Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 1–151 of 301. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I sat throughout this debate—at least when the leaders of the Parties spoke—because usually the backbenchers follow the line of the leaders. I admit that, from time to time, you will get a new line from the backbenchers. They are not all just as "back" as that, but, on the whole, they take the line of their leaders. Nevertheless some of them act like the proverbial hatchetman of the Party to whom Hitler on one occasion referred. They try to get a little bit dirty. I listened carefully to the Party leaders. Last night I listened to Deputy McGilligan. He is a brilliant lawyer. In fact, there are a great many lawyers in this House—perhaps 30 or 40. It would appear to me that the majority of those men are brilliant men, honest men, as individuals, which is something different from politicians. They are a sort of Jeykll and Hyde. They are as honest as the sun. As politicians, they do not care how a bounty is earned. They take the view that it is a Party game. I made some remarks about the Party game. The last time I spoke I was insulted. Nevertheless, everything I said was true. I do not think I got personal. When I made references to the Opposition, I was not referring to the present Opposition: I was referring to Oppositions.
However, getting back to Deputy McGilligan, he took the view that this was going to increase the cost of living. He pleaded, as a good counsel will in court.
We all know what counsel does in court. His object is to make his client, even though that person may be a rougue, the fairhaired boy. His job is to make his opponent the biggest blackguard thinkable, even though that person might be an angel. His job is to discredit the witness. That is his training. They seem to take the same line in here. The public outside are confused, just as a brilliant counsel would confuse a jury, were it not for the fact that there is a learned judge there to point out what is material and what is not. That is not the job of the Ceann Comhairle. Both sides can bluff all they like. His job is to see to it that they do not box. There is no one to tell the public what is true and what is false. I try to do that in my own little way. If I differ from others, it is because I came in here as an Independent. My whole upbringing was that of an Independent. I could have been in Parties long ago, but I chose the role of Independent because I had a little experience of Parties and I do not like Party politics. I do not like wrangling. I am not trying to be a holy Joe; I am just saying what I think is correct. I try to inform the people. I try to do what the learned judge does in court. I hope to help them in that way.
Comment on this
You are the typical hatchetman I referred to. You are a good attender—I will grant you that— but you are always interjecting.
Comment on this
Yes, Sir; I am preparing my ground. I am trying to make out that this game of politics is played by a lot of gentlemen, some of them not so gentle. This is the sort of game in which corruption pays dividends. I know that.
Comment on this
It is a game in this House. That was proved by the fact that when he was speaking Deputy Corish said he hoped we would approach this matter by leaving Party politics out of it. He said it would be a pity we could not deal with such matters as debates on the Adjournment without Party politics. Surely he was hinting at something he was forced to be a party to which he was ashamed of? Even the Minister for Transport and Power said it was a pity we could not get together and discuss problems privately. He said we could discuss costs and honestly find out whether a thing was possible or not. In a nutshell, what he was saying was: "It is a pity you do not do things in a constructive way here instead of making outrageous statements and promises to the public which are impossible in practice." There have been hints thrown out to drop the Party game, and I am preparing the ground.
Most of the attacks on the Vote on Account were not constructive, but were playing the Party game. On the last debate, we had Deputy J. A. Costello, the former Taoiseach, denouncing the previous Government for making things difficult for him when they were in Opposition. He brought the Party game to the notice of the House. All the contributions made here were made with an eye not so much on the Vote on Account but on the next election or the by-election in Dublin North-East.
Deputy McGilligan said the new sales tax would increase the cost of living. We are told the new sales tax is required to get the money to take the place of what we will lose by dropping tariffs. If we are going to lower tariffs, will goods not come in cheaper? Even if the sales tax means that luxury goods are to cost more, will those goods not come in cheaper because tariffs are being lowered? Deputy McGilligan did not mention that. He mentioned only the rotten part, but did not mention the rosy part at all. That is the game. Attempts have been made to make the game work in a better way, but they have failed, and the cause of the failure is this threat of an election. If there were an election only once in five years and no by-elections and if the seat becoming vacant were given to the Party of the occupant——
Comment on this
In Dublin Corporation, we regard it as a personal matter. When the late Alderman Byrne died, we put in his son. The seat is won by an individual's effort and money, and his family should have the right. Ways and means can be found.
Comment on this
I am putting my finger on the sore point. If there were no immediate threat of an election, men would forget trying to arouse passions and would be constructive for four years out of five. In the United States, the executive power is the President. He is elected once in four years. He does not resign because some Bill is defeated. Everybody loves and helps him for at least three years out of the four, and he is then subject to the usual attacks for the last year. If we had that system here, we would have less of the Teddyboyism, which takes place here from time to time. If it were not for the Ceann Comhairle, Standing Orders and the Guards, that is what we would have here. It is no use saying we are decorous. We are only decorous because we have to be. Deputy Costello's complaint was that the Opposition of that time hounded him when he was in difficulties. That is my point. That is the role of the Opposition—to mislead, to misrepresent and make things difficult for the Government, in case an election might break out.
I have a lot to say about housing. People spoke about housing who knew nothing about it. The fact that a person is a member of a city council does not mean he knows anything about housing. He could be a member of the council and not a member of the housing committee, and he could be a member of the housing committee and not attend the meetings.
