We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–122 of 251. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

A number of backbenchers of the Fianna Fáil Party must be feeling in need of sympathy as a result of the Budget introduced by the Minister for Finance. I am perfectly certain that it is a great disappointment to them. Their speechlessness during the Minister's speech was very striking. Of course, there was the usual little applause at the end. If they had not applauded, they would be regarded as deserting their officer in the front line of trenches.

Comment on this

It was hearty applause.

Comment on this

The Minister invited the House to examine the Budget in relation not only to this year but to the entire four years and to examine the activities of the Government. The Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Dillon, clearly demonstrated in no uncertain way to any thinking person how serious the situation has become since Fianna Fáil came into office in 1957. He referred to the increase in taxation, the removal of the food subsidies, the increase in emigration, the reduction—notwithstanding all the ballyhoo—of the number of people in employment in every activity. As he said, the Government's own published figures showed that there were 51,000 fewer people employed in February of 1961 than there were in February, 1957. If the people who emigrated had remained the unemployment figure, about which the Government and the back benchers boast, would be well above the 100,000 mark, where it was in 1957.

The Minister for Transport and Power went down to Longford and declared that it was an excellent Budget, that Fine Gael were insulting the intelligence of the people when they said it was not a good Budget. If I were present at that Fianna Fáil meeting in Longford I would have agreed with the Minister that it was a good Budget for some people, and I want Deputies to examine it from that point of view.

It is true that a reduction in income tax is very welcome to everybody who pays it but it must be remembered that there is almost £1 million additional taxation imposed on tobacco and cigarettes to pay for portion of that 1/6d. per week that the old age pensioner and other social assistance recipients are to get while benefits in the region of £120 per annum or more than £2 a week are secured by other people. Any Deputy can figure it out for himself. The Minister has given relief to the extent of 8d. in the pound on income tax and has pushed up the surtax limit. When you add those together, you get the figure which enables the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Transport and Power to declare that this a good Budget.

The Budget is like a loaf; it is the duty of the Government to distribute that loaf fairly amongst our citizens. It is not fair that one person should get a large slice and that a poorer person should get a crumb. While it is desirable to give relief in respect of income tax, this Budget gives those people much more than it gives the old age pensioner. As the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Dillon, said here, quoting the President of the United States, a Government who do not protect the poor cannot very long protect the rich. This Government have not taken the steps they should have taken to compensate for the increased cost of living imposed upon our people by the removal of the food subsidies on which, over the four years they have been removed, the Governmen have saved £28 million—£7 million a year. Nevertheless, they think everybody should be delighted with that little relief they have given.

I do not know exactly what the Government are playing at. I admit that it is reasonable for a Minister for Finance to accept the figure of 5 per cent for over-estimation in the Book of Estimates, and five per cent. upon £140 million, as in the Book of Estimates, is £7 million per annum. Of course Fianna Fáil have never accepted the responsibility for dealing with the finance of the country as they would spend their own money and as if it were their own business they were handling. There is an obligation upon a Government and the Minister for Finance to discharge their obligations to the nation as they would discharge obligations to their business associates or to their own family, to exercise care and eliminate waste. It is not necessary for me to say where that waste is but I have had experience of it while I was a Minister. Savings can be effected by prudence but I do not see very much evidence of that prudence in the present administration.

The Leader of the Opposition also pointed out clearly that this was not the only Budget, that there were several budgets each year. We have had budgets in respect of E.S.B. charges, increased bus fares and so on. It is clear that these are imposts the people are not able to carry. I do not intend to go over the proposed expenditure on Leinster House, Arus an Uachtaráin or any other building but I invite Deputies to examine the money that is being expended on new buildings for the Office of the Taoiseach. Such projects may give temporary employment but, if employment is the objective, I submit there are better means of providing it.

Again, the Minister for Transport and Power was shouting about the giving of 4/- a ton for the transport of lime. One would think this was the first time that was done. The truth is that this is only the restoration of what they took away some years ago. Perhaps they could be encouraged to go a step further and restore Section B of the Land Project and the Local Authorities (Works) Act. They need not say that is an appeal coming only from Fine Gael. It was hard pressed at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis and I do not believe there was a single Fine Gael supporter at the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis.

It is true the tickets were issued, and that anyone who wished could attend, but I do not believe anyone accepted that invitation. I assert that the members of the cumann who moved that resolution were Fianna Fáil to the backbone. Why did they draft that resolution? Because they knew that Section B of the Land Project had been of great service to the country because it involved capital expenditure of a productive nature.

There are 51,000 fewer people employed here. I wonder how many Fianna Fáil Deputies consider what effect that has upon our economy? I should like to ask the Minister did he read the report of Messrs. Rank (Ireland) Ltd., the flour millers, in which the chairman announced that the fall in the consumption of flour was catastrophic because 51,000 fewer people were employed and because over 200,000 people left the country in four years. That affects not only the flour milling industry but the boot manufacturers and every other section of the community. It causes a reduction in our wealth, but no effort is being made to deal with that problem.

I should like to remind the Fianna Fáil Government that, in his inaugural address, the President of the United States said more than what Deputy Dillon quoted. He said also that it was now within the power of man to abolish poverty and he then went on to say that it was now within the power of man to abolish the universe. My interpretation of that phrase is that it is now within the power of a Government to abolish poverty and therefore a Government should so adjust themselves. A Government can spend thousands of millions of pounds on the provision of nuclear weapons which are gone for all time when exploded—they are pure waste— whereas if even half of that financial energy were put to the abolition of poverty, one can imagine the benefits which would accrue to the world in general. When a Government can spend large sums of money on that type of development and cannot make money available to provide employment, something is radically wrong.

We all know that it is the responsibility of this Government or of any Irish Government—and this has also been asserted by the Bishop of Cork, to whom I take off my hat—to deal with the problem of emigration. That problem can be dealt with by creating a situation in which people can get a decent livelihood at home. No one need tell me that emigration is quite common, even in England. The Minister for Transport and Power said in Longford that people migrate from the rural areas in England and in other parts of the world. I assert that 90 per cent. of the people who emigrate, or migrate from those rural areas to the cities, are compelled to do so by economic stress. I defy contradiction from any Fianna Fáil Deputy on that fact.

Comment on this

I contradict the Deputy straight away.

Comment on this

Apparently Deputy Booth has a thorough knowledge of rural Ireland when he says he will contradict me right away. That is in keeping with the assertion of the Minister for Transport and Power but, of course, no one accepts that a person like the Minister for Transport and Power knows anything about rural Ireland. I invite Deputy Booth and any Fianna Fáil Deputy from rural Ireland to have a survey carried out in any parish along the Shannon or west of it as to the numbers who have migrated or emigrated from those areas. When the figures of the recent census become available—of course it will be too late then for argument on this Budget—they will show whether or not my assertions about emigration are true.

The only matter then at issue is: for what reason do they emigrate? I assert boldly and without fear of contradiction, knowing rural Ireland as I do, that no one can expect a farmer's son to work for his parents on a farm to-day for less than £1 a week when he can buy a ticket for 50/- and get £12 a week across the water. He will not do that and that is his set of economic circumstances. Deputy Booth may go with the Minister for Transport and Power and tell these country people that they should remain at work when there is work for them, but they do not say that there should be compensation for their labour. If there were adequate compensation at home for the labour of the Irish boy and girl, they would never leave the country.

There are many other points which I should like to stress but I do not want to delay the House. I resent, and I categorically deny, the assertion of the Government and the Minister for Transport and Power that the two inter-Party Governments to which I had the honour to belong left a mess or left debts behind them. That hoary old canard was used time after time but the former Taoiseach admitted in Mallow that we left the remnants of £12,000,000. When I said to him across the floor that it was only tailors' clippings he became very indignant. The truth of the matter is that the national income was raised under that. Everybody should remember that the 10/- for the calf's skin was raised to £20 for the calf.

I want to remind the House that on the introduction of the September Budget of 1947, the then Tánaiste declared that we were facing the bleakest of bleak years. What he did was to impose an additional £10 million in taxation on the people in that Budget. We came into office in the following year and removed that penal taxation. Fianna Fáil never forgave us for that. Every one of them, from the present President down to the most insignificant backbencher, wants to demonstrate and prove beyond yea or nay that we should not have reduced that taxation, that we should not have reduced the price of butter and the other commodities. The Minister for Transport and Power puts it that the inter-Party Government got into office on that first occasion on the plea that everybody could have easy living and that they could squander the savings of the war years.

Comment on this

On several conflicting pleas.

Comment on this

If Deputy Loughman is satisfied that on this occasion the Minister for Finance has been helpful to him and his colleagues in any way, I should like him to get up and say how he has been helpful. We know that notwithstanding the fact that the Minister for Defence got a memorandum from the Federation of Old I.R.A. in plenty of time for the Budget there was not a word about it. There is no indication of Government policy relating to them in this Budget —good, bad or indifferent. Does that mean that the Government have other plans? Does it mean that we are to have another Budget? What exactly is the line that this Government are taking? I should like to know because it is not clear from this Budget what their intentions are.

Over the years the inter-Party Government held office and, I must say, in the time of Fianna Fáil from 1951 to 1954, the national income steadily increased. The records are there. It increased every year and even when we come to the serious year of 1956 there is only one thing that is wrong. The inter-Party Government then did not take into account any political considerations but they did what was necessary, and they did it well in the interests of the country. The situation that arose at that time was outside the control of any Government and Fianna Fáil benefited by our action.

Do you think they thanked us? Not they. They did the exact opposite. The results of the action taken then were for the benefit of the whole country but the inter-Party Government got no thanks for any of it. The then Minister for Finance, my colleague Deputy Sweetman, did get a kind of lefthanded compliment because it was he who introduced the exemption from taxation on exports. He also got a sort of lefthanded thanks for the introduction of the Prize Bonds but do you think he, or any of us, got any recognition from any of the Fianna Fáil speakers down the country? Not they. Anything to our discredit that they could say down the country they said it was vigour, well knowing that their statements were not in accordance with the facts.

When the backbenchers of Fianna Fáil and their followers down the country—I do know they are getting fewer—examine this Budget they will be very displeased with the Government and with a Minister for Finance who boasted in the Seanad that he was going to give a great Budget. If this is a great Budget, it means that the mountain of Fianna Fáil has gone into labour and produced a mouse. This Budget is a fake, from start to finish. It places an additional impost upon the smoker and is something that is unrealistic. It means that Fianna Fáil are determined to go ahead with their wildcat schemes and to spend the people's money without any regard to the outcome.

Comment on this

Listening to Deputy MacEoin I really thought we were back in 1957. In that year, when Deputy MacEoin was a member of a Government which handed over control to Fianna Fáil things were really bad here. Deputy MacEoin has said that we were uncharitable and we never gave the inter-Party Government credit for anything. I am sure that he, as an honourable Deputy, will give us credit for putting this country back on its feet. In 1957 things were so bad in my constituency that no loans could be procured for 350 houses which had been built. Tradesmen were leaving their employment, unemployment was rife and things were never so bad. When I hear Deputies opposite trying to misrepresent the wonderful work done by the present Minister for Finance in putting the country on its feet I think there is very little honesty in politics.

They are crying about the food subsidies. I can assure this House that the food subsidies would never have been removed by Fianna Fáil were it not that they found that the financial position was so bad that they had to do something to save the country. This country was completely on the rocks in 1957. The people gave Fianna Fáil an overwhelming majority to get rid of the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this

No, to give them 100,000 jobs.

Comment on this

I remember asking questions here during the last days of the inter-Party Government in relation to S.D.A loans, broken promises and all the rest. To-day the country is on its feet again. Even Fine Gael supporters say it would be a pity if the inter-Party Government got in again and destroyed all the good work the present Ministry are doing.

The Leader of the Opposition was crying about the poor. Any social advances we have made have been made by Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil always gave something to the widows and orphans, the old age pensioners and pensioners generally so long as the economy could afford it. We shall continue to do so. I heard the last speaker speak about what happened in 1947. The present Taoiseach told the inter-Party Government, when they took office in 1948: "We have given you over the country in a good financial condition. We hope you will give it back to us in the same condition." But we did not get it back in the same condition.

We had to introduce the tough Budget of 1952 to save the country from economic ruin. It was hard for Deputies to sit behind their Minister for Finance introducing such a Budget, because we do not want to see our constituents hurt in any way. However, we had to put the interests of our country before our personal interests. At great sacrifice to everybody, the country was put back on a sound financial basis. The last speaker said we did not give the inter-Party Government credit for the good things they did. We supported them in anything they introduced for the benefit of the country. But they cannot claim that their general management of the country's finances could be praised.

