Housing (Loans and Grants) Bill, 1962. — Second Stage.
Contributions 107–212 of 212. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1962 ›
Deputies will have an opportunity of debating that Bill when it comes before the House.
Comment on this
I am hoping the Minister might be guided by me. I am making this submission very respectively to the Minister, with your permission, Sir.
Comment on this
I submit that it would be a very good thing. We are discussing a housing Bill. You come from Donegal, Sir, I come from Waterford.
Comment on this
I will say Deputy Breslin comes from Donegal. If the officials and the manager prepare plans and specifications for a housing scheme, those plans and specifications are drawn according to the standards laid down by the Department in regard to the thickness of walls, roof, and so on. I have no fault to find with those standards. I suggest that the manager and the officials should submit the plans and specifications to the council and if the council, the manager and the officials are agreed that the housing scheme is O.K., there should be no more about it and tenders should be invited. If a mistake were made by the local authority you can be assured that there would be no need for the Minister or the Department to come down and start screaming holy horror at them.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
As I was saying, they should be allowed to advertise straight away and if there was a mistake and the housing scheme was not what it should be, there would be no necessity for the Department or the Minister to come down on them. The sovereign people of Ireland would cry holy horror on them.
I welcome that section of the Bill that offers encouragement to architects to produce a prototype house. I compliment the Minister on that — it is a very good idea. It will give young architects a chance to produce something that has not been done before. I should say that a lot of this town planning being done in the country is nonsense because much of it is being done from a distance, from Dublin. A good deal of that work should be left to the local engineers, and also the planning and layout of the houses. The local engineers are vulnerable to the manager, to the council and to the people around them.
If this matter were left to them, if they were told that there was the housing scheme and there was the field and to go ahead, I have no hesitation in saying that in every case the engineering officers are quite capable and competent of producing the plans without having to submit them to the Department all the time. If the Minister would do that, he would cut a way through the jungle of green tape and through the quagmires in which local authorities find themselves when they start out on a housing scheme.
I am sure there are many Deputies listening to me who have had the experience of attending a local authority meeting and hearing a lot of talk that a housing scheme is to be undertaken. Sometimes one would be optimistic enough to say that the houses would be built in a year or two but, in fact, 12 or 18 months pass and the draft plan is produced. That disappears up to the Department of Local Government and it is a miracle if it comes back in two or three months and if it is all right. You then advertise for tenders and you have to wait for another while. I exhort the Minister to reduce the time it takes to promote, plan and build houses in any part of the country. I am sure that all my colleagues listening to me agree with me because when they do not agree with me, they interrupt me.
I hope it will not be very long before the Minister brings before the House the legislation to codify the Housing Acts. I hope that when he is putting that legislation to the House, he will remember what I have told him regarding the giving of power to local authorities in this matter. When I say local authorities, I mean the elected representatives of the people, with the managers and the officials. When they come together and put up a scheme that is passed by the council, there should be no further question of sending that to the Department. It should be advertised right away for tenders.
Comment on this
I have no hesitation in saying that I welcome this measure but I must go further and say that it has been somewhat of a disappointment to me, not for what it contains but for what it does not contain. The Minister has promised us this legislation for quite a time now and personally I was led to believe that the delay was due to the fact that he intended to introduce some really worthwhile changes. Let that not detract from my welcome of the Bill because it is an improvement and anything that makes for improved facilities for the building of more houses should be welcomed.
I do not think we should be too carried away in our enthusiasm for the Bill because there are people who believe that the encouragement of private building is of far greater value than it actually is. While this Bill does improve the situation as far as private building and repair are concerned, the overall problem of providing houses for the working classes is still here with us to a very great degree. There is still a great need for local authorities, with the assistance and cooperation of the Minister, to provide more and more houses for those who are deemed to be the working class.
Reference has been made to the surveys that have been and are being carried out by local authorities. I must confess that it is difficult to know how some of the local authorities have arrived at the figures which they have submitted to the Minister. This housing survey has not been completed by all local authorities but some information has been sent to the Minister. He was asked a Parliamentary Question the other day by Deputy Clinton about the surveys that had been carried out in certain counties and I was amazed at the reply he gave — at the figures contained in that reply. In fact I wondered if there was not a printing error in the Official Report for 4th July last at column 1470 where we had information in respect of Mayo that the total number of unfit dwellings in the county council area, apart altogether from the urban areas, was 4,894. I do not know whether the Minister remembers that figure or not. I assume it is correct since I have not been corrected. It is a shocking performance and is a serious reflection on us all.
Comment on this
This is the national assembly. I am getting slightly fed up with the mumblings and grumblings of the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot afford to throw any stones when he dabbles not only in his own county but in Dublin, Laois, Offaly and in every other county in Ireland.
Comment on this
It makes no difference to me if it is the Communist Party, not to mind the Labour Party. I shall defend my own county.
Comment on this
According to this reply of the Minister for Local Government, the Deputy would need to defend more than his own county. As I was saying when I was so rudely interrupted, the reply goes on to state that of these 4,894 unfit houses, only 38 are capable of being repaired economically.
Comment on this
I noticed as well in this reply concerning County Mayo that on 10th July last the Minister gave figures that there are no proposals at all for the building of any new houses in that county. I do not single out Mayo particularly——
Comment on this
Similarly in respect to Roscommon, the total number of unfit dwelling houses is 397 and the number capable of being put into a fit condition is only 27. In that county, they have proposals for the building of one house. Meath is in a similar situation. The total number of unfit dwellings there is 1,062. Of those, 365 are capable of being repaired. That is a comparatively high number. These are the only figures that have been returned to the Minister. There are many other counties in respect of which surveys have not been completed.
Comment on this
If Deputy Leneghan continues with these interruptions, I must ask him to leave the House.
Comment on this
I do not mind sensible interruptions but these mumblings and grumblings get on my nerves. As I was saying, there are many counties in which the surveys have not been completed but I feel sure the same picture applies to many of them. In any case, we public representatives, particularly those of us who are members of local authorities, do not need to rely on figures because the evidence is there for us that there are many houses needed, both in rural and urban areas. Representatives are approached from time to time by people who are in need of accommodation and I venture to say that over the past seven, eight or nine years, we have the same number of people asking us to see what can be done to get them suitable accommodation. It would not be an unfair remark to say——
Comment on this
I agree the Minister is not alone to blame for bad housing conditions in Wexford, Donegal, Meath, Mayo and elsewhere. There is a responsibility on the local authorities, on the county officials, but I also suggest there is a responsibility on the Minister. I think a better example of encouragement in this respect by a Minister could not be found than that set by the late Deputy T.J. Murphy. There was a situation in this country in 1948 when something like 100,000 houses were needed, and by his personal efforts, activity and energy in going around to visit the worst areas, to encourage the local officials and the local authority members, he got a tremendous number of houses built.
Comment on this
Supposing the Minister is giving the encouragement and it is not accepted at local level?
Comment on this
He is not giving sufficient encouragement and many of the local authorities feel annoyed and frustrated by the attitude of the Minister and of the Department.
I should like to refer now to another problem. I have already mentioned it to the Minister, but I do not know what powers, if any, he has in respect to it. We can all see that over the years many of our people have had to go to Britain to seek employment. There are many examples of men and their wives going to England to look for work and from whom the local authorities are demanding possession of their houses.
I think I could present the case better if I cited the example of a couple who had been in occupation of a cottage for over 30 years. The man found he could not get constant employment in his own area. He was forced to go to Britain and eventually was fortunate enough to be able to take his wife across. Now the local authority have proceeded to look for the tenancy of the cottage. I believe greater consideration should be given to such cases because the majority of those forced to go away in order to find employment always keep in their minds the intention of returning to Ireland as soon as the opportunity presents itself or as soon as they can get employment here. We hope that many of them will come back. If the local authorities now proceed to take the tenancies of these cottages from them, the local authorities and the Minister will have a further problem when they do in fact come back. It is not good enough to be taking the cottages from these people who intend to return to their own localities as soon as they can.
