We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee On Finance. - Road Traffic Bill, 1960—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–164 of 325. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Road Traffic Bill, 1960
Enacted

No. 50 of 1960 ›

Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 80 was discussed with amendments Nos. 42 and 43.

Comment on this

This section deals with stopping places and stands for omnibuses and reads:

(1) The Commissioner may, by notice in writing, direct, in respect of a route upon which omnibuses are operated, that specified points shall be stopping places or that specified places shall be used as stands for the omnibuses.

Does that mean a notice simply to the company or concern operating the omnibuses, or does it imply that there will be some kind of publication of the Commissioner's notice?

Comment on this

Subsection (5) of the section would probably clarify it.

Comment on this

It is the custom, certainly in the city, if there is a change of route, for example, if a roadway is closed, to give public notice of a change. If there is a change in the bus routes or stopping points, they normally do give notice and possibly under the C.I.E. Acts, it is obligatory on them to do so. I would like the Minister to ensure that where the public are affected by any change in a bus route or stopping place, due notice will be given of the change. It may very well be that that is already covered under the C.I.E. Acts. If it is not, I should like the Minister to ensure under this Bill that such notice will be given.

Comment on this

I still do not get the point the Deputy is making. This provision deals with stopping places for omnibuses and the Commissioner of the Garda may notify the operators concerned as to where the stops may be.

Comment on this

The point is he may amend or revoke the notice he has given; in other words, he may direct that point A which has been a stopping place up to now shall no longer be a stopping place.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that if that is done, notice should be given to the public.

Comment on this

The normal procedure is that the operators of the service are notified by the Commissioner as to the removal of a stopping place, the placing of a stop or a suggestion in regard to it. They, in turn, inform the public, their customers, as to where the stops will be, and that is the way it should be.

Comment on this

I am not disputing that that is the way it is done; in fact, due publicity always is given. However, I would like to see a legal onus on either the Commissioner or the operating concern to give that notice.

Comment on this

There is just one little difficulty about that, regardless of whether the notices should be given by the Commissioner or the bus company. Changes of stopping places could be an emergency measure. Some emergency may occur in which it is necessary to re-route buses and steps may have to be taken immediately. To outline and specify that adequate and suitable notice shall be given in a particular way could raise complications. In normal circumstances, bus operators, in the interests of serving their customers, inform them of changes. If the customers do not know the route the bus is taking or where it is going to stop, it could not be said they were fufilling the purpose of giving a service to the public at all. Commonsense dictates that they will take every possible step to inform the public of the changes required by the Commissioner.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 81, in the name of Deputy Ryan, was discussed with amendments Nos. 42 and 43.

Comment on this

I wish to direct the Minister's attention to subsection (5) of Section 86 which reads:

Where a person uses a mechanically propelled vehicle other than an omnibus in contravention of a bye-law under this section, he and, if he is not the registered owner of the vehicle, such owner shall each be guilty of an offence.

It is imposing too much of a liability to make the registered owner of the vehicle guilty of an offence of which he may be entirely innocent and of which he may have no knowledge whatever. I would ask the Minister to have another look at subsection (5). I suggest he should delete the words referring to the registered owner and leave the position that the only person who would be guilty of an offence is the person who used the vehicle in contravention of a bye-law.

Comment on this

The type of contravention that comes to mind immediately in this matter and with which we wish to deal specifically is the parking or leaving of a vehicle in a particular place. The difficulty encountered up to the present and over the years has been to nail who used the vehicle last, who put it there, who left it there. That has been a weakness which, in other respects, we are trying to remedy in Section 90 by bringing in the registered owner as liable for the offence whether or not he was the person who actually used the vehicle and had control of the vehicle at the time of the commission of the offence. I suggest we might possibly discuss that item on Section 90, if the House so wishes, or together with that section.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

How would that apply in the case of a person who hires a self-drive car?

Comment on this

The hiring firm would be equally guilty.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Even though the person who hired the car loaned the car to a third party?

Comment on this

That is the whole point.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

I think Section 3 deals with it.

Comment on this

An event such as the Deputy indicates would, on the registered owner's part, be a good defence in court.

Comment on this

It would, when it goes to a third person, but it would not be a good defence if they hired it out.

Comment on this

That is to the hirer.

Comment on this

Yes, not as I read subsections (7) and (8) "that such use was unauthorised."

Comment on this

I am inclined to agree that it would not be a good defence for the two parties but if the in-between person loaned it to somebody else it would be a good defence for the registered owner.

Comment on this

Would the Minister be prepared to come back to this section on Section 90? Could we leave it in abeyance for the moment?

Comment on this

Would the better thing be to discuss Section 90 now?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No— when we reach it.

