Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 14—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–189 of 354. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I was amazed at the irresponsible statements by some members on the Opposition benches and by some of the criticism of this Budget. There was nothing constructive about it. It is interesting to look back over the years and to consider the achievements of these people who indulged in irresponsible and destructive criticism of this Budget. They tried to bring prosperity to the country by selling our transatlantic aircraft; they cut down on productive employment; and, generally speaking, they destroyed the economic life of the nation. How could we expect anything from these people but destructive criticism?
Fianna Fáil are concerned with the national wellbeing. In his opening words on the Budget, the Minister for Finance said:
The purpose of the Budget is not merely to regulate the nation's finances but also to promote national progress.
"National progress" are the key words of the Fianna Fáil Party—both politically and economically. The Minister continued:
To judge what this year's Budget should do, it is not necessary to review the main features and trends of the past year.
The Minister took over this country in 1957 when the Coalition Government left office for the second time and left this country in a very bad way. A large number of people were in need of employment and the economic life of the country was in very bad condition. My fear is that some of the present criticism of this Budget by the Opposition will be swallowed by people outside who are not conversant with the facts.
It is essential that the people should think seriously about our national progress. It would be very easy for this Party to do the popular thing, as the Coalition did. It would be very easy for us to run away from our responsibilities as the Coalition completely ran away from their responsibilities in 1951 and again in 1957. However, propaganda is a very strange thing. It depends on how often you can tell a story and how well you can tell it. A Deputy told me last evening that this new turnover tax would increase the family budget even to the extent of an increase in the price of pepper. A tin of it would do a family for 12 months. Surely that was rather a farfetched statement on his part?
Comment on this
In 1957 the Minister for Finance had the dirtiest job to do that any Minister could have in order to bring the country back to a satisfactory state economically. I am concerned about progress. I am concerned about leaving the purchasing power with the people. We in Fianna Fáil are concerned about national development. The Minister, with the backing of his own Party, put the country back on the upgrade.
Take the years from 1948. The people were told that Fianna Fáil were robbing the country and that they should put Fianna Fáil out of office. As soon as they left office the Taoiseach, then Deputy Lemass, said from the opposite side of the House: "We have given you over the country in a sound financial position. Give it back to us the same way." Of course, they did not. They were not able to face up to their responsibility. They finished up by selling everything, aeroplanes——
Comment on this
Backed by the Deputy's Party, they sold the aeroplanes. Anything that was going ahead under Fianna Fáil was destroyed by the Coalition Government. They criticised our tourist industry. Fianna Fáil tried to encourage visitors from abroad to come here and we were told we were feeding strangers when we were not able to feed our own. They were not concerned about our adverse trade balance and wanted to bring home our external assets. This was the type of humbug we had to put up with here. They nearly destroyed the nation and we nearly lost our political freedom as well as our economic freedom so that we had almost to go on our knees to some foreign country to assist us.
This sort of propaganda and misrepresentation has been carried out in other good nations throughout Europe and against very good Governments in Europe which are now controlled by communists. In this Budget the Minister is doing nothing more than facing up to the responsibilities that he and his Party have to the people of this country and to posterity. Because there is a 2½ per cent turnover tax the Minister is criticised notwithstanding the fact that as the result of the policy of Fianna Fáil prosperity in business even during the last year is greater by 7 per cent than it had been the year before.
It would have been easy enough for the Minister to say: "We shall cut down on A, B or C. We shall build no more schools. We shall provide no more grants for factories." There was a statement made last night that we should not borrow for any development. Admittedly, one cannot expect very much except that type of talk from a member of a Party that did not last very long in this House or in the life of the nation. However, this nation is going ahead and it is to be hoped that what happened in 1948 will not happen again, that the people of Ireland will not fall for the same type of propaganda as they fell for in 1948 and in 1954. I appeal to the people of Ireland to go back over those years and to think how much the Coalition Government retarded the progress of this ancient nation. We want to see the people better off and see the Minister's policy being implemented in order to achieve that. We are concerned for every section of the community irrespective of class or creed. That has been our policy.
I know there are still some Deputies on the other side of the House and some of my colleagues here who wish to speak so I merely want to revert to the taxes. I am delighted to see Deputy Donegan here this afternoon because Deputy Donegan has been asking the Minister for Agriculture to increase the price of milk. He said he would like to see the farmers getting 6d a gallon if the nation could afford it but when it was increased by a penny a gallon under this Budget, Deputy Donegan went into the lobby and voted against giving the farmers of Ireland an extra penny a gallon. He has been asking many questions in the House and he took it up with the Minister for Agriculture on a few occasions and tried to embarrass the Minister by saying the farmers were badly treated. When he had an opportunity of doing something for the farmers along with his colleagues in the Fine Gael Party, he voted against the increase of a penny per gallon.
Comment on this
I shall not bother about it any more. I have made my point. Believe it or not, a few days after the Budget Deputy Donegan had another question down inquiring was the Minister giving a further increase. Can you beat that for politics? When he did get an opportunity of voting for an increase for the farmers he voted against the proposal. That is not too bad but the Labour Party beats all. I am delighted to see here the Chairman of the Labour Party. There is provision for an increase of 2/6d for the old age pensioners and Deputy Tully, the Chairman of the Labour Party, voted against that.
Comment on this
The people of County Dublin might believe that but I do not think very many here will. The Deputy should not be bluffing.
Comment on this
There was also Deputy Norton. I am surprised at such a distinguished parliamentarian doing a thing like that.
Comment on this
They voted against an increase in children's allowances. There is a number of big families down in Meath who would welcome this increase in children's allowances. There is an additional 10/- a month for the first child and Deputy Tully does not want his constituents to get the extra allowance. Is that not the position? I am sorry Deputy Tierney is not here. Deputy Tierney had a motion here in regard to the means test and in regard to increasing pensions generally. I voted against it because there was no money there at the time. Deputy Tierney went into the lobby and voted against Old IRA men getting increases in their pensions and their special allowances. The Minister had to wait until the Budget to know whether there would be money for these increases but we knew that if the Minister could do anything, he would do it. Now the Labour Party come along and vote against these increases about which Deputy Tierney and his Party talked so much. That is the type of hypocrisy we are up against.
Deputy Ryan put down a motion asking for increased allowances for retired Gardaí and he challenged a vote in the House. There was no money for such an increase at the time but now, when the Minister has decided to give an increase to the retired Gardaí, and I very much welcome it, Deputy Ryan and all the members of the Fine Gael Party voted against what they proposed a month ago. I do not know where we stand at all when we are up against that class of hypocrisy. I have great sympathy with certain Deputies. I know they have to do what they are told to do by the Party but what are we to think when we see them putting motions down when there is no money to meet the cost involved in these motions and then voting against their own proposals when the money is there to meet them.
From time to time in every democratic nation, certain economic circumstances will arise which will necessitate the Taoiseach or the Minister for Finance of that nation making an honest statement to the people so as to inform them of the position of the country financially. If the Taoiseach or the Minister for Finance failed to tell the people of this country how they stand financially, they would be completely failing in their duty. I am referring now to the White Paper. In introducing that White Paper, the Taoiseach did his duty in telling the people the financial position. That was all he did. At the moment a conference is in progress between the trade unions and the representatives of the employers seeking agreement on the formula which will be for the benefit of all sections of the community.
Comment on this
That was sabotaged by the Taoiseach on the last occasion. I hope it will not be sabotaged by him again.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is the best friend the workers of Ireland ever had and he did more to raise the workers of Ireland out of the gutter than any other Parliamentarian in his time.
Comment on this
I am talking about one man. The dead, God rest their souls, all did their part for Ireland in their day but I am talking about the present Taoiseach. If there ever was a man who was concerned for the welfare of the workers of Ireland and of our people, that man is Seán Lemass when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce. He did his part for the workers then and he is doing it for them today as Taoiseach. The workers under Fianna Fáil achieved more prosperity than ever they did under an inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
I am as deeply concerned about the workers of Ireland as Deputy Tully is. I am concerned about their wellbeing. There are people in this Parliament who are anxious to cash in on the present bus strike. They are passing resolutions about the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Transport and Power, seeking to capitalise on every critical position that arises between employers and employees. The people who do that are acting against the wellbeing of this country. If there are temporary disputes, these can be solved only by the people concerned coming together, by better understanding and goodwill, and it is a shame to have these resolutions being passed by disinterested persons. In disputes like these, the people concerned will get together and resolve their own difficulties.
