We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Housing (Loans and Grants) Bill, 1962. — Second Stage.

Contributions 1–106 of 212. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing (Loans and Grants) Bill, 1962
Enacted

No. 15 of 1962 ›

Neil T.C. Blaney Minister for Local Government (Mr. Blaney) Fianna Fáil

I move that the Bill be now read a Second Time. This Bill, as its long Title indicates, makes further and better provision in relation to grants and loans for private housing and it also consolidates the existing provisions of the Housing Acts on this subject. It is a first step in the simplification and modernisation of the general housing code.

Housing legislation at present comprises the separate codes of the Labourers Acts (1883-1958), the Housing of the Working Classes Acts (1890-1960), the Housing (Financial and Miscellaneous Provisions) Acts, 1932 to 1960, and the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts (1899-1958).

It is proposed in this Bill to consolidate and amend the various provisions in the latter two codes dealing with grants and loans for private housing.

The statutory provisions relating to the general powers of housing authorities in the Labourers Acts (1883-1958) and the Housing of the Working Classes Acts (1890-1958) are also being reviewed for consolidation and amendment in new legislation which will be introduced as soon as possible. Housing law will then be comprised in only two codes, the Loans and Grants Bill now before the House and the remainder of the law as proposed to be consolidated in relation to local housing authorities.

The existing provisions relating to State grants for new and reconstructed houses expired on the 31st March, 1962. The Bill (Section 2) provides for the continuance at existing levels of the grants available for the provision of new houses. No terminal date for the completion of grant houses is specified and continuing and extending legislation will therefore be unnecessary in future so far as the payment of grants is concerned. While the housing law is thus being made permanent, this is, of course, without prejudice to the introduction of any amending legislation which may be found necessary from time to time.

The present rates of grants for new houses are being retained, subject to the qualification that a grant will in future be made for unserviced houses only in cases in which the provision of a piped water supply and sewerage facilities is not reasonably practicable. This amendment is in accord with the policy of securing the provision of sanitary services in dwellings wherever possible.

Section 3 deals with reconstruction grants and proposes to continue these grants at the existing rates. Hitherto grants under separate sections and subject to different conditions were paid for (a) the reconstruction of houses in the occupation of farmers, the total rateable valuation of whose holdings did not exceed £50 and to agricultural labourers reconstructing houses for their own occupation in a rural area; and (b) the repair and improvement of houses by other persons. Section 3 deals with both these classes of grants on uniform conditions, subject to retention of the basis on which the grants are at present determined, viz., two-thirds of the cost of the work in the case of category (a) and one-third for category (b), but subject also in both cases to the maximum limit as set out in the section. The expression "agricultural labourer" is not being retained in this context: the classes for whom grants of two-thirds of the cost are to be made are referred to as persons who derive their livelihood solely or mainly from the pursuit of agriculture. Thus, farmers and agricultural labourers are brought within the same qualification. The proposed amalgamation of the two existing sections is designed to secure a desirable uniformity and simplification in administration.

Section 4 deals with the payment of second or subsequent grants in respect of a house which had previously received a new-house or reconstruction grant. The 1932 Housing Act contained no positive provisions allowing second grants and this situation was, in the earlier years of the housing programme, regarded as justified for the purpose of securing that durable and good quality work would be carried out when the house was being built or being reconstructed for the first time. The possibility of financial exploitation of a system of unrestricted successive grants had also to be guarded against. With the passing of time, however, and the ageing of housing stock either built or reconstructed originally with these grants, some relaxations were considered necessary to keep houses in repair, and improve them, to prevent deterioration, to allow for family expansion and to enable the question of storm damage to be dealt with.

Various amendments made in 1950, 1952 and 1954 helped the objective of securing durable and good standard work initially, while allowing subsequent grants for necessary reconstruction after the passing of a reasonable time or the emergence of circumstances outside the applicant's control. Under this section, the general bar to payment of further reconstruction grants, within a fifteen-year period of the first grant, is retained as is the reduced period of 10 years where re-roofing is necessary. However, as rigid application of a limiting period gave rise to hardship in certain cases where particular works became urgently necessary before the expiration of the period, it was decided in 1960, with the concurrence of the Minister for Finance, to pay limited grants for some of the more urgent works likely to arise under Section 12 of the Housing (Amendment) Act, 1954, which did not include a prohibition on the payment of further grants. Specific statutory authority for the continuance of the payment of these special grants is now being taken. The existing legislative power to make a grant for works necessitated by storm damage is being re-enacted with the reservation that a grant for works of this nature will not carry with it a disqualification on the subsequent payment at any time of a grant for normal reconstruction work.

The maximum grants under the section will be as follows: (a) For extra rooms to relieve overcrowding, involving an addition to floor area, £50 per room; (b) For provision of a bathroom, involving an addition to floor area, £50; (c) For storm damage, two-thirds of the cost in the case of persons deriving their livelihood solely or mainly from agriculture, including farmers with holdings not exceeding £50 and one-third in other cases, subject to the maximum of £100, £120 or £140, as appropriate. For works urgently necessary to conserve a house, one-third of cost subject to a maximum of £100, £120 or £140, as appropriate.

The aggregate of grants made at any one time under the section must not exceed the appropriate statutory maximum of £100, £120 or £140, which obtain at present. Payment of the grants will be made subject to regulations.

Provisions governing the payment of grants for the installation of private water and sewerage facilities are not being retained in housing legislation but will be dealt with in the Local Government (Sanitary Services) Bill, recently introduced.

As supplementary grants are closely connected with State grants, I shall now deal with the new provisions in this respect in advance of the order shown in the text of the Bill. Section 12 of the Bill discontinues the graded system of supplementary grants by local authorities for new houses, leaving housing authorities free to decide the type of supplementary grant scheme most suited to local circumstances within specified maximum limits of income and valuation for eligibility. The existing annual income limit is £624 for county boroughs and contiguous areas and £520 elsewhere but no limit applies to tenants of local authority dwellings or persons eligible for such tenancies. A uniform limit of £832 per annum is now proposed. An increase to £50 in the maximum valuation limit of £35 is proposed for farmers. The proposals confer on local authorities a power to exclude categories of applicants to whom, although they come within the statutory income or valuation limits, the payment of a supplementary grant by the housing authority is not considered to be warranted. Similarly, a housing authority will be free to limit their scheme to houses of particular types. As regards supplementary grants for reconstruction, repair and improvement, there are no existing statutory maxima for income and valuation. Section 8 of the Bill preserves this position.

Section 5 of the Bill introduces a new type of grant to assist minimum essential preservation work in rural areas. This proposal is part of a planned approach to deal with the remaining unfit housing problem in these areas. The evidence available so far, from the survey of unfit housing, shows a manifest need for flexibility of treatment of this branch of the housing problem. There are many persons living in unfit conditions who are not and are never likely to be in a position to rehouse themselves and whose needs cannot or are not being met by housing authorities. Owing to such factors as the location of the houses and the age and circumstances of the occupants, local authorities cannot be expected to give a high priority to providing new houses for these classes. Private grants and loans procedure has up to now been generally ineffective in these cases. The purpose of the section is to enable the occupant to carry out only the minimum essential works such as roof repairs, repairs of doors or windows and wall plastering. The work will be carried out on an economic and temporary basis so that the house may be reasonably fit for a limited period and so that its subsequent abandonment or demolition will not involve any substantial abortive expenditure The proposal will not in any way relieve the rural housing authority of its obligation to secure the demolition or closure of unfit rented houses which, normally, are a feature of urban, rather than of rural areas.

The State grant proposed under this section will not exceed £80, or two-thirds of the cost of the work, whichever is less. The housing authority may, in addition, make a grant sufficient to defray the balance of the cost or may contribute within this limit building materials or labour or other assistance in kind.

Housing authorities are also being authorised under this section to carry out the necessary works of repair with the consent of the occupiers and, in such circumstances, the State grants will be payable to the housing authority.

Section 6 of the Bill introduces a new scheme of grants to philanthropic and charitable organisations for the provision of housing for elderly persons. It is hoped that the increased rate of grant (£300 per dwelling unit) will provide the necessary impetus to encourage the provision of this type of housing. Aspects of a social character which are normally outside the scope of housing policy attend the problem of housing old people. For that reason, it is desirable that philanthropic or charitable organisations should be encouraged as far as possible to provide the necessary dwelling accommodation. Generous public financial aid is justified for this purpose since the funds likely to be available to such organisations are normally limited.

The section provides for the payment of supplementary grants by housing authorities of amounts not exceeding the grants paid by the State, and provision is also made entitling housing authorities to prescribe such conditions in relation to the payment of supplementary grants as they think fit.