I should like to mention a few particular points in connection with this measure, which we welcome for the improvements it contains. Most Deputies who have spoken have expressed their disappointment at the fact that no increase in the grants has been announced. I wonder whether or not the Minister can by regulation increase the grants from time to time, if he and the Government so desired? That was one of the disappointments for the ordinary public. Having said that, it ought to be said also that over the years Irish Governments have generally been pretty generous in the matter of providing State assistance for private building. We are inclined to make comparisons with other countries in respect of other things in order to demonstrate how backward we are. If the facts were known, however, I believe it could be proved that Ireland ranks pretty high in the matter of State assistance for private housing. However, there is a case in present circumstances, in view of the pattern of assistance we have had, to increase the grants on this occasion, especially when it is recognised that the cost of materials and wages has gone up considerably in recent years.
One might criticise the estimates made by the Minister's Department in respect of house building, repair and reconstruction. To say the least, they seem to be very conservative indeed. Many people, even with the assistance of the grant, find it difficult, if not impossible, to complete the work within the figure laid down by the officials of the Department. One is forced to ask: on what basis are these costs made? Is there any periodic review of them? If not, there should be. The schedule of prices used seems to have been used for far too long.
In Section 3, there is a stipulation that the reconstruction or repair work must put the house into perfect condition. The Minister should appreciate that there are people who want to do necessary repairs, say, on a roof or a gable end, and who want to do that work only. But when the inspector comes along, on the instructions of the Minister, of course, he insists that a certain amount of extra work must be done before the grant can be given. The Minister should ask his inspectors to relax a little in that respect.
I may be wrong in this, but my experience has been that in the rural areas it is possible for an applicant to obtain an instalment of a grant when approximately half the work is done. That is a tremendous help. But my information is that in the urban areas, no such instalment is given. The work must be completed before there is any question of any money being paid at all. There may be a particular case for the payment of instalments in the rural areas. If there is, I suggest that the working people in the towns and cities who avail of these grants should also be entitled to obtain an instalment of approximately half the grant when roughly half the work has been completed.
Again, in this matter of putting the house into a fit condition, in many cases this means they require the house to be practically rebuilt. I can understand perfectly the intention of the Minister and his officials in insisting that a certain amount of work be done. I would suggest, however, that in many cases they are so strict that the work cannot be carried out by people of very little means.
Section 5 might be described as an excellent section. Where the owner or tenant of a house cannot reconstruct, it allows the local authority to step in and do so, but it applies only to rural areas. I take grave exception to this. The Minister ought to extend the provisions of the section to the urban areas. It would be a tremendous advantage to this extent. In every town in the country, there is a portion regarded as the old part of the town for which the citizens have a great deal of regard. Every Deputy from a town will have places in mind. I have in mind a place in my own town. The majority of the owners and tenants in these places are not in a position to put their houses into proper condition. The local authorities in urban areas should be allowed to repair these houses so as to preserve the character of the old localities of which the people are so proud. Perhaps the Minister would consider that or else say why this provision applies to rural areas only?
All of us will welcome the basic idea behind Section 6. That is a proposal to enable an authority, not a local authority or a housing authority, to build houses for elderly persons such as pensioners. The Minister will have to be a little more explicit when speaking about this section again. That facility should be extended to the local authorities. Wexford town, in which I live, is one of the eight largest towns in Ireland. Frankly, Wexford Corporation could not in present circumstances engage in such a proposal. I assume, therefore, that towns of from 3,000 to 8,000 population would not be able to avail of these facilities, either. Therefore, I think the Minister should seriously consider affording this type of financial assistance to the housing authorities in order that they may engage in the building of housing for elderly persons.
The Minister should also consider what seems to be a forgotten section, as far as housing is concerned. I refer to young married couples. All of us appreciate the tremendous difficulties there are in the matter of housing accommodation for married couples. In many of our towns, the greatest number of houses are owned by the local authority. The situation seems to be — it is a situation with which the Minister is very conversant — that the son or daughter of a local authority tenant marries. Because there is no accommodation available, the young couple go to live with the father of the bride or the father of the bridegroom. They have a very slim chance of being housed by the local authority because, if they are offered another local authority house, only a third of the subsidy is paid on it. There may be some qualifications to that but, broadly speaking, that is the position generally. It is a pathetic situation when a young family comes along and there are two families living in a relatively small house with only two or three bedrooms. Very of ten, the father and mother and two or three children have to sleep in the one bed.
Again, I appreciate there are difficulties but I think the Minister could, under this section, help not alone in relation to the pensioners, or elderly persons, but also in relation to the young married couples. He should extend this section to provide that a housing authority will get financial assistance to build houses for young married couples. Then, there could later be a sort of swop with elderly parents whose children have married and gone out into other houses.
The Minister should, in any case, make an effort to see that married couples are provided for. They do not seem to be anybody's responsibility at the moment. In a town like Wexford, or a similar town, if a couple marry, they have not a chance of a house until they have three or four children. I know the situation here in Dublin is even worse. The fact that they have to live with their in-laws, and with their young family, in one or two rooms, does not do married life much good. In some cases, the situation is so bad that the marriage is broken up. I do not hold the Minister responsible for that.
Comment on this
The Minister should make an effort to see that something is done for young married couples. Would he also consider what can be done to assist small urban authorities in the matter of supplementary grants? Because the functional area of the county council is so big, and the county council is relatively wealthier than the small urban area, it can afford to give supplementary grants for the building and reconstruction of houses. The urban councils and small corporations, because their finances are so limited, cannot avail of the legislation which permits them to pay supplementary grants. I am sure the Minister has considered this problem. Perhaps he and his officials could try to devise some scheme whereby assistance would be given by the State to small urban councils and corporations to allow them to give supplementary grants similar to those given in the big cities and the county council areas.
We, in the Labour Party, welcome Section 10 because, despite the heated arguments that ensued here when the Labour Party introduced its Private Members Bill two or three weeks ago, we are glad to note now, even though it is belated, that the Minister has accepted the proposal and the principle enshrined in that measure. We believe that is an advance. Many cottages are now being vested in tenants in the rural areas and they will be enabled by this provision to improve their houses and keep them in proper repair, thereby preventing rural slums developing in rural Ireland.
In Section 10, there is another provision that I personally welcome. It is the provision in subsections (5) and (6) which provides that, when a local authority is forced to take over possession of a house which is still on loan, some payment may be made to the owner. That is only fair. In many cases, the owner who borrowed from the local authority has made an effort and repaid over many years a good deal of the money. If he falls on bad times and the local authority is forced to take possession, it is just not good enough that they should take the house and leave the man with nothing. This provision provides, if I read it correctly, that the local authority will be empowered in such cases to compensate the owner dispossessed by them.
I do not know what the object of Section 22 is. It is somewhat vague. It seems to me the section allows the Minister to do almost anything. I do not take exception to that, but I think he should place on the records of this House the reason that induced him to introduce this section because it does confer tremendous power, a power which he, perhaps, would not abuse but which some of his successors might possibly abuse. It seems to provide that the Minister may, in cases neither described nor determined, allow a grant. In all fairness, he should give some examples of the circumstances under which an applicant will be let through, so to speak.
In conclusion, I want to ask the Minister if there is any scheme, or if he contemplates any scheme, to compensate local authorities for the reduction in valuation on new and reconstructed houses. The fact that there are such generous rebates means there is less revenue for the local authorities. Houses being demolished and rates being discontinued, new houses being built and rates not paid in full for a period of, I think, ten years is a second cause of loss to local authorities. The Minister has, I believe, returns from the local authorities showing the losses that have been incurred over the years by reason of the reduction in valuation on new and reconstructed houses. Perhaps he would say in his concluding speech whether or not it is possible or whether or not he intends to assist in the matter of rates lost by reason of legislative proposals in various Housing Bills.
Comment on this
Like the Minister, I think this Housing Bill will be very useful in many ways to people who want to build their own houses. For one thing, it is a good idea there is no longer a two-year limit on Housing Bills. I find, and probably other Deputies find also, that anyone who wants to build a house will not do it just before the end of the two-year period because he thinks if he does, he may lose grants or that there may be something new in the new Housing Bill. Therefore, people will go ahead now and build the houses knowing there is no end, as it were, to the existing housing legislation.