I am sorry, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that I have a heavy cold and that I am not able to speak much longer but I wish to pay my tribute to the Minister for Finance. He is a great patriot who has the interest of Ireland at heart first, last and all the time. He is a man who will put the interests of Ireland before the interests of either his Party or himself. For that reason, we are recommending the Budget to the Irish people in the hope that national progress will continue to go ahead.
Comment on this
This year's Budget will be regarded as one of the most confusing ever presented by a Minister for Finance. It was incapable of immediate understanding by the majority of the people but one weekend was sufficient to evoke a storm of protest from the country at large. I could give hundreds of quotations but I will quote only The Kerryman as one: “Majority in the south-west not happy about the Budget.” It describes it as “A Brain-teaser Budget” and goes on to say:
Business people in particular are batting their brains figuring how to operate and account for the 6d in the £ turnover tax. And many of them in the south resent the role of unpaid tax collector and having a turnover tax to cope with as well as PAYE.
I shall not bother the House with many more quotations in relation to the reaction of the people, which is snowballing these days as the full implications of what is actually in the Minister's statement are coming more to light and as people appreciate the full impact of the Budget.
The statement regarding tax proposals this year is perforated by thin ends of wedges. We have so many new methods of taking money out of people's pockets, where the wedge is driven in just sufficiently to put it in position. We are told it is light. It has not been driven home, but it was never in this position before. All the Government have to do on another occasion is to give it another tap and sink it slightly deeper home. Then the money will flow in, still more millions out of the pockets of the producers in every section of our community, from every person, man, woman and child in the community.
For what purpose? To what end? Where will it end? Those are the questions we are asking in discussing this Budget Statement. Can it be alleged by any Minister or any Deputy supporting the Government that a single external factor is influencing the financial situation of the country this year? Is this Budget not influenced entirely by domestic factors? Our entire fiscal policy is framed on the conduct of our affairs over the past 12 months with very little effect by any external factor. Nobody can say there was any rationing of oils due to any international situation. It cannot be alleged that the terms of trade over the past 12 months were inimical to this country. But we can allege that when the terms of trade were somewhat better, the Government did not take much notice and did not allow for the fact that they might not maintain their strength. They claimed credit for any benefits accruing to the country due to the slightly better terms of trade. They ignored the warnings emanating from these benches that we would be in trouble if there was any deterioration in the terms of trade. However, they did not deteriorate to the point that would amount to a serious problem in preparing our national accounts for the coming 12 months.
We have, of course, a record imbalance of payments, but we know that was occasioned by our failure to get the level of exports that would make it possible for the country to maintain the standard of living which demanded the level of imports we had over the past 12 months. Again, when warnings were issued from these benches in regard to the balance of payments position, they were ignored by Ministers. Those were the days of never having had it so good, in which the atmosphere at all the Saturday night dinners was such that there was not a single cloud on the horizon.
But a different picture is painted by the confessions enshrined in the Minister for Finance's Budget Statement. Is it not a fact that the out-turn of revenue in the past 12 months far exceeded the anticipated amount which would accrue to the Minister for Finance to be disbursed among the various Departments of State? Is it not a fact that, by PAYE and other methods, the Government have succeeded over the past few years in bringing into the coffers of the State more than it was estimated would be needed for the management of the various Departments?
I intend to prove in a few minutes that the solution to our economic problems, advanced in very definite terms by members of the Government not so long ago, was that the direction of the policy and activities of Ministers in Government should be towards retrenchment and better management in every Ministry and not towards an increased burden of taxation either on business people by way of corporation profits tax or individually on every single person in the State by way of the turnover sales tax.
If we had this vast increase in the cost of running our various Departments, it is not by any means a sixmarker to ask any Deputy what has contributed most towards the inflation in the Book of Estimates in every single Department. Is it not solely attributable to the policy of the Government when they decided to abolish the food subsidies, when they took away the £9 million the House voted to keep down the cost of living and to ensure that every member of the community could purchase the necessaries of life at a reasonable price? Did they not ward off the type of increase which we have, unfortunately, since suffered? Is it not a fact we had the unfortunate experience that when the present Minister for Health first interfered with the level of food subsidisation, he presented that as a measure designed to cut from the Book of Estimates a substantial amount of money that had to be found by taxation? Once that was done, the people were told, the result would be they would have to pay less in taxation, they would have to pay more for the necessaries of life—bread, butter, tea and every item that had been subsidised—but they would get it back by way of a lesser charge on them in taxation. There was no other purpose in the reduction at that time of the food subsidies.
However, there followed from that a leap in the cost of living index figure. Consequent on that leap, we had the reasonable demands of State personnel for compensation to meet this increase in the cost of living— increases which the Government were forced to award—followed immediately by demands in the private sector of the community. Whether it was a limited liability company, a State company or a family-run concern, even if a person merely had a limited number of workers employed in the distributive trade, every single employer had to find an increase in wages to meet this increase in the cost of living and give their employees some reasonable addition due to the impact of the rise in the cost of living.
That was the unfortunate experience of the country but it should have been enough to have educated the Fianna Fáil Party in regard to the repercussions of their action in partially removing the food subsidies. It was at a later stage, despite election assurances — often quoted in this House; surely there is no need to quote them over again because by now they must be well driven into the memories of every Deputy—that the subsidies would not be touched and would be maintained, that the Minister for Finance did otherwise. It was partly as a result of these assurances that the Government secured office. Having secured office, they proceeded, in the face of these assurances, to eliminate what was left of the food subsidies.
Now we have the wheel turning again. We had the State personnel being compensated, and every penny of that compensation was necessary to reward the civil servants, members of the Garda and Army and everybody drawing a pay packet from the State. It was particularly necessary for those in the lower echelons to protect them from the impact of this savage leap forward in the cost of living. Each time a Minister had to introduce an Estimate, it was inflated by the demand for money to pay these increases, and that has been a major factor contributing to the increased cost of living and of operating the cost of services in this country. There was no reference of any kind to the fact that these increases were inimical to the conduct of so many private firms, to the people who complied with all the lectures and advice offered by Ministers as to how best they should operate their concerns. They also had to get increases to pay their personnel and at the same time pay the increased taxes to cover those who were State employees. In between, we had the consumer being ground down, the person who ultimately had to pay the whole lot whether as a taxpayer or a purchaser of the goods from firms which had to bear these increased charges.
There is no other factor contributing to the explosion—if I might call it that—of the cost of running individual Departments than the withdrawal of the food subsidies, thereby sparking off increases in the cost of living. There was some remedial action taken on behalf of people living on social welfare benefits to protect them from the full impact of the increased cost of living but it was not sufficient and none of the self-employed people, or the shopkeepers, or the farmers, and particularly the small farmers, received any compensation for the impact of the increases on the cost of living. There was a time when it was felt that the cost of living only had an impact on urban dwellers but that day has long gone.
In our journeyings throughout our constituencies, we are repeatedly reminded of the drop in the purchasing power of money and of how difficult it is for people to live on the income from small farms or from small sums of invested money; how difficult it is to exist, let alone enjoy a reasonable standard of living. It is in these circumstances that this year the Government have decided to extract £10½ million from the people in a full year, according to the Minister. Other Ministers imply that this money is absolutely necessary to pay for this, that and the other thing. Is it not a fact that the buoyancy in revenue over the past year was such that there could have been an increase to the dairy farmers of 5d a gallon for milk, or if the Government did not decide to do that they could have done many other things? If their forecasts of the prosperity that lies ahead of us are correct, if they believe them, they could confidently estimate on a continued buoyancy or an accelerated buoyancy without increasing taxation.
I emphatically deny that there was the slightest necessity for imposing additional taxation this year. We are entitled to suggest that the Government are playing a political game and looking forward to amassing a considerable surplus—by way of the turnover tax, the increased corporation profits tax and by new ways of implementing the existing income tax code—which will be available at an opportune moment to be dished out to purchase the suffrage of the people. Mark you, if they have that in mind, they have completely underestimated the intelligence of the people. They have completely miscalculated the reaction to their proposal in this Budget, because since this Budget Statement was made we have met people in different walks of life, but particularly those in the distributive trades, who are more incensed over the proposals in this Budget than by anything done by any Government at any time. I am not exaggerating when I say that. We are sorry to see that Deputy Burke has a cold to-day. He appeared to be in his usual good health last night but it is no wonder that he should have been talking so much about the fears in his mind as to the consequences of this Budget putting the Government out of office. If he was fearful more of us were hopeful about such an occurrence because there appeared to be no other way of bringing the Government to heel, despite the partial climb-down of the Minister for Transport and Power in the outrageous statement he made last night.
