Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).
Contributions 1–118 of 244. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Before lunch, I had come to the point of drawing attention to the position so far as it affects us this year regarding the adverse trade balance. It shows £5,000,000 more in the first half of 1962 than in the corresponding half of 1961. We must remember that while the Taoiseach has mentioned, and we were all glad to know it, the increase in industrial exports, if we are to maintain any equilibrium, we must depend on agriculture. It would surprise many Deputies—at least this is the impression I got—that the Taoiseach should gloss over the fact that a comparison of the values and amounts of exports in agriculture, including cattle, for last year as against the previous year shows that the position is not as good as it was. In comparison with the previous year, as a percentage of our overall trade, agriculture exports dropped from roughly 29 per cent. to 25 per cent.
I cannot understand how a Government can be so complacent while admitting that because we know—this is a point on which other speakers have dwelt and I suppose it is essential to deal with it—Common Market problems will arise. The main problem that confronts us, assuming we become members, concerns how we will stand in relation to agricultural exports. We in the Labour Party cannot say we are satisfied with the information being imparted to the House by the Taoiseach and his Ministers as to what preparations are being made.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
We believe the Taoiseach and his Ministers should be able to give a little more help and, if necessary, a little more advice to the House on this subject. Some members of the Cabinet believe they know all themselves and have no intention of imparting any of that knowledge to those who may need it but when we realise that in the Common Market or out of it, for the economic well-being of the country, we must depend mainly on the export of agricultural products, we fear that our present policy on agriculture is tending to look more in the direction of cattle ranching than in that of the small farmers carrying on mixed farming in the south.
The Minister for Agriculture may not agree with that; the Taoiseach may not agree; but we believe that present agricultural policy is not helping, as it should, the small farmer in the south. Yet we are being told, and he is being told, to prepare for the day when he must face the withering competition from the countries in the Common Market. The present policy of West Germany seems to be to draw more and more from the land into industry and Germany is one of the leading countries in the Common Market. Surely that is being done because the West German Government realise that with the competition from France in respect of agriculture, it is not wise for them to concentrate even to the present extent on agricultural policy in Germany.
With the advent of the new era, and if Britain goes in, we are also taken in, then as far as I can see there is no help being given to the small farmer and to the families of the working farmer in the south who should be in the forefront of the struggle and who should be given instructions as to the dangers they will have to face if the French and the Danes have free movement into the market in Britain.
We are told by people inside and outside this Chamber that we are defeatists when we draw attention to the dangers that may arise if we enter the Common Market. We have reached the stage now when some self-appointed experts consider that they are the only people who are competent to advise us. I am speaking of people who are not members of any political Party, people who consider themselves experts in these matters. I read recently in a certain newspaper that one of these self-appointed experts on conditions in the Common Market said that any opposition to our entry into that body was based either on gross ignorance or on a highly significant reaction against the principles which inspired the new European union. In other words, you have a person setting himself up as an expert and going around this country like a peacock telling us what we should do. It is time these people learned that this country cannot be run on military lines.
The Labour Party has not at any time said that we should stay out of the Common Market. We know the dangers and we are not saying to the Government that they are the people who must take the risks, that if they fail, we will blame them and if they succeed, we will praise them. We believe that this is something in which we must all row together, in which we must all play our parts together and the sooner these people who attack us because we are being constructive, the people who are strutting around the country like peacocks, learn that they can be done without the better it will be for them.
The Government are inclined to leave everything to the survey teams set up by the Committee on Industrial Organisation. That is not right. I give full credit to the members of that organisation for the work they are doing. I pay tribute to the different survey teams for the work they are doing but it is not sufficient to leave the whole matter to them. The Government must lead. In view of the fact that the report of the survey team into the cotton trade tells us that there may be one-third unemployment in that trade caused by entry into the Common Market, we should look at the other industries. If that is going to happen to the cotton trade what is the Government going to do, before it is too late, to protect the welfare of the people who may be dismissed? If that is going to be so in the cotton trade, what is going to happen in the other branches of industry?
What are the reports of the other survey teams? What we are anxious to know is what the Government are doing now to allay the fears and worries of other workers, whether they are in the cotton trade or any other branch of industry, who may see the danger of unemployment following on Common Market competition facing them in the future. Questions have been asked here as to what the Government are doing towards encouraging the personnel of the different Departments to study Continental languages. What I am interested in is the language used in everyday conversation by the workers when they express their fears as to what will happen to their employment if we enter the Common Market. That is the language and the main theme of conversation of the ordinary man in the street to-day.
That is why we believe it is incumbent on the Taoiseach to give a lead in this matter. Both the Taoiseach and Deputy Dillon lauded the Common Market and pointed out the glorious future that may lie before our agricultural community if we enter it. Is that true? In the case of many agricultural products these countries of the Continent can meet up to 95 and 96 per cent of their own requirements. In such a case what advantage will be offered to our farmers? What reports are coming back from the survey teams on the Continent as to how conditions there are going to affect the agricultural community in this country?
I want to see industry prosper and we all know that industry is going to be placed in a difficult position. We know what the protective duties and tariffs, which are primarily imposed to protect our industries, mean in terms of revenue to the Central Fund. If all that is to go with the coming of the Common Market, what is going to take its place? Employment fell in this country by 62,000 between 1955 and 1961. If that trend continues on our entry into the Common Market and if we lose our income by way of tariffs and protective duties what are we going to get instead of it?
This is too big a question for us to gloss over or to simply decide at the start that we are on one side or the other. We of the Labour Party are anxious to support the Government on this issue because I believe myself that it is for us, those of the younger generation who were too young to take part in the events of 1921, the testing time. We cannot say that because we are in different Parties we are entitled to adopt different attitudes. We are compelled, as Irishmen, to face the issue as it must be faced, but we cannot do that unless the Taoiseach and his Government are prepared to put their cards on the table, are prepared not just to leave it to the survey teams and to the industrialists to work out some system.
The Taoiseach said that he is disappointed with results up to the present time because of the fact that so many industrialists have not availed of the offers given to them. Surely they should be dealt with? We should have the right to ask why no one availed of them. But if we do that, we are accused. If others remain silent, it looks as if they are on their side.
Let the Taoiseach not condemn the workers. Let him not suggest that the eighth round wage increase has been responsible for the rise in the cost of living. Let him understand that we in the Labour Party condemn him for the complete removal of price control, for lecturing the workers for seeking increases in their wages and telling them that they are the culprits. The Taoiseach, the Minister for Transport and Power or any other member of the Cabinet has not drawn attention to the fact that corporation profits tax has increased by 12 per cent, that the bankers are protected by a 13 per cent. increase, that, even though CIE are getting so much money to buy new equipment and their policy is endorsed by the present Minister, they are closing down railway lines all over the country, thus creating more unemployment. In view of all that, I think we have the right to say that during the past twelve months the policy of the Government and the Taoiseach has not been one which benefits the people we represent and has not been fair to the workers.
Comment on this
I suppose it has now come to the time when the Taoiseach can be held to be fully responsible for Government policy. In other years he might have had the excuse that he had just taken over and that it takes a little time for a Prime Minister to make his own impression on the life of his society. I think it can be said without any hesitation that the present Taoiseach has certainly left his own impress on society in Ireland.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
We have seen in operation during his time of office to a remarkable extent the activities of the PRO. The PRO is a new development in democratic politics, probably one of the most pernicious developments in democratic politics in the past 20 or 30 years. When Mr. Kennedy wanted to get his son made President of America he called in the American PROs and achieved that objective. The advertising corporations achieved their objective and the American people got Kennedy as President and 4,000,000 or 5,000,000 unemployed. When Mr. Macmillan wanted to become Prime Minister he brought in Prentiss and Varley, and the British people at the moment are suffering from the repercussions of all this. Equally, we see these people in action white-washing the dictators of Southern Rhodesia, Spain, Portugal and various other countries in order to create a completely false impression of the real life in that society. The approach of the PRO is based on that of the patron saint of PROs, the late and regretted Dr. Goebbels. That was that you keep on repeating the "big lie" through all methods of communication, the newspapers, the economists, the television, the radio, hypocritical and sycophantic political commentators— the integration of the whole machinery of communication in order to put across a completely false picture of any society.
We have seen this happening during the present Taoiseach's regime in a more remarkable way than ever before in the history of the state. The PRO certainly has earned his keep as far as this Government are concerned. Despite the fact that the real structure of society here is substantially unchanged—and I hope to prove that —and that the picture is as it has been over the past 40 years of an old society, falling gradually, steadily and, in recent years, more precipitately into decay, the wonderful achievements of public relations and the perversion of communications have created the impression that, in fact, we have a society which is bubbling over with prosperity, which is surging forward in a completely new and rejuvenated life, particularly in the industrial and in the economic sphere.
This is entirely attributable to the myth created by the commentators of one kind or another, acting as they must do, prepared to say anything, write anything or do anything for the person who pays them the most. But, in spite of their achievements, since the announcement was made that Ireland now faces the prospect of entering into EEC, we are at last facing a terrible moment of truth, a moment of truth when all the front, all the facade, all the fairy tales, all the mythology about industry, about our past and about our future will be completely, ruthlessly and pitilessly exposed, because we are now about to be dragged into the harsh glare of all the competition of European industry.
Here, at home, I do not think anybody has any illusions. I do not think any of the ordinary members of the public have any illusions that the Government have completely lost control over the prices of even the most ordinary articles of consumption. Any visitor from Britain, or anywhere else, will tell you that he simply could not live in Ireland on the salary he finds adequate in England, or elsewhere. That is because of the price of food, the price of clothing, the cost of transport, of boots and shoes, and of the various ordinary articles of everyday use. There has been a complete stripping away of all semblance of price control. That was the decision of the Taoiseach, a confirmed believer in the efficacy of the dynamic of private enterprise and so-called free competition.
As we heard here at Question Time, there is no such thing as free competition. Free competition just does not exist. Instead there are cartels, monopolistic practices, rings, and so forth, of all kinds, to which the consumer falls a victim, a victim in the fact that he has to pay artificially high prices in order to ensure that artificially high profits are made, and will continue to be made, by a minority. That is the policy, even when it comes to the provision of the simplest and most basic essential needs of the ordinary men and women in our society. This is the end result of the working out of the Taoiseach's faith in private-enterprise capitalism.
We see it all now exposed as it was never before exposed because of this fortuitous event, the Common Market. Every time I have spoken I have said many of the things I am saying now, and which I will repeat again, but this time the charges that I make will not be merely personal indictments of the type of society created by the Taoiseach and by the Opposition when they were in power. My indictments are today backed by the confirmation of inquiries and commissions, established perforce by the Taoiseach and by the Government as a result of this fortuitous event, and the decision that we must now go into the Common Market.
The remarkable thing is, as I said, this extraordinary euphoria, this extraordinary sense of well-being, this extraordinary belief that everything in our society is prosperous, that things were never better. This is a particularly wonderful achievement in a society in which the Government cannot find enough money to give a proper education to the vast majority of its citizens. This boom does not allow us enough money to give our people proper health services. This is the boom society which tells the aged person that he can starve to death on 32/6 a week. Surely all this is a negation of the proposition that this is a prosperous society.
It is a prosperous society. It is prosperous for a wealthy minority. The whole economic organisation of our society has, since the beginning, been dedicated to creating this wealthy minority and, having created it, to giving them all the privileges of wealth, access to the universities, access to the best hospitals and nursing homes, access to the best in everything, access to plenty, and old age, with dignity, when the time comes to grow old and retire. But all this is for a wealthy minority. That is the privileged society we now have. The Taoiseach is an extremely intelligent man and he knew what he was doing; this is the end product of what he had in mind for Ireland when he joined the freedom movement to create an independent society here.
We have quite clearly got a serious discrepancy between the standard of living of the wealthy minority and the standard of living of the mass of our people. In addition, we still have a considerable number of unemployed, fewer than there were but, as Deputy Dillon pointed out, it is very difficult in a small society, such as ours, for people to continue to emigrate from a continually shrinking society. It is very difficult, too, to keep up a high level of unemployment in a continually shrinking society. The important thing is the number of jobs now available, the important thing is the number of people now in work, and the number in work six or seven years ago.
In addition to all this, we have seen here the mark of the Taoiseach on industrial relations. We had the introduction by him of the totalitarian fascist legislation directed against the electricians when they wanted to take industrial action and withdraw their labour. We well remember the complete debacle—again fortuitous—in which this effort ended. The TUC would not stand for it. They issued a statement to that effect and they made the Taoiseach, in one of the most humiliating episodes I remember in public life, climb down. He came in in the morning, a complete autocrat, thumping the table and threatening five years in jail for the whole lot of us; it was only the workers, but also the trade union representatives, and anyone who advocated strike action. At eight or nine o'clock that night, the legislation was thrown out. The important thing was that it did give most of us a window on the mind. It did give us some idea of his attitude.