Section 7 introduces a new type of grant designed to encourage experimentation by architects, builders, co-operative groups and local authorities in the production of low cost housing suitable for persons in low income groups. The grant for the erection of the approved prototype will not exceed 50 per cent. of the approved estimated cost. Subsequent reproductions of a successful prototype will be eligible for normal new house grants and supplementary grants in the ordinary way.

It has been represented by architects that, given more freedom of design, house costs could be reduced. Local authorities also have occasionally sought sanction to experimentation in design and specification related to local needs and circumstances. No adequate machinery exists at present which would encourage development of these suggestions. Where departures from prescribed standards occur or are proposed in private grant cases, it is usual to reduce the amount of grant normally available in order to preserve the principle that fixed standards should be observed as far as practicable.

If co-operative or self-help housing, to which I will refer later, can be developed into a formal movement in any area, the erection of a specially designed experimental or "prototype" house would provide useful experience to the co-operative group and encouragement to the spread of such activity.

The section proposes that, if a house-type were evolved through the experimentation envisaged which necessitated such a departure from the present fixed standards as would normally warrant a reduction or loss of grant, the new house-type (perhaps with modification) will be brought especially within eligibility for normal rates of grant for the purpose of reproduction. This will preserve the existing principle of fixed standards to be applied to grant-houses in general and will also enable local authorities to pay supplementary grants in the normal course.

Section 9 and 12 of the Bill authorise housing authorities to pay supplementary grants for the reconstruction and provision of houses under the Housing (Gaeltacht) Acts.

Section 10 re-enacts and extends Section 13 of the Housing (Amendment) Act, 1958, so as to enable a housing authority to make loans for the repair of (a) vested cottages; and (b) houses which have been or will be sold by housing authorities to tenant purchasers in urban areas, where the fee simple or fine is or will be mortgaged as security.

Section 11 provides for the making of loans by housing authorities for the acquisition or construction of houses. The section is intended to replace the existing provisions of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts and will be brought into operation on an appointed day by Order made by the Minister. The section authorises the making of regulations to deal inter alia with the details of procedure relating to the making of loans, the classes eligible for loans, repayments, transfers, etc.

Section 13 is a re-enactment and extension of Section 10 of the Housing (Amendment) Act, 1956, under which housing authorities are empowered to guarantee advances to private persons for the provision of houses. This guarantee procedure has, however, been almost wholly ineffective. The amended section enables guarantees to be given in respect of loans for reconstruction work as well as for new houses and extends the type of bodies to which guarantees may be given. The new section may in this way be utilised to a greater extent than its predecessor.

Section 17 is a new provision which authorises the Minister to withhold or reduce a grant where the conditions subject to which the grant was paid have not been complied with.

Section 20 of the Bill enables the Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, to vary from time to time the amounts of the maximum advances to be made to borrowers under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. I propose, on the passing of this Bill, to fix a uniform maximum of £2,000 which will govern advances by all housing authorities and which will replace the existing statutory limits of £1,600 and £1,800.

Sections 21 and 25 (subsection 2) make the necessary transitional provision for the payment of grants outstanding at 31st March, 1962, and authorised within the period 1st April, 1962, up to the passing of this Bill.

The remaining sections are necessary re-enactments of existing provisions of the Housing Acts dealing with private housing grants. I have now outlined the contents and the aims of this Bill, which is designed to encourage the elimination of unfit housing so far as positive legislation can deal with this problem.

As the Dáil is aware, a survey of unfit houses has been in progress for some time, with special reference to the extent of the problem in rural areas. In the last 30 years, the housing programme, particularly that portion of it undertaken by local authorities, has been more effective in urban than in rural areas, where the current survey figures up to the present indicate that some 30,000 houses need to be repaired and 20,000 more require to be replaced. The full completion of the survey will not materially alter the overall picture of the problem presented by these figures. The problem is a big one and obviously more difficult to solve than that section of the housing programme that has already been successfully implemented.

In rural areas, the unfit housing problem does not lend itself to the treatment possible in urban areas where blocks of unfit property, often in single ownership, can be dealt with by large-scale clearance operations. The outstanding feature of the rural problem is that of isolated and owner-occupied houses situated on holdings of varying economic categories. These categories range from those willing and able to meet the cost of new houses of reconstruction of their old houses with the aid of grants down to those who, for financial or other reasons, are either unable or unwilling to face the implications of even a very modest degree of repair. As Deputies familiar with rural conditions are aware, many elderly single persons or elderly couples with little or no resources or a short expectation of life without assured succession for occupation of their dwellings are the classes least inclined or able to do anything for themselves. As I have already said, it is part of the problem that local authorities are not universally disposed to regard this problem as part of their housing functions or, where they do accept some responsibility, they can give only a low priority to the rehousing of these classes, as compared with others seeking new housing.

So far as legislative proposals can go, this Bill contains provisions specially designed to deal with the needs of the rural position. For rural as well as for urban areas, the removal of housing grants from the need for renewable legislation gives an assurance to all concerned that they may continue to plan and build without fear of the non-renewal of the legislation on which the grants depend. The recurrence of unfitness in housing, even in the best circumstances, is a perennial problem and not one that can be assumed to be finally eradicable in the sense that even the best houses decay in time. The proposed provisions in regard to loans and eligibility for supplementary grants made the way easier for the erection of new houses and the reconstruction of old ones. The introduction of the minimum essential repair grants provided in Section 5 for county health areas represents an important new principle of housing policy which, I hope, will do much at reasonable cost to restore the habitability of some of the worst houses in rural areas.

Housing activities in recent years have shown a marked trend in the direction of private enterprise. This welcome trend, which appears likely to continue, deserves to be nurtured not only by improved legislation but also by positive encouragement of both individual effort and co-operative action. The success which has attended the active help and advice given by my Department to persons desiring to organise private group water supply schemes convinces me that a planned approach on these lines to the rural housing problem may yield results which more official lines of action could not achieve. The approach by way of self-help will, I am certain, be considerably assisted by the general provisions of the Bill and particularly by the provisions of Section 7 which will encourage experimentation towards the production of low-cost housing.

The general pattern of this Bill fits therefore into the first part of the attack on the unfit housing problem which is of particular urgency in rural areas. There is still a wide and important field in which local authorities can continue to make, by the direct provision of houses, further valuable contributions to meeting housing needs. I propose to deal with this aspect of the matter in conjunction with my proposals for an up-to-date consolidated code for local housing authorities, which will, I hope, contain special provision in relation to the rural situation. As I have already intimated, I hope to bring this legislation before the House without any great delay. When these two measures are enacted, we shall have in up-to-date form all the powers required for the effective prosecution of the housing activities of private and public enterprise.

Comment on this

The Minister in bringing this Bill to the House did do what we regretted he had not done in the earlier Bill, that is, to circulate a White Paper. Therefore we can at least say we have this explanatory memorandum to assist us in understanding the Bill. The Bill, however, is a pretty complex one, extending as it does over 26 sections and three Schedules. When one remembers that and when one recollects also that everyone knew that a Housing Bill had to be enacted as soon as possible after 1st April, 1962, it is virtually impossible to understand why the Minister was so dilatory in bringing the Bill to the House. We all knew such legislation was essential after the commencement of this financial year because the old housing enabling legislation terminated on 31st March last. In those circumstances, I am completely unable to understand why the Minister left it until these last few dying days of the Dáil before the recess to introduce this legislation.

Even with the assistance of the explanatory memorandum, for which I am grateful, the measure is one that it is not possible adequately and clearly to discuss here within a very short compass of time. It is therefore self-evident that the Minister must accept blame, and serious blame, for not having been sufficiently far forward with his programme and his plans to introduce this Bill at a time when the other Act was expiring. It is undoubted that various people have held back from starting new housing works waiting for the publication of this measure. Even in my own constituency, I know many cases where people, believing that grants were to be increased, held back, in case, by having commenced work before such grants were announced, they would lose the benefit of new provisions.

They will suffer a shock on the double now. First they will get a shock because there is no increase whatever in grants provided by this Bill to meet increased costs and, secondly, in many cases because of the neglect of the Minister to introduce the Bill at a reasonable time, they have lost — I was going to say a great part of the summer but I do not think anybody could describe the weather we have had so far as being summer — a substantial period of time. Apart from that, I must confess that I was almost stunned by the audacity of the Minister in one phrase. It is audacity of which the Minister is perfectly entitled to be proud. Towards the end of his speech, he said:

Housing activities in recent years have shown a marked trend in the direction of private enterprise. This welcome trend...

