Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).
Contributions 123–251 of 251. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I think the last speaker has been as long in this House as any Deputy and for as long as I can remember having an active interest in public affairs, I have been intrigued by his speeches from the Labour benches. On every occasion, they have set out to contain a plan and many people had come to believe that the Labour Party and its leader, as he then was, had the cure for all our illnesses, the panacea for all our evils, and that one day they would be unfolded to the people of Ireland.
His big opportunity was when a Coalition Government came into power and placed him in the key position of giving to this country the use of the great brain which he had threatened for so many years. He had the active support of two other members of his Party to back him up in an indispensable link with that Government. The people were sadly disillusioned. I do not have to go over the ground again. However, it was only three years and we were told that, had the time been longer, something would have fructified.
After another pause, the people of Ireland said perhaps he did not get a proper chance and they put him back in office again and, again, the master mind failed to produce one suggestion. A Deputy who can condemn everybody and who has a cure for every evil, from the question of the Common Market down to agriculture, did not produce one iota of a plan, any more than any of his colleagues.
Then the people are frustrated when, in 1961, they are again told that there is only one way of solving our problems. It is a secret method but it is there: it is available to the people of Ireland. There is a secret method of solving all our ills—put the Coalition Government back into power again. Let us not have too much of these things because the public must be frustrated at this stage. Emigration started in 1957—according to the speech we have just heard.
Comment on this
I said it has been with us for many years. I am sorry the Parliamentary Secretary cannot hear.
Comment on this
I remember being contradicted when I was on the Opposition benches when I told the then Minister for Industry and Commerce that houses were closing up and people were going abroad. What are we to gain by reminding ourselves of this time and again? The implication and insinuation always is: "You are responsible for it; if we were there, we would stop it."
Comment on this
Because you went into power on the strength of doing something about it and you finished up by having more harm done than good.
Comment on this
There has been emigration since 1847. That does not mean to say that the position cannot be rectified, but there is no person in Ireland, outside this House, anyhow, who would for a moment think that it can be done overnight. One way would be to close the ports and refuse permission to people to go. That is a way nobody wants to adopt. Even after we can provide work for everybody, we must face the fact that there will still be a certain amount of emigration.
What we want to know is whether we are moving in the right direction. The present Budget is a good, honest indication that the foundations of an expanding economy are well and truly laid. Contrast the position with 1957. If we cast our minds back, we shall readily realise the improvement in the past four years. I have as much contact with the people of the country as anybody in this House and probably more than most. I met good, solid supporters of Fine Gael who candidly admitted: "No matter what happens, we do not want to see another period like that."
There is one absolutely essential thing to progress in any country, that is, stability of Government. Whether or not the people on the Opposition benches believe it, there was no confidence in the Government in power in this country prior to 1957. We have heard many accusations as to why we came back to office in 1957. I have been told that promises of thousands of jobs and of the solution of emigration were the cause of it. I fought that election. I fought several elections before it, like other Deputies. Nobody needed to make any promise to get a Fianna Fáil seat in 1957, unless he was a fool. The people said, in effect: "What we want is to get rid of what we have." We pointed out from our platforms time and time again that we were not making any promise, without knowing what the situation was likely to be. How right we were.
Comment on this
Nobody has ever yet tried to explain how the Coalition Government would have balanced the Budget on that occasion, had they come back to power. It is a very simple thing to say: "You got into power in 1957 but we still have emigration." People probably have a better knowledge of the intelligence of their supporters but I wonder if that is sufficient to help their confidence. I do not think it is.
Deputy Norton accused us of not telling the people more about what should be done with regard to the Common Market, if we decide to join. Listening to him, I had the feeling that the people responsible for industrialisation must be a crowd of dupes who are not capable of appraising any position for themselves. I think you can take it that in industry in this country at the moment there is a very intelligent core of hard-headed businessmen who could teach Deputy Norton and the rest of us a few things about industry, rather than that we should go out and tell them what should happen.
Deputy Norton was interested in agriculture. He did not give us his opinion about the income tax question Deputy Byrne spoke of—to tax the farmers further—in which the Labour Party have secretly been interested for a long time. Nor did he explain when he agreed with the alleviation of income tax on industry, why his colleague, now the Leader of the Labour Party, saw fit to condemn it in his speech over Radio Eireann recently when he conjured up a picture of 4½d. a week to one class and much greater relief for what he described as the wealthy class. I could only infer one thing from that statement—that he was not in agreement with the relief given to industry on super-tax. That exposes the kernel of what I have been trying to put as mildly as possible without hurting anybody's feelings—that no two members on that side of the House agree on whether the Budget is good or bad, right or wrong.
There is one thing that can be said of this Budget: it is an election Budget, not in the sense that the Opposition think it is an election Budget. It is an election Budget where the Minister has in mind the knowledge that he also will be balancing the next Budget and that he will be in a position to give even a better Budget. A Coalition election Budget is a dishonest effort to create an impression that there is something to give away that is not there and God help the man who has to meet the situation in the following Budget. That is what we have had to do on quite a few occasions. Whoever balances the Budget I hope we shall never resort to those tactics again. Let us face the situation as we find it, give what any expansion of our economy justifies and do no more and no less. If we are not able to give, let us not give.
It would be a very spectacular thing to give the old age pensioners an extra 10/- a week. In my view, there is not a single allowance paid in this country that could not justifiably be doubled. It is a great thing when you can get up in Opposition and make veiled references, or suggest by innuendo, that something should be done but when you are on this side of the House you do not do it. There is a limit to the resources available and I think the Minister has allocated them justly and honestly. One heartening thing in the Budget is that our finances are in a healthy condition. They have been handled judiciously. The outlook for the future is one of continuing improvement and I believe that by every test this must be regarded as a good Budget.
Comment on this
The tone of this debate has changed somewhat. When the Minister finished his Budget speech there were happy and contented smiles on the faces of his colleagues. They were under the impression that the Budget would be received with acclamation throughout the country and that all in the garden was lovely. The speech we have just heard from the very able Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance was an apologia for Fianna Fáil, a defence of the policy which the Deputies now know—having been down the country—is not being received with any enthusiasm by any section of the community. In the debates I have read, the charge has been made against this Party that we have not referred to the Budget but discussed overall policy. We are entitled to discuss overall policy because one can only judge the policy of a Government by the statement of one of its leading Ministers, the Minister for Finance.
We have been told by Ministers in the last six or seven months that economically our situation is so good that it is unparalleled in the history of the State. It is only natural to assume, in the words of the Minister himself when he spoke in the Seanad recently, that this would be a good Budget, that the country was economically sound and that they were in a position therefore to offer reliefs to the general public that they had not got before; that this was a result of four or five years of good Government. I do not propose to go into Deputy Sweetman's argument, but when the Minister sat down after his Budget speech and when happy and contented members of his Party were smiling gleefully over the Minister's statement and over the Budget, Deputy Sweetman got up and literally cut the heart out of Fianna Fáil policy. He showed that they had been loading taxation on the people unremittingly. I challenge the Minister for Finance to deny that he has imposed taxation on every section of the community and I shall get up and withdraw if he can show that there is a single section of the community on which he has not imposed taxation, whether farmers, industrialists or income-tax payers.
The Minister laughs because he can do what he likes; he has seventy per cent. of the Deputies behind him. They are there on a policy they cannot carry out—a majority the electorate gave them. After imposing taxes on every section the Minister now comes along and takes off a few pence. He gives the income tax payers 6d. or 8d., a wonderful thing for the Minister to do. The trouble is that they expected a lot more. The Minister laughs again. Of course he does, because every Minister was foolish enough to go about saying that this country was more solvent than any other in Europe, that it was better than it had ever been before, and then the Minister offers the taxpayers, who have had the life and soul blistered out of them by Fianna Fáil, 8d. in the pound as a great concession.
When the Minister came into office he produced, in his first Budget speech, £250,000 for marketing. We were to have a new look in agriculture. What the Coalition, as they described it, could not do, they would do. We could not keep the cattle trade right but they had £250,000 specially provided for them. After four years the Minister spent £36,000—would he like to deny that? He is Minister for Finance and he comes from the premier tillage county in Ireland which he and I have the honour to represent. That £36,000 was spent on commissions, not on appointing anybody who might be likely to get us markets in any countries abroad, in any of the emergent countries. It has been spent on commissions and a continuation of the same policy.
What other relief has the Minister given? Has he given the industrialists, who are particular friends of the Fianna Fáil Party, any particular relief on machinery? Has he given them any particular relief in relation to plant depreciation to ensure for them conditions parallel with those which their counterparts enjoy in other countries, countries with which we have to compete in the world markets? I could not find anything in the Budget on those lines. There are reliefs in taxation; there is relief in relation to super-tax; there is a certain relief in relation to death duties, a relief long overdue. We have been told by the Taoiseach, by the Minister for Finance, by the Minister for Transport and Power and the Minister for Industry and Commerce that we are a healthy, solvent State. In the light of that, we naturally expect a little more.
