We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee On Finance. - Road Traffic Bill, 1960—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 165–325 of 325. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Road Traffic Bill, 1960
Enacted

No. 50 of 1960 ›

I merely said that it would be judicious on the part of any person contemplating doing such a thing to contact the Garda authorities, if this measure becomes law. It would be very difficult to decide.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister should take any positive step to prevent that sort of thing.

Comment on this

Is it not the Minister's job to define what is contained in the Bill and what he means to prevent?

Comment on this

No. What we are trying to do is to get a general framework within which we can improve the general appreciation of traffic law in the country. It is impossible to get down to definitions of specific cases and special circumstances. That is why I am being chary, rather than being negative, on the question now being discussed.

Comment on this

Deputy Russell is right in so far as "traffic sign" as defined in this section can include the type of sign he has described. Is that not correct? Therefore, it follows that any sign which indicates a filling station 400 yards ahead or that such and such a hotel is a half a mile away may be erected only with the permission of the Garda Commissioner and of the local authority, and that sort of thing.

Comment on this

Of course, regardless of what is on it, the sign will also be subject to strict control regarding its erection. A sign, regardless of what direction is on it, near the road and visible from the road is being controlled, not under this Bill but under the Town Planning Act.

Comment on this

Not necessarily in every county—very few counties.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will control the erection of signs. There are too many of them.

Comment on this

The Minister is not saying whether or not the erection of these signs is an offence against the section. He says he would advise any person who contemplates erecting such a sign to consult the local Garda. That is a most peculiar statement by the Minister. It is for the Minister to make quite clear in this House, when the question has been posed, whether or not these signs advertising hotels or filling stations, so many hundred yards away, are prohibited under the section. We should have the Minister's viewpoint on it.

Comment on this

My only complaint so far as the regulation of signs under this section is concerned is that I should like to see the Minister going a little further in subsection (14). The Minister provides in subsection (14):

A person shall not provide any such sign, device, notice or light as is not a traffic sign if, on provision thereof, it is visible from a public road and—

(a) it is capable of being confused with a traffic sign,

I agree with that.

(b) it makes a traffic sign provided in accordance with this section less visible to road users,

I agree with that.

or

(c) it obstructs the view of public road users so as to render the road dangerous to them.

I agree with that. I should like to see the Minister putting in a subclause (d) to govern the kind of eye-catching signs one frequently sees and which are a source of distraction to drivers. Certainly, I would have no complaint at all if the Minister also took power in subsection (14) to prevent the erection of signs such as are likely, or reasonably likely, to distract the attention of the driver from his driving while on the road. My only concern, and the Minister has met me on it, is to ensure that innocent people will not find themselves caught, through our inadvertence in the legislature, when it is not intended that they should be caught and I am quite satisfied with the assurance the Minister has given on that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I think we have disposed of amendment No. 88.

Comment on this

Could I point out one matter? I am surprised that Deputy O'Higgins has not already mentioned it because it would be a matter for a practising lawyer. In this amendment of the Minister's, again, I presume from the point of view of efficiency and tidiness, the accused is presumed guilty until he can prove himself innocent, which is a principle I always greatly resent. That will go into subsection (11) but then, if we go on to subsection (18), we find the complete reverse is the case. If you are prosecuted for failing to comply with a traffic sign, the traffic sign is presumed to have been authorised and it is up to you to prove that it was not. That is very much a case of "Heads, I win; tails, you lose". It means that if you are prosecuted for having a sign erected, you are guilty until you can prove the contrary, whereas if you are prosecuted for failure to comply with a notice, the presumption is that the notice was legal.

That does not seem to be a consistent way of legislating. I can see much more reason in supporting subsection (18) than that clause in subsection (11). I do not believe it is ever justifiable to say a defendant shall be deemed to be guilty unless he proves the contrary.

Comment on this

I move amendment 89:—

To add to the section the following subsection:

"(19) A request by or consent of the Commissioner under this section may be signed by an officer of the Garda Síochána authorised in that behalf by the Commissioner."

This amendment permits the Commissioner of the Garda to delegate the power of giving consent in relation to the erection of traffic signs.

Comment on this

What does "officer" include there? Does it mean a commissioned officer?

Comment on this

Superintendent or higher.

Comment on this

Inspectors are cut out?

Comment on this

Obviously.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister if this is the section which includes the provision of white lines?

Comment on this

Does this section give power to the Commissioner to make regulations in relation to white lines? The present position is that the white lines have no legal effect because they disappear.

Comment on this

Section 88 will deal with enforcement about which I think is what the Deputy is more concerned and which I fully agreed is the worthwhile part of this matter. This section here deals with the design, the width——

Comment on this

The definition.

Comment on this

Yes, the definition of the line or the type of line. Section 88 is one which deals with enforcement.

Comment on this

On subsection (16), would the Minister say whether this subsection gives him power to control the use of the type of traffic sign or other sign to which Deputy Russell referred? The Minister said that the erection of these signs might be controlled under town planning but I think he has power here to control the type of sign so that commercial signs erected will not confuse people in regard to direction, distance and so on?

Comment on this

I do not think what the Deputy assumes is so under this subsection.

Comment on this

Maybe I misunderstood him but I thought the Minister told Deputy Russell in reply to his query that this sort of sign: "60 yards to the next filling station" would be deemed to be a traffic sign.

Comment on this

I did not say it actually would. I said it might be. Whether I said it in that way or not, that was the intention.