I am glad to note that under the Bill the Minister intends to be very strict about giving grants for a new house, if it is not serviced with water and sewerage. Within the past few years, most people have realised that water and sewerage are a very essential part of a house — even as essential as the roof. I hope that as far as possible the Minister will insist that where there is a new house built, it shall have both water and sewerage.
Another good provision in the Bill is that the supplementary grants have now an extended upper limit. Recently owing to the fact that wages have increased, a number of people I know of could not avail of the council supplementary grant because their wage was too high. These were people who would be entitled to a council cottage but who thought it would be quicker to build a house for themselves. They built a house and then could not get a grant. I am glad that limit has been raised and also that the councils will be able to make supplementary grants under schemes of their own. The £80 grant to make old houses habitable is a very good and very original idea and will save local authorities many headaches.
I expect every member of a local authority has cases where there is perhaps a woman living alone; she does not want to go into another house and live with her relatives but wants to stay where she is. However, she cannot afford to do up the house; the roof or the walls may be bad. If a grant is given by the Department and if the local authority can also do up the house, that person will be in a really habitable house. If she had to wait for a council cottage, being a single person, she could wait for a very long time and possibly never get a house. That is a very good scheme and I hope the Minister will not be too strict about the amount of work which has to be done on this house in order to qualify for the grant. If the house is made habitable without any trimmings, so to speak, if it is weatherproof, I hope he will allow the grant to be given.
In regard to houses for elderly persons, that is also a very good new provision in this Bill. I hope that benevolent societies will take up the idea and build these houses. As in the case of the grant for the type of house I have referred to, these elderly people would have to wait years before they could get a council cottage because there are very few local authorities that would be willing to build a four-roomed council cottage for two people, perhaps a husband and wife. If benevolent societies or other people would build these houses for elderly persons, they would be doing a really valuable thing for the country. There are many people who are waiting for houses and who will have to wait a long time until something like this is done.
In this regard, however, I think it would be much better if these houses were not built in groups just for elderly people on the outskirts of towns or villages but if they were built, as it were, in and out of a town or village so that the elderly people would be in touch with the younger people. If elderly people are all together, it is not good for them. It would be much more cheerful for them to see younger people around them. I do not like the idea of just having a group of perhaps ten elderly people, all together just looking at each other, but that, I expect, will have to work itself out.
The last item I want to mention is the experimental houses. This also is a very original idea and I hope it will encourage people to build these experimental houses. The house plans now brought out by the Department are much too elaborate for the ordinary person building in the rural areas. When they come to me saying they want to build a new house and ask me to get a plan from the Department, I get it for them; it costs only a shilling or two, but invariably when they take it to their builder, the builder says it is much too expensive. They do not get the Department's plan therefore but pay something like £10 or £20 to an architect to design a plan for them which works out cheaper in the end. If these new experimental houses are a success, this part of the Bill will be well worth while.
I should like the Minister to have the accent not only on the cost of these houses, which I hope will be cheap, but also on the design. Council cottages are well designed and we do not want to have houses for private people inferior to those. So often when the thing is cheap, it looks cheap so when the Minister is giving grants for these houses, I hope he will insist that they will be pleasant to look at. What I have always been hoping for — and I mentioned it some time ago — is that we would be able to have our own design for a house. On the Continent and the rest of the world, every country has its own special house design. Sometimes it concerns only the roof, like Japan. Everybody knows what a Japanese house looks like because the roof is different; the French house has shutters and the German house has something else. We do not seem to have anything that distinguishes our houses as Irish. If the designers of these experimental houses would concentrate on creating something that looks Irish and that will always be recognised as Irish, we can then be proud of the houses that are built by people for their own occupation and by county councils as well.
Comment on this
This House could not be dealing with any matter of greater importance or greater urgency than the housing of our people. I have been wondering whether before the Minister introduced this Bill his Department had gone to the trouble of conducting a national survey of the housing needs in each county. The Housing Section of the Department have been doing a reasonably good job of work. They have contributed very generously towards the erection of new houses and, particularly, in the administration of the existing scheme of grants for erection and reconstruction of houses. I have felt, however, that the section might be better staffed. There appears to have been in the past some degree of delay in the carrying out of inspections for the purpose of grants for new houses and reconstruction. I have been wondering whether it has been penny wise and pound foolish for the Minister to restrict the staffing of this section of the Department. I would recommend that, irrespective of cost, the section should be well staffed with officers and engineers so that the many housing problems affecting the people might be dealt with speedily.
The volume of applications for reconstruction and new house grants has been steadily increasing. Therefore, if there is a shortage of inspectors or engineers, steps should be taken to bring the staff up to sufficient strength to deal with this problem.
Comment on this
The Deputy realises, of course, that it is administration he is dealing with, not the legislation before the House?
Comment on this
I was dealing with the question of a national housing survey just before you came in and I was wondering whether this survey had been carried out or not.
Comment on this
The appointment of engineers would be relevant to an Estimate but scarcely relevant to a new piece of legislation.
Comment on this
I was rather disappointed when this Bill was circulated. I expected that there would have been provision in it for the establishment of statutory housing committees for each local authority. I was expecting that the elected representatives on the councils would have been given additional powers in relation to housing. The work of county councils has increased considerably and we find that because of the problems in relation to roads, hospitals and health coming within the sphere of local authorities, the primary responsibility of local authorities in relation to housing seems to be placed in the background. That is why I was expecting that the Minister would have done something in this regard. The Minister should provide for the setting up of such committees who should be appointed by the county council for each county. Such housing committees would be charged with the responsibility of housing and for placing before county councils, as a guide, proposals for housing schemes and whatever other proposals they might have in relation to loans under the Small Dwellings Act or any other scheme of grants in operation.
The county managers, county engineers and county medical officers of health do not appear to be working with a degree of efficiency or speed and there appears to be considerable overlapping in many cases in the functions of these officers. That is why I feel that in order to bring about a greater degree of efficiency and speed, statutory housing committees should have been appointed. The Minister should consider this matter.
There is the General Council of County Councils, with which, no doubt, the Minister is very familiar. An expression of opinion should have been obtained from that body, prior to the introduction of any new housing Bill. I should like to hear from the Minister whether the officers of his Department or he at any time asked the local authorities for an expression of their views in relation to the question of housing.
Deputies who are members of local authorities — and they are over three-fourths of the membership of this House — know that while there has been a great degree of progress in the housing of our people in recent years, there still appears to be a tremendous volume of work yet to be accomplished in that regard. No doubt, many Deputies have expressed their views on the question of the housing of old people. There are many cases in every county and every urban area of old age pensioners or old people who have no prospect of qualifying for a local authority house. If the national housing survey I have suggested were carried out, it would reveal that there is an enormous number of elderly people who do not enjoy the independence of their own home.
An enormous problem faces the country in relation to the housing of newlyweds. The leader of the Labour Party certainly does not exaggerate the position when he says that in every part of the country there is a very serious problem in that regard. Many newlyweds must either take a room in a council house or go to live with relatives or friends, or take a flat. They cannot hope to be relieved of the inconvenience of having to live in a flat or rooms until they have a family of two, three or four children. That situation has presented every local authority with a great deal of difficulty. Now that we are moulding housing legislation for the future, special provision should be made for the housing of newlyweds.
I am sure the problem is grave in the city of Dublin and in every other city but I am familiar with the very distressing problem in the towns of Birr and Tullamore where the local authorities have undertaken the housing of the people to a reasonably good extent. We find that in practically every council house in Tullamore and Birr, there is living as a sub-tenant the married son or the married daughter and when that person applies to the local authority to be rehoused, he cannot be considered for accommodation by the local authority simply because he is living as a sub-tenant in a council house. That is unfair to the council, unfair, certainly, to the applicant who finds himself in that position. Where is such a person expected to live if there is a shortage of houses? Is it not only to be expected that the first to come to the rescue of the married son or daughter will be the father or mother? There are many cases throughout the country.
Comment on this
These people cannot provide houses for themselves. They have not the wherewithal to build. The amount of grants is insufficient and they probably would not qualify for a loan under the Small Dwellings Act if their employment was not secure or they could not find the necessary guarantors in support of their application for a loan. Therefore the local authorities cannot house them if they cannot house themselves.
