We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 14—General (Resumed).

Contributions 190–354 of 354. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Only a few questions were put to the Minister last week on the Financial Resolution and he was not at all too anxious to answer them. This proposal by the Minister and the Government has created the utmost confusion, distress and dismay. The Minister for Finance is under the impression that these people have a profit of 20 per cent. That is the appalling part of it; he framed this Budget on the basis that there is 20 per cent profit and he must have had it in mind that these people could well afford to carry the 2½ per cent without passing it on to the consumer. That bubble has been burst and this tax is now clearly an increase in the cost of living. It is tantamount to one week's wages in the year from the ordinary working man. It is tantamount to the profit on a beast where the ordinary small farmer is concerned.

We are indebted to Deputy Donegan for pressing the Minister hard and evoking a slight concession; if you can prove the fertilisers you purchase are to go into capital, you will be exempted. Who will examine the load of fertiliser leaving the shop in order to determine the proportion that will go into capital by way of improving grassland and the proportion that will go into conversion into crops which will be sold and will, therefore, be subject to a tax of 2½ per cent? We want the answers to these questions. They should have been answered before the House voted on the Financial Resolution implementing this proposal last week.

The Taoiseach, apparently in an effort to steal some of the thunder of the Labour Party, announced piously last week that the Government were now leaning to the left, like the Tower of Pisa. I saw a report that the tower has taken on some more crooked leanings, but, as far as this country is concerned, it is leaning to the left; all we wish is that the Government will lean far enough to the left, to the right, backwards and forwards as to overturn so that the country can be provided with a Government that will bring to all sections some measure of justice, a measure of justice that is not included in the Budget provisions this year.

Comment on this
Charles J. Haughey Minister for Justice (Mr. Haughey) Fianna Fáil

It is not unnatural, I suppose, that most of the discussion on the Budget has been on the turnover tax. I should like to assure the House that before deciding on this tax, the Government gave the most careful consideration to every aspect of the matter and examined it in the greatest possible detail. The arguments in favour of this particular tax were overwhelming. Apart altogether from the immediate necessity to bridge the budgetary gap this year, it was obvious for some time that the whole basis of our tax structure was fundamentally unsound. We had a situation here where the financial viability of the State was to a very great extent dependent on the consumption of drink and tobacco. That was undoubtedly a very undesirable and unhealthy position. I have, indeed, a distinct recollection of hearing Deputy Sweetman deplore that position and urge very strongly that something should be done about it. We had a position in which the Minister for Finance each year had no alternative but fervently to hope that people would drink and smoke more.

Deputy Dr. Browne has often adverted to this aspect of our finances and on a number of occasions he has been very critical both of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Health because of it. Now that the Government have decided to do something about this undesirable position about which he has often complained one could have reasonably expected that Deputy Dr. Browne would have supported us in our efforts in that regard. However, I suppose that was a bit too much to expect.

Apart from the social implications of this excessive Exchequer reliance on drink and tobacco, it is, from the fiscal point of view, a highly dangerous situation to be in. All those who have taken an interest in these matters in recent years have been of the opinion that something should be done about it and that an effort would have to be made to broaden the tax base. Not alone did financial prudence dictate such a change but social justice required that it should be of the greatest possible nature. With these considerations in mind, the Government had an examination made of the tax structures in practically every European country and, in particular, they had the sales taxes in force in Britain, West Germany, Austria, Sweden and France examined in detail. This examination pointed clearly and inevitably to the introduction of a turnover tax on the broadest possible base.

The advantages of a turnover tax on the broadest possible base are obvious. First of all, if the tax is sufficiently broadly based, a fairly low rate of tax will suffice, causing the least possible amount of difficulty to the less well-off sections of the community. It is undoubtedly the fairest possible type of tax. It is easy to administer and cheap and effective in its operation and, with the aid of the new electronic equipment which has been referred to in the White Paper on direct taxation, it will cost very little to collect.

There is nothing secret about this new equipment. The Revenue Commissioners have, for some considerable time, been preparing for its introduction and, in fact, as pointed out in the White Paper, its delivery is expected within the next few months. This equipment was arranged for in the first instance as a means of procuring economies and increased efficiency in the administration of the income tax code and the introduction of a "one taxpayer, one charge" system. But these modern electronic computers are most comprehensive in their range and I understand from the Minister for Finance that his estimates of the cheapness of the collection of this turnover tax are based on the use of this computer.

Another advantage of this turnover tax is that it will be able to make a solid contribution to our finances this year. As Deputies know, it is proposed to introduce it on 1st November next and, in addition, it will be fully and effectively in operation in the following financial year. A further advantage is that it is an important preliminary step from the point of view of bringing our fiscal and tax structure into line with that of the other European countries in the light of our possible forthcoming association with them.

It can, in addition, be a very useful mechanism in relation to the comprehensive policy for incomes on which the Government are working and which it is hoped to get accepted by all sections of our people. As the Taoiseach has already announced, the Government are working towards a comprehensive plan for the fair and equitable distribution of the additions to the pool of national wealth as they are brought about. Any policy for economic development must be comprehensive and it must win the greatest possible measure of agreement from all sections of the people. In order to set predetermined targets for economic growth, it is necessary to secure the greatest possible degree of co-ordination in the different sectors of economic activity.

If we can get this new comprehensive policy accepted by all concerned and working soundly, it will mark us out as a community destined to succeed in its economic objectives, a community which is determined to manage its affairs in a rational and intelligent way for the benefit of all sections equally. A steady flow of revenue into the Exchequer without regard to changes in habit or consumption patterns, such as this turnover tax will provide is a vitally important element in the sort of comprehensive plan proposed.

Everyone will realise the great difficulties in the way of such a comprehensive programme being worked out and accepted by all concerned but the possibility of having such a comprehensive programme in operation is such an exciting prospect and so obviously beneficial that it will, I am sure, evoke a high degree of co-operation and enthusiasm on all sides. I would be very sanguine that if we can propound such a policy in concrete terms, with predetermined rates of growth in the national economy, the benefits of which will be regularly passed on to all sections of the community, we will succeed in getting the co-operation on a national scale which will be necessary to get it into operation.

When the Government examined the budgetary situation this year, it was quite clear that, despite the most detailed, exhaustive and thorough pruning of all Government expenditure, the overall Budget deficit this year was one which could not be bridged by traditional methods.

Apart altogether from the undesirability, to which I have referred, of continuing to rely on a narrow tax base, it was obvious that the existing sources of taxation could not possibly produce the total amount of revenue required in the coming year. If that is accepted, as I think it must be, then there is no alternative to the turnover tax proposed. If the Opposition accept, as I think they must, that some new source of revenue had to be devised and if they are against a turnover tax as we propose, then they must tell us what alternative they would use.

It was clear that traditional resources could not meet the bill. That bill had been pruned to the greatest possible degree so that the inevitability of some new source of taxation had to be faced. After a thorough examination of all other possible methods of taxation, the Government decided on this form of turnover tax. If the Opposition claim we are wrong in proposing this form of taxation, then let them tell us what they would propose. It is only fair to ask them, if they object to our methods of bridging the gap, what method they would have used. I suggest they will not be able to do so. Because, in fact, when all the factors and all the circumstances are examined, it will be found that the solution we have propounded is the only one possible.

During the last week or so, in talking to my constituents, whether wage or salary earners or business people, I found there is a wide acceptance, in principle, of this new turnover tax. So far as I have been able to assess public reaction, the discussion has centred more on the methods by which the tax will be operated than on the merits of the tax itself. On its merits, the tax is fairly widely and generally accepted as reasonable and fair. Most of the people to whom I spoke are concerned more with the technical aspect and with the question of how exactly it will operate in different circumstances and how it will affect different businesses. I admit there is a certain amount of anxiety among traders and business people as to the manner in which it will operate in their particular circumstances and of the difficulties of administration it will cause them. I want to assure Deputies that the great majority of the fears which have been expressed are absolutely groundless.

This type of tax has been in operation for many years in a great number of European countries. It works simply, effectively and successfully and has been doing so in those countries for years. There are no insoluble difficulties associated with it. It will not come into operation until 1st November next and between now and then, the Minister for Finance has promised that all the interests concerned will be fully consulted. As the Parliamentary Secretary said a moment ago, all the questions will be answered and I have no doubt that all the difficulties which people see at the moment will be ironed out.

It is the intention of the Government to work in the closest co-operation with the business community in getting this tax implemented. An indication of our thinking in this regard has already been given in the announcement which the Minister for Finance has made to the effect that the huckster shop will, to a large extent, be exempted from the scope of the tax in so far as it will pay only a fixed monthly contribution. That sort of arrangement is an indication that the Government are approaching this tax in a most realistic and reasonable way. We are determined that it will be put into operation with the minimum possible amount of inconvenience for the business people and the traders concerned.

To ensure that this tax will operate smoothly and with the minimum amount of trouble is as much in the interests of the Government as it is in the interests of the business community. I am quite certain that when these discussions have been held and when the difficulties and the problems involved are considered, we shall be able to arrive at a satisfactory system which will work to the satisfaction of all. Indeed I can say that one of the factors which weighed with the Government in favour of this type of turnover tax as against any of the other taxes proposed was the fact that it was comparatively simple to operate from the point of view of the individual trader and businessman and will result in the least possible amount of administrative difficulty from his point of view.

I am sorry there is no member of the Labour Party present because I am genuinely puzzled about the attitude of the Labour Party in this matter, and more particularly by their attitude as indicated by their candidate for the by-election in Dublin North-East, Mr. Denis Larkin, formerly a Deputy of this House. He seems to me to be waging a consistent campaign against the introduction of this turnover tax. For a Labour candidate to adopt that attitude is quite inexplicable to me. We know that in practically every country in Europe where this tax is it has been introduced and operated by Labour Governments so that our Labour Party seems to be out of step with the general line of Labour Party thinking in other countries.

It is obvious why the Labour Parties in the various countries of Europe favour this tax. As has been pointed out, this is the fairest possible type of tax. It is a tax on expenditure and the person in a position to spend most pays most. Indeed in our country to-day, with the introduction of PAYE and with so many of our wage and salary earners now paying income tax, we would certainly have expected that the Labour Party would have plumped for this tax as against any increase in income tax under PAYE. I genuinely feel the Labour Party must be under some misapprehension in this matter and that they have not quite understood its implications. I can readily imagine that Mr. Denis Larkin will be prepared in a by-election campaign to use any stick he can find to beat the Government but I have always thought the Labour Party——

Comment on this

Is this in order ?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The turnover tax has been discussed.

Comment on this

Is it in order to discuss a candidate in North-East Dublin and his campaign?

Comment on this

I am talking about the Labour Party policy in regard to this turnover tax.

Comment on this

The Minister is speaking about a candidate for North-East Dublin.

Comment on this

I am using him as an instance.

Comment on this

A convenient instance.

Comment on this

A convenient instance of their thinking. I think he is under a misapprehension. However, I shall ignore the candidate in Dublin North-East if it will please Deputy Donegan.

Comment on this

Surely there is a convention not to criticise people who are not present ?

Comment on this

I have never heard of such a convention.

Comment on this

I always obey it.

Comment on this

Not to criticise people who are not present?

Comment on this

By name.

Comment on this

That is a new one on me.

Comment on this

We have privilege here. We cannot be sued.

Comment on this

I have no wish to pursue the matter any further.

Comment on this

He might be second in the race.

Comment on this

I have been endeavouring to indicate I would welcome some clarification from the Labour Party of their general attitude to this tax. It seems to be one which they should favour if they purport to represent, in the main, the interests of the wage and salary earner and the less well off sections of the community.

I think the social service provisions of the Budget have been widely welcomed. As Deputies know, it is the declared policy of this Government, a policy to which we have been consistently adhering for many years now, to improve our social welfare services and the position of those in receipt of these benefits at regular intervals in so far as the financial position makes it possible to do so. We have adhered to that policy down through the years and we have done so again on this occasion.

We realise that the State has a special obligation to care for the needs of the less well off sections. Indeed, we believe that apart from increases which are necessary in our social services to make sure that these sections of the community share in any advances in national prosperity there is still a case for bringing the whole level of social welfare benefits to a higher level than they are at present. We realise they compare unfavourably with those of other neighbouring countries. It is our intention not alone to see them increased step by step with other sectors but, where possible, to ensure that, in relation to the community as a whole, they are improved from time to time in an overall fashion.

Deputy O'Sullivan referred to the increase in corporation profits tax. I want to point out that it has been the consistent policy of this Government and of the present Minister for Finance, in so far as circumstances permitted, to reduce direct taxation on incomes and profits. That policy has successfully and consistently been pursued in previous years and substantial reductions have been effected. That policy is a sound one in so far as it is true that there is probably no more direct incentive one can make to economic expansion than a reduction in direct taxation in this way and it was with reluctance that the Government faced this increase in corporation profits tax because, to some extent, it ran counter to the policy which we have been pursuing for years of endeavouring to bring about a reduction in the overall level of direct taxation on industry. There are a couple of aspects of this matter to which I would like to refer.

It is true that over recent years company profits have increased considerably. If some increase had to be made in direct taxation then there was no point at which that increase could be imposed with less hardship and with less disincentive effect than on company profits in the form of corporation profits tax. It can, of course, be argued that any increase in taxation, particularly on company profits, is ultimately a bad thing because it is out of these profits that industry must seek to provide new equipment, to finance expansion, and so on. That argument has a certain validity but to a large extent it does not apply in our present circumstances because we have established a scheme of grants and loans whereby moneys can be made available on very favourable terms to trade and industry to finance reorganisation and re-equipment and to make themselves more efficient and to put themselves into a better position to face competition in the conditions of freer trade into which we are inevitably moving. To that extent, the imposition of this increase in corporation profits tax need not have any disadvantageous effects so far as industry is concerned because, instead of providing for expansion and re-equipment out of their own profits, industrialists will be able to come to the various institutions concerned and seek assistance and aid in any plans or programmes which they may have in this regard. The necessary machinery has been established for this purpose and, indeed, I think a number of industrial concerns have already availed of these provisions.

In this connection also, it is relevant to refer to our reasonably generous wear and tear allowances and the incentives to our export industries. In most cases profits accruing from export activity are completely free of either income tax or corporation profits tax. Therefore, whereas it undoubtedly represents a certain increase in direct taxation, and to that extent has some element of disincentive effect, nevertheless I think that the increase in CPT will to a large extent be cushioned by these factors to which I have referred.

The fact that the statistics of the capital Budget have been published in a separate paper this year underlines how important this aspect of the Budget has now become. It is obvious also I think that in the years ahead as economic expansion continues, a great deal more emphasis will be placed on and importance attached to the capital side of our Budgets. The current Budget, of course, is of vital importance in the short term in determining the level and the pace of economic activity and, indeed, in regulating all the various questions of social justice which fall to be settled at Budget time.