Comment on this

In a case like that, surely the Minister ought to be able to provide by regulation some sort of control over the type of sign displayed. For instance, around the country there are signs which want you to stop at a particular shop or a particular filling station and the "stop" is about 20 times bigger than the small print. Some motorists have been known to pull up abruptly when they saw such signs. I assume that in some part of this legislation the Minister has power to control that kind of advertising.

Comment on this

Deputy Murphy and other Deputies have been asking specific questions about specific and hypothetical cases they can see arising or indeed may exist at the moment. If I were to give a categorical answer on any one of them it would immediately be taken as of general application and it might not work out that way later on.

Comment on this

Does subsection (14) (a) cover the general position?

Comment on this

We do not want to confuse the Minister or make him say something he does not want to say. Deputy Russell put his finger on it.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

It was not hypothetical.

Comment on this

I do not agree we should go as far as Deputy Russell suggests we should go. He seems to think we should abolish all those signs. I say "no," but we should control them. My question and Deputy Murphy's question is: has the Minister power in this section or any other section in the Bill to control that sort of pseudo-road signing?

Comment on this

Subsections (10) and (14) cover it.

Comment on this

That is all right. I am satisfied.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

Under this section a traffic warden may charge a person who refuses to stop. May he arrest him?

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

In that case the traffic warden would be told to jump in the lake half the time.

Comment on this

He will not jump in the lake just because he is told to do so.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

If a cyclist rides through he can do nothing about it. He has power to charge but he may not arrest.

Comment on this

The appointment of traffic wardens is a function of the local authority. If we go back to Section 90 we find that the Commissioner is fully responsible for the appointment of car park attendants who also have certain functions with regard to traffic. Why has the local authority the function in one case and the Commissioner in the other? I would have thought it would be the logical thing to leave the local authority responsible for the appointment, conditions of service and employment of both traffic wardens and car park attendants.

Comment on this

In regard to traffic wardens, it was the local authorities and other public committees or local committees that first sought to have these wardens appointed and given some sort of status. In addition to that, it is my belief that local authorities have contributed towards the cost of equipping these people; certainly some cost fell upon them. With regard to the other people with whom we dealt earlier on, the parking attendants, it would appear that these people will not be a charge on the local authority; neither will they have been sponsored or requested by the local authorities. There is that distinction in the origin or the possible origin of the two categories, traffic warden and parking attendant. They originated in a different way. One is very closely related and emanates from the efforts of local authorities whereas the other is not so closely allied to them.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Would the Minister consider that a cap is a sufficient description of a uniform?

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

I would say that an armlet is less so. You could see a cap but not an armlet.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

What about a white coat or a distinguishing garment?

Comment on this

The regulations provide a white coat.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

The subsection says:

"uniform" includes any garment, armlet or cap.

Comment on this

The Minister will by regulation prescribe the uniform in all of these cases.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

He can prescribe a cap.

Comment on this

Of course, he could say a white boot, but that is not likely.

Comment on this

Why define "uniform" at all if the Minister will make regulations to define it?

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

It can be any garment. It could be a sock, an armlet or a cap.

Comment on this

The Deputy need have no fears that anything strange like that will happen by regulation.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

I have no wish to be jocose about it or to introduce a spirit of levity. Up to now I think "uniform" has been understood to mean a white coat. I think they should preserve that uniform garment.

Comment on this

This is the section which deals with the removal of a car which is abandoned or left badly parked, and so on. Subsection (2) provides:

Where a vehicle is removed pursuant to this section, such charge in respect of the removal as may be specified by the Minister for Justice by regulations shall be paid to the Commissioner by the owner of the vehicle.

Again, in subsection (3) we read:

Where a vehicle is stored pursuant to this section, such charge in respect of the storage as may be appropriate in accordance with a scale specified by the Minister for Justice by regulations shall be paid to the Commissioner by the owner of the vehicle.

I would ask the Minister to consider in both of these subsections providing that the charge will be a charge to cover expenses reasonably incurred and that there should be some words of limitation to prevent the charge being imposed as a penalty. I am not fussy as to how it will be done but I think something of that sort should be done.

Comment on this

I must say I agree with the Deputy that it would be wrong that there should be, or that there should appear to be, a penalty imposed by means of regulation described in a charge, by making it unduly high. It was that thought which prompted this section in the manner in which it appears now. Nevertheless, if it is felt that it is too weak in that respect I shall give it further consideration and, if need be, amendment. This section was introduced lest there might be the inclination to impose, possibly without much thought about the matter, a fixed charge which would be a penalty plus cost.

Comment on this

If the Minister inserted the words "charge to cover expenses reasonably incurred" or such words——

Comment on this

I shall look into it.

Comment on this

The question arises of liability for any damage that might occur to the vehicle in the course of removal or any damage which might take place during the period of storage. I take it there will be some indemnification whereby the Commissioner of the Garda will not be liable for any alleged damage during that operation.

Comment on this

No provision is made for any specific indemnity.

Comment on this

It would be desirable to provide that there would be no liability for such damage. It is possible that the vehicle might have to be removed and stored in the local pound, yard or garage as the case may be. It might be there for several weeks. In the course of storage, damage may be caused. It may deteriorate very considerably. Would there be any question that the owner could have an action against the Commissioner of the Garda for any such damage?