Comment on this

I should like to stress this point a little more. I feel that from the prosecution point of view it is obviously nicer to be able to name somebody for an offence that has been committed. It is fundamentally unjust that a person who cannot be held liable in equity will be held liable in law.

I can sympathise with the police in trying to make quite sure that an offence is punished but I cannot get any satisfaction out of knowing that somebody is being wrongly punished with our full knowledge and consent; that is what is comes to. It is far better that the offence should go unpunished rather than that the wrong person should get a punishment he did not deserve.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. I am quite agreeable to discuss it later, if the Minister thinks it more convenient. I would agree to Section 86 but only with the reservation that we can come back on it in some form, if necessary by recommitting the Bill on Report.

Comment on this

If we continue to discuss it now there would not be much point in the suggestion to discuss it later.

Comment on this

I gathered the Minister wanted it done in that way.

Comment on this

I do not mind. I merely made a suggestion.

Comment on this

I think that what Deputy Booth said is quite right. As often as not, you will have the case where the registered owner of the car is an entirely innocent party. If I give the Minister a loan of my car when he asks me for it, because he is stuck or something like that, and he then parks dangerously, or does something like that with my car, it would be grossly unjust that I should be guilty of an offence which is committed by the Minister and which was not committed by me. The only offence I could be said to have committed is possibly an error of judgment in being too kindhearted.

I do not think it is fair to deal with car owners in that way. I agree fully with Deputy Booth that it is better on occasion that the guilty person should get away with it scot free rather than that we should punish innocent people merely for the sake of punishing somebody.

Comment on this

I take it that the Deputy is aware that our parking laws are completely and absolutely unenforceable as the law now stands. As Deputy M.J. O'Higgins has said, if, for some reason or another, I seek and get his car and park it dangerously or wrongly, it certainly would be a gross error of judgment on his part if I turned out to be the type of person who would let him take the rap when I was responsible for using his car which he gave me to help me in my difficulty.

Comment on this

I might not know the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy would be much more careful again.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

That does not quite cover the case of people who hire self-drive cars. A person hires out a self-drive car. The owners might not even know the position until after the hirer had left the city or the country as the case may be.

Comment on this

The only defence the Minister is allowing to the hire purchase company in the case mentioned by Deputy Russell is to show that the use of the car was unauthorised. Clearly, the use of the car will not be unauthorised, if a person goes into a hire-purchase or self-drive company to get a car for a day, a week, a month or whatever the period may be. Quite clearly, the use of the car will be authorised but the misuse of the car will not be authorised. The expression here is to show that the use was unauthorised. I think it is putting the self-drive companies in an impossible position. They will be amenable for any offence committed under this section by the driver of the car. It will be a great hardship on ordinary individuals, quite apart from hire-purchase companies, if they are caught in this way when they themselves are quite innocent.

Comment on this

Could I ask the Deputy and any member of the House to suggest from his own knowledge of this matter any method other than this method whereby parking regulations can be applied to self-drive cars?

Comment on this

Yes—if the Minister would put at the end of subsections (7) and (8) the words "or that the offence was committed without the knowledge or consent of the registered owner". I think that would cover my point and I think it would cover what Deputy Russell has in mind.

Comment on this

It will not cover the other point.

Comment on this

What the Minister is arguing is clearly bad in principle. It is the duty of owners of cars—I am dealing with the question of self-drive companies, companies that deal in self-drive cars—to make the cars available to the client or customer who comes looking for these vehicles. That is their business. It is their means of livelihood to make the cars available. It seems to me to be bad in principle that the Legislature here should adopt the position of saying: "Very well; we are going to legislate in such a way that if there is any parking offence committed by any of your cars, you will be responsible for it." Is that not tantamount to saying that they have to go out of business, unless they are prepared to accept responsibility for every offence with one of their cars, whether they know anything about it or not?

That is definitely a very bad principle to establish. I do not think it is just or fair. What the Minister is seeking to achieve is that the users of cars will obey the road traffic code and will park their cars—he has used the example of parking—properly. That is what he is seeking to achieve. In fact, he is to some extent giving them an indemnity because he is saying to them, through this Bill: "Quite apart from what you do or do not do in the parking of the cars, an innocent person, an owner of a car, will be guilty before the courts because of this legislation."

Comment on this

Does this difficulty arise from the fact that a person who is caught by a Guard, where a vehicle is wrongly parked, has only to say that he did not park? Is that the question? Is the question one where the Guards cannot prove that the person driving the car away is the person who parked it? A better approach would be to regard the person who drives the car away as the person who parked it.

Comment on this

What about the people who do not turn up at all?