We have this autocracy where it comes to the right of the individual to withdraw labour if he feels he is not sufficiently remunerated, the negation of this right where he is concerned, and then this absolute rejection of the suggestion at any time that there should be an attempt at price control, dividend restriction, profit restriction. That any of these people who make money out of other people's work should be asked to curb their income, their profits, their dividends, is unthinkable to the Taoiseach, his attitude being that they have a right to whatever they can get—whatever you can get is right. We see the development of a society here where there is no limit to the amount of money which a man can get, a society in which he is facilitated by the refusal of the Government to act in order to curb prices even in respect of essential commodities.
The attitude of the Government has remained unchanged in spite of the fact that the Government know full well that in regard to the circulation of essential commodities there are restrictive trading practices of one kind or another. No action has been taken in order to try to restrict inflationary trends at that stage by restricting prices, restricting dividends, restricting profits. The approach by the Taoiseach has always been to try to restrict what he calls inflationary trends by curbing the income of the worker.
Now we hear that, having made a serious miscalculation in attacking the trade union leaders with the workers at that time, he realises that is a serious miscalculation and he is not going to do it again and this time he appears to want to or intends to bring the trade union leaders along with him in order to try to bring in here restrictive legislation of some kind or another for the purpose of refusing the worker the right to withdraw his labour if he feels he is not being sufficiently well or adequately compensated for what work he is doing so that he will have enough money to pay for the education, the clothing, the feeding and the housing of his family. However, that is something for the future. It will have to be fought then.
We have seen also with the Taoiseach the attitude concerning mineral development where the general principle has been accepted that we will not develop our own mineral resources, that we have allowed foreign countries to come in here and to take whatever mineral riches we have and bring them to their own country. All we ask as our contribution is some compensation for the landowner and then employment at mining workers' wages during the period when these riches will be taken out, when the countryside will be raped of the small mineral resources we have. That is all that we ask out of it. He has played for Ireland, I suppose it would be right to say, the Mr. Tshombe, the stooge of the Union Miniére in Katanga. He has played much the same part, unlike some of the other emergent countries. God knows, we should no longer be called an emergent country. Algeria has done its best. There have been Nasser, Nkrumah, Nehru, Mrs. Bandaranaike. Most of these other countries have attempted to see that if they have any mineral resources at all, these mineral resources are developed for the benefit of their own people and not in order, according as the share rises, to give quick money to Canadians, Americans, Swedes, British or any other outsiders. These countries, when they look for capital abroad, have tried and have many times succeeded in getting their capital without strings and the first thing they set out to do was to develop whatever mineral resources they have for their own people.
We, surely, should not have continued to have the intinn sclábhaíochta attitude to ourselves and our own people, our own technicians and technocrats, our physicians, scientists, physicists and mathematicians. Surely we have got to the stage now where it is possible for us to take on any worthwhile enterprise? If it is worth the Canadian's trouble to come to Ireland and go down to Mayo and Galway and take silver, lead or whatever it may be out of it, why cannot our own people do this? Why cannot we find the money?
The Taoiseach has often said, the Minister for Finance has often proved, that every time he has gone to the people looking for money for any worthwhile developmental project his loans are oversubscribed. He has repeatedly declared, and has a certain amount of right to have pride in it, that his loans are oversubscribed. The public is ready to make this money available. The riches are there; the technicians are there. Why do we bring in these outsiders? Why do we not do these things ourselves? Why is it that we have to reverse the world trend, particularly the trend in the Afro-Asian countries? They are getting rid of the people who exploited them physically or economically. They are getting rid of them and we are inviting them back. The reoccupation of Ireland is going on.
But, all of this is of relative unimportance when we consider the decision of the Government to look for full membership of the Common Market. Our position is rather unique in so far as we are looking for membership of the Common Market. We are not members of NATO and we were not members of the European Free Trade Association. Consequently, it seemed to us that this decision must be one taken only after the greatest care, naturally, but the greatest care particularly to examine what would be the best bargain, putting it crudely, for Ireland and for our people.
We get the impression that the Taoiseach has not examined all the possibilities sufficiently carefully and we also get the impression that the Taoiseach has entertained this whole idea with an overwhelming inferiority complex. His attitude appears to be that, right or wrong, good or evil, success or failure, we are going into this Common Market and, what is worse, we are going into this Common Market on any terms and, what is worse still, with regard to the extension of the idea of the Common Market as an economic unit to being a political unit and a unit involving defence commitments, we are now accepting the second and third conditions unconditionally. As far as I know—and I have tried very hard to get as much information as I could from the Taoiseach on this—when we looked for membership of the Common Market under the Rome Treaty, we were simply committed to join an economic unit of unity in Europe. We now know that this has been expanded very considerably and in an underhand way, to include membership of a political unit and membership of some kind of defence pact.
Could we ask why we did not seriously consider the possibility of joining EEC as associate members? The Taoiseach made it clear in his White Paper that it was possible to become a member by association rather than to become a full member and in so far as the position is not completely clarified—there is no blueprint of detailed conditions of associate membership—he quoted the position in relation to Greece, an under-developed society which felt it could not accept full membership. I cannot see what objection we could have had to considering seriously taking membership on the Greek pattern. It is regrettable that we need it, but I think everybody will agree that we do need as long a period as possible before getting rid of all our protective tariffs. I may have more to say about that but, accepting the reality of the situation, I think we should look for the longest possible period for dismantlement of tariffs, even if it is only in order to protect the workers in their employment.
In respect of a special list of products which includes almost all the industrial products of Greece, they got an extended transitional period of 22 years. They were given certain rights in regard to the imposition of customs duties or increasing existing ones up to 25 per cent of certain imports from EEC countries. They had access to the European Investment Bank. They had certain conditions granted to them in relation to agricultural commodities. In the case of certain agricultural products of major interest to the Greek colonies, the Community would appear to have agreed to grant broadly the terms that apply to the same products in Member States. On this analogy, a new applicant for association might expect special terms for its more important products.
Perhaps the Taoiseach would be more specific about it, but, broadly speaking, if one takes our industrial and agricultural products and our right of access to the European Investment Bank, it would appear it is possible to negotiate some sort of agreement which would not interfere with our country or Greece, as the case in point, and which would create a viable industrial and agricultural economy. One of the important things in relation to associate membership of the EEC is the fluidity of the conditions. There is no clear-cut blueprint. In fact, that is one of the things the Taoiseach said about it, that it was difficult to say what would precisely be implied in associate membership, but it is clear there is scope for negotiating in regard to industrial and agricultural products and in regard to any loans we might want. It is capable of adaptation to suit our special needs and now that we have heard that Sweden and a number of EFTA countries have agreed to accept association, it is very difficult to see why we cannot accept it rather than complete membership, with all the very serious implications for industry and possibly for agriculture which may ensue from it.
The only one point which I think could be made is in relation to the voting powers in the EEC. The associated country has no voting powers but the position in regard to votes is that the three major countries, Germany, France and Italy—and presumably Britain when she becomes a member—have four votes each; Belgium and the Netherlands have two votes each and Luxembourg has one vote. I presume we would be in with Luxembourg with one vote. In regard to voting on matters of policy, economic, foreign or industrial policy, in the early stages the decisions must be unanimous, but as time progresses, I understand voting will be by means of a qualified majority. Therefore, there is very little likelihood that we shall have any real say in the formulation of policy by the EEC powers, and this apparent position of authority, power to vote, is merely a shadow or has little substance. It is hardly worth the other very serious penalties we are likely to have to pay, if we accept entry into the Common Market as a full member.
I should like to ask the Taoiseach whether having considered the question of associate membership, it would be possible to get the same conditions for Ireland in relation to agricultural and industrial products as it appears the British are holding out for on behalf of the other Commonwealth countries. Would it have been possible for us to have looked for and achieved a special position comparable with the position which is being bargained for in relation to the Commonwealth countries and would that have been a satisfactory position from our point of view? It is one which is apparently of great concern to the Commonwealth and presumably they will have to make other arrangements for the disposal of their surpluses. I cannot see why, if we were given enough time, we should not be able to make similar adaptations and why we should not get much the same sort of conditions if we look for them.
It is clear now, and it has become clearer since the interview given by the Taoiseach to the New York newspaper, that there are three different components of membership—one, economic, two, political and three, defence commitments. I do not think there is any doubt in anybody's mind now that this is the most serious decision we have taken probably in the lifetime of any of us, if we go into the European Economic Community. It is quite clear from the text of the Rome Treaty and the other agreements into which we intend to enter that we will accept for Ireland interference in the rights of this Parliament to decide finally in regard to its own economic policy—possibly its political and its defence policies, but certainly in relation to its economic policy.
We have recently seen an example of this when the Belgian Government was forbidden to carry out semi-nationalisation of its coal mining industry. They were told this infringed the Rome Treaty and their Parliament had to reverse the decision and had to become subordinate to the supra-national Parliament now being established under the EEC. Are we quite satisfied that whatever gains we get out of membership—a minority membership—of this organisation is worth the great sacrifices we shall have to make?
Already we have seen ourselves sacrifice our uncommitted position in the United Nations Organisation. It is quite clear now that Deputy Aiken, who is talking today and who spoke three or four years ago as our Minister for External Affairs, is a completely different man. He is taking sides pretty consistently nowadays with the former colonial powers. One of the things which created the aura of independence about our delegation in the United Nations was the fact that we were always found on the side of the newly-emergent countries—the peoples who were just getting on to their feet as a result of the evacuation of whatever colonial powers were kicked out of a particular country. We showed ourselves to Nkrumah, Mboya, Nehru—above all, the greatest independent politician in the world today —as people who could take an independent stand.
We took an independent stand with those people and when they took a particular stand, we sided with them. We could be accepted by them as not being tied as an old tin can to a dog's tail, to the dictates of the Americans, the British, the French or the Belgians who may be indicted before the United Nations at any time. Quite clearly in relation to the Congo, we did not take an independent stand in respect to the position of Patrice Lumumba when we allowed him to be harried, hunted, humiliated and finally shot by the Belgian colonialists.
It was clear afterwards there was positive action we could have taken at that time, if we had not succumbed to the pressure put on us by the Belgian, British and American financial interests in the Katanga copper mines. It was afterwards shown clearly that it was possible in certain circumstances to use force in order to deal with and bring to heel the quisling Tshombe. But we did not take any part in such an act until it was too late, until the only worthwhile leader the Congolese might have had, Lumumba, was shot. Then, we took action.
Again, it was quite clear that our troops in the Congo were saved probably from very serious results, possibly the death of a number of them, not by the action of Deputy Aiken as our Minister for External Affairs or of the Government acting under the Taoiseach, but by the action of Dr. Conor Cruise O'Brien, an independent civil servant who had to resign rather than continue to follow policies which he knew were in contradiction to those which should have been followed by a society such as ours. Both the Minister for External Affairs, who was the Minister primarily responsible, and the Taoiseach stood over the sacking of this civil servant, one of the finest we have ever had, and saw the disappearance of Dr. O'Brien and Miss MacEntee from the Civil Service and later from Ireland altogether.
A country which can dispense with people of such high calibre is a country certainly which places a very poor value on people of integrity, people of honour, and it is a very poor comment on the Government that they allowed that civil servant to be humiliated in that way in the United Nations, without raising a single word in his defence.
I do not think anybody should have any illusions about the real meaning of the Common Market. It has its purposes, as far as I can see. The first of them is the fact that European capitalists, private enterprise, whatever you like to call them, found the national boundaries of their own countries did not allow them to take as great profits within their own boundaries as they might take if they could get us all into a nice consortium of nations in which they were free to rob and pillage as they saw fit under the rules of the Rome Treaty.
It is quite clear that Imperial Chemicals Incorporated, Courtaulds and all the other British, German, French and Italian monopolies are not in the slightest interested in creating a society in which the mass of the people will get a better life. They are interested in profits; they will sell anything for profits. They have shown that in the past. They make war for profits; they make explosives for profits; they make guns for profits; they kill people for profits. This is not an idealised version of this group of central European industrialists get- ting together and saying: "We can make things better for our people". What they say is: "Let us get together and make things better for ourselves. Let us get into a tidy, neat cartel through which we can have access to the whole of Europe for markets and can protect ourselves by cartelised arrangements".
What is happening in the Common Market and what is going to happen there is mirrored every day in most of our towns and villages—the supermarket. The supermarket is gobbling up, one after the other, the little gombeen shops which admittedly never had competition anyway because they were subject to restrictive trade practices. The unfortunate consumer is under the impression that this is in his interest, that it will mean lower prices, cleaner and quicker service and be an administrative improvement on the gombeen shops. Nothing could be further from the truth. There is a trade-war, a cut-price war, going on but only for the simple reason that they wish to put these people who are possible competitors out of business. That achieved, a monopolistic position will be reached and the prices will go back to the former high level and the public will then be the hunted animal, fair game, open season all the year round, any price you can get. We heard this at Question Time today: it was fair enough to buy at 15 and sell at 50. That was a fair profit—a fair profit was whatever you could get.
This is the so-called private enterprise capitalism. But returning to the comparison, the little gombeen shop in the Common Market happens to be us, Ireland, because anybody with a grain of sense knows that none of the fiddling industries—and the majority of them are fiddling—which we have here will be able to stand on their feet against the competition of international cartels. When you see ICI and Courtaulds huddling together for safety——
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
They are economically frightened of Eastern Europe and they have a right to be frightened about the industrial expansion there. They try to get together in order to get a little help from the members of this concern. That is the sole purpose of it.