Comment on this

Looking at it from the other side of the picture, the absence of any indemnity clause in this regard is in itself an insurance to the owner of the car that it is likely to be carefully handled by those removing it lest any damage might occur for which he would claim damages thereafter or for which he could not, if there was an indemnity clause. I can have a look at that also. There are two sides; this is another aspect of the matter. The absence of an indemnity clause may effectively be somewhat of an insurance that the car will be treated with proper respect and due attention during its removal and period of storage.

Comment on this

In the event of the insurance company of the owner not providing that indemnity——

Comment on this

The car could be damaged.

Comment on this

Deputy Moloney wants to go the other way.

Comment on this

Double indemnity.

Comment on this

If the insurance of the owner is not effective at the time——

Comment on this

I shall have a look at that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 91:

To delete subsection (1) and substitute the following subsection:

"(1) A person shall not do any act (whether of commission or omission) which causes or is likely to cause traffic through any public place to be obstructed."

Amendment No. 92 reads as follows:

To add to the section the following subsection:

"(3) Where a person is charged with an offence under this section, it shall be a good defence to the charge for him to show that there was lawful authority for the act complained of or that it was due to unavoidable accident."

The two are interrelated and can be taken together. These two amendments are designed to improve the draft Bill by making it clear that there is no onus of proof on the prosecution to show that an act of obstruction arose in the exercise of lawful authority or due to unavoidable accident. I believe there is a need for this type of precaution and that it is generally accepted that such need exists. Other sections are drafted similar to that which the amendment will now bring about.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Does that apply to pedestrians? I have in mind jay walkers, for instance. Could they be accused of obstruction by darting across the street?

Comment on this

They could, in theory, but I think they would be more effectively controlled and covered by the bye-laws which will be made, rather than by the section. Theoretically, the section would apply to them.

Comment on this

I do not know what the position is in Dublin city. I assume that for a public meeting in College Green or O'Connell Street the permission of the Garda Síochána is sought. The situation in small towns and villages is that the meeting is merely advertised and held. Is this a new proposal? In respect of public meetings, must the permission of the Garda be sought? Is permission sought in respect of a funeral?

Comment on this

It is contained in the 1933 Act, as we now propose by amendment to have it in this Bill. That should answer that.

Comment on this

So much is being put in now that it is not intended to enforce it.

Comment on this

I would not say that is the intention.

Comment on this

In legal theory, if one is to hold a public meeting, one must get the permission of the Garda.

Comment on this

Is it not quite the same thing.

Comment on this

It is the constitutional right of assembly. The Garda have no authority.

Comment on this

Is there not a conflict between that and the Road Traffic Act? You are not supposed to obstruct the traffic.

Comment on this

That is a different matter.

Comment on this

The one observation answers the other. Surely the traffic laws must take second place to the Constitution?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 92:—

To add to the section the following subsection:

"(3) Where a person is charged with an offence under this section, it shall be a good defence to the charge for him to show that there was lawful authority for the act complained of or that it was due to unavoidable accident."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 94:

In subsection (1), page 75, lines 41 and 42, to delete ", without lawful authority or reasonable cause, hold on to, get on or in to, or remain on or in," and substitute "hold on to, or get on or in to,"

Comment on this

I do not like the position where the onus of proof is being taken from the prosecution as it is throughout this Bill. However, I am not objecting.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 95:

To add to the section the following subsection:

"(3) Where a person is charged with an offence under this section, it shall be a good defence to the charge for him to show that there was lawful authority for the act complained of or that otherwise there was reasonable cause therefor."

Comment on this

In this section, it is stated:

(1) A person on a bicycle or a tricycle in a public place shall not hold on to any other vehicle (other than a pedal bicycle which no person is driving)

Why is a pedal bicycle which no person is driving excluded? Is the person cycling on a road and holding on to another bicycle not a danger to traffic and the public? I cannot see why this exclusion is made and I think there is no justifiable case for it. I should like to hear what motivated the Minister to include such——

Comment on this

He has two bicycles.

Comment on this

I do not doubt that the Deputy should raise the point and also point out that the practice of cycling on one machine and pushing another is possibly a dangerous procedure. On the other hand, one may be using a bicycle which may be his only means of getting round. If a person wants to move another bicycle a distance, there is not much way of doing it unless he can find some other means of doing so.

International conventions have, in fact, adopted this form of recommended legislation. I should be inclined to follow that. I should be inclined on my own to defend it also, even if there were not any international convention. Despite the fact that the Deputy may insist it could be a dangerous practice, it can be a very useful one. A person may not have any other means of transport for himself, his wife or family. A man going to work may have no other way of travelling.

Comment on this

Does the Minister assume that a number of people in this country have two bicycles, that one might break down and that it would be no harm to take a second one?

Comment on this

This is not a spare bicycle.

Comment on this

It is most dangerous.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether a man riding a bicycle leading a horse is entitled to that?

Comment on this

It is not illegal.

Comment on this

Is it illegal to get a crossbar?

Comment on this

That depends.

Comment on this

Is it illegal?

Comment on this

Not under this section.

Comment on this

Can a person walk holding on to a horse-drawn vehicle?

Comment on this

Walk?

Comment on this

Walk beside a horse-drawn vehicle?

Comment on this

Anybody who wishes to walk beside a horse-drawn vehicle——

Comment on this

Under this section, is he entitled to hold on to it?

Comment on this

He would be, unless there was some reason why he should not.

Comment on this

And he is not, if he is riding a bicycle?

Comment on this

My question should have related to Section 99.

Comment on this

That is, holding on to a vehicle.

