maybe I am stupid. If I am, I am sorry, but I understood the Minister to say to me that he heard my argument with interest but that, in view of the fact that he proposed to divest himself of functions in relation to that matter he thought it better to leave this matter to the discretion of the new board who would be responsible for it. Did he say that?

Comment on this

Let us have a look later at what we all said, not have somebody giving a synopsis of what we said.

Comment on this

Section 5, subsection (2) authorises the board to store butter. Section 42 gives the Minister power to direct the board to do it if he so wishes but the board has already authority to do it on their own. Presumably, if the Minister feels the board have not done something which they ought to have done he can direct them to do it.

Comment on this

Deputy Booth has come in late. I raised this matter on an earlier section and the Minister told me that he did not propose to consider the merits of this question because he was passing it over to the board.

Comment on this

Earlier on I did explain at length, I thought, that the Minister is responsible entirely for all matters, I might say, as far as the home market is concerned. This is an export marketing board that is being established. Ministers have fixed, will the consent of the Government, the price of butter. They have determined the price at which butter will be purchased by the Butter Marketing Committee. They have determined the price at which butter would be retailed. In the determination of these questions they have made provision for the cold storage of butter, the cost of cold storage and for other minor charges and all these were included in the price support system as far as the supply of milk was concerned. That picture is not changed. That picture does not change. The Minister and the Government will still be responsible for the determination of that matter. That is why there is this continuing provision made in these sections that we are discussing. There is this continuing provision for payment of the levy which is referred to here.

Comment on this

There is no levy or anything referred to here. Is not this section simply vesting power in the Minister to make a scheme which he may require the board to carry out for the cold storage of butter during the winter months, presumably to maintain a supply? I argued on an earlier section that that practice is costing us £500,000 a year, approximately, and that I thought the Minister ought to tell the House whether it was his intention to carry on that scheme or whether he would consider it desirable to effect the economy that could be made by permitting creameries to sell their butter as they made it and, if there was any gap in supply to meet the domestic demand in the months of January and February, to import butter.

Comment on this

If you were to permit the creameries to sell butter in that way do you not see the competition that there would be amongst them?

Comment on this

Not at all. Let them buy what was coming in at approximately what it cost them to produce butter at home. The Minister would thus save £500,000 in storage costs and accumulate a further not inconsiderable sum to meet the cost of production or the cost of the levy or to reduce the price to the consumer, whichever he likes to do. I think the Minister would save £500,000 and he would easily pick up, in respect of a levy primarily designed to maintain a table price throughout the year, another £100,000 for imports of butter. I do not think it unreasonable in the course of a discussion of this character to ask the Minister his reaction to that proposal with which he must be intimately familiar. He knows as much as I do about storage costs of butter, the procedure we operate and the alternatives that are available.

I was told within the last hour when I raised this matter that the Minister had decided to transfer all responsibility in regard to decisions relating to all future policy to the board. It now transpires under Section 42 that in fact this is a function the Minister will retain in his own hands. Does the Minister feel free to say that we are getting fair value for the £500,000 by the present system or would he think that, if a change would yield between £500,000 and £600,000 which could be used for the consumer or the producer, we ought to make the change ? That is a reasonable request to make, that the Minister would give us his opinion upon that. Surely the Minister is prepared to tell us whether he would consider the matter.

Comment on this

I commented on it, when the Deputy last raised it.

Comment on this

The comment the Minister made was that he had determined to resolve this matter because he had transferred responsibility to the Board, but in fact he has not.

Comment on this

That is not so. I have not made such a statement.

Comment on this

What was the statement? Does anybody know? I shall not accept this section if the Minister is not prepared to give us information.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 61
·
Níl 40
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Could the Minister give any indication of the sum to be transferred to the board?

Comment on this

I would not know until the end of the financial year. We are still exporting butter.

Comment on this

There must be some money in the Dairy Produces (Prices) Stabilisation Fund. I would not expect the Minister to have the figures pat, but could he give us some idea?

Comment on this

I have not got the figures but I can say it is not very much.

Comment on this

Will the Minister make available to the board any moneys in the Agricultural Grant in Aid?

Comment on this

The Bill determines the financial obligations of the Government to the board when it is established. It does not matter where the money comes from so long as the Government honours its bond to the board.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 24, line 22, to delete "income and expenditure account,".

This is a drafting amendment proposing to delete certain words which are unnecessary in view of subsection (1).

Comment on this

Why do you want to take out those words?

Comment on this

I have given the reason. They are regarded as unnecessary because I am empowered, in consultation with the Minister for Finance, to decide the form in which the accounts will be kept by the Board.