In our situation, however, I think it is true to say that it is the capital Budget which is ultimately of by far the greatest importance. As a developing economy, faced with a considerable under-employment of our resources and having a vital necessity to achieve a fundamental and far-reaching expansion of the economy, the essential thing in our case is to achieve the maximum possible amount of sound productive investment. It is only in this way that the growth rate which has been established as the national target for the next five-year programme of economic development can be achieved. Permanent long term development can only be achieved by a well planned programme of capital expenditure. The first White Paper on the programme for economic expansion clearly acknowledged the truth of that proposition.

For each year of the five year period of the Programme, specific annual programmes of public capital expenditure were laid down, because of course in our circumstances it is to the public sector in the main we must look in this regard. The White Paper published in 1958 envisaged that over the five year period 1959/60 to 1963/64 public capital expenditure would amount to approximately £220 million. The actual total expended will be in the region of £295 million or a yearly average of practically £60 million.

In view of the criticism of the increase in the public debt which has been made by the Opposition, it is important to have a look at the way in which that £295 million will have been invested by the time the first five year period of economic expansion ends at the end of this financial year. This will help to illustrate further how far the directive principle of the White Paper of giving priority to productive capital investment has been realised in this five year period. It also will be a very valuable guide in helping us to settle the estimates and targets to be set out in the second Programme to be published later this year.

The total of £295 million was invested roughly as follows. What may be loosely described as social purposes absorbed £77 million; productive capital expenditure on agriculture totalled £70 million; fuel and power absorbed £48 million; transport and communications, £40 million: industry, £34 million; harbours, airports and tourism generally, £12 million. Approximately £9 million was expended on developing forestry and fisheries, and miscellaneous purposes absorbed the balance of £5 million. It is clear from this analysis of the figures that the directive principle laid down in the first White Paper was adhered to. The figures show clearly that our public capital expenditure programme was in fact heavily weighted in favour of productive investment.

The second Programme for Economic Expansion, as the Taoiseach has indicated, is now being drafted. It will be published this year. The figures I have just given will have to be carefully considered in the framing of the second programme. It would seem from the figures that public capital expenditure at an average rate of £60 million a year equated with an annual average growth rate in the economy of somewhere between four and four and a half per cent over the five year period. In the preparation of the second programme we will have to consider whether we can assume that that equation will continue to apply in the next five year period—an equation of an average capital expenditure in the public sector of £60 million per year with a growth of from four to four and a half per cent in the economy—or whether it will be necessary for us to increase the overall total invested; whether better results could be gained by a reallocation of the total amount within the existing headings or whether new outlets not hitherto incorporated in our list will have to be found for productive investment.

The fact that public capital expenditure, strongly weighted in favour of productive investment, will reach a total of almost £300 million for the five year period represents to my mind a magnificent achievement in our particular circumstances. It is undoubtedly this high level of public capital expenditure which was in the main responsible for the satisfactory success achieved by the programme as a whole.

So far it has been possible to provide the necessary capital for our public investment programme without any great difficulty, but that is a situation to which a great deal of care and thought will have to be given in the future. We will have to have regard to two aspects of the situation. First, there will be the question of raising the necessary capital to finance our programmes of public capital expenditure, and raising that capital in the most advantageous and economic way. In addition, in settling the manner in which the public programme is to be financed, it will be necessary for us to have regard to and consider the needs and requirements of the private sector.

At present the gross total of savings available for investment in the community is in the region of £130 million a year. Expenditure in the public sector in 1963/64 is estimated to be in the region of £80 million. It will be readily seen that the public capital programme bites very heavily into the total volume of savings available. We can, of course, expect as national income expands and productivity increases that more money will automatically be available to finance investments in the private sector. It has however been true of our situation up to now that we had to rely in the main on the public sector to give us the volume of capital expenditure needed and if we can bring about a situation here where there would actually be a pressure of money seeking profitable outlets for investment in the private sector, it would be enormously advantageous from the point of view of the economy as a whole. Indeed, a welcome development in that regard, as the figures show this year, is the extent to which a number of our public enterprises are able to finance expansion out of their internal resources. Of course, there are many factors to be taken into account in that regard and it is important that we should not place too heavy a burden on these public enterprises or limit the scope of their freedom of action. Any number of factors must be taken into account in fixing their capital programmes but it is encouraging to see in a number of cases that these public concerns have been able to finance profitable productive capital expenditure from their own resources.

Some members of the Opposition have been critical of the increase in the State debt. In my opinion, there are no grounds whatever for that criticism. As I have said, productive capital investment is an absolutely vital necessity for a developing economy like ours. Up to now it has been to the public sector we have had to look for the main effort in this regard both as regards actual direct investment itself from public sources and investment which supplements private investment as in the case of industrial grants, grants to increase agricultural efficiency and so on. To say our public debt has increased by so many millions and no more and to regard that as a criticism of the financial policy of the Government is just simply not valid. It is quite clear from the figures that our real position in regard to the State debt has not deteriorated in recent years.

There are a great many tests which one could apply to determine whether or not this is so. There are a number of analyses of the situation that one can make. However, the simplest possible test I can think of is to look at the total amount of State debt in relation to the national income. If we go back to 1958, the year immediately preceding the inauguration of the Programme for Economic Expansion, we find that at 31st March 1958 the total State debt, including capitalised liabilities, sinking funds and the other capital funds, was £431 million compared with a national income for the preceding year, 1957, of £467 million. Before the Programme for Economic Expansion got under way therefore there was that rough correspondence between the total State debt and the national income, £431 million and £467 million respectively.

I should say, of course, that there is a large amount of artificiality about that total figure of State liabilities because, as Deputies will realise, in order to get a valid assessment of what the State's balance sheet is really like, one must take into account the various investments which the State holds in different companies, repayable advances and so on. It is necessary, further, to analyse these carefully and see which of them can be regarded as real assets and which of them should in fact be written off. Then ultimately one arrives at a total which represents the net debt of the State, that is taking its assets into account. Having said that, however, I think the figures I am taking are all right for the purposes for which I am using them, namely, to arrive at some basis of comparison between two different dates.

When we come to 31st March this year, we find that the total debt, measured on the same basis as I have taken for 1958, was £636 million. That compares with a national income for 1962 of £632 million so that in effect there has been no significant deterioration in the situation. Now I admit, as I said at the beginning, that this is a very rough and ready indicator but I think it is sufficient for my purpose to illustrate that the overall financial position of the State in regard to its capital position has not deteriorated in the five years which have elapsed since 1958. The significant thing is that we have been able in that five-year period to expend about £300 million, most of it heavily weighted in favour of productive investment, without in any way impairing the general structure of the capital position.

One of the recent decisions of the Government which have been particularly welcome to me has been the decision to establish the National Building Advisory Council. When I say it is particularly welcome to me, I am speaking as a Deputy for my own constituency. As we all know, the building industry at present is experiencing an all-time high level of activity. There is a great deal of work on hands and generally speaking conditions throughout the industry are extremely favourable. But we all know the history of the building industry. I do not want to be political but we do know that it was subject in the past to particularly violent fluctuations, and that as the State has or has not been able to make capital available, then the industry either prospered or suffered. I think it is vitally important that we should make an assessment of the situation and try to put the industry, which is a vitally important national industry, on a stable basis and that we should get away from the procession of booms and slumps which has to a large extent prevailed up to now.

It has been heartbreaking to us all, in our capacity as Deputies for different constituencies, to see the building industry come to a sudden stop and large numbers of skilled operatives emigrate, many of them forever as has happened in the past. If we could rectify that situation and bring about stability in the industry with no violent fluctuations so that the level of activity could be kept maintained from year to year and the jobs of all concerned made secure, then we would be doing a very good day's work not alone for the people in the industry but for the whole national economy. I hope that good results will flow from the decisions to establish this National Building Advisory Council. Its terms of reference are wide and comprehensive and I would hope that through its operations we will finally get away from this situation which I have described and which has from time to time brought so much unmerited disaster on so many unfortunate families.

I want to say, in conclusion, that this Budget cannot be considered in isolation. It is simply one further step in the general implementation of the social and economic policy of this Government. That policy is devoted to securing the maximum possible amount of economic expansion and to ensuring, as I have said, that the fruits and benefits of that expansion are passed on in the most equitable possible fashion to all the different sections of our community. Both aspects of this matter have equally engaged the attention of the Government both in the preparation of this Budget and in the framing of their policies generally. We believe that economic growth and social justice must go hand in hand and as the benefits of growth in the national economy become available, they must be passed on to all sections of our people in an equitable and just fashion.

I think it is true to say that we have always been looked on as the Party which can be relied on for good, sound, prudent management of the nation's finances. In this Budget, we are continuing to merit that trust. It provides all the necessary machinery and incentives for the expanding economy, which is our aim. It meets all our current obligations; it meets the requirements of social justice in so far as we can possibly do so; and it effects a fundamental and far-reaching change in the basis of our tax structure, which will be of enormous benefit in the years ahead.

Comment on this

The Minister for Justice opened his speech by stating that our tax structure was on a narrow base and that the arguments were overwhelmingly in favour of a turnover tax. We have heard all that before. Indeed, he said that Deputy Sweetman, on this side of the House, had said largely, in principle, the same sort of thing. If that is true, and I seem to remember that myself also, that does not mean that the only alternative was a turnover tax or that the only alternative was the type of Budget we now have before us. It is quite unfair for the Minister for Justice to say to the Opposition: "You should now tell us what you would do." That is rather like Deputy Burke who comes in here every year at Budget time and says: "You went up the steps and you voted against social service increases", not mentioning, of course, that Deputies voted on the same occasion against all the impositions.

It is not our job to say what we would do. Even if one were to admit, which I do not admit, that the revenue the Fianna Fáil Government wish to raise is necessary, there are many ways of raising it besides the type of iniquitous tax and the other measures that have been instituted.

The Minister for Justice, similarly, mentioned the figure of nearly £300 million spent over five years on the capital side of the Budget. He said it was heavily weighted in favour of productive investment. I am beginning to wonder whether or not this productive investment, if it is bearing any fruit, is bearing the sort of fruit that means that the plain people of Ireland have their noses against the glass looking through the window from outside and that a certain small number of other people gather all the fruits in the heated atmosphere inside. Because, if one is to take the real benefits to the Irish nation over the past five years in terms of real increased emoluments —in other words, if you increase the wages, you have to take into account the increase in the cost of living, the amount of increased employment—one finds that Fianna Fáil, who have been in power now for six years, have failed abysmally in all the things they said they would do. When out of office, they produced in a supplement to the Irish Press of Wednesday, 15th October, 1955, the announcement of their Programme of Economic Expansion. I quote from page 2 of that supplement from a speech given by the present Taoiseach, who was then shadow Minister for Industry and Commerce. The heading of this paragraph is “100,000 new jobs after 5 years”. I quote:

It will be noted that in the first year of the proposed programme, it is contemplated that public investment outlay will be expanded by £13 million, raising national expenditure by £20 million and creating 20,000 new jobs. No contribution from the private sector is reckoned in this year.

In the second year, it is assumed that gross national expenditure is again increased by £20 million bringing the total increase to £40 million with a corresponding effect on employment and that this will result from £18 million increase in private capital outlay plus £15 million of further public expenditure, adding £22 million.

In the third year, a further rise in gross expenditure by £20 million is assumed (making the cumulative increase £60 million) to which the additional private capital outlay of the previous year is reckoned to contribute £18 million, and new private capital outlay a further £20 million, increased public expenditure being kept at £17 million.

By the fifth year, on this calculation, full employment should be achieved, with the level of gross expenditure raised by £100 million, and 100,000 new jobs created.

What has been the result of six years of Fianna Fáil administration? Three hundred thousand people have emigrated and there are fewer people in employment today than there were when that supplement was produced. It is all very well for the Minister for Justice to come in here and airily give us a set of statistician's figures. If I were to quote his own profession, I would say "a set of accountant's figures." The things that matter are whether or not the plain people of Ireland have better emoluments, a higher standard of living and whether or not they have more jobs. By both these sliderules, Fianna Fáil stand condemned.

This Budget was condemned at the beginning, even the day before it was introduced or the day after Budget day, for many reasons. One of them was that it was the year in which there were disgraceful Budget leaks for which only the Cabinet could be responsible. Nothing but an inspired leak could have given the Irish Times of Tuesday, 23rd April, the following information. I quote from page one:

The new sales tax, it is believed, will be of the order of 2½ or 3 per cent, which would bring in about £11 million in a full year.

The Minister will preface his Budget by reviewing the nation's economy and declare the overall aim of a 4 per cent increase yearly on the gross national product.

It is expected that the sales tax will be widely based and may include all of the 50,000 retail establishments in the country. It almost certainly will be applied at the retail level ...

Comment on this

The Irish Times quoted several different alternatives— in fact they could not be wrong—on some date.

Comment on this

Deputy Noel Lemass made an unqualified withdrawal of certain allegations yesterday and I do not want to raise that matter again but in relation to Budget leaks, he might have picked some other part of my speech to intervene, having regard to his public withdrawal yesterday of his accusation on a previous occasion. We all know, of course, that you cannot slip a cork in the Fianna Fáil Party but he is up to tell Papa.

There was a pre-Budget speech made by the Taoiseach in which he produced, again, one of his five year plans but whereas in Clery's Restaurant in 1956 he spoke of jobs and investment, now he has decided to be a little more fluid. He realises that things have caught up with him. Now he talks of £30 million per year increase in incomes. I wonder how does that relate to a wage pause as suggested in the White Paper? How does that relate to what perhaps is an inspired statement by the principal officer of Aer Lingus that there must be a complete wage pause there? Does the Taoiseach feel that his statement about £30 million per year will cod anybody? He realises, of course, that creeping inflation over five years—the way they are going, it will not be creeping; it will be galloping—will look after his £30 million a year and that in real standards of living and real return for work done, the Irish people will be worse off, and not better off. We have got the other five year plan but there is not the slightest chance that the Taoiseach will cod the Irish people for a second time. I think I have successfully shown that on the first occasion he did cod them and got back to office on the strength of it.

There is a provision in this Budget whereby ordinary income tax will be charged on the letting of land. I should like to say something in relation to this. There are decades in the life of a family when it is necessary to let the farm, to keep it for a young boy growing up who is not old enough to farm it. Even in my own parish, I could mention three, four or five such instances. The basis on which this tax will be levied is, according to the Minister's speech, gross rents from the farm or property, less rates and maintenance. There are many costs in relation to a farm let on the 11 months system, or on any other system, besides rates and maintenance. There is the herding of animals on the land. There is the cost of the various things that have to be bought if you want to increase the fertility of the land.

Will the Minister allow the person letting land to charge against the income tax that will be levied the purchase of fertilisers to increase the productivity of the land? Will he regard that as something the landowner is doing for the purpose of getting a higher rent the following year or will he allow it by a deduction? I could probably mention five or ten other things which will bear heavily on old people, but I shall go no further than to say to the Minister that I want to know from him whether or not he will take such things into account.