Among the innovations in the Budget this year was a raid on the Road Fund. Deputy Noel Lemass announced that the Government had provided £2 million more for the Road Fund. I understood that this Road Fund was amassed from taxation on motor vehicles. At any rate, it is not something that was dispensed by the grace and favour of any Minister for Finance. There is a proposal to raid the Road Fund and we have this extraordinary delay, which was pinpointed at Question Time yesterday, in the allocation of Road Fund moneys to the various councils. They are all waiting to know what they will get and there is not a single county engineer, assistant engineer, or deputy engineer, who is aware of what he may budget for in the coming 12 months and they will not know until the Department of Local Government reveal what the amounts are.
I have no intention of going into further detail regarding the raid on that fund because I propose to leave, in their entirety, any remarks to be made to my colleague, the Chairman of the Cork County Council, Deputy Corry. No better authority can be found in this House to protest on any and every occasion the Road Fund is touched. I challenge him now to come into this House and to express his mind as actively and as forcefully as he has been wont to do regarding raids on the Road Fund. It will be interesting to see what reaction he will get from his own Party in office.
It has been thrown at members of the Opposition that they should pinpoint the economies that should be effected to reduce the cost of Government. It is like somebody being injured in an accident through the negligence of, say, a motor driver, and the person who comes and picks up the injured person being asked: "What can you do to repair the damage done by the motorist?" When the members of the Government were sitting in these benches, they had a very different approach to this matter of the information which is available only to members of Government regarding where and how economies can be effected.
May I quote a statement by the Taoiseach, with which I agree? It is from a leading article in the Irish Independent for Friday, 8th March:
It is not the taxpayers' business, not the newspapers' business, nor even the business of the Opposition to frame the Government's budget. It is the right of us all to protest that the bill is unreasonable, that too much of it is being served on too few, and that there is no sign of the Government being ready to give adequate help to those most in need.
That is the responsibility of Government and we are quite entitled to suggest that the Government have failed to exercise that close examination of the country's Estimates that would give us the guarantee that the money which is exacted from the people by way of taxation is being spent in the proper fashion.
When the present Leader of the Government was in Opposition, he was most vociferous about the level of expenditure at that time. He never suggested that once he assumed office he would increase taxation by £50 million per annum and introduce new systems which would be unlimited in the scope to which they can be utilised in later years with intensified effect.
Let us remember the time the Taoiseach betook himself to Clonmel. Up to yesterday, the Taoiseach was very fond of chambers of commerce. Having read the statement published by the Dublin Chamber of Commerce yesterday, I can see a cooling off in the affections between himself and these bodies. It is not long since he informed us across the floor of the House that chambers of commerce were analogous to Fianna Fáil cumainn. The Taoiseach told us that.
Comment on this
——he did not deny it, although he was in the House. At any rate, he was most affectionate at that time towards chambers of commerce and betook himself to Clonmel.
Comment on this
At Clonmel, according to a report of his speech in the Irish Times of 18th January, 1952, the Taoiseach said:
Increasing tax rates is, however, a course which produces other economic consequences also, which contracts the amount which the public has available to spend on other things and limits the amount of savings.
I agree, and I am sure Deputy Booth agrees with these sentiments. It is a statement of fact. The Taoiseach went on:
Clearly, therefore, tax increases should not be considered if there is a possibility of avoiding them by reducing the cost of Government services or by eliminating or postponing the introduction of services which we can do without until we are able to afford them.
That is somewhat contrary to the Budget provisions of this year. Those provisions could not be much more at variance with the sentiments the Taoiseach expressed at that time. The Taoiseach went further. He had other suggestions to make, like the possibility of introducing changes in administrative methods directed to securing a full return of work from public officials. He went on:
Food subsidies must be accepted as likely to remain a permanent feature in the Estimates unless a very steep fall in the cost of living should take place and that is not very likely, to put it mildly.
The Taoiseach has the habit of being forceful in his announcements. He can make assertions more effectively than most men in public life. It is accepted by many people that they are well thought out statements, that he prepares his material well. It cannot be said that he is impetuous in making rash statements such as that. They are not thought of on the spur of the moment. They are carefully prepared. We can be sure that when he declared that food subsidies must be accepted as likely to remain a permanent feature in the Estimates that he meant it.
That is not all. At column 47 of the Official Report for 8th May, 1956, the Taoiseach, then Deputy Lemass, had this to say:
Have the Government any sense of responsibility? Have they any knowledge of the tasks that are facing them? Did it occur to them that this Budget deficit of theirs should be rectified by reducing the cost of Government?
Remark—the Budget deficit was not to be rectified by the introduction of a turnover tax or overturn tax, whatever you like to call it. It was not to be rectified by that means, the means adopted this year. It was to be rectified by reducing the cost of Government. At column 49 the Taoiseach, then Deputy Lemass, went on:
In 1953, the Fianna Fáil Government, of which I was a member, took a decision——
He was not now speaking as an individual; he was not speaking merely for himself. Here we had a Government calmly sitting down around the table, with all the advice and all the assistance available only to members of a Government and, having given careful consideration to the financial problems of the country, the Government had come to a decision. What was the decision?:
——that taxation in this country had reached the danger limit.
If it had reached the danger limit when it was £50 million less than it is today, what word in the English language can be employed to describe the present situation? Perhaps on the next occasion the Government meet, with all the advice still available to them, they will arrive at some description comparable with the description of the situation at that time, namely, that taxation had reached the danger limit. The Taoiseach went on:
We announced that we had made up our minds on that fact and that, so far as we were concerned, there would be no increase in tax rates above the 1953 level.
"No increase in tax rates above the 1953 level." He went on:
We made it clear that, if any Budget difficulty arose, that difficulty would be met by a reduction of expenditure and not by increasing the burdens on the taxpayer.
Could anything be more clear? There was a confident leader of a Government who asserted that, seated at the Cabinet table with his colleagues, they had come to a decision. This was not something thought up in Mount Street. This was not something for publication in Gleás. It was a firm, recorded, Government decision. How ridiculous it looks, and particularly when we have to listen to the vapourings about honesty of Deputy Burke, who claimed that only the Government were national and honest. I suppose all the others are traitors, rogues and dishonest.
Here we see the most blatant contradictions of what the Minister and the Government are doing. At column 49, the Taoiseach went on:
Will the Government make up their minds now that Government expenditure cannot go higher than they have let it go to date? Can they give the people a promise that there is any prospect of stability now?
For the benefit of the Minister for Justice, I am quoting the remarks of someone who is quite familiar to him, the Taoiseach, regarding the excessive cost of Government in other days.
Comment on this
His solution of our difficulties was a more economic management of individual Departments and a reduction in the amount of national expenditure. In no circumstances would he consider increased taxation. That is on record. Unfortunately the Minister did not have the benefit of the quotations. They are exceedingly interesting.
Comment on this
The Chair might. There may be time for someone else to give them to the Minister to improve his knowledge of the vapourings of people who are quite prominent at the moment.
The Tánaiste could never leave it to to Taoiseach when it came to making affirmative declarations regarding the economic position of the country. He had much to say regarding the economies that could be effected in expenditure. As reported at column 68 of the same volume of the Official Report he said:
That is what the working class people in our rural areas are paying for the fact that the Government have not tackled what is the basic difficulty in all this matter, the phenomenon of rising Government expenditure.
It was a phenomenon at that time. It baffles us to find words to express the intensity with which that idea was conveyed by prominent politicians when they were in Opposition, when we compare it with the vast increase in Government expenditure that has occurred since—and there is not the slightest suggestion of putting a brake on it.
The Tánaiste went on:
Until we can manage to curb and curtail that, there will be no relief for any taxpayer in this country and the burdens upon the workers, upon the poorer sections of this community, are going to be increased.
At least he was a little more prophetic than the Taoiseach regarding further increases, and his solution of our difficulties was a curtailment in State expenditure.