Comment on this
The Minister represents Donegal but we are not all in that lucky position. I can only talk from my experience of my constituency and I have been a member of my county council for 20 years. I am satisfied that the Laois County Council do not do it.
Comment on this
It is illegal to have a sub-tenant and then who is going to house them? In Donegal, they are housed by the Donegal housing authority. They are not housed in my county and I have been a member of the county council for years. I understand they are not housed in County Dublin, either.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy relate what he is saying to the Bill? As far as I know, the Bill does not deal with local authority housing at all.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy not in order on the Second Stage to point out what is not in the Bill?
Comment on this
The Bill deals with grants and loans for private individuals. It does not deal with public authorities at all.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Flanagan not in order in pointing out that those who cannot be housed should have more facilities under this Bill?
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan is travelling far outside the scope of the Bill and what help he gets from other Deputies will not keep him within the scope of the Bill.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister who is going to house the sub-tenants? There must be an enormous number of them who cannot be housed and I want to know if this Bill is going to solve their problems?
Comment on this
This is a Bill designed to amend an Act already in operation and it does not deal with local authorities at all, except in so far as local authorities can deal with private individuals.
Comment on this
I quite agree with the ruling of the Chair. Everything the Chair says is always right. However, while the Chair has given that ruling, I still maintain that Deputy Cunningham and the Minister have one law for their county and another law for every other county.
Comment on this
With regard to the increase in the grant for the reconstruction of houses, I feel I am entitled to express my keen disappointment. Having regard to the fact that the cost of materials has considerably increased, that the cost of labour is now much higher, that the cost of all requirements for the building of additional rooms or for the removal of existing roofs and their replacement by new roofs has increased I feel that the grants are not nearly sufficient. I had expected that the system of grants at present in operation would have been doubled under this Bill and I am very disappointed that there is no special provision in the Bill substantially increasing the amount paid by way of grant to private individuals for the reconstruction of their houses.
The Minister must be aware that the small farmer may be described as a private individual but there is nothing in this Bill which will help him to provide his own house. Most of the small farmers cannot find sufficient money to supplement the grants given by the Department and in parts of the country many of them are so poor that they are not accepted as sufficiently sound to qualify for a loan. Throughout the length and breadth of the country, an enormous number of hovels are still in existence. We all know that there are many small farmers who would qualify to be housed by the local authority but, because of the increased pressure on local authorities from urban areas, it is impossible to promote schemes for the erection of houses for small farmers.
The time has now come when the State should erect a house for every small farmer and let them pay back the local authority, or the Department, or whoever else is responsible, the cost of the house in the form of an annuity payable yearly or half-yearly. We are just tinkering with the problem of housing our people in rural Ireland and it will never be solved until the small farmers are taken out of the thatched, mud-walled cabins in which many of them still have to exist in many parts of this country. They have not already provided themselves with houses because they have not got the financial backing.
This Bill will not help those people. There is nothing in it which will help to provide them with new houses. Surely, in 1962, when the Government speak of all their great housing achievements and when we see so many rat-infested hovels in which people are forced to live under the most degrading conditions, under conditions which one would not see in any civilised country in the world, when every county medical officer of health can report that there are houses in which seven people sleep in one room, all over 14 years of age, of both sexes——
Comment on this
Somebody is responsible and it is a state of affairs any Government should be ashamed of. It is a state of affairs that should not exist in any Christian country — six or seven people compelled to live in one room, people who have grown to manhood and womanhood. I know of people living in houses and their livestock are better housed than they are themselves. We all know of these cases. They are in every constituency throughout the length and breadth of the country. I could trot out the cases here one after another, if I thought the Ceann Comhairle would allow it.
Comment on this
I shall take Deputy McQuillan's advice and count ten, because I might say something which I should not like to go on the record of the House.
Comment on this
Getting back to the Bill and to the housing of our people, this measure will not improve the position in any degree whatsoever and I should like to hear from the Minister why he has not proposed in this Bill to increase housing grants. They have not got the money. Those are the people who, when the inter-Party Government were in office, talked about our having to scrape the bottom of the pot. How has the position changed now? Fianna Fáil Deputies were very vocal about housing conditions when we were in office. Why are they not proposing to spend all the money on housing they said they would? There were to be generous grants for any person who wanted to build his own house. There was to be an endless supply of money for the reconstruction and repair of houses. It was part of their policy to provide houses for old age pensioners. How are we to provide a house at £300?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will tell us how to build a house for £600. The Bill does not provide any definition of an elderly person. Is an elderly person a person of 60 or of 80 or of 90 for the purposes of this section? How are the local authorities and the Minister to determine what an elderly person is, seeing that no age limit has been suggested in this Bill? There is nothing to stop any of us who have reached middle age from describing ourselves as elderly people. I suppose this to be like many other Acts brought in by the Government. Paper never refuses ink and this paper is only for use by them on the platforms and at the church gates. Of course these people will never qualify for these grants. There will be inspectors down from the Department to try to determine their age, to look at their marriage certificates, their birth certificates, their parents' birth certificates and marriage certificates. There will be inquiries, certificates to be filled by peace commissioners and Gardaí. Parish priests and rectors will be pulled into it, and every other kind of certifying and verifying officer, to decide what an elderly person is. Perhaps the Minister would explain now.
I had expected that in this Bill there would have been a section to provide a scheme of grants so that persons with large families could provide themselves with special houses. I had expected there would be in it a very generous scheme of reconstruction grants to assist people to reroof their houses. The amount provided under this Bill will not give any measure of assistance to such people. There is no man more highly qualified to speak on those problems than the Minister who must be aware that there are numerous applicants for reconstruction grants who never carry out the work after the estimate is obtained. I should like to hear from him what these figures are because in my own constituency and outside it, I know of many instances where applicants have been unable to meet the high cost of reconstruction. If they could not meet it in the past, how can they meet it now? This Bill does nothing for them.
I also felt that where cases of overcrowding could be certified by the local authority, the office of the local authority could be used to obtain a report from the county medical officer of health for any private individual who wanted an inspection carried out for the purpose of making a case for special consideration to the Department. Overcrowding exists to a very great degree in rural Ireland, right down from Leitrim to Limerick, along the shores of the Shannon. I was expecting there would be some generous scheme in this Bill, whereby sufficient funds would be made available to enable those people to house themselves. I am extremely disappointed at the terms of the Bill in that regard. It is just another bit of patchwork, as far as housing legislation is concerned. The Minister has lost a golden opportunity of doing something towards solving our housing problem for all times.
I was expecting there would have been some section in this Bill in regard to the rates of interest on loans for the erection or reconstruction of houses. The present rates of interest are extraordinarily high. In order to solve the housing problem, one would expect to see in this Bill measures of a revolutionary character in regard to interest rates. The one way of encouraging and assisting people in the matter of housing is by making available loans at special low rates of interest. If that were done, I would venture to say that the present demands on local authorities would be eased considerably. Instead of expecting local authorities to provide houses for people who can provide them for themselves, the Minister should have availed of this golden opportunity of helping to solve the housing problem. Before this Bill becomes law, he should have provision made for special low rates of interest for housing. There is one section in this Bill which I consider very necessary and useful.
Comment on this
Since Deputy Lalor applauded me in the constituency, I would expect him to repeat the applause here. It is Section 18. Many cases have been brought to the notice of Deputies in the past where an applicant who had applied for a reconstruction grant or a grant for the erection of a new house died before the work was completed. In the past, this has led to a great deal of difficulty and expense for the next of kin. I am glad to see that steps have now been taken to rectify the matter and that the grant will be paid without undue delay and without the need of having to go through the present expensive and unnecessary legal formalities.
That is all I have to say except to place on record my very keen disappointment with the Bill. From a Party who were so vocal about housing when the inter-Party Government were in office, I would have expected more comprehensive housing legislation and more generosity towards the private individual. This Bill is merely a sham and an excuse for the Government to appear in certain places and say: " We have brought in a housing Bill". This Bill contains no benefits for the people. Such a Bill must be considered impractical and a waste of the time of the House. If any Deputy is approached by a private individual and asked: "What do I get under this Bill?", he will have to say honestly: "You will get nothing". The present scheme of grants remains as it is. This Bill does not help in any way to relieve the plight of people anxious either to build their own homes or reconstruct their existing mud-walled, thatched, rat-infested hovels.
