We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 119–244 of 244. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Before we discussed procedure. I was saying that CIE should leave the transport of goods and people to private enterprise competition when they have assimilated the people displaced by the closing of branch lines. In that way, you will get a decrease in the cost of transport, which has moved to an extraordinarily high level here, much higher than in England or on the Continent and that is another reason why we lose tourists. Tourists employ our people and earn badly-needed foreign currency, thus helping the balance of payments. CIE must be restrained or led to see what the situation should be, because in a big company like CIE the trend is always to expand.

I remember talking to a certain ESB official about the fact that they were in competition with ordinary traders, selling refrigerators and other articles which the ESB sell with great advantages because of their particular situation. I argued that there was no reason why they should compete with ordinary traders who were paying rates and were citizens of the country when the ESB have the advantage of being able to turn off the light and not having bad debts. He replied that when you have 700 or 800 employed in selling refrigerators and other appliances, each one seeking a chance of promotion and each one seeking security in employment, you do not stand in the same place in business. You move forward or backward. Every big company wants to expand and I believe the Taoiseach should dictate, as he may do, to CIE, a policy of opening to free competition the branch line routes that have been closed and so decrease the present cost of living in some way.

The Taoiseach was chided this morning for not telling the Oireachtas in the first instance, some things he told other people regarding the implications of our joining the Common Market. It is quite understandable that the Taoiseach should be a bit reticent about this because the whole concept by which he sought to convince the people that he was the genius of industrialisation was in danger. No doubt, the industries he did suggest here are those that existed behind tariff walls. No doubt, they could be described as feather-bedded industries in some cases, or industries that charge more at home and sell their supplies abroad at a lower price. Without going into individual cases, that is true. All that will not be permissible in the Common Market if one looks at the provisions of the Treaty of Rome.

Taking the section that deals with the free movement of goods, Article 9, on page 27, of the English version, there is a paragraph which says:

The Community shall be based upon a customs union covering the exchange of all goods and comprising both the prohibition as between Member States, of customs duties on importation and exportation and all charges with equivalent effect and the adoption of a common customs tariff in their relations with third countries.

There is no way out, no way you can get past a free customs union of six or ten countries and we all confidently expect it will be ten. In that situation, it is quite natural that the Taoiseach should be very reticent and should like to gloss over the whole thing. I believe, however, that he must face it and, in reply to this debate, say what the facts are and say what are the political and other implications.

There is one other matter which is a political matter and one to which I have referred before. If the number of votes for Fianna Fáil that were cast for the maintenance of insular economic isolation could be counted, it would be found that that is what has kept them in power for 30 years. It is quite true that people voted for them on the basis of the Sinn Féin policy in industry which is now as dead as mutton.

Comment on this

That is the way you would like to see it.

Comment on this

I would be happy to see the Sinn Féin policy with regard to industry as dead as mutton. I refer now to the policy, not to the industry. We should not get hypersensitive about the Common Market and it was the Taoiseach's duty to refer to other matters in which the Government have a great responsibility. One of the things to which I would like to draw attention is health. I know that we put up a policy with regard to health in the last election and that we put down a motion when we came back to this House to which the Minister for Health put down an amendment and as a result of that we are now meeting in a Select Committee on Health. We are all well aware of those things and the Taoiseach cannot cast aside his responsibility in these matters.

Comment on this

The Deputy had six years in which to do it and what did he do?

Comment on this

Quite a lot. I could tell the Deputy what we did but I am not going to be put off by Deputy Burke's bad mannered act. I am going to deal with the situation in regard to health. It is quite possible in this country for two old age pensioners living together not to be able to enjoy the provisions made for the lower income group. It is quite possible at the same time for four or five of their sons or daughters to be spending all their money or drinking their heads off and at the same time to hold individually green, blue or whichever is the relevant colour of health card.

At the same time, there is so much confusion in relation to the health services that yesterday I had to dictate 20 letters to the responsible officer in my constituency in relation to health matters. It is the Taoiseach's job to see to it that everybody in this country does not have to go for their medicines or whatever else they get on the basis that it is charity. There is no reason why any Deputy in this House should have to write one letter, not to say 20, in relation to health to any officer of his local authority. What the people are entitled to they should get proudly and not as a shilling or a half-crown being given to a beggerman. There is no reason why the Taoiseach should not be asked to get over that difficulty. If our Select Committee on Health sits for a long time and then produces its recommendations it is quite obvious that the Government is going to go through this term of office without doing anything about it. As I have said it is possible for two old age pensioners living together——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That would seem to be more relevant to the Estimate for the Department of Health.

Comment on this

I thought this was the Adjournment Debate, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is overall policy which is being discussed, not the administration of individual Departments.

Comment on this

I will not pursue the matter further except to say that it is time the Taoiseach would know that these things can happen. The same is also true with regard to the specification of hospitals. Even with the great personal nature of the medical profession we find that patients must take what is afforded them even though there are hospitals close to them which provide the services they need to others.

The Taoiseach adverted to agriculture's share of the national income. The Leader of the Opposition said that by taking in each other's washing we can increase the national income on a book keeping basis. There were a few statements made by the Taoiseach which indicated to me where his heart lies and where his thought moves. He said that the national income was increasing faster than the increase in the incomes from agriculture and he said that this was very pleasurable to him but that a proper balance had not yet been achieved. He then mentioned Denmark and Holland which are agricultural countries but which have a much greater proportion of their national income represented by earnings from industry.

That would be a fair approach if we had full development of our agricultural resources and almost as full a development of our industrial resources. The situation here is that for various reasons the potential of our 12,000,000 acres of arable land has not reached 50 per cent. in production and, at the same time, our industries are largely supply industries behind tariff walls which supply the needs of our people.

In that situation the Taoiseach must decide where he is going to look for any increase in our national income. He implied that he was going to look for it in industry rather than in agriculture. On this side of the House we believe that both sides of our economy must move together but that, as they move, the greatest potential exists in agriculture. We believe that 50 per cent. of their potential is not being extracted from the fields of Ireland. We believe that if the Taoiseach would live up to his responsibilities and provide a proper agricultural advisory service, as advocated by the Leader of the Opposition, and also provide at least a minimum amount of capital to each farmer for specified purposes to be watched over by the agricultural advisers and if we could proceed with the diversification of our agricultural productivity that we would get from our arable land a return that would stagger this country.

The Taoiseach does not believe that. He believes that the gap between the income from industry and the income from agriculture should widen with agriculture at the bottom and industry at the top. That is where he goes wrong. I should like to quote paragraphs 33 and 34 on page 20 from the Grey Book on Economic Development which is so well known to the House. Paragraph 33 says:—

In general, however, it would seem that attention should be concentrated primarily on raising the efficiency and volume of production in agriculture and in industries based on agriculture. Otherwise, there is little chance of avoiding economic stagnation and a continual loss in population. The measures already in force —extensive and costly though they are—have not succeeded in increasing agricultural output at a satisfactory rate or on a fully economic basis. The provision on a wider scale and the wholehearted acceptance by farmers of expert technical advice and assistance is needed. Means will have to be found to secure increased use of fertilisers, improvement of grasslands, more efficient and extensive use of homegrown feeding stuffs for conversion into export products, the reduction of costs and prices through increased yields and better marketing arrangements. It is necessary to re-examine existing measures of financial assistance in order to relate them more directly to increased and more efficient production. Separate chapters are devoted later to matters such as these.

Paragraph 34 states:

At this point, it need only be emphasised that, if an increase in agricultural production at competitive prices were achieved, the purchasing power of the farming community would be greatly raised and their demand for goods and services stimulated. The effect of this in creating additional employment in industry and services is vitally important because the possibilities of absorbing labour in agriculture are limited. Indeed, the provision of lasting employment turns on the concurrent development of manufacturing industry (mainly for export) and of tertiary industries, particularly tourism. But all this can be set in motion by improvements in agriculture, where the immediate potentialities of increased production are very great.

Yet the Taoiseach this morning put the cart before the horse and exposed the Fianna Fáil philosophy of keeping the farmer happy by giving him some little sop to keep him from creating too great a fuss, but, at the same time, keeping the upsurge on the other side.

Some extraordinary statements were made which I could not let pass. Deputy Booth made an extraordinary statement on land reclamation. He said that land reclaimed under Part A remained in good heart and did not revert to its previous unproductive state, while that reclaimed under Part B did. I cannot understand that. I do not think he realises that the same operations can be carried out on both lands and it is merely a difference in the methods of paying for them.

Again, the Deputy said he reacted very much to the proposal to increase beef production. Does he not know that it is estimated that by 1965 there will be a deficiency of 380,000 tons of beef in the Common Market countries? Is that not one of the lines on which we can go forward? He said you cannot produce beef without producing milk. That leads me to feel that Fianna Fáil do not want an increase in agricultural production. They got the answer from this side of the House: diversify your production into chocolate crumb, dried milk and all the other milk products for which there is a market in the world today and which I hope Bord Báinne will exploit. It is amazing that, when Deputy Booth was saying these things, Deputy Medlar said in a loud voice "True". Here is a man from Carlow-Kilkenny who does not at this stage understand the Land Project.

Comment on this

Nobody understands the Deputy.

Comment on this

The last time we were talking about milk, Deputy Burke left the House in a hurry and it might not be a bad idea if he did so now, too. Deputy Carter referred to the fact that farms were much smaller on the Continent and gave the impression that everything would be all right when we enter the Common Market. You cannot compare the size of farms on the Continent with the size of farms here. Did the Deputy ever hear of an olive grove or oranges in the sun? Acres do not count in relation to these things. These are things which have been there for years. From one acre or half an acre, a farmer in Italy or the South of France may be getting as much as a farmer with 25 acres here. We have not got the sun here, but we have something else. We have better production of grass. It is quite extraordinary that here, where we have the temperate products everybody wants, the prices in the hotels are scandalous because of the high-price policy of the Government.

Deputy Carter made another statement which should be corrected. He said we were savage critics of the Department of Agriculture on this side of the House. I want to put it on record that we are not, but we are proud to be savage critics of the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Personalities again.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke has asked whether or not this is a personal attack. Of course, it is an attack on his policies and not on the Minister himself. I have no interest in him.

Comment on this

The Deputy is hedging now.

Comment on this

Deputy Carter also referred to the rate of agricultural exports but did not refer to the fact that since 1958 there has been a decrease of 337,000 in the number of cattle on the land. Whether that is due to the T.B. Eradication Scheme or the beef subsidy last year, we do not know. That figure and the figure for agricultural exports are fixed figures nobody can fiddle with. The people on the land have not enjoyed a better living. Some of them may have enjoyed the same living by living off their own fat.

The Deputy took pride in the fact that 80 per cent. of the store cattle exported last year were attested. Is it not obvious that, if you have a beef subsidy and, at the same time, are slaughtering cattle, the reactors will go out as beef cattle and as sides of beef rather than as store cattle? These are merely statistics which are useful for the local paper, but that is all. If anybody comes up with another statistic, that is the end of it.

If there is one other way in which the Taoiseach and the Government have failed the country, it is in regard to education. At Question Time to-day, we had a series of questions concerning the facilities provided in Government Departments for the learning of Continental languages to fit us for the Common Market. While it is true that adults are trying now to brush up their French and other languages, nobody has said that the children in our schools should get proper tuition in one Continental language. This is something the Taoiseach can direct. He is giving grants to secondary schools and he can direct the type of education to be given. The same thing applies to national schools. But the Taoiseach has not done so.