There is a precedent here and I want to register the strong opposition of this Party to the precedent being created. This is the first time farmers will be asked to pay income tax. I want to record the difference between a farmer and anyone else. The difference between a farmer and anyone else in relation to income tax is quite simple, but it is not often adverted to. A farmer pays rates on his house; he pays rates on his buildings; and then he pays rates on his land. It is almost as if a shopkeeper paid rates on his stock in trade on his shelves. It is almost as if a person who had a salary paid income tax, and then paid a second tax on the total amount of the salary before there is any deduction for living expenses or any other allowance.

As I see it, this is a dangerous precedent. The farmer who is not working his own land—usually through ill-health or age—is now asked to pay income tax after he has paid rates thereon. Remember he also pays rates on his residence and on his outbuildings. If he has a garage, he pays rates on it. He pays rates on the land that provides his income and, having paid his rates, the Fianna Fáil Party now ask him to pay income tax as well. That is the dangerous precedent that is being established.

The question of bank deposits was not referred to by the Minister for Justice and no one would know as much about it, in his own profession, as he. I believe that was a stupid decision because, if the truth were told, the Government have benefited quite a lot, if not from hot money, certainly from warm money. The coffers have been kept full because of the fact that there have been large deposits of money in the commercial banks. Of course the commercial banks must be limited in the amount of overdraft accommodation and loans they give in various ways by the amount of deposits they hold.

A banker in one of the largest banks in the country gave me the figure of deposits in that bank at the moment. The amount on deposit is £110 million and the advances stand at between £55 million and £60 million. That is a safe situation. He expects to lose one-fifth of his deposits and it is quite clear that if he loses one-fifth of his deposits, the amount of advances must go down. If the amount of advances to ordinary business firms would go down by the same percentage, one would think that there would be perhaps £10 million or £11 million less for loans, but that is not so.

The Government also borrow from the commercial banks by guaranteeing, principally to State companies, loans which are then given by the commercial banks. They will not be reduced. No one could imagine that a situation could arise in which a Government decision would be made that Aer Lingus could borrow under a Government guarantee another £5 million, and that the banks would say: "No." The whole financial structure indicates that the banks would not say : "No." That leaves less for the ordinary commercial operator.

New firms coming into this country seem to get money pretty easily from Government sources. The Industrial Credit Company rush to give them money because they will employ 20 or 200 people. Everyone rushes to give the money if they are good people. I am in favour of that, but whatever the Government may say and they keep insisting it is just as easy for an existing firm to get loans or grants for expansion, the fact is that it is not as easy because experience has proved that old-established firms who are carrying on and employing people find it hard to get loans from Government sources. They have to fall back on the commercial banks. The Government are now creating a situation where deposits will flow out, and when they have flown out, the Government will still continue to borrow from the commercial banks in the way I have described and so reduce by a colossal amount the money available to commercial firms.

If one turns to page 6 of the publication, Capital Budget, 1963, issued before the Budget, one finds in the last column, headed “Sources of Finance”, that for various items including the Agricultural Credit Corporation, the Shannon Free Airport Development Company, Ltd., Bord Iascaigh Mhara, Bord Ghaeltarra Éireann, Comhlucht Siúicre Éireann Teo., Irish Steel Holdings Ltd., Nítrigin Éireann Teo. and others, a figure of £8.68 million was borrowed from the commercial banks.

I have given the figure of £110 million on deposit and I have said that the banker expects to lose one-fifth of that, but he will be expected to give exactly what the Government ask for Government firms, leaving the ordinary commercial enterprise—the backbone of the country — with less overdraft accommodation. I think it is pretty well known what that will mean.

The turnover tax is characterised by one fact. It will be imposed on a vast number of decent, uninfluential citizens, and the job of collecting it is being given to them rather than to some well-known pals of the Taoiseach. That is what is being said in every street in this country and, in my opinion, that is true. Small tobacconists, small newsagents, small grocers, small people selling spares for bicycles, do not add up to an influential group. It is believed that they will not exert pressure on the Government and that they will not count for anything in the ballot boxes. I believe the Government are wrong, that they will exert pressure and that they will count very much in the ballot boxes. I believe the Government have made not only a dreadful financial mistake but a political mistake. But I think everybody knows why they made it. They had to pick those who would bear the brunt of the load. Everybody knows who Fianna Fáil's friends are and whom they would wish to bear the load. No other civilised community has imposed a tax on food, essential clothing, and——

Comment on this

Every European country has done so.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

It certainly is so—every one of them.

Comment on this

It is a different type of tax.

Comment on this

It is not a different type at all.

Comment on this

We shall debate that on the Finance Bill. It is a different type of tax.

Comment on this

It is the same.

Comment on this

It is not, as this one is, imposed on food and essential items.

Comment on this

It is imposed on every single thing.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

I am telling the Deputy it is.

Comment on this

The Minister is wrong. In Britain, despite fantastic defence commitments and the fact that they had to pay for a war, there is no tax on essential items.

Comment on this

We are not bound to follow Britain.

Comment on this

This is not a matter of following Britain. This is a matter of getting away out in front. In Britain, people do not pay a tax on bread, butter, tea and sugar, on children's boots and shoes and clothing. There is no tax on the boy's suit or the girl's frock. There will be here. That is quite a step forward, is it not ?

I believe this is a cowardly sort of tax. It will be implemented in six months' time. Apparently the Government argue they will get the corporation profits tax now to keep them going. That is retrospective. In six months then, they will get this turnover tax. In the meantime, the Budget will have been forgotten. There will be a good deal of muddle. In the first six months, the grocers will lose half their profits.

Comment on this

And half their customers.

Comment on this

We hope not. This tax cannot be put on the cheap article. It will have to be put on the dear. The unfortunate retailer will have to argue as to what he will put on the dear article if he does not put it on the cheap. All these problems will mean that in the first six months there will be a considerable amount of money harvested by way of turnover tax. It will probably be next Budget time before the people have fully wakened up to all the implications of this sales and service tax. By that time it is the hope of the Government that, with a full year's sales tax ahead, they will be in a position to spend more, to go to the country and collect votes.

Comment on this

We need not go for another three years.

Comment on this

That may be the political purpose. I do not think it will work. I believe the people have wakened up to the implications of this. If some had not already wakened up, they will be very quickly informed by their grocer and——

Comment on this

By Fine Gael.

Comment on this

——and by Fine Gael. They will be told by Fine Gael that they will have to meet another 1/ - on the child's shoes, 1/6 on the boy's suit and 1½d. on tea. On a hair-do it will probably be 2d.

Comment on this

How much does a hair-do cost?

Comment on this

I have made my calculations. The Minister can make his own. Now, if a man earns £10 a week, or £520 a year, and if he spends £400 per year on ordinary retail commodities, he will in future find himself taxed on that £400 to the tune of one week's wages.

There are various views in the Government about this. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands ventilated one view both down the country and here in this House. I quote from today's Irish Independent:

What in fact would happen was that in the case of the necessaries of life there would be little if any increase, because of the highly competitive nature of the retail grocery business.

The Parliamentary Secretary's idea is apparently that the small grocer who stays open 16 hours a day will absorb this tax from his profits, which, at the moment, scarcely stand at five per cent. He will give half his income, in other words, to Fianna Fáil. That is what the Parliamentary Secretary thinks. That is what he believes will happen. I do not believe it will happen. It might happen for the first three or four months but, after that, the Government will find there will be an increase in the price of all the necessaries of life.

The farmer will pay a turnover tax. The Minister was questioned on the Financial Resolution in regard to this and he was a bit hazy; he said he would inquire. I hope he will give us an assurance now that the farmer will not be taxed 3/- on his barrel of seed, 10/- per ton on his high grade fertiliser, 3/- a stone on his grass seed, 15/- per ton on his pig meal, which is, in effect, 5/- per pig in the case of the small farmer who has to buy compounds. The farmer who can keep his own feeding barley to feed his pigs will pay no tax. I hope he will assure us that he will not pay tax on his farm machinery, whether that be a capital investment for the first time, or renewals, or repairs. Will the Minister assure us that tractor oil and fuel for commercial vehicles will not be taxed ?

These are the assurances we ask for and these are the assurances we must have. All these items are just as inherently related to production as is the yarn moving into the spinning mill to produce cloth, cloth which is not subject to tax. Pigmeal when it moves into the farm is the raw material of pig meat. The same is true of any end product, be it barley, wheat or oats. Fertiliser is a raw material in production from the land. Farm machinery is raw material on the land just as the machinery moving into the factory is the raw material of production in the factory.

It is the small trader who will be hit. From his replies to the questions raised on the Financial Resolution, the Minister seems to know very little about the actual implementation of this tax. Whether the Minister knows it or whether he does not, very large combines are getting together here. Their purchasing power is so great that they can buy their raw materials much more cheaply than the ordinary retailer can. They will be in a much more advantageous position from the point of view of this 2½ per cent turnover tax than the small trader will be; they will force him out of business. Is it the Government's intention that the small trader should be forced out? Do the Government believe these people are expendable? Do they believe there are too many of them? If the Government believe that, let them come out and say so. If the Government designed a tax which would put these people out of business, when announcing it the Government should let the people know what they planned the result to be.

I feel there was a certain political duplicity in the Minister's statement that the Government were giving £39 million a year to agriculture. That amount includes State building, research and Department of Agriculture wages and salaries.

Comment on this

Not the Department of Agriculture wages and salaries.

Comment on this

Perhaps not salaries, but certainly a considerable amount spent on the Agricultural Institute, a great amount on building and all the money spent on the bovine TB eradication scheme.

Comment on this

That pattern was set by the Coalition.

Comment on this

I am not at variance with the carrying out of the schemes but I am at variance with the Minister's statement that the farmers got £39 million for agriculture. The Minister produced a lesser figure and then added on the 1d per gallon for milk to make a total of £39 million. I do not believe that is politically honest. If the Minister would consult another part of his speech, he will find that the total State aid to the farmer, apart from certain incentives and an occasional grant, is under £9 million. It is right that it should be recorded that the direct State aid as far as the farmers are concerned is under £9 million.

Comment on this

I said £7½ million.

Comment on this

It is under £9 million. The figure I have just discussed with the Minister is the 1d per gallon for milk. The Minister knows well that this penny was, last night, reduced to .625 of a penny by the fact that Bord Bainne has imposed a levy of .375 of a penny on creamery milk. All the farmer gets now is .625 of a penny while his costs have gone up, since the last increase, by from 30 to 40 per cent. I should like to quote from the document issued by the Government on 30th June, 1961 as to the price obtained for milk by farmers in Europe. In Austria, it is 2/5d a gallon; Belgium, 2/1d; Denmark, 2/1d; France, 2/8d; Germany, 2/8d; Italy, 2/5d; Netherlands, 2/7d; Norway, 3/5d; Sweden, 2/10d; Switzerland, 3/2d; and the United Kingdom 3/2d. If the Minister wants to boast, he had better not boast abouts aids to agriculture. If he had done something about the marketing of agricultural produce over the past six years, we would be much better off now.

The relief in rates given last year has been entirely swallowed by the increase in rate poundage all over the country. On page 57 of his Budget speech, the Minister creates another precedent in relation to agriculture, a very dangerous precedent inasmuch as in addition to asking the farmer to pay rates on his land, he is now being asked to pay income tax. I quote :

A loophole in the existing law which will be closed relates to the case where a person, who engages in a trade or profession and is taxed on actual profits under Schedule D engages also in farming which is charged under Schedule B. Where a question arises as to the adequacy, having regard to the present standard of living and financial position, of the amount of business profits returned he may allege that the apparent discrepancy is accounted for by large profits from farming. Since his farming profits are taxed on a notional basis under Schedule B the taxpayer has nothing to lose by overstating them. A new section will provide that farming operations in such cases shall be assessed under Schedule B by reference to actual profits.

What are such cases? I go back to another phrase: "Having regard to the present standard of living and financial position". How is the Minister going to ascertain them? Is he going to have spies finding out if a person has a high standard of living, if he has rashers and sausages for his tea, whether he drinks whiskey or water? The implications arising from this matter are quite impossible.

If an industrialist or trader has a farm and even if he has other income, surely if he is paying the rates on his land as well as on his business, he should not be asked to pay income tax as well? There is another dangerous precedent in this inasmuch as where there is heavy investment in farming, it usually results in a higher level of farming and in a much higher standard of pay for the workers than the minimum rate. Where industrialists or moneyed people buy farms, it brings money into the district. You will have three, four, or five workers employed at £1 or 30/- a week more than the minimum rate where before there was no one employed.

The Minister indicated in his speech that the penny a gallon on milk was far less than he would wish to give. That penny is now down to .365 of a penny while the raw materials of the farming industry will have to bear this 2½ per cent turnover tax or 5/- per pig for a farmer who cannot grind his own meal.

As far as industry is concerned, the retrospective increase of 50 per cent on the corporation profits tax is infamous. It is infamous that any commercial firm which had been budgeting for capital investment, perhaps one which now has its contracts and tenders out, should now be told that its kitty is depleted by the amount of corporation profits tax, plus 50 per cent from 1st January, 1962. It is what I would term a dirty trick, no matter how tough the going is for the Government. I believe their own ineptitude and bad housekeeping is the reason they found the going tough but surely they could find a more decent method of dealing with the situation than a retrospective tax such as this?

At page 37 of the supplied version of the Budget speech, it is stated:

It is, therefore, proposed that the rate of corporation profits tax, which is now 10 per cent, be increased by five per cent and that all profits, including those hitherto within the exemption limit of £2,500, should bear this new 5 per cent.

What I want to know from the Minister is whether those profits within the exemption limit of £2,500 will be allowed the old 10 per cent.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Then it is only the new five per cent. I believe that the chambers of commerce who have reacted adversely to this increase are correct in their interpretation of the situation and that the Government are wrong. However, the Government are also wrong in their decision to taper off the 25 per cent export tax relief which was accorded in 1957. There are three incentives to industrialists to come here. One is a tax concession; another is a grant; and the third is a loan. Then there are the natural incentives such as a good labour force, which fortunately we have uniformly throughout the country, and the various other natural advantages which appertain to the position here.

As far as we are concerned on our side of the bargain, the strongest incentive we can offer the industrialists and the best from our point of view is an export tax concession. My reasoning on this is that if a man gets a grant and it does not suit him, he can get out. He may get a similar grant in some other country to build a factory and, having made his profit here, he can go. If we give an export tax concession particularly to an exporting firm, then surely that is a valid reason for that industrialist to remain. If I were to take in order of merit the incentives that bring people here, I would say the first is tax concessions, the second, grants, and the third, loans. I believe the tapering off of this tax concession is a grave mistake. It is a piece of legislation that was put through by the inter—Party Government and that is the sort of legislative measure that seems always to be dropped.