The Minister is displaying a great lack of knowledge of the housing requirements of private individuals. He has been badly advised in that regard. Legislation of this kind must be approved by the Government before it is introduced. The Government who approved this legislation are a Government who know very little about the disastrous plight of the people in rural Ireland in regard to housing. This Bill lacks everything necessary to stimulate the development of housing and complete the drive to rehouse our people. It can only be described as a standstill housing Bill, which gives nothing and which will do nothing.
The Minister would be well advised to consult with his advisers. The housing advisers at his disposal are men who know their job and who have practical experience of administration. But if the Housing Section had the lead, if they had the Minister and the Government prepared to spend money on housing, then we would get moving with the housing programme. But where you have a Department anxious to drive forward, and for each step forward they take, the Minister pulls them back two, you cannot expect progress or efficiency and our people cannot expect to be housed. That is why I feel that if we had a Minister for Local Government and a Government interested in housing, with the present Housing Section of the Department, all in step and all going forward, then we might get some place. I am sure we would get some place.
Our housing problems will not be solved by the present Government. All the people who were promised housing legislation at the last election can say tomorrow morning that they have got it, but they are no nearer to being housed. That is why I say the Fianna Fáil Party have not got a housing programme aimed at solving the housing difficulties of our people, the newlyweds, the aged, the couples with large families, those who experience overcrowding, and the sub-tenant. The latter is catered for in Donegal, but nowhere else. If the people want to stimulate housing, if local authorities are anxious to get on with housing, if private individuals are anxious to be provided with loans and grants to enable them to erect their own houses, the first thing they must do is change the Government. That will not be a difficult job at the next general election. It will not be a big job.
Comment on this
All that does not seem to be very relevant to the measure before the House. The Deputy ought to come more closely now to the measure before the House.
Comment on this
I was just endeavouring to convey to the Minister how close he is to removal from office. In conclusion, I want to say this is not the Bill we expected. It is certainly far from providing our people with the ways and means of providing themselves with houses, houses in which they can be proud to live in Christian decency.
Comment on this
Housing progress over the past 30 years has been magnificent. Tremendous advances have been made. This Bill is yet another step forward to clear up some of the remaining evils where the housing of our people is concerned. I did not expect the Bill would be welcomed by the Opposition. I did not expect any praise for it. But I did not think they would have wasted the time of the House making a foolish demand. It is not so very many years since they were in power. They had a Minister who brought in legislation and made promises. They also had a Minister who did not provide the wherewithal to execute the contracts undertaken.
This evening we heard repeated demands from Deputy O.J. Flanagan to spend more. Spend, spend, spend, that is all I have listened to since I came in here last October, an everincreasing demand for money and no recommendation or suggestion as to how that money will be found. It is pathetic. It is a waste of the time of this House. One expects a certain amount of political gibing, back and forth, but one expects from the Fine Gael front bench a little more responsibility than that shown by Deputy O.J. Flanagan this evening.
The Minister mentioned that there are 30,000 homes in need of repair. Of those 30,000, some 20,000 need replacement. That in itself indicates the tremendous progress over the past 30 years. There are something in the region of 600,000 homes in the country, and 30,000 would represent five per cent. of that number. The end of the housing problem would appear to be well in sight. Within the next decade, it should be completely solved. There will, of course, be annual wastage at the rate of some 1,000 houses per year. That is a remarkable achievement for the nation and for successive Governments. We have eradicated the truly horrible housing conditions that existed; we have reduced the number to some five per cent.
The Minister deserves to be complimented on the provisions in this Bill. He is making provision here for sections who were never hitherto catered for. He deserves the commendation of the House.
Section 2 does not provide for any increase in the housing grants. It is not necessary to increase these grants. The problem today is to find someone who will build houses. There is a shortage of workers. This is a far cry from 1956 and 1957 when workers were running out of the country. It was the Opposition who caused the unholy mess and left the country without the craftsmen and workers to build homes for our people. However, they are now making their way back to profitable employment.
I should like to see the Minister extend Section 2 to benefit people prepared to erect houses for letting. I understand Section 12 of the existing Act is being repealed. I should like some compensating factor if that section is repealed. It is a social amenity to have houses for letting, so that those who may have to move temporarily to a town can find accommodation. We know that local authorities are not empowered to build houses for temporary letting. But there are in every town in Ireland workers who, because of the nature of their work, may move in for one, two or ten years. They are never likely to qualify for a house from the local authority but they are likely to be settled for long enough to consider buying a house. It is that type of person for whom provision should be made and for whom people should be encouraged to build houses. Section 12 has not been availed off to any great degree and I think the reason was that people did not consider it very useful. I hope the Minister will reconsider that point.
In regard to reconstruction and improvement of houses, the Minister is making adequate grants available. The only comment I want to make is that I get many complaints from farmers and those who have reconstructed their houses that the costs they have to pay the builders are sometimes much higher than those estimated by the Department's inspector. I would welcome some method of narrowing this difference.
In regard to the additions to the Bill, in every county in Ireland, particularly in the west of Ireland, there are homes on small farms which over the years have fallen into disrepair. I was very pleased to note that these people who have not the wherewithal to build a house for themselves are being considered in this Bill and that the Minister is now providing a grant for necessary or minimum repairs. It is also good to see that county councils are authorised to make up the difference and to come in and do those repairs if they so wish. I wish this provision every success. I shall now be able to tell a few badly-housed people I am aware of in my constituency about it.
Another useful provision is that in relation to the housing of old people. I heard a lot of fun being made of what can be done with £600. Anybody who reads the Bill carefully will see that there is a provision for a kitchen, a bedroom and some kind of sanitary arrangements. With an area of 300 square feet in a small holding and with adequate planning, I am satisfied a reasonable home can be erected for £600. The Minister has shown tremendous foresight in this provision and I hope that, in addition to the Minister's efforts, the local authorities and other bodies will take advantage of it. However, I am not clear as to how the matter is to be dealt with and I would ask the Minister to be more specific.
Another new step taken by the Minister to create competition, as it were, is that in relation to the prototype house, the accent being on economy of building. I must compliment the Minister on this original idea. It is a good thing to foster competition among architects, builders and others. I am not too clear what the Minister has in mind but it is a desirable step. A great effort has recently been made by many architects to bring in a variety of architectural features into homes. This can be seen around Dublin and other parts of the country and deserves commendation. It is nice to see that the Minister is availing of this measure to encourage greater variety of design. One has looked for years at the usual type of three-bedroom houses. There has not been much variation, two windows at the top, one at the bottom, and the door, a long line of semi-detached houses strung along in a dreary fashion, the only change being one house has brick and another dashing, some are white and some grey, but the whole thing is rather dreary. The Bill will give more liberty in that respect. It is highly desirable that the standard of housing design be raised, that new building materials be used, and if they can be bought at a cheaper price, it is all to the good.
The First Schedule to the Bill provides:
1. The total area of all the floors of a house measured in the prescribed manner shall not be less than 500 square feet nor more than 1,400 square feet.
2. A house shall contain at least three rooms.
Would the Minister say whether it is his intention to adhere to the present formula of 155 square feet for a living room, 155 square feet for a bedroom, 120 square feet for a second bedroom and so on? This, to my mind, was largely responsible for the reproduction of the same type of house. There has been a tendency in the Department to give more liberty in regard to the lay-out of the rooms rather than confine them to these limits.
In regard to urban areas, county council areas, there is a tendency sometimes, especially in our larger provincial towns, to look for a small density per acre. It is evident to everybody in this House that land prices are soaring very high. Under Dublin Corporation, there is an average of ten houses to the acre. The county council has something like six houses to the acre. If it is within the Minister's power — perhaps it is not — some liberty in this regard would be of benefit.
Deputy Flanagan made the comments I wanted to make on this Bill. I welcome the Bill. I consider it an excellent measure, a step in the right direction, which will go a long way towards solving finally the problem of housing the people. When the Bill is in operation, the benefits deriving from it will manifest themselves in the eradication of a lot of bad housing and as a result, whatever Minister may be in office, whether the present Minister or some other Minister, in a few years' time we will be able to afford to review the problems then facing us. I have no doubt that this Government would like to introduce legislation which would solve immediately all the problems in relation to housing but it would be impossible to satisfy the needs of everybody.
