Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 152–301 of 301. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Now they are all rushing back because the Rent Control Act in Britain has been abolished.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy and the House like to hear what money was spent by Dublin Corporation? I have dealt with the number of houses built, the amount of money spent on the building of houses, and now I am going to tell the House the amount of money which was spent by Dublin Corporation. I will just give it in round figures. In 1951, they spent £3 million odd; in 1952-53, £3 million odd; in 1953, £2 million odd; in 1954, £3 million odd; in 1955, £2 million odd; in 1956, £2 million odd; in 1957, £2 million odd; in 1958, £1 million odd; in 1959, £1 million odd; and in 1960, no millions, but a fraction of——
Comment on this
In 1961, they spent only a fraction of a million. This is the great housing programme——
Comment on this
I have not got the figures for this year but I will tell the Deputy the number of houses built in eleven months of the year. It was 468 as compared with 1,564 built by us in 12 months of the last year we were in office.
Comment on this
The Deputy is speaking towards me; he is looking at me. If he looks at the Chair perhaps——
Comment on this
Deputy Sherwin is taking no notice whatever of my remarks. He will either conduct himself or leave the House. I am giving him his choice; either to conduct himself or leave the House.
Comment on this
I am telling the House, through you, Sir, that the Deputy has not got the facts right.
Comment on this
I am responsible for the conduct and the decorum of the House. Deputy Sherwin is not adding to either.
Comment on this
That is my impression too, Sir. I have explained to the House what has been spent on the building of houses throughout the State, the number of houses built, the amount of money spent by Dublin Corporation and all of that shows a decline, year in year out, since the inter-Party Government left office.
Comment on this
I am certain this Deputy from Cavan cannot know much about it. He probably did not catch what Deputy Dillon said yesterday.
Comment on this
It might be no harm if I repeated what Deputy Dillon told him yesterday about houses built in Cavan.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is not interested in the pay pause, he can go home. For the benefit of Deputy Dolan, I want to repeat now what houses were built in Cavan over the last number of years. The particulars are given in a reply by the Minister for Local Government to a question asked by Deputy O'Reilly from the constituency of Cavan.
Comment on this
As I was saying —I hope I shall not drive Deputy Dolan out of the House as I should like him to hear this reply—on 24th November, 1962, Deputy O'Reilly was interested to know, and requested the Minister for Local Government to tell him, the number of new houses built by Cavan County Council, the number of new houses built by private enterprise and the number of houses for which the Department paid reconstruction grants between the years 1954 and 1961. It is worth while putting it on the record. Cavan is a poor county like my own. They are, of course, a progressive people. They have not the same emigration we have. They have not the same influx as Deputy Sherwin told us Dublin had last year—1,500 families.
Here is the record for Cavan. In the year 1953-54, Cavan local authority built 78 houses; private enterprise built 145; and 254 houses were reconstructed. In the year 1954-55, the local authority built 99; private enterprise built 169; 250 were reconstructed. In the year 1955-56, 86 were built by the local authority; 154 were built by private enterprise; 304 were reconstructed. In the year 1956-57, 65 were built by the local authority; 166 were built by private enterprise; 396 were reconstructed. We went out of office in 1957. We no longer had any responsibility.
Comment on this
Remember the supplementary grants were stopped in 1956 as a result of Deputy O'Donnell's circular.
Comment on this
We are told the supplementary grants were stopped. We agree they were stopped in 1956, but in 1956 the local authority built 55 houses, private enterprise built 156 houses. In 1957-58 only 36 were built by the local authority; 131 by private enterprise. In 1958-59—we had no responsibility of any kind—29 were built by the local authority and only 56 by private enterprise. Again, we had no responsibility. In 1959-60—we had nothing whatever to do with it—eight were built by the local authority and 80 by private enterprise.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy know what he did in 1960-61? In that year the Cavan County Council built no new houses, not a solitary one, but 72 were built by private enterprise.
Comment on this
The Deputy left the builders and traders there without a house in 1960-61. We, at least, built houses.
Comment on this
Not one solitary house was built in Cavan in the year 1960-61. Deputy Dillon pointed out that this Vote on Account is a record one. When the Minister asks for a Vote on Account he asks for one-third of the revenue necessary to run Government for the next twelve months. This year what he asks for is a record. What local authorities are asking for to-day is a record amount for rates. These records stem from two things, and two things only. First, they stem from the slashing of the food subsidies and, secondly, from the reckless expenditure by the present Government. I use the word "reckless" purposely. In 1956, as every Deputy on the other side has pointed out, we had a financial crisis here due to the Suez crisis. For the first time in our history, other than in a national emergency, we had petrol rationing.
Comment on this
It was the Deputy put the squeeze on housing. He built none. We found it necessary to impose a tax on imported luxury goods, but we stated the tax would be a temporary one, and nothing but a temporary one. We went further. We said the moneys we collected would be used for one thing, and one thing only, namely capital development. That was in a time of international crisis. Today I do not see any international crisis. There may be a national one, but there is certainly not an international one. Why the necessity for this squeeze today? I cannot understand it. But I think there is a very good reason. There is no doubt whatever the present Government were sure that we were going to enter the Common Market, and that all we had to do was catch on to the coattails of Great Britain and, whatever terms Great Britain got into the Common Market, we would follow suit.