I shall give you my own experience, which is, I am sure, the experience of many Deputies on both sides. I went from the Christian Brothers to a college. I started off with Latin, English and no Continental language and I finished that way. If I am wise, I will try to teach myself one Continental language in the near future. Is it not true—Deputy Dolan may laugh; he is a teacher—that when one reaches secondary school level, there should be at least one Continental language on the curriculum? Is it not true that there is more reason for compulsion in relation to at least one Continental language than there is for compulsion in relation to our own language?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

That is certainly my view. I would sooner have a situation in which our people would be on a par with the people of Denmark, Holland, England, and everywhere else.

Comment on this

I would prefer that they should be on par rather than they should not be. If compulsion were removed——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies must allow Deputy Donegan to speak.

Comment on this

If compulsion were removed, more Irish would be learned and spoken. In the great majority of cases—I have said this before—the mark of an educated Irishman is that he has no love for the language. He has no love for it because it was shoved down his neck.

Comment on this

And the mark of an educated Welshman or Scotsman is that he does know his language because it was not shoved down his neck.

Comment on this

I do not intend to enter into a discussion here on the policy of the Irish language. I think it is relevant and I think it is a tragedy that the Taoiseach has not availed, even at this late hour, of this opportunity to tell us that he is negotiating with the secondary schools to ensure that at least one Continental language is taught to the children. The Taoiseach has sat back, happy and complacent. There was no mention of languages. There is no excuse for that. Languages are most important. This marks just one more direction in which the Government have failed.

Finally, I should like to point out that Ireland will never be a completely organised community. It will always have a high proportion of self-employed people, people providing small services in their own immediate community. I do not think these people have any greater claim on the economy than organised industry, and the people employed in it, have. I do not think they have any greater claim on the economy than civil servants, local authority officials, or anyone else, but I think they have got as good a claim, and I do not think this Government has given them as good, and for a very good reason; they are not as good a political fiddle to play. What we want now is a Government that will look to their needs as well as to the needs of those who are very often in a better position to help themselves. This Government has failed in that respect and the sooner they go to the country and give us a chance to do it, the better it will be for all concerned.

Comment on this

I listened with attention this morning to the Taoiseach's speech. It was very reserved. It presented quite a good report. I was amazed later when the Leader of the Opposition, who also showed great restraint, seemed to agree entirely with the Taoiseach, especially in relation to our entry into the Common Market. We may take it now it is ipso facto a fait accompli. I have no complaint in that regard.

To show how foolish I am, I thought, having heard these speakers, that we might be concluding here at five o'clock this evening. There did not seem to be any great bones of contention. It seemed feasible that we should finish at five o'clock. I have sat here since shortly before six o'clock. The first discordant note struck in the debate was that struck by the two Fianna Fáil speakers who spoke since six o'clock. They gave the impression they were on the defensive. Why I do not know. I listened then to Deputy Blowick. He seemed to think there had been a good deal of acrimony in the debate, but up to that hour I was not even aware of spasmodic sniping across the floor of the House.

It was pleasant to listen to Deputy Anthony Barry. He referred to education. He made a very fine contribution in my opinion, reasoned and unbiased, objective and devoid of any suspicion of a personal factor or any element of Party politics. His contribution seemed to be quite sincere. I should not have the temerity Deputy Booth had, treating the House to a travel talk, with emphasis on Continental features of agriculture. I know nothing about agriculture. I have, however, said here before—I think this is pertinent—that any subsidisation there may be of agriculture should be for the purpose of enabling farmers to improve their premises and increase the wages of their farm labourers. When factories are being built in rural Ireland, immediately the contractor goes on the site every agricultural worker will try to find a job on the site. Normally he has to work much harder than his counterpart in the building trade. His wages are much lower. We have brought that on ourselves with this industrial development. That aspect ought to be considered.

The Taoiseach gave the employment figures for the year 1961. They were not bad at all. The fact that emigration is decreasing is a good thing. Some years ago the Taoiseach sent out a call to our emigrants to come back. He said today that we are now experiencing a lack of skilled craftsmen in this country. Our emigrants in Britain are not getting better wages than they would get here. Building trade operatives in Dublin are paid better than their counterparts in London.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

They work very much longer hours in England. They work all day on Saturday and, in many cases, on Sunday, too. They may get greater money for working much longer hours. Why do they not come home? It is because there are no houses for them here. I appeal to the Taoiseach to consider the position of these people. They have become trained operatives. They are anxious to come home. Can they be housed if they do? They cannot. As Deputy Sherwin said the other day, there is no hope of their being housed for the next ten years. I am sure Deputy Burke has experience of Dublin city. There is no hope of providing houses for these people. Even a letter from the Taoiseach will not procure a house. There are married couples, with one child, sharing a room. These are the conditions. A rosy picture has been painted of other sectors of our economy. I appeal to the Taoiseach, when he has time to relax during the recess, to give consideration to this question of housing.

I was impressed this morning when Deputy Dillon referred to the small farmer looking over the gate admiring his little bit of land. Yes, that is good. Could we take an analogy? Can the Taoiseach do anything to ensure that the people living in the 40,000 houses owned by Dublin Corporation can purchase their homes? That would be a greater factor in stopping emigration than anything else. It would give these people a stake in the country, just as the small farmer has a stake, so that no matter how bad conditions might be, the small farmer will remain. I understand that the great obstacle is that the Government subsidy would cease if the local authority allowed these tenants to purchase their homes in which they have lived for over 20 years and in some cases over 30 years.

The Taoiseach has been accused of being the greatest feather-bedder. The old age pensioners do not think that. They have no feather bed.

I trust I shall never get to the stage when I just want to talk from one side of the House to the other, as the Opposition to the Government, but I was disappointed with the social services provisions. I have shown my disappointment in the House. I supported the Government but I was disappointed with the social services, more than disappointed. Even at this late stage, I would appeal to the Taoiseach to think of this section of the community since we are giving so much thought to the industrialists, the hoteliers and the other sections who seem to be getting a good return for their efforts. The old age pensioners have made their effort in the past. Many of them contributed much to the establishment of this State that has developed to the stage where we can join a Common Market. If our membership of the Common Market means the eventual removal of Partition, maybe it will be a very good day's work.

I have not the experience of industry that Deputy Booth has. I hope the Common Market is a success. I am not particularly concerned whether it is under a Fine Gael Government or a Fianna Fáil Government, but I hope this country may be successful. To quote Lincoln, we want government for the people—that is as it should be— not for individualist, not for the display of jealousies across the House, of which we have had so much even in the short period I have been here. As I have said before, I have not spoken often in this House because I wanted to learn from my elders. It is with regret that I say I am afraid I did not learn much.

Comment on this

I just want to refer briefly to the last speaker. He had a great deal to say about the old age pensioners and expressed disappointment with our system of social services generally. I should like him to tell the old age pensioners in his constituency that when they were getting an increase and when the Fianna Fáil Government tried to be as generous as the resources of the State would allow, Deputy Carroll voted against that increase. He really voted against that increase. I am not sure whether any of my friends saw him going through the Lobby or not but I think he did vote against the increase. He cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

I did not vote for 2/6d.

Comment on this

It is our intention to improve the lot of our less fortunate brethren in every way possible.

I listened to Deputy Donegan this evening. I came in peaceably to the House. My intention was not to speak at all because the Taoiseach had spoken on our behalf and I felt that was enough but having listened to Deputy Donegan I decided I would answer him on a few points.

Deputy Donegan made the point that we were not concerned with the farming community, that he had the cure for all ills, that his Party represented the intelligent outlook and that anything that was to be got for the farmers would be through his Party, that if the farmers would vote for Fine Gael, we would all be living in a Utopia.

I shall go back only a few years, to 1955 and 1956, when we were faced with the position that this State was almost shipwrecked. Deputy Donegan referred to land reclamation, lime subsidies, and so on from which the farmers benefited under the inter-Party Government. The position in my constituency in County Dublin was that reconstruction grants could not be paid. There were no lime subsidies, there was no such thing as land reclamation, no such thing as the building of schools, no such thing as the building of houses. I have the honour to represent part of the city, as well as County Dublin. As an indication of the economic position in the city, may I say that there were about 1,800 families who left their homes due to economic circumstances under the inter-Party Government in 1955 and 1956?

Comment on this

A quarter of a million left since you got into office—250,000.

Comment on this

The trend is the other way now.

Comment on this

I do not know. They are still going the Taoiseach said.

Comment on this

We can take it up outside the House. I challenge anybody to take me up outside the House as well as inside the House.

Comment on this

Well, now, we would have a nice burden to carry, God bless you.

Comment on this

The trend is the other way. The people are coming back so quickly from England now that Dublin Corporation are not able to house them quickly enough. Since we took over in 1957——

Comment on this

A quarter of a million went.

Comment on this

I am grateful to the Deputy for his assistance with my speech but if he will allow me to make my point, I shall continue. In 1956, 1,800 families left Dublin. They are not leaving now to anything like the same extent.

Comment on this

They have all gone.

Comment on this

They are coming back now.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Burke is entitled to make his statement.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I am upsetting the Leader of the Opposition by telling the truth. I can assure him it is not my intention to upset him. I am merely stating facts. In 1956, in my own constituency of County Dublin, 350 houses were built for which people could not obtain SDA loans. All we got in this House was legislation by the then Minister for Local Government, Deputy O'Donnell, debarring people of a certain income from applying for ordinary SDA loans. On many occasions when I was in Opposition, I asked him to make an honest statement that there was no money in the kitty for building houses and not to be deceiving the people that there was plenty of money and that they should keep building.

Comment on this
A Deputy

He gave much more money than you did.

Comment on this

All you have to do is to ask any of the contractors in the city of Dublin.

Comment on this

Ten million pounds in 1956.

Comment on this

In debts.

Comment on this

Ten million pounds in grants paid to the people.

Comment on this

There was not the price of a bag of cement when you were in office. People could not get money for houses. Contractors had to clear off to Canada, Australia and other places.

Comment on this

You will not let them start to build now.

Comment on this

That was the position until Deputy Paddy Smith became Minister for Local Government and enabled the contractors to honour the commitments they made on the advice of the previous Minister for Local Government who said there was plenty of money. At that time tradesmen were leaving for England and could not get away quickly enough. Not alone was the building trade declining but every other industry was feeling the recession.

Now we are asked what has Fianna Fáil done in the few years in which they have been in office. I remember the Taoiseach, the then Minister for Industry and Commerce, saying when Fianna Fáil were defeated in 1948: "We are handing this State over to you in a sound financial position. Give it back to us in the same way." We did not get it back in the same way. We got it back on the wrong side in 1951 and from 1951 to 1954 we had to take steps to rectify the weakened economic position. Being a national Party we were concerned for the wellbeing of all sections of the people. We always put the interests of the nation before our own personal interests.

Deputy Donegan was speaking here of food subsidies. We had to do a very hard thing in 1952. As a Deputy I was keen enough at that time to be concerned about the people that sent me here from County Dublin at a time when a tough Budget had to be introduced which would react on us as a Party. We had to take a decision in relation to the subsidies and although we were defeated in 1954 the people gave us a vote of confidence in 1957 and put us back in office.

The country is making considerable progress. The farming community is advancing and the workers who have got the eighth round of wage increases have improved their position. There is no such thing as an applicant for an SDA loan being refused. In regard to agriculture I wish to pay tribute to the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Smith, who I believe is one of the finest Ministers for Agriculture this country has ever had. During his time as Minister for Agriculture he has had one of the toughest jobs any Minister could have, namely, responsibility for the bovine tuberculosis eradication scheme which was completely neglected by previous Ministers. He has done everything possible to hold the English market for the Irish farmer. Deputy Donegan said there was a market for the by-product of milk. Does he really think that any Minister for Agriculture would turn his back on a market if it was possible to provide one? I can assure Deputy Donegan and any of his friends that the Minister for Agriculture and his Department have left no stone unturned to get markets for agricultural products. As I say, Deputy Smith has done a very good national job and posterity may have reason to compliment him. He had to do in a few years a job which should have taken at least 20 years to accomplish, and he has done it well.