Among the economies about which members of the Government waxed eloquently as recently as 8th May, 1957, was one contained in a statement by the Minister for Finance which I recall as having been well received in the country. As reported at column 940 of the Official Report, he said:
The Civil Service itself has been concentrating for quite a while on organisation and methods studies. Useful results have been achieved but the total cost of administration none the less remains too high.
A Budget statement is not a rash production. It is well prepared, thought out, and approved by the Government before it is presented. It is on record that the Minister said solemnly in his Budget statement in 1957 that the total cost of administration remains too high. In the same column, the Minister is reported as saying:
The existing Civil Service structure seems too elaborate for our needs.
Leading articles in provincial papers and in the daily press welcomed the decision of the Government to effect economies in the Civil Service. A douche of cold water on those pious outpourings is the fact that in the Book of Estimates for 1963-64, there is a figure of 20,635 State personnel, which represents an increase of 2,175 since 1956-57. Not one of those 20,635 persons was employed to administer the turnover tax. It yet remains to be seen what size battalion will be employed to ensure that the small shopkeepers pay up and look pleasant once a month.
This Budget has some other dramatic inclusions. One is the requirement in relation to the disclosure of bank deposits over £1,500. Legislation to require banks to disclose deposits has perhaps some merit. It can get after income tax defaulters, but it invites questions. I think the merits of requiring the disclosure of bank deposits are outweighed in two ways, the first of which is that money on deposit may now be sent out of the country. No doubt before he intervened between the managers and the depositors, and realising the degree of confidence which exists in those circumstances, the Minister gave due consideration to the fact that impairing that confidence might cause the removal out of the country of money on deposit. May I continue when the conversation has concluded on the opposite side?
Comment on this
I do not think it was the Minister's fault. Secondly, there is the question of the creation of uneasiness in the public mind by an intrusion, for the first time other than in court cases, into the very special confidential relationship between banks and their customers. Those two questions are pertinent, and they may well outweigh the merits of catching income tax defaulters. I suggest that the Government should carefully consider the implications of this legislation, lest at any time it might be further extended.
There is a definite danger of a movement of money out of the country. Another danger I see is one which will be familiar to Deputy Cunningham or any rural Deputy. We remember how hard it was to get people in remote areas to abandon the practice of putting money into a stocking and to get them to lodge their small deposits in the banks. Is there an incentive here for them to revert to that old practice? We have been appalled to read of horrible raids made on old people who keep their little savings at home—and these will be even less by the time the Minister has finished with the turnover tax. But, at any rate, there will be the dribbling home of money from our people whom we have sent to work in England. Emigrants' remittances make a substantial contribution to our balance of payments. A good deal of this money reaches the hands of the old mother or old father still in the homestead. Will all this have the effect of making them think twice before they lodge this money in the security of a bank? Will we have a repetition of the unfortunate incidents with which we are becoming all too familiar—robbery, stealing, assault? These incidents are becoming all too common in our courts and they arise because people fail to exercise common sense.
Comment on this
Is it? At any rate, they might decide to put it into the bank. There are people who prefer to have the assistance and advice of a bank manager. It would be very retrograde if the excellent relationship that exists between bank managers and their clients were impaired in any way as a result of this proposal. That should be weighed against any advantages that might accrue from tightening the income tax net in order to bring in some people, who admittedly should be brought in, but one should weigh the advantages against the disadvantages. Can we, in our circumstances, afford any movement of money away from our banks and out of the country because of any feeling of uncertainty these people might have concerning the confidential nature of their private transactions with their banks?
With regard to the 50 per cent increase in corporation profits tax and the extension to cover amounts not formally liable to tax, I can only say that this constitutes an intolerable burden on industry. I urge the early introduction of the Finance Bill so that there may be a review of the retrospective clause in particular, the retrospective clause in the Budget which has caused such consternation throughout the country.
Earlier, I referred to the warm and affectionate relations that appear to exist between the Taoiseach and the chambers of commerce. These have become somewhat impaired and we had the Taoiseach's interjection here that the Limerick Chamber of Commerce was analogous to a Fianna Fáil cumann. It cannot be alleged though that the statement issued yesterday by the Dublin Chamber of Commerce is politically coloured and we can, therefore, claim that it is an objective review of the consequences of this Budget.
Comment on this
Any time in the past five years that one opened a paper on Monday morning one found the Taoiseach, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, or the Minister for Transport and Power, bedecked in a white tie and encircled by other people wearing white ties, with the black headlines stating that the Taoiseach, or the Minister, had made some profound statement of policy at some chamber of commerce function on the previous Saturday night. One saw the admiring expressions because these great people had paid the chamber of commerce the compliment of selecting them, rather than this House, as the avenue through which to reveal some carefully prepared statement on the future of the country. We can assume that the Taoiseach and the Ministers knew, when accepting the invitations to these functions, that they were not Fine Gael Party functions. We can assume that. That lends considerably more weight then to the statement issued yesterday by the Dublin Chamber of Commerce. They referred to deposits in the banks. They said:
It was also considered that the proposal to have banks make a return of deposit interests was an encroachment into the privacy of banking transactions and could shake the confidence of overseas investors in the Irish banks.
Referring to corporation profits tax, they said:
The increase of 50 per cent in the amount of corporation profits tax which will be assessed on limited companies was wholly unexpected. It was generally recognised that this type of tax was undesirable. The revised method of assessment had greatly increased the incidence of this tax. Previously the amount paid could be deducted in arriving at the assessable figure for income tax but this was abolished in 1961.
Furthermore the exemption limit was reduced from £5,000 to £2,500 in the early years of the 1939-45 war, and the Minister now proposed that no exemption limit shall operate in respect of the new 5 per cent rate now introduced. Thus many small companies which were not previously liable for this tax would now be assessable.
Corporation profits tax fell entirely on the equity shareholders. This imposition on ordinary shareholders would discourage the investment of risk capital. The increase would also reduce the amount of corporate savings which was probably the most productive saving in the economy.
There is no disguising the fact that the 5 per cent increase in the rate of corporation profits tax and the inclusion of the first £2,500 in the basis for assessment will result in an addition of anything from 50 per cent to 100 per cent, depending on the company's profit. For example, a company earning a profit of £5,000 per annum will now attract an increased liability of 100 per cent.
Many firms have already received their assessment for 1962 and will now be called on to meet a further liability for corporation profits tax. This retrospective element will force the companies concerned to revise their plans for reinvestment, particularly companies in the distributive trades.
Receipts from income tax for the year ending March 31, 1963, show an increase of over £5,000,000 and corporation profits tax an increase of nearly £1,000,000. It seems probable that revenue buoyancy would have had the effect of increasing the yield from those taxes in the current year without the proposed corporation profits tax increase."
One recalls that on these social occasions and gatherings to which the Taoiseach repaired there was generally a lecture and advice tendered as to the desirability of all those engaged in industry modernising their concerns, adapting them to modern conditions in order to face competition from abroad. It was said these requirements would have to be met by the business community. How often have we read about the necessity for ploughing back profits to ensure expansion? What does this Budget do to assist the ploughing back of such profits? It is ripping the boards, the sole plate and the coulter from the plough. Granted, those engaged in export are exempted. That is something. But how many are employed in these exempted industries as compared with those employed in the distributive trade and industries catering for the requirements of our own people?
Surely the day has come when ordinary Irish people prepared to rear their families here are entitled to service by firms which have the same incentives, the same protection and the same advantages as are given to those who are providing these services and goods for people resident in other countries? What is wrong with that? Have we not gone far enough in asking our people to pay more for Irish butter in order that we may subsidise it for people across the Channel to eat it? We have had too much of that.
Comment on this
I realise the necessity for exports as well as Deputy Cunningham or anybody else. I never said that it would be a good day for this country if every ship was at the bottom of the sea. The Deputy now seems to be a very ardent convert to the idea of increased exports but he must remember that it was Deputy Sweetman who introduced the whole idea of tax-free incentives for exports. The wisdom of that action was such that Fianna Fáil decided it would be to their advantage and to the advantage of the country to retain it and to extend it. Was it not well for the country that Deputy Sweetman thought of that good idea? The Deputy's Party were in power for 20 years before that and they never thought of it. We know that many planks in Fianna Fáil policy have been abandoned but there are still a few left that it would be well for them to abandon also.