We have 18 on our Housing Committee and there are never more than six, seven or eight present. So it is no argument to say that a man is a member of the corporation or a member of the housing committee. I am telling you here and now that there are only two or three people here who know what they are talking about when they talk about Dublin housing and I am one of them. I would say that Deputy Barron and Deputy Timmons are others and that is about all. We attend the Housing Committee day in day out. We never miss out. I have not missed four meetings in eight years. I have everything at the tips of my fingers, apart from taking an interest in it and making a study of it. You all know the vice-chairman has to take pains to find out all the day-to-day facts. The ordinary member strolls in without looking at the agenda and there may be a big number as the meeting proceeds. But the vice-chairman cannot do everything.
I have listened to the Opposition here debating housing and when those questions were discussed by Deputy Declan Costello. The most startling facts were statements made by the Opposition. Deputy Ryan is a smart young fellow and a friend of mine who should know better. But of course he is a solicitor. He must win. That is my point. It was said that in 1959 a very small number of houses were built. In an interjection, he reduced that number by one-third. Why, why, why? If the official statement—whatever it was—said there were 270 odd houses built in 1959, why should he reduce that number to 200? Why did he not leave it at 270, or whatever it was? Again, when the official answer was given that there were 9,000 people with their names on the waiting, he said 9,500 were on the waiting list.
Comment on this
You see my point— that words do not seem to mean anything. They are bandied around here —shots in the dark.
There is another statement he makes. Imagine, he says, 9,000 people with over four in a room. That was the most false statement made in this House yet. He ought to know better because although he is not on the Housing Committee, he could easily find out. The truth of the present housing position is that there are 9,000 on the waiting list and, for your information, there are a lot of people from the country, who have just come up. Once you come up, you write in and get an application form, fill it in and you are on the waiting list.
Comment on this
Yes, they have just come up. The bye-laws set out that you must be four years resident before you can be considered for housing. But the names of those fellows who had just come up are there and they were mentioned as part of the 9,000, and even as families of over four. When you put that sort of thing over here, can you blame me if I am cynical and if I try to spill the beans to the public? The truth is that there are only about 4,500 on the list who are considered by the local authority as requiring houses. The rest is a fictitious number. If the City Manager were a politician, he would not have given that number but being an honest man, he gave every application for a dwelling. He even gave the names of people who had three rooms. It does not matter what you are if you apply; if you own a mansion, it does not matter if you apply. They will be included in an answer to a query on how many people there are on the waiting list.
The truth is there are little more than 1,000 people of four and five. That is all there are on the housing list. Just imagine a statement that there are 9,000, with four. The truth is there are only a little over 1,000. Of those 4,500, there are 1,100 families of one and two. How does that compare with the statements made here— reckless statements, all made so that the people outside will think this is a terrible Government? I think there is no truth in it. I will make the case that it was a mistake for the Opposition to make any reference to housing at all. It would have been better for themselves if they never opened their mouths about houses because they were speaking in total ignorance—even the former Minister for Local Government. He had a good knowledge of housing then, but he knows nothing about houses now. He might dig up an answer by reference to books and getting data. But that is no use. You cannot get the feeling of the thing from books; you can only get the feeling of the thing from living with it.
I have the official number—it is 4,401. It might vary. Amongst that number there are actually 1,100 families of one or two persons. There are only a little more than 1,000 families of four or five persons. That puts an entirely different complexion on the position. Of those 4,500, there are 750 families returned from England. Do not forget that in the past two years we housed approximately 750 families from England. More than 1,500 families came back—and we had to house them. The 750 we housed naturally had to get priority on the list because of the size of their families. We could not leave a wife and a gang of children out on the street. If you take those from the 4,500, it leaves only 3,000. That would be the true housing position, if it were not for the fact that people came back from Britain, not through any fault of anyone here. We did not expect these people to come back, and we could not plan for something we did not know about. You might say that the local authorities along the seaboard in France should be blackballed by the French Opposition because they had not houses ready for the Algerian refugees. How could the local authorities know that de Gaulle would throw up the sponge and pull out of Algeria? How could they know that these refugees would descend on their areas? If suddenly a million people come back, would it be fair to say: "You never built houses; look at the housing list."
That is not the truth. Up to 1960, they were running away. The housing problem was practically solved in 1960. I can prove it. Then suddenly the British brought in a measure—the Rent Restrictions Act. At one time in England if one were being overcharged, one could go to a local court and get the rent reduced to 30/-. In 1960, the Rent Restrictions Act was amended and landlords were given power to charge what they liked. That has a lot to do with people deciding to come here and preventing those at home from going away. They started to charge £3 and £4 per room and that is what is being charged at the moment.
Apart from that, in and around 1960, there was a lack of overtime. The unions decided against overtime. All those were earning up to £20 a week—double time for overtime, treble time for Sunday and they were making £20 a week and so everything was rosy in England. Rent was 30/- and income £20 a week. The fact that all this ended up around 1960 was something we did not know. How could the Housing Committee know? Gradually the housing vacancies began to reverse. Since we found there was a changing approach, we started to plan again. But again we hear this cry: "You only built this number this year." It takes two years from the planning stage to produce a house. It takes three or four years from the planning stage to produce a flat and there is a wait of two or three years.