The Government never anticipated that Britain would be refused. They never bothered to think what the alternative would be if Britain were refused. On one occasion the Taoiseach, with his tongue in his cheek, proclaimed: "If Britain is refused, we go it alone." Those were his words. Do we hear anything today about going it alone? We certainly do not.
What are we going to do now? Immediately Britain was refused admission she started negotiations with the EFTA countries. She called in, through her diplomatic channels, the Commonwealth Prime Ministers. She had to look for an alternative. What have we done? Nothing whatever. Even now the Taoiseach is going to Great Britain merely to have talks. Talks on what? We have not been told. We have not been told whether he is going to try to negotiate trade talks, economic talks, political talks, or any other kind of talk. He is merely going. He could be going to present shamrock to Mr. Macmillan on St. Patrick's Day.
The North-east has a serious problem. They are badgering the British Government to improve the economy and to do something for the unemployed. Here we are, down in the South, twiddling our fingers, doing nothing. We have a problem. Is it not time we began to talk with our neighbours across the Border? Is it not time we became realistic? We sent a note of thanks to the head of the RUC when he escorted the President over the Border to Armagh on a recent sad occasion. But when it comes to economic talks with the Northern Government, we refuse to recognise them.
Comment on this
I withdraw the word and substitute "untrue". We never refused to enter into economic negotiations——
Comment on this
So, we now have a change of policy enunciated by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach. For the first time, down through the years, this Government recognise the Six Counties——
Comment on this
I said "... refuse to recognise them." If you recognised the Government of the Six Counties down through the years, why have you never come out on your political platforms and said so?
Comment on this
Very well; I am talking nonsense, maybe; but if you recognise the Government of the Six Counties, it is time you consulted with them and that they consulted with you on the economic situation existing here.
Comment on this
I am speaking through the Chair. When I say "you", I do not refer to the Parliamentary Secretary: I am referring to the Government. I say now that it is time that the Government said, in effect: "We have similar problems North and South. Let us get together. Let us discuss our economic problems. Let us discuss the other problems which may be common to both of us and let us see where we go for the future." It is time that were done and, if it were done, we should know where we are going.
Comment on this
You are very fond of building up that Border here and there, without any hope of bringing down the tariff wall between it——
Comment on this
The Deputy will not get me away from these matters. I am very glad to hear to-day people such as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance talk about the number of cattle we have in this country. He boasts of the number of cattle on the hoof in this country at the moment. We are all proud of that. I wonder if Fianna Fáil are as proud of it as the Parliamentary Secretary is? Do you remember what they said about the cattle industry in this country? Do you remember what they said some years ago when they hoped every ship crossing the Irish sea carrying a four-footed beast would go to the bottom? Do you remember when they advised the people of this country to slit the throats of the calves?
Comment on this
The Government are now depending on two Blueshirts to keep them in office. Do not insult them.
Comment on this
Were it not that we had some very good officers in the Irish Army at that time to control these gentlemen when they were running wild——
Comment on this
I do not like that. It is personal. There is no need for that. Let us have none of that sort of stuff. The Deputy said it because Deputy Egan has a brother in the Army. The period of the Economic War is a period which Fine Gael should be damned well ashamed to mention in this House.
Comment on this
You acted the Quisling during the Economic War and the Irish people have repudiated you for it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I want to draw attention to a reference that has been made to me by Deputy O'Sullivan. He termed me a "Blue-shirt." I have no notion of stooping as low as Deputy O'Sullivan. Going around his native Millstreet, one is struck by the fact that he is not held in very high esteem. I am quite willing to meet the Deputy anywhere, either inside or outside this House, and, if he looks for it, he will get more of that, too: I shall tell him a bit more.
Comment on this
It was you, over there. I should be very ashamed to be on the same platform as you over there.
Comment on this
Deputy Sheridan stayed on his feet talking and refused to listen to me. So did several other Deputies. Deputy O'Donnell is discussing the Vote on Account. He should be listened to, without interruption.
Comment on this
I apologise to the Chair but certainly I shall not allow anybody to get away with anything on me.
Comment on this
The Deputy has interrupted me and deliberately stood up to speak while I was standing. He should be sufficiently well acquainted with the rules of the House to know that that is not allowed.
Comment on this
I appreciate how the Chair feels about being interrupted. Seeing how often I have been interrupted, I appreciate how the Chair feels about it.
Comment on this
We should try to see where we are going. I believe the Government do not know where they are going. They are telling us now that all the money, all the expenditure, they have poured out during the past few years has been on the building up of industries in this country. Where are we to export the manufactured goods turned out by these industries? Can any person tell me that? We thought, when we voted the money for these factories, we would export into the Common Market. That is closed to us. Where now will our manufactured goods go to? That is what I should like to know. Will the Minister tell us?
Comment on this
There is the answer we get: "Some of them, but we will not tell you where they go." Supposing, for a second, Britain gets the Commonwealth to rejoin her, with a tariff wall around that Commonwealth. Where are we to export our manufactured goods, our industrial goods?