We know the value of agricultural exports to this country and we know that in consequence of the wisdom of the 1948 Government in obtaining a good trade agreement with Great Britain we doubled the volume and trebled the value of our exports. The Deputy must have thrown off his coat with delight at that achievement. In terms of exports, whether agricultural or industrial, we are ensuring that we have sufficient exports to maintain the imports which are necessary to maintain the standard of living which we all hope to enjoy.
Regarding the employment situation in the country, the Minister for Social Welfare described the position as one which made it extremely difficult to frame the Budget of this year. He dealt extensively with the operations of his own Department but he did not deal with the wider consequences of the budgetary provisions. Strangely enough, he never once referred to the employment situation. If he had he would have found out that there are 58,500 fewer people in employment in the country than when his Government assumed office. This may be the reason he was wise enough to keep off the subject. If he had anything to brag about he would have given figures to the House but it was because he was compelled to bring in a Supplementary Estimate a few months ago to meet the worsening situation that he made no reference to the fact that fewer people are now employed. It is regrettable that the figures recently provided by his Department show that there was a disimprovement of 4,412 since the corresponding date last year and 5,073 with the corresponding date of two years ago.
These figures show the present unhealthy trend and they fall far short of the promise made by the Taoiseach in Clery's Restaurant to provide 100,000 new jobs, a promise that helped to gain a certain amount of support for this Government and to put it into office. It is preposterous, having regard to that, that we should have to listen last night to the statements made by a "former Minister for Finance," as he is described in a newspaper today. The country has had many inflictions of different kinds put upon it but it has not yet had Deputy Childers as Minister for Finance. He was speaking last night as Minister for Transport and Power, although I prefer to describe him as the Minister without functions. He had the audacity to deny last night that his Party ever made a promise to give employment to 100,000 people over a period of five years.
That promise was accepted throughout the country and it was one of the main planks in the Fianna Fáil platform—that, and the advice to the ladies to get their husbands to work. The employment situation must, indeed, be bad when the Minister for Transport and Power goes to the extent of denying that they ever assured the people that if they got back to office, not only would they bring the exiles back from abroad but they would also provide full employment for the people at home and for those coming along. The 100,000 new jobs which they promised were to absorb the whole lot.
The Minister for Transport and Power had no doubt that, as a result of the Budget, business would be stimulated to re-equip with modern machinery, to consider exports of being of prime importance and to supplement sales at home by increased export facilities. That is too much. It would be bad enough if Deputy Burke had said it but when a person such as the Minister for Transport and Power says it, surely it is time for the Government to realise that they have not a hope on earth of getting away with that kind of duplicity?
He went further and said that this matter of the 100,000 jobs was nauseating propaganda on the part of Fine Gael. We wonder where the nausea is. His idea of promoting increased sales at home is to impose a levy of 6d in the £ on everything sold at home. This, according to him, is the way to extend home consumption. It is generally hard to have to listen to the Minister for Transport and Power but he certainly excelled himself last night.
Before I go on to refer further to budgetary matters, I should like to bring one particular matter to the attention of the Government, a matter that is continuing to cause the utmost concern in the country, that is, the purchase of land by foreigners. Deputy Dillon has repeatedly voiced the concern of those of us who reside in the country and who know the efforts many young men have to make over the years to get enough money together to purchase a holding and settle down. These boys now have no chance whatever of acquiring a holding in competition with the foreigners who are now coming in and buying up the land.
The Minister for Lands was compelled to make a statement that the amount of land purchased did not exceed in value some £500,000 but this was contradicted by the Minister for Finance who said, within a matter of a fortnight, that the amount was about £1 million. We do not know what the figure is now but, whatever it is, it is entirely too much. We cannot afford to deny these young men the opportunity of continuing to live in their own country and to invest the money they have saved, through their hard work and through the economies they exercise, in order to continue in the way of life their fathers and their grandfathers had won for them and for which they had worked.
It is regrettable that these young men should be in such difficulties because of the Government's desire to accumulate as much hot money as possible and to present it to us as being something of benefit to the country. These people are very welcome as long as they come here with the intention of giving employment. There is plenty of scope for their industrial activities if they wish to engage in them but we resent particularly the attitude of many of them after they come here towards people exercising rights they have held traditionally especially along the coastline. It would be better for the Government to quell this now rather than face the storm which could develop if it is allowed to expand much further.
Regarding the social welfare benefits, it is quite true there were expectations of increases in advance of those given in this Budget. We are told by the Minister for Finance they have been given to mitigate the effects of the turnover tax not, as the Minister for Social Welfare expressed it, to compensate for those effects. However, there are other facets of our social welfare code which require attention. It is true that, because of the impact of the reducing value of money, the cost of living, and so forth, we are still operating a means test that is very harsh in many instances. It is a matter of regret that there was not the slightest easing of the means test in its application to the social welfare provisions of this Budget.
There is another matter to which I referred on the Social Welfare Estimate and which I thought might have been dealt with in this Budget, that is, the reduction of the qualifying age of female workers for pension rights which is not in accord with the practice in other countries. When it suits the Government's purpose, they are fond of introducing references to conditions in Scandinavia and other countries to support their arguments but they should take example from the more favourable attention such countries give to these workers. Apart from the mitigation of the taxation effects of this Budget, there was no social welfare provision in the Statement this year which was worthy of much attention.
The House will recall that last year there was a song and dance about the provision of £2 million to ease the rates burden on the agricultural community. Absolutely no relief was given to the shopkeepers, to the persons who are particularly hit in this Budget. No relief was given to any other persons in the community, apart from the farmers who had secured that remission only because of the effective demonstrations they had made. Since then, in discussions and otherwise, it was implied that the Government had been very diligently reviewing the whole rates collection system and that the first £20 was being considered as being exempt from rates. It was expected that in this Budget the Government would have come to the rescue still further of the agricultural community in regard to the payment of rates but, far from that, they have not even maintained the status quo because the effect of increased rates in practically every county in Ireland has been almost to eliminate any reliefs that were given in the Budget of last year. The cottier is now as substantial a ratepayer when income in many instances is compared, as his better-off neighbours. The shopkeeper on the side of the street, the very small farmer, none of those classes got any relief last year and if there is a further imposition in regard to rates this year, their position will be still worse.
If there is a song and dance made by the Minister for Social Welfare in regard to increased disablement benefit —and indeed it was not before its time that that increase was given in view of the increased cost of living and the reduced value of money—it must be remembered that the State is not going to pay for it. They claim they have been the fairy godmother but they will pay only half of it and those of us in local authorities who have already decided on our estimates will be faced with supplementary estimates to meet the £300,000 it is proposed to levy on the local authorities to meet half the cost of this benefit in the coming months.
That is not the only way in which this Budget has upset the calculations of the local authorities, a matter with which I propose to deal when I come to the major provision in the Budget this year, the turnover tax. Before I come to this turnover tax, I want to refer to the other impost the business community have had to bear, the increase in corporation profits tax. The business community in recent years have had to suffer many increases in their production costs. One of the major increases has been the increased cost of insurance stamps for their employees. To give them their due, they did not grouse about it. There was very little said by way of criticism of having to meet that additional charge, but when it is put into the mosaic of other charges they have to bear, the whole pattern represents a heavy burden. There have been the increased postage charges, not bearing very heavily on the individual citizen but certainly very heavily on business; there have been increased charges in regard to telephones; and not alone have there been increased transport charges but there have been diminished services. In the constituency I represent, one whole railway line has been removed. What cause was there for the withdrawal of these services other than the intention to relieve the Exchequer of the burden of having to subsidise CIE in the operation of this line? The community have been denied this service completely. During the present bus strike, they have been denied a bus service. Consequently they are completely stranded. If the railway line had been left in existence, they would have had the alternative of travelling by rail.
The people engaged in business in our towns throughout the country have been very adversely affected by the provisions of this Budget. They are the people who will bear this corporation profits tax and who several times during the year, by deliberate action of the various Ministers in this Government, have been called upon to bear increased costs in the operation of their concerns. Surely if there was any class that should have been selected for relief, it was that class when one considers the activity of the Valuation Office in increasing the valuation on very many of these business people and when one considers the impact of increased rates on them—never getting any relief. Was this the time, then, for the Government to embark on the injection of the thin end of the wedge in regard to the turnover tax?