The Taoiseach has very much wider knowledge of all these things than I have, and greater experience. He must know this is happening also. It is beyond me to understand why the Taoiseach is continuing to carry on as he is, why he has not examined every possible alternative because he must know that—while there will be marginal expansion here and there and some of the British parent firms may hang on in Ireland—the general body of them are too frightened of their own position in Britain to bother about what goes on in a subordinate factory here. It is inevitable that most of our industries will go to the wall. I get no pleasure in saying this. That will happen mainly because somebody has said—not a person on my side of the fence but some economist of the Government—that redundancy rates would be something in the region of 100,000 of the population, or 60,000 redundant and 40,000 normally unemployed, within a ten-year period of adaptation.
This is very frightening. The Taoiseach does not appear to have given it any serious consideration. Neither have we seen any serious reference to it by any of the committees set up by the Taoiseach. What is to happen to the people who become redundant? Have the Government become so complacent about emigration at a high level that this is their secret weapon, that they are filtering these people out continually through the mail boat to be used as cheap labour in countries with a labour shortage such as Germany and that by doing this, we shall conceal the fact that the nation is dying, that it is going completely out of existence and that it is all due to the fact that the Taoiseach personally in the '30's made the great miscalculation, the great blunder of saying in regard to a number of industries: "We will accept the principle of public ownership and control"?
May I, in parenthesis, explain the difference between public ownership as he knows it and as we want it. Public ownership, as the Taoiseach likes it, is where the public pays for the particular concern he is operating; as we want it, is where the public not only pay but control the operation of the particular industry.
The Taoiseach decided in respect of a few public utilities that we should accept the idea. In these cases it may have been thought it was not possible for private enterprise to make a profit quickly enough. I do not think he regrets it, and to the extent to which these industries are good, efficient and prosperous undertakings which he started, I give him full credit. But he made the big blunder of deciding that our people could not provide the personnel and the know-how in order to start off in private enterprise in the textile industry, in the ordinary sort of consumer industry. He handed those over to private enterprise capitalists. This development followed. It was resisted. The people who did go into Irish industry did so reluctantly. They had been associated with the Ascendancy class, they were agents, perhaps, of British firms and were making a nice, easy living and having a good time because they had their houses and cars and everything they needed. They did not want to change.
We made them change and they did it reluctantly but they also did it in a particular pattern. The pattern was that instead of buying the stuff and getting 6 per cent. for distributing it, they set up subsidiary factories and distributed from them instead of from the quays. They really carried out the same business as before, except that they called it an industry instead of a warehouse. Most of our industries were subsidiaries of British companies and we had this particular kind of wealthy individual running them who was not associated with the nationalist movement and who was now in complete control. Of course, they took in puppets, the Tshombes, the Quislings, the Paddy Murphys and so was established Irish industry.
They said that if they were to establish Irish industry, they should have complete protection from outside competition. They got that. Then they said that they would have to have complete protection on the home market and they were allowed that. The consumer was charged anything these people wished to charge. The Restrictive Trade Practices Act has been talked about by the Government but as far as the consumer is concerned, the Restrictive Trade Practices Act has no visible affect on restrictive trading in Irish industry. The consumer is at the complete mercy of these people who can charge anything they want to charge for all their commodities.
The result is alleged to be the creation of a viable industrial arm. That is not so and that is now being said by the Minister's investigators. These people did not have to become efficient and they are much less efficient than outside concerns. They did not have to worry about outside markets or about competition. The question of creating an industrial arm in Ireland which would employ all our people did not enter their minds. It did not worry them. So we had the stagnation of industry caused by neglect, by protection, by inefficiency, by not employing anything like the total number of people who should be employed, whose numbers were increased by the large numbers of people coming from rural Ireland because of the change in our system of agriculture.
This is the Taoiseach's creature. He must see that. I wonder does he accept it as that? I grant that he has been successful with some concerns, Aer Lingus, Bord na Móna and the ESB. They are outstanding successes, a feature of public ownership, State capitalism, if you wish. But surely these are the only concerns of which he can be proud in the slightest way, now that we have come up to the moment of truth in Ireland, to the exposure of the mythology of the past 40 years. These State-sponsored bodies are well staffed and well managed on the whole. I say that although I may occasionally criticise their activities. They give good service and are amenable to a reasonable extent to us in this House. They are far superior in every way one looks at it to the truncated body of so-called Irish industry.
The Taoiseach made his mistake then and we will now pay very dearly for it. I do not think the average Irish industrialist is the slightest bit anxious to go into the Common Market. The average Irish industrialist should be terrified at the prospect of competition in the Common Market, except for those who, because of their financial association with outside companies, will not suffer in any way because they will continue to draw dividends and make profits from their association with these outside companies, even though the Irish company may have closed down and the Irish worker be thrown on the street. That is one of the reasons why they are not greatly moved by the prospect of joining the Common Market and of 100,000 unemployed workers. They do not have to worry.
I have said that for many years and the Taoiseach cannot have got much comfort from the Commission which he himself established in order to examine the position. We have the statement of the position in that Commission's report or are they, too, being unfair to Irish industries? Are these industries all the things the publicists and economists tell us they are, all the political commentators tell us they are, all the Taoiseach and his colleagues tell us they are?
The report of the Committee on industrial organisation, in page 4, deals with the problems now facing us on the eve of entry to the Common Market. It says:
The problems that can be classified under the heading of preventative adaptation are posed by small size of firms, short production runs, under utilisation of productive capacity, lack of vertical integration, inadequate mechanisation, relatively high costs per unit of output, poor design of Irish goods, lack of marketing organisation abroad, cut-throat competition between Irish firms in foreign markets, and transition to more specialised production. These causes of uncompetitiveness may be removed, or made to operate with less strength.
Why were they not removed before now? If you are concerned with selling a cheap quality article in the European market, why could you not have taken steps to do that before now? If they are to be asked to do it now, why were they not asked to do it before now? Why did we allow and continue to allow the home consumer to be mulcted by these people's inefficiency, selfishness, failure to modernise and to increase production? Why is it that they now have to be kicked into it by the imminence of competition from the European cartels in the Common Market? These people entrusted by the Taoiseach with the creation of a just and prosperous society here, these private enterprise capitalists, are now faced with redundancy in the region of 60,000 or 70,000 of our people having to be thrown out of their jobs and with the prospect of factories closing down. On investigation, to find out what these people are doing, the Committee on Industrial Organisation go on to say at paragraph 10:
Is additional aid needed? If by this question is meant: could the changes be effected without additional aid, then the answer may well be “yes”. A more important question is: would the necessary changes be undertaken by a large enough proportion of Irish industry and in good time without additional aid, and the answer to this question is, in the Committee's view, “no”.
These are the fellows who have been feather-bedded for the past 40 years by the taxpayers, apologies being made for them, defended here by every Minister in every Government Department, whitewash applied with unlimited liberality at every possible opportunity —rotarian dinners, chambers of commerce, openings of factories—nothing but paeans of praise for these people.
Now they are faced with being put out of business and with redundancy at an unprecedented rate. Will they do something about it? According to a Government inquiry, published by the Stationery Office, set up by the Minister for Industry and Commerce—not damn likely! This is private enterprise for you. They have no intention of doing a thing, not unless they are aided by the taxpayer—this unfortunate, hunted animal, whom they have raped and robbed over the years through the protection of Government policy, subsidised by means of tariffs. Now the public are to be asked once again to come to the rescue of these people and to provide them with aid, further subsidisation, further financial assistance. These people certainly have had jam on both sides when it comes to the activities of the Taoiseach and the Government.
Another committee on industrial organisation, the committee dealing with the cotton, linen and rayon industry, had this to say: "Production costs of Irish firms are higher than in Britain and higher still than on the Continent." Of course, everybody knows British industry is incompetent and inefficient. It is private enterprise and capitalistic, too. In fact, we have all the inherent inadequacies of British capital operating here in Ireland. They were invited in by the Taoiseach. It is no surprise to any of us to find they are inefficient. They are inefficient over there as well. That is why they are terrified of the Common Market, even with their great factories. Anyway, even here they do not operate as efficiently as the parent firm. Why should they? They are protected here against competition in the home and export markets.
The Committee found that export prices are lower than home prices. Why should that be? Why is that, will the Taoiseach say? Profit margins from exports are smaller than those on home sales. Why should they be allowed to overcharge the home consumer? Then, I suppose, in some form they subsidise their exports from profits made on their home sales. They say that one of the difficulties facing us in the Common Market was that our exports to western European countries were not on any appreciable scale and are not likely to be within the competence of Irish mills. Again, that is published by the Stationery Office, a report of a committee set up by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That committee certainly could not be accused of any leftist or socialist ideas. I certainly was not a member of that organisation. That is what responsible committees established by the Government tell us is the state of Irish industry on the eve of our entry into European competition. These are the facts exposed by these people and supported by argument.
For fear that is not enough, we have added evidence. One of the decisions taken by Córas Tráchtála was to ask an independent body of Scandinavian experts to come here, look at Irish industry and tell us what they thought of it. These were people utterly outside any home influence, people of completely objective view, people of the highest international standing. This was conceded by the Minister for Industry and Commerce himself. There could be no question of any bias or any attempt on their part to condemn Irish industry just for the sake of doing so. They went to various industries and, as experts, examined them rapidly. But they did examine them and they found in relation to woollen woven fabrics, suitings, textiles, textile printing, cultivation machinery, glass, graphics, printed books, packaging, furniture, souvenirs, metal work—in relation to all of these things, the comment was the same: standard poor; low standard; neglected; no worthwhile designs; chosen from the parasite patterns of Europe. I will not weary the House by reading the report of these experts from Scandinavian countries. It was a most forthright and frightening condemnation, covering practically any worthwhile industry in the country. They had nothing but contempt and condemnation for everything they found.
These are facts which the Taoiseach simply has to read. He does not have to listen to them from me. He has them from his own people and he has them from outside. Yet as I said at the beginning, we have been subjected to a persistent, unending barrage of praise for the upsurge of prosperity and expansion in Irish industry. It is supposed to be throbbing with activity and dynamism. There is no limit to what it can reach. That is all demonstrable rubbish. It is the Taoiseach, who knows this better than anybody else, who has contributed to the creation of this myth of Irish industry and who has done nothing to expose it—nothing to tell these people, not today, tomorrow, or the day after, but five, ten or 20 years ago, that they were to operate in the best interest, not of themselves as individuals or family firms, but of the bulk of the Irish people and that, if they did not do that, we would operate these things ourselves, as we have shown we are competent to do in regard to those few companies to which I paid tribute to the Taoiseach for having started.
Surely nothing exposes better than anything else the complete fallacy of the view that private enterprise capitalism could be successfully operated here in Ireland. It has been operated here in Ireland under optimum conditions. Its promoters had every protection; they had every support. There was no question of any interference of any kind with them, except for the short period of the war years. Yet, this is the end product of their 30 years of activity. We are now in the position of going into this highly competitive market without a viable industrial arm. It is quite clear we have not got one. An economist has given it as his opinion that 60 per cent of our industries will go to the wall after we enter the Common Market. That seems to be a reasonable computation. It is a sad computation in many ways, but saddest from the point of view of the men and women who will be thrown out of work because of this failure on the part of industry here, because of this great blunder committed by the Taoiseach in the thirties in entrusting industry here to these people, people who had no real interest in the furtherance of the welfare of our people or the establishment of a viable industrial arm.
Everybody makes mistakes. What has been the theme song all along? "We have not got the know-how; we have not got the marketing ability; we have not got the export contacts." Surely that, if anything, demonstrates the intinn sclábhíochta, the slave mind approach where our own competence was concerned. Surely that should come to an end now. These people had everything. They had the know-how. They had the capital. They had the export contacts. They had access to the foreign markets. They had everything, and here they are, to-day, in decay, under-mechanised, no automation, with out-of-date machinery, and, everybody is agreed, grossly inefficient. These are the people in whom the Taoiseach put all his trust. Will he continue to do so? Are we to continue going around the world, to the Canadians, the Americans, the Swedes, the Danes, the Dutch, the British, and all the others, asking them to come over here and run our affairs for us? Is it not time we said we could do that ourselves?
Let me remind the Taoiseach of the old Sinn Féin idea—self-sufficiency. It was very wrong in many aspects, but basically it was instinctively right. If we had tried, and failed, at least we would now have the satisfaction of knowing it was we who had failed and that the failure was our own fault. But we cannot even say that about ourselves. Those whom we invited in failed on our behalf. They betrayed the people. They helped in large measure to create a society in which it is not possible to give every child a proper education, the sick proper health services, the aged more than 32/6 a week. This is not fortuitous. This is not an act of God. This is the result of the failure of our industrial policy over the past 30 years. The Scandinavian countries have shown that it is possible to create in a free society a social and economic pattern which allows people to retain many of the things they like, the democratic ideas they cherish, and, at the same time, which ensures to the people that they do not suffer in consequence of adopting that particular economic and social pattern.