Deputy Blowick became very excited about the question of housing. Frankly, I was quite surprised. In the years during which Deputy Blowick was a Minister of an inter-Party Government, why did he not take a greater interest in this matter? Reading the paper the other day, I was particularly shocked to learn the degree of bad housing in Mayo. I was shocked that Deputy Blowick was not aware of it. He mentioned a figure of 1,400 houses. He is a member of Mayo County Council and could have done a great deal more in Mayo. I do not think county councils need any more authority than they have now. If they use the powers they have, any bad housing in their areas could be eradicated.
The question of housing newlyweds has been referred to. Every member of the House is aware of the requirements in his county council area. If a county council want to provide facilities for newlyweds and to make special provision for them, it is within their power to do so and they ought to take steps to do so if they feel there is a need for it. I do not think it is the duty of the Department or of the Minister to direct the building of houses in any county. The power is vested in the county councils. The powers they have are sufficient for them to be able to solve the local problems in relation to housing.
I should like to refer to the section in the Bill which provides for stamp duty on the sale of a house in respect of which a grant has been paid and which has not been occupied. The stamp duty is one per cent. I would ask the Minister to examine that position. One per cent. on the price of a house can range from £20 to £25. It is difficult to understand why there should be a housing grant of £275 on the one hand and the imposition of stamp duty of, say, £25 on the other. A person buys a site, employs a builder and has a house built by way of contract. This is not applicable. It may not be a serious problem. Nevertheless, I would appreciate something being done about it.
I have not noticed anywhere in Ireland such conditions as have been described here this evening. I have been around Leitrim, Sligo and parts of Mayo, and all the poorer districts in the West of Ireland. I have never seen these conditions and I am surprised to hear that in Deputy Flanagan's constituency there are cases where seven people over 14 years of age, male and female, are sleeping and living in one room. I am shocked to hear of this. I have seen poverty in Ireland but I have never seen a case where people had stooped to such low moral standards. If such conditions exist in Deputy Flanagan's constituency I wonder what he is doing? It is a matter that should be brought to the attention of the clergy and everybody responsible. I am shocked. I have not seen such conditions anywhere.
Comment on this
I confidently recommend this Bill to the House and compliment the Minister on introducing it.
Comment on this
It is very difficult to know on what leg the last speaker is going to stand. He started off by stating it was not necessary to increase housing grants, that the greatest trouble at the moment was to get contractors or people to build houses. Then he criticised Deputy Blowick for not being aware that there were so many houses in Mayo which were in a shocking condition. Then he told us that he had travelled Mayo, Sligo, Leitrim and Dublin and had never seen the living conditions described by certain Deputies. I do not know if the Deputy knows himself what he wished to say, except to praise the Minister for bringing in this paltry measure to solve a major problem.
There is not the slightest doubt that this Bill will cause great disappointment throughout the country. It is a case of the mountain labouring and bringing forth a mouse. For the past six months, in my constituency, local authority members of the Minister's Party have told the public that new housing legislation was under way which would ease the situation for the small farmer. This Bill was to ease the position that exists in rural Ireland and which the Minister knows perfectly well exists because of the recent investigation carried out by every local authority into housing conditions. The prolonged delay in introducing this measure has led the public to expect great things.
The Bill is notable for omissions from it than for the good it contains. I do not mean to say that there are not good provisions and good sections in the Bill. I do not suggest there are not but there is nothing in this Bill to justify any member of the Fianna Fáil Party or any member of the Government blowing a trumpet. The simple little improvements provided for could have been brought in three or four months ago. There was no necessity for the long delay in dealing with the simple improvements included in the Bill. We all welcome them but the major point of the Bill is the renewal of existing legislation. It is a Bill to enable existing housing grants to be continued because the legislation covering housing grants is on a three year basis and the time had expired and the grants in operation would no longer be available. It was necessary under the circumstances for the Government to bring in legislation to continue existing housing grants. That is the only thing that has been achieved in this Bill, the continuation of the existing situation in relation to grants for private building.
Lest the Minister and members of his Party might think I am prejudiced against the Government, let me say that grants for essential repairs to houses, experiments on houses and houses for elderly people are all good things and are welcome. If I might select one of these matters for special reference, because other speakers have dealt sufficiently with the majority of them, I would like to ask the Minister to comment on the section that relates to the experiment in new types of houses. My feeling is that the Minister is preparing to give consideration to the idea of giving grants for the erection of the prestressed concrete type of house, one that can be built within three days, one that is as sound and lasting as the normal house built with normal building materials and one that can be built at a little less cost. I would like the Minister to say if he has that in mind, apart from any changes in design.
The main point I want to deal with is the problem that affects the small farmer in respect of housing. Surely when so much is talked in this House about the small farmer, it should be realised by the Government that there is a tremendous problem still to be solved. The best thing I can do is to relate the position as I see it in my own county. The Roscommon County Council is no better and no worse than any other county council in Ireland and so conditions there would be applicable to other counties.
In Roscommon, at least 60 per cent. of the farmers have valuations of less than £14. Those men, under £14 and down as far as £6, are described as farmers. They are in the majority in the county and they are expected, under the existing law, to build their own houses. They are expected, through the Government grant and the supplementary grant, through their own resources to supplement those grants in addition to the loan that is available and thereby provide themselves with houses. It has been established in Roscommon that a large proportion of the small farmers under £12 valuation are not in a position to bridge the gap between the State grant and the supplementary county council grant and the cost of the house. They have not that amount of money available and are not in a position to get it.
The result is that Roscommon County Council have decided that all farmers under a valuation of £12 and up to a valuation of £15 who are in need of houses must be re-housed by the council. If one could see the tortuous planning that has to be carried out in order to enable the council legally to implement its wishes in that regard, the Minister would feel that this Bill to which we were looking forward so much is very sadly lacking.
If the county council finds an individual with a valuation of £12 unable to build his house, the council will then go through the legal procedure of acquiring a plot of land for that farmer. The whole question of title comes into it and causes delay and a considerable amount of irritation, both to the council and to the individual looking for the house but it does not cause too much trouble to the legal men concerned. The council then proceeds to build a house and then the real trouble begins because there is a major difficulty in getting contractors to build these houses especially if they are in isolated places. Contractors find it is not a paying proposition to take on one or two isolated houses at the contract prices.
The council, having decided to build a house, becomes the official owner. The farmer is allowed to move in and is there on the same basis as the worker or the county council employee for whom the council normally build houses. Why could not all that procedure be eliminated? Why is it not possible for the council to build a house and put the repayment charges on the rent for the farmer? We know how it works out as far as the Land Commission charges are concerned and we know the majority of the farmers pay up as regularly as could be.
It is a tragedy at the present time to find that the capital requirements for building a house which are not available to the small farmer prevent him from getting a house in County Roscommon and will prevent him from getting one for the next eight to ten years. I believe that the number of houses in County Roscommon in need of development and reconstruction is 397 and from my own experience I think that is a conservative figure. I am not blaming the Minister or the county council for that and I am not blaming them for the position that has obtained up to the present. I am hoping that since this information has come to him about the condition of those houses, he will take steps to solve that problem and since he has figures for Roscommon, Mayo and every county in Ireland, I find it hard to credit that he could come in here and offer no solution or real help in getting rid of that backlog.
Building houses in local authority areas at the rate of 30 or 40 a year means that it will take ten years to meet the housing requirements of the people, not to speak of the other people who will be coming along in the meantime in need of re-housing, old people for whom provision is made in the Bill and the group who will need grants for essential repairs. There are so many other problems which have to be met by local authorities, in addition to the major one of re-housing small farmers, that councils will not be in a position to fulfil their duties in this regard.