The Opposition made a political issue out of this and I am going to see that it boomerangs on them, although I have no desire to do it. I might be supporting the Government, because there is need for the Government, and I make no apology for it, but I have no intention of taking sides in a general way on politics. I have been a member of the Dublin Corporation Housing Committee since 1955 and as vice-chairman I was attacked, although the main attack was on the Minister for Local Government who had nothing to do with it at all. The Minister for Local Government at no time refused a penny to Dublin Corporation nor did he at any time hold up sanction except for the usual short periods. Whatever guilt may attach to me, he is the innocent party. This business of trying to make political capital out of this situation has no foundation at all. Evidence would want to be produced to show that we asked for money and that the Minister refused to give it, or delayed giving it.
We asked him only for what we wanted. The City Manager and his officials are the executive authority and they administer the estate. The committees, such as the Housing Committee, are the policy makers. It is the Housing Committee which decides: "We will build flats, or we will build houses; we will build so many flats or so many houses, or we will not build them." If any brickbats are to be thrown, they cannot be thrown at the Minister for Local Government. We decided in 1959 that we would not build any more houses on the perimeter—and that is the only place we had land—that there was no demand for houses, that the people would not go out to them and that instead, they were coming in. It would have been unfair to the ratepayers. The houses were being wrecked by children playing cowboys and Indians in them and lighting fires. Under those circumstances, what sane person would decide to go on with the housing programme on the perimeter of the city?
Deputy Dillon was guilty of one big evasion. He said that 270 houses were built in 1959 but he did not refer to the 1,600 vacant houses, which meant that there were really 2,000 dwellings which nobody was taking. It would condemn the whole Opposition if that evasion were dragged out in court. The fact that there were 1,600 houses vacant actually put the corporation in a position which was almost as good as they had been in in 1950 when there were 20,000 people in urgent need of dwellings. I can give you the details from all the official corporation minutes which I have here. There were 800 applications for transfers back into the city from Ballyfermot and Finglas in 1959 and 1960. There were 1,500 refusals to go out. There were 1,500 houses lying idle for months where one after the other people said: "No; we want a nice flat in the city, around the corner from where we live at present." That is the truth and the figures are there. As I said, children were breaking windows and the ratepayers were being billed for windows, frames and doors which had been smashed and the ratepayers were in a panic. Yet Deputy Dillon comes in and says that only 270 houses were built in 1959. Although in 1959-60 there were 3,000 on the waiting list for houses, half of that number had been offered houses and would not take them. Deputy Dillon read out only one side of the picture without referring to the other.
In 1951, there were 2,588 houses built and the vacancy rate was only 194, which was nothing. Now we come to 1960-61 when 279 dwellings were handed over. There were 1,260 vacant dwellings, making an actual housing contribution for those on the waiting list of 1,539. That was as recently as two years ago. In 1959-60, there were only 505 dwellings handed over but there were 1,605 empty dwellings. We actually had 2,110 dwellings to hand over to those who wanted dwellings. How can the Opposition make a case there?
Members here are ignorant of the position in Dublin and likewise the people outside are ignorant but the members here are in a position to elicit the necessary information. How can the people outside judge a statement, which may be bandied around at the next bye-election, that no houses were being built, that only 500 were provided, when actually the truth is that there were 2,110 available in 1959-60 as against a total in 1951-52 of 2,239, almost as many dwellings provided when there were 20,000 on the waiting list, and they were bad cases.
Do I require to proceed any further? I will. As they say in court, when one side introduces a certain line of argument the other side is entitled to rebut it and I will certainly do that. Considerable play was made with the fact that in the first two years of the regime of this Government housing dropped; that in 1958-59 the present Government built only 460 dwellings. But it had nothing to do with the Government. Do not forget that if there were only 460 houses built, there were 1,393 vacancies. If only 460 houses were built in 1958-59, who was responsible? Who planned two years in advance? If only that number was built in that year, that was because in 1956 there had been no commonsense planning.
When a decision is made to build houses, there is, first of all, what is called a rough sketch plan, and to that the committee agrees in principle. That plan goes back and, after a month or two, we get a working plan with all the details. We examine that. We may alter it. If we alter it, it has to go back again for perhaps a fortnight, after which it is sent to us once more. If we agree to the working plan, it must then go to Local Government. They, of course, have hundreds of applications, and there are such things as priorities. It may take a fortnight, or a month, or two, before it comes back from Local Government.
Then we have to prepare bills of quantities—100 houses to be built, so many rooms, walls of such and such a thickness, so much wood, so much glass, etc. These are advertised and the contractors tender. Time is passing. When we eventually decide which is the best offer, we must once more send it to Local Government because they must approve the expenditure. It comes back and we must bond the contractor; we must make sure that he has money and that he is not like some of the fellows in 1956 who went bankrupt and left houses half finished. All that takes a year. By the time the builder gets on the site, 14 months may have elapsed. That cannot be avoided. The important point is that it takes about two years from the time the actual decision is taken to the time the house is handed over.