Comment on this

You still have the car which is a very valuable consideration.

Comment on this

You would need to have a Garda sitting on the bonnet of every car. Who has not done it?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

You do not say you left it there but you say nothing.

Comment on this

I understood that under this Bill the Guards have power to seize a car, if a person does not turn up. I think the Guards will have their answer. We should not go through this complicated process of getting at the matter by prosecuting somebody. It is very bad law that in order to get rid of a parking offence, you secure that someone will be prosecuted whether he is guilty or not. Under this section, the owner of a registered vehicle is to be guilty of an offence.

Comment on this

It carries responsibility and everybody will admit that.

Comment on this

It is all very well to talk now about responsibility. If this goes on, the car hire firms will be put in the position of safeguarding themselves by imposing larger fees as an insurance against anything that happens. Then all these innocent drivers of hire purchase cars will have to pay. I think it is a very bad principle.

Comment on this

One would think we were imposing things merely because we like to tidy things up. We are trying to seek a law which will bring about the enforcement of the parking regulations which heretofore, on the law as it now stands——

Comment on this

How does the Minister suggest this will do it?

Comment on this

Can the House suggest a way by which it can be done?

Comment on this

How does the Minister suggest this will do it?

Comment on this

I am suggesting it will have some good effect with regard to enforcement. I am asking the House whether it can suggest a better way and a way with fewer objections from the point of view of self-drive cars, apart from any others. I should be glad to hear it.

Comment on this

Deputy Sheldon made one suggestion which was an improvement.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins mentioned that certain results of that might be that people in the self-drive business were liable to be put out of business. Deputy Sheldon suggests that if this liability is to be left at the door of the self-driver operators or owners, it will mean they will have to charge a higher rate to the drivers and that the innocent driver will suffer with the guilty. If we want to enforce our parking laws, we want to enforce them for the common good. If there is a way whereby the driver of a hired car or the owner can indemnify himself and, at the same time, enable us by law to get rid of unauthorised and dangerous parking, it would be much preferable to show it to us rather than to say that the charges to hirers of cars will go up or that somebody will go out of business. That will not happen.

It would seem to be the height of folly to legislate here for parking offences and make the law such that the driver of a hired car was, in fact, excluded from it, which is the reverse of what I am trying to do. If I were to drop this provision in regard to these self-drive cars, then we would be giving these people who have no sense of responsibility in the sense that they do not own the car a licence to park as and when they liked. I do not think anybody intends that should be so.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not doing that?

Comment on this

I am not, but Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy Sheldon have, by their own statements, indicated that the drive-hire car owner would have to take certain action. Apparently, there is action open to them to take which will safeguard this situation but if we leave it out, there will be no action which we can take. I should be glad if somebody could suggest a solution to the problem. It is a serious problem, if this loophole is to be left in it.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Leaving out the question of cost, is there not a question of justice involved? What the Minister is saying is that if he cannot prosecute the guilty party, he will prosecute somebody else, who in this case happens to be the owner who is completely innocent of the offence. I do not think it is a defence for the Minister to say: "If you do not like it that way, why do you not think out something else?" In those circumstances, I should prefer to see it struck out altogether.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to do that and that is why I am asking the House to do it.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

That does not debar me getting up and saying it is an unjust section. I think the Minister recognises that fact. One of his defences is that you have got to prosecute somebody and there is an onus on the people who hire out cars to be responsible. But even allowing for that suggestion, I do not think it is going to get over the fundamental issue which is that this subsection, as it stands, constitutes a grave injustice. It is up to the Minister to find some way of circumventing that.

Comment on this

I agree fully with Deputy Russell, but I think this is equally important, on the question of principle and justice, for the ordinary private car owner as it is from the point of view of the operators of a self-drive company. The principle is wrong and bad. The Minister's reply to Deputy Sheldon and myself was that he could do nothing about it— that the authorities can do nothing about stopping bad or dangerous parking—but that the self-drive companies can do something about it. What could they do about it? What they could do, according to the Minister, following the suggestions made, was either close down and not operate services or else increase their charges to their customers.

If they increase their charges to their customers, the people who are going to suffer as the result of this legislation are not merely the reckless fly-by-nights who come over, get a car for a night or a couple of days, go away and are not amenable to the jurisdiction of our courts, but every person from now onwards who gets a car on a self-drive contract. The Minister seems to think that is an improvement of the law and that that is doing something worthwhile towards enforcing the parking regulations. I disagree with him entirely. What he is doing, if he follows that line, is that he is, to some extent at any rate, indemnifying the reckless driver who parks his car badly or dangerously.