Under Fianna Fáil this country has advanced economically and is continuing to do so. We are going more and more into export markets. We are creating employment for our people in industry. Our adverse trade balance has been redressed. A balanced Budget has again been introduced, which will help the poorer sections of the community. The reduction of income tax is welcomed. Farmers have been given increased subsidies and there are further aids such as the relief of agricultural rates—all with the view of helping farmers to create employment. I heard a man from my own part of the country, which I left 40 years ago, talk about people leaving the land. I come from old farming stock, one of a family of nine. Only one remained on the farm; the other eight had to leave. Listening to Opposition speakers, one would imagine that it was only during the last few years people left the land in Ireland. In small farms there was always only room for one. The remainder had to go elsewhere and, perhaps, emigrate if they could not get employment at home. I should like to have some constructive criticism from the Opposition on how we can improve the position in rural Ireland. We are trying to create industries in the towns to employ the people who have to leave the land. If there are two or three children in a family, you cannot divide a small holding amongst them. We have faced up to these problems and are doing our best to solve them.

We should consider all that has been achieved during the past four years. People who have money are not afraid to invest it in the country because they know they have a Government that will support them. The amount of money invested in industry here in the past four years is heartening. We are now on the road to prosperity. The Financial Times and other well-known conservative papers, which had not anything good to say about us in the past, now say that the Republic is doing well. That trend will put the country back on its feet. I appeal to the Leaders of the Opposition to give us credit for having done a jolly good job since we took over from them. I know they have to defend their policies as best they can, but what we need is constructive, rather than destructive criticism. In conclusion, I would again compliment the Minister for Finance on the very good job he has done during the past four years. May he long continue the good work.

Comment on this

Last week I listened to two speeches on the Budget, one from the Government side and one from the Opposition. Deputy Booth quoted the Chairman of the Bank of Ireland as saying our economy was expanding. He said bank deposits had increased and that the National Loan was over subscribed. I suppose a man in Deputy Booth's position believes that the prosperity of the country can be measured on that basis and that the credit for such prosperity is rightly due to the Fianna Fáil Government. Deputy McLaughlin's maiden speech followed. He gave a different outlook on the whole position. Speaking about his constituency, he said that though bank deposits were increasing, the number of families were decreasing.

Deputy P. J. Burke said it was not extraordinary that a certain proportion of people were leaving the land. He said it had always happened and that it would continue to happen, particularly on small farms. He pointed out that of the nine members of his family, only one remained on the land. I can assure Deputy Burke that although that was the case up to some years ago, it is not so any more. The entire nine members of the family would now have to leave and close down the farm. I paid a visit to Sligo-Leitrim during the by-election and saw houses closed down and the daffodils growing wild with nobody to look after them.

I would again point out, for Deputy Booth's benefit, that though bank deposits are growing, the numbers of young men and women left in the country are decreasing. Bank deposits will never make up for the loss of population. The Taoiseach, in his speech on the Budget, outlined what he called the three main objectives behind the Budget this year. The first was the improvement in the position of the social welfare class which he said was five per cent. I challenge the Taoiseach to say whether the improvement in that class could have been any less than five per cent.

While the Government improved the social welfare class by five per cent. they improved the conditions for the £4,000 a year class by 15 per cent. Last year, a person with an income of over £4,000 paid £1,283 2s. This year, he will pay £1,121 16s. 4d., a reduction of £161 5s. 8d., or approximately 15 per cent. From those figures must it not be taken that the Government could do no less than improve the benefits to the social welfare class by five per cent? Consequently the first objective of the Budget was a very poor effort.

The second objective was to help the farmers. Under the Budget, there is an increase of £1 per ton on the subsidy for potash fertiliser in the coming year. The Government have restored the lime subsidy. While that is welcomed, I think that subsidy, provided by the inter-Party Government, should never have been touched. Yet Fianna Fáil took more than £200,000 of it away. The Government now know that the reduction in the consumption of ground limestone in the past few years made it imperative that the subsidy we provided when we were in Government should be fully restored. Instead of cutting that subsidy, the Government should have, in fact, increased it.

There has been a lot of talk about the extra grants for cow byres. Under the inter-Party Government, there was a double grant under this heading, but that was removed by the present Government. Deputy Booth made what I regard as a very important statement and, mind you, the Deputy is a responsible member of Fianna Fáil. This statement will have very far-reaching effects on the policy towards the farmers of this country. He said agriculture is no longer the mainstay of this country. I believe Deputy Booth was reflecting the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government—a policy under which the Government, during the past few years, allowed the import of raw cane sugar to the detriment of the country's beet-growers.

The Taoiseach told us that the sugar factories were working to full capacity and that they could not handle one more acre of beet. What do we find this year? After Fianna Fáil had lost the referendum and several by-elections, we now find that contracts are being given for the production of 12,000 extra acres of beet, although there has been no extension of the sugar factories since the Taoiseach said they were incapable of handling another acre of beet. However, this is not any great encouragement to any small farmer who, due to his natural rotation of crops, had to give up the growing of beet for even a single season. Any such farmer will never get back his contract.

During the term of office of the inter-Party Government, all out efforts were designed to produce from the land of this country all the coarse grain required for feeding, and imports of maize were prohibited until January and February each year. During the past year, maize is being freely imported, without any embargo, and at the same time, the price of feeding barley has been reduced. If they had the interests of the farmers at heart, the Government would have increased the price of feeding barley in order to give small farmers the necessary encouragement to produce from their own land sufficient coarse grain to feed all their livestock. There is a considerable amount of goods which we import for processing here which could be produced at home. Here is something we can produce from our land. Instead of encouraging that production the Government have reduced the price and it may be reduced again.

In 1956, at the Carlow-Kilkenny by-election, Fianna Fáil promised that if their candidate were elected and their Government returned to office in the following year they would restore the price of wheat to 82/6d. They have reduced the price each year. Even this year, there has been a reduction, not in the actual price per barrel but in reference to moisture and other factors. That indicates that Fianna Fáil do not regard agriculture as the mainstay of our economy.

The inter-Party Government regarded agriculture as the mainstay of our economy. They were out to help it to produce more and to find markets. I do not blame the present Minister for Agriculture for the present state of affairs because it is the result of the policy of a Dublin-minded Government who feel that, if they start an industry here and an industry there, we do not have to bother about agriculture. We welcome the fact that a number of new industries have been started over the past four years, but thousands of industries have been closed down in that time because the home of every small farmer is an industry. Every small farmer's home shut down means another industry gone out of the country.

Since this Government came into office, 50,000 fewer people are working on the land. Now, in their last months in office, the Taoiseach has promised at a meeting in Dublin that they will look into the economy of the small farmer and put him in a position to gain as much from his small farm as the industrial worker will gain in the city or town. Is it not a bit late in the day for the Taoiseach to come forward with that bright idea? It reminds me very much of his statement before the general election of 1957 that he would provide 100,000 jobs over a period of five years. The people can have as much confidence in his statement that he will bring up the economy of the small farmer as they had reason to have in his statement about the 100,000 jobs.

In his first year of office the Minister for Finance said in his Budget that he was providing £250,000 to study improved marketing arrangements for agricultural products. That was good. It seemed as if the Government intended to provide improved marketing arrangements for our agricultural sector. What do we find? In their last months of office, the Government have set up a Pigs and Bacon Marketing Board and a Milk Board both of which will hardly be functioning before they go out of office. Had they been set up four years ago, the people would by now know whether these Boards can, in fact, provide improved markets for pigs and bacon and for milk products. It is obvious that the Government are just making promises.

The Taoiseach said Fine Gael are exploiting emigration for Party political purposes. He got a very quiet hearing. When Deputy J. A. Costello was speaking here as Taoiseach I recall the barracking he had to endure from the then Opposition. There was a different atmosphere when the Taoiseach spoke here last week. The Fine Gael Party are not exploiting emigration. Is it not our duty to draw attention to the very large number of men and women leaving our shores? Some of them may go to see life or to find a new life but most of them go because they are forced out. Deputy McLaughlin mentioned that there are great reports in the newspapers about the landings of our jet planes and the tourists who come here but that there are no reports about the boats full of young emigrants, which are leaving our shores.

In the past three years there has been an increase of £3½ million in rates. Practically every official has received a substantial increase in salary, including the professional personnel. The ordinary people do not begrudge them the increases which are due to them just as to everybody else but what hope have the people of paying rates to meet those increases if the prices of what they are selling have been decreasing in the past four years? A prominent Fianna Fáil member of Kilkenny County Council said, in effect: "It is all right for Ministers to tell us an agreement has been reached between the Managers' Association and the Officials' Association that an increase will come into effect on a certain date but what have the people got to meet those increases?" All they have are reductions in the price of feeding barley and wheat over the years. Each year there is a further reduction.

How can the people have any heart when the rates are going up each year? Those counties which do not increase the rates receive a letter from the Minister pointing out, for example, that twenty-two counties have given the increases and asking them if they do not propose to do likewise. There is no objection to improving the standard of living if the farmers get an opportunity to meet these expenses.

There was no reference by the Minister to the cost of living, which has increased by about £8 million in the past four years. Our people have paid £32 million more for food in the past four years. Recently in the Seanad the Minister said this Budget would be a good Budget. People felt that the price of butter which increased from 3/10d. to 4/7d. would surely be reduced. Is there not an encouragement to our people to go to Britain where they can buy our butter for 2/8d. a lb. rather than stay here and have to pay 4/7d. a lb. for it? They expected that flour, now selling at 7/10d. to 8/- and which was selling at 4/8d. when the present Government came in, would be reduced. That would be something. Bread, which was selling at 9d. per loaf when the Government took office, is now 1/3d. These are three things and it would have had a significant effect if the Government had devoted any surplus available to reducing the price of any of them.

If they had maintained the Local Authorities (Works) Act it would have helped to keep some people on the land. It is very hard for men to remain on county council work if they can work only six or seven months each year. If the Local Authorities (Works) Act had been operated it would mean a certain amount of work, even if only for a month or two in the winter, and would break their spell of unemployment. That Act was brought in by the inter-Party Government and, although the present Government had not the courage to repeal it, they withdrew funds from it.

Through higher taxes on lorries and commercial vehicles an extra £16,000 came to Kilkenny as an extra road grant. That money would normally be spent in summer time but had that £16,000 been given, and had the county surveyor and other officials been asked to put up some cases for winter work, it would have done something to relieve unemployment. But rather than give the money for winter employment the Government said it must be spent on roads and it will be spent in the summer time when there is a certain amount of work on the land available as well as on the roads. Had it been spent in the winter, it would have given encouragement to the people to stay on the land and it could have done a lot of good if used to relieve flooding in certain places.

The third point the Taoiseach made was in regard to the reduction of taxation on individuals. Any reduction in taxation, whether in income tax, surtax or any other tax, is appreciated by the people paying it. It will give them some relief but the main feature of this Budget is that there is no real incentive to production. I think the Government should go to the country and get the verdict from the people that they got in the case of the Referendum and then let the people decide what Government should be in power.

Comment on this

If a Budget is a good one, the proof of it must necessarily be a universally good reaction from the people. If such a reaction were available it would not be necessary for Government spokesmen, in trying to boost the Budget and explain their curious activities, to repeat the monumental untruth of 1957 that they were left with debts to pay. If this Budget and those that went before it sponsored by the present administration were the good Budgets that we are being asked to believe they were, it should not be necessary for Government spokesmen to call upon extraneous and untruthful arguments to boost up the situation which they alone say exists.

The position in regard to taxation generally is that over the last four years of Fianna Fáil administration we have had food taxes increased by £9,000,000, tobacco taxes by £3,000,000, beer taxes by £750,000 and rates by a further £3,000,000. All that adds up to an increased taxation which the people had to bear. It appears that the cost of administering for fewer and fewer is becoming greater and greater. We have a much reduced population and there is no appreciable reduction in any sphere of administrative activity. In fact, instead of the promises of the Minister in 1957 being realised, not alone the cost but the number of administrators has increased in the meantime. So much for the implementation of that early piece of wishful political thinking.

While there are reliefs in this Budget on the income tax, surtax and social welfare side, amounting to roughly £2,000,000, there is by way of extra taxation the sum of £3,000,000— £1,000,000 from tobacco and almost £2,000,000 from the imposition of additional duties by the conversion of existing levies, which were temporary, into permanent duties—not only converting them but increasing the percentage into something over twice as much in very many cases.

The levies were introduced to deal with a particular situation at that time, an economic situation with which the Government of the day had to deal. They dealt with it in a manner which was described by the present Taoiseach, then in Opposition, as "too little and too late". Over the years, the Minister for Finance in the present Government from time to time and to some extent has been keeping the word of his predecessor in acknowledging these levies as temporary measures, measures which would in time be abolished but when we come to what remained in this year we find that, principally those in relation to motor car parts, are converted rather than abolished. Prior to 1956 the House will recall that there was no duty on imported unassembled motor parts.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon.