It is quite clear now that the Taoiseach's greatest blunder was his failure to exploit to the full our natural resources of land, labour and capital, his failure to accept full responsibility for our own people to do things for ourselves in every aspect of our economy and our society. It is quite clear now that most of the emergent African countries are implementing just such a policy—some form of socialism, some form of public ownership, in order to reap the optimum value from the exploitation of whatever natural resources these countries have.
I want to deal now with another aspect of our membership of the Common Market. It arises out of the admission by the Taoiseach concerning defence. We must now face, in this proposed membership of the European Economic Community, certain defence commitments. I do not want to take up the time of the House going through the many questions asked here by Deputy McQuillan and myself, and by Deputy Corish also, in order to try to elicit what the precise position would be in regard to defence commitments. The Taoiseach was, to put it as its very mildest, less than frank with us.
The general belief we had was that we were joining some kind of economic organisation and that that would probably lead to certain political commitments, but that all we were asking for was membership of the EEC under the Rome Treaty, subscribing to the provisions of that Treaty. We now find that the Taoiseach has given an undertaking, an undertaking he refused to give at any time up to this here in this House, as reported in the New York Times on 18th July of this year: it is the report of an interview. The Taoiseach is reported as saying:
We are prepared to go into an integrated union without any reservations at all as to how far this will take us in the field of foreign policy or defence commitments.
As far as the Taoiseach's public statements are concerned, he never went as far as that in any of his statements to this House.
He was asked directly on a number of occasions by many of us, right up to and including today when he was questioned on the Spaak statement that defence commitments were indispensable or inevitable in the European Community; Dr. Birkelbach made much the same charge. Yet, at no time did the Taoiseach make an unequivocal, clear-cut statement such as that reported in the New York Times, an undertaking that, no matter what we are asked to do, we will do it without any reservations. It may be the positioning of nuclear bases here, polaris or land bases; it may be the provision of military installations; it may be to provide training facilities for British, German, French, or any other troops of member countries of EEC; it may be to provide facilities for rocket bases; it may be to provide facilities for aircraft establishments; all these things, without any reservations, and in anticipation, as far as one can gather, of any request from EEC or the Member countries.
The Taoiseach has given an undertaking now that we are prepared to enter into defence commitments. These will, of course, include the sending of our troops to Europe, should they be needed in furtherance of a defence commitment entered into in relation to our proposed entry into the Common Market organisation and in anticipation of such entry. I believe this —I have believed this all along—that the Taoiseach has—I do not want to use harsh words—certainly given undertakings which it was not within his competence to give at this stage. The Taoiseach has said that he discussed the proposal in relation to the Common Market during the election. He has given us to understand that because he discussed the proposals for the Common Market in the general election, he has now a mandate for any decision he proposes or intends to take.
He has considerably exceeded any authority which he has from the Irish people by giving any of the undertakings which are implicit in this statement made to the New York Times that without any reservations at all as to how far this will take us in the field of foreign policy or defence commitments, we are prepared to go. He has no authority whatsoever for making that statement. He at no time in the general election discussed in detail the political commitments involved in the Common Market and at no time at all during the election did he give us to understand that we are now bound, or would be likely to be bound, to accept certain defence commitments as members of the European Economic Community.
In reply to a series of questions by a number of us here, the Taoiseach said—Volume 195 of the Official Report:
The Government will accept nothing that it does not know all about.
Deputy McQuillan said:
The Taoiseach has already said that he accepted the political and defence objectives.
The Taoiseach replied:
I did not say that.
I said:
The Taoiseach has already said that he will accept the political and defence commitments in the Common Market. How will he get out of that now?
The Taoiseach replied:
I did not say that.
He is asked again in another question in relation to nuclear weapons— Column 1165, Volume 194—would he be prepared to accept the positioning of nuclear bases in this country and the Taoiseach said: "Certainly not." Then he went on:
Indeed, I understand that fixed nuclear bases are now obsolete.
And he got a titter from the back benches for that.
Comment on this
Clearly we believed all along that the Taoiseach had sold out this country in exchange for a commercial transaction. It was completely clear to us that he had without authority betrayed the people to these defence commitments I have mentioned, a most scandalous betrayal of his position as Taoiseach, for which we will ultimately, I hope, be able to make him answerable because I do not believe that in any suggestion that we should enter into defence commitments involving the provision of polaris bases, nuclear bases, the provision of troop facilities, training facilities for troops, air force establishments of one kind and another, he has any authority from the people to give these undertakings as he now has given them to a newspaper man outside this country and in direct refutation of every attempt we have made here in the House to try to make him admit this. We believed it to be true. We tried to make him admit it but he refused to do it on every possible occasion. That is simply a clear betrayal of his position as Taoiseach.
The only real inkling, I suppose, that we have had in this regard came from the speech of the Minister for Lands in which he made it fairly clear to us that we must join NATO if we were to get membership of the Common Market. He pointed out that the EFTA countries were not members of NATO and consequently could not get full membership, that we must accept the general commitments involved in joining with a group of nations who were themselves members of NATO. This implied that we must also become members of NATO. Then he tried to create the impression that our country had decided that we must take a part, that we must abandon this position of neutrality in regard to world affairs, this position of deciding on the merits of an issue as we saw it and not be biased by adherence to one or other side in the cold war, that we must abandon this position and must now take sides in Europe.
I do not think that it is a decision taken out of any finer impulses whatsoever. It is a completely hypocritical pose on the part of the Government to pretend that we are now determining to take sides in the cold war against Russia, that we believe that we must throw in our contribution in order to halt the onrush of atheistic communism. I think this is so much humbug, hypocritical humbug of the highest order I have heard for many years in listening to concentrated hypocrisy in this House and outside it from speakers on both sides of the House on this particular issue.
We are proposing to join with a number of nations in a defence act which is aimed against the Eastern European states and the Communist States. I have no brief for either side but I can tell you that if I were in the land mass of Europe and had facing me across my frontiers the German people who on no less than two occasions have raped and plundered and pillaged Europe and its people, I should be very slow to withdraw my arms, dismantle my defences and feel that I am perfectly safe with these people, that having done it twice in the past 40 years, they will not do it again. Why not? Who thinks they will not? Who has a right to think they will not? We are joining with France, the torturers of Algeria. These are the crusaders on the white chargers threshing their way across Europe to hunt the barbarian. We are joining with Belgium— Belgium that murdered the unfortunate Lumumba on his knees saying his prayers, blowing the back of his head off—Belgium!
We are going to liberate humanity with the Belgians and the French and the Germans and the Fascist Italians and the British of Suez. These are our new allies. Whom do the Taoiseach, the Minister for Lands and others think they are fooling? The record is against these people. If there are atrocities, there are atrocities on both sides. It there is Hungary, there is also Angola. If there are the atrocities of Suez, there are the atrocities of Algeria, the atrocities of Salazar, his prisons full. Franco, another of our fellow crusaders, has his prisons full.
Surely nobody will have the temerity to suggest that this union of European States is designed to further democratic freedoms or the Christian ideal in Europe? If this is the Christian ideal in Europe as practised by these people in their day-to-day lives with the people depending on them in Angola, in Egypt, in Africa, in India, in Ceylon, in Ireland, in Algeria, no wonder the world is turning its back on Christianity.
Nobody can tell me that when I join with these people, I am joining people whose hands are clean. These people are steeped in blood, steeped in tyranny, steeped in torture. They are rotted with decadence. They can offer us nothing, and to put forward this NATO alliance is anything else is a complete prostitution of the truth. I say that to these crusaders here, the Taoiseach and his friends who want us to join NATO and the Opposition who want us to join NATO.
I should like to pay tribute to one man in this House—he will probably be surprised—Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon was the only man who has been consistent in this House in the past 30 years. In 1939, he was pitched out of his Party because he wanted to fight Fascism. I do not know whether he wanted to fight Fascism or not or whether he was merely pro-British. I shall give him the benefit of the doubt. At least he wanted to make a stand and he thought we should make a stand. What I am saying is that when we got the chance to fight the barbaric excesses of Nazi Germany—six million people of all kinds incinerated, children, men and women depraved and humiliated—we got together and, with the exception of Deputy Dillon, to put it in Christian terms, we passed by on the other side: Let Hitler get on with his gas chambers. Let him roam Europe and let his soldiers get on with their butchery and savagery.
Cumann na nGaedheal, Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil and, I understand, the Labour Party all got together and said: "We shall take no part in this." Indeed we were particularly conscientious in the exercise of our neutrality. Take the censorship of publication. If an Irish boy died fighting against Nazism and Fascism, we were not told he was shot by a German—no: "He died." We did not want to recognise the nonconformists who were defending the name of Irish people on these foreign battle fields. Now Deputy Lemass and all his Cabinet colleagues who were there at the time are asking us to join in a European campaign against whatever barbarism there happens to be now, Communism. They should have some little regard and respect for the intelligence of our people.
What has happened in between? Did we believe in Nazism? Are we all neo-Nazis? Does it add up to our concept of Christianity? Now we are to join with the Germans who had a lunatic dictator whom they followed for so long, with the Italians who only a few years ago castrated before they strangled the dictator who led them and whom they worshipped for years, and the French, the Belgians, the Portuguese, the Spaniards and the rest. Let us have no more talk of a holy war. If you go into this NATO alliance, let us make it clear to the people you do it because it is a damn good bargain—remember that phrase? You used not to like it—and that you think it is all right to trade Irish property, Irish land, Irish people's lives, for some commercial undertaking. Tell us the truth. Tell us in fact what you are doing and do not, as you have so often done when it suited, shelter behind the croziers when you are under pressure and when you want somebody to pick your chestnuts out of the fire and undo the damage of your own stupid mistakes over the past 30 years.
The Taoiseach has created as no other single individual has created, this decadent, perverted materialist society in which the only values are the values of the market place. Whatever you get away with is right. Look at the decay of active public opinion, the poverty of old people, the hardship of their living conditions, the exploitation of the workers generally, the disparity between the privileged and the underprivileged the reduction in the general level of political freedoms and standards as we, the two of us, see it in our own day-to-day activities here. This certainly is a moment of truth for Irish industry, for all of our social and economic policies, and they will not survive the experience. The tragedy is that the results of the failure of the Taoiseach's policies over the past 30 years will cause very great hardship indeed to our people in the next three or four years. Now, in addition to trading the political independence of our country, he has decided to hand us over, tied hand and foot, to the decisions of this European consortium of nations to do as they will with us in respect to the military future. It seems to me he has played the final betrayal of all.
Comment on this
I have listened to Deputy Dr. Browne with some interest. At the outset he talked about Goebbels, Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin and all the rest, but his speech today was reminiscent of Goebbels at his best. Back in the 1930s, we remember Goebbels when he set out to denigrate his Government, to denigrate his people, and——
Comment on this
And the Minister for External Affairs was a great friend of his, as were a number of the Deputy's Party.
Comment on this
He did everything and anything to play the politics of everyone but his own country. Deputy Dr. Browne is not as foolish as he pretends and I should like to know from him what he professes. Is he a watery socialist; is he a full-blooded Communist; is he a straight socialist? He has left me in doubt.
Comment on this
I shall be surprised if Deputy Dr. Browne continues to get away with that brand of politics with the electorate here. No doubt the Taoiseach's Estimate gives us wide scope; we can dabble in foreign politics and back again to the home front, but Deputy Dr. Browne covered a very wide field indeed. I do not propose to follow him. I am amazed that an ex-Minister of this House and a man of Deputy Dr. Browne's intelligence should stoop to the rather dirty politics he displayed here this evening because it is a dirty political trick to set out to denigrate the efforts of one's own people.
The Government here are as good or as bad as the people who elect them. Bear that in mind, and if Deputy Dr. Browne wants to supplant them by either a watery brand of socialism or full-blooded Communism, I think he is mistaken. In the next election, the best he can do is go before the electorate and say the things he said here. If I felt as Deputy Dr. Browne feels about our system of government, that is what I would do. I would ask a mandate from the people for a full-blooded Communist Government. Before Deputy Dr. Browne leaves the House, I would remind him that if he were on the far side of the Iron Curtain, he would be queueing up now for his bowl of rice. I see Deputy McQuillan also leaving the House. Let him run down to his Roscommon constituency and postulate either full-blooded Communism or a weak brand of socialism. He will not do it because he knows very well that if he did, he would not come back to this House. I say that without prejudice.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I was dealing briefly with the philosophy of Deputy Dr. Browne and his Party and was wondering if the Deputy and his Party in the morning received an invitation from behind the Curtain—be it iron or bamboo—to join an alliance there, would he give us in his next speech here an indication of his attitude in that respect? There is no use in condemning the Common Market here because as we well know we have not been accepted as members of the Common Market. When one comes to think on the subject, when one realises that traditional enemies have lined up, have buried the hatchet and are prepared to come together, I do not think we, as a small country with a Christian outlook, should object to it.