If there were only 460 houses built in 1958-59, it must be remembered that Fianna Fáil came into power only in March or April of 1957. No one could expect them to get cracking immediately. They are responsible only for the last three or four months of 1957. The song and dance here is about the few houses built. There were few because there was no planning in 1956 and, because of that, there was a big drop. There was a big drop in the previous years, too. I have evidence here that, between 1956 and 1957, 1,100 workers were sacked; about 1,000 houses were not built and all these workers went to England. Later, when we tried to get going again, there were no workers available.
I have here the minutes of the Municipal Council of the city of Dublin, 1957. Now if I were to give the names of the Fianna Fáil people on the Council, there would be cries of "Ah!" I will give the Coalition names. No one can call them liars. Councillor Denis Larkin, T. D., Chairman of the Housing Committee, and a supporter of the Coalition Government: a good man on housing, he asked how many dwellings as distinct from cottages, flats and reconditioned houses were under construction in July in each of the years 1948 to 1957 inclusive. I shall deal with the last two years because they are the vital years.
Comment on this
No. One might as well go back to the Treaty. My point is that there was a crisis in 1956 which resulted in no houses being built in 1957 and 1958; that, in turn, resulted in 1,100 workers going to England. That is the vital period. If the Deputy built 1,000 houses ten years ago, well and good. I am not concerned with that. I am concerned with the cause of the drop in building in 1958 and 1959. That is what the Opposition have been hammering at.
Comment on this
I am concerned with 1957. The reference is page 151 so that the Deputy can look it up for himself. The total number of cottages and flats built, or houses reconditioned, in 1956 was 2,423. The Coalition must accept responsibility for the position in July, 1957, because Fianna Fáil had only just returned to office: there were 968 houses built. There was a drop from 2,423. In 1956, the number employed on corporation housing was 1,857; in July, 1957, it was 925. Housing collapsed. The collapse started in 1956. I have proved that. I looked up the Irish Independent for the last three months of the relevant period. I am not saying the Irish Independent is a Party paper, but it has leanings.
Comment on this
It has leanings. I make the point—it is an important one—that I am not quoting from the Irish Press. In the Irish Independent of 6th October, 1956, General Mulcahy, then Minister for Education, referred to the building of schools; he said there was a strained economy and “that is responsible for the slowing down of building”.
Councillor Larkin—Irish Independent of December 4th, 1956 — said that delay in sanctions meant that the corporation could not complete its target. Councillor Larkin was Chairman of the Housing Committee.
There is another important reference —Irish Independent of 20th October 1956. There was a mass meeting in the Mansion House under the auspices of the Dublin Trades Council and a resolution was passed: “An end to indiscriminate cuts in Government expenditure. Restitution of credit for socially progressive projects and Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act Building.” Placards were carried: “16,000 families living in slums” and “Building workers idle”.
Here is a gem. This is the Dublin County Council. On December 22nd 1956 Senator Carton, Fine Gael Chairman of the Housing Committee, described the position of housing as ghastly. The manager said that there was no delay by the council, there was a crisis in regard to loans and delay in sanction. Senator Carton accepted the manager's explanation.
Comment on this
I have here a report of a statement by Denis Larkin, then Lord Mayor, supporter of the Coalition Government, on February 21st in his Report to Council. I could mention Fianna Fáil to you but I shall not.
Comment on this
This is what Mr. Denis Larkin, then Lord Mayor, had to say on 21st February, 1956, in the Report to Council:
While there would be a time lag in the expectation of money, the corporation could not be expected to enter into contracts binding themselves without an assurance that the money would be forthcoming.
We had been promised money. We had a deputation to the Minister for Local Government, then Deputy P. O'Donnell. I was on the deputation. I was a witness to all this. I am not the type of fellow who comes in here once in a blue moon and takes a shot in the dark. I am a witness from day to day. Not every man can say that. I think I have the best attendance record for all corporation meetings. I would get a medal for my attendance at corporation meetings—and I am there for the beginning of the meetings. Mr. Denis Larkin said:
While there would be a time lag in the expectation of money—
We had been told we would get money but we were not getting it because there was a credit squeeze. Eventually, we got money from the Local Loans Fund but in 1956 we were hamstrung. Mr. Denis Larkin said that the corporation could not be expected to enter into contracts with builders in the expectation of the money without an assurance that the money would be forthcoming.
I looked through the Irish Independent for a period of three months only. I could have looked at the other papers. I could bring in a million quotations. I did not go through the Dáil Reports because notes from the Dáil Reports are all cod. There is no truth in them in the sense that the case made in the case the person wants to make; when he comes in here, he skips the bad things and takes the good things.
I am not reading up this case at all. I was one of those who went to the Minister for Local Government in 1956. We were told we would get the money but, as Councillor Denis Larkin, the then Lord Mayor, said, we would want a guarantee. Anyway, 1956 was a notorious year for the building trade and, as has been proved, as a result of 1956, there was no planning in 1956 or at the beginning of 1957: there was delay in planning. As a result, 1,100 workers lost their jobs and went to England just about then.
It is significant that, just about then, things began to get good in England. There were a few years there and things were rosy. The boys were making plenty of money and they started to move out. I want to be fair to the Opposition. Actually, we did not really require a lot more dwellings at that time.