It was alleged that Deputies on this side of the House were afraid to talk about this Budget. We have in this Budget the Fianna Fáil hardy annual. We have an increase in taxation on tobacco. We are told this increase is necessary to provide more benefits. The policy of this Government has consistently been a policy of increasing taxation. The Minister may deny that. It is a perfectly accurate statement. There is greater taxation today and greater expenditure in administration than there was before the Minister took office. That is the sorry story to be told.
There is apparently no intention of making any change in policy. The Minister has put aside £1,000,000 for Supplementary Estimates. Before he sat down, and while all the Deputies of his Party were smiling over this wonderful Budget, he hastened to tell us that he does not think there will be a Supplementary Estimate. Last year, we had £14,000,000 for Supplementary Estimates. We have had Supplementary Estimates every year since this Government took office. Does not every Deputy in the Fianna Fáil Party, even the most unenlightened, know perfectly well that a supplementary Budget will have to be produced after the general election?
With regard to general policy, is this House satisfied that our present economic development is sound? Let us review the position. There is an increase of 4 per cent in production. The average increase in the O.E.E.C. countries is six per cent. and some have gone as high as eight per cent. Most of these have full employment and, where there is full employment, it is difficult to increase the percentage of production. A developing country, such as we are, is more happily situated. Does the Minister think an increase of four per cent. something upon which to congratulate himself?
Judging by the reports of chamber of commerce meetings addressed by Fianna Fáil Ministers—meetings of ten to 15 people, or perhaps 50, if it should happen to be a banquet—the Government think that a four per cent. increase in production is indicative of an enormous expansion. The O.E.E.C. countries have a greater increase and they have full employment. We are told employment is improving here. The figures speak for themselves. About 7,000 have left the land and 5,900 have gone into industrial production. Is that something on which the Government can congratulate themselves?
The Minister represents the same constituency as I represent. Emigration from Wexford in the past three years has been positively appalling. He will have experience of the situation when he goes out to campaign; where he had 20 or 30 people at his meetings, he will find himself now with ten or 15. The rest have gone to England. Emigration is one of the greatest tragedies that has ever happened in this country. The people are getting fed up with all this talk about industrial expansion, about an improving economy and about our never having it so good before. We are told the balance of payments position is satisfactory and the economists proclaim the condition of the country is improving.
What does all this mean to the ordinary person? Where will he get a job? We had opportunities in Wexford of starting industries but it was impossible to hold the people because greater benefits offered elsewhere. Legislation was passed here—the Minister was not personally responsible for it—and the results of that legislation are clear for all to see. People have been unable to get employment and they have had to leave the country and seek a living elsewhere. On the other hand, money has been poured into the undeveloped areas for the purpose of starting industries. With what result? Emigration from Sligo is appalling. Emigration from Mayo is bad, as is emigration from Galway, Kerry, and all along the western seaboard. This Government have no policy apparently to check emigration.
It would not be fair to criticise the Government without giving them some indication of what they might do along certain lines. Of course, they will not have time to do anything now because they will not be in power long enough. Fundamentally, what is necessary to keep the people on the land is a good standard of living. There has been instability in agricultural marketing in the past three years. Six weeks ago, there was a rise in prices but that rise has disappeared again absolutely and completely. When the British Minister of Food comes here, I hope the Minister for Finance and his Government will be able to do something about that problem.
The economic situation has been changing over the past four years. We have seen the emergence of new nations in greater numbers than at any period in the history of the world. All the other countries of O.E.E.C. have been endeavouring to get markets in these countries. I have no evidence from travelling abroad, or from reading newspapers or economic journals, that there has been any attempt on the part of this administration to seek any new market. They seem to have based their policy on one thing and on one thing alone—and I am referring now to agriculture: the expenditure of huge sums of money on the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. If they did that and got the people to use more fertilisers, they believed they would save the Irish agricultural economy.
Does any Deputy believe that that has been a successful policy? If Wexford were an attested county— which it is not, for some reason I do not know—have we any guarantee that we would have a complete and continuous market at stabilised prices for agricultural produce? The answer is "no" because when you have sales where you have attested and unattested produce, you cannot rely on the prices and so long as you have that state of affairs, you will have emigration.
Have this Government any plans to deal with the emerging situation in Europe? There are two economic blocs. There are the “Seven”—who are now eight—known as the E.F.T.A. group and the “Six”, known as the E.E.C. Have the Government made any attempt to look for a market in those areas or have they made any attempt to move with the times? I am not suggesting they should join the “Six” or the “Seven.” I have a certain amount of knowledge in the matter but I have not got the inside information which is available to the Minister for Finance and his advisers, but I do know that in Europe to-day the E.E.C. have a purchasing power equal to that of the United States of America. I do know that in the setting up of the 20-nation group which includes Europe, North America and Canada, the “Six,” apart from representation from their own individual countries in this group, have a special representative appointed to that organisation so that overall problems of trade may be dealt with by the “Six.”
What have the Government done to meet that situation? They have appointed a representative—I think it is our Ambassador in Belgium—to deal with the E.E.C. market and there is one other official in that office. Anybody who knows anything about foreign affairs or trade knows perfectly well that one man and an assistant are not sufficient to deal with such matters. If the Government are really serious in looking for markets, they should do something about the matter.
The Minister referred to the changing situation in Europe, to the E.F.T.A. and the E.E.C., and I gather he told us he was alive to the situation. Is that the way to be alive? The Greeks, who found themselves in very much the same position as we were, were a poorer country. They did not mind admitting that they were poor. They had not got a lot of Ministers going around telling everybody how wealthy they were. They realised, with the formation of the "Six," that here was a potential market, something worth fighting for. Why did our Government not do the same? The Greeks sought an external association. They had some difficulties in procuring what they wanted and it took them a considerable period but at least they did so.
When the Minister is replying, can he tell us, on behalf of the Government, if they have done anything to try to get into this rich market, anything at diplomatic or trade level, so that we might be consolidating exports, agricultural exports in particular, which we are not sending to Britain, anything left over, and trying to send them into this rich market which is so much closer to us than the United States of America and which, as I said, has the purchasing power of the United States.
I am telling the House this because I want to show Dáil Éireann that I believe this Government have no policy. They have been over four years in office and this is the Minister's fifth Budget. He probably was not responsible for the first and he can throw the blame back on us, if he wishes. In the long economic statement which the Minister read to Dáil Éireann, there was no policy. They have no policy except to encourage foreign investors to come here, a policy largely initiated by the Government which held office before them.
They have that policy of trying to bring people in here from outside to start industries and the only other policy they have is the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. When they have eradicated bovine tuberculosis, they imagine the British will buy everything we have. That is their policy in a nutshell. The other item of policy is to balance the Budget and have what is considered by economists and bankers to be a sound economy, even though the manpower of Ireland is being exported. The best manpower and womanpower is going out of this country and if they send back money from the pay packets they earn in Birmingham or Coventry and other places, the economists are happy because the money is coming back and balancing the Budget. That is the policy of Fianna Fáil; that is the policy the Minister adumbrated to this House. I am prepared to take my chance with the rest in the general election and I can tell the Minister that no matter what the economists or bankers say about the economy being sound, as long as we are losing our manpower and have a Government such as we have, a Government without a policy, he will get his answer from the people and the sooner he gets it the better.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance referred to the importance of the members of the different Parties breaking away from the old policy of blaming the other Party. I agree with him to a certain degree, but I was surprised when I found him attacking all who did not agree with the Minister's Budget or with Fianna Fáil policy. He saw fit to criticise Deputy Norton and other members of the Labour Party. I am not speaking simply because I am a member of the Labour Party or because I am opposed to the Minister's policy or his Budget. I am speaking because I believe it is one period of the year when, if necessary, we must make an open confession and also draw attention to what we believe is either a good Budget or a bad Budget as it affects the people with whom we are directly concerned, the people in our constituencies and also the people we meet in our everyday lives.
Like Deputy Esmonde, I do not agree that we have a sound national economy. We have been told that we have a sound economy in recently published reports of banks and we have been told it by various economists. I have yet to hear of a banker or an economist signing at a labour exchange for unemployment benefit. The knowledge that these people have of how a Budget affects the people is very often confined by a narrow view.
On various occasions in this House, whether speaking as a member supporting an inter-Party Government or opposing Fianna Fáil, I have admitted that unemployment is a grave problem. The sore topic of unemployment has been discussed from all sides of the House on all occasions, whether the Government at the time were Fianna Fáil, Cumann na nGaedheal or inter-Party. We cannot get away from the fact that unemployment and emigration are anything but helpful to the people. The high rate of emigration, not merely this year but all the years back, coupled with the high rate of unemployment, is a clear answer to the banker, economist or Minister who may tell us that everything in the garden is lovely in 1961.
A great deal has been said by Deputy Norton with which I thoroughly agree and there is, therefore, no need for me to repeat what he said, but, having stressed the importance of the twin problems of unemployment and emigration, I think it well to draw attention to the booklet Economic Statistics issued in connection with the Budget. In reference to the suggestion that we have a sound balanced economy, the position shown on page 5 of the booklet is very interesting. There it is shown that, in 1960, import unit values rose by 1 per cent. and export unit values fell by 1 per cent. It must be admitted that we are running against the tide, taking the comparison between exports and imports as a basis for analysis of the sound economy about which the Minister has told us.