Comment on this

I agree that from the Minister's point of view that is true but if these words were left in the Bill, when the accounts were laid on the Table of the House they would contain this information; if we remove these words the accounts will not contain this information unless the Minister so directs. It is significant that the Minister elects to leave in the Bill the statement of accounts and balance sheet certified by the Comptroller and Auditor General. I do not attach too much importance to the point——

Comment on this

I do not think it has any.

Comment on this

Well, it is a further account which would provide information for Deputies. Does the Minister contemplate requiring the income and expenditure account to be shown?

Comment on this

We feel that the words are unnecessary since I, in consultation with the Minister for Finance, have the right to determine the manner in which they will be shown.

Comment on this

I do not press the matter.

Comment on this

Does Section 48 mean that the Minister will answer Parliamentary Questions?

Comment on this

I wanted information on more or less the same point. Some Fianna Fáil Deputies said tonight that, after all, the Minister and the Government were responsible to the House. The section said: "The board shall furnish to the Minister, at such times and in such form and manner as the Minister may specify, such information regarding its proceedings under this Act as the Minister may request."

We have had an amount of trouble in this House in recent times especially in regard to information sought by members in respect of State or semi-State bodies. I wonder would the Minister care to comment now on whether, if he is asked a question in the House as to the proceedings of this board, he will be in a position to give the information? As it now stands the section says that the Minister may get all the information he wants; therefore it is not unreasonable to suggest that he should be in a position to make that information available to Deputies.

Comment on this

It is not unreasonable that the Minister should expect to get the information he requires, seeing that the Exchequer may be involved in paying very substantial sums to meet the export losses but how a Minister would determine questions that would arise in that regard without having been furnished by the Board with the information is something I do not know. What bearing this matter of furnishing the Minister with information has upon the insertion of questions in the Order Paper is something I cannot see.

Comment on this

Will the Minister now answer the question?

Comment on this

Surely if the Minister says he requires this information and, as he told us, there is the consideration of the cost to the Exchequer, he must realise that the Government is not the Exchequer and the Minister for Agriculture is not the Exchequer. This House votes the money to the Government to give to the board. If the Minister wants the information, as he has said, it is not unreasonable that the Deputies who voted the money to him should get that information.

Comment on this

The annual accounts will be presented to the House.

Comment on this

Accounts, my eye! We had them before.

Comment on this

I want to support Deputy Corish. In relation to a measure such as this we have had quite a lot of experience in the past. In the past two years we had the spectacle of the Minister in charge of a Bill in this House giving an undertaking to the House that a certain statutory board about to be established would act in a certain way in relation to its statutory obligations. We found that undertaking was departed from when the Board was in fact established. Here is a section in which the Minister is empowered as a member of the House, elected by the House, to get certain information from a board being established and Deputy Corish has asked the Minister in charge of the Bill to give his view as to whether he, as Minister for Agriculture, is prepared to answer due and proper Parliamentary Questions by Deputies in relation to the activities of this board. I think that is a reasonable question to be raised by Deputy Corish and the Minister has not even attempted to reply to it. Is it in fact the Minister's intention in establishing this board that, when Deputies here ask for information concerning its activities, they will be met by a Ministerial reply that this is no part of the functions of the Minister, and that no information is to be given to Deputies?

Comment on this

Seeing that so many of my colleagues have been accused of having given assurances in the course of the discussion——

Comment on this

The Taoiseach did it and departed from them.

Comment on this

——on a similar provision I am desperately anxious not to make any commitment in that respect and to leave the House under no delusion. In fact, when Deputy O'Higgins was not present during the discussion this evening, we had several references to this matter and I tried to make it clear that, to whatever extent I am still responsible after the passage of this Bill into law for legitimately making information available to Deputies, I shall certainly discharge that responsibility.

Comment on this

Is it not clear that this is the very thing of which we are accusing the Minister? He seeks to get information which he refuses to convery to the Dáil. Surely that is most unreasonable. Surely the people who pay the piper should call the tune? Is it not the public that are being denied through the Dáil the right to get the information which the Minister has available and must get under this section? The Minister is flouting the authority of the people and it is a disgraceful attitude for him to adopt.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

May I ask the Minister in regard to Section 48——

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was interested only in three fresh subs?

Comment on this

That kind of insolence will get you nowhere.

Comment on this

We want to debate the Bill. We do not want that kind of stuff.

Comment on this

Impudence will get them nowhere.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

On many occasions when Parliamentary Questions are addressed to Ministers, Deputies are met with the reply, in so far as State and semi-State bodies are concerned, that the annual report is available for inspection in the library. I want to point out that the greatest weapon that Deputies have, and the greatest safeguard that the country has, is the Parliamentary Question and if the Parliamentary Question is to be ignored in the House by Ministers Parliament will cease to serve any useful function. Ministers are making a complete farce of this House.