I do not want to delay the House because I know there are other Deputies who want to speak. Generally speaking, the economic position has improved and the standard of living of our people has improved as has their purchasing power. There is a number of things about which I may not be pleased but we can deal with those as time goes on. One problem that arises is that, due to our industrial drive in the city and county of Dublin, the workers are coming back from England to take up employment here and, therefore, there is a greater need for the provision of houses. The machinery that is there for dealing with the position is not adequate. Because of the new prosperity and the greater numbers employed, we have these housing problems in Dublin county and city and I would ask the Taoiseach and the Government to do everything possible to relieve this problem.

Comment on this

If there are any difficulties on the lines Deputy P.J. Burke mentioned, it is to get people to come back to their houses. Of course there is also the problem that there are now fewer houses being built than when the inter-Party Government were in power. The facts and figures are here but they have been quoted time and time again. I was glad to see today that the Taoiseach reiterated the reversal of Fianna Fáil policy from which this country suffered for many years when he says there is no future for any feather-bed enterprise here now. The Taoiseach and his Government were the fathers and mothers of feather-bed enterprises in this country and many feather-bed enterprises prospered under the protection given to them by Fianna Fáil Governments.

Comment on this

Better feather-bed than feather-head.

Comment on this

In his speech this morning, the Taoiseach threw another burden on this side of the House when he announced that we must be prepared to take risks in the economic sphere. What kind of risks? When, where and in what circumstances are these risks to be taken? Is this House to be left with a vague generality that we must be prepared to take risks? It is not the sort of statement the Leader of a Government should make here in the most important policy debate for the year. The House and the country are entitled to hear from the Taoiseach what exactly he means by the general statement that we must be prepared to take risks.

Does the Taoiseach mean this is going to be a game of political pongo— that we will throw the ball and hope it will go into the right hole? If he wants to take risks, he will find many industrialists who will take risks with him, provided they are not risking any or very much of their own money. There are plenty of wise boys ready to avail of anything they can get from Foras Tionscal because there is in this regard a generally dangerous trend in respect to industry in this country. If there is one motive more pressing than the profit motive, it is the motive to avoid loss and if you can find in this country that you can get sufficient financial incentive from the Government to ensure you will not make a loss, then the only motive left is the profit one.

I fear there is a fair amount of Irish capital bound up at the moment in enterprises here which could fold their tents in the morning without any great loss to anybody involved but with a fair amount of loss to the Irish people. I would again ask what further extension of this risk policy is implied in the statement we heard from the Taoiseach this morning. If that is the sort of risk the Taoiseach envisages, I trust he will accept it from this side of the House that the most stringent investigations will be insisted upon on behalf of the Irish people. The Government are the trustees of the funds of the Irish people and if we are to embark on further risks, it behoves us on the Opposition benches to inquire diligently into the reasons for those risks.

I mention that aspect of it because, in my view, there is a growing tendency on the part of the Taoiseach, on the part of his Ministers and of his backbenchers, as we saw when Deputy Donegan was speaking earlier in the evening, to become arrogant to the point of being objectionable when any valid, legitimate criticism comes from this side of the House. Only last week when the Leader of the Opposition, very rightly, as he had a mandate to do, made certain references to a coincidence which happened in respect to the enforced resignation or dismissal of a Civic Guard, the Taoiseach got very annoyed and said it was scandalous.

Comment on this

It must have been scandalous.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This does not seem to me to be relevant.

Comment on this

I am making a general observation in respect to the attitude of the Government towards criticism.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes, but does this reference to the alleged incident involve administration of a Department or the direction of a Department? To say that it involves overriding policy, general national policy, is really carrying it beyond the level of reasonableness.

Comment on this

Surely it is quite open to a Deputy to object if the Leader of the Government describes as scandalous something which the Leader of the Opposition said or any other member of this House said in the performance of his legitimate duty?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair does not take that view.

Comment on this

Are we not discussing the Taoiseach's Estimate?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We are.

Comment on this

Surely at some stage a Deputy is entitled to object when the Taoiseach makes remarks of that nature. Otherwise, at what stage may a Deputy discuss such a matter?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

On the Estimate for the Department concerned.

Comment on this

I am not referring to any Estimate. I am referring to a trend which has made itself evident in the Taoiseach's behaviour. I shall quote from the Official Report, at column 2348, for 17th July, 1962 :

Mr. Dillon: This is not a matter to be passed over in this way. The plain truth is there is a great deal of public malaise in regard to this matter. The plain truth is there is an outstanding coincidence in the fact that this member of the Garda Síochána was, in the course of his duty, associated with the prosecution of a member of the Government. Immediately after this he is involved in this extraordinary discipline story——

The Taoiseach: That is a scandalous statement to make. The Deputy should be ashamed of it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

How can that be elevated to the level of national policy?

Comment on this

It is symptomatic of a trend in the Government. I am using particular facts to show this trend.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow that to be discussed on this Estimate. It does not seem to be relevant. The Deputy may find it easy to say, but that does not put it into the category of national policy for which the Taoiseach is responsible.

Comment on this

If I say plainly that the Taoiseach is trying to stifle legitimate criticism from this side of the House and that his attitude of arrogance——

Comment on this

This is the Estimate of the Taoiseach who very properly said to-day——

Comment on this

This is the legal expert from Longford——

Comment on this

Keep the light-house quiet. The Taoiseach stated this was a review of his activities and of the activities of his Government for the past 12 months. The incident Deputy Barrett is now discussing concerns an intervention in the debate by the Taoiseach and goes to show the trend of behaviour on the Government benches.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I gather now that a single incident of this kind is being elevated to the position of a matter of national importance.

Comment on this

I am not trying to elevate it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Then I shall ask the Deputy to pass from it.

Comment on this

I should like to point out, arising out of the remark of the Chair, that I am not trying to elevate this to a matter of national importance by using a single incident to show what is the general trend. The reason I raise it is that I think it is important in the interests of rights of members of the House that they should be entitled to argue——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies are always allowed to argue in a relevant manner, but to discuss the particular incident here is giving it undue prominence.

Comment on this

We are now discussing the Taoiseach's Estimate and, if so, we are surely entitled to discuss the actions of the Taoiseach in Dáil Éireann. This is the Taoiseach's Estimate and that is the occasion on which you discuss the conduct of the Taoiseach in the administration of his general responsibility in the past 12 months. If, as Leader of the House, the Taoiseach misconducts himself, is that not relevant——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If it is alleged that the Taoiseach has misconducted himself, there is a perfectly ordinary way of dealing with it—by motion.

Comment on this

Is this not a motion?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a motion dealing particularly with the alleged disorderly remark of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

It is a motion dealing with all the disorderly remarks of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I content myself with complaining of the trend I see in the Government Front Benches of describing legitimate criticism coming from this side of the House as disgraceful and scandalous.

If we are to embark on this policy on which the Taoiseach hopes to embark, I think the House is entitled to get much more information on matters of that kind. The Government have shown themselves unwilling to give this information in recent months. I trust I shall be permitted to mention an incident yesterday when a Dáil Question asked the reasons why the trial of a Senator was removed to the Central Court and Parliament was told it was not desirable that it should be informed of those reasons. I consider that a shocking invasion of the rights of Parliament. If Parliament cannot be told, who can? The Taoiseach says it is not usual to tell the judge. I am not interested in that, but the House has the right to demand from the Government the reasons why a citizen is removed from trial in the circuit court and put in the dock in Green Street.

The Taoiseach gives as the reasons that they had the interests of the man in question at heart. He forgot to tell us that the man in question was legally advised by his counsel and solicitor that it was not in his interest. He is an educated man, fit to hold a professorship in a constituent College of the National University and fit to sit in Seanad Éireann. It is ridiculous for the Taoiseach to try to avoid his responsibility to answer a question here by putting forward such a case. I realise that the answer might cause embarrassment somewhere but it is not the Taoiseach's or the Government's business to avoid causing embarrassment, if the liberties or rights of any citizen are at stake. I protest most vigorously against this invasion of the rights of Deputies.

I also regret the trend by which Deputies asking questions about CIE, broadcasting, etc., are told that the Minister has no function. I know that is our own fault; I know this House was responsible for it by voting away its rights; but I appeal to the Taoiseach in the future not even to invite the House to vote away the rights it has and which it should preserve on behalf of the Irish people. In my view, if this continues, Parliamentary democracy will die rapidly. The process has been accelerating in this House of late.

I do not intend to say much about the Common Market but I am sorry that no Deputy, so far as I know, who has so far spoken has gone any further than investigating the economic aspects of it. The Taoiseach at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis and on other occasions gently suggested there were other ramifications. There is a political background to this but nowhere, so far as I can see, in the literature supplied to the House or to the country to date has there been any exhaustive examination of what is probably the more important aspect of the Common Market, the political aspect.

We have a Constitution. The Taoiseach told us in an airy sort of way that it might be necessary to amend the Constitution, if we enter the Common Market. It should be pointed out to him that he cannot amend the Constitution, nor can we. The Irish people alone can do it. When the Taoiseach went to Brussels to discuss the Common market, did he go in armed with a copy of the Constitution and say: "Here is a fundamental document by which our hands are tied and we can give no promise that will take us one iota beyond the terms of that document?"

It is strange that the Leader of the Government should come back and say in an incidental fashion that at some stage it might be necessary to amend the Constitution. That is probably true but I do not think it should be said or envisaged until we know what the people think. I object to the fact that the Irish people have been almost completely starved of information on the political implications of the Common Market. We know we shall have to surrender much of our sovereignty, but there are certain aspects of legislation in which our hands are tied, both by tradition and the Faith which the majority of our people adhere to. It has been truly said that the legislation of a country is the aggregate of the collective conscience of the governed. Our collective conscience is displayed in our Constitution and our laws. They are Catholic and Christian, adhering to certain immutable principles in some respects. If we surrender our sovereignty to some supra-national Parliament, no matter how federal it may be, we may very easily reach the stage where we find ourselves up against certain aspects of international legislation to which we cannot conscientiously subscribe. That is a distinct possibility.

The people should be instructed on these aspects of the Common Market. We should stop calling it the Common Market and call it something to indicate that it is a political union, in the hope that the Irish people will become a little more inquisitive about it. I am not suggesting that I object to entering the Common Market, but if the Irish people are now instructed in every aspect of it and told that it is not merely a matter of bread and butter but that it might become a matter of spiritual and moral problems also they will be in a better position to indicate through their representatives in this House and in the Seanad to the Government exactly the line the Government should take.

We are being forced into the Common Market by virtue of the fact that we are close neighbours of Britain. If we go in, let us try to do so as far as possible on our own terms. I know that is not at all possible on the economic side but I think the Government should be in a position to insist that, if they become subject to legislation, they should be entitled to make our views very plain.

I do not want to keep the House much longer. Deputy Donegan referred to the activities of Bord Fáilte Éireann. He referred to the fact that it was quite easy to get bed and breakfast in any hotel in Dublin at the moment. He referred to the fact that tourists preferred to take their meals at the side of the road than enter a hotel. He indicated the reason for that was not that the hotels were overcharging but that the cost of foodstuffs was so high that they could not afford it. I am not ready to be so indulgent. Many hotels are pricing themselves out of a highly-subsidised market which Bord Fáilte has with immense industry and money voted by this House built up. There are hotels here in Dublin where there is price for a visitor with an Irish accent and one, much larger, price for the foreigner. I regret that is so. It is something of which the Taoiseach should take note. It is a sequel to the activities of Bord Fáilte which should be deprecated.