What are the facts? The facts are, of course, that there is a trend. If one likes to compare the proportion of private housing to local authority housing, undoubtedly the proportion of private housing is increasing. Why is it increasing? It is increasing because local authority housing has virtually ceased in comparison with what it was in earlier years. To suggest that there has been a marked trend in the direction of private enterprise is a distortion of the facts as they appear in the reply by the Minister to a question on 20th May last. On 20th May, at Columns 1579 and 1580, Volume 195, No. 12. of the Official Report, the Minister told Deputy Jones and the House that this was the position in relation to housing:

Number of houses built by local authorities

1954-55 | 5,267

1955-56 | 4,011

1956-57 | 4,784.

Lo and behold, in 1957 enter Fianna Fáil into the realm of Government: 1957-58, 3,467; 1958-59, 1,812; 1959-60, a little bit up — 2,414; 1960-61, 1,463; 1961-62, 1,238. Let us put that in pattern: 1,238 in 1961-62 after Fianna Fáil had been in office for five years and they surely cannot say that in five years they were still suffering from any effects of anything that was done by their predecessors. Yet, that figure of 1,238 contrasts with the figures of 5,267, 4,011 and 4,784 in the three years during which Deputy O'Donnell was responsible as Minister. I agree, if one counts as a virtue cessation of local authority building, that has been a swing in relation to private enterprise.

One goes on to examine the figures in relation to private enterprise housing. By that, I presume the Minister means the number of houses built by private persons with the aid of grants under the Housing Acts and that when the Minister was referring to the welcome trend in relation to housing activities by private enterprise it was that particular type of house to which he was referring. I agree that in 1961-62 there was a slight increase over the previous year in that type of housing but the fact remains that in no single year since Fianna Fáil came into office in 1957 have there been as many houses built by private persons with the aid of housing grants as there were in any of the three years for which Deputy O'Donnell was responsible, from 1954 to 1957.

Here are the facts; here are the figures. Let them go on the record of this House and let those members of Fianna Fáil who honestly believed — and there were some who honestly believed — the claptrap that was spoken and produced by Deputy Smith when he was Minister for Local Government before he became Minister for Agriculture—consider these facts and figures and let them come in their own minds, their own consciences and their own honesty to see whether Deputy Smith when Minister for Local Government and his successor were justified in the comments and the claims they made in respect of it.

Comment on this

You had not a penny in 1956 to pay a housing grant. I will tell you what you did.

Comment on this

Deputy Dolan should not make a liar of Deputy Blaney as Minister for Local Government because Deputy Blaney, on 20th May, said that this was the story, not the claptrap which poor Deputy Dolan swallowed hook, line and sinker. Here is what the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Blaney, says and I am sure he is right. I am sure he is telling the truth.

Comment on this

You had not a penny — not a penny. That is why housing stopped.

Comment on this
Patrick McAuliffe Acting Chairman (Mr. McAuliffe) Labour Party

Deputy Sweetman to continue.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Dolan will try to explain this to himself: Here is what the Minister for Local Government says — that in 1954/55, 5,006 houses were built with the aid of housing grants; that in 1955/56, 5,436 houses were built with the aid of housing grants and that in 1956/57, 5,647 houses were built with the aid of housing grants. These are the figures given by the Minister — 5,006, 5,436, 5,647.

Comment on this

They were started in 1954 and by 1957 there was not a penny to pay a housing grant. That is what happened. Those are the facts.

Comment on this

There were as many houses built in one year as there were in seven when Fianna Fáil were in office.

Comment on this

Facts are facts. The facts are quite simple.

Comment on this

The ordinary people of this country know what happened.

Comment on this

They do.

Comment on this

They gave you your answer.

Comment on this

The people must be very green or you would not be over there.

Comment on this

Did I hear Deputy Egan make a remark? Would he like to repeat it?

Comment on this

I would be quite happy to talk to you any time you want to talk to me, any place.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Sweetman to continue on the Bill. Interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

All right.

Comment on this

Deputy Dolan will have some explaining to do as to why, if there was not a penny piece to pay in grants, the Minister for Local Government said 5,006, 5,436 and 5,657 houses were erected in each of those years with the aid of housing grants.

Comment on this

Ask the merchants what credit they gave. They paid for it.

Comment on this

There were no grants paid, as Deputy Sweetman knows. He paid no grants.

Comment on this

There is one thing that is clear.

Comment on this

Why did you run out in 1957?

Comment on this

There is one thing, apparently, that is clear — we did not pay for certain things.

Comment on this

Even John Bull did not pay you — the man you thought would give you the money.

Comment on this

The lighthouse keeper seems to have got an additional supply. Further supplies appear to have arrived.

Comment on this

I defy you to state the amount of money you gave in grants in 1956.

Comment on this

I will indeed.

Comment on this

State the amount of money you paid in 1956 in housing grants — nothing — nil — you know it. You are the biggest fraud this country ever produced.

Comment on this

Go back to Castlebar again.

Comment on this

Do not mind Castlebar. You go back to your own fellows, the British.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy must cease interrupting. Deputy Sweetman on the Bill.

Comment on this

5,006, 5,436, 5,647 — and I challenge Deputy Dolan, when he is speaking after me, if he is going to speak, to provide to this House the amount that was paid out of the Local Loans Fund for housing in each of the three years 1954/55, 1955/56——

Comment on this

Nothing, as you know.

Comment on this

——and 1956/57.

Comment on this

I am the man who wrote to you.

Comment on this

Let him produce the figures and if he does not produce them to-day, I will produce them for him on the Money Resolution.

Comment on this

The people of the country produced them in 1957.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Sweetman must be allowed to continue on the Bill without interruption. Every Deputy will get a chance to speak.

Comment on this

We will provide him with the figures on the Money Resolution, if he does not want to provide them to-day. It was the Government which Deputy Leneghan supports which permitted Singer to get away with it, not this side of the House. Coming to the years about which Deputy Dolan is going to enlighten us, the facts are that in not a single year since 1957 has there been as many houses erected with the aid of housing grants, according to the Minister for Local Government.

The figures are: For 1957-58, 3,629; for 1958-59, 2,684; for 1959-60, 3,740; for 1960-61, 3,952 and for 1961-62, 4,049. In other words, in every single year there were more than 1,000 less than the number to which I referred a while ago. If anybody wants the amounts paid to Dublin Corporation from 1955 onwards, I have them here. In 1954-55, the amount was £4,622,195; in 1955-56, £4,041,587; in 1956-57, £3,625,694; in 1957-58, after Fianna Fáil were in office, £2,165,045; in 1958-59, and again with Fianna Fáil in office, £1,847,596. In 1959-60, the amount was £1,611,587, just less than half the amount in 1956-57 about which there has been a certain amount of talk.

If one wants to go from one end of the country to the other, to Cork, we will find the same situation, that there was more money paid out for Cork Corporation housing expenditure, as Deputy Anthony Barry can also vouch for, in the years 1955, 1956 and 1957 than there was in any year since. I know that the situation in respect of housing except in Dublin and Cork is that the demand for local authority housing is tapering off. That is not the case in either Dublin or Cork and that excuse is not available in relation to the provision of grants for either Dublin or Cork.

Comment on this

It was, until this Government came in.

Comment on this

You had not six-pence to pay anybody.

Comment on this

I am trying to listen to the intelligent observations of a man who knows something about this matter.

Comment on this

I am intelligent enough to know that you did not have money to pay anybody.

Comment on this

The number of people requiring houses in Dublin is increasing since this Government came in.

Comment on this

If that is so, perhaps Deputy Colley can explain to me why it is that in the last financial year less than half the funds were provided for Dublin Corporation housing than were provided in the past three years in which I had to provide the funds.

Comment on this

It takes a number of years for a scheme to come to fruition.

Comment on this

How many?

Comment on this

About two.

Comment on this

How many years have Fianna Fáil been in power since 1957? — Five. Deputy Colley is new to this House but I see that the old warrior, Deputy Collins, could see that he was walking himself into it.

Comment on this

I have the figures here for the cities of Dublin and Cork. If the Deputy does not believe that I am quoting the correct figures, they are easily available to him, but I am quoting the correct figures. They are unchallengeable by the Minister for Local Government. I do not blame some Deputies opposite who swallowed hook, line and sinker statements made by their Front Bench in the honest belief that their leaders were telling them the true story. The facts of those figures show that their leaders were not doing so.