In order to have this matter cleared up once and for all, I should like the Minister to give a much clearer reply to the points raised by Deputy Corish. Is he, or is he not, going to give the House all the information required concerning the activities of this board should Parliamentary Questions be addressed to him concerning the activities of the board? Or will the Minister consider that the information that is being sought by a Deputy will warrant making enquiries direct to the board and agree that the information that the board places at his disposal will be given to this House when sought by means of Parliamentary Question?

I feel the House would be satisfied, and we on this side of the House will express our satisfaction, if the Minister will give us a guarantee at this stage that, when a Parliamentary Question is addressed to him concerning any matter relating to the board, he will look upon it as part of his responsibility—he stated he would do so a few moments ago—to obtain the information from the board and pass it on, instead of giving the evasive answers which have been given in the past when questions concerning C.I.E., Bord na Móna and other State and semi-State bodies have been asked by Deputies in an effort to elicit information. As I said, the strongest weapon we have, whether in Government or Opposition, is the Parliamentary Question. I can foresee Deputies being anxious to ask many Parliamentary Questions concerning the activities of this board because of the very important functions the board will be asked to discharge. It is for that reason that I now ask that we should be informed as to where we stand and I shall be glad to hear from the Minister what his attitude will be in relation to giving Deputies information relevant to the activities of this board.

Comment on this

No Minister can know in advance what questions he will answer and what information he will give. The Deputy's request is entirely unreasonable. All I can say is that I shall answer every question not inconsistent with the proper discharge by the board of its duties and responsibilities.

Comment on this

May we take it then that the Minister will not inform any Deputy who asks a question that he should write direct to the board? The Minister will look upon it as his responsibility to obtain the information and will give the information here by way of Parliamentary reply?

Comment on this

I do not mind if Deputies write to the board every day of the week.

Comment on this

This section empowers the Minister to get certain information from the board. In relation to any information he will get, will the Minister undertake to give that information to the House?

Comment on this

I will not.

Comment on this

The position then will be that the Minister will withhold from the House information he will get from the board under this section?

Comment on this

And he wants the House to give him the board.

Comment on this

My relationship with the board and the responsibilities of the Minister for Agriculture for the board are a different matter entirely.

Comment on this

Behind-closed-doors stuff.

Comment on this

The Minister says he will have no objection to any Deputy writing to the board for information. I am sure he will have no objection. I am equally sure Deputies will write to the board. The question is: will the board reply?

Comment on this

I could not tell the Deputy that.

Comment on this

But the board must answer the Minister. The Minister is the only person who can obtain the information.

Comment on this

There is too much of the Star Chamber about this.

Comment on this

This is a situation against which we must guard. I do not know whether the Minister would or would not answer a question with regard to the price of butter. That is a very vital matter at the present time. It always has been. Under Section 42 of this Bill the Minister is given power to give directions to the board. Under Section 44, upon which I unfortunately missed the discussion, the Minister will have power to tell the board the price at which butter should be sold. I want to safeguard the situation in which, if the price of butter goes up by 2d. per lb. and I ask the Minister a question here——

Comment on this

I will be responsible for that if it does happen.

Comment on this

I do not know whether or not the Minister will be responsible. He has told us nothing to-night.

Comment on this

There are sections in this Bill placing upon the Minister for Agriculture responsibility for all the matters that Deputies are asking questions about now.

Comment on this

Pity the Minister did not tell us about that.

Comment on this

I want to safeguard the position in which the Minister gives a direction to the board to increase the price of butter to a certain level and, when we ask him a question in this House as to why butter should be such and such a price, he replies: "That is a matter for the board."

Comment on this

At the time the question is addressed to me I must determine whether it is a question I can or cannot answer.

Comment on this

The Minister as Minister has a special position vis-a-vis a board such as this. This section says in no unqualified manner that An Bord Bainne will give him all the information he requires. What information? There is no qualification in the section. Surely, if the information is at the disposal of the Minister, it is not unreasonable that he should impart any information that might be requested from him by an ordinary Deputy by way of Parliamentary Question.

Comment on this

Accepting the Minister's statement that it will be his responsibility to fix the price of butter in the home market and that he is, therefore, answerable to the Dáil in consequence of his powers in that respect, is it not true that the fixing of the price of butter on the home market would have a very strong impact on the board in its effect on the diminution of the surplus for export. Where does the demarcation line come?

Comment on this

Without being critical of the Chair and the liberal practices of the Chair, I should imagine it would be possible, if such a contingency as that arose, to discuss the matter here.

Comment on this

But could we get the information which the Minister states he will be empowered to get from the board under this section?

Comment on this

The Deputy could not.

Comment on this

Could we get the information the Minister will be authorised to get, that is, the information as to the impact on the board of the Minister's actions?

Comment on this

The Deputy could get only such information as I might decide I was entitled to give having regard to the board's responsibilities and mine.