Comment on this

This has turned into one of the most amazing free-for-all debates one could wish to hear. Some time ago, we had Deputy Blowick and six, seven or eight other Deputies. We had the expected contribution from Deputy Dr. Browne and nothing lower, I think, could be delivered in any House of Parliament in the world, but even more amazing than all these contributions was that of Deputy Desmond with his typical replica of a fair day speech. At the time, I was inclined to take Deputy Desmond seriously because I did not realise until later— he is returning now—that he was just killing time in the hope that his pals from Galway would return in time for the vote here tonight. Deputy Desmond, however, was not aware at that stage of the hospitality of the people of the West. His pals from Galway will not be back in time for the vote tonight, whether it is brandy or something else they are getting.

From Deputy Desmond's contribution, one would think we were in a kind of concentration camp in this country and if we were not, that we should be put into one. It was an extraordinary contribution to a debate of this type, particularly when one considers it came from a member of the Labour Party. Surely a member of the Labour Party should be inclined to praise the workers of the country and make known to the workers their good qualities, instead of trying to publicise something that is not happening at all, saying that we are in the nature of a nation of parasites. If Deputy Desmond's contribution were printed in toto and if the industrialists of Europe read it, no matter what facilities we offered, no matter what incentives we made available, I do not believe that one of then would come near us to set up any type of industry. It is most discouraging to hear a man who gets up and tries to hold up Irish employers and workers to ridicule because these workers are the very same people who have gone to the ends of the earth and proved themselves the most capable workers in the world.

Comment on this

Even on lighthouses.

Comment on this

Even on lighthouses. It is a shocking state of affairs that any man should come into this House and try to hold Irish people up to ridicule before the world. We are on the brink of joining the Common Market and most of the contributions regarding our entry into the Common Market are made by doctors, solicitors, briefless barristers and others who have not a head of cabbage at home for themselves, let alone anything to sell in the Common Market, but when a member of the Labour Party comes in and makes a profound statement to the effect that our employers and workers are disreputable, something is seriously wrong. The people in Europe may not be able to read English and it would be a good job if they were not, because if they read that kind of stuff they must take a very dim view of us indeed. It would be much better for any Deputy to give our employers, our workers and our Government, the credit they so richly deserve. They would be doing a better day's work for us and our country.

I have listened to all this story of gloom which has been presented here by certain people, usually by people who are not in power themselves and who did nothing for the people of the country or for the country in any way. Now when they can do nothing for anybody, for the country or for its inhabitants, they come in with every type of panacea that can be thought up. I do not know whether they dream them up at the bar counter or in bed at night, but wherever they come from, they are of no consequence. They know well that when they were in power, they did nothing. They know well they will never get back in power, so they can go on pouring out propaganda which is no use to our people in any way.

Travelling around the country, I find a completely new spirit alight in our people, a great sense of security and a great get-away from what we saw in 1956. It is difficult for the members of the Fine Gael Party, and of the Labour Party who combined with them on two occasions to wreck the economic fabric of the country, to have to listen to this, but, whether they like it or not, they will have to listen. If there is not a bright future for this country inside or outside the Common Market and if prosperity is not in front of us, that will not be the fault of the Government or the ordinary people. It will be the fault of a great lot of pessimists who cast aspersions on the efforts of the Government and on the Irish people.

I want to compare, for the benefit of the Deputies of the House and in the interests of truth, the position in my own constituency now and in 1956. In 1956 in the constituency which I represent, North Mayo, it was impossible for any man to get a day's work. There were no industries of any type and even the effort to develop Bord na Móna and an electric power station was completely negatived by the second Coalition Government, or whatever other silly name they called it. When they came into office, they wiped out the effort to establish industries there. What do I find in my constituency today? Let me be fair and honest. We cannot get sufficient people to work in the industries. If Deputy Blowick says that a few miles away in South Mayo something is wrong, the only answer I have to him is: it is a pity they do not have in South Mayo the type of good representation we have in North Mayo.

Now Bord na Móna is employing hundreds of people; Bellacorick power station is employing hundreds; the grassmeal company which has been started will in a short time employ many more people; the Glenamoy peat experimental station employs 50 men; the Moy drainage scheme employs hundreds more. Nobody here can refute these figures. What had we in 1956? We had nothing of any description. Even if a man worked for the county council—and there were not many working—he could not get a shopkeeper who would be inclined to take his cheque. That is all changed. I know these facts sound very nasty in the ears of the people who ruled the country at that time. But that will not alter them.

In 1956, we had not a fishing boat along the coast of my constituency except one idiotic thing sent up to Murrisk by the Coalition Government or whatever they called themselves. At present we have scores of these boats. Inside one week six boats were delivered to one fishing village alone. To-day the Government are prepared to survey the coast-line of my constituency and give us the landing facilities we have asked for. As a contrast to that, in 1956 Deputy O.J. Flanagan, the famous bog road questioner, who at that time was a Parliamentary Secretary, went around to every cove and inlet in my constituency and shed crocodile tears. The only effect it had was to make the sea deeper. He provided no landing facilities of any description and he was threatened that, if he came there again without doing something, he would be thrown into the Belmullet Canal. Naturally, he did not return.

I can put up with a good deal of nonsense and listen to hypocrisy for a while, but there comes a time when anybody must call halt. I would not be doing my duty to my own constituents if I did not get up and explain the position. Today we are getting a grant of practically £75,000 for a factory in the town of Ballina. Here are the gentlemen who a few years ago got a man elected down there on the strength of false and silly promises about a biscuit factory. You never produced anything west of the Shannon during your period of office. To-day we are getting a factory in Ballina and we will probably get more than one factory.

Comment on this

To-day you can get grants for creameries. Any scheme which can give employment in the West is getting Government support, and getting it without having to use any type of political pull. If there is any Deputy who leads his constituents to believe that just because he happens to be a member of the Opposition he is not entitled to meet a Minister or get a civil reply from a Minister or get what he wants, he is simply not telling the truth. The reason he is not getting what he wants is that he has been too lazy to ask for it, that he has fallen down on his responsibilities towards those he represents. Of course, he goes back to his constituents, having forgotten what he was asked to do, and blames the Government. There is no Deputy who cannot go to any Minister and ask what his constituents want. If he does go to a Minister he is treated civilly. I do not mind what kind of allegations are made against Ministers here. They are untrue and are made purely for political propaganda.

I have seen the change over the past six years. I want to be fair about it. I want to give the Government credit for the change which has taken place. I have seen it in my own constituency. I have travelled through several other constituencies. It is an amazing thing that I hear practically no grouses or grumbles. It is very significant that I have to come into this House to hear them from members of the Opposition. I think that is fair comment on the state of affairs in this country to-day. I hope it will long continue so.

Comment on this

Ní raibh mé chun labhairt ar an Meastachán seo go dtí gur chuala mé an méid adúirt lucht an Fhreasúra. Ba mhaith liom cúpla focal a rá ag bréagnú an méid atá raite acu.

Having listened to the pain and woe from the majority of speakers in the Opposition Benches—I am not including Deputy Anthony Barry, who made an intelligent contribution—one is prompted to think that the people who made those contributions never have any ambition to sit on this side of the House. If they had, I do not think they would make such destructive criticism at a time when our nation is faced with one of the most momentous decisions it has ever been called upon to make in its history.

The world in which we live today has changed enormously over the past 30 years. Today we are living in the jet age, and ways and means of doing things have changed out of all recognition. There is a tendency among the population to move from one area to another. Because of historical circumstances, a number of our people were forced to live on the Western seaboard and other poor lands. They now wish to move into better land, if it is available, or else to move into the cities. That accounts in great measure for much of the flight from rural areas, about which we hear so much talk. Did it ever strike the people who cry so much about it that you cannot expect people in congested areas to live on the same farms on which their grandfathers had to eke out a meagre existence? It is a great thing that people are able to move from these areas and have a better living in some other part of the country.

I do not think there is any need for me to enumerate the great achievements of Fianna Fáil since their return to office. Suffice it to say that all the debts which were handed over to them at that time have been wiped out.

Comment on this

What debts?

Comment on this

For housing, health and hospitals. I could instance my own constituency, where in 1956 housing collapsed completely because there was not a penny in the Local Loans Fund.

Comment on this

The houses were built.

Comment on this

That is an undeniable fact. Deputy P.J. Burke gave Deputy Rooney figures for his own constituency. Deputy Rooney did not interrupt Deputy Burke because he knew they were the facts. The despondency which existed then has been removed. Now, in my constituency, we have better roads, better houses and better schools. That is the picture not only in my constituency but in the rest of the country as well. The days have gone when the Road Fund has to be raided, when road workers could not earn a penny, when they were laid off in farms and in factories and had to take ship to foreign countries.

New industries have been created, providing more employment for our people. Many of those who went on the excursion to Shannon were, I am sure, surprised to see how far industry had progressed in that area, despite the fact that it is not very long established there. I have no doubt whatever that, if we enter the Common Market, more and more industries will find their way in here to absorb any who may remain unemployed.

It is a well-known fact that we have made tremendous progress in the agricultural sector of our economy. As Deputy Carter pointed out, over 80 per cent. of our cattle have now been attested, thanks to this Government's provision of funds to ensure that farmers were paid for their reactors, instead of having to sell them in the open fair to their neighbours, as happened in the time of the Coalition Government, thus spreading, instead of checking, the disease.

There are grants now for every form of agricultural activity for those who wish to avail of them. Industry has now branched out into food processing to absorb surplus agricultural production and negative to some extent any repercussions resulting from the present situation in relation to butter.

So far as education is concerned, the emphasis to-day is on science. It will become more and more important as a subject in future. The backlog in the schools' erection programme has been caught up on and education is going ahead. Some Deputy mentioned something about foreign languages being taught in the schools. It may be all right to give people a smattering, for that is all it is, of some foreign language in the secondary schools. It was rather shocking to hear an aspirant to the position of Minister for Agriculture, sitting on the Opposition front bench, assert that people are uneducated because they know their native language. He should be ashamed to make that statement. That is an argument I simply cannot comprehend. When we go abroad, and when we enter into competition with the other countries in the European Economic Community, we will be respected because we know our own language, because we are proud of our ancient heritage, and because we are good, nationally-minded people. To be good people internationally, we must be good people nationally.

That is the spirit in which this Fianna Fáil Government have approached this matter. We have a united Cabinet with a man of the calibre of the Taoiseach at its head. We are moving in the right direction. We need have no fears. The obstacles are not insurmountable. We have a well-defined policy; we have a healthy national outlook. There is no danger of our being swallowed up in any association we may have with the European Economic Community so long as our national policy remains sound and we stand fast by our heritage, our language and our country.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): I intend to deal with only one small aspect of Government policy. Most of us can remember when, quite some years ago now, a national transport system was established here. The Great Southern Railways, and other railways, were joined to form Córas Iompair Éireann. Some time later, the Dublin United Tramways were incorporated. Simultaneously, all the existing bus services on the roads were absorbed into a nationalised transport service.

For quite a number of years, this service was run as a subsidised social service. It provided a scheduled service covering the entire country in relation to both passengers and goods. It remained a bankrupt service all through the years. Annual subventions were voted by this House to help it pay its way. In 1958, a Transport Act was passed making a considerable difference in our approach to transport. That Act gave Córas Iompair Éireann commercial freedom as regards rates and fares. It also gave them power to negotiate package deals from which they have been able to secure an income of almost £1,000,000 per year. It gave them complete power to shut down branch lines where they considered such lines were not paying their way. It allowed them to pay compensation for any redundancies that might arise where branch lines were concerned.