Comment on this
The Minister finds no fault: we are agreed on that. Again, we have Denmark looking for a greater quota for her agricultural produce. What are we doing to increase the quota which Deputy Dillon got for us in 1948? Nothing whatever. I have not heard of the Minister for Agriculture visiting the British Government for a good many years back to try to negotiate better terms. We were so certain we would get into the Common Market that we did not bother our heads to look into the future. These are all very serious matters.
It is all very fine to say that there is a gap of £100 million between our imports and exports. That gap has been caused by the importation of raw materials for processing and of machinery for the setting up of industries here. However, the Minister must tell us and the industrialists where they are to export their manufactured goods. He must also tell the farmers what he is doing to procure markets for our agricultural produce. I do not believe he knows. Let me end with the biblical quotation by asking the Government : Quo vadis?
Comment on this
It was rather amazing to listen to Deputy O'Donnell. Were it not that the Irish people are the most charitable race in the world, they would never vote again for Fine Gael or Labour, because on two occasions when they got an opportunity of taking over the Government, they sabotaged the economic interests of this nation. In spite of that, they have the cheek to speak to the Irish people as they have spoken here since this Vote on Account was introduced. They ran away from their responsibilities in 1951 and left the Fianna Fáil Government with a very ugly job to do in balancing the budget. They were bluffing the people that everything in the garden was lovely. I remember the Taoiseach saying from the other side of the House after we had been defeated in the election: "We are handing over this State in a sound financial position; give it back to us the same way". The economic position of the country was never better when we handed over office to the inter-Party Government. Our external assets at that time, even in Britain, amounted to over £400 million.
The first thing our Minister for Finance had to do in 1951 was to try to rectify the economic mistakes made by the inter-Party Government. In 1952, we on this side of the House had to swallow a very hard pill in standing over the Budget of that year in order to put the national finances on a proper footing. We did that, putting the interests of Ireland before the interests of our Party. We felt that if we never came back to office, we had to put the country right financially. That was done and again the propaganda and the whispering started. In 1954, we were again defeated and from 1954 to 1957, things went from bad to worse with the inter-Party Government. Deputy McGilligan who was a member of that Government came in here last night criticising everything this Government were doing. I look upon him as an honourable, decent man but I cannot say that his politics were honest. Deputy Dillon, Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Sweetman, in spite of all that happened when they were the Government, will tell the people they have the cure for all ills now.
In 1957, for the second time, the Minister for Finance, and his colleagues in the Government had to face up to a shocking financial position left by the inter-Party Government and had to do unpopular things for which we have been criticised by Deputy McGilligan and Deputy O'Donnell. I should like some building contractors from the city and county of Dublin to have been listening to Deputy O'Donnell, especially those whom he forced to go to Canada, Australia and the United States by his plausible talk here when he was Minister for Local Government, advising building contractors that there was money for everything. Many a decent contractor accepted Deputy O'Donnell's word at that time and some of them are in Canada and Australia still. In my constituency at that time, there were no housing loans or grants available. In 1955 and 1956, people were leaving the country as fast as they could. They did not even bother to give up the key of the house to the local authority. Yet Deputy O'Donnell now tells the House what he did. There was not the price of a bag of cement left when the inter-Party Government left office, not to mind sufficient money to build houses.
When the Minister for Finance took office, he had to get a number of local authorities out of difficulties. There was no credit available from the banks or from building societies. Industry of all kinds had come to a standstill and the Fianna Fáil Government had to restore the people's confidence in the country. The banks started to advance money again. Then the Government, through the Minister for Finance, once more had to pay the debts that were incurred by the inter-Party Government on housing. There were then no grants for houses, no agricultural grant, no schools being built.
I must pay the former Deputy Mulcahy the compliment of saying that at that time at least he was honest. When he was Minister for Education and when I complained bitterly about the school building programme in Dublin, he replied with words to the effect that you cannot take trousers from a Highlander—you cannot build schools when there is no money available. Yet we had Deputy P. O'Donnell today saying there was plenty of money. He knows very well that it was action taken by him which deprived SDA applicants of their loans. I did not come in here armed with documentary proof of all this but I cannot let it rest when I hear Deputies opposite making such obviously dishonest statements.
Under Fianna Fáil government, the workers were never better off than they are nowadays. There was very little for anybody in 1956 when the other crowd left office. Immediately afterwards, social benefits increased, wages and salaries went up and the building industry was given a new lease of life. Industrial grants are now available and the people of Ireland are generally a jolly sight better off than they were under the inter-Party Government. I hope in the national interest the people will never trust them again.
Deputy P. O'Donnell spoke of the housing programme of the Dublin Corporation. Neither the Minister for Local Government nor the Minister for Finance has impeded in any way the Corporation's housing plans and I should like to point out that last year about 1,700 SDA loan houses were built. Through supplementary grant schemes, things have become much easier for those anxious to build their own houses, and all I hope is that the present Minister for Finance will continue the good work. As Deputy Sherwin has pointed out, Dublin in 1948 had an estimated housing deficiency of 20,000 dwellings. It was further estimated at the time that an additional demand for about 1,000 dwellings per annum would accrue as a result of normal family growth.