Comment on this

The present Minister will not always be Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I hope it will not be the case of the next Minister for Agriculture standing up and saying he has no information in the matter.

Comment on this

The Deputy is going to say that he knows that so long as I am here everything will be all right but he is trying to warn the House against what will happen——

Comment on this

This is the terrible price of trying to be polite to the Minister.

Comment on this

I feel reasonably satisfied from the reply the Minister has given that, if a reasonable question is asked, he will be prepared to answer it.

Comment on this

That is what a reasonable man would do, but we are not, of course, dealing with a reasonable man. If the Minister had made that statement half an hour ago there would be no trouble.

Comment on this

I am glad this section is in and I am glad the Minister has a function in the matter. We shall be entitled to put down questions and we shall expect to get the answers from the Minister.

Comment on this

One thing is certain: Deputies will not be able to accuse me in six, eight, ten or 12 months' time, if we are alive and here, of misleading the House as to what will happen with regard to conveying to Deputies information by way of Parliamentary Question so far as this board is concerned.

Comment on this

Sure, we just do not know.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give us any indication of the type of question to which he would feel constrained not to give an answer? There does not seem to be any great secrecy about the price of butter.

Comment on this

It would be easier for me to answer that if I saw the question and knew the circumstances.

Comment on this

Could the Minister not give the House some indication of the kind of question in a simple matter like the price of butter or milk products?

Comment on this

The ground would not be sure enough for me.

Comment on this

Might I say in respect of the day-to-day administration of State and semi-State bodies that the Taoiseach was asked some time ago whether he would be prepared to consider setting up machinery under which these boards and companies could be brought more under the control of the Oireachtas. On that occasion he stated that, if there was a desire expressed by the House in that regard, he would give consideration to making time available for discussion on the activities of such boards. The test of the matter will lie in what is the first question asked.

We had the experience of other boards being set up here, and when a certain line was taken by the Minister on the very first question put down, that line was followed up afterwards and very reasonable questions that should have been allowed were excluded from the Order Paper. The Minister should give very careful examination to the first question in order that the widest possible scope be allowed for subsequent questions. It is very easy for the Minister, or the next Minister, to say a precedent has been established and that the information cannot be made available.

Comment on this

This section says:

Every debt and other liability (including unliquidated liabilities arising from torts or breaches of contract) which immediately before the transfer date was owing and unpaid or has been incurred and is undischarged by the Committee shall, on the transfer day, become and be the debt or liability of the Board and shall be paid or discharged by and may be recovered from or enforced against the Board accordingly.

The Minister made some passing reference to this already. Can he guarantee to the House that every effort will be made to discharge any debts in existence before we transfer the obligation to the new board of meeting any expenses incurred?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That every effort will be made?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That the Exchequer will meet its commitments before the transfer of the new liabilities to the board?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Certain liabilities have been entered into in support of dairy produce of one kind or another during the last 12 months and certain liabilities may be entered into in respect of these things between now and the setting up of the board. May we assume that none of these will be transferred as a liability to the new board?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:—

In page 25, line 36, before "Every" to insert "In".

This is a drafting amendment to clarify the wording of the section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 26, to delete subsection (10).

This subsection is unnecessary because it is already provided for more comprehensively in the Customs Act, 1956, that every person who exports or imports goods in contravention of any enactment or any statutory instrument shall be guilty of an offence under the Customs Act, for which severe penalties, including forfeiture, are prescribed. Investigation of similar offences under the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Acts has hitherto been conducted by the Revenue Commissioners and it is not proposed to depart from that practice.

Comment on this

Could the Minister tell us what is meant by "milk products"? Does it mean milk, cheese and chocolate crumb.

Comment on this

They are all defined in Section 2.

Comment on this

There is no prohibition on the export of any of these things at present?

Comment on this

There is an export prohibition for quality control, not for quantity.

Comment on this

There is control on creameries in regard to the quality of butter exported but that does not apply to any ordinary individual transaction?

Comment on this

The Minister has this power at present and it is being given to him again under this section? It is the Minister for Agriculture?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I do not know the effect of this. It is legislation by reference. Could the Minister give us a short indication?

Comment on this

This section is complementary to Section 1 of the Bill and is referred to in detail in the notes on previous legislation which have been circulated with the Bill. Section 1 enables the provisions of the Bill to be brought into operation gradually, while this section makes corresponding provision in regard to suspension, by Order of the Minister, of the parts of the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Acts which are being replaced in the Bill.

Comment on this

What is the meaning of the section?

Comment on this

Briefly, its effect is to treat creamery butter consigned to the Board as butter consigned for export so that quality control, as prescribed under the Dairy Produce Act, 1924, for export of butter, will apply.

Comment on this

This is the usual provision, is it not?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this