Any of us who were given the books of unfortunate people within the past three weeks who failed to pay their rates last year cannot but be aware of their plight. These are the people whom the rate collectors reported as not having been in a position to pay their rates last year. In the majority of cases, they were people engaged in small businesses in the small towns of rural Ireland. Those of us who are members of local authorities have plenty of time to go down through the lists of defaulters. The returns show 96 and 97 per cent rates payment. That is a remarkable response by the ratepaying public to the levies imposed on them.
Consider the small proportion of those who could not meet the demand. There was agreement between the local rate collector—who in most instances is a tough individual, who does not throw anything away and who carries out his job most effectively—and the staff officers responsible for the collection of rates that these were cases in which it would be impossible to collect, without the utmost penalties being imposed and without placing these businesses in an impossible situation. It was agreed that that would happen if the Rates Office were to persist in the exaction of the rates that had been levied on these people.
It is also true, of course, that most of the people engaged in these businesses have absolutely no recourse to Health Act reliefs. They have to pay rates and taxation but, if they have the misfortune to contract disease or to have an accident, they have no recourse other than to try to meet the hospital bills. Those of us who are in a local authority are continually approached by such people seeking some assistance, seeking some easement of the bills presented to them by hospitals and such institutions.
Taking the agricultural situation, there is nothing in this Budget apart from the 1d increase that the Government decided upon. They stated they would not consider it but eventually they decided it would be better for them to give some increase in the price of milk. Apart from that, there was no ray of hope in the Budget Statement regarding the farming community. We had the Common Market dangled before us for so long and over a period in which the main Opposition Party felt it incumbent on them, in the national interest, to refrain from over-questioning the Government. They felt they should refrain from any statements that would in the slightest way embarrass the Government in a line of policy with which we were substantially in agreement. Yet, we could have had much to say.
We could have referred to very many things that were left undone. We could have referred to the delay in making the proper approaches, in preparing our people for advent to EEC—many of these things. We refrained from doing so. There was never any word of appreciation that I can recall of the part played by Deputy Dillon as Leader of the Opposition in giving the lead in that to the House. A Deputy nods his head: I am glad to know there was. At any rate, during all that period, it was represented to the farming community that admission to Europe would be achieved and that there would flow to our agricultural community benefits unknown before to the farmers of this country.
It is true that our application has not been withdrawn but unfortunately it is in suspension. Some years may pass before Britain is admitted and, consequently, before this country can afford to revive its application for membership. If we wished to be political, we could recall many statements made some years ago regarding the death of the British market but, even at this late hour, it is a matter of consolation to us to know that the policy we have ever upheld regarding the advantages to be gained by proper utilisation of that market is now recognised by the Government.
We can assert with truth that this Government have failed to review our marketing arrangements with Britain. There was an announcement, with considerable sounding of trumpets, that Ministers were on their way to London to meet their counterparts there and that it was expected they would bring back to this country favourable and considerable marketing arrangements with Britain. Unfortunately for the country and for the Government, they came back on that occasion with their hands hanging by their sides. Since then no positive effort appears to have been made to review our marketing arrangements with Britain, to bring them up to date, to encourage our people to harder work and to engage more actively in the production of commodities that we could sell under the terms of such agreements.
Let me dwell on the effect of the Budget on the farming community. In The Kerryman of 27th April, 1963 there is a report of an interview which took place between a reporter of that newspaper and Mr. Jerome Buttimer of Glenville, County Cork, National Vice-President of the NFA and President of the NFA in County Cork.
Said Mr. Buttimer: This Budget will be a disappointment for farmers who expected devaluation on the first £20 of their valuations.
The benefits of the recent increase of one penny per gallon in the price of milk given to the dairymen will now be offset by the new turnover tax because raw materials needed by the farmer will cost more. Domestic requirements for the farmer's household will also go up in price.
There were other dangers attached to the provisions of the Budget.
He refers to the latest burden and says :
There is a danger that local government expenditure will increase as a result of this Budget—that it will increase beyond the estimate recently provided for those services in county council estimates. County councils will have to pay more for their raw materials of various kinds —cement, food, clothing, equipment, machinery and many other items. The effect of this will be felt in the local rates next year as a result of supplementary estimates that the councils may bring in
That will all add up, I am afraid, to a heavier load on the already overburdened farmer as a ratepayer.
There is no mood of optimism there regarding the financial policy of the Government facing the next 12 months and any other comments that have been made have borne out the views expressed by Mr. Buttimer.
Earlier, I remarked that the Government were in the happy position, from the buoyancy of revenue last year, to bring relief to the classes that have got some increased awards in their social welfare benefits. They could have provided the money needed to give the increase to the dairy milk suppliers out of existing taxation. The buoyancy in revenue seemed to indicate that that trend was likely to continue. Forecasts of expansion in the economy in coming years would also indicate that that buoyancy would be accelerated. Nevertheless that did not satisfy the Government.
This year, we have the most remarkable innovation, financially, the country has experienced for very many years in the turnover tax. We recall that the first time this was brought to the attention of the country was when the Income Tax Commission reported that they were in favour of some kind of purchase tax as an alternative to income tax, but very definitely as an alternative to income tax. Then we had the Taoiseach repairing to Limerick and announcing to the country at large it was the intention of the Government to consider the introduction of a purchase and sales tax. The immediate effect of that, in circumstances in which our level of imports had increased and in which our exports were not being maintained, circumstances in which we had balance of payment difficulties, was an incentive to people to get out immediately to buy the articles pinpointed by junior members of the Government as being the specific items to be taxed heavily in the form of a purchase tax. We had them set out by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands, who repaired to the West of Ireland and identified them as fur coats, luxury motor cars, refrigerators and so on. They expected the tax to be confined to those items.
Since the Taoiseach spoke in Limerick, retailers throughout the country have been bombarded with applications from people to purchase these items. No doubt between now and All Souls' Day, when this turnover tax is to be imposed, many people will "jump the Minister's gun" and purchase many of these items. They may not exactly need them yet but they will come by the price and make whatever terms they can with the person supplying them in an effort to avoid paying the increased turnover tax. Consequently, I believe the full impact of the tax will not be achieved until many of these items are worn out. But, even as it is, the Minister has decided to obtain £3½ million from the tax in the four months of the financial year that will remain.
The Dublin Chamber of Commerce had some comments to make regarding the turnover tax in their statement which was published in today's newspapers. I am not aware, however, to what extent it is published in "The Truth in the News". The newspaper report goes on:
The statement from the Dublin Chamber of Commerce points out that the commercial community was in favour of the partial replacement of direct taxation by indirect taxation which would spread the burden more evenly. But the turnover tax now proposed was in addition to, and not a substitute for, income tax. In fact, with the additional corporation profits tax the volume of income tax has been increased by the Budget.
In the current financial year the yield from the turnover tax was expected to be £3,500,000 from four months receipts, so that in a full year the tax would probably produce about £10,000,000.
That is a very conservative figure for them to mention. The Minister puts it in advance of that by £500,000. There are many other people examining the situation who feel it could be even ahead of that. If the country is to experience this expanding economy repeated ad infinitum one can expect, unless there is a diminution in consumption arising from heavier taxation, that more will accrue from it. We must remember the admission of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance that we had reached the point of diminishing returns in relation to taxation on the simple luxuries. A long time ago, when the Government were increasing taxation on tobacco and spirits, that fact was pointed out to them from these benches. Now we have the admission that the only factor on this occasion which induced the Government to refrain from taxing tobacco, cigarettes, beer, wines and spirits was the fact that as a revenue winner, it would be ineffective. It was not because it would impose a further burden on the consumer, but because “the lolly” could not be derived from it. Therefore, we had to embark on the turnover tax.
The Dublin Chamber of Commerce go on to say :
This was a most unsatisfactory situation as it might encourage the Government to increase expenditure unnecessarily, or, in any event, be less zealous in its efforts to restrict spending to a minimum. It was to be hoped this temptation would be resisted and that any excess in Exchequer Revenue would be passed back to the citizen in the form of lower income tax.
Again, we believe there is a deeper and more invidious reason behind the over—taxation that is proposed than to give relief to any particular section of the community.
The report goes on :
Strong exception must be taken to the basis on which the turnover tax is to be operated. In effect the Government has introduced a levy on sales and has left the retail trade to take the odium of passing on this tax to the public.
The implication that the retail trade would be in a position to absorb portion of this tax was entirely erroneous.