In spite of these various legislative helps, the railways continued to prove insolvent. Although the deficit fell at the end of March, 1961, to a sum of £700,000, in March, 1962, the deficit was £1,600,000. Córas Iompair Éireann have said that the eighth round wage increases involved them in an expenditure of almost £2,500,000 and the increase in the deficit as between 1961 and 1962 is attributable to that eighth round increase. They have shut down large sections of railways in Clare and Cork. The Minister for Transport and Power came before this House recently asking for a large sum of money to increase the number of diesel engines from 175 to 212.

It would seem now that this Act has changed the entire pattern of, and the entire approach to, transport here. I will mention briefly the changing pattern over the past 20 or 25 years. With regard to goods transport, many Deputies can remember that 20 years ago, and before it, Messrs. Guinness had various sub-stations up and down the country. Their stout was dispatched by railway and distributed from these various centres. That has disappeared. The product of that concern is now carried by large tankers.

Deputies may also notice that recently CIE had a contract for bringing malting barley from all over the country to the Guinness concern. It has now been decided to bring that barley in bulk in specially made containers rather than in bags.

In 1933, 1934 and 1935, the Sugar Company, which was then beginning, had no transport of their own. Now the Sugar Company have about 100 lorries available for their own transport. Wheat in those days was not a commodity of much importance in this country. Wheat growing in recent years has become important and the transportation of wheat has largely fallen into the hands of the millers and the larger dealers.

Distribution of lime has passed into the hands of CIE and the Sugar Company. The distribution of fertilisers, likewise. Transportation of cattle is largely done by CIE and the cattle dealers.

In short, over all these years commercial transport as we know it here has been largely passed into the hands of either CIE or semi-State bodies or the larger commercial firms and on the other side of the picture, private transport, where the people can afford it, has passed largely into private motor cars. There has been a steady increase year by year in the number of private motor cars on the road.

Two sections of the community have remained outside that, namely, the small businessman who cannot afford to provide his own transport or who may not be allowed to and the ordinary private person who can afford nothing more than a bicycle. These people have largely to be served by a public transport service, in this country by CIE and there has been no alternative service for them.

When CIE was in its early stages of establishment and even before it was established, licensed hauliers were supplied with a plate. As far as I know, practically no plates have been issued to private hauliers since about 1935. In those days the ordinary type of lorry was about 2½ tons and the area it covered in the ordinary course of business was about 25 miles. Nowadays, the type of commercial lorries we see on the road are usually ten-ton lorries belonging to the bigger firms and they cover 50, 60 or 100 miles. The difficulty arises that in all these years there has been no increase in the number of plates issued to private people who may look for them and there has been no adequate allowance for the type of transport which we understand is the fashion nowadays, the larger lorry. In other words, private hauliers have been handicapped as regards area and as regards size of lorry which they may utilise.

To give one practical example of how this causes hardship in my area, I had occasion recently to make representations for a man who had a lorry. He has had a plate for that lorry for a number of years. He was engaged in bringing milk to the local creamery for the farmers. He found his work increased but he had not sufficient work to utilise two lorries and to provide two men for the two lorries. He could not get a larger lorry because he was hemmed in by the regulations as regards weight which pertained to his lorry.

Furthermore, in my area during the beet season, for instance, the Sugar Company may utilise their own lorries or may engage CIE but during the peak season the private man, whether he has a licensed plate lorry or just a private lorry, may be engaged in this work but he has to pay a commission to CIE. A farmer is not allowed, for instance, to carry his neighbour's agricultural produce, a few animals, perhaps, into the local mart. He is summoned immediately if he does so.

A situation has arisen that a lorry with a plate entitling the owner to cover the 26 Counties can be sold for the extraordinary figure merely for the plate of £5,000. This is what restrictive practice emanating from legislation surrounding CIE has resulted in.

Furthermore, if we look back over the years, we find no new type of private bus service has developed anywhere in our community. A few private bus services operate here and there throughout the country—two services operate in my area—but these are usually services which CIE consider not sufficiently profitable to bother about.

It is now proposed to shut down many more railway lines and even the present number of lines which it is suggested to shut down is not the end of the story for, if it is pursued to the limit laid down in the Beddy Report, not alone will the present sections be taken out but further sections will be taken out at a later date so that ultimately, in order to put the railways on a solvent basis, by 1964, we will be left with merely a skeleton railway service.

I make a point that we have passed the stage of having a subsidised social service which we had a number of years ago supplying the whole country and enjoying a virtual monopoly, that now we are entering the phase of having a commercial competitive service and by virtue of that fact the time has arrived when one should consider abolishing in part or in whole the relative monopoly enjoyed up to the present by CIE.

I suggest to the Taoiseach that he should consider abolishing the present restrictions on licensed lorries as regards area covered, weight carried and merchandise carried, that he should consider a freer issue of trade plates for private persons and that he should consider to a certain extent the abolition of the existing restrictions on the provision of bus services from private sources. These more liberal conditions could, in particular, be applied to those areas, sometimes extensive areas, in which branch railway lines have been taken up. I believe that in this fashion we would secure more adequate competition and not alone that, but help the small business man and the ordinary private passenger. If a small business man has a choice of engaging a private lorry or a CIE lorry, there is straight away an element of competition introduced. If that were done, we would provide a living for a number of small people, small farmers and small business men who would be in a position to secure a lorry and use that lorry for hire.

In many small countries, people are able to make a nice thrifty living on private haulage and here is an opportunity by which any private individual could develop a worthwhile living for himself and his family. The Minister for Transport and Power says the time has not arrived to depart from the relative monopoly position enjoyed by CIE and adverts to the fact that private haulage systems such as I have mentioned would have certain defects; first, they may not pay trade union wages and, secondly, they would be run as a family concern. What crime is it to run these things as family concerns? I think it is a very praiseworthy activity and nothing would please me more than to see a poor family putting their resources together and establishing such a service. In the present condition of monopoly enjoyed by CIE, that chance is not available to them. The time has arrived when we should consider the removal of some of the more restrictive practices associated with CIE and the provision of a more competitive and more complexive service.

Comment on this

In my opinion, this is one of the most important debates that takes place each year and this is my fourteenth experience of listening to a debate prior to the summer recess, when Government policy for the previous 12 months was examined and any matters of importance in regard to the remainder of the period of office discussed. In that period of time, this is the first occasion on which I have seen only one member of the Government contribute to the debate. In every Adjournment Debate of this nature, it is customary—indeed, it is almost essential—that the leading members of the Government participate in the discussion. It is generally accepted that the Tánaiste, the Minister for Local Government, the Minister for Lands and perhaps the Minister for Education come in here with a brief and give the Government's viewpoint on the various aspects of policy for which these Ministers are responsible.

However, we have had no contribution today from any member of the Government except the Taoiseach and without any disrespect to the other speakers, may I say the only other speakers of Fianna Fáil allowed to speak here were backbenchers who are mostly seen and seldom heard. Why is that? Is it not a fact that today we have the first opportunity for discussion of the problems that face this country, if our application to join the European Economic Community is accepted? Is it not a fact that this debate is one of the most eventful, one of the most significant, that has taken place in this House as a result of certain disclosures that have been made in connection with Government policy on the political and defence commitments that are likely to result, if our application for membership of the EEC was accepted?

The strains of the past 12 months or so are beginning to tell on this Cabinet. It was pathetic here about 20 minutes ago when a speaker behind me from the Belmullet area spent a quarter of an hour praising the Government. The Taoiseach and the Tánaiste looked up pathetically at the Deputy while he related the wonderful achievement of their Government. He reminded me of little flowers turning their faces to the sun, hoping to get a little bit of warmth or some little encouragement in a very dark field. It is a poor sun that shone on them from the bucolic quarters behind me here this evening. I know I am not entitled to describe that person in terms which I feel would fit him but I do say that in older times there was always a gentleman called the court jester and when the king had great difficulties on his mind, the court jester was at his best in order to distract the unfortunate monarch from the affairs of State.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy McQuillan should not liken a member of the House to a court jester.

Comment on this

I did not name anybody.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not liken any Deputy to a court jester.

Comment on this

I am drawing a comparison. I did not suggest he was a court jester. I am talking about medieval times.

Comment on this

He said he was like one.

Comment on this

"Court clown"—would that be a better term?

Comment on this

At any rate, it is quite apparent from the attitude of the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste that the strain of the past 12 months is beginning to tell on the Cabinet. It is quite apparent to the public at the present time that respect for law in this country is beginning to deteriorate and the Government can blame themselves for the feeling that is abroad that justice now depends on the side of the House one belongs to or how well in one is with a particular Government.

We have had the position—I had hoped to be able to raise it on another Estimate which has been postponed and which dealt with Law Charges— in which we have the Attorney General engaged in a part-time private practice and engaging in part-time responsibilities only for the State. We find that individual in his private practice going to a court to defend people like insurance companies, one of which was found, in the words of a High Court judge, to be guilty of illegal practice. Those companies, in my opinion, should have been dealt with by the Attorney General as a prosecutor instead of as a defending advocate. How can he adopt this Jekyll and Hyde attitude? How can he dispense justice and look after the public interest if in his private capacity he defends a company found guilty, I suggest, of illegal practice?

This is the gentleman who is devoting so much of his time to his private practice while a man like Singer slips through his fingers. Is it not a fact that it is through the faulty preparation of the prosecution's case against Singer—the responsibility of the Attorney General—that this man is now sunning himself in Spain? If the Attorney General were to do a full time job, as he should be doing, justice would have been done in that case. The two I have mentioned are only instances of the many cases which are disturbing the public mind at this moment.

The Taoiseach should also bear in mind that, when I refer to the Department of Justice, there is grave disquiet at some of the actions of the Minister for Justice in his capacity as Minister for Justice and in particular, that there is grave disquiet among the Gárda Síochána as a result of his activities. I have not the slightest doubt that the strains of office over the past 12 months are beginning to tell on the Cabinet. That is apparent in the fact that the Minister has had to sit here most of the day unhelped, unprotected, unloved.

Comment on this

He does not need any help.

Comment on this

He is a marvellous man. All his predecessors needed help, including, as he then was, Deputy de Valera.

Comment on this

As the Taoiseach spoke this morning, he put a number of Deputies into a deep slumber. His speech, for the first hour, was composed of a mass of statistics. He produced a number of new records which had been achieved by the Government since they came into office. I shall not bore the House by repeating them except in a few instances. The first record we had was an increase in the population. Mind you, the Taoiseach produced statistics to prove that. I think he deserves a trip down to the West of Ireland, to Athlone, to Belmullet, or even to Cork, where he will find the only people he will meet are on the trains making their way quickly to England.

That statement alone, when read by the people of rural Ireland, will cast doubts on the veracity of the remainder of his speech. He went on to tell us the great record we had for tourism last year. He said there was a tremendous improvement in the tourist industry. I am sick and tired in this House pointing out to the Taoiseach and his Government that the majority of the tourists who come to this country—in fact, 70 per cent, of them—are Irishmen and Irishwomen returning home to Ireland on holidays from Britain, America and other countries. Apart altogether from those returning emigrants, it is an extraordinary state of affairs that every Irish businessman who leaves for London to do two or three days' work is classed as a tourist if he registers in a Dublin hotel when he returns.