Comment on this

Prior to 1956 certain motor parts unassembled came into the country duty free.

Comment on this

Very few.

Comment on this

Nevertheless, they came in duty free. A 15 per cent levy was imposed on them to meet that temporary upset in the economic situation. Now in respect of certain specific articles in relation to the motor trade that 15 per cent has been converted into a duty and increased to 37½ per cent. Some of them prior to 1956 did carry a duty of 33? per cent——

Comment on this

Practically all.

Comment on this

——plus the 15 per cent. Now they have benefited to the extent of 8½ per cent—the parts that were subject to that amount of duty—but by and large there is now an additional tax on those things that frequently must be replaced, again making no distinction between whether these particular parts are imported assembled or unassembled. That distinction is important because if those things go to prices that are beyond the capacity of the average importing wholesaler, it must inevitably result in unemployment, however small. Unemployment, however small, is something that should not result from the implementation of a Budget.

We are told by the other side of the House that this is a good Budget. In the quasi ex cathedra statement of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Justice, this Budget is the best of a series of good Budgets. I do not believe the people will accept that statement, even from that ex cathedra source. We have had the pronouncements of the Tánaiste and the Minister for Transport and Power outside this House. We have had Deputy Burke of County Dublin expatiating on the excellence of this most recent Budget today; in the annals of hypocrisy, his pronouncements must surely rank with the best since men came to record the utterances of public men.

Consider the situation with regard to the relief given in taxation and the increases given to those in receipt of social welfare. Translated into £.s.d., the relief given to the old age pensioner, and it is the maximum relief, is £3 18s. per year. The relief given to a person in receipt of £2,000 per annum is £16 13s. 4d. per year.

Comment on this

I wish the interjecting Deputy from Cork would, on the infrequent occasions on which he makes contributions in this House, make himself clear.

Comment on this

The Deputy's Party reduced the old age pension by 1/-.

Comment on this

I will give the history of old age pensions. I will not suffer interruptions from the Deputy from Cork. I will tell the Deputy all about old age pensions in the shortest possible time. I will tell Deputy Galvin —I have just remembered his name; he speaks so infrequently it is difficult to recognise him—all about old age pensions. The old age pension in 1948, after 16 years of Fianna Fáil administration, stood at 10/- basic, with an urban addition from poor rate relief of 5/- and a rural addition of 2/6d. That was in 1948 after 16 years of Fianna Fáil.

On the coming into power of Deputy Costello's administration in that same year, the urban and rural rates of poor relief were abolished and old age pensions were increased to 17/6d. That increase of 7/6d. was the first increase after 16 years of Fianna Fáil administration, 16 long years in which absolutely nothing was done about old age pensions. In 1951, there was again an increase under Deputy Costello's administration. Another 2/6d. was given, bringing the old age pension up to 20/- per week.

Comment on this

The proposal was made but no legislation was passed.

Comment on this

Whether or not legislation was passed, it was certainly introduced. The intention was to grant the increase.

Comment on this

Not all the mock suavity of the Minister for Finance, supported by his interjectors, will put me off the course of my argument in outlining the history of Fianna Fáil in relation to old age pensions.

Comment on this

I was merely correcting the Deputy.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil increased the old age pension in 1952 by 1/6d. That was the time they brought in their nefarious Budget, a Budget which put upon the pensioners of this country a burden it was beyond their capacity to bear but which Fianna Fáil evidently believed could be made bearable by an increase of 1/6d. per week. In 1955, again under Deputy Costello's administration, the old age pension was increased from the Fianna Fáil level of 21/6d. to 24/-. That increase was given simultaneously with a reduction of 5d. in the lb. of butter.

In 1957, Fianna Fáil once more increased the old age pension by 1/-per week bringing it to 25/-; in 1959, they brought it up to 27/6; and in 1960, they increased it to 28/6. This year, they have increased it to 30/-. All those increases in the past four years have coincided with the removal of subsidies, with the increase in the price of butter and milk and flour and bread. None of that matches up to their boast in relation to social services. Over the past few years, by reason of either Government or ministerial directive—I take it ministerial directive has the approval of Government—social welfare officers, in my constituency at any rate, have been engaging in most exhaustive searches into people's means and, rightly or wrongly, as a result of that they have, in many cases, reduced old age pensions—wrongly, in my opinion. The net effect of all this has been to nullify and negative the measly increases given in the four previous years.

The people are not duped. I am talking now of social welfare services generally and not just of pensions alone. The social welfare benefits with regard to disability allowances and home assistance laid down under Deputy Costello's administration have not been altered one iota by the present Government. There has been no move to improve the lot of these people, except in isolated cases through public representations.

If this Budget and its predecessors are the wonderful success we are asked now to believe they are, how is it the situation has deteriorated so seriously in relation to employment? In 1955, in employment other than agriculture, there were 726,000 people employed. In 1960, after the operation of these good Budgets, in employment in the same sphere, there were only 699,000, a decrease of 27,000. What is the explanation? It is a figure of such really alarming proportions that some explanation must be given to the House and to the people. I am sure the Minister will explain when he comes to reply. The overall picture as disclosed by statistics issued by the Taoiseach's Department shows that there are 51,000 fewer people in employment now than there were in 1957. By way of contrast, as between mid-February, 1957, and mid-February, 1961, the cost of living has risen by 12 points from 107.7 to 119.

After years of denial and after years of the first enunciation of his theory that the success of a Government was to be measured by unemployment and emigration, we now have the Taoiseach at last admitting that there is emigration. In his speech on this most recent Budget, he concedes that the average outflow is in the region of 40,000. Figures available from British sources, of people from this country applying for insurance cards for the first time, would certainly seem to be at variance with these figures now conceded by the Taoiseach.

On the basis of our general knowledge of the numbers who go to America and other countries, coupled with the actual figures we have from Great Britain, it is safe to say that, between 1957 and 1961, over 200,000 people left this country. Is that the result of good Budgets? Is that the result of the policy that seemed to have as one of its cornerstones: "Wives, get your husbands out to work"? Is that the result of another part of the same edifice on which was printed "100,000 jobs"? The most pathetic thing about that promise, made by the Taoiseach, of 100,000 jobs, is not the fact that it was promised but the fact that he has denied that he ever so promised. From the point of view of public morality, that is probably the most pathetic thing that has taken place in this country for a very long time.

Deputy Burke of County Dublin seemed satisfied to excuse emigration on the basis that every member of a family has to go except one. That is not necessarily true. It is not necessary for that particular idea to be fully inplemented that every member of the family should have to go and that houses should be closed and land lie fallow, that no habitation should exist at all; that marriage rates should decline and averages in rural schools be reduced by half and in some cases schools should have to be closed, all in a very short time.

Deputy Burke seems to think that what we on this side of the House say about emigration is not true. I was present at a meeting organised by the local clergy and people in a parish in my own constituency not later than Sunday last. It was convened in order to see what could be done to relieve a very depressed situation in that area. It was attended by the parish priest, both of his curates, Deputy Calleary and myself. The parish priest made this rather startling and frightening announcement, that in accordance with what is obviously Church practice, he had taken a census of the families in his parish in 1956 and they then numbered 744. He took a similar census in 1961 and the number of families was 100 fewer. In one parish in my constituency, there are 100 families fewer than there were when this Government took office in 1957.

Is that a reaction from good Budgets or from good administration? Let me say at once that there will always be a certain amount of emigration but not emigration of family units which has now become the pattern, and a very serious one. Side by side with that, there is what one would expect : the fact which was also announced by the parish priest—and if the people on the Government benches, the Minister or those supporting him, want to check this, all they have to do is to ask my colleague, Deputy Calleary, who was present—that in the year 1960 and up to date in that parish, which four years ago boasted 744 families and which has now 100 fewer, there was one marriage.

I wonder if all these things mean what Deputy Burke tries to imply? Are they, as Government spokesmen outside solemnly aver and as the Minister for Finance asks the House to believe, indications or proof—whatever you like—of this wonderful prosperity which we are now allegedly enjoying? As a result of this Government's fiscal policy, prices have gone up. Until quite recently, speaking for the rural community, the prices of things they had to sell were depressed. That may have been due to a variety of factors but I would say that one of the factors was that this Government wasted so much valuable time, at a vital period, in legislating for matters that were of no great ultimate concern to the economic prosperity, that they lost what might have been gained on outside markets while others were consolidating their position.

We hear a lot about housing. From 1954 to 1957, 29,000 houses were built and under this wonderful régime, from 1957 to 1961, only 19,000 have been built. Some approach will have to be made to deal with the rural situation. At the moment, a sort of survey is going on in relation to housing, whether they are sanitary or habitable and whether people require new houses. From what I gather, the people do not seem to have a great deal of faith in this because they feel that once again the activities of public officials are merely an indication that an election is about to take place.

Mark you, when we come to regard emigration in all its facets, while economics may be the reason for this great exodus, I would say that a great deal of it is due to the fact that people have become despondent and depressed, have become weary of the unfulfilled promises, have abandoned hope not only in the immediate future but in their future for all time and have locked up and cleared out.

I was reading recently The Western People of Saturday, 22nd April, 1961. For the further amusement of the Minister for Finance and of Deputy Galvin, who appears to be contributing to the amusement——

Comment on this

We were not listening to you at all.

Comment on this

——I shall quote from this paper.

Comment on this

We have a right to a little joke, anyway.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance, Deputy Galvin and all the members of the Fianna Fáil Party are quite free to have their jokes and their laughs but they are not free in conscience or in whatever patriotic content might be attributed to them, to laugh and joke at the spectacle of emigration from rural Ireland. Lest they are running short of material for laughter at our people leaving our country, I will give them a little more now.

The National Farmers' Association held a meeting of the North Mayo Executive at Ballycastle in County Mayo to consider the whole situation there. The meeting was held in March last. They were holding the meeting in a parish that is next to the parish about which I have given the details that we received on Sunday afternoon last and it is the parish next again to the parish in which Deputy Calleary lives, so that if the Minister for Finance and Deputy Galvin want to rid themselves of doubts as to the authenticity of the description of the situation that exists there all they have to do is to ask their colleague Deputy Calleary. I quote from The Western People:—

Even the members of the Farmers' Association were shocked at the change. One two-teacher school had been closed, a school which forty years ago had an average of over sixty children, and the average of the other schools had dropped to half. From Glenurla to Kilbride forty doors had closed and forty happy, self-supporting families had disappeared never to return. It was not a case of a deserted village, but deserted villages and a deserted parish. Once upon a time no Mayo team paraded Croke Park without a Ballycastle man among its number; 20 years ago the parish annexed the Mayo senior championship; to-day the first time for two generations the parish is unable to field a team. Since Christmas forty youths had emigrated to England looking for work. The situation was considered by the meeting to be very grave and the unanimous decision was that if this decay were to be stopped the parish must unite, regardless of creed, politics or personal interests.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us who made that speech?

Comment on this

That is not a speech. That is the review of the situation by the National Farmers' Association at their executive meeting in Ballycastle, County Mayo, as reported in The Western People of Saturday, 22nd April, 1961.

Comment on this

Sent in by some supporter of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

Very good. If that is what Deputy Gilbride thinks of reviews carried out at a meeting of the National Farmers' Association, at which were present all shades of political opinion, including that held by himself, let him talk to the National Farmers' Association.

Comment on this

I question it very much.

Comment on this

I am sure the National Farmers' Association will pay as much attention to Deputy Gilbride's utterances on this as the people of Sligo-Leitrim did to his utterances in the recent by-election and to his utterances in regard to proportional representation.

Comment on this

They believed me.

Comment on this

The most significant part of that review is where they say that "if this decay were to be stopped the parish must unite regardless of creed, politics or personal interest." I can tell Deputy Gilbride, and I am sure Deputy Calleary will agree, that that was a parish in the constituency of North Mayo where the people all down the years had been predominantly supporters of Fianna Fáil. It is significant that when they try to arrest decay they are prepared to depart from the time-honoured formula of Fianna Fáil, that they are prepared to abandon Party, abandon personal interests, abandon political viewpoints to work together for the good that they thought would be done by the people whom they had supported down the years. I, for one, welcome that change. I do not mind which way they vote in future as long as they vote in a manner that is indicative of clear thinking, that is indicative of their desire to play a full part in the interests of their parish and of their country and indicative that they are prepared at least to break the Soviet-like grip which was being held on them by the Fianna Fáil Party.