Deputy Dr. Browne and, to a certain extent, Deputy Dillon, referred to the efforts to promote industrial activity here. Deputy Dr. Browne went all out to blame Fianna Fáil for the drawbacks and the disadvantages in that respect from which this country suffers. When I hear such objections voiced here, I am always in doubt about the philosophy and the intentions of the people who voice them. From the pre-1930's when the industrial drive commenced, we must realise that the people who at the beginning undertook to promote industrial activity had no easy job. From the earliest days, we were living in the shadow of free trade and it was the modern idea in the early 30's for every country, large and small, to try to promote its own industry. It was therefore small blame to any Government here to endeavour to start industries. No blame could be laid at the door of any Government, of any Minister, for that.
When one looks back one remembers that not merely had the Government of the day to impress on the manufacturer that we could make the goods but they had also to impress on the consumer that he could buy goods manufactured here as good as any that could be made in any country in Europe. There is no use in our starting off here with an inferiority complex. One becomes tired listening to the halfbaked arguments and statements we hear about the Common Market.
The Taoiseach's Estimate gives us an opportunity of discussing the country's economy in general. It hinges mostly on the Budget. It is generally accepted that the last Budget was a complete success as a budgetary exercise. It has been said that a Budget may be used as a brake or an accelerator. If the economy is growing too fast, or if something goes wrong, it can be used as a brake; if it is too slow, you can accelerate. Either way, the last Budget was as an exercise carried out correctly. Some Deputies said we did not provide sufficient social benefits; others said that the small farmers were suffering the most cruel form of slavery, due to pressure of Government policy. Some said we were not spending enough; others said we were not devoting enough money to the industrial drive.
In general, the emphasis seemed to be on spending but when talking of spending, one must think of where the money comes from. Our efforts in supporting the Government in any given year ensured as far as possible that revenue and expenditure would balance and that there would be no unfavourable balance at home or abroad. That was good policy and if it is pursued, the economy is on the right road.
The rate of growth must be watched. In the past five years it was favourable. In its last report, the Central Bank said that we might expect a period of expansion. Britain, where we sell the bulk of our primary produce, seems to be expecting a period of buoyant trade; European trade and production are expanding at the same time and it therefore seems that the immediate prospects for our exports are reasonably good. In the circumstances, I do not see why there should be such despondency about our entry into the Common Market. All the economic indicators suggest our economy is buoyant, that there are no factors that can damage it, provided we do not get into debt at home or abroad and provided we can always balance expenditure against income.
The Central Bank report which was recently issued also referred to the survey made by the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation and Development. Here is a brief quotation:
The general position has recently been stated as follows: In 1961, for the third year in succession, total national output expanded at a rate much higher than that postulated in the White Paper on Economic Expansion issued in November, 1958. Over the third period the average annual rate of growth exceeded 4½ per cent. The major contribution to the increase in 1961 was again made by the industrial sector.
Comment on this
I am quoting from the last report of the Central Bank. If I might continue and finish the short quotation. It says "Current external assets and payments showed a small surplus."
Comment on this
I am quoting from the Central Bank report. I am not giving the page but it is embodied in the last report. It continues: "Capital inflow combined with this surplus did produce a substantial increase in external savings." I am sorry I did not take the page but I will furnish it later on, if required. That is the report of an outside organisation which may be deemed to be objective in this matter and has nothing to gain by painting a gilded picture of our economy. It can be said, therefore, that that organisation deemed the management of the Government to be good and sound in general regarding our economic position.
If we look at any of the various publications with which we are issued either before or after the Budget, we shall see at a glance that all the indications are that the country has made substantial progress. I might go back for a moment and refer to a small publication known as Economic Statistics which was quoted here today and which was distributed with the Budget. It set out in general and clearly the economic position of the country. It shows that there was a favourable trend in the balance of payments, that the national income had increased by eight per cent., that fixed capital formation rose by 15 per cent. from £89 million in 1960 to £102 million in 1961. What is of more significance is that total savings increased by about £9 million.
Comment on this
No; I will take up the quotation again. I said that the total savings increased by about £9 million to £68 million, the highest yet recorded. The average index of weekly industrial earnings increased by 7.8 per cent and hourly earnings by 11 per cent. The report states that those economic trends were satisfactory. That brings me to the difference between the various Parties in this House. Fianna Fáil believe that the annual Budget was balanced and therein lies the secret of the success of the administration of the Government of the past five years.
The Taoiseach said, when speaking on the Budget, that the aims of the Budget were not to reduce purchasing power but to secure a transfer of purchasing power within the community, to balance the position so far as was possible in the interests of equity and social justice. It is evident, therefore, that the desire of the Government in recent legislation was to promote the common good.
We have all heard arguments advanced here regarding what the future may hold for small farmers and small businessmen. Anyone can assert at the moment that it is not easy to assess the likely developments of the coming decade. We have seen a great many changes since the last war and we are likely to see more in the next 10 years. Some people seem to be perturbed about the future of the small farmer and the question of his survival. What the critics overlook is that Europe is made up or based on the small farm economy. I know that matter is the subject of widespread comment at the moment and that many people hold that the pattern of our Irish agriculture will have to change if we are to survive.
The small farmer has many disadvantages, I admit, but if he has, he has also many advantages. I am not going to go fully into the advantages or disadvantages, beyond saying that he is not always in the best position to buy his equipment or to sell his livestock. Nor is he able to equip himself with modern machines. But when it comes to considering this matter in general, as related to the farming community in practice, the small farmer can be said to be free of many of the modern affictions that affect larger farming units—afflictions such as strikes and lock-outs. He can always resort to co-operation, especially from the point of view of production. He can always have available to him the most modern machines, provided at that point he is willing to bury his individual interests and co-operate with his neighbour. I often think that the critics who bemoan the plight of the small farmer are not too genuine. We know that the average-sized farm here is much higher than in European countries. Rather than bemoan the position of the small farmer, we should instead consider him as somebody who will be of immense value to the economy in the future, especially if we are accepted as members of the Common Market.
It was said here to-day—I do not altogether agree with it—that the farmer's love of the land was demonstrated by the fact that he would go out to the field, lean on the gate and look at the land. If that be so, I am at a loss to understand why so many farmers—I am not speaking of really small farmers either—who have a fair rent, the right of resale and fixity of tenure, lock up their doors and move out. I am referring now to bachelors who suffer at no time from economic pressure. It cannot be said that economic pressure is driving that type of man to emigrate.
I am tired of listening to Deputies opposite talking about the wholesale clearance from the west and north-west. That simply is not true. There is not a wholesale clearance, but there is a changing pattern, a pattern which has been changing gradually for the past 30 or 40 years. It is not changing at so great a rate, either. In our conditions in a relatively open-ended economy, it is bound to change at a faster rate than in a semi-closed economy. I can quote figures to support my point of view, if the House will not agree with me. For the record, I am taking these figures from the Free Press, and I am not giving the reference, either.
Comment on this
If the Deputy purports to quote, he should give the reference.
Comment on this
If it is a short quotation, I shall allow the Deputy.
Comment on this
It says that the percentage falls in employment in the primary industry in each of the following countries, taking 1870 as the base year, was: the United Kingdom from 15 per cent down to 4.5 per cent; the United States, from 50.8 per cent down to 11.6 per cent; Germany, from 35.5 per cent to 11.8 per cent. I am sorry I did not give the relevant year for the lower figure. When I gave 1870 as the base year, I should have quoted also 1950. Therefore, you can take the base year as 1870, going up to 1950. I could go on and give other figures: Sweden, 55.5 per cent down to 19.3 per cent; France, 43 per cent. down to 20.2 per cent; Japan, with its huge population, 76.4 per cent down to 36.2 per cent.
Comment on this
I am not going any further away from home than some of the Deputies who spoke here this evening and who went around the North Cape and back to Moscow. When we come to criticise the Government and the Department of Agriculture, we must have facts and figures to back our claims. I submit that some of the wild statements made here to-day would not stand a fact-finding examination. Last week, the Minister for Agriculture introduced his Vote. He was subjected to a barrage of abuse for his failure to meet the demands of the various sectors which compose the farming community. I submit that, in the circumstances, he can feel satisfied that for the past five years he has administered the affairs of his Department wisely and well. I should like the critics to take note of the fact that in a critical period, when production was falling elsewhere, we were increasing production here, even primary production.
Comment on this
Oh, yes. It was increasing here when marketing conditions did not favour agriculture in any shape or form. The report of the Department of Agriculture denotes good progress. We would all like to see even greater progress in our agricultural sector but, when we come to consider the position, we must admit that we live in highly competitive times, in times when agricultural produce is being dumped at cut prices in our best market. I am sure the severest critic of the Department of Agriculture will readily admit that it was difficult in recent years to dispose of food surpluses, either in the British market or outside it. That was due to many causes. In the case of certain products, as this House is very well aware, it was due to causes outside our control altogether. It is very difficult at the moment to market butter, bacon and eggs. A seller in an overcrowded market has to take the best price he can get. This House is aware of that because of the fact that we have to subsidise the sale of both butter and bacon in our traditional market.
Comment on this
Would it not be better to subsidise it for our own people so that they could eat it?
Comment on this
That raises another argument, one on which we have fought and won many elections. The Deputy should not forget that.
Comment on this
We disposed of that point some few years ago and I do not intend to go back on it here. The policy adopted by the Minister for Agriculture and the Government, and the price support system, have proved to be good. That is all I shall say on that point.
It was said here that the farmers' income should be greater. The people who make that claim should recognise that, even with difficult conditions obtaining abroad, production expanded here. Incomes rose during the year. Incomes may not have risen as much as we would like, but they certainly did rise.
Comment on this
I need only refer to the remarkable rise in agricultural exports. I will give the Deputy the figures. Agricultural exports have gone up in the past five years by more than £40 millions, or roughly 53 per cent. In 1956, cattle realised £36 million odd; in 1961, live cattle brought in £44 million odd. Beef and veal in 1956 realised £3,600,000. In 1961, the amount realised was £19 million.
Comment on this
Deputies opposite will have plenty of time to flay my speech to pieces between now and 11 o'clock.
Comment on this
Statistical evidence is available of the export drive by Fianna Fáil. If the Deputy does not want to listen to the figures, he need not do so. In 1956, mutton and lamb realised £1,500,000; in 1961, the figure was £1,800,000. In 1956, butter brought in £200,000; in 1961, the figure realised was £3,800,000. Other foodstuffs, in 1956, fetched £2,300,000; in 1961, the figure was £3,300,000. Cereals and foodstuffs in 1956 realised £600,000; in 1961, the figure was £3,800,000. That shows the excellent agricultural progress in this sector of our economy.
The Government's policy in relation to agriculture is under fire. Yet it is striking that one of the foremost steps taken by the Government is the generous price support system adopted. I assert that that price support system has contributed towards the marked rise in exports from this sector of the economy.
That brings me to the last point I want to make. The fact that 80 per cent of the store cattle exported from this country were attested indicates the good work accomplished in the drive to eradicate bovine TB. It has been asserted that for the period under review the elimination of bovine tuberculosis and the attestation of the various areas has been rapid and well accomplished and has been carried out, bear in mind, without any major dislocation of our export trade. All the time the Government are under fire for their agricultural policy. Also bear in mind that the Government had to find the money to eliminate reactors and to pay the owners.
One last point before I conclude. A few Deputies asserted—it is not of course a fact—that nothing was being done to promote better grass husbandry, which in turn reflects in better finished livestock and higher exports. We assert that for our period we have done more to promote better grass husbandry than we will get credit for.
There have been various aids. The decision to subsidise ground limestone, the decision to increase the subsidies on phosphatic and nitrogenous manures, the decision to reduce the tractor tax—all those decisions were taken with the calculated aim of promoting better grass husbandry. We on this side of the House are prepared to assert that but for having experienced a bad autumn or an early winter and a bad spring the usage of fertilisers would have been much greater. We are also prepared to assert here and now that that policy will pay in a seasonal period later on and that farmers will then readily appreciate the advantages of the price support system initiated by the Government.
Comment on this
I am sorry Deputy Carter did not continue to discuss the small farmers. I should like to supply some of the gaps he left—I will not say "unwittingly". He tells us that there is a lot of grousing from this side of the House and amongst people who do not seem to know their business and that all this grousing about the small farmer is so much ballyhoo. Before Deputy Carter leaves the House——
Comment on this
I should like him to read the record. Perhaps it would give him something to think about. I quote from agricultural statistics for the year 1934 in his own county of Longford.
Comment on this
There were 10,963 males engaged in agriculture in County Longford in 1934. Last year, even though the Deputy tells us everything is all right with the small farmer in Longford, the number seems to have dwindled, according to the Statistical Abstract. That number of nearly 11,000 has dwindled to 7,102—a decrease of 4,000 during a period in which Fianna Fáil were in power four years out of five. Would the Deputy explain where the 4,000 have gone? Have they gone on permanent holidays or what has become of these 4,000 of his constituents? I will not mention any other county. Looking at the country as a whole, we find a rather alarming situation. We find the total number of males engaged in agriculture has dropped since 1934 from 579,400 to 421,000.