Comment on this

That particular one was added to by me.

Comment on this

That one was expanded by the Minister.

Comment on this

Now we are extending it again.

Comment on this

No, you are tapering it off.

Comment on this

Yes, but if I had not done this, it would cease completely next year.

Comment on this

When one gives a tax concession, say, for a period of five years, the idea is to have a look at it at the end of the five years and one would normally expect the Minister to proceed with it. That is merely a draftsman's point.

Comment on this

It was never intended as a concession for all time.

Comment on this

Yes, but I am sure that if an industrialist walked into the Industrial Development Authority a year ago, he would have been told there was a 25 per cent export tax relief and that he would not have been told it would end in 1964.

Comment on this

It would not concern him.

Comment on this

It would, if he were exporting.

Comment on this

No. It concerns only the firms that were exporting before 1957.

Comment on this

Anyway, it is being tapered off?

Comment on this

Yes. It was a present to them.

Comment on this

I do not think it was a present. It is a mistake to taper it off. Our net external assets went up by something less than £10 million in 1962. Capital formation went up by £14 million to £150 million. In 1962, they were 15 per cent of our national product; in 1961 they were only 14 per cent. Savings in the year were up by £7 million to £74 million. It is hard to understand how a Government could get itself into trouble in that situation. It is all very well for the Minister for Justice to quote the figures that suit him. Everything was in their favour. They were going with the stream. There was not a black cloud in the sky; yet by this Budget they have increased the incidence of taxation by nine per cent or almost £12 million. They have done it in a rather slithery way but it will be taken out of the pockets of the people just the same.

Before the end of this year, the Minister in order to balance the Budget, borrowed almost £10 million from the commercial banks. That was in addition to any borrowing there was, as I have mentioned, in relation to guarantees to State companies, and that further depletes the amount of overdraft accommodation available to old industry and old commerce here. I deliberately use the word "old" in this connection as referring to the people Fianna Fáil have deserted absolutely.

The mounting of public debt is something that should cause everybody concern, although it does not worry the Minister for Justice. The public debt has increased by £57 million to £600 million costing £40 million to service. In this Budget, there seems to be no incentive to production. There are the retarding influences of the tapering off of the exports tax relief, the new corporation profits tax on smaller companies, the increase in corporation tax by 50 per cent, the retarding influence, if the Minister does not change his mind, of a tax of 5/- being imposed on every cottier's pig, of charging 3/- on every barrel of seed and 10/- on every ton of high-grade fertiliser.

Last but not least, it is quite apparent—and, indeed, the Party of which I am a member adverted to it long before the last election; it was one of the main planks of their policy —that in the matter of education, we have lagged very much behind and that no ordinary Vote to education and no ordinary Budget today would have produced the desired result here. Nothing has been done in this Budget to face up to the responsibilities we have in relation to our young people. It used to be said we were the hewers of wood and the drawers of water. Now that more than five per cent of the London population is Irish presumably it can be said they are the carriers of hods and mortar. However, the number of jobs in that operation is gradually decreasing. As mechanisation and automation come in, the number of hewers of wood and drawers of water there will be fewer every year.

In every civilised country on this globe, there is a principle that any boy and girl who have the required amount of intelligence and application can go right to the top if they study hard at the secondary school and the university, even though their parents may not have the money to put them there. I should have hoped that this Budget would contain such a provision but what do we get? In the Evening Herald of Tuesday, April 23rd, 1963, the evening of the Budget, we saw a very pleasant photograph of the Minister for Finance and there was then this banner headline: Body Blow to Education: University Fees Rise Sharply. Some figures are given: agriculture, science, engineering and architecture up from £70 to £90; commerce and arts, up from £50 to £65; medicine up to £100. Then there is a reference to Leicester University receiving a total of non-recurring grants over the past three years of £1,780,000. It is comparable with University College, Galway, which got £129,000 in the past three years and in the previous three years got something considerably less.

If the Government did not fail in everything else, they failed in that. They did not provide for the young people of this country the opportunity to which they are entitled. I sincerely believe that because this is a bad Budget and because they have not done that particular thing for the young people of Ireland they will be defeated. Many other people believe it as well.

Let me quote from the Irish Times of the day after the Budget. Mr. Leo Keogh, Secretary of the Retail Grocery, Dairy and Allied Trades Association, is reported as saying that most people had assumed that food would be excepted from the 6d in the £ turnover tax. The report continues:

We are very disappointed that food has fallen within the Budget net.... There are lots of things we don't like about the turnover tax but it is rather difficult to say anything about it until we know how it is intended to work it and get all the details.

Basically, however, we do not see how it would be practical to operate such a tax in this country. Ireland has about 41,000 retail outlets, and we feel that a tight system of registration will have to be introduced. Short of very strict registration, we can see scope for evasion.

Mr. Donal Nevin, Research Officer of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, said that the inclusion of food and other necessaries in the turnover tax was entirely indefensible, the more so as the rate of tax would be the same for a loaf of bread as for a Jaguar car. While a £1,000 motor car would incur a tax amounting to a derisory £25, essential foods such as bread, butter, sugar, tea, etc., would be taxed to an equivalent extent.

Here is another extract from that same article on the Budget in the Irish Times where it is said the big men in the trade will be the hardest hit.

Publicans, too, will be affected by this increase. It is estimated that in Dublin about 200 of the 600 publicans will be hit by the increase. One publican said last night: The big men in the trade are going to be hardest hit but it will have far-reaching effects if these bigger traders decide to put their prices up to pay for the increased taxation, then naturally everybody in the business will do likewise. It's going to be a hectic time during the next few months and this increased taxation is going to lower the value of a great number of public houses.

In the "Economic Comment" in the Irish Times of the same day by Mr. Garret FitzGerald the headline was “An Unhappy Budget”. I believe that Fianna Fáil are condemned by their own statements in 1956. The milk and water five-year plan that has been produced will confuse nobody. They must leave office because they have exported 300,000 people, because they have fewer jobs in the country, because they have not looked after our people, because they have introduced not only the precedent of income taxation on farmers but have also included in their turnover tax the raw materials of the agricultural community—if the Minister does not mend his hand and I appeal to him to do so. For these reasons, the Government stand accused. I believe they will leave office because of this Budget, and the sooner, the better.

Comment on this

Anyone who thinks that this Budget is an easy one is surely in for a very rude awakening next November. I listened to the Minister's speech and I have heard the various speakers from the Government benches. We can only hazard a guess at the real implications of this Budget and the terrible repercussions it will have upon the livelihood of so many people in this country.

The Budget, in my opinion, was misleading, in the main. Many people are still unaware of the extent to which it will affect them in their everyday costs and in the privacy of their lives. There is as yet an element of complacency. The daily papers which carried the headlines of this Budget did not state, as they so often do, that there was 1d on the pint, 1d on cigarettes, and so much on other goods.

The Budget is misleading, I said. Moreover, it is an unfair, inequitable and unjust Budget, and is patently dishonest. We had come to think and become accustomed to the idea that there would be a sales tax of some sort. We believed that this kind of tax would be applied to luxury or semi-luxury goods. We were not the only ones who thought in those terms. Indeed, some members on the front bench of the Fianna Fáil Party thought likewise.

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands is on record as telling his constituents some weeks ago that he could assure them that this tax would apply only and solely to luxury goods. The suggestion or insinuation that the tax would apply to foodstuffs or to the necessaries of life was out of the question. I can imagine his dismay when he learned the actual contents of the Budget. The Government Party removed the food subsidies in 1957, a particularly disgraceful thing to do. However, they have now gone the whole hog and are on record as being the first Irish Government to impose a tax on foodstuffs.

I am concerned, too, that the ramifications of this Budget will make new inroads into the privacy and domestic affairs of thousands of our people who heretofore were exempt from that kind of probing and prying. Some 50,000 shopkeepers in this country will now be obliged to give monthly returns to the Exchequer. They are subject to investigation. I fear the establishment of some kind of Gestapo to try to probe into the affairs of so many Irish people and naturally they are resentful of this Governmental decision.

Traders, small shopkeepers, hucksters and farmers are indignant and outraged that democracy should run so riot as to violate the privacy of their financial affairs to this extent. The existence of many of these small traders was already threatened by the many chain stores and self-service stores which are being established in many of our cities and towns. There was alarm and dismay about this new venture. I feel the Government, by imposing this turnover tax of 6d in the £, have rung the death knell for hundreds, if not thousands, of small shopkeepers in this country.

We are told that those traders whose turnover is less than £100 a month, or £25 a week, will be exempt, but to the extent that they shall have to pay only 17/6d per month to the Exchequer. The Minister or the civil servant who thought up this magnanimous idea was certainly a financial wizard, but he hardly had much charity in his heart. Let us say the profit on a turnover of £100 per month is ten per cent. That is putting it extremely high, although I understand the Minister for Finance is on record here as saying within the past few days he believed the profit in shops of this kind was nearer to 20 per cent. That is completely wrong. It is fantastic and absurd. The small trader with this kind of turnover has to make ends meet on a profit of £2 10s or £3 a week. He exists at subsistence or starvation level. Nevertheless, that unfortunate trader will have to pay his 17/6d at the end of each month.

We would have much preferred if the Minister had chosen a list of luxury and semi-luxury goods and imposed on them a tax sufficient to yield the revenue he is now getting from this new tax, instead of putting on a tax of this kind which affects every commodity. It affects not merely bread, butter, tea and sugar—the everyday diet of the ordinary people—but also boots, shoes, clothing, household utensils, even the services of the laundry and the barber. Everything is affected.

Inherent in this Budget is a deliberate attack on the standard of life of our people, particularly the working class people dependent on weekly wages, and also the social welfare beneficiaries, who are obliged to exist on around £2 a week. That the Government should increase the cost of living on those people is a truly deplorable thing, especially at a time when Ministers of the same Government are admonishing us to exercise restraint and caution in case there might be an inflationary trend.

We had the recent White Paper on Incomes and Output which was a clear directive to the workers that they ought not to seek wage increases and a clear statement to civil servants that they could not hope to get wage increases. It was in every sense a standstill on wages and salaries, while at the same time profits and prices were allowed to go unbridled. That has been a significant feature of Fianna Fáil Government for the past six years. They have shown a complete disregard for the cost of living. They removed the food subsidies, increased the cost of living out of all proportion at that time, and have now gone on to impose a tax on essential foodstuffs and commodities.

That same Government must clearly understand there is an obligation on the Irish trade union movement to safeguard the standard of life of the people they represent. The cost of living has already gone up by nearly six points in the past 12 months. One can only hazard a guess at the extent to which it will increase in November and December as a result of the imposition of this new tax. This tax will have the effect, in the average household where £10 a week is expended, of bringing about an increase of at least 5/-. But I believe the increase will be nearer to 10/- or 12/- because of the liberty granted to traders in the matter of its collection.

I believe this new tax will lead to profiteering. There are many decent and honourable traders who will not embark on that policy, but the traders are already on record as stating they are unable and unwilling—they cannot—to carry the burden of the tax and that the consumer must pay all. The Government anticipate profit eering. They say the only means by which a rise in the cost of foodstuffs will be prevented is the competition there will be between trader and trader. They expect, and are deliberately precipitating, a jungle war between the traders and small shopkeepers, particularly the hucksters who supply the bread, butter, tea, sugar and such everyday commodities. The Government hope that this jungle war will have the effect of stabilising prices, but in that kind of stabilisation, the small man will go to the wall and only the strong will survive. Many of our small traders will simply not be able to exist in those circumstances.

The trade union movement are gravely perturbed about this imposition. They have an obligation to safeguard the standard of life of their members, not only to ensure it shows no deterioration, but that it shows a progressive improvement. I prophesy therefore that the ninth round of wage increases is, of necessity, in the offing. It has been brought about, not because of any irresponsibility on the part of the workers or their representatives, but because of the deliberate policy of the Government.

Much capital has been made of the fact that the social welfare beneficiaries have not been forgotten on this occasion either. The annual handout of a pittance of 2/6d has come around again. No one is going to be deluded into thinking that this sop which has been thrown to the social welfare beneficiaries every year for the past six years has had any worthwhile effect in improving the lot of those unfortunate people. The half-crown has already been eaten up as a result of the increase in the cost of living this year and which has already reached five or six points. The sales tax imposed on these people will easily swallow up the rest, if there is any. Half-a-crown a week for the sick, the aged, the infirm, the unemployed and widowed represents fivepence per day for every shopping day in the week and it is very easy for that to be swallowed up by the kind of prices which prevail for all commodities today.

It was particularly despicable that foodstuffs should have been included in this tax measure because the people to whom I have referred will be the main sufferers. To suggest, therefore, that you are maintaining and improving the lot of these people is patently dishonest and I defy contradiction of that. We welcome the proposal to increase children's allowances. A married man with a wife and five children can now expect to get an increase of 5/10d a week from November next. That sum represents a spending capacity of 10d per day for that family or 1½d a day for each individual member. What good is such an increase——

Comment on this

It is not worth a box of matches.

Comment on this

——having regard to the fact that these people will now pay more on almost everything they require for everyday life? I believe that there will be an increase of pennies, or two-pennies, or halfpence on everything and the cost of living will spiral. There will be profiteering and no one will be able to control it. We believe in taxation where the essential services of our country are concerned. We believe in and have supported and will vote for the necessary taxation to provide money for stimulating the economy and providing a more secure, contented and prosperous life for our people.

It is said that a good Budget should energise rather than penalise. I see nothing in this Budget which will give a new energy or impetus to the economy but there is plenty of penalising in it. Almost every section of the community is now penalised as never before. I see nothing in the Budget which will give to our people the kind of health service they deserve, not merely as a charity but as a right, devoid of that odious means test which is an inherent part of it today. I see nothing in the Budget which will give our children the opportunities to attain to the highest spiritual, cultural and educational levels. I see nothing in it which will take out of education that class bias that money is the criterion rather than ability and that it is a matter of indifference whether a child has the aptitude to proceed because if that child's parents have not money, then that child will not get a higher education. We feel that that is absolutely wrong. It is the child's ability to benefit by education and not the ability of the parent to pay which should be the criterion.

These are the things we expect to be assisted and provided for in a Budget of this kind. On the other hand, we had the further statement of the Taoiseach's intention to embark on another five-year plan. Many people were gulled, duped and fooled into thinking that the last five-year plan was going to be the salvation of this country and its people. It was heralded as something which was going to end emigration for all time and provide full employment within five years. Looking back at that period, and at the sorry state of affairs in Ireland, one must conclude that the five-year plan was a miserable, abject failure.