If this legislation goes through in its present form quite clearly—and no one is going to blame him for it—a Garda will not be interested in finding out who parked the car badly. He does not need to find that out. Under this legislation all he has to do is to go to the motor registration office and find out who is the registered owner. Then he has his defendant, and that defendant must be convicted. The only defence open to him is that the use of the car was unauthorised, and in 99 out of 100 cases of the kind I have in mind—and I think the Minister has in mind also—the use of the car is not going to be unauthorised.

The Minister would be doing simple justice if he agreed that if the registered owner were not in a position to show that the misuse of the car, in the case of dangerous or bad parking or other offence, was without the consent or knowledge of the registered owner, then the registered owner should not be guilty of an offence. That would be a different situation. While it might not help the Minister in enforcing parking regulations, it would be simple justice.

The Minister says, in effect, "This is the best suggestion I can make." He says that if any Deputy can make any better suggestion he is prepared to consider it and, possibly, to adopt it. Deputy Sheldon has suggested that it would be an improvement—I do not think he claimed it would be perfect— if instead of having this liability attached willy-nilly to the registered owner, the Minister were to attach it to the person who drove the car away after it was parked, and if the Minister had it deemed that the person who took the car away was the person who had parked it. That might be an improvement. I do not think by any means it would be perfect.

The real answer is this. The Minister has no responsibility for the Garda and it is the job of the Garda to carry out the regulations or the law regarding parking as laid down. I do not think the Minister should interfere with that. I do not think it is his concern to make their job any harder, but equally I do not think he should cause injustice merely for the sake of making their job easier. It is their job to detect the parking offence, ascertain the offender and bring him to justice. The Minister is now relieving them of that duty and it is a duty anyone who joins the Garda should be prepared to undertake. Instead of allowing the Garda to do that job and encouraging them to get on with it, the Minister is saying to them: "You need not bother who committed the offence. Once the offence is committed, go for the registered owner, prosecute him and you are all right under this section." I think that is bad law, unjust and wrong in principle.

Comment on this

I should like to express agreement with Deputy O'Higgins as far as this section goes. This section deals only with the offence committed when somebody parks at a bus stop. Whatever may arise when we discuss Section 90 and the general question of parking, surely here it ought to be reasonably easy for the Garda in a good number of cases to spot who parked the car at a bus stop? It is not like finding a car parked at some unauthorised place. It should not be very difficult for the Garda to detect that and get the proper person. Parking at a bus stop is not like parking at some unauthorised place and being found there later. The minute you stop at a bus stop, you have committed the offence. There is no question of the length of time. It is purely a question of stopping at a place reserved for another purpose. This is not a question of coming along and finding a car parked at an unauthorised place, having to wait for someone to turn up, and not being able to prove that the one who turned up was the one who parked. If this section were amended by deleting "registered owner," the Garda, in Dublin at any rate, could very quickly prosecute sufficient people who stopped their cars at bus stops to put an end to that kind of thing and clear that part of the road without bringing in the registered owners at all.

Comment on this

I would go further than that. I feel there is a chance here of really helping the Minister to some extent. If the use of the car is unauthorised by the owner, obviously the owner knows who is the authorised user of it. If the Garda are unable to find out who actually parked the car, the registered owner could well be put under the obligation to disclose to the Garda who the user was at a specific time. I do not think that should cause any undue difficulty. If the owner of a car authorises somebody to drive it away, he usually has a pretty fair idea of what time he had it and what time he got the car back. We might be able to help the Minister to that extent by suggesting to him that if the registered owner were obliged to give full information to the Garda as to who was authorised to use the car between certain hours, that should give them all the information they want.

There might be a certain danger of the baby being passed from hand to hand and everybody saying: "It was not I who parked it there; I left it to someone else," and the registered owner would get out in view of the fact that the driver at that stage was altogether unauthorised. I do not know if there is any statutory obligation on the owner at the moment to disclose to the Garda who was using a car on a certain date if the driver himself or herself was not driving it. I think the problem might be met, as I have suggested, and that, certainly, would be as far as I would be prepared to go. Any other way of implicating the registered owner who is not the driver and is not even in the car at the time would be grossly unfair.

Comment on this

This latest suggestion by Deputy Booth is one that might give us some elbow-room to meet the varying points of view. It would be too much to think that we could get entirely out of this dilemma that apparently has now arisen or that anybody should be able to say that such-and-such a formula or amended formula would be the answer. Deputy Booth's suggestion, certainly on the surface, gives some hope of doing a little both ways. In so far as owners of vehicles are concerned, they can also be considered and, since Deputies have such strong views about the matter, I should be glad of their assistance and their further consideration of the matter and I should like them to convey to me the result of that further consideration between now and the next Stage of the Bill with a view to having it thoroughly examined.