I read in to-day's paper a statement from somebody in the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association asking a question which I have put several times to the Government in this House, that is, what is the Government policy with regard to the small farmer? The Government cannot plead that they are completely unaware of what is happening. They cannot plead they do not know that the small farmers are being forced out in pretty sizeable numbers. The small farmer is a vanishing member of the community.
If it is the intention of the Government to create a situation whereby the country will return to 200 or 300 acre farms, to the ranches that caused all the trouble in bygone days, the decentest way to treat the people is let them know at once that that is the policy, that, in the opinion of the Government, that is the best thing in the long run for the people, and that the sooner the small farmer finds other occupation, either in this country or by emigrating, the better. The small farmer is being forced out. It is not good enough to allow the exodus of anything up to 20,000 at least per year. Of the 40,000 emigrants, 20,000 at least are heads of households, their wives and families.
Comment on this
They are being forced out of the country. It is not right or democratic to allow that exodus year after year. It may be playing into the Government's hands. It may be the sincerest wish of the Government here and of the Taoiseach that these people should go out quietly without any fuss being made about it. I believe that is the policy.
There is one thing for which I admire Fianna Fáil, that is, the method by which they gull the people every time there is an election. Every time there is an election, they tell them that emigration will cease, that there will be plenty of work for everybody. Everything short of bringing back the emigrants is promised to the people. Every poor devil who is out of work will have full and plenty, if he votes Fianna Fáil back to power. The election is over and Fianna Fáil get back to power. What is the tune then? If you say there is unemployment, if you say there are people forced off the small holdings or that working people are forced, through unemployment, to emigrate, you are shouted down and blackguarded, and every underhand trick is tried, down to writing anonymous letters about your friends, even to the extent of having old age pensions, dole money or stamp money taken from them as I know happened in Mayo, and what happened in Mayo must be the case all round. Any person who opens his mouth to criticise is told he is anti-national. He is accused of not speaking Irish, of wearing the Union Jack for a shirt, a Swastika or some other emblem. So much for the nonsense and trash.
Comment on this
For a full three-quarters of an hour, Deputy Carter tried to cover up every failure that Fianna Fáil have brought about. He very carefully avoided the drop in population. He even praised the Minister for Agriculture notwithstanding the fact that the Minister for Agriculture himself had to admit there were 132,000 fewer store cattle in this country this year on the 1st January than there were in January twelve months. In other words, the farmers have to sell £132,000 worth of their capital. They are living on their capital and because they do not keep on doing that Deputy Carter and other Deputies blackguard them.
I want to tell the Taoiseach—I do not think he has any enmity against the farming community—that the farmer under £25 valuation who has no part-time employment is not able to make a living on the land. There is very little employment in the rural areas. There is little or nothing doing in forestry. There are one or two spots of arterial drainage.
Comment on this
During my time as Minister for Lands, with the help of other Ministers in the Government from Fine Gael, Labour and Clann na Poblachta, I put forward a forestry programme. In a few years I doubled the planted acreage whereas you were fooling with forestry for 30 years. You just left a few scrubwoods all over the country and you call that forestry. During the inter-Party Government time the planted acreage was doubled and a programme was laid down that no Fianna Fáil Minister dare go back on because if he could go back on it he would have done so. Deputy Carter spoke about ground limestone. The only thing his Party ever did in regard to ground limestone was to increase the price from 15/- to £1. The inter-Party Government started that scheme and Fianna Fáil tried to kill it.
There are three inseparable problems facing the country, unemployment, emigration and our entry into the Common Market. Deputy Dr. Browne was deploring the fact that we might have to subscribe to NATO. If we do not join the Common Market, it means the end for this country, complete stagnation. Under the Rome Treaty very high tariff barriers would be raised against our products. If we could not export to England I do not see where we could dispose of our goods. We would have no business exporting it to Australia and other remote places where we are not known.
I should like to get for this country all the benefits that membership would confer without the penalties but it is absolutely essential that we face up to the responsibilities which are involved in our membership of the EEC. If we do not join the Common Market we should be as isolated as a shellfish on the seashore. If we must join NATO in order to get these benefits let us do so because that would be preferable to being outside and having our so called neutrality.
I do not think it is beyond the power of the Government to create more employment. With the abandonment of the Local Authorities (Works) Act and the chiselling down of small drainage through the Special Employment Schemes Office, road works and various other activities, there are very few employment opportunities in country areas. It is very unfair because these people are paying their taxes and contributing their share to run the country and are as much entitled to consideration as people in other areas. One of the main causes of emigration is that people cannot live at home. No man is going to leave his house, emigrate with his wife and children to England, Canada or Australia just for the love of travel. He has to go due to economic circumstances.
Anyone with an ounce of experience or common sense knows that the small holding which gave a fairly frugal living, but a living, to a family in the past, on £10, £12, £15 or even £20 valuation, no longer provides such a living. If the farmer who owns that small holding does not have some part-time employment for at least three or four months of the year he cannot survive here. One of the signs of his honesty is that he does not get into debt or refuse to meet his lawful obligations to the State in the form of taxation; instead he clears out. He has to go for no other reason than an economic reason. With this flight from the land, our towns, both big and small, are very badly hit. This is a reaction from the thinning out of populations in the countryside. The policy pursued by the inter-Party Government was to spend more and more money in rural Ireland.
Comment on this
However, I have no doubt the Taoiseach will get advice from high places, from his so-called financial wizards, that the pursuing of such a policy would cause inflation, that it would create a purchasing power that would throw our balance of trade out of equilibrium. The money should be spent as it was spent during the days of the inter-Party Governments.
Comment on this
Any Deputy who thinks anything I have said is not correct has a duty to get up after me and say so. A falsehood or an incorrect statement should not be allowed to pass in this House. This is the place to correct it. Of course the object of these interruptions is to try to put me off my trend of thought.
I repeat that more money must be spent in rural Ireland, if the flight from the land is to be arrested. I do not advocate the giving of free money. I do not know what method can be employed to increase the incomes of small farmers, but employment could be provided and that seems the obvious way to increase rural incomes. However, for some reason, the Government oppose that policy. They seem to think such a policy would cause an upheaval, that things would get out of control. It must be done if the flight from the land is to be stopped, if we are to stop the shutting up of house after house, week after week throughout the countryside, if we are not to let the country go back to the ranchers, which seems to be the policy of most Deputies in the House.
Comment on this
There are not half a dozen voices in the House who back me in this; there are not half a dozen Deputies who are prepared to get down to an all-out attempt to stop this flight from the land.
Comment on this
I am putting the case of the people I represent and I do not care whether that puts me out of the House or not. I am not a political coward who makes promises and is afraid to follow them up afterwards. As I said earlier, there are three main problems facing the country—emigration, unemployment and our possible entry into the Common Market. I was not here when the Taoiseach introduced his Estimate this morning and therefore I do not know if he gave us any information on the cold shoulder we seem to be getting from the EEC. If he has not dealt with that matter, I hope he will do so in his reply. I should like him to know that any action he is taking to secure membership of the Common Market for this country will have the support of the majority of Deputies.
Any person who has any common sense can see that our future is tied up with the European Economic Community, should Britain join. If Britain joins and we do not, we will be no better than an isolated island like one of those inhabited places off the Galway or Kerry coasts. I come again to the unemployment problem in the rural areas and its reaction on the towns, big and small. I would ask the Taoiseach to take that matter up seriously, particularly during the recess when he and the other members of the Government will have plenty of time on their hands.
Another pressing problem is that of rates. This affects both farmers and business people in towns. Any person who has the ill-luck to live in an urban area has to meet two sets of rates, the county rate and the town rate. It puzzles me how they are able to carry on. In Mayo, we have three urban areas—Castlebar, Westport and Ballina—and how the people bear the two sets of rates in those towns, I do not know. It is a most appalling burden, even if business is very good. A lot remains to be done by the Government and I trust that by the time the Dáil reassembles, they will have made a good start.
Comment on this
This is the Taoiseach's Estimate and I want to say that I have been a political opponent of the Taoiseach for nearly 40 years. I want also to dissociate myself completely from the speech made by Deputy Dr. Browne this evening. He described the Taoiseach as a Quisling, as a Tshombe and as a man selling the country. It was a deplorable speech and I want to register my wholehearted opposition to it.
Comment on this
He referred to the Taoiseach as a Kruger. That was a deplorable effort. The whole speech was worthy only of a Hyde Park soap-box. That Deputy is completely detached from Irish life himself but as he is unique, it is not a matter of great worry. This is an occasion for stocktaking, for the examination of problems and of consciences. The wider aspects of State policy have been dwelt on by the Taoiseach and by the Leader of the Opposition and I shall try to deal with some of the narrower aspects. No matter what side of the House we sit on I think our main object is to see things go well, to try to ensure that progress is maintained in the country and that the trends causing uneasiness are observed and checked.
There are disturbing trends and there are good trends. We had a very good report today from An Bord Fáilte on tourism. It shows the big advance the country has made in this field but we were all disturbed by reports that there is a decline in tourism this year. It seems to me there could be some truth in the allegation that hoteliers in this country have tried to kill the goose that lays the golden egg, that they have raised prices too quickly and too much. A few years ago, I thought we could have a fair target for tourism in this country of £100 million a year. A great investment was made which should lead to that most important development. It would be a very bad thing if we are to see this fine export— that is what it is—being destroyed by those who are engaged in tourism. Bord Fáilte said this morning that it does not single-handedly undertake all the jobs of tourism. There are others involved and they should not be allowed to injure the progress and growth already obvious in this business.
In Cork city for instance, the growth of heavy industry is obviously a durable thing which will, I think, outlast any of the difficulties of entry to the Common Market. There is a shortage of certain skills in the country. I hope the last round of wage increases will be sufficient until we catch up with the injury done to our economy by that round. A lesson should be learned from it. No matter on what side of the House we sit, we should observe the trends that are dangerous and encourage things well done, no matter by whom. The manner in which criticism is offered and accepted should be a desirable, established pattern from this on.
This morning, the Taoiseach said next year would be a very important year. I think the next five years will be very important and that living in Ireland for at least two generations will be influenced by what we do in that period. Most of our past conceptions must be—this is happening— discarded. We may even change direction or even go into reverse in some cases. Such things are a mark of the times we live in. Old catchcries that helped to fill this House are now useless, if not harmful—which is what they are if they prevent any kind of keen examination of our problems.
All these problems could be covered in one question: how are we to make the country's economy a lively, working thing in which every activity will add to every other and the whole spell nearly full employment in town and country? If we go in that direction, things like emigration, inflation, even our Border trouble, our relations, economic and political, with other countries will fall into place; progress will be made if we realise that no group has a monopoly of patriotism. None of us has a solution for our present difficulties beyond the solution we would apply in our private affairs.
Many of us would try to work reasonably hard and intelligently, balance our accounts and save. We would seek to educate our children, in the things of God and the world and try to direct them into useful and profitable channels. We would try to ensure that they would be healthy and well-clad. Above all, we would try to see that none enjoyed advantages at the expense of others. Eventually, the training and education of each and the hard work of all and the consideration of each for the other and the profitability of the work of each would add to the whole and the family would prosper. I am convinced there is no other solution for human problems in progress than those and that they apply equally to the family and to the nation.
This nation is facing great changes and whatever great difficulty we had in the past in adjusting the balance between agriculture and industry will diminish into insignificance compared with the problems that will come with our entry into the Common Market. Neither arm of our economy is I think fitted for the shock of free trade at the moment. Too many of our industries are unfitted mentally for the challenge. They have only prospered through the exercise of pressure on the community for favoured treatment. The Taoiseach called it feather-bedding. That is very bad preparation for the harsh realities of the world. We must give priority to training for independence, an independence much more exciting and stimulating than what we meant before by that word. It means the opposite to dependence. Therefore, I think training and teaching are the most valuable investments that the country can make.
First, I think we must have close liaison between agriculture and education and industry. Every child over a certain age must proceed to his real education and this must go on and add to his work in the factory, the office or on the farm. The world is jumping into a new age of technical skills and we must jump with it. Those at the bench, in the workshop, on the farm, in food-processing plants, in hotels and in the transport service must all have technical competence. The secretary, the accountant and the salesman must come from the top educational drawer. This adds up to an enormous expansion of our expenditure on technical education. Even now we must run to catch up. Nothing else is so well worth doing and nothing else will permit us to survive at the level we would wish. Our job is to provide a living for our people within our shores but if they have to go abroad to ensure they would not have to hew wood and draw water, it means completely streamlining our whole system of education to embrace technical skills, crafts, accountancy and languages.
Great stress was laid to-day on the need for at least one Continental language being taught to every reasonably educated person reaching adolescence, but every workshop, every craft or trade, every manager, employer and trade unionist should have a part in this development. The local authorities must ensure that such teaching and training is provided, fully equipped and housed and in a form suitable for the local needs. The State must pledge the credit of the people to get this great move forward in technical training. This is a time to reorganise and stocktake. I have directed my criticism to what I consider to be our greatest lack and our greatest need in 1962.