These are the results that I can speak about from my constituency of this Budget and its predecessors. The same situation exists not alone in the two parishes which I have described but in every other parish in all that area. Perhaps it is the policy of Fianna Fáil—many people are coming to believe that it is—that it is best to wipe out all of the people along the coasts of our country, that it is best to banish them to England and America so that social services need no longer be given to them, so that employment need no longer be provided for them, now that the people who originally promised them the sun, moon and stars, no longer need them, either through declining years or departure from the political scene. They have done well as a result of the promises but the people to whom they made the promises have left for ever, having lost hope, not alone in the great promisers but in the country and in any future Government.

Comment on this

I have listened to the debate in the last few days and have read a good deal of it. I have not heard one attempt made by any Opposition speaker to say what the Opposition would have done if they were in power. Not one attempt has been made to tell us what changes they would have made in this Budget. All their speeches were given to attacking the Budget, attacking the Minister and attacking everything that was done. Most of their time was taken up in talking about the food subsidies. The abolition of the food subsidies seems to have been the worst thing that ever happened. They never told us that they themselves were responsible and were prepared to take away the food subsidies.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Of course it is not true.

Comment on this

In 1956 the Coalition Government set up a committee called the Flour and Bread Committee. I am quoting from page 1 of the Report of that Committee which says:

On the 27th February, 1956, you appointed us as a Committee to investigate and report on:

(1) the production, distribution and selling costs (including a fair allowance for profit) of flour and bread;

There are two other items and it then continues:

By letter dated 17th May, 1956, you directed that our terms of reference did not require us to examine the question of subsidisation of flour and bread prices.

Comment on this

Yes. So what?

Comment on this

It is a clear indication that the Government at that time in the month of May had made up their minds that the subsidies on bread and flour had to go.

Comment on this

They made up their minds they were not going to be disturbed.

Comment on this

They instructed the Committee that they were not to take into consideration subsidies at all.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

It is plain they had their minds made up that flour and bread subsidies had to go.

Comment on this

How can you make that deduction? It may be plain to you.

Comment on this

Why were the terms of reference changed between the 27th February and the 17th May, 1956? The terms of reference are given here: "On the 27th February, 1956, you appointed us as a Committee to investigate and report on......the production, distribution and selling costs...... of bread and flour." Then this document continues: "By letter dated the 17th May, 1956, you directed that our terms of reference did not require us to examine the question of subsidisation of flour and bread prices." Why change the terms of reference?

Comment on this

They were told to mind their own business as far as the food subsidies were concerned.

Comment on this

It is as plain as a pikestaff——

Comment on this

I quite agree. It is as plain as a pikestaff.

Comment on this

——that the Government had made up their minds that the subsidies had to go. Still they come in here and talk about subsidies. They knew the position they were in, that there was no money there. We heard a great deal about the wonderful things they would do and could do. Then they broke up and cleared out rather than do what they knew they would have to do, remove the flour and bread subsidies.

Comment on this

Why did you say you would not do it?

Comment on this

We never did. If anyone said it, he did not realise at the time the position the country was left in, that when the Coalition had gone they had not a shilling.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Gilbride should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

There is no use in any ex-Minister trying to tell the people or the House that they did not decide to abolish the food subsidies. If the Minister for Finance looked up the minutes of that time——

Comment on this

I remember them.

Comment on this

He will find that there, unless the leaf is gone.

Comment on this
Deputies

Ah!

Comment on this

I am advising the Minister for Finance that if he looks up the minutes he will probably find that there.

Comment on this

The Deputy has mended his hand. He said "probably." He did not say that the first time.

Comment on this

I said he probably would find it. Deputies should not try to put anything into my mouth that I am not saying. This is irritating them a great deal. They can have their say and I am entitled to have my say. I say it is quite clear the decision was made to do away with the subsidies. Yet Deputies make the statements that have been made about those subsidies.

Deputy Lindsay mentioned the by-election in Sligo-Leitrim. He and his colleagues went down to Sligo-Leitrim with a little pamphlet giving the different prices of flour and other commodities for 1961 and 1956 respectively. Did they tell the people in Sligo-Leitrim that if they got into power they would reduce those commodities to that price again? Will they say it now? Will they say it before the election and, if they do, will they tell the people where they are going to get the money?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil said they would not do it in 1957.

Comment on this

Will you tell the people where you are going to get the money? I have the utmost sympathy for the members of the Opposition Front Bench going around the streets of Sligo, and around every town in Sligo-Leitrim, with this pamphlet dealing with the prices of bread and flour although they had no intention of reducing these prices.

Comment on this

Who had their sympathy when the election was over?

Comment on this

They did not see the real point of that pamphlet.

Comment on this

We will not know what the position is until we get back. There may not be a bob there.

Comment on this

The real point is that the people of Sligo-Leitrim did not believe them because they hawked that pamphlet from door to door during the by-election campaign a short time ago. Yet, Sligo-Leitrim gave Fianna Fáil 48 per cent. of the votes in comparison with 30 per cent. at the general election.

Comment on this

Nonsense. The Deputy is dealing with different totals.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil got 48 per cent. of the votes in comparison with 30 per cent. of the vote at the general election.

Comment on this

That is the second speech that was written after the declaration of the poll.

Comment on this

I have the utmost sympathy for the ex-Ministers who hawked that pamphlet around because they had the people laughing at them.

Comment on this

Who won the election?

Comment on this

Had you prepared your speech for the victory celebration as well as ordering the dinner?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Gilbride is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I knew what the voting would be and if the people of Ireland vote the same way as the people of Sligo-Leitrim voted——

Comment on this

——you will go out.

Comment on this

——there will be a very small bench helping the Opposition in the next Dáil. If this Budget had been introduced there would have been a different outcome but when the general election is over there will be a different dividing line for the Opposition. If they are able to fill those benches they will be lucky.

Comment on this

The Deputy is an expert at dividing lines.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick made great play with the question of emigration. We all regret emigration but in 1947 when Fianna Fáil left office emigration was at its lowest. If emigration was high within the past few years, it was due to the depression left after the Coalition Government in 1957 when there was not a shilling to pay housing grants, when every county council in Ireland had to stop paying supplementary grants, when building was practically at a standstill and when drainage was practically at a standstill. That is what brought about emigration, the depression resulting from the six years the Coalition were in power.

Comment on this

The people do not believe that.

Comment on this

There was mention also of E.S.B. charges. Deputy Blowick boasted that he went round to protest meetings held in connection with the E.S.B. charges. Imagine an ex-Minister of the Coalition Government that withdrew the subsidy from the E.S.B. in 1955, when the price of electricity went up by a far greater amount than it did the last time, going around to protest meetings about the price of electricity! Could duplicity go any further?

In regard to drainage, since Fianna Fáil came into power great progress has been made in this direction. The Moy drainage is in full swing as Deputy Lindsay, who lives near it, knows. When his Party were in power they sought to get other places to take precedence over it.

Comment on this

That is wrong. That cock will not fight.

Comment on this

I have the evidence in my bag.

Comment on this

Produce it. We are not interested in the Deputy's bag.

Comment on this

I can produce it. I produced it in Sligo-Leitrim and I can produce it again. Another area took precedence over it. That should not happen.

Comment on this

What one was that?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has voted £100,000 for the drainage of the Duff in Sligo-Leitrim.

Comment on this

The Corrib cannot have got ahead of the lot.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let us hear Deputy Gilbride.

Comment on this

The Government have the confidence of the people.

Comment on this

Unemployment and emigration.

Comment on this

The Coalition Government left office because they would not get a shilling of the people's money for their national loans. Every loan floated by the Fianna Fáil Government has been over-subscribed.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

We have the money to carry on capital development and that is what is making the Opposition so sore.

Comment on this

It does not happen to be true.

Comment on this

The Prize Bonds.

Comment on this

Is it untrue?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Not one of their loans was fully subscribed and every one of ours was over-subscribed. That is the test of the confidence of the people.

Comment on this

The test might be the interest rates you offer.

Comment on this

This is a good Budget and no moaning, groaning or banshee wailing by Deputy Lindsay or anyone else will change that. It is a good Budget and I have been told that by Deputy Lindsay's own supporters.

Comment on this

You are all meeting Fine Gael supporters. Deputy Burke met some too.

Comment on this

They are joining Fianna Fáil cumainn.

Comment on this

Will we hear Deputy Galvin's maiden speech next?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Deputy Galvin should make his maiden speech now.

Comment on this

I do not mind what the Opposition say because they know what I am saying is true. The funny thing is that they know it is a good Budget. They know the people have confidence in the Government, and they know that when the election comes the people will place the same confidence in them as they did in 1957. Does anyone on the Opposition benches think that the Government who cleared out in 1957, refused to face their responsibilities, handed over the country in debt, with an unbalanced Budget, will get back into office again? I sat in this House in 1948 when the Coalition Government were taking over, and I remember perfectly the words of the present Taoiseach when he said: "We are handing over a country which is sound financially and sound in every way; see to it that it is handed back in the same way."

Comment on this

Why did you get out then?

Comment on this

You went out yourself. You ran away.

Comment on this

I am asking why you got out in 1948?

Comment on this

You ran away yourself. The Coalition left an unbalanced Budget and debts unpaid. Today the country is sound financially. Do members of the Opposition think that the people are daft enough to put the Coalition in office again to undo the work done by the Fianna Fáil Government during the past four and a half years? If they do, they must have less sense than I thought. This is a good Budget. The people think it is a good Budget. They have confidence in this Government and after the election, I am afraid the Opposition will be very small.

Comment on this

I am afraid Deputy Gilbride's prophetic words will come true because I do not think some Deputies on the opposite side of the House realise how few of them will be returned after the next general election. Perhaps they will find out very shortly. They will find that some of their apparent confidence has been about as accurate as the statistical computations of the previous speaker.

I have been particularly amused by the Fianna Fáil attitude to this Budget. Quite apart from the foolish speech made by the Minister in the Seanad about a month ago, the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party towards this Budget in the House and in the country has altered radically since the Budget itself was introduced. Speaking in the Seanad, the Minister inferred that this would be a good Budget. Clearly he meant that it would be a popular Budget, a Budget which would give benefices to people. Frankly, I do not accept as proper the definition of good and bad which that connotes. In my view, there are tough Budgets, soft Budgets, in-between Budgets, appropriate Budgets and inappropriate Budgets.

Comment on this

And honest Budgets.

Comment on this

An appropriate Budget is, of course, an honest Budget. That goes without saying. I would have thought the Parliamentary Secretary would have accepted that. To call a Budget good or bad is a misnomer. When the Minister spoke in the Seanad about a month ago of a Budget to "grig" Fine Gael, obviously he was trying to conjure up to the minds of the people that he would introduce a Budget that would give away so many benefices that it would be popular with all classes of the people. Indeed, I shall give the Minister credit for this: when he sat down after making his speech he believed that such was the situation. Of course, it became perfectly clear immediately afterwards, when he saw the reaction, not only of the back benchers of his own Party but the reaction of the people down the country, that it was not in any sense a popular Budget at all. For reasons which I shall go into at a later stage, I do not think it was an appropriate Budget either. I do not think it was appropriate to our economic needs and on that ground as well, the Minister has failed in the task which faces every Minister for Finance at this time of the year.

Before I go on to discuss the individual items of the Budget, however, and the economic policy which governed its introduction this year, I want to refer to two things which are, I think, to put it mildly, unfortunate in a Budget speech. A Budget speech should be an analysis of the position as seen at the particular moment. It should be an objective analysis. I do not think this can be described as an objective analysis because in this Budget statement the Minister has rung the changes, by taking the record of a four-year period when it suited him and another record of a three-year period when it suited him. If it were an honest statement, the Minister would have decided to take either a four-year record or a three-year record and have stuck to it for his comparisons.

Instead of doing that, however, when it suited him he took a four-year period and where that did not suit him he took a three-year period. I think it would be more appropriate to have taken a four-year period all through. Even if the Minister would prefer to take the period from April 1958, and completely ignore his first year in office, I would accept that he could make comparisons on those lines, but to make them on a four-year basis when it suits him in one case and on a three-year basis when it suits him in another, is not the type of impartial analysis that we have properly come to expect from a Budget statement.

The second thing I do not understand, knowing from past experience how a Budget speech is made up, is the figure mentioned in Column 660 of the report of his speech by the Minister for Finance. In that he says:

Though some indirect taxes have been increased, the reductions have been more significant and the net effect has been a relief of some £1½ million a year in indirect taxation.

That is not true. That is the plain answer to it; it just is not true.