I have here a report from the City Manager for last year which tells how this problem was tackled:—
In planning to meet the deficiency, it was estimated that about 200 dwellings per annum would become available for new tenancies as a result of net vacancies in the existing housing estates. By net vacancies I mean the complete vacation of houses and not transfers of tenancy on the death of a tenant to some other member of the family continuing to live in the house, or inter-transfers between tenants.
The net vacancies began substantially to increase in 1954-55 when they amounted to 605 dwellings; in 1955-56 the figure increased to 763, and by 1956-57 had reached 986. During the administrative years 1948-49 to 1956-57 inclusive, 15,279 new houses were built and the net vacancies reached a figure of 3,777. In that period, therefore, 19,056 families were rehoused. At the same time, operations under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts helped 5,879 families to provide homes for themselves — a total of 24,935 families. Capital expenditure in that nine-year period was £25,283,234 under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts, and £8,838,493 under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Acts—a total of £34,121,727. The combined effect of this was that the pressure for new housing substantially decreased.
I do not want to delay the House much longer in reading this report, but I think it is necessary in view of the statement made by Deputy P. O'Donnell. The City Manager goes on:—
It had been decided to pursue the construction programme with all possible expedition until the housing deficiency was made good, and to that end substantial acquisitions of further sites were made which are noted in Appendix II of this report. However, when the substantial and continuously increasing vacancy rate was noted and considered in 1956, this resulted in a suspension of new development proposals and some delay in placing new housing contracts. Net vacancies continued to increase for a further three years. In 1957-58, they provided 1,294 dwellings, in 1958-59, 1,393, and in 1959-60, 1,605. During this period, new building reduced from 1,564 dwellings in 1956-57 to 1,021 in 1957-58, 460 in 1958-59 and 505 in 1959-60. During that three-year period, therefore, 6,278 families were housed.
The Chairman of the Dublin Corporation Housing Committee is Mr. Denis Larkin and it cannot be said that he would not have the interests of the working classes at heart. The City Manager and the members are all most anxious to see that everything possible is done to provide adequate housing. Deputy P. O'Donnell's contribution here then was nothing but another effort to sabotage housing operations in Dublin.
Even though we met with a reversal in our attempts to join the Common Market, everything possible is being done by the Government to stimulate external trade but unfortunately everything we do is being met with opposition from the Fine Gael Party who seem out for sabotage of the national effort. I thought we were all at one in relation to international affairs, but apparently the Fine Gael Party are more concerned with their own interests and their own petty outlook than they are with the national interest. Of course I should have known that because they have proved it over the years. When Deputy O'Donnell started to talk about the Economic War, he mentioned cattle. He should have been ashamed of himself because they played England's game at that time. What happened during the Civil War could have been reversed if we had had a Party in this House other than the Fine Gael Party, or the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, as they were then.
I am sorry to go back on history like this but they brought it on themselves. Deputy O'Donnell raised this question in the House or I would not raise it. We on this side of the House are anxious to go ahead and not back. Because it was raised, I want to make clear the position in which the Irish people found themselves at that time. We were betrayed and Fine Gael played England's game. They are now telling the country to get rid of Fianna Fáil and that they have cures for everything.
Fianna Fáil always have, and always will, put the interests of Ireland before their own interests. Whether we are in office or out of office, we will always be concerned about the interests of the nation. We will not play with the economic interests of the nation as did Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Dillon and quite a number of others who spoke. They sabotaged the country, and left us in economic ruin when we defeated them in 1957.
Comment on this
This Vote traditionally gives us an opportunity of reviewing the economic position of the country and it is appropriate that a rural Deputy such as myself should avail of the opportunity to put before the House matters which affect my constituency. I do not want to extend the discussion which has been rather protracted and, in fact, has become very localised. From the discussions that have taken place, it is quite obvious that there are two schools of thought in the House, that there is the city man and the rural man. Deputy Sherwin talked for something over an hour and a half this morning and he discussed, nothing but housing and Dublin Corporation. That may be all very fine for Deputy Sherwin who is a Dublin Deputy, but the economic conditions prevailing in the country at the moment concern more than the townsman, the city man or Dublin Corporation.
I want to refer to the people who are affected by the prevailing economic conditions in my constituency. Perhaps I can segregate them into three different communities: (1), the farming community; (2), the traders in the small and big towns; and (3), the workers. I think it appropriate for me to say at this stage that the farmers must be considered the most important members of the community for many reasons. When I say that, I do not wish to detract in any way from the importance of the small town dweller, the big town dweller, the road worker or the factory worker.
I think it has been conceded by all politicians and by all economists that we are an agricultural country and, as such, our basic economy must be agriculture. I am glad—and I say this without apologies to anyone on either side of the House—to see that the farmers to-day are organised. I am glad to see the farmers members of the National Farmers' Association, Muintir na Tíre or any other branch of the farming organisations. I think it was well past time when the farmers should organise themselves as an economic unit. The working man who joined a trade union movement has reaped the reward of his organisation and to-day, as a result of the efforts made by the trade unions, the working man is guaranteed at least what he is entitled to: a fair wage for a fair day's work. Many years ago the worker was not paid for his labour. Perhaps that was a result of the stigma left over from the old days of the British rule when they used our great grandfathers as slave labour.