It has been said that we should not appear to be making the job of the Garda easy, that we should not go out of our way to do so and at the same time create injustice. The advice tendered to my Department by the Garda, who have been and are responsible for the operation of the parking laws, is that under the present law we might as well have none. Anyone who looks around the city or elsewhere realises that is only too true: it like a jungle as regards parking. It is not a question of going out of our way to make the job of the Garda easy but of trying to find a solution to the present situation. If we leave the law as it is and has been up to the present, it will mean that there will not be any parking laws as such. This is not an attempt to help the Garda to convict more people or make their job easier but an attempt to solve a difficulty without causing injustice to anybody.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

We all agree with those sentiments but I suggest that by giving the person who is not the owner of the car virtually carte blanche to park wherever he likes you are practically absolving him from all responsibility. The first person you want to get is the person who has parked a car at a bus stop. I think that is the primary desire, to get the offender first, and failing that, to get some means by which he will be tracked down if he has left the car there and gone away.

Comment on this

That is the kernel of the problem, to get the culprit in some way or other. If there is any suggestion, further than those already made, I should be very glad to have it.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

If it could be shown that the owner of the car, whether a private owner or somebody in the self-drive business, is guilty of any contributory negligence by hiring the car or loaning it to somebody who obviously should not get a car, then I would agree that he should be got if you can get him.

Comment on this

The Minister will consider the point?

Comment on this

I shall consider it and anything else that Deputies wish to have considered now or later.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

I notice that in some of the sections there is provision for consultation with the local authorities. In other sections, including Section 86, this is omitted. Is there a special reason for that?

Comment on this

In regard to bus stop procedure?

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Yes.

Comment on this

The Deputy is quite right. It has been knowingly omitted for the reason that it is felt that the bus stop problem is such a detailed one that each one is, in itself, a problem, and that consultation and procedure of that kind with the local authority would not appear to be a fitting method of approach nor would it appear likely to improve the siting of these bus stops ultimately.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

As the Minister probably knows, it is the practice for local authorities to make representations to the Garda regarding the siting of bus stops. Will that procedure be interfered with?

Comment on this

That would be the voluntary approach to the Commissioner and the submission of views?

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Yes.

Comment on this

Not at all. I am sure the Commissioner would be more than glad to have those views.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 82 was discussed with amendments Nos. 42 and 43.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Is consultation with the local authority again omitted on the same grounds? The question of the regulation of traffic is one in which one would imagine that the local authority should have some say.

Comment on this

This is the section giving power to make general bye-laws for the entire country and for general application. To consult each local authority in that case naturally would not be feasible or desirable.

Comment on this

This section also deals generally with bye-laws which the Commissioner may make including bye-laws to regulate and control the leading of animals. Does the Minister feel it necessary to be more specific regarding that? Most of us have had experience of animals being allowed more or less without control on the roads and causing damage. I am not at all clear as to the position regarding the legal liability for damage caused by animals allowed to stray or wander on the roads. I should like to feel that under this section there is some way of bringing home the responsibility to the person responsible for allowing the animals on the road without proper care or control if the animals cause damage to person or property.

Comment on this

I think this has been mentioned before. The question of animals on the roadway and the damage they may cause is a matter for civil action. If I am not mistaken, there is a committee dealing with this matter of civil liability at the moment and possibly this will be dealt with there in a broader sense. To attempt to bring it in here would have far reaching effects, effects which we would not be capable of dealing with adequately in a measure which is mainly directed towards road traffic law. For that reason, I would say to the House that it is a matter to be dealt with more appropriately by the committee, and probably better so, if the changes are made.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 83:

In subsection (2), page 65, line 24, to delete "of any specified class".

The purpose of this amendment is to make clear that bye-laws may, if necessary, prohibit the loading or unloading in certain streets of all goods and not merely goods of a specified class as in the section as it stands. It is to make that clear that this amendment is before the House.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Under the 1933 Act, the local authority or, in default, the Minister, was required to make bye-laws for the regulation of traffic at fairs and markets. Is that not correct?

Comment on this

I think a later section covers that.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Does it?

Comment on this

It has been put to me that there is something rather unjustifiable about giving power to charge a parking fee on a public road. It is obviously justifiable to have a parking fee payable where a public car park is provided off the public road, but for the motorist who is already paying heavily for his share of the road through his road tax, it does seem less than fair that he should be charged extra for stopping. I hope therefore that the Minister will divest himself of the power to charge a fee for parking on the public road and restrict himself to the right to make a charge where public car parks are provided off the public road.