Wheat imports showed a drop from £8.5 million in 1959 to £3.4 million in 1960, due, not to any activity of the Government, but to an act of God, the poor harvest in 1958. There was also a decline in the import of ships, boats and parts, from £2.4 million to £0.7 million. If you take only one item, importation of wheat, it would not suggest an expanding economy that imports should run at such a level as against exports.
I want to be fair to the Minister and to all concerned in the compilation of the booklet. It is mentioned in the booklet that imports of materials for further production went up by £11.1 million. That may sound all right because such imports automatically mean a certain amount of employment and re-export; but does the Minister remember when he and prominent members of his Party attacked the inter-Party Government during the period of the Korean war, when stock-piling was essential? Does he remember the accusations of bad house-keeping cast at the Government during the period 1954-55 because of the increase in imports which were very important to us and which were based on materials and machinery for production and re-export? The only redeeming feature is that the Minister can say that imports during 1960 to the extent of £11.1 million were imports of materials for production. Perhaps it is not sufficient to let it go at that. It may be important to make another comparison.
In the same year, imports of petroleum products declined. That is not due to the wisdom of the Minister or to the help of the economists and pseudo-economists who have been telling us what we should do. I am not speaking of the Minister's advisers. The decline in the importation of petroleum products is due to the fact that the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the 1954-57 period insisted on the establishment of the refinery in Cork harbour, which is giving so much employment and which in future will be a help towards a truly balanced economy. Of course, one Deputy from East Cork claimed that it was he who was entitled to credit for that. In my opinion, the person entitled to the credit is Deputy Norton and the Government entitled to the credit are the inter-Party Government.
It is important at this stage, not alone to compare imports with exports, but to compare agricultural exports with industrial exports. I do not have to point out the effect of an increase in industrial exports. It is well that that is happening. It is a great help to the country. The Minister must admit, however, that the basic rock upon which we must depend and the foundation upon which we can hope to achieve success is agriculture and the raw materials for other industries provided by agriculture.
We hear a great deal about "sixes" and "sevens" nowadays. One time, if a person was a bit muddled, the expression was that he was at sixes and sevens. We are all at sixes and sevens when it comes to knowing what is the European situation. We hear talk of inner and outer circles and in that connection the Minister could have had a little word with one of the prominent members of his Party regarding some of the serious statements he made outside this country about the Six and the Seven. However, that will be relevant on one of the Estimates.
One Table in this booklet is worth mentioning, that is, Table 7, Agricultural Workers. As I have said, the criterion of success for any Budget must be whether it takes due cognisance of the position in regard to employment in rural areas as well as industrial areas. Table 7 sets out the number of males engaged in farm work in 1951 as compared with 1960. In 1951, there were 68.9 thousand permanent workers in agriculture. That was 1951 when the Fianna Fáil Party were taking over again from an inter-Party Government, after a three-year period about which Deputy Brennan, the Parliamentary Secretary spoke, saying that after three years of inter-Party Government, the country was almost destroyed. In 1960, the figure dropped to 50.6 thousand. In other words, in 1951, there were 18.3 thousand more in permanent agricultural employment than in 1960. That situation affects not only me but Deputy MacCarthy and Deputy Manley because the three of us represent South Cork which is mainly rural. It is quite true to say that there were in South Cork in 1951 men engaged in agriculture known to Deputy MacCarthy, Deputy Manley and myself who are now in England.
The pattern for those employed on a temporary basis is completely different. In 1951, the number was 38.6 thousand which, in 1960, dropped to 38.4, a difference of only .2. However, the tragedy of it, known to the Minister, to economists and bankers alike, is that the man who is employed in a temporary capacity, whether in agriculture or in industry, cannot hope to maintain himself, a wife and a family in such circumstances. Directly related to the emigration figures which have been given here, not alone for this year or for the past three or four years that Fianna Fáil have been in Government but for all the years back, is the elimination to such a large degree of the farm workers in rural Ireland.
I wish to draw attention to a question put down by me on 25th April, 1961, because I was not satisfied with Table 10 on page 24 of the statistical returns. I thought they should be broken down and that a little more information should be available about the state of the farm worker and the forestry worker in rural Ireland. What are the figures? In 1956 wages and salaries in agriculture amounted to £17.8 million. It went from that to £18.2 million in 1957. In 1958, it came back to £17.8 million and in 1959, it moved slightly to £18 million. Where is the indication that the farm worker is prospering? These are the figures given by the Minister himself. Do not let us fool ourselves because we are not fooling the farm workers. In face of these figures, how can we be surprised that these workers are leaving the Twenty-Six Counties?
Take forestry, which we have been told is in a prosperous state. Table 10 shows that, in 1956, wages and salaries in forestry amounted to £1.3 million and in 1959, to £1,000,000. That is another indication of the expanding economy and the reward to be gained by those staying to work in rural Ireland. In relation to fisheries, Table 10 shows that wages and salaries in 1956 amounted to £.8 million and, in 1959, jumped to the colossal sum of £1 million, an increase of £.2 million.
I believe, interested as I am in the position of the people of rural Ireland as much as that of those in the towns and cities, that we are deceiving ourselves when we say we do not know what is causing emigration. The answer is there for us if we want to see it. I have condemned others who preceded this Minister and this Government, but I have yet to see a Fianna Fáil Deputy do anything but praise his own Ministers, even when he has had a poorer record than a Minister in the inter-Party Government who had been attacked by all.
If we study this booklet, we find there was a decline in the livestock numbers in 1960 as against 1959. I know we cannot hope that these figures will remain static, and perhaps it would be too much to hope that they might improve, but surely our policy should be towards an increase in those numbers, rather than having them remain static, or, far worse, showing a decrease? It all boils down to the fact that while we talk of the wonderful activities with regard to exports in the industrial field, we are closing our eyes and fooling ourselves with regard to the export situation in the agricultural sphere.
We must remember that the backbone of any economic success, whether we like it or not, must be directly related to prosperity in agriculture. Perhaps it is too much to hope now for the return of some of those men who have emigrated from the rural areas. When they were here, they were not appreciated. Their return in wages and salaries as shown in this booklet was anything but Christian, fair and just. It is no use, therefore, for us to sit back and study any of these papers. Some of our industrial concerns break even and there is an increase in the output to the shareholders, notwithstanding the fact that the hidden profit is there because of the extra scrip and the free tickets, as it were. We have followed the pattern of Britain and America in that regard.
Perhaps we have an expanding economy, but if we have, it is expanding in some spheres and sectors only. It is, perhaps, showing itself in certain parts of Dublin and Cork, but it is only in limited areas and confined to certain individuals. That will not help the country. It will not help the Minister or the Government or the Opposition, because I am afraid that if the Opposition got into office in the morning, they would not do very much more. I believe it is time for us to try, at any rate, to break through some policies of the past. What is wrong is that we are afraid we might step on the toes of some people and either hurt them or get hurt ourselves in the process.
The Minister gave an increase in social welfare benefits. I would prefer if that increase were much bigger. The Minister has not done much worse in that respect than other Ministers. I did not stand up here to lambaste him and say that everything was grand when someone else was Minister. He may say that he could not give any more to those unfortunate people. May I make a few suggestions?
When the Minister was examining the returns submitted to him from every Department, could he not have found it possible to cut down a bit on the squandermania in the Department of Defence? Could he not have found it possible to tell another Minister that he would have to wait another year or two for the luxuries some people will enjoy and which increase the Estimate covering broadcasting and television? Should the widow and the orphan not come before these? Could the Minister not say—and indeed if he did, he would be telling the truth—that more money was squandered by the setting up of the famous or infamous Ministry of Transport and Power than was ever known in the country before—not by the officials concerned, but by his own colleague who is going around the country telling people how to run their business? Could the Minister not have pared down on those items? If he did, I would agree with him and say he was making a valiant attempt to give us what we all wish for, a balanced economy based on fair play and justice to all, and with no special concessions to some.
The Minister must know that one of the serious problems confronting the people and imposed upon them by the action of the Fianna Fáil Government was the complete silencing—the sending to Siberia, as it were—of the Prices Advisory Body. Time was when that little booklet, Gléas, issued by Fianna Fáil, was sent out regularly reminding the people of the terrible inter-Party Government, of the terrible increases in the price of different commodities, reminding the people of every halfpenny added to every item. That little paper is missing now, of course. It would not do to tell the people of the increases now, and above all, it would not do to tell the people that the Prices Advisory Body had been silenced, in case, being determined to do their work, they drew the attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to the overcharging which is taking place in different parts of the country, as well as in Dublin.
The Minister may praise himself or take credit for the Government for the amount of money—£2,000,000 or so— that has been handed out for industrial employment indirectly through industrial grants. No one would oppose the spending of money on the creation of employment. I have expressed myself as being in full agreement with the views expressed by Deputy Norton. We would far prefer to see young Irish boys or girls earning money in their own country from foreigners, if such employment would keep them from going to England.