I have here before me the Tables issued explanatory of the Budgets in each of the last four years. I do not know whether, even in that, the Minister is using the three or four year period. In the years which we are considering now, I do not know whether he intended to include the year for which we are now budgeting or not. Let us be very clear where it goes. The position in respect of indirect taxation is set out consistently in each of the Tables explanatory of the Budgets in each year. In the one we got the other day, the net increase in indirect taxation is £855,000. For the year 1960 the Table explanatory of the Budget of that year shows an increase of £980,000 in tobacco duties and deductions of £1,590,000, or a net deduction of £610,000. In 1959 the position was that there was a deduction of £450,000, even counting as deductions certain special import levy changes to which I shall refer in a moment. In 1958 there was a deduction of £50,000. The total of all those figures is a change of £230,000. That is taking them over the four years.

The Minister for Finance refers to £1½ million. Even if we do not take this year into account, the figures are still wrong. If we take into account the figures for 1957-58, the position would not be a change of £230,000 but a change in the other way—of increased taxation of £2,600,000. Let us consider the matter whatever way the Minister likes to take it. I shall meet him and discuss it with him on a three year basis, a four year basis or including this year's Budget but let us be consistent and discuss all our economic problems and our revenue and taxation outturns in the same way. Let us not take one set of figures when it suits us and then jump and take another set of figures in another way. That is not the manner in which one should make an objective assessment of our position; that is not the method which should be used in making the Budget speech.

These changes in indirect taxation take no account of the special import levies being switched from capital to current account. I do not want to dwell overmuch on the manner in which the Minister, during the last general election, led the people to believe that those levies would be abolished when he got into office. It is an undeniable fact that the proceeds of the levies were switched from capital to current account and that doing so was a clear breach, not merely of the statements made by me at the time they were imposed, but also of the implications made by all the members of Fianna Fáil when they were speaking in that election campaign. The manner in which they have now been transferred into our permanent indirect taxation code merely means that it is going to make it more difficult for the country as a whole to face the situation which is about to break upon Europe with the merging of the Six and the Seven. I propose at a later stage to make some reference in regard to that and to the failure of the Government in that respect.

Before I go on to discuss those things, I think it is unfortunate that the Minister should jump from one comparison to another without using the same basis for each.

"It may not be appreciated by all the members of the Dáil, or the public who are discussing the Budget, that when this Government came to prepare it they had before them an estimate, presumably prepared by the Revenue Commissioners, that the revenue from taxation this year would exceed the revenue from taxation last year by £3,800,000. That was a very happy position for a Government to be in. They could face their problems, knowing that they would get £3,800,000 more tax revenue this year than in the previous year. That is the most significant and important fact in relation to this Budget."

I wonder does that strike any chord of memory in the Minister's mind? That statement is not mine except that I have changed the figure of £3,000,000 to £3,800,000. It is the speech of Deputy Lemass on the 5th May, 1955, when he was discussing the 1955 Budget, Col. 820, Vol. 150. Is it not significant that the figures, with the exception of £800,000 are somewhat the same? Then it was £3,000,000. Now it is £3,800,000 yet Deputy Lemass was then fulminating about it. It shows that the present Taoiseach, when he was Deputy Lemass, was not quite as responsible in his criticism as he would like people to believe.

The manner in which the Fianna Fáil Party have changed since the Budget was disclosed and since the Minister made his speech in the Seanad has been somewhat striking. Some people said here—the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Justice was, I think, one and Deputy Booth certainly was one—on the first day of the Budget debate, immediately after the Minister's speech, that Fine Gael were surprised by the Budget and that I particularly was surprised. It is rather peculiar but I have in front of me the note I brought into the House in relation to the Budget and which I gave to my colleagues in this Front Bench the night before the Minister introduced his Budget.

I told my colleagues that, knowing the Minister's mentality, I thought he would increase the old age pension by 1/6d. a week and that it would cost £675,000. My colleagues told me that no Minister for Finance could possibly be so niggardly as to give such a small increase in the circumstances disclosed by the Estimate of Receipts and Expenditure published on the Saturday before the Budget. When they voiced that criticism it was on the basis even that the Minister would be more generous by some £75,000.

I notice, too, that in relation to the increase of 1/6d. for social welfare benefits, the Minister has been very careful not to relax the means test in the place where it should be relaxed, and that is in respect of the old age pension itself. Everyone knows that, throughout the length and breadth of Ireland, new stringent reviews of the means test in relation to non-contributory old age pensions have been in operation during the past year and have pressed most unfairly and heavily on people who themselves, by their own industry, were able to build up modest means over the years when they were able to work. To say the least of it, it is unfortunate that the Minister did not take account of that when he was giving this increase, which has been described in the circumstances as being so impossibly niggardly that no Minister for Finance would ever dare to introduce it.

The Minister made available a sum in relation to income tax relief more or less on the figures I had expected, but he did it in one way which, I think, shows an almost complete lack of grasp of the economic problems and difficulties with which we are faced. I agree that the Minister for Finance is correct in saying if there is to be such a concession towards income tax, it is right to help individual effort. I concede that was a wise thing to do. But where the Minister has completely fallen down in his treatment of the income tax position is the manner in which it affects Irish companies.

We all know in relation to Irish companies that, to a great extent, it is only out of profits that those companies can make, any advances can be planned in further production, that it is out of profits they must re-tool, to use an American expression and so increase not merely their production but their productivity. The Minister has, however, in this Budget taken the step of ensuring that corporation profits tax will no longer be a valid deduction for company assessment for income tax purposes. Whom does that hit? It hits, first, Irish companies. It hits, second, foreign companies that have branches here. Whom does it not hit? It means that any person in this country who has invested his money outside the country, who is drawing, for example, British, Canadian or American dividends, is going to get the relief the Irish company will not get. That is a very bad principle of taxation.

It is an extremely bad principle of taxation that in relation to unearned income coming in from outside— money that is not being used to build up Irish production and to ensure that we develop here at home—is given this concession while, on the Minister's own statement, an Irish company, or even a foreign company with a branch here, will not get the benefit. That seems to me to be a complete failure to realise the appropriate approach in present circumstances. No case can be made by any rational person that an Irish taxpayer who has money invested in an Irish company should not be in a better position than the person who has all his money invested outside the country. Yet that is not the way in which the Minister has framed his income tax reliefs. To say it is unfortunate that he has done so is putting it very mildly indeed.

I must confess also that I believed with the advent of television this year the Minister might have deemed it necessary to include some relief for cinemas if he is to keep the goose that lays the golden egg. The advent of television in other parts of the world has, without question, seriously affected the cinema industry and, therefore, the entertainment duty from cinemas. I would have thought, therefore, that in order to protect his own revenue, if nothing else, the Minister would have been obliged to make some concession along that line.

I must confess also that I told my colleagues I expected the Minister should make some concessions towards the difficulties those who are living on pensions find in present circumstances. He did not deem it desirable or necessary to do so. I think that is unfortunate.

Inappropriate as the Budget is from the point of view of putting a premium on moneys invested outside rather than moneys invested internally in our own country, there are two other aspects in which, I think, it has also been singularly inappropriate. I cannot understand at all the suggestion made by the Minister in his Budget speech in relation to a comparison of our increase in the production of transportable goods with Belgium and with France.

The Minister suggests that our rate of increase was higher than that of Belgium and of France. I have tried, as far as I can, to make the comparison from an analysis of O.E.E.C. reports in the Oireachtas Library. I think the Minister, in the other House, sneered at people who would not take the trouble to go down to examine those reports in the Library. The latest figures available, as far as I can trace them, are a comparison between the third quarter of 1959 and the third quarter of 1960. In all the European countries in respect of which a record is taken in those publications, the increase was from 133 to 146 points, whereas ours was from 115 to 121 points,—that is, their increase was more than double ours. The increase in France in that period was 15 points and the increase in Belgium seven points. The average increase for the European Economic Community itself was about one and a half times the increase there was here.

In the fourth quarter of 1960, the combined European Community increase was approximately ten points; the Common Market increase was 12 points; and in Belgium there was, of course, the nation-wide strike and therefore it was not feasible to compare it. In France, for the same period, there was an increase of ten points. In our case, it was either five or six points. Therefore, I cannot see on what calculations the Minister has been able to make his average and to say that in fact the increase was higher here than it was in France and Belgium.

In any event, I do not think checking with individual countries is of much use to us. We want to take our comparison figures against the average of those other countries and, as well, put them against those for Britain because it is to Britain our people have been emigrating in recent years. I want to remind the Minister in that respect of a comment, with which I entirely agree, which occurs in Economic Development:

We now lag so far behind most other European countries in progress that even a spectacular increase in efficiency and output will leave us at a relative disadvantage.

Of course that is right. It seems to me from the comparisons in the recent publications of O.E.E.C. that far from catching up on their relative rate of progress we are, in fact, falling further and further behind, no matter what progress we may make.

In that situation, would it not have been material and appropriate for the Minister for Finance, in the introduction of this Budget, to endeavour to ensure there would be something in it to increase industrial production at home, whereas all he has done is to provide by this new method of taxation a detriment to Irish companies in production? We must face it—and it seems to be getting nearer and nearer —there will be very severe and radical tests when the Common Market and the European Free Trade Area join together and arrive at a modus vivendi.

I was looking at a television programme recently as to what it would mean to the British economic structure and it was accepted that there it would mean an entire revolution in their whole line of economic thought and development. If it is to mean that for them, how much more will it mean for us with the high tariff protection that has been built up and when, notwithstanding that we can all see the new situation arising, there has been consolidation still further in this Budget by the switch of the special import levies into the permanent taxation code?

If any of us consider the position of our industries and make an objective assessment of them—indeed every economist in the country has said this —we will find that any increase there has been was petering out at the end of last year. If that is so, should there not be something in this Budget to get the momentum going again? Whatever increase there has been in industrial production was due to two things. The first is that there was already some slack in the industrial economy. That slack has been taken up since and utilised and there is now no more to utilise. That is why any increase there was was petering out at the end of last year. The second is that it has arisen because the minds of our industrialists were directed — and properly so—towards export markets by the tax reliefs started in 1956 and increased by the present Minister for Finance in the following year.

The tax relief, the Minister says, would mean now something like £3 million a year in loss to revenue. There was a most interesting comment, by way of an aside, in Dr. Meenan's minority report to the Fourth Report by the Commission on Income Tax and I think it is a fair comment. The essential thing in relation to tax incentives, is a psychological one—there must be a real benefit to the persons concerned. There was a real incentive by the remission of 50 per cent. on income earned in any export trade. The Minister, merely for the purpose of trying to change anything I did, increased that incentive and the wisdom of that action by the Minister has been questioned by Dr. Meenan on the ground that it means the general taxpayer is getting nothing whatsoever out of any bouyancy that may arise through such additional exports.

I do not altogether agree that the general taxpayer is getting nothing. However, the essential thing was the psychological approach at that time and it was struck quite adequately and quite satisfactorily by the 50 per cent. remission. It would have been possible to devise a scheme by which the other 50 per cent. was utilised, not on a direct remission basis as was done by the Minister but by way of investment allowances or ploughing back into industry in such a way that we would get increased productivity and therefore increased exports for the future. I do not think the way in which that was done by the Minister was entirely the best way of utilising the funds at his disposal. Of course, I would agree with the Minister in this, when he refers to the loss of revenue, though not everyone realise it, that, when you lose revenue by means of giving a tax relief before it comes into operation, it is just as costly from an Exchequer point of view as if you give it after it has been imposed and after it has been collected. There is nothing in this Budget to provide any new incentive towards increased production or, more so, towards increased productivity. The important thing is, while having something there that is realistic, to add as being even more important the psychological reaction and the psychological development from it.

The Minister has produced nothing except to change that export tax incentive in a way that does not of itself increase development. For far too long we have been a high-cost economy. I admit at once that to change jigs in a small market like ours is more expensive than to change them, say, in an immense market like the United States; the fractional costs that can be placed over immense sales in a very large sales market mean it is a much cheaper thing to re-tool. But, if we are going to re-tool in industry as frequently as it is necessary, as frequently as modern inventions make it necessary, if we are to maintain export sales, then we have to devise a system of taxation which enables that to be done and enables our people to overcome the disadvantages of having a smaller market over which to spread the cost.

The smaller market means that the cost per unit is larger. But if it is not done, then I am afraid we shall not be able to maintain our position, much less increase it, and we shall certainly find ourselves in a very difficult position when primarily the British on the one hand and the whole of E.F.T.A. on the other hand seek and finally reach accommodation with the Six Common Market countries. There is nothing in this Budget to do that and in that respect also the Budget is entirely inappropriate to our needs.

In regard to agriculture, the Budget boasts of larger herds. I referred this House already to a seemingly obvious and self-evident fact. You cannot have larger herds of cattle unless they are produced in the ordinary natural way. The only way in which our breeding stocks can be increased is by more and more in-calf heifers being taken into the herds year by year. There is nothing in this Budget to meet the catastrophic fall of 11.9 per cent. in the number of our in-calf heifers in the January, 1961, enumeration compared with the January, 1960, enumeration The decrease of some 26,000 in the in-calf heifers is one of the results perhaps—rather than the resulting factor—of the stagnation that there has been and is likely to be— notwithstanding what is prognosticated in Economic Development—in our cattle population in the years ahead.