Comment on this

How does a person stand in regard to a horse-drawn vehicle under Section 99?

Comment on this

I suppose it would be wrong to say he would be entitled to do it in all cases, but——

Comment on this

I have often seen young persons holding on to a car.

Comment on this

There is a change here as against the present position. Perhaps the Minister would elaborate on it? Am I right in saying that the present position is that notice of intention to prosecute must be given within 14 days, unless warning is given on the spot? Under the provisions of Section 104, there are now certain circumstances in which the notice need not be given, as set out in subparagraphs (II) and (III) of paragraph (c).

Comment on this

It does differ in respect of the notice to be given with the exception where the 14-day notice is no longer operative.

Comment on this

There is also the addition that, again, the onus of proof of service of the notice is removed from the prosecution?

Comment on this

By and large, that is so.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

Paragraph (b) says:

...and it shall not be necessary to prove that the watch or electronic or other apparatus was accurate or in good working order.

Is the Minister satisfied with that subsection? I must say I am not. If the defence called for some proof that the watch was in good working order, would it not be wise to allow provision to have it tested?

Comment on this

It is possible that the defendant could show in some manner that the stop watch was defective. If that were possible, undoubtedly it would be a satisfactory defence. He would not be precluded from doing that by this section.

Comment on this

He would have some fun proving that any particular stop watch was the one used. It would be worse than the driver who turns up at a parked car and swears he did not park it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 96:

In subsection (1), page 79, to delete "being" in line 59 and substitute "is".

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 97:

In subsection (1), page 80, line 2, to delete "is incapable of making" and substitute "could not be expected to make"

A doubt has arisen as to the situation in which a driver is required to report an accident. As the Bill stands, a driver need not report an accident if somebody involved in the accident is present and does not demand the driver's name and address or other particulars. This exception, where the accident need not be reported, does not apply where the person who is present is incapable—in other words, if he is injured to such a degree that he is no longer capable of demanding anything from the driver in question.

It has been put to me that while a person might not be unconscious and might appear to be capable of looking after his own interests, it could well be that a broken limb or some other injury could bring about such a state of shock and confusion that the person, in spite of appearances, might not, in fact, be capable of properly looking after his own interest. It is to meet this point that the amendment has been put down.

Comment on this

Supposing the person concerned knew the name of the driver and did not ask his name? If they agreed not to report the accident, would that be sufficient?

Comment on this

In the event of agreement, the obligation would, I take it, be removed. The obligation would no longer rest on the driver to make that report if there is agreement by somebody capable of reaching that agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 98:

Before subsection (2) to insert the following subsection:

"(2) Where—

(a) a member of the Garda Síochána has reasonable grounds for believing that an injury has been caused to person or property in a public place and that a vehicle was involved in the occurrence of the injury (whether the use of the vehicle was or was not the cause of the injury), and

(b) the member is not aware of the place where the vehicle is being kept,

the member may require the owner of the vehicle to state to the member where the vehicle is being kept and the owner shall comply with that requirement."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps, with the agreement of the House, amendments Nos. 98, 99 and 102 could be debated together.

Comment on this

These amendments are designed to deal further with the hit-and-run driver. The Garda have experience of cases where such a driver will put his vehicle out of sight until blood stains and other marks are removed, body repairs carried out and broken lamps replaced—anything that might identify him with the accident. The new subsection (2) proposed in amendment No. 98 would require the owner of such a vehicle to disclose its whereabouts. His refusal to do so would be made an offence under amendment No. 99. Under the new subsection (5) proposed in amendment No. 102, the Garda would be entitled to apply for a warrant to enter premises and search for such a vehicle in cases where the owner's co-operation was not forthcoming or not fully forthcoming. In other words, the three amendments are designed to cope with this problem of the hit-and-run driver. It is a rather baffling one, and I believe that what is sought by the amendments is not unreasonable. I think the general belief is that whatever we can do about this matter within reason, we should attempt. These three amendments are a reasonable attempt to help detect the hit-and-run driver.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 99:

In subsection (2), page 80, line 11, to insert "or subsection (2)” before “of this section”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 100:

In subsection (2), page 80, line 12, to insert "on summary conviction" after "liable".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 101 was discussed with amendments Nos. 42 and 43.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 102:

To add to the section the following subsection:

"(5) (a) Where—

(i) a member of the Garda Síochána has reasonable grounds for believing that an injury has been caused to person or property in a public place and that a vehicle was involved in the occurrence of the injury (whether the use of the vehicle was or was not the cause of the injury), and (ii) the member has, either consequent upon a statement made pursuant to subsection (2) of this section or otherwise, reasonable grounds for believing that the vehicle is being kept in any premises,

the member may, on information on oath, apply to any justice of the District Court or Peace Commissioner for a warrant under this subsection.

(b) On an application being made under the foregoing paragraph, the Justice of the District Court or Peace Commissioner to whom the application is made may, if he so thinks proper, by warrant—

(i) authorise any specified member or members of the Garda Síochána to enter, within one week from the date of the warrant, and if necessary by the use of force, the premises to which the application relates, and

(ii) authorise any person or persons entering the premises under the warrant to search the premises and to examine, and take possession of for the purposes of examination, any vehicle found during the search, and any such warrant shall operate in accordance with its terms."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 103:

In subsection (1), page 81, line 39, to delete "on a public road" and substitute "in a public place".