The facts are that there are fewer people employed in Ireland today than there were six years ago. There are 4,412 fewer persons in employment to-day than there were this time 12 months ago and there are 5,073 fewer people in employment today than there were two days ago. In the past six years, almost 300,000 persons have been forced to leave this land. That is the evidence of the abject failure of the five-year plan. I do not think the people will be fooled a second time by this kind of proposition on paper which is incapable of being implemented or realised. By all means, let us have a plan that will prosper this country, any plan which will take away from the name of Ireland the shame and disgrace of being an underdeveloped country and the brand of a vanishing race. The Labour Party will support every plan and measure to eliminate these terrible effects.

The social and economic evils of our country have been unaffected by the implementation of this plan. We still have all these things with us and we still have the right to live and work in our own land denied to so many people. It has been said, indeed, that five per cent of the people of London are of Irish origin. We have won for ourselves, as I say, the name of a vanishing race and if we do not take steps to arrest this sorry state of affairs, this country will become a virtual byword for degeneration amongst great nations.

What irks me most of all as a newcomer and a young Deputy in this House is to hear spokesmen of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael arguing with each other, quoting figures and blaming each other for what happened five or six years ago, blaming each other for unemployment and emigration and trying to prove by way of figures that one side or the other was responsible for these problems at a given time.

It is no longer sufficient, and it will no longer convince anyone, for Fianna Fáil spokesmen to blame the Coalition for the sorry state of affairs in Ireland. That was all right for the first year. Any defects arising from the alleged misgovernment of the Coalition could have been and should have been undone within that 12 months. We would concede two years or even three years to the Government Party but, after six years, that excuse is wearing very thin and people will accept it no longer.

The fact is that the Fianna Fáil Government have been in direct and sole control of the affairs of this nation for 25 years. A quarter of a century is a long period of time, a long period in the history of this young State. I submit and contend that Fianna Fáil got every opportunity to remedy the affairs of the country, being returned on many occasions with complete and overwhelming majorities in this House. Yet, it must be contended that the precious years of liberty and freedom so hard won, so hard fought for, have been squandered away.

Every country in Europe, devastated by a great war, is rising rapidly to an era of full employment, a high standard of living for its people, security not merely in everyday working life but particular security in sickness, infirmity and old age, from which none of us is immune. These countries of Europe whom it was thought we would join very soon in an economic community have achieved economic miracles in the standard of life they have secured for their people. How is it that Ireland is so essentially backward? Is it the system of Government that is wrong? It is not sufficient to blame one Party or the other any longer. We must face the situation squarely. I contend again that as Irishmen who took over the affairs of this young nation they wasted the precious years of freedom and have certainly disappointed and outraged the hopes of the new generation, for which I speak.

The Taoiseach now says that he is going to make a move to the left. We wonder what that means. Obviously, the Taoiseach has been sniffing the air of change which is blowing throughout the land. He knows full well, as an astute politician, that a younger generation in this country will no longer tolerate the indignities which have been heaped upon them and on their fathers over the past 30 years. If their fathers were gulled into supporting two political Parties which emerged out of a Civil War and whose only basis for existence up to now was on what side they were on then, the younger generation is completely indifferent to that particular sad occasion. They want, above all else, the right to work in their own land. They want the right to a decent wage, decent conditions of work. They want a sense of security, a sense of dignity. They want to marry and found a family. They claim that as a fundamental right. They cry shame and disgrace on any Government who deny it to them.

Let us make no mistake about it. The 300,000 persons who have been forced to leave this land in the past six years have gone out with a very definite and large chip on their shoulders. They have little respect for the system which forced them out. We have a lot to be responsible for if they go astray in any regard in the countries of their adoption. It is not John Bull who is sending them out any more; it is not the foreign tyrant who is sending them out. It is their own native Government. It is indignity being heaped upon Irishmen and women by Irishmen in Parliament and we stand responsible and answerable to the extent that these young persons are led astray or forgo the finer things in culture, religion and everything that this country has stood for.

The Taoiseach has made the suggestion of moving to the left. I make bold to state that, despite the best intentions of the Taoiseach to move a little to the left, he will never be allowed to do so. The people who support, maintain and finance the Fianna Fáil Party are essentially the people with vested interests in this country. They represent, in the main, the rancher, the banker, the financial exploiters of this country and they will not allow that Party to move to the left. One can well imagine that there would be a speedy rift in that Party. A Party that is dependent on the people with vested interests in this country, is incapable of bringing about the radical change which I believe Labour and Labour alone can achieve.

I do not wish to delay the House much longer on this Budget. We judge a Budget on the good it will do for the economy of the nation, on the benefits and the dignity it will confer on its most cherished asset, its people. This Budget is a pretty savage one inasmuch as it will extract almost £12 million out of the pockets of the people. Ten and a half million pounds of that amount will come out of the pockets of the consumers alone. We deplore the fact that the Government made the decision to fix and apportion that tax irrespective of the ability of the people to pay. We believe that a tax be apportioned in accordance with the ability of the people to bear the burden. As has been pointed out so often in this debate in the past few days, this tax which will be imposed on luxuries such as a Jaguar car, a mink coat, or an expensive jewel, in the very same proportion as it will be imposed on bread and butter, is unfair, inequitable and unjust. We deplore it.

The Minister has hinted to me that the Labour Party support this kind of tax in other countries. Frankly, I deny that. There is an odious comparison between what has been done by the socialist Parties in England and those in control in Europe, and the economy of this country. Any tax which a Labour Party have been obliged to impose was in strict accordance with the ability of the people to pay. Those people had secure employment. They had good wages which guaranteed them not merely frugal comfort, but real comfort. They also had guarantees in respect of sickness, infirmity and old age. Any tax so imposed within the decimal system was imposed in strict accordance with the ability of the working classes to pay. We deny that this kind of tax is, in fact, in vogue in England. The tax in England was designed to cover luxury and semi-luxury lines only.

I believe this Budget will have very serious repercussions. I have said that bureaucracy has reared its ugly head in this instance with an unusual vengeance. The people of this country are proud of the privacy of their homes. They are proud to be masters of their own financial affairs. They resent intrusions of any kind. The State is now taking an unprecedented step forward into the affairs of the 50,000 traders of this country for the first time. It has also caught up the farming community in the net of taxation. I am sure the farmers will deeply resent being dragged into the net of taxation for the first time in the history of the State. Farmers who may be shopkeepers in their own right, or shareholders in co-operative stores, will now be liable for taxation not merely on that enterprise but on their farming profits as well.

Even after listening to the countless speeches which were made here, it is difficult to understand the depth and the reality of the repercussions which will arise from these impositions. It is only next November that the people will realise what really hit them in regard to the intrusion into the privacy of their homes, the imposition of a steep increase in the cost of living. They will have to contend anew with a galaxy of tax collectors, to whom I have referred as a kind of Gestapo, who will now be responsible for prying, spying and probing into the affairs of some 60,000 more Irishmen and women.

As a Party, we support enthusiastically any proposal or any request from the Government for moneys which are essential to maintain the essential services and to develop our economy, but we have very definite ideas as to how the money should be collected. In this instance, we say that we do not know of a worse or more unsavoury method of collecting taxation than the method adopted by the Minister. We deplore the fact that the Government should, of set purpose, depress the standard of living of our people, send prices spiralling and force the small traders into a jungle war in which many will be badly beaten and not survive. They have ensured that the ninth round of wage increases is just around the corner.

Comment on this
Michael Moran Minister for Lands (Mr. Moran) Fianna Fáil

I listened with interest to the speech of the last young Deputy. Obviously, he is very young and rather inexperienced, because he does not appear to have realised the improvements that have been made in the State since its foundation, and he appears to want to denigrate the improvements that have been made. I am afraid any impartial observer will disagree with him in that view.

As to his suggestion that my Party are maintained by the vested interests of the country, I think the most obvious comment on that is the fact that so far as I know there is in this city the greatest collection of industrial workers in the whole of the land, and so far as I know again, there is only one Labour Deputy officially representing them in this House. So it would appear to me that there was no necessity for the Taoiseach to make any reference to this Party moving to the left as we appear to have been, in the views of the working man, more to the left than any Party in this House over a great number of years. If, in our view, the national interest requires it in order to achieve the aims we are setting ourselves, to improve the social services and to provide for the planned programme upon which we are now embarking, I believe we will also have the full broad support of the people of the country, including the vast majority of the workers, to help us in this national aim.

It is rather significant that when people complain about taxation, or the form of taxation and how it should be collected, they are very slow to advance any alternative plan. It is fine and easy here for any Deputy to suggest that he will support everything that is for the national good, that he will support increased old age pensions, family allowances and benefits for the social welfare classes, that he will support further expenditure in the public sector but, of course, that he will not support any form or type of taxation to meet those national demands. It would be much more realistic, in my view, if those people would suggest where the money is to be found to pursue those national aims. This Budget has been framed not on a day-to-day basis but for the purpose of giving effect to the new planned financial programme referred to by the Taoiseach for further economic expansion over the next five years.

The people who suggest that the first Programme for Economic Expansion introduced by this Government was a failure are closing their eyes to economic facts, facts which are within the knowledge of everyone and which are apparent to impartial observers. With regard to something the last speaker said, the Irish Banking Review of March, 1963, had this to say at page 4 in connection with the last Programme for Economic Expansion.

Industrial output expanded by about 8½% in 1960 and in 1961 but by only 5% in 1962. The year was not stagnant and had indeed many promising features. There was a rise in industrial employment, a fall in emigration and a rise in population. Domestic and foreign investment continued to take place, though at a slower rate than in earlier years. Many new industries were opened and many more were in the course of being established.

That is the statement of an independent financial journal which has no axe to grind. It is not a quotation from a speech made by some Minister of State. In that journal is set out what has been achieved in actual fact under the first Programme for Economic Expansion; taking the good years with the bad, the economic increase averaged four per cent. It was actually higher in some years. When that programme was planned by the Government, we were planning for a modest two per cent and, having set that target, we thought that it would definitely be a tremendous improvement on the stagnation we had inherited in our economy. We have made much more progress than we anticipated. We are planning now for another five years and this Budget is designed to give effect to the new programme envisaged for further expansion to bring about a further steady four per cent per year increase in our economy over the next five years.

One of the best indicators of the economy of a country is the position of its equities. There has been an extraordinary increase in the price of Irish industrial equities. An economist examining the American economy would, first of all, study the figures in the Dowd Jones Industrial Register. Studying the British economy, he would turn to the Financial Times Index. In order to judge fairly here, we should look at the index for the Irish industrial register for Irish industrial equities and in that way discover the success achieved by the first Programme for Economic Expansion. A recent issue of the Financial Times had this comment to make:

Both the Irish equity index and the Irish country's production index have shown a comparatively high rate of growth in recent years.

That is an expression of opinion about our economy by an internationally reputable financial journal.

The figures for Irish industrial equities over the period covered by the White Paper make very interesting reading. The price index in January, 1959, gives the figure at 109.7; in 1960 it was up to 146.8; in 1961 it was up to 167.9; in 1962 it was up to 198.7; in 1963 it was up to 232.9 and in February of this year, which is the last figure I have, it was up to 237.6. It is still rising.

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

Did the Minister ever think of putting a tax on capital gains?

Comment on this

I will deal with taxes when I come to them and with the Deputy's big industrial friends about whom he is so worried. I want to point out the extraordinary growth in the economy as shown by these figures. There is an increase of 150 per cent since 1959. Figures are, I know, cold, but these figures are unanswerable as an indication of the quite extraordinary expansion in industrial activity here and the confidence of investors in Irish industrial equities in the period covered by the Programme for Economic Expansion. These are figures and comments that speak for themselves. These are not statements made by protagonists of the economic policy of this Government. The figures speak for themselves. The comments come from reputable sources. Our own Irish Banking Review points to an increase in employment, an increase in population and a reduction in emigration. All these are indications of the success of the planned financial policy pursued by this Government.

It is the intention now to pursue the same planned policy in the next five years and to further organise our resources in such manner as to achieve a still further expansion in our economy of four per cent per annum. That is a very desirable aim. I think it would even be the aim of our enemies. It is certainly the aim of all those who have the interests of the nation at heart. One must plan ahead and make provision for the necessary capital. That has been done in this Budget. One must plan for taxation to finance the programme envisaged in order to achieve the expansion at which we aim in the new programme announced by the Taoiseach in his speech on this Budget.

On the question of our economy generally, and particularly in relation to our balance of payments, Deputy Dillon made a contribution to this debate on 24th April. He referred to the external trade balance which he alleged stood at £102 million. I suppose £1 million one way or the other does not worry Deputy Dillon. He said:

These preparatory papers speak of the gap in the trade balance and of the deficit in the balance of payments and comment on the capital movements that are taking place between this country and the outside world which we have to cloak for the time being, the fiduciary reaction of the balance of trade on the net external assets of the joint stock banks, the Central Bank and the Government funds, and point out that our invisible exports make a substantial contribution by way of tourism, emigrants' remittances, pensions and so on and say there is a balance of £24 million which is made up of external subscriptions to Government loans. If that is not hot money, would I be exaggerating if I described it as warm money? That investment could be thrown on the market with very uncomfortable consequences at a moment's notice.

Let me take this step by step. It is quite obvious that Deputy Dillon, when dealing with these figures, does not understand what he is talking about. This £24 million which he alleges came into this country by way of external subscriptions to Government loans is completely fallacious. There was not more than £1 million— in fact somewhat less—subscribed from outside sources to any Government loan since this Government came into power. Here we have Deputy Dillon suggesting that £24 million has come into this country by way of external investment in national loans. Even if £24 million did come into our national loans here, I think it would be a very good thing but to keep the picture straight, let me put it on record that in any national loan in this country, there was less than £1 million subscribed by outsiders.

It is true, and I am sure Deputy Dillon must know this, that over the past few years there has been more investment in Irish national equities by outsiders and that investment may have accounted for a very considerable sum. Instead of denigrating these facts, no matter what side of this House we are on, should we not welcome the fact that because of the stability of this State, because of its high standing abroad, because of the belief abroad in the financial possibilities of this State, people now want to invest their money in this country rather than in Sweden, the banana republics of South America or any other country? Is this not the best proof that anyone can get of the success of the financial policy pursued by the Government, that independent judges outside who have money to invest look around and find that this country is the best place to invest it, that it is the place where it will be most safe and most productive?

Comment on this
Declan Costello Mr. D. Costello Fine Gael

Do you not think employment would be better proof?

Comment on this

I know the Deputy and his Party would be happy if the boot were on the other foot as it was in 1956 when everybody who had a few pounds to invest went out of this country, when capital was flying out of it, when everybody felt that this was a place to get your money out of, as they might feel when a revolution was pending in a banana republic. Now the boot is on the other foot. Now we have an inflow of capital to this country and because we have that inflow into Irish industrial equities and a smaller flow into Irish national loans, investments in the future of this country, we have Fine Gael whinging and crying that this is hot money. It would never occur to them to welcome the fact that an Irish Government have seen the day in which foreign investors have realised the stability of the economy of this country and that this is a place in which to put their money.