Comment on this
I was not exactly surprised when the Leader of the Opposition attempted to launch a counter-attack after the opening of this debate by the Taoiseach. Nor was I surprised at the way in which he did so. He opened his attack by stating that the speech of the Taoiseach was entirely without value and attempted to prove this by making a comment about the faces of the Deputies on this side of the House. I do not say that the faces of the Deputies on this side of the House are any more notably attractive than those of the Deputies on the other side, but if one has to criticise on that basis, it is a matter of considerable significance.
It is worth noting that in this rumbustious counterblast which seemed lacking in anything of importance, the leader of the Opposition could count on the support of only four members of his own Front Bench at most and of six of his backbenchers at most. The support from the back benches was reduced to three at one stage. If the situation in this country is so catastrophic as the Leader of the Opposition will have us believe, I should have thought that his own supporters would have come in to back him up in this connection. If the Government have been so criminally incompetent, one would imagine that the Fine Gael Party would have been so incensed that they would have been flocking to the support of their leader and trying to get into the fray themselves.
This is not what happened. The supporters of the Leader of the Opposition did not seem to be crowding over one another to come in and hear what he had to say. I may add that any of those on that side of the House who did not hear what he had to say did not miss very much. He went so far as to claim that he was either the author or co-author of the speech delivered by President Kennedy in the Independence Day celebrations in the United States this year. He stated that he had made a similar speech in Washington 14 years ago. Deputy Dillon has made so many speeches and has held so many different political views from time to time, mostly contradictory, that on the law of averages, he could almost certainly claim to have said at one time or another something similar to what anybody else might say today. The effrontery of the suggestion that he had helped President Kennedy with his speech left even me gasping.
He criticised very much the figures given and the inferences drawn from the increased national income because he stated that owing to the decline in money values, the national income is entirely illusory. He was working on the false assumption that whilst our currency might be deflated, the currency of all other countries remained constant which, I am sure, he must realise is entirely unsound. The inference to be drawn from the figures of national income is that, compared with similar figures prepared on a similar basis in other countries, the rate of increase of our national income is something which gives very good reason for optimism. These statistical figures are all produced on a similar basis and our rate of increase does compare favourably with those of other countries in Europe at the present time. Granted the increase has only just recently started, but it is growing.
Deputy Dillon also dealt with the position of the farmers. I can never understand his attitude and that of his Party in this regard. He has stated both on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture and again today that our land is not nearly productive enough. I think all of us will agree with that. Much of our land which is under cultivation of some sort is not nearly as productive as it should be. He goes on, as usual, to say that the greatest need is for the re-introduction of Part B of the Land Project. In his speech today, as a third and last point, he referred to better marketing techniques.
While we all agree that the productivity of our land is not nearly as high as it should be, we are not agreed as to what the next step is to deal with this problem. Deputy Dillon has made some reference to the increased use of fertilisers and here again we are in agreement with him, very much so. But the question is what is the highest priority. The view of this Government, with which I must say that as an uneducated city man I find myself in agreement, is that the top priority should be to bring the land already in production up to the peak of its productivity. If we relax in any way in our efforts to encourage the increased use of fertilisers, we are doing a bad day's work. If we spend more money on Part B of the Land Project, instead of putting that money into fertilisers, we are putting the cart before the horse.
I have never seen, and I believe there are not in existence, any figures to show what increased production has resulted from land reclamation. I have a horrible suspicion that much of the land which has been reclaimed has more or less lapsed into its previous condition.
Comment on this
I am sure that if that were nonsense, we would have facts and figures to prove it, but as we have not any facts or figures to prove it, there is still that suspicion in my mind.
Comment on this
When it cost up to £300 an acre, it was no longer economic. When the bleating at the other side of the House has stopped, I will continue.
Comment on this
These interjections from the Opposition have left me no more enlightened than I was before. The fact remains, however, that the farmer who pays more out of his own pocket for land reclamation under Part A is much more likely to keep the reclaimed land in production, once it has been reclaimed. All the facts and figures show that land reclaimed under Part A does stay in good heart. There is no denial of that. Deputy Dillon has therefore pretty well agreed with the facts but he does not agree with the policy. He still pleads for an increased emphasis on land reclamation, but from the facts he has given himself, it is quite clear the Government's policy is the right one and that what we must first do therefore is to subsidise the use of fertilisers to the very maximum so that the standard of productivity in the agricultural industry will be considerably raised. If we can do that, it will mean not only that we will increase our production but that we will reduce the costs of production.
When we have been able to make more progress with that, it is obviously, and, I think, correctly, the policy of the Government to put marketing as the next priority. The farmers in this country are no different from the farmers anywhere else. They have all suffered from periods of over-production when prices have collapsed. They are very naturally suspicious of any efforts being made to encourage them simply to produce more. I thoroughly agree with them in that. But Deputy Dillon made the call today: "Let us get more production first." If he can sell that one to a farmer, he is a right good salesman. I cannot think of any farmer who would be thick enough to accept such a suggestion. We have got first to get better productivity and reduce the costs of production. Then we have got to get our marketing at a much higher level. Only when we have got our marketing much more secure and scientific, can we in all conscience encourage our farmers to go in for a substantial programme of increased production.
We have not got control over over-seas markets. We discovered that to our cost when Deputy Dillon produced what at the time looked a fairly reasonable proposal for increasing our production of eggs. The only thing he did not take into account was the fact that the British Government might take similar steps to encourage British home production. When the British production of eggs for the home market was tremendously subsidised, we found we had no market for our eggs at all, or virtually none. That was no fault of anybody, but it did illustrate very fully that over-production can be extremely dangerous when you are supplying a market over which you have no control.
In the general picture of gloom and decay which has been painted by members of the Opposition, reference is always made to the cattle population and to the fact that it is not rising as rapidly as it should. I never heard any reference in this particular connection to one feature which I believe deserves considerable attention, that is, that the number of cattle slaughtered because of being TB reactors is very considerable. A number of cattle never reached maturity because they had to be slaughtered in order to deal with this TB problem, and the rate of slaughter is continuing. It is extremely difficult to have a rapidly increasing population of cattle when you are destroying them at that rate. The TB Eradication Scheme is one of the most valuable undertaken in recent years. It is already paying off as far as the export market is concerned. But to say that we have reason to despair because the total number of cattle is not rising is just nonsense. Purely from the statistical point of view, it appears that, once the TB Eradication Scheme is successfully concluded, the rate of increase will be very considerable.
I react—and I think the Government generally reacts—very much against overemphasis on the question of beef production. Just as in industry, it is very dangerous to put all your eggs into one basket—I know there is an equivalent danger of being jack of all trades and master of none —certainly in business there is an increasing move towards diversification of activities, because no industrialist is prepared to confine himself just to one line of business. I certainly am not and Deputy Dillon certainly is not in his business. The same applies, or should apply, to our agricultural policy. If we were to say the main purpose of our agriculture is to breed increasing numbers of beef cattle, I cannot feel for a moment that that would be sound. We must, by all means, try to raise to the highest possible standards each facet of agricultural production. But if we are to increase the number of cattle and have plenty for export, dead or alive, we are then faced with the problem of the disposal of the milk. I understand it is very hard to produce cattle without producing milk at the same time. Even I have got round to seeing that. That means that if we continue to regard cattle as producers of meat, milk and butter, we are obviously heading for trouble.
Comment on this
And other forms of production. But with some of these products, I find that it is only when some of these matters are raised directly from this side of the House that Deputy Dillon and the members of the Fine Gael Party show any great enthusiasm.
Comment on this
I do not blame the Deputy for not recognising his own language. It would put a strain on him and his antecedents.
Comment on this
The point I was trying to bring out was that some diversification in agriculture is essential. I have yet to hear Deputy Dillon make that statement, but I am glad to find that he now agrees. He is so accustomed to saying that we have learned a lesson from him that it is nice to find now that he is learning something from us. He is always pointing out—this is something Fine Gael seem to hold as a matter of Party policy—that Ireland is primarily an agricultural country. That is the sort of remark that goes down extremely well in certain quarters, but it is one that needs careful analysis.
Were Ireland to remain a primarily agricultural country, we should have to face the fact that a falling population is inevitable. Very often, when this matter is raised, our attention is directed to another primarily agricultural country, Denmark, where agriculture has reached a very high level indeed. Denmark is constantly being held up to us as an example. What so many people either do not know, or prefer, perhaps, to forget, is that the rate of industrialisation in Denmark is far higher than it is here, and continues to develop at a high rate simply because Denmark realised, before we did, I think, that agriculture alone cannot support a reasonably sized population; industry, whether or not strictly applied to agriculture, is absolutely essential.
There is this constant complaint of the flight from the land, as if this were a problem unique to ourselves. There is a flight from the land all over the United Kingdom, in France, in Germany, in South America, and, indeed, all over the world. It is something which cannot be halted. It is due to increased wages. It is due to greater mechanisation in agriculture, and so forth. Indeed, the flight from the land is inevitable, unless industries can be set up in rural areas to hold the people in these areas.
I cannot understand this constant effort by some people who, simply because they are politically in Opposition, seem to feel it incumbent on them to use every possible means of increasing a sense of inferiority complex in this country. I cannot understand these people who persistently say that everything is dreadful here; we are suffering from a flight from the land; our small farmers are in dire straits; we are suffering from emigration. So is every other country.
Comment on this
Talking of small farmers, it must be remembered that in the six countries of the European Community, the average size of the farm is well under 50 acres.
Comment on this
I think it is somewhere near 25 acres. In fact, our small farmers therefore are not half as small as some of the farmers with whom they will be in competition. Our farmers, too, have many advantages which continental farmers are still dreaming about. We have a far better system of land tenure. There are parts of France in which the system of land tenure is quite mediaeval. As we fly over the Continent, or pass through it in a train, we sometimes get the impression that the agricultural areas are composed of enormous farms. That is an entirely wrong impression. In actual fact, there are large areas without hedges, ditches, or any other physical features to divide them up, but the fact is they are divided into very small strips indeed. These are the farmers with whom we will be in competition. Yet there are people on the Opposition side of the House who try to spread alarm and despondency, for reasons apparently best known to themselves.
Comment on this
About the chronic deficiencies in our system, which are alleged to be the root cause of the flight from the land, emigration, and the plight of the small farmer.
Comment on this
I am open to conviction. Nobody has convinced me yet. There was a tremendous amount of abuse today of Irish industry. Deputy Dr. Browne made a very long speech; I only hope he is feeling better now that he has got it out of his system. His speech was the greatest nonsense. It is a pity really that he would not try to confine his remarks to something he knows something about. His idea seems to be, and he is generally joined by the Opposition in this view, that this country is dotted all over with tinpot industries, feather-bedded by the Taoiseach personally for his own personal reasons, and that none of them will be able to stand up against the ruthless competition of Continental Europe. In terms of political abuse, I suppose these remarks have a certain value, but I wish that people, before indulging in such abuse, would try to inform themselves of the facts.
I admit that the Committee on Industrial Organisation have made very critical observations of Irish industry generally. I think it is very salutary that they should have done so, but to say that the result of the deliberations of that Committee is that Irish industry is utterly condemned as inefficient is the greatest nonsense. If the general over-all quality of our industrial products was so utterly appalling as Deputy Dr. Browne would have us believe, and if our prices were so out of line with prices elsewhere, how is it that our industrial exports have risen so steadily and, in many cases, so rapidly?
I would be the first to admit that there are grave deficiencies in industrial design, that the standard of our management is probably not as high as it should be. I admit that we need a much greater sense of urgency and adventure, but the fact remains that, if a certain amount of industrial development had not taken place in this country under the shelter of some protection, we would now be out of the race for membership of the European Economic Community even before we started. A high proportion of our industrial exports has already been contributed by these feather-bedded, tinpot industries. That in itself gives the lie to the criticism which has been made in this House today.
It is no harm to remember that when the Treaty of Rome was under consideration and the industrialists of France, Germany, Italy and the Benelux countries were considering what was going to happen, they were all mortally afraid of one another also. It is only natural, human nature being what it is, that any industry which is based mainly on the home market feels nervous about having to engage in an export market while being subjected to competition which it has not previously had to suffer.
It is well worth while reading some of the comments in the British press at the moment where they are criticising their own industrialists for sheltering behind protection. Very often as I read those papers, as I do for my own education, I find it very difficult to believe that I am not reading an Irish paper speaking about Irish industry because the criticisms in British newspapers are exactly the same. I have taken the trouble over the years to keep an eye on the developments in Europe and I find that the same situation obtained amongst the Six before they came together. Their industrialists were afraid of one another just as to a considerable extent we are rather afraid of this competition also.
I do not think we should ever feel that we are the only people with problems. All the members of the Six have had their problems and a number of those problems still remain. So that our proposed membership of the Community does not mean that we as complete amateurs are going to become associated with high pressure professional business tycoons with whom everything is at the moment going magnificently.
Take Italy, for instance, at the moment. The rate of increase of production in Italy has been very considerable indeed but she still has a very large problem of emigration. I think about 1,000,000 Italians have already emigrated to Germany since the termination of hostilities in the second World War and she has had the same trouble as we have had on the question of migration within the country itself. There has been a very high rate of migration from the poverty-stricken areas of Southern Italy to the more prosperous industrial areas of the North. So that Italy has her problems all right.