We must not forget—and this has happened under different Governments —that we have gone out of our way to get industrialists to come in here. I give credit to both Governments for being determined to try to create additional employment. We gave many liberal grants; we gave many concessions; we gave benefits under the tax code with regard to exports; but still, no later than last Friday, I met a young woman who told me that her wage packet, at the end of a week's employment with industrialists who get a fine handsome amount of money by way of grant, is £2. We have flogged Irish industrialists for paying only £2 a week but apparently we dare not say anything to those other industrialists.
We must close our eyes because apparently we are privileged that they came in here. We hand them grants and they make their profits, but there is nothing to stop them from leaving this country in five or six years' time, if there is an international recession in trade. They could leave us our factories and our unemployment, and in the minds of many young Irish people would be the bitter knowledge that the Irish Government could not insist on those industrialists paying a decent wage to Irish men and women employed in their own country.
Those industrialists do not come here for love of the Minister or for love of Deputy Norton or any one of us, but to make their profits. Surely all Parties must admit that if we want to keep emigration down at as low a level as possible, we cannot succeed unless we are determined that anyone coming to this country and getting grants and other benefits will, in return, pay a decent wage to Irish men and women in their own country.
The Minister has found it suitable to give other benefits. He has found it suitable to give an amount of money by way of a grant to people in the hotel business. I agree with that. An awful lot of money is being spent on the improvement of hotels at the moment and I notice that a few Ministers seem to be on pretty friendly terms with the hoteliers because they find occasion to be present at the official openings. However, with all the benefits they are getting they are still robbing the people—not all of them but a lot of them. When visitors come to this country they are appalled by the charges of Irish hotels. There was a time when a booklet was published every year giving details of the charges but now it appears that there is no control on their overcharging.
There might be some reason in it if the State were not coming to their aid by way of grants although the Minister may say that we are receiving so much from tourism that an advantage will accrue to us. In the first page of the booklet Economic Statistics, it is stated that the amount of money spent by tourists in this country rose from £37.8 million in 1959 to £42.4 million in 1960. On the other hand, the amount spent by Irish people going abroad increased by £2.2 million so that our net profit on that whole transaction amounts to £2.2 million. That, at a time when these people are charging fantastic prices, not only to tourists who come here but to the unfortunate Irish people whose tax payments are helping to provide grants for these very hotels. I would ask the Minister to realise what a drastic step it was when the Minister for Industry and Commerce, probably in conjunction with the Minister for Finance, found it suitable to drop the Prices Advisory Body. Such a body is badly needed. We are providing grants for people who are not satisfied with what they are getting but who want more.
My last remark today relates to a matter for which I cannot blame the Minister but for which I do blame both this Government and the inter-Party Government. We are told that there is a relief of eightpence for the income taxpayer. That is good for those who will benefit by it. There is 1/6d. being given to the recipients of social benefits. It may be said by the Minister that he is giving something to everybody. I wonder what is he giving to that section of the community which comes in under Table 5 of Economic Statistics, the banking returns about which a lot has been written? Table 5 is a very interesting one. I wonder do the profits accruing under this Table amount only to eightpence as in the case of the income taxpayer or to 1/6d. which is the amount the social welfare recipients are getting?
Both Governments are at fault in this. When they tell the people what they are getting under social welfare, they make a lot of it. What are we paying out under our present economic system for such important matters as housing, sewerage and water supplies? If the Minister wants a loan, or if I want a loan, it is a private transaction but it is a different matter where loans are required by the nation for capital works. I am not saying that the Government should threaten these people with dire results if they do not provide money at a certain rate of interest, but there is no justification for any section of the community holding the whole State to ransom by the high rate of interest which they are charging the Minister and which the Minister will have to pay for the floating of a national loan.
I am blaming both Governments for it and the plain truth of the matter is that we are paying too much in interest to those who are holding the country to ransom. Both the Minister and myself are anxious to see more houses built for rural workers and for the town workers in the constituencies we represent. It is grand to see the great work done by Dublin Corporation in this regard, but at what a terrible price? We are paying too much to these people who, in actual fact, are drawing the life blood of the true economy of this country. We are giving them more that we are giving to any other section of the community.
I know that the Minister may not be able to deal with the matter. I wonder if any Party in this House would be able to deal with it? I wonder would they even be prepared to try to deal with it? So long as we are paying these high rates of interest we are not doing our best for the people, for the aged and infirm, for the farm worker or for the agriculturist himself. We know that emigration is continuing and that, to a large extent, is due to the fact that in 1956 these people played a stronger part in the affairs of this country than they should have been allowed to. They are still doing that.
Comment on this
We have had a fairly long debate. I mean to deal with as many points as possible, but if I have not a note of any point raised, it is not to be taken as an insult to the Deputy concerned.
Deputy Russell objected to the amalgamation of the special import levies with ordinary import duties for two reasons: one, that they should properly be regarded as capital items; and, two, that we should get rid of them as soon as possible. We have to remember that when we took over office in 1957, these import duties were calculated to yield £4,000,000. They are now down to £1,000,000. In the meantime, some of them were converted into permanent duties, but the greater part of them was abolished. Those remaining could be regarded as duties on semi-luxuries. It is probably the best form of taxation, where taxation is needed, that it should be imposed on semi-luxuries of that kind.
Deputy Russell also talked of foreign capital coming in. He said it was not sound finance that it should come in. In the same speech, he congratulated the country—and incidentally, I suppose, the Government—for the balance in our external payments. Deputy Russell is illogical in making these two points. If foreign capital is coming in and if, at the same time, we are balancing our payments, then no harm is being done. We have absorbed that capital and paid for it by exports of some kind. In fact, since we are balancing our payments and going a bit further, it means we are actually exporting capital. We are sending out money which is to our credit outside and is, therefore, potential capital, if at any time we should want to call upon it.
Deputy Russell, although he made a fair speech on many points, attacked the Government for appointing Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries who, he said, were not necessary. We have now the same number of Ministers as the Coalition Government had when they were leaving office, and we have a Parliamentary Secretary less. I just mention that so that Deputy Russell will see he is a biased Deputy as far as these two Governments are concerned. He is always ready to attack this Government and compare our performance with the performance of the Coalition Government—to our disadvantage, of course.
Deputy Byrne said it would have been better if, instead of reducing the standard rate of income tax, we had given better personal allowances. It must be remembered that the personal allowances are very good already. Under P.A.Y.E., up to £6 per week is exempted from income tax in the case of a single man; up to £10 per week in the case of a married man; and up to £19 per week in the case of a married man with three children. These figures show that the personal allowances are very good indeed. I had some figures produced for me on this matter and I found we compared favourably with other European countries on this very issue. I might mention again that the standard rate of income tax is now down to a figure it has not reached for 20 years previous to this.
Deputy Byrne also said that repair allowances should be granted in respect of Schedule A assessments on house property and that the poor law valuation should take into account any necessary repairs. As a matter of fact, that is so. The inspector who goes out to fix the poor law valuations must take into account the ordinary outgoings, which will include repairs, and what might be expected by way of rent. On the net income from that rent after the outgoings are deducted, the poor law valuation is fixed. Therefore, that matter is being looked after.
We heard a good many speeches from Fine Gael, but very little policy. There was a lot of criticism—criticism that could be directed against their own Government as well as this—and a lot of criticism based on misrepresentation. But very few, if any, speakers from the Fine Gael benches stated what the Fine Gael policy was on any particular issue. I asked Deputy O'Sullivan, when he was attacking the sur-tax provisions, whether he was speaking on behalf of Fine Gael—in other words, if he was stating Fine Gael policy—and he said: "yes." But I found it very difficult to get any Deputy from the Fine Gael side to give us the Fine Gael policy on any other matters raised. We have at least that one point made clear—that the Fine Gael Party are against this change in the sur-tax system.
Deputy O'Sullivan was attacking this sur-tax change. He mentioned the things that could have been done instead, but he completely ignored the amount this sur-tax change is costing. Some of the suggestions he made would cost £1,000,000 a year. He ignored the fact that the change made in the sur-tax is costing only £100,000 per year, and in these times you can do very little for anybody with that. Anybody who read this Budget in an intelgent way will see that you cannot do anything for any section of the population, unless you have at least £500,000, if not £1,000,000. That £100,000, as I explained in the Budget, was provided not so much to give a relief to people who needed it badly as to streamline the income tax and sur-tax system.
I explained in the Budget speech it was intended to accept the recommendations of the Income Tax Commission to amalgamate income tax and sur-tax, to have the one assessment issued for both, and to have the same collector and the same cheque payable for both. In order to provide for that amalgamation, it was necessary to change the sur-tax system to some extent. As everybody knows, when you change a system like that, if you do not want anybody to suffer by the change, you must provide a little money to deal with marginal cases and, as I say, it came to £100,000. I am not apologising for it; I am just explaining how this £100,000 arose.