Another matter arises in reference to subsection (9) where we have again the same trouble in regard to the registered owner being liable. I presume the Minister will reconsider that matter also, as in the previous case.

Comment on this

I was going to refer to subsection (9) but I take it that the Minister's remarks on the previous section cover this because he himself related Section 86 to Section 90——

Comment on this

——in dealing with it.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

Under subsection (2) (h), the bye-laws may provide for prohibiting wholly the parking, otherwise than in parking places, of vehicles on any specified public road. Each and every one of us knows of cases of cars breaking down on a public road and there is no place to put the car. What is the alternative?

Comment on this

This is not a general application of the power that is mentioned; it is to deal with specified streets or stretches of road. It does not apply to all roads.

Comment on this

What happens if a car breaks down on a specified road?

Comment on this

It is too bad if your car breaks down on any road.

Comment on this

It can happen anywhere.

Comment on this

If your car is in the street and it is in the middle of the night, you can always get it off the street. That is all I can say.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Subsection (5) says that the Commissioner may, by bye-laws under subsection (1), specify the fees to be charged by licensed parking attendants in respect of attended parking places. Would it also be desirable to specify the actual fees chargeable on a sign or notice?

Comment on this

This, I may say, is a power which is carried on from the Act of 1933. So far as an indication of what the fees might be, as laid down by the Commissioner, there is no reason why those may not be published and displayed in such a way that the public will be aware of them. So far as Deputy Booth's comment is concerned, regarding the charge for parking on a public roadway, that again is a power which, in principle, has been in existence since 1933. The power now sought has particular relation to possible experiments in the use of parking meters.

While the point may be made that if a car going along the road is not charged a specific fee, it should not be charged a specific fee if it stops on a particular part of that road, I do not think it is a very useful argument in this case, because we have had the power in the past to charge and to allow charges to be made and we are not imposing some new charge on the motoring public to which they were not liable in the past. Therefore, we could not be said to be worsening their position.

On the other hand, if parking meters are to contribute towards ease of parking and possibly in some cases the relief of congestion by properly controlled parking, surely then the benefits in both of those directions will be to the motorist because to a very large degree it is the motorists who suffer to a great extent if there is indiscriminate parking for unduly lengthy periods. If it works, all this will be of greater assistance to the motorist than to any other member of the community. Therefore, even if you can make the argument: why charge a motorist when his car is stationary on a particular street, if you do not charge him as he goes along a whole stretch of roadway, I feel that while it is a nice argument, the other one is better, that we are doing it by way of experimenting to help the motorist to park more readily and under some control.

Comment on this

In support of the Minister's argument, I understand that anyone's right to use a road is to use it as a thoroughfare, not to sit down or remain in one place. The ordinary common law right is to use it as a thoroughfare and charging people for that right does not seem to be quite in accord with that principle.

I hope I am not the only one who does not understand the reference in subsection (4) to ‘disc'. Does the Minister visualise flying saucers or who would want to park discs anyway?

Comment on this

That refers to the use of discs as an indicator of parking places.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

I should like to return to the point about what licensed parking attendants may charge. I should like the Minister to consider including in subsection (c) a provision whereby the Commissioner may require these charges to be displayed. The Minister has said there is nothing to stop them being displayed, but if we had adopted that attitude with regard to the other provisions of the Bill, we would have been at sixes and sevens long before now. Would the Minister consider putting in such a provision?

Comment on this

That power would lie under Section 94. I think the Deputy would like an undertaking that that power will be used to ensure the display of these charges if they are authorised?

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Users could be mulcted if they did not know about the charges.

Comment on this

The Deputy would prefer that they should know them rather than be done in the eye without having that knowledge. If the charges are to be made and authorised, I am inclined to think a notice to that effect should be displayed. I think what the Deputy has in mind is to stem the manner in which charges which are not really authorised seem to be the order of the day in parking places in the city of Dublin at the moment. As I said, my sympathy is with the Deputy, that we should, if possible, have these charges displayed. The power to do that is in Section 95. While I would not say offhand that these signs and charges will be displayed, I am certainly thinking in that direction and my sympathies lie in that direction.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Will the Minister translate his sympathies into practice in the Bill by inserting such a provision?

Comment on this

We do not need to do it. We have the power and it can be done.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

If necessary?

Comment on this

I am merely saying that without doubt it can be done and my sympathies are in the direction that it should be done.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

In subsection (6), reference is made to the powers of the Commissioner to license car parking attendants. I want to mention the fact that car parking attendants in the city at the moment are very alarmed that some attempt might be made to take away their livelihood. I hope that in licensing car parking attendants, the Minister will see that those who have been on the job, and have done a good job, will not be interfered with, and will be given priority when it comes to the issue of licences. Attempts may be made by certain groups to collar these jobs. It would be most unfair if the present attendants who have done a good job could not continue in that capacity. I mention the matter because I was asked to raise it, and I hope the Minister will make some comment on it. Has the Minister any comment to make on the point?