Comment on this
If we did not require them, it was not due to any foresight on their part: we could have needed them. Actually, the crowd began to leave the corporation houses in droves. We were housing families of three in those years: that is a small family. We even housed families of two in many cases. Surely if any family of three could get a house without any trouble, it indicates that houses were available. However, those are the years 1958, 1959 and 1960. That is my point.
Why do you come along and try to make political capital out of something when there is no truth in the assertion that the Minister for Local Government or the Government were at fault here? They may have been responsible for many things but why do you say they were responsible for any drop in housing? Who have they as witnesses?
Comment on this
The Deputy is unaware that they claimed they built more houses. We are merely contradicting that statement.
Comment on this
No. The case you are making is that there was a tremendous need and that they let the people down.
Comment on this
There would be no point in your argument, otherwise. You are appealing to the people outside, now, who want a house. There would be no sense in your argument if that were not your case. Everything said here is not for the enlightenment of the fellows on the other side. We are all wise to one another. Do not worry about that. What is said here is for the benefit of the people outside.
The case was put that this little crisis was due to the fact that we did not build dwellings. The truth is that there was no need for any extended building of dwellings until 18 months or two years ago. That is all. Then we got cracking immediately and we saw a slight change. There was not much of a change—a change of half a dozen—and we said: "We will go off again." This year, there has been an increase of 100 per cent. Eight hundred dwellings are being provided this year. Only a couple of hundred were provided last year. That was a vast improvement when you remember that we had to gear ourselves up again.
You cannot start from nothing. You cannot gear up in a month. It took Hitler seven years to have a go at France. You cannot suddenly say: "We will build houses"—and up they go like mushrooms. We had not the workers—they were all away. There was difficulty about carpenters, bricklayers, and so on. But we had to gear ourselves. We built 800 dwellings in the past year as against a couple of hundred in the previous year. I think there was a cement strike last year. That knocked us out of two months' building.
Do not forget that we have had two months of snow and that, in that weather, you cannot work on housing. You cannot ignore it. You cannot, on one hand, come in here and do a song and dance about the poor people being snowed up and say the Government are responsible and then ignore that bad weather when it comes to an assessment of the housing position. We lost at least 100 houses in the three months of this terribly bad weather. I know all about it. People were coming to me about differential rents and I know they were working only two days in the week, and so on.
We reversed the position of last year and, in spite of the fact that 750 more came back from Britain, in the oncoming year we shall have a thousand. The Minister expects that there will be about 100 under construction for next year. He is wrong. There will be a thousand. This statement is made by the City Manager— not by a politician. It is an informed and an honest statement. At the moment, 800 houses are under construction but inside the next couple of weeks, we shall have entered into contracts. It is only a matter of this week or next week when the other 200 or 300 will be in operation. Therefore, if you put forward the date by a fortnight or three weeks, a thousand houses will be under construction. That is the answer I got yesterday from the Principal Officer of Housing—and he proved it to me, although nobody has to prove it to me as I know it myself.
Here is a little gem—an item on page 19 of the 1957 Report of the Dublin Corporation municipal minutes —a motion moved by Councillor J. Barron, one of our Deputies here. The only two men who know anything about housing in this House are Deputy Barron and Deputy Timmons. This motion was: "That the Council are of opinion that no further building by the Corporation on the perimeter sites of the city be carried out and that we should concentrate on building flats in the city." That motion was referred to the Housing Committee and we adopted it in a few months. There are some wise guys who talk about the bad job the Government did on housing, but where were they in 1959 and 1960? They did not make any public statements as to the likelihood of 1,500 people coming back. They are wise after the event and their talk is just politics.
Before I finish with the subject of housing, I should like to read a statement by the City Manager in 1962. He said:
In 1960-61 the previously increasing vacancy rate started to reverse itself——but only in 1960-61: do not forget that—
—but still these vacancies provided 1,260 dwellings.
That is the key to the whole situation. You do not buy a loaf of bread if you have the press full. He went on:
In 1961/62 the figure had further fallen to 856 dwellings, and in the current year it is estimated that no more than about 700 will become available. Immediately that tendency became pronounced steps were taken again to develop the momentum of increased housing production. For the reasons indicated above, however, this necessarily entails a time lag before its results are available. During 1960/61 only 277 new dwellings were completed. This was somewhat increased last year to 391, and in the current year it is estimated that it will have increased to 698——
—or approximately 700. The statement continues:
There are at present 1,035 dwellings in course of construction by the Corporation's contractors. Summarising the housing operations from 1948/1949 to date, 18,198 new dwellings have been built under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts, and 8,758 financed by way of loans under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts.
I may mention the fact that they took a census to access the needs in 1948/49 and they said we needed 20,000 dwelllings to end the housing problem in Dublin. Instead of providing 35,000 houses, we actually provided 37,000.
The statement goes on:
A further 10,465 families have now got new tenancies as a result of the net vacancies to which I have referred, making a total of 37,421 families re-housed in that period. In addition 4,793 grants have been made to private householders, supplementing State Grants to enable these people to put their houses in a better state of repair. During that period the Corporation's capital expenditure under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts amounted to £32,504,900 and under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts to £13,203,794—total £45,708,694.
Notwithstanding these vast housing operations, however, pressure for new housing started to build up again about 18 months ago.