Would the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach pay heed to that? He informed us here, speaking on this resolution last week, that he knew of concerns in his constituency that could put up notices saying "Goods available at old prices."
The Dublin Chamber of Commerce report continues:
In practically every retail trade a levy of 2½ per cent on gross turnover would greatly exceed the net profit earned. Thus the retail trade would have no option but to recover the full amount of this tax from the public and the Government must take entire responsibility for the wide repercussions this increase in the cost of living will have on the various sections of the community.
The administration of this turnover tax will severely dislocate all sectors of the distributive trades. The compilation and verification of monthly turnover figures, the completion of numerous forms and returns which will be necessary under the scheme, and the discussion and negotiations with officials on these figures will all involve extra costs in clerical and executive man-hours.
Furthermore, as this tax is to be levied on gross turnover, it introduces the undesirable principle of paying "tax on tax". In some countries the sales tax is separately stated as an addition to the price.
With the extra costs involved in administering the collection of the levy for the State and the operation of the "tax on tax" principle it must be recognised that ultimate incidence of this tax on the public will exceed the bare 2½ per cent indicated by the Minister, the statement continues.
Commodities like tobacco, beer, spirits and oils were liable to excise duties several times greater than the prime cost of the article, and practically all imported consumer goods were subject to a customs duty. All those items would be liable to the new tax at the full retail price so that, in effect, the Government was increasing those excise and customs duties by the amount of the levy.
The mind boggles at the task of registering over 40,000 retailers and about 5,000 manufacturers and wholesalers, not to speak of thousands of hotels, guest houses, restaurants, barbers, taxi-drivers, jobbing plumbers and general handymen, and the even greater task of ensuring that each and every person registered makes a monthly return of his sales with a remittance of the amount of the levy involved.
Having regard to the fact that the scheme is intended to cover all retail transactions of both goods and services throughout the country the Minister's estimate that the cost of administration to the State will be less than one per cent of yield seems to be unduly optimistic.
I should like to know what the view of the Minister for Justice is regarding the cost of administering this turnover tax, leaving out for a moment the merits of this method of taxing our people. Is it possible that this will be administered for a sum of £80,000 per annum?
Comment on this
An electronic computer? Well, we are getting somewhere now. We are getting some information. Will this electronic computer be available to every huckster shop——
Comment on this
I am sorry. Through you, Sir, will this computer be available to every huckster shop in every town in the country?
Comment on this
Could the Minister quote the Minister for Finance because I have not got his speech with me? Could he give me the reference where he said that huckster shops will be out?
Comment on this
The Deputy is entitled to make his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
I know that the Chair is not able to vouchsafe the information I am looking for, but does the Minister conceive that a person is living on this level of income?
Comment on this
It is they that will be bled and they know the leeches who are bleeding them. The Minister has diverted me from the point I was making.
Comment on this
I did not seek diversion from the cost of administering the scheme because the electronic computer is going to do it. I am entitled to ask where will this electronic computer operate?
Comment on this
Will this be so mobile that it will visit Timoleague, Rockchapel, and any place we may name in the country and examine the shopkeeper's accounts and announce itself as being satisfied that the turnover was less than £100, accept 17/6 and furnish a receipt, and will it also take into account the amount of bad debts in that month ?
Comment on this
This electronic computer will first of all have ascertained from the wholesaler the amount of goods forwarded to the particular shopkeeper for sale, then check his——
Comment on this
Might I just inform the Deputy that there are now computers which can play the game of X's and O's with professors and beat them?
Comment on this
At any rate this electronic computer is interesting and the House awaits with bated breath more information from the Minister for Justice regarding its operation. It will be very interesting when one realises that it costs us 9d in the £ to collect income tax and I am entitled to ask why was not this marvellous computer used to collect the 9d in the £?
Comment on this
The White Paper on Direct Taxation mentioned bringing about the position of one taxpayer, one charge.
Comment on this
This saving will be effected in costs and it will mean an increase in revenue for the Government.
Comment on this
Less taxation ? Who said it? Is there any indication in this Budget that there is at the back of the mind of any member of the Government any intention to reduce taxation? We are introducing new methods of closing up all the loopholes in taxation.
Comment on this
We are embarking on a policy of closing all gaps to ensure that there is not a penny that will go astray.
Comment on this
It was legal evasion. It was provided for by legislation that it would be exempted. Now the Minister informs us that the electronic computer will relieve the Revenue Commissioners of the 9d in the £, to a great extent, in collecting income tax. If it does that much in collecting income tax, will £80,000 collect the £3½ million in the four months? Or do I take it that £80,000 is to cover 12 months and not four months? It will be responsible for the collection of the £3½ million from the 40,000 retailers, 5,000 manufacturers and wholesalers, not to speak of thousands of hotels, guesthouses, restaurants, barbers, taxi-drivers, jobbing plumbers and general handymen. If this £80,000 can be responsible for doing that, we can look forward to saving several million pounds next year because we will be able to wipe out three-quarters of the Civil Service by purchasing some of these machines.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not be aware that we will have to employ some extra electricians to look after the machines.
Comment on this
I had the feeling that the Minister was joking when he mentioned the electronic computer.
Comment on this
It might be like the helicopters. It might be too dear and we will have to leave it to next year.
Comment on this
——placed at the disposal of the Revenue Commissioners. Let me quote it ?
An electronic computer to enable the system of one taxpayer, one charge, to be brought into operation is expected to be supplied within the next few months.
Comment on this
This was published in April, 1963. Surely the Deputy read it? Imagine a Deputy getting up to speak on the Budget without having read the White Paper. I am aghast.
Comment on this
The Minister will be more aghast before I sit down. Is there a comparison between the operations of this machine and the collection of these levies from the shopkeepers?
Comment on this
I wonder if this "wonder" could ever be employed to take over the Ministry of Finance?
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister will agree that we would not be unfair in describing the turnover tax as an inhuman tax, because this machine is not human. It is an inhuman tax. This machine will now assist the Minister in taking £3½ million in four months and a minimum of £12½ million in one year. That is with the wedge driven at its present depth, the 6d depth. That wedge can always be given another tap when the occasion arises.
The Minister would command the biggest house any speaker has got here for many a long day if he would explain to us in the course of his address how this computer can possibly do the work that has to be done in relation to the working out of this tax. That would be one of the most interesting dissertations the House has ever had the experience of hearing because the tax covers every item of apparel from the swaddling clothes for the child to the habit for the corpse. It is a pretty wide range.
Comment on this
It is a pretty extensive range. The tax covers also every single item people have to eat or drink and everything they do. There is one thing about this tax : it does not leave anything out. There may be one or two matters we cannot very well refer to. At any rate, the Minister appears to be satisfied that one per cent of the estimated income will be responsible for the collection of this tax. From that, I pose another question: What is wrong with insurance companies in this country? In the town in which I reside, there are at least ten full-time insurance collectors calling to the doors for a precise amount which is up in the dresser waiting for them to call—the 2/- a week or whatever it is. It takes ten full-time men, at least, to collect this money. Consider the cost to the companies that continue this antiquated system of engaging human beings when there is this £80,000 machine that could collect the premiums for the whole country. If it takes that number of insurance collectors to collect precise amounts from a much fewer number of people than it is intended to trap under the turnover tax, there must be many inefficient concerns operating in the country.
Comment on this
Yes, I have, and when I see it after 1st November, it will carry a turnover tax on it.
Comment on this
As the debate progresses, we are getting some illumination. Now it appears that there will be no inflation in the number of personnel engaged for the purposes of collecting this tax apart from the electricians who will be keeping the wheels turning in this miraculous machine.
Comment on this
That will not entail much cost. The plugging in being effectively done is the plugging in of 6d in the £ on everything one eats, everything one wears and everything one does. That is the kind of plugging in that the people are interested in. There will be very little consolation for them in knowing that one or two electrically-minded gentlemen in Dublin will be sufficient to collect the tax from the 40,000 traders, the 5,000 manufacturers, all the hotels, all the plumbers, all the barbers, all the taxi-drivers and everybody providing a service.
We certainly are travelling fast these days. I want to know what kind of job this computer will do in relation to items sold in particular shops. Take a confectioner, for instance. The Minister says that so long as he gets two and a half per cent on the full turnover, he does not mind if there are small items that are exempted, that the retailer is at liberty to put the tax on the dearer articles, that so long as he gets two and a half per cent he is happy. Despite Deputy Brennan's hopes, there are very few stores in this country that can bear any part of this two and a half per cent.