We can have further discussions on this matter today when other Deputies speak or on the Money Resolution on this Bill. There will be plenty of opportunities but the facts cannot be gain-said that in relation to funds provided for housing, the figure for any year between 1954 and 1957 has never been touched since. These are figures for money paid to honest people who made honest claims.

I would extend the period of two years which Deputy Colley mentioned to three years, one year to get your sites, one year to plan and one year to build.

Comment on this

I would not quarrel with that.

Comment on this

Cutting it down to what he said was unfair to himself. Let us say it would be three years but Fianna Fáil have been in office for five years. After five years, the position in Dublin Corporation is, unfortunately, a pretty pale replica of what it was before. If the Deputy wants the dtails, I shall willingly give them to him for each year.

Comment on this

Give us the trend.

Comment on this

It is right down and still, after five years of Fianna Fáil, the figures are less than half what they were in respect to expenditure on housing for the working classes: £1,238,616 in 1961-62 and £2,689,259 in 1957 for housing for the working classes in Dublin. In Cork, the comparative figures are £366,000 in 1961-62 and £741,360 in 1957. No matter how the Deputy plays with the trend, when he looks at the full figures, he will find he was codded.

Comment on this

If I might interrupt the Deputy——

Comment on this

I always welcome a sensible interruption.

Comment on this

I would suggest that if the Deputy takes the figure for the three year period, he must relate the figure for 1957 to what was initiated in 1954, and if he takes the trend after 1957, he must make allowance for what was happening during the 1954-57 period. Then he will see the swing.

Comment on this

On the same basis, what was paid out in 1958 would be what was planned in 1955.

Comment on this

I grant that, but——

Comment on this

And the amount for 1958 is far in excess of the amount in 1962.

Comment on this

To pay for the Deputy's debts.

Comment on this

I cannot hear Deputy Sweetman with this continuous interruption from the Deputy.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Leneghan must allow Deputy Sweetman to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

Never mind. I am used to certain people making noises. On the same three-year basis, the position in 1957/58 should show itself in 1960/61. In 1960/61, the figure was £889,000, or less than half the 1955 plan.

Comment on this

Agreed, but——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Sweetman must be allowed to continue without these interruptions.

Comment on this

However Deputy Colley takes it, the figures show him wrong.

Comment on this

It is Deputy Blowick's bushes the Deputy is talking about?

Comment on this

If the position is that Deputy Colley is anxious to tell us he is penitent for what happened in those years and is now taking steps to improve the situation and accelerate the swing in Dublin and Cork, I willingly accept his penitence.

Comment on this

We will relate the figures to the requirements.

Comment on this

Relate them to the facts, and I shall give the facts. The Deputy was one of the people who was honestly and conscientiously misled. A great many people to my knowledge have deferred operations under the Housing Acts because of failure by the Minister to announce new legislation. The fact is that not merely have a number of people held back in that respect but a great many people who are about to build now will be bitterly disappointed by the fact that the grants have not been increased. Most people who are building expected that the grants being announced under new schemes would be better than those in existence, but of course, as the Minister indicated in his opening speech, all this Bill does in relation to grants is to continue them at the level at which they were previously paid.

There will be considerable disappointment in that respect. Not merely will there be disappointment but also some hesitation on the part of people to go ahead with what they had planned. As far as I can understand, the procedure that will now be adopted under Section 3 will mean that instead of two types of form of application for housing grants, in future, only one will be used and it will be immaterial whether the house concerned is one in respect of which the person has a valuation of a certain size or not. The same criterion will be operative to both classes.

I do not know whether Deputies in other areas have found as we have in Kildare that people frequently apply for grants, believing they were eligible under one section only to find that they had to apply under the other section. They then had to get a certificate from the local authority as to the suitability of the house for reconstruction grants under Section 3. As I understand the amalgamation of the two sections into one in the new Bill, it would seem that one type of application only will be required in future and accordingly the administration should be eased in that respect.

The Minister is proposing here that grants for new houses will be paid by virtue of Section 2, only where a piped water supply and sewerage system cannot reasonably be provided. I take it that what is meant there is that where a public or private supply cannot reasonably be provided, the reconstruction grant is intended to apply only to a public system. It is almost certain that is so but I should like to have it confirmed by the Minister.

In relation also to reconstruction grants, I should like one other point clarified. It refers to the supplementary grants that will now be available by virtue of the new procedure. The expression "agricultural labourer", in reference to a person working for hire in a rural area, has gone now under this new proposal and instead of that it refers to a person engaged solely or mainly in agricultural work. It seems from that that the basis on which supplementary grants have hitherto been paid to persons working for hire in rural areas but not actually working on land is being changed. It is desirable that that change should be explained to us in a more detailed fashion than appears in the memorandum and in the Minister's opening speech.

In relation to construction, and indeed in relation also to the erection of new houses, I do not know whether members of other local authorities find that their local authorities have the greatest difficulty in getting contractors to do isolated cottages. We have found in Kildare that it is virtually impossible to get contractors to do satisfactorily isolated cottages in rural areas. There is little difficulty in obtaining a contractor to do a group scheme of half a dozen houses, but, because of the difficulty of supervision and because the small type of building contractor does not now seem to be there as he was, it is virtually impossible to get contractors in Kildare to build individual isolated cottages in the rural areas. If other areas are finding the same difficulty, then a method of dealing with that problem must be found. It would seem that the only method is to increase the facilities available for people to build their own houses. Quite frankly, the provisions of Section 5 may, perhaps, ease that to some degree.

I am sure that every Deputy has come across the case of a person living in a totally unsatisfactory house, who has not got any young family perhaps, and yet feels he would not have the slightest possibility of meeting even a minimum differential rent, if he were to be rehoused by the local authority. The provisions of Section 5 will help, because in such cases where there are old people desiring some small repairs to their existing habitations, this section, while not providing them with the standard which they and we would like, at the same time would enable them to carry on for a period without having to meet the increased rent they would have to pay if the local authority had to rehouse them.

In addition, that type of house is nearly always in a rather remote part of a rural area. If it is in such a remote part, there will be the same difficulty for the local authority in getting a contractor to build a house in which to rehouse the people concerned. Therefore, the grants provided by Section 5 are one method of ensuring that this problem can be met to some degree.

It would be desirable for the Minister, when concluding, to outline in more detail what he has in mind in that section, which is a new one. Is it, for example, to be a complete condition that any part of the wall cannot be a mud wall? One often comes across an old house where the thatched roof requires to be completely replaced and where a grant cannot be obtained for its replacement because one section, perhaps, of one wall is a mud wall, and without the removal of that wall a grant would not in the ordinary course be paid. I hope that type of restriction will not be enforced, particularly in regard to the fringe areas around the bogs in Kildare, which I know and in respect of which I can at once think of two cases where this section would be of assistance.

Perhaps the Minister also when concluding would indicate whether it is intended that Section 6 of the Bill will provide only for charitable societies and such like? Is it intended that under no circumstances can this type of grant for elderly couples be provided for a small house on this scale, which would be sufficient for an old couple but not sufficient for a young married couple with a growing family?

The Minister made considerable play with the provisions for experimentation in house design provided by Section 7. I am not quite sure that the way he has provided for it in this Bill will ensure what is undoubtedly a desirable thing. I remember, for example, in relation to Kildare, one particular firm got the county council to erect a new type of house at a very reduced cost. The cost was trifling. The only effect of that erection was that no one else anywhere else bought the house. They were told that while they might be suitable in certain circumstances, they were not suitable for the general run of houses being built. Whenever it was asked if any local authority had taken up the experiment, the answer was: "Yes, Kildare has erected one." The obvious implication was that, because only one had been erected, they were not of any value and the experiment was never proceeded with and improved on, as it should have been if it was to be a success. I am a little afraid the same thing might easily occur in relation to the erection of the prototype provided for here in Section 7.

I am not quite clear what is the purpose of the change in nomenclature provided by Section 11 from the old small dwellings code. Incidentally, in passing, I might add I was particularly intrigued to know why in the explanatory memorandum, Section 11 was explained before Section 10. If Deputies look at the top of page 3 of the White Paper, they will find the first paragraph deals entirely with Section 11. Then we go on to the second paragraph, which deals with Section 10. It is unusual to change the order of explanation and I feel that there must have been some particular reason for the change, a reason which I failed to notice.

Section 13 extends the guarantee system provided by the Housing (Amendment) Act, 1946. The Bill itself does not refer to that Act but the explanatory memorandum is quite honest about it and explains that it is extending the guarantee system provided by the Housing (Amendment) Act, 1946. Yet I seem to remember certain Deputies saying, when those on that side of the House were on this side, that that was an utterly useless provision and one that should and would be completely scrapped. But I am glad to see and welcome their conversion, even at this late stage. Before I leave Section 11, might I inquire also whether I am correct in thinking that the regulations to be made under subsection (2) of Section 11 must be tabled under the general provision for tabling contained in Section 23, or whether that section is exclusive of it? I believe the regulations must be so tabled. Certainly it is essential that they would be.