That is vital because, as I said, it takes two years to produce a house. It goes on:
As I have already indicated, this was essentially due to the substantial drop in net vacancies and in the number of new houses becoming available. Moreover, during this time a number of families returned from England, and even though many of them had surrendered Corporation houses, they sought immediate priority over persons who had been on the waiting list for a considerable time.
When families with more than one child are given priority on the waiting list people start growling. That is human nature. The quotation continues:
In assessing the present housing deficiency no useful purpose is served by emphasising the fact that the applications list totals over 9,000. A majority of these applicants are persons whom the City Medical Officer does not consider to be in immediate need of housing and many of whom, either because of their short residence in the city or for some other reason, would not be housed by the Corporation anyway. When I referred above to the housing requirement as estimated in 1948, the deficiency of 20,000 represented families and persons whom the Corporation accepted as being urgently in need of re-housing.
Later on, we decided to invite anyone to apply so actually this figure of 9,000 is fictitious. It should be 4,500.
The case I am making is that the Housing Committee have done tremendous work. They work as hard as members of this House and the active members of the Housing Committee deserve to be paid as much as members of this House but they do not get a stamp. We can attend to our business because of the fact that some councillors attend regularly. Most of the councillors do not attend at all and they cannot know anything about this problem. When they talk about it, they are just taking a shot in the dark.
The main point is that at no time did the Minister for Local Government refuse money. The Housing Committee are the policy-making body. They ask for their requirements and they get them. If they did not build too many houses in 1958-59 it was due to the collapse of their finances brought about by the Coalition Government in 1956. I have said that it takes two years to build a house but it takes three to four years to build a flat, and the lack of flats goes back to the lack of money in 1956.
Some Deputies shed crocodile tears over people looking for houses, but if in 1956 or 1959 a Deputy had gone around saying he could get houses in Finglas or Ballyfermot, he would have been told: "We do not want a house in Finglas or Ballyfermot; we want a flat." The present position is that we have no more land in the north city. We have land in Raheny, which is a nice place. A tribute must be paid to Mr. Molloy of the Housing Committee who acquired land at a time when we had laid off housing. He said: "To be on the sure side, we had better acquire the land." That land is now developed and we have land for 3,000 or 4,000 houses, enough to solve the problem for the immediate future. We believe that a year or 18 months will clear the urgent demand, but there are always people who want houses at once. I have people coming to me who have just got off the boat with six children and have no place to go. These people have to be given priority. Next year we will have 1,000 houses and the following year we expect to have the same. After these two years, we do not expect that there will be any crisis in housing.
I want to say this much, that the Fine Gael Party should forget about housing as a political argument. It is extraordinary that the Labour Party had so little to say about it but, of course, they could not condemn their own Chairman of the Housing Committee. I will say no more about it. I have heard talk about the Taoiseach's reference to a cast-iron dog laughing. I have to laugh fairly often when I hear about these things but many simple-minded people outside accept those arguments. Deputy Dillon referred to a few houses built in 1959 but there was not a word from him about the 1,600 houses empty at that time. Getting back to the Vote on Account——
Comment on this
I am not a Party man and I never was. On two occasions earlier on, not within the past 20 years, I thought I would go into a Party but I got browned off and left again.
Comment on this
It does not matter. All Parties are the same in that respect. I speak what I think is the truth. If a barefaced lie is told, I may forget it but if that barefaced lie reflects on me, I will answer it. Those who start that business are attacking Denis Larkin, the Chairman of the Dublin Housing Committee, and Senator Carton, chairman of the County Dublin Housing Committee. If you want to attack anybody, attack the Housing Committees. The members of the Housing Committees do not bring politics into their work. They operate as teams. If you are going to talk like that, you should remember that the Housing Committees of Dublin County Council and Dublin Corporation are coalition bodies. Since I became a member in 1955, they have always been coalition committees. The Housing Committee of Dublin Corporation numbers 18 and there are only six Fianna Fáil members.
Comment on this
If you are going to make politics out of things like that, you will have to attack yourselves.
Comment on this
You are doing the solicitor now. I hope I will not have to stand up here again to talk about housing.
Comment on this
I heard Deputy Barry's interruption. He is one of the hatchet men but he is a good attender in this House and I am prepared to put up with his interruptions. I am well able to look after myself and when I go to the public I always tell them the truth. Of course there are some stupid people.
Comment on this
I try to. When they come about a house, I ask them all the questions necessary and if the answers are not satisfactory, I tell them that they cannot get a house. I am not like some of the people who say they will do their best. It is a lie to tell a person that you will do your best when you cannot do anything.
I believe the Government so far have been a good Government, and I believe the majority of the members of this House believe that. I do not mind what they say in here because, as I said before, all politicians are Jekylls and Hydes. When a motion was put down here in connection with the pay pause, the Labour Party did not vote for the resignation of the Government. They were having no nonsense. They appreciated that anything connected with wages was their business but they understood that the Government were trying to preserve the status quo, which is not bad.
The last increase in wages was due only in part to an increase in the cost of living. It was largely an increase in the standard of living, and that was admitted by members of the Labour Party. Now the position of those who have a job is quite good. If we are to argue on the question of social benefits I would argue against the record of the past and not on the future. The argument must be against the existing Government and their record of the immediate past, not the distant past. If we did that, we would be going back to the Civil War.