Comment on this

The Deputy would be surprised at the comments I could make in both directions—both for and against, and for good reason.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

I qualified my statement by referring to attendants who have done a good job and are satisfactory to the Garda. I hope they will not be interfered with. That is the corroboration of the "fors" and "againsts". Is that not so?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any power in this section or is it left to the Garda?

Comment on this

This section deals in a very specific way with emergency conditions and, in fact, it mentions "Garda Síochána in uniform" being on the spot if any emergency conditions arise. It gives power to do certain things by way of controlling traffic. The knowledge of the local authority or consultation even with his immediate superior does not arise.

Comment on this

In my area, we hold races on the public roads.

Comment on this

Without permission?

Comment on this

With the permission of the local authority. I should like to know will the local authority still have the power to grant that permission?

Comment on this

That will not be interfered with. I take it that the Deputy's fears are that someone will interfere with the local authority cooperating with the race committee—he did not say what the races were; trotters, I suppose—or that some power they have will be taken away. That is not so. That will not happen.

Comment on this

There is no provision in the Bill that the local authority can give permission to the race committee to hold the races on the public road.

Comment on this

The power is available. It derives from the local government laws. It will not be dealt with under this road traffic law, but under the existing local government code.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

This section refers to fairs. Is there any change from the 1933 Act under which the Minister may make regulations in connection with fairs and markets? It is permissive now? Is that not right?

Comment on this

I can say in answer to the Deputy's first query that this is practically a re-enactment of the provision in the 1933 Act.

Comment on this

In subsection (3) of this section, it is provided.

Where an order has been made under subsection (1) of this section, the Minister may at any time, after giving notice to the road authority charged with the maintenance of the road to which the order relates and considering any representations made to him by such road authority, by order revoke or amend the first-mentioned order and thereupon it shall be the duty of such road authority to remove or alter the notices erected and maintained by them under subsection (2) of this section in relation to the first-mentioned order.

Would it not be better to provide that the Minister should consult with the local authority before the inquiry is held?

Comment on this

With regard to subsection (6), may I take it that the Minister will have another look at this when he is considering Sections 89 and 90? This again is a question of the owner, as well as the driver or user, being held guilty.

Comment on this

Yes. It seems to be the same pattern.

Comment on this

It is the same category.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 88:

In subsection (11), to add at the end of the subsection "and, in any prosecution for an offence under this section and notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, the traffic sign shall be presumed, until the contrary is shown by the defendant, to have been provided by a person other than a road authority without the consent of the Commissioner."

This is a drafting amendment. The provisions of subsection (18) could, in effect, be used to defeat a prosecution under subsection (11), if the proposed amendment were not inserted. The amendment is designed to close a gap which would unwittingly have been left open.

Comment on this

May I point out that a number of people erect signs, such as cattle crossing signs, concealed entrances, and so on? Would it be possible to have some provision to enable these signs to be maintained or will those concerned have to apply for permission to keep the signs in existence?

Comment on this

I shall have to check on that. Strictly speaking, the signs should not be there, unless permission has been granted for them. I shall have to look into the matter to see what the general attitude is and what action may be taken.

Comment on this

I am not sure that I like the Minister's amendment. It raises a question similar to one we were discussing earlier. Subsection (10) of Section 95 provides:

A person other than a road authority shall not provide a traffic sign visible from a public road without the consent of the Commissioner.

Subsection (11) provides:

The occupier or (in the case of unoccupied land) the owner of land on which a traffic sign is provided in contravention of subsection (10) of this section shall be guilty of an offence.

That is a blunt statement that the occupier, or the owner if the land is unoccupied, shall be guilty of an offence if a sign appears without the consent of the Commissioner. There is no provision to meet the case where, without the authority of the occupier or owner, some other person erects a sign in contravention of subsection (10). According to subsection (11), the owner or occupier will be guilty. The Minister in his amendment carries that a step further. He says:

In subsection (11), to add at the end of the subsection "and in any prosecution for an offence under this section and notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, the traffic sign shall be presumed, until the contrary is shown by the defendant, to have been provided by a person other than a road authority without the consent of the Commissioner.

From the defendant's point of view, it will be presumed that the sign is erected without the consent of the Commissioner. The prosecution will not even be required to prove that and we are not leaving it open to the defendant to provide as a defence that the sign was erected without his knowledge or consent.