The Minister on several occasions referred in his introductory remarks to what he described as the principle of self-help. Does he mean by that a private person erecting his own house with the aid of Government grants and Government facilities, as apart from the provision of that house by a local authority building the house for the particular person? Or does he intend to imply by the use of the phrase "self-help", particularly in his mention of it in connection with experimentation in house design, something in the nature of what one might term roughly "Do-it-yourself"? Does he mean that the experimentation is to be towards a type of house which can be prefabricated on a factory basis and put into place without quite the same amount of skill or the same amount of labour on the site as would be involved in the more conventional type of building? Or does he mean by "self-help" that he is stressing a trend from public authority building towards private persons building with the help of grants and loans? It is desirable that he should clarify that because his phrase could be taken either way, and it is desirable, at least, that we should know in which direction his mind is travelling.

Comment on this

Any Bill introduced here which will be of assistance to those building their own houses, to local authorities providing houses in their respective areas, and which will be to the advantage of the country as a whole will naturally have the support of the Labour Party. I have no intention of making comparisons between the number of houses being built now and the number of houses built in any particular year. If one wishes to make such comparisons, they can more legitimately be made when we come to discuss the Estimate for the Department of Local Government. I wish to concentrate solely now on the provisions in this Bill.

It must be admitted by all that this Bill has certain defects. In Section 2, it is made quite clear that there will be no increase in the grants for building or for reconstruction. That is a grave defect. Building costs have soared over the past few years. That is not due to any action by the Government. Costs have increased everywhere. The present method is that the grants are based on estimates made by the Department of Local Government. As has been said here before, these estimates are in 90 out of 100 cases, far below the actual cost of either building or reconstruction work. It is a source of great disappointment to those hoping to build new homes, or spend some money on the reconstruction and improvement of their existing homes, to learn that they will not be allowed one penny extra under this Bill by way of grant because of the way in which the figures are estimated and because there is still no consideration being given to figures submitted by either the applicant, or the contractor on behalf of the applicant. Autocratic control is still held by the Minister for Local Government. It is he who decides whether the more suitable estimate is the one computed by his Department or the more realistic estimate submitted by the applicant. Section 2 is not satisfactory.

Section 3 will need amendment. It has been made quite clear here in the past that the present system of costs is outdated and outmoded and should be scrapped. Something will have to be done by the Minister between now and the Committee Stage to improve this Bill. It is a Bill which may in future be of some assistance to people building houses.

Section 5 is good. I give the Mini- ster credit for the provision whereby money can now be allocated by way of grant for what may be called minimum repairs. There are houses which are undoubtedly in bad repair. The occupants are not in a position financially to do the work themselves, work which departmental inspectors insist should be done before the people will qualify for a grant. This provision will help old people living in houses which are not in too serious disrepair and which, if repaired, will last these people for the remainder of their life-time.

I should like the Minister to clarify Section 6. On the face of it, it is very good, dealing with the provision of housing for elderly people. We would be tempted to say in fact that this should be considered one of the best sections in the Bill. Perhaps it could be if operated properly. However, it is not what we here wish it to be but how it is put into operation when it becomes law that is important. This section says that the amount of grant shall not exceed £300. I am anxious to know for what type of house this £300 may be provided, for which also a supplementary grant may be provided by the local authority. We may get building speculators who will buy two or three houses in the city here or in Cork, convert these houses and claim that each single room is a separate dwelling in the building. From my reading of the section, there is nothing to prevent anyone so doing.

It would be deplorable if anyone could take advantage of Government grants in that way. There should be protection for the people and for the State in relation to the money being paid out by insisting on certain minimum space requirements before such grants are paid. I suggest these dwellings should contain at least a living room and one bedroom to make a self-contained unit. Elderly people in Dublin or Cork city might wish to invite some friends in for the evening. They may be in a single room which must be used for the preparation of meals, for dining and everything else. That is not satisfactory. I am not accusing the Minister but lest some people may take advantage of a loophole in the section, I would ask that this matter be re-examined by the Minister so that these grants will be properly utilised and properly availed of in order to provide for these elderly people the housing conditions to which undoubtedly they are entitled.

Section 8 deals with supplementary grants. The position may vary from county to county. Cork County Council or other county councils may find no difficulty in paying these supplementary grants because the intake of rates can stand up to it and eventually they will get it back in the increased rates collected on the improved property. However, I have in mind the position of urban district councils. I have found from discussions in many places that while the members of these councils are anxious to provide a supplementary grant, they find it difficult financially to do so and therefore the people in these areas are at a disadvantage as against people in the areas under the jurisdiction of the county council. I do not know what the answer may be but I do suggest that some financial provision might be offered to the urban district council which, coupled with their contribution, might bring the supplementary grant up to the level of that offered in the county of which they are a part.

Section 10 is a section in which I have a particular interest. Let me make it clear that on speaking on Section 10, there is no idea in my mind of crowing or of saying: "Did I not tell you so?" All I will say at this late stage is that if the Minister had told us a few months ago that he was prepared to include provision for loans to people living in vested cottages, the Bill over which we fought so hard would have been withdrawn without our dividing the House on it. I am pleased to see that the Minister has seen fit to make this provision. I appreciate the position of members of the Government Party, for many of whom I have always had nothing but the highest respect. I realise they were speaking sincerely when saying they believed there was a need for loans in such cases. I am not blaming any individual member. We all know the rules of the Parties here.

There are times when our views may vary but I suppose the majority rules. I am glad the Minister now realises it is vitally important to be able to offer to the tenants of vested cottages, through the co-operation of the local authority, the advantage that should have been offered to them long before now in relation to the improvement of these houses.

The Minister mentioned the figure of 30,000 houses in need of repairs. If the survey carried out in County Cork, making comparisons between the conditions of the various cottages vested over the past 10, 12 and 20 years, is taken into account in the list of houses in need of repairs, the Minister will find there is a very high percentage which, I am very glad to say, will be able to avail of loans for repairs.

Section 13 provides:

A housing authority may, in accordance with a scheme approved of by the Minister, guarantee an advance or part of an advance by a building society, an assurance company, a bank or other industrial or commercial organisation...

I should like the Minister to inform the House what is meant by the words "other industrial or commercial organisation". Where a guarantee is offered, I can understand the reference to building society, insurance company or bank. Perhaps I am suspicious but it seems rather vague as to who may be brought in. Therefore, the Minister should clarify what is meant by these words.

I would ask the Minister also to give us a little information on Section 19 which provides that the Minister may allow a grant for a house which complies with his regulations but does not comply with local bye-laws. Normally we would not dispute about that but I am anxious to know the position. Supposing a case arises where the local authority maintains that a person building or reconstructing his home has broken some local bye-law and the Minister considers that he has not broken the departmental regulations. When that person receives the final instalment of grant from the bank, will the local authority pay the supplementary grant? This matter is serious enough to warrant the Minister clarifying it for us. Deputies who are members of the local authority might have to argue at a meeting of the local authority in Cork about this provision. The manager might insist that the person was not entitled to a supplementary grant because he had broken a bye-law and the Deputies, as members of the Oireachtas and also members of the local authority, might have to insist that as the person had received a local government grant, he should get the supplementary grant. For the benefit of Deputies who are members of local authorities and for the benefit of the officials of the local authority, I am anxious that this matter should be clarified.

Section 22 is on the same lines as Section 19, with a slight variation. It provides for the making of grants by the Minister notwithstanding non-compliance with a statute or statutory instrument. That is not a case of a breach of some local bye-law but a case in which a plea of ignorance of departmental rules and regulations may be made. This could be a very serious provision. I am not concerned as to who may be Minister for Local Government. I have tried to steer clear of any question of politics. We are dealing with housing legislation. If members who are now on my right were on my left, I would not blame them if they were suspicious of a Minister. That can happen. A person may break a departmental regulation and may, through some means or other, be able to convince the Minister that it was through ignorance of the law. It is a dangerous provision that such a person could succeed in getting a grant. I should like the Minister to clarify that matter also.