The fact is that whether it was brought about by mismanagement or by the Suez crisis, things were bad in 1956, as everybody knows. The Government of the time were depending on a few votes and it is one of the failings of democracy that when a Government are up against it, and the Coalition were up against it in 1956, there is likely to be ratting amongst some of their supporters. The play is always against the Government. The people who might shout now for the Government's resignation would shout three months later for Fine Gael's resignation. The politicians know, and they are the people who are always "lying into it," all those distortions of truth.
If you want to compare the present Government and be just, you can compare them only with the immediately preceding Government and if we do that, we find things were pretty hopeless in 1956. We remember the housing problem with all the housing workers idle and no credit. Perhaps the Government at the time did not deserve the mounting of attacks by Fianna Fáil. The then Taoiseach, I know, is quite an honest fellow. I believe he did his best and I know he felt very bitter afterwards. About a week ago, when I was having my little argument with Deputy Dillon—a man I greatly admire but I think he lost his head on that occasion—I said that Deputy Costello had said the same thing. Deputy Costello said they had acted like partisans in the French Revolution misrepresenting everything.
Do you blame me if I am cynical and express my contempt for the Party game? That is my mission here and I am not trying to be a "holy Joe". I came up without Party help. In fact, Parties did their damnedest to keep me out. However, I still believe this Government should continue for at least another year or two and should be helped.
Deputy Corish made a good speech. He put his Party point of view and made it clear that he was not trying to trip up the Government. He was not trying to harm the economy because he has the workers' position in mind. It was a fair speech for a political Party Leader. A Party leader can be as honest as the day is long but he must do a little playing with words. It is all in the game. There is such a thing as white lies but barefaced lies are different. Deputy Corish was not trying to cause a general election. He knows the actual position and the trouble that arose from the Common Market difficulty. He hopes that things will go along merrily as they are. At least I am sure he would like things to be better but that, to put it in Lincoln's words, he feels that to change horses in the middle of the stream might make things worse for the people.
I make no apology for defending the Government. I do not defend all they do, but when supporting a Government, you cannot play around with such an important function as government, even if you disagree on some minor sidelines. That would be a cheap performance. In the main, I think the Government have done well. At least they deserve, if not support, constructive criticism. We know Parties have to play the game and there is a bye-election coming on. We should give the Government credit where credit is due. It is impossible for a Government to be always right. In my opinion, all Governments honestly try to do a good job, even though they make mistakes and even though on the way to power, they do a lot of playacting. Once they get into office, that is suspended and they try to make the country economic and do the best possible for all the people. On the way to power, with the sort of system we have, you must bandy about untruths and distortions. You must misrepresent the Government and give them no credit if you hope to win and get the support of the 20 or 30 per cent. of the people who never ask questions. I shall continue to support the Government until I am satisfied that we have a state of affairs something like 1956. Then I shall not support them, but I am not going to risk the present position which is not so bad just because it might get me a few "hurrahs" from a few people outside who do not understand. I shall put up with their sneers which are not often genuine.
About a year ago, some 15 letters appeared in the papers abusing me and eight saying a good word for me but of the 15 letters of abuse, 11 of them came from a political club in North Dublin that met that week and decided to write the letters. I proved that and I have witnesses in this House to it. I do not mind what the people say outside.
Comment on this
The last speaker told us he would vote for the Government and sacrifice a few "hurrahs". If he continues as he is going, he will have to listen to a few "razzes" as well.
Comment on this
I am delighted to hear it. He also told us that were it not for the fact that we have a Chair in this House, we would have nothing but teddyboys on both sides. He told us that Party politicians consisted of nothing but teddyboys——
Comment on this
——and that on the way to Government, a Party politician would do anything to obtain his ends. The Deputy can never hope, I am afraid, to aspire to Government by the method he is using. I do not believe we are teddyboys in this House.
Comment on this
The Deputy spoke for an hour on the Vote on Account and confined his speech entirely to a discussion of the housing problem in the city of Dublin. That is filibustering, in my opinion.
Comment on this
He is trying to evade the fact that he himself within the past two weeks supported the Government who were about to introduce a standstill order——
Comment on this
He voted with the Government and he now comes along and says to the people of Dublin: "I am in here fighting for houses for the poor of Dublin." But there is not a word about his reason for voting for the standstill order. He tells us—I shall deal with housing now—that in 1960, Dublin Corporation had reached their housing target but that since then, a new situation has arisen and there is an influx of people from Britain to Dublin and, were it not for that——
Comment on this
Deputy Sherwin has told us that only three members of this House know anything about the housing of the people of Dublin. One is himself——
Comment on this
If that young Deputy waits, I shall name them. One is himself, Deputy Sherwin and then Deputy Barron and Deputy Timmons. I notice there was no mention of Deputy Briscoe and he was the gentleman who knew all about housing. Did the Deputy say that Deputy Burke was on that Housing Committee?
Comment on this
We had Deputy Burke and Deputy Briscoe on that Housing Committee during that time. I am glad to hear Deputy Sherwin say that they knew nothing about it. I always had the impression that Deputy Briscoe knew nothing about it.