Altogether, even allowing for the increase in cows, there is a substantial reduction this year in our breeding stock. If that reduction had been the other way around, if there had been an increase in in-calf heifers and a decrease in cows, I should have said that the Minister was entitled to the view that the decrease in our cow population was because of the scheme for the eradication of bovine tuberculosis and that we should not be unduly worried because when that scheme had come to full maturity and achieved its object the position would cure itself. But that is not the position. It is the other way around.

The in-calf heifer is not the type one would expect to see reduced by the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. The cow population is very slightly up. The in-calf heifer population is very heavily down. Even if what the Minister could do to relieve that situation in the Budget had been small, some gesture towards it would have been invaluable from a psychological point of view and some gesture towards it which could assist those who would be involved in appreciating the dangers there might be if that decrease were not arrested would have made this Budget far more appropriate.

In relation to the capital Budget, too, I notice that in the programme of capital expenditure in the current year a sum of £3½ million is being made available for the Industrial Credit Company, Limited, of which £300,000 is being found by them out of their own internal resources and £3,200,000 is to be found for them out of public funds. I have heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce say on various occasions that the moneys made available through or by the Industrial Credit Company were not in fact public moneys at all. That is nonsense. The Industrial Credit Company is merely the conduit pipe through which the Government of the day makes available public funds for the development of industry.

I suggest to the Minister for Finance as the person responsible for the purse strings in that regard that he should seriously consider splitting the functions of the Industrial Credit Company as at present operated into two separate divisions. Let us consider as one thing the ordinary commercial facilities of a commercial lending house. Those are what we considered—all of us in this House and outside— were the primary aims, objects and functions of the company but in recent years it has been utilised by the Government in two instances for a different function, not to carry out the ordinary commercial lending of that sort but to carry out direct Government subvention.

I am not arguing in relation to this whether the Government are right or wrong in determining that certain work had to be done but I think it is farcical to think that when the Industrial Credit Company in doing something that may be entirely necessary in the national interest, as in this case, it is doing it on an ordinary commercial basis. Speaking here earlier, I made quite clear that I accept at once that in relation to the termination of the G.N.R. system something had to be done, something radical in regard to the Dundalk railway works and the disemployment that would follow the closing there, but it was entirely wrong that it should be done by means of a company that pretends to be commercial, pretends to be making commercial loans when in fact it was to be done as a matter—if you like—of national salvage. It was right that something should be done to salvage the employment position that arose there but to suggest that the operation was an ordinary commercial one as the Minister for Industry and Commerce has frequently done is just nonsense.

The losses in relation to that operation so far—if any Deputy wishes to go down to the Company's office to look it up—are £350,000 of public funds. I suggest to the Minister that it would have been more appropriate to come to the House and to have asked the House for a Vote for the necessary funds to meet the unusual situation that arose rather than attempt to cover up something under the guise of being a commercial transaction when in fact obviously it was not. We shall have other opportunities of discussing in detail the situation that has given rise to the loss of £350,000, but it arose primarily because of the obstinacy of the present Taoiseach in insisting on putting in charge of that particular operation a person who had already been found out long ago as being far too dictatorial and incompetent to run any business concern in an adequate manner.

It would be far better for the public conscience if the two types of job that the Industrial Credit Company are at present being asked to do were segregated into different categories so that those who wish to study what is being done would know the correct facts. The Industrial Credit Company accounts and their whole capital structure are completely overbalanced and thrown out of balance by the Dundalk operation and the Verolme Dockyard Board, financed by the Industrial Credit Company as if they were ordinary moneys made available for ordinary commercial industries.

We have had some discussions on other occasions about national income. It is a fact that the national income as such, when computed by our statisticians, does not take into account the amount of increased bank advances but we all know that increased capital works at any time have their reflection in increased spending and is therefore reflected by an increase in national income when there has been an increase, for example, in bank advances or hire purchase debt. The increase that there has been in hire purchase debt is alarming some people at present. Whether it is wise or unwise depends to a great extent on what type of hire purchase debt is being incurred. If it is on consumer or near-consumer goods it can be very hurtful and harmful to the whole economy; if, on the other hand, there is an increase in hire purchase debt for the purpose of providing greater and better production it is a good thing, but unfortunately our type of statistical analysis is not as complete or as up-to-date as we would wish if we were to realise exactly what is happening.

I dislike the phrase the Minister used in his Budget speech in regard to housebuilding. It is typical of the sneering attitude that some people wish to take towards housing. They point to Germany and how the German people did not bother about improving their housing conditions until after they had improved their economic production. The position here was entirely different. If we had not improved our housing then, we would not have had any personnel to carry out further production; they would have gone. The Germans had not got the facility of emigration; on the contrary they had a continuous inflow of emigrants, escapees and refugees from Eastern Germany. We would have been denuded of all our working personnel if we had not first of all improved housing conditions for them.

The manner in which the Minister boasts of the reduction in moneys provided for housing in this Budget is an entirely wrong approach to that problem. I am not quite clear even yet whether the statistical analysis of the national income takes into account any increased figure for the improvement in housing conditions. I know that up to a couple of years ago it did not and it was one of the indicators which showed that no movement forward had been achieved in that respect.

There are some technical matters in this Budget which it would be more desirable perhaps to discuss on the Finance Bill rather than on the Budget itself, but there is one matter to which I want to refer now. The Minister stated he would tighten up the stamp duty arrangements in relation to purchases by non-nationals. Frankly, I do not think taxation is the right way to deal with that problem at all. I think it should be dealt with in another way, and the first step in that way is the Bill we have tabled here and which will be discussed tomorrow or the next day. If the Minister approaches this problem from a tax basis I hope that, when he is framing his Finance Bill, he will make that taxation watertight.

In the past there have been far too many instances in which certain people were prepared to sign questionable certificates for the purpose of getting away with the three per cent. stamp duty. Others were not prepared to do that. Certificates were completed in cases which, in my opinion, were not appropriate at all. The purchase by a non-national of a pre-1947 company, a proceeding which the Minister has stated he will prevent, represents only a fraction of the cases that have occurred in the last two years. In the case of a purchase by a non-national through a pre-1947 company, the certificate incorporated in the deed, and certified by the parties and, therefore, inferentially by the solicitor for the purchasers, was a true certificate certifying it was a purchase of a pre-1947 company. It was a true certificate.

The other type of case to which I refer is the case in which certain Irish citizens took up shares in post-1947 companies and, having taken up those shares, they then entered into a type of option agreement with a non-national under which they would hold 51 per cent. of the share capital and would not sell it except with the consent of the non-national. That procedure to my mind made the Irish national a trustee for the non-national and was completely contrary to the terms of the certificate included in the deed. There were many cases in which solicitors who would not lend themselves to that type of evasion lost their clients to other solicitors who would. I am not criticising the other solicitors. They thought they were right. Those of us who thought it was not right said firmly and flatly that we would not do it. We all know cases where people who wanted that done went elsewhere.

In so far as the Minister is coping with this problem by a system of taxation, I hope he will cope with it by a system which will be completely rigid and which will make certain that there cannot be that type of evasion in the future. When the Finance Bill comes before the House I shall bend my mind to amending the Bill, should that be necessary, to making it clear that it will be the same for everybody and to ensuring that such cases as have arisen in the last two years will not arise in the future. When I say the last two years, I am not criticising the Minister. The problem arose only in the last two years. Some people have been prepared to lend their names to the kind of certificates I have described. Others very properly have not.

It would be wrong not to say something about P.A.Y.E. on this Budget. It is quite clear from the returns given to me by the Minister that a great deal of the buoyancy in income tax revenue arises from P.A.Y.E. An immense amount of trouble has been taken by employers throughout the country to master the intricacies of the new system. I think they deserve to be congratulated. The system has meant more trouble and expense than many realised it would when the Act was being passed. It has meant more trouble, more difficulty and more expense than the Minister suggested it would entail when he was introducing the system.

It would be helpful if the Minister would give an estimate of the amount the Revenue Commissioners think will be provided in the current year by P.A.Y.E. taxation. It would help us to make a comparison with the figure for the last half of the financial year just ended. We could judge whether the system is operating fairly and justly. While employers are perhaps somewhat aggrieved because of the amount of trouble, difficulty and expense to which they have been put by the introduction of this system, they have nothing but praise for the manner in which they have been helped over their difficulties and for the attitude adopted generally by the Revenue Commissioners.

In so far as one can understand the Minister's speech he has now apparently abandoned any prospect of being able to curb, much less reduce, the Civil Service machine. When he came in in 1957, with all the attributes of the new broom, he said he would ensure there would be a new system, a system of rationalisation, and that system of rationalisation would mean great savings and substantial benefit. He tells us now that he is sorry that there is no prospect of that, no prospect of his being able to fulfil his hopes. But that is only one of three things in this Budget in which the Minister is now going back. He is going back, as Deputy Crotty said, in relation to the lime subsidy, retrieving the error he made before; he is going back in relation to the farm building grants, retrieving the error he made in abolishing the double byre grant as an incentive in the eradication of bovine tuberculosis.

In both these cases it is at least satisfactory that the sinner is doing penance, but it would have been far more satisfactory if there were no necessity for him to do penance. If he had left the transport subsidy as it was, we would have had more lime on our land in the last couple of years and if he had not, with his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, abolished the double incentive of farm building grants tied in with the eradication of bovine tuberculosis, we might have progressed even more in that very necessary scheme.

Other speakers have mentioned the breach of faith by the Minister in consolidating permanently into our whole customs code and protective tariffs the special import levies. I remember the debates here in March, 1956, and July, 1956, in relation to the special import levies. It was stated categorically by the then Opposition that we intended to keep them as permanent levies and that, of course, Fianna Fáil on the other hand, if they were there, would not do so but would remit them as soon as they got the opportunity. I am not criticising them alone for having broken their promise in that respect. I think it is a great mistake that the declared intention of any Government in relation to a thing like that should be slithered over and reneged upon. It means that a weapon which might be necessary in the future —if the terms of trade, for example change unfavourably against us—is gone because of the manner in which the Minister has coped with the situation.

I asked a question in relation to the terms of trade recently. It is a thing which I want to stress again this evening. The Taoiseach's answer was that if in 1960 the terms of trade had remained as they were in February, 1957, we would not have had last year a balance on external account but a deficit of £28.8 million, or call it £29,000,000. That deficit of £29,000,000 arose notwithstanding the fact that the terms of trade had worsened by some two per cent. on the year before. If the terms of trade had remained as they were in 1957, in the years 1958, 1959 and 1960, instead of having a balance on our external account in those years—and I am quite prepared to accept that there was a balance in actual fact over those years—we would have had not a balance, but a deficit of some £85,000,000 in three years.

I do not know whether the Minister is right, I do not know whether the Taoiseach is right, when they are gambling, as they are now, on the terms of trade remaining favourable to this country. Both say there is no danger whatever in our international balance of payments situation. If the terms of trade were to shift, not merely back to where they were in 1957, but were to shift half way towards it, we would be running a deficit of the order of about £20,000,000 per annum. It is, of course, lucky not only for the country but for the Government that there has been that shift in international prices in a way which facilitates and benefits this country so much, but I wonder are we right to gamble as the Government are gambling on its remaining the same?

The other night I was talking to an industrialist who most certainly has never supported Fine Gael and his view was that the dangerous situation ahead was a shift against us in international prices, but there is nothing in this Budget to provide an incentive to our people to be prepared to meet such a shift. There is nothing in this Budget by way of incentive to our people to enable them to gear themselves in readiness for such a shift, just as there is nothing in this Budget to enable our people to gear themselves for the merger of the Six Common Market Countries and the Seven in the European Free Trade Association.

Those are some of the reasons I think this Budget has been a failure and has been completely inappropriate. It has been a failure too because it has not lived up to the promises made by the Taoiseach when he was bidding for office in the 1957 General Election. It has been a failure also because in its economic survey it does not provide, or show that there will be provided, anything like the 100,000 jobs he promised in 1956, the 100,000 jobs that were to be provided not in the distant future but year by year at the rate of 20,000 a year so that at the end of a five year period of Government by Fianna Fáil there would be 100,000 new jobs. None of those is to be seen; instead we see a reference by the Minister for Finance in his speech that the most he could conjure up would be an increase of 5,000 in relation to new industries without at the same time taking account of those who might be going out of work or those who have gone out of work since he took office.