It is fantastic to suggest that tourism, in the sense of foreigners coming in here, provides the greatest proportion of our income from what is called tourism. Most of that money is from Irish people coming here to visit relatives and to enjoy themselves. Not only do these people provide huge sums of money to help us bridge our balance of payments gap but we receive each year £14,000,000 by way of emigrants' remittances. It is true, therefore, to say that it is the money we receive from our own people returning on visits here and by way of remittances from those abroad which help in no small way to keep this country going and it has been Government policy over the years to depend to a great degree on the export of our people for the money they send back each year. Without the Irish tourist and the Irish emigrants, the West of Ireland today would have no population whatsoever. It is not Government services, it is not employment or social services or anything provided by the State that are keeping the majority of the small holdings in the West going. It is the cheques at Christmas and in the summer from the sons and daughters who had to leave the country as a result of the disgraceful incompetence of Governments throughout the years.

At the end of his hour's statistical survey, during which he put the House into a deep slumber, the Taoiseach referred to the Common Market and said Ireland's application for membership had been further considered last Tuesday by the Council of Ministers, that after considering it, the Chairman sent for the Irish Ambassador and informed him that the Irish application was being referred back to the Council for further detailed study. I think that was the most significant statement made today by the Taoiseach. In face of it, we can forget all about the statistics.

Why was the Irish application considered last Tuesday? Is it not a fact that this Council have been overworked for weeks dealing with the British application? Is it not a fact that the Taoiseach, later on in his speech, pointed out that they were so busy that it would be a considerable time yet before they had an opportunity of dealing with Ireland's application? Why did they pick last Tuesday? Would it be correct to say that the Irish Government suggested that another look should be given at the Irish application which, after all, was in before the British application or that of any other country still outside the EEC? Would it be right to say that this alleged examination of the Irish application by the Council of Ministers was for the purpose of issuing a warning to the Irish Government to "get cracking," in the words of Fianna Fáil themselves.

I say that because at a later stage the Taoiseach made another admission in the course of his speech. He said we were not going to wait for the Common Market to reduce trade barriers and to end protection in certain industries, that we must start now. Why did he make that statement? Is it not a fact that he was told, through his ambassador, by the Council of Ministers that it was all very fine to use high-sounding phrases, to say Ireland is European in its outlook and that we would abide by all the principles and decisions of EEC and the Council of Ministers wanted to know what practical steps the Irish Government were taking to be in a position, if offered membership, to abide by the rules and regulations?

Today the Taoiseach said that EEC members know Ireland is prepared to participate fully and effectively in the Common Market. Does it look like that when we have the Taoiseach now saying that we must take the necessary steps to end protection and reduce tariffs before entering the Common Market?—not that I object to any reduction of tariffs or protection. I suggest the Taoiseach made that statement because the screw was put on him by the Council of Ministers. I was not given a copy of the Taoiseach's speech and I can only go on my hearing.

The Taoiseach went on to say that the length of time available for Ireland to adjust herself to the Common Market situation was only the period available to the other countries, to the end of 1969 or the beginning of 1970, and we will be required by that time to dismantle certain protective systems and be on the same basis as countries already members of the Common Market. Was it pointed out that the fact that membership would not come, possibly, until the middle of next year was no help to this country in the sense that it only shortened the time in which we would have an opportunity of taking off protection?

It is quite apparent that when the Taoiseach had to make that statement today, the situation as regards Ireland's application from the Taoiseach's point of view, is anything but hopeful. It is no good his coming to the House and saying he is going to take action in connection with certain industries, going to cut out the feather beds. As far as I am personally concerned— and other speakers here and people outside—he has been warning industry for the past five years of what he was about to do. He has threatened, and tried to persuade them to change their outlook. Were it not for the fact that this warning has been given by the EEC Council of Ministers, no steps would be taken. I look forward with interest to seeing what measures the Taoiseach proposes to take.

It is now 12 months since the Irish application went in last July. We applied for full membership before the British. We were first off the mark as we were so anxious to take part. When that application was made, the Council of Ministers requested further elaboration of the Irish case and the Taoiseach himself supplied it under three heads: first, the political aspects of it; second, the agricultural aspects; and third, the difficulties likely to face what the Taoiseach described as "basically sound industries" resulting from membership. He clarified a few other points such as the question of the gradual removal of protective barriers so that there would be no shock to the Irish economy by having to take severe action in that regard overnight.

I shall deal with the last point first, the difficulty facing some of our "basically sound industries". The Taoiseach admitted today that the time for sleeping is past, so far as some of our industries are concerned. The period for adjustment is so short that severe action must be taken by the Government, if these people, on their own, are not prepared to take the necessary steps. I fear the position, so far as some of the so-called sound industries are concerned, is even worse than would appear on the surface.

During the recess and later, we shall have reports on different industries from the Committee on Industrial Organisation. So far that committee has reported on a group of industries and the position in which they will find themselves as a result of our entering the Common Market. The Committee has reported on the cotton rayon and linen industries as follows: that there are over 5,000 people employed and that even if productivity were increased by 50 per cent. as a result of Common Market membership, one-third of that number would lose their jobs. Out of 5,000 people at present employed in that industry, over 1,600 would lose their jobs as a result of Common Market competition.

The report went on to say that if the present set-up is maintained, many small and medium-sized mills would find it difficult to survive. Since that report came out, what action have the Government taken as regards rationalising those industries? What steps are to be taken if that investigation is correct and 1,600 out of 5,000 employees will lose their jobs? As Deputy Dr. Browne pointed out today, on reliable reports available, at the minimum, over 60,000 people are likely to lose their employment as a result of membership of EEC. What steps are being taken to find alternative employment for them, in addition to the huge number of unemployed we have at present? Are we to wait until 1965 or 1966 to take practical measures to deal with a situation of that nature?

It may be argued by the Taoiseach that these industries and others, on which reports are made, are basically sound, that only one-third of the employees will lose their employment, but what will be the position in the mushroom industries dependent on the importation of all the raw material for processing or assembly here? What will be the position of the companies into which Irish capital has been lavishly poured, companies which are at present not asked to pay one penny in tax on what they make as a result of their exports? Is it not a fact that in these cases there is little or no hope of the survival of these industries in the Common Market? Is it not also a fact that Irish capital will go down the drain? Those people can then bale out without any personal loss and the Irish worker will be left to shift for himself. The Irish people will lose, so far as employment and investment are concerned.

In his explanatory statement to the Council of Ministers, speaking on the situation in regard to the loss of employment, the reorganisation of industry and the removal of protective barriers, the Taoiseach said that the solution for the Irish difficulty might be found in an alteration of Article 226 of the Treaty of Rome or under the provisions of the protocol dealing generally with the subject of tariff reductions and that that might be a way out to enable Irish industry to remain on its feet.

The Article to which I refer states:

In the course of the transitional period, where there are serious difficulties which are likely to persist in any sector of economic activity or difficulties which may seriously impair the economic situation in any region, a Member State may ask for authorisation to take measures of safeguard in order to restore the situation and adapt the sector concerned to the Common Market economy.

One of the best known French economists has stated that the Common Market is a lawyer's paradise. Some of the provisions of the Treaty of Rome can be read in so many different fashions that it is quite unreasonable for people to take one exact meaning from them. The trouble is that the people who drew up the various Articles are the best judges of what they wish to extract from them, and not the interpretation that the Irish Government will put on them.

Already in those countries there has been a reduction in all protective barriers to the extent of 50 per cent., if not more. It is expected that by 1970 all barriers will be down. Is there any hope that we will get another ten or 15 years to ease our position and save our industry from being shattered? Can we get in without having to jump on this very fast train? The position at the moment is that the express train of the Common Market is rushing along and we are asked to jump aboard from a standing position. What is likely to happen to any man who tries to board a fast train while it is moving? He will crash. That is likely to be the position of the country because we are not fit in present circumstances to stand a reduction in our protection barriers of 50 per cent. to bring us into line with the reductions that have already taken place in the other countries.

Will the position not be that many of those industries will collapse? Will the position not be that the Irish worker, like his counterpart in Southern Italy, if he does not make the trek to London, will have to make the trek to the European cities to join the peasants there from Southern Italy, to work as the economic serfs of the Germans, the French and the other highly industrialised groups who at present control the industrial sector of the Common Market?

Southern Italy, to a great extent, can be compared with Ireland, and particularly with the West of Ireland. In spite of any improvements that are taking place in Southern Italy, there is a constant flow of their best young men to work in the industrial cities of Germany, as a result of a shortage of labour and the attraction of high wages. That will be our position as far as I can judge it, because there is no incentive for countries like Germany, if Ireland becomes a Member State of the Common Market, to come here when they can draw Irish labour to their huge concerns in their home countries. It would be nonsensical for them to break up their industry into small units for the benefit of the Irish people. It is a much more economical proposition for them to have huge units and draw hundreds of thousands of workers to work in those units. There are huge towns today, bordering on those areas, the populations of which are composed of Spaniards, Italians and other poor people, and there is a niche ready there for the Irish people.

Comment on this

And the RIC men.

Comment on this

I do not have to count to ten again. Article 2 of the Treaty of Rome is full of pious aspirations about the desirability of economic expansion and a rising standard of living in the countries which comprise the Common Market. That Article will be trotted out to the Irish people. It suggests that it would be a wonderful and desirable thing to have a rising standard of living and economic expansion, but it does not say who the rising standard of living is for. It does not say one word about full employment. In the Treaty of Rome, there is not one sentence in all the articles that says full employment is one of the rights of all nations. Employment is to be given on a laissez faire principle. It will be a matter of competition and if there is a big pool of labour available, it is too bad for labour. That is in the interests of big business.

There is no guarantee whatever of employment within a particular State. There is no guarantee that the Irishman will get employment at all. Fianna Fáil have said for years that it was one of their principal planks— they got it from other groups—to achieve the goal of full employment. That is forgotten now in this mad rush into the Common Market and if there is not full employment here, it can be found in Germany or France. That is the case where private enterprise rules the roost, and the provisions of the Treaty of Rome are all loaded in favour of private enterprise. If the State intervenes against private enterprise, the State will lose. As we all know, it is the big business groups and cartels that control the existing economic set-up in the Common Market.

The second point the Taoiseach clarified, or tried to clarify, at the Council of Ministers, was the result of our application on agriculture. He rightly emphasised in his remarks the importance of the British market to us. He omitted to point out that that country was of such importance, apparently as a result of putting all our eggs in one basket, and his failure during his years as Tánaiste and the failure of the former Taoiseach, now in the Park, to look for alternative markets. They also failed to provide shipping to carry our produce from here to Britain. He failed to point out that over the years, he and his Party spoke in sneering terms of John Bull and threatened to twist the lion's tail.

The Taoiseach said that the British market was of vital concern to us. Having pointed out that, the Taoiseach said that he supported the European Economic Community policy which provided for orderly conditions of trading and equal marketing opportunities. I subscribe to the part of that statement where he said he would like to see orderly conditions of trading. Is it not extraordinary to find the Taoiseach going outside the country to tell us that he does not like chaos or disorganisation, but that he subscribed to the principle of orderly trading? In agriculture in Ireland, we have had disorder and chaos over the years. The small farmer was exploited by the bacon factory. The wheat-growing farmer was at the mercy of the millers. The small farmers who grew grain did not know where to get a market for it. Where was the order there? Where was the order in regard to our markets in Britain? Had we, over the past 20 years, a marketing board that would bring order out of chaos? Let us examine the position clearly.

We have no experience on this side, no training, no tradition of organisation in marketing or production. We have an awful lot to learn in that regard. How we are to learn that overnight so as to subscribe to the views and policy of the EEC in that regard is something I cannot fathom.