Comment on this
I am only taking you at your word. You told me that only three Deputies, Deputy Sherwin, Deputy Barron and Deputy Timmons knew all about it. Therefore, the other three do not know all about it.
Comment on this
One was a new member. Deputy Briscoe was never a member. He could not know as much as the other three.
Comment on this
Deputy Sherwin told us what they were doing for the building of houses in Dublin. He said that, if there was a hiatus in the building of houses, it was the Minister for Local Government in 1956 who was responsible for it. In the next breath, he tells us that, if there are not new houses built in Dublin, we should not blame the Minister for Local Government but we should blame the Housing Committee. In March, 1956, I informed Dublin Corporation that they could have £2 million for the building of houses. At that time I received Deputies Larkin and Briscoe——
Comment on this
No. He probably did not make an impression on me, because I have no note of him. I told them they could have £2 million and they told me they did not want it until mid-April. I asked them to get on with their building plans, that there was £2 million available for them whenever they required it. Nothing was done. I accused them, there and then, of sabotaging the housing programme in Dublin.
Comment on this
I do not care who was on it. I am telling you what I told Dublin Corporation at the time. At the same time, I told them they should review the position, that I thought they were building too many houses on the perimeter and that they should concentrate on building multistorey flats in the centre of the city. The reply I got from the Housing Committee was: "Mind your own bloody business"—that they would decide policy. I told them I believed the building of these houses in Ballyfermot and other places was responsible for cluttering up the city with traffic. These people had to be transported from their homes to the city and back. It was straining their resources to have to pay for transport. I told them I was afraid these houses would become vacant. Deputy Sherwin now confirms what I said. Again, for the record——
Comment on this
There will be an opportunity when the Budget comes up. We will find that no matter what blisters are in the Budget, the Deputy will vote with the Government. For the Deputy's benefit, I want to quote some figures given by the Minister for Local Government in reply to a question by Deputy Declan Costello. He was asked to state the number of houses and flats being built by Dublin Corporation to date in the current financial year and in each year since 1950.
Comment on this
I have not got the exact date. I am giving the reply from the official records of the House. For the financial year 1950-51, between flats and houses combined, there were 2,588 built. In 1951-52, 1,982——
Comment on this
In 1954-55, 1,922 flats and houses built; in 1955-56, 1,311 built; in 1956-57, 1,564 built.
Comment on this
I want the Deputy to listen to the figures for 1958-59. Up to this I have been dealing in thousands. In 1958-59, there were 450 houses and flats built; in 1959-60, 505.
Comment on this
Do not throw him out, Sir. Please let him hear these facts. In 1960-61, there were 277 houses and flats built. For the eleven months of 1961-62, there were 320 built. The present Minister for Agriculture was Minister for Local Government for 12 months. I remember him saying in 1958 that, when he came into office, he dealt with a back-log of housing in respect of houses and flats in Dublin. I wonder where were those houses and flats built? We cannot find them in the official records.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going to tell us now that they continued from 1958 to the present day to build somewhere in the neighbourhood of 1,400 houses when they had vacancies in the city? What caused these vacant houses?
Comment on this
Is it that they were built in the wrong places? If it is, then it is a very serious accusation to make against this famous committee— that they built all these houses and nobody will occupy them.
Comment on this
Why were they built? Was it just for the sake of giving employment that we built all these houses which Deputy Sherwin told us had their windows smashed and were broken up and left lying idle? What caused those houses to be sited there? Who was responsible for siting them? Was it this famous Housing Committee of the Dublin Corporation? If it was, it is a very serious matter. What is going to be done with these houses? Are they to be left lying vacant? If they are, they should be known as somebody's "folly". It is a disgrace. I have dealt with houses in the Corporation of Dublin because I wanted to bring to the notice of the Deputy—
Comment on this
It will not be the first time we met in public.
Now I am going to take the Deputy up on another matter. On 11th March, 1961, I asked the Minister for Local Government a very simple question. I asked him if he would state the amount of money actually spent on the building (a) of local authority houses and (b) private houses during each of the years ended 31st March, 1950 to 1960. That was not for Dublin Corporation. That was for houses built throughout the State, including Dublin Corporation, of course. What was the reply I got? The amount of money spent on the building of houses—it is well worth remembering—in the year 1949-50 was £9,557,645; in 1950-51, it was £10,417,927; in 1951-52, it was £11,468,612; in 1952-53, it was £10,607,675; in 1954-55, it was £7,619,230; in 1955-56, it was £6,993,246; and in 1956-57—the bad year—
Comment on this
I will say the next one in a low voice. For 1957-58 the amount spent was £4 million.
Comment on this
£3 million remember. In 1959-60 the amount spent throughout the State was £3,041,327, exactly half was spent in 1959-60 as was spent in 1956-57, the bad year.
Comment on this
Is it not an awful state of affairs when a Deputy belonging, as he says, to no Party, but an honest person, tells us we have spent £10 million building houses which nobody wants? It will be a great relief to the ratepayers of Dublin to know that Deputy Sherwin, the vice-chairman of the Housing Committee, is able to tell us there is no need for houses, that anybody who wants a house can get one.