This is largely a drafting amendment. It ensures that a Garda's power to stop a vehicle will apply to public places and not merely to public roads. It extends, or rather confirms, the intention of the Bill that public places shall be treated in this regard in the same manner as public roads.

Comment on this

I have no objection either to the amendment or the section but there is just a small point I wish to raise. It seems it might be better to provide in Section 109 that the obligation of stopping when required to do so by a member of the Garda should apply only in the case of a Garda in uniform. The Minister is probably aware that anyone travelling nowadays on the roads is frequently flagged down for lifts and if we do not specify that the member of the Garda is to be in uniform, a person will not know whether he is committing an offence or not if he chooses to ignore the person who signals him to stop.

Comment on this

Section 111, in fact, does provide what the Deputy seeks.

Comment on this

I think it does, in the main, cover it.

Comment on this

This section does, I think, deal with the question I raised on Section 109. There is just a vague possibility of a Garda, not in uniform, signalling a person to stop and being ignored and an offence could be committed because the non-uniformed Garda is able to produce an official identification card.

Comment on this

I think that would be asking the impossible, that he should produce the card and stop a man who would not know he was a Garda. You cannot have it both ways. I do not think there will be any real difficulty there.

Comment on this

Probably not.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 105:

In subsection (2), to add at the end of the subsection "and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding fifty pounds or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment for any term not exceeding six months or to both such fine and such imprisonment".

The purpose of the amendment is to apply to the offence of taking a mechanically propelled vehicle without authority a heavier penalty than the common penalty. The penalty it is proposed to apply is that which applies to a similar offence under the 1933 Act and I think it should meet the wishes of the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 106 was discussed with amendments Nos. 42 and 43.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the House so wishes, amendments Nos. 107, 108 and 109 may be discussed together and separate decisions may be taken, if required.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 107:

In subsection (1), page 82, line 50, to delete "five" and substitute "four".

In the section, the Minister takes power to permit the driving of certain vehicles over a period of 5½ hours and this amendment seeks to reduce the period to 4½ hours. Amendment No. 108 is also designed to reduce the total number of driving hours in a period of 24 hours from 11 to 9. Amendment No. 109 seeks to extend the rest period for drivers of certain classes of vehicles from a half-hour to one hour.

I suppose the number of hours a driver may be permitted to drive and the rest period he may have are matters of opinion. The opinion of the Minister seems to differ from that of many Deputies. As far as I am aware, the provisions the Minister has embodied in this section are similar to those embodied in the 1933 Act 28 years ago. Surely the Minister must realise that these hours need to be changed? It may be pointless to put the question to the Minister: would he like to have to drive for 5½ hours continuously?

Comment on this

He often has to do so.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister has ever driven a large lorry to that extent.

Comment on this

It would surprise the Deputy to learn what I have driven.

Comment on this

I should be surprised if he did and I am sure there are not many in the House who have driven large lorries for 5½ hours. We consider that 5½ hours is an excessive period to expect a driver of a big bus or a heavy lorry to drive.

The second amendment is designed to reduce the overall driving time in any 24-hours period from eleven to nine hours. Surely it is unreasonable that the drivers I have mentioned should be required to drive up to 11 hours in 24. I do not know what prompted the Minister to reintroduce this section embodied in the 1933 Act. In that period, driving was not as difficult as now: traffic has increased five, or six times, and possibly ten times, since 1933. The hazards and risks are greater. It may be true that roads have improved, that bends are not as bad, that road surfaces are better, but despite that it seems to me a tremendous operation for any man to drive in these modern conditions for a period of 11 hours.

One of the subsections proposes that the driver may get a rest of half-an-hour. Our amendment is designed to increase that period to one hour. I do not know what is in the mind of the Minister when he suggests that a driver who may be compelled by his employer to drive continuously for five and a half hours should then be content with half an hour's rest. Unlike the Minister or Deputy Lynch I have never driven a heavy lorry or a bus but I hate to contemplate my physical condition after driving say from Cork to Dublin, then getting a half hour's rest during which I am expected to have my lunch, and then get back into the cab of the lorry or bus and drive back to Cork or a similar distance which would take me five and a half hours. It is unreasonable that the Minister should expect a driver to be subjected to these conditions.

In the ordinary course of events if these amendments suggested new sections the Minister might be entitled to say that it was for the men's trade unions to negotiate on this matter but here the Minister takes power to determine what the maximum driving hours should be, what the overall driving hours should be in one day and what the rest period should be. We suggest in these three amendments that in the first case a driver should not be required to drive for any longer than four and a half hours continuously or nine hours in a period of 24 hours and that for the rest period he should be allowed one hour rather than a half an hour as proposed by the Minister in the section.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish speaks as if these hours, which are merely continued on from what was in the 1933 Act, will require that workers and drivers must do these hours and must only have the rest that is mentioned here. These hours are the hours beyond which they may not be required and it is from that angle that I think it is only fair to approach this matter. These are the hours beyond which they may not be required to work and drive. It is all very well to say, and there is a certain amount of force in it, that what was suggested and incorporated in the 1933 Act would be very much out of date today. I agree entirely with that but not altogether for the reasons stated by Deputy Corish. Over the years since 1933 there has been little if any exception taken to the hours as outlined as the maximum hours in that Act, which is still current. It is very easy to say that things have become more difficult on the roads today.