The figures have been mentioned by other people and I do not propose to dwell on them overmuch, except to state that there are now some 50,000 fewer people at work than the day the Minister for Finance went over to sit on that bench. As far as I can gather from Deputies in Fianna Fáil, and particularly from the speech made by Deputy Gilbride, there has not been any emigration. They would be well advised to read the statement of their own Minister for Finance who, when talking on the Budget, agreed with our contention that over the last five years it would be seen that unfortunately emigration has been extremely heavy.

It is sometimes extraordinary the way the Deputies behind the Minister, who are supposed to be supporting him, fail to pay him the compliment of reading his speeches so that when they are speaking they would not be contradicting what he has been saying. It is a fact, of course, he has acknowledged in his Budget speech that there has been a substantial amount of emigration. At Column 657 he said:

When the results of the 1961 census are available, we are likely to find that emigration was heavy in the past five years.

I agree, unfortunately, with the Minister.

What has been the effect of that emigration? The effect of it has been that the smaller towns and villages in rural Ireland have been worst hit but, in addition, the deadweight debt per capita is increasing and we are facing the situation in which substantial parts of the country are being denuded, denuded in a frightening way. Yet, I do not see any signs of realisation by the Government that that is happening, much less direct measures designed to prevent it or to meet the situation in future.

I do not propose this evening to recapitulate the things I said when speaking immediately after the Budget or on the radio in my criticism of the Minister then. Suffice it to say that now, on greater reflection, I think, even more so, that I was right in those criticisms, right in my criticisms of the Budget in so far as its appropriateness to the economic needs of our country at the present time is concerned, right in relation to the manner in which it will be received and judged by the people as a whole.

We have in this Budget, as the Minister himself opined, the last Budget before the general election. We have in it no sign of any incentive towards future progress in the economy. We have no sign of any thought being given to the manner in which we can meet the threat and the competition of the merger of Europe as an economic unity. We have little chance in it of ensuring that there will be a development by Irish companies when the main concession given in this Budget is a concession given in such a way that people whose money is invested outside the country benefit more than the people who are producing and working to produce more for and in the country.

Comment on this

For about two years now, we have been hearing speeches from Ministers indicating their belief that there was a new spirit of optimism abroad, that the people had left depression behind them, that the economy was buoyant and that all the hopes were that the nation was now on the high road to success and prosperity. If all these statements were true then one would expect that the Government, having been four years in office and about to face the electorate, would come in here with a Budget which not only measured up to the situation of today but which would give some evidence that they intended to fulfil the promises they made to the people at the last election. My complaint about this Budget is that it fails completely to fulfil the Government's promises but, more seriously, that in the face of a situation in which time is against us, this Budget fails lamentably to measure up to the needs of the situation today.

Let us see what the Budget does. Let us give the Budget credit for all the things it does. Some social welfare benefits have been increased. The increase to old age pensioners is 1/6d. per week, approximately 2½d. per day. That is the buoyancy and the high road to prosperity as seen by Ministers when it comes to helping the unfortunate old age pensioner. Income tax has been reduced in certain instances, but anybody who takes the trouble to make the calculation knows that the income tax reductions are quite insignificant. In the case of, let us say, a carpenter or other type of tradesman whose take-home pay is approximately £11 per week, the income tax reduction means 4½ per week, but he is going to pay a penny extra on every packet of cigarettes he buys. The person with an income of £3,000 per annum does not get a reduction of 4½d. a week in income tax. For him, the reduction is £2 10s. 0d. per week.

I make that contrast in order to show the Government's shifting values when it comes to comparing the position of the ordinary skilled worker with that of the person having an income of £3,000 per annum. As I said, the community who permit themselves the privilege and solace of smoking will pay an extra penny on the packet of cigarettes and an increased price for tobacco for the next 12 months at least. These are the benefits of the Budget. I put them down deliberately so that one can make a calculation. I put these on the credit side. Now we can have a look at the debit side.

When this Government took office in 1957, the cost of living index figure was 135; it is now 149, an increase of 14 points in the four years from mid-February, 1957 to mid-February, 1961. That increase of 14 points has had a very substantial effect on and has been of very substantial disadvantage for persons on low rates of income or static incomes. Those who feel it worst of all are those in the social welfare classes or persons who have to depend on home assistance or other forms of charity to enable them to keep body and soul together. If one looks at the cost of living consumer price index, one finds that of 200 commodities which make up the index, about 150 have increased in price over the past four years. Everybody knows, of course, that the Government have completely abandoned any control so far as prices are concerned. It does not matter what you make now, you can fix your own price for it and if you can sell it at that price, the equity or justice of the price does not matter. Whether you are a miller charging higher prices for your produce or an insurance company charging higher rates of insurance, any of these things can now be done without the slightest demur, so far as the governmental organisation is concerned.

A question was asked the other day in the House to ascertain the price of three staple commodities in 1957 and in 1961. The official answer was that in February 1957, a lb. of butter cost 3/8¾d. and that in February 1961, it cost 4/6¾d.; a 2lb. loaf in February 1957, cost 9d. and now costs 1/3½d.; a stone of flour in February, 1957, cost 4/2½d.; it now costs 8/2½d. Take these three articles alone. Deputies will realise the extent to which they enter into the domestic budgets of the ordinary man and woman around the country, the wage earner, the small farmer, the old age pensioner, that large mass of people who have nothing to insulate them against rises of that kind in their domestic budgets. They have had to bear all these increases since 1957 under this Government.

To that must be added what the Government did in the 1957 Budget when they saved, by the abolition of the food subsidies, approximately £9,000,000 and increased taxation by additional taxes on beer, spirits, tobacco and other commodities. If you place this Budget against the things which have been done over the past four years, it will be seen that there is no evidence of restitution for the action which has been taken against the community. There is no evidence here, even some months before the general election, that the Government are going to undo what they did at the time the food subsidies were abolished or that they are going to take any steps to adjust or control prices in order to bring price levels back to what they were when the Government took office.

The Minister for Transport and Power, in one of these frequent mathematical calculations which he makes, gave the impression that everything in the garden is lovely, that the only real danger is that one of these days the country, without knowing it, certainly without any advance notice, may be flooded with milk and honey. If there is all that milk and honey flowing about, if there is all that buoyancy and all that prosperity, one is tempted to ask why are the Government so meagre and stingy in the distribution of benefits to those sections of the community whose economic plight is such that benefits would be very welcome to them indeed?

To look at even this year, because of the fact that we had a bad harvest last year, the consumer of bread and flour is compelled to pay for that bad harvest, compelled to pay a guaranteed price to the miller for taking in defective wheat. That was done by increasing the price of bread and flour to the consumer. That device was resorted to, although it must have been known to everybody that the heaviest burden was being put on backs least capable of bearing it. Against the claims which have been made that this is a heaven-sent Budget which could only be introduced by this Government, I want to offer these facts to the community so that they may have a sober appreciation of the sacrifices they have already made and how insignifiant and microscopic is the return for what they have suffered.

It has always been accepted that a Budget is an instrument of Government economic policy, that through the medium of a Budget, one can establish the economic course of the nation and at the same time, weave from that economic life a social pattern of whatever kind is conceived to be best for the nation. I want to look at this Budget from the standpoint of what it proposes to do as an instrument of national policy, with particular reference to what it proposes to do in respect of unemployment, in respect of employment and in respect of emigration, which of course is fed and fertilised by the fact that we failed to solve our unemployment problem and thus provided the motive power for the continued large-scale emigration.

Let us look at the unemployment situation. I do not have to rely on my own figures or my own calculations. Let me take this book called Economic Statistics compiled by the Central Statistics Office and issued under the authority of the Taoiseach's Office. According to the information on page 22, Table 7, there were in June, 1956, 409,000 males engaged in farm work. By June, 1960, the number had fallen to 383,000; in other words, between June, 1956, and June, 1960, there were 26,000 persons fewer employed on the land, land being agricultural work. If agricultural work is taken in a wider concept to include forestry and fishing, the same Table shows that, in 1956, there were 445,000 persons employed in agriculture, fishing and forestry and that that number has fallen to 413,000, a reduction of 32,000, between 1956 and 1960. This represents an alarming fall in the number of persons on the land.

It is noticeable that many things —the continued mechanisation on the land, the introduction of tractors, the continued growth of mechanical operations, the introduction of the reaper and binder and combine harvester— have helped to reduce employment on the land. In many respects, this is a development which is not confined to Ireland. It operates in other countries, but with this exception, that in many of the other countries where this operates, the displaced agricultural worker can get alternative employment making the machines which have displaced him on the land. The agricultural worker who is displaced here is employed by the agricultural manufacturing firms of Britain, Germany, the United States and elsewhere.

The result of that is that while we might be able to look on understandingly at a movement from the land into the factory which makes machines for the land in this country, there is no such movement from the land into the agricultural machinery factory. The movement is from the land to the emigrant ship, to Britain into an agricultural machinery factory to make there the mechanical apparatus which has deprived the Irish agricultural worker of his opportunity of earning his living on Irish land. This situation would be bad in any circumstances, if we failed to provide alternative employment or work ancillary to farm work, but we cannot even provide an opportunity for work in respect of any other kind of employment.

If we turn to Table 16 on page 27 of Economic Statistics, we find the estimated number of persons in the main branches of non-agricultural economic activity set out. The Table shows that, in 1955, 726,000 persons were engaged in non-agricultural economic activity. In 1960, that number had fallen to 699,000. In other words, there was a reduction of 27,000 persons. There we have the picture with all the stubbornness these figures contain. There was a fall of 32,000 between 1936 and 1960 in agriculture, forestry and fishing, and a fall of 27,000 between 1955 and 1960, in non-agricultural employment.

That is a serious situation. It is a situation which does not concern only the Labour Party. It concerns the Government Party, the Fine Gael Party, and every thinking citizen up and down the country. On our ability to solve that problem, which challenges the very economic existence of the nation, depends the standard of living of our people not merely to-day and in the years to come, but it may well determine the standard of living of the Irish people for many and many a year to come.

I raise that matter not to impute blame to the Government as such. I think all Governments have been to blame over the past forty years. This problem of emigration has been with us too long. Serious though it is, however, we can produce a change if all Parties will unite, and if we develop a healthy and vigorous public opinion that, no matter what the cost, steps must be taken to solve this problem of emigration if the whole nation is to survive. We had hoped, of course, that after the last general election, judging by the promises made by the Government, we would see an end to unemployment and an end to emigration.

I have quoted before—I do not want to quote it at length again, but for the purpose of the record and for the benefit of those who might not have heard it, I want to quote again—from the famous pamphlet issued by the Fianna Fáil Party in Cork before the last election under the world-shaking heading: "Fianna Fáil plans the end of emigration." There is a subtitle which says: "Quick action needed to avert national disaster." It goes on with the usual boastful lead-in, and then we come to this part:

"The full employment proposals recently announced by Fianna Fáil show how the Party intend to deal with the problem of emigration by providing work for our own people at home."

That is followed in heavy type by:

"The Fianna Fáil plan proposes an increase over five years in the number of new jobs by 100,000. This would result in full employment and the end of abnormal emigration."

There is a promise. Fianna Fáil had a plan. It had to be put in operation quickly. It was released so that the simpletons around the country could believe that Fianna Fáil would provide 100,000 jobs in five years. That was February, 1957. In February, 1961, one would imagine that, even if the 100,000 jobs had not been provided, say, 80,000 would have been provided, since we are four-fifths of the way through the period. Does anyone believe that any additional jobs have been provided?

I have quoted from a book of statistics and compared 1955 and 1960. In agricultural employment, there are 32,000 fewer persons and in non-agricultural employment there are 27,000 fewer persons, showing, of course, that this pamphlet did the job it was intended to do. It was intended to collar seats for Fianna Fáil. It succeeded in doing that, but not a single new job has been provided. Instead, the number of people in employment is less now than it was before this Government took office. There is no indication—certainly there is none in this Budget—that the Government have any proposals to produce a spectacular change from the drift which exists to-day.

I want now to pass to emigration because it is the cause of the Government's failure to keep the Cork promise of 100,000 new jobs in five years and because of their failure to arrest the fall in employment in agricultural and non-agricultural occupations that we have with us the serious problem of emigration. I understand Deputy Gilbride said this evening that he did not think there was any emigration at all. Let us see the figures. I asked a question in the Dáil recently about the population of the State in 1956 and in 1960. I was told that the total population of the State based on the returns of the census taken on 8th and 9th of April, 1956, was 2,898,000 and that the population in April, 1960 was 2,834,000. In other words, the population in April, 1960, was 64,000 less than it was in 1956.

That is not all. The population has fallen by 64,000 but we have lost as well the entire natural increase in our population for each of those years. Every excess of births over deaths has gone in emigration, and on top of that, we exported another 64,000 to keep them company. Does anyone now doubt that our emigration has been travelling in the vicinity of approximately 50,000 people per year in the past four years? It must be a source of infinite solace to Deputy Gilbride's conscience that he did not know a single one of those 200,000 emigrants.