Deputy Crotty spoke of the price of wheat, and I think Deputy Flanagan also spoke on this subject. I wonder why the members of Fine Gael do not try to take an intelligent view of such a matter? They are not going to get anywhere by making an attack like that simply because they want to attack something. What was done by the Fianna Fáil Government on the price of wheat? A change was made in the price of wheat which was, to all intents and purposes, unmillable. The price was reduced and the reason was that if wheat like that comes to the mill, and it has to be sent out as feed, somebody must pay for it. I do not think that a farmer who produces bad wheat like that should get a subsidy. As far as I am concerned, we do not want that type of inefficient farming and we do not want to reward the farmer for bringing bad wheat to the mill.
Comment on this
Neither are we. Last year was a very bad year, but I met a number of farmers last year who produced very good wheat. They were the people who asked me why we should pay the full price for bad wheat. It is the good farmers who are in favour of what we are doing in this respect. What do the Fine Gael Party know about farming? Out of their 40 members, there are only eight farmers. How could they know anything about farming? I can make out the case that this reduction in price will benefit the good grower because whenever there is too much wheat in this country a levy is struck off every grower to pay for taking their wheat from the mills to sell for feed. If a farmer's wheat bushels somewhere as low as 56, it is taken from the millers and sent out for feed and he gets compensation up to 60/- per barrel, which it is not worth, and the good grower, whose wheat bushels from 60 to 64, is paying that levy.
It is only justice that the grower of good wheat should not have to compensate the grower of bad wheat. That is why the change in the price of wheat had my full support and advocacy on behalf of the good farmers in Wexford who were growing good wheat. Not a single one of them objected to that policy. It is all right for Deputy O.J. Flanagan and Deputy Crotty, who know nothing about farming, to say things like that.
Comment on this
Fine Gael speakers get up here and think it is their duty to look after the small farmers and to say that Fianna Fáil are not concerned with the farmers. Is it not extraordinary that I can look around here and see 15 or 20 farmers behind me and Fine Gael, out of their whole Party, can show only seven or eight farmers? Still they talk about Fianna Fáil being against the Irish farmers.
What test do they apply? The test they talk about is that the small farmers are flying from the land. Apply that test to Fine Gael themselves and we find that, in the last period in which they were in office, 27,000 emigrated and that during the past four years that figure has been cut to at least 20,000. So it is not as bad as Fine Gael would have us believe. As I said in my Budget speech—and I admitted that emigration was far too high—even if emigration is high now it was higher still when the Coalition Government were there. That being the position, why should we find fault with each other about emigration? Why do we not admit that none of us has succeeded in fully solving the problem?
Comment on this
Reverting to the small farmer, the Taoiseach was criticised because he said we intended to pay special attention to their problem. Do Fine Gael resent that? Are Fine Gael afraid we are taking that one last argument from them? Why should they resent the fact that we are going to pay special attention to the small farmer? We all know it is hard for the small farmer to make a living on the ordinary income from farming in this country which is about £20 per acre. The gross income of a small farmer with 20 acres is very small. He has not much to live on. It would appear, therefore, that we should tackle the position of the small farmer from the point of view that he is able to provide manual labour on his own land when the big farmer is not. We should help him to compete more successfully on that footing and there is one item which we hope will come into this picture in a big way—the growing of fruit and vegetables for processing and export. That is one of the best things coming along to help the small farmers. There are other things which we can examine and, if possible, adopt.
There were many Fine Gael speakers here during the debate and they all made the same point—that Fianna Fáil were neglecting the small farmers. Yet not one of them made any suggestion as to what we could do. I should very much like to know if any of them really had a suggestion or if they could tell me what they themselves did.
Comment on this
They are getting them. They are getting more contracts now than during the Coalition period. As a matter of fact we are growing more malting barley in the country. There is more prosperity now and more beer is being consumed. The big attack of the Fine Gael Party is that we are doing nothing for agriculture but are giving all our time to industry. That is a silly attitude and it is hardly worth my while wasting time over it. I wonder if, when they sit down to consider policy, Fine Gael decide industry should not be developed in this country? I think Fine Gael's talk in this connection is only more of their demagoguery.
Deputy Sweetman told me he found it difficult to verify the figures I gave with regard to Ireland's place in rehabilitation. I gave him the figures for 1959 and said that in that year we had a higher place in the European list than either France or Belgium. I got these figures from the O.E.E.C. General Statistics of January, 1961.
Comment on this
Ireland in 1959 had an increase of 2.7 per cent. France in 1959 had an increase of 2.1 per cent. Belgium in 1959 had an increase of 2.4 per cent. Therefore, actually, we did get a higher place than these two very well-developed countries.
Comment on this
I said in my Budget statement we had not yet reached the average but that we were within reach of it and would soon be there.
Comment on this
Next, Deputy Sweetman said I made the point that we had made a reduction over that period of £1½ million in indirect taxation. I started off the paragraph by saying "in the last three years". Therefore, it is quite clear that that is all right, as far as a period goes. The Deputy said that taking the last four years or three years or taking a given year, whatever way he took it, he could not make out the figures to be correct. It is quite clear that I was talking about the last three years, because the paragraph starts: "In the last three years." It may be that this point is somewhat confusing. The figures were taken as a full year's yield in each case, both for and against. New taxation was taken at a full year's yield and remission of taxation was also taken at a full year's yield. On that basis, the figure totted up to about £1½ million.
Comment on this
I shall ask the Minister a Parliamentary Question next week and we can argue the matter. I still think he is wrong.
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman did not altogether agree with Fianna Fáil government. He gave me the second 50 per cent. remission on profits for export. He thought it should have been better. The reason given at the time was that that had been given to the firms for further expansion of their business. I remember that instead of taking this money from them we decided we would leave the money with them to put it back into the business and build it up. The only difference between us is that Deputy Sweetman would perhaps have made sure they were doing it and, if you like, we did not. We said: "We will leave it with you for that purpose." I think it is being done in that way. I could not say it is being done in every case but I think it is.
I do not think the Deputy is right in making the point that, in our income tax arrangement by taking 8d. off the standard rate and by no longer allowing deduction of the corporation profits tax before taking income tax on companies, it has the effect of penalising investors at home as opposed to investors in outside firms.
Comment on this
I said that investors in foreign concerns would get more benefit than investors in home concerns.
Comment on this
I accept that. As far as I am concerned, that is all right. First of all, 98 per cent. of the companies will get practically full benefit from this income tax reduction to 6/4d. because the corporation profits tax they were paying was either nil or negligible. Therefore, they will get the full effect of the reduction. If you take the remainder, the bigger companies, they are practically all in the export business and therefore they are getting a very big benefit from income tax. In fact, most of them are getting a complete remission. Therefore, no matter what we give them further in income tax relief they could not take it because they are not paying anything. It means there are only some intermediate companies, as it were, who are not getting full remission on their profits because they are not exporting everything and at the same time they have not the full benefit of the 6/4d. rate that would be in question. However, it is not right to say either that an investor in a foreign company could do any better because the investor in the foreign company cannot get any better terms than the reduced standard rate.
The small Irish companies get that full benefit. The bigger companies get full remission of income tax and, as the Deputy is quite aware, I am sure, there is a range of rates from where a person is doing 100 per cent. export down to, say, ten per cent. export, all getting a different relief in income tax. Take it as half and half.
Comment on this
Take it as half and half. It would mean the company would pay half the rate, 3/2d. on its full profits. Therefore the investor in that company would be getting his dividend less that amount so he would be better off. There is no relief for a person who invested in a foreign company. Therefore he cannot do better as a result of what we are doing now than the person who has invested in an Irish company.
Comment on this
He cannot. He must bear the full rate of tax and therefore he cannot get any relief whatever. Another thing is that a person who is investing—in most Irish companies, at any rate—in an Irish company gets a 20 per cent. reduction in income tax under Section 20 of the 1932 Act.
The other point was in regard to the Civil Service. Many Deputies have attacked me on the Civil Service question and said I made great promises in my first Budget. I promised I would examine the whole machinery of the Civil Service to see what reductions could be made. In my first Budget I said I would have a saving of £250,000 in the Civil Service compared with the previous year and that saving was actually made. Since then, however, I have found that, with some of the bigger expansions going on, civil servants had to be provided. The scheme for the eradication of bovine tuberculosis has taken an enormous number of people.
Comment on this
Transport and Power is a very small Department. It does not take many people. The expansion of the telephone system requires a very large number of people. For these reasons, the cost of the Civil Service is going up. I said, however, I thought a rationalisation and reorganisation of the Civil Service should be possible. That has been done, to some extent. During the last year we reached the stage where four or five of the lower grades—writing assistant, typist, shorthand-typist, clerical officer and staff officer—have been amalgamated into one grade for the future. All these have been amalgamated into one grade for the time to come. If you have people in the Civil Service for 40 years and you have to wait for people to come in, it will be eight or 10 years before there will be much impression made under this new system, but somebody I hope will enjoy the benefit of this rationalisation.
Transport and power have been mentioned. That is another point evidently in the Fine Gael policy—attack transport and power. They think it is a good mark. We are devoting a lot of money to transport and power.