Take France on her agricultural problems alone. Our farmers have had their troubles, they have had their protests, they have held their protest meetings but the French farmers have not been as gentlemanly as our own; they have become extremely violent, blocking the roads, throwing produce around the streets and becoming extremely violent and troublesome. For any French Government, the problems of French agriculture must be a very great headache and of course France has her political worries in Algeria, not to mention in metropolitan France itself.
Germany has made a remarkable recovery since the war and her people have worked extremely hard to get the country back on its feet, but now there is growing labour unrest because the employees have begun to feel, and I must sympathise with them, that they have worked for the Fatherland long enough, long hours at low wages. Now they feel it is time they got some greater share of the prosperity they have restored to their country. Strikes are beginning to break out; demands for increased wages are being made; and in recent months the rate of increase of production has considerably slowed down.
All that means that when we join, as I hope and believe we will, this Community, we will not be joining people who have everything running their way already. We will be joining partners who have had troubles in the past and who still have troubles. To say that our worries and our difficulties are far greater than anybody else's is just not true, for which I think we should feel devoutly thankful. I admit there is no ground for complacency in the present situation but that does not mean we should be indulging in a policy of spreading despondency. It is very right that the Opposition should criticise the Government all the time to try to keep the Government on their toes but merely to moan about everything being so dreadful is very unconstructive, most unhelpful, not in the public interest and I do not think it is even going to give any political advantage.
There are many signs which give us ground for confidence. I was speaking only yesterday to a member of a large building contracting firm in this city whose activities are entirely devoted to building industrial premises. He told me his firm had never been employing so many men and that they were unable to accept any more contracts for building to commence earlier than 1964. Their entire labour force was fully booked up to 1964. I cannot imagine for a moment that hardheaded business men are putting hundreds of thousands of pounds into new factory building if the situation is even half as dismal as the Opposition would have us believe. Granted, the rate of increase of production may fluctuate from time to time. That is only natural. The fact remains that industrial production is increasing steadily.
There has been some criticism of our development of the tourist trade. It does seems that possibly bookings for this year were not quite as high as had been hoped, but I certainly could not follow Deputy Dillon in his contention that all the tourists who come here are returning Irish who have had to emigrate and are just coming home for holidays. Certainly, if they are all Irish, they have picked up Cockney, Lancashire and Welsh accents remarkably quickly and judging by some of the cars I see coming ashore at Dún Laoghaire, they have done amazingly well since they emigrated. Some of them appear to have emigrated as far as France, Germany, Switzerland and have come back here with cars bearing the registration numbers of those countries. Really that is nonsense. The great proportion of the tourists are genuine tourists. One has only to stand on the side of the road at the Airport or at any of the seaports to get confirmation of that.
We cannot undertake that the rate of increase of tourism will be absolutely uniform because here you are dealing with the tastes of people which vary very much from year to year. All sorts of outside circumstances over which we have no control may send a greater stream of tourist traffic to the Continent one year, to the United Kingdom another year and to us in another year. Here again, if the policy was unsound of supporting the tourist traffic by increased grants to hotels for expansion, how can we explain the investment of a considerable amount of American money in hotels in this city alone, not to mention the investment of German and other moneys in other hotels around the country?
Can you imagine an organisation such as the Hilton organisation, with its hotels all over the world, seriously considering building a large hotel out at Santry, unless and until they had made a very careful analysis of the tourist potential of the country generally? We can rest assured they would have been very careful indeed and the fact that they are developing that hotel and that so much American money is going into the other new hotel at Ballsbridge should give us confidence in ourselves, if we need it. I cannot see why we keep on losing confidence in ourselves. It is time we began to build up our morale and realised there are very few things, if any, we cannot do just as well as anybody else.
All this talk about technical know-how is of some value but of a very limited amount. We heard exactly the same thing being said at the time of the Suez crisis, when it was clearly laid down that the running of the Suez Canal was something which only the white man could understand, that once the European control and European technicians were taken away from the Suez Canal, it would become completely flooded, it would become silted up, all the ships would crash into one another or that some other dreadful thing would happen. It took the Egyptians about half a day or a full day to find out how the thing worked and it has worked extremely smoothly ever since. There is not half the technical know-how needed as some bigwigs would have us believe.
There is one matter on which considerable progress has been made, although in this regard there has been some criticism of the Government also, that is, the question of labour relations. The Government are often criticised for being reluctant to intervene in labour disputes and the cry goes out: "The community must be protected; somebody should do something." To any Government, that must be a temptation when they find the community being held up to ransom in a way which the Government feel is entirely unjustified. The way in which it has been tackled by this Government is the right way, and it is beginning to pay off.
There was a certain amount of irresponsibility on both sides in the matter of labour relations but the reaction of the public has been so solid, so unmistakable, that at last the trade unions and the employers have seen that the time has come when they must keep constantly in consultation with each other and not wait until some crisis has broken out. There is a lack of discipline which is very obvious in the trade union movement but there is an equal lack of discipline which is not nearly so obvious amongst employers. I would hope that this new movement which is developing satisfactorily will gain strength and that the unions will be able to impress on their members that indiscipline is a source of weakness to the trade union movement and that the employers will be able to convince their members to the same effect.
How much better it will be if success can be achieved by mutual consultation rather than by Government interference. The Government could at any stage, with the requisite majority, make lightning strikes illegal and there are many people who feel that would be a good thing to do in the interest of the community. However, that would inevitably build up resistance in the trade union movement generally and, I think, rightly so. If the unions themselves can convince their members that the whole basis of the strength of the trade union movement is the ability of a trade union to negotiate collectively with the employer, then a great step forward will have been taken.
The employers must also realise that it is in their interest to join an employers' organisation so that better negotiations at a high level can be carried out constantly on questions of wages, conditions of employment, and so forth. Employers, too, should be encouraged and in fact more than encouraged, forced, by their own fellows to a situation where once an agreement has been reached between the employers' organisation and the trade union, the employers will stand over that settlement to a man. Unfortunately, cases do take place when a dispute arises that negotiations take place and an agreement is accepted and then when one employer decides to get ahead of his competitors, he breaks that agreement and tries to get some advantage from doing so. Therefore criticism as regards indiscipline is not one which applies to one side only. It definitely applies to both sides.
The Government have given a lead in this matter and every possible encouragement to the unions and employers to come together and to stay together. I only hope that in due course the results of their negotiations can be made evident to us all. If the employers and the trade unions wish then jointly to ask the Government for some statutory recognition of any agreement which they may reach, I am sure the Government will be only too pleased to grant it.
There has been some criticism of the policy of allowing subsidiary companies to operate here. Deputy Dr. Browne particularly has painted a very dismal picture of what will happen to the subsidiary companies, once we join the European Economic Community. Why he thinks that, I cannot understand, because once a company has launched a subsidiary here and invested an enormous amount of money in it, it would be very reluctant to see its investment crash. I do not think there is any danger that will happen, particularly in view of the fact that in industry generally there is an increasing move to spread industry over a wide area geographically because it is much easier very often to manage a number of firms in different countries, at least in most of them, and keep production going all the time than if it is centralised completely. One labour dispute can stop the whole production. Therefore it is becoming more and more common to have subsidiary companies all around the world.
I do not think we should feel dubious about these subsidiaries but that we should welcome them. The idea that immediately membership of the European Economic Community is granted to us, we shall have 60,000 unemployed is mercifully complete nonsense. Nothing will happen all that quickly. I believe that Irish industrialists are fully aware of the position and are already working very hard to make alternative plans for production so that the number of redundant workers may be reduced to the minimum. I would hope and believe that the number of redundant workers in particular industries which may suffer will be absorbed in the new industries which are now being created.
In conclusion, may I say that I regard this whole prospect with the greatest possible excitement. We must go into this Community, not just for what we can get out of it but because we have a contribution to make towards it.
Comment on this
If we are prepared to do this with the same cheerful optimism as Deputy Dillon is now displaying, we have every reason to believe it will be a triumphant success and not the disaster he said it would be this morning.
Comment on this
Who said it? Thank God for unrestricted free speech. I am prepared to suffer almost anything for that.
Comment on this
If there is one way in which the Taoiseach is always consistent, it is that he adverts first of all to figures in relation to one facet of our economy. I refer to the industrial sector and those in insurable employment. Those are the people who can guard against an increase in the cost of living simply by ordinary trade union action. The Taoiseach always refers first to those who produce industrial goods. He says today that we have produced more and that there are more in industrial employment. Is it not true that if I simply drive a car 30,000 miles I will contribute to more industrial employment than any of us here could have done by any action of ours 30 or 40 years ago? If I shave with an electric razor, I am creating more industrial employment.
This is an age of industrial consumption. There will be more employment in that way as life becomes more complicated and less simple than it was in days gone by. I do not regard the figures the Taoiseach gave as displaying any sort of victory because we were so far behind in this field. If for no other reason than that we had a labour force here, the increase in that field was bound to have occurred. I would point to a section which comprises more than 50 per cent. of our population who are not guarded against increases in the cost of living — our farmers, small shopkeepers and self-employed people, all of whom give a service. They have to live on their profits and in most cases these profits are less than they were many years ago. They have to do that on the basis of a consumer price index and, taking 1947 at 100, that now stands at 154. Since 1957, there has been an increase of ten points. That is the reason we have got this colossal emigration.
Comment on this
I have no difficulty in telling Deputy Cunningham, if he will allow me. Last summer, I spoke to the parish priest in Newport in County Mayo and he told me of a new type of emigration. Seventy keys had been turned in 70 doors in the previous couple of years. Earlier, the type of emigration from that part of the country was of boys and girls going to England and Scotland and coming back at Christmas and for holidays. Yet Deputy Cunningham says it is not important.
Comment on this
The section to which I have referred, comprising more than 50 per cent. of our population, was not referred to at all by the Taoiseach. The tragedy about the thing is that if we move into the Common Market— and I do not say we should do so in any downhearted way—the people who will be most susceptible to the new form of competition will be the people whose jobs are less secure—the fewer than 50 per cent. of whom the Taoiseach boasted this morning. That is the situation we must face up to.
Right through the last decade, the Government have been determined at every opportunity to do things like the removal of the food subsidies to nail their colours to the mast of a high cost economy. That has been done three times with disastrous effects for the people who are self-employed, the farmers and the small shopkeepers. The Government now face the situation where, by their own action, there may be disastrous results for the other people who were sheltered by their membership of trade unions and in the Civil Service by their arbitration machinery.
The difference between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil is that Fianna Fáil never bothered about that other section of the community and that Fine Gael tried to bring them all up together. Fianna Fáil Deputies may laugh but I will tell a homely story of the count in the last general election. As we in Louth were watching the count, the figures coming in were not so hot for the Government. A Fianna Fáil county councillor came up to me and I said: "Well, what now?" What do you think he said? "Forget about it," he said. "Wait until the good ignorant Republican constituencies come in." That was his attitude. It was: "Wrap the green flag round us." You have still that ideology.
Comment on this
If Deputy Burke wants to interrupt me he will get his own back. The Taoiseach always addresses his remarks to the section of the community where the most votes can be had—the organised section. Let us consider for a while the high price economy policy of the Government. Let us take the report issued this morning—a very good report—of Bord Fáilte for the year ending in March, 1962. Then let us consider the returns published in the newspapers for this season up to August and we find that the hotels are doing badly. We know why. Go to any seaside resort at the present time and you will have no difficulty in making a reservation at a hotel. What is the answer? The secret is that tourists are now buying their own ham and their own bread and butter and are having their meals in the backs of their cars in hundreds on the main roads in the country because of the exceedingly high prices being charged by our first-class hotels. I do not suggest that hoteliers are grossly overcharging but that in the high-price economy in which we live, they must charge these prices to get a profit. We have been caught up by the actions of the present Government since 1957 and one of our major industries, tourism, is in real danger of pricing itself out of the market as a result.
Comment on this
Lest anybody should imagine I am thinking this up, I look at the "funnies" in the Evening Herald and other papers and in yesterday's Herald there was a caricature of a train outside every door of which were several pairs of boots and shoes. Underneath was the caption: “The transport people say there are tourists but the hotels say they have not got them.” These caricatures generally hit the nail on the head. The high-price economy of the Government has hurt one of our major industries.
Comment on this
If I am allowed by some of the Fianna Fáil backbenchers who have not contributed to this debate, or attempted to do so, I want to refer to the cost of public transport. The cost is exceedingly high. That is a result of the policy laid down for CIE. I do not suggest that the people in CIE should lose their jobs or that there should be a savage cutting down of services, but that as branch lines are closed and people can be assimilated elsewhere, it should be the policy of CIE—which it is not—to restrict their activities and leave transport of goods and people to private enterprise competition, if there are citizens willing to undertake it.
Comment on this
We got back as far as the Suez Canal. Deputy Burke did not come from a hotel here but from another establishment.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I must direct the attention of the Chair to the fact that we are not discussing exclusively the Supplementary Estimate for the Taoiseach's Department. We arranged, out of courtesy to the Taoiseach, to take the Supplementary Estimate as the Adjournment Debate. We are not discussing the Estimate exclusively.