The Labour Party regard housing legislation as being of vital importance to the people. I regret that this Bill was not before us earlier solely for the reason that we would have had more time to discuss it. It is being rushed Circumstances create the necessity to get this legislation through as quickly as possible because the Act should have been re-enacted at the end of March last. We find it difficult to discuss the Bill in its entirety for the purpose of clarification. I would ask that the points I have raised be dealt with by the Minister so as to help us in our approach to the Bill, which may facilitate the Minister in getting the Bill through the House.

The Labour Party are satisfied with the progress being made in some directions but are very disappointed that the grants have not been increased and that there is as yet no indication from the Government of a more modern and more realistic assessment of the costs on which grants are based.

Comment on this

I have listened to the debate and I can say that there is no doubt where the brilliant ideas on housing legislation come from. They come from the Opposition benches. The amazing thing is that they were seven and a half years in power and had not some of these brilliant ideas then and did not put into effect legislation in accordance with the brilliant ideas we are now supposed to believe they have.

My memory is not short. I remember the year 1956, for instance, when a councillor could not come outside the door of his house because of the number of people who were looking for housing grants and who could not get a penny. The people who were in office then tell us today about the tremendous amount of building that was carried on in that period. It may have been carried on — I am not saying it was not—but I would like somebody to specify where the building was carried out. It was not carried out in Mayo. There were no housing grants paid in County Mayo during the calendar year 1956. There is no use in saying otherwise. I agree that grants were paid during the financial year 1956-57 because there was a change of Government and as soon as that change of Government took place, grants were paid, in March, 1957. No grants were paid in 1956 or in 1955. I challenge anybody to give the figures for County Mayo. The gentlemen who have the audacity to get up here and quote figures are trying to hoodwink the public but they are not hoodwinking me.

I did think the repair and reconstruction grants would be somewhat increased. To be quite candid about it, I thought the Minister more or less indicated over the last few months that these grants would be increased. I would ask now that he should reconsider the position. He should relate the grants to the increase in the cost of wages, salaries and materials which has taken place over the past two years. He would be doing a very wise thing if he were to do that. Undoubtedly the Minister would have the complete backing of this House if he were to increase the grants. He would have the backing of his own Party and from what I have listened to during this debate, unless they are hypocrites, he would have the backing of the Opposition also. Therefore I ask the Minister to review the grants and see if he can increase them.

A very funny thing has happened, according to what I see here. There has been a statutory income limit in regard to the payment of supplementary grants by local authorities for the building of houses but I understand there has not been any statutory income limit with regard to the payment of supplementary grants by local authorities for the reconstruction and repair of houses. If that is so, how is it that local authorities have been enforcing an income limit? I do not see why they should have done that and I think they are wrong to do it. Local authorities who have made a regulation enforcing an income limit in respect of the payment of supplementary grants for the reconstruction of houses should now pay out those grants to the people from whom they withheld them.

As I see it, there is no statutory authority for doing that. There is a statutory authority for an income limit with regard to new houses, but in my county it has happened that the local authority has enforced a regulation which does not exist and have withheld grants from people. I ask the Minister to explain that.

The local authority also acts in regard to the payment of water rate. As far as I know, the introduction of water and sewerage schemes, whether it be for big towns or small towns, is carried out as the result of the placing of a contract to do the work on a payment basis where the whole county puts up the money. I wonder if, in those circumstances, the local authority could by any stretch of imagination have the authority to collect the water rate. I do not think they have any right to do so.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is going far beyond the scope of the Bill. I do not think the powers of a local authority in sanitation matters arise on this Bill at all. There was a Bill before the House earlier today in connection with that matter.

Comment on this

The way I look at it is that the only thing you can talk about is if you say nothing about anything.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is plenty the Deputy can say on the Housing Bill as presented to the House by the Minister.

Comment on this

I do not happen to be a rambler. I keep to the point, but if I come into the House and keep rambling about in circles until the cows come home, I can talk. If I say anything specific or try to be constructive, I am challenged and told to sit down.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not challenging the Deputy because he is constructive, far from it. I am challenging the Deputy because he is referring to something not within the scope of the measure before the House.

Comment on this

If we are to pursue that attitude, I do not know where we will work out. I am now in the position that I cannot say what I think about a Housing Bill. The issue would appear to be that I cannot refer to matters which are important to housing.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am telling the Deputy that there is a Housing Bill before the House. There has been before the House today a Bill for the extension of powers to local authorities for sanitary purposes which got a Second Reading.

Comment on this

Surely nothing relates more to housing than the question of sanitation. It appears that I cannot discuss the question of water rate and I obviously cannot discuss anything that matters.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There are 26 sections in the Bill and the Deputy can discuss all of them.

Comment on this

I suppose I can put in the water. I do not agree with a house being built 100 feet from the water main and the people not being able to get the water in. I think the Minister should come down to earth. For a long number of years past, all Ministers, in their wisdom or stupidity, have carried on the policy of giving grants for houses with three rooms. It is amazing the number of people in this country who do not want three rooms and, apart from that, who cannot afford them. It is past time that the Minister had enough sense to see through that one.

Surely there are in many parts of Ireland men and their wives who will only be in it for the next ten or 15 years. They may not have a lot of money and they only want a room and kitchen, as we say in the country, which means two rooms. If those people want houses with only two rooms, there should be grants available for them to build that type of house. Surely it would not take any great imagination for a Minister to bring in a Bill which would provide such benefits. When a man wants to build a house, he does not think in terms of square feet or cubic feet or any such nonsense. What he wants is a house that will be reasonable and decent to meet his requirements. I suggest that the Minister go down among the ordinary people in the towns and on the small farms. If he did that, he might come back to the House and provide a more sensible Bill than the one we are now discussing.

I know a case of a man and his wife with two unmarried sisters or brothers — I cannot say which just now — who wanted to build a small house. Under this Bill, they are restricted from the point of view of grants to a structure of 510 square feet with three rooms. What in the name of common sense would such a family do with such a house? I would accordingly ask the Minister to think this matter over. If a man and woman want to build a house in order to provide themselves with reasonable, decent accommodation, they should be eligible for grants, whether the house is three-roomed or two-roomed.

There is also the question of thatched houses. The Minister should make provision here for the payment of grants for either the building or the reconstruction of thatched houses. I can see no reason why in this country a man should be forced by law to slate his house. We are living in a democratic country; people fought for the rights which we now enjoy, and yet we find that if we try to avail of those rights, there is legislation there to penalise us.

It is a shocking state of affairs that a man is to be deprived of a grant just because he wants to live in a house with a thatched roof. If a man has a thatched house already and wants to repair it, surely he should get a grant to carry out that work.

The Minister would be well advised to travel through the West of Ireland where he will see some of the finest houses in the country and they are thatched. He should adopt a common sense policy in these matters and ignore the nonsense which has been perpetuated in this House for over 40 years. I feel sure that even Deputies in the Opposition benches will agree with me in that.

Comment on this

Ba bhaith liom cúpla focail a rá ar an mBille seo. At the outset, I wish to congratulate the Minister on its introduction and on the many new features it contains through which many problems in connection with housing throughout the country will be overcome. The Government have an outstanding record in housing and this measure is but a continuation of their efforts to go ahead with the housing drive until every person who needs a decent home is provided with it. They have already cleared the slums in the cities and in the towns but unfortunately there are still housing conditions in many rural areas which cause concern.

Some of the new features in this Bill are particularly applicable to such areas. They will serve to overtake the serious backlog in the provision of better housing conditions. A house has always been regarded as a man's castle and it has been the policy of the Government not only to ensure that the people of the country have decent homes but also to see that they will become owners of these homes even if they are only cottages. I am therefore glad to see in this Bill provisions which will help people in the long run to buy out their houses and cottages and become owners of them.

Despite what may have been said by the Opposition there is no doubt that there were grave financial difficulties from the point of view of housing in 1957 and 1956. In the latter year, it was impossible for anyone in my constituency to get a grant, with the result that right in the middle of winter, a housing scheme collapsed completely for lack of funds. There were so many useless credit notes flying around that merchants, already overloaded with orders and getting no money, were unwilling to supply materials. The Local Loans Fund had not got any money to give to the local authority and the whole housing effort was impeded. Local housing grants were stopped completely and this immediately finished the housing effort because if people were not able to get a local authority grant, the State grant available was not sufficient.

The result of that period is still to be seen. There are 146 people in that area who have not yet got their grants and this in turn has to a large extent discouraged people from seeking the benefits available under the Housing Acts. The position has recently changed because of the efforts of the Government and people have begun to avail of these grants in considerable numbers. Where new houses are concerned, I would ask the Minister, if at all possible, to publish a few designs so that people intending to build new houses will not be forced to go to some engineer or other person and pay anything up to £30 for a design which might have been just copied from a magazine — a design which the Department might not ultimately approve. I know that there are certain provisions in the regulations but very often the ordinary countryman reconstructing his house has not that document available to him, or, if he has, he is unable to interpret it. Consequently, he may have a plan which will not be sanctioned or which will qualify for only a reduced grant.