This is the lesson to be learned from these figures. I know the answer of Deputy Dillon and his friends is to suggest that this is hot money but people do not pick Irish industrial equities in which to put hot money because the price of these equities is dependent on the prosperity of the companies in which moneys are invested and that, in turn, will depend on the prosperity of the economy as a whole. These allegations of hot money will not wash in so far as this inflow of capital to Irish industrial equities is concerned.

If this money comes in to be invested in Irish national loans, it cannot be taken out overnight. The price of the loan will depend upon the state of the country. These people are not fools. If they are investing to a comparatively small degree in Irish national loans and if they are investing to a much larger degree in Irish industrial equities, it is the best proof anybody can give that the economic policy of this Government is paying off. These people realise that this is a country to invest in because of our stable conditions. They know our economy has been expanding and that their money is safe. That is the reason we had this inflow of capital.

I should have thought that this modern development of outsiders considering this country to be a proper and safe place in which to invest their money would be welcomed on all sides of the House and that we would not have had attempts to denigrate our international standing because of this proof by independent judges that Ireland is the country of the future, that Ireland is the place in which they can invest their money in order to share in the national prosperity that has taken place here.

Again, dealing with external assets, Deputy Dillon comes back to his old theory that there is something extraordinary happening about foreign investment in Irish land. On this occasion, he did not open his mouth so wide. A few months ago, he wanted to make out that there was something like £100 million of foreign money to buy up the land of Ireland but on 24th April, he had this to say:

The third category are purchases of buildings and lands by externs. It is hard to find out what the Government's view on this is. The Minister for Lands says it does not amount to £500,000, the Minister for Finance says his latest information is that about £1 million worth of land was purchased here in the past 12 months. I believe the figure to be substantially higher and I believe it to be substantially increased by a new invasion—the land speculators and the property speculators who are moving in and now buying up house and office property and renting it to nationals of this country.

I have already made it abundantly clear here and elsewhere that there is a statutory register established in the Irish Land Commission in which there is a record of every square yard of Irish land purchased by any foreigner, no matter for what purpose. Transactions of this kind can be divided into three categories, that is, the transactions in respect of which the 25 per cent stamp duty has been paid, which was introduced by this Government in the Finance Act about August, 1961; transactions which are exempt from this taxation because they are invariably what I have described as white elephants, old large houses with small amounts of land which would be of no interest to the Land Commission for their purposes; and thirdly, the transactions which are exempt from stamp duty by virtue of the fact that they are purchased solely for industrial purposes.

From 1st August, 1961, to 1st May this year, the number of transactions on which 25 per cent stamp duty has been paid was 139. The total acreage was 10,771 and the total money involved was £656,000. That is over a period of one year and nine months. That is the total amount, for the whole country, of land purchased on which the 25 per cent stamp duty has been paid. That would give an annual figure of somewhat less than the 5,000 acres a year. Let me say in passing that in many of these cases, they are sales from one alien to another.

Deputy Dillon uses his imagination to try to sell to the public the idea that a vast amount of the land of Ireland is being purchased by foreigners. The Minister for Finance gave a different figure because he gave the figure for transactions which were exempt from stamp duty, having been acquired exclusively for the purpose of industry other than agriculture. For the same period, from 1st August, 1961, to the 1st May, 1963, the number of these transactions was 169; the number of acres involved for these industrial purposes was 2,186, and the money involved over this period of nearly two years was £970,871.

That is the complete picture and these figures completely wipe out the allegations made by Deputy Dillon that there is some extraordinary investment by foreigners in the purchasing of Irish land. We now have a statutory register under which we must get details of every transaction in regard to Irish land entered into by any outsider, let it be for industry or for agriculture. However, long before this, these allegations were being made, but the average figure of land changing hands in this country then ranged from 3,500 to 5,000 acres and many of these transactions were between these aliens. It is true to say that some of these people came here from Britain after the war and, having purchased some ramshackle place, got their fingers burned. Having spent their own money on the place and found that their income was not sufficient to maintain it, they were anxious to unload it on one of their own type, if they could get another victim. There has been this continued pattern in recent years of about 5,000 acres a year changing hands between these people.

When Deputy Blowick was Minister for Lands in the Coalition Government, he at one time was asked questions by some Deputy about this matter. His answer was that at this rate it would take a long time to purchase all the land of Ireland. We are supposed here to have something like 12 million acres of arable land, and to suggest that the 4,000 or 5,000 acres involved in these transactions that take place year by year between these people will in any way affect our international balance of payments or have any impact on the national land structure here is to be completely unrealistic. Of course, in a way it may be good politics. From our history, we know that the question of land is a very delicate one in this country and if any wild allegations are made that huge quantities of Irish land are being purchased by foreigners to the detriment of the Irish people, there may be many foolish people who will believe stories of this kind. These are the facts as established under our law. That is the amount and the extent of these transactions and Deputy Dillon, in dealing with the economy, cannot get away with the suggestion that there are millions flowing into this country of what he terms hot money for the purchase of Irish land.

Deputy Dillon in dealing with our balance of payments problem—which is not, for the reasons I have given, a real problem at the moment because our external assets have not depreciated but have increased—is rather puzzled to find out how that has happened. He does not attempt to give any lucid explanation of that proposition. The suggestion is—and the Leader of the main Opposition would like the people to believe this—that the nation is in a terrible way, that we have a dreadful balance of payments problem but he knows very well that if there were this deficit on external account, there would be a consequent reduction in the external assets of our country. He made no attempt to explain, for the purpose of his argument, that our external assets, instead of being reduced, have increased over last year.

I have said that this Budget is designed not alone to meet present requirements, but, in the long term, to finance the new programme for the further economic expansion on which the Government are now embarking. To meet the needs of both capital investment and the expanded investment in different productive works throughout the country being undertaken under this Budget, it is necessary to find the money. The turnover tax has been introduced for this purpose. It is a new tax structure that will serve the needs of the nation in the long term. In particular, it will enable us to go ahead with the expansion of the economy as has been indicated by the Taoiseach.

Let me say this to the Labour Deputy—he is not here just now— who talked on this issue. This tax, in one form or another, is applicable in practically every country in Western Europe. It may not be in the same form as we have introduced it here but I think it is in the same form as we have introduced it in two great socialist countries in which the Labour Deputies should be interested, namely, the Scandinavian countries of Norway and Sweden. The difference there is that even with their resources —they have high social services and their people enjoy a high standard of living—their turnover tax is in the region of 10 per cent as against the modest two and a half per cent we are introducing here to meet our national needs.

I want, in particular, to say a word to the Deputies, even the Opposition Deputies, from rural Ireland. I want to ask them to consider the financial provisions being made for rural Ireland under this Budget. For agriculture alone, in one form or another, approximately £40 million is being provided under this Budget. Take the next Department that most affects rural Ireland, my own Ministry of Lands. A record provision is being made here for £2,709,300, the largest amount of money ever provided for the great social work of the Irish Land Commission since the foundation of this State.

Take Fisheries. Again, for rural Ireland, a half million pounds is being provided for the new programme outside the provision being made for Bord Iascaigh Mhara. Take the Forestry Division of my Department. We have provided in these Estimates and under this Budget a sum of £3,100,000 which is again the largest figure ever provided for any Minister for Lands for afforestation purposes since the foundation of this State.

We have, under Roinn na Gaeltachta, provided over half a million pounds—£586,000—for a Department that deals solely with rural Ireland. Indeed, a record figure was achieved in the purchase of land this year by the Department of Lands and the intake on the Land Commission side of lands for the relief of congestion was the greatest ever achieved in any single year.

For cash purchases of land this year, for the relief of congestion throughout the length and breadth of this country, a sum of £175,000 was provided. That represents as much as was spent for the purchase of land by cash in this country between all of the years from 1950 to 1960. These are the provisions that are being made in this Budget for the benefit of rural Ireland in addition to the social welfare benefits which will be approximately £4½ million. Although I know that a lot of that will go to cities and towns, a fair share will go also to small farmers on the dole and to old age pensioners throughout rural Ireland. There are, in addition, the family allowances.

I would ask Deputies sitting on the Opposition benches who come from rural Ireland to think twice before they challenge the provisions being made in this Budget for rural Ireland that will affect their people, particularly the people in the congested areas, from the west, in such a way.

Financial provision is also being made to give effect to all the matters envisaged under the inter-Departmental Committee on the Problems of Small Western Farms. Increased provision is being made for the matters that will arise by virtue of the setting up of local committees to co-ordinate work in the western counties so that local schemes with local initiative will get immediate help. All these matters are being provided under this Budget by means of this taxation.

I am sure the people of rural Ireland will shed no tears and chant no De Profundis about the song and dance made here by Deputy Dillon and his friends regarding the taxation of big industrialists with turnovers or profits of £100,000 and £200,000 a year. This is the issue for Deputies from rural Ireland, no matter, as I have said, on what side of the House they sit.

There is a very simple way in which the Government could put back the hands of the clock as the Coalition Government did in their time. The Government could reduce the work of my Departments dealing with rural Ireland. They could reduce these record figures now being provided for the benefit of the rural people. The Government could reduce the £40 million to agriculture. If the Government wanted to find a way of bridging the gap, they could do as Deputy Sweetman did on 25th July, 1956, when he directed the then Minister for Lands, Deputy Blowick, in words like this: "A very pressing demand for economy in the social services has been made and, after consultation with the Minister, it has been decided to suspend the operation of Section 27 Land Act purchases."

You can, of course, have economies in that way. You can stop every Department concerned with rural Ireland from expending any money. You can bring things to a standstill financially if you pursue the Tory policy represented by those on the opposite benches. But if you are to have faith in the expansion of our economy and if Deputies from rural Ireland believe, as I believe, that these large provisions should be made for the relief of the land slums of our country, for more housing for our small farmers, for greater provision for agriculture and for social welfare, then we will face the situation with confidence in ourselves and in our future. Considering what has been achieved under the Government's previous Programme for Economic Expansion I have no doubt that, with the help and co-operation of the Irish people, irrespective of the Opposition, we will achieve the maximum expansion in our economy as envisaged in the new Programme now being prepared by the Government.

Comment on this

I presume the purpose of a Budget debate is to give Deputies an opportunity of expressing not so much their personal views as the views of their constituents. Over the past five or six days, I have had the opportunity of getting the views of quite a number of my constituents on the Budget of last week, and it is only right that I, as their representative here, should express their views. I am sorry to have to tell the Minister for Finance that what I generally found in people's minds was annoyance, disappointment, dismay and frustration. No matter what way you look at it, and leaving out politics altogether, this Budget can only be described as a really bad one.

I want to speak first on behalf of that section of the people most annoyed, the town and country shopkeepers. They find themselves in the unfortunate position of being unpaid tax collectors. In addition, they are to have a greater annoyance. From 1st November next, or perhaps before that, they will have to start keeping accounts and records, not to satisfy themselves but to satisfy the Revenue Commissioners. From our experience of Civil Service forms and the manner in which they inspect them, we know that the business of shopkeeping is not going to be made any easier.

The job of a shopkeeper is arduous enough as it is. Those people were justifiably annoyed to read in the Minister's Budget speech what he proposed to do. This comes at a time when it is practically impossible for them to make ends meet. At present and for the past few years, business people in town and country find the making of a living almost beyond them. What with taxes and extra expenses, such as last year's increase in postage and telephones, coming one after another quietly but surely, the job of managing a business is becoming almost impossible.

I spoke on more than one occasion about the danger of supermarkets and multiple stores. At a time when family shopkeepers are already annoyed about the operations of these people on a large scale in our towns and villages, these family businesses are to have this extra burden placed on them. I say—not because I like to say it but because I believe it is true—many of those shopkeepers will be forced out of business. We know that businesses in our towns and villages to-day are barely existing. It is very bad that any act of any Government should further worsen the position of those people.

It is admitted in figures published by the Central Statistics Office that there is a decline in the number of agricultural workers. It is also well known that there are fewer people in employment now than there were last year and several thousand fewer than there were four or five years ago. In the past five or six years, more than 275,000 people have left the country. In the face of that and with all these added impositions, how can anyone say that there is any hope for the future of traders in town and country? Therefore, I protest most emphatically against the imposition of this tax which puts these people in the role of unpaid tax collector.

This Budget will hit every section of the community because this 2½ per cent turnover tax will be collected in all shops. It was a joke for the Minister to say that those with a turnover of less than £100 a month or £25 a week would have to pay only 17/6 a month. How can it have the name of a business if the turnover, with the present value of money, is less than £25 a week? I had thought this tax would be collected on bad debts, but I am glad to hear from the Minister for Justice that it will be imposed only on the money collected by the shopkeeper.

Did the Minister or any member of the Government ever think of the situation in regard to, say, a greengrocer's shop. Especially in respect of fruit and vegetables the money you take in does not represent a profit in so far as much of the produce may be sold at a loss. Having suffered that loss on the sale of his produce, will the trader still have to pay the 2½ per cent tax? If so, it is certainly most unjust. I would ask the Minister to take that aspect into consideration when framing the proposals in the Finance Bill.

I turn now to the farmers. I notice Deputy Corry is here. I am sure he will be able to speak for the farmers better than I am. I would ask him, if he speaks, to explain to the farmers in north east Cork how the Minister for Lands could say that they are getting this £40 million extra, which he says they will get this year. As everybody who is interested in the farming community knows, the farmers expected to get devaluation of the first £20 of their valuation in this Budget. That of course did not come about. Some weeks ago, they did get an increase of 1d a gallon of milk but that 1d is offset now by a turnover tax because anything they will need for farming will cost more. Even their domestic requirements will cost more and their household budgets will go up.

No matter how we look at it, the farmers are in fact worse off now than they were before they got that increase. Of course, about a year and a half or two years ago, there was a levy of practically 1d a gallon put on milk and it was only a few weeks ago that they got back that 1d and now it has gone again. It will be very difficult for anyone to explain to the farmers, who are a sensible body of people, that they are better off now than they were.

One important test of a Government's policy is how the employment position stands and how emigration stands. There can be no question about the unemployment position being worse and the emigration figures being higher. The Minister for Lands told us about the first five-year plan and gave us an amount of figures about investments in industrial equities and so on, but that is not sufficient for the man-in-the-street who is mainly interested in how he is affected with regard to the cost of living and getting a decent standard of living in his own country.

Any statements by the Minister for Lands will not get away from the fact that things in this country have worsened year after year. It is bad enough that the Government have deceived the people but they deserve most blame for allowing the situation in which we find ourselves to develop. When I was speaking on the Budget last year, I mentioned that in the coming year I could not foresee any improvement in the standard of living or in the country's position. I was regarded as a prophet of gloom. It is not a name which anyone likes to have tagged on to him but I am taking the risk of repeating it now because honestly I cannot see, with the Government's policy and expenditure and the cost of administering the services, that there is anything like real hope for an improvement in the next 12 months either. As a result of the turnover tax which is proposed, it is expected to get £3½ million, and it is expected to get an extra £3 million from the corporation profits tax and in the final analysis it will be the man-in-the-street who must pay. This year, he finds that an extra £8½ million has to be collected from him in one form or another. That is my criticism of the Budget.