I am glad that the farmers have organised themselves in a manner somewhat similar to the trade union movement. No matter what Government are in office, the important part to be played by the farming community must be recognised. The farmer has now become educated and respect is due to the poor farmers' sons who became highly educated. I want to pay tribute to those who went into the various Civil Service Departments, gained experience and passed it on to their organisations. I want to advise them in my own small way. Let the farming organisations keep clear of all political Parties and proceed on the lines on which they are proceeding at present, and Ireland will benefit from their efforts, and the farmers in general will benefit from the results of the efforts of these organisations.
I do not want to be personal towards the Minister for Agriculture but he must take responsibility for his Department and he must take responsibility for the well-being of the agricultural community. I regret to have to say in this House that, in my modest opinion, the Minister for Agriculture has completely abandoned and neglected the farmers, and especially the small farmers of Ireland. It is quite easy to talk about the industries in rural Ireland but we must never forget that in rural Ireland small farmers with small families, and sometimes small farmers with large families, are little old-established industries which, I regret to say, are quickly disappearing.
I very much regret having to criticise the Minister for Agriculture, who is not travelling to London on 18th March with the Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs. I think the Minister for External Affairs has enough travelling of his own to do to New York, Brussels and Paris and now we find him going to London when the Minister for Agriculture should be going there to talk to his opposite number in the British Government about finding a market for the produce of the small farmers of the West of Ireland and the large farmers of the midlands.
The Taoiseach still seems to be interested only in industry and he is still talking about industrial expansion when our entry into the Common Market is in jeopardy. It is considered by our economists that if we fail to become a member of the Common Market, there is no hope for the survival of many industries established over the past ten years. Is it not true to state that in many cases where large grants were passed on to industries in the past eight or nine years, these industries are now beginning to collapse? That is wasted money. There is one thing for which there is always a market, and that is, the produce which we can grow on the land of Ireland.
Great publicity has been given by Government speakers to the amount of money allocated to agriculture but I must repeat to the House what the House already knows, that is, that the farmers' income last year dropped by something like £20 million. I want seriously to ask the House what good there is in giving a grant to a farmer to erect a piggery, or a cow byre, or a henhouse, or to reclaim his land. If you do not provide him with a market for the produce he is going to get from his land. That is completely irregular planning.
A great amount of capital expenditure has been thrown at the Irish farmer that is not worth the snap of his fingers to him. What we want at the moment is a market for the Irish farmer. The egg from which the farmer's wife used to get the money to run her household, is gone. The pig is gone. What have they left? We are depending entirely on our cattle trade to keep up our exports, and in the west of Ireland we suffer from the disadvantage that when there is a possibility of profit to be made out of the store bullock, we are short of grass and must dispose of him. I must appeal to the Minister not to be demanding that the farmers should improve their holdings, and, at the same time, not making any effort to provide a market for their produce.
We in the west have probably been hit hardest by emigration. When speaking on the Vote on Account last year, I drew attention to the fact that we had 20,000 emigrants from Mayo in the previous ten years. The indications are that there will be a further increase in that movement. I was amused this morning to hear Deputy Sherwin talk about all the people coming back to Dublin. I think he is confused by the number of people coming here from the west of Ireland and stalling in Dublin looking for work. It is that rather than the number coming back from England that confuses him.
I have quite a good knowledge of my constituency and, apart from my political movements through it, I have quite a good commercial knowledge of it. In any town I go to, or in any small village, I see no movements back from England but I can see quite a big movement from Ballina station out of my constituency. That is a big loss to us.
I do not want to extend this already protracted discussion but I must refer to the position in my constituency with regard to the rates. Speaking here this time last year, I drew the attention of the House to the fact that a week or two earlier we had been discussing our estimate at the meeting in Castlebar of the Mayo County Council and I mentioned that the indications were that the rate for County Mayo would be 50s. in the £. It ultimately turned out that the rate was 55s. On that occasion, I beseeched the Government to do something for the seaboard counties of the west, as they could not, from their own resources, curtail the high expenditure.
On last Saturday week, one year later, I was present at the meeting of Mayo County Council with my colleagues. May I put it on the records of this House that there are 31 genuine members of that council who sit in Castlebar and who, irrespective of their political affiliations, are concerned to produce as low a rate as possible and at the same time to give the people as good a service as possible? The rate struck by any local authority is the price you pay for the services you give your people. On last Saturday week, for a poor county like Mayo, we struck the abnormal rate of 62s. in the £ and I am predicting here and now that the people of Mayo will get no better services, medically or otherwise, than they got last year.
That brings me to a section of the community which, in my opinion, must receive consideration in the forthcoming Budget. I refer to the small shopkeepers and business people of the small towns and villages in Mayo. They are a section of the community with a genuine grievance because they have had to suffer a progressive decline in their business. If you have a dwindling population, you must have a decline in business. To that misfortune must be added increased wages, rates, transport charges, electricity charges and so on, without any increase in business and in most cases, with the advent of supermarket business, reduced profits. In my constituency, many of the smaller towns such as Swinford, Killala, Crossmolina, Charlestown and Belmullet are just hanging on. May I repeat what I said at a county council meeting that in bringing our rates to 62s. in the £, we have drawn the axe on the small towns of County Mayo.