Comment on this

He said no such thing, of course.

Comment on this

That is the substance of what he said. In case he might slip up again, I should like to refer him to a reliable source of information.

Comment on this

Any old statement at all would do the Deputy.

Comment on this

In Britain, there is an official organisation known as the British Oversea Migration Board. Some short time ago, they published a report on the question of emigration. That report assumed considerable importance because at the time the possibility was being canvassed that there might be restrictions on immigrants into Britain from some overseas countries, including Ireland. The report says:

National insurance data showed that of the total of 177,000 immigrants from all sources, 64,000 were from the Republic in 1959, against 58,000 in 1958.

In order to get a picture of the extent of this haemorrhage of human beings, we can contrast our exports of human beings to Britain with those of other countries. This report goes on to say that emigration to Britain in that same period from independent Commonwealth countries was 35,000, from British colonies 30,000, and from foreign countries 45,000. We sent more emigrants to Britain than all the countries of the British Commonwealth and all the British colonies. More folk went from this country as emigrants than from all the countries outside the British Commonwealth. These figures do not include non-working persons so that young children are not taken into account.

The report goes on to say that there is a two-way flow of people, some going over for a certain period and then coming back again. I take it that that referred to the agricultural workers who go across to the beet fields of the east coast. Later, the report goes on to say:

We are advised that the figures for the first six months of 1960 show a total of 105,000, which is an increase of 45,000 over the corresponding period of 1959.

At that stage, the emigration figures were continuing to rise. We have, in those figures, a story of the disintegration by emigration, a saga of extinction as far as our loss of population is concerned. There is no indication in the Budget that the special steps which were promised in 1957 to end emigration have been taken.

Here we have not only emigration from the rural areas into the towns, but emigration from the towns to Britain, and from the cities to Britain. The wholesale emigration from the rural areas to Britain is a matter that has compelled members of the Hierarchy and those concerned with sociological problems to make comments as to the necessity of grappling with a serious situation of this kind. No matter what attempts might be made to put a gloss on the causes of emigration, to excuse it by saying that the Celt has a rambling foot or that he is venturesome, you should talk to the ordinary fellow on the emigrant ship or on the trains to London or other parts of England and he will tell you that it is not wanderlust. He will say that he is going through economic necessity, that he is going either because he cannot live on the lower rate of pay, or on no employment, or on intermittent employment or because he hopes to make a better living elsewhere.

Unless we can provide work for these classes of persons and raise their living standards, emigration is going to continue. I see no reason why a person should live for the short span of human life a poverty-stricken existence, if he can provide for himself and his wife and family a decent life elsewhere. If the nation declines to discharge its responsibility to the citizen, the citizen has very little responsibility to the nation. As long as the nation makes no serious effort to provide employment and decent standards of living for the citizen, that citizen has very little responsibility to the nation that has treated him with such systematic and sustained indifference.

If we are to solve problems such as the emigration problem, it can be done only by providing employment, by raising the living standards of our people, especially the standards of living of the agricultural community and particularly of the agricultural worker. Nobody can expect agricultural workers to live on present day wages and maintain their wives and families at a time when the post-war pound is worth less than 7/6d. If evidence be needed of the large scale on which this country is providing a marshalling yard in human life, it is to be found in the advertisements in our papers. Even the Government papers contain advertisements advising our people to emigrate. No doubt a substantial revenue is raised from these advertisements, all for the purpose of saying to our people that there is employment for them in Britain when they cannot find employment to sustain themselves here.

We can do one of two things. The first it to let things drift as they have been drifting, to let emigration continue, in the hope that, in ten years time, there will be a job for everybody who is left, a job of a kind. Every country which has had experience of that kind of thing knows that the remedy is not in a small population, is not in having one man tied to a job. All the small countries in the world and all the developing countries have found that a small population is not a remedy for economic difficulties. They have resorted to inviting people to come in as a way of building up their economy, of producing more wealth and becoming an adult member of the comity of nations instead of being an international Peter Pan, subject to the pity and interested comments of the rest of the world.

The second course is to take steps to stop emigration. So that the choice before us today is either to stop emigration and build up the nation as it was envisaged in the Proclamation of 1916, as it was envisaged by those who fought between those years and 1921 or give up the struggle and allow our people to find a living anywhere they can. I am afraid that we are drifting along that despairing line. We find emigration such an easy salve for unemployment that there is no use in our trying to put an end to it. We are beginning to give up the struggle. These figures from the British Report, the figures about the number of British insurance cards issued to Irish emigrants, the scenes you can see every night at the North Wall, Dún Laoghaire and every passenger port in the country, are terrifying testimony to what we are losing in the way of human population.

It seems to me we can end that only by a two-fold thrust in the field of industry by endeavouring to expand still more rapidly our production and exports. I welcome and regard as joyous news the fact that our industrial exports are expanding. I take pride in the fact that I was associated in a very special way with the pioneering efforts —and they were pioneering efforts at one stage, no matter what people may say now—to try to get acceptance of the idea of a reduction in income tax for firms which would go into the export market with their products over and above a datum year. I saw in that the only hope of inducing people to go into the export market.

I think these inducements have worked in making people realise the benefits of exports. In consequence, we have got the benefits of increased production and, to some extent, of increased employment at home, although it is cancelled by losses of employment in other directions. We cannot emphasise too vehemently the necessity for continued industrial expansion in every possible sector. That field alone offers the best prospect of an increase in our opportunities for employment and in the building up of our exports in other markets.

In the field of agriculture, I see nothing on the horizon at all, except one item, which offers prospects for agriculture. The most heartening news the small farmer and the agricultural industry generally have received is the announcement to-day by the Irish Sugar Company that they intend to go into this method of quick freezing and dehydration of foodstuffs on a scale which, because they are pioneers, may well get them markets in all parts of the world. There is no use offering high prices, even for cattle, to the small farmer. His land will not rear them. He is incapable of taking advantage of them.

There is no use telling him of the advantages being made available for the large farmer. He can never capitalise on those advantages. What you have got to do is to make him, as the Sugar Company propose doing, a grower of a whole variety of small products of that kind. Give him the seed, the fertilisers and a guaranteed price and get the stuff into the big markets—process it and get rid of it in the markets of the world. In that way, and in that way only, can the small farmer be provided with any prospect. But to tell him he can buy fertiliser at £1 a ton to put on a dozen acres of land and to expect him to produce animals off it that will earn him a decent livelihood is to make a mockery of his suffering.

The plain fact shows that, over a period of about 30 years, the volume of output in the agricultural industry has increased by about 12 per cent. If you deliberately tried to slow it down, you could hardly have slowed it down more successfully than that. Unless we try to get in the future other methods than those we have used in the past, we shall continue to have a stagnant agricultural industry. I see no hope for the small farmer and no hope for a fresh appraisal of our agricultural potential other than the steps which the Sugar Company are taking to process and market fruit, vegetables and certain meat stuffs, which they can sell in the markets of the world and for which we have a climate, a labour force and a fertility of land that ought to ensure the success of an enterprise of that kind.

Recently, I have seen references of a kind to the fact that a number of people are coming into this country from outside and establishing industries and that they are getting certain advantages here. That is inevitable in a small country such as this. So far as I am concerned, I am strongly in favour of it, so long as the object is not to allow the foreigner in to compete in a cut-throat way with an Irish industry and so long as the main purpose behind his coming here is to produce something we do not produce ourselves or produce for the export market. Subject to these two guarantees, I think it is a good line. I advocated it in other years, when it was the subject of much criticism by the present Government Party. I was told by no less a person than the Minister for External Affairs that if you allow these foreigners to invest in this country, you are really selling out the country to them.

Since then the Government's policy has undergone a metamorphosis. They now give you the impression that they are the authors of this scheme, that it first fertilised in their minds and that nobody else thought of it until they did. But if you read the speeches of the members of the Opposition Party when I was Minister for Industry and Commerce, you will find that many criticisms were levelled against the invitation I issued to these European and American industrialists to come here to make commodities, the manufacture of which was unknown to us, and to bring here with them capital and, above all, technical know-how so that we could build up industry here for our people.

I felt then, as I feel now, that it is better to have an Irishman working in Ireland, even with a foreign firm, than have him working with some firm in a foreign land completely separated from his own family. I hope this momentum will increase and that more and more people will realise the benefits we have to offer here, that in Ireland we have stable Government, intelligent labour, available man-power and a geographical position which offers excellent facilities for exports, certainly to the European markets and, without serious handicap, to the markets of the world.

I should like to pass from that to one other matter, and that is the existence in Europe of two rival trade blocs. During the past few days there has been a rumour in London to the effect that the British Government have made up their minds that they will accept in principle joining the European Economic Community, subject to certain safeguards in respect of Commonwealth countries and agricultural produce. If that is so, it is an important development as far as this country is concerned. There may be no justification for the rumour at this moment, but I think Britain has realised, particularly in the last twelve months, that if she is going to have any association with Europe in the creation of a political and economic policy, she will have that association through E.E.C.

Judging by speeches made by British Ministers, it looks as if we are not far away from a decision by the British to join the European Economic Community. It is a necessity for Britain as a political development and as an economic development as well. If Britain does that, there is virtually nothing we can do, short of complete economic isolation, except do the same. Britain, by being a member of E.E.C., is going to be compelled to impose tariffs against us as other members of the group must impose tariffs against their former friends.

That is a new situation confronting Irish industry. Beyond an occasional speech at a banquet, I see no serious effort being made here to indicate to industrialists the danger of this situation for Irish industry. I hear gallant words about our being able to meet the challenge and about our adjusting ourselves to meet the challenge. Let this be a sobering thought: when this was first mooted, the Department of Industry and Commerce, after a close survey of the situation, came to the conclusion that 60,000 people would lose their jobs in industries which could not stand up at that time to the competition from a Free Trade Area.

If we had to compete with any of the countries on the Continent of Europe in a number of the industries in which they participate, our chances of survival would be extremely poor indeed. These are highly-developed industries, where they have 50 firms making the one commodity and our people could not afford to withstand the competition of a group of that kind while we are producing here for a small home market with the high overhead costs that go hand in hand with producing for small markets.

Somebody told me the other day that there was a seminar in Killarney on avoiding the spread of Parkinson's Disease in embroidery or some subject of that kind far removed from reality. I would urge the Government that a lot of these industrialists ought to be brought to a conference and held at it for a month to discuss this whole business. Let somebody tell them of the dangers confronting them and what steps they must take to meet this challenge. Someone with a realistic mind should tell them that in future they have got to sell their goods on the British market and elsewhere purely on the basis of quality and in face of severe competition. They must be told that their goods will have no value whatsoever to the people who will be buying them, unless the goods we hope to export are of high quality.

Nothing sufficient is being done to inform the industrialists of this country of the danger in which they stand. There is no evidence of anybody being detailed to appraise the situation for the industrialists. The speeches I hear on the subject leave me cold and the authors of some of the speeches leave me colder still. The Government might well realise that not for 40 years has there been such a challenge to the economic viability of this. State as is represented in the development of the two trade groups in Europe and that that situation will become all the more difficult and all the more dangerous for us, if Britain goes into the European Economic Community and we are compelled, through sheer necessity, to follow her in order to keep whatever trade contracts we have with her and the other countries of the European Economic Community, tenuous and slender though they may be. Valuable time is being lost, and time becomes more valuable every day, in our not taking the necessary steps to warn these people of what is coming and to try to get them to brace themselves by actual deeds and not by a display of heroics for meeting such a dangerous situation.

I said at the outset that I thought this Budget failed to measure up to what was demanded of it today, that it is in no sense adequate to the situation confronting the country in the fields of emigration, unemployment and employment and that it does nothing whatsoever to meet the challenge of the ogre of the trading conditions in Europe. However, it represents apparently the accumulation of the constructive effort of the Fianna Fáil Party for four years—a trifle to the old age pensioners and a trifle to the payers of income tax. These are to be compensations for the abolition of the food subsidies and the imposition of new taxation in 1957 and subsequent years. As a Budget, it spreads the butter very thinly on the bread for the taxpayer. He sees a bit of butter and he is induced to believe there is more there than he can see or believes is there.

It is a poor Budget, against all the speeches which have been made over the past two years. It is a poor Budget, if it is to be accepted as a measure of the buoyancy and the prosperity towards which we were told we were riding by Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Government. The Budget fails to appreciate the necessities of the times and represents a monument to the failure of the Fianna Fáil Party to redeem the glittering promises they made in 1957 in order to get back to office to do what now turns out to be only a disappointing frustration.

Comment on this