The vocational schools could do more as far as housing is concerned, particularly in regard to reconstruction. In many areas, there are woodwork teachers and others qualified to go among the people and advise them on such matters as cutting a roof or putting in windows. That might solve the difficulty often experienced of getting contractors to do work in isolated places. Some prizes should be awarded for the manner in which grant type houses are kept.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is dealing with administration, which can be dealt with on the Vote for Local Government.

Comment on this

I had intended saying something about prefabricated houses and the feasibility of making use of them in certain areas. It would be well if local authorities were encouraged to build cottages in larger groups so that it would be more convenient to supply them with the services required.

Comment on this

I am very disappointed with this Bill. It was generally expected that the grants for private persons building their own houses would be increased even a little because of the very steep increases, up to 300 per cent in some cases, in the cost of materials and labour since the housing grants were last increased. The Minister must have his tongue in his cheek when he says he has the interest of housing the people at heart. If that were the case, he should have increased the grants. He definitely will not in this way reduce the drop in housing now evident since we were last in office.

I want to speak about a class for which the Minister has made no provision. He paid a good deal of lip service to them in his opening speech. He said earlier:

There are many persons living in unfit conditions who are not and are never likely to be in a position to rehouse themselves and whose needs cannot or are not being met by housing authorities. Owing to such factors as the location of the houses and the age and circumstances of the occupants, local authorities cannot be expected to give a high priority to providing new houses for these classes.

Later on, he referred to the housing survey taking place and said:

In the last 30 years, the housing programme, particularly that portion of it undertaken by local authorities, has been more effective in urban than in rural areas where the current survey figures up to the present indicate that some 30,000 houses need to be repaired and 20,000 more require to be replaced. The full completion of the survey will not materially alter the overall picture of the problem presented by these figures. The problem is a big one and obviously more difficult to solve than that section of the housing programme that has already been successfully implemented.

Further on, he said:

As Deputies familiar with rural conditions are aware, many elderly single persons or elderly couples with little or no resources or a short expectation of life without assured succession for occupation of their dwellings are the classes least inclined or able to do anything for themselves.

As I have already said, it is part of the problem that local authorities are not universally disposed to regard this problem as part of their housing functions or, where they do accept some responsibility, they can give only a low priority to the re-housing of these classes, as compared with others seeking new housing.

So far as legislative proposals can go, this Bill contains provisions specially designed to deal with the needs of the rural position.

According to the survey, there are 1,400 unfit houses in County Mayo alone. I have not the figures for the other counties.

Comment on this

Five thousand.

Comment on this

It is a lot worse than I thought. I can assure the Minister that, out of these 5,000, there must be many who will never be able to rehouse themselves. One of the most serious complaints that can be made against the Minister is that he is not doing anything for these people. In every county, there are people living in small holdings who have absolutely no money. They are living in houses which in some instances are actually dangerous to live in. The Land Commission has passed them by in the course of rearrangement or allotment and they probably cannot expect any help or a new house from that source. People have come to me who have nothing spared and who are in bad health, bad health possibly caused or at least aggravated by the very poor type of house in which they have lived all their lives. I almost feel like challenging a division on this Bill because no provision is made for that type of person.

There is a still more deserving type of case. I am sure every Deputy knows of young married men with two or three young children not yet of school-going age or with five or six children, some of them going to school. They are living in a cottage consisting of a small kitchen and one room and perhaps not in a healthy situation. No provision is being made for these people, either. The Minister has fallen down completely on his job.

The grant of £300, or £310 through a building society, is absolutely inadequate. When that £300 was first given through an Act of this House, it was possible, with the then cost of materials and labour, to build a nice, five-roomed house in my constituency for £900 or £950. The same house today would cost £1,450. Offering them a grant of £300 is like telling them they cannot build or else inviting them to put a debt around their necks they will probably never discharge. I would go so far as to ask the Minister to withdraw the Bill in its present form and accept an amendment to make provision for the two classes I have mentioned.

I shall tell the Minister exactly what shape the amended Bill should take. The Minister is bound to provide a house for these people in some way or other. If these people are not able to help themselves in the building of a house, he should provide a suitable house for them and recover all or portion of the cost by way of a further annuity on the holding, or else he should make available a sufficient grant to meet the cost of the house. The Minister is fully aware of the situation because he referred earlier to "single persons or elderly couples with little or no resources or a short expectation of life without assured succession for occupation of these dwellings" as "the classes least inclined or able to do anything for themselves." It is a reflection on us that we allow these people to live out their days in what are little better than the kind of hovels that we read existed in the days of landlordism, while the Minister stands idly by. Not alone that, but if I read his opening speech correctly, he is inclined to make a joke about it more than anything else. We have gone a long way towards improving the health of our people by a vast expenditure of money and with the skill and goodwill of all concerned.

I want to tell the Minister that I know several young married couples, who are not financially equipped to provide a house for themselves, and whose children cannot possibly grow up without contracting some kind of disease or ailment; at the very least, they will certainly not be as healthy and robust as they would be if they had a decent house in which to be reared. Vast sums of money are spent on the eradicating of tuberculosis and various other diseases, on the one hand, and at the same time, we allow children to be reared in houses in which, except for the intervention of Divine Providence, they cannot escape disease. I am not interested in the man who has the finances and who can, with the help of the £300 grant and the local authority grant, where such are given, build a house for himself. I am not concerned with him because he can help himself. I am concerned for the old people and for the young parents struggling to rear a young family. I might say that the latter are doing remarkably well in many cases in keeping their children fed and clothed.

The Minister is treating this problem in a shocking fashion. I know he will say that it is a tall order to ask him to build houses for these people. I do not think it is. Housing conditions are among the matters which have contributed more than anything else to the flight from the land all down through the years. The Minister comes in now with a Bill in exactly the same terms as the Bill that was passed two years ago. There is not one single improvement in it. I challenge him to show me any improvement in it. He paid lip service in his opening speech to those who cannot help themselves, and all the rest of it, throwing out a hint that local authorities might possibly come to their assistance. I think that kind of lip service borders on blackguardism. That is the only way I can describe it.

The Minister says this Bill contains provisions specially designed to deal with the needs of the rural areas. Would the Minister tell us what these provisions are? I have gone through the Bill and through the Minister's speech and I certainly cannot find out what they are. Is it that the Minister is in a mood to make a joke of people who cannot help themselves? As I said a moment ago, in most cases the ill-health suffered by these is due to the fact that they have been reared in unhealthy, insanitary hovels.

During the passage of the previous Bill, I asked the Minister what the position was with regard to the payment of grants. He did not reply. Would the Minister mind taking this opportunity now to tell us exactly what the system of grants is? Is it the £300 grant in the Second Schedule to the Bill before the House? Does that include the water and sanitation grant to be paid by another section of his Department? I asked the Minister that question during the passage of the earlier Bill. He did not reply to it. Possibly he overlooked it.

I almost feel like challenging a vote on this Bill because of the omissions. We have been waiting since last April for this Bill. Everybody thought it was high time that increased grants were made available because of the high costs of labour and materials so that we might see the end of the problem of those people who are able and willing to build for themselves. The Minister has come in once more with the old grant of three years ago. Does the Minister realise that building materials have increased in some cases by as much as 300 per cent.? In view of the way in which the Government have killed the housing programme, and in view of the money they have saved in the process, it is only fair now to give a decent improvement in the grant that has been payable for the past two years.

There has been a serious drop in the number of houses being built by local authorities. In the year 1954-1955, 5,267 houses were built. Last year, only 1,238 were built. That is almost down to one-fifth of the building that took place in 1954-1955. The number of private houses dropped from 5,000 to 4,000. The number employed on local authority housing in 1954-1955 was 6,056. To-day it is 1,156. These figures deserve a little more than the flippant treatment which Deputy Leneghan gave them. These are figures of national importance. The Minister should tell us what exactly has happened to have brought these conditions about. What is going wrong? The old story that the inter-Party Government were not paying housing grants did its work and got its votes in 1957. That story has been exploded now and, except for a very odd, innocent—I will not say half-witted — Deputy on the Fianna Fáil benches, who thumps his chest and still believes it, it has been successfully exploded. The serious aspect remains. The whole building programme has collapsed in a heap of ruins. That is something we cannot afford to ignore, treat as a joke, or a matter for banter in this House.