Comment on this
Let me say it. The shipping company, the air companies, C.I.E. and all the rest of them are being voted a lot of money but we are getting back our interest on it, something that no Government before us were able to do. We are getting our interest all the time from the air companies; the shipping company was earning interest but we always agreed to put it back into the company because they always needed more capital. It is going back as capital and, in fact, if you like, they are paying their way when they are able to pay interest on capital. We hope C.I.E. will pay interest in the coming year for the first time in their history, so that I think Transport and Power have done very well and I wish every other Department could pay for its loans as well as they are doing. I know that will not prevent Fine Gael propagandists from continuing their line of talk.
Deputy Norton spoke of many things and among them, the loaf. I admit the loaf has gone up in price but I did not think Deputy Norton would have the courage to talk about it. At any rate, we did not reduce the size of it. When we had to deal with it, we increased the price and we let the people have the same size loaf, but Deputy Norton, with the connivance and support of the Government of that time, thought he could hoodwink the people by not increasing the price but by reducing the size and passing off a smaller loaf on the people. I hope that no Fianna Fáil Government would resort to the contemptible type of subterfuge that Deputy Norton tried to bring off at that time.
Following in the footsteps of other Fine Gael speakers, Deputy Esmonde misrepresented me in several other things. He said that I said I did not think there would be any Supplementary Estimates this year. What I said was:
While I do not expect that Supplementary Estimates on current account will arise this year to the same extent as last year, I consider it would be imprudent not to make sizeable provision against the probability that some supplementaries will be unavoidable. I am, therefore, including £1,000,000 for this purpose.
That is a fair sample of what I may call Fine Gael misrepresentation in all the points they made in this debate. They do not seem to have any regard for truth. If it is a good point, they make it and the truth does not matter; it is not important, if you can get away with it.
Deputy Esmonde also said that income tax payers have had the tax increased in the past four years. Of course nothing could be further from the truth. We reduced the standard rate of income tax twice in that period; we also increased personal allowances. We also increased the earned income allowances on more than one occasion. That was the type of thing that was said by Fine Gael and by Deputy Esmonde without any foundation in truth.
Deputy Esmonde also asked me had I done anything for industry by way of depreciation allowances. I am not going to weary the House with that point because we have done everything a person could do by way of depreciation allowances in the past few years. It is very difficult to educate a man like Deputy Esmonde if he has not taken sufficient interest in the matter himself.
I have no great fault to find with Deputy Cosgrave's speech, except with regard to what he said about Army pay. It is a pity that a Deputy like Deputy Cosgrave, who is usually very fair in his comments here, should try to give the impression that the Army are being badly treated in the recent round of increases because it can only have the effect of making Army personnel discontented with what they got. Actually, they were well treated because every time there was an increase over the years—I am not referring to my time as Minister for Finance but for all time under all Governments— given to civil servants and others paid by the central authority, the Army got a similar increase based on the cost of living. In addition the Civil Service got what is known as a status increase over and above the cost of living increase in 1960 and that has been more than matched by our recent increases for the Army. Also, officers in the Army got children's allowances for the first time, so that really they have no complaint, or at least no complaint when they compare their lot with civil servants, local authority employees, teachers or any other class. They have been well treated and it does not serve any useful purpose to say otherwise here.
A number of Deputies spoke of the great increase in rates on agriculture in the past few years. A number of Deputies said that expenditure this year is the highest we have ever had in this country. Of course it is, and if we are all alive in five years' time, I am sure the same thing will be said because expenditure will be much higher then than it is now. It goes up all the time. You are sure to hit the nail on the head if you say it is the highest ever. The same sort of remark was made in regard to the rates on farmers.
Going back to the rate struck in 1953-54 when the Coalition came into office, it amounted in that year to £15,987,000. The rate that was struck in 1956-57 when they were leaving office was £19,700,000, so that the rates went up £3.7 million in their period of office. This year, the rate is £23.183 million. It has gone up £3.5 million in our five years of office, so that, while the Coalition were in for three years, the rate went up £3.7 million, but while we were in office for five years, it went up £3.5 million. As in the case of emigration and such matters the figure is very high and it is difficult for farmers to pay but if Fine Gael hold a solution to the problem, it would be better if, instead of passing the buck to us and saying: "You are responsible", they said: "We are responsible also; let us sit down now and see what we can do about it".
That would be a much more sensible approach. It would be better for the farmer. It would not be popular with Fine Gael as a Party but it would be much more popular with the farmers if we approached it in that way. That applies to many other spheres as well as the farming. I do not care what it is—emigration, rates, employment, unemployment, or anything else. We can say the position was worse under the Coalition Government, but that does not do very much good. It will not solve the problem. If we really want to solve the problem it would be much better to say that it is bad under us, that it was no better under the Coalition Government, and then ask ourselves what shall we do about it?
Some speaker made the point that cattle exports had decreased. They have never been as low as they were in 1956. We will leave it at that. Every Fine Gael speaker talked about the tobacco tax. We increased the tax three times out of a possible five times. That gave Deputies opposite some justification for their complaint but, in the whole three years, we put on 2d. one year, 1d. another year, and 1d. another year. That makes a total of 4d. Deputy Sweetman put on 5d. in one fell swoop.
Comment on this
Of course I did. Do not accuse me of being hard. I am not half as hard as the Deputy was when he was on these benches. Both of us increased the tax on petrol.
Comment on this
That is true and, if the Deputy comes in again, he will probably put some on top of mine.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish said he was appalled at the miserable pittance we gave the old age pensioners. Deputy Corish has, to say the least of it, a bit of a cheek. While Deputy Corish was Minister for Social Welfare, in the three years he was in office the cost of living went up by 11 points. In the last four years of Fianna Fáil administration it has gone up by 14 points. As against the 11 points rise in the cost of living, Deputy Corish gave the old age pensioners 2/6. As against the rise of 14 points we have given them 6/-. Yet, Deputy Corish gets up here and seeks the support of his friends on that side of the House when he talks of the miserable pittance we are giving the old age pensioners. Deputy Corish would have been much better advised not to say anything at all. I suppose what he would really like to have said, but he did not like to say it with the Fine Gael Party over there, was that he wished he could have done as well as we have done, but he was not allowed to.
Talking is no good. The Labour Party talk about the old age pensioners but, when they had the opportunity, they did not do much for them. The Minister for Social Welfare does not talk. He gets on with the job. He has given the old age pensioners 6/-. Deputy Corish talks, and gives them half-a-crown. That is the difference between us. Is action not better than words? I shall convey the Deputy's congratulations to the Minister for Social Welfare.
Comment on this
Now do not try to take the credit from him. He did something for the old age pensioners and the Deputy did very little. Leave it at that.
Comment on this
Including the removal of the food subsidies, the cost of living went up by 14 points as against 11 points under the Deputy. The Deputy gave the old age pensioners 2/6d. We have given them 6/-. The Minister for Social Welfare has done very well. When Deputy Kyne was on this side of the House supporting the Coalition Government, he said publicly that, if the Government wanted to tax tobacco in order to give more social welfare benefits, he would support that tax. But he is not prepared to support it when it is we who want to increase the benefits. Why I do not know. Is it that he thinks the people do not want increased benefits or that he does not want us to give increased benefits to social welfare recipients? I do not know which it is, but he appears to think it should not be done while we are here but it may be done when the Coalition are here.
Deputy Corish talked about the undeveloped areas. He had some criticism to offer about the geographical limits in which the Department is working. He seemed to deprecate the idea of giving better grants to the undeveloped areas than are available in other areas. He made some points that were all right but he was certainly not as severe on us as he is when he is talking down in Wexford.
Comment on this
The Deputy was very severe when he talked down in Wexford and lost an industry to the undeveloped areas.
Comment on this
The Minister will have to go back pretty far. The Minister may be mistaken. He may be thinking of some other meeting. I am not ashamed of anything I say. The Minister should explain. He should not leave things unsaid which should be said.
Comment on this
I have not got them here now. Deputy Dr. Browne complained that we had given an increase of only one per cent. to social welfare recipients. He evidently garnered his information from the answer given to a question here on 26th April. The answer was to the effect that the proportion of the national product devoted to social welfare generally was four per cent. in 1947-48, and five per cent. in 1959-60. To say that represents a one per cent. increase is certainly not putting the matter intelligently. The gross national product has gone up enormously since then and we are taking five per cent. now for social services as against four per cent. then. In cash the sum was at that time £13.075 millions. It is now £30.960 millions. That is a very big difference. It certainly conveys a different picture from the one Deputy Dr. Browne tried to paint with his reference to a one per cent. increase.
Deputy Dr. Browne talked about Socialist states. I think we all have our own understanding and appreciation of these so-called Socialist states. They do not do very much at all for the social welfare classes as far as one can learn. They tell people they must either work or starve. They can always make excuses for their attitude: the money is badly needed for building up the country's defences or its heavy industries; the turn of the social welfare recipients will come sometime.