The Taoiseach went on further in his statement to the Council of Ministers. This was significant:

There will be certain areas in Ireland faced with the problems of structural reorganisation.

That was in reference to agriculture. That is a most significant statement. When we talk of structural reorganisation in agriculture, it simply means that the smaller farmer in Ireland has to go to the wall.

Only two days ago, a leading article appeared in the Irish Times in which the leader writer gave a further exhortation. He said that further ruthless depopulation of rural Ireland must be planned. It is an accepted fact in the EEC countries that about 8,000,000 people are to go out of agricultural production. Alternative arrangements are to be made to place those people in industrial employment. It is quite clear that the same fate—depopulation or the wiping out of their holdings — faces the Irish small farmers as a result of competition in the Common Market.

That fact has not been exposed or shown to the public or told to the small farmers in Ireland. The Taoiseach went on further to say that the relatively young horticultural industry here might find some difficulty in adapting itself to Common Market arrangements. Was there ever a greater understatement—that the horticultural industry will find itself in some difficulty?

The British farmer, as far as the horticultural industry is concerned, is the greatest opponent of the Common Market today because horticulture which is well developed in Britain cannot hope to survive, unless protection is given to the British farmer. What chance has the Irish horticultural producer in the face of that? What protection does the Taoiseach hold out to the farmer who is in horticulture in this country?

Only six months ago, the Taoiseach and his Ministers went around the country pointing out that there would undoubtedly be difficulties for industry but that it would be of advantage to the Irish farmer. We had the same statement by the leaders of the National Farmers' Association and, I think, Macra na Feirme recently. But the Taoiseach, in the past three weeks, has back-pedalled on his former statements about the Utopia alleged to await the Irish farmer on admission to the Common Market.

The Taoiseach now knows—if he did not know it formerly—that the picture is anything but rosy. I find it hard to believe that such an intelligent man as the Taoiseach was not aware that the Irish farmer would be up against the greatest difficulties as a result of membership of the Common Market. I find it hard to understand how a man in his position would not think it his duty and his responsibility to let the small farmer know exactly what would face him. But, of course, if it were to be done from a political point of view, there was only one way in which it could be put across on the farmers and on our people. There was only one way in which they could be led to their execution and that was blindfolded, hoodwinked and doped to prevent them from knowing their fate if Ireland joins the Common Market.

The EEC countries are able to produce at the moment 90 per cent. of their agricultural requirements. You might say the only two items of agricultural produce for which there is a hope for the Irish farmer are mutton and, to a limited extent, in my opinion, beef. But I feel that, even in the beef end of it, the picture is not half as rosy as it is painted by those who have an interest in this country.

I am talking only about what I have read in various journals that were sent here from Europe and from Britain. I can only make my own interpretation of the figures and the reports I have read. What I have read in that regard certainly does not correspond with the Taoiseach's statement as to the future of Irish agriculture inside the Common Market.

The position is that in Britain at the present time we have a favoured market. We are favoured customers. We have, shall we say, more favourable terms of trade than the continental countries—those six countries which are members of the EEC—as far as agricultural produce is concerned. Still, the Danes and other countries are able to beat us hollow in the British market, although they have not the same privileges.

Seeing that Britain is our major customer, if Britain joins the Common Market, does it not mean that the Danes, the Germans and other members of the Common Market will then move into the British market on the same terms as we have there now? If we are not able to compete under the favourable circumstances we have at the moment, how do we hope to compete successfully if the barriers are down, so far as European countries are concerned?

I do not know why the truth cannot be told by the Government on this. I cannot understand their anxiety to get into the Common Market. I cannot understand why a number of prominent Churchmen in this country allow themselves to be used by the Government to persuade the Irish people that the Common Market will provide another Utopia.

I have read a booklet recently called The Irish and the New Europe. This was issued because the Taoiseach praised the author of it as a result of a statement made within the past few months to Catholic workers by a certain Bishop, Dr. Philbin. Deputies Dillon and Lemass were present when the Bishop made his statement.

When it comes to politics, I shall not apologise to anybody for criticising any man who takes part in politics. I do not care what he is, what his rank is, if he comes into the political arena of realistic politics, he must expect to be criticised.

I know that when Dr. Lucey of Cork showed up the conditions in rural Ireland, it was not long until the Government suggested that his criticism was incorrect and that his statements should not be believed.

This is what the other Bishop had to say:

Perhaps the basic reason for our condition is that we do not take our work seriously enough.

That is one of the exhortations to our people—we do not take our work seriously enough. Those are very encouraging words to the small farmer of County Galway, of County Roscommon and of County Mayo who is put to the pin of his collar to exist— that he does not work hard enough. They are grand words of encouragement to the boys and girls who are exploited by unscrupulous employers in various categories at present and who are the unorganised labour of the community. Those words are small encouragement to the farmer who is exploited by the bacon curer or the flour miller. There was one very truthful statement in that pamphlet and it was this:

It is the function of the moral component of our make-up to provide the fortitude necessary to endure the reverses and disappointments which are sure to form a proportion of our experiences. This truth, let me insist on it as a final word, must be accepted by the whole nation.

In other words, we must have the fortitude and courage to bear the reverses and ills that are likely to befall this country as a result of membership of the Common Market.

The Taoiseach may laugh but I do not see anything to laugh about. The Taoiseach hailed that statement and I do not believe at this stage in saying that our misfortunes in the past were, and our misfortunes in the future will be, due purely to the will of God. A lot of our misfortunes in the past were of our own making and so too will a lot of them in the future and there is no good in saying: "it is the will of God." There is no good calling on the Almighty and saying it is not our fault, or turning the other cheek and saying nothing can be done about it. If that viewpoint is accepted, it means the exploiter, the racketeer and the chancer has a full rein on the ground that nothing can be done about it. It means the small farmer, whose numbers are disappearing at the rate of 4,000 to 5,000 per year—which is a figure that cannot be contradicted— can look on it in this way: that he was too lazy, that he did not work and that he must bear with fortitude the fact that he can now work in Germany or Italy or London, while his home is bought up by a foreigner, a German, a Frenchman or somebody else, who under the Treaty of Rome is entitled to come in on the same terms as an Irishman and buy up the land. That is what faces the small farmer. His land will be bought by the man who will be employing him in the E.E.C. countries, Germany or elsewhere, and there will be a new plantation in Ireland.

The third point I should like to deal with is in regard to the political implications which the Taoiseach explained as far as Ireland was concerned to the Council of Ministers. On that, there is no need to bore the House, but I would say that the House and the country owe a debt of gratitude to Deputy Dillon, the Leader of the Fine Gael Party, for disclosing today in his opening speech the report of a statement made by the Taoiseach to Mr. Sulzberger, the correspondent of the New York Times. Whether we like or dislike Deputy Dillon or agree or disagree with him, he has at long last brought the Taoiseach out into the open on what the Fianna Fáil position is as far as the defence and the political implications of the Common Market are concerned.

For the past 12 months, Deputy Dr. Browne and myself and other Deputies have sought by all possible means in this House to extract from the Leader of the Government what the political and defence implications were for Ireland, if we joined the Common Market. We were told various stories. We received evasion, equivocation and, were I within the rules of order, I would say we got downright dishonest statements from the Taoiseach but I believe I would not be within the rules of order if I said that. At no stage did he come out honestly and say yes or no. He sought to evade his responsibility to the Irish people.

It would do no harm to quote again what has been quoted several times already today, a statement which should have been made here in this House. According to the New York Times for 18th July, the Taoiseach told this gentleman:

We are prepared to go into an integrated union without any reservations at all as to how far this will take us in the field of foreign policy and defence commitments.

I have read every speech on which I could lay my hands made by the Taoiseach and every report of every interview given by him in the past 12 months and sought by Dáil question to extract some statement on that matter, but we could not get an iota out of the Taoiseach, but to the New York Times he discloses the Government's mind and policy. I am not criticising the fact that it was made for the benefit of readers in New York or foreign cities; what I am criticising are the implications of that decision.

This House was to be taken into the confidence of the Taoiseach if any decision was made by the Government in connection with this vitally important matter for the Irish people. On May 9th last in the Dáil Debates, at column 458, I asked the Taoiseach:

Are not the political and defence commitments vitally important, apart altogether from the industrial and agricultural commitments? If it were found that there was a workable agreement in regard to the latter, could it happen this country would then join EEC, without realising what the defence and political commitments were likely to be?

The Taoiseach: I refer the Deputy again to the terms of the Rome Treaty.

What was that? He could tell a journalist from the New York Times that we were prepared to go into the whole matter, so far as defence commitments were concerned, but he could not tell a Deputy.

Comment on this

He was a good judge.

Comment on this

I further questioned the Taoiseach:

Would the Taoiseach say which comes first — the political and defence commitments or the industrial and agricultural commitments?

Then Deputy Norton chimed in and asked:

Is it not a fact that there is no obligation on us to enter into a military agreement as a condition of our entering the Common Market? Is it not also a fact that we ought not to insinuate a military agreement on ourselves?

The Taoiseach: There is certainly no commitment of that kind involved in acceptance of the Rome Treaty, but it is clear the Treaty envisages something more than a mere trading agreement. The aim is to establish a situation which will encourage the political integration of Western Europe.

I will not bore the House any further. The House could not be given the information which had to be extracted from a New York paper. It is a dreadful comment on the Taoiseach's outlook, as far as the public are concerned. For my part, the little confidence I have had in him is gone for ever.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy ever have any?

Comment on this

I had. Finally——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

He has had an hour.

Comment on this

He is entitled to speak.

Comment on this

So had Deputy Booth. This at least is more entertaining.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

It is much more entertaining.

Comment on this

Whether or not the Taoiseach likes it, that statement of his goes even further than a commitment to NATO and the Taoiseach has no authority from this House or the country to commit the Irish people to support or be a member of NATO. In spite of what the major Opposition Party may say, they have for 11 years in the House and outside it opposed membership of NATO on certain grounds. The grounds were very clear to the Leader of the Fine Gael Party and indeed to the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party who is now up in the Park.

Comment on this

He stood by this country——

Comment on this

You disgust me——

Comment on this

We can apply a few statistics to test the success or failure of the Government during the past 12 months. What is the position now compared with 1956, the year of the economic blizzard, when Britain and Europe were in just as much trouble as we were? The position is there are 50,000 fewer people earning wages than there were in 1956. So much for the extra employment about which we heard so much from the Government Benches.

Let us take the housing position. There are at least 25,000 homeless families at present. There are 1,000 families in County Dublin and 9,800 families in Dublin city seeking the tenancy of houses. If we look back over the past couple of years, we find there were fewer than 1,000 Corporation houses built in Dublin last year compared with 3,000 built in 1956, the year of the economic blizzard. What has happened during the past five years? It has been necessary for 250,000 people to emigrate. If we examine the figures, we find that during the years of Fianna Fáil, almost 1,000,000 people emigrated. Emigration persists. Some figures for emigration were given in replies to Questions recently. For the ten years ended 1936 an average of 16,500 people emigrated; for the ten years ended 1946, 18,500; for the five years ended 1951, 24,500; for the five years ended 1956, 39,500; and for the past five years the net average was 43,000. So we are breaking records in the matter of emigration with an average of 43,000 people emigrating in the past five years and, in addition, there are 50,000 fewer people earning wages now than there were in 1956.

The income that might have been earned by the 250,000 people who emigrated would have meant an additional £125,000,000 to our national income. It was mentioned earlier to-day that emigrants' remittances amount to something like £50,000,000. If they are earning approximately £10 per week, on average about ten per cent. of their earnings comes here in the form of emigrants' remittances. The Taoiseach to-day emphasised the value of tourism, but a large part of these earnings comes from the £125,000,000 earned outside the country by emigrants.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have to yield. It is 12 o'clock.