What good did it contain? There is some talk about an increase of 2/6 for old age pensioners and recipients of social welfare benefits, but there is no doubt that the 2/6 will be taken from them by the turnover tax. That is easily worked out. In fact, the old age pensioners and the social welfare recipients will find themselves worse off financially than they were before. I do not know if the Government think that they can keep going indefinitely on these lines. I want to tell them quite sincerely that the people are getting very tired of it. One question which I heard asked over the week-end on a number of occasions by sensible people was: "Do the Government want to get out ?" I do not know whether or not they want to get out but it is quite obvious that the people would like them to get out very soon because their policies have been utter failures.

The Minister for Justice finished his speech by saying that the Budget was one of good, sound, prudent management. I do not know how anyone could expect the ordinary people to accept this Budget as one of good, sound, prudent management. Let them address those sentiments to the shopkeepers in the country. I would appeal to the Government to alter their idea, where possible, of extracting money from the people hand over fist, day after day. There is a limit and there will have to be a very early limit to extracting money from the people, if any of us are to get a decent standard of living for himself or his family.

Comment on this

I am rather amused at the line-up that we see, particularly between the business people's interests and the shopkeepers' interests. It was very ably displayed by Deputy Barry tonight and Deputy Dockrell who spoke last week. They tried to play the fiddle and the Jew's harp together. They considered that, first, the business man is going to be put out of business. That means he is going to pay the 2½ per cent but on the other hand, every poor devil in the country is going to pay it. Which of them is right? Who is going to pay it? I suggest to the Minister for Finance that he will have some fun next April. When the income tax forms are filled in, he will find that the 2½ per cent is represented there in the claim for relief of income tax from every single one of them. Most of the bigger people can jolly well bear it. I was attacked here by Deputy P. O'Donnell the other night about the socks. What was the position about the socks? The phone from a Dublin draper to a Cork manufacturer was red hot for three days. One Cork manufacturer got an order for some £16,000 worth of goods in three days.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): All socks?

Comment on this

In three days. Why? I am prepared to say that the ordinary man inside the counter in Dublin is as nationally minded as anyone else. One firm could boast that 65 per cent of the goods they were selling were of Irish manufacture and 35 per cent were of foreign manufacture. Why?

Within the past 12 months, there was an action taken in Cork by a draper who had been refused goods because he tried to sell at a lesser profit than 50 per cent. I discovered, as a result of my investigations, that they are getting 63 per cent on British goods sold here as against 50 per cent on home manufactured goods. A merchant in Cork came to me. He wanted to get butter. I was amazed at the quantity he wanted. His order for butter to a local creamery was 1,000 lbs per week. He was selling that butter across the counter at 3/11d a lb. Deputies know the price the grocers have to charge for it—4/3d That merchant was selling butter at that price to induce the ordinary housekeeper to come in for the cheap butter and to pay him the 50 per cent profit he was taking on nylons. Let us get clear on these things and understand what is happening. These people could afford to cut the price of a dozen of eggs by 1/- and to cut the price of vegetables because the manufacturers would refuse to supply them if they sold manufactured goods at a profit margin of less than 50 per cent.

The case was published in the public press within the past 12 months, for anybody to read. These are the conditions under which there are imports of £2 million or £3 million worth of foreign goods. There is a 63 per cent profit margin on them as against a 50 per cent profit margin on Irish-made drapery goods. If we studied other businesses, I am sure the same gap would be apparent.

Comment on this

Maize and wheat offals.

Comment on this

We would find the same gap. That gap is there. Deputy Barry alluded to unemployment in East Cork. On previous occasions I have quoted in this House the position that obtains there. Deputy Barry will say that all the people there are unemployed. I say they are all working. I shall quote General Costello as reported in the Cork Examiner of 17th April, 1963:

The General came to the question of the labour content and described this problem as his biggest headache. He will require a labour force of 500. This force will require a further labour force of 3,500 engaged on the land in fruit and vegetable growing. The biggest difficulty is to get that labour force in East Cork and the only way a labour force can be got there is to build houses for more people. At present there is no unemployment there to speak about.

That is General Costello's statement. I heard Deputy Treacy moaning about unemployment. I cannot see it. I do not know where it is. If there are unemployed persons within shooting range, here is a programme that is being carried out in Kerry, East Cork and West Cork. The factories will be completed and equipped by February next and will be ready to start production by June, 1964. There will be a factory in Kinsale, West Cork, North Kerry, South Kerry and East Cork. There will be 500 people per factory. That is 2,500 extra people to be employed.

There is clamour about the flight from the land. General Costello has stated that he will require 3,500 extra people on the land producing vegetables and fruit for each of those factories. That means 17,500 extra people on the land, a total of 20,000 extra persons employed. That is what some of the money in this Budget is required for and I for one have no apology to make in connection with it.

People bemoan the flight from the land and ask how the emigrants are to be got back. Deputy Dillon referred to the fellows who were closing the door and stealing away in the night. I say to Deputy Barry and the rest of them, let them go out and work their constituencies as I have worked mine and the same conditions will obtain in their constituencies as are described by General Costello, that he can find no unemployment to speak about. Let them go out and look for the industries to create employment. There is one-fifth, in one stroke, of the 100,000 extra jobs and that is in relation to only Cork and Kerry. I hope the number of factories will be trebled within the next few years and that there will be employment for people on the land that will not put them into competition with the gentlemen who are operating the 500-acre and 1,000-acre wheat ranches, who have driven the ordinary farmer doing rotation tillage out of the grain market. If we get a condition of affairs where there will be, not £6 a week, but £10 a week for the agricultural labourers, there will be a complete change in the whole aspect of rural Ireland. Under present conditions, no one could expect any man to work as a labourer on the land today.

People come to me on a Saturday night and say: "Martin, give me a note for steel." I give them a letter for Irish Steel and they start work at £11 a week. With overtime and everything else, they can earn up to £20 a week. In an ordinary week, the worker is finished on Friday night, and he can sit in a ditch and watch the farmer, or the fool who is working for him, working on Saturday and Sunday. We must change those conditions in rural Ireland or there will be no hope of holding the agricultural community on the land.

Shares are taken in industry and I have seen the manner in which they are taken. The farmer takes a block of shares for himself and a couple of shares for his sons and daughters. If he takes the contract from us, he may take a contract for seven acres of vegetables or fruit. There will be one acre for his son, and another acre for his daughter. The contract will be divided up among the family so that they will be interested in getting the vegetables or fruit for the industry. When one of those factories is standing it will definitely mean an increase of somewhere between £300,000 and £400,000 in the income of the area concerned.

Now let me deal with the cash. If £1,250,000 is required for the five factories, we expect to get £750,000 from the Industrial Credit Company development grants, and we will provide £500,000 between the Sugar Company and ourselves. That is a very different attitude from the attitude adopted by Deputy Sweetman towards land division and extension, as pointed out by the Minister for Lands. That is the difference between this Party here and you people over there. The first thing you people did was to take 1/- from the old age pensioners, and you have the same policy today.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That was the time when the Sugar Company was a white elephant?

Comment on this

That was the time when we wanted to build 15 houses in Ballinacurra. There was a water main running along the road but Deputy O'Donnell, on the instructions of Deputy Sweetman that there was no more money, said there was no water.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We built Youghal Bridge for you.

Comment on this

I brought Deputy O'Donnell down and I entertained him and I showed him the site on which there are 15 houses today.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I was glad to see the Deputy at the opening of Youghal Bridge.

Comment on this

The less Deputy O'Donnell says about Youghal Bridge the better.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It would not be there if the Deputy got his way.

Comment on this

I gave a fair description of Deputy O'Donnell's manoeuvres which were a triumph of democracy. A statement was read from his colleague from Donegal, Deputy Blaney——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The Minister was not there. The Parliamentary Secretary was there, and so was Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

The Minister's statement was read there. We were in favour of reconstructing the old bridge in Youghal, and Deputy O'Gorman and I called on Deputy O'Donnell, who was then Minister for Local Government, and asked him if he would receive the architect with the plans and specifications for reconstruction. He said he would and he appointed a time. We met him in his room that evening at four o'clock. Deputy O'Donnell was there in the armchair with one civil servant sitting on one arm of the chair, and another civil servant sitting on the other arm of the chair. We asked Deputy O'Donnell would he take the plans and specifications and have them examined by his engineers. Immediately one civil servant grabbed him by the arm and said: "You cannot do that, Mr. Minister." The other fellow leaned over from the other arm and said: "It is a most outrageous proposal, Mr. Minister", and the Minister said: "I am very sorry, gentlemen". That was the triumph of democracy, as understood in the Department of Local Government in Deputy O'Donnell's time.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I did not throw you out as Deputy Smith did.

Comment on this

I am giving the facts, and you cannot deny them.

Comment on this
George Colley Acting Chairman (Mr. Colley) Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Corry get back to the Budget?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

He is more entertaining this way.

Comment on this

That is the manner in which those people worked. Deputy O'Donnell was told plainly and bluntly: "Stop housing. There are to be no more grants for housing because we cannot pay them. Stop the works." Deputy Blowick was told by the same voice to stop land division or any improvement to the land. That is the self-same policy which was handed down from the days when Deputy Blythe was Minister for Finance and announced a cut of 1/- in the old age pensions. That was their way of meeting difficulties: "Stop work". It took us a long time to get over it.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It did, indeed.

Comment on this

Those houses are now built and there are families living in them.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

And everyone is happy.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donnell could not find any water.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I think the Deputy has water on the brain.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, you could not find any and 15 families were left without homes, which was a small matter for Deputy O'Donnell. He put them down on a list as some of the 300,000 who had left the country.

Deputy O'Sullivan was anxious today to have my views on the Road Fund. I will give them very briefly. So much of that money has accumulated over the years that it is time now it was turned to some useful purpose. It is a bit like the Regional Hospital proposed for Cork. We have already spent £88,000 on paper in connection with that hospital. As one fellow said: "That is only Sweep money". I suppose the other is only Road Fund money. A fortnight ago, I asked the county engineer the cost of 1.3 miles of road from Kilcloyne Bridge to Carrigtwohill. The cost was £39,700. That road was so wide that a fellow tried to by-pass Carrigtwohill by going in over the ditch.

With regard to the regional hospital scheme, every three years, the boys are called up to Dublin and asked to prepare a new scheme in keeping with the latest improvements and every three years there were new plans. To date, it has cost £88,000. The position is somewhat similar in regard to the Road Fund. What is needed in this country is, first, employment for our people at home and, secondly, decent homes for them to live in. Now the Minister for Local Government will have to change his attitude in regard to these provisions governing housing.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donnell, the then Minister, invited a man to come over from England and bring him proposals. What happened? Two civil servants came in and hounded the Minister and he had to tell the poor man to go away home. That was supposed to be Government policy. There was the poor Minister sitting in the chair and the two advisers, one on each side of him, hounding him down.

Major General Costello was anxious to expand Mallow to provide more opportunities for the farmers and more employment in the area. He is at a standstill because he cannot get houses for the workers. I do not intend to let that position develop in East Cork and I give an assurance now that the first moment the sod is turned for that factory, we will start work on houses. There are too many little regulations. The instructions given to Deputy O'Donnell when he was Minister for Local Government are still there and the civil servants have not yet succeeded in getting them out of their heads.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That was seven years ago.

Comment on this

Yes, but they are still thinking about them. The difficulty is that one can never change them. I remember when there was a man in the Department of Agriculture who would allow you to buy nothing but a Scotch beef bull. That was the policy for 40 years in the Department of Agriculture. When he died, the Scotch beef bull died with him. But that is the condition of affairs. Those regulations are made and they are never forgotten.

With regard to housing, the worker is there in a house with his wife and family. His sons grow up and get employment in a local industry. They, in turn, want to get married and settle down. The subsidy for a house for such people is cut by the Department because they are coming out of a fit house. There is a second regulation then that a man must be married before a house can be built for him. When two young people get married now, they are apparently expected to live under a bush for the first year.

These are the conditions that cry out for change. I suggest that the Road Fund moneys be diverted to housing instead of burying it in roads. There is too much red tape and too many regulations. One of my greatest regrets is that the Minister for Finance did not carry out the reduction in staff he announced a few years ago. There are too many in these Departments and all these regulations are inventions to keep them busy. I suggest the Minister should get to work now and cut down the staffs of these Departments.

I am surprised Deputy O'Donnell is against this Budget. Is the Minister not giving him a turnover and an entertainment relief?

Those are some of the things that are required. I believe that the Road Fund money should be turned over to a more useful type of work. We have come to a stage in regard to the Road Fund when the two angels Deputy O'Donnell had at Youghal Bridge are endeavouring to find ways and means of spending money to the annoyance of the general public. I saw what they endeavoured to do within three mile of my own place. They endeavoured to bury another £40,000 or £50,000 in by-passing a village and running a new road through a bog just because they had the money there and did not know what to do with it. I am glad the Minister for Finance knocked that on the head. We have come to the point that these people do not know what to do with the money, they have so much of it. We have come to the point where they are doing grave damage to the ordinary people. If you by-pass a village, it will become a derelict village within two years. I have seen an example of it on my own doorstep and that kind of thing must be changed.

I would like to finish up with Deputy O'Donnell by telling him this much, that the extras on the new Youghal Bridge will be about as high as the contract price and that the angel who cut his estimate by £180,000 and knocked out the reconstruction did not do much good because it is going to cost that money anyway.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

You had great praise for him the day it was opened.

Comment on this

He will be amused at some of the replies that will be extracted here within the next 12 months about this matter. I was disappointed about the rate position. I was disappointed in this way, that we are in competition with the farmers in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. In preparation for the Common Market we have certain reductions in the duties on goods coming in here and I expected that the preparation that would be given to the agricultural community would be to place them on an equal footing with the farmers in Northern Ireland. They pay no rates on agricultural land and we here are entitled to the same treatment.

I cannot see any ground for the continuation of the present system of rating as far as agricultural land is concerned. I think there will have to be a complete change. It is unjust on the face of it that I am expected to produce in competition with my brother farmer across the border or the farmer in Britain. If I am expected to do that I must be put in the same position as they are and because I am not in that position is largely the reason that there is a gap between the wages of agricultural labourers in this country and those in Britain and Northern Ireland. That gap is there. The gap is now so pronounced in constituencies like mine, where we have pretty full employment, that there are very few agricultural labourers left on the land.