I said I did not blame the Minister and I want to clarify that. Quite a large number of these smallholders to whom I refer are congests and, in my opinion, the duty of solving their housing problems should lie on the Land Commission. Those people living on small holdings have for the past 30 years been awaiting with great patience and hope the attention of the Land Commission. They have been expecting, and rightly so, to be taken out of the congested localities in which they live, to be given new holdings and have houses built for them. No real effort has been made by the Land Commission to solve their problem and, therefore, it is now the responsibility of the county council because they feel the present situation can no longer be allowed to continue. Seeing that the county council is prepared to do everything within its power, it is not unfair for me to suggest to the Minister that he should come to their help.
The position, as I see it at any rate, is that it will be a minimum of ten years before all the people who need houses and whose condition is well known to the Minister are dealt with. That, in my opinion, is inexcusable. If the Minister is prepared on Committee Stage to make provision for dealing with that matter, I can assure him he will have the thanks and the gratitude of the people living on small holdings all over the country. I welcome the present measure for the good points that are in it, but I am very sorry indeed that the Minister who has the information through inquiries carried out by the local authorities is not prepared to do more. As a result of the information available to him, the Minister must be preparing fresh legislation to enable him to solve that problem and if he is able to tell us in his concluding remarks that a Bill to meet these requirements to which I have referred is likely to be brought in by October or November at latest, then I have no further criticism to offer at this stage.
He should ask the Government to give priority, when they are arranging priorities between now and next October, to this very important matter of rehousing small farmers, and, indeed, persons with small incomes whose problem is not being solved and for whom local authorities are not in a position to build on existing grants. If the Minister would get his teeth into that problem, he would be solving something that has caused anxiety not only to the people who have waited so long but to all the local authorities concerned.
Comment on this
The second last speaker, Deputy Flanagan, gave a definition of an elderly person. An elderly person is one who sits in the House from 4.30 until 10.30 p.m. trying to say a few modest words on a Bill like this. It is a very ageing process.
There are aspects of the Bill which I like because they show a certain kind of thinking that appeals to me. It is a tidying Bill and I hope it will tidy our country, urban and rural. We have a heritage in this country of old houses, very badly run down houses and the third category, no houses. That is being provided for as many labourers' cottages and small dwelling houses are being built. They first create a problem for the Department as well as for us who are engaged in running our towns and cities. A little off the main streets of many of our towns and, indeed, on the main streets and very near the centre of Dublin, there are 18th century and early 19th century houses which have now almost outlived their purpose. They are big houses, reasonably well built, but which have been allowed to run down and I wonder are we making enough use of them and whether the Minister's Department should not see whether that kind of house could be maintained.
They are still good structurally and from every point of view it is desirable that they should be maintained because they occupy a very prominent part of our towns and cities and are running down. They are in the twilight area—I believe that is the architect's term — and that is a depressing thing in any place. We do not want it. I think, probably with a considerable investment of public money, these houses could be converted into dual residences or flats, but we just cannot nibble at the idea. It will have to be a global proposal. Unfortunately the kind of houses I refer to are fairly common. It is a kind which is prevalent throughout the country.
I am particularly interested in the proposal in the Bill that we should provide homes for old people. It is proposed we should put up £300 per dwelling and that the local authority would put up a similar sum. To utilise that kind of money properly, you could use a number of those old houses and the £600 could be expended in providing dwellings inside the shell of these big houses. That would seem to me to be a most sensible way of spending that money because I agree with other Deputies who have said that it is not possible to put up any dwelling of any duration or character for £600. You could, however, do a lot of good work by using these old houses in the way I have suggested.
When grants are given, and dwellings built as a result, it would be no harm, particularly in the case of the more modest type of house, in the interest of tidier towns, if the owners of these working class houses were tempted to maintain the paint work on the outside. There is a charitable institution in Cork city which maintains very modest dwellings for about 20 or 25 aged people.
Notice taken that 20 members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
The charitable institution to which I was referring is a very old one dating from the eighteenth century. As I said, it houses about 20 or 25 old people, male and female. They all have separate rooms. The building is very run down in condition. I have been wondering if the grant provided in this Bill for making houses available for old people could not be devoted to an institution of that type so that separate dwellings could be provided in it. Perhaps the Minister would answer that question when he is replying. There are other homes of that kind in Dublin and Limerick and I feel we would be making a marvellous effort to accommodate properly our old people if these grants could be made available for the reconstruction of these old homes to provide separate dwellings.
The Minister referred to the fact that grants could be given for the restoration of premises over a period so that the restoration work would not involve any substantial expenditure at any one period. I think that is a wise thing to do. Planning officers and town architects frequently put a stop to applications for repair grants for a house because they say in a vague kind of way that the area is scheduled for demolition under a town plan, and though the house may have 20 years' life in it, because of this vague suggestion that it might interfere with the town plan nothing can be done with it and it is allowed to fall into complete disuse and crumbles away to nothing. I am pretty sure that over 10, 12 or even 20 years, it will still not be demolished and over that period the kind of expenditure envisaged here could give it an extra lease of life. I welcome that part of the Bill.
The section which proposes that architectural experiments should be carried out so that we could devise a standard house is a good thing, if we are careful that we do not over-standardise and that we keep the rural scene interesting — that we do not have row upon row of houses of the same type. We have experience from the 18th and 19th centuries of that kind of thing and we know what a dismal picture it creates. If there is anything I am proud of in our housing scheme in my native city, it is the varied kind of architecture. That makes the houses good to live in because it makes the people feel they are living in an interesting place. While the idea of getting a prototype house designed is a good one, we should be careful that we have sufficient variation of design so that we will not have monotony in our landscapes or street scenes.
The Minister proposes to fix a uniform maximum of £2,000 under Section 20 of the Bill by way of advances to borrowers under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts. I do not think that is enough. For housing in Cork three years ago, we got quotations at £1,400 per house. This year, the best quotation we could get was £1,900. I think that £2,000 for the man building a single house on a site where he has also to buy the lease of a bit of land is not a real figure.
In the same respect, I do not think the present grants for house repairs bear any relation to costs today. To my mind, they are roughly 33? per cent. too low. The fact of the matter is that costs of that kind have increased by that amount during the past two and a half years. If we do not realise that, we will be putting a sum on paper which will not be as effective in its results as we would desire. In general, I think we should be all reasonably pleased with what has been done for the housing of the working classes since the war ended. I am sorry the Fine Gael figures were better than those of Fianna Fáil because I should have liked to have seen the Fianna Fáil figures better since it would show they were getting on with the job.
Comment on this
This Bill is like the proverbial curate's egg — good in spots. The fact that the Minister has included in it practically all the sections of the Private Members' Bill which the Labour Party introduced, which was defeated by the House and which the Minister criticised so severely, gives us a certain amount of satisfaction. In that Bill, we dealt only with one or two aspects of housing and like everybody else in the country interested in the matter, we were expecting a very comprehensive Bill now. We were therefore disappointed to find that the Bill introduced today does not go nearly far enough in most of the things the Minister seems to be attempting to tackle. Like most of the Deputies on this side of the House who have spoken, I am very disappointed that the amount of the grant has not been increased, both for the erection and reconstruction of houses. It is quite possible that somewhere in the Bill power is given to the Minister to alter the grant at certain stages. That may be the answer to the problem.
I feel that the present system whereby the maximum grant given by the Department cannot be exceeded by a supplementary grant from the local authority has not been working so well, because most local authorities seem to try to get away with the smallest possible grant they can give. If the Minister felt that he could not substantially increase the amount of the grants for the erection of new houses, he could have introduced an innovation which would reduce the amount of interest on any loan given for the building of a house. In that way he could have given assistance if he did not want to give direct assistance by way of increased grants.
I know, of course, that the difficulty is money. I do not intend to make it a Party political issue. I do not want to say that it is because a particular Government are in power. We all know that the amount of money we would all like to see provided is very great. On the other hand, it is most unfair for Deputies to stand up here, no matter from which side of the House, and try to politically colour the picture which is being put before the House.
Listening to the debate, as I have been for many long hours, like Deputy Barry I was learning things. I do not mind at any time people talking about something they know, particularly if they know their subject well, but I dislike people who do not know their subject proceeding to lecture members of the House on that subject. That has happened on more than one occasion to-night from both sides of the House. In fact, in one instance someone talked about the easy way the local authorities could, if they so desired, solve all our housing problems.