Comment on this

There is only one further point I want to make. Emphasis has been laid on industrial activity but it has not been admitted fairly that the expansion in industrial activity is due mainly to the new approach to industrial expansion resulting from the 1956 Finance Act introduced by Deputy Sweetman as Minister for Finance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

As a result of the concessions given in that Act, by way of income tax relief in regard to profits from exports, enterprising industrialists and manufacturers were encouraged to engage in exporting from this country and that, in turn, has resulted in a higher income from industrial exports.

Comment on this

At this time of the night, a serious speech is not practicable. I know that most Deputies on both sides of the House are so glad that this long summer session is now coming to an end that they will not much mind what I say, provided I am brief. I intend to be as brief as I can, and I am helped in that determination by the knowledge that the newspapers are probably on their way to the presses and what I now say may not be reported.

Comment on this

But Parliament still exists, you know.

Comment on this

There are, however, a few matters to which I intend to refer because I know that, if I do not refer to them, the probability is I will be accused later of having evaded them. When I was introducing this Estimate earlier today, I mentioned the fact that our national statistics service has been greatly expanded in recent years. I still think that is a good thing, notwithstanding the grave misuse of statistics during this discussion here today. A large part of the debate, those Deputies who sat it out will remember, was concerned with the misinterpretation of statistics. It is quite possible that some Deputies have had an overdoes of them and have clearly not been able to digest them properly. Others have not been able to get the type of statistics they wanted. The statistics they got were too good for them. I am sorry I cannot do anything about that. We have no other kind. I hope that will always be so.

May I say I realise that there are Deputies who would like to see this country as miserable as they represent it to be, as depressed and as poverty-stricken as they say it is, but I am sure they know in their hearts that that is not true and they will go on their holidays tomorrow rejoicing that it is not true.

One of the matters to which I want to refer is the suggestion made by Deputy Dillon that a statement by me, which he quoted, to the representative of the New York Times regarding reservations in relation to the political implications of the European Economic Community was more definite than any I had made here is just simply not true. During the course of the past few years, I have done my best in a series of speeches, up and down the country and here in the Dáil, to get it known and realised that there exists in Europe an intention to continue the process of European integration beyond the economic arrangements envisaged by the Treaty of Rome and to embrace European unity in the wider political sense.

The concept of economic union involves a common commercial policy with the rest of the world. The Treaty of Rome provides for acceptance of the principle of a common commercial policy. A common commercial policy must necessarily involve co-ordination in the field of foreign policy. That is logical and inevitable. I think it is well known to Deputies that the efforts which have already been made to secure an agreement between the existing members of the European Economic Community on the terms of the instrument, which was intended to define their wider political aims, and their programme for political integration, have so far failed. There has been no agreement.

Very recently, a proposal emerged after a discussion between the President of the Republic of France and the Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany to renew these efforts later in the year. That proposal seems to have had a mixed reception in the other Community countries. I think it is quite clear to anybody with common sense that our application for membership of the European Community cannot be made subject to any reservation as to the future and still undefined political objectives of the present members. If we were to attempt to make reservations of that kind, our application would certainly fail. The policy of the Government is not to make reservations of that kind.

We accept—I speak now for the Government and the Government Party; I do not ask anyone else to concur in our view—and, indeed, welcome the prospect of still closer European union at some stage and in some form to be realised by agreement. It is quite clear that there is at present a wide divergence of view between the leaders of the countries now in the Community as to the form which the instrument expressing their political aim to promote greater unity should take. It would be very unwise for us at this stage, as an applicant for membership, to express support for either one view or the other, or to encourage here a public debate on that topic, a public debate which would be appropriate at some stage to crystallise public opinion about it. It is to be noted that none of the other countries which are now applying for membership of the Community is adopting any different attitude.

When our position as a member of the European Community has been established, we intend to exercise all our rights of membership and to express our definite view on matters arising for decision within the Community. It is, of course, true that this country cannot be committed to any agreement or any international instrument of that kind until it has been ratified by the Oireachtas. If I have to make a guess at this stage, it is that no agreement will emerge from these negotiations which will cause any serious problem for this country, or which the Government will not be prepared to approve, and move to have ratified.

I said earlier to-day that we are at present planning upon the assumption that we will become members of the European Community. A high ecclesiastic is reported to have said recently, speaking about the forthcoming Ecumenical Council, that he knew when it was going to start but only God knew when it was going to finish. The position regarding our application for membership of the European Community is the reverse. We do not know when it will start, but we do know when it will finish—at least we do know when the provisions of the Treaty of Rome will be in full operation, and that is 31st December, 1969.

I said this morning that the date of our accession might be later than we had originally assumed, and might be well into next year. Tonight, there are press reports of the successful conclusion of an agreement between the British negotiators and the Council of the European Economic Community in respect of what appeared to be one of the most difficult matters with which they were dealing, and it may be that that announcement, if correct, will bring the date of our accession somewhat nearer. We certainly do not anticipate that our negotiations with the Community will cause them very much difficulty or involve any very great delay.

Deputy Blowick, in the course of his lachrymose speech, dealt with the problem of the small farmers. I want to refer to this problem because it is one that is at present very much the concern of the Government. As Deputies know, we set up last year for our own guidance a committee of officials drawn from the Departments which are concerned in any way with the administration of policy in the small farming areas to have a look at the situation as a whole and to make recommendations to us as to the measures that might be taken to improve the structural organisation of agriculture and its productivity in those areas and to deal with the social problems which are known to exist there. When that report was submitted to me, I decided that it would be wise to publish it, even though it was not originally prepared for publication, because it would help to secure wider understanding of the character of the problem that arises there and because we wanted to invite all interested organisations and persons to submit their observations, critical or otherwise, upon the recommendations contained in the report.

Some important organisations have already informed me that they intend to submit these observations and to make suggestions arising out of the situation as disclosed by the report and they have asked that the Government's decisions upon these recommendations should be deferred until their comments have been received. That request may be to some extent based upon a misunderstanding because I do not think the position is one in which we have to choose between alternative policies. It is rather a matter of supplementing the recommendations of the report by other recommendations or suggestions which would help to make them more effective and the Government will not necessarily delay decisions upon aspects of these recommendations which appear to be of that kind, while awaiting the views of interested organisations.

I want to comment on the fact that no reference to that report that I know of has been made since its publication by Deputy Blowick or by any member of his Party or any member of the Fine Gael Party and certainly neither in the form of criticism nor suggestion has there been any practical help given to the formulation of a policy which will help us in the aim of applying in these areas measures which will ensure that the population will be stabilised or increased and that a reasonable standard of living and security in the enjoyment of it can be conferred upon their people.

Deputy Dillon referred to this old question of the purchase of Irish agricultural land by non-nationals. It seemed to me he was trying to suggest that there was some policy on the part of the Government to encourage the purchase of agricultural land by foreigners. That, of course, is completely untrue. Not merely have I on many occasions stressed in public the attitude of the Government in that respect, but, as Deputies are aware, we have imposed a substantial tax, a tax of 25 per cent. of the value of the property, upon transactions of that kind. The purpose of that tax was not to bring in money; it was to give in a formal way an indication of official disapproval of such sales.

But it is unwise that there should be any exaggeration of the character of the problem that has been presented in that way. Because of the provisions of the 1961 Finance Act, we have since August of last year now precise details of all transactions of that kind that occur and since then, 154 properties totalling 7,466 acres were sold—and may I say that that figure is not much larger than was usual for 20 years back? Transactions in property have always been proceeding and information regarding their magnitude is available. I confess the information was not always as reliable as that which we now have. It was secured very largely by reports received from the Garda authorities. But all the information is that nothing abnormal in respect of the purchase of Irish land by foreigners has emerged, certainly nothing to justify any undue concern.

However, if any assurance is required that these transactions will not be allowed to prevent the fulfilment of the Government's land policy, I can give it without hesitation. We expect to be able to make proposals for new land legislation available for the Dáil in the early future and that will give an ample opportunity for consideration of the matter.

Deputy Dillon also spoke about the agricultural advisory services. It is common ground between us that these services have to be expanded fully; it is common ground that they should be used fully by farmers, which they are not at present time. There is difference of opinion as to whether they should be organised as a national service or administered through the county committees of agriculture. We believe in administration by the county committees of agriculture but that is only a matter of detail and of no great importance.

The point I want to make is that Government policy in that respect is amply and fully disclosed by the Book of Estimates, which shows a very considerable increase in the allocation of money for these services. On the educational, research, advisory and technical services administered by the Department of Agriculture, the total to be expended this year will be three and a half times as much as it was ten years ago and certainly two and a half times as much as it was in the last year when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture.

We are as concerned as other Deputies regarding the present backlog of housing, particularly in the Dublin area. When the newly-elected Lord Mayor of Dublin was good enough to pay a courtesy visit on me a couple of weeks ago, he was accompanied by the City Manager and we discussed this problem of housing in Dublin. It was explained by the City Manager that the output of houses this year depended upon the plans made and the sites acquired for housing three or four years ago and that three or four years ago in Dublin, there was a situation in which the Corporation had quite a number of vacant houses on their hands and felt the situation had been reached where they could pull down upon their housing activities; that because of the drop in emigration, because of the movement back of certain classes of workers from Britain to employment in Dublin, that situation has reversed itself and there is now a deficiency in the houses available for letting by Dublin Corporation almost as high as ever it was. I was assured by the City Manager and by the Lord Mayor that the Corporation were making all the plans necessary to speed up their rate of construction to ensure that these arrears of housing would be wiped out.

There is nothing other than practical difficulties holding up the Corporation from doing so. They have certainly been assured that any money they require to enable them to fulfil their programme will be available to them and it is merely a matter of organisation, planning, acquiring land and developing their sites. The faster they get on with it, the better we will like it.

I do not know why Deputy Dillon referred to a speech which he made in 1948 as Minister for Agriculture to the National Press Club in Washington. I thought he would have liked to forget it. However, he not merely referred to the speech but he even represented me as having protested against that speech subsequently in the Dáil. Deputy Dillon is inclined to forget that every idle word he says here is taken down and can be used in evidence against him. I looked up what happened and I should like to tell the Dáil for their amusement.

Deputy Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture in the Government to which Deputy Dr. Browne belonged, went to Washington and there made a speech recommending to the world a grand plan, and the grand plan was that Ireland, Britain, the United States, Canada, Australia and New Zealand should form a customs union. I may be wrong about New Zealand. The price of milk was bad at the time and of course there is nothing the Irish milk producers would like less than a customs union with New Zealand. I think the Deputy left New Zealand out. He did not say that was going to be done with New Zealand but he left it out just the same.

All that happened in the Dáil when Deputy Dillon came back was that I asked the Taoiseach if the Minister for Agriculture in making this speech in Washington was expressing Government policy. "He was doing nothing of the sort," said the then Taoiseach, Deputy John Costello. "He was neither expressing the policy of the Government nor of any component part of it." I should like to make a bet that if I asked Deputy John Costello the same question tonight, I would get the same answer.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is trotting along very peacefully in my footsteps and he is very welcome. As long as he continues to do so, I shall treat him kindly.

Comment on this

In view of that, I shall content myself with expressing the hope that all Deputies here present will be back here again on 30th of October looking as healthy as they do now and a little wiser. I shall have some more pearls for their admiration at that time.

Comment on this
Division

Question put

Tá 65
·
Níl 49
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?