Comment on this
I am very sorry. Will you attribute it to my inexperience as a new member of the House?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance should have more experience and he did it.
Comment on this
Despite the fact that I may have gone over the line to impress on the Minister opposite that we have a grievance, I hope the Minister at the next Cabinet meeting will whisper my remarks to the Minister for Finance. At various times in the year in my constituency, we have numbers of unemployed and quite a lot of work to do in connection with unemployment assistance and stamps and the dole. I am sure the other Deputies from the constituency will bear that out. It is a terrible state of affairs that accommodation roads in my county are in a disgraceful condition——
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy but the question of accommodation roads should relevantly be raised on the Estimate. It is not really a matter for this debate.
Comment on this
I was about to correlate it with expenditure out of which money will be provided in the Vote on Account. I shall bow to your ruling but if you permit me to correlate my remarks, I think you will find that I am relevant.
Comment on this
Surely, so far as Government policy or lack of it impinges upon the situation, it is relevant to discuss it on the Vote on Account?
Comment on this
Practically everything apropos of Government policy other than specific itemising of Estimates is relevant.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not agree that Deputy Browne is itemising when dealing with expenditure on accommodation roads?
Comment on this
But he has indicated to the Chair that he is going to relate that to the expenditure on the Vote on Account. With due respect, I think the Deputy is so entitled.
Comment on this
It is difficult to blame the Deputy or any other Deputy when the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance referred to the 70-hour week worked by the Labour officials and the desirability of the Labour Party transferring their votes to Fianna Fáil in the by-election. When that was permitted, anything is permissible.
Comment on this
Everything cannot be permitted. Only matters of general policy and expenditure are permitted.
Comment on this
I quite appreciate the position of the Chair. He has been more than tolerant and he has to put up with quite a lot from other speakers. I do not propose to take up the time of the House. I want to make constructive criticism in an objective way for the benefit of the Government and ultimately for my constituents and I felt it my duty to bring these facts before the House. If the Chair would be patient and allow me to correlate my remarks to what I had in mind, I think he would find they are relevant.
The Department of Social Welfare pay £3 to £3 10s. in unemployment assistance each week. That is no use to a married man today. It is like giving biscuits to an elephant. I should prefer to see co-operation between the Board of Works and the Department of Social Welfare in this respect so that instead of giving a man £3 10s. for doing nothing—and in so doing, simply making him lazy physically and mentally and no addition to the economy—where there are accommodation roads to be repaired and schemes generally under the Board of Works required to be done, the Board of Works would put up another £3 10s. and do productive work which would benefit the constituency and benefit the individual who will have a decent income and a decent job? That is the suggestion to which I wished to correlate my earlier remarks. In that way accommodation roads would be immensely improved and they require it urgently. The recipient of unemployment benefit would be getting a respectable wage and doing respectable, productive work. You could also have him opening drains and working to benefit the land which would result in further production.
The time has come when something must be done for western seaboard counties. I do not know if it is relevant to suggest it now but the Government will have to consider seriously setting up a rates equalisation fund for counties like Mayo, Galway, Roscommon, Sligo, Leitrim, Donegal, Kerry and Cork. In Mayo, we are in the unhappy position that valuations are small and the population declining and therefore the per capita contribution expected from the remaining population has become an unbearable burden. We shall have to get more aid from the central authority. The Government have access to funds that no local authority could hope to get and if a burden becomes too big for any section of the community, we shall all have to make our contribution from the central authority to meet that problem. Here is a problem and if you do not do something about it, there will be no west of Ireland.
I appeal very strongly to the Minister sitting opposite, a Connacht man himself, with, I am sure, as much experience of West of Ireland problems as I have. He is a much older man and although a member of the Government, I believe that close to his heart he must have the very grave situation that arises for the farmers and townspeople in the West of Ireland, especially in places like Mayo and Galway.
I want to criticise the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands for his neglect since coming into office of the fishing industry in the West of Ireland. I was quite pleased when a young Parliamentary Secretary was appointed to that important position because I always believed, although I come from an inland part of the constituency, that there is a tremendous potential of wealth along the coast of Ireland, especially the north Mayo coast outside Erris and Achill. There is tremendous scope there. Almighty God has provided the material to raise the fish. All the fishermen on the west coast require is adequate boats, equipment and landing facilities. Yet it is not unusual to find that in the West the fish we eat on Fridays has been brought down from Dublin.
Comment on this
Provision will have to be made in the Vote on Account for fisheries. Is it not relevant to advise the Parliamentary Secretary how that money should be spent?
Comment on this
The position is that the Deputy will get an opportunity on the Estimate to discuss fisheries.
Comment on this
When the Budget is brought in, the money will be voted at that stage. I bow to your ruling, Sir.