When Deputy Maurice Dockrell made the case that the business community were unable to meet this two and a half per cent tax Deputy Colley intervened to say they were not expected to bear any of it. That is fair enough. They have not got the miracle machine the Minister for Justice refers to. Individual employers will have to engage clerical assistance to keep their books in order. Widows or other people carrying on small businesses will have to keep books, many of them for the first time. This method of exacting tax will constitute for them an intolerable burden. There is no question about that.
These are people who are already adversely affected by the cut-price shops and mammoth stores that are now attracting people away from family concerns. These people were already in serious trouble. The activities of the rate collector were bearing heavily upon them. In the health area in which I reside, even the water rate charges this year have gone up by 50 per cent. These people generally do not come within the categories entitled to free medical attention. Their medical charges have been increased.
Having to overcome all these difficulties to the best of their ability, they will now be obliged, in addition, to do all this clerical work. Many of these people keep their shops open until the small hours of the morning if it is possible to earn a shilling, because there is a dance in the vicinity. They provide a service. Their hours are not regulated by any trade union. They have to make a few shillings in order to eke out a living. It will be particularly difficult for these people to maintain books in the conditions under which they operate.
Comment on this
Ninety-five per cent of all retail sales at the moment are already being returned to the Revenue Commissioners for income tax purposes.
Comment on this
Yes. We are dealing with facts. Let us get the facts straight. All retailers responsible for 95 per cent of the retail business are already making returns to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
Let me make the point arising out of the intervention of the Minister. Ninety-five per cent of £450 million worth of retail goods are returned to the Income Tax Commissioners.
Comment on this
But there is five per cent of £450 million of retail goods which is not returned and that is distributed over thousands of small shopkeepers.
Comment on this
But they will have to prove they are out. To prove they are out, they will have to keep books.
Comment on this
Will this be spot inspection or at regular intervals, or what arrangement will be made? Will the computer travel down to do it, or who carries out the inspection?
Comment on this
I know the Minister is trying to help me and I appreciate his help but I want to know about the five per cent of the £450 odd millions worth of goods which are not returned to the Income Tax Commissioners and which are obviously goods sold in thousands of small trading shops that never kept a book until now.
Comment on this
They will now have to make returns. The Minister, of course, is satisfied that when they make returns and when he knows this proportion are sending their records to the Income Tax Commissioners, it will also guarantee that any of them that have not been sending in records before will be caught now by the income tax provisions, and judged on the turnover.
I want to go back to the specific commodities which we are told may be released from the exact provisions of the 2½ per cent. The Minister was the most positive of the Government speakers in this regard. He said :
The proceeds of the tax were to be used to reduce the rate of income tax. The first White Paper on Direct Taxation, in the course of a comment on this recommendation, said that a sales tax would not be inappropriate to the circumstances of this country, and, if the necessity were to arise for a major increase in taxation, it might become unavoidable.
He was not in love with the idea of a turnover tax all the time. Speaking about exemptions he said:
It is because the tax will apply to all retail sales, with the few exceptions indicated, that it is possible to have a rate as low as 6d in the £.
Comment on this
It is a quotation from the Minister's Budget Statement on 23rd August, 1963, as reported at column 86 of volume 202.
Comment on this
I can manage this job without a computer. I have quoted from column 82 of the Official Report for the 23rd April, 1963. The second reference was from column 86 of the same volume. Deputies who spoke on the Government side and tried to imply that there will be extensive exemptions from this tax have another think coming.
Having made his dramatic announcement, the Minister relaxed for the evening, but the following day he intervened when Deputy O'Donnell was speaking from these benches in regard to the capacity of some shopkeepers to bear any increase in the cost of running their concerns. As the Minister for Justice said, there may be people who will not be required to pay more than 17/6d a month, if their turnover is only £100 a month, but we have to consider what the profit would be on such a turnover. There are varying views on that. While it was being discussed, there were two Ministers in the House. The Minister for Finance was here and the Minister for Social Welfare was sitting cheek by jowl with him when Deputy O'Donnell referred to the impact on many of these small shopkeepers. As reported at column 359 of the Official Report of 24th April, 1963, Deputy O'Donnell inquired:
Will the Minister say that a person with a small business is making more than five per cent?
Dr. Ryan: Yes. They are making 20 per cent at least, and some of them are making more.
I do not know how many Deputies are engaged in the grocery trade, but is there any Deputy who is under the delusion that there is 20 per cent profit in any one of the little grocery shops? Would they have ten per cent profit?
Comment on this
They would not, but the Minister for Finance said it was 20 per cent, and sitting beside him was the Minister for Social Welfare who determines the non-contributory old age pension claims of small shopkeepers, and he concurred that it was at least 20 per cent. Is it any wonder that when appeals come to the local committees to be determined——
Comment on this
The Deputy should not discuss old age pensions and pensions committees on this Resolution.
Comment on this
Quite, but the Chair will appreciate that they impact themselves on the Budget to the extent that the Minister seems to be under the impression that there is 20 per cent and more profit on the sale of these goods. Is it any wonder that Deputies who support the Government seem to be under the impression that the business community can carry this 2½ per cent tax? What is 2½ per cent out of 20 per cent?
Comment on this
I am not interested in the net profit on cigarettes. I know Miss Martin's little shop in Limerick and I know her impressions at the moment about what she will have to pay.
Comment on this
There will be many of these creatures throughout the country trying to exist on a profit of less than ten per cent. If there is a profit on cigarettes, with the operation of the cut-price shops, even if one doubled one's smoking capacity, what proportion of the turnover would cigarettes account for? Is butter not more important in any shop?
Comment on this
I will bet the Deputy a "fiver" to a penny that there is not a penny increase on the lb of butter.
Comment on this
There was nothing at Punchestown today as inviting as that offer. You do not have to leave the House to get on a good thing. I am delighted at the opportunity because it is clear that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is at variance with the Minister in regard to the provisions of the Budget. The Minister made it quite clear that a 2½ per cent tax would be imposed per £ of turnover. That is 6d. in the £. The cost of a lb. of butter goes up therefore by a penny. If the Parliamentary Secretary was aware what the profit is in the retail trade on the handling of butter, he would realise that it cannot bear an increase of a penny.
Comment on this
No, £5 sterling. The price of tea will go up by 1½d. I want to see if there are any more opportunities of making money on the side.
Comment on this
I do not know if the Deputy is in order in going through the whole list of commodities.
Comment on this
It is good stuff. That is why Deputy Burke was shivering last night at the thought of going out of office. We know that it will have a tremendous effect on the by-election. Surely, Sir, the exaction of a turnover tax of 2½ per cent in this Budget can be referred to and its effect on every single commodity.
Comment on this
The Deputy may refer to it in a general way.
Comment on this
I contend that under this system of taxation, there will be an incentive to profiteering and there is no provision for supervision of profiteers by this miracle machine inasmuch as we have been told that the tax need not be imposed on the bottle of milk, the loaf of bread, the reel of thread, or the liquorice allsorts; the Minister for Social Welfare says he feels the intelligent retailer will make every effort to avoid increasing the price of essential commodities and will instead increase the price of items purchased mainly by the better off sections in order to meet this tax. That will interfere, of course, with the normal good relationship that exists between the retailer and his customers because the shopkeeper will be obliged, according to the Minister for Social Welfare, to put the levy on the alleged better off people in order to meet the tax on the ice-cream cone the child going out the door has just bought.
I asked earlier what the position would be in the case of confectioners. Confectionery is not sold in bulk. How will the confectioner recover this 2½ per cent on the two or three buns the child purchases? Confectioners do not engage in any other business. If their turnover is taxed, how will they recover? Will they have to pile it on to the wedding cake, increasing the price by 50 per cent in order to recoup themselves on the smaller items? According to the argument advanced by the Minister for Social Welfare, that is what they will do.
How will stationers be affected ? Will the proof be the delivery from the printers or magazine wholesalers ? These people are already paying 2d or 3d on imported magazines. Many of these are non-returnable. If you go behind the counter in a stationer's you will see bundles tied up for despatch to some hospital or institution, bundles of non-returnable unsold magazines and periodicals. Will this computer inspect behind their counters, write off the non-returnable and charge only on what was actually bought over the counter? These matters are agitating the minds of thousands of traders all over the country.