I would disagree very much with Deputy Corish in so far as the physical strain, and indeed the mental strain, is concerned. In 1933 when a driver set out on a long journey it was a very short journey if it did not become an adventure as to whether he ever reached his destination or as to whether he ever got back with the same machine. The vehicles in some respects were not very trustworthy especially in regard to their braking systems. The comfort of the drivers today is, I am glad to see in the more recent models of trucks, now being thought about but it certainly was not until quite recently and I never saw anybody kicking up a row about that aspect, which surprised me. By and large, these are not conditions imposed on the workers: they are conditions and hours beyond which they may not be imposed upon. Another vast difference today is—and I do not say this as a cute argument or as an effort to put something over on Deputy Corish, but in all sincerity —that the effectiveness of the unions and their widespread application mean they are better placed to look after in a full and comprehensive way the conditions of employment of the workers than they were. I say that in all sincerity and not as a smart answer to Deputy Corish's plea in this matter.

Taking it all round, to seek to bring in more restricted maxima in so far as these hours are concerned would be a more apparent benefit than a real benefit. Candidly I do not see what real value would be gained if we were to bring these hours in in the manner suggested by these amendments. Conditions are very different today from what they were in those years and the hours, which are maximum hours, are not at all unreasonable considering the improvement in the roads, the improvement in the machines and the more enlightened approach of our employers as a whole as well as the more effective representation of organised labour to look after the interests of their workers. All those together are more effective than anything in this Bill or the old Bill, or anything likely to come in a new Bill.

Comment on this

I gather from the Minister's remarks that this section has been lifted out of a former Act and the amendments, in the Minister's mind, are not necessary in spite of the fact that conditions have changed drastically since the 1933 Act came into operation. I should like to know if the Minister is satisfied on health and efficiency grounds that a man can drive a heavy vehicle for 11 hours within 24 hours with short breaks. In view of the fact that this legislation is brought in to improve safety conditions in the country, to embody in the Act a condition based on the 1933 Act is likely to lead to a recurrence of dangerous conditions on our roads, particularly at night and in winter time if a driver is put to the limit that he may be under this section.

When the section was originally brought in—I am open to contradiction on this—I do not think there was anything in the nature of a 44 or 48 hour week so far as drivers were concerned. It was possible then to knock 66, 68, 70 or even 80 hours out of a man, if you got away with it. Why then should we leave in, in new legislation which is getting rid of prohibitions on the workers, a section which will enable a driver to be exploited to that extent and "exploited" is the word I use? The target nowadays, whether in public relations or amongst labour personnel, is to shorten the working week and even in a country which a number of people in this House are afraid to mention the working week is to be reduced to 35 hours in the near future in many fields. Here we have this Christian country making a provision that a man may be subjected to driving a heavy vehicle for up to 11 hours within a 24 hour period. The Minister should have no objection whatever to accepting Deputy Corish's amendments and particularly the one in regard to the 11-hour period. Deputy Corish and the Labour Party were quite right to put them down.

Comment on this

I should like to point out to the Minister that one of the reasons he did not get complaints from people driving heavy lorries for long hours is that a man with the job of driving a heavy lorry over a long distance and for long hours has what is called a good job from the point of view of pay. Many of those men are in their forties and they would not like to complain even through their unions. I know some of them. I have had experience of driving long distances in heavy vehicles when the roads were very bad. Of course I was younger then and it is all right for people in their twenties.

The Bill is mainly concerned with safety on the roads. That ideal will not be attained if men have to drive heavy vehicles over very long hours. If a standard rule with regard to hours were set down, it would save a great deal of recrimination between employers and drivers. That standard should be less than the 11 hours set out in the Bill.

I agree with the Minister that the roads are better, lorries are better, and so on and so on, but the men are expected to drive much longer distances. That is a great strain on them. They drive at greater speed and on much more crowded roads. Therefore, they are creating a greater hazard.

Comment on this
George E. Russell Mr. Russell

I see the Minister's point that this does not necessarily mean that drivers will have to drive for 5½ hours, or 11 hours in the 24 hours. Obviously, their unions would see they did not exceed what they regard as the maximal period. I think it is fair to say that what were regarded as maximal periods of driving in 1933 should at least be looked at again from the point of view of existing conditions as against the conditions of the roads 28 years ago.

Furthermore, it will probably be many years before we enact another Road Traffic Bill. The Minister is legislating not only for what is happening today but for what is likely to be happening in 25 or 30 years' time, having regard to the rapid expansion of road traffic in other countries, and despite expansion here, we still lag behind other countries in that regard. If we cannot go the whole way, the Minister might make an adjustment in these figures, bearing in mind all the present circumstances and the possible future circumstances.

Comment on this

The Minister seems to regard this section lightly. It would be much better not to put a section in the Bill at all limiting the number of hours a driver may drive a heavy vehicle. He is laying down here that a driver may not drive for more than 11 hours. He may not drive continuously for more than 5½ hours and after a 5½ hours journey, he must get a half-hour break.

The conflict between the Minister and me is that I do not believe those hours are the correct hours. I believe the driver should be required to drive less during the day, less on a continuous journey and have more rest periods. The Minister's arguments with regard to the state of the roads and the conditions for driving 28 years ago compared with the present day conditions is flimsy. He would nearly have us believe a journey from, say, Wicklow to Dublin 28 years ago, in 1933, was a sort of romantic escapade, a journey during which the driver did not know what to expect, that it was a sort of gamble whether or not he would get from Wicklow to Dublin.