Comment on this
I would not want to depart from the accepted procedure, Sir. When the young Parliamentary Secretary was appointed, we hoped he would put initiative and drive into the fishing industry. I could not understand how a man from an inland part of the country was put in charge of fisheries, but I presumed he had a fishing background, either as a rod fisherman or as a deep-sea fisherman. Along with the other two Deputies from the constituency, I have attended many meetings in the Erris area and have gone on deputations to the Parliamentary Secretary. I regret to say he has done very little with regard to landing facilities in either Achill or Erris or the provision of fishing boats or gear.
Comment on this
I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will change his policy in that respect. Otherwise, he will be hearing more from me.
Finally, I appeal to the Government to take immediate steps to provide marketing facilities and a guaranteed market for farm produce. I appeal to them also to consider the plight of the towns in the West of Ireland. What is to keep them in business? I can assure the Government that I will never encourage either the NFA or trade union workers to look for anything unreasonable. But I want to tell the Government that, so long as I am a member of this House, I shall never hesitate to back up any section of my community who I feel are not getting a fair crack of the whip from Government policy.
Comment on this
I do not intend to take up the time of the House making a long political speech. As an Independent Deputy, however, I should like to make a few observations. My voice is not very often heard here. I feel my time is much better spent looking after the needs of my constituents than taking part in some of the political debates one has to bear with here at times. I am sick and tired of listening to the howls from the Opposition since I came into this House—I say that with emphasis—telling the people that the Government have brought the country to perdition. I am also sick of the Government answering the Opposition back by asking: "What did you do in 1955-56?" It reminds me of my school days, when one young fellow said to another "Strike me and I will strike you back."
The time to end this political bickering is long overdue. I do not agree that this Government, or any other Government as far back as I can remember, are perfect; but I think the Government are doing their best. Apparently, the Opposition think they would do much better if they were in government. But they are not in government. That is the will of the people. I would appeal to the Opposition, if they have any constructive advice to offer, to put it forward. In that way, they will be doing a good day's work for themselves and, above all, for Ireland, instead of adopting a negative attitude.
I am sorry to say that the example set here has gone further afield. One has only to read the debates of county councils and county committees of agriculture down the country. You will find those bodies reeking with politics. Political play-actors, I would call them, with one or two gluttonous speech-makers wasting the time of the sincere people on those bodies. They have only one idea in mind—to get their names pasted across the local papers.
This is the largest Estimate ever to come before this House. The only consolation in it for me personally is that our primary industry is being voted a large amount of money, which it richly deserves. It is still, and always will be, our basic industry. I am glad to say the Government have recognised that. A great deal of publicity has been given recently to an increase in the price of creamery milk. If such an increase is given, I shall welcome it indeed. Many people in my constituency have changed their former pattern of farming and have gone over to milk production. If an increase is given, I am sure it will be welcomed by all. At the same time, I appreciate the difficulties. I know the heavy subsidies Bord Bainne have to face at the moment. I do not think it is as easy as Deputy T. O'Donnell told us it was last night. I do not think we can find these markets in the countries mentioned by the Deputy.
I was present at an international milk conference in Tours, France, last May two years. With the exception of the Iron Curtain countries, every country in Europe was represented there. The delegates had only one aim in mind: to find a market for milk and milk products. Leaving that conference after three days, we were just as wise as when we went in. The president of the conference, Mr. Vincent, who was also chairman of the NFU said, "You will see that every gun at this conference is pointed at the British Market." Various references were made on that occasion to India, Africa and various places were named in Africa, such as Nigeria, where we could find a market for our milk and milk products. The Germans who had already tried those places got up and laughed at such a proposal. They said: "We tried those places but we came to realise that we were not a charitable institution; the market is there but we have nothing to get." That is my humble opinion, unless that trend has changed within the past two years. That is how I found it in the milk business. If anybody wants to get into the milk business or if anybody has high hopes of export markets, then I am not the one to depress him.
Speaking on this Vote last year, I explained the need for changing the Undeveloped Areas Act so that counties such as those I represent would get the chance to have new industries. I am glad to say that now through the enterprise of local people, a new industry is mooted for Mullingar. This is a meat factory which will benefit the farmers as well as the townspeople and the workers. We have high hopes that this factory will materialise some time next year. I ask the Minister to be prepared to give us all the help we will require when it comes to that time.
Last year, I also appealed to the Minister for Agriculture to give us the seed scheme which operated in other areas and now I want to express my gratitude to the Minister for making that scheme available to the farmers in North Longford. As they say, every little helps.
The Inny drainage scheme is a great boon to my constituency at the moment. I hope when it is finished, some other scheme will be made available by the Government for that part of the country. It is giving large-scale employment at the moment and greater benefits will come when swampy land becomes suitable for grazing and tillage. I should also like to compliment the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance on the working of this scheme.
I should like to remind the House that there is great uneasiness about increased rates on agricultural land. Deputy Browne also mentioned this. Rates can be a very heavy burden, although I am not unmindful of the reliefs given last year. I hope the day is not too far off when the Government will be in a position to give full derating on agricultural land. On the subject of rates, I am not forgetting people who need sympathy in this direction. I am speaking of people who are living in large useless buildings in towns and villages, whose businesses have been whittled down and whose backs are being broken by heavy rates. I do not know what can be done for them unless they form themselves into a body like other bodies which are doing all the shouting about rates.