I am a member of a local authority, Meath County Council, and despite the fact that the controlling interest in that county council is the Government Party — there have been changes from one side to the other over the years — down through the years that has been a progressive council; it still is and it does its best according to its lights to deal with housing. Of course, we must, as a council, deal through the county manager, and the county manager must deal with the Department of Local Government.
Meath County Council will build for people with up to £20 valuation, and despite that, we have given an official figure to the Department of 1,062 unfit houses. Surely if we consider that figure in relation to the counties where people with valuations of £5 and £6 cannot have council houses built for them, and when we find they send in a figure of a few hundred unfit houses, there must be something wrong? Someone is trying to cod someone. If the Department want to get the correct figure of unit houses, they should go a little further than sending a polite note to the secretary of a county council asking him to supply the figures of unfit houses in that county.
Comment on this
There is a separate figure for the urban areas and the county council areas. I have given the figure for the county council area in Meath. In Mayo, the figure is 4,894 unfit houses, almost 5,000. In the neighbouring county, Roscommon, it is 397; Sligo, 526; North Tipperary, 232. It is asking a bit too much to expect that anyone would believe those figures could be right. They are not comparable.
As I say, Meath County Council erects houses for people with valuations of £20 in certain circumstances, and yet it has six times as many unfit houses as Roscommon. The big trouble we find in Meath is that the people who have valuations of over £20 are living in very bad houses. In Meath, we would call them small farmers, although in other counties a valuation of over £20 is a fairly sizeable farm. The small farmers in Meath, as in every other county, are not doing so well at present and, as a result, they are not in a position to house themselves. Very many of them are not in a position to carry out reconstruction. Unfortunately this Bill does not do very much to help that type of person. That is why I was hopeful that the grants would be greater, or that they could borrow money at a smaller rate of interest and could attempt to house themselves.
There is also the question of the size of the new houses being built. While a figure of a minimum of 500 square feet and a maximum of 1,400 square feet may appear to be reasonable, there is one thing I dislike very much, that is, when someone builds a house an inspector comes with a tape measure and if it is inches out one way or the other, that is sufficient to prevent him from qualifying for a grant. That should not happen. I know of a few such instances. It is despicable that just because the space is a few inches out a person should be debarred from getting the grant. If a person wants to build a decent house, the design may be a little under or a little over but I think he should get the grant and no dickering about it.
I know of one instance where someone built a house and found there was one complete room which was in excess of the floor space required. It was at the end of the house. He needed a workshop so he closed the door between that room and the rest of the house with the result that the house he intended to live in was within the floor space of 1,400 square feet. He opened a double door in the other room and made it into a workshop and a car shed. The Department took great pleasure in pointing out that there was still a lintel and that he might at a later stage, if his family grew larger, open the door between the workshop and the house so he could not get the grant. The Minister will agree that there is no point at all in that sort of thing. Either we want people to make an effort to house themselves, and we are prepared to assist them or we do not.
So far as the question of improving the standard of building and the type of house are concerned, there is one question I should like to put to the Minister: has there been fairly recently a suggestion in the Department that people are tending to look for too high standards? Is it not a fact that local authorities have been instructed to reduce the standards? Is it not a fact that, in an effort to bring down contract prices, local authorities have been instructed to reduce the standard of the houses they are building for the working classes? If that is so, is it right that somebody should suggest here that the standard is being raised and that we are encouraging people to raise it?
I am aware of houses built to Departmental standards and if five or six people are sitting around a table and smoking for half an hour the ceiling, as a result of the alterations made, being so low, the place is full of smoke. Because, again, the Department have given instructions, there is only one fireplace in the whole house and it is not in the room which the people are using. Therefore, there is no way, unless they open the window or the door, of letting the smoke out of the house.
I do not know whose idea it was. I made inquiries and I was reliably informed that it was the Department that had issued instructions that the standard was to be lowered, that the standard was too high and that it was to be lowered, and therefore there would be a reduction in contract price. If the Minister considers or knows that to be untrue, I would be very glad if he would say so when he is replying because, believe me, I know where I stand in this respect.
The question of repairs has been discussed or mentioned in the Bill and certain suggestions were made. I am glad there is an arrangement by which a portion of a house can be repaired. A situation has arisen recently — it may be the regulation for a long time but it has come very much to the fore recently—of an inspector going down, inspecting the house and giving an estimate for the repairs to the house, an estimate which, in many cases, is very much lower than the cost of the work —that is beside the point—but an estimate for the job of work which must be done. Then, when the job is finished, he will point to other work to which he did not pay attention when he first examined the house.
He will inspect the house and say: "The house is grand but you must do that as well." A personal friend of mine in Deputy Mooney's constituency was told he would have to repair a conservatory attached to a house and which had no bearing on living accommodation. He could not do so, because all the money he could possibly get his hands on was spent on the work stipulated by the Minister's inspector in the first instance. I think it is right that that situation should be changed. If somebody wants to repair a certain portion of a house to live in, so as to have at least one or two good rooms, he should be able to get a grant for doing that type of work.
We also have in the country districts a situation that somebody is living in a house on the outside of which he must do some repairs. Under present regulations, the local authority engineers will inspect it, and sometimes the Department engineer, and may decide that the house is unfit for reconstruction. I have one instance at least and I have heard of one or two others where the people went ahead with the repairs and proved it was not true to say that the house was unfit for reconstruction. They reconstructed the house and made a good job of it. In one case, the grant was paid. In some other cases, the grant was refused because the Department or the local authority decided, before the work was started, that the work could not effectively be done.
I do not think that sort of situation should be allowed to continue. It is discouraging those who are trying to help themselves. I am full sure that if the matter is brought to top level — the officials who are advising the Minister denied they were aware of it —this sort of thing could not happen. Unfortunately, no matter what you seem to do, there is always somebody half way up the line who will make a decision on it and that is as far as the unfortunate person who wants to repair the house will get. Therefore, neighbours who might be encouraged to do something about their own houses will not attempt the same thing because of what happened to the first person. I would ask that the Minister would take this into account when he comes to reply and would see to it that in future such things cannot happen.
There is one question, lest I forget to mention it, on which I should like the Minister to clear my mind. It concerns Section 11. Subsection (8) of Section 11 says that no advances can be made: it is for the abolition of the existing——
Notice taken that 20 members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
Subsection (8) of Section 11 states that no new loans are to be made under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts, 1899 to 1958. Section 20 gives power to fix the maximum advances under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act of 1899. Maybe I am misreading it, or is there a contradiction in the Bill? If there is not, then I am perfectly satisfied. I wondered if there had been some slight error or error in the typing.
I wonder if the Minister would consider the question of sites for people who wish to build their own houses? I thought some reference might be made to it in the Bill. There is an unfortunate position in country districts where most people who want to build a house find they are asked a fantastic price for a site. They often find that they can get a site very reasonably from a tenant of a vested cottage. Possibly an old person who has got an acre of good land on which there is more than one site would be only too glad to dispose of portion of the acre for the housing of some of his neighbours, but, because the title of the vested cottage is tied up in some way, it is not possible to use it for a site. A loan, I understand, cannot be granted on foot of that particular type of site. Perhaps the Minister might consider if something could be done about that because it would relieve at least a number of people who at present are prevented from rehousing themselves because of lack of sites.
I should also like the Minister to consider further encouragement to people who form groups to build houses. I know that £10 extra has been given for years to those who form themselves into public utility or building societies. Those people are encouraged to build their own houses and use this extra £10. I think the Minister would be well advised if he would increase substantially that amount because it would encourage group effort. I have in mind particularly a group who came together in my own village and built a very excellent scheme — it is almost completed now — with the full assistance of the local authority and the Department. But there could be a little more co-operation from the Department, if there were an extra grant.
The grant to members of a public utility society is in fact the easiest way to offer encouragement to people like this. Also, a number of employers are rather anxious to build housing schemes for their employees. Again, I think an effort should be made to encourage that type of building and perhaps a little more encouragement from the Department might solve the problem. Those are matters which the Minister, I have no doubt, has gone into carefully or possibly they may not have been brought forcibly enough to his notice. Perhaps, when he is replying, he might deal with that aspect of the problem.