Will the Minister consider certain people I am sure he knows of whom I know of, who must, in the corn season, get up at 4 o'clock in the morning to load their lorries, travel a distance of perhaps 100 miles to Dublin, deliver their corn there, get into their lorry, go back 100 miles, come to Dublin again with a second load and then go back home again. That is the type of person I want to protect in this legislation. The Minister says he is protecting them by providing that they must not work for than 11 hours, but they can do a double journey within 11 hours and in doing it, they are a danger to the public. It is a very good thing to say to a labour representative that their trade unions will look after them!

We do not profess to absolute perfection in the trade union movement. It is true to say that this country, in the city in particular and in the country in general, is one of the best organised in Europe, so far as trade unions are concerned, but there are people who are not embraced by the trade union movement and despite all the efforts of the movement, will not be embraced by it, such as casual workers living far away from towns and cities. They are being exploited by merchants in the country today. They have to drive 80, 90 or 100 miles to and from Dublin twice per day. The Minister says they can work for 11 hours in the day and not break the law. On the second journey back from the city, the driver is a pretty tired and groggy man. He can have an accident through no fault of his own but because he is tired and sleepy in his cab.

The Minister wants to continue that situation on the roads of Ireland where there is ten times more driving than there was in 1933. It was not as dangerous in 1933, although they had the solid tyres and bad roads and did not have the speed. There were not the same risks or hazards as there are on the roads today. No matter how well the lorries have improved or how much the surface of the roads has improved, there are still fast sports cars and other vehicles on the roads. The driver must be aware of these conditions. He must be conscious and look out for them. How can he do that when he is driving for the eleventh hour in the day?

I am making these arguments because the Minister is laying down certain rules and conditions. He says there are limits beyond which you cannot drive, and that 11 hours is the maximum which the driver can be required to drive during a day. Certain of the drivers who are organised can be discounted but there are men who are casual drivers today and labourers tomorrow. They are the people who have to be protected and they are the people against whom the public must be protected because, not deliberately but by reason of these conditions, they may cause accidents. The present Taoiseach was in charge of the Road Traffic Bill of 1933 and when the Labour Party asked him at that time to extend the break from half an hour to one hour, he said he would consider it, that it was a good point. Here we are, 30 years after, and the matter is still being considered. It is still being considered whether a driver of a heavy lorry should get more than half an hour's rest in the day. Deputy McQuillan pointed out that conditions of employment have changed, changed so radically that a worker who worked a 54-, a 50- or a 48-hour week in 1933 now works a 40-hour week. If there is an improvement for workers generally, surely the Minister could have provided in his Bill for a reduction in the hours worked by drivers of heavy lorries.

The particular hours suggested may not suit the Minister. There has been a suggestion of a two-hour reduction in the over-all driving. We suggest an increase of half an hour in the break period and that a driver shall not be compelled to drive for more than four and a half hours. The Minister may not agree with these reductions. Surely he does not still contend that the hours acceptable to Dáil Eireann in 1933 should now be acceptable to Dáil Eireann in 1961. I appeal to the Minister to consider these three amendments in an effort to improve the lot of drivers who may not be protected by trade unions.

Comment on this

We are, I think, inclined to pay too much attention to the isolated effect of this section. We are told that 1933 is a far cry from 1961. We are told, not without a certain amount of truth, that conditions today are vastly different and that the strain of driving is more severe than it was in 1933 when these hours were laid down. It is worthy of note that the hours we are discussing here are the hours laid down in the 1960 British Act. If the argument of congestion on the roads and added mental strain in driving in heavy traffic carries weight, surely it should carry weight in Britain to a greater degree than it does here. I am not using that as an argument, but these hours are the absolute limit we think should be allowed. They are not the hours drivers must work. I suppose we will always have with us some few employers who will exploit their drivers and workers if they can get away with it; but, while these people are with us, nothing I might say on this Bill will prevent them acting in that manner, and Deputy Corish knows that very well. This section will not prevent the unscrupulous employer putting the screw on his worker. Usually the workman is afraid that, if he objects, he will lose his job, and he cannot afford to lose his job. Something written into this Bill will not prevent that odd isolated case.

The hours stipulated here are the limits beyond which no worker may be required to go. The possibility is that, by agreement, employers and workers will suit themselves where hours are concerned. I know drivers who drive 11 hours on one day and do no driving at all the following day. The people employing these are private employers, not very strong financially. They have to treat their drivers well because if they overwork them to the point where they may wreck the vehicle and cause damage, then it is the employers who lose.

Comment on this

And then they will sack the unfortunate drivers.

Comment on this

Isolated cases in which unscrupulous employers push their drivers beyond the limit of endurance, to the detriment of their business and the endangering of the lives of others, are not a proper foundation on which to base a general case for further restricting the freedom of the employers and the workers to make arrangements between themselves to suit both workers and employers, without putting an undue strain on any particular driver. If we were providing that drivers must work the 11 hours six days out of the seven and work not less than 5½ at a stretch, I would be absolutely with Deputy Corish, but that is not what is provided here. We are laying down the outside limit beyond which no driver may be required to work.

I will put it in another way. Consider the position of drivers on long-distance haulage. They might resent bitterly being compelled to stop by the roadside for an hour. Stopping for half an hour for a snack is much more to their liking. We are not saying here that drivers must do this or must do that. We are saying they may not be required to drive for longer than a specified period and that they must have a break of at least half an hour at the end of that period. That is an entirely different matter. Arrangements are usually made between the employers and the workers—sometimes by agreement with the trade unions—and a good driver is not so easy to come by. The employer who gets a good driver is very careful in his treatment of him because he is anxious to retain his services. Others will be looking for good drivers and, if he does not look after them, others will. I do not think the fears expressed by Deputy Corish are well founded. If there is still in this country a boss man who has so cowed his employees that they are afraid to complain, nothing written into this Bill will remedy that position. I do not think we should base our case on that type of employer as against the type of general employer we have in this country.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say how he arrived at these figures?