Last Thursday morning, I saw looming before my eyes in the newspapers mention of the very large sum of £5 million to be devoted to setting up supermarkets. I wonder who is at the root of this venture? I wonder who is to benefit by these supermarkets? I wonder how decent business people, small and large, who have borne the brunt for so long of good business and bad business, whose families have been engaged in the same business for generations, will fare against such ventures? Are we to turn our backs on these people? Are we to leave the rural towns like a city about which I read recently where supermarkets have taken over and where flats have replaced business houses and where the streets have become carparks and the ladies and gentlemen who deal in the supermarkets walk from their cars from places which once throbbed with good business? The Government should look very carefully into this matter and see if by any chance this is investment by foreigners because I can tell you it is not for love of the ordinary people of Ireland that they are coming in to start supermarkets.
Some time ago and also recently, there was great talk from the Opposition, and from other people, too, who were not so much of the Opposition, about Germans buying up land and about "hot" money coming in. I have not heard one word about the business people who are being put on the road by the invasion of supermarkets. Is the sympathy created now for the farmers merely because they have a strong organisation? I am glad that they have a good strong organisation because I am a farmer myself, and a farmer of no small dimensions either, and I need all the sympathy that is coming to me, whether from the Government or from an association. But I would ask the people who shouted here before about the Germans to take up the cudgels now for the business people of rural Ireland and the city of Dublin and to see that they are not put on the road and that they will not be found standing at the labour exchange.
There is another matter to which I should like to refer, a matter which, thank God, has not got far but which has sounded the deathknell of a certain section who were always decent, hard-working people and who were never found at the labour exchange. Some time ago, some financiers got the idea that they would start a business here called the cattle mart and they would eliminate the middleman and the farmers would have an assured market for all time. They even got around some of the county medical officers of health to publish items saying that fairs held in the streets were not healthy. They succeeded to a certain extent in doing that. Is the market for the farmers any better? I think it is a whole lot worse for them and for the business people of Ireland. Together with that, they have put some decent, hardworking people out of business. Once more, I should like to remind the House that they should be careful about the supermarkets.
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene in this debate but I have listened to the speeches made here during the past couple of days and, having done so, I feel it incumbent upon me to say something in relation to the matters that have been discussed. Listening to the Fine Gael speakers is a depressing experience. I can only regard them as a Party who project gloom and despondency. They have pursued a course of denigrating the Government and the efforts the Government are making to develop and improve our economy. No doubt their speeches are largely coloured by the fact that there is an impending by-election in North-East Dublin, a constituency I have the honour to represent, caused by the lamented passing of Deputy Belton.
In all the speeches made by the Fine Gael Party, there has been no specific proposal to reduce the large bill before the House. I should here like to compliment the members of the Labour Party, who have contributed to this discussion: they had a constructive approach and, if they had any criticism to make, it was that the bill is not large enough. Fine Gael, on the other hand, have endeavoured to represent to the country that our economy is unsound. Everybody knows we have a sound economy. It is through the efforts and the policy pursued by Fianna Fáil since they returned to office in 1957 that the economy has been made sound once more. To-day we can see the success of that policy.
I should like to refer to the housing position, on which some stress has been laid here. Fine Gael are trying to make political capital out of the present housing difficulty. They do not like to be reminded that it was their mishandling of the affairs of the country a number of years ago that produced some of the conditions that exist to-day. Every member of this House who is a member of a local authority has detailed the causes of the recession in the building industry in this city. I, and other members of the corporation, know well the reasons why building tapered off.
Since the return of the Fianna Fáil Government, building has been considerably stimulated. Today, there are over 1,000 houses and flats in course of construction. Another 3,000 are projected, and plans have been advanced for the building of a further 4,000. The effective waiting list is in the region of 4,000 or 5,000 applicants. With the impetus, encouragement and financial assistance given, I see no reason why the housing problem should not be solved within a reasonable period. The problem has been complicated somewhat by the fact that our emigrants are returning. On the waiting list to-day, there are at least 800 families who have returned from England, because of the employment opportunities resulting from the policy pursued by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
There are increased employment opportunities. The columns in the newspapers are full of advertisements seeking employment. The records of the Dublin Corporation stand in testimony of the situation.
In this Vote on Account, there is an additional sum of £400,000 for housing. That will help to stimulate further building activity by both local authority and private enterprise. That is in marked contrast to the experience in the Dublin Corporation when Fine Gael were the predominant partners in the Coalition Government some few years ago. In those depressing years, there were, in north-east Dublin, vacant building sites and uncompleted houses, a monument to the ineptitude of the Coalition Government. The builders emigrated to America, Canada and England and, of course, the building operatives followed them. We had the colossal figure of 100,000 unemployed. We had conditions which produced marches by the unemployed in this city.
Comment on this
Fine Gael have the cheek to criticise the efforts of the Fianna Fáil Government. I am giving the facts. The Coalition Government had tremendous unemployment and emigration was mounting week after week. Thanks to the efforts of this Government, and the policy pursued, that situation has now changed. That policy is outlined in the Vote on Account.