Comment on this

The position is that any person can produce whatever authorisation he has, and that will be an end to it. If the authorisation is not produced in the first instance, it can be produced in court. That will be the proof that the consent exists.

Comment on this

I am talking about the case where someone comes in on my land and erects an unauthorised sign without my consent. Should it not be open to me to prove that in my defence?

Comment on this

It would be open to the Deputy to follow the person who trespassed on his land.

Comment on this

Leave out the question of trespass. If I go in on the Minister's land and erect an unauthorised sign, under the section, will the Minister not be guilty, even though he knows nothing about it?

Comment on this

Theoretically, that would be so.

Comment on this

It is not a question of theory, it is a question of fact.

Comment on this

The Deputy thinks people run around the country putting up signs on other people's lands.

Comment on this

The mere fact that the sign is erected on the Minister's land makes the Minister guilty of an offence and it will be no defence for him to say that he did not erect the sign and that he knows nothing about it; he was living in Dublin, looking after his Ministerial duties. That is no defence for the Minister, and I think it should be.

Comment on this

Do not worry about the Minister. If such signs are erected on my land, I will see to it that they are removed, and whoever put them there as well.

Comment on this

But that would not be a defence in itself.

Comment on this

The argument is very hypothetical. While, hypothetically, the points may be good, I do not see any real sense in them. We have to presume, first of all, that somebody for some reason or another—for the first time, or as a habit—is moving around the country, erecting signs on other people's lands at some cost and trouble and before the owner becomes aware of the position, the Garda are hot on his heels, and so lacking in commonsense that they immediately take a prosecution. In the unlikely sequence of events adumbrated by the Deputy, the owner would find himself in court without a defence. I do not believe that the sequence could possibly continue and that the district justice would give him the hammer regardless. We have to have a most extraordinary sequence of extraordinary events to bring about this extraordinary situation. Candidly, I do not believe in this extraordinary trend of events.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister need feel they are so extraordinary at all. We are dealing with the Minister's amendment. Later in this section, the same provision is made in relation to signs other than road signs. If there is erected on a person's land a sign which makes a road sign less visible or which may cause confusion to a motorist or other user of the road, the same provision is made. If it is erected on a person's land, the owner or the occupier of the land is guilty of an offence, whether he did it or not, and we are declaring by law that he is guilty of an offence, even though he might be entirely innocent.

I do not think it will cause any breach in the Minister's Bill if, at the end of his amendment No. 88 and if again in subsection (15), he adds the words: "unless such owner or occupier shows that the sign was erected without his consent or authority." I would ask the Minister to consider adding those words or words to that effect, both in his amendment and in subsection (15).

Comment on this

Would the House be satisfied—this would not weaken or worsen the position from the point of view of the Bill as I see it—if, first of all, having been approached about the sign—no matter whether it is this sign or the one dealt with later—by the authorities, the owner pleads he knows nothing about it and proceeds to have it removed forthwith, that, then, would constitute a good defence?

Comment on this

I would be quite satisfied with that.

Comment on this

I will consider having that introduced on the next Stage.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Does this section mean that signs such as "Filling station 400 yards ahead" are now prohibited? Subsection (1) (a) says:

gives information in regard to a public road, including the places to which it leads and the distance to or from such places.

Comment on this

It is possible that they could be so described.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

I hope it does mean that.

Comment on this

I would say that anybody contemplating erecting such a sign or having erected such a sign would be well advised to contact the Garda authorities, if this Bill becomes law. Otherwise, he may find himself being contacted by the Garda authorities.

Comment on this

Will the same apply to advertising by business concerns?

Comment on this

It depends. If it could be construed in any way to be a direction for traffic—distance or that type of thing—possibly it could, but it does not come under it in the ordinary sense. Ordinary business signs or advertisements would not be dealt with under this Bill.

Comment on this

It could go very far. It was quite a common thing for garages who were the agents for a particular make of car to put up, several miles outside a town, a sign indicating that such and such a town was so many miles away and then the name of the main dealer.

Comment on this

That is very common.

Comment on this

I know it is quite common. I am not worrying about its being common. I wonder would it be an offence. In fact, it would be a good idea if the erection of all these signs were made an offence, whether they gave directions or not.

Comment on this

You could go a little too far in that way. If I were looking for a Ford agent or a Wolsely agent, it might be very helpful.

Comment on this

Hotels also erect signs to indicate that such a hotel is so many yards ahead.

Comment on this

The Minister does not contemplate in this Bill cutting out that type of advertisement?

Comment on this

It depends.

Comment on this

Deputy Russell referred to signs indicating a filling station so many yards ahead. Does the Minister contemplate cutting out that sort of advertisement?

Comment on this