Comment on this

They are the 1933 Act figures.

Comment on this

This is a reintroduction of a section in the 1933 Act. Would the Minister attempt to justify these figures now rather than say they are figures that are taken out of the 1933 Act? All the arguments the Minister has used now suggest to me that he should not have put in any figures.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy like me to remove them, because, mind you, I would?

Comment on this

No. The Minister and I have two different policies on this. I would do exactly what the Minister did but I would reduce the hours.

Comment on this

Let us be quite clear. Again, I am not being smart about this. The Deputy did say that before —"why put them in at all"—or something to that effect.

Comment on this

No. I said, because the Minister put them in, I was asking for a reduction——

Comment on this

Anyhow, you want them in?

Comment on this

——as against the argument the Minister might have used to put no figures in at all and, if I moved an amendment, the Minister might have told me that it was a matter for the trade union movement.

Comment on this

It is quite easy to clarify the point made by Deputy Corish. With regard to the figure used in 1933, that was the time of the Model T and the split rims and the punctures on the roads. The legislation was based on the length of time it would take to make the single journey from, perhaps, Letterkenny to Dublin for one of these very charitable traders for whom the Minister shows such regard. It was accepted that the journey would take 11 hours and that, in all conscience, it was unfair to suggest that a driver who had driven over 200 miles from Letterkenny to Dublin with a heavy load should be expected to about turn after a half-hour or an hour's grace and undertake the return journey.

Even in Ireland we are moving, although not quite as fast as in other countries, and we have discovered that it is now possible for one of these gentlemen in Letterkenny to send a driver to Dublin to collect a heavy load and to make the double journey within eleven hours. That is the reason the eleven hours has been retained.

The Minister has given no justification whatever for retaining the figure of eleven hours incorporated in the 1933 Act. It is sad to hear a Minister at this stage saying that good drivers are perhaps, scarce and that it is up to the employer, if he has a good driver, to be nice to him or some other merchant will take him away from him. That is no argument at all when we are dealing with legislation in connection with the welfare of members of the community.

The Minister has suggested that this provision is incorporated in the 1960 British Act. To be fair to him, he went on to say that that had no bearing on its introduction here. If it had not, I do not know why he was so anxious to mention it. The fact that the British decided on such a measure surprises me and I should like a little more information with regard to the safeguards provided in the British legislation in which such a provision as this was incorporated, as the Minister suggests.

When I was about 11 or 12 years of age, the journey from Athlone to Dubline took about four hours. There were a number of breaks to fix the occasional puncture. A good deal of bad language was used on those occasions by the driver with regard to the condition of the roads and the frequency of punctures. It was a leisurely journey, if you like, pleasant in many way. The condition of the roads and the leisureliness of the pace at that time are not comparable with present day conditions. Nowadays, it is a matter of arriving at one's destination in the shortest possible space of time. The stage has been reached when few people are prepared to stop to help a neighbour in trouble on the road. I know, of course, it has no bearing on the matter of the hours involved in Section 114 but it is clear that in 1933 the journey to the city of Dublin from Kerry or Cork or the tip of Donegal could be done inside 11 hours and the House was progressive enough at that time to say that that was the limit and that a driver would not be allowed to make the return journey. The measure was progressive in 1933, but, in 1961, the reintroduction of that type of legislation is putting the clock back, to say the least of it. I suggest that the Minister, at this 11th hour, should accept the proposal of Deputy Corish.

Comment on this

The main point made by the Minister is that there is no compulsion in this, that the section does not intend that a man should be compelled to work up to 11 hours. We all agree that the Minister's main function in this Bill is to try to prevent road accidents and death but in this section the Minister's attitude is that if a driver of a heavy vehicle drives for a period less than 11 hours, he is deemed not to be a danger to the public—not absolutely—he may be if he drives only for half an hour. From many points of view, if a man drives for over 11 hours, the Minister and the Government think he is a danger to the public. That is laudable. The Minister's intention in the Bill is to try to protect the lives of the road-using public but he ought to analyse this matter of the 11 hours.

The Minister did have occasion to say that in cases where a man may be required to drive 11 hours in a day, that would not happen for very many days or, at any rate, for very many weeks. I want to assure the Minister that in the season for, say, the distribution of lime and fertiliser and delivery of corn, men are required to drive for very long periods over a period of practically two months.

The Minister says, by inference, if you like, that the man who drives for, say, 2½ hours to Dublin, who waits there for his lorry to be unloaded, say, an hour, and gets into the lorry again and drives back for another 2 hours or 2½ hours, who is hanging around there while the lorry is being loaded and, although he may not be required to do so, helps with the loading of the lorry, which may take another hour or an hour and a half, and who is required to undertake the 2½ hour journey to Dublin again, there to be hanging around or doing odd jobs on his car for another hour, who gets into the cab and goes back on the two and a half hour journey, is pretty safe so long as he is driving only for 11 hours. The Minister must also consider the time in between. Even apart from the time in between, a man who is driving for 11 hours in a period of 24 hours and who does that for weeks must be a danger to himself and to the public.

Comment on this