Comment on this
The Local Authorities (Works) Act was mentioned. Nearly every Opposition Deputy spoke about it. It is always the same speech. I think it must have been a hand-out. The complaint is made that the Coalition Government spent money under this Act and we are doing nothing about it. We did away with it, as has been explained before, because we believed it was wasteful expenditure. I am sure any Deputy could quote a particular work which was beneficial, or perhaps half a dozen, but the great majority, and I know many of them, were wasteful and the areas concerned have gone back into the state they were in before ever any money was spent. The only defence that can be offered in support of that Act is the labour content. From that point of view it must be remembered that expenditure on forestry and fisheries— rural expenditure—has increased by £700,000 since 1956-57. We cut out £500,000 expenditure on the Local Authorities (Works) Act and are spending £700,000 more now than we did before on forestry and fisheries and it is all productive employment. We are getting some return——
Comment on this
That is productive employment. You have the forest when you are finished. You give employment and then you have the forest and it is an asset to the country. The same applies to the development of fisheries. In addition to that, take the Road Fund where a lot of money is spent. The amount brought in in 1956-57, after my colleague had taken a bit out of it, was £3.8 millions. In the coming year, it is down as £6.6 million, so that it has gone up by £2.6 million. If you take the Road Fund along with forestry and fisheries, we are spending six or seven times more than we spent on the Local Authorities (Works) Act.
We also had criticism of the Land Reclamation Scheme. Only to-day I heard it and I think it was from Deputy Crotty—any foolish statement that I cannot attribute to anybody else, I can attribute to Deputy Crotty. We were criticised because we dropped the B Scheme. We say it was a bad scheme. We did not believe that it was right or proper that any farmer should get £160 an acre for reclaiming his land. It was a bad scheme and had to be cut out. We said we would go back to the A Scheme and stick to it. What has been the result? In 1956-57, £1.37 million was spent on the A Scheme and £.68 million on the B Scheme. That is a total of £2 million. This year, we are spending £1.75 million —it is down £300,000 but——
Comment on this
I do not think the Fine Gael Party ever claimed that it was an improvement scheme. They always, and we all, looked on that scheme as a scheme for the benefit of agriculture, to improve agriculture. We came to the conclusion that when the land was reclaimed, it had to be fertilised and reseeded and we brought in the fertiliser scheme, phosphates and so on, to help rehabilitate that land after it had been drained and reclaimed and on phosphates and potash we are spending £2.4 millions.
I need hardly repeat, as I think everybody is aware of the fact, when we come to unemployment and employment, that unemployment is down by 30,000. We were not reminded of that by Fine Gael speakers but that is a fact.
Comment on this
In regard to employment nearly every speaker over there said employment had gone down by 50,000 in our time which is an absolutely crazy figure. There is no foundation at all for it, except that one Fine Gael speaker took it from another when he mentioned 50,000. Look at Table 7 and Table 16 in Economic Statistics. I should mention that these figures are taken in April and June each year, and, if I take April and June of 1954, that is how things stood when the Coalition came in and again, in 1957, that is when they went out.
Again, we can take the 1960 figure because we have not got the figure for 1961 yet. On that basis, on the agricultural side, where everybody is leaving the land, under the Coalition they went down 27,000 and they went down 20,000 in our three years. That was bad but not altogether as bad as the Coalition figure. On the other side, on the non-agricultural side, they went down 22,000 under the Coalition and 2,000 in our time so that the total is 49,000 in the three years they were there and 22,000 for the three years we were there.
We want to improve that. We have improved it but we want to improve it more. On the 1960 figure, the thing is eliminated, the figure is balanced in April and June, 1960. We had no reduction in employment from early 1959 to early 1960 and I am quite sure that on the figures for early 1961, there will be a further improvement. We are on the up-grade now, so, for goodness sake, if you have any idea of trying to solve this problem of getting more employment—I am speaking to the Fine Gael people—first of all, equip yourselves with the proper figure: it was very high from 1955 to 1957 and it was lower from that on and now it is balanced. We want to improve on that because now that it is balanced and the emigration figure is at a certain level, with which I will deal in a minute, we must bring that down and then our population will begin to go up again. That is what we are aiming at.
The Taoiseach gave figures in regard to emigration and I do not want to give them again. He took the three years of Coalition Government. Every Fine Gael speaker took the figure of 200,000. Where they got that figure, I do not know. Certainly it did not come from any statistics. It came by word of mouth, the way in which all tradition is handed down. There is no foundation whatever for that figure of 200,000 in the past three years.
Comment on this
I should say this, that sometimes we say we cannot give statistics because they are not available. The Statistics Department say they cannot give reliable figures for emigration but say that they will give figures for movements on land and in the air, out and in, and these are the figures we quote. We do not know how many cross the Border, but you can take it as a trend from one year to another. That is all you can say.
It was 120,000 for the past three years; it was 60,000 in 1957. As I said here before, we did not come in until near the end of March, 1957, and we had to settle down and start to work before we could stop emigration in a matter of a month or two. Even if you say: "We will give you until the end of June. Let us start at the end of June and take the figures from that on," we are quite satisfied because much more than half of them went out before the end of June and it will be all right; we will leave it at that. Every year, more than half go out in the first half of the year. We will leave it at that, that emigration is a bit better than it was at that time, but it is far too high and let us try to see if we can get a remedy for that very bad feature in our economy.
Comment on this
I said here that Fine Gael talked about this 200,000. Deputy Michael O'Higgins went one better. He said it was 120,000 in the past two years. Of course, there is no foundation for that, none whatever. As I said, we must try to get unemployment down, and we are being very successful in that. We must try to get our employment balanced, as we have succeeded now, in the beginning of 1960. The only other time it was done was in the beginning of 1954; it was balanced that time and we were nicely going ahead in 1954 but a general election took place; the Coalition took over and the whole thing went wrong again and if the people by any chance should put them back the next time, the whole thing is gone again, too.
Comment on this
If I were a betting man like Deputy Crotty, I would like to have him on on that.
I think Deputy Sweetman did not make the point today but on another occasion he made the point with regard to the special import levies. I should like to say a word about those levies. He accused us of breaking faith by taking the special import levies into current account. I do not see how he really could claim that. The first year we came in, we cut them very drastically—I think by more than one-half— and left that as capital, and next year we took them into current account but they were getting smaller and smaller and, as I explained at the beginning of this speech, if we want money by taxation, these taxes that remain now are on what you might call semi-luxury goods and it is the best form of taxation you could have.
Deputy Sweetman made the point that, of course, when I talk about balancing the Budget in the past three years, I had special import levies brought into current account. I tried to analyse that to see how this works out. It must be remembered, of course, that when a Minister introduces a Budget here, he makes a forecast for the year of how much will be expended and how much will be taken in by way of revenue and if it works out right, of course, then whatever he has provided in that Budget for sinking fund for national debt goes to sinking fund, no more, no less, but if by any chance he has a surplus, which we had last year—a very good surplus— that also goes to sinking fund because there is nothing for it to meet except sinking fund and if there is a deficit then, of course, the sinking fund is reduced by the amount of the deficit.
Taking that sort of arrangement, we find that for the three years Deputy Sweetman was looking after the finances, leaving out the special import levies for the moment, he paid £9.5 million off the national debt by way of sinking fund and in my three years, leaving out 1957-58, which I should like to deal with separately, I paid off £27 million but if we take the import levies and add them on to that, it would make this difference, that Deputy Sweetman's figure would then become £12.8 million for the three years against my £27 million.
The reason I leave 1957/58 out is that I was presented with Estimates for the coming year when the Government took over and I also asked the Revenue Commissioners for their estimate of revenue as taxes stood at that time, which is the usual thing you get for a start off, to see what the Budget will be like. Having got these Estimates which were prepared by Deputy Sweetman before he left and having got the estimates from the Revenue Commissioners, I found there was a gap of £11 million, which was a desperate amount of money to try to find, and although we cut the food subsidies out, which gave us a net income of about £5½ million, and put on extra taxation of another £3½ million and thought we might take a couple of millions for errors in estimation—the usual thing— we thought we might cover the £11 million, but actually there was a £5½ million deficit, which showed the desperate situation we were in at that time. In other words, it was not a gap of £11 million but of £16 million that I was facing when we came in at that time. That was as much the responsibility of the Coalition Government as it was ours. We will leave it at that.
Many Fine Gael speakers say there is no great advance in the economy of the country, that things are not too good, and so on. Then they forget about that and go on to say that all this big drive in exports is due to Deputy Sweetman when Minister for Finance. In other words, first of all, like the lawyer, they say there is no offence, but, if there is, then who is responsible. That is the way with Fine Gael speakers always: there is no advance in the economy but, if there is, Deputy Sweetman is responsible because he brought in the relief of income tax on exports which, as I have said over and over again, although Fine Gael people always say I do not say it, but I say again, was a very good policy on the part of the Coalition Government. I remember, before the first Coalition Government came in, for many years here when talking about industrial development, the Fine Gael people always said the two best industries in the country were due to them—the E.S.B. and the Sugar Company.
Comment on this
For many years, they talked about the way they were responsible for the E.S.B. and the Sugar Company. They never claimed any for the period 1948 to 1951 because they could not. Now, since they came back, they are claiming two more for the period 1954-1957—Whitegate and St. Patrick's Mines.