Comment on this

I have waited a long time for this Bill. I have had constituents making inquiries about this Bill months ago. Everybody knew that this Bill comes before the House periodically. The term of the last Bill expired in March. I was under the impression the Government had a Bill ready and that it would be introduced at the first opportunity as soon as March was out. We are now in the month of July. I put it to the Minister that was not good business. It was not good administration. Neither does it show that the Minister has any great concern for the people all over the country who are interested in building their own houses or in the local authorities who are interested in building houses for the working classes.

The biggest disappointment about this Bill is the statement in the explanatory memorandum which says that State grants are being preserved at their existing levels. Everybody expected the grants would be increased. That seemed the most obvious thing, remembering the enormous increase in the cost of building. I have been told that a few years ago a house could be built for about £2 per square foot to the standards and specification demanded by the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this

And still are being built for £2.

Comment on this

With no services.

Comment on this

Fully serviced houses are being built for £2.

Comment on this

I should like the Deputy to put me in touch with the contractor.

Comment on this

It is being done in Kildare.

Comment on this

That is a revelation. I should like to see the house. I do not want to doubt the Deputy but I have seen costings from various counties. They shattered me.

Comment on this

He built one himself.

Comment on this

That is a different story. If you have to pay men, it will not work out at £2 per square foot. It is a 40-hour week now, and local authority houses are all built under a fair wage clause. You will not build a house for £2 per square foot today. One swallow does not make a summer, and Deputy Brennan's house will not make a building scheme.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy not accept that houses are being built privately?

Comment on this
A Deputy

With galvanised roofs.

Comment on this

Yes. We were building houses under the Small Dwellings Acts in Waterford. The people paid £100, went into them and they are paying £80 a year and rates. There is a group of young people working in various factories who banded themselves together and approached the corporation for a site. They were waiting and hoping they would get an increased grant and then they would go on with the building of houses. I do not know what they will say when they see this but the houses they would build and the cost for a skimped-down, in my opinion, specification, not as good as the specification of the houses that were built heretofore, would be around £3 a week. Everybody in the country knows that the over-all cost of building has gone up considerably. That is not the Minister's fault. That is just a fact and it is a fact that should be faced. There is no use in saying you can build them at £3 a square foot.

Comment on this

Who said you cannot?

Comment on this

The Deputy should take care he does not have a strong deputation going from my constituency not alone to ask him how to do it but to give him a contract to do the job. There is a great deal of talk about figures here. I have often asked the Minister for figures and of course when we get figures in the House, we take it for granted they are correct. I have got figures from the Minister for housing in Waterford city and I cannot make head or tail of them. I have come to the conclusion that it would be hard for the Minister to make head or tail of what happens up and down the country, if the figures he has given for other parts of the country are similar to those for Waterford city.

I had a Question down to the Minister on 22nd May, 1962, asking him to state the number of new houses completed in Waterford city in each of the years since 1948 to 1961 inclusive. I stress "the number of new houses completed". The Minister told me the reply was in the form of a tabular statement which would be published in the Official Report. The tabular statement was handed to me and it then appeared in the Official Report. It gave a series of extraordinary figures especially in respect of 1956 and 1957. It said that in 1955-56 the number completed was 130; in 1956-57, it was 271; in 1957-58, 220; in 1958-59, 208; in 1959-60, 503; and in 1960-61, 157. I would give a lot of money and burn a lot of incense if these figures were true but I had a letter on 30th May which said:

I am directed by Mr. Neil T. Blaney, Minister for Local Government, to inform you that it has come to his notice that in the course of a reply which he gave to the Question asked by you in Dáil Éireann on 22nd May, 1962, regarding the number of houses completed in Waterford the figures given for the years 1957/58; 1958/59; 1959/60 and 1960/61 inadvertently included the numbers of reconstruction grants paid instead of those for new house grants. This resulted in the figures shown for these years being much greater than the correct figures. The correct figures in respect of the four years in question should have been as follows:

Figures given | Correct figures

1957/58 | 220 | 113

1958/59 | 208 | 111

1959/60 | 503 | 367

1960/61 | 157 | 42

I put down another Question for answer on 7th June and clearly asked for details in respect of the years 1948 to 1961 inclusive. I asked in relation to Waterford city (1) the number of new houses (a) completed, (b) completed by the local authority, and (c) built by private builders, and (2) the number of houses for which the Department paid out reconstruction grants. I was told that for the years 1956-57 the total number completed by the local authority and by private persons with the aid of State grants was 271, that the number completed by the local authority was 130 and that 141 were built by private persons. In 1958-59, 111 were completed by the local authority and by private persons with the aid of State grants; 75 were completed by the local authority, 36 by private persons and 133 reconstruction grants. In 1959, 367 were completed altogether, 348 by the local authority, 19 by private persons with the aid of State grants, and there were 155 reconstruction grants. In 1960-61, 42 was the total of new houses completed; 31 were completed by the local authority and 11 by private persons. There were 126 reconstruction grants.

The House may think I am being very tortuous about this but the extraordinary thing is that I have a letter from the housing officer in the Waterford Corporation. I asked him the same question as I asked the Minister. He replied to me on 13th June as follows:

The figures of Grants for Private House building as quoted you by the Department approximate very closely to ours for the various years.

The following is a break-down of the figures for houses "provided by the Corporation".

The Department insist that houses owned by Corporation and reconstructed by us, and on which the Department pays subsidy should be returned as "houses provided" even though the houses were already occupied.

1957/8

Newly built by Corporation | 47

Added to correct previous omission | 14

—

61

For 1958-59, there were 75 houses newly built by the Corporation. That is the correct figure, the figure the Minister gave me. For 1959-60, there were 22 houses built by the Corporation and the figure for those completed by the local authority is 348. I thought that perhaps the Department or the Minister were mixing up the reconstruction grants with the 348. I find that he told me that 345 reconstruction grants were paid that year. I discovered from an official of the Waterford Corporation that from 1952 to 1957 and included now as "houses provided", the total was 326. There is a total given here of 348 and that is given for one year. These figures are haywire. If the Minister is getting figures like these supplied to him, I wonder if he has a true picture of local authority housing.

I have often said in places where discussions took place on housing, before I came into the Dáil, and many people said the same thing, that the cost of site development is very high and is included in the all-in cost of the house. We must bend our energies to securing a reduction in the overall cost. The Minister is maintaining grants at the old level. I am sure I am not alone in believing that he should increase the grant substantially. I also consider that the Minister should examine the idea of giving unemployment grants for the development of sites for houses. The Minister, in my opinion, could give 100 per cent. grants in respect of roads that have to be made when new houses are built on virgin soil. Such grants could be provided out of the Road Fund. These roads are just as important to the people as main or county roads are. In connection with such roads in Waterford city, I submit that we should be entitled to get a special grant, in view of the fact that in ten years we paid over £500,000 in road tax and got back only £40,000.

The Minister says on page 4 of his brief that payments of the grants will be made subject to regulations. Regulations have surrounded housing development and reconstruction grants as a sort of bureaucratic quagmire which keeps spreading, making it more difficult for the ordinary person or the local authority to get through.

Recently I was shown an interesting cartoon depicting an old man who had been put in charge of the Local Government Board. It was a very old cartoon. The caption said that the Local Government Board was a government board that had been set up to do away with local government. Eighty years ago, that was presented as a joke but that is what has happened local government. It has happened in the matter of housing that local authorities and local officials are so fettered by regulations that production of houses is slowed down and the whole business of the purchase of sites and the drawing of plans is delayed. The plans and specifications when drawn are sent on the long, long trail to the Department and they pass up and down between the Department and the local authority. I believe the Minister is a man who would like to cut his way through that quagmire. I would suggest to him that a predecessor of his asked local authorities if they were satisfied with the managerial system and every one of them said they were. I do not agree with them but they are entitled to their opinion. The managerial system is in operation and the manager is a chief executive officer. He rates even higher. He is appointed by the Local Appointments Commissioners and has to be a man of great qualifications.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The County Management Act is not relevent to this debate.

Comment on this

The Minister says he hopes to have an up-to-date consolidated code for local authorities. That is on page 11. I am not saying anything about the managers. I am merely talking about the system. There is the local authority with its manager and the officials. The officials are all people appointed by the Local Appointments Commissioners. They are all well qualified. All those groups come together to consider a housing scheme and everything they do must be sent up to the Department for sanction. I put it to the Minister that in relation to the new code he is to introduce he could make the whole business airtight. He should give the local authorities power — the elected representatives of the council, the managers and the officials——

Comment on this