The farmers' sons are following them. It is very hard to expect a farmer's son to remain working at a wage of about £6 a week when he can get £12 a week in Irish Steel, or in Rushbrooke Dockyard or in Dwyers in Midleton. They will not do it and that position is very largely responsible for the drift from the land. Whether we will succeed in bringing them back to work in the new food processing project is something that will have to be worked out. It is the only hope we have left unless the land is going to be completely derelict.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It is the last chance.

Comment on this

Yes, and we are doing it because we have a Government here to help us.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

And the sugar company.

Comment on this

The sugar company is practically a Government-owned concern.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

But when it was first set up, it was described as a white elephant.

Comment on this

The sugar company was set up by us. There was no sugar company before we came in.

Comment on this

In columns 2041 and 2042 of the Official Report of the 18th June, 1947, we find this:

There remains beet—the blessings of beet! Some day, and in the not far distant time, our people will have to ask themselves whether it is in the best interests of the community as a whole to continue the production of sugar from beet in this country at an annual cost to the community of £3,000,000 sterling. That is what it costs in normal times to keep the beet industry going in this country. If, instead of growing beet and converting it into sugar, we import refined sugar into this country there will be £3,000,000 sterling more for the national exchequer and that £3,000,000 can be used to increase children's allowances in every home in Ireland from the 2/6d per child to 5/- per child, and the land vacated by that crop can be used for the production of profitable agricultural produce which will help to finance essential imports and to enrich the farmers who live upon the land.

That is a statement made by Deputy O'Donnell's leader in this House. That was his opinion of the sugar company and of the beet industry. How many people would they throw out of employment if they made that move? What is the use in Deputy O'Donnell trying to hit his head against a stone wall like that. That is the policy advocated by his leader in this House.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

When?

Comment on this

On the 18th June, 1947, six months before he became Minister for Agriculture. You put him in as Minister for Agriculture, although he had that policy.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We did not. The people did, and a very good Minister he was.

Comment on this

I wish to quote from column 2048, volume 106 of the Official Report of 18th June, 1947 where Deputy Dillon said:

We are subsidising butter production to the tune of £2,000,000 per annum. How long will that go on? Do we expect butter to get dearer in the markets of the world? Do we expect a time in the early future when the price of milk will become so adjusted——

That was the bob a gallon.

——that it will be possible to suspend this subsidy or do we intend to continue producing milk for conversion into butter in creameries at an annual cost to the taxpayer of £2,000,000 per annum? I want to go on record most emphatically that I think such a policy is sheer insanity and is purely pursued for the purpose of maintaining the prestige of incompetents in the offices of the Minister for Agriculture ....

Deputy O'Donnell did not know that was the policy enunciated by his leader.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They would not have the Deputy as Minister for Agriculture. He wanted to become Minister and nobody would have him.

Comment on this

Here is what Deputy Dillon said about wheat at column 2050 of the same volume.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I think the Deputy told me himself he was going to be Minister.

Comment on this

I quote:

... since the emergency, we had the enthralling, stimulating and surprising experience of eating bread made out of Irish wheat. Before you ate it you had to hold it out in your hands, squeeze the water out of it, then tease it out and make up your mind whether it was a handful of boot polish or a handful of bread. If it was boot polish, you put it on your boots or shoes and if it was bread, you tried to masticate it, if you were fit.

That is Deputy Dillon's opinion of bread made from Irish wheat. Then we have to listen to that man talking about farmers and the price they are getting for wheat.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about the bread, butter and sugar?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We did not tax them as you have done in this Budget.

Comment on this

In regard to sugar, their idea was to close down the four beet factories, disemploy the men and let them join the thousands of unemployed who have gone and that we have been hearing about. While Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture, he paid £12 a ton more for foreign sugar than was paid for the best white sugar leaving any of our four factories. When the gentlemen opposite choose a man with all those ideas and with that policy and put him at the head of the class as boss, what can you expect?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil did not put the Deputy at the head of the class. They kept him very much in the back benches.

Comment on this

You would be just as helpless as Deputy O'Donnell was as Minister for Local Government when he had somebody on one side saying: "You cannot do that, Mr. Minister" and somebody on the other side saying: "An outrageous proposal." That is the way the Department of Local Government was conducted when Deputy O'Donnell was Minister there. His leader's policy has not changed one iota since then.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They refused to take the Deputy as Minister.

Comment on this

Here is the shadow Minister for Agriculture. Here is his opinion of the farmers and yet he had the nerve to stand up tonight and shout about the penny a gallon for milk. This is what he said at column 1054, volume 199, of the Official Report of 5th February, 1963:

From two-thirds to three-quarters of the milk being delivered to creameries here is unfit for manufacture into cheese and the higherpriced milk products because it is too dirty.

His leader is training him well.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They would not have anything to do with the Deputy. They refused to have him as Minister.

Comment on this

If I were responsible for making a statement like that in this House, I would never again show my face in Louth. I went to the cheese factories in Mitchelstown and Mallow and I found on inquiry that not one per cent of the milk sent to these factories had to be rejected as dirty. It must be the farmers' wives and daughters in County Louth who are dirty. What I have read out about beet, sugar, milk, butter and wheat is Fine Gael policy enunciated by their leader. Nevertheless, they pay lip service to the farmers, pretend to be sorry for them and to sympathise with them.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They will not listen to the Deputy over there.

Comment on this

But the farmers have not such short memories.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They will never make the Deputy Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

I was here 20 years before Deputy O'Donnell and I shall be here 20 years after him.

Comment on this
George Colley Acting Chairman (Mr. Colley) Fianna Fáil

Perhaps the Deputy would come back to the Budget?

Comment on this

I am just giving the difference between the Budget those people will bring in and what those people want to do and the Budget brought in by the Minister for Finance. Let us have an examination of both sides. Not alone will those people who are now opposite immediately stop the five processing factories from being operated but they will close the beet factories, the creameries——

Comment on this

The cheese factory.

Comment on this

And the cheese factories. Is that not what they would do? Is that not their line of policy? What is the use, then, of all their talk? Where is the alternative to offer to the people?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil will not accept you, anyway, as Minister. There is no use in your preaching. They will not accept your policy, anyway.

Comment on this

Where is the alternative between us and the unfortunate Minister who sat down and was told: "You cannot do that, Mr. Minister"? After all, the Minister is appointed and he is supposed to be the boss.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They never made you the boss yet and they will not.

Comment on this

To tell you the truth, I had the utmost sympathy that day——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

You had the utmost ambition.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Would Deputy Corry address his remarks to the Chair?

Comment on this

I certainly am doing so. I am pointing out these facts and this difference in policy. Oh, here he is now—I am glad Deputy Donegan has come in. He will have to do something or every blooming girl in Louth will be unmarried. No farmer will go into Louth for a wife. He said all the girls in Louth were dirty—— that they were milking dirty milk. That is the difficulty I see in all this. The more you examine the provisions of this Budget, the more you realise the difference in policy between the two Parties, the more you realise the difference between, as I said, policies—and that difference started from their very foundation. It started when Mr. Blythe, the then Minister for Finance, stepped in here and cut the old age pension by 1/- a week. It started then and it was followed up the moment they got into difficulties here by Deputy Sweetman warning Deputy P. O'Donnell who was then Minister for Local Government: "You cannot pass any more houses. No more houses may be built. You stop that game. No more money for you."

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They will never make you Minister for Agriculture, no matter what you say.

Comment on this

Then he went across to Deputy Blowick, who was then Minister for Lands and said: "You will have to stop this land division and land improvement; that cannot go on any longer." That is the point we are watching. That is why we have to make up our minds, as far as we are concerned, that the people will not be inflicted with that kind of policy any more, a policy which did not work for Deputy Sweetman. He was not able to clear the road with that kind of game. He had to run out. He ran out after three years. He ran out while he had a complete majority in the House. He threw up the sponge and ran out. I do not know why, but he did it, anyway. "No more dough." I do not want——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

——ministerial office; you are dead anxious to get it but you never will.

Comment on this

I do not. That policy failed. You got an opportunity of being a man and you were not a man: you were a mouse.

Comment on this

If it is in order to call one Deputy a mouse, is it in order to call him a goat ?

Comment on this

He is calling the Chair a mouse.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The interruptions should cease and Deputy Corry should continue and confine his remarks to the Budget.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

He has nothing to say on that.

Comment on this

I am sorry that a person who occupied the responsible position of Minister in this Parliament—for a while, anyway—should be so rude. I think the Deputy should learn at least to conduct himself. I was queried here a while ago by Deputy Barry about the land policy of our Minister for Lands. I had a couple of experiences of it already. In one case, I came up here to him. I phoned him on a Tuesday and came up here on a Wednesday morning. He had the Land Commission below on that farm on Thursday and bought it. As a result, seven decent farms were made out of seven hovels for seven uneconomic holders. He made seven decent farms out of it. That is the kind of Minister for Lands we want— not a fellow who will be pulled by the arm by a civil servant and told: "You cannot do that, Mr. Minister." I had the same experience down in Ballinacurra a fortnight ago and again the Minister for Lands stepped in and did his job.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The other Cork Deputies must not be doing anything.

Comment on this

What about Glencolmcille, with your 5,000 gallons of water a day? Cabbage gardens are all you want up there. Stop crowing about that kind of thing. The funny part of it is that the Labour Party agree with me.

Comment on this

God bless us.

Comment on this

They agree in as far as passing the money is concerned. They agree the money is wanted but they do not agree as to how the money is to be found.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We enjoy Jimmy O'Dea.

Comment on this

I say that the whole of this could be boiled down very easily. Let the Minister for Finance have a look at his income tax return next year. He will see blazoned on the front of every business man's docket for relief, that 2½ per cent: it will be out there. The first demand that will be made will be that 2½ per cent. Deputy Barry says the shopkeepers have to pay it. Deputy Dockrell was divided. He said it would break the shopkeepers and the next moment he said that someone else would be involved. I suggest from what I have seen of the business people who are selling the butter for 7d a lb less than the full price, eggs for 1/- a dozen less than the full price, and so on, that those people can very well afford to carry the 2½ per cent. That is particularly so when I read in the public press of an action taken by a shopkeeper who was refused supply by a manufacturer because he was not prepared to charge 50 per cent profit. It was not 10 or 20 per cent profit—it was 50 per cent profit——

Comment on this

It must have been a Fianna Fáil wholesaler.

Comment on this

——and 63 per cent that one firm here in Dublin were getting from selling British socks. That is the position. I shall not hold up the House. I am sorry Deputy O'Donnell held me up for so long that I went beyond my time. I see no reason for any complaint.

Comment on this

I was one of the first to approve of this Budget because I am conscious of the fact that when you want something, the wherewithal has to be there to pay for it. Judging by many of the speakers I have listened to here, they want something, but they think it comes from a hole in the ground or that the Government turn it out by machine. I am satisfied there would be no reliefs this year, either for the farmer or the social beneficiary, unless we have this turnover tax. It is on the strength of this tax that £4½ million will be given back by way of relief to the people on social benefits and to the farming community. If the measure were defeated here, there would be no relief for them.

In view of the fact that the Budget was not balanced, nobody expected any reliefs this year. I was not expecting them. If anybody wants to turn down the reliefs, they can, therefore, defeat this proposal in the Budget, but they will be denying these reliefs not only in respect of this year but also in respect of the following year. The reason I supported the Budget was that I saw straight away that a surplus would be available to enable the Government to balance the Budget not only this year but every other year, that the money would be available to meet the case of people looking for reliefs. There is no other way. The tariff on imported goods is to be reduced by 10 per cent annually and will mean, therefore, a reduction in revenue.

I look upon a Government as the parents of a family. The Government are the parents of the State. Their job is to try to provide for the family. The only way that can be done is to ask those members of the family earning to contribute sufficient to take care of those who may not be earning and of children too young to earn. When the Government find they have no money and that some members of the family are in need, they simply have no choice but to ask those who have to give more.

I believe the Opposition are appealing to the worst side, to the greedy and mean side of human nature, by seeking to deny the Government this contribution to help the needy. Over the years, we had people demanding increased social benefits. I was one of them, but I always adopted a reasonable approach. I have learned from my experience of municipal affairs that when something is wanted it must be paid for. For years, I heard talk about a reduction in differential rents. Some of the Parties were not satisfied to reduce them by a couple of bob; they wanted to reduce them by pounds. I asked myself how much would that cost. I realised it would cost hundreds of thousands to the ratepayers and I said that was unreasonable. You cannot expect the ratepayers, who are already contributing largely to housing, to contribute hundreds of thousands more in order to reduce differential rents to that extent.

I do not like people making outlandish demands and not considering what they will cost—people who even have the nerve then to vote against the provision of the money. I look on those people as hypocrites. We hear demands from those people all the year. They must admit all these things cost millions, and they ought to have the decency to support the Government, whom they expect will do the dirty work. Some of those people thrive on misery. They look on it as a sure thing lobby in an election. There are Deputies here who would be disappointed if misery disappeared, because they would have to do more constructive work to get votes. The whole attitude is one of never being satisfied, of always making little of what the Government do, but at the same time refusing point blank to own up to their responsibilities in voting the money. They want to be on both sides—the side of the people who want more and the side of those who must pay. Surely that is a two faced policy?

In regard to the Budget proposals themselves, I am satisfied this turnover tax is asking for money only from those who can afford it. It does not create any burden for those who cannot afford it, workers with families. If you analyse it carefully, it means that it is only the single worker or the worker with no family who will be asked to pay 2/-, 3/-, or 4/- a week. The worker with children will have to pay little or nothing. The people on social benefits are not only getting sufficient to cover this tax but they are, in addition, getting as much again.

This is a long-term policy on the part of the Government. I believe that next year, as well as balancing the Budget, the Government will have, as was admitted by Deputy J. A. Costello, £6 million or £7 million in hand. Deputy Costello asked the Minister what he wanted it for, and I told Deputy Costello what the Minister could do with it, that he could give it back in increased social welfare benefits. I believe he will do that. I expect, in view of the statement by the Taoiseach that they were moving to the left, that he will have that money. I hold that this proposal, which simply asks those who have to give to those who have not, will be a new deal for those looking for relief.

As far as I can see, people do not want this tax to be a success. Obviously, if it is a success and if the Government are able when all the criticism is over to meet those people looking for relief next year, the Government will get the credit for doing that. Of course, the Opposition do not like that. I believe the opposition is mainly political. There is a fear the Government may be able to meet all those demands and satisfy the people with genuine grievances. It is because of that they are worrying and putting up such opposition. It is extraordinary that you have Deputies here representing workers who seem to be on the same front as big business. Everyone is attacking the turnover tax —big business and those who represent the working class. There is something funny about that. The working class are not worrying much, although we hear the argument here that the money is going to come from the working class. It is the chambers of commerce, the bookies, the dance hall proprietors, big business who are doing all the worrying. They are saying they will not be able to get it back.

Comment on this