Comment on this
It is four industries now to their credit. That is all right. In fact, a Fine Gael speaker said here the other day that if they had not established the E.S.B., we would have no electricity now. In other words, we would still be working in the dark.
Comment on this
Take the copper mines. I do not want to take from the credit of the Coalition Government.
Comment on this
When the first Coalition Government came in in 1948, they cut out of the Estimate mineral development. We had put £87,000 into it that year, thinking we were coming back. They came in and cut it out—no mineral development; they did not approve of it. When we came in again in 1951, we put it back—£87,000 for mineral development. It went on and copper was discovered and they came in, the men who did not believe in mineral development, and they handed this place over to the Canadians who came along and the place is being well worked now under, I must say, serious difficulties.
Comment on this
The copper mines were shut down when you left office. There were only enought staff there to keep them in order.
Comment on this
How were they shut down when we left office since they started only about a year ago and the export was worth £1 million last year, I believe—£1 million, I think, for all minerals?
Comment on this
That was very good, due, if you like, to the foresight of Fianna Fáil in carrying out investigations and now we will let the Coalition Government have the benefit of it.
With regard to the oil refinery, Deputy Desmond gave all the credit to Deputy Norton for that. I remember back in 1943—many of the young men here would not remember 1943—the election was practically fought against Fianna Fáil because they wanted to have an internal oil refinery. The Labour Party had a paper that time—I forget what it was called—but every page of it talked about this oil refinery. The whole issue was given to it, condemning it and getting votes against Fianna Fáil because one of their mad ideas was to have an oil refinery. Of course, it did not go on because no oil refinery would come in against such opposition and then it came on under Deputy Norton and is doing very well indeed. It is a welcome addition to our exports. Between the two of them, they were responsible for about £4.5 million last year.
Comment on this
We will say £5 million, but to claim that they are responsible for our significant increase in exports is just chauvinistic. It is industries that were built up by Fianna Fáil on the home market and now largely using Irish raw materials that are responsible for the big drive in industry. They are the most stable and diversified and are likely to succeed and to be able to compete because they have the home market to support them in their export drive. Take, for instance, confectionery, cement, leather goods, textiles. These four which are using nearly all native materials have contributed very largely to the big increase in exports.
A number of speakers, including my colleague Deputy Esmonde and, I think, Deputy Sweetman, accused us of not making any preparation for the position that may arise in relation to the Common Market or if there is any change in that situation. We are not asleep on the matter. We are watching developments very closely. We do not think any advisable step could be taken at the moment. We are watching to see if there is any possibility of a merger of the two bodies, a break-up of one body or some other development. We have our preparations made to take the appropriate steps, if the necessity should arise, and that is as much as any Government and their advisers could do in such a position. I do not see what other preparations could be made. We cannot very well publish our ideas on the matter. All these negotiations are going on secretly between the various countries in Europe. If they think it necessary to keep these things secret, I suppose it is as well for us also to keep our minds to ourselves.
What have we done? First of all, we have tried to build up these industries and put them in a position where they can succeed against any competitor. We have given them tax reliefs on export profits. We have given them education and technical assistance. We have given them various grants, first of all, from Córas Tráchtála when they were being set up and, secondly, wear and tear allowances, and so on. I do not think we can help them more on the taxation side or on the educational side. We have done everything possible at the moment. We have even taken 1/2d. off the rate of income tax which should help them.
In this export drive, we must remember these firms are competing on the British market with British manufacturers on their own ground and are getting their goods sold there. They are also going to countries other than Britain and competing with foreign manufacturers there. Therefore, they are making an attempt, and a successful attempt at that, to compete and if it should happen that the barriers are removed by other countries in Europe so that foreign industrialists can come in here with goods practically free of tax and our industrialists can export goods free of tax, we cannot do more in the meantime than build up our industries so that they will be in a position to compete.
As regards agriculture, we have done everything possible to help the farmer to produce more at a lower unit cost by giving him more grants for the building of houses, for drainage of land, for fertilising and for all the other various items which affect his costs, not to mention also relief in rates, and so on. Marketing committees have also been set up in recent times which should be very helpful to farmers. What more can we do? There is no doubt it is a problem and if any other Party can make a suggestion as to what more we can do. I am sure it will get very careful consideration.
If a Government give certain concessions which cost money, they must get the money somewhere else. The Opposition—I suppose we were the same when we were in opposition—are always inclined to agree that the concession should be given, but they object when it comes to the point of deciding who is to pay for it.
The other day, I heard a Deputy on this side of the House asking: "Do Deputies on the other side agree with the Government in increasing the price of milk to milk producers last year?" I am sure any Deputy would answer: "Yes; I agree that the producer should get more for his milk." It must be remembered that the butter sold on the home market is sold at the economic price of butter made from that milk at that price. There is no subsidy or relief. If we had no butter for export and were producing just enough milk to produce our own butter, then the economic price of butter would be the price at which it is being sold at present. I suppose nearly every Deputy will say: "I object to an increase in the price of butter." In fact, therefore, Deputies are saying: "We agree with increasing the price of milk but you can carry your own burden as regards increasing the price of butter." When we ask those questions, we get "yes" to one and "no" to the other, which is not very much help to us so that we must make provision ourselves.
The same remarks apply to the contributory pensions scheme which we brought in. Everybody said it was a grand scheme but now those who approved of it are objecting to the increase in the price of the stamp to which the employer, the employee and the Exchequer contribute. The complaint is made that the employee has to pay more for the stamp, but it is a contributory scheme. Every Deputy agrees that the contributory scheme is better than the non-contributory scheme because the recipient gets the pension without a means test. Although everybody will approve of the contributory scheme — and will call it the contributory scheme—Deputies do not want the person to contribute for the stamp. Even Opposition Deputies should have some sense of responsibility in matters of that kind.
There is one thing certain: we cannot have a better standard of living unless we have increased production. I remember speakers from the Coalition Government in 1954/55 talking about all the money they were giving out. Of course, it is no good unless there is production behind it. As a matter of fact, money was given out in the past but there was not enough production behind it. We must have more production, and the more production we have from both industry and agriculture, the better is it for the country as a whole.
As I have already said, it is all right for people on the Fine Gael benches to say that we should do more for agriculture. We should do more, and certainly if we knew where to do more for agriculture, we would do more, but that does not say we should do less for industry, because if we do more for industry also and get more wages, more profits and more revenue from these companies, we will have more to help agriculture and more to help the social welfare classes. We will also have well-paid employees to buy the agricultural produce and those engaged in agriculture will get better prices for their goods. Therefore, we should try to encourage industry as well as agriculture.
I remember in 1906 when I first took an interest in politics—I was fairly young at the time—I used to read Sinn Féin by Arthur Griffith, who always advocated what he called the two arms of agriculture and industry. He said that a nation depending solely on agriculture was like a man with one arm, and that a nation cannot get on without the two arms of agriculture and industry. Fianna Fáil have believed that ever since. As I said, by developing industry, we get greater exports to pay for imports and more employment, and in that way you improve the economy of the country, and help not only the people in industry but also agriculture in an indirect way.
We sometimes hear talk about the two great agricultural countries, Denmark and Holland. I looked up the figures in relation to those countries and I found that, in Holland, 18½ per cent. of its produce is agricultural— ours is 40 per cent., as Deputies know —and in Denmark, it is 20 per cent. That shows that those two well developed agricultural countries are developed because they have an industrial arm and because they have the market—although they export as well—and the people in industry take the greater part of the agricultural output. That should be the aim in this country. We should develop our industrial arm as well as our agricultural arm.
Finally, my colleague from Wexford, Deputy Browne, quoted our appeal to the electorate. In Wexford, we addressed five meetings in the whole election campaign and we purposely said we were making no promises.
Comment on this
What election is the Minister talking about? Is it the next election or the last election?
Comment on this
The last election. We made no promises; yet we got three out of five seats for the first time. We made no promises whatever. As some of my colleagues pointed out, we could not help winning because the people voted to get rid of the others——
Comment on this
Before I conclude, I want to say that the people were anxious to get rid of the Coalition. Fine Gael knew that and Labour knew it also. Since then, I have not heard Fine Gael or the Labour Party talk about a coalition. Fine Gael are out for one-Party Government. They say to the people: "We want one-Party Government; do not suspect us of forming a coalition again." They want one-Party Government because they know that if the people had any suspicion of a coalition being formed, they would not have a chance, and the Labour Party are in the same position. Coalition Government is finished. Opposition Deputies know that as well as we do.
Comment on this
The only thing we can do is to warn the electorate: "Do not trust them. If they get a majority, they will form a coalition, no matter what promises they make."
Comment on this
We will go before the electorate on our record. The Opposition are saying there will not be a Coalition Government again. We are not saying there will not be a Fianna Fáil Government again. We are saying: "There will be a Fianna Fáil Government again. We are going on our record; put us back," and they will put us back.
Comment on this
Before the Minister concludes, may I offer him "General Statistics—Main Economic Indicators," issued by O.E.E.C. for January, 1961, and tell him that the figures I quoted are on page 4? Would he be good enough to tell the House on what page are the figures he has quoted?
Comment on this
Resolution put.
Do you agree with this result?